article
stringlengths 0
745k
| abstract
stringlengths 0
92.7k
|
|---|---|
monolayer and bilayer graphene are semimetals with good conducting properties @xcite . moreover , in the presence of a microwave field the related optical conductivity is constant over a large regime of frequencies .
this has been found in theoretical calculations @xcite and was also observed experimentally @xcite .
the reason for this behavior is the existence of at least two bands in both materials , where at fermi energy @xmath0 ( i.e. graphene without a gate potential ) the lower band is occupied and the upper band is unoccupied . as consequence ,
the absorption of photons of energy @xmath1 from the microwave field creates electron - holes pairs due to the excitation of electrons from the lower band at energy @xmath2 to the unoccupied upper band at energy @xmath3 .
this mechanism applies also to gated graphene which has a shifted fermi energy @xmath4 .
however , in this case photons can only be absorbed if @xmath5 ( for @xmath6 ) , since all the states in the upper band are occupied up to the energy @xmath7 .
correspondingly , a photon can only be absorbed for @xmath8 if @xmath9 .
this means that electron - hole creation by a microwave field is only possible if @xmath10 it has been found in a number of recent experiments that the creation of a gap in the semimetallic band structure of monolayer graphene ( mlg ) is possible by absorption of hydrogen @xcite or in bilayer graphene ( blg ) by applying a double gate @xcite . in both cases an electron - holes pair
can also be created but this requires a photon energy larger than the band gap @xmath11 ( cf . fig .
[ paircreation ] ) . once electron - holes pairs have been created they will contribute to a current in the material , where the latter is related to the strength of the external microwave field by the optical conductivity @xmath12 .
this quantity can be measured experimentally and characterizes the electronic properties of the material .
in particular , it can be used to determine the band gap @xmath11 , since it vanishes for @xmath13 .
blg , in contrast to mlg , has two low- and two high - energy bands . as a result
, there are several gaps that lead to electron - hole pair creations on different energy scales with a more complex behavior of the optical conductivity @xcite . in the following the optical conductivity
shall be evaluated via the kubo formalism for the low - energy bands in mlg and blg at nonzero temperature @xmath14 .
this avoids electron - hole pair creation from higher energy bands and van hove singularities .
an important question in this context is the role of the low - energy quasiparticle spectrum on the optical conductivity . in order to focus on simple spectral properties , we consider only non - interacting electrons in a periodic tight - binding model .
thus disorder , electron - electron interaction and electron - phonon interaction are not taken into account . .
for this process the photon energy must be larger than the band gap @xmath15 .
, width=188,height=188 ]
the low - energy quasiparticle states in mlg with a gap @xmath15 are described by the massive two - dimensional dirac equation _
[ diracequ00 ] for simplicity , we have set the fermi velocity @xmath16 because this parameter will not appear in the final results for the conductivity . a similar equation exists for the low - energy quasiparticle states of blg @xcite : _ b==0 . [ diracequ01 ] with the plane - wave ansatz @xmath17
we obtain for mlg the following relations _ ( x , y)=_(x , y ) , e^2=m^2+k^2 [ eigen1 ] and for blg _ ( x , y)=_(x , y ) , e^2=m^2+k^4 .
[ eigen2 ] these solutions will be used as a basis for evaluating current matrix elements and the optical conductivity .
_ kubo formula : _ the optical conductivity can be calculated from the kubo formula .
this requires the evaluation of the current operator @xmath18 $ ] , where @xmath19 ( @xmath20 ) is a component of the position of the quasiparticle .
the nonzero matrix elements of the current operator with respect to the energy eigenstates of eqs .
( [ eigen1 ] ) , ( [ eigen2 ] ) are either diagonal elements @xmath21|e_k\rangle$ ] or the off - diagonal elements @xmath21|-e_k\rangle$ ] .
it turns out that the diagonal elements do not appear in the real part of the optical conductivity @xcite .
only the off - diagonal terms contribute because the optical conductivity requires a scattering process between two states whose energy difference is just the photon energy @xmath22 . a convenient representation of the kubo formula then is @xcite @xmath23 with the dirac - fermi distribution @xmath24 at inverse temperature @xmath25 .
( here and in the rest of this paper the spin and valley degeneracy , providing an extra factor 4 , has not been written explicitly . )
integration over @xmath26 gives _
=-_0 ^ 2 radial @xmath27 integration : @xmath28 _ current matrix elements : _ the commutator in the current operator is for dirac fermions the pauli matrix @xmath29 : @xmath30=i\sigma_\mu$ ] ( mlg ) and for blg in fourier representation @xmath31= i\frac{\partial { \bf h}_b}{\partial k_x } = 2i(k_x\sigma_1+k_y\sigma_2 ) \ .\ ] ] then for the current matrix element for mlg we obtain |e|_1|-e|^2 = [ current2 m ] which after angular integration yields _ 0 ^ 2|e|_1|-e|^2 d = = . [ memlg ] for blg ( with @xmath32 , @xmath33 and @xmath34 ) we have |e|k_x_1+k_y_2|-e|^2 = k^2[current2b ] and after the angular integration _ 0 ^ 2|e|k_x_1+k_y_2|-e|^2 d = k^2 .
[ meblg ] this is valid only for @xmath35 . as an example , these current matrix elements are plotted for @xmath36 in fig .
[ current ] with and without gap .
_ conductivity : _ now we insert the results of eq .
( [ memlg ] ) into the kubo formula eq .
( [ kubo0 ] ) and obtain for mlg _
mlg=(^2-^2 ) [ f_(e_f+/2)-f_(e_f-/2 ) ] .
[ ocond2 ] inserting eq .
( [ meblg ] ) into the kubo formula gives exactly twice the conductivity of mlg : @xmath37 .
thus the conductivities of mlg and blg agree up to a factor 2 .
the additive correction due to the gap parameter @xmath38 decays like @xmath39 . as an example , the behavior of the conductivity versus @xmath40 is plotted in fig .
[ conductivity ] .
the conductivity in eq . ( [ ocond2 ] ) obeys a scaling relation of the conductivity : @xmath41 i.e. the conductivity depends only on three independent parameters .
a similar scaling relation exists also for the conductivity in the presence of a scattering rate @xcite .
this implies that a reduction of temperature is equivalent to a simultaneous increase of frequency , gap and fermi energy .
the optical conductivity vanishes for photon energies less than the gap .
it jumps to some finite value when the photon energy exceeds the gap energy , where the size of the jump depends on the fermi energy ( cf .
[ conductivity ] ) .
the maximal jump appears at @xmath0 .
this allows us to measure the gap by measuring the jump of the optical conductivity .
such a measurement can be performed as an optical transmission experiment @xcite because the optical conductivity is related to the transmittance @xmath14 through the relation @xmath42 the parameter @xmath43 is the speed of light . then graphene is completely transparent for photonic energies up to the gap energy .
this could be used to filter light with frequencies higher than the one given by the gap energy .
our model assumption of taking into account only the low - energy bands of blg restricts the photon energies @xmath44 to less than @xmath45ev , which is the gap between the low - energy and the high - energy bands in blg @xcite .
this restriction also avoids stronger deviations from the dirac theory of mlg and van hove singularities .
taking into account high - energy bands does not change this picture qualitatively , since it would lead to additional jumps of the optical conductivities as soon as the photon energies exceed the gap energies .
a van hove singularity would appear as an additional peak .
the effect of the gap is a global enhancement by @xmath46 , where for blg the situation is more complex than for mlg . in conclusion ,
focusing on the low - energy dispersion of gapped monolayer and bilayer graphene , we have found simple expressions for the optical conductivities .
they agree for all parameters up to a factor 2 .
this is remarkable because the current - matrix elements of both graphene systems are rather different .
|-e\rangle|^2 $ ] as a function of the angle @xmath47 between the wave vector @xmath48 and the direction of the current operator .
the left panel is the matrix element for @xmath36 without gap ( @xmath49 ) and the right panel is the matrix element with gap ( @xmath50 ) .
full ( dashed ) curves are for blg ( mlg ) . , title="fig:",width=264,height=264 ] |-e\rangle|^2 $ ] as a function of the angle @xmath47 between the wave vector @xmath48 and the direction of the current operator .
the left panel is the matrix element for @xmath36 without gap ( @xmath49 ) and the right panel is the matrix element with gap ( @xmath50 ) .
full ( dashed ) curves are for blg ( mlg ) . , | we study the optical conductivity in the low - energy regime of gapped mono- and bilayer graphene .
a scaling relation is found , in which the four parameters frequency , gap , fermi energy and temperature appear only as combination of three independent parameters .
the ratio of the optical conductivity of bilayer and mononlayer graphene is exactly 2 . |
extended version of the ( standard ) marcum @xmath7-function , @xmath8 , where @xmath9 , originally appeared in ( * ? ? ?
* appendix , eq .
( 16 ) ) , defines the standard - function in order to avoid ambiguity with its normalized version to be introduced later . ]
nuttall _ q_-function ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 86 ) ) , given by the integral representation @xmath10 where the order indices are generally reals with values @xmath11 and @xmath12 , @xmath13 is the @xmath14th order modified bessel function of the first kind ( * ? ? ? * eq .
( 9.6.3 ) ) and @xmath15 are real parameters with @xmath16 , @xmath17 .
it is worth mentioning here , that the negative values of @xmath14 , defined above , have not been of interest in any practical applications so far .
however , the extension of the nuttall _
q_-function to negative values of @xmath14 has been introduced here in order to facilitate more effectively the relation of this function to the more common generalized marcum _
q_-function , as will be shown in the sequel .
an alternative version of @xmath1 is the
_ normalized nuttall q - function _ , @xmath2 , which constitutes a normalization of the former with respect to the parameter @xmath18 , defined simply by the relation @xmath19 typical applications involving the standard and normalized nuttall _
q_-functions include : ( a ) the error probability performance of noncoherent digital communication over nakagami fading channels with interference @xcite , ( b ) the outage probability of wireless communication systems where the nakagami / rician faded desired signals are subject to independent and identically distributed ( i.i.d . ) rician / nakagami faded interferers , respectively , under the assumptions of minimum interference and signal power constraints , ( c ) the performance analysis and capacity statistics of uncoded multiple - input multiple - output ( mimo ) systems operating over rician fading channels @xcite , and ( d ) the extraction of the required log - likelihood ratio for the decoding of differential phase - shift keying ( dpsk ) signals employing turbo or low - density parity - check ( ldpc ) codes @xcite .
since both types of the nuttall @xmath7-function are not considered to be tabulated functions , their computation involved in the aforementioned applications was handled considering the two distinct cases of @xmath20 being either odd or even , in order to express them in terms of more common functions .
the possibility of doing such when @xmath20 is odd was suggested in @xcite , requiring particular combination of the two recursive relations ( * ? ? ?
( 87 ) , ( 88 ) ) .
however , the explicit solution was derived only in ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 13 ) ) entirely in terms of the marcum @xmath7-function and a finite weighted sum of modified bessel functions of the first kind .
having all the above in mind , along with the fact that the calculation of @xmath21 itself requires numerical integration , the issue of the efficient computation of and still remains open .
the generalized marcum _
q_-function @xcite of positive real order @xmath6 , is defined by the integral ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 1 ) ) @xmath22 where @xmath18 , @xmath23 are non - negative real parameters the right hand side of can be easily shown to satisfy the limiting value of ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 4.71 ) ) , reproduced in . ] . for @xmath24
, it reduces to the popular standard ( or first - order ) marcum _ q_-function , @xmath25 ( or @xmath21 ) , while for general @xmath6 it is related to the normalized nuttall _
q_-function according to ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 4.105 ) ) @xmath26 an identical function to the generalized marcum _
q _ is the probability of detection incoherently integrated signals , the two functions are simply related by @xmath27 , as induced by ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 7 ) ) .
] ( * ? ? ?
( 49 ) ) , which has a long history in radar communications and particularly in the study of target detection by pulsed radar with single or multiple observations @xcite .
additionally , @xmath0 is strongly associated with : ( a ) the error probability performance of noncoherent and differentially coherent modulations over generalized fading channels @xcite , ( b ) the signal energy detection of a primary user over a multipath channel @xcite , and finally ( c ) the information - theoretic study of mimo systems @xcite .
aside from these applications , the generalized marcum _
q_-function presents a variety of interesting probabilistic interpretations .
most indicatively , for integer @xmath6 , it is the complementary cumulative distribution function ( ccdf ) of a noncentral chi - square ( @xmath28 ) random variable with @xmath29 degrees of freedom ( dof ) ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 2.45 ) ) .
this relationship was extended in @xcite to work for the case of odd dof as well , through a generalization of the noncentral @xmath28 ccdf .
similar relations can be found in the literature involving the generalized rician ( * ? ? ?
* ( 2.1145 ) ) , the generalized rayleigh @xcite ( for @xmath30 ) and the bivariate rayleigh ( * ? ? ?
* appendix a ) , @xcite ( for @xmath24 ) ccdf s . finally , in a recent work @xcite
, a new association has been derived between the generalized marcum _
q_-function and a probabilistic comparison of two independent poisson random variables .
more than thirty algorithms have been proposed in the literature for the numerical computation of the standard and generalized marcum _
q_-functions , among them power series expansions @xcite , approximations and asymptotic expressions @xcite , and neumann series expansions @xcite
. however , the above representations may not always provide sufficient information about the relative position of the approximated value with respect to the exact one , which in some applications is highly desired . in @xcite , the generalized marcum _
q_-function of integer order @xmath6 has been expressed as a single integral with finite limits , which is computationally more desirable relatively to other methods suggested previously . nevertheless , the integral
can not be computed analytically and appropriate numerical integration techniques have to be applied , thereby introducing an approximation error in its computation . in @xcite , an exact representation for @xmath0 , when @xmath6 is an odd multiple of @xmath4 ,
was given as a finite sum of tabulated functions , assuming that @xmath31 .
this result was recently enhanced in @xcite to a single expression that remains accurate over all ranges of the parameters @xmath15 , while in @xcite the same expression was bounded by particular utilization of novel gaussian _
q_-function inequalities .
finally , in @xcite , an equivalent expression to ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 11 ) ) was derived , adopting a completely different ( analytical ) approach from the latter .
close inspection of the issues mentioned above , render the existence of upper and lower bounds a matter of essential importance in the computation of .
several types of bounds for the standard and generalized @xcite marcum _ q_-functions have been suggested so far .
however , all the aforementioned works consider just integer values of @xmath6 , which is generally true when this parameter represents the number of independent samples of a square - law detector output
. nevertheless , in many applications , this requirement does not hold . according to ( * ? ? ?
4.4.2 ) , it would be desirable to obtain alternative representations for @xmath0 regardless of whether @xmath6 is integer or not .
for instance , in @xcite , the fading parameter of the nakagami-@xmath32 distribution is restricted to integer values in the lack of a closed - form expression for the generalized marcum _
q_-function of real order . additionally , in @xcite , the order @xmath6 of the generalized marcum _
q_-function , involved in the energy detection in various radiometer and cognitive radio applications , is expressed as the product of the integration time and the receiver bandwidth , thus implying that in general @xmath6 is a non - integer quantity .
furthermore , a probabilistic interpretation of @xmath33 , where @xmath34 and @xmath35 notations for the representation of the positive and the non - negative integer set , respectively . in the same way
, @xmath36 includes the positive and @xmath37 the non - negative reals . ] and @xmath38 , is given in @xcite , where it is related to main probabilistic characteristics of @xmath39 random variables , while in @xcite , noncentral @xmath28 random variables with fractional dof are studied .
finally , in @xcite , the integrand of has been proved to be a probability density function ( pdf ) for @xmath40 and @xmath41 , a result that also has been utilized in @xcite .
as described in subsection [ subsec : nuttall ] , a closed - form expression for the computation of the standard and normalized nuttall _ q_-functions is available in the literature only for the case of odd @xmath20 , with the additional restriction of integers @xmath3 . in subsection [ subsec : nuttall_closed ]
, we derive a novel closed - form expression for the computation of @xmath1 and @xmath2 when @xmath3 are odd multiples of @xmath4 and @xmath42 , being valid for all ranges of the parameters @xmath15 . besides
, in subsection [ subsec : nuttall_bounds ] , we proceed with the establishment of appropriate monotonicity criteria , revealing the behavior of both functions with the sum @xmath20 .
specifically , we demonstrate that the standard nuttall _
q_-function is strictly increasing with respect to @xmath20 when @xmath43 , under the constraints of @xmath44 and @xmath45 .
for the normalized nuttall _
q_-function , a similar monotonicity statement is proved without the necessity of reducing the range of @xmath18 . an alternative approach , sufficient enough to facilitate the problem of evaluating the nuttall _
q_-functions , is the derivation of tight bounds .
nevertheless , to the best of the authors knowledge , such bounds have not been reported in the literature so far .
subsection [ subsec : nuttall_bounds ] is completed with the exploitation of the previous results in order to derive novel upper and lower bounds for @xmath1 and @xmath2 when @xmath46 and @xmath45 , with the extra requirement of @xmath44 for the former .
additionally , in subsection [ subsec : marcum ] , the need for computing the generalized marcum _
q_-function , @xmath0 , of real order @xmath6 was highlighted , since it is a case of frequent occurrence in various applications .
however , a thorough literature search for studies concerning arbitrary values of @xmath6 , revealed only @xcite for the closed - form computation of @xmath0 of half - odd integer order , and the accepted paper @xcite , where bounds for @xmath0 were introduced for the case when @xmath6 is not necessarily an integer .
these considerations motivated us to generalize the scope of @xmath6 in ( * ? ? ?
( 16 ) ) @xmath47 as described in section [ sec : marcum_monotonicity ] , by providing a monotonicity formalization for the generalized marcum _ q_-function , namely that @xmath0 is strictly increasing with respect to its order @xmath41 for @xmath48 and @xmath45 .
this interesting statement was also recently presented in @xcite , using a different approach . as a consequence , novel upper and lower
bounds for @xmath0 of positive real order are derived .
we finalize the paper with some concluding remarks , given in section [ sec : conclusion ] .
so far , closed - form expression for either type of the nuttall _ q_-function is not available in the literature . in this section ,
we derive such a representation for the case when @xmath3 are odd multiples of @xmath4 and @xmath42 , through the theorem and corollary established below . before proceeding further with the corresponding proofs , some definitions of essential functions and notations used , would be very convenient .
hereafter , @xmath49 , @xmath50 and @xmath51 will denote the euler gamma ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 6.1.1 ) ) , the lower incomplete gamma ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 6.5.2 ) ) and the upper incomplete gamma ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 6.5.3 ) ) functions , respectively , defined by the integrals @xmath52 notations @xmath53 , @xmath54 and @xmath55 imply the factorial ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 6.1.6 ) ) , the rising factorial ( pochhammer s symbol ) ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 6.1.22 ) ) and the binomial coefficient ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 24.1.1 c ) ) , respectively , defined by @xmath56 for @xmath57 ; @xmath58 for @xmath59 , @xmath60 for @xmath61 , @xmath62 and @xmath63 for @xmath64 , @xmath65 .
finally , @xmath66 for @xmath67 ; @xmath68 for @xmath69 , stands for the signum function .
[ theorem : st_nuttall_exact ] the standard nuttall _ q_-function , @xmath70 , when @xmath71 , @xmath72 and @xmath5 , can be evaluated for @xmath16 , @xmath73 by the following closed - form expression : @xmath74 where the term @xmath75 is given by @xmath76.\label{eq : sotos_integral0}\end{aligned}\ ] ] given that @xmath72 , the modified bessel function of the first kind , @xmath77 , can be expressed by the finite sum ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 8.467 ) ) , which after some manipulations can be written as @xmath78 therefore , using and , the standard nuttall _ q_-function satisfies @xmath79.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the calculation of the integral difference in can be effectively facilitated by the following definition @xmath80 where @xmath81 .
since we examine the case when @xmath42 or equivalently @xmath82 , it follows that in the above expression the exponent @xmath83 is a non - negative integer . therefore , using ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 1.3.3.18 ) ) , obtains the form @xmath84.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the two integrals involved in can be considered as special cases of the more general one @xmath85 which for the case of non - negative values of @xmath86 can be calculated from ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 3.381.3 ) ) as @xmath87
while for negative values of @xmath86 , ( * ? ? ?
( 3.381.1 ) , ( 3.381.4 ) ) can be combined to yield @xmath88 , \quad b<0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore , a single expression for the integral @xmath89 for any real value of @xmath86 can be derived , by merging and with the help of ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 8.356.3 ) ) , in order to satisfy @xmath90^{l+1}\gamma\left(\frac{l+1}{2 } , \frac{b^2}{2}\right)\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus , is equivalent to @xmath91\\ = { } & ( -1)^{k+1}\sum_{l=0}^l\binom{l}{l}2^{\frac{l-1}{2}}\alpha^{l - l}\left[\gamma\left(\frac{l+1}{2}\right)\right.\\ & + ( -1)^{l - l - k-1}\gamma{\left(\frac{l+1}{2},\frac{(\beta+\alpha)^2}{2}\right)}\\ & \left.-[\operatorname{sgn}(\beta-\alpha)]^{l+1}\gamma\left(\frac{l+1}{2},\frac{(\beta-\alpha)^2}{2}\right)\right]\end{aligned}\ ] ] which , after the substitution @xmath81 , yields , thus completing the proof .
[ corollary : norm_nuttall_exact ] the normalized nuttall _
q_-function , @xmath2 , when @xmath71 , @xmath92 and @xmath5 , can be evaluated for @xmath16 , @xmath73 by the following closed - form expression : @xmath93 where the term @xmath75 is given by .
the proof follows immediately from and theorem [ theorem : st_nuttall_exact ] . in this section ,
novel lower and upper bounds for the normalized and standard nuttall _
q_-functions are proposed .
[ lemma : gen_inc_gamma_ratio_monotonicity ] the function @xmath94 , defined by @xmath95 is strictly increasing with respect to @xmath96 for all @xmath97 . by multiplying both the numerator and denominator of by the upper incomplete gamma function , @xmath98 , we obtain @xmath99 where from one can observe that the term @xmath100 is the complement of the regularized lower incomplete gamma function @xmath101 with respect to unity , defined in ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 6.5.1 ) ) by @xmath102 for all @xmath103 and @xmath104 .
fortunately , @xmath101 for @xmath105 is equal to the cumulative distribution function ( cdf ) of the standard gamma distribution @xmath106 , which is strictly decreasing with respect to the shape parameter @xmath96 .
additionally , this important result has also been proved analytically in ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 59 ) ) , thus implying that @xmath100 is strictly increasing with respect to @xmath103 for all @xmath107 .
furthermore , in @xcite , it has been demonstrated that the function @xmath108^{\frac{1}{p - q } } , \quad p > q>0,x>0\end{aligned}\ ] ] is increasing with respect to @xmath109 . by substituting @xmath110 and @xmath111 into , we realize that the ratio @xmath112 is increasing with respect to @xmath96 for @xmath113 , while it remains constant for the trivial case of @xmath114 .
therefore , it increases with @xmath103 for all @xmath115 , and the proof is complete .
the outcome of lemma [ lemma : gen_inc_gamma_ratio_monotonicity ] will be utilized for the establishment of the next theorem , concerning the monotonicity property of the normalized nuttall _ q_-function .
[ theorem : norm_nuttall_monotonicity ] the normalized nuttall _
q_-function , @xmath2 , where @xmath41 , @xmath12 and @xmath116 , is strictly increasing with respect to the sum @xmath20 , under the requirement of constant difference @xmath117 . combining , and using the series representation of the modified bessel function of the first kind in terms of the gamma function ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 8.445 ) ) , we obtain @xmath118 where we have interchanged the order of integration and summation , since all integrand quantities of the normalized nuttall _
q_-function are riemann integrable on @xmath119 .
additionally , the integral in is the case of , thus yielding @xmath120 therefore , reads @xmath121 introducing the variables @xmath122 and @xmath123 and taking the partial derivative of both sides of with respect to @xmath124 , we can easily obtain @xmath125 where the function @xmath126 has been employed for notational convenience .
we note here that , applying the weierstrass m - test @xcite , the series in can be proved to converge uniformly , thus enabling one to interchange the order of differentiation and summation . hence , recalling lemma [ lemma : gen_inc_gamma_ratio_monotonicity ] and the requirement of @xmath16 , that follows from the definition of the normalized nuttall _
q_-function , the proof is complete . in figs .
[ fig : kapin1 ] and [ fig : kapin1 ] , the normalized nuttall _
q_-function has been plotted versus the sum @xmath20 for several values of @xmath15 , considering @xmath127 and @xmath128 , respectively .
however , we note here that theorem [ theorem : norm_nuttall_monotonicity ] implies non - integer differences @xmath129 as well . for the interpretation of the next proposition
we define the pair of _ half - integer rounding operators _ @xmath130 and @xmath131 that map a real @xmath132 to its nearest left and right half - odd integer , respectively , according to the relations , where @xmath133 . ]
@xmath134 where @xmath135 and @xmath136 denote the integer floor and ceiling functions .
additionally , we recall that if @xmath137 is the fractional part of @xmath132 , then @xmath138 .
[ t][b][1]@xmath20[][][1]@xmath2[t][b][1]@xmath20[][][1]@xmath2[l][l][1]@xmath18=@xmath139 , @xmath23=@xmath140[l][l][1]@xmath18=@xmath141 , @xmath23=@xmath141[l][l][1]@xmath18=@xmath4 , @xmath23=@xmath142[l][l][1]@xmath18=@xmath142 , @xmath23=@xmath143[l][l][1]@xmath18=@xmath144 , @xmath23=@xmath144[l][l][1]@xmath18=@xmath143 , @xmath23=@xmath142[][][1]@xmath145[][][1]@xmath146[][][1]@xmath147[][][1]@xmath148[][][1]@xmath149[][][1]@xmath150[][][1]@xmath151[][][1]@xmath152[r][r][1]@xmath153[r][r][1]@xmath154[r][r][1]@xmath155[r][r][1]@xmath156[r][r][1]@xmath157[r][r][1]@xmath4[r][r][1]@xmath158[r][r][1]@xmath159[r][r][1]@xmath160[r][r][1]@xmath161[r][r][1]@xmath162[][][1]@xmath145[][][1]@xmath146[][][1]@xmath147[][][1]@xmath148[][][1]@xmath149[][][1]@xmath150[][][1]@xmath151[][][1]@xmath152[r][r][1]@xmath153[r][r][1]@xmath162[r][r][1]@xmath144[r][r][1]@xmath163[r][r][1]@xmath164[r][r][1]@xmath165[r][r][1]@xmath166 [ corollary : norm_nuttall_bounds ] the following inequalities can serve as lower and upper bounds on the normalized nuttall _
q_-function , @xmath2 , where @xmath116 and @xmath167 , for the case when @xmath43 and @xmath168 ( i.e. @xmath169 ) : @xmath170 with the equalities above being valid only for the case of half - odd integer values of @xmath3 .
the proof follows immediately from theorem [ theorem : norm_nuttall_monotonicity ] . for the calculation of the bounds in
, the quantities @xmath171 and @xmath172 can be evaluated exactly by utilizing the results of corollary [ corollary : norm_nuttall_exact ] . moreover , for the case of @xmath173 , the proposed bounds obtain the simplified form @xmath174 in figs .
[ fig : kapin2 ] and [ fig : kapin2 ] , the normalized nuttall _ q_-function along with its lower and upper bounds are depicted versus @xmath23 for several values of @xmath18 and @xmath6 , respectively , while the parameter @xmath14 is restricted according to the relation @xmath175 with @xmath176 taking values @xmath177 in fig .
[ fig : kapin2 ] and @xmath178 in fig .
[ fig : kapin2 ] .
it is evident , that the bounds proposed in are very tight , especially the upper one for @xmath179 and the lower one for @xmath180 , the latter being the case illustrated in fig .
[ fig : kapin2 ] .
[ t][b][1]@xmath23[][][1]@xmath181[t][b][1]@xmath23[][][1]@xmath182[l][l][1]@xmath6=@xmath165 , @xmath14=@xmath163[l][l][1]@xmath6=@xmath183 , @xmath14=@xmath184[l][l][1]@xmath6=@xmath141 , @xmath14=@xmath142[][][1]@xmath185[][][1]@xmath186[][][1]@xmath187[][][1]@xmath188[][][1]@xmath189[][][1]@xmath190[][][1]@xmath153[][][1]@xmath191[][][1]@xmath145[][][1]@xmath146[][][1]@xmath147[][][1]@xmath148[][][1]@xmath149[r][r][1]@xmath153[r][r][1]@xmath162[r][r][1]@xmath144[r][r][1]@xmath163[r][r][1]@xmath164[r][r][1]@xmath165[r][r][1]@xmath166[r][r][1]@xmath192[r][r][1]@xmath193[][][1]@xmath194[][][1]@xmath145[][][1]@xmath195[][][1]@xmath146[][][1]@xmath196[][][1]@xmath147[r][r][1]@xmath197[r][r][1]@xmath198[r][r][1]@xmath199[r][r][1]@xmath200[r][r][1]@xmath201 in order to obtain lower and upper bounds for the standard nuttall _ q_-function , a similar procedure can be carried out
. the next theorem will be particularly useful for the fulfillment of such a derivation .
[ theorem : st_nuttall_monotonicity ] the standard nuttall _ q_-function , @xmath1 , where @xmath41 , @xmath12 and @xmath44 , @xmath45 , is strictly increasing with respect to the sum @xmath20 , under the requirement of constant difference @xmath202 .
in theorem [ theorem : norm_nuttall_monotonicity ] , it has been proved that @xmath203 where we have substituted @xmath122 and @xmath123 . from , and after using the quotient rule for partial differentiation , we obtain @xmath204 since the nuttall _ q_-function is strictly positive , then for @xmath205 it follows that @xmath206 and the proof is complete . [ corollary : st_nuttall_bounds ] the following inequalities can serve as lower and upper bounds on the standard nuttall _ q_-function , @xmath1 , where @xmath44 , @xmath45 and @xmath167 , for the case when @xmath43 and @xmath168 ( i.e. @xmath169 ) : @xmath207 with the equalities above being valid only for the case of half - odd integer values of @xmath3 .
the proof follows immediately from theorem [ theorem : st_nuttall_monotonicity ] . similarly to the case of the normalized nuttall @xmath7 , in the calculation of the bounds from ,
the quantities @xmath208 and @xmath209 can be evaluated exactly from theorem [ theorem : st_nuttall_exact ] . finally , for @xmath173 , the standard nuttall _
q_-function can be simply bounded by @xmath210 which constitutes the counterpart of for the standard nuttall _ q_-function .
recently , li and kam in ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 11 ) ) , following a geometric approach , presented a novel closed - form formula for the evaluation of @xmath211 , for the case when @xmath6 is an odd multiple of @xmath4 and @xmath16 , @xmath212 , given by @xmath213\label{eq : kam_marcum_half}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath214 is the complementary error function ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 7.1.2 ) ) .
this representation involves only elementary functions and is convenient for evaluation both numerically and analytically . for the trivial case when
@xmath30 , exact values of the generalized marcum _ q_-function can be obtained from ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 12 ) ) @xmath215 following an algebraic approach , an alternative more compact closed - form expression , equivalent to , can be derived , considering the next steps .
particularly , in ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 10 ) ) it has been proved that the generalized marcum _ q_-function of order @xmath216 , with @xmath32 positive integer and @xmath217 can be written in terms of the generalized marcum _
q_-function of order @xmath218 as @xmath219 by substituting @xmath38 in the above equation and noting that for this case the modified bessel function of the first kind can be replaced by , we obtain @xmath220\nonumber\\ & + \emph{q}_{0.5}(\alpha,\beta ) , \quad m\in\mathds{n}\label{eq : revised_marcum_half}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where once again @xmath54 denotes the pochhammer s symbol and the term @xmath221 can be derived from the definition of the generalized marcum _
q_-function in , by using ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 10.2.14 ) ) as follows @xmath222 the above integral can be computed in closed - form as @xmath223 where _ q _ denotes the gaussian _
q_-function ( or gaussian probability integral ) ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 26.2.3 ) ) , defined by @xmath224 . using and , the generalized marcum _
q_-function of half - odd integer order can be computed for all @xmath225 from the expression @xmath226\nonumber\\ & + \emph{q}(\beta+\alpha)+\emph{q}(\beta-\alpha),\quad m+0.5\in\mathds{n}.\label{eq : revised_marcum_half_ii}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we note here that a similar result to has been recently reported in the literature ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 16 ) ) .
in order to examine the special case when @xmath30 , we first notice that from and an alternative expression
equivalent to ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 26.4.25))for the generalized marcum _ q_-function can be derived , written as @xmath227 which for integer @xmath6 falls into the series expansion ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 4 ) ) .
since @xmath0 is a continuous function of @xmath18 for all @xmath73 and @xmath41 , the above equation can be extended to be asymptotically valid for the case when @xmath30 as well , with the corresponding limiting value given by @xmath228 this last result also appears in ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 4.71 ) ) , where @xmath229 has been derived directly from by applying the small argument form of the modified bessel function . it has been proved in @xcite that , along with can define tight upper and lower bounds for the generalized marcum _
q_-function of integer order .
it seems apparent , that in order to derive bounds for @xmath230 of real order @xmath6 , a strict inequality , involving the whole range of @xmath6 , has to be established .
such a generalization concept can be formalized through the following theorem .
[ theorem : marcum_monotonicity ] the generalized marcum _
q_-function , @xmath230 , is strictly increasing with respect to its real order @xmath41 for all @xmath231 . concerning the case when @xmath30 , we notice that can be rewritten as @xmath232 however , in ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 59 ) ) the regularized lower incomplete gamma function @xmath101 has been proved to decrease monotonically with respect to @xmath103 for all @xmath107 .
additionally , for @xmath16 , implies that the normalized nuttall _
q_-function with @xmath233 falls into the generalized marcum _
q_-function of order @xmath6 . nevertheless ,
according to theorem [ theorem : norm_nuttall_monotonicity ] , @xmath234 is strictly increasing with respect to @xmath235 for @xmath41 , and the proof is complete .
the result of theorem [ theorem : marcum_monotonicity ] has also recently demonstrated by sun and baricz in @xcite , where two totally different proofs were given .
the first one combines the series form of the generalized marcum _
q_-function presented in , together with the fact that the regularized upper incomplete gamma function @xmath236 is strictly increasing with respect to @xmath103 for each @xmath107 , originally stated by tricomi in @xcite . a slightly different analytical proof to this can also be found in ( * ? ? ?
* th . 1 ) .
the second proof exploits the interesting relationship between the generalized marcum _
q_-function and the reliability function ( or ccdf ) @xmath237 of a @xmath28 random variable with @xmath29 dof and noncentrality parameter @xmath18 , namely the fact that if @xmath238 then @xmath239 . the interested reader is referred to ( * ? ? ?
3.1 ) for more information .
recalling the relation between the normalized nuttall and the generalized marcum _
q_-functions , that is , fig .
[ fig : kapin1 ] verifies graphically the results of theorem [ theorem : marcum_monotonicity ] , since it actually depicts @xmath230 versus the term @xmath235 .
[ corollary : st_marcum_bounds ] the following inequalities can serve as lower and upper bounds on the generalized marcum _ q_-function @xmath0 of real order @xmath240 for all @xmath241 .
@xmath242 with the equalities above being valid only for the case of half - odd integer values of @xmath6 .
the proof follows immediately from theorem [ theorem : marcum_monotonicity ] . in corollary [ corollary : st_marcum_bounds ] , the quantities @xmath243 and @xmath244 can be evaluated exactly either from , or , , while for @xmath245 reduces to @xmath246 which comes as a complement to the inequalities of and .
this last result was originally demonstrated in ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 16 ) ) , where the authors following a geometric approach proposed tight lower and upper bounds for the generalized marcum _
q_-function of integer order @xmath6 , which have been proved to outperform other existing ones .
this can be easily verified from fig .
[ fig : kapin3 ] , where @xmath247 has been plotted versus @xmath23 for several values of @xmath18 .
therefore , for the case of real @xmath6 , one can expect even further enhancement in the strictness of either the lower bound ( for @xmath248 ) or the upper one ( for @xmath249 ) .
this is clearly depicted in fig .
[ fig : kapin3 ] , where the curves @xmath250 and @xmath251 constitute very tight lower and upper bounds of @xmath252 and @xmath253 , respectively , for all range of @xmath23 .
[ ] [ ] [ 1]@xmath23[][][1]@xmath247[][][1]@xmath23[][][1]@xmath254[l][l][1]@xmath6=@xmath164[l][l][1]@xmath6=@xmath142[l][l][1]@xmath6=@xmath183[][][1]@xmath185[][][1]@xmath255[][][1]@xmath256[][][1]@xmath257[][][1]@xmath258[][][1]@xmath259[][][1]@xmath191[][][1]@xmath194[][][1]@xmath145[][][1]@xmath195[][][1]@xmath146[][][1]@xmath196[][][1]@xmath147[][][1]@xmath260[r][r][1]@xmath153[r][r][1]@xmath154[r][r][1]@xmath155[r][r][1]@xmath156[r][r][1]@xmath157[r][r][1]@xmath4[r][r][1]@xmath158[r][r][1]@xmath159[r][r][1]@xmath160[r][r][1]@xmath161[r][r][1]@xmath162[][][1]@xmath259[][][1]@xmath191[][][1]@xmath194[][][1]@xmath145[][][1]@xmath195[][][1]@xmath146[][][1]@xmath196[r][r][1]@xmath153[r][r][1]@xmath154[r][r][1]@xmath155[r][r][1]@xmath156[r][r][1]@xmath157[r][r][1]@xmath4[r][r][1]@xmath158[r][r][1]@xmath159[r][r][1]@xmath160[r][r][1]@xmath161[r][r][1]@xmath162
applicable monotonicity criteria were established for the normalized and standard nuttall and the generalized marcum _ q_-functions . specifically , it was proved that the two nuttall _
q_-functions are strictly increasing with respect to the real sum @xmath20 for the case when @xmath43 , while the generalized marcum _ q_-function increases monotonically with respect to its real order @xmath6 .
additionally , novel closed - form expressions for both types of the nuttall _ q_-function were given for the case when @xmath3 are odd multiples of @xmath4 and @xmath42 .
regarding the generalized marcum _
q_-function of half - odd integer order , an alternative more compact closed - form expression , equivalent to the already existing one , was derived . by exploiting these results , novel lower and
upper bounds were proposed for the nuttall _
q_-functions when @xmath43 , while the recently proposed bounds for the generalized marcum _ q_-function of integer @xmath6 , were appropriately utilized in order to extend their validity over real values of @xmath6 .
j. i. marcum , `` a statistical theory of target detection by pulsed radar , '' _ ire trans .
inf . theory _
it-6 , no . 2 ,
pp . 59267 , apr .
1960 , ( originally published by the rand corporation , santa monica , ca , research memorandum rm-754 , dec .
1947 , and rm-753 , jul .
1948 ) .
m. k. simon , `` the nuttall @xmath7 function its relation to the marcum @xmath7 function and its application in digital communication performance evaluation , '' _ ieee trans .
_ , vol .
50 , no . 11 , pp .
17121715 , nov .
yang and m .- s .
alouini , `` closed - form formulas for the outage probability of wireless communication systems with a minimum signal power constraint , '' _ ieee trans . veh .
_ , vol .
51 , no . 6 , pp . 16891698 , nov . 2002
. l. yang and m .- s .
alouini , `` on the average outage rate and average outage duration of wireless communication systems with multiple cochannel interferers , '' _ ieee trans .
wireless commun .
_ , vol . 3 , no . 4 ,
11421153 , jul .
j. m. romero - jerez and a. j. goldsmith , `` antenna array processing in fading and interference : an interference - cancellation vs. diversity comparative performance , '' in _ proc .
conf . on communications ( icc07 )
_ , glasgow , scotland , jun .
2428 , 2007 , pp .
11081113 .
s. jin , m. r. mckay , x. gao , and i. b. collings , `` mimo multichannel beamforming : ser and outage using new eigenvalue distributions of complex noncentral wishart matrices , '' _ ieee trans .
_ , vol .
56 , no . 3 , pp . 424434 , mar .
a. maaref and s. aissa , `` joint and marginal eigenvalue distributions of ( non)central complex wishart matrices and pdf - based approach for characterizing the capacity statistics of mimo ricean and rayleigh fading channels , '' _ ieee trans .
wireless commun .
_ , vol . 6 , no . 10 , pp .
36073619 , oct .
p . ho and h .- c .
wang , `` soft - decoding of low - density parity check codes for dpsk signals , '' in _ proc .
optical fiber communication / national fiber optic engineers conf . (
ofc / nfoec07 ) _ , anaheim , ca , mar . 2529 , 2007 , pp . 13 .
a. h. nuttall , `` some integrals involving the @xmath261 function , '' _ ieee trans .
inf . theory _ ,
21 , no . 1 , pp .
9596 , jan .
1975 , ( originally published by the naval underwater systems center , new london , ct , tech . rep .
4755 , may 1974 ) .
p. swerling , `` probability of detection for fluctuating targets , '' _ ire trans .
inf . theory _ ,
it-6 , no . 2 , pp . 269308 , apr .
1960 , ( originally published by the rand corporation , santa monica , ca , research memorandum rm-1217 , mar .
1954 ) .
m. k. simon and m .- s .
alouini , `` a unified approach to the probability of error for noncoherent and differentially coherent modulations over generalized fading channels , '' _ ieee trans .
_ , vol .
46 , no . 12 , pp .
16251638 , dec . 1998 .
, `` a unified performance analysis of digital communication with dual selective combining diversity over correlated rayleigh and nakagami-@xmath32 fading channels , '' _ ieee trans .
_ , vol .
47 , no . 1
3343 , jan . 1999 .
, `` some new results for integrals involving the generalized marcum @xmath7 function and their application to performance evaluation over fading channels , '' _ ieee trans . wireless commun .
_ , vol . 2 , no . 4 , pp .
611615 , jul .
s. gaur and a. annamalai , `` some integrals involving the @xmath262 with application to error probability analysis of diversity receivers , '' _ ieee trans .
_ , vol .
52 , no . 6 , pp . 15681575 , nov .
2003 .
a. pandharipande and j .- p .
m. g. linnartz , `` performance analysis of primary user detection in a multiple antenna cognitive radio , '' in _ proc .
ieee int . conf . on communications ( icc07 )
_ , glasgow , scotland , jun .
2428 , 2007 , pp .
64826486 .
m. k. simon , _ probability distributions involving gaussian random variables : a handbook for engineers and scientists_.1em plus 0.5em minus 0.4emnew york , ny : springer science - business media , llc , 2006 .
g. v. weinberg and l. panton , `` numerical estimation of marcum s @xmath7-function using monte carlo approximation schemes , '' defence science and technology organisation , edinburgh , australia , research rep .
dsto - rr-0311 , apr .
n. ding and h. zhang , `` a flexible method to approximate marcum @xmath7-function based on geometric way of thinking , '' in _ proc .
int . symp . on communications , control and signal processing ( isccsp08 ) _ , st .
julians , malta , mar .
1214 , 2008 , pp . 13511356 .
d. e. johansen , `` new techniques for machine computation of the @xmath7-functions , truncated normal deviates , and matrix eigenvalues , '' applied research laboratory , sylvania electronic systems , waltham , ma , tech . rep .
afcrl-556 , jul . 1961 .
r. li and p. y. kam , `` computing and bounding the generalized marcum @xmath7-function via a geometric approach , '' in _ proc .
symp . on information theory ( isit06 )
_ , seattle , wa , jul .
914 , 2006 , pp . 10901094 .
y. sun and s. zhou , `` tight bounds of the generalized marcum @xmath7-function based on log - concavity , '' in _ proc .
ieee global telecommunications conf .
( globecom08 ) _ , new orleans , la , nov . 30dec . 4 , 2008 , pp .
15 .
r. li and p. y. kam , `` generic exponential bounds on the generalized marcum @xmath7-function via the geometric approach , '' in _ proc .
ieee global telecommunications conf .
( globecom07 ) _ , washington , dc , nov . 2630 , 2007 , pp .
17541758 .
m. k. simon and m .- s .
alouini , `` exponential - type bounds on the generalized marcum @xmath7-function with application to error probability analysis over fading channels , '' _ ieee trans .
_ , vol .
48 , no . 3 , pp . 359366 , mar .
2000 .
s. p. herath and n. rajatheva , `` analysis of equal gain combining in energy detection for cognitive radio over nakagami channels , '' in _ proc .
ieee global telecommunications conf .
( globecom08 ) _ , new orleans , la , nov . 30dec . 4 , 2008 , pp .
15 .
vasilios m. kapinas ( s07m09 ) was born in thessaloniki , greece , in may 1976 .
he received the diploma degree in electrical and computer engineering from aristotle university of thessaloniki , greece , in 2000 .
since 2005 , he has been working toward the ph.d .
degree in telecommunications engineering .
sotirios k. mihos was born in thessaloniki , greece , in april 1984 .
he is an undergraduate student at the aristotle university of thessaloniki , greece , where he is working toward the diploma degree in electrical and computer engineering .
george k. karagiannidis ( m97sm04 ) was born in pithagorion , samos island , greece .
he received the university and ph.d .
degrees in electrical engineering from the university of patras , patras , greece , in 1987 and 1999 , respectively . from 2000
to 2004 , he was a senior researcher at the institute for space applications and remote sensing , national observatory of athens , greece . in june 2004 , he joined aristotle university of thessaloniki , thessaloniki , greece , where he is currently an assistant professor in the electrical and computer engineering department .
his current research interests include wireless communication theory , digital communications over fading channels , cooperative diversity systems , cognitive radio , satellite communications , and wireless optical communications .
he is the author or coauthor of more than 80 technical papers published in scientific journals and presented at international conferences .
he is also a coauthor of two chapters in books and a coauthor of the greek edition of a book on mobile communications .
he serves on the editorial board of the eurasip journal on wireless communications and networking .
karagiannidis has been a member of technical program committees for several ieee conferences .
he is a member of the editorial boards of the ieee transactions on communications and the ieee communications letters .
he is co - recipient of the best paper award of the wireless communications symposium ( wcs ) in ieee international conference on communications ( icc 07 ) , glasgow , u.k .
, june 2007 .
he is a full member of sigma xi . | monotonicity criteria are established for the generalized marcum _
q_-function , @xmath0 , the standard nuttall _ q_-function , @xmath1 , and the normalized nuttall _
q_-function , @xmath2 , with respect to their real order indices @xmath3 .
besides , closed - form expressions are derived for the computation of the standard and normalized nuttall _ q_-functions for the case when @xmath3 are odd multiples of @xmath4 and @xmath5 . by exploiting these results , novel upper and lower bounds for @xmath1 and @xmath2 are proposed .
furthermore , specific tight upper and lower bounds for @xmath0 , previously reported in the literature , are extended for real values of @xmath6 .
the offered theoretical results can be efficiently applied in the study of digital communications over fading channels , in the information - theoretic analysis of multiple - input multiple - output systems and in the description of stochastic processes in probability theory , among others .
closed - form expressions , generalized marcum _
q_-function , lower and upper bounds , monotonicity , normalized nuttall _
q_-function , standard nuttall _ q_-function . |
graphical representations of complex multivariate systems are increasingly prevalent within systems biology . in general a graph or _ network _
@xmath0 is characterised by a set @xmath1 of vertices ( typically associated with molecular species ) and a set @xmath2 of edges , whose interpretation will be context - specific .
in many situations the edge set or _
@xmath3 is taken to imply conditional independence relationships between species in @xmath1 @xcite . for
fixed and known vertex set @xmath1 , the data - driven characterisation of network topology is commonly referred to as _ network inference_. in the last decade many approaches to network inference have been proposed and exploited for several different purposes @xcite . in some settings
it is desired to infer single edges with high precision ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , whereas in other applications it is desired to infer global connectivity , such as subnetworks and clusters ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) . in cellular signalling systems
, the scientific goal is often to identify a set of upstream regulators for a given target , each of which is a candidate for therapeutic intervention designed to modulate activity of the target @xcite .
the output of network inference algorithms are increasingly used to inform the design of experiments @xcite and may soon enter into the design of clinical trials @xcite .
it is therefore important to establish which network inference algorithms work best for each of these distinct scientific goals .
assessment of algorithm performance can be achieved _ in silico _ by comparing inferred networks to known data - generating networks .
it can also be achieved using data obtained _ in vitro _ ; however this requires that the underlying biology is either known by design @xcite , well - characterised by interventional experiments @xcite , or estimated from larger corpora of data @xcite . in either case an estimated network @xmath4 , typically represented as a weighted adjacency matrix , is compared against a known or assumed benchmark network @xmath5 .
community - wide blind testing of network inference algorithms is performed at the regular dream challenges ( see http://www.the-dream-project.org/ ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
there is broad agreement in the network inference literature regarding the selection of suitable performance scores ( described below ) , facilitating the comparison of often disparate methodologies across publications . in this literature ,
the quality of an estimated network @xmath4 with respect to a benchmark @xmath5 is assessed using techniques from classifier analysis .
that is , each possible edge @xmath6 has an associated class label @xmath7 , where @xmath8 is the indicator function .
a network estimator @xmath4 may then be seen as an attempt to estimate @xmath9 for each pair @xmath10 .
two of the main performance scores from classifier analysis are area under the receiver operating characteristic curve ( auroc ) and area under the precision - recall curve ( aupr ) , though alternative performance scores for classification also exist ( e.g. @xcite ) .
these scores , formally defined in sec
. [ classification ] , are based on _ confusion matrices _ of true / false positive / negative counts and represent essentially the only way to quantify performance at a local level ( i.e. based on individual edges ) . at present , performance assessment in the network inference literature does not typically distinguish between the various scientific purposes for which network inference algorithms are to be used .
yet network inference algorithms are now frequently employed to perform diverse tasks , including identifying single edges with high precision @xcite , eliciting network motifs such as cliques @xcite or learning a coherent global topology such as connected components @xcite .
whilst performance for local ( i.e. edge - by - edge ) recovery is now standardised , there has been comparatively little attention afforded to performance scores that capture ability to recover higher - order features such as cliques , motifs and connectivity .
recent studies , including @xcite , proposed to employ spectral distances as a basis for comparing between two networks on multiple length scales . in this article
we present several additional multi - scale scores ( msss ) for network inference algorithms , each of which reflects ability to solve a particular class of inference problem .
much of the popularity of existing scores derives from their objectivity , interpretability and invariance to rank - preserving transformation . unlike previous studies , we restrict attention only to mss that satisfy these desiderata .
the remainder of this paper proceeds as follows : in section [ methods ] we formulate the assessment problem , state our desiderata and present novel performance scores that satisfy these requirements whilst capturing aspects of network reconstruction on multiple scales . using a large corpus of estimated and benchmark networks from the dream5 challenge in section [ results ] , we survey estimator performance and
conduct an objective , data - driven examination of the statistical power of each mss .
the proposed msss provide evidence that the `` wisdom of crowds '' approach , that demonstrated superior ( local ) performance in the dream5 challenge , also offers gains on multiple length scales .
sections [ discussion ] and [ conclude ] provide a discussion of our proposals and suggest directions for future work .
matlab r2013b code ` net_assess ` is provided in the supplement , to accelerate the dissemination of ideas discussed herein .
we proceed as follows : sections [ assumptions ] and [ desiderata ] clarify the context of the assessment problem for network inference algorithms amd list certain desiderata that have contributed to the popularity of local scores . sections
[ notation ] and [ classification ] introduce graph - theoretic notation and review standard performance assessment based on recovery of individual edges . in sections
[ mss one ] and [ mss two ] we introduce several novel msss for assessment of network inference algorithms .
we require each mss to satisfy our list of desiderata ; however these scores differ from existing scores by assessing inferred network structure on several ( in fact all ) scales . for each mss
we discuss associated theoretical and computational issues .
finally section [ test ] describes computation of @xmath11-values for the proposed msss .
performance assessment for network inference algorithms may be achieved by comparing estimated networks against known benchmark information .
the interpretation of the estimated networks themselves has often been confused in existing literature , with no distinction draw between the contrasting notions of significance and effect size . in this section
we therefore formally state our assumptions on the interpretation of both the benchmark network @xmath5 and the network estimators or estimates @xmath4 . *
all networks are directed , unsigned and contain no self - edges .
a network is _ signed _ if each edge carries an associated @xmath12 symbol .
( a1 ) is widely applicable since an undirected edge may be recast as two directed edges and both signs and self - edges may simply be removed .
the challenge of inferring signed networks and more generally the problem of predicting interventional effects requires alternative performance scores that are not dealt with in this contribution , but are surveyed briefly in sec . [ discussion ] .
the preclusion of self - edges aids presentation but it not required by our methodology . the form of this benchmark information will influence the choice of performance score and we therefore restrict attention to the most commonly encountered scenario : * the benchmark network @xmath5 is unweighted
. a network is _ weighted _ if each edge has an associated weight @xmath13 .
note that the case of unweighted benchmark networks is widely applicable , since weights may simply be removed if necessary .
we will write @xmath14 for the space of all directed , unweighted networks that do not contain self - edges and write @xmath15 for the corresponding space of directed , weighted networks that do not contain self - edges .
* the benchmark network @xmath5 contains at least one edge and at least one non - edge .
* network estimators @xmath4 are weighted ( @xmath16 ) , with weights having the interpretation that larger values indicate a larger ( marginal ) probability of the corresponding edge being present in the benchmark network .
in particular we do not consider weights that instead correspond to effect size ( see sec .
[ discussion ] ) .
* in all networks , edges refer to a _
direct _ dependence of the child on the parent at the level of the vertex set @xmath1 ; that is , not occurring via any other species in @xmath1 . assumptions ( a1 - 5 ) are typical for comparative assessment challenges such as dream @xcite . fix a benchmark network @xmath5 .
a _ performance score _ is defined as function @xmath17 that accepts an estimated network @xmath16 and a benchmark network @xmath18 and returns a real value @xmath19 that summarises some aspect of @xmath4 with respect to @xmath5 .
examples of performance scores are given below .
our approach revolves around certain desiderata that any ( i.e. not just multi - scale ) performance score @xmath20 ought to satisfy : * ( interpretability ) @xmath21 $ ] for all @xmath16 , @xmath18 , with larger values corresponding to better performance at some specified aspect of network reconstruction . *
( computability ) @xmath20 should be readily computable . * ( objectivity ) @xmath20 should contain no user - specified parameters . a network estimate @xmath16 is called @xmath20-_optimal _ for a benchmark network @xmath5 if it maximises the performance score @xmath22 over all networks in @xmath15 . * ( consistency ) the oracle estimator @xmath23 is @xmath20-optimal .
a _ rank - preserving _ transformation @xmath24 of a collection of real values @xmath25 satisfies @xmath26 whenever @xmath27 . *
( invariance ) @xmath20 should be invariant to rank - preserving transformations of the weights associated with an estimate @xmath4 .
the criteria ( d0 - 3 ) are important for practical reasons ; ( d4 ) is more technical and reflects the fact that we wish to compare estimators whose weights need not belong to the same metric space .
i.e. different algorithms may be compared on the same footing , irrespective of the actual interpretation of edge weights ( subject to ( a4 ) ) . given that much of the popularity of standard classifier scores derives from ( d0 - 4 ) , it is important that any proposed mss also satisfies the above desiderata . as we will see below , previous studies , such as @xcite , do not satisfy ( d2,4 ) , precluding their use in objective assessment such as the dream challenges . in secs .
[ mss one ] , [ mss two ] below we present novel mss that satisfy each of ( d1 - 4 ) .
the local performance scores that have become a standard in the literature , defined in sec .
[ classification ] below , are easily shown to satisfy the above desiderata . to date , the challenge of assessing network inference algorithms over multiple scales has received little statistical attention ; yet there are several general proposals for quantifying higher order network structure .
notably @xcite assessed spectral distances for suitability in application to biological networks .
the authors recommended use of the ipsen - mikhailov distance ( imd ) due to its perceived stability and robustness properties , as quantified on randomly generated and experimentally obtained networks @xcite .
imd evaluates the difference of the distribution of laplacian eigenvalues between two networks and therefore could be considered an mss .
there has , to date , been no examination of imd and related spectral metrics in the context of performance assessment for network inference applications .
however imd and related constructions ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) fail to satisfy the above desiderata : ( i ) imd itself fails to satisfy ( d4 ) since eigenvalues are not invariant to rank - preserving transformations ; ( ii ) the imd formula contains a user - specified parameter , invalidating ( d2 ) .
@xcite recently introduced `` structural intervention distance '' ( sid ; actually a pre - distance ) which interprets inferred networks @xmath28 as estimators of an underlying causal graph @xmath5 , where both @xmath28 and @xmath5 must be acyclic @xcite .
specifically , sid is the count of pairs of vertices @xmath10 for which the estimate @xmath28 incorrectly predicts intervention distributions ( in the sense of @xcite ) within the class of distributions that are markov with respect to @xmath5 . as such
, sid is closely related to the challenge of predicting the effect of unseen interventions .
however sid fails to satisfy ( d0 ) due to the requirement that estimated and benchmark networks must be acyclic ( i.e. a causal interpretation will not be justified in general ) and is therefore unsuitable for this application .
below we introduce notation that will be required to define our proposed scores : throughout this paper an unweighted network @xmath18 on vertices @xmath29 ( where @xmath30 ) is treated as a binary matrix @xmath31 with @xmath10th entry denoted @xmath32 .
when @xmath33 or @xmath34 we say that @xmath5 contains or does not contain the edge @xmath10 , respectively .
write @xmath35 for the set of parents for vertex @xmath36 . in this paper
we do not allow self - edges ( a1 ) , so that @xmath37 for all @xmath38 .
a path @xmath39 from @xmath40 to @xmath41 in @xmath31 is characterised by a sequence of vertices @xmath42 such that @xmath43 and @xmath44 for all @xmath45 .
note that a path @xmath39 may contain cycles , but these cycles may not involve @xmath46 .
we say that this path has length @xmath47 where @xmath48 .
let @xmath49 denote the set of all paths in @xmath5 from @xmath40 to @xmath41 , so that in particular @xmath50 .
we identify weighted , unsigned networks @xmath16 with non - negative real - valued matrices @xmath51^{p \times p}$ ] and denote the @xmath10th entry by @xmath52 .
should a network inference procedure produce edge weights in @xmath53 then by dividing through by the largest weight produces a network with weights in @xmath54 $ ] .
this highlights the importance of property ( d4 ) , invariance to rank preserving transformations .
it will be required to map @xmath4 into the space of unweighted networks by thresholding the weights at a certain level @xmath55 .
for @xmath56 we write @xmath28 for the unweighted network corresponding to a matrix with entries @xmath57 . in this section
we briefly review local scoring , which has become an established standard in the network inference literature . *
definition : * classification performance scores are defined as functions of confusion matrices , that count the number of true positive ( tp ) , false positive ( fp ) , true negative ( tn ) and false negative ( fn ) calls produced by a classifier . from ( a4 ) it follows that the @xmath58 largest entries in a network estimate @xmath4 correspond to the @xmath58 pairs of vertices with largest marginal probabilities of being present as edges in the benchmark network @xmath5 ; it is therefore reasonable to threshold entries of @xmath4 , say at a level @xmath55 , and to consider confusion matrices corresponding to the classifier @xmath28 . in the standard case of
_ local _ estimation , confusion matrices are given by tp@xmath59 , fp@xmath60 , tn@xmath61 and fn@xmath62 . based on these quantities , ( local ) performance scores may be defined .
in particular , one widely used score is the area under the receiver operating characteristic ( roc ) curve @xmath63 where @xmath64 is the _ true positive rate _ and @xmath65 is the _ false positive rate_. @xmath66 has an interpretation as the probability that a randomly selected pair from @xmath67 is assigned a higher weight @xmath52 that a randomly selected pair from @xmath68 @xcite .
as such @xmath66 takes values in @xmath54 $ ] with 1 representing perfect performance and @xmath69 representing performance that is no better than chance . for finitely many test samples ,
@xmath70 curves may be estimated by linear interpolation of points @xmath71 in roc - space .
precision - recall ( pr ) curves are an alternative to roc curves that are useful in situations where the underlying class distribution is skewed , for example when the number of negative examples greatly exceeds the number of positive examples @xcite . for biological networks that exhibit sparsity , including gene regulatory networks @xcite and metabolic networks @xcite , the number of positive examples ( i.e. edges ) is frequently smaller than the number of negative examples ( i.e. non - edges ) .
in this case performance is summarised by the area under the pr curve @xmath72 where @xmath73 is the _ positive predictive value_. ( in this paper we adopt the convention that @xmath74 whenever @xmath75 . )
@xmath76 also takes values in @xmath54 $ ] , with larger values representing better performance .
for finitely many test samples in pr - space , unlike roc - space , linear interpolation leads to over - optimistic assessment of performance .
the matlab code provided in the supplement follows @xcite in using nonlinear interpolation to achieve correct , unbiased estimation of area under the pr curve .
* captures : * local scores capture the ability of estimators to recover the exact placement of individual edges .
both @xmath66 and @xmath76 summarise the ability to correctly infer local topology across a range of thresholds @xmath55 , with pr curves prioritising the recovery of positive examples in the `` top @xmath58 edges '' @xcite .
* desiderata : * ( d1 ; computability ) , ( d2 ; objectivity ) and ( d3 ; consistency ) are clearly satisfied .
( d4 ; invariance ) is satisfied , since the image of a parametric curve is invariant to any monotone transformation of the parameter ( in this case @xmath55 ) .
we now introduce the first of our msss , which targets ability to infer the connected components of the benchmark network @xmath5 , through the existence or otherwise of directed paths between vertices .
* definition : * in the notation of sec
. [ notation ] , local performance scores are based on estimation of class labels @xmath77 associated with individual edges .
a natural generalisation of this approach is to assign labels @xmath78 to pairs of vertices @xmath6 , such that @xmath79 , based on _ descendancy _ ; that is , based on the presence or otherwise of a directed path from vertex @xmath40 to vertex @xmath41 in the benchmark network .
i.e. @xmath80 . by comparing descendancies in @xmath28 against descendancies in @xmath5 , we can compute confusion matrices and , by analogy with local scores , we can construct area - under - the - curve scores by allowing the threshold @xmath55 to vary .
we denote these scores respectively as @xmath81 and @xmath82 . by analogy with local scores ,
both @xmath81 , @xmath82 take values in @xmath54 $ ] , and @xmath81 is characterised as the probability that a randomly selected pair from @xmath83 is assigned a higher weight @xmath84 than a randomly selected pair from @xmath85 .
* captures : * mss1 captures the ability to identify ancestors and descendants of any given vertex .
mss1 scores therefore capture the ability of estimators to recover connected components on all length scales .
* desiderata : * ( d1 ; computability ) is satisfied due to the well - known warshall algorithm for finding the transitive closure of a directed , unweighted network @xcite , with computational complexity @xmath86 . for the estimated network
@xmath4 it is required to know , for each pair @xmath10 the value of @xmath87 , i.e. the largest value of the threshold @xmath55 at which @xmath88 . to compute these quantities
we generalised the warshall algorithm to the case of weighted networks ; see sec .
[ theory results ] .
( d2 - 4 ) are automatically satisfied analogously to local scores , by construction of confusion matrices and area under the curve statistics .
whilst mss1 scores capture the ability to infer connected components , they do not capture the graph theoretical notion of _ differential connectivity _
( i.e. the minimum number of edges that must be removed to eliminate all paths between a given pair of vertices ) .
our second proposed mss represents an attempt to explicitly prioritise pairs of vertices which are highly connected over those pairs with are weakly connected : * definition : * for each pair @xmath6 we will compute an _ effect _ @xmath89 that can be thought of as the importance of variable @xmath40 on the regulation of variable @xmath41 according to the network @xmath5 ( in a global sense that includes indirect regulation ) . to achieve this
we take inspiration from recent work by @xcite as well as @xcite , who exploit spectral techniques from network theory .
since the effect @xmath90 , which is defined below , includes contributions from all possible paths from @xmath40 to @xmath41 in the network @xmath4 , it explicitly captures differential connectivity .
we formally define effects for an arbitrary unweighted network @xmath91 ( which may be either @xmath5 or @xmath28 ) .
specifically the effect @xmath90 of @xmath40 on @xmath41 is defined as the sum over paths @xmath92 where @xmath93 is the kronecker delta .
effects @xmath90 quantify direct and indirect regulation on all length scales . to illustrate this , notice that eqn .
[ effects def ] satisfies the recursive property @xmath94 ( see sec . [ theory results ] ) . intuitively , eqn .
[ recurse ] states that the fraction of @xmath41 s behaviour explained by @xmath40 is related to the combined fractions of @xmath41 s parents behaviour that are explained by @xmath40 .
rephrasing , in order to explain the behaviour of @xmath41 it is sufficient to explain the behaviour of each of @xmath41 s parents .
moreover , if a parent @xmath58 of @xmath41 is an important regulator ( in the sense that @xmath41 has only a small number of parents ) then the effect @xmath95 of @xmath40 on @xmath58 will contribute significantly to the combined effect @xmath90 .
[ recurse ] is inspired by @xcite and later @xcite , but differs from these works in two important respects : ( i ) for biological networks it is more intuitive to consider normalisation over incoming edges rather than outgoing edges , since some molecular species may be more influential than others .
mathematically , @xcite corresponds to replacing @xmath96 in eqn .
[ recurse ] with @xmath97 .
( ii ) @xcite employed a `` damping factor '' that imposed a multiplicative penalty on longer paths , with the consequence that effects were readily proved to exist and be well - defined .
in contrast our proposal does not include damping on longer paths ( see discussion of d2 below ) and the theory of @xcite and others does not directly apply in this setting .
below we write @xmath98 for the matrix that collects together all effects for the benchmark network @xmath5 ; similarly denote by @xmath99 the matrix of effects for the thresholded estimator @xmath28 .
any well - behaved measure of similarity between @xmath99 and @xmath100 may be used to define a mss .
we constructed an analogue of a confusion matrix as tp@xmath101 , fp@xmath102 , tn@xmath103 , fn@xmath104 . repeating the construction across varying threshold @xmath55 ,
we compute analogues of roc and pr curves .
( note that , unlike conventional roc curves , the curves associated with mss2 need not be monotone ; see supp . sec .
[ auc con ] . ) finally scores @xmath105 , @xmath106 are computed as the area under these curves respectively .
* captures : * mss2 is a spectral method , where larger scores indicate that the inferred network @xmath4 better captures the _ eigenflows _ of the benchmark network @xmath5 @xcite . in general neither @xmath105 nor @xmath106 need have a unique maximiser ( see sec .
[ theory results ] ) . as such
, mss2 scores do not require precise placement of edges , provided that higher - order topology correctly captures differential connectivity .
* desiderata : * eqn .
[ effects def ] involves an intractable summation over paths : nevertheless ( d1 ; computability ) is ensured by an efficient iterative algorithm related but non - identical to @xcite , described in sec .
[ theory results ] . in order to ensure ( d2 ; objectivity ) we did not include a damping factor that penalised longer paths , since the amount of damping would necessarily depend on the nature of the data and the scientific context .
it is important , therefore , to establish whether effects @xmath90 are mathematically well defined in this objective limit .
this paper contributes novel mathematical theory to justify the use of mss2 scores and prove the correctness of the associated algorithm ( see sec . [ theory results ] ) . as with mss1
, the remaining desiderata ( d3 - 4 ) are satisfied by construction . in performance assessment of network inference algorithms
we wish to test the null hypothesis @xmath107 : @xmath108 for an appropriate null model @xmath109 .
we will construct a one - sided test based on a performance score @xmath20 and we reject the null hypothesis @xmath107 when @xmath110 $ ] for an appropriately chosen critical value @xmath111 . in general the distribution of a score @xmath112 under a network - valued random variable @xmath113 displays a nontrivial dependence on the benchmark network @xmath5 . we therefore follow @xcite and propose a monte carlo approach to compute significance levels , though alternative approaches exist including @xcite .
specifically , significance of an inferred network @xmath4 under a null model @xmath109 is captured by the @xmath11-value @xmath114 and given by the strong law of large numbers as @xmath115 where the @xmath116 are independent samples from @xmath109 .
the choice of null model @xmath109 is critical to the calculation and interpretation of @xmath11-values @xmath117 . in most biological applications ,
the null would ideally encompass biological sample preparation , experimental data collection , data preprocessing and network estimation ; however in practice it is convenient to define a null model @xmath118 conditional upon the inferred network @xmath4 ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) . for brevity ,
we restrict attention to the following choice : a random network @xmath119 is obtained from @xmath4 by applying a uniformly random permutation @xmath120 to the vertex labels @xmath1 ; that is , @xmath113 is a uniform sample from the space of graph isomorphisms of @xmath4 .
this choice has the interpretation that , for deterministic network inference algorithms , the null @xmath121 corresponds to randomly permuting the variable labels in the experimental dataset , prior to both data preprocessing and network inference .
note that @xmath121 results in a trivial ( @xmath116-independent ) hypothesis test when @xmath4 is either empty or complete ; we do not consider these degenerate cases in this paper . in sec .
[ signif ] we empirically assess the power of this test based on both existing and proposed scores @xmath20 .
matlab r2013b code ` net_assess ` , that was used to compute all of the scores and associated @xmath11-values used in this paper , is provided in the supplement .
in sec . [ theory results ] below we present theoretical results relating to the proposed scores , demonstrating that mss and local scores can yield arbitrarily different conclusions in settings where local topology is recovered very well but higher - order topology is recovered very poorly and vice versa . in sec .
[ dream info ] , in order to empirically assess the statistical power our proposed scores , we appeal to the large corpus of data available from the dream community , that represents a large and representative sample of network estimators used by the community .
whilst distributional results are difficult to obtain , we are able to characterise the behaviour of mss in both favourable and unfavourable limits .
our first result proves non - uniqueness of @xmath20-optimal estimates : [ nonunique ] for each score @xmath81 , @xmath82 , @xmath105 and @xmath106 , the benchmark network @xmath5 is always @xmath20-optimal ( d3 ) .
however , for mss1 and mss2 , @xmath20-_optimal _
estimates are not unique .
this result contrasts with local performance scores , where @xmath66 and @xmath76 are uniquely maximised by the benchmark network @xmath5 .
intuitively , theorem [ nonunique ] demonstrates that it is possible to add or remove individual edges from a network without changing its higher - order features , such as its connected components .
our second result proves that the mss are fundamentally different from existing scores by demonstrating it is possible to simultaneously recover local topology with arbitrary accuracy yet fail to correctly accurately recover the higher - order topology ( and vice versa ) : [ different ] ( a ) for any @xmath122 there exist a benchmark network @xmath18 and an estimate @xmath16 that satisfy ( i ) @xmath66 , @xmath123 , ( ii ) @xmath81 , @xmath124 , and ( iii ) @xmath82 , @xmath125 .
\(b ) for any @xmath122 there exist a benchmark network @xmath18 and an estimate @xmath16 that satisfy ( i ) @xmath81 , @xmath105 , @xmath82 , @xmath126 , ( ii ) @xmath127 , and ( iii ) @xmath128 .
an important consequence of this result is that estimators that perform well locally , including dream challenge winners , may not be appropriate for scientific enquiry regarding non - local network topology . given the increasing use of network inference algorithms in systems biology ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , this highlights the need to study performance of network inference algorithms on multiple length scales . our final theoretical contribution is to propose and justify efficient algorithms for computation of both mss1 and mss2 .
for mss1 we generalise the warshall algorithm to compute the transitive closure of a directed , weighted graph : [ warshall ] for a fixed weighted network @xmath91 , let @xmath129 be the largest value of the threshold parameter @xmath55 for which there exists a path from @xmath40 to @xmath41 in the network @xmath130 . then @xmath131 may be computed as follows : @xmath132 @xmath133 @xmath134 for mss2 , following @xcite we formulate effects @xmath90 as solutions to an eigenvalue problem .
however our approach is non - identical to @xcite ( see sec .
[ mss two ] ) ; as a consequence we must prove that ( i ) effects are mathematically well - defined , and ( ii ) an appropriately modified version of the algorithm of @xcite converges to these effects .
below we contribute the relevant theory : [ compute ] the effects @xmath135 for an unweighted network @xmath91 exist , are unique , satisfy eqn .
[ recurse ] and may be computed as @xmath136 where @xmath137 is the @xmath40th row of @xmath100 and @xmath138 is defined by ( i ) @xmath139 , ( ii ) @xmath140 for all @xmath141 and @xmath142 , ( iii ) @xmath143 otherwise .
theorem [ compute ] facilitates highly efficient numerical computation of the effect matrices @xmath100 required for mss2 . in practice eqn .
[ algo ] requires convergence diagnostics ; for experiments in this paper we used the stopping rule @xmath144 . for an objective comparison covering a wide range of network inference methodologies
, we exploited the results of the dream5 challenge , where 36 methodologies were blind - tested against both simulated and real transcription factor data @xcite .
the network inference challenge included ( i ) _ in silico _ data generated using genenetweaver @xcite , ( ii ) experimentally validated interactions from a curated database for _ e. coli _ , and ( iii ) transcription - factor binding data and evolutionarily conserved binding motifs for _ s. cerevisiae_. data were provided on the genomic scale , involving ( i ) 1643 , ( ii ) 4297 and ( iii ) 5667 genes respectively . for each of these systems ,
benchmark information was provided in the form of targets for a subset of genes . for assessment purposes we restricted attention to predictions made regarding these subnetworks only , satisfying ( a1 - 3 ) , consisting of ( i ) 195 , ( ii ) 334 and ( iii ) 333 genes respectively .
the dream5 data are well - suited for this investigation , representing a wide variety of network reconstruction algorithms contributed by the community and containing sufficiently many samples to provide a definitive assessment of statistical power . in each challenge
, participants were required to provide a list of inferred edges @xmath10 , together with associated weights @xmath145 .
such edges were directed , unsigned and excluded self - edges , satisfying ( a1 ) .
participants were asked to `` _ infer the structure of the underlying transcriptional regulatory networks _ '' , so that edges were ranked in terms of their probability of existence , rather than their inferred effect size ( a4 ) . for dream5 ,
( a5 ; direct dependence ) appears to be implicit .
the algorithms used to obtain edge lists and weights varied considerably , being classified according to their statistical formulation as either _ bayesian _ , _ correlation _ , _ meta _ , _ mutual information _ ( mi ) , _ regression _ or _
other_. for each methodology we obtained performance scores for datasets ( i - iii ) using the ` net_assess ` package ( supp . figs .
[ silico bar ] , [ ecoli bar ] , [ sc bar ] ) .
we also investigated the overall score reported by @xcite , that summarises performance by combining local auroc and aupr scores across all 3 datasets ( further details in supp .
[ overall def ] ) . in section [ participant ] below
we examine the characteristics of our proposed scores in an aggregate sense based on the full dream5 data .
section [ indiv ] then considers estimator - specific score profiles in order to understand the multi - scale properties of different network inference algorithms . in particular section [ community ] focusses on a `` wisdom of crowds '' approach that has previously demonstrated strong local performance in this setting .
finally section [ signif ] quantifies the statistical power of our proposed scores in the context of hypothesis testing .
local and mss scores may be arbitrarily different in principle ( theorem [ different ] ) , however in practice these scores may be highly correlated . to investigate this we produced scatter plots between the existing and proposed performance scores over all 36 estimators and all 3 datasets ( a total of @xmath146 samples ; fig .
[ dream ] , supp .
[ dream2 ] ) .
our findings , based on spearman correlation ( table [ corr table ] ) , showed that all scores were significantly correlated under aupr on the _ in silico _ and _ e. coli _ datasets ( @xmath147 ) , but not on the _ s. cereviviae _ dataset . indeed results for the _ s. cerevisiae _ dataset were less impressive for all methods , under all performance scores , in line with the general poor performance on this dataset reported by @xcite . on the combined data , both mss1 and mss2
was significantly correlated with the local score under auroc ( @xmath148 , @xmath149 ; @xmath150 in each case ) suggesting that accurate reconstruction of local topology is associated with accurate reconstruction of higher - order topology . on the other hand , on all 3 datasets and both auroc and aupr statistics , mss2 was less highly correlated with the local score compared to mss1 ( e.g. on the combined data and aupr , @xmath151 versus @xmath152 ) .
this suggests that estimated local topology is more predictive of descendancy relationships than predictive of differential connectivity and spectral features . in many cases mss1 and mss2 were significantly correlated ; this was expected since both estimators target multiple scales by design .
network inference algorithms are predominantly employed in contexts where there is considerable uncertainty regarding the data - generating network topology . in such settings attention
is often restricted to the `` most significant '' aspects of inferred topology ; we therefore similarly restrict attention to individual estimator performance as quantified by scores based on aupr , reserving auroc results for supp .
sec . [ auroc results ] . under mss1
the best performing methods included _ bayesian 1,2,6 _ and _ meta 1,5 _ ( fig .
[ dream ] ) . for mss2 many methods attained similarly high scores ; these included _
bayesian 1,2,6 _ and _
meta 1,5_. interestingly these 5 best performing algorithms did not rank highly according to the ( local ) overall score of @xcite ( placing 8th , 24th , 20th , 22nd and 34th respectively out of 36 ) .
similarly _ regression 2 _ , which almost maximised @xmath76 on the _ in silico _ dataset , was among algorithms with the lowest @xmath106 .
this appears to be a real example of the conclusion of theorem [ different ] , where _ regression 2 _ recovers several individual edges yet fails faithfully reconstruct higher - order topology , including connected components .
[ meta5 ] displays inferred and benchmark topology for _ regression 2 _ ; it is visually clear that the algorithm fails to distinguish between different connected components in the true data - generating network .
conversely , estimators such as _ bayesian 1,2 _ simultaneously achieve strong multi - scale performance and unimpressive local performance ( fig .
[ dream ] ) .
it is well understood that bayesian estimators are well suited to recovery of a coherent joint graphical model , compared to estimators that decompose network inference into independent neighbourhood selection problems @xcite .
these results suggest that this intuition is manifest in the multi - scale performance of bayesian network inference algorithms as quantified by both @xmath82 and @xmath106 .
a key finding of @xcite was that the _ community _ network , a principled aggregation of the dream5 participants predictions , was able to maximise the overall score for local performance ( the so - called `` wisdom of crowds '' phenomenon ) .
interestingly , we found that this _ community _ network also performed well over multiple length scales ( supp .
[ silico bar],[ecoli bar],[sc bar ] ) .
in fact the _ community _ network was almost @xmath105 and @xmath106-optimal over all 36 methodologies on all 3 datasets and was ranked highly under @xmath81 in all experiments .
these results suggest that aggregation of estimators that perform well locally ( e.g. _ regression 2 _ ) and well on higher - order topology ( e.g. _ bayesian 2 _ ) may be a successful strategy to achieve strong performance over multiple length scales .
a common fault of complex test statistics is that they lack power relative to simpler statistics ( e.g. @xcite ) . in order to explore the relative statistical power of existing and proposed performance scores @xmath20 in hypothesis testing , we computed monte carlo @xmath11-values for each network estimate @xmath4 in the dream5 challenge , taking each score in turn as a test function ( see sec .
[ test ] ) . under the assumption
that all dream5 participants were capable , in principle , of recovering some aspects of structural information ( i.e. estimators were not simply random samples from @xmath109 ) , we may estimate statistical power by treating the dream5 data as cases where @xmath107 should be rejected .
results ( fig . [ pvals ] ) showed that , over all 36 participants and all 3 datasets , @xmath153 assigned a significance level @xmath154 to 88% of the networks , @xmath82 achieved 73% whilst @xmath106 achieved 71% at this threshold . varying the threshold
@xmath155 we see that @xmath76 is roughly 25% more powerful compared to both @xmath82 and @xmath106 . given that challenge participants likely developed methodology to optimise local performance scores rather than multi - scale scores , these findings support the conclusion that the multi - scale scores @xmath82 , @xmath106 offer comparable power relative to @xmath76 . from the perspective of methodology , these results show that most dream5 algorithms are better suited to identifying local rather than higher - order topology .
results for roc - based scores demonstrated a more considerable decrease in statistical power between local and multi - scale test statistics ; it may therefore be prudent to restrict attention to multi - scale results based on pr - scores .
network inference algorithms are increasingly used to facilitate diverse scientific goals , including prediction of single interactions with high precision , identifying motifs such as cliques or clusters , and uncovering global topology such as connected components . yet
performance assessment of these algorithms does not currently distinguish between these contrasting goals ; we do not know which algorithms are most suited to which tasks .
widely used local scores based on classifier analysis capture the ability of an algorithm to exactly recover a benchmark network at the local level . in this paper we proposed novel multi - scale scores ( msss ) that instead capture ability to infer connectivity patterns simultaneously over all length scales . unlike previous multi - scale proposals , our mss satisfy desiderata that have contributed to the popularity of local performance scores , including invariance to rank - preserving transformation .
theoretical results demonstrated the potential for local and multi - scale analyses to draw arbitrarily different conclusions .
empirical results , based on a comprehensive analysis of the dream5 challenge data , confirmed that whilst local and multi - scale performance were correlated , in several cases an estimator recovered local topology well but recovered higher - order topology poorly and _
vice versa_. these results highlight the importance of performance assessment on multiple length scales , since apparently promising methodologies may be highly unsuitable for inference of non - local network topology .
notably the _ community _ network proposed by @xcite enjoyed both good local and good multi - scale performance .
finally we demonstrated that one proposed score ( @xmath106 ) possesses comparable statistical power with respect to local scores .
our proposals extend scores based on individual edges by considering paths of length @xmath156 .
multi - scale analysis of networks is now an established research field ; indeed techniques based on @xcite have recently come to light in both gene regulatory network @xcite and protein signalling network @xcite analyses .
this work differs to these within - network studies by focussing on the challenge of performance assessment .
the statistical comparison of two unweighted networks has recently been considered by @xcite . in related work , @xcite constructed an _ ad - hoc _ null distribution over residue interaction graphs based on degree - distribution , clustering coefficient , clustering spectrum , average network diameter and spectrum of shortest path lengths . however these are _ mean field _ statistics , which do not respect vertex labels , making their use inappropriate for many scientific applications .
existing and proposed scores capture complementary aspects of performance , so that it is misleading to speak of a universally `` best '' methodology .
mss was specifically designed to capture aspects of higher - order network reconstruction that have been relatively neglected by the community , however in general the existing and proposed scores together still fail to capture many important aspects of estimator performance . in that respect
, this paper represents a small step towards more comprehensive characterisation of estimator performance .
mss1 required a factor of @xmath157 more computation than existing local scores , with mss2 requiring a factor of @xmath158 .
( computational times are presented in supp .
[ times ] . ) given that in practice it may be desirable to restrict attention to a single measure of multi - scale performance , and given that @xmath82 and @xmath106 provide similar statistical power , it may be preferable to favour mss1 over mss2 . whilst multi - scale analysis has the potential to complement local analyses and deepen our understanding of the applicability and limitations of network inference algorithms ,
there are two commonly encountered settings where multi - scale analyses may actually be preferred over local analyses : 1 .
* time series data : * @xcite and others have noticed that , in the setting of causal graphical models and time series data , the `` true '' causal graph @xmath5 depends crucially on the time scale at which the process is described . to see this , notice that the simple multivariate process defined by the causal graph @xmath5 , equal to @xmath159 and distributions @xmath160 with @xmath161 independent @xmath162 random variables , satisfies @xmath163 with @xmath164 independent @xmath165 random variables .
thus any consistent estimator of a linear gaussian vector autoregressive process will , based on data from even time points only , infer the causal graph @xmath166 equal to @xmath167 . i.e. the apparently natural estimator demonstrates the worst possible performance under @xmath168 .
this is undesirable since it remains the case that all descendancy relationships in @xmath4 are all contained in @xmath5 .
however @xmath4 is readily seen to be @xmath169-optimal , so that the proposed scores are robust to the problem of inappropriate sampling frequency .
real - world examples of this problem arise in the ( frequently encountered ) settings where no natural time scale is available for experimental design , or the sampling frequency is limited by resource constraints .
* interventional experiments : * in experimental settings , network topology is frequently inferred through targeted interventions ( e.g. knock - downs , knock - outs , small molecule inhibitors , monoclonal antibodies etc . ) . differential analysis with respect to a control sample in this case does not reveal the direct children of the interventional target , but rather specifies the descendants of that target .
thus benchmark information is naturally available on descendants , whereas additional experimental work is required to uncover direct edges . in these settings
performance assessment using descendancy ( i.e. mss1 ) rather than using individual edges facilitates a reduction in experimental cost .
this paper focused on the problem of inference for network structure , but an alternative viewpoint is to assess networks by their predictive power @xcite . in this
setting ( a4 ) is replaced by an assumption that estimator weights correspond to effect size ( and may be signed ) . for example
these weights may be average causal effects ( ace ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
. however this setting is less common as many popular network inference methodologies do not entail a predictive statistical model .
moreover , prediction is often computationally intensive , whereas assessment of the inferred topology is relatively cheap .
this paper lays statistical and conceptual foundations for the analysis of network inference algorithms on multiple scales .
we restricted attention to the important problem of comparing between inference procedures , as in the dream challenges , and proposed novel multi - scale scores ( msss ) for this setting .
an empirical study based on the dream5 data demonstrated that multi - scale analysis provides additional insight into the character and capability of network inference algorithms and suggested that a crowd - source approach to inference may offer improved reconstruction of higher - order topology . in this paper we focussed on connectivity , but
multi - scale scores may be designed to capture ability to infer specific motifs such as cliques , or particular feedback circuits , for example .
this work is exploratory and should not be used to form conclusions regarding the performance of specific teams in the dream5 challenge .
the authors are grateful to gustavo stolovitzky and sach mukherjee for feedback on an earlier draft of this manuscript .
this work was supported by the centre for research in statistical methodology grant ( epsrc ep / d002060/1 ) .
cjo was involved in designing the dream8 challenge .
cjo , ra , sefs were not involved in the dream5 challenge .
@xmath20-optimality of the benchmark network @xmath5 follows immediately from the definition of each score . to prove nonuniqueness we begin by considering mss1 . for this , take @xmath5 to be the network @xmath170 and take @xmath171 to be the network @xmath172 ; then both networks entail the same descendancy relationships .
it follows from ( d3 ; consistency ) that both @xmath5 and @xmath171 maximise @xmath81 and @xmath82 , demonstrating that the maximiser will be non - unique in general .
the argument for mss2 is analogous , using the same pair of networks .
\(a ) given @xmath122 .
we proceed by constructing a sequence of pairs @xmath173 indexed by @xmath11 , the number of vertices , such that the scores associated with @xmath4 end simultaneously to the required limits as @xmath174 .
define a data - generating network @xmath5 on @xmath11 vertices by the edge set @xmath175 and consider an unweighted network @xmath4 with topology @xmath176 .
i.e. @xmath4 differs to @xmath5 in the addition of a single edge @xmath177 .
the roc curve corresponding to @xmath4 is defined by the three points @xmath178 so that by linear interpolation the area under the curve is @xmath179 .
the pr curve is similarly defined by @xmath180 here @xmath181 is the number of true examples ; for local scores this is @xmath182 , for mss1 this is @xmath183 and for mss2 this is @xmath184 . to compute the area under this curve we must use nonlinear interpolation @xcite . specifically , interpolation between the two points @xmath185 , @xmath186 with true / false positive values @xmath187
, @xmath188 respectively we create new points for each of @xmath189 , increasing the false positives for each new point by @xmath190 . by direct calculation
we have that the area under this interpolated curve is @xmath191}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] fix @xmath122 . for ( i ) , since @xmath4 differs to @xmath5 by just a single edge we have tp @xmath192 , fp @xmath193 , @xmath194 , tpr @xmath195 , fpr @xmath196 , ppv @xmath197 .
it is then easily checked that @xmath198 ^ 2}{[2(p-2)][2(p-2)-1 ] } \rightarrow 1 \ ; \ ; \ ; \text{as } \ ; \ ; \ ; p \rightarrow \infty.\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus @xmath199 . for ( ii - iii ) and
mss1 note that @xmath200 for all @xmath79 , so that @xmath4 predicts every possible descendancy .
thus tp @xmath201 , fp @xmath202 , @xmath203 , tpr @xmath195 , fpr @xmath195 , ppv @xmath204 and @xmath205 ^ 2}{[3(p-2)][3(p-2)+(p^2 - 4p+1 ) ] } \rightarrow 0 \ ; \ ; \ ; \text{as } \ ; \ ; \ ; p \rightarrow \infty.\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus @xmath206 . for mss2 note
that the estimated effects are @xmath207 whereas the benchmark effects are @xmath208\end{aligned}\ ] ] leading to tp @xmath209 , fp @xmath210 , @xmath211 , tpr @xmath195 , fpr @xmath195 , ppv @xmath212 and @xmath213 ^ 2}{[2p][2p+p(p-2 ) ] } \rightarrow 0 \ ; \ ; \ ; \text{as } \ ; \ ; \ ; p \rightarrow \infty.\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus @xmath214 .
taking @xmath215 , we have shown that @xmath173 satisfy the conclusions of the theorem .
\(b ) the converse result is proved similarly , taking @xmath5 to be the cycle @xmath216 and @xmath4 to be the reverse @xmath217 .
let @xmath218 be a path from @xmath46 to @xmath219 .
define the intermediate vertices in the path to be the vertices @xmath220 . for each pair of vertices @xmath40 and @xmath41 we wish to calculate @xmath87 , the largest threshold @xmath55 for which @xmath40 and @xmath41 are connected by a path in @xmath130 . for @xmath221 ,
let @xmath222 represent the largest value of the threshold @xmath55 for which @xmath130 contains a path from @xmath40 to @xmath41 with intermediate vertices in the set @xmath223 . from this definition
, we have @xmath224 , the weighted adjacency matrix and @xmath225 .
next we show that for @xmath226 , @xmath227 to see this , note that @xmath228 unless there is a more strongly connected path which goes through @xmath58 .
such a path must first connect @xmath40 to @xmath58 , and then connect @xmath58 to @xmath41 , with both paths involving intermediate vertices in @xmath229 .
this connection is broken in @xmath130 once the threshold @xmath55 is raised above the minimum of these two connections , that is when @xmath230 .
the conclusion of the theorem follows by iterative application of eqn .
[ recurse ] . _ remarks on the proof of theorem [ warshall ] : _ to make the algorithm more memory efficient , we note that it is not necessary to store more than @xmath158 values for @xmath55 at any point .
this stems from the fact that each iteration is calculated only from the results of the previous one , reducing the necessary storage to @xmath231 .
this can be improved further by noting that if @xmath232 or @xmath233 then @xmath58 can not be an intermediate vertex in a path connecting @xmath40 to @xmath41 and hence @xmath228 .
these @xmath234 index values are the only elements needed to calculate the @xmath58th iteration , and they themselves do not need to be updated . hence , the remaining elements in the matrix are needed only for their own update and can be safely over - written . a corollary to this
is that the @xmath40 and @xmath41 loops in the algorithm can be completed in any order or even in parallel .
note that this algorithm works whether or not the weight matrix @xmath91 is allowed to contain loops .
irrespective of whether loops are permitted or not , @xmath235 represents the largest value of the edge threshold for which node @xmath40 is contained in a cycle . for theorem
[ compute ] we require a series of lemmas : [ converge ] the effects @xmath236 are well - defined and satisfy @xmath89 .
we show the sum in eqn .
[ effects ] converges absolutely .
since all terms are non - negative , it is sufficient to prove that , for each @xmath79 such that @xmath237 , the sum is bounded above .
consider the partial sums @xmath238 if eqn .
[ effects ] diverges , so must @xmath239 since all paths are of finite length , so it is sufficient to prove @xmath240 is bounded above by one as @xmath241 .
we proceed inductively , with base case @xmath242 suppose @xmath243 .
then for @xmath244 we have @xmath245 since a path @xmath39 of length @xmath246 can be decomposed into a path from @xmath247 to @xmath248 and an edge from @xmath248 to @xmath249 . therefore @xmath250 as required .
the case where @xmath251 is similar , leading to @xmath252 from which we again conclude @xmath250 .
therefore @xmath253 for all @xmath254 by induction .
[ equivalent ] effects , as defined in eqn .
[ effects ] , satisfy ( i ) @xmath255 for all @xmath256 s.t .
@xmath257 , ( ii ) @xmath258 for all @xmath256 s.t .
@xmath237 .
the first statement follows immediately from eqn .
[ effects ] . for the second statement , consider two cases : firstly , for @xmath79 such that @xmath244 we have @xmath259 note that absolute convergence ( lemma [ converge ] ) ensures the manipulation of infinite sums is valid . the proof for @xmath251 is similar but requires slightly more care : @xmath260 [ character ] define a matrix @xmath138 by ( i ) @xmath139 , ( ii ) for @xmath261 and @xmath141 , set @xmath140 , ( iii ) @xmath143 otherwise .
then the conclusions of lemma [ equivalent ] are equivalent to the following : for each @xmath40 , the vector @xmath262 where @xmath263 satisfies @xmath264 .
equivalence may be verified directly .
suppose @xmath262 satisfies @xmath264 .
then for all @xmath58 we must have @xmath265 .
[ nonzero ] suppose not .
then there exists @xmath58 such that ( i ) @xmath266 and ( ii ) @xmath267 is maximal .
without loss of generality @xmath261 since otherwise @xmath268 .
then @xmath269 for all @xmath141 , since @xmath270 and @xmath271 .
by induction on a path from @xmath40 to @xmath58 we arrive at @xmath272 , contradicting ( i ) .
there exists a unique solution to @xmath264 with @xmath273 . _
existence : _ the @xmath40th row of @xmath138 contains only zeros , except for the @xmath40th entry which is equal to 1 . hence the characteristic polynomial contains a root ( eigenvalue ) @xmath274 with corresponding eigenvector @xmath275 . from lemma [ nonzero ]
we must have @xmath276 ( else @xmath277 for all @xmath41 , implying that @xmath278 ) .
taking @xmath279 proves existence .
_ uniqueness : _ suppose @xmath262 and @xmath280 both satisfy the criteria .
then @xmath281 is also an eigenvector of @xmath138 with unit eigenvalue . from lemma [ nonzero ]
we have @xmath282 for all @xmath58 , implying that @xmath283 .
together lemmas 1 - 5 prove that the effect matrix @xmath98 exists and is unique .
moreover , the @xmath40th row @xmath137 of @xmath100 may be computed as the unique eigenvector of @xmath138 corresponding to unit eigenvalue . for moderate dimensional matrices @xmath138
, eigenvectors may be calculated using any valid algorithm .
one such algorithm , suitable for high dimensional problems , is the `` power iteration '' method .
specifically we compute the leading eigenvector @xmath262 of @xmath138 as @xmath284 efficient computation in this setting is reviewed in @xcite .
banerjee , a. , jost , j. ( 2009 ) graph spectra as a systematic tool in computational biology .
_ discrete appl math _ * 157*(10):2425 - 2431 .
berkhin , p. ( 2005 ) a survey on pagerank computing , _ internet mathematics _
* 2*(1):73 - 120 .
breitkreutz _ et al . _
( 2012 ) molecular signaling network complexity is correlated with cancer patient survivability , _ proc natl acad sci usa _ * 109*(23):9209 - 9212 .
cantone _ et al . _
( 2009 ) a yeast synthetic network for in vivo assessment of reverse - engineering and modeling approaches , _ cell _ * 137*(1):172 - 181 .
chuang _ et al . _
( 2007 ) network - based classification of breast cancer metastasis , _ mol syst biol _ * 3*:140 .
dash , d. ( 2003 ) caveats for causal reasoning with equilibrium models , phd thesis , intelligent systems program , university of pittsburgh .
davis , j. , goadrich , m. ( 2006 ) the relationship between precision - recall and roc curves .
_ proceedings of the 23rd international conference on machine learning . _ acm press
new york pp.233 - 240 drummond , c. , holte , r.c .
( 2004 ) what roc curves ca nt do ( and cost curves can ) .
1st workshop roc analysis in ai _
, pp.19 - 26 .
fawcett , t. ( 2006 ) an introduction to roc analysis .
_ pattern recogn _ * 27 * , 861 - 874 .
feiglin _ et al . _
( 2012 ) static network structure can be used to model the phenotypic effects of perturbations in regulatory networks .
_ bioinformatics _ * 28*(21):2811 - 2818 .
feizi _ et al . _
( 2013 ) network deconvolution as a general method to distinguish direct dependencies in networks , _ nat biotechnol _ * 31*:726 - 733 .
goadrich , m. , oliphant , l. , shavlik , j. ( 2004 ) learning ensembles of first - order clauses for recall - precision curves : a case study in biomedical information extraction .
_ proceedings of the 14th international conference on inductive logic programming ( ilp)_. heiser _ et al . _
( 2012 ) subtype and pathway specific responses to anticancer compounds in breast cancer .
_ proc natl acad sci usa _ * 109*(8):2724 - 2729 .
( 2012 ) bayesian inference of signaling network topology in a cancer cell line .
_ bioinformatics _ * 28*(21):2804 - 2810
. iwasaki , y. , simon , h.a .
( 1994 ) causality and model abstraction .
_ artif intell _ * 67*(1 ) , 143 - 194 .
jeong _ et al . _ ( 2000 ) the large - scale organization of metabolic networks .
_ nature _ * 407*(6804):651 - 654 .
johannes _ et al . _
( 2010 ) integration of pathway knowledge into a reweighted recursive feature elimination approach for risk stratification of cancer patients .
_ bioinformatics _ * 26*(17):2136 - 2144 .
jurman _ et al . _
( 2011a ) biological network comparison via ipsen - mikhailov distance .
arxiv:1109.0220 .
jurman , g. , visintainer , r. , furlanello , c. ( 2011b ) an introduction to spectral distances in networks .
_ fr art in _ * 226*:227 - 234 .
lakhina _ et al . _
( 2004 ) structural analysis of network traffic flows .
_ proceedings of international conference on measurement and modeling of computer systems , acm new york usa _ ,
pp 61 - 72 .
maathuis _ et al . _
( 2010 ) predicting causal effects in large - scale systems from observational data .
_ nat methods _
* 7*(4):247 - 248 .
marbach _ et al . _
( 2009 ) generating realistic in silico gene networks for performance assessment of reverse engineering methods . _
j comp biol _ * 16*(2):229 - 239 .
marbach _ et al . _
( 2010 ) revealing strengths and weaknesses of methods for gene network inference . _ proc natl acad sci usa _ * 107*(14):6286 - 6291 .
marbach d , _ et al . _
( 2012 ) wisdom of crowds for robust gene network inference .
_ nat methods _
* 9*:796 - 804 .
milenkovi _ et al . _
( 2009 ) optimized null models for protein structure networks .
_ plos one _ * 4*(6):e5967 .
( 2005 ) generank : using search engine technology for the analysis of microarray experiments .
_ bmc bioinformatics _ * 6*:233
. nelander _ et al . _
( 2008 ) models from experiments : combinatorial drug perturbations of cancer cells .
_ mol syst biol _
* 4*(1):216 .
oates , c. , mukherjee , s. ( 2012a ) network inference and biological dynamics .
_ ann appl stat _ * 6*(3):1209 - 1235 .
page _ et al . _
( 1999 ) the pagerank citation ranking : bringing order to the web . _
technical report , stanford infolab . _
pearl , j. ( 2000 ) causality : models , reasoning , and inference . _ cambridge university press , cambridge uk .
_ peters , j. , bhlmann , p. ( 2013 ) structural intervention distance ( sid ) for evaluating causal graphs .
arxiv:1306.1043 .
prill _ et al . _
( 2010 ) towards a rigorous assessment of systems biology models : the dream3 challenges . _
plos one _ * 5*(2):e9202 . prill _ et al . _
( 2011 ) crowdsourcing network inference : the dream predictive signaling network challenge .
_ sci signal _ * 4*(189):mr7 .
scutari , m. , nagarajan , r. ( 2013 ) identifying significant edges in graphical models of molecular networks .
_ artif intell med _ * 57*(3):207 - 217 .
simon , n. , tibshirani , r. ( 2012 ) comment on `` detecting novel associations in large datasets '' by reshef _
et al._. _ technical report , stanford , ca , usa . _ stdler , n. , mukherjee , s. ( 2013 ) two - sample testing in high - dimensional models .
arxiv:1210.4584 .
tong _ et al . _
( 2004 ) global mapping of the yeast genetic interaction network .
_ science _ * 303*(5659):808 - 813 .
wang _ et al . _ ( 2008 ) motif - directed network component analysis for regulatory network inference . _ bmc bioinformatics _
* 9*(suppl .
1):s21 .
warshall , s. ( 1962 ) a theorem on boolean matrices .
_ j acm _ * 9*(1):11 - 12 .
weile _ et al . _
( 2012 ) bayesian integration of networks without gold standards .
_ bioinformatics _ * 28*(11):1495 - 1500 .
winter , c. ( 2012 ) google goes cancer : improving outcome prediction for cancer patients by network - based ranking of marker genes .
_ plos comput biol _ * 8*(5):e1002511 .
yates , p.d .
, mukhopadhyay , n.d .
( 2013 ) an inferential framework for biological network hypothesis tests .
_ bmc bioinformatics _ * 14*(1):94 .
for mss2 only , the analogue of the confusion matrix does not respect monotonicity of the entries tp , fp , tn , fn with respect to varying threshold parameter @xmath55 . as a consequence both the roc and pr curves constructed by interpolation have the potential to exhibit self - intersection and hence there may exist estimates @xmath4 such that the area @xmath20 under the associated roc and pr curves ( auc ) need not be bounded by @xmath285 , invalidating the definition of a score function having image in @xmath54 $ ] . to construct a consistent performance measure we instead define auc as follows :
let @xmath286 denote the coordinates of points on the curve whose auc is to be calculated .
reorder the sequence as @xmath287 such that the x - coordinates form an increasing sequence @xmath288 .
then auc is defined using the trapezium rule as @xmath289 .
note that whilst an ordering @xmath290 may in general be non - unique , the expression for @xmath20 does not depend on which particular ordering is selected .
the ` net_assess ` package for matlab r2013b is provided to compute all of the scores and associated @xmath11-values discussed in this paper . in the case of mss2 we compute roc and pr curves based on 100 uniformly spaced thresholds @xmath291 defined implicitly by @xmath292 .
this package can be used as shown in the following example : typical computational times for the package , based on the dream5 data analysis performed in this paper , are displayed in supp .
[ times ] .
note that local scores require @xmath158 operations to evaluate , whereas mss1 requires @xmath86 and mss2 requires @xmath293 .
we briefly summarise the approach of @xcite that assigns each network inference algorithm an `` overall score '' . for each network inference algorithm
a combined auroc score was calculated as the ( negative logarithm of the ) geometric mean over @xmath11-values corresponding to 3 individual auroc scores ( _ in silico _ , _ e. coli _ , _ s. cerevisiae _ respectively ) .
likewise a combined aupr score was assigned to each network inference algorithm .
for each algorithm an overall score was computed as the arithmetic mean of the combined auroc and combined aupr scores .
note that @xcite report the overall score over all 3 datasets , whereas the performance scores which we report in this paper were computed for each dataset individually .
note also that @xmath11-values used by @xcite were computed using a common null distribution , rather than the estimator - specific nulls @xmath121 that are used in this paper .
supp . figs .
[ silico bar ] , [ ecoli bar ] , [ sc bar ] display the scores @xmath20 obtained by each of the 36 dream methodologies on , respectively , the _ in silico _ , _
e. coli _ and _ s. cerevisiae _ datasets .
[ dream2 ] compares results for the dream5 challenge data based on both local and multi - scale scores and roc analysis .
[ meta5 ] displays both inferred benchmark topology for the _ in silico _ dataset using _ | graphical models are widely used to study complex multivariate biological systems .
network inference algorithms aim to reverse - engineer such models from noisy experimental data .
it is common to assess such algorithms using techniques from classifier analysis .
these metrics , based on ability to correctly infer individual edges , possess a number of appealing features including invariance to rank - preserving transformation .
however , regulation in biological systems occurs on multiple scales and existing metrics do not take into account the correctness of higher - order network structure . in this paper novel performance scores
are presented that share the appealing properties of existing scores , whilst capturing ability to uncover regulation on multiple scales .
theoretical results confirm that performance of a network inference algorithm depends crucially on the scale at which inferences are to be made ; in particular strong local performance does not guarantee accurate reconstruction of higher - order topology . applying these scores to a large corpus of data from the dream5 challenge ,
we undertake a data - driven assessment of estimator performance .
we find that the `` wisdom of crowds '' network , that demonstrated superior local performance in the dream5 challenge , is also among the best performing methodologies for inference of regulation on multiple length scales .
matlab r2013b code ` net_assess ` is provided as supplement .
key words : performance assessment , multi - scale scores , network inference . |
a programme has been started , using the recently commissioned nagoya - south african 1.4 m infrared survey facility ( irsf ) at saao sutherland , to study the stellar populations , evolution and structures of local group galaxies .
one aim of this programme is to detect long period variables ( miras and other types ) in these systems and to derive their infrared light curves .
the programme will necessarily take several years to complete . in the present communication
we discuss the light that initial observations of the dwarf spheroidal galaxy , leo i , throw on the agb star population of that galaxy .
the irsf is a 1.4-m telescope constructed and operated in terms of an agreement between saao and the graduate school of science and school of science , nagoya university , to carry out specialized surveys of the southern sky in the infrared .
the telescope is equipped with a 3-channel camera , sirius , constructed jointly by nagoya university and the national astronomical observatory of japan ( nagashima et al .
1999 ) , that allows _
j , h _ and _ k@xmath5 _ images to be obtained simultaneously .
the field of view is 7.8 arcmin square with a scale of 0.45 arcsec / pixel .
images centred on leo i ( referred to hereafter as field a ) were obtained at two epochs , 2001 - 01 - 16 and 2001 - 12 - 19 , and processed by means of the standard irsf pipeline ( nakajima , private communication ) .
a single image comprises 10 dithered 30-s exposures .
three such sets of frames were combined to give an effective 900-s exposure in each of _ j , h _ and @xmath6 at both epochs . at this stage ,
the effective field of view is reduced to 7.2 arcmin square .
standard stars from persson et al .
( 1998 ) were observed on each night and the results presented here are in the natural system of the sirius camera , but with the zero point of the persson et al
. standards . at the first epoch
, we obtained a supplementary set of images of an adjacent field ( field b ) centred 7 arcmin to the east of field a. the two fields overlap by only about 20 arcsec .
photometry was carried out on the images with the aid of dophot ( schechter , mateo & saha 1993 ) used in fixed - position mode .
since the seeing was much better at the first epoch ( 1.6 arcsec as opposed to 2.6 arcsec at the second epoch ) , the @xmath7 image obtained then was used as a template to measure a complete sample of stars to a limiting magnitude of about @xmath8 .
the data are plotted in figs . 1 ( @xmath1 vs @xmath9 ) and 2 ( @xmath10 vs @xmath11 ) . in the past , @xmath12 , derived from burstein and heiles ( 1984 )
has generally been adopted for this galaxy ( e.g. lee et al .
the results of schlegel et al .
( 1998 ) suggest that a larger value ( @xmath13 ) is appropriate . in neither case
will this lead to significant reddening at jhk and we have neglected it . the stars lying to the blue of the main concentration of stars in fig
. 1(a ) are shown as crosses there and are similarly marked in fig .
they are likely to be foreground field stars .
this view is strengthened by the results for the adjacent field b where the stars in the almost vertical sequence are almost certainly field dwarfs .
two points ( filled squares ) at @xmath141.5 in fig .
1(a ) and one in fig .
1(b ) are likely , from their colours , to be due to background galaxies . indeed ,
close inspection of our images shows evidence for extended emission associated with two of them , one of which is clearly a galaxy on publicly available hst images .
apart from the field stars discussed above and the four very red objects discussed in the next section , all the stars in field a lie on a sequence in fig .
objects identified as carbon stars by azzopardi , lequeux & westerlund ( 1986 = alw ) or by demers & battinelli ( 2002 = db ) are indicated by star symbols .
photometry was obtained for 21 known or suspected carbon stars in leo i , which account for all the stars in the alw and db lists except for the following : db 4 and 8 which are seen on the edges of our frames but were not measured ; db 13 and alw 4 and 6 which are outside our fields . + using the bolometric corrections for carbon stars as a function of @xmath15 given by frogel , persson and cohen ( 1980 ) and a distance modulus of 22.2 for leo i based on the rgb tip ( lee et al .
1993 ) one finds that the carbon star sequence runs from @xmath16 at @xmath17 to @xmath18 at @xmath19 .
however , as can be seen from work on galactic carbon stars ( whitelock 2000 ) , the stars at the redder end of this sequence may well be mira variables and can not be taken as defining the upper limit of the sequence without more observations .
all the stars of this sequence are agb stars .
the rgb tip is expected to be fainter than @xmath20 for any reasonable metallicities or ages ( see for instance castellani et al .
1992 , salaris & cassisi 1998 ) .
the present results show clearly how the blue - green grism results of alw miss the brighter carbon stars and would therefore lead to an underestimate of the brightness of the agb tip .
a similar underestimate of the agb tip is present in _ vi _ work ( e.g. lee et al .
1993 , fig 4d ) .
all but one of the brightest , reddest objects constituting the top of the agb sequence appear in the db list , and it is interesting to note that the obscured objects discussed below would , when dereddened , extend this sequence to even brighter k@xmath5 magnitudes . + at the lower ( bluer ) end of the agb sequence in fig .
1(a ) ( which is of course determined by our adopted magnitude cut off ) there is a group of objects without spectral classification .
they lie mainly to the blue of the known carbon stars in fig 2(a ) . it would be interesting to know whether these are o or c rich objects .
a few of them may be foreground stars . +
fig 1(a ) contains an object , without spectral classification , near the top of the agb sequence with @xmath21 . in view of its position in figs 1(a ) and 2(a ) it seems likely that it is also a carbon star . the fact that it was not found in the survey of db may mean that it is a variable and was below the magnitude limit of db at the time of their observations . the star s colour and luminosity are similar to those expected for carbon miras .
four very red objects are conspicuous in figs 1(a ) and 2(a ) ( field a ) while there is an even redder one , though it is rather fainter in k@xmath5 , in field b ( figs 1(b ) and 2(b ) ) .
the positions and photometry of these five objects at jd 2451962.52 are listed in table 1 .
their locations in the colour - magnitude and two - colour diagrams are consistent with their being bright agb stars obscured by circumstellar dust ( see e.g. whitelock 2000 ) . in view of the fact that the top magnitude or more of the agb sequence just discussed is heavily , and perhaps entirely , populated by carbon stars
, it seems very likely that these obscured stars are also carbon stars .
as noted by nikolaev & weinberg ( 2000 ) several other types of object have colours that would put them in this part of the two - colour diagram , for example , oh / ir stars and protostars . for the reasons outlined above
, it seems more likely they are carbon- rather than oxygen stars , though the discussion on ages below is not significantly affected if the latter is the case .
the presence of protostars of this brightness in a dwarf spheroidal galaxy would be quite remarkable .
these five stars are the most extreme examples yet found of this type of obscured object in dwarf spheroidal galaxies . the nearest comparable objects , though they are somewhat bluer(@xmath22 ) , are the two carbon miras that have been found in the sagittarius dwarf spheroidal ( whitelock et al . 1999 ) .
.photometry and positions ( equinox 2000 ) of 5 very red objects in the field of leo i [ cols="^ , < , < , < , < , < , < " , ] obscured stars are denoted by their letters in table 1 , other stars by their db numbers ( c10 etc . ) or their alw designation .
a full discussion of the nature of the obscured stars must obviously be deferred till further variability studies have been made .
neverthless it is of interest to draw some preliminary conclusions . + the results we have obtained are strikingly similar to those of nishida et al .
( 2000 ) ( see also tanab et al . 1997 , 1999 ) who found an obscured carbon mira in each of the intermediate age clusters , ngc 419 , ngc 1783 and ngc 1978 , in the magellanic clouds .
these variables have values of @xmath15 ( saao system ) between 3.75 and 4.76 .
thus , in colour , the obscured leo i stars lie between the sagittarius dwarf spheroidal miras , mentioned above , and the lmc cluster miras . in the magellanic cloud clusters the tip of the unobscured agb is at @xmath23 and @xmath24 ( using data from frogel et al .
1990 and distance moduli of 18.6 and 19.0 for the lmc and smc ) . in leo
i the corresponding values are 8.3 and 5.1 which however remain uncertain pending full variability studies . + in the magellanic cloud clusters the miras have a mean @xmath25 of 8.0 and @xmath18 or slightly brighter .
the corresponding figures for the obscured stars in leo i are quite uncertain both because three , and possibly all , are variable and also because the estimation of bolometric corrections for such stars from @xmath26 colours is rather uncertain .
the three obscured stars found to be variable have @xmath27 and @xmath28 whilst all five obscured stars yield @xmath29 and @xmath30 . to derive these results for leo i we have used a relation of @xmath31 to bolometric correction for carbon miras derived by whitelock ( to be published ) which includes the use of iso data .
thus the tip of the unobscured agb in @xmath25 and @xmath32 is very similar in leo i to that in the three magellanic cloud clusters .
the obscured agb may be fainter in @xmath32 than the cluster miras but that is not certain .
+ it is of some interest to note that if the intrinsic ( underlying ) colours of the five obscured stars were @xmath33 , they would all move to a position near the top of the agb in @xmath1 , when dereddened using the reddening law ( @xmath34 ) found for the circumstellar envelope of the galactic carbon mira r for ( feast et al . 1984 ) .
+ the magellanic cloud clusters are estimated to have ages in the range 1.6 to 2.0 gyr , metallicities , [ fe / h ] @xmath35 , and turn - off masses of @xmath36 . in view of the above discussion
it seems likely that the leo i obscured stars are in the same age and mass range .
it is therefore interesting to note that gallart et al ( 1999 ) suggest that major star formation in leo i stopped about 2 gyr ago and that a metallicity of that population as high as [ fe / h ] @xmath35 is possible .
the results thus suggest that the obscured stars , and the most luminous unobscured agb stars , at least , belong to this youngest major stellar component of leo i. + the very red star ( star e ) in field b is especially interesting .
it is @xmath37 arcmin from the centre of leo i , much further out than any of the other stars we discuss .
even the c stars outside field a , mentioned in section 2.2 , are within @xmath38 arcmin of the centre .
there is hi in a wide area around leo i and apparently associated with it ( blitz & robishaw 2000 ) .
star counts ( irwin & hatzidimitriou 1995 ) show that leo i has a tidal radius of 13 arcmin , which extends well beyond the distance of star e from the centre
. however the stellar density at these distances is very low compared with that in the main body of the galaxy .
furthermore , in dwarf spheroidals the younger populations are generally more concentrated to the centre than the older ones ( e.g. harbeck et al .
thus if we have correctly interpreted this star as similar to the obscured agb stars in field a , and hence relatively young , its position at such a large distance from the centre is remarkable .
this is particularly so when it is recalled that such objects are short lived and are therefore tracers of much larger populations .
since the star has only been observed at one epoch we can not comment on its possible variability .
we have obtained jhk@xmath5 photometry of a complete sample of stars to k@xmath5=16 in a 7.2 arcmin square field centred on leo i and in an adjacent field .
this sample includes all 21 known carbon stars falling in the imaged area .
our results show that the top one magnitude or more of the agb in @xmath1 is populated entirely or almost entirely by carbon stars .
these stars form a sequence in the @xmath39 diagram and several of them are variable .
in addition there are five very red stars , at least three of them variable , which from their magnitudes and colours are deduced to be agb tip stars obscured by dust shells .
they are strong candidates for mira variability .
these stars , and at least the brightest unobscured agb stars , probably belong to the youngest and most metal rich of the significant stellar populations in leo i. comparison with carbon stars in magellanic cloud clusters suggests ages of about 2 gyr for these stars in agreement with the age of the youngest major population in this galaxy as derived in other ways .
surprisingly , in view of the fact that younger populations are generally more centrally concentrated than others in dwarf spheroidals , one of the obscured stars lies about 8 arcmin from the centre of the galaxy , compared with a tidal radius of 13 arcmin .
we are grateful to noriyuki matsunaga for help at the telescope .
we also thank yasushi nakajima for providing the reduction pipeline and for information on the photometric system .
the irsf project was initiated and supported by nagoya university and the national astronomical observatory of japan , and we thank professor sato , professor nagata and all others involved in the project .
azzopardi m. , lequeux j. , westerlund b.e .
, 1986 , a&a , 161 , 232 (= alw ) blitz l. , robishaw t. , 2000 , apj , 541 , 675 .
burstein d. , heiles , c. , 1984 , apj sup .
54 , 33 castellani v. , chieffi a. , straniero o. , 1992 , apj sup , 78 , 517 demers s. , battinelli p. , 2002
, aj , 123 , 238 (= db ) feast m.w . ,
whitelock p.a .
, catchpole r.m . ,
overbeek m.d . , 1984 , mnras , 211 , 331 frogel j.a . ,
mould j. , blanco v.m .
, 1990 , apj , 352 , 96 frogel j.a . , persson s.e .
, cohen j.g . , 1980 , apj , 239 , 495 gallart c. et al . 1999 , apj , 514 , 665 guarnieri m.d . ,
renzini a. , ortolani s. , 1997 , apj , 477 , l21 harbeck d. , grebel e.k .
, holtzman j. , guhathakurta p. , brandner w. , geisler d. , sarajedini a. , dolphin a. , hurley - keller d. , mateo m. , 2001 , aj , 172 , 3092 held e.v . , clementini g. , rizzi l. , momany y. , saviane i. , di fabrizio l. , 2001 , apj , 562 , l39 hernandez x. , gilmore g. , valls - gabaud d. , 2000 , mnras , 317 , 831 irwin m. , hatzidimitriou d. , 1995 , mnras , 277 , 1354 lee g.l . , freedman w. , mateo m. , thompson i. , roth m. , ruiz m - t . , 1993 , aj , 106 , 1420 nagashima c. et al . , 1999 , in `` star formation 1999 '' , ed
. nakamoto t.,(nobeyama radio observatory ) .
nikolaev s. , weinberg , m.d . ,
2000 , apj , 542 , 804 nishida s. , tanab t. , nakada y. , matsumoto s. , sekiguchi k. , glass i.s .
, 2000 , mnras , 313 , 136 persson s.e . , murphy d.c . , krzeminski w. , roth m. , rieke m.j . , 1998 , aj , 116 , 2475 . salaris m. , cassisi s. , 1998 , mnras , 298 , 166 schecter p.l . , mateo m. , saha a. , 1993 , pasp , 105 , 1342 schlegel d. , finkbeiner d.p . , davis m. , 1998 , apj , 500 , 525 tanab t. , nishida s. , matsumoto s. , onaka t. , nakada y. , soyano t. , ono k. , sekiguchi t. , glass i.s . , 1997 , nature , 385 , 509 tanab t. , nishida s. , nakada y. , onaka t. , glass i.s . , sauvage m. , 1999 in `` asymptotic giant branch stars '' , ( iau symp . 191 ) , ed . le bertre t. , asp , p.573 whitelock p. , 2000
, in `` the carbon star phenomenon '' , ( iau symp .
177 ) , ed .
wing r.f . , kluwer , dordrecht , p.179 whitelock p. , menzies j. , irwin m. , feast m. , 1999 , in `` the stellar content of local group galaxies '' , ( iau symp .
192 ) , eds .
whitelock p. , cannon r. , asp , p.136 | the first results of a study of the dwarf spheroidal galaxy , leo i , using the new nagoya - south african infrared survey facility ( irsf ) are presented .
@xmath0 observations show that most , if not all , of at least the top magnitude of the agb in @xmath1 is populated by carbon stars .
in addition there are five very red objects which are believed to be dust enshrouded agb stars .
one of these is , remarkably , well outside the main body of the galaxy .
three of these obscured stars and five known carbon stars show variability in observations 11 months apart .
one of the obscured stars has @xmath2 making it highly likely that it , at least , is a mira variable .
the tip of the agb is at @xmath3 , but further variability studies are necessary to obtain a definitive value .
comparison with carbon stars , both miras and non - miras , in magellanic cloud clusters and taking into account other evidence on the ages and metallicities of leo i populations suggests that these obscured stars belong to the youngest significant population of leo i and have ages of @xmath4 gyr .
galaxies : dwarf - galaxies : stellar content - stars : agb and post - agb - stars : variable : other - local group |
the order parameter in high - temperature superconductors ( hts ) has been proved to have mainly a @xmath4 pairing symmetry.@xcite in particular , try - crystal phase - sensitive measurements @xcite have determined the presence of a predominant @xmath5gap symmetry up to the superconducting critical temperature @xmath1 over , if any , other minor components smaller than 5% of that with the @xmath5symmetry .
thermal transport measurements have also shown the predominance of this symmetry for the gap function .
in particular , when a magnetic field is rotated parallel to the cuo@xmath6 planes , the longitudinal thermal conductivity shows a fourfold oscillation which can be explained in terms of both andreev scattering of quasiparticles by vortices ( as ) and doppler shift ( ds ) in the energy spectrum of the quasiparticles if one takes a @xmath5gap into account.@xcite nevertheless , the fourfold oscillation in the thermal conductivity has been resolved up to @xmath7 k. above this temperature , no direct evidence for this type of symmetry from this kind of measurements has been published . furthermore ,
deviations from the expected angular pattern within a pure @xmath5symmetry have been attributed to the effect of pinning of vortices.@xcite the variation of the thermal conductivity as a function of angle @xmath8 between the heat current and the magnetic field applied parallel to the cuo@xmath6 planes depends mainly on the heat transport by quasiparticles , their interaction with the supercurrents ( vortices ) and the symmetry of the order parameter.@xcite an angular pattern showing properties of the order parameter symmetry can only be achieved when the temperature is low enough so that the quasiparticle momentum is close to the nodal directions of the gap .
otherwise , thermal activation would also induce quasiparticles at different orientations from those of the nodes and hence , the sensitivity of the probe to measure gap characteristics will be reduced .
the first question we address in this paper is related to the temperature range at which the nodal characteristics of the gap are directly observable by thermal conductivity .
the second question we would like to clarify in this paper is whether the thermal activation of quasiparticles with increasing temperature , treated phenomenologically within a fermi liquid approximation for thermal transport including the @xmath5gap function , can explain the experimental results in the whole temperature range , in particular the change of symmetry of @xmath0 as a function of temperature . in this paper ,
we calculate numerically the thermal conductivity at different angles and temperatures at fixed magnetic field , assuming an andreev reflection model for the scattering of quasiparticles by supercurrents , originally proposed by yu et al .
@xcite within the two dimensional brt expression @xcite for the thermal conductivity , and compare it to the experimental data .
angle scans in a magnetic field applied parallel to the cuo@xmath6 planes were performed in order to measure the angular variation of the longitudinal thermal conductivity @xmath0 in two single crystals of yba@xmath6cu@xmath9o@xmath10 high - temperature superconductor .
the overall results agree with the theoretical model and confirm the predominance of the @xmath5gap up to @xmath1 .
the measurements provide also new results that improve our knowledge of the thermal transport at temperatures at which the nodal properties of the gap are not directly observable . following the experimental and sample details of the next section , we present in sec .
[ res ] the main experimental results . in sec .
[ comparison ] we describe the used model and compare it with the experimental data .
a brief summary is given in sec .
in order to rule out effects concerning shape and structure characteristics of the crystal we have used two different samples of yba@xmath6cu@xmath9o@xmath10 ( ybco ) : a twinned single crystal with dimensions ( length @xmath11 width @xmath11 thickness ) @xmath12mm@xmath13 and critical temperature @xmath14k previously studied in refs .
@xcite and an untwinned single crystal with dimensions @xmath15mm@xmath13 and @xmath16k.@xcite for the measurement of the thermal conductivity , a heat current @xmath17 was applied along the longest axis of the crystal studied . in the untwinned sample
, j was parallel to the @xmath18-axis and in the twinned crystal was parallel to the @xmath19-axes ( twin planes oriented along ( 110 ) ) . in both cases
the position of the lattice axis with respect to the crystal axis was determined using polarized light microscopy and x - ray diffraction .
the longitudinal temperature gradient @xmath20 was measured using previously calibrated chromel - constantan ( type e ) thermocouples @xcite and a dc picovoltmeter .
special efforts were made in order to minimize the misalignment of the plane of rotation of the magnetic field applied perpendicular to the c - axis with the cuo@xmath6 planes of the sample .
this misalignment was minimized step by step , measuring the angle dependence of @xmath0 until a satisfactory symmetrical curve was obtained . in this way
, we estimate a misalignment smaller than @xmath21 .
an in - situ rotation system enabled measurement of the thermal conductivity as a function of the angle @xmath8 defined between the applied field and the heat flow direction along @xmath22 , see fig .
[ esquema ] . for more details on the experimental arrangement
see ref .
@xcite . as pointed out by aubin et al .
@xcite and observed in refs .
@xcite , the effect of the pinning of vortices plays an important role in determining the correct angle pattern in this kind of measurement .
in fact , when the angle of the magnetic field is changed , a non uniform vortex distribution due to pinning forces may appear .
as argued in ref .
@xcite , the pinning of the josephson - like vortices parallel to the planes is strongly affected by vortices perpendicular to the planes which may appear due to the misalignment of the crystal axes with respect to the applied magnetic field .
in this situation , even hysteresis in the angular patterns of the thermal conductivity can be measured .
@xcite we note that pinning of vortices is influenced by the distribution of the oxygen vacancies in the sample as well as by defects and impurity centers .
thus , in order to rule out the influence of this effect in the measurements , a field - cooled procedure have to be used .
this procedure consists of two steps . in the first step the sample
is driven into the normal state by heating to a few kelvin above @xmath1 and the angle is changed .
secondly , it is cooled down to the desired temperature at constant field . in fig .
[ fig1 ] we show the longitudinal thermal conductivity as a function of the temperature in both crystals at zero magnetic field . as argued by many authors ( see for example refs .
@xcite ) , the observed behavior in fig .
[ fig1 ] provides qualitative information about the quality of the sample .
the height of the peak observed in the temperature dependence of the thermal conductivity is related to the relative contributions between the density of impurity scattering centers and the strength of the inelastic electron - electron scattering .
crystals showing large peaks may have a small amount of impurity scattering centers @xcite and/or larger quasiparticle - related inelastic contribution .
the origin of the peak is explained in terms of a competition between the decrease of the inelastic scattering rate @xcite and the decrease of the population of quasiparticles as temperature decreases.@xcite taking this into account we might conclude that the untwinned crystal has a larger impurity scattering and a smaller quasiparticle - related inelastic scattering since its peak is considerably smaller than that of the twinned sample .
this is supported by its reduced t@xmath23 with respect to the twinned sample ( which indicates a larger density of oxygen vacancies ) . since the thermal conductivity at @xmath1 appears to be larger for the untwinned sample , we conclude that there should be a substantial reduction of the inelastic scattering .
as we show below , this makes the measurement of electronic properties related to the gap symmetry more difficult .
the angular patterns of the longitudinal thermal conductivity @xmath24 at different temperatures for the twinned and untwinned crystals are shown in figs .
[ fig2 ] and [ fig3 ] respectively . at low enough temperatures ( @xmath25 ) ,
a magnetic field parallel to the cuo@xmath6 planes of the sample produces a fourfold oscillation in the longitudinal thermal conductivity as the field is rotated from @xmath26 to @xmath27 .
we note that at both @xmath26 and @xmath28 the magnetic field is perpendicular to the heat flow . at @xmath29
the field is parallel to the heat flow ( see fig .
[ esquema ] ) . as noted in refs .
@xcite and @xcite the angular patterns are not free of the phononic contribution to the total thermal conductivity
. however , this contribution seems to be constant under variations of the magnetic field orientations for two reasons .
1 ) for fields parallel to the cuo@xmath6 planes , vortices are unlikely to have a normal core ( josephson vortices ) , making a change of the phonon attenuation with field and angle unlikely .
2 ) there is no experimental evidence that the phononic contribution does change substantially with field .
the similarity between the temperature dependencies of @xmath24 and @xmath30 below @xmath1 where a large change in the quasiparticle density ocurrs@xcite , indicates that the phonon - electron interaction does not play a main role in the temperature dependence of @xmath31 .
the electronic contribution is entirely responsible for the magnetic field dependence , revealed in both thermal conductivity @xcite and in microwave measurements @xcite , and indicates against any large phonon - electron scattering .
in fact , no remarkable phonon - electron scattering have been addressed in those experiments where the measured magnetic field dependencies are larger than the oscillation amplitudes measured in this paper .
therefore , measurable contributions of the phonons via phonon - electron scattering are more unlikely to occur in the angular patterns .
this characteristic makes the angular profiles of the thermal conductivity suitable to be compared with electronic models by using the quantity @xmath32 where the phononic contribution is subtracted@xcite . as pointed out in ref .
@xcite , the variation of the thermal conductivity in figs .
[ fig2 ] and [ fig3 ] can be explained with a model involving a doppler shift ( ds ) in the energy spectrum of the quasiparticles along with an accurate inclusion of the impurity scattering @xcite and/or assuming andreev scattering ( as ) of quasiparticles by vortices@xcite .
briefly , in the mixed state the quasiparticles are in the presence of a phase gradient produced by the superfluid flow of the vortices .
thus , as viewed from the laboratory frame they experience a doppler shift in their energy spectrum given by the scalar product of the momentum and superfluid velocity , * * p**@xmath33**v**@xmath34 .
when a quasiparticle of momentum * p * is moving parallel to the magnetic field , the product is zero and hence , no ds occurs .
thus , the angular characteristic of this effect is to produce an excess of quasiparticles in the direction perpendicular to the field and thereby , reducing the local " thermal resistance at this orientation @xcite . when the field is placed parallel to the heat current ,
the doppler shift is the same for both nodal directions at @xmath35 and @xmath36 .
therefore and since thermal resistances must be added in parallel , a simple picture in which there are only quasiparticles at the nodes would produce a fourfold oscillation in the thermal conductivity with opposite sign to that observed in the measurements .
however , as pointed out in refs .
@xcite , the ds affects both the carrier density as well as the scattering rate of quasiparticles , and since at high enough temperatures the latter dominates , the quasiparticles move more easily parallel to the magnetic field .
therefore , the sign of the fourfold oscillation observed in the experiments is also recovered within this picture . in the as mechanism a phase gradient , namely , the superfluid flow surrounding the vortices may induce andreev reflection of the quasiparticles @xcite .
thus , the ds in the energy spectrum * * p**@xmath33**v**@xmath34 is implicitly taken into account in the as picture .
as viewed from the laboratory frame , when the quasiparticle energy equals the value of the gap , then the quasiparticle is transformed into a quasihole reversing its velocity and hence , decreasing its contribution to the thermal conductivity .
thus , a quasiparticle with momentum * p * parallel to the magnetic field does not experience a ds and hence , no andreev reflection can take place .
the field acts as a filter @xcite for the quasiparticle that contributes to reduce the total temperature gradient .
note that the as picture gives rise to a fourfold oscillation in the thermal conductivity as the magnetic field is rotated parallel to the cuo@xmath6 planes without more considerations . then , qualitatively both as and ds can explain in principle the angle profiles observed at low temperatures . however as pointed out in ref .
@xcite , neither as nor ds alone can explain the magnetic field dependence of the oscillation amplitude in the whole field range @xmath37t@xmath38 t .
therefore , a more realistic picture of the thermal transport should take both into account .
as argued in ref .
@xcite , this scenario produces different regimes influenced by the predominance of either the ds or the as in the magnetic field dependence .
thus , at constant temperature the strength of the magnetic field becomes the parameter that changes the regime . at low magnetic fields the ds dominates and the as dominates at high fields @xcite . in both cases ,
an increase of the oscillation amplitudes with increasing magnetic field strength is predicted . in fig .
[ fig2 ] the oscillation amplitudes of the thermal conductivity at 3 t and 8 t for different temperatures in the twinned crystal are shown .
as the temperature increases the fourfold oscillation is no longer observable , see figs .
[ fig2 ] and [ fig3 ] .
this fact can be understood if one takes into account the thermal activation of the quasiparticles at different orientations from those of the nodes of the order parameter . in other words , if we suppose that the same processes that govern the thermal transport at low temperatures ( as and ds ) are responsible for the high temperature behavior as well , we have to conclude that an increasing number of carriers appears in the direction of the heat current as the temperature is raised . as we shall see below from the numerical results using the as model ,
this is , in fact , what takes place as the temperature is increased .
however , although the observed angle profiles can be well described by the numerical analysis , the amplitude of the oscillations are smaller than the simulation results at @xmath39k . as argued for the peak of the curves in fig .
[ fig1 ] and shown in the following section , this discrepancy can be solved by the inclusion of an inelastic scattering into the calculations.@xcite in fig .
[ fig3 ] we show the angle dependence of the untwinned crystal at 8 t. similar angle profiles as for the twinned sample have been found , but the amplitude of the oscillation is considerably smaller .
this can be explained in terms of a larger concentration of impurity scatterers in the untwinned sample , as discussed above and in ref .
in fact , if the impurity scattering rate is sufficiently large , the relative weight of the directionality of the as and ds mechanisms to @xmath0 weakens .
the influence of the impurity scattering has been considered in the original models by inclusion of an impurity rate.@xcite we note also that the symmetry of the @xmath40curves differs slightly for the twinned and untwinned samples at the same absolute or reduced temperature .
the effect of impurity scatterers can be accounted for by an impurity dependent gap parameter as done in ref .
@xcite . in general , however , it can be viewed as an effect related to the ratio of the modulus of the gap and the density of states of the quasiparticles at a temperature t and momentum * p*. therefore , since our twinned sample has a larger critical temperature @xmath1 than our untwinned sample , the oxygen deficiency in the latter could be also responsible for a reduced density of states , and therefore , for a different angle patterns respect to the sample with a higher @xmath1 .
figure [ fig4 ] shows the complete angle patterns measured in the twinned crystal at 8 t. at @xmath41 k no clear change in the thermal conductivity when the field is rotated parallel to the cuo@xmath6 planes is observed .
this can be explained by taking into account the temperature dependence of the gap , which vanishes at @xmath1 , and the relative increase of the inelastic scattering rate .
to compare the experimental results with theory we take recently published results of the longitudinal and transverse thermal conductivity@xcite into account that indicate that at high fields ( @xmath42 t ) , applied parallel to the planes , the main scattering mechanism for the quasiparticles appears to be the andreev reflection by vortex supercurrents.@xcite therefore , we use the formulation proposed by yu et al.@xcite using a two dimensional model of the brt expression for the thermal conductivity,@xcite which has been useful in the interpretation and discussion of previous results.@xcite under this model the longitudinal thermal conductivity can be written as @xmath43 where @xmath44 is the the x - axis component of the group velocity , and @xmath45 is the quasiparticle energy . for this energy
we use a free quasiparticle model @xmath46 where @xmath47 is the effective mass of the quasiparticle .
@xmath48 may be taken as a relaxation rate given by the sum of the following scattering mechanisms acting in series : scattering of qp by impurities @xmath49 , by phonons @xmath50,@xcite by quasiparticles @xmath51@xcite and as by vortex supercurrents @xmath52.@xcite the expression for this scattering rate according to the model for the as , proposed by yu et al .
@xcite , is given by @xmath53 ^2}{p_f^2\hbar ^2\ln ( a_\upsilon /\xi _
0)\sin ^2\psi ( { \bf p})}\right\}\,,\ ] ] where @xmath54 is the intervortex spacing given in this model by @xmath55 we use the bcs - like parameterization for the temperature dependence of the gap amplitude @xmath56 and the @xmath4-pairing symmetry in the resulting gap @xmath57 enters as follows @xmath58\,.\ ] ] we showed recently@xcite that at low temperatures and high fields , a quantitative agreement between this model and the oscillation amplitudes of the thermal conductivity tensor is achieved only if the intervortex spacing is increased by about five times the value defined in eq.([spacing ] ) if we use the parameters from ref .
@xcite ( @xmath59 mev , ginzburg - landau parameter @xmath60 , anisotropy @xmath61 , @xmath62 t ) .
furthermore , from those fits@xcite for the twinned crystal we obtained a momentum independent impurity scattering @xmath63 ps and @xmath64 . assuming a total scattering rate given by the sum of the as and impurity rates , i.e. @xmath65 , the model given by eqs .
( 1 ) to ( 5 ) reproduces remarkably well the symmetry of the curves in fig .
[ fig4 ] in the whole measured temperature range . because in this calculation we do not take explicitly into account the inelastic scattering rate @xmath66 given by phonons @xmath67 and by quasiparticles @xmath68 , the calculated oscillation amplitude above 20 k increases up to @xmath69 times that observed in the experiment . in fig .
[ fig5 ] we show the results of the numerical simulation .
each of the curves in this figure has been multiplied by a factor @xmath70 in order to fit the experimental oscillation amplitude ( fig .
[ fig4 ] ) .
we note that the symmetry of the results can be explained quite satisfactorily by this model .
this result , on one hand , supports the predominance of @xmath4-pairing symmetry of the order parameter up to temperatures close to @xmath1 and , on the other hand , confirms the idea of a competition between the thermal activation of quasiparticles in the direction of the thermal current and the gap structure .
we note that the @xmath4-gap symmetry is the only gap function that can explain the whole angular patterns up to t@xmath23 .
of course , a @xmath71-gap also gives a onefold oscillation similar to the experiments above @xmath72 50 k , but it does produce neither the fourfold oscillation below @xmath72 15 k nor the curves between 15 k and 50 k. thus , the set of curves in fig .
[ fig4 ] can be only explained if one uses a main @xmath4-gap into the calculations .
furthermore , the anisotropy of @xmath73-wave gap proposed for bscco,@xcite does not seem to occur in ybco since in the latter the nodes are observed at both field orientations @xmath8= 45@xmath74 and @xmath8= -45@xmath74(see also refs .
@xcite ) .
the factor @xmath70 is related to the inelastic scattering rate @xmath66 , which was not taken explicitly into account in the previous calculations . however , an approximation can be carried out to get roughly the temperature dependence of the total scattering rate , which could be in part associated to the temperature dependence of @xmath66 . since the as mechanism
is weakly temperature dependent below @xmath75 , we may approximate the total scattering rate as @xmath76 the temperature dependence of the inelastic scattering rate is given then by the factor @xmath70 in this approximation as @xmath77 in fig .
[ fig6 ] we plot @xmath78 . as expected , we recover the overall behavior of the inelastic scattering rate already described by many authors@xcite .
below @xmath1 it decreases rapidly and becomes negligible in comparison with the impurity and as scattering rates below @xmath79 k. although the approximation given by ( [ aprox ] ) is too rough to obtain the true temperature dependence of the inelastic scattering rate , it is instructive to compare the obtained power dependence with results from literature .
thermal hall angle measurements performed in the same ybco twinned crystal show that @xmath80 down to @xmath81k ( @xmath82 is the effective mass and @xmath83 is the hall scattering time of the quasiparticles responsible for the hall signal).@xcite the power law dependence obtained for @xmath84 is similar to that obtained for the longitudinal scattering rate assuming a @xmath3wave pairing.@xcite since quasiparticle - quasiparticle scattering mechanism should be the dominant temperature dependent inelastic scattering below @xmath1 , we expect a rate proportional to the density of quasiparticles .
interestingly , within the simple two - fluid model we expect a density of quasiparticles proportional to @xmath85 . on the other hand ,
a @xmath86 dependence is expected within the spin - fluctuation scattering picture@xcite .
in summary , we have measured the longitudinal thermal conductivity @xmath24 in two single crystals of ybco in the presence of a planar magnetic field which was rotated parallel to the cuo@xmath6 planes , from @xmath87 k up to a few kelvins below @xmath1 .
fourfold oscillations were recorded below @xmath88 k. above this temperature the angle dependence of the longitudinal thermal conductivity changes ; from the minimum at @xmath89 ( field parallel to the heat current ) a maximum develops at high @xmath90 .
the observed behavior in the whole temperature range can be very well reproduced by a model involving andreev scattering of quasiparticles by vortices and the two - dimensional brt expression for the thermal conductivity assuming a @xmath3wave pairing .
the overall results agree with the @xmath4-pairing symmetry of the order parameter .
this agreement suggests that the mechanisms that influence the behavior of the quasiparticles below @xmath1 and above @xmath91k are well described by the fermi liquid theory at nearly optimal doping .
the small differences found in the angle patters between the twinned and untwinned samples can be explained in terms of the different impurity concentration as well as oxygen deficiency and are accounted for by the phenomenology exposed in this work . | the angle dependence at different temperatures of the longitudinal thermal conductivity @xmath0 in the presence of a planar magnetic field is presented . in order to study the influence of the gap symmetry on the thermal transport ,
angular scans were measured up to a few kelvin below the critical temperature @xmath1 .
we found that the four - fold oscillation of @xmath0 vanishes at @xmath2k and transforms into a one - fold oscillation with maximum conductivity for a field of 8 t applied parallel to the heat current .
nevertheless , the results indicate that the @xmath3wave pairing symmetry remains the main pairing symmetry of the order parameter up to @xmath1 .
numerical results of the thermal conductivity using an andreev reflection model for the scattering of quasiparticles by supercurrents under the assumption of @xmath3wave symmetry provide a semiquantitative description of the overall results . |
the periodic orbits of a flow in @xmath0 form knots . for _ morse - smale flows _ there are only finitely many periodic orbits .
wada @xcite has classified all links that can be realized as a collection of closed orbits of nonsingular morse - smale flows on @xmath0 .
further , wada s scheme includes an indexing of the components of the link according to whether the orbit is an attractor , a repeller , or a saddle . in a _ smale flow _
, by contrast , the saddle sets may contain infinitely many closed orbits , while the attractors and repellers must still be collections of finitely many orbits .
franks @xcite devised an abstract classification scheme for nonsingular smale flows on @xmath0 using a device he called the _ lyapunov graph _ of a flow .
each vertex of a lyapunov graph corresponds to an attractor , repeller or saddle set ( the _ basic sets _ of the flow ) .
the saddle vertices are labeled with an _ incidence matrix _ ( determined non - uniquely by the first return map on a cross section ) .
a simple algorithm is used to decide if a given lyapunov graph can be realized by a nonsingular smale flow on @xmath0 .
however , the lyapunov graph contains no explicit information about the embedding of the basic sets .
in contrast to wada s study of morse - smale flows , franks work does does not allow one to _ see _ smale flows .
it was our curiosity to visualize smale flows that motivated this paper .
it is however worth noting that wada s results have provided tools for understanding bifurcations between morse - smale flows @xcite and it is likely that some of our results may sheld light on bifurcations between smale flows and form morse - smale flows to smale flows . also see @xcite for an example .
the project of this paper is to visually construct examples of smale flows and in some special contexts classify all the possible embedding types .
our primary tools will be the theory of _ templates _ , branched 2-manifolds which model the saddle sets @xcite and certain earlier results of franks that do give some information about the embedding of closed orbits .
specifically , computations of linking numbers and alexander polynomials are employed .
sections [ sec1 ] and [ sec2 ] contain background information .
our main classification theorem ( theorem [ thm_ls ] ) is in section [ sec3 ] .
various generalizations and applications follow in sections [ sec4 ] and [ sec5 ] .
the author wishes to thank john franks and masahico saito for helpful conversations .
a knot @xmath1 is an embedding of @xmath2 into @xmath0 .
it is traditional to use @xmath1 to denote both the embedding function and the image in @xmath0 .
a knot may be given an orientation .
we will always use a flow to induce an orientation on our knots .
the _ knot group _ of @xmath1 is the fundamental group of @xmath3 .
a link of @xmath4 components is an embedding of @xmath4 disjoint copies of @xmath2 into @xmath0 .
two knots @xmath5 and @xmath6 ( or two links ) are equivalent if there is an isotopy of @xmath0 that takes @xmath5 to @xmath6 .
when we talk about a knot we almost always mean its equivalence class , or _
knot type_. a _ knot diagram _ is a projection of a knot or link into a plane such that any crossings are transverse .
if the knot has been given an orientation the crossings are then labeled as positive or negative according to whether they are left - handed or right - handed respectively .
the knot group can be calculated from a diagram and , unlike the diagram , is invariant .
if a knot has a diagram with no crossings then it is called an _ unknot _ or a _ trivial knot_. the following proposition will be of use to us . *
( the unknotting theorem , @xcite ) * [ prop_unknotting ] the knot group of @xmath1 is infinite cyclic if and only if @xmath1 is the unknot . given a diagram of a two component link @xmath7 the _ linking number _ of @xmath5 with @xmath6 is half the sum of the signs of each crossing of @xmath5 under @xmath6 and is denoted @xmath8 .
the linking number is a link invariant , and thus is independent of the choice of the diagram . the hopf link shown in figure [ fig_hopf ] .
its linking number is @xmath9 , depending on the choice of orientations .
a knot @xmath10 is _ composite _ if there exists a smooth 2-sphere @xmath11 such that @xmath12 is just two points @xmath13 and @xmath14 , and if @xmath15 is any arc on @xmath11 joining @xmath13 to @xmath14 then the knots @xmath16 @xmath17 are each nontrivial , ( i.e. not the unknot ) .
we call @xmath5 and @xmath6 factors of @xmath1 and write @xmath18 of course the designation of the two components of @xmath19 as `` inside '' and `` outside '' is arbitrary . this implies @xmath20 .
we call @xmath1 the connected sum of @xmath5 and @xmath6
. if a nontrivial knot is not composite then it is _
prime_. figure [ prime ] gives an example .
it shows how to factor the _ square knot _ into two trefoils .
trefoils are prime .
it was shown by schubert ( * ? ? ?
* chapter 5 ) that any knot can be factored uniquely into primes , up to order .
the unknot serves as a unit . a knot which fits on a torus and wraps about it @xmath13 times longitudinally and @xmath14 times meridianally ( @xmath13 and
@xmath14 must be relatively prime ) , is called a @xmath21 _ torus knot_. if @xmath1 is any knot , then a @xmath21 _ cable _ about @xmath1 , where @xmath13 and @xmath14 are relatively prime , is defined as follows .
let @xmath22 be a solid torus neighborhood of @xmath1 , whose core is @xmath1 .
let @xmath23 be a _ standard longitude _ of @xmath24 for @xmath1 , i.e. @xmath25 .
now consider a torus @xmath26 with a @xmath21 knot on it .
let @xmath27 be a homeomorphism that takes a standard longitude of @xmath26 to @xmath23 . the image of @xmath21 under this map is said to be a @xmath21 cable of @xmath1 or , @xmath28 .
we shall extend the usual cabling notation a bit .
let @xmath29 be a meridian of @xmath1 , @xmath30 be a standard longitude of @xmath1 , and @xmath31 be a loop bounding a disk on @xmath26 .
( a curve on a surface is _ inessential _ if it bounds a disk in the surface , and is _ essential _ if it does not . )
thus , we have tools with which to build up new knots from old ones . in wada s paper and in sections 4 and 5 here , one builds new flows from old ones using processes based in part on taking connected sums and forming cables .
the cabling construction has been generalized in two ways .
a knot @xmath32 is a _ satellite _ of a given knot @xmath1 if @xmath32 lives inside a tubular neighborhood @xmath1 and meets every meridianal disk
. if the orientation of @xmath32 is always roughly the same as that of @xmath1 ( i.e. there is a fibration of @xmath22 by meridianal disks which are always transverse to @xmath32 ) , we say that @xmath32 is a _
generalized cable _ of @xmath1 .
it is known that the satellite of a nontrivial knot is nontrivial @xcite , a fact which we shall make use of in case 3 in the proof of theorem [ thm_ls ] .
knot polynomials form an important class of knot and link invariants .
we shall make use of the first known knot polynomial , the alexander polynomial .
it can be readily calculated from either a knot diagram or the fundamental group .
the latter approach will be of special importance to us .
the reader who wishes to check our polynomial calculations should be able to find all he or she needs in @xcite .
a @xmath33 flow @xmath34 on a compact manifold @xmath35 is called _ structurally stable _ if any sufficiently close approximation @xmath36 in the @xmath33 topology is _ topologically equivalent _ , that is if there exists a homeomorphism @xmath37 taking orbits of @xmath34 to orbits of @xmath36 , preserving the flow direction .
structurally stable @xmath33 flows have a hyperbolic structure on their chain - recurrent sets @xcite .
we define these concepts next .
a point @xmath38 is _ chain - recurrent _ for @xmath34 if for every @xmath39 and @xmath40 there exists a chain of points @xmath41 in @xmath35 , and real numbers @xmath42 all bigger than @xmath26 such that @xmath43 when ever @xmath44 .
the set of all such points is called the chain - recurrent set @xmath45 .
it is a compact set invariant under the flow .
a compact invariant set @xmath46 for a flow @xmath34 has a _ hyperbolic structure _ if the tangent bundle of @xmath46 is the whitney sum of three bundles @xmath47 , @xmath48 , and @xmath49 each of which invariant under @xmath50 for all @xmath51 . furthermore
, the vector field tangent to @xmath34 spans @xmath49 and there exist real numbers @xmath52 and @xmath53 such that @xmath54 @xmath55 we also define the local stable and unstable manifolds associated to an orbit @xmath56 .
they are respectively , @xmath57 and @xmath58 the global stable and unstable manifolds are defined similarly by removing the condition that @xmath59 .
it was shown by smale that if the chain - recurrent set @xmath45 of flow has a hyperbolic structure then @xmath45 is the union of a finite collection of disjoint invariant compact sets called the
_ basic sets_. each basic set @xmath60 contains an orbit whose closure contains @xmath60 .
the periodic orbits of a basic set @xmath60 are known to be dense in @xmath60 .
a basic may either consist of a single closed orbit or it may contain infinitely many closed orbits and infinitely other nonperiodic chain - recurrent orbits . in the later case
any cross section is a cantor set and the first return map is a _ subshift of finite type_. in the former case any cross section is a finite number of points but the first return map is still a ( trivial ) subshift of finite type .
thus , each basic set is a suspension of a subshift of finite type . a nontrivial basic
will be called _
chaotic_. a flow @xmath61 on a manifold @xmath35 is called a _ smale flow _ provided * the chain - recurrent set @xmath45 of @xmath61 has a hyperbolic structure , * the basic sets of @xmath45 are one - dimensional , and * the stable manifold of any orbit in @xmath45 has transversal intersection with the unstable manifold of any other orbit of @xmath45 .
most references allow for fixed points but we will be working primarily with nonsingular flows .
smale flows on compact manifolds are structurely stable under @xmath33 perturbations but are not dense in the space of @xmath33 flows .
it is easy to see that for dim @xmath35 = 3 , each attracting and repelling basic set is a closed orbit .
the admissible saddle sets , however , may be chaotic . a smale flow with no chaotic saddle sets
is called a _
morse - smale _ flow . for a chaotic saddle set of a smale flow in a 3-manifold
one can construct a neighborhood that is foliated by local stable manifolds of orbits in the flow .
collapsing in the stable direction produces a branched 2-manifold . with a semi - flow induced from the original flow , this branched 2-manifold becomes what is known as a _
template_. the template models the basic saddle set in that the saddle set itself can be recovered from the template via an inverse limit process and that any knot or link of closed orbits in the flow is smoothly isotopic to an equivalent knot or link of closed orbits in the template s semi - flow .
the proof of this is due to birman and williams @xcite and can also be found in ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 2.2.4 ) .
a key tool in the analysis of hyperbolic flows is the concept of a markov partition .
we refer the reader to @xcite for details . in our context
a markov partition is a finite , disjoint collection of disks transverse to a basic set of a flow .
each orbit of the basic set must pass through some element of the markov partition in forward time .
given a markov partition @xmath62 for a suspended subshift of finite type with first return map @xmath63
we define the corresponding @xmath64 _ incidence matrix _ @xmath65 , by @xmath66 the incidence matrix , like a knot diagram , is not invariant but does contain invariant information . we can encode additional information about the embedding of a basic set by modifying the incidence matrix . given a markov partition for a basic set with first return map @xmath63 , assign an orientation to each partition element . if the partition is fine enough the function @xmath67 is constant on each partition element . the _ structure matrix _
@xmath68 is then defined by @xmath69 , where @xmath70 is any point in the @xmath71-th partition element .
the next proposition was proved by franks in @xcite .
[ prop_link ] let @xmath61 be a smale flow with a single attracting closed orbit @xmath72 , and a single repelling closed orbit @xmath73 , with saddle sets @xmath74 .
then the absolute value of the linking number of @xmath72 and @xmath73 is given by @xmath75 where @xmath76 denote the respective structure matrices of the saddle sets .
the manner in which a saddle set `` links '' a closed orbit @xmath1 , is described by modifying the structure matrix @xmath68 to form a _ linking matrix _ @xmath77 . consider a markov partition , @xmath62 , of the saddle with incidence matrix @xmath65 . pick a base point @xmath78 in @xmath79 and paths @xmath80 from @xmath78 to @xmath81 , also in @xmath79 . for each @xmath82
let @xmath83 be a segment of the flow going from @xmath81 to @xmath84 without meeting any of the other partition elements .
now form a loop consisting of @xmath83 , @xmath80 , @xmath85 and , if needed , short segments in @xmath81 and in @xmath84 .
if the disks have been chosen small enough , then the linking number of any such loop with @xmath1 depends only on @xmath71 and @xmath86 . that this can always be done is shown in @xcite .
the _ linking matrix _ @xmath87 associated with a suitable markov partition for a given closed orbit @xmath1 is defined to by @xmath88 where @xmath14 is the linking number of the loops formed from segments connecting @xmath81 to @xmath84 and @xmath1 as described above .
the following proposition is a special case of theorem 4.1 in @xcite .
[ franks , 1981 ] [ prop_alex ] let @xmath61 be a smale flow in @xmath0 with one attracting closed orbit @xmath72 , one repelling closed orbit @xmath73 , and a single saddle set @xmath89 .
let @xmath90 and @xmath91 be the linking matrices for @xmath89 with respect to @xmath72 and @xmath73 respectively .
then the alexander polynomials of @xmath72 and @xmath73 are given by @xmath92 and @xmath93 respectively , up to multiples of @xmath94 . finally , we record a proposition about morse - smale flows .
it is an obvious corollary to wada s theorem @xcite , though it is easy to prove directly .
[ prop_hopf ] in a ( nonsingular ) morse - smale flow on @xmath0 with exactly two closed orbits , the link of closed orbits forms a hopf link with one component a repeller and the other an attractor .
by a _ simple smale flow _ we shall mean a smale flow with three basic sets : a repelling orbit @xmath73 , an attracting orbit @xmath72 , and a nontrivial saddle set .
in this section we will show how to construct simple smale flows in which the saddle set @xmath23 can be modeled by an embedding of the lorenz template shown in figure [ lorenz ] .
that is , there is an isolating neighborhood of the saddle set @xmath23 foliated by local stable manifolds of the flow , such that when we collapse out in the stable direction we get an embedding of the lorenz template .
call such flows _ lorenz - smale flows_. in this section we classify all possible lorenz - smale flows .
we shall call the isolating neighborhood of the saddle set @xmath87 .
the set of points of @xmath95 where the flow is transverse outward is called the _
exit set_. the backward orbits of these points approach orbits in the saddle set @xmath23 .
the exit set consists of two annuli , @xmath96 and @xmath97 , connected by a long strip @xmath68 .
the core of the exit set is homeomorphic to the boundary of the lorenz template .
we shall refer to the cores of @xmath96 and @xmath97 , as @xmath70 and @xmath98 , respectively .
see figure [ lnbhd ] .
the set of points of @xmath95 where the flow is transverse inward is called the _
entrance set_. the entrance set also consists of two annuli connected by a long strip .
denote these two annuli by @xmath99 and @xmath100 and their respective cores @xmath101 and @xmath102 and the connecting strip by @xmath103 . see figure [ lnbhd ] .
the intersection of the closures of the entrance and exit sets consists of three closed curves where the flow is tangential to @xmath95 .
although the entrance set is harder to visualize , its topological type can be determined by an euler characteristic argument .
notice that @xmath70 and @xmath101 are isotopic to @xmath104 and hence have the same knot type .
similarly , @xmath98 and @xmath102 must have the same knot type . take tubular neighborhoods of @xmath72 and @xmath73 and denote them by @xmath65 and @xmath105 respectively . to build a smale flow from these building blocks , we first attach the closure of the exit set of @xmath87 to @xmath106 .
this gives a vector field on a new 3-manifold pointing inward along its entire boundary .
that this can be done smoothly was shown by morgan in @xcite .
next attach @xmath107 to the boundary of @xmath108 so that the union @xmath109 is @xmath0 .
we know from proposition [ prop_link ] that the linking number between @xmath73 and @xmath72 must be @xmath9 , but what types of knots can @xmath72 and @xmath73 be ?
what are all the different ways the saddle set can be embedded so as to still have the lorenz template as a model ?
this later question is made precise by asking , what types of knots can @xmath70 and @xmath98 be ? can they be linked ? can the annuli @xmath96 and @xmath97 have any number of twists or are there restrictions ? ( this last question is equivalent to finding the _ framing _ of a knot . ) to answer these questions we use the following framework .
first , we study what may happen when the attaching of the exit set of @xmath87 to @xmath106 is such that @xmath70 and @xmath98 are both inessential in @xmath106 .
then we investigate the case where one of them , say @xmath98 , is essential but the other is still inessential .
finally we consider the case where both @xmath70 and @xmath98 are essential in @xmath106 .
the results of this analysis are then consolidated into the statement of theorem [ thm_ls ] .
our classification scheme is only up to isotopy of @xmath0 , plus mirror images and flow reversal .
also , we shall not be concerned with the orientation , i.e. the flow direction , of @xmath72 or @xmath73 , since their orientations can be easily reversed by modifying the flow in a tubular neighborhoods of @xmath72 and @xmath73 , ( * ? ? ?
* first paragraph ) .
[ thm_ls ] for a lorenz - smale flow in @xmath0 the following and only the following configurations are realizable .
the link @xmath110 is either a hopf link or a trefoil and meridian . in the latter case
the saddle set is modeled by a standardly embedded lorenz template , i.e. both bands are unknotted , untwisted , and unlinked , with the core of each band a meridian of the trefoil component of @xmath110 . in the former case
there are three possibilities : ( 1 ) the saddle set is standardly embedded .
( 2 ) one band is twisted with @xmath4 full - twists for any @xmath4 , but remains unknotted and unlinked to the other band , which must be unknotted and untwisted .
( 3 ) one band is a @xmath21torus knot , for any pair of coprime integers , with twist @xmath111 .
the other band is unknotted , untwisted and unlinked to the knotted one .
the proof is divided into three cases . *
case 1 : * suppose both @xmath70 and @xmath98 are inessential in @xmath106 .
it follows that @xmath96 and @xmath97 are untwisted , that is the linking number between each of the two components of @xmath112 and of @xmath113 is zero .
it is also obvious that @xmath70 and @xmath98 are unknotted and unlinked .
there are two subcases to consider .
it could be that @xmath70 and @xmath98 are concentric in @xmath106 , or it could be that they are not .
that is @xmath70 and @xmath98 may or may not form the boundary of an annulus in @xmath106 . in figure [ lonaball ]
we show that both cases can be realized . the neighborhood @xmath87 is attached to a 3-ball @xmath114 along the closure of the exit set of @xmath87 .
figure [ lonaball ] also shows two ways one might attach handles to the 3-ball so as to turn it into a solid torus .
suppose we attach the handle to the small disks marked @xmath115 and @xmath116 in the manner shown .
call the resulting solid torus @xmath117 .
if we take @xmath118 the result is still a solid torus , and the complement in @xmath0 is just another solid torus , @xmath119 . we can now build a smale flow with an attractor in @xmath117 , a repeller in @xmath119 and a lorenz saddle set in @xmath87 . upon further inspection
the reader should be able to see that @xmath70 and @xmath98 are concentric .
now , instead on attaching a handle at @xmath115 and @xmath116 , we attach one to @xmath114 and @xmath120 as shown again in figure [ lonaball ] .
this time call the solid torus obtained @xmath121 .
as before @xmath122 is a solid torus with solid torus complement in @xmath0 .
thus , we have constructed another lorenz - smale flow with @xmath70 and @xmath98 inessential on a tubular neighborhood of the attractor .
is it diffeomorphic to the lorenz - smale flow we constructed before ? to see that the answer is no , study the loops @xmath70 and @xmath98 again .
they are still both inessential , that is they both bound disks in @xmath123 .
but they are no longer concentric .
this can be seen from careful study of figure [ lonaball ] . in both these examples
the attractor and repeller form a hopf link .
we claim that if both @xmath70 and @xmath98 are inessential in @xmath106 then @xmath72 and @xmath73 must form a hopf link .
since @xmath105 is a tubular neighborhood of a knot , the union of @xmath65 and @xmath87 is a knot complement .
but we will show that @xmath108 is a solid torus whose core has the same knot type as that of @xmath72 .
thus , we could remove @xmath108 from our flow and replace it with a solid torus containing just an attractor and no saddle set .
this gives us a nonsingular morse - smale flow on @xmath0 with just two closed orbits whose link type is the same as @xmath110 .
but by proposition [ prop_hopf ] these must form a hopf link .
we now show that @xmath108 is a solid torus of whose core is the same knot type as @xmath72 .
first , assume that @xmath70 and @xmath98 are not concentric .
then they bound disjoint disks @xmath124 and @xmath125 in @xmath106 .
expand @xmath124 and @xmath125 , if needed , so that they contain all of @xmath96 and @xmath97 respectively but remain disjoint .
thicken @xmath124 and @xmath125 by pushing into @xmath65 a little , forming two 3-balls @xmath126 and @xmath127 , which are disjoint and do not meet the orbit @xmath72 .
let @xmath128 and @xmath129 .
it is clear that @xmath130 is a solid torus whose core is still @xmath72 .
the set @xmath131 is a 3-ball and @xmath132 .
but the union @xmath133 is taken along the disk @xmath134 . thus , there is a deformation retract from @xmath135 to @xmath130 .
this proves our claim for @xmath70 and @xmath98 not concentric .
now suppose @xmath70 and @xmath98 are concentric and assume @xmath70 is inner most .
then construct the 3-ball @xmath126 as before .
let @xmath136 and @xmath137 .
this time @xmath131 is a solid torus .
it is attached to @xmath130 along the annulus @xmath138 whose core @xmath98 is inessential in @xmath139 and is a ( 1,0 ) longitude in @xmath131 .
thus we can retract @xmath131 to @xmath97 and push it into @xmath130 without changing the knot type of @xmath72 .
this finishes the proof of our claim .
* case 2 : * suppose that @xmath70 is inessential but that @xmath98 is essential .
the opposite case is similar .
again , it is clear that @xmath96 is untwisted and that @xmath70 is unknotted and unlinked to @xmath98 .
we shall again show that @xmath72 and @xmath73 must form a hopf link .
it then follows that since @xmath98 lives in a standardly embedded torus , @xmath106 , @xmath98 is a torus knot or unknot .
if @xmath98 is a meridian ( 0,1 ) , or a longitude ( 1,0 ) then @xmath97 is untwisted .
if @xmath98 is an unknot @xmath140 or @xmath141 then @xmath97 has @xmath14 full twists . for nontrivial torus knots the twisting in @xmath97
is uniquely determined by the knot type of @xmath98 .
if @xmath98 is a @xmath21 torus knot then the twist in @xmath97 is @xmath111 . that any @xmath21 torus knot can be realized by @xmath98 is shown by construction in figure [ yess ] .
one places a @xmath21 curve on a torus .
attach an annulus to this curve along one boundary component .
add a `` lorenz ear '' to form a lorenz template .
next a `` finger '' pushes out of the torus and snakes along the boundary of the template and finally pokes through the @xmath70 loop .
thicken this complex up to get @xmath142 .
the repeller is then placed as a meridian in the complement .
an example with @xmath98 a @xmath143 curve is shown in figure [ yessex ] . the argument that @xmath72 and @xmath73 must form a hopf link is the same as in the concentric subcase of case 1 above .
the core @xmath98 of the annulus @xmath97 is a @xmath140 cabling of the core of the solid torus @xmath131 .
we can foliate @xmath131 with meridianal disks each of which meets @xmath97 in an arc .
thus , @xmath97 is a deformation retraction of @xmath131 .
we then push @xmath97 into @xmath130 .
* case 3 : * suppose that both @xmath70 and @xmath98 are essential in @xmath106 . in figure [ landt ]
we give an example .
the loops @xmath70 and @xmath98 are meridians in @xmath106 .
they are also standard longitudes in @xmath107 .
the attractor @xmath72 is a trefoil knot while @xmath73 is unknotted and is a meridian of @xmath72 .
we claim that up to mirror images and flow reversal , this is the only possible configuration .
now consider the general setting .
the attaching map from @xmath95 to @xmath106 takes @xmath70 and @xmath98 to two copies of some @xmath21 cable knot of the attractor , @xmath72 .
here we allow @xmath13 or @xmath14 to be zero , but not both .
likewise , the attaching map from @xmath95 to @xmath107 takes @xmath101 and @xmath102 to some pair of @xmath144 knots . of course @xmath70 and @xmath98
are respectively ambient isotopic to @xmath101 and @xmath102 within @xmath95 , so all four have the same knot type . for future reference ,
let @xmath145 .
a knot @xmath1 with @xmath146 is a left or right handed trefoil .
see ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 15.37 , corollary 15.23 ) .
the alexander polynomials of the attractor and repeller are @xmath147 and @xmath148 , respectively if the linking matrix for @xmath72 is @xmath149,\ ] ] then the result follows by proposition [ prop_alex ] .
the only difficulty in determining the linking matrix is the assignment of the signs to the powers of the @xmath51 s .
one can check our assignment explicitly for the @xmath150 case by studying figure [ landt ] . in general ,
if the powers are all of the same sign , the polynomial that results is not symmetric in @xmath51 , nor is any @xmath94 multiple .
but it is well known that the alexander polynomial of a knot is symmetric in @xmath51 , up to multiples of @xmath94 .
that is @xmath151 see @xcite .
@xmath152 not ready : [ lem_11 ] the fundamental groups of @xmath153 and @xmath154 are @xmath155 and @xmath156 , respectively .
the alexander polynomials of @xmath72 and @xmath73 are @xmath157 and @xmath158 , respectively .
we shall find @xmath159 using the seifert / van kampen theorem .
the calculations of @xmath160 are similar .
the alexander polynomials can then be determined from fox s free differential calculus @xcite .
we must choose generators for @xmath87 , @xmath105 and @xmath161 .
the generators for @xmath161 and @xmath87 are shown in figure [ generators ] .
the base point @xmath162 is in the `` middle '' of the strip @xmath103 .
for @xmath87 we shall abuse notation slightly and call the generators @xmath70 and @xmath98 , as they are isotopic to the @xmath70 and @xmath98 loops , however , we do not use the orientation of the flow .
( by the proof of the previous lemma the images of @xmath70 and @xmath98 must wrap around @xmath107 in the same direction . )
denote the generators of @xmath161 by @xmath163 and @xmath164 .
for @xmath105 we shall use a loop isotopic to @xmath73 but with base point @xmath165 .
again we abuse notation and call this new loop @xmath73 .
the fundamental groups of interest are then @xmath166 @xmath167 and @xmath168 the homomorphisms induced by inclusion maps are @xmath169 and @xmath170 .
these give @xmath171 @xmath172 @xmath173 and @xmath174 .
by van kampen s theorem @xmath175 .
@xmath152 it follows from lemmas 10 and 11 that if @xmath70 is a @xmath21 curve on @xmath106 then @xmath101 is a @xmath176 curve on @xmath107 .
if @xmath13 or @xmath14 is zero then the other is @xmath9 since the curve is in a torus .
now suppose @xmath70 is a @xmath177 curve on @xmath106 .
then @xmath178 , and so @xmath72 is a trefoil knot . since @xmath70 is a meridian of @xmath72 and @xmath70 is isotopic to @xmath101 which in turn is isotopic to @xmath73 , we see that @xmath73 must be a meridian of @xmath72 .
if @xmath70 is a @xmath179 curve on @xmath106 then the rolls of @xmath72 and @xmath73 are switched .
it is left only to show that @xmath13 and @xmath14 can not both be nonzero .
it shall be useful to study the attaching of the exit set of @xmath87 to @xmath106 in terms of the boundary curves of the exit set .
they consist of three loops denoted as @xmath180 , @xmath181 and @xmath15 .
we take @xmath180 to be isotopic to @xmath70 and @xmath181 to be isotopic to @xmath98 .
then @xmath15 is the remaining curve .
see figure [ ktemp.eps ] .
our strategy is to show that if @xmath13 and @xmath14 are both nonzero then @xmath15 bounds a disk in @xmath106 and that @xmath15 is a nontrivial knot .
this contradiction will then prove our claim .
let @xmath182 be the closure of the exit set of @xmath87 .
clearly @xmath183 is torus . now @xmath180 and @xmath181 bound an annulus @xmath184 in @xmath185 .
thus , @xmath185 has two components , the annulus @xmath184 and another component we shall call @xmath186 which has a single boundary component @xmath15 . now , @xmath187 is a torus with a disk removed . since @xmath188 must be a torus , @xmath186 is a disk .
since this torus is embedded in @xmath0 it follows that @xmath15 , the boundary of @xmath186 , is unknotted .
the alexander polynomial calculations in lemma 11 show that @xmath72 is knotted , and thus even for the @xmath189 case @xmath180 and @xmath181 are nontrivial knots .
now since @xmath180 and @xmath181 are parallel knots in @xmath106 we can deform @xmath87 to appear as in figure [ ktemp.eps ] . by studying figure [ gamma ] we see that @xmath15 is a satellite of @xmath180 .
this implies @xmath15 is nontrivial and completes the proof of theorem 9 .
@xmath152 in any lorenz - smale flow there is a pair of unlinked saddle orbits . in the lorenz template there are two fixed points in the first return map of the branch line .
these correspond to a pair of unlinked unknots in the semi - flow if the lorenz template is standardly embedded . in all of the embeddings allowed for in theorem [ thm_ls ] these two orbits remain unlinked .
thus , by the birman - williams template theorem @xcite , the saddle set also contains a pair of unlinked orbits .
@xmath152 consider a smale flow on @xmath0 with an attracting fixed point , a repelling fixed point , a lorenz saddle set and no other basic sets .
there is only one possible configuration , and in it the template of the saddle set is a standardly embedded lorenz template . the proof is similar to case 1 above .
wada s classification theorem for morse - smale flows is based on applying a series of _ moves _ to one or two existing morse - smale flows and building up new ones .
conclusion ( a ) of the next theorem establishes an operation that produces a new smale flow from two existing ones that is similar to wada s move iv @xcite .
[ thm_sums ] let @xmath190 and @xmath191 be nonsingular smale flows on @xmath0 such that ( 1 ) they each have only one attracting closed orbit with knot types @xmath5 and @xmath6 respectively , ( 2 ) there is only one repelling closed orbit which is unknotted and is a meridian of the attractor and , ( 3 ) the repellers bound disks whose interiors meet the chain - recurrent sets in a single point .
then ( a ) and ( b ) below hold true .
\(a ) there exists a nonsingular smale flow on @xmath0 such that there is only one attracting closed orbit which has knot type @xmath192 , and there is only one repelling closed orbit which is unknotted and is a meridian of the attractor .
\(b ) there exists a nonsingular smale flow on @xmath0 such that there is only one attracting closed orbit which has knot type @xmath5 , and there is only one repelling closed orbit which has knot type @xmath6 .
furthermore , the attractor and the repeller have linking number one , and can be placed into solid tori whose cores are meridians of the each other .
the proofs are simple cut and paste arguments .
some details are left to the reader . for ( a )
let @xmath193 , @xmath194 , be tubular neighborhoods of the repellers in @xmath195 , @xmath194 , respectively .
let @xmath196 , @xmath194 , be the disks described in hypotheses ( 3 ) .
thicken up these disks a bit by taking cross product with a small interval @xmath197 $ ] .
we require that each @xmath198 meet the corresponding @xmath199 in an unknotted arc .
let @xmath200 .
choose the signs so that flows enter the thickened disks on the positive sides .
see figure [ fig_cut ] .
delete from the 3-sphere of each flow the interior of the union of @xmath193 and @xmath198 , for the corresponding @xmath194 .
we now have flows on two cylinders @xmath201 , @xmath194 .
see figure [ fig_paste ] .
the boundary of @xmath201 is the union of @xmath202 , @xmath203 , and the annulus @xmath204 .
the flow exits @xmath201 on the interior of @xmath202 , for @xmath194 .
glue @xmath205 to @xmath206 by identifying @xmath207 with @xmath208 and @xmath209 with @xmath210 .
this creates a solid torus , @xmath211 .
the flow induced on @xmath211 is inward on @xmath212 .
further , the identifications can be chosen so that the flow on @xmath211 has an attracting orbit with knot type @xmath192 , assuming @xmath211 is standardly embedded .
it is now clear how to construct the desired flow on @xmath0 .
the proof of conclusion ( b ) is similar and in fact simpler and so is left as an exercise .
note that hypotheses ( 3 ) is not required .
the class of links which can arise in morse - smale flows ( nonsingular on @xmath0 ) is , according to wada s theorem , quite limited . for
smale flows it is easy to construct examples in which every knot and link can be realized simultaneously as a saddle orbits .
this is a consequence of the existence of _ universal templates _ , templates in which all links all realized as closed orbits , @xcite ; also see @xcite and @xcite .
franks has shown that any link can be realized as an attractor of a smale flow ( * ? ? ?
* propsition 6.1 ) . in the proof
the link is realized as a braid in an unknotted solid torus whose entrance set is its entire boundary .
thus given a smale flow with attractor @xmath1 we can replace @xmath1 with any generalized cable of @xmath1 , though a new saddle set will typically be introduced .
in @xcite it is shown that given a smale flow @xmath213 with a saddle set modeled by a template @xmath26 containing the closed orbit @xmath1 , there exists another smale flow @xmath214 with the same basic sets as @xmath213 except that @xmath1 is an attractor and and the template @xmath26 has been replaced ( as a model ) with @xmath215 , a template formed by `` surgering '' @xmath26 along @xmath1 ( a standard template operation ) . turning our attention to simple
smale flows we shall use a similar idea to show that given any knot @xmath1 there exists a simple smale flow with attractor @xmath1 and repeller a meridian of @xmath1 . as a corollary of the construction we can give a `` dynamics '' proof that alexander polynomials multiply under connected sums .
the template @xmath216 shown in figure [ univ.eps](a ) is known to contain all knots as periodic orbits @xcite .
thus we can suppose @xmath1 has been realized as an orbit in @xmath216 .
we shall work with a variation of @xmath216 shown in figure [ univ.eps](b ) and denoted @xmath211 .
it has five `` lorenz ears '' .
notice however that the middle ear does not stretch all the way across ; it is to extend only as far as an outer most arc of @xmath1 .
( technically @xmath211 is not a template , but it is still a branched manifold with a semi - flow ) .
now consider the rather odd looking object in figure [ anyk.eps ] .
the dark gray circle represents the tubular neighborhood of a repeller .
the the light gray tube has the same knot type as @xmath1 ( though only a portion of it is shown ) ; we have only added an extra loop in an outermost strand of @xmath1 .
the dark region is a topological ball which meets the light gray tube at a single disk near the cusp of the fourth lorenz ear .
their union is a solid torus @xmath65 .
the branched manifold @xmath211 has been cut open along @xmath1 and is now a true template @xmath26 ( compare with the proof of theorem a.3.3 in @xcite ) .
the boundary of @xmath26 is in the boundary of @xmath65 .
we thicken up @xmath26 to get @xmath217 .
now we can regard @xmath217 as a neighborhood of a saddle set .
its exit set is attached to @xmath65 as required . from the figure
we can see that @xmath218 is a solid unknotted torus .
thus , we can use a meridian of @xmath1 as a repeller and build up the desired flow .
@xmath152 the claim is that given knots @xmath5 and @xmath6 then @xmath219 . by theorem [ thm_anyk ] there
exist smale flows for @xmath5 and @xmath6 that satisfy the hypotheses of theorem [ thm_sums ] .
we use conclusion ( a ) of theorem [ thm_sums ] to construct a smale flow with attractor @xmath192 and apply ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 4.1 ) noting that there are only two saddle sets and hence only two linking matrices needed in the formula given in ( * ? ? ? * theorem 4.1 ) .
@xmath152 we have in these last two sections given a variety of tools for building new smale flows from old ones .
many other such results could be stated .
but , we are nowhere close to developing a calculus of smale flows along the lines of what wada has done for morse - smale flows .
indeed we do nt even know if there are any restrictions on the link type of @xmath110 for simple smale flows . | a smale flow is a structurally stable flow with one dimensional invariant sets .
we use information from homology and _ template _ theory to construct , visualize and in some cases , classify , nonsingular smale flows in the 3-sphere .
flows , knots , smale flows , templates . _
ams subject classification ( 1991 ) : _
58f25 , 57m25 . |
based on a canonical quantization approach , the loop quantum gravity program gives a picture of the quantum geometry of space in terms of spin networks .
dynamic enters the theory only through the hamiltonian constraint which is still poorly understood .
spin foam models @xcite are alternative way to give dynamic to spin networks and are candidates for the construction of a quantum theory of gravity in a covariant framework .
spin foam models are attempts to evaluate transition amplitude between spin network states .
therefore it extends the structure of spin networks , which are one dimensional complexes , to two - complexes built from vertices , edges ( colored by intertwining operators ) and faces ( colored by certain type of group representations ) .
a spin foam model would ultimately describe the quantum geometry of space - time and any slice of it would be a spin network describing the space structure at a given time .
it is a major property of four dimensional pure gravity that it is a constrained topological field theory : it can be expressed as a @xmath0 theory with @xmath1 ( resp .
@xmath2 ) group for the euclidean ( resp .
lorentzian ) signature , where the @xmath3 field is constrained to be `` simple '' and more particularly to be of the type @xmath4 this property has given hope to construct spin foam models of quantum gravity by constraining spin foam models describing @xmath0 theory .
indeed topological field theory of bf type can be exactly discretized with spin foam models .
this is , in three dimensions , the result of the work of ponzano - regge @xcite and in 4 dimensions the work of ooguri @xcite .
however without cosmological constant these models have infrared divergences .
in the euclidean signature case these previous spin foam models can be regularized by the addition of a cosmological term and one obtains , in three dimensions , the turaev - viro model @xcite and in four dimensions the crane - yetter model @xcite .
these spin foam models are built using representation theory of certain quantum groups .
the barrett - crane model @xcite is a spin foam model which aim is to implement , in the ooguri model , the constraint of simplicity on @xmath3 .
this can be done very easily in the euclidean case by restricting representations on the faces to be `` simple '' and by coloring the edges with a very peculiar intertwiner , known in the litterature as the barrett - crane intertwiner . soon after this proposal these authors gave a similar proposal @xcite in the lorentzian case .
these models , which gave an impetus for a large amount of work on spin foam models of constrained @xmath0 theory , have several drawbacks : \1 ) the weight of the vertices is well defined ( a 10j symbol ) but the weights on the edges and faces are not fixed and are still a matter of debate @xcite .
this issue is very important for proving the finiteness of the amplitude after integrating over the area variables for a fixed 2-complex @xcite .
\2 ) a meaning to the sum over 2-complexes has to be done in order to compute an amplitude , and up to now , there is no result on this important issue in the 4 dimensional case .
note however the recent work of @xcite in the case of three dimensional riemmannian quantum gravity .
\3 ) the simplicity constraint does not imply that the @xmath3 field is in the gravitational sector , and the relative weight of the gravitational sector compared to the other seems to be small @xcite .
our work aims at defining and studying the barrett - crane model in the case of the quantum lorentz group @xmath5 for @xmath6 real .
this is possibly interesting for different reasons .
the first one is that one would like to obtain spin foam models for describing quantum gravity with a positive cosmological constant .
this is important for the study of quantum gravity in de sitter space @xcite .
the second one is that the use of quantum groups enhance convergence , particularly in the infrared . in @xcite three spin foam models
are analyzed in the riemannian case .
they differ only by the choice of the weight on the edges and on the faces .
we will show that for any @xmath7- complex dual to a triangulation of the manifold , the integration over the coloring ( i.e area variables ) are finite for the quantum deformations of these three models .
the third one is that , if the sum over 2-complexes can be defined , it is only in the presence of a cosmological constant .
our work is divided in four sections . in section
ii we recall elementary facts on spin foam models . in section iii
we give a construction of the quantum hyperboloid and of the quantum lorentzian barrett - crane intertwiner .
section iv is devoted to the study of quantum simple lorentzian spin networks .
section v is an analysis of the cosmological deformation of the lorentzian barrett - crane model .
we will prove the infrared finiteness property in this section .
a large class of topological quantum field theories can be exactly discretized by spin foam models . for a review on this subject , see @xcite .
this class of theories includes @xmath0 theory in any dimension and @xmath0 theory with cosmological constant in three and four dimensions .
the barrett - crane model is a spin foam model which is advocated to be a discretization of the quantization of plebanski theory in four dimensions .
the euclidean version has been defined in @xcite and the lorentzian one was studied in @xcite . in this last paper ,
the authors have also mentioned the idea to extend their model to the quantum deformation of the lorentz group as a possible regularization .
after an overview of spin foam models ( lorentzian and euclidean ) in 3 and 4 dimensions , we recall the links between quantum spin foam models and @xmath0 theory with cosmological constant .
we then explore the relations between quantum deformation of lorentzian barrett - crane model and quantum gravity in the presence of a cosmological constant . in the sequel we will consider a riemannian ( resp .
lorentzian ) manifold .
we will denote @xmath8 the sign of the metric .
we will denote @xmath9 and @xmath10 the isometry group of @xmath11 the einstein - hilbert action on a @xmath12 dimensional oriented riemannian ( resp.lorentzian ) manifold with cosmological constant @xmath13 is defined by @xmath14= \frac{1}{g } \int_{m } d^d x \ ; \ ; ( { r}[g]-2 \lambda ) \sqrt{\vert g\vert}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] let us introduce an orthonormal triad @xmath15 and a @xmath16 connection @xmath17 .
the metric can be expressed in term of the cotriad @xmath18 as @xmath19 and the action ( [ actionofgravity ] ) is rewritten as the palatini action @xmath20 = \frac{1}{g } \int _ { m } d^d x \ ; \vert e \vert \ ; ( r_{\mu \nu}^{ij}[\omega]\ ; e_i^{\mu } \ ; e_j^{\nu}-2\lambda)\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath21 .
this action can be conveniently written in term of forms , as : @xmath22=\frac{1}{g } \int _ { m } ( r^{ij}[\omega]\wedge { \star } ( e_i\wedge e_j)-2\lambda { \star } 1)\ ] ] where the @xmath23 is the hodge operator . from the orthonormality of @xmath24
, we have : @xmath25 where @xmath26 is the sign of @xmath27 the palatini action can be recast , in any dimension as : @xmath22=\frac{1}{(d-2)!g } \int _ { m } s(e ) \epsilon_{i_1\cdots i_{d}}(r^{i_1i_2}\wedge e^{i_3}\wedge\cdots\wedge e^{i_d } - \frac{2\lambda}{d(d-1 ) } e^{i_1}\wedge\cdots\wedge e^{i_d}).\ ] ] the very first spin foam model was introduced by ponzano and regge @xcite as an attempt to define a discrete version of three dimensional riemannian quantum gravity .
the modern understanding of this construction follows the next lines of arguments .
the action of @xmath0 theory in @xmath28 dimension for the @xmath10 group is given by : @xmath29 as a result in the case where @xmath30 this is exactly the action of palatini .
the partition function of @xmath0 theory is @xmath31 \right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the action , being linear in the @xmath18 , we can integrate over the @xmath18 and we get : @xmath32(x)).\end{aligned}\ ] ] this partition function is therefore the `` volume '' of the space of flat connections on @xmath33 it can be exactly computed by the following discretization in the riemannian case .
we choose any triangulation @xmath34 of the manifold : to each edge @xmath35 we associate an irreducible representation @xmath36 of @xmath37 .
the ponzano - regge partition function is then given by @xmath38 where the sum runs over all irreducible representations of @xmath37 .
we have assigned the weight @xmath39 to each edge @xmath35 and the weight @xmath40 to each tetrahedron @xmath41 colored with the six representations labelling the edges of @xmath41 .
note that the @xmath42 we are using in this expression is invariant under the group of symmetry of the tetrahedron .
the length of the edge @xmath35 in natural units is @xmath43 , where @xmath44 is the planck length .
a simple explanation of this assertion comes from the classical limit of ponzano - regge sum : we let @xmath45 tends to zero while letting @xmath46 fixed to a classical length @xmath47 .
thus the weight of a tetrahedron @xmath41 behaves as @xcite : @xmath48 } } \cos(\frac{s_r[t]}{\hbar}+\frac{\pi}{4})\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath49 $ ] the volume of the tetrahedron and the regge action @xcite , given by @xmath50=\frac{1}{g}\sum_{\epsilon\in t}\theta_\epsilon \ ; l(\epsilon ) \ ; , \end{aligned}\ ] ] is a discretization , for @xmath51 , of ( [ actionofgravity ] ) .
the partition function ( [ prsum ] ) can also be expressed as a sum over spin foams lying in the dual 2-skeleton of the given triangulation : in this way , the ponzano - regge model appears to be a spin foam model .
note that the sum can be shown to be triangulation independent ( because of the biedenharn - elliot relation ) and thus it defines a topological invariant of the manifold @xmath52 .
the ponzano - regge sum , as well as the partition function of @xmath0 theory , differs from the partition function of @xmath28 dimensional gravity .
indeed the weight of a configuration of @xmath53 with @xmath54 differs from a weight of @xmath53 with @xmath55 in @xmath0 theory whereas it is the same in the action of gravity .
this problem is too much understated in the literature but is well addressed in @xcite .
the comparison between the two theories is still not very well understood .
the ponzano - regge sum suffers from an infrared divergence , i.e when the variables @xmath36 become large .
several possible regularization have been introduced , among them the turaev - viro one is the most natural and effective .
it consists in replacing the classical lie algebra @xmath56 by the corresponding quantum group @xmath57 where @xmath6 is the root of unity @xmath58 .
the edges are now labelled by irreducible representations of @xmath57 and the sum becomes : @xmath59 where @xmath60 is the quantum dimension of the representation @xmath36 , and @xmath61 , where @xmath62 is the quantum @xmath42 symbol associated to the tetrahedron @xmath41 , @xmath63 is the number of vertices of @xmath34 and @xmath64 .
note that the number of irreducible representations of @xmath57 with non vanishing q - dimension is finite when @xmath6 is a root of unity , therefore the sum ( [ sumtv ] ) is a finite sum .
the turaev - viro model is an exact discretization of @xmath0 quantum theory with a cosmological term , whose action is : @xmath65= \frac{1}{g } \int _ { m } \epsilon_{ijk } \ ; ( r^{ij}[\omega]-\frac{\lambda}{3 } e^i\wedge
e^j ) \ \ ; \wedge \ ; e^k.\end{aligned}\ ] ] when @xmath66 , this action is the same as the euclidean einstein - hilbert action with cosmological constant @xmath67 and the level @xmath68 is related to the cosmological constant by @xmath69 where @xmath70 is the cosmological length .
note that the partition function @xmath71 is unchanged when one turns @xmath6 into @xmath72 because of the invariance of the quantum dimension and the quantum @xmath42-symbol in this transformation .
this property corresponds in the @xmath0 theory to the invariance of the partition function @xmath73 when one tuns @xmath24 into @xmath74 and conjugate @xmath75 into @xmath76 .
there are , up to our knowledge , different ways to understand that the turaev - viro sum is related to @xmath0 theory with cosmological term and that quantum groups necessarily appear in the quantization process .
the first one , well exposed for example in @xcite uses the equivalence , due to witten @xcite , between @xmath0 theory with positive cosmological term and chern - simons theory with group @xmath77 in order to show that the turaev - viro sum is the partition function of @xmath0 theory with positive cosmological term one needs an additional result , shown by mathematicians , which is that the turaev - viro sum of a manifold @xmath52 is the modulus square of reshetikhin - turaev invariant of @xmath52 for the group @xmath78 the equality between reshetikhin - turaev invariant of @xmath52 and the partition function of chern - simons of m implies therefore the equality between the turaev - viro sum and the partition function of bf with cosmological constant as well as the relation between @xmath6 and @xmath79 an alternative way consists in studying the asymptotic behavior of the quantum @xmath42-symbol in the regime where @xmath80
this regime corresponds to the classical limit with a finite cosmological constant : physically , the length are bounded by @xmath81 because of the presence of a cosmological horizon .
the asymptotic value of the quantum @xmath62 has been well understood in @xcite where , after reintroducing the natural units , the authors obtain : @xmath82 } } \cos(\frac{s_{r,\lambda}[t]}{\hbar}+\frac{\pi}{4}),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath49 $ ] is the volume of the tetrahedron and the regge action in presence of a cosmological constant is @xmath83=\frac{1}{g}\left(\sum_{\epsilon\in t}\theta_\epsilon \ ;
l(\epsilon ) \ ; - \frac{1}{l_c^2 } v[t]\right)\;\;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] these two previous arguments are rather indirect . a very clear understanding of the appearance of quantum groups in the quantization of @xmath0 theory with cosmological term is obtained using the combinatorial quantization of chern - simons theory as first understood in @xcite
there are recent attempts to formally define 3-dimensional lorentzian spin foam models , with possible applications to 2 + 1 quantum gravity .
an analogue of the ponzano - regge sum can be straightforwardly defined .
one begins with the partition function of @xmath0 theory with @xmath84 group and applies the same method of integrating the @xmath53 field and replacing the delta function by its decomposition into characters of unitary representations of @xmath84 .
one is therefore led to define a ponzano - regge model where the representations coloring the edges belong to the principal series and to the discrete series .
the weight of the tetrahedron is given as the @xmath42 of these representations @xcite .
this subject is still in its infancy , and important properties such as the study of particular regularization of this @xmath84 ponzano - regge sum and the proof of the asymptotic behaviour of the @xmath42 symbols are still unknown .
it is expected that quantization of @xmath85 @xmath0 action with positive cosmological term is described by a turaev - viro model associated to @xmath86 for q real with @xmath87 due to the equality between the @xmath0 action with positive cosmological term and the chern - simons action associated to the lie algebra @xmath88 , there should exist a relation between the would be turaev - viro sum with @xmath86 and the would be reshetikhin - turaev invariants for the quantum algebra @xmath89 to be defined , these invariants , as well as the expectation value of observables , need regularization and up to now the litterature is empty on this subject .
note however our work @xcite , where we quantize chern - simons theory with @xmath2 group using the program of combinatorial quantization of hamiltonian chern - simons theory .
the action of @xmath0 theory in @xmath90 dimensions in the case of a simple compact lie group @xmath91 is @xmath92 = \int_m tr\left ( b \wedge f(a)\right)\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the field @xmath93 is a @xmath94-valued two - form , @xmath95 is the curvature associated to the @xmath94-connection @xmath96 and @xmath97 denotes the killing form on the lie algebra .
this defines a topological theory which has been first studied in @xcite . in the case of @xmath98 , which is the case that we consider in this section ,
ooguri @xcite was the first to provide an exact discretization of @xmath0 theory in 4 dimensions through the construction of a spin foam model .
let @xmath52 be a four dimensional oriented compact smooth manifold .
let @xmath34 be any triangulation of this manifold and @xmath99 the set of @xmath100 simplices of @xmath34 .
let @xmath101 be the set of irreducible representations of @xmath91 .
if @xmath102 , we denote @xmath103 the vector space on which the representation @xmath104 acts . to each face @xmath105 of @xmath34
we associate an element @xmath106 of @xmath107 to each tetrahedron @xmath41 we define @xmath108 , to be the space of @xmath109intertwiners @xmath110 @xmath108 is endowed with the hermitian form @xmath111 in the @xmath37 case an orthonormal basis of @xmath108 is labelled by elements of @xmath101 as well . to each tetrahedron
we associate an element @xmath112 of this orthonormal basis or equivalently an element @xmath113 the ooguri partition function is defined as : @xmath114 where the so - called @xmath115-symbol @xmath116 associated to each 4-simplex @xmath117 of the triangulation is constructed from the 10 representations labelling its 10 faces and the 5 representations labelling its 5 tetrahedra ( figure [ 15jsymbol1 ] ) . -symbol . ] for the same reason as for the ponzano - regge model , the sum ( [ osum ] ) is in general divergent .
the crane - yetter model @xcite is a regularization of ( [ osum ] ) .
it is the 4-dimensional analogue of the regularization of turaev - viro of the ponzano - regge sum and it is an exact discretization of @xmath0 theory with cosmological term whose action is : @xmath118 the regularization consists in replacing the classical lie group by the quantum group @xmath57 where @xmath6 is taken to be a root of unity .
however , because it is impossible to have a projection of the 4-simplex on a plane without having at least two edges which intersect , it is important to be careful on the definition of the @xmath115 symbol and to correctly take account of the crossing .. this issue does not appear in the turaev - viro construction .
the crane - yetter construction was generalized to the framework of 2-spherical categories in @xcite
. we will refer to this work and use its notations because the construction is cristal - clear there .
we take the quantum algebra @xmath57 for @xmath6 root of unit .
we pick any total order on the set of vertices of the triangulation @xmath34 .
this order induces , by lexicography , a total order on the set of faces , on the set of tetrahedra and on the set of 4-simplices . to each face
@xmath119 we associate a representation of @xmath57 and we denote by @xmath120 its associated vector space .
let @xmath117 be a @xmath90-simplex of @xmath34 , @xmath121 @xmath122 to each tetrahedron , appearing with positive sign in @xmath123 , for example @xmath124 , we associate the space @xmath125 of intertwiners @xmath126 @xmath127 to each tetrahedron appearing with negative sign in @xmath123 , for example @xmath128 , we associate the space @xmath129 of intertwiners @xmath130 @xmath131 we define the partition function of the 4-simplex @xmath132 defined by the graph shown in picture ( [ 15jsymbol2 ] ) . where @xmath133 is a family of intertwiners . ]
note that the definition of @xmath134 crucially depends on the ordering of the vertices .
however , the sum @xmath135 does not depend on the chosen ordering nor on @xmath34 .
it is therefore a topological invariant of the manifold .
this invariant can be expressed solely in term of the signature and the euler characteristic of the manifold @xcite .
furthermore , @xmath136 is the partition function of four dimensional @xmath0 theory with cosmological term whose action is : @xmath137 the cosmological constant @xmath13 is related to the quantum parameter @xmath6 by : @xmath138 where @xmath139 is the four dimensional planck length .
this relation is derived in @xcite for example .
pure gravity in @xmath90 dimensions is a constrained @xmath0 theory and the plebanski lagrangian is precisely designed to implement the contraint through the use of a lagrange multiplier @xcite .
the einstein - hilbert action is written as : @xmath20 = \frac{1}{g } \int _ { m } d^4 x \ ; \vert e \vert \ ; ( r_{\mu \nu}^{ij}[\omega]\ ; e_i^{\mu } \ ; e_j^{\nu}-2\lambda)\end{aligned}\ ] ] also written as : @xmath20 = \frac{1}{g } \int _ { m } d^4 x \epsilon_{ijkl } ( r_{ij}\wedge e^k\wedge e^l-\frac { 2\lambda}{4!}e^i\wedge e^j\wedge e^k \wedge e^l ) s(e)\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath140 is the curvature of the connection @xmath141 and @xmath142 is a basis of @xmath143 when @xmath144 this is exactly the form of a so(4 ) @xmath0 theory with cosmological constant , with @xmath145 and @xmath146 when @xmath3 is of this form it is said to belong to the gravitational sector .
note , as usual , the sign @xmath147 whose possible effect in the quantum theory is still not understood .
let us add some comments to clarify , for non experts , the condition of simplicity . if @xmath41 is an infinitesimal triangle , i.e
@xmath148 with @xmath149 in the tangent space of a point @xmath150 in @xmath151 we can define @xmath152 the simplicity condition reads as : @xmath153 which simply means that que quadratic form @xmath154 in @xmath155 and @xmath156 vanishes .
the condition of simplicity therefore is equivalent to : @xmath157}=0,\ ] ] which , when written explicitely in components , is exactly the three conditions : simplicity , intersection and normalisation of @xcite .
note , of course , that this condition has nothing to do with the condition @xmath158 where the wedge means exterior product simultaneously on forms and on the elements of the lie algebra @xmath159 , which reads in components @xmath160}^{kl]}=0 , \;\;\text{i.e}\;\ ; \epsilon^{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}\epsilon_{ijkl } b_{\mu\nu}^{ij } b_{\rho\sigma}^{kl}=0.\ ] ] when the @xmath3 field satisfies the condition that @xmath161 is nowhere equal to zero , @xmath3 is said to be non degenerate .
it can be shown that the condition of simplicity on @xmath3 and the condition that @xmath3 is non degenerate imply that there exists a cotetrad @xmath18 such that @xmath162 the gravitational sector is the sector @xmath163 the plebanski lagrangian is designed to enforce the condition of simplicity on @xmath3 .
the @xmath10 plebanski action is written as : @xmath164= \frac{1}{g } \int_{m } d^4 x ( f_{ij}(\omega)\wedge b^{ij}- \frac{\lambda}{4}\epsilon_{ijkl } b^{ij}\wedge b^{kl } -\frac{1}{2}\phi_{ijkl } b^{ij}\wedge b^{kl}),\ ] ] where @xmath165[kl]}$ ] is symmetric under the exchange of @xmath166 $ ] with @xmath167 $ ] and satisfies the constraint @xmath168 an analysis of this theory has been done in @xcite .
let us pinpoint the results : integration on @xmath169 imposes the constraint that there exists a @xmath90-form @xmath170 such that @xmath171 in term of components this is equivalent to @xmath172}= \tilde{\lambda}\epsilon_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}\epsilon^{ijkl}.\label{simple1}\ ] ] when @xmath3 is non degenerate this condition is also equivalent to @xmath173}_{\rho\sigma}= \tilde{\lambda}\epsilon_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}\epsilon^{ijkl}.\label{simple2}\ ] ] any of these conditions are equivalent to the condition of simplicity . as a result , integrating out
the lagrange multiplier @xmath174 enforces @xmath3 to be simple .
if one can design a method for restricting even more the @xmath3 field to the subsector @xmath175 one would therefore describe a quantization of the gravitational sector with a cosmological constant @xmath13 . at the present time we are far from being able to implement and control this restriction .
the barrett - crane model is a spinfoam model where the constraint of simplicity is imposed by a lattice analog of constraint ( [ simple2 ] ) : representations are balanced and the edges are colored by a simple intertwiner , the so - called barrett - crane intertwiner . the basic idea is to find a way to implement the constraints ( [ simple2 ] ) directly in the ooguri model associated to the group @xmath10 .
the euclidean barrett - crane model is based on simple geometric observations .
it consists in describing each @xmath90-simplex of the triangulation @xmath34 in term of a set of @xmath176 simple bivectors @xmath177 associated to its faces @xmath105 .
these bivectors satisfy a set of geometrical properties , given in @xcite . among them , the simplicity condition , i.e. @xmath178 , for all bivectors @xmath179 , is a discretization of the algebraic conditions ( [ simple2 ] ) .
barrett and crane have postulated that these conditions should be imposed at the quantum level @xcite as follows . in the euclidean case ,
they first write @xmath180 and label its irreducible representations by couple of non negative half - integers @xmath181 we can decompose this representation with respect to the diagonal subgroup @xmath37 and we denote @xmath182 and @xmath183 the barrett - crane euclidean spin foam model is defined through the following rules : 1 .
faces are labelled with finite dimensional irreducible representations , edges are labelled by intertwiner operators .
the representations coloring the faces of the triangulation are simple .
simple representations are of the type @xmath184 , i.e. @xmath185 , which is equivalent to the fact that @xmath186 or equivalently that these representations have a non zero vector invariant under the action of the diagonal @xmath78 we denote by @xmath187 the set of simple representations .
the area of a face @xmath105 colored by @xmath188 is then given by @xmath189 .
3 . the intertwiners coloring the tetrahedron of the triangulation is unique and called euclidean barrett - crane intertwiner .
this intertwiner is a 4-valent intertwiner between the simple representations coloring the faces of the tetrahedron and the trivial represenetation .
its expansion into 3-valent intertwiners introduces only simple representations in the intermediate channel .
up to a normalization , such an intertwiner is uniquely defined @xcite .
the weight associated to each 4-simplex is constructed from the @xmath176 simple representations coloring its faces and from the 5 barrett - crane intertwiners labelling its boundary tetrahedra .
we obtain the so - called @xmath190-symbol ( see figure [ 15jsymbol1 ] ) with @xmath191 fixed to the barrett - crane intertwiner .
finally , the euclidean barrett - crane partition function is defined by : @xmath192 where @xmath193 is the value of the @xmath190 symbol of the colored simplex @xmath194 there is still some confusion about the value of the weights @xmath195 an empirical idea , pursued by @xcite , is to obtain a good balance between all the weights , in such a way that the expectation values of observables do not give trivial results ( zero value ) or do not explode to infinity .
the work @xcite give a discussion of this important point and propose weights for @xmath196 on a basis of monte - carlo simulations .
the goal of the work @xcite is to find in the discretized @xmath0 theory the configurations satisfying the constraint of being simple .
the final conclusion is that the configurations of representations and intertwiners which are selected are precisely the one of the barrett - crane model .
the method , unfortunately , can not fix the weights @xmath195 the lorentzian barrett - crane model @xcite is constructed along the same lines , considering instead of @xmath197 the lorentzian group @xmath2 or its universal covering @xmath198 .
there are two types of models : the first one includes only spacelike faces and the second one includes timelike faces as well .
these models have both been introduced in @xcite . a field theory on a group description has been given in @xcite .
we will only discuss the first model .
let us recall that principal irreducible representations of @xmath198 are labelled by a couple @xmath199 . the lorentzian model of barrett - crane
is defined using the same recipes as the euclidean one : the faces are colored by simple representations of type @xmath200 and the tetrahedra are colored by the lorentzian barrett - crane intertwiner . the area of a face @xmath105 is related to the corresponding representation by the formula @xmath201 the lorentzian barrett - crane intertwiner is defined as in the euclidean case : it is unique up to a normalization and can be computed @xcite using the haar measure on the classical group ( this procedure needs a regularization because of the non - compactness of the group ) .
the lorentzian barrett - crane partition function is given by ( [ bcsum ] ) where @xmath187 is now the set of simple representations of @xmath198 of type @xmath202 and the series is replaced by an integral over @xmath203 note that the existence of the @xmath190 symbol has been proven in @xcite .
the lorentzian barrett - crane model is conjectured to be an exact discretization of the plebanski action associated to the lorentz group .
the sum still suffers from an infrared divergence when @xmath204 goes to infinity .
this is why it is very important to add a cut - off on the @xmath204 which can be implemented by adding a cosmological constant and going to the quantization of the lorentz group .
this is the path that we will follow .
note however that , up to now , another method has been applied . in @xcite ,
the authors have defined a spin foam model of lorentzian gravity by choosing appropriate weights @xmath205 and @xmath206 .
this version of the lorentzian model has the marvelous property of being finite in the sense that for each triangulation , the integral over @xmath207 of the state sum is finite @xcite .
therefore , there is no need to impose a cut off on the @xmath204 .
however the work @xcite indicates that this model may well be trivial and that other choice of @xmath205 and @xmath206 are necessary and for them the finiteness seems to be more intricate let alone false . the aim of our work is to define a quantum deformation of the lorentzian barrett - crane model .
our goal is to introduce a natural cut - off , the cosmological constant , and show that the spin foam model , for a large class of choice of @xmath208 , has the property of being finite for each triangulation we will be concentrating on the case where the quantum parameter is real and related to the cosmological constant by : @xmath209 where the cosmological length @xmath81 is defined by @xmath210 though it is consistent with all the results of the litterature , it is still conjectural that lorentzian plebanski theory with positive cosmological constant can be described by this type of spin foam model with this regime of @xmath211 the computation of the asymptotic of the 4-simplex could be a useful tool to support this conjecture .
the quantum lorentzian spin foam model is then the barrett - crane model associated to the quantum group @xmath212 where @xmath6 is taken to be real .
the representation theory of this quantum group is well exposed in @xcite where a plancherel theorem was proved and the intertwiners between principal unitary representations have been computed in @xcite .
the main results will be recalled in the next section .
note that principal unitary representations of @xmath212 are labelled by a couple @xmath213 where @xmath68 is an integer and @xmath214 is a real bounded by @xmath215 .
these representations are the quantum analogue of principal representations of @xmath216 .
the quantum lorentzian model is thus obtained considering only the representations @xmath200 where @xmath214 is now bounded .
the area @xmath217 of a face colored by @xmath214 is given by ( [ aireface ] ) , and satisfies therefore the inequalities : @xmath218 in the regime where @xmath219 note that these inequalities are intuitively the expected ones : we can not define area less than the planck area and the maximal area of a space like surface is given by the area of the cosmological horizon . before studying the model we recall mathematical results on the quantum lorentz group and other related objects .
in this section , we introduce the fundamental tools needed to define a cosmological deformation of the lorentzian barrett - crane model . we acquaint the reader with the structure of the quantum lorentz algebra @xmath212 and its representations .
we then describe the structure of the three dimensional quantum hyperboloid @xmath220 which appears to be a pile of quantum fuzzy spheres .
we then define the cosmological deformation of the barrett - crane intertwiner as an integral on @xmath220 .
the construction of this intertwiner mimics the classical one @xcite .
the classical hyperboloid @xmath221 is the submanifold of the four dimensional minskowski space @xmath222 defined as @xmath223 where the metric is given by @xmath224 .
@xmath221 admits two connected components @xmath225 , diffeomorphic to @xmath226 , which are the two sheets @xmath227 and @xmath228 the orthochronous proper lorentz group @xmath229 acts transitively on @xmath230 and therefore @xmath230 is the orbit of any element @xmath231 as a result @xmath230 is the homogeneous space @xmath232 where @xmath233 is the isotropy group ( the small group ) of @xmath234 this group is @xmath235 this analysis extends directly to the universal covering group @xmath236 of @xmath229 , and we get : @xmath237 the natural measure on minkowski space induces a measure @xmath238 on the hyperboloid which is invariant under the action of the lorentz group .
the same analysis leads to @xmath239 the homogeneous space @xmath240 has also two other descriptions .
the first one is associated to the polar decomposition .
let @xmath241 the isomorphism between the four dimensional minkowski space @xmath222 and the space @xmath242 of @xmath243 hermitian matrices .
we denote by @xmath244 the subset of positive - definite hermitian matrices of determinant equal to @xmath245 this map identifies the hyperboloid and @xmath244 : @xmath246 the polar decomposition of the group @xmath198 says that : @xmath247 as a result the polar decomposition gives another understanding of the identification @xmath248 the identification is obtained using the map @xmath249 another decomposition of @xmath198 , the iwasawa decomposition will provide another description of the hyperboloid .
the iwasawa decomposition says : @xmath250 where @xmath96 is the group of diagonal positive matrices of determinant 1 and @xmath251 is the nilpotent group of lower trigonal matrices with diagonal elements equal to 1 .
the iwasawa decomposition implies that the hyperboloid can also be identified as : @xmath252 expressing the polar decomposition in term of the iwasawa one is straightforward and we get : @xmath253 where @xmath254 is a point on @xmath255 the action of the lorentz group on @xmath256 , is mapped to the natural right action of @xmath236 on the homogeneous space @xmath257 . using @xmath258 as a level function
, we obtain that @xmath230 is a cone over @xmath259 foliated by the spheres of equation @xmath260 note that the radius of the sphere containing the point @xmath261 is equal to @xmath262 these spheres are invariant under the right action of @xmath37 on @xmath263 the measure on the hyperboloid is identified to the measure on @xmath257 invariant under the right action of @xmath236 . as a result if we identify @xmath257 with @xmath264 , the haar measure on @xmath236 factorizes as @xmath265 where @xmath266 is the right invariant integral on @xmath264 .
the measure on the hyperboloid is therefore identified with @xmath266 .
we will now describe a construction of the quantum algebra @xmath267 and of its algebra of function @xmath268 this is obtained through the use of the quantum duality principle . after having completed this task , we introduce the notion of quantum hyperboloid . the quantum lorentz algebra @xmath212 and the algebra @xmath269 of functions on this quantum group is recalled briefly in the appendix a.1 .
the quantum lorentz algebra is the quantum double of @xmath57 .
this construction is in this case the quantum analog of the iwazawa decomposition of the lorentz algebra i.e. @xmath270 where @xmath271 is the real algebra of @xmath243 lower triangular complex matrices with real diagonal of zero trace .
a complete survey of this construction is exposed in @xcite .
we let @xmath272 and define @xmath273 , to be the hopf algebra generated by the elements @xmath274 , @xmath275 , and the relations : @xmath276 this algebra can be endowed with a structure of ribbon quasi - triangular hopf algebra .
we will only recall the structure of coproduct which reads : @xmath277 we will denote by @xmath278 or @xmath279 the @xmath278-matrix and by @xmath280 .
finite dimensional unitary irreducible representations @xmath281 of @xmath57 are labelled by a spin @xmath282 and let us define @xmath283 the vector space associated to the representation @xmath281 .
this representation is of dimension @xmath284 and we denote by @xmath285 the orthonormal basis such that the action of the generators on this basis is given by the following expressions : @xmath286 where we have denoted as usual @xmath287_q=\frac{q^z - q^{-z}}{q - q^{-1}}.$ ] the quantum dimension of this representation is defined by @xmath288_q$ ] where @xmath289 we denote by @xmath290 the dual basis . through the use of the coproduct , representations can be tensorized .
for any unitary representations @xmath291 , we define the clebsch - gordan maps @xmath292 ( resp .
@xmath293 ) as intertwiners from @xmath294 to @xmath295 ( resp .
intertwiners from @xmath295 to @xmath296 . with a particular choice of normalisation ( see @xcite ) , these elements are unique and their matrix elements are the 3j coefficients of @xmath297 we will denote by @xmath298 the matrix elements of @xmath299 , i.e the linear forms on @xmath300 @xmath301 the algebra of quantum deformations of polynomial functions on @xmath37 is the hopf - algebra generated as a vector space by @xmath298 and denoted @xmath302 by a direct application of the definition , the algebra structure is given by : @xmath303 where we have denoted , as usual , @xmath304 , @xmath305 and @xmath306 .
the existence of the @xmath278 matrix implies the braiding relations : @xmath307 because the spin @xmath308 when tensored sufficiently many times contains any prescribed spin , @xmath309 can equivalently be viewed as the hopf algebra generated by the matrix elements of @xmath310 with the defining relation ( [ polsu2 ] ) and the additional relation @xmath311 explicit relations are recalled in the appendix of @xcite for example .
a very important notion in the theory of quantum groups is the principle of quantum duality
. we will only give the general idea of this principle , leaving aside delicate issues related to the topology of the spaces .
let @xmath312 a lie algebra .
if @xmath313 is a quantization , of hopf algebra type , of the enveloping algebra of @xmath312 , it endows a structure of lie algebra on the dual of the lie algebra @xmath314 .
it is obtained as follows : if @xmath315 , we denote @xmath316 we can define @xmath317 it can be shown that @xmath318 as a result the transpose map @xmath319 maps @xmath320 , is antilinear and satisfies jacobi identity because @xmath321 is coassociative .
the principle of `` quantum duality '' expresses the fact that : if @xmath312 is a lie algebra , such that @xmath313 is a quantization of @xmath322 , then @xmath314 admits a quantization , denoted , @xmath323 , and we have @xmath324 as hopf algebras .
a typical example is @xmath325 in this case a direct computation , using the structure of @xmath57 shows that @xmath326 therefore we can define , through the use of the quantum duality principle : @xmath327 note that such definition can only hold at the non - commutative level i.e when @xmath6 is non equal to @xmath245 indeed when @xmath328 , @xmath57 is cocommutative , therefore the dual @xmath329 is a commutative algebra , which prevents to be isomorphic to @xmath330 this principle can also be used at the level of function spaces . let @xmath91 be the lie group of lie algebra @xmath312 ,
let @xmath331 be the lie group of lie algebra @xmath332 we can define @xmath333 .
the quantum duality principle implies that we have @xmath334 as hopf algebras . as a result ,
in our case , @xmath98 , @xmath335 the quantum duality principle tells us that we can define @xmath336 we will now describe the space @xmath337 , which is a star - hopf algebra .
we will also show that it is very natural to define the quantum hyperboloid @xmath338 as being , as in the classical case , the hopf algebra @xmath339 .
we have already described the structure of hopf algebra of @xmath302 we can now define spaces of functions of different classes on @xmath264 .
the first one is the quantization of the compact supported functions on @xmath340 it is defined as : @xmath341 with the following ( `` multiplier'')-hopf algebra structure : @xmath342 which is the dual of the hopf algebra @xmath302 note that by definition an element @xmath343 in @xmath344 is such that only a finite number of @xmath345 are non zero . the coproduct maps @xmath344 into the larger space @xmath346 which is the reason why we have to work in the scheme of multiplier hopf algebras .
the quantum algebra of functions ( generally unbounded ) on @xmath264 is denoted @xmath347 and defined as @xmath348 it can be endowed with a structure of hopf algebra with the same formulas for the product , the coproduct and the star as ( [ multfunc ] , [ coprodfunc ] , [ starfunc ] ) . it also possess a unit element defined by @xmath349 where @xmath350 is the identity matrix of @xmath351 .
the very definition of @xmath352 comes from the existence of a haar measure .
@xmath344 admits a right invariant integral @xmath353 defined as follows : @xmath354 which satisfies @xmath355 for any @xmath356 we define @xmath357 , the algebra of compact supported functions on the quantum hyperboloid , as being , as in the classical case , the algebra @xmath358 . therefore , as an algebra , it has the structure @xmath359 this description is the deformation of the foliation of @xmath360 by quantum fuzzy spheres .
quantum fuzzy spheres have been introduced and studied in @xcite .
the construction of the quantum hyperboloid that we are proposing has a scaled limit @xmath361 studied recently by @xcite .
we will see more on this topic in the sequel .
we shall now group together the quantization of @xmath56 and @xmath362 in order to obtain @xmath363 .
this is done through the construction of the quantum double exposed in the appendix a.1 .
let us now introduce the quantum algebra of functions on @xmath236 , good references on this subject being @xcite .
we define the space of compact supported functions on @xmath236 by @xmath364 as algebras .
the expression of the coproduct is written in @xcite .
there exists a haar measure @xmath365 on @xmath366 which expression is @xmath367 , where @xmath368 denotes the normalized haar measure on @xmath369 .
the functional @xmath365 is a right and left integral for @xmath370 the matrix elements of the 2-dimensional left spinorial representation of @xmath212 can be seen as quantum deformations of polynomial functions on @xmath371 we denote by @xmath91 this @xmath243 matrix of non commuting elements . in @xcite the iwasawa decomposition of this matrix has been done , and we have @xmath372 where @xmath373 is a @xmath243 matrix satisfying the defining relations of @xmath374 and @xmath375 is a lower triangular matrix of the form : @xmath376 with the relations : @xmath377 note that these relations , which can be seen as the defining relations of @xmath337 are also the defining relations of @xmath57 ( this is the quantum duality principle ) through the identification : @xmath378 therefore the element @xmath379 is represented in @xmath344 as being the elements @xmath380 with the analog representation for @xmath381 and @xmath382 it is explained in @xcite why the classical limit of the integral @xmath383 on @xmath344 is the continuous integral @xmath384 of particular importance for the understanding of this classical limit is the element @xmath385 note that the classical limit of this element is exactly @xmath386 where @xmath387 is the radius of the sphere . in the quantum case , @xmath388 is in the center of the algebra and therefore is represented by a scalar @xmath389 on each subspace of matrices @xmath351 .
its value is @xmath390 the value of the radius of the fuzzy sphere @xmath351 is therefore defined by @xmath391 and explicitely given by @xmath392[i+1].$ ] the quantum analog of the relation ( [ x0c ] ) is @xmath393 .
since @xmath388 is a casimir with positive eigenvalues , the time component @xmath394 is a central element , with discrete spectrum @xmath395 on each components of @xmath351 . the classical limit
, @xmath396 is recovered as follows .
a quantum fuzzy sphere indexed by @xmath282 recovers its classical limit when @xmath397 tends to a classical value @xmath398 in that case , this classical sphere is located at time @xmath399 the value @xmath400 is interpreted as the distance on the hyperboloid between any point on this classical sphere and the point located at @xmath401 let us now recall basic notions on the representation theory of the quantum lorentz group .
irreducible unitary representations of @xmath212 have been classified .
they include the principal series on which the plancherel measure is concentrated .
the representations of the principal series are labelled by a couple @xmath402 with @xmath403 with @xmath404-\frac{\pi}{\kappa } , \frac{\pi}{\kappa}[$ ] .
we denote @xmath405 the principal representation associated to @xmath406 acting on the vector space @xmath407 as explained in @xcite , @xmath405 is a harisch - chandra representation which decomposes in representations of @xmath57 as : @xmath408 a basis of @xmath409 is given by @xmath410 where , for @xmath282 fixed , @xmath411 is the basis of the @xmath57 module @xmath283 ( [ su2rep ] ) .
@xmath409 contains a @xmath57-invariant vector if and only if @xmath412 .
these representations are called simple representations .
if @xmath406 is simple , we will denote @xmath413 the @xmath57 invariant vector of unit length @xmath414 as a result the matrix element @xmath415 is a linear form on @xmath416 .
we will also use the notation @xmath417 .
@xmath418 is an element of @xmath419 .
because this function is invariant on the left by @xmath57 , the iwasawa decomposition implies that @xmath420 as a result @xmath421 defines a function on the quantum hyperboloid .
moreover this function is invariant under the right action of @xmath297 as a consequence it is diagonal : @xmath422 with @xmath423 we can compute exactly its expression .
this is done using the work @xcite and the necessary background is recalled in appendix a.1 : we have @xmath424 we finally obtain @xmath425}{[i\rho][2j+1]}1_j.\ ] ] note that @xmath421 satisfies @xmath426 it is an easy check to see that in the classical limit , i.e @xmath427 , @xmath428 the coefficient @xmath429 which is exactly the classical zonal function used in @xcite .
the barrett - crane model is defined through the use of a particular intertwiner , which is nowadays called barrett - crane intertwiner ( bc intertwiner ) .
its quantum deformation is easy to define and this is the purpose of what is coming next .
it will be very important in the sequel to generalize to the quantum deformation the following type of integrals .
if @xmath430 is a principal representation of @xmath431 we also denote @xmath430 the associated unitary representation of the group @xmath371 if @xmath432 is a smooth compact supported function on @xmath236 , the following bounded operator can be defined : @xmath433 these type of integrals have a direct generalization to the quantum group case although there is no more notion of point nor of the meaning of @xmath434 let @xmath430 be a principal representation of @xmath416 , we denote @xmath435 the basis of @xmath436 as defined in the appendix a.1 . @xmath437
the dual basis of @xmath438 is a basis of @xmath439 as a result we can define @xmath440 its exact expression in a basis being given in the appendix a.1 .
we have shown in @xcite ( eq .
93 ) that if @xmath441 is an element of @xmath442 the following operator is well defined and is moreover of finite rank and corank ( i.e it is a finite dimensional matrix ) : @xmath443 this operator is the quantum analog of @xmath444 more generally if @xmath445 is a family of principal representations of @xmath236 , integrals of the type @xmath446 often appear in the construction of interwiners .
they will be generalized as follows : @xmath447 we will have to extend these operators in the case where @xmath432 is the constant function @xmath448 .
in particular we will show that when @xmath449 , the operator @xmath450 is well defined .
note that this operator , in the case @xmath451 has already been studied in detail in @xcite .
the basic definition of the q - deformation of the lorentzian bc intertwiner is similar to the classical one .
the q - bc lorentzian intertwiner is a n - valent intertwiner between simple representations of the quantum lorentz group such that any expansion of it into 3-valent intertwiners introduces only simple representations in the intermediate channel .
q - bc lorentzian intertwiner .
let @xmath452 a sequence of simple representations of the quantum lorentz group
. we will denote @xmath453=\bigotimes\limits_{i=1}^{n } \stackrel{\alpha_i}{\mathbb v}$ ] and @xmath454= \bigotimes\limits_{i=1}^{n}\omega(\alpha_i).$ ] the quantum lorentzian intertwiner @xmath455:\mathbb{v}[\alpha ] \rightarrow { \mathbb c}$ ] is defined by : @xmath456 \ ; = < \omega[\alpha]\vert ( \bigotimes\limits_{i=1}^n\stackrel{\alpha_i}{\pi})(1).\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is represented by the left graph of caption ( [ intertwiner ] ) . from its formal definition , @xmath455 $ ] , if it exists , is an interwiner . we are therefore led to study the convergence property of the series defining @xmath455.$ ] we note first that , for @xmath457 $ ] , @xmath455(z)=h(f[\alpha](z))$ ] where @xmath458(z)$ ] is an element of @xmath347 because the vector @xmath454 $ ] is invariant by the right action of @xmath297 as a consequence , the q - bc lorentzian intertwiner is defined by an integral on the quantum hyperboloid whose convergence will be analyzed in the sequel . from the expression of the matrix element @xmath405 ( see the appendix a.1 ) , it is straigthforward to see that : @xmath459 as a result we obtain : let @xmath460 a family of simple representations , let @xmath461 a family of spins and @xmath462 the magnetic numbers .
we denote by @xmath463 = \bigotimes_{i=1}^n \stackrel{a_i}{e}_{a_i}\!\!(\alpha_i)$ ] and we have : @xmath464\;\vert \ ; \stackrel{a}{e}_{a}[\alpha ] > \ ; = \ ; \sum_m [ d_m ] \ ; c(m , a , a ) \ ; \prod_{i=1}^n \lambda_{0a_i}^{mm}(\alpha_i),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath465 the series ( [ sum ] ) converges when @xmath449 and in this case the q - bc lorentzian intertwiner ( [ qli ] ) is well defined .
+ the clebsch - gordan coefficients are bounded by one , as a result we get the bound : @xmath466(2m+1)^n.\ ] ] from the asymptotics computed in @xcite , we have the following bound when @xmath52 goes to infinity : @xmath467 as a consequence , @xmath468 \ ; c(m , a , a ) \ ; \prod_{p=1}^n \lambda_{0a_p}^{mm}(\alpha_p ) = { \cal o}(m^{2n } q^{2m(n-2)})$ ] which implies that the series ( [ sum ] ) converges absolutely when @xmath469 @xmath470 we will now prove that the four valent q - bc intertwiner satisfies the property that its expansion in three valent intertwiners only includes simple representations in the intermediate channel : [ decompositionoftheqbcintertwiner ] the four valent q - bc lorentzian intertwiner @xmath455 $ ] is decomposed in three valent @xmath212 intertwiners as follows : @xmath471 \ ; = \ ; \int d\beta p(\beta)\ ; f(\alpha,\beta ) \ ; \psi_{\beta,\beta}^{\;\;0 } ( \psi_{\alpha_1,\alpha_2}^{\;\;\beta } \otimes \psi_{\alpha_3,\alpha_4}^{\;\;\beta } ) \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the measure @xmath472 is the plancherel measure and the kernel @xmath473 has its support on the set of simple representations .
its explicit expression is given in the following proof .
+ the proof of the decomposition ( [ decomposition ] ) is a direct application of the relations ( [ orthogonalityrelation],[schurlemma ] ) given in the appendix .
indeed , one first applies the completeness relation ( [ orthogonalityrelation ] ) to the q - bc intertwiner : @xmath474 \ ; = \ ; < \omega[\alpha ] \vert \int d\beta d\gamma \ ; m(\alpha_1,\alpha_2,\beta ) m(\alpha_3,\alpha_4,\gamma ) \phi^{\alpha_1 \alpha_2}_{\;\ ; \beta } \otimes \phi^{\alpha_3 \alpha_4}_{\;\ ; \gamma } ( \stackrel{\beta}{\pi } \otimes \stackrel{\gamma}{\pi})(1 ) \psi^{\;\ ; \beta}_{\alpha_1 \alpha_2 } \otimes \psi^{\;\ ; \gamma}_{\alpha_3 \alpha_4}\;\;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the use of the orthogonality relation ( [ schurlemma ] ) implies : @xmath474 \ ; = \ ; < \omega[\alpha ] \vert \int d\beta \ ; \frac{1}{p(\beta)}m(\alpha_1,\alpha_2,\beta ) m(\alpha_3,\alpha_4,\beta ) \phi^{\alpha_1 \alpha_2}_{\;\ ; \beta } \otimes \phi^{\alpha_3 \alpha_4}_{\;\ ; \beta } \phi^{\beta,\beta}_{\;\;0 } \ ; \psi_{\beta,\beta}^{\;\;0 } \ ; \psi^{\;\ ; \beta}_{\alpha_1 \alpha_2 } \otimes \psi^{\;\ ; \beta}_{\alpha_3 \alpha_4}\;\;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] moreover the clebsh - gordan coefficient @xmath475 with @xmath476 is different from zero if and only if @xmath155 is a non zero @xmath57-invariant vector .
such a vector exists if @xmath477 is a simple representation and by definition the normalization of @xmath478 is chosen such that @xmath479 as a consequence , the q - bc intertwiner can be decomposed as ( [ decomposition ] ) where @xmath480 @xmath470 note that we have proven the property of decomposition of the q - bc lorentzian intertwiner in a particular channel .
it is straightforward to extend this proof to the two other channels , as in the classical case @xcite .
a very important property satisfied by the q - bc intertwiner is the invariance under braiding , which can be formulated as follows .
let @xmath481 be an n - uplet of principal representations and let @xmath482 be an element of the braid group on @xmath483 strands . to @xmath482 is associated a unique permutation on @xmath483 points , denoted @xmath484 we associate , as usual , to @xmath482 a linear operator @xmath485 \rightarrow \mathbb { v}[\sigma(b)(\alpha)]$ ] by representing the braid by a product of @xmath486 matrices of @xmath416 .
note that this is well defined because the @xmath486 matrix of @xmath487 evaluated in the tensor product of principal representation is well defined , which is a non trivial fact ( see @xcite ) .
the property of invariance under braiding states that : @xmath488{\mathbb r}(b)=\iota[\alpha].\ ] ] this means that in the picture ( [ braiding ] ) representing the barrett - crane intertwiner , the lines are lines and not ribbons and the black dot is a completely symmetric pivot .
it is sufficient to show this property for an elementary braid , i.e of length one .
let @xmath489 be the transposition of the first two variables .
@xmath490 p_{12}r_{12 } & = & < \omega[\tau(\alpha ) ] \vert ( \bigotimes_{i=\tau(1)}^{\tau(n ) } \stackrel{\alpha_i}{\pi } ) ( \delta^{(n)}(x^a ) ) p_{12}{\mathbb r}_{12 } h(x_a)\\ \label{line1 } & = & < p_{12}\omega[\tau(\alpha)]\vert ( \bigotimes_{i=1}^n \stackrel{\alpha_i}{\pi})(\tau ( \delta^{(n)})(x^a)){\mathbb r}_{12 } h(x_a ) \label{line2 } \\ & = & < { \mathbb r}_{12}\omega[\alpha ] \vert ( \bigotimes_{i=1}^n \stackrel{\alpha_i}{\pi } ) ( \delta_{}^{(n)}(x^a ) ) h(x_a ) \label{line3 } \\ & = & \iota[\alpha]\;\;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we have successively used the definition of the q - bc lorentzian intertwiner , the quasitriangular relation @xmath491 and the invariance @xmath492 shown in the appendix ( [ ronomega1 ] ) .
@xmath470 remark : this property can also be shown using the decomposition in three valent interwiners .
the fact that the action of the @xmath486 matrix on three valent intertwiner amounts to multiply it by the ratio of ribbon elements and the fact that the ribbon element is trivial in a simple representation is sufficient to conclude .
finally , we can generalized the q - bc lorentzian intertwiner as follows : the generalized q - bc lorentzian intertwiner let @xmath452 and @xmath493 two sequences of simple representations of the quantum lorentz group . following ( [ qli ] ) , we define the generalized q - bc intertwiner @xmath494 \ ; : \ ; \mathbb{v}[\alpha ] \rightarrow \mathbb{v}[\beta]$ ] by : @xmath495 \ ; = \sum_{a , b } ( \bigotimes_{i=1}^p \stackrel{\beta_i}{\pi})(\delta^{(p)}(s(x^{b } ) ) ) \vert \omega[\beta ] > < \omega[\alpha ] \vert ( \bigotimes_{j=1}^n\stackrel{\alpha_j}{\pi})(\delta^{(n)}(x^{a}))\ ; h ( x_{b}x_{a})\;\;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is represented by the right graph of caption ( [ intertwiner ] ) and satisfies the following properties : 1 .
@xmath496 $ ] is an intertwiner and is well defined in the following sense : the series @xmath497 \vert \stackrel{a}{e}_a(\alpha)>$ ] converges .
any expansion of @xmath494 $ ] in three valent intertwiners introduces only simple representations in intermediate channels .
3 . @xmath494 $ ] is invariant under braiding .
@xmath498{\mathbb r}(b)=\iota[\beta;\alpha]= { \mathbb r}(b')^{-1}\iota[\sigma(b')(\beta);\alpha].\ ] ] + this proposition is proved along the same lines as the previous propositions . @xmath470 the graph of the right handside of caption as one vertex @xmath155 and @xmath483 edges entering , colored by @xmath499 $ ] , and @xmath500 colored edges going out , colored by @xmath501 $ ] .
we will denote this graph by @xmath502 $ ]
. it will be useful to define the vertex function @xmath503,\mathbb{v}[\beta])$ ] by : @xmath504 >
< \omega[\alpha ] \vert ( \bigotimes_{j=1}^n\stackrel{\alpha_j}{\pi})(\delta^{(n)}(x^{a}))\ ; h ( x_{b}x_{a})\end{aligned}\ ] ] as a consequence , the quantum lorentzian intertwiner is recovered from the vertex function as @xmath494 \ ; = \ ; h(f_v)$ ] .
in this section we will define what is meant by evaluation of a closed simple spin network for the quantum lorentz group . rather than studying the property of convergence in general we will concentrate on the evaluation of particular simple closed graph which are the basic ingredients for the construction of a spin foam amplitude . in particular we will give a formula for the weight associated to a 4-simplex , the so - called quantum @xmath190-symbol . of course ,
as in the classical case , problems of divergences due to the non - compactness of the quantum lorentz group appear as soon as one tries to evaluate naively a closed spin network .
this difficulty is handled by using a regularization similar to the classical case . moreover ,
quantum groups introduce problems of non trivial braidings in the definition of spin networks which have to be handled as well .
evaluation of simple closed spin network has been studied in @xcite in the case of @xmath1 . in the case of @xmath505
it has been studied in @xcite .
later on a study of simple closed spin network in the case where the group is the lorentz group has been done in @xcite .
the property of integrability of simple spin network has been unraveled in @xcite .
evaluation of simple spin networks , in the case of the quantum lorentz group , contains therefore the two difficulties : -the network is a graph embedded in three space and its projection on a plane contains possible crossings - the integrability , in the sense of baez and barett , has to be studied baring in mind that in the quantum case property of convergences are usually enhanced .
the barrett - crane intertwiner being formulated as an integral on the hyperboloid , the evaluation of a simple spin network is given by a multiple integral on a product of hyperboloid .
let @xmath506 where @xmath150 and @xmath507 are two points in the hyperboloid @xmath508 , @xmath509 the distance between them and @xmath200 the simple representation coloring the edge linking @xmath150 to @xmath507 .
a simple spin network is an unoriented graph @xmath510 where the edges are colored by simple representations .
we denote @xmath511 the set of vertices of @xmath510 and @xmath512 the set of edges of @xmath510 . if @xmath35 is an edge it defines a pair of vertices @xmath513 the evaluation of a simple spin network @xmath510 is given by the integral : @xmath514 however because of the non - compactness of the lorentz group , such an integral is divergent . to regularize it , one chooses any vertex @xmath515 , and define @xmath516 as being the integral @xmath517 it
can be shown @xcite that this integral , if it converges , does not depend on @xmath518 and does not depend on the chosen @xmath519 quantum lorentzian spin networks are defined in an analogous way . from an algebraic point of view
our construction is the same as yetter s one @xcite because the quantum lorentz algebra @xmath5 is twist equivalent , as a hopf algebra , to @xmath520 the only , but essential , difference is contained in the star structure and in the category of representation which is considered .
a simple lorentzian q - spin network is a graph @xmath510 embedded in @xmath521 colored by simple representations @xmath499 $ ] of @xmath5 .
the operation of evaluation of this network is defined in the sequel and when it is finite is an invariant under isotopy .
we first define the evaluation formally , along the lines of yetter .
we first project the graph @xmath510 on a plane keeping track of the under - over crossings .
we then apply the method of reshetikhin - turaev @xcite to compute the evaluation , where the coupons are q - bc intertwiner and the ribbons are colored by simple representations .
note that the structure of ribbons is invisible because the ribbon element on simple representations is equal to @xmath245 we will consider only graphs which are at least trivalent for each vertex , this implies that the q - bc intertwiner is well defined for each vertex .
unfortunately the definition of reshetikhin - turaev invariant uses traces over the vector spaces associated to the representations , therefore as such it is ill - defined .
the method of regularization of this evaluation is similar to the classical one .
we associate to each vertex @xmath155 the vertex function @xmath522 we tensor them and pair the spaces `` la reshetikhin - turaev '' while keeping track of the braiding by introducing @xmath486 matrices . the obtained result is an element @xmath523 where @xmath483 is the the number of vertices
. the formal evaluation of @xmath510 would be the integral @xmath524 , while the regularization consists in picking an arbitrary vertex and integrating @xmath525 over the quantum hyperboloid associated to the remaining vertices .
the invariance of the integral under @xmath5 implies first that @xmath526 and secondly that this @xmath527 is independant of the choice of the removed vertex .
when @xmath527 is finite @xmath510 is said to be integrable .
we have used the following convention for evaluating simple q - spin networks .
we select a projection of the graph in such a way that all the vertices are aligned and we enumerate them from the left to the right .
we first define the quantum analog of @xmath528 we will define it as an element of @xmath529 which is @xmath530 we will use the convenient abuse of notation of viewing this as a non commutative function of two variables @xmath531 using the sweedler notation , @xmath532 we obtain that @xmath533 this definition is a direct consequence of the definition of the q - bc interwiner and of the relation @xmath534 using the definition of the coproduct ( [ coprodfunc ] ) , we obtain : @xmath535 this function satisfies the following convolution property : @xmath536 where @xmath537 is the plancherel measure and @xmath538 is the integral over the quantum hyperboloid . this property is a direct consequence of ( [ schurlemma ] ) . first , let us consider the simple network @xmath539 $ ] with two vertices linked by a set of @xmath500 edges colored by @xmath499=(\alpha_1,\cdots,\alpha_p)$ ] . .
] it is straightforward to see that the associated graph function , represented by the graph ( [ gamma2 ] ) , is given by : @xmath540 the evaluation of this spin - network , defines the so - called @xmath541 functions , and are given by : @xmath542)=\theta^q_p(\rho_1, ...
,\rho_p)= h(\prod_{j=1}^p \stackrel{\alpha_i}{k } ) = \sum_m [ d_m]_q^2 \prod_{i=1}^p \lambda^{mm}_{\;\;0}(\alpha_i)=\\ & & = \sum_{n=1}^{+\infty}\frac{1}{[n]_q^{p-2}}\prod_{j=1}^p \frac{\sin(2n\nu_j)}{\sin(2\nu_j)}=g^q_p(\nu_1, ... ,\nu_p),\label{gqp}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have denoted @xmath543 we will need properties of these series and will concentrate on a precise study of these series when @xmath544 and @xmath545 these series have appeared in other contexts . when @xmath328 , @xmath546 is , up to a constant , the value found by witten @xcite of the volume of the moduli space @xmath547 of flat @xmath37 connections on the sphere with @xmath500 punctures associated to conjugacy classes @xmath548 , with @xmath549 where @xmath550 if we fix the variables @xmath551 and study the behaviour @xmath552 goes to @xmath553 , which amounts to recover the ordinary lorentzian barrett - crane model , these series are equivalent , up to a normalization of @xmath552 , to the integrals @xmath554 considered by barrett and crane . when @xmath544 , @xmath555 has appeared naturally in the work @xcite , and it is precisely the definition of the coefficient @xmath556 the functions @xmath546 have also been introduced by one of us and a.szenes in @xcite , as the value of cyclic traces on non commutative deformations of @xmath547 .
when @xmath557 , it is trivial to show that these series are uniformally convergent for @xmath558 , whereas it is a distribution in the case where @xmath559 and is equal to @xmath560 as a result , when @xmath558 and @xmath557 the functions @xmath561 are continuous functions ( even smooth functions ) of @xmath562 the functions @xmath563 and @xmath564 can be expressed in term of jacobi @xmath565 functions as shown in the appendix a.2 . in particular for @xmath566 we obtain that the evaluation of this simple spin network is equal to : @xmath567 in particular we can recover the classical behaviour , when @xmath427 , computed in @xcite . from the modular properties of @xmath568 we have for any real variable @xmath150 : @xmath569 as a result we get @xmath570 where @xmath105 is a function of @xmath552 .
the evaluation of @xmath571 is crucial for the computation of the weight of the spin foam on edges
. we can compute it exactly ( see the appendix a.2 ) and we have the @xmath572analogue of the formula of barrett - crane : @xmath573 when @xmath328 , @xmath546 , being volume of a symplectic manifold , is non negative
. however it can be equal to zero , which arizes when the manifold is empty .
let us define the function @xmath574 , which is the characteristic function of the set @xmath321 defined by @xmath575 and for @xmath576 , denote by @xmath577 the unique real number satisfying @xmath578 when @xmath544 we have @xmath579 the behaviour of @xmath580 is different , because it is always strictly positive .
indeed , in the appendix we have shown that @xmath581 with @xmath582 we will need a similar result for @xmath583 we will use the following formula , which is trivial from the definition of @xmath584 as series : @xmath585 ( note that when q=1 , this equation follows from the fact that the moduli space of the sphere with 4 punctures is obtained by gluing the moduli spaces of two three punctured spheres . ) . as a result ,
using the lower bound for @xmath586 , we obtain @xmath587 this has the far reaching consequence that the function @xmath571 is bounded from below by @xmath588 this behaviour is very different from the case where @xmath589 . in the riemannian case ,
@xmath590 are positive half - integers , and @xmath591 can vanish if the selection rules on @xmath592 are not satisfied .
in the lorentzian barrett - crane model , @xmath590 are any positive number , and the infimum of @xmath591 is @xmath553 , though it is never reached
. we will now give an expression , in term of multiple series , of the evaluation of a colored 4-simplex ( the 10j symbol ) .
important properties will show up on this expression : -it is finite -it is a continuous function of @xmath593 -it does not depend on the choice of crossing .
let us consider the graph embedded in @xmath594 , whose vertices and edges are those of the @xmath90 simplex colored by a sequence @xmath595 of simple representations .
when one projects this graph on a hyperplane there is a choice of crossing which has to be made .
we will denote @xmath596 the associated simple spin network .
the following computation is done with the choice of upper crossing which is depicted in the figure ( [ 10jsymbol ] ) . spin network . ] with the convention of the picture , it is straightforward to compute the graph function : @xmath597 where we have abusively denoted @xmath598 using the properties @xmath599 and @xmath600 this function can be written as : @xmath601 we evaluate this spin network by applying @xmath602 we obtain : @xmath603 using the invariance on the left and on the right of @xmath365 and the braiding relation , we obtain @xmath604 where @xmath605 we eliminate the @xmath486 matrix using the property ( [ ronomega2 ] ) , and the expression reduces to : @xmath606 it remains to evaluate the four integrals .
we denote by @xmath607 the basis of @xmath608 which satisfies @xmath609 as a result , in this basis , ( [ coprodfunc ] ) is expressed as : @xmath610 and the action of the antipode @xmath611 is given by : @xmath612 where @xmath613 is the matrix defined as : @xmath614^{1/2}e^{-i\pi a}\clebpsi{a}{a}{0}{m}{n}{0}.\ ] ] it is then straighforward to perform the integrations of ( [ evaluationof4simplex ] ) , and we get : @xmath615_q[d_{m_5}]_q[d_{m_9}]_q[d_{m_{10}}]_q x(\{m_i\})\ ] ] where the function @xmath616 is the evaluation of the @xmath57 spin network drawn in picture ( [ graph ] ) . .
] we now evaluate this spin network .
each box is replaced by the corresponding @xmath617 intertwiner multiplied by a number .
for example the box on the upper left is replaced by @xmath618 where @xmath619_q^{1/2}}{[d_{m_4}]_q^{1/2 } } \sixj{m_9}{m_8}{m_4}{m_3}{m_{10}}{m_2 } .\ ] ] as a result we obtain : @xmath620_q[d_{m_3}]_q^{1/2}[d_{m_6}]_q^{1/2}[d_{m_7}]_q^{1/2}[d_{m_8}]_q^{1/2 } } { [ d_{m_4}]_q^{1/2}[d_{m_5}]_q[d_{m_9}]_q^{1/2}}\sixj{m_3}{m_7}{m_6}{m_1}{m_2}{m_8 } \sixj{m_4}{m_7}{m_5}{m_6}{m_{10}}{m_3}\nonumber\\ & & \sixj{m_{10}}{m_6}{m_5}{m_1}{m_9}{m_{2 } } \sixj{m_4}{m_8}{m_9}{m_1}{m_5}{m_7 } \sixj{m_9}{m_8}{m_4}{m_3}{m_{10}}{m_2}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] using racah - wigner symmetry , we finally obtain the nice formula : @xmath621_q^{1/2 } \lambda^{m_i m_i}_{\;\;00 } ( \alpha_i ) \right ) \sixj{m_3}{m_7}{m_6}{m_1}{m_2}{m_8 } \sixj{m_4}{m_7}{m_5}{m_6}{m_{10}}{m_3 } \nonumber \\ & & \sixj{m_2}{m_6}{m_1}{m_5}{m_9}{m_{10 } } \sixj{m_4}{m_8}{m_9}{m_1}{m_5}{m_7 } \sixj{m_9}{m_8}{m_4}{m_3}{m_{10}}{m_2}\label{4simplexevaluated}\;\;. \end{aligned}\ ] ] this expression is a multiple series which converges absolutely .
indeed , each @xmath622-symbol is bounded by one and when @xmath52 goes to infinity , @xmath623_q^{1/2 } \lambda^{m m}_{\;\;00 } ( \alpha ) = { \cal o}(mq^m)$ ] . as a result
the graph @xmath624 is integrable . because the convergence is uniform in @xmath551
, @xmath625 is a continuous function of the variables @xmath551 .
note a very important property satisfied by @xmath625 : it is a function of @xmath6 symmetric in the exchange @xmath626 this is a direct consequence of the invariance of the @xmath42 symbols under the exchange @xmath627 the evaluation of the graph @xmath628 proceeds along the same lines , and its evaluation gives the same answer ( [ 4simplexevaluated ] ) .
this is compatible with the invariance @xmath627
with all the tools introduced in the previous section , we can now built cosmological lorentzian spin foam models .
let @xmath34 be a triangulation of the lorentzian manifold @xmath52 , we define by @xmath99 the set of @xmath100simplices of the triangulation .
the partition function of the spin foam model is defined as usual : @xmath629}\prod_{f\in \delta_2 } d\rho_f \prod_{f\in \delta_2 } a_2 ( \rho_f ) \prod_{t\in \delta_3 } a_3(\rho_1^t, ... ,\rho_4^t ) \prod_{s\in \delta_4}a_4(\rho_1^s, ...
,\rho_{10}^s ) , \ ] ] where @xmath630 is the value of the @xmath190 symbol of the @xmath631 simplex @xmath117 .
note that the value of @xmath632 and @xmath633 is still a matter of debate .
see @xcite for a clear survey of the situation . in this article
three choices of @xmath205 and @xmath206 have been analyzed .
we give their straighforward q - deformation in the sequel : 1)@xmath634 2)@xmath635 3)@xmath636 where @xmath637 is the plancherel measure .
it is therefore straighforward to show that the integral @xmath638 is finite for the three previous cases .
the integration is on a compact set , the function @xmath639 is continuous , and because of the lower bound on @xmath640 , the function @xmath206 is also continuous for the three cases . as
a result @xmath638 is a convergent integral for these three cases and more generally in the case where @xmath208 are continuous functions of the @xmath214 s .
in our work we have defined cosmological deformation of lorentzian spin foam models .
the only analysis that we have made of this model is its finiteness property for a fixed triangulation .
presently there are lots of work on the study of lorentzian spin foam models and its relations to quantum gravity .
central questions are the `` derivation '' of these models from the lagrangian field theory , the restriction to the gravitational sector , the analysis of the asymptotic properties of the weight of a simplex , the relation to the hamiltonian constraint , the possible non - perturbative definitions of the sum over the 2-complexes , the importance of the degenerate metrics , the nature of the spectrum of observables ( continuous or discrete ? ) .
they are all related to the following three questions : how fondamental is the barret - crane model ?
what are the observables and their spectrum ?
how do we do a semi - classical study of spin - foam models ?
the same questions can be formulated in the context of cosmological deformation of spin foam models as well .
even more pressing questions are present : how do we precisely connect the plebanski lagrangian field theory with a cosmological constant to cosmological deformation of the barrett - crane model
? how do we compute @xmath205 and @xmath206 ? how do we do a semi - classical expansion around de sitter space ?
what precisely are the states of quantum lorentzian gravity with a positive cosmological constant ? how do we couple these models to matter and extract information about physical quantities ? the fate of the spinfoam model approach depends crucially on the possibility of answering to these questions .
there are of course extensions of our work which can be readily done .
the first one is the inclusion of faces of timelike type .
the technology of quantum groups that we have developped in the past should give an easy answer to this extension . the spinfoam model that we have defined
should also appear as the perturbative expansion of a field theory on a non commutative analogue of @xmath641 .
another well studied question nowadays , in the classical case , is the asymptotic properties of the @xmath190 symbol . a similar question can be asked in the cosmological deformation case .
its formulation is as follows : we fix @xmath642 , define @xmath551 by @xmath643 , and we would like to understand the behaviour of @xmath644 in the limit where @xmath45 goes to 0 .
it is straightforward to see that @xmath645_q^{1/2}\frac{\sin((2m_j+1)\omega_j ) } { \sin(\omega_j)}r_q(m_1, ... ,m_{10})\ ] ] where @xmath646 is the product of the five @xmath647 symbols and @xmath648 the asymptotic properties of the simplex is therefore the classical expansion of this series around @xmath328 .
the form of this series is very reminiscent of the series that we have studied in @xcite , for which we have developped tools ( residue formulas ) for computing the asymptotic of such series .
we hope to apply analog of these methods to analyze the behaviour of the @xmath90-simplex .
we thank l.crane and c.rovelli for stimulating and enthousiastic discussions on spin foam models .
we also thank e.buffenoir for interesting discussions .
the lie algebra @xmath88 is also the real lie algebra of @xmath649 therefore we will use indifferently the notation @xmath5 or @xmath212 for its quantization .
we define the quantum lorentz group @xmath5 as being the quantum double of @xmath57 .
this construction is a standard and very important construction in the theory of quantum groups .
it is exposed in detail in @xcite .
the quantum double of @xmath57 is the hopf algebra @xmath650 .
@xmath651 denotes the hopf algebra @xmath309 with permuted coproduct .
the notation @xmath652 reminds the reader that inside @xmath653 , @xmath654 and @xmath655 do not commute but satisfy braided identities .
in @xcite we have classified and given simple expressions for the unitary irreducible representations of @xmath89 we will only need the representation of the principal series which we denote @xmath405 where @xmath656 matrix elements of @xmath405 are linear forms on @xmath416 and therefore are elements of @xmath657 using the decomposition @xmath658 we have expressed in @xcite the matrix elements of @xmath405 in terms of a basis of @xmath659 we will use the following convenient basis which elements are @xmath660 .
we will denote this basis by @xmath435 .
the dual @xmath661 is @xmath416 ( more precisely contains @xmath662 as a hopf sub - algebra ) .
one of its basis is the dual basis @xmath437 which is the basis @xmath663 with the duality bracket given by : @xmath664 we have given explicit formulas for the representation @xmath405 in this basis .
namely : @xmath665 where @xmath666 are coefficients defined in terms of analytic continuation of @xmath42 symbols of @xmath57 and whose properties are studied in depth in @xcite . an explicit expression is given in equation ( 89 ) of @xcite .
as a result we get the expression : @xmath667 the @xmath486 matrix of @xmath672 is given by the construction of the quantum double , its evaluation on principal representations has been computed in @xcite : @xmath673 in particular this expression implies that : @xmath674 in @xcite we have made a study of intertwining operators for the tensor product of principal representations .
we have shown that if @xmath676 label principal representations , the space of intertwiners @xmath677 is one dimensional when @xmath678 and zero otherwise .
we have chosen a particular normalized intertwiner , denoted @xmath679 , which satisfies the following completeness relation : @xmath680 with @xmath681 a normalization factor given by an infinite product expression and the integral @xmath682 means , as usual , an integral over @xmath683 and a sum over the integer @xmath684 . note that when @xmath676 are simple the expression for @xmath52 reduces to a simple ratio of theta functions , as explained in @xcite and recalled in the appendix a.2 of the present work . as explained in the sequel ,
this function @xmath52 is exactly the evaluation of the so - called `` theta '' graph @xmath688 to express @xmath707 in term of theta functions , one can use the following trick which will be useful later on .
we first expand @xmath708 , and we interchange the sum in @xmath707 by summing first over @xmath709 we therefore obtain that @xmath710 this enables us to show that @xmath555 is strictly positive and that we have the lower bound : @xmath717 to prove this lower bound we use the infinite product formula for @xmath568 and @xmath718 . as a result
we obtain the inequalities , when @xmath150 is real , : @xmath719 as a result we obtain that @xmath720 where @xmath721 | we study the quantum deformation of the barrett - crane lorentzian spin foam model which is conjectured to be the discretization of lorentzian plebanski model with positive cosmological constant and includes therefore as a particular sector quantum gravity in de - sitter space .
this spin foam model is constructed using harmonic analysis on the quantum lorentz group .
the evaluation of simple spin networks are shown to be non commutative integrals over the quantum hyperboloid defined as a pile of fuzzy spheres .
we show that the introduction of the cosmological constant , removes all the infrared divergences : for any fixed triangulation , the integration over the area variables is finite for a large class of normalization of the amplitude of the edges and of the faces . |
cold dark matter ( cdm ) models of structure formation have been remarkably successful in explaining a wide range of observations at both low and high redshifts . however , high resolution n - body simulations of the cdm model have revealed two potential conflicts with observations .
first , the inner mass density profiles of simulated halos are cuspy , as opposed to the shallow profiles inferred from the rotation curves of dwarfs and low surface brightness galaxies ( @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; but see van den bosch et al .
1999 ) , and the observations of soft cores in galaxy clusters by gravitational lensing ( @xcite ) .
second , group - sized halos in simulations contain a large number of low mass subhalos , greatly in excess of the observed number of satellite galaxies in the local group ( @xcite ; @xcite ) .
a variety of mechanisms have been proposed recently to reduce the clustering of mass on small scales , while simultaneously retaining the large scale successes of the cdm model .
these mechanisms include breaking the scale invariance of the power spectrum of primordial density fluctuations ( @xcite ) , postulating different collapse histories for dark matter and baryons ( @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) , and modifying the nature of dark matter .
the last option includes dark matter models with a variety of properties self - interacting ( @xcite ) , warm ( @xcite ) repulsive ( @xcite ) , fluid ( @xcite ) , and fuzzy ( @xcite ) . in the warm dark matter
( wdm ) model , the linear power spectrum is exponentially damped on scales smaller than the free - streaming length of the warm particle , @xmath2 , relative to the pure cdm model ( @xcite ) .
here , @xmath3 is the ratio of wdm density to the critical density , @xmath4 is the mass of the wdm particle , and @xmath5 is the hubble parameter .
non - linear gravitational evolution transfers power from large scales to small scales , so the clustering of the highly nonlinear mass distribution is insensitive to the shape of the linear power spectrum below the non - linear scale ( @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) .
conversely , absorbers seen in the spectra of high redshift ( @xmath6 ) quasars arise from mass density fluctuations in the quasi - linear regime ( @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) , so their properties remain sensitive to the linear power spectrum . in this @xmath7 , we set a lower limit on the mass of wdm particle by requiring that there be enough small scale power in the initial conditions to reproduce the observed properties of the forest at @xmath1 .
we study the forest in both cdm and wdm models with @xmath8 , @xmath9 , @xmath10 , @xmath11 , and @xmath12 , where @xmath13 , @xmath14 and @xmath15 are the contributions from total mass , vacuum energy , and baryons to the total energy density of the universe , and @xmath16 is the rms density fluctuation in @xmath17 spheres , chosen here to reproduce the observed cluster abundance ( @xcite ; @xcite ) .
table 1 lists the parameters of all models investigated .
our wdm models have @xmath18 and @xmath19 ev ( corresponding to @xmath20 ) , spanning the range of wdm masses required to match the phase space density of dark matter cores in disk galaxies and dwarf spheroidal galaxies ( @xcite and references therein ; @xcite ) we also analyze a broken scale invariance model ( bsi , @xcite ) , using an analytic fit to its power spectrum from white & croft ( 2000 ) , with a filtering scale @xmath21 required to fit the observed number density of low mass satellite galaxies in the local group .
llccc model & power spectrum & @xmath22 & @xmath23 & @xmath24 + & & ( ev ) & ( @xmath25 ) & ( k ) + cdm & cdm & & 0 & 6000 + wdm1000 & wdm & 1000 & 2.3 & 6000 + wdm750 & wdm & 750 & 3.3 & 6000 + wdm500 & wdm & 500 & 5.7 & 6000 + wdm200 & wdm & 200 & 19.2 & 6000 + cdm200 & wdm & 200 & 0 & 6000 + wdm750t025k & wdm & 750 & 3.3 & 25000 + bsik02 & cdm , bsi & & 0 & 6000 + [ table : models ] we calculate the linear power spectrum of the mass density field for all the models using the full boltzmann transport code of ma & bertschinger ( 1995 ) .
we assume the usual three massless neutrino species with a present - day temperature @xmath26 k , and treat the wdm component as a fourth ( massive ) species with @xmath27 .
fifty legendre moments are used to follow the evolution of the wdm phase space .
we compared our wdm power spectra with the fitting function of bardeen et al .
( 1986 ) and find that their formula provides a reasonable approximation for @xmath28 [ if a baryon - corrected shape parameter @xmath29 is used ] , but it overestimates the power spectrum by up to an order of magnitude at higher @xmath30 .
we employ a particle - mesh ( pm ) n - body code that is described in detail in steed et al .
( in preparation ) .
this code computes forces using a staggered mesh ( @xcite ; @xcite ) , and integrates the equations of motion using the leapfrog scheme described in quinn et al .
our periodic simulation volume has @xmath31mpc , with @xmath32 particles and an @xmath33 force mesh .
we assign initial displacements and velocities to the particles using the zeldovich approximation . in the wdm models
, we also add a randomly oriented streaming velocity component that is drawn from a fermi - dirac distribution with an rms velocity , @xmath34 we evolve from redshift @xmath35 in 24 equal steps of the expansion scale factor .
figure 1 shows the linear and non - linear power spectrum of the mass density field at @xmath1 in different models .
the differences between different models are significantly smaller in the non - linear power spectra , compared to the differences in their linear theory power spectra , because non - linear gravitational evolution has regenerated power on small scales . nevertheless , power transfer is not entirely successful in erasing the differences between the power spectra of different models .
thus , at @xmath1 , the wdm200 model has almost an order of magnitude less power on small scales compared to the cdm model , while the models wdm500 , wdm750 , and bsik02 are all deficient by @xmath36 dex .
we also ran these models with a @xmath37 box using the same @xmath38 and @xmath39 , and found similar results on overlapping length scales .
the model cdm200 has the same linear power spectrum as wdm200 , but @xmath40 .
this model gives virtually identical results to the wdm200 model , showing that the velocity dispersion of wdm particles has a negligible effect on the forest at @xmath1 .
hence , we do not show the results for this model in the figures .
the forest arises from a continuous , fluctuating , low - density @xmath41 $ ] gaseous medium whose temperature is determined by the balance between photoionization heating by the uv background and adiabatic cooling due to hubble expansion ( see e.g. , @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) .
photoionization equilibrium leads to a power - law relation between temperature and gas density , of the form @xmath42 , with @xmath43 , and @xmath44 ( @xcite ) .
the optical depth to photons ( @xmath45 ) is proportional to gas density , which in turn is proportional to @xmath46 for gas in photoionization equilibrium near @xmath47 .
pressure gradients in this low - density , fairly cool ( @xmath48 k ) gas are small , so gas traces dark matter ( @xcite ) .
hence , the gas density - temperature relation can be translated into a relation between mass density @xmath49 and @xmath45 ( the fluctuating gunn - peterson approximation " , @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) .
thus , the transmitted flux of photons @xmath50 $ ] in a quasar spectrum is a map of the mass density fluctuations along the line of sight .
we extract artificial absorption spectra along 400 random lines of sight through each simulation , using the tipsy package ( @xcite ; see http://www-hpcc.astro.washington.edu/tools/tipsy ) .
tipsy calculates the local mass density @xmath49 at the position of each dark matter particle using a cubic spline smoothing kernel ( hernquist & katz 1989 ) enclosing 32 neighbors , and assigns it a temperature @xmath51 .
spectra are then computed from this particle distribution using the algorithm described by hernquist et al .
we sample the spectra with resolution @xmath52 , roughly corresponding to that of the keck hires spectra to which we will compare our model predictions .
we `` fit a continuum '' to each spectral segment , @xmath53 in length , by rescaling all flux values so that the highest pixel has transmission of unity ( @xcite ) . fitting a continuum
makes low - power models appear more like high power models , so it is an important step for conservatively discriminating against models with suppressed power .
the optical depth to photons depends on a number of uncertain parameters including @xmath15 , @xmath54 , @xmath55 , and the intensity of the ionizing background
. however , the cumulative effect of all these parameters is to scale the normalization factor ( @xmath56 ) relating @xmath45 to @xmath57 , as long as collisional ionization is unimportant ( @xcite ) .
we fix @xmath56 in each model so that the mean transmitted flux at @xmath1 , @xmath58 , is 0.684 , as measured by mcdonald et al .
( 1999 ) from keck hires spectra of eight quasars .
figure 2 shows artificial absorption spectra at @xmath1 extracted along four random lines of sight , in three different models : cdm , wdm500 , and wdm750 .
the gas responsible for absorption is in larger and more diffuse structures in wdm models compared to the cdm model .
hence , the wdm spectra are smoother and have less small scale power as compared to the cdm spectra .
the fluctuations in the absorbing gas are also weaker in the wdm models , resulting in absorption lines that are broader and shallower than corresponding lines in the cdm artificial spectra .
= 5.5truein figure 3 shows the one dimensional power spectrum of the transmitted flux , @xmath59 , computed using 400 artificial spectra for each model .
the solid points show @xmath59 measured by mcdonald et al .
the shape and amplitude of @xmath59 of the cdm model matches the observations very well , in the entire range @xmath60 \la -1 $ ] .
however , the wdm models predict a wrong shape of @xmath59 .
thus , although the @xmath59 of wdm models match the observations on large scales , @xmath60 \la -2 $ ] , they have too little power on smaller scales .
this confirms the visual impression from the spectra in fig . 2 , and is also evident in the flux decrement correlation function ( not shown ) .
a higher value of @xmath55 further suppresses @xmath59 on smaller scales , worsening the discrepancy with observations .
note that lowering @xmath61 to make up the power suppressed by wdm is not feasible ; a lower @xmath61 raises the power spectrum on all scales at @xmath1 , and thus would be inconsistent with the observed @xmath59 on large scales .
= figure 4 shows the probability distribution function ( pdf ) of the transmitted flux ( @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) , computed using 400 artificial spectra for each model .
the solid points show the flux pdf measured by mcdonald et al .
the flux pdf of the cdm model matches observations remarkably well over the entire range of flux values .
as the mass of wdm decreases , there is less small scale power in the mass distribution , the mass fluctuations are weaker , and the gas responsible for absorption is in more diffuse structures .
hence there are fewer pixels where the transmission approaches unity , and more pixels at intermediate fluxes . in the flux range @xmath62 , the flux pdf for all wdm models with @xmath63 differs from observations by @xmath64 .
this mismatch further confirms that the mass fluctuation amplitude of these wdm models is too low at small scales when the fluctuations are normalized to match @xmath59 on large scales .
even the model wdm750t025k , with a higher temperature for the mean - density gas ( @xmath65 ) , does not match the observations as well as the cdm model . on the other hand , while wdm1000 does not match the observations very well , a higher value of @xmath55 can bring its flux pdf to better agreement with observations . since recent determinations of @xmath55 prefer values around @xmath66 ( e.g. , @xcite ) , we conclude that the observed flux pdf can not be reproduced by wdm models with @xmath67 ev .
the bsik02 model is also inconsistent with observations , being similar to wdm500 .
for a given cosmology , the properties of the forest depend on three factors : ( a ) the linear theory power spectrum , taken from a boltzmann code ; ( b ) power transfer from large to small scales during non - linear gravitational evolution , followed using n - body simulations ; and ( c ) the equation of state of the intergalactic medium , governed by photoionization equilibrium . here
, we have used the observed forest at @xmath1 to constrain the shape of the linear power spectrum , and consequently @xmath22 .
our principal conclusions are as follows : ( 1 ) @xmath68 ev is required to match @xmath59 and flux pdf of artificial spectra extracted from simulations of wdm models with keck hires observations of mcdonald et al .
( 1999 ) , for any reasonable @xmath69 .
this limit is similar to that obtained from the maximum observed phase space density of dwarf spheroidal galaxies ( dalcanton & hogan 2000 ) .
high resolution n - body simulations of wdm models with @xmath70 kev predict the observed circular velocity function of satellite galaxies in the local group , but produce cuspy halos ( @xcite ) .
( 2 ) forest properties depend on the shape of the linear power spectrum , and are insensitive to streaming velocities of wdm particles . even for a 200 ev wdm particle , @xmath71 at @xmath1 , an order of magnitude smaller than the thermal velocity of gas at @xmath48 k. hence , any mechanism that suppresses the cdm linear power spectrum more severely than a 750 ev wdm particle will be inconsistent with forest observations .
( 3 ) the bsi model proposed by kamionkowski & liddle ( 1999 ) , with @xmath72 chosen to match the abundance of dwarf galaxies , does not reproduce the observed properties of the forest at @xmath1 . we note that this is the extreme bsi model considered by white & croft ( 2000 ) , hence our conclusion is not in conflict with theirs .
we thank david weinberg and michael strauss for helpful comments on the manuscript .
dns is partially supported by the map / midex program , and the nasa atp grant nag5 - 7154 .
cpm is supported by a cottrell scholars award from the research corporation , and nsf grant ast 9973461 .
cen , r. , miralda - escude , j. , ostriker , j. p. , & rauch , m. , 1994 , , 437 , l9 croft , r. a. c. , weinberg , d. h. , katz , n. , & hernquist , l. 1998 , , 495 , 44 dalanton , j. j , . & hogan , c. j. , 2000 , preprint ( astro - ph/0004381 ) de blok , w. j. g. , & mcgaugh , s. s. , 1997 , , 290 , 533 eke , v. r. , cole , s. , frenk , c. s. 1996 , , 282 , 263 flores , r. , & primack , j. r. , 1994 , , 427 , l1 goodman , j. , 2000 , preprint ( astro - ph/0003018 ) hernandez , x. , & gilmore , g. , 1998 , , 294 , 595 hernquist , l. , & katz , n. 1989 , , 70 , 419 hernquist l. , katz , n. , weinberg , d. h. , & miralda - escud , j. 1996 , , 457 , l5 hogan , c. j. , & dalanton , j. j. , 2000 , preprint ( astro - ph/0002330 ) tyson , j. a. , kochanski , g. p. , & dellntonio , i. p. , 1999
, , 498 , l107 van den bosch , f. , robertson , b. e. , dalcanton , j. j. , & de blok , w. j. g. , 1999 , , submitted ( astro - ph/9911372 ) weinberg , d. h. , katz , n. , & hernquist , l. 1998 , in asp conference series 148 , origins , eds . c. e. woodward , j. m. shull , & h. thronson , ( asp : san francisco ) , 21 , astro - ph/9708213 | high resolution n - body simulations of cold dark matter ( cdm ) models predict that galaxies and clusters have cuspy halos with excessive substructure .
observations reveal smooth halos with central density cores .
one possible resolution of this conflict is that the dark matter is warm ( wdm ) ; this will suppress the power spectrum on small scales .
the lyman - alpha forest is a powerful probe of the linear power spectrum on these scales .
we use collisionless n - body simulations to follow the evolution of structure in wdm models , and analyze artificial lyman - alpha forest spectra extracted from them . by requiring that there is enough small scale power in the linear power spectrum to reproduce the observed properties of the lyman - alpha forest in quasar spectra , we derive a lower limit to the mass of the wdm particle of 750 ev .
this limit is robust to reasonable uncertainties in our assumption about the temperature of the mean density gas @xmath0 at @xmath1 .
we argue that any model that suppresses the cdm linear theory power spectrum more severely than a 750 ev wdm particle can not produce the lyman - alpha forest .
# 1([eqn:#1 ] ) |
felix will be the first full acceptance detector at a hadron collider .
it will be optimized for studying the structure of individual events over all of phase space ( see figure [ prodplot ] ) .
felix will observe and measure all charged particles , from the central region all the way out to diffractive protons which have lost only @xmath0 of their initial energy .
it will even see elastic protons which have a momentum transfer of at least @xmath1 gev@xmath2 .
this comprehensive , precision tracking is accompanied by equally superb electromagnetic and hadronic calorimetry .
felix will observe and measure photons and neutrons down , literally , to zero degrees , giving it an unparalleled ability to track the energy flow .
in contrast , the other lhc detectors are sensitive over only a fraction of phase space and see less than 10% of the typical energy flow .
felix is thus uniquely able to pursue physics complementary to that of the other detectors planned for the lhc .
the felix design involves the coordinated arrangement of three distinct systems : the magnetic architecture responsible for getting the beams through the i4 straight section , the tracking system , and the calorimetry .
each system must be complete in its own right , without compromising the characteristics of the other systems .
the magnetic apertures must not be limiting apertures of either the tracking or calorimeter systems .
there must be sufficient physical space for both tracking and calorimetry .
the calorimeters must be physically large enough to have good resolution , and must not interfere with either the tracking or the magnetic systems .
all of this requires a lot of space , and the detector must be carefully integrated into the design of the machine .
full acceptance can not be achieved by adding on " to central detectors optimized for high @xmath3 physics . here
felix is fortunate .
the decision to split the rf cavities at i4 , moving them to @xmath4 140 m from the interaction point ( ip ) , combined with the fact that felix s low " luminosity permits the focusing quadrupoles to be moved more than 120 m from the ip , provides the necessary longitudinal space .
i4 is also ideal from the point of view of transverse space .
the beams are separated by 42 cm at the location of the rf cavities , providing room for zero degree calorimetry . since the existing infrastructure , including the aleph solenoid , can be re - used with minimal modifications , i4 is clearly a superb location for a full acceptance detector .
( the central part of felix , which nicely fits into the existing cavern , and the extensions upstream into the forward regions , are shown in figure [ figi ] . ) nevertheless , the task of integrating a detector with genuinely full acceptance into the available space at i4 is not trivial .
the felix letter of intent @xcite outlines how it can be done , using well - understood magnets and compact detectors , for a comparatively modest price : we estimate a cost of about 25 mchf for the machine magnets and the infrastructure , and about 50 mchf for the detector outlined here and presented in more detail in the felix loi .
the heart of the felix physics agenda is qcd : felix will be the ultimate qcd detector at the lhc . surprisingly , the need for such a detector is not obvious to many members of the high energy community . in part
, this may be because of the success of the interplay between theory and experiment in the case of electron - positron collisions .
the cleanliness of the process , together with the low event rate and full - acceptance capability of the detectors , has led to an especially fruitful interaction between the qcd aspects of that experimental program with the remainder .
the case of hadron - hadron collider physics is quite different .
the high-@xmath3 , low cross section physics is accessed by highly selective triggers .
the phase - space acceptance of the detectors is largely limited to the central rapidity region .
full acceptance has not been attained since the bubble - chamber era of fixed - target physics .
therefore the basic data base is much more limited .
this situation is all the more serious because of the great variety in event classes for hadron - hadron collisions .
there are soft collisions with large impact parameters ; angular momenta of tens of thousands instead of the unique @xmath5 of the @xmath6 world .
central collisions produce much higher multiplicities than are seen in @xmath6 annihilation .
there are the diffraction classes of events , with and without jet activity , that comprise several to tens of percent of typical subsamples ( if seen in full acceptance ) and which present a major challenge to theory .
there are poorly understood strong bose - einstein - like correlations seen at very low @xmath3 and low relative @xmath3 in hadron - hadron collisions which do not occur in @xmath6 collisions .
but at collider energies this is only based on one sample of low-@xmath3 data from ua1 , because until now no other detector has had the measurement capability .
finally , there is little if any data in the forward fragmentation regions , where cosmic ray experiments insistently claim that anomalies exist .
given this richness of phenomena , and given the importance of qcd to the interpretation of the new - physics data expected to emerge from the lhc , it is clearly very important to improve the data - base with an lhc detector and experimental group fully dedicated to the observation and interpretation of as broad a range of qcd phenomena as possible .
this is of course the mission of the felix initiative
. many of these new opportunities in qcd physics at the lhc are not well known , and the felix collaboration has accordingly placed high priority in in providing a description of them in the felix loi .
we briefly summarize a few of the main themes here .
the parton densities at small @xmath7 are themselves a very important thing to measure . up to now hera has provided data down to @xmath7 values of order @xmath9 for @xmath10 in the perturbative domain of several gev@xmath2 .
felix will have the capability to extend these measurements to @xmath7 values below @xmath8 via observation of dileptons , low - mass dijets , and low - mass jet - photon systems carrying large longitudinal momenta . in this regime one
expects ( especially for proton - ion collisions ) the breakdown of the usual dglap / bfkl evolution - equation formalism and significant nonlinear effects to be observed .
the need for a vastly improved qcd data - base for hadron - hadron collisions is made even more urgent by the fact that qualitative changes are expected even in the structure of generic events because of the rapid increase with energy of gluon parton densities in the primary protons .
thanks to the measurements at hera , this is not only the theoretical expectation but also a data - driven one .
the parton densities at a @xmath11 gev scale become so large that minijet production in central collisions may become common place , with minijet @xmath3 large enough for reasonably clean observability .
these very high parton densities create , at a perturbative short distance scale , `` hot spots '' in the spacetime evolution of the collision process within which there may be thermalization or other nonperturbative phenomena not easy to anticipate in advance of the data .
particle spectra themselves may evolve to something quite distinct from what has been so far observed , with strangeness , heavy flavors , and/or baryon and antibaryon production enhanced .
especially in central proton - ion collisions , where the total gluon - gluon luminosity per collision is maximized , and where the evolution of a single proton fragment is followed , one can expect this class of phenomena to be most prominent and surprises most probable .
diffractive final states will comprise almost @xmath12 of all final states at the lhc .
the soft diffraction at very large impact parameter , which perhaps sheds light on pion - cloud or glueball physics , is at one extreme , and hard diffraction , where rapidity gaps coexist with jets , is at the other .
there are a large variety of hard diffraction processes , including some with two and three rapidity gaps , which are of basic interest to study . in this class there
are expected to be , for example , an extraordinary class of events where the complete event consists of a coplanar dijet accompanied by the two unfragmented beam protons detected in roman pots , and absolutely nothing else in the detector .
certainly atlas and cms can also detect such events , provided they sacrifice a luminosity factor of about 30 relative to their hard - earned peak luminosity .
however , to really understand this event class , one will need , at the very least , to examine the @xmath13-distribution of the roman - pot protons , as well as to study the generalizations of this process to the cases where one or both of the protons undergoes soft diffraction dissociation to a low mass resonance or a high mass continuum , or to a high-@xmath3 system containing a tagging jet .
only felix would have such a capability .
in addition to this class of hard diffraction and very soft diffraction processes , there is another very interesting class of semihard diffractive phenomena associated with the conjectured fluctuation of the initial - state projectile into a transversely compact configuration , which therefore interacts with an unusually small cross section .
evidence for this is seen in vector - meson photoproduction at hera , especially @xmath14 production , which exhibits the expected rapid increase of cross section with energy . also at fermilab , diffraction dissociation of a high energy pion into dijets , with all the initial pion energy going into the dijet system ,
is being studied by experiment e791 .
exactly the same process is available at the lhc with felix , as well as a similar process where one beam proton dissociates diffractively into three jets , one for each quark .
the @xmath15 dependence of these processes is remarkable , roughly @xmath16 , because this diffractive process should occur even in central collisions , thanks to the small size of the initial configuration .
the existence of events with a very high final - state multiplicity of minijets and their associated hadrons has other implications .
the products of such interactions for the most part can be expected to explode from the initially compact collision volume in all directions at the speed of light .
because of the high multiplicity density , the time of hadronization of all these degrees of freedom will be lengthened from the usual low - energy value of 1 - 2 fm to several fm .
up to this time of hadronization , the expanding `` fireball '' containing most of the partonic collision products is arguably a rather thin spherical shell , of thickness of order a fm .
so even before hadronization there is a large interior volume of hundreds of @xmath17 , isolated from the exterior vacuum , which may evolve toward a chirally disordered vacuum .
consequently in such events there might be a large pulse of semiclassical , coherent pions of relatively low @xmath3 emitted when this false vacuum eventually decays : disoriented chiral condensate .
this is at present only a speculative possibility , although experimental searches , especially in the context of ion - ion collisions , are underway .
more generally , one may ask : if disoriented vacuum is not what is in the interior of this quasi - macroscopic fireball , what is ? if the interior vacuum " is broken into domains of various chiral orientations , then topological obstructions might lead to production of ( skyrmionic ) baryons and antibaryons of unusually low @xmath3 . and
if there is activity deep inside the light cone , no matter what it is , then this activity has eventually to be turned into emission of particles ; hence a new particle production mechanism which deserves to be studied .
it would seem that the only alternative available for the @xmath18 of new phenomena emergent from the deep interior of the light cone under these circumstances is that that region relaxes back to the true vacuum , despite its being isolated from the true vacuum by a fireball shell and despite there not being enough elapsed time for chiral orientation to be distinguished energetically from chiral disorientation .
in general , the chiral vacuum condensate is distorted in the neighborhood of impurities such as an isolated proton .
this is just the long - range pion cloud surrounding it .
the pion - cloud structure can be probed especially well in high energy @xmath19 collisions at very large impact parameters , say 2 to 3 fm .
these interactions are , because of the larger radii of interaction at the lhc , a bigger component of the cross section , and can lead to larger final - state multiplicities than found at lower energies .
perhaps here too there may be coherence in the structure of the pion emission , and this class of events may turn out to be of special interest . again a detection capability at very low @xmath3 , 100 mev and less , as possessed by felix , is important for such studies . together with these many novel phenomena , there will be new methods for experimentally tagging different kinds of events .
the impact parameter of the collision is obviously of importance to be determined event - by - event .
this is done routinely in ion - ion collisions via zero degree measurements of nuclear fragments and by the amount of transverse energy produced . at the lhc , the felix instrumentation in the forward direction allows a data - driven approach for attacking the problem by the former method .
the large yield of minijets , strongly dependent upon impact parameter , may allow the latter method , based upon transverse energy production , to be used more effectively at the lhc ( by all detector groups ) because of the stronger correlation of multiplicity with impact parameter than at lower energy .
a combination of both methods , unique to felix , is likely to be the best of all .
a second important tag available to felix is the choice of beam . by tagging on a leading neutron or @xmath20 at very low @xmath13
, one can reasonably cleanly isolate the one - pion - exchange contribution , and thereby replace the lhc @xmath19 collider with a somewhat lower energy , lower luminosity @xmath21 collider . in a similar spirit , and including @xmath22 tags , one can study collisions of any combination of @xmath23 , @xmath24 , or @xmath25 with each other .
the beam - dependence of phenomena has historically been of considerable importance , and it may find important applicability , especially with respect to questions of valence - parton structure , at the lhc energy scale .
a special case of these tags is that of a photon tag in ion - ion collisions , via forward detection of the undissociated ions .
the luminosity for @xmath26 collisions is very high , and the capability of felix to exploit this luminosity is also very high .
another class of tags which has been underutilized is the diffractive tag , where leading protons are detected via roman - pots .
as discussed above , this leads to a very rich stratum of up - to - now poorly - measured , poorly understood , but potentially important physics .
finally , there may be pattern tags .
the event structure in final states containing jets is dependent upon the color flow .
typically , neighboring jets in phase space are connected by a partonic color line ( antenna ) . for quarks ,
one antenna line emerges from the jet , for gluons two . along these antenna lines in phase space , hadronization and minijet production is enhanced .
recently the tevatron collider experiments have observed these effects . in principle
this technique might allow one in the future to identify in an individual multijet event quarks versus gluons , and even fully classify the event structure according to the color flow .
clearly such a pattern - analysis technique is very difficult , and needs to be data - driven .
felix , with full acceptance , will be optimal for making the attempt .
we now introduce the major features of the felix design .
more details can be found in the felix loi .
@xcite .
a full acceptance detector must be able to analyze the global structure event - by - event .
this means that it should run at a luminosity no greater than @xmath27 @xmath28 s@xmath29 ; that is , with less than about one interaction per crossing .
this luminosity can be achieved at i4 by means of an insertion which can be tuned from @xmath30 m to @xmath31 m without changing the magnetic elements .
there are two significant features of this insertion .
first , the final - focus quadrupoles can be placed more than 120 m from the ip , providing the space needed to accommodate the felix dipoles .
second , it is economical .
the necessary quadrupoles are already in the lhc baseline design .
the ability to tune the insertion also has several nice features . at @xmath31 m
, felix is optimized for the study of low - t elastic scattering . at @xmath32 m , where felix s luminosity is about 4 x 10@xmath33 @xmath28 s@xmath29 when the lhc is at design luminosity , the beam size in the heart of felix detector ( @xmath4 120 m ) is minimized , permitting the roman pot detectors in these locations to come as close as 3 mm to the beam . finally , @xmath34 23 m permits felix to reach luminosities as high as 2 x 10@xmath35@xmath36 .
felix will implement a kissing scheme " in which the two beams are brought together at @xmath37 in the horizontal plane and then returned to the same inner or outer arc ( see figure [ setupvfnewi ] ) . to accomplish this , we need some 67 t - m to first bring the beams together ( d2 magnets ) , and then another 67 t - m ( d1 magnets ) to make them parallel .
this has to be accomplished within the 120 m available .
both sets of magnets must be superconducting machine dipoles .
the d1 magnets must also have large bores , to accomodate both beams and to provide acceptable tracking and calorimetry apertures .
felix is fortunate that brookhaven national laboratory ( bnl ) has designed large aperture superconducting dipole magnets for use at rhic . with a coil aperture of 18 cm and a design field of 4.28 t ( felix will use them at 3.62 t ) ,
these magnets are suitable for use as d1 magnets .
bnl is committed to producing these magnets for rhic and thus will be able to supply well - understood magnets on the felix time scale .
the constraints on the d2 magnets are somewhat less severe , and several options are available . of these
, felix proposes existing superconducting dipoles constructed as prototypes for unk . while these are single aperture magnets , the 42 cm beam separation permits two unk cold masses to be assembled in a common cryostat for use as d2 magnets . in order to avoid parasitic beam - beam interactions and long - range tune shift effects
, the beams will collide with a vertical crossing angle of @xmath38 mrad . to do this while optimizing the match of the magnetic architecture to tracking and calorimetry , we propose to re - use the existing ua1 magnet , split longitudinally into two halves and equipped with new coils .
we will also build two 5 meter long , 2 t warm dipole ( d0 ) magnets . the magnetic architecture is completed by the re - use of the existing aleph solenoid , which is well - matched with the use of the ua1 magnet .
an important feature of this overall design is that the strengths of the magnetic fields increase in the forward direction , always well - matched to the typical momenta of the particles , resulting in momentum resolution which is reasonably uniform over all of phase space .
finally , we note that all magnets can be accommodated in the existing aleph collision hall and adjacent tunnels without any significant civil construction .
some 50 tracking stations , located as far as 430 m from the ip , are needed to ensure full acceptance and uniform resolution .
the positions of most of the stations ( vertical lines ) are indicated in figure [ setupvfnewi ] .
felix will instrument radially outward , emphasizing compact , near - beam tracking .
how close we will approach the beams depends on the location .
in general , we will use roman pot detectors to aggressively approach the beams wherever the location is accessible and the pot mechanical structure does not interfere with other tracking or calorimetry .
elsewhere , we propose to use fixed - radius tracking , approaching to within 2.5 cm of the beams .
the acceptance for charged particles as a function of pseudorapidity ( a ) and their momenta ( b ) ( see figure [ acc - fract ] ) is almost 100% over the entire phase space .
an important consideration is the occupancy within the tracking detectors .
high particle densities close to the beam pose a significant pattern recognition problem .
each tracking station should thus have sufficient resolution and redundancy to be able to locally reconstruct track segments .
track segments are then matched , station - to - station , resulting in a very powerful spectrometer .
these considerations lead to a common conceptual design for most felix tracking stations , based on two technologies : si pixel detectors out to radii of about 8 cm , supplemented by gas electron multiplier ( gem ) chambers at larger radii .
we are also exploring the possibility of using gem as the basis for very compact micro - tpc s .
a conceptual design for a standard " fixed - radius tracking station is shown in figure [ beam_cyl_009i ] . the same technologies will be used for a compact microvertex detector .
felix proposes four calorimeters on each side of the ip to provide complete electromagnetic and hadronic calorimetry for angles @xmath39 radian , that is , for @xmath40 .
the coverage of the calorimeters is illustrated in figure [ felixcalsi ] .
the interplay with the magnets and tracking systems is illustrated in figures [ figi ] .
the calorimeters must have superb energy and spatial resolution , and must provide the information needed to identify neutrons , electrons and gammas .
this must be done in limited space , and in a high - radiation environment .
these considerations determine the structure of the calorimeters , the choice of sampling materials and the kinds of photodetectors and front end electronics which can be used for the readout .
the ua1 endwall calorimeter , which is expected to have a radiation dose of less than 5 mrad for 10 years running , is a sampling calorimeter based on plastic scintillators and wavelength shifting fibers .
the very forward ( d0 , d1 and zero degree calorimeters ) see much higher radiation levels , and will thus be spaghetti "- type calorimeters , based on either thin capillaries filled with liquid scintillator or on quartz fibers .
all three very forward calorimeters are similar in construction , differing only in their overall dimensions .
each consists of a preshower detector , an em calorimeter , and two hadron calorimeter sections .
the basic structure of the trigger is a multi - level triggering scheme which must reduce the trigger rate from 40 mhz to a rate acceptable for data recording
. a schematic view of the trigger scheme together with the rates and the latencies of the three trigger levels is shown in figure [ trig ] .
the initial level 1 triggering must be done deadtimeless for each bunch crossing .
it must establish clean evidence of the presence of an event from the triggering constituents and produce a constituent - based trigger decision .
this is achieved with simple algorithms based upon the topology of the elements of the detectors which fired , or upon special trigger counters and energy deposited therein .
these local trigger decisions are produced near the detector front - end electronics by special circuitry . during the level 1 latency ,
the sampled data of all channels of all detectors are stored in data pipelines .
after a positive level 1 trigger decision , the output data are associated with specific bunch crossings , formatted into event fragments , and stored for subsequent filtering by the level 2 trigger .
the output rate from level i is estimated to be around 100 khz . the level 2 system performs a fast decision on the event quality , based upon data from separate detectors or portions thereof , using more sophisticated algorithms . these may be realized by a set of dedicated hardware or software processors . the output rate from level 2 is estimated to be roughly 10 khz .
the level 2 filtered data are combined into complete events by the event builder , and are filtered by the level 3 computer farm . level 3 produces the complete event - based decision , and its task is to reduce the trigger rate from 10 khz to one acceptable for data recording ( around 100 mbytes / sec ) .
we estimate the mean felix event size to be around 0.5 mbytes
. therefore the level 3 rate might be around 200 hz . the first major data set containing inelastic events used for serious physics analyses is assumed to be of order @xmath41 @xmath19 collisions , taken with essentially a minimum - bias trigger .
the only selectivity provided at trigger level would address the rejection of bunch crossings with no interactions ( or more than one interaction ) , and rejection of candidate events seriously contaminated with beam - gas background .
after such a minimum - bias run , an intermediate - luminosity run could be naturally implemented using only the level 2 trigger strategy and a choice of interaction rate compatible with the lack of rejection that level 1 would provide .
such a strategy would seem to maximize the flexibility of choice of detailed triggers , and leave to a minimum the amount which is hard - wired into the front end of the daq system .
we assume here that this intermediate - luminosity run might yield of order @xmath41 recorded events for @xmath42 @xmath19 interactions in the felix detector , i.e. have a rejection of order @xmath43 .
finally , the design run , fully implementing the level 1 and level 2 triggers , should be expected to yield @xmath41 recorded events per @xmath44 interactions in the detector .
the detailed choice of the trigger algorithms should probably be deferred for as long as possible , for at least two reasons .
one is technological ; the rate of change is so large that one should opt for as modern hardware ( and software ) as possible .
the other is the physics itself , which is evolving and will continue to evolve rather rapidly with time .
it is not easy to anticipate in detail what will be the highest - priority qcd physics to address at the time of lhc commissioning .
after the presentations of j.d .
bjorken and k. eggert about possible forward physics in pp and p - a collisions at the lhcc `` workshop on further physics topics '' ( nov .
1994 ) the lhcc committee recommended this kind of physics by noting : _ `` the lhcc noted the interest in diffraction , and expects that such studies may also form part of the lhc experimental programme .
the committee encourages interested parties to work together on an integrated approach towards this physics , whilst bearing in mind the lhc physics priorities already established '' _
when the possibility for a new interaction region in i4 became reality ( summer 1995 ) several workshops took place to discuss the layout of a full acceptance detector .
in may 1996 the lhcc defined new rules for coming activities : _ the lhcc urges that any new experimental initiative should be consistent with the restricted resources likely to be available , and combined as far as possible with one of the foreseen experiment . " _ in an oct .
1996 memorandum@xcite to the lhcc , felix responded to these new guidelines by describing , in detail , the felix set - up , strategy and financial assumptions .
the group received general encouragement from the cern management to go ahead with the letter of intent . during the spring and summer of 1997 , the felix collaboration mobilized for the preparation of the loi , which was submitted to the lhcc in august 1997 . in november 1997 , the lhcc chose to address the felix letter of intent , finding _ ... that the felix loi is not responsive to these guidelines . while the physics topics addressed by the programme proposed in the loi are of interest ( particularly the complete reconstruction of diffractive events ) , the likely costs of constructing the proposed dedicated detector and of the modifications to the lhc collider are very high in comparison with the probable physics output
. finally , the composition and strength of the collaboration seem inadequate for carrying out a strong programme addressing these physics topics .
@xcite _ the cern research board has since endorsed the decision of the lhcc .
the felix collaboration believes that these decisions were reached in a precipitate manner , with gross violation of due process .
in particular , there has been no thorough scientific review of the felix proposal .
indeed , a primary grievance is that the lhcc referees never contacted the proponents before arriving at its negative conclusion , nor were the proponents permitted to directly present the initiative in person to the committee .
important issues , including possible staging scenarios to reduce cost , and ongoing efforts to build collaboration strength , were thus never presented to the committees .
the justification of the decision which has been presented by the lhcc , the research board and by the director general clearly has to do with costs : cern is under great financial stress , and the issue of affordability is of course a very real one , an issue not unnoticed by the collaboration .
it is clear that the felix collaboration as presently constituted is far from being able to provide the resources , a point which was reinforced in private discussions by the cern director general , who has indicated that he might have considered the felix loi more seriously if the collaboration would have been stronger , and with more collaborators from cern member states .
felix has formally protested both the conclusions of the lhcc and the procedure by which the felix loi has been considered by the lhcc .
the lhcc and research board have , however , raised several critical points .
felix had originally expected to address such issues via direct interaction with the referees and the lhcc through the usual procedures . in the present situation , we believe that the best way of proceeding is to present an addendum to the felix loi to the lhcc which will contain a thorough discussion of the following points : * the complementarity of the capabilities of felix with those of the already foreseen experiments ; * staging scenarios for the felix detector ; including * the possibility to construct a preliminary version of the felix experiment at fnal , hera or rhic with a stronger collaboration to demonstrate both the technical feasibility as well as to obtain a first glimpse of the physics .
felix welcomes all additional collaborators , and will continue to expand the collaboration , with particular emphasis on cern member states .
felix will also work to identify funding sources .
finally , the entire felix collaboration will continue to work on substantive issues as outlined above , and in the loi .
in particular , we are proceeding with the design and construction of a prototype forward tracking station , as sketched in figure [ beam_cyl_009i ] , to be tested at one of the current generation of colliders .
prototypes of the various forward calorimeters are also under construction .
felix looks forward to a more positive response from the committees .
it is clear , however , that more people must soon join the effort if felix is to succeed .
many people have made invaluable contributions to felix without formally joining the collaboration .
we would particularly like to acknowledge the contributions of the approximately 100 people in this category who directly contributed to the preparation of the felix letter of intent , and who are thanked in that document by name . the felix collaboration .
`` felix , a full acceptance detector at the lhc , letter of intent '' .
cern / lhcc 97 - 45 , lhcc / i10 , 1 august 1997 . the full text of the loi is available on the web at the felix webpage http://www.cern.ch/felix j.d .
bjorken , k. eggert and c. taylor , progress report about felix , lhcc 96 - 37 , http://www.cern.ch/felix/news/memor.html lhcc minutes , cern / lhcc 97 - 61 lhcc31 | the felix collaboration has proposed the construction of a full acceptance detector for the lhc , to be located at intersection region 4 , and to be commissioned concurrently with the lhc .
the primary mission of felix is qcd : to provide comprehensive and definitive observations of a very broad range of strong - interaction processes .
this paper reviews the detector concept and performance characteristics , the physics menu , and plans for integration of felix into the collider lattice and physical environment .
the current status of the felix letter of intent is discussed . |
_ dehn surgery _ is an operation to modify a three - manifold by drilling and then regluing a solid torus .
denote by @xmath6 the resulting three - manifold via dehn surgery on a knot @xmath0 in @xmath7 along a slope @xmath8 .
two dehn surgeries along @xmath0 with distinct slopes @xmath8 and @xmath9 are called _ purely cosmetic _ if @xmath10 as oriented manifolds . in gordon s 1990 icm talk (
* conjecture 6.1 ) and kirby s problem list ( * ? ? ?
* problem 1.81 a ) , it is conjectured that two surgeries on inequivalent slopes are never purely cosmetic . we shall refer to this as the _ cosmetic surgery conjecture_. in the present paper we study purely cosmetic surgeries along knots in the three - sphere @xmath11 .
we show that for most knots @xmath0 in @xmath11 , @xmath12 as oriented manifolds for distinct slopes @xmath8 , @xmath9 .
more precisely , our main result gives a sufficient condition for a knot @xmath0 that admits no purely cosmetic surgery in terms of its jones polynomial @xmath13 .
[ main1 ] if a knot @xmath0 has either @xmath1 or @xmath2 , then @xmath12 for any two distinct slopes @xmath8 and @xmath9 . here ,
@xmath14 and @xmath15 denote the second and third order derivative of the jones polynomial of @xmath0 evaluated at @xmath16 , respectively .
note that in ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 5.1 ) , boyer and lines obtained a similar result for knots @xmath0 with @xmath17 , where @xmath18 is the normalized alexander polynomial .
we shall see that @xmath19 ( lemma [ a2 ] ) .
hence , our result can be viewed as an improvement of their result ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 5.1 ) .
previously , other known classes of knots that are shown not to admit purely cosmetic surgeries include the genus @xmath20 knots @xcite and the knots with @xmath21 @xcite , where @xmath22 is the concordance invariant defined by ozsvth - szab @xcite and rasmussen @xcite using floer homology .
theorem [ main1 ] along with the condition @xmath21 give an effective obstruction to the existence of purely cosmetic surgery .
for example , we used knotinfo @xcite , knot atlas @xcite and baldwin - gillam s table in @xcite to list all knots that have simultaneous vanishing @xmath14 , @xmath15 and @xmath22 invariant .
we get the following result : the cosmetic surgery conjecture is true for all knots with no more than @xmath3 crossings , except possibly @xmath23 @xmath24 in @xcite , ozsvth and szab gave the example of @xmath25 , which is a genus two knot with @xmath26 and @xmath27 .
@xmath28 and @xmath29 have the same heegaard floer homology , so no heegaard floer type invariant can distinguish these two surgeries .
this example shows that theorem [ main1 ] and those criteria from heegaard floer theory are independent and complementary .
the essential new ingredient in this paper is a surgery formula by lescop , which involves a knot invariant @xmath30 that satisfies a crossing change formula ( * ? ? ?
* section 7 ) . we will show that @xmath30 is actually the same as @xmath31 .
meanwhile , we also observe that @xmath30 is a finite type invariant of order @xmath5 .
this enables us to reformulate theorem [ main1 ] in term of the finite type invariants of the knot ( theorem [ cormain ] ) . as another application of theorem [ main1 ] , we prove the nonexistence of purely cosmetic surgery on certain families of two - bridge knots and whitehead doubles . along the way ,
an explicit closed formula for the canonically normalized finite type knot invariant of order 3 @xmath32 is derived for two - bridge knots in conway forms @xmath33 in proposition [ v3formula ] , which could be of independent interest .
the remaining part of this paper is organized as follows . in section 2
, we review background and properties of jones polynomial , and prove crossing change formulae for derivatives of jones polynomial . in section 3 , we define an invariant @xmath34 for rational homology spheres and then use lescop s surgery formula to prove theorem [ main1 ] . in section 4 and section 5 , we study in more detail cosmetic surgeries along two - bridge knots and whitehead doubles . * acknowledgements . *
the authors would like to thank tomotada ohtsuki and ryo nikkuni for stimulating discussions and drawing their attention to the reference @xcite@xcite . the first named author is partially supported by jsps kakenhi grant number 26400100 .
the second named author is partially supported by grant from the research grants council of hong kong special administrative region , china ( project no
. 14301215 ) .
suppose @xmath35 , @xmath36 , @xmath37 is a skein triple of links as depicted in figure [ crossings ] .
, @xmath36 , @xmath38 are identical except at one crossing.,title="fig : " ] ( -188,-10)@xmath39 ( -109,-10)@xmath36 ( -30 , -10)@xmath38 recall that the _ jones polynomial _ satisfies the skein relation @xmath40 and the _ conway polynomial _ satisfies the skein relation @xmath41 the _ normalized alexander polynomial _
@xmath42 is obtained by substituting @xmath43 into the conway polynomial . for a knot @xmath0 ,
denote @xmath44 the @xmath45-term of the conway polynomial @xmath46 .
it is not hard to see that @xmath47 . if one differentiates equations ( [ jones ] ) and ( [ conway ] ) twice and
compares the corresponding terms , one can also show that @xmath48 .
see @xcite for details . in summary
, we have : [ a2]for all knots @xmath49 , @xmath50 in @xcite , lescop defined an invariant @xmath30 for a knot @xmath0 in a homology sphere @xmath7 .
when @xmath51 , the knot invariant @xmath30 satisfies a crossing change formula @xmath52 where @xmath53 is a skein triple consisting of two knots @xmath54 and a two - component link @xmath55 ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 7.2 ) . clearly , the values of @xmath56 are uniquely determined by this crossing change formula once we fix @xmath30(@xmath57 ) for the unknot .
this gives an alternative characterization of the invariant @xmath30 for knots in @xmath11 .
the next lemma relates it to the derivatives of jones polynomial .
[ w3 ] for all knots @xmath49 , @xmath58 the main argument essentially follows from nikkuni ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 4.2 ) .
we prove the lemma by showing that @xmath31 satisfies an identical crossing change formula as equation ( [ w3def ] ) . to this end
, we differentiate the skein formula for the jones polynomial ( [ jones ] ) three times and evaluate at @xmath16 . abbreviating the jones polynomial of the skein triple @xmath59 , @xmath60 and @xmath61 by @xmath62 , @xmath63 and @xmath64 , respectively
, we obtain @xmath65 the terms on the right hand side can be expressed as * @xmath66 * @xmath67 * @xmath68 , @xmath69 * @xmath70 * @xmath71 * @xmath72 here , ( a ) and ( d ) are well - known ; ( b),(c),(e ) and ( f ) are proved by murakami @xcite . after doing substitution and simplification
, we have @xmath73 meanwhile , it follows from ( [ conway ] ) and hoste ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 1 ) that @xmath74 this enables us to further simplify @xmath75 and reduce it to the same expression as the right hand side of ( [ w3def ] ) . as @xmath76 also equals @xmath77 when @xmath0 is the unknot , @xmath31 must equal @xmath56 for all @xmath49 .
we conclude the section by remarking that both lemma [ a2 ] and lemma [ w3 ] can be seen in a simpler way from a more natural perspective .
a knot invariant @xmath78 is called a _ finite type invariant _ of order @xmath79 if it can be extended to an invariant of singular knots via a skein relation @xmath80 where @xmath81 is the knot with a transverse double point ( see figure [ crossings2 ] ) , while @xmath78 vanishes for all singular knots with @xmath82 singularities . with a transverse double point ] it follows readily from the definition that the set of finite type invariant of order @xmath77 consists of all constant functions .
one can also show that @xmath44 and @xmath14 are finite type invariants of order @xmath83 , while @xmath56 and @xmath15 are finite type invariants of order @xmath5 . as the dimension of the set of all finite type invariants of order @xmath84 and @xmath85 are two and three , respectively ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) , there has to be a linear dependence among the above knot invariants , from which one can easily deduce lemma [ a2 ] and lemma [ w3 ] .
in fact , if we denote @xmath86 and @xmath87 the finite type invariants of order @xmath83 and @xmath5 respectively normalized by the conditions that @xmath88 and @xmath89 for any knot @xmath0 and its mirror image @xmath90 and that @xmath91 for the right hand trefoil @xmath92 , then it is not difficult to see that @xmath93 and @xmath94
the goal of this section is to prove theorem [ main1 ] .
recall the following results about purely cosmetic surgery from ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 5.1 ) and ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 1.2 ) .
[ mainlemma ] suppose @xmath0 is a nontrivial knot in @xmath11 , @xmath95 are two distinct slopes such that @xmath96 as oriented manifolds
. then the following assertions are true : * @xmath27 .
* @xmath97 . * if @xmath98 , where @xmath99 are coprime integers , then @xmath100 . *
@xmath26 , where @xmath22 is the concordance invariant defined by ozsvth - szab @xcite and rasmussen @xcite .
our new input for the cosmetic surgery problem is lescop s @xmath34 invariant which , roughly speaking , is the degree @xmath83 part of the kontsevich - kuperberg - thurston invariant of rational homology spheres @xcite . like the famous le - murakami - ohtsuki invariant
, the kontsevich - kuperberg - thurston invariant is universal among finite type invariants for homology spheres @xcite@xcite@xcite .
see also ohtsuki @xcite for the connection to perturbative and quantum invariants of three - manifolds .
we briefly review the construction .
jacobi diagram _ is a graph without simple loop whose vertices all have valency @xmath5 .
the degree of a jacobi diagram is defined to be half of the total number of vertices of the diagram . if we denote by @xmath101 the vector space generated by degree @xmath79 jacobi diagrams subject to certain equivalent relations as and ihx , then the degree @xmath79
part @xmath102 of the kontsevich - kuperberg - thurston invariant takes its value in @xmath101 . simple argument in combinatorics implies that * @xmath103 is an @xmath20-dimensional vector space generated by the jacobi diagram @xmath104{tata.pdf } } $ ] * @xmath105 is a @xmath83-dimensional vector space generated by the jacobi diagrams @xmath104{tata.pdf } } \ ; { \includegraphics[bb= 0 50 163 160 , scale=.09]{tata.pdf } } $ ] and @xmath106{tetra.pdf } } $ ] many interesting real invariants of rational homology spheres can be recovered from the kontsevich - kuperberg - thurston invariant @xmath107 by composing a linear form on the space of jacobi diagrams . in the simplest case ,
the casson - walker invariant @xmath108 is @xmath109 , where @xmath110{tata.pdf } } ) = 2 $ ] .
we shall concentrate on the case of the degree @xmath83 invariant @xmath111 , where @xmath112{tetra.pdf } } ) = 1 $ ] and @xmath113{tata.pdf } } \ ; { \includegraphics[bb= 0 50 163 160 , scale=.09]{tata.pdf } } ) = 0 $ ] . the following surgery formula for @xmath34
is proved by lescop and will play a central role in the proof of our main result .
* theorem 7.1 ) [ lescopsurgery ] the invariant @xmath34 satisfies the surgery formula @xmath114 for all knots @xmath115 . here
, @xmath44 is the @xmath45-coefficient of @xmath46 , and @xmath116 is the lens space obtained by @xmath117 surgery on the unknot .
then @xmath56 is a knot invariant , which was shown earlier in lemma [ w3 ] to be equal to @xmath31 for @xmath49 .
the terms @xmath118 and @xmath119 are both explicitly defined in @xcite , but they will not be needed for our purpose . for the moment , we make the following simple observation . [ w3cosmetic ] suppose @xmath0 is a knot in @xmath11 with @xmath120 , and @xmath121 are nonzero integers satisfying @xmath122
. then @xmath123 if and only if @xmath124 .
we apply the surgery formula in theorem [ lescopsurgery ] .
note that the first and third terms of the right hand side are clearly equal for @xmath117 and @xmath125 surgery .
next , recall the well - known theorem that two lens spaces @xmath126 and @xmath127 are equivalent up to orientation - preserving homeomorphisms if and only if @xmath128 . in particular
, this implies the lens spaces @xmath129 as oriented manifolds if @xmath130 , so their @xmath34 invariants are obviously the same .
consequently , @xmath131 and the statement follows readily .
in light of theorem [ mainlemma ] , we only need to consider the case when @xmath27 and @xmath132 , for otherwise , the pair of manifolds @xmath133 and @xmath134 will be non - homeomorphic as oriented manifolds . thus @xmath135 .
if we now assume @xmath136 , then lemma [ w3 ] implies that @xmath137
. we can then apply proposition [ w3cosmetic ] and conclude that @xmath138 .
consequently , @xmath139 . given ( [ v2 ] ) and ( [ v3 ] ) , theorem [ main1 ] can be stated in the following equivalent way , which is particularly useful in the case where it is easier to calculate the finite type invariant @xmath87 ( or equivalently @xmath30 ) than the jones polynomial .
[ cormain ] if a knot @xmath0 has the finite type invariant @xmath140 or @xmath141 , then @xmath12 for any two distinct slopes @xmath8 and @xmath9 .
in this section , we derive an explicit formula for @xmath87 and use it to study the cosmetic surgery problem for two - bridge knots . following the presentation of ( * ? ? ? * section 2.1 ) , we sketch the basic properties and notations for two - bridge knots . every two - bridge knot can be represented by a rational number @xmath142 for some odd integer @xmath143 and even integer @xmath144 . if we write this number as a continued fraction with even entries and of even length @xmath145=2b_1 + \cfrac{1}{2c_1 + \cfrac{1}{\cdots + \cfrac{1}{2b_m + \cfrac{1}{2c_m } } } } \ ] ] for some nonzero integers @xmath146 s and @xmath147 s , then we obtain the _ conway form _ @xmath148 of the two - bridge knot , which is a special knot diagram as depicted in figure [ conwayform ] .
we will write @xmath149 for the knot of conway form @xmath148 .
the genus of @xmath150 is @xmath151 ; and conversely , every two - bridge knot of genus @xmath151 has such a representation . of a two bridge knot .
in the figure , there are @xmath152 positive ( resp .
negative ) full - twists if @xmath153 ( resp @xmath154 ) , and there are @xmath155 negative ( resp .
positive ) full - twists if @xmath156 ( resp .
@xmath157 ) for @xmath158 . ]
burde obtained the following formula for @xmath159 , the @xmath45-coefficient of the conway polynomial of @xmath150 .
* proposition 5.1)[burde ] for the two - bridge knot @xmath149 , the @xmath45-coefficient of the conway polynomial is given by @xmath160 the above formula can be proved by recursively applying equation ( [ a2crossingchange ] ) .
the similar idea can be used to find an analogous formula for @xmath30 , which is the main task of the next few lemmas .
[ w3recursivelemma ] the invariant @xmath30 satisfies the recursive formula @xmath161 this follows from a direct application of the crossing change formula ( [ w3def ] ) at the rightmost crossing in figure [ conwayform ] , and the observation that both @xmath162 and @xmath163 are the unknot with @xmath164 .
[ w3lemma2 ] the invariant @xmath30 satisfies the recursive formula @xmath165 we first prove the lemma for @xmath166 .
we repeatedly apply lemma [ w3recursivelemma ] until @xmath167 is reduced to @xmath77 .
note that the knot @xmath168 can be isotoped to @xmath169 by untwisting the far - right @xmath170 full twists .
therefore , @xmath171 now , the lemma follows from substituting @xmath172 which is an immediate corollary of proposition [ burde ] .
the case when @xmath173 is proved analogously .
finally , applying lemma [ w3lemma2 ] and induction on @xmath151 , we obtain an explicit formula for @xmath30 , and consequently also for @xmath87 .
[ v3formula ] @xmath174 we use induction on @xmath151 .
for the base case @xmath175 , lemma [ w3lemma2 ] readily implies that @xmath176 so @xmath177 satisfies the formula .
next we prove that if the formula holds for @xmath178 , then it also holds for @xmath33 .
it suffices to show that @xmath179 where @xmath180 the above identity can be verified from tedious yet elementary algebra .
we omit the computation here .
for the rest of the section , we apply theorem [ cormain ] and proposition [ v3formula ] to study the cosmetic surgery problems for the two - bridge knots of genus @xmath83 and @xmath5 , which correspond to the conway form @xmath181 and @xmath182 , respectively .
note that the cosmetic surgery conjecture for genus one knot is already settled by wang @xcite .
if a genus @xmath83 two - bridge knot @xmath181 is not of the form @xmath183 for some integers @xmath184 , then it does not admit purely cosmetic surgeries .
suppose there are purely cosmetic surgeries for the knot @xmath181 .
theorem [ cormain ] implies that @xmath185 and @xmath186 where the formula for @xmath187 and @xmath87 follows from proposition [ burde ] and proposition [ v3formula ] , respectively . from equation ( [ v2genus2 ] )
, we see @xmath188 and @xmath189 , which was then substituted into the second and the third terms of equation ( [ v3genus2 ] ) , and gives @xmath190 hence , @xmath191 . plugging this identity back to equation ( [ v2genus2 ] )
, we see @xmath192 . as a result
, the two - bridge knot @xmath181 can be written as @xmath183 for some integers @xmath167 and @xmath193 .
we can perform a similar computation for a genus @xmath5 two - bridge knot @xmath182 . by proposition [ v3formula ] , @xmath194 in particular
, we see @xmath195 consequently , theorem [ cormain ] implies the family of two - bridge knots @xmath196 does not admit purely cosmetic surgeries . as explained in @xcite , both @xmath197 and @xmath198
are @xmath77 for the knot @xmath196 .
hence , purely cosmetic surgery could not be ruled out by previously known results from theorem [ mainlemma ] .
we are devoted to @xmath199 in this section , where @xmath199 denotes the satellite of @xmath0 for which the pattern is a positive - clasped twist knot with @xmath79 twists .
the knot @xmath199 is called the _ positive @xmath79-twisted whitehead double _ of a knot @xmath0 .
see figure [ whitehead ] for an illustration .
we apply the crossing change formula ( [ w3def ] ) at either one of the crossings of the clasps .
note that @xmath204 , @xmath205 is the unknot , and @xmath206 .
the classical formula for the alexander polynomial of a satellite knot implies that @xmath207 , from which we compute @xmath208 also observe that @xmath209 .
therefore , @xmath210 and so @xmath211 since the invariant @xmath212 , the whitehead double @xmath213 does not admit purely cosmetic surgeries if @xmath214 . when @xmath215 , proposition [ v3whitehead ] gives @xmath216 .
hence , theorem [ cormain ] immediately implies the following corollary .
there is no purely cosmetic surgery for the positive @xmath79-twisted whitehead double @xmath213 for @xmath214 .
moreover , if @xmath217 , then there is no purely cosmetic surgery for the untwisted whitehead double @xmath218 . | we show that two dehn surgeries on a knot @xmath0 never yield manifolds that are homeomorphic as oriented manifolds if @xmath1 or @xmath2 . as an application
, we verify the cosmetic surgery conjecture for all knots with no more than @xmath3 crossings except for three @xmath4-crossing knots and five @xmath3-crossing knots .
we also compute the finite type invariant of order @xmath5 for two - bridge knots and whitehead doubles , from which we prove several nonexistence results of purely cosmetic surgery . |
fifty years after the pioneering discoveries of fermi , pasta and ulam @xcite , the paradigm of coherent structures has proven itself one of the most fruitful ones of nonlinear science @xcite .
fronts , solitons , solitary waves , breathers , or vortices are instances of such coherent structures of relevance in a plethora of applications in very different fields .
one of the chief reasons that gives all these nonlinear excitations their paradigmatic character is their robustness and stability : generally speaking , when systems supporting these structures are perturbed , the structures continue to exist , albeit with modifications in their parameters or small changes in shape ( see @xcite for reviews ) .
this property that all these objects ( approximately ) retain their identity allows one to rely on them to interpret the effects of perturbations on general solutions of the corresponding models . among the different types of coherent structures one can encounter , topological solitons are particularly robust due to the existence of a conserved quantity named topological charge .
objects in this class are , e.g. , kinks or vortices and can be found in systems ranging from josephson superconducting devices to fluid dynamics .
a particularly important representative of models supporting topological solitons is the family of nonlinear klein - gordon equations @xcite , whose expression is @xmath0 specially important cases of this equation occur when @xmath1 , giving the so - called @xmath2 equation , and when @xmath3 , leading to the sine - gordon ( sg ) equation , which is one of the few examples of fully integrable systems @xcite .
indeed , for any initial data the solution of the sine - gordon equation can be expressed as a sum of kinks ( and antikinks ) , breathers , and linear waves . here
we focus on kink solitons , which have the form @xmath4 @xmath5 being a free parameter that specifies the kink velocity .
the topological character of these solutions arises from the fact that they join two minima of the potential @xmath6 , and therefore they can not be destroyed in an infinite system .
our other example , the @xmath2 equation , is not integrable , but supports topological , kink - like solutions as well , given by @xmath7 it is by now well established , already from pioneering works in the seventies @xcite that both types of kinks behave , under a wide class of perturbations , like relativistic particles .
the relativistic character arises from the lorentz invariance of their dynamics , see eq .
( [ kg ] ) , and implies that there is a maximum propagation velocity for kinks ( 1 in our units ) and their characteristic width decreases with velocity .
indeed , even behaving as particles , kinks do have a characteristic width ; however , for most perturbations , that is not a relevant parameter and one can consider kinks as point - like particles .
this is not the case when the perturbation itself gives rise to certain length scale of its own , a situation that leads to the phenomenon of length - scale competition , first reported in @xcite ( see @xcite for a review ) .
this phenomenon is nothing but an instability that occurs when the length of a coherent structure approximately matches that of the perturbation : then , small values of the perturbation amplitude are enough to cause large modifications or even destroy the structure .
thus , in @xcite , the perturbation considered was sinusoidal , of the form @xmath8 where @xmath9 and @xmath10 are arbitrary parameters .
the structures studied here were breathers , which are exact solutions of the sine - gordon equation with a time dependent , oscillatory mode ( hence the name ` breather ' ) and that can be seen as a bound kink - antikink pair .
it was found that small @xmath10 values , i.e. , long perturbation wavelengths , induced breathers to move as particles in the sinusoidal potential , whereas large @xmath10 or equivalent short perturbation wavelengths , were unnoticed by the breathers . in the intermediate regime , where length scales were comparable , breathers ( which are non topological ) were destroyed .
as breathers are quite complicated objects , the issue of length scale competition was addressed for kinks in @xcite . in this case , kinks were not destroyed because of the conservation of the topological charge , but length scale competition was present in a different way : keeping all other parameters of the equation constant , it was observed that kinks could not propagate when the perturbation wavelength was of the order of their width . in all other ( smaller or larger ) perturbations ,
propagation was possible and , once again , easily understood in terms of an effective point - like particle .
although a explanation of this phenomenon was provided in @xcite in terms of a ( numerical ) linear stability analysis and the radiation emitted by the kink , it was not a fully satisfactory argument for two reasons : first , the role of the kink width was not at all transparent , and second , there were no simple analytical results .
these are important issues because length scale competition is a rather general phenomenon : it has been observed in different models ( such as the nonlinear schrdinger equation @xcite ) or with other perturbations , including random ones @xcite .
therefore , having a simple , clear explanation of length scale competition will be immediately of use in those other contexts .
the aim of the present paper is to show that length scale competition can be understood through a collective coordinate approximation .
collective coordinate approaches were introduced in @xcite to describe kinks as particles ( see @xcite for a very large number of different techniques and applications of this idea ) .
although the original approximation was to reduce the equation of motion for the kink to an ordinary differential equation for a time dependent , collective coordinate which was identified with its center , it is being realized lately that other collective coordinates can be used instead of or in addition to the kink center .
one of the most natural additional coordinates to consider is the kink width , an approach that has already produced new and unexpected results such as the existence of anomalous resonances @xcite or the rectification of ac drivings @xcite .
there are also cases in which one has to consider three or more collective coordinates ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) .
it is only natural then to apply these extended collective coordinate approximations to the problem of length scale competition , in search for the analytical explanation needed . as we will see below ,
taking into account the kink width dependence on time is indeed enough to reproduce the phenomenology observed in the numerical simulations .
our approach is detailed in the next section , whereas in sec .
3 we collect our results and discuss our conclusions .
we now present our collective coordinate approach to the problem of length scale competition for kinks @xcite . we will use the lagrangian based approach developed in @xcite , which is very simple and direct .
equivalent results can be obtained with the so - called generalized travelling wave _ ansatz _
@xcite , somewhat more involved in terms of computation but valid even for systems that can not be described in terms of a lagrangian .
let us consider the generically perturbed klein - gordon equation : @xmath11 the starting point of our approach is the lagrangian for the above equation , which is given by @xmath12 as stated above , we now focus on the behaviour of kink excitations of the form and .
to do so , we will use a two collective coordinates approach by substituting the _ ansatz _ @xmath13 in the lagrangian of the @xmath2 system , and @xmath14 in @xmath15 , where @xmath16 and @xmath17 and @xmath18 are two collective coordinates that represent the position of the center and the width of the kink , respectively . substituting the expresions and in the lagrangian with our perturbation , @xmath19 and @xmath20
, we obtain an expresion of the lagrangian in terms of @xmath21 and @xmath22 , @xmath23 where , for the @xmath2 system , @xmath24 , @xmath25 and @xmath26 , and for the sg system , @xmath27 , @xmath28 and @xmath29 , and @xmath30 which is @xmath31 for @xmath2 and @xmath32 for the sg model .
we note that the effect of a spatially periodic perturbation like the one considered here was studied for the @xmath2 model in @xcite , although the authors were not aware of the existence of length scale competition in this system and focused on unrelated issues .
the equations of motion of @xmath21 and @xmath22 can now be obtained using the lagrange equations , @xmath33 where @xmath34 stands for the collective coordinates @xmath21 and @xmath22 .
the ode system for @xmath21 and @xmath22 is , finally , @xmath35 where @xmath36 and @xmath37 .
different behaviours of @xmath17 for different values of @xmath10 for @xmath38 , @xmath39 , @xmath40 , @xmath41 and @xmath42 in the a ) @xmath2 model , b ) sg model .
, title="fig:",width=226 ] different behaviours of @xmath17 for different values of @xmath10 for @xmath38 , @xmath39 , @xmath40 , @xmath41 and @xmath42 in the a ) @xmath2 model , b ) sg model .
, title="fig:",width=226 ] the equations above are our final result for the dynamics of sg and @xmath2 kinks in terms of their center and width . as can be seen , they are quite complicated equations and we have not been able to solve them analytically .
therefore , in order to check whether or not they predict the appearance of length scale competition , we have integrated them numerically using a runge - kutta scheme @xcite . the simulation results for different values of @xmath10 , @xmath39 are in fig .
[ fig : lengthscale ] .
we have taken @xmath38 in order to compare with the numerical results for the sg equation in @xcite .
the plots present already the physical variable @xmath17 , i.e. , the position of the center of the kink .
as we may see , the agreement with the results in @xcite is excellent for the sg equation ( cf . figs . 7 and 8 in @xcite ) : for small and large wavelengths the kink , initially at the top of one of the maxima of the perturbation , travels freely ; however , for intermediate scales , the kink is trapped and even moves backward for a while . as previous works @xcite on the same problem for the @xmath2 equation did not touch upon this issue , we have carried out numerical simulations , also using a runge - kutta scheme , of the full partial differential equation .
the results , presented in fig . [ fig : simphi4 ] , confirm once again the agreement with the prediction of the collective coordinate approach .
we see that for @xmath43 , the value at which the collective coordinate prediction is more dramatic , the kink is trapped at the first potential well , indicating that for that value the length scale competition phenomenon is close to its maximum effect .
different behaviours of @xmath17 for different values of @xmath10 for @xmath38 , @xmath39 , @xmath40 as obtained from numerical simulations of the full @xmath2 model .
, width=264 ] interestingly , a more detailed analysis of fig .
[ fig : simphi4 ] shows two different kink trapping processes . in agreement with the collective coordinate prediction , for @xmath44
we see that the kink is trapped very early , after having travelled a few potential wells at most .
this is the length scale competition regime .
however , there is an additional trapping mechanism : as is well known @xcite , kinks travelling on a periodic potential emit radiation .
this process leads to a gradual slowing down of the kink until it is finally unable to proceed over a further potential well .
this takes place at a much slower rate than length scale competition and hence the kink is stopped after travelling a larger distance in the system .
the radiation emission as observed in the simulation is smoother than in the length scale competition trapping .
as we have seen in the preceding section , a collective coordinate approach in terms of the kink center and width is able to explain in a correct quantitative manner the phenomenon of length scale competition , observed in numerical simulations earlier for the sg equation with a spatially periodic perturbation @xcite .
the structure of the equations makes it clear the necessity for a second collective coordinate ; imposing @xmath45 constant , we recover the equation for the center already derived in @xcite , which shows no sign at all of length scale competition , predicting effective particle - like behavior for all @xmath10 .
the validity of this approach has been also shown in the context of the @xmath2 equation , which had not been considered before from this viewpoint . in spite of the fact that the collective coordinate equations can not be solved analytically , they provide us with the physical explanation of the phenomenon in so far as they reveal the key role played by
the width changes with time and their coupling with the translational degree of freedom .
it is interesting to reconsider the analysis carried out in @xcite of length scale competition through a numerical linear stability analysis . in that previous work
, it was argued that the instability arose because , for the relevant perturbation wavelengths , radiation modes moved below the lowest phonon band , inducing the emission of long wavelength radiation which in turn led to the trapping of the kink .
it was also argued that those modes became internal modes , i.e. , kink shape deformation modes in the process .
the approach presented here is a much more simple way to account for these phonon effects : indeed , as was shown by quintero and kevrekidis @xcite , ( odd ) phonons do give rise to width oscillations very similar to those induced by an internal mode @xcite .
we are confident that what our perturbation technique is making clear is precisely the result of the action of those phonons , summarized in our approach in the width variable @xmath18 .
the case for the @xmath2 equation is sligthly different : whereas the sg kink does not have an internal mode @xcite and @xmath18 is hence a collective description of phonon modes , the @xmath2 kink possesses an intrinsic internal mode that is easily excited by different mechanisms ( such as interaction with inhomogeneities , @xcite ) .
therefore , one would expect that for the @xmath2 equation the effect of a perturbation of a given length is more dramatic than for the sg model , as indeed is the case : see fig .
[ fig : lengthscale ] for a comparison , showing that the kink is trapped for a wider range of values of @xmath10 in the @xmath2 equation .
remarkably , the present and previous results using this two collective coordinate approach , and particularly their interpretation in terms of phonons , suggest that this technique could be something like a ` second order collective coordinate perturbation theory ' , the width degree of freedom playing the role of second order term .
we believe it is appealing to explore this possibility from a more formal viewpoint ; if this idea is correct , then one could think of a scheme for adding in an standard way as many collective coordinates as needed to achieve the required accuracy .
progress in that direction would provide the necessary mathematical grounds for this fruitful approximate technique . finally , some comments are in order regarding the applicability of our results .
we believe that the collective coordinate approach may also explain the length scale competition for breathers , that so far lacks any explanation . for this problem , the approach would likely involve the breather center and its frequency , as this magnitude controls the kink width when the kink is at rest .
of course , such an _ ansatz _ would only be valid for the breather initially at rest , and the description of the dynamical problem would be more involved , needing perhaps more collective coordinates ( such as an independent width ) .
if this approach succeeds , one can then extend it to other breather like excitations , such as nonlinear schrdinger solitons or intrinsic localized modes .
work along these lines is in progress .
on the other hand , it would be very important to have an experimental setup where all these conclusions could be tested in the real world .
a modified josephson junction device has been proposed recently @xcite where the role of the kink width is crucial in determining the performance and dynamical characteristics .
we believe that a straightforward modification of that design would permit an experimental verification of our results .
we hope that this paper stimulates research in that direction .
we thank niurka r. quintero and elas zamora - sillero for discussions on the lagrangian formalism introduced in @xcite .
this work has been supported by the ministerio de ciencia y tecnologa of spain through grant bfm2003 - 07749-c05 - 01 .
is supported by a fellowship from the consejera de educacin de la comunidad autnoma de madrid and the fondo social europeo .
88 e. fermi , j. r. pasta , and s. m. ulam , los alamos scientific laboratory report no .
la - ur-1940 ( 1955 ) ; reprinted in _ nonlinear wave motion _ , a. c. newell , ed .
, ( american mathematical society , providence , 1974 ) .
a. c. scott , _ nonlinear science _
( oxford university press , oxford , 1999 ) .
s. kivshar and b. a. malomed , rev .
phys . * 61 * , 763 ( 1989 ) .
a. snchez and l. vzquez , int .
j. mod .
b * 5 * , 2825 ( 1991 ) .
m. j. ablowitz , d. j. kaup , a. c. newell , and h. segur , phys .
lett . * 30 * , 1262 ( 1973 ) .
d. w. mclaughlin and a. c. scott , phys .
a * 18 * , 1652 ( 1978 ) .
m. b. fogel , s. e. trullinger , a. r. bishop , and j. a. krumhansl , phys .
lett . * 36 * , 1411 ( 1976 ) ; phys .
b * 15 * , 1578 ( 1976 ) .
a. snchez , r. scharf , a. r. bishop , and l. vzquez , phys .
a * 45 * , 6031 ( 1992 ) .
a. snchez and a. r. bishop , siam review * 40 * , 579 ( 1998 ) .
a. snchez , a. r. bishop , and f. domnguez - adame , phys .
e * 49 * , 4603 ( 1994 ) .
r. scharf and a. r. bishop , phys .
e * 47 * , 1375 ( 1993 ) .
j. garnier , phys .
b * 68 * , 134302 ( 2003 ) .
n. r. quintero , a. snchez , and f. g. mertens .
84 * , 871 ( 2000 ) ; phys .
e * 62 * , 5695 ( 2000 ) . l. morales - molina , n. r. quintero , f. g. mertens , and a. snchez . phys . rev .
91 , 234102 ( 2003 ) .
m. meister , f. g. mertens , and a. snchez eur .
j. b * 20 * , 405 ( 2001 ) n. r. quintero and e. zamora - sillero , physica d * 197 * , 63 ( 2004 ) . h. j. schnitzer , and a. r. bishop , phys . rev .
b * 56 * , 2510 ( 1997 ) .
z. fei , v. v. konotop , m. peyrard , and l. vzquez , phys .
e * 48 * , 548 ( 1993 ) .
w. h. press , s. a. teukolsky , w. t. vetterling , and b. p. flannery , _ numerical recipes in c _ ,
2nd edition ( cambridge university press , new york , 1992 ) .
n. r. quintero and p. g. kevrekidis , phys .
rev.e * 64 * , 056608 ( 2001 ) .
n. r. quintero , a. snchez , and f. g. mertens , phys .
rev.e * 62 * , r60 ( 2000 ) .
d. k. campbell , j. f. schonfeld , and c. a. wingate , physica d * 9 * , 1 ( 1983 ) .
z. fei , yu . s. kivshar , and l. vzquez , phys .
a * 46 * , 5214 ( 1992 ) .
l. morales - molina , f. g. mertens , and a. snchez .
. j. b bf 37 , 79 ( 2004 ) . | we study the phenomenon of length scale competition , an instability of solitons and other coherent structures that takes place when their size is of the same order of some characteristic scale of the system in which they propagate .
working on the framework of nonlinear klein - gordon models as a paradigmatic example , we show that this instability can be understood by means of a collective coordinate approach in terms of soliton position and width . as a consequence ,
we provide a quantitative , natural explanation of the phenomenon in much simpler terms than any previous treatment of the problem .
our technique allows to study the existence of length scale competition in most soliton bearing nonlinear models and can be extended to coherent structures with more degrees of freedom , such as breathers .
* lead paragraph * + * solitons , solitary waves , vortices and other coherent structures possess , generally speaking , a characteristic length or size .
one important feature of these coherent structures , which usually are exact solutions of certain nonlinear models , is their robustness when the corresponding models are perturbed in different ways .
a case relevant in many real applications is that of space - dependent perturbations , that may or may not have their own typical length scale .
interestingly , in the latter case , it has been known for a decade that when the perturbation length scale is comparable to the size of the coherent structures , the effects of even very small perturbing terms are dramatically enhanced .
although some analytical approaches have shed some light of the mechanisms for this special instability , a clear - cut , simple explanation was lacking . in this paper , we show how such explanation arises by means of a reduction of degrees of freedom through the so - called collective coordinate technique .
the analytical results have a straightforward physical interpretation in terms of a resonant - like phenomenon .
notwithstanding the fact that we work on a specific class of soliton - bearing equations , our approach is readily generalizable to other equations and/or types of coherent structures . * |
the strong gravitational lensing has many astrophysical and cosmological applications ( see e.g. @xcite and references therein for a review ) .
the qualitative understanding of the majority of multi - image configurations attributed to strong lensing can usually be based on a model of single galaxy - lens in a uniform universe .
the quantitative description requires more complicated models , starting with so called _ external shear _ @xcite , invoking a galaxy cluster @xcite , or taking into account another galaxy in the lens vicinity ( @xcite , @xcite ) .
the influence of the mass distribution in the lens vicinity and along the line of sight has been investigated by many authors ( @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite to cite few ) .
photometric survey of several strong lens surroundings @xcite shows that many of them lie in poor groups of galaxies and that other groups near the line of sight are not uncommon .
spectroscopic observations ( @xcite , @xcite ) give the distribution of the galaxies along the line of sight and allow more detailed study of their grouping and influence on strong lensing in several cases .
the inclusion of the directly observed objects around the lens in modeling greatly improves the quality of fits .
@xcite investigate theoretically the problem of the main galaxy close neighbours constructing a poor group of galaxies .
they check the image configurations corresponding to various source positions behind the group , different group members playing the role of the main lens , and others playing the role of the environment .
they thoroughly analyze the influence of lens environment on the values of the fitted parameters .
they show that by neglecting the objects around the lens one introduces bias to the fitted parameter values , which plays the role of a systematic error .
in this paper we continue our investigation of the environmental and line of sight effects which influence the action of strong gravitational lenses using the results of the millennium simulation @xcite from its online database @xcite .
we basically follow the approach of @xcite ( hereafter paper i ) including also the time delays in our considerations .
we attempt to quantify the influence of matter in the strong lens environment ( _ env _ ) and along the line of sight ( _ los _ ) on the results of modeling multiple image configurations with measured time delays .
we simulate the propagation of light in four different ways . in the most simplified approach
we include only the isolated strong lens in a uniform universe model .
other approaches include the lens environment , or the matter along the line of sight , or both . using each of the approaches we simulate many multiple image configurations , and attempt to fit them with the same kind of simplified model .
the rate of failure ( i.e. the fraction of unsuccessful fits in each approach ) measures the influence of the environment and the line of sight ( or each of them separately ) on the strong lens .
the differences between the fitted values of model parameters and the parameters used in simulations give the estimate of the systematic errors introduced by the environment and the line of sight .
our goal is the comparison of various effects related to light propagation , not the improvement of strong lens modeling . in sec . 2 we describe our approaches to light propagation .
presents tools used to compare different models and the results of such comparison .
discussion and conclusions follow in sec . 4 .
the multiplane approach to gravitational lensing ( e.g. @xcite ; @xcite ) using the results of the millennium simulation @xcite and the non - singular isothermal ellipsoids ( nsie ) as models for individual halos ( @xcite ; @xcite ) is described in paper i. here we augment it with the description of relative time delays .
the evolution of the matter distribution is given by the millennium _ snapshots _ which correspond to several discrete epochs with given redshifts @xmath2 .
we assume that for @xmath3 the millennium cube of epoch @xmath4 adequately describes matter distribution .
thus a ray crosses perpendicular layers of matter of defined thickness cut from the millennium cubes of different epochs .
the cubes are randomly shifted and rotated to avoid effects of periodic boundary conditions of the simulation @xcite .
since there are several matter layers between the source at @xmath5 and the observer , they can be treated as thin , and may be represented as surface mass distributions projected into their middle planes .
the matter content of each cube is described as a _ background _ component representing matter density averaged on @xmath6 cells plus gravitationally bound haloes given by @xcite and @xcite . for the background
we calculate the gravitational force in 3d and then use its component perpendicular to a ray to obtain the deflection angle . for ray beams with the small opening angles of @xmath7 the major influence of each background cube is an almost constant deflection angle @xmath8 plus its small variation , which we describe as the action of the background convergence @xmath9 and shear @xmath10 , @xmath11 .
( these parameters are defined for each layer separately . )
each projected halo is represented as a difference between two nsie distributions with the same characteristic deflection angles @xmath12 , axis ratios @xmath13 , and position angles , but different values of core radii @xmath14 , which makes its mass finite : @xmath15 ( compare paper i ) .
the above formula gives the value of characteristic deflection @xmath12 for a halo of given mass and virial radius @xmath16 .
( we use @xmath14 , which validates the approximation ) .
we consider axis ratios which are distributed within @xmath17 with maximum probability at @xmath18 , loosely resembling the results of @xcite .
the position angles in the sky are random .
since the _ background _ contains the whole mass , including mass of haloes , the latter must be compensated by some negative density distribution .
we use the constant surface mass circular disk of radius @xmath19 ( @xmath20 ) for this purpose ( for details see paper i ) .
a compensated halo does not deflect rays outside its @xmath19 radius , so only a finite number of haloes has to be included in calculations .
a ray coming to the observer from the direction @xmath21 in the synthetic sky , crosses the @xmath22-th layer ( @xmath23 ) at some position @xmath24 given as @xcite : @xmath25 where @xmath26 is the angular diameter distance as measured by an observer at epoch @xmath27 to the source at epoch @xmath22 , @xmath28 - the angular diameter distance to the same source measured by a present ( @xmath29 ) observer . in calculations we use comoving distances , which in a flat cosmological model simplifies some of the expressions , but we skip these technical details here .
we also apply more efficient recurrent formula of @xcite , equivalent to the above equation . knowing the light path
, one can calculate the _ geometric _ part of the relative time delay @xmath30 ( as compared with the propagation time along a null geodesics in a uniform universe model ) using the formula @xcite : @xmath31 where we consider a ray coming to the observer from the direction @xmath21 ( which defines its earlier path , so all @xmath32 are known ) and the factors @xmath33 represent time dilatation .
the deflection in each layer can be calculated as a gradient of the deflection potential , which is also a measure of _ gravitational _ time delay @xmath34 @xcite : @xmath35 the potential is defined up to a constant @xmath36 .
the cumulative _ gravitational _ time delay after crossing all the layers is : @xmath37 where again @xmath21 defines the path and we account for time dilatation .
finally : @xmath38 the above expression contains unknown additive constant .
only the difference in calculated time delays between two rays can have a clear physical meaning .
our backward ray shooting covers separate and randomly chosen _
maps _ in the synthetic sky @xmath39 in size . to propagate a wide beam of this size
we need deflection angles in overlapping regions in all layers . for this purpose
we calculate and store the deflection angles for the @xmath40 evenly spaced positions of interest in each layer .
similarly we store the _ gravitational _ time delays caused by each layer . with the help of interpolations
one can obtain deflections and time delays for any position in any layer . the deflection angle and the deflection potential
are given by analytical formulae and for each grid point eq .
[ gradient ] holds exactly .
interpolations and finite differencing used in the numerical approach make this relation approximate . to check the selfconsistency of our methods we have numerically calculated the rotation of the deflection angle on the grid , for different positions , maps , and differencing spacings .
the rotation of the deflection field is present , but its level is fairly low : @xmath41 , where the averaging is over many positions within a single map .
the result holds for maps at different redshifts for spacings of @xmath42 . for spacings of @xmath43
the rotation is two times more important .
we choose to calculate the strong lens effects in the nonuniform universe model for sources at the redshift @xmath0 .
we examine all haloes within the beam up to this redshift ( typically few thousands of them ) as lens candidates estimating their einstein ring radii @xmath44 .
we choose ten lenses with the largest einstein rings as most likely to produce multiple images of a randomly positioned source and investigate them in detail .
when investigating multiple image properties we need zoomed maps of smaller parts of the sky . for better resolution
we use finer grids with deflections interpolated from previous calculations with the help of bi - cubic spline , so the interpolated deflection derivatives are continuous .
we expect the multiple images to lie within few einstein radii from the halo centre .
we check for the presence of other haloes inside the circle of the radius @xmath45 surrounding a dominating lens .
if they are present we enlarge the region of interest including @xmath45 zones around all companions .
finally we repeat backward ray shooting inside a square on the sky overlapping the region of interest .
the fine grids giving the deflection angles in consecutive layers encompass still larger areas , so one can follow majority of rays deflected off the main region .
we keep control of the rays and if some of them leave the mapped region , we neglect the related lens in further considerations .
we store the result of the ray shooting as a vector and scalar arrays : @xmath46 where @xmath47 gives the positions in the source plane of rays apparently coming from the directions @xmath48 on the observer s sky .
similarly @xmath49 denotes the total ( gravitational plus geometric ) time delay along the ray coming from the same direction .
superscripts @xmath50 , @xmath51 enumerate the rays .
calculations for each ray are based on eq.(2 ) and eq .
( 6 ) respectively . to estimate the importance of the influence of the matter along the line of sight ( _ los _ ) and/or the matter in the strong lens environment ( _ env _ ) on the lensing properties , we repeat the simulations four times .
the most realistic approach takes into account both _
los _ and _ env_. when we take into account the action of the strong lens and neglect all other haloes belonging to the same layer , the influence of _ env _ is lost , but _
los _ may still be included . in this way we check the effect of _ los _ alone .
similarly , assuming that rays are deflected only in the strong lens layer ( @xmath52 for other layers ) the effect of _ env _ alone is modeled .
finally using the same strong lens but in a uniform universe ( _ uni _ ) we have the clear case unaffected by neither _
los _ nor _ env _ , which may be used for comparison .
we use the _ prismatic transformation _
@xcite in all layers making the deflection at the middle points of all maps zero and transforming the time delays accordingly .
this implies that removing the background and all other haloes in the major lens plane changes the backward ray paths beyond the plane only in the second order .
thus the rays in the _ los+env _ and _ los _ approaches travel through very similar surroundings and the comparison of lens modeling in these cases is sensible .
the lens equation giving the dependence @xmath53 is stored in the array @xmath54 for many positions in the image plane and is sufficient for quite accurate interpolations . using numerical methods we find the distortion matrix and its determinant on the same grid , and then the critical lines and caustics .
finally we find image positions for many source positions using iterative methods .
( compare paper i ) .
we consider only sources placed inside caustics since we are interested in multiple image configurations .
the source positions are evenly spaced inside the region of interest .
once the images for a given source position are found , we calculate the corresponding flux amplifications and time delays , and store all such information for further analysis . different descriptions of light propagation produce different critical lines and caustic structures . while the positions on the observer s sky can be easily compared independently of light propagation model , the same
can not be said of source positions .
thus the comparison between image configurations corresponding to the same source position but obtained with different descriptions of light propagation is meaningless .
only the statistical properties of image configurations corresponding to given propagation model can be compared with one another .
@ccccccc@ shear & no & no & no & yes & yes & yes + delays & no & yes & yes & no & yes & yes + @xmath55 & no & no & yes & no & no & yes + model # & 1 & 2 & 3 & 4 & 5 & 6 + & 0.44@xmath56 0.19 & 0.35@xmath56 0.19 & [email protected] & 0.62@xmath56 0.17 & 0.52@xmath56 0.16 & 0.56@xmath56 0.17 + _ los _ & 0.64@xmath56 0.21 & 0.60@xmath56 0.20 & 0.63@xmath56 0.19 & 0.71@xmath56 0.19 & 0.66@xmath56 0.18 & 0.67@xmath56 0.19 + _ env _ & 0.65@xmath56 0.18 & 0.58@xmath56 0.19 & 0.59@xmath56 0.18 & 0.85@xmath56 0.08 & 0.76@xmath56 0.14 & 0.78@xmath56 0.11 + _ uni _ & .995@xmath56 .004 & .994@xmath56 .004 & .995@xmath56 .003 & .998@xmath56 .001 & .996@xmath56 .002 &
.998@xmath56 .001 + [ success ] in the case of pure elliptical , non - singular lens one would expect ( in general ) 1 , 3 , or 5 images .
our numerical method of finding the images starts from ray - shooting on a finite resolution grid with a small extended source as a target , so some images may be missed or unresolved .
also the external influence may change the number of images .
since configurations with more images probably better constrain the lens , we concentrate on cases with five or four images . to estimate the influence of the galaxies in the lens vicinity and the matter along the line of sight on the properties of the strong lensing , we attempt to model all our simulated cases of multiple imaging using a single lens model in a uniform universe .
the single lens we are using in modeling is a non - singular finite isothermal ellipsoid used also in the simulations for each of the haloes . when tracing the rays in simulations we interpolate all deflection angles from earlier computed arrays .
single lens modeling uses analytically calculated deflection angles and their derivatives , so it serves also as a test of ray tracing simulations in _ uni _ case .
we also try a more sophisticated lens model using the same non - singular finite isothermal ellipsoids with external shear . in this way
the tidal influence of masses close to the rays is at least partially represented .
models with included time delays information can be used to measure the hubble s constant @xmath55 @xcite .
we treat the value of the hubble s constant as a free parameter in some of our models , to check if it improves the fits and ( which is more important ) to find the possible influence of _ los _ and/or _ env _ on the accuracy of @xmath55 measurements .
the lens is described by six free model parameters ( @xmath13 , @xmath12 , @xmath57 defined in sec . 2 ,
the position angle in the sky , and two components of the lens position in the sky @xmath58 ; the other characteristic radius of the lens , @xmath59 is kept at constant ratio with @xmath57 : @xmath60 and is not free ) .
the source has some ( unobserved ) position in the sky @xmath61 ( another 2 free parameters ) .
models with the external shear have another 2 free parameters ( @xmath62 , @xmath63 ) , and the hubble s constant @xmath55 may also serve as a free parameter . thus the model has up to @xmath64 free parameters . for a @xmath65 image system we have @xmath66 observed positions and @xmath67 independent flux ratios .
if all relative time delays are measured , we have another @xmath67 independent observations . including lens position in the sky we have @xmath68 ( without time delays ) or @xmath69 ( with time delays ) independent observations . to have the positive number of the degrees of freedom @xmath70 in all considered cases , we need @xmath71 . in paper
i we considered all four and five image configurations .
( the four image configurations , constituting about 5% of all , were cases , where our numerical method failed to find the weakest central image . ) here we neglect the fifth ( weakest ) image ( even if found ) since it is usually not observed . in this work
we require that our models reproduce the image positions with the accuracy of @xmath72 , the lens position with @xmath73 , the image flux ratios ( measured in stellar magnitudes ) with @xmath74 , and time delays ( when taken into account ) with the accuracy of @xmath75 .
the rate of success of modeling depends on the chosen accuracy parameters ( compare paper i ) .
the values we are using correspond to the typical errors of present day observations ( e.g. @xcite ) , except for the high time delays accuracy , chosen for the reasons explained in sec . 4 .
we fit our models looking for a minimum of @xmath76 . with the exception of the term describing the errors in time delays modeling
, we strictly follow the approach of paper i. for completeness we repeat the formulae supplementing them with the time delay part : @xmath77 the first term , controlling the lens position , used in the model has the obvious form : @xmath78 where the subscript @xmath79 stands for `` lens '' . using the simplified model we can calculate the source positions @xmath80 related to observed image positions @xmath81 .
the deformation matrix @xmath82 and magnification matrix @xmath83 can be calculated at each image position : @xmath84 the mismatch between @xmath85 and @xmath61 implies magnified mismatch between modeled and observed image positions , which gives for @xmath86 ( @xcite ) : @xmath87 the fitting statistic for flux ratios is given as : @xmath88 where we calculate the flux ratios relative to the first ( brightest ) image and express them in stellar magnitudes as @xmath89 .
( the role of flux ratios is played by the ratios of corresponding lens magnifications . )
we then compare the modeled @xmath89 and simulated @xmath90 . for the time delays we use in full analogy : @xmath91 again we calculate the time delays relative to the first ( brightest ) image , comparing the modeled @xmath92 and simulated @xmath93 differences of time propagation .
@xmath65 is the number of images taken into account . in all cases
the quantities with an extra superscript `` @xmath94 '' are taken from simulations and mimic the observed values , while the quantities without it result from modeling . following the approach of paper i
, we try to fit simulated image configurations with the simplified models .
for the starting model we use the parameters of the lens used in the simulations .
if the external shear is included in modeling , we use its estimated value ( see the next subsection ) .
standard minimization algorithm gives the best model .
we accept it as a valid solution if its @xmath76 is within the range : @xmath95 where @xmath96 is taken from the table of @xmath76 distribution ; statistically in 95% of cases
the valid models belong to this range of @xmath76 for given dof . , [ gam2 ] )
is shown with the thick solid lines .
the distributions of the fitted shear values , are plotted with thin lines : dotted for model 4 ( time delays neglected ) , dashed for model 5 ( time delays included , @xmath55 fixed ) , and solid for model 6 ( @xmath55 treated as a free parameter ) . in the upper panel the influence of matter near the line of sight ( _ los _ ) and of the main lens environment ( _ env _ ) are taken into account ; other panels show the effects separately.,width=317 ] when simulating image configurations we use sources evenly spaced within caustic region of each lens .
thus every configuration represents some given solid angle of possible source positions @xmath97 .
its value is the same for all configurations related to a given lens @xmath51 , but differs between the lenses .
the magnification bias ( @xcite ; @xcite ) makes the strongly amplified sources more likely to be included in the observed sample . in general the effect
depends on the shape of the source luminosity function ; we adopt the simplification of @xcite assuming power law form of this function with the power index @xmath98 , so the relative probability @xmath99 of including given image configuration to the sample is proportional to the total magnification @xmath100 : @xmath101 where @xmath36 is a normalization constant . using the probability distribution we calculate the rates of acceptance of models of image configurations obtained using different approaches to light propagation .
the differences between individual lenses give the estimated errors of the calculated rates .
our lens population is probably too small to be representative and the rates of acceptance can be used to compare the different approaches , but have no absolute meaning .
the results are shown in table . 1 . according to this table both _
env _ and _ los _ do have an impact on acceptability of fits and the latter seems more important . with the inclusion of the external shear majority of the image configurations
can be reproduced successfully .
the time delays present an independent constraint on the solution and lower the rate of acceptance of our models .
the inclusion of @xmath55 as a free parameter slightly improves the rate of acceptance of fits . ) due to the matter outside the main deflector ( compare eq . [ kapp ] ) . the background contribution to the convergence
is automatically included and is not shown separately .
it is small ( @xmath102 ) in all investigated cases .
naming conventions follow fig . 1 . , width=317 ]
we estimate the external shear in two ways . in the first approach the estimate of the external shear
is done by removing the main lens and computing influence of its neighbours ( _ env _ ) and matter along the paths of the rays ( _ los _ ) in the weak lens approximation . after removing the main lens
we calculate the deformation matrix including only terms linear in deflection angles derivatives : @xmath103 , where @xmath104 - is the identity matrix and @xmath105 denotes the first order terms : @xmath106 with the usual convention we identify convergence and shear components : @xmath107 since we are interested in the mean shear acting in the region of the size similar to the main lens einstein ring , we calculate the deflection angles derivatives in eq .
[ matrix ] using finite differencing with spacing @xmath108 .
we repeat shear calculations for many locations inside einstein ring .
we obtain the distributions of estimated shear due to _ los _ and _ env _ for each lens .
we check the results with ten times smaller spacing obtaining very similar results . in fig . 1 we compare the distribution of estimated shear with the distribution of its fitted values .
this approach to shear estimation loosely resembles the cosmic shear measurement , since in both cases the resulting influence on ray paths / image shapes is taken into account .
the method gives also the estimated values of the convergence .
we are not using convergence in modeling , but we need it for the discussion of the results of hubble s constant fitting .
the distributions of the estimated convergence due to _ env _ , _ los _ and both are shown in fig .
[ all_kappa ] .
the distributions are not gaussian , so we characterize them by their _
median _ values ( @xmath109 ) and the parameter @xmath110 such that 68% of results belongs to the range @xmath111 .
the numbers are : @xmath112 ( _ env _ ) , @xmath113 ( _ los _ ) , and @xmath114 ( _ los+env _ ) respectively .
our simulations include only eighty lenses and their environments belonging to eight independent small regions of space , so the convergence distributions are not expected to be universal . in the _ los _
case the skewness and the range of @xmath115 resemble the results of the recent study by @xcite , who investigate the influence of weak lensing on the spread in the observed signals from standard candles and standard sirens . and @xmath63 of the external shear are shown for one of the lenses as an example . in all cases
los+env _ approach is used .
the solid error bars show the shear values fitted with the help of models 4 6 .
the spread of the results shows that the fitted shear value depends on the particular image configuration , not only on the lens and its environment .
similarly the value of shear estimated by the first method ( eq . [ gam1 ] , [ gam2 ] ) is shown with the dotted error bar . in this case
the estimated shear value depends on the position of the ray beams used in calculating the distortion matrix .
the contribution from the background matter distribution ( sec .
2.1 ) is drawn as an open triangle .
finally the shear values estimated by the second method ( eqs .
[ sis1 ] , [ sis2 ] ) taking into account external galaxies within the angular radius of @xmath116 , @xmath117 , and @xmath118 are shown with solid square , pentagon , and hexagon respectively.,width=317 ] in the second approach , following @xcite , we estimate the sources of shear taking into account contributions from individual haloes , which are close to the lens on the sky .
we use _ sis _ model for each halo .
the combined effect is given as : @xmath119 we include halos within the circle of radius @xmath120 around the main lens .
the subscript @xmath27 enumerates the haloes and @xmath121 denotes the layer it belongs to , @xmath122 is the deflection by a _ sis _ halo with the virial velocity @xmath123 , @xmath124 is the separation , and @xmath125 the position angle of the @xmath27-th halo relative to the lens .
the fits to image configurations do not reproduce the shear values estimated using the first approach exactly .
the fitting gives results which depend on the image configuration used in the particular optimization process and the estimates depend on the particular ray beams used in calculations . treating fitting and estimating as two methods of measuring the shear value
, we see that they are not in conflict : the distributions of fitted and estimated values are similar for combination of all lenses ( compare fig . [ shear ] ) and the averaged values for a single lens obtained with the two methods are within standard deviation of each other ( fig .
[ example ] ) .
the shear values estimated by the second method seem to be less reliable : comparing the influence of the lens neighbours on the sky within radii of @xmath116 , @xmath117 , and @xmath118 we see the dependence of the result on the size of the region taken into account .
our maps are too small , to check still larger regions ( even the @xmath118 radius is not applicable to all our lenses ) , however the dependence seen in the results suggests that the saturation expected in the limit of large radii has not been reached .
the analysis of fitted and inferred shear values for a sample of real quad lenses is presented by @xcite . according to their
study the values of the lens model shears and environment shears are in general different and in three of six investigated cases they are inconsistent at greater than 95% confidence . ) .
initial errors for all configurations are shown with thick solid lines ; the sum of all bins gives one for these histograms .
the distributions of time delay errors for acceptable models including shear but neglecting time delays are shown with thin lines ; these histograms are normalized by the rate of success ( column 4 in table 1 ) .
the dotted lines show the distributions before fitting , the thin solid lines - after fitting image positions and flux ratios .
the subsequent panels show results for the different approaches to light propagation , using the convention of fig .
1.,width=317 ] we define @xmath126 as a measure of the error in model time delays . in fig
. [ delays ] we present the probability distribution for the values of the time delays error .
our aim is to find whether successful fitting of image positions and flux ratios with a simplified model automatically improves the time delay errors .
the thick solid lines in fig .
[ delays ] show the distributions of initial time delay errors for all configurations and dotted lines - for configurations successfully fitted with models neglecting time delays .
these initial values are calculated for models having the parameters of the lens used in simulations and for the expected value of the external shear .
the thin solid lines show the distributions of time delay errors after the fit . comparing the plots we see that a small initial error in time delays gives a better chance of successful fit .
fitting of image positions redistributes the time delay errors . examining the numerical data we find , that fitting the image positions increases the fraction of models with acceptable time delay errors ( @xmath127 ) by 10 20 per cent , but another 15 25 per cent still have @xmath128 too large .
( large fraction of these , but not all , can still be improved with fitting procedure using time delays ) .
our results show that in @xmath129
@xmath130 of cases reproducing image positions and flux ratios implies also reproducing time delays with good accuracy .
the value of the hubble s constant @xmath55 defines the length unit in the universe , @xmath131 , and the time unit , @xmath132 . scaling the distances and sizes of all mass concentrations , but preserving their velocity dispersions , positions , orientations , and shapes , we get the same lens equation and the same image configurations . since relative time
delays scale as well , fits using time delays can be used to measure the scaling factor and so the hubble s constant @xcite . .
the histograms show the results only for the acceptable fits .
the distribution of fitted @xmath55 values depends on the approach to light propagation ( see the text for details ) .
the plotting conventions are explained within the figure.,width=317 ] using our lens models with @xmath55 treated as a free parameter and applying it to all quad image configurations we obtain distributions of estimated hubble s constant values corresponding to different descriptions of light propagation , using different lenses and different image configurations .
the _ uni _ case shows the typical accuracy of our method . despite the fact that an initial model has parameter values
the same as used in simulations and is acceptable , the fitting program looks for a minimum of @xmath76 which usually lies close to but not exactly at the initial position .
this affects all the fitted parameters .
the distributions of fitted hubble s constant values are not symmetric , with outliers at positions far from @xmath55 used in simulations , so we characterize them using median values @xmath133 and absolute deviation @xmath134 such , that 68% of results belong to the @xmath135 range .
the distributions of @xmath136 are shown in fig .
[ hub_yes ] for models including the external shear ( model 6 in table 1 ) .
the results of the hubble s constant fitting depend to some extent on the way the external shear and convergence are treated . in table 2
we present the median values and absolute deviations of the fitted hubble s constant for models neglecting the external shear ( column 1 ) and models taking it into account ( column 2 ) .
we also check the distributions of the corrected @xmath55 value ( see @xcite , @xcite ) @xmath137 where the convergence @xmath115 is estimated using eq .
[ kapp ] and for each lens its averaged value is employed .
we do not introduce the convergence into our models but only correct the results of fitting according to eq .
[ corected ] .
@cccc@ & neglected & fitted & corrected + & 70.5@xmath56 5.3 & 72.6 @xmath56 4.2 & 72.9 @xmath56 3.5 + _ los _ & 70.5@xmath56 6.4 & 73.1 @xmath56 5.0 & 73.4 @xmath56 4.1 + _ env _ & 72.3@xmath56 1.8 & 71.5 @xmath56 2.7 & 71.2 @xmath56 2.7 + _ uni _ & 72.8@xmath56 0.8 & 72.8 @xmath56 1.1 & 72.8 @xmath56 1.1 + [ hubvalues ] statistically the fitted @xmath55 values are in agreement with their expected values . in the most realistic _
case 68% of the results , after the correction using eq .
[ corected ] have errors below 5% .
the median estimated convergences are close to zero ; the _ los _ case with @xmath138 shows the largest departure . for _
los+env _ and _ los _ cases the inclusion of the external shear improves the median fitted @xmath55 and its accuracy .
the correction improves the accuracy in both cases and the median in the first case . for the _ env _
case the opposite is true .
the convergence we are using is estimated with the method of subsection 3.2 , which is not perfect ( compare shear estimated and fitted values ) .
this method can not be applied to real lenses since it is not based on observed properties of the image configuration . in our statistical approach
we have neither studied the individual lenses , nor the individual image configurations .
some experiments suggest that the constraints on the @xmath55 value from a single configuration are rather poor . for many image configurations values of @xmath136 from a wide range may give fits of comparable quality .
modeling simulated image configurations with simplified models we get the lens parameters . since we know the `` true '' parameters of the lens used in rays tracing , we are able to estimate the systematic errors introduced by _
los _ and _ env _ effects .
the results are presented in the following figures .
we investigate the lens axis ratio @xmath13 , and the characteristic deflection angle @xmath12 . with four image configurations
the lens virial radius is not sensibly constrained and the same can be said of the lens virial mass defined in eq .
( [ virialmass ] ) .
the knowledge of fitted @xmath13 and @xmath12 allows for a good estimate of mass within a given radius . for every parameter
we find the ratio of its fitted ( denoted by the superscript `` fit '' ) to original value .
the dotted lines in figs .
[ q - ratio ] [ alfa ] denote the results for the models , which do not use the external shear as a parameter , the solid lines - for models using it . as a free parameter ( not shown ) give results very similar to models including time delays .
the subsequent panels show results for the different approaches to light propagation , the convention follows fig .
1.,width=317 ] .,width=317 ] in fig .
[ q - ratio ] we show the distributions of the ratios @xmath139 for models including or not the external shear and time delay data , and for different approaches to light propagation .
( see the caption ) . as can be seen in this figure ( and also in fig .
[ alfa ] ) , the distributions are rather complicated and depend both on the lens model and the approach to light propagation
[ q - ratio ] and [ alfa ] suggest that the widths of the distributions increase systematically when going through the _ env _ , _ los _ , and _
los+env _ cases , but the absolute deviations plotted in fig .
[ madpar ] do not fully support this simplified view .
the median @xmath139 value is always close to unity ( with 1% accuracy ) . in fig .
[ alfa ] we show the distribution of the ratios @xmath140 for the characteristic lens deflection angle .
the median @xmath140 value is always close to unity ( 1% accuracy ) .
the characteristic deflection angle is related to the velocity dispersion of stars in the lensing galaxy in the same way as in simpler _ sis _ lens models , i.e. @xmath141 . since @xmath142 ( compare fig . [ madpar ] ) , the velocity dispersion derived from the lens modeling has typical relative error @xmath143 .
we also compare the influence of _ los _ and _ env _ on the errors in the fitted parameter values showing the absolute deviations of the fitted @xmath139 and @xmath144 ratios in one diagram . as can be seen in fig .
[ madpar ] , the typical errors in both parameters are roughly proportional to each other .
in this paper we have followed the approach of paper i , investigating the influence of the matter along the line of sight on the properties of strong gravitational lenses .
the main difference is the calculation of propagation time in the simulations and inclusion of the relative time delays in the modeling , which may serve the analysis of the hubble s constant measurement .
as compared to paper i , we have simplified the treatment of the background matter distribution ( compare sec .
2.1 ) , effectively replacing a part of the numerical calculation by the use of the fitted analytical formulae .
this approach was not employed in paper i , so the numerical inconsistencies , measured by the rotation to shear ratio ( up to @xmath145 ) were more important and could have affected its results , exaggerating the reported influence of the matter along the line of sight on strong lensing .
our numerical experiments show that matter in the immediate lens vicinity and matter along the line of sight do influence image configurations and values of fitted lens parameters .
if the hubble s constant is treated as a free parameter , its fitted value also depends on the matter outside the lens .
these conclusions are not new ( see e.g. @xcite ) and have been demonstrated to be true in several cases of real lenses ( @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) . according to our results matter along the line of sight is more important than the lens immediate neighbours .
this may cause problems in modeling multiple images and time delays of high redshift sources , where direct observations of the matter along the line of sight may be impossible .
we consider a `` typical '' strong lens and its environment using a synthetic model of the matter distribution based on the cosmological millennium simulation @xcite with gravitationally bound haloes described in @xcite and @xcite .
we investigate eight randomly chosen small square regions on the synthetic sky ( each @xmath146 on a side ) and look for the ten strongest lens candidates in each region , assuming that a source is located somewhere in the background at the redshift @xmath0 .
we artificially remove the lens neighbours and/or matter inhomogeneities along the line of sight to compare the resulting image configurations .
thus we obtain four different matter distributions with the same strong lens . to assess the importance of matter outside the lens we try to model the image configurations using a single lens in a uniform universe model . the rate of failure of this approach , as well as the spread of the fitted lens parameters serves as a measure of the influence of the matter outside the lens on its properties . inspecting table . 1
one can see that ( statistically ) matter along the line of sight is more important as compared to the lens close neighbours .
the same conclusion follows from inspecting figs .
[ q - ratio ] [ alfa ] , which show the distributions of fitted lens parameters .
the inclusion of the time delays in modeling lowers the rate of acceptance of fits not more than 10% , despite the high postulated time measurements accuracy ( @xmath147 ) .
we have introduced this accuracy requirement because many of our image configurations give time delays of the order of couple of days . for them
the time delay modeling and hubble s constant fitting with more realistic @xmath148 accuracy would be meaningless .
the time delay measurement accuracy we are using in our calculations is probably beyond the present observational possibilities . on the other hand one can choose appropriate lenses with appropriate image configurations for the purpose of estimating @xmath55
this however goes beyond the scope of this paper , where we examine a randomly chosen lens population as a whole . treating the value of the hubble s constant as a free parameter and using the simplified lens model with the external shear we get its median fitted value in agreement with the `` true '' value used in simulations ( compare table 2 and fig .
[ hub_yes ] in sec .
the convergence caused by matter outside the lens , when averaged over all our investigated cases , has median value close to zero ( sec .
3.2 ) , so the bias in fitted @xmath55 values should not be pronounced .
the expected convergence along a randomly chosen line of sight is zero since we measure it relative to the uniform universe model .
the haloes are compensated , so for each of them the above statement is also true .
since the positions of haloes in space are correlated , the density of matter near any lens should be on average increased . on the other hand , when calculating the convergence we remove the contribution of the lens itself , which is dominant .
thus the external convergence value close to zero on average , as in the case of lens population investigated here , is not implausible . in a more realistic approach
the convergence near the main lens should be positive due to the correlations in matter distribution . simply increasing the radii of compensating disks would not help , since the influence of each individual halo would diminish , but the number of haloes taken into account would increase in inverse proportion .
one may introduce some artificial limiting radius independent of masses and take into account only lenses within such limits .
we avoid such approach since the influence of high mass , distant haloes would be lost and the compensation would not be complete .
( a different method of compensating mass of haloes was presented in @xcite ) . some of the lenses give fitted hubble s constant values far from the median
we have checked the accuracy of our method applying it to lenses surrounded by the uniform matter distribution and found that it gives @xmath149 per cent scatter in fitted @xmath55 .
the outliers can not be explained as a result of unusually large convergence .
probably the perturbations to the outliers are nonlinear and can not be modeled as the external shear and convergence .
our calculations show that the external shear used in simplified modeling can be roughly estimated by weak lensing measurements along the line of sight ( compare figs .
[ shear ] , [ example ] and eqs .
[ gam1 ] , [ gam2 ] ) . on the other hand taking into account only galaxies visible on the sky close to the lens position ( fig .
[ example ] , eqs .
[ sis1 ] , [ sis2 ] ) may be insufficient we have checked such estimates using lens neighbours on the sky in circles of radii up to @xmath150 and found the dependence of the results on the size of the region .
it shows the important role played by the large scale structure , which is difficult to include in modeling .
more sophisticated methods using spectroscopic observations of galaxies along the line of sight ( @xcite , @xcite ) may give better estimates of the external shear .
in this paper we have limited our interest to configurations of four images . in five image configurations
we neglect the fifth , weakest image , which is not observed in real lenses .
( this is another difference in our approach as compared to paper i. ) neglecting the fifth image we loose the information related to the lens centre .
the nonsingular isothermal ellipsoids we are using have small , approximately constant surface density cores .
the size of the core has impact on the fifth image brightness , so without the fifth image it can not be fitted .
in simulation we postulate that the core size is proportional to the lens virial radius , which defines the total mass of the lens .
again , without the fifth image the total mass can not be fitted .
of course the mass inside the einstein ring can still be estimated using the fitted value of characteristic deflection angle @xmath151 .
we are grateful to the anonymous referee , whose critical remarks greatly improved the paper . the millennium simulation databases used in this paper and the web application providing on - line access to them were constructed as part of the activities of the german astrophysical virtual observatory .
we are grateful to volker springel for providing us with the smoothed millennium density distribution in the early stage of this project .
this work has been supported in part by the polish national science centre grant n n203 581540 .
99 auger , m.w . ,
fassnacht , c.d . ,
abrahamse , a.l . , lubin , l.m .
, and squires , g.k . , 2007 , aj , 134 , 668 avni , y. , 1981 , apj , 248 , l95 bar - kana r. , 1996 , apj , 468 , 17 bertone s. , de lucia g. , thomas p.a . , 2007 , mnras , 379 , 1143 carbone c. , matarrese s. , 2008 , mnras , 388 , 1618 chang k. , refsdal s. , 1984 , a&a , 132 , 168 chen j. , kravtsov a.v . , keeton c.r . , 2003 , apj , 592 , 24 daloisio a. , natarajan p. , 2011 ,
mnras , 411 , 1628 de lucia g. , blaizot j. , 2007 , mnras , 375 , 2 gorenstein , m.v . , falco , e.e . , shapiro , i.i . , 1988 , apj , 327 , 693 jaroszynski m. , kostrzewa z. , 2010 , aca , 60 , 41 jaroszynski m. , kostrzewa - rutkowska z. , 2012 , mnras , 424 , 325 ( paper i ) keeton c. r. , kochanek c. s. , seljak u. , 1997 , apj , 487 , 42 keeton c. r. , zabludoff , a.i .
, 2004 , apj , 612 , 660 kimm t. , yi s.k . , 2007 , apj , 670 , 1048 kochanek c.s . , 2006 , in : gravitational lensing : strong , weak and micro , saas - fee advanced course 33 , springer , berlin kochanek c.s . , apostolakis j. , 1988 , mnras , 235 , 1073 koopmans l.v.e . ,
de bruyn a.g . , jackson n. , 1998 , mnras , kormann r. , schneider p. , bartelmann m. , 1994 , a&a , 284 , 285 lemson g. , springel v. , 2006 , astr.soc.pac.conf . , 351 , 212 macleod c.l . , kochanek c.s .
, agol , e. , 2009 , apj , 699 , 1598 momcheva , i. , williams k. , keeton c. , zabludoff a.,2006 , 641 , 169 peacock , j.a . , 1982 , mnras , 199 , 987 refsdal , s. , 1964 , mnras , 128 , 307 schneider p. , ehlers j. , falco e.e . , 1992 , `` gravitational lenses '' , springer - verlag berlin heidelberg new york schneider p. , weiss a. , 1988 , apj , 327 , 526 springel v. , white s.d.m . , jenkins a. , et al . , 2005 , nature , 435 , 629 seitz s. schneider p. , 1992
, a&a , 265 , 1 shang , c. , haiman , z , 2011 , mnras , 411 , 9 wambsganss j. , bode p. , ostriker j.p . , 2004 , apj , 606 , l93 wambsganss j. , bode p. , ostriker j.p . , 2005 ,
apj , 635 , l1 williams k.a . , momcheva i. , keeton c.r .
, zabludoff a.i . ,
lehar j. , 2006 , apj , 646 , 85 wong , k.c .
, keeton c.r .
, williams k.a .
, momcheva i.g . ,
zabludoff a.i . , 2011 ,
apj , 726 , 84 young p. , gunn j.e . , oke j.b .
, westphal j.a . , kristian j. , 1981 , apj , 244 , 736 | we investigate the influence of the matter along the line of sight and in the lens environment on the image configurations , relative time delays , and the resulting models of strong gravitational lensing .
the distribution of matter in space and properties of gravitationally bound haloes are based on the millennium simulation . in our numerical experiments we consider isolated lens in a uniform universe model and the same lens surrounded by close neighbours and/or objects close to the line of sight which gives four different descriptions of the light propagation .
we compare the results of the lens modeling which neglects effects of the environment and line of sight , when applied to image configurations resulting from approaches partially or fully taking into account these effects .
we show that for a source at the redshift @xmath0 the effects are indeed important and may prevent successful fitting of lens models in a substantial part of simulated image configurations , especially when the relative time delays are taken into account . to have good constraints on the models we limit ourselves to configurations of four images .
we consider eighty lenses and large number of source positions in each case .
the influence of the lens neighbourhood and the line of sight introduces the spread into the fitted values of the deflection angles which translates into the spread in the lens velocity dispersion @xmath1 4 per cent .
similarly for the lens axis ratio we get the spread of @xmath1 10 per cent and for the hubble s constant of @xmath1 6 per cent . when averaged over all lenses and all image configurations considered
, the median fitted values of the parameters ( including the hubble s constant ) do not differ more than 1 per cent from their values used in simulations .
[ firstpage ] gravitational lensing : strong and weak - large - scale structure of the universe |
clarifying the origin of ultra - high energy cosmic rays ( uhecrs ) is one of the most important unsolved problems in modern astrophysics ( e.g. * ? ? ?
it is generally thought that cosmic rays with energies greater than 10@xmath1 ev ( 1 eev ) are of extragalactic origin because the galactic magnetic fields are not strong enough to confine them .
indeed , no apparent anisotropy in arrival directions of uhecrs along the galactic plane has been found . on the other hand ,
a steepening in the energy spectrum of uhecrs at around 50 eev is observed by the high resolution fly s eye ( hires ) experiment and the telescope array ( ta ) experiment @xcite , and also by the pierre auger observatory in a similar energy region @xcite .
this can be explained as a consequence of the cosmic ray energy losses due to interactions with the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) , as predicted by @xcite , and @xcite . in this case
, we expect that most of the observed cosmic rays of the highest energies originate from sources within the gzk horizon ( @xmath2100 mpc ) , and a correlation between nearby objects and arrival directions of cosmic rays is expected .
the uhecrs are deflected by the galactic and extragalactic magnetic fields on their way to earth .
the deflection angles are determined by the particle charges , source distances , and strength of the magnetic fields .
for example , in case of a proton arriving from a 100 mpc distance through a random extragalactic magnetic field 1 ng and correlation length of @xmath21 mpc , the expected deflection angle is @xmath3 for 100 eev ( and less than @xmath4 for 40 eev ) using the existing magnetic field estimates @xcite .
the ta experiment observes uhecrs in the northern hemisphere using a surface detector ( sd ) array @xcite of @xmath2 700 km@xmath5 area located in millard county , utah , usa ( 39.3@xmath6 n , 112.9@xmath6 w ) .
three fluorescence detector ( fd ) stations @xcite surround the sd array @xcite and view the atmosphere above it .
the sd array consists of 507 sds installed on a square grid with 1.2 km spacing , and measures particles from extensive air showers ( eass ) at ground level .
the energy and the arrival direction of a primary particle are determined from observed energy deposits as a function of distance from the shower core in the sds and the arrival time distribution of the eas particles .
the test operation of the sd array began in march 2008 , and the full sd array has been operational with a uniform trigger criteria from may 11 , 2008 .
the present analysis uses only the events detected by the sd array because this data set has the greatest statistics than that by the fds .
assuming the sources have the same intrinsic uhecr luminosities , the arrival directions of higher energy cosmic rays from nearby sources are expected to correlate better with the source positions .
we search for the correlations between the ta events and objects in catalogs by changing three parameters : the minimum energy of the cosmic ray events , @xmath7 , the separation angle , @xmath8 , between the cosmic ray arrival direction and the object , and the maximum redshift , @xmath9 , of the objects .
a similar approach has been taken in the analyses by the pierre auger observatory @xcite and by the hires experiment @xcite using the vcv catalog of 12th edition @xcite .
as putative sources of uhecr , we examine the objects in the 13th edition of the vcv catalog @xcite .
this catalog is a compilation of several surveys made under different conditions such as field of views ( fovs ) , observation periods , etc .
it does not represent a homogeneous sample of active galactic nuclei ( agns ) , and its degree of completeness is unknown @xcite . in addition , we have investigated unbiased data sets from different measurements , namely , radio : the third cambridge catalog of radio sources catalog ( 3crr ) @xcite , infrared : the 2mass ( the two micron all - sky survey ) redshift survey catalog ( 2mrs ) @xcite , x - ray : swift bat ( burst alert telescope ) 58-month hard x - ray survey catalog ( sb-58 m ) @xcite and 60-month agn survey catalog ( sb - agn ) @xcite , and gamma - ray : 2nd fermi large area telescope agn catalog ( 2lac ) @xcite . in each catalog , we select only those objects that have redshift information . in the case of the 2lac catalog ,
this criterion reduces the number of objects by @xmath250% .
the paper is organized as follows .
the observation status of the sd array and qualities of reconstructed events are briefly described in section [ sd_data ] .
the details of the parameter scanning in the correlation searches using the object catalogs are given in section [ correlation ] , and the results are described in section [ results ] .
we also investigated penalties for the multi - catalog scanning in section [ discussion ] .
the conclusions from this analysis are in section [ conclusion ] .
in this work we use the sd air shower events observed in the first 40-month run of ta from may 2008 through september 2011 .
these events are triggered by a three - fold coincidence of adjacent sds within @xmath10s @xcite .
the details of sd event reconstruction are described elsewhere @xcite .
first , the shower geometry including the arrival direction is obtained using the time differences between the observed signals at each sd .
next , the precise shower geometry and the lateral distribution of shower particles are determined using the observed energy deposit in each sd .
finally , the primary energy is determined from the lateral distribution .
the overall energy scale of the sd events is fixed by calibration with the fd energy scale using a hybrid event set as described in the reference @xcite .
the systematic uncertainty in energy determination is @xmath11 .
the data quality cuts for the reconstructed events are the same as in the previous ta analysis papers @xcite .
the events are cut if the zenith angle is greater than 45@xmath6 and/or the core position is within 1200 m of the sd array boundary .
the eas reconstruction efficiency under these criteria is greater than 98% including the duty cycle of the sd array for @xmath12 eev @xcite .
the accuracy in arrival direction determination is @xmath13 and the energy resolution is better than 20% in this energy range .
the number of events remaining after reconstruction and quality cuts is 988 for @xmath1410 eev , 57 for @xmath1440 eev , and 3 for @xmath15 eev . from our monte - carlo studies including the full detector response simulations , we confirmed that the acceptance of the sd array is fully geometrical , i.e. , independent of the arrival direction up to @xmath16 for showers with energies greater than 10 eev @xcite .
we also confirmed that the arrival direction distribution of the observed events in the horizontal coordinates and the equatorial coordinates are consistent with large scale isotropy shown in figure [ zenazi ] . in this analysis
, we use the geometrical acceptance to generate random events for reasons of computational efficiency .
the total exposure of the sd array in the first 40 months of operation is @xmath17 including the quality cuts .
we use the catalogs of extragalactic objects resulting from measurements as listed in table [ catalog_table ] . in several catalogs ,
the objects near the galactic plane are excluded to avoid incompleteness from the experimental limitation by the authors of each catalog .
we also exclude the observed sd events in the corresponding regions .
the target objects and the cut criteria in the each catalog are summarized below .
these criteria ( e.g. significance level ) were chosen by the authors of the each catalog .
the 3crr catalog contains radio galaxies detected at 178 mhz with fluxes greater than 10 jy @xcite .
objects in the direction of the galactic disk ( @xmath18 ) were not included .
the 2mrs @xcite catalog is derived from the 2mass observation with detection range between @xmath19 m and k@xmath20 magnitude .
this catalog also loses completeness near the galactic plane , so the authors of the catalog excluded regions with @xmath21 for @xmath22 and @xmath23 otherwise .
the sb-58 m catalog consists of objects which were detected with a significance greater than @xmath24 in the energy range of @xmath25 kev in the first 58 months of observation by swift bat .
we select the extragalactic objects in this catalog for this work .
the catalog of sb - agn contains agns with at least @xmath26 significance in the energy range of @xmath27 kev in the first 60 months of observation by swift bat .
the 2lac @xcite data set consists of agns detected with at least @xmath28 significance in the energy range of 100 mev@xmath29100 gev in the first 24 months of observation by fermi - lat .
the region of the galactic disk @xmath3010@xmath6 is cut away .
we also examine the vcv catalog which is a compilation of several agn surveys .
the number of objects and the sd events after the cuts applied in each case are given in table [ arrivaldirection_cut ] .
for a given set of parameters @xmath31 , there are @xmath32 events with energies @xmath33 .
we can count the number of events , @xmath34 , out of @xmath32 which are correlated with objects in a catalog with redshifts @xmath35 and within the angular separation @xmath8 .
we can calculate the chance probability , @xmath36 , that @xmath34 or more correlated events are found from an isotropic uhecr flux under the same conditions .
we carry out a parameter scan in @xmath31 space to find the set of parameters which maximizes the correlation between the ta events and the catalog objects , i.e. , minimizes @xmath36 . to determine the probability , @xmath36 ,
we first obtain the probability , @xmath37 , that a random event is correlated with at least one object by chance for a given @xmath38 .
we generate 10@xmath39 random events to obtain the probability , @xmath37 , in the same experimental region of the each catalog
. then @xmath36 can be obtained as a cumulative binomial probability : @xmath40 the scan over parameters was performed as follows .
the value of @xmath7 is set by the energy of the @xmath32-th highest energy event .
we scan over all values of @xmath32 such that @xmath7 is greater than 40 eev .
note that this energy is less than the energy ( 50 eev ) at which the ta energy spectrum begins to fall off steeply @xcite .
we set the upper boundary of the parameter @xmath9 as 0.03 , which corresponds to the distances smaller than 120 mpc .
this is comparable to the gzk horizon .
the selected step size of @xmath9 is @xmath41 , which is the typical accuracy in the redshift measurements .
the separation angle , @xmath8 , is varied from @xmath42 to @xmath4 .
the maximum search window of @xmath43 is selected as appropriate for lower energy events ( @xmath240 eev ) arriving from the distance of 100 mpc . the selected step size in @xmath8
is chosen as @xmath44 for @xmath45 and @xmath42 for @xmath46 .
the parameter ranges and step sizes are summarized in table [ parameter_table ] .
the minimum @xmath36 obtained from this procedure does not represent the correlation probability directly , because the parameter scanning enhances the correlation probability artificially @xcite .
therefore , a penalty for parameter scanning should be evaluated and the true probability of correlation must include this penalty .
this will be described in section [ results ] .
the results of the parameter scan are listed in table [ chanceprobability ] .
the smallest value of @xmath47 among all the catalogs is 1.3@xmath48 found in the sb - agn catalog with the best parameters @xmath49 . a sky map of the ta events and the objects under the condition @xmath50 which gives the smallest @xmath47 is shown in figure [ swiftbatagn ] .
all the observed uhecrs with @xmath33 correlate with at least one object with @xmath35 in the sb - agn catalog .
figure [ a2 ] , and [ a3 ] show the probability as a function of each parameter @xmath50 while fixing the values of the other two at the optimum value for this data comparison .
now let us consider the penalty for the parameter scanning .
we evaluate the probability , @xmath51 , of finding a correlation by chance with @xmath52 smaller than that obtained from the data as follows ( for a more detailed description of the penalty calculation see , e.g. , * ? ? ?
we generate 10@xmath39 random sets of @xmath32 `` cosmic ray events '' , where @xmath32 is the same as the number of the observed events with energies greater than @xmath53 eev . for each of the mock event sets ,
the parameter scanning was carried out using exactly same method as for the observed data set , and @xmath52 was calculated .
note that the parameters @xmath50 which yield @xmath52 are different for each of the 10@xmath39 trials .
the distribution of @xmath52 in case of the sb - agn catalog is shown in figure [ b1 ] together with @xmath47 .
one can see that rather small values @xmath54 can happen even though the simulated uhecr distribution is isotropic .
if we repeat the same experiment and the parameter scanning many times , the value of our result @xmath55 could be just a chance occurrence .
the probability including the penalty for the parameter scanning ( pps ) is evaluated as @xmath56 for the sb - agn catalog , and the values for all the catalogs are listed in table [ chanceprobability ] .
the smallest value of @xmath51 among the catalogs is @xmath57 from the the sb - agn catalog .
this does not yet include the penalty for searching in several catalogs .
if we have several catalogs , regardless of whether they are independent or partially overlapping , there is a possibility of finding a catalog which gives the same or smaller @xmath47 value by chance , even though there are no correlations between the events and the objects .
the straightforward way to calculate the penalty factor associated with the partially overlapping catalogs , as is the case in our analysis , is to include all the catalogs in the monte - carlo simulation .
therefore , we have repeated the simulation with 10@xmath39 mock sets as described above , but with the scanning performed in all six catalogs . calculating the fraction of mock sets that show equal or better correlation than the data , we find that the final probability with a penalty of parameter scanning ( pps ) and a penalty of multi - catalog scanning ( pcs ) @xmath58 . therefore , we conclude that no significant correlation between uhecrs and the astronomical objects is found in the current ta data set .
first , we consider the effect of finite resolution in the scanning parameters .
the uncertainty in determination of the arrival directions and energy only make correlations worse due to direction smearing and the contamination of the lower energy events than @xmath7 .
therefore , the obtained @xmath47 already includes these resolution effects . the same concerns the uncertainty in the redshifts of the catalog objects .
consider now the effect of the systematic uncertainty in energy determination . as mentioned above , this uncertainty is @xmath11 @xcite .
note , however , that the present analysis with the parameter scanning is independent of absolute energy scale : the _ energies _ of the events are no more than keys for event sorting , and a systematic energy shift does not affect the scanning in @xmath7 , hence the number of events involved in the correlation with the objects and the probability @xmath47 .
the last issue to discuss is the incompleteness of the catalogs , which remains even after we cut out the regions around the galactic plane .
the objects in the vcv catalog are inhomogeneous because it is a mere compilation of objects detected under different conditions .
the completeness of the other catalogs , in particular the 2lac , could be affected by our cuts , particularly by the selection of objects with the known redshift .
while the incompleteness may make the _ interpretation _ of correlations ambiguous if they are present , it does not affect the calculation of @xmath47 .
in fact , the effect of the incompleteness cancels out in @xmath47 since the same set of objects is used to cross - correlate with the data and each mock event set .
therefore , the incompleteness of the catalogs can not produce spurious correlations ( although it may , in principle , be responsible for their absence ) .
so far we have treated the objects in each catalog equally regardless of their class .
now let us examine whether there is a specific type of object that has stronger correlations with uhecrs than others .
we will consider the case of the sb - agn catalog which shows strongest correlations with uhecrs .
first , we count the number of objects of each class in the ta fov with redshifts smaller than 0.02 .
some of the objects are labeled unclassified " in the catalog . for these we used the information from other surveys @xcite .
the fractions of seyfert 2 , 1 , 1.5 , 1.9 and liner galaxies in the sb - agn catalog satisfying the above conditions are 0.441 , 0.235 , 0.132 , 0.044 , and 0.044 , respectively ( the total fraction of other class agns : 0.044 , and the fraction of the unclassified agn : 0.059 ) .
the total number of agns which are correlated with uhecrs is 22 with the parameters in table [ chanceprobability ] ( note that the number of uhecr events and that of agns are not the same because some of the events fall within the given angular distance from several sources ) . among these 22 agns the fractions of seyfert 2 , 1 , 1.5 , 1.9 , liner , and unclassified galaxies are 0.455 , 0.182 , 0.227 , 0.045 , 0.045 , and 0.045 , respectively .
we see that the largest difference is for the seyfert 1.5 galaxies .
the probability , @xmath36 , of finding 5 or more correlated seyfert 1.5 galaxies out of 22 by chance can be evaluated by the cumulative binomial probability with an expectation of 0.13 , and is @xmath59 .
therefore , no significant correlation with a specific type of agn in the sb - agn catalog is found .
[ conclusion ] we examine the correlations between the observed uhecr arrival directions and the extragalactic objects from the different survey catalogs under assumption that the sources have the same intrinsic uhecr luminosities .
we use the ta - sd events with energies greater than 40 eev obtained in the first 40 months of observation .
we search for maximum correlations by scanning over three parameters @xmath7 , @xmath8 , and @xmath9 in six different catalogs .
the smallest chance probability among these six catalogs was found with the swift bat ( 60-month ) agn catalog , @xmath60 .
this probability increases to @xmath61 when we include the penalty for the three - parameter scanning in the swift bat catalog alone , and to @xmath58 when scanning in all the catalogs is taken into account .
therefore , we conclude that no significant correlation with the considered catalogs of extragalactic objects is found in the present ta data set . investigating specifically the case of the swift bat ( 60-month ) agn catalog which gives the strongest correlation , we find that no particular subclass of objects is responsible for this correlation .
abu - zayyad t. , et al . ,
2011 proceedings of 32nd international cosmic ray conference , 2 , 250 abu - zayyad t. , et al . , 2012a , , 757 , 26 abu - zayyad t. , et al . ,
2012b , arxiv:1205.5067.v1 abu - zayyad t. , et al .
2012c , nucl .
instr . and meth . a , 689 , 87 tueller j. , baumgartner w.h .
, markwardt c.b . , et al .
2010 , , 186 , 378 the latest data taken from http://heasarc.nasa.gov/docs/swift/results/bs58mon/ greisen , k. 1966 , phys.rev.lett . , 16 ,
748 han , j.l . ,
manchester , r.n . ,
lyne , a.g . ,
qiao , g.j .
, & van straten , w. 2006 , apj , 642 , 868 huchra , j.p . , et al .
2012 , 199 , 26 ivanov , d. , et al .
2011 , proceedings of 32nd international cosmic ray conference , 2 , 258 kawai , h. , et al .
2008 , nucl .
suppl , 175 - 176 , 221 kotera k. & olinto a.v .
2011 , annu .
49 , 119 kronberg , p.p .
1994 , rept .
phys . , 57 , 325 laing , r.a . , riley , j.m .
, & longair , m.s .
1983 , mnras , 204 , 151 , data taken from http://3crr.extragalactic.info matthews , j.n . , et al .
2007 proceedings of 30th international cosmic ray conference , 5 , 1157 noguchi , k. et al , arxiv:1002.0909 parisi , p. , arxiv:1105.0527 pshirkov , m. , tinyakov , p. , kronberg , p. , & newton - mcgee , k. 2011 , astrophys.j .
, 738 , 192 sun , x.h . ,
reich , w.,waelkens , a. , enblin , t.a .
2008 , a&a , 477 , 573 takeda , m. , et al .
1998 , phys .
lett . , 81 , 1163 takeda , m. , et al .
2003 , astropart . phys . , 19 , 447 tokuno h. , et al .
2012 , nucl .
instr . and meth .
a , 676 , 54 tinyakov , p.g . , & tkachev , i. i. 2004 , prd , 69 , 128301 veron - cetty , m.p . , & veron , p. 2006
astrophys . , 455 , 773 veron - cetty , m.p . , & veron , p. 2010 a&a , 518 , a10 zatsepin , g.t . , & kuzmin , v.a .
1966 , jet plett . , 4 , 78 10 eev .
the top left : zenith angle , the top right : azimuth angle , the bottom left : declination , and the bottom right : right accension.,title="fig : " ] 10 eev .
the top left : zenith angle , the top right : azimuth angle , the bottom left : declination , and the bottom right : right accension.,title="fig : " ] 10 eev .
the top left : zenith angle , the top right : azimuth angle , the bottom left : declination , and the bottom right : right accension.,title="fig : " ] 10 eev .
the top left : zenith angle , the top right : azimuth angle , the bottom left : declination , and the bottom right : right accension.,title="fig : " ] ) of observed cosmic rays ( top ) , window @xmath8 ( middle ) , redshift @xmath9 ( bottom ) . in the each plot , the other two parameters are fixed at which parameter set provides @xmath62.,title="fig : " ] ) of observed cosmic rays ( top ) , window @xmath8 ( middle ) , redshift @xmath9 ( bottom ) . in the each plot ,
the other two parameters are fixed at which parameter set provides @xmath62.,title="fig : " ] ) of observed cosmic rays ( top ) , window @xmath8 ( middle ) , redshift @xmath9 ( bottom ) . in the each plot ,
the other two parameters are fixed at which parameter set provides @xmath62.,title="fig : " ] ) of observed cosmic rays ( top ) , window @xmath8 ( middle ) , redshift @xmath9 ( bottom ) . in the each plot ,
the other two parameters are fixed at which parameter set provides @xmath62.,title="fig : " ] ) of observed cosmic rays ( top ) , window @xmath8 ( middle ) , redshift @xmath9 ( bottom ) . in the each plot ,
the other two parameters are fixed at the optimum value.,title="fig : " ] ) of observed cosmic rays ( top ) , window @xmath8 ( middle ) , redshift @xmath9 ( bottom ) . in the each plot ,
the other two parameters are fixed at the optimum value.,title="fig : " ] | we search for correlations between positions of extragalactic objects and arrival directions of ultra - high energy cosmic rays ( uhecrs ) with primary energy @xmath0 eev as observed by the surface detector array of the telescope array ( ta ) experiment during the first 40 months of operation .
we examined several public astronomical object catalogs , including the veron - cetty and veron catalog of active galactic nuclei .
we counted the number of ta events correlated with objects in each catalog as a function of three parameters : the maximum angular separation between a ta event and an object , the minimum energy of the events , and the maximum redshift of the objects .
we determine combinations of these parameters which maximize the correlations , and calculate the chance probabilities of having the same levels of correlations from an isotropic distribution of uhecr arrival directions .
no statistically significant correlations are found when penalties for scanning over the above parameters and for searching in several catalogs are taken into account . |
ultracold laboratories have had great success in creating bose - einstein condensates ( becs ) @xcite in a variety of atomic gases such as rubidium ( rb ) , lithium ( li ) , sodium ( na ) and ytterbium ( yb ) .
these quantum fluids exist in various isotopic forms as well as in different hyperfine states .
the rapid pace of development in this field has led to condensates which are robust and relatively easy to manipulate experimentally .
in particular , the tunability of inter - species and intra - species interactions @xcite via magnetic and optical feshbach resonances makes the bec mixture a very attractive candidate for exploring new phenomena involving quantum coherence and nonlinearity in a multicomponent system .
the subject of this paper is to investigate the tunneling dynamics of a binary mixture of becs in a double well potential . a single species of bec in a double well
is called a bosonic josephson junction ( bjj ) , since it is a bosonic analog of the well known superconducting josephson junction .
in addition to josephson oscillations ( jo ) , the bjj exhibits various novel phenomena such as @xmath0-modes and macroscopic quantum self - trapping ( mqst ) , as predicted theoretically @xcite . in the jo and the @xmath0-modes , the condensate oscillates symmetrically about the two wells of the potential .
in contrast to this , the mqst dynamics represents a broken symmetry phase as the tunneling solutions exhibit population imbalance between the two wells of the potential .
these various features have been observed experimentally @xcite .
our motivation is to explore whether new phenomena arise when there are two interacting condensates trapped in a symmetric double well .
although our formulation and results are valid for a variety of bec mixtures , our main focus here is the rb family of two isotopes , namely the mixture of @xmath1rb and @xmath2rb , motivated by the experimental setup at jila@xcite .
the scattering length of @xmath1rb is known to be @xmath3 atomic units while the interspecies scattering length is @xmath4 atomic units . in experiments ,
the scattering length of @xmath2rb can be tuned using the feshbach resonance method @xcite .
the ability to tune the scattering length of one of the species makes this mixture of isotopes an ideal candidate for studying the coupled bjj system .
first , it opens up the possibility of exploring the parameter space where the rb 8585 scattering length is equal to the rb 8787 scattering length .
as will be discussed below , this symmetric parameter regime simplifies the theoretical analysis of the system and also captures most of the new phenomena that underlie the dynamics of the binary mixture .
furthermore , the tunability of the @xmath2rb scattering length can be exploited to study a unique possibility where one of the species has a negative scattering length , a case which strongly favors the @xmath0-mode oscillations that have not been observed so far . in our exploration of nonlinear tunneling dynamics of coupled bjj systems ,
the mqst states are found to be of two types . in the broken symmetry mqst state
, the two components may localize in different wells resulting in a phase separation or they may localize in the same well and hence coexist . by varying the parameters such as initial conditions , the phase separated broken
symmetry mqst states can be transformed to a symmetry restoring phase where the species continually avoid " each other by swapping places between the two wells .
in other words , if the dynamics is initiated with both species in the same potential well , the sustained tunneling oscillations are seen where the two species swap places between the well one and the well two . from the coexisting mqst phase
, one can achieve symmetry restoring swapping dynamics by initiating the dynamics with two species in the separate wells . in this case
, the emergence of the swapping modes can be interpreted as a phase where the two species chase " each other .
the paper is organized as follows . in section [ two_mode ] , we discuss the model and use the two mode approximation to the gross pitaevskii ( gp ) equation to map it to a system of two coupled pendulums with momentum
dependent lengths and coupling .
section [ fixed_pts ] discusses the stationary solutions and their stability .
these results enable us to look for various qualitatively different effects without actually solving the gp equations .
section [ dynamics ] describes the numerical solutions of the gp equations as various parameters of the system are tuned .
although we have explored the multi - dimensional parameter space , the novelties attributed to the binary mixture in a double well trap are presented in a restricted parameter space where the scattering lengths of the two species are equal .
additionally , in our numerical results described here , we fix the ratio of rb 8787 interaction to rb 85 - 87 interaction to be @xmath5 .
this restricted parameter space is accessible in the jila setup and provides a simple means to describe various highlights of the mixture dynamics .
section [ experiment ] provides additional details of the jila setup relevant for our investigation .
a summary is given in section [ summary ] .
in the semiclassical regime where the fluctuations around the mean values are small , the two - component bec is described by the following coupled gp equations for the two condensate wave functions @xmath6 , with @xmath7 representing the two species in the mixture .
@xmath8 here , @xmath9 , @xmath10 and @xmath11 , denote respectively , the mass , the trapping potential and the intra - atomic interaction of each species , with @xmath12 as the corresponding scattering length .
@xmath13 is the inter - species interaction , where @xmath14 is the corresponding scattering length . for the jila experiment , in view of the tight confinement of the condensate transverse to the trap , it is sufficient to consider the corresponding one - dimensional gpe equations .
the condensate wave functions satisfy the normalization conditions , @xmath15 the total number of atoms in the mixture is @xmath16 . in the weakly linked limit
, the dynamical oscillations of the two - component bec can be described by two wave functions representing the condensate in each trap labeled by @xmath17 , with the spatial and the temporal contribution factored as follows : @xmath18 the localized spatial modes @xmath19 are computed as sums and differences of the symmetric and antisymmetric solutions of the time
independent , coupled gp equations . to derive the equations of motion in the two
mode approximation , we introduce @xmath20 , the population imbalance , and @xmath21 , the relative phase of of species @xmath22 between the left and right sides of the double well potential , @xmath23 @xmath24 where @xmath25 are the time dependent coefficients in the two mode equations .substituting equations ( [ wf ] ) into the coupled gp equations and integrating over the spatial degrees of freedom , we obtain the following four coupled , nonlinear , ordinary differential equations which we refer to as the `` two mode '' model .
@xmath26 where @xmath27 . in the above equations
, @xmath28 denotes the fraction of atoms of species @xmath22 , while @xmath29 and @xmath30 are given by @xmath31 in the above , the space and time - independent parameters @xmath32 , @xmath33 , @xmath34 , @xmath35 and @xmath36 can be expressed in terms of various microscopic parameters that appear in gp equation and the localized modes , @xmath37 and their overlap ( integrated over spatial degrees of freedom ) .
the explicit expressions for these parameters are given in the appendix .
the parameters @xmath32 describe the tunneling amplitude while @xmath33 is related to the corresponding scattering length of the species .
the parameters @xmath35 and @xmath36 have their origin in the overlaps between the spatial modes @xmath38 and @xmath39 , and are expected to be small in the weak tunneling limit .
these overlaps modify the bare parameters denoted by the interaction @xmath33 and the tunneling @xmath32 . consequently , we have a variable tunneling model , since the tunneling parameters @xmath40 depend explicitly on the dynamical variables @xmath41 and @xmath42 . in our analysis
, we will mostly restrict ourselves to the case where the two species are equally populated , namely @xmath43 . in this case
, the above system of equations ( [ tuneqn ] ) can be viewed as the hamilton equations in terms of the canonical variables @xmath41 ( momenta ) and @xmath42 ( co - ordinates ) , with the hamiltonian given by the following form : @xmath44-\sum_{l = a , b }
\bar{k}_l \sqrt{1-z_l^2}\,\,\cos \phi_l .\ ] ] for the case where the overlap between the spatial modes @xmath45 and @xmath46 can be neglected , and the effective tunneling @xmath40 can be replaced by its bare value @xmath32 the above system can be viewed as a coupled pair of non - rigid pendulums , with momentum dependent lengths .
the coupling between the pendulums is also momentum dependent .
we parenthetically remark that this system can also be mapped to a pair of classical spins with cartesian components @xmath47 so that @xmath48 .
thus the spin vector locates a point on the unit sphere given by polar angles @xmath49 , with @xmath50 .
the corresponding spin hamiltonian , written in terms of bare variables , can be shown to be @xmath51 \\ + \lambda_{ab } ( s^a_z s^b_z)-d_{ab } ( s^a_x s^b_x).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the spin mapping provides an alternative means to visualize the effective interaction between the two species during the tunneling . if we ignore the spatial overlap integrals between the localized modes in two wells , ( @xmath52 , @xmath53 ) , the binary mixture of condensates in two - mode approximation , maps to two ising - like spins in a transverse magnetic field .
the full two - mode variable tunneling feature induces xy - like spin interaction . in this paper
, we find it convenient to exploit mapping to the coupled pendulums , for exploring tunneling dynamics in the coupled bjj .
although we have explored the full two - mode variable tunneling model , we will only discuss the constant tunneling case ( @xmath40 replaced by @xmath32 and @xmath54 replaced by @xmath55 . ) , as the overlap integrals are small and the various novel effects of the mixture described here are found to be robust and unaffected by the variable tunneling parameters .
the solutions of the coupled system are characterized by the interactions @xmath55 , the ratio of the tunneling amplitude for the two species , @xmath56 which we denote by @xmath57 as well as the initial phase difference @xmath58 and the initial population imbalance @xmath59 . in the multi dimensional parameter space the equilibrium or fixed point solutions , in which the right hand - sides of eqs .
( [ ftun])-([tun ] ) are zero , provide an effective tool to classify different categories of behavior of the system . in general ,
these fixed
point equations are transcendental and have to be solved numerically . however , in the symmetric case where @xmath60 , , @xmath61 , the fixed point equations can be tackled analytically .
further , as can be seen from eqs .
( [ ftun])([tun ] ) , the parameter @xmath62 can be eliminated in this case by rescaling @xmath63 ( @xmath64 ) and redefining @xmath65 as @xmath66 .
our detailed analysis shows that this special case captures many relevant phenomena characterizing the binary mixture in a double well . in this case
, the fixed points belong to two broad categories as stated below , resulting in two types of small amplitude oscillations about these two fixed points .
it is important to note that this type of mqst phase does not exist in a bjj with a single species .
+ * ( i ) zero - mode fixed points * ( @xmath67 + + ( 1 ) @xmath68 + ( 2 ) @xmath69 * ( ii ) @xmath0-mode fixed points * ( @xmath70 ) + + ( 1 ) @xmath71 + ( 2 ) @xmath72 + it should be noted that the mixed - mode fixed points , ( @xmath73 and @xmath74 , ( @xmath71 ) + are unstable for the restricted parameter regime we are considering here and hence will not be discussed .
the small oscillations about the fixed point ( @xmath75 ) result in zero - mode while small oscillations about ( @xmath76 ) lead to @xmath0-mode .
the oscillation frequencies are in the next subsection . the non trivial fixed points ( @xmath77 ) result in solutions with population imbalance and lead to tunneling dynamics with macroscopic quantum self - trapping or the mqst . in view of the @xmath78 symmetry
, we have two sets of stationary solutions : @xmath79 and @xmath80 ) , ( @xmath81 ) this suggests the possibility of modes where each species oscillates about the binary fixed points , going back and forth between the two wells . unlike mqst
, these modes will preserve the symmetry of the double well .
however , in contrast to zero - modes , these modes are non - linear and give rise to `` swapping phase '' that will be discussed later .
the emergence of fixed points with opposite signs for the two species , ( @xmath82 ) in the zero mode phase suggests that mqst in zero mode is accompanied by phase separation of the two species .
in contrast , in the @xmath0-mode mqst phase , the two species could coexist in the same potential well as ( @xmath83 ) .
therefore , the fixed point equations suggest that @xmath0-modes mimic attractive interaction between the two species .
the onset from oscillatory to mqst phase corresponds to the values of the parameters where the non trivial fixed points move from the complex to the real plane .
alternatively , the condition for the broken symmetry phase can be obtained by linear stability analysis of the fixed
point equations .
this is discussed in the next sub - section . in the asymmetric case
when @xmath84 the fixed points are obtained by solving the coupled transcendental equations : @xmath85 where @xmath86 for @xmath87 and @xmath88 .. analogous to the symmetric case , both the zero and the @xmath0-mode solutions including those corresponding to mqst can be found numerically . as expected , for the mqst fixed points @xmath89 in the zero - mode and @xmath90 in the @xmath0-mode
and we do not have the permutation symmetry or the @xmath78 symmetry .
however , unlike the symmetric case , @xmath91s do not scale time @xmath63 and the parameters and hence the ratio @xmath92 emerges as a new parameter .
+ frequencies of small amplitude oscillations about about ( @xmath93 ) and ( @xmath94 ) respectively referred to as the zero - mode or the @xmath0-modes are given by @xmath95\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath96 where @xmath97 for the zero - mode , and @xmath98 for the @xmath0-mode . in the symmetric case , with @xmath99 and @xmath100 , the normal mode frequencies @xmath101 and @xmath102 simplify to , @xmath103 the condition for the instability of the fixed point is determined when one of the normal mode frequencies become complex .
this gives rise to new fixed points where @xmath104 resulting in mqst phase where there is a population imbalance between the two wells of the double well potential for each species .
the condition for the existence of mqst is given by , @xmath105 for the parameter values where both the zero and the @xmath0-modes coexist , @xmath0-mode frequencies are smaller than the zero - mode frequencies .
figure 1 shows the values of @xmath106 where the tunneling is governed by the zero - mode and the @xmath0-mode .
for @xmath107 , the regime where the @xmath0-modes exist is is small but finite .
however , by tuning @xmath108 to negative values , the @xmath0-modes that have not been seen in earlier studies , can be observed .
variation with the parameter @xmath57 , the tunneling ratio for the two species , leads to similar results , with the parameter space for the existence of @xmath0 mode increasing slightly with @xmath57 .
the unshaded regime corresponds to mqst phase .
we now describe numerical solution of the tunneling equations . for small population imbalance
, we confirm the dynamics predicted by the fixed points as discussed above .
however , numerical solutions also illustrate nonlinear modes , not described by the fixed point analysis .
the fact that new features continue to exist in the nonlinear regime , assures their robustness . in our numerics , we set @xmath109 and study the dynamics for different values of @xmath110
. these conditions can be achieved by first tuning the @xmath111 via a feshbach resonance so that @xmath99 .
the variation of @xmath110 corresponds to varying the number of atoms in the double well trap .
as already mentioned , @xmath62 can be eliminated by using @xmath64 and @xmath112 .
the dynamics is governed by @xmath110 and the initial conditions : @xmath113 , @xmath114 , @xmath115 and @xmath116 .
as we discuss below , tunneling solutions belong to three broad categories : + \(i ) `` zero - phase mode '' , characterized by @xmath117 + \(ii ) `` @xmath0-phase mode '' characterized by @xmath118 + \(iii ) `` running - phase mode '' characterized by @xmath119 proportional to @xmath63 + in the single species case , @xmath117 also corresponds to @xmath120 . however , as we discuss below , in a binary mixture , we can have @xmath117 but @xmath121 .
this gives rise to a broken symmetry mqst phase in zero - modes as well .
+ for @xmath122 , and @xmath123 , and @xmath124 , both species execute small amplitude oscillations ( like oscillations of a non - rigid pendulum ) with , @xmath125 and @xmath126 as shown in fig . 2 .
such modes exhibit quasiperiodic dynamics characterized by superposition of sinusoidal modes with two competing frequencies . as @xmath127 increases , we see large amplitude non - sinusoidal oscillations .
therefore , in spite of the repulsive interaction between the two condensates , the two species execute a coherent oscillatory dynamics as expected from the zero - mode fixed point analysis described earlier .
if the dynamics is initiated with @xmath128 , both species oscillate in @xmath0-mode provided @xmath129 , and initial population imbalance is small ( @xmath124 ) .
analogous to the zero - mode , the dynamics in the @xmath0 mode is in general quasiperiodic .
as seen in the figure , the motion is in phase with the slow mode and out of phase with the other .
comparison with the zero and the @xmath0-mode oscillations show that species move more sluggishly in @xmath0-mode compared to the zero - mode as the zero - mode frequencies are larger than those of the @xmath0-mode . beyond a critical value of @xmath110 ,
the system enters the symmetry breaking mqst phase , as predicted by the fixed point analysis earlier .
one of the novel aspects of the binary mixture is the existence of zero - mode mqst accompanied by phase separation of the two species .
even with the initial conditions corresponding to both species abundance in the same well , the two components localize in the two different wells . in this case ,
transition to mqst is accompanied by phase separation : although the two species overlap for some time , the @xmath130 and the @xmath131 have opposite signs .
as @xmath110 increases further , the system exhibits `` swapping - modes '' where the two species swap places between the two wells but remain phase separated as shown in fig . 4 .
as seen in the figure ( at @xmath132 ) , the dynamics is initiated with positive population imbalance of both species
. however , the resulting dynamics corresponds to back and forth motion where the two species swap places between the two wells .
in contrast to mqst , the swapping dynamics restores the symmetry of the tunneling solution in the double well .
however , the two species remain mostly phase separated , _ avoiding each other by swapping_. in other words , the swapping phase is characterized by @xmath133 , but @xmath134 .
that is , at a given instant of time , the two species are more likely to be found in the separate wells .
thus in the swapping mode , the two species oscillate back and forth between the two wells and still manage to avoid each other .
the swapping is found to occur in the nonlinear zero - mode as well as in the running mode .
furthermore , a transition from mqst to swapping phase can be achieved either by varying @xmath110 ( fig .
5 ) or by varying the initial conditions ( fig . 6 ) .
+ for @xmath135 , and @xmath128 , and @xmath136,both species execute small amplitude oscillations with @xmath137 and @xmath138 , as shown in fig .
7 such modes are characterized by superposition of sinusoidal modes with two competing frequencies and the resulting dynamics is in general quasiperiodic . as expected from the fixed point analysis , the two species with both inter and intra - species repulsive interaction can self - trap in the same well .
that is , we have mqst where the species coexist in the same potential well , inspite of repulsive interaction among them . + as illustrated in figure [ fig8 ] , within the @xmath0-mode phase , if the dynamics of the two species is initiated in separate wells , that is , @xmath139 and @xmath140 have opposite signs , the mqst phase can be destroyed when the initial population imbalance increases beyond a critical value .
the tunneling solutions become symmetric as mqst is replaced by swapping modes . in this case
the swapping can be viewed as the two species `` chasing '' each other .
it should be noted that the swapping dynamics in the zero and the @xmath0-modes is very similar .
however , swapping in the zero - mode corresponds to two species avoiding each other while swapping in the @xmath0-mode corresponds to one component chasing the other .
this is because , in the zero - mode , species prefer residing in the separate wells while in the @xmath0-mode , they like to stay in the same well .
this unique type of coherence between the two different species is one of the most fascinating aspect of the binary mixture dynamics in double well potential .
the effects described in this paper should be realizable for condensate mixtures that already exist in the laboratory .
one example in particular is a mixture of @xmath2rb and @xmath1rb atoms that has been created in several recent experiments at jila @xcite .
this system is relevant to the analysis in this paper because the scattering length , @xmath141 , that characterizes the interaction between @xmath2rb atoms is tunable by an external magnetic field via a feshbach resonance centered at approximately 155 gauss @xcite .
additionally , the interspecies scattering length , @xmath142 , is also tunable with two feshbach resonances ( for a @xmath143/@xmath144 collision ) located at approximately @xmath145 gauss and @xmath146 gauss . in the most recent experiment @xcite ,
a @xmath2rb/@xmath1rb bec mixture was produced by trapping a thermal gas sample of the mixture and performing evaporative cooling on the @xmath1rb which sympathetically cools the @xmath2rb .
the cold gas mixture is then transferred to an optical trap that provides tight confinement transverse to the trapping beam and loose confinement along the beam .
if an additional pair of beams were applied along this direction as was done in the albiez experiment @xcite , it would create a setup to which the analysis in this paper would apply .
existence of a variety of bec species with tunable inter and intra species scattering lengths makes bec mixtures one of the most attractive candidates for exploring novel phenomena involving quantum coherence and nonlinearity .
our analysis , based on the two - mode gp equation for the two interacting species of bec in a double well trap unveils a variety of phenomena describing broken symmetry as well as subsequent restoration of symmetry , as we change the parameters or the initial conditions .
such coherence is found to exist over a broad range of parameters , establishing the robustness of the effects . to make direct comparison with experiments , we need to solve the coupled gp equations to obtain various parameters of the effective coupled pendulum system in terms of the microscopic parameters of the system and work in this direction
is in progress .
furthermore , by quantizing the hamiltonian ( coupled pendulum or the spin hamiltonian ) , we hope to study quantum dynamics of number fluctuations that may code the emergence of new quantum phases in the system . 99 m. h. anderson _
et al _ , science * 269 * , 198 ( 1995 ) ; k. b. davis _ et al _ phys .
lett . * 75 * , 3969 ( 1995 ) ; c. c. bradley _ et al _ , phys .
. lett . * 75 * , 1687 ( 1995 ) .
g. thalhammer , g. barontini , l. sarlo , j. catani , f. minardi and m. inguscio , phys .
. lett . * 100 * , 210402 ( 2008 ) .
a. smerzi , s. fantoni , s. giovanazzi and s. r. shenoy , phys .
* 79 * , 4950 ( 1997 ) ; s. raghavan , a. smerzi , s. fantoni and s. r. shenoy , phys . rev .
a , * 59 * , 620 ( 1999 ) . c. j. milburn , j. corney , e. m. wright and d. f. walls , phys
. rev .
a * 55 * , 4318 ( 1997 ) .
m. albiez _
et al _ phys .
lett . * 95 * , 010402 ( 2005 ) ; see also , cond - mat/0604348 .
scott papp , ph.d thesis , university of colorado , 2007 .
s. b. papp and c. e. wieman , phys .
. lett . * 97 * 180404 ( 2006 ) .
d. ananikian , and t. bergeman , pra , 74 , 039905 , 2006 tin - lun ho , v.b .
shenoy , phys .
* 77 * , 0031 ( 1996 ) .
jing chen , yan - qing guo , hai - jing cao , he - shan song , phys . lett.a
* 360 * , 429 ( 2006 ) .
s. ashhab and c. lobo , phys .
a , * 66 * , 013609 ( 2002 ) .
s. b. papp , j. m. pino , c. e. wieman , phys .
* 101 * , 040402 ( 2008 ) .
j. p. burke and j. l. bohn , phys .
a * 59 * , 1303 ( 1999 ) ; j. p. burke , j. l. bohn , b. d. esry , c. h. greene , phys .
lett . * 80 * 2097 ( 1998 ) .
with @xmath147 ( @xmath148 ) , the various coupling constants in the coupled equations can be shown to be given by , @xmath149 dr\\ \bar{\gamma}_{a(b ) } & = & \bar{g}_{a(b ) } \int [ ( \chi^{a(b)}_+)^2 ( \chi^{a(b)}_-)^2 ] dr\\ \delta \gamma_{a(b ) } & = & \gamma_{a(b)}^{-}-\gamma_{a(b)}^{+}\\ \delta \gamma_{ab } & = & \bar{g}_{ab } \int [ ( \chi^a_-\chi^b_-)^2-(\chi^a_+\chi^b_+)^2]dr\\ \delta \bar{\gamma}_{ab } & = & \bar{g}_{ab } \int [ ( \chi^a_-\chi^b_+)^2-(\chi^a_+\chi^b_-)^2]dr\\ \lambda_a(b ) & = & \bar{g}_{a(b ) } \int [ 2(\chi^{a(b)}_+ \chi^{a(b)}_-)^2 - 1/4((\chi^{a(b)}_-)^2 -(\chi^{a(b)}_+)^2)^2 ) ] dr\\ \lambda_{ab } & = & 2 \bar{g}_{ab } \int ( \chi^a_+ \chi^a_- \chi^b_+ \chi^b_-)dr\\ \bar{k}_a & = & [ \delta e - f_a \delta \gamma_a -f_b d_{ab}]/\hbar\\ \bar{k}_b & = & [ \delta e - f_b \delta \gamma_b -f_a d_{ab}]/\hbar\\ c_a & = & ( \gamma^a_+ + \gamma^a_- -2\bar{\gamma_a})/2 \hbar\\ c_b & = & ( \gamma^b_+ + \gamma^b_- -2\bar{\gamma_b})/2 \hbar\\ d_{ab } & = & ( \delta \gamma_{ab}- \delta \bar{\gamma}_{ab } ) /2 \hbar\end{aligned}\ ] ] for each species , the localized spatial modes @xmath150 are obtained by adding and subtracting the symmetric and the antisymmetric solutions of the time independent coupled gpe equations .
the @xmath151 is the difference in the chemical potential between the ( symmetric ) ground and the ( anti - symmetric ) first excited state of the coupled time - independent gpe equations . | we study the coherent nonlinear tunneling dynamics of a binary mixture of bose - einstein condensates in a double - well potential .
we demonstrate the existence of a new type of mode associated with the `` swapping '' of the two species in the two wells of the potential .
in contrast to the symmetry breaking macroscopic quantum self - trapping ( mqst ) solutions , the swapping modes correspond to the tunneling dynamics that preserves the symmetry of the double well potential . as a consequence of two distinct types of broken symmetry mqst phases where the two species localize in the different potential welils or coexist in the same well , the corresponding symmetry restoring swapping modes result in dynamics where the the two species either avoid or chase each other . in view of the possibility to control the interaction between the species , the binary mixture offers a very robust system to observe these novel effects as well as the phenomena of josephson oscillations and pi - modes |
ion - water clusters represent the transition between an ion in the gas phase and a fully hydrated ion .
hence these systems have been extensively studied to understand the thermochemistry of hydration and to infer how bulk properties emerge from properties of ions in clusters @xcite .
most notably , attempts have been made to infer the hydration free energy of an isolated ion , a thermodynamic descriptor of the nonideal interactions between the ion and water , by analyzing the thermochemistry of forming ion - water clusters @xmath0_n}$]@xcite , where x is the ion .
thermochemical data alone is inadequate for inferring the structural characteristics of hydration . in this
regard , theoretical calculations of cluster formation have proven useful .
( for example , see refs . . )
moreover , such calculations together with hydration free energy calculations of the clusters and water ligands have been used for estimating the hydration free energy of single ions . in calculating the hydration free energies , almost always a continuum model for the bulk solvent
is assumed and either one @xcite or an ensemble @xcite of gas phase configurations of the cluster is used for obtaining the hydration free energy of the cluster . in some studies
the gas - phase cluster is also allowed to relax in response to the model bulk medium @xcite .
an important development in the statistical mechanics of hydration has been the quasichemical organization @xcite of the potential distribution theorem .
this approach provides a rigorous , statistical mechanical framework to relate the thermodynamics of solute - water clusters to the bulk hydration of the solute . in practical implementations , approximations to the quasichemical theory are invariably made . in the _ primitive _ quasichemical approximation , the adjective _ primitive _ indicates neglecting the role of the bulk medium on the local clustering reaction the thermochemistry of ion - water clustering in the ideal gas phase , obtained using standard quantum chemistry approaches , is coupled with estimates of the response of the bulk medium , treated either as a dielectric continuum @xcite or as a discrete molecular solvent @xcite .
within primitive quasichemical theory , the hydration free energy is estimated by varying the number of water molecules in the cluster and finding the optimal coordination number that minimizes the hydration free energy of the ion .
this cluster variation approach has proven successful in establishing the hydration structure of small , hard ions such as li@xmath1(aq ) @xcite , na@xmath1(aq ) @xcite , and be@xmath2(aq ) @xcite ; for these cases , the optimal coordination structure predicted by primitive quasichemical theory is in good agreement with the most probable coordination observed in _ ab initio _ molecular dynamics simulations ( aimd ) .
similar agreement is also seen for mg@xmath2 , ca@xmath2 , and some of the transition metal dications @xcite . given the then limitations of small systems , short simulation times , and uncertain quality of the underlying electro density functionals in aimd simulations ( for example , refs . )
, primitive quasichemical theory proved useful in cross - checking the simulation results itself .
( the predictions for h@xmath1@xcite and ho@xmath3@xcite are also in fair agreement with aimd simulations , but consensus remains elusive@xcite .
these systems also challenge both theory and simulations because of the need to describe nuclear quantum effects . ) for the soft k@xmath1 ion , primitive quasichemical predicts an optimum coordination with four ( 4 ) water molecules @xcite .
but the results from aimd simulations are less conclusive .
some studies identify an inner - coordination number of four and a second outer - population with two additional water molecules within the nominal first hydration shell of the ion @xcite , but others make no such distinction @xcite . beside k@xmath1
, it has also been well appreciated that for some of the halides , optimum gas - phase clusters can show intermolecular bonding between the coordinating shell water molecules @xcite , a feature that is not usually observed in the coordination structure for the hydrated ion in the liquid . thus the primitive quasichemical approach for these ions has not been successful in reproducing the hydration structure and thermodynamics .
the limitations in describing the hydration of soft cations and anions suggests that the bulk medium plays an important role in the hydration structure of these ions . developing the framework to understand this effect is the objective of this article . in section [ sc : theory ] , we present the quasichemical theory , elucidate the role of the medium , and highlight the physical consequences of the primitive quasichemical approximation . in our previous work @xcite
we showed the importance of occupancy number variations of water in an empty coordination sphere for understanding an ion s coordination structure .
developing those ideas further , here we find that the bulk medium promotes a better packing of solvent molecules around the ion , leading to a decrease in the contribution to the hydration free energy due to interactions between the ion and the solvent molecules within the coordination sphere .
the medium stabilizes configurations which are otherwise not observed in isolated ion - solvent clusters . without proper account of this effect ,
the predicted optimal coordination state is typically lower than the optimal coordination observed in simulations , and appreciating this effect is necessary in calculating hydration thermodynamics as well .
we present only the main elements of the quasichemical theory ; more extensive discussions are available elsewhere @xcite .
we define the coordination sphere of radius @xmath4 around the ion , @xmath5 , and by so doing , separate the local , chemically intricate ion interactions with water molecules ( the solvent ligands ) within the coordination sphere from the interaction of the ion with the medium ( the bulk ) outside the coordination shell .
the chemical potential can then be written as @xcite @xmath6 where @xmath7 , @xmath8 is the boltzmann constant and t is the temperature .
@xmath9 is the probability of finding zero ( 0 ) solvent ligands within @xmath4 .
( the position of the water molecule is defined by the position of the oxygen atom .
the ion in the @xmath10 hydration state has @xmath11-ligands within @xmath4 . )
the contribution to the free energy due to ion - bulk interactions when the ion is in the @xmath12 state is @xmath13 .
the probability of finding zero ( 0 ) solvent ligands within @xmath4 when the ion - water interactions are turned off is @xmath14 .
this factor accounts for the free energy of creating an empty coordination sphere in the solvent and thus accounts for the packing ( steric ) contributions to @xmath15 .
the quasichemical form is obtained by noting that @xmath9 is specified by chemical equilibria of the form @xcite @xmath16}_0({\rm aq } ) +
n{\rm h_2o}({\rm aq } ) & \rightleftharpoons & { \rm \alpha[h_2o]}_n({\rm aq } ) \ , , \label{eq : ionaqcoord}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath17_n$ ] denotes the ion plus @xmath11-water cluster within the coordination sphere and ` aq ' indicates that the clustering reaction is in the presence of the bulk medium .
given the equilibrium constant of the above reaction is @xmath18 and the density of water molecules is @xmath19 , we immediately obtain @xcite @xmath20 note that the excess chemical potential of the cluster @xmath17_0 $ ] is just @xmath21 ( for ease in writing , we will denote @xmath22 by @xmath23 in all subscripts . ) approximating eq .
[ eq : lnx0 ] by its maximum term , we get @xmath24 @xmath18 is given by the ratio of partition functions of the cluster to individual molecules and can be challenging to calculate with full account of the surrounding medium @xcite .
but the equilibrium constant @xmath25 of the clustering reaction @xmath16}_0({\rm g } ) + n{\rm h_2o}({\rm g } ) & \rightleftharpoons & { \rm \alpha[h_2o]}_n({\rm g } ) \ , , \label{eq : iongcoord}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the ideal gas phase is more amenable to theoretical calculations . in eq .
[ eq : iongcoord ] , ` g ' indicates that the solvent outside the coordination shell is non - interacting ( or ideal ) ; that is , the reaction is performed in the ideal gas phase . since the free energy change for eqs .
[ eq : ionaqcoord ] and [ eq : iongcoord ] , with appropriate choice of standard concentrations , are just @xmath26 and @xmath27 , respectively , we find that @xmath28 the first two terms on the right hand side represent the hydration free energies of the clusters containing 0 waters and @xmath11 waters , respectively , and @xmath29 is the hydration free energy of a water molecule .
a similar development can be pursued when the coordination shell is empty , which is equivalent to the case when the ion and solvent do not interact . denoting the noninteracting solute by @xmath30 , the analog of eq .
[ eq : knbykn0 ] is @xmath31 note that @xmath14 is related to @xmath32 @xcite exactly like @xmath9 is related to @xmath18 ( eq . [ eq : lnx0 ] ) , and equilibria analogous to eqs .
[ eq : ionaqcoord ] and [ eq : iongcoord ] specify @xmath32 and @xmath33 , respectively . from eqs .
[ eq : qcapprox ] and [ eq : knbykn0 ] we obtain : @xmath34 eq [ eq : qcapprox2 ] not only permits the calculation of @xmath35 , but it also suggests an approach to identify the optimal coordination state . for different @xmath11 , we can compute @xmath25 ; often highly descriptive forcefields , including _ ab initio _ potentials , are used to model the thermochemistry of the gas - phase reaction .
the presence of the bulk medium outside the coordination shell is then corrected _ a posteriori _ by adding the free energy of hydrating the cluster and subtracting the free energy of transferring the requisite number of water molecules to the gas phase from the liquid . a continuum or dielectric model of the solvent
is often assumed for this purpose .
the coordination state that minimizes @xmath36 is then identified as the optimal coordination state @xcite . in
the _ primitive _ quasichemical approximation , the configuration of the gas phase cluster is not allowed to relax in computing the hydration free energy . to better understand this approximation , we first identify the role of the bulk medium on local ion - water clustering .
the ratio of equilibrium constants @xmath18 and @xmath32 was earlier@xcite shown to be @xmath37 where @xmath38 is the free energy of forming the ion - water cluster in the presence of the bulk and @xmath39 is hydration free energy of the ion in its @xmath40 coordination state .
specifically , @xmath41 where @xmath42 is the interaction energy of the ion with the rest of the medium , @xmath43 indicates averaging when the ion and the medium are thermally uncoupled ( denoted by the subscript 0 ) , and @xmath44 indicates that only cases with exactly @xmath11 solvent molecules within the coordination shell are considered in averaging . by parsing the interaction energy @xmath42 into a local piece , @xmath45 , obtained by considering ion - interactions with the @xmath11 coordinating water molecules , and the remaining long - range piece , @xmath46 , we have @xmath47 where we have made use of the rule of averages @xcite , in rewriting the second factor on the right ; @xmath48 indicates averaging such that the @xmath11-coordination shell molecules are thermally coupled with the ion , and the bulk medium is uncoupled from the ion but is coupled with the @xmath11-water molecules . identifying the first factor on the right in eq .
[ eq : munint ] by @xmath49 and the second factor by @xmath50 , we have @xmath51 we emphasize that @xmath49 accounts for the contribution to the chemical potential due to the interaction of the ion with solvent ligands within the coordination shell _ in the presence of the medium outside _ , and @xmath52 accounts for the contribution due to the interaction of the bulk medium with the ion when there are @xmath11 solvent ligands present inside the coordination shell .
note that when @xmath53 , @xmath54 ( eq . [ eq : quasichemical ] ) .
thus we find that @xmath55 ( our earlier work@xcite had an error in factoring @xmath56 . the error is discussed in appendix [ sc : appa ] for completeness . ) now if the medium outside the coordination shell was an ideal gas , @xmath57 from eq .
[ eq : knbyknt1 ] and [ eq : knbyknt2 ] , we get @xmath58 and this together with eqs .
[ eq : knbykn0 ] , [ eq : knbykn0 t ] , and [ eq : knbyknt3 ] gives @xmath59 finally , substituting in eq .
[ eq : qcapprox2 ] and noting eq .
[ eq : hardion ] , we get @xmath60 equation [ eq : frozen ] clearly identifies three different roles of the solvent medium and also helps us induce the physical consequences of the _ primitive _ quasichemical approach .
the quantity @xmath61 is the change in the free energy due to the local ion solvent interaction upon coupling the gas - phase cluster with the bulk medium .
it accounts for the energetics associated with the relaxation of the cluster in the presence of the medium .
utilizing gas phase geometries completely ignores this effect .
since the configuration of clusters with a high coordination state can be expected to be more sensitive to the presence of the bulk medium than configurations with lower coordination states , @xmath61 is expected to be larger for higher coordination states than for lower ones .
the quantity @xmath62 accounts for the interaction of the bulk medium with the ion when there are @xmath11 solvent ligands inside the coordination shell .
since the configuration of the cluster will change in the presence of the bulk medium , this quantity is also inadequately described when we do not allow the gas - phase cluster to relax .
we do expect , however , that since only long range ion - solvent interactions contribute to @xmath62 , this quantity can be well captured by dielectric models of hydration .
the final term is the hydration free energy of an @xmath11-water cluster without the ion .
it consists of packing interactions which are also typically ignored in the _ primitive _ quasichemical approach .
liquid water and ion water systems are studied under nvt conditions using metropolis monte carlo simulations@xcite .
the cubic simulation cell comprises 306 water molecules for the pure water system ; ion - water system consists of an additional ion which is held fixed at the center .
the box volume ( @xmath63 ) is adjusted such that the number density in each case is 33.33 nm@xmath64 .
water is modeled with the spc / e potential@xcite .
ion parameters and the magnitude of coordination radii are taken from our earlier study@xcite .
electrostatic interactions are modeled by the generalized reaction field ( grf ) approach@xcite .
both lennard - jones and electrostatic interactions were truncated at @xmath65 . as in our earlier work@xcite , na@xmath1 , k@xmath1 , and f@xmath3 ions were studied . since the trends for f@xmath3 follow those of the smaller na@xmath1 ion , for clarity we only present results comparing na@xmath1 and k@xmath1 .
the parameters for the ions were obtained from ref . .
simulations are carried out for 6@xmath6610@xmath67 sweeps .
each sweep consists of one attempted translation or rotation of each water molecule .
the first 3@xmath6610@xmath67 are set aside for equilibration . during the equilibration
phase the maximum angular deflection and linear displacement of the water molecule is optimized to yield an acceptance ratio of 0.3 .
the optimized values are then held fixed for the next 3@xmath6610@xmath67 sweeps .
configurations of the system are saved every 10 sweeps for analysis .
a similar simulation strategy was used for simulating ion - water and neat water clusters in the absence of the bulk medium .
the solvent ligands comprising the cluster are restricted to a sphere of radius @xmath4 .
clusters were simulated for 6@xmath6610@xmath68 sweeps with the first 3@xmath6610@xmath68 sweeps used for equilibration and the next 3@xmath6610@xmath68 sweeps used for production . during the production phase configurations of the clusters
were saved every 10 sweeps for analysis .
we calculate @xmath69 , the free energy of inserting an ion within a cluster in presence of the external solvent , for @xmath70 coordination states . for the ions studied here ,
the local chemical contribution @xmath71 is fully accounted for by this coordination number@xcite and thus these are the states of most interest .
@xmath69 is obtained indirectly by calculating the response of the medium , @xmath62 , and subtracting it from @xmath39 , the hydration free energy of the ion in the @xmath40 coordination state ( eq . [ eq : mundecomp ] ) .
values of @xmath39 were taken from our earlier work @xcite . to obtain @xmath62
, we simulate an ion water system in which the number of solvent molecules within the coordination shell was held at @xmath11 .
further , solvent molecules within the coordination sphere are fully - coupled with the ion , but the ion interacts with the bulk medium at various fractional charge states @xmath72 , where @xmath73 is the charge on the ion and @xmath74 .
ion - solvent pair correlation function was obtained from the @xmath75 simulation .
the electrostatic contribution to @xmath62 is determined by integrating the average potential , @xmath76 , at the centre of the ion due to the bulk medium .
@xmath72 is the charge seen by the bulk water molecules .
( we emphasize that the water molecules inside the coordination sphere always see a charge of @xmath73 . ) the electrostatic contribution to @xmath62 is approximated by the two point gauss - legendre quadrature @xmath77 which is exact to fourth order in perturbation theory@xcite . for obtaining the van der waals contribution to @xmath62 , we determine the distribution of ion - bulk interaction energies from the @xmath78 simulation . the van der waals contribution to @xmath62
is then obtained by approximating this distribution by a gaussian @xcite within the inverse form of the potential distribution theorem .
ion - water clusters within the coordination sphere were studied at different fractional charge states to obtain the electrostatic contribution to the free energy of forming an ion - water cluster when there is no bulk medium outside the coordination sphere .
( ion - solvent pair correlation function was obtained from the @xmath75 simulation . ) to calculate the van der waals contribution to the free energy , we first obtain the distribution of ion - solvent interaction energies for the neutral ion .
we obtain the uncoupled binding energy distribution by performing test particle insertions of the neutral ion in neat water clusters .
the vdw contribution is then obtained by histogram overlap @xcite .
for hydrated ions , an implicit assumption in using gas - phase clusters to calculate solution phase thermodynamic properties is that the average distribution of water molecules in the solution phase and gas phase clusters are similar .
examining the ion - water pair correlation ( fig .
[ fg : grkw6 ] ) does validate this assumption , but _ only _ for the low coordination states .
, of water around k@xmath1 in the presence ( aq ) and absence ( g ) of the external medium for the @xmath80}_6 $ ] cluster . the radius of the coordination sphere @xmath4 = 3.7 .
the pair correlation in presence of the medium shows enhanced structure relative to that for the cluster in the absence of the bulk .
this suggests that the external medium promotes a better packing of solvent around k@xmath1 .
* inset * : the distribution , @xmath81 , of the farthest water molecule from k@xmath1 .
observe that in the absence of the bulk medium , this water molecule is closer to the boundary of the cluster . ]
figure [ fg : grkw6 ] shows that the presence of the medium causes the cluster to be better packed , resulting in a somewhat sharper pair correlation for the cluster in the bulk than in its absence . as anticipated , the effect of the medium is most pronounced for the water molecule that is farthest from the ion ( fig .
[ fg : grkw6 ] , inset ) .
the distribution of the water molecules comprising the @xmath82 coordination states is insensitive to the presence of the external medium ( data not shown ) , a feature that is in accordance with our earlier @xcite finding that there is a core group of water molecules with which the ion interacts strongly enough that the effect of the bulk medium on these water molecules is small .
the higher coordination states are however influenced by the bulk medium as well .
for the cluster with no bulk medium outside , the 6@xmath83 water molecule is closer to the boundary of the cluster , a position that also allows this water molecule to associate with the remaining water molecules in the cluster rather than with the ion .
similar incomplete shell effects , where the second hydration shell starts to form before the first shell is complete , have been inferred on the basis of experimental studies on gas phase clusters with water@xcite or ammonia@xcite as solvent ligands .
figure [ fg : ions_ww ] shows that the bulk can stabilize configurations of the water molecules that would be unfavorable otherwise .
the average excess internal energy @xmath84 of the @xmath11-water molecules in the coordination sphere for the higher coordination states , relative to clusters in the absence of the bulk medium , is higher for the cluster that is extracted from simulations including the bulk .
further , @xmath84 is relatively insensitive to the presence of the bulk for the low coordination states .
thus we find that the medium promotes better packing of water molecules around the ion by stabilizing configurations of the cluster which are otherwise unfavorable . , of ion - water clusters for different coordination states . for curves denoted by ` aq ' ( filled symbols ) , @xmath84
is obtained by extracting the cluster from simulations in the presence of the bulk medium .
curves denoted by ` g ' ( open symbols ) correspond to clusters simulated in the absence of a bulk . the coordination radius @xmath4 = 3.7 . for higher coordination states ,
the average excess internal energy is lower in the case of a cluster without a bulk medium outside . ]
@xmath38 , the free energy of forming an ion plus @xmath11-water molecule cluster comprises a local contribution , @xmath69 , and the response of the bulk medium , @xmath85 ( eq . [ eq : knbyknt1 ] ) .
we next consider each of these contributions separately .
figure [ fg : xi_ions ] shows that @xmath69 is insensitive to the presence of the medium for small clusters ( @xmath86 ) .
however for larger clusters ( @xmath87 ) , not having a bulk medium to stabilize the cluster leads to a higher free energy .
the difference , @xmath61 is always negative . thus ignoring this difference while implementing cluster variation
will predict a less favorable contribution due to that coordination state : in effect , the probability of observing these higher coordination states will be predicted to be lower than when the difference is included .
, to the free energy of forming an ion plus @xmath11-water molecule cluster .
the filled symbols , @xmath69 , are results in the presence of the bulk ( aq ) and the unfilled symbols , @xmath88 , in its absence ( g ) .
the radius of the coordination sphere is @xmath89 . for @xmath86
, @xmath69 is insensitive to the presence of the bulk medium outside the coordination shell , whereas for @xmath87 , @xmath90 is more favorable with the medium than without . ] , of forming na@xmath1 plus @xmath11-water clusters . *
bottom * : the long - range contribution , @xmath91 , to the free energy of forming na@xmath1 plus @xmath11-water clusters .
note that increasing the radius @xmath4 of the coordination sphere does not greatly affect @xmath69 for @xmath92 but increases it for @xmath87 .
on the same scale , the response of the medium is more pronounced for the same change in @xmath4 and it tends to become insensitive to the presence of the coordinating solvents for large @xmath4.,title="fig : " ] , of forming na@xmath1 plus @xmath11-water clusters . * bottom * : the long - range contribution , @xmath91 , to the free energy of forming na@xmath1 plus @xmath11-water clusters .
note that increasing the radius @xmath4 of the coordination sphere does not greatly affect @xmath69 for @xmath92 but increases it for @xmath87 . on the same scale ,
the response of the medium is more pronounced for the same change in @xmath4 and it tends to become insensitive to the presence of the coordinating solvents for large @xmath4.,title="fig : " ] our previous work showed that increasing the coordination radius @xmath4 decreases the chemical term @xmath38 .
intuitively , we expect a more favorable clustering free energy with increasing coordination radius because the ion can be better accommodated by the coordination shell solvent molecules , that is the local contribution becomes favorable and we expect @xmath38 to decrease because @xmath69 is expected to decrease .
however , we find that increasing the coordination radius has no effect on the local contribution , @xmath69 , for small ( @xmath92 ) clusters and _ becomes marginally unfavorable for larger @xmath87 clusters _ ( fig [ fg : na_cn ] , top ) .
the observed decrease in @xmath38 with increasing @xmath4 is in fact found to arise from a increasingly favorable medium response : @xmath91 decreases as @xmath4 increases ( fig [ fg : na_cn ] , bottom ) .
this feature emerges because the coordination shell solvent becomes insensitive to the presence of the bulk for large coordination radii .
it is this feature that compensates for the increase in @xmath69 and leads to the observed decrease in @xmath38 .
figure [ fg : clusv ] shows the local chemical contribution ( eq . [ eq : lnx0 ] ) to the hydration free energy ; a maximum term approximation has been used . ) , @xmath93 . for k@xmath1 , neglecting the bulk medium in the local ion water clustering reaction leads to the identification of the @xmath94 coordination state as the optimal ( or most probable ) coordination state . account for
the medium indicates that @xmath95 is the most probable coordination state ( cf .
fig . 7 in ref . ) . for na@xmath1 , in the presence ( absence ) of the medium @xmath95 ( @xmath96 ) states are indicated to be optimal ( cf .
fig . 3 in ref . ) . ]
note that eq .
[ eq : lnx0 ] can be rewritten as @xcite @xmath97 where @xmath98 is the probability of observing @xmath11 solvent molecules in the coordination sphere in the absence of the solute .
thus the maximum term approximation is simply @xmath99 .
when the bulk medium is present , @xmath69 defines the local contribution to @xmath38 and when it is absent , @xmath88 defines the local contribution . in both cases
, we use the same long - range contribution @xmath91 to @xmath38 . for k@xmath1 , fig .
[ fg : clusv ] shows that neglecting the role of the bulk medium in the local ion - water clustering shifts the predicted most probable coordination state to @xmath94 , whereas the value obtained in simulations is @xmath95 for @xmath100 : within the maximum term approximation , @xmath101 is a minimum for @xmath94 ( @xmath95 ) in the absence ( presence ) of the medium .
for na@xmath1 , neglecting the medium suggests an optimal coordination state of @xmath96 , whereas in the presence of the bulk , a value of @xmath102 is predicted .
the value obtained in simulations@xcite is @xmath102 . for both na@xmath1 and k@xmath1 , any discrepancy between
the optimal coordination predicted using cluster variation and those observed in simulations is well within the uncertainty in the calculations .
earlier@xcite we had defined dominant hydration structures on the basis of how an increment in the coordination number contributes to @xmath71 , the local chemical contribution to hydration . if in going from @xmath103 , the contribution to @xmath71 ( eq . [ eq : lnx0 ] ) were only of the order of thermal energies ( and substantially smaller than the contribution obtained in going from @xmath104 ) , then the @xmath11-coordinate state was regarded as dominant . since this definition
is closely tied to the local interactions , it is expected to be insensitive to the definition of any chemically reasonable coordination radii .
[ fg : clusv ] shows that past @xmath96 for both na@xmath1 and k@xmath1 , the change in @xmath71 is only modest .
on this basis we would conclude that for the potential model used here , @xmath96 is the dominant coordination state for na@xmath1 and k@xmath1 , as was found earlier @xcite .
effort has focused on using thermochemical data obtained either experimentally or from quantum chemical calculations from gas phase clusters to estimate single ion hydration free energies .
an assumption often implicit in these studies is that the configurations of the clusters in the gas phase are similar to their aqueous counterparts .
our results show that this assumption is only true for small cluster sizes . for the na@xmath1 , k@xmath1 , and f@xmath3 ions considered here , clusters with less than three water molecules
satisfy this requirement . for larger clusters ,
the external medium starts to influence the local ion - water interaction .
the external medium stabilizes ion - water cluster configurations that are _ better packed _ around the ion , such that the local ion - solvent interaction contribution to the free energy of cluster formation is more favorable in the presence of the medium than without . for higher coordination states of the ion , and , more generally , for the coordination structure and thermodynamics of soft ions , our results show that the medium will play a sizable role in the coordination structure and thermodynamics of the hydrated ion . for these cases , accounting for the molecular characteristics of the bulk medium on the ion - water cluster
is important in inferring the structure and thermodynamics of the hydrated ion . in ref .
, the long - range contribution to @xmath56 was erroneously left out from the equations .
but these contributions were all correctly considered in the numerical work and hence no result is affected . since presenting these corrections
also provides a helpful alternative perspective on the equilibrium constants appearing in the quasichemical theory , we note those corrections here . where @xmath106 ( eq . [ eq : knbyknt2 ] ) and @xmath107 is the configurational partition function of a water molecules .
@xmath108 is the potential energy of the ion plus @xmath11 solvent molecules within the coordination volume and @xmath109 is the potential energy of the solvent molecules in the absence of the ions .
@xmath110 is the field of the bulk medium on the @xmath11 solvent ligands in the coordination volume in the absence of the ion .
[ eq : error ] includes the factor @xmath111 that was missing in eq .
10a in ref . .
based on the above definitions , we can show that @xmath112 where once again the factor @xmath111 was left out in ref . .
@xmath113 is the interaction energy of the ion with the @xmath11 solvent molecules within the coordination sphere .
note that @xmath114 ( eq . [ eq : knbyknt1 ] ) .
[ eq : winsmall ] includes the factor @xmath111 that was missing in eq . 11 , ref . | thermochemistry of gas - phase ion - water clusters together with estimates of the hydration free energy of the clusters and the water ligands are used to calculate the hydration free energy of the ion .
often the hydration calculations use a continuum model of the solvent . the primitive quasichemical approximation to the quasichemical theory
provides a transparent framework to anchor such efforts .
here we evaluate the approximations inherent in the primitive quasichemical approach and elucidate the different roles of the bulk medium .
we find that the bulk medium can stabilize configurations of the cluster that are usually not observed in the gas phase , while also simultaneously lowering the excess chemical potential of the ion .
this effect is more pronounced for soft ions . since the coordination number that minimizes the excess chemical potential of the ion is identified as the optimal or most probable coordination number , for such soft ions , the optimum cluster size and the hydration thermodynamics obtained without account of the bulk medium on the ion - water clustering reaction can be different from those observed in simulations of the aqueous ion .
the ideas presented in this work are expected to be relevant to experimental studies that translate thermochemistry of ion - water clusters to the thermodynamics of the hydrated ion and to evolving theoretical approaches that combine high - level calculations on clusters with coarse - grained models of the medium . |
in @xcite , sloane proposed the following curious problem . take a non - negative integer , write down its decimal representation , and multiply its digits together , getting a new non - negative integer .
repeat the process until a single - digit number is obtained .
the problem can thus be stated : is the number of steps taken in this process uniformly bounded ?
let us start with a general formulation of sloane s problem , while at the same time introducing some of the notation that we will use .
given a natural number @xmath1 , and an _ integer base _ @xmath2 , consider the base-@xmath3 expansion of the number @xmath1 , say @xmath4_q \;=\ ; \sum_{j=1}^k d_j q^{k - j}\ , \ ] ] where each digit @xmath5 ( and @xmath6 when @xmath7 ) .
let @xmath8 denote the product of all such digits , _
i.e. _ , @xmath9 thus @xmath10 defines a map @xmath11 , which we call the _ sloane map in base @xmath3_. clearly , such map can be iterated : write @xmath8 in base @xmath3 , multiply its digits to obtain @xmath12 , and so on . in particular ,
given any @xmath13 we can consider its _ orbit _ under the sloane map , namely @xmath14 the following proposition ensures that this sequence always stabilizes after a finite number of steps . [ trivialstart ] we have @xmath15 for all @xmath16 ( i.e. , as long as the base @xmath3 expansion of @xmath1 has at least two digits ) .
write @xmath1 in base @xmath3 as in , and note that @xmath17 .
since @xmath18 for all @xmath19 , it follows that @xmath20 from proposition [ trivialstart ] we deduce that @xmath1 is a fixed point of @xmath21 if and only if @xmath22 .
it also follows from proposition [ trivialstart ] that every orbit of @xmath21 is finite and converges to some @xmath23 that is a fixed point .
in other words , there exists a minimum number @xmath24 such that @xmath25 for all @xmath26 .
hence @xmath24 _ is the smallest number @xmath27 such that @xmath28 has a single digit_. sloane asked in @xcite whether such minimum number of steps until a fixed point is uniformly bounded . the number @xmath24 is known as the _ persistence _ of @xmath1 in base @xmath3 .
numerical evidence that @xmath24 is bounded has been collected for some values of @xmath3 .
furthermore , the answer to sloane s question is trivially positive for @xmath29 since for any @xmath30 one has @xmath31 , and @xmath32 is the fixed - point set of @xmath33 .
the problem known as the _ persistence problem _ can be stated as follows .
[ prob1 ] for a given @xmath34 , is there a positive number @xmath35 such that @xmath36 for all @xmath37 ?
a related set of issues goes as follows ( considering now @xmath38 as an element of @xmath39 ) .
[ prob2 ] what is the behavior of @xmath35 seen as a function of @xmath3 ?
more precisely , one can ask : 1 .
is the answer to problem [ prob1 ] positive for all , or all but finitely many , or most , or infinitely many , or perhaps only finitely many values of @xmath3 ?
2 . what is the asymptotic behavior of @xmath35 as @xmath40 ? here are some known facts about the persistence problem in various bases : 1 . in base @xmath29 ,
the situation is rather trivial : every positive integer has persistence @xmath41 in base @xmath42 .
2 . in base @xmath43 , no number with persistence greater than @xmath44 has ever been found .
3 . in base @xmath45
, the number @xmath46 has persistence @xmath47 , because under the sloane map @xmath48 we have @xmath49 in fact , this is the smallest number with persistence equal to @xmath47 .
4 . still in base @xmath45 , the number @xmath50 has persistence @xmath51 .
it is the smallest number with persistence equal to @xmath51 .
it is conjectured that @xmath52 for all @xmath1 .
this has been checked for all @xmath1 up to @xmath53 . in this paper
, we have two main goals .
the first goal is to examine the persistence problem in the light of some dynamical systems considerations .
we will show that sloane s question ( problem [ prob1 ] ) has an affirmative answer in a certain _ probabilistic _ sense .
roughly speaking , we will show that _ for any base @xmath3 , the set of natural numbers @xmath1 with persistence @xmath54 , _
i.e. _ such that @xmath55 , is an extremely rarified subset of @xmath56_. the probabilistic sense in question will be made progressively clear in [ sec : erg1 ] and [ sec : erg2 ] .
we will see in particular that problem [ prob1 ] has a positive answer for @xmath43 if a precise orbit that we will fully describe has a `` generic '' behavior under the @xmath57-action determined by a well - defined piecewise affine degree one circle map .
similarly , problem [ prob1 ] has a positive answer for @xmath58 if two precise orbits that we will fully describe have a `` generic '' behavior under the @xmath57-action determined by another well - defined piecewise affine degree one circle map .
the affine circle maps that we will encounter here are defined by @xmath3 and a number @xmath59 , a digit in base @xmath3 . for bases @xmath60 , the relevant dynamical systems for the sloane map are no longer @xmath57-actions , but rather @xmath61-actions with @xmath17 .
more precisely , they are given by certain free abelian groups of piecewise affine degree - one circle maps .
we will exploit some simple ergodic properties of such free - abelian actions in order to derive our main probabilistic result on the sloane map , namely theorem [ rankkdensity ] .
our second goal is to formulate a very general conjecture , namely conjecture [ conj : convvtoequi ] , concerning the asymptotic distribution of digits in the base @xmath3 expansion of long products whose factors are chosen from a given finite set of primes .
this conjecture is conveniently formulated in terms of certain objects that we call _ multiplication automata _ , in part because their time evolution produces patterns that resemble those produced by the evolution of ( one - dimensional ) cellular automata .
the most general form of the conjecture , as stated in [ multaut ] , is too broad to allow thorough numerical tests .
thus , short of a proof , we felt the need to provide an heuristic explanation lending support to this conjecture .
such heuristics is given in the language of _ inhomeogeneous markov chains _ , as a form of convergence to equilibrium for the evolution of our automata .
the multiplication automata and the associated convergence to fair distribution may be of interest to the physics of growth processes , and perhaps to other aspects of statistical mechanics . in order to avoid possible misunderstandings
, we warn the reader that another map has been studied , inspired by @xmath21 : let us call it the erds - sloane map , and denote it by @xmath62 . for each natural number @xmath1 , @xmath63 is the product of the non - zero digits of @xmath1 in base @xmath3 . according to guy @xcite ,
this map was introduced by erds . since our approach in this paper
is based on the conjectured generic property that all digits should become equally probable for ( products of ) high powers of digits , we have nothing new to say about @xmath62 ( although some results we have about @xmath64 can be interpreted in terms of @xmath65 ) .
let us start by making a trivial but important remark . choose some base @xmath2 .
looking back at the expansion given in , it is clear that we have the following _ trivial dichotomy _
: 1 . _
either _ one of the digits @xmath66 is equal to zero , in which case @xmath67 ; 2 . _ or else _ @xmath8 is equal to a product of digits in @xmath68 . this trivial dichotomy , together with first observations of relevant but scarce numerical data , suggest us an obvious strategy . in order to answer sloane s question in the affirmative for base @xmath3
, it suffices to establish the following .
[ basebpersist ] there exists a positive integer @xmath69 such that , for all @xmath70 , the base @xmath3 expansion of any product of @xmath71 digits greater than @xmath41 for base @xmath3 has at least one digit equal to zero .
as soon as a product of digits becomes divisible by @xmath3 , a zero appears as its right - most digit when written in base @xmath3 , and therefore the next iteration of the sloane map yields @xmath72 as the result .
this trivial remark allows us to concentrate only on those products that are not divisible by the base @xmath3 .
the effect of that will be dramatic when @xmath58 .
the following two conjectures are implied by conjecture [ basebpersist ] . in the case of base @xmath43 ,
the only non - zero values assumed by the sloane map are powers of @xmath42 . in other words
, we only need to investigate the orbit of @xmath41 under the doubling map @xmath73 .
1a[base3persist ] there exists a positive integer @xmath74 such that , for all @xmath75 , the base-@xmath44 expansion of @xmath76 has at least one digit equal to zero .
such a statement is reminiscent of a conjecture by erds to the effect that there is always a 2 among the digits in base 3 of @xmath76 for all @xmath71 sufficiently large
. this question has been recently adressed by lagarias in @xcite . in the case of base @xmath58 , in principle
all products of the form @xmath77 would need to be examined .
but since the basis 4 divides @xmath77 as soon as @xmath78 , we only have to consider : ( a ) powers of 3 or ( b ) products of the form @xmath79 .
in other words , we only need to consider the orbits of 1 and 2 under the tripling map @xmath80 .
1b[base4persist ] there exists a positive integer @xmath81 such that , for all @xmath82 , the base-@xmath83 expansions of @xmath84 and @xmath85 each have at least one digit equal to zero .
there is considerable computational evidence in favor of these conjectures .
proving these conjectures is certainly sufficient to solve the persistence problem for the corresponding bases .
let us take the time to establish a weak estimate on @xmath86 , the minimum stability time of @xmath13 ( in base @xmath44 ) introduced in
[ intro ] .
this should be compared to a similar estimate proved by erds concerning the erds - sloane map .
first , a very simple lemma .
[ trivlem1 ] if @xmath87 , then at least one of the digits in the base-@xmath44 expansion of @xmath88 is not equal to @xmath42 .
suppose the base-@xmath44 expansion of @xmath88 has exactly @xmath71 digits , all equal to @xmath42 .
then @xmath89 , and we have a solution to catalan s equation @xmath90 with @xmath91 , which is impossible .
see @xcite ) .
the special case needed here ( with bases @xmath42 and @xmath44 , which are _ prime _ ) can be proved by elementary means
see @xcite . ] [ trivrem1 ] it follows from the proof that @xmath92 .
let us now present our weak estimate . recall that if @xmath93 , then the number of digits in the base-@xmath3 expansion of @xmath94 is equal to @xmath95 . for all @xmath96 , we have @xmath97 .
let @xmath87 be given , and assume @xmath98 , otherwise there is nothing to prove . thus ,
suppose @xmath99 are such that 1 .
@xmath100 for @xmath101 ; 2 .
@xmath102 ; 3 .
@xmath103 for @xmath104 ; 4 .
@xmath27 is _ maximal _ with the above properties . from these properties
we see that the only possible values for @xmath105 are @xmath106 or @xmath107 .
this implies that @xmath108 .
hence it suffices to find a suitable bound for the number @xmath27 .
let @xmath109 denote the number of digits in the base-@xmath44 expansion of @xmath110 , for @xmath111 .
since @xmath100 , we deduce from lemma [ trivlem1 ] and remark [ trivrem1 ] that @xmath112 .
but we also know that @xmath113 .
therefore we have @xmath114 where @xmath115 . from this
it follows that @xmath116 but we also have @xmath117 .
hence , extracting the base-@xmath44 logarithm of all terms in the above inequality , we see that @xmath118 this shows that @xmath119 , as claimed .
in this section , more precisely in [ subsec : ergoz ] below , we introduce a simple dynamical system generated by a single piecewise affine degree - one circle map which will turn out to be very useful in the study of the sloane map for bases @xmath120 . but first let us present some simple arithmetical facts .
looking at the base-@xmath44 expansions of the successive powers of two ( see figure [ fig : powersof2base3 ] ) , it is clear that for every @xmath121 the rightmost @xmath71 digits of these powers exhibit a periodic behavior .
our goal here is to calculate the minimum period .
this periodicity is more general : the last @xmath71 digits of the base-@xmath3 expansion of @xmath122 form a periodic sequence , for all @xmath123 .
this fact is a simple consequence of modular arithmetic , and we call it _ tail periodicity_. first , we need the following simple lemma . recall that , if @xmath2 is an integer , then the set of all residues @xmath124 modulo @xmath3 that are relatively prime with @xmath3 form a _ multiplicative group _
( under multiplication modulo @xmath3 ) , called the _ group of units modulo @xmath3 _ , denoted @xmath125 .
this group @xmath125 has order @xmath126 , where @xmath127 is euler s _
totient function_. an integer @xmath128 is said to be a _ primitive root modulo @xmath3 _ if the residue class of @xmath128 modulo @xmath3 has order @xmath126 in @xmath125 ( in particular , if such a primitive root exists , then the group @xmath125 must be cyclic ) .
[ primroot1 ] let @xmath128 and @xmath3 be integers such that @xmath123 and @xmath128 is a primitive root modulo @xmath3 .
then the residues @xmath129 , @xmath130 , form a periodic sequence with minimum period equal to @xmath126 . by hypothesis
, @xmath131 is a generator of the cyclic group @xmath125 .
therefore , by euler s theorem , @xmath132 , and the elements @xmath133 exhaust the elements of @xmath125 .
since @xmath134 for all @xmath1 , the sequence @xmath122 is indeed periodic , with minimum period @xmath126 . as a consequence
, we have the following . given integers @xmath121 and @xmath30 , let @xmath135 denote the residue of @xmath88 modulo @xmath84 . [ primroot2 ] for each @xmath121 ,
the sequence @xmath135 , @xmath136 , is periodic with minimum period @xmath137 .
it is well - known that @xmath42 is a primitive root modulo @xmath84 for all @xmath121 ( see @xcite ) .
thus , the desired result follows at once from lemma [ primroot1 ] ( with @xmath138 and @xmath139 ) and the fact that @xmath140 .
note that for each @xmath71 there are exactly @xmath137 strings of length @xmath71 in the symbols @xmath141 which do not end in a zero .
call these strings _ allowable_. combining this counting , the above lemma and the fact that @xmath135 also never ends in a zero ( otherwise @xmath88 would be divisible by @xmath44 ) , we see that in any full ( minimum ) period of @xmath135 each allowable string appears exactly once . moreover , since there are exactly @xmath76 allowable strings of length @xmath71 that show only the digits @xmath41 and @xmath42 , the proportion of allowable strings in which at least one zero appears ( relative to the total number of allowable sequences of length @xmath71 ) tends to @xmath41 as @xmath142 . from this
we deduce that the set @xmath143 has _
asymptotic density @xmath41 _ , in the sense of [ sec : density ] below .
this fact can be generalized to other bases ( but the counting argument used here becomes a bit more involved ) . rather than delve into such arithmetic methods , we shall use a completely different approach to prove a more general density result that holds true for all bases . if , instead of looking at the final @xmath71 digits of the base-@xmath44 expansions of powers of two , we look at the first @xmath71 digits ( for @xmath121 fixed ) , the behavior of such _ heads _ is no longer periodic .
it is rather _ almost periodic _ , as we will show ( see remark [ remalmost ] ) . to in fact ,
let us present a more general result .
we consider two integers @xmath123 and consider the sequence @xmath122 , @xmath130 , written in base @xmath3 , say @xmath144_q\;=\;\sum_{i=1}^{k_n } d_{i , n}q^{k_n - i}\ , \ ] ] where @xmath145 and @xmath146 , and where the number of digits @xmath147 is given by @xmath148 .
if we add a `` decimal point '' in front of the above expansion , we get the number @xmath149_q\;\in\;\delta_q \ , \ ] ] where @xmath150\subset \mathbb{r}$ ] .
note that @xmath151 .
now , the crucial observation is that the sequence @xmath152 just defined is precisely the orbit of @xmath153 under the piecewise - affine map @xmath154 given by @xmath155 this map is built out of two linear maps of the real line : one expanding ( multiplication by @xmath156 ) , the other contracting ( multiplication by @xmath157 ) ; see figure [ slope ] . through the identification of the endpoints of @xmath158 , the map @xmath159 becomes a ( piecewise affine ) homeomorphism of the circle .
the reader can easily check that @xmath160 , for all @xmath30 .
has at least one zero in its base 3 expansion for all @xmath161 , and as explained by tao in said blog for the collatz case . ]
now we have the following result . [ proptopconj ]
the map @xmath154 is topologically conjugate to the rotation by @xmath162 .
the conjugacy is lipschitz , in fact differentiable except at a single point .
moreover , @xmath159 has an absolutely continuous invariant measure given by @xmath163 let us write @xmath164 in this proof .
first note that @xmath165 where we have used that @xmath166 .
hence , defining @xmath167\to \delta_q$ ] by @xmath168 we see that @xmath169 .
in other words , @xmath170 maps the orbit of @xmath72 under the rotation @xmath171 onto the orbit of @xmath172 under @xmath173 .
this suggests that @xmath170 is a conjugacy between @xmath174 and @xmath173 . to see this ,
let @xmath175 $ ] , and note that there are two possibilities . 1 .
we have @xmath176 : in this case , we have @xmath177 , and therefore @xmath178 2 .
we have @xmath179 : in this case , @xmath180 , and therefore @xmath181 thus , it follows that @xmath182 .
the map @xmath170 is a homeomorphism , as is clear from .
in fact @xmath170 is an analytic diffeomorphism in the open interval @xmath183 . upon identification of the endpoints @xmath72 and @xmath41 , @xmath170 becomes a circle homeomorphism which is differentiable at all points except one , where a break in the derivative occurs .
the absolutely continuous invariant measure @xmath184 for @xmath173 in @xmath158 can be obtained very simply as the push - forward of lebesgue measure @xmath185 in @xmath186 $ ] via @xmath170 . to wit ,
if @xmath187 is borel measurable , we have @xmath188 since from we have @xmath189 it follows that @xmath190 as was to be proved .
[ remalmost ] note that we do _ not _ assume that @xmath162 is irrational in the above theorem .
when @xmath191 is irrational , the orbit of any point under @xmath159 is almost periodic .
hence we have the promised almost periodicity of tails . for a more general result concerning piecewise affine homeomorphisms of the circle , see @xcite . [ largerp ]
the above theorem also holds true when @xmath192 , provided we define @xmath159 appropriately in such cases .
this can be done as follows .
let @xmath121 be such that @xmath193 , and define @xmath194 then , just as before , @xmath154 is a piecewise affine degree - one circle map with rotation number @xmath195 , and this circle map preserves the same measure @xmath184 given in theorem [ proptopconj ] ( _ cf . _ [ sec : further ] ) . in @xcite
, boshernitzan gave an example of a piecewise affine homeomorphism of the unit circle @xmath196 ( seen as the interval @xmath186 $ ] with the endpoints identified ) which preserves the rationals and has only dense orbits .
we remark that our @xmath159 s yield a _ plethora of such examples_. indeed , defining @xmath197\to \delta_q$ ] by @xmath198 , we see that each conjugated map @xmath199 is an example of the type devised by boshernitzan , provided its rotation number @xmath195 is irrational .
let us now present two corollaries of theorem [ proptopconj ] .
in order to state and prove the first corollary , we recall that the _ lower density _ of a subset @xmath200 , is given by @xmath201)\ .\ ] ] one defines the _ upper density _ @xmath202 of @xmath203 in similar fashion , replacing the @xmath204 by @xmath205 .
if the upper and lower densities are equal , then we say that @xmath203 has _
asymptotic density _
recall also that a continuous self - map @xmath173 of a compact metric space @xmath207 is _ uniquely ergodic _ , _
i.e. _ has a unique invariant borel probability measure @xmath184 , if and only if its birkhoff time averages @xmath208 converge uniformly to the space average @xmath209 , for every @xmath210 ( see for instance @xcite ) .
[ rankonedensity ] if @xmath123 are such that @xmath211 is irrational , then the set @xmath212 has asymptotic density equal to @xmath41 .
let @xmath164 and @xmath184 be as in theorem [ proptopconj ] , and let @xmath213 be our special orbit as before . since @xmath173 is lipschitz - conjugate to an irrational rotation , it is uniquely ergodic . for each @xmath214
, let @xmath215 be the set of all points @xmath216 whose base-@xmath3 expansion has at least one digit @xmath72 among its first @xmath19 digits .
then @xmath217 is a finite union of intervals , and its lebesgue measure is easily seen to be @xmath218\ ] ] thus , @xmath219 , and therefore @xmath220 , as @xmath221 .
note that if @xmath222 for some @xmath1 with @xmath223 , then @xmath224 , _
i.e. _ @xmath225 . since @xmath217 is a _
finite _ union of intervals and @xmath184 is a regular borel measure , we can find a continuous function @xmath226 such that @xmath227 everywhere and @xmath228 in particular , for all @xmath229 we have @xmath230 using and the fact that @xmath173 is uniquely ergodic , we deduce that @xmath231 provided @xmath94 is sufficiently large .
hence , combining and , we get @xmath232 for all sufficiently large @xmath94 .
writing @xmath233 , we have just proved that @xmath234 since all but finitely many elements of @xmath235 belong to @xmath203 , it follows that @xmath236 as well , for every @xmath19 .
letting @xmath221 , we deduce that @xmath237 , as desired .
another consequence of theorem [ proptopconj ] is the following explicit formula for the @xmath19-th digit of @xmath122 written in base @xmath3 . if @xmath238 denotes , as in , the @xmath19-th digit from left to right in the base @xmath3 expansion of @xmath122 , then @xmath239 where , as before , @xmath162 and @xmath147 is the number of digits in that expansion .
again , we let @xmath164 .
since @xmath238 is also the @xmath19-th digit of @xmath213 after the decimal point , we can certainly write @xmath240 but by theorem [ proptopconj ] , we have @xmath241 this immediately implies formula .
although it may seem a bit surprising that we have such an explicit formula for the digits @xmath238 , the formula is in practice rather useless for large values of @xmath1 : roughly speaking , evaluating @xmath238 depends on knowing at least the first @xmath1 digits of @xmath162 after the decimal point . at least for bases
@xmath44 , @xmath83 , @xmath242 , and @xmath243 , we have strong computational evidence suggesting the validity of the following conjecture , which ( for base @xmath44 ) is certainly stronger than conjecture [ base3persist ] . [ equaldigits ]
if @xmath3 is not a power of @xmath128 , then for each @xmath244 , we have @xmath245 ( as before , @xmath148 is the number of digits of @xmath122 in base @xmath3 . ) for computational evidence and heuristic arguments supporting this conjecture , see [ sec : compevid ] . if @xmath246 for some @xmath121 , then for every @xmath7 the base @xmath3 expansion of @xmath247 consists of the digit @xmath41 followed by @xmath1 zeros .
this shows that the hypothesis that @xmath3 is not a power of @xmath128 is indeed necessary .
we wish to generalize the results presented in [ sec : erg1 ] to the cases when the base @xmath3 is greater than @xmath83 .
the relevant dynamical system here is no longer the ( semi-)group given by a single piecewise affine degree - one circle map , but rather the ( semi-)group generated by several such maps .
let @xmath248 be the list of all primes smaller than @xmath3 . if @xmath13 is such that @xmath249 , then we can certainly write @xmath250 where @xmath251 .
we can treat the base-@xmath3 expansion of the right - hand side of pretty much in the same way as we treated the digits of @xmath122 in base @xmath3 in [ subsec : ergoz ] . keeping the notation introduced in
[ subsec : ergoz ] , let @xmath252\equiv \mathbb{s}^1 $ ] , and consider the piecewise affine homeomorphisms @xmath253 ( @xmath254 ) defined taking @xmath255 in .
we denote by @xmath256 the group of all piecewise affine homeomorphisms of the interval @xmath257 .
the group @xmath258 generated by @xmath259 is abelian .
let @xmath167\to \delta_q$ ] be the homeomorphism constructed in the proof of theorem [ proptopconj ] .
then for each @xmath260 we have @xmath261 , where @xmath262 and @xmath263 is the corresponding rotation .
since any two circle rotations commute , we have @xmath264 , and therefore @xmath265 as well , so @xmath266 is abelian .
this lemma tells us in particular that we have a well - defined surjective homomorphism @xmath267 given by @xmath268 however , this homomorphism is not necessarily one - to - one ( but see below ) . in any case , we see that @xmath269 acts on the circle in a special way as a group of piecewise - affine homeomorphisms of the circle .
what is the relevance of this action to the study of the sloane map in base @xmath3 ? in order to answer this question , we proceed as in [ subsec : ergoz ] .
let @xmath270_q= \frac{1}{q}\in \delta_q$ ] .
then for each @xmath271 we have @xmath272 where @xmath273 is the number of digits of the base-@xmath3 expansion of the numerator , given by @xmath274 thus , we see that the entire range of values assumed by the sloane map is contained in a single orbit of the action of the semi - group @xmath275
. we shall need the following facts about _ free - abelian _ actions .
let @xmath276 be a free abelian group of rank @xmath71 , with a fixed set of generators @xmath277 .
each @xmath278 has a unique representation @xmath279 with @xmath280 for all @xmath281 .
we write @xmath282 , the _ norm _ of @xmath283 .
we denote by @xmath284 the semigroup consisting of all elements @xmath283 for which @xmath285 for all @xmath260 . for each @xmath93 , let @xmath286 , and let @xmath287 .
now suppose that the group @xmath276 ( or the semigroup @xmath288 ) acts on a probability measure space @xmath289 as a group ( or semigroup ) of measure - preserving transformations ( m.p.t.s ) .
in other words , if @xmath290 denotes the m.p.t .
associated to @xmath278 , then @xmath291 for every @xmath283 ( where the star denotes push - forward of measures ) .
we say that the @xmath276-action ( or @xmath288-action ) on @xmath289 is _ ergodic _ if the only measurable subsets @xmath292 that are invariant under @xmath276 ( or @xmath288 ) _ i.e. _ such that @xmath293 for all @xmath283 are either null - sets or full - measure sets . just as for rank - one measure - preserving actions , there is a multi - dimensional version of birkhoff s ergodic theorem , both in the case of free - abelian groups and free - abelian semigroups .
we state the version for semigroups , which is the relevant one here .
a[multiplebirkhoff ] if the @xmath288-action on @xmath289 is ergodic , then for every @xmath294 and for @xmath184-almost every @xmath295 we have @xmath296 a proof of this theorem can be found in ( * ? ? ?
* ch . 2 ) .
one can also define _ unique ergodicity _ by analogy with the rank - one case .
a @xmath276-action ( or @xmath288-action ) on a compact metric space @xmath207 through continuous maps is _ uniquely ergodic _ if there exists a unique borel probability measure on @xmath207 which is @xmath276-invariant ( or @xmath288-invariant ) . as for rank - one actions
, we have the following fact ( which , once again , we state only for semigroup actions ) .
b[uniqueergod ] if a @xmath288-action by continuous maps on a compact metric space @xmath207 is uniquely ergodic then for every @xmath297 @xmath298 as @xmath299 , where @xmath184 is the unique @xmath288-invariant borel probability measure .
the proof of the analogous statement for rank - one actions as given in , say , @xcite applies _ mutatis mutandis _ to the present case .
the converse of theorem [ uniqueergod ] is also true , but will not be needed here .
now we go back to our investigation of the sloane map .
given a positive integer @xmath94 , let @xmath300 denote the `` cube '' @xmath301 , and let @xmath302 .
the _ lower asymptotic density _ of a subset @xmath303 is defined to be @xmath304 the _ upper asymptotic density _ of @xmath203 , denoted @xmath202 , is similarly defined ( replacing @xmath204 by @xmath205 ) .
we always have @xmath305 . when @xmath306 , this common value is called the _
asymptotic density _ of @xmath203 and it is denoted by @xmath307 .
[ trivdensity ] if the base @xmath3 is not a prime number , then the set @xmath308 has asymptotic density equal to @xmath41 .
since @xmath3 is not a prime , we can certainly write @xmath309 where each @xmath310 . now , if @xmath271 is such that @xmath311 for all @xmath260 , then @xmath3 divides @xmath312 , and therefore @xmath313 .
this shows that @xmath314 .
hence , for every @xmath94 sufficiently large we have @xmath315 and therefore @xmath316 this proves that @xmath237 .
the set @xmath203 in proposition [ trivdensity ] has asymptotic density @xmath41 for trivial reasons : most @xmath27-tuples @xmath317 are such that @xmath311 for all @xmath260
. note that we did not exploit the abelian action introduced in
[ sec : abelact ] .
we will prove in [ sec : secdensity ] below a more refined version of proposition [ trivdensity ] using the ergodic properties of such abelian actions .
our second density result makes use of the group @xmath266 and its action on the circle .
in fact , it will make use of certain subgroups of @xmath266 , which turn out to be _
free abelian_. we will need the following lemma . given @xmath318 , let us denote the subgroup of @xmath266 generated by @xmath319 by @xmath320 .
recall that @xmath262 is the rotation number of @xmath321 [ freeuniqergod ] if the numbers @xmath322 are rationally independent , then @xmath320 is a free abelian group of rank @xmath71 .
moreover , its action on the circle @xmath323 is uniquely ergodic .
suppose @xmath324 is such that @xmath325 from this and the fact that each @xmath321 is conjugate to @xmath326 by the same conjugating map , we have @xmath327 but then @xmath328 . in other words
, there exists @xmath329 such that @xmath330 .
the hypothesis of rational independence implies that @xmath331 .
hence there are no non - trivial relations in @xmath320 .
this shows the group is free abelian as stated .
moreover , at least one of the @xmath332 s must be irrational .
say @xmath333 is irrational ; then @xmath334 , being conjugate to an irrational rotation , is uniquely ergodic .
therefore , _ a fortiori _ , the action of @xmath320 on the circle is uniquely ergodic .
we are now in a position to state and prove our second density result .
this result refines proposition [ trivdensity ] , and in particular covers the case when the base @xmath3 is prime .
[ rankkdensity ] let @xmath318 be chosen so that the numbers @xmath322 are rationally independent .
then for every divisor @xmath335 of @xmath3 , the set @xmath336 has asymptotic density equal to @xmath41 .
things have been set up so that the same argument used in the proof of corollary [ rankonedensity ] can be applied , _
mutatis mutandis_. by lemma [ freeuniqergod ] , the action of the group @xmath337 on the circle @xmath323 is uniquely ergodic ; the unique invariant measure is the measure @xmath184 constructed in theorem [ proptopconj ] .
let us fix the divisor @xmath335 of the base @xmath3 .
we are interested in a particular orbit of the semigroup @xmath338 , namely that of the point @xmath339 .
for each @xmath340 , let us write @xmath341 .
also , denote by @xmath342 the number of digits in the base-@xmath3 expansion of the number @xmath343 .
then , just as in , we have @xmath344 as in the proof of corollary [ rankonedensity ] , for each @xmath214 , let @xmath215 be the set of all points @xmath216 whose base-@xmath3 expansion has at least one digit @xmath72 among its first @xmath19 digits .
as we saw there , @xmath220 as @xmath221 .
let @xmath345 be as in that proof also ; thus , each @xmath346 is continuous and @xmath347 , and @xmath348 the point now as is clear from is that @xmath349 in other words , @xmath350 if and only if @xmath351 for some @xmath352 . by analogy with what we did in the proof of corollary [ rankonedensity ] , for each @xmath214
we define @xmath353 .
note that all but finitely many elements of @xmath235 belong to @xmath203 .
hence , in order to prove that @xmath354 , it suffices to show that @xmath355 as @xmath356 .
since the action of @xmath288 on the circle is uniquely ergodic , combining theorem [ uniqueergod ] with we deduce that , for each fixed @xmath19 and all sufficiently large @xmath94 , @xmath357 since @xmath358 , it follows that @xmath359 for all sufficiently large @xmath94 . letting @xmath360
, this shows that @xmath361 for all @xmath19 , and therefore @xmath355 as @xmath356 , as required .
since in this paper we are primarily interested in the sloane map , in all of the above we have focused on products of prime numbers smaller than the base @xmath3 .
however , most of what we have done goes through when some or all of such primes are greater than @xmath3 .
recall from remark [ largerp ] that if @xmath192 we can still define the circle maps @xmath159 , and these still commute with each other because they all share a common absolutely continuous invariant measure . thus , suppose that @xmath362 is some non - empty finite set of primes , and that not all the prime divisors of @xmath3 are in @xmath362 .
then the set @xmath363 is rationally independent .
therefore the maps @xmath159 for @xmath364 generate a free - abelian group @xmath365 and the action of @xmath365 on the circle @xmath158 is uniquely ergodic ( as in lemma [ freeuniqergod ] , and the proof is the same ) .
moreover , the density result given in theorem [ rankkdensity ] also holds true for the list of primes in @xmath362 .
in particular , the vast majority of products of the form @xmath366 ( with @xmath367 ) have at least one digit zero in their base-@xmath3 expansions . in [ sec : compevid ] we will make a much stronger assertion , in the form of a conjecture , to the effect that the digits in the base-@xmath3 expansions of such products become asymptotically equidistributed as @xmath368 .
to ease many statements to be made in rest of the paper , we will call _ sloane s conjecture _ the positive answer to the question about multiplicative persistence raised by sloane in 1973 .
our goal is to place sloane s conjecture as a consequence of a much more general conjecture concerning long products of primes ( chosen from a given finite set ) . as in [ sec : further ] , let us be given a base @xmath2 and a finite set of primes @xmath362 with the property that not all prime divisors of @xmath3 belong to @xmath362 .
we call such an @xmath362 an _ allowable set of primes for @xmath3_. suppose we play the following game : starting with any given positive integer @xmath369 , we randomly select a sequence @xmath370 of primes in @xmath362 and we use them to generate the sequence of products @xmath371 with @xmath13 .
then it turns out that , regardless of the initial seed @xmath369 and of the sequence of primes selected , the frequency of each digit @xmath372 in @xmath373 always seems to approach @xmath374 as @xmath375 .
more seems to be true , and we formulate the conjecture that was revealed by our numerical computations in the following elementary way .
3[conj : convvtoequi0 ] ( elementary formulation).given an integer @xmath2 , an allowable set of primes @xmath362 for @xmath3 , and a positive integer @xmath369 , consider any of the possible sequences of products defined by setting @xmath376 and then , for each @xmath377 , @xmath378 where each @xmath379 is a element of @xmath362 .
then the digits @xmath380 are asymptotically equidistributed ( their numbers tend to be in equal proportions ) when @xmath375 in the base-@xmath3 representations of these successive @xmath373 s .
furthermore , the same holds true for blocks of consecutive digits of any length , _
i.e. , _ the asymptotic proportion of each block of digits of length @xmath381 is given by @xmath382 , the reciprocal of the number of distinct blocs of length @xmath383 in base @xmath3 .
we remark that when the restriction of allowability is removed ( but @xmath362 remains finite ) it seems that the non - zero digits remain well distributed while the zeros may be much more abundant , which is more than we need in order to get the sloane conjecture as a corollary .
let us give a more precise and more general statement of the above conjecture , expressing it in the language of _
the patterns arising by the multiplication game described above strongly suggest analogy with the dynamics of some simple _ cellular automata _ ( abbreviated @xmath384 ) _
i.e. , _ automorphisms of a shift space that commute with the shift @xcite .
successsive multiplications by any @xmath156 ( or by any sequence of such @xmath128 s ) do not yield a @xmath384 , because of the _ carryover effect _ , but give rise to a close enough object , which we define as follows .
[ quasicellular ] let @xmath2 and let @xmath362 be an allowable set of primes for @xmath3 .
a multiplication automaton ( or @xmath385 ) , with alphabet @xmath386 consists of a finite sequence of primes @xmath387 ( with @xmath7 ) called the multipliers , and two maps , the configuration map @xmath388 and the carryover map @xmath389 satisfying the following rules for all @xmath7 and all @xmath390 : 1 .
@xmath391 ; 2 .
@xmath392 . here
, we assume that the initial row @xmath393 of the configuration map is given , as well as the column @xmath394 of initial carryovers .
we also assume that @xmath395 for all but finitely many values of @xmath260 , and we call the number @xmath396 the _ seed _ of the @xmath385 . note that each row of an automaton has only finitely many non - zero elements ; in other words , for each @xmath13 there exists a smallest @xmath397 such that @xmath398 for all @xmath399 .
if the initial seed is non - zero , then @xmath400 as @xmath375 . despite appearances from the above recursive formulas
, it turns out that the values of the configuration map of a @xmath385 are determined _ purely locally _ , as the following proposition shows .
this further reinforces the similarity of @xmath385 s with @xmath384 s .
[ prop : locality ] in every @xmath385 , the configuration value @xmath401 depends only on the three values @xmath402 and on the multiplier @xmath403 .
we refer to formulas ( i ) and ( ii ) in definition [ quasicellular ] . from (
ii ) with @xmath404 replacing @xmath260 we see that @xmath405 but formula ( i ) with @xmath404 replacing @xmath260 gives us @xmath406 combining and with ( i ) we deduce that @xmath407 \ , , \ ] ] which is the desired result .
the way the @xmath385 operates purely locally as told by proposition [ prop : locality ] is illustrated in part ( a ) of figure [ fig : qauto ] where in each group of positions , the one framed in black is the value of @xmath401 .
it is worth pointing out that @xmath385 s can be interpreted as examples of _ error diffusion _ where the input is the previous line , the modified input is the product of the input by @xmath403 added to the carry over , and the new error is the next carry over ( see @xcite and references therein ) .
incidentally , part ( b ) of the same figure gives the allowed configuration of another automaton , namely the one that describes the evolution along columns ( a simple model of discrete epitaxy ) .
the configurations in part ( c ) of that figure are the forbidden ones resulting in a solid black square when nothing can be computed .
the simplest example of a multiplication automaton relevant to sloane s conjecture is obtained by taking @xmath43 and @xmath408 , choosing @xmath409 as the seed , and setting @xmath410 for all @xmath1 as the initial sequence of carryovers .
note that in this case @xmath411 for all @xmath1 .
the configuration map for this automaton yields the list of all powers of @xmath42 written in base @xmath44 .
this list corresponds to the orbit of @xmath412_3 $ ] under the map
@xmath413 introduced in [ subsec : ergoz ] . in the notation introduced above
, we have @xmath414 for all @xmath1 .
figure 2 exhibits the first 45 rows of this @xmath385 , _
i.e. _ the first 45 powers of 2 ( out of the about 8000 that we have computed ) .
some patterns seen there are reminiscent of those appearing in the simplest @xmath384 s
. another pair of examples is obtained by taking @xmath58 and @xmath415 , setting @xmath410 for all @xmath1 as before , and choosing either @xmath409 or @xmath416 as the seed .
the resulting pair of @xmath385 yields the two sequences @xmath417 and @xmath418 written in base @xmath83 , which are the relevant ones for sloane s conjecture in that base .
these sequences correspond to the orbits of @xmath419_4 $ ] and @xmath420_4 $ ] under successive iterations of the map @xmath421 introduced in [ subsec : ergoz ] .
the 23 first rows of these automata are presented side by side in figure 3 .
a @xmath385 as given in definition [ quasicellular ] can be used as a statistical model for the discrete - time evolution of a mixture of @xmath3 species ( labeled balls , say , or distinct molecules ) with positions at time @xmath1 labeled by the integers @xmath422 .
one is then interested in the asymptotic behavior of the mixture as characterized by the proportions of species populations as @xmath375 .
this analogy with statistical mechanics and the observed patterns in the two examples above ( see figures 2 and 3 ) , as well as in several other examples we have investigated , suggest the following conjecture .
is identically zero . ]
3[conj : convvtoequi ] ( general formulation . )
the configuration map of every multiplication automaton with non - zero seed converges to an equilibrium in the following sense . for each @xmath423 and each @xmath424-block @xmath425
, we have @xmath426 in other words , the populations of the @xmath3 species in the mixture become asymptotically perfectly balanced as time evolves .
figure 4 shows clearly that the proportion of zeros in @xmath88 ( _ i.e. _ , in row @xmath1 of the automaton of example 1 ) goes to one third of the digits when @xmath1 becomes large enough .
of course there are fluctuations in the proportions but the sizes of these fluctuations go to zero , as one would expect in a model of statistical physics .
similar data have been obtained with bases @xmath83 , @xmath242 , and @xmath243 and a variety of allowable sets @xmath362 of prime multipliers . in many cases
, we also checked that the expected asymptotic statistics of _ blocks _ behave according to the conjecture .
besides potential applications to random number generators , conjecture [ conj : convvtoequi ] , if proved true , would yield several interesting corollaries , such as sloane s conjecture for all bases ( as we have already pointed out ) , and other conjectures by erds , furstenberg , and lagarias that are reported in @xcite . to note that in definition [ quasicellular ] we have assumed that the allowable set of primes @xmath362 from which the multipliers are chosen is _
finite_. if this condition is removed , conjecture [ conj : convvtoequi ] becomes false , as the following example shows .
we work in base @xmath45 here , but similar examples can be given in other bases .
recall from elementary number theory that a _ repunit _ is a positive integer whose ( base 10 ) expansion consists of a string of ones , e.g. @xmath427 , etc . if a repunit @xmath428 has @xmath1 digits , then of course @xmath429
let @xmath71 be any integer greater than @xmath41 and consider the infinite sequence of repunits @xmath430 given by @xmath431 then the identity @xmath432 shows that @xmath433 divides @xmath434 , for each @xmath7 .
moreover , since @xmath435 , we see that @xmath434 has at least one prime factor which does not divide @xmath433 .
hence there exist a sequence of primes @xmath370 ( not necessarily distinct , but ranging over infinitely many values ) and a sequence of natural numbers @xmath436 such that @xmath437 for all @xmath1 . but
this means that each @xmath433 appears as a row of the ( generalized ) @xmath385 with base @xmath45 , seed @xmath409 and with @xmath362 being the set of all primes appearing as factors of some @xmath433 , which is infinite as we have shown .
in particular , the line - by - line digits for this automaton can not be asymptotically equidistributed .
therefore conjecture [ conj : convvtoequi ] can fail to hold when @xmath362 is infinite .
written in the decimal system , say , contains infinitely many primes . ]
let us now give an chain of heuristic arguments lending further support in favor of conjecture [ conj : convvtoequi ] .
the heuristics will be formulated for the most part in the context of example 1 above ( @xmath43 and @xmath408 ) .
the key idea is to model the deterministic behaviour of an @xmath385 by a stochastic process .
the irregularities observed in the rows of an @xmath385 are due to the carryover effect , and these will be interpreted as random
. this will be our standing assumption .
stated informally : _ everything is as if all would be random with appropriate distributions_. as pointed out already , we restrict our analysis almost entirely to the @xmath385 of example 1 .
we make the further restriction of looking only at the evolution of the populations of the @xmath44 species given by the single digits @xmath141 .
we ignore , of course , all zeros in positions to the left of the last non - zero digit in each row .
although our multiplication automaton is a _
object , we will model its evolution more precisely the row - by - row evolution ( or growth ) of the population frequencies ( or proportions ) of the digits @xmath141 by a _
stochastic process_. once more , we leave to the reader to see how what we propose here can be extended to the general situation of the conjecture . in the example at hand ,
the passage from row @xmath1 to row @xmath438 of the multiplication automaton involves only multiplication by @xmath42 .
the only possible values of the carryovers are @xmath72 and @xmath41 ; in the general case of multiplication of @xmath439 in base @xmath3 , finding the maximal carryover is indeed the first computation to be done .
thus , for each @xmath440 and each @xmath30 we have either @xmath441 if there is no carryover at the column position @xmath260 , or @xmath442 if there is a carryover at that position .
this means that in each position @xmath260 , the possible transitions of digits from one row to the next are @xmath443 , @xmath444 and @xmath445 without carryover , and @xmath446 , @xmath447 and @xmath448 with carryover .
these spell out the _ incidence matrix _
@xmath449 this suggests that the evolution of the proportions @xmath450 ( with @xmath451 ) of the digits @xmath141 from row to row of the automaton can be modeled by a simple ( homogeneous ) markov chain .
we refer to the column vectors @xmath452 as _ population vectors_. our standing assumption in this context is that _ the allowable transitions from each given state have equal probabilities_. hence this markov chain has as its _ transition matrix _ the doubly stochastic matrix @xmath453 .
the situation is not quite so simple , however , because this proposed scheme fails to take into account the fact that the _ total population _ @xmath147 occasionally increases as we go from row to row ( @xmath400 as @xmath375 ) depending on the leading digit , the multiplication factor , and the carryover inherited there.this growth of population size is our only hope to see the asymptotic equidistribution of digits stated above .
indeed , we know from [ sec : tails ] that the tails of size @xmath454 , namely the blocks @xmath455 ( with @xmath136 ) form a _
periodic sequence_. the same is true of the sequence of @xmath424-blocks @xmath456 for every fixed @xmath457 . hence there is no hope to observe equidistribution of digits along blocks of fixed sizes .
this compels us to change the model slightly , to accommodate the eventual increase in population size .
only two things can happen when we go from row @xmath1 to row @xmath438 : either @xmath458 , _
i.e. _ , the total population size stays the same , or @xmath459 , _
i.e. _ , the total population size grows by @xmath41 .
in the first case , the new proportions at time @xmath438 can be obtained from the old proportions at time @xmath1 by multiplication with the matrix @xmath460 . in the second case
, we can think that the left - most digit at row @xmath1 , namely @xmath461 gives rise not to one , but two new digits at row @xmath438 , namely @xmath462 and @xmath463 .
of these two , the last one is always equal to @xmath41 . since we
either have @xmath464 or @xmath465 , we now either have a non - zero probability of a transition @xmath466 , or the probability of a transition @xmath445 is now slighty greater than @xmath467 . in other words , the new population vector @xmath468 is obtained from the old population vector @xmath469 by multiplication with one of the two stochastic matrices @xmath470 where @xmath471 accounts for the increase of the population of @xmath41 s by one .
summarizing , the evolution of population proportions in each row of the multiplication automaton in example 1 can be modelled by an _
inhomogeneous markov chain _
( imc ) , given by a sequence of stochastic transition matrices @xmath472 and ( column ) probability vectors @xmath473 such that @xmath474 . here ,
each transition matrix @xmath475 .
there is a well - developed theory of imc s ; see for instance @xcite , or @xcite .
as it turns out , convergence to equilibrium as expressed in conjecture [ conj : convvtoequi ] is tantamount , in the present example , to _ strong ergodicity _ of the imc .
let us explain this point .
for each pair of integers @xmath476 , let @xmath477 .
following , @xcite , we say that the imc is _ strongly ergodic _ if there exists a row probability vector @xmath478 such that @xmath479 where the supremum is over all column probability vectors @xmath480 , and where @xmath481 is the so - called _ distance in variation _ , defined by @xmath482 whenever @xmath483 and @xmath484 are ( row ) probability vectors .
recall ( see @xcite , or any standard text on markov chains ) that a _ stationary distribution _ for a stochastic matrix @xmath485 is a column probability vector @xmath486 such that @xmath487 .
we have the following sufficient condition for strong ergodicity , as stated in ( * ? ? ?
6.8.5 ) ( _ cf .
v.4.5 , p. 170 ) ) .
c if each transition matrix @xmath488 has at least one stationary distribution and if there exists a stochastic matrix @xmath489 such that @xmath490 as @xmath375 , then the imc is strongly ergodic . is the _ max - norm _ : if @xmath491 , then @xmath492 . ] the hypotheses in this theorem are met in our example .
indeed , here we clearly see from that @xmath493 and @xmath494 as @xmath495 ; hence we can take @xmath496 .
moreover , an easy computation shows that the probability vectors @xmath497 are stationary distributions for @xmath498 and @xmath499 , respectively .
the heuristic argument just presented supports the validity of conjecture [ conj : convvtoequi ] in the case of example 1 , as long as one accepts the standing assumption stated in the beginning of this section .
the formalism of imc s can be similarly used to treat @xmath385 s with any other bases @xmath3 and allowable sets of multipliers @xmath362 .
the analysis of the two @xmath385 s in example 2 is completely analogous , because in those two cases @xmath415 is still a unitary set .
things become a bit different when @xmath362 has two or more elements . for example , take @xmath500 and @xmath501 . then instead of a single ( unperturbed ) stochastic matrix @xmath460
we now have a pair of such matrices , one for each multiplier : @xmath502 in each of these two matrices , the number of non - zero entries in each row equals the number of possible carryovers ( upon multiplication by the corresponding prime ) .
as we have seen in the previous subsection , in the context of example 1 , each digit @xmath503 in a given position on row @xmath1 of our @xmath385 gives rise to a new digit @xmath504 immediately below it on row @xmath438 , where either @xmath505 or @xmath506 , depending on whether the carryover at that position is @xmath72 or @xmath41 , respectively .
we have stated that , if the carryovers in row @xmath507 are assumed to be randomly placed , then the transition probabilities for the digit transitions @xmath508 are equal to @xmath467 ( hence the stochastic matrix @xmath460 introduced earlier ) . strictly speaking ,
this is not correct .
but as we will see below , the statement is close to being true provided the digits on row @xmath1 are already approximately uniformly distributed in the following ( finite ) sense .
we say that a @xmath71-block @xmath509 _ occurs _ in an @xmath94-block @xmath510 if there exists @xmath511 such that @xmath512 .
an @xmath94-block @xmath513 is said to be @xmath71-balanced ( for a given @xmath71 with @xmath514 ) if for each @xmath71-block @xmath515 the total number of ocurrences of @xmath516 in @xmath517 divided by the total number of @xmath71-blocks occurring in @xmath517 is equal to @xmath518.-blocks is @xmath84 . ]
the rough idea is that if row @xmath1 of our @xmath385 is @xmath71-balanced and we count , for a given allowable transition @xmath508 , how many times this transition occurs when we go from row @xmath1 to row @xmath438 and divide that number by the total number of observed transitions which start with the digit @xmath216 , then this ratio which we call an _ empirical transition probability _ is approximately equal to @xmath467 , with an error which is exponentially small in @xmath71 .
we call this phenomenon _ block protection_. the result can be formulated as follows
. [ protectblock ] if the @xmath1-th row @xmath519 is @xmath71-balanced for some @xmath121 , then the empirical probability @xmath520 of each transition @xmath508 ( computed from the digit transitions @xmath521 ) satisfies @xmath522 . the proof is deferred to appendix [ appendix ] . instead of looking at transitions @xmath508 between digits
, we may consider more generally transitions @xmath523 between blocks @xmath524 of a fixed length @xmath424 . here
@xmath525 lies on row @xmath1 of our @xmath385 while @xmath526 lies on row @xmath438 immediately below @xmath207 . for each given @xmath207
there are two possible values for @xmath527 ( depending on the carryover @xmath528 ) .
one can talk about block protection of such _ blocks _ in the same way we talked about block protection of _ digits_. an exact analogue of proposition [ protectblock ] holds true if we simply replace @xmath216 by @xmath207 and @xmath529 by @xmath527 , and the proof is similar .
the end result is that _ if row @xmath1 of our @xmath385 is @xmath71-balanced _ , then the empirical transition probabilities @xmath530 differ from @xmath467 by an error smaller than @xmath531 ( where @xmath71 is the length of the protecting blocks ) . to be more specific , let @xmath532 be the stochastic matrix that gives the actual transitions of @xmath424-blocks from row @xmath1 to row @xmath438 , and _ assume _ that row @xmath1 is @xmath71-balanced . for @xmath533
there are @xmath534 blocks .
if all allowed transitions were equally likely , we would get the @xmath535 stochastic matrix @xmath536 the actual stochastic matrices @xmath537 differ from the above matrix only in its non - zero entries , and by less than @xmath531 , _ provided row @xmath1 is @xmath71-balanced_. more generally , for arbitrary @xmath424 , if all allowed transitions @xmath523 were equally likely , the associated stochastic matrix would be @xmath538_{1\leq i , j\leq 3^\ell } \ , \ ] ] where @xmath539 stands for kronecker s delta . once again , the actual stochastic matrices @xmath540 differ from the matrix in only in its non - zero entries , and by less than @xmath531 _ if row @xmath1 is @xmath71-balanced_. now we come to the last part of the heuristics .
almost all of what was done in parts i and ii of the heuristics can be rigorously proved .
this is not the case , so far , with the arguments in the present section .
the discussion will be more informal .
the imc formalism as described in [ imcsection ] can only work if the stochastic matrices @xmath540 introduced in
[ sub : heuristic2 ] become asymptotically closer and closer to the corresponding matrices @xmath541 as @xmath495 , for any given @xmath424 .
thus , we need @xmath542 for any block - length @xmath424 .
this is indeed corroborated by our computational evidence .
proposition [ protectblock ] gives us a much weaker , conditional result : _ if _ the @xmath1-th row @xmath373 of our @xmath385 is @xmath71-balanced , _ then _ @xmath543 .
it is of course too much to expect that a row of our @xmath385 will be perfectly @xmath71-balanced .
but it is not difficult to generalize proposition [ protectblock ] so that the expression `` @xmath71-balanced '' is replaced by a suitable concept of `` almost @xmath71-balanced '' ( which can be stated in an appropriate quantitative way ) , so that the estimate in the conclusion is almost the same , with @xmath531 replaced by @xmath544 , say .
let us agree to say that the matrix @xmath540 is _
@xmath71-reasonable _ if @xmath545 .
the stability of the arguments presented so far then tell us that if row @xmath1 of our @xmath385 is almost @xmath71-balanced , then the stochastic matrices @xmath546 , @xmath547 remain @xmath71-reasonable for a certain number @xmath548 of steps .
thus , in order to justify the use of the imc formalism and get a proof of conjecture [ conj : convvtoequi ] ( at least for the case of the @xmath385 of example 1 ) , we need two things : 1 .
to guarantee the possibility of a _ good start _ , _
i.e. , _ a row @xmath1 of our automaton which is almost @xmath71-balanced , for as large a value of @xmath71 as possible .
2 . to make sure that throughout the steps @xmath549 the longer blocks in @xmath550 ( _ i.e. , _ those whose evolutions are not protected by the distributions of even longer blocks ) are not progressively getting too unevenly distributed , with consequences that would then cascade down to shorter and shorter blocks . at least at a rough level ,
point ( 1 ) is not difficult to achieve thanks to our results in [ sec : erg1 ] . indeed , by what we have seen in that section , adding a decimal point in front of @xmath373 ( the @xmath1-row of our @xmath385 ) , we get the orbit @xmath551 of @xmath270_3 $ ] under the circle map @xmath413 .
since all orbits of @xmath413 are dense , given any @xmath71-balanced string @xmath552 ( with @xmath553 ) , there exists @xmath7 such that @xmath554 has the string @xmath527 as its @xmath27-prefix , or head , which we call _
good_. for each such @xmath1 with a good head , the corresponding @xmath373 has a suffix , or tail , of a certain length @xmath457 .
note that we can not choose @xmath457 _ a - priori _ : if one uses the density of orbits of @xmath413 , one is forced to accept the value of @xmath457 imposed by the choice of the good head @xmath527 .
now , as we iterate further and consider the successive rows @xmath555 of the automaton , the tail of length @xmath457 generates a periodic sequence of tails lying beneath it ( all with the same length @xmath457 ) , whereas the heads increase in size .
clearly , the constant character of @xmath457 as @xmath19 increases makes the tails irrelevant in the computation of asymptotic proportions of symbols or other blocks .
the problem then becomes point ( 2 ) above for the heads .
this point is experimentally verified but is mathematically beyond our reach at this writing , contrary to point ( 1 ) as formulated above .
as promised , in this section we prove proposition [ protectblock ] .
the proof will require the two lemmas presented below .
let us fix @xmath121 .
it is an easy consequence of proposition [ prop : locality ] that , for each @xmath556 and each @xmath7 , the element @xmath557 of our @xmath385 is completely determined by the following data : 1 .
the element @xmath401 lying immediately above @xmath557 ; 2 . the @xmath71-block @xmath558 lying to the right of @xmath401 ; 3 .
the carryover @xmath559 , _
i.e. _ the carryover immediately to the right of @xmath560.t in other words , there exists a function @xmath561 such that @xmath562 in fact , the function @xmath563 can be explicitly computed .
define the _ value _ of a @xmath71-block @xmath564 by @xmath565 note that every block @xmath516 is uniquely determined by its value .
we now have the following lemma . for each digit @xmath566 , each @xmath71-block @xmath567 and each carryover @xmath568
, we have @xmath569 the concatenated block @xmath570 has value @xmath571 . in order to compute @xmath572
, we multiply this value by @xmath42 and add the carryover @xmath573 , getting the number @xmath574 .
this number is written in base @xmath44 and the resulting block is placed beneath @xmath575 .
the digit @xmath529 ( immediately below @xmath216 ) is precisely the @xmath71-th digit of @xmath576 from right to left , _
i.e. , _ @xmath577 .
hence we have @xmath578 and this proves .
note that the last term in the right - hand side of is equal to either @xmath72 or @xmath41 .
now , it turns out that @xmath563 is `` almost '' independent of the variable @xmath568 . roughly speaking ,
the only way the carryover @xmath573 to the right of the @xmath71-block @xmath516 can influence the value of the digit @xmath529 immediately below @xmath216 ( on the left of @xmath516 ) is if @xmath516 happens to be the block @xmath579 ( @xmath71 times ) .
every other block will contain in some position a @xmath72 or a @xmath42 ; upon multiplication by @xmath42 these yield @xmath72 and @xmath41 , respectively , and any carryover effect coming from the right of that position will not go through to the left of it .
this is part ( i ) of the following lemma .
[ phiproperties ] the function @xmath563 has the following properties . 1 . if @xmath566 and @xmath580 , then @xmath581 if and only if @xmath582 ; 2 .
if @xmath566 and @xmath504 , then @xmath583 first , let @xmath516 be a @xmath71-block such that @xmath581 .
then from we see that @xmath584 hence we must have simultaneously @xmath585 from these two inequalities we deduce that @xmath586 , and therefore @xmath587 .
this means that @xmath582 .
conversely , if @xmath582 then by a simple computation we see that holds true .
this proves ( i ) . to prove ( ii ) , there are two cases to consider : @xmath588 and @xmath589 . in either case , if @xmath590 then by part ( i ) we have @xmath591 if @xmath588
, then both sides in are equal to @xmath72 , and we get @xmath592 .
the number of blocks @xmath516 satisfying these inequalities is precisely @xmath593 .
if @xmath589 , then both sides in are equal to @xmath41 , and this time we deduce that @xmath594 . the number of blocks @xmath516 satisfying these last inequalities is also @xmath593 .
this finishes the proof . to consider an allowable transition of digits @xmath508 from row @xmath1 to row @xmath438 of our @xmath385 .
we are assuming that row @xmath1 is @xmath71-balanced . in order to compute the empirical probability @xmath520 of such transition
, we need to count how many times this transition happens and divide it by the total number of transitions which start with @xmath216 on row @xmath1 . for this purpose , first we count how many blocks @xmath590 are such that @xmath595 .
the answer is given by lemma [ phiproperties](ii ) : there are @xmath593 such blocks .
since row @xmath1 of our @xmath385 is @xmath71-balanced , the proportion of such blocks in that row is therefore the quotient @xmath596 .
this already tells us that @xmath597 we still have to account for the occurences of the block @xmath582 .
let @xmath598 be such that @xmath599 .
each occurrence of @xmath582 on row @xmath1 for which the carryover immediately to the right of @xmath516 equals @xmath573 contributes to the desired empirical probability .
since the proportion of such occurrences is at most @xmath600 , this shows that @xmath601 combining with we get the inequality in the statement . to to
the authors are grateful to george hentchel for bringing this problem to the attention of c.t . , and for sharing insights on how asymptotic equidistribution of digits would solve sloane s problem in base @xmath44 . | we investigate the so - called persistence problem of sloane , exploiting connections with the dynamics of circle maps and the ergodic theory of @xmath0 actions .
we also formulate a conjecture concerning the asymptotic distribution of digits in long products of finitely many primes whose truth would , in particular , solve the persistence problem .
the heuristics that we propose to complement our numerical studies can be thought in terms of a simple model in statistical mechanics . |
the prediction of many grand unified theories , that nucleon decay occurs at accessible lifetimes , remains unverified but continues to motivate experimental searches .
this expectation was foreshadowed in part by sakharov s early suggestion that the simultaneous effects of baryon number violation , c and cp violation , and departure from thermal equilibrium could produce the baryon - antibaryon asymmetry observed in the universe.@xcite it is interesting and suggestive that no fundamental symmetry is known which implies the conservation of baryon number .
currently , nucleon decay as a consequence of the minimal su(5 ) gut model is considered to be ruled out experimentally@xcite .
however , other unification models , both with and without supersymmetry , predict baryon number violating processes .
amplitudes for these processes involve the exchange of new particles with unknown masses so that precise nucleon lifetimes are not predicted . the expectation that these masses will be in the range between the gut scale of @xmath5 gev and the planck mass of @xmath6 gev leads to proton lifetimes in the range @xmath7 years@xcite .
decay modes with strange particles such as @xmath0 , are usually favored in models which incorporate supersymmetry@xcite .
previous searches for @xmath0 have been reported by the imb , kamiokande and frejus collaborations@xcite .
the @xmath1 track can be imaged in ionization calorimeters such as soudan 2 and frejus , but is usually below cherenkov threshold in water .
imb searched for an excess of events in a region of anisotropy and energy with a large background@xcite .
kamiokande looked for an excess of single ring mu - like events between 215 and 255 mev / c with a muon decay , and also for three - ring events compatible with an invisible , stopped @xmath8 decay@xcite .
frejus used two - track events with ranges consistent with the @xmath1 and the @xmath9@xcite . in the soudan 2 analysis , we use both the visibility of the @xmath1 in a fine grained tracking calorimeter and the visibility of the decay electron from a stopped @xmath9 to reduce backgrounds from atmospheric neutrino interactions .
we searched for the proton decay mode @xmath0 using two @xmath1 decay channels , @xmath10 and @xmath8 .
the soudan 2 detector is a time projection , modular iron tracking calorimeter with a total mass of 974 metric tons and fiducial mass of 770 tons .
details of module construction and performance may be found in references @xcite .
the detector is assembled as a close - packed rectangular stack of 224 modules ; each module is made from 1.6 mm thick sheets of corrugated steel , stacked in a hexagonal honeycomb " structure .
the average density is 1.58 g/@xmath11 . on the walls of the underground cavern surrounding the detector
, there is an active veto " shield comprised of double - layer , hexagonal cell , aluminum proportional tubes@xcite .
two million hytrel plastic drift tubes ( 1.0 m long by 15 mm in diameter ) fill the spaces in the honeycomb stacks .
ionization electrons deposited in an ar / co@xmath12 gas mixture drift toward either end of the tube in a 180 volt / cm electric field with a velocity 0.8 cm/@xmath13sec . upon reaching the tube end , the electrons are detected by vertical anode wires and horizontal cathode strips .
each crossing of a tube by an ionizing particle can create an anode / cathode signal at a common drift time which we call a hit " .
the pulse area , which is proportional to the integrated charge deposited in the tube , and the drift time for each hit are recorded by both the anode and cathode electronics .
the primary trigger requires at least 7 hits , separated by at least 600 ns , in a group of 16 anode channels or at least 8 hits in a group of 16 cathode channels within a @xmath14 @xmath13sec window .
the trigger efficiency for proton decay final states considered here is @xmath15 85% .
the complete detector triggers at a rate of @xmath16 0.5 hz from naturally occurring radioactivity and cosmic ray muons . every 240 seconds a
pulser " trigger provides a snapshot of the random background levels in the main detector .
these are used as underlying events to add detector noise to monte carlo events .
the data analysis proceeds in three stages .
first we identify contained events " .
event prongs are defined by scanning as track - like ( @xmath17 , @xmath13 or p ) or shower - like ( e or @xmath18 ) .
contained events are defined as having no hits on tracks or the main body of showers which are less than 20 cm from the outside surface of the detector and the prongs do not start or end between modules .
this is the same contained event selection as was used for our atmospheric neutrino analysis @xcite .
studies in reference @xcite showed that the efficiency for correct identification was 98% for tracks and 94% for showers .
an absence of shield activity was required .
second , the events are required to have a topology consistent with the proton decay channel under study , based on counting the number of visible tracks and showers . finally , kinematic selections which characterize a particular proton decay mode are applied to the data and also to event samples which monitor background processes .
the analysis procedure involves finding efficient selection criteria using our proton decay monte carlo program , while minimizing the backgrounds from atmospheric neutrinos and atmospheric muons .
the former backgrounds are calculated using the atmospheric neutrino monte carlo program described in reference @xcite , which incorporates the flux predictions of barr , gaisser and stanev@xcite .
backgrounds from atmospheric muons may result when muons inelastically scatter in the rock outside the active shield .
we use the term rock " event to describe the interactions of a resulting secondary such as a neutron or @xmath19 which goes into the soudan 2 calorimeter and causes a contained vertex event .
most rock events have hits in the soudan 2 shield which are time - coincident with the contained event in the calorimeter .
these shield - tagged events are used to estimate any background from rock events without shield tags .
a detailed analysis of the penetration depth distributions of events with and without shield hits has led to the conclusion that @xmath20 of all rock events have shield tags .
[ sec : pdepth ] our monte carlo simulation program tracks the decay products through the detector geometry and generates electronic hits in the same format as real data .
the generator starts with a parent ( or target ) nucleon within a nucleus .
the nucleon is considered to have a fermi momentum chosen from the bodek and ritchie parameterization@xcite .
the spatial location and the atomic number of the parent nucleus is chosen according to the composition and mass distribution of the detector .
the rescattering of pions within a parent nucleus is generated according to a phenomenological model@xcite .
parameters of the model have been set to reproduce pion production by low energy neutrinos in @xmath21-ne and @xmath21-deuteron reactions@xcite .
inelastic intranuclear rescattering for @xmath1 mesons is not expected to be significant due to the absence of low - lying @xmath22 resonances and is not simulated .
the detector response used in this monte carlo program was verified against calibration data from the isis facility using @xmath17 , e , @xmath13 and p beams at a variety of angles and energies@xcite . to choose the selection criteria and determine efficiencies we generated a large sample of @xmath10 monte carlo events from proton decay .
features of the typical monte carlo event shown in figure [ fig : pnk ] include a highly ionizing @xmath1 which ( usually ) comes to rest , and emits a 236 mev / c @xmath9 .
the @xmath9 has an average range of 42 cm in the soudan 2 detector . at the end of its range
, the @xmath24 of the muon is rising .
the @xmath9 comes to rest and decays into an @xmath25 , which gives an average of 3 hits .
the results of the analysis for the proton decay simulation , the neutrino simulation , the data , and the shield - tagged rock background are given in table [ tab : effpnk ] .
the simulated events are generated in the entire mass of the soudan 2 detector .
efficiencies within the fiducial mass are calculated by dividing the fraction of events which pass a set of cuts by the ratio of the fiducial mass to the total mass ( 0.79 ) .
the monte carlo events were first subjected to a simulated trigger , which 81 events failed .
both monte carlo and data events were processed through a filter program which applied containment criteria , reducing cosmic ray muons by a factor of more than @xmath26 .
114 mc events , essentially all with hits outside the containment volume , were rejected .
the remaining events were then scanned by physicists to remove the remaining non - contained events , mostly events starting or ending on module boundaries . at this stage
, 204 @xmath23 events remained , compared with 367 data events without shield hits , 1008 shield - tagged rock events , and 1923 events from the atmospheric neutrino monte carlo .
the data corresponds to 3.56 fiducial kiloton - years of exposure , compared to 20.24 kiloton - years for the atmospheric neutrino mc .
the required topology is two charged tracks with a common vertex .
events in which both tracks appear to be protons based on ionization and straightness are not included .
these topology features were exhibited by 95 of the remaining 204 events from the mc .
we also require that the @xmath1 candidate , which is usually the shorter track , has a length less than 50 cm .
the muon track length distributions for all four event samples at this stage of the analysis are shown in figure [ fig : muran ] .
the range of muons from the @xmath27 decay is peaked at 43 cm whereas the background distributions are relatively flat .
the muon range was therefore required to lie between 29 and 58 cm .
our final cut requires a visible muon decay electron having two or more hits .
this requirement discriminates strongly against neutrino induced background , since the predominant background is @xmath28 and in our iron detector most @xmath29 are absorbed rather than decay after stopping .
after all cuts , our efficiency for accepting @xmath23 events in the fiducial volume is 14% .
two atmospheric @xmath30 monte carlo events pass all of the cuts and represent an expected background of 0.21 events , taking into account that we found the atmospheric neutrino flavor ratio ( @xmath31 ) to be only 0.61 of the expected value@xcite .
the rock event background in the zero shield hit sample is calculated to be 0.19 events .
this was found based on the penetration depth analysis mentioned above , which found background in the track data equal to 9.5% of the shield - tagged track sample .
as shown in table [ tab : effpnk ] , one event in the data survives our cuts .
= 6.0 in .numbers of mc and data candidate events for @xmath23 which survive the triggering , containment , topology , and kinematic cuts of this analysis .
events are generated in the full detector , while efficiencies in table 3 are quoted for the fiducial volume . [ cols="<,>,>,>,>",options="header " , ] .
the kamiokande collaboration@xcite has reported a limit for @xmath0 of @xmath32 years with 9 candidate events and an estimated background of 7.3 events .
their unsubtracted limit is @xmath33 years .
imb has reported a limit without background subtraction of @xmath34 years with 6 candidate events and an estimated background of 4.7 .
more recently , they report @xmath35 years without a background subtraction based on 14 candidates@xcite . with background subtraction of 21.4 events , they calculated their limit to be @xmath36 years .
frejus has reported a background subtracted limit of @xmath37 years with 1 candidate and an estimated background of 1.8 . in all experiments , the largest contribution to the estimated background comes from @xmath21 quasielastic scattering .
the existence of the atmospheric neutrino @xmath21 deficit then calls into question the reliability of background estimates in all of these experiments .
it is not clear that rescaling the total @xmath21 rate to the observed rate leads to a correct estimate of the background for proton decay in this channel , since whatever is causing the atmospheric @xmath21 deficit may be energy dependent or different for @xmath21 and @xmath38 .
we note the possibility of such differences by comparing plots 2b and 2c .
we would assign a resulting systematic error of as much as 100% to the background estimates for this channel . in view of this large systematic error
we distrust the background subtraction in this channel and prefer to rely on the unsubtracted limit , which is unaffected by the background uncertainly .
we note that the background level in this analysis , and thus the importance of background subtraction , is an order of magnitude lower than in the water cherenkov experiments . in summary ,
we have searched for the proton decay mode @xmath0 using two decay modes of the @xmath1 , @xmath10 and @xmath8 .
we observe one candidate event for @xmath10 and zero candidates for @xmath8 ; the estimated backgrounds are 0.40 events and 1.14 events respectively .
our combined lower lifetime limit at 90% cl is @xmath39 years .
our limit with background subtraction is @xmath40 years .
this work was undertaken with the support of the u.s .
department of energy , the state and university of minnesota and the u.k .
particle physics and astronomy research council .
we wish to thank the following for their invaluable help with the soudan 2 experiment : the staffs of the collaborating laboratories ; the minnesota department of natural resources for allowing us to use the facilities of the soudan underground mine state park ; the staff of the park , particularly park managers d. logan and p. wannarka , for their day to day support ; and messrs b. anderson , j. beaty , g. benson , d. carlson , j. eininger and j. meier of the soudan mine crew for their work in the installation and running of the experiment .
sakharov , zh .
pisma 5 ( 1967 ) 32 ( jetp lett . 5 ( 1967 )
hirata et al . , _ kamiokande collaboration _ , phys .
b220 ( 1989 ) 308 .
r. becker - szendy et al .
, _ imb collaboration _ , phys .
d42 ( 1990 ) 2974 .
j. hisano , h. murayama , and t. yanagida , nucl .
b402 ( 1993 ) 46 .
j. wess and b. zumino , nucl . phys .
b70 ( 1974 ) 39 ; phys .
b49 ( 1974 ) 52 .
nath , a.h .
chamseddine , and r. arnowitt , phys .
d32 ( 1985 ) 2348 .
t. haines et al . , _ imb collaboration _ , phys .
( 1986 ) 1986 .
berger et al .
, _ frejus collaboration _ , nucl .
phys . b313 ( 1989 ) 509 .
allison et al .
instr . meth .
a376 ( 1996 ) 36 .
allison et al .
instr . meth .
a381 ( 1996 ) 385 .
h. gallagher , neutrino oscillation searches with the soudan 2 detector , phd thesis , university of minnesota 1996 .
oliver et al . , nucl .
instr . meth . a 276 ( 1989 ) 371 .
allison et al . ,
b391 , ( 1997 ) 491 .
g. barr , t.k .
gaisser and t. stanev , phys .
d39 ( 1989 ) 3532 .
a. bodek and j. ritchie , phys rev .
d23 ( 1981 ) 1070 .
mann et al .
, intranuke : a phenomenological code for pion rescattering within an extended nucleus , soudan 2 internal note , pdk-377 ( 1988 ) , unpublished ; w. leeson et al . , nucleon decay final state effects from fermi motion and from intranuke , soudan 2 internal note pdk-678 ( 1997 ) , unpublished .
r. merenyi et al .
rev . d45 ( 1992 ) 743 and r. merenyi , a study of intranuclear scattering in @xmath21 ne versus @xmath21 d interactions : implications for nucleon decay searches , phd thesis , tufts university , 1990 . c. garcia - garcia , el experimento de soudan 2 para el estudio de la establilidad de la materia : interacciones de neutrinos , ph.d .
thesis , universidad de valencia , 1990 .
gallagher , talk to appear in proceedings of win97 , capri , italy , june 1997 ; t. kafka , talk to appear in proceedings of taup 97 , lngs , assergi , italy , september 1997 . c. mcgrew et al .
, _ imb collaboration _ , submitted to physical review , 1997 . | we have searched for the proton decay mode @xmath0 using the one - kiloton soudan 2 high resolution calorimeter . contained events obtained from a 3.56 kiloton - year fiducial exposure through june 1997 are examined for occurrence of a visible @xmath1 track which decays at rest into @xmath2 or @xmath3 .
we found one candidate event consistent with background , yielding a limit , @xmath4 years at 90% cl with no background subtraction .
-.68 in -1.0 in 6.5 in 9.0 in , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
anomaly - mediated supersymmetry breaking ( amsb ) models have received much attention in the literature due to their attractive properties@xcite : the soft supersymmetry ( susy ) breaking terms are completely calculable in terms of just one free parameter ( the gravitino mass , @xmath11 ) , the soft terms are real and flavor invariant , thus solving the susy flavor and @xmath12 problems , the soft terms are actually renormalization group invariant@xcite , and can be calculated at any convenient scale choice . in order to realize the amsb set - up , the hidden sector must be `` sequestered '' on a separate brane from the observable sector in an extra - dimensional universe , so that tree - level supergravity breaking terms do not dominate the soft term contributions .
such a set - up can be realized in brane - worlds , where susy breaking takes place on one brane , with the visible sector residing on a separate brane .
the soft susy breaking ( ssb ) terms arise from the rescaling anomaly . in spite of its attractive features ,
amsb models suffer from the well - known problem that slepton mass - squared parameters are found to be negative , giving rise to tachyonic states . the original solution to this problem
is to suppose that scalars acquire as well a universal mass @xmath13 , which when added to the amsb ssb terms , renders them positive .
thus , the parameter space of the `` minimal '' amsb model ( mamsb ) is given by m_0 , m_3/2 , , sign ( ) .
an alternative set - up for amsb has been advocated in ref .
@xcite , known as hypercharged anomaly - mediation ( hcamsb ) .
it is a string motivated scenario which uses a similar setup as the one envisioned for amsb . in hcamsb ,
susy breaking is localized at the bottom of a strongly warped hidden region , geometrically separated from the visible region where the mssm resides .
the warping suppresses contributions due to tree - level gravity mediation@xcite and the anomaly mediation@xcite can become the dominant source of susy breaking in the visible sector .
possible exceptions to this sequestering mechanism are gaugino masses of @xmath14 gauge symmetries @xcite .
thus , in the mssm , the mass of the bino the gaugino of @xmath15 can be the only soft susy breaking parameter not determined by anomaly mediation@xcite . depending on its size
, the bino mass @xmath16 can lead to a small perturbation to the spectrum of anomaly mediation , or it can be the largest soft susy breaking parameter in the visible sector : as a result of rg evolution its effect on other soft susy breaking parameters can dominate the contribution from anomaly mediation . in extensions of the mssm , additional @xmath17s can also communicate susy breaking to the mssm sector @xcite .
besides sharing the same theoretical setup , anomaly mediation and hypercharge mediation cure phenomenological shortcomings of each other .
the minimal amsb model predicts a negative mass squared for the sleptons ( and features relatively heavy squarks ) . on the other hand ,
the pure hypercharge mediation suffers from negative squared masses for stops and sbottoms ( and features relatively heavy sleptons ) : see sec .
[ sec : pspace ] . as a result
, the combination of hypercharge and anomaly mediation leads to phenomenologically viable spectra for a sizable range of relative contributions @xcite .
we parametrize the hcamsb ssb contribution @xmath18 using a dimensionless quantity @xmath2 such that @xmath19 so that @xmath2 governs the size of the hypercharge contribution to soft terms relative to the amsb contribution .
then the parameter space of hcamsb models is given by , m_3/2 , , sign ( ) . in the hcamsb model , we assume as usual that electroweak symmetry is broken radiatively by the large top - quark yukawa coupling . then the ssb @xmath20 term and the superpotential @xmath21 term are given as usual by the scalar potential minimization conditions which emerge from requiring an appropriate breakdown of electroweak symmetry .
in hcamsb , we take the ssb terms to be of the form : m_1 & = & _ 1+m_3/2,m_a & = & m_3/2 , a=2 , 3 m_i^2 & = & -14\ { _ g+_f}m_3/2 ^ 2 a_f & = & m_3/2 , where @xmath22 , @xmath23 is the beta function for the corresponding superpotential coupling , and @xmath24 with @xmath25 the wave function renormalization constant .
the wino and gluino masses ( @xmath26 and @xmath27 ) receive a contribution from the bino mass at the two loop level .
thus , in pure hypercharge mediation , they are one loop suppressed compared to the scalar masses .
for convenience , we assume the above ssb mass parameters are input at the gut scale , and all weak scale ssb parameters are determined by renormalization group evolution . we have included the above hcamsb model into the isasugra subprogram of the event generator isajet v7.79@xcite . after input of the above parameter set ,
isasugra then implements an iterative procedure of solving the mssm rges for the 26 coupled renormalization group equations , taking the weak scale measured gauge couplings and third generation yukawa couplings as inputs , as well as the above - listed gut scale ssb terms .
isasugra implements full 2-loop rg running in the @xmath28 scheme , and minimizes the rg - improved 1-loop effective potential at an optimized scale choice @xmath29@xcite to determine the magnitude of @xmath21 and @xmath30 .
all physical sparticle masses are computed with complete 1-loop corrections , and 1-loop weak scale threshold corrections are implemented for the @xmath31 , @xmath32 and @xmath33 yukawa couplings@xcite .
the off - set of the weak scale boundary conditions due to threshold corrections ( which depend on the entire superparticle mass spectrum ) , necessitates an iterative up - down rg running solution .
the resulting superparticle mass spectrum is typically in close accord with other sparticle spectrum generators@xcite . once the weak scale sparticle mass spectrum is known , then sparticle production cross sections and branching fractions may be computed , and collider events may be generated .
then , signatures for hcamsb at the cern lhc may be computed and compared against standard model ( sm ) backgrounds .
our goal in this paper is to characterize the hcamsb parameter space and sparticle mass spectrum , and derive consequences for the cern lhc @xmath34 collider , which is expected to begin operation in fall , 2009 .
some previous investigations of mamsb at lhc have been reported in ref .
@xcite .
the remainder of this paper is organized as follows . in sec .
[ sec : pspace ] , we calculate the allowed parameter space of hcamsb models , imposing various experimental and theoretical constraints .
we also show sample mass spectra from hcamsb models , and show their variation with @xmath2 and @xmath11 .
we show typical values of @xmath35 and @xmath36 that result . in sec .
[ sec : lhc ] , we explore consequences of the hcamsb model for lhc sparticle searches .
typically , collider events are characterized by production of high @xmath37 @xmath32 and @xmath31 quarks , along with @xmath38 and observable tracks from late decaying charginos @xmath39 . for small @xmath2
, slepton pair production may be visible , while for large @xmath2 , direct @xmath40 and @xmath41 production may be visible .
the lhc reach for 100 fb@xmath3 should extend up to @xmath42 ( 105 ) tev , corresponding to a reach in @xmath43 ( 2.2 ) tev , for small ( large ) values of @xmath2 .
the hcamsb model should be easily distinguishable from the mamsb model at the lhc if @xmath6 is not too large , due to the presence of @xmath44 candidates in cascade decay events .
the presence of these reflects the mass ordering @xmath0 in the hcamsb model , while @xmath45 in the mamsb model . in sec .
[ sec : conclude ] , we present our conclusions and outlook for hcamsb models .
we begin our discussion by plotting out in fig . [
fig : m10 ] the mass spectra of various sparticles versus _ a _ ) .
@xmath46 in mamsb and _ b _ ) .
@xmath2 in the hcamsb model , for @xmath11 fixed at 50 tev , while taking @xmath47 , @xmath48 and @xmath49 gev . for @xmath13 and @xmath50
, the yellow - shaded region yields the well - known tachyonic slepton mass - squared values , which could lead to electric charge non - conservation in the scalar potential . in mamsb , as @xmath13 increases , all the scalars increase in mass , while @xmath51 , @xmath52 and @xmath53 remain roughly constant , and the superpotential @xmath21 term decreases .
the large @xmath13 limit of parameter space is reached around @xmath54 , where ewsb is no longer properly broken ( signaled by @xmath55 ) .
we also see the well - known property of mamsb models that @xmath56 .
in addition , an important distinction between the two models is the mass ordering which enters into the neutralino mass matrix : we find typically that @xmath0 in the hcamsb model , while @xmath1 in mamsb . thus , both models will have a wino - like @xmath57 state .
however , in the hcamsb model , the @xmath58 are dominantly higgsino - like states , with @xmath59 being bino - like , while in the mamsb model , we expect @xmath60 to be bino - like with @xmath61 being higgsino - like .
this mass ordering difference will give rise to a crucial distinction in lhc susy cascade decay events ( see sec .
[ sec : lhc ] ) which may serve to distinguish the two models . in the hcamsb case , as @xmath2 increases , the gut scale gaugino mass @xmath16 increases .
thus , the bino mass increases with @xmath2 , while the light charginos @xmath39 and neutralino @xmath57 remain wino - like with mass fixed near @xmath26 , and the gluino remains with mass fixed at nearly @xmath62 .
many of the scalar masses also vary with @xmath2 .
the reason is that as @xmath2 increases , so does the gut scale value of @xmath16 .
the large value of @xmath16 feeds into the scalar masses via their renormalization group equations , causing many of them to increase with @xmath2 , with the largest increases occurring for the scalars with the largest weak hypercharge assignments @xmath63 .
thus , we see strong increases in the @xmath64 , @xmath65 and especially the @xmath66 masses with increasing @xmath67 .
the @xmath68 squark only receives a small increase in mass , since its hypercharge value is quite small : @xmath69 . from fig .
[ fig : m10]_b _ ) .
, we already see an important distinction between mamsb and hcamsb models : in the former case , the @xmath65 and @xmath66 states are nearly mass degenerate , while in the latter case these states are highly split , with @xmath70 .
an exception to the mass increase with @xmath2 in fig .
[ fig : m10]_b _ ) . occurs in the values of @xmath71 and @xmath72 . in these cases ,
the large increase in @xmath73 feeds into the rge @xmath74 term@xcite , and _ amplifies _ the top - quark yukawa coupling suppression of the @xmath75 term .
since the doublet @xmath76 contains both the @xmath77 and @xmath78 states , both of these actually suffer a _ decrease _ in mass with increasing @xmath2 .
thus , we expect in hcamsb models with moderate to large @xmath2 that the third generation squark states will be highly split . for large @xmath67
, we expect the light third generation squarks @xmath79 and @xmath80 to be quite light , with a dominantly left- squark composition
. the heavier squarks @xmath81 and @xmath82 will be quite heavy , and dominantly right - squark states .
in addition , we see from fig . [ fig : m10]_b _ ) . that the superpotential @xmath21 term _ decreases _ with increasing @xmath2 .
at moderate - to - large @xmath6 , the @xmath21 term is from the tree - level scalar potential minimization conditions @xmath83 .
the running of @xmath84 versus energy scale @xmath85 is shown in fig .
[ fig : mhu ] for @xmath86 and 0.195 .
we see that as @xmath2 increases , the value of @xmath87 actually decreases , leading to a small @xmath88 value .
the relevant rge reads = ( - g_1 ^ 2m_1 ^ 2 -3g_2 ^ 2m_2 ^ 2 + g_1 ^ 2 s+3f_t^2 x_t ) .
a large value of @xmath16 thus leads to an _ upwards _ push to @xmath84 in its early running from @xmath89 , which is only later compensated by the downward push of the yukawa - coupling term involving the top yukawa coupling @xmath90 . in the figure , for the case of @xmath91 , the weak scale value of @xmath84 is actually positive . upon adding the large 1-loop corrections to the effective potential ( due to the light top - squark ) ,
the rg - improved scalar potential yields a positive value of @xmath88 .
thus , in the region of large @xmath2 , where @xmath21 becomes small and comparable to @xmath26 , we expect the neutralino @xmath57 to become a mixed wino - higgsino particle , and the corresponding @xmath92 mass gap to increase beyond the value @xmath93 mev which is expected in amsb models@xcite .
parameter as a function of energy scale @xmath85 for @xmath94 , @xmath95 and @xmath96 for @xmath97 tev and @xmath47 , @xmath48 in the hcamsb model . ,
scaledwidth=50.0% ] an interesting coincidence related to the rg evolution of @xmath84 in the limit where hypercharge mediation dominates is that the electroweak symmetry breaking _ requires _ the electroweak scale to be @xmath98 orders of magnitude below the scale @xmath99 ( @xmath99 may be of order the gut scale or string scale ) at which the bino mass @xmath16 is generated .
if the hierarchy between the electroweak scale and @xmath99 was smaller , then a susy breaking scenario in which hypercharge mediation dominates would not be capable of triggering ewsb ( the energy interval for rg evolution would not be large enough to drive the @xmath84 parameter to negative values ) .
this is a very uncommon feature among susy breaking scenarios . for a more detailed comparison ,
we list in table [ tab : cases ] the sparticle mass spectrum for a mamsb point with @xmath100 gev , @xmath97 tev , @xmath47 and @xmath48 , and two hcamsb points with small and large @xmath2 values equal to @xmath101 and @xmath96 .
while all three cases have a comparable gluino mass , we see that the rather small splitting amongst @xmath102 and also @xmath103 states in mamsb is turned to large left - right splitting in the hcamsb cases .
we also see that the @xmath104 mev mass gap in amsb and hcamsb1 which leads to long - lived and possibly observable @xmath105 tracks in collider detectors opens up to a few gev in the hcamsb2 case .
the latter mass gap is large enough to make the @xmath105 state less long lived , although still maintaining possibly measureable tracks in collider scattering events .
the value of @xmath106 versus @xmath2 is shown in fig . [
fig : ctau ] , where we usually get @xmath107 mm for most @xmath2 values .
the value drops to shorter lengths for large @xmath2 .
the shorter travel time of the @xmath105 would distinguish the large @xmath2 hcamsb case with a mixed higgsino - wino @xmath57 state from the low @xmath2 hcamsb case where @xmath57 is instead nearly pure wino - like .
.masses and parameters in gev units for three case study points amsb , hcamsb1 and hcamsb2 using isajet 7.79 with @xmath49 gev and @xmath48 .
we also list the total tree level sparticle production cross section in fb at the lhc . [ cols="<,^,^,^",options="header " , ]
in this paper , we have examined some phenomenological consequences of hypercharged anomaly - mediated susy breaking models at the lhc .
we have computed the expected sparticle mass spectrum , and mapped out the relevant parameter space of the hcamsb model .
we have computed sparticle branching fractions , production cross sections and expected lhc collider events , and compared against expectations for sm backgrounds .
our main result was to compute the reach of the lhc for hcamsb models assuming 100 fb@xmath3 of integrated luminosity .
we find an lhc reach to @xmath42 tev ( corresponding to @xmath43 tev ) for low values of @xmath2 , and a reach to @xmath108 tev ( corresponding to @xmath109 tev ) for large @xmath2 .
we expect the reach for @xmath110 to be similar to the reach for @xmath48 , due to similarities in the spectra for the two cases ( see fig .
[ fig : m10 ] . )
we also expect the reach for large @xmath6 to be similar to the reach for low @xmath6 in the @xmath111 and @xmath112 channels ( differences in the multi - lepton channels can occur due to enhanced -ino decays to taus and @xmath32s at large @xmath6 ) .
the lhc reach for hcamsb models tends to be somewhat lower than the reach for mamsb models , where ref .
@xcite finds a 100 fb@xmath3 reach of @xmath113 tev for low values of @xmath13 .
this is due in part because , in mamsb , the various squark states are more clustered about a common mass scale @xmath13 , while in hcamsb the squark states are highly split , with @xmath114 .
the hcamsb lhc event characteristics suffer similarities and differences with generic mamsb models .
both hcamsb and mamsb give rise to multi - jet plus multi - lepton plus @xmath38 event topologies , and within these event classes , it is expected that occasional hits of length a few _ cm _ will be found , arising from production of the long - lived wino - like chargino states .
some of the major differences between the models include the following .
a severe left - right splitting of scalar masses is expected in hcamsb , while left - right scalar degeneracy tends to occur in mamsb .
this may be testable if some of the slepton states are accessible to lhc searches .
it is well known that in mamsb , @xmath56 , while in hcamsb , @xmath115 , since the @xmath66 state has a large weak hypercharge quantum number .
in addition , the lightest stau state , @xmath116 , is expected to be mainly a left- state in hcamsb , while it is mixed , but mainly a right- state in mamsb . while it is conceivable that the left - right mixing might be determined at lhc ( using branching fractions or tau energy distributions ) ,
such measurements would be easily performed at a linear @xmath117 collider , especially using polarized beams@xcite . in hcamsb models ,
the light third generation squarks @xmath79 and @xmath80 are expected to be generically lighter than the gluino mass , and frequently much lighter .
this leads to cascade decays which produce large multiplicities of @xmath32 and @xmath31 quarks in the final state .
thus , in hcamsb models , a rather high multiplicity of @xmath32 jets is expected . in mamsb ,
a much lower mutiplicity of @xmath32-jets is expected , although this depends also on the value of @xmath6 which is chosen . in hcamsb models ,
the @xmath14 gaugino mass @xmath16 is expected to be the largest of the gaugino masses , with a mass hierarchy of @xmath0 .
this usually implies that the @xmath59 neutralino is mainly bino - like , while @xmath60 and @xmath118 are higgsino - like , and @xmath57 is wino - like .
in contrast , in the mamsb model , usually the ordering is that @xmath1 , so that while @xmath57 is again wino - like , the @xmath60 state is bino - like , and @xmath118 and @xmath59 are higgsino - like .
the compositions of the @xmath119 for @xmath120 will not be easy to determine at lhc , but will be more easily determined at a linear @xmath117 collider .
however , the mass ordering gives rise to os dilepton distributions with a prominent @xmath121 peak in hcamsb , while such a peak should be largely absent in mamsb models ( except at large @xmath6 where there is greater mixing in the neutralino sector ) .
thus , cascade decay events containing hits along with a @xmath121 peak in the os dilepton invariant mass distribution may be a smoking gun signature for hcamsb models at the lhc , at least within the lower range of @xmath6 .
this work was supported in part by the u.s .
department of energy .
99 l. randall and r. sundrum , _ nucl .
* b 557 * ( 1999 ) 79 ; g. giudice , m. luty , h. murayama and r. rattazzi , _ j. high energy phys .
_ * 12 * ( 1998 ) 027 .
i. jack and d. r. t. jones , _ phys .
* b 465 * ( 1999 ) 148 .
r. dermisek , h. verlinde and l - t .
wang , _ phys .
* 100 * ( 2008 ) 131804 .
s. kachru , l. mcallister and r. sundrum , _ j. high energy phys .
_ * 0710 * ( 2007 ) 013
. h. verlinde , l - t .
wang , m. wijnholt and i. yavin , _ j. high energy phys . _ * 0802 * ( 2008 ) 082 ; m. buican , d. malyshev , d. r. morrison , h. verlinde and m. wijnholt , _ j. high energy phys . _ * 0701 * ( 2007 ) 107 .
p. langacker , g. paz , l. t. wang and i. yavin , _ phys .
_ * 100 * ( 2008 ) 041802 .
f. paige , s. protopopescu , h. baer and x. tata , hep - ph/0312045 .
h. e. haber , r. hempfling and a. hoang , _
z. phys .
* c*_*75 * ( 1997 ) 539 .
d. pierce , j. bagger , k. matchev and r. zhang , _ nucl .
* b 491 * ( 1997 ) 3 .
g. belanger , s. kraml and a. pukhov , _ phys .
* d 72 * ( 2005 ) 015003 .
t. gherghetta , g. giudice and j. wells , _ nucl .
* b 559 * ( 1999 ) 27 ; j. l. feng , t. moroi , l. randall , m. strassler and s. su , _ phys .
_ * 83 * ( 1999 ) 1731 ; j. l. feng and t. moroi , _ phys . rev . _
* d 61 * ( 2000 ) 095004 ; f. paige and j. wells , hep - ph/0001249 ; a. datta and k. huitu , _ phys .
rev . _ * d 67 * ( 2003 ) 115006 ; s. asai , t. moroi , k. nishihara and t. t. yanagida , _ phys . lett . _ * b 653 * ( 2007 ) 81 ; s. asai , t. moroi and t. t. yanagida , _ phys . lett . _
* b 664 * ( 2008 ) 185 .
h. baer , j. k. mizukoshi and x. tata , _ phys .
* b 488 * ( 2000 ) 367 .
a. j. barr , c. lester , m. parker , b. allanach and p. richardson , _ j. high energy phys . _ * 0303 * ( 2003 ) 045 .
see h. baer and x. tata , _ weak scale supersymmetry : from superfields to scattering events _ , ( cambridge university press , 2006 ) h. c. cheng , b. dobrescu and k. matchev , _ nucl .
phys . _ * b 543 * ( 1999 ) 47 .
r. dermisek and h. d. kim , _ phys .
lett . _ * 96 * ( 2006 ) 211803 .
r. dermisek , _ mod .
lett . _ * a 24 * ( 2009 ) 1631 .
lepsusywg , note lepsusywg/02 - 04.1 .
h. baer , c. h. chen , f. paige and x. tata , _ phys .
rev . _ * d 49 * ( 1994 ) 3283 .
h. baer and m. brhlik , _ phys . rev . _
* d 55 * ( 1997 ) 3201 ; h. baer , m. brhlik , d. castano and x. tata , _ phys .
* d 58 * ( 1998 ) 015007 .
m. misiak _ et al .
_ , _ phys . rev . lett .
_ * 98 * ( 2007 ) 022002 .
e. barberio _ et al .
_ ( heavy flavor averaging group ) , hep - ex/0603003 .
h. baer , c. balazs , j. ferrandis and x. tata , _ phys .
_ * d 64 * ( 2001 ) 035004
. t. moroi and l. randall , _ nucl .
* b 570 * ( 2000 ) 455 .
l. f. abbott and p. sikivie , _ phys .
* b 120 * ( 1983 ) 133 ; j. preskill , m. wise and f. wilczek , _ phys .
* b 120 * ( 1983 ) 127 ; m. dine and w. fischler , _ phys .
* b 120 * ( 1983 ) 137 ; m. turner , _ phys . rev . _ * d 33 * ( 1986 ) 889 .
k. rajagopal , m. turner and f. wilczek , _ nucl .
* b 358 * ( 1991 ) 447 ; l. covi , j. e. kim and l. roszkowski , _ phys .
rev . lett . _ * 82 * ( 1999 ) 4180 ; l. covi , h. b. kim , j. e. kim and l. roszkowski , _ j. high energy phys . _ * 0105 * ( 2001 ) 033 ; for recent reviews , see l. covi and j. e. kim , arxiv:0902.0769 and f. steffen , _ eur .
j. _ * c 59 * ( 2009 ) 557 .
h. baer , a. box and h. summy , _ j. high energy phys .
_ * 0908 * ( 2009 ) 080 .
prospino , by w. beenakker , r. hopker and m. spira , arxiv : hep - ph/9611232 .
h. baer , v. barger , a. lessa and x. tata , arxiv:0907.1922 ( 2009 ) .
r. kadala , j. k. mizukoshi and x. tata , _ eur .
j. _ * c 56 * ( 2008 ) 511 . h. baer , v. barger , g. shaughnessy , h. summy and l. t. wang , _ phys .
* d 75 * ( 2007 ) 095010 .
h. baer , h. prosper and h. summy , _ phys .
* d 77 * ( 2008 ) 055017 ; h. baer , a. lessa and h. summy , _ phys .
* b 674 * ( 2009 ) 49 .
h. baer , c. h. chen , f. paige and x. tata , _ phys . rev .
_ * d 52 * ( 1995 ) 2746 and _ phys . rev . _
* d 53 * ( 1996 ) 6241 ; h. baer , a. belyaev , t. krupovnickas and x. tata , _ phys .
rev . _ * d 65 * ( 2002 ) 075024 .
h. baer , r. munroe and x. tata , _ phys .
* d 54 * ( 1996 ) 6735 . | we investigate the phenomenological consequences of string models wherein the mssm resides on a d - brane , and the hypercharge gaugino mass is generated in a geometrically separated hidden sector .
this hypercharged anomaly - mediated susy breaking ( hcamsb ) model naturally solves the tachyonic slepton mass problem endemic to pure amsb scenarios . in hcamsb ,
one obtains a mass ordering @xmath0 with split left- and right- scalars , whereas in mamsb models , one obtains @xmath1 with nearly degenerate left- and right- scalars .
we compute the allowed parameter space and expected superparticle mass spectrum in the hcamsb model . for low values of the hc and amsb mixing parameter @xmath2 ,
the spectra is characterized by light left - sleptons , while the spectra for large @xmath2 is characterized by light top- and bottom- squarks .
we map out the approximate reach of lhc for hcamsb , and find that with 100 fb@xmath3 of integrated luminosity , a gravitino mass of @xmath4 ( 105 ) tev can be probed for low ( high ) values of @xmath2 , corresponding to a gluino mass reach of @xmath5 ( 2.2 ) tev . both cases
contain as is typical in amsb models long lived charginos that should yield visible highly ionizing tracks in the lhc detector . also , in the lower @xmath6 range , hcamsb models give rise to reconstructable @xmath7 candidates in susy cascade decay events , while mamsb models should do so only rarely .
* prospects for hypercharged anomaly mediated + susy breaking at the lhc * + howard baer@xmath8 , radovan derm ' iek@xmath9 , shibi rajagopalan@xmath10 , heaya summy@xmath10 + _ 1 . dept . of physics and astronomy , university of oklahoma , norman
, ok 73019 , usa + 2 .
dept . of physics , indiana university , bloomington in 47405 , usa
+ _ |
recently the nnpdf collaboration published sets of parton distribution functions with qed corrections , the so called nnpdf2.3qed sets @xcite .
these sets contain the photon pdf with its uncertainty determined for the first time from dis and drell - yan lhc data . in this work we estimate and compare to the pdf uncertainties the contributions to the invariant mass of the drell - yan @xmath1-boson production due to electroweak corrections and the photon - induced channel , by considering the low - mass region , which is below the @xmath1 peak resonance and the high - mass tail .
in contrast to what was shown in ref .
@xcite where predictions were computed with fewz , here we propose to combine two distinct parton level public codes : dynnlo @xcite for the nlo qcd prediction and horace @xcite which provides the exact @xmath2 electroweak radiative correction together with the photon - induced channel for the @xmath1 production .
the motivation for this combination is the interest to measure the difference between predictions with electroweak effects at nlo / nnlo qcd accuracy computed in the improved born approximation ( iba ) instead of using electroweak correction computed by fewz in the @xmath0 scheme .
the main difference between these choices is that effective couplings in the iba reabsorb higher - order electroweak corrections and therefore it provides predictions in better agreement with experimental data .
computations are performed exclusively with the nnpdf23_nlo_as_0119_qed set of pdfs instead of using the respective lo and nnlo sets because here we will focus only on the nlo qcd accuracy and that is why we use a nlo set . in the next sections ,
we first show the differences at born level between the improved born approximation ( iba ) , available in horace by default , and the @xmath0 scheme in dynnlo , then , we proceed with the construction of the full prediction .
born level predictions and respective ratios for low- ( left ) and high - mass ( right ) drell - yan , @xmath3 production , using the iba and the @xmath0 scheme . at low - mass
there is a constant gap of 3 - 4% for all bins , while at high - mass , predictions increase progressively with the invariant mass , producing discrepancies of 7 - 8% in the last bin.,title="fig : " ] born level predictions and respective ratios for low- ( left ) and high - mass ( right ) drell - yan , @xmath3 production , using the iba and the @xmath0 scheme . at low - mass
there is a constant gap of 3 - 4% for all bins , while at high - mass , predictions increase progressively with the invariant mass , producing discrepancies of 7 - 8% in the last bin.,title="fig : " ] in order to obtain realistic results , which are ready for comparisons with real data , we have selected the kinematic range and cuts inspired by recent measurements performed by the atlas experiment for low- and high - mass drell - yan differential cross - section at @xmath4 tev @xcite .
figure [ fig : iba ] shows the predicted distribution at born level using the iba ( horace ) and the @xmath0 scheme ( dynnlo ) at low ( left plot ) and high ( right plot ) invariant mass regions , for the drell - yan process : @xmath5 . here
, the goal is to measure the numerical differences due to the choice of these methodologies .
for all distributions , the monte carlo uncertainty is below the percent level .
we have computed predictions with the nnpdf23_nlo_as_0119_qed set of pdfs because this is the set that we use to build the complete prediction at nlo in qcd with electroweak effects .
the uncertainties shown in the figure have been calculated as the 1-@xmath6 interval obtained after averaging over the 100 replicas provided by this set . in the low - mass region , we have applied kinematic cuts to the lepton pair imposing : @xmath7 gev and @xmath8 as in atlas @xcite . in this region
we observe an almost flat gap of 3 - 4% between the iba and @xmath0 predictions , however in the bin @xmath9 gev the difference is slightly higher . on the other hand , in the high - mass region
we have applied the following kinematic cuts : @xmath10 gev and @xmath11 as in ref .
we observe a progressive increase of the central value prediction as a function of the invariant mass , reaching a maximum of 7 - 8% at the highest bin in @xmath12 .
this suggests that the running of @xmath13 in the iba can play a crucial role when determining with accuracy the predictions in such region .
it is important to highlight that in both cases , pdf uncertainties are smaller than the observed differences induced by the choice of the scheme . these results are fully consistent with the iba implementation discussed in ref .
@xcite . in the sequel we are interested in combining electroweak effects with higher order qcd corrections in the iba and
then compare these results to pure qcd @xmath0 predictions .
comparison of predictions and respective ratios for low- ( left ) and high - mass ( right ) drell - yan , @xmath3 production .
we compare the nlo qcd prediction provided by dynnlo ( green distribution ) with : the combined prediction with @xmath14 ( red distribution ) and with the @xmath15 ( blue distribution).,title="fig : " ] comparison of predictions and respective ratios for low- ( left ) and high - mass ( right ) drell - yan , @xmath3 production .
we compare the nlo qcd prediction provided by dynnlo ( green distribution ) with : the combined prediction with @xmath14 ( red distribution ) and with the @xmath15 ( blue distribution).,title="fig : " ] at this point , we are interested in building a prediction based on iba which includes nlo qcd with @xmath2 correction and the photon - induced channel .
we propose to extract the nlo correction from dynnlo by removing its born level , which contains the direct and strong dependence on the @xmath0 scheme , and combine the result with the horace prediction .
schematically this can be achieved by defining the quantities : @xmath16 where @xmath17 and @xmath18 are the born levels presented in figure [ fig : iba ] , @xmath19 the nlo qcd , @xmath14 the @xmath2 electroweak correction and @xmath20 the photon - induced contribution . the combination is then constructed in the following way : @xmath21 where we remove the dynnlo born level while we include the nlo qcd correction in the final prediction .
we are aware that using this methodology we improve the combination but we do not remove entirely the pure @xmath0 dependence at higher orders , however this is the best combination we can propose without applying technical modifications to both codes . in figure
[ fig : full ] we compare @xmath22 with @xmath23 , the combination presented in eq .
[ eq:1 ] , with and without the @xmath20 term . for all distributions
we compute the 1-@xmath6 uncertainty except when including the photon - induced channel where we have used the 68% c.l . as in ref .
. in the low - mass region the inclusion of @xmath2 electroweak corrections has a strong impact on the last four bins , where differences can reach @xmath24 in comparison to the pure nlo qcd @xmath0 prediction , while the same correction for the high - mass distribution shows a moderate impact which is below @xmath25 for the highest invariant mass bin .
this behavior is expected and derives from the shape of the @xmath1-boson invariant mass : bins located in a region lower than the @xmath1 peak resonance undergoes large positive corrections while at high invariant mass we observe a change of sign of such corrections .
it is important to highlight that modern data provided by the lhc experiments are already corrected by final - state photon radiation which carries a dominant fraction of the electroweak effects shown in figure [ fig : full ] .
the photon - induced contribution has a moderate impact in the low - mass region while for high - mass it is dominant : this behavior is expected and due to the presence of the @xmath1 peak resonance where the photon - induced channel is negligible . also from these plots of figure [ fig : full ] , it is important to emphasize again that modern pdf sets , as the nnpdf2.3qed , have uncertainties which are accurate enough to appreciate the differences due to scheme choices and electroweak effects , including the new photon pdf , which shows a stable behavior of uncertainties in all invariant mass regions except at very high - mass bins where uncertainties grow , reaching more than @xmath25 .
this situation will be improved in future by including more relevant and precise data to constrain the photon pdf .
we have shown that the choice of the coupling scheme clearly modifies the predictions when looking at realistic experimental regions for the @xmath1-boson production .
we have constructed a combined prediction which includes the @xmath2 electroweak corrections together with the photon - induced channel in the iba using public codes .
we show that uncertainties from modern pdf sets are smaller than electroweak effects and therefore such corrections will provide noticeable differences when extracting future pdf sets .
finally , in a future work we expect to provide a similar study for other processes and kinematic regions , by propagating consistently the iba to higher orders and producing a direct comparison to the fewz results .
r. d. ball _ et al . _
[ nnpdf collaboration ] , nucl .
b * 877 * ( 2013 ) 2 , 290 [ arxiv:1308.0598 [ hep - ph ] ] .
v. bertone , s. carrazza and j. rojo , arxiv:1310.1394 [ hep - ph ] .
s. carrazza [ nnpdf collaboration ] , arxiv:1305.4179 [ hep - ph ] . s. carrazza [ nnpdf collaboration ] , pos dis * 2013 * ( 2013 ) 279 [ arxiv:1307.1131 [ hep - ph ] ] .
s. carrazza , s. forte and j. rojo , arxiv:1311.5887 [ hep - ph ] .
p. skands , s. carrazza and j. rojo , arxiv:1404.5630 [ hep - ph ] .
r. boughezal , y. li and f. petriello , phys .
d * 89 * ( 2014 ) 034030 [ arxiv:1312.3972 [ hep - ph ] ] .
s. catani and m. grazzini , phys .
* 98 * ( 2007 ) 222002 [ hep - ph/0703012 ] . c. m. carloni calame , g. montagna , o. nicrosini and a. vicini , jhep * 0710 * ( 2007 ) 109 [ arxiv:0710.1722 [ hep - ph ] ] . g. aad _ et al . _
[ atlas collaboration ] , arxiv:1404.1212 [ hep - ex ] .
g. aad _ et al . _ [ atlas collaboration ] , phys .
b * 725 * ( 2013 ) 223 [ arxiv:1305.4192 [ hep - ex ] ] . | parton distributions with qed corrections open new scenarios for high precision physics .
we recall the need for accurate and improved predictions which keeps into account higher order qcd corrections together with electroweak effects .
we study predictions obtained with the improved born approximation and the @xmath0 scheme by using two public codes : dynnlo and horace .
we focus our attention on the drell - yan @xmath1-boson invariant mass distribution at low- and high - mass regions , recently measured by the atlas experiment and we estimate the impact of each component of the final prediction . we show that electroweak corrections are larger than pdf uncertainties for modern pdf sets and therefore such corrections are necessary to improve the extraction of future pdf sets . |
the emergence of topological order is one of the most intriguing phenomena in interacting quantum systems.@xcite most importantly perhaps , emergent quasiparticles in two - dimensional topological phases of matter can acquire non - abelian statistics and may provide quantum states with highly nonlocal entanglement that form an ideal basis for quantum information processing.@xcite many unanswered questions about topological systems remain , despite recent developments in the field exploring phase transitions ( notably those driven by topological bose condensation)@xcite , stability of topological phases to perturbations,@xcite coupling of multiple non - abelian subsystems,@xcite or creation of non - abelian theories from coupling simpler subsystems.@xcite it is in these general realms that the current paper seeks to explore . in most cases we are not able to easily relate the complex topological physics to more traditional condensed matter systems .
however , one important exception is that topological systems of ising type ( meaning they are described by a topological field theory related to the ising conformal field theory ( cft ) or the su(2)@xmath2 chern - simons theory ) can be frequently related to superconductors , thus providing a particularly powerful handle for understanding them .
such systems are now of particular interest due to a variety of recent experiments aimed at realizing them in the laboratory.@xcite in the current work we will examine a variant of the moore - read@xcite quantum hall state , which is of this superconducting type.@xcite another approach that has been extremely important in developing an understanding of topological phases is the use of exactly solvable models.@xcite even when exactly solvable models are very far from any real experimental system , their solutions teach us general principles , and we may hope that the physical systems will be described by the same phase of matter as the model , and will therefore have the same universal properties . further , with modern quantum technologies , such as cold atoms , trapped ions , or josephson junctions,@xcite one may hope that the precise model system may even be successfully realized in the future . in this spirit
, we will deploy model hamiltonians that can be solved exactly as a central part of our current work . in this paper
, we consider the effect of inter - layer tunneling on a bilayer quantum hall system formed by two bosonic @xmath4 moore - read states , each one being the exact ground state of a three - body contact interaction . while we frame the discussion in terms of a quantum hall bilayer
, similar considerations apply to any system with two internal degrees of freedom , including valley degrees or spin degrees of freedom . to a large extent
the same physics will occur also for interacting particles in chern bands with chern number @xmath5 .
since the moore - read state can be thought of as a ( chiral ) @xmath6-wave superconductor of composite fermions , for intuition , it is useful to think of the inter - layer tunneling as a process occurring between two superconductors .
as is well known , tunneling of single particles is suppressed due to the superconducting gap , and one must consider then the tunneling of pairs , which gives rise to the rich phenomenology of the josephson effect.@xcite in the case of coupled moore - read states , however , it is crucial that the paired particles are _ composite fermions _ in this case , bosons bound to ( jastrow factor ) correlation holes . due to these correlation holes , it would be very difficult for bare bosons ( paired or otherwise ) to tunnel between the layers , as one must open a ( jastrow ) correlation hole in the new layer and remove the ( jastrow ) correlation hole from the old layer essentially moving the flux between the layers along with the boson . in order to create a setting for moore - read states in which tunneling is possible , we introduce an inter - layer correlation hole @xmath7 by adding a suitably strong two - body inter - layer contact repulsion ( @xmath8 of haldane pseudo potentials@xcite ) .
in such a situation , a correlation hole always exists in the opposite layer , which can receive a tunneling particle easily .
while one still expects single - particle tunneling to be suppressed due to the pairing physics of the moore - read state , in this situation one expects to realize pair tunneling similar to that of the conventional josephson effect .
the exact ground state of our three - body intra - layer contact interaction along with the two - body inter - layer interaction is the coupled moore - read state , first discussed in ref . in the resulting model ,
all particles carry the same jastrow correlations .
hence , by removing the overall flux attachment , the system yields a solvable model for two josephson coupled @xmath6-wave superconductors . in the presence of pure three - body contact interactions plus inter - layer two - body repulsion ,
the coupled moore - read states are degenerate with respect to moving pairs of bosons between layers .
this symmetry gives rise to a goldstone mode in the spectrum . here , pair tunneling is crucial and even at infinitesimal magnitude it selects one particular ground state from the previously degenerate manifold of ground states and gaps the goldstone mode .
if we denote the pseudospins of bosons in the two layers with @xmath9 and @xmath10 , then in the basis of symmetric and antisymmetric pseudospin states , @xmath11 , we find that the ground state wave function for small tunneling yields a particular superposition of coupled moore - read states that is exactly the halperin 220 state.@xcite this is a surprising result , for it immediately follows that we can write a purely two - body hamiltonian which reproduces the exact ground state of our three - body interaction . beyond the ground state properties , we see that the quasihole spectrum of these hamiltonians can be calculated exactly and we demonstrate that it reflects the physics of confinement of quasiholes . to make this connection , we begin by calculating the full spectrum ( for any number of quasiholes ) of the system of uncoupled moore - read states , where the quasihole excitations can be viewed as vortices of the composite fermion superconductor .
in addition , one needs to consider the possible fusion channels of the majorana zero modes in the vortex cores.@xcite the introduction of josephson tunneling between the layers can then be understood as locking the superconducting phase between the two layers , which results in binding ( confining ) vortices into pairs between the two layers , i.e. each vortex is accompanied by a partner at the same location in the other layer . taking this restriction into account , we find the spectrum of the coupled moore - read layers : the bulk is described by a u(1)@xmath12u(1)@xmath2 cft , but the edge revels a different u(1)@xmath13u(1 ) structure at fixed particle number .
we show how these theories relate to the ising@xmath14ising content of two uncoupled moore - read states , and demonstrate that the confinement of quasihole operators renders several types of topological excitations topologically invisible .
the overall effect of the josephson coupling on the spectrum of topological bulk excitations is then the same as the effect that would be induced by topological bose condensation of these invisible particles .
this paper is structured as follows : in section [ sec : josephsoncoupling ] we introduce our specific model of josephson coupled moore - read states and discuss its qualitative physics and the nature of its ground state sector . in section [ sec : excitations ] , we analyze the finite size quasihole spectra of our model bilayer hamiltonians with josephson coupling and also deduce the edge spectrum for an infinite droplet . in section [ sec : cft ]
we develop a description of this physics in terms of topological bose condensation transitions between the underlying conformal field theories .
the final section [ sec : conclusions ] is devoted to conclusions and a general outlook for generalizations of our approach .
our aim is to study the effect of josephson coupling on a bilayer system composed of two moore - read states . throughout this work ,
we focus on the case of bosons , although many of our results can be generalized to the case of fermions . within each layer
, we can use three - body contact interactions as the parent hamiltonian of the moore - read state to induce the desired pairing properties . in order to create a ground state that is susceptible to tunneling
, we additionally require a correlation hole between the layers .
these correlations are created by an additional inter - layer repulsion in the hamiltonian , leading us to define the parent hamiltonian for coupled moore - read states , defined on the plane as [ eq : projectiveh ] _ 32 & = & _ 3 _ i < j < k = 1^n _ ^(2)(z^_i - z^_j)^(2 ) ( z^_j - z^_k ) + & + & _ 3_i < j < k = 1^n _ ^(2)(z^_i - z^_j)^(2 ) ( z^_j - z^_k ) + & + & _ 2 _ i=1^n _ _ j=1^n _ ^(2)(z^_i - z^_j ) . we choose the prefactors @xmath15 and @xmath16 such that term acts as a projector on lowest landau level states , and we use an equivalent construction in the spherical geometry for our numerics ( see appendix [ apx : sphere ] ) . the hamiltonian ( [ eq : projectiveh ] ) conserves the number of particles per layer , and its ground state wave function in a given sector with ( even ) number of particles @xmath17 and @xmath18 per layer is given as per construction by the coupled moore - read state that was introduced in ref . , _ 0^n _ , n_(\{z^_i},\{z^_j } ) = pf()pf ( ) + _ i < j=1^n_(z^_i - z^_j)_i < j=1^n_(z^_i - z^_j)_i=1^n__j=1^n_(z^_i - z^_j ) . [ eq : doublepfaffian ] this state has an overall filling factor of @xmath19 , and a shift of @xmath20 , i.e. it includes orbitals up to a maximum flux of @xmath21 .
we shall take polynomials in complex coordinates @xmath22 to either denote states on the plane ( omitting overall gaussian factors ) or on the sphere ( via stereographic projection ) , as explained further in appendix [ apx : sphere ] .
each of the two coupled moore - read states can be thought of as a @xmath6-wave superconductor of composite fermions,@xcite and we can deploy the picture of a bose condensate of cooper pairs .
an important consequence is the fact that an odd number of particles per layer can not be accommodated in the ground state . instead ,
odd number configurations leave an unpaired fermion or ` broken pair ' which implies a finite gap @xmath23 for the resulting bogoliubov quasiparticle or neutral fermion excitation.@xcite hence , hamiltonian ( [ eq : projectiveh ] ) constrains the ground state to an even number of particles per layer .
all sectors with an even number of bosons per layer possess an exact ( and unique ) zero energy ground state .
it follows that ( cooper ) pairs can be moved between the layers at vanishing energetic cost and , if we think in terms of the larger hilbert space allowing such processes , the ground state degeneracy amounts to @xmath24 . henceforth , let us denote the ground state with @xmath25 particles in the upper layer and @xmath26 in the lower layer via the shorthand _
0,n = _ 0 ^ 2n , n-2n , n = 0, ,n/2 . as a consequence of the extensive ground state degeneracy , we need to include tunneling of ( pairs of ) particles between the layers in order to obtain the full physical picture .
taking the analogy with the superconducting system further , the number of cooper pairs per layer is the conjugate variable to the phases @xmath27 of the superconducting order parameters .
there is a u(1 ) symmetry in the difference @xmath28 between these complex superconducting order parameters , and we expect that long wavelength fluctuations of @xmath29 give rise to a goldstone mode . indeed , our numerics confirm that the gap of low - lying excited states at small angular momentum scales as @xmath30 , indicating the presence of a linearly dispersing goldstone mode . due to the discrete number of available momenta in finite size systems
, the goldstone excitations always occur at finite energy .
hence , we will focus on the physics of the ground state and zero - energy excitations for the coupled moore - read state , and leave the full exploration of the superconducting coherence and the collective goldstone mode for a future publication . to explore the effect of josephson coupling
, it would be sufficient to add a single - particle tunneling term @xmath31 to the hamiltonian .
while this term can not move single particles between the layers due to the neutral fermion gap @xmath23 , it would induce pair tunneling of magnitude @xmath32 at the second order of perturbation theory . for simplicity ,
we extend our model directly by a pair tunneling term , and choose this to be local , i.e."we consider tunneling of pairs with relative angular momentum zero , given by the term [ eq : vumklapp ] v_0^ = d^2r _ 0^ ( , ) _ 0 ( , ) + h.c .
, where @xmath33 creates a pair of particles with individual spins @xmath34 , @xmath35 , and relative angular momentum @xmath36 at the centre of mass position @xmath37 [ and @xmath38 .
explicit forms on the sphere are also given in appendix [ apx : sphere ] .
specifically , we consider the class of ` josephson coupled ' hamiltonians [ eq : hamtot ] _
^ ( t ) = _ +
t v_0^ , the ground state of @xmath39 is exactly degenerate and has a finite quasiparticle gap ( and a finite collective mode gap @xmath40 in finite size systems of @xmath41 particles ) .
we find that for small enough @xmath42 , the tunneling term mixes only the @xmath43 zero - energy ground states , @xmath44 , so the new ground state can be obtained by degenerate perturbation theory .
we are now in the position to verify the claim that the 220 state is also generated by @xmath61 by comparing the ground state wave functions of ( [ eq : hamtot ] ) and ( [ eq : ham220ud ] ) . for system
sizes up to @xmath62 , and @xmath63 we have verified that the ground state of @xmath64 are indeed superpositions involving only the zero energy ground states of @xmath65 to within a precision of @xmath66 .
[ fig : overlapsjc-220 ] shows the overlaps of the exact ground states with the @xmath67 state for finite size systems on the sphere as a function of the tunneling parameter @xmath42 . for @xmath68 , we find that the overlap is decreasing with system size , and for large @xmath42 there is some admixture of states beyond degenerate perturbation theory .
however , for values of tunneling @xmath69 , we find that the overlap with 220 _ increases _ with @xmath41 . on the basis of this data and our earlier heuristic arguments
, we conjecture that the ground state of the three - body hamiltonian with josephson coupling tends exactly to the 220 state in the limit where @xmath42 goes to zero and @xmath41 is taken to infinity . between ground states of the three - body hamiltonian with josephson coupling ( [ eq : hamtot ] ) and the 220 state in the @xmath58 basis , the ground state of ( [ eq : ham220ud ] ) .
data is shown for systems with @xmath70 particles on the haldane sphere .
inset : scaling of the difference @xmath71 with system size , highlighting the change in behaviour : the overlap decreases with @xmath41 in systems with @xmath68 , while it increases for @xmath69 . ] our considerations of pair tunneling terms in a two - body hamiltonian were originally inspired by the possibility of having umklapp scattering in the hofstadter lattice in ref . .
indeed , the hofstadter lattice provides a useful platform for strongly correlated quantum hall liquids,@xcite leading up to the general formulation of fractional insulators in general chern bands.@xcite for chern number @xmath5 bands , it is convenient to consider the single - particle eigenstates in terms of multiple flavors,@xcite and near @xmath72 the hofstadter model provides bands with @xmath5 matching the two flavors of our current model.@xcite however , a recent study@xcite argues that the microscopic hamiltonian in the hofstadter model does not yield a regime with sufficiently strong umklapp terms that could be described by two - body hamiltonians of the type ( [ eq : ham220ud ] ) , as originally believed .
partially motivated by these ( approximate ) physical realizations , and partially in order to show that the solvable point of the 220 state belongs to a a wider range of parameter space , hence representative of a stable phase of matter , we also consider a generalized hamiltonian where we allow for the magnitude of the tunneling term to be tuned by a variable prefactor @xmath73:@xcite [ eq : hameffalpha ] ^ ( ) = v_0^ + v_0^ + v_0^ + v_0^. we discuss the excitation spectrum of this hamiltonian in section [ sec : hameffalpha ] .
unlike @xmath74 , which produces a gap of order @xmath42 , the parent hamiltonian @xmath75 , and its generalization @xmath76 , yield a large many - body gap and do not have a low - lying collective mode .
the first two of these hamiltonians share a common spectrum for the ground state and quasihole excitations , which can be calculated analytically .
analyzing the ground state sectors of the pure three - body hamiltonian @xmath77 in comparison to the case of finite tunneling will inform us about the details of the transition that occurs when tuning from @xmath78 to finite tunneling @xmath42 . the physical picture that emerges
is the following : the quasiholes of the moore - read state can be thought of as vortices of the underlying composite fermion superconductor , i.e. , the superconducting phase winds by @xmath79 when going around one of these quasiparticles . in the absence of tunneling , we are free to place vortices independently in the @xmath9 and @xmath10 layers . however , when @xmath80 we induce an energetic confinement of the @xmath9-vortices at @xmath81 to @xmath10-vortices at @xmath82 , because an isolated vortex would create a mismatch of the superconducting phases between the two layers .
indeed , our analysis of the quasiparticle states confirms that the exact zero energy quasihole states of @xmath75 are obtained from the quasihole spectrum of @xmath77 by identifying the quasihole positions @xmath83 ( see appendix [ apx : exact ] for an explicit example ) .
the formation of quasiparticle excitations is a hallmark of topological order in incompressible fractional quantum hall liquids .
as the ( charge- ) density of the system is perturbed from the preferred value , which is realized in the many - body ground state , the excess density gives rise to local deviations from the average that behave as emergent types of particles with fractional charge and fractional statistics . in the bosonic paired hall states , described by moore - read s wave function at filling fraction @xmath0 , the quasiparticle charge amounts to @xmath84 .
in finite size systems , quasiparticle excitations can be studied either by changing the total number of particles in the system or , as we shall proceed , by adding / removing flux .
this procedure changes the density by varying the overall area of the system while keeping the number of particles constant .
we focus on quasihole excitations that are obtained when additional flux is added .
the specific number of low energy states at each angular momentum can be used as a probe of the underlying topological order.@xcite in the limit of a large droplet , the high angular momentum states yield a universal counting of edge states for the system on a disk , which can be derived from a @xmath85 dimensional conformal field theory ( cft ) describing the edge physics.@xcite note that here we have two hamiltonians , eqs .
( [ eq : projectiveh ] ) and ( [ eq : ham220ud ] ) , which have very similar ground states , in the sense that the projections of the ground states on fixed particle numbers in the layers are equal , but as we shall see , they give rise to different edge spectra .
nevertheless we argue that this observation does not pose a contradiction to the bulk - edge correspondence for topological systems , which states that in such systems , the edge and quasiparticle excitations follow directly from the ground state . despite their similarity ,
our two hamiltonians do not in fact have the same space of ground states : one has many degenerate ground states while the other does not .
furthermore , the hamiltonian without tunneling , eq .
( [ eq : projectiveh ] ) , has gapless goldstone modes and hence does not represent a proper topological phase of matter .
the situation encountered here is similar to that which occurs in loop models based on @xmath86-isotopy@xcite , where the same ground state can be found both in a gapless phase and in a gapped topological phase . as our target state ( [ eq : doublepfaffian ] )
is the exact ground state of the projective three - body hamiltonian ( [ eq : projectiveh ] ) , our aim is first to count the number of zero - energy quasihole excitations that this hamiltonian supports at a given flux @xmath87 .
their number follows directly from the counting of quasihole states in the single - component moore - read state of bosons at @xmath4 , as first described in ref . .
we briefly review these arguments in appendix [ apx : mr ] and focus on the excitations of our two - component wave function ( [ eq : doublepfaffian ] ) here . in the case of the two - component system , described by hamiltonian ( [ eq : projectiveh ] )
, we can determine the counting of quasiholes by directly using the results of ref . .
the inter - layer correlations are screened perfectly already in the ground state ( [ eq : doublepfaffian ] ) , and this is not altered by adding quasihole excitations .
this implies that there is no additional correlation between the quasihole positions in the two layers , and the wave function has the form [ eq : mrxmrstates ] ^_32 ( \{z_i^ } , \{z_j^ } ; \{w_k^ } , \{w_l^ } ) + = ^ , = 1_m_1^, m_n_^ ( z_1^, z_n_^ ; w_1^, w_2n_^ ) + ^ , = 1_m_1^, m_n_^ ( z_1^, z_n_^ ; w_1^, w_2n_^ ) + _ i , j ( z_i^-z_j^ ) .
here @xmath88 are quasihole wave functions of a single - layer moore - read state at filling fraction @xmath0 and @xmath89 are fermionic occupation numbers [ see eq .
( [ eq : readrezayiqh ] ) in appendix [ apx : mr ] for details ] . the total number of excited states ensues simply by convoluting the countings of two independent single - layer moore - read states , [ eq : deg_3 - 2 ] d_32(n_,n_,n _ , n _ , l_z ) + = _ l = 0^l_z d_(n_,n_,l ) d_(n_,n_,l_z - l ) where @xmath90 denotes the degeneracy of a single - layer moore - read state with @xmath41 particles and @xmath91 additional flux quanta above the ground state at fixed angular momentum @xmath92 [ see eq .
( [ eq : dmr ] ) ] .
similarly , the character of the cft , describing the edge of the infinite system,@xcite factorizes into the components , ^32(n_,n _ ) = ^(n _ ) ^(n _ ) , where @xmath93 is the character of the cft associated with each layer [ see eq .
( [ eq : singlemrcharacter ] ) ] . for the sector with even parity in both components ,
the character reveals a rapidly growing count of excitations , [ eq : mrxmrcharacter ] 1 + 2 q + 7 q^2 + 16 q^3 + 39 q^4 + 82 q^5 + 173 q^6 + ( q^7 ) . in finite size systems , only the first few terms of this series
are recovered , while the counting of high angular momentum states is reduced . to give some examples , table [ tab : degmrxmr ]
provides the degeneracies of @xmath92 eigenmodes with respect to the maximum angular momentum ( @xmath94 ) and their equivalent expression as angular momentum multiplets @xmath95 , as predicted by formula ( [ eq : deg_3 - 2 ] ) .
we give exemplary data for several system sizes with @xmath96 even . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,<,^,<,^",options="header " , ] [ neutral ] this type of reduction from one topological order to another has been discussed in some detail in the context of topological phase transitions in ref . .
there the transition was considered as driven by the condensation of a bosonic sector , with identification and splitting of some sectors and confinement of others as a consequence . in the case of a system with ising @xmath14 ising topological
order one can imagine the condensation of @xmath97 , which would then lead to u(1)@xmath98 , precisely as is summarized in ( [ neutral ] ) . in our system
there is no evidence for the condensation of @xmath97 , nevertheless the same result is obtained from the confinement of single @xmath34 sectors .
a similar analysis in the context of one - dimensional spin chains is studied in ref . .
up to this point our cft has reduced to two u(1)@xmath98 sectors one that represents the neutral sector and another for the charge sector . in terms of the primary fields of u(1)@xmath98 @xmath14 u(1)@xmath98
the bosonic electron operators can be defined as , [ eop - a ] _ e^(z^ ) = e^i_c(z^ ) , + _
e^(z^ ) = i e^i_c(z^ ) , [ eop - u ] and the correlator of these operators also reproduces the coupled moore - read state , eq . ( [ eq : doublepfaffian]).@xcite note that unlike the charge boson field,@xcite the neutral vertex operators @xmath45 are not balanced by a background charge . hence ,
only terms that balance the overall neutral boson charge " contribute to correlators of these operators .
note also that the neutral parts of the electron operators , defined as symmetric and anti - symmetric combinations of @xmath99 in eq .
( [ eop - u ] ) , correspond to the @xmath100 and @xmath101 sectors of ising@xmath102 @xmath14 ising@xmath103 , which can be viewed as a @xmath104 orbifold of u(1)@xmath98,@xcite hence recovering the definitions in eq .
( [ eops ] ) .
similarly , the quasihole operators can be expressed as , [ qhop - a ] ^+_qh(w_1 ) & = & e^i_n(w_1)/2e^i_c(w_1)/2 , + ^-_qh(w_2 ) & = & e^-i_n(w_2)/2e^i_c(w_2)/2 , which , in the confined[ising@xmath102 @xmath14 ising@xmath103 @xmath14 u(1)@xmath98 ] language , are equivalent to ^+_qh(w_1 ) & = & ( ^(w_1)^(w_1))_+ e^i_c(w_1)/2 , + ^-_qh(w_2 ) & = & ( ^(w_2)^(w_2))_- e^i_c(w_2)/2 .
note that in a system without an edge , any non - vanishing correlator must include both @xmath106 and @xmath107 , hence these quasiholes always appear as pairs ( to satisfy
charge " neutrality in the neutral sector ) .
it is important to note that , despite the fact that we used correlators of the fields of u(1)@xmath98 @xmath14 u(1)@xmath98 to obtain the ground state and quasihole wave functions in eqs .
( [ eop - a ] , [ qhop - a ] ) , not all 16 sectors of u(1)@xmath98 @xmath14 u(1)@xmath98 lead to valid wave functions . instead , only those sectors that are local with respect to electron operators , eq . ( [ eop - a ] ) , should be considered to determine the final cft . discarding the sectors that are not non - local with respect to electron operators is equivalent to condensing bosonic operators of the form @xmath108 within u(1)@xmath98 @xmath14 u(1)@xmath98 .
the resulting reduced cft is isomorphic to u(1)@xmath2 @xmath14 u(1)@xmath2 , which is the cft description of the 220 state with 4 distinct sectors , as expected .
the correspondence between confined[ising @xmath14 ising @xmath14 u(1)@xmath98 ] and u(1)@xmath2 @xmath14 u(1)@xmath2 is summarized in table [ finalbulk ] .
the lowest energy subspace of the effective two - body hamiltonian @xmath109 in the presence of extra flux was studied in section [ sec : excitations ] .
there it was shown that the character of the edge spectrum , for an even total number of particles , is given by eq .
( [ eq : jccharacter ] ) , i.e. ^ = [ ( ^_+ ) ^2 + ( ^_- ) ^2 ] ^. here @xmath110 , which is the character of a chiral boson [ eq . ( [ eq : chiralbosonchi ] ) ] , represents the charge sector while the neutral sector consists of two parts corresponding to the even / even and odd / odd distributions of particles between the two layers .
interestingly , the expression for the neutral sector is equivalent to the character of the vacuum sector of the compactified chiral boson , u(1)@xmath98 , i.e. [ eq : u14character ] ( ^_+ ) ^2 + ( ^_- ) ^2 = ^u(1)_4_0 .
this can be shown explicitly by noting that @xmath111 can be written as , [ eq : cagen ] ^u(1)_4_0 = _ 0 ^ , where [ eq : u14identitysector ] _ 0 = _
n=-^q^ represents the addition of bosonic descendant fields of the form @xmath112 to the chiral algebra of the chiral boson in the neutral sector . the full edge spectrum , including both the charge and the neutral sectors ,
can then be written as , ^ = _ 0 ^ ^ , which corresponds to the character of u(1)@xmath98 @xmath14 u(1 ) . before proceeding with an explanation of this observation , note that the difference between the characters of the uncompactified u(1 ) and the compactified u(1)@xmath98 is that the chiral algebra of the latter includes bosonic descendant fields of the form @xmath112 ( or their linear combinations ) with conformal dimensions @xmath113 where @xmath91 is an integer .
these operators , which represent creation or annihilation of bosons in the system , create extra modes in addition to the modes of the uncompactified u(1 ) .
therefore , in general , in a system where the number of the underlying particles is fixed , such operators do not enter the chiral algebra and the compactification radius of u(1 ) does not appear.@xcite in our two - body hamiltonian @xmath109 , pairs of particles can freely tunnel between the two layers .
thus , while the total number of particles ( or equivalently the total charge ) between the two layers is conserved , there is no such restriction on the neutral sector . as a result , the bosonic descendant operators of u(1)@xmath98 ( or , equivalently the confined[ising@xmath103 @xmath14 ising@xmath102 ] ) , which forms the neutral part of the cft , can be added to the chiral algebra of u(1 ) , giving rise to the appearance of one u(1)@xmath98 in the edge spectrum .
the remaining uncompactified u(1 ) factor represents the charge sector with fixed total charge , hence the edge spectrum becomes u(1)@xmath98 @xmath14 u(1 ) .
( [ eq : u14character ] ) is , in fact , a manifestation of the equivalence between the vacuum sector of the @xmath104 orbifold of u(1)@xmath98 and the combination of the ( @xmath115 , @xmath116 ) and ( 1,1 ) sectors of ising@xmath102 @xmath14 ising@xmath103 , as is shown in the first row of ( [ neutral ] ) .
similarly , the lowest energy subspace of @xmath117 for the case of @xmath118 odd , consists of even / odd and odd / even distributions of particles between the two layers .
the character of the neutral sector then corresponds to @xmath119 , which is equivalent to the character of the @xmath45 sector of u(1)@xmath98 .
this represents the equivalence between the @xmath45 sector of the @xmath104 orbifold of u(1)@xmath98 and the combination of the ( 1 , @xmath116 ) and ( @xmath115 , 1 ) sectors of ising@xmath102 @xmath14 ising@xmath103 , as is shown in the second row of ( [ neutral ] ) . as was noted before , a similar study of the edge spectrum of the three - body hamiltonian @xmath120 , eq .
( [ eq : projectiveh ] ) , results in a completely different structure , i.e."su(2)@xmath2 @xmath14 su(2)@xmath2 .
this implies that each layer behaves as an independent moore - read state with its own independent charge .
however , the ground state of this hamiltonian at filling fraction @xmath0 is the coupled moore - read state , whose electron operators must share the same charge .
we have not been able to find a cft that describes both the ground state and the excitation spectrum of this hamiltonian , and conjecture that such cft does not exist .
we believe this inconsistency is due to the fact that this hamiltonian is gapless in the thermodynamic limit .
we have analyzed two model hamiltonians for coupled quantum hall bilayers that give rise to ground - state wave functions built from the coupled moore - read states , eq .
( [ eq : doublepfaffian ] ) , thus providing a model for the observation of josephson physics in fractional quantum hall states .
the first model hamiltonian , @xmath77 , comprises a three - body intra - layer contact interaction and a two - body inter - layer contact interaction .
it has the coupled moore - read state , eq .
( [ eq : doublepfaffian ] ) , as its ground state and results in an excitation spectrum that is essentially equivalent to that of two independent moore - read states .
more specifically , the zero energy eigenstates of this hamiltonian can be obtained from those of a system with independent moore - read layers by simply multiplying by an inter - layer jastrow factor , which reflects the inter - layer interaction .
this hamiltonian has a goldstone mode reflecting the symmetry that one can move particles freely between layers two at a time and remain in the zero energy subspace .
so long there is no tunneling between the layers , this symmetry remains valid and the corresponding goldstone mode is present .
the second model hamiltonian @xmath121 consists of purely two - body terms , including both interactions and inter - layer tunneling .
this hamiltonian is gapped and its ground state is an equal - weight superposition of coupled moore - read states for all particle number distributions between the two layers with fixed parity .
this state is equivalent to the ( gapped ) halperin 220 state in a rotated basis , with the corresponding topological order being u(1)@xmath1 u(1)@xmath2 .
correspondingly , while the ground state of this system is a superposition of the ground states of @xmath122 , the excitation spectra of the two systems are quite different , even if we project onto fixed particle numbers in both layers .
since the @xmath122 hamiltonian is gapless , it does not have all of the properties one would desire of a true topological phase . for example
it is not a correlator of an obvious cft .
nonetheless , many of its properties are essentially those of the constituent ( non - abelian ) moore - read states with an excitation spectrum of zero - energy quasihole states given by the product of two moore - read spectra , and an edge spectrum given by su(2)@xmath12su(2)@xmath2 . however , even infinitesimal tunneling between layers gaps the goldstone mode , as well as gapping other zero energy states in the presence of quasiholes .
the result is a new ( and now a proper ) topological phase of matter , represented by the hamiltonian @xmath123 with nonzero tunneling parameter @xmath42 .
the system with tunneling has the same ( abelian ) topological order as @xmath121 .
in fact , we found that the ground state of @xmath123 becomes identical to the ground state of @xmath121 in the limit of small but nonzero tunneling .
we demonstrated in detail the connection between the two full quasihole excitation spectra of @xmath124 and @xmath121 , showing that inter - layer pair tunneling locks the elementary quasiholes of the layers in localized pairs ( one quasihole in each layer ) . in the cft language
, we see that this confinement of quasiholes rules out several sectors of the full su(2)@xmath2 @xmath14 su(2)@xmath2 theory ( the ones with unpaired elementary quasiholes ) , which implies that yet more sectors become topologically indistinguishable or invisible - that is , they can not be distinguished by their braiding properties from any of the remaining , non - confined particles .
the introduction of tunneling thus gives a reduction in topological order which is the same as that which would result from topological bose condensation of the topologically invisible particles
although no actual condensation in the usual sense happens here .
the resulting topological order is identical to that of the halperin 220 state , given by a u(1)@xmath2 @xmath14 u(1)@xmath2 cft in the bulk .
naively , one might therefore expect that the system exhibits a u(1 ) @xmath14 u(1 ) edge spectrum when considered at a fixed total number of particles @xmath41 .
instead , an interesting twist occurs in the edge spectrum of the coupled moore - read state , which takes the surprising form of u(1)@xmath3 u(1 ) at fixed @xmath41 .
we attribute this behavior to the fact that in the rotated ( symmetric / antisymmetric ) basis , the charged and neutral sectors of the 220 state are separated . with the charge quantum number being conserved but without any such conservation restriction on the neutral charge " ,
we show that the edge spectrum must take the observed form .
while much of our analysis here has focused on the properties of quasiholes , we note that it is in principle straightforward to construct trial wave functions for quasiparticle states and even for states with quasiholes and quasiparticles .
on the one hand , the @xmath67 state has natural composite fermion excitations . on the other hand ,
quasiparticle states for @xmath77 can be constructed from the successful trial wave functions for a single layer pfaffian considered in refs . .
one would expect to find a similar connection between the quasiparticle spectra as for the quasihole spectra , although numerical evidence will be harder to gather , because the quasiparticle states will not be zero energy states of any of the model hamiltonians .
the physics of a gapless goldstone mode being gapped by inter - layer tunneling is quite reminiscent of the well - studied physics of the 111 state.@xcite analogous to that case , in the absence of tunneling there is an exact degeneracy associated with moving particles between layers ( in the 111 case , particles can be moved between layers one at a time , whereas here they must be moved in pairs ) .
this degeneracy can also be understood in a different language where this state can be parametrized in terms of the components of a ( pseudo)-spinor , where the direction of the spinor represents the amplitude of the particles in the two layers . allowing the spinor direction to vary as a function of position , one obtains low energy goldstone mode excitations ( spin waves ) of the pseudospin ferromagnet.@xcite analogous to the case of the 111 state , introduction of a tunneling term between the layer breaks the symmetry , fixes the direction of the pseudospin and gaps the goldstone mode . in both this case and in the 111 state , the low energy excitations of the system are spin configurations known as merons , which correspond to introducing a quasiparticle vortex in only one of the two spin species .
therefore , independent majorana - like excitations can form in each layer independently although they are bound together , or confined , at longer distances .
the connection to the physics of the 111 state will be explored in more detail in a forthcoming paper .
in addition to the connection to 111 physics , and its associated exciton physics , there are several other connections that would be interesting to explore .
one possibility is to consider coupled @xmath125 read - rezayi wave functions , with tunneling of @xmath91 particles between layers at a time .
much of the same confinement physics will remain , although some non - abelian particles may remain deconfined .
another example to explore would be the tunnel coupling of more than two layers together . these are also issues that we will defer until a later time .
much of the discussion here seems somewhat reminiscent of ( although not precisely the same as ) the work of ref . on orbifold constructions in quantum hall multilayers
. it would be interesting to explore this connection further .
discussions with e. ardonne , m. barkeshli , b. estienne and n. read are gratefully acknowledged .
the authors would like to thank nordita and the aspen center for physics their hospitality , and acknowledge support from the leverhulme trust under grant ecf-2011 - 565 , the newton trust of the university of cambridge and by the royal society under grant uf120157 ( g.m . ) , the european union under marie curie award 299890 qetpm ( l.h . ) , science foundation ireland principal investigator awards 08/in.1/i1961 and 12/ia/1697 ( j.k.s . ) and
epsrc grant ep / i032487/1 ( s.h.s . ) .
the numerical work presented in this paper was performed for finite systems with spherical geometry .
single - particle orbitals on the plane relate to their counterparts in the spherical geometry via the mapping @xmath126 ( precisely , states within a spherical droplet on the plane centered around the origin and spanned by the first @xmath127 orbitals are mapped to the sphere pierced by @xmath128 flux quanta ) .
we denote wave functions as polynomials in coordinates @xmath52 throughout in the understanding that a corresponding state on the sphere follows via this mapping . to obtain the full form of the many - body wave function on the plane , a factor of @xmath129 needs to be added .
generally , quantum hall hamiltonians are parametrized by relative angular momenta of particles.@xcite on the sphere , it is more favorable instead to express hamiltonians in terms of projectors onto ( pairs and triplets ) of fixed total angular momentum : as the total angular momentum is bounded to @xmath130 on the sphere , states of maximal total angular momentum translate to minimal relative angular momentum.@xcite in a spherical geometry with @xmath87 flux quanta , two - body contact interactions are therefore given by projection to the maximal total angular momentum of pairs @xmath131 , and we take the following representation to express delta functions in the lowest landau - level on the sphere _ 2 _ i < j _ ^(2)(^_i - ^_j ) _ _ i < jp_ij(m^ _ ) .
an equivalent construction for the three - body terms in ( [ eq : projectiveh ] ) includes projectors onto the largest total angular momentum eigenstates for triplets of particles with @xmath132 , yielding @xmath133 we have defined the overall normalization @xmath134 of our hamiltonians such that the prefactor of projectors onto individual pair / triplet are equal to unity .
projections onto the lowest landau level are omitted in the main text for brevity .
the explicit form of these projectors can be expressed in terms of creation operators for pairs of particles @xmath135 at a given relative angular momentum @xmath36 . in eq .
( [ eq : vumklapp ] ) in the main text , we considered pair creation operators on the plane .
let us make the construction more explicit for the sphere . with the remarks of the preceding paragraph , relative angular momentum @xmath36 implies total angular momentum @xmath136 .
a complete basis for the corresponding angular momentum multiplet @xmath137 is obtained by coupling the two states @xmath138 which describe the two members of the pair .
the matrix elements for the transformation between these bases are given by the clebsch - gordon coefficients @xmath139 , such that @xmath140 with creation operators @xmath141 for a particle with @xmath142 , and equivalently defining creation operators for pairs @xmath143 .
( non - zero contributions arise only for @xmath144 ) .
hence , the projector has the second quantized form [ eq : projectors_sphere ] _
i < j p_ij(j ) = _ m ^_j , m _
j , m these expressions generalize straightforwardly to the case with spin , defining [ eq : pair_creation ] ^_j , m(_1 , _ 2 ) = _ m_1,m_2 c_l_1,m_1 ; l_2 , m_2^j , m a^_m_1,_1 a^_m_2,_2 .
in this appendix , we show that the halperin @xmath67-state is precisely a superposition of coupled moore - read wave functions with different numbers of spin - up and spin - down bosons , @xmath146 .
the underlying idea is to perform a basis transformation from spin - up and spin - down eigenstates @xmath147 to their symmetric and antisymmetric superpositions ( [ eq : basischange ] ) , @xmath148 . as we do not know the precise superposition of @xmath146 that yields the 220 state in this basis ,
let us proceed in reverse and start by writing the @xmath67-state in the @xmath149 basis : @xmath150 which we have written as a paired state@xcite using cauchy s identity @xmath151 = \psi_{110}$ ] .
note that the @xmath152-state can be written as @xmath153 , meaning that it has identical correlations between any two particles , so it is not necessary to indicate spin degrees of freedom explicitly .
in particular , the state has the same form in any ( pseudo-)spin basis .
we follow ho@xcite to denote the spin and spatial coordinates separately in the pair wave - function , and adopt the notation @xmath154 \prod_{i <
j}^{n}(z_i - z_j ) \nonumber\\ = & 2^{-\frac{n}{2}}\pf \left [ \frac{|+ - \rangle + |- + \rangle}{z_i - z_j } \right ] \prod_{i < j}^{n}(z_i - z_j ) \\ \equiv & 2^{-\frac{n}{2 } } \pf \left [ \frac{\mathbf{e}_z \cdot ( i \boldsymbol{\hat\sigma } \sigma_y)_{\alpha\beta}}{z_i - z_j } \right ] \prod_{i < j}^{n}(z_i^\alpha - z_j^\beta ) , \nonumber \label{eq:220_dvector}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where kets @xmath155 indicate the spin - states of the two members of a cooper pair , and their coordinates are written as @xmath52 , or @xmath156 when a specific spin state is represented . in the second step ,
we have chosen to symmetrize the notation , and finally , we use the notation of the symmetric spin - triplet wave function @xmath157 in terms of the @xmath48-vector , @xmath158 , with @xmath159 .
now , we take the inverse basis transformation to the original basis of pseudospin up / down .
the spin - state takes the form @xmath160\nonumber\\ & = |\uparrow \uparrow\rangle - |\downarrow \downarrow\rangle\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the language of spin - triplet pairing , this corresponds to @xmath161 , i.e. , the transformation amounts to a @xmath162 rotation of the spin reference frame around the @xmath163-axis . replacing the pair correlation function in ( [ eq:220_dvector ] ) accordingly , and using the explicit definition of the pfaffian of an @xmath164 matrix @xmath165 , [ eq : def_pfaffian ] m = _ s_n ( ) _ k = 1^n/2 m _ ( 2k-1 ) , ( 2k ) , where @xmath34 are elements of the permutation group @xmath166 , we find the explicit expression @xmath167\end{aligned}\ ] ] the pair wave function states that each pair is either both spin - up or both spin - down ( with a minus - sign ) . as we sum over permutations , we can make those choices explicit for all terms up to reordering of the permutation .
the number of choices to be made is equal to the binomial coefficient , and we have @xmath168\nn\\ & \times \prod_{k ' = 1}^{n/2-p}\left [ \frac{-1}{z^\downarrow_{\sigma(2p+2k'-1 ) } - z^\downarrow_{\sigma(2p+2k ' ) } } \right ] \nn\\ = & \psi_{111}\sum_{p=0}^{n/2 } \sum_{\sigma \in s_n } \text{sgn}(\sigma ) \frac{1}{2^{2p}p!}\prod_{k = 1}^{p}\left [ \frac{1}{z^\uparrow_{\sigma(2k-1 ) } - z^\uparrow_{\sigma(2k ) } } \right]\nn\\ & \times \frac{(-1)^{(\bar p)}}{2^{2\bar p}(\bar p ) ! } \prod_{k ' = 1}^{\bar p}\left [ \frac{1}{z^\downarrow_{\sigma(2p+2k'-1 ) } - z^\downarrow_{\sigma(2p+2k ' ) } } \right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used the shorthand notation @xmath169 .
we can now identify @xmath170 , and @xmath171 , as well as noting that the products of up - spin pair wave functions forms a complete pfaffian ( and similarly for the down - spin part ) .
hence , we see that the preceding expression is precisely the superposition _ 220 = _ , where @xmath172 is the operator that symmetrizes over all possible assignments of up - spin and down - spin to the particles . the basis change is explained more easily in terms of the cft representation of fermion fields .
let us focus only on the neutral part of the fermion operators , only , involving a neutral boson field denoted @xmath173 within this section .
we then have the representations as in eq .
( [ eop - a ] ) ( up to overall charge factors ) , @xmath174 hence , the ( anti-)symmetric superpositions yield @xmath175 the ( neutral part of the ) @xmath67-state has the form @xmath176 * ( * * needs to be fixed * * ) * again , contributions to the wave function arise by choices of pairs with either spin - up or spin - down , the pair - wave function from the ope of pairs of @xmath177-fields yields a pfaffian for each layer , and sectors with @xmath178 differ by an overall sign , as above .
let us now derive the parent hamiltonian for the coupled moore - read state , starting from the known parent hamiltonian for the @xmath67-state given in ( [ eq : ham220 ] ) , and we express the pseudopotentials in terms of the pair creation / annihilation operators ( [ eq : pair_creation ] ) , so the hamiltonian can be written in brief as _
220 = ^_++ _ + + + ^_ _ , and we imply the relative angular momentum to be zero , as well as summation over the angular momenta @xmath179 as per eq .
( [ eq : projectors_sphere ] ) .
the hamiltonian in the basis of spins @xmath180 is obtained by making the replacements a _ = ( a_a _ ) .
shortening the notation for clebsch - gordon coefficients to include only the angular momentum indices @xmath181 , and introducing the shorthand @xmath182 , we have @xmath183.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , we can identify the terms of the parent hamiltonian of eq .
( [ eq : ham220ud ] ) , as the intra - layer contact repulsions @xmath184 ( first line ) , inter - layer contact repulsion @xmath60 ( second line ) and the local pair tunneling terms @xmath185 ( third line ) .
in this appendix we show explicitly that the coupled moore - read state is the exact zero - energy ground state of @xmath109 , or equivalently , of @xmath186 .
we first focus on the example of four particles and then generalize the result .
the effective two - body hamiltonian with pair tunneling can be written using the following notation , ^()&= & _ i , j = 1^n ^(2)(z_i - z_j ) _
ss = , ( |ssss| + |ssss| + & + & |ssss| + |ssss|)_ij , where we have inserted the parameter @xmath42 to represent the strength of the pair tunneling term . starting with a total of four particles , the coupled moore - read wave function consists of three sectors : either all particles are in the top layer , all particles in the bottom layer or they divide equally between the two layers . using the notation @xmath187 , we start with an ( almost ) general superposition of these sectors ( assuming equal weight for the sectors @xmath188 , and @xmath189 , for ease of writing ) , which can be written as follows , |&= & _ 0 ^ 4,0 + k _ 0 ^ 2,2 + _ 0 ^ 0,4 + & = & ( ( 13)(14)(23)(24 ) - ( 12)(14)(23)(34 ) + & + & ( 12)(13)(24)(34))|s s s s + & + & k((13)(14)(23)(24)|s s ss + & - & ( 12)(14)(23)(34 ) |s s s s + & + & ( 12)(13)(24)(34)|s s s s ) . here
we have omitted @xmath190 and the parameter @xmath191 is the relative weight of the sectors with two particles in each layer , with respect to sectors where all four particles are in one layer . applying the effective hamiltonian on this wave function , the terms that are not trivially zero
take the form,@xcite @xmath192 thus , we can solve the model for its ground state for @xmath193 , by setting @xmath194 we see that the remaining terms vanish and @xmath195 is found to be the exact , zero - energy ground state of @xmath196 .
( generally , alpha plays the role of a phase difference of different particle number sectors , so it could equivalently be chosen as a complex number of unit norm
the problem is still solvable in that case , with correspondingly adjusted relative phases in the components of the wave function . ) in general , if we denote the ground state as , |&= & _ ss = , _
n = 0:2^n k_n m_n m_n - n _ i < j = 1^n ( z_i - z_j ) + & & |(n_s
= n , n_s = n - n)where @xmath197 is the pfaffian of @xmath91 particles , m_n & = & _ s_n ( ) + & & _ k = 1^n/2 , @xmath198 is the amplitude of the corresponding term , and @xmath199 denotes all permutations of @xmath91 particles in the @xmath200 layer and @xmath201 particles in the @xmath202 layer , then it can be shown that @xmath203 if a recursive equation of the form 2k_n = -(k_n-2 + k_n+2 ) , + with boundary conditions , @xmath204 is satisfied .
this equation always has solutions of the form @xmath205 , @xmath206 , and @xmath207 with @xmath208 , therefore @xmath195 is an exact , zero - energy ground state of @xmath109 , or @xmath209 .
a similar analysis can be done to show that in the presence of extra flux , quasiholes are created at the same position in both layers .
the example of two quasiholes and four particles might be illuminating .
suppose the particles in each layer see the quasiholes at different positions , for example , let the particles in the @xmath200 layer see the quasiholes at positions @xmath210 and @xmath211 while the particles in the @xmath202 layer see them at positions @xmath212 and @xmath213 .
using the notation @xmath214 and @xmath215 , the expression for the quasihole wave function takes the form , |^ & = & ( ( 13)(14)(23)(24 ) _ 12 _ 34 + & - & ( 12)(14)(23)(34 ) _ 13 _ 24 + & + & ( 12)(13)(24)(34 ) _ 14 _ 23)|s s s s + & + & k((13)(14)(23)(24)_12 _34|s s ss + & -&(12)(14)(23)(34 ) _ 13 _24|s s s s + & + & ( 12)(13)(24)(34)_14 _23|s s s s ) . similar to the previous case , applying the effective hamiltonian on this wave function results in the following non - trivial terms , ^|^ = ( ( z_1 - z_2 ) + ( z_3 - z_4 ) ) ( 13)(14)(23)(24 ) + ( _ 12(_34 + _34k)|s s s s+ _ 12(_34k +
_34)|s s ss ) + - ( ( z_1 - z_3 ) + ( z_2 - z_4 ) ) ( 12)(14)(23)(34 ) + ( _ 13(_24 + _24k)|s s s s+_13(_24k + _24)|s s s s ) + + ( ( z_1 - z_4 ) + ( z_2 - z_3 ) ) ( 12)(13)(24)(34 ) + ( _ 14(_23 + _23k)|s s s s+_14(_23k + _23)|s s s s ) and for @xmath216 , we see that for these terms to vanish we must have @xmath217 , i.e. the quasiholes must be at exactly the same position in both layers .
to make our presentation self - contained , we briefly review how to count the angular momentum degeneracy associated with the quasiholes of the single - layer moore - read state . in ref . ,
read and rezayi start with the explicit form of the quasihole wave functions for the moore - read state , as per their equation 2.14 : @xmath218 here @xmath219 is the number of flux quanta attached to the underlying particles to composite fermionize them . in this paper
we focus on bosons with @xmath220 .
@xmath221 is a polynomial of the form , [ eq : phi ] ( z_(p+2l-1),z_(p+2l ) ; w_1 ,
w_2n ) = + _ s_2n _ r = 1^n(z_(p+2l-1 ) - w_(2r-1))(z_(p+2l ) - w_(2r ) ) , which is symmetric under the exchange of @xmath222 s .
read and rezayi demonstrate that the degeneracy arising with the addition of @xmath91 flux quanta to the ground state of the system is characterized by two features : firstly , by the number @xmath223 and position of quasihole coordinates @xmath224 , @xmath225 and , secondly , by the state of @xmath226 fermions , which can be left unpaired at zero energetic cost , whenever quasiholes are present .
while the orbital degeneracy would also be found in simple abelian states , the second contribution represents the characteristic topological degeneracy associated with the non - abelian nature of the quasihole excitations .
in fact , the physics of the unpaired fermions can be used not only to count excitations , but also to provide signatures for the @xmath6-wave pairing of composite fermions in the ground state of realistic two - body hamiltonians in the second landau - level.@xcite the state ( [ eq : readrezayiqh ] ) describes @xmath6 fermions that are left unpaired . for each flux
quantum added to the system , that is one for each _ pair _ of quasiholes , the unpaired electrons gain an additional degree of freedom , which is analogous to an effective landau - level orbital that they may occupy .
this is one orbital for each flux added above the ground state .
we label the states of unpaired fermions with integers @xmath227 , @xmath228 , which represent the orbital that is occupied by a fermion , and we choose @xmath229.@xcite hence , for a situation with @xmath6 unpaired fermions and flux @xmath230 , i.e. @xmath91 flux quanta above the ground state , there are [ eq : dtopo ] d_(n , p ) = degenerate states with fixed quasihole positions .
this counting can be thought of as arising from @xmath6 fermions living in @xmath91 orbitals .
the overall topological degeneracy adds up to d _ = _
^n d_(n , p ) = 2^n-1 states , where the sum goes only over values of @xmath6 that match the parity of @xmath41 , so that @xmath231 is always even .
this result matches the non - abelian nature of the quasiholes , which have quantum dimension @xmath232 .
the orbital degeneracy follows from expanding the quasihole states in terms of symmetric polynomials of the @xmath223 quasihole coordinates @xmath224 , as shown in eq .
[ eq : phi ] . read and rezayi show that the relevant polynomials have a degree of at most @xmath233 , i.e. the number of unbroken pairs .
hence , this contribution can be thought of as the degeneracy associated with placing @xmath223 bosons in a landau level with @xmath233 flux quanta , which yields the orbital degeneracy of , [ eq : dorb ] d_(n , n , p ) = , and the total degeneracy of quasihole states of the moore - read state for fixed @xmath41 and @xmath91 becomes , d_(n , n ) = _ ^n d_(n , n , p ) d_(n , p ) . here
, we are also interested in the degeneracy of quasihole states as a function of angular momentum . in order to obtain this dependence
, we can use read and rezayi s analogy of unpaired fermions and bosons filling the respective numbers of orbitals as discussed above . in order to obtain the angular momentum decomposition of each of these terms individually
, we can use euler s generating function ( n_,q , x ) = _ m=1^n _ , [ eq : partitionfinite ] to be taken as an infinite series in the abstract variable @xmath219 , and we have introduced an additional parameter @xmath234 .
the degree @xmath36 of individual powers of @xmath219 encodes the angular momentum of a corresponding landau level orbital @xmath235 .
the parameter @xmath234 allows us to distinguish between terms stemming from unoccupied orbitals with trivial factors @xmath236 and occupied orbitals that are proportional to @xmath234 . for @xmath237 ,
the ensuing series provides the character of a chiral boson field , and powers in @xmath234 provide additional information on the number of occupied orbitals in the individual terms at fixed angular momentum .
this allows us to read off the finite size counting of the number of states with angular momentum @xmath238 for @xmath191 bosons in @xmath239 orbitals by taking certain derivatives , [ eq : dbose ] d_(k , n_,l ) = |_x , q0 the analogous counting for fermions follows from mapping the problem of @xmath191 fermions in @xmath239 orbitals onto the corresponding bose problem where @xmath240 orbitals are removed due to pauli blocking , and hence , [ eq : dfermi ] d_(k , n_,l ) = d_(k , n_-k+1,l ) . using read - rezayi s insights
, we obtain the count of quasihole states at a given angular momentum @xmath92 by following the rules of angular momentum addition and convoluting the bose and fermi countings . for the moore - read pfaffian state , with @xmath41 electrons and @xmath91 additional flux quanta , the @xmath92 dependent degeneracies become , [ eq : dmr ] d_(n , n ,
l_z ) = _ ^n _ l = 0^l_z + d_(2n , , l ) d_(p , n-1,l_z - l).finally , the degeneracies of state per @xmath92 sector can be translated into the count of multiplets in the total angular momentum @xmath241 , as given in the original paper by read and rezayi .
because eigenstates of rotationally invariant hamiltonians always occur in @xmath242-fold degenerate angular momentum multiplets @xmath243 , with @xmath244 , the number of multiplets @xmath245 at a given total angular momentum @xmath241 is given by @xmath246 in tables [ tab : degmrxmr ] and [ tab : degeffectiveh ] , we denote the structure of the zero - energy hilbert subspaces @xmath95 via their multiplet structure using the notation [ eq : low_energy_hilbert ] = _ l=0^l _ l^(l ) .
going beyond the counting of quasihole states in finite size systems , the large angular momentum part of the count of quasihole states maps onto the counting of edge states of the system , which is _
universal_.@xcite formally , the counting of edge modes can be deduced from @xmath247 in the limit of a ` large correlation hole ' with both @xmath248 and @xmath249 ( while maintaining @xmath250).@xcite in this picture , the largest angular momentum @xmath251 of the quasihole states on a sphere maps to the edge state of a disc with momentum @xmath252 , while general states obey @xmath253 .
we use this correspondence in this paper to compare finite size data to the edge state counting in the infinite system , which is conveniently described by the characters of conformal field theories.@xcite for the moore - read state , the edge of the infinite size droplet is described by a product of the majorana - weyl character @xmath254 and the character of a chiral boson @xmath110.@xcite the edge spectrum carries information about the parity of the fermion number and hence differs in sectors of even / odd number of particles , with the respective majorana - weyl characters , [ eq : mwchi ] ^_= . defining the character of the chiral boson as , ^=_n _ ( n_,q,1 ) , [ eq : chiralbosonchi ] the character for the moore - read edge becomes , [ eq : singlemrcharacter ] ^(n ) = ^ ^_(-1)^n , where only the parity of the number of particles in the droplet affects the result . f.a .
bais , b.j .
schroers and j.k .
slingerland , phys.rev.lett .
89 , 181601 ( 2002 ) .
bais , b.j .
schroers and j.k .
slingerland , jhep 0305 , 068 ( 2003 ) .
f. a. bais and j. k. slingerland , phys .
b * 79 * , 045316 ( 2009 ) .
bais , j.k .
slingerland and s.m .
haaker phys .
102 , 220403 ( 2009 ) m. barkeshli and x .- g .
wen , phys .
105 , 216804 ( 2010 ) .
m. barkeshli and x .- g .
wen , phys .
b * 84 * , 115121 ( 2011 )
. f. j. burnell , s. h. simon , and j. k. slingerland , phys .
b * 84 * , 125434 ( 2011 )
. f. j. burnell , s. h. simon , and j. k. slingerland , new j. phys .
14 015004 ( 2012 ) .
a. kitaev , annals of physics * 303 * , 2 ( 2003 ) .
m. b. hastings and x .-
wen , phys .
b * 72 * , 045141 ( 2005 ) .
a. hamma , c. castelnovo , and c. chamon , phys .
b * 79 * , 245122 ( 2009 ) .
i. klich , annals of physics * 325 * , 2120 ( 2010 ) .
s. dusuel , m. kamfor , r. ors , k.p .
schmidt , and j. vidal , phys .
* 106 * , 107203 ( 2011 ) .
a. pinczuk and s. das sarma , editors , perspectives in quantum hall effects : novel quantum liquids in low - dimensional semiconductor structures ( wiley , new york ; chichester , 1997 ) .
eisenstein , ann .
* 5 * , 159 ( 2014 ) .
a. vaezi and m. barkeshli , arxiv:1403.3383 ( 2014 ) .
t. mnsson , v. lahtinen , j. suorsa and e. ardonne , phys .
b * 88 * , 041403(r ) ( 2013 ) . c.v . kraus , m. dalmonte , m.a .
baranov , a.m. luchli , and p. zoller , phys .
lett . * 111 * , 173004 ( 2013 ) .
a. bhler , n. lang , c.v .
kraus , g. mller , s.d .
huber , and h.p .
bchler , arxiv:1403.0593 ( 2014 ) . c. l. kane , r. mukhopadhyay , and t. c. lubensky , phys .
88 , 036401 ( 2002 ) .
teo and c.l .
kane , phys .
b 89 , 085101 ( 2014 ) .
t. neupert , c. chamon , c. mudry , and r. thomale , arxiv:1403.0953 ( 2014 ) .
m. dolev , m. heiblum , v. umansky , a. stern , and d. mahalu , nature * 452 * , 829 ( 2008 ) .
i. radu , j. miller , c. marcus , m. kastner , l.n .
pfeiffer , and k.w .
west , science * 320 * , 899 ( 2008 ) .
willett , l.n .
pfeiffer , and k.w .
west , proceedings of the national academy of sciences * 106 * , 8853 ( 2009 ) .
p. jiang , h. choi , w. kang , s.h .
simon , l.n .
pfeiffer , k.w .
west , and k.w .
baldwin , arxiv:1112.3400 ( 2011 ) .
willett , rep .
. phys . * 76 * , 076501 ( 2013 ) .
lutchyn , j.d .
sau , and s. das sarma , phys .
* 105 * , 077001 ( 2010 ) .
j. alicea , phys .
b * 81 * , 125318 ( 2010 ) .
v. mourik , k. zuo , s.m .
frolov , s.r .
plissard , e.p.a.m .
bakkers , and l.p .
kouwenhoven , science * 336 * , 1003 ( 2012 ) .
a. das , y. ronen , y. most , y. oreg , m. heiblum , and h. shtrikman , nat phys * 8 * , 887 ( 2012 ) .
deng , c.l .
huang , m. larsson , p. caroff , and h.q .
xu , nano lett .
* 12 * , 6414 ( 2012 ) .
laughlin , phys .
50 , 1395 ( 1983 ) .
haldane , phys .
lett . * 51 * , 605 ( 1983 ) .
f.d.m . haldane and e.h .
rezayi , phys .
lett . * 60 * , 956 ( 1988 ) .
n. read and e.h .
rezayi , phys .
b * 54 * , 16864 ( 1996 ) .
n. read and e.h .
rezayi , phys .
b * 59 * , 8084 ( 1999 ) .
s.c . davenport and s.h .
simon , phys . rev .
b 85 , 075430 ( 2012 ) .
a. kitaev , physics reports * 321 * , 2 ( 2006 ) .
m. a. levin and x .- g .
wen , phys .
b * 71 * , 045110 ( 2005 ) .
k. walker and z. wang , front .
* 7 * , 150 ( 2011 ) . c. w. von keyserlingk , f. j. burnell , and s. h. simon , phys .
b * 87 * , 045107 ( 2013 ) . c. zhang , s. tewari , r.m . lutchyn , and s. das sarma , phys .
* 101 * , 160401 ( 2008 ) .
cooper and g.v .
shlyapnikov , phys .
lett . * 103 * , 155302 ( 2009 ) .
han , y.h . chan , w. yi , a. j. daley , s. diehl , p. zoller , and l.m .
duan , phys .
lett . * 103 * , 070404 ( 2009 ) .
m. sato , y. takahashi , and s. fujimoto , phys .
lett . * 103 * , 020401 ( 2009 ) .
g. mller and s. h. simon , phys .
b * 77 * , 075319 ( 2008 ) .
m. greiter , x .-
wen , and f. wilczek , nuclear physics b * 374 * , 567 ( 1992 ) .
p. bonderson , a.e .
feiguin , and c. nayak , phys .
lett . * 106 * , 186802 ( 2011 ) .
g. mller , a. wjs , and n.r .
cooper , phys .
lett . * 107 * , 036803 ( 2011 ) .
a. kol and n. read , phys .
b * 48 * , 8890 ( 1993 )
palmer and d. jaksch , phys .
lett . * 96 * , 180407 ( 2006 ) .
palmer , a. klein , and d. jaksch , phys .
a * 78 * , 013609 ( 2008 ) .
g. mller and n.r .
cooper , phys .
103 * , 105303 ( 2009 ) .
haldane , phys .
* 61 * , 2015 ( 1988 ) .
sheng , z .- c .
gu , k. sun , and l. sheng , nature communications * 2 * , 389 ( 2011 ) .
t. neupert , l. santos , c. chamon , and c. mudry , phys .
lett . * 106 * , 236804 ( 2011 ) .
n. regnault and b.a .
bernevig , phys .
x * 1 * , 021014 ( 2011 ) .
t. scaffidi and g. mller , phys .
lett . * 109 * , 246805 ( 2012 ) . y .- h .
jain , and k. sun , phys .
b * 86 * , 165129 ( 2012 ) .
z. liu and e.j .
bergholtz , phys .
b * 87 * , 035306 ( 2013 ) .
wu , n. regnault , and b.a .
bernevig , phys .
lett . * 110 * , 106802 ( 2013 ) .
f. harper , s.h .
simon and r. roy , preprint , arxiv:1404.5303 .
wen , phys .
b * 41 * , 12838 ( 1990 ) . m. milovanovi and n. read , phys . rev .
b * 53 * , 13559 ( 1996 ) .
m. freedman , c. nayak , and k. shtengel , phys .
b * 78 * , 174411 ( 2008 )
. i. d. rodriguez , a. sterdyniak , m. hermanns , j. k. slingerland , and n. regnault , phys .
b * 85 * , 035128 ( 2012 ) .
g. j. sreejith , a. wjs , and j. k. jain , phys .
lett . * 107 * , 136802 ( 2011 ) .
r. dijkgraaf , c. vafa , e. verlinde , h. verlinde , _ comm .
phys . _ * 123 * , issue 3 , 485 - 526 ( 1989 ) .
hofstadter , phys .
b * 14 * , 2239 ( 1976 ) .
p. difrancesco , p. mathieu and d. senechal , _ conformal field theory _ , springer , ( 1997 ) . by setting @xmath258 , the hamiltonian ( [ eq : hameffalpha ] ) recovers a pair tunneling term proportional to @xmath259 in analogy with ref . , where @xmath260 is related to the deviation from flux density @xmath72 in the hofstadter spectrum , i.e. , @xmath261 .
we had previously documented a large overlap of the ground state wave function near @xmath262 .
our derivation in section [ sec : josephsoncoupling ] demonstrate that the wave function is indeed exact at @xmath263 , or @xmath264 , where the hamiltonian reduces to ( [ eq : ham220ud ] ) .
wen , advances in physics * 44 * , 405 ( 1995 ) .
see e.g. : e. ardonne , n. read , e.h .
rezayi , and k. schoutens , nuclear physics b * 607 * , 549 ( 2001 ) .
similarly , the edge theory for odd @xmath265 is described by the overall character , @xmath266 .
note that one could equivalently define the electron operators as @xmath267 and @xmath268 , and then further symmetrize the resulting wave function over pairs of particles in each layer .
the definitions in eq .
( [ eop - u ] ) automatically do this .
this is analogous to the fact that in the edge spectrum of laughlin states , in systems with fixed numbers of particles , the compactification radius of @xmath269 does not appear and the mode counting corresponds to that of a an uncompactified @xmath269 . here , strictly speaking
, we are applying the lowest landau level ( lll ) projection of the effective hamiltonian , @xmath270 .
however , that the first projection has no impact since the groundstate is already in the lll and the second projection is irrelevant since the groundstate is the zero energy eigenstate of @xmath271 .
eisenstein , science * 305 * , 950 ( 2004 ) ; j.p . eisenstein and a. macdonald ,
nature * 432 * , 691 ( 2004 ) ; k. moon , h. mori , k. yang , s.m .
girvin , a.h .
macdonald , l. zheng , d. yoshioka , and s .- c .
zhang , phys .
b * 51 * , 5138 ( 1995 ) ; k. yang , k. moon , l. belkhir , h. mori , s.m .
girvin , a.h .
macdonald , l. zheng , and d. yoshioka , phys .
b * 54 * , 11644 ( 1996 ) .
g. mller , s. h. simon , and e.h .
rezayi , phys .
b * 79 * , 125106 ( 2009 ) . i.b .
spielman , j.p .
eisenstein , l.n .
pfeiffer , and k.w .
west , phys .
* 87 * , 036803 ( 2001 ) .
g. mller and s. h. simon , advances in condensed matter physics , vol .
2011 , article i d 815169 , doi:10.1155/2011/815169 | we study a quantum hall bilayer system of bosons at total filling factor @xmath0 , and study the phase that results from short ranged pair - tunneling combined with short ranged interlayer interactions .
we introduce two exactly solvable model hamiltonians which both yield the coupled moore - read state [ phys .
rev .
lett . * 108 * , 256809 ( 2012 ) ] as a ground state , when projected onto fixed particle numbers in each layer .
one of these hamiltonians describes a gapped topological phase while the other is gapless .
however , on introduction of a pair tunneling term , the second system becomes gapped and develops the same topological order as the gapped hamiltonian .
supported by the exact solution of the full zero - energy quasihole spectrum and a conformal field theory approach , we develop an intuitive picture of this system as two coupled composite fermion superconductors . in this language
, pair tunneling provides a josephson coupling of the superconducting phases of the two layers , and gaps out the goldstone mode associated with particle transport between the layers . in particular
, this implies that quasiparticles are confined between the layers . in the bulk
, the resulting phase has the topological order of the halperin 220 phase with u(1)@xmath1 u(1)@xmath2 topological order , but it is realized in the symmetric / antisymmetric - basis of the layer index .
consequently , the edge spectrum at a fixed particle number reveals an unexpected u(1)@xmath3 u(1 ) structure . |
the first detection of the transit of an exoplanet in front of its parent star ( @xcite ; @xcite ) opened a new avenue to determine the characteristics of these exotic worlds .
for all but the most eccentric cases , approximately half - an - orbit after their transits these planets pass behind their star along our line of sight allowing their thermal flux to be measured in the infrared .
the first detections of an exoplanet s thermal emission ( @xcite ; @xcite ) came from observations in space with spitzer using the infrared array camera ( irac ; @xcite ) . since then the vast majority of such measurements have been made using spitzer at wavelengths longer than 3 @xmath10 , and thus longwards of the blackbody peak of these `` hot '' exoplanets .
recent observations have extended secondary eclipse detections into the near - infrared ; the first detection was from space with nicmos on the hubble space telescope ( @xcite at @xmath112 @xmath10 ) .
more recently , near - infrared detections have been achieved from the ground ; the first of these detections include a @xmath116@xmath1 detection in k - band of tres-3b using the william herschel telescope @xcite , a @xmath114@xmath1 detection in z-band of ogle - tr-56b using magellan and the very large telescope ( vlt ; @xcite ) , and a @xmath115@xmath1 detection at @xmath112.1 @xmath10 of corot-1b also with the vlt @xcite .
thermal emission measurements in the near - infrared are crucial to our understanding of these planets atmospheres , as they allow us to constrain hot jupiters thermal emission near their blackbody peaks .
the combination of spitzer / irac and near - infrared thermal emission measurements allows us to constrain the temperature - pressure profiles of these planets atmospheres over a range of pressures @xcite , better estimate the bolometric luminosity of these planets dayside emission , and thus contributes to a more complete understanding of how these planets transport heat from the day to nightside at a variety of depths and pressures in their atmospheres @xcite .
the transiting hot jupiter tres-2b orbits a g0 v star with a period of @xmath112.47 @xmath12 @xcite . according to the @xcite theory this places tres-2b marginally in the hottest ,
mostly highly irradiated class ( the pm - class ) of hot jupiters and close to the dividing line between this hottest class and the merely warm class of hot jupiters ( the pl - class ) .
thus tres-2b could be a key object to refine the dividing line between these two classes , and indicate the physical cause of this demarcation , or reveal whether this divide even exists .
recently @xcite used spitzer / irac to measure the depth of the secondary eclipse of tres-2b in the four irac bands .
their best - fit eclipses are consistent with a circular orbit , and collectively they are able to place a 3@xmath1 limit on the eccentricity , @xmath2 , and argument of periastron , @xmath3 , of @xmath4@xmath2cos@xmath3@xmath4 @xmath6 0.0036 .
their best - fit eclipses at 3.6 , 5.8 and 8.0 @xmath10 are well - fit by a blackbody . at 4.5 @xmath10
they detect excess emission , in agreement with the theory of several researchers ( @xcite ) that predicts such excess due to water emission , rather than absorption , at this wavelength due to a temperature inversion in the atmosphere .
one - dimensional radiative - equilibrium models for hot jupiter planets generally show that the atmospheric opacity is dominated by water vapor , which is especially high in the mid - infrared , but has prominent windows ( the jhk bands ) in the near infrared @xcite .
one can probe more deeply , to gas at higher pressure , in these opacity windows .
models without temperature inversions feature strong emission in the jhk bands , since one sees down to the hotter gas .
models with temperature inversions , since they feature a relatively hotter upper atmosphere and relatively cooler lower atmosphere , yield weaker emission in the near - ir ( jhk ) , but stronger emission in the mid - infrared @xcite .
near - infrared thermal emission measurements should thus be useful to determine whether tres-2b does or does not harbour a temperature inversion .
owing to its high irradiation , with an incident flux of @xmath11@xmath13@xmath14@xmath15 @xmath16@xmath17@xmath18 , and favourable planet - to - star radius ratio ( @[email protected] ) , we included tres-2b in our program observing the secondary eclipses of some of the hottest of the hot jupiters from the ground . here
we present ks - band observations bracketing tres-2b s secondary eclipse using the wide - field infrared camera ( wircam ) on the canada - france - hawaii telescope ( cfht ) .
we report a 5@xmath1 detection of its thermal emission .
we observed tres-2 ( @xmath9=9.846 ) with wircam @xcite on cfht on 2009 june 10 under photometric conditions .
the observations lasted for @xmath113.5 hours evenly bracketing the predicted secondary eclipse of this hot jupiter assuming it has a circular orbit .
numerous reference stars were also observed in the 21x21 arcmin field of view of wircam . to minimize the impact of flat field errors , intrapixel variations and to keep the flux of the target star well below detector saturation , we defocused the telescope to 1.5 mm , such that the flux of our target was spread over a ring @xmath1120 pixels in diameter ( 6 ) on our array .
we observed tres-2 in `` stare '' mode on cfht where the target star is observed continuously without dithering .
5-second exposures were used to avoid saturation . to increase the observing efficiency we acquired a series of data - cubes each containing twelve 5-second exposures .
the twelve exposure data - cube is the maximum number of exposures allowed in a guide - cube in queue mode at cfht . to counteract drifts in the position of the stars positions on the wircam chips , which we had noticed in earlier wircam observations of secondary
eclipses @xcite , we initiated a corrective guiding `` bump '' before every image cube to recenter the stellar point - spread - function as near as possible to the original pixels at the start of the observation .
the effective duty cycle after accounting for readout and for saving exposures was 43% .
the images were preprocessed with the iiwi pipeline .
this pipeline includes the following steps : applying a non - linearity flux correction , removing bad and saturated pixels , dark subtraction , flat - fielding , sky subtraction , zero - point calibration and a rough astrometry determination .
we sky subtract our data by constructing a normalized sky frame built by taking the median of a stack of source - masked and background - normalized on - sky images .
our on - sky images consist of 15 dithered in - focus images observed before and after the on - target sequence .
for each on - target image the normalized sky frame is scaled to the target median background level and then subtracted .
we performed aperture photometry on our target star and all unsaturated , reasonably bright reference stars on the wircam array .
we used a circular aperture with a radius of 12.5 pixels .
we tested larger and smaller apertures in increments of 0.5 pixels , and confirmed that this size of aperture returned optimal photometry .
the residual background was estimated using an annulus with an inner radius of 21 pixels , and an outer radius of 30 pixels ; a few different sizes of sky annuli were tested , and it was found that the accuracy of the resulting photometry was not particularly sensitive to the size of the sky aperture . as tres-2 has a nearby reference star ( 0.17 separation ) that falls in our sky aperture , we exclude a slice of the annulus that falls near this reference star to avoid any bias in background determination to -45@xmath20 degrees as measured from due north towards the east are excluded from our annulus . ] . during our observations , despite the aforementioned corrective `` bump '' to keep the centroid of our stellar point - spread - function ( psf ) as steady as possible , our target star and the rest of the stars on our array displayed high frequency shifts in position ( figure [ figshifts ] ) . to ensure that the apertures for our photometry were centered in the middle of the stellar psfs
, we used a center - of - mass calculation , with pixel flux substituted for mass , to determine the x and y center of our defocused stellar rings for each one of our target and reference star apertures .
the light curves for our target and reference stars following our aperture photometry displayed significant , systematic variations in intensity ( see the top panel of figure [ figtres2brefstars ] ) , possibly due to changes in atmospheric transmission , seeing and airmass , guiding errors and/or other effects . the target light curve was then corrected for these systematic variations by normalizing its flux to the 11 reference stars that show the smallest deviation from the target star outside of the expected occultation .
reference stars that showed significant deviations in - eclipse from that of the target star and other reference stars , as indicated by a much larger root - mean - square in - eclipse than out - of - eclipse due to intermittent systematic effects for instance , were also excluded . for the reference stars that were chosen for the comparison to our target star
, the flux of each one of these star was divided by its median - value , and then an average reference star light curve was produced by taking the mean of the lightcurves of these median - corrected reference stars .
the target flux was then normalized by this mean reference star light curve .
ccc 1 & j19072977 + 4918354 & 10.294 + 2 & j19065501 + 4916195 & 10.737 + 3 & j19071365 + 4912041 & 11.270 + 4 & j19065809 + 4916315 & 9.875 + 5 & j19070093 + 4917323 & 11.337 + 6 & j19074435 + 4915418 & 10.766 + 7 & j19071824 + 4916526 & 11.239 + 8 & j19073380 + 4916035 & 10.712 + 9 & j19071955 + 4911176 & 11.514 + 10 & j19075629 + 4923281 & 9.671 + 11 & j19065548 + 4925404 & 11.454 + [ tablestars ] figure [ figtres2bfullframearray ] marks the 11 reference stars used to correct the flux of our target ; the 2mass identifiers of the reference stars are given in table [ tablestars ] .
note that the majority of the reference stars with the smallest out of occultation residuals to our target star are on the same chip as our target , despite the fact that there are other reference stars on other chips closer in magnitude to our target .
we believe this is due to the differential electronic response of the different wircam chips , and have noticed this same effect with other wircam observations of other hot jupiter secondary eclipses @xcite .
following this correction we noticed that the flux of our target and reference stars displayed near - linear correlations with the x or y position of the centroid of the stellar psf on the chip .
given the aforementioned high frequecy of these shifts ( fig .
[ figshifts ] ) this suggests that any leftover trend with position and the flux of the star was instrumental in origin .
thus these near - linear trends ( figure [ figshiftscorrection ] top panels ) were removed from the data for both the target and reference stars by performing a fit to the x and y position of the centroid of the psf and the normalized flux for the out - of - eclipse photometry .
we fit the out - of - eclipse photometric flux to the x and y position of the centroid of the psf with a function of the following form : @xmath21 where @xmath22 , @xmath23 , and @xmath24 are constants .
we then apply this correction to both the in - eclipse and out - of - eclipse photometry .
the out - of - eclipse photometric data prior to and following this correction are displayed in figure [ figshiftscorrection ] ( bottom panels ) .
no other trends that were correlated with instrumental parameters were found . by correcting the flux of our target with these 11reference stars and by removing the above correlation with the x / y position on the chip the point - to - point scatter of our data outside occultation improves from a root - mean - square ( rms ) of 13.7@xmath1410@xmath25 to 0.71@xmath1410@xmath25 per every 58 @xmath26 ( or 5 images ) .
the photometry following the aforementioned analysis is largely free of systematics , as evidenced by the fact that the out - of - eclipse photometric precision lies near the gaussian noise expectation for binning the data of one over the square - root of the bin - size ( figure [ figbinbyn ] ) .
our observations in ks - band , though , are still well above the predicted photon noise rms limit of 2.3@xmath1410@xmath27 per 58 seconds . for the following analysis we set the uncertainty on our individual measurements as 0.95 times the rms of the out of eclipse photometry after the removal of a linear - trend with time ; we found simply using 1.0 times the rms of the out - of - eclipse photometry resulted in a reduced @xmath28 below one , and thus resulted in a slight over - estimate of our errors .
similarly to nearly all our near - infrared photometric data - sets taken with cfht / wircam ( e.g. @xcite ) , our ks - band photometry following the reduction exhibited an obvious background trend , @xmath29 .
this background term displayed a near - linear slope , and thus we fit the background with a linear - function of the form : @xmath30 where dt is the time interval from the beginning of the observations , and @xmath31 and @xmath32 are the fit parameters .
given that most of our other data - sets display these background trends , it is unlikely , but not impossible , that this slope is intrinsic to tres-2 .
we fit for the best - fit secondary eclipse and linear fit simultaneously using markov chain monte carlo ( mcmc ) methods ( @xcite ; @xcite ; described for our purposes in @xcite ) .
we use a 5@xmath1410@xmath33 step mcmc chain .
we fit for @xmath31 , @xmath32 , the depth of the secondary eclipse , @xmath34 , and the offset that the eclipse occurs later than the expected eclipse center , @xmath35 .
we also quote the best - fit phase , @xmath36 , as well as the best - fit mid - eclipse heliocentric julian - date , @xmath37 .
we use the @xcite algorithm without limb darkening to generate our best - fit secondary eclipse model .
we obtain our stellar and planetary parameters for tres-2 from @xcite , including the planetary period and ephemeris .
the results from these fits are presented in table [ tableparams ] .
the phase dependence of the best - fit secondary eclipse is presented in figure [ figtres2bcontour ] .
the best - fit secondary eclipse is presented in figure [ figtres2b ] . ;
solid - line ) , 95.5% ( 2@xmath1 ; dashed - line ) and 99.7% ( 3@xmath1 ; short dashed - line ) credible regions from our mcmc analysis on the secondary eclipse depth , @xmath34 , and phase , @xmath36 .
the `` x '' in the middle of the plot denotes the best - fit point from our mcmc analysis . ] , while the bottom panel shows the binned residuals from the best - fit model . in each one of the panels the best - fit best - fit secondary eclipse and background , @xmath29 ,
is shown with the red line .
the expected mid - secondary eclipse is if tres-2b has zero eccentricity . ]
ccccc reduced @xmath28 & 1.089@xmath38 & 1.086@xmath39 + @xmath34 & 0.062@xmath0% & 0.064@xmath40% + @xmath41 ( @xmath42 ) & 4.5@xmath43 & 3.8@xmath44 + @xmath37 ( hjd-2440000 ) & 14994.0605@xmath45 & 14994.0600@xmath46 + @xmath31 & 0.00061@xmath47 & 0.00061@xmath48 + @xmath32 ( @xmath49 ) & -0.005@xmath50 & -0.005@xmath51 + @xmath36 & 0.5014@xmath52 & 0.5012@xmath53 + @xmath54 ( @xmath9 ) & 1636@xmath8 & 1646@xmath55 + @xmath56 & 0.0020@xmath57 & 0.0017@xmath58 + @xmath59 & 0.358@xmath60 & 0.367@xmath61 + [ tableparams ] to determine the effect of any excess systematic noise on our photometry and the resulting fits we employ the `` residual - permutation '' method as discussed in @xcite . in this method
the best - fit model is subtracted from the data , the residuals are shifted between 1 and the total number of data points ( @xmath62=1056 in our case ) , and then the best - fit model is added back to the residuals .
we then refit the adjusted lightcurve with a 5000-step mcmc chain and record the parameters of the lowest @xmath63 point reached . by inverting the residuals we are able to perform @xmath64 total iterations .
the best - fit parameters and uncertainties obtained with this method are similar to those found for our mcmc method and are listed in table [ tableparams ] . as the two methods produce similar results we employ the mcmc errors for the rest of this paper .
we also test for autocorrelation among the residuals to our best - fit model using the durbin - watson test @xcite ; for the durbin - watson test a test - statistic greater than 1.0 and less than 3.0 ( ideally near 2.0 ) indiciates a lack of autocorrelation .
our residuals pass this test with a test - statistic of 1.97 .
the depth of our best - fit secondary eclipse is 0.062@xmath0% .
the reduced @xmath28 is 1.089 .
our best - fit secondary eclipse is consistent with a circular orbit ; the offset from the expected eclipse center is : @xmath41 = 4.5@xmath43 minutes ( or at a phase of @xmath36=0.5014@xmath52 ) .
this corresponds to a limit on the eccentricity and argument of periastron of @xmath65 = 0.0020@xmath57 , or a 3@xmath1 limit of @xmath4@xmath2@xmath5@xmath3@xmath4 @xmath6 0.0090 ) .
our result is fully consistent with the more sensitive @xmath2cos@xmath3 limits reported from the secondary eclipse detections at the four spitzer / irac wavelengths @xcite .
thus our result bolsters the conclusion of @xcite that tidal damping of the orbital eccentricity is unlikely to be responsible for `` puffing up '' the radius of this exoplanet .
a secondary eclipse depth of 0.062@xmath0% corresponds to a brightness temperature of @xmath54 = 1636@xmath8 @xmath9 in the ks - band assuming the planet radiates as a blackbody , and adopting a stellar effective temperature of @xmath66 = 5850 @xmath67 50 @xcite .
this compares to the equilibrium temperature of tres-2b of @xmath68@xmath111472 @xmath9 assuming isotropic reradiation , and a zero bond albedo .
hot jupiter thermal emission measurements allow joint constraints on the bond albedo , @xmath69 , and the efficiency of day to nightside redistribution of heat on these presumably tidally locked planets .
the bond albedo , @xmath69 is the fraction of the bolometric , incident stellar irradiation that is reflected by the planet s atmosphere .
we parameterize the redistribution of dayside stellar radiation absorbed by the planet s atmosphere to the nightside by the reradiation factor , @xmath70 , following the @xcite definition .
if we assume a bond albedo near zero , consistent with observations of other hot jupiters @xcite and with model predictions @xcite , we find a reradiation factor of @xmath59 = 0.358@xmath60 from our ks - band eclipse photometry only , indicative of relatively efficient advection of heat from the day - to - nightside at this wavelength . in comparison ,
the reradiation factor for an atmosphere that reradiates isotropically is @xmath70=@xmath71 , while @xmath70=@xmath72 denotes redistribution and reradiation over the dayside face only . ;
solid - line ) , 95.5% ( 2@xmath1 ; dashed - line ) and 99.7% ( 3@xmath1 ; short dashed - line ) @xmath63 confidence regions on the reradiation factor , @xmath73 , and bond albedo from the combination of our ks - band point and the spitzer / irac measurements @xcite . ]
our secondary eclipse depth , when combined with the secondary eclipse depths at the spitzer / irac wavelengths from @xcite , is consistent with a range of bond albedos , @xmath69 , and efficiencies of the day to nightside redistribution on this presumably tidally locked planet ( figure [ figbondreradiation ] ) .
the best - fit total reradiation factor , @xmath73 , that results from a @xmath28 analysis of all the eclipse depths for tres-2b assuming a zero bond albedo is @xmath73 = 0.346@xmath74 .
thus our ks - band brightness temperature ( @xmath54 = 1636@xmath8 @xmath9 ) and reradiation factor @xmath59=0.358@xmath60 , reveal an atmospheric layer that is similar to , and perhaps slightly hotter , than the atmospheric layers probed by longer wavelength spitzer observations ( @xmath7@xmath111500 @xmath9 from spitzer / irac observations of tres-2b [ @xcite ] ) .
the ks - band is expected to be at a minimum in the water opacity @xcite , and thus our ks - band observations are expected to be able to see deep into the atmosphere of tres-2b .
our observations suggest that the deep , high pressure atmosphere of tres-2b displays a similar temperature perhaps a slightly warmer temperature to lower pressure regions . another way of parameterizing the level of day - to - nightside heat redistribution is calculating the percentage of the bolometric luminosity emitted by the planet s dayside , @xmath75 , compared to the nightside emission , @xmath76 .
measurements of the thermal emission of a hot jupiter at its blackbody peak provide a valuable constraint on the bolometric luminosity of the planet s dayside emission , and by inference its nightside emission @xcite . from simple thermal equilibrium arguments
if tres-2b has a zero bond albedo and it is in thermal equilibrium with its surroundings it should have a total bolometric luminosity of @xmath77 = 7.7@xmath1410@xmath78@xmath79 . by integrating the luminosity per unit frequency of our best - fit blackbody model across a wide wavelength range
we are able to calculate the percentage of the total luminosity reradiated by the dayside as @xmath1169% ( @xmath75 = 5.3@xmath1410@xmath78@xmath79 ) .
the remainder , presumably , is advected via winds to the nightside .
2.15 @xmath10 ) is our own , while the spitzer / irac red points are from @xcite .
blackbody curves for isotropic reradiation ( @xmath70=@xmath71 ; @xmath68@xmath111496 @xmath9 ; blue dashed - line ) and for our best - fit reradiation factor ( @xmath70=0.346 ; @xmath68@xmath111622 @xmath9 ; grey dotted - line ) are also plotted .
we also plot one - dimensional , radiative transfer spectral models @xcite for various reradiation factors and with and without tio / vo .
the models with tio / vo include @xmath70=@xmath71 ( purple dotted line ) , @xmath70=0.31 ( green dashed line ) , and @xmath70 = @xmath72 ( orange dotted line ) ; only the last of the models has a temperature inversion .
the model without tio / vo features emission from the dayside only ( @xmath70=@xmath72 ; cyan dot - dashed line ) .
the models on the top panel are divided by a stellar atmosphere model @xcite of tres-2 using the parameters from @xcite ( @xmath80=0.98 @xmath81 , @xmath82=1.00 @xmath83 , @xmath66=5850 @xmath9 , and log @xmath84= 4.43 ) .
we plot the ks - band wircam transmission curve ( dotted black lines ) and spitzer / irac curves ( solid red lines ) inverted at arbitrary scale at the top of both panels .
, title="fig : " ] 2.15 @xmath10 ) is our own , while the spitzer / irac red points are from @xcite .
blackbody curves for isotropic reradiation ( @xmath70=@xmath71 ; @xmath68@xmath111496 @xmath9 ; blue dashed - line ) and for our best - fit reradiation factor ( @xmath70=0.346 ; @xmath68@xmath111622 @xmath9 ; grey dotted - line ) are also plotted .
we also plot one - dimensional , radiative transfer spectral models @xcite for various reradiation factors and with and without tio / vo .
the models with tio / vo include @xmath70=@xmath71 ( purple dotted line ) , @xmath70=0.31 ( green dashed line ) , and @xmath70 = @xmath72 ( orange dotted line ) ; only the last of the models has a temperature inversion .
the model without tio / vo features emission from the dayside only ( @xmath70=@xmath72 ; cyan dot - dashed line ) .
the models on the top panel are divided by a stellar atmosphere model @xcite of tres-2 using the parameters from @xcite ( @xmath80=0.98 @xmath81 , @xmath82=1.00 @xmath83 , @xmath66=5850 @xmath9 , and log @xmath84= 4.43 ) .
we plot the ks - band wircam transmission curve ( dotted black lines ) and spitzer / irac curves ( solid red lines ) inverted at arbitrary scale at the top of both panels .
, title="fig : " ] we compare the depth of our ks - band eclipse and the spitzer / irac eclipses @xcite to a series of planetary atmosphere models in figure [ figmodel ] .
this comparison is made quantitatively as well as qualitatively by integrating the models over the wircam ks band - pass as well as the spitzer / irac channels , and calculating the @xmath28 of the thermal emission data compared to the models .
we first plot blackbody models with an isotropic reradiation factor ( @xmath70=@xmath71 ; blue dotted - line ) and that of our best - fit value ( @xmath70=0.346 ; grey dotted - line ) these models have dayside temperatures of @xmath85@xmath111496@xmath9 and @xmath85@xmath111622@xmath9 , respectively .
both blackbody models provide reasonable fits to the data , although the latter model ( @xmath70=0.346 ; @xmath28=4.7 ) provides a definitively better fit than the former isothermal model ( @xmath70=@xmath71 ; @xmath63=9.1 ) as it better predicts our ks - band emission and the spitzer / irac 8.0 @xmath10 emission .
this suggests that overall tres-2b has a near - isothermal dayside temperature - pressure profile and is well - fit by a blackbody .
we thus also compare the data to a number of one - dimensional , radiative transfer , spectral models @xcite with different reradiation factors that specifically include or exclude gaseous tio and vo into the chemical equilibrium and opacity calculations . in these models when tio and vo are present they act as absorbers at high altitude and lead to a hot stratosphere and a temperature inversion @xcite .
however , if the temperature becomes too cool ( tio and vo start to condense at 1670 @xmath9 at 1 mbar [ @xcite ] ) , tio and vo condense out and the models with and without tio / vo are very similar . in the case of tres-2b , for all the models we calculate , except our model that features dayside emission only ( @xmath70=@xmath72 ) , they do not harbour temperature inversions because the atmospheres are slightly too cool and tio / vo has condensed out of their stratospheres
. we plot models with tio / vo and reradiation factors of @xmath70=@xmath71 ( purple dotted line ) , @xmath70=0.31 ( green dashed line ) , and @xmath70=@xmath72 ( orange dotted line ) , and without tio / vo with a reradiation factor of @xmath70=@xmath72 ( cyan dot - dashed line ) .
@xcite argued that tres-2b experienced a temperature inversion due to the high 4.5 @xmath10 emission compared to the low 3.6 @xmath10 emission , which was predicted to be a sign of water and co in emission , rather than absorption , in tres-2b s presumably inverted atmosphere .
we also find that our models without a temperature inversion have difficultly matching the spitzer / irac 5.6 and 8.0 @xmath10 thermal emission ( @xmath28=25.4 for @xmath70=@xmath71 with tio / vo , @xmath28=15.3for @xmath70=0.31 with tio / vo , and @xmath28=5.5 for @xmath70=@xmath72 without tio / vo ) . if the temperature inversion is due to tio / vo , by the time the atmosphere becomes hot enough that tio / vo remains in gaseous form , the thermal emission is too bright to fit the 3.6 , and 5.8 @xmath10 thermal emission ( @xmath28=10.6for @xmath70=@xmath72 with tio / vo ) .
the combination of our blackbody and radiative transfer models with our own eclipse depth and those from the spitzer / irac instrument @xcite thus suggest that the atmosphere of tres-2b likely features modest redistribution of heat from the day to the nightside .
it is unclear whether the atmosphere of tres-2b requires a temperature inversion . a simple blackbody model ( @xmath70=0.346 and @xmath68@xmath111622 k ) provides an exemplary fit to the data ;
this may indicate that tres-2b has a fairly isothermal dayside temperature structure , perhaps similar to hat - p-1b @xcite .
an important caveat , on the above result is that our @xmath70=@xmath72 model without tio / vo ( @xmath28=5.5 ) and thus without a temperature inversion returns nearly as good of fit as our best - fit blackbody model ( @xmath70=0.346 ; @xmath28=4.7 ) ; thermal emission measurements at other wavelengths , and repeated measurements at the above wavelengths , are thus necessary to differentiate a blackbody - like spectrum , from significant departures from blackbody - like behaviour , and to confirm that tres-2b efficiently redistributes heat to the nightside of the planet .
specifically , the variations between the models displayed in figure [ figmodel ] are largest in the near - infrared j & h - bands and thus further near - infrared constraints if they are able to achieve sufficient accuracy to measure the small thermal emission signal of tres-2b in the near - infrared should prove eminently useful to constrain the atmospheric characteristics of this planet .
if the excess emission at 4.5 @xmath10 is due to water emission , rather than absorption , due to a temperature inversion in the atmosphere of tres-2b then the inversion is unlikely to be due to tio / vo .
this is because the atmosphere of tres-2b appears too cool to allow tio / vo to remain in gaseous form in its upper atmosphere .
if there is a temperature inversion then the high altitude optical absorber is likely to be due to another chemical species than tio / vo .
for instance , @xcite have investigated the photochemistry of sulphur - bearing species as another alternative .
tres-2b is a promising target for the characterization of its thermal emission across a wide wavelength range .
in addition to orbiting a relatively bright star , and having a favourable planet - to - star radius ratio , tres-2 lies within the kepler field .
the combination of secondary eclipse measurements already published using spitzer / irac , upcoming measurements with kepler ( @xmath11430 - 900 @xmath86 ; @xcite ) , and j , h and k - band near - infrared measurements that could be obtained from the ground , will allow us to fully constrain tres-2b s energy budget . at the shorter end of this wavelength range it should also be possible to constrain the combination of reflected light and thermal emission .
our results predict that even if the geometric albedo of tres-2b is as low as 5% in the kepler bandpass , if kepler is able to detect the secondary eclipse of this planet then it will be detecting a significant fraction of reflected light in addition to thermal emission .
this will largely break the degeneracy on the bond albedo and the reradiation factor for this planet , facilitating a more complete understanding of its energy budget .
the natural sciences and engineering research council of canada supports the research of b.c . and r.j .
the authors would like to thank marten van kerkwijk for helping to optimize these observations , and norman murray for useful discussions .
the authors especially appreciate the hard - work and diligence of the cfht staff in helping us pioneer this `` stare '' method on wircam .
we thank the anonymous referee for a thorough review . | we present near - infrared ks - band photometry bracketing the secondary eclipse of the hot jupiter tres-2b using the wide - field infrared camera on the canada - france - hawaii telescope .
we detect its thermal emission with an eclipse depth of 0.062@xmath0% ( 5@xmath1 ) .
our best - fit secondary eclipse is consistent with a circular orbit ( a 3@xmath1 upper limit on the eccentricity , @xmath2 , and argument or periastron , @xmath3 , of @xmath4@xmath2@xmath5@xmath3@xmath4 @xmath6 0.0090 ) , in agreement with mid - infrared detections of the secondary eclipse of this planet .
a secondary eclipse of this depth corresponds to a day - side ks - band brightness temperature of @xmath7 = 1636@xmath8 @xmath9 .
our thermal emission measurement when combined with the thermal emission measurements using spitzer / irac from odonovan and collaborators suggest that this planet exhibits relatively efficient day to night - side redistribution of heat and a near isothermal dayside atmospheric temperature structure , with a spectrum that is well approximated by a blackbody . it is unclear if the atmosphere of tres-2b requires a temperature inversion
; if it does it is likely due to chemical species other than tio / vo as the atmosphere of tres-2b is too cool to allow tio / vo to remain in gaseous form .
our secondary eclipse has the smallest depth of any detected from the ground at around 2 @xmath10 to date . |
in this paper we study asymptotic properties of certain extremal sequences of points defined on locally compact metric spaces . we shall refer to them as _ greedy energy sequences_. this terminology was recently introduced in @xcite .
these sequences are indeed generated by means of a greedy algorithm at every step of which a certain energy expression is minimized . the notion of energy that we refer to
will be specified shortly .
the asymptotic properties that we analyze are mainly the following : if @xmath18 denotes the sequence of configurations formed by the first @xmath19 points of a greedy energy sequence , we use potential - theoretic tools to study the behavior of the energy of @xmath20 as @xmath19 approaches infinity and the limiting distributions of these configurations .
we remark that in @xcite a number of results about greedy sequences were obtained in a context in which potential theory is no longer applicable .
potential theory on locally compact hausdorff ( lch ) spaces is a classical field which was developed , among others , by choquet @xcite , fuglede @xcite and ohtsuka @xcite . in recent years , and also in the context of lch spaces , zorii @xcite has studied solvability properties of the gauss variational problem in the presence of an external field . a similar problem ( we shall also call it gauss variational problem )
is considered below .
we next introduce the basic notions necessary to describe our results .
let @xmath21 denote a locally compact metric space containing infinitely many points .
if @xmath21 is not compact , let @xmath22 denote the one - point compactification of @xmath21 .
a _ kernel _ in @xmath21 is , by definition , a lower semicontinuous function ( l.s.c . )
it is called _ positive _ if @xmath24 for all @xmath25 .
assume that @xmath26 is a l.s.c
. function . for a set @xmath27 of @xmath19 ( @xmath28 )
points in @xmath21 which are not necessarily distinct , we write @xmath29 and define the _ energy _ of @xmath30 by @xmath31 whereas the _ weighted energy _ of @xmath32 is given by @xmath33 in potential theory the function @xmath6 is usually referred to as an _ external field_. if the kernel is _ symmetric _
, i.e. , @xmath34 for all @xmath25 , we may also write @xmath35 for a non - empty set @xmath36 , the _ weighted @xmath19-point energy _ of @xmath5 is given by @xmath37 in case that @xmath38 , we use instead the notation @xmath39 we say that @xmath40 is an _ optimal weighted @xmath19-point configuration _ on @xmath5 if @xmath41 if @xmath5 is compact , the existence of @xmath42 follows from the lower semicontinuity of @xmath43 and @xmath6 .
it is necessary to introduce now the continuous counterparts of the above notions .
let @xmath44 denote the linear space of all real - valued radon measures that are compactly supported on @xmath36 , and let @xmath45 given a measure @xmath46 , the _ energy _ of @xmath47 is the double integral @xmath48 whereas the function @xmath49 is called the _ potential _ of @xmath47 . the _ weighted energy _ of @xmath47 is defined by @xmath50 since any l.s.c .
function is bounded below on compact sets , the above integrals are well - defined , although they may attain the value @xmath51 .
the quantity @xmath52 is called the _ wiener energy _ of @xmath5 , and plays an important role in potential theory .
the _ capacity _ of @xmath5 is defined as @xmath53@xmath54 if @xmath43 is positive , and otherwise , it is defined as @xmath53@xmath55 .
a property is said to hold _ quasi - everywhere _
( q.e . ) , if the exceptional set has wiener energy @xmath51 .
given a net @xmath56 , we say that @xmath57 converges in the _ weak - star topology _ to a measure @xmath58 when @xmath59 where @xmath60 denotes the space of compactly supported continuous functions on @xmath5 .
we will use the notation @xmath61 to denote the weak - star convergence of measures . if @xmath62 , a measure @xmath63 satisfying the property @xmath64 is called an _
equilibrium measure_. if @xmath5 is compact , the existence of such a measure is guaranteed by the lower semicontinuity of @xmath43 and the compactness of @xmath65 equipped with the weak - star topology ( cf .
* theorem 2.3 ) ) .
however , uniqueness does not always hold .
the following result is due to g. choquet @xcite , and it is central in this theory .
[ choquettheo ] let @xmath43 be an arbitrary kernel and @xmath36 be a compact set .
if @xmath66 is a sequence of optimal @xmath19-point configurations on @xmath5 , then @xmath67 the following variation of theorem [ choquettheo ] was obtained by b. farkas and b. nagy @xcite .
[ fntheo ] assume that the kernel @xmath43 is positive and is finite on the diagonal , i.e. , @xmath68 for all @xmath69 . then for arbitrary sets @xmath36 , @xmath70 where @xmath71 is defined by @xmath72 .
we remark that theorems [ choquettheo ] and [ fntheo ] were proved in the context of lch spaces , but for the sake of uniformity we always assume , unless otherwise stated , that @xmath21 denotes a locally compact metric space .
in this paper we are interested in the so - called _ gauss variational problem _ in the presence of an external field @xmath6 . in what follows
we assume that @xmath36 is a closed set , and we will refer to @xmath5 as the _ conductor_. the gauss v.p .
consists of finding a solution to the minimization problem @xmath73 where @xmath74 denotes the class of measures @xmath75 throughout the rest of the paper we will denote @xmath76 simply as @xmath77 . if @xmath78 then by definition @xmath79 .
if @xmath80 and there exists a minimizing measure @xmath81 satisfying @xmath82 , we call @xmath47 an _ equilibrium measure in the presence of the external field _ @xmath6 . in this case we say that the gauss variational problem is _ solvable _ , and observe that @xmath77 is finite .
sufficient conditions for the existence and uniqueness of solution for a similar variational problem were provided by n. zorii ( see @xcite ) in the more general context of lch spaces .
she assumes that the kernel is positive if @xmath5 is not compact , and allows measures to have non - compact support in this case .
we remark that the theory of logarithmic potentials ( @xmath83 for an equilibrium measure @xmath81 .
this value is finite .
the _ essential support _ of @xmath47 is defined as @xmath84 using lemma 2.3.3 from @xcite and the argument employed in @xcite to prove parts @xmath85 and @xmath86 of theorem i.1.3 , it is easy to see that if @xmath43 is a symmetric kernel and @xmath81 is an equilibrium measure , then @xmath87 holds for all @xmath88 ( i.e. @xmath89 ) and @xmath90 holds q.e . on @xmath5 .
we are ready to introduce the following definitions ( see also definitions @xmath91 and @xmath92 in section [ statement ] ) .
[ defngreedyprimera ] let @xmath93 be a symmetric kernel on a locally compact metric space @xmath21 , @xmath94 be a closed set , and @xmath95 be an external field . if @xmath21 is not compact , we assume that @xmath6 satisfies the following ` growth ' condition at infinity : for each compactly supported probability measure @xmath96 , @xmath97 ( i.e. given @xmath98 , there exists a compact set @xmath99 such that @xmath100 for all @xmath101 ) .
assume that the gauss variational problem is solvable and @xmath81 is an equilibrium measure .
a sequence @xmath102 is called a _ weighted greedy @xmath103-energy sequence _ on @xmath5 if it is generated in the following way : * @xmath104 is selected arbitrarily on @xmath105 . * for every @xmath106 , assuming that @xmath107 have been selected , @xmath108 is chosen so that @xmath109 and @xmath110 the set formed by the first @xmath19 points of this sequence is denoted by @xmath111 .
we also introduce the following associated function : @xmath112 condition @xmath113 implies in particular that @xmath105 is compact .
consequently , for every @xmath106 , the existence of @xmath108 is guaranteed by the lower semicontinuity of @xmath43 and @xmath6 .
however , @xmath108 may not be unique .
in many practical circumstances it is not possible to determine the support or essential support of an equilibrium measure .
for this reason it is of interest to introduce the following : [ defngreedypointsclosed ] let @xmath93 be a symmetric kernel on a locally compact metric space @xmath21 , @xmath94 be a closed set , and @xmath95 be an external field . in case
it exists , a sequence @xmath114 is called a _ weighted greedy @xmath6-energy sequence _ on @xmath5 if it is constructed inductively by selecting @xmath104 arbitrarily on @xmath5 such that @xmath115 , and @xmath108 as in @xmath116 but taking the infimum on @xmath5 .
we use the notation @xmath117 to indicate the configuration formed by the first @xmath19 points of this sequence .
it seems that a. edrei was the first to study in @xcite properties of the configurations @xmath117 under the assumptions @xmath118 , @xmath119 is compact , @xmath120 and @xmath38 .
however , in the literature these configurations are often called _ leja points _ in recognition of leja s article @xcite .
a very important class of kernels is the so - called _ m. riesz kernels _ in @xmath121 , which depend on a parameter @xmath122 .
it is defined as follows : @xmath123 where @xmath124 denotes the euclidean norm and @xmath125 we shall use the notations @xmath126 , @xmath127 and @xmath128 to denote , respectively , the energy ( [ definicionenergia ] ) , weighted energy ( [ defweightedenergy ] ) and potential ( [ defnpotential ] ) of a measure @xmath129 with respect to the riesz @xmath130-kernel .
we will also use the symbols @xmath131 and @xmath53@xmath132 to denote the wiener @xmath130-energy and @xmath130-capacity of a set @xmath2 in this setting .
the paper is organized as follows . in section [ statement ] we present our results and in section [ proofs ] we provide their proofs . in section
[ numerical ] we present some numerical computations .
our first result is the following generalization of theorem [ choquettheo ] .
[ primer ] let @xmath93 be an arbitrary kernel on a locally compact metric space @xmath21 , @xmath94 be a compact conductor , and @xmath95 be an external field .
assume that the gauss variational problem is solvable . if @xmath66 is a sequence of optimal weighted @xmath19-point configurations on @xmath5 , then @xmath133 furthermore , if the gauss variational problem has a unique solution @xmath81 , then @xmath134 where @xmath135 is the unit dirac measure concentrated at @xmath136 . as the proof of theorem [ primer ] shows , without assuming the uniqueness of the equilibrium measure one can deduce that any convergent subsequence of @xmath137 converges weak - star to an equilibrium measure .
this observation is also applicable to the following result concerning greedy configurations .
[ theoexternalgreedy ] let @xmath93 be a symmetric kernel on a locally compact metric space @xmath21 , @xmath94 be a closed set , and @xmath95 be an external field satisfying @xmath113 in case that @xmath21 is not compact .
assume that the gauss variational problem is solvable and @xmath81 is a solution .
let @xmath138 be a weighted greedy @xmath103-energy sequence on @xmath5
. then * the following limit @xmath139 holds .
* if the equilibrium measure @xmath81 is unique , it follows that @xmath140 @xmath141 where @xmath142 is the @xmath143-th element of the weighted greedy @xmath103-energy sequence . conditions ( [ asympweight])-([eq29 ] ) are related in the following way .
[ relationconditions ] let @xmath144 be a real - valued symmetric kernel on a locally compact metric space @xmath21 , @xmath94 be a closed set , and @xmath95 be an external field .
assume that the gauss variational problem is solvable and @xmath81 is a solution .
suppose that @xmath145 is a sequence of points such that @xmath146 and set @xmath147 if the following limit @xmath148 holds , then @xmath149 theorem [ theoexternalgreedy ] can be extended to the following class of weighted greedy sequences .
[ defngreedyprimera2 ] let @xmath4 be a fixed integer .
under the same assumptions of definition [ defngreedyprimera ] , suppose that the gauss variational problem is solvable and @xmath81 is an equilibrium measure .
a sequence @xmath150 is called a _ weighted greedy @xmath151-energy sequence _ on @xmath5 if it is generated inductively in the following way : * the first @xmath8 points @xmath9 are selected so that @xmath152 is an optimal weighted @xmath8-point configuration on @xmath105 , i.e. @xmath153 for all @xmath154 . * assuming that @xmath155 have been selected , where @xmath14 is an integer , the next set of @xmath8 points @xmath156 are chosen to minimize the energy functional @xmath157 on @xmath158 .
for every @xmath159 , the subindices @xmath160 are assigned to the points @xmath15 in an arbitrary order .
let @xmath161 denote the configuration formed by the first @xmath162 points of this sequence . in analogy to definition [ defngreedypointsclosed ]
, we also introduce the following : [ defngreedypointsclosed2 ] under the same assumptions of definition [ defngreedypointsclosed ] , given an integer @xmath4 , a sequence @xmath163 ( in case it exists ) is called a _ weighted greedy @xmath164-energy sequence _ on @xmath5 if it is obtained inductively as in @xmath165 and @xmath166 but the minimization is taken on @xmath5 .
with @xmath167 we denote the configuration @xmath168 .
the following result is analogous to theorem [ theoexternalgreedy ] .
[ theogreedygeneral ] let @xmath4 . under the same assumptions of theorem @xmath169 ,
assume that @xmath170 is a weighted greedy @xmath151-energy sequence on @xmath5 , where @xmath81 is an equilibrium measure solving the gauss variational problem
. then * the following limit @xmath171 holds .
* if the equilibrium measure @xmath81 is unique , it follows that @xmath172 @xmath173 where @xmath174 is the @xmath175-th element of the weighted greedy @xmath151-energy sequence .
it is easy to see that @xmath176 implies that @xmath177 let @xmath1 and consider the riesz @xmath130-kernel @xmath178 in @xmath0 ( see @xmath179 ) for @xmath180 .
assume that @xmath181 is a closed set and @xmath6 is an external field satisfying the following properties : @xmath182 @xmath183 using the same arguments employed to prove theorem i.1.3 in @xcite ( which concerns the case @xmath184 and @xmath185 ) and the fact that @xmath178 is positive definite ( see ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 1.15 ) ) , it is not difficult to see that the gauss variational problem on @xmath5 in the presence of @xmath6 has a unique solution @xmath186 .
furthermore , the inequality @xmath187 is valid for all @xmath188 , where @xmath189 denotes the minimal energy constant @xmath190 , and @xmath191 holds q.e . on @xmath5 ( relative to the @xmath130-capacity of sets ) .
we remark that if @xmath184 and @xmath185 then these properties hold if @xmath192 is replaced by the condition @xmath193 the following result holds .
[ lemanbw ] let @xmath1 and @xmath194 .
assume that @xmath2 is closed and @xmath6 satisfies the conditions @xmath195 and @xmath192 @xmath196or @xmath197 in the case @xmath184 , @xmath185@xmath198 .
let @xmath199 be the equilibrium measure solving the gauss variational problem on @xmath5 in the presence of @xmath6 . if @xmath200 is an arbitrary collection of points and @xmath201 then for all @xmath202 , @xmath203 where @xmath204 is defined in @xmath205 and @xmath206 is the potential associated to @xmath207 .
moreover , @xmath208 implies that @xmath209 the case @xmath184 , @xmath185 of lemma [ lemanbw ] ( the logarithmic kernel is employed in this case ) is known as the _ generalized bernstein - walsh lemma _ and was proved by h. mhaskar and e. saff in @xcite .
[ corolario ] assume that all the assumptions of lemma @xmath210 hold .
let @xmath211 be a weighted greedy @xmath6-energy sequence on @xmath5 constructed using the riesz kernel @xmath178 for @xmath17 .
then this sequence is well - defined and @xmath212 for all @xmath213 .
moreover , all the asymptotic properties in theorem @xmath169 are applicable to this sequence @xmath196replacing @xmath111 by @xmath214 and @xmath47 by @xmath207@xmath198 .
[ corolario2 ] let @xmath4 and assume that all the assumptions of lemma @xmath210 hold .
let @xmath215 be a weighted greedy @xmath164-energy sequence on @xmath5 obtained using the riesz kernel @xmath178 for @xmath17 .
then this sequence is well - defined and @xmath216 for all @xmath106 .
furthermore , all the asymptotic properties in theorem @xmath217 are applicable to this sequence @xmath196replacing @xmath161 by @xmath218 and @xmath47 by @xmath207@xmath198 .
we remark that the problem of finding an explicit representation of the solution of a gauss variational problem in @xmath0 is a difficult task in general . however , there are certain assumptions on @xmath6 that could alleviate the difficulty of this problem , as the following result shows in the case of newtonian potentials .
[ propcircweight ] let @xmath219 and @xmath220 .
assume that @xmath6 is a radially symmetric function @xmath196i.e .
@xmath221 for all @xmath222@xmath198 satisfying @xmath192 .
assume further that , as a function of @xmath223 , @xmath6 has an absolutely continuous derivative and obeys one of the following conditions : * @xmath224 is increasing on @xmath225 ; * @xmath6 is convex on @xmath225 .
let @xmath226 be the smallest number for which @xmath227 for all @xmath228 , and let @xmath229 be the smallest solution of @xmath230 @xmath196it is easy to see that @xmath231 and @xmath229 is finite@xmath198 . if @xmath232 is the solution of the gauss variational problem on @xmath233 with @xmath6 as the external field , then @xmath234 and @xmath232 is given by @xmath235 where @xmath236 denotes the normalized surface area measure of the unit sphere @xmath237 @xmath238 in @xmath0 .
moreover , @xmath239 and @xmath240 the case @xmath184 , @xmath185 was analyzed by mhaskar and saff in @xcite ( see example 3.2 of that paper ) . see also @xcite .
we first present in figures @xmath241@xmath242 some plots of greedy energy points on @xmath243 $ ] , constructed under the following conditions : @xmath244 , @xmath245 ( the riesz @xmath130-kernel ) , and @xmath38 . in all these examples
the total number of points is @xmath246 , and the initial point is selected to be @xmath247 .
the values of @xmath130 are indicated . under the above conditions ,
the equilibrium measure is given by @xmath248 ( cf .
@xcite ) . .
] . ] . ] . ] . ]
we now present some plots of weighted greedy energy points .
the following example shows the first @xmath246 points of a weighted greedy @xmath6-energy sequence on @xmath243 $ ] ( see definition [ defngreedypointsclosed ] ) for the logarithmic kernel @xmath249 and the external field @xmath250.\ ] ] the first point selected for this sequence was again @xmath247 .
observe that the points are much more numerous near the origin , since @xmath6 takes the lowest value there . weighted greedy @xmath6-energy points for the logarithmic kernel and the external field @xmath251 . ]
the next two examples are also weighted greedy @xmath6-energy sequences on @xmath243 $ ] for the logarithmic kernel @xmath249 , but now the external field is @xmath252 it is known ( cf .
@xcite ) that in this case the equilibrium measure is @xmath253 with support @xmath254 $ ] , where @xmath255 and @xmath256[1-(\theta_1-\theta_2)^2].\ ] ] the following example corresponds to the choice @xmath257 .
the point @xmath104 is the origin , and the number of points shown is again @xmath246 . in this case , @xmath258 and @xmath259
. weighted greedy @xmath6-energy points for the logarithmic kernel and the external field @xmath260 with parameters @xmath261 . ] in the following example we choose @xmath262 , and again @xmath263 . weighted greedy @xmath6-energy points for the logarithmic kernel and the external field @xmath260 with parameters @xmath262 . ]
observe that now all the points were pushed to the interval @xmath264 $ ] !
another interesting phenomenon can be observed , which is that many points are almost coincident .
in this example , @xmath265 and @xmath266 . in figure [ puntoslejaweightedsquare ]
we show the first @xmath267 points of a weighted greedy @xmath6-energy sequence on @xmath268 ^ 2 $ ] .
the initial point is the origin , @xmath269 and the external field is @xmath270 , @xmath271 . weighted greedy @xmath6-energy points on @xmath272 ^ 2 $ ] for @xmath269 and the external field @xmath270 . ]
proof of theorem [ primer ] . our first goal is to show that @xmath273 let @xmath274 be arbitrary , and consider the measure @xmath275 on the product space @xmath276 .
define the function @xmath277 by @xmath278 .
therefore , @xmath279 for all @xmath280 . integrating with respect to @xmath207
it follows that @xmath281 @xmath282 @xmath283 @xmath284 taking the infimum over @xmath274 we obtain that @xmath285 , and therefore ( [ eq25 ] ) holds .
next we show that @xmath286 and at the same time we verify ( [ distribweightmin ] ) .
let @xmath287 and define @xmath288 assume that @xmath289 is a sequence of non - decreasing continuous functions that converges pointwise to @xmath43 on @xmath5 .
we fix @xmath143 .
then @xmath290 @xmath291 @xmath292 @xmath293 let @xmath294 and @xmath295 . both @xmath296 and @xmath297 are finite since @xmath5 is compact and @xmath43 and @xmath6 are lower semicontinuous . using @xmath298
we obtain @xmath299 by the compactness of @xmath5 and the continuity of @xmath300 , there exists a constant @xmath301 such that @xmath302 in particular , @xmath303 from ( [ eq : estimatesf ] ) and ( [ asimpdelosg ] ) we conclude that @xmath304 let @xmath305 be a cluster point of the sequence @xmath306 in the weak - star topology
. then there exists a subsequence @xmath307 that converges weak - star to @xmath96 ( cf .
* lemma 1.2.1 ) ) .
therefore @xmath308 @xmath309 now we apply ( [ eq : estimatesintgn ] ) , ( [ eqfinal ] ) , ( [ eq27 ] ) and ( [ eq25 ] ) to obtain @xmath310 from the monotone convergence theorem we conclude that @xmath311 therefore @xmath312 , the equilibrium measure . since @xmath47 is the only cluster point of @xmath306 , ( [ distribweightmin ] ) follows . [ lemconv ]
let @xmath93 be a symmetric kernel on a locally compact metric space @xmath21 , @xmath94 be a compact set , and @xmath95 be an external field .
assume that the gauss variational problem is solvable and @xmath81 is a solution .
let @xmath316 be a sequence of measures that converges to @xmath47 in the weak - star topology . then @xmath317 since @xmath6 and @xmath318 are lower semicontinuous we have @xmath319 @xmath320 in addition , for @xmath321 the inequality @xmath322 holds , and therefore @xmath323 by ( [ gaussvarineq1 ] ) and ( [ gaussvarineq2 ] ) , @xmath324 q.e . on @xmath325 , and since @xmath47 has finite energy this equality holds @xmath47-a.e .
thus @xmath326 and ( [ eqlemconv ] ) follows .
proof of theorem [ theoexternalgreedy ] . to prove this result we follow closely ideas from chapter v of @xcite . by definition ,
@xmath327 we have , for any @xmath321 , @xmath328
@xmath329 @xmath330 @xmath331 we now integrate with respect to @xmath47 to obtain @xmath332 taking into account that @xmath333 for all @xmath175 and @xmath334 , it follows that @xmath335 now , if @xmath66 is a sequence of optimal weighted @xmath19-point configurations on @xmath105 , then @xmath336 for all @xmath19 . therefore ( [ asympweight ] ) is a consequence of ( [ eqmitad ] ) and ( [ asympweightmin ] ) . throughout the rest of the proof
we assume that the equilibrium measure @xmath81 is unique .
consider the sequence of normalized counting measures @xmath337 as in the proof of theorem [ primer ] , we select a sequence @xmath338 of non - decreasing continuous functions that converges pointwise to @xmath43 on @xmath105 .
we have , as in ( [ eqfinal ] ) , @xmath339 let @xmath307 be a subsequence that converges in the weak - star topology to a measure @xmath340 . by the lower - semicontinuity of @xmath6 , @xmath341 thus from ( [ asimpdelosg ] ) and ( [ asympweight ] ) we conclude that @xmath342 now we let @xmath343 and obtain @xmath344 it follows that @xmath345 and @xmath207 is an equilibrium measure . by hypothesis
there is only one equilibrium measure , thus @xmath346 and ( [ distribweight ] ) is proved .
we next show ( [ eq29 ] ) .
first , @xmath347 by ( [ distribweight ] ) and lemma [ lemconv ] , @xmath348 this implies that @xmath349 applying ( [ asympweight ] ) , ( [ eq30 ] ) , and ( [ eq31 ] ) , we obtain @xmath350 for every @xmath106 , @xmath351 integrating this expression with respect to @xmath47 it follows that @xmath352 let @xmath353 on the other hand , for every @xmath213 , @xmath354 where @xmath355 .
we may assume that @xmath356 .
let @xmath357 .
assume that @xmath8 is an integer such that @xmath358 applying ( [ eq35 ] ) repeatedly we obtain for @xmath359 , @xmath360 and so @xmath361 taking into account ( [ eq34 ] ) and the previous inequality , @xmath362 @xmath363 furthermore , it is easy to see that @xmath364 @xmath365 by @xmath366 we know that @xmath367 as @xmath368 , which implies that @xmath369 if @xmath370 , then @xmath371 and hence it follows from ( [ eq : imp1 ] ) and ( [ eq : imp2 ] ) that @xmath372 @xmath373 since the second term of the right - hand side of ( [ eq : imp3 ] ) is a negative constant , applying ( [ eq : asymprho ] ) , ( [ eq32 ] ) , and ( [ eq : imp3 ] ) , it follows that there are finitely many integers @xmath8 satisfying ( [ eqcondition ] ) .
this together with ( [ eq34 ] ) implies ( [ eq29 ] ) .
now we assume that @xmath374 .
it is easy to verify that @xmath375 @xmath376 and so , from ( [ eq : imp1 ] ) and ( [ eq : imp2 ] ) , we deduce that @xmath377 @xmath378 if we assume that there is an infinite sequence @xmath379 of integers @xmath8 satisfying ( [ eqcondition ] ) , applying the last inequality and ( [ eq : asymprho ] ) , we obtain @xmath380 we may assume without loss of generality that @xmath381 . then the right - hand side of ( [ eq : ocho ] ) is a constant strictly less than @xmath382 , which contradicts ( [ eq32 ] ) .
this concludes the proof of ( [ eq29 ] ) .
@xmath315 proof of proposition [ relationconditions ] .
we know that @xmath383 since @xmath43 is real - valued and @xmath384 , we have that @xmath385 for all @xmath143 . from ( [ eq : tnbn ] )
it follows that @xmath386 and applying ( [ eq : assumption ] ) and lemma [ lemconv ] , we obtain @xmath387 therefore ( [ eq : efb ] ) is a consequence of ( [ primero])-([tercero]).@xmath315 sketch of the proof of theorem [ theogreedygeneral ] . in order to prove @xmath388 , we use the fact that @xmath389+\phi_{m , n}\,,\ ] ] where @xmath390 using the definition of @xmath391 and integrating the resulting inequality by @xmath392 it follows that @xmath393 this inequality and @xmath394 imply @xmath388 . the asymptotic expression ( [ distribweightgeneral ] )
is an application of ( [ asympweightgeneral ] ) . to prove @xmath395 we use the inequalities @xmath396 @xmath397 where @xmath398 and @xmath399 .
the rest of the arguments in the proof of @xmath395 are analogous to those used to justify @xmath400
. @xmath315 [ lema1 ] let @xmath1 and @xmath194 .
assume that @xmath2 is closed and @xmath6 satisfies the conditions @xmath195 and @xmath192 @xmath196or @xmath197 in the case @xmath184 , @xmath185@xmath198 .
let @xmath199 be the equilibrium measure solving the gauss variational problem on @xmath5 in the presence of @xmath6 .
then * for any measure @xmath401 , @xmath402 where @xmath403 denotes the support of @xmath207 , and @xmath404 means that the infimum is taken quasi - everywhere .
* if @xmath305 , then @xmath405 where @xmath406 denotes the support of @xmath96 , and @xmath407 means that the supremum is taken quasi - everywhere . *
suppose that @xmath305 has finite @xmath130-energy and there exists a constant @xmath408 such that @xmath409 for q.e .
@xmath410 and @xmath411 for all @xmath412
. then @xmath413 and @xmath414 .
the case @xmath184 , @xmath185 of this result is part of theorems i.3.1 and i.3.3 in @xcite .
we first justify ( [ eq : ecuacion1 ] ) . to the contrary ,
suppose that there exists a measure @xmath401 and a constant @xmath415 such that @xmath416 from @xmath417 we obtain that @xmath418 since @xmath419 is finite , @xmath403 is a compact set with positive @xmath130-capacity .
therefore , there exists a unique measure @xmath420 such that @xmath421 . since @xmath422 on @xmath423 , applying the first maximum principle ( cf .
* theorem 1.10 ) ) it follows that @xmath422 everywhere in @xmath0 . using ( [ gaussvarineq2riesz ] )
we conclude that @xmath424 q.e . on @xmath403 .
if we define now the measure @xmath425 , ( [ desig1 ] ) yields @xmath426 since @xmath207 and @xmath427 have finite energy , this inequality holds @xmath428-almost everywhere .
applying theorem 1.27 ( case @xmath220 ) and theorem 1.29 ( case @xmath429 ) from @xcite we obtain that the inequality ( [ desg2 ] ) holds everywhere in @xmath0 .
finally , multiplying both sides by @xmath430 and letting @xmath431 it follows that @xmath432 , which contradicts our initial assumption .
now we prove ( [ eq : ecuacion2 ] ) .
let @xmath433 and assume that @xmath434 is finite .
it follows from this assumption that @xmath96 has finite @xmath130-energy .
using @xmath435 we have @xmath436
the same argument employed above to prove part ( i ) shows that @xmath437 .
finally , the assumptions of ( iii ) imply that @xmath438 and consequently we obtain using @xmath439 and @xmath440 that @xmath414 . taking @xmath441 in @xmath442 and @xmath443 in @xmath444 we conclude that @xmath445 everywhere in @xmath0 , which implies that @xmath446 by theorem 1.15 from @xcite .
proof of lemma [ lemanbw ] . from ( [ eq : bwl1 ] ) and lemma [ lema1](i ) applied to the measure @xmath447 we obtain that @xmath448 . using ( [ gaussvarineq1riesz ] ) and
( [ eq : bwl1 ] ) we have @xmath449 the same argument employed to prove lemma [ lema1](i ) shows that the inequality @xmath450 is valid everywhere in @xmath0 , which is precisely @xmath451 .
finally , @xmath452 is a consequence of @xmath451 and @xmath435 .
@xmath315 proof of corollary [ corolario ] .
the fact that @xmath142 is well - defined for all @xmath106 follows from conditions @xmath195 and @xmath192 ( or @xmath197 in the case @xmath184 , @xmath185 ) .
applying lemma @xmath210 to @xmath453 and @xmath454 it follows that @xmath216 for all @xmath213 .
the case @xmath184 , @xmath185 is justified in the same way . it is clear from the proof of theorem @xmath169 that @xmath455-@xmath400 are valid for the weighted greedy @xmath6-energy sequence @xmath456 .
@xmath315 proof of corollary [ corolario2 ] . for every @xmath159 ,
the existence of the minimizing configuration @xmath457 is guaranteed by the conditions @xmath195 and @xmath192 ( or @xmath197 in the case @xmath184 , @xmath185 ) .
next , we show that @xmath458 for every @xmath159 .
it follows from the definition of @xmath32 that for each @xmath459 , the inequality @xmath460 @xmath461 holds for all @xmath412 .
( if @xmath462 then the first term on both sides of the inequality does nt appear in the expression . )
if we denote the left hand side of @xmath463 by @xmath408 , and apply lemma @xmath210 to @xmath464 , then ( [ eq : bwl2 ] ) implies that @xmath465 .
proof of proposition [ propcircweight ] .
it is easy to see that @xmath468 let @xmath96 be the measure supported on @xmath469 whose expression is given by the right - hand side of @xmath470 . from the definition of @xmath226 and @xmath229 it follows that @xmath96 is a probability measure and by simple computations we obtain that the potential @xmath471 coincides with the function on the right - hand side of @xmath472 .
therefore @xmath473 applying the definitions of @xmath226 and @xmath229 again , we get that @xmath474 if @xmath475 and @xmath476 if @xmath477 ( regarding @xmath6 as a function of @xmath223 ) . as a consequence @xmath478 for all @xmath222 .
therefore , it follows from @xmath479 , @xmath480 , and lemma [ lema1 ] , that @xmath481 and @xmath482 holds.@xmath315 * acknowledgments . *
i take this opportunity to thank my research advisor , professor edward saff , for his dedication and support , and for the many helpful discussions we held on these and other related topics .
i am also grateful to natalia zorii for her careful reading of this manuscript and her suggestions to improve it . | in this paper we introduce several extremal sequences of points on locally compact metric spaces and study their asymptotic properties .
these sequences are defined through a greedy algorithm by minimizing a certain energy functional whose expression involves an external field .
some results are also obtained in the context of euclidian spaces @xmath0 , @xmath1 . as a particular example , given a closed set @xmath2 , a lower semicontinuous function @xmath3 $ ] and an integer @xmath4 , we investigate ( under suitable conditions on @xmath5 and @xmath6 ) sequences @xmath7 that are constructed inductively by selecting the first @xmath8 points @xmath9 so that the functional @xmath10 attains its minimum on @xmath11 for @xmath12 , @xmath13 , and for every integer @xmath14 , the points @xmath15 are chosen to minimize the expression @xmath16 on @xmath11 .
we assume here that @xmath17 .
an extension of a result due to g. choquet concerning point configurations with minimal energy is obtained in the context of locally compact metric spaces and constitutes a key ingredient in our analysis . |
nowadays , the application of information technology is a vital part of our daily life .
people around the globe use billions of mobile devices daily and spend more times on using these digital devices than ever . sharing our opinions in social networks , searching the web , twitting , purchasing online products , participating in online polling and many other digital aspect of our lives
leave behind a tremendous digital footprint .
billions of sensors embedded in cars , mobiles and other forms of devices constantly sense , generate and communicate trillions of bytes of information .
this gigantic generated data , which is also referred to as _ big data _ , is rich of information about the behavior of individuals in an interconnected network . that is why those who are interested in analyzing human behavior from business analysts to social scientists to academic researchers are highly interested in this data @xcite .
decision makers tend to extract individual as well as social behavior indicators from this data in order to make better decisions .
using traditional data management models to process and manage big data is nearly impossible due to the huge volume of data , the vast velocity of data arrival and variety of data types @xcite .
therefore , there is a need to develop special techniques which are able to deal with these aspects of big data in order to support the data - driven decision makings .
these techniques are also called _
big data analytics_. big data management approaches are expected to provide a required level of availability , scalability , security and privacy while working with data @xcite . traditionally , automated techniques are used as big data analytics .
sometimes ai techniques are used to extract information from big data @xcite . in some other cases
heuristic approaches are used to extract social or individual behavioral indicators from a large community @xcite .
these techniques while perform reasonably well in some aspect such as storing or retrieving data in cloud data management systems , they might not perform well when it comes to data collection , curation , annotation and dissemination .
for example , ai techniques are not able to provide results with very high precisions when working with unstructured or incomplete data @xcite .
also , there are cases in which automated techniques are not able to do the job due to the nature of the tasks . for instance
, in a database , there might be some missing data items , such as a person s mail address , that there not exist in the datasets at all , hence no automated technique is able to extract such missing piece of information @xcite . to overcome this problem
many researches have proposed to enlist the human intelligence and wisdom of crowds in combination with the automated techniques @xcite .
crowdsourcing is a distributed computing method in which , under specific circumstances , can provide contributions comparable to experts contributions in terms of quality level @xcite .
crowd involvement in data management tasks , while improves quality of outcomes @xcite , raises new challenges . in this paper , we first study related - work in the area of big data analytics as well as crowdsourcing
. then we propose a generic framework that simplifies the analysis of existing hybrid human - machine big data analytics .
the result of such an analysis is a set of problems that are yet to be answered .
we propose such set of challenges and propose some directions for future research in the area . in summary , in section [ sec : rels ] , we study related work in the area of big data analytics and crowdsourcing . in section [ sec : frm ] , we propose our analysis framework .
the open issues are studied in section [ sec : issues ] , and we conclude in section [ sec : concs ] .
we organize this section in three different sub - sections .
we first study big data analytics .
we then study the crowdsourcing basic concepts and finally we use the wall - mart case study to articulate the problems that need more investigations .
many systems such as social networks , sensing systems , etc .
, produce very large amounts of information .
this data is not called big data only because of its size .
four important attributes , also referred to as _
4v _ , characterize the big data concept:(i ) data is huge in terms of its _ volume _ ; ( ii ) data is produced with a very high _ velocity _ ; ( iii ) data comes from a great _ variety _ of data types ; and finally ( iv ) data has different levels of _
veracity_. such a tremendous volume of data is a rich source of information about the behavior of individuals , social relations between individuals , patterns , e.g. , purchase patterns , in the behavior of individuals and so on .
hence , extracting these hidden aspects is of a great importance to the business owners and analysts .
the process of extracting these information from big data is called big data analytics and are applied using different techniques and methods @xcite . with the rise of recent web technologies and especially emergence of web 3.0 , recent applications which are working with big data aim to be implemented as distributed , scalable and widely accessible service on the web .
cloud computing paradigm makes applications available as services from anywhere in the world by shifting the infrastructure to the network .
the following properties of cloud computing has made it a good candidate for hosting deployments of data - intensive applications : -it produces virtually unlimited capacity by providing means to consume the amount of it resources that is actually needed .
-it reduces costs by only paying for what you use ( pay - as - you - go ) .
-it reduces the time that it systems have to spend on managing and supporting infrastructure .
for example in 2007 new york times aimed to build a service for users to have access to any new york times issue since 1851 , a service called timesmachine .
the big challenge was serving a bulk of 11 millions of articles in the form of pdf files . to process these 4 terabytes of files they decided to use amazon elastic compute cloud ( ec2 ) and simple storage service ( s3 ) .
the source data was uploaded to s3 and then a cluster of hadoop ec2 amazon machine images ( amis ) was started . with parallel running of 100 ec2 amis ,
the task of reading the source data from s3 , converting it to pdf and storing it back to s3 was completed within 36 hours @xcite . at the beginning
, big data analytics started to be done using the existing advanced analytics disciplines such as data mining techniques .
authors in @xcite use supervised learning techniques for link prediction in social networks . as another example , grahne et .
propose method for mining sets of items that have been frequently purchased together @xcite . since the clique detection techniques in np - hard by nature , grahne and his colleagues propose a heuristic method to partially overcome this problem .
authors in @xcite use the same itemset mining technique for detecting spam groups in consumer review systems . the first author and his colleagues have also used mining techniques in @xcite and iterative techniques in @xcite to identify collusion groups in the log of online rating systems
. traditional data management techniques may work fine as long as data are structured .
however , one of the main characteristics of big data is the wide variety of data types . in most of the cases
data are unstructured or incomplete .
hence , existing data mining or management techniques can not handle big data . to solve this issue big data management systems have been proposed .
current big data management systems in cloud use some well - known application logics can be categorized to mapreduce , sql - like and hybrid @xcite : the most well - known big data management system is apache hadoop , a framework for running data intensive applications on clusters of commodity hardware .
hadoop , which has been very successful and widely used in industry and academia , is a an open source java implementation of mapreduce @xcite .
mapreduce is a simple but powerful programming model that is designed to enable programmers to develop scalable data - intensive applications on clusters of commodity pcs @xcite .
the mapreduce model is inspired by the map and the reduce functions in functional programming languages .
a map instruction partitions a computational task into some smaller sub - tasks .
these sub - tasks are executed in the system in parallel .
a reduce function is used to collect and integrate all results from sub - tasks in order to build up the main task s outcome .
more than 80 companies and organizations ( e.g. aol , linkedin , twitter , adobe , visa ) are using hadoop for analytic of their large scale data .
some efforts have been done to add sql - like flavor on top of mapreduce as many programmers would prefer working with sql as a high - level declarative language instead of low - level procedural programming using mapreduce .
pig latin@xcite and sawzal @xcite are examples of such tools .
finally , some systems have been designed with the main goal of bringing some familiar relational database concepts ( such as .
tables and columns ) and a subset of sql to unstructured world of hadoop while enjoying hadoop s the extensibility and flexibility .
an example of hybrid solutions is hadoopdb project that tries to combine the scalability of mapreduce with the performance and efficiency of parallel databases . in parallel with recent trend that convinces companies to give up building and managing their own data centers by
using computing capacity of cloud providers , many companies are willing to outsource some of their jobs given the low costs of transferring data over the internet and high costs of managing complicated hardware and software building blocks .
therefore amazon concluded that cloud computing can allow having access to a workforce that is based around the world and is able to do things that computer algorithms are not really good for .
therefore amazon launched machanical turk ( mturk ) system as a crowdsourcing internet marketplace where now has over 200k workers in 100 different countries .
crowdsourcing is the process of enlisting a crowd of people to solve a problem @xcite .
the idea of crowdsourcing was introduced first by jeff .
howe in 2006 @xcite .
since then , an enormous amount of efforts from both academia and industry has been put into this area and so many crowdsourcing platforms and research prototypes ( either general or special purpose)have been introduced .
amazon mechanical turk(mturk ) , crowdflower , wikipedia and stackoverflow are examples of well - known crowdsourcing platforms . to crowdsource a problem , the problem owner , also called the _ requester _ , prepares a request for crowd s contributions and submits it to a crowdsourcing platform .
this request , also referred to as the _ crowdsourcing task _ or shortly as the _ task _ , consists of a description of the problem that is asked to be solved , a set of requirements necessary for task accomplishment , a possible criteria for evaluating quality of crowd contributions and any other information which can help workers produce contributions of higher quality levels .
people who are willing to contribute to the task , also called _ workers _ , select the task , if they are eligible to do so , and provide the requester with their contributions .
the contributions are sent to the requester directly or through the crowdsourcing platform .
the requester may evaluate the contributions and reward the workers whose contributions have been accepted @xcite .
several dimensions characterized a crowdsourcing task , each of which impacting various aspects of the task from outcome quality to execution time or the costs .
task definition is important in the success of a crowdsourcing process .
a poorly designed task can result in receiving low quality contributions , attracting malicious workers or leaving the task unsolved due to unnecessary complications @xcite .
therefore , it is highly recommended to design robust tasks .
a robust task is designed so that it is easier to do it rather than to cheat @xcite .
moreover , a requester should make sure that she has provided the workers with all information required for doing the task to increase the chance of receiving contributions of higher quality levels .
the importance of this dimension is because of its direct impact mainly on the outcome quality , task execution time and number of recruited workers .
quality of workers who contribute to a task can directly impact the quality of its outcome @xcite .
low quality or malicious workers can produce low quality contributions and consequently waste the resources of the requester .
research shows that recruiting suitable workers can lead to receiving high quality contributions @xcite .
a suitable worker is a worker whose profile , history , experiences and expertise highly matches the requirements of a task . in a crowdsourcing process
, workers might be recruited through various methods such as open - call , publish / subscribe @xcite , friend - based @xcite , profile - based @xcite and team - based @xcite . during the execution of the task ,
the requester may manually or automatically control the workflow of the task and manipulate the workflow or the list of the workers who are involved in the task in order to increase the chance of receiving high quality contributions @xcite .
moreover , workers may increase their experience while contributing to a task by receiving real - time feedback from other workers or requester .
the feedback received in real - time , and before final submission of the worker s contribution , can assist her with pre - assessing her contribution and change it so that satisfies the task requirements @xcite .
real - time workflow control and giving feedback can directly impact the outcome quality , the execution time and also the cost of the task , so they should be taken into account when studying crowdsourcing processes .
assessing the quality of contributions received from the crowd is another important aspect of a crowdsourcing process .
quality in crowdsourcing is always under question .
the reason is that workers in crowdsourcing systems have different levels of expertise and experiences ; they contribute with different incentives and motivations ; and even they might be included in collaborative unfair activities @xcite.several approaches are proposed to assess quality of workers contributions such as expert review , input agreement , output agreement , majority consensus and ground truth @xcite .
rewarding the workers whose contributions have been accepted or punishing malicious or low quality workers can directly impact their chance , eligibility and motivation to contribute to the future tasks .
rewards can be monetary ( extrinsic ) or non - monetary ( intrinsic ) .
research shows that the impact of intrinsic rewards , e.g. , altruism or recognition in the community , on the quality of the workers contributions is more than the monetary rewards @xcite .
choosing an adequate compensation policy can greatly impact the number of contributing workers as well as the quality of their contributions .
hence , compensation policy is an important aspect of a crowdsourcing process .
a single crowdsourcing task might be assigned to several workers .
the final outcome of such a task can be one or few f the individual contributions received from workers or an aggregation of all of them @xcite .
voting is an example of the tasks that crowd contributions are aggregated to build up the final task outcome .
in contrast , in competition tasks only one or few workers contributions are accepted and rewarded .
each of the individual contributions has its own characteristics such as quality level , worker s reputation and expertise and so many other attributes .
therefore , combining or even comparing these contributions is a challenging tasks and choosing a wrong aggregation method can directly impact the quality of the task outcome .
in this section , we first propose an overview of the concept of combining crowd and big data analytics .
we then propose a framework in order to simplify understanding and studying hybrid human - machine big data approaches . as mentioned earlier ,
one of the main characteristics of big data is the wide variety of data types .
data might be from different types ; they might be semi - structured , unstructured or structured but incomplete . traditional or advanced analytics can not handle such a variable tremendously large data .
so , they should be handled using the big data analytics . as we studied in the previous section ,
generally , the big data analytics rely on the deterministic or learning techniques which use the computing power of machines to process big data and extract necessary information , patterns , etc . due to huge size and high level of complexity of big data , the techniques used for data analysis usually leverage heuristic or learning techniques , and hence , they are not able to guarantee their performance . in some cases
the requester might need a predefined specific level of precision and accuracy for the results , but the existing techniques can not provide that level of precision . in these cases , to generate results having the specified quality level a crowd of people are employed to complement the performance of the machines .
to simplify understanding these concepts we study crowder @xcite and wallmart crowdsourcing project @xcite as two related work .
we study these systems later in section [ sec : dim ] to study how they deal with the inclusion of crowd into cloud .
crowder is a hybrid crowd - machine approach for entity resolution .
crowder first employs machines to perform an initial analysis on the data and find most likely solutions and then employs people to refine the results generated by machines .
wall - mart product classification project is another example of hybrid - crowd - machine approaches proposed for big data analytics @xcite . in this project
, a huge volume of data is constantly being received from various retailers from all across the country .
the sent data is structured but in most of the cases it is incomplete .
so , wall - mart can not use only machines for the purpose of entity matching and resolution .
the results , as tested , do not have the required level of accuracy . to overcome this problem
, wall - mart selects some individuals with adequate expertise to refine the results produced by machine .
big data analytics can be characterized using various dimensions .
some of these dimensions are related to the nature of big data and how the machine - based approaches deal with it .
availability , multi - tenancy , scalability , etc .
are examples of these dimensions .
these dimensions are well studied in several related work@xcite . in this work ,
we do not study these dimensions and identify new dimensions that emerge when a crowd of people in added to big data analytics .
from this view point , we identify three important dimensions : _ worker selection _ , _ task decomposition _ and _
quality control_. in the followings , we describe these dimensions and study crowder and wall - mart project as two existing case studies from point of view of these dimensions . figure [ fig : tax ] depicts a representation of the identified dimensions and important factors that should be taken into account when studying each dimension .
when somebody tries to empower big data analytics with a crowd of workers , there are several points that she should have in mind .
the first point is how to assess eligibility of workers .
doing some big data analyses may need specific skills and expertise .
in such cases only workers having suitable profiles containing those expertise should be selected .
defining good worker selection policies can greatly impact quality of analytics . in wall - mart project ,
since workers are selected manually from a private crowd , their profiles are checked against the requirements and only suitable workers are chosen . in crowder
no worker selection policies are put in place and everybody can contribute to the data analysis process .
the second point in worker selection is that , workers should be selected so that the chance of deception is decreased .
human - enhanced systems are constantly subject to misbehavior and deceptive activities .
the worker selection should be applied so that both individual and collaborative deceptive activities have a very low chance to happen .
selecting untrustworthy workers may result in producing dubious low quality results , so it is crucial to select trustworthy workers .
crowder does not apply any trust assessment technique while selecting workers , but the wall - mart project people are selected from a private crowd , so they generally have a minimum level of trustworthiness .
the third parameter is automaticity , i.e. , how to approach and select workers . in some systems ,
workers are selected manually . in this case
the system or task owner looks for people with suitable profiles and asks them to contribute to her task .
wall - mart project follows a manual worker selection method . on the other hand , in automatic methods , system on behalf of
the task owner and , based on the task requirements and people profile , selects and recruits a group of suitable workers .
crowder recruits its required workers automatically from people at the amazon mechanical turk . by task decomposition , we mean the process of breaking down a complex analytical task into some smaller sub - tasks that are easier to accomplish mainly in parallel .
these sub - tasks should be divided among the machines and humans involved in the system .
the first factor is how to decide on who should do what ? " .
more precisely , what is the basis on which the task owner or the system decides to assign a sub - task to a human or a machine to do it .
task assignment should be done based on several factors .
the first factor is the type of the task .
computers are good in performing computational tasks , but there are tasks that require some levels of intelligence to be done .
there are several tasks types that fit in this category such as image tagging , photo description , audio transcription and so on .
these tasks are better to be assigned to a human .
the type of the task is an important factor to decide to assign the task to a machine or a human . in both crowder and wall - mart projects ,
tasks are first assigned to machines to do .
then , the results obtained from machines are given to people to refine the results so that they meet the precision requirements .
after a task owner decides to assign a task to humans , the next challenges emerges : who is suitable to do the task ? "
several methods are proposed for eligibility assessment to answer this question @xcite .
generally speaking , the humans whose profiles have a higher level of match with the task requirements are more suitable workers to participate in the task .
wall - mart selects people manually and they check the suitability of workers when they select them to participate , but in crowder no suitability assessment approaches are used and everybody can contribute to the tasks . by quality control , we mean all the activities performed to make sure that the outcome of a hybrid human - machine big data task has an accepted level of quality . since , the task is performed by both machines and human and then the individual contributions are aggregated to build up the final task outcome , quality of the final task s outcome depends on two parameters : quality of the individual contributions and the aggregation algorithm .
quality of each single contribution is an important factor that directly impacts the quality of the final task outcome . quality of humans contributions depends on many parameters such as quality of the contributor , task requirements , the process of contribution generation ( e.g. , time of the process , cost of the process , etc . ) and so on @xcite .
quality of machines contributions mainly depends on the algorithm that is used to generate the contributions .
many quality control approaches are proposed for assessing quality of contributions in human - involved tasks such as expert review , ground truth , voting , input agreement , output agreement , etc .
wall - mart project uses the expert review method for assessing quality of single contributions received from machines .
but they do not control the quality of contributions received from human , because of the way they have recruited them . in crowder , the ground truth method is used to assess quality of machines contributions .
then , the contributions passing a minimum threshold are sent to crowd for final assessment . to increase the chance of receiving quality results from humans , the crowder ,
encourages them to provide a reason why they think the entities match .
this is a quality assurance ( design time ) technique called robust task design @xcite .
the aggregation algorithm is another important parameter impacting quality of the final outcome . for the simplest form in which all contributions are generated by only humans or machines ,
the aggregation algorithms take into account many parameters such as the quality of individual contributions , quality of the contributor , statistical distribution of contributions , etc . @xcite . in the context of hybrid human - machine systems
the situation is more complex .
that is because , in addition to all those parameters , a priority between machine and human should be considered as well .
assume that in a special case , a disagreement occurs between the human response and machine s result .
which one should be selected as the correct result ?
@xcite in almost all existing hybrid systems , the priority is given to human s response whenever a contradiction happens .
this is the case in crowder and wall - mart project as well . in both cases
the initial results are generated by machines and refined and curated by humans .
the hybrid big data analytics is a young but fast growing research area .
billions of people all around the world are equipped with mobile devices all capable of creating gigantic amounts of unstructured data forces the big data analytics area to leverage human computational power towards analyzing big data .
the involvement of humans in the big data analytics , while resolves some challenges , creates new challenges that need more attention and investigations . in this section
we bring some of these challenges and discuss how they probably can be solved in future . task decomposition as described in section [ sec : frm ] is an important dimension in hybrid human - machine big data analytics .
task decomposition has several challenging aspects .
the first aspect is how to decompose the task .
should the task be decomposed automatically or humans should be involved in ?
automated task decomposition is faster , but probably not enough accurate . on the other hand ,
involving public crowd with different levels of knowledge and experience as well as various and sometimes dubious incentives and motivations is a risky job that may waste time and money of the task owners .
employing expert crowd to do the decomposition is another solution which incurs higher costs , may cause more delays , etc . at the moment , the existing hybrid systems employ the manual ( expert - based ) approaches for decomposing the tasks .
the next challenge is assigning decomposed sub - tasks to humans and machines . deciding on who should do what " is seriously challenging .
the first challenge is to decide which part of the work should be assigned to machine and which parts should be given to crowd to be done .
the next challenging aspect here is crowd selection .
assigning sub - tasks to crowd can easily create security and privacy problems .
there are cases in which assigning whole the problem to one worker can cause serious privacy and security problems @xcite .
even these problems may occur if a large number of tasks of a requester goes to one worker , or a small group of collaborating workers , the security and privacy of the requester easily breach @xcite .
finding a privacy aware worker recruitment approach which is also security aware as too and in the same times has a reasonable performance can be a potential direction of research in the future of hybrid human - machine big data analytics .
furthermore , considering the size of the big data , the high velocity of data arrival and unstructured nature of big data makes the problem more complicated .
let s use an example to explain the challenge .
assume that in a big data management system people are employed to extract entities from a given text .
as the size of the problem is too big , a very large number of workers are required to do the job .
assume that the simple task is extracting entities from a given text .
there are several approaches to allocate tasks to users @xcite . letting every worker to see all tasks simply can overwhelm workers with stacks of tasks and it makes it impossible for them to find the jobs that suits their expertise .
so , it is necessary to have a mechanism for assigning tasks to workers .
assigning tasks according to the workers profiles is not also possible , because the types of data may change suddenly and system should change the worker selection criteria on the fly to match the new requirements . also data is unstructured , hence , matching the data with the profile of the workers in real - time is another challenge that needs investigations .
moreover , the unstructured nature of big data makes it challenging to use publish / subscribe model for worker selection . in publish
/ subscribe approach , workers apply to receive updates or tasks from a specific category but because big data is usually unstructured it is hard to fit arrived data items in particular predefined categories .
so it is not possible to assign tasks to workers based on this approach .
finding a task assignment approach is an interesting and challenging aspect of human - enhanced big data analytics .
the final outcome of a hybrid big data computation task is an aggregate of all contributions received from both machines and humans .
selecting a inadequate aggregation algorithm can easily lead to producing low quality results .
the size of the big data is very large ; the data is rapidly changing and unstructured .
all these characteristics emphasize that the traditional aggregation algorithms are unable to handle this problem .
simple algorithms even , the ones that rely on automated methods and do not involve humans in their computations such as @xcite and @xcite , can not show an accepted performance in the area . on the other hand , when it comes to crowd contributions , quality is always a serious question .
people have the potential to exploit the system in order to gain unfair benefits and they do cleverly so that they can easily trap any aggregation algorithm @xcite . selecting a suitable aggregation algorithm is a serious challenge even in traditional big data algorithms .
the combination of human and machine raises even more challenges . in some cases , such as computation tasks ,
the credibility of the results generated by machines is far more than human results , while in hits the credibility of crowd s contributions is much higher than machine s .
also , there might be cases in which there are contradictions between the machine s outcome and a worker s contribution . which one should have the higher priority in this case ?
machine or human ? answering these questions needs deeper investigations and research supported with excessive experimentations .
availability of service is one of the main attributes of cloud and big data services @xcite . according to the agreements between the service provider and the customer ,
the system is responsible for providing on - demand resources for the requester .
the existing techniques have solved the availability problem reasonably well @xcite . on the other hand , the crowd workers usually are not full - time workers and do not have obligations to be on - time , on - call or even available in a specific period of time @xcite .
some systems have solved this problem by paying workers to be on - call @xcite .
considering the size of the problems in big data , paying on - call workers drastically increases the costs and is not feasible to apply to this area .
moreover , in addition to the size of the data , big data is unstructured and also may come from disparate data sources @xcite .
therefore , analyzing such a diverse data in terms of type requires having a large crowd of on - call workers with a very broad range of expertise .
providing and keeping on - call such a large crowd having diverse set of expertise is a challenging task which in most of cases is not feasible , or at least imposes high costs to the system
. workers may come and get engaged in a task , then suddenly leave it without any notice or clear reason .
this crowd characteristic raises another challenge .
assume that a worker has started a task , e.g. , tagging data in an online stream , and then suddenly leaves the system due to a communication problem or intentionally . what would be the best scenario to solve this issue ?
how is the best worker whom should be replaced with the left worker ? should the task be restarted from beginning or it should resume executing from a specific milestone ? how these milestones should be defined ? and many other problems which all emerge because of leaving and joining workers in a human - enhanced big data management system .
all these crowd characteristics raise a great concern on the availability of service in hybrid big data systems .
therefore , availability is probably another promising and interesting future research direction in the area of hybrid big data .
the collaborative and social nature of web 2.0has created an opportunity for emergence of a wide variety of human - centric systems , such as social networks , blogs , online markets , etc . , in which people spend a large portion of their daily life . the fast growth of smart phones has made these applications more available than ever .
this has led to the era of big data where users deal with data of a tremendous volume , wide variety of types , a rapid velocity and variable veracity . to understand this gigantic era ,
users need to rely on big data analytics to extract useful information from such a huge pool of data .
recently , a trend has emerged towards analyzing big data using human intelligence and wisdom of the crowds .
this trend , creates great opportunities for big data analytics to create more accurate analytics and results , however they raise many challenges that need more research and investigations . in this paper
, we have studied the area of hybrid human - machine big data analytics .
we first studied the crowdsourcing and big data areas and then proposed a framework to study the existing hybrid big data analytics using this framework .
we then introduced some significant challenges we believe to point to new research directions in the area of hybrid big data analytics .
we believe that in the near future the trend towards hybrid systems which contain human as a computing power will dramatically increase and a great amount of efforts from both industry and academia will be put in studying hybrid human - enabled systems .
as many researches show the emergences of these human - centric systems has created a great challenge on the security and privacy of future big data services .
also , the existence dominance of casual workers in these hybrid systems makes it harder than ever to guarantee availability and quality of services .
social networks , global crowdsourcing systems and other types of mass collaborative systems on the web are pools rich of work forces that can easily participate in big data analytics . at the moment these systems are almost isolated and it is very hard to define a task on all of these pools of human resources .
we believe that in the future it will be a need for a generic people management system on the web which is capable of handling profiles , records and histories of people all around the web and acts as a broker for all systems which request for human involvement .
such a people management system can simplifies handling security and privacy issues as well as finding available crowd workers for tasks which need high levels of availability .
mohammad allahbakhsh , boualem benatallah , aleksandar ignjatovic , hamid reza motahari - nezhad , elisa bertino , and schahram dustdar .
quality control in crowdsourcing systems : issues and directions .
, 17(2):7681 , 2013 .
mohammad allahbakhsh , aleksandar ignjatovic , boualem benatallah , seyed - mehdi - reza beheshti , elisa bertino , and norman foo .
reputation management in crowdsourcing systems . in _ collaborative computing
: networking , applications and worksharing ( collaboratecom ) , 2012 8th international conference on _ , pages 664671 .
ieee , 2012 .
mohammad allahbakhsh , aleksandar ignjatovic , boualem benatallah , seyed - mehdi - reza beheshti , elisa bertino , and norman foo .
collusion detection in online rating systems . in _ proceedings of the 15th asia pacific web conference ( apweb 2013 ) _ , pages 196207 , 2013 .
mohammad allahbakhsh , aleksandar ignjatovic , boualem benatallah , seyed - mehdi - reza beheshti , norman foo , and elisa bertino .
representation and querying of unfair evaluations in social rating systems . , 2013 .
h. amintoosi and s.s .
a trust - based recruitment framework for multi - hop social participatory sensing . in _ distributed computing in sensor systems ( dcoss ) , 2013 ieee international conference on _ , pages 266273 , may 2013 .
lars backstrom and jure leskovec .
supervised random walks : predicting and recommending links in social networks . in
_ proceedings of the fourth acm international conference on web search and data mining _ , wsdm 11 , pages 635644 , new york , ny , usa , 2011 .
michael s. bernstein , joel brandt , robert c. miller , and david r. karger .
crowds in two seconds : enabling realtime crowd - powered interfaces . in _ proceedings of the 24th annual acm symposium on user interface software and technology
_ , uist 11 , pages 3342 , new york , ny , usa , 2011 .
alessandro bozzon , marco brambilla , and stefano ceri . answering search queries with crowdsearcher . in _ proceedings of the 21st international conference on world wide web _ , www 12 , pages 10091018 , new york , ny , usa , 2012 .
acm .
alfredo cuzzocrea , il - yeol song , and karen c davis .
analytics over large - scale multidimensional data : the big data revolution ! in _ proceedings of the acm 14th international workshop on data warehousing and olap _ , pages 101104 .
acm , 2011 .
murat demirbas , murat ali bayir , cuneyt gurcan akcora , yavuz selim yilmaz , and hakan ferhatosmanoglu .
crowd - sourced sensing and collaboration using twitter . in _ world of wireless mobile and multimedia networks ( wowmom ) , 2010 ieee international symposium on a _ , pages 19 .
ieee , 2010 .
steven dow , anand kulkarni , scott klemmer , and bjrn hartmann . shepherding the crowd yields better work . in _ proceedings of the acm 2012 conference on computer supported cooperative work _ , cscw 12 , pages 10131022 , new york , ny , usa , 2012 .
michael j. franklin , donald kossmann , tim kraska , sukriti ramesh , and reynold xin .
crowddb : answering queries with crowdsourcing . in _ proceedings of the 2011 acm sigmod international conference on management of data
_ , sigmod 11 , pages 6172 , new york , ny , usa , 2011 .
acm .
aleksandar ignjatovic , norman foo , and chung tong lee .
an analytic approach to reputation ranking of participants in online transactions . in _ proceedings of the 2008 ieee / wic / acm international conference on web intelligence and intelligent agent technology - volume 01
_ , pages 587590 , washington , dc , usa , 2008 .
ieee computer society .
aniket kittur boris smus jim laredoc maja vukovic jakob rogstadius , vassilis kostakos .
an assessment of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation on task performance in crowdsourcing . in _ proceeding of the fifth international aaai conference on weblogs and social media_. aaai , 2011 .
natala j. menezes jenny j. chen and adam d. bradley .
opportunities for crowdsourcing research on amazon mechanical turk . in _
proceeding of the chi 2011 workshop on crowdsourcing and human computation _ ,
may 2011 .
aniket kittur , susheel khamkar , paul andr , and robert kraut .
crowdweaver : visually managing complex crowd work . in _ proceedings of the acm 2012 conference on computer
supported cooperative work _ , pages 10331036 .
acm , 2012 .
anand p kulkarni , matthew can , and bjoern hartmann .
turkomatic : automatic recursive task and workflow design for mechanical turk . in _
chi11 extended abstracts on human factors in computing systems _ ,
pages 20532058 .
acm , 2011 .
christopher olston , benjamin reed , utkarsh srivastava , ravi kumar , and andrew tomkins .
pig latin : a not - so - foreign language for data processing . in _ proceedings of the 2008 acm
sigmod international conference on management of data _ , sigmod 08 , pages 10991110 , new york , ny , usa , 2008 .
aditya g. parameswaran , hector garcia - molina , hyunjung park , neoklis polyzotis , aditya ramesh , and jennifer widom .
crowdscreen : algorithms for filtering data with humans . in _ proceedings of the 2012 acm
sigmod international conference on management of data _ , sigmod 12 , pages 361372 , new york , ny , usa , 2012 .
alexander j. quinn and benjamin b. bederson .
human computation : a survey and taxonomy of a growing field . in _ proceedings of the 2011 annual conference on human factors in computing systems
_ , chi 11 , pages 14031412 , new york , ny , usa , 2011 .
acm .
maja vukovic and claudio bartolini . towards a research agenda for enterprise crowdsourcing .
in tiziana margaria and bernhard steffen , editors , _ leveraging applications of formal methods , verification , and validation _ ,
volume 6415 of _ lecture notes in computer science _ , pages 425434 .
springer berlin / heidelberg , 2010 .
maja vukovic , mariana lopez , and jim laredo .
peoplecloud for the globally integrated enterprise . in _
service - oriented computing .
icsoc / servicewave 2009 workshops _ ,
volume 6275 of _ lecture notes in computer science _ , pages 109114 .
springer berlin / heidelberg , 2010 .
gang wang , christo wilson , xiaohan zhao , yibo zhu , manish mohanlal , haitao zheng , and ben y zhao . serf and turf : crowdturfing for fun and profit . in
_ proceedings of the 21st international conference on world wide web _ , pages 679688 .
acm , 2012 .
yafei yang , qinyuan feng , yan lindsay sun , and yafei dai .
reptrap : a novel attack on feedback - based reputation systems . in _ proceedings of the 4th international conference on security and privacy in communication netowrks _
, page 8 .
acm , 2008 . | the increasing application of social and human - enabled systems in people s daily life from one side and from the other side the fast growth of mobile and smart phones technologies have resulted in generating tremendous amount of data , also referred to as big data , and a need for analyzing these data , i.e. , big data analytics . recently
a trend has emerged to incorporate human computing power into big data analytics to solve some shortcomings of existing big data analytics such as dealing with semi or unstructured data . including crowd into big data analytics
creates some new challenges such as security , privacy and availability issues . in
this paper study hybrid human - machine big data analytics and propose a framework to study these systems from crowd involvement point of view .
we identify some open issues in the area and propose a set of research directions for the future of big data analytics area . |
two dimensional @xmath0 principal chiral models defined by the continuum lagrangian @xmath8 are the simplest quantum field theories sharing with non - abelian gauge theories the property of asymptotic freedom and whose large n limit is a sum over planar diagrams . due to the existence of higher - order conservation laws , multiparticle amplitudes are factorized , and exact @xmath9 matrices have been proposed @xcite .
the resulting bound state mass spectrum is represented by @xmath10 and the bound state of @xmath11 particles transforms as the totally antisymmetric tensor of rank @xmath11
. the mass-@xmath5 parameter ratio has been computed , and the result is @xcite @xmath12 a `` standard '' lattice version of principal chiral models is obtained by choosing the action @xmath13\;\;\ ; , \;\;\;\;\;\beta\;=\;{1\over nt}\;\;\ ; , \label{latt - act}\ ] ] whose properties have been investigated by several authors @xcite especially by strong - coupling and mean field methods .
numerical simulations have also been performed ( at @xmath14 ) , most recently by dagotto - kogut @xcite and hasenbusch - meyer @xcite . as a preliminary step within a more general program whose ultimate goal is performing the numerical @xmath15 expansion of matrix - valued field theories
, we decided to explore the properties of principal chiral models at larger - than - usual values of @xmath4 .
in particular we wanted to investigate the following issues : - region of applicability , accuracy and @xmath4 dependence of the strong coupling series
. - onset of scaling , with special attention to the interplay between thermodynamical ( peak in the specific heat ) and field theoretical ( dip in the @xmath3-function ) effects . - check of conjectured exact results ( especially mass ratios ) by monte carlo measurements in the scaling region
. - role of coupling redefinitions in the widening of the asymptotic scaling regions . to this purpose
, we performed a variety of strong coupling and weak coupling calculations , and a number of numerical simulations for different values of @xmath4 , and especially at @xmath7 , where the mass spectrum is sufficiently non - trivial ( two independent mass ratios can be measured and compared with prediction ) , and @xmath16 effects should be already significantly depressed . in the present paper we only report on our analytical results , without offering any details on the derivations , that will be presented elsewhere .
we found that the most convenient approach to strong coupling is the character expansion .
free energy character expansion for @xmath17 chiral models to twelfth order and mass gap expansion to fifth order were presented in ref .
the formal extension of these series to @xmath18 is easily achieved with the abovementioned precision for @xmath19 . paying some attention in order to avoid double - counting ,
@xmath20 can be also obtained by the same technique .
we found explicit representations of the coefficients of the @xmath18 character expansion in the strong coupling regime in terms of bessel functions , by generalizing the technique discussed in refs .
these representations are exact up to @xmath21 . as consequence
we could compute the @xmath18 free energy to twelfth order in @xmath3 for @xmath19 in two dimensions @xmath22 \beta^8 \ , + \ , \left[56 + { 8n^2 ( 5n^2 - 2)\over ( n^2 - 1)^2 } \right]\beta^{10 } \nonumber \\ & & + \left [ 248 + { 8n^2(35n^2 - 17)\over ( n^2 - 1)^2 } + { 2n^2(14n^6 - 11n^4 + 8n^2 - 2)\over ( n^2 - 1)^4 } + { 16n^4(9n^4 - 26n^2 + 8)\over 3(n^2 - 1)^2 ( n^2 - 4)^2}\right ] \beta^{12 } \nonumber \\ & & + \ ; o\left ( \beta^{14}\right)\;\;+\;\;\ ; 4{n^{n-2}\over n!}\beta^n \,+\ , \left [ 8 { n^{n-1}\over n!}- 4{n^n\over ( n+1)!}\right]\beta^{n+2 } \nonumber \\ & & + \;\left [ 2{n^{n+2}\over(n+2 ) ! } + 4{n^{n+1}\over ( n-1)n ! } - 8{(n+2)n^n\over ( n+1 ) ! } + 24{n^{n-1}\over n ! } + 4{n^{n-2}\over ( n-2)!}\right]\beta^{n+4 } \ , + \ , o\left ( \beta^{n+6}\right)\;. \label{scs1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the case @xmath7 an analysis of the @xmath23 and @xmath21 contributions led to the result @xmath24 the internal energy ( per link ) density @xmath25 is immediately obtained from the previous results by @xmath26 these results have been used to draw the strong coupling curves in our figures and compare very well with numerical simulations in the region @xmath27 . short weak coupling series for the free - energy density of @xmath17 and @xmath18 chiral models were presented in ref .
@xcite .
we calculated the energy density up to three loops finding @xmath28\ ; \rangle \;=\ ; { n^2 - 1\over 8n^2\beta}\left [ 1\,+\,{a_1\over\beta}\,+\ , { a_2\over \beta^2}\,+\, ... \;\right ] \label{wcenergy}\ ] ] where @xmath29 @xmath30 and @xmath31 being numerical constants : @xmath32 and @xmath33 .
asymptotic scaling requires the ratio of any dimensional quantity to the appropriate power of the two loop lattice scale @xmath34 to go to a constant as @xmath35 . @xmath36 and @xmath37 are the first universal coefficients of the expansion of the @xmath3-function : @xmath38 @xmath39 evaluation of the ratios of @xmath5 parameters requires a one loop calculation in perturbation theory , which leads to @xcite : @xmath40 in order to get a more accurate description of the approach to asymptotic scaling we performed the change of variables suggested by parisi @xcite , defining a new temperature @xmath41 proportional to the energy : @xmath42 notice that the corresponding specific heat is , by definition , constant . the ratio of @xmath43 , the @xmath5 parameter of the @xmath44 scheme , and @xmath45 is easily obtained from the two loop term of the energy density : @xmath46 we encountered the usual ( and yet unexplained ) phenomenon of a much better convergence to asymptotic scaling for quantities plotted as functions of @xmath44 @xcite .
we tried to check for a perturbative explanation of this phenomenon by computing the first perturbative correction to the two loop lattice scale @xmath47\;\;\ ; , \label{asy_corr}\ ] ] in the standard and the @xmath44 scheme , which requires the calculation of the three - loop term of the @xmath3-function in both schemes . in the standard scheme we found @xmath48 \label{b2l}\ ] ] where @xmath49 @xcite .
the equivalence of the @xmath50 chiral model to the @xmath51 @xmath52 model allows a check of this equation , indeed for @xmath53 it must give ( and indeed it does ) the same @xmath54 of the standard lattice @xmath51 @xmath52 model @xcite .
the @xmath3-function of the @xmath44 scheme can be written in the form @xmath55 where @xmath56 is the specific heat and @xmath57 must be considered as a function of @xmath41 . expanding perturbatively eq .
( [ betae ] ) and using eq .
( [ wcenergy ] ) one finds @xmath58 as one may easily verify , the linear corrections to the two loop lattice scale in eq .
( [ asy_corr ] ) are small and of the same order of magnitude ( although of opposite sign ) .
they can not therefore explain the failure of the first and the success of the second scheme with respect to achieving asymptotic scaling .
we believe that the origin of this phenomenon is fully non - perturbative , and it can presumably be traced to the phenomenologically apparent correlation existing between the peak in the specific heat and the dip in the lattice @xmath3-function : the non - perturbative variable transformation that flattens the peak manages to fill the dip , in a theoretically yet uncontrolled way .
we performed monte carlo simulations of the lattice @xmath0 chiral models for a wide range of values of @xmath4 ( in particular @xmath59 ) and @xmath3 . summaries of the runs are presented in tables [ n3-table],[n6-table],[n9-table ] and [ n15-table ] . in our simulations we implemented the cabibbo - marinari algorithm @xcite to upgrade @xmath18 matrices by updating its @xmath60 subgroups . in most cases ,
we chose to update the @xmath61 diagonal subsequent @xmath60 subgroups of each @xmath18 matrix variable by employing the over - heat - bath algorithm @xcite ( for the `` heat bath '' part of it we used the kennedy - pendleton algorithm @xcite ) . an important class of observables of the @xmath0 chiral models can be constructed by considering the group invariant correlation function @xmath62\;\rangle\;\;\;.\ ] ] we define the correlation function @xmath63 from the second moment of the correlation function @xmath64 . on the lattice @xmath65\;\;\ ; , \label{xig}\ ] ] where @xmath66 is the fourier transform of @xmath64 .
the inverse mass gap @xmath67 is extracted from the long distance behavior of the zero space momentum correlation function constructed with @xmath64 .
moreover we measured the diagonal wall - wall correlation length @xmath68 to test rotation invariance .
@xmath69 should reproduce in the continuum limit the mass of the fundamental state .
the first definition of correlation length @xmath63 offers the advantage of being directly measurable , while the calculation of @xmath67 requires a fit procedure . on the other hand , since @xmath63 is an off - shell quantity an analytical prediction exists only for the inverse mass - gap ( eq . ( [ mass - lambda ] ) ) . in tables [ n3-table],[n6-table],[n9-table ] and [ n15-table ] we present data for the energy density @xmath25 , the specific heat @xmath70 , the magnetic susceptibility @xmath71 defined from the correlation function @xmath64 , the correlation length @xmath63 , the dimensionless ratios @xmath72 and @xmath73 , respectively for @xmath59 .
we carefully checked for finite size effects .
it turned out that for @xmath74 the finite size systematic errors in evaluating infinite volume quantities should be safely smaller than 1% , which is the typical statistical error of our data . in figs .
[ en_n6 ] and [ en_n9 ] we show the energy density versus @xmath3 respectively at @xmath7 and @xmath75 . there
the strong coupling series up to twelfth order in @xmath3 and the weak coupling one up to third order in @xmath76 are drawn .
as in other asymptotically free models , at all values of @xmath4 the specific heat shows a peak , connecting the two different asymptotic behaviors : monotonically increasing in the strong coupling region and decreasing at large @xmath3 . in figs .
[ asy_n3],[asy_n6],[asy_n9 ] and [ asy_n15 ] @xmath77 is plotted respectively for @xmath59 with the corresponding @xmath78 order strong coupling series ( except for @xmath14 ) .
increasing @xmath4 , the peak moves slightly towards higher @xmath3 values ( @xmath79 at @xmath7 , @xmath80 at @xmath81 ) , and becomes more and more pronounced .
we found the position of the peak to be more stable at large @xmath4 when plotting @xmath77 versus @xmath63 , as in fig .
[ specheat ] .
notice that , increasing @xmath4 , the specific heat around the peak does not show any apparent convergence to a finite value , which might be an indication of a ( first order ? ) phase transition at @xmath82 .
the @xmath1 order ( @xmath78 order ) strong coupling series of the energy ( specific heat ) are in quantitative agreement ( within our statistical errors ) for @xmath83 , and in qualitative agreement up to the peak of the specific heat , whose position should give an estimate of the strong coupling convergence radius .
tests of scaling , based on the stability of dimensionless physical quantities ( for example , the ratio @xmath72 ) and rotation invariance ( checking that @xmath84 ) , showed that , within our statistical errors , the scaling region is reached already at small correlation lengths , i.e. for @xmath85 .
fitting data in the scaling region to a constant we found @xmath86 notice that scaling is observed even before the peak of the specific heat .
since strong coupling series should be effective in this region , it might be possible to calculate continuum physical quantities by strong coupling techniques . in order to investigate this issue work to extend the strong coupling series is in progress .
we checked asymptotic scaling according to the two loop formula ( [ asysc ] ) by analyzing @xmath87 . in figs .
[ asy_n3],[asy_n6],[asy_n9 ] and [ asy_n15 ] we show the corresponding data respectively for @xmath59 . at all values of @xmath4
we observe the usual dip in the @xmath3-function , which is , again , more and more pronounced when increasing @xmath4 .
since @xmath88 we compare @xmath89 directly with eq .
( [ mass - lambda ] ) ( using also eq .
( [ lratio1 ] ) ) , whose predictions , @xmath90 are represented by dashed lines in the figures .
notice that the monte carlo data are much larger than the predicted values , while the first perturbative corrections in eq .
( [ asy_corr ] ) are , in all cases , about 20% at @xmath91 .
furthermore , data show a similarity with the behavior of the specific heat , strengthening the idea of a strong correlation between the two phenomena .
the approach to asymptotic scaling gets an impressive improvement using the @xmath44 scheme . in figs .
[ asy_n3],[asy_n6],[asy_n9 ] and [ asy_n15 ] we also plot @xmath92 now data approach the correct value , and the discrepancies are even smaller than the linear correction calculated in sec .
[ numericalresults ] ( which is about 15% at @xmath91 ) .
so flattening the peak of the specific heat by performing the coupling redefinitions @xmath93 , the dip of the @xmath3-function disappears .
we believe this to be the key point of the success of the @xmath44 scheme in widening the asymptotic scaling region .
the peak of the specific heat should be explicable in terms of complex @xmath3-singularities of the partition function close to the real axis @xcite .
the sharpening of the peak with increasing @xmath4 would indicate that the complex singularities get nearer and nearer to the real axis , pinching it at @xmath82 where a phase transition is expected .
such singularities should also cause the abrupt departure from the weak coupling behavior .
then a coupling transformation eliminating the peak should move the complex @xmath3-singularities away from the real axis , and therefore improve the approach to asymptotic scaling . from the monte carlo data and
the exact result ( [ mass - lambda ] ) we can extract the effective @xmath5-parameters @xmath94 and @xmath95 . fig .
[ ll ] and [ le ] show respectively the ratios @xmath96 and @xmath97 , where @xmath98 and @xmath99 are the corresponding two loop functions : @xmath100 . similarly to the specific heat , the effective @xmath5-parameter @xmath94 does not give evidence of convergence at large @xmath4 . on
the contrary @xmath95 appears to approach a finite function @xmath101 , which is well approximated by the two loop formula . in conclusion ,
scaling and asymptotic scaling ( in the @xmath44 scheme ) are observed at all values of @xmath4 considered , even around the peak of the specific heat .
it is interesting to notice that , even though the behavior of the specific heat with respect to @xmath4 suggests the existence of a phase transition at @xmath82 , the above scenario is apparently stable at large @xmath4 .
we studied the mass spectrum at @xmath7 , where eq .
( [ massratios ] ) predicts the existence of two independent mass ratios . in order to extract the other two independent mass values besides the fundamental one , we considered the following operators : @xmath102 @xmath103 having respectively the same transformation properties of the two and three particle bound states . the mass values @xmath104 and
@xmath105 were determined from the large distance behavior of the zero space momentum correlation functions constructed with the above operators . in practice
we found distances @xmath106 to be large enough to fit the data to the expected exponential behavior . in table
[ mass - table ] and in fig .
[ mass - fig ] we present the data for the ratios @xmath107 , @xmath108 and @xmath109 , analyzed using the jackknife method .
they show good scaling . fitting them to a constant we found @xmath110 this result confirms , within statistical errors of about 1% , the conjectured exact result ( [ massratios ] ) , which predicts @xmath111 | lattice @xmath0 chiral models are analyzed by strong and weak coupling expansions and by numerical simulations .
@xmath1 order strong coupling series for the free and internal energy are obtained for all @xmath2 .
three loop contributions to the internal energy and to the lattice @xmath3-function are evaluated for all @xmath4 and non - universal corrections to the asymptotic @xmath5 parameter are computed in the `` temperature '' and the `` energy '' scheme .
numerical simulations confirm a faster approach to asymptopia of the energy scheme . a phenomenological correlation between the peak in the specific heat and the dip of the @xmath3-function is observed .
tests of scaling are performed for various physical quantities , finding substantial scaling at @xmath6 . in particular , at @xmath7 three different mass ratios are determined numerically and found in agreement , within statistical errors of about 1% , with the theoretical predictions from the exact s - matrix theory .
# 1currentlabel@secnum>0 .[#1 ] two dimensional @xmath0 chiral models on the lattice dipartimento di fisica delluniversit and i.n.f.n . , i-56126 pisa , italy |
entanglement is one of the most peculiar features of quantum mechanics and it also plays the role of a fundamental resource in many applications of quantum information @xcite . on the other hand ,
entangled systems unavoidably interact with their environments causing decoherence and a loss of entanglement .
since entanglement is by definition a nonlocal resource , one expects that any attempt to restore it must involve the use of nonlocal operations .
we consider physical situations where two subsystems , for example two qubits , are prepared in an entangled state and subsequently decoupled @xcite . due to the interaction with their local environment , entanglement dynamics may exhibit a non - monotonous behaviour , with the occurrence of revivals alternating to dark periods @xcite . in some cases ,
this phenomenon is due to the fact that entanglement is transferred to quantum environments , and then back - transferred to the system @xcite . in other cases , the environment can be modelled as a classical system @xcite and no entanglement between the system and the environment is established at any time . in the latter cases ,
the occurrence of entanglement revivals may appear paradoxical , since the effect of the noise is analogous to a local operation on a subsystem .
a first interpretation of this phenomenon has been given in terms of correlations present in a classical - quantum state of environments and qubits @xcite .
in a recent work @xcite , we have proposed to solve the apparent paradox by introducing the concept of _ hidden _ entanglement ( he ) , which measures the amount of entanglement that may be recovered without the help of any nonlocal operation . the definition of he is based on the quantum trajectory description of the system dynamics , that allows to point out the presence of entanglement in the system even if the density operator formalism does not reveal it : this entanglement is thus not accessible ( hidden ) due to the lack of classical information @xcite .
relevant examples of situations where the environment can be modelled as a classical system may be found in solid - state implementations of qubits .
for example , in superconducting nanocircuits one of the most relevant sources of decoherence @xcite are fluctuating background charges localized in the insulating materials surrounding superconducting islands @xcite .
each impurity produces a bistable fluctuation of the island polarization .
the collective effect of an ensemble of these random telegraph processes , with a proper distribution of switching rates , gives rise to @xmath0-noise @xcite routinely observed nanodevices @xcite .
in this paper we exploit the concept of hidden entanglement to explain the occurrence of entanglement revivals in a simple system . in particular , we consider two noninteracting qubits , one of them affected by a random telegraph noise at pure dephasing @xcite .
the paper is organized as follows . in section
[ sec : model ] , we introduce the hamiltonian model . in section [ sec : entanglement - dynamics ] we discuss the entanglement dynamics , showing that the revivals of entanglement are due to the presence of hidden entanglement . in section [ conclusions ]
we summarize obtained results and present some final comments .
we consider two noninteracting qubits @xmath1 and @xmath2 , initially prepared in a pure maximally entangled state @xmath3 , evolving according to the hamiltonian ( @xmath4 ) @xmath5 where @xmath6 , @xmath7 and @xmath8 represents a random telegraph ( rt ) process @xmath9 @xcite acting on qubit @xmath1 .
the rt process induces a random switching of qubit @xmath1 frequency between @xmath10 and @xmath11 , with an overall switching rate @xmath12 ( without loss of generality , we assume @xmath13 ) .
we consider a symmetric rt process where the transition rates between the two states are equal , that is @xmath14 .
our first aim is to find the system density matrix at any time @xmath15 .
the two qubits independently evolve under the hamiltonian ( [ eq : hamiltonian1 ] ) : qubit @xmath2 freely evolves whereas qubit @xmath1 displays a pure dephasing dynamics due to the effect of the stochastic process @xmath16 .
the dynamics of single qubit subject to rt noise at pure dephasing has been solved in @xcite .
a possible way to obtain @xmath15 is to solve a _ stochastic _ schrdinger equation which gives the following formal expression for @xmath15 @xmath17 p[\xi(t)]\,\rho_\xi(t ) \
, , \label{eq : evolved_qubit_densityoperator}\ ] ] where @xmath18 with @xmath19 , and the probability of the realization @xmath16 can be written as @xmath20=\lim_{m\to \infty } \eta_{m+1}(\xi_m , t_m ; \ldots;\xi_1,t_1;\xi_0,t_0 ) , \label{eq : probability_evolved_qubit_state}\ ] ] where @xmath21 is a ( @xmath22 ) joint probability for the sampled @xmath16 at regular intervals @xmath23 , @xmath24 , @xmath25 ( @xmath26 ) @xcite .
since the qubits evolve independently , the above procedure leads to a simple form depending on the single qubit coherences . in the computational basis @xmath27 , where @xmath28 , with @xmath29 and @xmath30 , and assuming an initial bell state @xmath31 , we obtain @xmath32 where the coherence decay factor @xmath33 reads @xcite @xmath34 , \label{eq : coherence - decayfactor}\ ] ] with @xmath35 , @xmath36 and @xmath37 . in the following
we shall exploit @xmath15 given by eq.([eq : densityoperator ] ) to analyze the two - qubit entanglement dynamics .
to quantify the degree of entanglement of the system state @xmath15 we use the entanglement of formation @xmath38 @xcite that can be readily calculated by the formula @xcite @xmath39 where @xmath40 is the concurrence and @xmath41 . for the state @xmath15 of eq .
( [ eq : densityoperator ] ) we obtain @xmath42 , where @xmath33 is given in eq .
( [ eq : coherence - decayfactor ] ) .
it is worth to notice that the evolved state @xmath15 belongs to the hilbert space spanned by the bell states @xmath43 , therefore the entanglement of formation equals the entanglement cost @xcite . in the strong coupling regime , @xmath44 @xcite entanglement revivals occur during the system dynamics @xcite . to understand the nature of this phenomenon we initally consider the limiting case of an extraordinarily slow rt process , @xmath45 ( @xmath46 ) .
this regime physically describes situations where the stochastic process is slow enough to be considered static during the system time evolution lasting @xmath47 , i. e. we assume @xmath48 @xcite .
the evolution expressed by eq.([eq : densityoperator ] ) describes an average resulting from the collection of several time evolutions each lasting @xmath47 .
the average includes the possibility that the rt process takes any of the two values @xmath49 or @xmath50 at time @xmath51 with equal probability . by a straightforward calculation
we find that the concurrence in this case is given by @xmath52 . under these conditions
we do not find any entanglement decay , rather the concurrence is equal to one at times @xmath53 and it vanishes at times @xmath54 , where @xmath55 is a non - negative integer .
( color online ) entanglement of formation @xmath56 as a function of the dimensionless time @xmath57 for the @xmath58 . from top to bottom , the solid curves correspond to @xmath59 and @xmath60 , the dashed curves represent @xmath61 for the same values of @xmath62.,scaledwidth=65.0% ] the entanglement revivals ( see the top solid curve in fig .
[ fig : rt ] ) are not due to periodic entanglement death and rebirth by nonlocal operations .
indeed , the hamiltonian evolution described by eq .
( [ eq : hamiltonian1 ] ) only includes local operations .
since local operations can not increase entanglement @xcite , its increase during the intervals @xmath63\tilde{t}_n,{t}_n]$ ] must be attributed to the manifestation of quantum correlations that were already present at times @xmath64 , but were _ hidden _ , in the sense that the density operator formalism does not capture them .
these correlations are evident in the quantum trajectory description of the system dynamics @xcite .
the system evolution in fact results from averaging on only two possible quantum trajectories .
the first trajectory corresponds to @xmath65 and the bloch vector of qubit @xmath1 rotates around its @xmath66-axis with frequency @xmath10 .
the second trajectory orresponds to @xmath67 and the bloch vector of qubit @xmath1 rotates around the @xmath66-axis with a different frequency @xmath11 .
the bloch vector of qubit @xmath2 instead rotates in both cases around its @xmath66-axis with frequency @xmath68 .
thus , during the first trajectory the system state evolves , up to an irrelevant global phase factor , as @xmath69 while during the second trajectory the system evolves , apart from an irrelevant global phase factor , as @xmath70 the two quantum trajectories only differ by the fact that the basis states @xmath71 and @xmath72 they acquire the additional relative phase @xmath73 in the quantum superpositions of eqs .
( [ eq : state-1 ] ) and ( [ eq : state-2 ] ) .
since the two quantum trajectory occur with equal probability , the system s state is described by the quantum ensemble @xmath74 where @xmath75 .
the entanglement associated to the quantum ensemble @xmath76 can be suitably identified by its average entanglement given by @xcite @xmath77 since both states @xmath78 and @xmath79 are maximally entangled at any time ( @xmath80 is the _ entropy of entanglement _
@xcite ) .
the _ hidden entanglement _
@xcite of the ensemble @xmath76 is defined as the difference between the average entanglement of eq .
( [ eq : average_entanglement ] ) and the entanglement of the corresponding density operator @xmath81 : @xmath82 the meaning of hidden entanglement is simple : it measures the entanglement that can not be exploited as a resource due to the lack of classical knowledge about which state in the ensemble @xmath76 we are dealing with .
once this classical information is provided , the entanglement can be recovered .
coming back to the interpretation of entanglement revivals , the ensemble description ( average entanglement @xmath83 ) tells us that at times @xmath64 the system is always in a maximally entangled state ( @xmath84 or @xmath85 ) but the lack of classical knowledge about which of the two states in the ensemble @xmath76 we are dealing with prevents us from distilling any entanglement : in fact , entanglement is _ hidden _ being @xmath86 and @xmath87 . at times
@xmath88 this lack of knowledge is irrelevant since the random relative phase becomes meaningless at @xmath89 : all the initial entanglement is recovered , @xmath90 and @xmath91 .
we now investigate the case when the rt process evolves during the systen evolution time , i. e. we consider the regime @xmath92 .
this situation is illustrated in fig .
[ fig : rt ] where we observe that the amplitude of revivals decreases as @xmath12 increases ( g decreases ) .
aslo in this case there is hidden entanglement . the possible quantum trajectories the system undergoes are now infinite .
the system state is described by the quantum ensemble @xmath93,{|{\varphi_\xi(t)}\rangle } \}$ ] and the average entanglement of @xmath76 is calculated by solving the path - integral @xmath94 p[\xi(t)]\,e\big({|{\varphi_\xi(t)}\rangle } \big).\ ] ] once again , we obtain @xmath83 since during each trajectory the state remains in a maximally entangled state at any time . on the other hand ,
the entanglement of formation assumes lower values with respect to the static noise case , @xmath45 .
in particular , the amplitude of revivals does not reach anymore the initial maximum value .
this is due to the fact that , in general , the action of the rt process during the time evolution makes the coherences of @xmath95 ( in the basis @xmath96 ) no longer in phase at times @xmath88 . in the time interval @xmath630,{t}_n]$ ]
one or more transitions can occur between the two rt states , such that we can have a random extra phase at the times @xmath88 given by @xmath97 where @xmath55 is a non - negative integer .
this unknown phase difference is responsible for the decay of the absolute values of coherences @xmath98 in the evolved two - qubit state @xmath99 of eq .
( [ eq : densityoperator ] ) : if we knew the phase difference @xmath100 for each state @xmath101 , we would be able to restore the coherence absolute value to 1 , and therefore recover all the initial entanglement , by simply applying the unitary local operation @xmath102 . for completeness
we point out , that the relative maxima of the entanglement of formation occur at @xmath103 , as one can derive from equation ( [ eq : coherence - decayfactor ] ) .
notice that the amount of the decay of the amplitude of entanglement revivals is monotonously related to the normalized autocorrelation function of the symmetric rt process @xmath104 @xcite . indeed , as we have already mentioned , the reduction of the amplitude revivals is related to the transitions of the rt occurred in @xmath105 $ ] , whose mean number is @xmath106 . from a quantitative point of view , for @xmath107 the coherences decay factor eq .
( [ eq : coherence - decayfactor ] ) can be approximated as @xmath108 $ ] , so that @xmath109 and @xmath110 , with @xmath111 defined in eq .
( [ eq : entanglement_formation ] ) .
this clearly shows that the decay of the entanglement amplitude revivals is due to the decrease of the rt correlations , or in other words , to the memory loss of the stochastic process @xmath16 itself .
in this paper we have exploited the concept of hidden entanglement to interpret the occurrence of entanglement revivals in a particular system where back - action from the environment is absent .
namely , we have considered a system composed of two noninteracting qubits where one qubit is subject to random telegraph noise at pure dephasing . during the dynamics , entanglement vanishes and
revives always `` remaining '' inside the system , as it is signalled by the average entanglement , @xmath112 at any time . at certain times @xmath113 this entanglement is completely hidden , in the sense that the entanglement of formation @xmath114 while the hidden entanglement @xmath115 . for this reason
, the two - qubit entanglement can be simply recovered at subsequent times without the help of any nonlocal operation : in the considered case in fact the hamiltonian only involves local operations .
finally we remark that the concept of hidden entanglement can be of practical relevance in solid - state devices , where dominant noise sources tipically have large amplitude components at low frequencies . in these systems entanglement revivals
may also be induced by applying local pulses to the qubits @xcite .
50 nielsen m a and chuang i l 2000 _ quantum computation and quantum information _
( cambridge university press , cambridge ) .
lpez c e , romero g , lastra f , solano e and retamal j c 2008 _ phys .
* 101 * 080503 ; lpez c e , romero g and retamal j c 2010 _ phys .
a _ * 81 * 062114 ; bai y - k , ye m - y and wang z d 2009 _ phys .
a _ * 80 * 044301 . | entanglement dynamics of two noninteracting qubits , locally affected by random telegraph noise at pure dephasing , exhibits revivals .
these revivals are not due to the action of any nonlocal operation , thus their occurrence may appear paradoxical since entanglement is by definition a nonlocal resource . we show that a simple explanation of this phenomenon may be provided by using the ( recently introduced ) concept of _ hidden _ entanglement , which signals the presence of entanglement that may be recovered with the only help of local operations . |
the structure and heating of the solar corona , as well as the acceleration of the solar wind , are influenced by the structure and topology of the large - scale coronal magnetic field . on this basis
, the existence of a planet at a distance of 0.1 au or less @xcite , with a strong internal magnetic field is expected to have a significant effect on the stellar magnetosphere , which is controlled by the magnetic field structure @xcite . in recent years , some signatures of this star - planet interaction ( spi ) have been observed .
shkolnik et al .
@xcite have reported on modulations in the ca ii k emission line , an indicator for chromospheric activity .
they find enhancements in the line intensity that have the same period as the planetary orbital motion , though sometimes with a significant non - zero phase - shift .
the cause is deemed magnetic and not tidal because of the lack of an equivalent hot spot offset in phase by @xmath0 . in addition , a statistical survey of the x - ray fluxes from stars with close - in planets has found them enhanced by a 30 - 400% on average over typical fluxes from similar stars with planets that are not close - in @xcite .
direct x - ray observations of the hd 179949 system @xcite showed that the spi contributed @xmath130% to the emission at a mean temperature of @xmath1 1 kev .
some analytical and semi - empirical arguments have been advanced to explain these observations .
one posits that particles are accelerated along magnetic field lines that connect the star and planet , creating hot spots where they hit the chromospheric layer @xcite . as a result ,
hot spots are observed generally in phase with the planetary orbit , but with the capacity to have large offsets , depending on the exact structure of the magnetic field between the star and planet .
another shows that transition of field lines from a high - helicity state to a linear force - free state is energetically adequate to power the enhanced intensities @xcite .
the detailed behavior of the dynamical interaction of coronal and wind plasma with two magnetic field systems is , however , very difficult to realize with idealized models .
the problem properly requires simultaneous descriptions of both the stellar and the planetary magnetospheres , the planetary orbital motion , and often asynchronous stellar rotation , together with a self - consistent stellar wind solution .
here we describe an initial simulation of the magnetic star - planet interaction .
we use idealized test cases to study the fundamental changes in the steady - state coronal structure due to the presence of the planet and its magnetic field .
the dynamical interaction due to the planetary orbital motion is captured in an indirect manner .
the numerical simulation has been performed using the university of michigan solar corona ( sc ) model @xcite , which is based on the bats - r - us global mhd code @xcite and is part of the space weather modeling framework ( swmf ) @xcite .
the model solves the set of magnetohydrodynamic equations on a cartesian grid using adaptive mesh refinement ( amr ) technology .
this model has been extensively validated for the solar corona using coronal observations and in - situ solar wind measurements taken at 1 au @xcite .
we assume that the particular physical description of the coronal heating and wind acceleration is not crucial to study the change in the existing coronal structure due to the planet .
it is important to mention that we use a _ global _ model for the corona that can not reproduce realistic chromospheric emission due to heating of coronal loops .
we also do not fully describe the observed coronal heating , since for example no input from magnetic reconnection or loop footpoint motion is included .
thus , while we adopt the physical parameters of some real systems in the modeling , we do not expect the models to fully reproduce all aspects of observations ( in particular , details of the temperature and level of the emissions ) at this point .
the full physical description of the model and its limitations can be found in @xcite we performed several different numerical simulations , of which we highlight two here .
case a : both the stellar and planetary magnetic fields are perfectly aligned dipoles .
we set the stellar polar field to be @xmath2 and the planetary polar field to be antiparallel at @xmath3 ( i.e. , opposite to the stellar dipole ) .
the planetary magnetic field is weaker than jupiter s , and follows the assumption that hot - jupiters are expected ( but not required ) to have lower spin rates due to tidal locking , and thus have weaker magnetic fields @xcite .
we note that a simulation in which the planetary dipole was set to be in the same direction with the stellar dipole resulted in a quantitatively similar solution as in this case .
case b : the planetary magnetic field is a perfect dipole and the stellar magnetic field is driven by solar magnetic synoptic map ( magnetogram ) .
this map contains measurements of the photospheric radial magnetic field taken during solar maximum ( carrington rotation cr2010 , very active sun ) .
the use of a magnetic synoptic map enables us to generate a realistic , sun - like , three - dimensional magnetic field . in case
a , we mimic the relative motion between the planet and the background plasma by fixing the planet and rotating the star and the coronal plasma in the inertial frame .
this way , the planet orbits the star backwards in the frame rotating with the star .
this is done due to the fact that the actual orbital motion of the planet requires time - dependent boundary conditions .
we plan to implement this technical improvement in future simulations . for the sake of definiteness
, we partially match the parameters of the system to the observed parameters of hd 179949 @xcite , which is an f8v type star .
we use the following stellar parameters : @xmath4 , @xmath5 , and stellar rotation period of @xmath6 . in the hd 179949 system ,
the planet is located at a distance of 0.045 au ( 9.65 stellar radii ) , and a @xmath7 phase - lead of a chromospheric hot spot is observed .
the planetary parameter @xmath8 has not been used here . in case b , we fix the planet relative to the star and run the simulation in the frame rotating with the star . in this case
we use solar parameters except for the planetary properties , which are the same as in case a. this case represents a steady - state , large scale interaction of a sun - like star with with a tidally - locked extrasolar planet ( e.g. , @xmath9 boo ; @xcite ) located at the same distance as before . in both simulations , the boundary condition for the planetary plasma number density and temperature were @xmath10 and @xmath11 respectively @xcite .
the stellar boundary conditions were @xmath12 and @xmath13 respectively , based on previous simulation of the solar corona @xcite .
to further aide interpretation of the results , we performed two additional simulations as a reference , identical to the cases above , but with the planet removed ; i.e. , considering the star with just the @xmath2 dipolar field , and with the cr2010 magnetogram . in each simulation , the set of mhd equations is solved until convergence . the end result is a three - dimensional , steady - state solution for the particular system that includes all the mhd variables ( density , pressure , velocity , and magnetic field ) . since the mhd solution contains the values for @xmath14 and @xmath15 at each spatial cell , we can perform the line - of - sight integration to obtain the predicted x - ray emissions for a particular view angle .
the integration takes in to account cells in front of the star but omits cells behind it .
we repeat this procedure for different view angles to mimic the predicted x - ray flux as the system rotates .
the x - ray flux , @xmath16 , is calculated as the line - of - sight integral @xmath17 . here
@xmath18 is the line - of - sight depth and we have used a piecewise linear approximation to the radiative loss @xmath19 for a plasma with solar photospheric abundances @xcite .
simulation results are illustrated in figure [ fig : f1 ] .
top and middle panels show the three - dimensional solutions excluding and including the planet , respectively .
bottom panels show the difference in x - ray flux for temperature range of @xmath20 with and without the planet .
left panels show results of case a , while right panels show results of case b. considering first case a , we note a key difference between simulations with and without the planet . in the former ,
magnetic field lines are conspicuously brought in toward the planet and are constricted due to the presence of the planetary magnetosphere .
this has a palpable influence on the coronal electron number density , @xmath14 , which now increases azimuthally approaching the star - planet line to form an x - ray bright spot facing the planet .
this solution is qualitatively very similar in case b , where there is also a clear longitudinal concentration of the plasma density , and consequently the x - ray flux ( which is proportional to @xmath21 ) .
while we can not simulate chromospheric emission with our current models , its surface intensity distribution on the sun follows closely those regions of the disk that are brighter at euv and x - ray wavelengths .
the results of these simulations are , then , fully consistent with the observed location of chromospheric hot spots seen in - phase with the planetary orbit .
the longitudinal brightening effect is also clear in figure [ fig : f2 ] , where the line - of - sight x - ray flux originating at different plasma temperatures is shown as a function of viewing angle for the simulations including planets . in the idealized dipole field case ,
the emission is much more intense when the corona is viewed from the direction of the planet than from the opposite direction when the star hides the brighter parts of the corona that form the hot spot in phase with the planet ( a difference of 25 - 35% in observed x - ray flux ) .
the simulation based on the realistic , complex magnetic field results in a hot spot ( 15 - 30% difference in x - ray flux ) shifted by about @xmath7 relative to the star - planet line .
this suggests that the phase shifts between hot spots and planetary orbital phase seen in spi observations are probably due to the complexity of the stellar coronal magnetic fields and the consequent complexity of the magnetic connectivity between star and the planet . also of interest
is the magnitude of the x - ray flux enhancement seen compared to the case where there is no planet . in the ideal dipole field case
, we find enhancements of at least 10% in base emission and as much as @xmath180% relative to the no - planet case , and a contrast between minimum and maximum of 20 - 30%
. these numbers are consistent with the observed signatures of spi found in x - ray observations .
when solutions driven by realistic magnetogram data are considered , we find that enhancements in base emission by a factor of 10 are possible . the simulation with realistic , complex magnetic field results in much higher density enhancement and closing of coronal loops compared to the dipolar case . the mhd model , however , does not take into account the detailed physics of smaller scale x - ray emitting coronal loops , and the magnitude of the predicted x - ray enhancements should be considered approximate .
the density enhancement in the closed - field zone provides a vital medium which can be heated to produce the spi effect .
the compression alone produces significant increase in radiative loss at low temperatures ; localized dynamical effects , not modeled here , such as megnetic reconnection due to the planetary orbital motion , and particle acceleration then likely further heat the plasma to the observed @xmath22 1 kev temperatures @xcite .
in conclusion , we find that a dominant physical effect creating observable time - variable spi signatures is that the existence of the planet and its magnetosphere , close to the star , prevents the expansion of the stellar coronal magnetic field and the acceleration of the stellar wind .
the pressure gradient is not as large as it would be in the absence of the planet , so the coronal field lines that would be opened by the wind remain closed and the plasma in these loops do not escape .
this effect alone reproduces three observable feature : 1 ) enhancement of total x - ray flux , 2 ) appearance of coronal hot spots , 3 ) phase - shift of the hot spots from star - planet line .
the density enhancement results in low temperature coronal heating .
we will further develop the model to include the planetary orbital motion in order to capture more dynamical effects of spi .
this work has been inspired by initial study performed by noe lugaz .
we thank an unknown referee for his / hers useful comments and ruth murray - clay for useful discussion .
oc is supported by nsf - shine atm-0823592 grant , nasa - lwstrt grant nng05gm44 g .
jjd and vlk were funded by nasa contract nas8 - 39073 to the _ chandra x - ray center_. simulation results were obtained using the space weather modelling framework , developed by the canter for space environment modelling , at the university of michigan with funding support from nasa ess , nasa esto - ct , nsf kdi , and dod muri . ,
g. , sokolov , i. v. , gombosi , t. i. , chesney , d. r. , clauer , c. r. , de zeeuw , d. l. , hansen , k. c. , kane , k. j. , manchester , w. b. , oehmke , r. c. , powell , k. g. , ridley , a. j. , roussev , i. i. , stout , q. f. , volberg , o. , wolf , r. a. , sazykin , s. , chan , a. , yu , b. , & kta , j. 2005 , journal of geophysical research ( space physics ) , 110 , 12226 | since the first discovery of an extrasolar planetary system more than a decade ago , hundreds more have been discovered .
surprisingly , many of these systems harbor jupiter - class gas giants located close to the central star , at distances of 0.1 au or less . observations of chromospheric hot spots that rotate in phase with the planetary orbit , and elevated stellar x - ray luminosities , suggest that these close - in planets significantly affect the structure of the outer atmosphere of the star through interactions between the stellar magnetic field and the planetary magnetosphere . here
we carry out the first detailed three - dimensional magnetohydrohynamics ( mhd ) simulation containing the two magnetic bodies and explore the consequences of such interactions on the steady - state coronal structure .
the simulations reproduce the observable features of 1 ) increase in the total x - ray luminosity , 2 ) appearance of coronal hot spots , and 3 ) phase shift of these spots with respect to the direction of the planet .
the proximate cause of these is an increase in the density of coronal plasma in the direction of the planet , which prevents the corona from expanding and leaking away this plasma via a stellar wind .
the simulations produce significant low temperature heating . by including dynamical effects , such as the planetary orbital motion
, the simulation should better reproduce the observed coronal heating . |
one of the key challenges in neuroscience is how the human brain activities can be mapped to the different brain tasks . as a conjunction between neuroscience and computer science , multi - voxel pattern analysis ( mvpa ) @xcite addresses this question by applying machine learning methods on task - based functional magnetic resonance imaging ( fmri ) datasets .
analyzing the patterns of visual objects is one of the most interesting topics in mvpa , which can enable us to understand how brain stores and processes the visual stimuli @xcite .
it can be used for finding novel treatments for mental diseases or even creating a new generation of the user interface in the future .
technically , there are two challenges in previous studies .
the first challenge is decreasing sparsity and noise in preprocessed voxels .
since , most of the previous studies directly utilized voxels for predicting the stimuli , the trained features are mostly sparse , high - dimensional and noisy ; and they contain trivial useful information @xcite .
the second challenge is increasing the performance of prediction .
most of the brain decoding problems employed binary classifiers especially by using a one - versus - all strategy @xcite . in addition , multi - class predictors are even mostly based on the binary classifiers such as the error - correcting output codes ( ecoc ) methods @xcite .
since task - based fmri experiments are mostly imbalance , it is so hard to train an effective binary classifier in the brain decoding problems . for instance , consider collected data with 10 same size categories . since this dataset is imbalance for one - versus - all binary classification , most of the classical algorithms can not provide acceptable performance @xcite . for facing mentioned problems
, this paper proposes anatomical pattern analysis ( apa ) as a general framework for decoding visual stimuli in the human brain .
this framework employs a novel feature extraction method , which uses the brain anatomical regions for generating a normalized view . in practice
, this view can enable us to combine homogeneous datasets .
the feature extraction method also can automatically detect the active regions for each category of the visual stimuli .
indeed , it can decrease noise and sparsity and increase the performance of the final result .
further , this paper develops a modified version of imbalance adaboost algorithm for binary classification .
this algorithm uses a supervised random sampling and penalty values , which are calculated by the correlation between different classes , for improving the performance of prediction .
this binary classification will be used in a one - versus - all ecoc method as a multi - class approach for classifying the categories of the brain response .
the rest of this paper is organized as follows : in section 2 , this study briefly reviews some related works .
then , it introduces the proposed method in section 3 .
experimental results are reported in section 4 ; and finally , this paper presents conclusion and pointed out some future works in section 5 .
there are three different types of studies for decoding visual stimuli in the human brain .
pioneer studies just focused on the special regions of the human brain , such as the fusiform face area ( ffa ) or parahippocampal place area ( ppa ) .
they only proved that different stimuli can provide different responses in those regions , or found most effective locations based on different stimuli @xcite .
the next group of studies introduced different correlation techniques for understanding similarity or difference between responses to different visual stimuli .
haxby et al
. recently showed that different visual stimuli , i.e. human faces , animals , etc .
, represent different responses in the brain @xcite .
further , rice et al . proved that not only the mentioned responses are different based on the categories of the stimuli , but also they are correlated based on different properties of the stimuli .
they used gist technique for extracting the properties of stimuli and calculated the correlations between these properties and the brain responses .
they separately reported the correlation matrices for different human faces and different objects ( houses , chairs , bottles , shoes ) @xcite .
the last group of studies proposed the mvpa techniques for predicting the category of visual stimuli .
cox et al . utilized linear and non - linear versions of support vector machine ( svm ) algorithm @xcite .
norman et al . argued for using svm and gaussian naive bayes classifiers @xcite .
carroll et al .
employed the elastic net for prediction and interpretation of distributed neural activity with sparse models @xcite .
varoquaux et al .
proposed a small - sample brain mapping by using sparse recovery on spatially correlated designs with randomization and clustering .
their method is applied on small sets of brain patterns for distinguishing different categories based on a one - versus - one strategy @xcite .
mcmenamin et al .
studied subsystems underlie abstract - category ( ac ) recognition and priming of objects ( e.g. , cat , piano ) and specific - exemplar ( se ) recognition and priming of objects ( e.g. , a calico cat , a different calico cat , a grand piano , etc . ) .
technically , they applied svm on manually selected rois in the human brain for generating the visual stimuli predictors @xcite .
mohr et al . compared four different classification methods , i.e. l1/2 regularized svm , the elastic net , and the graph net , for predicting different responses in the human brain .
they show that l1-regularization can improve classification performance while simultaneously providing highly specific and interpretable discriminative activation patterns @xcite .
osher et al .
proposed a network ( graph ) based approach by using anatomical regions of the human brain for representing and classifying the different visual stimuli responses ( faces , objects , bodies , scenes ) @xcite .
-0.1 in -0.27 in
blood oxygen level dependent ( bold ) signals are used in fmri techniques for representing the neural activates . based on hyperalignment problem in the brain decoding @xcite ,
quantity values of the bold signals in the same experiment for the two subjects are usually different .
therefore , mvpa techniques use the correlation between different voxels as the pattern of the brain response @xcite .
as depicted in figure 1 , each fmri experiment includes a set of sessions ( time series of 3d images ) , which can be captured by different subjects or just repeating the imaging procedure with a unique subject .
technically , each session can be partitioned into a set of visual stimuli categories .
indeed , an independent category denotes a set of homogeneous conditions , which are generated by using the same type of photos as the visual stimuli .
for instance , if a subject watches 6 photos of cats and 5 photos of houses during a unique session , this 4d image includes 2 different categories and 11 conditions .
consider @xmath0number of scans @xmath1
3d images@xmath2 for each session of the experiment .
@xmath3 can be written as a general linear model : @xmath4 , where @xmath5number of scans ( n ) @xmath6 @xmath7 categories ( regressors)@xmath2 denotes the design matrix ; @xmath8 is the noise ( error of estimation ) ; and also @xmath9number of categories @xmath10 3d images@xmath2 denotes the set of correlations between voxels for the categories of the session .
design matrix can be calculated by convolution @xmath11 of onsets ( or time series @xmath12 ) and the hemodynamic response function ( hrf ) @xcite .
this paper uses generalized least squares ( gls ) approach for estimating optimized solution @xmath13 , where @xmath14 is the covariance matrix of the noise ( @xmath15 ) @xcite .
now , this paper defines the positive correlation @xmath16 for all categories as the active regions , where @xmath17 denotes the estimated correlation , @xmath18 and @xmath19 are the correlation and _ positive _ correlation for the @xmath20-th category , respectively .
moreover , the data @xmath3 is partitioned based on the conditions of the design matrix as follows : @xmath21 where @xmath22 denotes the set of all conditions in each session , @xmath7 and @xmath23 are respectively the number of categories in each session and the number of conditions in each category .
further , @xmath24 = \{number of scans @xmath25 @xmath6 3d images } denotes the 4d images for the @xmath20-th category and @xmath26-th condition in the design matrix .
now , this paper defines the sum of all images in a condition as follows : @xmath27 \label{eqrawfeatures}\ ] ] where @xmath28 $ ] denotes all voxels in the @xmath29-th scan of @xmath30-th condition of @xmath20-th category ; also @xmath31 is the number of scans in the given condition .
@xmath32 matrix is denoted for applying the correlation of voxels on the response of each condition as follows : @xmath33 \in c^{p}_{q_r } \implies { ( { \zeta}}^{p}_{q_r})_{[x , y , z ] } = { ( \beta_p)}_{[x , y , z ] } \times { ( c_{q_r}^p)}_{[x , y , z]}\ } \label{eq : rawfeatures}\ ] ] where @xmath34 denotes hadamard product ; and @xmath35}$ ] is the @xmath36$]-th voxel of the @xmath30-th condition of @xmath20-th category ; and also , @xmath37}$ ] is the @xmath36$]-th voxel of the correlation matrix ( @xmath38 values ) of the @xmath20-th category . since mapping 4d fmri images to standard
space decreases the performance of final results , most of the previous studies use the original images instead of the standard version . by considering 3d image @xmath39 for each condition
, this paper enables to map brain activities to a standard space .
this mapping can provide normalized view for combing homogeneous datasets . for registering @xmath39 to standard space ,
this paper utilizes the flirt algorithm @xcite , which minimizes the following cost function : @xmath40 where @xmath41 denotes the reference image , @xmath42 is the space of allowable transformations , the function @xmath43 denotes the normalized mutual information between two images , @xmath44 is the condition after registration ( @xmath45 denotes the transformation function ) @xcite .
the performance of ( [ eqimagereg ] ) will be analyzed in section 4 .
now , consider @xmath46 , where @xmath47 , @xmath48 and @xmath49 denotes the set of indexes of voxels for the @xmath50-th region . the extracted feature for @xmath50-th region of @xmath30-th condition of @xmath20-th category is calculated as follows , where @xmath51 $ ] denotes the index of @xmath52-th voxel of @xmath50-th atlas region ; and @xmath49 is the set of indexes of voxels in the @xmath50-th region .
@xmath53 \in a_l \implies { \gamma}_{q_r}^p(l)=\frac{1}{\mid a_l \mid}\sum_{v = 1}^{\mid a_l \mid}{({\xi}_{q_r}^{p})[a_v]}=\frac{1}{\mid
a_l \mid}\sum_{v = 1}^{\mid a_l \mid}{({\xi}_{q_r}^{p})[x_v , y_v , z_v ] } \label{featureextraction}\ ] ] this paper randomly partitions the extracted features @xmath54,\dots,$ ] @xmath55 , \dots,[{\gamma}_{q_r}^{p}(1 ) \dots { \gamma}_{q_r}^{p}(l ) ] \}$ ] to the train set @xmath56 and the test set @xmath57 . as a new branch of adaboost algorithm , algorithm 1 employs @xmath58 for training binary classification .
then , @xmath59 is utilized for estimating the performance of the classifier .
as mentioned before , training binary classification for fmri analysis is mostly imbalance , especially by using a one - versus - all strategy . as a result ,
the number of samples in one of these binary classes is smaller than the other class . this paper also exploits this concept . indeed , algorithm 1 firstly partitions the train data @xmath60 to small @xmath61 and large @xmath62 classes ( groups ) based on the class labels @xmath63 .
then , it calculates the scale @xmath64 of existed elements between two classes ; and employs this scale as the number of the ensemble iteration @xmath65 .
here , @xmath66 denotes the floor function . in the next step , the large class
is randomly partitioned to @xmath67 parts .
now , train data @xmath68 for each iteration is generated by all instances of the small class @xmath61 , one of the partitioned parts of the large class @xmath69 and the instances of the previous iteration @xmath70 , which can not truly be trained . in this algorithm
, @xmath71 function denotes the pearson correlation @xmath72 ; and @xmath73 $ ] is the train weight ( penalty values ) , which is considered for the large class .
further , @xmath74 denotes any kind of weighted classification algorithm .
this paper uses a simple classical decision tree as the individual classification algorithm ( @xmath75 ) @xcite . + generally , there are two techniques for applying multi - class classification .
the first approach directly creates the classification model such as multi - class support vector machine @xcite or neural network @xcite .
in contrast , ( indirect ) decomposition design uses an array of binary classifiers for solving the multi - class problems . as
one of the classical indirect methods , error - correcting output codes ( ecoc ) includes three components , i.e. base algorithm , encoding and decoding procedures @xcite . as the based algorithm in the ecoc , this paper employs algorithm 1 for generating the binary classifiers ( @xmath76 ) .
further , it uses a one - versus - all encoding strategy for training the ecoc method , where an independent category of the visual stimuli is compared with the rest of categories ( see figure 1.e ) .
indeed , the number of classifiers in this strategy is exactly equal to the number of categories .
this method also assigns the brain response to the category with closest hamming distance in decoding stage .
data set @xmath77 is train set , @xmath78 denotes real class labels of the train sets , + classifier @xmath79 , + 1 .
partition @xmath80 , where @xmath81 , @xmath82 are small and large classes .
calculate @xmath83 based on number of elements in classes .
+ 3 . randomly
sample the @xmath84 .
+ 4 . by considering @xmath85 ,
generating @xmath86 classifiers : + 5 .
construct @xmath87 and @xmath88 @xmath89 + 7.train @xmath90 .
construct @xmath91 , @xmath92 as the set of instances can not truly trained in @xmath75 .
if * @xmath93 : go to line @xmath94 ; * else : * return @xmath95 as final classifier . +
this paper employs two datasets , shared by openfmri.org , for running empirical studies . as the first dataset , ` visual object recognition ' ( ds105 ) includes 71 sessions ( 6 subjects ) .
it also contains 8 categories of visual stimuli , i.e. gray - scale images of faces , houses , cats , bottles , scissors , shoes , chairs , and scrambled ( nonsense ) photos .
this dataset is analyzed in high - level visual stimuli as the binary predictor , by considering all categories except scrambled photos as objects , and low - level visual stimuli in the multi - class prediction .
please see @xcite for more information . as the second dataset , ` word and object processing ' ( ds107 ) includes 98 sessions ( 49 subjects ) .
it contains 4 categories of visual stimuli , i.e. words , objects , scrambles , consonants
. please see @xcite for more information .
these datasets are preprocessed by spm 12 ( www.fil.ion.ucl.ac.uk/spm/ ) , i.e. slice timing , realignment , normalization , smoothing .
then , the beta values are calculated for each session .
this paper employs the _ mni 152 t1 1 mm _
( see figure 1.d ) as the reference image ( @xmath41 ) in eq .
( 4 ) for registering the extracted conditions ( @xmath96 ) to the standard space ( @xmath97 ) .
in addition , this paper uses _ talairach _ atlas ( contains @xmath98 regions ) in eq .
( 5 ) for extracting features ( see figure 1.d ) .
figures 2.a - c demonstrate examples of brain responses to different stimuli , i.e. ( a ) word , ( b ) object , and ( c ) scramble . here
, gray parts show the anatomical atlas , the colored parts ( red , yellow and green ) define the functional activities , and also the red rectangles illustrate the error areas after registration .
indeed , these errors can be formulated as the nonzero areas in the brain image which are located in the zero area of the anatomical atlas ( the area without region number ) .
the performance of objective function on ds105 , and ds107 data sets is analyzed in figure 2.d by using different distance metrics , i.e. woods function ( w ) , correlation ratio ( cr ) , joint entropy ( je ) , mutual information ( mi ) , and normalized mutual information ( nmi ) @xcite .
as depicted in this figure , the nmi generated better results in comparison with other metrics .
figure 3.a and c illustrate the correlation matrix of the ds105 and ds107 at the voxel level , respectively .
similarly , figure 3.b and d show the correlation matrix the ds105 and ds107 in the feature level , respectively .
since , brain responses are sparse , high - dimensional and noisy at voxel level , it is so hard to discriminate between different categories in figure 2.a and c. by contrast , figure 2.b and d provide distinctive representation when the proposed method used the correlated patterns in each anatomical regions as the extracted features . ) on the error of registration .
+ , title="fig:",scaledwidth=60.0% ] -0.1 in -0.3 in + ( a ) ( b ) + + ( c ) ( d ) -0.3 in the performance of our framework is compared with state - of - the - art methods , i.e. cox & savoy @xcite , mcmenamin et al .
@xcite , mohr et al .
@xcite , and osher et al .
@xcite , by using leave - one - out cross validation in the subject level .
further , all of algorithms are implemented in the matlab r2016a ( 9.0 ) by authors in order to generate experimental results .
tables 1 and 2 respectively illustrate the classification accuracy and area under the roc curve ( auc ) for the binary predictors based on the category of the visual stimuli .
all visual stimuli in the dataset ds105 except scrambled photos are considered as the object category for generating these experimental results . as depicted in the tables 1 and 2 ,
the proposed algorithm has achieved better performance in comparison with other methods because it provided a better representation of neural activities by exploiting the anatomical structure of the human brain .
table 3 illustrates the classification accuracy for multi - class predictors . in this table , ` ds105 ' includes 8 different categories ( p=8 classes ) and ` ds107 ' contains 4 categories of the visual stimuli . as another 4 categories dataset , `
all ' is generated by considering all visual stimuli in the dataset ds105 except scrambled photos as object category and combining them with the dataset ds107 . in this dataset ,
the accuracy of the proposed method is improved by combining two datasets , whereas , the performances of other methods are significantly decreased . as mentioned before , it is the standard space registration problem in the 4d images .
in addition , our framework employs the extracted features from the brain structural regions instead of using all or a subgroup of voxels , which can increase the performance of the predictive models by decreasing noise and sparsity .
-0.15 in [ tbl : binaryaccuracy ] [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] -0.3 in
this paper proposes anatomical pattern analysis ( apa ) framework for decoding visual stimuli in the human brain .
this framework uses an anatomical feature extraction method , which provides a normalized representation for combining homogeneous datasets .
further , a new binary imbalance adaboost algorithm is introduced .
it can increase the performance of prediction by exploiting a supervised random sampling and the correlation between classes .
in addition , this algorithm is utilized in an error - correcting output codes ( ecoc ) method for multi - class prediction of the brain responses .
empirical studies on 4 visual categories clearly show the superiority of our proposed method in comparison with the voxel - based approaches . in future , we plan to apply the proposed method to different brain tasks such as low - level visual stimuli , emotion and etc . -0.1 in
we thank the anonymous reviewers for comments . this work was supported in part by the national natural science foundation of china ( 61422204 and 61473149 ) ,
jiangsu natural science foundation for distinguished young scholar ( bk20130034 ) and nuaa fundamental research funds ( ne2013105 ) . -0.1 in norman , k. a. , polyn , s. m. , detre , g. j. , haxby , j. v. : beyond mind - reading : multi - voxel pattern analysis of fmri data .
trends in cognitive sciences , vol . 10 ( 9 ) , pp .
424430 , 2006 .
haxby , j. v. , connolly , a. c. , guntupalli , j. s. : decoding neural representational spaces using multivariate pattern analysis
. annual review of neuroscience , vol .
37 , pp . 435456 , 2014 .
osher , d. e. , saxe , r. , koldewyn , k. , gabrieli , j. d. e. , kanwisher , n. , saygin , z. m. : structural connectivity fingerprints predict cortical selectivity for multiple visual categories across cortex .
cerebral cortex , vol . 26 ( 4 ) , pp . 16681683 , 2016 .
friston , k. j. , ashburner , j. o. h. n. , heather , j. : statistical parametric mapping .
neuroscience databases : a practical guide , vol . 1 ( 237 ) , pp .
174 , 2003 .
cox , d. , savoy , r. l. : functional magnetic resonance imaging ( fmri ) ` brain reading ' : detecting and classifying distributed patterns of fmri activity in human visual cortex .
neuroimage , vol .
19 ( 2 ) , pp . 261270 , 2003 .
mcmenamin , b. w. , deason , r. g. , steele , v. r. , koutstaal , w. , marsolek , c. j. : separability of abstract - category and specific - exemplar visual object subsystems : evidence from fmri pattern analysis .
brain and cognition , vol .
93 , pp . 5464 , 2015 .
mohr , h. , wolfensteller , u. , frimmel , s. , ruge , h. : sparse regularization techniques provide novel insights into outcome integration processes .
neuroimage , vol .
163176 , 2015 .
escalera , s. , pujol , o. , petia , r. : error - correcting output codes library .
journal of machine learning research , vol .
11 , pp . 661664 , 2010 .
liu , x. y. , wu , j. , zhou , z. h. : exploratory undersampling for class - imbalance learning .
ieee transactions on cybernetics , vol .
39 ( 2 ) , pp . 539550 , 2009 .
jenkinson , m. , bannister , p. , brady , m. , smith , s. : improved optimization for the robust and accurate linear registration and motion correction of brain images .
neuroimage , vol .
17 ( 2 ) , pp . 825841 , 2002 .
duncan , k. j. , pattamadilok , c. , knierim , i. , devlin , j. t. , consistency and variability in functional localisers .
neuroimage , vol .
46 ( 4 ) , pp .
10181026 , 2009 . g. e. rice , d. m. watson , t. hartley , and t. j. andrews : low - level image properties of visual objects predict patterns of neural response across category - selective regions of the ventral visual pathway .
the journal of neuroscience , vol .
26 , pp . 88378844 , 2014 . m. k. carroll , g. a. cecchi , i. rish , r. garg , and a. r. rao , prediction and interpretation of distributed neural activity with sparse models .
neuroimage , vol .
1 , pp . 112122 , 2009 . g. varoquaux , a. gramfort , and b. thirion , small- sample brain mapping : sparse recovery on spatially correlated designs with randomization and clustering .
international conference on machine learning , 2012 . | a universal unanswered question in neuroscience and machine learning is whether computers can decode the patterns of the human brain .
multi - voxels pattern analysis ( mvpa ) is a critical tool for addressing this question .
however , there are two challenges in the previous mvpa methods , which include decreasing sparsity and noises in the extracted features and increasing the performance of prediction . in overcoming mentioned challenges
, this paper proposes anatomical pattern analysis ( apa ) for decoding visual stimuli in the human brain .
this framework develops a novel anatomical feature extraction method and a new imbalance adaboost algorithm for binary classification .
further , it utilizes an error - correcting output codes ( ecoc ) method for multi - class prediction .
apa can automatically detect active regions for each category of the visual stimuli .
moreover , it enables us to combine homogeneous datasets for applying advanced classification .
experimental studies on 4 visual categories ( words , consonants , objects and scrambled photos ) demonstrate that the proposed approach achieves superior performance to state - of - the - art methods . |
the ideas of zero range potential ( zrp ) approach were recently developed to widen limits of the traditional treatment by demkov and ostrovsky @xmath4 and albeverio et al . @xmath5 .
the advantage of the theory is the possibility of obtaining an exact solution of scattering problem .
the zrp is conventionally represented as the boundary condition on the matrix wavefunction at some point .
alternatively , the zrp can be represented as pseudopotential ( breit @xmath6 ) .
on the other hand , darboux transformation ( dt ) allows to construct in natural way exactly solvable potentials .
general starting point of the theory goes up to matveev theorem ( see @xcite ) .
the transformation can be also defined on the base of covariance property of the schrdinger equation with respect to a transformation of wavefunction and potential ( matveev and salle @xmath7 ) .
darboux formulas in multi - dimensional space could be applied in the sense of andrianov , borisov and ioffe ideas @xcite . in the circumstances ,
dt technique can be used so as to correct zrp model .
we attempt to dress the zrp in order to improve the possibilities of the zrp model .
we use notations and some results from @xcite .
dt modifies the generalized zrp ( gzrp ) boundary condition ( section @xmath8 ) and creates a potential with arbitrarily disposed discrete spectrum levels for any angular momentum @xmath9 . in the section @xmath10 we consider @xmath11-representation for a non - spherical potential so as to dress a multi - centered potential , which includes @xmath0 zrps . as an important example , we consider electron scattering by the @xmath1 and @xmath2 structures within the framework of the zrp model ( section @xmath12 ) . in section @xmath13 we present the our calculations for the electron-@xmath3 scattering and discuss them .
let us start from the simplest case of a central field .
then angular momentum operator commutates with hamiltonian and therefore wavefunction @xmath14 can be expanded in the spherical waves @xmath15 where @xmath16 , @xmath17 is initial particle direction , @xmath18 are partial waves , and @xmath19 are phase shifts .
consider the radial schrdinger equation for partial wave with angular momentum @xmath9 .
the atomic units are used throughout the present paper , i.e. @xmath20 and born radius @xmath21 .
@xmath22 @xmath23 @xmath24 denotes differential operator , and @xmath25 are hamiltonian operators of the partial waves .
this equations describe scattering of a particle with energy @xmath26 .
the wavefunctions @xmath18 at infinity have the form @xmath27 let us consider gzrp in coordinate origin .
this potential is conventionally represented as boundary condition on the wavefunction ( see @xmath28 ) @xmath29 where @xmath30 are inverse scattering lengths .
the potential @xmath31 and therefore wavefunctions @xmath18 can be expressed in terms of the spherical functions @xmath32 where spherical functions @xmath33 are related to usual bessel functions as @xmath34 , @xmath35 . in the vicinity of zero they have the asymptotic behavior @xmath36 , and @xmath37 . to substituting the equation @xmath38 into the boundary condition
we obtain the elements of @xmath11-matrix @xmath39 the bound states correspond to the poles of the @xmath11-matrix ( i.e the zeros of the denominator @xmath40 ) , which lie on the imaginary positive semi - axis of the complex @xmath41-plane .
it is obvious that bound state , with orbital momentum @xmath9 , exists only if @xmath42 ( elsewise an antibound state exists ) and has the energy @xmath43 .
thus , spectral problem for gzrp is solved for any value @xmath41 . on the other hand , the equations ( [ e ] )
are covariant with respect to dt that yields the following transformations of the potentials ( coefficients of the operator @xmath25 ) @xmath44 and the wavefunctions @xmath18 @xmath45 where @xmath46 are some solutions of the equations @xmath47 at @xmath48 , and @xmath49 are real parameters , which can be both positive or negative .
the dt @xmath50 combines the solutions @xmath18 and a solution @xmath46 that corresponds to another eigen value @xmath51 . repeating the procedure we obtain a chain of the integrable potentials @xmath52 . in general , dressed potential @xmath53 is real for real function @xmath46 .
the next step in the dressing procedure of the zero - range potential ( @xmath31 ) is a definition of the free parameters of the solutions @xmath46 .
suppose the prop functions @xmath46 satisfy the boundary conditions @xmath54 with @xmath55 .
in the simplest case of @xmath56 we have @xmath57 and @xmath58 the dt @xmath50 gives rise to the following requirement on dressed wavefunction @xmath59 the dressed potential @xmath60 is given by @xmath61 it is regular on semiaxis only if @xmath62 . in the limiting case at @xmath63
we obtain long - range interaction @xmath64 , which can be regular on semiaxis only if @xmath65 .
assuming @xmath66 we get @xmath67 ( trivial transformation ) , and boundary condition can be obtained by the substitution : @xmath68 to dress free wave @xmath69 we obtain zrp at the coordinate origin .
thus , zrp can be also introduced in terms of dt .
to consider transformation with parameter @xmath70 we obtain regular solution @xmath71 and tangent of phase shift is @xmath72 in the other cases asymptotic of the functions @xmath73 at zero is given by @xmath74 it is clear that the each dt introduces short - range core of centrifugal type ( which depends on angular momentum @xmath9 ) in the potential . in this situation
the boundary conditions on the dressed wavefunctions @xmath75 $ ] require modification .
thus , in the case @xmath76 the boundary conditions become @xmath77 and in the case @xmath78 we obtain @xmath79 in the generalized case , zrp with angular momentum @xmath9 generates also @xmath80 complex poles of the @xmath11-matrix , which correspond the quasi - stationary states ( resonances ) .
the dts @xmath50 with the parameters @xmath49 results in the @xmath11-matrix elements for dressed gzrp @xmath81 we can use darboux transformation in order to add ( or remove ) poles of the @xmath11-matrix .
the principal observation allows to built a zero - range potential eigen function in the multi - center problem .
let us consider @xmath0 zrps at the points @xmath82 and interaction @xmath83 .
the wavefunction @xmath14 can be expressed in terms of the ( outgoing - wave ) green function , defined by the equation @xmath84 the second ( ingoing - wave ) green function is defined by @xmath85 .
the partial waves @xmath86 , defined by @xmath87 for multi - centered target which includes @xmath0 zrps and interaction @xmath83 can be expressed as a superposition of the green functions @xmath88 in which @xmath89 are phase shifts , @xmath90 denote @xmath11-matrix orthonormal eigenfunctions , @xmath91 are real numbers .
they naturally generalize the spherical partial waves @xmath92 for a non - spherical potential @xmath93 . expanding the partial waves @xmath86 at the infinity we obtain the expressions for @xmath90 @xmath94 where @xmath95 is wavefunction for potential @xmath83 , and @xmath96 is scattering amplitude .
scattering amplitude for potential @xmath83 and @xmath0 zrp is given by @xmath97 by the imposition of the boundary conditions @xmath54 the calculation of the partial waves is reduced to the solution of the following system @xmath98 in which we use @xmath99 where @xmath100 , @xmath101 .
the tangents @xmath102 can be found from compatibility condition of this system . in simplest case @xmath103
@xmath104 the system @xmath105 is reduced to the usual equations of zrp theory @xmath93 . in order to construct functions
@xmath106 and @xmath107 for dressed potential , i.e. for @xmath83 , we need to write down green function as single - center expansion over spherical harmonics . in the simplest case ,
when the prop function is @xmath108 , the green function is given by @xmath109 where @xmath110 the function @xmath111 has the following asymptotic at infinity @xmath112 the integral cross section can be readily derived using the optical theorem : @xmath113 thus , averaged integral cross section is given by @xmath114
for purpose of illustration we consider scattering problem for a dressed multi - center potential .
the multi - center scattering within the framework of the zrp model was investigated by demkov and rudakov @xmath93 ( 8 centers , cube ) , drukarev and yurova @xmath116 ( 3 centers in line ) , szmytkowski @xmath117 ( 4 centers , regular tetrahedron ) .
let structure @xmath1 contains @xmath0 identical scatterers , which involve only @xmath119 waves .
denote position vector of the scatterer @xmath120 by the @xmath121 .
suppose , for the sake of simplicity , the distance between any two scatterers @xmath122 and @xmath120 is @xmath123 .
there are three such structures in three - dimensional space - dome @xmath124 , regular trihedron @xmath125 , regular tetrahedron @xmath126 .
the partial waves @xmath127 and phases @xmath89 can be classified with respect to symmetry group representation , degeneracy being defined by the dimension of the representation @xmath93 .
the structures @xmath124 , @xmath125 , @xmath126 belong to the @xmath128 point groups respectively .
the equation @xmath105 leads to algebraical problem @xmath129 the phases can be readily found from compatibility condition of this system . to factorize the determinant we derive the expressions for the phases @xmath130 @xmath131 thus , assuming @xmath132 we obtain the phases of a regular tetrahedron @xmath117 .
the partial and integral cross sections can be expressed as @xmath133 the structures @xmath2 can be used , for instance , to study a slow electron scattering by the polyatomic molecules like @xmath135 , @xmath136 , @xmath137 , etc .
let @xmath138 denote the position vectors of the scatterers @xmath139 and @xmath140 denotes the position vector of the scatterer @xmath141 .
the scatterers @xmath139 are situated in vertices of a regular structure @xmath1 , i.e. @xmath123 . suppose , for the sake of simplicity , the distance between the scatterer @xmath141 and any scatterer @xmath139 is @xmath142 .
therefore the position of the scatterer @xmath141 perfectly fixed only if @xmath132 ( geometric center of the tetrahedron , @xmath143 ) .
the partial waves are given by the equation @xmath127 , where the summation should be performed over the @xmath144 .
the constants @xmath91 and phases can be derived analytically .
thus , we obtain the phases @xmath145 where @xmath146 is inverse scattering length of the scatterers @xmath139 .
the @xmath147 obey the quadratic equation @xmath148 where @xmath149 indicates inverse scattering length of the scatterer @xmath141 . in the limiting case when the distance between @xmath139 and @xmath141 scatterers is very large ,
i.e. @xmath150 , the expression for @xmath151 becomes @xmath152 and @xmath153 .
this situation corresponds to independent scattering on the structure @xmath1 and scatterer @xmath141 .
the tangent of @xmath154 also reduces to @xmath155 for structure @xmath1 in the limit @xmath156 .
the integral cross sections for @xmath3 ( closed - shell ground - state @xmath157 ) are plotted in fig .
@xmath158 for a number of values of @xmath159 , which are regarded as constant in the range of interest .
the present calculations were carried out with @xmath160 .
our calculations were made within the framework of the zrp model and hence they are not expected to be correct for low impact energies ( i.e for energies @xmath161 ev ) where polarization effects ( @xmath3 spherical polarizability @xmath162 ) are known to be important . because induced polarization potentials are always attractive , including polarization algebraically increases the computed phases ( @xmath163 at @xmath164 ) and therefore decreases the integral cross section .
thus , fig .
@xmath158 clearly shows that polarization effects reproduce the deep minimum ( ramsauer - townsend minimum near @xmath165 ev ) seen in the experimental data @xmath166 and numerical calculations @xmath167 , which are incomparably smaller in the our calculations .
the ics can be corrected by the zrps dressing .
fig . @xmath168
show ics for dressed @xmath169 structure . in our calculation , the parameters @xmath170 , @xmath171 were used . in the higher collision energies our cross section ( fig .
@xmath158 ) differs from the experimental results in size but coincides in shape .
it is known that role of the higher partial waves is important at the higher collision energies . thus , taking into consideration the @xmath172 waves for the scatterers @xmath139 and @xmath141 we can add in partial waves and improve the agreement both in size at the higher energies and in the position of shape resonance .
we demonstrate the posibilities of dt in multi - center scattering problem .
thus , these transformations allow to correct the zrp model at low energies . in the limiting case @xmath63
dt induces the long - range forces @xmath173 depending on angular momentum and leads to singularity in the cross section at zero energy .
albeverio s , gesztesy f , hegh - krohn r and holden h ( 1988 ) solvable models in quantum mechanics , springer - verlag , new york breit g ( 1947 ) phys .
71:215 matveev v b ( 1979 ) lett .
3:213 matveev v b , salle m a ( 1991 ) darboux transformations and solitons , springer , new york andrianov a , borisov n , ioffe m ( 1984 ) phys .
a 105:19 - 22 baltenkov a s ( 2000 ) phys .
a 286:92 - 99 szmytkowski r , szmytkowski c ( 1999 ) j. math . chem .
26:243 - 254 wan h x , moore j h , tossel j a ( 1989 ) j. chem .
91:1340 zaitsev a , leble s ( 1999 ) preprint 12.01.1999 math - ph/9903005 ; ( 2000 ) romp 46:155 | a dressing of a nonspherical potential , which includes @xmath0 zero range potentials , is considered .
the dressing technique is used to improve zrp model .
concepts of the partial waves and partial phases for non - spherical potential are used in order to perform darboux transformation .
the problem of scattering on the regular @xmath1 and @xmath2 structures is studied .
the possibilities of dressed zrp are illustrated by model calculation of the low - energy electron - silane ( @xmath3 ) scattering .
the results are discussed . |
cellular automata with complex behavior exhibit dynamical patterns that can be interpreted as the movement of particles through a physical medium .
these particles are interpretable as loci for information storage , and their movement through space is interpretable as information transfer .
the collisions of these particles in the cellular automaton s lattice are sites of information processing @xcite .
cellular automata with complex behavior have immense potential to describe physical systems and their study has had impact in the design of self - assembling structures @xcite and the modelling of biological processes like signaling , division , apoptosis , necrosis and differentiation @xcite .
john conway s game of life @xcite is the most renowned complex binary cellular automaton , and the archetype used to guide the search methodology for other complex binary cellular automata that we describe in this work .
previously , complex behavior in binary cellular automata has been characterized through measures such as entropy @xcite , lyapunov exponents @xcite , and kolmogorov - chaitin complexity @xcite .
we propose the characterization of the behavior of @xmath0-dimensional cellular automata through heuristic measures derived from the evaluation of their minimal boolean forms .
this proposed characterization is derived from heuristic criteria validated in elementary cellular automata with simple boolean forms .
table [ table : ca - boolean - behavior ] illustrates the rationale for this characterization showing elementary cellular automata whose boolean forms are minimally simple , and whose behavior can be unequivocally identified .
cellular behaviors of growth , decrease , and chaoticity are characterized by the boolean operations _ or _ , _ and _ , and _ xor _ , respectively .
the cellular behavior of stability can be characterized by the absence of a boolean operator or the use of the _ not _ operator .
we define an evaluation criterion to produce metrics that characterize the behavior of cellular automata whose minimal boolean expressions are more complex ( i.e. have more terms and the combination of various operators ) than those appearing in table [ table : ca - boolean - behavior ] .
the produced metrics are used to create static and dynamic measures of behavior .
the static measure of behavior is calculated from the truth table of the minimal boolean expression of the cellular automaton , and the dynamic measure of behavior is derived from the averaged appearance of the metrics in _
n _ executions of the cellular automaton from _
n _ random initial conditions .
we use the euclidean distance of these measures in a given cellular automaton to the measures of the game of life to assess its capacity for complex behavior , and use this distance as a cost function to guide the genetic search of @xmath0-dimensional cellular automata with complex behavior .
a cellular automaton is formally represented by a quadruple @xmath1 , where * @xmath2 is the finite or infinite cell lattice , * @xmath3 is a finite set of states or values for the cells , * @xmath4 is the finite cell neighborhood , * @xmath5 is the local transition function , defined by the state transition rule .
each cell in the lattice @xmath2 is defined by its discrete position ( an integer number for each dimension ) and by its discrete state value @xmath3 . in a binary cellular automaton , @xmath6 .
time is also discrete .
the state of the cell is determined by the evaluation of the local transition function on the cell s neighborhood at time @xmath7 ; @xmath8 is the next time step after time @xmath7 .
the neighborhood is defined as a finite group of cells surrounding and/or including the observed cell .
the global state is the configuration of all the cells that comprise the automaton , @xmath9 .
the lattice @xmath2 is the infinite cyclic group of integers @xmath10 .
the position of each cell in the lattice is described by the index position @xmath11 .
configurations are commonly written as sequences of characters , such as @xmath12 the finite global state is a finite configuration @xmath9 , where @xmath2 is a finite lattice , indexed with @xmath13 integers , @xmath14 the set of neighborhood indices @xmath15 of size @xmath16 is defined by the set of relative positions within the configuration , such that @xmath17 @xmath18 is the neighborhood of the observed cell @xmath19 that includes the set @xmath15 of indices , and is defined as @xmath20 this describes the neighborhood as a character string that includes the cells that are considered neighbors of the observed cell @xmath21 . a compact representation of the neighborhood value @xmath18 is a unique integer , defined as an @xmath22digits , @xmath23based number [ 2 ] @xmath24 the local transition function @xmath5 yields the value of @xmath19 at @xmath25 from the neighborhood of the cell observed at present time @xmath7 is expressed by @xmath26 where @xmath27 specifies the states of the neighboring cells to the cell @xmath21 at time @xmath7 .
the transition table defines the local transition function , listing an output value for each input configuration .
table [ table : tran - function - truth - table ] is a sample transition table for an elementary cellular automaton with a neighborhood of radius 1 , wherein adjacent neighboring cells of @xmath19 are @xmath28 and @xmath29 , forming a tuple @xmath30 , @xmath31 .
.local transition function of @xmath32 as a truth table .
[ cols="^,^",options="header " , ] c + averaged spacetime evolution + + + identified glider +
we wish to thank jan baetens , hector zenil , alyssa adams , and nima dehghani for their helpful comments .
we appreciate the support of the physics and mathematics in biomedicine consortium .
we also wish to thank todd rowland for his encouragement and continued interest in the project h. abelson , d. allen , d. coore , c. hanson , e. rauch , g. j. sussman , g. homsy , j. thomas f. knight and r. w. radhika nagpal , `` amorphous computing , '' _ communications of the acm _ , * 43*(5 ) , 2000 , pp .
74 - 82 .
m. hirabayashi , s. kinoshita , s. tanaka , h. honda , h. kojima and k. oiwa , `` cellular automata analysis on self - assembly properties in dna tile computing , '' _ lecture notes in computer science _
, * 7495 * , 2012 , pp .
544 - 553 .
m. hwang , m. garbey , s. a. berceli and r. tran - son - tay , `` rule - based simulation of multi - cellular biological systems a review of modeling techniques , '' _ cellular and molecular bioengineering _
, * 2*(3 ) , 2009 , pp .
285 - 294 . | we propose the characterization of binary cellular automata using a set of behavioral metrics that are applied to the minimal boolean form of a cellular automaton s transition function .
these behavioral metrics are formulated to satisfy heuristic criteria derived from elementary cellular automata .
behaviors characterized through these metrics are growth , decrease , chaoticity , and stability . from these metrics ,
two measures of global behavior are calculated : 1 ) a static measure that considers all possible input patterns and counts the occurrence of the proposed metrics in the truth table of the minimal boolean form of the automaton ; 2 ) a dynamic measure , corresponding to the mean of the behavioral metrics in _
n _ executions of the automaton , starting from _
n _ random initial states .
we use these measures to characterize a cellular automaton and guide a genetic search algorithm , which selects cellular automata similar to the game of life . using this method
, we found an extensive set of complex binary cellular automata with interesting properties , including self - replication . |
the concept of logical depth was introduced by c. bennett @xcite to differentiate useful information ( such as dna ) from the rest , with the key observation that non - useful information pertains in both very simple structures ( for example , a crystal ) and completely unstructured data ( for example , a random sequence , a gas ) .
bennett calls data containing useful information logically deep data , whereas both trivial structures and fully random data are called shallow .
the notion of useful information ( as defined by logical depth ) strongly contrasts with classical information theory , which views random data as having high information content .
i.e. , according to classical information theory , a random noise signal contains maximal information , whereas from the logical depth point of view , such a signal contains very little useful information .
bennett s logical depth notion is based on kolmogorov complexity .
intuitively a logically deep sequence ( or equivalently a set ) is one for which the more time a compressor is given , the better it can compress the sequence .
for example , both on trivial and random sequences , even when given more time , a compressor can not achieve a better compression ratio .
hence trivial and random sequences are not logically deep . several variants of logical depth have been studied in the past @xcite . as shown in @xcite , all depth notions proposed so far
can be interpreted in the compression framework which says a sequence is deep if given ( arbitrarily ) more than @xmath10 time steps , a compressor can compress the sequence @xmath6 more bits than if given at most @xmath10 time steps only . by considering different time bound families for @xmath10 ( e.g. recursive , polynomial time etc . ) and the magnitude of compression improvement @xmath6 - for short : the _ depth magnitude _ - ( e.g. @xmath11 ) one can capture all existing depth notions @xcite in the compression framework @xcite . e.g. bennett s notion is obtained by considering all recursive time bounds @xmath12 and a constant depth magnitude , i.e. , @xmath13 .
several authors studied variants of bennett s notion , by considering different time bounds and/or different depth magnitude from bennett s original notion @xcite . in this paper
, we study the consequences these changes of different parameters in bennett s depth notion entail , by investigating the computational power of the deep sets yielded by each of these depth variants . *
we found out that the choice of the depth magnitude has consequences on the computational power of the corresponding deep sets .
the fact that computational power implies bennett depth was noticed in @xcite , where it was shown that every high degree contains a bennett deep set ( a set is high if , when given as an oracle , its halting problem is at least as powerful as the halting problem relative to the halting problem : @xmath14 is high iff @xmath15 ) .
we show that the converse also holds , i.e. , that depth implies computational power , by proving that if the depth magnitude is chosen to be `` large '' ( i.e. , @xmath7 ) , then depth coincides with highness ( on the turing degrees ) , i.e. , a turing degree is high iff it contains a deep set of magnitude @xmath7 . * for smaller choices of @xmath5 , for example ,
if @xmath5 is any recursive order function , depth still retains some computational power : we show that depth implies either highness or diagonally - non - recursiveness , denoted dnr ( a total function is dnr if its image on input @xmath16 is different from the output of the @xmath16-th turing machine on input @xmath16 ) .
this implies that if we restrict ourselves to left - r.e .
sets , recursive order depth already implies highness . we also show that highness is not necessary by constructing a low order - deep set ( a set is low if it is not powerful when given as an oracle ) .
* as a corollary , our results imply that weakly - useful sets introduced in @xcite are either high or dnr ( set @xmath17 is weakly - useful if the class of sets reducible to it within a fixed time bound @xmath18 does not have measure zero within the class of recursive sets ) .
* bennett s depth @xcite is defined using prefix - free kolmogorov complexity .
two key properties of bennett s notion are the so - called slow growth law , which stipulates that no shallow set can quickly ( truth - table ) compute a deep set , and the fact that neither martin - lf random nor recursive sets are deep .
it is natural to ask whether replacing prefix - free with plain complexity in bennett s formulation yields a meaningful depth notion .
we call this notion plain - depth .
we show that the random is not deep paradigm also holds in the setting of plain - depth . on the other hand
we show that the slow growth law fails for plain - depth : every many - one degree contains a set which is not plain - deep of magnitude @xmath19 . *
a key property of depth is that `` easy '' sets should not be deep .
bennett @xcite showed that no recursive set is deep .
we give an improvement to this result by observing that no @xmath4-trivial set is deep ( a set is @xmath4-trivial if the complexity of its prefixes is as low as possible ) .
our result is close to optimal , since there exist deep ultracompressible sets @xcite . * in most depth notions , the depth magnitude has to be achieved almost everywhere on the set .
some feasible depth notions also considered an infinitely often version @xcite .
bennett noticed in @xcite that infinitely often depth is meaningless because every recursive set is infinitely often deep .
we propose an alternative infinitely often depth notion that does nt suffer this limitation ( called i.o .
we show that little computational power is needed to compute i.o .
depth , i.e. , every hyperimmune degree contains an i.o .
deep set of magnitude @xmath8 ( a degree is hyperimmune if it computes a function that is not bounded almost everywhere by any recursive function ) , and construct a @xmath9-class where every member is an i.o .
deep set of magnitude @xmath8 .
for hyperimmune - free sets we prove that every non - recursive , non - dnr hyperimmune - free set is i.o .
deep of constant magnitude , and that every nonrecursive many - one degree contains such a set . in summary ,
our results show that the choice of the magnitude for logical depth has consequences on the computational power of the corresponding deep sets , and that larger depth magnitude is not necessarily preferable over smaller magnitude .
we conclude with a few open questions regarding the constant magnitude case .
due to lack of space , some proofs are ommitted and will appear in the journal version of this paper .
we use standard computability / algorithmic randomness theory notations see @xcite
. we use @xmath20 to denote less or equal up to a constant term .
we fix a recursive 1 - 1 pairing function @xmath21 .
we use sets and their characteristic sequences interchangeably , we denote the binary strings of length @xmath22 by @xmath23 and @xmath24 denotes the set of all infinite binary sequences .
the join of two sets @xmath25 is the set @xmath26 whose characteristic sequence is @xmath27 , that is , @xmath28 and @xmath29 for all @xmath22 .
an order function is an unbounded non - decreasing function from @xmath30 to @xmath30 . a time bound function is a recursive order @xmath12 such that there exists a turing machine @xmath31 such that for every @xmath22 , @xmath32\!\downarrow\ , = t(n)$ ] , i.e. , @xmath33 outputs the value @xmath10 within @xmath10 steps of computation .
set @xmath14 is left - r.e .
iff the set of dyadic rationals strictly below the real number @xmath34 ( a.k.a .
the left - cut of @xmath14 denoted @xmath35 ) is recursively enumerable ( r.e . ) , i.e. , there is a recursive sequence of non - decreasing rationals whose limit is @xmath34 .
all r.e .
sets are left - r.e . , but the converse fails .
we consider standard turing reductions @xmath36 , truth - table reductions @xmath37 ( where all queries are made in advance and the reduction is total on all oracles ) and many - one reductions @xmath38 .
two sets @xmath25 are turing equivalent ( @xmath39 ) if @xmath40 and @xmath41 . the turing degree of a set @xmath14 is the set of sets turing equivalent to @xmath14
. we fix a standard enumeration of all oracle turing machines @xmath42 ; the jump @xmath43 of a set @xmath14 is the halting problem relative to @xmath14 , i.e. , @xmath44 . the halting problem is denoted @xmath45 . a set @xmath14 is high ( that is , has high turing degree ) if its halting problem is as powerful as the halting problem of the halting problem , i.e. , @xmath46 .
high sets are equivalent to sets that compute dominating functions ( i.e. , sets @xmath14 such that there is a function @xmath47 with @xmath48 such that for every computable function @xmath49 and for almost every @xmath22 , @xmath50 ) , i.e. , a set is high iff it computes a dominating function @xcite .
a set @xmath14 is low if its halting problem is not more powerful than the halting problem of a recursive set , i.e. , @xmath51 .
note that @xmath45 is high relative to every low set .
if one weakens the dominating property of high sets to an infinitely often condition , one obtains hyperimmune degrees .
a set is of hyperimmune degree if it computes a function that dominates every recursive function on infinitely many inputs .
otherwise the set is called of hyperimmune - free degree .
another characterization of computational power used in computability theory is the concept of diagonally non - recursive function ( dnr ) .
a total function @xmath49 is dnr if for every @xmath16 , @xmath52 , i.e. , @xmath49 can avoid the output of every turing machine on at least one specified input .
a set is of dnr degree , if it computes a dnr function .
it is known that every r.e .
dnr degree is high , actually even turing equivalent to @xmath45 @xcite .
if one requires a dnr function to be boolean , one obtains the pa - complete degrees : a degree is pa - complete iff it computes a boolean dnr function .
it is known that there exists low pa - complete degrees @xcite .
fix a universal prefix free turing machine @xmath53 , i.e. , such that no halting program of @xmath53 is a prefix of another halting program .
the prefix - free kolmogorov complexity of string @xmath54 , denoted @xmath55 , is the length of the length - lexicographically first program @xmath56 such that @xmath53 on input @xmath56 outputs @xmath54 .
it can be shown that the value of @xmath55 does not depend on the choice of @xmath53 up to an additive constant .
@xmath57 is the length of a shortest program that outputs the pair @xmath58 , and @xmath59 is the length of a shortest program such that @xmath53 outputs @xmath54 when given @xmath60 as an advice .
we also consider standard time bounded kolmogorov complexity .
given time bound @xmath12 ( resp .
@xmath61 ) , @xmath62 ( resp .
@xmath63 ) denotes the length of the shortest prefix free program @xmath64 such that @xmath65 outputs @xmath54 within @xmath66 ( resp .
@xmath18 ) steps .
replacing @xmath53 above with a plain ( i.e. , non prefix - free ) universal turing machine yields the notion of plain kolmogorov complexity , and is denoted @xmath67 .
we need the following counting theorem .
[ t : counting ] there exists @xmath68 such that for every @xmath69 , @xmath70 .
a set @xmath14 is martin - lf random ( mlr ) if none of its prefixes are compressible by more than a constant term , i.e. , @xmath71 for some constant @xmath72 , where @xmath73 denotes the first @xmath22 bits of the characteristic function of @xmath14 .
a set @xmath14 is @xmath4-trivial if its complexity is as low as possible , i.e. , @xmath74 .
see the books of downey and hirschfeldt @xcite and nies @xcite for more on @xmath75 and @xmath4-complexity , mlr and trivial sets .
effective closed sets are captured by @xmath9-classes .
a @xmath9-class @xmath76 is a class of sequences such that there is a computable relation @xmath77 such that @xmath78 .
let @xmath79 be an order .
a set @xmath17 is @xmath80 if for every recursive time bound @xmath12 and for almost all @xmath81 , @xmath82 .
a set @xmath17 is @xmath0 ( resp .
order@xmath2 ) if it is @xmath83 ( resp .
@xmath80 ) for every @xmath84 ( resp . for some recursive order @xmath49 ) .
a set is said bennett deep if it is @xmath0 .
we denote by @xmath85 the above notions with @xmath4 replaced with @xmath75 .
it is easy to see that for every two orders @xmath86 such that @xmath87 , every @xmath80 set is also @xmath88 .
bennett s slow growth law ( sgl ) states that creating depth requires time beyond a `` recursive amount '' , i.e. , no shallow set quickly computes a deep one .
[ l.sgl ] let @xmath89 be a recursive order , and @xmath90 be two sets . if @xmath14 is @xmath91 ( resp .
@xmath92 ) then @xmath93 is @xmath94 ( resp .
@xmath92 ) for some recursive order @xmath95 .
furthermore given indices for the truth - table reduction and for @xmath89 , one can effectively compute an index for @xmath95 .
the symmetry of information holds in the resource bounded case .
[ l.sym.inform .
] for every time bound @xmath12 , there is a time bound @xmath96 such that for all strings @xmath97 with @xmath98 , we have @xmath99 . furthermore given an index for @xmath12 one can effectively compute an index for @xmath96 .
[ c.sym.inform .
] let @xmath12 be a time bound and @xmath100 be strings .
then there exists a time bound @xmath96 such that for every prefix @xmath60 of @xmath54 we have latexmath:[$c^t(y \ | \
a ) \geq^+ c^{t'}(x \ index for @xmath12 one can effectively compute an index for @xmath96 .
given @xmath64 a @xmath102-minimal program with advice @xmath103 for @xmath60 , @xmath104 remaining bits , and a delimiter after @xmath64 , one can reconstruct @xmath54 in time @xmath105 steps given a. thus @xmath106 .
bennett s original formulation @xcite is based on @xmath4-complexity . in this section
we investigate the depth notion obtained by replacing @xmath4 with @xmath75 , which we call plain depth .
we study the interactions of plain depth with the notions of martin - lf random sets , many - one degrees and the turing degrees of deep sets .
the following result is the plain complexity version of bennett s result that no mlr sets are bennett deep . due to lack of space
, the proof will appear in the journal version of this paper . a direct proof is given , though this result is also a corollary of theorem [ t : hdeepc - is - hdeepk ] . [ mlrdeepc ] for every mlr @xmath14 and for every recursive order @xmath89 , @xmath14 is not @xmath107 .
suppose by contradiction that set @xmath14 is mlr and @xmath107 , for some @xmath89 as above .
we claim that @xmath108 .
to prove the claim , let @xmath109 .
then given @xmath110 with @xmath111 , the program @xmath64 : `` print the smallest @xmath112 such that @xmath113 . ''
is a program for @xmath22 of size @xmath114 , i.e. , @xmath115 suppose @xmath116 is a @xmath75-minimal program for @xmath73 of size @xmath117 , then appending @xmath118 bits to @xmath116 yields a prefix free program @xmath119 for @xmath73 of size @xmath120 . since @xmath14 is mlr we have @xmath121 , i.e. , @xmath122 which implies @xmath123 ( for @xmath124 sufficiently large ) .
if @xmath111 , then @xmath125 , thus @xmath126 , i.e. , @xmath127 , which proves the claim .
since for all @xmath81 we have @xmath128 ( via a `` print '' program ) , it follows that for every @xmath111 , @xmath129 which contradicts that @xmath14 is @xmath107 .
sequences that are mlr relative to the halting problem are called @xmath130-random .
equivalently a sequence @xmath14 is @xmath130-random iff there is a constant @xmath72 such that @xmath131 for infinitely many @xmath22 @xcite . since there is a constant @xmath132 such that @xmath133 is a trivial upper bound on the plain kolmogorov complexity of any string of length @xmath22 , it is clear that no @xmath130-random sequence can be @xmath1 . thus most mlr sequences are not @xmath1 .
the following result shows that the slow growth law fails for plain depth .
due to lack of space , the proof will appear in the journal version of this paper .
[ t : manyone - deg - deepc ] every many - one degree contains a set which is not @xmath134 .
the recursive many - one degrees consist only of sets which are not @xmath134 .
so consider any set @xmath14 different from both @xmath135 and @xmath30 and let @xmath136 .
given any @xmath137 , choose @xmath138 and let @xmath22 be any number between @xmath139 and @xmath140 which has @xmath75-complexity @xmath124 .
now on one hand @xmath141 and on the other hand , one can compute @xmath124 from the @xmath124-digit binary number representing @xmath22 and one can compute @xmath142 from @xmath124 and using @xmath143 one can compute @xmath144 from the binary representation of @xmath22 and its length @xmath124 so that @xmath145 for some time bound @xmath12 and some constant @xmath72 independent of @xmath22 and @xmath124 .
this shows that @xmath14 is not @xmath134 .
clearly @xmath146 .
furthermore , @xmath147 by mapping all values of form @xmath148 to @xmath64 and all other values to a fixed non - element of @xmath14 .
note that this result shows that order@xmath2 does not imply order@xmath3 : all the sets in the truth - table degree of any order@xmath2 set are all order@xmath2 ( by the sgl ) , but this degree contains a non order@xmath3 set by the previous result .
however , the converse is true , every order@xmath3 set is order@xmath2 .
[ t : hdeepc - is - hdeepk ] if @xmath14 is @xmath149 for some recursive order @xmath89 then @xmath14 is also @xmath150 for some recursive order @xmath95 .
there is a recursive sequence @xmath151 of numbers such that @xmath152 ( up to some constant ) ; for example one can take @xmath153 .
furthermore , assume that some time - bounded version @xmath154 is given .
then , for every @xmath137 and every @xmath155 , @xmath156 up to a constant .
now for @xmath137 and each @xmath155 , let @xmath157 and note that these @xmath158 sum up to a number below @xmath159 , hence there is a prefix - free machine @xmath53 with recursive domain such that @xmath160 for all @xmath161 whose length is some @xmath162 .
as this is a recursive measure which can be evaluated with some time - bound @xmath96 , there is a constant @xmath72 such that for almost all prefixes @xmath161 of @xmath14 of some length @xmath162 , @xmath163 and thus @xmath164 .
one can therefore construct a new prefix - free machine @xmath165 where one redistributes , for those @xmath161 of length @xmath162 where @xmath164 , the weight back to the @xmath166 with @xmath167 and obtains that @xmath168 , where @xmath132 is again a constant independent of the @xmath161 and @xmath162 considered .
since this step will be taken for almost all prefixes of @xmath14 and as @xmath169 can be translated into @xmath4 with a constant off - set , one has for almost all @xmath22 that @xmath170 where @xmath171 it can easily be seen that @xmath95 is a recursive order and that taking @xmath172 in place of @xmath173 allows to absorb , for almost all @xmath22 , the various constants .
the following result shows that being constant deep for @xmath75 implies computational power .
[ t.deep.high.or.dnc ] let @xmath14 be an @xmath134 set .
then @xmath14 is high or dnr .
we prove the contrapositive .
suppose that @xmath14 is neither dnr nor high .
let @xmath174 be ( a coding of ) @xmath175 .
because @xmath176 , there are infinitely many @xmath124 where @xmath177 is defined and equal to @xmath174 .
hence there is an @xmath14-recursive increasing function @xmath49 such that , for almost every @xmath124 , @xmath178 is the time to find an @xmath179 with @xmath180 and to evaluate the expression @xmath181 to verify the finding . as @xmath14 is not high
, there is a recursive increasing function @xmath89 with @xmath182 for infinitely many @xmath124 .
now consider any @xmath124 where @xmath182 .
then for the @xmath183 found for this @xmath124 , it holds that @xmath184 and @xmath185 is also larger than the time to evaluate @xmath181 .
hence @xmath186 is larger than the time to evaluate @xmath177 for infinitely many @xmath124 where @xmath177 codes @xmath175 . for each such @xmath124
, let @xmath22 be a number with @xmath187 and @xmath188 . starting with a binary description of such an @xmath22
, one can compute @xmath124 from @xmath22 and run @xmath177 for @xmath186 steps and , in the case that this terminates with a string @xmath161 of length @xmath140 , output @xmath189 .
it follows from this algorithm that there is a resource - bounded approximation to @xmath75 such that there exist infinitely many @xmath22 such that , on one hand @xmath190 while on the other hand @xmath191 can be described in @xmath192 bits using this resource bounded description .
hence @xmath14 is not @xmath134 . since there are incomplete r.e .
turing degrees which are high , these are also not dnr and , by theorem [ t.high.iff.deep ] , they contain sets which are @xmath193 . thus the preceeding theorem can not be improved to show that `` @xmath1 sets are dnr '' .
[ t : deep - not - dnr ] there exists a set @xmath14 such that @xmath14 is @xmath194 ( for any @xmath195 ) but @xmath14 is not dnr .
there is a degree which is high but not dnr @xcite .
thus we can , by theorem [ t.high.iff.deep ] , select a set @xmath14 in this degree which is @xmath194 for every @xmath196 .
bennett s original depth notion is based on prefix free complexity .
he made important connections between depth and truth - table degrees ; in particular he proved that the @xmath0 sets are closed upward under truth - table reducibility , which he called the slow growth law . in the following section we pursue bennett s investigation by studying the turing degrees of deep sets . in the first subsection
, we investigate the connections between linear depth and high turing degrees .
we then look at the opposite end by studying the interactions of various lowness notions with logical depth .
the following result shows that at depth magnitude @xmath8 , depth and highness coincide on the turing degrees .
the result holds for both @xmath4 and @xmath75 depth .
[ t.high.iff.deep ] for every set @xmath14 the following statements are equivalent : 1 .
the degree of @xmath14 is @xmath197 for some @xmath198 .
the degree of @xmath14 is @xmath194 for every @xmath195 .
@xmath14 is high .
we prove @xmath199 using the contrapositive : let @xmath200 and @xmath201 such that @xmath202 with @xmath203 .
let @xmath137 be the limit inferior of the set @xmath204 such that there are infinitely many @xmath22 with @xmath205 .
now one can define , relative to @xmath14 , an @xmath14-recursive function @xmath49 such that for each @xmath22 there is an @xmath124 with @xmath206 and @xmath207 . as @xmath14 is not high , there is a recursive function @xmath89 with @xmath208 for infinitely many @xmath22 ; furthermore , @xmath209 for all @xmath22 .
it follows that there are infinitely many @xmath22 with @xmath210 which is also at most @xmath211 away from the optimal value , hence @xmath14 is not @xmath212 deep , which ends this direction s proof .
let us show @xmath213 .
let @xmath198 , @xmath14 be high , and let @xmath214 be dominating .
we construct @xmath215 such that @xmath93 is @xmath194 . by definition , if @xmath12 is a time bound and @xmath112 an index of @xmath12 then for every @xmath216 @xmath217\!\downarrow\ , = t(m)$ ] .
since @xmath49 is dominating , we have for almost every @xmath216 , @xmath218\!\downarrow$ ] .
we can thus use @xmath49 to encode all time bounds that are total on all strings of length less than a certain bound into a set @xmath219 , where _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ @xmath220 iff @xmath221\!\downarrow$ ] for all @xmath222 .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ thus @xmath12 is a ( total ) time bound iff for almost every @xmath223 , @xmath224 ( where @xmath112 is an index for @xmath12 ) .
we have @xmath225 and we choose the pairing function @xmath226 such that @xmath227 encodes the values @xmath228 let @xmath81 and suppose @xmath229 is already constructed .
given @xmath230 and @xmath227 , we construct @xmath231 . from @xmath227 , we can compute the set @xmath232 , i.e. , a list eventually containing all time bounds that are total on strings of lengths less or equal to @xmath233 .
let @xmath234 find the lex first string @xmath235 of length @xmath236 such that @xmath237 let @xmath238 : = a(n ) x_n.$ ] by construction we have @xmath215 . also , @xmath239 , i.e. , @xmath240 .
let us prove @xmath93 is @xmath241 ; we then extend the argument to show @xmath93 is @xmath194 .
let @xmath12 be a time bound .
let @xmath22 be large enough such that @xmath242 and @xmath243 where the @xmath244 s are derived from @xmath12 as described below .
let @xmath223 be such that @xmath245 and @xmath246 , i.e. , @xmath247 ends with the first @xmath248 bits of @xmath235 ( one bit is `` lost '' due to the first bit used to encode @xmath249 ) .
we consider two cases , first suppose @xmath250 .
let @xmath251 be a time bound ( obtained from @xmath12 ) such that @xmath252 , where neither the constant nor @xmath251 depends on @xmath253 .
let @xmath254 be derived from @xmath251 using lemma [ l.sym.inform . ] .
we have @xmath255 for the second case , suppose @xmath256 .
we have @xmath257 note that each iteration of the argument above yields a @xmath258 term ( @xmath259 ) , therefore for any @xmath195 , there is a number @xmath260 of iterations , such that @xmath93 can be shown @xmath194 , for all @xmath22 large enough such that @xmath261 .
[ c : kalso - holds ] theorem [ t.high.iff.deep ] also holds for @xmath4-depth . because every set @xmath14 is @xmath197 ( for some @xmath262 ) iff it is @xmath263 for some @xmath264 , since for every @xmath54 , @xmath265 .
an analogue of theorem [ t.deep.high.or.dnc ] holds for @xmath4 .
[ t.deep.high.or.dnc.k ] let @xmath14 be a @xmath266 set for some recursive order @xmath89 .
then @xmath14 is high or dnr .
we prove the contrapositive .
suppose that @xmath14 is neither dnr nor high .
let @xmath174 be ( a coding of ) @xmath267 , where @xmath268 .
the rest of the proof follows the proof of theorem [ t.deep.high.or.dnc ] , with @xmath139 replaced with @xmath269 .
as a corollary , we show that in the left - r.e .
case , depth always implies highness .
[ c : l - re - then - high ] if @xmath14 is left - r.e . and @xmath266 ( for some recursive order @xmath89 ) then @xmath14 is high .
let @xmath14 be as above . by definition of @xmath14 being left - r.e .
, the left cut @xmath35 of @xmath14 is r.e . and @xmath270 .
by lemma [ l.sgl ] , @xmath35 is @xmath94 ( for some recursive order @xmath95 ) . by theorem [ t.deep.high.or.dnc.k ]
, @xmath35 is high or dnr . since every r.e .
dnr set is high , @xmath14 is high . as a second corollary , we prove that every weakly - useful set is either high or dnr .
a set @xmath14 is weakly - useful if there is a time - bound @xmath18 such that the class of all sets truth - table reducible to @xmath14 with this time bound @xmath18 is not small , i.e. , does not have measure zero within the class of recursive sets ; see @xcite for a precise definition . in @xcite , it was shown that every weakly - useful set is @xmath0 ( even order@xmath2 as observed in @xcite ) thus generalising the fact that @xmath45 is @xmath0 , since @xmath45 is weakly - useful .
[ t : wudeep ] every weakly - useful set is order@xmath2 .
it is shown in @xcite that every high degree contains a weakly - useful set .
our results show some type of converse to this fact .
[ t : wu - then - hi ] every weakly - useful set is either high or dnr .
this follows from theorem [ t.deep.high.or.dnc.k ] , since every weakly - useful set is order@xmath2 by theorem [ t : wudeep ] .
we showed in theorem [ t.high.iff.deep ] that every @xmath271 set is high . also theorem [ t.deep.high.or.dnc.k ]
shows that every order@xmath2 set is either high or dnr .
thus one might wonder whether there exists any non - high order@xmath2 set .
we answer this question affirmatively by showing there exist low order@xmath2 sets .
[ t : pawu ] if @xmath14 has pa - complete degree , then there exists a weakly - useful set @xmath215 .
let @xmath48 be a boolean dnr function and let @xmath272 .
it follows that if @xmath273 is boolean and total , then @xmath274 .
one can thus encode @xmath49 into a set @xmath41 such that for every @xmath16 such that @xmath273 is boolean and total and for every @xmath54 , @xmath275 .
one can also encode @xmath14 into @xmath93 ( for example , @xmath276 ) so that @xmath39 .
thus for every recursive set @xmath277 there exists @xmath16 such that for every string @xmath54 , we have @xmath278 , where @xmath279 is computable within @xmath280 steps ( by using a lookup table on small inputs ) .
it follows that every recursive set is truth - table reducible to @xmath93 within time @xmath280 .
because the class of recursive sets does not have measure zero within the class of recursive sets @xcite , it follows that @xmath93 is weakly - useful .
[ c : padeep ] if @xmath14 has pa - complete degree , then there exists an order@xmath2 set @xmath215 .
furthermore , there is a @xmath9-class only consisting of order@xmath2 sets .
this corollary follows from theorems [ t : wudeep ] and [ t : pawu ] .
recall that a set @xmath14 is said low for @xmath281 iff chaitin s @xmath281 is martin - lf random relative to @xmath14 ; a set @xmath14 has superlow degree if its jump @xmath43 is truth - table reducible to the halting problem .
well - known basis theorems @xcite given now the following corollary .
[ c : low - deep ] for each of the properties low , superlow , low for @xmath281 and hyperimmune - free , there exists an order@xmath2 set which also has this respective property .
there exists low sets @xmath14 of pa - complete degree @xcite . by theorem
[ c : padeep ] there exists an order@xmath2 set @xmath215 . since @xmath14 is low it follows that @xmath93 is low .
here recall that a set @xmath14 is said low for @xmath281 iff chaitin s @xmath281 is martin - lf random relative to @xmath14 ; a set @xmath14 has superlow degree if its jump @xmath43 is truth - table reducible to the halting problem .
this corollary follows from theorems [ t : wudeep ] and [ t : pawu ] as well as from the well - known basis theorems for @xmath9-classes @xcite .
the reason one uses pa - complete sets instead of merely martin - lf random sets ( which also satisfy all basis theorems ) , is that martin - lf random sets are not weakly - useful ; indeed , it is known that they are not even @xmath0 .
this stands in contrast to the following result .
there are two martin - lf random sets @xmath14 and @xmath93 such that @xmath282 is order@xmath2 .
barmpalias , lewis and ng @xcite showed that every pa - complete degree is the join of two martin - lf random degrees ; hence there are martin - lf random sets @xmath25 such that @xmath282 is a hyperimmune - free pa - complete set .
thus , by theorem [ t : pawu ] there is a weakly - useful set turing reducible to @xmath282 which , due to the hyperimmune - freeness , is indeed truth - table reducible to @xmath282 .
it follows that @xmath282 is itself weakly - useful and therefore order@xmath2 by theorem [ t : wudeep ] .
the next observation shows that this can not be generalised to @xmath4-trivial sets and that they are not @xmath0 .
a trivial set is not @xmath0 .
let @xmath14 be trivial ( with respect to the prefix - free kolmogorov complexity @xmath4 ) .
there is a recursive function @xmath12 and constant @xmath72 such that @xmath283 for infinitely many @xmath22 ; let @xmath93 be the set of these @xmath22 . as @xmath14 is trivial , there is another constant @xmath132 such that @xmath284 for all @xmath22 . for @xmath22 ranging over @xmath93 , let @xmath137 be the limit inferior of the number of strings @xmath161 of length @xmath22 with @xmath285 ; this limit inferior exists .
now there is a recursive bound @xmath96 such that , for almost all @xmath22 , @xmath286 and either @xmath287 or @xmath137 strings @xmath288 of length @xmath22 with @xmath289 are found .
note that there are infinitely many @xmath290 for which there are exactly @xmath137 strings @xmath288 of length @xmath22 with @xmath291 for all @xmath292 .
these @xmath293 also satisfy @xmath294 .
the string @xmath295 is among these @xmath137 strings @xmath288 for all of these @xmath22 and therefore @xmath296 for infinitely many @xmath22 . as @xmath297 for some constant @xmath298 and all @xmath22
, it follows that @xmath299 for infinitely many @xmath22 and @xmath14 is not @xmath0 .
a key property of depth is that `` easy '' sets should not be deep .
bennett @xcite showed that no recursive set is deep . here
we improve this result by observing that no @xmath4-trivial set is deep .
it follows easily from equivalent characterisations of @xmath4-triviality ( see @xcite ) , but our proof is self - contained . as we will see
this result is close to optimal .
[ t : ktshallow ] no @xmath4-trivial set is @xmath0 .
let @xmath14 be @xmath4-trivial and @xmath68 such that @xmath300 , @xmath301 .
let @xmath302 be such that for every string @xmath54 , @xmath303 and let @xmath304 .
there exists a constant @xmath305 such that the set @xmath306 is infinite ( see @xcite p. 139 ) .
note that @xmath307 is co - r.e .
, i.e. , there exists uniformly recursive approximations @xmath308 of @xmath307 .
let @xmath309 . by theorem [ t : counting ]
( with @xmath310 ) , @xmath311 .
consider the function @xmath312 by modifying @xmath47 on the finitely many values before the liminf is reached , @xmath47 is recursive .
wlog @xmath47 is bounded by a time bound which we also denote @xmath47 .
we have @xmath313 such that @xmath314 thus for each of these infinitely many @xmath22 s we have @xmath315 , i.e. , @xmath14 is not @xmath0 . call a set @xmath14 ultracompressible if for every recursive order @xmath49 and all @xmath22 , @xmath316 .
the following theorem shows that our result is close to optimal .
there is an ultracompressible set @xmath14 which is @xmath0 .
there is a set @xmath14 which is not @xmath4-trivial but which satisfies that for every @xmath317 order @xmath49 and all @xmath22 , @xmath316 .
it would be interesting to know whether such sets as found by herbert can be @xmath0 .
the result of herbert is optimal , csima and montalbn @xcite showed that such sets do not exist when using @xmath318 orders and baartse and barmpalias @xcite improved this non - existence to the level @xmath319 .
we also point to related work of hirschfeldt and weber @xcite .
there is a @xmath319 order @xmath49 such that a set @xmath14 is @xmath4-trivial iff @xmath320 for all @xmath22 .
that is , the difference between a @xmath4-trivial and an ultracompressible set is less than the difference of two orders of different complexity .
the existence of an ultracompressible @xmath0 set was proved in @xcite .
this shows that theorem [ t : ktshallow ] is close to optimal .
bennett observed in @xcite that being infinitely often bennett deep is meaningless , because all recursive sets are infinitely often deep .
a possibility for a more meaningful notion of infinitely often depth , is to consider a depth notion where the length of the input is given as an advice .
we call this notion i.o . depth .
a set @xmath14 is i.o .
@xmath92 if for every @xmath321 and for every time bound @xmath12 there are infinitely many @xmath22 satisfying @xmath322 if we replace @xmath4 with @xmath75 in the above definition , we call the corresponding notion i.o . @xmath134 . the fact that all recursive sets are infinitely often deep in bennett s
approach does no longer hold for i.o .
depth as defined above .
let @xmath14 be recursive .
then @xmath14 is neither i.o .
@xmath134 nor i.o .
@xmath92 .
let @xmath14 be recursive and @xmath12 be a time bound .
wlog @xmath14 is recursive in time @xmath12 , i.e. , for every @xmath81 we have @xmath323 for some constant @xmath72 , thus @xmath324 .
the @xmath4 case is similar .
the following shows that very little computational power is needed to compute an i.o .
deep set .
[ t : iodeep - hypimmune ] 1 .
there is a @xmath9-class such that every member is i.o .
@xmath197 for all @xmath196 .
in particular there is such a set of hyperimmune - free degree .
furthermore , every hyperimmune turing degree contains such a set .
every nonrecursive many - one degree contains an i.o .
@xmath134 set .
if @xmath14 is neither recursive nor dnr , then @xmath14 is i.o .
@xmath134 .
this result is obtained by splitting the natural numbers recursively into intervals @xmath325 such that @xmath326 .
now one defines the @xmath9-class such that for each @xmath327 where @xmath328 is defined up to @xmath329 , a string @xmath330 is selected such that for all @xmath331 , @xmath332 and then it is fixed that all members @xmath14 of the @xmath9-class have to satisfy @xmath333 for all @xmath334 .
since there are @xmath335 strings @xmath293 and for each program of size below @xmath336 can witness that only @xmath337 many @xmath293 are violating @xmath338 for some @xmath331 , there will be less than @xmath339 many @xmath293 that get disqualified and so the search finds such a @xmath293 whenever @xmath340 is defined up to @xmath329 .
hence , for every total @xmath328 , there are infinitely many intervals @xmath341 with @xmath22 of the form @xmath342 such that on these @xmath341 , @xmath343 and @xmath344 for a constant @xmath72 , as the program only needs to know how @xmath14 behaves below @xmath345 and can fill in the values of @xmath293 on @xmath341 .
so the complexity improves after time @xmath346 from @xmath347 to @xmath345 and , to absorb constants , one can conservatively estimate the improvement by @xmath348 . by the choice of @xmath349
, the ratio @xmath350 tends to @xmath159 and therefore every @xmath14 in the @xmath9-class is @xmath351 for every @xmath196 .
note that there are hyperimmune - free sets inside this @xmath9-class , as it has only nonrecursive members .
furthermore , one can see that the proof also can be adjusted to constructing a single set in a hyperimmune turing degree rather than constructing a full @xmath9-class . in that case one takes some function @xmath47 in this degree which is not dominated by any recursive function and then one permits for each @xmath352 the time @xmath353 in the case that @xmath354 and chooses @xmath293 accordingly and one takes @xmath355 in the case that @xmath340 does not converge on all values below @xmath329 within time @xmath356 otherwise .
this construction is recursive in the given degree and a slight modification of this construction would permit to code the degree into the set @xmath14 . for the second item , consider a set @xmath357 .
every many - one degree contains such a set . for each binary string @xmath161 , let _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ @xmath358 and @xmath359 for all @xmath360 and @xmath361 for all @xmath362 which are not a power of @xmath363 .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ in other word , for every @xmath357 , @xmath364 contains those @xmath293 which are a prefix of @xmath14 and for which @xmath365 is defined but not @xmath366 . for each @xmath367 where @xmath340 is a total function @xmath12
, we now try to find inductively for @xmath368 strings @xmath369 such that whenever @xmath370 is found then it is different from all those @xmath371 which have been found for some @xmath372 and the unique @xmath373 satisfies @xmath374 .
note that due to the resource - bound on @xmath102 one can for each @xmath372 check whether @xmath371 exists and take this information into account when trying to find @xmath370 .
therefore , for those @xmath124 where @xmath370 exists , the @xmath373 can be computed from @xmath124 , @xmath16 and @xmath137 and hence @xmath375 for some constant @xmath72 independent of @xmath376 .
now assume that @xmath14 is not infinitely often @xmath1 .
then there is a total function @xmath328 and a @xmath377 such that @xmath378 for all prefixes @xmath293 of @xmath14 .
it follows that in particular never a @xmath370 with @xmath379 consisting of prefixes of @xmath14 is selected in the above algorithm using @xmath380 .
this then implies that for almost all @xmath22 and the majority of the @xmath124 in the interval from @xmath381 to @xmath382 ( which are those for which @xmath370 does not get defined ) it holds that @xmath383 for the unique @xmath384 .
there are at most @xmath385 many strings @xmath386 such that at least half of the members @xmath293 of @xmath387 satisfy that @xmath388 and there is a constant @xmath132 such that for almost all @xmath22 the corresponding @xmath161 satisfy @xmath389 .
it follows that @xmath390 for some constant @xmath298 and almost all @xmath22 and all @xmath391 ; in other words , @xmath390 for some constant @xmath298 and almost all prefixes @xmath293 of @xmath14 . hence @xmath14 is recursive ( * ? ? ?
* exercise 2.3.4 on page 131 ) .
for the third item , let @xmath14 be as above , and let @xmath12 be a time bound .
let @xmath392 .
since @xmath393 and @xmath14 is hyperimmune - free , there exists a recursive @xmath89 such that @xmath394 .
wlog we can choose @xmath89 such that @xmath395 .
let @xmath214 be defined by @xmath396 . because @xmath14 is not dnr
, we have @xmath397 .
thus , @xmath398 @xmath399 and latexmath:[$c^t(a{\upharpoonright}m \
let @xmath16 be an index of a program such that @xmath401 with @xmath22 satisfying @xmath399 .
thus @xmath402 @xmath399 and @xmath403 and @xmath404 , i.e. , @xmath14 is i.o .
@xmath134 . for the third item ,
note that merkle , kjos - hanssen and stephan ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 2.7 ) showed that a set @xmath14 has dnr turing degree iff there is a function @xmath405 such that @xmath406 for all @xmath22 .
it will be shown that sets which are neither recursive nor i.o .
@xmath1 will permit to construct such a function @xmath405 and are thus dnr .
assume now that there is a time bound @xmath12 and a constant @xmath72 such that , for all @xmath22 , @xmath407 .
now , for input @xmath22 , one searches relative to @xmath14 for an @xmath124 such that @xmath408 and lets @xmath409 for the so found @xmath124 . as @xmath14 is not recursive this search terminates for every @xmath22 and obviously @xmath405 . by assumption , @xmath410 and , assuming a suitable compatibility between conditional and normal kolmogorov complexity , @xmath411 , that is , @xmath406 . due to these connections ,
non - recursive and non - high r.e .
sets are a natural example of sets where all members of the turing degree satisfy that they are i.o .
@xmath1 but not @xmath1 .
results of franklin and stephan @xcite imply that for every schnorr trivial set and every order @xmath89 it holds that @xmath14 is not i.o .
@xmath149 , as for every order @xmath89 there is a time bound @xmath12 such that the function @xmath412 grows slower than @xmath89 .
thus , the second and third points can not be generalised to i.o . order@xmath3 .
it also follows that there are high truth - table degrees and hyperimmune - free turing degrees which do not contain any i.o .
order@xmath3 set .
these are obtained by considering examples for schnorr trivial sets such as the following ones : all maximal sets and , for every partial recursive @xmath413-valued function @xmath414 whose domain is a maximal set , all sets @xmath14 satisfying @xmath415 .
we conclude that the choice of the depth magnitude has consequences on the computational power of the corresponding deep sets , and that larger magnitudes is not necessarily preferable over smaller magnitudes . therefore choosing the appropriate depth magnitude for one s purpose is delicate , as the corresponding depth notions might be very different .
when the depth magnitude is large , we proved that depth and highness coincide .
we showed that this is not the case for smaller depth magnitude by constructing a low order deep set , but the set is not r.e .
we therefore ask whether there is a low @xmath92 r.e .
set . by taking the complement of a layer of a universal martin - lf test ,
one obtains a @xmath9-class containing only mlr reals .
are there @xmath9-classes containing only @xmath75-deep reals ? for @xmath4-depth , note that there is a @xmath9-class of weakly useful sets which then , by theorem [ t : wudeep ] , is also a @xmath9-class of order@xmath2 sets . david doty and philippe moser .
feasible depth . in s.
barry cooper , benedikt lwe , and andrea sorbi , editors , _ computability in europe _ ,
volume 4497 of _ lecture notes in computer science _ , pages 228237 .
springer , 2007 . | we study bennett deep sequences in the context of recursion theory ; in particular we investigate the notions of @xmath0 , @xmath1 , order@xmath2 and order@xmath3 sequences .
our main results are that martin - lf random sets are not order@xmath3 , that every many - one degree contains a set which is not @xmath1 , that @xmath1 sets and order@xmath2 sets have high or dnr turing degree and that no @xmath4-trival set is @xmath0 .
a sequence is bennett deep @xcite if every recursive approximation of the kolmogorov complexity of its initial segments from above satisfies that the difference between the approximation and the actual value of the kolmogorov complexity of the initial segments dominates every constant function .
we study for different lower bounds @xmath5 of this difference between approximation and actual value of the initial segment complexity , which properties the corresponding @xmath6-deep sets have .
we prove that for @xmath7 , depth coincides with highness on the turing degrees . for smaller choices of @xmath5 ,
i.e. , @xmath5 is any recursive order function , we show that depth implies either highness or diagonally - non - recursiveness ( dnr ) . in particular , for left - r.e .
sets , order depth already implies highness . as a corollary , we obtain that weakly - useful sets are either high or dnr .
we prove that not all deep sets are high by constructing a low order - deep set .
bennett s depth is defined using prefix - free kolmogorov complexity .
we show that if one replaces prefix - free by plain kolmogorov complexity in bennett s depth definition , one obtains a notion which no longer satisfies the slow growth law ( which stipulates that no shallow set truth - table computes a deep set ) ; however , under this notion , random sets are not deep ( at the unbounded recursive order magnitude ) .
we observe that all @xmath4-trivial sets are shallow . for bennett
s depth , the magnitude of compression improvement has to be achieved almost everywhere on the set .
bennett observed that relaxing to infinitely often is meaningless because every recursive set is infinitely often deep .
we propose an alternative infinitely often depth notion that does nt suffer this limitation ( called i.o .
depth ) .
we show that every hyperimmune degree contains a i.o .
deep set of magnitude @xmath8 , and construct a @xmath9-class where every member is an i.o .
deep set of magnitude @xmath8 .
we prove that every non - recursive , non - dnr hyperimmune - free set is i.o .
deep of constant magnitude , and that every nonrecursive many - one degree contains such a set . |
this supplement provides the reader with further material to assist with some of the technical materials of the main part paper for the proposed qsi hamiltonian @xcite , the numerical linked cluster ( nlc ) method @xcite gives reliable quantitative properties of the system in the thermodynamic limit down to some temperature by developing an expansion in connected tetrahedra that embed in the pyrochlore lattice . for each cluster
, we perform an exact diagonalization ( ed ) and calculate physical quantities from the resulting spectrum and states .
once a property is calculated , the properties of all subclusters are subtracted to get the weight of the cluster @xmath62 denoted as @xmath63 . in the thermodynamic limit ,
an extensive property , @xmath64 is expressed as @xmath65 where @xmath66 is the count of the cluster , per lattice site .
we consider all clusters up to four tetrahedra , the largest diagonalization being a 13-site system .
all states are required to calculate the partition function and thermodynamic quantities presented below .
the particular clusters to fourth order in our expansion are shown in figure s1 .
nlc using the tetrahedral basis requires exact diagonalization of increasingly large tetrahedral clusters . using modern hardware and freely - available linear algebra routines , diagonalizations for clusters of one tetrahedron ( four sites ) and two tetrahedra ( seven sites )
could be done in less than a second , while the three - tetrahedron ( 10-site ) cluster still required less than 10 seconds .
computing only the spectrum for a single four - tetrahedron ( 13-site ) cluster required about 1200 seconds and more than 1 gb of memory , while generating the full set of eigenstates required approximately 8 gb of memory .
note that the hamiltonian of an n - site cluster is a @xmath67 complex hermitian matrix .
exact diagonalizations of larger systems are , in practice , limited by memory requirements
. the next order calculation will have @xmath53 more sites and the memory requirement will grow by a factor of @xmath68 .
nlc generates a sequence of property estimates @xmath69 with increasing order @xmath70 , where @xmath71 and @xmath72 is some physical quantity calculated at the @xmath73th order .
when such a sequence is found to alternate , its convergence can be improved by euler transformation @xcite . in general ,
given alternating terms @xmath74 , the euler transform method amounts to estimates , @xmath75,\ ] ] where @xmath76 is the forward difference operator @xmath77 usually , a small number of terms are computed directly , and the euler transformation is applied to rest of the series . in our case , where direct terms are available to fourth order , we begin the euler transform after the second order , so that the third and fourth order euler - transformed property estimates are @xmath78 we use the notation of ross _ et al . _
@xcite and define the quantum spin ice hamiltonian as @xmath79\nonumber \\ & & + j_{z\pm } [ ( s_i^z(\zeta_{ij}s_j^+ + \zeta_{i , j}^*s_j^- ) + i \leftrightarrow j ] \ } .
\label{hqsi}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the parameters for yb@xmath2ti@xmath2o@xmath3 determined by fitting from high - field inelastic neutron ( magnon ) spectra in ref .
@xcite are , measured in mev , @xmath21 , @xmath22 , @xmath23 , and @xmath24 .
two other sets of parameter estimates for yb@xmath2ti@xmath2o@xmath3 were determined by fitting the diffused ( energy - integrated ) neutron scattering using the random phase approximation ( rpa ) @xcite .
the values obtained by thompson _ et al . _
@xcite are : @xmath80 , @xmath81 , @xmath82 , and @xmath83 , while those obtained by chang _
et al . _
@xcite are @xmath84 , @xmath85 , @xmath86 , and @xmath87 . in all cases ,
the values of the @xmath9 exchange parameters are given in mev .
the calculated heat capacity for all these parameters , together with the experimental data on yb@xmath2ti@xmath2o@xmath3 from difference groups @xcite , are shown in fig
it is clear that the latter two parametrizations by thompson _
et al . _ and
chang _ et al .
_ do not give a good description of the heat capacity of the material .
it is not clear at this time why rpa calculations find such @xmath9 parameters compared to high - field paramagnon spectra @xcite .
this problem warrants further attention . in order to explore to
what extent quantum mechanical effects are at play in @xmath88 , we introduce a hamiltonian with rescaled quantum terms as @xmath89 where @xmath90 is the classical spin - ice hamiltonian consisting of @xmath43 terms only , while all other terms are included in @xmath91 .
the value @xmath19 corresponds to the parameters of ross _
et al_.@xcite in the perturbative regime ( @xmath55 ) , this model maps on to a @xmath92 model with @xmath93 and @xmath94 .
specific heat and entropy of the system with different values of @xmath38 in 4th order euler transform , down to a temperature where @xmath53rd and @xmath54th order euler transforms agree with each other are shown in fig .
s3 and fig .
heat capacity of the perturbative classical @xmath92 model , calculated by classical loop monte carlo simulations @xcite is shown in fig .
s5 . note that while the models with different @xmath38 always have a short - range order peak , in the @xmath92 model , long - range order temperature increases well past the short - range order peak with increasing @xmath95 .
the number of experimental specific heat , @xmath0 , results on yb@xmath2ti@xmath2o@xmath3 has rapidly accumulated over the past year or so @xcite . most of these data are somewhat problematic in wanting to assess whether those thermodynamic data hide spin ice phenomenology , associated with a rapid diminution of spinon / antispinon excitation and the concurrent @xmath0 hump at a temperature @xmath29 k as we now discuss .
all of the published @xmath0 data @xcite do not go to sufficiently high temperature to extract reliably the limiting @xmath101 high temperature behaviour that would allow one to determine the residual magnetic entropy by integrating @xmath36 upon decreasing @xmath25 starting from the infinite @xmath102 value .
one must therefore integrate @xmath36 from low temperature , and assume an entropy value , @xmath103 at some reference ( low ) temperature , @xmath104 .
the apparent large amount of residual entropy below @xmath105 k in the single crystal samples of refs .
@xcite make difficult ascribing a reasonable value to @xmath103 .
this problem is further compounded by the rising low - temperature nuclear contribution to the total specific heat below about 0.1 k. the very sharp 1st order transition seen in powder powder sample of ref .
@xcite , without a precise measurement of the associated latent heat also make difficult using those data for comparison of experimental entropy with the @xmath1 calculated by nlc . on the otherhand , the data of bl "
ote _ et al . _
@xcite seem the most adequate for comparison with nlc : there is a sharp specific heat peak at @xmath106 k with sufficient temperature resolution that allows integration of @xmath36 over the peak without concern about an associated latent heat .
the @xmath0 data are dropping rapidly below @xmath7 , suggesting the opening of an excitation gap , ultimately reaching a low - value that is limited by the `` high temperature tail '' ( @xmath107 k ) of the nuclear contribution . using the data from ref .
@xcite , we thus assume that the magnetic part of the specific heat is zero at @xmath108 k , and integrate _ upward _ ( increasing temperature ) @xmath36 up to the highest temperature point available from those data ( @xmath109 k ) .
this results in the data ( filled black circles in fig . 3 in the body of the paper )
. it would be highly desirable to repeat this procedure from the @xmath0 data of refs .
@xcite which show a sharp peak , but including ( magnetic specific heat ) data for @xmath25 up to 20 k where the limiting high - temperature regime @xmath110 can be fitted and compared with nlc , along with measurements of the magnetic entropy , @xmath1 . in the perturbative regime of the qsi
, we consider the effective hamiltonian @xmath112 where @xmath113 are the ising variables .
@xmath114 denotes the sum over the nearest neighbors , @xmath115 denotes the sum over the third nearest neighbors which share a nearest neighbour .
distance - wise there exists another type of third nearest neighbors which do not share a nearest neighbor . for any given spin , there are six third nearest neighbors for both types .
antiferromagnetic @xmath116 drives the spin ice formation in the classical spin ice system , and a small fluctuation - induced ferromagnetic exchange @xmath117 favors the @xmath41 ordering within the spin ice manifold , _ i.e. _ , all tetrahedra on the same primitive fcc lattice have the same one of the six spin ice states .
monte carlo simulations are performed using the metropolis algorithm .
single spin flip updates are used along with the non - local loop algorithm @xcite , which restores the ergodicity of the system once it is frozen into the spin ice states .
systems of 128 spins are simulated in a cubic box with periodic boundary conditions .
up to about 78,000 monte carlo steps per spin are used in equilibrating the system at a given temperature , with the same number of steps in data sampling . to investigate the calorimetric quantities , fluctuations of the energy
are recorded to give the heat capacity : @xmath118 the defect ( spinon / antispinon ) monopole number @xmath120 , for a cluster , is evaluated as @xmath121 where @xmath122 is the monopole count in the local @xmath123 basis state @xmath124 .
this count is a sum over all the tetrahedra in a cluster , @xmath125 , where @xmath126 the monopole density @xmath52 is defined as number of monopoles present per site , giving @xmath127 to relate our presentation more directly to the compact lattice qed context set in refs .
@xcite , in which confinement in three - dimensions is traditionally referred to the strong ( electric charge ) coupling , we refrain from using the language of `` monopoles '' employed in ref .
@xcite to label local defects in the ice rule of the parent classical spin ice .
we use instead the more traditional wording of spinon / antispinon to label finite energy excitations out of the 2in/2out spin ice manifold . | we use numerical linked cluster ( nlc ) expansions to compute the specific heat , @xmath0 , and entropy , @xmath1 , of a quantum spin ice model of yb@xmath2ti@xmath2o@xmath3 using anisotropic exchange interactions recently determined from inelastic neutron scattering measurements and find good agreement with experimental calorimetric data . in the perturbative weak quantum regime , this model has a ferrimagnetic ordered ground state , with two peaks in @xmath0 : a schottky anomaly signalling the paramagnetic to spin ice crossover followed at lower temperature by a sharp peak accompanying a first order phase transition to the ferrimagnetic state .
we suggest that the two @xmath0 features observed in yb@xmath2ti@xmath2o@xmath3 are associated with the same physics .
spin excitations in this regime consist of weakly confined spinon - antispinon pairs .
we suggest that conventional ground state with exotic quantum dynamics will prove a prevalent characteristic of many real quantum spin ice materials .
the experimental search for quantum spin liquids ( qsls ) , magnetic systems disordered by large quantum fluctuations , has remained unabated for over twenty years @xcite .
one direction that is rapidly gathering momentum is the search for qsls among materials that are close relatives to spin ice systems @xcite , but with additional quantum fluctuations , or
_ quantum spin ice _ @xcite .
spin ices are found among insulating pyrochlore oxides , such as r@xmath2m@xmath2o@xmath3 ( r = ho , dy ; m = ti , sn ) @xcite . in these compounds ,
the magnetic r rare earth ions sit on a lattice of corner - sharing tetrahedra , experiencing a large single - ion anisotropy forcing the magnetic moment to point strictly `` in '' or `` out '' of the two tetrahedra it joins ( see .
fig .
1a ) .
consequently , the direction of a moment can be described by a classical ising spin @xcite . in these materials ,
the combination of nearest - neighbor exchange and long - range magnetostatic dipolar interactions lead to an exponentially large number of low - energy states characterized by two spins pointing in and two spins pointing out on each tetrahedron ( see fig .
1a ) .
this energetic constraint is equivalent to the bernal - fowler ice rule which gives water ice a residual entropy @xmath4 per proton , estimated by pauling @xcite and in good agreement with experiments on water ice @xcite .
since they share the same `` ice - rule '' , the ( ho , dy)@xmath2(ti , sn)@xmath2o@xmath3 pyrochlores also possess a residual low - temperature pauling entropy @xmath5 @xcite , hence the name spin ice .
the spin ice state is not thermodynamically distinct from the paramagnetic phase . yet , because of the ice - rules , it is a strongly correlated state of matter a _ classical _ spin liquid of sorts @xcite .
( a ) two neighboring tetrahedra with spins in their two - in / two - out ground state , ( b ) spinon / antispinon pair , ( c ) spinon / antispinon pair separated by a ( green ) string of misaligned spins in the pyrochlore lattice . , width=302 ] for infinite ising anisotropy , quantum effects are absent @xcite .
however , these can be restored when considering the realistic situation of _ finite _ anisotropy . in two closely related papers , hermele _ et al . _
@xcite and castro - neto _ et al . _
@xcite considered effective spins one - half on a pyrochlore lattice where the highly degenerate classical spin ice state is promoted via quantum fluctuations to a qsl with fascinating properties .
this qsl is described by a compact lattice quantum electrodynamics ( qed ) -like theory . in this qsl state
inherited from the parent classical spin ice , the ice - rules amount to a divergence - free coarse - grained fictitious electric field whose sources are deconfined spinons while the sources of the canonically conjugate field are deconfined monopoles @xcite , along with a gauge boson ( `` artificial photon '' ) .
recent numerical studies have found evidence that qed - like phenomena may be at play in some minimal quantum spin ice ( qsi ) lattice models @xcite but does the qsi picture apply to real materials ?
also , should a qsi state be solely defined by whether or not a qsl state is realized ? while a qsi picture has been suggested relevant to the qsl behavior in tb@xmath2ti@xmath2o@xmath3 @xcite and pr@xmath2m@xmath2o@xmath3 @xcite , intense experimental @xcite and theoretical @xcite interest has recently turned to yb@xmath2ti@xmath2o@xmath3 ( ybto ) , which has been argued to be on the verge of realizing a qsl originating from qsi physics .
in fact , the combination of ( i ) an unexplained transition at @xmath6 0.24 k @xcite , ( ii ) the controversial evidence for long - range order below @xmath7 @xcite and ( iii ) the high sensitivity of the low - temperature ( @xmath8 mk ) behavior to sample preparation conditions @xcite are all tantalizing evidence that ybto has a fragile and perhaps unconventional ground state .
thus , explaining ybto is a key milestone in the study of qsi in a materials context .
in this paper , we first use the numerical linked cluster ( nlc ) method @xcite to calculate the heat capacity , @xmath0 , and entropy , @xmath1 , of a microscopic model for ybto with exchange parameters , @xmath9 , taken from ref .
@xcite .
this calculation , which converges down to about 1 k , agrees well with experiments .
it demonstrates that ybto is indeed a spin - half , anisotropic exchange model , with @xmath9 determined from magnon energies in the strong - field polarized paramagnet regime @xcite .
our work suggests that a two - peaked @xmath0 structure is natural in ybto and should be present in the best ( `` quality '' ) samples @xcite . below the higher temperature @xmath0 hump near 2 k ,
the system has a residual @xmath1 comparable to @xmath5 , but without a clean @xmath10 plateau developing upon cooling .
we propose that the lower temperature sharp peak in @xmath0 is associated with a strongly first order transition to a ferrimagnetic state .
such a behavior is indeed found in our study when the quantum ( non - ising ) exchanges are small .
finally , we argue that despite a conventional ground state , the spin excitations consist of spinon / antispinon pairs connected with ( dirac - like @xcite ) strings of reversed spins , whose confinement length @xmath11 diverges in the limit of small quantum exchanges .
we propose that these excitations should ultimately form the basis for describing what we expect to be highly unconventional inelastic neutron spectra @xcite .
_ model & method _ the anisotropic exchange qsi model is defined by the nearest - neighbor hamiltonian @xcite on the pyrochlore lattice @xmath12\nonumber \\ & & + \lambda j_{z\pm } [ ( s_i^z(\zeta_{ij}s_j^+ + \zeta_{i , j}^*s_j^- ) + i \leftrightarrow j ] \ } .
\label{hqsi}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath13 is a @xmath14 complex unimodular matrix , and @xmath15 @xcite .
the @xmath16 quantization axis is along the local @xmath17 $ ] direction , and @xmath18 refers to the two orthogonal local directions .
we take @xmath19 , except when stated otherwise .
recently ross _
et al . _
@xcite used inelastic neutron scattering data in high fields to deduce the @xmath20 exchange parameters for ybto : @xmath21 , @xmath22 , @xmath23 , and @xmath24 , all in mev .
these parameters have also been determined through an analysis of the zero - field energy - integrated paramagnetic neutron scattering @xcite , but the values of the @xmath9 parameters disagree significantly an issue that we address in the supplementary material @xcite .
nlc expansions provide a controlled way of calculating macroscopic properties of a thermodynamic system @xcite . by summing up contributions from clusters
upto some size , one can obtain properties in the thermodynamic limit , which include all terms in high temperature expansions upto some order .
furthermore , since the contributions of the clusters are entirely included for all temperatures , all short distance physics is fully incorporated , and thus can converge down to lower temperatures than a ( high - temperature , @xmath25 ) series expansion @xcite in @xmath26 .
nlc is particularly suited to the study of spin ice systems .
it was recently shown that for classical spin ice models , just first order nlc based on a single tetrahedron , gives @xmath0 and @xmath1 for all @xmath25 within a few percent accuracy @xcite . here , we calculate the thermodynamic properties of the exchange qsi model of eq .
( [ hqsi ] ) using tetrahedra - based nlc upto 4@xmath27 order @xcite .
euler extrapolations @xcite are used to eliminate some alternating pieces in the expansion , which further improves the convergence of the calculations to lower @xmath25 . in zero field , there is only one cluster in each of the first three orders , and three clusters in the fourth order @xcite .
the different @xmath28-tensor elements on different sites ( expressed in a global frame ) @xcite mean that many more clusters are needed for calculating field - dependent @xmath0 , magnetization and susceptibility , and these will be presented elsewhere .
figure 2 shows @xmath0 calculated with different nlc orders . by 4@xmath27 order
, there is good convergence to temperatures below the @xmath0 peak at @xmath29 k. applying euler transformations @xcite improves the convergence down to slightly below 1 k. the experimental data from refs .
@xcite , shown for comparison , agree well with the nlc results . here
, we used the mean values of the @xmath20 from ref .
@xcite and did not adjust any parameters . given the variability in the experimental @xmath0 data from one group to another @xcite , it does not seem useful at this time to search for @xmath20 parameters giving a better fit .
this agreement shows that the @xmath9 parameters are not substantially renormalized compared to the high ( 5 tesla ) field values @xcite . using the @xmath20 of refs .
@xcite gives substantially different @xmath0 results @xcite .
specific heat , @xmath0 , per mole of yb for the model parameters in ref .
@xcite , in units of the boltzmann constant @xmath30 , calculated via nlc ( up to 4@xmath27 order nlc together with euler extrapolations ) are compared with experimental data for yb@xmath2ti@xmath31o@xmath3 .
the black circles are data from ref .
@xcite . ,
width=340 ] entropy , @xmath1 , per mole of yb , in units @xmath32 following the methods described in the caption of fig .
2 .
the black circles are obtained by integrating the data from ref .
@xcite excluding the nuclear ( hyperfine ) contribution .
the pauling entropy @xmath33 is shown as a horizontal line .
the inset shows @xmath1 in the perturbative regime with @xmath34 .
a clear plateau at @xmath35 is seen , followed at lower @xmath25 by a precipitous drop of @xmath1 ( i.e. latent heat ) accompanying the transition to long range fm order @xcite .
, width=340 ] figure 3 shows @xmath1 calculated by nlc , together with the entropy obtained by integrating @xmath36 data of ref . @xcite .
we found the data from ref .
@xcite ideally suited to perform this comparison @xcite .
the entropy converges to lower temperature slightly better than @xmath0 where , with euler transformations , @xmath1 converges down to about 0.7 k , matching well with the experimental entropy values over the overlapping temperature range . _ perturbative considerations _
in order to better understand the properties of this system , we turn to the perturbative regime @xmath37 in eq
. 1 @xcite . to second order in @xmath38 , only @xmath39 , by far
the largest quantum term for ybto , leads to a degeneracy - lifting classical potential for different spin - ice configurations .
it amounts to a fluctuation - induced ferromagnetic exchange constant @xmath40 @xcite between shortest distance spins on the same tetrahedral sublattice that share a neighbor @xcite .
it leads to the selection of a @xmath41 long - range ordered ground state in which all tetrahedra are in the same configuration and the spins develop a small ferromagnetic moment along one of the @xmath42 cubic directions .
this @xmath41 ferrimagnet ( fm ) lacks the coulombic physics originally present in the @xmath43-only spin ice model @xcite . to calculate @xmath0 and @xmath1 in the perturbative regime at low @xmath25
, we turn to classical loop monte carlo simulations @xcite of the @xmath44 model @xcite .
these reveal a very sharp lower temperature peak signalling a first order phase transition to a @xmath41 state ( see fig .
s5 @xcite ) .
_ excited states in the perturbative regime : spinons and strings _
a surprise of the perturbative treatment is that , while the ground state is classical , the spin - flip excitations remain non - trivial and of quantum nature .
this is because , once a spin is flipped in a spin - ice state , creating a spinon / antispinon pair @xcite , the pair can hop through @xmath39 acting through _ first order _ degenerate perturbation theory .
thus , the dispersion in the excited state manifold is @xmath45 , _ much larger _ than the dispersion within the low - energy manifold of spin ice states , which is only @xmath46 .
a sketch of a spinon / antispinon pair is shown in fig .
1b and 1c .
note that only spins inside the tetrahedron `` already '' containing spinons are flippable in first order degenerate perturbation theory .
hence , the connecting string of misaligned spins can only fluctuate by higher order processes involving closed loops with alternating in - out spins @xcite .
thus the renormalized string tension per unit length remains finite and of order @xmath47 .
one can estimate the typical string length as the length , @xmath48 , at which the cost of the string becomes comparable to the delocalization energy of the spinon / antispinon pair .
the string energy per unit length goes as @xmath49 , whereas the delocalization energy ( spinon bandwidth ) goes as @xmath38 .
this leads to @xmath11 scaling as @xmath50 , which diverges as @xmath51 .
a detailed theory of neutron scattering in this ferrimagnetic phase is not attempted here , but we anticipate it to follow the proposal of ref .
@xcite . at temperatures above the transition to the @xmath41 long - range
ordered state , the system explores the classical two - in / two - out spin ice states and should display singularities ( pinch points , pps ) in neutron scattering @xcite rounded off by the finite density of thermally excited spinon / antispinon defects @xcite . while the system has thermally smeared pps above the ferrimagnetic transition and no static pps well below the transition , it may display some remnant of pps in the spin dynamics at higher energies .
these interesting issues deserve further attention .
monopole defect density , @xmath52 , calculated using nlc , shown down to a temperature where @xmath53rd and @xmath54th order euler transforms agree . here , quantum exchanges are scaled with respect to ybto parameters by different values of @xmath38 .
, width=226 ] _ beyond the @xmath55 regime _ why is the transition temperature of ybto so low ? as discussed by ross _
et al . _
@xcite , the low @xmath25 peak in @xmath0 is at a temperature lower than mean - field theory by an order of magnitude .
comparing @xmath0 for the quantum model with different @xmath38 with the corresponding classical model with the perturbative @xmath56 value provides a hint of the reason why @xcite .
it shows that , in the classical model , the long - range order keeps steadily moving up with increased @xmath47 , even beyond the short - range order @xmath0 peak .
in contrast , the quantum systems , with different @xmath38 continue to display a short - range order @xmath0 peak and presumably long - range order only occurs at a much lower @xmath25 .
perturbative considerations here have an analogy with strong coupling studies of mott physics in the hubbard model , where the nel temperature first increases with @xmath57 as @xmath58 but then begins decreasing when the system moves away from the perturbative small @xmath59 regime .
we propose that a similar non - monotonic @xmath7 arises in this qsi model due to enhanced quantum fluctuations .
another argument for a reduced @xmath7 comes from considering the temperature dependence of the defect ( spinon / antispinon ) monopole density , @xmath52 , as calculated by nlc ( see fig . 4 and figs . s3 and s4 @xcite ) . to illustrate the point
, we show the behavior for several different @xmath38 values .
convergence increases to lower @xmath25 , with decreasing @xmath38 , as expected .
one finds that as @xmath25 drops below the hump in @xmath0 , @xmath52 displays a plateau - like region , whose value increases steadily with increasing @xmath38 .
this indicates that the states _ within _
the spin - ice manifold develop large spinon / antispinon spectral weight , thus strongly renormalizing all low energy scales and , presumably , leading to reduced @xmath7 .
_ discussion : what constitutes an exchange qsi ?
_ we suggest that a double - peaked @xmath0 with an entropy between the peaks comparable to @xmath5 is the hallmark of an exchange quantum spin ice ( qsi ) .
however , one is unlikely to find an exact plateau at @xmath35 outside the perturbative ( small @xmath38 ) regime .
such a double - peaked structure and quasi - separation of the energy / temperature scales associated with short and long - range physics has also been suggested for other systems where quantum spin liquid physics may apply @xcite . according to the gauge mean - field theory of ref .
@xcite , at low temperature below which short - range spin ice correlations develop , a system may exhibit either a conventional ferrimagnetic ( fm ) order , a coulombic ferromagnet ( cfm ) or a full - blown quantum spin - liquid ( qsl ) , depending on its quantum exchange parameters .
the largest quantum exchange terms in ybto is @xmath39 , which favors the fm state , which we believe is the origin of the 0.24 k transition in the best samples @xcite .
it remains to be seen if there are real materials for which @xmath60 , which favors the qsl @xcite , is the dominant quantum term .
nevertheless , even when the ground state is fm , the excitations remain highly exotic , consisting of spinon - antispinon pairs separated by long strings .
this non - trivial feature is derived from the underlying spin - ice physics . finally , as one notes that @xmath39 is strictly zero for non - kramers ions ( e.g. pr , tb ) and that virtual crystal field excitations @xcite in tb - based pyrochlores are a fundamentally different pathway from anisotropic superexchange @xcite to generate anisotropic @xmath61 couplings between effective spins one - half @xcite , the prospect to ultimately find a qsi - based qsl among rare - earth pyrochlores @xcite is perhaps promising .
this work is supported in part by nsf grant number dmr-1004231 , the nserc of canada and the canada research chair program ( m.g . , tier 1 ) .
we acknowledge very useful discussions with b. javanparast , k. ross and j. thompson .
we thank p. dalmas de rotier for providing specific heat data of ref .
[ ] . |
a growing literature has presented empirical findings of the persistent impact of trade activities on economic growth and poverty reduction ( portugal - perez,@xcite,@xcite,@xcite , ackah , @xcite ) . besides discussing on the relation between trade and development , they also report on the growth by destination hypothesis , according
to which , the destination of exports can play an important role in determining the trade pattern of a country and its development path .
simultaneously , there has been a growing interest in applying concepts and tools of network theory to the analysis of international trade ( serrano,@xcite,@xcite,@xcite , @xcite , picciolo,@xcite ) .
trade networks are among the most cited examples of the use of network approaches .
the international trade activity is an appealing example of a large - scale system whose underlying structure can be represented by a set of bilateral relations .
this paper is a contribution to interweaving two lines of research that have progressed in separate ways : network analyses of international trade and the literature on african trade and development .
the most intuitive way of defining a trade network is representing each world country by a vertex and the flow of imports / exports between them by a directed link .
such descriptions of bilateral trade relations have been used in the gravity models ( @xcite ) where some structural and dynamical aspects of trade have been often accounted for . while some authors have used network approaches to investigate the international trade activity , studies that apply network models to focus on specific issues of african trade are less prominent .
although african countries are usually considered in international trade network analyses , the space they occupy in these literature is often very narrow
. this must be partly due to the existence of some relevant limitations that empirical data on african countries suffer from , mostly because part of african countries does not report trade data to the united nations .
the usual solution in this case is to use partner country data , an approach referred to as * mirror statistics*. however , using mirror statistics is not a suitable source for bilateral trade in africa as an important part of intra - african trade concerns import and exports by non - reporting countries .
a possible solution to overcome the limitations on bilateral trade data is to make use of information that , although concerning two specific trading countries , might be provided indirectly by a third and secondary source .
that is what happens when we define a bipartite network and its one - mode projection . in so doing
, each bilateral relation between two african countries in the network is defined from the relations each of these countries hold with another entity .
it can be achieved in such a way that when they are similar enough in their relation with that other entity , a link is defined between them .
our approach is applied to a subset of 49 african countries and based on the definition of two independent bipartite networks where trade similarities between each pair of african countries are used to define the existence of a link . in the first bipartite graph ,
the similarities concern a mutual leading destination of exports by each pair of countries and in the second bipartite graph , countries are linked through the existence of a mutual leading export commodity between them .
therefore , bilateral trade discrepancies are avoided and we are able to look simultaneously at network structures that emerge from two fundamental characteristics ( exporting destinations and exporting commodities ) of the international trade . as both networks were defined from empirical data reported for 2014 , we call these networks * destination share networks * * * ( dsn@xmath0 ) and * * * * * commodity share networks * ( csn@xmath1 , respectively .
its worth noticing that the choice of a given network representation is only one out of several other ways to look at a given system .
there may be many ways in which the elementary units and the links between them are conceived and the choices may depend strongly on the available empirical data and on the questions that a network analysis aims to address ( @xcite ) . the main question addressed in this paper is whether some relevant characteristics of african trade would emerge from the bipartite networks above described .
we hypothesized that specific characteristics could come out and shape the structures of both the dsn@xmath0 and the csn@xmath0 .
we envision that these networks will allow to uncover some ordering emerging from african exports in the broader context of international trade .
if it happens , the emerging patterns may help to understand important characteristics of african exports and its relation to other economic , geographic and organizational concerns . to this end
, the paper is organized as follows : next section presents the empirical data we work with , section three describes the methodology and some preliminary results from its application . in section four
we present further results and discuss on their interpretation in the international trade setting .
section five concludes and outlines future work .
trade map - trade statistics for international business development ( itm ) - provides a dataset of import and export data in the form of tables , graphs and maps for a set of reporting and non - reporting countries all over the world .
there are also indicators on export performance , international demand , alternative markets and competitive markets .
trade map covers 220 countries and territories and 5300 products of the harmonized system ( hs code ) .
since the trade map statistics capture nationally reported data of such a large amount of countries , this dataset is an appropriate source to the empirical study of temporal patterns emerging from international trade .
nevertheless , some major limitations should be indicated , as for countries that do not report trade data to the united nations , trade map uses partner country data , an issue that motivated our choice for defining bipartite networks .
our approach is applied to a subset of 49 african countries ( see table 1 ) and from this data source , trade similarities between each pair of countries are used to define networks of links between countries .
table 1 shows the 49 african countries we have been working with .
it also shows the regional organization of each country , accordingly to the following classification : 1 - southern african development community ( sadc ) ; 2 - unio do magreb rabe ( uma ) ; 3 - comunidade econmica dos estados da africa central ( ceeac ) ; 4 - common market for eastern and southern africa ( comesa ) and 5 - comunidade econmica dos estados da frica ocidental ( cedeao ) . for each african country in table 1
, we consider the set of countries to which at least one of the african countries had exported in the year of 2014 .
the specification of the destinations of exports of each country followed the international trade statistics database ( @xcite ) from where just * the first and the second main destinations of exports * * of each country * were taken . similarly and also for each african country in table 1 , we took the set of commodities that at least one of the african countries had exported in 2014 .
the specification of the destinations of exports of each country followed the same database from where just * the first and the second main export commodities of each country * were taken . for each country ( column label `` * * country * * '' ) in table 1 , besides the regional organization ( column label `` * * o * * '' ) and the first and second destinations ( column labels `` * * destinations * * '' ) and commodities ( column labels `` * * products * * '' ) , we also considered the export value in 2014 ( as reported in @xcite ) so that the size of the representation of each country in the networks herein presented is proportional to its corresponding export value in 2014 . [
cols="<,<,<,<,<,<,<,<,<,<,<,<,<,<",options="header " , ] table 6 : comparing topological coefficients obtained for dsn@xmath0 and csn@xmath0 .
the dsn@xmath0 also has a larger clustering coefficient than the csn@xmath0 , showing that when a country shares a mutual export destination with other two countries , these two other countries also tend to share a mutual export destination between them .
the densities of dsn@xmath0 and csn@xmath0 confirm that topological distances in the dsn@xmath0 are shorter than in the csn@xmath2 and that on average going from one country in the dsn@xmath0 to any other country in the same graph takes less intermediate nodes than in the csn@xmath0 .
although the networks dsn@xmath0 and csn@xmath0 inform about the degree of the nodes , their densely - connected nature does not help to discover any dominant topological pattern besides the distribution of the node s degree .
moving away from a dense to a sparse representation of a network , one shall ensure that the degree of sparseness is determined endogenously , instead of by an a priory specification .
it has been often accomplished ( araujo2012,@xcite ) through the construction of a minimal spanning tree ( mst ) , in so doing one is able to develop the corresponding representation of the network where sparseness replaces denseness in a suitable way . in the construction of a mst by the _
nearest neighbor _ method , one defines the 49 countries ( in table 1 ) as the nodes ( @xmath3 ) of a weighted network where the distance @xmath4 between each pair of countries @xmath5 and @xmath6 corresponds to the inverse of weight of the link ( @xmath7 ) between @xmath5 and @xmath8 . from the @xmath9 distance matrix @xmath10 , a hierarchical clustering is then performed using the _
nearest neighbor _ method .
initially @xmath11 clusters corresponding to the @xmath11 countries are considered .
then , at each step , two clusters @xmath12 and @xmath13 are clumped into a single cluster if @xmath14 with the distance between clusters being defined by @xmath15 with @xmath16 and @xmath17 this process is continued until there is a single cluster .
this clustering process is also known as the _ single link method _ , being the method by which one obtains the minimal spanning tree ( mst ) of a graph . in a connected graph ,
the mst is a tree of @xmath18 edges that minimizes the sum of the edge distances . in a network with @xmath11 nodes
, the hierarchical clustering process takes @xmath18 steps to be completed , and uses , at each step , a particular distance @xmath19 @xmath20 @xmath10 to clump two clusters into a single one .
in this section we discuss the results obtained from the mst of each one - mode projected graphs dsn@xmath0 and csn@xmath0 . as earlier mentioned
, the mst of a graph may allow for discovering relevant topological patterns that are not easily observed in the dense original networks . as in the last section
, we begin with the analysis of the dsn@xmath0 and then proceed to the csn@xmath0 .
we look for eventual topological structures coming out from empirical data of african exports , in order to see whether some relevant characteristics of african trade have any bearing on the network structures that emerge from the application of our approach . in the last section , we observed some slight influence of the regional position of each country in its connectivity . with the construction of the minimum spanning trees
we envision that some stronger structural patterns would come to be observed on the trees .
figure 7 shows the mst obtained from the dsn@xmath0 and colored according to each country main destination of exports in 2014 .
the first evidence coming out from the mst in figure 7 is the central position of ago clustering together the entire set of `` china '' exporters ( red ) in 2014 .
another important pattern that emerges in the mst is the branch of uma countries ( yellow ) in the right side of the tree , being `` europe '' their most frequent destination of exports .
similarly , part of the countries that export mostly to `` other '' seems to cluster on the left branch ( purple ) .
interestingly , the countries that exports to `` african countries '' ( blue ) occupy the less central positions on the tree . this result illustrates the suitability of the mst to separate groups of african countries according to their main export destinations and the show how opposite are the situations of those that export to `` china '' from the countries that have africa itself as their main export destinations . regarding centrality ,
ago occupies the most central position of the network since this country exports to the top most african export destinations ( `` china '' and `` europe '' ) being therefore , and by this means , easily connected to a large amount of other countries . indeed , ago is the center of the most central cluster of `` china '' exporters . on the other hand
, many leaf positions are occupied by countries that exports to other african countries as they have the smallest centrality in the whole network , they are ken , nam and swa .
their weak centrality is due to the fact that their leading export destinations are spread over several countries ( zmb , tza , zaf , bwa and ind ) .
figure 8 shows the mst obtained from the csn@xmath0 and colored according to the main export commodity of each country in 2014 .
the first observation on the mst presented in figure 8 is that , centrality is concentrated in a fewer number of countries ( when compared to the mst of the dsn@xmath0 ) .
the top most central and connected positions are shared by countries belonging to two regional organizations : sadc and cedeao , being mainly represented by zaf and ago and clustering countries whose main export commodities are `` diamonds '' and `` petroleum '' , respectively .
unsurprisingly , centrality and connectivity advantages seem to be concentrated in these two leading commodity partitions ( `` diamonds '' and `` petroleum '' ) and organization groups ( sadc and cedeao ) .
indeed , half of cedeao countries occupy the upper branch rooted in zaf and having `` diamonds''(yellow ) as their main export commodity .
another regional cluster is rooted in ago and tie together several uma countries whose main export commodity is `` petroleum''(blue ) . on the other hand ,
half of uma countries are far from each other on the tree , they occupy the leaf positions , being weakly connected to the other african countries to which , the few connections they establish rely on having `` manufactured '' as their main export commodity .
likewise , there is a branch clustering exporters of `` raw materials''(green ) being also placed at the leaf positions on the tree .
such a lack of centrality of `` raw materials '' exporters in the csn@xmath0 seems to be due to the fact that their leading export products are spread over many different commodities ( the `` raw materials '' partition comprises 12 different commodities ) .
in the last decade , a debate has taken place in the network literature about the application of network approaches to model international trade . in this context , and
even though recent research suggests that african countries are among those to which exports can be a vehicle for poverty reduction , these countries have been insufficiently analyzed .
we have proposed the definition of trade networks where each bilateral relation between two african countries is defined from the relations each of these countries hold with another entity .
both networks were defined from empirical data reported for 2014.they are independent bipartite networks : a destination share network ( dsn@xmath0 ) and a commodity share network ( csn@xmath2 ) . in the former , two african countries are linked if they share a mutual leading destination of exports , and in the latter , countries are linked through the existence of a mutual leading export commodity between them .
1 . sharing a mutual export destination happens more often : the very first remark coming out from the observation of both the dsn@xmath0 and the csn@xmath2 is that , in 2014 and for the 49 african countries , sharing a mutual exporting product happens less often than sharing a mutual destination of exports .
2 . great exporting countries tend to be more linked : there is a positive correlation between strong connected countries in both the dsn@xmath0 and the csn@xmath0 and those with high amounts of export values in 2014 .
it is in line with recent research placed in two different branches of the literature on international trade : the world trade web ( wtw ) empirical exploration ( @xcite,@xcite,@xcite,@xcite , benedictis,@xcite,@xcite ) and the one that specifically focus on african trade ( @xcite,@xcite , morrissey,@xcite,@xcite,@xcite ) .
references ( @xcite,@xcite ) reports on the role of export performance to economic growth .
they also discuss on the relation between trade and development , and on the growth by destination hypothesis , according to which , the destination of exports can play an important role in determining the trade pattern of a country and its development path .
destination matters : the idea that destination matters is in line with our finding that in the dsn@xmath0 , the highest connected nodes are those whose main export destination is china .
according to baliamoune - lutz ( baliamoune ) export concentration enhances the growth effects of exporting to china , implying that countries which export one major commodity to china benefit more ( in terms of growth ) than do countries that have more diversified exports . * the china effect : one of the patterns that came out from our dsn@xmath0 shows that half of ceeac and sadc countries belongs to the bulk of `` china '' destination cluster , having high betweenness centrality .
additionally , the `` china '' destination group of countries displays the highest clustering coefficient ( 0.96 ) , meaning that , besides having china as their main exports destination , the second destination of exports of the countries in this group is highly concentrated on a few countries . *
the role of intra - african trade : another important pattern coming out from the mst of the dsn@xmath0 shows how opposite are the situations of the countries that export to `` china '' from the countries that have africa itself as their main export destinations . in the mst of the destination share network ,
many leaf positions are occupied by intra - african exporters as they have the smallest centrality in the whole network .
their weak centrality is due to the fact that their leading export destinations are spread over several countries .
this result is in line with the results reported by reference ( @xcite ) where the growing importance of intra - african trade is discussed and proven to be a crucial channel for the expansion of african exports .
moreover , kamuganga found significant correlation between the participation in intra - african trade and the diversification of exports . * the angola cluster : our results highlighted the remarkable centrality of ago as the center of the most central cluster of `` china '' exporters . indeed , ago is the country that holds the most central position when
both dsn@xmath0 and csn@xmath0 are considered .
this country occupies in both cases the center of the largest central clusters : `` china '' exporters in dsn@xmath0 and exporters of `` petroleum '' in csn@xmath0 .
* uma countries anti - diversification : in the opposite situation , we found that uma countries display very low centrality , showing that besides having `` europe '' as their first export destination , the second destination of exports of uma countries is spread over several countries .
this result is in line with reference ( gamberoni ) report on european unilateral trade preferences and anti - diversification effects .
we showed that uma countries occupy a separate branch in the mst of the dsn@xmath0 , being `` europe '' their most frequent destination of exports .
4 . in the csn@xmath0 ,
the highest connected nodes are those that cluster as `` petroleum '' exporters , being followed by those that export `` diamonds '' . unsurprisingly
, `` raw materials '' exporters display very low connectivity as their second main exporting product is spread over several different commodities .
organizations matter : regional and organizational concerns seem to have some impact in the csn@xmath0 . * sadc and petroleum : the group of sadc countries , although comprising a large number of elements , is the one with the poorest connectivity and clustering in the csn@xmath0 .
it is certainly due to the fact that without ago and moz , this large group of countries does not comprise `` petroleum '' exporters .
* uma countries anti - diversification : again in the csn@xmath0 , its mst shows that uma countries are placed on a separate branch .
although they are countries with high amounts of export values in 2014 , uma countries display low connectivity and low centrality .
the leaf positions in the mst of either dsn@xmath0 or csn@xmath0 - while occupied by countries with very low centrality and connectivity - were shown to characterize countries that export mainly to `` europe '' and whose main exporting product is `` raw materials '' .
future work is planned to be twofold .
we plan to further improve the definition of networks of african countries , enlarging the set of similarities that define the links between countries in order to include aspects like mother language , currencies , demography and participation in trade agreements .
on the other hand , we also plan to apply our approach to different time periods .
as soon as we can relate the structural similarities baliamoune - lutz , m. ( 2011 ) growth by destination ( where you export matters ) : trade with china and growth in african countries in african development review , special issue : special issue on the 2010 african economic conference on setting the agenda for africa s economic recovery and long - term growth v.23 , 2 .
gamberoni , e. ( 2007 ) do unilateral trade preferences help export diversification ?
an investigation of the impact of the european unilateral trade preferences on intensive and extensive margin of trade , iheid working paper 17 .
picciolo , f. ; squartini , t. ; ruzzenenti , f. ; basosi , r. and garlaschelli , d. ( 2012 ) the role of distances in the world trade web , _ in _ proceedings of the eighth international conference on signal - image technology & internet - based systems ( sitis 2012 ) . | this paper is a contribution to interweaving two lines of research that have progressed in separate ways : network analyses of international trade and the literature on african trade and development .
gathering empirical data on african countries has important limitations and so does the space occupied by african countries in the analyses of trade networks . here
, these limitations are dealt with by the definition of two independent bipartite networks : a destination share network and a commodity share network .
these networks - together with their corresponding minimal spanning trees - allow to uncover some ordering emerging from african exports in the broader context of international trade .
the emerging patterns help to understand important characteristics of african exports and its binding relations to other economic , geographic and organizational concerns as the recent literature on african trade , development and growth has shown .
financial support from national funds by fct ( fundao para a cincia e a tecnologia ) .
this article is part of the strategic project : uid / eco/00436/2013 keywords : trade networks , african exports , spanning trees , bipartite graphs |
in hierachical cosmological scenarios galaxies and clusters form in virialized dark matter dominated halos that are assembled via merging and accretion of smaller structures ( white & rees 1978 , davis _
et al _ 1985 ; for a recent analysis , e.g. tormen 1997 , 1998 ) . until recently , to what extent the _ subhalos _ survive within the potential well of the larger system has been largely uncertain , because cosmological @xmath13-body simulations were not able to resolve more than a handful of substructure halos ( e.g. carlberg 1994 , summers , davis & evrard 1995 , frenk _ et al _ 1996 ) .
infalling subhalos are heated by tidal forces generated by the global potential and by mutual encounters and rapidly lose a large fraction of their masses ; this is a physical effect but is greatly enhanced by limited numerical resolution .
the finite resolution sets an upper limit to the potential depth of halos - large force softening or low numbers of particles per halo conspire to produce soft , diffuse substructure halos that are easily disrupted by tidal forces ( moore , katz & lake 1996 ) and lead to structureless virialised halos .
this is the classic _ overmerging _ problem ( white _ et al _ 1987 ) .
gas physics is not a solution ; it is necessary to accurately reproduce the dynamics of the ( dominant ) dark matter component .
it is now clear that mass and force resolution of the simulations are the key parameters for overcoming the overmerging problem ( moore , katz & lake 1996 , brainerd , goldberg & villumsen 1998 , moore _
et al _ 1998 , ghigna _ et al _ 1998 , tormen , diaferio & syers 1998 , klypin , gottlber , kravtsov & kokhlov 1999a , okamoto & habe 1999 ) .
increased resolution leads to substructure halos ( _ subhalos _ hereafter ) with higher central densities , enabling them to survive .
halos extracted from large cosmological simulations and re - simulated ( see next section ) with @xmath26 particles and force resolution @xmath27 of the virial radius yield a wealth of substructure allowing a comparison between the mass and light distributions within clusters and galaxies ( ghigna _ et al _ 1998 , hereafter g98 ; okamoto & habe 1999 , moore _
tormen , diaferio & syers ( 1998 ) have addressed the same issue using a sample of clusters simulated at lower resolution .
high - resolution simulations of moderately large cosmological volumes that retain significant amounts of substructure within virialized halos have also become recently feasible ( klypin _ et al _ 1999a , hereafter kgkk ; klypin , kravtsov , valenzuela & prada 1999b ; coln , klypin , kravtsov & khokhlov 1999 ; coln , klypin & kravtsov 1999 ; see also kauffman _ et al _ 1999a , 1999b and diaferio _ et al _ 1999 ) .
these latter approaches have the advantage of providing relatively large samples of dark matter halos representing clusters , groups or galaxies , but can not detect systematic biases introduced by the limited resolution .
the central density profile of halos is also affected by numerical resolution . in order to compare the predictions of hierarchical models with observational data on the mass , light and x - ray profiles of clusters ( e.g. carlberg _ et al _
1996 , carlberg , yee & ellingson 1997 , smail _ et al _ 1997 ,
abdelsalam , saha & williams 1998 , adami , mazure , katgert & biviano 1998 , allen 1998 , markevitch , vikhlin , forman & sarazin 1999 ) , galaxy rotation curves ( e.g. moore 1994 , flores & primack 1994 , moore _
et al _ 1999b and references therein ) , giant arc properties in gravitationally lensing clusters
( e.g. kneib _ et al _ 1996 ; also , williams , navarro & bartelmann 1999 , flores , maller & primack 2000 , meneghetti _ et al _ 2000 ) or constraints on processes directly related to the nature of the dark matter , such as particle - particle annihilation rates ( calcaneo - roldan & moore , in preparation ) , it is important to resolve the central structure of dark matter halos . using @xmath13-body simulations with @xmath28 particles per halo for the cdm models and its popular variants , navarro , frenk & white ( 1996 , 1997 ) found that the profiles of isolated relaxed dark matter halos can be well described by a `` universal '' profile ( nfw profile ) from galactic to cluster scales ; these results have been confirmed by other authors using simulations of comparable resolution
e.g cole & lacey 1996 , tormen , bouchet & white 1996 . however , improving the numerical resolution ( moore _ et al _ 1998 ) leads to profiles with central cusps significantly steeper than that of an nfw profile ( @xmath29 for the latter ) ; halos simulated with @xmath30 particles have profiles fit by the functional form @xmath31^{-1}$ ] ( moore _ et al _
1999b ) , which has a cusp @xmath32 as @xmath33 .
( in a recent analysis , jing & suto , 2000 , find similar results for galaxies and groups , but shallower central profiles for a sample of clusters simulated in a @xmath34cdm cosmology ; see our comments in 4 ) . in this paper
, we examine how much resolution per halo is required to make numerical effects negligible for various physical quantities and obtain robust results on the halo density profiles and the space , mass , velocity distribution of substructures .
we perform one large ( and expensive ) simulation of a dark matter halo , taking the simulation originally analysed by ghigna _
et al _ ( 1998 ; hereafter g98 ) and increasing the force and mass resolution by almost an order of magnitude .
the plan of the paper is as follows : in 2 , we describe the n - body simulations and , in 3 ,
the method used to identify the substructure halos . in 4 , we consider the issue of the typical density profile of isolated and substructure halos .
section 5 is devoted to the statisitcal properties of the substructure , the effects of resolution , evolution and environment .
we study the distribution of their internal velocities and masses , their spatial distribution and whether they trace the mass , and also the issue of velocity bias . in 7
, we examine the relation between the cluster progenitor halos at high redshift and the substructure halos at the present epoch , and the formation of the central `` cd '' halo .
we summarise the results and conclude in 8 .
[ s : intro ]
our aim is to achieve very high spatial and mass resolution within the dark halo of a cluster drawn from a fair volume " of a standard cdm universe . to achieve such resolution
, we initially perform a simulation of a large volume ( @xmath35 per side ) of a cdm universe ( normalised such that @xmath36 and with the shape parameter @xmath37 and @xmath2 ) .
the size of this box is nearly ten times the turnaround radius allowing the tidal field and hence infall pattern to be modelled correctly .
we choose a cluster that is virialised by a redshift @xmath38 and use a technique of volume renormalization " to obtain higher resolution within the region of interest ( see g98 and references therein ) .
our goal is to simulate the formation of this cluster such that @xmath39 particles lie within the turnaround radius at the final time .
( note that if we simulated the entire volume at this resolution we would need to use a total of @xmath40 particles . ) beyond the turnaround region the mass resolution is decreased in a series of shells allowing us to reproduce the external tidal field correctly .
the particle distribution is evolved using the high performance parallel treecode pkdgrav , using periodic boundaries and a variable timestep scheme based upon the local acceleration ( quinn _ et al _ 1997 , wadsley , quinn & stadel 2000 , in preparation ) . to maintain accurate forces when the mass distribution is fairly regular , from a redshift z=69 to z=2 we use an opening angle of @xmath41 and we complete the simulation using an opening angle of 0.7 .
we expand the cell moments to hexadecapole order .
the code uses a spline softening length such that the force is completely newtonian at twice our quoted softening lengths .
the time integration method is an adaptive implementation of the standard leapfrog integration scheme .
individual particle time steps @xmath42 are chosen to satisfy the criterium @xmath43 , where @xmath44 is the force softening length of a particle , @xmath45 the magnitude of the local acceleration and @xmath46 a constant determined on the basis of stability and accuracy requirements ( for these runs @xmath47 ) . in order to maintain synchronization of the system
, the time steps are quantized on power - of - two subdivisions of the largest time step ( the `` system '' time step @xmath48 ) , i.e. @xmath49 ( e.g. , hernquist & katz 1989 ) . for these runs ,
5001000 system steps are used , equally spaced in time . here
we consider two simulations of the cluster ( the same object as in g98 ) with largely different resolutions , which we label lores and hires .
in the high resolution region of the box , the particle mass is @xmath50 for lores and @xmath51 for hires ; the softening is 1 and @xmath52 respectively . at the final epoch ,
the cluster has a radius @xmath53 ( @xmath54 is the radius within which the average density is 200 times the cosmic density and it is a measure of the extent of the virialized region ) and a mass within such radius @xmath55 . with these parameters , run hires has more than 4 million particles within @xmath54 , a factor of 8 of improvement with respect to lores .
= 5truecm the mass growth curve of this cluster is shown in figure 3 of ghigna _ et al _ ( 1998 ) .
the cluster does not undergo major mergers since @xmath56 ; the virial mass increases by @xmath57% since that epoch , while the mass within the physical volume of the @xmath38 cluster ( i.e. the mass within @xmath58 ) grows by only @xmath15% .
the early formation and `` quiet '' recent history of the cluster are convenient for this study , since they allows us to single out the effects of tides from major accretion or merger events .
the results presented here are very likely typical of observed well relaxed clusters , but can not be easily generalized to objects with more turbulent recent histories .
[ s : nbody ]
the wealth of substructure that exists within the cluster is exemplified by figure [ f:2maps ] .
the panels show maps of the projected density distribution in a box of side @xmath59 for lores ( upper ) and hires ( lower panel ) . each particle is plotted using a grey scale according to the logarithm of the local density ( defined using an sph smoothing kernel over 64 neighbouring particles using the code _
smooth _ of stadel & quinn 1997 , http ref : http://wwwhpcc.astro.washington.edu/tools ) .
only regions with density contrast @xmath60 are shown .
the change of resolution from lores to hires has a dramatic effect on the abundance of substructure : lower mass objects are resolved throughout the cluster and features appear in the very central region which was previously smooth .
the density maps are obtained at redshift @xmath56 , at which epoch more than 80% of the mass of the cluster is in place , yet it is not fully relaxed . in figure [ f:2maps ] , we can see three dominant substructure clumps ( center , north , south - west ) .
similar features are observed in the light and x - ray distribution of observed high - redshift clusters ( e.g. abell 521 ; maurogordato _ et al _ 2000 ) . by @xmath38 , the second largest clump merges with the central object , the dark counterpart of a cd galaxy . at @xmath56 , the cluster s radius and masses
are @xmath61 ( physical units ) and @xmath62 . identifying the substructure halos
is a critical step ( g98 , kgkk ) .
here we use the group finding algorithm skid , developed by stadel _
et al _ ( for a full description of the code see http://wwwhpcc.astro.washington.edu/tools ) .
skid is a `` lagrangian '' version of denmax ( gelb & bertschinger 1994 ) , the densities being evaluated at each particle position using an sph smoothing kernel rather than at the nodes of a grid .
the particles are moved along the density gradients until each oscillates around a point .
they are then linked using a friends - of - friends algorithm ( fof ; davis _ et al _ 1985 ) and the groups ( halos ) found are checked iteratively for self - boundness . in g98 we have verified the efficiency of skid and tested the robustness of its estimates of the halo structural parameters ( see below ) against alternative methods . the ability of skid to single out particles bound to substructure from the diffuse particles bound solely to the entire cluster ( smooth background particles ) depends crucially on the linking length , @xmath63 , adopted for the fof stage .
if @xmath63 is too small a subhalo will be fragmented into smaller units whereas if it is too large then halos will be merged together . a value @xmath64 , where @xmath65 is the distance from the halo s center at which the circular velocity profile has its peak @xmath66 ( see , e.g. , g98 , section 3.3 ) , is usually satisfactory . in our simulations ,
the subhalos have a large range of sizes and there is not a value for @xmath63 that is ideal for all of them at a time ; moreover there are many instances of substructure halos that contain their own substructure `` halos within halos within halos '' . to account for the complete hierarchy of substructure present in the current simulation we run skid with three values of @xmath67 , 5 and @xmath68 , and combine the outputs avoiding duplication .
( skid run with @xmath69 provides the first level of the `` hierarchy '' of halos ; we then add the second level obtained with @xmath70 but discarding those halos that are separated from a first - level halo by a distance less than the latter s @xmath65 ; and so forth for the third level .
the completeness of the final halo catalog in several regions of the cluster was verified against the density concentrations visible in the 3d density map )
. however , it turns out that for the statistics of intermediate - to - massive halos ( e.g. those with circular velocities larger than @xmath71 ) a run of skid with @xmath72 is adequate ( and fast ) .
= 6.0truecm we consider halos with a minimum number of member particles of 16 ( corresponding to a mass of @xmath73 in hires ) . in general , we use halos with more than 16 particles when they are employed as tracers , but we adopt a minimum number of 32 particles when their individual properties are relevant .
the high resolution region analyzed is roughly the final turn - around radius , about twice the virial radius . within this region , in hires , we identify over 2000 substructure halos . within @xmath54 , there are @xmath74 1200 halos at the final epoch and @xmath75 at @xmath56 .
the innermost halo is at @xmath76 from the cluster s center although about ten halos lie within a projected distance of @xmath76 .
we use the output of skid to determine the halo structural parameters : radius @xmath77 , mass @xmath78 and `` circular velocity '' @xmath16 ( the latter is the peak value of the rotation curve @xmath79 , where @xmath80 is the halo mass within a distance @xmath81 from its center ) . in 4.1 of g98 , we discussed the effects of numerical resolution on the completeness of subhalo samples .
we modelled the substructure halos as isothermal spheres embedded in a larger isothermal potential the cluster s halo and used the standard formula for tidal stripping by the cluster s potential to estimate the limiting radii ( tidal stripping is the main cause of subhalo disruption , once the cluster is in place ) .
( using nfw profiles to model the halos would not change our estimates significantly ; see kgkk for a semi - analytical calculation using nfw profiles ) . applying this simple model to the present simulation
indicates that the halo samples obtained from lores and hires should not be affected by major incompleteness for substructure halos with @xmath82 100 and @xmath83 , respectively , assuming pericenters greater than @xmath84 .
we take these values as _ quasi - completeness limits _ of the subhalo samples ; they mark the values of @xmath16 below which the samples become apparently incomplete .
these estimates do not take into account halo disruption at redshifts @xmath85 , before the cluster is assembled .
for instance , following the cluster s progenitors from high redshift to the present shows that the sample derived from hires may be @xmath86% incomplete starting from @xmath87 ( see 7 ) .
[ s : iden ] = 6.0truecm
one of the most fundamental properties of dark matter halos is their global density profile .
@xmath13-body simulations have been extensively used to study the structure of cold dark matter halos , yielding a variety of important results ( e.g. quinn _ et al _ 1986 , frenk _ et al _ 1988 , dubinsky & carlberg 1991 , carlberg 1994 , navarro , frenk & white 1996 , 1997 , cole & lacey 1996 , tormen , bouchet & white 1996 , fukushige & makino 1997 , brainerd _
et al _ 1998 , g98 , tormen , diaferio & syer 1998 , huss , jain & steinmetz 1999 , kgkk , okamoto & habe 1999 ) .
systematic studies of halos across a wide range of masses has revealed a remarkable one parameter scaling ( nfw profile ; navarro , frenk & white 1996 , 1997 ) , with a density profile of the form @xmath88 , where @xmath89 is the spherically - averaged density at the distance @xmath81 from the halo s center and @xmath90 a scale radius .
the halos studied by nfw had @xmath91 particles within their virial radii and were resolved to a scale of a few % of this region .
et al _ ( 1998 , 1999b ) showed that increasing the resolution by about an order of magnitude produces steeper central cusps , @xmath92 .
is the current resolution sufficient to resolve the central density profile of cdm halos or will increasing the resolution make the cusp even steeper ?
figure [ f : profiles ] shows the density profile of the cluster , measured in three runs with different resolutions @xmath93 and @xmath94 particles within the final virial radius .
the lower solid curve shows the expected nfw curve for a halo of this mass in this cosmology .
it provides a good fit to our lowest resolution simulation but underestimates the central density of the higher resolution runs .
the upper solid curve shows the slightly modified profile proposed by moore _
et al _ ( 1999 ; henceforth m99a ) , @xmath31^{-1}$ ] , where @xmath90 is a scale radius . with increasing resolution
, the cluster s profile appears to converge ( asymptotically ) to m99a s curve .
the asymptotic profile is attained in the regions that have many particles and beyond several softening lengths ; as it is shown by the vertical bars , density profiles measured from these @xmath13-body simulations can be `` trusted '' only for scales @xmath95 times the force resolution .
this statement is likely to apply to simulations run with different techniques , provided force and mass resolutions are well balanced , but a detailed study of a large number of halos systematically varying the numerical parameters , time - stepping criteria etc , would be necessary to establish this ( see also moore , katz & lake 1996 and moore _
et al _ 1998 ) . with increasing resolution
, the profiles of substructure halos become closer to those of isolated halos .
figure 3 compares the `` typical '' profile of subhalos with @xmath96 in lores and hires ( obtained for each run by averaging the profiles of three subhalos with @xmath97 and @xmath16 close to 200@xmath98 ) with the profile of a similar isolated halo , simulated with 10@xmath99 particles ( data taken from moore _
et al _ 1999 ) .
it is interesting to note that the typical subhalo profile is steeper in lores than in hires , perhaps as a result of numerical relaxation between the hot halo particles and cold subhalo particles .
this confirms that caution is required when studying the properties of the profiles of substructure halos even in high - resolution simulations ( g98 ; avila - reese _ et al _ 1999 , bullock _ et al _ 1999 ) . in a recent paper ,
jing & suto ( 1999 ) claim that the central density profiles of four simulated cdm clusters are closer to -1.1 than -1.5 as found here .
we suspect that this difference may be due to the resolution . jing etal use a plummer softening with quoted resolution @xmath100 ( their figure 2 ) and they measure the central slopes using the data between @xmath101 .
this region may be dominated by dynamics on scales of order the softening ( as seen above , we find that the profiles are reliable at scales that are 3 times the scale at which the force becomes newtonian our spline softening is completely newtonian at twice the quoted values whereas a plummer softening is still `` softer '' than newtonian at the resolution quoted by jing & suto ) .
it should be noted that a steep central profile ( with @xmath102 ) was also found by moore _
et al _ 1998 using a high resolution simulation of a different cluster ( the `` coma '' cluster ) . at the resolutions achieved here and
in jing etal , only a handful of systems have been studied and the same cluster has not been simulated using different codes .
we have placed our initial conditions on our website ( www.nbody.net ) so that other researchers can run this cluster and compare with the results presented here and in ghigna _
et al _ ( 1998 ) .
= 6truecm the `` circular '' velocities @xmath16 of the subhalos are the quantities that can be most easily compared with observations ( although the relation between @xmath16 and the rotation curve or velocity dispersion of the visible component of a galaxy is not straightforward ; e.g. navarro , frenk & white 1996 ) .
tidal truncation usually changes the mass of a halo by a large amount ( often by @xmath103 - 90% ) , however the peak circular velocity is a fairly stable quantity and can be regarded , to some extent , as a `` label '' that can identify a halo for several billion years within the cluster environment .
= 6truecm major or total halo disruption is significant for those few massive halos ( with @xmath104 ) that take part in the formation of the cluster and undergo similar - mass mergers during the early phases of the assemblage , at @xmath105 ( see 7 ) ; once the cluster is in place , the dynamical friction timescale is much larger than a hubble time even for halos with mass @xmath106 ( for recent analyses on dynamical friction see van den bosch _ et al _ 1999 and colpi , mayer & governato 1999 ) .
most of the substructure halos with small to intermediate masses survive within the cluster . on average , their central masses ( the mass within @xmath65 ) do not change dramatically and @xmath16 varies only as the cubed root of the mass . over 5 billion years ,
@xmath16 varies by @xmath86% and mainly for halos that spend a large fraction of their orbital period in the inner region of the cluster ( g98 , kgkk ; see also below ) . furthermore ,
since mergers are rare in clusters ( g98 , okamoto & habe 1999 ) , most halos conserve their identities .
this fact is useful , for example , to compare the @xmath16 distribution of a cluster s substructure halos with that of their progenitors predicted using the press - schechter ( ps ) approximation .
the differential velocity distribution function ( vdf ) , defined as the number of halos per unit velocity interval per unit ( physical ) volume , is shown in figures [ f : dvf2res ] and [ f : dvf_zs ] .
the first figure shows the effect of changing resolution .
it compares the curves obtained for hires ( solid line ) and lores ( dotted ) at the final epoch ( @xmath38 , upper panel ) and for the young cluster ( @xmath56 , lower panel ) .
we have used all the halos contained within the virial radius , @xmath54 , at the two epochs , @xmath107 and @xmath61 respectively .
the fall off at the low - velocity end are caused by incompleteness due to limited resolution , which dominates hires and lores samples for @xmath108 and @xmath109 , respectively .
lores s curve appears to be slightly affected by resolution up to @xmath110 ; beyond that @xmath16 , the results for the two runs agree well . in that range ,
the vdf at @xmath38 is reasonably well approximated by a power - law with exponent @xmath111 , motivated by the ps approximation for field halos in this mass range ( e.g. gross _ et al _ 1998 , tormen 1998 , jenkins _
et al _ 1999 ; klypin _ et al _ 1999b ) .
in order to single out evolutionary effects , we compare directly the halo distributions for run hires at the two epochs in figure [ f : dvf_zs ] . in the main panel of the figure
, we compare the vdfs measured for the halos within the _ same physical ( or proper ) volume _ , as determined by the virial radius of the cluster at @xmath38 .
there is virtually no difference between the curves for the two redshifts ( solid and dashed curves ) ; the vdf is essentially `` frozen '' in time .
we find the same result for the _ normalized _ vdfs , that is , the vdfs obtained considering only the subhalos within r200 at each respective epoch and measuring circular velocities and distances in units of the cluster s circular velocity and virial radius , also at the respective epoch ; the comparison of the two curves is shown in the inset of the figure .
( for these plots , we only show data for @xmath16 greater than the quasi - completeness limit of hires . )
the amplitude of the vdf of the subhalos ( those within @xmath112-@xmath113 ) decreases a little over time , corresponding to a decrement of @xmath16 of about 20% .
tidal stripping removes particles orbiting at the outskirts of substructure halos but tidal heating of the halo cores , from tidal shocks near pericenter or from halo - halo encounters may also affect their concentrations and accelerate particles to the halo boundaries .
a 20% decrement of @xmath16 corresponds to a @xmath114% decrement of the mass .
this effect may be physical but can be enhanced by limited resolution .
in fact , the lores simulation exhibits excessive mass loss of the inner halos with medium - to - small masses if compared with hires ( see next section ) .
kgkk have examined the central mass loss of a model subhalo of @xmath115 , orbiting in a rich cluster with pericenter @xmath116 , varying the mass and spatial resolution ( see their 2.4 ) .
the halo s central mass loss depends on the force softening used , if the latter exceeds a certain `` optimal '' value ( @xmath117 of the halo s tidal radius at pericenter , for a plummer softening ; interestingly , the dependance on the particle mass is very weak ) ; however , beyond the `` optimal '' resolution , the time evolution of the central mass appears to converge to a step function which drops by 20 - 30% at every passage at pericenter , yielding a mass loss of @xmath114% over 5 billion years ( the orbital period in their model is 2 gyrs ) . in the hires simulation ,
the `` optimal '' resolution indicated by kgkk s test is met e.g. by subhalos of @xmath87 at @xmath118 and subhalos of @xmath115 at @xmath119 ( we use the isothermal model approximation described in 3 to obtain these estimates ) .
the fractions of inner subhalos with @xmath120 and @xmath121 and with estimated pericenters less than @xmath122 and @xmath84 respectively are @xmath123% in both cases ; therefore the decrease of the vdf from @xmath56 to @xmath38 may be affected by numerical resolution , but , since the corresponding mass loss is close to the value expected from kgkk s test , it is probably a physical effect . in any case
, it sets an upper limit .
( for comparison , in lores , the `` optimal '' resolution for @xmath124 is met only if @xmath125 ) .
the shape of the vdf does not depend significantly on the environment .
this is also shown by figure [ f : dvf_zs ] , where we plot the vdf for the inner subhalos ( @xmath126 ; upper dotted line ) and those in the cluster s periphery ( @xmath127 ; lower dotted line ) .
a power - law @xmath128 is always a reasonable fit for @xmath129 .
= 6truecm ( 300 , 150 ) ( 0 , 60 ) = 8.4truecm = 6.truecm knowledge of the mass distribution function ( mdf ) is useful to estimate the disruptive power of halo - halo collisions in dense environments .
for example , modelling this process is necessary to understand the origin of intracluster light and the morphological evolution of galaxies in clusters and groups ( `` galaxy harassment '' ; moore _ et al _ 1996 ) .
the mass and radii of substructure halos can also be probed directly using mass - reconstruction methods based on observations of arcs and arclets in clusters ( natarajan _ et al _ 1998 ) .
= 6truecm the mdf provides information independent of that derived from the vdf .
the mass of a halo of given @xmath16 depends on its orbital history , which determines the extent of tidal disruption that it has suffered .
this strongly correlates with the smallest pericentric distance reached by a halo ( g98 ) and , to a lesser degree , with the number of orbits completed ( since a halo loses mass very quickly the first time it passes through pericenter and more slowly every time it completes an orbit ; kgkk ) .
however , since halos of different masses but with the same pericenter lose similar fractions of mass and the distribution of pericenters does not depend significantly on mass ( g98 ) , we still have roughly @xmath130 , even for the subhalos .
= 6truecm figure [ f : dmf_2res ] plots the mdf for the substructure halos ( defined as the number of halos per unit logarithmic mass interval per unit physical volume ) .
results are shown for both runs at the two redshifts considered previously . at @xmath56 , the agreement between hires and lores is good .
the mass limit for which both runs are close to completeness ( in the circular velocity distribution ) is @xmath131 , the typical value for a halo with @xmath132 ( see figure 20 of g98 ) . at @xmath38 ,
the mdf for the lores cluster is @xmath114% lower than for the hires simulations .
this difference , as for the vdf , is caused by numerically enhanced mass loss near the cluster s center ; it disappears if we exclude the halos in the central region , @xmath133 , from the counts ( figure [ f : dmf_coreless ] ) .
as discussed in the previous section , our hires run is not affected significantly by artificial mass loss for @xmath134 , i.e @xmath135 .
as found for the vdf , the mdf does not exhibit significant evolution within a physical volume during the lifetime of the cluster ( figure [ f : dmf_zs ] , main panel ) . at both redshifts ,
the mdf is close to a power - law @xmath136 , for @xmath137 , but becomes shallower for lower masses , @xmath138 ( in the figure , we plot @xmath139 ) .
the main panel of figure [ f : dmf_zs ] also shows the mdf for inner and outer halos ( symbols as for figure [ f : dvf_zs ] ) ; all the curves are similar , with slopes varying between @xmath140 and @xmath141 .
the inset shows the normalized mdfs for the cluster subhalos at the two redshifts , obtained in a similar way as the normalized vdfs of figure [ f : dvf_zs ] in the previous section .
the mass bound to substructure halos is a little more than 10% of the total cluster mass , with more fractional mass in halos at early rather than at late epochs .
the value varies very slowly with resolution , but it can oscillate significantly since a large fraction of the mass belongs to the two or three most massive subhalos ( @xmath142 ) that contribute @xmath143% .
if they are close to the cluster s center or if they possess their own substructure , the masses measured by skid are quite sensitive to the linking length used and can differ significantly from estimates obtained adopting the spherical overdensity method ( see g98 ) , sometimes by a factor of 2 .
for instance , using the spherical overdensity method for lores we find a global fraction of mass in subhalos of @xmath144% ( g98 ) , while using skid s masses this value reduces to @xmath145% . if we exclude the largest substructure halos , different mass estimates yield halo mass fractions differing only by about 1%
. figure [ f : mfrac_v ] plots the fraction of cluster mass that is in subhalos with circular velocity above a given value @xmath16 , but below @xmath146 the difference between the two runs never exceeds 1% .
also , between @xmath56 and @xmath38 , the mass fraction decreases by only @xmath147% ( note that the mass fraction is computed relative to the virial mass , @xmath148 , at the respective epoch , namely @xmath149 and @xmath150 ) .
where the halo samples are close to completeness , the results are well represented by the function @xmath151 + \beta$ ] , with @xmath152-@xmath153 .
the mass fraction varies roughly linearly with clustercentric distance ( g98 , figure 11 ) .
( 300 , 460 ) ( 0 , 290 ) = 8.4truecm = 6.truecm ( 0 , 60 ) = 8.4truecm = 6.truecm in this section , we examine the bias existing between the spatial distribution of particles ( i.e. , the mass ) and that of the subhalos . here , the bias is defined as the ratio @xmath154 , where @xmath155 and @xmath156 are the number density profiles of subhalos and particles as functions of clustercentric distance @xmath157 . for convenience
we normalize all quantities to the cluster parameters , i.e. we measure lengths in units of the virial radius , @xmath54 , and @xmath158 and @xmath159 as fractions of the total numbers of subhalos and particles within @xmath54
. the halo distribution will be ( positively ) biased if @xmath160 increases as @xmath157 decreases , anti - biased in the opposite case . in g98 we found that the halos are anti - biased ; coln _ et al _ ( 1999 ) also find anti - bias for dark matter halos in large volume simulations of four cosmological models ( they measure the bias defined by the ratio between the 2-point correlation functions of mass and dark matter halos , as it is customary for large scale structure studies ) . to study this problem
it is particularly important to pay attention to the limitations imposed by the finite resolution , since overmerging preferentially erasing subhalos in the central regions of the cluster always introduces anti - bias in the subhalo distribution ( or enhances it ) .
we compare the _ normalized _ ( or fractional ) number density profiles of halos and particles as a function of clustercentric distance @xmath157 in figure [ f : ndens_vs_p ] , for the redshifts @xmath56 and @xmath38 ( top and bottom panel respectively ) .
we plot the numbers of halos with @xmath161 in spherical shells of radius @xmath157 divided by the volume of the shell ( in units of @xmath54 ) , divided by the total number ( @xmath162 ) of cluster subhalos above the circular velocity limit ( the `` cluster '' subhalos are those contained in @xmath54 at the respective epoch ; this yields 188 and 219 subhalos if @xmath163 , and 104 and 110 if @xmath164 for hires , while for lores the corresponding numbers are 165 and 158 , and 116 and 100 ) . for the mass
, we plot the particle number density profile divided by the number of particles within @xmath54 . in each panel , the _
long dashed _
curves are the normalized mass profiles ; the two other curves are for the halos of hires ( _ solid with errobars _ ) and lores ( _ dotted _ ) .
for @xmath56 , we set @xmath163 , which yield good statistics ; for @xmath38 we use @xmath164 , which has similarly good statistics
. varying the value of @xmath165 does not make any difference , as long as there are enough halos to obtain significant measures .
= 6truecm within the cluster , at @xmath56 , the halos have a number density profile similar to that of the mass , but the latter profile declines more steeply than the former approaching the virial radius and beyond ( i.e. , @xmath166 ) .
this means that the population of halos ( for a circular velocity limited sample ) in the volume encompassing the cluster is globally anti - biased with proportionally fewer halos where the particles are more clustered . at @xmath38 , there is also anti - bias , the mass being clearly more concentrated than the halos ; for @xmath167% of @xmath54 , there is a factor of 2 of difference between the two profiles ( and is even larger if we require that the two profiles overlap beyond @xmath54 ) . at both redshifts , there are no significant differences between the curves for hires and lores
. therefore the halo number density profiles measured from this simulation should not be significantly affected by residual overmerging ( see also 6 ) .
figure [ f : ndens_zs ] compares directly the halo number density profiles at @xmath56 and @xmath38 in the physical ( proper ) volume centered on the cluster ( for both samples , we set @xmath168 ) .
the halos are clearly more concentrated in the volume of the newly formed cluster .
infalling material subsequently enhances the halo number density in the outer region , @xmath169 ( the virial radius of the cluster at @xmath56 ) , while tidal disruption in the inner region reduces the number density of halos with circular velocities above the limit .
it is interesting to note that allowing for a @xmath86% decrease of a halo s @xmath16 between @xmath56 and @xmath38 ( because of central mass loss , as observed in the vdf analysis in
5.3 ) is sufficient to recover most of the central steepness of the @xmath56 profile ; this is shown by the dotted line in the figure .
this indicates that , once the cluster is in place , tidal mass loss alone ( instead of total halo evaporation ) causes the measured decrement of the subhalo number density towards the cluster s center .
apart from tidal mass loss , mergers between halos during the cluster assembly ( at @xmath170 ) are probably a major cause of the anti - bias between halos and particles . at @xmath56 , the uniform anti - bias of the cluster subhalos ( with respect to the ` field ' ; as seen in figure [ f : ndens_vs_p ] , upper panel ) may reflect the fact that the cluster has only recently being assembled through the merging of group - sized halos of similar masses , so that mergers and tides have affected its subhalo population more uniformly .
note that the galaxies that would reside in the subhalos could have a different bias , if their circular velocities are not directly affected by the central mass loss of their dark halos . as a final word of caution , we point out that the issue of bias would be better addressed with a statistical sample of clusters and a more representative sample of field halos .
this approach requires a trade - off between statistics and resolution but considerable progress has recently been made ( coln _ et al _ 1999 ; see also kauffmann _ et al _ 1999a , b , diaferio _ et al _ 1999 , benson _
et al _ 2000 ) .
( 300 , 460 ) ( 0 , 290 ) = 8.4truecm = 6.truecm ( 0 , 60 ) = 8.4truecm = 6.truecm = 6truecm the issue of velocity bias the difference between galaxy and dark matter ( dm ) velocities was first addressed by carlberg & couchmann ( 1989 ) as a means of reconciling low measures of @xmath171 from the observed velocities of galaxies in clusters .
there are two types of velocity bias considered in the literature , the one - point velocity bias ( @xmath172 ) which compares the velocity dispersions of galaxies and dark matter particles ( e.g. carlberg & dubinski 1991 , carlberg 1994 ) and the two - point or pairwise velocity bias ( @xmath173 ) which compares the relative velocity dispersions in pairs of objects ( e.g. couchmann & carlberg 1992 ) . here
we consider the first type . a recent paper ( coln , klypin & kravtsov 1999 ; ckk hereafter ) focussed on the different forms of velocity bias for numerical simulations of the @xmath34cdm cosmology .
the situation is still rather confusing .
ckk find that the dark matter halos within clusters are positively biased , with @xmath174-@xmath25 ( similar results were also found by diaferio _ et al _ 1998 and okamoto & habe 1999 ) , while kgkk find @xmath175 for a similar set of data ( see their figure 15 ) . in g98 , we did not detect velocity bias
. the difference may be partly due to the fact that g98 and kgkk measure the global @xmath176 using the whole sample of cluster subhalos , while ckk consider the radial profile @xmath177 .
we re - examine the issue here in more detail .
note that the comparison between the spatial distribution of the halos and that of the mass considered in the previous section , does not provide sufficient information , since the scaled profiles of differently biased tracers may not differ much ( carlberg 1994 ) .
we compare the 3d velocity dispersion ( @xmath178 ) profiles of halos and dark matter for run hires in figure [ f : v3d ] ( the averages are taken in spherical shells of width @xmath179 ; at the center , @xmath178 for the dm drops sharply from @xmath180 at @xmath181 to @xmath182 at @xmath183 , if radial bins of width @xmath184 are used , as it is shown by the light solid curve in the lower panel of the figure ) .
we consider the cluster at @xmath38 ( lower panel ) and also the output at @xmath185 , separated in time from the final epoch by less than one typical subhalo orbital period ; we also subdivide the halos in three subsamples according to the values of their circular velocities ( as listed in the figure ) . in this way
, we should be able to single out significant differences between the ( 3d ) velocities of halos and dark matter from statistical flukes , partly overcoming the drawback of dealing with only one cluster .
the samples with @xmath186 have the worst statistics , especially for @xmath187 where they provide @xmath0 halos per bin . with quite large oscillations ,
the @xmath178 of the halos is consistent with that of the dark matter for @xmath188 . within the cluster ,
the data show a significant ( positive ) bias in the innermost bin , with @xmath189-@xmath25 .
the maximum amplitude of bias in our data is similar to that reported by ckk but the signal is globally weaker ( ckk have @xmath190 at @xmath191 , that is @xmath192 for the cluster studied here ) .
we also show the velocity dispersion profiles of halos and particles for run lores , in figure [ f : v3d_2kpc ] .
the trend of increasing @xmath176 with decreasing @xmath157 is more apparent in this case . here
, the sample with the lowest circular velocities is largely incomplete due to limited resolution ; interestingly , it exhibits a more marked bias than the other samples .
it is also interesting to note that there are no obvious biases in the distribution of the orbital parameters of the halos and the particles ( we have computed the orbits approximating the cluster potential to a static spherical potential obtained from its density profile , as in g98 ,
when we average over the virial volume of the cluster , the velocity bias of the halos in the central region has a small impact ; in the three cases considered previously , the global bias within @xmath54 is always less than @xmath193 ( although it remains positive ) . also considering only massive halos ( @xmath194 )
does not yield any significant bias . in this case
, anti - bias would be expected if dynamical friction were efficient in slowing down such halos , but the friction time for subhalos within a cluster is almost always larger than the hubble time ( see colpi , mayer & governato 1999 for a recent analysis ) . even restricting the samples to half the virial radius does not make a significant difference ( in one case , for hires at @xmath185 , there is anti - bias , but the other two yield positive or no bias , unless the `` cd@xmath195global potential '' is included ) . in conclusion , we find evidence of positive velocity bias in the central region of the cluster but the signal is much weaker than ckk s detection .
it seems that limited resolution enhances the signal ; overmerging accentuates the impact of physical processes like mergers and total halo disruption that could lead to positive velocity bias .
a larger set of high - resolution simulations would be welcome to address these issues with better statistics .
.results of tracing the cluster s progenitor halos at @xmath19 to the substructure halos at the final time ( _ descendents _ ) , for three ranges of mass of the progenitors ( corresponding to more than @xmath196 , between @xmath196 and @xmath197 , and between @xmath197 and 100 particles ) .
the first and second columns report the minimum circular velocity of the progenitors in each mass range and their number ; the third and fourth columns give , respectively , the percentage of progenitors in each range with a descendent at @xmath38 other than the `` cd '' object , and the percentage of progenitors that merge with the `` cd '' .
( these values are obtained requiring for the descendents a minimum number of traced particles @xmath198 equal to 1% of the particles in the progenitor and not less than 4 ; there is no difference if we set @xmath198 to be at least 16 ) . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] as seen in 5 , over the lifetime of the cluster the abundance of substructure
does not appear to change significantly ; however substructure is erased also at earlier redshifts . to examine this issue ,
we have identified the dark matter halos that are progenitors of the cluster at @xmath19 and @xmath18 ( using the public friends - of - friends code available from http://wwwhpcc.astro.washington.edu/tools , run with a linking length of @xmath199 times the mean interparticle separation ) .
we define as progenitors those halos that contribute particles to the virial volume of the cluster at the final epoch .
we have then `` traced '' them to the substructure halos identified at @xmath38 , by comparing the indexes of their particles . for the @xmath38 subhalos
we use only the ` core ' particles , @xmath200 those that are separated from the halo centers by a distance less than the value of @xmath65 - this ( conservative ) approach avoids ambiguities when there is a hierarchy of substructure . for the central object
, we adopt a radius @xmath201 , a value that should single out the progenitor halos that merge to form the `` cd '' core against those that only supply particles to its halo through tidal stripping .
we accept descendents only if they have a number of traced particles larger than 1% of the particles of the progenitors and not less than a minimum number , @xmath198 , which we varied between 4 and 16 ( the number of particles traced can be small for small halos since we only consider their ` core ' particles ) . in our approach
, a progenitor with no descendent subhalos at @xmath38 should have been completely disrupted with its particles lost in the diffuse particle background of the cluster or , possibly , in the outer parts of large subhalos ( visual inspection of 10 cases confirms this ) .
such halos may survive if the numerical resolution were increased further , so that the fraction of progenitors with no descendents is an estimate of the importance of residual numerical effects .
cases in which two or more progenitors have a common descendent , i.e. the progenitors particles contribute to the descendent s core , point to true mergers .
table 1 reports the results of the tracing for the @xmath19 progenitors in three mass ranges .
table 2 is the analog for @xmath18 . in the first column
, we show the minimum value of the circular velocity for the progenitors in each mass range .
all the @xmath19 progenitors with @xmath9 have a descendent at @xmath38 ; the tracing is still essentially complete at @xmath202 ( @xmath203% ) and deteriorates only for @xmath16 approaching @xmath204 ( @xmath205% ) .
the central object accretes only another halo ( of @xmath206 ) .
these results are stable against varying @xmath207 .
the loss of halos from @xmath208 to the present appears negligible for @xmath14 .
the most prominent feature of the tracing of the @xmath18 progenitors is the large fraction of massive halos that merge with the central object : about 25 progenitors with @xmath209 , a dozen for @xmath210 .
there is virtually no contribution to the central object s ( core ) mass from progenitors with @xmath211 .
essentially all the progenitors with @xmath186 have a partner at @xmath38 ; the tracing starts deteriorating at @xmath212 where the percentage of `` childless '' progenitors is @xmath213% , independent of @xmath207 in the range 4 - 16 .
successful tracing with the `` cd '' might still hide overmerging , but it seems safe to consider the mergers of the massive halos as real , since they occur before the cluster formation and involve objects of comparable masses ( for which the dynamical friction time is small ) .
also the distribution of their particles in the @xmath38 cluster is well concentrated within the cd .
we have examined the distribution at the final epoch of the particles in the cores of the @xmath18 progenitors with @xmath214 that merge with the cd ( we use @xmath215 comoving ) ; about 80% of such particles end up within @xmath84 from the cluster s center at @xmath38 .
very likely further increases of resolution , and the inclusion of baryons with cooling , will reveal substructure within a cd s radius ; e.g. the substructure already present within the progenitors at @xmath18 could survive and be found within the cd . however
, these subhalos would lose a very large fraction of their masses and should have small circular velocities and low mass - to - light ratios . in conclusion ,
overmerging effects in this simulation appear negligible for large and intermediate halos ; loss of substructure may still affect halos starting from @xmath216 at the @xmath7420% level .
this does not seem to be important for most of the statistical properties of the substructure considered in the previous section , in view of the strict similarities of the results for lores and hires ( except possibly for the velocity bias ) .
we use `` n - body '' simulations to follow the collisionless evolution of the dark matter component of a rich galaxy cluster .
increasing the force and mass resolution ( figure [ f:2maps ] ) by an order of magnitude has a dramatic effect on the abundance of substructure and allows us to assess the biases introduced by low resolution studies .
we find the following main results : * we compare the density profile of the cluster halo simulated with @xmath217 , @xmath218 and @xmath219 particles within the virial radius . at our highest resolution
the force softening is @xmath52 ( @xmath220% of the virial radius ) and the profile is well fit by @xmath221^{-1}$ ] .
this agrees with the results of moore _
et al _ ( 1999b ) for lower resolution simulations , and suggests that we may have converged on the asymptotic central slope .
the best fit nfw profile to the data has residuals of order 30% .
( in a recent paper , jing & suto , 2000 , find shallower central cusps ( @xmath222 ) for four high resolution simulations of clusters in the @xmath34cdm model ; the reasons of the disagreement are not yet clear , see 4 ) .
* for the first time we can confidently resolve the cluster density profile beyond @xmath223
. between @xmath224 and @xmath225 the density profile has a central cusp with a slope @xmath226 .
this disagrees with the central mass profile of cl0024 + 1654 recovered from a strong lensing analysis which indicate a constant density core over the same radial range ( tyson _ et al _ 1998 ) . *
the density profiles of substructure halos has not yet `` converged '' .
lower resolution studies found that halos within clusters had steeper density profiles than field halos this may be due to particle - halo heating of substructure halos . *
the distribution function of substructure circular velocities ( vdf ) is essentially invariant over the lifetime of the cluster ( @xmath227 billion years ) and is quite close to a power - law @xmath228 , with little dependence on environment ( 5.1 ) .
clusters simulated with @xmath30 particles can reliably measure this function for halos with circular velocity above @xmath229 .
( note that the cluster forms early , at @xmath230 , with no major mergers since ; the evolution of the properties of the substructure may be different in objects with more turbulent recent histories . ) * the distribution of halo masses ( mdf ) shows the same `` invariance properties '' as the vdf virtually no evolution and little dependence on environment and is close to a power - law @xmath231 for halo masses @xmath232 ( a fraction @xmath233 of the cluster s virial mass ) ; tidally driven mass loss changes the mdf self - similarly ( 5.2 ) .
clusters simulated with @xmath30 particles can reliably measure this function for halos with masses above @xmath234 . *
the substructure halos of circular velocity limited samples are spatially anti - biased with respect to the underlying mass distribution ( see 5.3 for definitions ) . at an early epoch ( @xmath56 )
, the anti - bias is uniform within the cluster ( halo and particles have number density profiles of similar shape ) ; at the final time , the anti - bias of the halos increases approaching the cluster s center .
halo - halo collisions and tidal mass loss ( which decrease a halo s @xmath16 , on average by @xmath86% over 5 billion years ) are the likely source of the anti - bias ( 5.3 ) .
* the 3d velocity dispersions of halos and dark matter particles are generally consistent within and around the cluster , except in the central region ( @xmath235 ) where the halos are `` hotter '' than the particles with a ( positive ) velocity bias @xmath236-@xmath25 ) .
the sign and maximum amplitude of the bias is similar to that reported by coln _
et al _ ( 1999 ) , but the radial range over which @xmath237 is much more limited ( their detection extends to @xmath238 ) .
the magnitude of the bias appears to be enhanced by limited resolution since `` overmerging '' erases preferentially the central cluster halos .
when we average over @xmath54 , the velocity dispersions of halos and particles do not differ by more than 10% .
* following the cluster progenitors from high redshift to the present shows that , at the current resolution , overmerging should be globally unimportant for subhalos with @xmath129 , although a fraction of high - redshift halos may be lost for @xmath16 close to @xmath229 .
all the cluster progenitors with @xmath202 at @xmath19 have a descendant among the subhalos at @xmath38 ; about @xmath239% of the progenitors at @xmath18 with @xmath87 may be artificially disrupted .
the `` cd '' object at the cluster s center is assembled at high redshift ( @xmath240 to 1 ) through the merging / accretion of a dozen halos with @xmath241 ; it also accretes one large halo within the cluster ( at @xmath242 ) .
it is now clear that the hierarchical model for structure formation can naturally form massive dark matter halos that contain a wealth of substructure resembling observed galaxy clusters ; high resolution numerical simulations allow us to obtain robust statistical measures of the properties of the substructure and make detailed predictions .
since substructure halos are expected to host galaxies in a cluster and galaxy satellites in a galaxy , the comparison with the observed distribution of those objects can produce important tests for the cosmological models .
for example , whereas the mdf obtained from cluster simulations in the cdm universe easily reproduces that derived from the observed circular velocity function of cluster galaxies ( moore _ et al _
1999a ) , the predicted abundance of substructure of galactic halos is not matched by the observed population of satellites of the milky way and andromeda ( klypin _ et al _ 1999b ,
sg is a marie curie fellow of the tmr program of the european union ( 4-th framework , grant n. erbfmbict972103 ) .
we are grateful to carlos frenk , volker springel , simon white and the referee for helpful comments and suggestions .
the numerical simulations analysed here were performed using the edinburgh cray t3e supercomputer as part of the virgo consortium and partially on the sgi origin at ncsa .
some of the analyses were carried out at the sgi origin of the uk s national cosmology supercomputer cosmos .
coln , p. , klypin , a. & kravtsov , a. v. 1999 , apj , submitted ( astro - ph/9907337 ) coln , p. , klypin , a. , kravtsov , a. v. & khokhlov , m. 1999 , apj , 523 , 32 colpi , m. , mayer , l. & governato , f. 1999 , apj , 525 , 720 couchmann , h. m. p. & carlberg , r. g. 1992 , apj , 389 , 453 davis , m. , efstathiou , g. , frenk , c.s . & white , s.d.m .
1985 , apj 292 , 371 .
jenkins , a. , frenk , c. s. , pearce , f. r. , thomas , p. a. , colberg , j. m. , white , s. d. m. , couchman , h. m. p. , peacock , j. a. , efstathiou , g. & nelson , a. h. 1999 , apj , 499 , 20 jing , y. p. & suto , y. 2000 , apj , 529 , 69 moore , b. , governato , f. , quinn , t. , stadel , j. & lake , g. 1998 , apj , 499 , 5 moore , b. , ghigna s. , governato f. , lake , g. , quinn , t. stadel , j. & tozzi , p. 1999a
, apjl , 524 , 19 ( m99a ) moore , b. , quinn , t. , governato f. , stadel , j. & lake , g. 1999b , mnras , 310 , 1147 ( m99b ) natarajan , p. , kneib , j. p. , smail , i. & ellis , r. s. 1998 , apj , 499 , 600 navarro , j. f. , frenk , c. s. & white , s. d. m. 1996 , apj , 462 , 563 | can dissipationless n - body simulations be used to reliably determine the structural and substructure properties of dark matter halos ? a large simulation of a galaxy cluster in a cold dark matter universe
is used to increase the force and mass resolution of current `` high resolution simulations '' by almost an order of magnitude to examine the convergence of the important physical quantities .
the cluster contains @xmath0 million particles within the final virial radius , @xmath1 ( with @xmath2 ) , and is simulated using a force resolution of @xmath3 ( @xmath4 of @xmath5 ) ; the final virial mass is @xmath6 , equivalent to a circular velocity @xmath7 at the virial radius .
the central density profile has a logarithmic slope of -1.5 , identical to lower resolution studies of the same halo , indicating that the profiles measured from simulations of this resolution have converged to the `` physical '' limit down to scales of a few kpc ( @xmath8 of @xmath5 ) . also the abundance and properties of substructure are consistent with those derived from lower resolution runs ; from small to large galaxy scales ( @xmath9 , @xmath10 ) , the circular velocity function and the mass function of substructures can be approximated by power laws with slopes @xmath11 and @xmath12 respectively . at the current resolution ,
overmerging a numerical effect that leads to structureless virialized halos in low - resolution @xmath13-body simulations seems to be globally unimportant for substructure halos with circular velocities @xmath14 ( @xmath15% of the cluster s @xmath16 ) .
we can identify subhalos orbiting in the very central region of the cluster ( @xmath17 ) and we can trace most of the cluster progenitors from high redshift to the present .
the object at the cluster center ( the dark matter analog of a cd galaxy ) is assembled between @xmath18 and @xmath19 from the merging of a dozen halos with @xmath20 .
tidal stripping and halo - halo collisions decrease the mean circular velocity of the substructure halos by @xmath21 over a 5 billion year period .
we use the sample of 2000 substructure halos to explore the possibility of biases using galactic tracers in clusters : the velocity dispersions of the halos globally agree with the dark matter within @xmath22 , but the halos are spatially anti - biased , and in the very central region of the cluster ( @xmath23 ) , they show positive velocity bias ( @xmath24@xmath25 ) ; however , this effect appears to depend on numerical resolution . |
spin ice are ferromagnetic frustrated rare - earth materials with pyrochlore structure @xcite .
the rare earth ions are located at the corners of tetrahedrons , and due to the anisotropy their magnetic moments can point only in the two possible orientations in the direction that connects the corner to the center of the tetrahedron - acting like ising spin variables .
the exchange and dipolar interactions between the magnetic moments , as well as the geometry of the structure , impose the so called ice rule - at the ground state , two of the spins located at the corners point inward and the two other spins point outward each tetrahedron .
spin ice materials present also excitations ( violation of this 2-in , 2-out ice rule ) that behaves like magnetic monopoles @xcite , rising both theoretical @xcite and experimental @xcite interest in the study of the system . as the spin - orbit coupling is large in rare - earth ions , the interactions on a spin ice structure
is dominated by the exchange interaction @xcite
. nevertheless , the dipolar long range interactions are comparable in magnitude , and also plays a significant role in the description of the system , so spin ice is usually described by an effective pyrochlore ising model @xcite that includes both exchange and dipolar interactions . in a simplified version of the the spin ice model , the dipolar coefficient is set to zero , and the exchange interaction is considered only between nearest neighbors .
this simplified version is referred as the nearest neighbor spin ice model ( nnsi ) @xcite , and was employed to the qualitative description of several properties of spin ice materials .
belonging to a different class of materials , but with some similar properties , two - dimensional spin ices are artificial structures , litographically assembled , constituted by elongated permalloy nano - islands @xcite .
the magnetic moments of the nano - islands are , due to the islands shape anisotropy , constricted to point on the direction of the longest axis @xcite .
again , magnetic moments behave as ising spin variables , being referred only as spins . if the geometry of the array is a two - dimensional square lattice , in which the islands alternate in orientation along the @xmath0 and @xmath1 axis , as depicted in fig .
[ sjk](a ) , the system is denominated a two - dimensional square spin ice .
exchange interactions are not present , due to the dimensions of the nano - islands and lattice spacing , providing a classical character to the phenomena here studied , but the dipolar long range interactions is still present and it is responsible for the two - dimensional version of the ice rule - at the ground state , in each vertex of the array of nano - islands , two spins point in the direction of the vertex and two others point in the opposite direction .
also these two - dimensional spin ice systems are subject of great interest , and several studies on the thermodynamics and dynamics of the system and its excitations - the magnetic monopoles - are conducted @xcite . in a recent work ,
xie , du , yan and liu @xcite used a nearest neighbors model to study phase transitions in a square two - dimensional spin ice , in the context of the conserved monopoles algorithm @xcite , to analyze the thermodynamics of monopoles in an ensemble with fixed monopole density .
the authors consider first a model hamiltonian presenting the exchange interactions between the nearest neighbors spin pairs as well as the long range dipolar interaction .
this model hamiltonian can represent both the artificial two - dimensional square spin ice , lithographically constructed , and also the square spin ice mapping obtained from the projection of the three - dimensional tetrahedral lattice of the pyrochlore spin ice on a plane @xcite . since spin frustration comes from the nearest neighbors interactions , this hamiltonian is then reduced to an effective nearest neighbors hamiltonian given by @xmath2 where the sum runs over the nearest neighbors spin pairs and @xmath3 is the effective coupling that include both exchange and dipolar interactions and assume different values for the two different alignments of the pair of spins ( perpendicular or parallel ) .
following the denomination employed for the nearest neighbors spin ice model , we will refer to this model as the nearest neighbors two - dimensional spin ice model ( nn2dsi ) . in the present work we will use an extension of the nn2dsi model to study the thermodynamics of the two dimensional square spin ice in the canonical ensemble and compare its results to those obtained by considering the long range character of the dipolar interaction , presented in references @xcite .
there , the authors used monte carlo simulations to develop a study of the thermodynamics of the model , including the interaction between all the pairs of spins on finite lattices , with periodic boundary conditions treated by the ewald summation technique @xcite or with open boundary conditions
. these approaches , of course , made the results more precise , but with the cost of increasing the computational efforts .
the extension of the model we present here will consider a set of eight spins as the nearest neighbors of a given spin , in contrast with the six nearest neighbors of the nn2dsi model @xcite , for the reasons we will present in section [ sri ] .
also in section [ sri ] , we will show that the major influence on a reference spin comes from this set of eight neighbors , in comparison to the influence of all the other spins on the lattice , justifying the use of the nn2dsi model as an effective model for two - dimensional spin ice . in section [ nn2dsi ]
we define the model hamiltonian to the extension of the nn2dsi model employed here . in section [ nr ]
we present the numerical results of our monte - carlo simulations , including the phase transition from the ordered to the disordered phase and the behavior of the density of monopoles and strings on the lattice as a function of the temperature .
finally , we present our conclusions in section [ conclusions ] .
the dipolar interaction between the permalloy nano - islands on the artificial two - dimensional spin ice model can be described by the dipolar hamiltonian given by @xmath4 where @xmath5 is the dipole coupling coefficient , with @xmath6 the permeability of the vacuum , @xmath7 the magnetic moment of each spin .
@xmath8 is the j - th spin on the lattice , @xmath9 is the position of the j - th spin relative to the k - th spin .
the sum runs over all pairs of nano - islands ( spins ) .
the ground state of the hamiltonian ( [ hamiltonian ] ) is twofold degenerated , one of these configurations is represented on fig .
[ sjk](a ) .
its useful to divide the square spin ice lattice in two sub - lattices , one composed by all the horizontal spins , denoted by @xmath10 , and the other composed by the vertical ones , @xmath11 , the sub - lattices spacing denoted by @xmath12 , as depicted on fig .
[ sjk](b ) , each sub - lattice containing @xmath13 spins .
@xmath8 denotes spins in both sub - lattices , being @xmath14 on the horizontal sub - lattice and @xmath15 on the vertical one .
@xmath10 and @xmath11 are thus ising variables , assuming values equal to @xmath16 .
the notation we adopt here has the advantage of allowing the reference to each point of confluence of four spins ( the vertexes where we can introduce magnetic monopoles ) by the index @xmath17 . at the same time , the same index locate the four spins adjacent to this vertex , given by @xmath10 , @xmath11 , @xmath18 and @xmath19 . .
the lattice spacing is denoted by @xmath12.,title="fig : " ] .
the lattice spacing is denoted by @xmath12.,title="fig : " ] here we will consider as the nearest neighbors of a given spin @xmath20 on a sub - lattice its four adjacent neighbors located at both horizontal and vertical directions at a distance @xmath12 on the same sub - lattice and the other four adjacent neighbors diagonally located at a distance @xmath21 on the other sub - lattice , as indicated in figure [ shells](a ) .
this set of eight nearest neighbors surrounds the reference spin as a two dimensional shell , so we will refer to the sets of spins at a given distance of the reference spin as shells . for example , the set of sixteen next - nearest neighbors , indicated in red in figure [ shells](b ) , will be referred as the second shell of spins and so on .
the number of spins on a given shell is equal to @xmath22 , where @xmath23 is the index of the shell , and the relative distance @xmath24 of the spins on the shell to the reference spin grows with @xmath23 , being @xmath25 for the spins located at the edges of the shell .
the influence on a specific spin due its eight nearest neighbors relative to the influence of all the other spins on the lattice can be easily computed by means of the following process .
let us compute the energy cost of flipping one single spin , @xmath26 , from the ground state , due to its nearest neighbors .
considering the geometry of the lattice , and computing the contribution to the hamiltonian ( [ hamiltonian ] ) coming from the spin @xmath20 by means of @xmath27 where the sum in @xmath28 is taken over the nearest neighbors of @xmath8 , one can find that this variation of the energy is given by @xmath29 @xmath30 since @xmath31 .
the same process can be employed to compute now the energy cost relative to the contribution of the next - nearest neighbors , the second shell of spins surrounding @xmath32 , as shown in figure [ shells](b ) , resulting in @xmath33 with @xmath34 .
note the alternating sign of each contribution as we go from one shell to the next one . by proceeding this way for the third shell of spins , as well as for the fourth , fifth and so on ,
we obtain the result depicted in figure [ figexshell ] , in which we observe the rapid decay of the energy contribution ( in absolute values ) of the coupling of each shell with the reference spin to the total energy of the system ( closed circles with dashed line ) .
this rapid decay is due to the @xmath35 decay law of the dipolar interaction as well as to the alternating sign of the spins on a given shell .
if all the contributions of the spins on a given shell acted on the same direction , one should expect that the energy relative to that shell would decrease as @xmath36 , since , as we have seen , the number of spins on the @xmath23-th shell grows with @xmath23 and the strength of the interaction decreases with @xmath35 , with @xmath37 .
the @xmath36 decay is plotted on fig .
[ figexshell ] as a reference ( dotted line ) , and we can see that the energy cost evaluated here decreases faster than this rate . ) , dashed line is only a guide for the eyes .
dotted line : the expected @xmath36 decay if all the contributions of the spins on the n - th shell act on the same direction .
the influence of the shells decays faster than this reference decay .
full squares : the cumulative contribution to the energy cost of flipping the reference spin from the first up to the n - th shell . ] also in fig .
[ figexshell ] we show the cumulative energy cost by flipping the reference spin ( @xmath38 ) as we consider the joint influence of a greater number of shells ( gray squares ) .
here , the alternating sign of each shell contribution tends to partially cancel each other as we go further on including new shells , and contributes to the fast convergence of @xmath38 .
we can see that the energy difference by considering only the first shell or up to the 10th shell is very small .
in fact , by considering only the first shell , @xmath38 is given by eq .
( [ de1 ] ) , i.e. , @xmath39 . by adding the contribution of the second shell , eq .
( [ de2 ] ) , the result changes to @xmath40 .
after including the contributions of the first 20 shells , one obtain @xmath41 .
as we can see , the contribution coming from the nearest neighbors is very close from the total energy variation computed after including 20 shells .
the contribution from the first shell of neighbors ( nearest neighbors ) is only @xmath42 greater than the convergence value , @xmath43 .
since the major contribution to the energy change as we flip a given spin comes from its coupling to the nearest neighbors , it seems to be a reasonable approximation to compute only the contributions of these neighbors spins .
of course , better approaches could be constructed by considering the next - nearest neighbors and so on , but with the cost of complexity and increasing computational time .
so , the nearest neighbors two dimensional spin ice model ( nn2dsi ) @xcite can be useful to describe , at least qualitatively , the major features of the two dimensional square spin ice and , as a toy model , the phenomena relative to the pyrochlore three dimensional real spin ice .
furthermore , we can estimate the errors involved on the nearest neighbors approach in comparison with the long range dipolar interaction model by considering the ratio between the energy costs evaluated above , @xmath44 , with @xmath45 standing for the long range dipolar model and @xmath46 for the nearest neighbors approach .
since @xmath38 is expressed in units of the dipolar coupling @xmath47 , the exact energy variation could be recovered from the nearest neighbors result by replacing the dipolar coupling by an effective dipolar coupling @xmath48 .
thus , we can consider the replacing of @xmath47 by @xmath49 on the nearest neighbors model results as a first correction to our results .
on the nearest neighbors approach we are dealing with here , each spin at each sub - lattice couples with the four nearest neighbors of the same sub - lattice , with different couplings , however , due to the alignment of the spins and to the structure of the dipolar coupling presented in eq .
( [ hamiltonian ] ) .
so , the coupling between two @xmath50 neighbor spins on the horizontal direction is @xmath51 , while the coupling of two @xmath50 spins on the vertical direction is @xmath47 .
the contribution to the hamiltonian of the coupling of a specific spin @xmath17 on the horizontal sub - lattice with its four nearest neighbors in a @xmath13 square spin ice lattice is given by @xmath52 with a equivalent expression for the contribution of an spin on the vertical sub - lattice , @xmath53 . here , and
in what follows , we have already included a factor @xmath54 in order to avoid double counting on the evaluation of @xmath55 .
each spin of a given sub - lattice also couples to the four nearest spins of the other sub - lattice , as represented in figure [ shells](a ) . in our convention
we assign the same indexes to a given @xmath50 spin and its nearest @xmath56 neighbor at the lower - left position , as exemplified in figure [ sjk](b ) .
then , the contribution to the hamiltonian of the coupling of an specific @xmath17 spin on the horizontal sub - lattice with its four vertical @xmath56 nearest neighbors is given by @xmath57 and the contribution of a spin on the vertical sub - lattice with its four horizontal neighbors is @xmath58 finally , the nearest neighbors hamiltonian to the artificial two - dimensional square spin ice is given by @xmath59 where the sum runs over @xmath60 .
the relative simple structure of the hamiltonian given by eq .
( [ hnn2dsi ] ) allow us to use simple and fast algorithms for a monte carlo simulation with periodic boundary conditions , in contrast with hamiltonian ( [ hamiltonian ] ) , where the sum runs over all the spin pairs and periodic boundary conditions require the use of the ewald summation .
so , in this approach , we can obtain faster results and/or employ larger lattices , allowing to obtain qualitative results for several observables on the square spin ice as an insightful scenario for studying dynamic and thermodynamic phenomena in both artificial two - dimensional and real three - dimensional spin ice models .
we simulated the thermodynamics of the hamiltonian described by eq .
( [ hnn2dsi ] ) by using monte carlo simulation with metropolis algorithm for different lattices sizes with periodic boundary conditions .
as expected , the ground state at zero temperature is twofold degenerated and presents the ice rule structure , as depicted in fig .
[ sjk](a ) .
the system exhibits frustration and the mean magnetization is zero in both ordered and disordered phases .
so , as the order parameter , we use the pseudo - magnetization , defined as @xmath61 the function @xmath62 projects each spin of the lattice on local axes that follow the ice rule structure , @xmath63 for an odd @xmath64 , and @xmath65 if @xmath64 is even , with @xmath66 corresponding to the integer part of the argument .
the mean pseudo - magnetization per spin is @xmath67 or @xmath68 in the ground states and tends to zero as the system evolves to the disordered phase .
we use three different lattice sizes , @xmath69 , @xmath70 and @xmath71 , each one with @xmath72 spins . as we have already mentioned , due to the nearest neighbors interactions and consequent ease in the implementation of the periodic boundary conditions , the computational procedures are ( relatively ) very fast .
here , we use typically @xmath73 to @xmath74 monte carlo steps , with up to @xmath75 independent runs , in each simulation . in order to determine the critical temperature of the system we observe the absolute value of the pseudo - magnetization as a function of the temperature and also the specific heat of the system . in fig .
[ mcl10 ] , we observe the pseudo - magnetization curve for @xmath69 , the standard errors bars are smaller than the ellipses height .
the specific heat is also presented on fig . [ mcl10 ] , and shows its maximum at @xmath76 .
the results for the specific heat with @xmath70 and @xmath71 are shown in figure [ c24e32 ] , where we focused the temperature range near the critical temperatures given by @xmath77 and @xmath78 respectively .
we observe two main differences relative to the simulations of the long range dipolar interaction system presented in ref .
@xcite - first , in contrast with the long range results , the critical temperature shows a dependence with the lattice size , as we expect for a nearest neighbor interaction .
so , @xmath79 decreases as the size of the lattice grows
. also , the peaks on the specific heat curves are not so sharp as in the long range interaction system .
second , the transition temperature for the nn2dsi system is a bit higher than that for the long range interaction system , as we could expect , since , when we consider other shells besides the nearest neighbors one , the frustrated structure tends to smooth the bond of a specific spin to the rest of the lattice , as we saw on section [ sri ] . lattice . ] and @xmath71 lattices . ] in the context of the finite size scaling theory , by assuming for the nn2dsi model the same universality class of the two dimensional ising model , as shown in ref .
@xcite , we can use the binder s fourth order cumulant given by @xmath80 to evaluate the @xmath81 critical temperature from the intersection of the @xmath82 curves for different @xmath64 , as shown on fig .
[ figbinder ] . within the results we have we can estimate the transition temperature in the range @xmath83 .
if we apply the effective dipolar coupling @xmath48 , as discussed in section [ sri ] , it points to a transition temperature of @xmath84 , to be compared with the results presented for the long range dipolar model , given by @xmath85 @xcite or @xmath86 @xcite . .
] the four spins that are adjacent to a given site @xmath17 are given by @xmath10 , @xmath11 , @xmath18 and @xmath19 ( fig [ sjk](b ) ) .
considering the `` _ flux _ '' due to the spins pointing inward ( or outward ) the vertex @xmath17 we can define its magnetic monopole charge @xcite as @xmath87 by using eq .
( [ charge ] ) , we can compute the magnetic charge at each lattice vertex and , consequently , count the number of monopoles with @xmath88 , @xmath89 , or @xmath90 , @xmath91 , at each configuration of the system .
we also can distinguish between the string vertexes , those that are part of a string connecting two monopoles ( or of a string loop ) , and the vacuum vertexes .
both present @xmath92 , but in the vacuum the two @xmath50 spins of a given vertex point in opposite directions ( the same is valid for the @xmath56 spins ) .
thus , we can also compute @xmath93 , the number of vertexes that have the string structure .
we will pay attention here to the single monopoles density , defined by @xmath94 , where @xmath95 is the total number of vertexes in a @xmath13 lattice , and the string density , @xmath96 .
the density of monopoles with double charge , @xmath97 showed to be negligible in all range of temperatures we studied here , as already expected , since the energy associated to the double charge monopole vertex is quite higher than the other ones .
it is worth to mention that , since @xmath89 counts only the positive monopoles , @xmath98 corresponds in fact to the density of pairs of monopoles , occupying each one two lattice vertex , so the maximum @xmath98 is @xmath99 . in fig .
[ figdensity ] we present the behavior of @xmath98 and @xmath100 as a function of the temperature .
as we can see , at low temperatures both monopoles pairs and strings densities are very low , but @xmath101 , indicating that the states are populated by pairs of adjacent monopoles ( dimers ) .
as temperature grows , the density of string vertexes grows , i.e. , the states become populated by monopoles separated by strings . at @xmath102
we reach the condition @xmath103 . above this temperature
the states are statistically populated by monopoles separated by strings of length greater than one lattice spacing , at least .
observe that this temperature is lower than the critical one , so there is a range of temperatures where the system is still on the ordered phase but is composed of a gas of separated monopoles .
the system smoothly evolves , thus , from a rarefied gas of dimers at low @xmath104 to a gas of separated monopoles at @xmath105 ( although the separation is small ) and then to the disordered phase , at @xmath106 . at @xmath105
approximately @xmath107 of the lattice vertexes are occupied by monopoles or strings . from this temperature on , both monopoles and strings densities experience a rapid growth , with a occupation of the lattice approximately equal to @xmath108 of the vertexes at @xmath106 and @xmath100 , approximately twice the monopoles pairs density , @xmath98 , indicating that the strings lengths are typically two lattice spacing . in fig .
[ figcharges ] we illustrate this evolution by sampling four states from the ensemble at four different temperatures .
the red ellipses represent the positive magnetic monopoles ( vertexes in which there are three spins pointing inward and one pointing outward the vertex ) .
blue ellipses represent the negative monopoles .
the big red and blue ellipses represent doubly charge monopoles ( four spins pointing inward or four spins pointing outward the vertex ) .
the small arrows represent string vertexes , the direction of the arrows is equivalent to the resultant direction for the addition of the four spins adjacent to each vertex .
the four snapshots in the figure are sampled configurations , fig .
[ figcharges](a ) shows a state at @xmath109 , and we observe a low density of dimers . at @xmath110 ( fig .
[ figcharges](b ) ) the sampled state is already more populated , presenting a reasonably number of monopoles separated by strings , most of them with length of one or two lattice spacing .
it is interesting to observe the presence of a string loop ( a closed stream of string vertexes , with no magnetic charges ) , the one positioned at the left / center of the chart .
the presence of string loops , however , is not so likely at this temperature .
right bellow the critical temperature , as shown on fig.[figcharges](c ) , the number of charges and strings has growth , and a few monopoles with double charge are observed , although its statistical density is still very low . finally , above @xmath79 the states are more populated , with a greater presence of double charged monopoles and longer strings . lattice .
( a ) at low temperature the states present low densities and are composed by dimers .
( b ) at the characteristic temperature @xmath105 the density of strings becomes equal to the density of monopoles pairs .
( c ) right bellow @xmath106 the strings have mean length approximately equal to two lattice spacings .
string loops appear , but their occurrence are still uncommon .
( d ) in the disordered phase ( @xmath111 ) the states are highly populated by monopoles .
double charged monopoles become more common , the strings are longer and the densities are higher.,title="fig : " ] lattice .
( a ) at low temperature the states present low densities and are composed by dimers .
( b ) at the characteristic temperature @xmath105 the density of strings becomes equal to the density of monopoles pairs .
( c ) right bellow @xmath106 the strings have mean length approximately equal to two lattice spacings .
string loops appear , but their occurrence are still uncommon .
( d ) in the disordered phase ( @xmath111 ) the states are highly populated by monopoles .
double charged monopoles become more common , the strings are longer and the densities are higher.,title="fig : " ] lattice .
( a ) at low temperature the states present low densities and are composed by dimers .
( b ) at the characteristic temperature @xmath105 the density of strings becomes equal to the density of monopoles pairs .
( c ) right bellow @xmath106 the strings have mean length approximately equal to two lattice spacings .
string loops appear , but their occurrence are still uncommon .
( d ) in the disordered phase ( @xmath111 ) the states are highly populated by monopoles .
double charged monopoles become more common , the strings are longer and the densities are higher.,title="fig : " ] lattice .
( a ) at low temperature the states present low densities and are composed by dimers .
( b ) at the characteristic temperature @xmath105 the density of strings becomes equal to the density of monopoles pairs .
( c ) right bellow @xmath106 the strings have mean length approximately equal to two lattice spacings .
string loops appear , but their occurrence are still uncommon .
( d ) in the disordered phase ( @xmath111 ) the states are highly populated by monopoles .
double charged monopoles become more common , the strings are longer and the densities are higher.,title="fig : " ]
we have presented here an extension of the nearest neighbor spin ice model for two dimensional square arrays . in comparison with the model proposed in @xcite , this extension includes the coupling with two other spins in such way that the set of nearest neighbors closes a shell around a given reference spin .
we computed the influence of the successive shells of spins surrounding the reference spin , and concluded that , at the ground state , the nearest neighbors are responsible for the major influence on that spin , all the rest of an infinite lattice contributing only with @xmath42 of the interaction energy . based on this observation
, we define an effective coupling that works as an empirical correction for the @xmath47 coupling dependent results .
we used monte carlo simulation to obtain the phase transition of the system and compare the results with the ones obtained by simulation of the long range dipolar interaction , showing a reasonably agreement , justifying the use of the nn2dsi model as a insight model for the study of spin ice phenomena .
as an application , we study the evolution of the monopoles and string densities as functions of the temperature , defining the temperature ranges as one can expect the predominance of dimers or separated dipoles .
the authors would like to thank financial support from cnpq and fapemig ( brazilian funding agencies ) .
39 d. j. p. morris , d. a. tennant , s. a. grigera , b. klemke , c. castelnovo , r. moessner , c. czternasty , m. meissner , k. c. rule , j. u. hoffmann , k. kiefer , s. gerischer , d. slobinsky , and r. s. perry .
, * 326*(5951),411414 ( 2009 ) . | in this work , we show that , due to the alternating orientation of the spins in the ground state of the artificial square spin ice , the influence of a set of spins at a certain distance of a reference spin decreases faster than the expected result for the long range dipolar interaction , justifying the use of the nearest neighbor two dimensional square spin ice model @xcite as an effective model . using an extension of the model presented in ref .
@xcite , considering the influence of the eight nearest neighbors of each spin on the lattice , we analyze the thermodynamics of the model and study the monopoles and string densities dependence as a function of the temperature . |
as the amount of available sequence data from genomes or proteoms rapidly grows , one is confronted with the problem that , for a given set of taxa , tree topologies relating homologous sequences of these taxa can ( and in practice often will ) differ from the each other , depending on which locus in the genome or which protein is used for constructing the tree .
possible reasons for discordance among gene trees and the species phylogeny include horizontal gene transfer , gene duplication / loss , or incomplete lineage sorting ( deep coalescences ) .
thus one is confronted with the task to determine the phylogeny of the taxa ( the ` species tree ' ) from a set of possibly discordant gene trees ( maddison @xcite , and maddison and knowles @xcite ) .
several methods have been proposed and are used to infer a species tree from a set of possibly discordant gene trees : \(1 ) declaring the most frequently observed gene tree to be the true species tree was shown to be statistically inconsistent under the multispecies coalescent model by degnan and rosenberg @xcite , in cases where branch lengths of the underlying species tree are sufficiently small .
\(2 ) a popular approach for species tree reconstruction is by concatenating multiple alignments from several loci to one large multiple alignment and construct a single ` gene tree ' from this multiple alignment by standard methods .
this approach was pursued e.g. by teichmann and mitchison @xcite and cicarelli et al.@xcite . however , also this method was shown to be inconsistent under the multispecies coalescent by degnan and kubatko @xcite , if branch lengths on the species tree are sufficiently short .
\(3 ) similarly , the concept of minimizing the number of ` deep coalescences ' ( maddison @xcite ) was recently shown to be statistically inconsistent under the multispecies coalescent model by than and rosenberg @xcite .
\(4 ) on the other hand , it is well known from coalescent theory that the probability distribution of gene trees , or even the distributions rooted gene triplet trees , on a species tree uniquely determine the species tree if incomplete lineage sorting is assumed to be the only source of gene tree discordance .
similarly ( see allman et al .
@xcite ) , _ the distributions of unrooted quartet gene trees identify the unrooted species tree topology .
_ however , as soon as triplet / quartet gene trees are inferred from experimental data , their distributions will differ from the theoretical ones , and this may lead to conflicts among the inferred triplets / quartets on the hypothetical species tree , a problem which is not straight forward to resolve ( ` quartet - puzzeling ' could be an approach to resolve this , see strimmer and von haeseler @xcite ) . also direct maximum likelihood calculations using gene tree distributions
are very problematic due to the enormous number of possible gene trees on a given set of taxa .
\(5 ) recently liu and yu @xcite have proposed to use the ` average internode distance ' on gene trees as a measure of distance between taxa on species trees and apply classical neighbor joining to these distance data .
they prove that this reconstructs the underlying species tree in a statistically consistent way . in the present paper
we propose a method to overcome many of the difficulties discussed above , and in particular to make the above mentioned result by allman et al.@xcite accessible in practice .
that is , we describe a polynomial time algorithm ( in the number of taxa ) , which uses empirical distributions of unrooted quartet gene trees as an input , to estimate the unrooted topology of the underlying species tree in a statistically consistent way . due to the conceptual similarity to classical neighbor joining we call this algorithm ` quartet neighbor joining ' , or briefly ` quartet - nj ' .
the fact that quartet - nj uses quartet distributions as an input makes it flexible in practice : quartet gene tree distributions can be obtained directly from sequence data ( as is described in the application to a prokaryote data set in section [ sect : appsim ] of this paper ) , or e.g. from gene tree distributions , which is the type of input required by liu and yu s ` neighbor joining for species trees ' @xcite . also , quartet - nj is naturally capable of dealing with multiple lineages per locus and taxon .
the paper is organized as follows : after a brief review of the multispecies coalescent model and distributions of quartet gene trees in section [ sect : mscm ] , we investigate in section [ sect : cherrypicking ] how to identify cherries on a species tree . to this end
we show how to assign ` weights ' to unrooted quartet trees on the set of taxa , using the distributions of quartet gene trees , and how to define a ` depth ' for each pair of taxa . in analogy to classical cherry picking we
prove that under the multispecies coalescent model any pair of taxa with maximal depth is a cherry on the species tree .
moreover , we give an interpretation of this theorem by the concept of ` minimal probability for incomplete lineage sorting ' , in analogy to the concept of minimal evolution underlying classical neighbor joining . in section [
sect : algorithms ] we translate our cherry picking theorem into a neighbor joining - like procedure ( ` quartet - nj ' ) and prove that it reproduces the true unrooted species tree topology as the input quartet distributions tend to the theoretical quartet distributions .
in other words , quartet - nj is statistically consistent .
finally , in section [ sect : appsim ] we apply the quartet - nj algorithm to data from coalescence simulations , as well as to a set of multiple alignments from nine prokaryotes , in order to demonstrate the suitability of quartet - nj . in both situations
we consider only one lineage per locus and taxon .
we are going to present briefly the multispecies coalescent , which models gene ( or protein ) tree evolution within a fixed species tree .
the material in this section is neither new nor very deep .
rather this section is to be considered as a reminder for the reader on the relevant definitions , as well a suitable place to fix language and notation for the rest of the paper . for a more detailed introduction to the multispecies coalescent model
we refer e.g. to allman et al.@xcite .
let us consider a set @xmath0 of @xmath1 taxa ( e.g. species ) and a rooted phylogenetic ( that is : metric with strictly positive edge lengths and each internal node is trivalent ) tree @xmath2 on the taxon set @xmath0 .
the tree @xmath2 is assumed to depict the ` true ' evolutionary relationship among the taxa in @xmath0 , and the lengths of its internal edges are measured in coalescence units ( see below ) .
this tree is commonly called the _ species tree _ on the taxon set @xmath0 .
it is a fundamental problem in phylogenetics to determine the topology of this tree .
molecular methodes , however , usually produce evolutionary trees for single loci within the genome of the relevant species , and these _ gene trees _ will usually differ topologically from the species tree ( degnan and rosenberg @xcite ) .
this has several biological reasons , like horizontal gene transfer , gene duplication / loss or incomplete lineage sorting .
the latter describes the phenomenon that to gene lineages diverge long before the population actually splits into two separate species , and in particular gene lineages may separate in a different order than the species do .
the multispecies coalescent model describes the probability for each rooted tree topology to occur as the topology of a gene tree , under the assumption that incomplete lineage sorting is the only reason for gene tree discordance .
notation : we adopt the common practice to denote taxa ( species ) by lower case letters , while we denote genes ( or more general : loci ) in their genome by capital letters . e.g. if we consider three taxa @xmath3 , the letters @xmath4 will denote a particular locus sampled from the respeceive taxa .
( by abuse of notation , we will identify the leaf sets of both species _ and _ gene trees with @xmath0 ) . considering only a single internal branch of the species tree , and two gene lineages within this branch going backwards in time , we find that the probability that the two lineages coalesce to a single lineage within time @xmath5 is given by @xmath6 where @xmath5 is in _ coalescence units _
( that is number of generations represented by the internal branch divided by the total number of allele of the locus of interest , present in the population ) . in particular ,
if the branch on the species tree has length @xmath7 , the probability that two lineages coalesce within this branch is @xmath8 . from this ,
nei @xcite derives the following probabilities under the multispecies coalescent model for a three taxon tree .
denote the taxa by @xmath9 , the corresponding loci by @xmath4 , and assume that the species tree has the topology @xmath10 with internal edge length @xmath11 . then the probability that a gene tree sampled from these taxa has the topology @xmath12 is equal to @xmath13 while the other two topologies are observed with probability @xmath14 . in @xcite degnan and salter
show how to calculate the probabilities of a gene tree in a fixed species tree on an arbitrary taxon set .
it turns out that these probabilities are polynomials in the unknonws @xmath15 , where @xmath16 denotes the length of the edge @xmath17 on the species tree .
in particular , the multispecies coalescent model is an algebraic statistical model . in the following we consider four taxon species trees on the taxon set @xmath18 , and we use newick notation to specify ( rooted ) species trees .
for instance @xmath19 denotes the caterpillar tree with edge lengths @xmath20 and @xmath21 in coalescent units .
moreover , unrooted quartets are denoted in the format @xmath22 , meaning the quartet gene tree which has cherries @xmath23 and @xmath24 .
up to permutation of leaf labels there is only one additional tree topology on four taxa , namely the balanced tree @xmath25 . for both of these two species tree topologies
it is not hard to calculate the probabilities of the tree possible unrooted quartet gene trees on @xmath0 , and one obtains for both species tree topologies @xmath26 and @xmath27 the probabilities of unrooted quartet gene trees on @xmath0 have the same form and are given by the formulas @xmath28 [ lemquartetprob ] in particular , the gene quartet distribution determines the _ unrooted _ species tree topology , but not the position of the root ( allman et al . ) .
the sum of the internal edge lengths of the rooted species tree ( resp .
the length of the internal edge of the unrooted species tree ) is given by the formula @xmath29 returning to the study of the multispecies coalescent on species trees on arbitrary taxon sets , we deduce from the above that the quartets displayed on the species tree @xmath2 on the taxon set @xmath0 are exactly those which appear with a probability bigger than @xmath30 for any sampled locus .
hence , the distributions of quartets determine uniquely the quartet subtrees which are displayed by the true species tree @xmath2 , and hence determine the unrooted topology of @xmath2 ( see allman et al.@xcite ) . in the following two sections
we describe a neighbor joining algorithm which makes this theoretical insight applicable in practice , meaning that it yields a method to estimate unrooted species trees from ( empirical ) distributions of quartet gene trees , which is statistically consistent under the multispecies coalescent model .
statistical consistency of this algorithm will follow from the ` cherry picking theorem ' below .
here we give a precise criterion , using theoretical distributions of quartet gene trees under the multispecies coalescent , to determine which pairs of taxa on the species tree are cherries .
this criterion can as well be applied to estimated quartet distributions and thus enables us to recursively construct a species tree estimate from observed gene quartet frequencies in section [ sect : algorithms ] . as always , we consider a fixed species tree @xmath2 on the taxon set @xmath0 , and we denote by @xmath31 the probability that a gene tree on @xmath0 displays the gene quartet tree @xmath32 .
recall that by lower case letters @xmath33 we denote the species from which the genes @xmath34 are sampled . regardless of whether @xmath2 contains the ( species- ) quartet @xmath35
, we can attach to it the following numbers : [ defn : weight ] the _ weight _ of the quartet @xmath35 is defined as @xmath36 if the taxa @xmath37 are not pairwise distinct , then we set @xmath38 . of course , if @xmath37 are pairwise distinct we may equivalently write @xmath39 if the quartet @xmath35 is displayed on the species tree @xmath2 , then the weight @xmath40 is precisely the length of the interior branch of the quartet @xmath35 .
moreover , the other two weights , @xmath41 and @xmath42 , are less than zero . [ lem : weightdistance ] the proof is immediate using equation : if the quartet tree @xmath35 is displayed on the species tree @xmath2 , then @xmath43 otherwise , if @xmath35 is not displayed on @xmath2 , then one of the other two quartet trees on @xmath44 is displayed , say @xmath45 , and we have @xmath46 since @xmath47 . this little
lemma motivates the following definition and a cherry picking theorem which is formulated and proved in close analogy to the ` classical ' one ( see saito and nei @xcite for the original publication , or pachter and sturmfels @xcite for a presentation analogous to ours ) .
[ defn : depth ] for any pair of taxa @xmath48 we define the _ depth _ of @xmath49 to be the number @xmath50 ( recall that if @xmath51 then @xmath52 . ) [ thm : cherrypicking ] if a pair of taxa @xmath48 has maximal depth @xmath53 , then @xmath54 is a cherry on the species tree @xmath2 .
as mentioned above , the proof of this theorem is parallel to the proof of the classical cherry picking result as presented in @xcite .
we state it here for sake of completeness of our exposition . as a first step ,
we introduce the auxiliary values @xmath55 for every four taxon subset @xmath56 , as well as @xmath57 for every pair of taxa . obviously , if @xmath54 is a cherry on @xmath2 , then @xmath58 for all @xmath59 , and hence also @xmath60 . in general , for any pair of taxa @xmath49
one has @xmath61 by lemma [ lem : weightdistance ] .
we will now assume that the pair @xmath49 does _ not _ form a cherry on the species tree @xmath2 and prove that in this case there exists a cherry @xmath62 on @xmath2 such that the following inequalities hold : @xmath63 from this we deduce the claim of the theorem : if @xmath54 is not a cherry on @xmath2 , then it does not have maximal depth .
we have to find a cherry @xmath62 on @xmath2 such that indeed @xmath64 holds . as we assume @xmath65 and @xmath66 not to form a cherry on @xmath2 , the unique path connecting @xmath65 and @xmath66 crosses at least two interior nodes ( symbolized as black dots in figure [ tree1 ] .
we denote the number of internal nodes on this path by @xmath67 . to each @xmath68 a rooted binary tree @xmath69 is attached ( see figure [ tree1 ] ) .
@xmath70 i & [ fillstyle = solid , fillcolor = black ] & [ linestyle = none]\cdots & [ fillstyle = solid , fillcolor = black ] & j \\ & [ mnode = tri]t_{1 } & & [ mnode = tri]t_{r } \ncline{1,1}{1,2 } \ncline{1,2}{1,3 } \ncline{1,3}{1,4 } \ncline{1,4}{1,5 } \ncline{1,2}{2,2 } \ncline{1,4}{2,4 } \endpsmatrix $ ] [ tree1 ] by interchanging @xmath65 and @xmath66 , if necessary , we may assume that the number of taxa in @xmath71 is less or equal than the number of taxa in @xmath72 .
first we consider the case that the subtree @xmath71 consists of a single leaf @xmath73 . in this case
the pair @xmath74 is a cherry on @xmath2 , and it is easy to see that indeed @xmath75 .
second , if @xmath71 has more than one leaf , let choose a cherry @xmath62 in @xmath71 ( every rooted binary tree with more than one leaf has at least one cherry ! ) .
now we decompose the difference @xmath76 into six sums which will be treated separately : @xmath77 where @xmath78 inspection of the tree in figure [ tree1 ] immediately shows that each summand in @xmath79 is positive , and more precisely , greater or equal to @xmath80 .
hence @xmath81 . in @xmath82 ,
the expressions @xmath83 all vanish , hence this sum is positive .
@xmath70 i & & & & & & p \\ & [ fillstyle = solid , fillcolor = black ] & [ linestyle = none]\cdots & [ fillstyle = solid , fillcolor = black ] & [ linestyle = none]\cdots & [ fillstyle = solid , fillcolor = black ] \\ j & & k & & l & & q \ncline{1,1}{2,2 } \ncline{3,1}{2,2 } \ncline{2,2}{2,3 } \ncline{2,3}{2,4 } \ncline{2,4}{2,5 } \ncline{2,5}{2,6 } \ncline{2,6}{1,7 } \ncline{2,6}{3,7 } \ncline{3,3}{2,4 } \ncline{3,5}{2,4 } \endpsmatrix $ ] [ tree2 ] the third sum @xmath84 might be negative - but not too negative : the situation is illustrated by figure [ tree2 ] ( which arises from the tree in figure [ tree1 ] by deleting the irrelevant subtrees @xmath85 ) , whose inspection shows that each for each summand @xmath86 we have @xmath87 thus we see @xmath88 , whence @xmath89 is positive .
now we treat the frouth sum : if @xmath90 is a node in one of the subtrees @xmath85 , then @xmath91 , so @xmath92 is non - negative .
more precisely we have @xmath93 . on the other hand ,
the sum @xmath94 is greater or equal @xmath95 , whence also @xmath96 is positive . in total
we have found that in any case @xmath97 , which proves our claim .
as explained above , this suffices to prove the cherry picking theorem . in practical applications one will not know the precise probability of each quartet gene tree @xmath22 .
hence one has to use e.g. relative frequencies as estimates .
let us denote by @xmath98 the ( experimentally determined ) relative frequency of the gene quartet @xmath22 . in analogy
to definitions [ defn : weight ] and [ defn : depth ] we make the following the _ empirical weight _ of the quartet @xmath35 of taxa is defined as @xmath99 moreover , the _ empirical depth _ of a pair @xmath49 of taxa is defined as @xmath100 under the multispecies coalescent model , the relative frequency @xmath101 of a quartet gene tree @xmath32 is a statistically consistent estimator for its probability @xmath102 .
hence the _ empirical _ depth @xmath103 of a pair of taxa @xmath104 is a statistically consistent estimator for @xmath53 . in particular
this means : _ inferring a pair @xmath49 of taxa , where @xmath105 is maximal , as a cherry on the species tree is statistically consistent .
_ more precisely , we have [ cor : consistent ] let @xmath106 be the number of loci sampled from each taxon in @xmath0 and denote by @xmath107 the set of pairs of taxa at which @xmath105 attains its maximum .
if the number of genes @xmath106 tends to infinity , then the probability that @xmath107 contains a pair which is not a cherry on the true species tree approaches zero . as there are only finitely many taxa in @xmath0 , there is a strictly positive difference between the maximum value of @xmath108 on @xmath109 and its second biggest value .
since moreover @xmath108 and @xmath105 are continuous , there exists an @xmath110 such that whenever @xmath111 , @xmath112 is maximal if and only if @xmath113 is maximal , and the claim follows from theorem [ thm : cherrypicking ] .
but the probability that @xmath114 approaches 1 as @xmath106 grows , for any choice of @xmath115 . recall that classical neighbor joining is a greedy algorithm which in each ` cherry picking ' step declares a pair of taxa to be neighbors if this minimizes the sum of branch lengths in the refined tree resulting from this step ( saito and nei @xcite ) . in other words , classical cherry picking and neighbor joining is guided by the principle of _ minimal evolution_. it turns out that our cherry picking result in theorem [ thm : cherrypicking ] can be interpreted in a similar fashion .
let us make the following ad - hoc definition .
let @xmath116 be independent random variables with values in @xmath117 , and let @xmath118 be the probability of @xmath119 for each @xmath120 .
we call the geometric mean @xmath121{p_{1}\dotsb p_{n}}\ ] ] the _ average probability _ of the random experiments @xmath116 giving the result @xmath122 .
let us now consider what the cherry picking theorem [ thm : cherrypicking ] does with a set of taxa @xmath0 , initially arranged as a star - like tree ( see figure [ fig : cherrypickingtree ] ) .
consider two taxa @xmath123 fixed and let @xmath124 . on a species tree on @xmath0 which displays the cherry @xmath54 , this is the probability that a gene quartet tree sampled from the taxa @xmath37 differs from the species quartet tree @xmath35 .
let @xmath125{\prod_{k , l}q(ij , kl)}\ ] ] be the average probability of discordance of a sampled gene quartet tree with the corresponding quartet on the species tree , for a set of four taxa containing @xmath65 and @xmath66 .
we will also call this number the ` average probability of incomplete lineage sorting ' for quartets containing the taxa @xmath65 and @xmath66 . with this terminology ,
the cherry picking theorem [ thm : cherrypicking ] can be phrased as follows .
a pair of taxa @xmath48 is a cherry on the true species tree @xmath2 if it minimizes the average probability for incomplete lineage sorting for quartets containing the taxa @xmath65 and @xmath66 .
[ thm : avprobincomplete ] using theorem [ thm : cherrypicking ] we only have to show that @xmath126 is minimal if and only if @xmath53 is maximal . but
this follows from the fact that @xmath127 where @xmath128 is a constant independent of @xmath104 .
@xmath129 i & [ fillstyle = solid , fillcolor = black ] & [ fillstyle = solid , fillcolor = black ] \\ & [ fillstyle = solid , fillcolor = black ] & [ fillstyle = solid , fillcolor = black ] \\
j & [ fillstyle = solid , fillcolor = black ] & [ fillstyle = solid , fillcolor = black ] \ncline{2,2}{1,1 } \ncline{2,2}{1,2 } \ncline{2,2}{1,3 } \ncline{2,2}{2,3 } \ncline{2,2}{3,1 } \ncline{2,2}{3,2 } \ncline{2,2}{3,3 } \endpsmatrix & & \psmatrix[mnode = circle , linewidth=1pt , rowsep=1 cm , colsep=1 cm ] i & & [ fillstyle = solid , fillcolor = black ] & [ fillstyle = solid , fillcolor = black ] \\ & [ fillstyle = solid , fillcolor = black ] & [ fillstyle = solid , fillcolor = black ] & [ fillstyle = solid , fillcolor = black ] \\
j & & [ fillstyle = solid , fillcolor = black ] & [ fillstyle = solid , fillcolor = black ] \ncline{2,2}{2,3 } \ncline{2,2}{1,1 } \ncline{2,2}{3,1 } \ncline{2,3}{1,3 } \ncline{2,3}{1,4 } \ncline{2,3}{2,4 } \ncline{2,3}{3,4 } \ncline{2,3}{3,3 } \endpsmatrix \end{tabular } $ ] [ fig : cherrypickingtree ]
in this section we discuss how the above cherry picking result can be used to design an algorithm which estimates a species tree from ( observed ) gene quartet tree frequencies .
the first version of our neighbor joining algorithm reconstructs the underlying species tree from the ( theoretical ) gene quartet tree distributions .
[ alg : naive ] * input * : a set of taxa @xmath130 containing at least four elements , and for each quartet @xmath131 with @xmath132 the probability @xmath133 of the quartet @xmath134 under the multispecies coalescent model on the species tree @xmath2 . *
output * : the species tree @xmath2 .
* step 0 . * set @xmath2 to be the graph with vertex set @xmath0 and with empty edge set . * step 1 . * if @xmath135 go to step 4 .
* for each unordered pair @xmath136 calculate the depth @xmath53 . let @xmath137 be a pair of taxa with maximal depth .
add a node @xmath20 to @xmath2 and draw edges from @xmath65 to @xmath20 and from @xmath66 to @xmath20 .
replace @xmath0 by @xmath138
. * step 3 .
* for each quartet @xmath139 with @xmath140 set @xmath141 and for all quartets @xmath142 which do not contain @xmath20 set @xmath143 .
replace @xmath144 by @xmath145 .
go to step 1
. * step 4 . *
if @xmath146 , then add a vertex to @xmath2 and draw edges from this new vertex to the three elements of @xmath147 .
each calculation of @xmath53 requires @xmath148 logarithms and additions .
repeating this for every pair @xmath104 of taxa gives a computational complexity of @xmath149 for step 2 .
this is also the complexity of one iteration of the algorithm . since each step will identify exactly one cherry , we need @xmath150 iterations to reconstruct @xmath2 , which gives a total complexity of @xmath151 for algorithm [ alg : naive ] .
it is rather straightforward to improve step 2 so that the algorithm requires only @xmath149 arithmetic operations ( see subsection [ subsect : complexity ] ) . using the result of theorem [ thm : avprobincomplete ]
, we may summarize : _ with algorithm [ alg : naive ] we have described a greedy algorithm which inferes in each step the cherry which requires minimal incomplete lineage sorting .
_ further , the fact that cherry picking is statistically consistent implies that also species tree estimation by algorithm [ alg : naive ] is statistically consistent : let @xmath106 be the number of loci sampled from each taxon in @xmath0 and denote by @xmath152 the estimate for the species tree produced by algorithm [ alg : naive ] .
if the number of genes @xmath106 goes to infinity , then the probability that @xmath152 equals the true species tree @xmath2 approaches 1 .
this follows by a repeated application of corollary [ cor : consistent ] . in practical applications two problems may occur using algorithm [ alg : naive ] :
first , there might be several non - disjoint pairs of taxa with maximal depth .
this could be resolved by chosing one of these pairs randomly .
a more serious problem occurs when many of the empirical gene quartet distributions are 0 .
this will be discussed in the following subsection .
algorithm [ alg : naive ] works well if one uses as input the theoretical probabilities for quartet gene trees .
it also works well , if one uses relative quartet frequencies which are ` very close ' to the probabilities @xmath102 ( and in particular non - zero ) . in other cases ,
the result might be problematic , as we are going to explain now .
imagine that for some reason ( e.g. very long branch lenghts on the species tree ) the observed quartet gene trees reflect very precisely the topology of the species tree .
this might mean in the extreme case that for every four - taxon subset @xmath153 one observes only this very quartet gene tree which is displayed also by the ( unknown ) species tree . in some sense this situation should be optimal , since the observed gene quartet trees fit together without conflict and thus yield an unambiguous estimate for the species tree .
however , let us run algorithm [ alg : naive ] with the empirical depth function @xmath105 in place of @xmath108 and consider any pair @xmath104 of taxa .
regardless of the choice of @xmath65 and @xmath66 , there exist @xmath154 such that @xmath35 is a quartet on the species tree , and hence by our assumption @xmath155 . calculating the empirical depth of @xmath49 yields @xmath156 thus _ every _ pair @xmath49 maximizes @xmath105 , and
so in each iteration of algorithm [ alg : naive ] the choice of a cherry is completely arbitrary .
so this procedure fails in a situation , which has to be considered the ` easiest ' possible in some obvious sense .
a possible solution to this problem is to perturb the arguments in the logarithms in equation by a small number @xmath157 . in other words , we fix @xmath158 and calculate , for each pair of taxa @xmath104 , the ` perturbed depths ' @xmath159 obviously , for @xmath160 we have @xmath161 and @xmath162 , for all pairs @xmath163 . from this
we obtain the following easy assume that the theoretical probabilities @xmath102 are known for each four taxon subset @xmath164 and are used as input for algorithm [ alg : naive ] .
then there exists a constant @xmath165 such that algorithm [ alg : naive ] computes the same results with @xmath166 in place of @xmath108 , for each @xmath167 .
in other words , if @xmath168 is the species tree inferred by algorithm [ alg : naive ] with @xmath166 in place of @xmath108 , then the limit @xmath169 exists and is equal to @xmath170 . [
lem : epsilon ] this follows from the fact that @xmath2 is a binary tree , that there are only finitely many values of @xmath108 and that @xmath171 depends continuously on @xmath172 .
this suggests that for practical applications it will be reasonable to fix @xmath173 ` small enough ' , and run algorithm [ alg : naive ] with the perturbed empirical depth function @xmath174 in place of @xmath108 in order to avoid ` infinite depths ' as in the discussion at the beginning of this subsection .
hence we obtain the following modification of algorithm [ alg : naive ] .
[ alg : improved ] *
input * : a finite set of taxa @xmath175 , a ` small ' constant @xmath157 , and for each four taxon subset @xmath176 the relative quartet gene tree frequencies @xmath177 , @xmath178 , @xmath179 . * output * : an unrooted tree @xmath180 on @xmath0 which is our estimate for the topology of the species tree @xmath2 on @xmath0 .
* algorithm * : run algorithm [ alg : naive ] with the depth function @xmath53 substituted by the empirical depth @xmath181 .
the result of this calculation is @xmath180 . indeed ,
if we apply this modified algorithm to the problematic situation at the beginning of this subsection , we will obtain ( for any choice of @xmath172 ) a fully resolved correct estimate for the species tree @xmath2 .
of course , this algorithm has the same complexity as algorithm [ alg : naive ] .
we want to claim that , for sufficiently small values of @xmath172 , quartet - nj produces a asymptotically correct estimate of the true species tree on @xmath0 . to this end , we first prove there exists a constant @xmath165 such that for all @xmath182 the trees @xmath180 are equal . in other words , the limit @xmath183 exists . [
lem : epsilon_empirical ] since there are only finitely many cherries to pick , we may restrict our considerations to the picking of the first cherry .
we have to distinguish two cases : first assume that there are taxa @xmath104 such that @xmath184 , i.e. the set @xmath185 is nonempty . if @xmath172 is small enough , then the maximum of the values of @xmath174 is attained at one of the pairs in @xmath186 .
at which of those pairs the maximum is attained then only depends on the number of summands in @xmath181 which approach infinity as @xmath172 tends to zero .
this number is clearly independent of @xmath172 , whence the set of potential cherries to pick is independent of @xmath172 . in the second case , there are no elements in the set @xmath186 .
this means that each of the perturbed empirical depths @xmath181 approaches the _ finite _ value @xmath103 as @xmath172 tends to zero .
this again means that , for @xmath172 small enough , the pair which maximizes @xmath174 does not depend on @xmath172 . combining this with lemma [ lem : epsilon ] we obtain the desired result . the limit @xmath187 exists and is a statistically consistent estimate for the true species tree @xmath170 . in particular ,
quartet - nj ist statistically consistent .
[ thm : main ] the existence of the limit in the theorem is established by lemma [ lem : epsilon_empirical ] .
it remains to prove that it is a statistically consistent estimate for @xmath2 .
recall that the definition of the function @xmath181 depends on the relative frequencies @xmath101 .
if we consider the probabilities @xmath102 known and fixed and moreover fix the pair of taxa @xmath49 , then we may consider the function @xmath188 depending on the ` variables ' @xmath101 and @xmath172 .
this is a continuous function which vanishes on the line @xmath189 .
thus for every @xmath115 there exists an open ball centered at @xmath190 which is mapped to @xmath191 by @xmath192 . in particular , there exists a positive constant @xmath193 such that for every @xmath49 we have @xmath194 if @xmath195 and @xmath196 . if we chose @xmath115 small enough
, we thus may conclude that @xmath197 for every @xmath196 and for all relative frequencies satisfying @xmath195 .
moreover , by lemma [ lem : epsilon ] we may assume , by reducing @xmath198 if necessary , that @xmath199 for every @xmath196 .
taking this together we obtain that , provided @xmath195 for every quartet @xmath35 , @xmath200 .
since @xmath101 is a statistically consistent estimate for @xmath102 , this proves that @xmath201 is a statistically consistent estimate for @xmath2 .
the question of how to find an appropriate @xmath202 to run the neighbor joining algorithm will of course depend on the special problem instance and is left open here . here
we briefly mention a complexity reduction for the quartet neighbor joining algorithm . since algorithm [ alg : naive ] and [ alg : improved ] are completely equivalent in this respect , we formulate this reduction only with the simpler notation of algorithm [ alg : naive ] .
we consider step 2 in algorithm [ alg : naive ] . in our present formulation ,
this step calculates the depth @xmath53 by adding up @xmath148-many quartet weights for each pair of taxa @xmath104 .
however , most of these quartet weights will not have changed during the last iteration of the algorithm .
assume that in the previous iteration the cherry @xmath203 was identified and joined by a new vertex @xmath20 .
then for any pair of taxa @xmath104 which are still present in @xmath0 we may calculate the new depth @xmath204 from the old one by the formula @xmath205 this reduces the complexity of step 2 from @xmath206 to @xmath207 , and hence the overall complexity of algorithms [ alg : naive ] and [ alg : improved ] are reduced by this modification to @xmath149 .
in order to test quartet neighbor joining on real data , algorithm [ alg : improved ] was applied to a set of protein sequences from nine prokaryotes , among them the two archaea _ archaeoglobus fulgidus _ ( af ) and _ methanococcus jannaschii _ ( mj ) , as well as the seven bacteria _ aquifex aeolicus _ ( aq ) , _ borrelia burgdorferi _ ( bb ) , _ bacillus subtilis _ ( bs ) , _ escherichia coli _ ( ec ) , _ haemophilus influenzae _ ( hi ) , _ mycoplasma genitalium _ ( mg ) , and _ synechocystis sp . _ ( ss ) .
the choice of organisms follows teichmann and mitchison @xcite , while the multiple sequence alignments where taken out of the dataset used by cicarelli et al . in @xcite .
for each of the 28 protein families in the list 1 .
ribosomal proteins , small subunits : s2 , s3 , s5 , s7 , s8 , s9 , s11 , s12 , s13 , s15 , s17 , l1 , l3 , l5 , l6 , l11 , l13 , l14 , l15 , l16 , l22 ; 2 .
trna - synthetase : leucyl- , phenylalanyl- , seryl- , valyl ; 3 .
other : gtpase , dna - directed rna polymerase alpha subunit , preprotein translocalse subunit secy , a distance matrix was calculated using belvu @xcite with ` scoredist'-distance correction ( sonnhammer and hollich @xcite ) . for each distance matrix ,
a set of quartet trees was inferred in the classical way by finding , for each four taxon set @xmath208 , the unrooted quartet @xmath32 which maximizes the value @xmath209 where @xmath210 denotes the respective entry in the distance matrix .
algorithm [ alg : improved ] was then run with the parameter @xmath211 , and @xmath212 on the quartet distribution obtained from analyzing all the 28 protein families above , and in a second try on the quartet distributions obtained only by the ribosomal proteins .
the resulting tree topologies are depicted in figures [ fig : all ] and [ fig : ribosomal ] , respectively ( the root of these trees is of course not predicted by algorithm [ alg : improved ] .
rather it was placed a posteriori on the branch which separates archaea from bacteria on the unrooted output of the algorithm . )
the different choices of @xmath172 did not affect the result in these calculations .
as a first test of performance of algorithm [ alg : improved ] two series of simulations were performed as follows . for a certain choice of a species tree @xmath2 on a set of taxa @xmath0
, a coalescent process was repeatedly simulated using the coalescence package of mesquite @xcite , @xcite .
each simulation yielded a set of gene trees on @xmath0 , and from these the frequency of each unrooted quartet gene tree with leaves in @xmath0 was determined .
these frequencies where then submitted to algorithm [ alg : improved ] and the resulting ( unrooted ) tree was compared with the ( unrooted version of the ) species tree @xmath2 .
we report here the proportion of correct inferences of the unrooted species tree in the different situations . in the first series of simulations the underlying species tree was the 5-taxon caterpillar tree @xmath213 , with all internal branch lengths set equal ( of course , the length of the pending edges does not have an impact , as we consider only one lineage per taxon ) .
algorithm [ alg : improved ] was run 1000 times using 5 , 10 , 20 and 50 sampled gene trees per trial , 500 times using 100 gene trees , 250 times using 200 gene trees , and 100 times using 500 simulated gene trees per trial .
the proportion of trials which yielded the correct unrooted species tree topology is reported in table [ tab : caterpillar ] .
note that simulations under the 5-taxon caterpillar tree are also performed by liu and yu @xcite in order to assess the performance of their ` neighbor joining algorithm for species trees ' . for our choices of branch lengths and sample sizes
, the performance of algorithm [ alg : improved ] seems to be roughly equal to the performance of ` neighbor joining for species trees ' ( liu and yu @xcite , figure 2 ) . in a second series of simulations ,
the underlying species tree was the tree inferred by algorithm [ alg : improved ] for the nine prokaryotes in section [ subsect : prokaryotes ] , see figure [ fig : all ] .
again , for different internal branch lengths and different numbers of gene trees per trial , 1000 trials ( in the case of 5 , 10 , 20 and 50 gene trees per trial ) , and 500 resp .
100 trials ( in the case of 100 resp .
500 gene trees per trial ) were run , and the proportions of correctly inferred unrooted species tree topologies are reported in table [ tab : prokaryotes ] .
two comments are in order : ( 1 ) in fact , for each choice of the parameter @xmath20 ( and fixed number of gene trees per trial ) two simulations were performed .
for the first , the length of the branch leading to the cherry formed by mj and af was set to @xmath214 , while in a second simulation this branch length was set to @xmath215 .
the differences in the proportions of successful trials are small in most cases ( between one and two percent ) , and , as expected , in most cases the proportion of successful trials was bigger in the first situation .
\(2 ) the number of gene trees ( or rather , the number of unrooted quartet gene trees for each 4-taxon subset ) used for the reconstruction of the prokaryote species tree in section [ subsect : prokaryotes ] where 21 and 28 , respectively . from table [
tab : prokaryotes ] we see that such a species tree @xmath2 is likely to be inferred correctly by algorithm [ alg : improved ] if its internal branch lengths are around @xmath216 ( with a probability of more than 90 percent ) . for branch lengths around @xmath217
, however , the probability for a correct inference of @xmath2 decreases to about 40 to 50 percent .
( however , there might still be certain clades on @xmath2 which can be detected with high accuracy also for smaller branch lengths . ) clearly , in these considerations we ignore effects such as horizontal gene transfer , for whose existence there is evidence in the case of the nine prokaryotes considered in section [ subsect : prokaryotes ] for some non - ribosomal proteins ( see teichmann and mitchison @xcite ) .
.simulation results for the 5-taxon caterpillar tree @xmath213 with all internal branch lengths set to @xmath20 ( in coalescent units ) .
table entries are proportions of trials which yielded the correct unrooted species tree topology .
columns are labelled by the number of simulated gene trees used in each trial . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] elizabeth s. allman , james h. degnan , and john a. rhodes . _ identifying the rooted species tree from the distribution of unrooted gene trees under the coalescent .
_ j. math .
( 2011 ) , in press : doi:10.1007/s0028501003557 .
y. yu , t. warnow , and l. nakhleh , _ algorithms for mdc - based multi - locus phylogeny inference .
_ proceedings of the 15th annual international conference on research in computational molecular biology ( recomb ) , lnbi 6577 , 531 - 545 , 2011 . | in this article we propose a new method , which we name ` quartet neighbor joining ' , or ` quartet - nj ' , to infer an unrooted species tree on a given set of taxa @xmath0 from empirical distributions of unrooted quartet gene trees on all four - taxon subsets of @xmath0 . in particular , quartet - nj can be used to estimate a species tree on @xmath0 from distributions of gene trees on @xmath0 .
the quartet - nj algorithm is conceptually very similar to classical neighbor joining , and its statistical consistency under the multispecies coalescent model is proven by a variant of the classical ` cherry picking'-theorem . in order to demonstrate the suitability of quartet - nj , coalescent processes on two different species trees ( on five resp .
nine taxa ) were simulated , and quartet - nj was applied to the simulated gene tree distributions .
further , quartet - nj was applied to quartet distributions obtained from multiple sequence alignments of 28 proteins of nine prokaryotes . |
quantum information processing holds the promise of solving efficiently a variety of computational tasks that are intractable on a classical computer @xcite .
such tasks are routinely decomposed into a series of single - qubit rotations and two - qubit entangling gates @xcite . while the implementation of accurate single - qubit gates has been achieved in a variety of platforms @xcite , two - qubit entangling gates with similar accuracies are still very demanding .
such accuracies are compromised by the fact that _ ( i ) _ the qubits used to encode the information are not perfectly isolated from the environment , _
( ii ) _ the quantum data bus used to mediate the entangling gates is not perfectly isolated either , and moreover leads to entangling gates that are slower than their one - qubit counterparts , and _ ( iii ) _ the tools to process the information introduce additional external sources of noise .
this becomes even more challenging in light of the so - called fault - tolerance threshold ( ft ) , which imposes stringent conditions as these gates should have errors below @xmath0 for reliable quantum computations @xcite .
therefore , it is mandatory that two - qubit entangling gates be robust against the typical sources of noise present in the experiments .
this poses an important technological and theoretical challenge . on the one hand
, technology must be improved to minimize all possible sources of noise .
on the other hand , theoretical schemes must be devised that minimize the sensitivity of the entangling two - qubit gates with respect to the most relevant sources of noise . with trapped ions @xcite ,
it is possible to encode a qubit in various manners : there are the so - called `` optical '' , `` zeeman '' and `` hyperfine '' qubits . here , we shall focus on hyperfine qubits . in this approach ,
the qubit states are encoded in two hyperfine levels of the electronic ground - state manifold , and the qubit transition frequency typically lies in the microwave domain .
hyperfine qubits offer the advantage that spontaneous emission from the qubit levels is negligible , in practice .
additionally , one - qubit gates can be implemented via microwave radiation , which has already been shown to allow for errors below the ft @xcite . entangling two - qubit gates require a quantum data bus to mediate the interaction between two distant qubits .
the most successful schemes in trapped ions @xcite make use of the collective vibrations of the ions in a harmonic trap to mediate interactions between the qubits .
the more recent _ driven geometric phase gate _ @xcite , which is the subject of this work , also relies on phonon - mediated interactions and thus requires a qubit - phonon coupling . in the case of hyperfine qubits , the qubit - phonon coupling is not easily provided with microwave radiation . although there are schemes to achieve such a coupling by means of magnetic field gradients @xcite , spin - phonon coupling is most commonly provided by optical radiation in a so - called stimulated raman configuration . in this setup ,
transitions between the qubit levels are off - resonantly driven via a third auxiliary level from the excited state manifold by a pair of laser beams .
therefore , in contrast to the direct microwave coupling , spontaneous photon emission may occur , which acts as an additional source of noise with detrimental effects on the gate performance @xcite . in this manuscript
, we will complement the analysis of the driven geometric phase gate in the presence of noise @xcite , where we showed its built - in resilience to thermal fluctuations , dephasing noise , and drifts of the laser phases .
there , we also explored the behavior of the gate with respect to microwave intensity noise , and proposed ways to increase its robustness . in this manuscript
, we consider two additional sources of noise that are present in experiments , namely laser intensity fluctuations and residual spontaneous emission .
the first part of the manuscript is devoted to the study of the stimulated raman configuration , and the derivation of an effective dynamics within the qubit manifold using the formalism of @xcite .
this allows us to obtain expressions for the desired qubit - phonon coupling and the residual spontaneous emission .
we then use these expressions to analyze the effects of photon scattering by numerically simulating the gate dynamics in such a stimulated raman configuration .
subsequently , we investigate the performance of the gate in the presence of laser intensity fluctuations .
finally , in the last section we provide a summary of the results of this manuscript .
let us consider the situation depicted in fig .
[ fig1 ] . for the moment , we will neglect the fact that we are dealing with ions in a harmonic trap . we consider a @xmath1type three - level system that is illuminated by two lasers @xmath2 and @xmath3 with frequencies @xmath4 and @xmath5 , respectively
. the levels @xmath6 and @xmath7 form the qubit .
we denote the qubit transition frequency by @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the energy of state @xmath10 .
note that we set @xmath11 throughout this manuscript .
the beatnote of the two lasers is tuned close to the qubit transition frequency @xmath12 .
we assume that each of the laser beams only couples one of the qubit levels to the excited state @xmath13 , and is detuned by an amount @xmath14 from the respective transition . here , we consider that @xmath2 only couples to the transition @xmath15 with rabi frequency @xmath16 and @xmath3 only to @xmath17 with rabi frequency @xmath18 . hence , the hamiltonian of the system is given by h_full = _ s=,,e _ s |ss| + ( _ 1,e^i(*k*_1 - _ 1 t
+ _ 1 ) |e| + _ 2,e^i(*k*_2 - _ 2 t + _ 2 ) |e| + h.c . ) where @xmath19 and @xmath20 are the laser wave vectors and phases , and @xmath21 is the position of the ion .
type system .
laser @xmath2 couples to the transition @xmath22 with rabi frequency @xmath16 and @xmath3 couples to @xmath23 with rabi frequency @xmath18 .
the beatnote of the two lasers is tuned close to the qubit transition frequency @xmath24 .
both beams are detuned by an amount @xmath14 from the respective transition . by choosing @xmath14 much larger than the excited state s linewidth @xmath25 and the individual rabi frequencies effective
two - level dynamics within the qubit manifold arise . in order to achieve the driven geometric phase gate two lasers in a stimulated raman configuration
are tuned close to the first red - sideband excitation of the phonons in @xmath26direction @xmath27 .
additionally , a strong direct microwave drive with rabi frequency @xmath28 is applied on the carrier transition ( blue arrow ) .
spontaneous emission from the auxiliary level is indicated by the curly lines.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] choosing the detuning much larger than the auxiliary state s linewidth @xmath29 and the individual rabi frequencies @xmath30 , the excited state population is very small and can be adiabatically eliminated from the dynamics . applying the formalism presented in @xcite , we obtain the effective hamiltonian @xmath31 within the qubit manifold , where @xmath32 , and @xmath33 . here
@xmath34 ( @xmath35 ) denotes the effective laser wave vector ( frequency ) and we have set the raman - beam phase @xmath36 .
furthermore , we have introduced @xmath37 and define @xmath38 . after moving to an interaction picture with respect to the ground - state hamiltonian @xmath39 the hamiltonian eq.([raman_eff_ham_complete ] ) becomes h_int = _
|| + _ || + ( ^+ e^i(*k*_l- _ l t ) + h.c . ) [ raman_eff_ham_ip ] where @xmath40 denotes the detuning of the two lasers beatnote from the qubit transition frequency , such that @xmath41 , and we have introduced the effective rabi frequency of the raman transition _ l=- . [ eff_rabi_freq ] the first part of eq.([raman_eff_ham_ip ] ) represents the ac - stark shifts of the qubit levels in the presence of the two laser fields . in general , the ac - stark shifts are different for the two levels , such that the differential ac - stark shift leads to dephasing when the laser intensities fluctuate .
therefore , they are typically nulled in experiments by choosing the right laser polarizations and intensities . in this manuscript
, we assume @xmath42 such that the ac - stark shifts can be neglected @xcite . from the second part of eq.([raman_eff_ham_ip ] ) we can see that we obtain a coupling between the qubit levels with an effective rabi frequency given by eq.([eff_rabi_freq ] ) .
note that the effective wave vector in eq.([raman_eff_ham_ip ] ) is an optical wave vector and will lead to a non - negligible lamb - dicke factor and thus enable a qubit - phonon coupling .
so far , we have only provided the coherent hamiltonian dynamics and neglected incoherent scattering processes .
however , elastic and inelastic photon scattering ( i.e. spontaneous emission ) may occur in this configuration as indicated by the curly lines in fig .
[ fig1 ] . in the schrdinger picture ,
the complete dynamics is described by the master equation @xcite = -i[h_full , ] + _ s= , ( l_s l_s^ -\{l_s^ l_s , } ) [ master_eq ] where the incoherent photon - scattering processes are described by the jump operators l _
= |e| , l _
= |e| , [ lindblads_full ] where @xmath43 and @xmath44 denote the scattering rates to the levels @xmath6 and @xmath7 , respectively .
the total scattering rate is then given by @xmath45 .
starting from one of the qubit levels two processes may occur : a photon is scattered elastically , such that we end up in the same qubit state but the state has acquired a random phase . this process is known as rayleigh scattering . besides , it may happen that a photon is scattered inelastically and the qubit state is changed .
this process is termed raman scattering .
it is clear that both of the processes will have a detrimental effect on the entangling gate .
since we seek an effective dynamics within the qubit manifold , we again use the formalism of @xcite , to obtain the effective master equation = -i[h_eff , ] + _ s= , ( l_s^eff ( l_s^eff)^ -\{(l_s^eff)^ l_s^eff , } ) , [ eff_master_eq ] where the effective hamiltonian is given in eq.([raman_eff_ham_ip ] ) , and the effective jump operators correspond to @xmath46 where we have introduced the frequencies @xmath47 . from the above equations it follows that the effective decay rates scale as @xmath48 .
thus , it is clear that the effective decay rates can be suppressed by increasing the detuning @xmath14 . from eq.([eff_rabi_freq ] ) we see that increasing @xmath14 demands an increase in the modulus of the individual rabi frequencies and thus in the applied laser power to maintain the value of the effective rabi frequency , which will in turn determine the gate speed .
in this part , we want to extend our analysis of the stimulated raman configuration and derive the spin - motion coupling . to this end
, we now consider a string of @xmath49 ions in a linear paul trap .
we assume that the ions are sufficiently cold such that their motion , which is strongly coupled via the coulomb interaction , is described in terms of normal modes @xcite .
for a crystal of @xmath49 ions there are @xmath49 normal modes in every spatial direction , and thus the motional hamiltonian is given by h_m = _ = x , y , z _
n=1^n _ , n a^_,n a_,n [ motional_ham ] where @xmath50 denotes the motional mode frequency of mode @xmath51 in spatial direction @xmath52 and @xmath53 is the respective creation ( annihilation ) operator . as we can see from eq.([motional_ham ] ) , the normal modes of different spatial directions are uncoupled . assuming the ions are illuminated in a stimulated raman configuration the system s full hamiltonian reads h_full = h_m+ _ i , s _ s |s_i s| + _ i ( _ 1,e^i(*k*_1 _ i - _ 1 t ) |e_i | + _ 2,e^i(*k*_2 _
i - _ 2 t ) |e_i | + h.c . )
[ full_ham_lambda ] where @xmath54 denotes the individual ions .
again , by performing adiabatic elimination of the excited state , we obtain the hamiltonian h_eff= h_0 + _ i ( _ i^+ e^i(*k*_l_i- _ l t ) + h.c . ) [ stimulated_raman_phonons ] where we have defined h_0 = _ i ^z_i + _ , n _ , n a^_,n a_,n .
[ def_h0 ] we will now assume that the effective laser wave vector is aligned along the @xmath55-axis of the trap , i.e. @xmath56 .
in this case , the laser only couples to the phonons in @xmath26direction and we will omit the index @xmath52 as it is clear that we refer to the case @xmath57 . we can now rewrite the @xmath55-component of the ion s position as x_i = x_i^0 + _ n=1^n m_in
( a_n + a_n^ ) where @xmath58 is the dimensionless normalized amplitude of mode @xmath51 for ion @xmath59 and @xmath60 is the equilibrium position of ion @xmath59 in @xmath55-direction .
assuming the trap axis along the @xmath61direction , we have @xmath62 for all ions . using the lamb - dicke parameter ( ldp ) @xmath63 and moving to an interaction picture with respect to @xmath64 , eq.([stimulated_raman_phonons ] )
can be recast into the form h_eff= _
i e^i_n m_in _ n ( a_ne^- i_n t + a_n^ e^ i_n t ) _
i^+ e^-i_l t + h.c .. [ stimulated_raman_eta ] typically , for optical wave vectors we have @xmath65 such that we can expand the first exponential in the above equation in powers of @xmath66 . assuming a laser detuning @xmath67
, we obtain the red - sideband excitation , and eq.([stimulated_raman_eta ] ) finally becomes h_rsb = _ i , n _ in _
a_n e^-i_n t + h.c .. [ h_eff_final_rsb ] here we performed a rotating wave approximation relying on @xmath68 and introduced the sideband coupling strengths _ in = i_n _ l m_in .
[ def_sideband_coupling_strengths ] in the following we shall consider @xmath69 ions , in this case @xmath70 and @xmath71 else .
in this section we will briefly explain the driven geometric phase gate introduced in @xcite .
we start by considering a crystal of @xmath69 trapped ions in a linear paul trap .
the internal degrees of freedom of the ions are treated in the usual two - level approximation , and we again assume that the motion of the ions is described in terms of normal modes .
thus , the system is described by the hamiltonian @xmath64 in eq.([def_h0 ] ) . additionally ,
a strong microwave that drives the qubit transition directly is applied to the ions .
the interaction of the ions with the microwave field is described by the hamiltonian h_d = _ i=1^n _ i^+ e^- i_d t + h.c . [ def_hd ] where @xmath72 ( @xmath28 ) denotes the ( rabi ) frequency of the applied microwave , and
we have assumed that @xmath73 . in order to realize an interaction between the internal states of the ions , we use the coupled harmonic motion of the ions as was done in previous schemes .
the coupling between the internal states of the ions and their motion is provided by two - photon stimulated raman transitions via a third auxiliary level ( see above ) .
the hamiltonian describing the qubit phonon coupling is then given by h_qp = _ i _
i^+ e^i(*k*_l_i- _ l t ) + h.c . where all quantities were already introduced .
the system s full hamiltonian is then given by h_dss = h_0 + h_d + h_qp .
[ full_gate_ham ] recall that we have assumed equal rabi frequencies for the two lasers such that ac - stark shifts are negligible .
let us briefly remark at this point that a full analysis starting from the complete three level system illuminated by the raman lasers and the microwave gives the same effective hamiltonian in the limit @xmath74 .
this limit will be fulfilled in all our considerations here . setting the laser frequencies such that @xmath75 , where @xmath76 and @xmath77 , we obtain the first red - sideband excitation as was explained above . moving to an interaction picture with respect to @xmath64 and assuming that the microwave is on resonance with the qubit transition @xmath78 , the interaction of the ions with the applied fields is described by the `` driven single sideband '' hamiltonian @xmath79 .
\label{qubit_phonon}\ ] ] the situation is depicted in fig .
note that we performed two rotating wave approximations here using @xmath80 and @xmath81 . moving to yet another interaction picture with respect to the applied microwave driving term
, the qubit - phonon interaction hamiltonian reads @xmath82 in the above equation we can observe that three state - dependent forces in the @xmath83 and @xmath84 bases act on the ions .
however , the forces in @xmath85 and @xmath84 rotate at the rabi frequency of the microwave driving while the force in @xmath86 is left unaltered . now ,
if the microwave driving is sufficiently strong @xmath87 , we can neglect the @xmath85 and @xmath84 forces in a rotating wave approximation , such that we are left with a single state - dependent force in the @xmath86-basis . in this limit
, we can approximate the hamiltonian in eq.([single_sideband_ip2 ] ) as @xmath88 we should note that for trapped ions there have been different proposals using strong - driving assisted gates @xcite .
this has also been considered in the context of cavity - qed to generate entangled states of different cavity modes @xcite , or atomic entangled states in thermal cavities @xcite .
let us briefly analyze the action of the hamiltonian in eq.([x_force ] ) , which consists of a single state - dependent force in the @xmath86-basis that aims at displacing the normal modes of the ions in @xmath55-@xmath89 phase space .
if the ions are in an eigenstate of @xmath90 , the above hamiltonian couples to one of the normal modes and displaces it along periodic circular trajectories in phase space .
this situation is illustrated in fig .
[ fig_phase_space_trajectories ] . ) on the center - of - mass mode if the internal states of the ions are in the states @xmath91 or @xmath92 , respectively .
the mode is displaced along circular trajectories in phase space as indicated by the arrows .
if the trajectories are closed , the motion returns to its initial state and the full state consisting of the ions internal and motional states acquires a phase equal to the area enclosed in phase space.,scaledwidth=40.0% ] in general , this hamiltonian will produce entanglement between the internal and motional states of the ions . yet ,
if the internal and motional states of the ions are in a product state initially , and the phase - space trajectories are closed , the internal and motional states end up in a product state again . in this case
the state of the system acquires a phase which is equal to the area enclosed in phase space @xcite . in our setup , the eigenstates @xmath93 and @xmath94 couple to the center - of - mass mode , while the eigenstates @xmath95 and @xmath96 couple to the zig - zag mode .
since the areas enclosed in phase space are different for the two modes , one can adjust the parameters such that , up to an irrelevant global phase , we obtain the following truth table @xmath97 this is a conditional @xmath98 phase gate , which is an entangling gate in the usual computational basis . together with single - qubit rotations , it forms a universal set of gates for quantum computation .
the major asset of the geometric phase gates is that they are _ insensitive _ to the ions motional state in case the trajectories are closed and internal and motional states were in a product state initially .
note that for weak drivings @xmath28 , the approximation leading to eq.([x_force ] ) is not valid any more , the phase - space trajectories do not close , and the geometric character of the gate is lost .
remarkably , the unitary evolution of the hamiltonian in eq.([x_force ] ) is exactly solvable .
if the trajectories are closed , i.e. @xmath99 , the time - evolution operator generated by the hamiltonian in eq.([x_force ] ) is given by @xmath100 it is readily checked that for @xmath101 , this yields the truth table in eq.([table_phase_gate ] ) .
unfortunately , due to the different non - commuting qubit - phonon couplings in , the associated unitary evolution operator can not be calculated exactly .
however , the leading - order contributions for strong drivings can be obtained by means of a magnus expansion @xcite .
this allowed us to derive a set of conditions under which the approximation in eq.([x_force ] ) for the hamiltonian is fulfilled .
we showed , both analytically and numerically , that microwave drivings with strengths @xmath28 of a few mhz typically suffice .
it was also shown that the constraint @xmath99 can be fulfilled such that the geometric character is fulfilled for general two - qubit states . moreover ,
when complemented with a single spin - echo pulse , we showed that the gate is extremely well approximated by eq.([ms_gate ] ) .
once the mechanism of the driven geometric phase gates has been described , we are interested in its performance in the presence of typical sources of noise in ion traps .
we showed in @xcite that the gate can attain errors below the ft in the presence of residual thermal motion , laser phase and dephasing noise .
also , a constraint on the intensity stability of the microwave driving was given .
however , the impact of spontaneous emission and laser intensity noise was not investigated . in this section
, we shall study the effects of these two additional sources of noise . in order to include the effects of spontaneous emission , we study the gate dynamics in a master equation approach . for our numerical simulations
, we used a realistic set of parameters for an ion - trap experiment summarized in table [ tab_1 ] , assuming the raman beams to be at a right angle .
as a specific ion species we chose @xmath102mg@xmath103 . in order to perform the simulations
as efficiently as possible we cast the hamiltonian @xmath104 in eq.([full_gate_ham ] ) in a picture where it becomes time independent , namely @xmath105 where the unitary transformation is given by @xmath106 .
the effective lindblad operators in this picture are given by eqs . and .
these operators are time - dependent and only appear in the form @xmath107 and @xmath108 . analyzing these products in detail ,
we find that there are time - independent terms , but also additional terms carrying oscillatory time dependences with frequencies @xmath109 .
since the amplitude of these terms fulfills @xmath110 for the constraints taken so far , we can safely neglect their contributions in the time evolution .
the effective dissipative processes are then described by the jump operators & l^eff_= ^z , l^eff _
= ^- , + & l^eff_= ^+ , l^eff _ = ^z .
+ note , the lindblad operators @xmath111 describe dephasing caused by rayleigh scattering where the qubit state is not altered .
the remaining contributions describe raman scattering where the qubit state is altered upon a scattering event . for our simulations
we assume equal branching ratio for the two decay channels , i.e. @xmath112 . .*values of trapped - ion setup for the numerical simulation and parameters of @xmath102mg@xmath113 * [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ tab_1 ] the dynamics is then given by = -i[h_dss , ] + _ i , k ( l_i , k^eff ( l_i , k^eff)^ -\{(l_i , k^eff)^ l_i , k^eff , } ) [ eff_master_eq_final ] where @xmath114 denotes the different ions and @xmath115 the various scattering events . in order to investigate the effects of spontaneous emission exclusively
, we assume both of the phonon modes to be in the ground state @xmath116 , and a microwave driving of @xmath117mhz .
the phonon hilbert spaces were truncated at a maximum phonon number of @xmath118 .
for these parameters , together with the values from tab .
[ tab_1 ] , we integrated the master equation , starting from the state @xmath119 until the expected gate time @xmath120s .
note that we included a refocusing spin - echo pulse @xmath121 at half the expected gate time in the dynamics in order to avoid errors due to the fast oscillations of the applied microwave drive @xcite .
we expect to produce the state @xmath122 for the internal states of the ions where @xmath123 is a maximally - entangled bell state .
we studied the effects of spontaneous emission by simulating the time evolution of the gate for various detunings @xmath14 of the raman beams , and then computed the fidelity of producing the target state according to _
|^- = tr(|^-^-|_phonons ( t_g ) ) .
[ fidelity_computation ] here @xmath124 is the state of the full system propagated until the gate time according to eq.([eff_master_eq_final ] ) starting from @xmath125 . in order to illustrate the results more clearly we plot the error @xmath126 as function of the raman detuning @xmath14 in fig . [ fig_spontaneous_emission ] . at the expected gate time
starting from the initial state @xmath128 with the phonons in the vacuum state the time evolution includes the effects of spontaneous emission .
the error is shown as a function of the raman beam detuning .
the figure shows that errors below the fault - tolerance threshold @xmath129 are only obtained for very large detunings @xmath130thz .
the inset shows the error in generating @xmath131 for detunings @xmath14 between 100@xmath132ghz and 1@xmath132thz .
note that for each detuning the single photon rabi frequencies fulfill @xmath133 in order to maintain the gate speed.,scaledwidth=95.0% ] we see from the figure that very large detunings of the order of 10@xmath132thz are needed to suppress spontaneous emission sufficiently to obtain errors below the fault - tolerance threshold .
we note that these detunings are very large compared to the detunings that have been used so far in two - qubit entangling gates between hyperfine qubits with cw lasers ( @xmath134-@xmath135ghz @xcite ) . from a technological point of view , this is due to limited laser power , such that the detuning can not be increased further without compromising the effective rabi frequency , and thus the gate speed . from a more fundamental point of view
, the conditions to nullify the ac - stark shifts in eq.([raman_eff_ham_ip ] ) , impose that the detuning can not be larger than the fine - structure splitting ( e.g. @xmath136 ghz for @xmath137be@xmath113 ) @xcite .
however , we note that in pulsed experiments with intense laser sources and heavier ions ( e.g.@xmath138yb@xmath113 @xcite ) , the desired detunings of the order of 10@xmath132thz have been implemented , while simultaneously minimizing the ac - stark shift .
an advantage of our setup is that it does not require for cancellation of the ac - stark shift , since the associated dephasing would be directly suppressed by the applied strong microwave driving as was shown in @xcite .
hence , we are not bound to @xmath139 , and can consider higher detunings even for lighter ion species .
it then seems that the only limitation to minimize the residual scattering is due to the available laser power .
if this limitation can not be overcome , it seems more promising to implement the gate in an all - microwave setup to avoid photon scattering completely .
let us finally note that , according to the results of @xcite , raman scattering is largely suppressed for detunings larger than the fine - structure splitting of the excited state manifold which is about 2.75@xmath132thz for @xmath102mg@xmath113 . in this case ,
rayleigh scattering is the dominant spontaneous emission process .
therefore , our results which always include raman and rayleigh scattering on the same footing represent a worst - case scenario
. we should then expect that the detrimental effects of spontaneous emission will be somewhat smaller in this regime . as we have seen in the last paragraph
it is desirable to operate the lasers very far detuned from the transitions they couple to .
the typical detunings used for stimulated raman transitions @xmath140 ghz demand that the lasers be operated at relatively high powers in order to obtain reasonable effective laser rabi frequencies . unfortunately , at these high powers there will be fluctuations in the laser intensity .
these fluctuations will act as another source of noise for the gate since they lead to fluctuations of the pulse area of the applied laser pulses . in this section ,
we want to investigate the impact of laser intensity fluctuations on the gate performance quantitatively .
a fluctuating laser intensity leads to fluctuations in the laser rabi frequency .
this , in turn , leads to fluctuations in the sideband coupling strengths @xmath141 as we can see from the definition .
therefore , @xmath142 becomes @xmath143 where @xmath144 .
we assume that the sideband couplings fluctuate around some mean value @xmath141 , where the fluctuations are described by the quantity @xmath145 .
we model the fluctuations @xmath146 by a so - called ornstein - uhlenbeck ( o - u ) process which is characterized by a diffusion constant @xmath147 and a correlation time @xmath148 @xcite .
the o - u process is a gaussian process and is therefore characterized by its first and second moments @xmath149 here the overline denotes the stochastic average .
the correlation time also sets the time scale over which the noise is correlated @xcite .
we chose the correlation time @xmath150s and set @xmath151 where @xmath152\cdot 10^{-4}.$ ] thus , @xmath147 is determined and together with eqs .
the o - u process is fully characterized .
remarkably , there is an exact update formula for the o - u process @xmath153^{1/2 } n , \label{ou_update}\ ] ] where @xmath51 is a gaussian unit random variable . with our choice of parameters ,
we obtain an expected gate time @xmath154s .
starting from the initial state @xmath155 , we expect to produce the bell state @xmath156 at the gate time . with the update formula at hand we numerically integrated the noisy hamiltonian eq.([noisy_ham ] ) incorporating the laser intensity fluctuations until the expected gate time , and computed the fidelity of producing @xmath131 according to _ |^- = tr(|^-^-|_phonons |(t_g)(t_g)| ) where @xmath157 denotes the state of the full system propagated in time by the noisy hamiltonian .
once again we introduced a refocusing spin - echo pulse in the @xmath84 basis at half the expected gate time . in order to solely capture the errors introduced by the laser intensity fluctuations
, we assumed the phonons to be in the ground state initially . in fig .
[ fig_laser_intensity_noise ] the results of our simulations are illustrated .
we plot the error @xmath158 of producing the bell state @xmath131 at the expected gate time .
as it can be clearly seen from the figure , errors well - below the fault - tolerance threshold @xmath0 can be obtained for large drivings and relative intensity fluctuations on the order of @xmath159 or smaller . however , for relative fluctuations of @xmath160 the gate can not attain errors below the ft . of producing the bell state @xmath161 from the initial state @xmath162 at the expected gate time @xmath127 .
we set a truncation of @xmath163 phonons to the vibrational hilbert spaces . for laser intensity fluctuations of
the order of @xmath164 gate errors well - below the fault - tolerance threshold @xmath129 can be achieved.,scaledwidth=95.0% ]
in this manuscript , we have investigated the effects of spontaneous emission and laser intensity fluctuations on the performance of driven geometric phase gates as introduced in @xcite .
we have found that laser intensity fluctuations of the order of @xmath165 allow for errors below the stringent fault - tolerance threshold of @xmath166 .
spontaneous emission turns out to be the more substantial source of infidelity . only for detunings of the order of @xmath167thz spontaneous emission
is suppressed sufficiently to obtain errors below @xmath166 . in combination with the results in @xcite
, this shows that the driven geometric phase gate is robust ( i.e. it can beat the ft ) for several sources of noise , namely thermal ion motion , dephasing noise , laser phase drifts , laser intensity fluctuations , and residual photon scattering .
moreover , strong - driving entangling gates can be implemented with an always - on sympathetic cooling to overcome the errors due to motional heating of the ions @xcite .
j. i. cirac and p. zoller , phys .
lett . * 74 * , 4091 ( 1995 ) ; f. schmidt - kaler , h. hffner , m. riebe , s. gulde , g. p. t. lancaster , t. deuschle , c. becher , c. f. roos , j. eschner , and r. blatt , nature * 422 , * 408 ( 2003 ) .
a. srensen and k. mlmer , phys .
* 82 * , 1971 ( 1999 ) ; c. a. sackett , d. kielpinski , b. e. king , c. langer , v. meyer , c. j. myatt , m. rowe , q. a. turchette , w. m. itano , d. j. wineland , and c. monroe , nature * 404 , * 256 ( 2000 ) ; j. benhelm , g. kirchmair , and r. blatt , nat . phys . * 4 , * 463 ( 2008 ) .
g. j. milburn , s. schneider , and d.f.v .
james , fortschr .
* 48 , * 801(2000 ) ; d. leibfried , b. demarco , v. meyer , d. lucas , m. barrett , j. britton , w. m. itano , b. jelenkovic , c. langer , t. rosenband , and d. j. wineland , nature * 422 * , 412 ( 2003 ) .
f. mintert and c. wunderlich , phys .
* 87 * , 257904 ( 2001 ) ; a. khromova , ch .
piltz , b. scharfenberger , t. f. gloger , m. johanning , a. f. varon , and ch .
wunderlich , phys .
* 108 , * 220502 ( 2012 ) . c. ospelkaus , c. e. langer , j. m. amini , k. r. brown , d. leibfried , and d. j. wineland , phys .
* 101 * , 090502 ( 2008 ) ; c. ospelkaus , u. warring , y. colombe , k. r. brown , j. m. amini , d. leibfried , and d. j. wineland , nature * 476 , * 181 ( 2011 ) .
d. j. wineland , m. barrett , j. britton , j. chiaverini , b. demarco , w. m. itano , b. jelenkovic , c. langer , d. leibfried , v. meyer , t. rosenband and t. schaetz , phil .
lond . a * 361 , * 1349 ( 2003 ) . | we present a study of the performance of the trapped - ion driven geometric phase gates introduced in @xcite when realized in a stimulated raman transition .
we show that the gate can achieve errors below the fault - tolerance threshold in the presence of laser intensity fluctuations .
we also find that , in order to reduce the errors due to photon scattering below the fault - tolerance threshold , very intense laser beams are required to allow for large detunings in the raman configuration without compromising the gate speed . |
the convection - diffusion model can be expressed mathematically , which is a semi linear parabolic partial differential equation .
specially , we consider an initial value system of _ convection - diffusion _ equation in @xmath3 dimension as : @xmath4,\ ] ] together with the dirichlet boundary conditions : @xmath5,\ ] ] or neumann boundary conditions : @xmath6.\ ] ] where @xmath7 is the boundary of computational domain @xmath8 \times [ c , d]\subset { \mathbb{r}}^2 $ ] , @xmath9 $ ] is time interval , and @xmath10 @xmath11 and @xmath12 are known smooth functions , and @xmath13 denote heat or vorticity .
the parameters : @xmath14 and @xmath15 are constant convective velocities while the constants @xmath16 are diffusion coefficients in the direction of @xmath17 and @xmath18 , respectively .
the convection - diffusion models have remarkable applications in various branches of science and engineering , for instance , fluid motion , heat transfer , astrophysics , oceanography , meteorology , semiconductors , hydraulics , pollutant and sediment transport , and chemical engineering . specially , in computational hydraulics and fluid dynamics to model convection - diffusion of quantities such as mass , heat , energy , vorticity @xcite .
many researchers have paid their attention to develop some schemes which could produce accurate , stable and efficient solutions behavior of convection - diffusion problems , see @xcite and the references therein . in the last years
, the convection - diffusion equation has been solved numerically using various techniques : namely- finite element method @xcite , lattice boltzmann method @xcite , finite - difference scheme and higher - order compact finite difference schemes @xcite . a nine - point high - order compact implicit scheme proposed by noye and tan
@xcite is third - order accurate in space and second - order accurate in time , and has a large zone of stability .
an extension of higher order compact difference techniques for steady - state @xcite to the time - dependent problems have been presented by spotz and carey @xcite , are fourth - order accurate in space and second or lower order accurate in time but conditionally stable .
the fourth - order compact finite difference unconditionally stable scheme due to dehghan and mohebbi @xcite have the accuracy of order @xmath19 .
a family of unconditionally stable finite difference schemes presented in @xcite have the accuracy of order @xmath20 .
the schemes presented in @xcite are based on high - order compact scheme and weighted time discretization , are second or lower order accurate in time and fourth - order accurate in space .
the high - order alternating direction implicit ( adi ) scheme with accuracy of order @xmath21 proposed by karaa and zhang @xcite , is unconditionally stable . a high - order unconditionally stable exponential scheme for unsteady @xmath22d convection - diffusion equation by tian and yua @xcite have the accuracy of order @xmath21 .
a rational high - order compact alternating direction implicit ( adi ) method have been developed for solving @xmath3d unsteady convection - diffusion problems @xcite is unconditionally stable and have the accuracy of order @xmath21 . a unconditionally stable fourth - order compact finite difference approximation for discretizing spatial derivatives and the cubic @xmath23- spline collocation method in time , proposed by mohebbi and dehghan @xcite ,
have the accuracy of order @xmath19 .
an unconditionally stable , semi - discrete based on pade approximation , by ding and zhang @xcite , is fourth - order accurate in space and in time both .
the most of schemes are based on the two - level finite difference approximations with dirichlet conditions , and very few schemes have been developed to solve the convection - diffusion equation with neumann s boundary conditions , see @xcite and references therein . the fourth - order compact finite difference scheme by cao et al .
@xcite is of @xmath24th - order accurate in time and 4th - order in the space .
a high - order alternating direction implicit scheme based on fourth - order pade approximation developed by you @xcite is unconditionally stable with the accuracy of order @xmath21 .
the differential quadrature method ( dqm ) dates back to bellman et al .
@xcite . after the seminal paper of bellman , various test functions have been proposed , among others , spline functions , sinc function , lagrange interpolation polynomials , radial base functions , modified cubic b - splines , see @xcite , etc .
shu and richards @xcite have generalized approach of dqm for numerical simulation of incompressible navier - stokes equation .
the main goal of this paper is to find numerical solution of initial value system of @xmath3d _ convection - diffusion _ equation with both kinds of boundary conditions ( dirichlet boundary conditions and neumann boundary conditions ) , approximated by dqm with new sets of modified cubic b - splines ( modified extended cubic b - splines , modified exponential cubic b - splines , modified trigonometric cubic b - splines ) as base functions , and so called modified trigonometric cubic - b - spline differential quadrature method ( mtb - dqm ) , modified exponential cubic - b - spline differential quadrature method ( mexp - dqm ) and third modified extended cubic - b - spline differential quadrature method ( mecdq ) .
these methods are used to transform the convection diffusion problem into a system of first order odes , in time .
the resulting system of odes can be solved by using various time integration algorithm , among them , we prefer ssp - rk54 scheme @xcite due to its reduce storage space , which results in less accumulation errors .
the accuracy and adaptability of the method is illustrated by three test problems of two dimensional convection diffusion equations .
the rest of the paper is organized into five more sections , which follow this introduction . specifically , section [ sec - metho - decr - tem ] deals with the description of the methods : namely- mtb - dqm , mexp - dqm and mecdq .
section [ sec - impli ] is devoted to the procedure for the implementation of describe above these methods for the system together with the boundary conditions as in and .
section [ sec - stab ] deals with the stability analysis of the methods .
section [ sec - num ] deals with the main goal of the paper is the numerical computation of three test problems .
finally , section [ sec - conclu ] concludes the results .
the differential quadrature method is an approximation to derivatives of a function is the weighted sum of the functional values at certain nodes @xcite .
the weighting coefficients of the derivatives is depend only on grids @xcite . this is the reason for taking the partitions @xmath25 $ ] of the problem domain @xmath26 distributed uniformly as follows : @xmath27 = \ { ( x_i , y_j)\in \omega : h_x = x_{i+1}-x_{i } , h_y = y_{j+1}-y_{j } , i\in \delta_x , j\in \delta_y\},\ ] ] where @xmath28 , and @xmath29 are the discretization steps in both @xmath17 and @xmath18 directions , respectively .
that is , a uniform partition in each @xmath30-direction with the following grid points : @xmath31 @xmath32 let @xmath33 be the generic grid point and @xmath34 the @xmath35-th order derivative of @xmath36 , for @xmath37 , with respect to @xmath30 at @xmath33 for @xmath38 is approximated as follows : @xmath39 where the coefficients @xmath40 and @xmath41 , the time dependent unknown quantities , are termed as the weighting functions of the @xmath35th - order derivative , to be computed using various type of base functions . the trigonometric cubic b - spline function
@xmath42 at node @xmath43 in @xmath17 direction , read as @xcite : @xmath44 where @xmath45 , @xmath46 .
then the set @xmath47 forms a base over the interval @xmath48 $ ] . setting @xmath49 the values of @xmath50 and its first and second derivatives in the grid point @xmath51 , denoted by @xmath52 , @xmath53 and @xmath54 , respectively , read : @xmath55 the modified trigonometric
cubic b - splines base functions are defined as follows @xcite : @xmath56 now , the set @xmath57 is the base over @xmath48 $ ] .
the procedure to define modified trigonometric cubic b - splines in @xmath18 direction , is followed analogously . in order to evaluate the weighting coefficients @xmath60 of first order partial derivative in eq .
, we use the modified trigonometric cubic b - spline @xmath61 , @xmath62 in dq method as base functions . setting @xmath63 and @xmath64 . using mtb - dqm , the approximate values of first order derivative
is obtained as follows : @xmath65 setting @xmath66 $ ] , @xmath67 $ ] , and @xmath68 $ ] . eq . reduced to compact matrix form : @xmath69 the coefficient matrix @xmath70 of order @xmath71 can be read from and as : @xmath72\ ] ] and the columns of the matrix @xmath73 read as : @xmath74 = \left [ \begin{array}{c } 2 a_4\\ a_3-a_4\\ 0 \\ \vdots \\ \\ 0 \\ 0
\\ \end{array } \right ] , \im'[2 ] = \left[\begin{array}{c } a_4 \\ $ 0 $
\\ a_3 \\ $ 0 $
\\ \vdots \\ \\ $ 0 $
\\ \end{array}\right ] , \ldots , \im'[n_x-1 ] = \left [ \begin{array}{c } $ 0 $ \\
\vdots \\ \\ $ 0 $
\\ a_4 \\ $ 0 $
\\ a_3 \\ \end{array } \right ] , \mbox { and } \im'[n_x ] = \left [ \begin{array}{c } $ 0 $ \\ \\
\vdots \\ \\ $ 0 $ \\ 2a_4
\\ a_3- a_4 \\ \end{array } \right].\ ] ] the exponential cubic b - splines function @xmath75 at node @xmath43 in @xmath17 direction , reads @xcite : @xmath76 where @xmath77 the set @xmath78 forms a base over @xmath48 $ ] . setting the values of @xmath79 and its first and second derivatives at @xmath51 by @xmath80 , @xmath81 and @xmath82 , respectively . then @xmath83 the modified exponential cubic b - splines base functions
are read as : @xmath84 the set @xmath85 is a base over @xmath48 $ ] . the procedure to define modified trigonometric cubic b - splines in @xmath18 direction ,
is followed analogously . setting @xmath86 and @xmath87 for all @xmath88 .
using mexp - dqm , the approximate values of the first - order derivative is given by @xmath89 setting @xmath90 $ ] , @xmath67 $ ] , and @xmath91 $ ] , then eq . can be reduced to compact matrix form : @xmath92 let @xmath93 and @xmath94 . using eqns . and , the coefficient matrix @xmath95 of order @xmath71 , read as : @xmath96\ ] ] and the columns of the matrix @xmath97 read : @xmath98 = \left [ \begin{array}{c } \omega / h_x\\ -\omega / h_x\\ 0 \\ \vdots \\ \\ 0 \\ 0 \\ \end{array } \right ] ,
\beth'[2 ] = \left[\begin{array}{c } \omega/2h_x \\ $ 0 $ \\ -\omega/2h_x \\
$ 0 $ \\ \vdots \\ \\ $ 0 $
\\ \end{array}\right ] , \ldots , \beth'[n_x-1 ] = \left [ \begin{array}{c } $ 0 $ \\ \vdots \\ \\ $ 0 $ \\ \omega/2h_x \\ $ 0 $ \\
\\ \end{array } \right ] , \mbox { and } \beth'[n_x ] = \left [ \begin{array}{c } $ 0 $ \\
\\ \vdots \\ \\ $ 0 $ \\ \omega / h_x \\ -\omega / h_x \\ \end{array } \right].\ ] ] the extended cubic b - splines function @xmath99 , in the @xmath17 direction and at the knots , reads @xcite : @xmath100 where @xmath101 and @xmath102 , and @xmath103 is a free parameter @xcite .
the set @xmath104 forms a base over @xmath48 $ ] .
let @xmath105 and @xmath106 , then the values of @xmath107 and its first and second derivatives in the grid point @xmath51 , denoted by @xmath108 , @xmath109 and @xmath110 , respectively , read : @xmath111 the modified extended cubic b - splines base functions are defined as follows @xcite : @xmath112 the set @xmath113 is a base over @xmath48 $ ] . setting @xmath114 and @xmath115 .
using mecdq method , the approximate values of the first - order derivative is given by @xmath116 setting @xmath117 $ ] , @xmath67 $ ] , and @xmath118 $ ] .
eq . can be re - written in compact matrix form as : @xmath119 using eqns . and
, the matrix @xmath120 of order @xmath71 read as : @xmath121\ ] ] and the columns of the matrix @xmath122 read : @xmath123 = \left [ \begin{array}{c } -1/h_x\\ 1/h_x\\ 0 \\
\vdots \\ \\ 0
\\ 0 \\ \end{array } \right ] , \phi'[2 ] = \left[\begin{array}{c } -1/2h_x \\ $ 0 $ \\ 1/2h_x \\ $ 0 $
\\ \vdots \\ \\ $ 0 $
\\ \end{array}\right ] , \ldots , \phi'[n_x-1 ] = \left [ \begin{array}{c } $ 0 $ \\ \vdots \\ \\ $ 0 $ \\ -1/2h_x \\ $ 0 $ \\
1/2h_x \\ \end{array } \right ] , \mbox { and } \phi'[n_x ] = \left [ \begin{array}{c } $ 0 $ \\
\\ \vdots \\ \\ $ 0 $ \\ -1/h_x \\ 1/h_x \\
\end{array } \right].\ ] ] using thomas algorithm " the system , and have been solved for the weighting coefficients @xmath124 , for all @xmath125 . similarly , the weighting coefficients @xmath126 , in either case , can be computed by employing these modified cubic b - splines in the @xmath18 direction . using @xmath127 and @xmath126 , the weighting coefficients , @xmath128 and @xmath129 ( for @xmath130 )
can be computed using the shu s recursive formulae @xcite : @xmath131 where @xmath35 denote @xmath35-th order spatial derivative . in particular
, the weighting coefficients @xmath132 of order @xmath3 can be obtained by taking @xmath133 in .
after computing the approximate values of first and second order spatial partial derivatives from one of the above three methods , one can re - write eq as follows : @xmath134 in case of the dirichlet conditions , the solutions on boundaries can directly read from as : @xmath135.\ ] ] on the other hand , if the boundary conditions are neumann or mixed type , then the solutions at the boundary are obtained by using any above methods ( mtb - dqm , mexp - dqm or mecdq method ) on the boundary , which gives a system of two equations . on solving it we get the desired solution on the boundary as follows : from eq . with @xmath136 and
the neumann boundary conditions at @xmath137 and @xmath138 , we get @xmath139 in terms of matrix system for @xmath140 , the above equation can be rewritten as @xmath141 \left [ \begin{array}{c } u_{1j } \\
u_{n_x j } \\
\end{array } \right ] = \left [ \begin{array}{c } s_j^a \\ s_j^b \\ \end{array } \right],\ ] ] where @xmath142 and @xmath143 .
on solving , for the boundary values @xmath144 and @xmath145 , we get @xmath146 analogously , for the neumann boundary conditions at @xmath147 and @xmath148 , the solutions for the boundary values @xmath149 and @xmath150 can be obtained as : @xmath151 where @xmath152 and @xmath153 . after implementing the boundary values , eq can be written in compact matrix form as follows : @xmath154 where 1 .
@xmath155 $ ] is the solution vector : + @xmath156 , and @xmath157 represents the initial solution vector .
2 . @xmath158 $ ] is the vector of order @xmath159 containing the boundary values , i.e. , + @xmath160 3 .
@xmath161 be a square matrix of order @xmath162 given as @xmath163 where @xmath164 and @xmath165 @xmath166 are the block diagonal matrices of the weighting coefficients @xmath58 and @xmath167 , respectively as given below @xmath168 , \mbox { and } & ~ b_r = \left [ \begin{array}{cccc } m_r & o & \ldots & o \\ o & m_r & \ldots & o \\ \vdots & \vdots & \ddots & \vdots \\ o & o & \ldots & m_r \\
\end{array } \right ] , \end{array}\ ] ] where @xmath169 and @xmath170 are the matrices of order @xmath171 , and the sub - matrix @xmath172 of the block diagonal matrix @xmath173 is given by @xmath174 .
\end{array}\ ] ] finally , we adopted ssp - rk54 scheme @xcite to solve the initial value system as : @xmath175 where @xmath176
the stability of the method mtb - dqm for @xmath3d convection - diffusion equation depends on the stability of the initial value system of odes as defined in .
noticed that whenever the system of odes is unstable , the proposed method for temporal discretization may not converge to the exact solution . moreover , being the exact solution can directly obtained by means of the eigenvalues method , the stability of depends on the eigenvalues of the coefficient matrix @xmath161 @xcite .
in fact , the stability region is the set @xmath177 , where @xmath178 is the stability function and @xmath179 is the eigenvalue of the coefficient matrix @xmath161 . the stability region for ssp - rk54 scheme is depicted in ( * ? ? ?
* fig.1 ) , from which one can clam that for the stability of the system it is sufficient that @xmath180 for each eigenvalue @xmath179 of the coefficient matrix b. hence , the real part of each eigenvalue is necessarily either zero or negative .
it is seen that the eigenvalues of the matrices @xmath181 and @xmath173 @xmath182 have identical nature .
therefore , it is sufficient to compute the eigenvalues , @xmath183 and @xmath184 , of the matrices @xmath185 and @xmath186 for different values of grid sizes @xmath187 . the eigenvalues @xmath183 and @xmath184 for @xmath188 has been depicted in figure [ eq - eignv ] .
analogously , one can compute the eigenvalues @xmath183 and @xmath184 using mecdq method @xcite or mexp - dqm .
it is seen that in either case , @xmath183 and @xmath184 have same nature as in figure [ eq - eignv ] .
further , we can get from figure [ eq - eignv ] that each eigenvalue @xmath179 of the matrix @xmath161 as defined in eq .
is real and negative .
this confirms that the proposed methods produces stable solutions for two dimensional convection - diffusion equations .
this section deals with the main goal , the numerical study of three test problems of the initial value system of convection - diffusion equations with both kinds of the boundary conditions has been done by adopting the methods mtb - dqm , mexp - dqm and mecdq method along with the integration ssp - rk54 scheme .
the accuracy and the efficiency of the methods have been measured in terms of the discrete error norms : namely- average @xmath189 norm ( @xmath190-error norm ) and the maximum error ( @xmath191 error norm ) .
[ ex1 ] consider the initial value system of @xmath3d convection - diffusion equation with @xmath192 , while values of @xmath193 for @xmath194 can be extracted from the exact solution @xmath195 where initial condition is a gaussian pulse with unit hight centered at @xmath196 .
we have computed the numerical solution of problem [ ex1 ] for @xmath197 and different values of @xmath198 . for @xmath199 ^ 2 $ ] : @xmath200 errors and the rate of convergence ( roc ) @xcite at @xmath201 for different values of @xmath202 ( @xmath203 )
has been reported in table [ tab1.1 ] for @xmath204 .
table [ tab1.1 ] confirms that the proposed solutions obtained by these methods are more accurate , and approaching towards exact solutions .
the behavior of the approximate solution at time @xmath201 taking @xmath205 is depicted in figure [ ex1-fig1.1 ] for @xmath206 and in figure [ ex1-fig1.2 ] for @xmath207 . for @xmath208 ^ 2 $ ] , time @xmath209 , and grid space step size @xmath210 : the @xmath190 and @xmath200 error norms in the proposed solutions
have been compared with the errors in the solutions by various schemes in @xcite in table [ tab1.2 ] for @xmath211 and in table [ tab1.3 ] for @xmath212 .
the initial solution and mtb - dqm solutions in @xmath213 ^ 2 $ ] with the parameter values @xmath214 have been depicted in figure [ ex1-fig1.3 ] , and similar behavior is seen from the other two methods .
it is evident from the above reports that the proposed results are more accurate as compared to @xcite and approaching towards the exact solutions .
l*8l + @xmath71 & & & & & + & @xmath200 @xmath215 & roc @xmath215 & & @xmath200 @xmath215 & roc @xmath215 & & @xmath200 @xmath215 & roc + 5 & 2.91e-03 & & & 2.91e-03 & & & 1.94e-03 & + 10&6.41e-04 & 2.18 & & 6.42e-04&2.181 & & 4.93e-04 & 1.98 + 20&6.50e-05 & 3.30 & & 6.51e-05&3.303 & & 6.05e-05 & 3.03 + 40&7.19e-06 & 3.18 & & 7.18e-06&3.180 & & 6.91e-06 & 3.13 + 80@xmath216 & 7.22e-07 @xmath217 & 3.31 & @xmath218 & 7.00e-07@xmath217&3.358 & @xmath218 & 6.99e-07 @xmath219&3.31 + + 5 & 4.93e-04 & & & 4.97e-04 & & & 3.20e-04 & + 10&4.86e-05 & 3.34 & & 4.87e-05 & 3.35 & & 4.39e-05&2.87 + 20&4.70e-06 & 3.37 & & 4.70e-06 & 3.37 & & 4.35e-06&3.34 + 40&4.51e-07 & 3.38 & & 4.46e-07 & 3.40 & & 4.50e-07&3.27 + 80@xmath216&4.58e-08@xmath216 & 3.30 @xmath216 & & 3.49e-08 @xmath216&3.67 & & 4.37e-08@xmath216 & 3.36 + * 3l schemes & @xmath190 & @xmath200 + p - r - adi @xcite & 3.109e-04 @xmath220 @xmath220 & 7.778e-03 + noye @xmath221 tang @xcite & 1.971e-05 & 6.509e-04 + kalila
@xcite & 1.597e-05 & 4.447e-04 + kara @xmath221 zhang adi @xcite & 9.218e-06 & 2.500e-04 + tang @xmath221 ge adi@xcite & 9.663e-06 & 2.664e-04 + dehghan @xmath221 mohebbi @xcite@xmath220 @xmath220 & 9.431e-06 & 2.477e-04 + mtb - dqm & 8.026e-12 & 4.327e-08 + mexp - dqm(p=0.0001 ) & 7.030e-12 & 4.154e-08 + mecdq ( @xmath222 ) & 4.504e-12 & 3.343e-08 + mcb - dqm ( @xmath223 ) & 8.269e-12 & 4.388e-08 + * 3l schemes & @xmath190 & @xmath200 + noye @xmath221 tang @xcite & 1.430e-05 & 4.840e-04 + kalila et al.@xcite & 1.590e-05 & 4.480e-04 + dehghan @xmath221 mohebbi @xcite @xmath220 @xmath220 & 9.480e-06 @xmath220 @xmath220 @xmath220 & 2.469e-04 + mtb - dqm & 8.900e-12 & 4.501e-08 + mexp - dqm(p=0.0001 ) & 9.147e-12 & 4.315e-08 + mecdq ( @xmath224 ) & 4.646e-12 & 3.852e-08 + mcb - dqm ( @xmath223 ) & 9.147e-12 & 4.561e-08 + [ ex2 ] consider the initial value system of @xmath3d convection - diffusion equation with @xmath225 ^ 2 $ ] with @xmath226 , where @xmath227 and the neumann boundary condition @xmath228,\]]or the dirichlet s conditions can be extracted from the exact solution @xcite : @xmath229 the computation by the proposed methods has been done for different values of @xmath230 and @xmath231 . for @xmath232 , we take @xmath233 for the solutions at @xmath234 .
the rate of convergence and @xmath190 error norms in the proposed solutions has been compared with that of due to fourth - order compact finite difference scheme @xcite for @xmath235 , in table [ tab2.1 ] .
it is found that the proposed solutions from either method are more accurate in comparison to @xcite , and are in good agreement with the exact solutions . for @xmath236
, we take @xmath237 for the solution at @xmath234 . in table
[ tab2.2 ] , the @xmath190 and @xmath200 error norms are compared with that obtained by fourth - order compact finite difference scheme @xcite for @xmath236 , and @xmath238 .
rate of convergence have been reported in table [ tab2.3 ] . from tables
[ tab2.2 ] and [ tab2.3 ] , we found that the proposed solutions are more accurate as compared to the results in @xcite , while the rate of convergence is linear .
the behavior of solutions is depicted in figure [ ex2-fig2.2 ] and [ ex2-fig2.3 ] with @xmath239 for @xmath240 and @xmath241 , respectively .
for the same parameter , mentioned above , the numerical solution is obtained by using neumann conditions and reported in table [ tab2.4 ] .
the obtained results are in good agreement with the exact solutions , the rate of convergence for @xmath242 is quadratic for each method . * 2lclcllclcllclcllc + & & & & & & & + @xmath243 & @xmath242 & roc & @xmath190 & roc & & @xmath242 & roc & @xmath190 & roc & & @xmath242 & roc & @xmath190 & roc & & @xmath190 & roc + 0.2 & 4.231e-06 & & 4.969e-10 & & & 1.714e-05 & & 3.584e-09 & & & 4.231e-06 & & 4.999e-10 & & & & + 0.1 & 5.155e-07 & 3.0 & 2.472e-11 & 4.3 & & 5.168e-07 & 5.1 & 2.473e-11 & 7.2 & & 5.153e-07 & 3.0 & 2.478e-11 & 4.3 & & 2.289e-10 & + 0.05 & 5.108e-08 & 3.3 & 9.041e-13 & 4.8 & & 5.105e-08 & 3.3 & 9.044e-13 & 4.8 & & 5.107e-08 & 3.3 & 9.049e-13 & 4.8&&1.621e-11 & 3.82 + 0.025 & 1.147e-08 & 2.2 & 1.922e-14 & 5.6 & & 1.147e-08 & 2.2 & 1.922e-14 & 5.6 & & 1.147e08 & 2.4 & 1.923e-14 & 5.6&&8.652e-13 & 4.23 + + 0.2 & 7.4031e-06 & & 1.4907e-09 & & & 3.5634e-05 & & 1.5314e-08 & & & 2.0585e-06 & & 6.7290e-11 & & & & + 0.1 & 1.1460e-06 & 2.7 & 1.3103e-10 & 3.5 & & 1.1421e-06 & 5.0 & 1.3148e-10 & 6.9 & & 1.5919e-07 & 3.7 & 1.1624e-12 & 5.9 & & 2.749e-09 & + 0.05 & 1.4578e-07 & 3.0 & 7.5377e-12 & 4.1 & & 1.4582e-07 & 3.0 & 7.5396e-12 & 4.1 & & 1.9012e-08 & 3.1 & 5.4939e-14 & 4.4 & & 2.394e-10 & 3.52 + 0.025 & 1.3902e-08 & 3.4 & 2.7129e-13 & 4.8 & & 1.3904e-08 & 3.4 & 2.7132e-13 & 4.8 & & 6.2220e-09 & 1.6 & 9.0456e-15 & 2.6 & & 1.658e-11 & 3.85 + * 6l*6l*6l & & & & & & & + @xmath243 & @xmath200 & & @xmath190 & & @xmath200 & & @xmath190 & & @xmath200 & & @xmath190 & & @xmath200 & & @xmath190 + 0.04 @xmath215 & 4.1718e-03@xmath215 & & 1.7833e-03@xmath215 & & 1.7475e-03@xmath215 & & 7.9168e-04 & & 1.2939e-03@xmath215 & & 3.6957e-04 & & 1.1826e-01 @xmath215 & & 4.9331e-03 + 0.02 & 5.2095e-04 & & 6.8410e-05 & & 5.2097e-04 & & 6.8445e-05 & & 6.3735e-04 & & 6.8622e-05 & & 1.5310e-02 & & 4.1351e-04 + 0.01 & 3.2496e-04 & & 2.1508e-05 & & 3.2484e-04 & & 2.1493e-05 & & 2.5394e-04 & & 1.8260e-05 & & 9.4696e-04 & & 2.8405e-05 + * 5l*5l*5l & + & & & & & + @xmath243 & @xmath242 & roc & @xmath190 & roc & & @xmath242 & roc & @xmath190 & roc & & @xmath242 & roc & @xmath190 & roc + 0.1 & 2.6263e-02 & & 3.6277e-02 & & & 2.6280e-02 & & 3.6670e-02 & & & 2.4464e-02 & & 4.0175e-02 & + 0.05 & 6.8144e-03 & 1.9 & 4.1447e-03 & 3.1 & & 6.8144e-03 & 1.9 & 4.1339e-03 & 3.1 & & 3.3580e-03 & 2.9 & 1.6264e-03 & 4.6 + 0.025 & 1.1634e-03 & 2.6 & 2.7780e-04 & 3.9 & & 1.0719e-03 & 2.7 & 1.9697e-04 & 4.4 & & 8.1776e-04 & 2.0 & 1.0090e-04 & 4.0 + & + & & & & & + 0.01 & 5.0998e-04 & & 3.5191e-03 & & & 5.0738e-04 & & 1.0116e-05 & & & 7.4180e-04 & & 2.5558e-05 & + 0.05 & 1.8776e-04 & 1.4 & 1.8193e-03 & 1.0 & & 1.8776e-04 & 1.4 & 2.9979e-06 & 1.8 & & 2.0972e-04 & 1.8 & 5.1381e-06 & 2.3 + 0.025 & 9.9342e-05 & 0.9 & 9.1372e-04 & 1.0 & & 9.9342e-05 & 0.9 & 7.9462e-07 & 1.9 & & 9.5677e-05 & 1.1 & 8.1188e-07 & 2.7 + l*4c*5c*5c & + & & & & & + @xmath243 & @xmath242 & roc & @xmath190 & roc & & @xmath242 & roc & @xmath190 & roc & & @xmath242 & roc & @xmath190 & roc + 0.05 & 1.0176e-02 & & 6.7504e-03 & & & 1.0177e-02 & & 6.7513e-03 & & & 9.1549e-03 & & 5.7412e-03 & + 0.025 & 2.2164e-03 & 2.2 & 1.0428e-03 & 2.7 & & 2.2165e-03 & 2.2 & 1.0429e-03 & 2.7 & & 1.9834e-03 & 2.2 & 8.7214e-04 & 2.7 + 0.0125 & 2.9460e-04 & 2.9 & 7.2888e-05 & 3.8 & & 2.9460e-04 & 2.9 & 7.2889e-05 & 3.8 & & 2.5565e-04&3.0 & 5.6518e-05 & 3.9 + & + & & & & & + 0.05 & 1.2070e-01 & & 6.3285e-01 & & & 1.2070e-01 & & 6.3293e-01 & & & 1.0921e-01 & & 6.0454e-01 & + 0.025 & 2.7808e-02 & 2.1 & 6.2302e-02 & 3.3 & & 2.7809e-02 & 2.1 & 6.2304e-02 & 3.3 & & 2.6004e-02 & 2.1 & 5.5004e-02 & 3.5 + 0.0125&6.0348e-03 & 2.2 & 6.4433e-03 & 3.3 & & 6.0348e-03 & 2.2 & 6.4433e-03 & 3.3 & & 5.4733e-03 & 2.2 & 5.5668e-03 & 3.3 + & + & & & & & + 0.05 & 1.4931e-05 & & 5.8044e-08 & & & 1.4932e-05 & & 5.8056e-08 & & & 1.3598e-05 & & 4.8332e-08 & + 0.025 & 3.3009e-06 & 2.2 & 1.0664e-08 & 2.4 & & 3.3009e-06 & 2.2 & 1.0665e-08 & 2.4 & & 2.9824e-06 & 2.2 & 8.7286e-09 & 2.5 + 0.0125 & 4.5947e-07 & 2.8 & 8.0780e-10 & 3.7 & & 4.5947e-07 & 2.8 & 8.0780e-10 & 3.7 & & 3.9840e-07 & 2.9 & 6.0761e-10 & 3.8 + & + & & & & & + 0.05 & 1.7132e-05 & & 6.9905e-08 & & & 1.7132e-05 & & 6.9910e-08 & & & 1.6511e-05 & & 6.5219e-08 & + 0.025 & 3.9931e-06 & 2.1 & 1.4135e-08 & 2.3 & & 3.9932e-06 & 2.1 & 1.4136e-08 & 2.3 & & 3.7892e-06 & 2.1 & 1.2756e-08 & 2.4 + 0.0125 & 8.8931e-07 & 2.2 & 2.7052e-09 & 2.4 & & 8.8931e-07 & 2.2 & 2.7052e-09 & 2.4 & & 8.2511e-07 & 2.2 & 2.3316e-09 & 2.5 + [ ex3 ] the initial value system of @xmath3d convection - diffusion equation with @xmath244 ^ 2 $ ] and @xmath245 , and @xmath246 where @xmath247 the distribution of the initial solution is depicted in figure [ ex3-fig3.1 ] .
the solutions behavior is obtained for the parameter values : @xmath248 and @xmath249 , and is depicted in figure [ ex3-fig3.2 ] due to mtb - dqm , also we noticed the similar characteristics obtained using mexp - dqm and mecdq method .
the obtained characteristics agreed well as obtained in @xcite .
in this paper , the numerical computations of initial value system of two dimensional _ convection - diffusion _ equations with both kinds of boundary conditions has been done by adopting three methods : modified exponential cubic b - splines dqm , modified trigonometric cubic b - splines dqm , and mecdq method @xcite , which transforms the _ convection - diffusion _ equation into a system of first order ordinary differential equations ( odes ) , in time , which is solved by using ssp - rk54 scheme .
the methods are found stable for two space convection - diffusion equation by employing matrix stability analysis method .
section [ sec - num ] shows that the proposed solutions are more accurate in comparison to the solutions by various existing schemes , and are in good agreement with the exact solutions .
the order of accuracy of the proposed methods for the convection - diffusion problem with dirichlet s boundary conditions is cubic whenever @xmath250 and otherwise it is super linear , in space . on the other hand ,
the order of accuracy of the proposed methods for the convection - diffusion problem with neumann boundary condition is quadratic with respect to @xmath251 error norms , see table [ tab2.4 ] .
huai - huo cao , li - bin liu , yong zhang and sheng - mao fu , a fourth - order method of the convection - diffusion equations with neumann boundary conditions , applied mathematics and computation 217 ( 2011 ) 9133 - 9141 .
hengfei ding and yuxin zhang , a new difference scheme with high accuracy and absolute stability for solving convection - diffusion equations , journal of computational and applied mathematics 230 ( 2009 ) 600 - 606 .
kalita , d.c .
dalal and a.k .
dass , a class of higher order compact schemes for the unsteady two - dimensional convection - diffusion equation with variable convection coefficients , int .
methods fluids 38 ( 2002 ) 1111 - 1131 .
m. zerroukat , k. djidjeli and a. charafi , explicit and implicite messless method for linear advection - diffusion - type partial differential eqations , international journal numerical method in engineering 48 ( 2000 ) 19 - 35 .
g. arora , v. joshi , a computational approach for solution of one dimensional parabolic partial differential equation with application in biological processes , ain shams eng j ( 2016 ) , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.asej.2016.06.013 .
singh , p. kumar , an algorithm based on a new dqm with modified extended cubic b - splines for numerical study of two dimensional hyperbolic telegraph equation , alexandria eng .
j. ( 2016 ) , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.aej.2016.11.009 .
g. arora , rc mittal and b. k. singh , numerical solution of bbm - burger equation with quartic b - spline collocation method , journal of engineering science and technology , special issue 1 , 12/2014 , 104 - 116 .
v. k. srivastava and b. k. singh , a robust finite difference scheme for the numerical solutions of two dimensional time - dependent coupled nonlinear burgers equations , international journal of applied mathematics and mechanics 10(7 ) ( 2014 ) 28 - 39 .
a. korkmaz and h.k .
akmaz , extended b - spline differential quadrature method for nonlinear viscous burgers equation , proceedings of international conference on mathematics and mathematics education , pp 323 - 323 , elazi , turkey 12 - 14 may , 2016 .
muhammad abbas , ahmad abd .
majid , ahmad izani md .
ismail , abdur rashid , the application of cubic trigonometric b - spline to the numerical solution of the hyperbolic problems , applied mathematics and computation 239 ( 2014 ) 74 - 88 .
( left ) of 2d convection - diffusion equation with @xmath238 , @xmath254 for @xmath255 , title="fig:",width=236,height=170 ] ( left ) of 2d convection - diffusion equation with @xmath238 , @xmath254 for @xmath255 , title="fig:",width=379,height=170 ] ( left ) of 2d convection - diffusion equation with @xmath238 , @xmath254 for @xmath255 , title="fig:",width=283,height=194 ] ( left ) of 2d convection - diffusion equation with @xmath238 , @xmath254 for @xmath255 , title="fig:",width=283,height=194 ] d convection - diffusion equation in example [ ex3 ] at @xmath256 ( left ) and @xmath257 ( right),title="fig:",width=283,height=194 ] d convection - diffusion equation in example [ ex3 ] at @xmath256 ( left ) and @xmath257 ( right),title="fig:",width=283,height=194 ] d convection - diffusion equation in example [ ex3 ] at @xmath256 ( left ) and @xmath257 ( right),title="fig:",width=283,height=194 ] d convection - diffusion equation in example [ ex3 ] at @xmath256 ( left ) and @xmath257 ( right),title="fig:",width=283,height=194 ] d convection - diffusion equation in example [ ex3 ] at @xmath256 ( left ) and @xmath257 ( right),title="fig:",width=292,height=194 ] d convection - diffusion equation in example [ ex3 ] at @xmath256 ( left ) and @xmath257 ( right),title="fig:",width=292,height=194 ] | this paper deals with the numerical computations of two space dimensional time dependent _ parabolic partial differential equations _ by adopting adopting an optimal five stage fourth - order strong stability preserving runge - kutta ( ssp - rk54 ) scheme for time discretization , and three methods of differential quadrature with different sets of modified b - splines as base functions , for space discretization : namely- @xmath0 mecdqm : ( dqm with modified extended cubic b - splines ) ; @xmath1 mexp - dqm : dqm with modified exponential cubic b - splines , and @xmath2 mtb - dqm : dqm with modified trigonometric cubic b splines .
specially , we implement these methods on _ convection - diffusion _ equation to convert them into a system of first order ordinary differential equations ( odes ) , in time .
the resulting system of odes can be solved using any time integration method , while we prefer ssp - rk54 scheme .
all the three methods are found stable for two space convection - diffusion equation by employing matrix stability analysis method .
the accuracy and validity of the methods are confirmed by three test problems of two dimensional _ convection - diffusion _ equation , which shows that the proposed approximate solutions by any of the method are in good agreement with the exact solutions .
convection - diffusion equation , modified trigonometric cubic - b - splines , modified exponential cubic - b - splines , modified extended cubic - b - splines , differential quadrature method , ssp - rk54 scheme , thomas algorithm |
the higgs boson search is underway at the cern lhc . by the recent results , the allowed regions of the higgs boson mass has been constrained to be 117.5 - 118.5 gev , 122.5 - 129 gev and larger than 539 gev at 95% confidence level ( cl ) at the atlas @xcite , and 114.4 - 127.5 gev and larger than 600 gev at 95% cl at the cms @xcite .
since the electroweak precision data at the lep suggest that the higgs boson mass is less than around 160 gev at 95% cl @xcite assuming the standard model ( sm ) , we expect that a light ( sm - like ) higgs boson will be discovered with the mass of around 125 gev soon .
on the other hand , it is well known that several phenomena such as tiny neutrino masses @xcite , existence of dark matter @xcite and baryon asymmetry of the universe @xcite can not be explained in the sm . because there is no strong motivation to the sm ( minimal ) higgs sector
, we may consider extensions of the higgs sector in order to explain these phenomena .
first , by imposing an unbroken discrete symmetry to the higgs sector , we can obtain dark matter candidates , such as the inert doublet model @xcite .
second , the type - ii seesaw model @xcite , where a higgs triplet field is added to the sm , can generate neutrino masses at the tree level .
radiative seesaw models @xcite can also explain neutrino masses at loop levels , where additional scalar bosons , e.g. , charged scalar bosons , are running in the loop .
finally , the scenario based on the electroweak baryogenesis can explain the baryon asymmetry of the universe by an additional cp - phase and nondecoupling effects in extended higgs sectors @xcite .
discoveries of additional scalar bosons such as charged higgs bosons will be direct evidence of extended higgs sectors .
in addition , as indirect signatures , detecting the deviation of the higgs boson couplings with gauge bosons @xmath9 , those with quarks and leptons @xmath10 and higgs selfcoupling constant @xmath7 , where @xmath8 is the sm - like higgs boson , from those predicted values in the sm can also be evidence of extended higgs sectors . in particular , once @xmath8 is discovered at the lhc in near future , precision measurements of these coupling constants at the lhc and at the international linear collider ( ilc ) turns to be very important .
therefore , in order to distinguish various extended higgs sectors , it is necessary to prepare precise calculations for the higgs boson interactions including radiative corrections . in this letter
, we construct the renormalization scheme for the one - loop calculation of the observables in the higgs sector such as mass spectrum and coupling constants in the higgs triplet model ( htm ) , where the hypercharge @xmath0 higgs triplet field is added to the sm .
the htm is motivated to generate tiny neutrino masses by the type - ii seesaw mechanism .
this model is unique because the electroweak rho parameter deviates from unity at the tree level .
in such a model , unlike the sm , four independently measured parameters such as @xmath11 , @xmath12 , @xmath13 and @xmath14 are necessary to describe the electroweak observables @xcite . in the model with the @xmath15 higgs triplet field ,
the rho parameter and the w boson mass were calculated at the one - loop level in the on - shell scheme in ref .
recently , in the htm , one - loop corrections to the rho parameter as well as the w boson mass have been studied @xcite , and it is clarified that relatively large mass differences among the triplet - like higgs bosons are favored by the precision data at the lep / slc @xcite . however , radiative corrections to the higgs sector with renormalization have not been studied in the htm so far . in the htm
, there are seven physics scalar states ; i.e. , the doubly - charged @xmath5 , the singly - charged @xmath6 , a cp - odd @xmath4 as well as two cp - even ( @xmath8 and @xmath3 ) scalar states .
when the vacuum expectation value ( vev ) of the triplet field @xmath16 is much smaller than that of the doublet field @xmath17 as required by the electroweak precision data , @xmath8 behaves as the sm - like higgs boson while @xmath5 , @xmath6 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 are the triplet - like ones .
phenomenology for the htm has been studied in refs .
when the triplet - like higgs bosons are degenerated in mass , @xmath18 mainly decays into the same sign dilepton or the diboson depending on the magnitude of @xmath16 . on the other hand , in the case with the mass difference among the triplet - like fields , cascade decays of the triplet - like higgs bosons can be dominant @xcite .
for example , when @xmath18 ( @xmath3 or @xmath4 ) is the heaviest of all the triplet - like higgs bosons , the main decay mode of @xmath18 ( @xmath3 or @xmath4 ) can be @xmath19 or @xmath20 ( @xmath3 or @xmath21 ) . in any case , measuring the masses of the triplet - like higgs bosons is important to test the htm . for @xmath22 ,
characteristic relationships among the masses of the triplet - like higgs bosons are predicted at the tree level @xcite : @xmath23 up to @xmath24 , where @xmath25 , @xmath26 , @xmath27 and @xmath28 are the masses of @xmath5 , @xmath6 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 , respectively .
these formulae are useful to distinguish the model from the others which also contain charged scalar bosons when the masses of the triplet - like higgs bosons are measured with sufficient accuracy . in particular , in order to compare the mass spectrum with future precision measurements , it is very important to evaluate the radiative correction to the above tree - level formulae .
we first define @xmath29 in order to investigate how the mass formulae in eq .
( [ eq : intro1 ] ) are modified by the quantum effect .
we find that the magnitude for @xmath30 can be as large as @xmath31 when we take parameter sets favored by the electroweak precision data : @xmath22 , @xmath32 gev and @xmath33 gev @xcite . the theoretical prediction on the triple higgs boson coupling @xmath7 is also quite important because the higgs potential is reconstructed by measuring the mass of @xmath8 and the coupling of @xmath7 . in the case of the two higgs doublet model , radiative corrections to the coupling of @xmath7
have been studied by using the effective potential method in ref .
@xcite as well as the diagrammatical method in the on - shell scheme in ref .
@xcite , in which the renormalized @xmath7 coupling can deviate from the sm prediction by about 100% due to the nondecoupling property of the additional scalar bosons without contradiction of the perturbative unitarity @xcite .
we here calculate the renormalized @xmath7 coupling in the htm , and find that the deviation of this coupling from the sm prediction can also be of @xmath34 in the parameter choice of @xmath22 , @xmath32 gev and @xmath33 gev .
the htm is one of the minimal extension of the sm , where the higgs triplet field @xmath35 with @xmath0 is added to the sm .
the most general higgs potential under the @xmath36 gauge invariance is given by @xmath37 \nonumber \\ & & + \lambda_1 ( \phi^\dagger \phi)^2 + \lambda_2 \left[{\rm tr}(\delta^\dagger \delta ) \right]^2 + \lambda_3 { \rm tr}\left[(\delta^\dagger \delta)^2\right ] + \lambda_4 ( \phi^\dagger\phi ) { \rm tr}(\delta^\dagger \delta ) + \lambda_5 \phi^\dagger \delta \delta^\dagger \phi .
\label{eq : pot } \end{aligned}\ ] ] the higgs fields are parameterized as @xmath38,\quad \delta = \left[\begin{array}{cc } \frac{\delta^+}{\sqrt{2 } } & \delta^{++ } \\
\delta^0 & - \frac{\delta^+}{\sqrt{2 } } \\ \end{array}\right],\quad \text{with } \delta^0 = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2 } } ( \delta^0+v_\delta + i \xi^0 ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath17 and @xmath16 are the vevs of the doublet field and the triplet field , respectively , which satisfy @xmath39 . when the triplet field @xmath35 carries lepton number of two units ( @xmath40 ) , the @xmath41 term breaks the lepton number , so that it is the source of majorana masses of neutrinos .
the tree - level contributions to the tadpoles for the component fields @xmath42 and @xmath43 are given by @xmath44 by using the stationary conditions @xmath45 , we obtain @xmath46 where @xmath47 . the mass of the doubly - charged scalar bosons @xmath48 @xmath49 is given as @xmath50 the mass matrices can be expressed for the singly - charged scalar states in the basis of @xmath51 and the cp - odd scalar states in the basis of @xmath52 as @xmath53,\quad m_{\rm cp - odd}^2 = m_\delta^2 \left [ \begin{array}{cc } \frac{4 v_\delta^2}{v_\phi^2 } & - \frac{2 v_\delta}{v_\phi } \\ - \frac{2 v_\delta}{v_\phi } & 1 \\
\end{array}\right ] .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] the mass eigenstates of the scalar fields are obtained by diagonalizing these mass matrices by the mixing angle @xmath54 and @xmath55 as @xmath56 = \left[\begin{array}{cc } \cos\beta & - \sin\beta \\
\sin\beta & \cos\beta \\ \end{array}\right ] \left[\begin{array}{c } g^\pm \\
h^\pm \\
\end{array}\right ] , \quad \left[\begin{array}{c } z^0 \\ \xi^0 \\
\end{array}\right ] = \left[\begin{array}{cc } \cos\beta ' & - \sin\beta ' \\
\sin\beta ' & \cos\beta ' \\ \end{array}\right ] \left[\begin{array}{c } g^0 \\
a \\
\end{array}\right ] , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath57 and @xmath58 are the nambu - goldstone bosons which are absorbed by the longitudinal component of the weak gauge bosons , and the mixing angles are given by @xmath59 we then obtain the masses of the singly - charged scalar bosons and the cp - odd scalar boson as @xmath60 for the cp - even scalar states , the mass matrix is given in the basis of ( @xmath42 , @xmath43 ) by @xmath61 .
\label{eq : meven}\end{aligned}\ ] ] by the diagonalization of this matrix with the mixing angle @xmath62 as @xmath63 = \left[\begin{array}{cc } \cos\alpha & - \sin\alpha \\ \sin\alpha & \cos\alpha \\
\end{array}\right ] \left[\begin{array}{c } h \\
h \\
\end{array}\right ] , \end{aligned}\ ] ] we obtain the masses of the cp - even higgs bosons and the mixing angle : @xmath64 where @xmath65 , @xmath66 are elements of the mass matrix in eq .
( [ eq : meven ] ) . from eqs .
( [ eq : vc1 ] ) , ( [ eq : vc2 ] ) , ( [ eq : mhpp ] ) , ( [ eq : mhp ] ) , ( [ eq : ma ] ) , ( [ eq : mh ] ) , ( [ eq : mh ] ) and ( [ eq : tan2a ] ) , eight parameters : @xmath67 , @xmath68 , @xmath41 and @xmath69-@xmath70 in the higgs potential can be translated into five mass parameters : @xmath25 , @xmath71 , @xmath27 , @xmath28 and @xmath72 , one mixing angle @xmath62 and two vevs : @xmath17 and @xmath16 . in the next section ,
we take @xmath73 as one of the input parameters instead of @xmath17 .
masses of neutrinos are generated through the yukawa interaction : @xmath74 where @xmath75 is a @xmath76 symmetric complex matrix , @xmath77 is the @xmath78-th generation of the left - handed lepton doublet . after the electroweak symmetry breaking ,
the neutrino masses are obtained as @xmath79 it can be seen that when the lepton number violating parameter @xmath41 is taken to be of @xmath80 ev with @xmath81 , we can take @xmath82 to be @xmath83 gev with satisfying @xmath84 ev which is required by the data .
in such a case , the htm can be tested at tev - scale collider experiments .
the smallness of @xmath41 is just the assumption in the minimal version of the htm .
however , if the parameter @xmath41 is forbidden at the tree level but is generated at higher orders of perturbation , such a tiny value of @xmath41 may be explained in a natural way @xcite . in the htm ,
the electroweak rho parameter @xmath85 deviates from unity at the tree level : @xmath86 the experimental value of the rho parameter @xmath87 is quite close to unity : @xmath88 @xcite , so that the value of @xmath16 is bounded from above : @xmath89 gev .
therefore , @xmath90 is phenomenologically acceptable . in such a case , since @xmath54 , @xmath55 and @xmath62 are near zero , the scalar bosons @xmath5 , @xmath6 , @xmath4 and @xmath3 can be regarded as the triplet - like higgs bosons while @xmath8 behaves the sm - like higgs boson . neglecting terms with @xmath24
, there appear characteristic mass formulae as @xmath91 the relation in eq .
( [ mass1 ] ) can also be described as @xmath92 the mass formulae eqs .
( [ mass1 ] ) and ( [ mass2 ] ) can be understood by considering global symmetries in the higgs potential in eq .
( [ eq : pot ] ) , which is invariant under the @xmath36 gauge symmetry .
the potential has accidental global symmetries in some specific cases as discussed below .
first , let us consider the case where the @xmath41 term is absent in the potential .
the potential then respects the global @xmath93 symmetry which conserves the lepton number .
unless the lepton number is spontaneously broken the triplet field does not carry the vev ; i.e. , @xmath94 .
the terms of @xmath95 and @xmath96 then do not contribute to the four mass parameters @xmath25 , @xmath26 , @xmath28 and @xmath27 , so that they are described by the @xmath97 and @xmath70 couplings .
therefore , two of the four are independent and the rest two are determined via eqs .
( [ mass1 ] ) and ( [ mass2 ] ) .
next , we consider the case where both the @xmath41 term and the @xmath70 term are zero . in this case
, an additional global @xmath98 symmetry ( we call this symmetry as @xmath99 ) appears in addition to the @xmath93 lepton number symmetry . under this @xmath99 symmetry ,
@xmath100 and @xmath35 can be transformed with the different @xmath98 phases . in this case
, only the @xmath97 coupling can contribute to the masses of the triplet - like higgs bosons .
therefore , all these masses are degenerate ; i.e. , @xmath101 .
in this section , we define the scheme for the one - loop calculations by setting the renormalization conditions for the parameters of the htm in the similar way to the case in the two higgs doublet model constructed in ref .
first of all , while at the tree level the tadpoles @xmath102 and @xmath103 are set to be zero , at the one - loop level they are nonzero and used to eliminate the one - point functions of @xmath8 and @xmath3 .
we here prepare the tadpole counter - terms @xmath104 and @xmath105 by shifting the tadpoles as @xmath106 second , there are eight parameters in the higgs potential : @xmath25 , @xmath26 , @xmath27 , @xmath28 , @xmath107 , @xmath62 , @xmath73 and @xmath16 . at the one - loop level ,
the counter - terms for these parameters are obtained as @xmath108 where @xmath78 represents @xmath18 , @xmath109 , @xmath4 , @xmath3 and @xmath8 .
in addition to these counter - terms , those for mixing angles as well as the wave function renormalization factors are defined by @xmath110 & \to \left[\begin{array}{cc } 1 + \frac{1}{2 } \delta z_{g^+ } & \delta \beta + \delta c_{gh } \\
- \delta \beta + \delta c_{gh } & 1 + \frac{1}{2 } \delta z_{h^+ } \\
\end{array}\right ] \left[\begin{array}{c } g^\pm \\ h^\pm
\\ \end{array}\right ] , \\
\left[\begin{array}{c } g^0 \\
a \\
\end{array}\right ] & \to \left[\begin{array}{cc } 1 + \frac{1}{2 } \delta z_{g^0 } & \delta \beta ' + \delta c_{ga } \\
- \delta \beta ' + \delta c_{ga } & 1 + \frac{1}{2 } \delta z_{a } \\
\end{array}\right ] \left[\begin{array}{c } g^0 \\
a \\ \end{array}\right ] , \\
\left[\begin{array}{c } h \\
\\ \end{array}\right ] & \to \left[\begin{array}{cc } 1 + \frac{1}{2 } \delta z_{h } & \delta \alpha + \delta c_{hh } \\
- \delta \alpha + \delta c_{hh } & 1 + \frac{1}{2 } \delta z_{h } \\
\end{array}\right ] \left[\begin{array}{c } h \\
h \\
\end{array}\right ] .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] in order to determine these 22 counter - terms @xmath104 , @xmath105 , @xmath111 , @xmath112 , @xmath113 , @xmath114 , @xmath115,@xmath116 , @xmath117 , @xmath118 , @xmath119 , @xmath120 , @xmath121 , and @xmath122 , we give the renormalization conditions below .
we first discuss @xmath111 and @xmath112 . at the tree level
, the vevs @xmath73 and @xmath16 are determined together with the gauge coupling constants @xmath123 and @xmath124 for su(2)@xmath125 and u(1)@xmath126 by the four electroweak observables @xmath127 , @xmath12 , @xmath13 and @xmath128 as @xmath129 where @xmath128 is defined as the ratio of the coefficients of the vector part and the axial vector part in the @xmath130 vertex as in refs . @xcite with @xmath131 .
we note that in the htm , because the rho parameter deviates from unity at the tree level , the relation of @xmath132 does not hold .
thus , we have to introduce @xmath128 as the independent input parameter to describe the electroweak parameters .
consequently , the counter - terms @xmath111 and @xmath112 are determined as @xmath133 , \\ \frac{\delta v_\delta}{v_\delta } & = \frac{1}{2(2\hat{s}_w^2\hat{c}_w^2m_z^2g_f-\sqrt{2}\pi\alpha_{\text{em}})}\notag\\ & \hspace{-8mm}\times\bigg\{2\hat{s}_w^2\hat{c}_w^2m_z^2g_f\left [ -\left.\frac{\partial}{\partial p^2}\pi_t^{\gamma\gamma}(p^2)\right|_{p^2=0}-\frac{2\hat{s}_w}{\hat{c}_w}\frac{\pi_t^{\gamma z}(0)}{m_z^2 } + \frac{\hat{c}_w^2-\hat{s}_w^2}{\hat{c}_w^2}\left(\frac{\hat{c}_w}{\hat{s}_w}\frac{\pi_t^{\gamma z}(m_z^2)}{m_z^2}-\delta_{v}'\right ) + \frac{\pi_t^{zz}(m_z^2)}{m_z^2 } \right]\notag\\ & -\sqrt{2}\pi\alpha_{\text{em}}\left(\frac{\pi_t^{ww}(0)}{m_w^2 } + \delta_{vb}\right)\bigg\ } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath134 and @xmath135 are the vertex and box diagram corrections to the muon decay process and the vertex diagram corrections to the @xmath130 vertex , respectively , whose explicit formulae are given in refs .
@xcite , and @xmath136 , for ( @xmath137 , @xmath138 , @xmath139 , @xmath140 ) are the transverse component of the gauge boson two - point functions .
the counter - terms @xmath118 and @xmath119 are related to @xmath111 and @xmath112 as @xmath141 the tadpole counter - terms @xmath104 and @xmath105 are determined so as to eliminate the one - point function for @xmath8 ( @xmath142 ) and @xmath3 ( @xmath143 ) at the one - loop level : @xmath144 the counter - terms for doubly - charged higgs bosons ( @xmath145 and @xmath146 ) are determined by the on - shell conditions as @xmath147 where @xmath148 represents the two - point function for @xmath149 .
the four counter - terms relevant to the singly - charged scalar states ( @xmath150 , @xmath151 , @xmath116 and @xmath120 ) are determined by @xmath152 similarly , the four counter - terms relevant to the cp - odd scalar states ( @xmath153 , @xmath154 , @xmath115 and @xmath121 ) are determined by @xmath155 finally , the six counter - terms relevant to the cp - even scalar states ( @xmath156 , @xmath157 , @xmath117 , @xmath158 , @xmath159 and @xmath122 ) are determined by the following on - shell conditions @xmath160 therefore , all the 22 counter - terms are determined completely by the above conditions , and one - loop calculations for the other observables are now predictable .
we note that @xmath161 and @xmath162 are automatically satisfied as a consequence of the nambu - goldstone theorem , when we impose the renormalization conditions of @xmath163 and @xmath164 in eqs .
( [ mix1 ] ) and ( [ mix2 ] ) , respectively .
we also note that because of the ward - takahashi identities the conditions in eqs .
( [ mix1 ] ) and ( [ mix2 ] ) are respectively equivalent to the conditions on the mixings between @xmath165 and @xmath6 and between @xmath166 and @xmath4 : @xmath167 where @xmath168 and @xmath169 are defined from the @xmath170 and @xmath171 two - point functions as @xmath172
we here evaluate observables at the one - loop level by using the renormalization method defined in the previous section .
first , we calculate the deviation from the tree - level formula among the masses of the triplet - like higgs bosons in eq .
( [ r_def ] ) which holds approximately in the limit of @xmath173 .
then , we calculate the one - loop contribution of the triplet - like higgs bosons to the triple higgs boson coupling @xmath7 . at the tree level , @xmath174 can be expressed in terms of the quartic coupling constants as @xmath175 under the situation of @xmath173 , we have @xmath176 in the limit of @xmath177 , @xmath178 , so that the squared mass of @xmath4 is no more an independent parameter , which is determined by @xmath179 .
the one - loop corrected quantity of @xmath174 can be written as @xmath180 where @xmath30 is the one - loop correction to @xmath174 in the limit of @xmath181 , which is evaluated as @xmath182 the squared renormalized pole mass of @xmath4 , @xmath183 , is not the input parameter in this limit .
therefore , we can not adopt the on - shell renormalization condition for @xmath4 given in eq .
( [ delma ] ) in the present case .
instead , @xmath184 is predicted in this case by @xmath185\notag\\ & \simeq(m_a^2)_{\rm tree}- \pi_{aa}^{\rm 1pi}[(m_a^2)_{\rm tree } ] + 2\pi_{h^+h^-}^{\rm 1pi}[m_{h^+}^2 ] -\pi_{h^{++}h^{--}}^{\rm 1pi}[m_{h^{++}}^2 ] , \label{mapole } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath186 are the 1pi diagrams for the two - point functions of @xmath149 , and @xmath187 are the 1pi diagrams for the one - point functions of @xmath8 and @xmath3 .
consequently , we obtain @xmath188 - 2 \pi^{\rm 1pi}_{h^{+}h^{-}}[m_{h^{+}}^2 ] + \pi^{\rm 1pi}_{aa}[(m_a^2)_{\rm tree } ] } { m_{h^{++}}^2 -m_{h^{+}}^2 } .
\label{eq : delr}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we note that @xmath30 is a function of three input parameters , e.g. , @xmath25 , @xmath189 ( @xmath190 ) and @xmath107 , because this quantity is evaluated in the limit of @xmath191
. we here comment on the contribution of the term which is proportional to @xmath192 to @xmath174 .
as we mentioned before , the upper bound of @xmath16 is about 8 gev by the electroweak data , which means @xmath193 .
therefore , this contribution to @xmath174 can be neglected , and main contribution to @xmath174 should come from @xmath30 . in the following numerical analysis , we take @xmath194 gev and @xmath195 . as a function of the mass of the lightest triplet - like higgs boson for each fixed value of @xmath189 .
we take @xmath194 gev and @xmath195 , and we neglect the contributions from the terms proportional to @xmath192 . in the left ( right )
figure , we show the case with the negative ( positive ) values of @xmath189 . in the right figure , the horizontal axis @xmath28 is the pole mass of @xmath4 defined in eq .
( [ mapole ] ) .
, title="fig:",width=264 ] as a function of the mass of the lightest triplet - like higgs boson for each fixed value of @xmath189 .
we take @xmath194 gev and @xmath195 , and we neglect the contributions from the terms proportional to @xmath192 . in the left ( right )
figure , we show the case with the negative ( positive ) values of @xmath189 . in the right figure , the horizontal axis @xmath28 is the pole mass of @xmath4 defined in eq .
( [ mapole ] ) .
, title="fig:",width=264 ] in fig .
[ fig : deltar ] ( left ) , @xmath30 is shown as a function of @xmath25 for several values of @xmath189 ( @xmath196 ) . from the electroweak precision data ,
@xmath197 gev is favored for @xmath198 gev @xcite .
it is found that negative values of @xmath30 are predicted in the case with non - zero values of @xmath189 .
the magnitude of @xmath30 is 0.06 to 0.13 when we take @xmath199 gev@xmath200 gev and @xmath201 gev . in fig .
[ fig : deltar ] ( right ) , @xmath30 is shown as a function of the pole mass of @xmath4 for several values of @xmath189 ( @xmath202 ) although these cases are not necessarily favored by the electroweak precision data @xcite .
the mass of the sm - like higgs boson @xmath8 is again taken to be 125 gev
. positive values of @xmath30 are predicted .
the magnitude of @xmath30 is 0.11 to 0.17 for @xmath199 gev@xmath203 gev and @xmath204 gev .
we here give a comment regarding to the current experimental bound for the mass of the doubly - charged higgs boson at the lhc .
when @xmath205 gev and @xmath206 , the doubly - charged higgs boson can mainly decay into the same sign dilepton .
in such a case , the mass of the doubly - charged higgs boson is bounded from below about 300 gev and about 400 gev by the results from the atlas collaboration and the cms collaboration @xcite , respectively . although we perform the numerical analysis in the limit of @xmath191 , results are not so changed even if we take @xmath207 gev , because of the tiny contribution of @xmath208 . in the case of @xmath207 gev and @xmath209 , the main decay mode of @xmath5 can be the same sign diboson , so that the current bound for @xmath25 can not be applied .
next , we discuss the one - loop contributions of the triplet - like higgs bosons to the triple higgs boson coupling @xmath7 for the sm - like higgs boson @xmath8 .
we calculate the @xmath7 vertex function at the one - loop level both in the diagrammatic method in the on - shell scheme defined in the previous section and in the effective potential method .
the leading contribution to the deviation in the @xmath7 coupling constant @xmath210 from the sm prediction is obtained for @xmath211 as @xmath212 neglecting the terms proportional to @xmath192 , @xmath213 is determined by three input parameters : @xmath25 , @xmath189 and @xmath107 in the same way of the calculation of @xmath30 , and then eq . ( [ eq : hhh1 ] )
can be expressed as @xmath214 .
\label{eq : hhh2 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] we have confirmed the correctness of this result in both the methods of calculation ; i.e. , the diagrammatical method in the on - shell scheme and the effective potential method .
we note that the one - loop contribution of the triplet - like higgs bosons are quartic power - like in mass , so that it does not decouple in the large mass limit .
the deviation from the sm prediction can be very large when @xmath215 even under the constraint from perturbative unitarity @xcite , where @xmath216 represents the mass of the heaviest of all the triplet - like higgs bosons .
it is known that the similar effect can also appear in the calculation of the one - loop corrected @xmath7 coupling in the two higgs doublet model when the masses of the scalar bosons in the loop are given mainly by the vev @xcite . as a function of the mass of the lightest triplet - like higgs boson for each fixed value of @xmath189 .
we take @xmath194 gev and @xmath195 , and we neglect the contributions from the terms proportional to @xmath192 .
the solid ( dashed ) lines represent the result by using the diagrammatical method in the on - shell scheme ( the effective potential method ) . in the left ( right )
figure , we show the case where @xmath18 ( @xmath4 ) is the lightest of all the triplet - like higgs bosons . in the right figure , the horizontal axis @xmath28 is the pole mass of @xmath4 defined in eq .
( [ mapole ] ) .
, title="fig:",width=264 ] as a function of the mass of the lightest triplet - like higgs boson for each fixed value of @xmath189 .
we take @xmath194 gev and @xmath195 , and we neglect the contributions from the terms proportional to @xmath192 .
the solid ( dashed ) lines represent the result by using the diagrammatical method in the on - shell scheme ( the effective potential method ) . in the left ( right )
figure , we show the case where @xmath18 ( @xmath4 ) is the lightest of all the triplet - like higgs bosons . in the right figure , the horizontal axis @xmath28 is the pole mass of @xmath4 defined in eq .
( [ mapole ] ) .
, title="fig:",width=264 ] we here show the numerical results for @xmath217 for @xmath194 gev and @xmath195 . in fig .
[ hhh ] ( left ) , the deviation @xmath218 is shown as a function of @xmath25 for several values of @xmath189 ( @xmath196 ) , where @xmath18 is the lightest of all the triplet - like higgs bosons .
the solid lines represent the result by using the diagrammatical method in the on - shell scheme , while the dashed ones represent that by using the effective potential method .
it can be seen that the results by using the two ways are almost the same .
the small deviation comes from the effect from the wave function renormalization .
the deviation from the sm prediction can be significant for large @xmath25 and @xmath189 values due to the quartic power dependence of these parameters ( see eq .
( [ eq : hhh2 ] ) ) . in the case of @xmath219 , the magnitude of the deviation to be 50% for @xmath220 gev .
the larger deviation is obtained for the larger value of @xmath221 .
for example when we take @xmath222 gev ( @xmath223 gev ) and @xmath220 gev , it amounts to about 100@xmath224 ( 150% ) . in fig .
[ hhh ] ( right ) , the similar plots are shown as a function of @xmath28 but in the case with positive values of @xmath189 , where @xmath4 is the lightest , and here @xmath28 is the pole mass of @xmath4 defined in eq .
( [ mapole ] ) .
the deviation from the sm prediction can also be significant . when we take @xmath225 gev ( @xmath226 gev ) and @xmath227 gev , it amounts to about 100@xmath224 ( 180% ) .
we note that these large deviations satisfy the tree - level unitarity bounds .
for instance , the case with @xmath228 gev and @xmath204 gev implies @xmath229 gev and @xmath230 gev . we have confirmed that this parameter set satisfies the unitarity bounds @xcite .
finally , at the ilc , the triple higgs boson coupling would be expected to be measured with several times 10 % accuracy , so that the deviation in the @xmath7 coupling in the htm suggested by the electroweak precision data could be detectable .
we have investigated the one - loop renormalization for the higgs potential in the htm by using the on - shell scheme .
we have studied how the characteristic relation among the masses of the triplet - like higgs bosons ( @xmath231 ) is changed at the one - loop level .
we have found that @xmath174 can be modified by the radiative corrections around @xmath31 for @xmath173 .
we have also calculated the renormalized triple higgs boson coupling in the htm and its deviation from the sm prediction .
it has been found that for the parameter sets suggested by the electroweak precision data the magnitude of the deviation can be as large as @xmath232 due to the quartic power - like dependence of the masses of the triplet - like higgs bosons .
therefore , by measuring the mass spectrum of the triplet - like higgs bosons and also the triple higgs boson coupling accurately , the htm can be tested at future collider experiments .
detailed analysis is shown elsewhere @xcite .
+ + @xmath233 the work of m.a . was supported in part by grant - in - aid for scientific research for young scientists ( b ) , no .
22740137 . the work of s.k .
was supported in part by grant - in - aid for scientific research , nos .
22244031 and 23104006 .
k.y . was supported by japan society for the promotion of science .
s. kortner , _ talk given at rencontres de moriond _ ( 2012 ) .
m. pieri , _ talk given at rencontres de moriond _ ( 2012 ) .
r. barate _
[ lep working group for higgs boson searches , aleph collab .
, delphi collab . ,
l3 collab .
, opal collab . ] , phys .
b * 565 * , 61 ( 2003 ) .
t. schwetz , m. a. tortola , j. w. f. valle , new j. phys .
* 10 * , 113011 ( 2008 ) .
e. komatsu _ et al .
_ [ wmap collaboration ] , astrophys . j. suppl . * 192 * , 18 ( 2011 ) . a. d. sakharov , pisma zh .
fiz . * 5 * , 32 - 35 ( 1967 ) .
t. p. cheng and l. f. li , phys .
d * 22 * , 2860 ( 1980 ) ; j. schechter and j. w. f. valle , phys . rev .
d * 22 * , 2227 ( 1980 ) ; g. lazarides , q. shafi and c. wetterich , nucl .
b * 181 * , 287 ( 1981 ) ; r. n. mohapatra and g. senjanovic , phys .
d * 23 * , 165 ( 1981 ) ; m. magg and c. wetterich , phys .
b * 94 * , 61 ( 1980 ) .
a. zee , phys .
b * 93 * ( 1980 ) 389 [ erratum - ibid .
b * 95 * ( 1980 ) 461 ] ; a. zee , phys .
b * 161 * ( 1985 ) 141 .
a. zee , nucl .
b * 264 * ( 1986 ) 99 ; k. s. babu , phys .
b * 203 * ( 1988 ) 132 ; d. aristizabal sierra and m. hirsch , jhep * 0612 * , 052 ( 2006 ) . l. m. krauss , s. nasri and m. trodden , phys .
d * 67 * ( 2003 ) 085002 ; k. cheung and o. seto , phys . rev .
d * 69 * , 113009 ( 2004 ) .
m. aoki , s. kanemura and o. seto , phys .
lett . * 102 * , 051805 ( 2009 ) ; m. aoki , s. kanemura and o. seto , phys .
d * 80 * , 033007 ( 2009 ) ; m. aoki , s. kanemura and k. yagyu , phys .
d * 83 * , 075016 ( 2011 ) .
a. i. bochkarev , s. v. kuzmin and m. e. shaposhnikov , phys .
b * 244 * ( 1990 ) 275 ; a. e. nelson , d. b. kaplan and a. g. cohen , nucl . phys .
b * 373 * , 453 ( 1992 ) ; n. turok and j. zadrozny , nucl .
b * 369 * , 729 ( 1992 ) ; k. funakubo , a. kakuto and k. takenaga , prog .
phys . * 91 * , 341 ( 1994 ) ; a. t. davies , c. d. froggatt , g. jenkins and r. g. moorhouse , phys .
b * 336 * , 464 ( 1994 ) ; j. m. cline , k. kainulainen and a. p. vischer , phys .
d * 54 * , 2451 ( 1996 ) ; l. fromme , s. j. huber and m. seniuch , jhep
* 0611 * , 038 ( 2006 ) . m. czakon , j. gluza , f. jegerlehner and m. zralek , eur .
j. c * 13 * , 275 ( 2000 ) ; j. r. forshaw , d. a. ross and b. e. white , jhep * 0110 * , 007 ( 2001 ) ; j. r. forshaw , a. sabio vera and b. e. white , jhep * 0306 * , 059 ( 2003 ) ; m. c. chen and s. dawson , phys . rev .
d * 70 * , 015003 ( 2004 ) ; m. c. chen , s. dawson and t. krupovnickas , phys .
d * 74 * , 035001 ( 2006 ) ; m. c. chen , s. dawson and t. krupovnickas , int .
j. mod .
. a * 21 * , 4045 ( 2006 ) ; p. h. chankowski , s. pokorski and j. wagner , eur .
j. c * 50 * , 919 ( 2007 ) ; m. c. chen , s. dawson and c. b. jackson , phys .
d * 78 * , 093001 ( 2008 ) ; p. h. chankowski and j. wagner , phys .
d * 77 * , 025033 ( 2008 ) ; r. s. chivukula , n. d. christensen and e. h. simmons , phys .
d * 77 * , 035001 ( 2008 ) .
j. f. gunion , c. loomis and k. t. pitts , _ in the proceedings of 1996 dpf / dpb summer study on new directions for high - energy physics ( snowmass 96 ) , snowmass , colorado , 25 jun - 12 jul 1996 , pp lth096 _ [ arxiv : hep - ph/9610237 ] .
m. muhlleitner and m. spira , phys .
d * 68 * , 117701 ( 2003 ) ; m. kakizaki , y. ogura and f. shima , phys .
b * 566 * ( 2003 ) 210 ; t. han , b. mukhopadhyaya , z. si and k. wang , phys .
d * 76 * , 075013 ( 2007 ) ; m. kadastik , m. raidal and l. rebane , phys .
d * 77 * , 115023 ( 2008 ) ; j. garayoa and t. schwetz , jhep * 0803 * , 009 ( 2008 ) ; a. g. akeroyd , m. aoki and h. sugiyama , phys .
d * 77 * , 075010 ( 2008 ) ; a. g. akeroyd and c. w. chiang , phys .
d * 80 * , 113010 ( 2009 ) ; f. del aguila and j. a.
aguilar saavedra , nucl .
b * 813 * , 22 ( 2009 ) ; a. g. akeroyd , c. w. chiang and n. gaur , jhep * 1011 * , 005 ( 2010 ) ; a. g. akeroyd and c. -w .
chiang , phys .
d * 81 * , 115007 ( 2010 ) ; c. -w .
chiang , t. nomura and k. tsumura , phys .
d * 85 * , 095023 ( 2012 ) .
e. j. chun , k. y. lee and s. c. park , phys .
b * 566 * , 142 ( 2003 ) ; a. g. akeroyd and m. aoki , phys .
d * 72 * , 035011 ( 2005 ) ; p.
fileviez perez , t. han , g. -y .
huang , t. li , k. wang , phys .
rev . * d78 * , 015018 ( 2008 ) .
s. chakrabarti , d. choudhury , r. m. godbole and b. mukhopadhyaya , phys .
b * 434 * , 347 ( 1998 ) ; a. g. akeroyd , h. sugiyama , phys .
rev . * d84 * , 035010 ( 2011 ) ; a. melfo , m. nemevsek , f. nesti , g. senjanovic and y. zhang , arxiv:1108.4416 [ hep - ph ] .
s. kanemura , t. kubota and e. takasugi , phys .
b * 313 * , 155 ( 1993 ) ; h. huffel and g. pocsik , z. phys .
c * 8 * , 13 ( 1981 ) ; j. maalampi , j. sirkka and i. vilja , phys .
b * 265 * , 371 ( 1991 ) ; a. g. akeroyd , a. arhrib and e. m. naimi , phys .
b * 490 * , 119 ( 2000 ) ; i. f. ginzburg and i. p. ivanov , phys .
d * 72 * , 115010 ( 2005 ) . | we study radiative corrections to the mass spectrum and the triple higgs boson coupling in the model with an additional @xmath0 triplet field . in this model ,
the vacuum expectation value for the triplet field is strongly constrained from the electroweak precision data , under which characteristic mass spectrum appear at the tree level ; i.e. , @xmath1 and @xmath2 , where the cp - even ( @xmath3 ) , the cp - odd ( @xmath4 ) and the doubly - charged ( @xmath5 ) as well as the singly - charged ( @xmath6 ) higgs bosons are the triplet - like . we evaluate how the tree - level formulae are modified at the one - loop level .
the @xmath7 coupling for the standard model - like higgs boson ( @xmath8 ) is also calculated at the one - loop level .
one - loop corrections to these quantities can be large enough for identification of the model by future precision data at the lhc or the international linear collider . |
the perovskite oxide la@xmath9a@xmath10mno@xmath2 ( a = ca , ba , sr ) has initiated a substantial body of research due to its colossal magnetoresistance @xcite .
extensive theoretical studies and experimental investigations utilizing la@xmath9a@xmath10mno@xmath2 perovskites in bulk form revealed a strong coupling between lattice distortions and magnetism , which substantially modify magnetic properties such as magnetoresistance and curie temperature @xcite .
la@xmath0sr@xmath1mno@xmath2 ( lsmo ) has the highest curie temperature ( 370k ) and a 100% spin polarization @xcite .
lsmo can be coherently grown on a range of commercially available perovskite substrates , such as e.g. ndgao@xmath2 ( ngo ) and srtio@xmath2 ( sto ) .
the epitaxy stabilizes a different crystal structure which modifies the magnetic properties .
especially magnetic anisotropy is shown to be very sensitive to the lsmo crystal structure @xcite . when anisotropic strain is applied to the lsmo
the magnetocrystalline anisotropy becomes strongly uniaxial @xcite , which is a useful tool to tailor the magnetic properties for device applications . in the case of isotropic tensile strain ,
e.g. tetragonal lsmo thin films on cubic sto ( 001)@xmath11 substrates , the magnetocrystalline anisotropy is biaxial with easy axes aligned with the @xmath12110@xmath13@xmath14 lattice directions @xcite .
( we use subscript c , pc , o and t for cubic , pseudocubic , orthorhombic and tetragonal crystal structures , respectively . )
next to the magnetocrystalline anisotropy a uniaxial anisotropy is present as well , which is stepedge induced @xcite . here
we investigate the case of isotropic compressive strain , which can be realized with lsmo thin films on the cubic ( laalo@xmath2)@xmath5-(sr@xmath6altao@xmath7)@xmath8 ( lsat ) ( 001)@xmath11 substrate .
lsmo thin films under compressive strain adopt an orthorhombic crystal structure @xcite , which is characterized by the presence of oxygen octahedra rotations around all three pseudocubic crystal axes . as the magnetic coupling depends on the mn - o - mn bond angle @xcite
, it is an interesting question whether the magnetic properties are anisotropic in the different orthorhombic directions .
note that for another case , orthorhombic lsmo grown on ngo ( 110)@xmath4 the difference in lattice mismatch between the two in - plane directions determines the anisotropy @xcite , so this system is not suitable to study the effect of the orthorhombicity on the magnetic properties . for lsmo films grown on ngo ( 110)@xmath4 the [ 1@xmath30]@xmath4 lattice direction is subjected to less compressive strain than the [ 001]@xmath4 lattice direction and is therefore the easy axis due to the strain anisotropy . for lsmo films grown on lsat
the lattice mismatch is equal and the anisotropy is due to the intrinsic anisotropy of the orthorhombic crystal structure between the [ 1@xmath30]@xmath4 and [ 001]@xmath4 lattice directions . here
, we show that lsmo thin films can be grown coherently and untwinned on lsat substrates and that the orthorhombicity induces anisotropic magnetic properties .
next to a biaxial component of the magnetic anisotropy , we observed a uniaxial component to the anisotropy which is aligned with the principal crystal directions and became more pronounced for increasing film thickness .
we found no correlation between the uniaxial anisotropy and the stepedge direction .
we obtained twinned samples , by growth on surfaces with reduced crystalline quality , for which the uniaxial anisotropy was reduced .
therefore we conclude that the uniaxial anisotropy is caused by the orthorhombic crystal structure .
c for 12 hours .
b ) after annealing at 950@xmath15c for 1 hour , the images are 5 by 5 @xmath16 m and the color scale is 2 nm . the insets show a close - up of the roughness of the terraces.,width=302 ] the as - received lsat substrates were cleaned with acetone and ethanol before they were subjected to an anneal treatment .
two anneal treatments were used to obtain respectively surfaces with smooth terraces and surfaces with sub unit cell roughness on the terraces .
the first treatment consisted of an annealing step at 1050@xmath15c for 12 hour in 1 bar of o@xmath6 gas pressure .
for the second treatment both the anneal time and temperature were decreased to 1 hours and 950@xmath15c respectively .
the surfaces were characterized with atomic force microscopy ( afm ) .
typical results are shown in figure [ substrates ] .
for the substrates subjected to the first anneal treatment a step and terrace structure with 4 ( a single unit cell ) step height was observed .
the stepedges were not straight but meandering and 4 deep holes are observed near the stepedges .
note that the miscut of these substrates is very small , approximately 0.02@xmath15 , giving a terrace width of more than 1 @xmath16 m . between the stepedges areas with atomically smooth morphology were observed .
the substrates subjected to the second treatment show terraces with reduced crystalline quality , but still single unit cell step heights .
lsmo thin films were grown on the lsat ( 001 ) substrates by pulsed laser deposition ( pld ) from a stoichiometric target in an oxygen background pressure of 0.35 mbar with a laser fluence of 3 j/@xmath17 and at a substrate temperature of 750@xmath15c .
after lsmo deposition , the films were cooled to room temperature at a rate of 10@xmath15c / min in a 1 bar pure oxygen atmosphere .
the growth settings were previously optimized and were identical to the ones used for lsmo films on other substrates @xcite . in this paper
four samples are described , see table [ table ] .
sample u12 and u40 were grown on substrates with a smooth surface and have a thickness of 12 and 40 nm respectively . samples t29 and t50 were grown on substrates with terraces with reduced crystalline quality and are respectively 29 and 50 nm thick .
( the sample labels consist of either the letter t or u for twinned / untwinned and a number which indicates the sample thickness . )
the sample thicknesses were measured with x - ray reflectivity measurements .
afm measurements ( not shown ) revealed surfaces of the thin film where the morphology of the substrate was still visible .
the curie temperature of the films was larger than 350 k ( 350 k was the measurement limit of the vibrating sample magnetometer ) and did not depend on film thickness and the twinning , as discussed in the next section , of the films . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ]
the top panel of figure [ xrd ] shows reciprocal space maps of lsmo and lsat around the ( 204)@xmath11 , ( 024)@xmath11 , ( @xmath1804)@xmath11 and ( 0@xmath184)@xmath11 lsat reflections .
these results were obtained from sample u40 .
the lsmo has a slightly distorted orthorhombic ( monoclinic ) unit cell with ( 110)@xmath4 out - of - plane orientation and ( 1@xmath30)@xmath4 and ( 001)@xmath4 in - plane orientations .
the orthorhombicity can be deduced from figures [ xrd]a and [ xrd]c which show a difference in lattice spacing for the ( 260)@xmath4 and ( 620)@xmath4 lsmo reflections , which represent a dissimilarity between the lsmo a and b lattice parameters .
the lattice parameters are as follows : [email protected] , [email protected] , [email protected] , @[email protected]@xmath15 , @[email protected]@xmath15 and @[email protected]@xmath15 .
next to the lsmo ( 444)@xmath4 and ( 44@xmath23)@xmath4 reflections satellites are observed . in a previous paper @xcite
we have discussed the orthorhombic crystal structure and the presence of satellite peaks in the [ 001]@xmath4 direction for lsmo grown on ngo ( 110)@xmath4 substrates .
the satellites result from periodic lattice modulations which partially relieve the applied strain @xcite . as the lsmo crystal structure can easily relieve strain in the [ 1@xmath30]@xmath4 lattice direction with a change in the @xmath22 angle , the lattice modulations are only present in the [ 001]@xmath4 direction .
we conclude that lsmo films on lsat behave similarly as lsmo on ngo .
the panels e - h ) of figure [ xrd ] show the same reciprocal space maps , but obtained for sample t50 .
dissimilar lattice spacings are observed in both in - plane directions and the satellite peaks are visible in all reciprocal space maps .
zhou et al . observed similar satellite peaks around reflections of lsmo on lsat and attributed the satellites to an in - plane superlattice with alternating [ 1@xmath30]@xmath4 and [ @xmath240]@xmath4 orientations @xcite .
this can not be the case for our samples as the [ @xmath240]@xmath4 in - plane orientation would result in reciprocal space maps with both the ( 620)@xmath4 and the ( 260)@xmath4 peak visible in the same plot . in e.g. figure
[ xrd]f this is clearly not the case .
together with the presence of the satellites in figure [ xrd]b and [ xrd]d only in the [ 001]@xmath4 direction , we conclude that sample d is twinned in domains with different [ 1@xmath30]@xmath4 and [ 001]@xmath4 orientations .
for the two thinner samples we observed the same behavior as the thicker samples with equal substrate treatment ( not shown ) .
sample u12 was untwinned as concluded from the positions of the bragg reflections , but here no satellites could be observed .
sample t29 was twinned with satellites in both directions in reciprocal space . to explain the absence of twinning in the samples with smooth surfaces we compare our results to the more widely studied srruo@xmath2 ( sro ) thin films on sto substrates .
sro is orthorhombic and single domain films can be realized by growth on smooth vicinal substrates with stepedges approximately aligned with the main crystal axis . in that case
the [ 001]@xmath4 lattice directions aligns with the stepedge direction @xcite .
this has been explained in three different ways .
gan et al . suggested that single domain growth is related to the observed stepflow growth mode @xcite .
maria et al . suggested that stepedge strain is the dominant mechanism as the films are not orthorhombic at deposition temperature @xcite .
finally vailionis et al . suggested that the films are tetragonal at deposition temperature and that the [ 001]@xmath25 lattice direction aligns preferentially with the stepedges @xcite .
in contrast to sro the lsmo films have a preferred orientation with the [ 001]@xmath4 lattice direction aligned perpendicular to the stepedges and does not grow in stepflow mode
. therefore the explanation by maria et al .
is the most likely candidate to explain the single domain growth . during cooldown
orthorhombic domains nucleate at the stepedges and the stepedge strain favors octahedra buckling in one direction and the domains continue to grow across the terraces resulting in a single domain film . for the samples with a rough surface the orthorhombic domains can nucleate at defects at the substrate surface and no preferential orientation exists , resulting in twinned films . in summary , growth on a relatively smooth surface results in untwinned lsmo films , while growth on terraces with reduced crystalline quality results in twinned lsmo films .
we used the difference in magnetic properties between twinned and untwinned films to identify the contribution from the orthorhombicity as it should be reduced for the twinned samples .
top panel : reciprocal space maps around the a ) ( 204)@xmath11 , b ) ( 024)@xmath11 , c ) ( @xmath1804)@xmath11 and d ) ( 0@xmath184)@xmath11 lsat reflections of the 40 nm thick sample grown on a smooth substrate ( sample u40 ) . in a ) and c ) the dissimilar spacing of the ( 260)@xmath4 and ( 620)@xmath4 lsmo reflections is clearly observed while in b ) and d ) satellites are present next to the ( 444)@xmath4 and ( 44@xmath23)@xmath4 lsmo reflections .
middle panel : reciprocal space maps around the e ) ( 204)@xmath11 , f ) ( 024)@xmath11 , g ) ( @xmath1804)@xmath11 and h ) ( 0@xmath184)@xmath11 lsat reflections of the 50 nm thick sample grown on a rough substrate ( sample t50 ) .
the satellites are present in all maps and both e ) and h ) show intensity at the position for the ( 260)@xmath4 lsmo reflection . therefore this sample is twinned .
bottom panel : schematic of the real space crystal structure of an untwinned sample viewed along i ) [ 001]@xmath4 and j ) [ 1@xmath30]@xmath4.,width=302 ]
the samples were characterized with vibrating sample magnetometer ( vsm , model 10 vsm by microsense ) measurements at room temperature .
the in - plane angle of the applied field was varied to determine the magnetic anisotropy .
for all field angles a full magnetization loop was measured and the remanent magnetization was obtained from the loop .
figure [ lsat13hb86mag]a shows the magnetization loops of sample u12 with the field aligned with three high symmetry directions . in figure
[ lsat13hb86mag]b we plotted the dependence of the remanent magnetization on the in - plane field angle .
the largest remanence was found for an applied field at approximately 40 degrees with respect to the [ 001]@xmath4 in - plane lattice direction .
a predominant biaxial behavior is observed with easy axes aligned with the [ 110]@xmath14 and symmetry related crystal directions .
next to this biaxial anisotropy a small uniaxial anisotropy is present as well which can be seen in the difference in remanent magnetization at 0 and 90 degrees and the shift of the easy axes to @xmath1940@xmath15 .
this uniaxial contribution becomes more pronounced in the thicker film ( sample u40 ) shown in figure [ lsat13hb86mag]c and [ lsat13hb86mag]d .
the remanent magnetization of sample b at 0 degrees approaches the easy axes value and the remanent magnetization at 90 degrees is much smaller , only 20 percent of the easy axes value . due to the combination of uniaxial and biaxial anisotropy the easy axes
are shifted to @xmath1915@xmath15 .
the hard axis magnetization loop does not show a switch of the magnetization , but an almost linear dependence of the magnetization on the applied field which is characteristic for a hard axis loop in a sample with a uniaxial anisotropy .
a similar thickness dependence of the anisotropy was also found for the samples t29 and t50 , which are twinned .
the results are plotted in figure [ lsat13hb86mag]e-[lsat13hb86mag]h .
a biaxial and a uniaxial contribution are present and the uniaxial contribution is more pronounced in the thicker film .
sample t50 shows easy axes which are shifted to @xmath1930@xmath15 and the hard axis remanence is 50 percent of the easy axis value .
comparing samples u12 and u40 with samples t29 and
t50 we find that the uniaxial contribution is more pronounced in the samples u12 and u40 .
a ) magnetization loops with the field aligned with 3 high symmetry directions and b ) remanence versus field angle dependence obtained from sample u12 .
the latter graph shows the data from the measurements ( black dots ) and the result from the fit procedure described in the text ( blue line ) .
c ) and d ) the corresponding graphs for sample u40 .
e ) and f ) sample t29 .
g ) and h ) sample t50 .
the field angle is defined with respect to the crystal structure , 0@xmath15 ( 90@xmath15 ) corresponds to the [ 001]@xmath4 ( [ 1@xmath30]@xmath4 ) lattice direction.,width=340 ]
in order to quantify the biaxial and uniaxial contribution to the anisotropy we start with a general anisotropy energy equation which contains both a biaxial and a uniaxial contribution @xcite .
@xmath26 in which @xmath27 is the anisotropy energy , @xmath28 the volume of the sample , @xmath29 ( @xmath30 ) the uniaxial ( biaxial ) anisotropy constant , @xmath31 the angle of the magnetization , @xmath32=0@xmath15 ( @xmath33=45@xmath15 ) the angle of the easy axis of the uniaxial ( biaxial ) anisotropy .
the easy axes are found by minimizing the energy with respect to @xmath31 .
this results in : @xmath34 from which the easy axes , @xmath35 , can be obtained .
the measured remanence versus field angle dependencies are the projections of the magnetization , which at remanence is aligned with the easy axis , onto the measurement direction : @xmath36 where @xmath37 is the remanent magnetization , @xmath38 is the field angle , @xmath39 is the remanence in the easy direction and @xmath35 is the closest easy axis .
equation [ rem ] has been used to obtain the fits in figure [ lsat13hb86mag ] . the measured data , and therefore the anisotropy , is well described by equation [ energy]-[rem ] .
this allows us to extract the ratio between the uniaxial and biaxial anisotropy energies @xmath40 .
the results are presented in table [ table ] .
for all samples the uniaxial anisotropy energy is found to be smaller than the biaxial anisotropy energy . between the different samples
the ratio @xmath40 changes by a factor of 10 . the anisotropy field @xmath41 can be obtained from the slope d@xmath42/d@xmath43 at @xmath43=0 in the hard axis magnetization loop of a material with uniaxial anisotropy by the relation @xmath44 here , @xmath45 is the saturation magnetization , @xmath42 is the magnetization and @xmath43 is the applied field .
the anisotropy energy is given by @xmath46 in which @xmath47 is the permeability of free space .
we obtained a value for @xmath29 of 540@xmath195 j / m@xmath48 for the almost uniaxial sample u40 .
this would imply a biaxial anisotropy constant of 600@xmath1910 j / m@xmath48 which corresponds well with earlier obtained results @xcite .
therefore one can assume that the @xmath30 value is the same for all films and independent of thickness .
the uniaxial anisotropy constants are calculated from the @xmath40 ratios and presented in table [ table ] as well .
the uniaxial anisotropy is very weak for these samples , only in the range 50 - 600 j / m@xmath48 .
next we turn to the origin of both contributions to the anisotropy .
the biaxial contribution with easy axes aligned with the @xmath12110@xmath13@xmath14 lattice directions corresponds well with earlier results of magnetic anisotropy of lsmo on sto ( 001)@xmath11 substrates @xcite .
this represents the intrinsic magnetocrystalline anisotropy of lsmo strained to in - plane cubic symmetry . for the uniaxial contribution
different explanations exist .
it is well known that a weak uniaxial anisotropy in lsmo can be the result of stepedge induced anisotropy @xcite . however , the thickness dependence of the uniaxial anisotropy is at odds with an interpretation in terms of stepedge induced anisotropy .
the stepedge induced anisotropy compared to the biaxial anisotropy should scale with the ratio of the volume of the surface layers containing the stepedges ( in practice the monolayers at the interfaces ) to the volume of the film .
therefore the stepedge induced anisotropy should be most pronounced for the thinnest films as the miscut of the samples was comparable . here the opposite is observed .
also the uniaxial easy axis was not aligned with the stepedge directions in most of the samples , sometimes even 90 degrees perpendicular to the stepedges .
this rules out the contribution of stepedge induced anisotropy .
the uniaxial easy axis is aligned with the [ 001]@xmath4 lattice direction while the hard axis is aligned with the [ 1@xmath30]@xmath4 lattice direction .
this , together with the reduced uniaxial anisotropy for the twinned samples , relates the observed anisotropy to the orthorhombicity of the lsmo films .
it is unclear what the origin of the magnetic anisotropy in the orthorhombic crystal structure is . in general magnetic anisotropy in manganites
is explained by a global strain field which relates the easy axis to the maximum strain direction @xcite .
this can not be applied for these samples , as the lsmo has equal strain in the [ 001]@xmath4 and the [ 1@xmath30]@xmath4 lattice directions due to the cubic symmetry of the substrate .
note that for the case of orthorhombic lsmo on ngo ( 110)@xmath4 the uniaxial easy axis is aligned with the [ 1@xmath30]@xmath4 lattice direction and is due to strain anisotropy @xcite , in contrast to the observed anisotropy of lsmo on lsat .
the difference between the two lattice directions in the orthorhombic symmetry is due to the different oxygen octahedra rotations .
we therefore suspect that the microscopic origin of the magnetocrystalline anisotropy in lsmo is effected by the oxygen octahedra rotations . a plausible scenario would be that the difference in octahedra rotations along the [ 1@xmath30]@xmath4 and [ 001]@xmath4 directions results in a different mn - o - mn bond angle ( @xmath49)in these two directions . for manganites
it is well known that the bandwidth , due to the double exchange mechanism , depends on the mn - o - mn bond angle according to @xcite @xmath50 in which @xmath51 is the bandwidth , @xmath52 is proportional to the amount of octahedra rotation and @xmath53 is the mn - o distance .
this suggests that for lsmo on lsat the mn - o - mn bond angle is larger in the [ 001]@xmath4 direction than in the [ 1@xmath30]@xmath4 direction , resulting in an increase in the bandwidth and therefore the easy axis is aligned with this direction .
this explanation is also consistent with the increase of @xmath40 with film thickness . due to structural reconstructions at the interface and the surface @xcite
, the oxygen octahedra rotations in the surface and interfacial regions deviate from those of the bulk of the film .
the biaxial anisotropy is intrinsic to mno@xmath7 octahedra and not sensitive to the structural reconstructions . in a follow up
work we will investigate the crystal structure , and especially the octahedra rotations , in more detail , in order to resolve the microscopic origin of the magnetocrystalline anisotropy in lsmo .
an alternative interpretation of the magnetic data is that the anisotropy is somehow related to the lattice modulations observed with the satellites in the xrd measurements .
as the lattice modulations only occur in the orthorhombic [ 001]@xmath4 direction , it is not possible to discriminate between anisotropy induced by the orthorhombic crystal structure and anisotropy induced by the lattice modulations in our experiment .
nevertheless , we expect that the lattice modulations result in microtwins which have reduced magnetic coupling at the microtwin boundaries .
the shape anisotropy of each microtwin would then be aligned with the [ 1@xmath30]@xmath4 direction , contrary to the observation of a magnetic [ 001]@xmath4 easy axis .
although one would suspect that the uniaxial anisotropy would disappear for the twinned samples , this is not the case .
we assume that this is due to the dominant presence of grains with one orientation .
lsmo films with an orthorhombic crystal structure can be grown coherently and untwinned on cubic lsat substrates .
the magnetic anisotropy of the films is described by a combination of biaxial anisotropy with easy axes along the @xmath12110@xmath13@xmath14 directions and a uniaxial anisotropy with easy axis along the [ 001]@xmath4 direction . for thicker films
the uniaxial anisotropy becomes more pronounced .
the uniaxial part of the anisotropy is induced by the orthorhombic symmetry of the lsmo .
we expect these findings to lead to a better understanding of the microscopic origin of the magnetocrystalline anisotropy in lsmo .
this research was financially supported by the dutch science foundation , by nanoned , a nanotechnology program of the dutch ministry of economic affairs and by the nanoxide program of the european science foundation . | la@xmath0sr@xmath1mno@xmath2 ( lsmo ) thin films under compressive strain have an orthorhombic symmetry with ( 1@xmath30)@xmath4 and ( 001)@xmath4 in - plane orientations .
( the subscript o denotes the orthorhombic symmetry . ) here , we grew lsmo on cubic ( laalo@xmath2)@xmath5-(sr@xmath6altao@xmath7)@xmath8 ( lsat ) substrates and observed a uniaxial contribution to the magnetic anisotropy which is related to the orthorhombic crystal structure .
since the lattice mismatch is equal in the two directions , the general understanding of anisotropy in lsmo , which relates the uniaxial anisotropy to differences in strain , can not explain the results .
these findings suggest that the oxygen octahedra rotations associated with the orthorhombic structure , possibly resulting in different mn - o - mn bond angles and therefore a change in magnetic coupling between the [ 1@xmath30]@xmath4 and [ 001]@xmath4 directions , determine the anisotropy .
we expect these findings to lead to a better understanding of the microscopic origin of the magnetocrystalline anisotropy in lsmo . |
surveys with bolometer arrays at millimetre ( mm ) and submillimetre ( submm ) wavelengths are potentially sensitive to dusty objects at extreme redshifts , galaxies that drop out of surveys at shorter and longer wavelengths due to obscuration and unfavourable @xmath11 corrections .
the first cosmological surveys using scuba ( holland et al .
1999 ) and mambo ( kreysa et al . 1998 ) quickly and radically changed the accepted picture of galaxy formation and evolution , moving away from the optocentric view of the last century .
the discovery of so - called ` scuba galaxies ' ( smail , ivison & blain 1997 ) was greeted with surprise due to the remarkable evolution in the dusty , starburst galaxy population implied by such a large source density at the flux levels accessible to the first generation of bolometer arrays ( blain et al .
excitement was replaced by pessimism with the first efforts to study smgs at optical and infrared ( ir ) wavelengths : early reports , backed up with a study in the hubble deep field north by hughes et al .
( 1998 ) , suggested that the majority of the submm population had no plausible optical counterparts .
attention was diverted to various redshift engines and broadband photometric techniques ( e.g.townsend et al .
2001 ; aretxaga et al . 2003 ; wiklind 2003 ) . as a result , only a handful of detailed studies were attempted , often for extreme and possibly unrepresentative galaxies ( e.g. knudsen et al .
2004 ) .
recent progress has largely been the result of radio imaging of submm survey fields .
early radio follow - up detected roughly half of the submm sources observed ( smail et al .
2000 ; ivison et al . 2002
hereafter i02 ) , with an astrometric precision of @xmath30.3@xmath12 and , combined with the submm flux density , provide a rough estimate of redshift ( carilli & yun 1999 ) .
radio data also enabled some refinement of submm samples ( i02 ) , increasing the detection fraction to two thirds of smgs at 0.85-mm flux density levels in excess of @xmath35mjy . with positions in hand ,
these bright smgs were found to be a diverse population some quasar - like , with broad lines and x - ray detections ( e.g. ivison et al .
1998 ) , some morphologically complex ( e.g. ivison et al . 2000
downes & solomon 2003 ; smail , smith & ivison 2005 ) , some extremely red ( e.g. smail et al.1999 ; gear et al .
2000 ; i02 ; webb et al . 2003b
; dunlop et al.2004 ) , some with the unmistakable signatures of obscured active nuclei and/or superwinds ( e.g. smail et al .
2003 ) .
spectroscopic redshifts have been difficult to determine . the first survey based on a submm / radio sample
was undertaken by chapman et al.(2003 , 2005 hereafter c03 , c05 ) : the median redshift was found to be @xmath32.2 for @xmath13-mjy galaxies selected using scuba and pinpointed at 1.4ghz .
the accurate redshifts reported by c03 and c05 facilitated the first systematic measurements of molecular gas mass for smgs ( @xmath310@xmath14m@xmath15 ) via observations of co ( neri et al .
2003 ; greve et al .
2005 ) , as well as constraints on gas reservoir size and dynamical mass ( tacconi et al.2005 ) .
the data suggest smgs are massive systems and provide some of the strongest tests of galaxy - formation models to date ( greve et al.2005 ) . in spite of this progress ,
a detailed understanding of smgs remains a distant goal .
confusion currently limits our investigations to the brightest smgs ( although surveys through lensing clusters have provided a handful of sources more typical of the faint population that dominates the cosmic background smail et al .
2002 ; kneib et al .
2004 ; borys et al .
we must also recall that selection biases have potentially skewed our understanding : around half of all known smgs remain undetected in the radio ( due simply to the lack of sufficiently deep radio data , which do not benefit from the same @xmath11 correction as submm data ) and the radio - undetected fraction remains largely untargeted by existing spectroscopic campaigns .
these is also only limited coverage of red and ir wavelengths in spectroscopic surveys . here , we present a robust sample of bright smgs selected using scuba and mambo in one of the ` 8-mjy survey ' regions : the lockman hole ( see scott et al .
2002 ; fox et al .
2002 ; i02 ; greve et al . 2004 ; mortier et al .
our goal is to provide a bright sample which we would expect to detect in well - matched radio imaging ( @xmath16 ) whilst minimising , so far as is practicable , the possibility that sources are spurious or anamalously bright .
we may thus determine the true fraction of radio drop - outs amongst smgs ( potentially lying at very high redshift , @xmath7 ) , as well as practical information such as the intrinsic positional uncertainty for smgs in the absence of radio / ir counterparts .
throughout we adopt a cosmology , with @xmath17 , @xmath18 and @xmath19km@xmath20mpc@xmath5 .
existing surveys have typically employed a snr threshold of 3.03.5 . at these
snrs , false detections are dominated by ` flux boosting ' ( 2.2 ) , possibly at the 1040 per cent level ( scott et al . 2002
; laurent et al . 2005 ) .
our goal is to provide a highly reliable submm source catalogue , free from concerns about contamination by spurious or artificially bright sources .
this issue has limited our ability to address the true recovery fraction in the radio , and hence the corrections that must be made to the redshift distributions that are used to determine star - formation histories and galaxy - formation models . to achieve this
we have combined independent submm and mm maps of the lockman hole , constructing a single , reliable catalogue that is several times larger than would have been realised by simply adopting a high snr threshold in the individual submm and mm maps .
greve et al .
( 2004 ) argued that several maps with low signal - to - noise ratio ( snr ) of the same region , with only marginal differences in frequency , produce several visualisations of essentially the same sky , tracing the same population of luminous , dust - enshrouded galaxies and we have adopted the same philosophy in the present work .
our maps came from the survey of greve et al .
( 2004 ) who presented a 1.2-mm map of the lockman hole region ( as well as data on the elais n2 region ) , centred on the coordinates mapped at 0.85 mm by scuba in the ` 8-mjy survey ' ( scott et al . 2002 , 2004 ) .
mortier et al .
( 2005 ) have recently present a refined analysis of scuba data which lies within the lockman hole mambo map ; we began with a 2-@xmath1 mambo catalogue , extracted as described by greve et al .
( 2004 ) , and looked for 0.85-mm sources within 14arcsec ( roughly the area of five beams ) in the mortier et al .
( 2005 ) sample , applying a correction for separation and checking for a combined significance above our initial threshold , 4.5@xmath1 .
we included sources that exceed 4.5@xmath1 in either dataset , as long as there is a valid reason why the source is not seen in the other image .
smgs from scott et al .
( 2002 ) were substituted where blends were evident in the mortier et al.catalogue . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] notes : @xmath21 sources in parentheses lack robust radio identifications .
+ @xmath22 values in bold are for sources identified in the radio ( @xmath23 ) .
+ @xmath24 values in bold are for redshifts that we consider to be most robust .
[ speccat ]
table 3 lists the mag_best magnitudes of our sample in @xmath25 , measured using sextractor . fig .
7 shows a histogram of @xmath25 magnitudes compared with those from the surveys by smail et al.(2002 ) , i02 , clements et al .
( 2004 ) and pope et al .
the various surveys broadly agree , with median @xmath25-band magnitudes ranging between @xmath2626 and a wide range in magnitude within each sample .
the clements et al .
( 2004 ) sample has a bright tail which is less evident in the other surveys .
our sample appears to show the smallest dispersion , although the presence of upper - limits in all five samples make this statement hard to quantify .
nevertheless , from this comparison we can state that the bright , radio - identified smg population , spanning barely a magnitude in submm flux density , covers over 10 orders of magnitude in rest - frame ultraviolet flux .
the optical magnitudes of the radio - identified smgs discussed in this paper span around @xmath2726 , with a faint tail .
the median magnitude is @xmath28 , comparable to the sample analysed by c05 , @xmath29 , and @xmath30.6mag fainter than the spectroscopically - identified sample of c05 .
as expected , a similar bias in the spectroscopically identified subset exists within our own sample , which is @xmath30.9mag brighter than our complete catalogue .
the redshift distribution determined here inevitably suffers from spectroscopic incompleteness , but our sample should be otherwise unbiased . concentrating on cases where our spectroscopy failed to secure a robust redshift
the failures tend to coincide with the faintest optical counterparts , @xmath30 , as one might expect .
looking at the long - wavelength flux ratios ( fig .
5 ) for those targets where we failed to obtain identifications or redshifts , e.g.lh1200.002 or .004 , we see no indication that their ( sub)mm / radio photometric properties differ from those of the sample as a whole . it seems unlikely therefore that they lie at substantially higher redshifts than the subset of smgs for which we have obtained redshifts .
the exceptions are lh1200.022 , and especially lh1200.007 , which have relatively low 0.85-/1.2-mm flux density ratios and fairly high 1.2-mm/1.4-ghz flux density ratios .
this suggests they may lie at high redshift , or be particularly cold .
however , as discussed in 3.2 , these two sources are not particularly secure ( although that may simply reflect their general faintness in all bands due to their high redshifts ) .
reliable identification of these two sources is therefore only achievable through higher resolution ( interferometric ) ( sub)mm observations ( e.g. lutz et al .
2001 ) .
for the six smgs where we have a single radio identification ( and hence an unambigious counterpart ) and for which we have measured robust redshifts ( table 3 ) , we determine a median of @xmath31 ( where the scatter is estimated from bootstrap re - sampling ) .
this rises slightly to @xmath10 if we include the four sources with robust redshifts for at least one radio counterpart and the five smgs where we have less secure redshifts .
these figures are slightly lower than , but entirely consistent with , the spectroscopic redshift distribution determined by c05 ( _ z _ = 2.2 ) .
this suggests that the statistical properties of the c05 sample has not been strongly biased by the modest significance @xmath323@xmath1 ) of some of the submm data used in their analysis .
the median redshift we derive is in reasonable agreement with that predicted by the galform semi - analytic model ( baugh et al.2005 ) , which gives a median redshift of @xmath33 at our flux limit , with a quartile range of @xmath340.9 and only 1020 per cent of the population at @xmath35 .
this again suggests that much of the activity in the bright smg population is amenable to study via the precise positions derived from their radio counterparts .
this provides a much - needed route to identify the true far - ir - luminous source within these frequently morphologically complex and crowded fields .
we illustrate in fig .
8 the distribution of 1.2-mm/1.4-ghz and 0.85-/1.2-mm flux ratios for our sample versus our spectroscopic redshifts .
the former show a trend to higher flux ratios at higher redshifts , in line with predictions from sed modelling ( e.g. carilli & yun 1999 ) , although with a large scatter ; the latter flux ratio , however , is essentially a scatter plot .
we conclude that significantly more reliable flux measurements ( in terms of both absolute calibration and overall snr ) will be needed to use the 0.85-/1.2-mm flux ratio for astrophysical analysis . at face value , both our spectroscopic redshift distribution and that of c05 are inconsistent with the redshift distribution ( _ z _ @xmath32 3 ) claimed by eales et al .
( 2003 ) using the @xmath36 flux density ratio ( fig .
the eales et al.sample contained 23 sources with @xmath37 = 3.16.5mjy ( cf .
19 sources , @xmath37 = 1.65.7mjy here ) , with a radio - detected fraction of 73 per cent ( cf .
79 per cent here ) .
thus , the two samples differ only in that the eales et al .
photometry targets were selected above 4@xmath1 at 1200@xmath38 m rather than above 5@xmath1 at a combination of 850 and 1200@xmath38 m .
we believe the disagreement in the mean redshifts derived by these studies most likely results from the fact that current photometric measurements in the mm and submm wavebands are insufficiently precise for typical smgs to allow them to be used as a reliable redshift indicator , particularly when some data do not comprise fully sampled images .
the disagreement may have been compounded by the lower significance of the eales et al .
targets , and the dual - wavelength extraction performed here could exclude the most distant starbursts ( though we note that the radio - detection of a substantial number of the eales et al.targets is hard to reconcile with the high median redshift claimed for that sample ; indeed , the radio - based estimates given in eales et al . , with _ z _ = 2.35 , are more consistent with the spectroscopic results ) .
we have developed and applied a dual - survey extraction technique to scuba and mambo images of the lockman hole , resulting in a robust sample of 19 smgs .
of these , 15 are detected securely by our deep radio imaging . those undetected at 1.4ghz can be explained by a combination of contamination by spurious sources ( 10 per cent ) and the large observed scatter in radio flux densities , which is probably due to a significant range in dust temperature .
we determine 15 spectroscopic redshifts , of which we consider ten to be secure .
the resulting redshift distribution ( _ z _ = 2.14 for the full spectroscopic sample ) is consistent with that determined for a much larger sample by c05 ( _ z _ = 2.2 ) .
our results thus support the conclusions of c05 , who modelled their incompleteness and estimated only a small shift ( @xmath39 ) in the median redshift as a result .
those galaxies for which our spectroscopy failed to determine redshifts are usually optically faint , @xmath30 , where the sample ranges from @xmath27 to @xmath40 with a median of 25.0 . from the radio detections , and
the spectroscopy , is seems unlikely that a significant fraction of bright smgs lie at very high redshift ( @xmath41 ) and we conclude that the bright smg population is readily amenable to study via radio - selected samples , down to a 850-@xmath38 m flux density limit of @xmath37mjy .
" we note , however , that the dual - wavelength extraction performed here could potentially bias our sample against very - high - redshift sources which would only be detected at 1.2 mm . an analysis of separations between smgs and their radio counterparts has allowed us to re - calibrate the rule - of - thumb relationship between positional accuracy , beam size and significance . the most secure smgs , at @xmath310@xmath1 , representative of those expected in upcoming , confusion - limited , wide - field ( tens of square degrees ) 0.85-mm surveys using scuba-2 ( audley et al .
2004 ) , with lower significance , simultaneous detections at 0.45 mm , will be located with a uncertainty of @xmath42arcsec , at which level the precision of the telescope pointing and scuba-2 flat - field may become important contributors to the positional error budget . assuming these sources of uncertainty can be minimised , the current requirement for deep radio coverage to identify counterparts and enable follow - up spectroscopy may not be as urgent , particularly if 3@xmath433-arcsec deployable integral - field units are employed for spectroscopic follow up ( e.g. kmos sharples et al .
2003 , 2004 ) .
is acknowledges support from the royal society .
awb acknowledges support from nsf grant ast-0205937 , the research corporation and the alfred p. sloan foundation . 99 aretxaga i. , hughes d.h . , chapin e.l .
, gaztaaga e. , dunlop j.s . ,
ivison r.j . , 2003 , mnras , 342 , 759 audley m.d .
et al . , 2004 ,
spie , 5498 , 63 baugh c.m . ,
lacey c.g . ,
frenk c.s . ,
granato g.l . ,
silva l. , bressan a. , benson a.j . , cole s. , 2005 , mnras , 356 , 1191 blain a.w . ,
smail i. , ivison r.j .
, kneib j .-
, 1999 , mnras , 302 , 632 blain a.w . , chapman s.c . , smail i. , ivison r.j . , 2004 ,
apj , 611 , 52 borys c. et al .
, 2004 , mnras , 352 , 759 borys c. , scott d. , chapman s. , halpern m. , nandra k. , pope a. , 2005 , mnras , 355 , 485 carilli c.l .
, yun m.s . , 1999 , apj , 513 , l13 chapman s.c .
, smail i. , ivison r.j . ,
blain a.w . , 2002 , mnras , 335 , l17 chapman s.c . , blain a.w .
, ivison r.j . , smail i. , 2003 , nature , 422 , 695 ( c03 ) chapman s.c . , smail i. , blain a.w . , ivison r.j . ,
2004a , apj , 614 , 671 chapman s.c .
, smail i. , windhorst r. , muxlow t. , ivison r.j . , 2004b , apj , 611 , 732 chapman s.c .
, blain a.w . , smail i. , ivison r.j . , 2005 ,
apj , 622 , 772 ( c05 ) clements d. et al . , 2004 , mnras , 351 , 611 downes a.j.b . , peacock j.a .
, savage a. , carrie d.r . , 1986 , mnras , 218 , 31 downes d. , solomon p.m. , 2003 , apj , 582 , 37 dunlop j.s .
et al . , 2004 ,
mnras , 350 , 769 dunlop j.s . , 2005 , in : ` starburst
from 30 doradus to lyman break galaxies ' , eds de grijs r. , gonzalez - delgado r.m . , in press ( astro - ph/0501429 ) eales s. , bertoldi f. , ivison r.j .
, carilli c. , dunne l. , owen f. , 2003 , mnras , 344 , 169 egami e. et al . , 2004 ,
apjs , 154 , 130 fox m.j .
et al . , 2002 ,
mnras , 331 , 839 gear w.k . , lilly s.j .
, stevens j.a .
, clements d.l . , webb t.m .
, eales s.a . ,
dunne l. , 2000 , mnras , 316 , l51 genzel r. , baker a.j . , tacconi l.j .
, lutz d. , cox p. , guilloteau s. , omont a. , 2003 , apj , 584 , 633 greve t.r .
, ivison r.j . , bertoldi f. , stevens j.a . , lutz d. , dunlop j.s . , 2004 , mnras , 354 , 779 greve t.r .
2005 , mnras , 359 , 1165 holland w.s .
et al . , 1999 ,
mnras , 303 , 659 huang j .- s .
et al . , 2004 ,
apjs , 154 , 44 hughes d.h .
et al . , 1998 ,
nature , 394 , 241 ivison r.j .
, smail i. , le borgne j .- f . ,
blain a.w . , kneib j .-
, bzecourt j. , kerr t.h . , davies j.k . , 1998 , mnras , 298 , 583 ivison r.j .
, smail i. , barger a. , kneib j .-
, blain a.w . ,
, kerr t.h .
, cowie l.l . , 2000
, mnras , 315 , 209 ivison r.j .
et al . , 2002 ,
mnras , 337 , 1 ( i02 ) ivison r.j .
et al . , 2004 , apjs , 154 , 124 kneib j .-
p . , van der werf p.p . , kraiberg knudsen k. , smail i. , blain a. , frayer d. , barnard v. , ivison r. , 2004 , mnras , 349 , 1211 knudsen k.k .
, van der werf p.p . ,
jaffe w. , 2003 , a&a , 411 , 343 kreysa e. et al . , 1998 , proc .
spie , 3357 , 319 laurent g.t .
et al . , 2005 ,
apj , 623 , 742 ledlow m.j . , smail i. , owen f.n . ,
keel w.c . ,
ivison r.j . ,
morrison g.e . , 2002 ,
apj , 577 , l79 lutz d. et al . , 2001 , a&a , 378 , l70 mortier a.m.j .
2005 , mnras , submitted neri r. et al .
, 2003 , a&a , 597 , l113 oke j.b .
et al . , 1995 ,
pasp , 107 , 375 pope a. , borys c. , scott d. , conselice c. , dickinson m. , mobasher b. , 2005 , mnras , 358 , 149 scott s.e .
et al . , 2002 , 331 , 817 scott s.e . , 2004 , phd thesis , university of edinburgh sharples r.m .
, bender r. , hofmann r. , genzel r. , ivison r.j . , 2003 ,
spie , 4841 , 1562 sharples r.m .
et al . , 2004 ,
spie , 5492 , 1179 simpson c. , dunlop j.s . ,
eales s.a . ,
ivison r.j . ,
scott s.e . , lilly s.j . ,
webb t.m.a . , 2004 .
mnras , 353 , 179 smail i. , hogg d.w . , yan l. , cohen j.g . , 1995 , apj , 449 , l105 smail i. , ivison r.j . , blain a.w . , 1997 , apj , 490 , l5 smail i. , ivison r.j .
, kneib j .-
, cowie l.l .
, blain a.w . ,
barger a.j . ,
owen f.n . , morrison g. , 1999 , mnras , 308 , 1061 smail i. , ivison r.j . ,
owen f.n . ,
blain a.w .
, kneib j .-
, 2000 , apj , 528 , 612 smail i. , ivison r.j . , blain a.w .
, kneib j .-
, 2002 , mnras , 331 , 495 smail i. , chapman s.c . ,
ivison r.j . ,
blain a.w .
, takata t. , heckman t.m . , dunlop j.s .
, sekiguchi k. , 2003 , mnras , 342 , 1185 smail i. , smith g.p .
, ivison r.j . , 2005 ,
apj , in press ( astro - ph/0506176 ) swinbank a.m. , smail i. , chapman s.c . ,
blain a.w . ,
ivison r.j . ,
keel w.c . , 2004 ,
apj , 617 , 64 townsend r.h.d . ,
ivison r.j .
, smail i. , blain a.w .
, frayer d.t . , 2001 , mnras , 328 , l17 webb t.m .
et al . , 2003a , apj , 587 , 41 webb t.m.a .
, lilly s.j . , clements d.l . , eales s. , yun m. , brodwin m. , dunne l. , gear w.k . , 2003b , apj , 597 , 680 wiklind t. , 2004 , apj , 588 , 736
notes on our spectroscopic observations of the individual sources , referring to the slit positions shown in fig . 3 .
* lh1200.001 : * a complex field .
lris slits on several masks had been placed on a faint @xmath25-band source coincident with the most probable radio counterpart ( @xmath44 ) .
its spectrum , shown in fig .
a1 , is consistent with a redshift of 3.036 , with ly@xmath45 and hints of weak nv and several other lines .
we searched for [ oii ] and [ oiii ] using nirspec ( 4.1 ) , yet we were not able to confirm or rule out @xmath46 with confidence .
a search for co(32 ) at iram was unsuccessful ( greve et al .
2005 ) , though this could have been due to insufficient velocity coverage .
the second radio counterpart , 4arcsec to the north and also with @xmath23 , is associated with an ero ( fig .
the nirspec longslit was positioned to cover this galaxy ; no lines were evident .
its closest neighbour was observed with gmos ( fig .
a2 ; [ 28 ] ) and found to have emission lines ( ly@xmath45 , possibly nv and siii ) consistent with @xmath47 ( the apparent continuum blueward of ly@xmath45 is merely an artifact of the reduction process ) . at the edge of the same slit , near the northern radio position
, there is tentative evidence for line emission from ly@xmath45 , nv and possibly civ at @xmath48 . the optically bright radio source 11arcsec se of the smg centroid ( fig .
a2 ; [ 26 ] ) is an agn , with broad ciii ] and mgii emission lines , this time at @xmath49 .
the optical galaxy 8arcsec sse of the smg centroid ( fig .
a2 ; [ 27 ] ) has [ oii ] at @xmath50 .
a further ero , overlooked by i02 , and detected at 3.5@xmath1 in our smoothed radio image , lies 7.5 arcsec nne of the smg centroid ( fig .
we conclude that the submm emission likely originates from the two central radio components , which most probably lie at @xmath51 .
* lh1200.002 : * two galaxies in this field were targeted spectroscopically with gmos .
one target , slit [ 25 ] , lies close to the faint radio emission near the smg centroid , but we were unable to identify its redshift .
the other target probably unassociated with the smg has a faint emission line which , if [ oii ] , indicates @xmath52 ( fig .
a2 ; [ 24 ] ) .
* lh1200.003 : * another complex field .
lh1200.003 may be a blend of 23 smgs , with mambo resolving the source into two , and the vla resolving three faint radio sources ( one marginally outside our radio search region ) .
slits had been placed on all likely counterparts .
the radio source to the se , targeted by slits on five lris masks at various position angles , is a starburst at @xmath53 .
the most probable ( central ) radio identification is associated with a galaxy at @xmath54 ( fig .
a1 ) . the galaxy to the nnw
possibly associated with faint mm emission , lh1200.213 in greve et al .
( 2004 ) was targeted spectroscopically using lris and gmos and is an agn at @xmath55 , with broad civ emission , as well as narrower ly@xmath45 , heii , niv and nv ( fig .
a2 ; [ 15 ] ) .
* lh1200.004 : * from two possibilities , an lris slit had been placed on the galaxy with the marginally higher @xmath56 value ( 0.044 versus 0.033 ) .
the galaxy has a weak line in its spectrum at 558 nm , possibly ly@xmath45 , but we were unable to determine the redshift reliably . * lh1200.005 : * lris slits were placed on a faint optical galaxy @xmath33 arcsec west of the obvious radio counterpart .
the galaxy is estimated to lie at @xmath57 from absorption lines in its optical spectrum ( c05 ) , a value tentatively confirmed via h@xmath45 in the @xmath11 band , although nirspec slit - rotation problems mean the line can not be recovered in the final spectrum or image .
although optically faint ( fig . 3 , @xmath58 ) , the extremely red object ( ero ) described by lutz et al.(2001 ) , seen in fig . 4 at the radio position , was targeted using lris and gmos .
no redshift was forthcoming .
the likelihood of finding a @xmath59 galaxy so close to the smg centroid is slim , so the two may well be associated , but we regard the redshift as tentative until h@xmath45 is detected unambiguously .
* lh1200.006 : * lris slits had been placed on by far the most probable radio counterpart in the region ( @xmath60 ) . its optical spectrum was identified by c05 as that of a starburst at @xmath61 ( fig .
this position was also observed by swinbank et al .
( 2004 ) using nirspec , although only [ nii ] would have been accessible .
since the one - dimensional optical spectrum is not wholly convincing , this redshift can not be relied upon absolutely . the optically bright object to the nw
was targeted by gmos : a foreground galaxy ( @xmath62 ) with h@xmath63 and [ oiii ] emission lines evident ( fig .
a2 ; [ 220 ] ) .
* lh1200.007 : * there is no secure radio counterpart .
an lris slit was placed on a nearby _ xmm - newton _ x - ray source , which is marginally detected in our smoothed radio image .
it lies at @xmath64 ( fig .
a1 ) , and may contribute submm flux to what could well be a blended submm source . the faint , red galaxy to the north , barely seen in a noisy part of our @xmath11 image ( fig .
4 ) , was not targeted spectroscopically .
* lh1200.008 : * an lris slit had been placed on by far the most probable radio counterpart in the region ( @xmath65 ) , an @xmath66 galaxy amongst a dense ensemble of fainter objects ( fig .
3 ) , with absorption lines in its spectrum corresponding to @xmath67 ( fig . a1 ) , with ciii ] and heii weakly in emission .
* lh1200.009 : * gmos slits were placed on the radio counterpart and on an optically bright galaxy to the nnw .
an unambiguous redshift could not be determined for either , although the nnw galaxy may show faint [ oii ] at @xmath68 ( fig .
a2 ; [ 231 ] ) .
lris slits had been placed on a faint @xmath25-band galaxy @xmath36arcsec ssw of the obvious radio counterpart .
this was due to an positional offset in an earlier version of the greve et al .
mambo catalogue .
the galaxy 3arcsec nw of the slit centre , 4arcsec sww of the radio source , appears to be a ly@xmath45 emitter at @xmath69 ( fig .
a1 ) , though no other lines are seen . as with lh1200.005 , the likelihood of finding a @xmath59 galaxy so close to the submm centroid is low , so it may be associated with the radio source and the smg .
the position of the radio source is blank to @xmath70 in our deep gemini / niri imaging ( fig .
the ly@xmath45 emitter is detected , barely , in @xmath11 .
we note that at least one similarly faint smg ( smmj14009 + 0252 , @xmath71 ) has been found at @xmath59 ( smith et al .
, in preparation ) .
* lh1200.010 : * lris slits had been placed on both of the radio - identified galaxies in this region with one of them ( and several other radio - quiet galaxies ) targeted by gmos . by far the most robust counterpart ( @xmath72 ) , morphologically complex in @xmath25 ( fig . 3 ) but relatively uncluttered in @xmath11 ( fig . 4 ) ,
has the spectrum of a starburst at @xmath73 ( c05 , smmj105230.73 + 572209.5 ) , confirmed in h@xmath45 by swinbank et al .
( 2005 ) and in nv by gmos ( ly@xmath45 falling between chips fig .
a2 ; [ 210 ] ) , although undetected in co(32 ) at iram ( greve et al .
the lris spectrum of the radio - bright disk - like galaxy 10arcsec to the sw is also consistent with this redshift .
nothing was seen at the remaining gmos slit positions , [ 211 ] and [ 212 ] .
* lh1200.011 : * an lris slit had been placed on by far the most probable radio counterpart in the region ( @xmath74 ) , a compact source with a 5-arcsec - long tail visible in @xmath25 and @xmath11 ( figs 3 & 4 ) .
it has the spectrum of a starburst at @xmath75 ( c05 , smmj105158.02 + 571800.2 ) , confirmed convincingly in h@xmath45 and [ nii ] by swinbank et al .
the fainter radio source , 14arcsec to the nee , lies at @xmath76 .
simpson et al . ( 2004 ) identified a @xmath77-band feature , presumably a noise spike , as [ oii ] at @xmath78 ( rest - frame 359 nm for @xmath79 ) , as well as a continuum break at 1.2@xmath38 m ( consistent with the balmer break at either redshift ) .
* lh1200.012 : * a complex field , with the robust radio identification ( @xmath80 ) lying between 34 galaxies visible in @xmath25 , and on top of a galaxy seen in the _ spitzer _
3.6-@xmath38 m imaging of huang et al .
a ns - oriented lris slit had been placed on the brightest of the @xmath25-band galaxies , @xmath32arcsec sse , a starburst at @xmath81 ( fig .
a1 ; c05 , smmj105155.47 + 572312.7 ) .
the nirspec slit , centred on the same point , yielded continuum but no strong lines .
however , 2arcsec nw along the slit where fuzz is visible in @xmath25 , 1arcsec sw of the radio centroid there is more red continuum emission a line at 2.405@xmath38 m , corresponding to h@xmath45 at @xmath82 ( fig .
we view the likelihood of its association with the smg as high . another lris slit was placed on the radio source to the nw , associated with another _ spitzer _ galaxy , this time at @xmath83 ( @xmath84 in h@xmath45 according to swinbank et al.2005 ) .
gmos slits [ 129 ] through [ 132 ] were placed on all of the brightest optical knots , but nothing was seen in the spectra .
* lh1200.014 : * an interesting case , with strong similarities to lh1200.010 and .012 .
the brightest of the two radio counterparts associated with faint @xmath11-band emission ( fig .
4 ) is the least likely identification , although by a small margin ( @xmath85 versus 0.022 ) .
lris slits were placed on the brightest @xmath25-band galaxy ( fig .
3 ) , just to the wsw , which displays [ oii ] in emission as well as ca h / k and several balmer lines in absorption at @xmath86 ( fig . a1 lh1200.014a ; c05 , smmj105200.22 + 572420.2 ) .
its association with the smg , and with the radio - identified galaxies , is plausible , as is the possibility that it acts as a lens ( chapman et al .
the slit passed over the radio centroid which appears to share the same broad spectral features ( fig .
a1 lh1200.014b ) .
a gmos slit , [ 123 ] , was placed directly on the radio centroid , but the spectral coverage ( @xmath87550 nm in this case ) meant we were unable to confirm the presence of [ oii ] .
* lh1200.042 : * lris slits had been placed on by far the most probable radio counterpart in the region ( @xmath88 ) . although optically faint , it has an absorption - line spectrum consistent with @xmath89 ( fig . a1 lh1200.042a ) .
the bright optical galaxy 3arcsec to the sse , targeted by both gmos [ 225 ] and lris , is associated with very faint radio emission and is tentatively consistent with @xmath90 ( fig .
a1 lh1200.042b ) .
* lh1200.096 : * again , lris and gmos slits had been placed on the most probable radio counterpart ( @xmath91 ) , an ero ( i02 ) visible out to 24@xmath38 m ( egami et al .
2004 ) , ignoring several brighter optical galaxies .
the lris spectrum was classified as a starburst at @xmath92 by c05 ( fig .
a1 smmj105151.69 + 572636.0 ) ; gmos saw nothing at this position .
this is the curious smg discussed by i02 , apparently associated with the steep - spectrum lobe of a radio galaxy , the flat - spectrum core of which lies to the west , with [ oii ] evident at @xmath93 in its spectrum ( fig .
a2 , [ 120 ] ) .
is this system a jet - triggered burst , a galaxy projected onto an unrelated radio lobe , or a faint , dusty , ultra - steep - spectrum radio galaxy ?
our picture of this system is muddled and contradictory . to confuse matters further , our niri @xmath11-band imaging ( fig .
4 ) reveals another ero , wsw of the radio emission , visible out to 8@xmath38 m in the _ spitzer _ imaging , and just missed by gmos slit [ 119 ] on a nearby , bluer galaxy .
* lh1200.104 : * despite the lack of radio detections in the vicinity , a bright _ spitzer _ counterpart described by ivison et al .
( in preparation ) suggests this smg is not spurious .
a diffraction spike from the nearby star makes identification impossible in our optical imaging . | the modest significance of most sources detected in current ( sub)millimetre surveys can potentially compromise some analyses due to the inclusion of spurious sources in catalogues typically selected at @xmath03.03.5@xmath1 . here ,
we develop and apply a dual - survey extraction technique to scuba and mambo images of the lockman hole . cut above 5@xmath1 , our catalogue of submillimetre galaxies ( smgs ) is more robust than previous samples , with a reduced likelihood of real , but faint smgs ( beneath and around the confusion limit ) entering via superposition with noise .
our selection technique yields 19 smgs in an effective area of 165arcmin@xmath2 , of which we expect at most two to be due to chance superposition of scuba and mambo noise peaks .
the effective flux limit of the survey ( @xmath34mjy at @xmath31 mm ) is well matched to our deep 1.4-ghz image ( @xmath4jy beam@xmath5 ) .
the former is sensitive to luminous , dusty galaxies at extreme redshifts whilst the latter probes the @xmath6 regime .
a high fraction of our robust smgs ( @xmath380 per cent ) have radio counterparts which , given the @xmath310-per - cent contamination by spurious sources , suggests that very distant smgs ( @xmath7 ) are unlikely to make up more than @xmath310 per cent of the bright smg population .
this implies that almost all of the @xmath8mjy smg population is amenable to study via the deepest current radio imaging .
we use these radio counterparts to provide an empirical calibration of the positional uncertainty in smg catalogues .
we then go on to outline the acquisition of redshifts for radio - identified smgs , from sample selection in the submillimetre , to counterpart selection in the radio and optical / infrared , to slit placement on spectrograph masks .
we determine a median of @xmath9 from a sample of six secure redshifts for unambigious radio - identified submillimetre sources and @xmath10 when we include submillimetre sources with multiple radio counterparts and/or less reliable redshifts .
these figures are consistent with previous estimates , suggesting that our knowledge of the median redshift of bright smgs population has not been biased by the low significance of the source catalogues employed .
galaxies : starburst galaxies : formation cosmology : observations cosmology : early universe |
robot design deals with complexity in a manner similar to personal computers .
robots have input / output devices that either provide output by acting in the environment or sensors that provide input . like pcs ,
robot peripherals contain firmware ( device controllers ) to predictably and efficiently manage resources in real - time .
data is provided via a well - defined interface ( set of system calls over a transport ) .
however , pcs abstract the differences in internal organization and chipsets through classifying devices in terms of their roles in the system .
these roles define an appropriate set of access and control functions that generally apply across the entire classification .
subsequent differences in devices are accommodated through the use of custom device drivers . robots also contain a mechanism for providing input and output to the higher - level algorithms , but the placement of the hardware abstraction layer is different than in personal computers .
although most devices are classified according to the data type they produce and consume , classification occurs within the framework , not at the firmware level .
the disadvantage of this approach is that customized links from each hardware platform to each framework must be created . in the current robotics landscape
, this is a huge burden given the rate of innovation on new hardware platforms for many research and education purposes .
this ongoing backlog of creating one - to - one connections between platforms and hardware stifles innovation of control architectures .
the small number of developers comfortable with device driver creation either due to the unfamiliarity of the transports or the complexity of the threaded management of connections is source of slow progress .
fortunately , we can leverage some commonalities found at the device driver level that link salient concepts both in the device driver domain and the robotics domain .
we propose a domain specific language based on these concepts called robot device interface specification ( rdis ) .
the rdis describes the robot interface in terms of connection , primitives and interfaces .
an accurate characterization of the device domain enables some important innovations .
first , the rdis enables a declarative , rather than a programmed interface to frameworks .
this approach benefits both device manufacturers and framework developers and users by separating the device semantics from the framework semantics .
robot designers can describe the interface that they provide via onboard firmware and how it maps to abstract concepts via the rdis .
the framework developers are only responsible for providing a mapping from the abstract concepts to the framework .
the abstract interface allows a many - to - many mapping between devices and frameworks using only a single map for each device and framework .
this is beneficial because manufacturers typically only provide device drivers for a single , often proprietary framework .
specific device drivers for many frameworks are left to either framework developers ( in the case of popular robots ) or framework users ( as needed ) .
the lack of available drivers for a specific device on a specific framework can be a barrier to leveraging existing software components .
second , an abstraction that maps device semantics to domain specific concepts enables a new generation of development and runtime tools that can discover and manage available resources at both development and runtime .
expertise in creating efficient threaded drivers for specific frameworks can be reused .
this approach would simplify development by presenting developers with available resources that conform to specific domain concepts . in this paper
, we present the rdis work in progress including rdis specification and tools as well as a use of the rdis to generate device specific programs . the rest of this paper is organized as follows : section [ rw ] discusses work related to declarative descriptions of robot hardware .
section [ rdis ] presents the preliminary domain model and its applicability to existing platforms .
the current implementation is discussed in section [ case ] .
the summary and future work directions are detailed in section [ summary ] .
although the literature reveals very few attempts at using dsls for hardware device drivers , thibault et al @xcite report the creation of efficient video device drivers using a novel dsl @xcite .
this language is targeted at the hardware interface layer and creates device driver code rather than interpreting code for efficiency .
urbi ( universal robotic body interface ) focuses on creating a model that controls the low level layer of robots and is independent from the robot and client system due to the client / server architecture .
others @xcite have attempted to address the lack of standardization in abstraction layers but have not considered moving abstractions to drivers using device descriptions .
some frameworks use a declarative description of the robots for simulation .
player / stage @xcite is both a 2d simulator and a robot control framework .
robot description files are broken into two pieces : 1 ) a 2d description of the robot and its sensors and 2 ) a set of interfaces that abstract the data produced by hardware to a standard format .
the description , used for simulating the robot , consists of a polygon - based footprint with sensor locations marked .
actuation and sensor characteristics along with parameters for simplified error models are used to complete the model of the robot .
a domain - specific set of classes and message types describe what data can be obtained or how the robot can be manipulated ( i.e. pose2d for position and laser or ir for distance to other objects ) .
the classes and message types represent the interface that abstracts the robot hardware to the data that it can produce or consume .
writing software to the interfaces that a robot can utilize ( rather than the specific robot ) allows software to be written either for a simulated robot or a real robot , which in turns eases the transition from simulation to physical implementation .
ros @xcite targets a 3d simulation framework ( gazebo ) and more sophisticated intelligent controller , which require a more rigorous description
. urdf ( uniform robot description format ) provides a 3d physical description broken into links and joints to facilitate not only mobile robots but manipulators as well . geometric bounding boxes and meshes allow for collision detection and realistic visualization . like player / stage
, ros utilizes a message - based model to decouple data providers from data producers .
ideally robots that provide and consume similar data types can be controlled similarly . unlike player stage , urdf not only serves as a mechanism for simulating robots , but also allows for the visualization of real robots in both real - time and off - line ( through saved messages ) .
a select number of robot control frameworks move beyond visualization information and relevant interface declaration in the hardware description .
preop , an alice - based programming interface @xcite for robots takes this paradigm further .
not only is 3d visualization information supplied , but also the programming interface is completely specified by the selection of the robot object .
this is accomplished by linking the real - time control mechanism and exposed api available to the user within the robot object .
frameworks and general reuse within the robotics research community rely upon the relatively invariant nature of mobile robots in several ways .
first , in an effort to reduce the complexity of control software , many robots reuse certain kinematic designs .
for example , differential drive is a fairly common choice as a configuration .
there is a computationally simple , closed form solution for forward and inverse kinematics and when combined with wheel encoders , provides a method for calculating pose relative to a starting position ( which in turn enables closed loop control ) .
although manipulators can contain arbitrary linkages , typically robots are constrained to configurations that provide a closed form inverse kinematic formulation and are numerically conducive to path planning ( avoiding singularities ) @xcite .
therefore , software that takes advantage of the kinematic control inherent in one configuration could be applied to other robots that reuse that configuration with appropriate parameterization .
second , many robots including the popular mobile robots pioneer class , irobot creates , k - team robots , erratic er-1 , white box robotics model 914 , ar.drones , and birdbrain finches contain an embedded firmware controller that accepts commands via a serial , bluetooth , wifi or usb interface rather than require the users to download a program to onboard memory .
this approach is popular because it allows the hardware designers to hide the complexity of hardware control within the firmware .
there are a few designs that still expect developers to download code to the firmware .
the benefits of the low latency of local control are far outweighed by the burden of identifying a local toolchain to build the remote executables and the complexity of testing on a remote platform . to that end ,
robots that utilize local control often provide modes where the local software program presents an api to an external computer ( i.e. lego mindstorms via lejos and e - puck ) .
rdis , robot device interface specification , is a domain specific language that defines the connection to robot firmware and maps data types to defacto standard messages for use in frameworks .
this mechanism provides an abstraction layer between the device and frameworks that negates the need for device drivers as point solutions .
the rdis has three purposes : 1 ) provide enough information for simulation and visualization of hardware and controllers , 2 ) declaratively specify the mechanism for requesting data and actuation , and 3 ) inform users of standard message types that can be obtained from the hardware to facilitate connections to existing frameworks .
the rdis enables several efficiencies in robotics controller development .
although the long term goal is to embed the rdis within the firmware as a response to a request , it could also be requested via the internet from a repository .
however manufacturers that provide access to the rdis within their hardware would benefit from being able to take advantage of the rdis connectors available for frameworks without specifically providing device drivers .
then the rdis serves as a discovery message to the development architecture regarding the services available and how to manage the services at runtime . making the hardware the system of record for its abilities is in line with other modern technologies ( bluetooth for example ) .
the challenge in successfully defining the rdis is in creating a model that captures the generalizable aspects of robots and appropriately identifies the aspects that vary .
domain models , when designed properly , can be somewhat invariant to changes and can provide a stable basis for deciding the structure and parameters of the specification .
primary concepts include connection , message formats , primitives and exposed interfaces ( figure [ er ] ) .
figure [ circles ] shows a diagram of the domain and the scope of the rdis .
connections are generally through standard transports and describe how the robot connects to external controllers .
message formats either encode parameters in ascii formats or send natively as byte values .
primitives describe the device invariant features which are requests that can be made and ingoing and outgoing parameters .
exposed interfaces describe a more convenient exposed interface that may map directly to primitives or may add value to a primitive by data conversion or specific parameterization .
there are some cross - cutting concerns .
messaging paradigms are either request - reply ( service - based and adhoc ) or publish / subscribe ( periodic updates that are published or expected ) .
threading models include single ( one loop that services incoming and outgoing data ) , dual threaded ( one thread for servicing incoming requests and one thread for periodic requests ) , or multiple threads ( requests create threads and periodic requests are on different frequencies ) .
some drivers maintain state
( i.e. current position relative to the starting point ) and the validation routines for incoming data and read and write routines can vary .
a preliminary rdis that meets requirements 2 and 3 has been implemented for the finch robot from bird brain and the koala from k - team .
figure [ generate ] shows how the rdis is used to create robot specific driver code for frameworks .
the rdis and the resulting templates contain attributes to describe several functions including connection , basic primitives , external interfaces and mapping to abstract robotic concepts .
the connection statement delineates the physical connection parameters , the overall threading model and functions to call upon the creation of the connection ( excerpt shown in figure [ connect ] ) . depending upon the physical connection
, other parameters could include port i d , serial connection parameters , or usb i d .
although we intend to support three threading models , the single threading model is used which processes requests and publishing of data in a single active loop .
a callback is used to process any subscriptions ( if supported by the framework and indicated by the abstract mapping ) and second thread is used to issue a keepalive command if required by the platform .
all data protection , including appropriate mutexes are generated by the rdis handler based on the threading model selected .
basic primitives describe the mechanism for sending information to and from the robot .
primitive specifications indicate the associated connection ( described in connection statement ) , frequency and message formatting .
frequency indicates whether the method is a request / reply or periodic .
request / reply methods ( indicated as adhoc ) are only submitted when a request is received .
parameters can be provided by the client and data can be returned to the calling client .
periodic requests are executed on a schedule and utilize a set of state variables ( defined in state variables section ) to retrieve and save method data .
message formats for communicating with robot firmware are either position based or delimited .
the interim specification presented here encodes the messages along with the input and output fields .
an example of the setmotor function in figure [ setmotorc ] and the underlying abstract syntax tree is shown in figure [ setmotor ] .
the external interface exposes the api available to client programs .
each interface is composed of one or more primitive methods or can return state variables ( updated asynchronously by periodic primitives ) . the separation between the external interface and primitives encapsulates the robot firmware and its parameters from developers .
for example , actuation commands are sometimes provided in encoder units where an external api would utilize a standard measure such as meters per second . a mapping to abstract concepts in sensing and locomotion provides a link between robots and existing frameworks . rather than specify framework
specific information within the rdis , abstract concepts that describe the data available are used instead .
for example , since a differential drive robot can be controlled via linear and rotational velocity , we provide a mapping between linear and rotational velocity and robot primitives ( left and right velocity ) .
an example is shown in figure [ am ] . in the current design , the rdis is modeled as a json subset ( excerpt in figure [ rdisjson ] ) .
the intermediate product is an abstract syntax tree that represents the robot details in a domain specific model .
this intermediate format can be further processed to verify conformance to the specification .
end products are generated from the verified syntax tree , either in a single or multiple passes , using templates that format data based on the model .
the preliminary result of this approach includes rdis specifications and grammars that generate a command line program , websocket server and a ros driver .
the ros driver looks for specific interface signatures in the abstract mapping section that match to ros message structures .
it is important to note that the rdis toolset is enabled by antlr and stringtemplate .
these are open source libraries that parse and process data according to grammars .
these grammars are often used to define domain specific languages that are subsequently processed either by interpreters or translators .
the sample rdis and the translation to a c - based command line controller and a websocket server and a c++ ros node were achieved through the use of grammars and the antlr and stringtemplate libraries .
although these libraries provide many built - in features , the ability to embed code to customize processing is important to using these tools effectively .
this preliminary result supports the idea that general robot devices can be described declaratively in a manner that supports discovery and that links to the backend processes .
the ultimate goal to enable more accessible programming by embedding the robot device descriptions within the device .
discovery occurs when the design environment queries the device for its supported services ( or apis ) .
the initial approach for platforms that support onboard reconfigurable firmware is to augment the firmware to support a single command that communicates the rdis .
the information provided by the rdis can be used by any rdis - enabled development environment .
it is expected that manufacturers will choose to rdis enable their devices once there are more rdis - enabled environments are available .
the rdis must be expanded to be useful in a larger context .
these tasks include but are not limited to : 1 ) addition of a complete kinematic , visual and collision description consistent with existing simulators and frameworks , 2 ) error handling at both the communication and primitive levels , 3 ) implementation of additional threading models , 4 ) refinement of the state concept and how it matches to primitives and interfaces , 5 ) management of sensor and actuator error models consistent with existing frameworks , and 6 ) match internal mechanisms to framework standard interfaces and message types through linking the description and the exposed api instead of relying upon matching external interface signatures .
these changes require updates to the specification and the underlying parsers , lexers , tree grammars and string templates .
the authors gratefully acknowledge the partial support nsf via grants cns-1042360 and eec-1005191 . b p gerkey , r t vaughan , k stoy , a howard , g s sukhatme , m j mataric , most valuable player : a robot device server for distributed control _ proc . of the ieee / rsj intl . conf . on intelligent robots and systems ( iros ) _ , 2001 m. quigley , b. gerkey , k. conley , j. faust , t. foote , j. leibs , e. berger , r. wheeler , and a. ng , `` ros : an open - source robot operating system , '' _ international conference on robotics and automation _ , 2009 .
s. cooper , w. dann , and r. pausch , `` alice : a 3-d tool for introductory programming concepts , '' _ proceedings of the fifth annual ccsc northeastern conference on the journal of computing in small colleges _ ,
107 - 116 .
2000 s.a .
thibault , r.marlet , c.consel , domain - specific languages : from design to implementation application to video device drivers generation , _ ieee transactions on software engineering _ volume : 25 issue : 3 , may / jun 1999 | there is no dearth of new robots that provide both generalized and customized platforms for learning and research .
unfortunately as we attempt to adapt existing software components , we are faced with an explosion of device drivers that interface each hardware platform with existing frameworks .
we certainly gain the efficiencies of reusing algorithms and tools developed across platforms but only once the device driver is created .
we propose a domain specific language that describes the development and runtime interface of a robot and defines its link to existing frameworks .
the robot device interface specification ( rdis ) takes advantage of the internal firmware present on many existing devices by defining the communication mechanism , syntax and semantics in such a way to enable the generation of automatic interface links and resource discovery .
we present the current domain model as it relates to differential drive robots as a mechanism to use the rdis to link described robots to html5 via web sockets and ros ( robot operating system ) . |
the dominant feature in @xmath0 is the first tall , sharp peak at @xmath21 ( fig .
[ fig1 ] ) . precisely at the jamming threshold , @xmath22 , this peak is a @xmath23-function at @xmath24 ; @xmath0 is precisely zero for @xmath25 and has a power - law tail extending to @xmath26 .
the weight under the @xmath23-function is the coordination number at contact , @xmath27 .
( as we discuss below , @xmath27 is a few percent less than the isostatic coordination number , @xmath28 for our @xmath29-dimensional systems @xcite . ) for @xmath30 , there is some overlap between particles so that the delta - function peak broadens and shifts to @xmath31 .
the broadening produces a tail extending to @xmath32 that disappears in the limit where @xmath18 vanishes . by analyzing the height of the first peak and its left - hand width , we showed @xcite that the peak approaches a delta - function as @xmath33 decreases towards zero .
we have since obtained more systems over a wider range of @xmath18 .
figure [ fig2 ] shows the dependence on @xmath18 of the first - peak height @xmath34 and its left - hand width @xmath35 for both harmonic and hertzian potentials .
independent of the interaction potential , we find : @xmath36 these scalings are consistent with the area of the peak approaching a constant in the limit @xmath37 . , ( top panel ) and the left - hand width , @xmath38 , ( bottom panel ) of the nearest - neighbor peak of @xmath0 , over several orders of magnitude of @xmath18 , for monodisperse spheres with purely repulsive ( a ) harmonic spring and ( b ) hertzian interactions.,title="fig:",width=264 ] , ( top panel ) and the left - hand width , @xmath38 , ( bottom panel ) of the nearest - neighbor peak of @xmath0 , over several orders of magnitude of @xmath18 , for monodisperse spheres with purely repulsive ( a ) harmonic spring and ( b ) hertzian interactions.,title="fig:",width=264 ] we turn now to the shape of the first peak in @xmath0 at @xmath25 for a system at @xmath39 , just above the jamming transition .
as shown in fig .
[ fig3](a ) , for the region @xmath25 , @xmath0 is almost strictly exponential with only a small curvature near its peak
. it can be fit with the functional form : @xmath40 ^{-1}\right ) \label{eqn3}\ ] ] where @xmath41 , with @xmath42 and @xmath43 . up to contact , @xmath44 , on a linear-@xmath45 scale , for @xmath46 ( a ) @xmath47 , ( b ) @xmath48 , ( c ) @xmath49 , and ( d ) @xmath17.,title="fig:",width=132 ] up to contact , @xmath44 , on a linear-@xmath45 scale , for @xmath46 ( a ) @xmath47 , ( b ) @xmath48 , ( c ) @xmath49 , and ( d ) @xmath17.,title="fig:",width=132 ] up to contact , @xmath44 , on a linear-@xmath45 scale , for @xmath46 ( a ) @xmath47 , ( b ) @xmath48 , ( c ) @xmath49 , and ( d ) @xmath17.,title="fig:",width=122 ] up to contact , @xmath44 , on a linear-@xmath45 scale , for @xmath46 ( a ) @xmath47 , ( b ) @xmath48 , ( c ) @xmath49 , and ( d ) @xmath17.,title="fig:",width=122 ] as we compress the system above @xmath3 we see that the exponential behavior of the tail at @xmath25 gradually becomes more gaussian as the system is compressed above the transition .
this is shown in fig .
[ fig3]a - d .
we can still use eq .
[ eqn3 ] to fit the shape , however , with different coefficients @xmath50 and @xmath51 . in fig .
[ fig4 ] we show the evolution of @xmath50 and @xmath51 with @xmath18 .
this evolution occurs more rapidly for hertzian ( not shown ) than for harmonic spheres . and
@xmath51 ( top ) and @xmath52 ( bottom ) in eq .
[ eqn3 ] , with @xmath18 , for harmonic repulsions .
the parameters @xmath53 are clearly related to the pressure , while @xmath52 is associated with @xmath54.,width=264 ] the results for @xmath55 have implications for the distribution of inter - particle normal forces , @xmath56 .
this is shown in fig .
[ fig5 ] . at high compressions
, @xmath56 is well - described by a gaussian , but the tail straightens out towards an exponential as @xmath33 is lowered towards zero .
these results are consistent with previous results of makse , et al .
@xcite , who studied sphere packings at fixed pressure .
( as we noted above , constant pressure corresponds to constant @xmath33 . )
the gaussian shape at high @xmath33 is consistent with expectations for equilibrium systems interacting with a harmonic potential @xcite .
however , these systems are at zero temperature , and it is unclear whether they can be described by a nonzero effective temperature .
the exponential behavior at small @xmath33 agrees with experimental and simulation data on static granular packings of hard particles , which necessarily exist at packing fractions near @xmath3 @xcite .
, for the purely repulsive , harmonic potential , at different compressions @xmath33.,width=264 ] there is interesting behavior above the asymmetric first peak in @xmath0 as well as below it .
[ fig6](a ) shows that @xmath57 versus @xmath58 varies as a power - law for a system just above the transition at @xmath59 : @xmath60^{-\eta } \label{eqn4}\ ] ] with @xmath61 .
this result was first reported for gravity - sedimented , granular packings @xcite , but over a much smaller range in @xmath0 than presented here .
we note that there is a very slight knee that occurs near @xmath62 .
the asymptotic power law behavior near @xmath63 should be determined only from the region below this knee . as we will show below
, this knee becomes more pronounced as @xmath33 increases . the number of neighbors , @xmath64 , that are separated by a distance of at most @xmath65 @xcite is given by the integral @xmath66 this is shown in fig . [ fig6](b ) .
therefore , fig .
[ fig6](a ) and eq .
[ eqn4 ] imply , that for a system at the transition , @xmath67 should increase with @xmath65 as @xmath68 where @xmath69 is defined in eq .
[ eqn4 ] and @xmath70 is the average number of neighbors per particle at contact at the transition .
this scaling is consistent with the one reported by ohern _
@xcite , who looked at how the excess coordination number increased as a system was incrementally compressed above @xmath3 .
we note that we have found a similar exponent of @xmath71 using the hertzian interaction potential , @xmath72 , as we found for the harmonic potential , @xmath73 . .
( a ) @xmath57 versus @xmath58 . a power law with exponent of @xmath74 is indicated .
( b ) @xmath64 vs. @xmath75 , computed by numerically integrating @xmath76 .
a power law with exponent of @xmath77 is indicated.,title="fig:",width=264 ] + .
( a ) @xmath57 versus @xmath58 . a power law with exponent of @xmath74
is indicated .
( b ) @xmath64 vs. @xmath75 , computed by numerically integrating @xmath76 .
a power law with exponent of @xmath77 is indicated.,title="fig:",width=264 ] donev et al .
@xcite also calculated the number of neighbors @xmath64 near the transition , but for a system of hard spheres .
when they plotted @xmath78 versus @xmath79 they found that the slope was closer to 0.6 than 0.5 .
they argued that this implies that @xmath80 for hard spheres , which is different from our result for soft repulsive spheres ( eq .
[ eqn6 ] ) . based on this difference
, they concluded that the power - law behavior seen for @xmath81 is not universal and depends on the interparticle potential as well as perhaps the procedure leading to the @xmath82 configuration .
however , that conclusion does not follow from their analysis .
the confusion occurs because their results were for a system in which all the rattlers ( that is , particles without any neighbors ) had been removed .
it is not surprising that this changes the nature of the pair correlation function from a system , such as ours , where _ all _ particles are considered .
that is , we analyze the system directly as produced by energy minimization without performing the additional step of removing particles that do not happen to be part of the backbone of the structure . whether one chooses to remove rattlers or not depends on the physics one wants to study .
here we remark that it is more natural to include rattlers in @xmath0 if one is going to compare to any experiment .
we also note that rattlers can join the backbone when the system is perturbed , and can therefore influence the system s response and stability , as argued in ref .
finally , we claim that the conclusion of donev , et al . that the power - law exponent depends on the potential of interaction or the algorithm for creating the states ( aside from removing one class of particles by hand ) is unfounded .
rather , the difference arises from whether one studies systems with rattlers included or removed .
when donev , et al .
include rattlers in their analysis , they also find an exponent closer to 0.5 @xcite , consistent with what we have found here and in previous work @xcite .
there is a difference between @xmath83 and @xmath27 .
@xmath83 is the number of contacts _ only _ for a system that has all rattlers removed from the system .
if the rattlers are not removed from the system then @xmath84 .
because @xmath0 , for example measured in an experiment , does not distinguish between rattlers and particles belonging to the connected backbone of the structure , one must use @xmath85 in eqs .
[ eqn6 ] . indeed , calculating @xmath64 either directly as in ref .
@xcite , or integrating @xmath0 via eq .
[ eqn5 ] , are identical only when using @xmath86 , and _ not _ @xmath87 in eq .
[ eqn6 ] . if @xmath88 denotes the total number of particles , @xmath89 the number of overlapping pairs , and @xmath90 the total number of rattlers , then @xmath91 while @xmath92 .
although only @xmath93 of the particles are rattlers at the transition , their exclusion can produce a change of the power law exponent .
we find that the observed power - law for @xmath0 depends on @xmath33 ( see fig .
[ fig7](a ) ) . as @xmath33 increases
, the knee in @xmath0 near @xmath94 becomes more prominent . in the region below this knee ( _ i .
e. _ , at smaller @xmath1 ) , the slope of @xmath95 $ ] versus @xmath96 $ ] decreases .
we show this slope , @xmath69 , as a function of @xmath33 in fig .
[ fig7](b ) . as @xmath33 approaches zero
, the value of @xmath69 increases and approaches @xmath97 .
a similar trend was noted in the x - ray tomography experiments of aste et al .
@xcite , who measured @xmath0 inside large , @xmath98 granular packings . note that donev , et al .
@xcite study configurations _ below _ the unjamming transition , and it is not clear if the apparent value of @xmath69 also changes as the density is decreased below @xmath99 .
, just above the first peak for @xmath100 ( @xmath101 ) , @xmath47 ( circle ) , @xmath48 ( squares ) , @xmath102 ( diamonds ) , @xmath49 ( @xmath103 ) . ( a ) @xmath0 vs. @xmath58 , showing the power - law behavior in @xmath104 .
( b ) the exponent @xmath69 characterizing the power - law behavior of ( a ) , as a function of @xmath33 .
( c ) @xmath0 from the nearest - neighbor , first peak at @xmath21 out to the first minimum at @xmath105 as a function of @xmath106.,title="fig:",width=264 ] , just above the first peak for @xmath100 ( @xmath101 ) , @xmath47 ( circle ) , @xmath48 ( squares ) , @xmath102 ( diamonds ) , @xmath49 ( @xmath103 ) .
( a ) @xmath0 vs. @xmath58 , showing the power - law behavior in @xmath104 .
( b ) the exponent @xmath69 characterizing the power - law behavior of ( a ) , as a function of @xmath33 .
( c ) @xmath0 from the nearest - neighbor , first peak at @xmath21 out to the first minimum at @xmath105 as a function of @xmath106.,title="fig:",width=264 ] , just above the first peak for @xmath100 ( @xmath101 ) , @xmath47 ( circle ) , @xmath48 ( squares ) , @xmath102 ( diamonds ) , @xmath49 ( @xmath103 ) .
( a ) @xmath0 vs. @xmath58 , showing the power - law behavior in @xmath104 .
( b ) the exponent @xmath69 characterizing the power - law behavior of ( a ) , as a function of @xmath33 .
( c ) @xmath0 from the nearest - neighbor , first peak at @xmath21 out to the first minimum at @xmath105 as a function of @xmath106.,title="fig:",width=264 ] fig .
[ fig7](c ) shows , for different values of @xmath18 , how @xmath0 behaves in the region from @xmath107 out to the first minimum at @xmath108 .
there are several notable features in @xmath0 in the vicinity of contact that are apparent when @xmath0 versus @xmath109 is plotted on @xmath110 axes .
there is a drop in @xmath0 that occurs at @xmath63 for each value of @xmath33 ( note that this corresponds to different values of @xmath106 for different @xmath33 ) .
the separation @xmath63 distinguishes particles that are overlapping from those which are just out of contact .
the magnitude of the jump decreases , and the extent of the power - law region described by eq .
[ eqn4 ] also decreases , as the system is progressively compressed above the unjamming transition .
the region beyond contact is _ relatively _ unaffected by compression .
( although the power law exponent changes slowly with @xmath18 as highlighted in fig .
[ fig7](b ) , by far the largest change occurs in crossing from @xmath25 to @xmath111 . )
this indicates that as the system is compressed , particles are depleted from the region beyond contact , @xmath111 , and are absorbed into the contact region , @xmath25 . we have determined that this drop in @xmath0 is not an artifact of the zero - temperature system .
we have used several different protocols for creating particle configurations , as shown in fig .
[ fig8 ] and described in its caption .
evidently , the drop in @xmath0 persists to finite temperature .
, from the nearest - neighbor , first peak at @xmath21 out to the first minimum at @xmath105 , at @xmath112 .
different symbols represent different configuration protocols with and without temperature : conjugate gradient minimization to @xmath82 ( open circles ) , quenched molecular dynamics at @xmath82 ( open squares ) , molecular dynamics at a very low temperature ( solid diamonds ) , molecular dynamics at a higher temperature ( + ) .
the jump in @xmath0 persists to small but nonzero temperature , and is smoothed out at high enough temperatures.,width=264 ] why should there be an abrupt drop in @xmath0 at @xmath63 ?
one possibility is that , to a first approximation , compression only changes the nearest - neighbor spacing of particles that are already in contact , that is , within a distance @xmath25 of each other .
particles separated by a distance @xmath111 may not be moved appreciably closer to one another by compression .
instead , we suggest that upon compression , the movement of particles that are not yet overlapping is predominantly in a direction perpendicular to the line connecting them . this is consistent with our data . as the system is compressed and particles are incorporated into the contact region , the number of overlapping pairs increases .
as mentioned above , the average number of overlapping neighbors per particle , @xmath67 , increases with compression as @xmath113 .
as this occurs , the distribution of @xmath67 values , @xmath114 , also shifts .
this is shown in fig .
close to the transition , most particles have 6 overlapping neighbors . as the system is compressed to @xmath115 , the maximum shifts to @xmath116 but
there is still no observable weight at @xmath117 . , at several different compressions .
key same as fig .
[ fig5].,width=264 ]
the approach of the unjamming point is also apparent in features associated with the second peak in @xmath0 .
figure [ fig10 ] shows this region of @xmath0 for several values of @xmath18 . for the system closest to jamming , at @xmath39 , ( fig .
[ fig10](a ) ) there is a pronounced splitting of the second peak in @xmath0 into two sub - peaks , located at @xmath118 and @xmath119 .
such a splitting of the second peak has long been known @xcite .
indeed , the emergence of a split second peak was one of the early criteria used to signal the onset of the glass phase in supercooled liquids @xcite .
region around the split second peak for @xmath120 ( a ) @xmath47 , ( b ) @xmath102 , and ( c ) @xmath17.,width=302 ] on the small-@xmath1 side of both of these sub - peaks we find that @xmath0 increases rapidly . in fig .
[ fig11 ] , we have attempted to characterize these features for the system closest to the transition . in that figure we plot @xmath0 versus @xmath121 and @xmath122 .
we have not been able to tell whether @xmath0 itself diverges or whether the divergence appears only in its slope , @xmath123 .
we would need to average over many more systems to tell these two possibilities apart unambiguously .
our best fits to the two possible cases are : @xmath124 and @xmath125 where the fit parameters are provided in table [ table1 ] .
.fit parameters for the two sub - peaks , situated at @xmath118 and @xmath119 , respectively , that make up the split second peak in @xmath0 . for @xmath126 .
[ cols="^,^",options="header " , ] [ table1 ] for @xmath127 .
left - hand sub - peak at @xmath118 .
right - hand sub - peak at @xmath119 .
the solid line corresponds to a power - law fit , the dashed line to a logarithmic fit , and the grey line to a shifted power - law fit.,title="fig:",width=151 ] for @xmath127 .
left - hand sub - peak at @xmath118 .
right - hand sub - peak at @xmath119 .
the solid line corresponds to a power - law fit , the dashed line to a logarithmic fit , and the grey line to a shifted power - law fit.,title="fig:",width=151 ] on the high-@xmath1 side of each sub - peak , it is clear from fig .
[ fig10](a ) that there is both a step - function drop - off @xcite and an additional smooth decrease of @xmath0 with increasing @xmath1 .
although , from these data , we can not unambiguously determine a functional form for this last smooth decrease , the data suggest that it might be fit with @xmath128 where @xmath129 and @xmath130 and @xmath131 for the first and second sub - peaks , respectively .
as the system is compressed above the transition , the structure around both sub - peaks becomes rounded .
in particular , it is only in the limit of @xmath37 that the drop - off becomes a sharp step - function . here , we suggest a simple interpretation of the origin of the step - function drop - off in @xmath0 on the high-@xmath1 side of both sub - peaks . at the jamming transition
, each particle must be held in place by particles that are just in contact with no overlap . at that point
there is an average of precisely @xmath132 neighbors per particle in the force network .
it seems plausible that the second - nearest - neighbor peaks originate from pairs of particles that have at least one neighbor in common , while pairs that do not have a common neighbor contribute only to a slowly - varying background .
the separation @xmath119 corresponds to two particles on diametrically opposite sides of a common neighbor ( fig .
[ fig12 ] , right figure ) .
this is the largest distance that can separate two particles that have _ one _ common neighbor .
the separation @xmath133 corresponds to the largest possible separation between two particles , @xmath134 and @xmath135 , that have _ two _ common neighbors ( fig .
[ fig12 ] , left figure ) . in this case the four particles lie in the same plane ; the two common neighbors touch and the particles @xmath134 and @xmath135 are on opposite sides of the crease between them .
when @xmath1 is only slightly greater than @xmath131 , there can no longer be any contribution from two particles that share a common neighbor .
similarly , when @xmath1 is only slightly greater than @xmath136 , there can be no contribution from pairs of particles that share two common neighbors .
this leads to step - function drop - offs at @xmath118 and @xmath119 . .
right : the particles at the left and the right share one common neighbor and are separated by @xmath119.,title="fig:",width=151 ] .
right : the particles at the left and the right share one common neighbor and are separated by @xmath119.,title="fig:",width=151 ] support for the hypothesis that the drop - offs are due to pairs of particles that share common neighbors can be obtained from the angular correlations between two neighbors of a common particle .
we show this angular correlation , @xmath137 , in fig .
[ fig13 ] , where @xmath138 is defined in the sketch in the inset . at @xmath139 ( which corresponds to particles separated by @xmath119 ) fig .
[ fig13](d ) shows that the distribution goes to zero as , @xmath140 if the sub - peak at @xmath119 arises from pairs that share one common neighbor , then the form of @xmath0 just below @xmath119 should be related to the form of @xmath137 just below @xmath141 by @xmath142 where the jacobian factor diverges as @xmath143 thus , eq . [ eqn15 ] implies @xmath144 this is in reasonable agreement with the fit in eq .
[ eqn10 ] , where we found @xmath145 , implying that the second sub - peak does indeed arise from two particles that share a common neighbor and that this leads to the observed step - function drop - off just above @xmath119 .
however , we should note that this argument does not necessarily imply that @xmath0 diverges at @xmath119 , as indicated by eq .
[ eqn17 ] , since we can not determine the behavior of @xmath137 asymptotically close to @xmath146 with sufficient accuracy . by a similar argument ,
if the first sub - peak arises from pairs of particles that share two common neighbors , then the peak at @xmath118 corresponds to @xmath147 . for @xmath148 ,
we find @xmath149 this behavior implies @xmath150 ; this result is not too different from the fit in eq . 7 , which suggests @xmath151 .
this consistency check suggests that the first sub - peak does indeed arise from pairs of particles that share two common neighbors .
, versus @xmath152 for @xmath126 .
bottom four panels are fits to the regions around ; ( b ) @xmath153 , ( c ) @xmath154-left , ( d ) @xmath154-right , ( e ) @xmath155 .
the power law exponents are @xmath156 0.5 , 0.17 , 0.17 , and 0.75 , respectively , title="fig:",width=302 ] + , versus @xmath152 for @xmath126 .
bottom four panels are fits to the regions around ; ( b ) @xmath153 , ( c ) @xmath154-left , ( d ) @xmath154-right , ( e ) @xmath155 .
the power law exponents are @xmath156 0.5 , 0.17 , 0.17 , and 0.75 , respectively , title="fig:",width=132 ] , versus @xmath152 for @xmath126 .
bottom four panels are fits to the regions around ; ( b ) @xmath153 , ( c ) @xmath154-left , ( d ) @xmath154-right , ( e ) @xmath155 .
the power law exponents are @xmath156 0.5 , 0.17 , 0.17 , and 0.75 , respectively , title="fig:",width=132 ] , versus @xmath152 for @xmath126 .
bottom four panels are fits to the regions around ; ( b ) @xmath153 , ( c ) @xmath154-left , ( d ) @xmath154-right , ( e ) @xmath155 . the power law exponents are @xmath156 0.5 , 0.17 , 0.17 , and 0.75 , respectively , title="fig:",width=132 ] , versus @xmath152 for @xmath126 .
bottom four panels are fits to the regions around ; ( b ) @xmath153 , ( c ) @xmath154-left , ( d ) @xmath154-right , ( e ) @xmath155 .
the power law exponents are @xmath156 0.5 , 0.17 , 0.17 , and 0.75 , respectively , title="fig:",width=132 ] although pairs with two common neighbors can not contribute to @xmath0 for @xmath157 , pairs with only one common neighbor can still contribute .
such pairs may account for the smooth decrease in @xmath0 ( see eq . [ eqn13 ] ) just above @xmath118 .
we have shown that the unjamming transition is accompanied by several features in the pair correlation function : * a delta - function at @xmath63 with area @xmath158 . * a power - law at @xmath111 of the form @xmath159 . * a sub - peak at @xmath118 that either diverges or has diverging slope as @xmath160 and that has a step - function drop - off just above @xmath118 . * a sub - peak at @xmath119 that either diverges or has diverging slope as @xmath161 and that has a step - function drop - off just above @xmath119 . here , we suggest that some of these structural features are reflected in a less extreme form in the two primary empirical criteria that have been used extensively in the literature to identify the glass transition . the first is the ratio , @xmath162 , of the first minimum to the first maximum in @xmath0 . as the temperature @xmath163 of a glass - forming liquid decreases , @xmath164 decreases .
wendt and abraham @xcite proposed that @xmath165 corresponds to a reasonable estimate of the glass transition temperature , @xmath166 .
we note that at the unjamming transition we have studied here , @xmath167 .
it is possible that the decrease in @xmath164 observed as @xmath163 is lowered towards @xmath166 is a remnant of the vanishing of @xmath164 that occurs at the unjamming transition
. the latter property may be the underlying reason for the success of this empirical criterion .
a second popular empirical criterion concerns the second peak of @xmath0 . as @xmath163 is lowered towards @xmath168 , the second peak splits into two sub - peaks .
the flattening of the second peak that signals its splitting has been used to identify @xmath166 @xcite .
we suggest that the splitting may reflect the singular sub - peaks that occur at jamming / unjamming transition .
the singular nature of the splitting at this transition may provide the fundamental underpinnings of this criterion .
we thank bulbul chakraborty and corey ohern for instructive discussions and salvatore torquato for comments on our manuscript .
we also gratefully acknowledge the support of nsf - dmr-0087349 ( ajl ) , nsf - dmr-0352777 ( srn ) , de - fg02 - 03er46087 ajl , les ) , and de - fg02 - 03er46088 ( srn , les ) . | we study the pair correlation function @xmath0 for zero - temperature , disordered , soft - sphere packings just above the onset of jamming . we find distinct signatures of the transition in both the first and split second peaks of this function .
as the transition is approached from the jammed side ( at higher packing fraction ) the first peak diverges and narrows on the small-@xmath1 side to a delta - function . on the high-@xmath1 side of this peak
, @xmath0 decays as a power - law . in the split
second peak , the two subpeaks are both singular at the transition , with power - law behavior on their low-@xmath1 sides and step - function drop - offs on their high-@xmath1 sides .
these singularities at the transition are reminiscent of empirical criteria that have previously been used to distinguish glassy structures from liquid ones .
it is only natural to suspect that the dramatic dynamical arrest that occurs as a liquid is cooled into a glass must be accompanied by a signature in the underlying atomic arrangements .
however , the atomic configurations in the liquid and glass are strikingly similar to one another . over the years
, the challenge to identify a subtle structural difference between the two states has led to the proposal of several empirical criteria @xcite . in this paper
, we revisit an old idea , due to bernal @xcite , of using static sphere packings to gain insight into the structure of amorphous systems @xcite .
we find that , with decreasing density , the structure of such packings changes distinctly as they unjam .
it is particularly revealing to study static packings of spheres interacting via a finite - ranged , purely - repulsive potential .
there is a fundamental change in the mechanical properties in such systems , reminiscent of the glass transition @xcite , as the packing fraction @xmath2 is varied across a well - defined unjamming / jamming transition at @xmath3 , which was found to coincide with the value of random close packing @xmath4 @xcite . above @xmath3
the system has nonzero static shear and bulk moduli , while below @xmath3 it costs no energy to shear or compress the system by an infinitesimal amount .
moreover , the unjamming transition in many ways resembles a critical point @xcite , with many quantities , including a diverging length scale , behaving as power - laws as the transition is approached from higher density .
here we show that the unjamming transition exhibits clearly identifiable structural signatures associated with diverging quantities , even though both the jammed and the unjammed states are disordered .
these structural characteristics are echoed in some of the empirical criteria @xcite that have previously been proposed for the glass transition .
the simulations reported here are for monodisperse , soft spheres of diameter @xmath5 that interact through the potential @xmath6 , for @xmath7 , and @xmath8 when @xmath9 . here
, @xmath1 is the center - to - center separation between two particles , measured in units of @xmath5 .
we have studied both the harmonic , @xmath10 , and the hertzian , @xmath11 , cases .
particles are defined to be in contact if they overlap .
our three - dimensional systems consist of @xmath12 spheres in periodic , cubic , simulation cells . to enable a systematic study of the approach to the unjamming transition
, we employ conjugate - gradient energy minimization @xcite to obtain @xmath13 configurations at various packing fractions @xmath2 .
we average over ensembles of configurations at the same distance from the transition point , _ i.e. , _ at the same values of @xmath14 , which is equivalent to averaging over systems with the same pressure @xcite .
structural signatures of jamming are more evident @xcite in the pair correlation function , @xmath0 , than in the structure factor , @xmath15 , even though the two functions are simply related by a fourier transform .
we therefore focus on the structural characteristics that signal the approach of the zero - temperature transition from the jammed side , through a detailed analysis of @xmath0 computed with extraordinary resolution .
in particular , we study two features of @xmath0 that undergo dramatic changes at the unjamming transition : the first peak and the split second peak ( _ i .
e. _ , the two subpeaks that merge with increasing temperature to become the second peak in a typical dense liquid ) . a plot of @xmath0 is shown in fig . [ fig1 ] above the jamming transition . vs. @xmath1 at two extreme values of @xmath16 ( dotted line ) and @xmath17 ( solid line ) .
the maximum value of the first peak height is higher and its width narrower for the lower value of @xmath18 . for @xmath19 ,
the first peak maximum is approximately @xmath20 , far beyond the scale of the graph.,width=264 ] |
wetting phenomena occur in a large variety of experiments , where a planar substrate is exposed to a gas phase under thermal equilibrium conditions .
generally , ` wetting ' refers to a situation where a bulk phase @xmath1 in contact with a substrate coexists with a layer of a different phase ( @xmath2 ) which is preferentially attracted to the surface of the substrate . by changing physical parameters such as temperature and chemical potential , the system may undergo a wetting transition from a non - wet phase , where the thickness of the layer stays finite , to a wet phase , where the layer becomes macroscopic .
the phase diagram associated with the surface layer could be rather complex exhibiting a variety of surface phase transitions , prewetting phenomena and multicritical behavior @xcite .
for example , by increasing the temperature @xmath3 while moving along the @xmath4-@xmath2 coexistence curve , a wetting transition may take place at a temperature @xmath5 , beyond which the thickness of the layer becomes infinite .
usually this transition is first order , although in certain models the transition is continuous , and is then referred to as continuous wetting . on the other hand , when the chemical potential difference between the two phases is varied , moving towards the coexistence curve at @xmath6 , a different type of transition takes place in which the thickness of the layer diverges .
this phenomenon is known as complete wetting . in many experimental situations
it is reasonable to assume that a wetting stationary layer is in thermal equilibrium .
in fact , methods of equilibrium statistical mechanics turned out to be very successful in a large variety of theoretical and experimental studies ( for a review , see ref .
@xcite ) . within this approach ,
a wetting transition is usually considered as the unbinding of an interface from a wall .
the interface configuration is described by a function @xmath7 which gives the height of the interface at point @xmath8 on the substrate .
one then introduces an effective hamiltonian of the form @xcite @xmath9 \,,\ ] ] where @xmath10 is the effective surface tension of the @xmath4-@xmath2 interface , @xmath11 is a potential accounting for the interaction between the wall and the interface , and @xmath12 is the interface dimension . in the non - wet phase the potential @xmath13 contains an attractive component which binds the interface to the wall .
assuming thermal equilibrium , the probability of finding the interface in a certain configuration is then given by the canonical distribution @xmath14
\sim \exp\bigl(-\beta { \cal h}[h]\bigr).\ ] ]
as the parameters describing the system are varied , the attractive component of the potential may become weaker so that it is no longer able to bind the interface , leading to a wetting transition . in order to study wetting phenomena under thermal equilibrium conditions
one usually introduces a stochastic langevin equation corresponding to the effective hamiltonian ( [ hamiltonian ] ) .
this langevin dynamics should reproduce the equilibrium distribution ( [ equilibriumensemble ] ) in the limit @xmath15 .
since many different dynamical rules may approach the same stationary state , this condition does not fully determine the form of the langevin equation .
however , assuming short - range interactions and keeping only the most relevant terms in the renormalization group sense , one is led to the edwards - wilkinson equation with a potential @xcite @xmath16 where @xmath17 is a zero - average gaussian noise field with a variance @xmath18 and a noise amplitude @xmath19 .
this langevin equation has the same symmetry properties as the hamiltonian ( [ hamiltonian ] ) , namely , it is invariant under translations , rotations , and reflections in space .
apart from the potential term , the equation is also invariant under shifts @xmath20 and reflections @xmath21 .
moreover , it can be shown that this type of langevin dynamics obeys _ detailed balance _ and relaxes towards the equilibrium distribution ( [ equilibriumensemble ] ) in the bound phase .
wetting phenomena may also take place in many systems under non - equilibrium conditions .
for example , in growth processes such as molecular beam epitaxy or others , a layer is grown on a substrate , whose properties depend on the growth conditions . by varying these conditions
one expects wetting phenomena to take place . here ,
unlike the equilibrium case , the dynamics does not obey detailed balance , leading to a rather different class of wetting phenomena .
the simplest way to study nonequilibrium wetting on the level of the langevin equation is to introduce a nonlinear term in eq .
( [ ew ] ) , leading to a kardar - parisi - zhang ( kpz ) equation with a potential @xcite @xmath22 it is important to note that this nonlinear term is a relevant perturbation of the underlying field theory , i.e. , even if @xmath23 is very small , it will be amplified under renormalization group transformations , driving the system away from thermal equilibrium .
recently , a simple solid - on - solid ( sos ) model for non - equilibrium wetting in @xmath0 dimensions was introduced @xcite .
the model is controlled by an adsorption rate @xmath24 and a desorption rate @xmath25 and exhibits a continuous wetting transition at a critical growth rate @xmath26 .
the wetting transition is related to the unpinning process of an interface from a substrate and may be described by the kpz equation ( [ langevinequation ] ) .
the model has then been generalized to include a short - range interaction between the interface and the substrate @xcite .
this was done by introducing a modified growth rate @xmath27 at the substrate level .
this results in a contact interaction between the interface and the substrate , which is attractive for @xmath28 and repulsive for @xmath29 .
it was found that sufficiently strong attractive interaction modifies the nature of the wetting transition , making it first order .
in addition , it has been demonstrated that there exists an extended region in the phase diagram , where the pinned and the moving phases _ coexist _ in the sense that the transition time from the pinned to the moving phase grows exponentially with the system size so that the two phases become stable in the thermodynamic limit .
it should be emphasized that this kind of phase coexistence , which has also been observed in the past in other models @xcite , can only occur in nonequilibrium systems . some of these results have been confirmed by numerical and mean field studies of kpz type models @xcite .
in particular , by adding a repulsive interaction between the interface and the substrate , a crossover from a continuous to a first order wetting transition was found .
non - equilibrium wetting phenomena have also been studied recently in models of growing magnetic domains @xcite . in this paper
we present a detailed account of the phase diagram of the sos model in 1 + 1 dimensions . in order to get some indication on the behavior of the model in higher dimensions
we introduce a mean field approximation for the model , and study the resulting phase diagram and the dynamical behavior of the interface .
it is found that the mean field approximation reproduces the main qualitative features of the phase diagram obtained in 1 + 1 dimensions .
in addition , a new feature is found in the pinned phase . by studying the height distribution of the pinned interface
, two distinct types of behavior are discovered upon varying the dynamical parameters of the model : in one regime the distribution decays superexponentially with the height , while in the other the decay is exponential .
the two regimes are separated by a prewetting transition line .
relevance of this phase diagram to wetting phenomena in dimensions higher than @xmath0 is considered .
the paper is organized as follows . in sec .
[ definitionsection ] we recall the definition of the sos model and summarize its properties .
the special case @xmath30 , where the model is exactly soluble , is discussed in detail in sec .
[ secdetailedbalance ] .
the mean field approximation , which is the main focus of the present work , is presented and analyzed in sec .
[ mfsection ] .
the paper ends with concluding remarks in sec .
[ secconcl ] .
deposition and evaporation processes in the bulk . at the hard - core wall at zero height ( not shown here ) evaporation is forbidden and the deposition rate @xmath24 is replaced by a modified deposition rate @xmath27 in order to take the interaction between substrate and surface layer into account .
, width=340 ] the sos model defined in @xcite is probably the simplest model which follows the spirit of eq .
( [ langevinequation ] ) .
it is defined on a one - dimensional lattice with @xmath31 sites and periodic boundary conditions , where each site @xmath32 is associated with an integer variable @xmath33 describing the local height of the interface .
the repulsive part of the potential @xmath11 is implemented as a hard - core wall at zero height , restricting the heights @xmath33 to be non - negative .
thus @xmath34 .
moreover , an effective surface tension is introduced by imposing the restricted solid - on - solid ( rsos ) condition @xmath35 ) : * deposition of an atom on the substrate with rate @xmath27 : @xmath36 * deposition of an atom on top of already deposited islands with rate @xmath24 : @xmath37 * evaporation of an atom at the edge of a terrace with rate @xmath38 : @xmath39 * evaporation of an atom in the middle of a plateau with rate @xmath25 : @xmath40 if the selected process would violate the restrictions @xmath41 or @xmath42 , the attempted move is abandoned and a new site @xmath32 is selected .
each attempted update corresponds to a time increment @xmath43 .
since one of the four rates can be chosen freely by rescaling time , we set @xmath44 . thus the model is controlled by three parameters , namely , a growth rate @xmath24 , a desorption rate @xmath25 , and a special growth rate @xmath27 at the substrate which accounts for an additional short - range interaction between the substrate and the wetting layer .
the model can be easily generalized to higher dimensions .
note that in this case it is possible to introduce different evaporation rates for various types of edge sites , e.g. linear edges and corner sites .
for simplicity we will assume that all rates for evaporation at edges are equal to @xmath45 .
in this case the model can simply be generalized to higher dimensions by including all nearest neighbors in eqs .
( [ process2 ] ) and ( [ process3 ] ) .
let us first consider the case without interactions between substrate and wetting layer , i.e. , @xmath46 . in this case
the presence of a hard - core wall at zero height leads to a _ continuous _ phase transition between a bound and a moving phase ( see fig . [ figphasetrans ] ) .
the phase transition line @xmath26 is determined by a vanishing propagation velocity of a freely evolving interface .
for @xmath47 the interface moves downward until it fluctuates close to the wall while for @xmath48 the propagation velocity is positive and the interface detaches from the wall .
obviously this transition takes place even in finite systems with a critical threshold depending on @xmath31 .
we note that for @xmath49 , where evaporation from the middle of plateaus is forbidden , the interface velocity in the bulk can not be negative so that in this case the transition relies on a different mechanism @xcite .
phase diagram of the wetting model for @xmath46 .
the second - order wetting transition is represented as a solid line .
the dashed line indicates where the coefficient @xmath23 of the nonlinear term in the kpz equation effectively vanishes . for @xmath30
the dynamical rules obey detailed balance ( see text ) .
, width=302 ] example of a closed cycle of deposition and evaporation processes , showing that detailed balance can only be established if @xmath30 .
, width=340 ] one can easily verify that the dynamical rules ( [ process0])-([process3 ] ) do not generally satisfy detailed balance .
to this end we consider the closed cycle of deposition and evaporation processes , as shown in fig .
[ figdb ] .
let the statistical weights of these configurations in the steady state be @xmath50 , and @xmath51 .
obviously detailed balance implies @xmath52 these equations can only be satisfied if @xmath30 ( as already anticipated , @xmath38 is assumed to be equal to 1 without any loss of generality ) .
this special case will be discussed in more detail in sec .
[ secdetailedbalance ] . the two parameters @xmath25 and @xmath24 can be used to control @xmath53 and @xmath23 in the kpz equation ( [ langevinequation ] ) . in the case of detailed balance , where a bound interface is thermally equilibrated
, the coefficient @xmath23 is expected to vanish .
this can be verified by comparing the propagation velocities of a horizontal and an artificially tilted interface far away from the wall .
the line , where both velocities coincide , is shown as a dashed line in fig .
[ figphasetrans ] .
as expected , it crosses the phase transition line exactly at the point @xmath54 , where detailed balance is satisfied .
moving away from this point , we can therefore study the crossover from equilibrium to non - equilibrium wetting .
numerical simulations suggested that the transitions for @xmath55 and @xmath56 are associated with different sets of critical exponents @xcite .
these findings are in accordance with results obtained by munz and hwa @xcite , who showed that the scaling properties of a kpz interface interacting with a wall depend on the sign of @xmath23 .
phase coexistence region in the phase diagram for small values of @xmath27 . , width=302 ] in most experimental applications the wetting layer interacts with the substrate , giving rise to an additional short - range force at the bottom layer which may be either attractive or repulsive . in the present model
such a force can be taken into account by introducing a different growth rate @xmath27 for deposition at zero height .
the influence of this parameter was studied in detail in ref .
since @xmath27 does not influence the propagation velocity of the interface far away from the wall , the location of the transition line , along which the moving phase is stable , remains unchanged .
however , if @xmath27 is smaller than a certain threshold @xmath58 , the attractive interaction is so strong as to stabilize the bound phase even when the free interface would grow . in other words , for very low values of @xmath27
, there exists an extended region in the phase diagram where the bound and the moving phase _ coexist _ in the sense that the transition time from the bound to the moving phase grows exponentially with the systems size .
the upper boundary of the coexistence region depends on @xmath27 , as shown in fig .
[ figcoex ] . a thermodynamically stable coexistence of the bound and the moving phase requires a robust mechanism which eliminates large protruding islands in the bound phase .
in the present model this mechanism works as follows .
once an island has been formed by fluctuations , the detached part of the interface quickly grows since @xmath48 . in the phase coexistence region , where the coefficient @xmath23 in the kpz equation is negative
, the island will grow until the slope at the edges exceeds a critical value , where the growth is compensated by the nonlinear term .
afterwards , the pyramidial island shrinks linearly with time until it is eliminated .
therefore , phase coexistence can only occur under non - equilibrium conditions in those regions of the phase diagram where @xmath23 is negative .
very recently , the tricritical point and the critical behavior at the upper boundary of the phase coexistence region has been investigated in a discretized kpz equation with a potential @xcite .
we first consider the special case @xmath30 , where detailed balance is satisfied . in this case the stationary probability distribution of the bound interface configurations @xmath59 is given by the canonical ensemble expression corresponding to an energy functional @xmath60 @xmath61 \ .\ ] ] the partition sum @xmath62\ ] ] runs over all interface configurations obeying the rsos constraint ( [ rsos ] ) . the energy @xmath60 is given by @xmath63 where @xmath11 is a potential of the form @xmath64 as sketched in fig . [ figpotential ] .
therefore , eq .
( [ equilibriumdistribution ] ) may be rewritten as schematic drawing of @xmath11 with a potential well at zero height .
, width=264 ] @xmath65 note that in this expression @xmath66 plays the role of the chemical potential difference @xmath67 between the wetting layer and the gas phase .
obviously the transition takes place at @xmath68 . to verify the validity of this probability distribution , it is sufficient to demonstrate that the dynamical rules obey detailed balance with respect to it .
in fact , the deposition process ( [ process1 ] ) reduces the probability @xmath69 by a factor of @xmath24 while the evaporation processes ( [ process2 ] ) and ( [ process3 ] ) , which both take place with the same rate , increase @xmath69 by a factor of @xmath70 . consequently , the probability currents between pairs of configurations compensate each other so that detailed balance is satisfied , proving the validity of the equilibrium ensemble ( [ equilibriumdistribution2 ] ) .
similarly one can show that detailed balance is also satisfied at the bottom layer .
we note that these considerations are only valid in the bound phase @xmath71 , where the probability distribution is stationary .
once the system enters the moving phase , the process is out of equilibrium .
the canonical ensemble can be used to compute the density profile of a bound interface in the case of detailed balance . to this end
we use a transfer matrix formalism introduced in @xcite , writing the boltzmann factor @xmath72 in eqs .
( [ equilibriumdistribution ] ) and ( [ equilibriumdistribution2 ] ) as a product @xmath73 where @xmath74 and @xmath75 the transfer matrix @xmath3 is infinite - dimensional , acts in spatial direction , and yields the contribution to the boltzmann factor between adjacent sites with the heights @xmath76 and @xmath77 . because of the rsos condition ( [ rsos ] ) , it has a tridiagonal structure and reads @xmath78 using the transfer matrix formalism , the stationary density @xmath79 of sites at height @xmath76 can be expressed as @xmath80 where @xmath81 , @xmath82 denote canonical basis vectors in height space . for @xmath83
this expression is governed by the largest eigenvalue @xmath84 of the transfer matrix @xmath85 where @xmath86 denotes the corresponding eigenvector .
thus , in an infinite system , the stationary densities may also be written as @xmath87 note that the numerator in this expression is quadratic in @xmath86 , just as in a quantum - mechanical problem . in order to understand how the interface detaches from the wall ,
it is useful to study the scaling behavior of the density of sites at the bottom layer close to the transition point .
let us first consider the case @xmath46 , where interactions between substrate and bottom layer are absent . for @xmath88
the eigenvalue problem reads @xmath89 where @xmath84 is the largest eigenvalue of @xmath3 and @xmath90 are the components of the corresponding eigenvector @xmath86 representing the stationary state .
close to criticality we can carry out the continuum limit @xmath91 , replacing discrete heights @xmath76 by real - valued heights @xmath92 . in this limit
the above eigenvalue problem turns into a differential equation which , to leading order in @xmath93 , is given by @xmath94 this differential equation is solved by an airy function @xmath95 since @xmath96 has to vanish for @xmath97 , we obtain the eigenvalue @xmath98 so that @xmath99^{1/3}\tilde{h})$ ] . therefore , the heights , in particular the average height and the interface width , scale as @xmath100 next , we determine the density of exposed sites at the substrate @xmath101 . in the continuum limit of eq .
( [ stationarydens ] ) @xmath102 is proportional to @xmath103 , hence @xmath104 ^ 2\,,\ ] ] where @xmath105 is a normalization factor .
since @xmath106 and @xmath107 one obtains a linear scaling law @xmath108 thus the density of exposed sites at the bottom layer scales _ linearly _ with the distance from criticality , proving that the wetting transition at @xmath109 is continuous . 1 + 1-dimensional interface with island sizes @xmath110 .
, width=226 ] imposing fixed boundary conditions @xmath111 , it is also possible to study finite - size scaling at the critical point @xmath112 .
at criticality the transfer matrix has a simple structure and can be thought of as generating a simple random walk near a wall so that the mean height and the bottom layer density scale as @xmath113 the transfer matrix does not provide any information regarding dynamical properties .
numerical simulations ( whose details are not shown here ) suggest that an initially flat interface at zero height roughens with time ( for @xmath114 ) as @xmath115 assuming standard power law scaling , we can combine eqs .
( [ hscaling ] ) , ( [ linearrho ] ) , ( [ fsscaling ] ) , and ( [ timescaling ] ) in the scaling forms @xmath116 where @xmath117 and @xmath118 are scaling functions with an appropriate asymptotic behavior . as expected these scaling forms are consistent with the critical exponents @xmath119 of the edwards - wilkinson universality class @xcite .
another interesting aspect is the stationary distribution @xmath120 of island sizes @xmath121 in the bound phase ( see fig .
[ figislands ] ) . in the case of detailed balance
this distribution can be computed exactly . to this end
we introduce the projection operator @xmath122 which projects onto states with nonzero height .
moreover , let @xmath123 be a transfer matrix describing an interface that does not touch the bottom layer . obviously the distribution @xmath120 , which may be interpreted as a first - return probability of the interface to the bottom layer , is given by @xmath124 note that the leftmost column and the topmost row of the restricted transfer matrix @xmath125 are zero , while all other matrix elements are the same as in eq .
( [ tmatrix ] ) .
because of this simple structure , the spectrum of @xmath125 is just the spectrum of @xmath3 multiplied by @xmath24 combined with a zero mode so that the largest eigenvalue of @xmath125 , which dominates the matrix product in eq .
( [ basereturnprob ] ) , is @xmath126 . in the limit @xmath127
we therefore obtain an exponential distribution of the form @xmath128 therefore , the average island size scales as @xmath129 and diverges at the transition .
since @xmath130 , this result is in agreement with eq .
( [ linearrho ] ) . in order to determine the stationary interface profile @xmath79 in the limit @xmath131 ,
let us go back to eq .
( [ eigevequation ] ) . by assuming that the second and the third term on the left hand side can be neglected
, one finds that @xmath132 with the corresponding asymptotic solution @xmath133 therefore , in the case of detailed balance , the profile of a bound interface decays as a gaussian for large values of @xmath76 . even for @xmath134 , where detailed balance is violated , numerical simulations ( see fig .
[ figgaussian ] ) suggest that in 1 + 1 dimensions the entire bound phase is characterized by gaussian density profiles .
numerically determined stationary interface profile of the full model in 1 + 1 ( lower data points ) and 2 + 1 dimensions ( upper data points ) for different values of @xmath25 slightly below the critical threshold .
the bold lines indicate the slopes @xmath135 and @xmath136 , respectively .
, width=302 ] let us now consider the influence of an attractive force between substrate and wetting layer by taking @xmath28 .
obviously , the interface is bound to the wall for @xmath71 , while for @xmath137 it will tunnel through the potential barrier .
this means that the critical point @xmath68 remains unchanged .
however , if @xmath27 is decreased below a certain threshold @xmath58 , the attraction is sufficiently strong such that the transition becomes first order . to demonstrate the crossover to a discontinuous transition in the case of detailed balance
, we look for a localized pinned interface solution at the transition point @xmath138 .
assuming an exponential interface profile @xmath139 with some @xmath140 , the eigenvalue problem then reduces to three independent equations @xmath141 which have the ( unnormalized non - negative ) solution @xmath142 consequently , the stationary density of exposed sites at the bottom layer is @xmath143 while the densities at higher levels are given by @xmath144 it turns out that the bottom layer density @xmath101 is positive for @xmath145 and vanishes at @xmath146 . for @xmath147 , however , one has @xmath148 , so that the exponential ansatz @xmath149 is no longer physically meaningful . hence ,
in the case of detailed balance , the transition becomes first order at the tricritical point @xmath150 for @xmath151 , the potential well is deep enough to bind the critical interface to the wall , leading to an exponentially decaying interface profile . for @xmath152 , such a localized solution does not exist and the transition becomes continuous .
phase diagram for @xmath30 in the @xmath153-plane .
, width=302 ] the phase diagram for @xmath30 is shown in fig . [ figqq ] .
using the transfer matrix approach , we can show that the critical behavior along the second order transition line is always the same as the one discussed in sec .
[ secondorderscaling ] .
however , in the vicinity of the tricritical point the scaling properties are different . moreover , they depend on the direction from which the tricritical point is approached .
let us first consider the case @xmath138 , approaching the tricritical point horizontally from the left along the first - order phase transition line . using the expressions ( [ rho0 ] ) and ( [ rhoh ] ) one can compute the interface height @xmath154 and the squared interface width @xmath155 approaching the tricritical point from the left by increasing @xmath27 , these quantities scale to lowest order in @xmath156 as @xmath157 & \rho(0 ) = 4\delta \end{split}\ ] ] on the other hand , if the tricritical point is approached vertically keeping @xmath158 fixed , a numerical diagonalization of the transfer matrix suggests that the asymptotic interface profile crosses over from an exponential to a gaussian decay . in this case
the height , the width , and the bottom layer density are found to scale as @xmath159 where @xmath160 .
moreover , by keeping the boundary sites fixed at zero height , we can study finite - size scaling at the tricritical point .
evaluating products of the transfer matrix numerically we find that @xmath161 decay of the density of sites at zero height at the tricritical point @xmath162 , @xmath146 .
the slope of the curve tends to @xmath163 , leading to the conjecture that @xmath164 . , width=302 ] finally , numerical monte carlo simulations at the tricritical point ( see fig . [ figtc ] ) suggest that an initially flat interface roughens in such a way that @xmath165 assuming standard power law scaling all these results can be combined in the scaling forms @xmath166 where @xmath167 and @xmath168 are scaling functions with an appropriate asymptotic behavior . again these scaling forms are consistent with the critical exponents @xmath119 of the edwards - wilkinson universality class .
mean field theories describe a system in an approximate way by ignoring spatial correlations . for a given model
there are many possible types of mean field theories , depending on the microscopic level one is trying to describe .
previous mean field approaches to non - equilibrium wetting considered the average height as the dynamical variable and studied the mean field approximation of its dynamics .
for example , in a study by giada and marsili @xcite the kpz equation ( [ langevinequation ] ) was mapped by a hopf - cole transformation to a langevin equation with multiplicative noise , discretizing space and replacing nearest - neighbor interactions by global couplings . using a morse potential with a potential
well at zero height they were able to reproduce second- and first order transitions as well as phase coexistence .
more recently , santos _
et al . _
@xcite extended these studies , suggesting that the mean field phase diagram does not change if fluctuations are taken into account .
moreover , they identified a narrow domain close to the borderline between phase coexistence region and wet phase , where the system exhibits spatio - temporal intermittency . in this section
we construct mean field equations describing the temporal evolution of the height distribution @xmath169 for height @xmath170 .
this approach is expected to yield more detailed information on the structure of the interface than previous mean field theories . in order to construct the mean field equations for the height distribution ,
let us first consider the case of a freely evolving interface without a wall .
the rate equations describing the temporal change of @xmath169 consist of several terms corresponding to different processes .
let us , for example , consider the probability that an attempted update leads to the desorption of an atom from the interior of a plateau at level @xmath171 .
this probability is proportional to @xmath169 , which is the probability to find a randomly selected site at height @xmath171 .
moreover , it depends on the heights of the nearest neighbors , which are restricted to take the values @xmath172 .
for simplicity we assume that each site has two nearest neighbor sites
. clearly one can generalize it to the case where each site has @xmath173 nearest neighbors . in this case
one may have several types of edge of corner sites , requiring a larger number of growth rate parameters . to avoid this complication ,
we restrict ourselves to the case of two nearest neighbors . thus , neglecting spatial correlations , the probability to find the two nearest neighbor sites at the heights @xmath174,@xmath175 is assumed to be proportional to @xmath176 divided by @xmath177 .
for example , for evaporation from a plateau we have @xmath178 and thus the contribution of the process ( [ process3 ] ) to the dynamical equation of @xmath169 is @xmath179 similarly the loss of probability due to evaporation at the edges ( [ process2 ] ) is given by @xmath180 while the depositon process ( [ process1 ] ) leads to a loss term of the form @xmath181 in addition , there are corresponding gain contributions at the neighboring levels such that the total probability is conserved . collecting all terms ,
the mean field equations can be written as @xmath182 where @xmath183 the hard - core wall at the bottom layer can be taken into account by formally setting @xmath184 and replacing @xmath24 with @xmath27 in the expression for @xmath185 , which then can be written as @xmath186 mean field phase diagram for @xmath46 .
the second - order phase transition line is represented as a solid line .
the bound phase consists of two parts , where the interface profile @xmath169 either decays expontially ( e ) or superexponentially ( se ) for large @xmath171 .
, width=302 ] the main result of the calculations , which will be presented in detail below , is the mean - field phase diagram shown in fig .
[ figmfphasediag ] for the case @xmath46 . as in the @xmath0 dimensional model
, there is a continuous phase transition from a bound to a moving phase . in calculating the mean field height distribution in the moving phase it is found that the interface is localized around its average height at
any given time , representing a _ smooth _ growing interface .
this is expected in high dimensions , for which mean field represents a reasonable approximation . clearly , in @xmath187 dimensions this is not the case as discussed before .
in the bound region , two types of phases were found . in the larger part of the @xmath188-plane ( denoted as se in fig .
[ figmfphasediag ] ) the height profile decays superexponentially at large height .
in particular it is found that for large @xmath171 the profile takes the form @xmath189 where @xmath4 is a constant .
in addition , another region is found ( denoted as e in fig .
[ figmfphasediag ] ) , where the height distribution decays exponentially @xmath190 where @xmath191 is a constant .
the superexponential behavior may be understood by considering the equilibrium case ( i.e. @xmath30 ) in which a @xmath12-dimensional manifold is attracted by a gravitational force to a hard wall .
the energy of a fluctuation reaching a height @xmath171 scales as @xmath192 , leading to the height distribution @xmath193 where @xmath194 is a constant .
this behavior is seems to be valid in an extended non - equilibrium region of the phase diagram , as shown in fig .
[ figgaussian ] , where numerical simulations in @xmath195 dimensions are presented .
numerical attempts to find signatures of a possible exponential phase in @xmath135 and @xmath136 dimensions failed since it is very difficult to obtain a reliable statistics in the tail of the height distribution , especially in higher dimensions , where finite size effects become increasingly relevant .
the conjecture , that the exponential phase might be related to the roughening transition of kpz interfaces in @xmath196 could not be substantiated by numerical simulations . in the stationary state one
has @xmath197 and @xmath198 so that @xmath199 vanishes for all @xmath200 .
therefore , the stationary mean field equations read @xmath201 where @xmath202 . in order to solve this equation by iteration , it is convenient to consider quotients of successive densities @xmath203 classification of fixed points depending on @xmath25 and @xmath24 . in region
i ( ii ) there exists only one real fixed point @xmath204 ( @xmath205 ) , while in region iii there are three real fixed points .
regions i and ii are separated by the straight dotted line @xmath206 .
the phase transition line ( solid line ) crosses from region i to region ii and back into region i , as illustrated in the upper inset .
the lower inset zooms the area where the both lines enter wedge - shaped region iii .
, width=377 ] in terms of these variables , the stationary mean field equations take the form @xmath207 the bulk equation ( [ xiteration ] ) can be interpreted as an iterative map @xmath208 , where @xmath209 for @xmath210 . in addition the initial condition for @xmath211 is given by the bottom layer equation @xmath212 in order to evaluate the stationary height distribution for given @xmath25 and @xmath24 , one has to look for a point on the line of possible initial conditions ( [ bottomcurve ] ) and iterate the map ( [ map ] ) such that it reaches a real fixed point with @xmath213 .
this trajectory then corresponds to a physical height distribution .
to proceed , we first analyze the fixed points of the map . the fixed point equation
@xmath214 has four solutions .
two of the solutions , @xmath215 and @xmath216 are real in the entire @xmath188-plane , while other two solutions @xmath217 may either be both real or complex conjugate to each other .
we denote the region in the @xmath188-plane , where @xmath217 are real , by region iii ( see fig . [ figtech ] ) .
we further divide the complementary region to iii into two regions , i where @xmath218 , and ii , where @xmath219 . since the bracket in eq .
( [ fixedpointequation2 ] ) is equal to @xmath220 at @xmath221 and positive for @xmath222 in the limit of large @xmath223 the fixed point @xmath224 has to be positive . analyzing the map ( [ map ] ) with the initial condition ( [ bottomcurve ] )
we find that the only fixed points , which correspond to physical height distributions , are either @xmath225 or @xmath226 when it is real . here
@xmath227 is the solution of eq .
( [ fixedpointequation2 ] ) which satisfies @xmath228 in the region iii .
in particular we find that below the transition line , the height distribution is controlled by the fixed point @xmath215 in region i and by the fixed point @xmath227 in region iii .
details of the analysis , which led to this result , are given in the appendix .
we now study the stationary height profile in the two regions . in region
i the map flows to the hyperbolic fixed point @xmath215 along its stable trajectory . expanding the map for small values of @xmath223 to lowest order
, this stable manifold is described by the nonlinear relation @xmath229 in the limit @xmath230 . along this manifold ,
the map approaches the fixed point @xmath215 super - exponentially as @xmath231 yielding the height profile in eq .
( [ superexp ] ) . in region
iii stationary solutions are controlled by the fixed point @xmath232 ( see appendix ) . linearizing the map around this fixed point one obtains an exponential behavior @xmath233 where @xmath191 is a constant , leading to the exponential height profile ( [ normalexp ] ) . to complete the analysis of the phase diagram
, one has to locate the wetting transition line .
this is done by simulating the dynamical mean field equations ( [ meanfieldequations ] ) and determining the point from where on the interface detaches . this analysis leads to the transition line shown in fig .
[ figmfphasediag ] .
so far all mean field results were obtained for @xmath46 , i.e. , without an attractive force between the substrate and the wetting layer .
lowering @xmath27 changes the bottom layer equation ( [ bottomcurve ] ) and thereby the possible starting points of the iteration .
as shown in the appendix , the mean field approximation reproduces the phenomenon of phase coexistence .
however , unlike in the model in @xmath0 dimensions , it emerges everywhere along the phase transition line as soon as @xmath57 ; hence , there is no tricritical point .
moreover , in the limit @xmath234 the threshold for the growth rate @xmath24 , where the interface detaches , tends to infinity .
therefore , the region of phase coexistence is not bounded from above as in the @xmath0 dimensional model .
in this paper we have given a detailed account of a recently introduced solid - on - solid model for non - equilbrium wetting , which is defined in the spirit of a kpz equation in a potential .
introducing a hard - core wall at zero height , the model exhibits a contininuous wetting transition from a bound to a moving phase .
the model is controlled by two paramters @xmath25 and @xmath24 , which effectively determine the asympotic slope of the potential and the coefficient of the nonlinear term in the kpz equation .
for @xmath30 the dynamical rules of the model obey detailed balance . in this case the stationary distribution of a bound interface is given by a boltzmann ensemble , which allows one to derive various quantities exactly .
moving away from this line , the model crosses over to a non - equilibrium behavior , that is characterized by different critical properties .
the model can be generalized further by including an attractive interaction between the substrate and the wetting layer . if this force is strong enough it may turn the continuous transition into a discontinuous one . moreover , the bound and the moving phase may coexist in regions where the coeffient of the nonlinear term in the kpz equation is negative . in order to assess the behavior of the model in higher dimensions , we have proposed a mean field approximation , which is based on rate equations for the densities at different heights .
the phase diagram turns out to be surprisingly rich .
it turns out that the mean field approximation reproduces the properties of the original model .
however , in the moving phase the interface remains smooth as it is expected for kpz - type growth in higher dimensions . as a new feature ,
the mean field approximation predicts the existence of two different regions in the bound phase . in one of these regions
the interace profile decays superexponentially with increasing height while in the other region an exponential decay is observed .
this can be explained by classifying the fixed points of an iterative map for quotients of the densities .
the question to what extent this crossover from superexponential to exponential profiles can be observed in the full model is still open . *
acknowledgments * + the support of the israel science foundation ( isf ) and the einstein center of the minerva foundation is gratefully acknowledged .
the simulations were partly performed on the alice parallel computer at the iai in wuppertal .
h.h would like to thank the infn and the weizmann institute for hospitality , where parts of this work have been done .
besides @xmath235 , eq .
( [ fixedpointequation2 ] ) has three other fixed points which are the roots of the polynomial equation @xmath236 as shown in fig .
[ figtech ] , the @xmath188-plane can be divided into three different regions . in regions
i and ii one fixed point is real and two of them are complex conjugate , while in region iii all fixed points are real .
the boundary of region iii is characterized by the existence of a two - fold degenerate fixed point .
comparing eq .
( [ fixedpointequation ] ) with a polynomial of the form @xmath237 , the boundary of region iii can be given in a parameter representation by @xmath238 where @xmath239 .
the boundary has the form of a wedge , shown as a dashed line in fig .
[ figtech ] .
the lower branch for @xmath240 and the upper branch for @xmath241 terminate in the triple point @xmath242 , where eq . ( [ fixedpointequation ] ) has a three - fold degenerate fixed point @xmath243 .
physically meaningful stationary solutions of the iterative map must start from a point on the line given by eq . ( [ xiteration0 ] ) and have to flow towards a real fixed point with @xmath244 . for this reason we divided the complement of region iii into two parts , namely , region i with @xmath245 and region ii with @xmath246 .
both regions are separated by a straight line @xmath206 , where @xmath247 .
we first show that in regions i and ii a physically meaningful stationary solution always flows to the fixed point @xmath235 . to this end
we show that the other real fixed point @xmath224 is either larger than @xmath45 or unstable .
stationary solutions in region i : superstable manifold of the fixed point @xmath215 for @xmath248 and different values of @xmath24 in regions i and ii . for @xmath47 the manifold ( bold line )
interesects with the with the dashed line of possible initial conditions ( [ bottomcurve ] ) , representing a stationary solution in the bound phase , where the bottom layer density @xmath249 is positive .
approaching @xmath250 this intersection point moves to infinity and @xmath249 tends to zero .
for @xmath48 the superstable manifold originates in the other real fixed point so that no stationary solution exists .
similar graphs are also obtained for other values of @xmath25 in regions i and ii .
, width=604 ] as shown in the upper inset of fig .
[ figtech ] , the phase transition line starts at @xmath49 in region i , crosses into region ii at the point @xmath162 and then crosses back into region i at the point @xmath251 . obviously the fixed point @xmath224 can only be physically meaningful between these two crossing points , where @xmath246
. however , in this interval @xmath224 turns out to be unstable . to demonstrate this point we consider the eigenvalues of the jacobian of the map @xmath252 in eq .
( [ map ] ) @xmath253 using eq .
( [ fixedpointequation ] ) the partial derivatives can be expressed as @xmath254 along the dotted line in fig .
[ figtech ] , where @xmath255 , the two eigenvalues @xmath256 are complex conjugate in the interval between the two crossing points @xmath257 .
as can be verified numerically , they are also complex conjugate in a neighborhood of this line , which includes the phase transition line .
since the determinant of the jacobian @xmath258 is larger than @xmath45 for @xmath213 , the fixed point @xmath224 is found to be unstable .
thus we can conclude that physically meaningful stationary solutions in regions i and ii are always controlled by the fixed point @xmath235 . since for @xmath259 the two eigenvalues tend to @xmath260 and @xmath261 , the fixed point @xmath235 is nonlinear and hyperbolic .
it has superstable manifold which in the limit of @xmath230 is given by @xmath262 .
this manifold is shown in fig .
[ figoutside ] for different values of @xmath24 below , at , and above the critical point .
as it can be seen , a stationary solution exists if the manifold intersects the line of possible initial conditions ( [ bottomcurve ] ) . in the wedge - shaped region iii , there are three real fixed points @xmath267 .
the first one is smaller than @xmath45 and unstable , while the second one is smaller than @xmath45 and hyperbolic .
the properties of @xmath268 depend on @xmath25 and @xmath24 .
below the dotted line in fig .
[ figtech ] it is larger than @xmath45 and stable , while it is smaller than @xmath45 and unstable above .
[ figinside ] illustrates typical situations at @xmath263 for various values of @xmath24 , crossing the region iii from bottom to top . below the wedge in region i ( panel a )
, the stationary solution can be constructed in the same way as before . entering region iii from below ( panel b ) ,
two new real fixed points @xmath269 emerge , which are fully unstable and hyperbolic , respectively .
the superstable manifold of the fixed point @xmath235 now originates in @xmath224 , while it is the linearly stable manifold of the hyperbolic fixed point @xmath227 which intersects the dashed line of possible initial conditions ( [ bottomcurve ] ) . as before ,
the intersection point moves continuously to infinity as @xmath24 approaches the critical point ( panel c ) .
thus the unbinding transition manifests itself in the same way as in the regions i and ii , the only difference being that the physically relevant stable manifold is now controlled by the hyperbolic fixed point @xmath270 instead of @xmath235 .
the linear stability of @xmath227 is responsible for the purely exponential profile observed in region @xmath271 . lowering @xmath27 changes the line of possible initial conditions ( [ bottomcurve ] ) , while the stable manifold of the fixed point @xmath235 remains the same .
the typical situation for @xmath272 is shown in fig .
[ figmfcoex ] .
the left panel shows the stable manifold ( solid line ) and the bottom layer equation ( dashed line ) without attractive force at the critical point @xmath273 .
both curves approach each other smoothly and intersect at infinity so that the transition is continuous .
the right panel shows the same situation in the presence of an attractive force for @xmath274 .
accordingly , the effect of lowering @xmath27 is to move the dashed line of possible intial conditions upward such that it intersects the critical stable manifold at a certain finite point .
this means that the bottom layer density @xmath249 is finite at the critical point , making the transition first order .
moreover , a stationary solution still exists even if @xmath24 is increased , proving the possibility of phase coexistence in the mean field equations . increasing @xmath24 beyond a certain threshold ,
a stationary solution no longer exists .
this defines the upper boundary of the phase coexistence region in the mean field phase diagram .
u. alon , m. r. evans , h. hinrichsen and d. mukamel , phys .
lett . * 76 * , 2746 ( 1996 ) ; u. alon , m. r. evans , h. hinrichsen and d. mukamel , phys . rev . * e 57 * , 4997 ( 1998 ) . h. hinrichsen , eprint cond - mat/0209179 . | we report a detailed account of the phase diagram of a recently introduced model for non - equilibrium wetting in @xmath0 dimensions [ phys .
rev . lett . * 79 * , 2710 ( 1997 ) ] .
a mean field approximation is shown to reproduce the main features of the phase diagram , while providing indications for the behaviour of the wetting transition in higher dimensions .
the mean field phase diagram is found to exhibit an extra transition line which does not exist in @xmath0 dimensions .
the line separates a phase in which the interface height distribution decays exponentially at large heights , from a superexponentially decaying phase .
implications to wetting in dimensions higher than @xmath0 are discussed .
# 1 |
with the introduction of efficient multi - object spectrographs on 4m - class telescopes , it has become possible to construct large samples of faint galaxies with measured redshifts .
with such a sample , one can compute the luminosity function ( lf ) of galaxies as a function of redshift and thereby directly observe the evolution ( or lack thereof ) of the galaxy population .
several groups have now presented the results of deep , faint galaxy redshift surveys ( @xcite , cfrs ; @xcite , autofib ; @xcite ; @xcite , cnoc ) .
the conclusions from these surveys are in broad agreement : the population of blue , star - forming galaxies has evolved strongly since @xmath16 while the population of red galaxies shows at most modest signs of evolution ( although , see kauffmann , charlot , & white ( 1996 ) for an alternative analysis of the red galaxies ) . however , there are important differences as well .
lin et al . ( 1996a ) demonstrate that the lfs from the various groups are formally inconsistent with each other .
since there are many selection effects involved with the construction and analysis of faint redshift surveys , it is difficult to pinpoint the reasons for the disagreement between the various groups .
while it is likely that the small numbers of galaxies in each survey and the small areas covered are partly responsible , it is also likely that systematic errors are in important contributor to the differences in detail .
quantitative estimates of the evolution are , of course , dependent upon having a reliable measurement of the local lf , and it is , therefore , of concern that there remain considerable uncertainties about the _
local _ lf . the lfs derived from large - area local redshifts survey ( e.g. , the stromlo / apm survey , loveday et al . 1992 ; the cfa survey , marzke , huchra , & geller 1994a ; the las campanas redshift survey , lin et al .
1996b ) all have similar shapes , but there are still substantial differences over the overall normalization , the characteristic luminosity , and the slope at low luminosities . the rapid evolution at @xmath17 required to match steep @xmath18-band counts at intermediate magnitudes @xmath19 ( maddox et al . 1990 ) could be reduced if the normalization or the faint - end slope have been underestimated .
the results of the largest of the local surveys , the las campanas redshift survey ( lcrs ) with 18678 galaxies used in the lf analysis and a median redshift of @xmath20 , are seemingly consistent with both a low normalization and a flat faint - end slope .
the lcrs is selected from ccd drift scans rather than photographic plates and surveys what should be a fair volume of the universe ( shectman et al .
1996 , davis 1996 ) .
it also probes both the southern and northern galactic caps .
accordingly , the local luminosity function computed from their data should be free from systematic photometric errors and fluctuations in large - scale structure in the distribution of galaxies .
however , both the cfa survey and the autofib survey find a normalization which is a factor of 2 higher than that obtained from the lcrs .
while the normalization of the cfa survey can be questioned on the grounds that it does not sample a fair volume , the autofib survey is the concatenation of many fields distributed across the sky .
the autofib survey is particularly important because the galaxy sample was selected with a much fainter surface brightness threshold than any of the other local surveys .
mcgaugh ( 1994 ) emphasizes that a large population of intrinsically luminous but low surface brightness galaxies may be missed in the shallow photometry on which all the local surveys , except autofib , are based .
a steep faint - end slope of the lf , with a power law exponent of @xmath21 , is a natural prediction of galaxy formation theories based on hierarchical structure formation models ( kauffmann , guiderdoni , & white 1994 ) .
there is only weak evidence for a steep faint - end slope in the local field galaxy lf .
marzke et al .
( 1994b ) report an upturn in the luminosity function of late - type galaxies with @xmath22 , but lcrs , autofib , and cowie et al .
( 1996 ) all derive a flat faint - end slope .
there is , however , evidence for a steep faint - end slope in galaxy clusters ( e.g. , de propris et al .
1995 , bernstein et al .
environmental influences on galaxy evolution may be reflected in variations of the lf for galaxies in different environments , and it is therefore important to measure the lf in a variety of environments . in this paper , we investigate the evolution and environmental dependence of the galaxy lf based on data obtained during the course of our redshift survey of the corona borealis supercluster . the primary motivation for the survey was to study the dynamics of the supercluster .
however , the majority of galaxies for which we measured redshifts actually lie behind the corona borealis supercluster , thus providing a sample suitable for study of the evolution of the lf .
the galaxies were originally selected from plates taken as part of the second palomar observatory sky survey ( poss - ii ; @xcite ) and have been calibrated in the gunn @xmath23 and @xmath7 bands , which correspond roughly to the photographic @xmath24 and @xmath25 bands .
previous redshift surveys have generally been either selected in bluer bands ( @xmath18 ) , for sensitivity to changes in star - formation rates , or redder bands ( @xmath26 and @xmath27 ) , for sensitivity to old stellar populations which more reliably trace stellar mass .
although we had no option but to use the @xmath23 and @xmath7 bands , the two bands turn out fortuitously to have the virtue that corrections to the rest @xmath18 band , where lfs are traditionally computed and compared , are small since the @xmath23 band matches the rest @xmath18 band at @xmath28 and the @xmath7 band matches the rest @xmath18 band at @xmath29 .
the cnoc survey used photometry in @xmath23 and @xmath7 as well , and so it is particularly interesting to compare our results to that survey since there should be no systematic effects due to using different passbands for galaxy selection .
finally , with over 400 redshifts in the corona borealis supercluster , and roughly 300 in a background supercluster , we can explore the variation of the lf from the field to the supercluster environment .
the paper , the second in the series presenting results from the norris survey of the corona borealis supercluster , is organized as follows . in 2 , we summarize our survey , particularly emphasizing those features that are directly relevant to the computation of the lf .
we discuss the details of the computation of the lf in 3 .
the results are given in 4 for both field galaxies and for the two superclusters individually and are discussed in 5 . finally , we summarize our conclusions in 6 .
we use a hubble constant @xmath30 km s@xmath31 mpc@xmath32 and a deceleration parameter @xmath33 . for comparison to the most recent work in the field ( e.g. , cfrs and cnoc ) ,
we use the ab - normalized @xmath18 band , @xmath6 ( oke 1974 ) . the offsets from @xmath6 to @xmath8 and @xmath18 are @xmath34 and @xmath35 ( fukugita , shimasaku , & ichikawa 1995 ) .
the norris survey of the corona borealis supercluster has been described in detail in small et al .
( 1996 ) , paper i of the current series , and will be only briefly reviewed here .
the core of the supercluster covers a @xmath36 region of the sky centered at right ascension @xmath37 , declination @xmath38 and consists of 7 rich abell clusters at @xmath11 .
since the field - of - view of the 176-fiber norris spectrograph is only 400 arcmin@xmath39 , we planned to observe 36 fields arranged in a rectangular grid with a grid spacing of 1 . as it turned out ,
we successfully observed 23 of the fields and 9 additional fields along the ridge of galaxies between abell 2061 and abell 2067 , yielding redshifts for 1491 extragalactic objects .
we have extended our survey with 163 redshifts from the literature , resulting in 1654 redshifts in the entire survey .
1022 of these galaxies lie beyond the corona borealis supercluster , although of these 1022 , 325 ( 318 with @xmath4 ) galaxies are in a background supercluster ( @xmath13 ) which we have dubbed the `` abell 2069 supercluster . ''
the survey fields are distributed across an area of 25 deg@xmath39 . the total area covered by the 32 observed fields ,
albeit sparsely sampled , is 2.99 deg@xmath39 .
as noted above and described in detail in paper i , the objects have been selected from poss - ii photographic plates of poss - ii field 449 , which neatly covers the entire core of the supercluster .
we have both a @xmath24 ( kodak iii - aj emulsion with a gg395 filter ) plate and an @xmath25 ( kodak iii - af emulsion with a rg610 filter ) plate .
the plates were digitized with 1 arcsec@xmath39 pixels at the space telescope science institute and then processed using the sky image cataloging and analysis tool ( skicat , @xcite ) .
the instrumental intensities recorded by skicat were calibrated with ccd sequences in the @xmath23 and @xmath7 bands of galaxies in abell 2069 .
the random magnitude errors are 0.25@xmath40 for @xmath23 and @xmath7 brighter than 21@xmath40 and become substantially worse at fainter magnitudes .
( we describe how we correct our computed lfs for these magnitude errors in 3.2 . ) with the skicat system , the star - galaxy separation is 90% accurate to @xmath41 .
our lf analysis is limited to galaxies with @xmath42 .
since our original motivation for the survey was to study the dynamics of the corona borealis supercluster , we chose a comparatively high spectral resolution for a faint galaxy redshift survey .
a third of the objects were observed with @xmath43spectral resolution during the period when the largest ccd available at palomar was a 1024@xmath39 device with 24 pixels ; the rest were observed with @xmath44 resolution with a very efficient 2048@xmath39 ccd ( also with 24 pixels ) .
since the operation of retrieving the fibers for one set - up and redeploying the fibers for another takes roughly an hour with the norris spectrograph , we decided to observe only two fields per night in order to minimize the amount of time lost due to changing fields .
thus , our exposures were 2 - 4 hours long , and we generally obtained high quality spectra on @xmath45 galaxies . in figure
[ figures : success ] , we plot our success rate , the fraction of objects ( i.e. , including stars and quasars ) on which fibers were deployed for which we successfully measured redshifts , as a function of magnitude . figure [ figures : success ] shows that our success rate falls substantially below unity beyond @xmath46 .
therefore , we have computed weights for each galaxy to correct for a our incomplete sampling .
the weight for a particular object is defined to be simply the ratio of the total number of objects in the photometric catalog to the number of objects with redshifts in an interval of @xmath47 centered on the magnitude of the object .
this prescription assumes that the redshift distribution of the objects for which we failed to measure redshifts is identical to the redshift distribution of the objects for which we successfully measured redshifts .
the color distribution of the objects that we observed but failed to identify is similar to that of the objects that we successfully observed , leading us to conclude that we do not suffer biases against particular types of galaxies ( paper i ) .
moreover , we do not believe that we should have redshift - dependent biases in our success rate .
since we limit the computation of the lf to @xmath48 , we are unlikely to be affected by a bias in redshift .
the 4000 break and ca h , ca k lines of old stellar populations and the [ ] line of star - forming galaxies are all within our spectral range out to @xmath1 .
we plot the calculated weights as a function of @xmath7 magnitude for all galaxies with @xmath42 and which satisfy our surface brightness threshold ( see below ) in figure [ figures : weights ] .
the weights are greater than unity even for bright galaxies because of the sparse sampling of our survey area .
( since the very brightest galaxies ( @xmath49 ) produce scattered light contamination of nearby spectra on the ccd , we usually did not place fibers on galaxies with @xmath49 , and thus the weights increase for the very brightest galaxies . ) in paper i , we carefully studied the surface brightness selection effects present in our sample .
we found that by restricting our sample to objects with @xmath42 and with core magnitudes @xmath50 ( where the core magnitude is the integrated magnitude within the central 9 arcsec@xmath39 ) , we are free from surface brightness selection effects . for comparison , @xmath51 corresponds to a central surface brightness of @xmath52 @xmath7 mag arcsec@xmath53 for a galaxy with an @xmath54 ( @xmath55 mag in the @xmath7 band ) disk .
we compute galaxy lfs in the rest - frame @xmath6 band and , for the local lf , in the rest - frame gunn @xmath7 band as well .
rest - frame colors and @xmath56-corrections are computed from the spectral energy distributions compiled by coleman , wu , & weedman ( 1980 , hereafter ccw ) .
we assign each galaxy a spectral type based on its @xmath57 color and its redshift .
following lilly et al .
( 1995 ) , the spectral type is a real number which takes the values 0 for an elliptical galaxy , 2 for an sbc galaxy , 3 for an scd galaxy , and 4 for an i m galaxy .
we then interpolate between the ccw spectral energy distributions to construct the spectral energy distribution appropriate for the given spectral type .
galaxies whose colors are redder than a ccw e galaxy or bluer than a ccw i m galaxy are simply assigned the spectral energy distribution of an e galaxy or an i m galaxy , respectively . the number of galaxies with colors outside the limits defined by the ccw e and i m types is known to be small even to large redshifts ( e.g. , crampton et al .
the fact that many of our galaxies lie outside the ccw limits ( see figure 17 , paper i ) is due to the large errors in our colors ( @xmath58 ) .
we compute the absolute rest - frame @xmath6-band magnitude as follows : @xmath59 where @xmath60 incorporates the corrections based on the spectral energy distribution and @xmath61 is the luminosity distance in mpc .
the @xmath62 term represents the change in the bandwidth with redshift and is included in the traditional @xmath56-correction . again following lilly et al .
( 1995 ) , we separate the bandwidth stretching term , which has negligible error since it depends only on the accurately measured redshift , from the terms which depend on the spectral energy distribution and are therefore much more uncertain .
we plot @xmath60 for the @xmath23 and @xmath7 bands in figure [ figures : keff ] . by converting from @xmath63 for objects with @xmath64 and from @xmath65 for objects with @xmath66
, @xmath60 may be kept less than @xmath67 for @xmath68 for all spectral types .
we use the step - wise maximum - likelihood ( swml ) method of efstathiou , ellis , & peterson ( 1988 ) to estimate the lf .
the probability of observing a galaxy of absolute magnitude @xmath69 at redshift @xmath70 in a flux - limited catalog is given by , @xmath71 where @xmath72 is the lf and @xmath73 is the intrinsically faintest galaxy observable at @xmath70 in the flux - limited catalog .
the lf is parameterized as a set of @xmath74 numbers @xmath75 such that @xmath76 and then the likelihood , @xmath77 where @xmath78 is the number of galaxies in the sample , is maximized with respect to the @xmath75 .
we constrain the values of @xmath75 to satisfy @xmath79 the virtues of the swml method are that it is not biased by the presence of clustering since the normalization of the lf cancels out of the expression for the probability @xmath80 and also that one does not have to assume a particular functional form for the lf . in order to include the weights , we make the substitution @xmath81 where @xmath82 is the weight of galaxy @xmath83 ( zucca , pozzetti , & zamorani 1994 , lin et al .
one must then estimate the mean galaxy density separately .
we use a standard technique which we describe below .
since the weights are greater than one , their use will increase the calculated likelihood for the sample and thus lead to artificially small error estimates . by renormalizing the weights so that @xmath84 , the error estimates are appropriate for the true sample size ( lin et al . 1996b ) .
note that the normalization constraint on the @xmath75 reduces the estimated errors .
we do not use the traditional @xmath85 method ( @xcite ) employed by ellis et al .
( 1996 ) and lilly et al .
( 1995 ) since the method is sensitive to clustering .
we have , however , compared the results of the two techniques for samples with @xmath86 , where the clustering in our survey is not pronounced , and found that they agree satisfactorily . for @xmath87
, we can construct volume - limited sub - samples with @xmath4 in which any galaxy with @xmath88 is visible in the entire volume .
of course , the value of the lf in a given magnitude bin for a volume - limited sample is estimated by counting the number galaxies with absolute magnitudes in the bin and then dividing by the volume of the sample and the width of the bin .
the swml lfs for @xmath87 agree well with the lfs estimated from the volume - limited samples .
we compute the mean density @xmath89 of a magnitude - limited sub - sample using the following estimator : @xmath90 where @xmath91 is the volume of the sample , @xmath78 is the number of objects in the sample , and @xmath92 is the selection function .
the selection function , @xmath93 gives the fraction of the lf observable at a given redshift .
here , @xmath94 is the lf , @xmath95 is the maximum absolute magnitude that an object can have at redshift @xmath96 and still be included in the sample , and @xmath97 is the absolute magnitude of the most instrinsically faint galaxy in the sample . in practice , one does not begin evaluating the integrals at @xmath98 , but rather at the absolute magnitude of the most instrinsically bright galaxy in the sample . the estimator in equation [ equations : mean_density ]
is almost identical to the minimum variance estimator derived by davis & huchra ( 1982 ) for @xmath99 and is unbiased by density inhomogeneities .
an additional complication of computing a lf in the @xmath6 band where the objects have been selected in the @xmath7 band is that one must ensure that any object , regardless of its color , would have been detectable in both bands .
if one ignores this complication , then the faintest objects at a given redshift will be biased in color . in our survey , since the @xmath7 band is centered at a longer wavelength than the @xmath18 band , the faintest objects would be biased to the red . in order to avoid such a bias ,
we adjust our absolute @xmath6 magnitude limits as a function of redshift so that the bluest galaxy at any @xmath6 magnitude limit would be observable in the @xmath7 band .
for the local lf computed in the @xmath7 band , the bias works in the opposite sense , and so we adjust our rest - frame absolute @xmath7 magnitude limits to ensure that the reddest galaxy a given limit would be detected in the observed @xmath7 band . for each lf , we estimate the parameters of the best - fitting schechter ( 1976 ) function , @xmath100 where @xmath101 is the normalization , @xmath102 determines the location of the bright - end exponential cutoff , and @xmath103 is the faint - end slope .
the fitting was performed using a standard @xmath104-minimization algorithm ( press et al .
1992 ) with the schechter function integrated over the width of the adopted magnitude bin .
we intend these fits to be useful for comparisons with other work . usually , there are too few points for the fits to be well defined
. our random magnitude errors ( @xmath105 ) will artificially brighten the characteristic magnitude @xmath102 of the lf and steepen the faint end .
we correct for the magnitude errors by fitting to the data points a schechter function ( equation [ equations : schechter ] ) convolved with a gaussian of dispersion @xmath106 ( efstathiou et al .
in fact , however , the corrections to the schechter function parameters are substantially less than the 1@xmath107 statistical errors .
the error in the normalization from the @xmath104-fitting only includes the uncertainties due to @xmath102 and @xmath103 .
the error due to large - scale structure fluctuations is @xmath108 ( davis & huchra 1982 ) , where @xmath109 is the second moment of the two - point spatial correlation function ( peebles 1980 ) and @xmath91 is the appropriate volume .
we use @xmath110 ( @xmath111 mpc)@xmath112 ( tucker et al . 1997 ) and record the error from density fluctuations alongside the uncertainty in @xmath101 due to @xmath102 and @xmath103 .
in the following subsections , we report our results for the local lf , the evolution of the lf , and the lfs of the corona borealis and abell 2069 superclusters .
all samples are magnitude - limited at @xmath113 .
the parameters of the best fitting schechter functions are summarized in table 1 , where the sample is given in the first column , the number of galaxies used to compute the lf in the second column , the absolute range over which the fit is valid in the third column , @xmath101 in the fourth column , @xmath102 in the fifth column , @xmath103 in the sixth column , the reduced @xmath104 in the seventh column , and the estimate of the variance due to density fluctuations in the eighth column .
the numbers of galaxies listed in the second column are slightly smaller than the total number of galaxies satisfying the sample listed in the first column because a few galaxies have been trimmed from each sample , as described above , to ensure that there are no color biases in the faintest bins
. corrections to @xmath101 to match galaxy counts , as discussed below , have _ not _ been applied to the values listed in table 1 .
we wish to emphasize that the fitted schechter functions are intended only to guide the eye and that comparisons of the various lfs in this paper are best done by comparing the individual data points in the plots .
the @xmath6-band local galaxy lf is plotted in figure [ figures : local_lf ] .
the unfilled circles show the lf for @xmath114 with the superclusters removed .
the filled circles show the lf for @xmath114 with the the superclusters included . in order to remove the superclusters
, we simply delete all objects with @xmath115 .
the median redshift of our local sample with the superclusters removed is @xmath116 .
the stromlo / apm lf is plotted with the solid line .
we also plot the autofid local lf with the dashed line . in figure
[ figures : local_lf ] and all subsequent figures where appropriate , we convolve the schechter function fits to the lfs from other surveys with a gaussian of dispersion @xmath106 in order to facilitate comparisons with our lf data points , which are constructed with galaxies whose photometry suffers from random magnitude errors of @xmath106 .
all of the local luminosity functions have similar shapes , but the normalizations and low luminosity ends vary significantly . in order to investigate
further the normalization of the local luminosity function , we compute the _ shape _ of local luminosity in the rest - frame @xmath7 band and then normalize this lf to the @xmath7-band counts of weir , djorgovski , & fayyad ( 1995 ) .
we plot our @xmath7-band local lf , normalized to the counts of weir et al .
( 1995 ) , in figure [ figures : local_lf_r ] , along with the @xmath7-band local lf from lcrs . to convert from isophotal @xmath117 magnitudes to total gunn @xmath7 magnitudes ,
we apply a 25% isophotal - to - total light correction and then use @xmath118 ( shectman et al .
thus , the corrections compensate for each other and @xmath119 . the counts of weir et al .
( 1995 ) are based on 4 overlapping , high galactic latitude plates taken as part of the poss - ii survey . knowing the shape of the lf
, we can estimate the differential number counts as @xmath120 { dv \over dz } dz \nonumber \\ & = & \phi^\ast \int_0^\infty \phi^\prime[m(m , z ) ] { dv \over dz } dz \\ & = & \phi^\ast { di \over dm } \nonumber , \label{equations : diff_counts}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath121 is @xmath72 with @xmath101 set equal to 1 , @xmath122 is the absolute magnitude of an object at redshift @xmath96 with apparent magnitude @xmath123 , and the @xmath124 are the magnitude intervals .
we estimate @xmath101 by minimizing the quantity @xmath125 ^ 2 } \over { \phi^\ast di(m_i)}}\ ] ] with respect to @xmath101 ( efstathiou et al .
1988 ) , which yields @xmath126 ^ 2 / di(m_i ) } \over { \sum_i di(m_i)}}.\ ] ] we find @xmath127 mpc@xmath32 where the errors reflect the changes due to varying jointly @xmath102 and @xmath103 by @xmath128 .
this is a 21% reduction from the normalization determined in the norris field itself .
although the median redshift of our local sample is @xmath116 , the agreement with lcrs ( @xmath129 ) in the @xmath7 band leads us to believe that we have computed a fair estimate of the local lf . in figure
[ figures : r_counts ] , we plot the @xmath7-band differential number counts .
the histogram shows the counts from the poss - ii plate from which we selected our objects .
the thick solid line is the counts from weir et al .
( 1995 ) , and the triangles are ccd counts from metcalfe et al .
the dashed line represents the predicted counts based on our field galaxy lf , including evolution at @xmath86 ( see 4.2 below ) , with the superclusters removed .
even with the superclusters removed , our local lf appears to be normalized too high . the solid line , however , gives the predicted counts with the normalization reduced by 21% . with the reduced normalization ,
the predicted counts agree quite well with the observed counts to @xmath113 . for comparison ,
we also show , as the dotted line , the predicted counts from the lcrs .
these counts fall below the weir et al .
( 1995 ) counts for @xmath130 because they do not include the evolution of the lf beyond @xmath131 .
since the volume of the norris region , with the superclusters removed , is @xmath132 mpc@xmath112 , we would expect from equation [ equations : delta_n ] @xmath133 .
it is therefore not cause for concern that this region is overdense by 21% .
we compute the field galaxy lf in two redshift intervals : @xmath134 and @xmath135 .
the results are plotted in figure [ figures : field_lf ] .
the normalization of the local lf ( unfilled circles ) has been reduced by 21% to match the @xmath7-band counts .
the filled circles are the lf of the high redshift interval .
we also plot the lfs of the stromlo / apm survey ( solid line ) , the cnoc survey ( @xmath136 , dashed line ) , and the cfrs survey ( @xmath135 , dotted line ) , all of which have been convolved with a gaussian with @xmath137 to account for random photometry errors . since the lf for the autofib survey was divided into redshift intervals which do not neatly match our redshift intervals and , more importantly , since lin et al .
( 1996a ) have already performed a detailed comparison with the autofib survey , we do not plot the autofib lfs .
the @xmath135 lf has clearly evolved with respect to the local lf .
we create two sub - samples of galaxies according to the rest - frame equivalent width of [ ] @xmath93727 .
the division is made at a rest - frame equivalent width of 10 , which roughly corresponds to dividing the sample into types earlier and later than sbc ( kennicutt 1992 ) and thus allows direct comparison with the results of cnoc and cfrs .
for galaxies with @xmath139 , [ ] is not redshifted into our observed wavelength range , and so we use the strength of h@xmath140 to divide our sample . after correcting for stellar absorption , we have 7 galaxies with @xmath139 and @xmath138(h@xmath140 ) @xmath141 5 , which we include in the @xmath138 ( [ ] ) @xmath141 10 sample .
we have also investigated separating our sample by color , but we have found that the large errors on our colors tend to dilute trends which are seen clearly in samples defined by @xmath138 ( [ ] ) .
the lfs for galaxies with @xmath138 ( [ ] ) @xmath142 10 and @xmath138 ( [ ] ) @xmath141 10 are shown in figure [ figures : no_o2_lf ] and figure [ figures : o2_lf ] , respectively .
we also plot in each figure the lfs for the corresponding color - selected samples from cnoc and cfrs .
it is important to remember when considering possible detailed discrepancies between our lfs and the cnoc and cfrs lfs that our sample is divided by @xmath138 ( [ ] ) , which , while roughly equivalent to color selection , is not identical .
there is no significant indication that the population of early - type galaxies ( i.e. , @xmath138 ( [ ] ) @xmath142 10 ) has evolved since @xmath1 ; this result is not surprising given that the light of early - type galaxies is dominated by red , long - lived stellar populations .
in contrast , the lfs of the late - type galaxies ( i.e. , those with @xmath138 ( [ ] ) @xmath141 10 ) show striking evidence for evolution , even though the sample sizes are small and the error bars are large .
the lfs of the corona borealis supercluster and the abell 2069 supercluster are given in figure [ figures : clusters_lf ] .
we take the redshift range of the corona borealis supercluster to be @xmath143 and that of the abell 2069 supercluster to be @xmath144 .
the normalization of the corona borealis supercluster function is a factor of 2 greater than that of the abell 2069 supercluster , but the shapes of the lfs of the two superclusters are similar .
note that the volumes used to normalize the superclusters lfs are in redshift space ; the real - space volumes may be quite different ( see 5.3 below for a detailed discussion ) .
since the bright ends of the supercluster lfs are clearly not well - described by a schechter function , we restrict our fit to @xmath145 .
in addition , the fit to the corona borealis supercluster is limited to @xmath146 since the faintest two data points appear to describe a sharp upturn in the lf .
prior evidence for rapid evolution of the galaxy lf to @xmath17 from galaxy counts was based crucially on normalizing the local lf to the bright ( @xmath147 ) galaxy counts from schmidt - telescope photographic surveys ( e.g. , maddox et al .
. with this low normalization , predicted counts from the no - evolution model fall well short of the observed counts for @xmath148 .
however , the evolution of the lf which we and others observe is not enough to make up for this shortfall . in figure
[ figures : b_counts ] , we plot the observed counts from the apm survey ( maddox et al . 1990 ) and from the ccd survey of metcalfe et al .
( 1991 ) , along with various predicted counts .
the dotted line shows the expected counts using the loveday et al .
( 1992 ) lf for @xmath134 and the cnoc @xmath6 lf for @xmath86 .
despite including the observed evolution of the lf , the predicted counts only begin to agree with the observed counts for @xmath149 , by which point the predicted counts are dominated by galaxies with @xmath86 . in contrast , the predicted counts computed using the evolving lfs measured for our survey and for the autofib survey , while substantially overpredicting the counts for @xmath150 , match the observed counts for @xmath151 . in order to help unravel this confusing situation , we plot in figure [ figures : b_and_r_lf ] various @xmath6- and @xmath7-band local lfs on the same diagram .
@xmath6-band lfs are plotted with respect to the bottom axis , while @xmath7-band lfs are plotted with respect to the top axis .
the two axes are offset by @xmath152 , which is the median color we measure for field galaxies with @xmath87 .
our @xmath6- and @xmath7-band local lfs , both of which have been reduced by 21% following the discussion in 4.1 , are plotted with filled and unfilled circles , respectively . with the color offset , they agree extremely well .
the stromlo / apm lf , represented by the solid line , lies consistently below our @xmath6-band lf .
the lcrs @xmath7-band lf is consistent with our @xmath7-band lf . unlike lin et al .
( 1996b ) , we do _ not _ conclude that the lcrs @xmath7-band lf matches the stromlo / apm lf .
the reason for the disagreement lies in the different measurements of the median color of local galaxies .
our median color is that of an sb galaxy , whereas the lcrs median color is that of a much redder e galaxy . the median color of galaxies in the _ third reference catalogue of bright galaxies _ ( de vaucouleurs et al .
1991 ) is @xmath153 ( see table 2 of fukugita et al .
1995 ) , which is roughly that of an sb galaxy .
sebok ( 1986 ) also concludes that the typical local galaxy has the color of an sb galaxy .
it is thus surprising that the mean color of the lcrs galaxies is so red .
since our @xmath7-band lf agrees with the lcrs @xmath7-band lf and since the lcrs computed the colors of their galaxies by matching directly to the apm catalog , the most natural explanation for the anomalous red colors of the lcrs is a systematic error in the bright apm magnitudes .
we note that weir et al .
( 1995 ) conclude that magnitudes derived from @xmath24 plates are only reliable for @xmath154 or , equivalently , @xmath155 .
galaxies brighter than @xmath156 are saturated on the photographic plates . a systematic error in the bright apm counts
would remove the need for rapid , and otherwise unsubstantiated , galaxy evolution at @xmath17 .
we note also that there is possible evidence for a rise in the local lf above an @xmath157 for the least luminous galaxies in our survey .
such a rise is evident in the data of marzke et al .
( 1994b ) for irregular galaxies , the cfrs , and the low surface brightness galaxy redshift survey of sprayberry et al .
similar behavior is also perhaps visible in the local lf of the autofib survey .
although ellis et al .
( 1996 ) argue against a rise in the lf for @xmath158 , the three faintest points in the their local lf ( their figure 8) all lie above their preferred schechter function fit .
however , since such faint galaxies are only visible in our survey in a quite small volume , we refrain from attempting to make a definitive statement .
we asserted in 4.2 that the lf of star - forming galaxies ( @xmath138 ( [ ] ) @xmath141 10 ) evolved from @xmath0 to @xmath1 and that the luminosity function of galaxies with weak [ ] emission ( @xmath142 10 ) did not .
a powerful method to verify this result is to compute @xmath159 for appropriate samples ( @xcite ) . if there is no evolution in the number density of objects , @xmath160 ; if the number density declines , @xmath161 ; and if the number density increases , @xmath162 .
our @xmath159 analysis is complicated by the need to remove the superclusters and to account for the 21% overdensity of our local field . in order to excise the superclusters ,
we simply remove all galaxies with @xmath115 . if the maximum redshift @xmath163 at which a galaxy could be observed in our survey lies in the range 0.06 to 0.13 , we set @xmath164 .
we correct for the overdensity of our local field by reducing the weights of galaxies with @xmath114 by 21% .
the values of @xmath159 for various samples of galaxies are given table 2 , both with and without the 21% correction to the weights of the galaxies with @xmath114 .
for samples selected by color , we compute the @xmath159 statistic for galaxies in the redshift range @xmath2 ( with the supercluster region excluded ) . for samples selected by the strength of [ ]
, we use the redshift range @xmath165 ( with the supercluster region excluded ) since [ ] from objects with @xmath139 is not redshifted into our observed wavelength range .
the differences between our weighted and unweighted statistics are small .
the @xmath159 test supports our claim , at the @xmath166 level for the weighted statistic , that the population of star - forming galaxies is evolving .
the rate of evolution increases with the strength of [ ] .
the population of galaxies with @xmath138 ( [ ] ) @xmath141 20 has @xmath167 .
this result is analogous to the results from cfrs in which the rate of evolution is the strongest for the bluest population of galaxies .
@xmath159 for the population of red galaxies is consistent with no evolution , in agreement with the lf analysis . broadly speaking , our results are in accord with the results of cfrs , autofib , cowie et al ( 1996 ) , and cnoc .
since the cnoc survey , like our survey , uses photometry in the @xmath23 and @xmath7 bands , it is particularly interesting to compare our results in detail to theirs since many of the systematic effects associated with @xmath56- and color - corrections ought to be the same .
it is encouraging to see ( figure [ figures : no_o2_lf ] and [ figures : o2_lf ] ) that , given the small samples , our lfs agree well with those of cnoc .
the agreement is significantly improved if one reduces the normalization of the cnoc lfs by 20% , as , in fact , is recommended by lin et al .
( 1996a ) .
now that we have confirmed that the population of blue galaxies is evolving with redshift , we wish to investigate whether we can detect differences in the colors and the spectral properties of the evolving population with redshift .
first , we reiterate that the color distribution of objects with measured redshifts is similar to the color distribution of unidentified objects , leading us to believe that the type distribution of the identified objects is not strongly biased ( paper i ) . although emission lines are generally easier to detect than absorption lines , the difficulty of identifying emission lines at observed wavelengths longer than 5577 , where there are many strong night sky features , combined with the strength of ca h , ca k , and the 4000 break in absorption line objects at @xmath168 mitigate the bias in favor of emission line objects . a sample of the spectra of 8 absorption line objects in this redshift range is shown in figure [ figures : ab_line_objs ] to illustrate the ease of detection of their characteristic absorption features . in figure [ figures : obs_g - r ] , we plot the observed @xmath5 color as a function of redshift of all the objects in our survey along with the tracks of five representative model galaxy spectra .
the bluest spectrum is simply a flat - spectrum object , @xmath169 the four other spectra are typical of the hubble types e , sbc , scd , and i m and are taken from ccw .
the large , solid diamonds mark the observed median color in the redshift ranges @xmath170 ( arranged to exclude the superclusters ) , @xmath171 , @xmath172 , @xmath173 , and @xmath174 .
perhaps counter - intuitively , we see that the observed median color does not become progressively bluer with respect to the model spectra with increasing redshift .
as discussed by lilly et al .
( 1995 ) and illustrated in our figure [ figures : rest - frame_g - r ] , the median color does not become bluer because the color - magnitude relation in the local universe ( i.e. , the fact that more luminous galaxies are redder ) breaks down for @xmath131 as the population of blue galaxies brightens while the population of red galaxies does not evolve significantly .
we plot in figure [ figures : rest - frame_g - r ] the absolute @xmath6-band magnitudes versus rest - frame @xmath5 for our galaxies divided into four intervals in redshift . in the low - redshift interval , the color - magnitude relation is apparent , but it disappears in the higher redshift intervals . at @xmath175
, we observe far down the lf to absolute magnitudes where blue galaxies are dominant . at @xmath131
, we do not observe as far down the lf , but the population of blue galaxies has brightened so as to be included in the samples . the increase in the luminosity of the population of blue galaxies
is presumably associated with a change in the star formation activity at earlier times . in our spectra , there are two convenient star formation indicators , [ ] @xmath93727 and h@xmath10 @xmath94101 .
[ ] emission is found in galaxies with ongoing star formation , and its strength is proportional to the strength of h@xmath103 ( @xcite ) .
strong h@xmath10 absorption is a signature of the presence of a population of a - stars , which are visible @xmath1761 gyr after a burst of star formation .
these lines are reliably measured by automated programs ( see paper i ) since both occur in regions of the spectrum where the continuum is featureless and there is little crowding from other lines .
an important virtue of the h@xmath10 line is that , since it appears in absorption , a galaxy with detectable h@xmath10 would have been identified no matter what its spectral characteristics , which implies that there is no bias towards detecting objects with h@xmath10 absorption . a galaxy with [ ] emission is , of course , easier to identify than if it had had only absorption lines .
however , as we discussed above , the combination of the difficulty of identifying weak emission lines in the face of strong sky subtraction residuals and of the ease of identifying the strong features characteristic of absorption - line galaxies at moderate redshifts suggests that our survey is not strongly biased towards detecting objects with [ ] . by adding together spectra of late - type galaxies in two redshift intervals in order to obtain two spectra with very high signal - to - noise ratios , heyl et al .
( 1996 ) find that the two star - formation indicators [ ] @xmath93727 and h@xmath10 have both become stronger in the higher redshift mean spectrum .
those authors interpreted the increase in the strength of [ ] and h@xmath10 in the @xmath86 spectra to imply that not only were the higher - redshift galaxies forming stars more rapidly , but that also the nature of the star formation was changing with redshift .
specifically , they asserted that the strong h@xmath10 absorption in the higher redshift sample is evidence that the star formation in that sample is dominated by bursts . with our high - quality spectra ,
we can reliably measure [ ] and h@xmath10 without adding together the spectra of many galaxies . in figure
[ figures : o2_and_hd ] , we plot as a function of redshift the fraction of galaxies with [ ] emission and the fraction of galaxies with h@xmath10 absorption .
the vertical dashed line marks the redshift beyond which h@xmath10 is shifted into the region of the spectrum in which sky subtraction becomes increasingly difficult . while the fraction of galaxies with [ ] emission increases with redshift , the fraction of galaxies with strong h@xmath10 absorption shows no significant variation with redshift , suggesting that the star formation is _ not _ occurring in short - lived bursts ( c.f .
, hammer et al .
1997 ) in order to investigate this disagreement more carefully , we repeat the analysis of heyl et al . ( 1996 ) and construct high signal - to - noise ratio composite spectra .
the individual spectra have been median - combined after scaling by the median count level .
the magnitude weights , which correct for our incompleteness at faint magnitudes , have not been applied since scaling by the median count level in each spectrum effectively incorporates the magnitude weights . in figure
[ figures : coadd ] , we plot the composite spectra of galaxies with @xmath138 ( [ ] ) @xmath141 20 , @xmath177 , and either @xmath178 ( thick line , @xmath179 ) or @xmath180 ( thin line , @xmath181 )
. @xmath138 ( [ ] ) @xmath141 20 is typical for the late - type galaxies in which heyl et al .
( 1996 ) observe spectral changes with redshift .
while the [ ] line is modestly stronger in the higher redshift composite spectrum , there is no difference in the strength of h@xmath10 ( which is partially filled - in by emission in both spectra ) , which indicates that the nature of the star formation has not changed from @xmath1 to @xmath182 in contrast to heyl et al .
( 1996 ) , we again do not conclude that the spectra of intermediate - redshift blue galaxies show spectral signs of short bursts of star formation .
( we do not believe that the small differences in the rest - equivalent widths of the ca h and k lines are significant since it is difficult to fit a reliable continuum in the vicinity of the 4000 break . )
the modest increase in the strength of the [ ] line with redshift for galaxies with @xmath183 is due , as previously discussed by cowie et al .
( 1996 ) , to the increase in the intrinsic luminosity of star - forming galaxies with redshift . in figure [ figures : o2_ew ]
, we plot absolute magnitude versus the rest equivalent width of [ ] for the galaxies in our sample divided into four redshift intervals . as the redshift increases ,
more and more luminous galaxies exhibit strong [ ] .
notice , however , that the range of rest equivalent widths does not vary significantly with redshift .
it is difficult to draw firm conclusions about the nature of the evolving galaxy population from the lfs alone .
the lfs provide only a statistical view of the entire population and include information about the evolution of individual galaxies only indirectly .
furthermore , the luminosity of a galaxy is an unreliable tracer of the physical state of the galaxy .
the luminosity of a galaxy , especially in the rest - frame ultraviolet , can change dramatically on short timescales , making the identification of the descendants of distant galaxies in the local population very difficult . in order to make further progress , additional data on the nature of distant galaxies
is required .
the morphologies of distant galaxies , measured with the _ hubble space telescope _ ( hst ) , are already providing crucial clues ( @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) .
the counts of faint elliptical and early - type spiral galaxies match predictions based on counts in the local universe , provided that the local lf is normalized , as advocated here , a factor of @xmath1761.5 - 2 higher than found by loveday et al .
in contrast , the hst number counts of late - type and irregular galaxies are far in excess of the counts expected from observations of nearby galaxies , even with a high normalization of the local lf . an alternative method for selecting distant galaxies
is by their gas absorption cross section .
steidel , dickinson , & persson ( 1994 ) study the evolution of 58 galaxies selected by @xmath1842796 , 2803 absorption seen in the spectra of high - redshift quasars .
these authors found that the galaxies responsible for quasar absorption lines in the range @xmath185 , which typically have luminosities near @xmath54 , do not evolve over the redshift range .
however , their sample is small and , when divided by color , is not inconsistent with results from surveys of galaxies selected by apparent magnitude ( lilly et al .
in addition , steidel et al .
( 1994 ) note that intrinsically faint blue galaxies do not appear in their sample , and so the population of galaxies which is observed to be evolving most rapidly is not included in their survey .
it is now possible , especially with 10m - class telescopes , to measure the masses ( e.g. , vogt et al . 1993 , 1996 ; rix et al .
1996 , guzmn et al . 1996 ) and chemical abundances of distant galaxies . since the masses and metallicities of galaxies evolve more smoothly than the luminosities , measurements of these two quantities will allow more easily interpretable comparisons of distant and local populations ( guzmn et al . 1996 ) .
in addition , the mass and metallicity are , compared to morphology and even gas absorption cross section ( churchill , steidel , & vogt 1996 ) , straightforward to define and interpret . a survey to measure the masses and chemical abundances of the faint blue galaxies ought to yield important insights into the nature of this rapidly evolution galaxy population and aid in the identification of their present - day counterparts .
the lfs of the two superclusters have quite similar shapes and generally resemble the field galaxy lf . since the normalizations of the superclusters lfs are computed in redshift space , in which distances along the line - of - sight may be substantially altered with respect to real space , it is not straighforward to compare the normalization of the supercluster lfs with that of the local field galaxy lf . for the purpose of the discussion here ,
we introduce a factor @xmath186 , the ratio of the redshift - space volume to the real - space volume .
we expect @xmath186 to be in the range @xmath187 .
the lower limit corresponds to assuming that the peculiar velocities in the supercluster regions are small ; the upper limit corresponds to assuming that the depth of the superclusters along the line - of - sight is similar to the linear sizes of the superclusters on the plane of the sky ( @xmath188 mpc ) .
the real - space mean density of galaxies in the corona borealis supercluster , obtained simply by integrating the measured lf data points ( @xmath189 ) , is @xmath190 mpc@xmath32 .
the mean density of field galaxies in the same range of absolute magnitude is @xmath191 mpc@xmath32 .
similarly , the real - space mean density of galaxies in the a2069 supercluster ( @xmath192 ) is @xmath193 mpc@xmath32 , while the mean density of field galaxies in the same range of absolute magnitude is @xmath194 mpc@xmath32 .
thus , the overdensities are @xmath195 and @xmath196 for the corona borealis and a2069 superclusters , respectively .
it is also important to know whether our sampling of the superclusters is biased towards either the abell clusters within the superclusters or the `` field '' of the superclusters .
owing to the difficulties of converting redshift - space volumes to real - space volumes , we assess our sampling of the superclusters using projected surface densities , which are not affected by redshift - space distortions . for the corona borealis supercluster ,
the project surface density @xmath197 is the mean redshift - space galaxy volume density multiplied by the depth in redshift space of the supercluster along the line - of - sight , @xmath198 mpc .
thus , @xmath199 mpc@xmath53 @xmath200 mpc@xmath53 .
we compare this value with the median surface density of the regions surrounding successfully observed corona borealis supercluster galaxies .
we compute the surface density around a given corona borealis supercluster galaxy by counting the number of supercluster galaxies in a 6 arcmin diameter circle surrounding the chosen galaxy . we either simply count the number of galaxies with measured redshifts within the corona borealis supercluster , or we count the total number of galaxies on the original poss - ii @xmath25 plate , weighted by the empirically - determined fraction of galaxies at a given magnitude which are in the supercluster .
the results of these two methods agree well : the median values of the raw and weighted surface densities are @xmath201 mpc@xmath53 and @xmath202 mpc@xmath53 .
these two values bracket the projected surface density measured by multiplying the mean galaxy density ( computed from the lf ) by the line - of - sight depth of the supercluster .
we conclude , therefore , that we have fairly sampled the corona borealis supercluster .
we perform an identical analysis for the background a2069 supercluster .
the redshift - space depth of the a2069 supercluster is also @xmath203 mpc .
given a mean galaxy volume density of @xmath204 mpc@xmath32 , the projected surface density is @xmath205 mpc@xmath53 .
the median surface density of the regions surrounding the successfully observed a2069 supercluster galaxies , computed in the same fashion as for the corona borealis supercluster , is @xmath206 mpc@xmath53 ( unweighted ) or @xmath207 mpc@xmath53 ( weighted ) .
thus , we are slightly biased to the denser regions of the a2069 supercluster .
the overall resemblance between the supercluster lfs and the field galaxy lf suggests that the fundamental physical processes which drive galaxy formation and evolution must not depend strongly on environment .
there are , however , important differences between the lfs in the field and in the superclusters that must ultimately be due to environmental effects .
the most striking difference between the field and supercluster lfs is that the supercluster lfs to do not continue the exponential decline for galaxies brighter than @xmath208 .
both superclusters evidently contain a population of very luminous galaxies . despite the fact that there are only 6 galaxies with @xmath209 in the two superclusters combined ,
it is clear that these galaxies are giant ellipticals found in the densest regions of the superclusters .
the 4 of the 6 for which we have spectra ( the other 2 were taken from the literature ) are dominated by the light of an old , red stellar population .
all of the galaxies are found in regions in the upper 27th percentile of local surace density , with half of them found in regions in the upper 10th percentile .
in fact , the four galaxies in the corona borealis supercluster are all found in the dense ridge of galaxies between the abell clusters a2061 and a2067 . for the corona borealis supercluster , the characteristic magnitude @xmath102 is @xmath210 brighter than in the field and
is quite close to the value measured by colless ( 1989 ) for rich clusters .
there is no significant difference between @xmath102 for the abell 2069 supercluster and that of the field . for the corona borealis supercluster lf
, the data points for the two faintest magnitude bins hint that the lf may steepen significantly for galaxies fainter than @xmath211 .
since the hint is based on only two data points , which are themselves based on only 29 galaxies , we must be cautious in our interpretation .
however , a steepening of the supercluster lf fainter than @xmath211 would be in accord with observations of the faint end of the lf in galaxy clusters and groups , in which a number of workers report steep ( @xmath212 ) lfs ( impey , bothun & malin 1988 ; ferguson & sandage 1991 ; biviano et al . 1995 ; de propris et al . 1995 ; driver & phillipps 1996 ) . with the exception of the study of the coma cluster by biviano et al .
( 1995 ) , the observations of steep faint ends in cluster and group lfs have depended , since redshifts were not available , on the subtraction of a background component from the foreground cluster , a procedure which is prone to systematic errors . although it would be unwise to draw strong conclusions from our two data points , they do have the virtue of being based on galaxies with measured redshifts .
we have presented an analysis of the lf of galaxies in the norris survey of the corona borealis supercluster .
our @xmath7-band lf of local field galaxies , when normalized to counts in high galactic latitude fields , agrees well with the lcrs .
however , the normalization of our @xmath6 local lf is roughly a factor of 1.6 higher than that of the stromlo / apm survey . since lin et al .
( 1996b ) claim that the lcrs local lf agrees well with the stromlo / apm survey , the difference must lie in a systematic photometry error in one ( or more ) of the three surveys . a clue to the nature of this error
is provided by examining the mean colors of norris and lcrs galaxies .
the mean color of local norris galaxies is that of an sb galaxy , whereas the mean color of lcrs galaxies , computed by matching lcrs galaxies directly with galaxies in the apm catalog , is that of an e galaxy . given the agreement of the norris and lcrs @xmath7-band lfs , we therefore believe that the error is most likely in the apm catalog .
indeed , brightening the magnitudes of apm galaxies with @xmath213 by @xmath1760.25@xmath40 would bring all of the local lfs into agreement . a ccd - based local redshift survey ( e.g. , the sloan survey
, gunn & weinberg 1995 ) will certainly resolve any remaining questions about the local lf .
we have observed evolution of the field galaxy lf within our sample , thereby confirming the conclusions drawn from several previous redshift surveys .
the evolution is limited to the population of blue , star - forming galaxies .
the population of blue galaxies becomes more luminous with increasing redshift , and thus the median color of the field galaxy population does not change .
the evolution of the population of blue galaxies is reflected in the larger fraction of galaxies at higher redshift exhibiting spectral signatures of ongoing star formation .
in contrast to the results of heyl et al .
( 1996 ) , but in agreement with hammer et al .
( 1996 ) , we find that the star formation is long - lived .
we do not see evidence for short - term bursts of star formation .
we are unable to detect any evolution of the population of galaxies with @xmath138 ( [ ] ) @xmath142 10 . the fact that the evolution which we observe in our @xmath23- and @xmath7-band selected survey is consistent with the results of the surveys of lilly et al .
( 1995 ) , ellis et al .
( 1996 ) , cowie et al .
( 1996 ) , and lin et al .
( 1996 ) adds to the already strong evidence that a consistent picture of the evolution of the galaxy lf is emerging .
in particular , it is quite reassuring that our lfs agree well with those of lin et al .
( 1996a ) since both used the @xmath23 and @xmath7 bands and should therefore have very similar systematic effects .
the lfs of the two superclusters show significant differences from the field galaxy lf , despite considerable overall similarity .
since the superclusters are @xmath214 denser than the field , we are likely to be observing the influence of the environment on galaxy formation and evolution .
the most prominent difference is an excess of very bright galaxies ( @xmath208 ) relative to the best - fitting schechter function , which accurately describes the field lf over the observed absolute magnitude range .
these very bright galaxies are found in very dense regions of the superclusters and have spectra dominated by an old , red stellar population . in the corona
borealis supercluster , the characteristic magnitude @xmath102 is @xmath210 brighter than in the field .
@xmath102 for the abell 2069 supercluster is , however , very close to the value in the field . we have also presented suggestive evidence that there is a sharp upturn in the supercluster lf for @xmath215 .
while there is also a suggestion of an upturn in the local field galaxy lf for the least luminous galaxies in our survey , it does not appear as dramatic as the upturn seen in the supercluster lf , but more data are needed before the possible difference can be quantified .
we are grateful to the kenneth t. and eileen l. norris foundation for their generous grant for construction of the norris spectrograph .
we thank the staff of the palomar observatory for the expert assistance we have received during the course of the survey , david hogg for many enlightening discussions , and the referee for a careful reading of this paper and helpful suggestions .
this work has been supported by an nsf graduate fellowship ( tas ) and nsf grant ast-92213165 ( wlws ) . | we measure the field galaxy luminosity function ( lf ) as a function of color and redshift from @xmath0 to @xmath1 using galaxies from the norris survey of the corona borealis supercluster .
the data set consists of 603 field galaxies with @xmath2 and spans a wide range in apparent magnitude ( @xmath3 ) , although our field galaxy lf analysis is limited to 493 galaxies with @xmath4 .
we use the observed @xmath5 colors of the galaxies to compute accurate corrections to the rest @xmath6 and @xmath7 bands .
we find that our local @xmath7-band lf , when normalized to counts in high galactic latitude fields , agrees well with the local lf measured in the las campanas redshift survey .
our @xmath6-band local lf , however , does not match the @xmath8-band lf from the stromlo / apm survey , having a normalization 1.6 times higher .
we see compelling evidence that the @xmath6-band field galaxy lf evolves with redshift .
the evolution is strongest for the population of star - forming galaxies with [ ] @xmath93727 rest - frame equivalent widths greater than 10 .
the population of red , quiescent galaxies shows no sign of evolution to @xmath1 .
the evolution of the lf which we observe is consistent with the findings of other faint galaxy redshift surveys .
the fraction of galaxies with [ ] emission increases rapidly with redshift , but the fraction of galaxies with strong h@xmath10 absorption , a signature of a burst of star - formation , does not .
we thus conclude that the star formation in distant galaxies is primarily long - lived .
we also compute the lfs of the corona borealis supercluster ( @xmath11 , 419 galaxies with @xmath12 ) and the abell 2069 supercluster ( @xmath13 , 318 galaxies with @xmath14 ) .
the shapes of the two supercluster luminosity functions are broadly similar to the shape of the local luminosity function .
however , there are important differences .
both supercluster lfs have an excess of very bright galaxies .
in addition , the characteristic magnitude of the corona borealis supercluster lf is roughly half a magnitude brighter than that of the local field galaxy lf , and there is a suggestion of an upturn in the lf for galaxies fainter than @xmath15 . |
over the past few years rapidity gaps , i.e. pseudorapidity regions without hadronic activity , have been observed in hadronic collisions at both the hera @xmath7 collider @xcite and in @xmath8 collisions at the fermilab tevatron @xcite .
such rapidity gaps are widely attributed to the exchange of color singlet quanta between incident partons @xcite , the exchange of two gluons in a color singlet state being the simplest such model @xcite . at the tevatron , a fraction @xmath9 of all dijet events with jet transverse energies @xmath10 gev and jet separations of more than three units of pseudorapidity exhibit rapidity gaps between the jets .
this observation is particularly striking since it demonstrates that color singlet exchange effects in qcd events are relevant at momentum transfers of order 1,000 gev@xmath6 , raising the hope that perturbative methods can be used for quantitative descriptions .
a gap fraction of order one percent was in fact predicted by bjorken @xcite , in terms of a fraction @xmath11 of dijet events which are due to @xmath0-channel color - singlet exchange and a survival probability @xmath12 of rapidity gaps of order 10% @xcite , [ eq : ps ] f_gap = f_s p_s . here
the survival probability estimates the fraction of hard dijet events without an underlying event , i.e. without soft interactions between the other partons in the scattering hadrons .
such multiple interactions would fill the rapidity gap produced in the hard scattering process .
for @xmath13 elastic scattering , bjorken estimated the color - singlet fraction @xmath14 in terms of the imaginary part of the two - gluon @xmath0-channel exchange amplitude , which is known to dominate the forward scattering amplitude for @xmath0-channel color - singlet exchange . in impact parameter space , at impact parameters small
compared to @xmath15 , the result is f_s^impact & = & 29 & & 12 |433 - 2n_f|^2 = 0.15 .
[ eq : fbjorken ] here 2/9 is the relative color factor of the two - gluon color - singlet to the one - gluon color - octet exchange cross section and @xmath16 is an infrared cutoff parameter which regularizes the two - gluon loop - integral .
this model for the calulation of the color singlet fraction @xmath14 , with the two gluon - exchange amplitude replaced by its imaginary part , will be called the two - gluon exchange model in the following . in this model
, the color singlet fraction grows with the color charge of the scattered partons . for @xmath2 and @xmath3 elastic scattering @xmath14
would be larger by factors @xmath17 and @xmath18 , respectively @xcite .
this results in a substantial decrease of the observable gap fraction as the contribution from gluon induced dijet events is reduced , _
e.g. _ by increasing the average transverse momentum of the observed jets and thereby the feynman-@xmath19 values of the incident partons .
such measurements have recently been reported by both the cdf @xcite and the d0 @xcite collaborations , and no such effect is observed .
in fact , the d0 data are compatible with a slight increase of the gap fraction with increasing jet @xmath20 , casting doubt on the validity of the two - gluon exchange model @xcite . in this paper
we reconsider the basic ideas behind the two - gluon exchange model .
we demonstrate its limitations and show that , even when starting from this perturbative picture of rapidity gap formation , the determination of the color singlet exchange fraction @xmath14 is essentially nonperturbative .
we start from a basic feature of the two - gluon exchange model : unitarity fixes the imaginary part of the @xmath0-channel two - gluon exchange amplitude in terms of the born amplitude and this imaginary part dominates @xmath0-channel color singlet exchange @xcite . rewriting this relationship in terms of phase shifts ,
the one- and two - gluon exchange amplitudes are found to be too large to be compatible with unitarity .
phase shift unitarization leads to a more realistic description , in which the total differential cross section remains unchanged compared to the born result , but with @xmath0-channel color singlet exchange fractions which differ substantially from the expectations of the two - gluon exchange model .
these features are demonstrated analytically for fixed values of the strong coupling constant , @xmath21 , in section [ sec2 ] . in section [ sec3 ]
we then perform a numerical analysis for running @xmath21 , showing that the key properties of the fixed-@xmath21 results remain unchanged .
the predicted color singlet fractions are found to very strongly depend on the regularization of gluon exchange at small momentum transfer , however , and thus can not be reliably calculated within perturbation theory .
within our unitarized model the non - perturbative effects can be summarized in terms of two parameters , the survival probability of gaps , @xmath22 , and a universal coulomb phase shift , @xmath23 .
implications for the formation of gaps at the tevatron are analyzed in section [ sec4 ] .
in particular we calculate how the gap fraction between two hard jets varies with jet transverse energies and jet pseudorapidity separation and then compare predicted fractions with tevatron data @xcite .
our conclusions are given in section [ sec5 ] .
consider the elastic scattering of two arbitrary partons , @xmath24 and @xmath25 , p(i_1)+p(j_1)p(i_2)+p(j_2 ) , at momentum transfer @xmath26 . here
@xmath27 denote the colors of the initial and final state partons .
the cross section and the partial wave amplitudes are completely dominated by the forward region , @xmath28 , where the rutherford scattering amplitude , [ eq : mborn ] m = -8_s t^at^a = 8_s f_c = m_0f_c , provides an excellent approximation .
note that helicity is conserved in forward scattering , hence spin need not be considered in the following .
the only process dependence arises from the color factor @xmath29 . in order to study unitarity constraints
, we need to diagonalize the amplitude in both momentum / coordinate space and in color space .
the first step is most easily achieved by transforming to impact parameter space , [ eq : fourier ] t(*b * ) = ( * q * ) e^-i*q * . neglecting multi - parton production processes , _
i.e. _ inelastic channels , unitarity of the @xmath30-matrix implies the relation [ eq : unitarity1 ] t(*b * ) = @xmath31 .
( [ eq : unitarity1 ] ) represents a matrix relation in color space .
more fully it can be written as t(*b*)_i_2 j_2 , i_1 j_1 = _ i , j t(*b*)_i_2 j_2 , i j t^(*b*)_i j , i_1 j_1 , [ eq : unitarity2 ] where the sum runs over the dimension of the color space , @xmath32 for @xmath33 and @xmath13 scattering and @xmath34 ( 64 ) for @xmath2 ( @xmath3 ) elastic scattering . since the color factors can be written as hermitian matrices , the right - hand side of eq .
( [ eq : unitarity2 ] ) represents a simple matrix product of the color matrices .
this product is easily diagonalized by decomposing the color factors @xmath35 into a linear combination of projection operators onto the irreducible color representations which are accessible in the @xmath36-channel , [ eq : col.factor ] f_c = ( f_c)_i_2j_2,i_1j_1 = _ k f_k ( p_k)_i_2j_2,i_1j_1 = _ k f_k p_k .
for the case of quark - antiquark elastic scattering , for example , with color decomposition @xmath37 , the color factor can be written in terms of gell - mann matrices as ( f_c)_i_2j_2,i_1j_1 = ( ^a2 ) _ i_2i_1 ( ^a2 ) _
j_1j_2 = 49_j_1i_1_i_2j_2- 13(^a2 ) _
j_1i_1 ( ^a2 ) _
i_2j_2 = 43p_1 - 16 p_8 . for all cases , @xmath13 , @xmath33 , @xmath2 and @xmath3 elastic scattering ,
the decomposition into @xmath36-channel projectors is summarized in table [ tab : colorop ] .
this color decomposition , combined with the transformation to impact parameter space , diagonalizes the unitarity relation for elastic scattering amplitudes .
.representations and color operators for qcd elastic scattering .
the indices of the projection operators @xmath38 in the last column represent the dimensionalities of the irreducible color representations in the @xmath36-channel .
results for the @xmath39 decomposition are taken from ref .
@xcite . [ cols="^,<,<,^",options="header " , ]
both the d0 @xcite and the cdf @xcite collaborations at the tevatron have analyzed the fraction of dijet events with rapidity gaps , as a function of both the transverse energy , @xmath20 , and the pseudorapidity separation , @xmath40 , of the two jets .
as these phase space variables change , the composition of dijet events varies , from mostly gluon initiated processes at small @xmath20 and @xmath41 ( and , hence , small feynman-@xmath19 , @xmath42 ) to @xmath13 scattering at large values .
a dependence of the gap fraction on the color structure of the scattering partons would thus be reflected in a variation with @xmath20 and @xmath41 .
bjorken s two gluon exchange model , which is equivalent to the small @xmath43 region in our analysis , predicts a larger fraction of color singlet exchange events for gluon initiated processes @xcite ( see fig . [
fig : fs.vs.psi ] for @xmath44 ) .
the gap fraction should thus decrease with increasing @xmath20 or @xmath41 .
the opposite behavior is expected in statistical models of color rearrangement @xcite . here
the eight color degrees of freedom for gluons , as compared to three for quarks , make it less likely for gluon initiated processes that @xmath0-channel color singlet exchange is achieved by random color rearrangement .
this would lead to a smaller gap fraction at small @xmath42 and therefore small @xmath20 or @xmath41 . in the unitarized rpwe framework ,
the dependence on the regularization parameters is sufficiently strong to encompass both scenarios .
this is demonstrated in figs .
[ fig : fgap.exp.d0 ] and [ fig : fgap.exp.cdf ] , where the results of the running coupling analysis for three choices of the regularization parameters are compared with tevatron data , taken at @xmath45 gev .
the data correspond to dijet events with two opposite hemisphere jets of @xmath46 gev , @xmath47 ( cdf ) or @xmath48 gev , @xmath49 ( d0 ) .
d0 data are taken from ref .
@xcite and show the fraction of dijet events with rapidity gaps .
cdf @xcite shows the ratio of gap fractions in individual @xmath41 and @xmath20 bins to the overall gap fraction in the acceptance region . for comparing our calculation with the data we fix the survival probability @xmath22 in eq .
( [ eq : ps ] ) to reproduce the overall gap fraction in the acceptance region , which was measured as @xmath50 for the d0 sample and @xmath51 for the cdf sample .
required survival probabilities strongly depend on regularization parameters and vary between 1.9% and 5.5% , which is on the low side of previous estimates @xcite . for a given choice of regularization parameters , predictions for the @xmath20 or @xmath41 dependence of the gap fraction
are quite similar for the cdf and d0 cuts . to the extent that the two data sets are consistent within errors , it is not yet possible to discriminate between different choices of regularization parameters , i.e. to obtain sensitivity to the non - perturbative dynamics .
d0 data somewhat favor color singlet fractions which grow with @xmath42 and which are more in line with expectations from color evaporation models @xcite . note that our unitarized gluon exchange model , with @xmath52 gev and @xmath53 gev is able to describe this trend , even though it is an extension of the two - gluon exchange model .
cdf data slightly prefer a gap fraction which decreases with increasing @xmath41 and , hence , with larger @xmath42 . the unitarized gluon exchange model , with @xmath54 gev and @xmath55 gev describes such a situation .
comparison with fig .
[ fig : fs.reg.dep ] shows that this set of parameters predicts a much smaller gap fraction for @xmath13 scattering than for gluon initiated processes , which is qualitatively similar to the two - gluon exchange model @xcite .
indeed , the shape of the gap fraction for the two gluon exchange model is very similar to the long - dashed curves in fig . [
fig : fgap.exp.cdf ] .
clearly , the data are not yet precise enough to unambiguously distinguish between these different scenarios . on the theoretical side ,
the variation of the rpwe predictions with model parameters highlights the limitations of a perturbative approach to the color singlet exchange probability . taking the phase @xmath23 and the survival probability @xmath22 as free parameters ,
the unitarized two - gluon exchange model is clearly capable of fitting the present tevatron data , however .
the formation of rapidity gaps in hadronic scattering events is a common occurrence , and its ubiquity asks for a theoretical explanation within qcd .
the formation of gaps between two hard jets at the tevatron is particularly intriguing and is commonly being explained in terms of color singlet exchange in the @xmath0-channel , be it via an effective color singlet object like the `` pomeron '' or via a statistical color rearrangement , in terms of multiple soft gluon exchange .
`` pomeron '' exchange models build on the observation that color singlet exchange in the @xmath0-channel can be achieved in qcd via the exchange of two gluons , with compensating colors @xcite .
when trying to build a quantitative model for the formation of rapidity gaps @xcite , one encounters infrared divergences in the color singlet hard scattering amplitude , which in a full treatment would be regularized by the finite size and the color singlet nature of physical hadrons @xcite . in turn , this indicates that non - perturbative information may be indispensable for a quantitative understanding of the hard color singlet exchange process .
we have analyzed this question within a particular model , based on the unitarization of single gluon exchange in the @xmath0-channel .
the low - nussinov model @xcite corresponds to a truncation of the unitarization at order @xmath56 .
we find that , for any reasonable range of regularization parameters , the two - gluon exchange approximation violates partial wave unitarity , and thus a fully unitarized amplitude is needed for phenomenological applications .
the unitarization of hard elastic quark and gluon scattering is not unique , of course , but any acceptable method must preserve the successful description of hard dijet events by perturbative qcd .
the phase shift approach used here fulfills this requirement : the unitarization does not change the born - level predictions for the color averaged differential cross sections . as a corollary ,
the color - inclusive dijet cross section is independent of the regularization parameters which need to be introduced for the full phase shift analysis .
the situation is entirely different when considering the @xmath0-channel color singlet exchange component which is introduced by the exchange of two or more gluons or by unitarization .
the @xmath0-channel color singlet exchange fraction , @xmath14 , is strongly affected by the full unitarization and deviates from the expectations of the two - gluon exchange approximation , changing even the qualitative predictions of the low - nussinov model .
these strong unitarization effects are reflected by a strong dependence on the precise regularization procedure .
this cutoff dependence , which parameterizes non - perturbative effects , does not allow to make quantitative predictions for the color singlet exchange fractions in particular partonic subprocesses .
these limitations , which have been demonstrated here for the two - gluon exchange approximation to the pomeron , may be generic to pomeron exchange models , and should be analyzed more generally . in spite of these limitations , we find some intriguing features of the unitarized gluon exchange amplitudes .
for all partonic subprocesses and for all regularization parameters , the color singlet exchange fractions can be described in terms of a single universal phase , @xmath57 , which absorbs all non - perturbative effects .
this suggests a unified phenomenological description of the rapidity gap data , via the gap survival probability @xmath22 and the phase @xmath57 .
such an analysis goes beyond the transverse momentum and pseudorapidity dependence of rapidity gap fractions which have just become available , and should best be performed directly by the experimental collaborations .
we would like to thank f. halzen and j. pumplin for useful discussions on the physics of rapidity gaps .
this research was supported in part by the u.s .
department of energy under grant no .
de - fg02 - 95er40896 , and in part by the university of wisconsin research committee with funds granted by the wisconsin alumni research foundation .
e. berger , j. collins , g. sterman , and d.soper , nucl .
* b286 * , 704 ( 1987 ) ; n. nikolaev and b. zakharov , z. phys .
* c53 * , 331 ( 1992 ) ; v. del duca , scientifica acta * 10 * , 91 ( 1995 ) [ hep - ph/9503226 ] ; e. levin , proceedings of the _ gleb wataghin school on high energy phenomenology _ , campinas , brazil , july 1116 , 1994 , [ hep - ph/9503399 ] ; and references therein . d. zeppenfeld , in _ particles and fields _ , proceedings of the
_ viiith j. a. swieca summer school _ , rio de janeiro , brazil , february 618 , 1995 , ed . by j. barcelos - neto , s. f. novaes , and v. o. rivelles ( world scientific , singapore , 1996 ) , p. 78
[ hep - ph/9603315 ] . | rapidity gaps between two hard jets at the tevatron have been interpreted as being due to the exchange of two gluons which are in an overall color - singlet state .
we show that this simple picture involves unitarity violating amplitudes .
unitarizing the gluon exchange amplitude leads to qualitatively different predictions for the fraction of @xmath0-channel color singlet exchange events in forward @xmath1 , @xmath2 or @xmath3 scattering , which better fit tevatron data .
= cmssbx10 scaled 2 to + r. oeckl@xmath4 and d. zeppenfeld@xmath5 + .5 cm @xmath5_department of physics , university of wisconsin , madison , wi 53706 , usa _
+ @xmath6_damtp , university of cambridge , cambridge cb3 9ew , uk _ |
strong electronic interactions are known to play a central role in disordered solids , of which coulomb glasses are a canonical example .
the lack of metallic screening on the insulating side of the metal - insulator transition ( mit ) enables long - range coulomb interactions @xcite .
efros and shklovskii ( es ) , following the original considerations for the non - interacting fermi glass case of mott@xcite , derived a form for the t = 0 k photon assisted frequency dependent conductivity describing the crossover from interacting coulomb glass - like behavior to fermi glass - like behavior@xcite .
these derivations were based on a theory of resonant absorption@xcite and take into account the mean coulomb interaction between two sites forming a resonant pair @xmath1 , where @xmath2 $ ] is the most probable hop distance between pairs and @xmath3 is the dielectric constant . the real part of the es crossover form for the frequency dependent conductivity is : @xmath4^{4}[\hbar\omega + u(r_{w } ) ] \label{eq : esxover}\ ] ] where @xmath5 is a constant of order one , @xmath6 is the non - interacting single particle density of states ( dos ) , @xmath7 is the pre - factor of the overlap integral and @xmath8 is the localization length . the concentration dependent localization length is predicted to diverge as @xmath9 as the mit is approached , where @xmath10 is the dopant concentration , @xmath11 is the critical dopant concentration of the mit ( @xmath12 in si : p@xcite ) and @xmath13 is the localization length exponent . neglecting logarithmic factors , eq .
( [ eq : esxover ] ) predicts a gradual crossover from linear to quadratic behavior as the incident photon energy exceeds the interaction energy of a typical charge excitation .
for the case where the photon energy , @xmath14 , one recovers the quadratic frequency dependence , plus logarithmic corrections , that mott originally derived for the non - interacting fermi glass case@xcite . in the opposite limit , @xmath15 the conductivity shows an approximately linear dependence on frequency , plus logarithmic corrections , and the material is called a coulomb glass .
we should note that eq .
( [ eq : esxover ] ) was derived for the case where @xmath16 , the coulomb gap width .
however a quasi - linear dependence ( albeit with a different pre - factor ) and an eventual crossover to mott s non - interacting quadratic law is still expected even for the case where @xmath17 .
@xmath18 there is a lack of experimental evidence to either corroborate or disprove eq .
( [ eq : esxover ] ) due to the difficulties associated with performing frequency dependent measurements in the so - called quantum limit , i.e. @xmath0 , but at small enough photon energies so as to not be exciting charge carriers to the conduction band .
moreover , in order to study the possible crossover from mott to es type behavior , one must measure across a broad enough bandwidth centered about the characteristic crossover energy scale for instance the coulomb interaction energy @xmath19 or the coulomb gap width@xcite , @xmath20 .
there have been some very recent experiments that have attempted to address these issues .
m. lee et al . found that for concentrations close to the mit the expected linear to quadratic crossover occurs , but is much sharper than predicted @xcite .
they proposed that this sharp crossover was controlled not by the average interaction strength @xmath19 as in eq.([eq : esxover ] ) @xcite , but instead by a sharp feature in the density of states , i.e. the coulomb gap @xcite .
they postulated that this coulomb gap was not the single particle one measured in tunneling , but rather a smaller `` dressed '' or renormalized coulomb gap that governs transport .
there is some evidence from dc transport that such a feature exists , at least close to the mit @xcite .
nominally uncompensated n - type silicon samples were obtained from recticon enterprises inc . a czochralski method grown boule with a phosphorous gradient along its length
was cut into 1 mm thick discs .
room temperature resistivity was measured using an ade 6035 gauge and the dopant concentration calibrated using the thurber scale@xcite .
the si : p samples discussed here span a range from 39% to 69% , stated as a percentage of the sample s dopant concentration to the critical concentration at the mit .
a number of samples were measured before and after etching with a @xmath21 solution ; this resulted in no difference in the results . in the millimeter spectral range , 80 ghz to 1000 ghz , backward wave oscillators ( bwo )
were employed as coherent sources in a transmission configuration@xcite .
the transmitted power through the si : p samples as a function of frequency was recorded . for plane waves normally incident on a material ,
resonances occur whenever the thickness of the material is an integer number of half wavelengths .
both components of the complex conductivity can be uniquely determined for each resonance .
the real part of the conductivity was evaluated at microwave frequencies from the measured loss of highly sensitive resonant cavities at 35 and 60 ghz via the perturbation method .
this is a common technique and is described in the literature@xcite .
the conductivity as determined from the resonant cavity data was normalized to the dc conductivity at higher temperatures , at above approximately 25 k. the resonant cavity data confirmed the linear dependence on frequency of the real part of the complex conductivity into the microwave regime for the samples closest to critical .
in fig . [ armitagecg1 ] , we show the t@xmath220 frequency dependent conductivity for two samples .
this data , representative of all samples in our range , shows an approximately linear dependence at low frequencies and then a sharp crossover to an approximately quadratic behavior at higher frequencies .
this is the qualitatively expected behavior from eq .
( [ eq : esxover ] ) . however , as seen by the overlayed fits , eq .
( [ eq : esxover ] ) provides only a rough guide .
the solid lines are linear and quadratic fits to the low frequency and high frequency data respectively .
the dotted line is a fit to the form of the es crossover function achieved by summing the separately determined linear and quadratic fits .
as can be seen , the crossover between linear and quadratic portions is much more abrupt than the es function predicts .
the dashed line is a fit using the same method as ref .
@xcite , namely forcing the linear portion to pass through the low frequency data , as well as the origin and leaving the pre - factor of the quadratic term as a free variable .
the fit is not satisfactory in either case .
a sharp crossover as such is observed over our entire doping range and has been observed previously in an analogous system , si : b , for samples closer to the mit @xcite . note , that a linear dependence is seen in the imaginary part of the conductivity @xmath23 over the whole measured frequency and doping range @xcite .
this is consistent with theoretical predictions @xcite . because our data spans a large range of concentrations , the doping dependence of the crossover energy scale can be analyzed to see whether its dependence is consistent with other energy scales , e.g. the coulomb interaction energy @xmath19 or the coulomb gap width @xmath20 as @xmath24 ref .
recall that the coulomb interaction energy between two sites forming a resonant pair is @xmath25 which is dependent on concentration via the dielectric constant ( measured , but not shown ) and the localization length dependent most probable hop distance . by equating the crossover energy scale to the expected functional form for this coulomb interaction energy we are able to determine the magnitude of the localization length and its scaling exponent . with an appropriate pre - factor in the overlap integral @xcite , @xmath26 for the expression for the most probable hop distance term , @xmath27 , we get a localization length dependence of @xmath28 with a magnitude of 21.2 , 19.9 , 20.1 , 14.5 , 14.3 and 13.0 nm for the 69% , 62% , 56% , 50% , 45% and 39% samples respectively .
the localization length exponent is close to unity , the value originally predicted by mcmillan in his scaling theory of the mit @xcite , and the magnitude of the localization length is reasonable . due to the fact that we obtain reasonable estimates for the relevant physical parameters over the whole doping range
, we do not favor the previous speculation that it is in fact the coulomb gap energy that creates the sharp crossover and hence sets its energy scale@xcite .
the approximately linear power law seen in the coulomb glass regime at low @xmath29 in fig .
[ armitagecg1 ] of the conductivity can be expressed with the imaginary part as a simple kramer - kronig compatible form , @xmath30 in order to determine the power @xmath31 one can take the ratio of @xmath32 versus @xmath33 ( with the frequency as a variable ) .
the power @xmath31 is given by , @xmath34 as determined from eq .
3 . the dashed line through the nbsi data is a guide to the eye .
the bottom panel shows the divergence of the prefactor of the real part of the conductivity , and the dotted line is a simple power law fit.,width=264 ] fig .
[ armitagecg2]a shows the ratio mentioned above of the imaginary to the real part of the dielectric constant for si : p .
similar data from amorphous nbsi is included for comparison purposes@xcite .
we note that this ratio for si : p is large and essentially constant across the entire doping range . from eq .
( [ eq : esingap ] ) , one expects @xmath35 to be approximately equal to @xmath32 to within a factor of 2 - 5 ( with a reasonable estimate for @xmath7 ) because @xmath36 .
applied to si : p , the theory correctly predict a linear correspondence between @xmath33 and @xmath32 , but incorrectly predicts the proportionality by at least a factor of thirty .
the proportionality is near the predicted value for nbsi , but has a dependence on the doping concentration which is presumably due to entering the quantum critical ( qc ) regime as discussed below .
here we have used the susceptibility @xmath37 of the dopant electrons ( i.e. with the background dielectric constant of silicon subtracted ) in the expression for the magnitude of the imaginary component of the conductivity in eq .
[ eq : alpha ] . the middle panel in fig .
[ armitagecg2 ] shows the power @xmath31 as determined by eq .
( [ eq : alpha ] ) . the values for si : p are approximately equal to , but slightly less than one , consistent with fig .
[ armitagecg1 ] .
this indicates that the prefactor of the real and imaginary components of the complex conductivity have the same concentration dependence .
the situation is different for nbsi . near the mit , @xmath38 is expected to cross over to the qc dynamics @xcite , i.e. @xmath39 when @xmath8 , the localization length , is of the same scale as @xmath40 , the dephasing length ( the characteristic frequency dependent length scale ) @xcite .
this should be a smooth crossover and therefore looking at a fixed window of frequencies , a continuous change from @xmath41 is expected , similar to that measured for nbsi shown in the middle panel of fig [ armitagecg2 ] . setting the relations for localization length and dephasing length equal @xcite
, one finds the crossover condition for the frequency in terms of the normalized concentration , @xmath42 where @xmath43 is the dynamic exponent . as the prefactor can vary from system to system , the fact that we see an @xmath44 across our entire doping range in si : p , but an @xmath31 that approaches @xmath45 in nbsi indicates that the critical regime in si : p is much narrower and out of our experimental window .
this is consistent with simple dimensional arguments@xcite that show the crossover should be inversely proportional to the dopant density of states . the much smaller dopant density in si : p vs. nbsi ( a factor of @xmath46 ) is consistent with a narrower qc regime as compared to nbsi . the bottom panel in fig .
[ armitagecg2 ] shows magnitude of the real part of the conductivity as the mit is approached .
this demonstrates that the prefactor a can be written as a function of the normalized concentration , i.e. @xmath47 for si : p .
in @xmath48 interacting systems , the effects of correlations become simpler as one goes to lower energies and/or lower temperatures .
the canonical example of this is a fermi liquid where at t=0 and @xmath29=0 one recovers the non - interacting theory , but with parameters that are substantially modified ( renormalized ) from the free electron ones .
the coulomb glass is a fundamentally important example in solid state physics because it belongs to a class of systems where this does not occur and the non - interacting functional forms are not recovered at asymptotically low energies . as predicted in the crossover function eq .
[ eq : esxover ] , we have observed in si : p that the non - interacting functional form is recovered in the high - frequency limit and the low - frequency response shows interactions . within the theory
this is a result of the additional internal excitation structure of a resonant pair caused by interactions and the fact that any one pair can be thought of as a distinct entity , well separated in energy from other spatially nearby pairs because of the large disorder induced energy spread .
this internal structure enables the excitation of pairs relatively deep within the fermi sea and changes the factor in the initial state phase space from @xmath29 to @xmath49 .
in contrast , in amorphous nbsi a smooth crossover is observed as the mit is approached from a linear frequency dependence to a power law characterized by an exponent smaller than unity .
this is consistent with the eventual frequency dependence @xmath50 expected from quantum critical scaling arguments .
no crossover to @xmath51 was observed in nbsi . since it is the exponent @xmath31 that distills the important physics ( it indicates the phase space of initial states for @xmath31 = 1 or 2 and the presence of critical dynamics for @xmath52 )
, we propose that one can classify the electrodynamics of electron glasses based on their @xmath31 value . a schematic showing the parameter space for @xmath31
is shown in fig .
[ armitagecg3 ] . here
one has @xmath31
s close to @xmath45 near the mit .
there is a smooth crossover to coulomb glass - like @xmath53 at lower doping levels and an intervening non - interacting fermi glass regime at even higher energies and lower dopings .
we expect that these general considerations are valid , despite the fact that some of the parameter space may not be accessible in certain systems .
for instance , one may begin to excite structural modes at energies high enough to see @xmath51 behavior in nbsi . for dopings not close enough to critical in si : p , excitation to the conduction band
may be observed before critical dynamics are . for @xmath54 .
note that the boundaries drawn on the plot are smooth crossovers and not sharp onsets . a classification based on @xmath31
gives a taxonomy for the electrodynamics of electron glasses.,width=264 ]
in summary , we have observed a crossover in the frequency dependence of the conductivity from coulomb glass - like behavior to fermi glass - like behavior across our entire range of doping concentrations in si : p .
the existence of a crossover is consistent with theoretical predictions , but it is sharper than predicted . the fact that we see the same functional form over the whole doping range ( even deep into the insulating regime , where eq .
[ eq : esxover ] is expected to be more valid ) shows that the nature of the low energy charge excitations is qualitatively the same over the whole doping range ; the inadequacy of eq .
[ eq : esxover ] in describing the frequency dependent conductivity quantitatively is not limited to concentrations close to critical . in the amorphous semiconductor nbsi
, we observe a gradual crossover from @xmath53 coulomb glass - like behavior to quantum critical - like dynamics .
this comparison allows us to obtain a general classification scheme for the electrodynamics of electron glasses based on the exponent of the frequency dependence @xmath31 .
we expect that this classification or ` taxonomy ' will be valid even when certain regimes are not experimentally accessible .
we wish to thank phu tran for assisting with the cavity measurements and barakat alavi for assisting with the sample preparation .
we would also like to thank steve kivelson and boris shklovskii for helpful conversations .
this research was supported by the national science foundation grant dmr-0102405 . | we report measurements of the real and imaginary parts of the ac conductivity in the quantum limit , @xmath0 of insulating nominally uncompensated n - type silicon .
the observed frequency dependence shows evidence for a crossover from interacting coulomb glass - like behavior at lower energies to non - interacting fermi glass - like behavior at higher energies across a broad doping range . the crossover is sharper than predicted and
can not be described by any existing theories . despite this
, the measured crossover energy can be compared to the theoretically predicted coulomb interaction energy and reasonable estimates of the localization length obtained from it .
based on a comparison with the amorphous semiconductor nbsi , we obtain a general classification scheme for electrodynamics of electron glasses . |
numerous techniques for forecasting electric energy consumption have been proposed in the last few decades . for operators , energy consumption ( load )
forecast is useful in effectively managing power systems .
consumers can also benefit from the forecasted information in order to yield maximum satisfaction .
in addition to these economic reasons , load forecasting has also been used for system security purposes . when deployed to handle system security problems
, it provides expedient information for detecting vulnerabilities in advance .
forecasting energy consumed within a particular geographical area greatly depends on several factors , such as , historical load , mean atmospheric temperature , mean relative humidity , population , gdp per capita . over the years
, there has been rapid growth annually of about 10% from year 1999 to 2005 for energy demand in the gaza strip . with about 75% of energy demands from service and household sectors ,
these demands are barely met @xcite . in order to meet these demands and
efficiently utilize the limited energy , it is imperative to observe historic trends and make futuristic plans based on past data . in the past ,
computationally easier approaches like regression and interpolation , have been used , however , this methods may not give sufficiently accurate results .
as advances in technology and sophisticated tools are made , complex algorithmic approaches are introduced and more accuracy at the expense of heavy computational burden can be observed .
several algorithms have been proposed by several researchers to tackle electric energy consumption forecasting problem .
previous works can be grouped into three@xcite : _ * time series approach : * _ : : in this approach , the trend for electric energy consumption is handled as a time series signal .
future consumption is usually predicted based on various time series analysis techniques .
however , time series approach is characterized with prediction inaccuracies of prediction and numerical instability .
this inaccurate results is due to the fact the approach does not utilize weather information .
studies have shown that there is a strong correlation between the behavior of energy consumed and weather variables .
zhou r. _ et al_. @xcite proposed a data driven modeling method using time series analysis to predict energy consumed within a building . the model in @xcite
was applied on two commercial building and is limited to energy prediction within a building .
basu k. _ et al_. @xcite also used the time series approach to predict appliance usage in a building for just an hour .
+ simmhan y. _ et al_. @xcite used an incremental time series clustering approach to predict energy consumption .
this method in @xcite was able to minimize the prediction error , however , very large number of data points were required .
autoregressive integrated moving average ( arima ) is a vastly used time series approach .
arima model was used by chen j. _ et al_. @xcite to predict energy consumption in jiangsu province in china based on data collected from year 1985 to 2007 .
the model @xcite was able to accurately predict the energy consumption , however it was limited to that environment .
the previous works on time series usually use computationally complex matrix - oriented adaptive algorithms which , in most scenarios , may become unstable . _ * functional based approach : * _ : : here , a functional relationship between a load dependent variable ( usually weather ) and the system load is modelled .
future load is then predicted by inserting the predicted weather information into the pre - defined functional relationship .
most regression methods use functional relationships between weather variables and up - to - date load demands .
linear representations are used as forecasting functions in conventional regression methods and this method finds an appropriate functional relationship between selected weather variables and load demand .
liu d. _ et al_. @xcite proposed a support vector regression with radial basis function to predict energy consumption in a building .
the approach in @xcite was only able to forecast the energy consumed due to lighting for some few hours .
+ in @xcite , a grey model , multiple regression model and a hybrid of both were used to forecast energy consumption in zhejiang province of china .
yi w. _ et al_. @xcite proposed an ls - svm regression model to also forecast energy consumption .
however , these models were limited to a specific geographic area . _
* soft computing based approach : * _ : : this is a more intelligent approach that is extensively being used for demand side management .
it includes techniques such as fuzzy logic , genetic algorithm and artificial neural networks ( ann ) ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ?
? * ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the ann approach is based on examining the relationship that exist between input and output variables .
ann approach was used in @xcite to forecast regional load in taiwan .
empirical data was used to effectively develop an ann model which was able to predict the regional peak load .
catalo j. p. s. _ et al_. @xcite used the ann approach to forecast short - term electricity prices .
levenberg - marquardt s algorithm was used to train data and the resulting model @xcite was able to accurately forecast electricity prices .
however , it was only able to predict electricity prices for about 168 hours .
+ pinto t. _ et al_. @xcite also worked on developing an ann model to forecast electricity market prices with a special feature of dynamism .
this model @xcite performs well when a small set of data is trained , however , it is likely to perform poorly with large number of data due to the computational complexities involved .
load data from year 2006 to 2009 were gathered and used to develop an ann model for short - term load forecast in @xcite . in @xcite , ann hybrid with invasive weed optimization ( iwo )
was employed to forecast the electricity prices in the australian market .
the hybrid model @xcite showed good performance , however , the focus was on predicting electricity prices in australia .
most of the ann models developed in existing work considered some specific geographic area@xcite , some models were able to forecast energy consumption for buildings ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) and only for few hours@xcite .
this study used available historical data from year 1994 to 2013 ( but trained data from year 1994 to 2011 ) in determining a suitable model .
the resulting model from training will be used to predict electric energy consumption for future years ] , while the error criteria such as mean squared error ( mse ) , root mean squared error ( rmse ) , mean absolute error ( mae ) and mean absolute percentage error ( mape ) are used as measures to justify the appropriate model @xcite .
the model was used to predict the behavior for year 2012 and 2013 .
the remainder of this paper is organized as follows : section [ sec:2 ] gives a brief description of the ann concept .
section [ sec:3 ] presents the ann approach used to analyse our data .
section [ sec:4 ] evaluates the performance of the ann model .
section [ sec:5 ] draws conclusions .
ann is a system based on the working principles of biological neural networks , and is defined as a mimicry of biological neural systems .
ann s are at the vanguard of computational systems designed to create or mimic intelligent behavior . unlike classical artificial intelligence ( ai ) systems that are aimed at directly emulating rational and logical reasoning ,
ann s are targeted at reproducing the causal processing mechanisms that give results to intelligence as a developing property of complex systems .
ann systems have been designed for fields such as capacity planning , business intelligence , pattern recognition , robotics . .
in computer science and engineering , ann techniques has gained a lot of grounds and is vastly deployed in areas such as forecasting , data analytics and even data mining .
the science of raw data examination with the aim of deriving useful conclusions can simply be defined as data analytics .
on the other hand , data mining describes the process of determining new patterns from large data sets , by applying a vast set of approaches from statistics , artificial intelligence , or database management .
forecasting is useful in predicting future trends with reliance on past data .
the focus on this paper will be on using the ann approach in forecasting energy consumption .
practically , ann provides accurate approximation of both linear and non - linear functions . a mathematical abstraction of the internal structure of a neuron is shown in fig .
[ fig:1 ] . despite the presence of noise or incomplete information
, it is possible for neurons to learn the behaviour or trends and consequently , make useful conclusions .
usually , a neural network is trained to perform a specific function by adjusting weight values between elements as seen in fig . [ fig:2](a ) .
the neural network function is mainly determined by the connections between the elements @xcite . by observing the data ,
it is possible for the ann to make accurate predictions .
unlike other forecasting approach , the ann technique has the ability to predict future trends with theoretically poor , but rich data set .
in this section , we present the overall modeling process .
the implementation of the ann model can be described using the flow chart in fig . [ fig:2](b ) .
historical monthly data ( historical energy consumption , mean atmospheric temperature , mean relative humidity , population , gdp per capita ) has been gathered from years 1994 to 2013 from gaza region as shown in fig .
[ fig:3 ] . based on the gathered data ,
this study will develop a forecast model that predicts energy consumption for year 2012 and 2013 . using the ann technique , training and learning procedures are fundamental in forecasting future events .
the training of feed - forward networks is usually carried out in a supervised manner @xcite . with a set of data to be trained ( usually extracted from the historical data ) , it is possible to derive an efficient forecast model .
the proper selection of inputs for ann training plays a vital role to the success of the training process . on the other hand ,
the learning process involves providing both input and output data , the network processes the input and compares the resulting output with desired result .
the system then adjusts the weights which acts as a control for error minimization . in order to minimize error
, the process is repeated until a satisfactory criterion for convergence is attained .
the knowledge acquired by the ann via the learning process is tested by applying it to a new data set that has not been used before , called the testing set .
it should now be possible that the network is able to make generalizations and provide accurate result for new data .
due to insufficient information , some networks do not converge .
it is also noteworthy that over - training the ann can seriously deteriorate forecasts .
also , if the ann is fed with redundant or inaccurate information , it may destabilize the system .
training and learning process should be thorough in order to achieve good results . to accurately forecast
, it is imperative to consider all possible factors that influence electricity energy consumption , which is not feasible in reality .
electric energy consumption is influenced by a number of factors , which includes : historical energy consumption , mean atmospheric temperature , mean relative humidity , population , gdp per capita , ppp , etc . in this paper ,
different criteria were used to evaluate the accuracy of the ann approach in forecasting electric energy consumption in gaza .
they include : mean squared error ( mse ) , root mean squared error ( rmse ) , mean absolute error ( mae ) and mean absolute percentage error ( mape ) .
a popular and important criterion used for performance analysis is the mse .
it is used to relay concepts of bias , precision and accuracy in statistical estimation . here
, the difference between the estimated and the actual value is used to get the error , the average of the square of the error gives an expression for mse .
the mse criterion is expressed in equation ( [ eqn:1 ] ) .
@xmath0 where @xmath1 is the actual data and @xmath2 is the forecasted data .
the rmse is a quadratic scoring rule which measures the average magnitude of the error .
the rmse criterion is expressed in equation ( [ eqn:2 ] ) .
rmse usually provides a relatively high weight to large errors due to the fact that averaging is carried out after errors are squared .
this makes this criterion an important tool when large errors are specifically undesired . @xmath3
the mae measures the average error function for forecasts and actual data with polarity elimination .
equation ( [ eqn:3 ] ) gives the expression for the mae criterion used .
the mae is a linear score which implies that all the individual differences are weighted equally in the average .
@xmath4 mape , on the other hand , measures the size of the error in percentage ( % ) terms .
it is calculated as the average of the unsigned percentage error .
equation ( [ eqn:4 ] ) gives the expression for the mape criterion used .
@xmath5 validation techniques are employed to tackle fundamental problems in pattern recognition ( model selection and performance estimation ) . in this study , 2-fold and
k - fold cross validation techniques will be employed and the validation set will only be used as part of training and not part of the test set .
the test set will be used to evaluate how well the learning algorithm works as a whole .
the forecast model was simulated to obtain results of the energy consumed for year 2012 and 2013 in gaza .
table 1 compares the actual and the forecasted energy consumption for year 2012 .
2-fold and k - fold cross validation techniques were used and the performance of the forecast model based on different error criteria is shown in table 2 .
similarly , table 3 and 4 shows the results for year 2013 .
the results obtained have good accuracy and shows that the proposed ann model can be used to predict future trends of electric energy consumption in gaza .
.2-fold and k - fold cross validation for year 2012 [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ tab:4 ]
in this paper , an ann model to forecast electric energy consumption in the gaza strip was presented . to the best of our knowledge ,
this is the first of it s kind in existing literature .
based on the performance evaluation , the error criteria were within tolerable bounds .
empirical results presented in this paper indicates the relevance of the proposed ann approach in forecasting electric energy consumption .
future works will consider other forecasting techniques .
park d. c. , el - sharkawi m. a. , marks ii r. j. , atlas l. e. and damborg m. j.,(1991 ) electric load forecasting using an artificial neural network , _ ieee transactions on power engineering _ , vol.6 , pp .
442 - 449 zhou r. , pan y. , huand z. and wang q. , ( 2013 ) building energy use prediction using time series analysis , _
ieee 6th international conference on service - oriented computing and applications _ , pp .
309 - 313 .
basu k. , debusschere v. and bacha s. , ( 2012 ) appliance usage prediction using a time series based classification approach , _
ieee 38th annual conference on ieee industrial electronics society _ , pp .
1217 - 1222 . catalo j. p. s. , mariano s. j. p. s. , mendes v. m. f. and ferreira l. a. f. m. , ( 2007 ) an artificial neural network approach for short - term electricity prices forecasting , _ ieee intelligent systems applications to power systems _ , pp
. 1 - 7 .
pinto t. , sousa t. m. and vale z. , ( 2012 ) dynamic artificial neural network for electricity market prices forecast , _
ieee 16th international conference on intelligent engineering systems _ , pp .
311 - 316 . khamis m. f. i. , baharudin z. , hamid n. h. , abdullah m. f. and solahuddin s. , ( 2011 ) electricity forecasting for small scale power system using artificial neural network , _
ieee 5th international power engineering and optimization conference _ , pp .
54 - 59 .
safari m. , dahlan y. n. , razali n. s. and rahman t. k. , ( 2013 ) electricity prices forecasting using ann hybrid with invasive weed optimization ( iwo ) , _ ieee 3rd international conference on system engineering and technology _ , pp .
275 - 280 . | due to imprecision and uncertainties in predicting real world problems , artificial neural network ( ann ) techniques have become increasingly useful for modeling and optimization .
this paper presents an artificial neural network approach for forecasting electric energy consumption . for effective planning and operation of power systems ,
optimal forecasting tools are needed for energy operators to maximize profit and also to provide maximum satisfaction to energy consumers .
monthly data for electric energy consumed in the gaza strip was collected from year 1994 to 2013 .
data was trained and the proposed model was validated using 2-fold and k - fold cross validation techniques .
the model has been tested with actual energy consumption data and yields satisfactory performance .
example.eps gsave newpath 20 20 moveto 20 220 lineto 220 220 lineto 220 20 lineto closepath 2 setlinewidth gsave .4 setgray fill grestore stroke grestore |
non - abelian anyons have a topological charge that provides a nonlocal encoding of quantum information @xcite . in superconducting implementations
@xcite the topological charge equals the electrical charge modulo @xmath0 , shared nonlocally by a pair of midgap states called majorana fermions @xcite .
this mundane identification of topological and electrical charge by no means diminishes the relevance for quantum computation . to the contrary
, it provides a powerful way to manipulate the topological charge through the well - established sub-@xmath1 charge sensitivity of superconducting electronics @xcite . following this line of thought ,
three of us recently proposed a hybrid device called a _
top - transmon _ , which combines the adjustable charge sensitivity of a superconducting charge qubit ( the _ transmon _ @xcite ) to read out and rotate a topological ( _ top _ ) qubit @xcite . a universal quantum computer with highly favorable error threshold can be constructed @xcite if these operations are supplemented by the pairwise exchange ( braiding ) of majorana fermions , which is a non - abelian operation on the degenerate ground state @xcite . here
we show how majorana fermions can be braided by means of charge - sensitive superconducting electronics .
( braiding was not implemented in ref .
@xcite nor in other studies of hybrid topological / nontopological superconducting qubits @xcite . )
we exploit the fact that the charge - sensitivity can be switched on and off _ with exponential accuracy _ by varying the magnetic flux through a split josephson junction @xcite .
this provides a macroscopic handle on the coulomb interaction of pairs of majorana fermions , which makes it possible to transport and exchange them in a josephson junction array .
we compare and contrast our approach with that of sau , clarke , and tewari , who showed ( building on the work of alicea et al .
@xcite ) how non - abelian braiding statistics could be generated by switching on and off the tunnel coupling of adjacent pairs of majorana fermions @xcite .
the tunnel coupling is controlled by a gate voltage , while we rely on coulomb interaction controlled by a magnetic flux .
this becomes an essential difference when electric fields are screened too strongly by the superconductor to be effective .
( for an alternative non - electrical approach to braiding , see ref .
@xcite . ) the basic procedure can be explained quite simply , see sec .
[ braiding ] , after the mechanism of the coulomb coupling is presented in sec .
we make use of two more involved pieces of theoretical analysis , one is the derivation of the low - energy hamiltonian of the coulomb coupled majorana fermions ( using results from refs .
@xcite ) , and the other is the calculation of the non - abelian berry phase @xcite of the exchange operation . to streamline the paper the details of these two calculations
are given in appendices .
the basic building block of the josephson junction array is the cooper pair box @xcite , see fig .
[ fig_box ] , consisting of a superconducting island ( capacitance @xmath2 ) connected to a bulk ( grounded ) superconductor by a split josephson junction enclosing a magnetic flux @xmath3 .
the josephson energy @xmath4 is a periodic function of @xmath3 with period @xmath5 .
if the two arms of the split junction are balanced , each with the same coupling energy @xmath6 , the josephson energy @xmath7 varies between @xmath8 and @xmath9 as a function of @xmath10 .
cooper pair box , consisting of a superconducting island ( brown ) connected to a bulk superconductor by a split josephson junction ( black , with the gauge - variant phase differences indicated ) .
the island contains majorana fermions ( yellow ) at the end points of a nanowire ( grey ) .
these are coupled by the coulomb charging energy , tunable via the flux @xmath3 through the josephson junction . ] when the island contains no majorana fermions , its hamiltonian has the usual form @xcite @xmath11 in terms of the canonically conjugate phase @xmath12 and charge @xmath13 of the island
. the offset @xmath14 accounts for charges on nearby gate electrodes .
we have chosen a gauge such that the phase of the pair potential is zero on the bulk superconductor .
a segment of a semiconductor nanowire ( typically inas ) on the superconducting island can have majorana midgap states bound to the end points @xcite . for @xmath15 segments
there can be @xmath16 majorana fermions on the island .
they have identical creation and annihilation operators @xmath17 satisfying @xmath18 the topological charge of the island equals the fermion parity @xmath19 the eigenvalues of @xmath20 are @xmath21 , depending on whether there is an even or an odd number of electrons on the island .
the majorana operators do not enter explicitly in @xmath22 , but affect the spectrum through a constraint on the eigenstates @xcite , @xmath23 this ensures that the eigenvalues of @xmath24 are even multiples of @xmath1 for @xmath25 and odd multiples for @xmath26 . since @xmath20 contains the product of all the majorana operators on the island , the constraint effectively couples distant majorana fermions without requiring any overlap of wave functions .
we operate the cooper pair box in the regime that the josephson energy @xmath4 is large compared to the single - electron charging energy @xmath27 . the phase @xmath12 ( modulo @xmath28 ) then has small zero - point fluctuations around the value @xmath29 which minimizes the energy of the josephson junction , with occasional @xmath28 quantum phase slips . in appendix [ cinteraction ]
we derive the effective low - energy hamiltonian for @xmath30 , @xmath31 the energy minimum @xmath32 at @xmath33 is increased by @xmath34 due to zero - point fluctuations of the phase .
this offset does not contain the majorana operators , so it can be ignored .
the term @xmath35 due to quantum phase slips depends on the majorana operators through the fermion parity .
this term acquires a dynamics for multiple coupled islands , because then the fermion parity of each individual island is no longer conserved .
we generalize the description to multiple superconducting islands , labeled @xmath36 , each connected to a bulk superconductor by a split josephson junction enclosing a flux @xmath37 .
( see fig .
[ fig_islands ] . )
the josephson junctions contribute an energy @xmath38 we assume that the charging energy is dominated by the self - capacitance @xmath2 of each island , so that it has the additive form @xmath39 while both @xmath6 and @xmath2 may be different for different islands , we omit a possible @xmath40-dependence for ease of notation
. there may be additional fluxes enclosed by the regions between the islands , but we do not include them to simplify the expressions .
none of these simplifications is essential for the operation of the device .
two cooper pair boxes , each containing a pair of majorana fermions .
single electrons can tunnel between the superconducting islands via the overlapping majorana s @xmath41 and @xmath42 .
this tunnel coupling has a slow ( cosine ) dependence on the enclosed fluxes , while the coulomb coupling between the majorana s on the same island varies rapidly ( exponentially ) . ]
the set of majorana s on the @xmath40-th island is indicated by @xmath43 with @xmath44 .
the fermion parities @xmath45 of neighboring islands @xmath40 and @xmath46 are coupled with strength @xmath47 by the overlapping majorana s @xmath43 and @xmath48 .
we denote the gauge - invariant phase difference @xcite by @xmath49 . the corresponding tunnel hamiltonian @xcite @xmath50 is @xmath51-periodic in the gauge - invariant phase difference , as an expression of the fact that single electrons ( rather than cooper pairs ) tunnel through the midgap state . for example , in the two - island geometry of fig .
[ fig_islands ] one has [ h12def ] @xmath52 in appendix [ cinteraction ] we derive the effective low - energy hamiltonian in the regime @xmath53 , @xmath54 the single sum couples majorana s within an island , through an effective coulomb energy @xmath55 .
the double sum couples majorana s in neighboring islands by tunneling .
both the coulomb and tunnel couplings depend on the fluxes through the josephson junctions , but in an entirely different way : the tunnel coupling varies slowly @xmath56 with the flux , while the coulomb coupling varies rapidly @xmath57 $ ] . three cooper pair boxes
connected at a tri - junction via three overlapping majorana fermions ( which effectively produce a single zero - mode @xmath58 at the center ) .
this is the minimal setup required for the braiding of a pair of majorana s , controlled by the fluxes through the three josephson junctions to a bulk superconductor . ]
since @xmath59 and @xmath60 in the majorana - coulomb hamiltonian do not commute , the evolution of the eigenstates upon variation of the fluxes is nontrivial . as we will demonstrate
, it can provide the non - abelian braiding statistic that we are seeking . similarly to earlier braiding proposals
@xcite , the minimal setup consists of three superconductors in a tri - junction .
( see fig .
[ fig_trijunction ] . )
each superconductor contains a pair of majorana fermions @xmath61 , with a tunnel coupling between @xmath62 , and @xmath63 .
the majorana - coulomb hamiltonian takes the form @xmath64 with gauge - invariant phase differences [ alphatrijunction ] @xmath65 as we vary @xmath66 between @xmath8 and @xmath67 , the coulomb coupling @xmath55 varies between two ( possibly @xmath40-dependent ) values @xmath68 and @xmath69 .
we require @xmath70 , which is readily achievable because of the exponential flux sensitivity of the coulomb coupling expressed by eqs . and .
we call the coulomb couplings @xmath69 and @xmath68 _ on _ and _ off _ , respectively .
we also take @xmath71 , meaning that the coulomb coupling is weaker than the tunnel coupling .
this is not an essential assumption , but it allows us to reduce the 6majorana problem to a 4majorana problem , as we will now show .
consider first the case that @xmath72 for all @xmath40 .
then the hamiltonian has four eigenvalues equal to zero : three of these represent the majorana s @xmath73 far away from the junction , while the fourth majorana , @xmath74 is situated at the tri - junction .
the tri - junction contributes also two nonzero eigenvalues @xmath75 , separated by the gap @xmath76 for @xmath77 well below @xmath78 and @xmath71 these two gapped modes can be ignored , and only the four majorana s @xmath79 need to be retained . the hamiltonian @xmath80 that describes the coulomb interaction of these four majorana s for nonzero @xmath55 is given , to first order in @xmath81 , by @xmath82
the hamiltonian describes four flux - tunable coulomb - coupled majorana fermions .
although the coupling studied by sau , clarke , and tewari @xcite has an entirely different origin ( gate - tunable tunnel coupling ) , their hamiltonian has the same form .
we can therefore directly adapt their braiding protocol to our control parameters .
schematic of the three steps of the braiding operation .
the four majorana s of the tri - junction in fig .
[ fig_trijunction ] ( the three outer majorana s @xmath83 and the effective central majorana @xmath58 ) are represented by circles and the coulomb coupling is represented by lines ( solid in the _ on _ state , dashed in the _ off _ state ) .
white circles indicate majorana s with a large coulomb splitting , colored circles those with a vanishingly small coulomb splitting .
the small diagram above each arrow shows an intermediate stage , with one majorana delocalized over three coupled sites .
the three steps together exchange the majorana s 1 and 2 , which is a non - abelian braiding operation . ]
.[table1 ] variation of the flux through the three josephson junctions during the braiding operation , at time steps corresponding to the diagrams in fig .
[ fig_braiding ] . the flux @xmath84 is varied in the opposite direction as @xmath85 , to ensure that the coupling parameters @xmath86 do not change sign during the operation . [ cols="<,^,^,^",options="header " , ]
we have three fluxes @xmath87 to control the couplings .
the braiding operation consists of three steps , see table [ table1 ] and fig . [ fig_braiding ] .
@xcite had more steps , involving 6 rather than 4 majorana s . ) at the beginning and at the end of each step two of the couplings are _ off _
( @xmath88 ) and one coupling is _ on _ ( @xmath89 ) .
we denote by @xmath90 the step of the operation that switches the coupling that is _ on _ from @xmath40 to @xmath46 .
this is done by first increasing @xmath91 from @xmath8 to @xmath92 and then decreasing @xmath66 from @xmath92 to @xmath8 , keeping the third flux fixed at @xmath8 . during this entire process
the degeneracy of the ground state remains unchanged ( twofold degenerate ) , which is a necessary condition for an adiabatic operation .
if , instead , we would first have first decreased @xmath66 and then increased @xmath91 , the ground state degeneracy would have switched from two to four at some point during the process , precluding adiabaticity .
we start from coupling 3 _ on _ and couplings 1,2 _ off_. the braiding operation then consists , in sequence , of the three steps @xmath93 , @xmath94 , and @xmath95 .
note that each coupling @xmath96 appears twice in the _ on _ state during the entire operation , both times with the same sign @xmath97 .
the step @xmath90 transfers the uncoupled majorana at site @xmath46 to site @xmath40 in a time @xmath98 .
the transfer is described in the heisenberg representation by @xmath99 .
we calculate the unitary evolution operator @xmath100 in the adiabatic @xmath101 limit in appendix [ berry ] , by integrating over the berry connection . in the limit @xmath102
we recover the result of ref .
@xcite , @xmath103 the result after the three steps is that the majorana s at sites 1 and 2 are switched , with a difference in sign , @xmath104 the corresponding unitary time evolution operator , @xmath105 has the usual form of an adiabatic braiding operation @xcite . for a nonzero
@xmath68 the coefficient @xmath106 in the exponent acquires corrections of order @xmath107 , see appendix [ berry ] .
if one repeats the entire braiding operation , the majorana s 1 and 2 have returned to their original positions but the final state differs from the initial state by a unitary operator @xmath108 and not just by a phase factor .
that is the hallmark of non - abelian statistics @xcite .
in summary , we have proposed a way to perform non - abelian braiding operations on majorana fermions , by controlling their coulomb coupling via the magnetic flux through a josephson junction .
majorana fermions are themselves charge - neutral particles ( because they are their own antiparticle ) , so one may ask how there can be any coulomb coupling at all .
the answer is that the state of a pair of majorana fermions in a superconducting island depends on the parity of the number of electrons on that island , and it is this dependence on the electrical charge modulo @xmath0 which provides an electromagnetic handle on the majorana s .
the coulomb coupling can be made exponentially small by passing cooper pairs through a josephson junction between the island and a bulk ( grounded ) superconductor .
the control parameter is the flux @xmath3 through the junction , so it is purely magnetic
. this is a key difference with braiding by electrostatically controlled tunnel couplings of majorana fermions @xcite .
gate voltages tend to be screened quite efficiently by the superconductor , so magnetic control is advantageous .
another advantage is that the dependence of the coulomb coupling on the flux is governed by macroscopic electrical properties ( capacitance of the island , resistance of the josephson junction ) .
tunnel couplings , in contrast , require microscopic input ( separation of the majorana fermions on the scale of the fermi wave length ) , so they tend to be more difficult to control . both ref .
@xcite and the present proposal share the feature that the gap of the topological superconductor is not closed during the braiding operation .
( the measurement - based approach to braiding also falls in this category @xcite . ) two other proposals @xcite braid the majorana s by inducing a topological phase transition ( either by electrical or by magnetic means ) in parts of the system . since the excitation gap closes at the phase transition , this may be problematic for the required adiabaticity of the operation .
the braiding operation is called topologically protected , because it depends on the _ off / on _ sequence of the coulomb couplings , and not on details of the timing of the sequence . as in any physical realization of a mathematical concept ,
there are sources of error .
non - adiabaticity of the operation is one source of error , studied in ref .
low - lying sub - gap excitations in the superconducting island break the adiabatic evolution by transitions which change the fermion parity of the majorana s .
another source of error , studied in appendix [ berry ] , is governed by the _
off / on _ ratio @xmath107 of the coulomb coupling .
this ratio depends exponentially on the ratio of the charging energy @xmath109 and the josephson energy @xmath110 of the junction to the bulk superconductor .
a value @xmath111 is not unrealistic @xcite , corresponding to @xmath112 .
the sign of the coulomb coupling in the _ on _ state can be arbitrary , as long as it does not change during the braiding operation . since @xmath113 ,
any change in the induced charge by @xmath114 will spoil the operation .
the time scale for this quasiparticle poisoning can be milliseconds @xcite , so this does not seem to present a serious obstacle .
a universal quantum computation using majorana fermions requires , in addition to braiding , the capabilities for single - qubit rotation and read - out of up to four majorana s @xcite . the combination of ref .
@xcite with the present proposal provides a scheme for all three operations , based on the interface of a topological qubit and a superconducting charge qubit .
this is not a topological quantum computer , since single - qubit rotations of majorana fermions lack topological protection .
but by including the topologically protected braiding operations one can improve the tolerance for errors of the entire computation by orders of magnitude ( error rates as large as 10% are permitted @xcite ) .
a sketch of a complete device is shown in fig .
[ fig_device ] .
josephson junction array containing majorana fermions .
the magnetic flux through a split josephson junction controls the coulomb coupling on each superconducting island .
this device allows one to perform the three types of operations on topological qubits needed for a universal quantum computer : read - out , rotation , and braiding .
all operations are controlled magnetically , no gate voltages are needed . ] this research was supported by the dutch science foundation nwo / fom and by an erc advanced investigator grant .
considering first a single island , we start from the cooper pair box hamiltonian with the parity constraint on the eigenstates . following ref .
@xcite , it is convenient to remove the constraint by the unitary transformation @xmath115.\label{gaugetr}\ ] ] the transformed wave function @xmath116 is then @xmath28-periodic , without any constraint .
the parity operator @xmath20 appears in the transformed hamiltonian , @xmath117 for a single junction the parity is conserved , so eigenstates of @xmath22 are also eigenstates of @xmath20 and we may treat the operator @xmath20 as a number .
is therefore the hamiltonian of a cooper pair box with effective induced charge @xmath118 .
the expression for the ground state energy in the josephson regime @xmath30 is in the literature @xcite , @xmath119 the first term @xmath120 is the minimal josephson energy at @xmath29 .
zero - point motion , with josephson plasma frequency @xmath121 , adds the second term @xmath122 .
the third term is due to quantum phase slips with transition amplitudes @xmath123 by which @xmath12 increments by @xmath124 . using @xmath125
, the ground state energy may be written in the form @xmath126 with @xmath127 defined in eq . .
higher levels are separated by an energy @xmath128 , which is large compared to @xmath127 for @xmath30 .
we may therefore identify @xmath129 with the effective low - energy hamiltonian of a single island in the large-@xmath4 limit .
we now turn to the case of multiple islands with tunnel coupling .
to be definite we take the geometry of two islands shown in fig .
[ fig_islands ] .
the full hamiltonian is @xmath130 , where @xmath131 and @xmath132 are two copies of the cooper box hamiltonian and @xmath133 is the tunnel coupling from eq . .
to obtain @xmath28-periodicity in both phases @xmath134 and @xmath135 , we make the unitary transformation @xmath136 with @xmath137 the cooper pair box hamiltonians are transformed into @xmath138 with @xmath139 . the tunnel coupling transforms into @xmath140 where @xmath141 and h.c
. stands for hermitian conjugate . since @xmath142 ,
the transformed tunnel coupling @xmath143 is @xmath28-periodic in @xmath134 and @xmath135 .
for @xmath30 the phases remain close to the value which minimizes the sum of the josephson energies to the bulk superconductor and between the islands . to leading order in @xmath144 this minimal energy
is given by @xmath145\nonumber\\ & + { \cal o}(e_{m}^{2}/e_{j}).\label{emindef}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the josephson coupling of the islands changes the plasma frequency @xmath146 for phase @xmath147 by a factor @xmath148 , so the zero - point motion energy is @xmath149 the transition amplitudes @xmath150 for quantum phase slips of phase @xmath147 are similarly affected , @xmath151 these are the contributions to the effective hamiltonian @xmath152 for @xmath53 , @xmath153\biggr)\nonumber\\ & \times[1+{\cal o}(e_{m}/e_{j})]+{\rm const}.\label{heffmultiapp}\end{aligned}\ ] ] eq . in the main text generalizes this expression for two islands to an arbitrary number of coupled islands .
we evaluate the unitary evolution operator @xmath154 of the braiding operation in the adiabatic limit .
this amounts to a calculation of the non - abelian berry phase ( integral of berry connection ) of the cyclic variation of the interaction hamiltonian @xmath155 .
the eigenvalues are doubly degenerate at energy @xmath160 ( up to a flux - dependent offset , which only contributes an overall phase factor to the evolution operator ) .
the two degenerate ground states at @xmath161 are distinguished by an even ( @xmath1 ) or odd ( @xmath162 ) quasiparticle number , the braiding path in three - dimensional parameter space along which the berry phase is evaluated .
this path corresponds to the flux values in table [ table1 ] , with couplings @xmath165 for @xmath88 and @xmath166 for @xmath89 .
the ratio @xmath167 in the figure is exaggerated for clarity . ]
if we avoid this line the berry connection can be readily evaluated .
it consists of three anti - hermitian @xmath168 matrices @xmath169 , @xmath170 off - diagonal terms in @xmath169 are zero because of global parity conservation . explicitly , we have @xmath171 a closed path @xmath172 in parameter space has berry phase @xcite @xmath173 the path @xmath172 corresponding to the braiding operation in fig . [ fig_braiding ] and table [ table1 ]
is shown in fig .
[ fig_path ] .
we take all couplings @xmath96 positive , varying between a minimal value @xmath174 and maximal value @xmath175 .
the parametrization is well - defined along the entire contour .
the contour integral evaluates to @xmath176,\;\;\sigma_{z}=\begin{pmatrix } 1&0\\ 0&-1 \end{pmatrix},\\ & \epsilon=\frac{3}{\sqrt{2}}\frac{\delta_{\rm min}}{\delta_{\rm max}}+{\cal o}\left(\frac{\delta_{\rm min}}{\delta_{\rm max}}\right)^{2}. \label{braiding_error}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the limit
@xmath177 corresponds to the braiding operator in the main text ( with @xmath178 and @xmath179 ) .
99 c. nayak , s. simon , a. stern , m. freedman , and s. das sarma , rev .
mod . phys . * 80 * , 1083 ( 2008 ) .
r. m. lutchyn , j. d. sau , and s. das sarma , phys .
lett . * 105 * , 077001 ( 2010 ) .
y. oreg , g. refael , and f. von oppen , phys .
lett . * 105 * , 177002 ( 2010 ) .
kitaev , phys .
* 44 * ( suppl . ) , 131 ( 2001 ) .
d. v. averin and yu . v. nazarov , phys .
lett . * 69 * , 1993 ( 1992 ) .
m. h. devoret , a. wallraff , and j. m. martinis , arxiv : cond - mat/0411174 .
j. a. schreier , a. a. houck , j. koch , d. i. schuster , b. r. johnson , j. m. chow , j. m. gambetta , j. majer , l. frunzio , m. h. devoret , s. m. girvin , and r. j. schoelkop , phys .
b * 77 * , 180502(r ) ( 2008 ) .
f. hassler , a. r. akhmerov , and c. w. j. beenakker , new j. phys .
* 13 * , 095004 ( 2011 ) .
s. bravyi and a. yu .
kitaev , phys .
a * 71 * , 022316 ( 2005 ) ; s. bravyi , phys .
a * 73*. 042313 ( 2006 ) .
n. read and d. green , phys .
b * 61 * , 10267 ( 2000 ) .
d. ivanov , phys .
lett . * 86 * , 268 ( 2001 ) .
f. hassler , a. r. akhmerov , c .- y .
hou , and c. w. j. beenakker , new j. phys .
* 12 * , 125002 ( 2010 ) .
j. d. sau , s. tewari , and s. das sarma , phys .
a * 82 * , 052322 ( 2010 ) .
k. flensberg , phys .
* 106 * , 090503 ( 2011 ) .
l. jiang , c. l. kane , and j. preskill , phys .
* 106 * , 130504 ( 2011 ) .
p. bonderson and r. m. lutchyn , phys .
. lett . * 106 * , 130505 ( 2011 ) .
j. alicea , y. oreg , g. refael , f. von oppen , and m. p. a. fisher , nature phys .
* 7 * , 412 ( 2011 ) .
j. d. sau , d. j. clarke , and s. tewari , phys .
b * 84 * , 094505 ( 2011 ) .
a. romito , j. alicea , g. refael , and f. von oppen , arxiv:1110.6193 .
l. fu , phys .
104 * , 056402 ( 2010 ) ; c. xu and l. fu , phys . rev .
b * 81 * , 134435 ( 2010 )
. b. van heck , f. hassler , a. r. akhmerov , and c. w. j. beenakker , phys .
b * 4 * , 180502(r ) ( 2011 ) .
f. wilczek and a. zee , phys . rev
52 * , 2111 ( 1984 ) .
makhlin , g. schn , and a. shnirman , rev .
phys . * 73 * , 357 ( 2001 ) .
m. tinkham , _ introduction to superconductivity _
( mcgraw - hill , new york , 1996 ) .
p. bonderson , m. freedman , and c. nayak , phys .
* 101 * , 010501 ( 2008 ) .
m. cheng , v. galitski , and s. das sarma , phys .
b * 84 * , 104529 ( 2011 ) .
p. j. de visser , j. j. a. baselmans , p. diener , s. j. c. yates , a. endo , and t. m. klapwijk , phys .
lett . * 106 * , 167004 ( 2011 ) .
j. koch , t. m. yu , j. gambetta , a. a. houck , d. i. schuster , j. majer , a. blais , m. h. devoret , s. m. girvin , and r. j. schoelkopf , phys . rev .
a * 76 * , 042319 ( 2007 ) .
v. nazarov and ya .
m. blanter , _ quantum transport : introduction to nanoscience _
( cambridge , 2009 ) . | we show how to exchange ( braid ) majorana fermions in a network of superconducting nanowires by control over coulomb interactions rather than tunneling . even though majorana fermions are charge - neutral quasiparticles ( equal to their own antiparticle ) , they have an effective long - range interaction through the even - odd electron number dependence of the superconducting ground state .
the flux through a split josephson junction controls this interaction via the ratio of josephson and charging energies , with exponential sensitivity . by switching the interaction on and off in neighboring segments of a josephson junction array
, the non - abelian braiding statistics can be realized without the need to control tunnel couplings by gate electrodes .
this is a solution to the problem how to operate on topological qubits when gate voltages are screened by the superconductor . |
in string theory , it had been thought that standard concepts of space - time would break down at the scale @xmath3 since it is the scale of probes , i.e. fundamental strings . in @xcite , however , it was argued that the structure of space - time on sub - stringy scales can be probed by d - branes .
space - time appearing in the d - brane approach has very different features from that probed by fundamental strings .
first of all , space - time coordinates are promoted to non - commuting matrices , and usual space - time emerges from moduli space of d - brane world - volume gauge theory .
so it is interesting to investigate space - time by using d - branes as probes and compare it with space - time probed by fundamental strings .
investigations toward this direction were made in @xcite , in which d - branes on orbifolds were studied . in particular , three dimensional orbifolds in @xcite serve as local descriptions of singularities in calabi - yau manifolds .
investigations on the moduli space of calabi - yau manifolds were made in @xcite based on fundamental strings .
it was shown that the moduli space has a rich phase structure .
it includes topologically distinct calabi - yau spaces and non - geometric phases such as orbifold and landau - ginzburg phases .
topologically distinct calabi - yau phases are connected by flops .
a flop is achieved by a sequence of operations : first blowing down some homologically nontrivial cycle @xmath4 and then blowing up another @xmath4 . in this process , hodge numbers do not change but more subtle topological indices such as intersection numbers among homology cycles change .
in the course of the flop , the space becomes singular due to the shrinking of some @xmath4 . as a conformal field theory
, however , this process occurs smoothly .
possibility of the smooth topology change is demonstrated by using mirror symmetry in @xcite . in the gauged linear sigma model approach@xcite ,
the singularity is avoided by giving non - zero theta angle . as for the non - geometric phases ,
it is argued that they can also be interpreted geometrically by analytic continuation to calabi - yau phases , although part of the calabi - yau manifold has been shrunk to string or sub - stringy scales @xcite . in @xcite ,
the moduli space of calabi - yau manifolds was investigated by using d - branes as probes .
they considered d - branes in typeii string theory on orbifolds @xmath5 and @xmath6 .
it gives @xmath7 gauge theory with fayet - iliopoulos d - terms coming from twisted sectors of closed strings . as the coefficients of the fayet - iliopoulos d - terms change , the moduli space of the gauge theory changes .
a priori , it may seem that a rich phase structure arises as in @xcite .
however it is shown that only calabi - yau phases are allowed and non - geometric phases are projected out .
this result matches the analytically continued picture of the moduli space in @xcite .
it is also consistent with the study of the moduli space of calabi - yau compactifications in m theory@xcite , which can be thought of as strong coupling limit of type iia theory . to proceed the comparison between the moduli space of calabi - yau spaces probed by fundamental strings and that probed by d - branes , it is important to investigate topology changing process in the d - brane approach . in this paper
we present an explicit example in which the moduli space includes topologically distinct calabi - yau phases connected by flops based on d - brane world - volume gauge theory .
the organization of this paper is as follows . in section 2 , we review flops in terms of toric geometry and gauged linear sigma models which are necessary to the analyses in the following sections . in section 3 , we explain d - branes on orbifold @xmath0 . in section 4 ,
we first review the work @xcite , which treats @xmath8 cases .
we then consider @xmath2 cases and explicitly check that non - geometric phases are projected out . in the @xmath1 case , we present the model in which there are five topologically distinct phases connected by flops . in section 5 , we consider d - brane on orbifolds with non - isolated singularities .
section 6 contains discussion .
in this section , we review toric varieties and physical realization of toric varieties in terms of gauged linear sigma models emphasizing topology changing process . for details , see @xcite . a complex @xmath9-dimensional toric variety is a space which contains algebraic torus @xmath10 as a dense open subset .
a toric variety is determined by a combinatorial data @xmath11 called a fan , so we denote it by @xmath12 .
a fan @xmath11 is a collection of strongly convex rational polyhedral cones in @xmath13 with apex at the origin . to be a fan it must have the property that ( 1 ) any two members of the collection intersect in a common face , ( 2 ) for each member of @xmath11 all its face are also in @xmath11 .
@xmath12 can be expressed in the form @xmath14 , where @xmath15 , @xmath16 and the action of @xmath17 on @xmath18 are determined by @xmath11 as follows .
let @xmath19 be the integral generators of the one dimensional cones in @xmath11 . then associate a homogeneous coordinate @xmath20 of @xmath18 with each vector @xmath21 .
define @xmath16 , a subset of @xmath18 , by @xmath22 here @xmath23 means that @xmath24 is a cone in @xmath11 , and @xmath25 means that @xmath21 is a generator of some one - dimensional cone in @xmath24 .
@xmath15 vectors @xmath19 in @xmath13 satisfy @xmath26 relations @xmath27 with @xmath28 .
then the action of @xmath17 on @xmath20 is defined as @xmath29 an important point is that a set of vectors @xmath30 determines the action of @xmath17 on @xmath18 , but does not determine @xmath16 . to determine @xmath16
we must specify which vectors generate each cone @xmath24 in @xmath11 .
the specification is called a triangulation of @xmath11 . in general
there are various triangulations for the same set of vectors @xmath30 .
different triangulations correspond to different @xmath16 and hence different toric varieties @xmath12 .
various properties of a toric variety @xmath12 can be expressed in terms of its fan @xmath11 .
for example , @xmath12 is compact if and only if @xmath11 spans the whole of @xmath13 .
what we want to investigate is geometry in the neighborhood of singularities in calabi - yau manifolds , so we consider cases where @xmath12 has zero chern class . for these cases a fan @xmath11 must have the following property , @xmath31 for a certain vector @xmath32 .
this condition leads to relations among @xmath17 charges , @xmath33 due to ( [ eq : q - n ] ) .
( [ eq : c_1 ] ) also implies that all the points specified by vectors @xmath34 lie in a certain hyperplane @xmath35 .
thus we can represent a fan @xmath11 in terms of the intersection of @xmath11 with the hyperplane @xmath35 .
we call it as a toric diagram . in the following we consider cases that the fan @xmath11 is simplicial , for which @xmath12 has at most quotient singularities .
simplicial fan is such that each cone @xmath24 can be written in the form @xmath36 for some linearly independent vectors @xmath37 .
when @xmath38 , we define a volume for simplicial cones to be @xmath39 times the volume of the polyhedron with vertices @xmath40 . here
we take @xmath21 to be the first nonzero lattice point on the ray @xmath41 . )
, the volume of a cone can be represented by `` area '' of intersection of the cone with the hyperplane @xmath35 .
unit of the area is defined as the area of the intersection between @xmath35 and a cone with unit volume .
] @xmath12 is smooth if every @xmath9-dimensional cone in the fan has volume one .
if some cones have volume greater than one , @xmath12 has quotient singularities .
however we can obtain a smooth toric variety by subdividing the cone until each cone has volume one .
this procedure corresponds to a blow up of the singularity .
an important point is that the resolution of the singularity is not necessarily unique .
there are often numerous ways of subdividing the cones in @xmath11 .
thus there are numerous smooth varieties that can arise from different ways of resolving the singularity . in general
these varieties are topologically distinct . for calabi - yau threefold such topologically distinct varieties
can be connected by flops .
a flop is a transformation of a manifold into a topologically different manifold which replaces some homologically nontrivial cycle @xmath4 with another @xmath4 . in toric language ,
a flop is described by toric diagrams which include figure [ fig : toricflop ] .
we denote toric varieties corresponding figure [ fig : toricflop](a ) and [ fig : toricflop](b ) as @xmath42 and @xmath43 respectively .
the toric variety @xmath42 is written as @xmath44 where @xmath45 and @xmath46 charge of @xmath20 are @xmath47 due to the relation @xmath48 .
the toric variety @xmath43 is @xmath49 where @xmath50 and @xmath46 charge is the same as that for @xmath51 . to see the difference between the two manifolds , we define subsets of @xmath52 as @xmath53 , @xmath54 and @xmath55 .
then the toric varieties are written as @xmath56 . here
@xmath57 is common to both manifolds .
different contributions come from @xmath58 and @xmath58 .
@xmath59 is a @xmath4 , which we call @xmath60 , and @xmath61 is another @xmath4 , which we call @xmath62 .
topology change occurs by the replacement of @xmath60 by @xmath62 .
the quotient construction of a toric variety can be physically realized as a classical vacuum of @xmath63 supersymmetric two dimensional gauged linear sigma model@xcite . in this approach , @xmath20 is the lowest component of a chiral superfield with @xmath64 charge @xmath65 . the quotient by @xmath66 may be viewed to having taken place in two stages .
first we fix the @xmath67 degree of freedom by imposing d - flatness condition and then divide by @xmath64 gauge symmetry .
the most important point is that inclusion of fayet - iliopoulos d - term with coefficient @xmath68 provides the degrees of freedom which are the counterparts to the possible triangulations of @xmath11 . in the gauged linear sigma model description ,
a flop is described by a model with the following d - flatness condition @xmath69 the @xmath64 action on four chiral superfields is @xmath70 , @xmath71 , @xmath72 , @xmath73 . for @xmath74 , the vacuum moduli space specified by the d - flatness condition
do not contain @xmath75 .
this condition is equivalent to removing the point set @xmath76 in toric description . for @xmath77 ,
the vacuum moduli space do not contain @xmath78 .
this condition is equivalent to removing the point set @xmath79 . for both cases @xmath80 controls the size of @xmath4 associated with the blow up .
the flop occurs in passing from @xmath74 to @xmath77 and vice versa .
thus the sign of the fayet - iliopoulos parameter specifies the triangulation as noted above .
classically there is a singularity at @xmath81 , but as long as theta angle is generic , smooth topology change can occur @xcite .
we consider a typeii string theory on an orbifold @xmath0 , with @xmath82 a subgroup of @xmath83 . we begin with several remarks on orbifolds itself .
we take complex coordinates for @xmath84 as @xmath85 @xmath86 , and an action of a generator @xmath87 of @xmath82 on @xmath85 as @xmath88 where @xmath89 are integers which satisfy @xmath90 , mod @xmath91 . here
we consider cases @xmath92 since an orbifold with @xmath93 for some @xmath94 is a direct product of @xmath95 and @xmath96 . thus orbifolds are labeled by @xmath91 and @xmath97 , but
different @xmath98 s often give the same orbifold .
that is , if there is some integer @xmath15 which has no common factor with @xmath91 except one and satisfies the equation @xmath99 the orbifold with @xmath97 is the same as the orbifold with @xmath100 .
this is because the two cases give the same action of @xmath82 on @xmath85 if we take all elements @xmath101 , ( @xmath102 ) into account .
it includes a trivial case @xmath103 @xmath104 .
apart from this , an exchange between @xmath105 and @xmath106 does not change the geometry since it is merely an exchange between @xmath85 and @xmath107 .
we present explicit examples of the equivalence in the following sections .
to describe d - branes on the orbifold @xmath0 , we first consider @xmath91 d - branes on @xmath84 .
it gives four dimensional @xmath108 supersymmetric @xmath109 gauge theory .
bosonic field contents of the theory are a gauge field @xmath110 , ( @xmath111 ) , and three complex scalar fields @xmath85 , ( @xmath112 ) where @xmath113 .
we then impose invariance under @xmath82 .
it acts on the space - time indices of @xmath84 as ( [ eq : orbifold ] ) , supersymmetry due to the relation @xmath90 , mod @xmath91 . ] and on chan - paton indices ( which label the d - branes ) in the regular representation @xmath114 .
thus the generator @xmath87 of @xmath82 acts on the gauge field as @xmath115 invariance under @xmath82 gives @xmath116 , where @xmath117 , therefore the gauge group @xmath109 is reduced to @xmath7 . for @xmath85 , @xmath82 acts as @xmath118 invariance under @xmath82 gives @xmath119 which leave @xmath120 fields .
we denote these fields as @xmath121 since all fields have charge zero for diagonal @xmath64 , nontrivial gauge symmetry is @xmath122 . the field contents can be described by quiver diagrams@xcite .
it consists of @xmath91 vertices associated with gauge fields @xmath123 and @xmath120 oriented links associated with @xmath124 .
the links represent the information on @xmath7 charges of @xmath124 .
the equivalence ( [ eq : equivalence ] ) except @xmath125 corresponds to a certain exchange among vertices . to obtain vacuum moduli space of the theory , we first impose f - flatness conditions .
f - flatness conditions give @xmath126 equations @xmath127 so the resulting space is ( n+2)-dimensional , which we denote as @xmath128 .
then we impose d - flatness conditions and divide by the gauge symmetry .
d - flatness conditions give ( real ) @xmath129 equations @xmath130 where @xmath131 and @xmath132 is a coefficient of fayet - iliopoulos d - term , which comes from the twisted sector of closed strings .
together with a gauge fixing of @xmath122 symmetry , we have three dimensional space as expected .
this is the vacuum moduli space of the d - brane world - volume gauge theory .
we denote it by @xmath133 . note that although f - flatness condition leads to @xmath134=0 $ ] , @xmath135 $ ] does not vanish if @xmath136 . thus the vacuum moduli space is embedded nontrivially into a larger non - commuting configuration space .
we express the geometry of the moduli space by using toric method as follows .
first , we express @xmath137-dimensional space @xmath128 by a toric variety @xmath138 . to make the translation into a toric description , we use another definition@xcite of toric varieties from that described in section 2 .
first , we introduce @xmath120 variables @xmath139 and @xmath137 variables @xmath140 as @xmath141 , @xmath142 .
then the solution of the f - flatness conditions is written in the form @xmath143 where @xmath144 .
we can regard @xmath145 as the @xmath146-th component of the @xmath147-th @xmath137-dimensional vector @xmath148 .
these @xmath120 vectors define a cone @xmath149 in @xmath150 as @xmath151 we now define dual cone @xmath24 of @xmath149 by @xmath152 a collection of cones , @xmath24 and its faces , defines the fan @xmath153 .
then we express the three dimensional vacuum moduli space @xmath133 by a toric variety .
it is obtained from @xmath128 by imposing @xmath129 d - flatness conditions and @xmath122 gauge fixing .
it is equivalent to the holomorphic quotient by @xmath154 after removing an appropriate point set .
together with the holomorphic quotient by @xmath155 in @xmath128 , @xmath133 is expressed as @xmath156 .
note that @xmath154 charges of @xmath157 are determined from @xmath122 charges of @xmath158 through the following relations @xmath159 in fact there are redundancy in the homogeneous coordinates , so we can eliminate such coordinates by using appropriate @xmath160 quotients .
in this section , we study the vacuum moduli space of d - brane world - volume gauge theory on @xmath0 for @xmath161 . although @xmath8 cases were already investigated in @xcite , we describe the results for these cases rather elaborately to explain the method of analysis . for @xmath5 ,
any model is equivalent to the model with @xmath162 . for convenience .
this choice is always allowed due to the equivalence under ( [ eq : equivalence ] ) and @xmath163 .
] for example , a model with @xmath164 is equivalent to the model with @xmath162 as follows , @xmath165 in this case , the cone @xmath149 is generated by nine vectors , @xmath166 the fan @xmath153 is determined by the condition @xmath167 @xmath168 , and its one dimensional cones are generated by @xmath169 they satisfy the relation @xmath170 , so the @xmath46 charges of @xmath20 s are given by @xmath171 combining @xmath172 charges which originate from @xmath173 gauge group of the original d - brane world - volume theory , we have @xmath174 charges of @xmath20 s as @xmath175 the resulting toric variety takes the form @xmath176 . the charge matrix ( [ eq : qtot ] )
determines six vectors which generate one dimensional cones in @xmath11 .
@xmath177 here @xmath178 , so two of the three homogeneous coordinates @xmath179 are redundant .
it implies that the toric variety is written in the form @xmath180 this is the moduli space @xmath133 of the d - brane world - volume gauge theory . to determine the triangulation of @xmath181
, we go to the gauged linear sigma model description .
it is a @xmath182 gauge theory with six chiral superfields .
the d - flatness conditions are @xmath183 @xmath184 @xmath185 here @xmath186 and @xmath187 are coefficients of fayet - iliopoulos d - term associated to the @xmath173 gauge group of the original d - brane theory .
now we eliminate two of @xmath188 , @xmath189 and @xmath190 . when @xmath191 and @xmath192 , @xmath188 and @xmath190 can not vanish , so they take value in @xmath172
. then we can eliminate these fields by using d - flatness conditions and @xmath173 gauge symmetry .
thus we have @xmath193 it is the d - flatness condition of a @xmath64 gauged linear sigma model with four chiral superfields with charges @xmath194 here we include the information on the fayet - iliopoulos d - term parameter .
as we are considering the region @xmath191 and @xmath192 , the fayet - iliopoulos parameter of the resulting @xmath64 gauge theory @xmath195 is positive .
then @xmath196 , which implies @xmath197 in the toric description .
the toric diagram which gives this @xmath16 is figure [ fig : z3 ] .
the diagram consists of three triangles with area one , so the corresponding toric variety is a smooth manifold obtained by blowing up the orbifold singularity of @xmath5 . in @xcite , it was also shown that the result does not depend on which set of fields are eliminated out of @xmath188 , @xmath189 and @xmath190 . therefore the orbifold phase is projected out . for @xmath6 ,
any model is equivalent to the model with @xmath198 .
for example , a model with @xmath199 is equivalent to the model with @xmath198 as follows , @xmath200 the quiver diagram for @xmath199 and that for @xmath198 are related by the following permutation @xmath201 of vertices ( see figure [ fig : q5 ] ) , @xmath202 the moduli space takes the form @xmath203 , and the charge matrix is given by @xmath204 figure [ fig : z5 ] represents the corresponding toric diagram .
= 4.5 cm there are two types of models for @xmath205 .
one has @xmath206 and the other has @xmath207 .
the quiver diagrams are depicted in figure [ fig : q7 ] . for the case of @xmath206 , one can see that @xmath153 is generated by 31 vectors in @xmath208 , and
hence @xmath128 takes the form @xmath209 . combining @xmath210 quotient coming from @xmath211 gauge symmetry of the d - brane theory
, @xmath133 takes the form @xmath212 .
however one can see that 25 vectors out of 31 are redundant .
hence we eliminate 25 coordinates by @xmath213 action and finally the moduli space takes the form @xmath214 . for one choice of redundant variables ,
the charge matrix is given by @xmath215 for this choice of redundant variables , fayet - iliopoulos parameters must satisfy @xmath216 under these conditions , fayet - iliopoulos parameters of the resulting @xmath182 gauged linear sigma model satisfy inequalities @xmath217 these inequalities determine the phase uniquely .
the corresponding toric diagram is figure [ fig : z7a ] . for the case of @xmath207
, one can see that @xmath153 is generated by 24 vectors in @xmath208 , and hence @xmath128 takes the form @xmath218 . combining the @xmath210 coming from @xmath211 gauge symmetry of the d - brane theory
, @xmath133 takes the form @xmath219 .
however one can see that 18 vectors out of 24 are redundant .
hence the moduli space takes the form @xmath214 . for one choice of redundant variables ,
the charge matrix is given by @xmath220 it determines eight vectors which generate one dimensional cones for @xmath181 , @xmath221 for the choice of redundant variables fayet - iliopoulos parameters must satisfy @xmath222 under these conditions , fayet - iliopoulos parameters of the resulting @xmath182 gauged linear sigma model satisfy inequalities @xmath223 the triangulation of the toric diagram is uniquely determined as in figure [ fig : z7b ] .
= 4.5 cm thus only the completely resolved phase is realized . here
we comment on the correspondence between the classification of models by @xmath98 and the classification of toric diagrams . in the @xmath224 case , if we allow @xmath93 for some @xmath94 , there are three types of models , @xmath206 , @xmath207 and @xmath225 . on the other hand , triangles with area seven
whose corners lie on the lattice @xmath226 are also classified into three types ; the first is the triangle corresponding to figure [ fig : z7a ] , the second is that corresponding to figure [ fig : z7b ] and the third is that with corners @xmath227 , @xmath228 and @xmath229 . here
the classification of triangles is defined by the following equivalence relation : two triangles are equivalent if they are related by @xmath230 transformation with determinant @xmath231 .
in fact , there is a relation between @xmath98 and the triangle which appears in the corresponding toric diagram@xcite .
that is , if we write three corners of the triangle as @xmath232 , @xmath86 , the following relations @xmath233 hold for an appropriate order of @xmath89 .
note that the triangle corresponding to the @xmath225 model have lattice points on its codimension one boundary .
this is a characteristic feature to the cases whose singularity is non - isolated ( see section 5 ) . from the examples treated in this paper
, it seems that the classification of models on @xmath0 corresponds to the classification of triangles with area @xmath91 ( see section 6 ) . for @xmath234
, there are two types of models .
one has @xmath235 and the other has @xmath236 .
also satisfies @xmath90 modulo 9 , but it is nothing but the model on @xmath5 with @xmath164 . ] for the @xmath236 case , the action of @xmath237 on @xmath85 is @xmath238 where @xmath239 . for @xmath240 , @xmath241 , which means that there is a non - trivial fixed point @xmath242 with @xmath243 . therefore the corresponding space has a non - isolated singularity .
we discuss such cases in section [ sec : nonisolated ] . for the case of @xmath235
, one can see that @xmath153 is generated by 78 vectors in @xmath244 , and hence @xmath128 takes the form @xmath245
. combining the @xmath246 quotient coming from @xmath247 gauge symmetry of the d - brane theory , @xmath133 takes the form @xmath248 .
however one can see that 71 vectors out of 78 are redundant .
hence the moduli space takes the form @xmath249 . for one choice of redundant variables ,
the charge matrix is given by @xmath250 by a similar analysis to the previous sections we can see that the toric diagram is given by figure [ fig : z9a ] .
= 7.5 cm for @xmath251 , there are two types of models .
one has @xmath252 and the other has @xmath253 . for the case of @xmath252
, one can see that @xmath153 is generated by 201 vectors in @xmath254 , and hence @xmath128 takes the form @xmath255
. combining the @xmath256 quotient coming from @xmath257 gauge symmetry of the d - brane theory , @xmath133 takes the form @xmath258 .
however one can see that 193 vectors out of 201 are redundant .
hence the moduli space takes the form @xmath259 with the charge matrix , @xmath260 the corresponding toric diagram is figure [ fig : z11a ] . for the case of @xmath253
, one can see that @xmath153 is generated by 91 vectors in @xmath254 , and hence @xmath128 takes the form @xmath261
. combining the @xmath256 quotient coming from @xmath257 gauge symmetry of the d - brane theory , @xmath133 takes the form @xmath262 .
however one can see that 83 vectors out of 91 are redundant .
hence we can eliminate 83 coordinates by @xmath263 action and finally the moduli space takes the form @xmath259 . for one choice of redundant variables ,
the charge matrix is given by @xmath264 it determines eight vectors which generate one dimensional cones in @xmath181 , @xmath265 figure [ fig : z11b ] represents these eight vectors . for the choice of redundant variables fayet - iliopoulos parameters must satisfy @xmath266 under these conditions , fayet - iliopoulos parameters of the resulting @xmath267 gauged linear sigma model satisfy the following inequalities @xmath268 however these conditions are not enough to determine the phase . to see this
we explicitly write down the d - flatness conditions .
@xmath269 if @xmath270 can have both positive and negative value , topology change occurs as the sign of @xmath270 changes .
in fact , we can see that it occurs as follows . under the conditions ( [ eq : zeta11b ] )
, @xmath270 s must satisfy @xmath271 these inequalities restrict possible sign of @xmath270 and the following five cases , which we call ( a ) , ( b ) , ( c ) , ( d ) and ( e ) , are allowed .
@xmath272 we can see that the triangulation of the toric diagram is uniquely determined for each case .
the corresponding toric diagrams are depicted in figure [ fig : z11bflop ] .
each triangulation consists of eleven cones with volume one , thus it represents a phase of completely resolved manifolds with definite topology .
the phases ( a ) and ( b ) are connected by a flop with respect to the parallelogram with vertices @xmath273 , @xmath274 , @xmath275 and @xmath276 , and the flop is accomplished by the change of the sign of @xmath277 .
similarly the phases ( a ) and ( c ) , ( a ) and ( d ) , ( c ) and ( e ) are connected by a flop controlled by @xmath278 , @xmath279 , @xmath280 , respectively .
we can see that there is no triangulation except these five cases which completely resolves the orbifold singularity .
orbifolds often have non - isolated singularities as in the @xmath281 , @xmath236 case . consider an orbifold @xmath0 with @xmath97 .
if @xmath91 and @xmath105 have a common factor except one , the orbifold has a non - isolated fixed point of @xmath82 and hence has a non - isolated singularity .
thus there are models with non - isolated singularity if @xmath91 is not a prime number .
especially orbifold singularities are always non - isolated if @xmath91 is even
. the analyses in the previous sections can be almost straightforwardly applicable to these cases .
we have explicitly calculated the moduli space of d - branes on such orbifolds for @xmath282 cases , case , @xmath105 must be zero ( mod 2 ) for some @xmath94 , so the orbifold is a direct product of @xmath283 and @xmath96 . ] and @xmath281 , @xmath236 case and verified that only the geometric phases are realized .
topologically distinct phases emerge in the @xmath284 , @xmath285 case , in which there are five phases connected by flops ( figure [ fig : z6bflop ] ) .
we have also found that the moduli space consists of six blown - up phases connected by flops in the @xmath281 , @xmath236 case .
we can see that for both cases there is no other triangulation which completely resolves the orbifold singularity .
we also note that toric diagrams corresponding to non - isolated cases always have vertices on its codimension one boundary .
from the analyses we have made in this paper , it seems that there is a correspondence between the classification of models on @xmath0 by @xmath98 and the classification of triangles with area @xmath91 ( as noted in subsection 4.3 ) , and what phases are allowed for each model is determined according to the method of subdivisions of the triangle with area @xmath91 into @xmath91 triangles with area one .
( here vertices of each triangle lie on the lattice @xmath226 . )
it means that only completely blown - up phases are realized as pointed out in @xcite , and topology change can occur if the triangle with area @xmath91 includes parallelogram with respect to the lattice @xmath226 . | we consider d - branes on an orbifold @xmath0 and investigate the moduli space of the d - brane world - volume gauge theory by using toric geometry and gauged linear sigma models . for @xmath1 , we find that there are five phases , which are topologically distinct and connected by flops to each other .
we also verify that non - geometric phases are projected out for @xmath2 cases as expected .
resolutions of non - isolated singularities are also investigated . -.1cm-.4 |
a @xmath0-dimensional random walk that proceeds via a sequence of unit - length steps , each in an independent and uniformly random direction , is sometimes called a _ pearson rayleigh _ random walk ( prrw ) , after the exchange in the letters pages of _ nature _ between karl pearson and lord rayleigh in 1905 @xcite .
pearson was interested in two dimensions and questions of migration of species ( such as mosquitoes ) @xcite , although carazza has speculated that pearson was a golfer @xcite ; rayleigh had earlier considered the acoustic ` random walks ' in phase space produced by combinations of sound waves of the same amplitude and random phases .
the prrw can be represented via partial sums of sequences of i.i.d .
random vectors that are uniformly distributed on the unit sphere @xmath4 in @xmath5 .
clearly the increments have mean zero , i.e. , the prrw has _
zero drift_. the prrw has received some renewed interest recently as a model for microbe locomotion @xcite .
chapter 2 of @xcite gives a general discussion of these walks , which have been well - understood for many years .
in particular , it is well known that the prrw is recurrent for @xmath6 and transient if @xmath2 .
suppose that we replace the spherically symmetric increments of the prrw by increments that instead have some _ elliptical _ structure , while retaining the zero drift .
for example , one could take the increments to be uniformly distributed on the surface of an ellipsoid of fixed shape and orientation , as represented by the picture on the right of figure [ fig1 ] .
more generally , one should view the ellipses in figure [ fig1 ] as representing the _ covariance _ structure of the increments of the walk ( we will give a concrete example later ; the uniform distribution on the ellipse is actually not the most convenient for calculations ) .
( -2.5,-2.5 ) rectangle ( 2.5,2.5 ) ; ( 0,-2 ) edge ( 0,2 ) ( -2,0 ) edge ( 2,0 ) ; /in -1/-1 , -1/1 , 1/-1 , 1/1 , 0/0 ( , ) ellipse ( 10pt and 10pt ) ; ( -2.5,-2.5 ) rectangle ( 2.5,2.5 ) ; ( 0,-2 ) edge ( 0,2 ) ( -2,0 ) edge ( 2,0 ) ; /in -1/-1 , -1/1 , 1/-1 , 1/1 , 0/0 ( , ) ellipse ( 18pt and 6pt ) ; a little thought shows that the walk represented by the picture on the right of figure [ fig1 ] is essentially no different to the prrw : an affine transformation of @xmath5 will map the walk back to a walk whose increments have the same covariance structure as the prrw . to obtain genuinely different behaviour ,
it is necessary to abandon spatial homogeneity . in this paper
we consider a family of spatially _ non - homogeneous _ random walks with zero drift .
these include generalizations of the prrw in which the increments are not i.i.d . but have a distribution supported on an ellipsoid of fixed size and shape but whose orientation depends upon the current position of the walk .
figure [ fig2 ] gives representations of two important types of example , in which the ellipsoid is aligned so that its principal axes are parallel or perpendicular to the vector of the current position of the walk , which sits at the centre of the ellipse .
( -2.5,-2.5 ) rectangle ( 2.5,2.5 ) ; ( 0,-2 ) edge ( 0,2 ) ( -2,0 ) edge ( 2,0 ) ; in 22.5 , 67.5 , ... , 360 ( 0:1.5 ) ellipse ( 18pt and 8pt ) ; ( -2.5,-2.5 ) rectangle ( 2.5,2.5 ) ; ( 0,-2 ) edge ( 0,2 ) ( -2,0 ) edge ( 2,0 ) ; in 0 , 45 , ... , 359 ( 0:1.5 ) ellipse ( 6pt and 14pt ) ; the random walks represented by figure [ fig2 ] are no longer sums of i.i.d . variables .
these modified walks can behave very differently to the prrw .
for instance , one of the two - dimensional random walks represented in figure [ fig2 ] is _ transient _ while the other ( as in the classical case ) is recurrent .
the reader who has not seen this kind of example before may take a moment to identify which is which .
it is this _ anomalous recurrence behaviour _ that is the main subject of the present paper . in the next section ,
we give a formal description of our model and state our main results .
we end this introduction with a brief comment on motivation . in biology , the prrw is more natural than a lattice - based walk for modelling the motion of microscopic organisms , such as certain bacteria , on a surface .
experiment suggests that the locomotion of several kinds of cells consists of roughly straight line segments linked by discrete changes in direction : see , e.g. , @xcite . the generalization to elliptically - distributed increments studied here represents movement on a surface on which either radial or transverse motion is inhibited . in chemistry and physics
, the trajectory of a finite - step prrw ( also called a ` random chain ' ) is an idealized model of the growth of weakly interacting polymer molecules : see , e.g. , 2.6 of @xcite .
the modification to ellipsoid - supported jumps represents polymer growth in a biased medium .
we work in @xmath5 , @xmath7 .
our main interest is in @xmath3 , as we shall explain shortly .
write @xmath8 for the standard orthonormal basis vectors in @xmath5 .
write @xmath9 for the origin in @xmath5 , and let @xmath10 denote the euclidean norm and @xmath11 the euclidean inner product on @xmath5 .
write @xmath12 for the unit sphere in @xmath5 . for @xmath13 ,
set @xmath14 ; also set @xmath15 , for convenience . for definiteness
, vectors @xmath16 are viewed as column vectors throughout .
we now define @xmath17 , a discrete - time , time - homogeneous markov process on a ( non - empty , unbounded ) subset @xmath18 of @xmath5 .
formally , @xmath19 is a measurable space , @xmath18 is a borel subset of @xmath5 , and @xmath20 is the @xmath21-algebra of all @xmath22 for @xmath23 a borel set in @xmath5 .
suppose @xmath24 is some fixed ( i.e. , non - random ) point in @xmath18 .
write @xmath25 for the increments of @xmath26 . by assumption , given @xmath27 ,
the law of @xmath28 depends only on @xmath29 ( and not on @xmath30 ) ; so often we ease notation by taking @xmath31 and writing just @xmath32 for @xmath33 .
we also use the shorthand @xmath34 = { { \mathbb p } } [ \ , \cdot \ , \ ! \mid x_0 = { { \mathbf{x}}}]$ ] for probabilities when the walk is started from @xmath35 ; similarly we use @xmath36 for the corresponding expectations .
we make the following moments assumption : : : there exists @xmath37 such that @xmath38 < \infty$ ] .
the assumption ensures that @xmath32 has a well - defined mean vector @xmath39 $ ] , and we suppose that the random walk has _
zero drift _ : : : suppose that @xmath40 for all @xmath35 .
the assumption also ensures that @xmath32 has a well - defined covariance matrix , which we denote by @xmath41 , $ ] where @xmath32 is viewed as a column vector . to rule out pathological cases , we assume that @xmath32 is _ uniformly non - degenerate _ , in the following sense .
: : there exists @xmath42 such that @xmath43 \geq v$ ] for all @xmath35 .
note that assumption is weaker than _ uniform ellipticity _ , which in this context usually means , for some @xmath44 , @xmath45 \geq { \varepsilon}$ ] for all @xmath46 and all @xmath47 .
our main interest is in a recurrence classification .
first , we state the following basic ` non - confinement ' result .
[ lem : lim_sup_infty ] suppose that @xmath26 satisfies assumptions , and .
then @xmath48 we give the proof of proposition [ lem : lim_sup_infty ] in section [ sec : non - confinement ] ; we actually prove more , namely that the hypotheses of proposition [ lem : lim_sup_infty ] ensure that a version of kolmogorov s ` other ' inequality holds .
the fact ensures that questions of the escape of trajectories to infinity are non - trivial .
indeed , we will give conditions under which one or other of the following two behaviours ( which are not _ a priori _ exhaustive ) occurs : * @xmath49 , a.s .
, in which case we say that @xmath26 is _ transient _ ; * @xmath50 , a.s . , for some constant @xmath51 , when we say @xmath26 is
_ recurrent_. if @xmath26 is an irreducible time - homogeneous markov chain on a locally finite state - space , these definitions reduce to the usual notions of transience and recurrence ; in general state - spaces , our approach allows us to avoid unnecessary technicalities concerning irreducibility . in dimension @xmath52
, it is a consequence of the classical chung
fuchs theorem ( see @xcite or chapter 9 of @xcite ) that a spatially _ homogeneous _ random walk with zero drift is necessarily recurrent .
however , this is _ not _ true for a spatially non - homogeneous random walk : as observed by rogozin and foss @xcite , a counterexample is provided by a version of the ` oscillating random walk ' of kemperman @xcite in which the increment law is one of two distributions ( with mean zero but infinite second moment ) depending on the walk s present sign .
our conditions exclude these heavy - tailed phenomena , so that in @xmath52 recurrence is assured in our setting .
[ t : zero_drift_implies_recurrence ] suppose that @xmath52 .
suppose that @xmath26 satisfies assumptions , , and .
then @xmath26 is recurrent .
theorem [ t : zero_drift_implies_recurrence ] is essentially contained in a result of lamperti ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 3.2 ) ; we give a self - contained proof below .
theorem [ t : zero_drift_implies_recurrence ] shows that in @xmath52 , under mild conditions , the classical chung
fuchs recurrence classification for homogeneous zero - drift random walks extends to zero - drift non - homogeneous random walks .
the purpose of the present paper is to demonstrate a natural family of examples in dimension @xmath3 where this extension fails , and hence exhibit the following .
there exist spatially non - homogeneous random walks whose increments are non - degenerate , have uniformly bounded second moments , and have zero mean , which are -3 mm * transient in @xmath53 ; * recurrent in @xmath2 .
although certainly appreciated by experts , this fact is perhaps not as widely known as it might be .
zeitouni ( pp . 9192 of @xcite ) describes an example of a transient zero - drift random walk on @xmath54 , and states that the idea `` goes back to krylov ( in the context of diffusions ) '' .
peres , popov and sousi @xcite investigate the minimal number of different increment distributions required for anomalous recurrence behaviour .
we now introduce our family of non - homogeneous random walks .
write @xmath55 for the matrix ( operator ) norm given by @xmath56 .
the following assumption on the asymptotic stability of the covariance structure of the process along rays is central .
: : suppose that there exists a positive - definite matrix function @xmath57 with domain @xmath4 such that , as @xmath58 , @xmath59 a little informally , says that @xmath60 as @xmath61 ; in what follows , we will often make similar statements , formal versions of which may be cast as in .
note that and together imply that @xmath62 ; next we impose a key assumption on the form of @xmath57 that is considerably stronger . to describe this , it is convenient to introduce the notation @xmath63 that defines , for each @xmath46 , an inner product on @xmath5 via @xmath64 : : suppose that there exist constants @xmath65 and @xmath66 with @xmath67 such that , for all @xmath46 , @xmath68 informally , @xmath66 quantifies the total variance of the increments , while @xmath65 quantifies the variance in the radial direction ; necessarily @xmath69 . the assumption that @xmath70 excludes some degenerate cases . as we will see , one possible way to satisfy condition is to suppose that the eigenvectors of @xmath71 are all parallel or perpendicular to the vector @xmath72 , and that the corresponding eigenvalues are all constant as @xmath72 varies ; the level sets of the corresponding quadratic forms @xmath73 for @xmath46 are then ellipsoids like those depicted in figure [ fig2 ] .
our main result is the following , which shows that both transience and recurrence are possible for _ any _ @xmath3 , depending on parameter choices ; as seen in theorem [ t : zero_drift_implies_recurrence ] , this possibility of anomalous recurrence behaviour is a genuinely multidimensional phenomenon under our regularity conditions .
[ thm : recurrence ] suppose that @xmath26 satisfies , with constants @xmath74 as defined in .
the following recurrence classification is valid . * if @xmath75 , then @xmath26 is transient . * if @xmath76 , then @xmath26 is recurrent . *
if @xmath77 and holds with @xmath78 for some @xmath79 , then @xmath26 is recurrent .
moreover , we show that in any of the above cases , @xmath26 is _ null _ in the following sense .
[ thm : null ] suppose that @xmath26 satisfies , with constants @xmath74 as defined in .
then , in any of the cases ( i)(iii ) in theorem [ thm : recurrence ] , for any bounded @xmath80 , @xmath81 [ rem : uequalsv ] theorems [ thm : recurrence ] and [ thm : null ] both remain valid if we permit @xmath82 in ; indeed , the condition @xmath83 is not used in the proof of theorem [ thm : recurrence ] given below , so this case is recurrent , by theorem [ thm : recurrence](ii ) . the condition @xmath83 is used at one point to simplify the proof of theorem [ thm : null ] given below , but a small modification of the argument also works in the case @xmath84 .
the remainder of the paper is organised as follows . in section [ sec : ell - rws ] we describe a specific family of examples called _ elliptic random walk models _ that satisfy assumptions and exhibit both transient and recurrent behaviour dependent on the parameters of the model .
we also present some simulated data that depicts the random walks in both cases . in section [ sec : non - confinement ] we prove a @xmath0-dimensional martingale version of kolmogorov s other inequality and use that to prove the non - confinement result ( proposition [ lem : lim_sup_infty ] ) . in section [ sec : rw ] we prove the recurrence classification ( theorem [ thm : recurrence ] ) , and in section [ sec : nullity ] we prove theorem [ thm : null ] . in the appendix we prove recurrence in the one - dimensional case ( theorem [ t : zero_drift_implies_recurrence ] ) .
finally , we remark that in work in progress we investigate diffusive scaling limits for random walks of the type described in the present paper ; the diffusions that appear as scaling limits possess certain pathologies from the point of view of diffusion theory that make them interesting in their own right .
let @xmath3 . we describe a specific model on @xmath85 where the jump distribution at @xmath16 is supported on an ellipsoid having one distinguished axis aligned with the vector @xmath47 .
the model is specified by two constants @xmath86 .
construct @xmath32 as follows .
given @xmath87 , take @xmath88 uniform on @xmath4 and set @xmath89 for @xmath90 an orthogonal matrix representing a transformation of @xmath5 mapping @xmath91 to @xmath92 , and @xmath93 .
see figure [ fig : delta ] .
( -2,-2.2 ) rectangle ( 10,2 ) ; ( -0.5,0 ) circle ( 1 ) ; ( -1.5,0 ) arc ( 180:360:1 and 0.4 ) ; ( 0.5,0 ) arc ( 0:180:1 and 0.4 ) ; at ( -0.3,0.65 ) @xmath88 ; ( 4,0 ) ellipse ( 1.2 and 2 ) ; ( 2.8,0 ) arc ( 180:360:1.2 and 0.6 ) ; ( 5.2,0 ) arc ( 0:180:1.2 and 0.6 ) ; at ( 4.2,1.2 ) @xmath94 ; ( 9,0 ) ellipse ( 1.2 and 1.8 ) ; ( 7.8,0 ) arc ( 180:360:1.2 and 0.75 ) ; ( 10.2,0 ) arc ( 0:180:1.2 and 0.75 ) ; ( -0.5,0 ) edge ( 0.1,0.6 ) ( 4,0 ) edge ( 4.72,1.2 ) [ rotate around=-30:(9,0 ) ] ( 9,0 ) edge ( 9.72,1.08 ) ; at ( 10,0.85 ) @xmath32 ; at ( 9.2,-0.3 ) @xmath47 ; at ( 7.2,-2.5 ) @xmath9 ; ( 9,0 ) edge ( 9,-3 ) ; ( 9,-3 ) circle ( 1pt ) ; ( 1,0 ) ( 2.4,0 ) ; ( 5.7,0 ) ( 7.1,0 ) ; ( recall that @xmath95 , so for @xmath96 we can take @xmath97 and @xmath98 . ) thus @xmath32 is a random point on an ellipsoid that has one distinguished semi - axis , of length @xmath99 , aligned in the @xmath92 direction , and all other semi - axes of length @xmath100 .
note that the law of @xmath32 is well defined owing to the spherical symmetry of the uniform distribution on @xmath4 and the fact that only one axis of the ellipsoid is distinguished ( for this reason it is enough to take any @xmath90 satisfying @xmath101 in order to define @xmath32 ; see also remark [ rem : hx ] below ) .
note also that @xmath32 is not chosen to be uniformly distributed on the surface of the ellipsoid ; this does not affect the range of asymptotic behaviour exhibited by the family of walks as @xmath102 and @xmath103 vary , but it does simplify the calculation of @xmath104 .
indeed , we have @xmath105 = \operatorname{\mathbb{e } } [ q_{\hat{{{\mathbf{x } } } } } d { { \bm{\zeta}}}{{\bm{\zeta}}}^{{\scalebox{0.6}{$\top$}}}d q_{\hat{{{\mathbf{x}}}}}^{{\scalebox{0.6}{$\top$ } } } ] = q_{\hat{{{\mathbf{x } } } } } d \operatorname{\mathbb{e } } [ { { \bm{\zeta}}}{{\bm{\zeta}}}^{{\scalebox{0.6}{$\top$ } } } ] d q_{\hat{{{\mathbf{x}}}}}^{{\scalebox{0.6}{$\top$}}}= \frac{1}{d } q_{\hat{{{\mathbf{x } } } } } d^2 q_{\hat{{{\mathbf{x}}}}}^{{\scalebox{0.6}{$\top$}}},\ ] ] by linearity of expectation , and using the fact that @xmath106 = \frac{1}{d}i$ ] for @xmath88 uniformly distributed on @xmath4 .
also , a calculation similar to the above confirms that @xmath40 for all @xmath16 , since @xmath107 = { { \mathbf{0}}}$ ] .
since @xmath108 is bounded above by @xmath109 , assumption holds . clearly and hold , with @xmath110 for @xmath46 .
it is also a simple matter to check that and hold : the matrix @xmath71 represented in coordinates for the orthonormal basis @xmath111 is diagonal with entries @xmath112 .
indeed , @xmath113 q_{{\mathbf{u}}}^{{\scalebox{0.6}{$\top$}}}\\ & = a^2 { { \mathbf{u}}}{{\mathbf{u}}}^{{\scalebox{0.6}{$\top$}}}+ b^2 ( i - { { \mathbf{u}}}{{\mathbf{u}}}^{{\scalebox{0.6}{$\top$ } } } ) , \end{split}\ ] ] and therefore @xmath114 for all @xmath46 , and @xmath115 for all @xmath16 . [ rem : hx ] the seeming ambiguity in the definition of @xmath32 due to the choice of @xmath116
can be resolved by noting that @xmath32 can be rewritten as @xmath117 where @xmath118 is also uniform on @xmath4 ( this follows from the spherical symmetry of the uniform distribution on @xmath4 ) .
moreover , the symmetric matrix @xmath119 is determined explicitly in terms of @xmath92 : @xmath120 consequently , we could choose to specify @xmath32 explicitly as @xmath121 with @xmath122 taken to be uniform on @xmath4 .
as before , we find that @xmath123 = h_{\hat{{\mathbf{x } } } } \operatorname{\mathbb{e } } [ \tilde{{\bm{\zeta } } } ] = { { \mathbf{0}}}$ ] and @xmath124 = h_{\hat{{\mathbf{x } } } } \operatorname{\mathbb{e } } [ \tilde{{\bm{\zeta}}}\tilde{{\bm{\zeta}}}^{{\scalebox{0.6}{$\top$}}}]h_{\hat{{\mathbf{x } } } } = \textstyle\frac{1}{d}h_{\hat{{\mathbf{x}}}}^2 = a^2\hat{{\mathbf{x}}}\hat{{\mathbf{x}}}^{{\scalebox{0.6}{$\top$}}}+ b^2 ( i - \hat{{\mathbf{x}}}\hat{{\mathbf{x}}}^{{\scalebox{0.6}{$\top$}}}).\ ] ] recall that we assume our random walk to be time - homogeneous , so that equation in fact determines the distribution of @xmath28 for all @xmath125 .
formally , we define @xmath126 a sequence of independent random variables uniformly distributed on @xmath4 , and for each @xmath125 we define @xmath28 conditional on @xmath127 via @xmath128 we call @xmath129 defined in this way an _ elliptic random walk_. as a corollary to theorems [ thm : recurrence ] and [ thm : null ] , we get the following recurrence classification for the elliptic random walk model . for this model
the @xmath130 in is identically zero so we get a complete classification that includes the boundary case .
[ cor : ellipsoid - lamperti ] let @xmath3 and @xmath131 .
let @xmath26 be an elliptic random walk on @xmath5 .
then @xmath26 is transient if @xmath132 and null - recurrent if @xmath133 . in two dimensions we can explicitly describe the random walk as follows . for @xmath134 , @xmath135 with @xmath136 in cartesian components ,
set @xmath137 .
fix @xmath138 .
let @xmath139 denote the ellipse with centre @xmath47 and principal axes aligned in the @xmath47 , @xmath140 directions , with lengths @xmath141 , @xmath142 respectively , given in parametrized form by @xmath143 \right\},\ ] ] and for @xmath144 set @xmath145 \right\}.\ ] ] the parameter @xmath146 in the parametrization ( [ param ] ) should be interpreted with caution : it is _ not _ , in general , the central angle of the parametrized point on the ellipse . given @xmath147 , @xmath148 is taken to be distributed on @xmath149 , ` uniformly ' with respect to the parametrization ( [ param ] ) .
precisely , let @xmath150 be a sequence of independent random variables uniformly distributed on @xmath151 $ ] . then , on @xmath152 , @xmath153 while , on @xmath154 , @xmath155 figure [ fig : sim ] shows two sample paths of a simulation of the elliptic random walk in @xmath156 in the two cases of recurrence and transience . in each picture
the walk starts at the origin at the centre of the picture ; time is represented by the variation in colour ( from red to yellow , or from dark to light if viewed in grey - scale ) . for the recurrent case @xmath157 ( _ left _ ) and the transient case @xmath158 ( _ right_).,title="fig : " ] for the recurrent case @xmath157 ( _ left _ ) and the transient case @xmath158 ( _ right_).,title="fig : " ] [ rem : ellipse ] a. the process @xmath26 reduces to the classical prrw when @xmath159 : in that case it is spatially homogeneous , i.e. , the distribution of the increment @xmath160 does not depend on @xmath29 . for @xmath161 the random walk is not spatially homogeneous , and the jump distribution depends upon the projection onto the unit sphere of the walk s current position .
b. as mentioned earlier , we choose to take increments as defined at , rather than increments that are uniform on the ellipse with respect to one - dimensional lebesgue measure on @xmath139 , purely for computational reasons .
in fact , in two dimensions , since the lebesgue measure on @xmath139 coincides with the measure induced by taking @xmath146 uniformly distributed on @xmath151 $ ] when @xmath159 , and the case @xmath162 is critically recurrent , the qualitative behaviour will be the same in either case : the walk will be transient for @xmath163 and recurrent for @xmath164 . for higher dimensions , taking increments that are uniform with respect to the lebesgue measure on @xmath165 will still specify a family of models that exhibit a phase transition , from transience ( for @xmath166 small ) to recurrence ( for @xmath166 large ) but the exact shape of the ellipsoid in the critical case ( i.e. , the smallest ratio @xmath166 for which the walk is recurrent )
may be different .
c. it follows from that @xmath167 in particular , for this family of models @xmath168 is itself a markov process , since the distribution of @xmath169 depends only on @xmath170 and not @xmath29 ; however , in the general setting of section [ sec : rws ] , this need not be the case .
+ one - dimensional processes with evolutions reminiscent to that given by have been studied previously by kingman @xcite and bingham @xcite .
those processes can be viewed , respectively , as the distance from its start point of a random walk in euclidean space , and the geodesic distance from its start point of a random walk on the surface of a sphere , but in both cases the increments of the random walk have the property that the distribution of the jump vector is a product of the independent marginal distributions of the length and direction of the jump vector .
in contrast , for the elliptic random walk the laws of @xmath171 and @xmath172 are _ not _ independent ( except when @xmath162 ) .
d. [ rem : stas ] the theory equally applies to the case where the ellipsoid specifying the jump distribution is oriented with some fixed angle @xmath173 with respect to the radial direction .
if we define @xmath174 , where @xmath175 is an orthogonal matrix that maps @xmath176 to @xmath177 , then we find that transience of @xmath26 is equivalent to @xmath178 note that for @xmath53 , @xmath179 and therefore @xmath32 are well defined , but this is not so for higher dimensions . nevertheless , for _ any _ collection of matrices @xmath180 satisfying @xmath181 for all @xmath46 we get the same recurrence classification .
this is because the distribution of @xmath182 given @xmath29 is determined through the angle @xmath183 via @xmath184 and therefore assumption holds with @xmath185 and @xmath186 .
in this section we prove that the assumptions , , and imply that @xmath187 , a.s .
we first present a general result for martingales on @xmath5 satisfying a `` uniform dispersion '' condition ; the result can be viewed as a @xmath0-dimensional martingale version of _ kolmogorov s other inequality _ ( see e.g. @xcite ) .
[ lem : d - dim - koi ] let @xmath188 .
suppose that @xmath189 is an @xmath5-valued process adapted to a filtration @xmath190 , with @xmath191 = 1 $ ] .
suppose that there exist @xmath192 such that for all @xmath193 , a.s .
, @xmath194 & \leq b ; \label{koi : moments}\\ \operatorname{\mathbb{e } } [ \| y_{n+1 } - y_n \|^2 \mid { { \mathcal g}}_n ] & \geq v ; \label{koi : unif - ellip } \\
\operatorname{\mathbb{e } } [ y_{n+1 } - y_n \mid { { \mathcal g}}_n ] & = { { \mathbf{0}}}. \label{koi : zero - drift } \end{aligned}\ ] ] then there exists @xmath195 , depending only on @xmath23 , @xmath196 , and @xmath197 , such that for all @xmath198 and all @xmath199 , @xmath200 \geq 1 - \frac{d(1+x)^2}{n } , { \ \text{a.s.}}\ ] ] let @xmath201 and set @xmath202 ; throughout the paper we adopt the usual convention @xmath203 . in analogy with previous notation ,
write @xmath204 for the jump distribution , and let @xmath205 where @xmath206 is a constant to be specified later .
note that @xmath207 is @xmath208-measurable .
now , on @xmath209 , @xmath210 and @xmath211 = { } & \operatorname{\mathbb{e } } [ \delta_n \mid { { \mathcal g}}_n ] \\ & { } + \operatorname{\mathbb{e } } [ \widehat{\delta}_n\left((a-1)(1+x ) - \|\delta_n\|\right){{\mathbf 1}{\{\|y_{n+1}\| > a(1+x)\ } } } \mid { { \mathcal g}}_n ] .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] but @xmath212 implies that @xmath213 , and by , @xmath214 = { { \mathbf{0}}}$ ] .
hence , on @xmath215 , @xmath216 \bigr\| & \leq \operatorname{\mathbb{e } } [ \|\delta_n\| { { \mathbf 1}{\ { \|\delta_n\| > ( a-1)(1+x)\ } } } \mid { { \mathcal g}}_n]\\ & \leq ( a-1)^{-1}(1+x)^{-1 } \operatorname{\mathbb{e } }
[ \|\delta_n\|^2 \mid { { \mathcal g}}_n ] \\ & \leq b'(a-1)^{-1}(1+x)^{-1 } , { \ \text{a.s.}},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where , by and lyapunov s inequality , @xmath217 depends only on @xmath23 and @xmath196 .
hence we can choose @xmath218 for some @xmath219 large enough so that @xmath220 \bigr\| \leq ( v/8)(1+x)^{-1 } , \text { on } \
{ \| y_n \| \leq x \ } .\ ] ] [ eq : w - square ] also , on @xmath215 , by a similar argument , @xmath221 \bigr\| & = \operatorname{\mathbb{e } } [ \|\delta_n\|^2 \mid { { \mathcal g}}_n ] \nonumber\\ & \quad + \operatorname{\mathbb{e } } [ \left ( ( a-1)^2(1+x)^2 - \|\delta_n\|^2 \right){{\mathbf 1}{\ { \|y_{n+1}\| > a(1+x ) \ } } } \mid { { \mathcal g}}_n ] \nonumber\\ & \geq \operatorname{\mathbb{e } } [ \|\delta_n\|^2 \mid { { \mathcal g}}_n ] - \operatorname{\mathbb{e } } [ \|\delta_n\|^2 { { \mathbf 1}{\ { \| \delta_{n}\| > ( a-1)(1+x ) \ } } } \mid { { \mathcal g}}_n ] \nonumber\\ & \geq v - ( a-1)^{2-p}(1+x)^{2-p } \operatorname{\mathbb{e } } [ \|\delta_n\|^p \mid { { \mathcal g}}_n ] \nonumber\\ & \geq v/2,\end{aligned}\ ] ] for all @xmath222 and @xmath223 for sufficiently large @xmath224 , using and .
now , set @xmath225 .
then , on @xmath226 , by and , @xmath227 & = \operatorname{\mathbb{e } } [ \|w_{n+1}\|^2 - \|w_n\|^2 \mid { { \mathcal g}}_n ] \\ & = \operatorname{\mathbb{e } } [ \|w_{n+1 } - w_n\|^2 \mid { { \mathcal g}}_n ] + 2 \bigl{\langle}w_n , \operatorname{\mathbb{e } } [ w_{n+1 } - w_n \mid { { \mathcal g}}_n ] \bigr{\rangle}\\ & \geq \frac{v}{2 } - \frac { 2 \|w_n\| v } { 8(1+x ) } \geq \frac{v}{2 } - \frac { v x } { 4(1+x ) } \geq \frac{v}{4}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] hence @xmath228 is a @xmath208-adapted submartingale , where @xmath229 by construction , @xmath230 , so @xmath231 \leq \operatorname{\mathbb{e } } [ z_n \mid { { \mathcal g}}_0 ] - \sum_{k=0}^{n-1 } \operatorname{\mathbb{e } } [ v_k \mid { { \mathcal g}}_0 ] \leq a^2(1+x)^2 - \sum_{k=0}^{n-1 } \frac{v}{4 } { { \mathbb p } } [ n < \tau \mid { { \mathcal g}}_0 ] , \ ] ] which implies @xmath232
\leq a^2(1+x)^2 $ ] . in other words , @xmath233 \leq \frac{4a^2(1+x)^2}{v n } , { \ \text{a.s.}}\qedhere\ ] ] now we can give the proof of proposition [ lem : lim_sup_infty ] .
it is enough to show that for all @xmath234 the event @xmath235 occurs infinitely often . for a given @xmath236
, we will apply lemma [ lem : d - dim - koi ] to @xmath237 with @xmath238 ; that result is applicable , since , and imply , and , respectively .
thus lemma [ lem : d - dim - koi ] shows that , for some finite @xmath239 , @xmath240 } \geq \frac{1}{2 } , { \ \text{a.s.}},\ ] ] for all @xmath241 . for @xmath242 , define the event @xmath243 and filtration @xmath244 .
then @xmath245 , and , by , @xmath246 } \geq \frac{1}{2}$ ] , a.s . , for all @xmath247 .
an application of lvy s extension of the borel
cantelli lemma ( see , e.g. , ( * ? ? ?
* cor . 7.20 ) ) shows that @xmath248 occurs infinitely often , a.s . for each @xmath247
such that @xmath248 occurs , either * @xmath249 , or * @xmath250 and @xmath251 for some @xmath252 .
since one of these cases must occur for infinitely many @xmath247 , we have that @xmath253 occurs infinitely often , as required .
in this section we study the random walk @xmath29 and give the proof of the recurrence classification , theorem [ thm : recurrence ] .
the method of proof is based on applying classical results of lamperti @xcite to the @xmath254-valued radial process given by @xmath255 .
the method rests on an analysis of the increments @xmath256 given @xmath257 ; in general , @xmath258 is not itself a markov process
. the following notation will be useful . given @xmath135 and @xmath259 , write @xmath260 so that @xmath261 is the component of @xmath262 in the @xmath177 direction , and @xmath263 is a vector perpendicular to @xmath177 .
first we state a general result on the increments of @xmath258 for a markov process @xmath29 on @xmath18 .
recall that we write @xmath264 , and let @xmath265 be the radial component of @xmath32 at @xmath87 in accordance with the notation described above ; no confusion should arise with our notation @xmath28 defined previously .
we make an important comment on notation . when we write @xmath266 , and similar expressions , these are understood to be uniform in @xmath47 .
that is , if @xmath267 and @xmath268 , we write @xmath269 to mean that there exist @xmath270 and @xmath271 such that @xmath272 [ lemma1 ] suppose that @xmath26 is a discrete - time , time - homogeneous markov process on @xmath273 satisfying for some @xmath37 .
then , for @xmath255 , we have @xmath274 < \infty,\ ] ] and the radial increment moment functions satisfy @xmath275 = \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}_{{\mathbf{x } } } [ \delta_{{\mathbf{x } } } ] + \frac { \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}_{{\mathbf{x } } } [ \| \delta \|^2 - \delta^2_{{{\mathbf{x } } } } ] } { 2 \| { { \mathbf{x}}}\| } + o ( \| { { \mathbf{x}}}\|^{-1-\delta } ) , \\ \label{mu2 } \mu_2({{\mathbf{x } } } ) & : = \operatorname{\mathbb{e } } [ ( r_{n+1}- r_n)^2 \mid x_n = { { \mathbf{x } } } ] = \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}_{{\mathbf{x } } } [ \delta_{{\mathbf{x}}}^2 ] + o ( \|{{\mathbf{x}}}\|^{-\delta } ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] as @xmath61 , for some @xmath276 . by time - homogeneity
, it suffices to consider the case @xmath31 . by the triangle inequality , @xmath277 , so that follows from .
we prove and by approximating @xmath278 \end{split}\ ] ] for large @xmath47 .
let @xmath279 for some @xmath280 to be determined later .
on the event @xmath281 we approximate using taylor s formula for @xmath282 , and on the event @xmath283 we bound using .
indeed , for all @xmath284 , taylor s theorem with lagrange remainder shows that @xmath285 for some @xmath286 $ ] , so on the event @xmath281 , @xmath287 where the error terms follow from the fact that @xmath288 for @xmath289 . on the other hand , @xmath290 by the triangle inequality and the fact that @xmath291 on @xmath283 . since @xmath292
we can combine and to give @xmath293 \biggr|\\ & = \biggl| \| { { \mathbf{x}}}+ \delta \| - \|{{\mathbf{x}}}\| - \left[\delta_{{\mathbf{x}}}+ \left ( \frac{\| \delta \|^2 - \delta_{{\mathbf{x}}}^2 } { 2\| { { \mathbf{x}}}\| } \right ) \left ( 1 + o(\| { { \mathbf{x}}}\|^{\beta-1 } ) \right ) \right ] \biggr| { { \mathbf 1}{(a_{{\mathbf{x}}}^{{{\mathrm{c } } } } ) } } \\ & \leq \| \delta \|^p \| { { \mathbf{x}}}\|^{\beta(1-p ) } + \left| \delta_{{\mathbf{x}}}+ \left
( \frac{\| \delta \|^2 - \delta_{{\mathbf{x}}}^2 } { 2\| { { \mathbf{x}}}\| } \right ) \left ( 1 + o(\| { { \mathbf{x}}}\|^{\beta-1 } ) \right ) \right| { { \mathbf 1 } { ( a_{{\mathbf{x}}}^{{{\mathrm{c } } } } ) } } \\ & \leq 2 \| \delta \|^p \| { { \mathbf{x}}}\|^{\beta(1-p ) } + \frac{\| \delta \|^p}{2\| { { \mathbf{x}}}\| } \left ( 1 + o(\|
{ { \mathbf{x}}}\|^{\beta-1 } ) \right ) \|{{\mathbf{x}}}\|^{\beta(2-p ) } .\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore , taking expectations and using , we obtain @xmath294 + \frac { \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}_{{\mathbf{x}}}[\| \delta \|^2 - \delta_{{\mathbf{x}}}^2 ] } { 2\| { { \mathbf{x}}}\| } + o ( \| { { \mathbf{x}}}\|^{\beta-2 } ) + o ( \| { { \mathbf{x}}}\|^{\beta(1-p ) } ) + o ( \| { { \mathbf{x}}}\|^{\beta(2-p ) - 1 } ) .\ ] ] taking @xmath295 makes all the error terms of size @xmath296 for some @xmath297 , namely for @xmath298 .
for the second moment , we use the identity @xmath299 so that @xmath300 + \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}_{{\mathbf{x}}}[\|\delta\|^2 ] - 2\|{{\mathbf{x}}}\|\mu_1({{\mathbf{x } } } ) = \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}_{{\mathbf{x}}}[\delta_{{\mathbf{x}}}^2 ] + o(\|{{\mathbf{x}}}\|^{-\delta}),\ ] ] as required . with the additional assumptions , , and
, we can use lemma [ lemma1 ] to prove the following result .
[ lemma2 ] suppose that @xmath26 is a discrete - time , time - homogeneous markov process on @xmath273 satisfying , , , and .
then , with @xmath301 defined at , , and @xmath130 defined at , there exists @xmath302 such that , as @xmath303 , @xmath304 by definition of @xmath130 at we have @xmath305 as @xmath303 .
then implies that @xmath306 & = \operatorname{tr}{(m({{\mathbf{x}}}))}\\ & = \operatorname{tr}{(\sigma^2(\hat{{\mathbf{x } } } ) ) } + o({\varepsilon}(\|{{\mathbf{x}}}\|))\\ & = v + o({\varepsilon}(\|{{\mathbf{x}}}\| ) ) , \end{split}\ ] ] and @xmath307 & = { \langle}\hat{{\mathbf{x } } } , m({{\mathbf{x } } } ) \cdot \hat{{\mathbf{x}}}{\rangle}\\ & = { \langle}\hat{{\mathbf{x } } } , \sigma^2(\hat{{\mathbf{x } } } ) \cdot \hat{{\mathbf{x}}}{\rangle}+ o({\varepsilon}(\|{{\mathbf{x}}}\|))\\ & = u + o({\varepsilon}(\|{{\mathbf{x}}}\| ) ) , \end{split}\ ] ] and implies that @xmath308 = \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}_{{{\mathbf{x } } } } [ { \langle}\delta , \hat{{\mathbf{x}}}{\rangle } ] = { \langle}\mu({{\mathbf{x } } } ) , \hat{{\mathbf{x}}}{\rangle}= 0 $ ] .
using these expressions in lemma [ lemma1 ] yields .
now we can complete the proof of theorem [ thm : recurrence ] .
we apply lamperti s @xcite recurrence classification to @xmath309 , the radial process .
proposition [ lem : lim_sup_infty ] shows that @xmath310 , and lemma [ lemma1 ] tells us that is satisfied .
because the error terms in are uniform in @xmath47 , lemma [ lemma2 ] shows that for all @xmath311 there exists @xmath312 such that @xmath313\ ] ] for all @xmath35 with @xmath314 .
therefore , it follows from theorem 3.2 of @xcite that @xmath26 is transient if @xmath315 and recurrent if @xmath316 .
for the boundary case , when @xmath317 , if @xmath78 then @xmath318 for @xmath319 , which implies that @xmath26 is recurrent , again by theorem 3.2 of @xcite .
in this section we give the proof of theorem [ thm : null ] . in the transient case , this is straightforward . [
lem : null - trans ] in case ( i ) of theorem [ thm : recurrence ] , for any bounded @xmath80 , as @xmath320 , the null property holds .
it is sufficient to prove in the case where @xmath321 . in case ( i ) , @xmath26 is transient , meaning that @xmath322 a.s .
, so that @xmath323 , a.s .
, for any @xmath271 .
hence the cesro limit in is also @xmath324 , a.s . , and the @xmath325 convergence follows from the bounded convergence theorem .
it remains to consider cases ( ii ) and ( iii ) , when @xmath26 is recurrent .
thus there exists @xmath51 such that @xmath326 , a.s . let @xmath327 .
it suffices to take @xmath328 , @xmath329 , so @xmath330 infinitely often .
we make the following claim , whose proof is deferred until the end of this section , which says that if the walk has not yet entered a ball of radius @xmath331 ( for any @xmath332 big enough ) , the time until it reaches the ball of radius @xmath333 has tail bounded below as displayed .
[ lem : null - estimate ] in cases ( ii ) and ( iii ) of theorem [ thm : recurrence ] , there exists a finite @xmath334 such that for any @xmath335 and @xmath336 there exists a finite positive @xmath337 such that @xmath338 \geq c m^{-1/2 } , \text { on } \ { n < \tau_{r } \ } , \ ] ] for all sufficiently large @xmath339 . assuming this result
, we can complete the proof of theorem [ thm : null ] . in case ( i ) , the result is contained in lemma [ lem : null - trans ] .
so consider cases ( ii ) and ( iii ) .
fix @xmath333 and @xmath331 with @xmath340 , with @xmath341 as in lemma [ lem : null - estimate ] .
note that @xmath342 , a.s .
set @xmath343 and then define recursively , for @xmath344 , the stopping times @xmath345 with the convention that @xmath203 . since @xmath329 and @xmath346 ( by proposition [ lem : lim_sup_infty ] ) , for all @xmath344 we have @xmath347 and @xmath348 , a.s . , and @xmath349 in particular , @xmath350 , a.s
. we now write @xmath351 .
we use lemma [ lem : d - dim - koi ] to show that the process must exit from @xmath352 rapidly enough . indeed , if @xmath353 is any finite stopping time , set @xmath354 and @xmath355 .
then the assumptions , and show that the hypotheses of lemma [ lem : d - dim - koi ] are satisfied , since , for example , @xmath356 = \operatorname{\mathbb{e } } [ \| x_{\kappa+n+1 } -x_{\kappa+n } \|^p \mid { { \mathcal f}}_{\kappa+n } ] = \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}_{x_{\kappa + n } } [ \| \delta \|^p ] , \ ] ] by the strong markov property for @xmath26 at the finite stopping time @xmath357 . in particular , another application of lemma [ lem :
d - dim - koi ] , similarly to , shows that we may choose @xmath358 sufficiently large so that @xmath359 \geq \frac{1}{2 } , { \ \text{a.s.}},\ ] ] an event whose occurrence ensures that if @xmath360 , then @xmath26 exits @xmath352 before time @xmath361 . fix @xmath362 .
then , an application of at stopping time @xmath363 shows that @xmath364 \leq { { \mathbb p}}\bigl [ \max_{0 \leq \ell \leq n(r ) } \| x_{{\gamma_k } + \ell } - x_{\gamma_k } \| < 2 r { \ ; \bigl| \;}{{\mathcal f}}_{\gamma_k } \bigr ] \leq \frac{1}{2 } , { \
\text{a.s.}}\ ] ] similarly , @xmath365 & = \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}\bigl [ { { \mathbf 1}{\ { \eta_k - \gamma_k > n(r ) \ } } } \operatorname{\mathbb{e } } [ { { \mathbf 1}{\ { \eta_k - \gamma_k > 2 n(r ) \ } } } \mid { { \mathcal f}}_{\gamma_k + n(r ) } ] { \ ; \bigl| \;}{{\mathcal f}}_{\gamma_k } \bigr ] \\ & \leq \frac{1}{2 } { { \mathbb p } } [ \eta_k - \gamma_k >
n ( r ) \mid { { \mathcal f}}_{\gamma_k } ] \leq \frac{1}{4 } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] this time applying at stopping time @xmath366 as well .
iterating this argument , it follows that @xmath367 \leq 2^{-m}$ ] , a.s .
, for all @xmath368 . from here
, it is straightforward to deduce that , for some constant @xmath312 , for any @xmath362 , @xmath369 \leq c , { \ \text{a.s.}}\ ] ] on the other hand , the tail estimate implies that @xmath370 \geq c m^{-1/2 } , { \
\text{a.s.}},\ ] ] for @xmath371 and all sufficiently large @xmath339 . for any @xmath372 , set @xmath373 ,
so that @xmath374 for @xmath375 .
note @xmath376 and @xmath377 , a.s .
then we claim @xmath378 this is easiest to see by considering two separate cases .
first , if @xmath379 , @xmath380 which implies , since the set of @xmath247 less than @xmath30 for which @xmath381 is contained in the set @xmath382 . on the other hand ,
if @xmath383 , using the elementary inequality @xmath384 for non - negative @xmath385 with @xmath386 , we have @xmath387 which again gives .
to estimate the growth rates of the numerator and denominator of the right - hand side of , we apply some results from @xcite .
first , writing @xmath388 and @xmath389 , by we can apply theorem 2.4 of @xcite to the @xmath390-adapted process @xmath391 to obtain that for any @xmath44 , a.s .
, for all but finitely many @xmath339 , @xmath392 on the other hand , writing @xmath393 and @xmath394 , by we can apply theorem 2.6 of @xcite to the @xmath390-adapted process @xmath391 to obtain that for any @xmath44 , for all @xmath339 sufficiently large , @xmath395 now gives the almost - sure version of the result .
the @xmath325 version follows from the bounded convergence theorem .
it remains to complete the proof of lemma [ lem : null - estimate ] . a more general , two - sided version of the inequality in lemma [ lem : null - estimate ] is proved in ( * ?
* theorem 2.4 ) but under slightly different assumptions .
because of this , we can not apply that result directly ; nevertheless , the proof techniques naturally transfer to our setting .
in doing so , the arguments become simpler to apply , so we reproduce them here . by the markov property for @xmath26 it
is enough to prove the statement for @xmath31 , namely that there exists finite @xmath396 such that for any @xmath397 and @xmath336 there exists a finite positive constant @xmath337 such that , if @xmath398 then @xmath399 \geq c m^{-1/2},\ ] ] for sufficiently large @xmath339 .
we outline the two intuitive steps in the proof .
first we show that the probability that @xmath400 exceeds some large @xmath236 is bounded below by a constant times @xmath401 .
second , we show that if the latter event does occur , with probability at least @xmath402 it takes the process time at least a constant times @xmath403 to reach @xmath404 . combining these two estimates
will show that with probability of order @xmath401 the walk takes time of order @xmath403 to reach @xmath404 , which gives the desired tail bound . roughly speaking ,
the first estimate ( reaching distance @xmath236 ) is provided by the optional stopping theorem and the fact that @xmath405 is a submartingale ( cf .
* theorem 2.3 ) ) , and the second ( taking quadratic time to return ) is provided by a maximal inequality applied to an appropriate quadratic displacement functional ( cf .
* lemma 4.11 ) ) .
a technicality required for the first estimate is that to apply optional stopping , we need uniform integrability ; so we actually work with a truncated version of @xmath406 .
we now give the details .
recall that @xmath407 and let @xmath408 .
lemmas [ lemma1 ] and [ lemma2 ] , with the fact that @xmath409 by , imply that @xmath410 \geq \frac{2{\varepsilon}}{r_k } + o(r_k^{-1 } ) \geq \frac{{\varepsilon}}{r_k},\ ] ] for all @xmath411 , for sufficiently large @xmath396 and some positive constant @xmath412 . now
, suppose that @xmath333 and @xmath331 satisfy @xmath413 and fix @xmath236 with @xmath414 .
set @xmath415 and @xmath416 .
since @xmath417 is a martingale , we have that @xmath418 is a submartingale , as is the stopped process @xmath419 . in order to achieve uniform integrability
, we consider the truncated process @xmath420 and show that this is a submartingale . for @xmath421 ,
we have @xmath422 so @xmath423 = 0 $ ] .
for @xmath424 , @xmath425 and the last term can be bounded in absolute value : @xmath426 for @xmath427 as appearing in , since on @xmath428 we have @xmath429 and therefore @xmath430 implies that @xmath431 . applying from lemma [ lemma1 ] we obtain @xmath432 \leq bx^{1-p},\ ] ] for some @xmath433 not depending on @xmath236 . combining this with and
again the fact that @xmath434 on @xmath435 , we have that @xmath436 \geq \frac{{\varepsilon}}{r_k } - bx^{1-p } \geq \frac{{\varepsilon}}{x } - bx^{1-p } \geq 0,\ ] ] for sufficiently large @xmath236 . hence , for sufficiently large @xmath236 , @xmath437 is a uniformly integrable submartingale and therefore , given @xmath438 , by optional stopping , @xmath439 & = \operatorname{\mathbb{e } } [ y_{\sigma_x}^x { { \mathbf 1}{\{\sigma_x < \tau_r\ } } } \mid x_0 ] + \operatorname{\mathbb{e } } [ y_{\tau_r}^x{{\mathbf 1}{\{\tau_r < \sigma_x\ } } } \mid x_0 ] \\
& \leq 2x { { \mathbb p } } [ \sigma_x
< \tau_r \mid x_0 ] + r. \end{split}\ ] ] in other words , given @xmath438 , @xmath440 \geq \frac{r - r}{2x},\ ] ] for all sufficiently large @xmath236 .
now , consider @xmath441 , adapted to @xmath442 .
we have @xmath443 using the fact that @xmath418 is a submartingale together with the strong markov property for @xmath26 at the stopping time @xmath444 yields @xmath445 \geq 0 { \
\text{a.s.}}$ ] , and lemmas [ lemma1 ] and [ lemma2 ] again with the strong markov property imply that @xmath446 \leq c { \ \text{a.s . } } , $ ] for some constant @xmath447 ; hence @xmath448 \leq c { \ \text{a.s.}}$ ] , for some constant @xmath449 .
then a maximal inequality ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 3.1 ) similar to doob s submartingale inequality implies that , on @xmath450 , @xmath451 \leq \frac{cn}{y } , \text { for any } y > 0.\ ] ] in particular , we may choose @xmath44 small enough so that @xmath452 \leq
\frac{1}{2 } , \text { on } \{\sigma_x < \infty\}.\ ] ] combining the inequalities and , we find that given @xmath438 , @xmath453\\ & = \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}\big [ { { \mathbf 1}{\{\sigma_x
< \tau_r\ } } } { { \mathbb p}}\big [ \max_{0 \leq k
\leq { \varepsilon}x^2 } |r_{\sigma_x+k } - r_{\sigma_x}|
< x/2 { \ ; \bigl| \;}{{\mathcal f}}_{\sigma_x } \big ] { \ ; \bigl| \;}x_0 \big]\\ & \geq \frac{1}{2 } { { \mathbb p}}\big [ \max_{0 \leq k \leq \tau_r } r_k > x { \ ; \bigl| \;}x_0 \big ] \geq \frac{r - r}{4x } , \end{split}\ ] ] for sufficiently large @xmath236 , where the equality here uses the fact that @xmath454 . if both of the events @xmath455 and @xmath456 occur , then the process @xmath417 leaves the ball @xmath457 before time @xmath458 and takes more than @xmath459 steps to return to the ball @xmath460 , and therefore @xmath461 . setting @xmath462 and @xmath463 yields the claimed inequality .
it is only in the proof of lemma [ lem : null - estimate ] that we use the condition @xmath83 from . in the case
@xmath84 , inequality holds only for ( any ) @xmath464 , and not @xmath44 ; thus to obtain a submartingale one should look at @xmath465 for @xmath466 .
the modified argument yields a weaker version of , with @xmath467 replaced by @xmath468 for any @xmath302 , but , as stated in remark [ rem : uequalsv ] , this is still comfortably enough to give theorem [ thm : null ] ( any exponent greater than @xmath469 in the tail bound will do ) .
we omit these additional technical details , as the case @xmath84 is outside our main interest .
we use a lyapunov function method with function @xmath470 . [
l : zero_drift_implies_recurrence ] suppose that @xmath26 is a discrete - time , time - homogeneous markov process on @xmath471 .
suppose that for some @xmath427 and @xmath472 , @xmath473 & < \infty ; \\
\inf_{x \in { { \mathbb x } } } \operatorname{\mathbb{e } } [ ( x_{n+1 } - x_n ) ^2 \mid x_n = x ] & \geq v .\end{aligned}\ ] ] suppose also that for some bounded set @xmath474 , @xmath475 = 0 , \text { for all } x \in { { \mathbb x}}\setminus a .\ ] ] then there exists a bounded set @xmath476 for which @xmath477 \leq 0 , \text { for all } x \in { { \mathbb x}}\setminus a ' .\ ] ] write @xmath478 and @xmath479 .
we compute @xmath480 & = \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}_x [ ( f(x + \delta ) - f ( x ) ) { { \mathbf 1 } { ( e_x ) } } ] \\ & { } ~~ { } + \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}_x [ ( f(x + \delta ) - f ( x ) ) { { \mathbf 1 } { ( e_x^{{\mathrm{c } } } ) } } ] .\end{aligned}\ ] ] on @xmath481 we have that @xmath236 and @xmath482 have the same sign , so @xmath483 \\ & = \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}_x \left [ \log \left ( \frac { 1 + | x + \delta |}{1+|x| } \right ) { { \mathbf 1 } { ( e_x ) } } \right ] \\ & = \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}_x \left [ \log \left ( 1 + \frac { \delta \operatorname{sgn}(x)}{1+|x| } \right ) { { \mathbf 1 } { ( e_x ) } } \right ] \\ & \leq \left ( \frac { \operatorname{sgn}(x)}{1+|x| } \right ) \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}_x [ \delta { { \mathbf 1 } { ( e_x ) } } ] - \frac{1}{6 } ( 1+|x| ) ^{-2 } \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}_x [ \delta^2 { { \mathbf 1 } { ( e_x ) } } ] , \end{aligned}\ ] ] using the inequality @xmath484 for all @xmath485 . here , since @xmath486 = 0 $ ] for @xmath487 , @xmath488 | \leq \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}_x [ | \delta | { { \mathbf 1 } { ( e^{{\mathrm{c}}}_x ) } } ] \leq \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}_x [ | \delta |^p |x|^{1-p } ] = o(|x|^{-1 } ) .\ ] ] similarly , @xmath489 \geq v - \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}_x [ \delta^2 { { \mathbf 1 } { ( e^{{\mathrm{c}}}_x ) } } ] \geq v- o(1 ) .\ ] ] ( note that here , and in what follows , our notation follows the convention as described by ; consequently , in one dimension the error terms are understood to be uniform as either @xmath490 , or @xmath491 . )
finally we estimate the term @xmath492 \right| \leq \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}_x \left [ \left ( \log ( 1 + | \delta | ) + \log ( 1 + 2 |\delta | ) \right ) { { \mathbf 1 } { ( e_x^{{\mathrm{c } } } ) } } \right ] .\ ] ] here , @xmath493 for all @xmath236 with @xmath494 greater than some @xmath495 sufficiently large , using the fact that @xmath496 is eventually decreasing
. it follows that @xmath492 \right| \leq 2|x|^{-p } \log ( 1 + 2 |x| ) \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}_x[|\delta|^p ] = o(|x|^{-2}).\ ] ] combining these calculations we obtain @xmath480 & \leq \left ( \frac{\operatorname{sgn}(x)}{1 + |x| } \right ) o ( |x |^{-1 } ) - \frac{1}{6 } ( 1 + |x| ) ^{-2 } ( v - o(1 ) ) + o ( |x|^{-2 } ) \\ & \leq - \frac{v}{6 } ( 1+|x| ) ^{-2 } + o ( |x|^{-2 } ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] which is negative for all @xmath236 with @xmath494 sufficiently large . under assumptions , and , the hypotheses of lemma [ l : zero_drift_implies_recurrence ] are satisfied , so that for some @xmath497 , @xmath477 \leq 0 , \text { for all $ x \in { { \mathbb x}}$ with $ |x| \geq x_0$},\ ] ] where @xmath498 .
we note that assumption implies that @xmath499 < \infty$ ] for all @xmath30 , and therefore @xmath500 < \infty$ ] for all @xmath30 .
let @xmath501 and set @xmath502 .
let @xmath503 .
then @xmath504 is a non - negative supermartingale , and hence there exists a random variable @xmath505 with @xmath506 , a.s .
in particular , this means that @xmath507 setting @xmath508 , which satisfies @xmath509 , a.s .
, since @xmath510 as @xmath511 , it follows that @xmath512 on @xmath513 .
however , under assumptions , and , proposition [ lem : lim_sup_infty ] implies that @xmath514 , a.s .
, so to avoid contradiction , we must have @xmath515 , a.s . in other words ,
@xmath516 = 1,\ ] ] and since @xmath517 was arbitrary , it follows that @xmath518 = 1,\ ] ] which gives the result .
part of this work was supported by the engineering and physical sciences research council [ grant number ep / j021784/1 ] .
an antecedent of this work , concerning only the elliptic random walk in two dimensions , was written down in 20089 by mm and aw , who benefited from stimulating discussions with iain macphee ( 7/11/195713/1/2012 ) .
the present authors also thank stas volkov for a comment that inspired remark [ rem : ellipse ] .
o. hryniv , i.m .
macphee , m.v .
menshikov , and a.r .
wade , non - homogeneous random walks with non - integrable increments and heavy - tailed random walks on strips .
_ electr .
j. probab .
_ * 17 * ( 2012 ) article 59 , 28pp . | famously , a @xmath0-dimensional , spatially homogeneous random walk whose increments are non - degenerate , have finite second moments , and have zero mean is recurrent if @xmath1 but transient if @xmath2 . once spatial homogeneity is relaxed , this is no longer true .
we study a family of zero - drift spatially non - homogeneous random walks ( markov processes ) whose increment covariance matrix is asymptotically constant along rays from the origin , and which , in any ambient dimension @xmath3 , can be adjusted so that the walk is either transient or recurrent .
natural examples are provided by random walks whose increments are supported on ellipsoids that are symmetric about the ray from the origin through the walk s current position ; these _ elliptic random walks _ generalize the classical homogeneous pearson rayleigh walk ( the spherical case ) .
our proof of the recurrence classification is based on fundamental work of lamperti . _
key words : _ non - homogeneous random walk ; elliptic random walk ; zero drift ; recurrence ; transience .
_ ams subject classification : _
60j05 ( primary ) 60j10 , 60g42 , 60g50 ( secondary ) |
massive stars , when evolving off the main sequence , undergo phases of strong mass - loss , often resulting in the formation of shells , disks or rings of circumstellar material .
one class of evolved massive stars , b[e ] supergiants ( b[e]sgs ) , are early - type emission line stars with high - density gaseous and dusty circumstellar disks of yet unknown origin ( see * ? ? ?
* for a recent review ) .
the gaseous inner disk is traced by the emission of low - ionized metal lines from both permitted and forbidden transitions . of these , the lines of [ caii ] and [ oi ] are particularly useful . while their intensities probe regions of high and medium densities , where the transition between the two regimes might be settled at an electron density of @xmath1@xmath2 , their line profiles contain the information on their kinematics .
farther out , molecules form via gas phase chemistry , and intense band emission from co molecules has been reported for many of these stars .
in addition , the presence of tio band emission features in optical spectra of several b[e]sgs has been suggested , but still lacks confirmation . besides atomic and molecular gas
, these stars are also surrounded by warm circumstellar dust , as is obvious from their strong infrared excess emission , interferometric observations , and resolved spectral dust features @xcite .
kinematic studies of the atomic and co gas reveal that the material is confined to detached ( sometimes multiple ) rings rotating around the star on keplerian orbits .
abundance studies of these rings reveal an enrichment in the isotopic molecule @xmath3co , in agreement with an evolutionary stage just beyond the main sequence .
furthermore , b[e]sgs could be the progenitors of a group of early - type blue supergiants ( bsgs ) with ring nebulae such as , e.g. , sher25 and sbw1 .
optical images of these two stars display equatorial rings and bipolar lobes , and @xcite propose that as soon as the rings or disk - like structures seen around b[e]sgs have expanded and cooled they would look exactly like these objects .
support for such a possible evolutionary link comes from the fact that , like b[e]sgs , neither sher25 nor sbw1 has evolved yet through a red supergiant phase , indicating that in both cases , the ejection of the material forming the disks or rings must have happened during their bsg phase .
such a scenario has a much wider impact : as the bsgs with rings closely resemble the progenitor star of the supernova sn 1987a , b[e]sgs might be regarded as the most plausible candidates for supernova explosions of the sn 1987a - type .
notably , two b[e]sgs were recently suggested to be viable sn1987a - type progenitor candidates : in the small magellanic cloud and the galactic object mwc137 @xcite . for a better understanding of the evolution of these stars up to the supernova stage
, it is hence essential to study b[e]sgs in great detail , and in particular their mass - loss behavior and the chemistry involved in the formation of the observed dense molecular and dusty rings or disk - like structures .
the atmospheres of massive stars have an oxygen - rich composition , which means that the abundance of oxygen atoms greatly exceeds that of carbon atoms .
the same trend is then expected in their disks , because they form from the material released from the stellar surface .
consequently , carbon atoms in the disks are locked in co , which , as the most stable molecule with a dissociation energy of 11.2ev , forms as soon as the gas temperature drops below the dissociation temperature of co , for which a value of @xmath4k is typically quoted .
the excess oxygen atoms will form other molecules , and a rich chemistry is expected at larger distances from the star .
the sio molecule is the second most stable oxygen compound .
its binding energy of 8.0ev is higher than that of other oxides or oxygen compounds such as no , oh , or water , but lower than that of co , and thus sio should form in slightly cooler environments ( @xmath5k ) . as with co , the rather high gas temperature of the sio forming region guarantees that high vibrational levels will be excited , causing coupled rotational - vibrational transitions , detectable via prominent band and band head features . and
in fact , sio bands are commonly observed in absorption in the atmospheres of mira stars , cool giants , and red supergiants . in these objects
, sio is an important molecule , based on which the physical properties in the transition region between the outer atmosphere and the innermost circumstellar envelope can be studied . to our knowledge , rotational - vibrational sio bands in emission have only been reported for supernova 1987a @xcite .
these emission bands appeared 160 days after the outburst and were not detectable beyond day 578 .
the rise of the sio features had a time - delay of 48 days with respect to that of co molecular bands .
this is in agreement with the lower binding energy , requiring a cooler environment for the formation of sio molecules by gas phase chemistry .
the disappearance of the emission bands agrees with the onset of dust formation in the ejecta , which is interpreted as depletion of molecular sio due to condensation of silicate dust , for which the sio molecule is proposed to be a major building block within an oxygen - rich environment . unlike the transient phenomena of a rapidly expanding , diluting ejecta of a supernova , the rings or disks around b[e]sgs seem to be quite stable structures of accumulated material .
this guarantees these disks as ideal chemical laboratories to study molecule formation and dust condensation . however , apart from co band emission , detected in most of these objects , and warm circumstellar dust , no information exists about the chemical composition of these disks .
hence , it is necessary to begin searching for other molecular emission features that can be used to study the structure and kinematics of b[e]sg stars disks comprehensively . to pioneer this work
, we selected a sample of galactic b[e]sgs , with known co band emission , to search for molecular rotational - vibrational band emission from sio .
during the period of march - may 2014 , we observed four galactic b[e]sgs in the @xmath0-band wavelength region using the cryogenic high - resolution infrared echelle spectrograph ( crires , * ? ? ? * ) on the eso vlt ut1-antu 8-m telescope .
details on the objects and their observations are given in table[tbl_obs ] .
data were obtained at four different standard settings with reference wavelengths of 4048.6 , 4060.1 , 4135.5 , and 4147.0 nm , so that the total spectra cover a continuous wavelength range from 3.9884.176@xmath6 m .
this range contains the first four band heads of the sio first - overtone bands .
we used the 0.4slit , which provides a spectral resolution of @xmath7 , corresponding to a velocity resolution of @xmath8kms@xmath9 .
data reduction was performed with the eso crires pipeline ( version 2.3.2 ) .
the observations were taken in an abba nod pattern for proper sky subtractions .
raw frames were corrected for bad pixels , flat fields , non - linearity , and then wavelength calibrated using oh lines in the standard star spectrum .
a telluric standard star observation was similarly reduced . for telluric correction , a b - type standard
star was observed immediately after the target at a similar airmass .
the iraf task _ telluric _ was used to remove the atmospheric features .
the final spectra were normalized and continuum subtracted .
we clearly detect emission from the first three band heads of the sio first - overtone bands in cpd-529243 ( fig.[fig_cpd - fit ] ) , and from the first band head in the spectra of the other three stars , cpd-57 2874 , hd327083 , and hd62623 ( fig.[fig_sio ] ) . in each star
s spectrum , the band heads display a blue - shifted shoulder and a red - shifted maximum with respect to the laboratory wavelength .
their separation is marked by the bar in figs.[fig_cpd - fit ] and [ fig_sio ] .
such structures are also typically observed in the band heads of co , and are an unequivocal manifestation of rotational broadening . to confirm that the observed features are emission from sio molecules , we compute synthetic band head models . for this
, we modify our existing co disk code by implementing the sio line lists and einstein transition probabilities provided by @xcite . for each of our targets , information about the rotation velocity of the co region and disk inclination angles are listed in table[tbl_param ] .
the rotation velocities of the co gas have been obtained from the broadening of the first band head of the co first - overtone bands resolved in high - resolution spectra , and the disk inclination angles have been determined from interferometric observations . from the wavelength separation between the position of the blue shoulder and the red peak of the first band head , we obtain an estimate of the sio rotation velocity projected to the line of sight .
this parameter is refined during the fitting procedure .
the final rotation velocities , corrected for disk inclination , are included in table[tbl_param ] .
the high spectral resolution , combined with the sensitivity of the synthetic spectra to rotation velocity , guarantee that these values have a precision of @xmath10kms@xmath9 . comparing the velocities obtained in the two molecular band emitting regions , we find a consistently lower value for sio , suggesting that this molecule is formed within the keplerian disk at larger distances from the star . for cpd-52 9243 , where three observed band heads are available , we can also constrain temperature and column density , for which we find @xmath11k and @xmath12@xmath13 . with this column density ,
most of the individual sio rotation - vibration lines within the observed wavelength range are optically thick .
although the sio rotation velocity in this object is only marginally lower , both temperature and column density are significantly lower than the values obtained from the co modeling .
this suggests that the two band head formation regions are physically disjoint . for the other three objects , where solely the first band head is detected
, it is only possible to constrain the rotation velocity , because different combinations of temperature and density result in almost identical synthetic spectra .
hence , the fits shown in fig.[fig_sio ] are only to demonstrate that the observed features can indeed be assigned to sio band emission , and to determine the sio rotation velocity . under the assumption of keplerian rotation of the disks and using the stellar mass ranges of the objects ( table[tbl_obs ] ) ,
the radii of both ( co and sio ) molecular rings can be computed .
these values are included in table[tbl_param ] .
furthermore , considering that the circumstellar dust is mainly composed of silicates , we can calculate the dust evaporation distances .
assuming that the grains are spheres with a maximum size of @xmath14 m , and that the silicate evaporation temperature is @xmath15k , the minimum dust evaporation radii follow from the stellar luminosities ( listed in table[tbl_obs ] ) and are added to table[tbl_param ] .
obviously , the much hotter molecular rings reside within the dusty disks .
we report on the detection of sio first - overtone band emission in the high - resolution @xmath0-band spectra of four galactic b[e]sgs , which are known to display strong co band emission .
while sio bands are commonly seen in absorption from the atmospheres of cool stars and giants , they were detected in emission , so far , only in spectra of sn1987a during the post - explosion period from day 160 to day 578 .
hence , to our knowledge , this is the first discovery of sio first - overtone band emission from hot , high - density environments of evolved massive stars .
the high spectral resolution of our data allows us to precisely determine the rotation velocity of the sio gas .
for all of our target stars , this velocity is lower than that determined from the co band forming region .
moreover , model fits to the observed three band heads in cpd-52 9243 demonstrate that , in contrast to the co band emitting region , the emission of the sio bands originates from a cooler and less dense disk region , indicating that sio molecules form at larger distances within the keplerian disks .
for all four objects , we find , in addition , that the sio ring radii are smaller than the silicate dust evaporation distances .
this finding is of great importance , because it demonstrates that molecules provide an excellent tool to study b[e]sg stars disks .
the emission features of both molecules detected so far , co and sio , carry all the essential information about the physical properties ( temperature , density ) and kinematics of their formation region . as different molecules require diverse conditions , a huge variety can be expected to form throughout the disk , filling the space between the hottest inner rim traced by co bands , and the dust condensation region .
hence , it is essential and timely to search for emission features from many more molecules that are expected to form within the oxygen - rich environment of these disks .
moreover , molecules such as co and sio are also indispensable to study the disk structure at much larger distances . with their numerous pure rotational transitions ,
these molecules are also suitable to trace much cooler environments .
the rotational transitions spread over the submm and radio regime , making the disks of b[e]sgs ideal targets to be observed with high spatial and spectral resolution facilities such as alma . combining the results obtained from different molecular species tracing diverse temperature regions , and hence distances from the star , will greatly improve our knowledge and comprehension of the disk structure , and help to understand the disks possible formation history .
in addition , the discovery of sio band emission has an even wider impact
. evolved massive stars , such as red supergiants , b[e]sgs , and supernovae ( e.g. , sn1987a ) , are the main sources of silicate dust , for which sio molecules are regarded as a major building block . studying the physical properties of sio gas in the disks of b[e]sgs might , hence , provide indispensable insight into the early stage of silicate dust formation within the oxygen - rich environment of these enigmatic stars .
we thank the referee , dr . john bally , for his valuable comments on the manuscript .
this research made use of the nasa astrophysics data system ( ads ) and of the simbad database , operated at cds , strasbourg , france .
mk acknowledges financial support from gar ( grant number 14 - 21373s ) .
the astronomical institute ondejov is supported by the project rvo:67985815 .
lc , mla , and aft acknowledge financial support from the agencia de promocin cientfica y tecnolgica ( prstamo bid pict 2011/0885 ) , conicet ( pip 0300 ) , and the universidad nacional de la plata ( programa de incentivos g11/109 ) , argentina .
financial support for international cooperation of the czech republic ( mmt , 7amb14ar017 ) and argentina ( mincyt - meys arc/13/12 and conicet 14/003 ) is acknowledged .
lccccccccr hd 62623 & 07 43 48.469 & -28 57 17.37 & 2.340 & 2014 - 03 - 27 & 85009500 & 3139 & 4.85.2 & [email protected] & 1 , 2 + cpd-57 2874 & 10 15 21.971 & -57 51 42.71 & 4.281 & 2014 - 04 - 16 & 900010000 & 1520 & 6.00 & [email protected] & 3 + cpd-52 9243 & 16 07 01.968 & -53 03 45.75 & 4.443 & 2014 - 03 - 22 & 15800 & 17.418.6 & 4.97 & [email protected] & 4 , 5 + hd 327083 & 17 15 15.374 & -40 20 06.74 & 3.296 & 2014 - 05 - 31 & 11500 & 60 & 6.00 & 4.80 & 6 + & & & & & 20000 & 25 & 5.00 & [email protected] & 7 lccccccc cpd-52 9243 & 46 & 36 & 1 & 35.5 & 11.912.7 & 12.213.1 & 16.1 + cpd-57 2874 & 60 & 130 & 2 , 3 & 110 & 0.81.0 & 1.11.5 & 52.7 + hd 327083 & 50 & 86 & 4 & 78 & 3.0 / 7.2 & 3.6 / 8.7 & 16.7 / 52.7 + hd 62623 & 38 & 53 & 3 , 5 & 48 & 9.812.3 & 11.915.0 & 17.5 | b[e ] supergiants ( b[e]sgs ) are evolved massive stars in a short - lived transition phase . during this phase ,
these objects eject large amounts of material , which accumulates in a circumstellar disk - like structure .
the expelled material is typically dense and cool , providing the cradle for molecule and dust condensation and for a rich , ongoing chemistry .
very little is known about the chemical composition of these disks , beyond the emission from dust and co revolving around the star on keplerian orbits . as massive stars
preserve an oxygen - rich surface composition throughout their life , other oxygen - based molecules can be expected to form .
as sio is the second most stable oxygen compound , we initiated an observing campaign to search for first - overtone sio emission bands .
we obtained high - resolution near - infrared @xmath0-band spectra for a sample of galactic b[e]sgs with reported co band emission .
we clearly detect emission from the sio first - overtone bands in cpd-529243 and indications for faint emission in hd62623 , hd327083 , and cpd-572874 . from model fits , we find that in all these stars the sio bands are rotationally broadened with a velocity lower than observed in the co band forming regions , suggesting that sio forms at larger distances from the star . hence , searching for and analyzing these bands is crucial for studying the structure and kinematics of circumstellar disks , because they trace complementary regions to the co band formation zone
. moreover , since sio molecules are the building blocks for silicate dust , their study might provide insight in the early stage of dust formation . |
1 . temperature dependence of the magnetization , measured with @xmath2 = 1 t with zero - field - cooling ( zfc ) , field - cooled - cooling ( fcc ) , and field - cooled - warming ( fcw ) procedures .
the inset shows the time evolution of the normalized magnetization after zfc to @xmath15 = 8 , 40 , 60 and 100k .
field dependence of the sample s temperature showing an abrupt warming from 2.5 to @xmath20 30 k at @xmath21 @xmath19 2.2 t. the inset shows a spontaneous magnetization jump , measured with a fixed magnetic field .
time dependence of the magnetization during a magnetic field sweep , for different waiting times between consecutive field increments : @xmath62 = 7.5 ( squares ) , 15 ( circles ) , 30 ( up triangles ) and 60 min .
( down triangles ) , at @xmath15 = 2.5 k. the inset shows an enlarged portion of the region just before the magnetization jump . | the occurrence at low temperatures of an ultrasharp field - induced transition in phase separated manganites is analyzed .
experimental results show that magnetization and specific heat step - like transitions below 5 k are correlated with an abrupt change of the sample temperature , which happens at a certain critical field .
this temperature rise , a magnetocaloric effect , is interpreted as produced by the released energy at the transition point , and is the key to understand the existence of the abrupt field - induced transition .
a qualitative analysis of the results suggests the existence of a critical growing rate of the ferromagnetic phase , beyond which an avalanche effect is triggered .
mixed valent manganites show a great deal of fascinating properties , arising from the strong interplay between spin , charge , orbital , and lattice degrees of freedom @xcite .
the most intriguing one is the existence of a phase separated state , the simultaneous coexistence of submicrometer ferromagnetic ( fm ) metallic and charge ordered ( co ) insulating regions dagotto .
the phase separation scenario has its origin in the unusual proximity of the free energies of these very distinct fm and co states , and in the fact that the competition between both phases is resolved in mesoscopic length scales , giving rise to real space inhomogeneities in the material .
yet another surprising result more recently found in manganites is the appearance of ultrasharp magnetization steps at low temperatures ( below @xmath0 5 k ) in the isothermal magnetization @xmath1(@xmath2 ) curves @xcite .
this effect , the field induced transition of the entire compound from one phase to the other of the coexisting states , is included in the category of metamagnetic transitions @xcite .
however , unlike the broad continuous transitions expected for inhomogeneous granular systems , in this case it occurs in an extremely narrow window of magnetic fields .
these ultrasharp steps were observed in both single crystals and polycrystalline samples , indicating that it is not related to a particular micro - structure of the material . the actual existence of a phase separated state was recognized as a key parameter for the observation of these magnetization jumps @xcite .
the effect was first reported in manganites doped at the mn site , and the disorder in the spin lattice was thought to play a relevant role hebert1 .
however , a similar behavior was also found in pr@xmath3ca@xmath4mno@xmath5 , and the qualitative interpretation of the phenomenon shifted to the martensitic character of the phase separated state @xcite .
accommodation strains were shown to be relevant in the stabilization of phase separation @xcite , but their role in the magnetization steps is not clear , since it is expected that grain boundaries would act as a sort of firewall for the movement of the domain walls , stopping the avalanche process . additionally , despite its intrinsic first - order character , the martensitic transformation is spread over a large range of the external parameter driving the transition , the magnetic field in the present case , in strong disagreement with the abrupt character of the transition . the aim of this investigations is to address a basic question concerning this abrupt field - induced transition : why is this metamagnetic transition so sharp , and what is actually causing it ?
we report the occurrence of ultrasharp magnetization steps at low temperatures in a prototype phase separated manganite , which are accompanied by discontinuities in the magnetic field dependence of the specific heat . concomitantly with these facts
, we found that the field - induced transition is accompanied by a large increase in the temperature of the sample , by dozens of degrees .
this feature suggests a mechanism in which the abrupt first order transition in the whole sample is triggered by the released heat in a microscopic phase transformation .
a low temperature heat controlled magnetization avalanche was previously found in bulk disordered magnets @xcite due to the heat released by the fm domain wall motion during the reversal of the remnant magnetization .
also , local heating induced by non - uniform current flow was proposed as the origin of the mesoscopic fluctuations between coexisting phases observed in la@xmath6pr@xmath7ca@xmath8mno@xmath5@xcite .
we propose that in phase separated manganites the interplay between the growth of the fm phase induced by the magnetic field and the heat generated by this growth is the key to explain the avalanche process leading to an ultrasharp field - induced transition in these inhomogeneous strongly correlated systems .
the particular compound under study is a high quality polycrystalline sample of la@xmath6pr@xmath7ca@xmath8mno@xmath5 , synthesized by the sol - gel technique .
it belongs to the well known family of compounds la@xmath9pr@xmath10ca@xmath11mno@xmath12 whose tendency to form inhomogeneous structures in the range [email protected] is extensively documented .
uehara , uehararate , kim , balagurov , kiryukhin , nonvolatile scanning electron micrographs revealed a homogeneous distribution of grain sizes , of the order of 2 @xmath14 m .
an identification of the magnetic phases of the material can be made through the temperature dependence of the magnetization , @xmath1(@xmath15 ) .
the results were obtained on an extraction magnetometer with a field @xmath2 = 1 t , and are shown in fig .
1 . as the temperature
is lowered the sample changes from a paramagnetic to a charge - ordered antiferromagnetic state at @xmath16 = 220 k. just below , a small kink at 190 k is a signature of the onset of the formation of ferromagnetic clusters @xcite .
a more robust ferromagnetic phase appears at @xmath17 = 70 k ( 90 k on warming ) , which coexists with the majority co state in an inhomogeneous phase separated state @xcite . in a temperature window extending from @xmath17 down to a temperature @xmath18 @xmath19 20 k the magnetization shows considerable relaxation effects , as shown in the inset of fig .
1 , signaling the growth of the fm phase against the co background .
the temperature @xmath18 ( which depends on the applied field ) can be identified as a blocking temperature ; relaxation below @xmath18 is strongly reduced . additionally ,
the magnetic state below @xmath18 is highly dependent on the sample magnetic field and cooling history .
if the sample is cooled without an applied field ( zfc ) the magnetization at 2 k shows a significant low value , that remains unchanged while warming until @xmath18 , above with it shows a continuous increase and merges with the field cooling warming curve .
= 1 t with zero - field - cooling ( zfc ) , field - cooled - cooling ( fcc ) , and field - cooled - warming ( fcw ) procedures .
the inset shows the time evolution of the normalized magnetization after zfc to @xmath15 = 8 , 40 , 60 and 100k.,width=264 ] with the application of a large enough magnetic field the low temperature ( below @xmath20 5 k ) zero - field - cooled state is transformed into a fm phase in an abrupt step - like metamagnetic transition .
figure 2(a ) shows magnetization measurements as a function of applied field , @xmath1(@xmath2 ) , measured at @xmath15 = 2.5 k. at a certain critical field @xmath21 the entire system changes to a nearly homogenous fm state , which remains stable even after the field is removed .
the width of the transition , determined by repeating the measurements with lower field increments , is below 10 oe .
figure 2(b ) shows specific heat data as a function of applied field , @xmath22(@xmath2 ) , measured by the relaxation method at the same base temperature , @xmath15 = 2.5 k. as can be readily noticed , a discontinuous transition occurs at approximately the same magnetic field , indicating that a true thermodynamic transition is taking place .
= 2.5 k. both measurements show an abrupt change at the same critical field @xmath21 @xmath19 2.2 t.,width=226 ] since the observed transition is first order , it is expected that the latent heat involved should affect the thermodynamic state of the sample , for instance , its temperature . in order to gain some insights on the magnitude of the effect
the following experiment was performed : with the sample placed in a vacuum calorimeter with a weak thermal link to the temperature controlled surroundings ( kept at 2.5 k ) , the sample s temperature was measured while the magnetic field was increased , with field increments identical to the data of fig.2 . the obtained result , plotted in fig .
3 , shows the occurrence of a sudden and huge increase of the sample s temperature , greater than 25 k , at the same critical field of the magnetization jump .
since the relaxation time for temperature stabilization between the sample and the temperature controlled surroundings ( of the order of several seconds ) is much larger than the internal time constant between the sample and the sample holder ( of the order of milliseconds ) , the temperature rise measured is intrinsic to the sample .
the abrupt increase of the sample s temperature can be then doubtless ascribed to the heat generated when the non - fm fraction of the material is converted to the fm phase .
the same experiment was repeated with samples of la@xmath23pr@xmath24ca@xmath11mno@xmath5 with different pr content , as well as in samples of the series landcamno . whenever a magnetization jump occurs a sizable increase of the sample s temperature
was observed .
it is also worth mentioned that in the @xmath1(@xmath2 ) and @xmath22(@xmath2 ) data of figure 2 the sample s temperature is in fact not strictly constant ; there is also a sudden temperature rise at the field of the step transition , followed by a quick relaxation to the base temperature of system . the process which starts with nearly the whole material in the non - fm phase at @xmath25 = 2.5 k and ends with a nearly homogeneous fm state at @xmath26 @xmath27 30 k , is conceptually related with the magnetocaloric ( mc ) effect @xcite .
30 k at @xmath21 @xmath19 2.2 t. the inset shows a spontaneous magnetization jump , measured with a fixed magnetic field.,width=226 ] the mc effect consists basically in a temperature change @xmath28 induced by the application of a magnetic field , which , within the approximation of reversible process , is related with the entropy change @xmath29 generated by ordering the spin lattice . in our case
, however , the approximation of reversible adiabatic process is not valid , due to the strong irreversible character of the field - induced transformation .
also , as the phase transition from de co to the fm phases involves large changes in the magnetic , structural and electronic properties , which are strongly correlated , the magnetic field affects all the degrees of freedom of the system .
this fact makes inapplicable some of the usual basic equations employed in the description of the mc effect .
a more realistic approach is to use the conservation of the internal energy during the fast conversion process ( hypothesis of adiabaticity ) . neglecting small changes of the sample volume
, we can make the identity @xmath30 , where @xmath31 is the internal energy per volume unit . replacing the whole ( irreversible ) process by an isothermal plus an isobaric one
, we can write : @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the specific heat of the fm phase at constant pressure .
this yields an estimate for the released heat at the field induced transition given by @xmath34 .
this estimated value was obtained from specific heat measurements as a function of temperature performed at zero magnetic field after the sample was transformed to the fm phase by application of a field of 9 @xmath15 .
the magnetization and specific heat results , shown in fig . 2 ,
are macroscopic signatures of a phenomenon which must be understood at a microscopic level .
below the temperature @xmath18 the sample gets into a strongly blocked regime , in which the fm clusters can not grow against the co background ( see inset of fig 1 ) .
after zero- field - cooling , the sample reaches the blocked state with a small , time independent , fraction @xmath35 of fm phase , which can be thought as distributed in isolated regions or clusters surrounded by a co matrix .
the application of an external magnetic field @xmath2 weakens this frozen - in state , inducing the increase of each cluster of volume @xmath36 in an amount @xmath37 , which can depend on @xmath38 , @xmath15 , @xmath2 and time .
the released heat yielded by this particular process is @xmath39 .
part of this energy is used to locally increase the temperature of the fm volume @xmath36 , a process that can be considered as instantaneous , taking into account that the thermal conductivity of the fm phase is much greater than that of the co phase .
the remaining energy @xmath40 is evacuated through the surrounding co region .
this balance yields @xmath41 once a process involving a change of the local fm fraction happens , the further evolution of the system is determined by the interplay between the rates at which the system is generating heat , and the rate at which the co phase is releasing it . when the former is greater than the latter , a local temperature rise within the fm region is obtained .
if this temperature reaches values beyond the blocking temperature corresponding to the applied field @xmath2 the system becomes critical , in the sense that the adjacent co regions , which in turn will increase their local temperature too , become highly unstable .
these unstable co regions are now easily transformed to the fm state , releasing heat , and so on , inducing an avalanche - like chain reaction . at the end ,
all regions which have ferromagnetism as its equilibrium state at @xmath15=@xmath26 and field @xmath2 had been converted from co to fm .
the equilibrium fractions of the coexisting phases at that @xmath15 and @xmath2 values then determine the size of the avalanche process .
following equation ( 2 ) , we can make an estimation of the critical value of the volume change @xmath42 which is needed to _ turn - on _ the avalanche process .
the first condition to be accomplished is that the temperature of the local fm region increases beyond the blocking temperature @xmath18(@xmath2 ) . assuming that it occurs in a time scale @xmath43 , and that in this scale the heat transferred to the co region is negligible , we obtain @xmath44 where @xmath45 8 k at @xmath46 = 2.2 t was estimated from zfc magnetization measurements .
this calculation yields @xmath47 , i.e. , almost one per cent increase of the local fm volume is needed to initiate the abrupt transition .
this condition must be accompanied by another one , related with the time @xmath43 in which the volume enlargement occurs . as mentioned above
, this time has to be short enough to avoid the heat be released through the surrounding co region , i.e. , the condition @xmath48 must hold , where @xmath49 is the area of the cluster surface , @xmath50 is the thermal conductivity of the co phase and @xmath51 is a local spatial coordinate .
a crude estimation of @xmath43 can be done assuming that , within the adjacent co region , the temperature decays from @xmath52 to @xmath25 in a length @xmath53 , and taking into account that typical low temperature values for @xmath50 could range between 0.1 - 1 w/(mk ) .
these assumptions give , for instance , @xmath5410@xmath55 - 10@xmath56 s for clusters of volume @xmath36 = ( 50 nm)@xmath57 , and predicts a critical rate @xmath58 .
therefore , we estimate that thermal processes that happen within a narrow time window , involving a one percent increase of the local fm regions are needed to initiate the abrupt field - induced transition , the critical rate scaling as the linear size of the fm cluster .
the occurrence of the step transition is then governed by the probability of such an event , once the magnetic field has yielded the crossover between the free energies of the coexisting phases . one way to modify
the avalanche probability is allowing the system to relax before reaching the critical state . allowing relaxation an increase of the fm fraction as a function of the elapsed time occurs , and consequently the value of the @xmath59 needed to _ turn - on _ the process should also increases
this would be reflected on the dependence with the elapsed time of the critical field @xmath21 at which the jump occurs . to verify this hypothesis
we have measured the time dependence of the magnetization during a field sweep , @xmath1(@xmath2,@xmath60 ) at 2.5 k , starting with @xmath2 = 1.9 t , and waiting a time @xmath61 at fixed @xmath2 before changing to the next field value . in fig .
4 we show the @xmath1 vs @xmath60 curves obtained for different values of @xmath62 , confirming the above presumption : for larger @xmath62 the magnetization jump occurs at higher critical fields . as a remarkable result , we observed that in most cases the step transition occurs spontaneously within the time interval where the field was unchanged .
this fact signs unambiguously that the width of the step transition , beyond any experimental resolution , is strictly zero .
the inset of fig .
3 shows a spontaneous ( as opposed to field - induced ) magnetization jump , which happens at a fixed field and temperature values .
the occurrence of spontaneous magnetization jumps in phase separated manganites was also reported by another group.spontaneous = 7.5 ( squares ) , 15 ( circles ) , 30 ( up triangles ) and 60 min .
( down triangles ) , at @xmath15 = 2.5 k. the inset shows an enlarged portion of the region just before the magnetization jump.,width=321 ] the fact that the step transition can be reached spontaneously while the external parameters ( @xmath2 and @xmath15 ) are kept constant indicates that the abrupt transition is truly connected with the probability of occurrence of certain microscopic process , which within the above described scenario is a particular enlargement of the fm phase .
however , this process will initiate the avalanche only when the local increment of the fm phase is large and fast enough to yield the appropriate increase of the local temperature through a magnetocaloric effect .
figure 4 and its inset clearly show that not any enlargement process is able to trigger the step transition .
the relaxation effects displayed by the system before the occurrence of the magnetization jump indicate that the system can in fact increase its fm phase fraction without initiating the avalanche , i.e. , there are fm regions that starts to become unblocked for field values just below the critical field , increasing their local volume by overcoming energy barriers .
for instance , the curve for @xmath62 = 60 min .
( with @xmath21 = 2.56 t ) shows a sizable increase of the fm fraction before the occurrence of the magnetization jump . from inspection of fig .
4 , it is likely that for larger values of @xmath62 larger values of the fm fraction before the jump would be obtained .
the waiting time @xmath62 is a key parameter to determine the energy barriers values for which the system is blocked .
eventually , for an extremely large value of @xmath62 the whole system would behave as unblocked and the @xmath1(@xmath2 ) curve obtained in this hypothetical situation would display a continuous metamagnetic transition behavior , without jumps .
therefore , once the value of the minimal @xmath21 corresponding to the fastest experiment is established , the limit temperature above which the step transition no longer occurs is determined by the blocking temperature corresponding to this field , @xmath18(@xmath21 ) .
this suggests why the magnetization jump occurs only below a very specific temperature , mahendiran above which the system overcomes the energy barriers without turning on the avalanche process . in conclusion ,
we have presented evidence that the low temperature abrupt field - induced transition occurring in phase separated manganites is intimately related with the sudden increase of the sample temperature at the first order transition point , a feature which is crucial for the understanding of the phenomenon .
we proposed a simple model in which the close interplay between the local increase of the fm phase and the heat released in this microscopic transformation can turn - on the avalanche leading to the observed step - like transition . within this framework ,
the entity which is propagated is heat , not magnetic domain walls , so the roles of grain boundaries in ceramic samples or strains which exist between the coexisting phases are less relevant .
the observation of spontaneous transitions gives additional support to that view , demonstrating that the step transition is not only the result of a crossover between macroscopic free energies induced by the magnetic field , but must be triggered by a microscopic mechanism which initiates the avalanche process .
additionally , we have established that a critical relative increment of a fm region or cluster is needed for the system to reach the `` chain reaction '' state , i.e. , larger initial fm factions require larger critical fields to _ turn - on _ the process , a feature previously observed .
@xcite finally , it must be emphasized that the basic condition for the occurrence of the abrupt transition is that the system must reach the low temperature regime in a strongly blocked state . at temperatures
just a few degrees higher the abrupt step - like transition no longer occurs , and it is replaced by a standard continuous metamagnetic transition @xcite . in summary , we propose that some microscopic mechanism promotes locally a fm volume increase , which yield a local temperature rise , and triggers the observed avalanche process .
this work was partially supported by capes , cnpq , fapesp , conicet , and fundacin antorchas . |
low mass x - ray binaries ( lmxbs ) are compact binaries where the primary is a compact object and the secondary a low mass star ( @xmath81@xmath7 ) .
the secondary is transferring mass via roche - lobe overflow , forming an accretion disk around the compact object that gives rise to the observed x - rays . by far , most of the persistently bright lmxbs are neutron star systems that can be divided into two groups , the z - sources and atoll sources ( hasinger & van der klis 1989 ) .
z - sources are usually the brightest lmxbs in x - rays ( they are thought to have mass accretion rates that reach the eddington limit ) and trace a z - like shape in their x - ray colour - colour diagrams .
atoll sources on the other hand have lower accretion rates ( @xmath91 - 2 orders of magnitude lower ) and their colour - colour diagrams usually consists of fragmented island - like regions .
apart from the difference in accretion rates , the main physical difference between z - sources and atoll sources are thought to be the strength of the neutron star magnetic field and their evolutionary history ( hasinger & van der klis 1989 ) .
lmcx-2 is a persistent lmxb that shows the properties of a z - source ( smale et al .
2003 ) , and it is therefore thought to be a neutron star system that has an accretion rate around the eddington limit .
it is one of the most x - ray luminous lmxbs known ( @xmath10@xmath910@xmath11 erg s@xmath3 ) , but due to its extra - galactic nature ( it is located in the large magellanic cloud at a distance of @xmath948 kpc ) , its x - ray flux is rather low .
its optical counterpart was identified by pakull ( 1978 ) as a @[email protected] blue star . despite being x - ray luminous and having a known optical counterpart , thus far little
is known about the system parameters of lmcx-2 .
even the estimates for the orbital period range from 6.4 hrs ( motch et al .
1985 ) or 8.2 hrs ( callanan et al . 1990 , smale & kuulkers 2000 ) up to 12 days by crampton et al .
( 1990 ) . to make things even more complicated ,
no periodic variability was detected in 6 years of macho data ( alcock et al . 2000 ) . in recent years
steeghs & casares ( 2002 ) developed a new technique to detect a signature of the donor star in persistent lmxbs . using phase - resolved spectroscopy they detected narrow emission lines in scox-1 , especially in the bowen blend ( a blend of niii and ciii lines between 4630 - 4650 ) , that were interpreted as coming from the irradiated side of the donor star .
this discovery in scox-1 was followed by a survey of other lmxbs that are optically bright enough to also resolve these narrow components .
thus far these narrow emission lines have been detected in x1822@xmath14371 ( casares et al .
2003 ) , gx339@xmath144 ( hynes et al . 2003 ) , v801ara and v926sco ( casares et al .
2006 ) , grmus ( barnes et al .
2007 ) , aqlx-1 and gx9@xmath159 ( cornelisse et al 2007a , b ) , leading to constraints on their system parameters .
in this paper we apply the technique of bowen fluorescence to lmcx-2
. we will show that it is possible to detect a periodic signal in our spectroscopic dataset that we identify as the orbital period .
furthermore , similar to the other x - ray binaries thus far , the bowen region shows the presence of narrow emission lines that we identify as coming from the irradiated side of the companion , giving the first ever constraints on the system parameters of lmcx-2 .
on november 21 and 22 2004 we obtained a total of 77 spectra of lmcx-2 with an integration time of 600s each , using the fors2 spectrograph attached to the vlt unit 4 ( yepun telescope ) at paranal observatory ( eso ) .
each spectrum was taken with the 1400v volume - phased holographic grism using a slit width of 0.7@xmath16 , giving a wavelength coverage of @xmath1@xmath14514 - 5815 and a resolution of 70 km s@xmath3 ( fwhm ) .
the seeing during the first night was between 0.4 and 0.7 arcsec , while on the second night it varied between 0.5 and 2.7 arcs .
the slit was orientated at a position angle of 7@xmath17 to include a comparison star in order to correct for slit losses . during daytime
he , ne , hg and cd arc lamp exposures were taken for the wavelength calibration scale .
we de - biased and flat - fielded all the images and used optimal extraction techniques to maximise the signal - to - noise ratio of the extracted spectra ( horne 1986 ) .
we determined the pixel - to - wavelength scale using a 4th order polynomial fit to 20 reference lines giving a dispersion of 0.64 pixel@xmath3 and rms scatter @xmath180.05 .
we also corrected for any velocity drifts due to instrumental flexure by cross - correlating the sky spectra .
finally , we divided all spectra of lmcx-2 by a corresponding low order spline - fit of the comparison star to get the final fluxed spectra .
since we did not observe a spectro - photometric standard star , we were not able to correct for instrumental response , and all spectra are therefore in relative fluxes .
we created average spectra for each individual night .
since we do not have a flux standard to derive an absolute flux for lmcx-2 , we decided to normalise the continuum flux to one by dividing each average spectrum by a low order spline fit . in fig.[spectrum ] we show the results .
both spectra are dominated by the very narrow high excitation heii @xmath14686 emission line , while also bowen emission is present in both spectra .
however , compared to other x - ray binaries , such as scox-1 , x1822@xmath14371 , v801ara and v926sco the bowen emission is much weaker compared to heii in lmcx-2 ( steeghs & casares 2002 , casares et al .
2003 , casares et al .
this might be due to the much lower metal abundances in the large magellanic cloud ( motch & pakull 1979 ) .
the most striking difference between the spectra is the dramatic change of h@xmath19 ( see fig.[spectrum ] ) . during the first night (
21 november ) h@xmath19 is dominated by a weak emission feature superposed on a broad absorption feature , while in the second night ( 22 november ) the emission feature has become almost as strong as heii @xmath14686 .
furthermore , also the hei @xmath14922@xmath205016 lines have become more prominent during the second night ( although they might be present during the first night ) . in order to quantify the change in the most prominent emission lines we estimated the equivalent widths and their line fluxes ( in arbitrary units ) for the two nights , and
show them in table[width ] .
for h@xmath19 we decided to also include the absorption component , giving negative values for the first night .
table[width ] shows that there is no change in equivalent width of heii and the bowen region , and the line fluxes have dropped by @xmath940% during the second night . on the other hand the h@xmath19 and hei lines
have all increased significantly in both equivalent width and line flux .
unfortunately , due to the faintness of these lines ( or the presence of an absorption feature ) , it is not possible to say if they have all changed by the same amount , but it is likely that the same process is responsible for this change in line intensity . finally , in order to see if these changes could be related to a change in brightness we have also created a lightcurve of the continuum flux for lmcx-2 .
we have normalised the flux of the first night around unity , and show the result in fig.[light ] .
we note that during the second night the continuum flux was @xmath940% lower compared to the first night , a similar fraction as was observed for the line fluxes of the heii lines and bowen region , keeping their equivalent widths the same and suggesting a common origin .
we determined phase - resolved radial velocities by cross - correlating each spectrum with a gaussian of width 150 km s@xmath3 centered on the core of the heii @xmath14686 line .
since the conditions during the second night were much worse , together with the fact that the source was @xmath940% fainter , we have binned these spectra together in groups of three , and then determined the radial velocity . in fig.[radial
] we show the results .
the first thing to note in fig.[radial ] is that during both nights the radial velocity shows a sine - like variation , which we interpret as orbital motion of a region that is co - rotating with the binary , and perhaps is connected to the dynamical properties of the primary .
however , during the second night it appears that either the semi - amplitude of the radial velocity or the off - set compared to the rest wavelength has increased .
this last behaviour was noted by crampton et al .
( 1990 ) , who observed a long - term variation in the radial velocity of heii .
we searched the radial velocity curve for any periodic signal with a duration between 1 hr and 2 days using the lomb - scargle technique ( scargle 1982 ) .
apart from the 24 hr alias due to the separation of our 2 observing nights , only two significant peaks with comparable strength were present in the power spectrum ; one peak is at a period of [email protected] days and another at [email protected] day .
interestingly , the 0.32 day period is similar to the photometric period detected by callanan et al .
( 1990 ) , suggesting that this is the orbital period .
although we can not exclude the possibility that the 0.45 day period is real ( but see sect.3.3 ) , we tentatively interpret the 0.32 day period as the orbital period and use it in the rest of this paper . fitting a sine curve with a period of 0.32 day to the radial velocity curve
gives a phase zero at hjd 2,453,[email protected] , an off - set of 344@xmath011 km s@xmath3 , and the semi - amplitude of our sine fit is 41@xmath04 km s@xmath3 .
note that we did not attempt to account for the seemingly variable systemic velocity from night to night , but only did a single sine fit to both nights . .lmc
x-2 equivalent widths and spectral line fluxes .
[ width ] [ cols="<,^,^,^,^ " , ] we used doppler tomography on the most prominent emission lines in order to probe the structure of the accretion disk ( marsh & horne 1988 ) . in order to create the maps , we used the orbital period of [email protected] hrs as determined by callanan et al .
( 1990 ) and a systemic velocity derived from the radial velocity curve in sect.3.2 . to comply with the standard definition of orbital phase 0 in doppler maps ( when the donor star is at inferior conjunction ) we used the phasing derived from the bowen map ( see below ) and applied a shift of @xmath90.5 orbital phase compared to the value derived in sect.3.2 .
since heii @xmath14686 is by far the strongest emission line in lmcx-2 we decided to create doppler maps for each individual night , and we show the result in fig.[hedopp ] .
both maps show a ring - like structure , but there are some minor differences . during the second night it appears as if the outer edge of the structure is at higher velocities than during the first night ( 218@xmath010 km s@xmath3 compared to 180@xmath010 km s@xmath3 ) .
furthermore , during the first night there is a clear emission feature in the lower part of the map , that appears to have shifted toward the lower - right quadrant during the second night .
since we only have 2 nights of observations , it is not clear if these changes are real , but it suggests that there is some change in accretion disk structure from night to night .
we also created a doppler map of the bowen region by simultaneous fitting all the major niii ( @xmath14634/4640 ) and ciii ( @xmath14647/4650 ) lines using the relative strengths as given by mcclintock et al .
the map is dominated by a bright emission feature , that we used to rotate the map ( by @xmath90.5 orbital phase ) until it was located in the top .
fig.[bowdopp ] shows the resulting map .
the bright emission feature is at a velocity of @xmath21=351@xmath028 km s@xmath3 , and another ( much fainter ) spot is also present in the map .
if we interpret the bright spot as arising on the surface of the donor star ( see sect.4.2 ) , the fainter spot is in a region where we could expect an interaction between the accretion disk and the accretion flow .
we do note that the velocity of the bright spot is much higher than the disk velocities in the heii doppler map ( fig.[hedopp ] ) , and we will discuss this in sect.4.2 .
furthermore , since the radial velocity curve in sect.3.2 could not exclude a 0.45 days orbital period , we also created a bowen map for this period .
although there are several spots present in this map , none is as sharp and significant as those in fig.[bowdopp ] .
this is further support that the 0.32 day period is the correct orbital period .
we have presented phase - resolved spectroscopy of lmcx-2 , one of the brightest x - ray sources in the large magellanic cloud , and also one of the most luminous lmxbs known .
this enables us to derive the first constraints on its system parameters , and in particular give new insights on the previously reported orbital periods that ranged from @xmath96 - 8 hrs by motch et al .
( 1985 ) or callanan et al .
( 1990 ) up to @xmath912 days by crampton et al .
( 1990 ) .
callanan et al . ( 1990 ) based their claim of a short orbital period on an extended @xmath92 week photometric campaign .
a clear 8.15 hr modulation was present in their data that was interpreted as the orbital period , although there is indication of a long term ( @xmath910 day ) variability that was also observed by crampton et al .
( 1990 ) . on the other hand , crampton et al .
did not detect the @xmath98 hr period in a @xmath91 week photometric campaign . however , there was a variation in the heii radial velocity curve over a period of 4 nights in their spectroscopic data that they interpreted as a @xmath912 day orbital period .
interestingly , they noticed that the h@xmath19 emission lines also changed in strength over those 4 nights ( even going into absorption ) , with maximum line strength occurring at minimum ( continuum ) light .
although crampton et al . (
1990 ) did speculate that the @xmath912 day period is a precession or beat period , they discarded this due to the absence of shorter periods in their data set .
in sect.3.2 we have shown that there is a @xmath98 hr period present in the radial velocity of heii @xmath14686 that is similar to the period detected by callanan et al .
( 1990 ) . since the semi - amplitude of this radial velocity curve is rather small ( @xmath941 km s@xmath3 )
, it might have been difficult to detect with the 4 m class telescope and an instrument with a resolution of @xmath134 used by crampton et al .
we , therefore , tentatively identify this period with the orbital period .
however , that does leave the question of the long term variation observed by both crampton et al .
( 1990 ) and callanan et al .
similarly to crampton et al .
( 1990 ) , we also observe a large change in the emission line strength of h@xmath19 , with a stronger line occurring at lower continuum flux levels .
unfortunately we only have two nights of observations , and are therefore not able to check if there is also a long term variation in our heii radial velocity curve .
however , fig.[radial ] does suggest that during the second night ( when the continuum flux was lower ) either the amplitude or the mean velocity of the radial velocity has increased compared to the first night ( when the continuum flux was higher ) , similar to what crampton et al . observed .
one explanation for the observed properties could be the presence of an inclined precessing , warped , accretion disk in lmcx-2 , as is also observed in herculesx-1 and ss433 ( katz 1973 , margon 1984 ) .
we will discuss this suggestion in detail in a forthcoming paper by shih et al .
( in preparation ) , but here we will briefly highlight the spectroscopic evidence . during the first night we could be observing the accretion disk more edge on compared to the second night , and
this could explain the much lower h@xmath19 and hei line intensities observed .
this is further strengthened by the fact that the doppler maps suggest that heii is extending to higher radial velocities during the second night .
if true , this could also explain the change in continuum flux observed in fig.[light ] .
callanan et al .
( 1990 ) already suggested that a significant contribution to the optical light is either coming from the heated surface of the secondary or the outer disk bulge . if the fraction of the secondary or disk bulge that is in the shadow of the accretion disk changes as a function of precession period , this would lead to a change in the optical , with maximum light occurring when the accretion disk is most edge on .
we can compare the characteristics of lmcx-2 to those of xtej1118@xmath15480 , an x - ray transient that is known for having a precessing ( although not necessarily inclined ) accretion disk ( uemura et al . 2000 ) .
zurita et al .
( 2002 ) showed that the nightly average h@xmath22 lines changed in both velocity and width that is consistent with a periodic variation on the precession period ( torres et al .
2004 ) . estimating the average wavelength of heii @xmath14686 for the two nights in lmcx-2 gives [email protected] and [email protected] , respectively , suggesting a slight velocity shift .
however , we must be careful with this slight shift , since we do not have a full orbital coverage each night and this could lead to a systematic off - set to the average wavelength . a better way to find out if this slight shift in velocity is real , is by examining the two heii doppler maps .
they show a bright spot that appears to have moved over night , suggesting the presence of an irradiated region that shows movement on a much longer time - scale than the orbital period , such as the warped and irradiated part of the accretion disk .
unfortunately , we only have two nights of data and can therefore not follow the long - term evolution of this bright spot to unambiguously claim that it moves periodically on a longer timescale . a spectroscopic campaign with a vlt - class telescope would be needed to follow the evolution of the emission lines in lmcx-2 over a full expected precession cycle ( of @xmath91 week ) and show that this bright spot in the heii doppler maps is long - lived and connected to a precessing disk .
the radial velocity curve of the heii @xmath14686 emission line shows a periodic variability that we have interpreted as the orbital period .
this could suggest that it also traces the primary and that we have an estimate for both orbital phase zero and @xmath23 .
however , the doppler maps in fig.[hedopp ] show that the heii emission is dominated by the bright spot due to the warped accretion disk .
since this spot does not have a similar phasing as the primary ( and even moves due to precession ) , we can not use the radial velocity curve to determine the orbital phasing of the primary .
furthermore , if lmcx-2 harbours an inclined precessing accretion disk it is also not likely that semi - amplitude of the heii radial velocity curve traces @xmath23 . in this case the accretion disk , or at least the irradiated side that produced the bright spot in the heii doppler map , is tilted out of the orbital plane thereby changing its radial velocity .
this is clear from fig.[radial ] , where it appears that either the average velocity or the semi - amplitude of the radial velocity curve has changed . only from long - term spectroscopic monitoring of lmcx-2
might it be possible to determine the @xmath23 velocity , but currently we can not constrain this value .
this also means that currently we can not be certain that the average velocity that we determined corresponds to the systemic velocity @xmath24 .
we have detected narrow emission lines in the bowen region that dominate the bowen doppler map .
although these lines are not visible in the individual spectra , they become prominent when we create an average spectrum that is shifted into the rest - frame of these narrow lines . as fig.[average ] shows , all important bowen lines are present , and especially the niii @xmath14640 line is very strong , suggesting that this spot is real and not just a noise feature in the doppler map .
these narrow lines have been detected in many other x - ray binaries thus far , such as scox-1 , x1822@xmath14371 , gx339@xmath144 , v801ara , v926sco , aqlx-1 , gx9@xmath159 and grmus ( steeghs & casares 2002 , casares et al .
2003 , hynes et al .
2003 , casares et al .
2006 , cornelisse et al . 2007a , b , barnes et al .
since there are few compact regions that could produce such narrow emission lines , it was proposed that they arise on the irradiated surface of the donor star . especially in x1822@xmath14371 , but also in v801ara this connection could unambiguously be made , strengthening the claim in all other sources .
furthermore , the width of these emission lines in lmcx-2 suggests that they come from a very compact region in the system , and apart from the donor star surface not many other regions in the binary could produce such narrow lines .
therefore , following the other systems and given the narrowness of these emission lines we tentatively identify them as coming from the donor star of lmcx-2 , despite the fact that the absolute phasing of the system is unknown . in lmcx-2
there is another problem with identifying the compact spot in the bowen doppler map with the secondary , namely the fact that all emission in the heii doppler maps is at much lower velocities than the compact bowen spot .
this would suggest that all emission in the heii map is at sub - keplerian velocities , and not related to the accretion disk .
however , such behaviour is not unique to lmcx-2 . also in the heii @xmath14686 doppler maps of many other lmxbs ( such as scox-1 , x1822@xmath14371 , v801ara and v926sco amongst others ) is most , if not all , emission at sub - keplerian velocities ( steeghs & casares 2002 , casares et al .
2003 , 2006 ) .
however , if the compact spot in the bowen map is produced on the donor star , lmcx-2 would be the most extreme system in showing too low disk velocities .
we do note that one of the assumptions of the technique of doppler tomography is that all motion occurs in the orbital plane .
if the accretion disk in lmcx-2 is inclined , as suggested above , these assumptions are no longer fulfilled .
this would make the interpretation of the accretion disk structure using the doppler maps more difficult , and could be a reason why we observe these sub - keplerian velocities .
for example ,
in ss433 the precession angle of the jets ( and most likely also the accretion disk ) is thought to be @xmath920@xmath25 ( margon 1984 ) , and if lmcx-2 has a similar precession angle ( and a relatively low inclination ) this could easily account for observed accretion disk velocities that are a factor 2 too low .
again , long term spectroscopic monitoring would be needed to give more insight into the real accretion disk velocities .
however , we do note that this should not impact our interpretation of the compact spot arising on the secondary star , and we remain confident that we have detected a signature of the donor star . assuming that we have detected the donor star in lmcx-2 we can use these data to constrain the system parameters .
firstly , the narrow lines must arise on the irradiated surface , therefore the determined @xmath2 ( 351@xmath028 km s@xmath3 ) must be a lower limit to the center of mass velocity of the secondary ( @xmath4 ) .
however , since @xmath2 must be smaller than @xmath4 this already gives a lower limit to the mass function of @xmath26=@xmath27@xmath28@xmath29/(1+@xmath30)@[email protected] @xmath7 ( at 95% confidence ) , where @xmath30 is the binary mass ratio @xmath32/@xmath27 and @xmath29 the inclination of the system . in order to further constrain the mass function the @xmath33-correction must be determined .
unfortunately , this depends on @xmath30 , @xmath29 and the disk flaring angle @xmath22 , all of which are unknown for lmcx-2 ( muoz - darias et al .
furthermore , the @xmath33-correction by muoz - darias et al .
( 2005 ) assumes an idealised accretion disk that is located in the orbital plane of the system , both of which are most likely not true for lmcx-2 .
therefore , we must be very careful with any constraints we will derive in the rest of this section .
we can set a strict lower - limit to @xmath4 by assuming that it is equal to @xmath2 , i.e that all emission is coming from the poles .
furthermore , we can use the 4th order polynomials for the @xmath33-correction by muoz - darias et al .
( 2005 ) to determine @xmath4 as a function of @xmath30 in the case of @xmath22=0@xmath25 and @xmath29=40@xmath25 ( since lmcx-2 does not show dips or eclipses its inclination must be lower than @xmath970@xmath25 , and therefore the polynomials for the @xmath33-correction when @xmath29=40@xmath25 are a better approximation than in the case of @xmath29=90@xmath25 ) .
we show these limits on @xmath4 in fig.[limits ] .
note that these limits are still true even if the accretion disk is severely warped or out of the orbital plane .
assuming that the width of the narrow emission lines is mainly due to rotational broadening we can derive a lower - limit to @xmath30 using @xmath34@xmath35@xmath29=0.462@xmath4@xmath36(1+@xmath30)@xmath37 ( wade & horne 1988 ) . from fig.[average ] we derive a _
fwhm _ of the narrow lines of [email protected] km s@xmath3 . since these emission lines are expected to arise from only part of the secondary
, this value must be a strict lower - limit and the true _
fwhm _ must be higher .
furthermore , our estimate still includes the effect of the intrinsic instrumental resolution of 70 km s@xmath3 . following casares et al .
( 2006 ) we accounted for this effect by broadening a strong line in our arc spectrum using a gray rotational profile without limb darkening ( since the fluorescence lines occur in optically thin conditions ) until we reached the observed _ fwhm _ ( gray 1992 ) .
we found that a rotational broadening of @xmath38@xmath35@xmath29@xmath660@xmath018 km s@xmath3 reproduced our results .
since this is a strict lower - limit on the true rotational broadening this will also give a lower limit on both @xmath30 and @xmath4 that is shown in fig.[limits ] .
casares et al .
( 2006 ) derived an upper - limit to @xmath30 by assuming that the secondary is the largest possible zero - age main sequence star fitting in its roche - lobe .
however , lmcx-2 shows the x - ray properties of a z - source ( smale et al .
z - sources trace a z - like shape in their x - ray colour - colour diagrams and are thought to have more evolved secondaries ( see e.g. hasinger & van der klis 1989 ) . although the evolved nature of the secondary in z - sources is not unambiguously confirmed , it is still reasonable that the assumption of a zero - age main sequence donor is most likely not true for lmcx-2 .
we therefore can not use this assumption to derive an upper - limit on the mass ratio , since the evolved donor star could be more massive than a main sequence star ( schenker & king 2002 ) .
however , we can use an alternative way to set an upper - limit to @xmath30 , namely using the fact that lmcx-2 has a precessing accretion disk .
one of the main criteria to produce a precessing accretion disk is to have an extreme mass ratio ( e.g. whitehurst 1988 ) . from an overview by patterson et al .
( 2005 ) of compact binaries that have a precessing accretion disk and for which the mass ratio is known , we can use the system with the largest measured @xmath30 thus far and assume that it must be smaller for lmcx-2 .
this leads to a conservative upper - limit of @[email protected] , and our final limit for the system parameters shown in fig.[limits ] .
all these limits constrain an area in fig.[limits ] that is still quite large , and at the moment it is still not possible to constrain any of the system parameters tightly enough in order to say anything about the component masses or the evolution of lmcx-2 .
however , we can make two more assumptions , although more speculative , for lmcx-2 to further constrain its system parameters .
given that lmcx-2 shows the x - ray properties of a z - source ( smale et al .
2003 ) , we can speculate that its compact object is a neutron star . in this case the maximum mass for the compact object would be @xmath93.2@xmath7 , and we could use this to set tighter upper - limits to @xmath4 than derived from the assumptions we have made thus far . in fig.[limits ] we have therefore also indicated the maximum limit where the compact object can still be a neutron star , i.e. where @xmath27@xmath35@xmath39=3.2@xmath7 , as a solid dark line . however
since we can not completely rule out the possibility that the compact object in lmcx-2 is a low mass black hole , we have decided not to use this limit to constrain @xmath4 .
finally , we can speculate that the semi - amplitude that we have derived from the heii @xmath14686 radial velocity curve is @xmath23 .
in this case we set an upper - limit to @xmath30=@xmath23/@[email protected] .
note that we have used this value for @xmath30 and @xmath4=@xmath2 to draw the roche lobe in fig.[bowdopp ] to illustrate that it encompasses the bright spot .
however , this set of system parameters is just one possible solution within the allowed region in fig.[limits ] and we do not imply that it represents the true or even preferred system parameters of lmcx-2 .
we note that this value of @xmath30=0.12 is similar to the mass ratios determined from other x - ray binaries that show a precessing accretion disk ( odonoghue & charles 1996 ) , suggesting that it might be close to the true mass ratio of lmcx-2 .
also , if we assume that the @xmath912 day variation observed by crampton et al .
( 1990 ) is the precession period , and that the 8.2 hr photometric period is a superhump period , we can estimate the fractional period excess of the superhump over the orbital period @xmath40 .
we find that @[email protected] and with the @xmath40(@xmath30)-@xmath30 relation by patterson et al .
( 2005 ) we estimate that @[email protected] .
this is again close to the mass ratio derived above .
although this would set tight constraints to @xmath30 , and makes a black hole nature for the compact object very unlikely , we have argued in sect.4.2 that we can not make this assumption and have therefore not plotted this in fig.[limits ] .
finally , we do want to point out that , despite the large range of system parameters possible , lmcx-2 most likely harbours a neutron star that is more massive than the canonical 1.4@xmath7 . since lmcx-2 does not show eclipses or dips we can estimate an upper - limit on the inclination of 65@xmath25 ( see e.g. paczynski 1974 ) .
combined with the lower limit on the mass function already gives @xmath41(@xmath27)/@xmath28@[email protected]@xmath7 .
for the compact object to be 1.4@xmath7 , this only leaves @[email protected] ( and @[email protected] ) .
furthermore , already for @xmath4=309 km s@xmath3 ( and @xmath29@xmath865@xmath25 ) the mass of the compact object will exceed 1.4m@xmath42 .
this only leaves a very small corner in the bottom - left part of our allowed system parameters , and makes lmcx-2 another strong candidate to harbour a massive neutron star .
we have detected for the first time a spectroscopic period in lmcx-2 that is close to previously published photometric period of 8.15 hrs by callanan et al .
we interpret this as the orbital period , while the 12 day period detected by crampton et al .
( 1990 ) is most likely the super - orbital period due to an inclined precessing accretion disk .
the signature of such a precessing accretion disk is also present in our data , mainly in the heii doppler maps , but also in the form of a nightly change in semi - amplitude and/or mean velocity of the radial velocity curve of heii @xmath14686 . in a forthcoming paper by shih et al .
( in prep . ) we will explore the consequences of such a precessing accretion disk in more detail .
the main result of our spectroscopic data - set is the detection of narrow emission lines in the bowen region .
following previous detections of such lines in other lmxbs , we tentatively identify these as arising from the surface of the secondary .
this gives us for the first time the possibility to derive the mass function of lmcx-2 and constrain its system parameters .
although they point toward a massive neutron star , the constraints on the system parameters are currently not very tight
. however , this could change with a better determination of both the spectroscopic and precession period during a long term spectroscopic campaign to study the emission line kinematics . using the relation between the mass ratio @xmath30 and the fractional period excess of the spectroscopic and
the photometric period @xmath40 could give strong constraints on @xmath30 and thereby the other system parameters .
in particular this would be an excellent way to identify the nature of the donor star to find out if z - sources really have more evolved secondaries .
this work is based on data collected at the european southern observatory paranal , chile ( obs.id .
074.d-0657(a ) ) .
we acknowledge the use of the molly and doppler software packages developed by t.r . marsh .
rc acknowledges financial support from a european union marie curie intra - european fellowship ( meift - ct-2005 - 024685 ) .
jc acknowledges support from the spanish ministry of science and technology through project aya2002 - 03570 .
ds acknowledges a smithsonian astrophysical observatory clay fellowship as well as support from nasa through its guest observer program .
ds acknowledges a pparc / stfc advanced fellowship . 99 alcock , c. , allsman , r.a . ,
alves , d.r . , axelrod , t.s . ,
becker , a.c . ,
bennett , d.p . ,
charles , p.a . , cook , k.h . ,
drake , a.j . ,
freeman , k.c . , and 16 coauthors 2000 , mnras ; 316 , 729 barnes , a.d . ,
casares , j. , cornelisse , r. , charles , p.a . ,
steeghs , d. , hynes , r.i . ,
obrien , k. 2007 , mnras , accepted for publication [ astro - ph/0707.0624 ] casares j. , steeghs d. , hynes r.i , charles p.a . , obrien k. , 2003 , apj , 590 , 1041 casares , j. , cornelisse , r. , steeghs , d. , charles , p.a . , hynes , r.i .
, obrien , k.o . , & strohmayer , t.e .
2006 , mnras , 373 , 1235 cornelisse , r. , casares , j. , steeghs , d . ,
barnes , a.d . , charles , p.a . , hynes , r.i . , obrien , k. 2007a , mnras , 375 , 1463 cornelisse , r. , steeghs , d. , casares , j. , charles , p.a . ,
barnes , a.d . ,
hynes , r.i .
, obrien , k. 2007b , mnras , accepted for publication [ astro - ph/0707.0449 ] callanan , p.j . ,
charles , p.a . , van paradijs , j. , van der klis , m. , pedersen , h. , harlaftis , e.t .
1990 , a&a , 240 , 346 crampton , d. , hutchings , j.b . ,
cowley , a.p . ,
schmidtke , p.c . , thompson , i.b .
1990 , apj , 355 , 496 hynes , r.i . ,
obrien , k. 2007 , mnras , 375 , 1463 hasinger , g. , & van der klis , m. 1989 , a&a , 225 , 79 gray , d.f . , 1992 , `` the observation and analysis of stellar photospheres '' , cup , 20 horne k. , 1986 , pasp , 98 , 609 hynes r.i . , steeghs d. , casares j. , charles p.a . , obrien k. , 2003 , apj , 583 , l95 katz , j.i .
1973 , nature , 246 , 87 margon , b. 1984 , ara&a , 22 , 507 marsh t.r .
, horne k. , 1988 , mnras 235 , 269 mcclintock , j.e . , canizares , c.r . , & tarter , c.b .
1975 , apj , 198 , 641 motch , c. , chevalier , c. , ilovaisky , s.a . ,
pakull , m.w .
1985 , space sci .
reviews , vol .
40 , p. 239 motch , c. , pakull , m.w .
1989 , a&a , 214 , l1 muoz - darias , t. , casares , j. , & martinez - pais , i.g .
2005 , apj , 635 , 502 odonoghue , d. , charles , p.a .
1996 , mnras ; 282 , 191 paczynski , b. 1974 , a&a , 34 , 161 pakull , m. 1978 , iau circ . ,
3313 patterson , j. , kemp , j. , harvey , d.a .
, fried , r.e . ,
rea , r. , monard , b. , cook , l.m . ,
skillman , d.r . ,
vanmunster , t. , bolt , g. , et al .
2005 , pasp ; 117 , 1204 scargle , j.d .
1982 , apj , 263 , 835 schenker , k. , king , a.r .
2002 , asp conf.ser .
261 , `` the physics of cataclysmic variables and related objects '' , 261 , 242 steeghs d. , casares j. , 2002 , apj , 568 , 273 smale , a.p . , kuulkers , e. 2000 , apj , 528 , 702 smale , a.p . ,
homan , j. , kuulkers , e. 2003 , apj , 590 , 1035 torres , m.a.p .
, callanan , p.j . ,
garcia , m.r .
, zhao , p. , laylock , s. , kong , a.k.h .
2004 , apj , 612 , 1026 uemura , m. , kato , t. , matsumoto , k. , honkawa , m. , cook , l. , martin , b. , masi , g. , oksanen , a. , moilanen , m. , novak , r. , sano , y. , ueda , y. 2000 , iauc , 7418 wade r.a . ,
horne k. , 1988 , apj , 324 , 411 whitehurst , r. 1988 , mnras , 232 , 35 zurita , c. , casares , j. , shahbaz , t. , wagner , r.m . , foltz , c.b .
, rodriguez - gil , p. , hynes , r.i . , charles , p.a . , ryan , e. , schwarz , g. , & starrfield , s.g .
2002 , mnras , 333 , 791 | two nights of phase - resolved medium resolution vlt spectroscopy of the extra - galactic low mass x - ray binary lmcx-2 have revealed a [email protected] day spectroscopic period in the radial velocity curve of the heii @xmath14686 emission line that we interpret as the orbital period .
however , similar to previous findings , this radial velocity curve shows a longer term variation that is most likely due to the presence of a precessing accretion disk in lmcx-2 .
this is strengthened by heii @xmath14686 doppler maps that show a bright spot that is moving from night to night .
furthermore , we detect narrow emission lines in the bowen region of lmcx-2,with a velocity of @xmath2=351@xmath028 km s@xmath3 , that we tentatively interpret as coming from the irradiated side of the donor star .
since @xmath2 must be smaller than @xmath4 , this leads to the first upper - limit on the mass function of lmcx-2 of @[email protected]@xmath7 ( 95% confidence ) , and the first constraints on its system parameters .
[ firstpage ] accretion , accretion disks stars : individual ( lmcx-2 ) x - rays : binaries . |
ithe major galaxy mergers in galaxy formation inevitably leads to the presence of a binary black hole ( bbh ) located in the center of a giant galaxy @xcite .
the following observational results provide possible evidence of the presence of bbhs : double compact cores @xcite , two broad - line emission systems @xcite , the x - shaped morphology of radio lobes @xcite , wiggle patterns of radio jets @xcite , periodic variations and periodic outbursts @xcite , and the orbital motion of the compact core @xcite . strong evidence for bbhs as linking some observational results , however , has not yet been found .
clarifying the mechanism for the formation of bbhs is essential in the study of galaxy mergers in galaxy formation @xcite , in the role of black hole mergers in the evolution of supermassive black holes @xcite , and in the detection of gravitational waves at the phase of bbh orbital decay @xcite .
is a nearby low - luminosity fr i radio galaxy and giant elliptical galaxy with a redshift ( @xmath8 ) of 0.0213 @xcite , and has the strong jet and counter jet that extend to about 100 kiloparsecs ( kpc ) which have been observed at radio @xcite , infrared @xcite , optical @xcite and x - ray waves @xcite .
the orbital motion of the compact core in , which has a period of @xmath1 years , was observed with a position accuracy of 10 micro arcseconds ( @xmath9as ) by using phase - referencing very long baseline interferometry ( vlbi ) @xcite .
several observational and theoretical studies have shown that the periodic flux variation and periodic outburst activities in the radio , optical , x - ray , and @xmath10-ray light curves are associated with the orbital motion of a bbh in the center of the galaxies @xcite . here
we report the detection of a signal periodicity in light curves from the compact core of , which indicates the presence of a very close bbh in the center of this object , and also present evidence for black hole mergers .
we use a hubble constant ( @xmath11 ) of 71 km s@xmath12 mpc@xmath12 , the matter density ( @xmath13 ) of 0.27 and the vacuum energy ( @xmath14 ) of 0.73 in this letter , resulting that an angular size or separation of 1 milliarcsecond ( mas ) corresponds to 0.436 pc at the distance of 3c 66b .
the millimeter - wavelength flux variation for was monitored every two weeks from the end of 2003 through to the beginning of 2005 at 93.716 ghz using the nobeyama millimeter array ( nma ) of the national astronomical observatory of japan ( naoj ) , and every four weeks from the end of 2005 through to the middle of 2006 at 86.2 ghz using the plateau de bure interferometer ( pdbi ) of the institut de radioastronomie millimtrique ( iram ) .
these flux monitor observations using two - type millimeter arrays will enable us to eliminate any dependence on the characteristic features of each array , giving us more reliable and accurate results . in the nma observation , and were observed as a visibility calibrator .
also , the flux densities of each calibrator were precisely derived by observing and .
phase fluctuations in the observation are caused by short - term variations of the excess path length in the atmosphere , which is mainly due to the time variation of water vapor pressure .
since these phase variations cause decoherence in the visibility data , it is necessary to correct this loss .
the decoherence factors at all observation epochs were estimated from the synthesized maps of each visibility calibrator @xcite . to accurately derive the flux densities of the observed object , the flux data at epochs with a decoherence of more than 20 % were flagged . and were observed for the bandpass calibration .
the weighted mean of the flux density data that were estimated from each visibility calibrator was plotted . in the pdbi observation ,
the flux densities of were corrected by observing and the compact h@xmath15 region , and/or , except on january 14 and on july 23 in 2006 .
the phase and bandpass calibrations were performed by itself .
we first investigated the contribution of large - scale jet emissions into observed flux densities .
a map of with millimeter jets can be made by combining the visibility data obtained from the nma monitoring observations for all epochs ( see figure 1a ) .
the total flux density of the millimeter map of 3c 66b at 93 ghz exceeds 500 mjy , while the sum of the expanding jet and counter jet is less than 24 mjy .
we made the spectral energy distributions ( seds ) of the jet and the counter jet from our data and other data at different wavelengths , respectively .
we found that these seds follow ( agree with ) a simple power - law synchrotron model , even though the flux densities at all wavelengths were observed at the different dates ( see figure 1b ) .
this fact indicates that the observed flux variations of were dominated by the unresolved core , not by the expanding jet and counter jet .
figure 2 shows the 3-mm peak flux monitor data obtained from the unresolved core of between 2003 november and 2006 august , and the spectral analysis results from these monitor data by using lomb - scargle periodogram @xcite . from these results
, we detected a periodic flux variation on a cycle of 93@xmath161 days with a maximum - to - minimum amplitude ratio of @xmath17 , and non - periodic flux variation from the unresolved core .
the variability timescale of the observed signal is shorter than that of the orbital period of about 1 year . due to the orbital motion around the center of gravity in a bbh ,
the doppler factor for the emitting region is a periodical function of time @xcite , and the observed signal periodicity has a geometrical origin due to doppler - shifted modulation .
compared to the intrinsic period , the observed signal period is shortened by the relativistic effect @xcite .
it is also noted that the non - periodic flux variation may be caused by the non - thermal radiation in the flaring state that is emitted by a relativistic emission region not directly affected by a bbh ( e.g. , a shock in the knots of jet in the core that is not resolved with the angular resolutions of nma and pdbi ) .
both the observed flux variation ( see figure 2 ) and the orbital motion @xcite were well fitted by a simple model of sin function .
this result indicates that the difference between the apogee and perigee velocities will be small , and that the doppler boosting factor will be small .
if they were large , the profile of the observed flux variation would be that of a spike like the periodic outburst activities in the flaring state .
this indicates that the binary system in has a nearly circular orbit . as a consequence of the binary orbital revolution around the center of gravity , the observed signal period ( @xmath18 )
is related to the orbital period ( @xmath19 ) by @xcite @xmath20 where @xmath21 is @xmath22 with the jet outflow velocity of @xmath23 and the light speed of @xmath24 , and @xmath25 is the inclination angle between the jet axis and the line of sight .
the apparent speed in the relativistic jet is written by @xcite @xmath26 given the detected signal period ( @xmath18 ) of 93@xmath161 days , the orbital period ( @xmath19 ) of @xmath1 years @xcite , and the derived apparent speed ( @xmath27 ) of [email protected] ( see figure 3 ) , the following physical parameters for an inner - jet outflow that has the effect of the bbh orbital motion found in were estimated from equations ( [ eq : period ] ) and ( [ eq : apparent ] ) ; a speed ( @xmath21=@xmath22 ) of [email protected] and an inclination angle ( @xmath25 ) of [email protected] degrees in accordance with the standard model for jet bulk motion .
consequently , the derived doppler factor ( @xmath28 ) of 2.8 [ = @xmath29 is a small value that does not have a strong effect on the profile of the periodical flux variation . the jet is presumably linked to the accretion disk around a black hole .
at least one of the two black holes in a binary system will have an accretion disk .
if both of the black holes have an accretion disk , the relationship between the observed jet and the two black holes is not simple . assuming that the observed jet is dominated by the accretion disk around either one of the two black holes , we show two schematic geometries of a bbh in figure 4 .
the orbital motion velocity ( @xmath30 ) around the center of gravity can be written as @xmath31 , where @xmath32 is the intrinsic orbital frequency .
the observed flux modulation by doppler boosting can be written by @xmath33 where @xmath34 is the intrinsic spectral flux density in the comoving frame , @xmath35 is the source spectral index ( @xmath36 ) , and @xmath37 is the doppler factor including the time variation due to the orbital motion of the bbh , which is written by @xcite @xmath38 where @xmath39 is @xmath40 . from equation ( [ eq : flux ] ) , the observed maximum - to - minimum flux ratio can be expressed as @xmath41 by applying this model to the sin curve of the periodic flux variation caused by a bbh ( see figure 2 ) , an orbital motion velocity ( @xmath30 ) of the bbh can be derived from equations ( [ eq : doppler ] ) and ( [ eq : ratio ] ) , and an orbital radius ( @xmath42 ) of @xmath43 cm [ @xmath44 pc ] can then be estimated when @xmath35=0 .
although an upper limit for the orbital radius could only be estimated from the core motion using phase - referencing vlbi @xcite , the orbital radius of a bbh can be directly derived by adding the periodic flux monitor data that we found successfully . from two types of geometry of a bbh system shown in figure 4 ,
an orbital separation ( @xmath45 ) of two black holes is @xmath46 ( see figure 4a ) or @xmath47 ( see figure 4b ) when @xmath48 , where @xmath49 and @xmath50 denote the mass of the smaller and larger black holes , respectively .
since the revolution period of a two - body problem with a circular orbit has a relational expression of @xmath51 ( where @xmath52 is the gravitational constant ) , the mass of the larger black hole ( @xmath50 ) is estimated to be @xmath53 or @xmath54 @xcite demonstrated a tight correlation between the black hole masses and the velocity dispersions of their host bulges , and @xcite then derived the relationship between central stellar velocity dispersions and black hole masses .
based on this relationship , an estimated mass of @xmath55 @xmath5 @xcite is adopted as the total mass of the two black holes [ @xmath56 for 3c 66b , where @xmath5 is the mass of the sun . from equations ( [ eq : small ] ) and ( [ eq : large ] ) , the following basic bbh physical parameters were estimated ; the larger black hole mass of @xmath4 @xmath5 , the smaller black hole mass of @xmath6 @xmath5 , and the separation ( @xmath45 ) between the black holes of @xmath57 cm [ @xmath3 pc ] that corresponds to about @xmath58 times the schwarzschild radius ( @xmath59 ) of @xmath60 cm [ @xmath61 pc , @xmath62 au ] .
this estimated separation is much shorter than that of a celestial object recently identified as being a potential sub - parsec bbhs by @xcite , revealing the presence of a very close bbh in the center of .
the decay time of a bbh in the center of due to the gravitational radiation is estimated to be @xmath7 years using the following equation @xcite @xmath63 the estimated decay time is much shorter than the hubble time .
the model of galaxy formation based on @xmath64cdm indicates that there were a large number of galaxy mergers , which led to giant elliptical galaxies .
centaurus a ( cena ) , which is the nearby radio galaxy and bright elliptical galaxy , has the prominent warped dust lane and gas disk in the central region ( e.g. , @xcite ) , suggesting that cen a experienced a recent merging event during a few @xmath65 years ( @xcite and references therein ) .
3c66b is a giant elliptical galaxy within the cluster abell 347 @xcite and has the prominent face - on dust lane @xcite .
these indicate that 3c 66b differs from quasars with active merging @xcite and is one of nearby radio galaxies that experienced the galaxy merging event . within a timescale of @xmath65 years
, two black holes caused after the galaxy merging event would come closer to each other due to the dynamical friction and gas interaction , and then merge into one due to the gravitational - wave radiation ( e.g. , @xcite ) . in conclusion , this shows a possibility that a very close bbh in the center of exists just before its merger into one black hole .
the detection of strong gravitational - wave radiation is expected during the final stage of a black hole merger . in this letter ,
the following assumptions are adopted ; 1 ) the derived apparent speed of the jet is equal to the bulk flow speed ; 2 ) the jet axis is parallel to the binary angular momentum and is perpendicular to the accretion disk around a black hole by which the observed jet is formed ; 3 ) the bbh has a binary orbit with an orbital eccentricity of zero ( this is a circular orbit ) ; and 4 ) the spectral index is zero at around our observing frequencies .
it is theoretically suggested that the pattern speed is slower than the bulk flow speed of the jet @xcite , while the study on the relativistic bulk motion in about 100 agns demonstrates that there is no clear distinction between these speeds @xcite .
for instance , the ratio of these speeds for grs1919 + 105 was estimated to be 0.8 @xcite . as our estimated proper motion has an error of 15 % that is comparable to this uncertainty , the assumption 1 )
can be considered reliable in this letter .
the complexity of mergers and active galactic nuclei ( agns ) feeding may not support the assumptions 2 ) and 3 ) . to evaluate these assumptions , it is necessary to monitor the flux variation with higher precision as closely as possible .
if these assumptions are not entirely inappropriate , however , our derived physical parameters are not significantly changed . since the synchrotron radiation from the agn core is expected to be optically thin or peak at around our observing frequencies , we adopted the assumption 4 ) in this letter .
when @xmath66 as compared with @xmath67 , the derived physical parameters of a bbh in are changed at a factor of 1 to 3 . using the atacama large millimeter / submillimeter array ( alma ) including the atacama compact array ( aca ) that is used to obtain precise images of celestial objects with high angular resolution @xcite , the multi - wavelength profile of the periodic flux variation and periodic outburst activities of candidate objects can be monitored with precision of one mjy or better .
the spike profile of the periodic flux variation will provide us with the orbital eccentricity of a bbh in and the relationship between the jet axis and the binary angular momentum .
in addition , the multi - wavelength profile will improve our derived basic physical parameters of the bbh with high precision ; the orbital radius , the orbital separation and the masses of the two black holes , and the decay time .
we thank m. saito for his useful comments , t. hasegawa for his comments on data analysis , h. suda for his support with regard to the nma observations and data reduction , and r. neri for the technical help he provided for the pdbi data reduction .
this research was partially supported by the ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology ( mext ) of japan , grant - in - aid for young scientists ( b ) 17740114 , 2005 - 2007 , and grant - in - aid for scientific research ( b ) 21340044 , 2009 - 2011 .
abraham , z. , & carrara , e. a. 1998 , , 496 , 172 baade , w. , & minkowski , r. 1954 , , 119 , 215 baker , j. g. , centrella , j. , choi , d. ii . , koppitz , m. & meter , j. 2006 , , 73 , 104002 begelman , m. c. , blandford , r. d. , & rees , m. j. 1980 , nature , 287 , 307 bodo , g. , & ghisellini , g. 1995 , , 441 , l69 boroson , t. a. , & lauer , t. r. 2009 , nature , 458 , 53 camenzind , m. , & krockenberger , m. 1992 , a&a , 255 , 59 de paoils , f. , ingrosso , g. , & nucita , a. a. 2002 , a&a , 388 , 470 de paoils , f. , ingrosso , g. , & nucita , a. a. 2004 , a&a , 426 , 379 fanti , c. et al .
1982 , a&a , 105 , 200 ferrarese , l. , & merritt , d. 2000 , , 539 , l9 ghisellini , g. , padovani , p. , celotti , a. , & maraschi , l. 1993 , , 407 , 65 ginzburg , v. l. , & syrovatskii , s. i. 1969 , a .rev .
a&a , 7 , 375 hardcastle , m. j. , alexander , p. , pooley , g. g. , & riley , j. m. 1996 , mnras , 278 , 273 hardcastle , m. j. , birkinshaw , m. , & worrall , d. m. 2001 , mnras , 326 , 1499 huchra , j. p. , vogeley , m. s. , & geller , m. j. 1999 , , 121 , 287 iguchi , s. et al . , 2009 , , 61 , 1 kohno , k. et al . , 2005 , , 57 , 147 lind , k. r. , & blandford , r. d. 1985 , , 295 , 358 lobanov , a. p. , & roland , j. 2005 , a&a , 431 , 831 lomb , n. r. 1976 , ap . space .
sci , 39 , 447 macchetto , f. et al .
, 1991 , , 373 , l55 merritt , d. , & ekers , r. d. 2002 , science 297 , 1310 merritt , & ferrarese , l. 2001 , , 547 , 140 noel - storr , j. , baum , s. a. , & odea , c. p. 2007 , , 663 , 71 peters , p. c. 1964 , phys .
, 136 , 4b , 1224 rieger , f. m. , & mannheim , k. 2000 , a&a , 359 , 948 rodriguez , c. et al . , 2006 , , 646 , 49 roos , n. , kaastra , j. s. , & hummel , c. a. 1993 , , 409 , 130 sanders , d. b. et al . , 1988 , , 325 , 74 scargle j. d.,1982 , , 263 , 835 sillanp , a. , haarala , s. , valtonen , m. j. , sundelius , b. , & byrd , g. g. 1988 , , 325 , 628 struve , c. , oosterloo , t. a. , morganti , r. , & saripalli , l. 2010 , a&a , 515 , 67 sudou , h. , iguchi , s. , murata , y. , & taniguchi , y. 2003 , science , 300 , 1263 tansley , d. , birkinshaw , m. , hardcastle , m. j. , & worrall , d. m. 2000 , mnras , 317 , 623 treister , e. et al .
, 2010 , science , 328 , 600 valtaoja , e. et al . ,
2000 , , 531 , 744 valtonen , m. j. et al . , 2008 ,
nature 452 , 851 verdoes kleijn , g. a. , baum , s. a. , de zeeuw , p. t. , & odea , c. p. 1999 , , 118 , 2592 volonteri , m. , miller , j. m. , & dotti , m. 2009 , , 703 , l86 yu , q. 2002 , mnras , 331 , 935 | recent observational results provide possible evidence that binary black holes ( bbhs ) exist in the center of giant galaxies and may merge to form a supermassive black hole in the process of their evolution .
we first detected a periodic flux variation on a cycle of @xmath0 days from the 3-mm monitor observations of a giant elliptical galaxy for which an orbital motion with a period of @xmath1 years had been already observed .
the detected signal period being shorter than the orbital period can be explained by taking into consideration the doppler - shifted modulation due to the orbital motion of a bbh .
assuming that the bbh has a circular orbit and that the jet axis is parallel to the binary angular momentum , our observational results demonstrate the presence of a very close bbh that has the binary orbit with an orbital period of @xmath1 years , an orbital radius of @xmath2 pc , an orbital separation of @xmath3 pc , the larger black hole mass of @xmath4 @xmath5 , and the smaller black hole mass of @xmath6 @xmath5 .
the bbh decay time of @xmath7 years provides evidence for the occurrence of black hole mergers .
this letter will demonstrate the interesting possibility of black hole collisions to form a supermassive black hole in the process of evolution , one of the most spectacular natural phenomena in the universe . |
d.f . acknowledges financial support from the european research council under the european unions seventh framework programme ( fp/20072013)/erc ga 306559 and epsrc ( uk , grant ep / j00443x/1 ) . i. c. acknowledges financial support by the erc through the qgbe grant , by the eu - fet proactive grant aqus , project no . 640800 , and by the autonomous province of trento , partly through the siquro project ( `` on silicon chip quantum optics for quantum computing and secure communications '' )
here we provide further details on the effect of nonlocal interactions on the landau critical velocity .
the starting point of this discussion is the bogoliubov dispersion of collective excitations in such a _ nonlocal fluid _ when this is at rest .
after simple manipulation of eq.(4 ) of the main text , this can be written in the more usual form @xcite : @xmath150 that allows for transparent analytical manipulations and easier connection to the many - body literature .
with respect to the usual case of a local fluid @xcite , the nonlocality enters via the denominator of the interaction term that suppresses interactions at large @xmath151 . for a propagating fluid of light
, the frequency @xmath25 corresponds to the wavevector @xmath152 in the propagation direction expressed in temporal units , @xmath153 , and @xmath151 is the transverse wavevector ( note the different convention from @xcite ) . in terms of the optical parameters of the optical medium
, @xmath154 is the effective mass of the photons , @xmath155 is the fluid density , @xmath156 is the interaction constant , and the nonlocality is again modeled with a lorentzian function of size @xmath157 .
here , @xmath7 is the background refractive index and @xmath158 the free wavevector in the medium , and @xmath159 is the optical nonlinearity .
the units of this latter are such that @xmath160 is the nonlinear refractive index shift .
, the right ( b , d ) panels are for a nonlocal fluid with a value of @xmath161 inspired by the experiment .
the dotted curve in the right panels repeats the local fluid dispersion for comparison .
the red dashed line is the straight line @xmath162 corresponding to the critical speed @xmath106 .
the panels in the bottom row show the same curves in log - log scale . ]
examples of such a bogoliubov dispersion are shown in fig.[fig : bogo ] both in linear - linear and in log - log scales .
the landau critical velocity is defined as the minimum of the phase velocity @xmath163 where in our case @xmath164^{1/2}.\ ] ] on the nonlocal length @xmath157 [ upper panel ( a ) ] and on the density @xmath165 [ lower panel ( b ) ] . in this latter ,
the density is normalized to @xmath166 and the velocity to @xmath167 .
the vertical dot - dashed lines indicate the transition points between the two @xmath168 regimes .
the vertical dashed line in the upper panel indicate the experimental conditions .
the dotted line in the lower panel shows how @xmath169 behaviour would extend to the whole domain . ] * for weak nonlocalities @xmath171 [ fig.[fig : bogo](a , b ) ] , the phase velocity @xmath172 is a monotonically growing function of @xmath151 , so the minimum is attained at @xmath173 .
the critical landau speed is then the speed of sound , @xmath174 * for strong nonlocalities @xmath175 [ fig.[fig : bogo](c , d ) ] , the phase velocity @xmath172 has a local minimum at @xmath176 where it attains the smaller value @xmath177}\ ] ] plots of the critical velocity @xmath178 as a function of the nonlocality length and of the fluid density are shown in the two panels of fig.[fig : vc ] .
the former clearly shows that the critical velocity is equal to the sound velocity upto @xmath179 , then it quickly decays to zero according to the formulas : @xmath180 the latter shows the usual @xmath169 dependence at low @xmath165 , which then transforms into a slower @xmath181 law at high @xmath165 according to the formulas : @xmath182 note that the two regimes continuously connect at the transition point @xmath179 .
for the parameters of the experiment @xmath183 with a background refractive index estimated around @xmath184 , one has @xmath185 which gives a factor @xmath186 reduction of the critical velocity @xmath106 below the speed of sound @xmath187 .
40ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.85.299 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1098/rspa.2014.0320 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.92.043802 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.60.4114 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.69.1644 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop _ _ ( , ) link:\doibase 10.1038/nphys1364 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1038/nphoton.2011.211 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/nphys1959 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/optica.2.000484 [ * * , ( ) ] http://prl.aps.org/abstract/prl/v69/i17/p2503_1 [ * * ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1364/ol.37.002325 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/nphys486 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.99.043903 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.87.013802 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ ( , ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.78.063804 [ * * , ( ) ] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17572718 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/bf02780991 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/s0079 - 6417(08)60077 - 3 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1098/rspa.1957.0071 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1073/pnas.1400033111 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1073/pnas.1312737110 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.91.023621 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/ao.27.005082 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1209/0295 - 5075/92/14002 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.85.045602 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) http://stacks.iop.org/0034-4885/72/i=12/a=126401 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) y. pomeau and s. rica , _ model of superflow with rotons _ , phys
71 * , 247 ( 1993 ) . | recent work has unveiled a new class of optical systems that can exhibit the characteristic features of superfluidity .
one such system relies on the repulsive photon - photon interaction that is mediated by a thermal optical nonlinearity and is therefore inherently nonlocal due to thermal diffusion .
here we investigate how such a nonlocal interaction , which at a first inspection would not be expected to lead to superfluid behavior , may be tailored by acting upon the geometry of the photon fluid itself .
our models and measurements show that restricting the laser profile and hence the photon fluid to a strongly elliptical geometry modifies thermal diffusion along the major beam axis and reduces the effective nonlocal interaction length by two orders of magnitude .
this in turn enables the system to display a characteristic trait of superfluid flow : the nucleation of quantized vortices in the flow past an extended physical obstacle .
these results are general and apply to other nonlocal fluids , such as dipolar bose - einstein condensates , and show that `` thermal '' photon superfluids provide an exciting and novel experimental environment for probing the nature of superfluidity , with applications to the study of quantum turbulence and analogue gravity . over the past decade ,
theoretical and experimental studies of photon fluids have opened new routes to realizing quantum many - body systems . in the most general case , a photon fluid
is created by propagating a laser beam through a defocusing nonlinear medium such that the photons in the beam act as a gas of weakly interacting particles @xcite . as in atomic many - body systems ,
the collective photon behavior can be described by a gross - pitaevskii equation @xcite , where the electric field plays the role of the order parameter , a macroscopic wave function with a clear resemblance to dilute - gas bose - einstein condensates ( becs ) and superfluid helium .
much research with photon fluids has therefore centered on exploring characteristics of superfluidity , such as the nucleation of vortices of quantized circulation in the flow past an obstacle for sufficiently high flow speeds @xcite .
+ significant progress on this front has been made in the field of _ polariton _ fluids , strongly coupled exciton - polaritons in semiconductor microcavities , that have shown superfluid characteristics , such as the frictionless flow around an obstacle @xcite , and shedding of solitons @xcite and quantized vortices @xcite . differently from these driven - dissipative systems with a _
local _
nonlinearity , signatures of superfluid behavior in the dispersion relation have also been observed for room - temperature , _ nonlocal _ photon fluids in a propagating geometry @xcite .
in such a system , heating induced by a laser beam leads to a decrease in the refractive index of the propagation medium and a consequent defocusing effect for the laser beam , resulting in an effective repulsive photon - photon interaction established by the medium .
for a monochromatic beam , the transverse beam profile acts to define the geometry of the two - dimensional ( 2d ) fluid and is fully described by hydrodynamic equations , where the propagation direction maps on to an effective time coordinate @xcite .
due to heat diffusion , this interaction is inherently nonlocal , i.e. , the photon density at one point in space influences the interactions at a distant point .
photon - photon interactions are therefore effectively spread out over distances of the order of the characteristic thermal diffusion ( or nonlocal ) length .
while solitons and vortex solitons have previously been reported in these systems @xcite , the nonlocal aspect of the interaction has only recently attracted attention @xcite , enabling studies of novel shock front and turbulence dynamics @xcite .
the main effect of the fluid nonlocality in the context of superfluidity is a reduction and even cancellation of the effect of interactions on intermediate length scales and a restoration of the standard single - particle dispersion relation for excitations in the medium at much lower wavevectors than the inverse healing length .
while one can expect that this effect may result in the inhibition of superfluid behavior in generic nonlocal superfluids such as dipolar atomic becs , the interplay of nonlocality and superfluidity has not yet been completely explored in the literature .
+ here we analyze in detail the nature of a propagating laser beam s thermal photon - photon interactions mediated by a dilute dispersion of graphene nanoflakes in methanol .
our primary result is that with a suitable configuration of the photon fluid s geometry , as determined by the laser beam s transverse profile , nonlocal interactions can exist simultaneously with characteristics of superfluidity , as evidenced by the nucleation of quantized vortices in the photon fluid s flow past an obstacle .
analytically , we start with a model that accounts for the boundary conditions of the system . by
introducing a distributed loss term in the heat diffusion equation , we recover and thus justify the lorentzian response function that has been used in many previous works @xcite .
we then show that , for fixed boundary conditions , changing the geometry of the photon fluid , e.g. by using a highly elliptical rather than circular beam , enables us to control and reduce the effective nonlocal interaction length by two orders of magnitude .
this choice of beam geometry has the primary effect of restoring locality to a sufficient extent so as to restore superfluid behavior .
with such an elliptical beam , we experimentally demonstrate evidence of superfluidity in nonlocal photon fluids revealed by the nucleation of quantized vortices in the wake of an extended obstacle .
+ _ photon fluids : _ although the findings of this work are general and apply to any nonlocal superfluid , we derive the main conclusions by focusing our attention on the specific case of a thermal photon fluid where the photon - photon interaction is mediated by heating induced by the local intensity of a propagating laser beam .
details of the system we are analyzing can be found in ref .
@xcite and are summarized in fig .
[ fig : fig1 ] , which shows the experimental layout used in the experiments described below .
the essential component in the system is the actual nonlinear medium , a cylindrical cell with a radius @xmath0 cm and length @xmath1 cm , filled with methanol ( whose negative thermo - optic coefficient provides the repulsive photon - photon interaction ) and a low concentration of graphene nanoflakes ( on the order of @xmath2 ) , providing a weak absorption of the input beam needed to enhance the nonlinearity .
+ we briefly recall the main features and equations describing photon fluids . the nonlinear propagation of a laser beam of electric field amplitude @xmath3 in a defocusing medium can be described within the paraxial approximation @xcite in terms of a nonlinear schrdinger equation , @xmath4 here , @xmath5 is the optical wavenumber , @xmath6 is the vacuum wavelength of the light , and @xmath7 is the linear refractive index . in the limit of negligible absorption @xmath8 , and a local interaction such that @xmath9 , with @xmath10 the negative nonlinear refractive index , eq .
is formally identical to the gross - pitaevskii equation for dilute boson gases with a repulsive interatomic interaction @xcite . by considering the propagation direction
@xmath11 as time coordinate @xmath12 , where @xmath13 is the speed of light in vacuum , and the electric field @xmath14 as a function of photon fluid density @xmath15 ( with units of @xmath16 ) and phase @xmath17 , one arrives at a set of hydrodynamic equations over transverse spatial coordinate @xmath18 that describes the laser beam as a 2 + 1-dimensional quantum fluid of light @xcite , @xmath19 the transverse gradient of the phase of the beam determines the transverse fluid flow velocity @xmath20 and the speed of long - wavelength sonic waves is given by @xmath21 . here
@xmath22 is proportional to the phase of the wave function , and by taking the transverse gradient , eq .
may be recast as the equation of motion for @xmath23 in direct analogy to the hydrodynamic euler equation for dilute - gas becs @xcite .
transverse wave perturbations propagating on an intense plane - wave beam obey the well known bogoliubov dispersion relation @xcite . @xmath24 relating frequency @xmath25 and wavenumber @xmath26 of phonon excitations . here
@xmath27 is the fourier transform of the medium response function . in the local case , @xmath28 but in the nonlocal case
@xmath29 will take on a more complicated functional form that will ultimately determine the extent of superfluid behavior observable in the photon fluid .
it is precisely the nature of this response function that we investigate in more detail in the following .
+ _ thermal , nonlocal nonlinearity : _ we now consider in detail the case of _ nonlocal _ photon - photon interactions .
the cell used in our experiments is sufficiently long and the characteristic frequency of the propagation evolution ( eq .
( [ eq : nlse ] ) ) is sufficiently slow that we may neglect any variations of the heat diffusion profile along @xmath11 . under these assumptions , the nonlocal change in the refractive index @xmath30 , at a given propagation plane along @xmath11 , can then be found by convolving the material response function @xmath31 with the source beam intensity profile @xmath32 on that plane .
we assume a beam that occupies the central region of the fluid , far from the system s physical boundaries , so that the system is approximately shift - invariant with @xmath33 with the constant @xmath34 accounting for the properties of the material , and @xmath35 . for a thermal nonlinearity such as that provided by the methanol - graphene system , the temperature dependent change in the index of refraction is @xmath36 where @xmath37 .
the spatial profile of @xmath38 is then determined by the 2d steady - state heat equation , @xmath39 where @xmath40 is the thermal conductivity . +
thus the response function is , to within a constant , the green s function for heat diffusion in the medium , and obeys @xmath41 we can find a numerical solution for @xmath31 by using a narrow gaussian source beam @xmath42 to approximate the delta function , and then numerically solving eq .
with the condition @xmath43 for @xmath44 .
our choice of boundary condition assumes that , due to efficient heat transport to the surrounding environment at the boundaries , there is no change in temperature at the boundary itself .
+ that determines the flow of the photon fluid [ inset ( a ) ] .
inset ( b ) shows the measured nonlocal dispersion relation of the photon fluid from ref .
@xcite .
solid red line - bogoliubov dispersion relation , eq .
( [ eq : bogodr_nl ] ) with a local nonlinearity @xmath45 .
solid blue line - nonlocal dispersion relation with @xmath46^{-1}$ ] , and @xmath47 @xmath48 and @xmath49 determined from the best fit to the experimental data ( black circles ) . , scaledwidth=48.0% ] alternatively , we can approximate the effect of the boundary by incorporating a distributed loss term @xmath50 into the steady - state heat equation , @xmath51 with the addition of this distributed loss term we obtain a lorentzian @xmath52-space response function , @xmath53 where the nonlocal length @xmath54 is fixed by the system boundary and determines the spatial - frequency cutoff of the response function . in @xmath52-space
the nonlocal change in the index of refraction is @xmath55 , with @xmath56 the effective nonlinear coefficient .
the response function defined in eq
. , which we derive from the distributed loss model ( dlm ) , has been taken as an a priori assumption in previous works @xcite .
the dlm solution proves to be a valid analytical approximation to the exact numerical solution of eq . .
indeed , the corresponding dlm real - space response function @xmath57 where @xmath18 and @xmath58 is the zeroth - order modified bessel function of the second kind , is shown in fig . to provide quantitative agreement with the numerical solution to the heat equation assuming a narrow gaussian source beam . in the same figure
we also show the measured @xmath59 ( red curve ) , obtained using an interferometric method similar to that used by minovich _
et al .
_ @xcite .
summarizing this first result , the experimental measurement of the response function indicates that the dlm provides a good approximation to both the measured @xmath60 and to the exact numerical solution to eq . .
+ we next turn to the analytical dlm solution to describe how the beam or fluid geometry may be used to control the nonlocal interaction length . we first point out that for a medium with physical boundaries , as in the experiments described below and in ref .
@xcite , a cylindrically symmetric beam with @xmath61 beam radii @xmath62 implies superfluid behavior only for very low wavevectors such that @xmath63 where the response function approaches a local response @xmath64 .
however , accessing these wavevectors is experimentally unrealistic as it requires observation and measurement of waves in the transverse plane of the beam that have a wavelength that is of the order of the size of the medium itself .
+ however , the situation is more interesting in the case of an elliptical beam geometry with @xmath65 .
the focused beam radius @xmath66 leads to a temperature distribution whose width scales with @xmath67 along the @xmath68-axis .
this focusing along the @xmath68-axis also leads to enhanced thermal diffusion away from the major axis of the beam aligned with the @xmath69-axis , as may be seen by applying the approximation @xmath70 in eq . .
within this approximation we may use an effective one - dimensional heat equation , resulting in an effective 1d response function @xmath71 with the introduction of an effective nonlocal length , @xmath72 .
the key point here is that focusing along the @xmath68-axis decreases the length scale for thermal diffusion to @xmath73 along both major and minor beam axes .
thus our elliptical geometry can lead to superfluid behavior for the range @xmath74 , which is now experimentally accessible .
a circular beam with @xmath75 may seem an option , but is impractical from an experimental standpoint since the spatial extent of the fluid would then be too small to observe superfluid behavior such as vortex nucleation in the flow past an obstacle . + .
red curve : experimental measurement using a methanol - graphene medium with @xmath76 cm , @xmath77 cm , @xmath78 , similar to that used in the experiments in fig .
[ fig : flowobstacle ] . dashed blue curve : the numerical solution to eq . with a physical circular boundary at @xmath77 cm .
black curve : the analytical solution from the dlm model with @xmath79 cm .
all curves are normalized to one.,width=264 ] we arrive at an alternative view of the effective geometry - induced tailoring of the medium response by considering the spatial extent of the focused spot size @xmath67 and the associated @xmath68-component of the wavevector @xmath80 , where @xmath81 is largest wavelength oscillation supported by the spatial extent of the minor axis of the elliptical photon fluid , such that @xmath82 .
we may then determine the @xmath52-space response function by first numerically solving the full 2d heat equation and taking the fourier transform to obtain @xmath83 .
we found that either integrating the response function over all @xmath84 or simply taking @xmath85 gives similar functions . in the latter case , the dlm response function may again be rewritten as @xmath71 , and together with eq .
provides good agreement with the dispersion relation reported in ref .
@xcite ( see fig . [
fig : fig1 ] ) .
therefore , the dlm approach explicitly indicates that the highly elliptical geometry of the beam leads to an effective 1d response function with a nonlocal length , which in the limit @xmath86 loses all trace of the physical boundary conditions and is essentially determined solely by the beam or fluid geometry , @xmath73 .
this provides a clear route to re - establishing and controlling the onset of superfluid behavior in an otherwise highly nonlocal and non - superfluid medium .
+ _ superfluidity and vortices : _ in order to verify our findings we performed a series of experiments and numerical simulations with both round and highly elliptical pump beams , aimed at observing a characteristic trait of superfluid flow , namely quantized vortex nucleation in supercritical flows around an obstacle .
we first briefly describe the characteristics of quantized vortices in superfluids .
the physics of quantized vortices has been of great interest ever since their discovery in @xmath87he @xcite and later in becs @xcite , and their inherent dynamics are intensively studied in quantum turbulence @xcite .
unfortunately , due to the relatively short coherence length in @xmath87he , the vortex core diameter is of the order of a few ngstrms and is hard to visualize by optical means , although progress has been made using hydrogen tracer particles @xcite .
in contrast , in becs and photon fluids , the diluteness of the fluid leads to larger healing lengths , with vortex core diameters on the order of half a micron and tens of microns respectively , allowing for direct observation @xcite .
furthermore , in photon fluids straightforward optical interferometry provides easy access to phase information and thus photon fluids provide an accessible platform to study quantized vortex dynamics , where core position , circulation and winding number can be easily identified . + _ experiments : _ the experimental setup is shown in fig . [
fig : fig1 ] .
we launch a highly elliptical continuous - wave laser beam with wavelength @xmath88 nm through a cylindrical cell with length @xmath89 cm and radius @xmath77 cm , filled with a methanol - graphene solution as a thermal nonlinear medium . as shown in inset ( a ) of fig .
[ fig : fig1 ] , the beam propagates along @xmath11 , with its minor axis oriented along @xmath68 .
methanol has a negative thermo - optic coefficient of @xmath90 1/k ( providing the repulsive photon - photon interaction ) and thermal conductivity @xmath91 w/(m@xmath92k ) , while nanometric graphene flakes ( on the order of 1.6 mg of graphene in the 60 @xmath93 volume of methanol ) are added in order to increase the absorption coefficient to @xmath94 @xmath95 and ensure sufficient thermo - optic nonlinearity at the input intensities ( of the order 4 - 7 w/@xmath96 ) used in the experiments .
the beam is loosely focused onto the sample by a set of cylindrical lenses with a minor axis @xmath61 beam radius of @xmath97 m ( the major axis radius is @xmath98 cm ) .
the sample is placed in one arm of a mach - zehnder interferometer .
the other arm is used to probe the spatial phase profile of the sample output plane with a reference beam . to this end ,
a piezo - controlled delay stage is introduced in order to retrieve the full phase information by a phase - shifting interferometry technique @xcite .
finally , the intensity profile of the beam at the cell output is imaged with 4x magnification onto a ccd camera . as an obstacle ,
a knife blade is immersed in the sample along the beam path [ see inset ( a ) , fig . [
fig : fig1 ] ] so that the beam propagation axis is at a slight angle @xmath99 with respect to the knife axis , thus introducing a relative transverse flow @xmath100 along the @xmath69-axis , determined by the respective angle @xmath99 . + for excitations with wavenumbers smaller than the inverse of the effective nonlocal length @xmath101 the dispersion is a linear function in @xmath52 ( @xmath102 . using the parameters and the technique described in ref .
@xcite , we measured the @xmath103 spectrum of elementary excitations and indeed show that these follow the bogoliubov dispersion with an effective 1d nonlocal length , @xmath104 m and @xmath105 determined from the best fit to the experimental data [ see fig .
[ fig : fig1](b ) ] .
hence there exists a critical velocity @xmath106 for which a fluid with flow speed @xmath107 behaves as a superfluid and is not perturbed by small defects inserted in the flow . for local fluids ,
the critical velocity is determined by the speed of sound . however , as discussed in the appendix , the nonlocality can significantly reduce the critical velocity . for our experimental parameters ,
this reduction amounts to approximately a factor of two .
furthermore , in this work we consider an extended impenetrable obstacle such that the local flow speed can become supercritical in its vicinity , even if the asymptotic speed @xmath108 far from the obstacle remains subcritical .
+ the breakdown of superfluidity leads to dissipation and drag forces on the obstacle and consequently , the nucleation of quantized vortices is expected to appear in the local interaction case @xcite .
figure [ fig : flowobstacle ] shows experimental evidence in our _ nonlocal _ superfluid of the breakdown of the viscousless flow and subsequent nucleation of quantized vortices , which are considered to be hallmark evidence of superfluid behavior . in detail , figs .
[ fig : flowobstacle](a ) and ( b ) show the normalized near - field intensity profile at the sample output @xmath109 for two different input intensities @xmath110 w/@xmath96 and @xmath111 w/@xmath96 , respectively ( corresponding to two different sound speeds , @xmath112 and @xmath113 ) and with @xmath99 chosen to create a flow speed @xmath114 m / s along the positive @xmath69-axis . , normalized by input beam intensity @xmath115 .
( a ) and ( b ) @xmath109 showing superfluid instability at high flow speed , @xmath116 m / s : ( a ) @xmath110 w/@xmath96 , i.e. , @xmath117 and @xmath118 , and ( b ) @xmath111 w/@xmath96 , i.e. , @xmath119 and @xmath120 .
white circles indicate the position of the vortex singularities obtained from the corresponding phase diagrams shown in ( c ) and ( d ) , respectively .
, scaledwidth=48.0% ] the intensity profiles show how the rigid obstacle creates a wake in the downstream region , but just as in an ordinary fluid , the light intensity is able to flow around the tip of the obstacle and fill in the shadowed region .
a series of vortices ( dark regions in the intensity profile , marked with white dots ) are seen to nucleate from close to the tip .
one vortex is observed for @xmath112 and a second vortex is formed for higher excitation ( i.e. sound ) speeds , @xmath113 .
this interpretation finds confirmation in the phase profiles shown in figs .
[ fig : flowobstacle](c ) and ( d ) where the drag on the obstacle is visualized by the bending of the phase pattern around the tip of the obstacle .
the nucleation of vortices in the wake of the obstacle is evidenced by the clockwise - circulating phase singularities .
we note that increasing the light intensity , and therefore the magnitude of @xmath121 , both increases the speed of sound of the fluid ( decreasing @xmath122 ) , and also speeds up the effective temporal " evolution of the fluid , such that within certain limits increasing @xmath123 will have the same effect as increasing the propagation length .
the observation of two vortices in fig .
[ fig : flowobstacle](d ) is therefore due to the faster sound speed , i.e. faster overall evolution ( rather than to an increase in flow speed ) . + beam radius : ( a ) intensity profile at the output of the nonlinear medium , zoomed in around the obstacle tip .
the inset shows the full beam profile .
( b ) phase profile for the circular beam ( wrapped between @xmath124 and @xmath125 .
the smoothness and absence of singularities indicate a complete absence of vortex nucleation around the obstacle
. elliptical input pump beam ( @xmath126 mm , @xmath127 mm ) : ( c ) intensity profile with a white circle indicating the position of a vortex nucleated from the obstacle , and ( d ) the phase profile . a clear phase singularity can be observed confirming the presence of the vortex .
simulations in ( a)-(b ) and ( c)-(d ) are performed under identical conditions , aside from the input beam profile , with input intensity @xmath128 w/@xmath96 , propagation length @xmath1 cm , fluid flow speed @xmath129 m / s , and nonlocal interaction length @xmath130 cm.,scaledwidth=48.0% ] _ numerical simulations : _ in order to investigate these observations of vortex nucleation in more depth , we performed numerical simulations that were based on split - step propagation of eq . , with @xmath131 chosen to match the experiment .
nonlocality is described by the dlm 2d lorentzian response function @xmath83 with @xmath130 cm .
the dimensions and shape of the obstacle were chosen so as to match the experiments . as can be seen in figs .
[ numerics](a)-(b ) ( normalized intensity and phase , respectively ) , when using a round beam no particular features are observed in the flow around the obstacle .
however , figs .
[ numerics](c)-(d ) show the results for the exact same simulation parameters ( in particular , for the same intensity @xmath128 w/@xmath96 ) for an elliptical beam with minor axis @xmath132 @xmath133 m , and vortex nucleation is clearly observed close to the tip of the obstacle .
these numerical results are in good agreement with our experiments and show how by simply controlling the geometry of the beam , or more generally the geometry of the fluid , one may tune the effective nonlocal interaction length @xmath134 and hence re - establish and control superfluid behavior in nonlocal fluids .
+ radii , @xmath135 and @xmath136 , normalized to the local healing length @xmath137 , versus @xmath138 .
the inset , corresponding to the white region in ( e ) , shows a vortex core with labeled major axis @xmath135 and minor axis @xmath136 .
( b ) normalized beam intensity , @xmath109 , ( c ) phase @xmath139 and ( d ) nonlinear potential , @xmath140 , for a purely local superfluid after 20 cm of propagation , with @xmath141 , @xmath142 , and @xmath61 beam radii @xmath143 = 1 mm .
( e ) , ( f ) and ( g ) show the corresponding profiles for a nonlocal superfluid with @xmath144 @xmath133 m , and @xmath145 .
, scaledwidth=48.0% ] as a side note , the vortices nucleated in the presence of nonlocality have an elliptical shape that is observed both in the experiments and numerical simulations described above . in fig .
[ fig : sims2](a ) we plot the vortex core @xmath61 radii @xmath135 , @xmath136 ( normalized to a local healing length @xmath146 so as to account for any local variation in the fluid density associated with the output beam intensity ) as a function of increasing nonlocality , @xmath138 . for each value of the 2d nonlocal interaction length @xmath138 ,
the input power is chosen such that we observe one clearly defined vortex core , and flow speed is adjusted to maintain a constant @xmath141 . at @xmath147 m ( purely local response ) the vortex cores are circular . however , as we increase @xmath138 , we observe a continuous increase in the core aspect ratio , @xmath148 .
figures [ fig : sims2](b)-(d ) show the normalized intensity @xmath109 , phase @xmath139 and effective nonlinear potential energy @xmath140 profiles , respectively , for a purely local superfluid after 20 cm of propagation . as can be seen in fig .
[ fig : sims2](b ) , the nucleated vortices have the expected circular central core region , which is reflected in the effective nonlinear potential energy profile shown in fig .
[ fig : sims2](d ) . figures [ fig : sims2](e)-(g ) show the corresponding profiles for @xmath149 m , taken as a representative example from the points shown in fig .
[ fig : sims2](a ) .
the vortices are now clearly elliptical : in particular , fig . [
fig : sims2](g ) shows a marked deformation of the effective nonlinear potential energy term so that the spatial extent of the knife blade felt by any point in the fluid is much larger when compared to the local case .
we may thus interpret the vortex deformation in terms of a nonlocal smearing of the nonlinear potential along the obstacle edge .
+ large nonlocal interaction lengths will strongly suppress superfluid behavior , effectively removing the photon - photon ( or particle - particle ) interactions that are at the origin of the linear superfluid dispersion relation .
however , by controlling the geometry of the beam or fluid , it is possible to limit the effective nonlocal interaction length and thus re - establish superfluid behavior . a distributed loss model for heat flow can quantitatively justify this effect and explain how we reduced the effective nonlocal length by two orders of magnitude in our experiments .
both experiments and numerical simulations with elliptical beams demonstrate the nucleation of quantized vortices from an extended hard obstacle in a flowing photon fluid , which is considered to be the hallmark trait of superfluid behavior .
+ although it was necessary to consider the full details of our specific system in order to unveil the role of the fluid geometry , the general conclusions reach beyond thermal photon fluids and apply to any nonlocal superfluid , or , for that matter , to any form of nonlocal interaction .
the photon superfluids specifically described here are of relevance in relation to recent proposals for studying horizon and hawking - like emission in artificial spacetime geometries that mimic lorentz - invariance based on the superfluid dispersion relation @xcite , or for cases in which it is the nonlocality itself that is used to mimic long - range gravitational effects @xcite .
thermal photon fluids may also provide an alternative testbed for nonlocal effects observed in dipolar becs @xcite . |
globular clusters ( gcs ) are remarkable stellar systems where a variety of compact objects may form and evolve .
numerous millisecond pulsars ( msps ) inhabit gcs as revealed by radio observations ( lyne 1996 ) , e.g. 11 msps in 47 tuc ( robinson et al . 1995 ) . in the x - ray band ,
the number of bright sources ( @xmath8 kev ) per unit stellar mass is two orders of magnitude larger for gcs than for the remainder of the galaxy ( clark 1975 ) .
persistent x - ray sources in gcs divide into two luminosity groups : one with low luminosities ( @xmath9 erg s@xmath4 , @xmath10 kev ) , and the other with high luminosities ( @xmath11 erg s@xmath4 ) ( hertz and grindlay 1983 , hertz and wood 1985 , verbunt et al .
the nature of the low luminosity , dim x - ray sources ( dxss ) has been controversial ( for reviews see bailyn 1995 , verbunt et al .
1994 , grindlay 1993b , hut et al .
suggestions for their origin include cataclysmic variables , with mass accreting onto a white dwarf ( grindlay 1993a ) , low mass x - ray binaries ( lmxbs ) with accretion at quiescent levels onto a neutron star ( ns ) or black hole ( bh ) ( verbunt , van paradijs and elson 1984 ) , plerionic msp binaries ( tavani 1991 ) or chance superpositions of foreground / background objects ( margon and bolte 1987 ) .
we have employed the batse instrument on board the compton gamma - ray observatory to search for transient and persistent hard x - ray emission ( @xmath12 kev ) .
hard x - rays may be produced by gc compact objects in a number of ways . in a binary
, hard x - ray emission can be powered by mass accretion onto the bh / ns primary , or in pulsars , from shock interactions in the relativistic pulsar winds in the binary .
hard x - ray emission may also be produced by magnetospheric emission of isolated msps .
transient emission has been observed previously from gcs .
ngc 6440 , a gc containing dxss , has exhibited a high luminosity transient episode ( forman , jones and tananbaum 1976 ) .
m15 may also have shown a transient event ( pye and mchardy 1983 ) . in the hard x - ray band ,
sigma has observed transient emission from the globular cluster terzan 2 .
recent rosat hri observations indicate that the sigma source is most likely associated with the x - ray burster xb 1724 - 30 ( mereghetti et al .
slx 1732 - 304 in the gc terzan 1 has also been detected as a hard x - ray source ( churazov et al .
our search does not include terzan 2 , terzan 1 or ngc 6440 due to problems with nearby interfering sources .
we have been able to observe m15 however . in section 2 , we describe hard x - ray emission mechanisms in detail .
section 3 outlines the batse earth occultation flux measurement technique and the parameters of our search . in sections 4 and 5
we present the results of our search , providing upper limits on transient events and constraints on the recurrence times of transients from dxss .
section 6 contains upper limits on persistent emission and constraints on the number of isolated and interacting msps .
section 7 is a summary and conclusion .
soft x - ray transients ( sxts ) have exhibited emission in excess of 10 kev ( e.g. white , kaluzienski and swank 1984 ) .
these hard power law tails along with an anticorrelation of intensity and spectral hardness have been taken as indications of a bh primary ( tanaka 1989 , tanaka and lewin 1995 ) .
originally , the discovery of x - ray sources in gcs was interpreted as a possible manifestation of massive accreting bhs ( e.g. , bahcall and ostriker 1975 ) . we know today that
_ all _ bright x - ray sources in gcs show x - ray bursts , and therefore most likely contain neutron stars . though it is unlikely that clusters contain very massive black holes , they may harbor a population of stellar mass black holes
kulkarni , hut and mcmillan ( 1993 ) estimate that there may be @xmath13 systems in galactic gcs in which a bh of mass @xmath13m@xmath14 has captured a companion . in a few of these systems
the companion may have had time to evolve off the main sequence , producing an active x - ray binary .
hard x - ray activity from such systems would be observable in our search .
lmxbs that contain ns primaries and accrete with luminosities below some critical value also exhibit transient episodes of hard x - ray emission ( e.g. barret and vedrenne 1994 ) and an anticorrelation of spectral hardness and intensity , e.g. : 4u0614 + 091 ( barret and grindlay 1995a ) , 4u1608 - 522 ( mitsuda et al . 1989 ) . &
( kpc ) & ( erg s@xmath4 ) & + aql x-1 & 2.5 & @xmath15 & batse ( @xmath0 kev ) + cen x-4 & 1.2 & @xmath16 & signe 2mp ( @xmath17 kev ) + xb 1724 - 308 ( ter 2 ) & 14.0 & @xmath18 & sigma ( @xmath19 kev ) + ks1731 - 260 & 8.5 & @xmath18 & sigma + 4u1608 - 522 & 3.6 & @xmath20 & batse + a1742 - 294 & 8.5 & @xmath20 & sigma + table [ table : hardx ] lists the observed hard x - ray properties of several transient and persistent lmxbs .
all of these sources have been observed as type - i x - ray bursters which indicate ns primaries .
the hard x - ray outbursts generally exceed @xmath21 erg s@xmath4 , with emission extending above 100 kev .
the time scales for the hard x - ray outbursts are typically @xmath22 days .
such events would be easily detectable in our search .
additional bursters are being detected as hard x - ray sources in a batse monitoring program ( barret et al .
1996 ) .
persistent hard x - ray emission may also be produced by msps , and the fact that gcs contain large numbers of msps makes them ideal systems in which to search for such emission ( chen 1991 , tavani 1993b ) .
recent theoretical work has shown that hard x - ray and gamma ray emission may be produced by msps either in isolation ( chen , middleditch and ruderman 1993 ) or in interacting binaries ( tavani 1993a ) .
isolated msps could produce hard x - ray emission by the same mechanism operating in young crab - like pulsars
. though the magnetic fields are smaller in recycled pulsars , the voltage drop at the light cylinder may be similar due to the smaller rotation periods ( ruderman and cheng 1988 ) . in binary systems , msps may emit hard x - rays by interaction with a companion ( tavani 1991 ) .
this is in analogy to psr b1957 + 20 in which the pulsar is evaporating its companion ( e.g. kluzniak et al . 1988 ) . in such systems
the pulsar is partly or fully buried in a gaseous envelope originating from its companion .
the interaction of the msp wind with the surrounding material produces energetic emission by synchrotron radiation or inverse compton scattering of shock accelerated particles .
emission , which can be explained by this model , has recently been observed in the @xmath23 kev range from the binary pulsar psr 1259 - 63 near periastron ( grove et al .
1995 , tavani et al .
the batse instrument was designed to provide continuous coverage of the entire sky in the hard x - ray / gamma - ray band from @xmath24 kev @xmath25 2 mev ( harmon et al .
1992 ) , and has an optimal sensitivity in the range @xmath0 kev for a source with a typical photon index of 2 .
source fluxes are measured by batse using the earth as an occulting object .
as a source rises or sets , steps appears in the detector count rates due to attenuation by the earth s atmosphere .
source fluxes are determined by fitting the amplitude of these steps .
thus , depending on the geometry of the earth s rising and setting limbs , one can make two source measurements per gro orbit ( approximately 90 min . ) , and from these construct a light curve .
fluxes in the resulting light curve , for a location in the sky with no sources , form a distribution about a mean flux of zero . both positive and negative
fluxes are produced in the occultation edge fits , all with formal error estimates .
the distribution of flux estimates has a width which is larger than expected for a poisson distribution of background rates .
this is due to systematic effects , such as contributions in the occultation fits from nearby sources and spurious background fluctuations . the main limitation of the occultation technique is source confusion due to the large angular extent of the earth s occulting limbs .
there are several diagnostics that can be employed to identify confused sources .
one such check is to compare the measured relative rates in separate detectors to the rates expected given the batse detector responses ( pendleton et al .
another technique is to compare the rates from the rising limb to those from the setting limb . for constant flux from the expected source ,
the rising and setting edges should give the same rates .
the precession of the earth s limb can also be used to localize the emission , a technique that has been successfully employed to create images of sky regions for brighter , long duration events ( zhang et al .
1993 ) .
we divide our search of 27 gcs into two parts , which we will refer to as search a and search b ( see figure [ fig : proj_full ] ) .
search a is a lower sensitivity search of 23 gcs which are at larger distances and/or in regions of the sky prone to source confusion .
search a includes gcs at distances @xmath26 kpc , gcs near the galactic center , gcs containing no known dxss , and gcs known to contain bright lmxbs .
search b is a higher sensitivity search of four nearby gcs which are not subject to serious source confusion problems .
we limit this search to gcs at @xmath26 kpc which also contain dxss near the cluster core .
we also exclude clusters within 15@xmath27 of the galactic center , to avoid source confusion in this dense area .
the gcs of search b are shown in figure [ fig : proj ] ( circled ) . in
what follows , all cluster parameters have been taken from peterson ( 1993 ) .
@xmath28 & @xmath29 & coverage & persistent + & ( kpc ) & ( cnt s@xmath4 ) & ( @xmath30 @xmath31s@xmath32 & ( erg s@xmath4 ) & ( % ) & x - ray + & & & [ @xmath33 & [ @xmath34 & & source(s ) + m4 & 2.0 & 3.5 & 2.8 & 0.9 & 80.0 & + ngc6544 & 2.5 & 4.0 & 3.2 & 1.7 & 77.1 & + ngc6656 & 3.0 & 2.6 & 2.1 & 1.6 & 82.4 & dim + ngc6838 & 3.9 & 4.0 & 3.2 & 4.0 & 80.5 & + ngc6539 & 4.0 & 4.4 & 3.5 & 4.7 & 70.9 & + ngc6366 & 4.0 & 6.5 & 5.2 & 6.9 & 74.9 & + ngc6760 & 4.2 & 6.3 & 5.0 & 7.2 & 38.7 & + ngc6254 & 4.3 & 3.3 & 2.6 & 4.0 & 74.3 & + ngc6809 & 4.8 & 4.5 & 3.6 & 6.8 & 72.3 & + ngc3201 & 5.0 & 7.0 & 5.6 & 11.6 & 77.6 & + ngc4372 & 5.2 & 4.0 & 3.2 & 7.2 & 69.8 & + ngc6218 & 5.6 & 3.8 & 3.0 & 7.8 & 74.5 & + ngc4833 & 5.8 & 2.9 & 2.3 & 6.4 & 69.0 & + ngc6626 & 5.9 & 4.0 & 3.2 & 9.2 & 79.4 & dim + ngc6541 & 6.6 & 3.3 & 2.6 & 9.3 & 73.3 & dim + ngc6712 & 6.8 & 4.4 & 3.5 & 13.4 & 72.9 & bright + ngc7099 & 7.4 & 3.0 & 2.4 & 10.9 & 88.4 & dim + ngc6341 & 7.5 & 3.5 & 2.8 & 13.0 & 85.7 & dim + ngc6624 & 8.1 & 3.5 & 2.8 & 15.2 & 84.2 & bright + ngc5272 & 10.1 & 2.4 & 1.9 & 16.0 & 88.0 & dim + m15 & 10.5 & 3.5 & 2.8 & 25.5 & 87.6 & bright + ngc1851 & 12.2 & 4.5 & 3.6 & 44.3 & 88.1 & bright + ngc1904 & 13.0 & 3.1 & 2.5 & 34.9 & 88.1 & dim + we have generated light curves for all the clusters extending from april 1991 to march 1995 ( @xmath11400 days ) . for search
a , we have analyzed the rate history of each cluster for events with structure on a time scale of one or more days .
generally in each light curve there are several events " apparent ; most of these can be attributed to interference from nearby bright sources .
there are , however , a few spikes that can not readily be explained as interfering sources .
none of these events are particularly outstanding in terms of amplitude or structure . for search b
we have further analyzed such events to determine if they originate from the clusters , as described below .
for the 23 clusters in search a , however , such an analysis is impractical . for search a , therefore , we take the largest of the outstanding features to set conservative upper limits to the minimum observable event amplitude ( table [ table : roughlimits ] ) .
we initially find count rate upper limits ( @xmath35 in table [ table : roughlimits ] ) .
to convert these limits to photon fluxes , we have multiplied by a constant conversion factor determined from other light curves for which we have properly deconvolved the instrument response with an assumed photon index of 2.0 to generate photon flux histories .
this conversion is accurate to within approximately @xmath36 . from the photon rate , we calculate a luminosity upper limit by assuming power law spectra with index 2 .
the effective time coverage for each cluster is shown in table [ table : roughlimits ] .
coverage with batse is less than @xmath37 and varies as a function of sky position due to the geometry of the earth s occulting limbs and due to interfering sources .
when target occultations occur within 10 seconds of the occultation of a bright interfering source , no edge fits are produced .
this leads to data gaps , as in the case of ngc 6760 , which has highly non - uniform coverage due to the nearby source aql x-1 .
note that we obtain a limit of @xmath38 erg s@xmath4 for ngc 5272 ( m3 ) which is known to contain a time variable supersoft x - ray source .
note also that the cluster ngc 6440 has been excluded from our search due to nearby interfering sources .
for search b , we have produced rate histories over the time period mentioned above and properly deconvolved the detector response to obtain photon light curves .
we have searched these light curves for outburst events .
candidate events are identified as features of duration one or more days which rise at least @xmath39 above the background flux distribution . with this criterion
we have identified 40 possible candidate events .
we analyzed each of these isolated events further to determine if they originate from the clusters .
we check for nearby interfering sources and compare the relative rates in the detectors .
this analysis eliminates all but 13 of the events as candidates .
these 13 candidates consist of peak - like structures with durations of 1 to 8 days .
the significance of these events , as measured from the photon flux error bars near the peaks , ranges from @xmath7 to @xmath40 .
the maximum luminosities in these candidate events would range from @xmath41 erg s@xmath4 , and in one case @xmath42 erg s@xmath4 ( @xmath0 kev ) .
these luminosities are similar to the expected transient peak luminosities ( c.f .
table [ table : hardx ] ) and deserve further investigation .
we further analyze candidate events by studying the correlation between the rising and setting rates within a given gro pointing period .
figures [ fig : ngc6752cand ] and [ fig : ngc5139cand ] show example rate histories for candidate events in ngc 6752 and ngc 5139 . for each source ,
the rise and set rates clearly have different temporal behaviors . in each case
nearly all the flux is from the fits in the rising limbs .
formally we can calculate the correlation coefficient for the rising vs setting rates . as a test of this technique we have calculated the correlation coefficient for a two day data sample from the crab . the rise and set
data for the crab are well correlated with a correlation coefficient of 0.77 and a corresponding probability of @xmath43 that the observed correlation could arise from a random sample .
for the two events shown in figures [ fig : ngc6752cand ] and [ fig : ngc5139cand ] the correlation coefficients are -0.07 and -0.10 respectively , with a @xmath44 and @xmath45 probability of being random .
we have calculated the correlation coefficient for the other 11 candidate events during the relevant time intervals . for each event
the rises and sets either show very weak correlation or , in several cases , strong anticorrelation .
the most significant correlation has a @xmath46 probability of being random .
the lack of significant positive correlations imply that the events " observed in the light curves do not originate from the target sources but are due to interfering sources located elsewhere . as a check to this interpretation
we have analyzed the event in ngc 6752 shown in figure [ fig : ngc6752cand ] in more depth .
we have chosen to look further at this particular event because it is somewhat extended in time , lasting for approximately 5 days , and reaches moderate flux levels .
we have produced a map in an approximately @xmath47 region centered on ngc 6752 during the time of the candidate event .
the map is created by forming a grid of points separated by @xmath48 , and producing occultation histories for each grid point .
the resulting rates for each point can be combined together to form a map .
the map for the ngc 6752 event shows an emission enhancement well localized at @xmath49 ` northeast ' of the cluster during the first gro pointing period ( tjd @xmath50 ) .
it is also clear from the limb geometry that such an event would be visible only on the setting rates , and indeed this is what is observed in the rate history for ngc 6752 . during the second pointing period ( tjd @xmath51 )
, the emission peak moves to @xmath52 ` southwest ' of the cluster , and is well localized only in the detector with the less optimal pointing .
all of this leads us to conclude that the enhancement is not associated with the cluster . in the absence of any detected transient events , we are able to set a lower limit to the recurrence times of transient sources in the clusters of search b. for a given time interval in a gc light curve , there will be a minimum luminosity , @xmath53 , at which an event would be visible .
@xmath53 is determined by the width of the flux distribution .
we step through the cluster light curves and determine the total number of days that events of different @xmath53s would be observable .
the result is a distribution of the number of days observable vs @xmath53 ( figure [ fig : cov_all ] ) .
the @xmath53 distribution depends on the assumed duration of outburst events and the photon index used in the deconvolution .
this dependence , however , is rather weak .
the distribution depends more strongly on the time intervals into which the data are integrated .
figure [ fig : cov_int ] shows the @xmath53 distribution for different data integration times .
the minimum observable luminosities are shifted down at longer integration times due to an increased sensitivity , i.e. a smaller width in the distribution of fluxes .
@xmath54 & @xmath55 & @xmath54 & @xmath55 + & ( kpc ) & & ( years ) & ( years ) & ( years ) & ( years ) + & & & @xmath56 erg s@xmath4 & & @xmath57 erg s@xmath4 & + 47 tuc & 4.6 & 5 & 2.0 & 3.4 & 3.5 & 5.8 + ngc 5139 & 5.2 & 2 & 0.6 & 0.4 & 2.9 & 1.9 + ngc 6397 & 2.2 & 5 & 3.6 & 6.0 & 3.6 & 6.0 + ngc 6752 & 4.1 & 3 & 3.2 & 3.2 & 3.6 & 3.6 + total & & & 9.4 & 13.0 & 13.6 & 17.4 + we determine limits to the recurrence times of outbursts from the @xmath53 distribution . for each @xmath53
there is an associated observable time , @xmath54 , for which an event exceeding @xmath53 would be detectable .
@xmath54 is essentially the integral of the @xmath53 distribution .
@xmath54 is related to the mean event recurrence time , @xmath58 , by @xmath59 , where @xmath60 is the probability of observing no events in time @xmath54 assuming a poisson distribution of events .
we calculate a lower limit for @xmath58 using a 5% probability of detection . with multiple x - ray sources in each cluster ,
an event could originate from any of the sources .
the minimum event recurrence time , @xmath58 , can be stated as a minimum recurrence time for sources , if we use the number of dxss in each cluster , @xmath61 .
the minimum source recurrence time , @xmath55 , is given by @xmath62 ( table [ table : tau_limits ] ) .
we also calculate a total recurrence time for all the sources as a class using the total @xmath54 for all clusters ( which gives the total @xmath58 ) and the total @xmath61 of 15 .
figure [ fig : tau ] is plot of @xmath55 vs @xmath53 for the four clusters .
recurrence times for sources in the clusters are constrained to lie above the lines .
it is clear that with increasing event luminosity , @xmath54 increases and therefore @xmath55 increases , giving a tighter recurrence time constraint at higher luminosities .
table [ table : tau_limits ] displays recurrence time lower limits for event luminosities of @xmath56 and @xmath57 erg s@xmath4 .
the estimates of @xmath61 are taken from the literature : 47 tuc ( hasinger , johnston and verbunt 1994 ) , ngc 5139 ( @xmath63cen ) ( cool et al .
1995a ) , ngc 6397 ( cool et al . 1993 ) , and ngc 6752 ( grindlay 1993b ) . for 47 tuc
we take only the dxss within the core . for the latter three clusters we have assumed , for consistency , that sources within 5 core radii of each cluster center are associated with the gc and others
note that changing @xmath61 simply scales the numbers in table [ table : tau_limits ] and the curves in figure [ fig : tau ] .
these recurrence time limits can be compared to the several recurrent transients that have been discovered with all - sky x - ray surveys .
one such transient is aql x-1 , observed over a 7 year period with the vela 5b satellite .
it has an outburst recurrence time measured at 1.2 years ( priedhorsky and terrell 1984 ) .
another example is cen x-4 from which hard x - ray outbursts were observed in 1969 and 1979 ( kaluzienski , holt and swank 1980 , bouchacourt et al . 1984 ) , indicating that its recurrence time is approximately 10 years or less , putting it at the outer edge of our limit .
both aql x-1 and cen
x-4 have exhibited hard x - ray emission during outburst in excess of @xmath15 erg s@xmath4 ( @xmath0 kev ) ( c.f .
table [ table : hardx ] ) .
a number of other sources have also displayed recurrent outbursts : 1608 - 522 , 1630 - 472 , 1730 - 335 ( van paradijs and verbunt 1984 , chen , shrader and livio 1996 ) .
these systems have recurrence times of approximately 0.5 to a few years .
our recurrence limits indicate that transient sources with outburst luminosities greater than approximately @xmath15 erg s@xmath4 ( @xmath0 kev ) and recurrence times less than about 2 to 6 years can not constitute the population of dim gc sources in the four sampled clusters .
the recurrence time lower limit for all sources is @xmath5 years , if one is willing to consider them as a class .
this suggests that the dim sources in these clusters are not quiescent lmxbs of a type similar to aql x-1 or cen x-4 .
some caution should be taken with this interpretation .
the outburst recurrence times are determined well only for a few systems which may not be typical .
also lmxbs in gcs may have systematically different properties than the field binaries in which the hard x - ray emission and recurrent outbursts have been observed .
indeed some bright lmxbs in gcs have unusual properties , for example very short orbital periods ( bailyn 1996 ) .
one might argue that a substantial number of x - ray outbursts from aql x-1-like lmxbs might be detectable only below 20 kev .
if this were the case , such events would be not detectable by batse .
however , the recently monitored behavior of aql x-1 shows clearly that batse can usually detect hard x - ray emission at times when the optical counterpart of aql x-1 is excited .
these events are most likely associated with major x - ray outbursts ( harmon et al .
@xmath64 & @xmath65 & @xmath66 + & ( @xmath30 @xmath31s@xmath4 ) & ( erg s@xmath4 ) & & ( @xmath30 @xmath31s@xmath4 ) & + & [ @xmath67 & [ @xmath68 & & [ @xmath69 & + 47 tuc & 3.3 & 5.8 & 19 & 0.71 & 46 + ngc 5139 & 4.1 & 9.2 & 31 & 0.62 & 66 + ngc 6397 & 4.2 & 1.7 & 6 & 3.10 & 14 + ngc 6752 & 3.6 & 5.0 & 17 & 0.85 & 42 + we have searched for longer time scale persistent emission using the flux histories for the four gcs in search b. previous upper limits have been obtained only for 47 tuc .
observations with sigma spanning seven days set a limit at @xmath70 erg s@xmath4 ( @xmath71 kev ) ( barret et al . 1993 ) and an observation by the balloon - borne exite instrument found an upper limit of @xmath72 erg s@xmath4 ( @xmath73 kev ) ( grindlay et al .
upper limits have also been obtained for 47 tuc with comptel , osse and egret in their respective bands ( oflaherty et al .
1995 ) .
our batse search offers improved sensitivity as a result of the very long integration time .
we have detected no emission for the four clusters .
the upper limits are summarized in table [ table : persist_limits ] .
we have obtained these upper limits by formal error calculations integrating over large time windows . as discussed in section 3 , such a procedure yields error values systematically larger than the actual flux distribution .
we have studied this effect for the four gcs of search b and determined a correction factor of 1.6 based on fitted widths of flux distributions .
we have used the factor of 1.6 correction to the formal error estimates for the upper limit values of table [ table : persist_limits ] .
the clusters of search b were chosen to limit the systematic effects of interfering sources , a selection which permits very sensitive flux limits .
we note that the sensitivities may depend on the assumed spectral shape used in deconvolution .
we have employed power law spectra with photon index 2.0 .
using our upper limits , we constrain the number of isolated high energy emitting msps in the clusters .
the luminosity for a typical non - interacting msp can be calculated .
chen ( 1991 ) does this using the outer - gap emission model of cheng , ho and ruderman ( 1986 ) and the observed period distribution for msps .
the resulting luminosity from a cluster is a constant times the number of isolated msps , assuming isotropic emission . for a cluster with one msp
, this would yield a luminosity of approximately @xmath74 erg s@xmath4 . combining this luminosity estimate with our luminosity upper limit
, we find the maximum number of isolated msps , @xmath64 , in each of the clusters ( table [ table : persist_limits ] ) .
the estimate of @xmath64 depends on the period distribution of msps . in the luminosity calculation ,
chen ( 1991 ) , uses the period distribution of all the 28 then - known msps , fit as a falling power law .
this distribution is poorly constrained due to selection effects and small number statistics and may vary from cluster to cluster .
this adds additional uncertainty to our values of @xmath64 .
the flux from an interacting binary msp has been estimated by tavani ( 1993b ) . using this model we calculate the estimated flux from each cluster for a single interacting msp system , @xmath65 ( table [ table : persist_limits ] ) .
combined with our flux upper limits , the flux estimate yields an upper limit on the number of interacting msps , @xmath66 .
the constraints on @xmath66 are weak .
this calculation uses an average msp spin - down power of @xmath75 erg s@xmath4 ( taylor et al .
msp spin - down powers are in the range @xmath76-@xmath21 erg s@xmath4 but are still not well constrained .
we have monitored 27 galactic globular clusters ( gcs ) with batse during a period of approximately four years each .
we have detected no distinct hard x - ray outburst episodes and no persistent emission .
the lack of detected events has several interesting implications . for the gcs with dim x - ray sources ( dxss )
, we find a lower limit for the outburst recurrence time from dxss of @xmath77 years .
this limit excludes the existence of ` aql x-1-like ' objects ( i.e. , persistent x - ray sources subject to major x - ray outbursts with a time scale of @xmath78 year ) , since @xmath55 is comparable to or greater than this outburst recurrence time scale .
this suggests that the dxss in these clusters are not lmxbs similar to aql x-1 .
the lack of strong outburst events in our search means we also have no evidence of accreting bhs in gcs .
if active bh binaries exist in gcs , they would be clearly detectable with hard x - ray luminosities of order of @xmath79 erg s@xmath4 .
we have calculated upper limits on persistent hard x - ray emission from gcs .
the limiting luminosity is @xmath80 erg s@xmath4 for the closest clusters .
the limit for 47 tuc is somewhat more sensitive than previous measurements
. a model - dependent but reasonable estimate of the expected hard x - ray magnetospheric emission from isolated msps ( chen 1991 ) implies that the number of isolated msps emitting hard x - rays in 47 tuc is less than 19 . taking the observed 11 msps in 47 tuc , and a beaming factor of 2 for short period pulsars , this upper limit is comparable to actual number of msps in 47 tuc .
our results are therefore a constrain the magnetospheric model of msp hard x - ray emission .
our upper limits on persistent hard x - ray emission also provide a mild constraint on the number of interacting pulsars in binaries . the observed efficiency ( a few percent ) of conversion of pulsar spindown luminosity into hard x - ray emission in the case of the periastron passage of the be star / pulsar system psr b1259 - 63 ( tavani et al . 1996 , grove et al . 1995 ) together with the observed msp spindown average luminosity of @xmath75
erg s@xmath4 implies a limit to the gc population interacting pulsar binaries .
we find limits of @xmath81 interacting msps in the clusters studied .
we would like to acknowledge the batse instrument team for their support .
we thank jonathan grindlay , didier barret and andrew chen for helpful comments .
we thank mark stollberg for assistance with data analysis .
this work is columbia astrophysics laboratory contribution number 596 .
this work is supported in by nasa grants nag 5 - 2235 and ngt 8 - 52806 .
bahcall , j. and ostriker , j. 1975 , nature , 256 , 23 bailyn , c. 1996 , in the origins , evolution , and destinies of binary stars in clusters , eds .
milone and j.c .
mermilliod , ( asp conf . ser . ) , in press bailyn , c. 1995 , araa , 33 , 133 barret , d. and grindlay , j. 1995 , , 440 , 841 barret , d. et al .
1996 , in 3rd compton symposium , munich , in press barret , d. and vedrenne , g. 1994 , apjs , 92 , 505 barret , d. et al .
1993 , , 405 , l59 barret , d. et al .
1992 , , 394 , 615 barret , d. et al .
1991 , , 379 , l21 bouchacourt , p. et al . 1984 , , 285 , l67 chen , k. 1991 , nature , 352 , 695 chen , k. , middleditch , j. and ruderman , m. 1993 , , 408 , l17 chen , w. , shrader , c. , and livio , m. 1996 , , submitted cheng , k.s . , ho , c. , and ruderman , m. 1986 , , 300 , 500 churazov , e. , et al .
1995 , , 443 , 341 churazov , e. , et al .
1994 , adv . in space res . ,
cospar , munich , in press clark , g.w .
1975 , , 199 , l143 cool , a.m. et al .
1995a , , 438 , 719 cool , a.m. et al .
1995b , , 439 , 695 cool , a.m. et al .
1993 , , 410 , l103 forman , w. , jones , c. and tananbaum , h. 1976 , , 207 , l25 grindlay , j.e .
1993a , adv .
space res . , 13(12 ) , 597 grindlay , j. 1993b , in dynamics of globular clusters - eds . s. djorgovski and g. meylan ( asp conf .
ser . ) , 285 grindlay , j. et al .
1993c , in compton gamma - ray observatory , aip conf .
proc . 280 , eds .
m.friedlander , n.gehrels and d. macomb , ( new york : aip ) , 243 grove , j.e . , et al .
1995 , , 447 , l113 harmon , b.a .
1996 , in 3rd compton symposium , munich , in press harmon , b.a . ,
1992 , compton observatory science workshop , nasa cp 3137 , 69 hasinger , g. , johnston , h.m . , and verbunt , f. 1994 , , 288 , 466 hertz , p. and grindlay , j. 1983 , , 275 , 105 hertz , p. and wood , k.s .
1985 , , 290 , 171 hut , p. et al .
1992 , pasp , 104 , 981 kulkarni , s.r . , hut , p. and mcmillan , s. 1993 , nature , 364 , 421 kaluzienski , l.j .
, holt , s.s . , and swank , j.h .
1980 , , 241 , 779 kluzniak , w. et al . 1988 ,
nature , 334 , 225 a. lyne , 1996 , in proc .
7th m. grossmann symposium , eds .
m. kaiser , r. jantzen , ( world scientific ) , in press margon , b. and bolte , m. 1987 , , 321 , l61 mereghetti , s. et al .
1995 , , 302 , 713 mitsuda , k. et al .
1989 , pasj , 41 , 97 oflaherty , k.s .
, et al . 1995 , , 297 , l29 pendleton , g.n .
1996 , nim , in press peterson , c.j .
1993 , in structure and dynamics of globular clusters : asp conf .
50 , eds . s.g.djorgovski and g. meylan ( sanfrancisco : asp ) , 337 priedhorsky , w.c . and terrell 1984 , , 280 , 661 pye , j. and mchrady , i. 1983 , mnras , 205 , 875 robinson , c. et al .
1995 , mnras , 274 , 547 ruderman , m. and cheng , k.s .
1988 , , 335 , 306 tanaka , y. and lewin , w.h.g .
1995 in x - ray binaries , eds .
w.h.g.lewin , j.van paradijs , and e.p.j .
van den heuvel ( cambridge university press ) , 126 tanaka , y. 1989 , in proc . of the 23rd eslab symposium , vol .
1 , ed . j.hunt ( esa pub
. div . ) , 3 tavani m. , et al . , 1996 ,
a&as , in press tavani , m. 1993a , aas , 97 , 313 tavani , m. 1993b , , 407 , 135 tavani , m. 1991 , , 379 , l69 tomaney , a. , crotts , a. , and shafter , a. 1994 , baas , 181 , 73.09 taylor , j. et al . 1995 , princeton pulsar catalog van paradijs , j. and verbunt , f. 1984 , in high energy transients in astrophysics , ed . s.e .
woosley ( new york : aip ) , 49 verbunt , f. , van paradijs , j. , and elson , r. 1984 , , 210 , 899 verbunt , f. , et al .
1994 , mmsai , 65 , 249 verbunt , f. , et al .
1995 , , 300 , 732 white , n.e . ,
kaluzienski , j.l . , and swank , j.h .
1984 , in high energy transients in astrophysics , ed .
woosley ( new york : aip ) , 31 zhang , s.n .
1996 , in 3rd compton symposium , munich , in press zhang , s.n . ,
1993 , nature , 366 , 245 | we have monitored a sample of 27 nearby globular clusters in the hard x - ray band ( @xmath0 kev ) for @xmath11400 days using the batse instrument on board the compton gamma - ray observatory .
globular clusters may contain a large number of compact objects ( e.g. , pulsars or x - ray binaries containing neutron stars ) which can produce hard x - ray emission .
our search provides a sensitive ( @xmath150 mcrab ) monitor for hard x - ray transient events on time scales of @xmath2 day and a means for observing persistent hard x - ray emission .
we have discovered no transient events from any of the clusters and no persistent emission .
our observations include a sensitive search of four nearby clusters containing dim x - ray sources : 47 tucanae , ngc 5139 , ngc 6397 , and ngc 6752 .
the non - detection in these clusters implies a lower limit for the recurrence time of transients of 2 to 6 years for events with luminosities @xmath3 erg s@xmath4 ( @xmath0 kev ) and
@xmath5 years if the sources in these clusters are taken collectively .
this suggests that the dim x - ray sources in these clusters are not transients similar to aql x-1 .
we also place upper limits on the persistent emission in the range @xmath6 erg s@xmath4 ( @xmath7 , @xmath0 kev ) for these four clusters . for 47 tuc
the upper limit is more sensitive than previous measurements by a factor of 3 .
we find a model dependent upper limit of 19 isolated millisecond pulsars ( msps ) producing gamma - rays in 47 tuc , compared to the 11 observed radio msps in this cluster . |
forecasting of seasonal rainfall , especially the summer monsoon , is important to the indian economy ( @xcite ) .
seasonal forecasts of rainfall are made at the national - scale ( @xcite ) because monsoons are large scale phenomena and there is an association between all - india summer monsoon rainfall and aggregate impacts ( @xcite ) .
however rainfall is a spatially heterogeneous phenomenon , and the country may be divided into distinct homogeneous rainfall zones , based on mean rainfall ( @xcite ) .
there are also many regional differences in inter- and intra - annual variability ( @xcite ) , rainfall trends and the occurrence of extreme events ( @xcite ) .
apart from the south - west monsoon winds affecting major parts of the country and causing rainfall during the months june - september ( jjas ) , other factors play a role in monsoon rainfall [ @xcite ] .
these include the retreating monsoon rainfall on the eastern coast particularly during october and november [ @xcite ] , and the western disturbances affecting north - western parts of the country during summer months [ @xcite ]
. furthermore , orography plays an important role [ @xcite ] .
this paper studies spatial heterogeneity in interannual differences and extremes of rainfall , for both individual grid - points and all - india mean rainfall ( aimr)- the spatial mean across all grid points . such differences in variability within the aforementioned homogeneous zones have been studied by ( @xcite ) .
however the different aspects of temporal changes and variability , when clustered , can not be expected to coincide with the clusters formed on the basis of mean rainfall , as observed in @xcite . regarding prediction of annual rainfall , an important variable is the sign of year - to - year changes in rainfall . while impacts of rainfall over a season depend on the magnitude and distribution within that season , its change from the previous year is a related variable . forecasting the change in rainfall from the present year to
the next is equivalent to forecasting next year s rainfall , once the present year s rainfall is known .
the sign of this change is a binary variable , and therefore can be expected to exhibit larger spatial coherence than its magnitude . while this sign alone does not describe the full impacts of rainfall , it represents a compromise between impacts and ability to make forecasts at sub - national scales .
furthermore , the internannual change in aimr exhibits large mean reversion , and therefore the sign of this change can be predicted with reasonably high confidence .
together , this property of the sign of rainfall change at different spatial scales and their spatial coherence are worth examining . to the best of our knowledge , these properties have not been studied previously . here
we find that the sign of year - to - year changes is spatially coherent , but this has different effects from the mean rainfall field .
specifically , clusters describing frequent coincidence of the sign of year - to - year changes differ from the aforementioned clusters defining relatively homogeneous mean rainfall . therefore they must be examined directly .
similarly , it is also important to be able to make forecasts of annual extreme events at local or sub - national scales , i.e. the occurence of years with excess and deficient rainfall .
such years are often associated with floods and droughts respectively , which have very widespread impacts on people s lives and economy in india .
we find that there is spatial coherence in the occurrence of local extremes , and clusters can be identified based on such co - occurence .
the corresponding clusters tend to differ from the aforementioned clusters formed on the basis of mean rainfall ( @xcite ) .
identifying grid - level extremes and locations where these coincide with each other is a fundamentally different problem than characterizing variability of large scale patterns using , for example , empirical orthogonal functions as in @xcite .
furthermore , the former problem is not subsumed within that of characterizing spatial patterns of temporal variability , because grid - level extremes need not be correlated with a few large scale spatial patterns of rainfall .
therefore the properties of grid - level extremes and associated clusters must be examined directly .
this paper introduces a systematic approach for identifying homogeneities as well as heterogeneities in year - to - year changes in rainfall as well as annual local extremes .
homogeneities are manifested in spatial coherence , which is an important property of spatiotemporal fields generated by physical processes , and makes possible the identification of relatively homogeneous clusters .
recently , there has been substantial progress in data science and data mining , allowing for comprehensive analysis of spatiotemporal datasets ( @xcite ) and extraction of prominent patterns with respect to these homogeneities .
we objectively quantify spatial coherence , and use the results to study a number of properties of year - to - year change and annual extremes .
the results are applied to identify cases where coherence can be exploited to form significant regionalizations .
we analyze 110 years of gridded rain gauge data across india [ @xcite ] , based on concepts of spatiotemporal data mining .
heterogeneities are manifested in the property that on larger scales there are substantial differences in statistics that also lead to differences from aimr .
the overall message is threefold .
first , spatial heterogeneities are substantial , involving both inter - region differences and differences from the all - india spatial mean .
these heterogeneities must be taken into account when considering both year - to - year rainfall changes and extreme rainfall .
second , both these features involve significant spatial contiguities , and hence for both features it is possible to find homogenous spatial clusters .
third , the sign of inter - annual difference is reasonably predictable , and predictability at grid - level improves when combined with national - level prediction .
in this work we analyze observations from rain gauges , maintained by the indian meteorological department ( imd ) , and processed to a @xmath0 grid , comprising 357 spatial indices , for the period 1901 - 2011 ( @xcite ) .
monthly and annual means are considered . in case of month
- wise analysis , each data - point has form @xmath1 where @xmath2 denotes the spatial location , @xmath3 the month and @xmath4 the year . with annual means ,
each data - point has form @xmath5 . by averaging across locations ( spatial mean ) ,
we get all - india mean rainfall ( aimr ) , denoted by @xmath6 .
annual rainfall time - series @xmath7 at individual grid - locations indexed by @xmath2 , as well as aimr , exhibit considerable variability .
one property of this variability is mean reversion . in case year @xmath8 experiences more rainfall than previous year @xmath9 ,
then year @xmath10 is likely to experience less rain than year @xmath8 .
this is partly related to the tropical quasi biennial oscillation [ @xcite ] .
the change in rainfall from year to year is an important variable , and directly related to forecasting the next year s rainfall once the present year s value is known .
furthermore , since the changes occur heterogeneously and do not take the same sign uniformly over india , we identify clusters where these changes frequently coincide . for analyzing this , we define a variable called the location - wise phase as @xmath11 . for aimr ,
corresponding phase is @xmath12 . for individual locations and aimr , the time - series of phase @xmath13 and @xmath14 mostly alternates between @xmath15 and @xmath16 indicating mean reversion .
the limitation of phase as defined here is that it does not measure the magnitude of rainfall changes .
however its usefulness lies in its higher spatial coherence than changes in rainfall magnitude , as it is a binary variable , and hence amenability to forecasting . despite the large scale of monsoon systems ,
there is coherence in phase over the indian landmass .
this is partly a consequence of the discretization involved in defining phase , where only the sign of rainfall change from year - to - year is considered .
here we identify locations with high probability of having either the same or the opposite phase as that of aimr , i.e. the national phase . for each location @xmath2 , we compute the set @xmath17 , including years where local phase agrees with national phase , and denote its cardinality as @xmath18 . hence @xmath18 describes the number of years when the grid - location agrees in phase with the national phase .
the mean of @xmath18 across grid - locations is 70 , i.e. locations on average agree in 70 years ( out of 110 years of phase data ) with the national phase .
this is just one effect of the spatial coherence of phase , which therefore becomes easier to predict than the spatial pattern of rainfall .
the histogram of relative frequency , @xmath18/110 , is shown in figure 1 .
the figure also identifies locations where @xmath18 is unusually high , corresponding to frequent agreement with national phase ; and low , corresponding to frequent disagreement .
central and western india agree with the national phase with high frequency , whereas locations on the south - eastern coast frequently disagree .
locations with frequent agreement or disagreement ( with the national phase ) are where the direction of local change can be predicted with high probability based on the spatial - mean forecasts alone . to make analysis more robust to fluctuations at the grid scale , we estimate @xmath19 , the mean of @xmath20 across the 9 grid locations centered at @xmath2 , ignoring locations outside the indian landmass . the previous analysis is repeated for these so - called `` 1-hop neighborhoods '' .
the results are shown in figure 1 .
it shows similar results as the previous analysis ; however phase in this case is more spatially coherent ( figure 1 ) , with larger contiguous regions frequently having the same phase . /110 , their relative frequency of conforming with all - india mean phase across the 110 years .
( red : over 70% , green : 60 - 70% years , blue : 50 - 60% , yellow : under 50% .
b : the histogram of @xmath21/110 , in percentages .
c : same as a , but using mean of 1-hop neighbourhoods ( defined in section 3.3 ) at each location .
d : histograms corresponding to c. ] indian meteorological department ( imd ) attempts to predict indian summer monsoon rainfall ( ismr ) each year , based on various meteorological variables .
the magnitude of aimr is difficult to predict , but its phase may be easier to predict , since phase is only a binary quantity and also shows strong mean - reverting behavior due to quasi - biennial oscillation ( qbo ) . in this work , we study its predictability by exploiting only this property , without considering any remote teleconnection effects ( such as sea surface temperatures over pacific and indian oceans ) . including these
will undoubtedly improve the predictability of phase , but that is beyond the scope of this paper .
based on the dataset , we make estimates of the conditional distribution @xmath22 .
we find that @xmath23 and @xmath24 .
this shows that phase of aimr in any year can be predicted with reasonable confidence by simply considering the phase of aimr in the previous year .
next , we look at the predictability of phase at grid - level . by studying @xmath21 ,
we have already studied the probability @xmath25 , which is around 0.62 whenever @xmath26 .
we now evaluate @xmath27 for each location @xmath2 , and find that on average ( across locations ) , @xmath28 , @xmath29 .
this means that the mean - reverting property of phase is present at grid - level too , with same strength as in case of aimr .
however , the forecast of aimr can be improved based on additional variables and remote teleconnection effects , which may not be possible at the grid - level .
therefore , we study how the predictability of grid - level phase can be improved by conditioning on aimr phase .
for this , we study the quantities @xmath30 and @xmath31 . we find that in about 300 ( out of 357 in total ) locations , incorporation of national phase of the current year increases this probability i.e. @xmath32 and @xmath33 .
furthermore , in 209 locations , incorporation of national phase of the previous year increases this probability i.e. @xmath34 and @xmath35 .
thus we find that , due to the mean - reverting property , both aimr phase and grid - level phase in any year can be predicted from its previous year s value with reasonable confidence , and the predictability at grid - level increases when combined with national - level information about phase .
extreme rainfall can cause floods and droughts , with significant impacts .
imd predicts spatial mean rainfall ( aimr ) , and included in this methodology is the forecasting of extreme years with respect to seasonal mean rainfall at the national scale .
however local extremes can be even more consequential .
we consider the spatial association between local extremes , in addition to their association with aimr , because we would like to explore the extent to which the incidence of local extremes can be inferred ( and hence probabilistically forecast ) from extremes of aimr .
the long - term mean aimr across years is denoted by @xmath36 , and corresponding standard deviation by @xmath37 .
similarly , at locations @xmath2 , long - term mean rainfall across years differs by location and its mean is @xmath38 and standard deviation @xmath39 .
we examine positive and negative extremities ( pex , nex ) at different spatial scales . at the national scale ,
years of spatial positive extremity are defined as @xmath40 , and years of spatial negative extremity as @xmath41 . for location @xmath2 ,
local positive extremity years are defined in relation to location - specific statistics , comprising @xmath42 .
similarly , local negative extremity years comprise @xmath43 .
next , we define two features called locational positive and negative extremities .
each year , some locations have local pexs and others local nexs . in some years
, an unusually high number of locations simultaneously have local pexs or nexs .
these years are defined as locational positive extremity years or locational negative extremity years respectively .
these need not coincide with spatial extremity years , as they are defined differently and involve widespread occurrence of local extremes ; in contrast with large deviations in the spatial mean .
we define @xmath44 and @xmath45 as the number of locations with local pexs and nexs respectively in year @xmath8 .
respective means of these variables , across years , are @xmath46 and @xmath47 , and their standard deviations are @xmath48 and @xmath49
. then locational pex years are the set @xmath50 , while locational nex years comprise @xmath51 .
as can be expected , locational pex years turn out to have simultaneously many local pexs , because these years are defined as such , i.e. involving an unusually large number of local pexs .
but many locations also experience normal local rain , or even local nexs , during these years .
analogous behavior is seen during locational nex years .
this is a manifestation of the heterogeneity of rainfall .
the average number of locations having local pexs is : 113 during locational pex years , 47 during normal years , and 27 during locational nex years .
similar statistics are found for mean numbers of local nexs .
figure 2 illustrates the situation in 4 representative years .
locations depart in their extreme behavior from the national - scale .
some locations have local nexs during several locational pex years , or local pexs during several locational nex years .
as stated earlier , this is a manifestation of spatial heterogeneity . for this analysis
, we estimate the probability of a local pex / nex event at each location , conditioned on pex / nex events at the national scale . we define random variable @xmath52 as the `` year type '' at location @xmath2 , which can take values 1 ( normal year ) , 2 ( local pex ) , 3 ( local nex ) .
similarly we define @xmath53 as the `` year type '' for the national scale , which is either 1 ( normal year ) , 2 ( locational pex ) , or 3 ( locational nex ) .
we estimate conditional distributions @xmath54 for each @xmath2 .
these describe the conditional probability of local year type , given the year type at all - india level .
the results are illustrated in figure 3 .
only about 60 of the 357 locations have @xmath55 or @xmath56 above 0.4 .
we also observe that there are some locations where @xmath57 or @xmath58 are significant albeit small .
these results suggest that there are only few locations at the grid - scale having substantial probability of conforming in any given year to such national scale extremes , and even there the probabilities are not high .
the locations with reasonable correspondance are found to be concentrated along western , central and south - western parts of india , while those with low or negative correspondance are mostly on the eastern side .
this indicates that making consistent predictions of grid - scale extremities based on national - scale forecasts alone is not possible , because the national scale extremes do not correspond to frequent repeated incidence of grid - level extremes .
what national scale extremes entail at the local scale ( i.e. grid - level ) , if not extremes , is considered next .
we now analyze the association between the concepts defined above , namely phase and extremity .
we do this because , as discussed previously , the phase is an important variable that exhibits coherence and therefore amenable to prediction at the regional scale .
furthermore , we have already seen through conditional distributions @xmath54 , illustrated in figure 3 , that local extremities and all - india extremities are not highly correlated .
correlation between local ( i.e. grid - level ) phase and all - india phase is somewhat higher ( figure 1 ) .
we therefore would like to understand precisely what , if anything , national - scale extremities entail at local scales .
we consider correlations between local phase and all - india extremities , by estimating conditional distributions @xmath59 .
figure 4 identifies locations where @xmath60 and @xmath61 are more than 0.7 , i.e. where rainfall is likely to increase ( compared to the previous year ) in the years of all - india pex , and where it is likely to decrease in the years of all - india nex .
these locations are significant in number ( 137 and 84 respectively ) , and distributed all over the main landmass .
thus , there is a significant correlation between all - india extremities and local phase .
this property implies that forecasts of strong positive or negative extremities , at the national scale , might be utilized for high probability forecasts of phase in many regions .
hence , although local forecasts of extremities are difficult , corresponding forecast of phase is more feasible ; and furthermore , as described below , the probability of correct forecasts increases during years having spatial - mean extremes , when the conditional probabilities of the corresponding phase at the grid - level are higher .
we have already explored the relation between grid - level phase @xmath13 and spatial - mean phase @xmath14 through the conditional probabilities @xmath25 .
we now examine the quantity @xmath62 , i.e. whether the relation between national and local phase is stronger during years with extremes in the spatial - mean rainfall .
it turns out that for all 357 locations , @xmath63 and @xmath64 .
this means that in spatial - mean extreme years , all locations are more likely to follow the spatial - mean phase than in normal years .
averaged across all locations , the probability of conforming to the spatial - mean phase is about 0.66 in both spatial - mean pex and nex years , and about 0.62 otherwise .
geophysical phenomena are spatially coherent , with generally higher correlations at smaller distance .
spatial coherence is not merely another property of the dataset but also helps point the way towards the possibility of forecasting as well as methods for doing so .
specifically where a variable is more coherent , it indicates the possibility of forecasting using less information , and forecasts can be made for several locations simultaneously .
therefore we consider spatial coherence of local extremities and local phase by answering the following questions : 1 .
are adjacent locations likely to be in the same phase every year ? 2 .
is the agreement or disagreement of the phase at grid - level with the spatial - mean phase spatially coherent ?
3 . if a location has a local extremity ( pex / nex ) in any year , are its neighbors more likely to have the same extremity in that year ?
does coherence of local extremities increase during national - level extremities ?
understanding such properties helps us develop a conceptual basis for clustering of phase and extremes , which is described in the following section . to answer these quantitatively , we define two measures of spatial coherence with respect to any property @xmath65 : 1 . for locations having property @xmath65 ,
the mean number of 1-hop neighbors ( mnn ) , with 1-hop neighborhood defined in section 3.3 , also having @xmath65 2 .
mean connected component size ( mccs ) of a graph where each vertex represents a grid location , and two vertices are joined by an edge if and only if they are 1-hop neighbors on the grid and both have property @xmath65 .
these two measures elicit different but complementary aspects of coherence .
the mnn describes only the mean properties of the isotropic 1-hop neighbourhoods , whereas the mccs considers coherence over more general anisotropic domains .
the conclusions from applying these two measures could differ , but we use them in conjunction to evaluate the following properties : being in positive phase in a year ( pp ) , being in negative phase in a year ( np ) , agreement with all - india phase in a year ( ap ) , disagreement with all - india phase in a year ( dp ) , having a local nex in a year ( ln ) , having a local pex in a year ( lp ) , having a local nex in a year of spatial / locational pex / nex ( ln - sp , ln - sn , ln - ln , ln - lp ) and having a local pex in a year of spatial / locational pex / nex ( lp - sp , lp - sn , lp - ln , lp - lp ) .
these properties are evaluated for each location , and both the measures of spatial coherence ( mnn and mccs ) introduced above are calculated for each property .
results are shown in table 1 .
[ tab : tab1 ] .spatial coherence for the different properties introduced in section 5 [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the main messages emerging from results in table 1 are : 1 .
local phase is spatially coherent , because mean number of neighbors for properties pp and np ( being in positive and negative phase respectively ) are about 5 ( which is about 60% of the neighborhood size of 8) .
therefore if a location is in positive or negative phase , about 60% of its neighbors have the same phase .
however on averaging across grid locations , the mean probabilities of being in positive or negative phase are each close to 50% .
therefore these results indicate that being in a certain phase is more likely when its neighbors are in the same phase .
agreement with all - india phase is more spatially coherent than disagreement , because both mnn and mccs are larger for property ap ( agreement with national phase ) than for dp ( disagreement with the national phase ) . therefore if a location agrees with the national phase , the probabilities that its neighbors also agree with the national phase are larger than otherwise .
local extremities are spatially coherent because the mnn for lp ( local pex in a year ) and ln ( local nex in a year ) correspond to conditional probabilities of pex and nex that are significantly larger than the unconditional probabilities of locations having pex and nex respectively . in an average year , only about 14% locations of india have local pex ( or local nex ) , but 3.9 out of 8 neighbors ( nearly 50% ) of a local pex ( or nex ) also have local pex ( or nex ) .
4 . local extremities of any sign are more spatially coherent in years of all - india extremities of same sign ; and less spatially coherent in years of all - india extremities of opposite sign .
this is inferred from mnn and mccs being smaller for property ln - sp ( local nex during spatial pex ) than for ln - sn ( local nex during spatial nex ) , and likewise for property lp - sn ( local pex during spatial nex ) than for lp - sp ( local pex during spatial pex ) .
similar relations hold in case of locational extremities . for example in a spatial mean nex year , there is larger coherence around locations with local nexs as manifested by larger mnn and mccs . in summary , for phase , the local phase is coherent and agreement with aimr phase is more coherent .
this raises the possibility of forecasting phase through clustering , despite the substantial heterogeneities in rainfall .
furthermore , despite the generally weaker association between local and national extremes discussed previously , local extremes exhibit coherence and this raises the possibility of using further information to forecast coherent clusters where extreme events can be used . because this coherence is higher during spatial mean extremes of the same sign , such cluster - based forecasting would be more plausible for sub - national scale extremes having the same sign as the national - level extreme .
motivated by this discovery of spatial coherence , we now try to identify small but spatially contiguous sets of grid - locations with homogeneous behaviour with respect to phase and local extremes .
earlier , different criteria such as mean and variability of rainfall have been used to identify such clusters ( @xcite ) . here
we extend such analyses to include phase and extremities as defined above .
clustering techniques , well - known in data mining , seek to partition data according to predefined measures of similarity .
each partition is called a _
cluster_. we use spectral clustering ( @xcite ) to partition the grid into relatively homogeneous clusters .
this method takes as input an @xmath66 matrix @xmath67 , where @xmath68 is the number of data - points and each entry @xmath69 encodes a measure of similarity between the datapoints indexed by @xmath70 and @xmath71 .
this similarity measure is application - specific .
we are also required to specify the number of clusters @xmath72 . clustering algorithms
assign to each data - point a cluster index in @xmath73 , with the points having the same index comprising a cluster .
generally points assigned to the same cluster are expected to be more `` similar '' to each other than to other points , with respect to the measure of similarity in @xmath67 .
the goal of clustering with respect to local phase and extremes is to identify regions at the sub - national scale where these properties are similar .
hence we smooth the data by estimating means over 1-hop neighborhoods at each grid - location , before applying the clustering algorithms below .
to generate clustering according to phase , for every pair of locations @xmath74 we compute @xmath75 , i.e. @xmath69 is the number of years when @xmath70 and @xmath71 have same phase .
thus the measure of similarity is related to the tendency of the locations to be in the same phase . by specifying a small number of clusters ,
we identify coherent regions that coincide in phase much of the time . although the spectral clustering algorithm is not biased to manifest spatial contiguity of clusters , spatial neighbors often appear in the same cluster .
not all clusters formed by the algorithm have high intra - cluster similarity with respect to @xmath67 defined above . in figure 5
, we only show the clusters having high intra - cluster similarity , such that locations within any one of the selected clusters coincide in phase in a large number of years .
these are the clusters for which comparatively higher probability forecasts of phase might be possible . to identify locations simultaneously experiencing either local positive or negative extremes , we define similarity measure for each pair @xmath74 as @xmath76 for pex ( the number of years when both @xmath70 and @xmath71 have local pex ) , and @xmath77 for nex ( the number of years when both @xmath70 and @xmath71 have local nex ) . using these as the similarity matrices for spectral clustering with 10 clusters , we find in case of strong intra - cluster similarity the clusters of locations frequently experiencing local pexs ( or nexs ) in the same years .
locations in any one of the clusters in fig 6a have simultaneous local pex in at least 8 ( about @xmath78 ) of their local pex years . in fig 6b
we show clusters of locations which have simultaneous local pex in at least 3 ( about 20% ) all - india pex years . for this analysis
, we use similarity matrix @xmath79 .
locations in any of the clusters in fig 6c have simultaneous local nex in at least 6 ( about @xmath80 of their local nex years , and locations in the clusters of fig 6d have simultaneous local nex in at least 3 ( about 20% ) all - india nex years . for fig 6d ,
the similarity matrix used is @xmath81 .
such large and spatially contiguous clusters could not have arisen if the occurrence of local nex or pex were independent across the locations within the clusters , and are one manifestation of the spatial coherence described previously .
although we are smoothing the results using means over 1-hop neighborhoods before applying the spectral clustering algorithm , we note that similar ( but noisier ) clusters are obtained if the algorithm were implemented on the data without smoothing .
however , the threshold probability for including these clusters in the figure is much lower than that of phase . with a higher threshold of @xmath82 ,
very few clusters survive .
therefore while there is coherent behavior in extremes across many locations , the conditional probability of nexs across these clusters given a spatial mean extreme is small .
therefore high probability forecasts of local extremes , or extremes across individual clusters , can not rely on the spatial mean forecast alone .
even the clusters that are not conditionally dependent on spatial mean extremes ( in fig 6a and 6c ) do not have simultaneous local extremes with as high probability as in the case of the clusters involving phase in fig 5 .
this indicates that forecasting extremes at the sub - national scale is fundamentally more difficult than forecasting phase .
forecasting rainfall received in any year is important for india s economy , especially for millions of workers directly dependending on rainfed agriculture for their livelihoods .
currently , imd makes forecasts of seasonal rainfall at the national scale , and these seasonal - mean forecasts do not carry direct implications for individual regions .
however impacts are mainly felt through events occurring at local and sub - national scales .
making regional or grid - level forecasts is far more difficult due to the heterogeneity of rainfall , but our findings show that some weaker forecasts ( related to phase ) might be possible at smaller scales , and that could furthermore be largely based on aimr forecasts .
this is mainly because the phase , being a binary quantity , exhibits larger spatial coherence and larger association with the all - india phase , and therefore is more amenable to prediction based on the aimr change .
we showed here that , despite the heterogeneity , local phase has a high probability of following the national phase ; and this probability is higher during extreme years .
furthermore , the identification of coherent clusters in which the phase coincides with high frequency raises the possibility of the forecasting of phase within these clusters .
the treatment of phase has more general consequences for understanding variability ; for example one could think of clusters with mostly the same phase as being those that vary together ( after neglecting the magnitude of changes ) .
understanding the phase and its behaviour is important because the knowledge of phase indicates whether rainfall in the following year will be more or less than the present year , and this type of comparison might be important for adaptation to rainfall variability . the results presented here also showed that , corresponding to the mean - reversion of aimr , its phase is reasonably predictable .
therefore , years with negative phase have high probability of being followed by positive phase years ; and vice versa .
this also carries over to the grid - level , despite the spatial heterogeneity in phase .
together , the mean reverting character of large - scale rainfall and the discretization involved in defining the phase make this variable more predictable than many of its alternatives .
another aspect of the paper is in understanding the properties of years experiencing extreme rainfall .
extreme rainfall is important for impacts , and local and sub - national extremes play the largest roles .
statistical forecasting of the monsoon does not extend to seasonal forecasts at the grid level , but it is important to understand the relation between local and national extremes , and whether local extremes can be forecast . here
we consider grid - level extremes , and their relation with spatial - mean extremes .
the results show that grid - level as well as regional extremes do not follow the national extremes with high probability .
this implies that national - level forecasts alone can not be deployed to infer or predict grid - level extremes with high confidence
. however it was objectively shown that grid - level extremes exhibit spatial coherence .
moreover the coherence increased in the presence of a national - scale extreme of the same sign .
this , together with the demonstration that extremes tend to occur in spatially contiguous clusters , raises the possibility of forecasting extremes at the level of individual clusters where extremes tend to coincide .
such forecasts would only be probabilistic , and making such forecasts would require exploiting additional information than merely the occurrence of national - level extremes , such as sea surface temperature patterns . beyond such speculation based on the results presented here ,
the exploration and elaboration of such methodology is outside the scope of this paper .
however it was also shown that such efforts are likely to face intrinsic difficulties because grid - level extremes within relatively homogeneous clusters do not coincide with high probability , as shown in the previous section .
a number of possible regionalizations can be made , some more useful than others . however
a necessary condition for the existence of contiguous clusters based on some variable is that the variable should exhibit spatial coherence . by introducing objective measures of coherence that cover both isotropic and anistropic cases
, we were able to identify some variables for which significant regionalizations are possible .
long - term simulations of indian rainfall are needed to formulate socio - economic and developmental policies , especially in the presence of climate change , and such simulations should be able to capture regional variations accurately .
it has been noted that under the influence of climate change , such spatial differences are actually increasing ( @xcite ) .
we have identified additional salient characteristics of spatiotemporal heterogeneities relevant to evaluating simulations by climate models ( @xcite ) .
these findings by previous authors of the non - stationarities of extreme rainfall statistics suggest that our present analysis assuming a stationary climate must be extended to consider how the clusters and associated relationships examined here are evolving in time due to climate change .
this research was supported by divecha centre for climate change , indian institute of science .
we are thankful to dr .
j. srinivasan , dr . v.venugopal and dr .
k. rajendran for their valueable inputs .
shashi shekhar , zhe jiang , reem y. ali , emre eftelioglu , xun tang , venkata m. v. gunturi and xun zhou ( 2015 ) , spatiotemporal data mining : a computational perspective , _ international journal of geo - information _ , _ 4 _ , 2306 - 2338 .
b. jayasankar , sajani surendran , and k. rajendran ( 2015 ) , robust signals of future projections of indian summer monsoon rainfall by ipcc ar5 climate models : role of seasonal cycle and interannual variability , _ geophysical research letters _ , _
42(9 ) _ , 3513 - 3520 rajeevan , m and bhate , jyoti and jaswal , ak ( 2008 ) , analysis of variability and trends of extreme rainfall events over india using 104 years of gridded daily rainfall data , _ geophysical research letters _ , _ | forecasts of monsoon rainfall for india are made at national scale .
but there is spatial coherence and heterogeneity that is relevant to forecasting .
this paper considers year - to - year rainfall change and annual extremes at sub - national scales .
we use data mining techniques to gridded rain - gauge data for 1901 - 2011 to characterize coherence and heterogeneity and identify spatially homogeneous clusters .
we study the direction of change in rainfall between years ( phase ) , and extreme annual rainfall at both grid level and national level .
grid - level phase is found to be spatially coherent , and significantly correlated with all - india mean rainfall ( aimr ) phase .
grid - level extreme - rainfall years are not strongly associated with corresponding extremes in aimr , although in extreme aimr years local extremes of the same type occur with higher spatial coherence .
years of extremes in aimr entail widespread phase of the corresponding sign .
furthermore , local extremes and phase are found to frequently co - occur in spatially contiguous clusters . |
it is well known that the maximal visibility of hom dip in the case of classical fields is @xmath36 .
the customarily used definition of visibility for hom dip is @xmath37 where @xmath38 the subscripts @xmath39 and @xmath40 denote the exit ports of the beam splitter .
@xmath41 is the instateneous intensity at exit @xmath42 the average is over a stochastic mixture of classical fields ( this includes random relative phases , which average out first order interference behind the beam splitter ) .
the maximum and minimum are taken with respect of some variation of the conditions of the fields entering the beam splitter ( like the relative time shift , polarizations , etc . ) .
as we are not able to measure instantenious values of the intensities in reality we have integrations over detectors time resolution @xmath43 we have taken the integration ( effectively ) over full time range , because we are interested in pulsed radiation , and we assume that the pulses time width is much narrower than the time resolution of the detectors .
the redefined correlation function in the classical case , for the same physical conditions reads @xmath44 where @xmath45 and it does not depend on the manipulations on the beams before they enter the beam splitter ( under the mentioned relations between the pulses and time resolution of detection ) .
thus if we write the initial field amplitudes as @xmath46 , and @xmath47 , respectively for inputs @xmath48 and @xmath49 of the beam splitter , then we see that @xmath50 is just @xmath18 for fields of changed amplitudes , namely @xmath51 , and @xmath52 . as @xmath53 is a maximum visibility for @xmath18 for any inputs , the maximum visibility for @xmath50 can not breach this value .
in the previous section we considered hom interference in terms of classical electric fields .
the results showed , that new definition of correlation function ( @xmath18 and @xmath50 ) does not change final visibility of whole process and the maximal value of visibility is @xmath54 .
now , let us consider the same process in terms of optical fields , what is a natural consequence of @xcite and @xcite .
let us start with the state produced by type i frequency degenerate pdc process .
the simplified interaction hamiltonian is of the form @xmath55 where @xmath39 and @xmath40 are annihilation operators for both spatial modes , @xmath56 is a coupling constant depending on the nonlinearity of the crystal and the power of the pumping field .
if we take the vacuum as an input state we get two mode bright squeezed vacuum in the output @xmath57 where @xmath58 is a gain parameter . each component of this state is composed of @xmath59 photons , distributed equally in a and b spatial modes ( @xmath22 by each mode ) .
now we will consider a modified state @xmath60 where @xmath61 and @xmath62 denote respectively matched and mismatched modes , and @xmath63 $ ] is a parameter measuring distinguishability in the spatial mode @xmath40 with respect to @xmath39 .
the ( relevant ) beam splitter transformations act as follows : @xmath64 , @xmath65 , and @xmath66 , where @xmath67 and @xmath68 are annihilation operators for spacial modes before and after the beam splitter respectively .
we have for mismatched modes @xmath69= [ b_h , b_v^\dagger]= [ c_h , c_v^\dagger]=[d_h , d_v^\dagger]=0.\ ] ] please notice that for @xmath70 we reproduce the two - mode bright squeezed vacuum state . after all calculations corresponding to the beam splitter transformation , given state takes form ( see appendix ) @xmath71 where @xmath72 .
let us define two following expressions @xmath73 and + @xmath74 where @xmath75 and @xmath76 are photon number operators in spatial mode ( or detectors ) a and b respectively .
function @xmath77 follows the traditional approach and is a quantum version of @xmath18 . the new approach is represented by function @xmath78 here we divide coincidence number by normalizing factor before we calculate the average values .
please notice that in both cases , if the number of photons in one spatial mode is equal to @xmath79 , the product @xmath80 is equal to @xmath79 as well no coincidences are observed .
the correlation function @xmath81 can be rewritten as @xmath82 where @xmath83 is the operator of the total number of photons .
the definition is fully consistent with the approach of @xcite and formula ( [ newstokes ] ) .
there are two special cases , namely @xmath70 and @xmath84 where we are able to perform accurate analysis ( without cutting sum over @xmath22 ) . as was pointed out for @xmath85 the state ( [ bsvalfa ] )
is just two mode bright squeezed vacuum .
the beam splitter transforms it into following state @xmath86 it leads to the analytic expressions for @xmath77 and @xmath81 .
namely @xmath87 @xmath88 similarly one can obtain results for @xmath84 .
after beam splitter the state reads @xmath89 the functions @xmath77 and @xmath81 are equal to @xmath90 @xmath91 with all that we can calculate the visibilities of the hom experiment for @xmath92 state .
one can identify maximal number of coincidence as value of @xmath18 functions for @xmath93 and minimal value for @xmath70 .
@xmath94 where @xmath95 . using expressions ( [ g_qan ] ) , ( [ g2an ] ) ,
( [ g_qpi ] ) , ( [ g2pi ] ) one obtains @xmath96 and @xmath97 the visibilities versus parametric gain @xmath58.,scaledwidth=47.0% ] fig.([vis ] ) shows the visibilities @xmath98 and @xmath99 with respect to the parametric gain @xmath58 .
please notice that in the limit of infinite parametric gain @xmath58 the difference @xmath100 tends to zero .
one can also observe , that both quantum visibilities are greater and tend asymptotically to the classical maximum value @xmath54 .
the above considerations show that one can extend the applicability of the ideas of ref .
@xcite to optical phenomena which are not polarization based , or related to pairs of spatially separated ( multiport ) interferometers @xcite .
the approach with rates leads to a clearer visibility of the hong - ou - mandel effects , for higher pump values .
the work is part of project brisq2 , within eu fp7 ( grant agreement no .
308803 ) . the work is subsidized form funds for science for years 2012 - 2015 approved for international co - financed project brisq2 by polish ministry of science and higher education ( mnisw ) .
kk and wl are supported by ncn grant no .
2012/05/e / st2/02352 mw is supported by ncn grant .
2015/19/b / st2/01999 .
we thank prof .
m. chekhova for discussions . 6 p. kok , b. w. lovett , introduction to optical quantum information processing , cambridge university press ( 2010 ) . c. k. hong , z. y. ou , l. mandel , phys .
. lett . * 59 * , 2044 ( 1987 ) . c. santori , .
dfattal , j. vuckovic , g. s. solomon , y. yamamoto nature 419 594 ( 2002 ) . m. b. nasr , b. e. a. saleh , a. v. sergienko m. c. teich phys . rev
. lett . * 91 * 083601 ( 2003 ) .
k. sanaka , k. resch , a. zeilinger phys .
* 96 * 083601 ( 2006 ) .
t. iskhakov , k. spasibko , m. chekhova , g. leuchs , new journal of physics * 15 * , 093036 ( 2013 ) .
m. ukowski , m. wieniak , w. laskowski , arxiv:1506.08732 ( 2015 ) m. ukowski , w. laskowski , m. wieniak , arxiv:1508.02368 ( 2015 ) m. d. reid , d. f. walls , phys .
a * 34 * , 1260 ( 1986 ) a. dutta , m. marciniak , m. wieniak , m. ukowski , in preparation .
as an initial state we take @xmath102 which is two - mode @xmath59photon fock state .
we can express this state in terms of creation operators formalism @xmath103 where @xmath104 and @xmath105 stand for creation operators for two spatial modes and @xmath106 is a vacuum state .
let us denote the @xmath2 beam splitter transformation by @xmath10 .
hence we get @xmath107^n { | \omega \rangle } \\ \nonumber = \frac{1}{2^n } \frac{1}{n ! } ( c^{\dagger 2}-d^{\dagger 2})^n { | \omega \rangle } \\ \nonumber = \frac{1}{2^n } \frac{1}{n ! } \sum^n_{k=0 } { { n}\choose{k } } \hat{c}^{\dagger 2(n - k ) } \hat{d}^{\dagger 2k } { | \omega \rangle},\ ] ] where @xmath108 and @xmath109 are creation operators for modes after beam splitter .
moreover the operators @xmath110 and @xmath111 commute . using the action of an creation operator on vacuum state
the state reads @xmath112 ! } \sqrt{(2k ) ! } \\
\nonumber \times { | 2(n - k),2k \rangle } \nonumber \label{afterbs}\ ] ] let us notice that there are only two components in the state ( [ afterbs ] ) , which reveal no coincidences , namely for @xmath113 and @xmath114 .
we consider the state ( [ bsvalfa ] ) @xmath116 where @xmath61 and @xmath62 are horizontal and vertical polarization respectively and @xmath63 $ ] is a parameter which introduces a kind of polarization distinguishability measure in the spatial mode @xmath40 .
please notice that for @xmath70 we reproduce the two mode bright squeezed vacuum state .
after beam splitter the states takes the following form @xmath117 where @xmath118 . using the binomial expansion we get @xmath119 where the coefficients @xmath120 equals @xmath121 acting on vacuum by the creation operators one obtains ( [ bsvout ] ) @xmath122
we present all calculations concerning the expressions ( [ g_q ] ) and ( [ g2 ] ) @xmath123 + @xmath124 in order to calculate expectation values ( [ g_q ] ) and ( [ g2 ] ) we use the fact that @xmath125 , where @xmath126 is a certain function of a photon number operator . to calculate expressions ( [ g_q ] ) and ( [ g2 ] ) for state ( [ bsvalfa ] )
, we should take summation to infinity into account .
however for numerical reasons we cut sums to the certain @xmath127 according to the following criterion @xmath128 where @xmath129 is the contribution of the @xmath22 th component in the state ( [ bsv ] ) .
let us notice that the smaller @xmath58 we take the smaller @xmath127 we need .
for instance , for @xmath130 @xmath131 is reasonable .
after rather technical calculation we get @xmath132 @xmath133 where @xmath134 is a product of four kronecker deltas .
namely , @xmath135 for compactness we introduced simplified shortcut notation , @xmath136 .
@xmath137 and @xmath138 are appropriate multi - indices , @xmath139 contains the rest of expression ( [ g22 ] ) .
calculating of the expectation value @xmath77 we follow the same way . in our shortcut notation one | we test ideas put forward e.g in arxiv:1508.02368 , which suggest that using rates in quantum optics can lead to better indicators of non - classicality for states of quantum optical fields with undefined photon numbers . by rate we mean the ratio of registered photons in a given detector to the total number of detected photons in all detectors in the experiment . for the hong - ou - mandel effect for parametric down conversion fields ,
we show that by using two detector correlation functions which are defined in terms of averages of products of measured rates , rather than usual intensities , one can observe non classical visibilities beyond @xmath0 for significantly higher pump rates . at such rates we already have a partially stimulated emission which leads to significant amplitudes for multiple pairs production , still the new approach allows to clearly see the non - classical dip . _
introduction .
_ superposition principle is at the core of quantum mechanics .
quantum entanglement is simply a manifestation of the superposition rule in the composed systems .
all quantum interference effects base on the fact of superposition of probability amplitudes of processes that make a contribution to the given event . in @xmath1
hong , ou and mandel realized one of the most impressive experiments opening new possibilities in modern quantum optics .
their seminal paper @xcite is a powerful confirmation of quantum mechanical predictions concerning quantum interference .
the general idea of the standard hom experiment is as follows @xcite .
let us consider two photons entering @xmath2 beam splitter .
let us assume that the single
photon states take the following form @xmath3 @xmath4 where @xmath5 and @xmath6 are certain functions depending on the wave vector @xmath7 and normalized in the following sense @xmath8 the relations ( [ norm ] ) are an immediate consequence of the orthonormality of fock states . the input (
before beam splitter ) state reads @xmath9 the output state is defined by unitary transformation @xmath10 which describes action of the beam splitter .
let us write appropriate transformation relations for annihilation operators @xmath11 @xmath12 one can introduce so called coincidence function @xmath13 where @xmath14 and @xmath15 are the photon number operators for the spacial modes @xmath16 and @xmath17 respectively .
the @xmath18 function can be interpreted as a measure of coincidence counts detected by detectors situated behind the beam splitter .
please observe that if one of the channels is empty ( lack of photons ) @xmath19 . by straightforward calculations it can be shown that @xmath20 please notice that in the case of equality @xmath21 we obtain @xmath19 what we see as so called hong ou mandel ( hom ) dip i.e. the coincidence function tends to zero .
@xmath19 means that photons entering beam splitter are completely indistinguishable . obviously , the wave vector @xmath7 is only one of the parameters whereby we can distinguish photons .
the hom effect can be applied as an verifier of a quality of single
photon sources @xcite . by quality
we mean that the source produces only single photons and the produced states are pure .
if the input states are single photon mixed states the coincidence counts do not approach zero because of interference of photons ( with some probability ) which are distinguishable .
the appearance of any non single
photon components will be manifested in nonzero coincidences as well .
obviously nonzero dip without photon number resolution does not inform us what is the reason of clicks in both detectors i.e. multi
photon components , impurity of inputs or both .
the other application of the hom effect is quantum optical coherence tomography @xcite where hom interferometer is the main part of the experimental set up . the above description of the hom interference based on single photon states .
it turns out that the effect can be demonstrated for @xmath22 photon states and bright macroscopic superpositions as well @xcite . in @xcite sanaka et al .
presented the fock state filter based on hom type multiphoton interference .
they consider an unbalanced beam splitter ( with the reflectivity coefficient @xmath23 ) and the product of one photon state and the n photon state ( in general a superposition of number state ) as the input .
for the certain value of @xmath23 ( depending on @xmath22 ) the probability of detecting only one photon in a certain detector @xmath24 equals zero .
it means that by linearity if the detector @xmath24 register one photon we can eliminate appropriate n photon component from the fock state superposition entering beam splitter .
obviously for @xmath25 and balanced beam splitter their reasoning reduces to the original hom experiment . in @xcite authors
consider a ( very ) bright squeezed vacuum state generated via frequency - degenerate type - ii parametric down conversion ( pdc ) .
bright ( nearly @xmath26 photons per mode on average ) twin beams interfere on a balanced beam splitter .
instead standard coincidence function the observable chosen to measure the effect is the variance of the photon number difference at the outputs normalized by the average of the total number of photons . the reported visibility was @xmath27 .
however this is a measure which is not directly related to the standard definition of interferometic visibility , which in the case of the experiment @xcite was a tiny @xmath28 .
in this paper we present a new approach to data analysis for the hom interference measurement , based on the tricks introduced in @xcite . in @xcite zukowski
et al .
present the new approach to bell inequalities for quantum optical fields .
the new concept is to replace averages of intensities by averages of rates i.e. the normalized intensities .
it leads to removal of some loopholes inherent in earlier approaches to quantum optical bell inequalities @xcite . in @xcite
the same authors introduce some modification of the standard stokes parameters .
the modified stokes operators are normalized and the vacuum component is removed .
the replacement is as follows : @xmath29 where @xmath30 is the projection operator on non vacuum sectors i.e. @xmath31 and @xmath32 denote any pair two orthogonal polarizations ( generally elliptic ) , while in the denominator we have the operator for the total number of photons @xmath33 , which is independent of @xmath34 .
obviously the operation of removing vacuum components is not unitary and all new averages should be properly normalized .
this new definition allows to construct improved entanglement criteria for multi - photon states .
the new approach allows a better description of polarization correlations of the quantum light .
the aim of this paper is to apply the ideas of @xcite to more general situations , as the working example we choose the hom dip .
the state under consideration is two mode bright squeezed vacuum . to be able to compare the depth of a dip
, we introduce a mode mismatch parametrized by angle @xmath35 . in all consideration
we assume that the detectors are photon - counting with perfect efficiency .
the paper is organized as follows . in the first section
we discuss the case of classical field beams . in the second section we move to describing the both quantum cases ( with old and redefined coincidence functions ) . |
in cosmology , one models the evolution and observables associated with an inhomogeneous universe of density @xmath0 and expansion rate @xmath1 by employing a friedmann - lematre - robertson - walker ( flrw ) homogeneous / isotropic model of density @xmath2 , where @xmath3 denotes some suitably defined spatial average .
one then assumes that the expansion rate and cosmological observables are those obtained in the corresponding flrw model .
one of the proposals to explain `` dark energy '' calls into question this long - standing ( 86-year ) procedure .
the idea is that the expansion rate and cosmological observables of a suitably inhomogeneous universe containing only dust , if analyzed within the framework of a homogeneous model , seems to behave as if the stress tensor also contains a fictitious negative - pressure fluid ( _ i.e. , _ dark energy ) .
although this proposal is conservative in the sense that it does not involve a cosmological constant of incredibly small magnitude ( presumably rationalized on some anthropic basis ) , a scalar field of unbelievably small mass , or an entirely unmotivated modification of general relativity , it is rather revolutionary because it implies that there is no dark energy and the expansion of the universe does not actually accelerate ( at least , not in the usual sense ) . at present , the idea that the backreaction of inhomogeneities accounts for the observational evidence usually attributed to dark energy is more of a concept than a predictive model .
however , it is generally agreed that if the proposal is to be relevant , nonlinearities are required
. there have been many criticisms of this approach .
one of them @xcite is based on the claim that even in the presence of highly nonlinear density perturbations ( @xmath4 ) the metric for our universe can everywhere be written as a perturbed conformal newtonian metric of the form ) , satisfying the stated conditions , as the _ perturbed conformal newtonian _ metric . ]
@xmath5 , \label{newtpert}\ ] ] where @xmath6 is conformal time , @xmath7 is a metric of a three - space of constant curvature , and @xmath8 satisfies the newtonian conditions @xmath9 , @xmath10 , and @xmath11 . the covariant derivative with the metric @xmath7 is denoted by @xmath12 .
the usual statement is that in the dust case one is allowed to use the perturbed conformal newtonian metric either in the linear regime ( _ i.e. , _ perturbations of every quantity being small ) or in the weak - field ( newtonian ) regime .
the claim is that if the metric can be written in the above form and satisfies the above conditions , even in the presence of large inhomogeneities , any cosmological observable will be the same as the cosmological observable calculated with @xmath13 , _
i.e. , _ in the homogeneous / isotropic model .
this has been described as a `` no - go '' theorem that backreactions can not _ in principle _
account for the observations .
while it is impossible to consider the most general inhomogeneous solutions , there are spherically symmetric inhomogeneous dust solutions , which are not perturbations of einstein - de sitter , that can be constructed to give observables similar to @xmath14cdm models .
these models serve as a counterexample to the no - go argument . in this paper
we will show why these models can not be described in terms of a conformal newtonian metric perturbed about a spatially flat background , and attempt to understand the implications for the backreaction proposal . indeed , while it may turn out that backreactions are not the answer
, we argue that assuming the results of measurements of the luminosity distance as a function of redshift usually interpreted as an accelerated expansion , the metric describing our universe can not be written in the form of a perturbed conformal newtonian metric where @xmath15 is calculated from the homogeneous dust model . in other words , if the expansion history of the universe is well described by the @xmath14cdm model , then perturbing about an einstein - de sitter model by the perturbed conformal newtonian metric of eq .
( [ newtpert ] ) is inappropriate , because einstein - de sitter would be the wrong background .
this is because of large peculiar velocities with respect to the background einstein - de sitter space .
so if inhomogeneities are responsible for the observables usually attributed to dark energy , the universe can not be obtained by small perturbations of the einstein - de sttter model . in other words ,
the reason we interpret the observations as evidence for dark energy and acceleration of the universe is that we are comparing the observables to observables computed in the wrong background .
as we will discuss , the reason is that the proper meaning of `` peculiar '' is `` after subtraction of a background hubble flow term . ''
we will argue that large peculiar velocities must be present if the backreaction program works , and the peculiar velocities are not related to `` local '' departures from the hubble flow that would show up as large velocity dispersions . as an explicit example , consider the argument of ref .
they propose that the backreaction of inhomogeneities in a dust universe modifies the evolution of the effective volume - averaged scale factor and results in an evolution of the volume expansion that resembles a @xmath14cdm model , rather than the unperturbed spatially flat dust model .
if one would write the metric for such a perturbed universe in terms of a perturbed conformal newtonian metric , then one would have to use @xmath15 described by a @xmath14cdm model , _ not _ the @xmath15 from an unperturbed spatially flat dust model .
if one would attempt to express the metric in terms of a perturbed metric with @xmath15 described by a spatially flat dust model , then there would be enormous peculiar velocities in the hubble flow .
we explore the issue by considering the spacetime of a particular lematre - tolman - bondi spherically symmetric model . in the model
we study , the observer is centered in a large ( gpc ) underdense region in an asymptotically einstein - de sitter universe .
this model has large , but not highly nonlinear , density and curvature inhomogeneities .
we show by explicit calculation that the metric _ can not _ be expressed as a perturbed conformal newtonian metric during the entire evolution .
we also show that the reason for this can be traced to large peculiar velocities that develop with respect to the einstein - de sitter background . in the next section
we describe the relevant features of the einstein - de sitter and lematre - tolman - bondi models . in section [ ltbpg ]
we develop the formalism to express the original lematre - tolman - bondi metric in the form of a perturbed conformal poisson metric . in section [ discussion ] we discuss the reason for the numerical results of the previous section .
finally , in section [ conclusions ] we present our conclusions .
in this section we will establish the notation for the homogeneous , isotropic , and spatially - flat cosmological model ( the einstein de sitter model ) .
we will then briefly introduce the formalism of ltb spherically symmetric cosmological models in the synchronous gauge , and turn to a particular ltb model with values of cosmological observables similar to the @xmath14cdm model .
the eds model describes a spatially - flat , matter - dominated universe . in order to connect with the ltb solution of the next section
, we can express the line element in terms of the scale factor @xmath15 : @xmath16 the friedmann equation and its solutions are ( @xmath17 is the present scale factor in general , the subscript @xmath18 will denote the present value of a quantity and @xmath19 ) @xmath20 at any epoch , the age of the universe is @xmath21 .
we also note that the present distance to the horizon is @xmath22 .
the ltb model @xcite is based on the assumptions that the system is spherically symmetric with purely radial motion and the motion is geodesic without shell crossing ( otherwise we could not neglect the pressure ) .
the line element in the synchronous gauge can be written in the form @xmath23 here , the prime superscript denotes @xmath24 .
we will denote @xmath25 by an overdot .
the function @xmath26 is an arbitrary function of @xmath27
. we will also find it useful to define equivalent functions @xmath28 and @xmath29 , related to @xmath26 by @xmath30 one can recover the usual friedmann - robertson - walker metric by the replacements @xmath31 in spherically symmetric models , in general there are two expansion rates : an angular expansion rate , @xmath32 , and a radial expansion rate , @xmath33 . assuming a dust equation of state , the einstein equations
may be expressed as @xmath34 these are the generalization of the friedmann equations for a homogeneous / isotropic universe to a spherically symmetric inhomogeneous universe .
adding the equations results in an equation that can be easily integrated to yield the dynamical equation for @xmath35 : @xmath36 where @xmath37 is a function of @xmath27 related to the density @xmath38 by @xmath39 equation ( [ rdot ] ) can be differentiated to yield the dynamical equation for @xmath40 : @xmath41 since we will eventually express the ltb solution using a perturbed conformal poisson metric , it is convenient to use instead of time a new independent variable related to the eds scale factor : @xmath42 .
we also introduce new dependent variables @xmath43 and @xmath44 .
therefore , our variables are @xmath45 the solution @xmath46 corresponds to the eds model .
the dynamical equations for @xmath47 and @xmath48 are @xmath49 \nonumber \\ \frac{dz}{dx } & = & \frac{z}{x}\left [ \frac{1}{2z } \frac{xb_2+a_2/y - a_1z / y^2}{\sqrt{b_1x+a_1/y } } -1\right ] , \label{dynamicaleqs}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the functions @xmath50 , @xmath51 , @xmath52 , and @xmath53 are related to @xmath37 , @xmath28 and their derivatives by @xmath54 here , @xmath55 is the present eds expansion rate .
since each shell labeled by @xmath27 evolves independently , we can choose initial conditions to be specified at different times for different shells .
however , for simplicity we choose to specify initial conditions at the same time for all shells .
we will choose the initial time to be recombination for the eds model , @xmath56 .
the initial value of @xmath57 ( or @xmath47 ) can be chosen freely with a suitable rescaling of @xmath27 .
we choose @xmath46 at @xmath56 to match to the eds solution as @xmath58 .
a particular ltb model is generated by a choice for @xmath37 and @xmath28 . for a discussion of the free functions in ltb models , see ref.@xcite .
for other works based on ltb solutions aiming at showing the effect of inhomogeneities , see @xcite .
our goal here is to study a ltb model with observables similar to the standard @xmath14cdm model .
we will adopt the particular model of alnes , amarzguioui , and grn ( aag ) @xcite , but with slightly different parameters . the model is eds at large @xmath27 ,
the observer is in the center of an underdense ( compared to the eds density ) region , and a there is region of density larger than the eds value to compensate the underdense region . for various values of @xmath42 .
middle figure : the functions @xmath59 and @xmath60 as a function of @xmath61 .
notice that @xmath62 is always very close to unity ( an approximation we will employ later ) .
bottom figure : the current proper distance as a function of the comoving coordinate @xmath61 for the ltb model and the eds model ( @xmath63).[rbd],width=604 ] in the aag model @xmath37 and @xmath28 are given by @xmath64 \nonumber \\
\beta(r ) & = & h_0 ^ 2a_0 ^ 2r^2 \frac{\delta\alpha}{2 } \left(1-\tanh\frac{r - r_0}{2\delta r}\right ) .\end{aligned}\ ] ] alnes , amarzguioui , and grn choose @xmath65 , @xmath66 , @xmath67 gpc , @xmath68 . with that choice of parameters , at the origin at present @xmath69 .
they found that this choice of parameters reproduces the luminosity distance
redshift diagram expected for a @xmath14cdm model .
that choice of parameters results in a `` weak '' singularity at the origin @xcite , as can be see by the fact that @xmath70 .
can not be positive at @xmath71 .
however , it is possible to have @xmath72 for off - center observers . ] while this is not a serious issue ( the observer could be slightly displaced from the origin or a slightly different density profile could be used ) we will employ different parameters than aag to mitigate the weak singularity .
we do this simply by the choice @xmath73 .
this results in the present expansion rate at the origin of @xmath74 .
the density compared to the eds density is shown in fig .
notice that at the origin @xmath75 vanishes .
the curvature function @xmath29 is also shown in fig .
the fact that as @xmath27 approaches @xmath18 , @xmath76 is negative and @xmath77 is much smaller than the eds value , implies that the evolution deep in the void will resemble a negatively - curved , empty universe .
for sufficiently large @xmath27 , @xmath76 approaches @xmath18 and @xmath77 approaches the eds value , so far from the void the universe evolves as an eds model universe . or @xmath78 when the solution is very near the eds solution as @xmath79 or @xmath80 . ] the aag model can actually be thought of as a swiss - cheese model of holes of radius @xmath80 .
( see ref .
@xcite for a discussion of swiss - cheese models . ) in fig .
[ rbd ] we display the functions in term of the comoving coordinate label @xmath27 multiplied by @xmath81 .
that combination is related to the present comoving proper distance in units of @xmath82 , @xmath83 where @xmath84 .
the spatial curvature term @xmath26 is close to unity , and @xmath48 is of order unity , so to a reasonable approximation @xmath85 , the eds result .
( the choice @xmath65 implies @xmath86 mpc . ) in fig .
[ rbd ] we show the present proper distance as a function of @xmath61 .
the evolution of @xmath87 and @xmath88 is shown in fig .
[ yzypzp ] .
the initial conditions specified at @xmath56 are @xmath46 , with an initial underdensity in the interior .
since the underdense region expands more rapidly than average , a typical ltb evolution will lead to shell crossing in a rather small dynamical time .
the occurrence of shell crossing means that the synchronous coordinate system becomes singular and the evolution in that system can no longer be calculated .
agg delay the onset of shell crossing by endowing the shells with a large initial infall velocity ( negative @xmath89 and @xmath90 ) .
thus , it takes the system a while for the underdense regions with large expansion rate to reverse the infall and this essentially delays the eventual shell crossing.cdm model ) , the synchronous gauge does not have problems , and , in particular , the ltb solution is an exactly solvable model with nonlinear inhomogeneities for an extended time evolution . ] and @xmath48 as a function of @xmath61 for the indicated values of @xmath42 . at the initial time of the evolution , @xmath56 and @xmath46 . for the other values of @xmath91 , @xmath47 is always smaller than unity and asymptotically approaches @xmath92 ( the eds solution ) for large values of @xmath78 . for small values of @xmath78
the function @xmath48 is smaller than unity , then for larger values of @xmath78 it becomes larger than unity , and eventually @xmath48 approaches unity from above .
lower figures : the functions @xmath89 and @xmath90 as a function of @xmath78 for the indicated values of @xmath42 .
the function @xmath89 never changes sign , while the function @xmath90 does .
note that for @xmath56 , the values of @xmath89 and @xmath90 have been multiplied by @xmath93.[yzypzp ] , width=604 ] alnes , amarazguioui , and grn also calculate the luminosity distance as a function of redshift , assuming that the observer is in the center of the underdense region ( @xmath94 ) .
the photon geodesic equation for the position of the photon as a function of time , @xmath95 or @xmath96 , is found from the ltb metric @xcite : @xmath97 where we have used the new comoving radial coordinate @xmath61 .
the redshift of the photon , @xmath98 or @xmath99 , is @xcite @xmath100 equations ( [ xofv ] ) and ( [ zofv ] ) are solved with initial conditions @xmath101 at @xmath102 .
the luminosity distance is then simply @xmath103 a graph of the luminosity distance as a function of redshift is shown in fig.[dlz ] . the striking feature in fig . [ dlz ]
is that the ltb model resembles a dark - energy model .
aag show that their ltb model is a better fit to the `` gold '' data set of riess _
_ @xcite than the concordance @xmath14cdm model ( at the expense of additional parameters ) . with our different choice for @xmath104 , @xmath105 in our model is slightly different than the agg choice of parameters , but nevertheless demonstrates a shape characteristic of @xmath14cdm models .
note that as @xmath106 , @xmath105 follows the curve expected for the empty model .
this is because the center of the void _ is _ , in fact , evolving as an empty universe at late times .
cdm is the standard @xmath14cdm model with @xmath107 , the model labeled eds is the eds model , and the model labeled empty is an empty universe model .
rather than @xmath108 , we show the usual difference in the distance modulus compared to the empty model .
[ dlz ] , width=604 ] whether our ( or aag s ) ltb model is a better fit than @xmath14cdm in light of new data is inconsequential .
our goal is not to champion any particular ltb model as a cosmological model that describes our universe , but rather to explore the failure of the no - go argument that inhomogeneities can not describe @xmath105 because the spacetime of our universe can be expressed in the perturbed newtonian form .
we note that in the ltb model there is no dark energy , and since there is only a pressureless component to the stress - tensor , no individual fluid element undergoes local acceleration .
_ we emphasize that observations can not directly establish that there is dark energy , or even that the universe accelerates in the usual sense .
they only tell us that high - redshift supernovae are about one - half magnitude fainter than expected in the einstein - de sitter model .
_ stronger statements have additional ( always unstated ) model assumptions ! in the next section
we will discuss the formulation of the model using a perturbed conformal poisson metric .
but before turning to the main issue of this paper , we note that although no fluid element in the ltb model undergoes local acceleration , one can easily show that in the backreaction proposal a suitably volume - averaged definition of the scale factor has negative pressure ( see refs .
@xcite for a discussion ) .
this is related to the averaging issue in cosmology as emphasized by buchert and ellis @xcite .
the ltb model of the previous section is an example of a nonlinear cosmological model .
it is also a model that exhibits an observable that is very different from the unperturbed model ( eds ) .
our goal now is to investigate where and why the `` no - go '' argument discussed in the introduction fails . to get insights
, we will express the ltb metric , eq .
( [ ltbmetric ] ) , in the form of a perturbed conformal poisson metric with small potentials .
we will consider a metric perturbed about the eds ( spatially flat ) background . in the metric we adopt ,
vector and tensor perturbations are absent : the perturbations are given by the potentials @xmath8 and @xmath109 ) .
the differences are that in the perturbed conformal poisson metric the spatial perturbation ( @xmath110 ) need not equal the temporal perturbation ( @xmath8 ) , and the perturbed conformal newtonian metric also has the additional restrictions on the metric coefficients discussed after eq.([newtpert ] ) . ] @xmath111,\ ] ] where @xmath112 is conformal time , @xmath113 . when considering a dust model ( or , in general , in the absence of anisotropic stress )
, one usually takes the same scalar perturbation in both the spatial and temporal part of the metric , that is , @xmath114 .
also , it is usually assumed that the potentials are time independent .
as we will soon show , however , we will have to allow the two potentials to differ and be time dependent : this is caused directly by the nonlinear structure of the ltb model .
this can be seen mathematically by the fact that in the case @xmath115 , the system of equations will be overconstrained if we are beyond linear order .
the cause of why @xmath116 and they are time dependent is actually one of the main issues we will try to understand in this paper : what we want to show is that it is not possible to describe the aag model by means of the perturbed conformal newtonian metric of eq.([newtpert ] ) as far as the linearized theory is concerned .
of course , this behavior is due to the fact that the aag model has an initial density and curvature perturbation which is not within the linear regime of perturbation theory . even though this is the specific cause of the particular behavior of the aag model
, we will try to learn the general physical cause of that behavior
. the aag model will be just a tool to understand the general lesson about the importance of voids not dynamically restricted which , as we will explain , are a key - feature to evade the no - go argument discussed in the introduction .
we point out that the calculations we are going to show are consistent with the standard result that at linear order the potentials are time - independent and identical : @xmath115 .
it is indeed possible to show ( see ref.@xcite ) that if there is no time dependence , then the equations will not overconstrain the scalar potentials in the case @xmath114 . in the next subsection
we will set up the gauge transformation needed to calculate the potentials @xmath8 and @xmath110 of the metric of eq.([nmetric ] ) in the perturbed conformal poisson metric corresponding to the ltb metric of eq .
( [ ltbmetric ] ) in the synchronous gauge . to be able to compare the metrics of eqs .
( [ ltbmetric ] ) and ( [ nmetric ] ) , we will express the latter in the synchronous gauge .
we will use the gauge transformations of the linearized theory : the consistency of this will be discussed later .
the generic form of the perturbed eds model , both in cartesian and spherical coordinates , is @xcite @xmath117dx^idx^j\right\ } \nonumber \\ & = & a^2(\tau ) \left[-(1 + 2 \psi ) d\tau^2 - 2\omega'dr d\tau + \left(1 - 2\phi+\frac{2}{3 } \upsilon \right)dr^2 + \left(1 - 2 \phi-\frac{1}{3}\upsilon\right)r^2 d\omega^2\right ] , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath118 and @xmath119 .
because of spherical symmetry we are including only longitudinal degrees of freedom in the metric perturbations . under a gauge transformation
the metric perturbations transform according to @xmath120 where @xmath121 and @xmath122 express the gauge freedom . in radial coordinates , @xmath123 .
this transformation corresponds to a diffeomorphism which keeps the perturbations in eq .
( [ wmetric ] ) small : this is actually the definition of gauge transformations in the linearized theory .
the new coordinates are given by @xmath124 where again only the longitudinal component has been taken into account .
will appear in the equations since the displacement is @xmath125 .
] in the following , @xmath126 , and @xmath127 will refer to the quantities in the ltb synchronous gauge , while the corresponding quantities without the tilde will refer to quantities in the perturbed conformal poisson metric .
we can now choose the gauge transformations in order to end up with @xmath128 , that is , to end up in the synchronous gauge .
taking in account that we are coming from a metric of the form eq.([nmetric ] ) , which has @xmath129 and @xmath130 , we find from eqs.([psitilde ] ) and ( [ omegatilde ] ) that @xmath131 these expressions can be expressed in integral form as @xmath132 where the overbar denotes the quantity evaluated at @xmath133 , the initial time of the evolution ( @xmath134 corresponds to @xmath56 ) . the time - independent integration functions @xmath135 and @xmath136 express the residual gauge freedom , which we are going to discuss shortly .
but before doing that , let us make use of the remaining two gauge transformations , eqs .
( [ phitilde ] ) and ( [ chitilde ] ) . comparing the ltb metric , eq .
( [ ltbmetric ] ) , with the form of the perturbed metric , eq . ( [ wmetric ] ) , we see @xmath137 now compare the perturbed conformal poisson metric , eq . ( [ nmetric ] )
, with the form of the perturbed metric , eq . ( [ wmetric ] ) , with result that @xmath138 .
the general solution to this equation is @xmath139 , where @xmath140 and @xmath141 are constant in @xmath27 ( but possibly time - dependent ) . in our case
we are describing a model where @xmath142 as @xmath58 , _
i.e. , _ it approaches the unperturbed eds solution at large @xmath27 , so we must choose @xmath143 .
therefore @xmath144 . since we know @xmath145 and @xmath146 , we can write @xmath147 since we know @xmath121 and @xmath122 in terms of the potentials and initial data for @xmath121 and @xmath122 from eqs .
( [ zetart ] ) and ( [ betart ] ) , we finally find the dynamical equations for the potentials @xmath148 and @xmath149 : @xmath150 these are the dynamical equations to solve for @xmath149 and @xmath148 . before solving ,
it is illustrative to evaluate eqs .
( [ dy1 ] ) and ( [ dy2 ] ) at the initial time @xmath133 to find the integration functions @xmath135 and @xmath151 .
the result is @xmath152 \label{zebeze}\\ \bar{\beta}'(r ) & = & r \int_r^\infty\frac{w^2(r_1)-1}{2r_1w^2(r_1)}dr_1 .
\label{bebebe}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the fact that @xmath153 was used in eq .
( [ zebeze ] ) : all the gauge quantities have to go to zero as @xmath58 where the spacetime is exact einstein - de sitter . the residual gauge freedom expressed by @xmath135 and @xmath151 is therefore fixed by the value of @xmath110 at initial time , that is , by the initial conditions of the hole in the synchronous gauge .
note that @xmath154 must vanish at the center of the hole because of spherical symmetry .
only @xmath121 is allowed to be nonzero at @xmath94 .
with some manipulation we can express eqs .
( [ dy1 ] ) and ( [ dy2 ] ) in a more manageable form .
the difference of eqs .
( [ dy1 ] ) and ( [ dy2 ] ) yields one equation , while combining eq .
( [ dy1 ] ) with eq .
( [ dy2 ] ) multiplied by @xmath27 and then differentiated with respect to @xmath27 yields a second equation : @xmath155 where the functions @xmath156 and @xmath157 are defined as @xmath158 using the fact that as @xmath58 , the potentials and their derivatives must vanish , we can integrate eqs .
( [ ni1 ] ) and ( [ ni11 ] ) with respect to @xmath27 to obtain @xmath159 final manipulations involving multiple differentiations with respect to @xmath160 and integration by parts yield the results : @xmath161 where @xmath162 .
note that the integration functions @xmath135 and @xmath151 have disappeared from the final solution .
they are , however , determined by the value of @xmath163 at initial time as seen from eqs .
( [ zebeze ] ) and ( [ bebebe ] ) . for completeness
we give the expressions for @xmath164 and @xmath165 : @xmath166 now we are in a position to express the potentials , the displacements in time , @xmath167 , and radial coordinate , @xmath168 , in terms of the new radial coordinate @xmath84 . in terms of the variables @xmath47 and @xmath48 defined in sec .
[ theltb ] , the expressions are @xmath169 the functions @xmath170 , @xmath171 , @xmath172 , and @xmath173 are @xmath174 where , as before , @xmath42 .
the evolution equations for @xmath47 and @xmath48 are given in eqs .
( [ dynamicaleqs ] ) .
the initial conditions are @xmath175 at @xmath176 .
it is clear that for an eds solution ( @xmath177 , @xmath178 , and @xmath179 ) the sources @xmath170 , @xmath171 , @xmath172 , and @xmath173 vanish .
since we will never allow shell crossing in the evolution , each shell evolves separately . in the next sections we will present the results for the potentials and coordinate displacements .
first , we show in fig .
[ pp2 ] the values of the potentials @xmath180 and @xmath181 for various values of @xmath182 .
there are several striking features .
first of all , at the initial time , @xmath56 ( as well as for @xmath183 ) , @xmath110 and @xmath8 are greater than unity for @xmath184 .
also striking is the fact that near @xmath185 , @xmath186 . for @xmath187 , @xmath110 and @xmath8
are smaller than unity , but they have different signs . and @xmath181 as function of @xmath78 for the indicated values of @xmath91 .
the potential @xmath180 is indicated by solid curves and the potential @xmath181 is indicated by dashed curves . in the lower half of the figure
the values of @xmath91 are indicated only for @xmath181 ; the values of @xmath91 for @xmath180 are , from top to bottom , @xmath188 , @xmath189 , @xmath190 , and @xmath191 . in the upper half of the figure ,
the values of @xmath78 at the horizon are indicated by a vertical dotted line for @xmath183 ( leftmost line ) and @xmath192 .
[ pp2 ] , width=604 ] in the next section we will explain the reason for this behavior . here , we note that when the potentials are greater than unity , they are constant within the horizon . if we take the initial epoch to be @xmath56 , then @xmath193 is found by solving eq .
( [ xofv ] ) . the value of @xmath193 for the ltb metric is not too much different than the corresponding value for the eds model , @xmath194 . in the eds model , @xmath195 , and @xmath196 at @xmath197 , and @xmath191 respectively . in fig .
[ pp2 ] we indicate values of @xmath193 for @xmath183 and @xmath198 . as seen in fig
. [ pp2 ] , when the potentials are larger than unity , within the scale of the horizon , they are very nearly constant .
we will return to this point in sect .
[ conclusions ] .
now we turn to fig .
[ dtdr ] where we show the coordinate differences between the ltb metric and the perturbed conformal poisson metric .
first , let us examine @xmath199 .
at the initial point in the evolution @xmath200 is much larger than unity and positive .
so even at the very beginning of the calculation _ we can not express the ltb metric in terms of a perturbed conformal newtonian metric !
_ this occurs even though the metric is everywhere regular , and density perturbations are not highly nonlinear . and coordinate displacement @xmath201 as a function of @xmath78 for the indicated values of @xmath91 . the time displacement @xmath199 is negative for @xmath56 , @xmath202 , and @xmath203 .
it is positive for @xmath204 , @xmath190 , and @xmath191 . for @xmath56 ,
@xmath104 is positive , for all other values of @xmath91 , @xmath104 is negative . clearly , @xmath205 vanishes in the limit @xmath206 as it must .
[ dtdr ] , width=604 ] eventually , when @xmath91 drops below about @xmath188 , @xmath200 becomes smaller than unity and continues to decrease . in the next section
we will discuss the cause of this behavior .
now let us turn to @xmath104 .
at the initial point in the evolution , @xmath56 , @xmath104 is positive .
this means that @xmath207 , or the coordinate label in the perturbed conformal poisson metric is greater than the coordinate label in the synchronous gauge . for other values of @xmath91
, @xmath104 is negative ( _ i.e. , _
@xmath208 , or the coordinate label in the perturbed conformal poisson metric is less than the coordinate label in the synchronous gauge ) .
finally , we turn to the issue of peculiar velocities .
we first remark that the dust ltb metric of eq .
( [ ltbmetric ] ) is comoving : there are _ no _ peculiar velocities . again denoting a quantity in the synchronous frame by a tilde ,
the four - velocity is @xmath209 .
however in the poisson frame there are peculiar velocities ( see also @xcite ) . at linear order , under a coordinate transformation @xmath210
, we have ( quantities in the poisson frame do not carry a tilde ) : @xmath211 from this we find ( @xmath212 is a unit vector in the radial direction ) @xmath213 as expected , the change in the four - velocities is of the same order as the gauge transformation . at linear order @xmath214 and @xmath215 .
the value of @xmath216 would be interpreted as a peculiar velocity .
now we express the four - velocity as @xmath217 .
the three - velocity is @xmath218 at linear order .
using this , @xmath219 , so @xmath220 the result for @xmath221 as a function of @xmath61 is shown in fig .
[ ur ] for several values of @xmath91 .
the large initial values of the velocity are the key to understanding why the perturbative description breaks down . for the indicated values of @xmath91 .
a negative ( positive ) value corresponds to a radial velocity towards ( away from ) the center .
[ ur ] , width=604 ] we now turn to the discussion .
the linear gauge transformation we have performed in the previous section is a useful tool to understand where and why the no - go argument discussed in the introduction fails . in this section , first we will introduce the _ general _ physical cause of the breakdown of the description by means of the perturbed conformal poisson metric
. then we will show how this general feature shows up in the model here examined .
finally we will conclude the section with some comments about other models developed in the literature .
the description by means of the perturbed conformal poisson metric breaks down because of the large @xmath222 in the aag model . as can be seen from fig .
[ h ] , @xmath223 is of order unity .
a large @xmath222 is a typical feature of models with inhomogeneities , and from this point of view we think the ltb model is a useful tool to study the consequences of the evolution of structures in the real universe . in particular , the aag version allows us to follow the evolution of the inhomogeneities for a rather large time span , thanks to the large initial infall velocity of the shells ( negative value of @xmath224 for @xmath56 , as can be seen from fig .
[ h ] ) . for the indicated values of @xmath91 .
[ h ] , width=604 ] a different expansion rate means a different flrw solution , and even if the initial @xmath222 is small , the two solutions ( void and eds ) will eventually follow very different evolutions .
what we have in mind is the comparison of a background flrw solution in the underdensity ( the void region ) and in the flrw solution at large @xmath78 .
we will denote the value of @xmath78 beyond which the solution is approximately eds as @xmath80 .
we make the point that these two patches have different backgrounds , even though the `` average '' background _ is _ the eds solution .
the aag model can indeed be thought of as an exact swiss - cheese model matched to the density and the ( zero ) curvature of the eds solution at a sufficiently large radius ( @xmath225 ) .
we can imagine populating the universe with other holes of radius @xmath226 . on scales larger than any spherical hole
, the aag model evolves as the eds model . from this perspective , in the framework developed by buchert @xcite , the backreaction of the inhomogeneities is zero .
( see refs .
@xcite for a discussion . ) here , we find a lack of a global background in spite of the absence of a volume backreaction .
it can happen that at some specific time the background of the void patch is close to the eds solution .
this will be , however , a special moment because of the different evolution of the two patches .
it will be more typical to have a large departure from the eds flow , which will be manifest in a large @xmath222 or in large `` peculiar '' velocities .
these `` peculiar '' velocities are the result of comparing the cosmic evolution of two different flrw solutions , or , in other words , the results of perturbing about the wrong background . summarizing , _ an inhomogeneous universe featuring voids can not be studied by means of a global homogeneous background , and this holds even
if the inhomogeneities do not affect , as it happens in a swiss - cheese model , the global evolution_. what we have just discussed is clearly shown by the results obtained in the previous section . to understand them it is useful to focus on two key quantities .
first , it is possible to show ( see the appendix [ quadro ] ) that the value of @xmath110 at the origin has the following time dependence : @xmath227 where @xmath228 describes the scale factor of the void region . in turn
, this implies that @xmath229 .
this expression makes clear that @xmath230 can be thought as the time integral of @xmath222 .
a similar relation holds for @xmath154 ( see the appendix [ quadro ] ) : @xmath231 .
this implies that @xmath232 , where we note that @xmath233 , the velocity of the comoving matter in the poisson frame shown in fig .
[ ur ] , is , as expected , almost the same as the `` peculiar '' velocity of the comoving matter with respect to the eds background : @xmath234 where the last relation holds because , as we have seen , @xmath235 is of order unity .
( we have also used the fact that @xmath26 is very close to unity . ) expressing these key - quantities as a function of @xmath222 , which is the source of the effects , will help us in understanding the results of the previous section .
first , at early times ( @xmath236 ) `` peculiar '' velocities are larger than @xmath237 , as can be seen in fig .
. the reason can be understood from eq .
( [ pecp ] ) : at early times @xmath238 is indeed large .
this highlights the usefulness of the aag model , which allows us to encompass both early times with a large expansion rate and the present time .
this also illustrates the interesting fact that even with smaller @xmath222 we could have large peculiar velocities at early times when one might expect the system to be accurately described as a perturbation of an eds universe .
these large velocities cause the potentials to be greater than unity and the perturbed conformal poisson metric to be unable to describe the metric in the void region . in the linear gauge transformation
this shows up as the fact that peculiar velocities are of the same order as the gauge transformation .
this is a general breakdown which affects the perturbed conformal poisson metric even if we perform a nonlinear gauge transformation @xcite
. evaluated at @xmath185 ( dashed curve ) and @xmath239 ( solid curve ) as a function of @xmath240 .
[ nb ] , width=604 ] at later times , velocities become order @xmath241 as can be seen from fig.[ur ] ; this is caused by the slowing down of the expansion . however , both @xmath242 and @xmath110 do not depend on @xmath222 , but rather on its time integral , or , in other words , on the different size of the void region compared to the eds region , that is , on @xmath243 .
this dependence appears in @xmath110 because it is the spatial perturbation that has to connect these two differently expanding spatial regions .
the reason for the breakdown of the linear transformation is , therefore , the growth of @xmath242 , that is , the departure of the two metrics .
this shows up directly in @xmath110 .
the basic problem is that the linear gauge transformation neglects terms like ( @xmath244 compared to terms like @xmath110 : see eq .
( [ phitilde ] ) . as you can see from fig .
[ nb ] , this approximation is no longer valid for @xmath245 .
so even if the velocities are small , the linear transformation breaks down because their time - integrated effect is large . as a consequence
we find , for example , @xmath186 .
it is however possible to describe the late evolution of the model in the perturbed conformal newtonian metric by means of a nonlinear gauge transformation whose potential follows nonlinear equations of motion @xcite .
we will comment now on the models of refs .
@xcite and @xcite .
according to ref .
@xcite there is no breakdown of the perturbed conformal newtonian metric during the dynamical evolution of the _ particular _ ( it is important to not generalize ) ltb model the authors have considered .
the model of ref .
@xcite does not deal with the possibility of using the perturbed conformal newtonian metric to describe the spacetime of the universe , but it will nevertheless help us to make our point because it is a model which can be described with the perturbed conformal newtonian metric if we perform a nonlinear gauge transformation .
we start noting that in both ref .
@xcite and ref .
@xcite the validity of the perturbed conformal newtonian metric is assumed as a starting point .
these particular models are not allowed to have large peculiar velocities .
the point is that this is a particular choice , and , in our opinion , not general as demonstrated by the dependence in eq.([pecp ] ) of the peculiar velocities on @xmath222 .
we would like to stress again that these `` background '' peculiar velocities have nothing to do with anything that can be measured as a local effect .
therefore , the models of refs .
@xcite and @xcite over - restrict the dynamics of the inhomogeneities , or , equivalently , demand the existence of a global background .
for example , in the model of ref .
@xcite , the initial @xmath222 of eq .
( [ pecp ] ) is exactly zero , and in the model of ref .
@xcite it is @xmath246 .
therefore , these models serve as an illustration to show the circular reasoning at the basis of the no - go argument : if we demand that the spacetime metric of the inhomogeneous universe has a global background without any departure due to differently evolving regions , then we will find the validity of the perturbed conformal newtonian metric .
this is the main point of this work , and the linear gauge transformation is a useful tool to understand it .
it is interesting to note that the model of ref .
@xcite can confront the sne data , but its luminosity distance does not show a big departure in shape from the eds one , while the aag model features a luminosity distance similar to the @xmath14cdm model .
this is mainly due to the size of the hole , roughly @xmath189 times smaller than the aag one .
we point out that if we want to have a @xmath14cdm - like luminosity distance in a setup with only one hole and the observer at the center , then we will likely have large background peculiar velocities .
this might , however , be a typical , but not a general feature . to illustrate this
we have calculated the luminosity distance for the model of ref .
@xcite , but with a hole roughly @xmath189 times larger : we found that @xmath247 always .
this can be seen , again , as due to a restriction on the dynamics : allowing larger peculiar velocities we find voids with more general dynamics .
we stress again the usefulness of the aag model in showing these general features .
the ltb model analyzed in this paper is a very useful toy model to explore the role of large inhomogeneities in the determination of cosmological observables such as the luminosity distance as a function of redshift .
we employed the toy model to demonstrate where and why the no - go argument discussed in the introduction fails . to this end
we have performed a linear gauge transformation in order to understand the problems we have to face if we want to express the ltb model in the form of a perturbed conformal newtonian metric , eq.([newtpert ] ) .
we would like to stress that we regard the aag model as a tool useful to show a general feature needed to evade the no - go argument : we focused on the _ general _ physical cause of the nonlinear behavior of the aag model more than on its particular initial conditions .
we came to the conclusion that the way the no - go argument is proved is by assuming , as a starting point , the validity of the argument itself .
the way to escape the no - go argument is by allowing large `` background peculiar velocities , '' where these velocities have nothing to do with , _
e.g. , _ velocity dispersions in clusters or anything that can be measured as a local effect .
if indeed inhomogeneities are responsible for the `` apparent '' acceleration of the universe , then the evolution of the expansion rate must resemble a @xmath14cdm model . if that is true , then there will naturally be `` peculiar '' velocities if one describes the evolution in terms of perturbations of an eds model .
one can not simply assume peculiar velocities are small and then use that as a basis to show inhomogeneities can have no effect .
in the calculation of peculiar velocities it is necessary to specify a background solution about which to calculate velocities .
the peculiar velocities can be small in the @xmath14cdm background but not in the eds background .
the velocities appear as a departure from eds of the hubble flow , preventing the metric from being written in the conformal newtonian form .
in other words , to evade the no - go argument we need to free the inhomogeneous models of dynamical restrictions ( small background peculiar velocities ) which impose the existence of a global background . another way to see how the no - go argument of eq .
( [ newtpert ] ) fails is through the equations of motion : in order to have a model , _
e.g. , _ an ltb model , explain the observed departure of @xmath105 from the eds result requires nonlinear equations of motion , and this is because of the large background peculiar velocities which can generally occur . by this ,
we mean that in order to end up with a large spatial variation of the background @xmath248 requires a nonlinear evolution like the one of the ltb model discussed in this paper . and
this can occur even if it is possible , as in the aag model , to describe an inhomogeneous universe by means of the perturbed conformal newtonian metric from ( let s say ) @xmath249 to present time .
this is shown here by explicit calculation .
therefore , one must reconsider very carefully the statement that inhomogeneities can not have a significant effect on cosmological observables such as the luminosity distance as a function of redshift if arguments are based on the _ assumption _ that the metric describing our universe can be written in the perturbed conformal newtonian form of eq .
( [ newtpert ] ) .
now we enumerate some of our findings . 1 . in the model we consider , even at late times
when the density contrast is linear and the velocities are small , one can not express the ltb metric in the perturbed conformal newtonian form of eq .
( [ newtpert ] ) by means of a linear gauge transformation .
the breakdown of the linear transformation clearly shows the importance of background velocities .
+ the linear gauge transformation breaks down mainly because of the large @xmath250 .
this is caused by the different expansion rates ( @xmath251 ) of the void and the eds solution , as can be seen in fig .
[ h ] , which shows the expansion rates as a function of @xmath78 for several values of @xmath91 .
the result is that the two metrics do not remain close enough for a linear transformation to connect them .
as discussed in the previous section , the basic problem is that the linear gauge transformation neglects terms like ( @xmath252 compared to terms like @xmath110 .
summarizing , the cause of the break down of the linear gauge transformation is the large @xmath222 , and the underlying cause of that is the nonlinearity of the equations of motion .
the failure described above can be stated as the fact that the linearized equations of motion work only for a limited range of times .
2 . it is possible to find a nonlinear gauge transformation to overcome this problem with a perturbed conformal newtonian metric description of the ltb metric whose potential follows nonlinear equations @xcite
. these nonlinear equations ( which are actually the exact einstein equations ) at some time will typically give large potentials and make the perturbed conformal newtonian gauge description inconsistent ( large @xmath253 in the ltb model examined ) because at some point the peculiar velocities will be larger than @xmath237 if we do not restrict the dynamics , as shown by the aag model .
although at the present time , in the model we consider , the magnitude of the potentials are small , they are not equal at the level of the linearized theory , _ viz .
_ @xmath116 .
this could navely be interpreted as some anisotropic stress or something else funny with the stress tensor .
this is exactly the point that has been made in , _
ref.@xcite : analyzing an inhomogeneous model in the framework of a homogeneous model introduces spurious components and behavior to the stress tensor ( _ possibly even a negative - pressure fluid ! _ ) .
4 . if we start with a perturbed eds model , then the growth of perturbations will lead to the formation of large voids , filamentary structure , and other nonlinearities .
perhaps the ltb models are useful toy models to study the effect of that phenomenon .
the model explored in this paper is a good example because it is capable of dealing with nonlinearities within a large timespan .
finally , another point worth mentioning is the physical nature of super - hubble modes of @xmath110 and @xmath8 . at the initial time , within each hubble radius patch , @xmath110 and @xmath8 are very nearly constant , but possibly larger than one ( with a value of about @xmath254 near the origin ) .
that _ does not _
mean that we can simply subtract different values , because we are only allowed to do this once .
if we do it at @xmath56 , then at @xmath255 we would have @xmath110 and @xmath8 near the origin of @xmath256 .
summarizing , inhomogeneities , in particular voids not dynamically restricted , undermine the existence of a global background .
the interesting question for future consideration is if backreactionscdm - like luminosity distance , then it is not straightforward to understand which category of backreaction ( weak or strong ) the model belongs to .
the strong backreaction indeed is about a change of background , but this is also the case for the weak backreaction because , as in the case of this example , it `` defines '' an effective background , the @xmath14cdm model .
moreover , the change of background of the strong backreaction should be related to observable data on the light cone as it is for the weak backreaction .
] of cosmological perturbations can substantially distort derived conclusions about the energy - momentum tensor of the universe without allowing dramatic violations of _ statistical _ homogeneity .
the present work addresses the key issue that backreaction effects can not be assumed _ in principle _ to be small on the basis of the no - go argument explained in the introduction and therefore opens a wide range of possibilities to tackle the study of the inhomogeneities in the universe . it is a pleasure to thank j. m. bardeen , t. buchert , s. m. carroll , k. van acoleyen and h. van elst for useful discussions , comments and suggestions .
this work was supported in part by the department of energy . v.m .
would like to acknowledge the kavli institute for cosmological physics for hosting a visit to the university of chicago and `` fondazione angelo della riccia '' for support .
s.m . and v.m .
acknowledge asi contract i/016/07/0 cofis " for partial financial support .
in this appendix we will discuss the approximations used in sect.[discussion ] .
although we have checked numerically that they hold , we will present here an analytic explanation .
the second term dominates the expression for @xmath149 in eqs.([finalphi ] ) or ( [ phinew ] ) , so in the limit that @xmath259 , @xmath260 can be written as @xmath261^{2 } \frac{r_1}{2 } dr_1 , \ ] ] where we defined @xmath262 as the coordinate radius at which the metric is the eds one ( it will disappear from the final expression ) . to proceed further ,
define a function @xmath263 as @xmath264^{2 } \frac{r_1}{2 } dr_1 = - c(0,t ) \left [ \int_0^{r_{\textrm{eds } } } \left(\frac{r}{a \ , r_1 } -1 \right ) ' \frac{r_1}{2 } dr_1 \right ]
^2 \left [ \int_0^{r_{\textrm{eds } } } \frac{r_1}{2 } dr_1 \right]^{-1 } .\ ] ] now define @xmath265 where @xmath266 gives the scale factor for the flrw solution at the center .
thanks to birkhoff s theorem , outer shells do not influence the center , which can be indeed thought as a homogeneous patch .
expanding @xmath35 in the void region as , thanks to the fact that @xmath267 as discussed in ref .
@xcite . ] @xmath268 we find @xmath269 where , after integrating by parts , we have made the approximation that the void region occupies almost all of the volume of the hole of radius @xmath262 .
now we wish to show that @xmath263 depends only weakly on time . to this end , we expand @xmath270 and @xmath271^{2}$ ] in @xmath27 around @xmath262 to third order , that is up to the fourth derivative of @xmath57 with respect to @xmath27 , and then we plug the resulting series in the integrals .
the result is @xmath272 the first remark is that the term proportional to @xmath273 cancels .
the dependence on time is therefore in the @xmath274 term .
following a procedure similar to this one used to obtain eq .
( 3.5 ) of ref .
@xcite , but keeping both density and curvature inhomogeneities , we find : @xmath275 where @xmath276 , @xmath277 is a constant , @xmath278 is the eds density , and @xmath279 is the initial averaged density .
we see , therefore , that a general condition to have the constancy of @xmath280 is that the second and third derivatives with respect to @xmath27 of @xmath281 and @xmath29 are proportional , so that the time dependence cancels .
this is indeed the case in the aag model .
we remark that @xmath281 and @xmath29 can be seen as the defining functions for a ltb model , and this result holds thanks to the matching guaranteed by @xmath282 .
we now discuss the approximation that @xmath283 .
starting from eq .
( [ berta ] ) , with the approximation that @xmath284 , we have @xmath285.\ ] ] now from fig .
[ yzypzp ] , the term in the square brackets oscillates about one , so it is not a bad approximation to set it to unity .
the integral can then be done with the result that @xmath286 , used in sect .
[ discussion ] .
g. f. r. ellis , relativistic cosmology its nature , aims and problems . in _ general relativity and gravitation _ ( d. reidel publishing co. , dordrecht ) , ed .
b. bertotti , f. de felice and a. pascolini , pp . 215288 ( 1984 ) . | it has been argued that the spacetime of our universe can be accurately described by a perturbed conformal newtonian metric , and hence even large density inhomogeneities in a dust universe can not change the observables predicted by the homogeneous dust model . in this paper
we study a spherically symmetric dust model and illustrate conditions under which large spatial variations in the expansion rate can invalidate the argument . |
since long ago the hybrid system @xmath6 , made out of @xmath29-particle , proton and electron , @xmath0 , was attempted to explore for field - free case @xcite and for the case of a magnetic field of moderate strength @xmath40a.u .
@xcite . in both studies
no indication to appearance of a bound state was observed .
here we will show that for larger magnetic fields @xmath30 g the exotic hybrid ion @xmath6 can exist in parallel configuration as optimal being a sufficiently long - living state .
it decays to @xmath41 . for all magnetic fields
the binding energy of @xmath6 is slightly smaller than the binding energy of the atomic ion @xmath42 and their difference decreases as a magnetic field grows . in parallel configuration
the orbital momentum projection on the molecular axis is preserved and eigenstates are characterized by magnetic quantum number @xmath43 , for the ground state @xmath44 ( perron theorem ) .
the hamiltonian which describes two infinitely heavy centers @xmath45 and @xmath46 of charges @xmath47 and @xmath48 situated along the line forming the angle @xmath49 with the @xmath50axis , and electron placed in a uniform constant magnetic field directed along the @xmath50axis , @xmath51 is given by @xmath52 ( for geometrical setting see fig .
1 ) . in the case of @xmath6
the charges @xmath53 and @xmath54 correspond to the @xmath55particle and the proton as heavy charged centers .
the vector potential is given by a certain one - parameter family of vector potentials corresponding to a constant magnetic field @xmath56 @xmath57 where @xmath58 is a parameter .
the position of the _ gauge center _ or _ gauge origin _
, where @xmath59 , is defined by @xmath60 , with @xmath61 arbitrary . for simplicity
we fix @xmath62 .
the gauge origin @xmath63 is chosen to be located somewhere along the line connecting the charged centers but not necessarily coinciding with the mid - point @xmath64 ( see fig . [ fig:1 ] ) . if @xmath65 we get the well - known and widely used symmetric or circular gauge .
if @xmath66 or 1 , we get the asymmetric or landau gauge . to study the ground state of the hamiltonian ( [ ham - heh ] ) for the case of the @xmath6 we use the variational method with the physically relevant trial function in a way similar to what was done for the @xmath67 molecular ion in a strong magnetic field ( see @xcite ) .
a general recipe of the choice of the trial function is presented in @xcite .
the trial function has a form @xmath68 where [ psi123-heh ] @xmath69 } + a e^{-{\alpha}_2 r_2 - b [ { \beta}_{2x } \xi x^2 + { \beta}_{2y}(1-\xi ) y^2 ] } } \ , \\
\psi_2 & = & { \large e^{-{\alpha}_3 z r_1 -{\alpha}_4r_2 - b [ { \beta}_{3x } \xi x^2 + { \beta}_{3y}(1-\xi ) y^2]}\ , } \end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath70 , @xmath71 , @xmath72 and @xmath58 are variational parameters . the function @xmath73 simulates the incoherent interaction of the electron with charged centers , where the parameter @xmath74 `` measures '' an asymmetry in the interaction of the electron with @xmath29 and @xmath75 . on the other side
, @xmath76 describes the coherent interaction of the electron with @xmath29 and @xmath75 .
considering the internuclear distance @xmath77 as a variational parameter we have in total @xmath78 variational parameters ( a free normalization of the trial function ( [ psi - heh ] ) allows us to keep fixed one of the parameters @xmath79 ) .
the result of calculations shows that the total energy surface @xmath80 for @xmath81a.u . has global minimum at @xmath82 and a finite internuclear distance @xmath83 which gives rise a valley when @xmath49 begins to vary . for smaller magnetic fields there
exists either no minimum or at most some irregularity . hence if the minima exists the optimal configuration for fixed magnetic field @xmath81a.u
. always corresponds to zero inclination , @xmath82 ( parallel configuration ) , see for illustration fig .
[ fig:2 - 2 ] . furthermore , for any fixed magnetic field there exists a critical inclination @xmath84 beyond of which the minimum in the total energy curve at fixed inclination disappears .
it implies that the system @xmath6 does not exist for inclinations larger than the critical inclination .
for example , for @xmath85a.u . the critical angle @xmath86 , which is much smaller than @xmath87 for @xmath67 @xcite .
the total energy @xmath88 , binding energy @xmath89 and equilibrium distance @xmath90 as well as the position and the height of the barrier on the total energy curve of the system @xmath0 in parallel configuration for various magnetic fields are presented in table [ table:1 ] .
binding energy of @xmath6 is always larger than the binding energy of the hydrogen atom .
this implies that ion @xmath6 does not decay to @xmath91 .
in general , the binding energy of @xmath6 grows very fast with the magnetic field increase being smaller than the binding ( ionization ) energy of the @xmath42 atomic ion .
it continues till @xmath92 g when these two binding energies coincide . at larger magnetic fields @xmath93 g the total energy of @xmath6 becomes lower than the total energy of @xmath94 ( see table i ) .
it implies the following picture . at the magnetic fields @xmath95 g the ion @xmath6 is unstable towards a decay to @xmath41 .
however , at @xmath96 g this decay is forbidden and the exotic molecular ion @xmath6 becomes stable . from a domain when decay is permitted to a domain where it is forbidden (
see table i ) .
an increase in accuracy of the total energy of @xmath6 and/or @xmath14 can easily shift this point . ] in figs .
[ fig:2 - 1]-[fig:2 - 2 ] the total energy of @xmath97 viz .
internuclear distance @xmath77 is shown at @xmath98a.u . and @xmath85a.u .
, respectively , as an illustration . at large internuclear distances
@xmath77 , the behavior of the total energy is defined by the interaction of @xmath42 and @xmath75 .
it can be modeled by the repulsive @xmath99-interaction term that is displayed by the dotted line in fig .
[ fig:2 - 2 ] , which is in good agreement with the results of our variational calculations . the equilibrium distance @xmath90 shrinks down quite drastically , reducing almost by a factor of three from @xmath98a.u . to @xmath100 g
( see table [ table:1 ] ) .
thus , the @xmath97 ion becomes more compact as the magnetic field increases .
the position of the maximum @xmath101 of the total energy curve @xmath102 also reduces with magnetic field increase but not so dramatically as for @xmath90 ( see table [ table:1 ] ) .
together with the increase of the height of the barrier ( see table [ table:1 ] ) , it indicates an increase in lifetime of @xmath97 with magnetic field growth .
the lifetime is always very large .
the electronic distribution is always a single - peak one with the peak position shifted towards the charge @xmath103 . as an illustration
the electronic distribution is presented for @xmath85a.u . in fig .
[ fig:2e ] . at @xmath104
g the lowest vibrational state of @xmath6 can also exist ( see table [ table:1 ] and for illustration fig .
[ fig:2 - 2 ] ) . as for rotational states , we calculated the energy of the lowest rotational state following the procedure developed in @xcite for the @xmath67 molecular ion .
the rotational energy grows with a magnetic field increase being systematically larger than vibrational ones unlike the field - free case .
for example , at @xmath85a.u .
the lowest rotational energy is 6.72ry while the lowest vibrational one is equal to 0.65ry only with the height of the barrier 2.481ry ( see table i ) . for magnetic fields @xmath105
g the well keeps the lowest vibrational state but not the lowest rotational state . near the schwinger limit @xmath34 g for both systems @xmath2 and @xmath3 in symmetric configuration @xmath106 and @xmath107 the well - pronounced minimum in total energy occurs at @xmath108 ( see table [ table:7 ] ) . in the same time no indication to appearance of the minimum for asymmetric configuration @xmath109 and @xmath110 is found . for both systems
the discovered potential well is rather shallow , the potential barrier heights are 0.34ry and 0.26ry , respectively .
but as a magnetic field increases it deepens quickly for both systems .
both systems are quite compact ( here the equilibrium distance is defined as a distance between the end - situated heavy particles @xmath111 , see table [ table:7 ] ) .
the lifetimes of these systems are very short .
the ion @xmath18 is highly unstable towards decays @xmath112 , @xmath113 , but it does not decay to @xmath114 or @xmath115 . in turn , the ion @xmath19 is highly unstable towards decays @xmath116 , @xmath117 , but it does not decay to @xmath118 or @xmath119 . _
_ we presented theoretical arguments about a possible existence of exotic ions @xmath32 and @xmath120 as well as some indications to the existence of the exotic ions @xmath121 , @xmath18 , @xmath19 .
a striking conclusion can be drawn that the exotic molecular ion @xmath33 is the most bound one - electron system among those made from protons and/or @xmath10particles at strong magnetic field @xmath122 a.u .
it is then followed by two other @xmath29-particle containing ions : the atomic ion @xmath42 and the hybrid ion @xmath32 - are characterized by slightly larger total energies ( see tables i , iv , vii ) .
it is worth mentioning that @xmath123-atom - the only neutral one - electron system is the least bound one . both ions @xmath120 and @xmath32 can exist also in the excited states . in table
[ table:7 ] a comparison of total energies of different one - electron systems at the magnetic field @xmath124 g is given . in very strong magnetic fields
@xmath125 g the ions @xmath126 are stable . in this domain of magnetic fields a striking relation between the binding energies of @xmath120 and @xmath21
exists : their ratio does not depend on magnetic field and is equal to two .
it may allow to explain the observed ratio of the absorption features of the isolated neutron star 1e1207.4 - 5209 @xcite by the helium - hydrogen content of its atmosphere under a surface magnetic field @xmath127 g @xcite .
kadomtsev and v.s .
kudryavtsev , _
pisma zhetf * 13 * _ , 15 , 61 ( 1971 ) ; + _ sov
jetp lett .
* 13 * _ , 9 , 42 ( 1971 ) ( english translation ) ; + _ zhetf * 62 * _ , 144 ( 1972 ) ; + _ sov . phys .
jetp * 35 * _ , 76 ( 1972 ) ( english translation ) a. turbiner , j.c . lopez and u. solis h. , _
pisma v zhetf * 69 * _ , 800 ( 1999 ) ; + _ jetp lett . *
69 * _ , 844 ( 1999 ) ( english translation ) + ( astro - ph/980929 ) a.v .
turbiner , j.c .
lopez - vieyra and n.l .
guevara , _ phys.rev . * a 71 * _ , 023403 ( 2005 ) + ( astro - ph/0406473 ) j.c . lopez v. and a.v .
turbiner , _ phys.rev . *
a62 * _ , 022510 ( 2000 ) + ( astro - ph/9911535 ) a.v .
turbiner and j.c .
lpez vieyra , _ phys.rev . *
a68 * _ , 012504 ( 2003 ) , a.v .
turbiner and j.c .
lopez vieyra , _ mod.phys.lett .
* a20 * _ , 2845 ( 2005 ) + ( astro - ph/0404290 ) a.v .
turbiner and j.c .
lopez vieyra , _ phys.repts . *
424 * _ , 309 ( 2006 ) d. sanwal , g.g .
pavlov , v.e .
zavlin and m.a .
teter , _ apjl * 574 * _ , l61 ( 2002 ) + ( astro - ph/0206195 ) g.f .
bignami et al . , _ nature * 423 * _ , 725 ( 2003 ) k. mori , j. chonko and c.j .
hailey , _ apj * 631 * _ , 1082 ( 2005 ) + ( astro - ph/0407369 ) a.v .
turbiner and j.c .
lopez vieyra , _ mod.phys.lett . *
a19 * _ , 1919 ( 2004 ) + ( astro - ph/0404290 ) u. wille , _ phys.rev . *
a38 * _ , 3210 ( 1988 ) d. larsen , _ phys.rev .
* a25 * _ , 1295 ( 1982 ) r.d .
benguria , r. brummelhuist , p. duclos and s. prez - oyarzn , _ journ.phys .
* b37 * _ , 2311 ( 2004 ) + ( math - phys/0403034 ) j.c .
lopez , p.o .
hess and a. turbiner , _ phys.rev . * a56 * _ , 4496 ( 1997 ) + ( astro - ph/9707050 ) a.v . turbiner and j.c
lpez vieyra , _ phys . rev . *
a69 * _ , 053413 ( 2004 ) + ( astro - ph/0310849 ) a.y .
potekhin and a.v .
turbiner , _
phys.rev . *
a63 * _ , 065402 ( 2001 ) + ( physics/0101050 ) a.v .
turbiner , _ zhetf * 79 * _ , 1719 ( 1980 ) ; _ soviet phys .- jetp * 52 * _ , 868 ( 1980 ) ( english translation ) ; + _ usp .
fiz . nauk . *
144 * _ , 35 ( 1984 ) ; _ sov .
uspekhi * 27 * _ , 668 ( 1984 ) ( english translation ) ; + _ yad . fiz . *
46 * _ , 204 ( 1987 ) ; _ sov .
journ . of nucl
. phys . * 46 * _ , 125 ( 1987 ) ( english translation ) ; + doctor of sciences thesis , itep , moscow , 1989 ( unpublished ) , `` analytic methods in strong coupling regime ( large perturbation ) in quantum mechanics '' a. bohr and b. mottelson , ` _ nuclear structure _ ' , w. a. benjamin , reading mass . | the coulombic systems @xmath0 and @xmath1 , @xmath2 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 placed in a magnetic field @xmath5 are studied .
it is demonstrated a theoretical existence of the exotic ion @xmath6 for @xmath7 in parallel configuration ( the magnetic field is directed along internuclear axis ) as optimal as well as its excited states @xmath8 . as for the exotic ion @xmath9 it is shown that in spite of strong electrostatic repulsion of @xmath10particles this ion can also exist for @xmath11 in parallel configuration as optimal in the states @xmath12 ( ground state ) , @xmath13 . upon appearance
both ions are unstable towards dissociation with @xmath14 in the final state but with very large lifetime . however , at @xmath15a.u .
the ion @xmath6 becomes stable , while at @xmath16a.u .
the ion @xmath9 becomes stable . with a magnetic field growth ,
both exotic ions become more and more tightly bound and compact , their lowest rotational and vibrational energies grow . at the edge of applicability of non - relativistic approximation , @xmath17 g , there are indications that three more exotic linear ions @xmath18 , @xmath19 and even @xmath20 in parallel configuration may also occur .
the possibility of formation of new exotic chemical compounds which do not exist in field - free case is one of the most fascinating features of the physics in strong magnetic fields @xcite . in particular , it was conjectured long ago that linear neutral chains of molecules ( polymer - type molecules ) situated along a magnetic line might exist in astro - physically strong magnetic fields .
they were called the _
ruderman chains_. in the year 1999 , the first theoretical indication for the existence of the exotic one - electron molecular ion @xmath21 in magnetic fields @xmath22 g was provided @xcite .
it is a sufficiently long - living state for which the optimal configuration is parallel ( all protons situated along a magnetic line ) decaying to @xmath23 .
perhaps , the most astonishing result is an observation of the fast increase of the ionization energy of the exotic @xmath21 ion with a magnetic field growth . eventually , for magnetic fields @xmath24 g the binding energy of the exotic @xmath21 ion becomes larger than the binding energy of the traditional @xmath25 ion . as a result the exotic ion @xmath21 becomes stable as well as the traditional ion @xmath25 and the hydrogen atom .
later in the year 2000 , it was indicated the possible existence of the exotic one - electron molecular ion @xmath26 for magnetic fields @xmath27 g @xcite .
it is worth emphasizing that for _ all _ studied one - electron molecular systems @xmath28 the optimal configuration for @xmath22 g is parallel , when all protons were situated along a magnetic line ( see , in particular , @xcite ) .
very recently , it was announced that two @xmath29-particle contained ions , @xmath6 and @xmath9 can exist at @xmath30 @xcite ( for a discussion and review the status of one - electron systems , see @xcite ) .
usually , the investigations of the coulomb systems in a strong magnetic field were justified by the fact there exists a strong magnetic field on a surface of neutron stars or some white dwarfs .
the recent discovery of absorption features at 0.7kev and 1.4kev in the x - ray spectrum of the isolated neutron star 1e1207.4 - 5209 by chandra @xmath31-ray observatory @xcite and its further confirmation by xmm - newton @xmath31-ray observatory @xcite ( see also @xcite ) motivated more profound and extended studies in a strong magnetic field .
in particular , it was assumed the hydrogenic atmosphere of 1e1207.4 - 5209 with main abundance of the exotic ion @xmath21 @xcite which may explain the above absorption features .
there were already found two other neutron stars whose atmospheres are characterized by absorption features @xcite , which are waiting to be explained .
these discoveries pushed us to make a detailed study of traditional atomic - molecular systems as well as for a search for new exotic chemical compounds in a strong magnetic field .
the goal of present article is to make a detailed investigation of coulomb systems made from one electron and several protons and/or @xmath29-particles in presence of a strong magnetic field .
it is natural to expect that due to vanishing rotational energy the optimal configuration with minimal total energy is the parallel configuration : all massive positively - charged particles are situated along a magnetic line .
we demonstrate that for sufficiently strong magnetic fields which appear on the surfaces of the neutron stars the exotic ions @xmath32 , @xmath33 can exist , while the ions @xmath18 , @xmath19 and @xmath20 may appear to exist as well .
the consideration is non - relativistic , based on a variational solution of the schroedinger equation .
hence , the magnetic field strength is restricted by the schwinger limit @xmath34 g .
also it is based on the born - oppenheimer approximation of zero order : the particles of positive charge ( protons and @xmath29-particles ) are assumed to be infinitely massive .
atomic units are used throughout ( @xmath35=@xmath36=@xmath37=1 ) , albeit energies are expressed in rydbergs ( ry ) .
the magnetic field @xmath38 is given in a.u . with @xmath39 g . |
is a nearby ( @xmath9pc ; * ? ? ? * ) complex star forming region .
it hosts an ultracompact ( uc ) hii region near its center , powered by the infrared source . the molecular content of this region has been the subject of several observational studies in the last decade .
so far , it is known a huge co bipolar outflow @xcite , @xmath10 long ( = 3.6pc ) , which is probably a relic of the formation of the b0v star associated to irs1 @xcite .
is an excellent laboratory to learn about the physical conditions and kinematics of an extreme pdr ( g@xmath11 = 5 10@xmath12 in units of habing field , * ? ? ?
continuum observations at 6 cm , reported by @xcite , show that the uc hii region is highly asymmetric , has a cometary shape and reaches its maximum toward its exciting star , .
the cs 7@xmath136 emission map from @xcite shows that the uc hii region is located inside a cavity and bound by a dense molecular ridge ( see fig . 1 ) .
this picture is consistent with infrared images of the region , which show an almost spherical distribution of hot dust surrounded by the molecular cloud .
the physical and chemical conditions of the pdrs associated to uc hii regions remain not enough known , mainly due to important observational problems : ( a ) these pdrs are too thin to be resolved by single - dish telescopes ; ( b ) they are usually located in very complex star - forming regions , where confusion with the parent molecular cloud , hot cores , and outflows may be considerable .
the study requires specific pdr tracers which allow us to separate their emission from other sources .
reactive ions and small hydrocarbons have been proposed as abundant species , which may trace the hot ionized / molecular gas interface @xcite .
the detection of the reactive ions co@xmath4 and hoc@xmath4 is almost unambiguously associated to regions with a high ionizing flux , either pdrs or xdrs @xcite . in the case of ,
@xcite have recently reported the detection of the reactive ions co@xmath4 and hoc@xmath4 towards the peak of the uc hii region .
in addition to chemical arguments , both the morphology and velocity profile of the lines suggested a link between the hii region and these species .
both ions were detected towards the peak of the uc hii regions and remain undetected in the molecular cloud .
furthermore , the velocity profile of these lines is different from those of other dense gas tracers .
the reactive ions have an intense emission peak at 10.5 km s@xmath14 which is not detected in the other molecules observed .
therefore , the emission of this velocity component may arise in narrow layers of molecular gas surrounding the hii region , where the chemistry is dominated by uv photons .
small hydrocarbons have enhanced abundances in pdrs @xcite .
in particular , @xcite have detected c - c@xmath0h@xmath1 and c@xmath15h towards the horsehead nebula with an abundance one order of magnitude larger than that predicted by gas - phase pdr models .
this is clearly seen by comparing the [ c - c@xmath0h@xmath1]/[hc@xmath0n ] ratio in pdrs and dark clouds .
while both species have similar abundances in dark clouds , the [ c - c@xmath0h@xmath1]/[hc@xmath0n ] ratio is above 10 in pdrs .
since both molecules are easily destroyed by photodissociation , this suggests the existence of an additional c - c@xmath0h@xmath1 formation mechanism in pdrs .
enhanced abundances of some other compounds have also been related to the presence of intense uv fields into molecular clouds . @xcite
measured a value of [ hco]/[h@xmath2co@xmath4]=9.7 in the region ngc2024 . however , the same authors report values significantly lower than 1 i.e . , an order magnitude below those found in ngc2024 in galactic clouds without developed regions , or having no indication of star formation .
more recently , @xcite have searched for hco in a reduced sample of prototypical pdrs ; the estimated [ hco]/[h@xmath2co@xmath4 ] abundance ratios range from 30 ( in the orion bar ) to 3 ( in ngc7023 ) .
the largest hco abundances are found in the orion bar , the paradigm of interaction between an region ( m42 ) and its parent molecular cloud .
@xcite obtained a high angular resolution image showing widespread hco emission in the external galaxy m82 .
the enhanced hco abundance ( [ hco]/[h@xmath2co@xmath4]@xmath183.6 ) measured across the whole m82 disk was also interpreted in terms of a giant pdr of 650 pc size .
sio is known to be a privileged tracer of large - scale shocks in the interstellar medium @xcite .
its fractional abundance is enhanced by more than 3 orders of magnitude in shocked regions relative to its abundance in quiescent clouds where it takes values @xmath19 10@xmath20 .
@xcite observed sio towards a sample of pdrs and obtain fractional abundances of @xmath1810@xmath21 in these regions , i.e. , a factor of 10 larger than that in dark clouds . in this paper , we present observations of a selected set of molecular species ( c@xmath1h , c - c@xmath0h@xmath1 , hc@xmath0n , h@xmath2co@xmath4 , hco , and sio ) which are thought to be good probes of the different layers of the molecular gas in pdrs . in this way
, we have performed a study of the physical conditions , the chemistry , and the kinematics of the molecular gas surrounding the uc hii region .
the observations were carried out using the iram 30 m radio telescope in pico de veleta ( spain ) during july 2002 and august 2003 .
the multi - receiver capability of the telescope was used for these observations .
the observed rotational transitions , frequencies , beam sizes , and main - beam efficiencies are shown in table 1 .
the backends used for the observations were an autocorrelator split in several parts , a 256 @xmath22 100 khz and two 512 @xmath22 1 mhz filter - banks .
all the lines but h@xmath2co@xmath4 1@xmath130 and c@xmath0h@xmath1 5(1,4)@xmath134(2,3 ) have been measured with two spectral resolutions , namely the lower spectral resolution provided by the 1 mhz filter - bank and the higher one , 78 khz100 khz , provided by the autocorrelator and the 100 khz filter bank .
the h@xmath2co@xmath4 1@xmath130 and c@xmath0h@xmath1 5(1,4)@xmath134(2,3 ) lines have only been measured with the 1 mhz filter - bank , providing the lower spectral resolution . the c@xmath0h@xmath1 6(1,6 ) @xmath135(0,5 ) [ ortho ] and 6(0,6)@xmath135(1,5 ) [ para ] are blended .
the observational strategy was as follows .
we have mapped the uc region and its surroundings in millimeter transitions of h@xmath2co@xmath4 , hc@xmath0n , hco , and sio .
the c@xmath1h and c@xmath0h@xmath1 transitions were observed along a strip transversal to the uc region , at an inclination angle ( east to north ) of 135 , which is approximately the symmetry axis of .
the mapped area ( @xmath23 ) and strip positions are sketched in fig . 1 , overlaid on the cs 7@xmath136 map of @xcite and the 6 cm - continuum map of @xcite .
the relative offsets are referred to , ( ra , dec.)@xmath24=(@xmath25 ) .
longer integration time was devoted to observe two particular positions : the maximum of the continuum emission , at ( 0 , 0 ) , and the maximum of the molecular envelope , at ( + 10 , -10 ) .
these two positions were also observed in the reactive ions co@xmath4 and hoc@xmath4 , and already published in a recent paper @xcite .
the small hydrocarbons c@xmath1h and c@xmath0h@xmath1 have been observed along a strip crossing the ionization bar in .
after the hyperfine - structure analysis which compares the relative intensities of each component , we have found that the c@xmath1h triplet emission at 87.3 ghz is optically thin at all positions .
based on this result , we will deal in the following just with the most intense hyperfine component ( @xmath26 ) , referring to this as `` the c@xmath1h 1@xmath130 line '' .
some of the c@xmath1h and c@xmath0h@xmath1 observed spectra are shown in fig . 2 .
the gaussian fits to a single component are also shown in table 2 for all the lines .
the c@xmath1h 1@xmath130 line shows emission at high velocities ( @xmath27 @xmath28 kms@xmath14 and @xmath27 @xmath29 kms@xmath14 ) that is not detected ( or only marginally detected ) in the c@xmath0h@xmath1 lines .
these velocity ranges coincide with those of the red - shifted and blue - shifted emission in the large - scale , now inactive , outflow associated with irs 1 @xcite .
we have not detected emission at high velocity in any other of the pdr tracers studied in this paper and @xcite .
thus , we consider that the high velocity c@xmath1h emission is not related to the uc region but to the low density gas that share the kinematics of the large - scale outflow . since we are mainly interested in the study of the pdr surrounding the uc region , we have only used the c@xmath1h emission in the range 812 kms@xmath14 in our calculations . within the considered velocity range ,
the velocities and spatial distribution of the c@xmath1h 1@xmath130 and c@xmath0h@xmath1 2@xmath131 lines are remarkable similar , which suggest that both lines trace essentially the same region .
however , the emission of the c@xmath0h@xmath1 2@xmath131 and the c@xmath0h@xmath1 6@xmath135 lines have different kinematics and spatial distribution , which became eloquent when looking at the central velocities in table 2 and the shaded areas in fig . 2 . the c@xmath0h@xmath1 2@xmath131 line is narrower than the 6@xmath135 line along the whole strip . furthermore , the central velocity of the 2@xmath131 line is lower than that of the 6@xmath135 line towards the uc region . when looking at the areas , it is remarkable the different spatial distribution of the 2@xmath131 and 6@xmath135 lines .
the 2@xmath131 emission ( a low excitation line ) is clearly lower at the central part of the strip , while the 6@xmath135 emission ( a high excitation line ) is particularly intense there .
this behavior is better explained by assuming the existence of _ at least _ two gas components characterized by different velocities . the blue velocity component ( hereafter referred to as c1 ) , emitting at velocities from @xmath30 8 to 10 km s@xmath14 ,
is dominated by the emission of the 2@xmath131 line along the whole strip , but it is not particularly intense in the 6@xmath135 line .
this component remains quite uniform along the strip .
the red velocity component , with emission from @xmath30 10 to 12 km s@xmath14and hereafter referred to as c2 , has intense emission in the 6@xmath135 line but it is very weak in the 2@xmath131 line .
c2 is especially intense towards the inner region .
the distribution of both components can be interpreted as c1 associated with the foreground molecular cloud and c2 associated with the region , or the interface between it and the molecular cloud .
this trend is illustrated in fig . 3 , where we plot the integrated intensity of the c@xmath0h@xmath1 6@xmath135 line ( fig .
3a ) and the 6@xmath135/2@xmath131 line intensity ratio ( hereafter referred to as r@xmath31 ) for each component ( fig .
r@xmath31 remains quite constant and @xmath18 1 for c1 along the strip .
however , it has significant variations in c2 .
the values of r@xmath31 are @xmath32 outside the uc region and @xmath33 towards the inner region .
the fig .
3b clearly separates both components , and shows that c2 is tracing highly excited molecular gas , linked to the uc region .
this splitting of the values of r@xmath31 is also in agreement with the spatial distribution of both components .
of course , the different beams involved in both lines affect the computation of r@xmath31 .
we could estimate the beam dilution by convolving the c@xmath0h@xmath1 6@xmath135 emission of the c2 down to the angular resolution of the 2@xmath131 line .
this one - dimensional smoothing was performed along the symmetry axis , which shows the largest variations in other molecular tracers .
the results are shown by dashed lines in fig .
3 . as expected , the distribution of the 6@xmath135 line intensity peaks in the southeastern border of the uc region .
furthermore , it is remarkable that r@xmath31 remains @xmath34 in the three central positions . in other words ,
the high value of r@xmath31 there , even smoothed , strengthens the mutual relationship between c2 and the uc region .
we have mapped the region indicated in fig . 1 in several rotational lines .
4 shows the resultant maps in h@xmath2co@xmath4 1@xmath130 ( fig .
4a ) , sio 2@xmath131(fig .
4b ) , hco 1@xmath130 ( fig .
4c ) , and hc@xmath0n 10@xmath139 ( fig . 4d ) .
superimposed are the 6 cm - continuum emission from @xcite .
all the maps were constructed by integrating the lines along the total velocity range of emission .
we note remarkable differences in the distribution of the different species .
the h@xmath2co@xmath4 and the hc@xmath0n emission clearly follow the high density gas , properly traced by the cs 7@xmath136 emission ( see fig
. 1 ) and reach a minimum toward the center of the uc region .
this is consistent with the interpretation of h@xmath2co@xmath4 and hc@xmath0n as being photodissociated within the uc region .
however , the other molecules present different behaviors . the sio and hco emissions seem to be located preferably at intermediate positions between the molecular envelope and the region .
although this effect should be regarded as tentative , because the spatial difference between the continuum peak and the sio distribution is about half a beam , the systematic difference looks evident , and clearly the sio or hco maps are different to those of h@xmath2co@xmath4 or hc@xmath0n .
this result is in line with @xcite , who also found moderately enhanced sio and hco emissions close to the ionization front in the prototypical region m42 .
however , the two species peak at different positions .
the hco maxima appears almost exactly at the sio minimum , and both emissions completely bound the inner uc region . in fig .
5 we show all the spectra we have observed towards the ( 0,0 ) position ( this paper and * ? ? ?
the dashed vertical line traces the limits of c1 and c2 .
unfortunately , some of the lines at ( 0,0 ) are rather weak , which yields a low s / n ratio . even though , a quick look suggests the existence of two different behaviors in the shape of the observed lines .
a first group of lines has the maximum intensity at velocities @xmath35 10 km s@xmath14 , close to the c1 velocity ; this is the case for the sio and hco lines . a second group peaks at velocities @xmath36 km s@xmath14 and are especially intense in c2 ; the c@xmath0h@xmath1 6@xmath135 , co@xmath4 2@xmath131 and hoc@xmath4 1@xmath130 belongs to this group .
the strong difference between the sio lines at c2 velocities should be more carefully analyzed in future observations .
after a joint view of the maps ( fig . 4 ) and the spectra ( fig . 5 ) , we see that the sio and hco emitting gas do not seem to share the same volume with the reactive ions and small hydrocarbons , but to arise in a more shielded layer of the pdr , which is preferably at the velocity of c1 . as further discussed in sects . 5 and 6 ,
different excitation conditions and chemistry are associated to this shielded layer and c2 .
we have developed a lvg code to estimate the main physical parameters of the c@xmath0h@xmath1 molecule .
the einstein a- coefficients have been taken from @xcite .
the collisional rates are from @xcite , who provided values for kinetic temperatures ( @xmath37 ) of 30 , 60 , 90 , and 120k .
our lvg code treats the ortho- and para - c@xmath0h@xmath1 as different species . in most positions ,
we have detected only the 2(1,2)@xmath131(0,1 ) [ ortho ] and the 6@xmath135 ( a blending of the 6(1,6)@xmath135(0,5 ) [ ortho ] and 6(0,6)@xmath135(1,5 ) [ para ] ) lines .
then , we need to assume a value of the c@xmath0h@xmath1 ortho - to - para ratio ( otpr ) in our calculations . in order to have an estimate of the otpr ,
we have used the 6@xmath135/5@xmath134 line intensity ratio ( hereafter r@xmath38 ) towards the ( 0@xmath39,0@xmath39 ) and ( @xmath40,@xmath41 ) positions .
the observed value , r@xmath42 , is compatible with r@xmath43 , which is expected for the standard value of 3 .
therefore , we have assumed otpr=3 in our lvg calculations hereafter .
the lvg code was run for different sets of @xmath37 , from 10 to 150k .
for @xmath37different to those tabulated by @xcite , we have interpolated or extrapolated between the two closest temperatures . a minimum value of 30 k for @xmath37 is needed to reproduce the 6@xmath135/2@xmath131 line ratio ( hereafter referred to as r@xmath31 ) both in c1 and c2 . for @xmath37@xmath44k
, r@xmath31 is weakly dependent on the assumed kinetic temperature and traces mainly the hydrogen density . in table 3
, we show the lvg results assuming @xmath37@xmath45k , the kinetic temperature derived by @xcite from multiline molecular observations .
we have obtained rather uniform values of both the molecular density ( @xmath46(h@xmath1 ) ) and the c@xmath0h@xmath1 column density ( @xmath47(c@xmath0h@xmath1 ) ) in c1 across the observed strip .
the derived @xmath46(h@xmath1 ) is around 5@xmath48 @xmath8 , in agreement with results derived from other tracers @xcite , and the @xmath47(c@xmath0h@xmath1 ) are in the range 13@xmath49 @xmath50 .
a different behavior is observed in c2 .
the c2 hydrogen density increases from a few 10@xmath12 @xmath8 outside the uc region to @xmath7 @xmath8 in the three central positions .
this limit is almost insensitive to @xmath37 in the range 50 to 150k .
thus , the larger values of the r@xmath31 observed towards the region can not be due to a higher kinetic temperature .
the fig .
6 shows the lvg results from two of the runs , corresponding to values of @xmath37 of 60 and 120k .
the shadowed areas indicate the range of observed values towards the ( @xmath51,@xmath51 ) position . while @xmath47(c@xmath0h@xmath1 ) is similar in c1 and c2 , the c2 density is a factor @xmath52 greater than in c1 .
recent results of @xcite and near - ir images show a shell - like structure , intense in mid- and near - ir , of a few arcsec width , wrapping up the uc region .
it is indeed possible that c2 is tracing the _ high density molecular gas _ associated to this feature .
this would also explain the spatial distribution of @xmath47(c@xmath0h@xmath1 ) in c2 which slightly increases towards the border of the region , the expected behavior of a molecular shell surrounding the ionized gas .
we have estimated the c@xmath1h column density ( @xmath47(c@xmath1h ) ) across the studied strip using the lvg code and assuming @xmath46(h@xmath1)=10@xmath53 @xmath8 and @xmath37=50k .
we have adopted the cross sections provided by @xcite for the hcn molecule , and then used the ios ( infinite - order sudden ) approximation for molecular collision dynamics to get the collisional coefficients between different levels . a similar procedure was followed by @xcite , who also provided the einstein a- coefficients for c@xmath1h .
the c1 and c2 components have been separated towards the ( 0@xmath39,0@xmath39 ) and ( @xmath40,@xmath41 ) .
most of the c@xmath1h emission seem to be associated to c1 outwards these positions .
the results are shown in tables 3 and 4 .
@xmath47(c@xmath1h ) varies from 2 to 4 10@xmath54 @xmath50 , decreasing toward the center of the region , as expected in a region where the molecules are photodestroyed by a high incident uv flux .
when compared to c@xmath0h@xmath1 , the [ c@xmath0h@xmath1]/[c@xmath1h ] ratio slightly increases towards the center ; an exception is the last point of the strip , which has a considerable lower s / n ratio ( see table 3 ) .
comparing both components , the [ c@xmath0h@xmath1]/[c@xmath1h ] ratio is three times greater in c2 than in c1 ( see table 4 ) . as we will refer in sect .
6.1 , the significantly larger [ c@xmath0h@xmath1]/[c@xmath1h ] ratio in c2 reveals that the chemistry of the molecular gas is heavily affected by the uv radiation .
the h@xmath2co@xmath4 , sio and hc@xmath0n column densities have been estimated using an lvg code and assuming @xmath37=50k and @xmath46(h@xmath1)=10@xmath53@xmath8 . under these physical conditions , the excitation temperature of the h@xmath2co@xmath4 1@xmath130 line is @xmath1820k .
we have also derived the hco column density by assuming optically thin emission , lte conditions and a rotation temperature of 20k .
the uncertainty in the excitation temperature of hco should not affect the fractional abundances of these molecules .
the results for some selected positions are shown in table 5 .
significant changes in the fractional abundances are detected across the uc region .
in particular , the hc@xmath0n abundance decreases by a factor of @xmath183 towards the uc region ( x(hc@xmath0n@xmath55 a few 10@xmath56 ) , when compared towards the dense molecular cloud ( where x(hc@xmath0n ) @xmath18 10@xmath57 ) .
this decrease of the hc@xmath0n abundance in regions of enhanced uv field has also been found in other regions like the prototypical pdr of the orion bar @xcite , or the starburst galaxy m82 @xcite , and it is easily explained by photodissociation .
sio has a different behavior .
the sio abundance is low towards the center of the uc region ( x(sio)@xmath5810@xmath20 ) .
it is also low towards the dense molecular cloud , where we derive x(sio)@xmath5910@xmath20 , in agreement with the values of the sio abundance measured in dark clouds .
however , it is one order of magnitude higher at intermediate positions between the uc region and the molecular cloud ; here , the sio abundance is comparable to that found by @xcite towards the pdrs associated with the orion bar and s140 . similarly to sio
, the hco abundance is also enhanced at the border of the uc region .
in particular the [ hco]/[h@xmath2co@xmath4 ] ratio is 10 times larger in the position ( 0,24 ) than in the center of the uc region and in the dense molecular cloud .
we have measured a hco abundance as high as @xmath60 towards the hco peak .
such large values of the hco abundance have been found at the border of the region ngc 2024 by @xcite and in the orion bar by @xcite , suggesting that this molecule is specially abundant in the pdrs formed at the edges of the regions .
@xcite found large values of the hco abundance in the starburst galaxy m82 , where a low - density ionized component is filling a substantial fraction of its volume ( see also * ? ? ? * ) .
our data show the existence of a high - density layer of gas associated to the uc region in .
this layer is traced by c2 and seems to have different physical conditions from that of c1 and the molecular cloud .
furthermore , a different chemistry may also carry out in the layer traced by c2 . in order to explore this idea ,
we have computed the column densities and fractional abundances for the two components , towards the positions ( + 10,-10 ) and ( 0,0 ) , and for the molecules studied in this paper and @xcite .
the results are shown in table 4 .
significant differences exist between the [ co@xmath4]/[hco@xmath4 ] , [ hco@xmath4]/[hoc@xmath4 ] and [ c@xmath0h@xmath1]/[c@xmath1h ] ratios between c1 and c2 . in order to characterize the chemistry of the two components ,
we have modeled the pdr using the plane - parallel model developed by le bourlot and collaborators @xcite with an uv field g@xmath61 in units of the habing field and a total density ( _ i.e. _ atomic plus molecular ) of 210@xmath53 @xmath8 ( * ? ? ?
* and this paper ) .
the main results are sketched in fig .
the molecules co@xmath4 , hoc@xmath4 , c@xmath1h , and c@xmath0h@xmath1 are known to be good tracers of the surface layers ( @xmath62mag ) of the pdrs ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
these environments are highly exposed to an intense uv field , and hence we will refer to these molecules as `` _ high uv _ '' species ( huv for briefing ) .
in particular , the reactive ion co@xmath4 is only expected to reach significant abundances at a visual extinction , @xmath63mag @xcite . in fig .
7a we show the co@xmath4 and hco@xmath4 fractional abundances as a function of the visual extinction for our model . as expected , the abundance of co@xmath4 is only significant at @xmath63mag , and just at this low visual extinction , the predicted [ co@xmath4]/[hco@xmath4 ] ratio agrees with that measured in c2 towards the region ( light gray region in fig .
the [ co@xmath4]/[hco@xmath4 ] ratio is more than one order of magnitude greater in c2 than in c1 ( table 4 ) , which indicates that c1 arise in a more shielded layer of the molecular gas having @xmath64mag ( dark gray region in fig .
the [ hco@xmath4]/[hoc@xmath4 ] ratio is a factor of 2 lower in c2 than in c1 .
low values of the [ hco@xmath4]/[hoc@xmath4 ] ratio are associated to highly ionized regions @xcite .
unfortunately , the reactive ion hoc@xmath4 is not included in le bourlot s model , but we can estimate its abundance in an indirect way .
the [ hco@xmath4]/[hoc@xmath4 ] ratio is strongly dependent on the electron abundance . in order to have [ hco@xmath4]/[hoc@xmath4 ] @xmath65
, it is required an electron abundance , x(e@xmath66)@xmath67 @xcite . using our model ,
we conclude that these high electron abundances are only reached at @xmath68mag .
thus , the [ co@xmath4]/hco@xmath4 ] and the [ hco@xmath4]/[hoc@xmath4 ] ratios support the interpretation of c2 as arising from a layer of molecular gas located at a visual extinction @xmath69mag from the advancing ionization front .
a new pdr model including reactions of hoc@xmath4 is under development , and it will directly predict the [ hco@xmath4]/[hoc@xmath4 ] ratio , as a function of global physical conditions ( uv field , density , extinction ) in a near future .
the [ c@xmath0h@xmath1]/[c@xmath1h ] ratio also changes between c1 and c2 .
in fact , this is a factor of 23 larger in c2 than in c1 .
our chemical model predicts that the [ c@xmath0h@xmath1]/[c@xmath1h ] ratio is maximum at a visual extinction between 2 and 4mag ( see fig .
these values of the visual extinction are in agreement with those derived from the measured [ hco@xmath4]/[hoc@xmath4 ] ratio .
thus , it seems reasonable that the emission of c2 arises in the same layer of dense gas than hoc@xmath4 ( @xmath68mag ) , while co@xmath4 arises in even a more external layer ( @xmath63mag ) .
however , our model fails to predict values of [ c@xmath0h@xmath1]/[c@xmath1h ] as large as those measured in c2 even at this low visual extinction .
the maximum value of the [ c@xmath0h@xmath1]/[c@xmath1h ] ratio predicted by the model is @xmath18 0.01 , three times lower than those measured in c2 .
( see fig .
7b and table 4 ) .
a failure of pdr models to account for the observed c@xmath0h@xmath1 abundance has already been commented in previous works @xcite . the existence of an additional formation mechanism for c@xmath0h@xmath1 linked to the pahs photodestruction has been proposed as an alternative to account the large c@xmath0h@xmath1 fractional abundances in pdrs . summarizing
, we can infer from the comparison of our observations of huv molecules and model calculations that c2 is tracing the dense molecular gas located at a visual extinction @xmath69mag from the ionization front , while c1 is mainly tracing the more shielded part ( @xmath6mag ) of the pdr .
consequently , the uc region is surrounding by a thin layer ( @xmath70 @xmath50 ) of dense ( @xmath7 @xmath8 ) molecular gas , whose chemistry is heavily affected by the uv stellar radiation and kinetically well represented by c2 .
in contrast to the huv species , the column densities of hco and sio decrease towards the uc region , as expected in this harsh environment .
furthermore , their abundances are larger in c1 than in c2 ( see [ hco]/[h@xmath2co@xmath4 ] and [ sio]/[h@xmath2co@xmath4 ] in table 4 ) , and show an enhancement at its edges ( see table 5 ) .
clearly , both hco and sio do not share a behavior similar to the huv molecules ; moreover , they are not particularly abundant in the cold envelope .
both molecules seem to be mainly present in the shielded parts of the pdr ( @xmath6mag ) , and would belong to a family of species which can survive in those environments , less exposed to the uv field than the huv molecules .
we hereafter call such molecules as `` _ low uv _ '' ( or luv for briefing ) species .
the abundance of our luv molecules are unusually high and could not be explained by gas - phase models ( see , for example , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
equally puzzling is the fact that both molecules peak at different positions .
as we have already stated before , both sio and hco have near their maxima abundances comparable to other pdrs , such as and orion bar @xcite .
moreover , the [ hco]/[h@xmath2co@xmath4 ] abundance ratio near the hco peak is in the range 1015 , higher than in @xcite and @xcite .
this enhancement can be due to a few reasons .
firstly , some relevant chemical reactions leading to formation of sio and hco might not be considered in gas - phase models .
it was already analyzed by several authors ( see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) and sounds rather unlikely . even though , we should not disregard the hypothesis , mainly due to a possible lack of complete chemical networks and rate coefficients .
so far , the most widely accepted alternative explanation arises by considering the grain chemistry . as many authors pointed out ( see , for example , the review by * ? ? ?
* ) , the dust plays a key role in driving the chemistry and the energetics in pdrs . @xcite
have modeled the si chemistry in pdrs , and found that most of si is in solid form at extinctions greater than 3 mag .
this issue was observationally confirmed by @xcite in , where a special distribution and enhancement of sio was detected .
@xcite have included photodesorption of si in their pdr model .
sio would later be produced in gaseous phase by reactions with oh and o@xmath1 . by doing so
, those authors could account for the observed sio abundance in and .
laboratory measurements of the rate coefficient of the reaction si + o@xmath1 @xmath13 sio + o @xcite , followed by detailed calculations of si chemistry , have confirmed the results by @xcite . in the case of hco ,
the photodesorption of h@xmath1co followed by its photodissociation in gaseous phase have been claimed as a mechanism capable to counterbalance the photodissociation of hco against the uv photons @xcite .
the authors could get an enhancement of hco ( at @xmath6 mag ) but not to the observed levels .
this may be due to the need of more reliable rates for the processes involved , but also to the reduced network used in the gas - phase formation of this low - abundance species .
we have measured similar abundances of hco and hence are in a similar situation ; the uv field intensity , greater in than in orion bar @xcite , does not seem to affect the hco abundance .
however , photodesorption may not efficiently work in some other environments . @xcite
have modeled both gas- and dust - chemistry in quiescent cores , and shown that the abundance of some species with lower binding energies than si do not significantly change when including photodesorption .
the modeled quiescent cores , however , have a @xmath71 ratio at least two orders of magnitude lower than in , because the densities are two orders of magnitude lower , and the incident uv field takes interstellar values .
even though , their results should be taken into account , and a complete model like the @xcite s one , under physical conditions more typical of pdrs , will surely improve our knowledge about the particular chemistry of luv species and pdrs in general . anyway ,
if sio and hco are formed after photodesorption of si and h@xmath1co , respectively , we would expect other atoms and molecules do so , and would be detectable . at this respect , an interesting test may be to carry out an observational campaign to search for and study other luv species throughout the whole field . a good candidate to belong to the luv group in nh@xmath0 , a widely recognized species linked to grain chemistry ,
whose abundance close to the borders of regions is enhanced @xcite .
the different spatial distributions of our luv molecules is another interesting issue .
both molecules almost complete a `` ring '' between the uc region and the molecular envelope .
however , they peak at different locations throughout the ring : while sio arises in the densest part of the ionization front , hco peaks in the tail of the cometary shape .
different local conditions should exist in order to explain the variations in relative abundances of sio and hco .
a rather simple explanation is that hco and sio have a different desorption yield ; in this case one would expect a layered structure in the morphology of these molecules .
unfortunately , the low angular resolution of the hco and sio maps prevent us from concluding about that .
a second possibility is that a low - velocity shock associated with the ionization front contributes to enhance the hco and/or sio abundances . in the case of hot cores ,
this process was already analyzed by @xcite .
the low velocity shocks contribute to release si and/or h@xmath1co from the grain surfaces , and the gas phase chemistry is modified by the advancing shock front .
the radical hco is rapidly destroyed by o , but in shocked regions the o abundance is reduced because it is converted to h@xmath1o .
furthermore , sio is efficiently formed by the reaction si @xmath72 oh @xmath13 sio @xmath72 h , being oh the photodissociation product of h@xmath1o . thus , the hco and sio abundances are very sensitive to the o / oh / h@xmath1o relative fractional abundances and can change locally because of low velocity shocks and small inhomogeneities in the incident uv field . finally , a variation in the grain composition may account for the differences between the hco - peak to the sio - peak .
observations of dust emission may help to solve this interesting puzzle in .
@xcite have studied this region in the mid - ir , from 8.2 to 20.6@xmath73 m . besides the ir sources ,
continuum dust emission is dominated by a ring - like structure which roughly bounds the ionized region .
while the dust temperature is rather uniform in the area ( 100115k ) , the opacity is greater in the ring .
@xcite also studied the silicate absorption feature at 10@xmath73 m , and found a patchy distribution , not necessarily correlated to the point sources , the temperature , or the opacity .
so far , dust properties may significantly change in areas as small as a few arcsec , although this result encourages one of our alternatives ( variation in grain composition ) , the distribution of hco and sio is still an open subject because the other proposed explanations ( different desorption yield and low - velocity shocks ) may be working in this case . to summarize ,
our sio and hco observations show that these compounds are enhanced in the outskirts of the uc regions ( @xmath6mag ) .
the enhancement in the abundance of these species may be related to the interaction of the uv photons with grains , instead of the direct effect of the uv photons on the molecular gas chemistry .
the interaction of the uv photons with grains may modify the chemistry of large column densities of the molecular gas , and may show an evidence of the advancing pdr into the molecular cloud .
in the uc regions , the high densities of the ionized gas lead to enormous internal pressures ( @xmath74 @xmath8 k ) . since the sources are very small , their expansion timescales should be as short as a few hundred years @xcite .
surprisingly , the number of uc regions is greater than the expected from the massive star formation rate @xcite , which is known as the `` lifetime problem '' of the uc regions
. a deep knowledge of the morphology and physical conditions of the dense pdr around the uc region in , would shed some light on this problem .
we can explore one of the proposed explanations , in which the extremely dense neutral gas confine the hii region by pressure @xcite ; our data show the existence of a gas layer with @xmath46(h@xmath1)@xmath7 @xmath8 . hence ,
if we assume a kinetic temperature of 100k , a hydrogen density @xmath46(h@xmath1 ) @xmath75 @xmath8 would be enough to pressure - confine the uc region .
the velocity range associated to c2 is undoubtedly different from that linked to the parent molecular cloud , and hence it should have a particular kinematics . by means of the pdr chemistry , we have a good chance of further studying the kinematics of the molecular gas confining the uc region , because some chemical species may avoid the confusion of the foreground molecular cloud . in fig . 8
, we show the position - velocity ( p - v ) diagram of the c@xmath0h@xmath1 2@xmath131 ( fig .
8a ) and 6@xmath135 lines ( fig .
8b ) across the observed strip .
as we previously discussed , most of the c@xmath0h@xmath1 2@xmath131 line traces c1 , whereas the 6@xmath135 emission is dominated by c2 .
the p - v diagram of the c@xmath0h@xmath1 6@xmath135 line is preferably located toward the region ( center of the map ) , rather than extended along the whole strip .
the curves superimposed in fig . 8 were symmetrically traced around c1 , and roughly follow the c@xmath0h@xmath1 6@xmath135 maxima . as the extreme velocities of the curves are @xmath76 and 12 km s@xmath14 , this pattern is compatible with a picture where the pdr is expanding at a velocity between 2 and 3 km s@xmath14 .
it is worth mentioning that such a low expansion velocity was recently observed in an uc region in w48 , by observations of carbon recombination lines @xcite .
we have carried out a molecular survey towards the uc region to have a deeper insight into the chemistry associated to this kind of objects .
our results show the existence of two groups of molecules . the first group ( huv ) is formed by molecules that present large abundances in the surface layers of pdrs ( @xmath62mag ) .
the species co@xmath4 , hoc@xmath4 , c@xmath1h , and c@xmath0h@xmath1 belong to this group .
gas - phase pdr models can successfully account for the behavior of co@xmath4 , hoc@xmath4 , and c@xmath1h . in the case of c@xmath0h@xmath1 , however , pdr models fall short of explaining the observed abundances .
new c@xmath0h@xmath1 formation mechanisms linked to the photodestruction of pahs have been proposed to account for this difference .
hco and sio belong to another group of molecules ( luv ) .
their abundances are enhanced at the edges of the pdr ( @xmath6mag ) , which can not be explained by current gas - phase pdr models .
photodesorption from grain mantles appears like a probable mechanism capable of explaining the observed abundances .
a revision of gas - phase chemical networks , as well as a model able to include photodesorption in pdrs , may significantly improve the knowledge of luv species .
other molecules , like nh@xmath0 , whose chemistry is related with the grains also present large abundances at the edges of the regions @xcite .
this issue may show that the interactions of the uv radiation with the grains could produce important effects on the chemistry of the molecular gas , even at local visual extinction as deep as 10mag .
finally , we have used pdr chemistry to determine the physical conditions and kinematics of the layer of gas surrounding the uc region . using a lvg code to fit our c@xmath0h@xmath1 observations , we have derived hydrogen densities @xmath7 @xmath8 for this layer .
the proposed scenario of a pressure - confined region requires @xmath46(h@xmath1 ) @xmath77 @xmath8 , perfectly compatible with this result .
in addition , the p - v diagram of the c@xmath0h@xmath1 lines might show that while the gas layers at a visual extinction @xmath78mag are expanding at a velocity of @xmath18 23 km s@xmath14 , the back layers of the pdr are moving at the velocities of the foreground molecular cloud .
this kinematics supports the interpretation that the uc region could be confined by a dense ( @xmath46(h@xmath1 ) @xmath79 @xmath8 ) and thin ( @xmath69 10@xmath80 @xmath50 ) layer of neutral gas . on the other hand
, the search for other luv molecules looks as an exciting observational task which may lead to determine the chemical processes carrying out in the more shielded part of pdrs .
moreover , further observations and multi - transitional studies of the huv molecules are needed to determine accurately the physical conditions and dynamics of this neutral layer .
we are grateful to the technical staff in pico de veleta for their professional support during the observations .
we specially wish to thank the anonymous referee , who greatly improved the paper by sharing with us his / her viewpoints about the pdr chemistry .
this paper has been partially funded by the spanish mcyt under projects dges / aya2000 - 927 , esp2001 - 4519-pe , esp2002 - 01693 , and aya2003 - 06473 .
c@xmath1h & @xmath81 + & @xmath82 & 87.284156 & 28.5 & 0.77 + & @xmath83 & 87.316925 & 28.5 & 0.77 + & @xmath84 & 87.328624 & 28.5 & 0.77 + + c@xmath0h@xmath1 & @xmath85 + & 2(1,2 ) @xmath13 1(0,1 ) & 85.338893 & 29 & 0.77 + & 3(2,2 ) @xmath13 2(1,1 ) & 155.518295 & 17 & 0.65 + & 6(0,6 ) @xmath13 5(1,5 ) & 217.822148 & 11.5 & 0.52 + & 6(1,6 ) @xmath13 5(0,5 ) & 217.822148 & 11.5 & 0.52 + & 5(1,4 ) @xmath13 4(2,3 ) & 217.940046 & 11.5 & 0.52 + + hc@xmath0n & @xmath86 & 90.9789933 & 27 & 0.76 + + hco & @xmath87 + & @xmath88 & 86.6708200 & 28.5 & 0.77 + + sio & @xmath89 & 86.8468910 & 28.5 & 0.77 + sio & @xmath90 & 130.268702 & 19 & 0.70 + + h@xmath2co@xmath4 & @xmath91 & 86.7543300 & 28.5 & 0.77 + ( 20 , -20 ) & c@xmath0h@xmath1 @xmath92 & @xmath35 0.13 & & + ( 10 , -10 ) & c@xmath0h@xmath1 @xmath92 & 1.10 ( 0.10 ) & 10.9 ( 0.1 ) & 2.8 ( 0.3 ) + ( 0 , 0 ) & c@xmath0h@xmath1 @xmath92 & 0.82 ( 0.11 ) & 10.4 ( 0.2 ) & 3.7 ( 0.6 ) + ( -10 , + 10 ) & c@xmath0h@xmath1 @xmath92 & 0.76 ( 0.10 ) & 9.8 ( 0.2 ) & 3.6 ( 0.6 ) + ( -20 , + 20 ) & c@xmath0h@xmath1 @xmath92 & 0.76 ( 0.15 ) & 10.5 ( 0.3 ) & 3.3 ( 0.8 ) + ( -30 , + 30 ) & c@xmath0h@xmath1 @xmath92 & 0.70 ( 0.14 ) & 9.5 ( 0.3 ) & 2.7 ( 0.5 ) + + ( 20 , -20 ) & c@xmath0h@xmath1 @xmath93 & @xmath35 0.07 & & + ( 10 , -10 ) & c@xmath0h@xmath1 @xmath93 & 0.76 ( 0.09 ) & 10.6 ( 0.3 ) & 3.4 ( 0.5 ) + ( 0 , 0 ) & c@xmath0h@xmath1 @xmath93 & 0.56 ( 0.07 ) & 8.9 ( 0.3 ) & 4.2 ( 0.6 ) + ( -10 , + 10 ) & c@xmath0h@xmath1 @xmath93 & 0.47 ( 0.12 ) & 10.6 ( 0.6 ) & 4.4 ( 1.2 ) + ( -20 , + 20 ) & c@xmath0h@xmath1 @xmath93 & @xmath35 0.06 & & + ( -30 , + 30 ) & c@xmath0h@xmath1 @xmath93 & @xmath35 0.06 & & + + ( 20 , -20 ) & c@xmath0h@xmath1 @xmath94 & @xmath35 0.11 & & + ( 10 , -10 ) & c@xmath0h@xmath1 @xmath94 & 0.18 ( 0.04 ) & 11.6 ( 0.1 ) & 0.5 ( 0.2 ) + ( 0 , 0 ) & c@xmath0h@xmath1 @xmath94 & 0.38 ( 0.09 ) & 9.8 ( 0.7 ) & 5.6 ( 1.3 ) + ( -10 , + 10 ) & c@xmath0h@xmath1 @xmath94 & @xmath35 0.09 & & + ( -20 , + 20 ) & c@xmath0h@xmath1 @xmath94 & @xmath35 0.11 & & + ( -30 , + 30 ) & c@xmath0h@xmath1 @xmath94 & @xmath35 0.15 & & + + ( 20 , -20 ) & c@xmath0h@xmath1 @xmath95 & 0.62 ( 0.20 ) & 9.9 ( 0.6 ) & 3.3 ( 1.1 ) + ( 10 , -10 ) & c@xmath0h@xmath1 @xmath95 & @xmath35 0.11 & & + ( 0 , 0 ) & c@xmath0h@xmath1 @xmath95 & 0.29 ( 0.04 ) & 9.3 ( 0.1 ) & 1.1 ( 0.2 ) + ( -10 , + 10 ) & c@xmath0h@xmath1 @xmath95 & 0.41 ( 0.09 ) & 9.7 ( 0.2 ) & 1.6 ( 0.6 ) + ( -20 , + 20 ) & c@xmath0h@xmath1 @xmath95 & 0.25 ( 0.09 ) & 9.8 ( 0.3 ) & 1.8 ( 0.7 ) + ( -30 , + 30 ) & c@xmath0h@xmath1 @xmath95 & 1.09 ( 0.17 ) & 8.4 ( 0.4 ) & 4.6 ( 0.7 ) + + ( 20 , -20 ) & c@xmath1h @xmath96 & 4.77 ( 0.18 ) & 10.5 ( 0.1 ) & 3.9 ( 0.2 ) + ( 10 , -10 ) & c@xmath1h @xmath96 & 3.49 ( 0.03 ) & 10.7 ( 0.2 ) & 4.7 ( 0.3 ) + ( 0 , 0 ) & c@xmath1h @xmath96 & 2.32 ( 0.12 ) & 9.3 ( 0.1 ) & 3.8 ( 0.3 ) + ( -10 , + 10 ) & c@xmath1h @xmath96 & 3.67 ( 0.10 ) & 9.3 ( 0.1 ) & 5.3 ( 0.2 ) + ( -20 , + 20 ) & c@xmath1h @xmath96 & 3.57 ( 0.18 ) & 9.7 ( 0.1 ) & 4.5 ( 0.3 ) + ( -30 , + 30 ) & c@xmath1h @xmath96 & 1.97 ( 0.23 ) & 10.3 ( 0.1 ) & 2.7 ( 0.5 ) + ( + 20 , -20 ) & @xmath352.4 10@xmath12 & @xmath972.2 & & @xmath354.6 10@xmath12 & @xmath971.8 & & 4.2 & 0.010 + ( + 10 , -10 ) & 8.4 10@xmath12 & 1.1 & & @xmath983.5 10@xmath53 & 4.0 & & 3.0 & 0.017 + ( 0 , 0 ) & 4.5 10@xmath12 & 1.8 & & @xmath984.5 10@xmath53 & 2.3 & & 2.0 & 0.021 + ( -10 , + 10 ) & 4.6 10@xmath12 & 2.2 & & @xmath984.7 10@xmath53 & 1.4 & & 3.2 & 0.011 + ( -20 , + 20 ) & 6.4 10@xmath12 & 1.6 & & 1.1 10@xmath53 & 2.4 & & 3.1 & 0.013 + ( -30 , + 30 ) & 4.5 10@xmath12 & 3.1 & & 4.4 10@xmath12 & 1.8 & & 1.7 & 0.029 + c@xmath0h@xmath1 & @xmath49 @xmath50 & 1.1 & 4.0 & 1.8 & 2.3 + c@xmath1h & @xmath99 @xmath50 & 1.4 & 1.5 & 1.2 & 0.8 + co@xmath4 & @xmath100 @xmath50 & @xmath101 & @xmath102 & @xmath101 & 31.1 + hoc@xmath4 & @xmath100 @xmath50 & @xmath103 & 9.9 & 8.8 & 9.6 + hco & @xmath49 @xmath50 & @xmath104 & @xmath105 & 3.7 & @xmath106 + h@xmath2co@xmath4 & @xmath107 @xmath50 & 9.3 & 9.5 & 5.9 & 5.8 + hc@xmath0n & @xmath49 @xmath50 & 2.0 & 5.2 & 1.1 & 4.0 + sio & @xmath100 @xmath50 & 34 & @xmath108 & 11 & @xmath109 + hc@xmath110o@xmath4 & @xmath100 @xmath50 & 10.9 & 14.2 & 11.3 & 6.6 + + hco@xmath4/hoc@xmath4 & & @xmath111 & 930 & 830 & 450 + co@xmath4/hco@xmath4 & @xmath112 & @xmath59 & @xmath113 & @xmath59 & 72 + + c@xmath0h@xmath1/c@xmath1h & @xmath114 & 8 & 26 & 15 & 30 + c@xmath0h@xmath1/hc@xmath0n & & 0.6 & 0.8 & 1.6 & 0.6 + hco / h@xmath2co@xmath4 & & @xmath105 & @xmath115 & 6.3 & @xmath116 + sio / h@xmath2co@xmath4 & & 0.37 & @xmath117 & 0.19 & @xmath118 + ( + 12 , + 24 ) & 15.8 & 1.7 & 6.4 & @xmath119 & 9.3 & 2.5 & @xmath120 & hco peak + ( 0 , + 24 ) & 14.1 & 1.0 & 4.1 & @xmath119 & 14.7 & 3.4 & @xmath121 & hco peak + ( 0 , 0 ) & @xmath122 & 1.6 & 11.9 & 0.8 & @xmath109 & @xmath123 & @xmath124 & center + ( + 12 , -12 ) & @xmath125 & 1.7 & 11.1 & 4.3 & @xmath119 & @xmath126 & @xmath127 & sio peak + ( + 36 , + 12 ) & 4.0 & 2.8 & 18.9 & @xmath128 & 1.4 & 0.2 & @xmath129 & dense envelope + ( -12 , -36 ) & 9.6 & 1.8 & 25.6 & @xmath109 & 5.3 & 0.4 & @xmath130 & dense envelope + ( 0 , -12 ) & @xmath131 & 1.3 & 12.0 & 6.0 & @xmath132 & @xmath126 & @xmath133 & sio peak + | aiming to learn about the chemistry of the dense pdr around the ultracompact ( uc ) region in , we have observed a series of mm - wavelength transitions of c@xmath0h@xmath1 and c@xmath1h . in addition , we have traced the distribution of other molecules , such as h@xmath2co@xmath3 , sio , hco , and hc@xmath0n .
these data , together with the reactive ions recently detected , have been considered to determine the physical conditions and to model the pdr chemistry .
we then identified two kind of molecules .
the first group , formed by the reactive ions ( co@xmath4 , hoc@xmath4 ) and small hydrocarbons ( c@xmath1h , c@xmath0h@xmath1 ) , traces the surface layers of the pdr and is presumably exposed to a high uv field ( hence we called it as `` _ high uv _ '' , or huv ) .
huv species is expected to dominate for visual absorptions @xmath5mag .
a second group ( less exposed to the uv field , and hence called `` _ low uv _ '' , or luv ) includes hco and sio , and is mainly present at the edges of the pdr ( @xmath6mag ) .
while the abundances of the huv molecules can be explained by gas phase models , this is not the case for the studied luv ones .
although some efficient gas - phase reactions might be lacking , grain chemistry sounds like a probable mechanism able to explain the observed enhancement of hco and sio . within this scenario
, the interaction of uv photons with grains produces an important effect on the molecular gas chemistry and constitutes the first evidence of an ionization front created by the uc region carving its host molecular cloud .
the physical conditions and kinematics of the gas layer which surrounds the uc region were derived from the huv molecules .
molecular hydrogen densities @xmath7 @xmath8 are required to reproduce the observations .
such high densities suggest that the region could be pressure - confined by the surrounding high density molecular gas . |
undoubtedly the axial anomaly represents a fundamental issue for understanding the basic aspects of quantum field theory .
this issue has been analysed deeply over the years .
+ the anomaly problem has been treated by means of renormalization procedure , giving the interpretation of its origin in terms of ultraviolet divergences @xcite .
a more formal analysis of the axial anomaly can be made by using the path integral formalism @xcite .
+ dolgov and zakharov @xcite have shown an alternative approach to the axial anomaly , by studying the @xmath2 triangular diagram through dispersion relations . from this approach
follows the interpretation of the axial anomaly as an infrared phenomenon .
it appears as due to a singularity present in the chiral limit in the absorbitive part of the triangular diagram .
+ the infrared aspect of the axial anomaly , rised in this paper , is complementary to the more familiar ultraviolet one , which emerges from the renormalization procedure .
a particularly interesting feature of this approach is that it allows to shed light upon the physical meaning of the anomalous chiral symmetry breaking , which is connected to a non conservation of helicity .
+ the connection between the anomaly and the breaking of a given symmetry has received a lot of attention in the literature and this subject has been discussed and developed in several papers .
gribov @xcite , in a seminal work , has described the source of the anomalies as a collective motion of particles with arbitrarily large momenta in the vacuum .
related to this work , in ref .
@xcite , mueller has discussed the manifestation of the axial anomaly as a flow of landau levels . in the papers of refs .
@xcite the origin of the axial anomaly has been studied in two dimensions and , again , as a level crossing phenomenon .
the infrared interpretation of the axial anomaly , according to the dolgov and zakharov approach , has been possibly advanced in @xcite . in a series of papers @xcite the leading terms in the chiral limit
have been correctly evaluated .
furthermore the dispersive analysis of the triangular @xmath2 diagram is fundamental in the formulation of the t hooft consistency condition @xcite .
the axial anomaly plays an essential role also in the interpretation of spin dependent parton distribution ( see @xcite ) .
+ in this work we attempt to relate the dolgov and zakharov approach to the axial anomaly to some effects in the dynamics of physical reactions , as the radiative decays of @xmath0 and @xmath1 .
we will try to show that the axial anomaly can be related to polarized radiative decays , as in the usual ultraviolet interpretation it is connected to the @xmath3 decay .
we calculate the corresponding decay rates for the cases where the outgoing leptons are in a definite helicity state and we examine in some detail the structure of the mass singularities and their cancellation .
we study how the kinoshita - lee - nauenberg ( kln ) theorem @xcite applies and we consider the analogies and the differences with respect to the corresponding unpolarized decay rates .
+ the paper is organized as follows . in the section [ anomaly ]
we briefly reconsider the dispersive approach to the axial anomaly .
in particular we concentrate on its physical origin .
+ in section [ helicity ] we extend the dolgov and zakharov approach to the study of the radiative pion decay .
we calculate the differential decay rate for the process , where the outgoing lepton undergoes an helicity flip and we interpret its behaviour in the chiral limit , as a manifestation of the axial anomaly . + in section [ mass ]
we study the behaviour of the inner bremsstrahlung contribution to the pion decay rate in the collinear and infrared limits .
we consider separately the unpolarized decay rate and both the cases of right - handed and of left - handed outgoing lepton .
we find that the mass singularities cancellation mechanism occurs in different ways , according to the polarization of the outgoing lepton .
we discuss the various realizations of the kln theorem .
+ we also consider a more general process , i.e. the radiative @xmath1 decay in a lepton - antilepton pair , with a right - handed polarized lepton .
we examine how the mass singularities cancel in this case and discuss the differences with respect to the pion decay .
+ finally , in the conclusions , we summarize our arguments . + a short discussion of the main results obtained has been already given in @xcite .
the dolgov and zakharov approach @xcite to derive the axial anomaly is based on the dispersion relation method . in this framework ,
the triangular diagram with two vector and one axial vertices is seen as the lowest order contribution to the process : @xmath4 as described by the diagrams of fig . 1 . [ cols="^ " , ] [ fig2 ] in terms of dispersion relations ,
the functions @xmath5 , @xmath6 can be expressed as follows : @xmath7 we can use unsubtracted dispersion relations , because the integrals contained in @xmath5 , @xmath6 are convergent , since these functions are multiplied by three and two powers of momentum , respectively .
+ the imaginary part of the invariant scalar functions can be derived from the absorbitive part of the triangular diagram , calculated by cutting the diagram as shown in fig .
[ fig2 ] and by using the cutkosky rules or the perturbative unitarity relation .
we obtain @xcite : @xmath8 using eqs .
( [ def1 ] ) , ( [ def2 ] ) , ( [ dr ] ) and the above expressions , we derive the complete triangular diagram contribution : @xmath9 and the anomalous axial - vector ward - takahashi identity : @xmath10 thus , in the dispersive approach we find the same result obtained by using the renormalization procedure @xcite .
the method above allows a more direct treatment , since we avoid evaluating divergent integrals and introducing regularization schemes .
+ the fact that the axial anomaly can be derived without using the renormalization procedure , suggests that this should not be considered as the only origin of the anomalous breaking of the chiral symmetry .
moreover , by studying the axial anomaly with the renormalization procedure , that is by considering its ultraviolet interpretation , an important aspect of this phenomenon remains obscure and we are bound by a formal derivation only .
as stressed in @xcite and @xcite , the dispersive approach shows that the anomaly is related to the chiral limit and therefore , it can be interpreted as an infrared effect . in this work
we are close to this infrared interpretation , which , as we will see , can help to shed light on some aspects of the physics connected to the axial anomaly .
+ let us briefly discuss the physics involved in the amplitudes contributing to the absorbitive part of the triangular diagram .
the two born diagrams , obtained from the cut of the triangular diagram ( see fig . [ fig1 ] ) , describe the following two processes : 1 . the production of a fermion - antifermion pair ( for example @xmath11 ) by an axial - vector source ; 2 .
the subsequent annihilation of the pair into two real photons .
in both these processes there occur helicity flips , thus the chirality is not conserved in the zero mass limit .
+ let us go to the center of mass frame of the two final photons . in the first process the axial - vector source produces an @xmath11 pair of total spin zero , since a spin 1 state can not annihilate into a two real photons state .
thus @xmath12 and @xmath13 must have the same helicity and hence opposite chirality in the massless limit . in the process
b ) the @xmath11 pair annihilates into two real photons by going through an intermediate virtual state .
there are four possible virtual states @xcite : one is drawn in fig .
3 c [ fig3 ] ( @xmath14 and @xmath15 are the @xmath13 and @xmath12 linear momenta ) , a second one is obtained by reversing the virtual state helicity ; the remaining two are obtained replacing the outgoing virtual fermion with an incoming virtual antifermion .
let us study the case shown in fig . 3 and assume that @xmath12 and @xmath13 are both right - handed . in the vertex b the chirality is conserved in the massless limit , while in the vertex a there is an helicity flip , thus the chiral symmetry is broken .
as can be easily checked , for all the remaining virtual states we always have an allowed vertex and a forbidden one .
+ at the born level , these reactions are described by the classical qed lagrangian , which , in the @xmath16 limit , is invariant under chiral transformations .
thus it seems at first sight that the absorbitive part of the triangular diagram , being proportional to the product of amplitudes relative to processes forbidden by chiral invariance , vanishes . on the contrary
, one sees that taking the limit @xmath16 in ( [ g2 ] ) gives a finite result @xcite : @xmath17 therefore , by studying the absorbitive part of the triangular diagram , one establishes that a non - conservation of helicity occurs , becoming , in the massless limit , a non - conservation of chirality .
we interpret this as related to the presence of the anomalous term in the divergence of the axial - vector current .
thus the axial anomaly can be derived by studying the properties of the amplitude in the infrared region .
+ even if in this work we will analyse the cancellation of mass singularities in polarized processes , we will not discuss the physical implication of the zero fermion mass limit .
+ as stated in refs .
@xcite , the result in eq .
( [ limit ] ) indicates that there occurs a cancellation of the suppression factor @xmath18 , due to the terms coming from the vertices with helicity flip . in ( [ g1 ] )
the logarithmic factor conspires to give a finite result .
this logarithm is a collinear one ; we shall discuss about this kind of logarithms in section [ mass ] .
its presence is a manifestation of the singularity occurring in the fermion propagator as @xmath16 , which exactly cancels the suppression factor @xmath18 in the numerator . + we observe that the behaviour of the absorbitive part of the triangular diagram given in eq .
( [ limit ] ) shows that the @xmath16 limit is not smooth ; if we evaluate the amplitudes with the massless theory , they identically vanish . if , on the contrary , we take the chiral limit after summing their product over the intermediate states , we obtain a result different from zero .
in the process b ) contributing to the absorbitive part of the triangular diagram a charged polarized fermion , changes helicity by emitting a photon .
thanks to the collinear singularity within the propagator relative to this fermion , the chiral suppression factor @xmath18 is cancelled and the absorbitive part of the triangular diagram does nt vanish in the chiral limit .
+ let us now extend these remarks to physical processes having the same features as the ones characterizing the absorbitive part of the triangular diagram .
this means that we want to investigate about a manifestation of the axial anomaly in reactions where a fermion changes helicity by emitting a photon .
we call these processes helicity changing processes .
they have been considered by lee and nauenberg @xcite , who observed that states with opposite helicity do nt decouple in the massless limit , provided that this limit is taken after having summed the transition probability over the final phase space . in the process
b ) the incoming @xmath12 and @xmath13 are in a definite helicity state , as discussed above . in the reactions we want to study ,
we calculate the probability that an outgoing fermion assumes an helicity opposite to the one required by the interaction before the emission of the photon . in other words ,
we evaluate the probability that in the fermion - photon vertex occurs an helicity flip . according to the dolgov and zakharov analysis
, we interpret the presence of a term independent of the fermion mass in the corresponding cross sections as a manifestation of the axial anomaly .
due to this term , the probability for a process with helicity flip does nt vanish in the chiral limit . + we first examine the non radiative pion decay @xmath19 where @xmath20 is an antilepton ( @xmath21 or @xmath22 ) and @xmath23 is the associated neutrino . at the born level
the total decay rate is given by : @xmath24 where @xmath25 is the fermi coupling constant , @xmath26 is the pion decay constant , @xmath27 is the ckm matrix element , @xmath28 and @xmath29 are the lepton and pion masses , respectively .
the decay rate ( [ born ] ) is proportional to @xmath30 , since , due to angular momentum conservation , the pion produces a left - handed lepton , while the structure of the weak coupling requires the @xmath31 to be right - handed for @xmath32 .
+ this situation is confirmed by the expression of the total decay rate for the process in which the antilepton is polarized : @xmath33 where @xmath34 and @xmath35 are the linear momentum and the spin vector of the lepton , respectively , giving @xmath36 , for right - handed and left - handed lepton , respectively .
( [ bornpol ] ) indicates that the lepton is mandatory left - handed , as requested by angular momentum conservation .
+ we now consider the radiative correction , due to the emission of a real photon , to the pion decay , @xmath37 when the outgoing antilepton is polarized , i.e. when it is in a definite helicity state . as we have seen in the non - radiative case , due to angular momentum conservation , the @xmath0
is coupled to a left - handed lepton .
we calculate the probability that the lepton flips its helicity and becomes right - handed , by emitting a real photon .
+ the amplitude describing the radiative pion decay can be divided into two parts , the inner bremsstrahlung and the structure dependent amplitudes @xcite : @xmath38 the inner bremsstrahlung amplitude , where the photon is radiated from the external charged particles , can be calculated using the rules of qed , with a point like pion coupling ; the structure - dependent amplitude is governed by the strong interactions .
+ clearly , the relevant part for the problem we are considering is the inner bremsstrahlung contribution described by the diagrams of fig .
c [ innerb ] the term associated to the @xmath39 diagram is the so called contact term and it is introduced to ensure gauge invariance ( see , for example , @xcite ) .
+ we consider only tree level diagrams , since , to reveal the effects of the axial anomaly , it is sufficient to take into account the contribution of the vertex with the helicity flip . for the moment , we may neglect the corrections due to the emission of virtual photons ; these will be discussed in section [ mass ] .
finally , at this order in perturbation theory , we retain terms of all powers in the lepton mass .
we will argue that the manifestation of the axial anomaly is strictly connected to these terms .
+ the inner bremsstrahlung amplitude is given by @xcite : @xmath40 v(p_l , s_{lr } ) , \label{e:4.5}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath41 and @xmath42 are the dirac spinors for the neutrino and the lepton , respectively , @xmath43 is the pion momentum , @xmath44 and @xmath45 are the momentum and the polarization vector of the lepton , @xmath46 and @xmath47 are the momentum and the polarization vector of the photon . + we see that @xmath48 is proportional to the lepton mass @xmath28 , thus the decay rate is proportional to @xmath30 . as we have said above , this factor is a consequence of the structure of the weak coupling .
thus , if we remove it by normalizing the radiative decay rate with respect to the non radiative one , we can emphasize the mass dependence of the radiation emission process .
+ the differential inner bremsstrahlung contribution for right - handed lepton is : @xmath49 \nonumber \\ & & + \,\big[(a+2r)(1+r)^2 + ay(y-4r ) + 2ry(1+y)-y(1+y^2 + 5r^2)\big]\,\ln{\frac{y+a}{y - a } } \nonumber \\ & & + \,(1-y+r)^2(y-2r - a ) \ln{\frac{y+a-2}{y - a-2}}\bigg\}. \label{ibr}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the dimensionless variable @xmath50 is defined as @xmath51 and @xmath52 the physical region for @xmath50 is : @xmath53 we see that , in eq .
( [ ibr ] ) , there is a term independent of the lepton mass , the one in the first square brackets . owing to this term , the differential decay rate does nt vanish in the limit @xmath54 .
we have : @xmath55 this indicates that there occurs an helicity flip and thus a chirality non conservation in the limit of zero lepton mass .
according to the interpretation given above , this term can be interpreted as connected to the axial anomaly .
it corresponds to the anomalous term present in the divergence of the axial current .
+ since the polarized radiative process with the right - handed @xmath31 is forbidden , in the limit @xmath54 , by the chiral invariance of the massless qed lagrangian , the appearance of a term different from zero , in this limit , indicates the action of a cancellation mechanism , analogous to the one acting in the absorbitive part of the triangular diagram .
+ to see how this mechanism acts , let us examine the decay rate differential with respect to the lepton energy and to the emission angle : @xmath56 \ , \frac{1}{(y - a\cos{\theta } ) } \nonumber \\ & & + ( 1-y+r)^2(y - a-2r)\ , \frac{1}{(y - a\cos{\theta } -2 ) } \bigg\}. \label{integrale}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the first term is proportional to the lepton propagator squared .
thanks to this term , when we carry out the final integration over the emission angle , we obtain , besides logarithmic collinear divergences , also power collinear divergences .
these power terms are essential for the convergent behaviour of the distribution .
the cancellation of the chiral suppression would not take place were these terms absent . the term related to the axial anomaly
( [ massa0 ] ) ) originates from this cancellation . to obtain the differential decay rate
, we have to evaluate integrals of the form : @xmath57 where the propagator has a power mass singularity that exactly cancels the factor @xmath30 , coming from the vertex lepton - photon .
+ the integration of the terms in equation ( [ integrale ] ) containing the lepton propagator gives rise to the collinear logarithms : @xmath58 in the differential decay rate ( [ ibr ] ) there are also terms proportional to the logarithm @xmath59 this one is another collinear logarithm ; it diverges in the limit @xmath60 and @xmath54 and corresponds to the possibility that the photon is emitted parallel to the pion .
+ finally , we point out that the chiral limit ( @xmath54 ) is not smooth .
in fact we get different results depending upon whether we describe an helicity changing process using the massless theory or we take the @xmath54 limit , after carrying out the integration over the final phase space .
the radiative pion decay is not a good process to see this , since , owing to the angular momentum conservation in the pion vertex , this process can not take place within a massless theory , given the structure of the @xmath61 coupling of the electroweak theory . to see that the chiral limit is not a smooth one , we consider the scattering of a polarized electron with a proton ( treated as a point like particle ) of initial and final momenta @xmath62 and @xmath63 respectively , accompanied by the emission of a real photon .
we consider a left - handed incoming electron with momentum @xmath43 and spin @xmath64 : we calculate the probability that the electron makes an helicity flip , emitting a real photon with momentum @xmath46 and polarization @xmath47 and thus becoming right - handed electron with momentum @xmath65 and spin @xmath66 : @xmath67 we study this process with the massless qed .
the left - handed and right - handed spinors are given respectively by : @xmath68 the corresponding transition amplitude identically vanishes : @xmath69 ( l^2 + i \epsilon ) } \nonumber \\ & & \bar{u}(p')\frac{1-\gamma_5}{2 } { \not\!}\epsilon({\not\!}p ' + { \not\!}k ) \gamma_{\rho } \frac{1-\gamma_5}{2}u(p ) \bar{u}(q')\gamma^{\rho}u(q ) = 0,\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ qed0 ] since it contains the product of different chirality projectors .
+ we now calculate the cross sections for processes with helicity flip using the massive qed and then we take the massless limit after having summed the transition probability over the final phase space .
an example can be found in @xcite , where the cross section for the process @xmath70 is calculated .
here @xmath71 is the target ( for example another fermion ) , @xmath72 is a bremsstrahlung photon , assumed almost collinear with respect to the direction of the incident electron and @xmath73 is a set of particles produced in the reaction .
+ the helicity flip cross section is given by : @xmath74 where @xmath75 , @xmath76 is the energy of the incoming electron and @xmath77 is the cross section for the born process @xmath78 we see that the expression ( [ hf ] ) does not vanish in the massless limit .
+ the result in eq .
( [ hf ] ) coincides with the one in eq .
( [ massa0 ] ) at leading order . indeed , in @xcite the subdominant terms are not accounted for .
as it will become apparent in the following section , these terms are essential for the cancellation of mass singularities .
@xcite , the authors give a different interpretation of the helicity changing processes and hence come to a different conclusion about the smoothness of the zero mass limit . +
as it is well know , there are two types of divergences occurring in a theory when the mass of a particle goes to zero , which will be comprehensively call in the following mass singularities .
+ the first type of divergences appears when we reach the phase space region , where the momentum of the massless particles vanishes : these are called infrared divergences .
they occur for example in qed when the energy of the photon goes to zero .
the block - nordsieck theorem @xcite assures that the infrared divergences cancel out in any inclusive cross section .
+ the other type of mass singularities occurs in theories with massless coupled particles , like in qed when the photon couples to a fermion , in the limit of zero fermion mass .
the origin is purely kinematical : when two massless particles , say with momenta @xmath46 and @xmath79 , move parallel to each other , they have combined invariant mass equal to zero : @xmath80 even though neither @xmath46 nor @xmath79 are soft .
these divergences are called collinear singularities .
+ if we keep the fermion mass finite and integrate over the photon emission angle , the collinear divergence does nt occur , but the possibility of a divergence in the limit @xmath81 results in the presence of the collinear logarithms , that is logarithms of the form @xmath82 , diverging for @xmath16 . + in the case of collinear singularities , the theorem by kinoshita , lee and nauenberg @xcite guarantees that these divergences cancel out if we sum the transition probability over the set of degenerate states , order by order in perturbation theory .
this cancellation mechanism is analogous to that of the infrared divergences , as stated by the block - nordsieck theorem .
both types of mass singularities arise because the states of a theory with massless particles are highly degenerate .
the infrared divergences can be interpreted as a consequences of the fact that a state with a single charged particle is degenerate with a state made of the same particle plus a number of soft photons ; this correspond to the impossibility of distinguishing experimentally a charged particle from one accompanied by soft photons , owing to the finite resolution of the measurement apparatus .
the situation of the collinear singularities is analogous : the state with a massless charged particle is degenerate with the states containing the same particle and a number of collinear photons .
this corresponds to the fact that , as a consequence of the finite angular resolution , we can not establish if a massless charged particle is accompanied by collinear photons .
+ let us now discuss the structure of mass singularities and their cancellation in the decay rates for the radiative pion and @xmath1 decays and how the kln theorem applies to this cases . + it is useful to separate the cases of unpolarized , right - handed and left - handed outgoing lepton .
+ let us consider first the mass singularity cancellation mechanism for the familiar case of unpolarized radiative @xmath0 decay to the first order in @xmath83 .
the differential inner bremsstrahlung contribution is given by : @xmath84\,\ln{\frac{y+a}{y - a } } \nonumber \\ & - & ( 1-y+r)^2\,\ln{\frac{y+a-2}{y - a-2 } } \bigg\}. \label{irnp}\end{aligned}\ ] ] one can easily see that the eq .
( [ irnp ] ) is divergent both in the collinear and in the infrared limits .
the coefficients of the collinear logarithms do nt go to zero in the limit @xmath85 .
there are also infrared divergences , because if we let @xmath50 reach its kinematical limit @xmath86 , corresponding to the photon energy going to zero , the expression ( [ irnp ] ) diverges .
+ the decay rate is made free from mass singularities in the ordinary way : the divergences cancellation occurs in the total inclusive decay rate , when we add all the first order contributions to the perturbative expansion , i.e. those relative to real and virtual photon emission .
+ the diagrams describing the real photon emission contribution were already given in fig .
4 ; the diagram for the virtual correction is drawn in fig .
c [ fig5 ] the expression for the lepton energy spectrum , including the inner bremsstrahlung contribution and the virtual photon one , calculated to the leading order in @xmath87 , is given by @xcite : @xmath88 .
\label{spettroy}\ ] ] @xmath89 is the lepton distribution function , given , to the first order in @xmath83 , by : @xmath90p^{(1)}(y ) , \label{defd}\ ] ] where @xmath91 is the logarithm @xmath92 diverging in the collinear limit ; if the lepton is an electron , @xmath93 .
@xmath94 is the gribov - lipatov - altarelli - parisi kernel @xcite , which can be expressed in the form : @xmath95 @xmath96 is a finite term , free from infrared and collinear singularities , which has the expression : @xmath97 the differential decay rate to order @xmath83 therefore becomes : @xmath98 to calculate the inclusive decay rate , we have to integrate the expression in eq .
( [ ordalfa ] ) over @xmath50 ; to the leading order in the lepton mass , the physical region for @xmath50 is @xmath99 .
the kernel @xmath100 has the property that : @xmath101 thus , when we calculate the inclusive decay rate , the coefficient of the collinear logarithm vanishes and the resulting expression is finite in the zero mass limit . + carrying out the integration over @xmath50 , we obtain the well known inclusive decay rate to order @xmath83 @xmath102 . \label{tot}\ ] ] as expected , the expression ( [ tot ] ) is finite in the collinear limit and is also free from infrared divergences , because , as usual , the infrared divergences present in the soft photon contribution and in the virtual photon contribution have cancelled each other . +
let us now discuss the mass singularities in the case of the right - handed inner bremsstrahlung contribution , given in eq .
( [ ibr ] ) .
it is easy to see that @xmath103 is finite in the limit @xmath104 , i.e. it is free from collinear singularities . in this limit
the coefficients of both the collinear logarithms vanish . indeed , as we have observed in section [ pionpol ] , only the term related to the axial anomaly survives in the zero mass limit , that is the part of the decay rate independent of the lepton mass .
+ we observe that the right - handed inner bremsstrahlung contribution is free from infrared divergences as well . if we make the lepton energy @xmath50 reach its kinematical limit @xmath105 , we obtain a finite result : @xmath106 the result ( [ limir ] ) shows that the soft photon emission does not contribute to the radiative @xmath0 decay with a right - handed lepton .
this is a consequence of the fact that the soft photon contribution factorizes with respect to the born decay rate , but this vanishes in the case of right - handed @xmath31 ( see eq .
( [ bornpol ] ) ) . physically , eq .
( [ limir ] ) is due to the fact that soft photons do nt carry spin , thus they can not contribute to the angular momentum balance ; therefore the process with the right - handed lepton emitting a soft photon is forbidden by angular momentum conservation .
+ for the same reason of angular momentum conservation , in the right - handed case also the virtual contribution identically vanishes .
the virtual photon diagram ( see fig .
5 ) interferes with the born one ; the corresponding correction to the total decay rate for @xmath107 was calculated long ago by kinoshita @xcite and is given by : @xmath108 + \frac{r}{1-r } \ln{r } + 1\bigg\}\gamma_0 , \label{kin}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath109 @xmath110 is the ultraviolet cutoff and @xmath111 is the infrared one . + as usual , the virtual correction is factorized with respect to the born decay rate , but , as we have already seen , if the lepton is right - handed , this is identically zero .
+ in the right - handed case , the mass singularities cancellation occurs trough a mechanism different from the one working in the unpolarized decay rate .
the infrared and the collinear limits give separately a finite result .
in particular , the coefficient of the collinear logarithms is the lepton mass , instead of the usual correction factor coming from the soft and the virtual photon contributions , as in eq .
( [ ordalfa ] ) . in this sense , since the soft and collinear radiation factorizes with respect to the born helicity changing decay rate , the double logarithm sudakov term can be equally factorized .
it could be useful to investigate the impact of the higher order terms on the radiative correction to the born amplitude .
it is an open question if say hard collinear photons can be factorized and resummed .
+ the particular mass cancellation mechanism occurring in the right - handed radiative decay is the consequence of the combination of two constraints : the angular momentum conservation in the pion vertex and the helicity flip in the photon - lepton vertex .
+ the situation is completely different if we consider the radiative process with the outgoing left - handed lepton , i.e. the process without helicity flip .
the differential inner bremsstrahlung contribution for left - handed outgoing lepton is given by : @xmath112 \nonumber \\ & & + \big[(a-2r)(1+r)^2 + ay(y-4r ) -2ry(1+y ) + y(5r^2+y^2 + 1)\big ] \
, \ln{\frac{y+a}{y - a } } \nonumber \\ & & + ( 1-y+r)^2(2r - a - y ) \ , \ln{\frac{y+a-2}{y - a-2 } } \bigg\ } \label{ibl}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the expression ( [ ibl ] ) contains collinear singularities , since the coefficients of the collinear logarithms do nt vanish in the limit @xmath104 , as one can see from eq .
( [ ibl ] ) .
the decay rate ( [ ibl ] ) is also infrared divergent , as one can verify by taking the limit @xmath113 . in this case
we do nt have the constraint constituted by the helicity flip in the photon - lepton vertex and in the pion vertex the angular momentum is conserved for soft and virtual photon emission .
thus , in the left - handed case , the mass singularity cancellation occurs in the ordinary way , as in the unpolarized case , i.e. in the total inclusive decay rate , obtained by adding all the order @xmath83 contributions . + let us show how the cancellation takes place .
as we have already seen ( eq .
( [ bornpol ] ) ) , in the born @xmath0 decay the outgoing lepton is left - handed , due to angular momentum conservation .
thus the unpolarized and the left - handed born decay rate coincide : @xmath114 because of the factorization with respect to the born decay rate , also the unpolarized and the left - handed virtual contributions are equal : @xmath115 expressing the left - handed inner bremsstrahlung contribution in terms of the unpolarized and the right - handed ones , the total contribution to order @xmath83 to the left - handed process is given by : @xmath116 the expression ( [ totl ] ) is finite both in the infrared and in the collinear limit , because the mass singularities present in the terms between brackets cancel each other , as we have seen ( see eq .
( [ tot ] ) and @xmath117 is free from mass singularities .
+ let us now discuss the origin of these different cancellation mechanisms .
the presence of mass singularities is a consequence of the fact that the states of a theory containing massless particles are highly degenerate .
the kln theorem states that the mass singularities disappear from the transition probability when we average it over the ensemble of degenerate states .
this theorem contains the block - nordsieck theorem as a special case , when we consider only the cancellation of the infrared divergences .
+ we can define two degeneration ensembles , one relative to the infrared divergences and one relative to the collinear singularities .
we call them the infrared and the collinear ensembles , respectively .
if we sum the transition probability over the states contained in the former , the infrared divergences cancel out and if we average it over the latter , we obtain a quantity free from both infrared and collinear singularities .
the infrared ensemble is the one prescribed by the block - nordsieck theorem , while the second is the one prescribed by the kln theorem and contains the first as a subset .
+ let us now examine how the infrared and collinear ensemble are composed for the radiative pion decay in the cases of unpolarized , left - handed and right - handed outgoing lepton .
this discussion concerns the issue of the degeneration of states already addressed for the unpolarized case @xcite .
this issue in the case of helicity changing processes presents peculiar features .
+ we have seen in section [ pion ] that in the unpolarized and left - handed inner bremsstrahlung contributions there are mass singularities , indicating that we have not summed the transition probability over the entire ensemble of degenerate states . in these cases
the infrared ensemble contains , to order @xmath83 , the state with a pion , a charged lepton and a neutrino and all the other states differing from this for the presence of a soft virtual or real photon , i.e. a photon with an energy @xmath118 , where @xmath119 is an infrared cut off , tipically the measurement apparatus resolution .
the collinear ensemble is constituted by all the states of the infrared ensemble plus the states with a hard photon moving parallel to the pion or the lepton . clearly the degeneration arises in the limit @xmath120 . + according to the kln theorem the fact that @xmath103 is finite both in the infrared and in the collinear limits means that in the right - handed case , calculating the differential decay rate ( i.e. summing over the photon polarization and integrating over the photon energy and emission angle ) , we have already averaged over the set of degenerate states relative to this process .
let us now consider how the degeneration ensemble for the right - handed radiative decay is composed . to obtain @xmath121
we have not averaged over the infrared subspace of the collinear ensemble , but this is enough to render the transition probability free from mass singularities .
indeed in this case the infrared ensemble is empty , owing to the constraints imposed both by the angular momentum conservation in the pion vertex and by the helicity flip in the photon - lepton vertex .
thus in this case the degeneration ensemble contains only the states with the outgoing lepton accompanied by hard collinear photons .
+ we conclude that imposing to the outgoing lepton a polarization opposed to the one prescribed by the vertex preceding the photon emission , implies a reduction of the degeneration subspace .
this fact has two consequences : the first is that both the infrared and the collinear limits are finite and the second is that these limits are disconnected , since the collinear degeneration subspace is constituted only by the states with the pion and the outgoing lepton accompanied by hard collinear photons .
thus in this case we have a particular application of the kln theorem .
+ in the radiative pion decay , due to the angular momentum conservation in the pion vertex , there is no room for a right - handed lepton .
for such a channel , soft and virtual photon contributions are zero .
this result is valid independently of the lepton mass .
+ let us now consider a more general case , by loosing the value of the angular momentum of the decaying state .
as an example , we study the radiative @xmath1 decay in a lepton - antilepton @xmath122 pair , in which the lepton is in a definite helicity state .
+ the @xmath1-leptons vertex is : @xmath123 with @xmath124 where @xmath125 is the weinberg angle and @xmath126 is the @xmath1 mass .
+ we have chosen this process , since , by varying the constants @xmath127 and @xmath128 , we can control the structure of the @xmath1-leptons coupling ; thus it is possible to point out the role played by the conservation law occurring in this vertex in the chiral limit in the collinear singularity cancellation .
if we set @xmath129 , we require that in the limit of zero lepton mass , the @xmath1 couples to a left - handed lepton .
+ we calculate the decay rate for the process in which the lepton is right - handed . at the born level this is given by : @xmath130 - 2g_vg_a(1 - 4r ) \bigg\}. \label{bornz}\end{aligned}\ ] ] if in eq .
( [ bornz ] ) we set @xmath129 , @xmath131 vanishes in the chiral limit , since there is nt the term related to the axial anomaly .
+ let us now study the decay process with the lepton emitting a real photon ( see fig .
6 ) c [ fig6 ] and evaluate the probability that the outgoing lepton is right - handed .
the electromagnetic interaction does nt couples states with different chirality , hence the decay rate is expected to vanish for @xmath104 .
+ the decay rate for the process described by the diagram of fig . 6 , differential with respect to the lepton energy , is given by : @xmath132 \nonumber \\ & + & \frac{(1-y)}{2(1-y+r)}\ , \big[(g^2_v+g^2_a)a(2r - y ) + 2g_vg_a(y^2 - 2r)\big ] \nonumber \\ & + & \frac{2}{(y-1)}\ , \big[2(g^2_v-2g^2_a)ar + ( g^2_v+g^2_a)a + 2g_vg_a(4r - y^2+y-1)\big ] \nonumber \\ & + & \big[g^2_v+g^2_a + 2g_vg_a\,\frac{1}{a}\,\big(4r^2+r(y - y^2 + 1)-y\big)\big ] \,\big[\ln{\frac{y+a}{y - a } } - \ln{\frac{y+a-2}{y - a-2}}\big]\bigg\}. \nonumber \\ \label{rz}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath133 @xmath50 is the usual dimensionless variable : @xmath134 where @xmath135 is the lepton energy and @xmath136 the physical region for @xmath50 is @xmath137 the result obtained , as given by the emission of the photon by a single leg , is gauge dependent . to have a gauge independent amplitude , the contribution of the diagram b ) of fig .
7 must be added . for the purpose of the polarized amplitude , however , the helicity flip contribution of the diagram b ) of fig .
7 gives zero in the massless limit and is therefore negligible in our discussion .
+ from now on we consider the case @xmath129 , to have the condition of chirality conservation in the @xmath1 vertex for @xmath120 . taking this limit in eq .
( [ rz ] ) , we see that @xmath138 does not vanish : @xmath139 the result of this limit is the contribution related to the axial anomaly , which has the same form of the one found in the pion case .
+ let us now discuss the mass singularities cancellation mechanism for the @xmath1 decay case .
if we keep the lepton mass different from zero , the helicity is not fixed by the interaction occurring before the photon emission , even if we set @xmath129 .
thus , for @xmath140 , the soft and virtual photons contribution are different from zero and diverge in the infrared limit .
indeed , if we let the lepton energy reach its kinematical limit , @xmath141 , we see that @xmath138 diverges .
we expect the infrared divergences to cancel , if we add all the first order contributions , given by the diagrams of fig .
6 and 7 c [ fig7 ] and calculate the totally inclusive decay rate .
( [ collz ] ) shows that the collinear limit gives a finite result .
thus , we conclude that , as in the case of the radiative pion decay , evaluating @xmath138 we have already summed over all the collinear degeneration subspace . as a consequence ,
the collinear and infrared limit are disconnected .
+ if we take the limit @xmath142 in eq .
( [ collz ] ) , we obtain : @xmath143 in general , if a quantity is finite in the collinear limit , it is finite also in the infrared limit , since the collinear subspace contains the infrared one .
( [ irz ] ) indicates that in the massless limit the soft photon contribution is zero .
indeed , it is factorized with respect to the born decay rate , which , for @xmath104 and @xmath129 , vanishes . as we have discussed in section [ anomaly ] , the presence of the anomalous term is directly connected to the emission of the photon , hence it vanishes in the infrared limit . + the virtual photon contribution vanishes in the zero mass limit , as well .
indeed , it is factorized respect to the born decay rate , which goes to zero as @xmath104 .
the virtual correction factor can produce only a logarithmic collinear singularity , not a power - like one , needed for the cancellation of the chiral suppression .
+ we observe that taking the infrared limit @xmath144 in eq .
( [ hf ] ) , gives a finite result ( indeed the cross section vanishes ) .
this is a consequence of the fact that the cross section ( [ hf ] ) has been calculated to the leading order in the lepton mass . from the eq .
( [ rz ] ) , we see that , for @xmath145 , the infrared divergent term is given by : @xmath146 and it is proportional to the lepton mass . performing the calculation , neglecting the mass terms , as done in ref .
@xcite , means imposing the chirality conservation law in the @xmath1 vertex ; thus the soft photon contribution is zero and the infrared divergences disappear . to the leading order in the lepton mass
, we have only the anomalous term , which vanishes in the infrared limit . +
as done for the pion case , we now examine the composition of the degeneration ensembles for the radiative @xmath1 decay with the right - handed lepton .
( [ irz ] ) indicates that , in the chiral limit , the soft photons do nt contribute to the process with the right - handed outgoing lepton , since , not carrying spin , they can not contribute to the helicity flip .
+ as we have already said , the virtual photon contribution vanishes in the zero mass limit . in the limit @xmath120 ,
also the diagram with the photon emitted by @xmath147 does nt contribute , since , clearly , it violates the chirality conservation in the @xmath1 vertex .
+ the collinear degeneration arises in the massless limit .
the result ( [ collz ] ) shows that , in this limit , the collinear ensemble is constituted only by the states with the lepton accompanied by hard collinear photons , just as in the case of the pion decay .
thus for @xmath120 the infrared ensemble is empty and also the states with the antilepton accompanied by a hard collinear photon do nt contribute .
we have shown that the dolgov and zakharov treatment of the axial anomaly can be extended to processes characterized by a lepton which changes helicity by emitting a photon , as it was already noticed in @xcite .
the corresponding decay rates do nt vanish in the chiral limit , due to a term independent of the lepton mass ; we interpret the presence of this term as related to the axial anomaly .
this can be seen as a signal of the anomalous symmetry breaking in processes different from the usual ones , like the @xmath3 decay .
+ we have computed the rates corresponding to the @xmath0 and @xmath1 radiative decays .
we have analysed their infrared and collinear limits .
it results essential to keep the terms of all orders in the lepton mass , since the cancellation of the infrared and collinear divergences takes place among these terms .
we have examined the connection between the polarization of the outgoing leptons and the application of the kln theorem .
+ we have shown that for the helicity changing processes the cancellation of the collinear singularities occurs through a mechanism different from the usual one of real and virtual compensation .
the coefficients in front of the collinear terms go to zero in the chiral limit , producing the finiteness of the distribution .
we have found , however , a difference between the pion case and the more general case of the @xmath1 decay .
the former represents a particular case due to the angular momentum conservation in the pion vertex . as a consequence ,
the virtual and real soft photon contribution are zero , even if the lepton mass is kept different from zero .
the inner bremsstrahlung contribution is finite both in the infrared and in the collinear limits .
+ in the @xmath1 case , the decay rate diverges in the infrared limit , since , for @xmath140 , the soft photon contributions are not zero .
however in the collinear limit , the result is finite , despite the fact that the collinear degenerate states arise only in the zero lepton mass limit . in this limit
the virtual and real soft photon contributions do vanish . in order to make the collinear limit finite , it is therefore sufficient to sum over degenerate states made of the changing helicity lepton accompanied by a hard collinear photon .
the transition probability becomes finite after summing over the photon final phase space .
+ we noticed that in the helicity changing processes the collinear limit results disconnected from the infrared one .
the contributions coming from the virtual photon emission and from the emission of photons by particles different from the one changing helicity , are zero .
+ this situation is due to the fact that the born part of the process fixes the fermion chirality in the zero mass limit , while , after the photon emission , it is in a state of opposite chirality ; this reduces the collinear ensemble .
+ we conclude that the collinear singularity cancellation mechanism for helicity changing processes is controlled by the anomalous breaking of the chiral symmetry .
the axial anomaly implies that the collinear limit gives a finite result , independent of the fermion mass .
+ the extension of the above remarks to other gauge theories like qcd , is possible .
it could allow a more systematic and complete treatment of the infrared and collinear singularities .
+ 99 s. adler , phys . rev .
* 177 * ( 1969 ) 2426 ; + j.s .
bell and r. jackiw , nuovo cimento * a60 * ( 1969 ) 47 .
k. fujikawa , phys .
* 42 * ( 1979 ) 1195 .
dolgov and v.i .
zakharov , nucl .
* b27 * ( 1971 ) 525 .
gribov , hungarian academy of sciences report kfki-1981 - 66 ( 1981 ) .
lectures given at the institute for theoretical physics , santa barbara , 1988 .
mueller , phys . lett .
* b234 * ( 1990 ) 517 .
r. jackiw , in `` lectures on current algebra and its application '' , princeton university press , princeton , new jersey ( 1972 ) ; + h.b .
nielsen and m. ninomiya , int .
phys . * a6 * ( 1991 ) 2913 ; + c. adam and r.a .
bertlmann , z. phys . *
c56 * ( 1992 ) 123 .
b. falk and l.m .
sehgal , phys .
b325 * ( 1994 ) 509 .
smilga , comments nucl .
phys . * 20 * ( 1991 ) 69 .
tung , phys .
* d52 * ( 1995 ) 1353 ; + s. groote , j.g .
krner , j.a .
leyva , phys . lett . *
b418 * ( 1998 ) 192 .
g. t hooft , in `` recent developments in gauge theories '' , proceedings of the cargese summer institute , cargese , france , 1979 , edited by g. t hooft et al .
( nato advanced study institutes , series b : physics , vol .
59 ) ( plenum , new york , 1980 ) .
carlitz , j.c .
collins and a.h .
mueller , phys . lett .
* b214 * ( 1988 ) 229 ; + s. narison , g.m .
shore and g. veneziano , nucl .
b391 * ( 1993 ) 69 ; + g.m .
shore and g. veneziano , mod .
* a8 * ( 1993 ) 373 ; + a. freund and l.m .
sehgal , phys .
b341 * ( 1994 ) 90 .
lee and m. nauenberg , phys .
* 133 * ( 1964 ) 1549 ; + t. kinoshita , j. math .
* 3 * ( 1962 ) 650 .
l. trentadue and m. verbeni , uprf-99 - 21 , december 1999 , phys . lett .
* b * , in press .
zakharov , phys .
* d42 * ( 1990 ) 1208 .
k. huang , `` quarks , leptons and gauge fields '' ( world scientific , singapore , 1992 ) .
bryman , p. depommier and c. leroy , phys . rept .
* 88 * ( 1982 ) 151 and references therein . for a different interpretation of this kind of processes
see : h.f .
contopanagos and m.b .
einhorn , phys .
* d45 * ( 1992 ) 1322 and references therein .
f. bloch and a. nordsieck , phys .
* 52 * ( 1937 ) 54 .
kuraev , jetp lett .
* 65 * ( 1997 ) 127
gribov and l.n .
lipatov , sov .
15 * ( 1972 ) 438 , 675 ; + g. altarelli and g. parisi , nucl . phys . *
b126 * ( 1977 ) 298 ; + yu.l .
dokshitzer , sov .
jetp * 46 * ( 1977 ) 641 . t. kinoshita , phys . rev
* 2 * ( 1959 ) 477 . | we discuss a connection between axial anomaly and polarized radiative processes . by comparison with the corresponding unpolarized cases , we consider some physical outputs for the @xmath0 and @xmath1 polarized radiative decays .
we analyse in detail the pattern of mass singularity cancellation .
uprf-00 - 10 + june 2000 axial anomaly effects in pion and @xmath1 radiative decays 1.0 cm luca trentadue and michela verbeni + .2 cm _ dipartimento di fisica , universit di parma , + infn gruppo collegato di parma , 43100 parma , italy _ + pacs 11.30.rd , 13.20.cz , 11.15.bt |
lease take a look at the images in the top row of fig .
[ fig : fig1 ] .
which object stands out the most ( i.e. , is the most salient one ) in each of these scenes ?
the answer is trivial .
there is only one object , thus it is the most salient one .
now , look at the images in the third row .
these scenes are much more complex and contain several objects , thus it is more challenging for a vision system to select the most salient object .
this problem , known as _ salient object detection ( and segmentation ) _ , has recently attracted a great deal of interest in computer vision community .
the goal is to simulate the astonishing capability of human attention in prioritizing objects for high - level processing .
such a capability has several applications in recognition ( e.g. , @xcite ) , image and video compression ( e.g. , @xcite ) , video summarization ( e.g. , @xcite , media re - targeting and photo collage ( e.g. , @xcite ) , image quality assessment ( e.g. , @xcite ) , image segmentation ( e.g. , @xcite ) , content - based image retrieval and image collection browsing ( e.g. , @xcite ) , image editing and manipulating ( e.g. , @xcite ) , visual tracking ( e.g. , @xcite ) , object discovery ( e.g. , @xcite ) , and human - robot interaction ( e.g. , @xcite ) . a large number of saliency detection methods have been proposed in the past 7 years ( since @xcite ) . in general , a salient object detection model involves two steps : 1 ) _ selecting objects to process _
( i.e. , determining saliency order of objects ) , and 2 ) _ segmenting the object area _
( i.e. , isolating the object and its boundary ) .
so far , models have bypassed the first challenge by focusing on scenes with single objects ( see fig . [
fig : fig1 ] ) .
they do a decent job on the second step as witnessed by very high performances on existing biased datasets ( e.g. , on asd dataset @xcite ) which contain low - clutter images with often a single object at the center .
however , it is unclear how current models perform on complex cluttered scenes with several objects . despite the volume of past research
, this trend has not been yet fully pursued , mainly due to the lack of two ingredients : 1 ) suitable benchmark datasets for scaling up models and model development , and 2 ) a widely - agreed objective definition of the most salient object . in this paper
, we strive to provide solutions for these problems .
further , we aim to discover which component might be the weakest link in the possible failure of models when migrating to complex scenes . some related topics , closely or remotely , to visual saliency modeling and salient object detection include : object importance @xcite , object proposal generation @xcite , memorability @xcite , scene clutter @xcite , image interestingness @xcite , video interestingness @xcite , surprise @xcite , image quality assessment @xcite , scene typicality @xcite , aesthetic @xcite , and attributes @xcite .
one of the earliest models , which generated the _ first wave _ of interest in image saliency in computer vision and neuroscience communities , was proposed by itti _
et al . _
this model was an implementation of earlier general computational frameworks and psychological theories of bottom - up attention based on center - surround mechanisms . in @xcite ,
itti _ et al .
_ showed examples where their model was able to detect spatial discontinuities in scenes .
subsequent behavioral ( e.g. , @xcite ) and computational studies ( e.g. , @xcite ) started to predict fixations with saliency models to verify models and to understand human visual attention .
second wave _ of interest appeared with works of liu _ et al . _
@xcite and achanta _ et al . _
@xcite who treated saliency detection as a binary segmentation problem with 1 for a foreground pixel and 0 for a pixel of the background region .
since then it has been less clear where this new definition stands as it shares many concepts with other well - established computer vision areas such as general segmentation algorithms ( e.g. , @xcite ) , category independent object proposals ( e.g. , @xcite ) , fixation prediction saliency models ( e.g. @xcite ) , and general object detection methods .
this is partly because current datasets have shaped a definition for this problem , which might not totally reflect full potential of models to _ select and segment salient objects in an image with an arbitrary level of complexity_. reviewing all saliency detection models goes beyond the scope of this paper ( see @xcite ) .
some breakthrough efforts are as follows .
et al . _
@xcite introduced a conditional random field ( crf ) framework to combine multi - scale contrast and local contrast based on surrounding , context , and color spatial distributions for binary saliency estimation .
et al . _
@xcite proposed subtracting the average color from the low - pass filtered input for saliency detection .
et al . _
@xcite used a patch - based approach to incorporate global context , aiming to detect image regions that represent the scene .
et al . _
@xcite proposed a region contrast - based method to measure global contrast in the lab color space . in @xcite ,
wang _ et al . _ estimated local saliency , leveraging a dictionary learned from other images , and global saliency using a dictionary learned from other patches of the same image .
et al . _
@xcite observed that decomposing an image into perceptually uniform regions , which abstracts away unnecessary details , is important for high quality saliency detection . in @xcite ,
et al . _ utilized the difference between the color histogram of a region and its immediately neighboring regions for measuring saliency .
et al . _
@xcite defined a measure of saliency as the cost of composing an image window using the remaining parts of the image , and tested it on pascal voc dataset @xcite .
this method , in its essence , follows the same goal as in @xcite .
et al . _
@xcite proposed a graphical model for fusing generic objectness @xcite and visual saliency for salient object detection .
shen and wu @xcite modeled an image as a low - rank matrix ( background ) plus sparse noises ( salient regions ) in a feature space .
more recently , margolin _ et al . _ @xcite integrated pattern and color distinctnesses with high - level cues to measure saliency of an image patch .
some studies have considered the relationship between fixations and salincy judgments similar to @xcite .
for example , xu et al .
@xcite investigated the role of high - level semantic knowledge ( e.g. , object operability , watchability , gaze direction ) and object information ( e.g. , object center - bias ) for fixation prediction in free viewing of natural scenes .
they constructed a large dataset called `` object and semantic images and eye - tracking ( osie ) '' .
indeed they found an added value for this information for fixation prediction and proposed a regression model ( to find combination weights for different cues ) that improves fixation prediction performance .
koehler et al .
@xcite collected a dataset known as the ucsb dataset .
this dataset contains 800 images .
one hundred observers performed an explicit saliency judgment task , 22 observers performed a free viewing task , 20 observers performed a saliency search task , and 38 observers performed a cued object search task .
observers completing the free viewing task were instructed to freely view the images . in the explicit saliency judgment task , observers were instructed to view a picture on a computer monitor and click on the object or area in the image that was most salient to them . _ salient _ was explained to observers as something that stood out or caught their eye ( similar to @xcite ) .
observers in the saliency search task were instructed to determine whether or not the most salient object or location in an image was on the left or right half of the scene .
finally , observers who performed the cued object search task were asked to determine whether or not a target object was present in the image .
then , they conducted a benchmark and introduced models that perform the best on each of these tasks .
a similar line of work to ours in this paper has been proposed by mishra _
et al . _
@xcite where they combined monocular cues ( color , intensity , and texture ) with stereo and motion features to segment a region given an initial user - specified seed point , practically ignoring the first stage in saliency detection ( which we address here by automatically generating a seed point ) .
ultimately , our attempt in this work is to bridge the interactive segmentation algorithms ( e.g. , @xcite ) and saliency detection models and help transcend their applicability .
perhaps the most similar work to ours has been published by li _
_ @xcite . in their work , they offer two contributions . _ first _ , they collect an eye movement dataset using annotated images from the pascal dataset @xcite and call their dataset pascal - s .
_ second _ , they propose a model that outperforms other state - of - the - art salient object detection models on this dataset ( as well as four other benchmark datasets ) .
their model decouples the salient object detection problem into two processes : 1 ) _ a segment generation process _ , followed by 2 ) _ a saliency scoring mechanism _ using fixation prediction . here ,
similar to li _ et al .
_ , we also take advantage of eye movements to measure object saliency but instead of first fully segmenting the scene , we perform a shallow segmentation using superpixels .
we then only focus on segmenting the object that is most likely to attract attention .
in other words , the two steps are similar to li _ et al . _ but are performed in the reverse order .
this can potentially lead to better efficiency as the first expensive segmentation part is now only an approximation .
we also offer another dataset which is complimentary to li _ et al .
_ s dataset and together both datasets ( and models ) could hopefully lead to a paradigm shift in the salient object detection field to avoid using simple biased datasets .
further , we situate this field among other similar fields such as general object detection and segmentation , objectness proposal generation models , and saliency models for fixation prediction .
several salient object detection datasets have been created as more models have been introduced in the literature to extend capabilities of models to more complex scenes .
table [ tab : db ] lists properties of 19 popular salient object detection datasets . although these datasets suffer from some biases ( e.g. , low scene clutter , center - bias , uniform backgrounds , and non - ambiguous objects ) , they have been very influential for the past progress .
unfortunately , recent efforts to extend existing datasets have only increased the number of images without really addressing core issues specifically background clutter and number of objects .
majority of datasets ( in particular large scale ones such as those derived from the msra dataset ) have scenes with often one object which is usually located at the image center .
this has made model evaluation challenging since some high - performing models that emphasize image center fail in detecting and segmenting the most salient off - center object @xcite .
we believe that now is the time to move on to more versatile datasets and remedy biases in salient object datasets .
in this section , we briefly explain how salient object detection models differ from fixation prediction models , what people consider the most salient object when they are explicitly asked to choose one , what are the relationships between these judgments and eye movements , and what salient object detection models actually predict .
we investigate properties of salient objects from humans point of view when they are explicitly asked to choose such objects .
we then study whether ( and to what extent ) saliency judgments agree with eye movements . while it has been assumed that eye movements are indicators of salient objects , so far few studies ( e.g. , @xcite ) have directly and quantitatively confirmed this assumption .
moreover , the level of agreement and cases of disagreement between fixations and saliency judgments have not been fully explored .
some studies ( e.g. , @xcite ) , have shown that human observers choose to annotate salient objects or regions first but they have not asked humans explicitly ( labelme data was analyzed in @xcite ) and they have ignored eye movements . knowing which objects humans consider as salient is specially crucial when outputs of a model are going to be interpreted by humans .
there are two major differences between models defining saliency as `` where people look '' and models defining saliency as `` which objects stand out '' .
_ first _ , the former models aim to predict points that people look in free - viewing of natural scenes usually for 3 to 5 seconds while the latter aim to detect and segment salient objects ( by drawing pixel - accurate silhouettes around them ) . in principle a model that scores well on one problem should not score very well on the other . an optimal model for fixation prediction should only highlight those points that a viewer will look at ( few points inside an object and not the whole object region ) .
since salient object detection models aim to segment the whole object region they will generate a lot of false positives ( these points belong to the object but viewers may not fixate at them ) when it comes to fixation prediction . on the contrary
, a fixation prediction model will miss a lot of points inside the object ( i.e. , false negatives ) when it comes to segmentation .
_ second _ , due to noise in eye tracking or observers saccade landing ( typically around 1 degrees and @xmath0 30 pixels ) , highly accurate pixel - level prediction maps are less desired .
in fact , due to these noises , sometimes blurring prediction maps increases the scores @xcite . on the contrary , producing salient object detection maps that can accurately distinguish object boundaries are highly desirable specially in applications . due to these
, different evaluation and benchmarks have been developed for comparing models in these two categories . in practice ,
models , whether they address segmentation or fixation prediction , are applicable interchangeably as both entail generating similar saliency maps .
for example , several researches have been thresholding saliency maps of their models , originally designed to predict fixations , to detect and segment salient proto - objects ( e.g. , @xcite ) . in our previous study
@xcite , we addressed what people consider as the most outstanding ( i.e. , salient ) object in a scene . while in @xcite we studied the explicit saliency problem from a behavioral perspective , here we are mainly interested in constructing computational models for automatic salient object detection in arbitrary visual scenes .
a total of 70 students ( 13 male , 57 female ) undergraduate usc students with normal or corrected - to - normal vision in the age range between 18 and 23 ( mean = 19.7 , std = 1.4 ) were asked to draw a polygon around the object that stood out the most .
participants annotations were supposed not to be too loose ( general ) or too tight ( specific ) around the object .
they were shown an illustrative example for this purpose .
participants were able to relocate their drawn polygon from one object to another or modify its outline .
we were concerned with the case of selection of the single most salient object in an image .
stimuli were the images from the dataset by bruce and tsotsos ( 2005 ) @xcite 681 pixels .
images in this dataset have been presented at random to 20 observers ( in a free - viewing task ) for 4 sec each , with 2 sec of delay ( a gray mask ) in between . ] .
see fig .
[ fig : sampleio - am ] for sample images from this dataset .
we first measured the degree to which annotations of participants agree with each other using the following quantitative measure : @xmath1 where @xmath2 and @xmath3 are annotations of @xmath4-th and @xmath5-th participants , respectively ( out of @xmath6 participants ) over the @xmath7-th image . above measure
has the well - defined lower - bound of 0 , when there is no overlap in segmentations of users , and the upper - bound of 1 , when segmentations have perfect overlap .
[ fig : exp1].left shows histogram of @xmath8 values .
participants had moderate agreement with each other ( mean @xmath9 ; std @xmath10 ; significantly above chance ) .
inspection of images with lowest @xmath8 values shows that these scenes had several foreground objects while images with highest annotation agreement had often one visually distinct salient object ( e.g. , a sign , a person , or an animal ; see fig . [
fig : sampleio - am ] ) .
we also investigated the relationship between explicit saliency judgments and freeviewing fixations as two indicators of visual attention .
here we used shuffled auc ( sauc ) score to tackle center - bias in eye movement data @xcite . for each of 120 images , we showed that a map built from annotations of 70 participants explains fixations of free viewing observers significantly above chance ( sauc of @xmath11 , chance @xmath12 , @xmath13-test @xmath14 ; fig .
[ fig : exp1].right ) .
the prediction power of this map was as good as the itti98 model @xcite .
hence , we concluded that explicit saliency judgments agree with fixations .
[ fig : sampleio - am ] shows high- and low - agreement cases between fixations and annotations . here
, we merge annotations of all 70 participants on each image , normalize the resultant map to [ 0 1 ] , and threshold it at 0.7 to build our first benchmark saliency detection dataset ( called bruce - a ) .
prevalent objects in bruce and tsotsos dataset are man - made home supplies in indoor scenes ( see @xcite for more details on this dataset ) .
similar results , to link fixations with salient objects , have been reported by koehler _
_ @xcite . as in @xcite
, they asked observers to click on salient locations in natural scenes .
they showed high correlation between clicked locations and observers eye movements ( from a different group of subjects ) in free - viewing . while the most salient @xcite , important @xcite , or interesting @xcite object may tell us a lot about a scene , eventually there is a subset of objects that can minimally describe a scene .
this has been addressed in the past somewhat indirectly in the contexts of saliency @xcite , language and attention @xcite , and phrasal recognition @xcite .
based on results from our saliency judgment experiment @xcite , we then decided to annotate scenes of the dataset by judd _
et al . _
the reason for choosing this dataset is because it is currently the most popular dataset for benchmarking fixation prediction models @xcite .
it contains eye movements of 15 observers freely viewing 1003 scenes from variety of topics .
thus , using fixations we can easily determine which object , out of several annotated objects , is the most salient one .
we only used 900 images from the judd dataset and discarded images without well - defined objects ( e.g. , mosaic tiles , flames ) or images with very cluttered backgrounds ( e.g. , nature scenes ) . figure [ fig : figdiscarded ] shows examples of discarded scenes .
we asked 2 observers to manually outline objects using the labelme @xcite open annotation tool ( http://new-labelme.csail.mit.edu/ ) .
observers were instructed to accurately segment as many objects as possible following three rules : 1 ) discard reflection of objects in mirrors , 2 ) segment objects that are not separable as one ( e.g. , apples in a basket ) , and 3 ) interpolate the boundary of occluded objects only if doing otherwise may create several parts for an occluded object .
these cases , however , did happen rarely .
observers were also told that their outline should be good enough for somebody to recognize the object just by seeing the drawn polygon .
observers were paid for their effort .
[ fig:1 ] shows sample images and their annotated objects . to determine which object is the most salient one , we selected the object at the peak of the human fixation map . here
we explore some summary statistics of our data . on average ,
36.93% of an image pixels was annotated by the 1st observer with a std of 29.33% ( 44.52% , std=29.36% for the 2nd observer ) .
27.33% of images had more than 50% of their pixels segmented by the 1st observer ( 34.18% for the 2nd ) . the number of annotated objects in a scene ranged from 1 to 31 with median of 3 for the 1st observer ( 1 to 24 for the 2nd observer with median of 4 ; fig .
[ fig : stat].left ) .
the median object size was 10% of the total image area for the 1st observer ( 9% for the 2nd observer ) .
[ fig : stat].left ( inset ) shows the average annotation map for each observer over all images .
it indicates that either more objects were present at the image center and/or observers tended to annotate central objects more .
overall , our data suggests that both observers agree to a good extent with each other .
finally , in order to create one ground truth segmentation map per image , we asked 5 other observers to choose the best of two annotations ( criteria based on selection of annotated objects and boundary accuracy ) .
the best annotation was the one with max number of votes ( 611 images with 4 to 1 votes ) .
next , we quantitatively analyzed the relationship between fixations and annotations ( note that we explicitly define the most salient object as the one with the highest fraction of fixations on it ) .
we first looked into the relationship between the object annotation order and the fraction of fixations on objects .
[ fig : stat].middle shows fraction of fixations as a function of object annotation order . in alignment with previous findings @xcite we observe that observers chose to annotate objects that attract more fixations . but
here , unlike @xcite which used saliency models to demonstrate that observers prioritize annotating interesting and salient objects , we used actual eye movement data .
we also quantized the fraction of fixations that fall on scene objects over the judd - a annotations , and observed that in about 55% of images , the most salient object attracts more than 50% of fixations ( mean fixation ratio of 0.54 ; image background=0.45 ; fig .
[ fig : stat].right ) .
the most salient object ranged in size from 0.1% to 90.2% of the image size ( median=10.17% ) .
the min and max aspect ratio ( w / h ) of bounding boxes fitted to the most salient object were 0.04 and 13.7 , respectively ( median=0.94 ) .
judd dataset is known to be highly center - biased @xcite , in terms of eye movements @xcite , due to two factors : 1 ) the tendency of observers to start viewing the image from the center ( a.k.a viewing strategy ) , and 2 ) tendency of photographers to frame interesting objects at the image center ( a.k.a photographer bias ) . here
we verify the second factor by showing the average annotation map of the most salient object in fig .
[ fig : meps ] . our datasets seem to have relatively less center - bias compared to msra-5k and cssd datasets .
note that other datasets mentioned in table i are also highly center - biased . to count the number of images with salient objects at the image center , we defined the following criterion .
an image is on - centered if its most salient object overlaps with a normalized ( to [ 0 1 ] ) central gaussian filter with @xmath15 .
this gaussian filter is resized to the image size and is then truncated above 0.95 . utilizing this criterion
, we selected 667 and 223 on - centered and off - centered scenes , respectively .
partitioning data in this manner helps scrutinize performance of models and tackle the problem of center - bias . to further explore the amount of center - bias in bruce - a and judd - a datasets , we first calculated the euclidean distance from center of bounding boxes , fitted to object masks , to the image center .
we then normalized this distance to the half of the image diagonal ( i.e. , image corner to image center ) .
[ fig : arearatio].left shows the distribution of normalized object distances .
as opposed to msra-5k and cssd datasets that show an unusual peak around the image center , objects in our datasets are further apart from the image center .
[ fig : arearatio].right shows distributions of normalized object sizes .
a majority of salient objects in bruce - a and judd - a datasets occupy less than 10% of the image . on average , objects in our datasets are smaller than msra-5k and cssd making salient object detection more challenging .
we also analyzed complexity of scenes on four datasets . to this end
, we first used the popular graph - based superpixel segmentation algorithm by felzenszwalb and huttenlocher @xcite to segment an image into contiguous regions larger than 60 pixels each ( parameter settings : @xmath16 = 1 , segmentation coefficient @xmath17 = 300 ) .
the basic idea is that the more superpixels an image contains , the more complex and cluttered it is @xcite . by analogy to scenes , an object with several superpixels is less homogeneous , and hence is more complex ( e.g. , a person vs. a ball ) .
[ fig : stats ] shows distributions of number of superpixels on the most salient object , the background , and the entire scene .
if a superpixel overlapped with the salient object and background , we counted it for both .
in general , complexities of backgrounds and whole scenes in our datasets , represented by blue and red curves , are much higher than in the other two datasets .
the most salient object in judd - a dataset on average contains more superpixels than salient objects in msra-5k and cssd datasets , even with smaller objects .
the reason why number of superpixels is low on the bruce - a dataset is because of its very small salient objects ( see fig . [
fig : stats].right ) . further , we inspected types of objects in judd - a images .
we found that 45% of images have at least one person in them and 27.2% have more than two people . on average
each scene has 1.56 persons ( std = 3.2 ) . in about 27% of images , annotators chose a person as the most salient object .
we also found that 280 out of 900 images ( 31.1% ) had one or more text in them .
other frequent objects were animals , cars , faces , flowers , and signs .
in general , it is agreed that for good saliency detection , a model should meet the following three criteria : 1 ) _ high detection rate_. there should be a low probability of failing to detect real salient regions , and low probability of falsely detecting background regions as salient regions , 2 ) _ high resolution_. saliency maps should have high or full resolution to accurately locate salient objects and retain original image information as much as possible , and 3 ) _ high computational efficiency_. saliency models with low processing time are preferred . here , we analyze these factors by proposing a simple baseline salient object detection model . we propose a straightforward model to serve two purposes : 1 ) _ to assess the degree to which our data can be explained by a simple model_. this way our model can be used for measuring bias and complexity of a saliency dataset , and 2 ) _ to gauge progress and performance of the state of the art models_. by comparing performance of best models relative to this baseline model over existing datasets and our datasets , we can judge how powerful and scalable these models are . note that we deliberately keep the model simple to achieve above goals .
our model involves the following two steps : + _ * step 1 * _ : given an input image , we compute a saliency map and an over - segmented region map .
for the former , we use a fixation prediction model ( traditional saliency models ) to find spatial outliers in scenes that attract human eye movements and visual attention . here , we use two models for this purpose : aws @xcite and hounips @xcite , which have been shown to perform very well in recent benchmarks and to be computationally efficient @xcite . as controls , we also use the generic _ objectness _ measure by alexe _
et al . _
@xcite , as well as the human fixation map to determine the upper - bound performance .
the reason for using fixation saliency models is to obtain an quick initial estimation of locations where people may look in the hope of finding the most salient object .
these regions are then fed to the segmentation component in the next step .
it is critical to first limit the subsequent expensive processes onto the right region .
for the latter , as in the previous section , we use the fast and robust algorithm by felzenszwalb and huttenlocher @xcite with same parameters as in section [ statistics ] .
_ * step 2 * _ : the saliency map is first normalized to [ 0 1 ] and is then thresholded at @xmath18 ( here @xmath18 = 0.7 )
. then all unique image superpixels that spatially overlap with the truncated saliency map are included .
here we discarded those superpixels that touch the image boundary because they are highly likely to be part of the background .
finally , after this process , the holes inside the selected region will be considered as part of the salient object ( e.g. , filling in operation ) .
[ fig : samples ] illustrates the process of segmentation and shows outputs of our model for some images from msra-5k , bruce - a , and judd - a datasets .
the essential feature of our simple model is dissociating saliency detection from segmentation , such that now it is possible to pinpoint what might be the cause of mistakes or low performance of a model , i.e. , or .
this is particularly important since almost all models have confused these two steps and have faded the boundary .
note that currently there is no training stage in our model and it is manually constructed with fixed parameters .
the second stage in our model is where more modeling contribution can be made , for example by devising more elaborate ways to include or discard superpixels in the final segmentation .
one strategy is to learn model parameters from data .
some features to include in a learning method are size and position of a superpixel , a measure of elongatedness , a measure of concavity or convexity , distance between feature distributions of a superpixel and its neighbors , etc . to some extent ,
some of these these features have already been utilized in previous models @xcite .
another direction will be expanding our model to multi scale ( similar to @xcite ) .
we exhaustively compared our model to 8 state of the art methods which have been shown to perform very well on previous benchmarks @xcite .
these models come from 3 categories allowing us to perform cross - category comparison : 1 ) _ salient object detection models _ including cbsal @xcite , svo @xcite , pca @xcite , goferman @xcite , and fts @xcite , 2 ) _ generic objectness measure _ by alexe _
et al . _
@xcite , and 3 ) _ fixation prediction models _ including aws @xcite and hounips @xcite .
we use two widely adopted metrics : * * precision - recall ( pr ) curve : * for a saliency map @xmath19 normalized to @xmath20 $ ] , we convert it to a binary mask @xmath21 with a threshold @xmath22 . @xmath23 and @xmath24 are then computed as follows given the ground truth mask @xmath25 : @xmath26 [ eqn : precision_recall ] to measure the quality of saliency maps produced by several algorithms , we vary the threshold @xmath22 from 0 to 255 . on each threshold , @xmath23 and @xmath24 values
are computed .
finally , we can get a precision - recall ( pr ) curve to describe the performance of different algorithms .
+ we also report the f - measure defined as : @xmath27 + here , as in @xcite and @xcite , we set @xmath28 to weigh precision more than recall . * * receiver operating characteristics ( roc ) curve : * we also report the false positive rate ( @xmath29 ) and true positive rate ( @xmath30 ) during the thresholding a saliency map : @xmath31 where @xmath32 and @xmath33 denote the opposite ( complement ) of the binary mask @xmath21 and ground - truth , respectively .
the roc curve is the plot of @xmath30 versus @xmath29 by varying the threshold @xmath22 .
results are shown in fig .
[ fig : bruce ] .
consistent with previous reports over the msra-5k dataset @xcite , cbsal , pca , svo , and alexe models rank on the top ( with f - measures above 0.55 and aucs above 0.90 ) .
fixation prediction models perform lower at the level of the map .
fts model ranked on the bottom again in alignment with previous results .
our models work on par with the best models on this dataset with all f - measures above 0.70 ( max with alexe model about 0.73 ) . moving from this simple dataset ( because our simple models ranked on the top ; see also the analysis in section [ statistics ] ) to more complex datasets ( middle column in fig .
[ fig : bruce ] ) we observed a dramatic drop in performance of all models .
the best performance now is 0.24 belonging to the pca model .
we observed about 72% drop in performance averaged over 5 models ( cbsal , fts , svo , pca , and alexe ) from msra-5k to bruce - a dataset .
note in particular how map model is severely degraded here ( poorest with f measure of 0.1 ) since objects are now less at the center .
our best model on this dataset is the salbase - human ( f - measure about 0.31 ) .
surprisingly , auc results are still high on this dataset since objects are small thus true positive rate is high at all levels of false positive rate ( see also performance of map ) . patterns of results over judd - a dataset are similar to those over bruce - a with all of our models performing higher than others .
the lowest performance here belongs to fts followed by the two fixation prediction models .
our salbase - human model scores the best with the f - measure about 0.55 . among our models that used a model to pick the most salient location , salbase - aws scores higher over bruce -
a and judd - a datasets possibly because aws is better able to find the most salient location .
the average drop from msra-5k to judd - a dataset is @xmath0 41% ( for 5 saliency detection models ) .
[ fig : f - measure2 ] shows that these findings are robust to f - measure parameterization .
tables [ tab : db - fmeasure ] and [ tab : db - auc ] summarize the f - measure and auc of models .
.f - measure accuracy of models .
performance of the best model is highlighted in boldface font . [ cols="^,^,^,^ " , ] to study the dependency of results on saliency map thresholding ( i.e. , how many superpixels to include ) , we varied the saliency threshold @xmath18 and calculated f - measure for salbase - human and salbase - aws models ( see fig .
[ fig : salthreshold ] ) .
we observed that even higher scores are achievable using different parameters .
for example , since objects in the judd - a dataset are larger , a lower threshold yields a better accuracy .
the opposite holds over the bruce - a dataset . to investigate the dependency of results on segmentation parameters
, we varied the parameters of the segmentation algorithm from too fine ( @xmath16 = 1 , k = 100 , min = 20 ; many segments ; over - segmenting ) to too coarse ( @xmath16 = 1 , k = 1000 , min = 800 ; fewer segments ; under - segmenting ) .
both of these settings yielded lower performances than results in fig . [
fig : bruce ] . results with another parameter setting with @xmath16 = 1 , k = 500 , and min = 50 are shown in fig .
[ fig : res_500_50 ] . scores and trends are similar to those shown in fig .
[ fig : bruce ] , with salbase - human and salbase - aws being the top contenders . .
stars correspond to points shown in fig .
[ fig : bruce ] . note that even higher accuracies are possible with different thresholds over our datasets .
corresponding f - measure values over msra-5k for salbase - aws model are : 0.62 , 0.67 , 0.70 , 0.73 , and 0.62.,width=321,height=143 ] analysis of cases where our model fails , shown in fig .
[ fig : failure2 ] , reveals four reasons : _ first _ , on bruce - a dataset when humans look at an object more but annotators chose a different object .
_ second _ , when a segment that touches the image border is part of the salient object .
_ third _ , when the object segment falls outside the thresholded saliency map ( or a wrong one is included ) .
_ fourth _ , when the first stage ( i.e. , fixation prediction model ) pick the wrong object as the most salient one ( see fig .
[ fig : rrr ] , first column ) . regarding the first problem ,
care must be taken in assuming what people look is what they choose as the most salient object .
although this assumption is correct in a majority of cases ( fig .
[ fig : exp1 ] ) , it does not hold in some cases .
with respect to the second and third problems , future modeling effort is needed to decide which superpixels to include / discard to determine the extent of an object .
the fourth problem points toward shortcomings of fixation prediction models .
indeed , in several scenes where our model failed , people and text were the most salient objects .
person and text detectors were not utilized in the saliency models employed here .
[ fig : rrr ] shows a visual comparison of models over 12 scenes from the judd - a dataset .
cbsal and svo generate more visually pleasant maps .
goferman highlights object boundaries more than object interiors .
pca generates center - biased maps . some models ( e.g. , goferman , fts ) generate sparse saliency maps while some others generate smoother ones ( e.g. , svo , cbsal ) .
aws and hounips models generate pointy maps to better account for fixation locations .
in this work , we showed that : 1 ) explicit human saliency judgments agree with free - viewing fixations ( thus extending our previous results in @xcite ) , 2 ) our new benchmark datasets challenge existing state - of - the - art salient object detection models ( in alignment with li _ et al .
_ s dataset @xcite ) , and 3 ) a conceptually simple and computationally efficient model ( @xmath00.2 s for @xmath34 saliency and segmentation maps on a pc with a 3.2 ghz intel i7 cpu and 6 gb ram using matlab ) wins over the state of the art models and can be used as a baseline in the future .
we also highlighted a limitation of models which is the main reason behind their failure on complex scenes .
they often segment the wrong object as the most salient one .
previous modeling effort has been mainly concentrated on biased datasets with images containing objects at the center . here , we focused on this shortcoming and described how unbiased salient object detection datasets can be constructed .
we also reviewed datasets that can be used for saliency model evaluation ( in addition to datasets in table [ tab : db ] ) and measured their statistics .
no dataset exists so far that has all of object annotations , eye movements , and explicit saliency judgments .
bruce - a has fixations , and only explicit saliency judgments but not all object labels .
judd - a , osie , and pascal - s datasets have annotations and fixations but not explicit saliency judgments . here , we chose the object that falls at the peak of the fixation map as the most salient one .
ucsb dataset lacks object annotations but it has fixations and saliency judgments using clicks ( as opposed to object boundaries in bruce - a ) . future research by collecting all information on a large scale dataset will benefit salient object detection research .
here we suggested that the most salient object in a scene is the one that attracts the majority of fixations ( similar to @xcite ) .
one can argue that the most salient object is the one that observers look at first . while in general , these two definitions may choose different objects , given the short presentation times in our datasets ( 3 sec on judd , 4 sec on bruce ) we suspect that both suggestions will yield to similar results .
our model separates detection from segmentation .
a benefit of this way of modeling is that it can be utilized for other purposes ( e.g. , segmenting interesting or important objects ) by replacing the first component of our model .
further , augmented with a top - down fixation selection strategy , our model can be used as an active observer ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
our analysis suggests two main reasons for model performance drop over the judd - a dataset : the _ first reason _ that the literature has focused so far is to avoid incorrectly segmenting the object region ( i.e. , increasing true positives and reducing false positives ) .
therefore , low performance is partially due to inaccurately highlighting ( segmenting ) the salient object .
the _ second reason _ that we attempted to highlight in this paper ( we believe is the main problem causing performance drop as models performed poorly on judd - a compared to msra-5k ) is segmenting the wrong object ( i.e. , not the most salient object ) .
note that although here we did not consider the latest proposed salient object detection models in our model comparison ( e.g. , @xcite ) , we believe that our results are likely to generalize compared to newer models .
the rationale is that even recent models have also used the asd dataset @xcite ( which is highly center - biased ) for model development and testing .
nontheless , we encourage future works to use our model ( as well as li et al.s model ) as a baseline for model benchmarking . two types of cues can be utilized for segmenting an object : appearance @xcite ( i.e. , grouping contiguous areas based on surface similarities ) and boundary @xcite ( i.e. , cut regions based on observed pixel boundaries ) .
here we mainly focused on the appearance features .
taking advantage of both region appearance and contour information ( similar to @xcite ) for saliency detection ( e.g. , growing the foreground salient region until reaching the object boundary ) is an interesting future direction . in this regard
, it will be helpful to design suitable measures for evaluating accuracy of models for detecting boundary ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
our datasets allow more elaborate analysis of the interplay between saliency detection , fixation prediction , and object proposal generation . obviously , these models depend on the other . on one hand ,
it is critical to correctly predict where people look to know which object is the most salient one . on the other hand , labeled objects in scenes can help us study how objects guide attention and eye movements .
for example , by verifying the hypotheses that some parts of objects ( e.g. , object center @xcite ) or semantically similar objects @xcite ) attract fixations more , better fixation prediction models become feasible .
l. itti , c. koch , and e. niebur . a model of saliency - based visual attention for rapid scene analysis .
_ ieee trans . pami _ , 1998 .
n. d. b. bruce and j. k. tsotsos .
saliency based on information maximization .
_ nips _ , 2005 .
x. hou and l. zhang .
dynamic attention : searching for coding length increments .
_ nips _ , 2008 .
a. garcia - diaz , x. r. fdez - vidal , x. m. pardo , and r. dosil .
decorrelation and distinctiveness provide with human - like saliency .
_ acivs _ , 2009 .
h. jiang , j. wang , z. yuan , y. wu , n. zheng , and s. li .
salient object detection : a discriminative regional feature integration approach .
_ ieee conference on computer vision and pattern recognition _ , 2013 .
a. c. berg , t. l. berg , h. daume , j. dodge , a. goyal , x. han , a. mensch , m. mitchell , a. sood , k. stratos et al .
, `` understanding and predicting importance in images , '' in ieee conference on computer vision and pattern recognition ( cvpr ) , 2012 , pp .
3562 - 3569 .
x. han , a. mensch , m. mitchell , a. sood , k. stratos et al .
, `` understanding and predicting importance in images , '' in ieee conference on computer vision and pattern recognition ( cvpr ) , 2012 , pp .
3562 - 3569 .
s. dhar , v. ordonez , and t. l. berg , `` high level describable attributes for predicting aesthetics and interestingness , '' in ieee conference on computer vision and pattern recognition ( cvpr ) , 2011 , pp .
1657 - 1664 .
z. wang , a. c. bovik , h. r. sheikh , and e. p. simoncelli , `` image quality assessment : from error visibility to structural similarity , '' ieee transactions on image processing , vol .
600 - 612 , 2004 .
g. kulkarni , v. premraj , s. dhar , s. li , y. choi , a. c. berg , and t. l. berg , `` baby talk : understanding and generating simple image descriptions , '' in ieee conference on computer vision and pattern recognition ( cvpr ) , 2011 , pp .
1601 - 1608 .
u. rutishauser , d. walther , c. koch , and p. perona , `` is bottom - up attention useful for object recognition ? '' in proceedings of the ieee conference on computer vision and pattern recognition , 2004 , vol . 2 , 2004 , pp .
ii-37 . c. guo and l. zhang , `` a novel multiresolution spatiotemporal saliency detection model and its applications in image and video compression , '' ieee trans . on image processing ,
1 , pp . 185 - 198 , 2010 .
ma , x .- s .
hua , l. lu , and h .- j .
zhang , `` a generic framework of user attention model and its application in video summarization , '' ieee transactions on multimedia , vol .
907 - 919 , 2005 .
a. ninassi , o. le meur , p. le callet , and d. barbba , `` does where you gaze on an image affect your perception of quality ? applying visual attention to image quality metric , '' in ieee conference on image processing ( icip ) , vol . 2 , 2007 , pp .
ii-169 .
j. li , m. levine , x. an , x. xu , and h. he , `` visual saliency based on scale - space analysis in the frequency domain , '' ieee trans . on pattern analysis and machine intelligence ,
996 - 1010 , 2013 .
s. frintrop , g. m. garca , and a. b. cremers , `` a cognitive approach for object discovery , '' icpr , 2014 .
d. meger , p .- e .
forssen , k. lai , s. helmer , s. mccann , t. southey , m. baumann , j. j. little , and d. g. lowe , `` curious george : an attentive semantic robot , '' robotics and autonomous systems , vol .
56 , no . 6 , pp .
503 - 511 , 2008 .
ali borji received his bs and ms degrees in computer engineering from petroleum university of technology , tehran , iran , 2001 and shiraz university , shiraz , iran , 2004 , respectively .
he did his ph.d .
in cognitive neurosciences at institute for studies in fundamental sciences ( ipm ) in tehran , iran , 2009 and spent four years as a postdoctoral scholar at ilab , university of southern california from 2010 to 2014 .
he is currently an assistant professor at university of wisconsin , milwaukee .
his research interests include visual attention , active learning , object and scene recognition , and cognitive and computational neurosciences . | salient object detection or salient region detection models , diverging from fixation prediction models , have traditionally been dealing with locating and segmenting the most salient object or region in a scene .
while the notion of most salient object is sensible when multiple objects exist in a scene , current datasets for evaluation of saliency detection approaches often have scenes with only one single object .
we introduce three main contributions in this paper : first , we take an in - depth look at the problem of salient object detection by studying the relationship between where people look in scenes and what they choose as the most salient object when they are explicitly asked .
based on the agreement between fixations and saliency judgments , we then suggest that the most salient object is the one that attracts the highest fraction of fixations .
second , we provide two new less biased benchmark datasets containing scenes with multiple objects that challenge existing saliency models .
indeed , we observed a severe drop in performance of 8 state - of - the - art models on our datasets ( 40% to 70% ) .
third , we propose a very simple yet powerful model based on superpixels to be used as a baseline for model evaluation and comparison .
while on par with the best models on msra-5k dataset , our model wins over other models on our data highlighting a serious drawback of existing models , which is convoluting the processes of locating the most salient object and its segmentation .
we also provide a review and statistical analysis of some labeled scene datasets that can be used for evaluating salient object detection models .
we believe that our work can greatly help remedy the over - fitting of models to existing biased datasets and opens new venues for future research in this fast - evolving field .
shell : xx ieee transactions on image processing salient object detection , explicit saliency , bottom - up attention , regions of interest , eye movements |
quantum field theories have been widely accepted in the physics community , mainly because of their their well - tested predictions .
one of the famous numbers predicted by quantum electrodynamics is the electromagnetic moment of the electron which has been tested up to a previously unencountered precision .
unfortunately , quantum field theories are percepted with some suspicion by mathematicians .
this is mainly due to the appearance of divergences when naively computing probability amplitudes .
these _ infinities _ have to be dealt with properly by an apparently obscure process called renormalization .
nevertheless , mathematical interest has been changing lately in favour of quantum field theories , the general philosophy being that such a physically accurate theory should have some underlying mathematically rigorous description .
one of these interests is in the process of renormalization , and has been studied in the context of hopf algebras @xcite . of course , the process of renormalization was already quite rigorously defined by physicists in the early second half of the previous century
however , the structure of a coproduct describing how to subtract divergence really clarified the process .
one could argue though that since the elements in the hopf algebra are individual feynman graphs , it is a bit unphysical .
rather , one would like to describe the renormalization process on the level of the 1pi green s functions , since these correspond to actual physical processes .
especially for ( non - abelian ) gauge theories , the graph - by - graph approach of for instance the bphz - procedure is usually replaced by more powerful methods based on brst - symmetry and the zinn - justin equation ( and its far reaching generalization : the batalin - vilkovisky formalism ) .
they all involve the 1pi green s functions or even the full effective action that is generated by them .
the drawback of these latter methods , is that they rely heavily on functional integrals and are therefore completely formal .
one of the advantages of bphz - renormalization is that if one accepts the perturbative series of green s function in terms of feynman graphs as a starting point , the procedure is completely rigorous . of course , this allowed the procedure to be described by a mathematical structure such as a hopf algebra . in this article , we prove some of the results on green s functions starting with the hopf algebra of feynman graphs for non - abelian gauge theories .
we derive the existence of hopf subalgebras generated by the 1pi green s functions .
we do this by showing that the coproduct takes a closed form on these green s functions , thereby relying heavily on a formula that we have previously derived @xcite .
already in @xcite hopf subalgebras were given for any connected graded hopf algebra as solutions to dyson - schwinger equations .
it turned out that there was a close relation with hochschild cohomology .
it was argued by kreimer in @xcite that for the case of non - abelian gauge theories the existence of hopf subalgebras follows from the validity of the slavnov
taylor identities _ inside _ the hopf algebra of ( qcd ) feynman graphs .
we now fully prove this claim by applying a formula for the coproduct on green s functions that we have derived before in @xcite .
in fact , that formula allowed us to prove compatibility of the slavnov
taylor identities with the hopf algebra structure .
this paper is organized as follows . in section 2
, we start by giving some background from physics . of course
, this can only be a quick _ lifting of the curtain _ and is meant as a motivation for the present work . in section 3 ,
we make precise our setup by defining the hopf algebra of feynman graphs and introduce several combinatorial factors associated to such graphs .
we put the process of renormalization in the context of a birkhoff decomposition .
section 4 contains the derivation of the hopf algebra structure at the level of green s functions , rather then the individual feynman graphs .
we will encounter the crucial role that is played by the so - called slavnov taylor identities .
we start by giving some background from physics and try to explain the origin of feynman graphs in the perturbative approach to quantum field theory .
we understand _ probability amplitudes for physical processes as formal expansions in feynman amplitudes _ , thereby avoiding the use of path integrals .
we make this more explicit by some examples taken from physics .
the interaction of the photon with the electron in quantum electrodynamics ( qed ) is described by the following expansion , @xmath0 here all graphs appear that can be built from the vertex that connects a wiggly line ( the photon ) to two straight lines ( the electron ) .
the quartic gluon self - interaction in quantum chromodynamics is given by @xmath1 this expansion involves the gluon vertex of valence 3 and 4 ( wiggly lines ) , as well as the quark - gluon interaction ( involving two straight lines ) we shall call these expansions * green s functions*. of course , this names originates from the theory of partial differential equations and the zeroth order terms in the above expansions are in fact green s functions in the usual sense .
we use the notation @xmath2 and @xmath3 for the green s function , indicating the external structure of the graphs in the above two expansions , respectively . from these expansions
, physicists can actually derive numbers , giving the probability amplitudes mentioned above . the rules of this game are known as the feynman rules ; we briefly list them for the case of quantum electrodynamics .
feynman rules for non - abelian gauge theories can be found in most standard textbooks on quantum field theory ( see for instance @xcite ) .
+ assigning momentum @xmath4 to each edge of a graph , we have : @xmath5 \parbox{30pt } { \begin{fmfgraph*}(30,10 ) \fmfleft{l } \fmfright{r } \fmf{plain , label=$k$}{l , r } \end{fmfgraph * } } \hspace{3mm}&= \frac{1}{\gamma^\mu k_\mu + m}\\[7 mm ] \parbox{30pt } { \begin{fmfgraph*}(30,30 ) \fmfset{wiggly_len}{4pt } \fmfset{wiggly_slope}{70 } \fmfleft{l } \fmfright{r1,r2 } \fmf{photon}{l , v } \fmf{plain}{r1,v } \fmf{plain}{v , r2 } \fmflabel{$k_1$}{l } \fmflabel{$k_2$}{r1 } \fmflabel{$k_3$}{r2 } \end{fmfgraph * } } \hspace{3 mm } & = -i e \gamma^\mu \delta(k_1+k_2 + k_3)\\[5mm]\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath6 is the electron charge , @xmath7 the electron mass and @xmath8 are @xmath9 dirac gamma matrices ; they satisfy @xmath10 . also , @xmath11 is an infrared regulator and @xmath12 is the so - called gauge fixing parameter .
in addition to the above assignments , one integrates the above internal momenta @xmath4 ( for each internal edge ) over @xmath13 .
consider the following electron self - energy graph + ( 150,60 ) according to the feynman rules , the amplitude for this graph is @xmath14 with summation over repeated indices understood .
the alert reader may have noted that the above improper integral is actually not well - defined .
this is the typical situation happening for most graphs and are the famous divergences in perturbative quantum field theory .
this apparent failure can be resolved , leading eventually to spectacularly accurate predictions in physics .
the theory that proposes a solution to these divergences is called _ renormalization_. this process consists of two steps .
firstly , one introduces a _ regularization parameter _ that controls the divergences .
for instance , in _ dimensional regularization _
one integrates in @xmath15 dimensions instead of in @xmath16 , with @xmath17 a complex number . adopting certain rules
holds for complex dimension @xmath18 as well .
indeed , using schwinger parameters , or , equivalently , the laplace transform , one can write @xmath19 as the integral over @xmath20 of @xmath21 . ] for this integration in complex dimensions , one obtains for instance for the above integral : @xmath22 where the @xmath23 on the left - hand - side is the graph and the @xmath23 on the right - hand - side is the gamma function from complex analysis .
moreover , @xmath24 is a polynomial in the external momentum @xmath25 .
the previous divergence has been translated into a pole of the gamma function at @xmath26 and we have thus obtained a control on the divergence . the second step in the process of renormalization is _
subtraction_. we let @xmath27 be the projection onto the pole part of laurent series in @xmath17 , i.e. , @xmath28 = \sum_{n<0 } a_n z^n\ ] ] more generally , we have a projection on the divergent part in the regularizing parameter .
this is the origin of the study of rota - baxter algebras in the setting of quantum field theories @xcite .
we will however restrict ourselves to dimensional regularization , which is a well suited regularization for gauge theories .
for the above graph @xmath23 , we define the * renormalized amplitude * @xmath29 by simply subtracting the divergent part , that is , @xmath30 $ ] . clearly , the result is finite for @xmath31 . more generally , a graph @xmath23 might have subgraphs @xmath32 which lead to sub - divergences in @xmath33 . the so - called * bphz - procedure * ( after its inventors bogoliubov , parasiuk , hepp and zimmermann )
provides a way to deal with those sub - divergences in a recursive manner .
it gives for the * renormalized amplitude * : [ bphz ] @xmath34 where @xmath35 is the so - called * counterterm * defined recursively by @xmath36\end{aligned}\ ] ] the two sums here are over all subgraphs in a certain class ; we will make this more precise in the next section .
we now focus on a special class of quantum field theories quantum gauge theories which are of particular interest for real physical processes . without going into details on what classical gauge field theories are , we focus on the consequences on the quantum side of the presence of a classical gauge symmetry
. such a gauge symmetry acts ( locally ) on the classical fields by * gauge transformations * and these transformations form a group , the gauge group .
this group is typically infinite dimensional , since it consists of functions on space - time taking values in a lie group . for quantum electrodynamics
this lie group is abelian and just @xmath37 , for quantum chromodynamics the theory of gluons and quarks
it is @xmath38 .
when ( perturbatively ) quantizing the gauge theory , one is confronted with this extra infinity .
a way to handle it is by _ fixing the gauge _ , in other words , choosing an orbit under the action of the gauge group .
all this can be made quite precise in _ brst - quantization_. although in this process the gauge symmetry completely disappears , certain identities between green s functions appear .
this is a purely ` quantum property ' and therefore interesting to study .
in addition , being identities between full green s functions , it is interesting with a view towards nonperturbative quantum field theory . for quantum electrodynamics ,
the identities are simple and linear in the green s functions : @xmath39 these are known as * ward identities * since they were first derived by ward in @xcite .
the apparent mismatch between the number of external lines on the left and right - hand - side is resolved because the vertex graphs are considered at _ zero momentum transfer_. this means that the momentum on the photon line is evaluated at @xmath40 . for non - abelian gauge theories such as quantum chromodynamics ( qcd ) , the identities are quadratic in the fields and read : @xmath41 the dotted and straight line here corresponds to the ghost and quark , respectively .
after their inventors , they are called the * slavnov taylor identities * @xcite .
the importance of these identities lie in the fact that they are compatible with renormalization under the condition that gauge invariance is compatible with the regularization procedure .
in fact , it turns out that dimensional regularization satisfies this requirement , see for instance section 13.1 of @xcite . as a consequence ,
the slavnov - taylor identities hold after replacing @xmath42 by @xmath43 or @xmath35 in the above formula .
for instance , in the case of quantum electrodynamics one obtains the identity @xmath44 actually derived by ward , where @xmath45 and @xmath46 . for quantum chromodynamics on the other hand ,
one derives the formulae @xmath47 where the notation is as above : @xmath48 .
the above formula can be readily obtained from the above slavnov
taylor identities after replacing @xmath42 by @xmath35 .
they are the key to proving renormalizability of non - abelian gauge theories , let us try to sketch this argument .
first of all , the different interactions that are present in the theory can be weighted by a coupling constant .
for example , in qcd there are four different interactions : gluon - quark , gluon - ghost , cubic and quartic gluon self - interaction .
all of these come with their own coupling constants and gauge invariance ( or rather , brst - invariance ) requires them to be identical . in the process of renormalization ,
the coupling constants are actually not constant and depend on the energy scale .
this is the _ running of the coupling constant _ and is the origin of the renormalization group describing how they change . for qcd ,
the four coupling constants @xmath49 are expressed in terms of the original coupling constant @xmath50 as @xmath51 we see that the slavnov
taylor identities guarantee that _ the four coupling constants remain equal _ after renormalization . the above compatibility of renormalization with the slavnov
taylor identities is usually derived using the zinn - justin equation ( or the more general bv - formalism ) relying heavily on path integral techniques .
our goal in the next sections is to derive this result taking the formal expansion of the green s functions in feynman graphs as a starting point .
we will work in the setting of the connes - kreimer hopf algebra of renormalization .
we suppose that we have defined a ( renormalizable ) quantum field theory and specified the possible interactions between different types of particles .
we indicate the interactions by vertices and the propagation of particles by lines .
this leads us to define a set @xmath52 of vertices and edges ; for qed we have @xmath53 whereas for qcd we have , @xmath54 we stress for what follows that it is not necessary to define the set explicitly .
a * feynman graph * is a graph built from vertices in @xmath55 and edges in @xmath56 . naturally , we demand edges to be connected to vertices in a compatible way , respecting the type of vertex and edge .
as opposed to the usual definition in graph theory , feynman graphs have no external vertices , they only have external lines .
we assume those lines to carry a labeling .
an * automorphism * of a feynman graph is a graph automorphism leaving the external lines fixed and respects the types of vertices and edges .
this definition is motivated by the fact that the external lines correspond physically to particles prepared for some collision experiment the interior of the graph and those lines are thus fixed .
the order of the group of automorphisms @xmath57 of a graph @xmath23 is called its * symmetry factor * and denoted by @xmath58 .
let us give two examples : @xmath59 for disconnected graphs , the symmetry factor is given recursively as follows .
let @xmath60 be a connected graph ; we set @xmath61 with @xmath62 the number of connected components of @xmath23 that are isomorphic to @xmath60 .
we define the * residue * @xmath63 of a graph @xmath23 as the vertex or edge the graph reduces to after collapsing all its internal vertices and edges to a point . for example
, we have : @xmath64 henceforth , we will _ restrict to graphs with residue in @xmath43 _ ; these are the relevant graphs to be considered for the purpose of renormalization . for later use
, we introduce another combinatorial quantity , which is the * number of insertion places * @xmath65 for the graph @xmath66 in @xmath23 .
it is defined as the number of elements in the set of vertices and internal edges of @xmath23 of the form @xmath67 . for disconnected graphs @xmath68 , the number @xmath65 counts the number of @xmath69 of disjoint insertion places of the type @xmath70 .
we exemplify this quantity by @xmath71 here , one allows multiple insertions of edge graphs ( i.e. a graph with residue in @xmath56 ) on the same edge ; the underlying philosophy is that insertion of an edge graph creates a new edge . for the definition of the hopf algebra of feynman graphs @xcite
, we restrict to * one - particle irreducible * ( 1pi ) feynman graphs .
these are graphs that are not trees and can not be disconnected by cutting a single internal edge .
for example , all graphs in this paper are one - particle irreducible , _ except _ the following which is one - particle reducible : @xmath72 connes and kreimer then defined the following hopf algebra .
we refer to the appendix for a quick review on hopf algebras .
the hopf algebra @xmath73 of feynman graphs is the free commutative @xmath74-algebra generated by all 1pi feynman graphs , with counit @xmath75 unless @xmath76 , in which case @xmath77 , coproduct , @xmath78 where the sum is over disjoint unions of subgraphs with residue in @xmath43
. the antipode is given recursively by , @xmath79 two examples of this coproduct , taken from qed , are : @xmath80 the above hopf algebra is an example of a connected graded hopf algebra , i.e. @xmath81 , @xmath82 and @xmath83 indeed , the hopf algebra of feynman graphs is graded by the * loop number @xmath84 * of a graph @xmath23 ; then @xmath85 consists of rational multiples of the empty graph , which is the unit in @xmath73 , so that @xmath86 .
one can enhance the feynman graphs with an external structure .
this involves the external momenta on the external lines and can be formulated mathematically by distributions , see for instance @xcite .
the case of quantum electrodynamics has been worked out in detail in @xcite .
we now demonstrate how to obtain equation for the renormalized amplitude and the counterterm for a graph as a birkhoff decomposition in the group of characters of @xmath73 .
let us first recall the definition of a birkhoff decomposition .
we let @xmath87 be a loop with values in an arbitrary complex lie group @xmath88 , defined on a smooth simple curve @xmath89 .
let @xmath90 be the two complements of @xmath35 in @xmath91 , with @xmath92 .
a * birkhoff decomposition * of @xmath93 is a factorization of the form @xmath94 where @xmath95 are ( boundary values of ) two holomorphic maps on @xmath90 , respectively , with values in @xmath88 .
this decomposition gives _ a natural way to extract finite values from a divergent expression_. indeed , although @xmath96 might not holomorphically extend to @xmath97 , @xmath98 is clearly finite as @xmath31 .
we now look at the group @xmath99 of @xmath100-valued characters of a connected graded commutative hopf algebra @xmath73 , where @xmath100 is the field of convergent laurent series in @xmath17 .
represented by @xmath73 in the category of commutative algebras . in other words ,
@xmath101 and @xmath102 are the @xmath100-points of the group scheme . ] the product , inverse and unit in the group @xmath102 are defined by the respective equations : @xmath103 for @xmath104 .
we claim that a map @xmath105 is in one - to - one correspondence with loops @xmath93 on an infinitesimal circle around @xmath26 and values in @xmath106 .
indeed , the correspondence is given by @xmath107 and to give a birkhoff decomposition for @xmath93 is thus equivalent to giving a factorization @xmath108 in @xmath102 .
it turns out that for graded connected commutative hopf algebras such a factorization exists .
let @xmath73 be a graded connected commutative hopf algebra .
the birkhoff decomposition of @xmath87 ( given by an algebra map @xmath109 ) exists and is given dually by @xmath110\ ] ] and @xmath111 .
the graded connected property of @xmath73 assures that the recursive definition of @xmath112 actually makes sense . in the case of the hopf algebra of feynman graphs defined above
, the factorization takes the following form : @xmath113\\ \phi_+(\gamma)&=\phi(\gamma ) + \phi_-(\gamma ) + \sum_{\gamma \subsetneq \gamma } \phi_-(\gamma ) \phi(\gamma/\gamma)\end{aligned}\ ] ] the key point is now that the feynman rules actually define an algebra map @xmath114 by assigning to each graph @xmath23 the regularized feynman rules @xmath33 , which are laurent series in @xmath17 .
when compared with equations one concludes that the algebra maps @xmath115 and @xmath116 in the birkhoff factorization of @xmath42 are precisely the renormalized amplitude @xmath43 and the counterterm @xmath35 , respectively .
summarizing , we can write the bphz - renormalization as the birkhoff decomposition @xmath117 of the map @xmath118 dictated by the feynman rules . although the above construction gives a very nice geometrical description of the process of renormalization ,
it is a bit unphysical in that it relies on individual graphs .
rather , as mentioned before , in physics the probability amplitudes are computed from the full expansion of green s functions .
individual graphs do not correspond to physical processes and therefore a natural question to pose is how the hopf algebra structure behaves at the level of the green s functions .
we will see in the next section that they generate hopf subalgebras , i.e. the coproduct closes on green s functions . in proving this , the slavnov
taylor identities turn out to play an essential role .
for a vertex or edge @xmath119 we define the * 1pi green s function * by @xmath120 where the sign is @xmath121 if @xmath122 is a vertex and @xmath123 if it is an edge .
the restriction of the sum to graphs @xmath23 at loop order @xmath124 is denoted by @xmath125 .
the coproduct takes the following form on the 1pi green s functions : @xmath126 with the sum over @xmath66 over all disjoint unions of 1pi graphs . the sketch of the proof is as follows
first , one writes the coproduct @xmath127 as a sum of maps @xmath128 where these maps only detects subgraphs isomorphic to @xmath66 .
one then proves the above formula for @xmath128 with @xmath66 a 1pi graph using simply the orbit - stabilizer theorem for the automorphism group of graphs . finally , writing @xmath129 in terms of @xmath128 and @xmath130 one proceeds by induction to derive the above expression .
one observes that the coproduct does not seem to close on green s functions due to the appearance of the combinatorial factor @xmath65 .
let us try to elucidate this and compute these factors explicitly .
let @xmath131 be the number of vertices / internal edges of type @xmath122 appearing in @xmath23 , for @xmath119 .
moreover , let @xmath132 be the number of connected components of @xmath66 with residue @xmath122 . since insertion of a vertex graph ( i.e. with residue in @xmath55 ) on a vertex @xmath133 in @xmath23 prevents a subsequent insertion at @xmath133 of a vertex graph with the same residue , whereas insertion of an edge graph ( i.e. with residue in @xmath56 ) creates two new edges and hence two insertion places for a subsequent edge graph , we find the following expression , @xmath134 indeed , the binomial coefficients arise for each vertex @xmath133 since we are choosing @xmath135 out of @xmath136 whereas for an edge @xmath6 we choose @xmath137 out of @xmath138 _ with repetition_. we claim that this counting enhances our formula to the following @xmath139 before proving this , we explain the meaning of the inverse of green s functions in our hopf algebra .
since any green s function starts with the identity , we can surely write its inverse formally as a geometric series .
recall that the hopf algebra is graded by loop number .
hence , the inverse of a green s function at a fixed loop order is in fact well - defined ; it is given by restricting the above formal series expansion to this loop order . in the following , also rational powers of green s functions
will appear ; they will be understood in like manner .
let us simplify a little and consider a scalar field theory with just one type of vertex and edge , i.e. @xmath140 .
we consider the sum @xmath141 naturally split into a sum over vertex and edge graphs .
we have also inserted the above combinatorial expression for the number of insertion places .
next , we write @xmath142 and try factorize the sum over @xmath143 into a sum over @xmath144 ( connected ) and @xmath145 .
some care should be taken here regarding the combinatorial factors but let us ignore them for the moment .
in fact , if we fix the number of connected components @xmath146 of @xmath143 in the sum to be @xmath147 we can write @xmath148 with @xmath144 a connected graph . here , we have simply inserted 1 , @xmath149 which follows directly from the definition of @xmath150 as the number of connected components of @xmath143 isomorphic to @xmath144 .
now , by definition @xmath151 for a connected graph @xmath144 so that we obtain for the above sum @xmath152 by applying the same argument @xmath147 times .
recall also the definition of the green s function @xmath153 from eq . .
a similar argument applies to the edge graphs , leading to a contribution @xmath154 , with @xmath155 the number of connected components of @xmath156 .
when summing over @xmath147 and @xmath155 , taking also into account the combinatorial factors , we obtain : @xmath157 the extension to the general setting where the set @xmath43 contains different types of vertices and edges is straightforward .
an additional counting of the number of edges and numbers of vertices in @xmath23 gives the following relations : @xmath158 where @xmath159 is the number of lines ( of type @xmath6 ) attached to @xmath119 .
for instance @xmath160 equals 2 if @xmath6 is an electron line and 1 if @xmath6 is a photon line .
one checks the above equality by noting that the left - hand - side counts the number of internal half lines plus the external lines which are connected to the vertices that appear at the right - hand - side , taken into account their valence .
with this formula , we can write eq . as @xmath161 this is still not completely satisfactory since it involves the number of vertices in @xmath23 which prevents us from separating the summation of @xmath23 from the other terms .
we introduce the following notation for the fraction of green s functions above : @xmath162 with @xmath163 the total number of edges attached to @xmath133 . before we state our main theorem ,
let us motivate the definition of these elements in the case of qcd . in qcd , there are four vertices and the corresponding elements @xmath164 are given by , @xmath165 the combinations of the green s functions are identical to those appearing in formulas .
indeed , as we will see in a moment , setting them equal in @xmath73 is compatible with the coproduct .
although motivated by the study of the slavnov taylor identities in non - abelian gauge theories , the following result holds in complete generality . the ideal @xmath166 is a hopf ideal , i.e. @xmath167 let us write the above eq . in terms of the @xmath164 s
: @xmath168 in this expression , @xmath169 appears with a certain power , say @xmath170 , and we can replace @xmath171 by @xmath172 as long as we add the term @xmath173 .
this latter term can be factorized as @xmath174 times a certain polynomial in @xmath164 and @xmath169 and thus corresponds to an element in @xmath175 . as a result
, we can replace all @xmath169 s by @xmath164 for some fixed @xmath133 modulo addition of terms in @xmath176 .
the second step uses the following equality between vertices and edges : @xmath177 in terms of the loop number @xmath178 and residue @xmath122 of @xmath23 .
the equality follows by an easy induction on the number of internal lines of @xmath23 ( cf .
@xcite ) . finally , one can separate the sum over @xmath23 at a fixed loop order to obtain @xmath179 understood modulo terms in @xmath176 . from this one
derives that @xmath180 lies in @xmath181 as follows .
let us first find a more convenient choice of generators of @xmath175 . by induction
, one can show that @xmath182 where @xmath183 is a ( formally ) invertible series in @xmath164 and @xmath169 . in fact , it starts with a nonzero term of order zero . by multiplying out both denominators in the @xmath164 and @xmath169 , we arrive at the following set of ( equivalent ) generators of @xmath175 @xmath184 with @xmath185 .
a little computation shows that the first leg of the tensor product in the coproduct on these two terms coincide , using eq . .
as a consequence , one can combine these terms to obtain an element in @xmath186 modulo the aforementioned terms in @xmath187 needed to arrive at .
as a consequence , we can work on the * quotient hopf algebra * @xmath188 .
suppose we work in the case of a non - abelian gauge theory such as qcd , with the condition that the regularization procedure is compatible with gauge invariance such as dimensional regularization ( see also @xcite ) .
in such a case , the map @xmath118 defined by the ( regularized ) feynman rules vanishes on the ideal @xmath175 because of the slavnov taylor identities . hence , it factors through an algebra map from @xmath189 to the field @xmath100 .
since @xmath189 is still a commutative connected hopf algebra , there is a birkhoff decomposition @xmath190 as before _ with @xmath35 and @xmath43 algebra maps from @xmath189 to @xmath100_. this is the crucial point , because it implies that both @xmath35 and @xmath43 vanish automatically on @xmath175 . in other words , both the counterterms and the renormalized amplitudes satisfy the slavnov taylor identities . in particular , the @xmath191 s are the terms appearing in eq . which coincide because @xmath192 .
note also that in @xmath189 expression holds so that the coproduct closes on green s functions , i.e. they generate hopf subalgebras . as a corollary to this
, we can derive a generalization of dyson s formula originally derived for qed @xcite .
it provides a relation between the renormalized green s function written in terms of the coupling constant @xmath50 and the unrenormalized green s function written in terms of the bare coupling constant defined by @xmath193 for some @xmath194 .
the following analogue of dyson s formula for qed holds in general , @xmath195 where @xmath196 .
this follows from an application of @xmath197 to @xmath198 using eq . while counting the number of times the coupling constant @xmath50 appears when applying the feynman rules to a graph with residue @xmath122 and loop number @xmath178 .
in fact , this number is @xmath199 which is also @xmath200 as noted before .
for convenience , let us briefly recall the definition of a ( commutative ) hopf algebra .
it is the dual object to a group and , in fact , there is a one - to - one correspondence between groups and commutative hopf algebras .
let @xmath88 be a group with product , inverse and identity element .
we consider the algebra of representative functions @xmath201 .
this class of functions is such that @xmath202 .
for instance , if @xmath88 is a ( complex ) matrix group , then @xmath203 could be the algebra generated by the coordinate functions @xmath204 so that @xmath205 are just the @xmath206th entries of the matrix @xmath50 .
let us see what happens with the product , inverse and identity of the group on the level of the algebra @xmath207 .
the multiplication of the group can be seen as a map @xmath208 , given by @xmath209 . since dualization reverses arrows , this becomes a map @xmath210 called the _
coproduct _ and given for @xmath211 by @xmath212 the property of associativity on @xmath88 becomes _ coassociativity _ on @xmath73 : @xmath213 stating simplify that @xmath214 .
the inverse map @xmath221 , becomes the _ antipode _
@xmath222 , defined by @xmath223 .
the property @xmath224 , becomes on the algebra level : @xmath225 where @xmath226 denotes pointwise multiplication of functions in @xmath73 .
a hopf algebra @xmath73 is an algebra @xmath73 , together with two algebra maps @xmath227 ( coproduct ) , @xmath228 ( counit ) , and a bijective @xmath229-linear map @xmath230 ( antipode ) , such that equations are satisfied . if the hopf algebra @xmath73 is commutative , we can conversely construct a ( complex ) group from it as follows . consider the collection @xmath88 of multiplicative linear maps from @xmath73 to @xmath229 .
we will show that @xmath88 is a group .
indeed , we have the _ convolution product _ between two such maps @xmath231 defined as the dual of the coproduct : @xmath232 for @xmath233
. one can easily check that coassociativity of the coproduct ( eq . ) implies associativity of the convolution product : @xmath234 .
naturally , the counit defines the unit @xmath6 by @xmath235 .
clearly @xmath236 follows at once from eq . .
finally , the inverse is constructed from the antipode by setting @xmath237 for which the relations @xmath238 follow directly from equation . with the above explicit correspondence between groups and commutative hopf algebras
, one can translate practically all concepts in group theory to hopf algebras .
for instance , a subgroup @xmath239 corresponds to a _
hopf ideal _ @xmath240 in that @xmath241 and viceversa . the conditions for being a subgroup can then be translated to give the following three conditions defining a hopf ideal @xmath175 in a commutative hopf algebra @xmath73 @xmath242 | we describe the hopf algebraic structure of feynman graphs for non - abelian gauge theories , and prove compatibility of the so - called slavnov taylor identities with the coproduct .
when these identities are taken into account , the coproduct closes on the green s functions , which thus generate a hopf subalgebra .
graphs - leipzig |
thermal or pseudothermal light ( as the one obtained by scattering of coherent light by a diffuser ) presents a random intensity distribution known as speckle pattern @xcite .
this structure can have interesting applications , e.g. in metrology @xcite .
in particular , speckle structure of parametric down conversion ( pdc ) light has recently received a large attention due to relevance in view of applications to quantum imaging @xcite .
the aim of sub shot noise ( ssn ) quantum imaging is to obtain the image of a weak absorbing object with a level of noise below the minimum threshold that is unavoidable in the classical framework of light detection .
being interested in measuring an image , one is forced to consider a multi - mode source , which is able to display quantum correlation also in the spatial domain .
theoretically , this goal can be achieved by exploiting the quantum correlation in the photon number between symmetrical modes of spdc .
typically the far field emission is collected by a high quantum efficiency ccd camera .
it is fundamental to set the dimension of the modes coherence areas with respect to the dimension of the pixels .
in particular , the single pixel dimension must be of the same order of magnitude of the coherence area or bigger , in order to fulfill the sub - shot noise correlation condition , compatibly with the requirement of large photon number operation .
thus , the possibility of tailoring the speckle size by acting on the intensity and size of the pump beam represents an interesting tool for the applications to quantum imaging and in particular to the detection of weak objects under shot - noise limit @xcite .
a detailed theory of correlations and speckle structure in pdc has been developed in @xcite and , in another regime , in @xcitefurthermore , experimental results were presented in @xcite . nevertheless , a systematic comparison of experimental variation of speckle size and their correlations with the theoretical results of @xcite is still missing .
in this paper we present a systematic detailed experimental study of the speckle structure produced in type ii pdc with particular attention to its variation with pump beam properties .
in particular dependence on pump power and size are investigated in detail : results that will represent a test bench for the theoretical models .
the process of spdc is particularly suitable for studying the spatial quantum correlations @xcite , because it takes place with a large bandwidth in the spatial frequency domain .
any pair of transverse modes of the radiation ( usually dubbed idler and signal ) , characterized by two opposite transverse momenta @xmath0 and @xmath1 , are correlated in the photon number , i.e. they contain , in an ideal situation , the same number of photons . in the far field zone , the single transverse mode is characterized by a coherence area , namely the uncertainty on the emission angle @xmath2 ( @xmath3 , @xmath4 being the wavelength ) of the twin photons .
it derives from two effects that participate in the relaxation of the phase matching condition . on the one side the finite transverse dimension of the gain area inside the crystal ,
coinciding with the pump radius @xmath5 at low parametric gain .
on the other side the finite longitudinal dimension of the system , i.e. along the pump propagation direction , that is generally given by the crystal length @xmath6 .
the appearance of the emission is a speckled structure in which the speckles have , roughly , the dimension of the coherence area and for any speckle at position @xmath0 there exists a symmetrical one in @xmath1 with equal intensity .
this is rather evident in the ccd images of spdc shown in fig .
[ cross - corr ] . in the following
we summarize , very briefly , some elements of the theory describing this structure . omitting some unessential constants , the hamiltonian describing the three fields parametric interaction is @xmath7 the evolution of the quantum system guided by hamiltonian ( [ qh ] ) , in the case of relatively high gain regime and non - plane - wave pump , requires a numerical solution and it is discussed in detail in @xcite .
anyway , in the low gain regime an analytical solution is achievable @xcite .
therefore , it is worth to briefly mention the result in the first order of the perturbation theory ( @xmath8 ) for a gaussian pump , where the quantum state of the scattered light has the entangled form @xmath9 \left| 0\right\rangle\nonumber\\ & = & \left| \mathrm{vac } \right\rangle+\sum_{\mathbf{q}_{1},\mathbf{q}_{2 } } \sum_{\omega}f(\mathbf{q}_{1},\mathbf{q}_{2},\omega)\left| 1_{\mathbf{q}_{1},\omega}\right\rangle \left| 1_{\mathbf{q}_{2},-\omega}\right\rangle,\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath10e^{-(\mathbf{q}_{1}+\mathbf{q}_{2})^{2}\frac{w_{p}^{2}}{4}},\nonumber\\ & & \omega_{1}= \omega_{p}/2+\omega , \qquad\omega_{2}=\omega_{p}/2-\omega.\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath11 being the transverse wave vectors and @xmath12 the pump , idler and signal frequencies respectively .
the coherence area , in the limit of low parametric gain @xmath13 , can be estimated by the angular structure of the coincidence probability @xmath14 at some fixed frequency @xmath15 . as mentioned before ,
now is clear that we deal with two functions that enter in the shaping of the coherence area : the @xmath16 function and the fourier transformed gaussian pump profile . since they are multiplied , the narrower determines the dimension of the area .
the half width half maximum of the gaussian function , appearing in ( [ f ] ) , is @xmath17 .
if we expand the longitudinal wave detuning around the exact matching point @xmath18 , the linear part @xcite dominates for angles @xmath19 , not too next to collinear regime and the @xmath16 function turns out to have a hwhm of @xmath20 at degeneracy . on the other hand , around the collinear emission ,
the quadratic term prevails @xcite and the bandwidth becomes @xmath21 .
concerning our experiment , we consider small ( but not zero ) emission angles @xmath2 and large enough pump radius @xmath5 , such that we always work in the region @xmath22 .
therefore , in principle , the dimension of the coherence area is only determined by the pump waist . when moving to higher gain regime , which is of greater interest for our experiment , the number of photon pairs generated in the single mode increases exponentially as @xmath23 i.e. a large number of photons is emitted in the coherence time along the direction @xmath2 . in this case , also the pump amplitude becomes important in the determination of the speckles dimension .
as described in @xcite , this can be explained by a qualitative argumentation : inside the crystal , the cascading effect that causes the exponential growth of the number of generated photons is enhanced in the region where the pump field takes its highest value , i.e. close to the center of the beam .
thus , in high gain regime , most of the photon pairs are produced where the pump field is closed to its peak value . as a result the effective region of amplification inside
the crystal becomes narrower than the beam profile .
thus , in the far field one should consider the speckles as the fourier transform of the effective gain profile , that being narrower , produces larger speckles .
a further fundamental consideration for the practical implementation is that in high gain regime , instead of measuring the coincidences between two photons by means of two single photo - detectors , one collects a large portion of the emission by using for instance a ccd array with a certain fixed exposure time . within this time
several photons are collected by the single pixels and the result is an intensity pattern , having the spatial resolution of the pixel .
looking at the images , we can appreciate the speckled structure and a certain level of correlation of the speckles intensity between the signal and idler arms ( fig .
[ cross - corr](a ) and ( b ) ) .
we can define also the auto - correlation function of the signal intensity pattern itself , since in the single transverse mode of the signal arm there are many photons . to be precise
the speckle s dimension is better related to the spread of this function , although the two functions , the cross- and the auto- correlation , present in the very high gain regime the same behaviour with respect to the pump parameters , see @xcite . from the experimental view - point
it is convenient to study the auto - correlation because of the higher visibility that allows a more accurate estimation of its size .
our setup is depicted in fig .
[ fig2 ] . a type ii bbo non - linear crystal ( @xmath24 cm ) is pumped by the third harmonic ( wavelength of 355 nm ) of a q - switched nd : yag laser .
the pulses have a duration of 5ns with a repetition rate of 10 hz and a maximum energy , at the selected wavelength , of about 200 mj .
the pump beam crosses a spatial filter ( a lens with @xmath25=50 cm and an iris of 250 @xmath26 m of diameter ) , in order to eliminate the non - gaussian components ( see fig .
[ pump ] ) . before entering the crystal
the pump is collimated and its diameter is varied , when necessary , by changing the distance between two lenses ( a biconvex and a biconcave ) placed after the spatial filter .
after the crystal , the pump is stopped by a uv mirror , transparent to the visible ( t=87% measured at 685 nm ) , and by a low frequency - pass filter .
the down converted photons ( signal and idler ) pass through a lens of 5 cm of diameter ( @xmath27 cm ) and an interference filter centered at the degeneracy @xmath4=710 nm ( 10 nm bandwidth ) and finally measured by a ccd camera .
we used a @xmath28 ccd array , princeton pixis:400br ( pixel size of 20 @xmath26 m ) , with high quantum efficiency ( 80% ) and low noise ( @xmath29 electrons / pixel ) .
the far field is observed at the focal plane of the lens in a @xmath30 optical configuration , that ensures that we image the fourier transform of the crystal exit surface .
therefore a single transverse wavevector @xmath0 is associated to a single point @xmath31 in the detection plane . the ccd acquisition time is set to 90 ms , so that each frame corresponds to the pdc generated by a single shot of the laser .
let us define @xmath32 the intensity level , proportional to the number of photons , registered by the pixel in the position @xmath33 of a region @xmath34 .
@xmath35 is the fluctuation around the mean value that is estimated as @xmath36 , with @xmath37 the number of pixels .
we evaluate the normalized spatial auto - correlations of the intensity fluctuations by choosing a large arbitrary region @xmath34 , belonging for instance to the signal portion of the image , and measuring @xmath38 where @xmath39 is the displacement vector in the pixel space and assumes discrete values .
@xmath40 has unit value for @xmath41 .
[ auto - corr ] shows some typical section of the auto - correlation for different value of the pump intensity .
one note that , especially for small photon number , the auto - correlation is dominated by the peak at @xmath41 and drop down even for displacement of one pixel , creating symmetrically a sort of shoulder .
this is explained by the presence of noise at the scale of the pixel : first of all the shot - noise that gives a contribution of @xmath42 , then the electronic noise in the read - out and digitalization process is @xmath43 and , finally , the quantum efficiency that fluctuates with a standard deviation @xmath44 ( we evaluated it using a self - calibration procedure similar to the one described in @xcite ) . on the other side
the fluctuations at the scale of the coherence area of the light are given by @xmath45 , where @xmath46 is the number of modes ( spatial modes @xmath47 temporal modes ) , collected by one pixel .
therefore a large number of spatial modes limits the visibility of the genuine auto - correlation of the field with respect to the other sources of noise due to the detection by ccd .
anyway we can take the width of the shoulder as the most correct estimation of the coherence radius .
[ g2g5r2r5 ] reports on the left hand side , one of our main results , namely the speckle s radius @xmath48 as a function of the photon number per pixel for two different pump size @xmath49 mm and @xmath50 mm .
the increasing of the radius of the auto - correlation function versus the mean number of photons can not be explained by the theory in the low gain regime , predicting no dependence on the gain , i.e. on the pump intensity .
this is a signature of the fact that we are working in a non linear regime of pdc in which the parametric gain @xmath13 does not fulfill the condition @xmath51 , as we will discuss in the next paragraph .
it must be noticed that we are constrained in the range of intensities of the pump . for high intensities
we are limited by the damage threshold of optical components , for low intensities by the visibility of the speckle structure because we collect a lot of temporal modes in the same frame . in order to comment the behavior of the radius it is important to evaluate the effective gain region .
we adopt two approaches .
first we try to evaluate @xmath13 by the statistics of the light .
approximatively , according to fig .
[ g2g5r2r5 ] , we can consider the dimension of the pixel always smaller than the coherence area and thus the number of collected spatial modes @xmath52 @xcite .
we evaluate the number of temporal modes @xmath46 , within this approximation , by using the property of the thermal statistics corrected for the presence of experimental imperfections described above : @xmath53 the estimation is performed on a statistical ensemble of independent pixel belonging to a single shot frame , thus is definitely a spatial statistics .
after that , we can approximatively estimate the parametric gain by the relation @xmath54 where @xmath55 is the number of photons in the single space - temporal mode , @xmath56 is the quantum efficiency ( including losses ) and @xmath57 is the collection efficiency .
it takes into account that the pixel collects only a portion of the spatial mode and roughly is given by the ratio between the pixel area and the auto - correlation area @xmath58 . the result
is reported in fig .
[ g2g5r2r5 ] , on the right hand side . as expected , the gain @xmath13 is larger than @xmath59 , confirming that we are working in high gain regime .
let also notice that , although each point is an average over tens of images they are distributed rather noisy , as well as the radius ( on the left insert ) .
in order to explain the main features of the data it is fundamental to take into account the characteristics of the pump . it is the third harmonic of a multimode high power laser and the power is varied by the delay between the q - switch turn - on and the lamp flash .
the calibration curve delay - power ( mean pulse power ) has been measured by a power meter , and we observed a reproducibility with uncertainty around 10% .
the fluctuation of the mean pulse power is about 20% ( measured by a photodiode ) .
since the mean number of photons is proportional to @xmath60 , the fluctuations of the pump power generate large fluctuations in the photons number from frame - to - frame .
furthermore , a multimode laser when the number of modes @xmath37 is larger than few units should present a thermal statistics of the intensity fluctuation according to the formula @xmath61 @xcite and , after the non linear process of second and third harmonic generation the fluctuations can increase even more . the expected temporal profile of the output pulse is very far from a smooth gaussian function .
therefore , taken into account the strong non - linearity of the pdc generation , it is reasonable to consider that , inside the single pulse entering the crystal , only few peaks of intensity contribute to the large majority of the pdc emission .
the main consequence is that the number of _ effective _ temporal modes @xmath46 , collected in the single shot , is much less than what expected by evaluating the ratio between the pulse duration ( 5 ns ) and the pdc coherence time @xmath62 ps and @xmath46 also fluctuates randomly from image to image . by using eq .
[ thermal ] , we obtain a mean number of effective temporal modes @xmath63 when @xmath49 mm and @xmath64 for @xmath50 mm . at the same time , the values of the parametric gain @xmath13 are in general bigger than 1 ( see fig [ g2g5r2r5 ] ) .
the gain region in which we are working ensures the possibility to reach a sufficient non - linear cascading effect in the photon pairs production inside the crystal . as a confirmation of the high non - linearity obtained in our experiment
we estimate the gain @xmath13 in an independent way @xcite . in fig .
[ gainvsn](a ) we present the measurement of the number of photon in the spatial mode defined as @xmath65 by varying the mean pump amplitude @xmath66 , while the pump size is fixed to @xmath49 mm . here
the mean pump amplitude is the square root of the average power of the single pulse divide by the transverse pump area measured by a ccd .
the data are fitted by the equation @xmath67 , where @xmath68 is fixed to @xmath69 , while @xmath70 ( @xmath71 ) is the free parameter .
the experimental values , mediated on three different acquisitions , are @xmath72^{1/2}$ ] .
[ gainvsn](b ) shows the comparison between the values of the gain obtained in this way ( green squares ) and in the previous statistical approach ( the red dots ) .
the data are very close , and we can conclude that we are actually in a strong non linear regime . now , let us consider the trend of the coherence radius versus the parametric gain for the two different pump size as reported in fig .
the data are well fitted by two straight lines ( not showed in figure ) , @xmath73 with @xmath74 .
we obtain that @xmath75 and @xmath76 agree within the their uncertainty .
although a comparison with a theoretical model in high gain regime is needed for a proper interpretation of our data , we can consider this behavior as an evidence of the influence of the gain and of the pump diameter on the dimension of the speckles .
in fact , for the same value of the gain , the speckles radius is always larger when the pump size is smaller as predicted in the low gain .
finally , we investigate the dependence of the radius of the speckles from the pump diameter , as shown in figure [ pdiam_r ] .
we fix the power of the laser to 0,78 mw , within the fluctuations , and we change the diameter varying the distance between the two collimating lenses ( see figure [ fig2 ] ) . since the diameter changes , the intensity and the gain @xmath13 change as well
the theory , in low gain regime , provides that the radius of the speckles is proportional to the inverse of the pump size ( @xmath5 ) obtaining the red line in figure .
it approach the experimental data only when the pump diameter is large .
this confirms the role of the high gain regime in the speckle size .
in fact , together with the reduction of the pump diameter , the gain increases , and thus the effective gain area is even more reduced .
this effect impresses upon the speckles size a stronger dependence with respect to the pump size .
this paper provides a detailed experimental study of the size of the coherence area in pdc in the high gain regime .
we show that the speckles present , not only a dependence on the pump diameter , as in the usual low gain regime , but also a strong dependence form the pump intensity .
the understanding of the behavior of the coherence area in the high gain regime is fundamental for the innovative application in the field of quantum imaging .
our results provide the basis for a comparison with the theoretical models ; in general , the observed dependencies of speckles size on pump parameters allow the tailoring of speckles properties , an instrument useful not only for applications to quantum imaging but also for quantum metrology , quantum information , etc .
this work has been supported by miur ( prin 2005023443 - 002 ) , by 07 - 02 - 91581-asp , by regione piemonte ( e14 ) and by fondazione compagnia di san paolo .
thanks are due to alessandra gatti , enrico brambilla , lucia caspani , luigi lugiato and ottavia jedrkiewicz for useful discussions .
uno , k. ; uozumi , j. ; asakura , t. , _ opt .
comm . _ * 1996 * , _ 124 _ , 16 - 22 ; uozumi , j. ; ibrahim , m. ; asakura , t. _ opt . comm . _ * 1998 * , _ 156 _ , 350 - 358 ; funamizu , h. ; uozumi , j. _ journ .
opt . _ * 2007 * , _
54_(10 ) , 1511 - 1528 .
jedrkiewicz , o. ; jang , y. -k . ; brambilla , e. ; gatti , a. ; bache , m. ; lugiato , l. a. ; di trapani , p. _ phys . rev .
* 2004 * , _ 93 _ , 243601 - 1 - 4 ; jedrkiewicz , o. ; brambilla , e. ; bache , m. ; gatti , a. ; lugiato , l. a. ; di trapani , p. _ journal of modern optics _ * 2006 * , _ 53 _ , 575 - 595 ; brida g. ; genovese m. ; meda a. ; ruo - berchera , i. arxiv:0810.1470v1 [ quant - ph ] .
klyshko , d.n .
`` photons and nonlinear optics '' , gordon and breach science publishers , 1988 ; pittman , t.b . ;
strekalov , d. v. ; klyshko , d. n. ; rubin , m. h. ; sergienko , a. v. ; shih , y. h. _ phys .
* 1996 * , _ 53 _ , 2804 - 2815 ; monken , c.h .
; souto ribeiro , p. h. ; padua , s. _ phys .
a _ * 1998 * , _ 57 _ , 3123 - 3126 ; fedorov , m.v . ;
efremov , m. a. ; volkov , p. a. ; moreva , e. v. ; straupe , s. s. ; kulik , s. p. _ phys .
lett . _ * 2007 * , _ 99 _ , 063901 - 1 - 4 . | speckle structure of parametric down conversion light has recently received a large attention due to relevance in view of applications to quantum imaging the possibility of tailoring the speckle size by acting on the pump properties is an interesting tool for the applications to quantum imaging and in particular to the detection of weak object under shot - noise limit . here we present a systematic detailed experimental study of the speckle structure produced in type ii pdc with particular attention to its variation with pump beam properties .
parametric down conversion , entanglement , speckles , quantum imaging , quantum correlations |
the mass , @xmath0 , of an isolated main - sequence star can be determined from its absolute luminosity , @xmath1 , and the mass luminosity relation , @xmath2 } , \tau,\mbox{\boldmath$s$})$ ] .
the corresponding mass(absolute - magnitude ) relation is @xmath3 , where @xmath4 represents some photometric pass band , and the other parameters have been dropped for conciseness . for galactic disc stars with @xmath5 ,
the stellar age is usually @xmath6 gyr , [ fe / h]@xmath7 and the dependence on the stellar spin , @xmath8 , is not significant .
the continuous distribution of stars by luminosity is related to the distribution by mass through @xmath9 , where @xmath10 and @xmath11 are the lf and mf , respectively .
the differential volume number density of stars in the absolute - magnitude interval @xmath12 to @xmath13 is @xmath14 , which is also the differential number density of stars , @xmath15 , in the mass range @xmath0 to @xmath16 .
the conversion of an observed lf to the mf is demonstrated in fig . 1 using two well - cited examples from the literature .
the mf is a good approximation to the initial mass function ( imf ) for stars with @xmath17 , because they do not evolve appreciably within the age of the galactic disc .
the mass-@xmath18 data compiled by henry & mccarthy ( 1993 , hereinafter hm93 ) suggest that the @xmath19 relations adopted by miller & scalo ( 1979 , hereinafter ms ) and scalo ( 1986 , hereinafter sc ) assign masses that may be somewhat too small for stars with @xmath20 .
as shown in section 4 , theoretical work on the structure of low - mass stars confirms that there is additional structure in the @xmath19 relation near this magnitude .
this is an important point ( dantona & mazzitelli 1983 , hereinafter dam83 ) because @xmath21 , and thus any mis - understood structure in the @xmath19 relation carries through to unphysical structure in the mf .
the slope , @xmath22 , becomes small at the faintest magnitudes and is not very well determined .
this holds true in other photometric passbands as well ( hm93 ) and leads to large uncertainties in the mf near the hydrogen burning mass limit . in fig .
1 the imf , @xmath11 , is plotted as the volume number density per unit mass interval .
this is obtained from the imf , @xmath23)$ ] , expressed as the surface number density per unit logarithmic mass interval .
it is is given by eqn .
30 in ms for a constant star formation rate and a galactic disc age @xmath24 gyr ( their table 7 ) , and by sc in his table vii for @xmath24 gyr .
the conversion is @xmath25)/(2\,h\,m\,{\rm ln}(10))$ ] , where @xmath26 is the galactic disc thickness .
the miller & scalo imf , @xmath27 , continues to increase down to @xmath28 .
the scalo imf , @xmath29 , on the other hand , has a significant maximum at @xmath30 .
the reason for the difference is the adopted lf , measurement of which has been improved significantly between 1979 and 1986 through star - count surveys in the solar neighbourhood ( wielen , jahreiss & krger 1983 ) and on deep photographic plates ( reid & gilmore 1982 , hereinafter rg ) . both @xmath27 and @xmath29 have a dip near @xmath31 .
this results because star - count data have to be corrected for the loss of the more massive stars through stellar evolution , and because @xmath32 is smaller for the more massive stars .
the dip can be minimised by choosing an appropriate age for the galactic disc ( @xmath33 gyr ) and star - formation history . for stars brighter than @xmath34 ,
the galactic disc thickness decreases from @xmath35 pc to @xmath36 pc ( e.g. fig .
10 in sc ) leading to an enhancement of the volume density of brighter stars near the galactic plane .
an additional reason for the dip in @xmath29 is that the lf adopted by sc shows such a feature at @xmath37 .
this is recognised to be real ( upgren & armandroff 1981 ) and a result of stellar physics ( dam83 ; kroupa , tout & gilmore 1990 , hereinafter ktg90 ) .
the intricate details of the transformation of an observed single - star lf to the imf , taking account of the varying @xmath32 , the birth - rate history of stars and stellar evolution , can be found in sc and haywood , robin & crz ( 1997 ) . concerning low - mass stars , we know today that ( i ) the smooth @xmath19 relation used by ms and sc is not consistent with stellar models , and that ( ii ) the lfs adopted by ms and sc do not correctly represent the distribution of single stars with luminosity .
consequently , the mfs plotted in fig . 1
do not correctly describe the spectrum of stellar masses . since 1986 ,
constraints on the lf have been improved ( section 2 ) , the understanding of malmquist bias has advanced considerably ( section 3 ) , the observational and theoretical constraints on the mass luminosity relation have been improved ( section 4 ) , and the characteristics of the binary star population in the galactic field is much better quantified ( section 5 ) .
discussions of the mf in the substellar regime can be found in laughlin & bodenheimer ( 1993 ) , basri & marcy ( 1997 ) , chabrier ( these proceedings ) , and jones ( these proceedings ) .
a review of the faint end of the lf can also be found in bessell & stringfellow ( 1993 ) .
trigonometric parallaxes are used to infer the lf for the stars in the immediate neighbourhood of the sun , where most multiple - star systems have been identified .
completeness extends , for northern declinations , to 20 pc for stars with @xmath38 , but severe incompleteness sets in beyond 5 pc for stars with @xmath39 ( jahreiss 1994 , henry et al .
estimates of the nearby lf , @xmath40 , using somewhat different sampling volumes , are provided by wielen et al .
( 1983 ) , dahn , liebert & harrington ( 1986 , hereinafter dlh ) and ktg93 in the v - band , and by hm90 in the k - band .
three additional stars have been found recently within 5.3 pc : gl 866c with @xmath41 ( henry , private communication ; see also simons , henry & kirkpatrick 1996 and kroupa 1995a ) , lp 94420 with @xmath42 ( kirkpatrick , henry & irwin 1997 ) , and lhs 1565 with @xmath43 ( henry et al .
however , @xmath40 remains poorly constrained for @xmath39 , and the contribution by faint main - sequence stars to the mass of the galactic disc remains unclear .
other techniques have been developed with the aim of improving the constraints on the lf at the faint end .
rg made deep photographic exposures with a schmidt telescope ( see also hawkins , these proceedings ) to probe the distribution of faint main sequence stars to distances of about 100 pc .
they used an automatic plate measuring machine to identify galactic - disc red - dwarf stars from the hundred thousand images recorded on a typical schmidt - telescope plate in the direction of the south galactic pole .
at least two photometric pass bands are necessary to define the colours of the objects , and multiple exposures on different plates are used to confirm images .
the sample of possible red dwarf stars is contaminated by red giants for typically @xmath44 , and galaxies dominate the number counts at the faintest magnitudes ( @xmath45 ) .
distances to the stars in the final red - dwarf sample are estimated using photometric parallax .
the stellar number densities are estimated taking into account the distance to which a star can be detected . after the pioneering work by rg , other deep surveys with the method of photometric parallax explored the distribution of faint stars in different directions , gilmore , reid & hewett ( 1985 ) , hawkins & bessell ( 1988 ) , leggett & hawkins ( 1988 ) , stobie , ishida & peacock ( 1989 , hereinafter sip ) and kirkpatrick et al .
these yield _ photometric _ lfs , @xmath46 , that are consistent with each other and , after correction for galactic disc structure , are independent of the direction of the line - of - sight through the galactic disc .
a consistent finding among these surveys , each yielding about 3060 stars with @xmath39 , is that @xmath46 has a maximum at @xmath47 with a decline at fainter magnitudes . that it also does not show significant variation with direction has been verified by the extensive photographic survey of tinney , reid & mould ( 1993 ) .
the resulting lf is based on about 3500 stars spread over an area of 270 square degrees . surveys with the hubble space telescope ( hst ) avoid contamination by galaxies down to @xmath48 , and can thus probe the stellar distribution to distances of a few kpc .
santiago , gilmore & elson ( 1996 ) report @xmath49 based on about 20 fields and verify that @xmath46 decreases for @xmath39 .
they discuss the uncertainties in @xmath49 owing to photometric calibration .
finally , jarrett , dickman & herbst ( 1994 ) constrain the faint star lf by counting 14 red stars with @xmath39 that appear projected against dark molecular clouds .
significant conclusions from a comparison with @xmath40 or @xmath46 are not possible but the sample is also interesting because it may contain young m dwarfs that have migrated from the molecular cloud .
in a colour magnitude diagram there is scatter about the average relation , because the luminosity of a main - sequence star is a function of mass , metallicity , age and spin ( section 1 ) .
consequently , the distance estimated from the colour and apparent magnitude of a star is subject to error . in a magnitude
limited survey , such as is used to construct @xmath46 , this leads to overestimation of the stellar number densities because the number of stars increases with distance .
more intrinsically brighter stars are counted in the photometrically defined sampling volume than intrinsically fainter stars are lost from it .
this bias also leads to the resulting stellar sample appearing brighter than is typical for stars of the given colour .
sip applied for the first time the complete malmquist corrections to the raw photometric lf .
the malmquist correction , @xmath50 , where @xmath51 is the scatter about the mean absolute magnitude @xmath13 in the colour magnitude diagram , and is assumed to be constant and gaussian .
the cosmic scatter , @xmath51 , depends on the photometric bands used for photometric parallax .
using @xmath52 , rather than the shallower @xmath53 relation , leads to significantly larger malmquist bias ( reid 1991 ; fig . 2 in kroupa 1995a ) .
the detailed study of cosmic scatter in section 3 of ktg93 shows that @xmath54 is non - gaussian and a function of @xmath55 , because the effects of metallicity , unresolved binaries and age lead to different , colour dependent changes in @xmath18 .
recent progress in the modelling of realistic stellar atmospheres ( fig . 1 in baraffe et al .
1995 ) qualitatively supports the metallicity model of ktg93 ( their figs . 5 and 6 ) .
malmquist corrections are thus even more involved than the treatment by sip .
the @xmath19 relation steepens near @xmath56 and flattens again near @xmath57 , because the formation of h@xmath58 in the outer shells of main - sequence stars causes core contraction .
this leads to brighter luminosities and full convection for @xmath59 ( chabrier & baraffe 1997 ; kroupa & tout 1997 , hereinafter kt ) , and to a pronounced local minimum in @xmath22 at @xmath60 .
artificial suppression of h@xmath58 formation leads to full convection at @xmath61 and to fainter stars ( ktg90 , kt ) . in this case
@xmath22 has no significant extrema for @xmath62 .
this is illustrated in fig .
the discussion in section 1 implies that a minimum in @xmath22 should correspond to a maximum in the lf , unless the mf has a minimum that cancels out the structure in @xmath22 .
all photometric lfs show a maximum near @xmath63 ( section 2 ) .
the well constrained average photometric lf , @xmath64 ( section 6 ) , shows this maximum to be in beautiful agreement with the theoretical @xmath65 relation , opening the possibility of testing stellar structure theory near the critical @xmath66 where stars become fully convective .
for example , the modern stellar models of kt , that rely on the eddington approximation for the surface boundary condition , place the minimum in @xmath22 at too bright an @xmath18 ( long - dashed curve in fig . 2 ) .
treatment of a realistic stellar atmosphere together with the most recent stellar structure physics by baraffe et al .
( 1995 ) , leads to improved agreement of the extremum in @xmath22 with @xmath64 ( kt ) .
agreement , however , does not necessarily imply correct physics , as the out - dated models of ktg90 ( short - dashed curve in fig . 2 ) demonstrates .
theoreticians must , in addition , seek agreement with luminosity(effective - temperature ) , colour magnitude and mass(absolute - magnitude ) relations ( kt ) .
duquennoy & mayor ( 1991 , hereinafter dm91 ) constrain the period distribution and the binary proportion for g - type field stars .
the former can be approximated by a gaussian distribution in log@xmath67 with mean near 34 au , where @xmath68 is the semi - major axis .
the proportion of binary systems among g - dwarfs is @xmath69 .
virtually the same conclusions hold true for k- ( mayor et al .
1992 ) and m - dwarfs ( fischer & marcy 1992 ) ( see also halbwachs , these proceedings , and the summary in kroupa 1995c ) .
fisher & marcy find that about 7 per cent of all m - dwarfs are triple systems , and that about 1 per cent are quadruple systems .
the proportions are likely to be higher because the sample of m - dwarf systems within 20 pc is far from complete .
the companion star fraction for m - dwarfs is thus @xmath70 ( compare with @xmath71 ) . similarly , @xmath72 and @xmath73 is higher than @xmath74 and @xmath75 , respectively .
the mass - ratio distribution for g - dwarf binary systems is biased towards low - mass companions ( fig .
10 in dm91 ) .
the data are still rather poor for lower - mass primaries but exclude a preponderance of companions with nearly equal mass ( mayor et al .
1992 , fischer & marcy 1992 ) .
how mass - ratio distributions can be miss - interpreted if unknown selection effects operate is shown by tout ( 1991 ) . that deep star - count data are affected significantly
if companion stars are not counted has been stressed by buser & kaeser ( 1985 ) , who construct the system lf from the nearby lf ( their fig . 2 ) and apply it to galactic structure studies .
piskunov & malkov ( 1991 ) compute the single - star lf given an observed system lf and assumed different mass - ratio distributions , as well as a power - law @xmath76 relation . in their fig .
1 , they show how the system lf significantly underestimates the stellar number densities
. however , the above studies do not include malmquist bias nor the method of photometric distance estimation . in deep surveys
the typical resolution is 2 arc sec ( rg ) , which implies that multiple stellar systems with dimensions less than @xmath77au will not be resolved at a distance of @xmath78pc .
furthermore , most faint companions will not be seen even if the system is formally resolved because the photometric distance limit decreases with decreasing brightness of the star , and because glare around a bright star can hide faint companions .
the great majority of faint companion stars will be missed . counting a multiple star system as a single star has the following effects :
if the companion(s ) are bright enough to affect the system luminosity noticeably , then the estimated photometric distance will be too small ; the remaining companions are lost from the star - count analysis .
the former effect enhances the apparent stellar number density at brighter magnitudes .
this is countered by the larger effective photometric distance limit together with the approximately exponential stellar density fall - off perpendicular to the galactic plane .
the second effect reduces the star - counts at faint magnitudes leading to a significant bias , because a g- , k- and bright m - dwarf has , on average , a faint m - dwarf companion .
before proceeding to infer the mf from the lf , we must understand which information is contained in each of the lfs discussed in section 2 . clearly , @xmath40 is the most direct measurement of the mf , given @xmath79 . but @xmath40 is poorly constrained for @xmath39 by the small number of stars per magnitude bin , amounting in total to about 20 stars .
the constraints available so far suggest that @xmath40 is approximately flat for @xmath39 .
the deep surveys show that @xmath46 does not vary with direction , so that they can be combined to improve the constraints on @xmath46 .
however , not all estimates of @xmath46 have been treated correctly for malmquist bias , which depends on the colour magnitude relation used . to avoid this problem , kroupa ( 1995a ) combined four photometric lfs that base photometric distance estimation on the @xmath53 relation , but are not corrected for malmquist bias , and obtained @xmath80 .
application of malmquist corrections then gives an estimate of the distribution of stars with luminosity in the deep surveys , @xmath64 .
this lf implies that 5 stars should have been found in the sampling volume in which @xmath40 is defined .
given that the one - dimensional velocity dispersion of the stars defining @xmath40 is about 30 km / sec ( ktg93 ; reid , hawley & gizis 1995 ) , it follows immediately that the chance of observing a local overdensity by a factor of 4 is negligibly small .
it is therefore concluded with high confidence that @xmath64 and @xmath40 do not measure the same physical quantity .
the same mixing argument explains why @xmath46 is independent of direction .
it comes to mind ( dlh ) that unresolved binary systems are the most likely cause of the significant underdensity of faint stars in @xmath64 .
this has been verified by ktg91 .
subsequently , reid ( 1991 ) claimed that binary systems can not resolve the discrepancy .
this , however , is a conclusion drawn upon the basis of assumptions that define models outside solution space ( kroupa 1995b ) . in order to clarify some of the questions posed by ktg91 and reid ( 1991 )
, ktg93 developed a detailed model of star - count data in which they took into account consistently all the effects discussed above that influence @xmath46 .
one possible solution is shown in fig . 3 . the upper panel shows the linear @xmath53 relation from sip ( solid line ) , which is taken to be a model for single stars with the same solar - neighbourhood metallicity and age . a realistic distribution of metallicity
, age and binarity then leads to a sample of stars that spread around the underlying relation .
the systematic colour - dependent off set from the underlying relation is evident .
this necessitates a consistent correction of the @xmath53 relation fitted to the data .
a complex multi - dimensional monte - carlo analysis shows that the sip star count data towards the north galactic pole can be fitted with the same mf that also fits @xmath40 .
an exponential galactic disc , with @xmath32 a free parameter , is included explicitly , because unresolved metal - rich binary systems with nearly equal component masses at a true distance of 300400 pc , can enter a photometric distance limit of about 100 pc ( kroupa 1995b ) .
the resulting mf is approximated by a two - part power - law below @xmath81 .
the imf for all stellar masses is obtained by extension with a third power - law segment for more massive stars from the analysis of sc : @xmath82 where @xmath83 for @xmath84 , @xmath85 for @xmath86 , and @xmath87 for @xmath88 ( fig . 22 and eqn . 13 in ktg93 ) .
in this notation salpeter s power - law index is @xmath89 .
there is some evidence that @xmath90 for the imf ( tsujimoto et al .
1997 and references therein ) , and for main - sequence stars in the galactic field @xmath91 .
the model _ observed _ single - star lf becomes the solid curve in the lower panel of fig .
it is affected significantly by the spread of metallicities and trigonometric distance uncertainties , and compares very well with the real @xmath40 shown as the solid histogram ( from kroupa 1995a ) .
the thin dotted histogram shows the effect of counting gl 866c and shifting the sampling distance from 5.2 pc to 5.23 pc .
the dashed curve is the model photometric lf with malmquist bias not removed , assuming a companion star fraction @xmath92 and @xmath93 pc .
the solid dots show @xmath94 ( binned into one - magnitude wide bins offset by half a magnitude ) , which is the relevant observational constraint , and the open circles are @xmath64 . in the above model
, stars are combined randomly from the imf to make the uncorrelated mass ratio distribution , @xmath95 , for binary systems .
this procedure does not give an @xmath95 that is consistent with the observational constraints ( section 5 ) because too many low - mass companions are produced . that the mf derived with the above analysis remains a good solution if @xmath95 consistent with the observational constraints is used ,
is shown in fig .
4 . in the upper left panel
( @xmath96 and @xmath97 are the mass of the secondary and primary , respectively ) the model @xmath95 for g - dwarf primaries is the solid histogram , which can result from the initial uncorrelated distribution ( dot - dashed histogram ) if stars form in embedded clusters ( kroupa 1995d ) .
the observed data ( dm91 ) are the solid dots .
the overall binary proportion is @xmath98 . of these about 9 per cent
have periods shorter than @xmath99 d , with @xmath95 given by the solid histogram in the upper right panel of fig .
4 . the observed data ( mazeh et al .
1992 ) are the solid dots .
the model @xmath95 for all primaries less massive than @xmath100 and all periods is shown in fig .
12 in kroupa ( 1995d ) .
the single star lf for a population with equal metal abundance , age and no distance errors is the solid curve in the lower panel of fig . 4 ( compare to fig .
the corresponding system lf is the dashed curve , and the relevant observational data are the solid dots ( @xmath64 ) .
comparison of figs .
3 and 4 shows that the model photometric lfs contain too many systems for @xmath101 . as discussed in kroupa ( 1995b ) , this is not to be taken too seriously because , among other effects , photometric calibration may be uncertain for the faint red dwarfs . j. gizis ( private communication ) points out that the hitherto neglected non - linearity of the @xmath53 relation ( section 4 in leggett , harris & dahn 1994 ; fig . 1 in baraffe et al .
1995 ) increases @xmath46 at the faint magnitudes , which improves agreement with the models . the model shown in fig .
4 does not rely on adoption of a colour - magnitude relation .
it is thus possible to unify @xmath40 and @xmath46 .
the above analysis leads to the most stringent constraints on the mf available because both the single - star ( i.e. @xmath40 ) _ and _ the much better constrained system lf ( i.e. @xmath46 ) are used simultaneously .
nevertheless , the most direct path to the mf is via the single - star lf . only a major , careful and time - consuming observational effort ( e.g. henry et al . 1997 )
will improve the poorly constrained @xmath40 , but it is instructive to consider the mf that results from the direct conversion ( see section 1 ) of the presently available @xmath40 using different @xmath3 relations : dam86 find @xmath102 for @xmath103 using the wielen et al .
( 1983 ) lf and their theoretical mass luminosity relation ; hm90 find @xmath104 for @xmath105 using the nearby lf they estimate in the k - band and their empirical @xmath106 relation ; laughlin & bodenheimer ( 1993 ) find @xmath107 for @xmath108 using @xmath109 from hm90 and their own mass luminosity relation ; haywood ( 1994 ) finds @xmath110 for @xmath111 using @xmath112 from dlh and stellar models from vandenberg ; kroupa ( 1995b ) finds @xmath113 for @xmath114 and @xmath19 from ktg93 ; and mera et al .
( 1996 ) find @xmath115 for @xmath116 using @xmath40 from ktg93 and their own @xmath19 relation .
clearly , more or less the same estimate for the single - star lf , @xmath40 , yields quite different results depending on which mass luminosity relation is used .
another major source of bias in all these estimates of the mf is the neglect of the metallicity spread and parallax errors .
this is demonstrated by comparing @xmath113 ( fig .
3 in kroupa 1995b ) with the model that does include these effects : @xmath117 ( fig .
16 in ktg93 ) .
an entirely independent estimate of the mf is provided by tsujimoto et al .
( 1997 ) , who find @xmath118 down to below the hydrogen burning mass limit using a model for the chemical enrichment history of the galaxy , and the additional constraint given by the mass - to - light ratio of stars in the solar neighbourhood . finally , it is interesting to note that zhao , rich & spergel ( 1996 ) construct a consistent model of the galactic bar , and compare the distribution of microlensing time - scales with predictions assuming different stellar mfs .
their fig .
3 shows that it is possible to obtain reasonable agreement with the distribution of time - scales if the mf is flat below @xmath119 ( @xmath120 ; but see chabrier , these proceedings ) , and also if it continues as a salpeter ( @xmath89 ) power - law to lower masses , as long as there is no significant population of brown dwarfs .
below approximately @xmath119 the imf may be conveniently approximated by a power law with @xmath121 down to the hydrogen burning mass limit ( see also larson 1992 ) . whether the mf continues as some log - normal function to smaller masses
( e.g. zinnecker 1984 ; adams , these proceedings ) can not yet be decided upon ( see also malkov , piskunov & shpilkina 1997 ) .
main - sequence stars ( @xmath122 ) contribute @xmath123 pc@xmath124 to the oort limit for the three - part power - law mf with @xmath125 and @xmath126 pc .
the inter - stellar medium contributes @xmath127 pc@xmath124 ( kuijken & gilmore 1989 ) and stellar remnants contribute @xmath128 pc@xmath124 ( weidemann 1990 ) .
it follows that the dynamically inferred mass - density in the galactic disc ( @xmath129 pc@xmath124 , kuijken & gilmore 1991 ) can be accounted for .
it also follows that dark matter , e.g. in the form of brown dwarfs , can not be a significant mass - component .
the steeper mfs discussed in section 3 imply essentially the same @xmath130 ( mera et al .
1996 ) , but it remains to be seen if such mfs can also fit @xmath131 . for this , detailed modelling ( section 6 ) is required .
care must be taken to ensure that a @xmath3 relation is used that fits the observational constraints ( fig .
2 ) , that its first derivative is continuous , and that it is defined on an adequately fine stellar - mass grid ( kt ) .
lfs extending down to approximately the hydrogen burning mass limit have been observed for the young pleiades ( hambly , hawkins & jameson 1991 ) and the dynamically evolved hyades ( reid 1993 ) clusters .
the power - law mf for galactic field stars with @xmath132 fits both lfs ( kroupa 1995e ) .
observed lfs must be corrected consistently for unresolved binary stars , but care must be taken not to assume the same binary - star orbital characteristics in open clusters as in the galactic field . the pleiades and hyades clusters are not typical reservoirs of galactic field stars , so there does not appear to be much evidence for an environmentally dependent imf for low - mass stars .
i am grateful to michael hawkins for a very memorable evening ten years ago at the siding spring observatory , where he gave me my first introduction to this subject .
i thank c. a. tout for proof - reading the manuscript .
andersen , j. , 1991 , a&ar , 3 , 91 baraffe , i. , chabrier , g. , allard , f. , & hauschildt , p. h. , 1995 , apj , 446 , l35 basri , g. & marcy , g. w. , 1997 , in star formation : near and far , holt , s. , maryland bessell , m. s. & stringfellow , g. s. , 1993 , ara&a , 31 , 433 buser , r. & kaeser , u. , 1985 , a&a , 145 , 1 chabrier , g. & baraffe , i. , 1997 , a&a , in press dahn c. c. , liebert , j. , harrington r. s. , 1986 , aj , 91 , 621 ( dlh ) dantona , f. & mazzitelli , i. , 1983 , a&a , 127 , 149 ( dam83 ) dantona , f. & mazzitelli , i. , 1986 , a&a , 162 , 80 ( dam86 ) duquennoy , a. & mayor , m. , 1991 , a&a , 248 , 485 ( dm91 ) fischer , d. a. & marcy , g. w. , 1992 , apj , 396 , 178 gilmore , g. , reid , n. , & hewett , p. , 1985 ,
mnras , 213 , 257 hambly , n. c. , hawkins , m. r. s. , & jameson , r. f. , 1991 , mnras , 253 , 1 hawkins , m. r. s. & bessell , m. s. , 1988 , mnras , 234 , 177 haywood , m. , 1994 , a&a , 282 , 444 haywood , m. , robin , a. c. , & crz , m. , 1997 , a&a , 320 , 428 henry , t. j. & mccarthy , d. w. , 1990 , apj , 350 , 334 ( hm90 ) henry , t. j. & mccarthy , d. w. , 1993 , aj , 106 , 773 ( hm93 ) henry , t. j. , ianna , p. a. , kirkpatrick , j. d. , & jahreiss , h. , 1997 , aj , in press jahreiss , h. , 1994 , in science with astronomical near - infrared sky surveys , epchtein , n. , omont , a. , burton , b. , & persi , p. , kluwer : dordrecht , 63 jarrett , t. h. , dickman , r. l. , & herbst , w. , 1994 , apj , 424 , 852 kirkpatrick , j. d. , mcgraw , j. t. , hess , t. r. , liebert , j. , & mccarthy , d. w. , 1994 , apjs , 94 , 749 kirkpatrick , j. d. , henry , t. j. , & irwin , m. j. , 1997 , aj , 113 , 1421 kroupa , p. , 1995a
, apj , 453 , 350 kroupa , p. , 1995b
, apj , 453 , 358 kroupa , p. , 1995c ,
mnras , 277 , 1491 kroupa , p. , 1995d ,
mnras , 277 , 1507 kroupa , p. , 1995e ,
mnras , 277 , 1522 kroupa , p. & tout , c. a. , 1997 , mnras , 287 , 402 ( kt ) kroupa , p. , tout , c. a. & gilmore , g. , 1990 , mnras , 244 , 76 ( ktg90 ) kroupa , p. , tout , c. a. & gilmore , g. , 1991 , mnras , 251 , 293 ( ktg91 ) kroupa , p. , tout , c. a. & gilmore , g. , 1993 , mnras , 262 , 545 ( ktg93 ) kuijken , k. & gilmore , g. , 1989 , mnras , 239 , 605 kuijken , k. & gilmore , g. , 1991 , apj , 367 , l9 larson , r. b. , 1992 , mnras , 256 , 641 laughlin , g. & bodenheimer , p. , 1993 ,
apj , 403 , 303 leggett , s. k. & hawkins , m. r. s. , 1988 , mnras , 234 , 1065 leggett , s. k. , harris , h. c. , & dahn , c. c. , 1994 , aj , 108 , 944 malkov , o. yu . ,
piskunov , a. e. , & shpilkina , d. a. , 1997 , a&a , 320 , 79 mayor , m. , duquennoy , a. , halbwachs , j .- l . , & mermilliod , j .- c . , 1992 , in complementary approaches to double and multiple star research , iau colloqu .
135 , mcalister , h. a. & hartkopf , i. , san francisco : asp , vol . 32 , 73 mazeh , t. , goldberg , d. , duquennoy , a. , & mayor , m. , 1992 , apj , 401 , 265 mra , d. , chabrier , g. , & baraffe , i. , 1996 , apj , 459 , l87 miller , g. e. & scalo , j. m. , 1979 , apjs , 41 , 513 ( ms ) piskunov , a. e. & malkov , o. yu . , 1991 ,
a&a , 247 , 87 reid , n. , 1991 , aj , 102 , 1428 reid , n. , 1993 , mnras , 265 , 785 reid , n. & gilmore , g. , 1982 , mnras , 201 , 73 ( rg ) reid , n. , hawley , s. l. , & gizis , j. e. , 1995 , aj , 110 , 1838 santiago , b. x. , gilmore g. , elson , r. a. w. , 1996 , mnras , 281 , 871 scalo , j. m. , 1986 , fundam . cosmic phys . , 11 , 1 ( sc ) simons , d. a. , henry , t. j. , & kirkpatrick , j. d. , 1996 , aj , 112 , 2238 stobie , r. s. , ishida , k. , & peacock , j. a. , 1989 , mnras , 238 , 709 ( sip ) tinney , c. g. , reid , i. n. , mould , j. r. , 1993 , apj , 414 , 254 tout , c. a. , 1991 , mnras , 250 , 701 tsujimoto , t. , yoshii , y. , nomoto , k. , matteucci , f. , thielemann , f .- k .
, & hashimoto , m. , 1997 , apj , in press upgren , a. r. & armandroff , t. e. , 1981 , aj , 86 , 1898 weidemann , v. , 1990 , in baryonic dark matter , lynden - bell , d. , & gilmore , g. , dordrecht : kluwer , 87 wielen , r. , jahreiss , h. , & krger , r. , 1983 , in the nearby stars and the stellar luminosity function , davis philip , a. g. , upgren , a. r. , iau colloq .
76 , new york : davis press , 163 zhao , h. s. , rich , r. m. , & spergel , d. n. , 1996 , mnras , 282 , 175 zinnecker , h. , 1984 , mnras , 210 , 43 | since the major review by scalo ( 1986 ) , significant progress has been achieved in constraining the mass function ( mf ) of low - mass stars . the break - throughs which today allow a much better understanding of the stellar luminosity function ( lf ) and
the underlying mf are documented here and the resulting mf for galactic field stars is confronted with microlensing data , the chemical enrichment history of the galaxy , the oort limit and well - studied open clusters . |
the first planetary nebula ( pn ) belonging to a globular cluster ( gc ) was discovered more than 85 years ago , in m15 ( pease 1928 ) .
it was another six decades before a second gcpn was found , this time in m22 ( gillett et al . 1989 ) .
jacoby et al .
( 1997 , hereafter jmf97 ) then carried out a systematic ground - based ccd survey of 133 milky way gcs , using a narrow - band [ ] 5007 filter along with a filter in the neighboring continuum .
they discovered two more pne , in the galactic clusters ngc 6441 and pal 6 .
the number of pne known in gcs in the local group was raised to five by the serendipitous discovery of a pn in the cluster h5 belonging to the fornax dwarf spheroidal galaxy ( larsen 2008 ) . outside the local group ,
[ ] emission has been detected in the integrated light of a handful of gcs during spectroscopic investigations , as summarized by minniti & rejkuba ( 2002 ) , zepf et al .
( 2008 ) , chomiuk , strader , & brodie ( 2008 ) , and peacock , zepf , & maccarone ( 2012 ) .
( however , as discussed in 5 , not all of these distant emission sources are actually pne . )
pne in gcs raise two issues related to stellar evolution .
the first is _ why are there so few pne in gcs ? _ jmf97 posed this question because one would expect to find @xmath016 pne in the milky way gcs on the basis of the total luminosity of the galactic gc system , a pn lifetime of @xmath02@xmath1 yr , and the assumption that every star produces a visible pn near the end of its life .
( the prediction comes basically from an application of the `` fuel - consumption theorem , '' as defined by renzini & buzzoni 1986 . ) in order to explain the smaller number actually observed , jmf97 suggested that the assumption that every star produces a pn may be incorrect in gcs .
in fact , single stars in very old populations , having started their lives at about @xmath2 , leave the asymptotic giant branch ( agb ) with masses reduced to as low as @xmath0@xmath3 ( alves , bond , & livio 2000 ; hereafter abl00 ) to @xmath0@xmath4 ( kalirai et al .
2009 ) . the theoretical post - agb evolutionary timescales of such low - mass remnants are so long ( e.g. , schoenberner 1983 ) that any nebular material ejected at the end of the agb phase has time to disperse before the central star becomes hot enough to ionize it .
thus , the single stars now evolving in gcs would not be expected to produce any visible ionized pne .
now the question becomes _ why are there any pne in gcs at all ? _ the answer probably lies in the evolution of binary stars .
there are ( at least ) two ways that binaries can produce pne in populations in which single stars can not .
( 1 ) coalescence of two stars in a binary near the main sequence could produce first a blue straggler , and eventually a higher - mass post - agb remnant that _ would _ evolve rapidly enough to ionize a pn .
abl00 detected no photometric variations for k648 , the central star of the pn ps 1 in m15 , consistent with it being a merger remnant .
( 2 ) or a red giant or agb star may undergo a common - envelope ( ce ) interaction with a companion , rapidly exposing the giant s hot core , and thus promptly subjecting the ejecta to ionizing radiation . these and other scenarios to account for the presence of pne in gcs have been discussed by abl00 , ciardullo et al .
( 2005 ) , buell ( 2012 ) , jacoby et al .
( 2013 ; hereafter jcd13 ) , and others .
they are part of a larger conceptual framework in which it has been increasingly recognized that binary interactions are likely to be a major , if not dominant , formation channel for pne in all populations ( e.g. , bond & livio 1990 ; bond 2000 ; de marco 2009 ; and references therein ) .
the binary - merger hypothesis can be tested by determining the luminosities of central stars of pne in gcs , and then inferring their masses from theoretical core - mass / luminosity relations .
abl00 used the wide field planetary camera 2 ( wfpc2 ) on the _ hubble space telescope _ ( _ hst _ ) to carry out photometry of k648 .
the absolute luminosity of the star implied a mass of @xmath5 .
this is significantly higher than the masses of remnants of single stars in gcs ( see above ) , giving the star a fast enough post - agb evolution for it to have ionized the ejecta before they had time to dissipate .
abl00 concluded that the central star must have achieved its high mass as a result of a merger .
_ hst _ imaging of all four pne in galactic gcs , and photometry of their central stars , have been collected and discussed by jacoby et al .
( 2014 , 2015 ) .
apart from k648 , the evidence for high stellar masses resulting from binary mergers has remained less compelling .
in fact , if the pn were ejected as a consequence of a ce interaction , the mass of its central star would be unlikely to differ much from those of remnants of single - star evolution , or could even be lower .
jacoby et al
. do , however , argue that the morphologies of these gcpne are at least suggestive of ejection from a binary interaction .
a potential test is to search for x - ray emission , arising from a synchronously rotating , active , late - type companion star to the pn nucleus .
variable x - ray emission from k648 has in fact been detected by hannikainen et al .
( 2005)which , if due to the central star rather than the surrounding pn , would argue against the merger scenario i discussed above .
further progress could be made with a larger sample than the five known pne in the milky way and fornax gc populations .
there are many hundreds of gcs known in the andromeda galaxy , m31 ; and smaller numbers are known in m33 , the magellanic clouds , and other members of the local group . as noted by many authors , galaxies like m31 have experienced different evolutionary histories than our galaxy , which might be reflected in systematic differences in their gc systems ( e.g. , van den bergh 2010 and references therein ) . conceivably , for example , there could be a population of gcs with intermediate rather than extremely old ages , which would be richer in pne than the milky way gcs .
jcd13 obtained integrated spectra of 274 old gcs in m31 , searching for emission at [ ] 5007 that would indicate the presence of a pn in the cluster .
three candidate pne were found among this sample of old gcs . in the complementary survey discussed here ,
i have used _ hst _ to search for pne in gcs belonging to local group galaxies , especially m31 , by obtaining direct narrow - band [ ] images .
in my search for pne in local group gcs , i used _ hst _ in its `` snapshot '' mode , in which short exposures are inserted into gaps in the telescope schedule that remain once the primary observations have been sequenced as optimally as possible .
my observations were made during two _ hst _ proposal cycles . in cycle 16
( program i d snap-11218 ) i submitted a list of 125 target gcs , of which 41 were successfully observed . in cycle 17
( snap-11714 ) i submitted 100 targets , of which 23 were observed .
the cycle 16 observations were made with wfpc2 , from 2007 july 10 to 2008 november 23 . in cycle 17 , i used the uvis channel of the newly installed wide field camera 3 ( wfc3 ) , and these observations were made between 2009 september 1 and 2011 september 29 .
nine of the cycle 17 observations were repeats of wfpc2 targets , using the more sensitive wfc3 .
eleven additional gcs were serendipitously present in the frames along with the primary targets , for a total of 66 unique clusters , belonging to eight different galaxies . the list of candidate targets for both
cycles was developed as follows .
the overall aim was primarily to maximize the total integrated luminosity of the cluster sample , in order to maximize the probability of discovering pne ; and secondarily to provide targets widely distributed across the sky .
( 1 ) for the magellanic clouds , i chose the 8 `` population ii '' clusters with integrated visual absolute magnitudes of @xmath6 , as listed by olszewski , suntzeff , & mateo ( 1996 , their table 1 ) .
( 2 ) in m33 , i selected the 5 brightest red ( i.e. , old ) gcs listed by christian & schommer ( 1988 , their table vii ) ; all of them are brighter than @xmath7 ( @xmath8 ) . ( 3 ) in the dwarf irregular galaxies ngc 6822 and wlm , i chose hubble vii in the former , and wlm-1 in the latter .
hubble vii , with an integrated @xmath9 ( @xmath10 ) is an old , metal - poor gc ( e.g. , wyder , hodge , & zucker 2000 ) .
wlm-1 is the lone gc known in its galaxy , and is also very old ( e.g. , hodge et al . 1999 , who give @xmath11 and @xmath12 ) .
( 4 ) for the fornax dwarf spheroidal , out of its five known gcs i included the two bright clusters ngc 1049 and h2 , for which strader et al.(2003 ) give @xmath13 magnitudes of 12.6 and 13.5 ( @xmath14 and @xmath15 ) .
( 5 ) for the dwarf elliptical ngc 147 , i selected hodge ii , with a @xmath13 magnitude of 16.5 ( sharina et al .
2006 ) , corresponding to @xmath16 .
( 6 ) i then selected gcs in the m31 system in order of increasing integrated @xmath13 magnitudes from the catalog of galleti et al .
( 2004 ) , which is maintained online , until the target lists were filled to the allocated numbers .
these lists contained clusters with integrated @xmath13 magnitudes ranging from 13.8 to 16.8 ( @xmath17 to @xmath18 ) . with both wfpc2 and wfc3 ,
i observed each cluster in the narrow - band f502n [ ] 5007 filter , and the broad - band f555w @xmath13 " filter .
exposure times for most of the gcs were @xmath19 s and @xmath20 s in f502n and f555w , respectively , for wfpc2 , or @xmath21
s and @xmath22 s in f502n and f555w for wfc3 .
for the nearby magellanic cloud gcs , the wfpc2 exposures were shortened to @xmath23 s and @xmath24 s. the field of view of wfpc2 is @xmath25 for the pc chip ( i placed the target gcs near the corner of the pc field least affected by charge - transfer inefficiency [ cti ] ) , plus @xmath26 for each of the three neighboring wide - field ( wf ) chips .
the plate scale is @xmath27 for pc , and @xmath28 for the wf . for the wfc3 imaging
i centered each target in a @xmath29 pixel subarray , and the plate scale is @xmath30 , giving a field of view of @xmath31 .
table 1 lists the 66 gcs that were imaged .
the nomenclature is as given in 2.2 ; for m31 i have used the designations of the galleti et al .
( 2004 ) and peacock et al .
( 2010 ) catalogs .
column 2 gives their integrated visual absolute magnitudes , calculated using integrated @xmath13 magnitudes and distances and reddenings from the sources cited in the previous subsection .
serendipitously , nine of the wfpc2 frames contained a second , usually fainter gc in one of the wf chips , as indicated in the footnotes to the table .
in one case , the smaller wfc3 field contained a second cluster : ngc 147 hodge iii ( @xmath32 , @xmath33 ) was in the field of view when hodge ii was observed .
all exposures were dithered for cosmic - ray removal by taking two exposures in each filter and moving the telescope pointing by a few pixels between exposures .
for the wfpc2 frames , i used iraf routines to align and combine them , while for wfc3 i used the pipeline drizzle - combined images from the _ hst _ archive .
a pn will be bright in the narrow - band f502n filter centered near the emission line of [ ] at 5007 .
the broad - band f555w filter also transmits at 5007 ( where the system throughput is actually higher than for f502n ) , as well as at other emission lines in pne , the strongest of which are [ ] 4959 , h@xmath34 and h@xmath35 , and 5876 . to estimate the expected relative count rates for a typical pn in these two filters , i used the line intensities for the halo pn bobn 1 given by otsuka et al .
i convolved them with the system throughputs for both cameras in the two filters , as given in the respective _ instrument handbooks _
( wfpc2 : mcmaster & biretta 2008 ; wfc3 : bond & quijano 2007 ) .
the resulting predicted count - rate ratios for the pn are @xmath36 for wfpc2 , and 2.1 for wfc3 .
drizzled wfc3 images from the _ hst _ archive are in units of counts @xmath37 , so a typical pn would be approximately twice as bright in f555w as in f502n
. however , wfpc2 images from the archive pipeline give total counts accumulated during the exposure .
since the ratio of exposure times was @xmath38 ( in most cases ) for wfpc2 , the ratio of expected integrated counts for a pn in the two filters is thus @xmath39 .
by contrast , a star will appear much brighter in the broad - band f555w filter than in narrow - band f502n .
for a typical gc red giant , the count - rate ratios for a star will be @xmath40 and 30 for wfpc2 and wfc3 , respectively ( the wfc3 ratio being smaller because its f502n bandpass is wider than the one used in wfpc2 ) . at the distance of m31 , the fwhm of stellar images in _ hst _ frames of @xmath0@xmath41 corresponds to a linear diameter of @xmath00.2 pc .
all but the largest pne will appear essentially stellar at this resolution .
thus i searched the images for point sources of comparable brightness ( within factors of @xmath02 or 0.5 , depending on the camera ) in both filters , and rejected sources that were considerably brighter in f555w .
i did this using two different methods : ( 1 ) first i simply visually blinked the f502n and f555w images .
this technique works very well , because there are relatively few point - like sources detected in the f502n frames , especially with wfpc2 , and those that are present are therefore conspicuous .
apart from the rare true pne , nearly all of the apparent sources seen at f502n fell into two categories : ( a ) bright stars ( mostly gc red giants ) , easily recognized because they are much brighter in the f555w frames , and ( b ) spurious artifacts , particularly cases where cosmic rays struck the same pixels in both of the f502n frames that were combined , sometimes producing artifacts that resemble real sources ; however , these are also very easy to recognize and reject because they lack counterparts in the f555w images .
( this valuable check would not have been possible if a broad - band filter had been chosen that rejected the 5007 line . ) ( 2 ) it was , however , difficult to blink the images near the centers of the gcs , because of the high surface brightness in the f555w frames .
thus i also created an image of each gc in which i calculated the ratio of the two frames , and searched them ( again visually ) with a display windowing that emphasized sources with similar count rates in both filters .
this method worked well in the centers of the clusters .
as noted above , the target clusters were placed in the pc chip of wfpc2 ; however , i also searched the three neighboring wf chips , and found several new pne in the fields surrounding the gcs , as well as recovering many previously cataloged pne .
i also searched the entire frames taken with wfc3 , likewise finding a few field pne .
figure 1 illustrates the two search techniques . in the example
shown , i independently recovered a known field pn in m31 , no . 285 in the catalog of ford & jacoby ( 1978 ) .
the left frame shows the f502n [ ] image , with the pn marked in the center , and also showing a bright star to the lower left .
the middle frame shows the @xmath13-band f555w image ; now numerous stars are also detected , and the field star is much brighter , but the pn is nearly unchanged .
the right frame shows the ratio image , f502n
/ f555w , with the display stretched to show objects that have similar brightnesses in both frames and reject sources with low f502n / f555w ratios .
now the stars have disappeared , leaving only the pn , and verifying that it is a source emitting at 5007 .
i determined a nominal limiting magnitude for the wfpc2 f502n frames as follows .
i marked apparent point - like stellar sources on a frame of the well - resolved fornax h2 cluster over a range of brightnesses from obvious detections down to sources so faint that they were likely to be spurious .
( by 20078 , the wfpc2 , which had been onboard _ hst _ since 1993 , was suffering badly from cti and hot pixels in addition to the usual cosmic - ray hits , leading to the presence of many low - level streaks and other artifacts in these frames . )
i then compared the f502n frame with the f555w frame to determine which of the marked sources had brightened ( indicating that they were real stars ) or disappeared ( indicating that they were artifacts ) .
i found a strong cutoff at a flux level such that 100% of the sources brighter than this level were real , but below this level the fraction of spurious detections rose rapidly .
i then calibrated this flux level , using aperture photometry and the reduction procedure described in the _ wfpc2 data handbook _ ( gonzaga & biretta 2010 , 5.2.5 ) .
i included cti corrections as formulated by dolphin ( 2009 ) .
the resulting limiting line flux for the wfpc2 frames is @xmath42 .
it is customary in work on extragalactic pne ( e.g. , ciardullo et al .
1989 ) to use `` [ ] @xmath435007 magnitudes , '' defined by @xmath44 . on this scale , the source detections in my wfpc2 f502n frames
are complete to @xmath45 . at the distance of m31 , this limit reaches more than 3.5 mag into the pn luminosity function in the andromeda bulge ( e.g. , fig . 9 in jcd13 ) .
this magnitude limit applies to isolated sources .
the limit is brighter in the central regions of gcs , due to the bright backgrounds and source confusion . using artificial - star experiments ( i.e. , adding an artificial pn image to the center of a gc ) ,
i find that the limiting magnitude is about 0.9 mag brighter , or about @xmath46 , at the center of a m31 gc of typical central surface brightness . for wfc3 ,
the limiting magnitudes are considerably fainter , since wfc3 is a factor of @xmath03.2 more sensitive , has lower readout noise , and was very considerably less affected by cti than was wfpc2 at the late stage of its lifetime .
the wfc3 frames are cosmetically quite superior to the wfpc2 images , exhibiting very few low - level artifacts apart from occasional instances of a cosmic ray striking the same pixels in both f502n images . using the same techniques
, i estimated that the limiting detection magnitude for the wfc3 exposures was @xmath47 for isolated sources , and again about 0.9 mag brighter for pne at the centers of typical m31 gcs .
i found only one out of the 66 gcs that were imaged in the two snapshot programs to have nearby candidate [ ] @xmath435007 emission sources .
i identified two sources in the vicinity of the m31 cluster b086 , as shown in figure 2 .
details of these sources are given in table 2 .
the brighter of them , here designated m31
b086 - 2 , has been cataloged previously by meyssonnier , lequeux , & azzopardi ( 1993 ; no .
481 in their list of unresolved emission - line objects in m31 ) , and by azimlu , marciniak , & barmby ( 2011 ; no .
1596 in their catalog of objects considered to be regions in m31 ) .
the fainter source , m31 b086 - 1 , has to my knowledge not been cataloged previously .
both objects appear to be unresolved at wfc3 resolution .
i converted the measured count rates for both of them to @xmath48 magnitudes , using the wfc3 photometric zero - points given online .
results are in table 2 . since both sources are unresolved , and have values of @xmath48 consistent with those of pne in m31 , it appears plausible that they are pne ( although it can not be ruled out entirely that either one is a symbiotic binary , nova at the nebular stage , a very compact region , or other 5007 - emitting source ) .
however , b086 lies in a very rich field only @xmath49 from the nucleus of m31 , and fairly near a spiral arm and dust lane .
moreover , both pn candidates , at separations of @xmath50 and @xmath51 from the center of b086 , are well outside the half - light radius of b086 , measured on my images to be @xmath52 .
thus , in the absence of a spectroscopic followup and radial - velocity confirmation , it is questionable whether either object is physically associated with b086 .
if the brighter source had been centered in the gc , it would have added only 3.5% to the flux of the cluster within a diameter of @xmath53 , in a bandpass similar to that of the f502n filter .
the fainter source would constitute only 0.6 % of the cluster flux if centered in the cluster .
thus , ground - based direct imaging would be unlikely to have detected either pn candidate if located near the cluster center .
b086 was observed by jcd13 , but since my pn candidates would have been well outside their spectroscopic fiber aperture , it is not surprising that they were not detected .
in the course of examining the _ hst _ frames , i noted a number of candidate @xmath54 sources in the fields surrounding the target gcs .
these field sources are listed in table 3 .
although they are too distant from the gcs to be considered cluster members , i give them designations based on the name of the target cluster .
as an index of my survey completeness , i include previously cataloged objects that i independently recovered , as well as new discoveries .
the table includes @xmath48 values measured from my material ; i adjusted the zero - point for these magnitudes so as to match the absolute line fluxes listed by ciardullo et al .
( 1989 ) for the sources in common .
the rms scatter was 0.2 mag , consistent with the moderately low snr of the wfpc2 [ ] snapshot images .
the final column in table 3 gives cross references for the previously known sources .
nearly all of the sources brighter than @xmath55 have been cataloged previously .
all of the listed objects appear stellar at _ hst _ resolution , making it likely that most of them are pne , even though some were included in earlier compilations of regions .
however , one object appears to coincide with a classical nova .
i augmented my snapshot observations by searching the _ hst _ archive for frames taken by other investigators with any of the _ hst _ cameras , using a [ ] f502n filter , in the vicinity of m31 , and then checking whether any gcs were within the fields of view .
surprisingly , only two _ hst _ programs , other than my own , have ever used this filter at pointings lying within @xmath56 of the center of m31 .
fortuitously , 12 cataloged gcs lie within the fields observed in these two programs .
images were obtained with the advanced camera for surveys ( acs ) or wfc3 , as listed in table 4 .
three of these clusters had also been imaged in my snapshot survey , so the grand total number of local group gcs outside the milky way imaged by _
hst _ in a f502n filter is 75 .
the f502n images in the two archival programs were accompanied either by frames in f547 m or f550 m ( which exclude the 5007 emission line ) or in f555w ( which includes 5007 as described above ) . out of the 12 clusters ,
one very convincing pn candidate was found within the m31 cluster b477 , as illustrated in figure 3 .
details are given in table 4 .
this emission - line object had been listed by walterbos & braun ( 1992 ; no .
683 , which they described as being unresolved , in their catalog of h@xmath34/ [ ] sources in m31 ) , and by merrett et al .
( 2006 , hereafter mmd06 ; no . 446 in their catalog of pne in m31 ) .
the @xmath48 value in table 4 is quoted from mmd06 .
m31-b477 was not one of the clusters observed spectroscopically by jcd13 , and the association with the star cluster has apparently not been recognized until now .
b477 is , however , not considered to be an old gc of the type targeted in my snapshot survey : kang et al .
( 2012 ) give an age of only 325 myr , based on _ galaxy evolution explorer _ uv photometry .
morphologically , b477 also does not resemble a gc , as can be seen in figure 3 .
the present imaging survey is complementary in several ways to the ground - based spectroscopic search for pne in the m31 gcs carried out by jcd13 .
my survey concentrated on the brightest gcs in m31 ( and the rest of the local group ) , while their large - scale spectroscopic program targeted a wide range of cluster luminosities in m31 .
their method is particularly favorable for pne in fainter gcs , in which there is less dilution of the pn 5007 emission by cluster starlight in the integrated spectrum .
their spectroscopic apertures had diameters of @xmath57 , which captures most of the cluster light but would still miss more widely separated pne , whereas i covered the entire cluster plus a large surrounding field .
jcd13 observed 274 old gcs in m31 , as compared to only 75 imaged in my survey ( plus two archival programs ) throughout the local group .
of the 56 gcs in m31 that i observed or had archival f502n images , jcd13 obtained spectra of 39 of them .
jcd13 were able to reach fainter limiting magnitudes than my wfpc2 frames , down to about @xmath58 vs. my 24.1 , because they used a larger telescope ( 3.5 m vs. 2.4 m ) , and much longer integration times ( 210 minutes vs. 6001000 s ) .
the limiting magnitudes for my wfc3 frames are , however , similar to those of jcd13 .
the spectroscopic observations are susceptible to spurious detections of ambient [ ] emission from diffuse nebulae superposed on the gc , whereas direct high - resolution imaging of point sources does not suffer from this problem .
one inadequacy of direct imaging in [ ] is that it does not provide a line profile , line ratios such as [ ] /h@xmath35 , or other spectroscopic information , all of which help discriminate pne from other emission - line sources .
for example , zepf et al . (
2008 ) found very broad [ ] emission from a source within a gc in the virgo galaxy m49 , attributed to an accreting black hole ( bh ) rather than a pn .
irwin et al .
( 2010 ) found [ ] emission , unaccompanied by balmer emission , from a gc in the fornax galaxy ngc1399 ; they discussed this source in terms of a white - dwarf being tidally disrupted by an intermediate - mass bh , and alternative non - pn scenarios for this object have been proposed by maccarone & warner ( 2011 ) and clausen et al.(2012 ) .
jcd13 found candidate pne in three old gcs in m31 : nb89 , b115 , and bh16 .
of these , only nb89 was observed in my snapshot programs , and only because it happens to lie a few arcseconds away from the bright primary target gc b127 .
much deeper _ hst _ [ ] imaging of nb89two exposures of 2700 s each was obtained in the archival wfc3 program go-12174 , as summarized in table 4 .
the pn candidate in nb89 has @xmath59 according to jcd13 .
an isolated point source this bright would have been detected easily in the deep wfc3 frames , yet no 5007 point source is seen in the images . it is conceivable that the pn coincides exactly with a red giant in the cluster .
however , a more likely possibility is that the emission arises from ambient nebular emission that filled jcd13 s aperture , rather than from a point source indeed , jcd13 raised this as a strong possibility .
in fact , nb89 does lie exactly superposed on a filament of the spiral - shaped emission region discovered by ciardullo et al .
( 1988 ) in their deep ground - based h@xmath34 imaging of the m31 nucleus .
although it is unclear whether this low - excitation region has sufficiently strong 5007 emission for this explanation , the lack of a point - like source in the _ hst _ [ ] images supports this view .
there is no available narrow - band 5007 _ hst _ imaging for the other two clusters , b115 and bh16 , in which jcd13 detected [ ] emission , with @xmath48 values of 22.6 and 25.3 , respectively .
however , there are archival broad - band optical and near - uv images for both clusters , obtained in the andromeda treasury program go-12058 ( pi j. dalcanton ) .
veyette et al .
( 2014 ) have shown that pne have distinctive optical and nuv broad - band colors .
this is especially true shortward of the balmer jump , where there are significant contributions to the flux from the nebular continuum and numerous emission lines , and from the underlying photosphere of the central star . in figure 4
i show _ hst _ images of b115 and bh16 , taken with wfc3 in the near uv ( f275w ) and optical uv ( f336w ) , and with acs at approximately the @xmath60 band ( f475w ) .
the sizes of the frames are similar to those of the spectroscopic apertures used by jcd13 . in both cases
, there is a conspicuous , very blue star - like object within the field .
it is probable that these are the pne detected by jcd13 , although high - resolution narrow - band imaging would be needed to absolutely confirm the identifications .
similar sets of broad - band wfc3 and acs images exist for nb89 , but in this case there is no obvious blue star in or near the cluster .
this is consistent with the above suggestion that the [ ] emission in nb89 is from ambient diffuse nebulosity rather than a pn .
the current online version of the galleti et al .
( 2004 ) m31 catalog ( version 5 , 2012 august ) has 2060 entries , which include confirmed gcs , candidate gcs , and candidate objects subsequently shown not to be genuine gcs .
the mmd06 catalog of pne in m31 contains 3300 confirmed pne and pn candidates .
i intercompared these two catalogs , finding 44 cases where the coordinates agreed within @xmath61 .
a majority of these objects are actually candidate gcs that have been reclassified as regions by caldwell et al .
( 2009 ) , and are thus neither gcs nor pne .
sixteen of the gcs have not been classified ; most of them are from the catalog of kim et al .
( 2007 ) , and i suspect that they are also misclassified regions . of these 44 clusters , only seven were included in the spectroscopic observations of jcd13 ( b075 , b105 , bh16 , b530 , sk052a , sk070a , and sk104a ) .
jcd13 reported 5007 emission only in the old cluster bh16 ( see 5 above ) .
for the other six , the nominal separations of the emission - line objects from the clusters are larger than the jcd13 aperture radius .
there are five cases where an m31 cluster classified as an `` old '' gc by caldwell et al .
( 2009 , 2011 ) , peacock et al .
( 2010 ) , strader et al .
( 2011 ) , and/or jcd13 has an mmd06 source lying within @xmath61 .
these are listed in table 6 .
of these five , there are archival _ hst _ images available for only two .
( 1 ) bh16 was discussed in the previous section , in which i suggested that a blue point - like source to the se of the cluster center , which would have been within jcd13 s spectroscopic aperture , is the pn .
curiously , however , the pn detected by jcd13 does not appear to be the object cataloged as mmd06 1360 , which differs substantially in both radial velocity and @xmath48 from the jcd13 pn .
the _ hst _
images show a bright blue star lying @xmath62 wsw of the cluster , which may be the mmd06 source .
( 2 ) sk104a also has a neighboring blue star in broad - band _ hst _ images , lying @xmath63 nne from the cluster center .
this is possibly the pn candidate , but narrow - band imaging and/or spectroscopy is needed to confirm this .
i used _ hst _ snapshot observing to obtain [ ] 5007 images of 55 of the brightest `` population ii '' gcs in local group galaxies outside the milky way .
an additional 11 fainter clusters serendipitously fell within these frames .
a search of the _ hst _ archive found [ ] images of nine more gcs in m31 , for a grand total of 75 local - group gcs .
i searched all 75 of these clusters for point - like 5007 sources , which would be strong pn candidates . among these old gcs of the local group ,
i found only the m31 cluster b086 to have two pn candidates in its vicinity .
however , they are at such large angular separations that their cluster membership is doubtful .
one very convincing pn candidate was found in images of the young m31 cluster b477 .
i also investigated _ hst _ images of the three candidate pne found in old clusters by jcd13 in their ground - based spectroscopic survey of m31 gcs .
one of them appears to be a case where ambient diffuse nebulosity produced the 5007 emission , rather than a true pn . for the other two ,
there are only broad - band _ hst _ images available , but both clusters contain a bright blue point source which is plausibly the pn .
a comparison of two extensive catalogs of gcs and pne in m31 revealed several additional candidate pne within a few arcseconds of old gcs , but spectroscopy and narrow - band _ hst _ images will be needed to verify the cluster membership .
the total luminosity of the 157 known gcs in the milky way system , determined from the data in the harris ( 1996 ) compliation ( 2010 editionharris / mwgc.dat ] ) , corresponds to a visual absolute magnitude of @xmath64 . for my sample of 75 local - group gcs , although only numbering about half of the milky way clusters , the total luminosity is actually slightly higher , at @xmath65 .
in the milky way gc system , there are four known pne ( jmf97 ; table 4 of jcd13 ) .
if they were at the distance of m31 , they would have @xmath48 magnitudes of 21.3 , 25.3 , 27.4 , and 29.7 .
given the limiting magnitudes of my surveys ( 3.2 ) , only one of them would be bright enough to be detected in my wfpc2 snapshots , and one more in my deeper wfc3 frames . in the actual old - population m31 clusters , we have two very probable pne those in b115 and bh16along with several more candidates ( 4.1,4.3 ) , which are as yet unconfirmed .
as noted in 1 , there is also a pn in one of the gcs of the fornax dwarf spheroidal ( larsen 2008 ) .
thus , within the small - number statistics , the incidences of pne in the old gcs of the milky way and in the rest of the local group are very similar . according to our understanding of stellar evolution
, we do not expect that pne can be formed by single stars in the ancient populations of gcs2357 in m22 ( gillett et al .
1989 ) and the pn in the fornax gc h5 ( larsen 2008 ) .
this may raise the possibility for these two objects of a late thermal pulse ( in a single star ) , similar to that invoked to explain the compact h - deficient [ ] -emitting nebula surrounding v605 aquilae ( clayton et al .
2013 and references therein ) .
detailed discussion is given by jacoby et al .
( 2015 ) ] .
binary - star mergers and ce events provide a plausible explanation for the fact that a few pne nevertheless exist in these clusters .
one observational test would be to search for evidence of binarity in the central stars of pne in milky way gcs : those whose masses appear to be too low to have resulted from mergers are likely to have gone through a ce interaction , leaving them as close but still un - merged binaries .
i also found some 60 point - like [ ] 5007 sources in the fields surrounding the gcs ( all but one of them in m31 ) ; many of them were already cataloged , but the stellar appearances in the _ hst _ images verify that they are highly probable field pne .
support for program numbers snap-11218 and snap-11714 was provided by nasa through grants from the space telescope science institute , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , incorporated , under nasa contract nas5 - 26555 .
helpful assistance and advice on the _ hst _ scheduling was given by alison vick , denise taylor , sylvia baggett , ronald gilliland , and larry petro .
this research has made extensive use of the simbad database , operated at cds , strasbourg , france ; and of the catalogs of galleti et al.(2004 ) , merrett et al .
( 2006 ) , and harris ( 1996 ) .
lcll fornax : h2 & @xmath15 & 2008 - 11 - 23 & 2010 - 01 - 10 + fornax : ngc 1049 & @xmath66 & 2008 - 09 - 19 & 2010 - 02 - 01 + lmc : ngc 1466 & @xmath67 & & 2009 - 09 - 01 + lmc : ngc 1786 & @xmath67 & 2008 - 09 - 19 & 2010 - 02 - 06 + lmc : ngc 1835 & @xmath68 & 2007 - 08 - 28 & + lmc : ngc 1916 & @xmath69 & 2008 - 06 - 01 & + lmc : ngc 2005 & @xmath70 & 2008 - 11 - 22 & 2009 - 12 - 05 + lmc : ngc 2019 & @xmath67 & 2008 - 08 - 26 & 2009 - 10 - 28 + lmc : ngc 2210 & @xmath66 & 2007 - 12 - 26 & + m31-b005 & @xmath69 & 2008 - 11 - 15 & + m31-b008 & @xmath71 & & 2010 - 01 - 02 + m31-b019 & @xmath72 & 2008 - 08 - 23 & + m31-b023 & @xmath73 & 2008 - 08 - 05 & 2011 - 09 - 05 + m31-b027 & @xmath69 & 2007 - 08 - 28 & + m31-b037 & @xmath71 & 2007 - 09 - 13 & + m31-b041 & @xmath74 & 2007 - 09 - 13 & + m31-b058 & @xmath72 & 2008 - 07 - 22 & + m31-b061 & @xmath75 & 2007 - 07 - 17 & + m31-b063 & @xmath76 & 2007 - 07 - 17 & + m31-b082 & @xmath69 & 2008 - 07 - 21 & + m31-b086 & @xmath77 & & 2011 - 01 - 26 + m31-b097d & @xmath78 & 2008 - 07 - 28 & + m31-b103d & @xmath79 & 2008 - 09 - 09 & + m31-b110 & @xmath80 & 2008 - 11 - 15 & + m31-b124 & @xmath81 & 2008 - 11 - 16 & + m31-b127 & @xmath82 & 2008 - 11 - 16 & + m31-b158 & @xmath83 & 2008 - 07 - 28 & + m31-b171 & @xmath77 & & 2011 - 09 - 29 + m31-b174 & @xmath84 & 2008 - 11 - 15 & + m31-b179 & @xmath68 & 2008 - 08 - 10 & + m31-b192 & @xmath85 & 2008 - 11 - 15 & + m31-b193 & @xmath68 & 2008 - 11 - 15 & + m31-b225 & @xmath73 & 2008 - 06 - 16 & + m31-b293 & @xmath86 & 2007 - 09 - 24 & + m31-b311 & @xmath84 & 2008 - 06 - 19 & + m31-b312 & @xmath69 & 2008 - 11 - 17 & 2010 - 09 - 03 + m31-b327 & @xmath66 & 2007 - 09 - 12 & + m31-b338 & @xmath87 & 2008 - 06 - 19 & + m31-b343 & @xmath86 & & 2011 - 08 - 14 + m31-b366 & @xmath88 & & 2010 - 09 - 04 + m31-b373 & @xmath76 & 2008 - 07 - 24 & + m31-b379 & @xmath89 & 2007 - 09 - 30 & + m31-b384 & @xmath90 & & 2009 - 10 - 09 + m31-b386 & @xmath69 & 2008 - 07 - 28 & + m31-b405 & @xmath77 & 2008 - 06 - 14 & + m31-b407 & @xmath91 & 2008 - 06 - 18 & + m31-b472 & @xmath77 & 2008 - 09 - 09 & + m31-b480 & @xmath92 & 2008 - 07 - 24 & + m31-b514 & @xmath90 & 2007 - 07 - 19 & + m31-g001 & @xmath93 & 2007 - 07 - 16 & + m31-g002 & @xmath90 & 2008 - 09 - 24 & + m31-mcgc1 & @xmath91 & & 2009 - 09 - 30 + m31-mcgc3 & @xmath86 & & 2009 - 11 - 09 + m31-mcgc5 & @xmath89 & & 2009 - 12 - 02 + m31-nb89 & @xmath94 & 2008 - 11 - 16 & + m31-vdb0 & @xmath81 & 2007 - 09 - 12 & + m33-mkk33 & @xmath66 & & 2011 - 06 - 16 + m33-r12 & @xmath66 & & 2009 - 12 - 02 + m33-r14 & @xmath75 & & 2010 - 02 - 26 + m33-sm310 & @xmath95 & & 2009 - 12 - 02 + m33-u49 & @xmath96 & & 2009 - 11 - 26 +
ngc 147 : hodge ii & @xmath97 & 2008 - 11 - 21 & 2010 - 06 - 17 + ngc 147 : hodge iii & @xmath79 & 2008 - 11 - 21 & + ngc 6822 : h vii & @xmath98 & 2007 - 07 - 10 & + smc : ngc 121 & @xmath71 & 2007 - 11 - 19 & + wlm : wlm-1 & @xmath90 & 2008 - 09 - 08 & 2009 - 10 - 03 + lllll ngc 147 hii-1 & 00:33:12.62 & 48:28:17.5 & 22.6 & fjj ngc 147 - 1 + m31 b005 - 1 & 00:40:16.29 & 40:43:23.2 & 24.0 & amb 551 ; mmd 1944 + m31 b195d-1 & 00:40:25.75 & 40:37:06.0 & 23.2 & mmd 2052 + m31 b195d-2 & 00:40:30.82 & 40:36:53.8 & 20.7 & mla 47 ; hkpn 47 ; mmd 2049 + m31 b023 - 1 & 00:40:58.27 & 41:14:16.8 & 23.5 & + m31 b037 - 1 & 00:41:37.51 & 41:15:10.6 & 22.2 & mla 378 ; mmd 1052 + m31 b063 - 1 & 00:42:06.30 & 41:29:29.5 & 24.0 & + m31 b086 - 3 & 00:42:16.99 & 41:14:02.3 & 24.6 & + m31 b082 - 1 & 00:42:17.84 & 41:01:15.6 & 22.4 & mla 485 + m31 b127 - 1 & 00:42:37.07 & 41:14:34.8 & 20.6 & fj 54 ; mmd 2811 + m31 b127 - 2 & 00:42:37.47 & 41:14:34.3 & 21.9 & fj 71 ; mmd 2826 + m31 b127 - 3 & 00:42:38.26 & 41:15:33.4 & 21.4 & fj 35 ; mmd
2815 + m31 b127 - 4 & 00:42:38.36 & 41:14:26.9 & 22.6 & fj 143 ; mmd 2827 + m31 b127 - 5 & 00:42:38.38 & 41:14:33.9 & 21.3 & fj 55 ; mmd 2810 + m31 b127 - 6 & 00:42:38.95 & 41:14:56.0 & 21.9 & fj 70 ; mmd 2812 + m31 b127 - 7 & 00:42:39.39 & 41:14:17.1 & 22.1 & fj 65 ; mmd 2809 + m31 b127 - 8 & 00:42:39.72 & 41:15:36.3 & 21.0 & fj 18 ; mmd 2817 + m31 b127 - 9 & 00:42:39.75 & 41:15:49.3 & 20.9 & fj 17 ; mmd 2825 + m31 b127 - 10 & 00:42:40.08 & 41:14:37.8 & 22.0 & fj 66 ; mmd 2828 + m31 b127 - 11 & 00:42:40.12 & 41:13:23.9 & 22.8 & fj 159 ; mmd 2822 + m31 b127 - 12 & 00:42:40.18 & 41:15:32.7 & 23.1 & fj 334 + m31 b127 - 13 & 00:42:40.20 & 41:13:50.3 & 23.2 & fj 160 ; mmd 2824 + m31 b127 - 14 & 00:42:40.28 & 41:15:44.2 & 23.3 & fj 333 + m31 b127 - 15 & 00:42:40.34 & 41:14:09.5 & 22.0 & fj 181 ; mmd 2823 + m31 b127 - 16 & 00:42:40.69 & 41:14:09.4 & 20.9 & fj 56 ; mmd 1250 + m31 b127 - 17 & 00:42:41.34 & 41:14:06.9 & 22.1 & fj 141 ; mmd 1251 + m31 b127 - 18 & 00:42:42.10 & 41:14:09.0 & 21.5 & fj 57 ; mmd 1249 + m31 b127 - 19 & 00:42:42.15 & 41:14:22.3 & 22.6 & fj 174 ; mmd 1255 + m31 b127 - 20 & 00:42:42.33 & 41:15:53.3 & 21.1 & fj 4 ; mmd 1339 + m31 b127 - 21 &
00:42:42.43 & 41:13:55.9 & 22.1 & fj 99 ; mmd 1246 + m31 b127 - 22 & 00:42:42.62 & 41:13:33.8 & 23.9 & + m31 b127 - 23 & 00:42:42.91 & 41:15:19.8 & 22.6 & fj 73 ; mmd 1303 + m31 b127 - 24 & 00:42:43.02 & 41:15:31.8 & 22.2 & fj 19 ; mmd 1306 + m31 b127 - 25 & 00:42:43.03 & 41:15:36.5 & 21.6 & fj 20 ; mmd 1290 + m31 b127 - 26 & 00:42:43.07 & 41:14:08.8 & 22.5 & fj 139 ; mmd 1252 + m31 b127 - 27 & 00:42:43.27 & 41:15:56.1 & 21.8 & fj 7 ; mmd 1323 + m31 b127 - 28 & 00:42:43.79 & 41:16:01.0 & 21.5 & fj 8 ; mmd 1324 + m31 b127 - 29 & 00:42:43.81 & 41:15:38.9 & 22.7 & fj 319 + m31 b127 - 30 & 00:42:44.03 & 41:15:01.7 & 23.5 & m31 nova 2006 - 11b + m31 b127 - 31 & 00:42:44.39 & 41:15:04.9 & 22.5 & mmd
1349 + m31 b127 - 32 & 00:42:44.90 & 41:15:20.6 & 21.8 & fj 74 ; mmd 1347 + m31 b127 - 33 & 00:42:44.99 & 41:16:03.9 & 22.3 & fj 324 + m31 b127 - 34 & 00:42:45.16 & 41:15:23.2 & 21.1 & fj 21 ; mmd 1266 + m31 b127 - 35 & 00:42:45.21 & 41:16:05.4 & 21.4 & fj 9 + m31 b127 - 36 & 00:42:45.25 & 41:15:29.2 & 22.3 & fj 323 ; mmd 1295 + m31 b127 - 37 & 00:42:45.76 & 41:16:01.2 & 23.5 & fj 454 ? + m31 b127 - 38 & 00:42:45.85 & 41:16:01.3 & 23.3 & + m31 b127 - 39 & 00:42:46.05 & 41:15:16.1 & 21.6 & fj 59 ; mmd 1287 + m31 b127 - 40 & 00:42:46.28 & 41:15:22.5 & 22.3 & fj 22 ; mmd 1296 + m31 b127 - 41 & 00:42:46.36 & 41:15:46.0 & 21.5 & fj 72 ; mmd 1299 + m31 b127 - 42 & 00:42:46.69 & 41:16:09.6 & 21.2 & fj 10 ; mmd 1309 + m31 b179 - 1 & 00:43:32.62 & 41:17:20.9 & 23.2 & amb 272 ; mmd
1391 + m31 b179 - 2 & 00:43:32.71 & 41:18:32.8 & 21.4 & mla 796 ; amb 2249 ; mmd 2767 + m31 b193 - 1 & 00:43:40.11 & 41:36:01.0 & 23.1 & amb 2331 ; mmd 647 + m31 b472 - 1 & 00:43:41.55 & 41:28:02.1 & 22.4 & fj 274 ; mla 836 ; mmd 3022 + m31 b472 - 2 & 00:43:43.26 & 41:27:30.2 & 22.8 & fj 285 ; mmd 2706 + m31 b193 - 2 & 00:43:49.91 & 41:37:34.3 & 24.0 & + m31 b225 - 1 & 00:44:27.52 & 41:22:29.0 & 22.6 & mla 998 ; amb 2930 ; mmd 979 + m31 b225 - 2 & 00:44:31.02 & 41:22:25.7 & 22.9 & wb 445 ; amb 334 ; mmd 978 + m31 b386 - 1 & 00:46:30.45 & 42:01:09.6 & 25.3 & + lcll m31-b080 & @xmath99 & 2010 - 12 - 21 & + m31-b084 & @xmath85 & 2010 - 12 - 21 & + m31-b096 & @xmath75 & 2010 - 12 - 21 & + m31-b124 & @xmath81 & & 2010 - 12 - 23 + m31-b127 & @xmath82 & & 2010 - 12 - 23 + m31-b132 & @xmath100 & & 2010 - 12 - 23 + m31-b264 & @xmath101 & & 2010 - 12 - 23 + m31-b477 & @xmath95 & 2003 - 09 - 27 & + m31-nb21 & @xmath92 & & 2010 - 12 - 23 + m31-nb39 & @xmath94 & & 2010 - 12 - 23 + m31-nb41 & @xmath102 & & 2010 - 12 - 23 + m31-nb89 & @xmath94 & & 2010 - 12 - 23 + lllc b075 & 00:42:08.824 & 41:20:21.25 & + 759 & 00:42:09.100 & 41:20:22.80 & 3.3 + b105 & 00:42:30.747 & 41:30:27.34 & + 534 & 00:42:30.700 & 41:30:24.60 & 2.8 + bh16 & 00:42:46.090 & 41:17:35.99 & + 1360 & 00:42:45.900 & 41:17:36.50 & 2.3 + sk052a & 00:42:37.315 & 41:50:53.58 & + 2598 & 00:42:37.500 & 41:50:56.00 & 3.0 + sk104a & 00:45:44.311 & 41:57:27.80 & + 139 & 00:45:44.600 & 41:57:27.00 & 3.4 + | single stars in ancient globular clusters ( gcs ) are believed incapable of producing planetary nebulae ( pne ) , because their post - asymptotic - giant - branch evolutionary timescales are slower than the dissipation timescales for pne .
nevertheless , four pne are known in galactic gcs .
their existence likely requires more exotic evolutionary channels , including stellar mergers and common - envelope binary interactions .
i carried out a snapshot imaging search with the _ hubble space telescope _ ( _ hst _ ) for pne in bright local group gcs outside the milky way .
i used a filter covering the 5007 nebular emission line of [ ] , and another one in the nearby continuum , to image 66 gcs .
inclusion of archival _ hst _ frames brought the total number of extragalactic gcs imaged at 5007 to 75 , whose total luminosity slightly exceeds that of the entire galactic gc system .
i found no convincing pne in these clusters , aside from one pn in a young m31 cluster misclassified as a gc , and two pne at such large angular separations from an m31 gc that membership is doubtful . in a ground - based spectroscopic survey of 274 old gcs in m31 , jacoby et al .
( 2013 ) found three candidate pne .
my _ hst _ images of one of them suggest that the [ ] emission actually arises from ambient interstellar medium rather than a pn ; for the other two candidates , there are broad - band archival uv _ hst _ images that show bright , blue point sources that are probably the pne . in a literature search ,
i also identified five further pn candidates lying near old gcs in m31 , for which follow - up observations are necessary to confirm their membership .
the rates of incidence of pne are similar , and small but non - zero , throughout the gcs of the local group . |
the prediction of microstructural evolution in response to thermo - mechanical loading is important for materials design , processing or thermomechanical fatigue phenomena .
computational modeling of evolving texture in response to large plastic deformation and recrystallization has been studied extensively @xcite but less so than that produced by thermally - induced stresses i.e .
stress - induced texture evolution @xcite .
we consider a thermo - mechanical setting in which temperature changes cause stresses to develop due to geometrical constraints .
the temperature is sufficiently high to generate grain boundary motion and yet low enough such that recrystallization does not occur .
the induced stresses may be associated with both elastic and plastic deformation @xcite . in a previous work ,
a hybrid monte carlo ( hmc ) approach @xcite was developed by combining a mc algorithm for grain boundary motion @xcite with the material point method ( mpm ) @xcite for elastic deformation .
purely elastic driving forces , originating from the anisotropic mechanical response of individual grains , are treated as a bulk body force in a potts model for grain boundary evolution @xcite .
the approach is time accurate through the use of parametric links @xcite to sharp - interface ( si ) kinetics @xcite .
it also takes advantage of the fact that mc grain boundary mobility is independent of the driving force @xcite .
the present work extends this paradigm to include the influence of inelastic deformation on texture evolution @xcite . as in the elastic study @xcite
, texture evolution is assumed to be dominated by grain boundary kinetics @xcite .
furthermore , we consider infinitesimal deformation to distinguish the stress - induced texture from deformation texture .
the latter is associated with grain and lattice rotation in response to finite deformations @xcite .
a stochastic , crystal plasticity model , developed from rate - independent crystal plasticity @xcite , is applied within the mpm framework as the constitutive model to capture the elasto - plastic response of a polycrystalline media @xcite . as opposed to conventional deterministic algorithms @xcite ,
the stochastic algorithm relies on a mc routine to determine the activated slip system which is therefore referred to as the monte carlo plasticity ( mcp ) .
when plastic deformation occurs , dislocations are generated , stored and annihilated within the microstructure .
the heterogeneous distribution of these dislocations within the polycrystalline medium constitutes a plastic driving force for grain boundary migration .
this is treated as a body force within the mc kinetics using parametric links between mc and si models . a red / black ( rb ) updating scheme is used to parallelize the mc algorithm @xcite , although other methods might also be useful @xcite .
this parallelized hmc approach is used to investigate the microstructural evolution of nickel polycrystals under plastic loading .
as expected , the grains with smaller schmid factors gradually dominate the polycrystalline system .
the data is subsequently used to construct a macroscopic kinetic equation to predict the evolution of microstructure .
plastic response of polycrystalline materials is treated through a classical rate - independent small deformation crystal plasticity formulation @xcite .
the foundations of the constitutive model assume that the elasto - plastic response of single crystals is dominated by slip deformation mechanisms @xcite .
a successful numerical algorithm must carry out three tasks : the determination of activated slip systems ; the calculation of the plastic slip on each activated slip system ; and , the solution of redundant constraints associated with a hardening law @xcite .
various numerical methods have been devised and successfully implemented in deterministic formats @xcite .
as opposed to deterministic algorithms , the current work adopts a probabilistic approach borrowed from concepts in statistical mechanics in which only one slip system is activated during each time step .
plastic slip is therefore treated as a series of discrete , probabilistic events that mimic the sequential accumulation of dislocations at the lattice scale .
this monte carlo crystal plasticity ( mcp ) is algorithmically simple because plastic slip can be resolved through the solution of one equation with no redundant constraints . on the other hand ,
the associated computational steps has to be sufficiently small such that a sequence of single slips mimics multiple slip behavior . a probabilistic algorithm , detailed in what follows ,
is used to determine which slip system is chosen at each step .
the constitutive framework and stress updating routine are otherwise standard @xcite . given a set of potentially activated slip systems @xmath1 , identified through comparison of resolved shear stress with slip resistance @xcite
, the elastic energy of a crystal , @xmath2 , can be calculated if each slip system of the set @xmath3 is individually activated .
this generates @xmath4 possible states for the deformed crystal .
the probability , @xmath5 , of a slip system being selected is computed using the partition function @xcite , @xmath6 : @xmath7{l}$z=\sum\limits_{\alpha=1}^{n}e^{-\beta e_{\alpha}}$\\$p_{\alpha}=\frac{e^{-\beta e_{\alpha}}}{z}$ , \end{tabular } \label{mc_pla}\ ] ] where @xmath8 is the index of a potentially activated slip system , and @xmath9 is the inverse of the fundamental temperature .
dislocation energy can be ignored in eqn .
( [ mc_pla ] ) due to the fact that an isotropic hardening model is used @xcite .
the @xmath10 slip system of the set @xmath3 is activated when the following criterion is met : @xmath7{l}$\sum\limits_{\alpha=1}^{i}p_{\alpha}-p_{i}\leq r<\sum\limits_{\alpha=1}^{i}p_{\alpha}$. \end{tabular } \label{random}\ ] ] here @xmath11 is taken as a random number between @xmath12 and @xmath13 . with the activated slip system determined , the deformation can easily be parsed into elastic and plastic components . as a verification of this mcp method ,
a uniaxial tension test was carried out on a single crystal of nickel .
the material properties @xcite required for this model are listed in table [ plapara ] .
.nickel properties required in mcp model @xcite . [ plapara ] [ cols="<,<,<",options="header " , ] a prescribed strain increment , @xmath14 was enforced at each time step : @xmath15 , \ ] ] with @xmath16 fig .
[ stress_mcp_svd ] compares the results obtained using the mcp logic with their counterparts obtained with a deterministic model wherein a singular value decomposition ( svd ) algorithm is applied to solve the ill - conditioned constraint equations .
the two approaches clearly agree .
sharp - interface , grain boundary kinetics @xcite is the basis for our grain boundary kinetics model .
it can be developed by considering a bi - crystal subjected to uniaxial loading that results in plastic deformation as shown in fig .
[ si_schem ] .
the dislocation energy , @xmath17 , and dislocation density , @xmath18 are related using the relation @xcite @xmath19 here @xmath20 is the shear modulus , @xmath21 is the burgers vector , and @xmath22 is the flow stress . the thermodynamic driving force for interfacial accretion is given by @xcite @xmath23\!]+\kappa \gamma^ { * } \ , \label{driv_trac}\ ] ] where @xmath24 is the capillary driving force , @xmath25 is the local mean curvature , and @xmath26\!]$ ] is the jump in a field across the grain boundary . the elastic driving force is temporarily suppressed in order to study the influence of the plastic behavior on texture evolution .
the herring relation @xcite is used to describe the accretive normal speed of the interface , @xmath27 : @xmath28 where @xmath29 is grain boundary mobility .
the mc paradigm is intended to implement si kinetics within a computationally efficient setting .
continuum , deterministic fields are linked to discrete , probabilistic counterparts , and the physical domain is discretized into a square lattice .
a q - state potts model @xcite is used to represent a crystalline system and grain orientation is described by an integer - valued spin field , @xmath30 , which ranges from @xmath13 to @xmath31 .
the system hamiltonian is then written as @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the spatially varying bulk energy associated with the @xmath34 lattice , @xmath35 is the interaction energy between the neighboring spin fields @xmath30 and @xmath36 , @xmath37 is the number of neighbors considered on the selected lattice , and @xmath38 is the kronecker delta .
kinetics , within the mc paradigm , is translated to a series of probabilistic trials carried out at all lattice sites .
the acceptance of a trial event is determined by a probability function based on the change in the hamiltonian associated with a trial flip .
plastic effects can therefore be accounted for if the plastic driving force is treated as a bulk energy term in eqn .
( [ h_1 ] ) . parametric links between si and mc models are used to convert si parameters into mc format @xcite : @xmath39 where @xmath40 and @xmath41 are reasonable grain boundary stiffness and grain boundary mobility obtained from the literature @xcite , while @xmath42 is the computed bulk energy density associated with the si model .
the counterparts in the mc paradigm , which can be analytically or numerically derived , are @xmath43 @xcite , @xmath44 and @xmath45 @xcite , respectively .
a characteristic energy , @xmath46 , length , @xmath47 , and time , @xmath48 along with the mc lattice size @xmath49 , interaction energy @xmath50 , effective temperature @xmath51 , inclination angle @xmath52 and time step @xmath53 , are also required to bridge the si and mc paradigms @xcite .
these links endow the mc simulation with physical time and length scales .
in a typical mc implementation , an update of variables immediately follows the acceptance of a trial event as in the metropolis algorithm for example @xcite . to improve the efficiency of this approach within a parallelized setting
, we adopted a red / black ( rb ) updating rule @xcite wherein the domain is decomposed into a checkerboard , and each mc step is divided into red / black and black / red half steps .
this is an alternative to the n - fold way algorithm @xcite .
in contrast to the large number of updates associated with a standard mc time step , states are not updated in the rb format until each half step finishes . when applied within a parallel environment , the domain is divided uniformly among processors with synchronous communication between processors at each half - step .
the approach is first implemented within a 2d , bi - crystal setting @xcite .
a circular grain is placed at the center of a square domain and the inner grain shrinks or grows due to the combined effects of capillary and bulk driving forces .
the two - state square lattice ising model is then employed to represent the physical system .
mc simulations were carried out on a @xmath54 grid , at an effective temperature @xmath55 .
the evolution of inner grain was simulated with four combinations of capillary and bulk driving forces .
capillary driving force was fixed by giving a constant interaction energy , i.e. , @xmath56 , while bulk driving force , which is half of the bulk energy difference per site between inner and outer grains , varies from @xmath57 to @xmath58 .
in particular , the bulk energy term will be used later on to represent mechanical effect ( dislocation energy ) in realistic plastic deformation .
corresponding si simulations were also run using the established parametric links between mc and si models . fig .
[ 2d_rb ] ( a ) indicates good agreement between the two models in the prediction of inner grain area as a function of time . an additional test case was also performed for a polycrystalline system where the q - state ( @xmath59 ) potts model with isotropic interaction energy ( @xmath56 ) was used .
many mc simulations were carried out at effective temperatures @xmath60 and @xmath61 , respectively .
[ 2d_rb ] ( b ) shows the measured average grain size with linear fits to the data .
the linear grain growth behavior is consistent with that of the _ isotropic grain growth theory _ @xcite . in later applications ,
a relatively high mc effective temperature is preferred to remove lattice pinning @xcite .
. solid line and discrete points represent mc and si results respectively .
grid size is @xmath62 .
( b ) isotropic grain growth at two mc temperatures for 2-d polycrystals .
the gray and black dots demonstrate @xmath51=0.5 and @xmath51=1.0 , respectively .
grid size is @xmath62 .
mc results are averaged over @xmath63 samples.,scaledwidth=60.0% ]
the aforementioned parallelized mc algorithm was next applied within the previous polycrystalline setting to study the influence of bulk energy distribution on the evolution of texture .
the interaction energy was taken to be isotropic and a gaussian distribution for the bulk energy was assigned to each orientation . fig .
[ mc_texture ] ( a ) shows the orientation - dependent gaussian shape bulk energy : @xmath64 , \label{flow}\ ] ] where @xmath4 is orientation , and @xmath44 is the bulk energy associated with this material .
the bulk energy is adimensioned within a pure mc setting .
mc simulations were carried out at an effective temperature @xmath60 .
[ mc_texture ] ( b ) presents the orientation distribution at three time slices .
as physically expected , materials points with a lower bulk energy are favored .
this indicates that grains which experience the least plastic deformation will be favored as opposed to the ones have larger dislocation content . , and @xmath60 .
simulation results were averaged over @xmath65 runs.,scaledwidth=60.0% ] the parallelized hmc approach was then used to consider the microstructural evolution of three - dimensional , polycrystalline nickel in response to plastic deformation .
attention was restricted to texture development in response to plastic deformation which is dominated by grain boundary kinetics rather than that of triple junction kinetics @xcite . to meet this requirement ,
all numerical experiments were performed at an mc effective temperature ( @xmath66 ) , which is a non - physical temperature .
note that the corresponding physical temperature ( as opposed to mc temperature ) is still not high enough to initiate recrystallization .
in addition , elastic driving forces were suppressed for the sake of clarity .
the mcp framework is implemented in mpm as a plastic constitutive model mediating the mechanical response @xcite .
the required fitting parameters are listed in table [ plapara ] .
material properties at room temperature were adopted even though they may be temperature dependent @xcite . in order to illustrate the methodology and facilitate the interpretation of the results , grains were distinguished by a single angle of rotation with respect to the z - direction and allowed it to vary from @xmath67 to @xmath68 in @xmath69 angle steps .
the other two euler angles were held fixed . a similar
setting has been previously consider with deformation restricted to the elastic regime @xcite . as mentioned previously ,
plastic slip occurs when the resolved shear stress on a slip system exceeds its threshold resistance . as a consequence ,
orientations with bigger schmid factor will be plastically deformed first
[ schmid_orn ] shows the orientation dependent schmid factor of a face centered cubic ( fcc ) single crystal .
orientations near @xmath70 and @xmath71 have the largest schmid factor .
these orientations slip more easily and thus accumulate dislocations the fastest .
therefore , subsequent grain boundary motion will tend to remove such grains .
in the current study , an @xmath72 mpa uniaxial loading was applied in the x - direction in @xmath65 loading increments . at each step , the strain increment associated with each mpm particle is computed using the mpm algorithm , and the mcp algorithm is then called to partition elastic and plastic deformations .
the quasi - static state of the polycrystalline system is reached after a series of iterations when either the relative stress increment or relative strain increment meets the prescribed convergence criterion for all the particles @xcite .
after each mcp step , dislocation energy is computed and converted into the mc domain using our parametric links . the microstructure is subsequently evolved for one mc step , equal to @xmath63 minutes @xcite . figs .
[ texture_pla ] ( a ) and ( b ) describe the evolution of orientation distribution at five different time slices .
negative rotation angles are used to represent orientation from the @xmath73 to @xmath68 .
as expected , texture evolution favors grains which have smaller schmid factors with respect to the loading axis .
interestingly , orientations between @xmath74 and @xmath75 are not selected with the same frequency as orientations between @xmath67 and @xmath76 even though the two groups have identical schmid factors .
this is because the effective young s moduli of the former group elements are larger than that of their counterparts .
therefore less elastic , and thus more plastic strain , results from the same loading . to illustrate this principle more clearly
, pure mechanical simulations were performed in single crystals of various orientations .
[ orn_sgl ] ( a ) shows that more plastic deformation is obtained on the @xmath76 orientation than the other two orientations . fig .
[ orn_sgl ] ( b ) highlights the differences in the mechanical response between @xmath67 and @xmath75 orientations which have the same schmid factor .
as expected , more plastic deformation is observed in the @xmath75 orientation .
independent runs.,scaledwidth=60.0% ] to quantify the effect of texture evolution with plasticity , the texture histograms were fitted to a time dependent gaussian equation @xcite : @xmath77 , \label{text_evl}\ ] ] where @xmath78 is the orientation probability density , @xmath79 is the orientation angle , and @xmath80 is a time - dependent gaussian variance . the fitted results are shown as solid curves in fig .
[ fitted_texture ] ( a ) along with the gaussian variance described in fig .
[ fitted_texture ] ( b ) .
the effects of plastic deformation on texture evolution are quantified with a previously developed hybrid algorithm that blends a discrete , probabilistic algorithm for grain boundary motion with a continuum , deterministic model of elastic deformation .
plastic deformation is accounted for using a monte carlo plasticity model in which slip occurs through a sequence of probabilistically determined , single slip events .
mechanical loading results in an inhomogeneous distribution of dislocation energy which amounts to a plastic driving force for texture evolution . grains with less damage grow at the expense of those which have been more heavily deformed . in the current approach , the dislocation density associated with the area swept by a moving interface
is replaced with that of the overtaking grain .
this implies that , when a grain boundary moves , the dislocation content adjacent to the grain boundary is extended into the material through which the grain boundary migrates .
however , this is not always the case in reality . on the other hand , if one assume that no dislocations were transmitted with the boundary motion , then a new dislocation free grain would be introduced and the material would recrystallize @xcite . though recrystallization undoubtedly occurs , and is certainly important in the materials studied and at these levels of deformation , it is not the only option .
a grain boundary can simply migrate in a heavily deformed polycrystal @xcite .
the migration of a grain boundary in a deformed polycrystal involves the propagation of some , but not always all , of the dislocation content that are adjacent to it .
the authors are not aware of a meaningful quantitative description of how the dislocation structure propagates with a migrating grain boundary , and thus assume that nearly all the dislocations are carried with a boundary when it moves .
this hybrid computational methodology enables the temporal evolution of the microstructure under thermomechanical loading .
it offers an alternative to sharp - interface and phase - field modeling .
the resulting texture evolution maps are expected to be useful in materials and process design , thermomechanical fatigue as well as in part performance assessment throughout service life .
the current work was limited to a single angle of misorientation between grains .
an extension of this work to include fully arbitrary misorientation is underway , which will allow us to capture the influence of plastic deformation on the texture evolution of more realistic material systems .
the research is funded by sandia national laboratories .
sandia national laboratories are operated by the sandia corporation , a lockheed martin company , for the united states department of energy under contract de - ac04 - 94al85000 .
we also acknowledge the golden energy computing organization at the colorado school of mines for the use of resources acquired with financial assistance from the national science foundation and the national renewable energy laboratories .
10 f. roters , p. eisenlohr , l. hantcherli , d.d .
tjahjanto , t.r .
bieler , and d. raabe .
overview of constitutive laws , kinematics , homogenization and multiscale methods in crystal plasticity finite - element modeling : theory , experiments , applications .
, 58(4):1152 1211 , 2010 .
a. u. telang , t. r. bieler , a. zamiri , and f. pourboghrat .
incremental recrystallization / grain growth driven by elastic strain energy release in a thermomechanically fatigued lead - free solder joint .
, 55(7):2265 2277 , 2007 .
remi dingreville , corbett c. battaile , luke n. brewer , elizabeth a. holm , and brad l. boyce .
the effect of microstructural representation on simulations of microplastic ratcheting .
, 26(5):617 633 , 2010 . | a hybrid monte carlo ( hmc ) approach is employed to quantify the influence of inelastic deformation on the microstructural evolution of polycrystalline materials .
this approach couples a time explicit material point method ( mpm ) for deformation with a calibrated monte carlo model for grain boundary motion .
a rate - independent crystal plasticity model is implemented to account for localized plastic deformations in polycrystals .
the dislocation energy difference between grains provides an additional driving force for texture evolution .
this plastic driving force is then brought into a mc paradigm via parametric links between mc and sharp - interface ( si ) kinetic models .
the mc algorithm is implemented in a parallelized setting using a checkerboard updating scheme .
as expected , plastic loading favors texture evolution for grains which have a bigger schmid factor with respect to the loading direction , and these are the grains most easily removed by grain boundary motion .
a macroscopic equation is developed to predict such texture evolution .
* @xmath0 * monte carlo , grain boundary , plasticity , anisotropy , texture , driving force |
the goal of this note is to use a deformation technique to construct slope stable bundles and reflexive sheaves on an arbitrary ( projective ) calabi - yau threefold with prescribed chern classes within a certain range . for a projective algebraic surface @xmath0 ,
gieseker @xcite showed that if @xmath1 , then there exists a rank @xmath2 stable bundle @xmath3 over @xmath0 with @xmath4 and @xmath5 using deformation theory of sheaves , which was motivated from the differential geometric counterpart obtain by taubes @xcite . a similar result in the higher rank case
was proved by artamkin @xcite . now for threefolds
, we do nt have corresponding existence result in such a general formulation .
it is well - known that serre construction and monad construction are successful tools to construct vector bundles , especially on @xmath6 .
however , for a general calabi - yau threefold , little is known about the construction of stable bundles with prescribed chern classes . in 2006 ,
douglas , reinbacher and yau @xcite proposed the following conjecture ( abbreviated as dry - conjecture below ) concerning the existence of stable reflexive sheaves on calabi - yau threefolds . from now on , we restrict ourself to the case of @xmath7 .
( * ? ? ? * conjecture 1.1 ) let @xmath0 be a simply connected calabi - yau threefold .
let @xmath8 , i=2,3 , and @xmath9 be an integer .
suppose there is an ample class @xmath10 such that @xmath11 then there exists a rank @xmath12 stable reflexive sheaf @xmath13 on @xmath0 w.r.t .
some polarization and @xmath14 , @xmath15 and @xmath16 .
the main result in this note is theorem [ main ] in section @xmath2 .
it gives a sufficient condition on a curve @xmath17 in a calabi - yau threefold @xmath0 so that @xmath18 deforms to a stable reflexive sheaf . as an application , we get the following theorem
. let @xmath19 be a very ample divisor on a calabi - yau threefold @xmath0 .
then there exists a rank @xmath12 stable reflexive sheaf @xmath13 on @xmath0 with @xmath14 , @xmath20 $ ] and @xmath21 for @xmath22 .
note that we use @xmath23 $ ] to denote a curve class and its poincar dual cohomology class interchangeably . in general
, testing stability of a bundle or a sheaf is a difficult problem .
our approach is inspired by the idea of huybrechts @xcite , where he studied sufficient conditions that @xmath24 deforms to a stable bundle on a calabi - yau threefold @xmath0 .
the advantage of this approach , just as the one used by gieseker and artamkin , is that the constructed reflexive sheaf is stable with respect to _ all _ polarization of @xmath0 . to deduce theorem @xmath2
, we first use the fact that @xmath25 is very ample to choose a suitable representative curve in the class @xmath26\in h_2(x,\bz)$ ] with @xmath27 so that it fulfill the conditions in theorem @xmath28 .
then we get a rank @xmath2 stable reflexive sheaf with @xmath7 and @xmath29 $ ] .
finally we complete the proof by induction on the rank .
this paper is organized as follows . in section
@xmath28 we study the deformation of @xmath24 to a stable bundle on a calabi - yau threefold .
this question has other motivation and applications .
here we use it as a toy model for the later construction . in section
@xmath2 we generalize the method to construct stable reflexive sheaves .
although the approach is motivated from the result in section @xmath28 , this section is self - contained . finally in section @xmath30 we discuss briefly further research directions .
some applications to elliptic fibered calabi - yau will come up later .
b.w . would like to thank peng gao , xiaowei wang for helpful discussions .
this work was done when the authors were visiting the department of mathematics in national taiwan university , we would like to thank for the hospitality of the department during their visit .
in 1980 s , witten @xcite asked the following question : can one deform the bundle @xmath24 on a calabi - yau threefold to a stable bundle so that its restriction to any rational curve is nontrivial ? this is list as problem 77 in yau s problem list @xcite . due to the lack of knowledge about rational curves in calabi - yau threefolds ,
this problem is still open .
however , huybrechts @xcite made some progress for certain calabi - yau threefolds .
now if we consider only the first half of the question : can one deform the direct sum @xmath24 to a slope stable bundle ? then @xcite and @xcite gave satisfactory answers already .
we aim to generalize huybrechts result in the following formulation .
this also serves as a warm - up for the construction in the next section . for convenience , we shall work on the dual bundle @xmath31 instead of @xmath24 .
[ log ] let @xmath0 be a calabi - yau threefold with a smooth ample divisor @xmath25 .
suppose @xmath32 , and the natural map @xmath33 is nonzero , then there exists an extension @xmath34 so that @xmath3 is slope stable with respect to any polarization of @xmath0 .
furthermore , @xmath3 is a deformation of @xmath35 .
the strategy of the proof is as follows .
we construct a family of vector bundles @xmath13 over @xmath0 parametrized by @xmath36 , so that @xmath37 fits into the following non - splitting short exact sequences @xmath38 moreover , we demand that for each @xmath39 , @xmath40 fits into the following @xmath41 it follows from the assumption that @xmath40 has no global section .
we take a generic @xmath40 as the required @xmath3 . to check its stability
, we shall use the fact that semistability is an open property .
now we construct the family @xmath13 . by assumption , the map @xmath33 , or equivalently , @xmath42 is nonzero , we can find @xmath43 so that its image @xmath44 is not zero
. therefore we get vector bundles @xmath45 and @xmath37 , fitting into the following commutative diagram @xmath46 such that the horizontal sequences are non - splitting . here
the bottom sequence defines the required element @xmath47 in ( [ theta ] ) .
taking cokernel of the middle vertical map , we get @xmath48 to define @xmath13 , we construct another element @xmath49 @xmath50 and let @xmath40 be the sheaf defined by the extension @xmath51 . for this
, we apply @xmath52 to the standard sequence @xmath53 then we obtain the following maps @xmath54 note that @xmath55 is surjective , since @xmath56 by the ampleness of @xmath25 and kodaira vanishing theorem . for @xmath57 in ( [ comm1 ] ) , we let @xmath58 . then we obtain the following diagram @xmath59 taking cokernel of the middle vertical map , we get the required element @xmath60 in ( [ eta1 ] ) . since @xmath61 by the sequence @xmath47 in ( [ comm1 ] ) , and @xmath62 by the sequence @xmath63 in ( [ comm2 ] ) and the assumption , and both @xmath64 are nonzero , we know that @xmath65 and @xmath60 are linearly independent in @xmath66 , and therefore , they generate a 2-dimensional subspace @xmath67 .
the required family @xmath13 is defined as the family of vector bundles over @xmath0 parametrized by @xmath68 whose fiber @xmath40 is given by the sheaf ( which is locally free ) defined by the extension @xmath69 . finally , we show that @xmath40 is stable for @xmath39 . since @xmath37 is ( strictly )
semistable , and by @xcite semistability is an open property , we know that @xmath40 is semistable . if it is strictly semistable , then by @xmath70 and the stability of @xmath71 , we either have a nonzero homomorphism @xmath72 , or a nonzero homomorphism @xmath73 .
note that by the nonsplitting of the sequence @xmath47 in ( [ comm1 ] ) , we have @xmath74 .
it follows from upper semi - continuity that @xmath75 for generic @xmath39 . therefore , @xmath40 has no global section and nonzero homomorphism to @xmath76 .
hence it is stable .
simply take @xmath3 be such an @xmath40 , we get the required stable bundle . in the remainder of this section ,
we discuss the relation of proposition [ log ] with the results of huybrechts and give an example on quintic threefold .
this part will not be used later in this note , the readers who are interested in the construction of stable bundles and reflexive sheaves can skip to the next section .
we first make some remarks about this proof .
\(1 ) the proof works for singular ample divisor @xmath25 as well .
indeed , what we need in the proof is to find a nontrivial extension @xmath77 so that @xmath78 .
the role played by @xmath79 is replaced by that of @xmath80 .
\(2 ) the ampleness of @xmath25 is not essential in the proof .
all we need is @xmath81 which is equivalent to @xmath82 since @xmath0 is a calabi - yau threefold .
this implies that the proof works even for some non - projective ( nonkhler ) case as well . to compare with huybrechts results , recall that he @xcite gave the following sufficient conditions so that @xmath31 deforms to a stable bundle , in the case where @xmath83 is a calabi - yau manifold embedded as a hypersurface in @xmath84 : \(i ) @xmath85 , where @xmath86 is the normal bundle of @xmath0 .
\(ii ) the natural map @xmath87 is nonzero .
one can show that if a calabi - yau threefold satisfies huybrechts conditions ( i ) and ( ii ) , then it also satisfies the assumptions in proposition [ log ] , where we take @xmath25 as the zero divisor of a section of @xmath88 whose existence is guaranteed by condition ( ii ) .
we also provide an example ( corollary [ example ] below ) which is not covered by his method . in this sense , proposition [ log ] can be regarded as a generalization of his approach . before we proceed , we recall huybrechts idea .
he constructed two families of vector bundles @xmath13 and @xmath89 over @xmath0 parametrized by @xmath90 , so that @xmath91 for @xmath39 , and @xmath37 is a nontrivial extension of @xmath71 by @xmath76 , and @xmath92 is a nontrivial extension of @xmath76 by @xmath71 . by the openness of semi - stability , he proved that @xmath40 is stable for generic @xmath93 .
our approach is essential the same .
we have constructed the family @xmath13 in the proof .
now we construct another family @xmath89 so that @xmath92 fits into a nontrivial @xmath94 recall that the map @xmath95 in ( [ map ] ) is injective , the standard sequence @xmath96 defines a nonzero element in @xmath97 , its image under @xmath95 , say @xmath98 , is a nontrivial element in @xmath99 . in conclusion
, we have the following commutative diagram @xmath100 here the middle vertical sequence is the required element @xmath101 in ( [ theta2 ] ) .
note that we have obtained an element @xmath63 in ( [ comm2 ] ) .
similarly , we can show that @xmath98 and @xmath63 generate a 2-dimensional subspace @xmath102 .
we define @xmath89 be the family of vector bundles on @xmath0 parametrized by @xmath103 so that the fiber @xmath104 is the bundle obtain by the extension @xmath105 . it remains to show that @xmath91 for @xmath39 .
note that for @xmath106 , we have @xmath107 .
therefore we get @xmath108 applying @xmath109 to the short exact sequence given by @xmath57 in the top horizontal sequence above , we get @xmath110 for @xmath111 in ( [ gamma ] ) , let @xmath112 be the subset of elements @xmath113 with @xmath114 .
let @xmath115 be the subset of elements @xmath113 with @xmath116 .
notice that @xmath117 are 1-dimensional affine subspaces , and after projectivization , we have @xmath118 . from diagram ( [ comm3 ] ) , by composing the homomorphisms @xmath119 and @xmath120 , we see that there is a one - to - one affine map @xmath121 which send @xmath63 to @xmath60 .
it further implies that @xmath122 maps to @xmath123 for some @xmath124 .
therefore , possibly after relabeling the index , we have @xmath125 for @xmath39 . to conclude this section , we provide an example .
[ example ] let @xmath126 be a quintic threefold .
let @xmath127 be a hyperplane .
denote @xmath128 .
then we have @xmath32 , and the natural map @xmath129 is nonzero .
therefore @xmath31 deforms to a stable bundle @xmath3 fitting into the following @xmath130 first we show that @xmath32 .
consider the natural map @xmath131 the euler sequence on @xmath132 defines an element in @xmath133 .
then we obtain the following diagram @xmath134 it follows that @xmath135 , and @xmath136 . now from the following @xmath137 we obtain @xmath138 .
next we show that @xmath129 is not zero .
it is equivalent to the nonvanishing of @xmath139 .
we can find a bundle @xmath140 which fits into the following diagram @xmath141 then by @xmath142 for @xmath143 , it is equivalent to show that @xmath144 is nonzero .
now we obtain @xmath145 taking cohomology of the bundles , we get @xmath146 a dimension calculation shows that the left vertical map is nonzero
. hence we can apply proposition [ log ] to get the result .
in this section we shall construct stable reflexive sheaves on calabi - yau threefolds with some given chern classes .
recall that a sheaf @xmath13 on @xmath0 is reflexive if @xmath147 is a reflexive @xmath148-module for every @xmath149 ; and an @xmath150-module @xmath84 is reflexive if the canonical homomorphism @xmath151 is an isomorphism .
it is well - known that for a reflexive sheaf @xmath13 on a smooth variety @xmath0 , the singular locus @xmath152 has codimension at least @xmath30 in @xmath0 ; and every rank @xmath28 reflexive sheaf is invertible .
serre construction is a useful tool to construct rank @xmath2 vector bundles on threefolds .
hartshorne @xcite generalized this construction to reflexive sheaves on @xmath6 , and vermeire @xcite to an arbitrary projective threefold . in particular , for calabi - yau threefolds , we have the following ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 1)[hart ] let @xmath0 be a projective calabi - yau threefold .
let @xmath153 be an invertible sheaf with @xmath154 .
then there is a one - to - one correspondence between \(1 ) a rank @xmath2 reflexive sheaf @xmath89 on @xmath0 with @xmath155 , and a section @xmath156 whose zero locus has codimension @xmath2 , and \(2 ) a cohen - macaulay curve @xmath157 , generically locally complete intersection , and a global section @xmath158 which generates @xmath159 except at finitely many points , where @xmath160 .
recall that a curve is cohen - macaulay if it has equidimension one and has no embedded point .
this correspondence is straightforward . given a sheaf @xmath89 with a section @xmath156 , we have @xmath161 the cokernel of @xmath162 has the form @xmath163 because the zero locus of @xmath162 has codimension @xmath2 .
it defines an element in @xmath164 conversely , given a curve @xmath157 and a section @xmath165 as stated in ( 2 ) of proposition [ hart ] , it defines an element in @xmath166 via the above isomorphism , and hence an extension ( [ ext1 ] ) . using this correspondence , we generalize proposition [ log ] to obtain the following result .
[ main ] let @xmath157 be a cohen - macaulay curve in a calabi - yau threefold @xmath0 , generically locally complete intersection .
suppose @xmath19 is an ample divisor so that @xmath167 , and the scheme - theoretic intersection @xmath168 is zero dimensional which lies in the zero locus of a section of @xmath169 ; suppose further that there is a section in @xmath170 which generates @xmath171 except at finitely many points .
then @xmath18 deforms to a stable reflexive sheaf .
we follow the same idea in the proof of proposition [ log ] .
first we show that there is a nontrivial extension @xmath172 with @xmath173 .
note that @xmath89 plays the role of @xmath79 in proposition [ log ] .
consider the standard exact sequence @xmath174 by tensoring it with @xmath175 and the assumption that @xmath168 is zero dimensional , we obtain a short exact sequence @xmath176 where @xmath177 is a closed subscheme of @xmath25 with ideal sheaf @xmath178 on @xmath25 . by assumption , @xmath179
is contained in the zero locus of a section of @xmath169 , that is , we have an injective homomorphism @xmath180 .
now we pull back the sequence ( [ b1 ] ) via this homomorphism , and get @xmath181 where the top row is the required sequence ( [ a1 ] ) .
in addition , @xmath173 because @xmath89 is a subsheaf of @xmath182 and the assumption @xmath167 . next , since the intersection @xmath168 is zero dimensional , the natural homomorphism @xmath183 is injective . using serre duality
, we have isomorphisms @xmath184 by assumption , we have a section @xmath185 which generates @xmath171 except at finitely many points .
now we apply the strategy in the proof of proposition [ log ] .
the homomorphism @xmath186 in diagram ( [ comm111 ] ) gives a commutative diagram @xmath187 where the top row is given by @xmath185 and the bottom row by @xmath188 .
since @xmath189 generates @xmath190 except at finitely many points , by proposition [ hart ] , we know that @xmath37 is reflexive . on the other hand , since @xmath25 is ample , kodaira vanishing theorem implies that @xmath56 .
it follows that the natural homomorphism @xmath191 is surjective
. therefore we can find @xmath192 fitting into the following @xmath193 now consider the central columns of diagram ( [ comm10 ] ) and ( [ comm20 ] ) , we obtain two extensions @xmath194 we define a family of sheaves @xmath13 on @xmath0 parametrized by @xmath90 so that its fiber @xmath40 is a sheaf given by the extension @xmath195 . in addition , by ( [ comm20 ] ) , for @xmath39 , @xmath40 fits into an exact sequence @xmath196 finally , we show that @xmath40 is stable for generic @xmath197 . from (
* theorem 2.8 ) , semistability is an open property .
it follows that if @xmath40 is not stable , it must be strictly semistable and we have @xmath198 for some rank @xmath28 torsion free sheaves @xmath199 on @xmath0 with @xmath200 . since @xmath37 is reflexive , and being reflexive is also an open property ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 1.1.10 ) , @xmath40 is reflexive for all but finitely many @xmath201 .
so we can take double dual of the sequence ( [ des ] ) and hence assume without loss of generality that @xmath202 is invertible . by specializing @xmath93 to @xmath203 , we know that @xmath202 is a deformation of @xmath76 . since @xmath70
, @xmath76 has no nontrivial deformation .
it forces @xmath204 . on the other hand , since @xmath62 , the upper semi - continuity theorem implies that @xmath205 for all but finitely many @xmath201 .
then we have @xmath206 , which contradicts to @xmath204 .
this proves that @xmath40 , which is a deformation of @xmath18 , is a stable reflexive sheaf for generic @xmath93 . here
some remarks are in order .
\(1 ) the curve @xmath157 must have at least two connected components in order to fulfill the assumptions in the theorem .
\(2 ) the ampleness of @xmath25 is not essential .
as in the proof of proposition [ log ] , we only need @xmath207 , which is equivalent to @xmath82 since @xmath0 is a calabi - yau threefold .
\(3 ) from diagram ( [ comm11 ] ) , we know that @xmath208 is an ideal sheaf of a closed subscheme @xmath209 . therefore , from the bottom row of ( [ comm20 ] )
, the constructed stable reflexive sheaf @xmath13 fits into @xmath210 which is exactly the serre construction .
the following is a straightforward application of theorem [ main ] .
[ k3 ] let @xmath211 be a k3-fibered calabi - yau threefold .
for @xmath212 , let @xmath213 be cohen - macaulay curves with arithmetic genus @xmath214 in distinct fibers , generically locally complete intersection .
then there exists a rank @xmath2 stable reflexive sheaf @xmath13 on @xmath0 with @xmath14 and @xmath215 $ ] . to show this
, we simply apply theorem [ main ] to the curve @xmath216 , and take @xmath25 be a fiber of @xmath217 disjoint from the curves @xmath218 . here
@xmath25 is not ample .
however , since @xmath25 is a k3 surface , @xmath82 .
hence item ( 2 ) in the previous remark applies .
suppose every curves @xmath218 has arithmetic genus @xmath28 , then the obtained sheaf is locally free .
here is another example .
let @xmath219 be an elliptic fibered calabi - yau threefold .
let @xmath220 be the fiber class .
then there exists rank @xmath2 stable bundle @xmath13 on @xmath0 with @xmath14 , @xmath221 with @xmath27 .
in fact , this is exactly the pull - back of a stable bundle over @xmath222 with @xmath7 and @xmath223 ; one can also verify directly this pull - back bundle is stable .
suppose @xmath224 is a horizontal curve in @xmath0
. then one can construct stable reflexive sheaves on @xmath0 with @xmath7 and @xmath225 under some mild conditions .
however , the construction of a curve @xmath17 in the class @xmath226 fulfill the requirement in theorem [ main ] is technical and we shall not pursuit in this direction . in the remainder of this section
, we shall prove the main result of this paper which is an application of theorem [ main ] .
[ result ] let @xmath19 be a very ample divisor on a calabi - yau threefold @xmath0
. then there exists a rank @xmath227 stable reflexive sheaf @xmath13 on @xmath0 with @xmath14 , @xmath20 $ ] and @xmath21 for any @xmath22
. we shall prove it by induction on the rank @xmath12 .
first we consider rank @xmath2 case .
[ ini ] let @xmath19 be a very ample divisor on a calabi - yau threefold @xmath0 .
then there exists a rank @xmath2 stable reflexive sheaf @xmath13 on @xmath0 with @xmath14 , @xmath20 $ ] and @xmath21 for any @xmath27
. we shall apply theorem [ main ] to construct this sheaf .
it suffices to find a curve in the class @xmath26 $ ] so that it satisfies the assumptions in theorem [ main ] .
since @xmath25 is very ample , we can assume that it is effective and smooth by bertini s theorem .
we can also find another smooth divisor @xmath228 in @xmath229 so that they span a @xmath230 in the linear system @xmath229 .
let @xmath231 .
let @xmath232 be divisors representing different points in this @xmath230 , distinct from that of @xmath25 and @xmath233 .
then @xmath234 for all @xmath235 .
again since @xmath25 is very ample , the divisors @xmath234 are also very ample
. hence we can deform @xmath236 to irreducible curves @xmath237 so that @xmath238 are zero dimensional .
moreover , we can arrange these curve @xmath218 so that they are pairwise disjoint .
now let @xmath239 .
since @xmath27 , @xmath167 . moreover , the scheme - theoretic intersection @xmath168 is contained in @xmath236 , which is the zero locus of a section of @xmath169 .
using riemann - roch , we know that @xmath240 . hence there is a section of @xmath241 which generates @xmath241 generically .
now we can apply theorem [ main ] to the curve @xmath17 and the ample divisor @xmath25 to get a stable reflexive sheaf @xmath13 from a deformation of @xmath18 . by a straightforward calculation , @xmath242 .
we shall use the following generalization of theorem [ main ] to do the induction .
[ ind ] let @xmath89 be a stable sheaf on a calabi - yau threefold @xmath0 with @xmath243 and not reflexive .
let @xmath19 be an ample divisor .
suppose it satisfies the following conditions : \(1 ) there exists an extension @xmath244 with @xmath245 , and \(2 ) the natural homomorphism @xmath246 is nonzero , and its image contains an element corresponding to a reflexive sheaf .
then @xmath247 deforms to a stable reflexive sheaf @xmath13 fitting into @xmath248 the proof follows from that of theorem [ main ] , with the ideal sheaf @xmath249 replaced by @xmath89 here . we shall not repeat it . now we give the proof of theorem [ result ] .
we prove it by induction on the rank @xmath12 .
for @xmath250 , the result follows from proposition [ ini ] .
now suppose for an @xmath227 and every @xmath22 , we have constructed rank @xmath12 stable reflexive sheaves @xmath251 from a deformation of @xmath252 , so that @xmath253 and @xmath254 $ ] . furthermore , there exists an ample divisor @xmath255 in the linear system @xmath229 , so that @xmath251 fits into the following diagram @xmath256 with @xmath257 . in order to apply proposition [ ind ] to find a rank
@xmath258 stable reflexive sheaf , we need to construct a sheaf @xmath259 which fulfill the assumptions there . for this , we make the following induction assumptions : ( a1 ) we can find other divisors @xmath260 in @xmath229 , distinct from @xmath255 , so that they span a pencil that contains the divisor @xmath255 .
let @xmath236 be the intersection of these divisors .
the singular locus of @xmath261 is contained in the union @xmath239 with @xmath237 , which has the configuration type described in the proof of proposition [ ini ] .
the singular locus of @xmath262 is contained in @xmath263 .
( a2 ) for every other divisor @xmath264 in the pencil , and a curve @xmath265 which is disjoint from @xmath17 , we can find a surjective homomorphism @xmath266 . to get a picture of these assumptions , it is helpful to look at the case @xmath250 .
obviously , @xmath267 satisfies these assumptions ( c.f .
proof of proposotion [ ini ] ) , and @xmath268 with @xmath269 ( c.f . remark ( 3 ) after theorem [ main ] ) .
now we construct a rank @xmath12 stable sheaf @xmath259 with @xmath270 $ ] and satisfies the assumptions ( a1 ) and ( a2 ) .
we shall show that @xmath259 satisfies the conditions in proposition [ ind ] as well .
therefore @xmath271 deforms to a rank @xmath258 stable reflexive sheaf @xmath272 .
based on ( a2 ) , we can find a curve @xmath265 , linearly equivalent to @xmath236 in @xmath264 , and a surjective homomorphism @xmath266 .
accordingly , from diagram ( [ comm4 ] ) , we can find a surjective homomorphism @xmath273 . for @xmath250 ,
this is given by @xmath274 , which is obvious since the restriction @xmath275 is the direct sum of @xmath276 and torsion part .
it induces a surjective homomorphism @xmath277 .
define @xmath278 evidently , @xmath279 , @xmath280 $ ] , and @xmath259 is not reflexive .
moreover , @xmath259 is stable because @xmath251 is stable .
it is clear that @xmath259 satisfies the induction assumptions ( a1 ) and ( a2 ) .
accordingly , we denote @xmath281 ( resp .
@xmath282 , @xmath283 ) be the kernel of @xmath284 ( resp .
@xmath273 , @xmath285 )
. then we obtain the following @xmath286 now we verify condition ( 1 ) in proposition [ ind ] . notice that we can find ( infinitely many ) divisor @xmath287 , linearly equivalent to @xmath25 , so that there is an exact sequence @xmath288 with @xmath289 . by pushing forward this sequence via the injective homomorphism @xmath290
, we obtain a sheaf @xmath291 fitting into @xmath292 let @xmath293 be the induce homomorphism from the left column .
choose @xmath287 so that the composition of @xmath119 with @xmath294 is nonzero , hence injective .
it implies that by the middle column , we have @xmath295 .
then consider the middle row in ( [ comm5 ] ) , @xmath296 applying @xmath297 , since @xmath25 is ample , @xmath298 by kodaira vanishing theorem .
we obtain a surjective homomorphism @xmath299 notice that the central row in ( [ comm6 ] ) is an element in @xmath300 , by the surjectivity of ( [ surj ] ) , we can find @xmath301 fitting into @xmath302 from the middle column , we get @xmath303 .
hence the middle row in ( [ comm7 ] ) is the required extension which satisfies condition ( 1 ) in proposition [ ind ] .
we denote @xmath304 . for condition
( 2 ) in proposition [ ind ] , we consider the sequence @xmath305 applying @xmath306 and @xmath307 , we get the following @xmath308 where @xmath309 and @xmath310 are injective maps . first we claim that every nonreflexive extension in @xmath311 lies in the image of @xmath310 . indeed , for any extension @xmath312 so that @xmath313 is not reflexive . taking double dual ,
we have @xmath314 we want to show that @xmath315 is surjective . if not , let @xmath316 be its image
. then @xmath317 since @xmath313 is not reflexive .
on the other hand , by the inclusion @xmath318 , and @xmath319 , we know that @xmath320 is a quotient of @xmath276
. then we get @xmath321 where @xmath322 is a nonzero sheaf support at points . applying @xmath307
, we get @xmath323 the surjectivity of the first map implies that we can find a sheaf @xmath324 fitting into @xmath325 this is not possible .
since @xmath326 is a reflexive sheaf on a smooth threefold , it admits a two term locally free resolution .
therefore @xmath327 , it implies that @xmath328 , which contradicts to the middle row .
therefore @xmath315 is surjective , and every nonreflexive extension in @xmath311 lies in the image of @xmath310 which proves the claim .
next we show that @xmath309 in ( [ comm38 ] ) is not surjective .
using diagram ( [ comm4 ] ) , we obtain @xmath329 and using ( [ comm5 ] ) , we get @xmath330 by the sequence @xmath331 we have @xmath332 by induction , we know that @xmath333 combined with ( [ dim1 ] ) and ( [ dim2 ] ) , we get @xmath334 hence @xmath309 is not surjective .
to verify condition ( 2 ) in proposition [ ind ] , note that @xmath335 does not contained in @xmath336 , it implies that @xmath220 in ( [ comm38 ] ) is injective .
therefore , we can find @xmath337 which is not in the image of @xmath309 . since @xmath220 is injective , @xmath338 is nonzero .
it follows that @xmath339 is nonzero as well .
since @xmath339 does not contained in the image of @xmath310 , we know that it corresponds to a reflexive sheaf . finally , applying proposition [ ind ] to the nonreflexive sheaf @xmath259 , we obtain a stable reflexive sheaf of rank @xmath258 from the deformation of @xmath340 .
for calabi - yau threefolds of picard number @xmath28 , it is relatively easier to verify directly the stability of a bundle .
however , for general case , there is no standard procedure to check stability .
this is the reason the deformation argument plays a key role .
as we already mentioned , the main theorem of this paper is an application of the technical result theorem [ main ] . for special calabi - yau threefolds ,
e.g. elliptic fibered or branched covering of fano threefolds , one may use theorem [ main ] to construct stable bundles or reflexive sheaves with other given chern classes , as we briefly did in corollary [ k3 ] and the discussion afterwards .
it is also interesting to compare the result with the spectral cover construction for elliptic calabi - yau @xcite , and results obtained by elementary transformation @xcite . for rank @xmath341 , maeda (
* theorem 2.5 ) showed that one can construct vector bundles of rank @xmath12 using a generalized serre construction .
we expect one can combine his construction with theorem [ main ] in this note to get some refined results on the existence of stable bundles instead of reflexive sheaves . in theorem
[ result ] , applying deformation of the representative curve in the class @xmath26 $ ] , one may get curves of lower arithmetic genus and therefore obtain reflexive sheaves with lower values of @xmath342 .
the existence of such deformation depends on the configuration of the curve and the calabi - yau threefold .
we hope to come back to these questions in future research .
shing - tung yau .
open problems in geometry . in _ differential
geometry : partial differential equations on manifolds ( los angeles , ca , 1990 ) _ , volume 54 of _ proc .
pure math .
_ , pages 128 .
soc . , providence , ri , 1993 . | we use serre construction and deformation to construct stable bundles and reflexive sheaves on calabi - yau threefolds . |
the small magellanic cloud ( smc ) is an excellent test - bed for studying star formation in a low - metallicity environment .
its low metallicity ( @xmath0 0.2 z@xmath1 determined from numerous elemental abundances ; * ? ? ? * ) and strong interstellar radiation field ( isrf ; 4 - 10 g@xmath5 , * ? ? ?
* ) make it an important contrasting environment to star forming environments in the milky way or the large magellanic cloud ( lmc ) .
the smc is also a good comparative theater to studies of ` passive ' star formation in blue compact dwarf galaxies ( bcds ; see * ? ? ?
* for the distinction between active and passive ) , because their star - forming regions have similar densities ( @xmath0 100 @xmath6 ) , star formation rates ( @xmath0 0.1 m@xmath1 yr@xmath7 ) , radiation field hardnesses , and the smc is the lowest - metallicity nearby star - forming region @xcite .
n66 @xcite is the largest hii region in the smc , covering an area on the sky of approximately 180@xmath8 300 , and therefore offers the best view of large - scale star formation in the smc .
it surrounds a large stellar association known as ngc 346 .
n66 contains 33 o stars distributed across the hii region , which is about half the number for the entire smc , and 11 of them are earlier than type o7 @xcite .
the most massive star is of o3iii(f * ) ( @xmath0 100 m@xmath1 ) or o3vf * ( @xmath0 90 m@xmath1 ) type @xcite .
the o stars illuminate the surrounding ism and are responsible for an h@xmath9 luminosity of about 60 times that of the orion nebula @xcite .
uv and optical spectra have been used to derive an age of about 3 myr for the o stars in n66 and a metallicity of 0.2 z@xmath1 ( the metallicity has been determined independently for individual o stars , forbidden line emission originating in the gas , and spectral models ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
n66 is experiencing ongoing star formation .
@xcite identified about 100 embedded ysos with _
irac and mips photometry , and @xcite found a further 263 candidate young stellar sources including intermediate mass pre - main sequence and herbig aebe stars , as well as massive yso candidates .
the first mid - ir study of n66 , with isocam , showed strong nebular [ siv ] 10.51 and [ neiii ] 15.56 emission across the region that is indicative of young and massive ( o- and b - type ) stars , the presence of faint polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon ( pah ) emission bands , a mid - infrared continuum from very small grain ( vsgs ) and large thermal dust grain emission , and an isrf at 1600 @xmath10 times that of solar @xcite .
a companion paper to @xcite , @xcite , included [ o iii ] @xmath115007 , h@xmath12 v(1 - 0 ) s(1 ) 2.12 , and co observations to show that the peaks in h@xmath13 , co , and pah emission are all spatially correlated across the photodissociation regions ( pdrs ) in general , and further suggested that the co has been largely photodissociated across the hii region by the o star population , and exists only in small clumps .
@xcite included n66 as part of a study of pahs in hii regions across the smc , and determined that the pah population is both smaller and less ionized than in higher - metallicity galaxies . in two comparison studies ,
the atomic / ionic gas content and the effects of metallicity on pah emission were studied for n66 , 30 doradus in the lmc , and ngc 3603 in the milky way @xcite .
the elemental abundances were determined for each region using the ionic forbidden lines from mid - infrared spectra ; for n66 , the results confirmed that the metallicity is about 0.2 z@xmath1 .
it was discovered that the pahs are photodestroyed in radiation fields where nebular [ neiii]/[neii ] @xmath14 3 , and that this photodestruction law is independent of metallicity .
what is still unclear about n66 is where the pah emission originates , and what conditions are traced by the pah emission .
in particular , pah ionization state , which is a function of the ultraviolet ( uv ) radiation field , is also equally sensitive to electron density ( charge state z @xmath15 g@xmath5t@xmath16/n@xmath17 ; * ? ? ?
* ) , and there are cases evident in the literature that suggest that neutral pahs have the ability to exist inside hii regions ( e.g. in the vicinity of the horsehead nebula : * ? ? ?
the reason that star formation is often traced by emission from pahs @xcite is that , while pahs are sensitive to excitation from a broad range of wavelengths ( uv - ir ) , they are particularly susceptible to excitation by uv photons . pah emission is commonly observed in the pdrs around young massive clusters @xcite .
these spectral features are predominantly present from 3 - 17
. the molecules responsible for this emission are typically dozens to thousands of carbon atoms large .
following photoexcitation , they emit by fluorescence from stretching and bending modes either from the carbon - to - hydrogen ( c - h ) or carbon - to - carbon ( c - c ) bonds . due to the stochastic excitation and emission mechanism as well as the ionization balance of pahs ,
the local physical conditions have a large impact on the observed pah band ratios via radiation field hardness , column density , dust temperature , and dust composition @xcite . due to the relatively low ionization potentials of pahs ( about 6 - 8 ev for small pahs ; * ? ? ?
* table @xmath18 ) , pdrs are expected to be dominated by ionized pahs whereas regions with weaker radiation fields , such as the diffuse ism in the milky way or inside molecular clouds , should have largely neutral or negatively - charged pahs @xcite . in order to study the mid - infrared properties of n66 in greater detail with particular emphasis on the pah emission as an independent tracer of the physical conditions across the region , we present _ spitzer space
telescope_/irs spectra of a number of infrared point sources and use the spectral information along the entire irs long slits to study the dust and gas emission throughout the hii region and photodissociation region ( pdr ) .
we present the observations in section [ observations ] , describe our data reduction in section [ datareduction ] , present our analysis in section [ analysis ] , and summarize the results in section [ conclusion ] .
n66 ( figure [ threecolor ] ) was observed as part of the irs gto program to study massive star formation in giant hii regions in the local group ( pid 63 ) .
imaging using _
spitzer_/irac @xcite of the whole region revealed a number of bright point sources , the brightest eight of which were chosen for spectroscopic follow - up with the low- and high - resolution modules of the _ spitzer _ infrared spectrograph ( irs ; * ? ? ? * ) .
the present study concentrates on the short - wavelength low - resolution spectra only ( @xmath11 @xmath19 14.7 ) ; the high - resolution _
spectra have been analysed in @xcite to determine element abundances and to constrain the strength of the interstellar radiation field ( isrf ) using forbidden emission lines , and the long - wavelngth low - resolution data ( 15 @xmath19 @xmath11 @xmath19 37 ) have not been included due to the spatial resolution and slit orientation mismatch .
this dataset is therefore in contrast to that presented in @xcite , in which long- and short - wavelength spectral maps are used to analyze n66 .
while they analyzed full spectral maps of the entire region , the data we present here is deeper and allows us to study the faint extended emission around the point sources at a level of detail that the full maps did not allow .
the pointings for the original eight positions ( astronomy observing request 4385024 ) were systematically offset by about 5 with respect to the actual source positions . as a result , most of the intended point sources were partially or wholly outside of the 3.6-wide slit .
however , there is at least one point source in each of these slits regardless , though they are not always the intended ones . in order to target the intended point sources , n66 was re - observed with correct astrometry ( aor 16207872 ) .
the point sources detected in the original and re - observed samples are shown in figure [ psposns ] along with the slit orientations .
see table [ targets ] for a full list of the point source ( ps ) positions , labeled in order of decreasing right ascension , and table [ slitcentroids ] for a list of slit centroids . ] and [ slitcentroids ] for coordinate information.[psposns],title="fig : " ] and [ slitcentroids ] for coordinate information.[psposns],title="fig : " ] three exposures were taken at each nod position in staring mode ( see the _
spitzer / irs _ manual ) , where the source is positioned at 1/3 ( nod1 ) and 2/3 ( nod2 ) of the slit length .
the original observations had 60-second exposure times , whereas the re - observed sample have 15-second exposure times .
the low - resolution spectra ( @xmath20 @xmath0 65 - 130 ) cover the spectral range 5.2 - 14.7 using the short - low ( sl ) module .
the sl-1 slit covers the spectral range 7.4 - 14.7 and the sl-2 slit covers the spectral range 5.2 - 7.7 .
the sizes of the two slits ( 3.7 @xmath8 57 and 3.6 @xmath8 57 respectively ) correspond to a physical size of 1.1 @xmath8 16.7 pc at the distance of n66 ( we adopt a value of 60.6 kpc from * ? ? ? * ) .
therefore the point sources , with a fwhm at 6 of 4 pixels out of 34 , are resolved down to about 2 pc along the slit .
the _ spitzer / irs _ images were processed with the _ spitzer science center ( ssc ) _ pipeline , version s18.7 .
the basic calibrated data ( bcd ) were used .
images were cleaned by interpolating values over flagged bad pixels using the _ ssc_-provided idl package irsclean ] . after cleaning ,
the observed sky positions were subtracted from the other positions in their respective aors to remove any intervening flux from zodiacal light , the milky way , and foreground smc .
since the sky positions are relatively far from n66 , we may assume that emission in the sky spectra is primarily from the diffuse smc and not from n66 .
the spectra of these sky positions exhibit [ siv ] emission but no dust features .
the strength of the sky position s [ siv ] emission is 7.9 @xmath8 10@xmath21 w @xmath22 , which is almost 50% the value for the lowest [ siv ] flux found in the extended emission spectra ( see [ srcext ] ) , and less than 20% of the flux for the rest of the spectra . using the optimal extraction routines available in the _ spectroscopy modeling analysis and reduction tool _
( smart - adopt ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , point source and extended emission can be simultaneously extracted .
smart s optimal extraction routines fit a polynomial function to the extended emission as well as template supersampled point spread functions ( psfs ) to point sources in the slit , as shown in figure [ optext_fit ] .
the backgrounds are relatively smooth for these spectra , and polynomials of four orders and less were used .
details , including how to fit partially extended point sources and measuring the residuals , are presented in @xcite .
however , the fundamental operation demands that for each wavelength element , the relative weights to the total flux assigned to the point source(s ) and background are measured simultaneously .
therefore , the flux is distributed to each component in a way that agrees with the combination of point source(s ) and polynomially - fitted background . the advantage of simultaneous point source and extended emission extraction compared to more traditional
, variable column extractions is illustrated in figure [ optext_comp ] .
two point sources have been extracted using two different methods as an example .
the source in the left - hand plot is a massive embedded young stellar object ( yso ) , ps7 , and the right - hand plot shows the spectrum of the unresolved dust emission associated with the young star cluster ngc 346 , ps9 .
the ` column extraction ' extracts all of the emission inside a column that varies in width with the psf .
the ` optimal extraction ' uses the smart - adopt routines .
there are significant differences revealed by the optimal extraction method .
for example , the [ s iv ] 10.51 emission line , which is often prominent in hii regions , is not associated with the point source spectra ; the reason it appears in the column extraction is because it is nebular emission along the line - of - sight to the point source .
in fact , we would get the wrong diagnostic with a variable column extraction , since the nebular [ siv ] would be erroneously assigned to the point source .
the [ neii ] 12.81 emission line is also nebular in nature for the massive embedded yso ( left - hand plot ) .
in addition to the nebular forbidden atomic lines , a certain amount of the dust continuum is also missing from the optimally extracted spectra , meaning that it is also nebular in nature . by separating out the point source from the line - of - sight nebular emission , we have separate views of emission that is associated with the unresolved point sources in n66 and emission that originates in the diffuse h ii region and pdr . ]
10.51 emission , a portion of the [ ne ii ] 12.81 emission , and some dust continuum emission is not associated with these point source spectra , but is nebular in nature .
this nebular emission is shown in the `` difference '' spectra in the bottom panels.[optext_comp ] ] optimal extraction of all of the pointings was performed , producing point source and extended emission spectra from the full slit length for each pointing .
two of the re - observed pointings have extended emission spectra that were dominated by noise and are not used in the analysis .
observations where the point source lies partially outside of the slit in the dispersion direction were extracted with a special tool developed for and included in smart - adopt . applying the centered psf template to an observation with incorrect
pointing makes the spectral shape incorrect , but accounting for the pointing error allows a properly - shaped psf to be fit to the point source so that regular optimal extraction and accurate flux calibration can be done . for details on the source extraction for sources offset in the dispersion direction ,
see @xcite .
the reduced spectra are shown in appendix 1 at the end of this paper .
typical mid - infrared spectra of hii regions and their surrounding pdrs have the following features : a dust continuum , several prominent pah features , molecular hydrogen emission lines , atomic and ionic emission lines , and absorption or emission features due to small silicaceous grains centered at 9.8 and 17 . in order to study the dust and gas diagnostics in n66 , all of the spectra were decomposed into these components .
we used the specral decomposition tool pahfit @xcite .
pahfit models the dust continuum that underlies the pah features with as many as eight blackbody continua at fixed temperatures less than 300 k , fits the silicate absorption features at 9.8 and 17 , and models the pah features with asymmetric drude profiles . in order to fit the spectra for n66 with pahfit
, a couple of small changes were made . in some cases , the input full - width at half maxima ( fwhm ) of the 6.2 and 11.3 features needed to be changed in order to fit the features more precisely ( see [ pahprofiles ] below for a discussion about the 11.3 pah feature profiles ) .
second , for sources that exhibit a silicate emission feature , two additional drude profiles were added to model the 9.8 silicate emission feature : these drude profiles , centered at 9.2 and 10.0 , have fwhm of 0.3 and 0.2 respectively . for spectra with silicate emission features included , pahfit did _ not _ also fit silicate absorption features . due to the presence of hydrogen recombination lines in some of the spectra
, we include the hi 6 - 5 7.46 line to pahfit s line list .
example point source and extended emission pahfit fits are shown in the top panels of figure [ decompcomp ] , where the plotting scheme is explained in the caption .
one major difference in the fits between the point source and extended emission spectra is that the silicate absorption feature is only fit to those point source spectra that do not explicitly require a silicate emission feature , and none of the extended emission features exhibit silicate absorption in the final fits .
there is some concern that pah fitting routines like pahfit may be introducing errors inadvertently into the pah fluxes .
when applying pahfit , the underlying pah `` plateaux '' are incorporated into the wings of the drude profiles used to fit the pah bands , in particular for the 7.7 band .
peeters et al .
( 2013 , in preparation ) has found that the spatial morphology of the plateau is quite distinct from that of the 6.2 , 7.7 , and 8.6 pah bands in data of the reflection nebula ngc 2023 . to see
if the pah plateaux in the n66 spectra is also decoupled from the pah features , we have fit a spline to the underlying continuum and measured the pah features above the continuum , as in @xcite .
we have determined that , although the exact values for the pah band fluxes differ depending on the decomposition method used , the trends discussed in detail in [ pahratios ] hold regardless .
the spectral decomposition method illustrated in figure [ decompcomp ] is a reliable method for comparing pah band fluxes .
, title="fig : " ] , title="fig : " ] due to concerns about error propagation from extraction to decomposition , the errors of the pah feature strengths were determined with a monte carlo method .
the root mean square error in the continuum near 6 was measured for each spectrum and then used to randomly perturb the spectrum .
6 was chosen because the noise is systematically higher at the shortest wavelengths in the sl spectrum , due to the lower signal in these sources at this wavelength .
the noise is , on average , two times greater at 6 than it is at 14 , measured as the standard deviation of the root mean square of the difference of the unperturbed spectrum and the best fit pahfit model .
the spectrum , including the random noise , was then fit with pahfit and the resultant strengths of the pah features were recorded .
this was done 300 times , after which the standard deviation of the pah feature strength measurements was taken as the statistical error in the 300 fitted feature strengths .
while pahfit also fits any number of user - requested atomic , ionic , and molecular features in addition to the dust continuum and pah features , we fit the narrow lines manually with the idea tool in smart .
the reason for this additional step is that pahfit functions first and foremost as a fitting tool , and will therefore include all of the parameters it is given into the final solution .
this means that in the point source spectra , for instance , pahfit will generally give the [ siv ] 10.51 line a flux even when it is clear from a visual inspection that this line is not detected .
therefore , in order to systematically determine narrow line fluxes and upper limits , we chose to use a manual tool for line fits .
we used a first - order local continuum subtraction to estimate continuum flux beneath the narrow features .
the [ neii ] 12.81 feature is blended with a pah feature and the line flux may therefore contain some pah emission ; due to the presence of pahs in all spectra , we believe that any offset due to this contamination is largely systematic but may contribute substantially to the point source spectra ps12 , ps13 , and ps14 , which exhibit much lower [ neii ] fluxes than the other spectra .
the continuum at 13.7 - 14.2 contains two prominent pah features that , when compared to the pahfit dust continuum and pah feature fits , systematically contributed roughly twenty per - cent to the continuum at these wavelengths ; the continuum was therefore measured as the average in the pahfit dust continuum beneath the pah features .
the final atomic , ionic , pah , and continuum measurements along with their errors are given in tables [ lines ] & [ pahs ] .
we carried out a literature search in order to identify known objects associated with the infrared point source centroids .
table [ targets ] lists the targeted point sources from this study , corresponding labels from @xcite and @xcite , and additional information from the literature .
all point sources are identified as sites of recent or ongoing star formation , and are typically young protostars or young stellar clusters . a number of the point sources exhibit interesting spectral features that are worth a closer look .
we describe these point sources in detail below .
unresolved emission from two bright star clusters in n66 exhibit silicate emission features in their spectra : ngc 346 ( ps9 ) and n66b ( ps6 ) ; see figure [ starclusters ] .
both of these point sources are bright h@xmath9 sources @xcite , contain ` blue ' stars @xcite , and have been modeled as @xmath0 3 myr old with _ hubble _ color - magnitude diagrams @xcite .
this age is consistent with the presence of remnant dust from the natal cloud surrounding the cluster . ) .
both show pronounced silicate emission features . [ starclusters ] ] the origin of the silicate emission is most likely an optically thin layer of intracluster and/or enveloping dust that has been heated to @xmath0 200 k by the stars in the central clusters .
the presence of silicate emission suggests a relatively low optical depth ; this is supported by optical data of n66 ( see , for example , the high - resolution _
hubble _ data presented in * ? ? ?
* ) , where the stars in the centers of the clusters are clearly visible through the intervening dust , and supported by the measured extinction by dust @xcite .
this geometry is similar to clumpy model geometries for young star clusters presented in @xcite , where silicate emission / absorption was found to be dependent on the line - of - sight dust geometry .
neither cluster is resolved in the spectral slit , and we therefore did not employ the irs ll module ( 15 @xmath19 @xmath11 @xmath19 37 ) to measure the 17 silicate emission as in @xcite and @xcite because the flux mis - match between the sl and ll _ spitzer_/irs modules is very substantial and would bias the silicate dust temperature measurement .
the presence of an o5.5v star in n66b and an o9v star in ngc 346 means that the point source extractions show a little [ s iv ] emission in n66b , none in ngc 346 , and [ neii ] emission in both .
the [ siv ] emission in n66b is likely due to the o5.5v star .
see @xcite , figure 7 for a map of the positions of the known o stars across n66 , many of which appear off of the stellar cluster positions .
silicates in emission associated with young star clusters have not been observed regularly before . in ngc 3603 ,
pointings on and near the central star cluster show silicate emission @xcite .
there is one pointing in 30 doradus in the lmc ( source b ; * ? ? ?
* and also found in lebouteiller et al@xmath23 2008 ) near r136 that exhibits silicate emission , but this source has been spectroscopically identified as an m - type supergiant star @xcite . while there are numerous detections of silicates in emission among protoplanetary systems ( @xmath24 * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) and evolved stars such as asymptotic giant branch stars ( agbs , both galactically and extragalactically ; see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , there are relatively few young stellar clusters that show silicate emission .
@xcite show that a diffuse silicate population is likely across the orion nebula .
compared with those observations , the silicate emission observed in ngc 3603 , ngc 346 , and n66b is distinct in that it is clearly associated with the stellar clusters and not visibly dispersed across the region .
it seems likely that the strong silicate emission associated with the star clusters in n66 and ngc 3603 is tied to a relatively short period of time in the early evolution of star clusters and will only last a short period of time ; that these clusters are definitively young ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) and therefore contain no agb stars excludes the possibility of silicate - rich winds from post - main sequence stars contributing to the observed silicate emission .
there is a third spectrum exhibiting a silicate emission feature : ps8 . in this instance , the silicate feature is not as pronounced as for the star clusters discussed above , though it has pronounced pah features as well ( see figure [ spec1 ] in the appendix )
. searching by position , we found a be star at those coordinates , cl * ngc 346 kwbbe 200 .
@xcite fit a uv - to-8 spectral energy distribution ( sed ) with a b - star template and a t @xmath0 800 k blackbody , observed p cygni profiles on a number of optical spectral lines , roughly determined a luminosity of 10@xmath25 l@xmath1 , and concluded that this source is a b[e ] supergiant .
evidence against it being a herbig be system is that no inverse p cygni profiles associated with infall were observed , and that the derived luminosity is on the high end for herbig be stars .
we note , however , that silicate emission and strong pah bands are often detected in herbig aebe star systems ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , where cooler dust and pahs are expected due to its young age . additionally , ps8 exhibits a class a pah spectrum as shown in figure [ pah7786 ] and discussed in
[ pahprofiles ] , which is typical for non - isolated herbig aebe stars @xcite , and is a 24 source as observed by _
spitzer_/mips @xcite , suggesting that there is cold dust that @xcite s sed fit did not account for .
while the absence of inverse p cygni profiles offers a conundrum , the evidence from the mid - ir suggests that kwbbe 200 is , in fact , a herbig aebe star , not a b[e ] supergiant . the single brightest mid - ir point source in n66 , ps7 , lying at the location of the hii region n66a @xcite , was found to be a 16.6 m@xmath1 class i young stellar object ( yso ) by @xcite using _
spitzer / irac _ and _ mips _ photometry matched to models of class i protostars presented in @xcite .
shown in figure [ ysospec ] , the spectrum has a deep silicate feature at 9.8 which corresponds to high optical depth and therefore supports the class i designation .
furthermore , the presence of h@xmath13o ice in the 6 - 7.5 range and a co@xmath13 ice feature at 15 in the high - resolution _ spitzer _ spectrum of n66a suggests cold , dense conditions similar to other massive class i yso environments ( @xmath24 * ? ? ?
lastly , there is no [ siv ] or [ neii ] detected , suggesting that the central heating source does not have a strong uv continuum .
these spectroscopic signatures all confirm @xcite s original designation .
ice at 15 , and a strong mid - infrared continuum .
the nebular lines seen in the high - resolution spectrum come from intervening diffuse material .
[ ysospec ] ] to confirm the yso mass , we fit _ spitzer_/irs data ( wavelength coverage from 5 to 35 ) with the @xcite models . for these fits of an embedded protostar , stellar temperature ( and mass ) ,
disk / envelope mass and inner / outer radii are all fit , though for embedded sources disk masses are known to be ill - constrained .
the best fit to our data was a 17.8 m@xmath1 yso embedded in an envelope of about 10@xmath26 m@xmath1 .
the circumstellar extinction is calculated to be a@xmath27 = 25.7 , and the interstellar extinction is a@xmath27 = 0.1 . for comparison ,
@xmath28=1.88 from the pahfit parameter fit to this source , which is consistent with the circumstellar extinction @xcite .
the total luminosity of this model is 3.47 @xmath8 10@xmath29 l@xmath30 .
this result differs from the fit presented in @xcite by a @xmath0 7% increase in mass and @xmath0 15% increase in luminosity .
@xcite studied the _
data for the hii region n66a in great detail and determined that it is supported by an o8 star . while the massive yso discussed in this section
dominates the infrared emission , the fine structure emission in the extended emission spectrum is due to the young o- and b - star population in n66a , while the diffuse dust emission probably comes from the pdr at the interface to the molecular cloud in which the massive yso is buried .
there are in fact two ysos at ps9 s centroid in the @xcite atlas ; the more massive yso studied here dominates the infrared luminosity substantially : there is a factor of about 19 ratio between the luminosities of the two ysos . at the sensitivity of these data ,
the massive yso is the only point source detected .
ionic emission lines in an hii region can help quantify the strength and hardness of the radiation ( see * ? ? ?
* ) but may also be used to shed light on the physical characteristics of the point sources and diffuse emission across the region . in general , the point source spectra are all associated with sites of active star formation . by contrast , the extended emission spectra trace the h ii and pdr emission that is photoexcited by the massive stellar population dispersed across the region . for this dataset , we find two distinguishing features in the ionic line emission that are specially worth noting .
\(1 ) [ siv ] 10.51 emission is largely undetected among the point source spectra but is detected in all of the extended emission spectra .
\(2 ) [ neii ] 12.81 is detected in every point source and extended emission spectrum with only two exceptions among the point source spectra .
the strong [ siv ] line , due to ionization of the interstellar gas by the o star population , is seen in the extended emission spectra across the region ( see figures [ spec3 ] and [ spec4 ] ) .
[ s iv ] and [ neii ] are often found in sites of active star formation , e.g. giant hii regions @xcite , blue compact dwarf galaxies ( bcds ; * ? ? ?
* ) , and starburst galaxies @xcite .
our analysis differs from previous works by separating the diffuse emission from the infrared point source emission .
we show that the dense regions embedded in the pdr do not generally show [ siv ] emission .
the absence of [ s iv ] in most of the point source sample is likely because the heating sources at the point source locations are not hard enough to triply - ionize sulfur .
the gas density at these positions can be estimated from the [ siii ] 18.71 and 33.48 lines fluxes from high - resolution _
spitzer _ data at the point source positions published in @xcite .
the ratio of these two lines ranges from 0.43 - 2.7 , suggesting densities of n@xmath17t@xmath31 @xmath19 3 @xmath8 10@xmath32 @xmath6 for the lowest value ratio and below about 10@xmath33 @xmath6 for most of the positions ,
well less than the critical densities of @xmath34([siv])@xmath35 10@xmath36 @xmath6 @xmath34([neii])@xmath37 10@xmath38 @xmath6 .
it should be noted that these estimates for the [ siii]-derived gas density are subject to the diffuse as well as the dense material at these positions because the point source emission can not be treated separately from the diffuse emission in the high - resolution modules as it can for the low - resolution modules . in order to classify the pah spectra observed in n66 , we plot example high signal - to - noise ( s / n ) n66 pah spectra versus templates in the 7 - 9 range and 11 - 12 range from @xcite and @xcite respectively in figures [ pah7786 ] and [ pah11hi ] .
@xcite was able to classify the 6 - 9 pah features based on their peak centroids , and discovered that there is a relationship with environment : class a spectra are typical for hii regions and non - isolated herbig aebe stars , class b spectra are more typical for isolated herbig aebe stars , and class c spectra are more common in evolved stellar systems .
@xcite studied the 11.3 pah complex and developed templates for classes a and b only .
the n66 spectra for the 7.7 and 8.6 features ( figure [ pah7786 ] ) are generally most similar to the class a template , as is expected for an hii region .
however , in some of the spectra , the 7.7 features appear to be wider than the templates . for the 11.3 pahs , the observed line centers appear to be slightly redshifted with respect to the orion nebula ( figure [ pah11lo ] ) ; i.e. less than one resolution element . however , this is the only feature in the n66 spectra , ionic , molecular , or pah , which shows a centroid shift , and while such a systematic offset could very well be due to continuum subtraction it is deserving of closer attention . 450 for classes a and c and @xmath0 1500 for class b ) , showing both
the width of the 7.7 feature and the suppressed 8.6 emission in the right panel . for the spectra of the extended emission ,
the strong lines at 7.46 and 8.99 are hi 6 - 5 and [ ariii ] respectively .
the n66 spectra by and large resemble the class a template , as expected for a giant hii region .
spectra were scaled so that the peak of the 7.7 feature matched that of the templates .
[ pah7786 ] ] ] therefore , the available high - resolution spectra ( r @xmath0 600 ) of n66 were reduced for comparison with the pah templates from @xcite ( figure [ pah11hi ] ) .
labelling for these spectra , first used in @xcite , follows that work .
unfortunately , the sh data have a low s / n .
however , in the spectra for positions 1 , 2 , 3 , and 5 , a narrow line , 2 - 3 wavelength elements wide , that corresponds to the position of the hi 9 - 7 11.31 line , is visible . due to the fact that the raw images do not reveal single pixels with high values at this wavelength ,
it is not likely that this line is due to improperly calibrated pixels on the array , but is an actual astronomical feature . in order to determine whether the narrow line at 11.3 is the hi 9 - 7 line
, we compared the line strength to that of the detected h i 7 - 6 12.37 line to see if their ratio is consistent with case b recombination theory @xcite .
we used a temperature of 12,500 k and a number density of 10@xmath33 @xmath6 to compare to the data ; n66 has measured values of 12,269 k average and 50 - 500 @xmath6 @xcite . for case
b , @xmath39 for sources 1 , 2 , and 3 , the ratio was about 0.2 , and for source 5 , it was @xmath19 0.1 .
considering the low s / n of these data , but also considering the other detected hi lines ( hi 7 - 6 line in hi - res and the hi 6 - 5 line at lo - res ) , it is likely that the detected line is the hi 9 - 7 line and that this line is contributing to the apparent redshift of the 11.3 feature .
leaving aside the narrow line , there are still several cases in which the peak of 11.3 pahs in n66 are slightly redward ( @xmath40 0.1 ) of the two templates ( positions _ 8 , 9 , 10 _ and _ 13 _ show it most clearly in spite of the low s / n ) . according to the _ spitzer _
irs instrument handbook the wavelength calibration is good to 1/5 of a resolution element , or , for sh , @xmath0 0.001 .
pointing offsets are also a minor concern , but could produce a 0.5-pixel shift , or @xmath0 0.04 .
both of these potential errors are small in comparison to the @xmath0 0.1 shift in the pah feature centroid , would additionally affect all features in this spectral order , and therefore can not account for the shift seen .
we must stress once again that continuum subtraction may play a role in the centroid mismatch .
if born out , this is the only ism - type environment observed so far that exhibits a profile redshifted compared to class a. we also note the absence of the 11.0 feature seen in the templates , though its absence is likely due to the low s / n of these spectra . ]
while the observed wavelength shifts across n66 appear in both point source and ism spectra , a worthwhile comparison is herbig aebe stars , which often exhibit 11.3 pah peaks that are shifted redward by a similar amount .
@xcite show peak shifts in both the 7.7 and 11.3 pah complexes .
it is interesting that we do not see an appreciable shift in the 7.7 feature , which is often shifted by as much as 0.3 or more in herbig aebe environments and would therefore be detectable with our spectra . because the redward shift of the 11.3 pah complex is small ( 0.1 ) and the detected hi 9 - 7 line must be resolved out of the feature , we recommend that high - resolution and high s / n follow - up observations be made .
jwst s miri instrument , with its spectral resolution of @xmath0 3000 , is a perfect candidate instrument for such follow - up .
such observations would be capable of not only confirming the wavelength shift of the pah and more accurately determining the line flux and width of the narrow line , but , an expanded high - resolution study could be used to determine whether these features are peculiar to n66 ( or , perhaps , the smc ) , or are systematic at low metallicity .
the continuum between 13.5 and 14.2 is due to emission by a combination of very small carbonaceous dust grains ( vsgs : a @xmath41 50 ; * ? ? ?
* ) and warm large dust grains .
however , we expect the vsgs to dominate the emission at these wavelengths ; @xcite , 5 , notes that the vsg contribution to the continuum at @xmath11 @xmath19 20 is roughly independent of the radiation field strength because it results from single - photon heating . the 14 continuum is measured as the continuum beneath the pah bands as fit with pahfit .
figure [ vsgsb ] plots the 14 continuum over [ siv ] versus the radiation field hardness as traced by [ siv]/[neii ] for the extended emission spectra . by normalizing the 14 continuum emission by the [ siv ] line flux ,
we are able to compare the dust continuum emission to the radiation field strength , and then plot that value versus the radiation field hardness .
there is an anti - correlation that suggests that the 14 continuum is weakest where the radiation field is hardest and strongest .
weaker continua in harder and stronger radiation fields supports the assertion first presented in @xcite that the vsgs are likely being photodestroyed by the u = 10@xmath38 isrf radiation field in n66 .
because the correlation seen in figure [ vsgsb ] is roughly linear excluding the outlier , this supports the assertion that the 14 emission is mostly due to vsgs , not large grains ; if there was a substantial contribution from large grains to the 14 continuum , then the expected variations in large grain dust temperature across the region would make this trend non - linear .
flux in the extended emission versus [ siv]/[neii ] .
these data show an anti - correlation that suggests that the 14 continuum is weakest in the hardest and strongest radiation fields.[vsgsb ] ] there are four major pah features in the 5 - 15 wavelength range .
these features are identified by specific resonant modes inside the pahs @xcite .
( 1 ) the 6.2 feature is created by an aromatic c - c stretch mode .
( 2 ) the 7.7 feature is also due to c - c aromatic stretch modes .
( 3 ) the 8.6 feature is emitted by a c - h in - plane bending mode , while ( 4 ) the 11.3 feature is due to a solo c - h out - of - plane bending mode and is sensitive to edge structure @xcite .
furthermore , the 6.2 , 7.7 , and 8.6 pah features are attributed to ionized pahs , whereas the 11.3 pah feature is attributed to neutral pahs @xcite , and there is believed to be a wavelength - size dependence for pahs , wherein larger pahs emit most efficiently in the longer - wavelength pah features @xcite .
pah ratios offer an independent assessment of the ism s physical characteristics .
@xcite found an average correlation between the i@xmath2/i@xmath3 and i@xmath4/i@xmath3 for a sample of starbursts , bcds , hii regions and pdrs , reproduced in figure [ galliano1 ] , where galliano s average is shown as a solid line with the one-@xmath42 standard deviation plotted on either side of the average .
the data points for n66 are also plotted , with the point source data as red triangles and the extended emission data as green stars .
the point source data show a range of i@xmath2/i@xmath3 from @xmath0 0.03 - 6.3 , over two orders of magnitude , in a relatively narrow range of i@xmath4/i@xmath3 @xmath0 0.5 - 1.8 .
the extended emission spectra have respective ranges of 0.35 - 8.4 and @xmath0 1 - 3 .
averaging together all values for the i@xmath4/i@xmath3 and i@xmath2/i@xmath3 ratios weighted by feature strength , the point sources have values of 1.1 and 2.7 and the extended emission have values of 1.4 and 3.7 respectively .
these averages are relatively close together and lie within the galaxy sample s average correlation .
however , the wide spread around those averages suggests an intriguing variety of physical attributes .
for instance , the massive embedded yso ( ps7 , discussed in detail in section [ yso ] ) has a very high i@xmath2/i@xmath3 ratio value ; see figure [ galliano1 ] .
this might suggest that the pah emission from the embedding envelope is either more heavily ionized than other point sources , or else the average pah size is smaller . having a population of ionized pahs in the yso environment seems unlikely because the temperature of a class i yso is probably very low ( @xmath0250 k ; * ? ? ? * ) .
the hii regions n66b and n66c ( ps5 & ps6 ) both lie near the average value for i@xmath2/i@xmath3 , but ngc 346 ( ps9 ) lies well off of this average , with an outlying value of @xmath0 0.03 . the low value for the 7.7 feature strength in ngc 346 is confirmed with a visual inspection of the spectrum - see the appendix , figure [ spec2 ] . as an opposite example to the yso , ngc 346 may either contain a largely neutral pah population or else very large pahs ; the latter solution seems most sensible given the numerous blue stars in the cluster .
the lack of correlation seen in figure [ galliano1 ] is intriguing because the 6.2 and 7.7 pah features are generally very tightly correlated for spectra of hii regions and entire galaxies @xcite , for planetary nebulae @xcite , and in the reflection nebula ngc 2023 ( peeters et al .
2013 in preparation ) .
we have already determined that this is not due to the decomposition method ( see [ specfit ] ) .
the same lack of trend can be seen with the column - extracted pah fluxes from @xcite , although a weak correlation may be seen in the @xcite results for the high s / n data points .
we are not aware of any other mention in the literature of a decoupling of the 6.2 and 7.7 pah features in this manner . /i@xmath3
versus i@xmath4/i@xmath3 from @xcite figure 3 is plotted as the solid line with its 1-@xmath42 spread shown .
the n66 data points are overplotted.[galliano1 ] ] to study general trends , the i@xmath2/i@xmath4 and i@xmath43/i@xmath4 are plotted against i@xmath2/i@xmath3 in figure [ galliano2 ] . a trend is seen in the i@xmath2/i@xmath4 versus i@xmath2/i@xmath3 ratios plot that was not recorded in the @xcite dataset .
the values of the i@xmath2/i@xmath3 ratio seem to suggest that the areas of extended emission ( on the right ) are largely photoionized whereas the point sources ( on the left ) are more neutral , with some exceptions .
the variation of the i@xmath2/i@xmath4 ratio might suggest some photoprocessing effect : the 6.2 pah flux becomes weaker in harder radiation fields due to the destruction of the smaller pah molecules . /i@xmath4 and i@xmath43/i@xmath4 versus
i@xmath2/i@xmath3 pah ratios are plotted for n66 .
[ galliano2 ] ] there is no trend between the i@xmath43/i@xmath4 and i@xmath2/i@xmath3 pah ratios . because the i@xmath43/i@xmath4 ratio should be independent of ionization state and therefore should trace the size of the pahs , while the i@xmath2/i@xmath3 ratio does trace ionization state , it appears that the size distribution is _ independent of ionization state_. this includes both point sources and extended emission spectra , and it should be noted that a spread of about one order of magnitude still exists in the i@xmath43/i@xmath4 ratio values . we therefore conclude that n66 shows no evidence of local variation in the n@xmath44 value due to the ionization state for the pah population , but it is unclear how this result should compare to galaxies with significantly different metallicity or star formation activity . in @xcite , the weak 7.7 feature across the entire smc , including n66 , and
the relatively strong 11.3 feature suggested to the authors that pahs across the smc are both small and mostly neutral .
however , the authors used a stringent signal - to - noise cut - off , thereby excluding extended emission from their analysis and biasing their results towards the conditions found for our point source spectra . when our data are compared against the grey data points in the pah ratios plots in @xcite , it is interesting to note that the results from the map agree well with our targeted spectroscopy results .
what our analysis is able to show is that the point sources lie in a similar pah ratio space to the extended emission , despite the different physical conditions as discussed .
furthermore , it is clear that the pah population exists on a spectrum , from more neutral in the dense pdr where the point sources lie , to more ionized in the diffuse pdr and hii region .
the pah population size distribution in low - metallicity environments is a contentious topic . in a study of low - metallicity bcds
, @xcite found relatively strong i@xmath43 and i@xmath3 features and interpreted this finding to mean a large n@xmath44 value for pahs .
the analysis of the i@xmath45/i@xmath3 pah ratio by @xcite suggests the opposite , that low - metallicity environments ( 12+log(o / h ) @xmath46 8.1 ) host pah populations with small sizes on average .
we do not have the long - wavelength data to sufficient depth or spatial resolution for a i@xmath45/i@xmath3 analysis ; however , that data is available in the @xcite maps , and they determine that the n@xmath47 value is smaller in the smc than in the milky way based on the weak 17.0 pah feature .
our own results , including a wide range of i@xmath43/i@xmath4 ratio values , suggest that these average trends do not hold on small size scales , where local effects likely come in to play . in this section
, we compare the pah and forbidden line emission for n66 with data from other sources with similar star formation environments to n66 , including giant hii regions and blue compact dwarf galaxies ( bcds ) . for the pah emission , we take the ratio of the 11.3 and 6.2 pah features which will trace the ionization state of the pahs and also the pah size distribution . for the gas , we take the [ siv]/[neii ] ratio as a tracer of the radiation field hardness .
the other giant hii regions studied are 30 doradus and ngc 3603 @xcite , and the population of well - studied bcds comes from @xcite .
the results are plotted in figure [ pahvsradn ] .
/i@xmath4 versus [ siv/[ne ii ] for n66 point sources ( plus signs ) and extended emission spectra ( stars ) plotted along with results for ngc 3603 ( triangles ) , 30 doradus ( squares ) , and some well - studied bcds ( diamonds ) .
references for these data are given in the text .
[ pahvsradn ] ] the n66 point sources have pah ratio values similar to sources with small [ siv]/[neii ] ratio values .
however , the extended emission spectra , whose [ siv]/[neii ] ratio is on average higher than most other sources , also exhibits a lower i@xmath48/i@xmath49 value , as was discussed in [ pahratios ] , suggesting that the pah population in the diffuse ism of n66 is more ionized than in the other hii regions and in integrated spectra of bcds , despite sometimes equally hard isrfs as traced by the [ siv]/[neii ] ratio .
there is a source of bias in this comparison worth noting .
the spectra of 30 doradus , ngc 3603 , and the bcd sample were not extracted using smart - adopt as described in [ srcext ] .
instead , they are all composite spectra . for the giant hii regions
ngc 3603 and 30 doradus , each spectrum likely has contributions from both unresolved point sources in the pdr and diffuse hii emission . for the bcds ,
each spectrum likely contains emission from both star - forming and quiescent regions .
it is therefore not surprising that the results for n66 are both separated and qualitatively different from those of the other regions .
the smc ( including n66 ) is the closest low - metallicity star forming galaxy to the milky way and can therefore be used to study possible trends to other low - metallicity star - forming environments .
it is therefore important to determine what the dominant source of the pah emission in n66 is , in order to properly interpret unresolved h ii region studies .
does the pah emission primarily come from the high s / n point sources , or from the diffuse ism in the hii region and pdr ? using the spectral maps of n66 presented in @xcite in order to study a spatially well - sampled dataset , we made maps of the 6.2 and 11.3 pah features by subtracting away the continuum measured locally .
the 7.7 feature straddles the sl1 and sl2 orders and the 8.6 feature is very hard to pick out from the continuum , so these two features were excluded from the analysis .
the average brightness in the pdr was measured and then point sources were defined as anything that was 3-@xmath42 above the average ; the annulus selected around each point source was 6 pixels across , or 10.8 @xmath50 . using this metric
, we summed up the emission for point sources as well as the diffuse emission from the entire map in the 6.2 and 11.3 pah features .
there are a total of 13 selected point sources in the 6.2 map , and 14 in the 11.3 map , and the map is 300@xmath50 @xmath8 430@xmath50 .
we find that the fraction of the pah emission coming from the point sources is 28 @xmath51 8% for the 6.2 pah feature and 21 @xmath51 6% for the 11.3 pah feature .
due to the relatively high level of variance between these two pah features , we conclude that , as a rough proxy for studies of unresolved star formation at low - metallicity , the point sources ( resolved down to @xmath0 2 pc ) contribute roughly @xmath0 20 - 35% of the pah emission across the region .
this means that it is the extended emission which dominates the observed pah brightness in n66 , and possibly low - metallicity giant hii regions generally .
n66 is the largest starburst in the smc and contains half of the entire galaxy s o stars .
its hard radiation field and low metallicity make it an excellent corollary to studies of bcds and high - redshift starbursts .
our analysis of _ spitzer / irs _ spectra from 5 - 14 makes use of powerful optimal extraction routines that separate emission from the dense pdr s unresolved point sources and the surrounding ism s more diffuse emission .
the point sources are all associated with sites of active star formation in the region .
of special note are the spectroscopic confirmation of a massive embedded class i yso , the detection of silicates associated with young ( @xmath0 3 myr ) stellar clusters , and the detection of pahs and silicates associated with a b[e ] star that indicates it may in fact be a herbig aebe star . in the diffuse ism
, we find evidence that the very small grains are being photodestroyed , consistent with previous studies of n66 .
the pah emission shows several interesting features .
the 11.3 pah complex has an unexplained centroid shift for both point sources and the diffuse ism . in general , the pahs are best classified as type a. however , a slight widening of the 7.7 feature in some of the spectra is either due to the 7.46 hi 6 - 5 line in the diffuse emission spectra , or else the removal of ism contamination that reveals type b - like circumstellar features .
the 6.2 and 7.7 pah band fluxes in n66 do not correlate with each other , an observation that we do not believe has been observed in other objects . because we were able to separate out the point source and extended emission in the spectral slit , the conclusions we draw from the pah ratios are detailed where those presented in @xcite are more general
: we find that the pahs are more neutral in the densest parts of the pdr ( including the entire point source catalogue ) , and more ionized in the diffuse ism while @xcite determined that the pahs were on average more neutral than in higher - metallicity galaxies . on average ,
@xcite found that pahs in the smc are smaller compared to those in more metal rich galaxies .
we show that on small scales , the size distribution of the pahs in n66 ( based on the 8.6 pah feature flux ) does not appear to be correlated with their ionization state and is therefore independent of the ratio of uv field strength to electron density .
we stress that , on average , our results match the work of @xcite extremely well , and that the spread in ionization state and lack of clear trend with minimum pah size on small scales is made possible by our spectral extraction techniques .
lastly , we have determined using spectral maps of the region that only @xmath0 20 - 35 % of the pah emission in n66 is coming from the unresolved point sources , and it is therefore dominated by the diffuse emission .
this percentage suggests that studies of unresolved low - metallicity star - forming regions in nearby bcds and starburst galaxies will also have pah spectra dominated by the diffuse hii region and pdr , not the unresolved point sources , and the observed pah signatures of the point source spectra are therefore not representative of the entire hii region s properties .
the authors would like to thank the anonymous referee , whose comments helped to improve the manuscript .
dgw would like to thank k. sandstrom for discussions concerning the pah spectra of n66 , e. muller for discussions about the molecular gas content , and p. martini and a. leroy for helpful suggestions .
kej gratefully acknowledges support for this paper provided by nsf through career award 0548103 and the david and lucile packard foundation through a packard fellowship .
jsb wishes to acknowledge the support from a marie curie intra - european fellowship within the 7th european community framework program under project number 272820 .
the spectra used in the analysis are presented here . the reduction method for producing the point source and extended emission
is discussed in [ srcext ] .
feature labels can be seen clearly.[spec1],title="fig : " ] feature labels can be seen clearly.[spec1],title="fig : " ] feature labels can be seen clearly.[spec1],title="fig : " ] feature labels can be seen clearly.[spec1],title="fig : " ] feature labels can be seen clearly.[spec1],title="fig : " ] feature labels can be seen clearly.[spec1],title="fig : " ] feature labels can be seen clearly.[spec1],title="fig : " ] 00h59m21.8s & -72d11m13.3s & ps1 & & & + 00h59m20.0s & -72d11m21.0s & ps2 & 9 & i & + 00h59m17.1s & -72d11m24.3s & ps3 & 13 & & + 00h59m14.8s & -72d11m03.8s & ps4 & 8 & h & 1 class i yso + 00h59m14.0s & -72d09m27.1s & ps5 & & g & n66c ; 1 class ii yso + 00h59m12.3s & -72d09m58.7s & ps6 & 11 & f & n66b ; 1 class i yso + 00h59m09.3s & -72d10m57.8s & ps7 & 5 & e & n66a ; 2 class i ysos + 00h59m05.8s & -72d11m27.5s & ps8 & 7 & d & kwbbe 200 , a be star + 00h59m05.4s & -72d10m36.1s & ps9 & 6 & c & n66 ; ngc 346 + 00h58m59.8s & -72d10m16.7s & ps10 & & & + 00h58m57.6s & -72d09m56.7s & ps11 & & & + 00h58m57.0s & -72d09m54.5s & ps12 & 10 & a & + 00h58m54.7s & -72d09m51.5s & ps13 & & & + 00h58m51.7s & -72d09m29.2s & ps14 & & & + 00h59m49.99s & -72d13m00.1s & slt1 & sky position + 00h59m42.00s & -72d11m09.9s & slt2 & sky position + 00h59m21.62s & -72d11m17.2s & slt3 & + 00h59m20.42s & -72d11m22.2s & slt4 & + 00h59m17.30s & -72d11m25.1s & slt5 & + 00h59m15.26s & -72d09m19.1s & slt6 & + 00h59m14.69s & -72d11m03.1s & slt7 & + 00h59m13.49s & -72d09m54.7s & slt8 & + 00h59m12.29s & -72d09m58.3s & slt9 & + 00h59m10.13s & -72d10m51.2s & slt10 & + 00h59m09.24s & -72d10m57.0s & slt11 & + 00h59m06.74s & -72d10m25.3s & slt12 & + 00h59m05.98s & -72d11m26.9s & slt13 & + 00h59m05.52s & -72d10m35.8s & slt14 & + 00h58m59.11s & -72d10m23.2s & slt15 & + 00h58m59.02s & -72d10m28.6s & slt16 & + 00h58m58.32s & -72d09m50.0s & slt17 & + 00h58m56.95s & -72d09m54.0s & slt18 & + 00h58m52.42s & -72d09m24.1s & slt19 & + ps1 & ps & @xmath190.47 & @xmath190.52 & [email protected] & @xmath190.11 & [email protected]&@xmath190.22 & [email protected] + ps2 & ps & [email protected] & @xmath190.47 & [email protected] & @xmath190.41 & [email protected] & @xmath190.12 & [email protected] + ps3 & ps & [email protected] & @xmath190.32 & [email protected]&@xmath190.18 & [email protected]&@xmath190.12 & [email protected] + ps4 & ps & @xmath190.80 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & @xmath190.91 & @xmath190.30 & [email protected] + ps5 & ps & @xmath190.05 & @xmath190.09 & [email protected] & @xmath190.09 & @xmath190.056 & @xmath190.15 & [email protected] + ps6 & ps & @xmath190.29 & @xmath190.09 & @xmath190.38 & [email protected]&@xmath190.097 & @xmath190.30 & [email protected] + ps7 & ps & @xmath191.0 & @xmath190.80 & [email protected]&@xmath190.68 & @xmath190.52 & @xmath190.38 & @xmath190.70 + ps8 & ps & @xmath190.40 & @xmath190.42 & @xmath190.59 & @xmath190.45 & @xmath190.11 & @xmath190.10 & @xmath190.38 + ps9 & ps & @xmath190.67 & @xmath190.85 & @xmath192.1 & @xmath190.81 & @xmath190.68 & @xmath190.68 & [email protected] + ps10 & ps & @xmath190.62 & @xmath190.17 & [email protected] & @xmath190.42 & [email protected]&@xmath190.052 & [email protected] + ps11 & ps & @xmath190.45 & @xmath190.05 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + ps12 & ps & @xmath190.45 & @xmath190.38 & [email protected]&@xmath190.39 & [email protected]&@xmath190.032 & [email protected] + ps13 & ps & @xmath190.37 & @xmath190.33 & @xmath190.37 & @xmath190.14 & @xmath190.35 & @xmath190.35 & [email protected] + ps14 & ps & @xmath190.15 & @xmath190.21 & [email protected] & @xmath190.40 & [email protected]&@xmath190.037 & [email protected] + slt3 & ee & @xmath194.0 & [email protected] & @xmath190.52 & 41@xmath515 & @xmath190.39 & [email protected] & [email protected] + slt4 & ee & @xmath192.9 & 1.2@xmath512 & @xmath191.2 & 55@xmath516 & @xmath190.79 & [email protected] & [email protected] + slt5 & ee & @xmath193.9 & [email protected] & @xmath194.7 & [email protected] & @xmath191.3 & [email protected] & [email protected] + slt6 & ee & [email protected] & [email protected] & @xmath190.26 & 54@xmath516 & @xmath191.6 & [email protected] & [email protected] + slt8 & ee & [email protected] & [email protected] & @xmath190.57 & 72@xmath518 & @xmath190.31 & [email protected] & [email protected] + slt9 & ee & @xmath190.82 & [email protected] & @xmath190.77 & 79@xmath519 & @xmath190.82 & @xmath191.0 & [email protected] + slt10 & ee & [email protected] & 13@xmath512 & @xmath190.40 & 94@xmath5110 & @xmath190.46 & [email protected] & [email protected] + slt11 & ee & @xmath192.3 & 19@xmath51 3 & @xmath191.4 & 104@xmath5111 & @xmath190.38 & [email protected] & 11@xmath512 + slt12 & ee & [email protected] & 11@xmath512 & @xmath190.38 & 87@xmath519 & @xmath190.60 & [email protected] & 13@xmath512 + slt13 & ee & @xmath198.3 & 10@xmath512 & @xmath190.67 & 50@xmath516 & @xmath190.19 & [email protected] & [email protected] + slt14 & ee & @xmath193.9 & 11@xmath512 & @xmath190.32 & 106@xmath5111 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + slt15 & ee & [email protected] & 11@xmath512 & @xmath190.28 & 153@xmath5115 & @xmath190.27 & [email protected] & [email protected] + slt16 nod 1 & ee & @xmath1911 & 18@xmath513 & @xmath191.8 & 116@xmath5112 & @xmath191.3 & [email protected] & [email protected] + slt16 nod 2 & ee & @xmath1919 & 11@xmath512 & @xmath193.5 & 123@xmath5113 & [email protected] & [email protected] & 12@xmath512 + slt17 & ee & @xmath190.40 & [email protected] & @xmath190.19 & 73@xmath518 & @xmath190.27 & [email protected] & [email protected] + slt19 & ee & @xmath190.24 & [email protected] & @xmath190.10 & 16@xmath512 & @xmath190.23 & [email protected] & [email protected] + ps1 & ps & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 1.6 + ps2 & ps & [email protected] & 18@xmath512 & [email protected] & [email protected] & 5.9 + ps3 & ps & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.98 + ps4 & ps & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2.1 + ps5 & ps & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.68 + ps6 & ps & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.65 + ps7 & ps & [email protected] & 11@xmath511 & [email protected] & [email protected] & 18 + ps8 & ps & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 3.0 + ps9 & ps & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 16 + ps10 & ps & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 1.2 + ps11 & ps & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.85 + ps12 & ps & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 3.5 + ps13 & ps & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.11 + ps14 & ps & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.60 + slt3 & ee & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2.2 + slt4 & ee & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 4.8 + slt5 & ee & [email protected] & 17@xmath512 & [email protected] & [email protected] & 5.3 + slt6 & ee & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 4.3 + slt8 & ee & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 3.8 + slt9 & ee & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 4.9 + slt10 & ee & [email protected] & 19@xmath511 & [email protected] & [email protected] & 8.6 + slt11 & ee & [email protected] & 19@xmath511 & [email protected] & [email protected] & 9.7 + slt12 & ee & [email protected] & 17@xmath512 & [email protected] & [email protected] & 9.1 + slt13 & ee & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 4.4 + slt14 & ee & [email protected] & 21@xmath512 & [email protected] & [email protected] & 7.9 + slt15 & ee & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 8.6 + slt16 nod 1 & ee & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 9.6 + slt16 nod 2 & ee & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 12 + slt17 & ee & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 1.7 + slt19 & ee & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2.3 + | the focus of this work is to study mid - infrared point sources and the diffuse interstellar medium ( ism ) in the low - metallicity ( @xmath0 0.2 z@xmath1 ) giant hii region n66 in order to determine properties that may shed light on star formation in these conditions . using the _ spitzer space telescope _
s infrared spectrograph , we study polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon ( pah ) , dust continuum , silicate , and ionic line emission from 14 targeted infrared point sources as well as spectra of the diffuse ism that is representative of both the photodissociation regions ( pdrs ) and the hii regions . among the point source spectra
, we spectroscopically confirm that the brightest mid - infrared point source is a massive embedded young stellar object , we detect silicates in emission associated with two young stellar clusters , and we observe spectral features of a known b[e ] supergiant that are more commonly associated with herbig be stars . in the diffuse ism , we provide additional evidence that the very small grain population is being photodestroyed in the hard radiation field .
the 11.3 pah complex emission exhibits an unexplained centroid shift in both the point source and ism spectra that should be investigated at higher signal - to - noise and resolution . unlike studies of other regions , the 6.2 and 7.7 band fluxes are decoupled ; the data points cover a large range of i@xmath2/i@xmath3 pah ratio values within a narrow band of i@xmath4/i@xmath3 ratio values .
furthermore , there is a spread in pah ionization , being more neutral in the dense pdr where the radiation field is relatively soft , but ionized in the diffuse ism / pdr .
by contrast , the pah size distribution appears to be independent of local ionization state .
important to unresolved studies of extragalactic low - metallicity star - forming regions , we find that emission from the infrared - bright point sources accounts for only 20 - 35% of the pah emission from the entire region .
these results make a comparative dataset to other star - forming regions with similarly hard and strong radiation fields . |
amorphous polymer materials are commonly used in various industrial products , such as packaging films , body materials , electro - photographic toners , adhesive agents , buffer materials , etc . from the viewpoints of the control of the viscoelastic and mechanical properties of these amorphous polymer materials , understanding of the dynamics of the polymer chain
is one of the essentials of polymer science and engineering .
the time - temperature superposition ( tts ) principle is a useful concept widely used for the analysis of the dynamic properties of a polymer.@xcite according to the time - temperature superposition , which assumes that all of the relaxation modes of a polymer chain obey the same temperature dependence , the dynamic material functions obtained at several different temperatures can be collapsed into a `` master '' curve by shifting the time scale of each function .
the shifting coefficients , which are the so - called `` shift factor '' , are represented as a function of the temperature of the system .
the dependence of the shift factor on temperature can be well described by the vogel - fulcher - tammann ( vft ) or the williams - landel - ferry ( wlf ) equation , both being basically the same equation , and the equations are applicable above the glass transition temperature ( @xmath0 ) + ca .
50 k. however , in the case when the system temperature approaches the @xmath0 , the breakdown of tts can be observed in many polymer systems.@xcite incidentally , the breakdown of tts of the dynamic material functions lead to the decoupling of stokes - einstein law of diffusion - viscosity relation at low temperature.@xcite using the viscoelastic and optical birefringence measurements of polystyrene , inoue and co - workers @xcite revealed that the stress relaxation of a polymer melt has two components .
one ( r - component ) is related to the relaxation of the orientation of a polymer chain , which is well described by the rouse theory , and the other ( g - component ) is related to the relaxation of the transverse component of the monomeric motion on a length scale shorter than the shortest rouse mode .
these two components have different temperature dependencies to each other .
the g - component has the strongest temperature dependence versus that of the r - component .
obviously , the existence of two relaxation modes having different temperature dependencies can be due to the breakdown of the tts of the viscoelastic functions .
similarly , the tts of the dielectric relaxation also breaks down at a temperature close to the glass transition temperature for the polymer .
the broadband dielectric relaxation measurements of amorphous polymer melts@xcite show a significant difference between the temperature dependencies of the relaxation times of the segment mode and the normal mode .
the normal mode is a relaxation behavior due to fluctuation of the end - to - end vector of a polymer chain and the segment mode is one of several beaded monomer units .
the ratio of the relaxation times between the normal mode ( @xmath8 ) and segmental mode ( @xmath9 ) is constant , as long as the tts can be applicable at a sufficiently higher system temperature than its @xmath0 , though the ratio ( @xmath10 ) gradually decreases when the system temperature is approaching the @xmath0 .
the relaxation time of the segmental mode has a stronger temperature dependence than the ones of the normal mode .
several lines of studies suggested that the difference in the temperature dependence between the chain and segmental relaxation times is due to dynamic heterogeneities at a temperature close to the @xmath0 of the polymer.@xcite however , the basic mechanism for the thermo - rheological complexity is still not completely understood.@xcite this investigation has been highly motivated by these studies concerned with the tts of polymer dynamics near the @xmath0 . in this study , the applicability of tts to the stress relaxation modulus functions @xmath11 of dense bead - spring polymer melts over a wide temperature and time range were evaluated .
the effect of the chain rigidity in a polymer melt on its relaxation behavior in the glass - rubber transition regime will also be discussed in this study .
in this section , the details of the simulation model and computational methods for the dense bead - spring polymer melt are described .
the polymer molecules are represented by the soft - core spheres and the stretch and bending springs .
two types of polymer chains were prepared ; one is the freely - jointed chain ( @xmath12 ) , which has a stretching spring between neighboring beads , while the other is the freely - rotating chain ( @xmath13 ) , which is the extension model of @xmath12 to describe the stiffness of the chain .
@xmath13 has both stretching and bending springs .
all monomers interact through the lennard - jones ( 12 - 6 ) potential @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the distance between two beads , @xmath16 is the ( finite ) distance at which the inter - particle potential is zero , and @xmath17 is the depth of the potential well .
@xmath18 is truncated at @xmath15 = 2.0 @xmath16 .
in addition , the bonded neighbors in a chain interact through the fene bond potential @xmath19 , \ ] ] where @xmath20 is the maximum length of the bond .
the equilibrium bond length @xmath21 = 0.96@xmath16 with @xmath20 = 1.5@xmath16 . for the @xmath13 , the harmonic angle potential @xmath22 , \ ] ] where @xmath23 is the external angle between two adjacent bonds and @xmath24 is the force constant ( @xmath24 = 2.0@xmath25 ) , is added to the total energy .
the simulation box with the periodic boundary condition includes 133 polymer chains of length n = 30 , and has 3990 particles in total .
all the @xmath26 simulations of this study are performed by the cognac 8.0 codes.@xcite the production time step for integration is dt = 0.01@xmath27 , where @xmath27 is the unit of time @xmath28 , and @xmath29 is the mass of the bead ( @xmath30 in this study ) .
the nose - hoover thermostat @xcite and andersen barostat @xcite are used to control the temperature @xmath31 and the pressure @xmath32 of the system , respectively .
for all simulations in this study , the pressure of the system was set to zero ( @xmath33 ) in this study , @xmath34 is measured from the temperature dependence of the specific volume of a polymer melt .
the specific volume of a polymer melt decreases with the decreasing temperature , but the shrinkage rate of the volume of the polymer melt changes to a lower value at a temperature close to @xmath34 .
it was noted that such a volume change in the system will continuously occur , in contrast to the abrupt change in volume at the freezing point of a crystalline material .
@xmath34 can be defined as the intersection of two regression lines of the specific volume versus the temperature in the liquid state and in the glassy state .
the molecular dynamics simulations of the dense bead - spring melts with the step - wise cooling from @xmath35 to @xmath36 with a rate of @xmath37 per @xmath38 was performed .
the cooling rate @xmath39 is @xmath40 .
universally , @xmath0 depends on @xmath39 , the @xmath0 at low @xmath39 is lower than ones at high @xmath39 , @xmath39-dependence on @xmath0 for a dense bead - spring melt is reported by buchholz et.al.@xcite , which exhibit that @xmath41 is almost constant at @xmath42 , although @xmath0 is significantly increasing with the increasing of @xmath43 .
it is expected that the cooling rate of @xmath44 is the sufficiently small value for the estimation of the asymptotic value of @xmath41 for @xmath12 and @xmath13 melts .
@xmath3 is obtained using green - kubo formula , @xmath45 where @xmath46 is the volume of the system,@xmath47 is the stress tensor of the system given by @xmath48 where @xmath49 is the total number of beads in the system , @xmath50 is the mass of a bead , @xmath51 and @xmath52 are the @xmath53-component and @xmath54-component of the velocity vector of the @xmath55-th bead respectively , @xmath56 is the @xmath53-component of position vector from @xmath55-th bead to @xmath57-th bead , and @xmath58 is the y - component of force acting between the @xmath55-th and @xmath57-th beads . in order to obtain an accurate @xmath3 ,
the stress tensor should be calculated at every time step .
however , it is inefficient to store and access such huge files of the values of the instantaneous stress components . to avoid this difficulty , the correlator algorithm described in ref . was used .
the algorithm utilizes the instantaneous stress values at every md step for the calculation of @xmath3 function , although using an array of correlators and an accumulator in this algorithm require only a small memory size to store the data .
the temperature dependences of the specific volume of two bead - spring polymer melts ( @xmath12 and @xmath13 ) are shown in figure 1 .
the plotted volume data are the mean values from five independent md simulations .
it is noted that there is no difference in the specific volume between the @xmath12 and @xmath13 melts at temperatures above the glass transition region .
however , the glass transition region of @xmath13 melt begins at a higher temperature than that of the @xmath12 melt .
both curves have an obvious bending point .
the glass transition temperature was defined as the intersection point of two regression lines obtained from the lower and higher temperature regions than the bending point , and these obtained values are @xmath34 = 0.44 ( for @xmath12 ) and @xmath34 = 0.56 ( for @xmath13 ) . ) of @xmath12 melt(upper ) and @xmath13 melt ( bottom ) as a function of temperature at the cooling rate of @xmath59 .
the open circles represent the simulated volume data , and the dashed lines represent the regression results individually fitted to the volume data at temperatures lower and higher than the bending point of the function .
the plotted data are obtained from five independent md runs of 2000 @xmath27.,height=377 ] as mentioned in the introduction , the dynamic materials functions ( e.g. , a relaxation modulus , a diffusion coefficient , viscosity , creep compliance , etc . ) at several different temperatures can be coincided with a master curve by shifting the time scale of each function .
the tts can be applied to the @xmath3 in the following manner , @xmath60 where @xmath61 is the reference temperature ( @xmath61 = 1 in this study ) and @xmath62 and @xmath63 are the vertical and horizontal shift factors , respectively . the @xmath62 value is given by @xmath64 + where @xmath65 is the density of the polymer melt at the temperature @xmath31 .
eq.7 is derived based on the analogy of the classical rubber elasticity theory . in order to discuss the time - dependence of the horizontal shift factor , two shift factors(@xmath66 and @xmath67 )
were defined at two different times ( @xmath68 and @xmath69 ) as follows : @xmath70 where @xmath68 and @xmath69 are chosen at around the onset ( @xmath69 = 1 @xmath27 ) and middle ( @xmath68 = 100 @xmath27 ) of the time - range where the chain - relaxation is observed in the @xmath3 function at @xmath61 = 1 .
@xmath68 is roughly equivalent to the time - scale of the relaxation of three or four segments , and @xmath69 is shorter than the relaxation time - scale of a dimer . due to the large fluctuations in the @xmath3 functions ,
the shift factors @xmath71 are chosen to maximize the number of plotted points of @xmath72 in the windows which are located at the coordinates of the points of @xmath73 around @xmath74 or @xmath75 .
although five squares with the side length of 0.1 ( on a double logarithmic scale ) were employed , the choice of these parameters does not significantly affect the tts results .
figure 2 shows the stress relaxation modulus @xmath76 of the @xmath12(black line ) and @xmath13(gray line ) polymer melts in the log - log plot of @xmath3 versus time , which are averages of ten independent md - runs .
the oscillations at an early time ( @xmath77 < 1 @xmath27 ) are due to the bond relaxation of a chain .
the slope of @xmath3 versus time on the log - log scale at @xmath77 = @xmath68 is about -0.7 ( for @xmath12 ) and -0.5 ( for @xmath13 ) .
the rouse prediction value is -1/2 .
the curve of @xmath3 for the @xmath13 melt is somewhat extended in comparison to the one for @xmath12 .
the stretching of @xmath3 in the @xmath13 melt suggests a polymer chain entanglement , which is not observed in the @xmath12 ( @xmath49 = 30 ) melt , that can occur due to the rigidity of a polymer chain .
@xcite the vertical shifted stress relaxation moduli ( @xmath78 ) of the @xmath12 and @xmath13 melts at several different temperatures are shown in figure 3 ( @xmath12 ) and figure 4 ( @xmath13 ) , respectively .
each curve of @xmath78 is an average of ten independent md runs .
the md runs with the length of @xmath79 are performed at each temperature ( varied from @xmath31=1 to near its @xmath34 ) .
the pressures of all the systems treated in this study were set to zero .
@xmath78 of the chain - relaxation regime is shifted to the right hand with the decreasing temperature , on the other hand , one of the bond - stretching relaxation regime migrates to up .
therefore , the horizontal width between the end of a bond stretching relaxation regime and the onset of a chain - relaxation regime is gradually extended as the temperature decreases .
the relaxation modes in this crossover regime are not clearly assigned in this study , though likhtman et al . expressed them as the `` colloidal or glassy modes '' in ref .. the middle graph(b ) in figs .
3 and 4 shows the results of the tts reduced to @xmath80 = 1 by the definition ( eq.8 ) of @xmath4 .
the tts works well at a much higher temperature compared to its @xmath0 .
however , at lower temperatures ( near @xmath0 ) , the @xmath1 functions at different temperatures will not collapse into one single universal curve . obviously , a different relaxation process , which has a different temperature dependence , appeared at around @xmath75 ( @xmath81 ) . instead of using the shift factor @xmath4 ,
the results of the tts using the shift factors @xmath67 defined by eq.8 , are shown ( bottom graph ) in figure 3 ( @xmath12 ) and in figure 4 ( @xmath13 ) .
similar to the middle graph ( shifted by @xmath4 ) , the curves can be collapsed to @xmath73 at a higher temperature ( above @xmath0 ) , conversely , they deviate from @xmath73 at a lower temperature ( near @xmath0 ) . and @xmath82 : the solid line ( @xmath12 melt ) and dashed line ( @xmath13 melt ) .
the vertical lines indicate the times ( @xmath68 and @xmath69 ) at which the horizontal shift factors ( @xmath4 and @xmath2 ) are defined.,height=188 ] ) of @xmath12 melt as a function of time at different temperatures ( @xmath83 and@xmath84 ) .
the upper graph ( a ) shows the @xmath85 without any horizontal shift factor .
the middle ( b ) and bottom ( c ) graphs show the time - temperature superposition of @xmath85 using the horizontal shift factors @xmath86 and @xmath87 , respectively .
the plotted data are obtained from ten independent md - runs .
the vertical dashed lines in ( b ) and ( c ) indicate the times , at which the horizontal shift factors ( @xmath86 and @xmath87 ) are defined.,height=566 ] ) of @xmath13 melt as a function of time at different temperatures ( @xmath88 and @xmath89 ) .
the same format as shown in figure 3 is used .
, height=566 ] figure 5 shows the horizontal shift factors , `` @xmath86 '' and `` @xmath87 '' , of the @xmath12(upper ) and @xmath13(bottom ) melts as a function of the @xmath0-normalized temperature .
solid lines in figure 5 are the least squares fits to the data of shift factors using wlf equation given by : @xmath90 where @xmath91 and @xmath92 are wlf parameters , and @xmath61 is the refarence temperature ( @xmath93 ) .
the wlf parameters were obtained for @xmath12 as @xmath94 ( @xmath95 ) , @xmath96 ( @xmath97 ) , and for @xmath13 as @xmath98 ( @xmath95 ) , @xmath99 ( @xmath97 ) . at sufficiently higher temperatures , above its @xmath0
, @xmath86 is in total agreement with @xmath87 for both polymer types ( @xmath12 and @xmath13 ) . at low temperatures near its @xmath0
, @xmath87 will become greater than @xmath86 and the rate of @xmath86 by @xmath87 decreases with the decreasing of the temperature , as shown in figure 6 .
the extrapolation to @xmath100 = 1 for the line in figure 6 estimates that the @xmath101 of @xmath12 could vary by an order of magnitude or even more . the ratios of @xmath101 of the @xmath13 melt are also shown in figure 6 by the open triangles . the temperature dependence of @xmath101 of the @xmath13 is greater than the ones for @xmath12 , and vary by a greater order of magnitude ( or even more ) than the ones for @xmath12 by extrapolating to @xmath100 = 1 . however , both temperatures normalized by the @xmath0 at the beginning of the decrease of @xmath102 for the @xmath12 and @xmath13 melts are observed around @xmath100 = 1.2 .
this may mean that the @xmath0-normalized temperature at which @xmath101 begin to decrease ( i.e. , begins the breakdown of tts ) is independent of the rigidity of the chain .
this indifference to the stiffness of the chain can also be seen in the temperature dependencies of the ratio of the segmental ( @xmath103 ) and chain(@xmath104 ) relaxation times which are observed by the dielectric relaxation measurements .
the rate @xmath105 of several well - defined homo - polymers ( pip , pp , ppg , pc and pog ) starts to drop in a similar range of @xmath103 ( @xmath106 to @xmath107 ) , although a more rigid polymer chain will lead to a greater temperature dependence of @xmath108 .
@xcite @xmath0 is often defined as @xmath109 @xcite , thus there is the huge amount of change ( @xmath110 to @xmath111 ) of @xmath9 in the glass transition regime .
the temperature @xmath31 , at which @xmath112 to @xmath113 corresponds to @xmath114 for fragile glass formers@xcite , which are applicable to many amorphous polymers .
it is surprising that such simple bead - spring model ( linear topology , without a side - chain group ) investigated in this study exhibits the temperature - dependencies of the shift factors on short and long time scales , which are qualitatively comparable with the experimental observations . -scaled temperature dependence of horizontal shift factors(@xmath66 and @xmath67 ) of @xmath12 melt ( upper ) and @xmath13 melt ( bottom ) .
the filled squares represent the logarithmic value of the @xmath67 , and the gray filled circles represent the ones of @xmath66 .
solid lines are least squares curves fit to the wlf equation ( eq.9).,height=377 ] -scaled temperature dependence of the ratio ( @xmath102 ) : the open circles represent the values of the @xmath12 melt , and the open triangles represent the values of the @xmath13 melt.solid and dot lines are drawn point - to - point with a straight line with no smoothing.,height=226 ] the self diffusion coefficient ( @xmath115 ) of a molecule in a liquid is affected by the viscosity(@xmath116 ) of the liquid . according to stokes - einstein law , @xmath117 should be constant with temperature .
however , a decoupling between the diffusion and the viscosity due to the dynamic heterogeneity near @xmath0 is reported in the experimental@xcite and theoretical@xcite studies on many supercooled liquid systems . to examine the relationship between the decoupling of @xmath115-@xmath116 relation and the breakdown of tts of @xmath1 , the temperature dependencies of the self diffusion coefficient of a chain and of the viscosity of @xmath12 melt
are additionally evaluated in this study .
the self diffusion coefficient of a chain is calculated from the mean square displacement of the center of mass ( @xmath118 ) of a chain as follows : @xmath119 where @xmath120 is position vector of the center of mass of @xmath57-th chain , @xmath121 is the total number of chains in the system . by using of einstein relation ,
@xmath115 is obtained as : @xmath122 @xmath115 at different temperatures are determined using each data of @xmath118 during @xmath123 to @xmath124 . on the other hand ,
the zero - shear viscosity @xmath116 of a liquid is given by : @xmath125 where @xmath126 is a positive number , and @xmath1 denotes a stress relaxation modulus .
due to the large fluctuation or the shortage of data of the long time scale part of @xmath3 obtained by md simulations , it is difficult to evaluate @xmath127 with eq.11 . and
so , the long part of @xmath3 is approximated by the stress relaxation modulus function based on rouse model , and @xmath128 can be rewritten as : @xmath129 where @xmath130 is an integral number from 1 to @xmath131 , @xmath132 is rouse relaxation time of a chain . assuming the parfect tts of @xmath3 at long time scale @xmath133 ( with @xmath68 = 100 @xmath27 ) , @xmath126 is chosen as @xmath134 , and @xmath132 has the same temperature dependence at @xmath135 and is expressed as @xmath136 .
@xmath137 is the rouse relaxation time at the refarence temperature ( @xmath93),which is estimated as @xmath138 , by fitting of rouse model to the data of the long time part of @xmath139 .
cnsequently , the value of the second term of the right - hand of eq.13 is obtained as @xmath140 .
the first term of right - hand of eq.13 is calculated by numerical integration of the @xmath3 vs. @xmath77 data .
figure 7 shows that temperature dependencies of @xmath141 and @xmath142 of fjc melt .
the @xmath141 and @xmath142 are divied by the corresponding value of each quanity at reference temperature @xmath143 .
these data of @xmath144 and @xmath145 can also be fit to the wlf equation ( eq.9 ) , and the wlf parameters were determined for @xmath12 melt as @xmath91 = 1.70 , @xmath92 = 0.66 ( @xmath146 $ ] ) and @xmath91 = 1.62 , @xmath92 = 0.65 ( @xmath147 $ ] ) , respectively .
though , @xmath141 and @xmath142 exhibit the same themperature dependence at temperatures sufficiently higher than its @xmath0 , @xmath142 has the somewhat greater themperature dependence than ones of @xmath141 when the system temperature approaches its @xmath0 ( @xmath148).this means that the breakdown of stokes - einstein law of viscosity - diffusion relation for @xmath12 melt occurs in the glass transition regime .
these trands of temperature dependence of @xmath115 and @xmath142 calculated in this study , are consistent with the experimentally observed ones of low molecular weight unentangled polystyrene@xcite .
although , the effect of the swelling of @xmath3 on the viscosity is greatly attenuated by the contribution of rouse modes at long time scale , the difference between @xmath145 and @xmath149 at low temperature is mainly originated from the swelling of @xmath3 at shourt time scale ( @xmath150 ) , which is the consequence of the breakdown of tts of @xmath3 .
therefore , assuming identical temperature dependence between @xmath141 and @xmath151 , the increasing of @xmath117 as decreasing temperature as shown in the inset figure of figure 7 can be explained from the viewpoint of the decreasing of @xmath152 at low temperature ( figure 3 ) . scaled temperature dependence of @xmath144 and @xmath145 for @xmath12 melt .
the open circles represent the values of @xmath144 and the open inverted triangles represent the value of @xmath145 .
solid and dashed lines are least squares curves fit to the wlf equation ( eq.9 ) for @xmath144 and @xmath145 , respectively .
the inset figure shows the the @xmath0-scaled temperature dependence of the ratio ( @xmath153 ) .
the filled squares represent the values calculated by means of md simulations , and solid line represent the same quantity but using wlf - fitted values for @xmath144 and @xmath145.,height=377 ] in order to explain the breakdown of the tts of @xmath1 , the dynamic heterogeneity in the @xmath12 melt was investigated . in the equilibrium state , the motion of each particle in a liquid is a simple continuous stochastic process due to thermal fluctuations independent from other particle movements .
however , when the system temperature is near the @xmath0 , instead of the continuous motion of an individual particle being frozen out , dynamic clusters of beads , the so - called cooperatively rearranged region ( @xmath154 ) , appeared .
the existence of @xmath154 leads to the dynamics of an amorphous polymer melt becoming very heterogeneous .
based on some viscoelastic and dielectric measurements , such a heterogeneity would bring about a breakdown of the tts of the relaxation process behavior in a polymer melt .
the degrees of the dynamic heterogeneity can be evaluated using the self - part of the van hove function , which is expressed by the followed equation : @xmath155 where @xmath156 is a position vector , @xmath49 is the number of beads , @xmath57 is an index of a bead , @xmath157 denotes the `` @xmath158 '' function , and @xmath159 and @xmath160 are the position and displacement vectors of @xmath57-th bead , respectively .
the @xmath161 and @xmath162 at @xmath31 = 1 and 0.48 as a function of @xmath163 are shown in figure 7(upper ) and 7(lower ) , respectively .
the dashed lines in fig.7 are the gaussian distributions represented by eq.10 , @xmath164 where @xmath165 is the root - mean - square displacement of the beads , @xmath165 = 0.47@xmath166 ( @xmath167 ) and @xmath165=2.1@xmath166 ( @xmath168 ) . both @xmath169 ) and @xmath170 at @xmath31
= 1 are in good agreement with each corresponding gaussian distribution .
this means that both bead motions for the short(@xmath171 ) and long(@xmath172 ) times at high temperature(@xmath31 = 1 ) can be expressed as a simple stochastic process .
however , when the system temperature ( @xmath31 = 0.48 ) approaches its glass transition temperature ( @xmath0 = 0.44 ) , the bead motions on the short time scale(@xmath173 ) deviate from the gaussian distribution , and exhibit a broader distribution .
@xmath174 at @xmath31 = 0.48 again becomes a gaussian distribution on the long time scale(@xmath175 ) . in order to specify the duration of the heterogeneous period , the non - gaussian parameter(@xmath6 )
is evaluated from eq.11 .
@xmath176 the value of @xmath6 is a statistical value showing the degree of deviation from a gaussian distribution .
@xmath6 = 0 means that its distribution is equivalent to a gaussian .
the higher @xmath6 , the more its distribution deviates from a gaussian shape .
figure 8 shows @xmath6 at @xmath31 = 1 and @xmath31 = 0.48 as a function of the logarithmic time .
@xmath6 at @xmath31 = 1 ( filled triangles in fig.8 ) , which is sufficiently higher than the temperature in its glass transition region , is nearly zero on the plotted time scale ( @xmath77 = 0.001 to 1000@xmath27 ) .
in contrast , @xmath6 at @xmath31 = 0.48 ( open circles in fig.8 ) , which is near its @xmath0(@xmath0 = 0.44 ) , exhibits a maximum value around @xmath177 = 0.4 @xmath27 and @xmath6 rapidly decreased to zero at times longer than @xmath177 > 1@xmath27 , which corresponds to the period for the @xmath178 that begins to collapse to the master curve .
this strongly suggested that the breakdown of tts of @xmath1 is related to its dynamic heterogeneity . from the experimental observations
, it also suggests the relationships between the breakdown of tts and its dynamic heterogeneity.@xcite melt at @xmath31 = 1 and @xmath31 = 0.48 .
the upper graph represents @xmath179 with dt @xmath180 @xmath69 @xmath180 @xmath181 , for which the root mean square displacements of beads in melts at @xmath31 = 1 and at @xmath31 = 0.48 are approximately 0.5 @xmath16 .
the lower graph represents @xmath179 with dt @xmath180 @xmath68 @xmath180 @xmath181 , for which one of the beads in the melts at @xmath31 = 1 and at @xmath31 = 0.48 are approximately 2.1 @xmath16 .
the broken lines in each graph are the gaussian form ( eq.10 ) with @xmath165 = 0.47 @xmath16 and 2.1 @xmath16.,height=377 ] of @xmath12 melt as a function of @xmath86-scaled time .
the open circles represent the values of @xmath182 at @xmath31 = 0.48 , and the filled triangles represent the values of @xmath182 at @xmath31 = 1.0 .
dot lines are drawn point - to - point with a straight line with no smoothing.,height=188 ]
it has been in this study the breakdown of the time - temperature superposition ( tts ) near its glass transition temperature ( @xmath0 ) in simple bead - spring polymer melts with and without a chain angle potential .
the stress relaxation modulus at different temperatures @xmath1 are calculated by the green - kubo relations .
the tts of @xmath1 in the bead - spring polymer melts works well at temperatures sufficiently higher than its @xmath0 .
however , when the system temperature is approaching the glass transition regime , a breakdown of the tts is observed .
+ at temperatures near the @xmath0 , the temperature dependence of the shift factor ( @xmath2 ) , which is defined on the time scale between the bond relaxation and the chain relaxation regimes of a @xmath3-function , is significantly stronger than ones ( @xmath4 ) defined on the time scale of the chain relaxation modes.the decoupling of the stokes - einstein law of diffusion - viscosity relation also appears in association with the breakdown of tts of @xmath1 in the glass transition regime .
+ the analysis of the van hove function @xmath5 and non - gaussian parameter @xmath6 of the bead motions strongly suggest that the breakdown of tts is concerned with the dynamic heterogeneity .
+ the effect of the chain stiffness on the temperature dependence of the shift factors was also investigated in this study .
the stiffer chain melt has a stronger temperature dependence of the shift factors than the ones of the flexible chain melt .
however , regardless of the chain stiffness , the stress relaxation modulus functions of the bead - spring polymer melts will begin to breakdown the tts at a similar temperature around @xmath183 .
it is very interesting that such a simple bead - spring model ( linear topology , without side - chain group ) investigated in this study , exhibits the temperature - dependencies of the shift factors on the short and long time scales , which are qualitatively comparable to the broadband dielectric relaxation spectroscopy in several well - defined homo - polymers .
this unexpectedly implies that the simple polymer model , such as a bead - spring model , can be applicable to the investigation of the universal behaviors that appear in a supercooled polymer melt .
the author thanks professor j.takimoto at yamagata university , department of polymer science and engineering , for the very valuable suggestions and advice .
the author also thanks the members of the working group for computer chemistry of the japan association for chemical innovation , that deepens the utilization and application research of integrated simulator for soft materials ; octa , for their useful discussions . | the breakdown of the time - temperature superposition ( tts ) near its glass transition temperature ( @xmath0 ) in simple bead - spring polymer melts with and without the chain angle potential was numerically investigated .
the stress relaxation modulus at different temperatures @xmath1 was calculated by the green - kubo relation .
the tts of @xmath1 of bead - spring polymer melts worked well at temperatures sufficiently higher than its @xmath0 .
however , when the system temperature is approaching the glass transition regime , the breakdown of tts is observed . at temperatures near the @xmath0 ,
the temperature dependence of the shift factor ( @xmath2 ) , which is defined at the time scale between the bond relaxation and the chain relaxation regimes of a @xmath3-function , is significantly stronger than ones ( @xmath4 ) defined by the time scale of the chain relaxation modes . in direct relation to the breakdown of tts of @xmath1
, the decoupling of stokes - einstein law of diffusion - viscosity relation also appears in the glass transition regime .
the analysis of the van hove function @xmath5 and non - gaussian parameter , @xmath6 , of the bead motions strongly suggest that the tts breakdown is concerned with the dynamic heterogeneity .
the effect of the chain stiffness on the temperature dependence of the shift factors was also investigated in this study .
the stiffer chains melt has a stronger temperature dependence of the shift factors than the ones of the flexible chains melt .
however , regardless of the chain stiffness , the stress relaxation modulus functions of the bead - spring polymer melts will begin to breakdown the tts at a similar @xmath0-normalized temperature around @xmath7 . |
the prediction of an attractive force between two uncharged , perfectly reflecting plane - parallel plates embedded in vacuum by h. b. g. casimir back in 1948 turned out to be a milestone on the way to modern quantum physics @xcite .
the equilibrium casimir effect can be equivalently ascribed to quantum zero - point fluctuations of the electromagnetic field , or to charge and current fluctuations in the plates @xcite . by introducing objects to the quantum vacuum , forces appear due to topological constraints .
casimir s famous formula for the equilibrium energy @xmath0 @xmath1 was rederived and verified many times ( e.g. see ref .
@xcite ) . in the present notation @xmath2 denotes the separation between the plates , @xmath3 their surface area , @xmath4 the speed of light , and @xmath5 the reduced planck constant , indicating the quantum nature of the casimir effect .
the casimir effect is relevant on small length scales ( e.g. on the submicron scale ) . shortly after casimir
s breakthrough , the formalism was further developed to be applicable to any kind of dielectric media at finite temperature @xcite .
the rapid development of casimir physics culminated in the birth of fluctuational electrodynamics in the 1950s @xcite . on the experimental side
, scientists were able to quantitatively verify the existence of the theoretically predicted forces in high - precision measurements for the first time around the turn of the millennium @xcite .
consequently , many sources of imprecision in force measurements between objects at close proximity were identified and remedied . a few years ago , the attractivity of the casimir force was reversed by a suitable choice of interacting materials immersed in a fluid @xcite .
the reversal of the algebraic sign of the force verified the theoretical predictions made by lifshitz over 50 years ago @xcite .
recently , situations out of equilibrium have entered the limelight of theory . in this context ,
phenomena such as vacuum friction or objects at different temperatures have been investigated @xcite .
casimir forces in thermal non - equilibrium have been computed for a variety of different set - ups , e.g. for parallel plates @xcite , deformed plates @xcite , between dielectric gratings @xcite , between cylinders @xcite , between a sphere and a plate @xcite , between atoms and surfaces @xcite , between three bodies @xcite , and for inhomogeneous media @xcite . also interactions between brownian charges at different temperatures
have been studied @xcite . moreover ,
non - equilibrium casimir forces have been computed in fluid or other classical systems @xcite . generally , in thermal non - equilibrium
, forces can be repulsive @xcite , exhibit different power laws @xcite , show stable points @xcite or levitation @xcite . for two spheres with different temperatures , points of self - propelled pairs
have been observed @xcite , where the two identical spheres feel equal forces in the same direction for a specific choice of parameters .
the subject of self - propulsion has become a very popular topic also in fluid systems , where small particles are propelled through different means @xcite . in this paper
, we study the casimir force for anisotropic objects in thermal non - equilibrium focusing first on self - propulsion , employing methods of fluctuational electrodynamics and classical scattering theory . in sec .
[ sec : non_eq_force_two_objects ] , we review the force formulas for two objects in thermal non - equilibrium from ref . @xcite . in sec .
[ sec : self_prop_isolation ] , we give a compact expression for the self - propulsion force for a particle _ in isolation _
, also providing a simplified version valid for a small particle . as an example
, we explicitly calculate the force for an almost transparent janus particle . in sec .
[ sec : arbitrary_object_in_front_of_a _ plate ] , we add a smooth plate to our set - up and ask for the lateral casimir force alongside the plate . in particular , we examine the case where the separation @xmath2 between particle and plate is much smaller than the thermal wavelength @xmath6 ( roughly @xmath7{\mu m}$ ] at room temperature ) , i.e. , in the so - called near field limit . following the derivation of the lateral casimir force
, we explicitly calculate the case of a spheroid in sec .
[ sec : lateral_force_spheroid ] . finally , in sec .
[ sec : linear_response ] , we discuss our results from the viewpoint of linear response theory , arguing for an additional term in the friction for an anisotropic particle moving parallel to the surface .
appendices provide technical details and definitions .
in this section , in order to keep this article self - contained , we briefly review the formulae and relations for the non - equilibrium casimir force , closely sticking to ref .
readers interested only in the new results of this article may skip this section . and @xmath8 , respectively , embedded in vacuum in an environment at temperature @xmath9 . sec .
[ sec : non_eq_force_two_objects ] reviews the general force formulas for this situation from ref .
@xcite . ]
let us consider the situation of two arbitrary ( in terms of shape and material properties ) objects at different temperatures @xmath10 and @xmath8 embedded in vacuum in an environment at finite temperature @xmath9 as illustrated in fig .
[ fig : twoobjects ] . in such a non - equilibrium situation the total ( casimir ) force
acting on object 1 can be written as a sum consisting of all thermal and quantum contributions @xcite @xmath11 the terms in the sum , @xmath12 and @xmath13 account for the force contributions due to the thermal sources in objects 1 and 2 , respectively .
@xmath14 is the contribution due to thermal fluctuations of the environment .
the last term @xmath15 incorporates the contribution from zero point fluctuations , i.e. , it is the usual zero - temperature casimir force . by introducing the equilibrium casimir force @xmath16 at finite temperature , we can get rid of the environment contribution and are able to rewrite the total force as @xcite @xmath17\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] this remarkable result states that the force contribution due to sources in the environment does not have to be computed . in the following ,
we give the different contributions in a basis - independent representation in terms of two well - known quantities : the dyadic free green s function @xmath18 and the classical scattering operator @xmath19 for the objects in isolation , both @xmath18 and @xmath19 being @xmath20 spacial matrices depending on two position vectors @xmath21 and @xmath22 .
the precise definitions of these two quantities are given in appendix [ app : greens_function ] and [ app : scattering_operator ] , respectively .
the first contribution to the force on object 1 , @xmath12 originates from thermal charge and current fluctuations within object 1 itself ( which we then refer to as _ self - force _ ) . in operator notation
this term reads @xcite @xmath23-\mathbb{t}_1{\operatorname{im}}[\mathbb{g}_0]\mathbb{t}_1^*]\frac{1}{1-\mathbb{g}_0^*\mathbb{t}_2^*\mathbb{g}_0^*\mathbb{t}_1^*}\bigg\}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that each operator product in eq . contains a matrix multiplication as well as a spacial integral over a common coodinate .
the trace in eq finally is meant over both the @xmath20 matrix as well as the positions @xmath21 and @xmath24 of the resulting operator .
this operator trace can be converted into a more familiar trace over matrix elements in a partial wave representation , yielding closed form equations for specific geometries . for the second contribution to the total force on object 1 evoked by the fluctuations within object @xmath25 ( the _ interaction force _ ) one writes @xcite @xmath26-\mathbb{t}_2{\operatorname{im}}[\mathbb{g}_0]\mathbb{t}_2^*]\mathbb{g}_0^*\frac{1}{1-\mathbb{t}_1^*\mathbb{g}_0^*\mathbb{t}_2^*\mathbb{g}_0^*}\mathbb{t}_1^*\bigg\}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] finally , for completeness , we provide also the more familiar expression for the equilibrium force acting on object 1 at thermal equilibrium at temperature @xmath27 , given by ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) @xmath28\nonumber\times\\ & { \operatorname{im}}{{\rm tr}}\bigg\{\nabla\mathbb{g}_0\mathbb{t}_2\frac{1}{1-\mathbb{g}_0\mathbb{t}_1\mathbb{g}_0\mathbb{t}_2}\mathbb{g}_0\mathbb{t}_1\bigg\}\,.\label{eq : eq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we note , that in contrast to the non - equilibrium force in eqs . and
the equilibrium force does not exhibit @xmath18 being sandwiched by @xmath19 operators of the same object @xcite .
besides , the equilibrium force satisfies @xmath29 as expected , while the forces in non - equilibrium are not equal and opposite in general @xcite .
finally , we recall that eqs . and can not obviously be integrated to obtain an energy , also in contrast to eq . . in the following section , sec
[ sec : self_prop_isolation ] , we will analyze equation for the case of one object in isolation , being at a different temperature than the environment ( this force is then denoted the _ self - propulsion _ force ) . in sec .
[ sec : arbitrary_object_in_front_of_a _ plate ] , a planar surface is added as object 2 , and the force in eq .
parallel to the surface is studied ( i.e. , the change of self - propulsion due to the presence of the surface ) .
in order to obtain the total casimir force for an object in isolation ( which we call the _ self - propulsion force _ ) , we start by removing the second object from eq . , i.e. , we set @xmath30 , and obtain @xmath31\notag\\&-\mathbb{t}_1{\operatorname{im}}[\mathbb{g}_0]\mathbb{t}_1^*\big]\big\}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] due to the facts that @xmath18 is translationally invariant , @xmath32 , and @xmath33 is a symmetric operator , a partial integration of the first term shows that it is identically zero .
it can thus be exactly rewritten to@xmath34\mathbb{t}_1^*\big]\big\}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] this is the force acting on an isolated arbitrary object at temperature @xmath10 in an environment at zero temperature . in order to obtain the force for a finite @xmath9 , the same expression , evaluated at @xmath9 ,
must be subtracted ( see eq . and recall that the force is zero in equilibrium ) .
we thus have the exact expression for the force on the object , i.e. , the self - propulsion force @xmath35\notag\times\\&{\operatorname{re}}{{\rm tr}}\bigg\{\nabla\mathbb{g}_0\big[\mathbb{t}_1{\operatorname{im}}[\mathbb{g}_0]\mathbb{t}_1^*\big]\bigg\}\ , .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the following subsections , we will analyze this term for special cases , thereby for brevity of notation dropping the subscript @xmath36 and setting @xmath37 . by using the techniques presented in detail in ref .
@xcite , we expand the force formulae of the previous section in the spherical wave basis ( see appendix [ app : spherical_basis ] for details ) . applying this procedure to eq .
, we obtain @xmath38 in this equation @xmath39 comprises the discrete matrix of the classical scattering operator @xmath19 for waves with quantum numbers @xmath40 and @xmath41 and polarization @xmath42 , see appendix [ app : t_elements ] . primed indices denote incoming waves , while unprimed denote scattered ones .
@xmath43 is the infinitesimal translation operator which plays the role of a spatial derivative @xcite , it is given explicitly in eq .
below . finally , the representation of the self - propulsion force in the equation above implies matrix multiplications over the given indices @xmath44 .
the properties of the spherical basis are introduced in appendix [ app : spherical_basis ] .
for the @xmath45th component of the self - propulsion force the trace in eq . turns into ( using the einstein summation convention ) @xmath46 where , regarding without loss of generality the @xmath47-component of the force , one has @xmath48\}\,\delta_{m'm}\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath49 the self - propulsion force is expected to vanish for isotropic objects , as can be easily seen for the case of a homogeneous sphere , where the matrix @xmath50 is diagonal ( see e.g. eq . below ) . as the @xmath43 matrix has only off - diagonal terms , eq .
is zero for that case .
this observation corresponds to our physical expectation , since an object can only be self - propelled if there is a preferred direction of radiation .
. is valid for an object of any size and shape . in this subsection
, we aim to collect the leading terms ( leading matrix elements ) contributing to the self - propulsion force for a small object .
such leading terms will be dominant if the size of the object ( denoting @xmath51 as the largest dimension of the anisotropic object ) is the smallest scale involved , i.e. , if @xmath51 is small compared to the thermal wavelength @xmath52 ( which is roughly @xmath7{\mu m}$ ] at room temperature ) , as well as the material skin depth . in lowest order in @xmath51 , we find that the off - diagonal elements @xmath53 and @xmath54 contribute , and more specifically , for the @xmath47-component of the force , @xmath55\nonumber\\ & -b(1,m){\operatorname{im}}[\mathcal{t}^{n , n}_{2m,1m'}\mathcal{t}^{*\,n , n}_{1m,1m'}]\big)+\mathcal{o}(r^8 ) .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] as @xmath53 and @xmath54 are of order @xmath56 and @xmath57 , the self - propulsion force is found to be of order @xmath58 for small @xmath51 . in order to demonstrate the power of our derived formulae , we explicitly evaluate the self - propulsion force for a janus particle of radius @xmath51 at temperature @xmath27 , which is almost transparent , i.e. , @xmath59 , see fig .
[ fig : j ] . in this limit , the classical scattering operator @xmath60 , where @xmath61 is the potential introduced by the objects @xcite . taking @xmath62
local and isotropic , the electric response of the janus particle reduces to the scalar @xmath63\theta(r - r)}$ ] , where @xmath64 is the unit step function and @xmath65 is the radial distance measured from the center of the sphere . by additionally assuming our particle to be non -
magnetizable , we can easily calculate the @xmath50 matrix elements defined in appendix [ app : t_elements ] .
in leading order , we arrive at @xmath66({\operatorname{re}}[\varepsilon_1]-1)\nonumber\\ & -{\operatorname{im}}[\varepsilon_1]({\operatorname{re}}[\varepsilon_2]-1)\}\bigg]+\mathcal{o}(r^{11})+\mathcal{o}(\varepsilon-1)^3\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] this result holds up to order @xmath67 and @xmath68 . by setting @xmath69
we can verify again that the force vanishes for a homogeneous sphere to the given order .
and @xmath70 at temperature @xmath27
. the particle is embedded in vacuum at temperature @xmath9.[fig : j ] ]
in a process of miniaturization , manufacturers of technical devices try to decrease the dimension of their products .
these compact technical solutions use components with a size of several micrometers or even nanotechnology . on these scales ,
casimir forces have to be considered in order to avoid unintended effects such as `` stiction '' , meaning components sticking together and disturbing the functionality of the device @xcite .
for instance , micro - electromechanical systems ( mems ) are hugely influenced in their behavior by casimir physics .
these devices are made up of components between @xmath36 to @xmath71{\mu m}$ ] in size being located in close proximity .
regarding situations out of equilibrium , it has been found that the forces between a sphere and a plate can show properties very different from equilibrium counterparts , including e.g. levitation @xcite . in ref .
@xcite , the force normal to the surface was investigated . in this section ,
we want to focus on the other component , i.e. , pointing _ alongside _ the plate : the lateral casimir force , which again , we denote the _ self - propulsion force _ , as it propels the object parallel to the surface , i.e. , in a direction where the system is translationally invariant , see fig . [ fig:2 ] . ) , which due to translational invariance vanishes identically in equilibrium . ] in thermal equilibrium , a lateral force can not be observed for any kind of object due to the mentioned translation invariance of the arrangement .
however , in a non - equilibrium situation we can not invoke such arguments , and , depending on the symmetries of the object , we will indeed observe a lateral force below .
we start again from the exact expression for the self - force in eq . , which , written in the spherical basis reads @xcite , @xmath72\nonumber\times\\ & ( 1+\mathcal{t}\mathcal{u}\mathcal{t}_p\mathcal{u})^{-1}\bigg[\frac{\mathcal{t}^\dagger+\mathcal{t}}{2}+\mathcal{t}\mathcal{t}^\dagger\bigg](1+\mathcal{u}^\dagger\mathcal{t}_p^\dagger\mathcal{u}^\dagger\mathcal{t}^\dagger)^{-1}\bigg\}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] we aim to analyze this equation for the case of a small object ( with scattering matrix @xmath50 ) in front of a planar surface ( with scattering matrix @xmath73 ) , hence expanding in powers of @xmath50 ( see app .
[ app : plane_wave_basis ] for details on the plane wave basis , and app .
[ app : conversion_matrix ] for details on the conversion matrices @xmath74 ) .
furthermore , we aim at the behavior of the force at small distance @xmath2 , i.e. , in the near - field regime with @xmath75 ( the size @xmath51 of the object is nevertheless assumed small compared to @xmath2 ) .
interestingly , the leading term , which is linear in both @xmath73 and @xmath50 ( the one - reflection approximation `` ) is identically zero due to the translational invariance of the planar surface along @xmath76 . the leading term in the near - field ( see eq .
below ) is hence quadratic in both @xmath73 and @xmath50 , resulting from two ' ' reflections .
@xmath77 of the plate turns into the fresnel coefficients ( see appendix [ app : t_elements ] for details ) . in the considered limit of @xmath75 ,
only the fresnel coefficient for electric polarization contributes , and only its limit for infinite wave vector ( where @xmath78 is the dielectric function of the plate ) , @xmath79 we arrive at the following expression for the force , valid for @xmath80 , ( here , the terms with @xmath81 and @xmath82 dominate , and for brevity , we have omitted the index @xmath40 and superscript @xmath42 at @xmath83 and give only the indices @xmath41 and @xmath84 , e.g. @xmath85 ) @xmath86 ^ 2\sum_{m}a_{m}{\operatorname{re}}[\mathcal{t}_{0,m}\mathcal{t}^*_{1,m}-\mathcal{t}_{-1,m}\mathcal{t}^*_{0,m}]\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath87 takes the values @xmath88 for @xmath89 and @xmath90 for @xmath91 .
. allows the computation of the lateral casimir force in the near - field limit for an arbitrary object in front of a plate in thermal non - equilibrium and constitutes one of our main results .
the leading order term is of order @xmath92 and behaves like @xmath93 in the given limit @xmath94 .
it is striking that only the imaginary part of the reflection coefficient contributes to the lateral force in the given limit .
the lateral casimir force in the near - field is an effect due to evanescent wave contribution .
we note that the term in eq .
vanishes in the limit where the plate approaches a perfect reflector ( @xmath95 ) .
we also computed the force on the object due to the fluctuations in the plate , i.e. , the interaction force @xmath96 in eq . .
we found that it exactly equals eq . in the given limit ,
i.e , @xmath97 in the near field limit , the temperature of the environment is expected to be negligible ; furthermore , as any equilibrium contribution in eq . vanishes for the considered components , eq . was expected , and its direct confirmation is a consistency check for our computations .
hence , in the given limit , the total lateral casimir force can now be computed for any combinations of the temperature @xmath27 of the object and the temperature @xmath98 of the plate , @xmath99 this relation remains true for the forces found in eqs .
, , and below . often the polarizability tensor @xcite of small objects ( nanoparticles ) is better known than the @xmath83 matrix elements in eq . , and we also convert eq . into a form containing these
explicitly ( see appendix [ app : polarizability_tensor ] for details ) .
we find @xmath100 ^ 2 { \operatorname{im}}\left[\alpha_{zx}\alpha_{xx}^*+\alpha_{zy}\alpha_{xy}^*+2\alpha_{zz}\alpha_{xz}^*\right]\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath101 is the @xmath102 component of the @xmath20 dimensional polarizability tensor @xcite .
the strong dependence of the force on the spatial orientation of the object becomes apparent from eq . .
in the case of a sphere , the off - diagonal components of the polarizability tensor are identically zero and we confirm once more that the lateral force vanishes in that case .
we finally note that the self - propulsion force for a small object near a surface scales as @xmath103 for small @xmath51 , while it scales as @xmath58 for a free particle , compare eq . .
we also note that the force for an isolated particle can not be described by a polarizability tensor ( higher asymmetries are neccessary ) in contrast to eq . .
finally , a computation for a dilute janus particle , compare eq .
, yields in the presence of a surface a force of order @xmath58 , so that forces in the presence of a plate are generally much stronger than for isolated particles .
spheroids , i.e. , ellipsoids with an axis of rotational symmetry , are suitable candidates in order to observe lateral casimir forces in front of a plate in thermal non - equilibrium as they exhibit an explicit anisotropy [ equilibrium forces involving ellipsoids have been studied in detail @xcite , which are however irrelevant for our discussion ] . in this section ,
we focus on the case of a prolate ( cigar - shaped ) spheroid , for which @xmath104 , where @xmath105 and @xmath106 denote the radius parallel and perpendicular to the axis of symmetry .
the orientation of the spheroid with respect to the surface is described by the two angles @xmath107 and @xmath108 , see fig .
[ fig : schematic_spheroids ] .
the spheroid s polarizability can then be expressed by the two components , @xmath109 where @xmath110 and @xmath111 are unit vectors pointing along the axis of rotational symmetry and perpendicular to it , respectively ( and the superscript @xmath27 denotes the transpose of the vector ) .
eq . is then directly rewritten to @xmath112 ^ 2{\operatorname{im}}\left[\alpha_\parallel\alpha_\perp^*\right]\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in this equation @xmath27 is the temperature of the spheroid and the temperature of the plate can be added according to eq .
. the rotation angles @xmath107 and @xmath108 appear as they translate the local coordinate system into the global frame as described in appendix [ app : polarizability_tensor ] .
the force in @xmath76-direction is maximal for @xmath113 and @xmath114 .
sketch of an object with axis of rotational symmetry , and the definition of the angles @xmath107 and @xmath108 appearing in eq . .
the object is mimicked by an arrow , which points in the direction of the axis of rotational symmetry . ] in order to evaluate eq .
numerically , we resort to the polarizabilities for spheroids given in refs .
@xcite , @xmath115 with the dielectric permittivity @xmath116 and the geometrical factors @xmath117 for prolate spheroids , @xmath118 here , @xmath119 is the eccentricity of the spheroid . for a prolate spheroid ( @xmath104 ) ,
the dielectric responses of the materials , making up the plate and the spheroid , are modeled by the simple form @xmath121 the parameters are given in table [ table:1 ] and resemble realistic values @xcite .
.[table:1 ] parameters for the oscillator model of the dielectric function of spheroid and plate , where superscripts refer to fig .
[ fig : optanisotropie]@xmath122 and fig .
[ fig : optkugelform]@xmath123 . @xmath124 and @xmath125 are given in rad / sec , @xmath126 is dimensionless . [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] in order to understand the behavior of the force as a function of the involved parameters , we first investigate the factor @xmath127 $ ] in eq . as a function of frequency @xmath128 for different values of @xmath129 ,
see fig .
[ fig : polarizabilites ] ( we keep the spheroid s volume fixed ) . by rewriting the imaginary part , @xmath130={\operatorname{re}}[\alpha_\perp]{\operatorname{im}}[\alpha_\parallel]-{\operatorname{re}}[\alpha_\parallel]{\operatorname{im}}[\alpha_\perp]\,,\ ] ]
we note that this term yields two contributions being responsible for the two peaks seen in fig .
[ fig : polarizabilites ] . for small ratios , @xmath131 ,
these two peaks are far away from each other on the frequency axis ( since the resonances in @xmath132 and @xmath133 are far away from each other ) and also rather small ( since the products @xmath134{\operatorname{im}}[\alpha_\parallel]$ ] are small for the same reason ) , cf . blue curve . for higher ratios of @xmath135
the two contributions become larger and larger ( cf .
green curve ) as now the overlap between @xmath132 and @xmath133 increases .
ultimately , for @xmath136 , where the spheroid approaches a sphere , the peaks decrease to zero , as @xmath137\rightarrow 0 $ ] for @xmath138 .
imaginary part of @xmath139 for different ratios of @xmath135 upon constant volume over the rescaled frequency axis @xmath140 in @xmath141 .
the curves are normalized by the maximal value shown in the graph . ]
having analyzed @xmath127 $ ] , it is evident , that the factor @xmath142 ^ 2 $ ] in eq .
, being peaked as a function of @xmath128 as well , strongly influences the expected force , too .
[ fig : optanisotropie ] shows the lateral force ( the self - propulsion force ) for the peak in @xmath142 ^ 2 $ ] located at @xmath143{rad/\mu m}$ ] , corresponding to the second row in table [ table:1 ] .
we show the force for @xmath144 k and @xmath145 k , and the angles @xmath114 and @xmath113 are chosen to maximize eq . .
in order to give the force in useful units , we show its ratio to the corresponding gravitational force acting on the object , with a mass density of @xmath146{g\ , cm^{-3}}$ ] .
we see that in fig .
[ fig : optanisotropie ] , the force is maximal for @xmath147 , where the left peak of the red curve in fig .
[ fig : polarizabilites ] overlaps with the peak of @xmath142 ^ 2 $ ] .
the force is in the range of permills of the gravitational force . in fig .
[ fig : optanisotropie ] , we show the force for the same parameters , but now @xmath142 ^ 2 $ ] has a peak at @xmath148{rad/\mu m}$ ] , corresponding to the third row in table [ table:1 ] .
the force is now maximal for @xmath149 , where the left peak of the green curve in fig .
[ fig : polarizabilites ] overlaps with the peak of @xmath142 ^ 2 $ ] .
notably , it is of the order of the gravitational force , hence being well in the detectable regime , e.g. using fly - by experiments , where the changes in particle trajectory can be detected @xcite . imagining a spheroid rotating around the @xmath150-axis while flying parallel to a surface
, the periodic accelerations should be visible .
lateral casimir force for a prolate spheroid ( temperature @xmath151{k}$ ] ) of fixed radius @xmath152{nm}$ ] in front of a plate ( temperature @xmath153{k}$ ] ) as a function of @xmath135 .
the force is normalized by the gravitation force @xmath154 .
the distance between spheroid and plate was set at @xmath155{nm}$ ] .
the perpendicular radius @xmath106 was varied from @xmath156{nm}$ ] to @xmath157{nm}$ ] . ]
lateral casimir force for a prolate spheroid of fixed radius @xmath152{nm}$ ] in front of a plate as a function of @xmath135 with the same set - up parameters as in fig .
[ fig : optanisotropie ] , but with a different material of the plate ( cf .
table [ table:1 ] ) . ]
in this section , we would like to connect our findings for the self - propulsion force to other experimentally measurable quantities . in subsection [ sec : on ] , we exploit the onsager theorem in order to predict the heating of the particle when flying parallel to a planar surface with a given velocity @xmath158 . in subsection
[ sec : ts ] , we discuss a subtle additional contribution to the casimir friction force felt by the particle . the onsager theorem ( proven explicitly for fluctuational electrodynamics in ref .
@xcite ) , relates two distinct ( experimental ) set - ups , where the global equilibrium is disturbed by different means . in set - up i ) , starting from equilibrium , one perturbs the temperature of one of the objects , and asks for the change of casimir force due to that . in set - up
ii ) , again starting from equilibrium , one perturbs the system by driving one of the objects with a constant velocity , and asks for the change of its temperature ( more precisely the change in its total heat absorption @xmath159 ) .
the onsager theorem then states , @xmath160 in this equation @xmath161 and @xmath162 can be either of the two objects @xmath163 . specifically exploiting this relation for
the set - up considered in the previous sections , we can predict the heating of the anisotropic particle , when it is driven parallel to the surface at constant velocity @xmath158 .
it follows directly from eq .
( which we also have to expand in temperature differences in order to make linear response theory valid ) , @xmath164 ^ 2\sum_m a_m{\operatorname{re}}\left[\mathcal{t}_{-1,m}\mathcal{t}_{0,m}^*-\mathcal{t}_{0,m}\mathcal{t}_{1,m}^*\right]\ , . \end{aligned}\ ] ] we note that the same manipulations performed for the force in the previous sections can also be performed here , such that eqs . and are as well linked to the heating of the polarizable object .
we also note that @xmath165 can be positive or negative , depending on the direction of driving with respect to the orientation of the particle , so that the anisotropic particle is heated or cooled .
last , for an isotropic object , this expression is identically zero as is the self - propulsion force , and @xmath166 , such that the heating of the particle will be of higher order in @xmath158 .
imagine the anisotropic particle moving parallel to the surface with constant velocity @xmath158 . due to this motion and eq . , the temperature of the particle will change , with @xmath167 linear in @xmath158 .
according to our computations in the main text , this change in temperature will result in a lateral casimir force , which constitutes an _ additional contribution to the particle s friction _ force .
this friction force is linear in @xmath158 , and hence additional to the standard approaches for computation of friction , as e.g. in refs .
it appears for anisotropic particles , and regardless of the particle heating up or cooling down , always increases the friction . from eq .
, this additional friction force seems to vanish for @xmath168 .
another well - known relation in linear response relates the above mentioned friction coefficient @xmath169 to the fluctuations of forces @xmath170 in equilibrium ( the so - called kirkwood formula @xcite ) @xmath171 where @xmath172 represents the force fluctuations .
gives the time dependent friction coefficient , if , for @xmath173 , the particle was at rest , and for @xmath174 , the particle moves with constant velocity @xmath175 .
we can now discuss two distinct time scales of that friction , following our discussion in the previous subsection .
first , there is a quick adjustment of the friction due to the reaction rate of the charge and current fluctuations in the materials , which we expect on the time scale related to typical frequencies appearing in casimir integrals , i.e , of the order of @xmath176 .
second , as discussed above , the particle if anisotropic will change its temperature , giving rise to the additional friction contribution . the time scale for it is much longer , related to the time necessary to change the particle s temperature . interestingly , with eq .
, this time scale should also visible in the fluctuations of @xmath170 , more specifically , in its time dependent autocorrelator .
this is physical , as now , the force depends on the particles temperature , and therefore @xmath177 is influenced by temperature fluctuations of the object ( or more precisely , by fluctuations of its internal energy @xmath178 ) .
following arguments of ref .
@xcite , the time scale of fluctuations of @xmath179 is estimated to be @xmath180 , where @xmath181 is the object s heat capacity and @xmath182 is the heat transfer coefficient , connecting the object to its environment ( including the plate ) . this time scale is typically in the micro- to millisecond regime @xcite and hence much larger then the electronic @xmath183 .
this discussion is sketched in fig .
[ fig : friction_force ] . principle behavior of the time - dependent friction coefficient for an anisotropic particle in front of a plate , moving at constant velocity @xmath158 for @xmath184 . in the evolution of time
two contributions show up , exhibiting the signatures of different time scales @xmath183 and @xmath185 .
@xmath183 is due to charge fluctuations , while @xmath185 is due to fluctuations of internal energy of the particle , and is absent for isotropic particles .
the dashed line represents the stationary friction coefficient as proposed by standard approaches for computation of friction .
the details for @xmath186 are omitted due to unknown behavior in this regime . ]
using fluctuational electrodynamics , we have studied the phenomenon of self - propulsion through casimir forces in thermal non - equilibrium in two scenarios . for an isolated object
the self - propulsion force is found to be of order @xmath187 for small @xmath51 ( denoting @xmath51 as the largest dimension of the object ) .
as expected , the self - propulsion force vanishes for isotropic objects .
we then add a planar surface to our set - up focusing on the self - propulsion of the object alongside the surface , i.e. , the lateral casimir force . in the near - field , where the separation @xmath2 between particle and plate is much smaller than the thermal wavelength @xmath188 ( which is roughly @xmath7{\mu m}$ ] at room temperature ) , the leading order term for small and anisotropic particles is of order @xmath92 and diverges like @xmath93 . rewriting the force formula in terms of polarizabilities ,
we expose the strong dependence of the lateral force on the spatial orientation of the object . for the case of a spheroid
we show that the force can be as large as the gravitational force , thus being potentially measurable in experiments . finally , we link our results to relations of linear response theory in fluctuational electrodynamics . exploiting the onsager theorem
we can predict the heating or cooling of the anisotropic particle , when it is driven parallel to the surface at constant velocity @xmath158 .
this change in temperature leads to a lateral casimir force , which constitutes an additional contribution to the particle s friction force linear in @xmath158 compared to the standard approaches for computation of friction .
we close by specifying the time scales @xmath183 and @xmath185 of the two contributions to the friction , where the time scale of the standard approach is assumed to be of the order of @xmath189{s}$ ] and the time scale of the correction term is typically in the micro- to millisecond regime .
we thank m.t.h .
reid , e.d .
tomlinson , g. bimonte , t. emig , r. l. jaffe , m. kardar and n. graham for discussions .
this research was supported by deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft ( dfg ) grant no .
kr 3844/2 - 1 and mit - germany seed fund grant no .
in classical electrodynamics the electric field obeys the helmholtz equation @xcite @xmath191{\mathbf{e}}(\omega,{\mathbf{r}})=0\;,\ ] ] where @xmath192 describes free space , and @xmath193 is the potential introduced by the objects .
thus , the dyadic free green s function is defined by @xcite @xmath194\mathbb{g}({\mathbf{r}},{\mathbf{r}}')=\mathbb{i}\delta^{(3)}({\mathbf{r}}-{\mathbf{r}}')\;.\ ] ] accordingly , the free green s function @xmath18 solves the wave equation for @xmath195 .
the classical scattering operator @xmath19 is a convenient way of rewriting the helmholtz equation as a lippmann - schwinger equation @xcite .
the lippmann - schwinger equation @xmath196 is the general solution to the helmholtz equation . here
@xmath18 is the free green s function as discussed in appendix [ app : greens_function ] and the homogeneous solution @xmath197 obeys the free helmholtz equation @xmath198{\mathbf{e}}=0 $ ] . the iterative substitution for @xmath197 yields the following formal expression in terms of the @xmath19 operator : @xmath199 solving for @xmath19
, we obtain @xmath200 the @xmath19 operator contains all the geometric information of our objects . to the lowest order of expansion it equals the potential @xmath201 , as in the born approximation .
the spherical wave basis offers the most concise representation of partial waves as it does not contain evanescent modes . here
, we adopt the wave expansion given in ref .
@xcite , where the waves , depending on spherical coordinates @xmath65 , @xmath107 , and @xmath108 , are defined as @xmath202 the function @xmath203 denotes the spherical bessel function of order @xmath40 and @xmath204 represents the spherical hankel function of the first kind of order @xmath40 .
@xmath205 are the spherical harmonics , where the standard definition according to ref .
@xcite has to be applied .
the partial wave indices in the spherical basis are given by @xmath206 , containing the polarization @xmath42 ( magnetic @xmath207 or electric @xmath208 ) , the spherical multipole order @xmath40 , as well as the multipole index @xmath41 .
sums over partial wave indices @xmath209 turn into @xmath210 in the spherical basis .
the plane wave basis is a convenient way to describe planar bodies such as a ( infinite ) plate .
we determine the @xmath47-direction as our symmetry axis for planar objects lying in the @xmath211-plane . in the following , we consider two sets of eigenfunctions of the wave equation .
the first one is applicable to problems involving thick slabs ( with negligible transmission coefficient ) and makes use of elementary left- and right - moving waves .
the vector eigenfunctions in this basis for the two polarizations are defined according to ref . @xcite as @xmath212 in these equations @xmath213 and @xmath214 are the spatial coordinate and the wave vector perpendicular to the symmetry axis . for the wave vector we can hence write @xmath215 , with @xmath216 .
the waves are denoted by partial wave indices @xmath217 and @xmath218 , where @xmath219 and @xmath220 . in terms of these eigenfunctions ,
regular and outgoing waves read as @xmath221 the second set of eigenfunctions employs waves of definite parity that are convenient in problems involving slabs of finite thickness whose transmission coefficient can not be neglected .
these waves have a definite parity ( carrying the index @xmath222 ) under reflections at the @xmath223 plane and consist of a superposition of left- and right - moving waves : @xmath224\,,\\ { \mathbf{e}}^\mathrm{out}_{s , p,{\mathbf{k}}_\perp}({\mathbf{r}})=\frac{i^{\frac{1-s}{2}}}{\sqrt{2}}[{\mathbf{e}}^\mathrm{out}_{r,\,p,\,{\mathbf{k}}_\perp}({\mathbf{r}})+s{\mathbf{e}}^\mathrm{out}_{l,\,p,\,{\mathbf{k}}_\perp}({\mathbf{r}})]\,.\label{eq : transformation_identity_moving_waves}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the waves carry the partial wave indices @xmath225 and @xmath226 .
the transition between the two sets of outgoing waves can be written in terms of the unitary transformation @xmath227 the transformation matrix immediately follows from eq . and is given by @xmath228
the matrix elements of the classical scattering operator @xmath19 are readily evaluated as @xcite @xmath229 the function @xmath230 is a permutation among the partial wave indices , which fulfills @xmath231 . in the spherical basis
@xmath230 changes the multipole index @xmath41 to @xmath232 , i.e. @xmath233 .
note that the matrix elements satisfy the condition @xmath234 because of the symmetry of @xmath19 .
the scattering of electromagnetic waves by a sphere of radius @xmath51 and permittivity @xmath235 is often referred to as mie scattering . in this specific case
the boundary value problem can be solved analytically and one obtains the matrix elements of @xmath50 in closed form , the so - called mie coefficients .
these coefficients are well - known quantities and thoroughly defined in ref .
@xcite . assuming isotropic and local @xmath235 and
@xmath236 the @xmath50 matrix is diagonal in all indices and most notably independent of @xmath41 , @xmath237 . introducing the abbreviations @xmath238 and @xmath239 ,
the matrix element @xmath240 can be written as @xcite @xmath241-j_l(r^*)\frac{d}{d \tilde r^*}[\tilde r^*j_l(\tilde r^*)]}{\mu j_l(\tilde r^*)\frac{d}{d r^*}\left[r^*h_l(r^*)\right]-h_l(r^*)\frac{d}{d \tilde r^*}[\tilde r^*j_l(\tilde r^*)]}\,.\ ] ] @xmath242 is obtained from @xmath243 by interchanging @xmath236 and @xmath235 . the @xmath50 matrix of a plane - parallel dielectric slab of finite thickness in the region @xmath244 is closely related to the fresnel reflection and transmission coefficients @xmath245 and @xmath246 for outgoing waves on the right of the slab by @xcite @xmath247 by substituting @xmath248 for @xmath51 we obtain the equivalent matrix elements for outgoing waves on the left side of the slab . here
, we provide a slightly different variant of the scattering matrix , the transformed matrix @xmath249 , which is linked to the original @xmath50 matrix by application of the unitary transformation @xmath250 defined in eq .
reading as @xmath251 .
the fresnel coefficients both depend on the thickness @xmath40 of the slab ( c.f .
@xcite , p.299 ) . considering an infinitely thick plate ( @xmath252 )
, the transmission vanishes and @xmath245 approaches the relation given in ref .
@xcite : @xmath253 the fresnel reflection coefficient for magnetic polarization @xmath254 is obtained from @xmath255 by interchanging @xmath235 and @xmath236 .
the outgoing plane wave eigenfunctions in eq . are expanded in regular spherical waves by means of the conversion matrix @xmath256 : @xmath257 the matrix elements of @xmath256 are given according to ref .
@xcite by @xmath258 where @xmath259 is the angle of @xmath214 with respect to the @xmath76 axis .
outgoing spherical waves can be expanded into regular spherical waves with respect to a different origin by application of the translation matrix @xmath74 .
the expansion of outgoing waves of object 1 in the coordinate system of object 2 can be written as @xmath260 the translation matrix @xmath261 implies a shift of waves along the @xmath47 axis by length @xmath2 , where @xmath262 is the connection vector between the origins of the coordinate system of object 1 and 2 .
the matrix elements of @xmath74 are readily calculated according to ref .
@xcite : @xmath263a_{l'l\nu m}(d)\delta_{mm'}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the function @xmath264 is defined as @xmath265 with @xmath266 the spherical hankel function of the first kind . by replacing @xmath266 with @xmath267 , the spherical bessel function of the first kind , we obtain the regular part of the translation matrix that is linked to the infinitesimal translation operator @xmath43 by @xmath268
in the dipole limit @xmath81 for electrical polarization @xmath82 , the @xmath50 matrix elements for objects featuring a rotational axis of symmetry can be rewritten in terms of the ( anisotropic ) polarizability tensor @xmath269 as @xmath270 where we have to perform an integration over the solid angle @xmath271 .
the polarizability tensor contains information about the electrical properties of the object as well as the orientation of the object .
it can be assumed diagonal in a properly chosen coordinate system . by transformation of this diagonal tensor ,
@xmath272 we obtain the polarizability tensor in the global frame by a passive rotation of the coordinate system around the @xmath150- and @xmath47-axis , respectively , as @xmath273 the rotation matrices @xmath274 are given for example in ref .
the polarizability tensor @xmath269 is a convenient way to calculate the @xmath50 matrix elements used in this limit , as the computation of the @xmath19 operator in eq .
is fairly difficult for arbitrary shape of the object .
note that the dipole limit is applicable only if the size of the object ( denoting @xmath51 as the largest dimension of the anisotropic object ) is the smallest scale involved , i.e. , if @xmath51 is small compared to the thermal wavelength ( which is roughly @xmath7{\mu m}$ ] at room temperature ) , as well as the material skin depth . in this case , the @xmath275 elements as defined in eq .
are the dominant ones .
63ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo
secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty in @noop _ _ , vol .
( ) p. @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _
( , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , ) | we theoretically study the phenomenon of self - propulsion through casimir forces in thermal non - equilibrium .
using fluctuational electrodynamics , we derive a formula for the self - propulsion force for an arbitrary small object in two scenarios , i ) for the object being isolated , and ii ) for the object being close to a planar surface . in the latter case ,
the self - propulsion force ( i.e. , the force parallel to the surface ) increases with decreasing distance , i.e. , it couples to the near - field .
we numerically calculate the lateral force acting on a hot spheroid near a surface and show that it can be as large as the gravitational force , thus being potentially measurable in fly - by experiments .
we close by linking our results to well - known relations of linear response theory in fluctuational electrodynamics : looking at the friction of the anisotropic object for constant velocity , we identify a correction term that is additional to the typically used approach . |
since introduced by howard @xcite , the concept of the expected value of information has long been studied in the context of decision analysis @xcite and applied to various areas , such as medical decision making @xcite , environmental science @xcite and petroleum engineering @xcite .
the expected value of information is defined as the expected increase in monetary value brought from reducing some degree of uncertainty on unknown parameters involved in a decision model by obtaining additional information .
there are several definitions of the expected value of information depending on the type of information , which includes perfect information , partial perfect information and sample information .
in particular , the expected value of partial perfect information ( evppi ) , or sometimes called the partial expected value of perfect information , denotes the value of eliminating uncertainty on a subset of unknown parameters completely , and has been advocated and used as a decision - theoretic sensitivity index for identifying relatively important unknown parameters @xcite . for many problems encountered in practice , calculating the evppi analytically is not possible . the simplest and most often - used method
to approximately evaluate the evppi is the nested monte carlo computation @xcite .
as pointed out in @xcite , however , the standard nested monte carlo computation of the evppi results in biased estimates , which directly follows from jensen s inequality .
moreover , it can be inferred from ( * ? ? ?
* section 2 ) that the standard nested monte carlo computation can not achieve the square - root convergence rate in the total computational budget .
in fact , the author of this paper empirically observed a deteriorated convergence rate for a simple toy problem in @xcite .
therefore , an unbiased and efficient computation of the evppi might be of particular interest to practitioners . in this line of investigation
, there have been some recent attempts to construct such computational algorithms @xcite .
as far as the author knows , however , every algorithm proposed in the literature has its own restrictions , for instance , on a decision model , and there is no general algorithm with mild assumptions . in this paper
we construct general unbiased monte carlo estimators for the evppi as well as the expected value of perfect information ( evpi ) .
our estimators for the evppi on a certain subset of unknown parameters only assume that i.i.d .
random sampling from the conditional distribution of the complement of unknown parameters should be possible .
if this is not the case , it might be necessary to incorporate markov chain monte carlo sampling into our estimators , although such an investigation is beyond the scope of this paper . for a decision model which satisfies the above assumption ,
our estimators are quite simple and straightforward to implement .
our approach to construct unbiased estimators is based on the multilevel monte carlo ( mlmc ) method , which was first introduced by heinrich @xcite for parametric integration and by giles @xcite for path simulation , and was later extended by rhee and glynn @xcite .
we refer to @xcite for a state - of - the - art review on the mlmc method .
the idea of the mlmc method can be simply described as follows : for a dimension @xmath0 , let @xmath1^s)$ ] , and @xmath2^s)$ ] be a sequence of functions which approximates @xmath3 with increasing accuracy ( in the @xmath4 norm ) but also with increasing computational cost .
we denote by @xmath5 the true integral of @xmath3 , i.e. , @xmath6^s}f(x){\,\mathrm{d}}x . \end{aligned}\ ] ] the naive monte carlo computation chooses @xmath7 points @xmath8 independently and randomly from @xmath9^s$ ] to approximate @xmath5 by the average @xmath10 for some @xmath11 .
note that the former is an unbiased estimator of @xmath5 whereas the latter contains the bias @xmath12 .
the mlmc method , on the other hand , uses the telescopic representation @xmath13 , and then each term is independently approximated by the naive monte carlo computation , i.e. , @xmath14 where we set @xmath15 and @xmath16 .
for the level @xmath17 such that @xmath18 , the corresponding average is set to 0 . the original mlmc method in @xcite
considers the case @xmath19 , that is , the telescopic representation of @xmath3 is truncated up to @xmath11 terms .
the resulting estimator contains the bias @xmath12 .
the extended mlmc method in @xcite introduces a probability mass function @xmath20 such that @xmath21 for all @xmath22 , where @xmath23 denotes the set of positive integers , and considers the _ single term estimator _
@xmath24 or the _ coupled sum estimator _
@xmath25 where @xmath26 and @xmath8 are chosen independently and randomly according to @xmath20 and @xmath27^s)$ ] , respectively .
these estimators are shown to be unbiased @xcite .
in this setting , the superiority of the mlmc method over the naive monte carlo method depends on the balance between the growth rate of the computational costs for @xmath28 and the decay rate of the variances of @xmath29 .
an application of the mlmc method to the nested monte carlo computation in a different context has been done , for instance , in @xcite and also mentioned in ( * ? ? ?
* section 9 ) .
however , the mlmc method has never been applied to computations of the expected value of information . in this paper , we show that the framework of the mlmc method actually fits quite well into constructing unbiased estimators both for the evpi and the evppi .
because of their simplicity and efficiency , we believe that our unbiased estimators will be one of the most standard choices particularly for evaluating the evppi .
finally , it should be remarked that an unbiased estimator for optimization of expectations has been constructed very recently by blanchet and glynn @xcite in a general context , whose main approach is commonly used in this paper .
the remainder of this paper is organized as follows . in the next section ,
we introduce the definitions of the evpi and the evppi , and then discuss the standard nested monte carlo computations . in section [ sec:3 ] , we construct unbiased estimators for the evpi and the evppi based on the mlmc method , and also briefly discuss some practical issues relating to implementation .
we conclude this paper with numerical experiments in section [ sec:4 ] .
let @xmath30 be a finite set of decision options .
the task of a decision maker is to decide which option @xmath31 is optimal under uncertainty of @xmath32 . here
@xmath32 is assumed to be a continuous random variable defined on the @xmath0-dimensional domain @xmath33 with density @xmath34 , and a monetary value function @xmath35 is assigned for each option @xmath31 . throughout this paper , we assume @xmath36 . under the risk neutrality assumption ,
the optimal option is one which maximizes the expected monetary value @xmath37:=\int_{\omega_x}f_d(x)p_x(x){\,\mathrm{d}}x .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus the expected monetary value without additional information is given by @xmath38 $ ] .
suppose that perfect information is available .
in this situation , a decision maker can decide an optimal option after eliminating uncertainty of @xmath32 completely .
therefore , the monetary value for a decision maker after @xmath39 is indicated by perfect information is simply given by @xmath40 . as a result , the expected monetary value with perfect information becomes @xmath41 $ ] .
the evpi denotes how much the expected monetary value is increased by eliminating uncertainty of @xmath32 .
thus the evpi is defined by @xmath42 - \max_{d\in d}{\mathbb{e}}_x\left[f_d\right ] .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the evpi is equivalent to how much a decision maker is willing to pay for obtaining perfect information .
assume that the random variable @xmath32 is separable into ( possibly correlated ) two random variables as @xmath43 with @xmath44 , and that available information is perfect only for @xmath45 .
in this situation , a decision maker can decide an optimal option under uncertainty of @xmath46 after eliminating uncertainty of @xmath45 completely .
therefore , the monetary value for a decision maker after @xmath47 is indicated by partial perfect information is given by @xmath48 $ ] , where the expectation is taken with respect to @xmath46 given @xmath47 . as a result ,
the expected monetary value with partial perfect information for @xmath45 becomes @xmath49 \right]$ ] .
thus , similarly to the evpi , the evppi on @xmath45 is defined by @xmath50 \right ] - \max_{d\in d}{\mathbb{e}}_x\left[f_d\right ] .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] here we recall that the marginal density function of @xmath45 and the conditional density function of @xmath46 given @xmath47 are given by @xmath51 and @xmath52 respectively .
since both the evpi and the evppi are often difficult to calculate analytically , the monte carlo computations are used in practice .
let us consider the evpi first .
for @xmath53 , let @xmath8 and @xmath54 be i.i.d .
random samples generated from @xmath34 .
the evpi is approximated by @xmath55 we can approximate the evppi in a similar way .
let @xmath56 .
let @xmath54 be i.i.d .
random samples generated from @xmath34 , and @xmath57 i.i.d .
random samples generated from @xmath58 . for each @xmath59 , let @xmath60 be i.i.d .
random samples generated from @xmath61 .
then the evppi is approximated by the following nested form @xmath62 in the case where there is no correlation between @xmath45 and @xmath46 , random samples @xmath60 used in the inner sum can be replaced by @xmath63 i.i.d .
random samples generated from @xmath64 for all @xmath59 . here
we would emphasize that both the monte carlo estimators @xmath65 and @xmath66 are biased .
that is , @xmath67 \neq { \mathrm{evpi}}\quad \text{and}\quad { \mathbb{e}}\left[\overline{{\mathrm{evppi}}}_{x^{(1)}}\right ] \neq { \mathrm{evppi}}_{x^{(1)}}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] this result follows directly from jensen s inequality . in case of the evpi , we have @xmath67 & = { \mathbb{e}}\left[\frac{1}{n}\sum_{n=1}^{n}\max_{d\in d}f_d(x_n)\right ] - { \mathbb{e}}\left[\max_{d\in d}\frac{1}{l}\sum_{l=1}^{l}f_d(x'_l)\right ] \\ & \leq { \mathbb{e}}\left[\frac{1}{n}\sum_{n=1}^{n}\max_{d\in d}f_d(x_n)\right ] - \max_{d\in d}{\mathbb{e}}\left[\frac{1}{l}\sum_{l=1}^{l}f_d(x'_l)\right ] \\ & = { \mathbb{e}}_x\left[\max_{d\in d}f_d \right ] - \max_{d\in d}{\mathbb{e}}_x\left[f_d\right ] = { \mathrm{evpi } } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the inequality stems from jensen s inequality .
it is clear that the first term of the evpi can be estimated without any bias , whereas the second term is estimated with a positive bias .
we refer to @xcite for a possible bounding technique to quantify the bias .
therefore , in total , @xmath65 is a downward biased estimator of @xmath68 . in case of the evppi ,
both the first and second terms of the evppi are estimated with positive biases .
thus it is difficult to conclude whether the estimator @xmath66 is biased either upward or downward . nevertheless , these two biases are not cancelled out , so that we have @xmath69 \neq { \mathrm{evppi}}_{x^{(1)}}$ ] .
moreover , there is a limitation in the asymptotic convergence rate of the estimator @xmath66 . for simplicity ,
let us focus on the first term of the evppi , which is approximated as @xmath70 \right ] \sim
\frac{1}{n}\sum_{n=1}^{n}\max_{d\in d}\frac{1}{m}\sum_{m=1}^{m}f_d(x^{(1)}_n , x^{(2)}_{m , n } ) .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is clear from jensen s inequality that the operator @xmath71 yields a positive bias .
assuming that the bias depends on @xmath45 and decays uniformly at a certain rate @xmath72 for @xmath73 , it follows from the heuristic argument in ( * ? ? ?
* section 2 ) that the approximation error itself decays at the rate @xmath74 notice that the total number of samples used is @xmath75 . by putting @xmath76 and @xmath77 for @xmath78 ,
the convergence rate of the standard nested monte carlo estimator in the total computational budget @xmath79 is given by the form @xmath80 , where @xmath81 let us assume that the bias decays at a faster rate than the canonical monte carlo rate , i.e. , @xmath82 .
when @xmath83 , that is , when @xmath84 , the resulting value for @xmath85 is @xmath86 .
this convergence rate is also observed empirically in @xcite .
the best possible value for @xmath85 is actually @xmath87 , which is strictly less than @xmath88 and is attained when @xmath89 .
this result suggests fewer samples for the inner sum and more for the outer sum , which is opposite from what is empirically recommended in @xcite .
nevertheless , the above argument concludes that the square - root convergence rate in @xmath79 can not be achieved by the standard nested monte carlo estimator .
we now move on to constructing unbiased monte carlo estimators for the evpi and the evppi based on the mlmc method .
we first construct unbiased monte carlo estimators for the evpi . for @xmath90 ,
let us denote @xmath91 where @xmath8 are i.i.d .
random samples generated from @xmath34 .
then the following simple but interesting properties hold : @xmath92 = { \mathbb{e}}\left[\max_{d\in d}f_d(x_1)\right ] = { \mathbb{e}}_x\left[\max_{d\in d}f_d \right ] , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath93 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the latter property stems from the law of large numbers .
hence it is trivial that @xmath94 = \max_{d\in d}{\mathbb{e}}_x\left[f_d\right ] .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore , the evpi can be rewritten into @xmath95 - \lim_{n\to \infty}{\mathbb{e}}\left[q(n)\right ] .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] based on this finding and the idea of the mlmc method , unbiased monte carlo estimators for the evpi can be constructed . for a fixed integer @xmath96
, we have the telescopic representation for the right - hand side of ( [ eq : evpi_rewrite ] ) @xmath92 - \lim_{n\to \infty}{\mathbb{e}}\left[q(n)\right ] & = \left\ { { \mathbb{e}}\left[q(1)\right]-{\mathbb{e}}\left[q(b)\right]\right\}+\left\ { { \mathbb{e}}\left[q(b)\right]-{\mathbb{e}}\left[q(b^2)\right]\right\}+\cdots \\ & = \sum_{l=1}^{\infty}\left\ { { \mathbb{e}}\left[q(b^{l-1})\right]-{\mathbb{e}}\left[q(b^l)\right]\right\ } \\ & = \sum_{l=1}^{\infty}{\mathbb{e}}\left[q(b^{l-1})-q(b^l)\right ] , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the last equality stems from the linearity of expectation .
now let us introduce a positive integer - valued independent random variable @xmath11 with a probability mass function @xmath97 such that @xmath98 for all @xmath22 .
then the first _ single term estimator _ of the evpi is given by @xmath99 where @xmath26 are i.i.d .
random samples generated from @xmath97 , and for each @xmath22 we define @xmath100 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath101 are i.i.d .
random samples generated from @xmath34 .
note that the same samples @xmath101 are commonly used in the first and second terms in @xmath102 .
it can be seen that this estimator is unbiased : @xmath103 & = { \mathbb{e}}\left[\sum_{l=1}^{\infty}p_l(l)y_{l}^{{\mathrm{single } } } \right ] = \sum_{l=1}^{\infty}p_l(l){\mathbb{e}}\left[y_{l}^{{\mathrm{single } } } \right ] \\ & = \sum_{l=1}^{\infty}{\mathbb{e}}\left[q(b^{l-1})-q(b^l)\right ] = { \mathrm{evpi}}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] the second _ coupled sum estimator _ of the evpi is given by @xmath104 where @xmath26 are i.i.d .
random samples generated from @xmath97 , and for each @xmath22 we define @xmath105 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath101 are i.i.d .
random samples generated from @xmath34 .
note that the same samples @xmath101 are commonly used in every term in @xmath106 .
it can be seen that this estimator is also unbiased : @xmath107 & = { \mathbb{e}}\left[\sum_{l=1}^{\infty}p_l(l)y_{l}^{{\mathrm{coupled } } } \right ] = \sum_{l=1}^{\infty}p_l(l){\mathbb{e}}\left[y_{l}^{{\mathrm{coupled } } } \right ] \\ & = \sum_{l=1}^{\infty}\sum_{j=1}^{l}\frac{p_l(l)}{\sum_{k = j}^{\infty}p_l(k)}{\mathbb{e}}\left[q(b^{j-1})-q(b^j ) \right ] \\ & = \sum_{j=1}^{\infty}\sum_{l = j}^{\infty}\frac{p_l(l)}{\sum_{k = j}^{\infty}p_l(k)}{\mathbb{e}}\left[q(b^{j-1})-q(b^j ) \right ] \\ & = \sum_{j=1}^{\infty}{\mathbb{e}}\left[q(b^{j-1})-q(b^j)\right ] = { \mathrm{evpi } } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the fourth equality is given by swapping the order of sums . in a way similar to that for the evpi , it is possible to construct unbiased monte carlo estimators for the evppi .
since unbiased estimators for the evpi have been constructed already , it suffices to construct unbiased estimators for @xmath108 - { \mathbb{e}}_{x^{(1)}}\left[\max_{d\in d}{\mathbb{e}}_{x^{(2)}\mid x^{(1)}}\left[f_d\right ] \right ] .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath90 and @xmath109 , let us denote @xmath110 where @xmath111 are generated independently and randomly from @xmath112 .
then the following properties hold : @xmath113 = { \mathbb{e}}_{x^{(2)}\mid x^{(1)}}\left[\max_{d\in d}f_d(x^{(1)},\cdot ) \right ] , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath114 = \max_{d\in d}{\mathbb{e}}_{x^{(2)}\mid x^{(1)}}\left[f_d(x^{(1)},\cdot)\right ] , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the latter property stems again from the law of large numbers . using these results , we have @xmath115 - { \mathbb{e}}_{x^{(1)}}\left[\max_{d\in d}{\mathbb{e}}_{x^{(2)}\mid x^{(1)}}\left[f_d\right ] \right ] \\ & = { \mathbb{e}}_{x^{(1)}}{\mathbb{e}}\left[q(1;\cdot)\right ] - { \mathbb{e}}_{x^{(1)}}\left[\lim_{n\to \infty}{\mathbb{e}}\left[q(n;\cdot)\right]\right ] \\ & = { \mathbb{e}}_{x^{(1)}}\left[{\mathbb{e}}\left[q(1;\cdot)\right ] - \lim_{n\to \infty}{\mathbb{e}}\left[q(n;\cdot)\right]\right ] .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] for a fixed integer @xmath96 , we have the telescopic representation @xmath116 - \lim_{n\to \infty}{\mathbb{e}}\left[q(n;\cdot)\right]\right ] & = { \mathbb{e}}_{x^{(1)}}\left [ \sum_{l=1}^{\infty}\left\ { { \mathbb{e}}\left[q(b^{l-1};\cdot)\right]-{\mathbb{e}}\left[q(b^l;\cdot)\right]\right\}\right ] \\ & = { \mathbb{e}}_{x^{(1)}}\left [ \sum_{l=1}^{\infty}{\mathbb{e}}\left[q(b^{l-1};\cdot)-q(b^l;\cdot)\right ] \right ] .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] now let us introduce a positive integer - valued independent random variable @xmath117 with a probability mass function @xmath118 such that @xmath119 for all @xmath120 .
then the first _ single term estimator _ of @xmath121 is given by @xmath122 where @xmath26 and @xmath57 are i.i.d .
random samples generated from @xmath97 and @xmath58 , respectively , and for each @xmath22 and @xmath109 we define @xmath123 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath124 are i.i.d .
random samples generated from @xmath112 .
it can be seen that this estimator is unbiased : @xmath125 & = { \mathbb{e}}\left[\sum_{l=1}^{\infty}p_l(l){\mathbb{e}}_{x^{(1)}}\left[z_{l_n , \cdot}^{{\mathrm{single}}}\right ] \right ] = { \mathbb{e}}_{x^{(1)}}\left[\sum_{l=1}^{\infty}p_l(l){\mathbb{e}}\left[z_{l_n , \cdot}^{{\mathrm{single } } } \right]\right ] \\ & = { \mathbb{e}}_{x^{(1)}}\left[\sum_{l=1}^{\infty}{\mathbb{e}}\left[q(b^{l-1};\cdot)-q(b^l;\cdot)\right]\right ] = { \mathrm{evpi}}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] the second _ coupled sum estimator _ of @xmath121 is given by @xmath126 where @xmath26 and @xmath57 are i.i.d .
random samples generated from @xmath97 and @xmath58 , respectively , and for each @xmath22 and @xmath109 we define @xmath127 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath124 are i.i.d .
random samples generated from @xmath112 .
note that the same samples @xmath101 are commonly used in every term in @xmath128 .
this estimator can be shown unbiased in a similar way as above .
therefore , @xmath129 can be estimated without any bias by @xmath130 where @xmath131 , and @xmath26 and @xmath132 are i.i.d .
random samples generated from @xmath97 .
note that even if one randomly chosen level @xmath133 is used commonly for each @xmath59 as @xmath134 the resulting estimator is still unbiased .
so far , we do not specify the probability mass function @xmath118 in both the estimators for the evpi and the evppi .
it should be chosen so as for both the variance of the estimator and the expected computational cost to be finite @xcite .
let us consider the estimator ( [ eq : est_evpi_single ] ) of the evpi as an example .
the variance and the expected computational cost per one sample of ( [ eq : est_evpi_single ] ) are given by @xmath135}{p_l(l)}\quad \text{and } \quad \sum_{l=1}^{\infty}p_l(l)b^l , \end{aligned}\ ] ] respectively , where the expectation is taken with respect to random samples @xmath136 for every @xmath22 .
it can be easily shown that the optimal choice for @xmath97 , which minimizes @xmath137}{p_l(l ) } + \lambda p_l(l)b^l\right ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] for some lagrange multiplier @xmath138 , is given by @xmath139}{b^l}}\left ( \sum_{j=1}^{\infty}\sqrt{\frac{{\mathbb{e}}\left[(y_j^{{\mathrm{single}}})^2\right]}{b^j}}\right)^{-1 } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] if the sum over @xmath140 is finite . in order to achieve the root mean square error less than @xmath141 , the required expected total computational cost is @xmath142 b^j}\right)^{2 } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] again if the sum over @xmath140 is finite , see ( * ? ? ?
* section 2.2 ) .
note that the above argument also holds for other estimators ( [ eq : est_evpi_coupled ] ) , ( [ eq : est_evppi_single ] ) and ( [ eq : est_evppi_coupled ] ) .
therefore , in preferable cases , our unbiased estimators can achieve the square - root convergence rate in @xmath79 , which is not possible for the nested monte carlo computation as heuristically discussed in the last section .
note that if the sum over @xmath140 is not finite , on the other hand , there is no theoretical foundation on the convergence behavior of our estimators , so that one may observe a deteriorated convergence rate in practical computations . in practice , we need a more reasonable choice for @xmath97 in some sense since the expectations @xmath143 $ ] are not known in advance . as an alternative approach ,
let us specify the form of @xmath97 as @xmath144 for all @xmath145 with @xmath146 .
let us assume that the expectations @xmath143 $ ] decay at a rate @xmath147 for some @xmath148 .
in order for both the variance of the estimator , in which @xmath143 $ ] is replaced by @xmath147 , and the expected computational cost to be finite , it suffices that @xmath149 holds .
moreover , the optimal choice for @xmath97 obtained in the last paragraph gives @xmath150 .
the same value of @xmath151 can be obtained , as done in @xcite where the special case with @xmath152 and @xmath153 is considered , by minimizing the work - normalized variance @xmath154 furthermore , in practical applications , one may set the total computational cost @xmath79 instead of @xmath7 , i.e. , the number of i.i.d .
copies used in the estimators . in this case , we first generate a random sequence @xmath155 independently from @xmath97 and then define @xmath7 by @xmath156
finally , we conduct numerical experiments for a simple toy problem . in order to evaluate the approximation error quantitatively
, we design a toy problem such that the evpi and the evppi can be calculated analytically .
let us consider the following setting .
let @xmath157 be a set of two possible actions which can be taken by a decision maker under uncertainty of @xmath158 .
for @xmath159 we define @xmath160 where @xmath161 and @xmath162 .
the prior probability density of @xmath32 is given by @xmath163 for given @xmath164 and @xmath165 .
then we have @xmath166 : = \max\left\ { \int_{{\mathbb{r}}^s}f_{d_1}(x)p(x){\,\mathrm{d}}x , 0\right\ } = \max\left\ { w_0+\sum_{j=1}^{s}w_j\mu_j , 0\right\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] now let @xmath167 be a subset of @xmath168
. for simplicity , let us focus on the case @xmath169 .
we write @xmath170 , @xmath171 and @xmath172 .
the evppi on @xmath173 can be calculated analytically as follows .
since there is no correlation between @xmath173 and @xmath174 , we have @xmath175 \right ] \\ & \quad = \int_{{\mathbb{r}}^{|u|}}\max\left\ { \int_{{\mathbb{r}}^{s-|u|}}f_{d_1}(x_u , x_{-u})\prod_{j\in -u}p_{x_j}(x_j){\,\mathrm{d}}x_{-u } , 0\right\}\prod_{j\in u}p_{x_j}(x_j){\,\mathrm{d}}x_u \\ & \quad = \int_{{\mathbb{r}}^{|u|}}\max\left\ { \sum_{j\in u}w_jx_j+w_0+\sum_{j\in -u}w_j\mu_j , 0\right\}\prod_{j\in u}p_{x_j}(x_j){\,\mathrm{d}}x_u \\ & \quad = \int_{\omega_{\geq 0}}\left ( \sum_{j\in u}w_jx_j+w_0+\sum_{j\in -u}w_j\mu_j\right ) \prod_{j\in u}p_{x_j}(x_j){\,\mathrm{d}}x_u , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we write @xmath176 . by changing the variables according to @xmath177 where @xmath178 \in { \mathbb{r}}^{|u|\times |u| } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] we have @xmath179 i.e.
, the sum of @xmath180 s is nothing but the last component of @xmath181 .
moreover , the probability density of @xmath182 is the normal density with the mean @xmath183 and the variance @xmath184 , the above integral can be written into @xmath185 \right ] & = \int_{\omega_{\geq 0}}\left ( \sum_{j\in u}w_jx_j+w_0+\sum_{j\in -u}w_j\mu_j\right ) \prod_{j\in u}p_{x_j}(x_j){\,\mathrm{d}}x_u \\ & = \int_{a}^{\infty}\left ( y_{|u|}-a\right ) p(y_{|u|}){\,\mathrm{d}}y_{|u| } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we write @xmath186 finally , the last integral equals @xmath185 \right ] = \left [ 1-\phi\left ( -\frac{\mu_{{\mathrm{all}}}}{\sigma_u}\right)\right]\mu_{{\mathrm{all } } } + \phi\left ( -\frac{\mu_{{\mathrm{all}}}}{\sigma_u}\right ) \sigma_u,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we write @xmath187 and @xmath188 further , @xmath189 denotes the standard normal density function and @xmath190 does the cumulative distribution function for @xmath189 .
thus , the evppi on @xmath173 is given by @xmath191\mu_{{\mathrm{all } } } + \phi\left ( -\frac{\mu_{{\mathrm{all}}}}{\sigma_u}\right ) \sigma_u -\max\left\ { \mu_{{\mathrm{all } } } , 0\right\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the analytical expression for the evpi is given by setting @xmath192 .
in what follows , we focus on the case where @xmath193 and @xmath194 , @xmath195 , @xmath196 for all @xmath197 for the sake of simplicity .
first , let us consider the evpi computation .
the analytical calculation of the evpi is given by @xmath198 .
we use the three estimators ( [ eq : evpi_mc ] ) , ( [ eq : est_evpi_single ] ) and ( [ eq : est_evpi_coupled ] ) of the evpi for approximate evaluations .
when the total computational budget equals @xmath79 , the naive monte carlo estimator ( [ eq : evpi_mc ] ) is set by @xmath199 , whereas our proposed estimators ( [ eq : est_evpi_single ] ) and ( [ eq : est_evpi_coupled ] ) are set as described in the last paragraph of subsection [ subsec : imple ] with @xmath152 and @xmath144 where @xmath200 .
for a given total computational budget , 100 independent computations are conducted for each estimator .
figure [ fig : evpi ] compares the boxplots of the evpi computations obtained by three estimators as functions of @xmath201 with @xmath202 .
it can be seen that the naive monte carlo estimator gives more accurate results than our estimators . in case of the evpi ,
the naive monte carlo estimator is not of the nested form so that the approximation error decays at a rate of @xmath203 if the bias decays at a faster rate than the canonical monte carlo rate .
moreover , it can be expected that the variances of our estimators are much larger than that of the naive monte carlo estimator , which yields wider variations among the independent evpi computations by our estimators as well as the difficulty in confirming the unbiasedness of our estimators when the total computational budget is small .
let us move on to the evppi computation , in which case the situation changes significantly .
because of the invariance of parameters , we focus on computing the evppi s on @xmath204 .
the analytical calculations of the evppi s are given by @xmath205 , @xmath206 , @xmath207 , and @xmath208 , respectively .
we use the three estimators ( [ eq : evppi_mc ] ) , ( [ eq : evppi_mlmc ] ) with the single term estimator ( @xmath209 ) , and ( [ eq : evppi_mlmc ] ) with the coupled sum estimator ( @xmath210 ) of the evpi for approximate evaluations .
when the total computational budget equals @xmath79 , the nested monte carlo estimator ( [ eq : evppi_mc ] ) is set by @xmath211 , @xmath212 and @xmath213 as heuristically suggested in subsection [ subsec : nested_mc ] with @xmath214 .
in fact , although we also conducted the same numerical experiments by setting both @xmath215 and @xmath216 , we obtained similar results to those with @xmath217 , which are thus omitted in this paper .
our proposed estimators ( [ eq : evppi_mlmc ] ) with @xmath131 are set as described in the last paragraph of subsection [ subsec : imple ] with @xmath152 and @xmath144 where @xmath200 .
for a given total computational budget , 100 independent computations are conducted for each estimator .
figure [ fig : evppi ] compares the boxplots of the evppi computations on @xmath204 ( from upper panels to lower panels ) obtained by three estimators as functions of @xmath201 with @xmath202 .
it is obvious that the convergence behavior of the nested monte carlo estimator is much worse than that of the monte carlo estimator used for computing the evpi , as can be expected from the heuristic argument in subsection [ subsec : nested_mc ] . on the other hand , the convergence behaviors of our estimators
do not differ so much whether they are used for computing either the evpi or the evppi , and the length of the boxes for both of our estimators decays to 0 much faster than that for the nested monte carlo estimator .
hence , as can be seen , both of our estimators give more accurate results than that of the nested monte carlo estimator as @xmath79 increases . in practice , we recommend to use the coupled sum estimator since there are several outliers with large evppi values found in case of the single term estimator .
99 andradttir , s. , glynn , p. w , : computing bayesian means using simulation , acm trans . model .
* 26 * , 2 , article no . 10 ( 2016 ) .
bates , m. e. , sparrevik , m. , lichy , n. , linkov , i. : the value of information for managing contaminated sediments , environ .
technol . * 48 * , 94789485 ( 2014 ) .
bickel , j. e. , gibson , r. l. , mcvay , d. a. , pickering , s. , waggoner , j. : quantifying the reliability and value of 3d land seismic , spe res .
eval . & eng .
* 11 * , 832841 ( 2008 ) .
blanchet , j. h. , glynn , p. w. : unbiased monte carlo for optimization and functions of expectations via multi - level randomization , in : proc .
2015 winter simulation conference ( 2015 ) .
bratvold , r. b. , bickel , j. e. , lohne , h. p. : value of information in the oil and gas industry : past , present , and future , spe res .
eval . & eng .
* 12 * , 630638 ( 2009 ) .
brennan , a. , kharroubi , s. , ohagan , a. , chilcott , j. : calculating partial expected value of perfect information via monte carlo sampling algorithms , med .
decis . making * 27
* , 448470 ( 2007 ) .
bujok , k. , hambly , b. m. , reisinger , c. : multilevel simulation of functionals of bernoulli random variables with application to basket credit derivatives , methodol .
* 17 * , 579604 ( 2015 ) .
claxton , k. : bayesian approaches to the value of information : implications for the regulation of new health care technologies , health econ .
* 8 * , 269274 ( 1999 ) .
coyle , d. , oakley , j. e. : estimating the expected value of partial perfect information : a review of methods , eur . j. health econ .
* 9 * , 251259 ( 2008 ) .
dakin , m. e. , toll , j. e. , small , m. j. , brand , k. p. : risk - based environmental remediation : bayesian monte carlo analysis and the expected value of sample information , risk analysis * 16
* , 6779 ( 1996 ) .
delqui , p. : the value of information and intensity of preference , decision analysis * 5 * , 129139 ( 2008 ) .
felli , j. c. , hazen , g. b. : sensitivity analysis and the expected value of perfect information , med .
decis . making * 18 * , 95109 ( 1998 ) .
giles , m. b. : multilevel monte carlo path simulation , operations research * 56 * , 607617 ( 2008 ) .
giles , m. b. : multilevel monte carlo methods , acta numer . * 24 * , 259328 ( 2015 ) .
heinrich , s. : monte carlo complexity of global solution of integral equations , j. complexity * 14 * , 151175 ( 1998 ) .
howard , r. a. : information value theory , ieee trans .
* 2 * , 2226 ( 1966 ) .
madan , j. , ades , a. e. , price , m. , maitland , k. , jemutai , j. , revill , p. , welton , n. j. : strategies for efficient computation of the expected value of partial perfect information , med .
decis . making * 34 * , 327342 ( 2014 ) .
mak , w .- k . ,
morton , d. p. , wood , r. k. : monte carlo bounding techniques for determining solution quality in stochastic programs , operations research letters * 24 * , 4756 ( 1999 ) .
nakayasu , m. , goda , t. , tanaka , k. , sato , k. : evaluating the value of single - point data in heterogeneous reservoirs with the expectation - maximization algorithm , spe econ . & mgmt .
* 8 * , 110 ( 2016 ) .
oakley , j. e. : decision - theoretic sensitivity analysis for complex computer models , technometrics * 51 * , 121129 ( 2009 ) .
oakley , j. e. , brennan , a. , tappenden , p. , chilcott , j. : simulation sample sizes for monte carlo partial evpi calculations , j. health econ .
* 29 * , 468477 ( 2010 ) .
raiffa , h. : decision analysis : introductory lectures on choices under uncertainty .
addison - wesley publishing company , massachusetts ( 1968 ) .
rhee , c .- h . ,
glynn , p. w. : a new approach to unbiased estimation for sdes , in : proc .
2012 winter simulation conference ( 2012 ) .
rhee , c .- h .
, glynn , p. w. : unbiased estimation with square root convergence for sde models , operations research * 63 * , 10261043 ( 2015 ) .
sadatsafavi , m. , bansback , n. , zafari , z. , najafzadeh , m. , marra , c. : need for speed : an efficient algorithm for calculation of single - parameter expected value of partial perfect information , value health * 16 * , 438448 ( 2013 ) .
samson , d. , wirth , a. , rickard , j. : the value of information from multiple sources of uncertainty in decision analysis , eur .
39 * , 254260 ( 1989 ) .
sato , k. : value of information analysis for adequate monitoring of carbon dioxide storage in geological reservoirs under uncertainty , int .
j. greenh .
gas control * 5 * , 12941302 ( 2011 ) .
strong , m. , oakley , j. e. : an efficient method for computing single - parameter partial expected value of perfect information , med .
decis . making * 33 * , 755766 ( 2013 ) .
( from upper to lower ) by the naive nested monte carlo estimator ( left ) , the single term estimator ( middle ) , and the coupled sum estimator ( right ) with the total computational budgets @xmath218.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=32.0% ] ( from upper to lower ) by the naive nested monte carlo estimator ( left ) , the single term estimator ( middle ) , and the coupled sum estimator ( right ) with the total computational budgets @xmath218.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=32.0% ] ( from upper to lower ) by the naive nested monte carlo estimator ( left ) , the single term estimator ( middle ) , and the coupled sum estimator ( right ) with the total computational budgets @xmath218.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=32.0% ] + ( from upper to lower ) by the naive nested monte carlo estimator ( left ) , the single term estimator ( middle ) , and the coupled sum estimator ( right ) with the total computational budgets @xmath218.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=32.0% ] ( from upper to lower ) by the naive nested monte carlo estimator ( left ) , the single term estimator ( middle ) , and the coupled sum estimator ( right ) with the total computational budgets @xmath218.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=32.0% ] ( from upper to lower ) by the naive nested monte carlo estimator ( left ) , the single term estimator ( middle ) , and the coupled sum estimator ( right ) with the total computational budgets @xmath218.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=32.0% ] + ( from upper to lower ) by the naive nested monte carlo estimator ( left ) , the single term estimator ( middle ) , and the coupled sum estimator ( right ) with the total computational budgets @xmath218.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=32.0% ] ( from upper to lower ) by the naive nested monte carlo estimator ( left ) , the single term estimator ( middle ) , and the coupled sum estimator ( right ) with the total computational budgets @xmath218.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=32.0% ] ( from upper to lower ) by the naive nested monte carlo estimator ( left ) , the single term estimator ( middle ) , and the coupled sum estimator ( right ) with the total computational budgets @xmath218.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=32.0% ] + ( from upper to lower ) by the naive nested monte carlo estimator ( left ) , the single term estimator ( middle ) , and the coupled sum estimator ( right ) with the total computational budgets @xmath218.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=32.0% ] ( from upper to lower ) by the naive nested monte carlo estimator ( left ) , the single term estimator ( middle ) , and the coupled sum estimator ( right ) with the total computational budgets @xmath218.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=32.0% ] ( from upper to lower ) by the naive nested monte carlo estimator ( left ) , the single term estimator ( middle ) , and the coupled sum estimator ( right ) with the total computational budgets @xmath218.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=32.0% ] | the expected value of partial perfect information ( evppi ) denotes the value of eliminating uncertainty on a subset of unknown parameters involved in a decision model .
the evppi can be regarded as a decision - theoretic sensitivity index , and has been widely used for identifying relatively important unknown parameters .
it follows from jensen s inequality , however , that the standard nested monte carlo computation of the evppi results in biased estimates . in this paper
we introduce two unbiased monte carlo estimators for the evppi based on multilevel monte carlo method , introduced by heinrich ( 1998 ) and giles ( 2008 ) , and its extension by rhee and glynn ( 2012 , 2015 ) .
our unbiased estimators are simple and straightforward to implement , and thus are of highly practical use .
numerical experiments show that even the convergence behaviors of our unbiased estimators are superior to that of the standard nested monte carlo estimator .
_ keywords _ : value of information , expected value of partial perfect information , unbiased estimation , multilevel monte carlo |
in their papers @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , ozsvth and szab constructed a decorated topological quantum field theory ( tqft ) in @xmath0 dimensions , called heegaard floer theory .
( strictly speaking , the axioms of a tqft need to be altered slightly . ) in its simplest version ( called hat ) , to a closed , connected , oriented three - manifold @xmath1 and a @xmath2 structure @xmath3 on @xmath1 one associates a vector space @xmath4 over the field @xmath5 also , to a connected , oriented four - dimensional cobordism from @xmath6 to @xmath7 decorated with a @xmath2 structure @xmath8 , one associates a map @xmath9 the maps @xmath10 can be used to detect exotic smooth structures on @xmath11-manifolds with boundary .
for example , this can be seen by considering the nucleus @xmath12 of the elliptic surface @xmath13 i.e. a regular neighborhood of a cusp fiber and a section , cf . @xcite .
let @xmath14 be the result of a log transform with multiplicity @xmath15 ( @xmath16 , odd ) on a regular fiber @xmath17 , cf .
* section 3.3 ) .
then @xmath18 and @xmath19 are homeomorphic 4-manifolds ( with @xmath20 ) , having as boundary the brieskorn sphere @xmath21 however , they are not diffeomorphic : this can be shown using the donaldson or seiberg - witten invariants ( see @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) , but also by comparing the hat heegaard floer invariants @xmath22 and @xmath23 , where @xmath24 and @xmath25 are the cobordisms from @xmath26 to @xmath27 obtained by deleting a @xmath11-ball from @xmath18 and @xmath19 , respectively . indeed , the arguments of fintushel - stern @xcite and szab - stipsicz @xcite can be easily adapted to show that @xmath24 and @xmath25 have different hat heegaard floer invariants ; one needs to use the computation of @xmath28 due to ozsvth - szab @xcite , and the rational blow - down formula of roberts @xcite .
( it is worth noting that the maps @xmath29 give no nontrivial information for closed 4-manifolds , cf .
@xcite ; exotic structures on those can be detected with the mixed heegaard floer invariants of @xcite . )
the original definitions of the vector spaces @xmath30 and the maps @xmath29 involved counting pseudoholomorphic disks and triangles in symmetric products of riemann surfaces ; the riemann surfaces are related to the three - manifolds and cobordisms involved via heegaard diagrams . in @xcite , sarkar and the third author showed that every three - manifold admits a heegaard diagram that is nice in the following sense : the curves split the diagram into elementary domains , all but one of which are bigons or rectangles . using such a diagram , holomorphic disks in the symmetric product can be counted combinatorially , and the result is a combinatorial description of @xmath31 for any @xmath32 as well as of the hat version of heegaard floer homology of null homologous knots and links in any three - manifold @xmath1 . a similar result was obtained in @xcite for all versions of the heegaard floer homology of knots and links in the three - sphere .
the goal of this paper is to give a combinatorial procedure for calculating the ranks of the maps @xmath33 when @xmath24 is a cobordism between @xmath6 and @xmath7 with the property that the induced maps @xmath34 and @xmath35 are surjective .
note that this case includes all cobordisms for which @xmath36 is torsion , as well as all those consisting of only 2-handle additions .
roughly , the computation of the ranks of @xmath33 goes as follows .
the cobordism @xmath24 is decomposed into a sequence of one - handle additions , two - handle additions , and three - handle additions . using the homological hypotheses on the cobordism and the @xmath37-action on the heegaard floer groups we reduce the problem to the case of a cobordism map corresponding to two - handle additions only . then , given a cobordism made of two - handles , we show that it can be represented by a multi - pointed triple heegaard diagram of a special form , in which all elementary domains that do not contain basepoints are bigons , triangles , or rectangles . in such diagrams
all holomorphic triangles of maslov index zero can be counted algorithmically , thus giving a combinatorial description of the map on @xmath38 we remark that in order to turn @xmath30 into a fully combinatorial tqft ( at least for cobordisms satisfying our hypothesis ) , one ingredient is missing : naturality .
given two different nice diagrams for a three - manifold , the results of @xcite show that the resulting groups @xmath30 are isomorphic .
however , there is not yet a combinatorial description of this isomorphism .
thus , while the results of this paper give an algorithmic procedure for computing the rank of a map @xmath39 the map itself is determined combinatorially only up to automorphisms of the image and the target .
in fact , if one were to establish naturality , then one could automatically remove the assumption on the maps on @xmath40 , and compute @xmath33 for any @xmath24 , simply by composing the maps induced by the two - handle additions ( computed in this paper ) with the ones induced by the one- and three - handle additions , which are combinatorial by definition , cf .
@xcite .
the paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec :
triangles ] , we define a multi - pointed triple heegaard diagram to be nice if all non - punctured elementary domains are bigons , triangles , or rectangles , and show that in a nice diagram holomorphic triangles can be counted combinatorially . below ) in @xcite , using slightly different methods . ]
we then turn to the description of the map induced by two - handle additions .
for the sake of clarity , in section [ sec : two ] we explain in detail the case of adding a single two - handle : we show that its addition can be represented by a nice triple heegaard diagram with a single basepoint and , therefore , the induced map on @xmath30 admits a combinatorial description .
we then explain how to modify the arguments to work in the case of several two - handle additions .
this modification uses triple heegaard diagrams with several basepoints . in section [ sec : last ] , we discuss the additions of one- and three - handles , and put the various steps together . finally , in section [ sec : example ] we present the example of @xmath41 surgery on the trefoil . throughout the paper
all homology groups are taken with coefficients in @xmath42 unless otherwise noted .
we would like to thank peter ozsvth and zoltn szab for helpful conversations and encouragement .
in particular , several key ideas in the proof were suggested to us by peter ozsvth .
this work was done while the third author was an exchange graduate student at columbia university .
he is grateful to the columbia math department for its hospitality .
he would also like to thank his advisors , robion kirby and peter ozsvth , for their continuous guidance and support .
finally , we would like to thank the referees for many helpful comments , and particularly for finding a critical error in section [ sec : last ] of a previous version of this paper .
the goal of this section is to show that under an appropriate condition ( `` niceness '' ) on triple heegaard diagrams , the counts of holomorphic triangles in the symmetric product are combinatorial .
we start by reviewing some facts from heegaard floer theory . a triple heegaard diagram @xmath43 consists of a surface @xmath44 of genus @xmath45
together with three @xmath46-tuples of pairwise disjoint embedded curves @xmath47 @xmath48 in @xmath44 such that the span of each @xmath46-tuple of curves in @xmath49 is @xmath45-dimensional .
if we forget one set of curves ( for example @xmath50 ) , the result is an ( ordinary ) heegaard diagram @xmath51 by the condition on the spans , @xmath52 , @xmath53 and @xmath54 each has @xmath55 connected components . by a multi - pointed triple heegaard diagram @xmath56 ,
then , we mean a triple heegaard diagram @xmath57 as above together with a set @xmath58 of @xmath55 points in @xmath44 so that exactly one @xmath59 lies in each connected component of @xmath52 , @xmath53 and @xmath54 . to a heegaard diagram @xmath60
one can associate a three - manifold @xmath61 . to a triple heegaard diagram @xmath62 , in addition to the three - manifolds @xmath61 , @xmath63 and @xmath64
, one can associate a four - manifold @xmath65 such that @xmath66 ; see @xcite .
associated to a three - manifold @xmath1 is the heegaard floer homology group @xmath31 .
this was defined using a heegaard diagram with a single basepoint in @xcite . in @xcite , ozsvth and szab associated to the data @xmath67 , called a multi - pointed heegaard diagram , a floer homology group @xmath68 by counting holomorphic disks in @xmath69 with boundary on the tori @xmath70 and @xmath71 it is not hard to show that @xmath72 ( here , @xmath73 is the @xmath74-torus , and @xmath75 means ordinary ( singular ) homology . ) the decomposition is not canonical : it depends on a choice of paths in @xmath44 connecting @xmath59 to @xmath76 for @xmath77 .
the heegaard floer homology groups decompose as a direct sum over @xmath2-structures on @xmath61 , @xmath78 more generally , there is a decomposition @xmath79 associated to the triple heegaard diagram @xmath80 together with a @xmath2-structure @xmath8 on @xmath65 , is a map @xmath81 the definition involves counting holomorphic triangles in @xmath82 with boundary on @xmath83 , @xmath84 and @xmath85 , cf .
@xcite and @xcite .
two triple heegaard diagrams are called _ strongly equivalent _ if they differ by a sequence of isotopies and handleslides .
it follows from ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 8.14 ) , the associativity theorem ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 8.16 ) , and the definition of the handleslide isomorphisms that strongly equivalent triple heegaard diagrams induce the same map on homology .
call a @xmath86-pointed triple heegaard diagram _ split _ if it is obtained from a singly - pointed heegaard triple diagram @xmath87 by attaching ( by connect sum ) @xmath74 spheres with one basepoint and three isotopic curves ( one alpha , one beta and one gamma ) each , to the component of @xmath88 containing @xmath89 .
we call @xmath87 the _ reduction _ of the split diagram .
the following lemma is a variant of ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 3.3 ) .
[ lemma : splitdiagrams ] every triple heegaard diagram @xmath80 is strongly equivalent to a split one .
reorder the alpha circles so that @xmath90 are linearly independent .
let @xmath91 be the connected component of @xmath52 containing @xmath92 .
since @xmath90 are linearly independent , one of the curves @xmath93 , @xmath94 , must appear in the boundary of @xmath91 with multiplicity exactly @xmath95 . by handlesliding this curve over the other boundary components of @xmath91
, we can arrange that the resulting @xmath93 bounds a disk containing only @xmath92 .
repeat this process with the other @xmath59 , @xmath96 , being sure to use a different alpha curve in the role of @xmath93 at each step .
we reorder the curves @xmath97 so that @xmath93 encircles @xmath98 .
now repeat the entire process for the beta and gamma curves . finally , choose a path @xmath99 in @xmath44 from @xmath59 to @xmath76 for each @xmath100 .
move the configuration @xmath101 along the path @xmath99 by handlesliding ( around @xmath93 , @xmath102 or @xmath103 ) the other alpha , beta and gamma curves that are encountered along the path @xmath99 .
the result is a split triple heegaard diagram .
note that its reduction is obtained from the original diagram @xmath80 by simply forgetting some of the curves and basepoints .
the maps from are compatible with the isomorphism , in the following sense . given a triple heegaard diagram @xmath80 , let @xmath87 be the reduction of a split diagram strongly equivalent to @xmath80 .
then the following diagram commutes : @xmath104^ { } \ar[d]^{\cong } & \hf\left(y_{\alpha,\gamma } , { \mathfrak{t}}|_{y_{\alpha,\gamma}}\right)\otimes h_*\left(t^k\right)\ar[d]^{\cong}\\ \hf(\sigma,\alphas,\betas,{\mathbf{z}},{\mathfrak{t}}|_{y_{\alpha,\beta } } ) \otimes\hf(\sigma,\betas,\gammas,{\mathbf{z } } , { \mathfrak{t}}|_{y_{\beta,\gamma } } ) \ar[r]^(.62){{\hat{f}}_{\sigma,\alphas,\betas,\gammas,{\mathbf{z}},{\mathfrak{t } } } } & \hf(\sigma,\alphas,\gammas,{\mathbf{z}},{\mathfrak{t}}|_{y_{\alpha,\gamma } } ) . }
\ ] ] here , the map in the first row is @xmath105 on the @xmath30-factors and the usual intersection product @xmath106 on the @xmath75-factors .
the vertical isomorphisms are induced by the strong equivalence . the proof that the diagram commutes follows from the same ideas as in @xcite : each of the @xmath74 spherical pieces in the split diagram contributes a @xmath107 to the @xmath108 factors above
; moreover , a local computation shows that the triangles induce intersection product maps @xmath109 which tensored together give the intersection product on @xmath110 it is tempting to assert that the map @xmath111 induced by a singly - pointed triple heegaard diagram depends only on @xmath65 and @xmath8 .
however , this seems not to be known .
fix a triple heegaard diagram @xmath112 as above .
the complement of the @xmath113 curves in @xmath44 has several connected components , which we denote by @xmath114 and call _ elementary domains_. the _ euler measure _ of an elementary domain @xmath115 is @xmath116 a _ domain _ in @xmath44 is a two - chain @xmath117 with @xmath118 its euler measure is simply @xmath119 as mentioned above , the maps @xmath120 induced by the triple heegaard diagram @xmath121 are defined by counting holomorphic triangles in @xmath122 with respect to a suitable almost complex structure . according to the cylindrical formulation from @xcite ,
this is equivalent to counting certain holomorphic embeddings @xmath123 where @xmath124 is a riemann surface ( henceforth called the source ) with some marked points on the boundary ( which we call corners ) , and @xmath125 is a fixed disk with three marked points on the boundary .
the maps @xmath126 are required to satisfy certain boundary conditions , and to be generically @xmath46-to-@xmath95 when post - composed with the projection @xmath127 more generally , we will consider such holomorphic maps @xmath128 which are generically @xmath129-to-@xmath95 when post - composed with @xmath130 these correspond to holomorphic triangles in @xmath131 where @xmath129 can be any positive integer .
we will be interested in the discussion of the index from @xcite .
although this discussion was carried - out in the case @xmath132 , @xmath133 , it applies equally well in the case of arbitrary @xmath74 and @xmath129 with only notational changes . in the cylindrical formulation ,
one works with an almost complex structure on @xmath134 so that the projection @xmath135 is holomorphic , and the fibers of @xmath136 are holomorphic .
it follows that for @xmath137 holomorphic , @xmath138 is a holomorphic branched cover .
the map @xmath139 need not be holomorphic , but since the fibers are holomorphic , @xmath139 is a branched map .
fix a model for @xmath125 in which the three marked points are @xmath140 corners , and a conformal structure on @xmath44 with respect to which the intersections between alpha , beta and gamma curves are all right angles .
since @xmath126 is holomorphic , the conformal structure on @xmath124 is induced via @xmath138 from the conformal structure on @xmath125 .
it makes sense , therefore , to talk about branch points of @xmath139 on the boundary and at the corners , as well as in the interior .
generically , while there may be branch points of @xmath139 on the boundary of @xmath124 , there will not be branch points at the corners .
suppose @xmath128 is as above .
denote by @xmath141 the projection to @xmath142 there is an associated domain @xmath143 in @xmath144 where the coefficient of @xmath145 in @xmath143 is the local multiplicity of @xmath146 at any point in @xmath147 by @xcite , the _ index _ of the linearized @xmath148 operator at the holomorphic map @xmath126 is given by @xmath149 for simplicity , we call this the index of @xmath150 note that , by the riemann - hurwitz formula : @xmath151 where @xmath152 is the ramification index ( number of branch points counted with multiplicity ) of @xmath153 ( here , branch points along the boundary count as half an interior branch point . ) from and we get an alternate formula for the index : @xmath154 note that it is not obvious how to compute @xmath155 from @xmath143 .
a combinatorial formula for the index , purely in terms of @xmath143 , was found by sarkar in @xcite .
however , we will not use it here .
fix a multi - pointed triple heegaard diagram @xmath156 .
recall that a domain is a linear combination of connected components of @xmath157 .
the _ support _ of a domain is the union of those components with nonzero coefficients .
if the support of a domain @xmath158 contains at least one @xmath59 then @xmath158 is called _ punctured _ ; otherwise it is called _
unpunctured_. [ def : nice ] an elementary domain is called * good * if it is a bigon , a triangle , or a rectangle , and * bad * otherwise .
the multi - pointed triple heegaard diagram @xmath56 is called * nice * if every unpunctured elementary domain is good .
this is parallel to the definition of nice heegaard diagrams ( with just two sets of curves ) from @xcite .
a multi - pointed heegaard diagram @xmath159 is called _ nice _ if , among the connected components of @xmath160 all unpunctured ones are either bigons or squares .
note that a bigon , a triangle , and a rectangle have euler measure @xmath161 and @xmath162 respectively .
since @xmath163 is additive , every unpunctured positive domain ( not necessarily elementary ) in a nice diagram must have nonnegative euler measure .
a quick consequence of this is the following : [ lemma : forget ] if @xmath80 is a nice triple heegaard diagram , then if we forget one set of curves ( for example , @xmath50 ) , the resulting heegaard diagram @xmath159 is also nice . in order to define the triangle
maps it is necessary to assume the triple heegaard diagram is weakly admissible in the sense of ( * ? ? ?
* definition 8.8 ) .
in fact , nice diagrams are automatically weakly admissible , cf .
corollary [ lemma : admissible ] below .
our goal is to give a combinatorial description of the holomorphic triangle counts for nice triple diagrams .
[ easternorthodox ] let @xmath164 be a nice multi - pointed triple heegaard diagram . fix a generic almost complex structure @xmath165 on @xmath134 as in ( * ? ? ?
* section 10.2 ) .
let @xmath166 be a @xmath165-holomorphic map of the kind occurring in the definition of @xmath167 .
in particular , assume @xmath126 is an embedding , of index zero , and such that the image of @xmath146 is an unpunctured domain . then @xmath124 is a disjoint union of @xmath129 triangles , and the restriction of @xmath146 to each component of @xmath124 is an embedding .
since the image of @xmath146 is unpunctured and positive , we have @xmath168 by , we get @xmath169 this means that at least one component of @xmath124 is topologically a disk .
let @xmath170 be such a component .
it is a polygon with @xmath171 vertices .
we will show that @xmath172 and that @xmath173 is an embedding .
let us first show that @xmath170 is a triangle .
the index of the @xmath174 operator at a disconnected curve is the sum of the indices of its restrictions to each connected component .
therefore , in order for an index zero holomorphic curve to exist generically , the indices at every connected component , and in particular at @xmath175 must be zero .
applying to @xmath176 we get @xmath177 if @xmath178 then by we have @xmath179 hence , the map @xmath146 has no interior branch points . if @xmath180 then @xmath170 is mapped locally diffeomorphically by @xmath139 to @xmath44 .
the image must have negative euler measure , which is a contradiction .
so , suppose @xmath181 .
the preimages of the alpha , beta , and gamma curves cut @xmath170 into several connected components . without loss of generality , assume that the boundary branch point is mapped to an alpha circle .
then , along the corresponding edge of @xmath170 there is a valence three vertex @xmath182 , as shown in figure [ figure : hexagon ] .
let @xmath183 denote the edge in the interior of @xmath170 meeting @xmath182 . since there is only one boundary branch point , the other intersection point of the edge @xmath183 with @xmath184 is along the preimage of a beta or gamma circle .
it follows that one of the connected components @xmath185 of @xmath186 is a hexagon or heptagon . smoothing the vertex @xmath182 of @xmath185 we obtain a pentagon or hexagon which is mapped locally diffeomorphically by @xmath139 to @xmath44 .
the image , then , has negative euler measure , again a contradiction . therefore , @xmath172 so @xmath170 is a triangle . furthermore , by , @xmath187 which means that there are no ( interior or boundary ) branch points at all
thus , just as in the hypothetical hexagon case above , the preimages of the alpha , beta , and gamma curves must cut @xmath170 into 2-gons , 3-gons , and 4-gons , all of which have nonnegative euler measure .
since the euler measure of @xmath170 is @xmath188 there can be no bigons ; in fact , @xmath170 must be cut into several rectangles and exactly one triangle .
it is easy to see that the only possible tiling of @xmath170 of this type is as in figure [ fig : tiling ] , with several parallel preimages of segments on the alpha curves , several parallel beta segments , and several parallel gamma segments .
we call the type of a segment ( @xmath189 , @xmath190 or @xmath191 ) its color .
the tiling consists of one triangle and six different types of rectangles , according to the coloring of their edges in clockwise order ( namely , @xmath192 , @xmath193 , @xmath194 , @xmath195 , @xmath196 , and @xmath197 ) .
we claim that the images of the interiors of each of these rectangles by @xmath146 are disjoint . because of the coloring scheme
, only rectangles of the same type can have the same image .
suppose that two different @xmath192 rectangles from @xmath170 have the same image in @xmath142 ( the cases @xmath193 , @xmath194 are exactly analogous . )
let @xmath198 and @xmath199 be the two rectangles ; suppose that @xmath198 is closer to the central triangle than @xmath200 and @xmath199 is closer to the @xmath189 boundary of @xmath201 because of the way the rectangles are colored , the upper edge of @xmath198 must have the same image as the upper edge of @xmath202 hence the @xmath192 rectangle right above @xmath198 has the same image as the one right above @xmath202 iterating this argument , at some point we get that the central triangle has the same image as some @xmath192 rectangle , which is impossible .
now suppose that two different @xmath195 rectangles , @xmath198 and @xmath200 have the same image .
( the cases @xmath196 and @xmath197 are exactly analogous . )
there are two cases , according to whether the upper edge of @xmath198 has the same image as the upper edge of @xmath200 or as the lower edge of @xmath202 suppose first that the upper edge of @xmath198 has the same image as the upper edge of @xmath199 . by the _
@xmath190-height _ of @xmath203 we mean the minimal number of beta arcs that an arc in @xmath204 starting in @xmath203 , going right , and ending at a gamma arc must cross . ( the diagram is positioned in the plane as in figure [ fig : tiling ] . )
since @xmath139 is a local homeomorphism , and @xmath198 and @xmath199 have the same image , it is clear that the @xmath190-height of @xmath198 and the @xmath190-height of @xmath199 are equal . by the _
@xmath189-height _ of @xmath203 we mean the minimal number of alpha arcs that an arc in @xmath205 starting in @xmath206 going up , and ending at a gamma arc must cross .
again , it is clear that the @xmath189-heights of @xmath198 and @xmath199 must be equal . but
this implies that @xmath198 and @xmath199 are equal . now , suppose that the upper edge of @xmath198 has the same image as the lower edge of @xmath199 .
there is a unique rectangle @xmath91 in @xmath124 with boundary contained in @xmath207 , containing @xmath198 and @xmath199 , and with one corner the same as a corner of @xmath198 and the opposite corner the same as a corner of @xmath199 .
it is easy to see that @xmath139 maps antipodal points on the boundary of @xmath91 to the same point in @xmath44 .
it follows that @xmath208 is a two - fold covering map .
but then @xmath139 must have a branch point somewhere inside @xmath91 a contradiction .
see figure [ fig : grid ] .
finally , suppose some arc @xmath209 on @xmath210 has the same image as some other arc @xmath211 in @xmath124 .
if @xmath211 is in the interior of @xmath124 then any rectangle ( or triangle ) adjacent to @xmath209 has the same image as some rectangle ( or triangle ) adjacent to @xmath211 .
we have already ruled this out . if @xmath211 is on @xmath210 , then either any rectangle ( or triangle ) adjacent to @xmath209 has the same image as some rectangle ( or triangle ) adjacent to @xmath211 or there is a branch point somewhere on @xmath210 .
we have already ruled out both of these cases .
we have thus established that @xmath170 is an embedded triangle . by forgetting @xmath170
, we obtain a holomorphic map to @xmath212 still of index zero , but such that its post - composition with @xmath135 is generically @xmath213-to-@xmath95 rather than @xmath129-to-@xmath214 the result then follows by induction on @xmath215 observe that , in proposition [ easternorthodox ] above , even though each of the @xmath129 triangles is embedded , some of their domains may overlap .
it turns out that they may do so only in a specific way , however : [ allow ] suppose @xmath209 is an index zero homology class represented by a union of embedded holomorphic triangles , in a nice triple diagram .
suppose the union of triangles corresponds to an embedded holomorphic curve in @xmath216 .
then any two triangles in @xmath209 are either disjoint in @xmath44 or overlap in @xmath44 `` head to tail '' as shown in figure [ fig : overlap ] .
let @xmath217 and @xmath218 be two of the triangles in the domain @xmath209 . for a generic representative of @xmath209 to exist ,
the pair must also have index zero , and be embedded in @xmath134 .
we already know that @xmath217 and @xmath218 are tiled as in figure [ fig : tiling ] .
this strongly restricts how @xmath217 and @xmath218 can overlap .
one way for @xmath217 and @xmath218 to overlap is for @xmath217 to be entirely contained inside @xmath218 . in this case
, it is not hard to see that the two holomorphic triangles in @xmath134 intersect in one interior point .
indeed , the intersection number of two holomorphic curves in a @xmath11-manifold is invariant in families .
if we deform the heegaard diagram so that the boundary of @xmath217 in @xmath44 is a single point ( i.e. , the alpha , beta and gamma circles involved in @xmath219 intersect in an asterisk , with vertex the `` triangle '' @xmath217 ) then obviously @xmath220 is a single point .
it follows that the same is true for the original triangles @xmath217 and @xmath218 . another way that @xmath217 and @xmath218 might overlap is `` head to head '' as shown on the left side of figure [ fig : headhead ] .
it is then possible to decompose @xmath221 into a pair of rectangles @xmath91 and @xmath222 , and two new embedded triangles @xmath217 and @xmath218 , as shown in figure [ fig : headhead ] .
an immersed rectangle in @xmath44 has index at least @xmath95 , since it admits a generic holomorphic representative .
so , each of @xmath223 and @xmath224 has index at least @xmath95 .
similarly , the pair of triangles @xmath225 has index at least @xmath226 .
so , by additivity of the index , the whole domain has index at least @xmath227 a contradiction . using these two observations , and the rulings of @xmath217 and @xmath218 , it is then elementary to check that the only possible overlap in index zero is `` head to tail '' as in figure [ fig : overlap ] .
it follows that , for a nice heegaard diagram , we can combinatorially describe the generic holomorphic curves of index @xmath226
. if @xmath158 is the domain of a generic holomorphic curve of index @xmath226 then @xmath228 has @xmath129 components , each of which bounds an embedded triangle in @xmath44 .
each pair of triangles must either be disjoint or overlap as shown in figure [ fig : overlap ] .
any such @xmath158 clearly has a unique holomorphic representative with respect to a split complex structure @xmath229 on @xmath134 .
further , it is well known that these holomorphic curves are transversally cut out , and so persist if one takes a small perturbation of @xmath229 . in summary , to count index zero holomorphic curves in @xmath134 with respect to a generic perturbation of the split complex structure , it suffices to count domains @xmath158 which are sums of @xmath129 embedded triangles in @xmath44 , overlapping as allowed in the statement of lemma [ allow ] .
in ( * ? ? ?
* definition 4.2 ) , ozsvth and szab associate to a four - dimensional cobordism @xmath24 consisting of two - handle additions certain kinds of triple heegaard diagrams .
the cobordism @xmath24 from @xmath6 to @xmath7 corresponds to surgery on some framed link @xmath230 denote by @xmath231 the number of components of @xmath232 .
fix a basepoint in @xmath6 .
let @xmath233 be the union of @xmath232 with a path from each component to the basepoint .
the boundary of a regular neighborhood of @xmath233 is a genus @xmath231 surface , which has a subset identified with @xmath231 punctured tori @xmath234 , one for each link component .
a singly - pointed triple heegaard diagram @xmath235 is called _ subordinate to @xmath233 _ if * @xmath236 describes the complement of @xmath233 , * @xmath237 are small isotopic translates of @xmath238 , * after surgering out the @xmath239 , the induced curves @xmath102 and @xmath103 ( for @xmath240 ) lie in the punctured torus @xmath234 . * for @xmath240 ,
the curves @xmath102 represent meridians for the link components , disjoint from all @xmath241 for @xmath242 , and meeting @xmath103 in a single transverse intersection point . * for @xmath240 ,
the homology classes of the @xmath103 correspond to the framings of the link components .
a related construction is as follows .
given @xmath6 and @xmath232 as above , choose a multi - pointed heegaard diagram @xmath243 for @xmath244 as in @xcite , of some genus @xmath45 ; here , @xmath245 and @xmath246 .
precisely , the sets @xmath247 and @xmath248 are collections of distinct points on @xmath44 disjoint from the alpha and the beta curves , with the following two properties : first , each connected component of @xmath249 and @xmath250 contains a single @xmath59 and a corresponding @xmath251 . second , if @xmath252 is an @xmath231-tuple of embedded arcs in @xmath250 connecting @xmath59 to @xmath251 ( @xmath253 ) , and @xmath254 is an @xmath231-tuple of embedded arcs in @xmath249 connecting @xmath59 to @xmath251 ( @xmath253 ) then the link @xmath232 is the union of small push offs of @xmath252 and @xmath254 into the two handlebodies ( induced by the beta and alpha curves , respectively ) .
next , we attach handles @xmath255 to @xmath256 connecting @xmath59 to @xmath251 ( for @xmath253 ) , and obtain a new surface @xmath44 . we choose a new @xmath102 ( @xmath257 ) to be the belt circle of the handle @xmath258 , and a new @xmath93 to be the union of the core of @xmath258 with @xmath259 , so @xmath93 intersects @xmath102 in one point .
choose @xmath103 ( @xmath260 ) to be a small isotopic translate of @xmath102 , intersecting @xmath102 in two points .
let @xmath261 ( @xmath257 ) be the union of @xmath262 with a core of the handle @xmath258 .
obtain @xmath103 ( @xmath257 ) by applying dehn twists to @xmath261 around @xmath102 ; the framing of the link is determined by the number of dehn twists .
in this fashion we obtain a multi - pointed triple heegaard diagram @xmath263 with @xmath264 curves of each kind .
note that @xmath67 is an @xmath231-pointed heegaard diagram for @xmath6 , @xmath265 is a @xmath231-pointed heegaard diagram for @xmath7 , and @xmath266 is a @xmath231-pointed heegaard diagram for @xmath267 . the new circles @xmath93 , @xmath257 , are part of a maximal homologically linearly independent subset of @xmath268 , and similarly for @xmath102 and @xmath103 ( @xmath257 ) .
consequently , by the proof of lemma [ lemma : splitdiagrams ] , there is a split diagram strongly equivalent to @xmath269 whose reduction @xmath87 is obtained from @xmath270 by forgetting @xmath271 of the @xmath93 ( respectively @xmath102 , @xmath103 ) , @xmath272 , as well as @xmath273 .
it is then not hard to see that @xmath87 is a triple heegaard diagram subordinate to a bouquet for @xmath232 . in this section
we will show that for any two - handle addition , one can construct a _
triple heegaard diagram strongly equivalent to a diagram @xmath274 as above .
this involves finessing the diagram for the link @xmath232 inside @xmath1 and then , after adding the handles and the new curves , modifying the diagram in several steps to make it nice .
for the most part we will focus on the case when we add a single two - handle . in the last subsection we will explain how the arguments generalize to several two - handles . to keep language concise , in this section
we will refer to elementary domains as _
let @xmath159 be a multi - pointed heegaard diagram .
recall that the diagram is called nice if all unpunctured regions are either bigons or squares .
[ lemma : bad_region_adjacent ] on a nice heegaard diagram @xmath159 , for any alpha circle @xmath93 with an arbitrary orientation , there exists a punctured region @xmath158 which contains an edge @xmath163 belonging to @xmath93 , and such that @xmath158 is on the left of @xmath93 .
the same conclusion holds for each beta circle .
suppose a half - neighborhood on the left of the alpha circle @xmath93 is disjoint from all the punctured regions . then immediately to the left of @xmath93 we only have good regions .
there are two possibilities as indicated in figure [ fig : bad_region_adjacent ] .
if there is a bigon region on the left of @xmath275 then the other edge is some beta edge @xmath276 .
the region on the other side of @xmath276 must be a bigon region or a square since otherwise we would have a punctured region on the left of @xmath93 .
if we reach a square , we continue to consider the next region .
eventually we will reach a bigon region since the number of regions are finite and we will not reach the same region twice .
all regions involved form a disk bounded by @xmath93 ( as in figure [ fig : bad_region_adjacent ] ( a ) ) . in particular
, this means @xmath93 is null homologous .
this contradicts the fact that the @xmath277 alpha circles represent linearly independent classes in @xmath278 in the second case , there are no bigon regions .
then on the left of @xmath93 , we see a chain of squares , as in figure [ fig : bad_region_adjacent ] ( b ) .
the opposite edges on these squares give another alpha circle , say @xmath279 .
then @xmath93 and @xmath279 are homologous to each other in @xmath278 this contradicts the same fact as in the previous case .
recall that in order to define the triangle maps it is necessary for the triple heegaard diagram to be weakly admissible in the sense of ( * ? ? ?
* definition 8.8 ) .
[ lemma : admissible ] if @xmath80 is a nice multi - pointed triple heegaard diagram then @xmath80 is weakly admissible . by definition ,
the diagram is weakly admissible if there are no nontrivial domains @xmath158 supported in @xmath280 with nonnegative multiplicity in all regions , and whose boundary is a linear combination of alpha , beta , and gamma curves .
suppose such a domain @xmath158 exists , and consider a curve appearing with a nonzero multiplicity in @xmath281 without loss of generality , we can assume this is an alpha curve , and all regions immediately to its left have positive multiplicity in @xmath282 by lemma [ lemma : forget ] , the diagram @xmath67 is nice .
lemma [ lemma : bad_region_adjacent ] now gives a contradiction .
let @xmath283 be a three - manifold together with a knot @xmath284 .
we choose a singly pointed heegaard diagram @xmath285 for @xmath1 together with an additional basepoint @xmath286 such that the two basepoints determine the knot as in @xcite . after applying the algorithm from @xcite to the heegaard diagram
, we can assume that the heegaard diagram is nice , with @xmath287 the ( usually bad ) region containing the basepoint @xmath288 furthermore , the algorithm in @xcite also ensures that @xmath287 is a polygon .
we denote by @xmath289 the region containing @xmath290 note that either @xmath291 or @xmath289 is good . throughout this section
, we will suppose that @xmath289 and @xmath287 are two different regions , and that @xmath289 is a rectangle .
the case when @xmath291 corresponds to surgery on the unknot , which is already well understood .
the case when @xmath289 is a bigon can be avoided by modifying the original diagram by a finger move .
( alternately , this case can be treated similarly to the case that @xmath289 is a rectangle . )
let @xmath24 be the four manifold with boundary obtained from @xmath292 $ ] by adding a two handle along @xmath293 in @xmath294 , with some framing .
@xmath24 gives a cobordism between @xmath1 and @xmath295 , where @xmath295 is obtained from @xmath1 by doing the corresponding surgery along @xmath293 .
now we are ready to describe our algorithm to get a nice triple heegaard diagram for the cobordism @xmath296 let @xmath252 be an embedded arc in @xmath44 connecting @xmath297 and @xmath298 in the complement of beta curves , and @xmath254 be an embedded arc connecting @xmath297 and @xmath298 in the complement of alpha curves .
the union of @xmath252 and @xmath254 is a projection of the knot @xmath284 to the surface @xmath144 where @xmath44 is viewed as a heegaard surface in @xmath299 for convenience , we will always assume that @xmath252 and @xmath254 do not pass through any bigon regions , and never leave a rectangle by the same edge through which they entered ; this can easily be achieved . in this step ,
we modify the doubly pointed heegaard diagram @xmath300 to make @xmath301 embedded in @xmath144 while preserving the niceness of the heegaard diagram .
typically , @xmath252 and @xmath254 have many intersections .
we modify the diagram inductively by stabilization at the first intersection @xmath302 on @xmath254 ( going from @xmath297 to @xmath298 ) to remove that intersection , while making sure that the new diagram is still nice .
a neighborhood of @xmath252 and the part on @xmath254 from @xmath297 to @xmath15 are shown in figure [ fig : knot_embedded_before ] . in the same picture ,
if we continue the chain of rectangles containing @xmath252 , we will end up with a region @xmath303 which is either a bigon or the punctured region @xmath287 .
to get rid of the intersection point @xmath15 , we stabilize the diagram as in figure [ fig : knot_embedded_after ] . more precisely , we do a stabilization followed some handleslides of the beta curves and an isotopy of the new beta curve .
after these moves , the number of intersection points decreases by one and the diagram is still nice .
if we iterate this process , in the end we get a nice heegaard diagram in which @xmath252 and @xmath254 only intersect at their endpoints .
furthermore , the bad region @xmath287 is still a polygon .
our goal in steps 2 and 3 is to describe a particular triple heegaard diagram for the cobordism @xmath24 . starting with the alpha and the beta curves we already have , for each beta curve @xmath102
we will add a gamma curve @xmath103 ( called its twin ) which is isotopic to @xmath102 and intersects it in exactly two points .
( after this , we will add some more curves in the next step . ) for any beta curve @xmath102 , by lemma [ lemma : bad_region_adjacent ] we can choose a region @xmath145 so that @xmath145 is adjacent to the punctured region @xmath287 with the common edge on @xmath102 . if @xmath304 , then we add @xmath103 close and parallel to @xmath102 as in figure [ fig : adding_gamma_curve_simple ] ( a ) , and make a finger move as in figure [ fig : adding_gamma_curve_simple ] ( b ) . here and after , without further specification , we make the convention that the thick arcs are alpha arcs , the thin ones are beta arcs , and the interrupted ones are gamma arcs .
suppose now that @xmath145 is different from @xmath287 .
then @xmath145 has to be a good region .
if @xmath145 is not a bigon , since the complement of the beta curves in @xmath44 is connected , we can connect @xmath145 with @xmath287 without intersecting beta curves , via an arc traversing a chain of rectangles , as indicated in the figure [ fig : adding_gamma_curve_before ] .
then we do a finger move of the curve @xmath102 as indicated in figure [ fig : adding_gamma_curve_after ] .
note that the knot remains embedded in @xmath44 .
now we have a bigon region .
we then add the gamma curve @xmath103 as shown in figure [ fig : adding_gamma_curve_after ] .
note that for each pair @xmath102 and @xmath103 , we either have one sub - diagram of the form in figure [ fig : adding_gamma_curve_simple ] ( b ) , or one sub - diagram of the form in figure [ fig : beta_gamma_bigon ] .
observe also that during this process , no bad region other than @xmath287 is created .
after step 2 , the knot is still embedded in the heegaard diagram . in other words , we can use arcs to connect @xmath297 to @xmath298 by paths in the complement of alpha curves , and in the complement of beta curves so that the two arcs do not intersect except for the end points @xmath298 and @xmath297 , and do not pass through any bigons .
we will see two chains of squares , as indicated in figure [ fig : stabilization ] .
we do a stabilization of the heegaard diagram by adding a handle with one foot in each of @xmath287 and @xmath289 .
we add the additional beta circle @xmath305 to be the meridian of the handle , which we push along @xmath252 until it reaches @xmath306 we also push @xmath305 through the opposite alpha edge of @xmath289 , into the adjacent region .
then , we connect the two feet in the complement of alpha curves along @xmath254 and get a new alpha circle @xmath307 . finally , we add the surgery gamma circle @xmath308 as in figure [ fig : stabilization ] .
the result is a triple heegaard diagram ( with @xmath309 curves ) which represents surgery along the knot @xmath284 , with a particular framing ; the framing is the sum of the number of twists of @xmath308 around the handle and a constant depending only on the original heegaard diagram .
note that , depending on the framing , the local picture around the two feet of the handle may also look like figure [ fig : stabilization_anti ] , in which case instead of the octagon region @xmath310 from figure [ fig : stabilization ] we have two hexagon bad regions @xmath311 and @xmath312 .
after the stabilization , @xmath307 and @xmath308 separate @xmath287 into several regions ; among these , @xmath313 and @xmath314 are ( possibly ) bad but all other regions are good .
we end up with a diagram with four ( or five ) bad regions : @xmath313 , @xmath314 , @xmath310 ( or @xmath311 and @xmath312 ) , and @xmath303 .
( in some cases , @xmath313 or @xmath314 might be good , or , if there is little winding of @xmath315 some of @xmath310 , @xmath316 and @xmath314 might coincide .
the argument in these cases is a simple adaptation of the one we give below . )
we will kill the badness of @xmath317 @xmath318 and @xmath310 ( or @xmath311 and @xmath312 ) , while the region @xmath313 will be the one containing the basepoint @xmath297 for our final triple heegaard diagram .
we push the finger in @xmath303 across the opposite alpha edge until we reach a bigon , @xmath319 or a region of type @xmath320 as in figure [ fig : beta_gamma_bigon ] . in this case
( figure [ fig : dprime_bigon ] ( a ) ) , our finger move will kill the badness of @xmath303 , as indicated in figure [ fig : dprime_bigon ] ( b ) , and does not create any new bad regions .
this is completely similar to case 1 .
the finger move kills the badness of @xmath303 , and does not create any new bad regions .
let us suppose the topmost region in figure [ fig : beta_gamma_bigon ] is @xmath313 .
the case when the topmost region is @xmath314 is completely similar .
the regions involved look like figure [ fig : dprime_ds_bad ] . if on the left @xmath313 is on top of @xmath314 , we isotope the diagram to look as in figure [ fig : dprime_ds_nice ] .
the case when on the left of figure [ fig : beta_gamma_bigon ] @xmath314 is on top of @xmath313 is similar , except that we do the double finger move on the other side of @xmath305 .
we have now killed the badness of @xmath303 . if there are any bigons between beta and gamma curves adjacent to @xmath314 as in figure [ fig : beta_gamma_bigon ] or figure [ fig : adding_gamma_curve_simple ] ( b ) , also shown in figures [ fig : dw2_special_handleslide ] ( a ) resp .
( c ) , we do a `` handleslide '' ( more precisely , a handleslide followed by an isotopy ) of @xmath308 over each @xmath103 ( @xmath322 ) involved as indicated in figures [ fig : dw2_special_handleslide ] ( b ) resp .
the intersection of @xmath308 and @xmath307 has the pattern as figure [ fig : dw2_two_patterns ] ( a ) or ( b ) . in case (
a ) , we do nothing . in case
( b ) , we do the finger move as in figure [ fig : dw2_two_patterns ] ( c ) . now among the possibly bad regions generated from @xmath314 , we have a unique one whose boundary has an intersection of a beta curve with a gamma curve , namely the one near @xmath305 as in figure [ fig : dw2_beta_gamma_crossing ] ( a ) .
( see also figures [ fig : stabilization ] and [ fig : dprime_ds_nice ] . )
we then do a finger move as in figure [ fig : dw2_beta_gamma_crossing ] ( b ) .
note that this finger move will not create any badness other than that of @xmath313 . after these special handleslides and finger moves , the region @xmath314 is divided into several possibly bad regions @xmath323 these bad regions are all adjacent to @xmath313 via arcs on @xmath308 and , furthermore , there are no intersection points of beta and gamma curves on their boundaries .
we seek to kill the badness of @xmath324 using the algorithm in @xcite .
the algorithm there consisted of inductively decreasing a complexity function defined using the unpunctured bad regions .
in our situation , we apply a simple modification of the algorithm to the heegaard diagram made of the alpha and the gamma curves ; the modification consists of the fact that we do not deal with the bad region(s ) @xmath310 ( or @xmath311 and @xmath312 ) , but rather only seek to eliminate the badness of @xmath325 thus , in the complexity function we do not include terms that involve the badness and distance of @xmath310 ( or @xmath311 and @xmath312 ) .
since all the @xmath326 s are adjacent to the preferred ( punctured ) region @xmath313 via arcs on @xmath315 the algorithm in @xcite prescribes doing finger moves of @xmath308 through alpha curves , and ( possibly ) handleslides of @xmath308 over other gamma curves .
we do all these moves in such a way as not to tamper with the arrangements of twin beta - gamma curves , i.e. as not to introduce any new intersection points between @xmath308 and @xmath327 for any @xmath328 .
( in other words , we can think of fattening @xmath329 before applying the algorithm , so that they include their respective twin beta curves . ) in particular , regions of type @xmath320 are treated as bigons .
the fact that the algorithm in @xcite can be applied in this fashion is based on the following two observations : * our fingers or handleslides will not pass through the regions adjacent to @xmath305 , except possibly @xmath313 itself .
( this is one benefit of the modification performed in figure [ fig : dw2_beta_gamma_crossing ] . )
* we will not reach any squares between @xmath102 and @xmath330 nor the `` narrow '' squares created in figure [ fig : dw2_special_handleslide ] . in the end , all the badness of @xmath324 is killed .
we arrive at a heegaard diagram which might still have some bad regions coming from regions of type @xmath331 as in figure [ fig : dw2_special_bad_region ] ( a ) .
we kill these bad regions using the finger moves indicated in figure [ fig : dw2_special_bad_region ] ( b ) . after these moves ,
the only remaining bad regions are @xmath310 ( or @xmath311 and @xmath312 ) , and the preferred bad region @xmath332 our remaining task is to kill the badness of @xmath310 or @xmath333 .
recall that depending on the pattern of the intersection of @xmath307 and @xmath308 ( cf .
figure [ fig : dw2_two_patterns ] ) , there are two cases : either we have an octagon bad region @xmath310 , or two hexagon bad regions @xmath311 and @xmath312 . in the first case ,
one possibility is that a neighborhood of @xmath334 looks as in figure [ fig : dstar_bad ] .
we then do the finger moves indicated in figure [ fig : dstar_nice ] .
it is routine to check that the new diagram is isotopic to the one in figure [ fig : dstar_bad ] .
similarly , in the second case , one possibility is that a neighborhood of @xmath334 looks as in figure [ fig : dstar_bad_case2 ] . in this case
, we do the finger moves indicated in figure [ fig : dstar_nice_case2 ] .
however , the actual picture on the heegaard diagram may differ from figure [ fig : dstar_bad ] or [ fig : dstar_bad_case2 ] in several ( non - essential ) ways .
one possible difference is that at the bottom of the figure [ fig : dstar_bad_case2 ] , the extra gamma curve on top of @xmath313 might be on the right rather than on the left ; however , we can still push the two fingers starting from @xmath313 on each side of @xmath307 .
another possible difference is that at the very left of figures [ fig : dstar_bad ] and [ fig : dstar_bad_case2 ] , the curve @xmath308 may have an upward rather than a downward hook , i.e. look as in figure [ fig : dw_1and2_switched](c ) rather than ( a ) .
if so , instead of the beta finger from the left in figures [ fig : dstar_bad ] and [ fig : dstar_bad_case2 ] ( cf . also figure [ fig : dw_1and2_switched](b ) ) , we push a beta - gamma finger as in figure [ fig : dw_1and2_switched](d ) .
finally , instead of the situations shown in figures [ fig : dstar_bad ] and [ fig : dstar_bad_case2 ] , we might have the same pictures reflected in a horizontal axis .
if so , we apply similar finger moves and arrive at the reflections of figures [ fig : dstar_nice ] and [ fig : dstar_nice_case2 ] . in all cases ,
the finger moves successfully kill the badness of all regions other than @xmath316 in which we keep the basepoint @xmath288 the result is a nice triple heegaard diagram for the cobordism @xmath24 .
we now explain how the arguments in this section can be extended to a cobordism @xmath24 which consists of the addition of several two - handles .
we view @xmath24 as surgery along a link @xmath335 of @xmath231 components .
we start with a multi - pointed heegaard diagram @xmath336 together with another set of basepoints @xmath248 describing the pair @xmath337 as in @xcite .
each of the two sets of curves ( @xmath268 and @xmath338 ) has @xmath339 elements .
applying the algorithm in @xcite we can make this diagram nice , i.e. such that all regions not containing one of the @xmath297 s are either bigons or rectangles . for @xmath340
we denote by @xmath341 the region containing @xmath342 as in step 1 of section [ sec : boss ] , we inductively remove intersection points between the various components of the projection of @xmath232 to @xmath44 .
this projection consists of arcs @xmath262 and @xmath343 with endpoints at @xmath59 and @xmath344 , such that each @xmath262 is disjoint from the beta curves , and each @xmath343 is disjoint from the alpha curves . instead of figure [
fig : knot_embedded_before ] we have the situation in figure [ fig : link_embedded_before ] .
again , we stabilize and perform an isotopy to obtain a good diagram with one fewer intersection point , as in figure [ fig : knot_embedded_after ] . iterating this process ( on all link components )
, we can assume that the projection of @xmath232 is embedded in the heegaard surface .
we then add twin gamma curves as in step 2 of section [ sec : boss ] .
for this we need to do several isotopies of the beta curves as in figure [ fig : adding_gamma_curve_after ] . in that figure , if the region on the top left is @xmath345 the one on the right might be @xmath346 for @xmath347 ; however , the isotopy can be done as before .
next , we stabilize the heegaard diagram @xmath231 times ( once for each link component ) to obtain a triple diagram for the cobordism , as in step 3 of section [ sec : boss ] .
we then do the analogue of step 4 by pushing @xmath231 fingers to kill the badness of the regions of type @xmath348 .
since the fingers only pass through rectangles , they do not intersect each other .
the only change is that in figures [ fig : dprime_ds_bad ] and [ fig : dprime_ds_nice ] , the region on the very right may contain a different puncture @xmath59 than the one on the left . by contrast , in case 2 of step 4 , the region on the right in figure [ fig : dprime_bigon ] contains the same puncture as the region on the left , since they lie in the same connected component of the complement of the beta circles . at the end of step 4 , the beta curves split the heegaard surface into @xmath231 connected components @xmath349 .
we then do the analogue of step 5 in section [ sec : boss ] .
note that this step ( except for the very last bit , figure [ fig : dw2_special_bad_region ] ) only involves moving gamma curves through alpha curves .
( here , we think of the move in figure [ fig : dw2_special_handleslide ] as a single step , rather than as a handleslide followed by an isotopy . )
therefore , we can perform the moves in this step once for each connected component of @xmath232 , independently of each other , because the moves take place in the corresponding component @xmath350 in the situation considered in figure [ fig : dw2_special_bad_region ] , the gamma curves cross a beta curve ; however , the special region @xmath321 is part of a unique @xmath351 , so we can perform the isotopy of the gamma curves as before , without interference from another @xmath352 finally , for step 6 , note that in all the previous steps we have not destroyed the property that the projection of @xmath232 to the heegaard surface is embedded . more precisely , in the part of the stabilized heegaard diagram shown in figure [ fig : stabilization ] , we take a component of the link projection to be a loop starting in @xmath310 , near the upper foot of the handle , going down along @xmath307 until it reaches @xmath313 , then going inside @xmath313 until it reaches the intersection of @xmath308 and @xmath353 and then going along a sub - arc of @xmath308 to its original departure .
these paths remain embedded , and disjoint from each other , throughout steps 4 and 5 .
( indeed , neither @xmath305 nor this sub - arc of @xmath308 is moved during these steps . )
it then suffices to note the finger moves in step 6 take place in a neighborhood of the projection of the corresponding link component ( the path considered above ) .
therefore , these finger moves can be done without interfering with each other .
the result is a nice multi - pointed triple heegaard diagram for @xmath24 .
let @xmath24 be a @xmath11-dimensional cobordism from @xmath354 to @xmath355 , and @xmath8 a @xmath2-structure on @xmath24 .
choose a self - indexing morse function on @xmath24 .
this decomposes @xmath24 as a collection of one - handle additions which together form a cobordism @xmath356 , followed by some two - handle additions forming a cobordism @xmath357 , and three - handle additions forming a cobordism @xmath358 , in this order .
let @xmath6 and @xmath7 be the intermediate three - manifolds , so that @xmath359 the map @xmath360 from @xcite is defined as the composition @xmath361 of maps associated to each of the pieces @xmath356 , @xmath357 and @xmath358 .
we will review the definitions of these three maps in sections [ section : onethreehandles ] and [ sec : twohandlemaps ] .
first we review a few facts about the @xmath362-action on the hat heegaard floer invariants . in ( * ?
* section 4.2.5 ) , ozsvth and szab constructed an action of the group @xmath363 on @xmath31 . in @xcite ( see also ( * ? ? ?
* section 2 ) ) , they also showed that the cobordism maps @xmath22 extend to maps @xmath364 moreover , if @xmath24 is a cobordism from @xmath6 to @xmath7 ( endowed with a @xmath2 structure @xmath8 ) and we denote by @xmath365 the natural inclusions , then for any @xmath366 of the form @xmath367 one has @xmath368 this equality has the following immediate corollaries : [ l1 ] if @xmath369 then @xmath370 for any @xmath371 [ l2 ] if @xmath372 then @xmath373 for any @xmath374 consider now a 3-manifold of the form @xmath375 , and let @xmath376 denote the torsion @xmath2-structure on @xmath377 . then for any @xmath2-structure @xmath3 on @xmath1 there is an isomorphism @xmath378 as @xmath379$]-modules , cf .
* theorem 1.5 ) . here , the action of @xmath380 on @xmath4 is trivial , as is the action of @xmath362 on @xmath381 .
further , the action of @xmath382 on @xmath383 is exactly the given by cap product @xmath384 .
next , we review the definition of the heegaard floer maps induced by one- and three - handle additions , cf .
* section 4.3 ) .
suppose that @xmath356 is a cobordism from @xmath354 to @xmath6 built entirely from @xmath95-handles .
let @xmath8 be a @xmath2-structure on @xmath356 .
the map @xmath385 is constructed as follows . if @xmath386 are the @xmath95-handles in the cobordism , for each @xmath387 pick a path @xmath388 in @xmath354 , joining the two feet of the handle @xmath389 this induces a connected sum decomposition @xmath390 , where the first homology of each @xmath391 factor is generated by the union of @xmath388 with the core of the corresponding handle .
further , the restriction of @xmath8 to the @xmath392-summands in @xmath6 is torsion .
it follows that @xmath393 .
let @xmath394 be the generator of the top - graded part of @xmath395 .
then the heegaard floer map induced by @xmath356 is given by @xmath396 it is proved in ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 4.13 ) that , up to composition with canonical isomorphisms , @xmath397 does not depend on the choices made in its construction , such as the choice of the paths @xmath398 dually , suppose that @xmath358 is a cobordism from @xmath7 to @xmath355 built entirely from @xmath399-handles .
let @xmath8 be a @xmath2-structure on @xmath358 .
the map @xmath400 is constructed as follows .
one can reverse @xmath358 and view it as attaching @xmath95-handles on @xmath355 to get @xmath401 after choosing paths between the feet of these @xmath95-handles in @xmath402 we obtain a decomposition @xmath403 ( where @xmath129 is the number of @xmath399-handles of @xmath358 ) .
further , the restriction of @xmath8 to the @xmath392-summands in @xmath7 is torsion .
it follows that @xmath404 .
let @xmath405 be the generator of the lowest - graded part of @xmath406 .
then the heegaard floer map induced by @xmath358 is given by @xmath407 and @xmath408 for any homogeneous generator @xmath409 of @xmath406 not lying in the minimal degree .
again , the map is independent of the choices made in its construction .
let @xmath357 be a two - handle cobordism from @xmath6 to @xmath7 , corresponding to surgery on a framed link @xmath232 in @xmath6 , and let @xmath8 be a @xmath2-structure on @xmath357 .
let @xmath87 be a triple heegaard diagram subordinate to a bouquet @xmath233 for @xmath232 , as in the beginning of section [ sec : two ] .
then , in particular , @xmath410 is a heegaard diagram for @xmath6 , @xmath411 is a heegaard diagram for @xmath7 , and @xmath412 is a heegaard diagram for @xmath413 .
( here , @xmath45 is the genus of @xmath414 and @xmath231 the number of components of @xmath232 . )
the @xmath2-structure @xmath8 induces a @xmath2-structure ( still denoted @xmath8 ) on the four - manifold @xmath415 specified by @xmath416 ( note that @xmath415 can be viewed as a subset of @xmath357 . )
consequently , there is an induced map @xmath417 as discussed in section [ sec : prels ] .
the @xmath2-structure @xmath418 is necessarily torsion , so @xmath419 let @xmath394 denote the generator for the top - dimensional part of @xmath420 .
then we define ( cf .
* section 4.1 ) ) the map @xmath421 by @xmath422 .
now , consider instead the nice , @xmath231-pointed triple heegaard diagram @xmath80 constructed in section [ sec : two ] .
as discussed in the beginning of section [ sec : two ] , @xmath80 is strongly equivalent to a split triple heegaard diagram whose reduction @xmath87 is subordinate to a bouquet @xmath233 as above .
let @xmath423 be the generator for the top - dimensional part of @xmath424 .
then , by diagram , with @xmath425 , we have @xmath426 in light of corollary [ lemma : admissible ] and proposition [ easternorthodox ] , the rank of the map @xmath120 can be computed combinatorially .
further , since the triple heegaard diagram @xmath80 is nice , so are each of the three ( ordinary ) heegaard diagrams it specifies .
consequently , by @xcite , the element @xmath427 can be explicitly identified ( as can a representative for @xmath423 in @xmath428 ) .
therefore , the rank of @xmath429 can be computed combinatorially .
recall that @xmath24 is a @xmath11-dimensional cobordism from @xmath354 to @xmath355 , @xmath8 a @xmath2-structure on @xmath24 , and that @xmath24 is decomposed as a collection of one - handle additions @xmath356 , followed by some two - handle additions @xmath357 , and three - handle additions @xmath358 , with @xmath6 and @xmath7 the intermediate three - manifolds , so that @xmath359 as in section [ sec : action ] , we consider the maps @xmath430 [ onto1 ] if @xmath431 is surjective , then @xmath432 the cobordism @xmath356 consists of the addition of some @xmath95-handles @xmath433 as in section [ section : onethreehandles ] , we choose paths @xmath388 in @xmath354 joining the two feet of the handle @xmath389 the union of @xmath388 with the core of @xmath255 produces a curve in @xmath356 , which in turn gives an element @xmath434 since @xmath24 is obtained from @xmath435 by adding @xmath399-handles , we have @xmath436 , so the hypothesis implies that the map @xmath437 is surjective
. hence there exist disjoint , embedded curves @xmath262 in @xmath354 ( disjoint from all the @xmath438 ) such that @xmath439 ) = -e_i , i=1 , \dots , n.$ ] we can connect sum @xmath388 and @xmath262 to get new paths @xmath440 in @xmath354 between the two feet of @xmath389 using the paths @xmath440 we get a connected sum decomposition @xmath441 as in section [ section : onethreehandles ] , with the property that the inclusion of the summand @xmath442 in @xmath443 is trivial . since we can view @xmath435 as obtained from @xmath357 by adding @xmath399-handles ( which do not affect @xmath444 ) , it follows that the inclusion of @xmath380 in @xmath445 is trivial .
lemma [ l1 ] then says that @xmath446 for any @xmath447 thus the kernel of @xmath448 contains all elements of the form @xmath449 , where @xmath450 and @xmath451 is any homogeneous element not lying in the top grading of @xmath452 on the other hand , from section [ section : onethreehandles ] we know that the image of @xmath453 consists exactly of the elements @xmath454 where @xmath394 is the top degree generator of @xmath455 therefore , @xmath456 this gives the desired result .
[ onto2 ] if @xmath457 is surjective , then @xmath458 this is similar to the proof of lemma [ onto1 ] .
a suitable choice of paths enables us to view @xmath7 as @xmath459 such that the inclusion of the summand @xmath460 in @xmath445 is trivial .
lemma [ l2 ] then says that @xmath461 for any @xmath462 and @xmath463 in other words , every element in the image of @xmath448 must be of the form @xmath464 where @xmath465 and @xmath405 is the lowest degree generator of @xmath455 on the other hand , from section [ section : onethreehandles ] we know that the kernel of the map @xmath466 does not contain any nonzero elements of the form @xmath467 let @xmath24 be a cobordism from @xmath354 to @xmath355 , and @xmath8 a @xmath2-structure on @xmath24 .
assume that the maps @xmath431 and @xmath457 from formula are surjective .
then in each ( relative ) grading @xmath468 the rank of @xmath469 can be computed combinatorially .
the map @xmath10 is , by definition , the composition @xmath470 .
lemmas [ onto1 ] and [ onto2 ] imply that @xmath471 or , equivalently , @xmath472 using lemma [ onto1 ] again , the expression on the right is the same as the rank of @xmath473 thus , the maps @xmath10 and @xmath448 have the same rank . as explained in section [ sec : twohandlemaps ] , the rank of @xmath448 can be computed combinatorially .
note that the relative gradings on the generators of the chain complexes are also combinatorial , using the formula for the maslov index in ( * ? ? ?
* corollary 4.3 ) .
this completes the proof .
in fact , using sarkar s remarkable formula for the maslov index of triangles ( * ? ? ? * theorem 4.1 ) , the absolute gradings on the heegaard floer complexes can be computed combinatorially , and so the rank of @xmath10 in each absolute grading can be computed as well .
we give a nice triple heegaard diagram for the cobordism from the three - sphere to the poincar homology sphere , viewed as the @xmath41 surgery on the right - handed trefoil .
the right - handed trefoil knot admits the nice heegaard diagram shown in figure [ fig : poincare_trefoil ] , which is isotopic to ( * ? ? ?
* figure 14 ) . applying the algorithm described in section [ sec : two ]
, we obtain the nice triple heegaard diagram shown in figure [ fig : poincare_nice ] .
we leave the actual computation of the cobordism map to the interested reader . | in a previous paper , sarkar and the third author gave a combinatorial description of the hat version of heegaard floer homology for three - manifolds . given a cobordism between two connected three - manifolds , there is an induced map between their heegaard floer homologies .
assume that the first homology group of each boundary component surjects onto the first homology group of the cobordism ( modulo torsion ) .
under this assumption , we present a procedure for finding the rank of the induced heegaard floer map combinatorially , in the hat version . |
through the @xmath14 transition at quark level , the @xmath15 decays are able to produce the @xmath16 bound states like @xmath17 ; particularly , the hidden charm tetraquarks to consist of @xmath18 , such as @xmath19 , @xmath20 , and @xmath21 , known as the @xmath22 states @xcite . for example
, we have @xcite @xmath23 where @xmath3 is composed of @xmath24 , measured to have the quantum numbers @xmath25 . on the other hand
, the @xmath26 decays from the @xmath27 transition can also be the relevant production mechanism for the @xmath16 and @xmath18 bound states .
however , the current measurements have been done only for the ratios , given by @xcite @xmath28 where @xmath29 are the fragmentation fractions defined by @xmath30 .
in addition , none of the @xmath22 states has been observed in the @xmath31 decays yet . from figs .
[ fig1]a and [ fig1]d , the @xmath32 decays proceed with the @xmath33 transition , which is followed by the recoiled @xmath2 with @xmath34 , respectively , presented as the matrix elements of @xmath35 . unlike @xmath17 as the genuine @xmath16 bound state , while the matrix element for the tetraquark production is in fact not computable , @xmath36 is often taken as the charmonium state in the qcd models @xcite . in this study , we will extract @xmath37 from the data of @xmath38 in eq .
( [ data1 ] ) to examine the decays of @xmath39 , @xmath40 , and @xmath41 , of which the extraction allows @xmath36 to be the tetraquark state . on the other hand , to calculate the @xmath42 decays in figs .
[ fig1]b and [ fig1]e and the semileptonic @xmath43 decays in figs .
[ fig1]c and [ fig1]f , we use the @xmath44 transition matrix elements from the qcd calculations .
and @xmath31 decays with the formations of the @xmath16 pair , where @xmath45 , @xmath46 and @xmath47 correspond to the @xmath48 , @xmath49 , and @xmath50 decays , while @xmath51 , @xmath52 and @xmath53 the @xmath54 , @xmath55 , and @xmath56 decays , respectively.,title="fig:",width=192 ] and @xmath31 decays with the formations of the @xmath16 pair , where @xmath45 , @xmath46 and @xmath47 correspond to the @xmath48 , @xmath49 , and @xmath50 decays , while @xmath51 , @xmath52 and @xmath53 the @xmath54 , @xmath55 , and @xmath56 decays , respectively.,title="fig:",width=192 ] and @xmath31 decays with the formations of the @xmath16 pair , where @xmath45 , @xmath46 and @xmath47 correspond to the @xmath48 , @xmath49 , and @xmath50 decays , while @xmath51 , @xmath52 and @xmath53 the @xmath54 , @xmath55 , and @xmath56 decays , respectively.,title="fig:",width=192 ] and @xmath31 decays with the formations of the @xmath16 pair , where @xmath45 , @xmath46 and @xmath47 correspond to the @xmath48 , @xmath49 , and @xmath50 decays , while @xmath51 , @xmath52 and @xmath53 the @xmath54 , @xmath55 , and @xmath56 decays , respectively.,title="fig:",width=192 ] and @xmath31 decays with the formations of the @xmath16 pair , where @xmath45 , @xmath46 and @xmath47 correspond to the @xmath48 , @xmath49 , and @xmath50 decays , while @xmath51 , @xmath52 and @xmath53 the @xmath54 , @xmath55 , and @xmath56 decays , respectively.,title="fig:",width=192 ] and @xmath31 decays with the formations of the @xmath16 pair , where @xmath45 , @xmath46 and @xmath47 correspond to the @xmath48 , @xmath49 , and @xmath50 decays , while @xmath51 , @xmath52 and @xmath53 the @xmath54 , @xmath55 , and @xmath56 decays , respectively.,title="fig:",width=192 ] in terms of the effective hamiltonians at quark level for the @xmath57 , @xmath58 , and @xmath59 transitions in fig . [ fig1 ] , the amplitudes of the @xmath60 , @xmath32 , and @xmath61 decays can be factorized as @xcite @xmath62 respectively , where @xmath63 , @xmath64 , @xmath65 for @xmath66 , @xmath67 , @xmath68 , @xmath69 is the fermi constant , @xmath70 are the ckm matrix elements , and @xmath71 are the parameters to be determined . in eq .
( [ amp1 ] ) , the decay constant , four momentum vector , and four polarization @xmath72 are defined by @xmath73 while the matrix elements of the @xmath74 transitions can be parametrized as @xcite @xmath75 f_1^{bm}(t)+\frac{m^2_b - m^2_m}{t}q^\mu f_0^{bm}(t)\,,\nonumber\\ \langle j/\psi|\bar c\gamma_\mu b|b_c^-\rangle&=&\epsilon_{\mu\nu\alpha\beta } \varepsilon^{\ast\nu}p_{b_c}^{\alpha}p_{j/\psi}^{\beta}\frac{2v(t)}{m_{b_c}+m_{j/\psi}}\;,\nonumber\\ \langle j/\psi|\bar c\gamma_\mu \gamma_5 b|b_c^-\rangle & = & i\bigg[\varepsilon^\ast_\mu-\frac{\varepsilon^\ast\cdot q}{t}q_\mu\bigg](m_{b_c}+m_{j/\psi})a_1(t ) + i\frac{\varepsilon^\ast\cdot q}{t}q_\mu(2m_{j/\psi})a_0(t)\nonumber\\ & -&i\bigg[(p_{b_c}+p_{j/\psi})_\mu-\frac{m^2_{b_c } -m^2_{j/\psi}}{t}q_\mu \bigg](\varepsilon^\ast\cdot q)\frac{a_2(t)}{m_b+m_{j/\psi}}\;,\nonumber\\ % \langle x_c^0|\bar c\gamma_\mu \gamma_5 b|b_c^-\rangle&=&-\epsilon_{\mu\nu\alpha\beta } \varepsilon^{\ast\nu}p_{b_c}^{\alpha}p_{x_c^0}^{\beta}\frac{2ia(t)}{m_{b_c}-m_{x_c^0}}\;,\nonumber\\
\langle x_c^0|\bar c\gamma_\mu b|b_c^-\rangle & = & -\bigg[\varepsilon^\ast_\mu-\frac{\varepsilon^\ast\cdot q}{t}q_\mu\bigg](m_{b_c}-m_{x_c^0})v_1(t ) - \frac{\varepsilon^\ast\cdot q}{t}q_\mu(2m_{x_c^0})v_0(t)\nonumber\\ & + & \bigg[(p_{b_c}+p_{x_c^0})_\mu-\frac{m^2_{b_c } -m^2_{x_c^0}}{t}q_\mu \bigg](\varepsilon^\ast\cdot q)\frac{v_2(t)}{m_b - m_{x_c^0}}\;,\end{aligned}\ ] ] respectively , where @xmath76 , @xmath77 , and @xmath78 with @xmath79 are the form factors .
in our numerical analysis , we use the wolfenstein parameterization for the ckm matrix elements in eq .
( [ amp1 ] ) , given by @xmath80 , @xmath81 , and @xmath82 , with @xcite @xmath83 the parameters @xmath71 , decay constants and form factors , adopted from refs .
@xcite , @xcite , and @xcite are as follows : @xmath84 where the form factors correspond to the reduced matrix elements derived from eqs .
( [ amp1 ] ) and ( [ ff1 ] ) , given by @xmath85 the momentum dependence for @xmath86 from ref .
@xcite is taken as @xmath87 with @xmath88 , @xmath89 and @xmath90 gev for @xmath91 , @xmath92 and @xmath93 , respectively . with @xmath94 from eq .
( [ data1 ] ) , we obtain @xmath5 mev , which is lower than @xmath95 mev @xcite from perturbative and light - front qcd models , respectively .
the momentum dependences for the @xmath44 transition form factors are given by @xcite @xmath96 where the values of @xmath97 and @xmath98 in table [ ff0 ] are from refs .
@xcite and @xcite , respectively .
.the @xmath99 form factors at @xmath100 and @xmath98 for the momentum dependences in eq .
( [ f_mc ] ) . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] for the @xmath101 decays , the results are given in table [ tab1 ] .
while @xmath5 mev leads to @xmath102 in accordance with the data , we predict that @xmath6 , @xmath7 , and @xmath8 , which are accessible to the experiments at the lhcb . besides , our results of @xmath103 and @xmath104 in table [ tab1 ] are also supported by the @xmath105 and isospin symmetries , respectively . with the form factors adopted from ref .
@xcite , we calculate that @xmath106 and @xmath107 , which are 2 - 3 times smaller than the results from the same reference .
the differences are again reconciled after keeping the next - leading order contributions in the @xmath108 expansion . for the semileptonic @xmath109 decays
, @xmath110 is due to the both negligible electron and muon masses , of which the numerical value is close to those from refs .
note that by taking @xmath111 as the theoretical input in eq .
( [ data2 ] ) , we derive that @xmath112 which agrees with the above theoretical prediction . for the @xmath113 mode , which suppresses the phase space due to the heavy @xmath114
, we obtain @xmath115 .
the ratio of @xmath116 is close to that in ref .
@xcite , but @xmath117 is apparently 4 - 5 times smaller than that in ref .
@xcite , though with uncertainties the two results overlap with each other . with the spectra of @xmath118 in fig .
[ spec ] , our results can be compared to the recent studies on the semileptonic @xmath31 cases in refs .
@xcite for the @xmath22 states . and ( b ) @xmath119 decays , where the solid and dotted lines correspond to @xmath120 and @xmath121 , respectively.,title="fig:",width=288 ] and ( b ) @xmath119 decays , where the solid and dotted lines correspond to @xmath120 and @xmath121 , respectively.,title="fig:",width=288 ]
in sum , we have studied the @xmath0 and @xmath1 decays with @xmath122 and @xmath3 .
we have presented that @xmath123 and @xmath124 , and @xmath9 and @xmath10 . with @xmath125 as the theoretical input , the extractions from the data have shown that @xmath13 and @xmath126 .
we have estimated @xmath127 with @xmath68 to be @xmath12 , @xmath12 , and @xmath128 , respectively .
the work was supported in part by national center for theoretical sciences , national science council ( nsc-101 - 2112-m-007 - 006-my3 ) , and most ( most-104 - 2112-m-007 - 003-my3 ) .
99 for a review on the tetraquark states , see h.x .
chen , w. chen , x. liu and s.l .
zhu , phys .
rept . * 639 * , 1 ( 2016 ) .
olive _ et al . _
[ particle data group collaboration ] , chin .
c * 38 * , 090001 ( 2014 ) . | we study two - body @xmath0 and semileptonic @xmath1 decays with @xmath2 , where @xmath3 is regarded as the tetraquark state of @xmath4 . with the decay constant @xmath5 mev determined from the data
, we predict that @xmath6 , @xmath7 , and @xmath8 . with the form factors in qcd models ,
we calculate that @xmath9 and @xmath10 , and @xmath11 and @xmath12 , respectively , and extract the ratio of the fragmentation fractions to be @xmath13 . |
since the first demonstration of a laser - cooled atomic beam by phillips and metcalf @xcite the development and improvement of cold atom sources has evolved into an essential activity in atomic physics laboratories . in particular sources for cold rb , k and cs received a lot of attention and became compact and familiar standard devices @xcite .
however , for most other atomic and all molecular species the situation is less favorable and considerable time as well as resources remain necessary for the development of a source . aside from optical cooling schemes many other cooling principles
have been explored , we mention cryogenic cooling by surfaces @xcite or buffer gas @xcite , filtering by magnetic @xcite or electric funnels @xcite and stark deceleration of molecules @xcite as well as rydberg atoms @xcite . in spite of the success of these sources in specific cases ,
optical cooling is the preferred option whenever an appropriate optical transition is available .
the highest optically cooled atom fluxes to date have been produced from zeeman - slowed atomic beams @xcite .
zeeman slowers have the additional advantage of a wide applicability .
unfortunately , their use adds a substantial engineering effort to system design and construction , in particular if beam - brightening and recycling principles are involved @xcite .
the magnetic field inside the zeeman slower must be very smooth and satisfy a particular profile in order to optimize the slowing .
in addition , as the acceptance angle is small , the source oven has to be positioned on the beam axis and operated under high flux conditions . in typical applications
this gives rise to a high background of hot atoms and results in maintenance because the oven has to be reloaded regularly .
an important simplification of cold atom sources was realized when monroe _ _ et .
_ @xcite demonstrated that in a room - temperature vapor a fraction of the atoms can be optically captured and cooled into a magneto - optical trap ( mot ) and subsequently loaded into a magnetic trap .
the primary drawback of this vapor - cell mot ( vcmot ) is that the lifetime of the magnetically trapped atoms is limited by collisions with hot atoms from the vapor , thus limiting the time available for experiment .
one approach to overcome this limitation is pulsed loading , starting from an alkali getter dispenser @xcite or by ultraviolet light induced desorption @xcite .
all other solutions involve a dual chamber arrangement in which a source chamber , containing some variation of the vcmot source , is separated by a differential pumping channel from an ultra - high - vacuum ( uhv ) chamber in which the atoms are recaptured in a secondary mot in preparation for experiments under uhv conditions .
three basic types of vcmot sources are used in the dual mot configurations . in the first type a pulsed vcmot serves to load the recapture mot by a sequence of cold atom bunches , transferred with the aid of a push beam @xcite .
the second type is known as the lvis ( low - velocity intense source ) @xcite . in this case
the vcmot and the push beam are operated continuously , giving rise to a steady beam of cold atoms in the direction of the push beam . in the third type the standard three - dimensional ( 3d ) mot arrangement in the source chamber
is replaced by a two - dimensional ( 2d ) mot configuration , with ( 2d@xmath13-mot ) or without ( 2d mot ) push and cooling beams along the symmetry axis @xcite . this has the important advantage that the source mot can be optimized for capture because , with confinement in only two directions , the residence time and collisional losses are intrinsically low .
vcmot sources work most conveniently for elements like cs , rb , and k , having a vapor pressure of @xmath14 mbar around room temperature @xcite .
elements such as li , yb , cr and the alkaline earths must be loaded from atomic beams since their vapor pressures are only significant at temperatures far above the maximum baking temperature of a conventional uhv system @xcite . in the case of elements which are chemically reactive with glass , such as li , a vapor cell is additionally impractical . in this paper
we present a novel 2d mot source for cold lithium .
it yields a cold flux comparable to the maximum achieved with lithium zeeman slowers @xcite .
contrary to previously realized 2d mot systems our source is transversely loaded with a beam from an effusive oven , rather than longitudinally like in beam brighteners or isotropically like in vapor cells .
this demonstrates the possibility to use 2d mot sources in applications where a vapor cell can not be used and avoids the background of hot atoms in the beam .
an important _ a priory _ uncertainty of this arrangement is the risk of depletion of the low - velocity tail of capturable atoms by the onset of nozzling as occurred in the famous zacharias fountain experiment @xcite .
our work shows that large cold atomic fluxes can be realized without this depletion becoming inhibitive .
recently this was also demonstrated with a li oven loaded 3d mot @xcite .
another novelty of our source is the application of the 2d mot concept to a light atom like lithium .
magneto - optical trapping of light species requires a high gradient for efficient capture . as this also compresses the cold atoms into a cloud of small volume ,
in particular in the 3d configuration trap losses are substantial even for small atom numbers .
we demonstrate that in our dual mot arrangement , the 2d mot can be optimized for capture with a large gradient and without considerable losses , whereas the 3d recapture mot can be optimized with a different gradient for maximum total atom number . in the following sections we describe our experimental apparatus ( section [ section : experimental ] ) and our results ( section [ section : experimentalresults ] ) . in section
[ section : sourcemodel ] we present a simple model for the loading of the 2d mot .
the performance of our system and loss mechanisms are discussed in section [ section : discussion ] and in section [ section : conclusion ] we summarize our findings and comment on the suitability of our approach for other atomic species .
the experimental setup of the lithium 2d mot source is sketched in fig.[fig : vacuum ] .
the vacuum system consists of a stainless steel six - way cross of @xmath15 tubing of which two cf40 ports define the horizontal symmetry axis of the source .
the other four cf40 ports are configured under @xmath16 and sealed with standard vacuum windows providing the optical access for the retroreflected 2d mot beams with a waist ( @xmath17 radius ) @xmath18 .
a lithium oven is mounted with a cf16 flange onto the bottom of a water - cooled tube with inner radius @xmath19 and connected along the vertical axis into the center of the cross .
the source is connected horizontally onto the main uhv chamber , separated by a gate valve . between the main vacuum and the source
a @xmath20 long differential pumping ( dp ) channel of @xmath21 diameter can maintain a maximum pressure ratio of @xmath22 between the main uhv chamber and the source .
there is no direct line of sight from the oven to the main uhv chamber nor to the windows .
when the oven is operated and the 2d mot lasers are off , no lithium was detected in the main uhv chamber . also no measurable gas load is observed on the main vacuum while the source is operated .
[ ptb ] libeamsource.eps the oven consists of a stainless steel lithium reservoir , @xmath23 high and @xmath24 in diameter , attached to a cf16 flange by a @xmath25 long tube of @xmath26 inner diameter .
the oven is embedded in a simple heat shield of glass wool and aluminium foil and is connected to the vacuum system using a nickel gasket .
the reservoir was loaded with @xmath27 g of @xmath28li and @xmath29 g of @xmath30li under an inert gas ( argon ) atmosphere . as commercial lithium contains a large fraction of lih it has to be degassed by dissociating the hydride . for this purpose
we baked the oven under vacuum in a separate setup for two hours at a temperature of @xmath31 .
some @xmath32 of the lithium was lost in this process . to protect the employed turbopump from alkali contamination
a liquid nitrogen cold trap was used in this procedure . under typical conditions
the oven is operated at @xmath33 ( @xmath34 c ) , well above the melting point of lithium at @xmath35 .
all data presented in this paper , except those presented in fig.[fig : loadingvstemp ] , were obtained at this temperature .
the oven temperature is calibrated by doppler thermometry of the emerging li flux using a probe beam under @xmath36 with the vertical axis ( see fig.[fig : vacuum ] ) .
temperature stabilization is done with a thermocouple reference .
starting from room temperature the oven reaches the regulated value of @xmath37 in @xmath38 minutes .
the @xmath28li abundance was measured to be @xmath39 using absorption spectroscopy on the @xmath28li @xmath40 @xmath41 line and the @xmath30li @xmath42 @xmath43 line . as sketched in fig.[fig : vacuum ] the 2d mot consists of a 2d quadrupole magnetic field in combination with two orthogonal pairs of retroreflected laser beams of opposite circular polarization , at a power of up to @xmath44 mw per beam in a waist of @xmath45 and red - detuned with respect to the optical resonance near @xmath46 . like in a standard 3d mot @xcite , a cold atom moving in the crossed laser field is optically pumped to a state for which the zeeman shift places it closer to resonance with a laser opposing the motion of the atom .
thus the atoms are trapped and cooled in the radial direction and collect along the symmetry axis of the 2d quadrupole field but are free to move in the axial direction . as a result only atoms with a sufficiently low axial velocity can be radially trapped ; atoms with a residence time of less then @xmath47 ms in the optical trapping region leave the 2d mot before they are significantly cooled .
only the radially cooled atoms give rise to a sufficiently collimated beam to pass through the dp - channel and be recaptured by a 3d mot in the middle of the uhv chamber . for best performance
the atoms are accelerated out of the source by a push beam , aligned along the symmetry axis and with a waist of @xmath48 mm passing through the dp - channel .
the detuning and intensity of the push laser determine the velocity of the atoms emerging from the source .
this velocity is chosen below the capture limit of the recapture mot but is sufficiently fast to assure that the atoms do not fall below the recapture region as a result of gravity .
for this reason the push beam is essential for horizontal configurations but optional in vertical arrangements . in all arrangements
the push beam acceleration increases the output flux because it reduces the residence time in the 2d mot and therefore background - induced losses . in the literature on the 2d@xmath13 mot @xcite and the lvis @xcite control over the axial velocity
is reported by using a pair of counter - propagating axial cooling beams over the entire trap but this method is not employed here .
the magnetic quadrupole field is provided by two sets of nd@xmath49fe@xmath50b magnets ( eclipse magnets n750-rb ) with a measured magnetization of @xmath51 .
each set consists of two stacks of three @xmath52 magnet bars separated by @xmath53 to make an effective dipole bar of @xmath54 total length .
the optimum position of the centers of the dipole bars was experimentally found to be @xmath55 from the symmetry axis in the horizontal plane as sketched in fig.[fig : vacuum ] . for this distance
we calculate a field gradient of @xmath56 , constant within @xmath57 along the 2d mot symmetry axis over a total length of @xmath58 .
the use of permanent magnets simplifies the application of the high field gradients needed for light species .
it combines a simple construction with convenient alignment and occupies much less space than the more traditional racetrack coils .
the quadrupole field falls off over short distances along the symmetry axis . at the position of the recapture mot ,
@xmath59 cm downstream from the center of the 2d mot , only a small gradient of @xmath60 remains .
[ ptb ] li6levels.eps laser cooling of @xmath61 differs from the familiar case of _ _
@xmath62rb , in which a spectrally - well - resolved cycling transition on the @xmath42 line can be strongly driven to cool and trap the atoms while a weak repumping beam is sufficient to compensate for parasitic leakage to the dark state manifold . in the case of @xmath0 the hyperfine splitting of the @xmath63 excited state is of the order of the natural linewidth , @xmath64 and all @xmath42 transitions from the @xmath65 manifold , @xmath66 are excited simultaneously ( see fig.[fig : lilevels ] ) @xcite .
hence , there is no closed transition suitable for cooling and trapping and strong optical pumping to the @xmath67 level can not be avoided . as a consequence the ` trapping ' and ` repumping ' beams have to be of comparable intensities , which means that both beams contribute to the cooling and mutually serve for repumping .
also the detunings will have a strong influence in this respect @xcite . in spite of these differences
we stick to the conventional terminology , referring to the transition @xmath68 as the ` trapping ' transition and to @xmath69 as the ` repumping ' transition . a laser system for wavelength @xmath70 was developed to serve the 2d ( source ) mot and the 3d ( recapture ) mot as well as to provide laser beams for @xmath28li diagnostics .
the laser system consists of a single master oscillator and four injection - locked slave lasers , all operating a @xmath71 mitshubishi ml101j27 diode heated to @xmath72 .
the master oscillator is a home - built external - cavity diode laser ( ecdl ) @xcite , frequency stabilized using saturated absorption spectroscopy in a @xmath28li heat pipe @xcite .
the power from the master laser is distributed over six beams , which can be independently shifted in frequency using isomet 1205-c acousto - optic modulators ( aom s ) .
of these six beams four are amplified by injection - locking of the slave lasers and of these four beams one pair is used for the retroreflected trapping and repumping beams of the 2d mot while the other pair is equally distributed over six beams and similarly employed for the 3d mot .
the remaining two frequency - shifted ecdl beams serve as pushing beam , as probing beam or as plug beam in various diagnostic applications .
to establish the principle of our source and to enable comparison with experiment we present a semi - empirical kinetic model in which the oven is replaced by an emittance of area @xmath73 at the saturated vapor pressure of lithium . around @xmath74 the saturated vapor pressure is given by @xmath75 where @xmath76 pa and @xmath77 is the latent heat of vaporization @xcite .
as @xmath78 is only accurate to within @xmath79 we neglect the small dependence on the isotopic composition .
the total atomic flux @xmath80 emitted by the oven may be estimated by the detailed balance expression for the total flux onto and from the emittance under thermal equilibrium conditions , @xmath81 where @xmath82 is the atomic density and @xmath83 ^{1/2}$ ] the mean thermal speed , with @xmath84 the boltzmann constant and @xmath85 the mass of the li atoms .
for @xmath86 we have @xmath87 pa , corresponding to a density @xmath88 @xmath89 . with these numbers the total flux from the source
is found to be @xmath90 . with @xmath91 gram of li
this corresponds to @xmath92 hours running time .
the flux of @xmath28li atoms captured by a 2d mot at a distance of @xmath93 above the oven can be written as an integral over the velocity distribution@xmath94 where @xmath39 is the @xmath28li abundance , @xmath95 the solid angle of capture ( with @xmath96 the capture surface ) , @xmath97 with @xmath98 the emission angle with respect to the oven axis , @xmath99 the capture velocity , @xmath100 ^{1/2}=1.31\times10^{3}~$ ] the most - probable atomic speed in the oven and @xmath101 the normalization factor of the speed distribution . note that by integrating eq.([exp : flux - a ] ) over a hemisphere we regain eq.([exp : flux - b ] ) in the limit @xmath102 . because the solid angle of capture is small we have @xmath103 and the flux @xmath104 emitted by the oven within the solid angle of capture is given by @xmath105 for @xmath86 we calculate a total flux density of @xmath106 s@xmath107@xmath108 at @xmath93 above the oven . presuming the capture speed to be small , @xmath109 , the captured flux @xmath110
may be approximated by @xmath111 this expression represents the theoretical maximum flux that can be extracted from the 2d mot source . to discuss the capture and cooling behavior in the 2d mot we distinguish two coaxial spatial regions , crossing - over at @xmath112 defined by @xmath113 , _
i.e. _ the surface where the zeeman shift in the radial gradient of the quadrupole field , @xmath114 , is compensated by the detuning of the laser , @xmath115 , _
i.e. _ , to the red side of the cooling transition at angular frequency @xmath116 in zero field . in the outer region @xmath117 ,
the 2d mot functions much like a zeeman slower , while in the inner region @xmath118 the motion of the atoms can be described by a damped harmonic oscillator model @xcite . first we discuss the outer region .
an atom with velocity @xmath119 at distance @xmath120 from the symmetry axis will be at resonance with the cooling laser if the difference of the zeeman shift and the laser detuning equals the doppler shift,@xmath121 here @xmath122 is the wavevector of the cooling laser . in view of the angle of @xmath123 between the directions of the hot lithium beam and
the opposing laser cooling beams the positive doppler shift is reduced by a factor @xmath124 with respect to the fully counter - propagating configuration .
accordingly , the maximum available slowing distance is larger , @xmath125 , where @xmath18 is the waist of the cooling beams . substituting @xmath126 in the expression for the zeeman shift we rewrite eq.([rescondition ] ) in the form of an expression for the highest atomic speed @xmath127 for which the resonance condition is satisfied@xmath128 .
\label{delta}\ ] ] note that with the left - circular @xmath129 and right - circular @xmath130 polarizations of the 2d mot beams as indicated in fig.[fig : vacuum ] the atoms are @xmath131 optically pumped into a fully stretched state with the magnetic field being orthogonal to the propagation direction of the hot flux . in the simplest 1d model for capture process ( in which only the trajectory along the symmetry axis of the oven is considered ) @xmath126 represents the capture radius @xmath132 and @xmath127 the capture velocity @xmath133 of the 2d mot provided the resonant photon scattering force @xmath134 is large enough to keep the atom in resonance with the cooling laser , @xmath135 .
the resulting condition@xmath136 is satisfied in our experiment . combining eqs.([delta ] ) and ( [ eq : vmax ] ) we obtain an equation quadratic in @xmath137 , which reduces for @xmath138 to@xmath139
this expression shows that the optimal gradient for capture scales like @xmath140 , which is important for comparing the performance of the source for different atomic species . substituting the optimal gradient into eq.([eq : vmax ] )
we obtain @xmath141 where @xmath142 is the maximum attainable deceleration by the scattering force . in spite of the insight it offers
the 1d model is far too simple to justify the use @xmath143 for reliable estimates of the captured flux .
therefore , we decided to estimate @xmath99 experimentally by measuring the loading rate of the 3d mot as a function of the mean velocity in the cold beam and eq.([delta ] ) is only used for scaling between the conditions of the 3d mot and the 2d mot .
this procedure is discussed in section [ section : discussion ] . in the inner region @xmath118 of the trap
the atomic motion is described by an overdamped harmonic oscillator model with a spring constant @xmath144 and damping coefficient @xmath145 @xcite .
the atoms approach the axis with the cooling time constant @xmath146 . for our 2d mot parameters
atoms entering the 2d mot with velocity @xmath148 only contribute to the cold lithium beam if @xmath149 is less than the residence time @xmath150 in the trapping beams @xmath151 . in the absence of collisions with background gas @xmath150
is determined by the velocity component @xmath152 of the trapable lithium atoms along the symmetry axis of the 2d mot and the entry point in the optical field . if even the atoms with the shortest residence time can still be cooled , _
i.e. _ for @xmath153 essentially all captured atoms contribute to the cold beam .
for @xmath154 we calculate with @xmath155that this condition is satisfied for @xmath156 , including the experimental value @xmath157 ( see section [ section : discussion ] ) .
to evaluate the merits of the 2d mot it is essential to have a reliable estimate of the input flux from the lithium oven . for this purpose
the oven flux was measured at @xmath158 by observing - in the absence of the nd@xmath49fe@xmath50b magnets - the doppler profile of the hot lithium beam using a horizontal probe beam with a waist of @xmath159 running parallel to the 2d mot axis and back - reflected by a gold - plated mirror ( spring - mounted at the entrance of the dp - channel ) as indicated in fig.[fig : vacuum ] . to avoid optical pumping to dark states
the probe intensity was kept at the low value of @xmath160 . with a thermal velocity of @xmath161
the interaction time is @xmath162 @xmath163s and the scattering rate is estimated to be @xmath164 photons per atom .
the effect of small fluctuations in the intensity of the probe laser was suppressed by measuring the intensity of the probe beam relative to that of a reference beam originating from the same laser diode .
both the probe beam and the reference beam were measured with texas instruments opt101 photodiodes .
[ ptb ] transverseprofiles.eps the observed doppler profile is shown in fig.[fig : transversedoppler ] .
the solid line represents a fit of the calculated doppler profile for the oven temperature @xmath158 and presuming the measured @xmath28li - abundance .
the solid line is the sum of six overlapping doppler broadened lines ( dotted lines ) .
the unusual lineshapes reflect the clipping profile of the oven tube .
the two large peaks at @xmath165 and @xmath166 correspond to the trapping and repumping transitions in @xmath28li , respectively .
analogously the other four peaks at @xmath167 and @xmath168 are for the @xmath169 and @xmath170 transitions of the @xmath40 line of @xmath30li @xcite .
the best fit is obtained for @xmath171s@xmath107 , where the error reflects our estimate of systematic uncertainties .
this result overlaps with the value @xmath172s@xmath107 calculated with eq.([eq : phis ] ) of the semi - empirical model starting from the oven temperature .
[ ptb ] tof.eps
we probe the intensity of the cold @xmath28li beam in the middle of the main vacuum chamber by measuring the fluorescence after flashing a sheet of resonant laser light ( knife - edge defined : @xmath173 thick and @xmath174 high ) propagating horizontally through the middle of the uhv chamber orthogonal to the beam axis at position @xmath175 downstream from the entry point of the dp - channel .
the fluorescence flash is imaged vertically as a stripe onto a ccd camera .
the length of the stripe provides information about the divergence of the beam . to remove stray - light fluctuations the integrated signal from the pixel area containing the stripe image
is divided by the background signal from a reference area . for the probe beam we use @xmath47 ms flashes of @xmath176 in a ratio of @xmath177 trap
/ repump light at zero detuning .
the beam is retroreflected to prevent the atoms from being pushed out of resonance .
velocity characterization of the cold @xmath28li beam is done with a time - of - flight ( tof ) method . for this purpose the beam is periodically interrupted at typically @xmath178 hz repetition rate with a resonant @xmath179 ` plug ' laser ( @xmath180 trap / repump light ) deflecting the atoms near the entrance of the dp - channel . from the decay of the fluorescence signal @xmath181 as a function time
( see fig.[fig : tof ] ) we obtain the apparent tof - distribution , which is proportional to @xmath182 and can be transformed into the axial velocity distribution using the flight distance of @xmath183 . in a typical measurement we average over @xmath184 cycles to reach a proper signal / noise ratio also for small fluxes traversing the light sheet at high velocity .
the procedure is illustrated in fig.[fig : tof ] for a push - beam intensity of @xmath185 and a detuning @xmath186 .
note that the derivative of @xmath181 can be nicely described by the gaussian function @xmath187,\ ] ] where @xmath188 is the mean apparent arrival time and @xmath189 is the full width at half maximum ( fwhm ) .
the absence of arrival times shorter than @xmath190 reflects the absence of atoms with velocities @xmath191 .
this absence of ` hot ' flux was verified up to @xmath192 @xmath193 and was anticipated because the cold beam is pushed horizontally out of the 2d mot , _
i.e. _ orthogonally to the hot flux from the oven .
the observed relative spread @xmath194 is insensitive to the push - beam intensity and comparable to the instrumental resolution for the shortest flight times investigated ( @xmath195 . the value of @xmath196 is entirely determined by the properties of the push beam and insensitive to other 2d mot parameters .
this behavior was previously also observed in other 2d mot systems @xcite . since optical pumping to different hyperfine states takes only a few optical cycles in @xmath28li and @xmath197 corresponds to @xmath198 photon recoils
, the atoms must have been accelerated to their final velocity still within reach of the repump light , _ _ i.e . _ _ inside 2d mot ( the push beam does not contain repumper light ) .
this limits the acceleration to a well - defined duration of time , which is consistent with the observed relatively narrow velocity distribution .
the absence of slow atoms is not caused by gravity because for the lowest velocities measured @xmath199 the gravitational drop is only @xmath200 , less than half the height @xmath201 of the light sheet .
to relate the fluorescence signal @xmath181 to the velocity distribution in the atomic beam we have to account for the detection efficiency , which is inversely proportional to the velocity of the atoms and depends on the divergence of the beam . for this purpose
we approximate the beam spot at the position of the light sheet @xmath202 by a gaussian profile with @xmath203-radius @xmath204 .
the fraction @xmath205 of the beam giving rise to fluorescence is obtained by integrating the normalized gaussian beam profile in horizontal and vertical direction over the surface area of the light sheet,@xmath206 where @xmath207 is the radius of the optical field of view .
here we neglected some clipping by the dp - channel .
note that the divergence angle @xmath208 of the cold beam equals the ratio of transverse to axial velocity of the atoms , @xmath209 .
the length of the fluorescence stripe was found to vary only slightly with the intensity of the push beam .
this sets a lower bound on the beam divergence , @xmath210 for @xmath211 and on the characteristic transverse velocity , @xmath212 .
since @xmath213 for all velocities studied eq.([eq : integral-1 ] ) can be written in the form@xmath214 where @xmath215 is the view angle and @xmath216 the vertical acceptance angle .
[ ptb ] flux-and-velocity.eps the fluorescence decay signal @xmath181 can be expressed in the form@xmath217 where @xmath218 is the normalized axial velocity distribution with @xmath219 representing the most - probable velocity in the beam , and @xmath220 the velocity of the fastest atoms still arriving at the detector after delay time @xmath149 .
hence , the transformation between the beam property @xmath218 and the observed fluorescence decay is given by@xmath221 here @xmath222 represents the distribution of flight times in the beam .
for @xmath223 the prefactor @xmath224 causes the distribution @xmath182 to shift to larger delay times but its shape remains well - described by a gaussian . in our case
the shift is @xmath79 @xmath225 as indicated by the dotted line in fig.[fig : tof ] .
hence , the most - probable velocity in the beam is given by @xmath226 .
for the example of fig.[fig : tof ] we calculate @xmath11 with a fwhm of @xmath227 .
we have observed a ten - fold increase in @xmath222 at constant average flux by pulsing the push beam ( see inset in fig.[fig : tof ] ) .
this indicates that the 2d mot is not limited by its density when the push beam is continuously on .
the most - probable velocity @xmath219 was found to be the same for pulsed and continuous operation .
the experimental results for @xmath219 as a function of the push beam intensity are shown as the open circles in fig.[fig : velvspush ] .
varying the push - beam intensity @xmath228 over the range @xmath229 we found @xmath219 to increase from @xmath230 .
the flux of the cold atomic beam is investigated as a function of the push - beam intensity @xmath231 by recapture into the 3d mot .
the results are shown as the solid squares in fig.[fig : velvspush ] .
first of all we note that in the absence of the push beam the flux arriving at the recapture mot is very small . under these conditions
the 2d mot performance is very sensitive to the alignment of the quadrupole field , the mot beams and the repumper .
this low flux is attributed to the horizontal orientation of the beam axis , orthogonal to the direction of the hot flux from the oven . in view of this symmetry
the trapped atoms have an axial velocity distribution centered around zero . only the atoms with axial velocity @xmath232
will reach the capture volume of the 3d mot .
slower atoms drop below the trapping region as a result of gravity .
high - field - seeking atoms will be deflected away from the recapture mot by the quadrupole field outside the 2d mot for axial velocities @xmath233 .
atoms with axial velocity @xmath234 are absent due to clipping by the oven tube ( @xmath99 is the capture velocity of the 2d mot ) . as an aside we point out that by inclining the axis of the oven tube toward the beam axis direction it should be possible to realize a high flux cold beam with an axial velocity proportional to the inclination angle and without any ( near)resonant light co - propagating with the atomic beam into the uhv chamber . in a more practical solution
this may be realized by not retroreflecting the 2d - mot beams but tilting them so that the average @xmath235-vector points along the cold beam axis .
[ ptb ] 2dtraprep.eps measuring the loading rate @xmath236 in the 3d mot we obtain the ` useful ' flux of the cold @xmath28li beam .
the rate is obtained from the leading slope of the loading curve , observing the 3d mot fluorescence as a function of time using a ccd camera .
this fluorescence is calibrated against an absorption image taken immediately after switching - off the 3d mot .
the measured rate @xmath236 represents a lower limit for the flux emerging from the 2d mot .
fig.[fig : velvspush ] shows that @xmath236 increases steeply until it reaches a maximum at @xmath237mw@xmath108 .
further increase of the push - beam intensity causes the loading rate to decrease .
this is attributed to the finite capture velocity of the 3d mot ( see section [ section : discussion ] ) . for the data shown in fig.[fig : velvspush ] we used for the 3d mot a magnetic field gradient of @xmath238 , @xmath239 trapping light per beam at a detuning of @xmath240 @xmath241 and @xmath242 repumping light per beam at a detuning of @xmath243 @xmath241 .
both colors are distributed over six beams clipped at their beam waist of @xmath45 , thus defining the acceptance radius @xmath244 of the 3d mot .
[ c]ccccparameter & trap & repump & push + detuning @xmath245 & -7.5 @xmath241 & -1 @xmath241 & -3.5 @xmath241 + power per beam & 50 mw & 48 mw & 0.8 mw + waist ( @xmath17 radius ) & 9 & 9 & 1.2 + gradient & 50 g / cm & & + oven temperature & 623 k & & + most - probable velocity & 36 m / s & & + fwhm of velocity distribution & 11 m / s & & + [ ptb ] 2dpowers.eps we have optimized the total flux by varying both the trap and the repump detuning . for these measurements
the laser power of the trap and repump lasers were set to their maximum values of @xmath246 and @xmath247 , respectively .
the results are shown as a contour diagram in fig.[fig:2dtraprep ] .
the maximum flux is observed when the trap laser is far detuned ( @xmath248 ) and the repump laser is close to resonance ( @xmath249 ) .
we observe a small local maximum in flux if the trap laser is tuned close to resonance ( @xmath250 ) .
we attribute this to better beam collimation because the 2d mot is expected to be transversely colder when operated close to resonance @xcite . apparently the advantage of better collimation can not compensate loss in 2d mot capture efficiency . with optimized detunings we measured @xmath236 as a function of the available optical power in the 2d mot trap @xmath251 and repump @xmath252 beams .
for this purpose either the trapping power is kept constant at @xmath253 per beam and @xmath254 is varied or the repumping power is kept constant at @xmath255 per beam and @xmath256 is varied . as is shown in fig . [ fig:2dpowers ]
the loading rate increases linearly with @xmath256 for @xmath257 , whereas @xmath236 increases linearly with @xmath254 for @xmath258 until it levels off for @xmath259 .
the experimental parameters for optimal source performance are collected in table [ table-1 ] .
the output flux was reproducible to within @xmath260 depending on the 2d mot alignment .
fig.[fig : loadingvstemp ] shows the loading rate as a function of the oven temperature . at low temperatures the loading rate increases exponentially with the oven temperature
this reflects the exponential increase of the effusive flux from the oven . above @xmath261 a loss mechanism sets in .
this limits further increase of the flux until at @xmath262 the cold atomic flux reaches its maximum value , corresponding to a loading rate of @xmath263s@xmath107 into the 3d mot .
the error reflects our best estimate of systematic uncertainties .
as will be will be discussed in section [ section : discussion ] the losses are attributed to knock - out collisions in the effusive beam emerging from the oven . the dotted line shows the fraction of atoms surviving the loss mechanism . [ ptb ] loadingvstemp.eps
to analyze the performance of the 2d mot source we define the overall efficiency parameter @xmath264 as the ratio of the 3d mot loading rate @xmath236 and the maximum capturable flux @xmath110 from the oven,@xmath265 this efficiency is determined by the capture efficiencies of the 2d and 3d mot as well as the transfer efficiency @xmath266 related to the divergence of the atomic beam . to determine @xmath266 as well as the capture velocity @xmath99 we replotted the data of fig.[fig : velvspush ] in the form of fig.[figrate - vs - peakvelocity ] , showing the capture rate @xmath236 in the 3d mot as a function of the most - probable axial velocity @xmath219 in the cold atomic beam .
like in subsection [ subsection : fluorescence ] we approximate the atomic beam profile at the position of the 3d mot @xmath267 by the gaussian profile with @xmath203-radius @xmath204 . the transfer efficiency is obtained by integrating the normalized profile from @xmath268 on the beam axis to the acceptance radius @xmath269 of the 3d mot,@xmath270 here @xmath271 , @xmath272 and @xmath273 .
the factor @xmath274 represents the conical approximation to the trapezoidal clipping profile imposed by the dp - channel , where @xmath275 marks the edge of the dark shadow . defining the 3d mot acceptance angle @xmath276 and velocity ratio @xmath277 we write compactly @xmath278 .
similarly we define the clipping angle @xmath279 and write @xmath280 . substituting the expressions for @xmath281 and @xmath282 into eq.([eq : transferefficiency ] ) and evaluating the integral we obtain for the transfer efficiency@xmath283 the velocity - averaged transfer efficiency ( recaptured fraction ) into the 3d mot is given by@xmath284 where @xmath218 is the normalized axial velocity distribution defined by eq.([eq : flux ] ) . the solid line in fig.[figrate - vs - peakvelocity ] is a plot of @xmath285 for fixed value of @xmath99 .
the position of the maximum is insensitive for the beam divergence and the best fit is obtained for a capture velocity of @xmath286 .
in contrast the peak height @xmath287 depends strongly on the beam divergence . using the lower limit for the characteristic transverse velocity @xmath288 we calculate an upper limit for the recaptured fraction @xmath289 . for comparison also
the result for zero beam divergence is shown in the plot ( dotted line ) .
[ ptb ] rateversuspeakavelocity.eps for the conditions used in experiment , @xmath290 and @xmath291 , we calculate with eq.([delta ] ) @xmath292 for @xmath293 .
apparently the simple 1d model overestimates the capture velocity by some @xmath294 .
because both the 2d mot and the 3d mot are configured in the @xmath123 configuration with respect to the input beam and also @xmath295 in both cases we presume a similar overestimate for the capture velocity of the 2d mot .
in the latter case we have @xmath296 and @xmath297 and calculate with eq.([delta ] ) @xmath298 .
presuming somewhat arbitrarily that also this value overestimates the actual capture velocity by @xmath294 we obtain @xmath299 as a reasonable estimate .
starting from @xmath300@xmath107 we obtain with eq.([eq : phimax ] ) for the theoretical maximum flux @xmath301@xmath107 . with the measured value @xmath302@xmath107 the overall efficiency @xmath303
is estimated to be @xmath304 .
this set a lower limit on the recaptured fraction , @xmath305 , and ( using our model ) also an upper limit for the characteristic transverse velocity , @xmath306 as the upper and lower limits more or less coincide our best estimate is @xmath307 , which corresponds to a transverse 2d mot temperature of @xmath308 .
the corresponding beam divergence at optimal recapture for oven temperature @xmath86 is @xmath309 . for these conditions
the brightness of the beam emerging from the 2d mot is calculated to be @xmath310@xmath107@xmath107 . because @xmath311 the output from the oven is well characterized by a small cold flux of capturable atoms overtaken by the hot flux of the full emittance .
once the hot flux exceeds a critical value we expect the cold flux to be attenuated by ` knock - out ' collisions .
this depletion of the low velocity class of atoms is a well - known phenomenon in close - to - effusive beam sources @xcite . comparing the total flux per unit area just above the emitting surface , @xmath312@xmath107@xmath313 , with the flux per unit area in the capture region @xmath314@xmath107@xmath313
, we expect these knock - out collisions to occur primarily in the first few centimeters of the expanding beam . once the atoms enter the 2d mot the cross section increases because optically excited atoms interact resonantly with the hot background flux @xcite
. to model the attenuation we calculate the collision rate of an atom moving at velocity @xmath99 along the symmetry axis at position @xmath315 above the oven exit orifice with atoms from the hot background flux moving at typically the average velocity @xmath316,@xmath317 here @xmath98 is the emission angle of the fast moving atoms with respect to the symmetry axis , @xmath318 , @xmath319 is the knock - out cross section and @xmath320 is the relative velocity of the colliding atoms @xcite . using the substitution @xmath321 we can solve the differential equation under the boundary condition @xmath322 at @xmath323 and obtain @xmath324 , \label{eq : attenuatedflux}\ ] ] where @xmath325 . in this model
the density in the oven is taken to be uniform . because for @xmath326 the collision probability vanishes we may freely extend the integral to infinity , @xmath327 .
hence , at the entrance of the 2d mot the attenuated flux is given by@xmath328 where @xmath329 is the characteristic duration of the attenuation process .
to estimate @xmath319 we take the approach of ref .
@xcite and consider a slow atom moving at the capture velocity @xmath99 along the symmetry - axis from the oven towards the capture region . fast
atoms flying - by with the thermal velocity @xmath330 will give rise to momentum transfer as a result of van der waals interaction . as this happens most frequently close to the oven even a small momentum transfer @xmath331 suffices to kick the atoms out of the capture cone @xmath332 . because @xmath333 the trajectory of the fast atom is hardly affected and the momentum transfer to the cold atom can be calculated by integrating the transverse component of the van der waals force over time , @xmath334 . here
@xmath335 with @xmath120 the radial distance between the colliding atoms and @xmath336 the van der waals coefficient @xcite with @xmath337 the bohr radius and @xmath338 the hartree energy . changing from the time variable @xmath339 to the angular variable @xmath98 using @xmath340 , where @xmath341 is the distance of closest approach , we obtain using @xmath342 and @xmath343 , @xmath344 the critical distance of closest approach for which the atoms are just scattered outside the capture cone @xmath332 is given by @xmath345 note that this quantity depends only very weakly on the precise values of @xmath346and @xmath330 . for @xmath299 and temperatures in the range
@xmath347 we calculate for the knock - out cross section @xmath348 .
note that , in contrast to ` knock - out ' collisions , ` knock - in ' collisions are rare .
the steep dependence of @xmath349 on @xmath341 implies that most of the atoms scattered outside the acceptance cone scatter over much larger angles than the minimum angle required for knock - out .
thus scattered atoms typically hit the wall of the oven tube and stick , rather than giving rise to knock - in . along the same lines we estimate the momentum transfer by resonant collisions inside the 2d mot .
as the relative velocities are large and the typical collision time is much shorter than the lifetime of the atoms in the excited state we may use again the classical scattering model discussed above . in the present case
the critical distance of closest approach corresponds to momentum transfer just exceeding the escape value from the 2d mot , @xmath350 @xcite . neglecting the direction of the transition dipole
the resonant - dipole force can be approximated by @xmath351 , where the @xmath352 coefficient is defined as @xcite@xmath353 here @xmath354 is the elementary charge , @xmath355 the electric constant and @xmath356the transition dipole moment for the @xmath357 transition in li @xcite .
the corresponding critical distance of closest approach is in this case @xmath358 for @xmath299 and temperatures in the range @xmath359 we calculate for the resonant cross section @xmath360 .
accounting for the knock - out probability of trapped atoms the loading rate into the 3d mot can be written as @xmath361 .
\label{eq : lossesc3}\ ] ] combining eqs.([eq : phis ] ) and ( [ eq : phimax ] ) with the @xmath362 and @xmath352 loss exponents of eqs.([eq : lossesc6 ] ) and ( [ eq : lossesc3 ] ) and introducing the characteristic attenuation time @xmath363 we obtain the following expression for the 3d mot loading rate@xmath364 , \label{eq : coldfluxfnt}\ ] ] using @xmath365 we have @xmath366 . note that only @xmath367 , @xmath330 and @xmath82 are sensitive for the oven temperature .
a best fit of eq.([eq : coldfluxfnt ] ) to the data using @xmath368 and @xmath82 ( at @xmath74 ) as free parameters is shown as the solid line in fig.[fig : loadingvstemp ] .
the fit shown is obtained for @xmath369 and @xmath370 at @xmath74 , which are both within the error limits given for these quantities .
thus also the position of the maximum confirms our model . as the result obtained for @xmath368 strongly anti - correlates with the value presumed for @xmath99 we can not improve upon the estimate @xmath371 already given in subsection [ subsection : recapture ] .
interestingly , comparing the two loss mechanisms we find @xmath372 , which shows that the resonance mechanism , dominating the background losses in the vcmot @xcite , is of minor importance in the present case .
since the output flux scales like @xmath373 an obvious way to increase the output of mot sources is to increase the capture velocity . doubling the waist of the 2d mot beams in the @xmath374 plane ( see fig.1 ) in order to increase the capture radius we find with eq.([eq : vmax2 ] ) that the capture velocity increases by @xmath375 and the output by a factor @xmath192 .
in addition , since @xmath376 scales like @xmath377 the beam attenuation decreases slightly
. in several respects the 2d mot source demonstrated in this paper represents an interesting alternative for the zeeman slower .
first of all the source yields a large controllable output flux of up to @xmath378 , comparable to fluxes typically achieved in lithium zeeman slowers .
the transverse temperature of the source is low @xmath379 which makes it possible to recapture as much as @xmath260 in a 3d mot @xmath183 downstream from the source .
in contrast to zeeman slowers , the 2d mot source yields a clean and monochromatic cold atomic beam of which the most probable velocity can be varied over a wide range of velocities with the aid of a push beam .
permanent magnets for the creation of the quadrupole field add to the simplicity of the design .
the resulting source is more compact than a typical zeeman slower and is still capable of loading @xmath5 atoms in a 3d mot .
importantly , the 2d mot principle works equally well with light atoms as with more heavy atoms like k , rb and cs .
this shows that , like the zeeman slower , also the 2d mot beam source has a wide applicability . in cases with a sizable vapor pressure at room temperature
the source will act as a vcmot .
as an example of a system for which a 2d mot has not yet been realized we briefly discuss the case of na . in this case
the gradient of the quadrupole field should be scaled down proportional to @xmath380 in accordance with eq.([eq :- m1/2 ] ) to obtain the optimum value @xmath381 . in view of eq.([eq : vmax2 ] ) the capture velocity scales down with the same factor . using eq.([eq : coldfluxfnt ] ) we calculate for na a maximum total output flux of @xmath382 for an oven temperature @xmath383 .
this output is lower than realized with zeeman slowers but the oven is operated at much lower temperature @xcite . unlike the output of the zeeman
slower the output of the 2d mot source is limited by a fundamental loss mechanism . as described in subsection [ subsection : lossmechanisms ] this is caused by van der waals forces between atoms leaving the oven and ( to a lesser extent ) by resonant - dipole forces between optically excited atoms in the 2d mot and the hot background flux from the oven .
these losses are quantified by the exponent in eq.([eq : coldfluxfnt ] ) , which is shown as the dashed line in fig.8 .
note that near maximum output at @xmath4 the attenuation factor is already as small as @xmath384 .
therefore , the source is best operated at temperatures below @xmath385 , where the flux may be slightly smaller but the depletion time of the oven is comfortably long .
alternatively , one could incorporate a recycling principle @xcite .
we developed a novel beam source for cold @xmath0 atoms .
the source is based on the 2d mot principle and yields a controllable output flux of up to @xmath386 , comparable to fluxes typically achieved in lithium zeeman slowers .
some @xmath260 of the atoms are recaptured into a 3d mot @xmath183 downstream from the source .
the source is side - loaded from an oven and a push beam assures that only capturable atoms enter the main vacuum chamber .
this yields a clean and quite monochromatic cold atomic beam of which the most - probable axial velocity @xmath219 can be varied over the range @xmath387 by varying the intensity of the push beam .
the 2d mot can be fully optimized for capture because the push beam assures that the density of trapped atoms is intrinsically low .
the push beam also drastically simplifies the alignment of the 2d mot .
permanent magnets simplify the implementation of the quadrupole field .
the resulting source is compact and enables us to load up to @xmath5 atoms into a 3d mot , which is sufficient as a starting point for most experiments with quantum gases .
the output flux increases exponentially with the oven temperature until at @xmath388 a loss mechanism limits the flux .
we identify knock - out collisions near the oven exit as a result of van der waals forces between the atoms as the limiting mechanism . at maximum output
the beam attenuation factor is @xmath389 .
therefore , the source is more efficiently operated at a lower oven temperature . for @xmath390
we measured a loading rate of @xmath391 in the 3d mot . at this temperature
the uninterrupted running time on @xmath392 of lithium is @xmath92 . with our work
we demonstrate that the 2d mot principle works equally well with light atoms as with more heavy atoms and is likely to be suitable for any atomic system with an optical cooling transition .
the authors thank p. cleary and m. koot for assistance with the characterization of the nd@xmath49fe@xmath50b magnets , g.v .
shlyapnikov and t.w .
hijmans for stimulating discussions and n.j .
van druten for critically reading the manuscript .
this work is part of the research program on quantum gases of the stichting voor fundamenteel onderzoek der materie ( fom ) , which is financially supported by the nederlandse organisatie voor wetenschappelijk onderzoek ( nwo ) . | we demonstrate a novel 2d mot beam source for cold @xmath0 atoms . the source is side - loaded from an oven operated at temperatures in the range @xmath1 the performance
is analyzed by loading the atoms into a 3d mot located @xmath2 downstream from the source .
the maximum recapture rate of @xmath3 is obtained for @xmath4 and results in a total of up to @xmath5 trapped atoms .
the recaptured fraction is estimated to be @xmath6 and limited by beam divergence .
the most - probable velocity in the beam @xmath7 is varied from @xmath8 to @xmath9 byincreasing the intensity of a push beam .
the source is quite monochromatic with a full - width at half maximum velocity spread of @xmath10 at @xmath11 , demonstrating that side - loading completely eliminates beam contamination by hot vapor from the oven .
we identify depletion of the low - velocity tail of the oven flux as the limiting loss mechanism@xmath12 our approach is suitable for other atomic species . |
a good understanding of the antikaon spectral function in nuclear matter is required for the description of @xmath0-atoms @xcite and the subthreshold production of kaons in heavy ion reactions @xcite .
an exciting consequence of a significantly reduced effective @xmath0 mass could be that kaons condense in the interior of neutron stars @xcite . the ultimate goal is to relate the in - medium spectral function of kaons with the anticipated chiral symmetry restoration at high baryon density . to unravel quantitative constraints on the kaon spectral functions from subthreshold kaon production data of heavy - ion reactions requires transport model calculations which are performed extensively by various groups @xcite . the next generation of transport codes which are able to incorporate more consistently particles with finite width are being developed @xcite .
this is of considerable importance when dealing with antikaons which are poorly described by a quasi - particle ansatz @xcite .
there has been much theoretical effort to access the properties of kaons in nuclear matter @xcite .
an antikaon spectral function with support at energies smaller than the free - space kaon mass was already anticipated in the 70 s by the many k - matrix analyses of the antikaon - nucleon scattering process ( see e.g. @xcite ) which predicted considerable attraction in the subthreshold scattering amplitudes .
this leads in conjunction with the low - density theorem @xcite to an attractive antikaon spectral function in nuclear matter .
nevertheless , the quantitative evaluation of the antikaon spectral function is still an interesting problem .
the challenge is first to establish a solid understanding of the vacuum antikaon - nucleon scattering process , in particular reliable subthreshold antikaon - nucleon scattering amplitudes are required , and secondly , to evaluate the antikaon spectral function in a systematic many - body approach .
the antikaon - nucleon scattering is complicated due to the open inelastic @xmath1 and @xmath2 channels and the presence of the s - wave @xmath3 and p - wave @xmath4 resonances just below and the d - wave @xmath5 resonance not too far above the antikaon - nucleon threshold . in this
talk we review recent progress obtained within the newly formulated @xmath6-bs(3 ) approach , for chiral bethe - salpeter approach to the su(3 ) flavor group @xcite .
it constitutes a systematic and non - perturbative application of the chiral su(3 ) lagrangian to the meson - baryon scattering problem consistent with covariance , crossing symmetry , large-@xmath7 sum rules of qcd and the chiral counting concept .
the low - energy pion- , kaon- and antikaon - nucleon scattering data were reproduced successfully demonstrating that the chiral su(3)flavor symmetry is a powerful tool to analyze and predict hadron interactions systematically .
the amplitudes obtained in that scheme are particularly well suited for an application to the nuclear kaon dynamics , because it was demonstrated that they are approximately crossing symmetric in the sense that the @xmath8 and @xmath9 amplitudes smoothly match at subthreshold energies .
therefore we believe that those amplitudes , which are of central importance for the nuclear kaon dynamics , lead to reliable results for the propagation properties of kaons in dense nuclear matter @xcite .
as was pointed out in @xcite the realistic evaluation of the antikaon self energy in nuclear matter requires a self consistent scheme .
in particular the feedback effect of an in - medium modified antikaon spectral function on the antikaon - nucleon scattering process was found to be important for the @xmath3 resonance structure in nuclear matter . in this
talk we present a selection of results obtained in a novel covariant many - body framework @xcite .
self consistency was implemented in terms of the free - space meson - nucleon scattering amplitudes , where the amplitudes of the @xmath6-bs(3 ) approach were used . besides presenting realistic kaon and antikaon spectral functions we discuss the in - medium structure of the s - wave @xmath10 and p - wave @xmath11 resonances .
we briefly review the most striking phenomena arising when applying the chiral @xmath12 lagrangian to the kaon- and antikaon - nucleon interaction processes . at leading chiral order these interactions
are supposedly described by the weinberg - tomozawa term , @xmath13 where the parameter @xmath14 mev is known from the decay process of charged pions .
in contrast to the successful application of the chiral lagrangian in the flavor @xmath15 sector , its application to the strange sector of qcd is flawed by a number of subtleties if the rigorous machinery of chiral perturbation theory is applied .
the leading interaction term ( [ wt ] ) fails miserably in describing the s - wave scattering lengths of both kaons and antikaons off a nucleon .
most stunning is the failure of reproducing the repulsive @xmath16 scattering length @xcite .
the chiral lagrangian predicts an attractive scattering length at leading order instead .
this is closely linked to the presence of the @xmath3 resonance in the @xmath17 scattering amplitude just below the @xmath17 threshold .
considerable theoretical progress has been made over the last few years by incorporating the dynamics of that @xmath3 resonance into the chiral dynamics .
the key point is to change approximation strategy and expand the interaction kernel rather than the scattering amplitude directly . that amounts to solving some type of coupled - channel scattering equation like the lippmann - schwinger or the bethe - salpeter equation . as a consequence
the @xmath10 resonance is generated dynamically by coupled channel effects .
a realistic description of the antikaon - nucleon scattering process requires the inclusion of all su(3 ) channels @xmath18 and @xmath19 together with correction terms predicted by the chiral @xmath12 lagrangian .
the number of free parameters controlling the chiral correction terms can be significantly reduced by insisting on sum rule relations as they arise from qcd in the large-@xmath7 limit . for a detailed description of an up - to - date scheme with a more complete list of references
we refer to the recent work @xcite . in that work
it is shown that the chiral @xmath12 lagrangian does describe all low - energy pion- , kaon- and antikaon - nucleon scattering data fairly well , once chiral perturbation theory is applied to the covariant scattering kernel of the bethe - salpeter scattering equation . in this talk
we would like to discuss an aspect in more detail , which is particularly important when applying the chiral kaon- and antikaon - nucleon dynamics to kaon and antikaon propagation in dense nuclear matter .
crossing symmetry relates the @xmath9 and @xmath8 scattering amplitudes at subthreshold energies .
this manifests itself in the form of the dispersion - integral representation of the antikaon - nucleon scattering amplitude , @xmath20 , evaluated in forward direction , amplitudes .
the lines in the right hand side of the figures give the @xmath9 amplitudes.,width=302 ] @xmath21 where we performed one subtraction at @xmath22 to help the convergence of the dispersion integral .
for sake of clarity we consider here the isospin zero channel only .
the scattering amplitude @xmath23 shows unitarity cuts not only for @xmath24 , representing for instance the inelastic process @xmath25 , but also for @xmath26 reflecting the elastic @xmath8 scattering process .
a problem arises because the kaon- and antikaon - nucleon scattering processes are described by two distinct bethe - salpeter equations .
if the bethe - salpeter interaction kernel of the @xmath9 sector , that implies a particular scattering amplitude @xmath23 , is evaluated in perturbation theory , the amplitude @xmath23 does not describe properly the unitarity cuts of the @xmath27 channel , manifest at the subthreshold energy @xmath28 .
analogously , an evaluation of the kaon - nucleon scattering amplitudes in terms of a perturbative interaction kernel is not reliable far below threshold where the @xmath9 channel opens .
of course , crossing symmetry is reconciled once the interaction kernels of the @xmath8 and @xmath9 sectors include the appropriate infinite class of feynman diagrams .
it is important to face this problem since the in - medium antikaon spectral function tests the subthreshold @xmath9 amplitudes , @xmath29 where we recalled the low - density theorem written down for for the antikaon polarization function @xmath30 @xcite .
if an antikaon can propagate in dense nuclear matter with @xmath31 and say @xmath32 for simplicity , the evaluation of the antikaon polarization function @xmath33 at that energy requires the knowledge of the scattering amplitudes @xmath34 at a subthreshold energy @xmath35 .
this problem is solved in the chiral coupled channel framework by supplementing the bethe - salpeter equation with an appropriate renormalization program that leads to the matching of the subthreshold @xmath8 and @xmath9 amplitudes , @xmath36 close to the optimal matching point @xmath37 .
this is a crucial input of the @xmath6-bs(3 ) approach developed in @xcite . even though the renormalization of the chiral lagrangian in perturbation theory is straightforward , this it not anymore the case once the infinite diagram summation implied by the bethe - salpeter equation is performed .
an additional renormalization condition is needed . in @xcite
it was strongly argued that this condition is naturally provided by the crossing symmetry constraint . in fig .
[ fig : crossing ] we demonstrate that the hyperon pole - subtracted scattering amplitudes , @xmath38 and @xmath39 , comply with the crossing identities ( [ exp - cross ] ) close to @xmath40 approximatively .
we are therefore convinced that our subthreshold antikaon - nucleon scattering amplitudes are determined reliably and well suited for an application to the nuclear kaon dynamics . , @xmath25 , @xmath41 etc relevant for subthreshold production of antikaons in heavy - ion reactions .
the solid and dashed lines give the results of the @xmath6-bs(3 ) approach with and without p- and d - wave contributions respectively .
the dotted lines correspond to the parameterizations given in @xcite.,width=302 ] we close this section on the microscopic input by a presentation of total cross sections relevant for transport model calculation of heavy - ion reactions .
we believe that the @xmath6-bs(3 ) approach is particularly well suited to determine some cross sections not directly accessible in scattering experiments .
typical examples would be the @xmath42 reactions . here
the quantitative realization of the chiral su(3 ) flavor symmetry including its important symmetry breaking effects are an extremely useful constraint when deriving cross sections not accessible in the laboratory directly .
it is common to consider isospin averaged cross sections @xcite @xmath43 the reaction dependent normalization factor is determined by @xmath44 where the sum extends over isospin channels which contribute in a given reaction . in fig .
[ fig : cross - pred ] we confront the cross sections of the channels @xmath45 and @xmath46 with typical parameterizations used in transport model calculations .
the cross sections in the first column are determined by detailed balance from those of the first row .
uncertainties are present nevertheless , reflecting the large empirical uncertainties of the antikaon - nucleon cross sections close to threshold .
the remaining four cross sections in fig .
[ fig : cross - pred ] are true predictions of the @xmath6-bs(3 ) approach .
we should emphasize that we trust our results quantitatively only for @xmath47 mev .
it is remarkable that nevertheless our cross sections agree with the parameterizations in @xcite qualitatively up to much higher energies except in the @xmath48 reactions where we overshoot those parameterizations somewhat . besides some significant deviations of our results from @xcite at @xmath49 200 mev , an energy range where we trust our results quantitatively , we find most interesting the sizeable cross section of about 30 mb for the @xmath50 reaction .
note that here we include the isospin two contribution as part of the isospin averaging .
as demonstrated by the dotted line in fig .
[ fig : cross - pred ] , which represent the @xmath6-bs(3 ) approach with s - wave contributions only , the p- and d - wave amplitudes are of considerable importance for the @xmath50 reaction .
and momentum @xmath51 at nuclear saturation density , @xmath52 , and @xmath53 .
the solid line follows from the real part of the @xmath27 scattering amplitudes of @xcite .
the circles represent the parameterization ( [ kplus : spec ] ) and the dashed line shows the free - space kaon spectrum for comparison.,width=226 ] we begin with a discussion of kaon propagation in dense nuclear matter .
the kaon self energy is evaluated in terms of the real parts of the s- and p - wave kaon - nucleon scattering amplitudes of @xcite .
the resulting quasi - particle energy @xmath54 is shown in fig .
[ fig : kplus ] for nuclear saturation density , @xmath52 , and 2 @xmath52 .
we neglect small rescattering effects proportional to @xmath55 with @xmath56 , which introduce a 15 @xmath57 correction term at small kaon momenta only .
a nuclear environment leads to an increase of the kaon energy where the effect is reduced as the kaon momentum @xmath58 increases .
our result can be interpreted rather accurately in terms of scalar and vector potentials , parameterizing the kaon polarization function , @xmath59 for @xmath60 .
we emphasize that the parameterization of the polarization function @xmath61 is reliable only at the quasi - particle energy of the kaon , @xmath62 , as is implied by ( [ kplus : spec ] ) .
in particular , the parameterization ( [ kplus : spec ] ) does not describe correctly any derivatives of the polarization function .
the parameterization @xmath61 is in striking contradiction to the naive representation , @xmath63 in terms of the weinberg - tomozawa term and the so called kaon - nucleon sigma term , @xmath64 , frequently seen in the literature .
the scalar and vector terms in ( [ kplus : spec ] ) and ( [ kplus : wt ] ) have opposite signs .
as we argued in the previous section , the chiral lagrangian does not describe the kaon - nucleon scattering process correctly if evaluated in perturbation theory .
the small attractive energy dependence of the self energy reflects important range terms required to describe the s - wave kn phase shifts .
the rather small repulsive momentum dependence follows from the net - repulsion of the p - wave amplitudes . for non - zero momentum the small attractive vector potential in ( [ kplus : spec ] )
leads to a reduction of the repulsion implied by the s - wave scattering lengths and p - wave scattering volumes .
we checked that the parameterization ( [ kplus : spec ] ) is valid to high accuracy for kaon momenta smaller than @xmath65 mev reproducing quantitatively the kaon quasi - particle energy @xmath62 .
this is clearly demonstrated in fig .
[ fig : kplus ] where we compare the spectrum following from the exact polarization operator with that one from the parameterization ( [ kplus : spec ] ) at two different nuclear densities .
we turn to antikaon and hyperon resonance propagation in dense nuclear matter . in fig .
[ fig : kaon - sp ] we present the antikaon spectral function together with the antikaon - nucleon scattering amplitudes of selected channels at various nuclear matter densities , @xmath66 , as evaluated in a self consistent manner in @xcite .
the antikaon spectral function exhibits a rich structure with a pronounced dependence on the antikaon three - momentum .
that reflects the coupling of the @xmath10 and @xmath11 hyperon states to the @xmath9 channel .
typically the peaks seen are quite broad and not always of quasi - particle type . as was emphasized in @xcite the realistic evaluation of the antikaon propagation in nuclear matter
requires the simultaneous consideration of the hyperon resonance propagation .
the most important contributions , the s - wave @xmath10 and p - wave @xmath11 resonances , experience important medium modifications as demonstrated in fig . [ fig : kaon - sp ] .
the results at @xmath67 should be considered cautiously because nuclear binding and correlation effects were not yet included in @xcite . ,
the momentum @xmath68 and the nuclear density with @xmath69 @xmath70 .
the right hand panel illustrates the in - medium modification of the @xmath3 and @xmath11 hyperon resonances .
it is plotted the real and imaginary parts of the antikaon - nucleon scattering amplitudes in the appropriate channels .
the hyperon energy and momentum are @xmath71 and @xmath72 respectively.,width=529 ]
we reviewed the application of the microscopic @xmath6-bs(3 ) dynamics developed recently in @xcite to kaon , antikaon and hyperon resonance propagation in nuclear matter .
of central importance for the microscopic evaluation of the kaon and antikaon spectral functions in cold nuclear matter are the kaon- and antikaon - nucleon scattering amplitudes , in particular at subthreshold energies .
the required amplitudes are well established by the @xmath6-bs(3 ) approach and show sizeable contributions from p - waves not considered systematically so far @xcite . for the antikaon spectral
function one finds a pronounced dependence on the three - momentum of the antikaon reflecting the presence of hyperon - nucleon - hole states .
the quantitative evaluation of the antikaon self energy requires the self consistent consideration of the in - medium change of the hyperon resonance structures . at nuclear saturation density
we reported attractive mass shifts for the @xmath3 , @xmath11 and @xmath5 of about 60 mev , 60 mev and 100 mev respectively .
the resonance widths increase to about 120 mev , 70 mev and 90 mev .
whereas the kaon spectral function is well approximated by a quasi - particle approach the antikaon spectral function shows typically a rather wide structure invalidating a simple quasi - particle description .
99 friedman e , gal a and batty c j 1994 , 518 .
lutz m f m and florkowski w 2001 _ acta .
phys . pol . _
* b 32 * , 2081 .
laue f 1999 , 1640 .
brown g e , lee c h , rho m and thorsson v 1994 , 693 ; + brown g e and bethe h a 1994 _ astrophys .
jour . _ * 423 * , 659 .
li g q , lee c h and brown g e 1997 , 5214 .
li g q , lee c h and brown g e 1997 , 372 .
fuchs c 1998 , 245 ; wang z s 1998 , 3284 .
david c , hartnack c and aichelin j 1999 , 358 .
bratkovskaya e l , cassing w and mosel u 1997 , 593 .
li b a 1999 , 034902 .
ivanov yu b , knoll j and voskresensky d n 2000 , 313 .
leupold s 2000 , 475 .
cassing w and juchem s 2000 , 417 .
schaffner - bielich j , koch v and effenberger m 2000 , 153 .
lutz m 1998 , 12 .
ramos a and oset e 2000 , 481 .
lutz m , steiner a and weise w 1994 , 755 .
pandharipande v r , pethick c j and thorsson v 1995 , 4567 .
kolomeitsev e e , voskresensky d n and kmpfer b 1995 , 889 .
waas t , kaiser n and weise w 1996 , 12 ; + waas t , kaiser n and weise w 1996 , 34 .
waas t , rho m and weise w 1997 , 449 .
tolos l 2001 , 547 .
martin a d 1981 , 33 .
dover c d , hfner j and lemmer r h 1971 , 248 .
lutz m f m and kolomeitsev e e 2001 eprint : nucl - th/0105042 .
lutz m f m and korpa c l 2001 eprint : nucl - th/0105067 iwasaki m 1997 , 3067 .
cugnon j , deneye p and vandermeulen j 1990 , 170 . | in this talk we review recent progress on the systematic evaluation of the kaon and antikaon spectral functions in dense nuclear matter based on a chiral su(3 ) description of the low - energy pion- , kaon- and antikaon - nucleon scattering data . |
the interaction between high power plasma jets and the circumgalactic medium ( cm ) is now the firmly established paradigm for radio galaxies ( rgs ) , as many talks at this meeting verify .
the original `` twin exhaust '' model ( blandford & rees 1974 ) outlined how fast plasma jets could possibly carry energy efficiently from the active galactic nucleus ( whose nature was still the subject of speculation in 1974 ) into hot spots of radio lobes , depositing that energy at `` working surfaces '' associated with the regions where the jets impinged on the ambient medium .
blandford & rees touched on most of the issues that have occupied researchers in this field over the quarter century since .
those authors perceptively captured a basic concept that seems now clearly to be at the heart of the physics of the radio galaxy phenomenon , and also that previewed discovery of remarkably similar outflows from an amazing diversity of astrophysical systems .
we are still at the task of learning about jet physics more than 25 years later , because the application of the simple concept is actually very complex .
jet - based flows are highly driven systems , inherently unstable and probably always far from any general equilibrium .
we still do not properly understand how the jets are formed , what they are made of , how they manage to propagate as much as megaparsecs into the ambient medium , nor how and where the relativistic electron populations we observe in the flows are accelerated nor how they evolve more generally .
those issues , of course , are the central themes of this meeting . over the past 15 years or so numerical simulations of time
dependent jet flows have progressed enormously from the earliest two dimensional axisymmetric gasdynamical flows ( smith et al .
1985 ) to three dimensional flows ( e.g. , cox , gull & scheuer 1991 ) until now fully three dimensional flows incorporating self - consistent mhd are relatively straightforward , if not yet easy , to model with modest resolution ( e.g. , clarke 1997 ) .
these simulation methods have also been extended to include flows in either 2d or 3d with relativistic bulk motions ( e.g. , van putten 1993 ; duncan & hughes 1994 ; aloy et al .
1999 ; zhang , koide & sakai 1999 ) .
simultaneously , physical models of particle acceleration physics , especially as it relates to the formation of collisionless shocks , have become much better developed ( e.g. , jones 2001 ) , even if that can not yet be called a solved problem .
all of these very positive developments have been well represented in presentations at this meeting , in fact .
most of our information about rgs currently derives from radio synchrotron emissions reflecting the spatial and energy distributions of relativistic electrons convolved with the spatial distribution of magnetic fields .
x - ray observations , especially of nonthermal compton emissions , depending on the electron and ambient photon distributions , are now beginning to add crucial information , as well . using these connections ,
much effort has been devoted to interpreting observed brightness , spectral and polarization properties of the nonthermal emissions for estimates of the key physical source properties , such as the energy and pressure distributions and kinetic power , as well as to find self - consistent models for the particle acceleration and flow patterns . as telescopes and analysis techniques
have improved the level of detail obtained , it has become apparent , however , that the observed properties are not very simple and much harder to interpret than most simple models predict ( e.g. , rudnick 2001 ) .
this problem stems in part from the complexity of the flow dynamics expected , and also for inherent difficulties in simulating both the dynamics and the transport of radiating particles in multi - dimensional flows .
the latter is especially challenging .
until now , in fact , all published efforts to model nonthermal emission properties from simulated flow behaviors have been based on ad - hoc simple assumptions about the relationships between nonthermal particles and bulk flow variables such as total fluid pressure , density and magnetic field ( e.g. , clarke , burns & norman 1989 ; matthews & scheuer 1990 ; aloy et al .
2000 ) . to address properly the inherently nonequilibrium character of nonthermal particles , however , it is essential that they be treated explicitly .
we report here on our program to do this .
it provides the first multi - dimensional numerical simulations of jet - driven flows including acceleration and transport of radiating nonthermal electrons in a fashion that enables detailed study of the connections between flow dynamics , particle transport and nonthermal emissions .
this is made possible by a new and very efficient scheme for nonthermal particle transport ( jones , ryu & engel 1999 ; jun & jones 1999 ) .
we focus in this paper on the links between plasma dynamics and particle acceleration and transport that we can see with this treatment . a companion paper ( tregillis , jones & ryu 2001a )
discusses initial `` synthetic radio observations '' made on our simulated objects .
we will see , in fact , that the nonthermal particle and emission properties are often very poorly represented in standard cartoons of rgs .
flow dynamics in our simulations is treated with a second - order , conservative `` tvd '' ideal mhd code described in ryu & jones 1995 , ryu , jones & frank 1995 and ryu et al .
the method depends on approximate solutions to the 1d mhd riemann problem at zone boundaries , and uses conventional directional splitting techniques in multiple dimensions to retain second order accuracy .
the code maintains the divergence free condition for magnetic fields to machine accuracy using an upwinded constrained transport scheme as described in ryu et al .
1998 . to follow nonthermal particle transport we solve the standard `` convection diffusion '' equation for the momentum distribution , @xmath0 ( e.g. , skilling 1975 ) .
this equation includes the effects of adiabatic and radiative losses as well as terms that account for particle acceleration due to spatial diffusion at shocks and momentum diffusion resulting from mhd turbulence . the computational effort needed to solve
this equation over an entire grid is enormous , because it must be solved simultaneously for momenta spanning at least several orders of magnitude , and must capture microphysics taking place on spatial scales also spanning many orders of magnitude . to manage
that with conventional finite differencing methods in momentum space would involve vastly more effort than the mhd itself , so is simply not practical . on the other hand
, there are a couple of very important properties of the problem that can be utilized to circumvent the difficulties in some circumstances , reducing the work level to being just comparable to the mhd ; that is , the total cost and number of variables is about doubled , so manageable .
the first key feature is that @xmath0 is mostly a smooth and broad function .
in fact , away from cutoffs it can be adequately described by defining a `` local spectral index '' , @xmath1 , which varies slowly with @xmath2 .
thus , we integrate the convection diffusion equation over logarithmic momentum bins at each spatial zone and simply track the number of nonthermal particles in each bin . those quantities are updated in a conservative scheme using fluxes across momentum boundaries computed from the dynamical variables , magnetic field , radiation field , etc . by applying the simple quasi - power law model for the distribution of @xmath0 within momentum bins we can make the bins rather large and still maintain good accuracy . for the results shown here
we have used eight momentum bins uniformly spread over @xmath3 .
the second key feature is that the microphysics governing @xmath0 generally takes place on scales within a modest factor of the gyro radii of the particles . for energies of a few tens of gev and below , relevant to radio synchrotron emission and x - ray compton emission
those length scales and the associated time scales are at least several orders of magnitude smaller than scales resolved in the mhd solution .
diffusive acceleration up to gev energies at shocks should be essentially instantaneous on the time scale of rg dynamics , so one can find @xmath0 immediately behind a shock from the steady state solution there . in the test particle limit that depends only on the shock compression ratio , r , i.e. , @xmath4 , which approaches 4 at strong shocks .
downstream , @xmath0 becomes modified by adiabatic and radiative effects using the methods outlined in the previous paragraph .
this scheme can be implemented to include spatial diffusion , and second order fermi acceleration , as well as other loss mechanisms . in the present , exploratory simulations , however , we have neglected spatial diffusion , and have included only diffusive shock acceleration , plus adiabatic and radiative losses for nonthermal electrons .
we treat the nonthermal electrons as a passive component for now , and have included improvements that enhance the performance of the originally published scheme .
jones et al . 1999 carried out several exploratory simulations using these methods for axisymmetric jets .
their purpose , as for us also , was to begin an examination of how best to understand the links between complex rg flow dynamics and nonthermal particle transport properties .
they discussed three simulations based on identical flow dynamics , but with different simple idealized models for the nonthermal particle transport properties . here
we discuss extensions of those same three simulations from two to three dimensions .
earlier discussions of some of these results are contained in jones , ryu & tregillis 2000 and tregillis , jones & ryu 2000 .
the 3d jets were light ( @xmath5 ) with an internal mach number , @xmath6 , and assumed to be in pressure balance with a uniform ambient medium ( the cm ) at their origin .
the magnetic field in the in - flowing jet was helical , with a uniform poloidal component , @xmath7 , that mapped into the cm , plus a toroidal component , @xmath8 , derived from a uniform axial current with a return current along the jet boundary .
the maximum @xmath9 , while the axial `` beta '' of the jet plasma was @xmath10 . to break axisymmetry
the in - flowing jet was made to precess on a 5 degree cone with a period allowing approximately @xmath11 rotations during the simulation .
thus , our flows have a fully three dimensional flavor very early on .
previous 3d simulations have shown that even numerical perturbations will eventually cause jets to deviate substantially from quasi-2d symmetry ( norman 1996 ) , but only after the jet has propagated many jet radii . on the other hand
there is good evidence that at least some jets really do precess ( e.g. , condon & mitchell 1984 ; mantovani et al .
1999 ; sudou & taniguchi 2000 ) .
the simulations were carried out on a @xmath12 grid with open boundary conditions except for the jet origin .
the in - flowing jet had a top hat velocity profile inside a radius of 15 zones , with a thin sheath around it .
thus , the long dimension of the computational domain was approximately 38 jet radii . these flows are , therefore , still relatively `` young '' compared to most rgs .
our initial objectives depend on maintaining a reasonably fine resolution of the dynamical structures in the jets and their `` heads '' , so the large effort needed in these simulations constrains us to look at young flows for the moment . figures 1 and 2 illustrate some of the basic dynamical properties of the simulated flows about 90% of the way to the end time .
all of the images shown here are volume renderings filtered to show only plasma that entered the grid through the jet origin .
that is , we have used a passive mass fraction variable and made transparent any zone containing less than 99% jet material by mass .
figure 1 represents the velocity field in this manner .
the left panel displays the flow speed of the jet and its cocoon .
the jet itself is clear , of course , but note also that flow speeds in the cocoon can be a substantial fraction of the jet speed .
it is also obvious that the cocoon flow is not regular at all .
that point is made more dramatic in the right panel of figure 1 , which displays flow compression ; i.e. , @xmath13 .
the image isolates shocks in the flow . while such classic features as conical shocks near the jet origin are evident , it is hard to identify anything resembling the canonical `` jet termination shock '' .
rather , the head of the flow is filled with a `` shock web '' , and most of it involves back flows in the cocoon rather than the jet itself .
there is a very small jet termination shock near the bottom right of the image , but close examination shows that very little of the jet flow actually passes through it .
we have produced several animations , including flow speed , flow compression and magnetic pressure for the entire simulation in order to study the flow properties and to explain the features seen here .
those are currently available for viewing at url + http://www.msi.umn.edu:80/projects/twj/radjet/radjet.html .
almost as soon as the jet terminus propagates past the position of the first conical shock all semblance of any simple symmetry vanishes .
the end of the jet begins to `` flail '' violently , occasionally isolating pieces of initially high speed plasma that dissipate or run into the wall of the cocoon .
the main jet flow then extends forward abruptly , sometimes seeming to poke a sharp `` finger '' into the cm .
these structures resemble hybrids of the so - called `` dentist s drill '' ( scheuer 1982 ) and `` splatter spot '' ( lonsdale & barthel 1986 ) concepts for production of secondary hotspots , and confirm behaviors seen in some earlier 3d simulations ( cox , gull & scheuer 1991 ) .
most of the time there is no recognizable jet termination shock , but the violence of the end of the jet flow maintains a complex shock web similar to that visible in figure 1 .
most of the shock surfaces are relatively weak compared to what one would derive for the 1d jet termination shock ( the latter strength being for a light jet roughly the jet internal mach number ) . some portions of the shock web can , however , equal or exceed that strength .
generally speaking flows within the cocoon in this simulation are backwards directed , but also highly chaotic , as the shock web indicates .
figure 2 illustrates the distribution of the log of gas pressure , @xmath14 and magnetic pressure , @xmath15 , for the same time as in figure 1 . note first that there is considerable intermittency to both distributions . for @xmath14
this is reflects the complex flows within the cocoon , since cocoon shocks will enhance @xmath14 and pressure gradients drive the chaotic motions , as well .
there is very little similarity in the details of the distributions of @xmath14 and @xmath15 , however .
the strongest magnetic fields are generated primarily by flow shear , not compression , so this is expected .
the filamentary nature of the magnetic field is evident in the image , and it is clear that the magnetic pressure is much more intermittent than the gas pressure , as we would expect in a system that is this strongly driven and so far from equilibrium .
local variations in @xmath15 of two orders of magnitude are typical , with much larger excursions into occasional magnetic voids .
peak field strengths in the cocoon are comparable to the jet field , but the average cocoon field generally is much less on account of rarefaction in flows emerging from the jet .
we can not say , of course , how the magnetic field would evolve on scales smaller than our numerical resolution , but on our grid the magnetic field never approaches equipartition with the thermal plasma ; i.e. , @xmath16 everywhere .
there are times and places where @xmath17 , however , so that magnetic stresses exceed reynolds stresses .
the magnetic field is not entirely passive , in other words , even though on average it would appear so .
we note also that the animation of the magnetic pressure reveals brief episodes when the peak field strength near the jet terminus is considerably stronger than average .
those episodes correspond to times when the jet extends itself most rapidly into the cm as it `` breaks '' and reforms . in summary
, the terminus of our light 3d jet behaves in a violently unstable manner that makes the concept of a simple jet termination shock not very applicable , while creating a chaotic cocoon with a rich web of shocks and highly filamentary , intermittent magnetic fields .
on top of the dynamics just described we computed the evolution of nonthermal electron populations using the methods outlined in 2 .
we emphasize that our purpose at this stage of the program is not to look for the parameters that necessarily most resemble real rgs , but , rather to understand how particle populations will behave under simple assumptions and how `` synthetic observations '' of the simulated objects behave .
further , we want to know and what that tells us that we can reliably derive from observations when we know the actual source physical properties .
we simulated three models for nonthermal electron transport analogous to those discussed by jones et al .
1999 for similar , but axisymmetric flows . in all three models
nonthermal electrons passing through shocks are accelerated according to standard test particle diffusive shock acceleration theory ( e.g. , drury 1983 ) , so that a momentum distribution becomes flattened to @xmath18 , if initially steeper , where @xmath19 , and @xmath20 is the shock compression ratio . in all three models electrons in smooth
flows are subject to adiabatic energy gains and losses as a result of flow expansion or compression . in two of the models
all the nonthermal electrons are introduced only at the jet origin , whence they are advected with the jet plasma .
those electron populations enter with a power law momentum distribution , @xmath21 , with @xmath22 , which corresponds to a synchrotron spectral index @xmath23 , typical for jets .
these two models differ only in the rates of radiative cooling for the nonthermal electrons . in our `` control model '' ,
radiative cooling is negligible , whereas in the `` strong - cooling model '' an electron with momentum @xmath24mc ( e = 5 gev ) would loose half its initial energy to synchrotron radiation in a field @xmath7 over the full duration of the simulation . for the parameters used to create synthetic observations ( tregillis et al .
2001a ) we used @xmath25 g . in that field such electrons would radiate synchrotron emission near 2.4 ghz and their radiative lifetimes would be about 50 million years , thus defining the duration of the simulation .
we note that since the equations of ideal mhd have no inherent time or length scales , the dynamics can be computed without any reference to physical units .
defining radiative cooling rates constrains physical parameters , but , as discussed in jones et al .
1999 , it is still possible to rescale the physical system in order to keep the dynamics unchanged while adjusting the electron cooling rates .
that is what we have done here .
the intent is to explore how electron `` aging '' takes place in the simulated flows , taking into account the highly intermittent character of the magnetic fields .
the third electron transport model injects new nonthermal electrons from the thermal plasma at shocks and then follows them in a manner analogous to the control model .
evidence from galactic shocks , such as supernova remnants , strongly suggests that a fraction of the thermal electron population passing through a collisionless shock is injected into the nonthermal population , although the physics of that process is still unclear ( e.g. , jones 2001 ) . here
we apply a simple injection model that extracts a small , fixed fraction ( @xmath26 ) of the total electron flux through a shock .
the intent of the `` injection model '' simulation is to examine the effects of the complex shock web on particle spectra when the population is dominated by in situ injection .
thus , radiative cooling is made negligible and the nonthermal electron population entering at the jet origin is small , as well .
the electron spectral distributions of all three transport models are intricate , reflecting the complex shock and magnetic field properties discussed earlier .
the chaotic motions in the cocoon make it difficult to identify the immediate causes of any particular feature in a local electron population
. generally speaking , the local particle spectra usually depend more directly on where the particles have been than what their current local environment is like . in a complex , changing flow , that is difficult to reconstruct that history from snapshots .
we offer a few comments on the individual model behaviors , but for details refer readers to a more complete discussion in preparation ( tregillis , jones & ryu 2001b ) . for the control model
the entire electron population has spectra flatter than @xmath22 , since diffusive shock acceleration can only flatten the spectrum .
> from standard relations one can easily compute the minimum shock strength necessary to flatten an incident electron population ; namely , @xmath27 ( with @xmath28 ) . shock modification of the electron population entering with the jet requires passage through shocks of modest strength ; namely , @xmath29 .
however , just as in the earlier axisymmetric results , there is little evidence of particle acceleration directly associated with a dominant jet terminal shock .
too little of the jet flow exits through such a shock structure to have a global impact .
instead , the evident particle acceleration is associated with strong shock sites within the shock web near the jet terminus .
those tend to vary quickly over both space and time .
thus , the particle spectral distribution shows much delicate structure , which is difficult to capture in gray scale , but which is evident in the color image given in jones et al .
2000 and on the previously mentioned web site .
the effect of the shock web is easily apparent in the electron spectral distributions shown for the injection model in the left panel of figure 3 .
the images in this figure come from the same time as those in figures 1 and 2 , and the orientation of the grid is the same , as well .
they render the spatial distribution of @xmath30 for 5 gev electrons , with flatter spectra having higher tones .
the image is not weighted by emissivity , so can not alone tell us the expected synchrotron spectrum along a given line of sight . that property requires a radiative transfer calculation based on self - consistent emissivities , which is done in the companion paper by tregillis et al .
2001a . to view @xmath31
we have taken a 2d slice down the center of the computational box and a transverse one as well .
again only plasma that is entirely of jet origin is rendered .
the remaining space is transparent . as an aside
we note that the irregular boundary of the visible regions emphasizes the fact that some large scale mechanical mixing is taking place between the jet cocoon and the cm in response to kelvin - helmholtz instabilities .
the jet can be seen entering from the top .
a very small population of nonthermal electrons is actually introduced by the in - flowing jet with @xmath32 in this model , making the jet visible here . almost everywhere else , the electron population is completely dominated by injection at the shocks within the flow , however .
mostly the electron spectral slope lies in the range @xmath33 , but there are pockets of larger and smaller values , as well .
we see for these slices that most of the volume is occupied by electron populations with spectra moderately steeper than @xmath34 for the incoming jet . that reflects the fact that most of the plasma gets processed only by relatively weak shocks , as we discussed earlier .
sometimes a particular slope value streams into the back - flow , identifying relatively long lived shock structures and their downstream flow patterns .
this is about the closest the patterns come to the canonical model in which all the cocoon flow represents flow after passage through a unique , strong jet termination shock .
the more realistic situation is clearly much more complicated .
the right panel in figure 3 shows the analogous electron spectral index distribution in the `` strong cooling '' transport model .
recall in this model that all the nonthermal electrons entered with the jet , so the only role of shocks is to flatten portions of the momentum spectrum steeper than @xmath35 as a population enters the shock .
thus , without radiative cooling all rendered regions in this image would show tones ( `` brightness '' ) at least as high as the in - flowing jet . for this model
, 5 gev electrons would just cool over the duration of the simulation if they sat in a magnetic field equal to the jet poloidal value , @xmath7 .
of course , electrons actually spend a much shorter time inside the jet itself , since jet plasma would cross the computational grid in about @xmath36 the simulation time if it were not deflected by the ambient medium along the way .
so , there is little `` aging '' of the electron population at this energy within the jet flow .
the most notable property of the distribution outside the jet is its complex structure showing that spectral aging is not a smooth function of location , and certainly not a simple measure of distance from the jet terminus .
in fact one can again identify `` streams '' of nearly constant @xmath30 that roughly correspond to the patterns of flow .
mostly @xmath37 , but both flatter and steeper pockets are scattered through the volume .
thus , most of the cocoon electron population has experienced some amount of radiative cooling at this energy , as intended for this model . on the other hand that cooling has mostly taken place very near the head of the flow , and it is not uniform .
that pattern is quite consistent , in fact , with the properties of the magnetic field as illustrated in figure 2 , especially when one accounts for the episodes of stronger field amplification mentioned in the dynamical discussion .
> from these behaviors it is clearly very risky to attempt to use synchrotron spectral distributions to infer local spectral aging rates .
we have begun an effort to study the connections between dynamics in simulated radio galaxy plasma flows and the properties of nonthermal electron populations carried in those flows . to do this
we have introduced a new numerical scheme for electron transport that allows us a much more detailed look at this problem than has been possible before .
especially when the dynamics is fully three dimensional the flows are generally chaotic in the cocoon , and the jet itself can flail about violently .
the deflected jet can pinch itself off and redirect itself to enhance its penetration of the ambient medium .
these behaviors mostly eliminate the presence of a strong jet termination shock , which is assumed present in all modern cartoon models of the rg phenomenon . instead a much more complex `` shock web '' forms near the end of the jet that leads to a far less predictable pattern of particle acceleration . similarly , the magnetic fields in these flows are highly filamented , as well as spatially and temporally intermittent .
this leads to a very localized and complex pattern of synchrotron aging for relativistic electron populations , which makes it difficult to use properties of the electron spectrum to infer the local rate of aging .
these results may appear discouraging to interpretation of observations at first glance , but we aim through this study to establish a more robust physical basis for linking observed source properties with physical model characteristics , and so to define firmly such key properties as the power of the jets that drive these phenomena .
an important step in that task is the use of synthetic observations of the simulated objects .
that effort is also underway as described in our companion paper in these proceedings ( tregillis et al
. 2001a ) .
work by twj and ilt has been supported under nsf grants ast96 - 16964 and ast00 - 71167 , as well as the university of minnesota supercomputing institute .
work by dr has been supported by kosef grant krf-2000 - 015-ds0046 .
aloy , m .- a .
, gmez , j. , ibez , j. , mart & mller , e. 2000 , ` radio emission from three - dimensional relativistic hydrodynamic jets : observational evidence of jet stratification ' , , 528 , l85-l88 blandford , r. d. & rees , m. j. 1974 , ` a twin exhaust model for double radio sources ' , , 169 , 395 - 415 clarke , d. 1997 , ` a restarting jet revisited : mhd computations in 3-d ' in computational astrophysics ; 12th kingston meeting on theoretical astrophysics ; asp conference series # 123 , edited by d. a. clarke and m. j. west .
clarke , d. , burns , j. & norman , m. 1989 , ` numerical observations of a simulated jet with a passive helical magnetic field ' , , 342 , 700 - 717 condon , j. j. & mitchell , k. j. 1984 , ` 4c 29.47 - quasi - periodic outbursts recorded by precessing jets ? ' , , 276 , 472 - 475 cox , c. , gull , s. & scheuer , p. 1991
, ` three - dimensional simulations of the jets of extragalactic radio sources ' , , 252 , 558 - 585 drury , l. oc .
1983 , ` an introduction to the theory of diffusive shock acceleration of energetic particles in tenuous plasmas ' , rep .
phys . , 46 , 973 - 1027 duncan , g. & hughes , p. 1994
, ` simulations of relativistic extragalactic jets ' , , 436 , l119-l122 jones , t. w. 2001 , ` cosmic particle acceleration : basic issues ' , in 7th taipei astrophysics workshop on cosmic rays in the universe asp conf . series , in preparation jones , t , w. , ryu , d. & engel , a. 1999 , simulating electron transport and synchrotron emission in radio galaxies : shock acceleration and synchrotron aging in axisymmetric flows , , 512 , 105 - 124 jones , t. , tregillis & ryu , d. 2000 , ` simulations of nonthermal electron transport in multidimensional flows : application to radio galaxies ' , in life cycles of radio galaxies , new astronomy reviews ( elsevier science ) , edited by j. biretta ( in press ) .
jun , b. & jones , t. 1999 , ` radio emission from a young supernova remnant interacting with an interstellar cloud : magnetohydrodynamic simulation with relativistic electrons ' , , 511 , 774 - 791 lonsdale , c. & barthel p. 1986 , ` double hotspots and flow redirection in the lobes of powerful extragalactic radio sources ' , , 92 , 12 - 22 matthews , a. & scheuer , p. 1990
, ` models of radio galaxies with tangled magnetic fields .
i - calculation of magnetic field transport , stokes parameters and synchrotron losses .
ii - numerical simulations and their interpretation ' , , 242 , 616 - 635 mantovani , f. , junor , w. valero , c. & mchardy , i 1999 , ` vlbi observations of 3c 273 at 22 ghz and 43 ghz . i. search for short time - scale structural variation ' , , 346 , 397 - 406 norman , m. 1996 , ` structure and dynamics of the 3d supersonic jet ' , in energy transport in radio galaxies and quasars , asp conf .
series 100 , ed .
p. hardee , a. bridle & j. zensus , p 319 rudnick , l. 2001 , ` what shape are your spectra in ? ' , this volume ryu , d. & jones , t. 1995 , numerical magnetohydrodynamics in astrophysics : algorithm and tests for one - dimensional flow ,
, 442 , 228 - 258 ryu , d. , jones , t. & frank , a. 1995 , ` numerical magnetohydrodynamics in astrophysics : algorithm and tests for multidimensional flow ' , , 452 , 785 - 796 ryu , d. , miniati , f. , jones , t. & frank , a. 1998 , ` a divergence - free upwind code for multidimensional magnetohydrodynamic flows ' , , 509 , 244 - 255 scheuer , p. 1982 , ` morphology and power of radio sources ' , in extragalactic radio sources ( dordrecht ) p 163 - 165 skilling , j. 1975 , ` cosmic ray streaming .
i - effect of alfven waves on particles ' , , 172 , 557 - 566 smith , m. , norman , m. , winkler , k. & smarr , l. 1985 , ` hotspots in radio galaxies - a comparison with hydrodynamic simulations ' , , 214 , 67 - 85 sudou , h. & taniguchi , y. 2000 , ` large - scale regular morphological patterns in the radio jet of ngc6251 ' , , 120 , 697 - 702 tregillis , i. , jones , t. , ryu , d. & park , c. 2000 , ` simulations of nonthermal electron transport in multidimensional flows : synthetic observations of radio galaxies ' , in life cycles of radio galaxies , new astronomy reviews ( elsevier science ) , edited by j. biretta ( in press ) tregillis , i. , jones & ryu 2001a , ` nonthermal emissions in radio galaxies from simulated relativistic electron transport in 3d mhd flows ' , this proceedings tregillis , i. , jones , t. & ryu , d. 2001b , ` 3d mhd simulations of relativistic electron transport and nonthermal emission in radio galaxies ' , ( to be submitted ) van putten , m. 1993 , ` a two - dimensional relativistic ( gamma = 3.25 ) jet simulation ' , , 408 , l21-l23 zhang , h. , koide , s. & sakai , j. 1999 , ` two - dimensional simulations of relativistic jet - cloud collisions ' , , 51 , 221 - 231 | we report on an effort to study the connections between dynamics in simulated radio galaxy plasma flows and the properties of nonthermal electron populations carried in those flows .
to do this we have introduced a new numerical scheme for electron transport that allows a much more detailed look at this problem than has been possible before .
especially when the dynamics is fully three dimensional the flows are generally chaotic in the cocoon , and the jet itself can flail about violently .
the bending jet can pinch itself off and redirect itself to enhance its penetration of the ambient medium .
these behaviors often eliminate the presence of a strong jet termination shock , which is assumed present in all modern cartoon models of the rg phenomenon . instead a much more complex `` shock web '' forms near the end of the jet that leads to a far less predictable pattern of particle acceleration .
similarly , the magnetic fields in these flows are highly filamented , as well as spatially and temporally intermittent .
this leads to a very localized and complex pattern of synchrotron aging for relativistic electron populations , which makes it difficult to use properties of the electron spectrum to infer the local rate of aging . |
ever since the late 1960s anomalies @xcite have played an important role in our understanding of strong - interaction physics .
anomalies arise if the symmetries of the lagrangian at the classical level are not supported by the quantized theory after renormalization , resulting in so - called anomalous ward identities @xcite . for the case of chiral @xmath11 ,
the constraints due to the anomalous ward identities have efficiently been taken care of through the effective wess - zumino - witten ( wzw ) action @xcite .
the wzw action is expressed in terms of the pseudoscalar octet of goldstone bosons and contributes at @xmath12 in the momentum expansion of chiral perturbation theory @xcite ( for an overview see , e.g. , refs.@xcite ) .
it is determined through the underlying group structure up to an overall constant @xcite and , in the purely strong sector , gives rise to interaction vertices involving an odd number of goldstone bosons ( odd - intrinsic - parity sector ) @xcite .
using topological arguments , witten has shown that the wzw action is quantized , i.e. a multiple of an integer parameter @xmath13 . by including a coupling to electromagnetism ,
this parameter has been identified as the number of colors @xmath14 by comparing with the prediction of the qcd triangle diagram for the ( anomalous ) decay @xmath15 .
once the overall factor is fixed , the ( gauged ) wzw action also predicts other interactions such as the @xmath16 vertex .
however , it has recently been pointed out by br and wiese @xcite that the @xmath14 dependence in the pion - photon vertices is completely canceled once the @xmath14 dependence of the quark charges is consistently taken into account . in that sense ,
the width of the decay @xmath17 is predicted absolutely without reference to the number of colors .
the conclusion from their analysis is that one should rather consider three - flavor processes such as @xmath18 or @xmath19 to test the expected @xmath14 dependence @xcite in a low - energy reaction .
however , by investigating the corresponding @xmath20 and @xmath21 decays up to next - to - leading order in the framework of the combined @xmath22 and chiral expansions , borasoy and lipartia have concluded that the number of colors can not be determined from these decays due to the importance of sub - leading terms which are needed to account for the experimental decay widths and photon spectra @xcite .
the decay @xmath23 is the prime example of an anomalous process @xcite and its invariant amplitude can be written as @xmath24 the prediction in the chiral limit , as obtained from the wzw action , is given by @xcite @xmath25 where @xmath26 , @xmath27 , and @xmath28 denotes the su(3 ) chiral limit of the pion - decay constant @xcite : @xmath29=92.4\ , \mbox{mev}$ ] @xcite . using eq .
( [ calfpi0pred ] ) with the empirical value @xmath30 instead of @xmath28 , one obtains for the decay rate @xmath31 in agreement with the average value of ref .
@xcite : @xmath32 corrections due to explicit chiral symmetry breaking have been studied in refs . .
the most recent analyses yield @xmath33 @xcite in @xmath34 chiral perturbation theory at @xmath35 including electromagnetic corrections at @xmath36 , @xmath37 @xcite in the framework of a dispersion theory approach , and @xmath38 @xcite using @xmath39 chiral perturbation theory at @xmath3 in combination with large-@xmath14 arguments . as has been stressed in ref .
@xcite , the individual experimental results show a large dispersion and depend on the specific reaction used to extract the amplitude .
the primakoff experiment at jefferson lab ( primex ) @xcite aims at a determination of the width with an accuracy of 1.5 % and will thus match the increased precision of the theoretical analysis . as mentioned above
, the wzw action also predicts more complicated processes such as the @xmath16 interaction and one clearly needs to confirm our picture of both the leading - order term as well as the relevant corrections .
the invariant amplitude for @xmath40 can be written as @xmath41 where the mandelstam variables are defined as @xmath42 , @xmath43 , @xmath44 and satisfy the standard relation @xmath45 .. ] the lowest - order prediction [ @xmath12 ] is independent of @xmath47 , @xmath48 , @xmath49 , and @xmath50 @xcite , @xmath51 the physical threshold for @xmath52 is at @xmath53 , @xmath54 , and @xmath55 .
the amplitude @xmath2 was measured by antipov _
@xcite at serpukhov using 40 gev pions .
their study involved pion pair production by pions in the nuclear coulomb field via the primakoff reaction @xmath56 where @xmath57 and @xmath58 denote the nuclear charge and mass number , respectively . in the one - photon - exchange domain ,
( [ eq : bin2 ] ) is equivalent to @xmath59 with an almost real photon ( @xmath60 ) .
diffractive production of the two - pion final state is blocked by @xmath61-parity conservation . at cern compass @xcite , a physics program based on pion and
kaon scattering from the nuclear coulomb field ( primakoff scattering @xcite ) has begun .
the program goals include state - of - the - art measurements of the chiral anomaly transitions @xmath62 and @xmath63 as well as measurements of pion and kaon polarizabilities and radiative transitions @xcite and hybrid meson production @xcite . the chiral anomaly sample of ref .
@xcite ( roughly 200 events ) covered the ranges @xmath64 and @xmath65 .
the small @xmath48 range selects events predominantly associated with the exchange of a virtual photon , for which the target nucleus acts as a spectator . assuming a constant amplitude @xmath2 , the value @xmath66 was extracted from the experiment @xcite . the considerable discrepancy with the theoretical prediction of eq . ( [ eq : int5 ] )
has generated a lot of interest in clarifying the situation from both the experimental and theoretical sides .
higher - order corrections in the odd - intrinsic - parity sector of chpt have extensively been studied by bijnens _
they included one - loop diagrams involving one vertex from the wzw term and tree diagrams from the anomalous @xmath3 lagrangian @xcite , where the parameters of the lagrangian have been estimated via vector - meson dominance ( vmd ) calculations . while the higher - order corrections to @xmath67 of eq.([calfpi0pred ] ) are small , for @xmath2 they increase the lowest - order value between 7 % and 12 % within the kinematic range of the serphukov experiment @xcite .
moreover , genuine one - loop corrections and @xmath3 tree - level contributions were found to be comparable in size .
it has also been stressed by holstein @xcite that the experimental value of eq .
( [ eq : int6 ] ) was obtained under the assumption of a _ constant _ amplitude whereas a re - analysis using a suitable dependence on the kinematical variables would produce a lower value @xcite @xmath68 and thus reduce the difference between theory and experiment .
a sophisticated analysis has been carried out by hannah @xcite in the framework of a two - loop evaluation [ @xmath69 using dispersive methods . from a comparison with the antipov _
et al . _ data with the two - loop analysis leaving @xmath70 as a free parameter , hannah obtained @xmath71 by also including radiative corrections , ametller
et al._@xcite showed that the electromagnetic corrections generate a sizeable increase in the primakov cross section , leading , in comparison with eq .
( [ eq : thtab ] ) , to a further decrease @xmath72 finally , using an integral equation approach , truong @xcite obtained @xmath73 further theoretical investigations of @xmath2 include calculations in the framework of dynamical constituent quarks @xcite .
the limited accuracy of the existing data in combination with the various new calculations clearly motivates improved and more precise experiments @xcite . in a recent jlab experiment @xcite
, results on @xmath74 were obtained from an analysis of @xmath75 data taken with the clas detector .
the photon energy was approximately 2 gev .
a chew - low analysis was used to extract @xmath2 from the cross sections over a large kinematic range .
preliminary results were presented by b. asavapibhop @xcite and an experimental paper is in preparation @xcite . in this present work , we will focus on the reaction @xmath76 where an incident high - energy pion scatters inelastically from a target electron in an atomic orbit , as shown in fig .
[ fig : kinematics ] .
this reaction and also @xmath77 can , in principle , be studied with the ( 190 - 300 ) gev pion and kaon beams in the cern compass experiment @xcite .
new high - statistics pion data will allow for a determination of the form factor for @xmath78 .
the kaon beam three - flavor process can as well test the expected @xmath14 dependence in a low - energy reaction @xcite .
a similar ( pion ) experiment has already been performed at the cern sps @xcite .
the experiment did not explicitly extract a value @xmath79 but rather claimed that the experimental value was consistent with theory expectations . although the experimental backgrounds were described in @xcite , comparisons of experimental and theoretical distributions versus different kinematic variables were not shown ; unfortunately , the data are no longer available for such comparisons @xcite . without presenting such detailed comparisons , amendolia _ et al .
_ reported 36 events for the reaction @xmath80 corresponding to a cross section of @xmath81 nb .
however , without statistical tests such as the kolmogorov - smirnov distribution test @xcite comparing experimental and theoretical distributions , it is not possible to be sure that background events were not included in the cross section value of ref .
the cross section of @xmath82 , in principle , may also include @xmath83 production via the @xmath84 transition @xcite .
however , threshold effects eliminate this background for the 300 gev pion beam energy of @xcite , since an energy of @xmath85 is required to produce a @xmath86 with @xmath87 via @xmath88 . our work is organized as follows . in sec .
[ section_kinematics ] we briefly discuss the kinematics and formalism of @xmath82 . in sec .
[ section_theory ] we present the calculation of the anomaly amplitude @xmath2 within su(3 ) chpt , discuss some phenomenological approaches , and use monte carlo techniques to integrate the cross section and compare it with the experimental result of @xcite . in sec .
[ section_summary ] we summarize our results and draw some conclusions .
some technical details are relegated to the appendices .
following the nomenclature of ref .
@xcite , the kinematics for @xmath89 is shown in fig .
[ fig : kinematics ] for an incoming pion that scatters inelastically off an electron target and produces an additional @xmath90 in the final state : @xmath91 .
we consider the target electron to be at rest and the binding energy of the electrons bound in an atom to be negligible relative to the incoming pion energy .
we define the standard set of five invariants as @xcite @xmath92 the invariant @xmath93 is fixed by the incident beam energy @xmath94 , @xmath95 , and one is left with four scalar variables @xmath96 , @xmath47 , @xmath97 , and @xmath48 .
the fourfold differential cross section , expressed in terms of the five invariants of eq .
( [ five_invariants ] ) , is given by ( see , e.g. , ref .
@xcite ) ] ] @xmath98 where @xmath99 and where the gram determinant is given by @xcite @xmath100 the factor 1/16 has been extracted for later convenience . the expressions of the scalar products entering eq . ( [ eq : dif19 ] ) in terms of the invariants of eq .
( [ five_invariants ] ) are given in eq .
( [ scalar_products ] ) . in the one - photon exchange approximation
( see fig .
[ fig : opea ] ) the total invariant amplitude @xmath101 can be written as @xmath102 where @xmath103 is the virtual photon polarization vector ( @xmath104 ) and @xmath105 the squared matrix element of eq .
( [ dsigma ] ) involves the contraction of the standard lepton tensor known from the one - photon exchange approximation in electroproduction processes , @xmath106 with the hadronic tensor and is given by @xmath107 the explicit expression for eq .
( [ m2overline ] ) is given in app .
[ squared_amplitude ] .
in this section we describe the theoretical input to our analysis of the reaction @xmath82 .
since we work in the one - photon exchange approximation , it is sufficient to consider the transition - current matrix element @xmath108 where @xmath109 is the electromagnetic current operator ( including the elementary charge ) . in the isospin - symmetric limit , @xmath2 is a completely symmetric function of the mandelstam variables @xmath47 , @xmath48 , and @xmath49 . in the _ physical _ region ,
the mandelstam variables satisfy the standard relation @xmath110 .
we will lay emphasis on a calculation within the framework of chiral perturbation theory at @xmath3 but will also discuss the results of some ( more ) phenomenological approaches .
this will allow us to have an estimate of effects which would be subsumed in terms of @xmath111 and higher .
besides the neutral - pion decay into two photons , the amplitude for @xmath112 is of prime interest for testing our understanding of anomalous ward identities . in the momentum and quark - mass expansion , its leading - order contribution is of @xmath12 and originates from the wess - zumino - witten action @xcite .
the interaction lagrangian relevant in the presence of external electromagnetic fields ( described by the vector potential @xmath113 ) is given by @xcite @xmath114,\ ] ] where @xmath115 denotes the quark - charge matrix and @xmath116 contains the goldstone boson fields .
the current @xmath117 by itself is not gauge invariant and the additional terms of eq .
( [ lanoelm ] ) are required to obtain a gauge - invariant action .
the first term of eq .
( [ lanoelm ] ) gives rise to the @xmath118 coupling ( see fig . [
fig : tree_4 ] ) @xmath119 whereas the second is responsible for the @xmath15 decay not discussed in this paper .
weinberg s power counting scheme @xcite establishes a connection between the chiral expansion and the loop expansion . since the anomalous sector only starts at @xmath12 , the contribution at @xmath3 results from either one - loop diagrams with exactly one vertex from the wzw term or tree - level diagrams with exactly one vertex from the anomalous lagrangian at @xmath3 . in order to determine the one - loop contributions we need , besides eq .
( [ lanoelm ] ) , the wzw contribution involving 5 goldstone bosons , @xmath120 and the lowest - order lagrangian in the presence of an electromagnetic field , @xmath121 + \frac{f^2_0}{4}\mbox{tr}(\chi u^\dagger + u\chi^\dagger),\ ] ] where the relevant covariant derivative is given by @xmath122 $ ] and @xmath123 contains the quark - mass matrix @xmath124 and @xmath125 is related to the scalar quark condensate in the chiral limit .
the most general anomalous lagrangian at @xmath3 has recently been derived in refs .
@xcite . according to table v of ref .
@xcite , seven structures have the potential of contributing to @xmath118 vertices . in principle , the corresponding low - energy coupling constants should be calculable from the underlying theory . however , since we can not yet solve qcd , the parameters are either taken as free parameters that are fitted to experimental data or are estimated from models such as meson - resonance saturation @xcite . in
what follows , we will make use of the su(3 ) version of chiral perturbation theory , because this will allow us in future calculations to make contact with other anomalous processes involving in addition kaons .
moreover , we note that previous calculations at @xmath3 @xcite were performed for real photons , @xmath52 , because the amplitude was embedded in a primakoff reaction , where the virtual photon of the coulomb field of a heavy nucleus is quasi real . for our reaction such
an approximation is not admissable which we will also explicitly see when we discuss the results .
the relevant one - loop diagrams are shown in figs .
[ fig : loop_a ] , [ fig : loop_b ] , and [ fig : loop_cde ] and fall into two distinct groups .
the first category just includes one graph ( fig .
[ fig : loop_a ] ) whose loop is attached to one single vertex ( the loop is composed by one internal line so to speak ) , while in the second category the loop always binds two different vertices together ( the loop is therefore composed of two internal lines ) . moreover , at @xmath3 one obtains a contact contribution shown in fig .
[ fig : tree_6 ] . combining the @xmath12 and @xmath3 results , multiplying with a factor of @xmath126 for each external pion line , and renormalizing the coefficients of the @xmath3 lagrangian , the result of the one - loop calculation in su(3 ) chpt at @xmath3
is given by @xcite : @xmath127\right\}\right ) .
\label{eq : theor3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the constants @xmath128 and @xmath129 are linear combinations of _ renormalized _ low - energy coupling constants @xmath130 of the most general odd - intrinsic - parity lagrangian at @xmath3 @xcite , @xmath131 these coefficients still depend on the renormalization scale @xmath132 but in such a way that the scale dependence of the logarithms in eq .
( [ eq : theor3 ] ) is precisely compensated .
the function @xmath133 originates from a standard one - loop integral of mesonic chiral perturbation theory and is given by @xmath134\nonumber\\ & = & \left \
{ \begin{array}{ll } -2-\sigma\ln\left(\frac{\sigma-1}{\sigma+1}\right ) & ( x<0 ) \nonumber\\ -2 + 2\sqrt{\frac{4}{x}-1}\,\mbox{arccot } \left(\sqrt{\frac{4}{x}-1}\right ) & ( 0\le x<4 ) \nonumber\\ -2-\sigma\ln\left(\frac{1-\sigma}{1+\sigma}\right)-i\pi\sigma & ( x>4 ) \end{array } , \right.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath135 for @xmath136 $ ] .
up until now , we have carried out everything which is necessary to meet the requirements of a consistent @xmath3 calculation within the framework of mesonic chpt . however , our result still depends on two unknown parameters ( @xmath128 and @xmath129 ) which prevent us from _ predicting _ observables such as the total cross section or distributions . of course ,
these low - energy coupling constants ( lecs ) can in principle be determined within appropriate experiments . here , we actually move on and estimate the constants by using theoretical means which evidently have to go beyond mesonic chpt .
the lecs are supposed to include whatever qcd information on all particles which do not belong to the goldstone boson octet . at low energies the lightest
are expected to be significant and we are thus led to consider the effects due to the vector mesons @xcite . for that purpose we made use of the nonlinear chiral lagrangian of ref .
@xcite , evaluated the tree - level diagrams contributing to @xmath137 involving internal vector meson lines , and expanded the propagators to be able to collect the arising @xmath3 pieces ( for later purposes we also consider the expressions keeping the full propagators ) . a comparison ( matching ) with the polynomial @xmath138 pieces of the most general
anomalous lagrangian yields the estimate @xmath139 using @xmath140 in su(3 ) results in @xmath141 instead of expanding the vector - meson propagators in the vector - meson saturation calculation , we could also keep the complete propagators .
this would correspond to the replacement @xmath142 in eq .
( [ eq : theor3 ] ) .
we then obtain some estimate of higher - order terms beyond @xmath3 . a full calculation of all @xmath143 radiative corrections as well as the isospin symmetry breaking effects due to the different @xmath144- and @xmath145-quark masses is beyond the scope of the present paper .
as discussed in ref .
@xcite , the most important electromagnetic correction originates from a photon - photon fusion into a neutral pion ( see fig .
[ fig : em_corr ] ) yielding an additional contribution of the type @xmath146 due to the @xmath147 pole of the exchanged photon , eq .
( [ deltae2 ] ) becomes important for small values of @xmath48 .
note that including the single diagram of fig .
[ fig : em_corr ] does not lead to a conflict with gauge invariance . on the other hand ,
other electromagnetic corrections were found to be very small in ref .
@xcite , where the authors concluded that their full calculation can be very well reproduced by adding only the contribution of eq .
( [ deltae2 ] ) . in our analysis we will also compare data with phenomenological calculations using three different forms of the transition - current matrix element : 1 .
phenomenological ansatz of terentev @xcite : @xmath148 .
\label{eq : theor1}\ ] ] here , the multiplicative constant @xmath70 refers to the low - energy prediction of eq .
( [ eq : int5 ] ) and the variation of the function @xmath2 is supposed to come mainly from vector - meson - exchange diagrams .
the parameters @xmath149 ( @xmath150 ) implicitly contain factors of @xmath151 and are related to the partial widths @xmath152 and @xmath153 [ @xmath154 and @xmath155 . in the numerical analysis
we make use of @xmath156 mev and @xmath157 mev . comparing eq .
( [ eq : theor1 ] ) with eq .
( [ replacement ] ) would result in @xmath158 and @xmath159 in comparison with @xmath160 and @xmath161 of ref .
2 . pole model of rudaz including vector - meson dominance ( vmd ) @xcite : @xmath162 .
\label{eq : theorudaz}\ ] ] 3 . vmd model including the effects of final state p - wave @xmath163 scattering @xcite : @xmath164\nonumber \\ & & \times \left(\frac{1-s_2/m_{\rho}^{2}}{d_{1}(s_2)}\right ) \left(\frac{1-t_{2}/m_{\rho}^{2}}{d_{1}(t_{2})}\right ) \left(\frac{1-u_2/m_{\rho}^{2}}{d_{1}(u_2)}\right ) , \label{eq : theor5}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath165 note that the ansatz of eq .
( [ eq : theor5 ] ) has only been derived for real photons , @xmath52 , and we therefore have to expect some shortcomings in the description of @xmath166 .
using monte carlo techniques we determined the total cross section based on eq.([dsigma ] ) for kinematical variables inside the region specified by @xmath167 which are the minimal ( maximal ) values obtained from the equations for the kinematical boundaries [ see ref .
@xcite and eq .
( [ kinbound ] ) ] . for the generated invariants the positivity of @xmath168 of eq .
( [ dsigma ] ) is checked and events with positive @xmath169 are rejected . in order to check the monte carlo calculations we also compared the result with an explicit numerical integration using the simplifications of a constant @xmath2 and @xmath170 ( see appendix [ appendix_direct_calculation ] ) .
the results for the total cross section are shown in table [ table_sigmatot ] .
the first column denotes the model / theory and the corresponding parameters used ; the second column contains the integrated cross section for each case with @xmath70 fixed to @xmath171 .
the cases 1 ) , 4 ) , 5 ) , and 6 ) of table [ table_sigmatot ] were already used in fig . 4 of ref .
@xcite and our corresponding cross sections are in reasonably good agreement . in the third column
we show the respective physical threshold amplitudes . in the chiral limit
, the threshold amplitudes should reduce to the low - energy prediction @xmath172 of eq .
( [ eq : int5 ] ) . in this context
it is important to realize that , in general , the dependence of the threshold amplitude on @xmath173 results from both kinematical variables and explicit symmetry breaking .
the models of 2 ) - 6 ) can only account for the first type of dependence and the corresponding modification is of the type @xmath174 , where the relevant constant depends on the parameters of the model and is of the order of 1 .
the results of 7 ) - 11 ) , in addition , contain corrections from goldstone boson loops of the form @xmath175 which are of both kinematical and chiral symmetry breaking type . in the calculation of 9 ) , the @xmath147 singularity due to the electromagnetic correction of eq .
( [ deltae2 ] ) generates a 17 % increase in units of @xmath176 , but when integrated over @xmath48 ultimately leads to a less pronounced contribution to the cross section .
finally , in the last column we have also included the overall factor @xmath177 which one extracts based on the experimental result @xmath81 nb of ref .
@xcite if one treats @xmath70 as a free parameter in the respective model .
the error in @xmath177 only reflects the error in the experimental cross section and does not include any error estimate implied by the models .
however , we explicitly do _ not _ advocate such an extraction as a strict test of the low - energy theorem of eq .
( [ eq : int5 ] ) , because it introduces a bias in how the chiral limit is approached .
rather , at this point , the only rigorous approach consists of using the chiral expansion as in eq .
( [ eq : theor3 ] ) and confronting it directly with experimental results . using the estimate of eq .
( [ cestimate ] ) for the parameters @xmath128 and @xmath129 , we obtain as the chpt result at @xmath3 @xmath178 by also including the most prominent electromagnetic correction @xcite in terms of photon - photon fusion into a neutral pion the result increases slightly : @xmath179 both results are in excellent agreement with the experimental result @xmath81 nb of ref . @xcite . in general ,
the conceptual advantage of the chpt calculation over the remaining empirical models is that it is the only calculation which naturally incorporates both genuine quantum effects ( loops ) and higher - order corrections ( as estimated from the vmd saturation ) .
moreover , in principle , a controlled improvement is possible by performing a complete @xmath111 calculation , whereas the remaining calculations suffer from the absence of a systematic method of improvement .
a comparison of 8) with 7 ) clearly shows the necessity to include the consequences resulting from the virtuality of the exchanged photon .
this can also be seen from the transitions 2 ) to 3 ) or 4 ) to 5 ) in the calculations using terentev s model . on the other hand ,
the spread of the obtained cross sections is an indication that higher - order terms ( in the chiral expansion ) may play an important role .
this conjecture is supported by an analysis for a pion beam energy of 150 gev which leads to total cross section results between 0.17 nb and 0.21 nb , i.e. , the results scatter substantially less than for the higher energy . in fig .
[ fig : invs ] we show the generated distributions of events as functions of the invariants @xmath96 , @xmath47 , @xmath97 , and @xmath48 as obtained using chiral perturbation theory at @xmath3 [ see eq .
( [ eq : theor3 ] ) ] with the low - energy constants of eq .
( [ cestimate ] ) and the most prominent electromagnetic correction of eq .
( [ deltae2 ] ) .
the results are based on the generation of @xmath180 events restricted to the kinematic region @xmath181 the regions have been chosen such as to avoid the @xmath182 pole and to be far enough away from the @xmath86-meson production threshold . in fig .
[ fig : mv_dif ] we show the differential cross section @xmath183 as a function of @xmath97 for three different choices of the low - energy constants of eq .
( [ cestimate ] ) .
clearly , @xmath184 gev ( triangles ) would correspond to unrealistically large higher - order terms which is supported by the drastically different behavior for this case .
figure [ fig : mod_8_9 ] illustrates how the inclusion of the electromagnetic correction of eq .
( [ deltae2 ] ) affects the differential cross section @xmath183 .
the calculational errors in the plotted points of figs .
[ fig : mv_dif ] and [ fig : mod_8_9 ] range from 0.1 % at @xmath185 gev@xmath186 to 0.3 % at @xmath187 gev@xmath186 .
finally , fig .
[ fig : mod_comp ] contains a comparison of different ( model ) calculations for the differential cross section @xmath183 . here , the calculational errors in the plotted points range from 0.03 % at @xmath185 gev@xmath186 to 0.07 % at @xmath187 gev@xmath186 .
we have studied the reaction @xmath0 with the purpose of obtaining information on the @xmath1 anomalous amplitude @xmath2 . in table
[ table_sigmatot ] we have summarized the results of various phenomenological models and of a full calculation at @xmath3 in chiral perturbation theory for the total cross section using the kinematical conditions of ref . @xcite . in particular , by integrating the chpt results using monte carlo techniques we obtain @xmath4 nb at @xmath3 and @xmath5 nb after including the dominant electromagnetic correction .
both results are in good agreement with the experimental cross section of @xmath6 nb @xcite . on the basis of
the chpt results one would extract from the the experimental cross section as amplitudes @xmath7 gev@xmath8 and @xmath9 gev@xmath8 , respectively , which have to be compared with the low - energy theorem @xmath10 .
we emphasize the need for new data to allow comparison of experimental and theoretical distributions and to obtain @xmath2 with smaller uncertainty . in order to further support our findings and to obtain @xmath2 with a smaller uncertainty
, it would be useful for future experiments to also consider distributions such as those shown in figs .
[ fig : invs ] - [ fig : mod_comp ] .
the work of t. e. and s. s. was supported by the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft ( sfb 443 ) . the work of i. g. and m. a. m. was supported by the israel science foundation .
many thanks go to r. tenchini for interesting clarifications and communications regarding the work amendolia _
et al._. we also thank a. vainshtein for helpful comments and encouragement . furthermore ,
s. s. would like to thank a. i. lvov for clarifying comments on the calculation of appendix [ appendix_direct_calculation ] and j. gasser and j. gegelia for very useful comments on interpreting the chpt result .
the ten scalar products appearing in the calculation of the differential cross section of eq .
( [ dsigma ] ) may be expressed in terms of the five standard invariants of eq .
( [ five_invariants ] ) as @xcite @xmath188
in order to evaluate eq .
( [ m2overline ] ) , one makes use of the double epsilon expression @xmath189 the evaluation of the expression in brackets in eq .
( [ m2overline ] ) is straightforward but tedious and we only quote the final result : @xmath190\nonumber\\ & & + 2p_a\cdot p_b p_1\cdot p_b [ p_2 ^ 2 p_3 ^ 2-(p_2\cdot p_3)^2]\nonumber\\ & & + 2p_a\cdot p_2 p_1\cdot p_2 [ p_b^2 p_3 ^ 2-(p_b\cdot p_3)^2]\nonumber\\ & & + 2p_a\cdot p_3 p_1\cdot p_3 [ p_b^2 p_2 ^ 2-(p_b\cdot p_2)^2]\nonumber\\ & & + 2(p_a\cdot p_b p_1\cdot p_2+p_a\cdot p_2p_1\cdot p_b ) ( p_b\cdot p_3 p_2\cdot p_3-p_b\cdot p_2 p_3 ^ 2)\nonumber\\ & & + 2(p_a\cdot p_b p_1\cdot p_3+p_a\cdot p_3 p_1\cdot p_b ) ( p_b\cdot p_2 p_2\cdot p_3-p_b\cdot p_3 p_2 ^ 2)\nonumber\\ & & + 2(p_a\cdot p_2 p_1\cdot p_3+p_a\cdot p_3 p_1\cdot p_2 ) ( p_b\cdot p_2 p_b\cdot p_3-p_2\cdot p_3 p_b^2).\end{aligned}\ ] ] we deliberately did not express the scalar products @xmath191 , @xmath192 , and @xmath193 in terms of the masses , because it is then straightforward to apply eq .
( [ evaluation ] ) for other processes involving particles with different masses , such as , e.g. , @xmath194 .
note that eq .
( [ evaluation ] ) is manifestly symmetric under both the exchange @xmath195 and the exchange of any two elements of @xmath196 . finally , using eqs .
( [ scalar_products ] ) the scalar products in eq .
( [ evaluation ] ) may be expressed in terms of the invariant variables of eq .
( [ five_invariants ] ) .
using the covariant normalization for both bosons and fermions , the differential cross section for @xmath197 can be written as @xmath198 where we consider the final - state pions in their rest frame ( denoted by @xmath199 ) and the ejected electron in the laboratory frame .
integration with respect to @xmath200 and @xmath201 yields @xmath202 let the pion beam define the positive @xmath203 axis . using @xmath204 in combination with @xmath205
we obtain @xmath206 and can thus write @xmath207 to obtain the kinematic boundaries of @xmath47 and @xmath97 one can either solve for @xmath97 in terms of @xmath47 , or vice versa @xcite , @xmath208,\nonumber\\ s_2^\pm&=&s+m_1 ^ 2-\frac{1}{2m_a^2}[(s+m_a^2-m_b^2)(m_a^2+m_1 ^ 2-t_1 ) \mp \lambda^{1/2}(s , m_a^2,m_b^2)\lambda^{1/2}(t_1,m_a^2,m_1 ^ 2 ) ] , \nonumber\\ \label{kinbound}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath209 is defined in eq . (
[ lambda ] ) . in order to test our numerical integration programs , we evaluated eq .
( [ app_dsigma_int ] ) under the following simplifying assumptions : we neglected terms containing the square of the electron mass and we assumed @xmath2 to be constant [ see eq .
( [ eq : int5 ] ) ] . under these assumptions
we obtain for the angular integral @xmath210.\ ] ] inserting eq .
( [ angular_integral ] ) into eq .
( [ app_dsigma_int ] ) and using eq .
( [ m2overline ] ) results in @xmath211\ ] ] for @xmath170 and @xmath212 .
we first integrate eq .
( [ app_dsigmadt1ds2 ] ) with respect to @xmath97 from @xmath213 to @xmath214 , where @xmath215 is an experimental cut on the maximal value of @xmath97 : @xmath216 \ln\left(\frac{t_1 ^ -}{t_1^c}\right)],\nonumber\\\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath217 $ ] as implied by the physical boundary conditions . a numerical integration of @xmath218 yields @xmath219 nb for @xmath220 gev@xmath186 which agrees within less than 0.5 % with the monte carlo result 1.855 nb ( we used @xmath221 mev ) .
s. l. adler , phys .
rev . * 177 * , 2426 ( 1969 ) .
s. l. adler and w. a. bardeen , phys .
rev . * 182 * , 1517 ( 1969 ) .
w. a. bardeen , phys .
* 184 * , 1848 ( 1969 ) .
j. s. bell and r. jackiw , nuovo cim .
a * 60 * , 47 ( 1969 ) .
j. wess and b. zumino , phys .
b * 37 * , 95 ( 1971 ) .
e. witten , nucl .
b223 * , 422 ( 1983 ) . s. weinberg , physica a * 96 * , 327 ( 1979 ) ; j. gasser and h. leutwyler , annals phys . * 158 * , 142 ( 1984 ) ; nucl .
* b250 * , 465 ( 1985 ) .
a. pich , rept .
phys . * 58 * , 563 ( 1995 ) ; a. pich , in _ probing the standard model of particle interactions _ , proceedings of the les houches summer school in theoretical physics , session 68 , les houches , france , 28 july - 5 september 1997 , edited by r. gupta , a. morel , e. de rafael , and f. david ( elsevier , amsterdam , 1999 ) ; g. ecker , lectures given at advanced school on quantum chromodynamics ( qcd 2000 ) , benasque , huesca , spain , 3 - 6 july 2000 , hep - ph/0011026 .
@xcite s. scherer , in _ advances in nuclear physics , vol .
27 _ , edited by j. w. negele and e. w. vogt ( kluwer academic / plenum publishers , new york , 2003 ) .
o. br and u .- j .
wiese , nucl .
* b609 * , 225 ( 2001 ) .
r. n. rogalyov , hep - ph/0202046 .
b. borasoy and e. lipartia , phys .
d * 71 * , 014027 ( 2005 ) .
s. eidelman et al .
b * 592 * , 1 ( 2004 ) .
j. f. donoghue , b. r. holstein , and y. c. lin , phys .
lett . * 55 * , 2766 ( 1985 ) .
j. bijnens , a. bramon , and f. cornet , phys .
lett . * 61 * , 1453 ( 1988 ) .
b. moussallam , phys . rev .
d * 51 * , 4939 ( 1995 ) .
b. ananthanarayan and b. moussallam , jhep * 0205 * , 052 ( 2002 ) . n. f. nasrallah , phys . rev .
d * 66 * , 076012 ( 2002 ) .
j. l. goity , a. m. bernstein , and b. r. holstein , phys .
d * 66 * , 076014 ( 2002 ) .
a. gasparian _ et al .
_ , conceptional design report _ a precision measurement of the neutral pion lifetime via the primakoff effect _ ,
url : www.jlab.org/primex .
m. v. terentev , phys .
b * 38 * , 419 ( 1972 ) .
m. antipov _ et al .
_ , phys .
d * 36 * , 21 ( 1987 ) .
g. baum _ et al .
_ ( compass collaboration ) , proposal for a _ common muon and proton apparatus for structure and spectroscopy _ , cern - spslc 96 - 14 , spsc / p 297 ; http://wwwcompass.cern.ch .
m. a. moinester and v. steiner , _ primakoff physics for cern compass hadron beam : hadron polarizabilities , hybrid mesons , chiral anomaly , meson radiative transitions _
, contributed to charles u./jinr and international u. ( dubna ) cern compass summer school , august 1997 , prague , czech republic , hep - ex/9801011 . m. a. moinester ( compass collaboration ) , _ pion and kaon polarizabilities at cern compass _ , contributed to advanced study institute on symmetries and spin ( praha spin 2002 ) , prague , czech republic , 14 - 27 july 2002 , czech .
j. phys .
, b169 ( 2003 ) , hep - ex/0301024 . m. a. moinester , _ hybrid meson production via pion scattering from the nuclear coulomb field _ , proceedings of the `` future physics at compass '' workshop , geneva , switzerland , sept .
2002 , cern yellow report 2004 - 011 , http://wwwcompass.cern.ch/compass/publications/2004_yellow/ , hep - ex/0301023 . j. bijnens , a. bramon , and f. cornet , z. phys .
c * 46 * , 599 ( 1990 ) .
j. bijnens , a. bramon and f. cornet , phys .
b * 237 * , 488 ( 1990 ) .
j. bijnens , int .
j. mod .
phys . a * 8 * , 3045 ( 1993 ) .
d. issler , slac - pub-4943-rev ( 1990 ) ( unpublished ) ; r. akhoury and a. alfakih , annals phys .
* 210 * , 81 ( 1991 ) ; h. w. fearing and s. scherer , phys .
d * 53 * , 315 ( 1996 ) .
@xcite t. ebertshuser , h. w. fearing , and s. scherer , phys .
d * 65 * , 054033 ( 2002 ) .
@xcite j. bijnens , l. girlanda , and p. talavera , eur .
j. c * 23 * , 539 ( 2002 ) .
b. r. holstein , phys .
d * 53 * , 4099 ( 1996 ) .
t. hannah , nucl .
* b593 * , 577 ( 2001 ) . l. ametller , m. knecht , and p. talavera , phys .
d * 64 * , 094009 ( 2001 ) .
t. n. truong , phys .
d * 65 * , 056004 ( 2002 ) .
r. alkofer and c. d. roberts , phys .
b * 369 * , 101 ( 1996 ) ; b. bistrovic and d. klabucar , phys .
d * 61 * , 033006 ( 2000 ) ; b. bistrovic and d. klabucar , phys .
b * 478 * , 127 ( 2000 ) ; x. y. li and y. liao , phys .
b * 505 * , 119 ( 2001 ) ; s. r. cotanch and p. maris , phys .
d * 68 * , 036006 ( 2003 ) .
m. a. moinester , in _ proceedings of the international conference on physics with gev particle beams _ , 22 - 25 august 1994 , jlich , germany , edited by h. machner and k. sistemich ( world scientific , singapore , 1995 ) , hep - ph/9409307 .
r. a. miskimen , k. wang , a. yegneswaran ( spokespersons ) , thomas jefferson national accelerator facility experiment e94015 , _ study of the axial anomaly using the @xmath222 reaction near threshold_. b. asavapibhop , _ study of the axial anomaly in the @xmath223 reaction at low @xmath224 using the clas and the photon tagger _ , phd thesis , university of massachusetts , amherst , massachusetts , 2000 , http://www.jlab.org / hall - b / clas_g1/anomaly/. c. unkmeir , a. ocherashvili , t. fuchs , m. a. moinester , and s. scherer , phys .
c * 65 * , 015206 ( 2002 ) .
t. ebertshuser , _ mesonic chiral perturbation theory : odd intrinsic parity sector _ , phd thesis , johannes gutenberg - universitt , mainz , germany , 2001 , http://archimed.uni-mainz.de/ ; t. ebertshuser and s. scherer , in preparation .
g. ecker , j. gasser , h. leutwyler , a. pich , and e. de rafael , phys .
b * 223 * , 425 ( 1989 ) .
g. ecker , j. gasser , a. pich , and e. de rafael , nucl .
phys . *
b321 * , 311 ( 1989 ) . t. fujiwara , t. kugo , h. terao , s. uehara , and k. yamawaki , prog .
phys . * 73 * , 926 ( 1985 ) .
.[table_sigmatot]total cross section for @xmath0 as obtained in different models and chiral perturbation theory ( see text ) .
the third column contains the physical threshold amplitudes for @xmath52 .
in the last column we made use of the experimental result @xmath81 nb of ref . @xcite to convert this into the value for @xmath177 which would be extracted based on the given model : @xmath225 gev@xmath8 . here
we follow the common practice to quote the extracted values .
the error only reflects the experimental error and does not include any error estimate implied by the models .
we stress that in the framework of chpt the overall factor of eq .
( [ eq : theor3 ] ) is not a free parameter .
therefore , the `` extracted '' values for the chpt calculation have to be taken with a grain of salt ( see the discussion in the text ) . [ cols="<,^,^,^ " , ] | we discuss the reaction @xmath0 with the purpose of obtaining information on the @xmath1 anomalous amplitude @xmath2 . we compare a full calculation at @xmath3 in chiral perturbation theory and various phenomenological predictions with the existing data of amendolia _
et al_. by integrating our theory results using monte carlo techniques we obtain @xmath4 nb at @xmath3 and @xmath5 nb after including the dominant electromagnetic correction .
both results are in good agreement with the experimental cross section of @xmath6 nb . on the basis of
the chpt results one would extract from the the experimental cross section as amplitudes @xmath7 gev@xmath8 and @xmath9 gev@xmath8 , respectively , which have to be compared with the low - energy theorem @xmath10 .
we emphasize the need for new data to allow for a comparison of experimental and theoretical distributions and to obtain @xmath2 with smaller uncertainty . |
one of the most promising future high energy facilities is the recently proposed muon collider . in order to facilitate a decision on whether and how it should be built , all the various uses it can be put to should be assessed .
the highly collimated and intense neutrino beams unavoidably generated by muon decay provide a unique opportunity for precision studies of qcd and electroweak physics .
an excellent example of such investigations is related to the ongoing issue of the validity of the nonrelativistic qcd ( nrqcd ) expansion for charmonium states and the extraction of the so - called color octet matrix elements .
the fact that heavy quarkonium represents a non - relativistic quantum - mechanical system significantly simplifies its theoretical studies .
in particular , the presence of several important scales in the quarkonium system , @xmath2 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 ( @xmath5 ) where @xmath6 is a small parameter ( relative velocity of quarks in the quarkonium state ) allows separation of physical effects occurring at different scales @xcite .
a large excess of prompt @xmath0 s and @xmath7 s at the tevatron over to the predictions of the color singlet model , i.e. the model which postulates that only quarks in a relative color singlet state can evolve into a charmonium , sparked both experimental and theoretical interest and resulted in the realization of the importance of contributions generated by the operators involving quark states in a relative color octet configuration .
the emerging effective theory ( nrqcd ) , systematically describing these processes , factorizes the charmonium production cross section in the form @xmath8 where @xmath9 are short - distance coefficients containing the perturbatively calculable hard physics of the production of a @xmath10 $ ] system at almost zero relative velocity ( like @xmath11 , etc . ) , expressed as a series in @xmath12 . here
, the index @xmath13 incorporates a spectral decomposition of the quarkonium state in terms of the quantum numbers @xmath14 of the @xmath15 $ ] system , as well as the number of additional derivatives acting on the heavy quark fields .
the essence of nrqcd is to organize the above expansion in powers of the heavy quark velocity @xmath6 within the hadron , and it can be further generalized to include other heavy quarkonium - like systems , such as heavy hybrids @xcite .
( [ factor ] ) puts all nonperturbative long - distance information into the nrqcd matrix elements , which describe the evolution of the @xmath10 $ ] system into a charmonium plus soft hadrons a process that can not be calculated at present from first principles .
several attempts have been made to determine these nrqcd matrix elements from various experiments .
the processes involved are sensitive to various linear combinations of nrqcd matrix elements .
the problem is aggravated by the usually very large theoretical uncertainties involved in these calculations ( on the order of @xmath16 ) , due to higher twist effects , uncalculated and/or incalculable higher order perturbative and nonperturbative contributions .
in this situation any independent determination of these quantities should be welcome .
a major advantage of using the neutrino beam is that , at leading order in @xmath17 , the spin structure of the @xmath18 coupling selects a certain combination of octet operators .
the largest contribution is from the one with the quantum numbers @xmath19 .
of course , order of magnitude measurements of the size of the matrix elements of this operator have already been performed for the @xmath0 and @xmath7 , as well as for the @xmath20 states .
the estimates of these matrix elements mostly come from tevatron fits to hadroproduction cross sections for the @xmath0 and @xmath20 and yield , with large theoretical errors @xcite , @xmath21 these values are consistent , within a @xmath22 accuracy level , with the value found from @xmath23 decay at lep @xcite ( the latter does not separate cascade and direct production , so the value of @xmath24 is understandably larger than the one in eq .
( [ estim ] ) ) .
there are , however , large discrepancies between the tevatron fits and the values of @xmath20 matrix elements obtained from b decays @xcite , and between various determinations of @xmath25 from the tevatron fits .
clearly , new results from hera leptoproduction experiments would not clarify the situation as at leading order the process @xmath26_8(^3s_1)$ ] is forbidden by parity conservation of strong interactions . in this situation
other determinations are welcome and desired .
the present paper is an exploratory investigation of the main features of inclusive charmonium production in @xmath27 collisions . this process parallels @xmath0 leptoproduction , in which case fleming and mehen @xcite found that the @xmath28 contribution to the total @xmath29 cross section is small compared to the color octet @xmath30 contribution .
a set of cuts , requiring an energetic gluon jet well separated from the @xmath0 , enhances the @xmath28 contributions , but then the color singlet contribution will dominate . these cuts , however ,
leave behind only a small part of the total cross section .
we do nt expect that either the difference in the spin structure or the @xmath31 suppression of neutral current ( nc ) versus charged current ( cc ) events can change this picture , so that we feel justified to calculate only the @xmath30 contributions .
we will find , however , that while the leptoproduction of @xmath0 is not sensitive to the @xmath19 matrix element , and measures one combination of @xmath32 and @xmath33 , measuring the @xmath34 distribution in our process allows for a determination of both the @xmath19 and the @xmath33 matrix elements .
the difference is due to a difference in the spin structure of the @xmath23 and photon couplings .
the relative size of the @xmath19 and the @xmath33 contributions to the differential cross sections turns out to change drastically around @xmath35 .
this fact and the less steep decrease of the differential cross section ( compared to leptoproduction ) together allow an easy separation of the two contributing matrix elements .
we will find that the hard process at small @xmath34 favors the @xmath36 contribution by a significant factor . in an experiment which can not easily separate direct @xmath0 production from a @xmath20 cascading down to a @xmath0 ( such is the situation at lep , for example ) , these cascades enhance the observed cross section by a significant amount .
in particular , given the estimates of eq .
( [ estim ] ) , we find @xmath37 ! noting that @xmath38 we conclude that @xmath0 production via this cascade mechanism is of the same order of magnitude as via the direct route .
it is however easy to include the effect of these unresolved cascades into the formalism by simply replacing the actual @xmath39 matrix element with a @xmath40 which takes into account this cascade factor @xcite .
the rate of @xmath20 production can then easily be related to our @xmath19 contribution to the @xmath0 production rate , because in that case there are no other competing matrix elements .
the large number of events expected at the muon collider will certainly allow to study the entire spectrum of charmonium states .
due to the fact that the dominant @xmath32 matrix element of the @xmath41 and the dominant @xmath19 of the @xmath20 are related by heavy quark symmetry , our results can be trivially translated to a prediction of these rates .
the only relevant matrix element above is measurable in any other cascade @xmath0 production process . in the present study
we also discuss what we can learn about these matrix elements at existing neutrino facilities .
as we show below , the mere event of the detection of charmonium states in current experiments ( nomad or nutev ) would imply the presence of the color - octet structures predicted by the nrqcd factorization formalism .
the main question to be addressed here is the smallness of the event number .
since the detectors used in current neutrino experiments are optimized for the observation of neutrino - related phenomena ( such as neutrino oscillations ) and not for charmonium detection , we shall concentrate on @xmath0 production , which has the cleanest experimental signature of all charmonium states .
however cascade processes should also be included , helping to increase the event number .
we will find that both at nomad and nutev , the event rate is on the verge of observability .
the rest of the paper is organized as follows . in sec .
[ sec : calc ] we explain the velocity scaling of the nrqcd matrix elements that we use and provide analytical formulas for the structure functions @xmath9 .
we discuss the numerical results for the muon collider , nomad and nutev in detail in sec .
[ sec : numbers ] and offer concluding remarks in the conclusions .
at leading order , @xmath30 , only neutral current @xmath42 interactions contribute to charmonium production and fig .
[ fig : leadinggraphs ] shows the relevant feynman diagrams . at @xmath28 ,
in addition to the color singlet contribution , one may expect some enhancement from charged current interactions due to the difference in the couplings and the propagators , but we do not expect that this could drastically change the cross section to invalidate our order - of - magnitude estimates . before proceeding with the calculation ,
let us briefly review the velocity counting rules of the charmonium production matrix elements which will be used below .
the charmonium production matrix elements are defined in nrqcd as @xmath43 where the operators @xmath44 are bilinear in the heavy quark fields .
( @xmath45 is the charmonium spin @xmath46-component . )
each matrix element is proportional to a power of the relative velocity @xmath6 of the heavy quarks .
each spatial derivative acting on a heavy quark field introduces one power of @xmath6 .
the nonperturbative evolution of the @xmath47 system proceeds through multipole radiation of soft gluons , which introduce additional powers of the velocity . for the @xmath0 and @xmath7 ,
the leading matrix element is at @xmath48 , @xmath49 which clearly selects the dominant fock state .
we observe , however , that this matrix element corresponds to a @xmath47 system in a color singlet state , which can be produced only at subleading order , @xmath50 .
therefore , its contribution will be smaller than that of the velocity - subleading color octet configuration , such as @xmath51 t^a \psi | j/\psi + x \rangle\ , \langle j/\psi + x | \psi^\dagger \left [ -\frac{i}{2 } { d^ { \ { i } \sigma^{k \ } } } \right ] t^a \chi | 0 \rangle , \nonumber \\ \langle 0 | { \cal o}^{j/\psi}_8(^1p_0 ) | 0 \rangle & = & \langle 0 | \chi^\dagger \left [ -\frac{i}{2}\ , { \bf d } \right ] t^a \psi |j/\psi + x \rangle\ , \langle j/\psi + x | \psi^\dagger \left [ -\frac{i}{2 } { \bf d } \right ] t^a \chi | 0 \rangle , \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath52 represents scalar , vector or traceless symmetric tensor contraction of indices .
five of these configurations , namely those with the quantum numbers @xmath32 , @xmath19 , @xmath33 for @xmath53 , scale as @xmath54 .
the @xmath55 matrix element is negligible , of the order @xmath56 , and will be neglected hereafter . in the case of the p - wave states
@xmath20 we encounter a similar situation .
the leading matrix elements are again suppressed by one factor of @xmath17 , and are color singlets at @xmath57 .
they project out the dominant p - wave @xmath58 combination @xmath59 \psi |\chi_{c0 } + x \rangle\ , \langle \chi_{c0 } + x | \psi^\dagger \left [ -\frac{i}{2 } { \bf d \cdot \sigma } \right ] \chi | 0 \rangle \nonumber \\ \langle 0 | { \cal o}^{\chi_{c1}}_1(^3p_1 ) | 0 \rangle & = & \frac{1}{2 } \langle 0 | \chi^\dagger \left [ -\frac{i}{2 } { \bf d \times \sigma } \right ] \psi |\chi_{c1 } + x \rangle\ , \langle \chi_{c1 } + x | \psi^\dagger \left [ -\frac{i}{2 } { \bf d \times \sigma } \right ] \chi | 0 \rangle \\ \langle 0 | { \cal o}^{\chi_{c2}}_1(^3p_2 ) | 0 \rangle & = & \langle 0 | \chi^\dagger \left [ -\frac{i}{2 } { d^{(i } \sigma^{k ) } } \right ] \psi |\chi_{c2 } + x \rangle\ , \langle \chi_{c2 } + x | \psi^\dagger \left [ -\frac{i}{2 } { d^{(i } \sigma^{k ) } } \right ] \chi | 0 \rangle .
\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] the leading matrix elements in the velocity expansion are @xmath60 and @xmath61 , but the @xmath19 configuration is produced at leading order in @xmath17 : @xmath62 the velocity counting rules in nrqcd require , for the most interesting case of the @xmath0 , to calculate the contributions of the @xmath63 matrix elements , @xmath64 ( heavy quark symmetry requires @xmath65 ) .
we note that the same structure functions can be used to evaluate all contributions to @xmath66 , for which @xmath19 is leading , of order @xmath67 , and to @xmath41 , for which @xmath32 is leading , also of order @xmath67 .
we do not calculate the hard - to - identify @xmath68 , where the uncalculated @xmath69 would also contribute at leading order ( this matrix element is completely unimportant for the @xmath0 , as it is suppressed as @xmath56 in that case ) .
we also note that parity and @xmath70 conservation forbids all interference terms in eq .
( [ eq : struct1 ] ) .
the calculation is quite straightforward and we quote the result in the form of the following structure functions @xmath71 : @xmath72 where @xmath73 is the total invariant mass of the @xmath27 system , @xmath74 is the momentum fraction of the incoming gluon and @xmath75 is the momentum - squared transferred from the leptonic system ; @xmath76 . because we are doing a tree level calculation , @xmath17 does not run ; in the actual calculation we will choose the educated guess of evaluating @xmath77 .
now , our calculation gives @xmath78 h_{\,^3\!s_1^{(8)}}\left(y , q^2\right)&=&\left(g_a^c\right)^2 \,\times 2 m_c^2\,\frac{q^2(y^2 - 2y+2)+16(1-y)m_c^2}{\left(q^2 + 4m_c^2\right)^2 } % \nonumber\\h_{\,^3\!p_0^{(8)}}\left(y , q^2\right)&= & { \left(g_v^c\right)^2 \,\times 2\,{q^2}\ , } { \,\frac { { { \left(q^2 + 12m_c^2 \right ) } ^2 } } { { { \left ( { q^2 } + 4m_c^2 \right ) } ^4}}}\,(y^2 - 2y+2 ) % \\[0.1 in ] h_{\,^3\!p_1^{(8)}}\left(y , q^2\right)&=&\left(g_v^c\right)^2 \,\times 4\,q^4\ , { \frac { q^2(y^2 - 2y+2 ) + 16(1-y)m_c^2 } { { { \left ( { q^2 } + 4m_c^2 \right ) } ^4 } } } % \nonumber\\h_{\,^3\!p_2^{(8)}}\left(y , q^2\right)&= & \left(g_v^c\right)^2\,\times \frac{4}{5}\,q^2\,{\frac { ( y^2 - 2y+2){q^4 } + 48(1-y)q^2m_c^2 + 96(y^2 - 2y+2){{{m_c}}^4 } } { { { \left(q^2 + 4m_c^2 \right ) } ^2 } } } \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath79 and @xmath80 are the vector and axial couplings of the @xmath81-quark .
we have checked that an appropriately modified version of these structure functions correctly reproduces the @xmath82 cross section in ref .
we immediately observe that the coupling constants favor the @xmath19 contribution , which is due to the large axial coupling ( a similar contribution is , of course , absent in the case of @xmath0 lepto and photoproduction ) . indeed
our numerical estimates will show that this matrix element dominates the total cross section , and also the differential cross section unless @xmath83 . at large @xmath34 ,
the relative @xmath84 enhancement of the @xmath85-wave structure functions makes them dominant .
these structure functions should eventually be incorporated in the specific monte carlo generators built for each particular detector .
our numerical estimates presented in the following chapters ignore the fine details of the experiments and should be understood as a preliminary feasibility study .
due to its clean experimental signature , one of the most important charmonium production processes is @xmath0 production .
we have calculated the total cross section and the differential @xmath34 distribution of @xmath0 s at various experiments , both currently running and proposed . for lack of knowledge of the size of the nrqcd matrix elements we set them equal to a reasonable baseline size " value , defined as @xmath86
these values satisfy the restrictions imposed by heavy quark symmetry and are compatible with the existing extractions @xcite .
the results below were found using mrst parton distribution functions ( pdf ) @xcite , substituting @xmath87 for the charm quark mass and imposing a cut @xmath88 in the calculation of the total cross section .
the energy dependence of the total cross section , taken at various representative incident neutrino energies , is shown in table [ tab : crs-1 ] .
we find that the total cross section is very sensitive to the neutrino beam energy @xmath89 .
the origin of this strong dependence can be traced to the fact that the main contribution to the integral in eq .
( [ eq : struct1 ] ) comes from the smallest available @xmath90 , so that larger @xmath73 probes a smaller region of @xmath74 where the gluon pdf s are enhanced .
it becomes obvious that in order to have a reasonably large event number , the neutrino beams with the highest possible energy should be employed .
.[tab : crs-1]total cross sections for the @xmath0 production in @xmath91 for various representative incident neutrino energies .
the values are taken to correspond to the minimal , average and maximum neutrino beam energy at nomad and maximum available neutrino beam energy at nutev respectively . [
cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] we have calculated the total cross section for the two presently running high energy neutrino experiments , nomad at cern and nutev at fermilab , as well as for the much - discussed high energy muon collider . table [ tab : crs ] shows the results for each term in the spectral decomposition .
the values support our previous expectations that the @xmath36 contribution dominates the total cross section .
note that these numbers refer to direct @xmath0 production ; a cascade mechanism involving @xmath20 decay into @xmath0 can be easily calculated from our @xmath19 contribution and its ratio to direct @xmath19 production is universal and can be taken from other experiments .
we should emphasize that due to the expected small number of events the question of background suppression becomes very important .
in particular , in the case of the currently running experiments , nomad and nutev , the leptonic decay channel of @xmath0 becomes virtually the only possibility of detecting the produced @xmath0 s .
this makes electromagnetic lepton pair production a very important source of background @xcite .
c||c|c|c|c|c|c|c|c spectral & & & & + decomp . ' '' '' & @xmath92 $ ] & @xmath93&@xmath92 $ ] & @xmath93&@xmath92 $ ] & @xmath93&@xmath92 $ ] & @xmath93 + @xmath94&@xmath95&@xmath96&@xmath97&@xmath98&@xmath99&@xmath100&@xmath101&@xmath102 + @xmath103&@xmath104&@xmath105&@xmath106&@xmath107&@xmath108&@xmath109&@xmath110&@xmath111 + @xmath112&@xmath113&@xmath114&@xmath115&@xmath116&@xmath117&@xmath118&@xmath119&@xmath120 + @xmath121&@xmath122&@xmath123&@xmath124&@xmath125&@xmath126&@xmath127&@xmath128&@xmath129 + @xmath130&@xmath131&@xmath132&@xmath133&@xmath134&@xmath135&@xmath136&@xmath137&@xmath138 + & @xmath139&@xmath140&@xmath141&@xmath142&@xmath143&@xmath144&@xmath145&@xmath146 + & & & & another important issue is diffractive @xmath0 production .
it is difficult to separate , both theoretically and experimentally , diffractive and color octet contributions .
this is due to the fact that both of these processes contribute at @xmath147 . in principle , the absence of a rapidity gap in the color - octet nrqcd process may help @xcite .
in addition , a perturbative qcd calculation of the diffractive leptoproduction @xcite suggests that this process falls off at high @xmath34 as @xmath148 .
we expect this behavior to hold for the case of diffractive `` neutrinoproduction '' as well .
as indicated in our calculation , the color octet contribution falls off only as @xmath149 which makes the diffractive process negligible at sufficiently high @xmath34 .
show the @xmath34 distribution of the events . as expected , these decrease quickly with increasing @xmath34 .
the decrease , however , is not so drastic as not to let us use higher @xmath34 cut up to @xmath150 which may also allow to reduce the nonperturbative background .
now we turn to the discussion of some of the presently running and planned neutrino experiments .
a proposal to build a high energy @xmath151 storage ring has recently drawn much attention .
although seemingly a sideline , luminous neutrino beams are unavoidably generated by the decaying muons , and provide an ideal environment for charmonium generation .
such machines comprise both necessary ingredients , high luminosity and high neutrino beam energy , that are needed for detailed studies of charmonium production . the proposed first muon collider @xcite would use @xmath152 muons , boosted in linear accelerators . these muons and antimuons decay into the @xmath153 s ( or @xmath154 s ) in both final booster ( called rla3 ) and in the accelerator ring .
a straight section of the ring was proposed in order to achieve a highly collimated neutrino beam .
the resulting neutrino spectra that have been calculated by harris and mcfarland @xcite peak in the @xmath155 region . with a representative set of parameters @xmath156 dis events/(g/@xmath157 year ) are expected .
this high number of events allows a measurement of the partial distributions without the need for extremely costly dedicated detectors . with the cross sections given in table [ tab : crs ] ,
this translates to @xmath158 events/(g/@xmath157 year ) .
we will now sample the various suggestions for the neutrino detectors to get a rough idea of the yield and capabilities . in all cases
we look at a detector diameter of @xmath159 , in which almost all of the neutrino beam fits . as an obvious minimal suggestion
, we might look at a @xmath160 thick , table - top sized detector @xcite , containing approximately @xmath161 of water - density target .
we estimate a yield of @xmath162 , providing just enough statistics for a crude estimate of the octet matrix elements .
by contrast , a light target considered e.g. in @xcite ( a @xmath163 thick liquid hydrogen detector ) would only produce approximately @xmath164 , not much better than presently running experiments .
the best answer may be the general purpose detector " suggested by b. king @xcite .
this detector consists of a one meter long stack of silicon ccd tracking planes , providing @xmath165 g/@xmath166 density .
in such a detector an estimated @xmath167 would occur and the high efficiency and precise reconstruction capabilities should allow for disentangling the contribution from the color octet @xmath19 and @xmath33 matrix elements , through the measurement of the differential @xmath34 distributions .
note that an increase in the length of the straight section of the storage ring provides a relatively cheap way of increasing the luminosity of the neutrino beam , resulting in better statistics . ref .
@xcite actually considers a @xmath168 long straight section , gaining a factor of @xmath169 over our estimates .
another option is a conventional fixed target type heavy detector @xcite .
a representative example of a 2 ton iron calorimeter @xmath170 long , would see very high event rates ( approximately @xmath171 before cuts and detection efficiencies are included ) .
if background difficulties can be overcome , this option provides an excellent opportunity to study all differential rate distributions with precise statistics . as fig .
[ fmc.q3.il.eps ] shows , the differential cross section quickly decreases with @xmath34 .
however , the decrease is not as fast as in the leptoproduction case . comparing the @xmath34 behavior of formula for the @xmath19 contribution to eq .
( 3 ) in ref . @xcite , we find @xmath172 where @xmath173 is slightly @xmath34-dependent .
we have checked that our curves actually reproduce this relationship with @xmath174 .
the upshot is that the absence of a photon propagator results in a much wider tail of the @xmath34 distribution than in leptoproduction , allowing for better discrimination between @xmath175- and @xmath85-wave contributions .
[ fmc-ring.ratio.1.eps ] shows the ratio of the contributions from these matrix elements as a function of @xmath34 . at low @xmath34 , where the contribution into the cross section is large
, the @xmath19 dominates but a determination of the differential cross section in the range @xmath176 , where the event number is still sizable , would allow a reliable extraction of both @xmath19 and @xmath33 matrix elements .
higher @xmath34 s will only measure a linear combination of these , as the ratio in fig .
[ fmc-ring.ratio.1.eps ] becomes @xmath34-independent .
given the above calculation , it is easy to estimate the production rate of other charmonium states , for instance @xmath68 . using heavy quark symmetry
, it is possible to relate , at leading order in @xmath177 , the leading @xmath63 matrix elements of @xmath68 , @xmath178 to the corresponding @xmath0 matrix elements .
a simple calculation shows , using the data in table [ tab : crs ] with baseline - sized matrix elements , that the @xmath68 yield will be one third of the @xmath0 s .
this fact and the absence of a clear signature will make @xmath68 quite elusive in this experiment .
a similar remark holds for the @xmath41 , whose only contributing matrix element , the @xmath67 level @xmath32 , is related to the @xmath19 matrix elements of the @xmath20 s .
the nomad detector at cern uses the cern sps neutrino beam , mainly designed for detecting neutrino oscillations .
the average neutrino energy is small , @xmath179 , and , even with the huge mass of the detector , the event number is small .
one would expect approximately @xmath180 events per year in the main detector with its fiducial mass of @xmath181 tons .
the situation is somewhat better in the front calorimeter , where such a search is underway , simply because of the larger mass of the detector . with a mass of @xmath182 tons , and the detector characteristics given in ref .
@xcite , the yield becomes @xmath183 , which must be multiplied by the decay ratios and detector efficiencies to find the number of observable events .
given the inaccuracies of our calculation and the crude estimate of the size of the matrix element , it does not seem impossible that several such events would be seen .
another high energy neutrino oscillation experiment has a chance of probing , as a byproduct , our process .
the larger average neutrino energy at the fermilab experiment , compared to cern , results in approximately twenty times larger cross section , compensating for the smaller size of the detector .
the fermilab experiment nutev detected , during its lifetime of one year , about @xmath184 million dis events .
using the numbers in table [ tab : crs ] , this would imply @xmath185 events .
this is again on the verge of observability .
in conclusion we note that an analogous calculation can be done for the @xmath186 system . in that case , however , the @xmath17 suppression of the ratio of the color singlet vs. color octet contributions is compensated by the smallness of the heavy quark velocity .
indeed , we expect @xmath187 ( recall that in @xmath0 leptoproduction the color singlet contribution was suppressed by @xmath188 . ) as a consequence , our tree level calculation is unable to accurately predict the dominant @xmath189 production rate . however , because all numerical factors in the color octet contribution are smaller for the @xmath189 than for the @xmath0 ( including the size of the phase space ) , we can at least exclude the possibility of @xmath189 production at presently running experiments . in order to make a meaningful estimate for the muon collider
, one needs to perform much more involved @xmath28 calculations . to summarize , we have investigated charmonium production at some of the currently running ( nomad and nutev ) and proposed ( first muon collider ) neutrino factories .
we found that the @xmath0 production cross section is dominated by the contribution from the matrix element of the color octet @xmath36 operator , which is not accessible in photo and leptoproduction experiments .
our exploratory study shows that the neutrino beam from the @xmath151 collider can be successfully used to accurately extract the color octet @xmath19 and @xmath33 matrix elements of the @xmath0 .
this measurement is complementary to leptoproduction , where @xmath190 and @xmath191 contribute . in order to achieve an accurate extraction
, however , a detailed investigation is necessary , including the @xmath28 contributions .
a significant deviation of the measured values of the nonperturbative charmonium matrix elements extracted from high energy @xmath192 and @xmath193 experiments could be a sign of intrinsic charm in the proton .
we would like to thank sean fleming , tom mehen and adam falk for useful discussions .
we also acknowledge the help of the experimentalists kai zuber at nomad and todd adams and drew alton at nutev for answering our questions concerning their experiments . this work was supported in part by the united states national science foundation under grant no .
phy-9404057 and no .
phy-9457916 , by the united states department of energy under grant no .
de - fg02 - 94er40869 , and by a grant from the nserc of canada .
bodwin , e. braaten and g.p .
lepage , phys . rev . *
d51 * , 1125 ( 1995 ) , hep - ph/9407339 ; for a recent review see , for example , b. grinstein , a modern introduction to quarkonium theory , " hep - ph/9811264 .
petrov , _ to be published in the proceedings of 3rd international conference in quark confinement and hadron spectrum ( confinement iii ) , newport news , va , 7 - 12 jun 1998 _ , hep - ph/9808347 ; g. chiladze , a.f . falk and a.a .
petrov , phys .
* d58 * , 034013 ( 1998 ) , hep - ph/9804248 .
ryskin , r.g .
roberts , a.d .
martin and e.m .
levin , z. phys .
* c76 * , 231 ( 1997 ) , hep - ph/9511228 ; s.j .
brodsky , l. frankfurt , j.f .
gunion , a.h .
mueller and m. strikman , phys . rev . * d50 * , 3134 ( 1994 ) , hep - ph/9402283 . | at existing and planned neutrino factories ( high energy and high intensity neutrino beam facilities ) precision studies of qcd in neutrino - nucleon interactions are a realistic opportunity .
we investigate charmonium production in fixed target neutrino experiments .
we find that @xmath0 production in neutrino - nucleon collision is dominated by the color octet @xmath1 nrqcd matrix element in a neutral current process , which is not accessible in photo or leptoproduction .
neutrino experiments at a future muon collider will acquire sufficient event rate to accurately measure color octet matrix element contributions . the currently running high energy neutrino experiments nomad and nutev
could also observe several such events . |
the ground state magnetic dipole moment has sensitivity to the orbital and spin components of the state wavefunction , and hence serves as an important observable in the study of nuclear structure .
in particular , the simultaneous consideration of the magnetic dipole moments of mirror nuclei can provide a framework to test present day nuclear structure models .
+ sugimoto @xcite showed that if isospin is a good quantum number , the nuclear magnetic dipole moment could be decomposed into isoscalar and isovector components @xmath3 where the sum of the isoscalar @xmath4 and isovector @xmath5 moments are taken over all nucleons and @xmath6 denotes the expectation value of @xmath7 for the state @xmath8 , where @xmath9 and @xmath10 are the magnetic quantum number and nuclear spin , respectively .
the isoscalar magnetic moment represents the sum of the magnetic moments of the mirror partners @xmath11 here @xmath12 is the total isospin and @xmath13 . the left - hand side of eq
. [ eq2 ] can also be expressed in terms of the isoscalar spin expectation value @xmath0 @xmath14 where @xmath15 and the constant 0.38 is the sum of the magnetic moments of the bare proton and neutron .
the extreme single - particle limit gives @xmath16 for odd-@xmath17 mirror partners whose odd nucleon occupies a single - particle orbital with @xmath18 , where @xmath19 is the orbital angular momentum .
the value @xmath20 $ ] results for the cases when the odd nucleon resides in an orbital with @xmath21 . experimentally deduced @xmath0 values generally fall within single - particle expectations , except for a few instances that are discussed in detail later .
buck and perez @xcite analyzed the magnetic moments of mirror nuclei in a different approach .
they showed that a plot of the gyromagnetic ratio , @xmath22 , of the odd proton member of the mirror pair @xmath1 as a function of the gyromagnetic ratio of the odd neutron member @xmath2 resulted in a straight line .
further scrutiny of this linear dependence of @xmath23 on @xmath24 , provided simple expressions for the slope @xmath25 and intercept @xmath26 : @xmath27 where @xmath28 and @xmath29 are the spin and orbital contributions to the @xmath30-factor , respectively , with @xmath31 for protons and neutrons , respectively .
the extreme single - particle model gives @xmath32 and @xmath33 , while the most recent evaluation of mirror magnetic moments for @xmath34 nuclei by buck , merchant , and perez @xcite produced @xmath35 and @xmath36 .
the small deviation of the experimental moments from the extreme single particle expectation was taken to possibly reflect meson exchange currents and/or small contributions to @xmath37 from the even nucleon @xcite .
ground state magnetic moment measurements of the neutron - deficient nuclei @xmath38c @xcite , @xmath39cl @xcite , @xmath40k @xcite , and @xmath41cu @xcite have been completed at nscl .
the results for the odd-@xmath17 nuclei @xmath40k ( @xmath42 ) and @xmath41cu @xmath43 have significantly extended the evaluation of @xmath0 and @xmath1 vs. @xmath2 to heavier masses . in this paper , the experimental approach to magnetic moment measurements at nscl is described , followed by a summary discussion of the new magnetic moment values for @xmath40k and @xmath41cu and the resulting systematic trends of mirror moments at higher mass numbers .
ground state magnetic moments are measured at nscl using the technique of nuclear magnetic resonance on @xmath26-emitting nuclei ( @xmath26-nmr ) .
nuclei of interest are produced by bombarding a fixed target with intermediate energy projectiles from the nscl coupled cyclotrons .
the incoming beam is made incident on the target at a small angle relative to the normal beam direction to break the reaction plane symmetry and produce a spin - polarized secondary beam of high - velocity ions .
the ion species are mass separated in the a1900 fragment separator @xcite , with the separator tuned to maximize both the purity and transmission of the desired radioactive isotope .
an adjustable slit system located at the a1900 intermediate image is used to select a portion of the momentum distribution of the desired isotopes , which is then transmitted to the @xmath26-nmr endstation .
the production of spin polarized nuclei in intermediate - energy heavy - ion reactions was first demonstrated by asahi _
@xcite , and has been used extensively to measure ground state nuclear moments of short - lived isotopes at riken , ganil , gsi , and msu .
a classical treatment of the mechanism to describe the nuclear polarization in such reactions @xcite considered conservation of linear and angular momentum .
the treatment was extended by okuno _
@xcite to account for varying initial reaction conditions .
although good qualitative agreement with experimental measurements was achieved , the magnitude of the observed polarization was typically a factor of three smaller than predictions .
the extension of ground state magnetic moments of mirror nuclei to heavier masses at nscl was enabled by the establishment of spin polarization in intermediate - energy heavy - ion reactions where a single nucleon is picked up from the target by the fast - moving projectile . the initial measurements of groh _ et al . _
@xcite showed that large , positive spin polarization is obtained near the peak of the momentum distribution for proton pickup reactions .
subsequent systematic measurements by turzo _
@xcite at ganil demonstrated the method for neutron pickup as well . a more accurate prediction of the spin polarization realized in intermediate - energy heavy - ion reactions ,
both for nucleon removal and pickup , has been developed @xcite .
starting with the classical kinematic picture discussed above , a monte carlo simulation that included the addition of a more realistic angular distribution of the outgoing fragments , deorientation caused by @xmath37-ray emission , and corrections for the out - of - reaction plane acceptance , was shown to reproduce , both qualitatively and quantitatively , the polarization observed in intermediate - energy reactions .
the development of an accurate simulation of the spin polarization process significantly aided the execution of the magnetic moment measurements of @xmath40k and @xmath41cu described below .
the @xmath26-nmr system at nscl consists of a small electromagnet , @xmath26 detectors , and a radiofrequency ( rf ) system @xcite .
the room temperature electromagnet has a pole gap of 10 cm and operates at a maximum field of 0.5 t. the @xmath26 detectors consist of two plastic @xmath44 telescopes placed around the sample holder in `` up '' and `` down '' positions relative to the orientation of the magnetic field of the electromagnet .
the thin telescope element is 0.3-cm thick bc400 plastic scintillator of dimensional area 4.4 @xmath45 4.4 cm , while the thick telescope element is also bc400 scintillator with thickness 2.5 cm and area 5.1 @xmath45 5.1 cm .
the scintillators are mounted on bc800 plastic light guides that allow placement of the 12-stage photomultiplier tubes outside the fringing field of the electromagnet .
a vacuum chamber can be placed in the pole gap of the electromagnet between the two @xmath26 detector telescopes .
the part of the vacuum chamber above and below the sample holder has been removed and replaced with thin plastic to reduce the attenuation of @xmath26 particles .
the downstream plate of the vacuum chamber is used to mount the sample holder , rf coils , a beam collimator , and a solid - state si detector for monitoring the secondary beam .
the rf system at nscl was recently upgraded to allow the simultaneous application of multiple frequencies to the sample without significant loss of power @xcite .
the frequency - modulated signal from one of up to six frequency generators can be selected by a double - balanced mixer , amplified to a maximum 250 w , and delivered to a high - power rf box containing a bank of vacuum variable capacitors and an impedance matching element ( either a 50 @xmath46 resistor or multi - turn transformer ) .
these two elements , along with the rf coil surrounding the sample holder , make up an @xmath47 resonance circuit with a resonance @xmath48 factor of @xmath49 .
tuning of the @xmath47 for a given frequency is accomplished by setting the variable capacitors via remote controlled stepper motor units .
any combination of capacitors can be selected by way of fast switching relays . the time sequence for applying each frequency and the corresponding capacitance , as well as any necessary secondary beam pulsing , is controlled by a pulse pattern generator .
the proton separation energy of @xmath40k is only 80 kev based on the 2003 atomic mass evaluation @xcite , and its vicinity to the proton drip line may reveal new and interesting nuclear structure features that may be reflected in the ground state magnetic dipole moment .
the @xmath40k ions were produced starting with a primary beam of @xmath50ar at 150 mev / nucleon via a single proton pickup from a be target followed by two neutron removal .
the @xmath40k production rate was @xmath51 pps / pna of primary beam .
the nmr was scanned between 520 and 620 khz based on a previous measurement @xcite .
a resonance signal was observed at frequency @xmath52 khz , corresponding to a magnetic moment @xmath53 @xcite .
the systematic variation of the ground state magnetic moments of the odd-@xmath17 cu isotopes , where neutrons are filling the @xmath54 shell , are quenched relative to shell model expectations @xcite .
in addition , the level structure @xcite and transition probabilities @xcite give a disparate picture of the robustness of the @xmath55ni double shell closure .
the magnetic moment of the one - proton particle nucleus @xmath41cu is expected to be @xmath56 based on shell models calculations completed in the full @xmath54 shell @xcite .
@xmath41cu ions were produced by impinging a @xmath57ni primary beam of energy 140 mev / nucleon on a be target .
the single - proton pickup reaction and subsequent two neutron removal resulted in a @xmath41cu production rate of @xmath58 pps / pna of primary beam .
a broad nmr scan was completed between 1400 and 2800 khz , and a resonance signal was observed at @xmath59 khz .
the deduced magnetic moment value @xmath60 @xcite was nearly 20% smaller than shell model expectations .
the new ground state magnetic moments of @xmath40k and @xmath41cu dramatically extend the mass range of known mirror partners for @xmath34 and @xmath42 systems . the systematic trend in @xmath0 for odd-@xmath17 mirror nuclei
is depicted in fig .
data are taken from ref .
@xcite with the exception of @xmath40k and @xmath41cu discussed here and @xmath61al @xcite and @xmath62ni @xcite , for which signs of @xmath7 are taken from theoretical predictions .
nearly all @xmath0 values are bounded by the extreme single - particle limits , including the new value @xmath63 deduced for the @xmath64 mirror partners , which includes @xmath40k and @xmath40s .
it was surprising that the @xmath65 system followed the trends established by more well - bounded nuclei , given that @xmath40k exhibits such a small proton binding energy .
the two mirror systems whose @xmath0 value lies outside the extreme single - particle expectation are those with @xmath66 and @xmath67 .
the former disparity has been linked to possible proton intruder configurations in the ground state wavefunction of @xmath38c @xcite .
the later has been attributed to a breaking of the @xmath55ni double - magic core @xcite .
while the linear behavior of @xmath23 vs. @xmath24 was demonstrated for @xmath34 nuclei , no such analysis had been performed for @xmath42 nuclei due to the limited experimental data for magnetic moments of @xmath68 nuclei near the proton drip line .
there are now five @xmath42 mirror pairs whose ground state magnetic moments are known , including the @xmath69 system discussed here .
the @xmath1 vs. @xmath2 plots for the @xmath34 and @xmath42 mirror nuclei are presented in fig .
[ fig2 ] . a linear fit for all @xmath42 data shown in fig .
[ fig2 ] results in slope @xmath70 and intercept @xmath71 .
the linear trend in @xmath1 vs. @xmath2 for the @xmath42 mirror moments follows that already noted for the @xmath34 data .
in addition , the deduced @xmath25 and @xmath26 values for the @xmath42 partners agree within errors of the values obtain by buck _
@xcite for the @xmath34 mirror pairs .
recently , perez _ et al .
_ @xcite extended the treatment of the linear behavior of mirror magnetic moments by using shell model estimates to make small modifications to @xmath1 and @xmath2 .
the inclusion of contributions of total spin and angular momentum from both odd and even nucleon types improved the fit to the linear correlations between gryomagnetic ratios of mirror partners , and demonstrated the consistent treatment of @xmath1 vs. @xmath2 for both @xmath34 and @xmath42 mirror pairs .
we note that the two mirror systems at @xmath72 and @xmath67 that show anomalous behavior in @xmath0 as shown in fig .
[ fig1 ] follow the linear correlation in @xmath1 vs. @xmath2 demonstrated for other known mirror partners .
the slope @xmath25 in the buck - perez relation represents a ratio of the neutron and proton spin and orbital @xmath30-factors , effectively canceling any systematic spin dependence from the mirror partners , as opposed to relation for @xmath0 , which will amplify such spin effects . the underlying case for the disparate behavior of the @xmath72 and @xmath73 mirror moments may lie in the spin contribution from low-@xmath19 proton orbitals that comprise some part of the ground state wavefunction of the @xmath74 nucleus
we plan to continue our efforts to extend the measurements of known ground state magnetic moments to heavier nuclei . to this end
, we are developing a new laser polarizer beam line @xcite that will receive short - lived , low - energy rare isotope beams from the gas catcher system at nscl .
this new experimental set up will be operational in 2011 and will enable @xmath26-nmr measurements on refractory elements currently inaccessible at isol facilities , where collinear laser spectroscopy and laser polarization measurements have been a staple for many years .
the experimental program on magnetic moments at nscl has benefitted over the years from contributions by t.j .
mertzimekis , a.e .
stuchbery , d.e .
groh , a.d .
davies , m.huhta , j.s .
berryman , h.l .
crawford , r.r .
weerasiri , j.b .
stoker , w.f .
rogers , g. georgiev , d.a .
anthony , and m. hass .
this work was supported in part by the u.s .
national science foundation grant phy-06 - 06007 . | progress in the measurement of the ground state magnetic moments of mirror nuclei at nscl is presented .
the systematic trend of the spin expectation value @xmath0 and the linear behavior of @xmath1 versus @xmath2 , both extracted from the magnetic moments of mirror partners , are updated to include all available data . |
the rise of magnetic flux from the deep levels of the solar convection zone to the photosphere is a complex phenomenon involving many different magnetic and hydrodynamical processes .
particular attention has been devoted in the past @xmath5 years to the time - evolution of a single buoyant magnetic flux tube considered as a one - dimensional object ( @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite .
further references and a recent review can be found in the paper by @xcite ) .
these calculations incorporate several aspects of the basic physics of the rise of the magnetic tubes ( buoyancy , magnetic and rotational forces , external stratification , etc ) .
they have been successful in predicting morphological and kinematic features of the resulting active regions which are observed at the surface of the sun . yet , the assumption of one - dimensionality of the magnetic region is certainly a drastic simplification . from laboratory and numerical experiments in different contexts we know of the complicated hydrodynamical and magnetic structure within and outside a tubular object which is moving with respect to the surrounding fluid .
the one - dimensional numerical models mentioned above , in particular , do not contain two ingredients which turn out to be fundamental in studying the rise of buoyant magnetized plasma regions , to wit , the vorticity of the velocity field and the twist of the field lines around the main axis of the tube .
vorticity and transverse field components may be crucial for the formation of the tubes in the first place ( @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) .
they also play a central role in the time evolution of the rising magnetic region .
a clear warning in this sense came from the work of schssler ( 1979 ) , who showed how the cross section of a straight , buoyant magnetic tube initially with the same temperature of its surroundings develops an _ umbrella _ shape ( two side lobes connected on their upper side by an arch ) .
the side lobes rotate in opposite directions around a horizontal axis , each thus constituting a vortex tube ; they finally detach from each other and from the arch above them .
the whole process occurs at the beginning of the rise , namely before the tube has risen across a height equivalent to a few times its own diameter .
the physics involved has been considered in detail by longcope , fisher & arendt ( 1996 ) .
these authors have studied the boussinesq problem , including untwisted and very weakly twisted magnetic tubes .
they clearly show how the two rotating side lobes , when detached from the rest , are subjected to a downward - pointing lift force , as a result of their flow being non - circulation free .
the lift ends up cancelling the buoyancy force , this being the reason for their horizontal asymptotic motion .
if this were a universal mechanism operating on all rising magnetic flux tubes , then magnetic buoyancy should no longer be considered an efficient mechanism to bring magnetic flux to the photosphere . in the present paper we consider in detail the more general case of a buoyant magnetic flux tube with an arbitrary initial twist of the field lines ( but still horizontal and with uniform values of all variables along the direction of the axis ) .
the transverse magnetic field ( i.e. , the component of the field vector normal to the tube axis ) imparts a certain rigidity to the tube cross section .
if strong enough , it can prevent the conversion of the tube into a vortex tube pair .
the minimum amount of twist necessary for that corresponds to an average pitch angle of order @xmath6 the external pressure scaleheight , and @xmath7 the density difference between tube and surroundings ( see [ sec_tube_unity ] ) .
this approximate criterion is indeed fulfilled by magnetic tubes with the classical parker magnetic buoyancy , as shown in a preliminary presentation of this paper ( @xcite ) . in the present article ,
we explore in more detail the physics involved in that process , discussing a number of ( m)hd processes occurring inside the tube , in the boundary layer at its periphery and in the trailing wake .
we also show how the results of schssler ( 1979 ) and longcope ( 1996 ) can be seen as the limiting case in which the trailing wake in fact engulfs most of the original rising tube .
the pitch angle just mentioned thus signals the borderline between the weak and strong twist regimes : a buoyant tube with an initial twist above that level rises without being strongly deformed and is followed by a wake containing only a small fraction of the initial total magnetic flux .
additionally to the work of moreno - insertis & emonet ( 1996 ) , there is another paper in the recent literature dealing with a related subject ( cargill et al .
the authors have studied the interaction of a twisted tube with a magnetized medium in the absence of gravity when the tube is subjected to an ad - hoc , spatially uniform acceleration .
special emphasis was put on the reconnection of the ambient magnetic field with the tube s own one .
buoyancy , stratification , or different degrees of twist were not studied in that paper .
two further papers , submitted simultaneously with the present one , deal with the rise of buoyant twisted magnetic tubes ( @xcite ; hughes , falle & joarder , 1998 ) .
the first authors , in particular , study the interaction between tubes rising in pairs .
the results of both papers concerning the rise of single tubes are in general agreement with those of moreno - insertis & emonet ( 1996 ) .
the layout of the paper is as follows . after a brief presentation of the equations and the numerical procedure in [ sec_equations ] , the basic features of the physical problem are considered ( [ sec_parameters ] ) .
this includes the main parameters and a discussion of the amount of twist necessary to prevent the deformation of the tube and its conversion into vortex rolls . in [ sec_rise ] , the simulation of the rise of a tube with that amount of twist is presented .
in particular , the initial acceleration phase , the internal torsional oscillations and the later asymptotic phase are discussed .
section [ sec_interface ] deals with the structure of the magnetic boundary layer around the tube , and [ sec_wake ] examines the trailing wake .
finally , the transition between the twisted and untwisted case is explained in [ sec_split ] .
a general discussion follows in [ sec_discussion ] .
our medium is an ideal compressible and stratified gas governed by the general equations of the magnetohydrodynamics ( mhd ) including ohmic diffusion : @xmath8 with @xmath9 the internal energy per unit mass and @xmath10 the ohmic diffusivity , which is assumed constant .
all other symbols have their customary meaning .
cartesian coordinates @xmath11 are adopted so that the @xmath12-direction is anti - parallel to @xmath13 . in this paper
we consider a two - dimensional problem : we assume that there are no variations of the physical variables along the @xmath14-axis ( @xmath15 ) , although @xmath16 and @xmath17 are generally non zero . equations ( [ eq_continuity])([eq_energy ] ) are cast in their conservative form and solved with a code written by @xcite .
the latter is based on a modified lax - wendroff scheme ( @xcite ) and stabilized with artificial viscosity as described by richtmyer & morton ( 1967 ) .
the inclusion of physical resistivity in our equations and the absence of any shock phenomena in the solutions permit us to minimize the use of the artificial viscosity .
the latter is restricted , in any case , to regions of very steep gradients only .
this code has been repeatedly tested and used for two - dimensional simulations of the outbreak of the magnetic field at the surface of the sun by shibata and collaborators ( see e.g. @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) .
in addition , we have successfully run several tests for our problem , checking for the convergence of the code as well as for the conservation of mass , energy and magnetic flux in the box . in this paper
, we only consider a case with left - right symmetry about a vertical plane containing the tube axis .
for each half of the tube we use a numerical grid of 300 points in the horizontal direction and 700 points in the vertical one ( although in the figures presented here , only a small fraction of the box is shown ) . in the following
, the results are given in dimensionless form , using as units the background density , pressure scaleheight and alfvn speed calculated at the center of the tube at time @xmath18 .
the initial condition consists of an unperturbed background atmosphere , with pressure @xmath19 and density @xmath20 , and , superimposed , a perturbation associated with a magnetic flux tube . to avoid any confusion due to pseudo - convective effects , the background atmosphere is adiabatically stratified .
it spans vertically @xmath21 of the pressure scaleheight at the bottom of the box .
the pressure contrast between the top and bottom is @xmath22 .
the density contrast is @xmath23 .
after inclusion of the magnetic tube , the resulting system satisfies the following simple condition : @xmath24 , with @xmath25 the pressure excess as compared with the background stratification , @xmath26 the electric current density and @xmath27 the speed of light . in the absence of gravity , this would be a perfect equilibrium condition . the density profile in the magnetic region is determined by assuming that the entropy in the tube is constant and equal to the unperturbed value in the atmosphere .
the tube at time @xmath18 is thus buoyant ( @xmath28 ) and fulfills @xmath29 to first order in @xmath1 , with @xmath30 the specific heat ratio .
this case is intermediate between the two extreme possibilities of full thermal equilibrium , i.e. , @xmath31 ( which would be a factor @xmath30 more buoyant ) and the case of a tube with @xmath32 .
the evolution presented here is qualitatively very similar to the first case , whereas it deviates in important respects from the second . along this paper
we will deal with a number of different magnetic field profiles at time @xmath18 .
the longitudinal field @xmath33 will be taken to have a gaussian profile , @xmath34 the transverse field @xmath35 is chosen to be purely azimuthal ; calling @xmath36 and @xmath37 the polar coordinates around the tube center , we have @xmath38 . for @xmath39
, we will choose distributions such that the pitch angle @xmath40 , @xmath41 adopts an asymptotically flat profile : @xmath42 or , alternatively , an exponentially decaying one : @xmath43 the choice of @xmath44 determines the _ rigidity _ of the tube center . in this paper
we consider the case @xmath45 and @xmath46 . as we will see , both profiles ( [ eq_pitchassympt ] ) and ( [ eq_pitchgauss ] ) yield basically the same time evolution ( [ sec_shearflow ] ) .
as explained in the discussion , we have also run some tests with flat , top - hat magnetic profiles ( [ sec_adeq_param_distr ] ) .
the side and bottom boundaries are closed lids .
a closed boundary at the top of the box must be avoided for two reasons : ( 1 ) the sound waves generated by the tube in the external medium must be able to leave the box and ( 2 ) the rise of the tube should not be unduly braked through the excess pressure at a closed boundary at the top .
an ideal _ free _ boundary should be transparent for the outgoing disturbances and should not introduce disturbances through incoming waves . in the present calculations we achieve this by introducing a _ fiducial layer _ ( @xcite ) well above the upper boundary of the box . at each time step , the pressure in the fiducial layer is calculated by assuming that each point in it is in static equilibrium with respect to the point on the boundary of the box lying directly below it ; the densities are then obtained via the constant background entropy ; the velocity is set to zero in the fiducial layer . the net mass flux across the boundary
is not necessarily zero .
however , the total mass of the box only varies by a maximum factor of @xmath47 during each single run .
the present physical problem is characterized by four basic dimensionless input parameters : ( 1 ) the thickness of the tube in units of the local pressure scale height , @xmath48 ; ( 2 ) the plasma beta at the center of the tube , @xmath49 ; ( 3 ) the ratio between the transverse and the longitudinal component of the field , as measured by , e.g. , the pitch angle at a representative position of the tube , @xmath50 , to be specified in the following ; ( 4 ) the ohmic diffusivity @xmath10 in terms of , e.g. , @xmath51 , with @xmath52 the alfvn speed : @xmath53 .
these parameters determine the properties of the initial magnetic tube and are independent of the velocity of the flow that develops along time .
however , in this problem there is a characteristic value for the flow velocity , namely the terminal speed of rise , @xmath54 , given by the dynamical equilibrium between buoyancy and aerodynamic drag : @xmath55 with @xmath56 the customary drag coefficient , @xmath57 , and @xmath58 the sound speed .
hence , the customary velocity - related parameters , like , e.g. , the mach number , the reynolds number and the magnetic weber number , can be immediately obtained as a function of the foregoing input parameters . for instance , using equation ( [ eq_drho0 ] ) we obtain that the mach number must be of order : @xmath59 . as a result
, we expect the rise to be very subsonic and , assuming @xmath60 , sub - alfvenic as well .
this latter condition can be violated for tubes rising to higher levels of the convection zone .
the rest of this section is devoted to a discussion of the values expected for the most important parameters of this problem .
the central parameter for the present paper is the twist of the tube as measured by the pitch angle of the field lines , @xmath40 .
the values of this parameter of interest for our calculation are those for which the transverse component of the field , @xmath61 , is able to suppress the conversion of the tube into a pair of vortex rolls . in the following
we study different agents that tend to deform the tube .
we come to the conclusion that the minimum value of @xmath62 necessary to counteract them is the same for all .
the tube of the initial condition explained in [ sec_inicond ] is increasingly buoyant toward its center .
thus , the central regions rise faster than the periphery ; the upper layers of the tube are thereby compressed whereas those located below the center are expanded .
the magnetic field lines are deformed by this process ; the transverse field , in particular , exerts an increasing resistance against further deformation .
one can calculate the minimum transverse field that can effectively withstand ( and reverse ) the buoyant deformation ( @xcite ) . at this point
, it is sufficient to obtain an order of magnitude estimate for it that can serve as a guide for the rest of the paper .
this can be easily done for tubes with smooth distributions like ( [ eq_blong ] ) and ( [ eq_pitchassympt ] ) or ( [ eq_pitchgauss ] ) and satisfying @xmath63 .
the resulting criterion is best expressed in terms of the pitch angle calculated at the position _ of the maximum of the transverse field _
, @xmath50 ; it reads : @xmath64 for the tubes with initial condition [ sec_inicond ] , this approximate criterion should hold within about a factor @xmath65 . a more precise condition involving the detailed buoyancy distribution in the tube
can be obtained by studying the magnetostatic equilibrium of a horizontal twisted tube with a non - homogeneous buoyancy distribution in the limit @xmath63 ( @xcite ) .
it can be shown ( see their eqs . 44 and 49 )
that for the deformation of the tube to remain small , the radial profile of the pitch angle , @xmath66 , must satisfy : @xmath67 where @xmath68 is the radial average of @xmath69 between the radii @xmath70 and @xmath36 . at each radius @xmath36 , the deformation of the magnetic field is directly related to @xmath71 , i.e. , to the _ differential buoyancy _ at that radius . the threshold due to the differential buoyancy ( eq . [ eq_min_pitch ] or [ eq_analytic_paper ] ) , however , can not be the only criterion of interest for our problem .
in fact , even a uniformly buoyant tube , if untwisted , is subjected to a deformation and conversion into vortex rolls .
a deforming agent independent of the initial differential buoyancy is the pressure profile ( i.e. , the pressure fluctuations , @xmath72 , above the background stratification ) built by the external flow around the boundary of the tube ( @xcite ) : a simple criterion for the resistance of the tube against those fluctuations is @xmath73 now , @xmath72 is itself of order the ram pressure of the external flow relative to the tube .
thus , it is no higher than about @xmath74 . substituting from eq .
( [ eq_term_speed_order ] ) , we obtain again a criterion as in ( [ eq_min_pitch ] ) .
given the central role of the vorticity in the present problem , it is adequate to understand the minimum condition ( [ eq_min_pitch ] ) in terms of the vorticity generation .
the time evolution of the longitudinal component of the vorticity , @xmath75 , is governed by the following equation : @xmath76\;. \label{eq_vort}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath77 represents the projection of the lorentz force on the transverse plane @xmath78 . for definiteness ,
when speaking about the sign of the vorticity in the rest of this section , we refer to the right half of the tube only . at issue in this section
is the generation of vorticity in the main body of the tube ( the vorticity in the tube periphery is discussed in [ sec_vorticity_generation ] ) .
the first term on the right hand - side is the counterpart in terms of vorticity of the gravitational torque : it produces _ positive _ vorticity because @xmath79 points outwards .
the second term on the right - hand side of ( [ eq_vort ] ) represents the effect of @xmath61 and can be rewritten as : @xmath80 with @xmath81 the longitudinal component of the electric current density . at the beginning of the run ,
the longitudinal current is axisymmetric so that @xmath82 is zero .
as soon as the tube center begins to rise relative to the periphery , the longitudinal current is enhanced in the upper half and diminishes in the lower half of the tube . according to eq .
( [ eq_vort_mag ] ) , this produces _ negative _ vorticity in the interior of the tube , i.e. , it tends to counteract the effect of the gravitational torque . by setting these two terms equal
, we obtain a criterion for the minimum transverse magnetic field that can effectively oppose the initial deformation of the tube : the result is , again , ( [ eq_min_pitch ] ) . for the problem we are considering here , the last term of the vorticity equation ( [ eq_vort ] ) is o(@xmath83 ) smaller than the other two terms and is therefore not of primary interest here ( @xmath84 represents a local characteristic length for the transverse magnetic field , e.g. , the radius of the tube or the thickness of the tube boundary ) . criteria equivalent to ( [ eq_min_pitch ] ) can also be obtained through other physical considerations .
for instance , tsinganos ( 1980 ) obtained a similar threshold for @xmath40 by calculating the stability of the tube against splitting due to the development of rayleigh - taylor and kelvin - helmholtz instabilities at its apex .
the choice of values for the parameters @xmath49 and @xmath85 must be guided both by ( astro)physical insight and feasibility of the numerical calculation .
@xmath49 is expected to be very high in the solar interior , like , e.g. , o(@xmath86 ) for the magnetic tubes at the bottom of the convection zone .
the courant condition for the numerical code , though , sets a stringent upper limit to the value of @xmath49 that we can use . using expression ( [ eq_term_speed_order ] )
we can calculate the number of timesteps necessary for our tube to cross the whole integration box , @xmath87 , as @xmath88 with @xmath89 the total number of cells in the vertical direction .
a trade - off between field intensity and magnetic flux of the tube is then necessary . as a compromise we have chosen @xmath90 and @xmath91
this should be sufficient to understand qualitatively the flows in and around the tubes with the field strength and flux expected in the progenitors of active regions .
the magnetic reynolds number can be defined in this problem in terms of the terminal speed of rise and the tube radius .
its order of magnitude is thus given by @xmath93 .
the choice of a value for this parameter must be guided primarily by numerical criteria : large magnetic field gradients develop in the tube along the evolution , specially at its upper rim .
we have chosen the ohmic diffusivity so that the resulting value of @xmath94 is a few times @xmath95 .
this yields good numerical performance but causes some unwanted diffusion of the field outward from the tube .
a measure for the latter can be obtained from the @xmath14-component of walen s equation , obtained by combining the continuity and induction equations , ( [ eq_continuity ] ) and ( [ eq_induction ] ) : @xmath96 in the central region of the tube , the variation in @xmath97 is basically due to diffusion .
the calculations presented in the following are not diffusion dominated ( as expected from the high @xmath94 ) , in the sense that the decrease of this quantity is small in the tube center during the period of time shown in the figures .
this can also be checked through an order of magnitude estimate : the diffusion term in ( [ eq_walen ] ) for the initial gaussian distribution can be compared to the rate of change of the field ( left - hand side of the same equation ) imposed by the rise of the tube .
the ratio between them is @xmath98 , which is o(@xmath99 ) in the present case . in the hydrodynamical literature on air bubbles
, the weber number is used to measure the relative importance of the inertial forces of the flow to the surface tension at the boundary of the bubble ( e.g. @xcite ) .
the role of surface tension is played in our case by the jump in magnetic tension of the transverse component at the boundary of the tube .
hence we define the magnetic weber number as @xmath101 inserting for @xmath102 the terminal speed we easily obtain @xmath103 .
the condition on the minimum pitch angle to avoid the splitting of the tube , ( [ eq_min_pitch ] ) , can thus be reformulated as the condition that the _ weber number be at most of order one _ , .
the critical value of the pitch angle parameter @xmath50 obtained by substituting in ( [ eq_min_pitch ] ) the chosen values of @xmath49 , @xmath85 and @xmath105 is @xmath106 . in the present section
we describe some major features of the rise of a tube with a pitch angle @xmath50 close to that value , @xmath104 .
the time evolution is illustrated in fig .
[ fig_rise ] , which shows a fraction of the integration box used ( @xmath107 and @xmath108 of the box in the horizontal and vertical directions , respectively ) . in [ sec_split ]
we compare the results for flux tubes with different values of the initial @xmath50 . in the absence of external flows to keep it in place , the tube lacks equilibrium globally and starts rising , at the same time sending out sound waves all across the box .
the initial global acceleration is basically _ free - fall _ ,
i.e. , @xmath109 , with an overbar indicating average values in the tube and @xmath110 standing for the enhanced inertia factor , which turns out to be @xmath65 ( see [ sec_term_velo ] ) . superimposed on the global rise , different kinds of motions within and around the tube take place which tend to deform its initial axisymmetric shape ( fig .
[ fig_rise ] , upper row ) .
one of them is the faster rise of the tube center compared with the periphery due to the differential buoyancy ( [ sec_diff_buoy_pres_fluct ] ) . as a consequence of this
, the magnetic tension associated with the transverse field builds up at the tube front ; the relative motion of the tube center is thus stopped and reversed .
a vertical oscillation of the tube center ensues within the tube s cross section .
the compression / expansion in the upper / lower half of the tube together with the internal oscillations are clearly visible in fig .
[ fig_lm_center ] , where we have plotted the position as a function of time of several lagrange markers located along the vertical symmetry axis of the tube .
simultaneously with the processes just explained , the external matter slides around the tube and _ drags _ toward the rear the outermost tube layers where the magnetic field is too weak to oppose any important lorentz force . the field is thus stretched all along the boundary ( [ sec_interface ] ) .
vorticity is being generated in the matter being dragged : as a result , two magnetized vortex rolls are created that trail the tube motion ( fig .
[ fig_rise ] , third panel ) .
the main body of the tube thereby loses about @xmath107 of its original magnetic flux .
this figure sensitively depends on the initial pitch angle ( [ sec_split ] ) .
given the sign of the vorticity , the matter between the rolls is moving upwards with respect to the back of the tube .
a pressure excess appears at the upper end of the inter - vortex space , directly below the lowermost tube layers .
the vertical oscillations of the tube center are in fact part of a torsional oscillation in which most of the tube interior is taking part ( fig .
[ fig_torsional_oscill ] ) .
the torsional oscillation has left - right symmetry : each tube half is rotating back and forth around a horizontal axis offset by a fraction of @xmath111 from the midplane .
the energy of this oscillation is being radiated away from the tube via pressure forces ; it is also damped through the diffusion ( physical and numerical ) present in the code .
thus it slowly decreases in amplitude .
the frequency of these oscillations is of order @xmath112 $ ] .
hence , one expects a few torsional oscillations to be completed while the tube is rising across a scaleheight . the strong initial acceleration phase is followed by a quasi - stationary asymptotic regime ( fig .
[ fig_rise ] , lower row ) . in it ,
the rate of change of the tube interior and external flows becomes small compared with the initial phases .
the transition occurs at about @xmath113 ( between the third and fourth panels of fig .
[ fig_rise ] ) .
the asymptotic regime is characterized by the adoption of a terminal speed of rise , a sharp separation of tube interior and surroundings and a well - developed trailing wake .
simultaneously , the tube stops losing magnetic flux to the wake and there is no further important deformation of the magnetic field lines in the head of the tube .
the following subsections deal with some of the features characterizing this asymptotic regime .
once the wake is developed , the resistance of the surroundings to the advance of the tube can be calculated using the customary aerodynamic drag force with almost constant drag coefficient @xmath56 . in the asymptotic regime ,
the total buoyancy of the tube is a slowly varying quantity .
thus we can expect the tube to reach a terminal speed of rise given by : @xmath114 @xmath115 and @xmath116 being the cross sectional area and horizontal diameter , respectively .
the order of magnitude of this speed was estimated in eq .
( [ eq_term_speed_order ] ) .
the best fit to the numerical results yields a value of @xmath117 of approximately @xmath118 .
the approach to this asymptotic regime is not immediate to formulate analytically , since the coefficient @xmath56 is not constant while the tube is changing its shape and developing a wake .
the initial acceleration of the tube as a whole is @xmath119 the factor @xmath110 allows for the added inertia due to the co - acceleration of the external medium ( @xmath120 for a rigid straight cylinder ) . to approximate the velocity of the tube in the initial and intermediate time - dependent phases , we use the expression for a tube which starts from rest with acceleration @xmath121 , is being acted upon by a constant driving force and has fixed @xmath56 , viz . :
a constant driving force and has fixed @xmath56 , viz . : @xmath122 with @xmath54 still given by eq . ( [ eq_term_speed_exact ] ) .
the numerical results show a surprising closeness to eq .
( [ eq_velocity ] ) . in fig .
[ fig_velocity ] , we show with a dotted line the velocity given by eq .
( [ eq_velocity ] ) , while the actual speed of the tube apex , @xmath123 , is indicated as circles . as can be seen , the tube speed _ oscillates _ around the mean speed given by eq .
( [ eq_velocity ] ) .
this is due to the strong oscillations of the tube interior : in fact , the tube center oscillates with a much larger amplitude , as is shown by the curve with asterisks .
the tube center _ pushes _ the apex , so that circles and asterisks are slightly out of phase .
the amplitude of the oscillation diminishes as its energy is being radiated to the external medium and both curves converge toward the dotted line .
the initial acceleration of the tube apex is very close to ( [ eq_accel_vterm ] ) with @xmath120 , i.e. , as corresponds to the global buo- 8.5 cm yancy of the tube .
the tube center , in turn , has a higher acceleration , corresponding to the local value of the buoyancy , namely @xmath124 ( this value is shown in the figure as a dashed line ) . here again , the enhanced inertia factor @xmath110 must be set equal @xmath65 . as a test to the validity of the terminal velocity formula ,
we have calculated the evolution of tubes starting with the same initial condition as the one used to obtain fig .
[ fig_velocity ] ( in particular , the same tube radius , @xmath111 ) but with @xmath49 chosen in a range between @xmath125 and @xmath126 .
the velocity curves of all these tubes are similar to those shown in fig .
[ fig_velocity ] , with the time scale contracted by a factor @xmath127 and the velocity scale enlarged by the same factor .
more precisely , if all these tubes reach the aerodynamic drag regime with terminal velocity given by eq .
( [ eq_term_speed_exact ] ) , then the curves depicting the velocity of the apex normalized by the plasma beta , @xmath128 , versus the position of the apex must all basically coincide ( the drag coefficient @xmath56 does not change much with varying reynolds number in this regime ) .
the results of the tests show indeed a large degree of superposition of those curves : the maximum relative deviation between them is a factor @xmath129 , which can be attributed to the change in @xmath56 consequent with the variation in the reynolds number . as a result of the resistance to deformation provided by the transverse field
, there is a neat separation between the tube interior and the outside in the asymptotic regime .
a good indicator of the location of the tube boundary can be obtained by comparing the kinetic energy density of the relative flow field , @xmath130 , viz .
@xmath131 , with the energy density of the transverse magnetic field , @xmath132 .
we define the _ equipartition line _ as the locus of those points in the tube periphery where the two energy densities are equal .
[ fig_equipartition_line ] shows , at time @xmath133 , the relative flow field @xmath134 and , superimposed on it , the equipartition line .
the flow field changes markedly when going across the equipartition line : the velocities inside are much smaller than outside it .
in other words , once the terminal velocity has been reached the tube rises basically as a unity , with only a weak internal flow pattern corresponding mainly to the torsional oscillations described in the previous section . a comparison of fig
. [ fig_equipartition_line ] with the results of laboratory experiments ( e.g. , @xcite or plate 15 in @xcite ) , shows that there are striking similarities between buoyant magnetic tubes and air bubbles rising in a liquid , both in the shape of the rising object itself as in the wake , in spite of the very different parameter values involved ( like , e.g. , the density deficit ) .
all along the initial phase , a pressure profile is set up around the tube periphery which closely resembles the pressure distribution around rigid cylinders in relative motion with the surroundings . to show this , we can plot ( fig .
[ fig_bound_press ] ) the pressure in the points along the equipartition line . in this figure ,
the pressure excess associated with the return flow between the vortex rolls of the wake is clearly visible .
all around the equipartition line there is a region with non - zero vorticity .
this contains ( 1 ) a boundary layer surrounding the tube and ( 2 ) the trailing wake.further out , there is the external medium with a largely vorticity - free flow . in this section
we study the structure of the boundary layer ; the wake is considered in [ sec_wake ] .
the two main physical features characterizing the magnetic boundary layer around the tube are a strong shear of the tangential flow and high magnetic field gradients .
they lead to enhanced generation of vorticity , ohmic diffusion and generation of entropy . in the following subsections we study these items in turn :
a pronounced shear is taking place in a thin band around the equipartition line ( fig .
[ fig_equipartition_line ] ) . as a result
, the matter elements and the transverse field are being stretched at the tube periphery all around the tube . to visualize this phenomenon , we use _ lagrange markers _ which follow the motion of the tube s mass elements ( fig . [ fig_lagrange ] ) .
we choose six groups of markers at time @xmath18 ( left panel ) , at a distance of the tube center such that @xmath135 is @xmath136% ( white asterisks ) , @xmath137% ( black triangles ) and @xmath138% ( black diamonds ) , respectively , of @xmath139 ( the maximum value of @xmath135 in the tube ) both in the upper and lower half of the tube .
the markers are set in the neighborhood of the tube axis and are left to evolve with the tube . as time advances , the markers of the outermost group in the upper tube half are stretched by a very large factor along the tube periphery ( center and right panel of the figure ) ; in fact , many of them are brought all the way down to the wake .
the markers of the group immediately below them ( triangles ) are brought close to the uppermost group and stretched , albeit by a smaller factor than the other group .
large compression and stretching happen basically only in the neighborhood of the interface between tube and surroundings : closer to the tube center ( diamonds ) the mass elements are just periodically moved following the internal torsional oscillation . at the rear of the tube ,
the lagrange markers with @xmath140 ( triangles ) are also somewhat stretched by the flow of the trailing wake ( see [ sec_wake ] ) .
the outermost parcels at the back of the tube ( white asterisks ) are trapped in the tail and no longer rise with the tube .
0.45 corresponding to this shearing , the pitch angle increases to large values at the tube periphery : in fig .
[ fig_pitch_angle ] we plot the pitch angle distribution along the vertical axis of symmetry for the three instants shown in fig .
[ fig_lagrange ] .
the pitch angle becomes large in the interface at the tube front ( middle panel ) . in the quasi - stationary regime
, its distribution shows a horizontal asymptote outside the tube similar to the one of the initial condition .
this feature is _ not _ a mere consequence of our initial condition ( [ eq_pitchassympt ] ) .
in fact , an initial pitch angle distribution with exponential decline for large radius at time @xmath18 ( see eq .
[ eq_pitchgauss ] ) yields in the quasi - stationary regime a horizontal asymptote similar to the one of fig .
[ fig_pitch_angle ] .
it is then perhaps more natural to choose the initial condition of eq .
( [ eq_pitchassympt ] ) from the outset .
the large pitch angles apparent on the right of fig .
[ fig_pitch_angle ] are all in a region of the tube where the magnetic field intensity is very low ; the central regions , on the other hand , have low pitch angles .
thus , one should not expect a global kink - unstable behavior of the tube .
this can be checked by calculating the net tension in the tube over background ( see 9.2 in @xcite ) . with the convention that tension is positive and pressure negative ,
we obtain a positive value indicating that the tube is under longitudinal tension rather than compression .
thus , there should be no tendency to buckling of the tube .
the large jump in tangential speed visible across the equipartition line in fig .
[ fig_equipartition_line ] marks the presence of a _ vortex sheet _ surrounding the tube .
in fact , vort- 12.2truecm icity ( more precisely , its longitudinal component @xmath141 ) is generated at the boundary layer during the whole duration of the run .
from there , it is advected toward the wake .
these processes are governed by eq .
( [ eq_vort ] ) . as in [ sec_tube_unity ] , the right - hand side is dominated by the first two terms [ the third is again o(@xmath142 ) smaller ] .
however , along the front of the tube those two terms , i.e. , the gravitational and magnetic vorticity sources , _ reinforce each other _ rather than mutually cancel , as in the tube interior .
this is because the radial derivative of the transverse field component reverses its sign in the neighborhood of the equipartition line .
for instance , in the simple case in which the field lines are still not far from circular ( e.g. , along the front ) the magnetic contribution is approximately , @xmath143}_{\cong\jlong}\;,\ ] ] so that @xmath144 changes sign at about the maximum of @xmath62 . as a result , ( and taking into account the sign of the azimuthal derivative @xmath145 ) , in the right half of the tube positive vorticity
is generated all along the front of the tube , and negative vorticity is generated at the rear , i.e. , at the interface between the tube and the wake . at the rear
@xmath79 is approximately parallel to @xmath13 and therefore the magnetic stress is anyway the main source of vorticity there . in fig .
[ fig_vorticity_halo ] we show the distribution of vorticity in the box at four different times during the evolution .
white and black indicate positive and negative vorticity , respectively ( i.e. , clockwise and anticlockwise rotation ) , whereas the grey background is the zero vorticity level .
soon after the beginning ( leftmost panel ; @xmath146 ) the gravitational torque is creating positive and negative vorticity in the right and left tube halves , respectively , across the whole tube interior . in the second panel ( @xmath147 ) , this has already been countered by the magnetic tension of the transverse field : the reversal of the sign of the vorticity in the interior reveals the first backward torsional oscillation .
additionally , a vortex sheet is already apparent all around the tube front . at the rear
, there is only an incipient wake and no clear vortex sheet yet .
the third and fourth panels correspond to the asymptotic phase ( @xmath133 , i.e. , close to the beginning of the stationary regime , and at an advanced stage , @xmath148 , respectively ) .
vorticity generation now occurs basically close to the equipartition line only .
vortex sheets along _ both _ the front and the rear of the head of the tube are visible . as expected , the sign of the vorticity in them is opposite . a detailed distribution of @xmath149 in the boundary layer around the tube ( from top to bottom ) , can be seen in fig .
[ fig_vort_angle_12 ] .
the vorticity indeed changes sign at the edge of the tube : the abrupt shape of the zero crossing is due to the acute shape of the latter .
the small maximum at the right end of the distribution is characteristic of the tail ( [ sec_wake_structure ] ) .
0.41 the structure of the magnetic boundary layer is dominated by the ohmic diffusivity , which in part plays in the present case the role of the viscosity in the standard hydrodynamic boundary layers .
an important difference between viscous and purely magnetic boundary layers , though , concerns the no - slip condition for the flow : in the purely magnetic case , there is no counterpart to the viscous second - order derivative term that could force the tangential velocity to reach a zero value at the boundary . in our case , however , the flows on the inner side of the equipartition line are reduced or suppressed by the magnetic forces .
in other words , in the present boundary layer the lorentz force imposes a _ no - slip _ condition which does not allow a penetration of the external incoming flow into the tube nor large fluctuations of the transverse velocity inside .
this is clearly visible in fig .
[ fig_velo_interface ] where we have plotted @xmath150 , @xmath151 , @xmath62 and @xmath135 along a vertical axis slightly offset from the symmetry axis .
the slope of the profile of @xmath62 and @xmath135 across the boundary layer results from the equilibrium between the outward ohmic diffusion and the field advection through the external flow . for @xmath62 , for instance , this is controlled by the transverse component of the induction equation ( eq . [ eq_induction ] ) . written in terms of the magnetic potential @xmath152 ,
the latter reads : @xmath153 as the transverse field diffuses outward , it _ swallows _ 11.22truecm some of the incoming external matter ( which , in this way , slowly enters the magnetic field system ) . simultaneously
, this same external matter _
advects _ the magnetic field back toward the tube interior .
the equilibrium between those two terms is reached for a given thickness of the boundary layer , @xmath154 . to obtain an estimate for @xmath154
, we note that the external flow has a lengthscale comparable with the tube radius ( a common feature of cylinders moving in fluid media ) , so that , @xmath155 this estimate is in agreement within a factor about @xmath65 with the results of the numerical calculation ( see fig . [ fig_velo_interface ] ) .
an analogous advection diffusion equilibrium can be seen to hold for @xmath135 in the boundary layer . in spite of the striking similarities between the present problem and the rise of an air bubble ,
the corresponding boundary layers at the periphery of the rising object differ in important ways .
the boundary of an air bubble is basically a _ free surface _ for the external medium , since the density and viscosity in the interior are negligible compared with those outside .
the external flow must then satisfy a zero tangential stress boundary condition rather than the no - slip condition of the present magnetic tube ( e.g. , @xcite , 5.14 ; @xcite , 1984b ) . as a consequence ,
the tangential velocity at the gas / liquid interface in the air bubble does not vanish , but must instead satisfy the following equation : @xmath156 with @xmath157 the curvature of the boundary layer and @xmath158 the tangential component of the relative flow speed .
the resulting jump in tangential velocity across the boundary layer of a bubble is therefore only of order @xmath159 , while it is o(@xmath160 ) for a no - slip boundary layer , as in the present problem .
the magnetized boundary layer of the rising tube , in fact , resembles more closely the boundary layers around solid bodies with a no - slip condition than those around air bubbles .
the distribution of vorticity along the equipartition line shown in fig .
[ fig_vort_angle_12 ] is quite similar to that around the boundary of a rigid cylinder at @xmath161 ( e.g. , @xcite ) . in our case , though , the reversal of the sign occurs more abruptly because of the particular geometry of the equipartition line .
the enhanced ohmic dissipation in the boundary layer is creating entropy at a rate : @xmath162 to order of magnitude , this entropy increase can be written : @xmath163 with @xmath164 the local plasma beta in the boundary layer .
the entropy increase for a matter element moving all along the tube boundary is then of order @xmath165 . as a result
, the density difference @xmath105 of those elements can be substantially modified .
this , however , is unlikely to cause important modifications in the dynamical behavior of the tube boundary .
the main driving force there , the pressure gradient , is of order @xmath166 ; therefore , it should be more important than the local gravitational term @xmath167 by the ratio @xmath168 , where @xmath169 is the magnetic field strength in the boundary layer .
in our numerical simulation we also have some increase of entropy due to the artificial viscosity .
its influence , however is only secondary because of the low value of @xmath92 chosen .
wakes have been the object of active research in fluid dynamics for at least the past four decades .
this includes the wake behind solid cylinders ( e.g. , @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite , @xcite ; @xcite ) , drops ( @xcite ; @xcite ) and air bubbles ( @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) . in this chapter
we briefly describe the formation and structure of the wake behind the rising magnetic tube and pay special attention to the similarities and differences to other wakes known in the literature .
solid cylinders , air bubbles and drops have a clearly defined boundary from the beginning .
vorticity is created along the boundary and advected downflow .
the wake is formed out of external fluid only , via , e.g. in solid bodies , the detachment of the boundary layer . in our case ,
in contrast , there is no such clear boundary at the beginning .
the layers of weak magnetic field in the outskirts of the tube ( a ) are unable to resist the incipient external flow so that they are bodily convected to the rear and ( b ) increase their vorticity through the mechanisms explained in [ sec_vorticity_eq ] and [ sec_vorticity_generation ] .
it is the accumulation of this rotating material at the back of the tube that constitutes the wake .
the material making up the wake may in fact be a large fraction of the initial tube in the case of small initial pitch angles ( [ sec_split ] ) .
the process of formation of the wake is basically complete by @xmath170 ( see figs .
[ fig_rise ] and [ fig_equipartition_line ] ) and this signals the transition to the asymptotic regime of rise ( [ sec_asymp_reg ] ) .
the latter , however , is not exactly stationary , since the wake does not remain unmodified in the rest of the evolution .
in fact , it slowly grows in size and episodically changes its shape . the growth can be seen in fig .
[ fig_wake_growth ] , where the vertical size of the rolls is depicted as a function of time .
the elongation is roughly linear , with a small - amplitude oscillation superimposed .
this kind of behavior is not unknown in fluid dynamics .
the elongation of the wake is indeed similar to what is observed behind a rigid cylinder moving at constant speed with @xmath171 after an impulsive start ( see @xcite ) : in the laboratory experiment the linear growth of the wake with time continues well after the high-@xmath172 flows have been set up around the cylinder and @xmath56 has reached a constant value close to @xmath160 . for higher values of @xmath172 ( @xmath173 )
the growth of the wake with time is exponential rather than linear ( @xcite ) . in our case , a small part of the growth of the wake is due to the stratification ; however , its main cause is the transport of rotating material from the boundary layer along the boundary of the tube to the wake .
this is clearly visible in the third and fourth panels of fig .
[ fig_vorticity_halo ] : a white _ streamer _ of positive vorticity coming from the tube front is being wrapped up first around and then into the roll on the right - hand side of the wake .
simultaneously , a black _ tongue _ with origin in the back of the tube is also making inroads into the wake , next and following a parallel path to the white streamer . in the case of rigid tubes and bubbles moving through a fluid ( and assuming perfect symmetry about the object s midplane ) , the growth of the wake normally lasts until a dynamical equilibrium is adopted . in it ,
the vorticity generated in the boundary layer is advected to the wake , where it is redistributed through viscous diffusion and further advection .
simultaneously , the energy gained through the driving force ( the potential energy for the bubbles ) is transformed into heat in the wake , again through viscous dissipation ( @xcite ; @xcite ) .
further changes may occur if there is no mechanism to dispose of the heat thus generated .
0.35 in the results presented here , no dynamical equilibrium is reached since there is no equivalent mechanism to diffuse the vorticity effectively .
this can be seen quantitatively as follows : the characteristic time for the adoption of a stationary state in the wake through viscous diffusion and dissipation is @xmath174 times longer than the characteristic time for the formation of the wake itself , @xmath175 being the transverse dimension of the wake and @xmath176 the viscous reynolds number . in our case ,
@xmath177 and we expect @xmath176 ( e.g. , calculated on the basis of the numerical viscosity ) to be at least as high as @xmath92
. therefore , the establishment of the dynamical equilibrium lasts much longer than the evolution presented in this paper .
the consequence of this is the very inhomogeneous vorticity distribution apparent in fig .
[ fig_vorticity_halo ] . in a high-@xmath176 case , in fact
, it may never come to a full dynamical equilibrium because an instability interrupts the approach to a steady state : the two standing rolls develop asymmetric oscillations until one of them is released downstream ( see , e.g. , @xcite , plate @xmath178 ) .
in contrast , in low-@xmath176 bubble experiments , the trailing vortex rolls are similar to a hill s vortex ( e.g. , @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) .
9.8truecm in experiments with buoyant air bubbles , it is often observed that a small quantity of air is torn off ( or sucked from ) the bubble corner and becomes stretched all around the wake .
the result , commonly called the _ skirt _ , is a sheet of air aligned with the interface between the wake and the external medium , which remains attached to the bubble ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
a similar feature can be identified in our numerical simulations coinciding with the streamers or tongues of vorticity of both signs mentioned in the last section .
in contrast to the air bubbles , the _ skirt _ here is made of magnetized material . during the whole rise the magnetic field in the skirt
is continuously compressed and stressed both by the wake and external flows .
all along the central symmetry plane , the rising tube is leaving behind a _ tail _ of weakly magnetized matter ( fig .
[ fig_rise ] ) .
its upper part is compressed by the two rolls of the wake .
in fact , the _ tail _ is not only magnetized , but also has non - zero vorticity .
this can be seen both in the distribution of fig .
[ fig_vort_angle_12 ] ( maximum of positive vorticity at the right end of the figure ) and , as a light shadow , in the vorticity map of fig .
[ fig_vorticity_halo ] .
similar structures are seen behind moving pair of vortices as well as in bubble experiments ( e.g. @xcite ) .
the total amount of magnetic flux which is lost by the tube to the tail is small ( only 6 percent of the total flux ) .
close to the lateral edges of the tube ( see fig . [ fig_second_roll ] and the last panel in fig . [ fig_vorticity_halo ] ) small secondary rolls are built from time to time ; they grow for a while and then they are released to the downflow .
these features are reminiscent of the secondary rolls observed near the detachment point of boundary layer around solid cylinders ( @xcite ; @xcite ) . these secondary rolls
strongly perturb the skirt and the wake when they are released : this is the main cause for the irregular shape of the wake in the last panel of figs .
[ fig_rise ] and [ fig_vorticity_halo ] .
the initial value of @xmath50 for the tube whose rise we have described in the foregoing chapters was close to the value given by the criterion ( [ eq_min_pitch ] ) , namely @xmath179 .
this criterion provides a lower bound for the twist necessary to withstand the destruction of the tube through vorticity generation in its interior , external pressure forces , etc ; we do not know yet how sharp that bound is . in the present section
we investigate the transition from the low - twist to the high - twist regimes .
we conclude that the change from one to the other is gradual and takes place over a range of , say , @xmath136 degrees in @xmath50 , around the value given by the right hand side of eq .
[ eq_min_pitch ] . in fig .
[ fig_comparison_initial_pitch ] we show the relative flow , @xmath180 ( upper panels ) and the contours of longitudinal magnetic intensity , @xmath135 ( lower panels ) , for four cases with @xmath181 and @xmath182 , respectively .
there is a clear gradation of properties and evolutionary patterns along the four columns of the figure .
the amount of flux remaining in the _ head _ of the tube is an increasing function of @xmath50 .
this can be seen in fig .
[ fig_remaining_flux ] : the stars , representing the percentage of the initial flux which remain in the head , go from more than @xmath21 for @xmath183 to about @xmath184 for @xmath185 and ( trivially ) @xmath186 for @xmath187 . in this figure , the change between the two regimes occurs between , say , @xmath188 and @xmath189 .
not only the size , but also the shape of the remaining head varies markedly from one case to the other ( fig .
[ fig_comparison_initial_pitch ] , upper panels ) . for @xmath190 ,
the tube maintains its roundish shape all along .
this is specially striking at the rear of the tube : the rising return flow between the two rolls in the wake can not dent the back of the tube .
this case is closest to the motion of a rigid cylinder in a fluid . for @xmath50 decreasing down to @xmath191 , the back of the tube becomes first flat and then concave through the action of the return flow .
this transition coincides with the increase of the magnetic weber number up across unity : @xmath100 is 0.19 , 0.74 and 5.75 for @xmath190 , @xmath192 and @xmath193 , respectively . in the untwisted case , there is no longer a neat separation between tube interior and external flows .
the rolls in the wake now contain 70% of the original magnetic flux , with most of the rest contained in the upper arch linking them .
the evolutionary pattern in this case is similar in many respects to the results of longcope et al .
( 1996 ) .
further insight into the structural differences for the tubes of fig . [ fig_comparison_initial_pitch ] can be obtained by comparing 0.6 the energy density of the transverse field , @xmath194 with the kinetic energy reached asymptotically by the head of the tube .
the order of magnitude of the latter is @xmath195 .
this varies little ( about @xmath196 only ) between @xmath197 and @xmath190 . the magnetic energy of the transverse field , in contrast , varies by a large factor ( approx .
@xmath198 ) between those two extremes . for the comparison ( fig . [ fig_energy ] ) , we plot
now the distribution of @xmath194 along the vertical axis at times @xmath18 ( upper panel ) and @xmath148 ( lower panel ) , divided in both cases by the kinetic energy density at the upper stagnation point of the tube in the asymptotic regime , @xmath199 ( calculated in the figure at time @xmath148 ) . in the case with the highest @xmath50 ( dashed line ) , at @xmath18 only a thin skin at the outermost tube boundary is below the terminal kinetic energy level ; we expect a skin of roughly that size to be dragged to the wake . for @xmath200 ( solid line ) and @xmath185 (
dotted line ) , most ( or all ) of the tube at time @xmath18 has @xmath194 below the @xmath199 level .
however , in the initial phases of the evolution the transverse field is substantially intensified through the compression and stretching phenomena explained in [ sec_rise ] .
this allows the _ head _ of the tube to be formed and its energy @xmath194 to be at ( or above ) the @xmath199 level in the asymptotic regime ( fig .
[ fig_energy ] , dotted line in the second plot ) .
the results presented in this paper can be discussed from a twofold perspective .
first , they can be applied to the theory of the magnetic activity in the sun , trying to understand different aspects of the rise of magnetic flux across the convection zone . on the other hand ,
the simulations described here bear a strong resemblance to the results of laboratory and numerical experiments on the motion of air bubbles and rigid cylinders ; it would be as well to clarify similarities and differences .
the following subsections discuss different aspects of those topics .
the numerical calculation of the present paper is necessarily idealized .
the calculations were done in a high - beta regime with small ratio of radius to pressure scaleheight . in thus far , they are within the parameter regime of expected for the magnetic tubes in the deep convection zone .
the latter have a larger @xmath0 , by a factor between @xmath178 and @xmath126 , than adopted here but many qualitative features of the rise should be similar in both cases .
the only diffusive process considered , though , the ohmic resistivity , together with the numerical viscosity and diffusion , yield laminar flows in and around the tube with reynolds number of a few hundred .
this can not be expected to hold in the actual sun : there , the rise of the tube will be accompanied by turbulent flows ( with , in particular , a turbulent wake ) . in spite of the foregoing
, a conclusion seems unavoidable : for the transport of the magnetic flux to the surface in the form of buoyant magnetic flux tubes to be effective , the latter must be twisted from the early stages of their rise .
we have shown for a tube with a density deficit of order the full isothermal value ( @xmath201 ) that an average pitch angle around @xmath3 $ ] is indeed necessary for the tube to withstand the various deforming agents .
otherwise , they lose most of their magnetic flux to the trailing wake . as shown by earlier authors , the vortex rolls of the wake
can easily end up moving horizontally rather than rising .
the condition on the minimum pitch angle may be less stringent , though , if we consider that the rise may actually be driven by the parker instability in tubes which are stored in a neutrally buoyant equilibrium ( @xcite ) .
the instability occurs with the upgoing mass elements being driven by a vertical force which remains well below @xmath202 while the amplitude is not too large . to a driving force of amount
@xmath203 ( @xmath204 ) corresponds through ( [ eq_min_pitch ] ) a minimum pitch angle which is about a factor @xmath205 smaller than for isothermal straight tubes .
for example , in the case discussed in the paper of @xcite , @xmath206 for the top of the rising loop in the lowermost @xmath207 km of the rise , i.e. , for distances equivalent to about @xmath136 times the tube radius .
even if the tubes are strongly buoyant [ @xmath208 from the beginning , their time evolution may depend to some extent on the precise distribution of the density deficit in the tube at time @xmath18 . a gaussian profile , as used in this paper , yields a fast deformation of the initial magnetic configuration , followed by internal torsional oscillations .
this is directly associated with the torque of the buoyancy force throughout the tube interior . a top - hat profile ( @xmath209 but @xmath210const ) , on the other hand ,
has no buoyancy torques associated except at the tube boundary .
yet , the time evolution of such a tube for smooth pitch angle distributions like ( [ eq_pitchassympt ] ) or ( [ eq_pitchgauss ] ) is qualitatively similar to the cases studied in this paper , as has been tested through a series of numerical experiments .
this can be understood in different ways : first , the hydrodynamic forces associated with the external flow depend on the speed of rise of the tube , which is a function of the average buoyancy rather than of the precise shape of the @xmath211 profile . to counteract them
, one needs to have a sufficient pitch angle in the tube interior . on the other hand , the gravitational term in the vorticity equation ( [ eq_vort ] ) for a top - hat profile
is concentrated at the periphery of the @xmath211 distribution , but is correspondingly more intense . to counteract it ,
it is necessary to have a large current density @xmath212 , which can only be achieved if @xmath62 is sufficiently intense , at least close to the tube boundary . through both arguments one arrives at criteria basically like eq .
( [ eq_min_pitch ] ) .
if the magnetic tubes that yield active regions at the surface must be twisted already in the early stages of the rise , the sun should have a mechanism to routinely produce twisted tubes in the dynamo layers .
if one relaxes the condition of symmetry along the tube imposed in the present paper , one may think that the twist could result through torsional shearing .
this might come about as a natural subproduct of the generation of vorticity explained in this paper , if it took place at different rates on the different cross sections of the tube along the axis .
this can be the case , for instance , if the originally horizontal tube develops an omega - loop shape in which a stretch of it rises while the rest remains at the original level .
if the tube was originally untwisted ( or only weakly twisted ) , the rising sections would tend to turn into vortex tube pairs which contain most of the original magnetic flux .
now , in contrast to the 2d case , this rotation produces a transverse field component in the flanks of the rising section of the loop .
if enough @xmath62 is built up , the rotation in the vortices could be braked . yet
, a simple calculation shows that for this mechanism to be at all effective , the footpoint separation , @xmath213 , of the omega loop has to be small , in fact smaller than one pressure scaleheight .
more precisely , if we require that the tube develops a transverse component of the level required by the criterion ( [ eq_min_pitch ] ) after rising a distance equivalent to a few of its own radii , we obtain @xmath214 this is a very small footpoint separation : the ratio of the lorentz force associated with the curvature of the field lines to the buoyancy force in such a tube is at least of order @xmath215 .
consequently , it is not easy to _ raise _ a loop that is narrow enough for a sufficient pitch angle to develop at all .
this is an indication that the tubes possibly have to be formed with the necessary amount of twist before they start to rise .
an interesting possibility for generating magnetic tubes with a non - zero total twist has been discussed by @xcite : they consider a rayleigh - taylor unstable slab of plasma with horizontal magnetic field such that the angle subtended by the field vector with a fixed horizontal axis monotonically changes with depth . upon development of the instability ,
the layer yields magnetic tubes with non - zero degree of twist . in their experiment ,
the authors showed how the resulting tubes were more resistant to deformation through the surrounding flows than in the corresponding untwisted case ( @xcite ) .
a corresponding three - dimensional problem has been calculated by @xcite .
they show how an unstable layer with a parallel horizontal field produces magnetic tubes with non - zero vorticity . through nonlinear interaction , these tubes arch as they rise in a vertical plane , thereby becoming twisted .
another open question concerns the fate of a twisted tube as it rises across successive density scaleheights in the convection zone .
the internal and external densities are essentially equal for most of the rise ( except for the small relative difference of order up to @xmath216 ) : the tube thus expands and its field intensity weakens by several orders of magnitude along the journey ( see @xcite , 1992 , 1997b ) .
in fact , the beginning of this process can be seen by comparing the maximum field intensity of the three panels of fig .
[ fig_pitch_angle ] .
the rate of decrease associated with an off - axis expansion of the tube , though , is different for the longitudinal and transverse components of the field ( @xcite , 9 ) . a rough but simple argument based on the conservation of flux in 2d yields a rate of change of the twist following an approximate law @xmath217 .
if so , the tubes could reach the upper convection zone with very large degrees of twist , possibly such that they can become kink unstable .
yet , three - dimensional effects could render that simple law of little use .
the stretching of the tube apex in the longitudinal direction , for instance , a phenomenon common in parker - unstable rising loops , may reduce the level of twist there .
also , the conservation of the total helicity in the tube could put an upper limit to the number of turns of the field lines around the axis at any single place .
however it is , large pitch angles should be a common appearance in rising tubes when they reach photospheric levels .
the sheared field structures observed in emerging active regions ( @xcite , @xcite ) may be a consequence of this ( see also @xcite , @xcite and @xcite ) .
[ [ magnetic - tubes - air - bubbles - and - rigid - cylinders - similarities - and - differences ] ] magnetic tubes , air bubbles and rigid cylinders : similarities and differences ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ along this paper we have compared our results to the laboratory experiments of flow past rigid cylinders and air bubbles at @xmath218 @xmath219 . in the following we summarize the similarities and differences found . _ magnetic tubes and air bubbles .
_ remarkable similarities are : ( a ) the general shape and structural features ( skirt , central tail ) ( b ) the _ protection _ of the interior of the rising object through surface tension .
these similarities are all the more striking given the difference in buoyancy [ density deficit @xmath220 for the tubes , @xmath221 for the bubbles ] and in the physical source of the surface tension ( capillary effects vs. jump in the tangential field component ) . as a result , defining the weber number on the basis of the corresponding surface tension mechanism , one can formulate a common law of dependence of structural properties on @xmath100 . _ magnetic tubes and rigid cylinders . _ a clear similarity concerns the boundary layer : both objects have a no - slip condition along the boundary .
consequently , the relative jump of the tangential velocity across the boundary layer is large , @xmath222/v_{tg}^ { } \sim \hbox{o}(1)$ ] .
in contrast , there is a zero - tangential stress condition along the fluid / air interface of a bubble ; correspondingly , @xmath222/v_{tg}^ { } \sim \hbox{o}(re^{-1/2})$ ] . as a result of the no - slip condition ,
both buoyant magnetic tubes and rigid cylinders produce ( and shed downstream ) secondary rolls near the point of separation of the boundary layer .
_ features specific to the buoyant magnetic tubes with twist .
_ in the magnetic tubes of the present simulations , the wake is formed in the initial phases of the rise out of material bodily transported from the initial tube thus , the wake is magnetized and maintains a magnetic connection to the head of the rising tube along time .
the kind of behavior followed by the magnetic rope depends directly on the amount of magnetic flux incorporated into the wake , which , in turn , depends on the initial twist . in the case of an initially highly twisted tube ( @xmath223 ) ,
the magnetic rope is almost rigid and its shape and the flow around it strongly remind those of a _
solid cylinder_. if the initial pitch angle is closer to the threshold ( [ eq_min_pitch ] ) , then the tube deforms and adopt a _ bubble_-like shape ( though it still satisfies a no - slip condition along its boundary ) .
finally , if @xmath50 is very small , the tube behaves like a rising _ thermal _ ( longcope et al .
1996 ) .
this work was partially funded through the dges project no .
95 - 0028-c of the spanish ministry of education and culture .
the numerical calculations were carried out using the computing resources of the instituto de astrofsica de canarias and of the centre de computaci i comunicacions de catalunya .
the authors are grateful to m. kaisig for providing the numerical code and for his subsequent help with it .
thanks are also due to a large number of scientists in hao , jila and cora in boulder ( colorado ) as well as in the university of chicago for interesting discussions on the topic of this paper .
batchelor , g.k .
, 1967 , an introduction to fluid dynamics , ( cambridge : cup ) bouard , r. , coutanceau , m. , 1980 , j. fluid mech .
101 , 583 caligari , p. , moreno - insertis , f. , schssler , m. , 1995 , , 441 , 886 cargill , p.j . , chen , j. , spicer , d.s . ,
zalesak , s.t . , 1996 , , 101 , 4855 cattaneo , f. , hughes , d.w . , 1988 , j. fluid mech . , 196 , 323 cattaneo , f. , chiueh , t. , hughes , d.w . , 1990 ,
j. fluid mech . , 219 , 1 collins , r. , 1965 , chem .
, 20 , 851 collins , w.m . , dennis , s.c.r . , 1973a , quart . j. mech .
, 26 , 53 collins , w.m . , dennis , s.c.r . , 1973b , j. fluid mech . , 60 , 105 choudhuri , a.r . , 1989 , , 123 , 217 christov , c.i
, volkov , p.k . , 1985 , j. fluid mech .
, 158 , 341 dandy , d.s . , leal , l.g .
, 1989 , j. fluid mech . , 208 , 161 davies , r.m . ,
taylor , g.i .
lond . , a 200 , 375 dsilva , s. , choudhuri , a.r . , 1993 , , 272 , 621 emonet , t. , moreno - insertis , f. , 1996 , , 458 , 783 fan , y. , fisher , g.h . , deluca e.e . , 1993 , , 405 , 390
fan , y. , fisher , g.h . ,
mcclymont , a.n . , 1994 , , 436 , 907 fan , y. , zweibel , e.g. , lantz , s.r . , 1997 , , submitted .
hnat , j.g . ,
buckmaster , j.d . , 1976 ,
fluids , vol .
19 , no . 2 , 182 hughes , d.w . ,
falle , s.a.e.g . , joarder , p. , 1998
, , submitted .
kaisig , m. , tajima , t. , shibata , k. , nozawa , s. , matsumoto , r. , 1990 , , 358 , 698 kurokawa , h. , 1989 , spa .
rev , 51 , 49 leka , k.d . , canfield , r.c . ,
mcclymont , a.n . , van driel - gesztelyi , l , 1996 , , 462 , 547 lites , b.w . ,
low , b.c .
, martnez pillet , v. , seagraves , p. , skumanich , a. , 1995 , , 446 , 877 .
longcope , d.w . , fisher , g.h . ,
arendt , s. , 1996 , , 464 , 999 matthews , p.c . ,
hughes , d.w . , proctor , m.r.e .
, 1995 , , 448 , 938 moreno - insertis , f. , 1983 , , 122 , 241 moreno - insertis , f. , 1986 , , 166 , 291 moreno - insertis , f. , 1992 , in sunspots , theory and observations , eds .
j.h.thomas and n.o.weiss , p. 385
( dordrecht : kluwer ) .
moreno - insertis , f. , 1997a , in _ the inconstant sun _ , c. marmolino and g. cauzzi , eds .
astr . it . *
68*. moreno - insertis , f. , 1997b , in _ solar magnetic fields _ , viggo hansteen , ed . , university of oslo , p. 330 .
moreno - insertis , f. , emonet , t. 1996 , , 472 , l53 nordlund , , stein , r.f .
1990 , comput .
commun . , 59 , 119 parlange , j .- y .
, 1969 , _ j. fluid mech . _ , 37 , 257 parker , e.n . , 1979 , cosmical magnetic fields , ( oxford : oxford university press ) , chap .
9 richtmyer , r.o . ,
morton , k.w .
1967 , difference methods for initial - value problems ( 2d ed . ; new york : interscience ) , chap .
13 ryskin , g. , leal , l.g . , 1984a , j. fluid mech . , 148 , 1 ryskin , g. , leal , l.g . , 1984b , j. fluid mech . , 148 , 19 rubin , e.l . ,
burstein , s.z . , 1967 ,
phys . , 2 , 178 rust , d.m . ,
kumar , a. , 1996 , , 464 , l199 schssler , m. , 1979 , , 71 , 79 shibata , k. 1983 , , 35 , 263 shibata , k. , tajima , t. , steinolfson , r.s . , matsumoto , r. 1989 , , 345 , 584 stone , h.a .
, 1994 , ann .
fluid mech . , 26 , 65 ta phuoc loc , 1980 , j. fluid mech . , 100 , 111 ta phuoc loc , bouard , r. , 1985 , j. fluid mech . , 160 , 93 tanaka , k. , 1991 , , 136 , 37 tsinganos , k.c .
, 1980 , , 239 , 746 wegener , p.p . , parlange , j .- y . , 1973 , annual rev .
fluid mech . , 5 , 79 | the physics of a twisted magnetic flux tube rising in a stratified medium is studied using a numerical mhd code .
the problem considered is fully compressible ( no boussinesq approximation ) , includes ohmic resistivity , and is two dimensional , i.e. , there is no variation of the variables in the direction of the tube axis .
we study a high plasma @xmath0 case with small ratio of radius to external pressure scaleheight .
the results obtained can therefore be of relevance to understand the transport of magnetic flux across the solar convection zone .
we confirm that a sufficient twist of the field lines around the tube axis can suppress the conversion of the tube into two vortex rolls . for a tube with relative density deficit of order @xmath1 ( the classical parker buoyancy ) and radius smaller than a pressure scale - height ( @xmath2 )
, the minimum amount of twist necessary corresponds to an average pitch angle of order @xmath3 $ ] .
the evolution of a tube with this degree of twist is studied in detail , including the initial transient phase , the internal torsional oscillations and the asymptotic , quasi - stationary phase . during the initial phase , the outermost , weakly magnetized layers of the tube are torn off its main body and endowed with vorticity .
they yield a trailing magnetized wake with two vortex rolls .
which fraction of the total magnetic flux is brought to the wake is a function of the initial degree of twist . in the weakly twisted case ,
most of the initial tube is turned into vortex rolls . at the opposite end ( strong initial twist ) , the tube rises with only a small deformation and no substantial loss of magnetic flux .
the formation of the wake and the loss of flux from the main body of the tube are basically complete after the initial transient phase . a sharp interface between the tube interior and the external flows is formed at the tube front and sides ; it has the characteristic features of a magnetic boundary layer .
its structure is determined as an equilibrium between ohmic diffusion and field advection through the external flows .
it is the site of vorticity generation via the magnetic field during the whole tube evolution . from the hydrodynamical point of view
, this problem constitutes an intermediate case between the rise of air bubbles in water and the motion of a rigid cylinder in an external medium . as in the first one ,
the tube is deformable and the outcome of the experiment ( shape of rising object and wake ) depends on the value of the weber number .
several structural features obtained in the present simulation are also observed in rising air bubbles , like a central _ tail _ , and a _ skirt _ enveloping the wake . as in rigid cylinders
, the boundary layer satisfies a no - slip condition ( provided for in the tube by the magnetic field ) , and secondary rolls are formed at the lateral edges of the moving object .
# 1#2 # 1#2 # 1*#1 * # 1b^#1_bl # 1v_rel^#1 # 1v_rel^#1 # 1v^#1_term #
1v^#1_apex # 1v^#1_rise # 1c_s^#1 # 1re_m^#1 # 1 # 1#2 to 0pt12.0 cm @xmath4 |
it is the purpose of this paper to extend the results of yetter @xcite , generalizing classical results of gerstenhaber @xcite and gerstenhaber and schack @xcite on the infinitesimal deformation theory of associative algebras and poset - indexed diagrams of associative algebras to a deformation theory for arbitrary pasting diagrams of @xmath0-linear categories , @xmath0-linear functors , and natural transformations . in particular , in @xcite the standard result that obstructions are cocycles was established only for the simplest parts of pasting diagrams : for pasting diagrams in which no compositions either 1- or 2-dimensional occur . in this paper
we will establish it for deformation complexes of pasting diagrams in general , by first giving a detailed and rigorous exposition of a method developed heuristically by shrestha @xcite , then applying the method to prove that obstructions are all cocycles in a family of pasting diagrams sufficient to imply the result in general . along the way to proving that obstructions are closed in general , we will have occasion to consider deformations of pasting diagrams in which specified functors or natural transformations are required to be deformed trivially .
although in the present work such conditions will be used only to reduce the problem of showing obstructions are cocycles to simple instances , the ability to handle deformations subject to such restrictions could well be useful in other settings .
we will also make explicit a point overlooked in the statements and proofs of @xcite theorems 8.2 and 8.3 : the cochain maps constructed in those theorems depend on choices of association for 2-dimenensional compositions in the pasting digaram .
however , as we establish here , the cochain maps are independent of those choices , up to algebraic homotopy , and thus , the isomorphism type of the deformation complex for a pasting diagram is well - defined in either the homotopy category or derived category of cochain complexes over @xmath0 .
at the level of the hochschild cochain complexes @xmath1 , the interesting cochain maps are described fully in @xcite .
our purpose in this section is , rather , to describe chain maps induced by pasting compositions on the full deformation complexes @xmath2 , when @xmath3 is a composable pasting diagram .
proposition 4.5 of @xcite constructs two chain maps : if @xmath4 , and @xmath5 are functors , then there is a cochain map @xmath6 given by @xmath7 similarly if @xmath8 and @xmath9 are functors , there is a cochain map @xmath10 given by @xmath11 proposition 4.6 of @xcite gives two more : if @xmath12 is a natural transformation , then post- ( resp .
pre- ) composition by @xmath13 induces a cochain map @xmath14 ( resp .
@xmath15 for any functor @xmath16 . here
@xmath17 and @xmath18 and , @xcite proposition 4.7 give a cochain map , which ties together all of the deformations when a natural transformation , its source and target , and their common source and target are deformed simultaneously : let @xmath19 be a natural transformation between @xmath0-linear functors @xmath20 .
let @xmath21 denote the cone on the cochain map @xmath22 : c^\bullet({\cal a})\oplus c^\bullet({\cal b } ) \rightarrow c^\bullet(f ) \oplus c^\bullet(g).\ ] ] the cochain groups are @xmath23 with coboundary operators given by @xmath24\ ] ] proposition 4.7 was omitted in the statement of the proposition , though it is plainly present in the proof given in @xcite ] was then let @xmath19 be a natural transformation , then @xmath25 : c^\bullet({\cal a } \stackrel{f}{g } { \cal b } ) \rightarrow c^\bullet(f , g)\ ] ] is a cochain map .
in @xcite the chain maps of propositions 8.1 , 8.2 and 8.3 were used only to construct the deformation complex of a general pasting diagram .
in fact , they can be assembled into chain maps from the deformation complex of a composable pasting diagram to the simpler pasting diagram in which the compositions have been carried out .
propositions [ chainmapfrom2comp ] , [ chainmapfrom1precomp ] and [ chainmapfrom1postcomp ] give the map explicitly in the cases of a single 2 composition , precomposition of a natural transformation by a functor , and postcompostion of a natural transformation by a functor , respectively . in each case
the proof begins by collecting the maps from the propositions of @xcite with values in the direct summands corresponding to cells of the pasting diagram in which the compositions have been performed , together with identity maps for those cells which remain from the original diagram , and arranging their summands in the correct places of a matrix of maps .
what is indicated in the sketches of proofs following each proposition are the main difficulties in the unedifying calculation which shows that the result is , in fact , a chain map between the deformation complexes . [ chainmapfrom2comp ]
let @xmath26 be @xmath0-linear functors , and @xmath19 and @xmath27 be natural transformations .
let @xmath3 be the pasting diagram consisting of both @xmath28 and @xmath13 and their ( iterated ) sources and targets , and let @xmath29 be the pasting diagram consisting of the 2-dimensional composition @xmath30 and its ( iterated ) sources and targets .
then there is a chain map @xmath31 induced by the 2-dimensional composition . in particular if the summands of @xmath32 ( resp .
@xmath33 ) are given in the order @xmath34 ( resp .
@xmath35 @xmath36 is given by @xmath37\ ] ] ( sketch ) the only subtlety in the completely computational verification that this is a chain map involves one coordinate in which a relation of the sort in gerstenhaber and voronov @xcite or the proof of proposition 4.7 in @xcite is needed .
[ chainmapfrom1precomp ] let @xmath38 and @xmath39 be @xmath0-linear functors , and @xmath40 be a natural transformation .
let @xmath3 be the pasting diagram consisting of @xmath28 and its ( iterated ) sources and targets together with @xmath41 and @xmath42 , and let @xmath29 be the pasting diagram consisting of the 1-dimensional composition @xmath43 and its ( iterated ) sources and targets .
then there is a chain map @xmath44 induced by the 1-dimensional composition . in particular if the summands of @xmath32 ( resp .
@xmath33 ) are given in the order @xmath45 ( resp .
@xmath46 @xmath47 is given by @xmath48\ ] ] ( sketch ) here the `` hardest '' verification is a coordinate which vanishes by the naturality of @xmath43 .
[ chainmapfrom1postcomp ] let @xmath49 and @xmath50 be @xmath0-linear functors , and @xmath19 be a natural transformation .
let @xmath3 be the pasting diagram consisting of @xmath28 and its ( iterated ) sources and targets , together with @xmath51 and @xmath52 , and let @xmath29 be the pasting diagram consisting of the 1-dimensional composition @xmath53 and its ( iterated ) sources and targets .
then there is a chain map @xmath54 induced by the 2-dimensional composition .
in particular if the summands of @xmath32 ( resp .
@xmath33 ) are given in the order @xmath55 ( resp .
@xmath56 @xmath57 is given by @xmath58\ ] ] ( sketch ) here , almost all of the coordinates in the bottom row present some minor `` difficulty '' , one depends on a gerstenhaber - voronov - style relation , while most of the others require unpacking the definitions of pullback or pushforward maps along functors and natural transformations to see some commutativity relation between them .
in this section we use the cochain maps of the previous section to give explicit examples of deformation complexes associated to various shapes commutative pasting diagrams . in one example
we see that cochain maps induced by two different associations of the 2-dimensional composition are not actually equal , but only chain homotopic ( or , to put it another way , are not equal in the abelian category of cochain complexes , but _ are _ in the homotopy category of cochain complexes and thus _ a fortiori _ in the derived category ) . in the examples , we use commutative pasting diagrams because only in that context is the effect of the compositions of 2-arrows evident : if no commutativities are enforced , the iterative cone construction given explicitly in @xcite proposition 4.7 suffices to describe the entire structure of the deformation complex of the pasting diagram , as indeed it does in the case of commutative pasting diagrams in which no compositions occur ( for example , the commutative `` pillow '' consisting of two categories a pair of parallel functors between them , and two copies of the same natural transformation between the functors ) .
only when compositions are involved do the cochain maps of the previous section play a role . in what follows
, we leave zero entries in matrices of maps giving coboundaries blank , as this seems to improve readability .
we begin with the simplest example , a `` commutative pillow with triangular cross - section '' : [ triangularpillow ] consider the pasting diagram given by three functors @xmath59 and three natural transformations @xmath60 , @xmath61 and @xmath62 , with the obvious 0- , 1- and 2-cells and a single 3-cell enforcing the condition @xmath63 .
the deformation complex of the pasting diagram is then given by @xmath64 @xmath65 with coboundary given by @xmath66\ ] ] note that here we have chosen to consider the composition @xmath67 to be the source of the 3-cell and the single natural transformation @xmath68 to be the target .
for the opposite choice the complex would be the same , except that the non - diagonal entries of the last row would be negated .
the complex @xmath69 of example [ triangularpillow ] is related to the map @xmath70 of proposition [ chainmapfrom2comp ] by [ babyqi ] @xmath69 is quasi - isomorphic to the ( dual ) mapping cylinder on @xmath70 .
this follows immediately by applying the following general lemma about ( dual ) mapping cylinders of chain maps between mapping cones .
let @xmath71 and @xmath72 be chain maps , and suppose @xmath73 is a chain map between their mapping cones of the form @xmath74 .\ ] ] then the ( dual ) mapping cylinder on @xmath75 , @xmath76 \oplus cone(g)[1 ] \oplus cone(g)$ ] with differential given by @xmath77 , \ ] ] is quasi - isomorphic to @xmath78 with differential given by @xmath79 .\ ] ] include the last complex into the ( dual ) mapping cylinder by @xmath80 , the cokernel is plainly isomorphic to @xmath81})$ ] , which is acylic , so the subcomplex is quasi - isomorphic to the ( dual ) mapping cylinder as claimed .
continuing with pasting diagrams which only involve 2-dimensional compositions , consider next the two `` pillows with square cross - sections '' : consider the pasting diagram given by four functors @xmath82 and four natural transformations @xmath60 , @xmath61 , @xmath83 and @xmath84 , with the obvious 0- , 1- and 2-cells and a single 3-cell enforcing the condition @xmath85 .
the deformation complex of the pasting diagram is then given by @xmath86 @xmath87 with coboundary given by @xmath88\ ] ] where @xmath89 consider the pasting diagram given by four functors @xmath90 and four natural transformations @xmath60 , @xmath61 , @xmath91 and @xmath92 , with the obvious 0- , 1- and 2-cells and a single 3-cell enforcing the condition @xmath93 .
the deformation complex of the pasting diagram is then given by @xmath94 @xmath95 with coboundary given by @xmath96\ ] ] where @xmath97 now , observe that in this example , we made a choice : we computed the bottom row , and in paricular the map @xmath98 by left - associating @xmath28 , @xmath13 and @xmath68 . had we right - associated them , the bottom row , other than @xmath98 would have remained the same ( though it would have been more natural to write @xmath99 , @xmath100 and @xmath101 as the names for the other maps ) .
the second entry , rather than being @xmath98 would have been @xmath102 .
now , it is easy to see that the chain maps from @xmath103 @xmath104 to @xmath105 given by the entries of the bottom row other than @xmath106 are not equal , and their difference has a single non - zero entry @xmath107 .
there is however a contracting homotopy for this difference , given by the map with all by the second entry zero , and that entry given by @xmath108 , due to the relationship between the brace and coboundary discovered in the classical case by gerstenhaber and voronov @xcite and seen to apply in the categorical setting in @xcite .
thus in the homotopy category ( or the derived category , if one prefers ) our choice of left - association was a matter of indifference .
it is easy to compute more examples in which no 1-dimensional compositions occur , for instance a `` pillow '' with a pentagonal cross - section with a triple composition equal to a double composition , by combining the techniques of the last three examples . rather than
write this out explicitly , we now turn to examples involving 1-dimensional composition : [ equalspost1comp ] consider the pasting diagram consisting of three categories @xmath42 , @xmath109 and @xmath52 , three functors @xmath20 and @xmath50 , two natural transformations @xmath60 and @xmath110 and a single 3-cell enforcing the condition that @xmath111
. the deformation complex of the pasting diagram is given by @xmath112 @xmath113 with coboundary given by @xmath114\ ] ] [ equalspre1comp ] consider the pasting diagram consisting of three categories @xmath42 , @xmath109 and @xmath52 , three functors @xmath115 and @xmath39 , two natural transformations @xmath116 and @xmath117 and a single 3-cell enforcing the condition that @xmath118
. the deformation complex of the pasting diagram is given by @xmath112 @xmath119 with coboundary given by @xmath120\ ] ] consider the pasting diagram consisting of three categories @xmath42 , @xmath109 and @xmath52 , four functors @xmath20 , @xmath50 and @xmath121 , and three natural transformations @xmath60 , @xmath122 and @xmath123 , with the obvious 0- , 1- and 2- cells and a single 3-cell enforcing the condition that @xmath124
. the deformation complex of the pasting diagram is given by @xmath125 @xmath126 with coboundary given by @xmath127^ * & -id & d_{h(f),k } \end{array } \right]\ ] ] where @xmath128 consider the pasting diagram consisting of three categories @xmath42 , @xmath109 and @xmath52 , four functors @xmath115 , @xmath39 and @xmath121 , and three natural transformations @xmath129 , @xmath130 and @xmath131 , with the obvious 0- , 1- and 2- cells and a single 3-cell enforcing the condition that @xmath132 .
the deformation complex of the pasting diagram is given by @xmath125 @xmath133 with coboundary given by @xmath134^ * & \sigma_*(f^ * ) & -id & d_{h(f),k } \end{array } \right]\ ] ] where @xmath135 consider the pasting diagram consisting of three categories @xmath42 , @xmath109 and @xmath52 , four functors @xmath136 , @xmath137 and @xmath138 , and three natural transformations @xmath139 , @xmath130 and @xmath140 , with the obvious 0- , 1- and 2- cells and a single 3-cell enforcing the condition that @xmath141 .
the deformation complex of the pasting diagram is given by @xmath125 @xmath142 with coboundary given by @xmath143 _ * & \sigma^*(k _ * ) & -id & d_{h(f),k } \end{array } \right]\ ] ] where @xmath144 consider the pasting diagram consisting of three categories @xmath42 , @xmath109 and @xmath52 , four functors @xmath136 , @xmath145 and @xmath146 , and three natural transformations @xmath147 , @xmath148 and @xmath149 , with the obvious 0- , 1- and 2- cells and a single 3-cell enforcing the condition that @xmath150 .
the deformation complex of the pasting diagram is given by @xmath125 @xmath151 with coboundary given by @xmath152 _ * & \sigma^*(g^ * ) & -id & d_{f , k(g ) } \end{array } \right]\ ] ] where @xmath153
first , observing that the map @xmath154 is simply the identity in the case where the composable pasting diagram @xmath3 is simply the 2-cell @xmath28 ( with its sources and targets ) , and that the ( dual ) mapping cylinder on a map is the cone on the direct sum of the map and the identity on its target we have if @xmath3 is a pasting diagram with a single 3-cell the boundary of which has domain ( resp .
codomain ) which is a composable pasting diagram @xmath29 and codomain ( resp .
domain ) which is a single 2-cell , then @xmath155 is quasi - isomorphic to the ( dual ) mapping cylinder of the map of proposition 8.3 of @xcite induced by the composition .
observe this is a generalization of proposition [ babyqi ] and in special instances relates the ( dual ) mapping cylinder of the map in proposition [ chainmapfrom1postcomp ] ( resp . [ chainmapfrom1precomp ] ) to the complex of example [ equalspost1comp ] ( resp .
[ equalspre1comp ] ) .
the following is a trivial observation about the deformation complex constructed in proposition 8.3 of @xcite and the remarks following : [ uniontopushout ] if @xmath156 is a pasting diagram which is the union of pasting diagrams @xmath157 and @xmath158 , then the deformation complex @xmath155 is the pushout of the induced inclusions of deformation complexes @xmath159 for @xmath160 @xmath161 .
in @xcite shrestha developed a method of using polygons with edges labeled by arrow - valued operations to simultaneously encode cocycle conditions , the formulas for obstructions , and the condition that the next term of a deformation cobound the obstruction .
suitable cell - decompositions of the surface of a 2-sphere into such polygons and `` trivial '' polygons which encode tautologous equalities in place of cocycle conditions and zero ( as a difference of identical sums ) in place of an obstruction , then provide a convenient method of proof for standard obstructions - are - cocycle results . as an example , consider the cocycle conditions , formulas for obstructions , and cobounding conditions in the case of the deformation of composition , writing the undeformed composition as @xmath162 to match the notation for the degree @xmath163 deformation term as @xmath164 : the cocycle condition is , of course , @xmath165 the formula for the degree @xmath163 obstruction is @xmath166 . and the condition that @xmath167 cobounds @xmath168 is @xmath169 now consider the square , with oriented edges labeled by the compositions occuring in the expression of the associativity of composition : @xmath170^{a(bc ) } & \circ\\ .\ar[r]_{ab}\ar[u]^{bc } & \ar[u]_{(ab)c.}}.\ ] ] + each of the above formulas can be obtained from ( or represented by ) the square by adding all possible terms obtained by assigning degrees to the edges in such a way that the degrees are chosen from a particular set and the sum of degrees along each of the oriented parts of the boundary has a specified value , and taking the difference of the expressions thus obtained for each of the oriented parts of the boundary .
gerstenhaber s proof @xcite that obstructions to the deformation of an associative algebra are hochschild cocycles can then be described in terms of the cube below by first noting that the formula for the coboundary of the degree @xmath163 obstruction can be written as a signed sum of the obstruction - type expressions ( with the edge - degrees ranging from @xmath171 to @xmath172 ) , five faces representing the usual terms of the coboundary , and one representing @xmath171 , `` prolonged '' by pre- or post - composing with the degree @xmath171 label on another edge so that all of the expressions represent compositions of terms from the deformation of an iterated composition of all four maps , and thus , all representing parallel maps , can all be added .
@xmath173_{(\overline{ab}c)d } & & & \odot \\ .\ar[ru]_{\overline{ab}c}\ar[rrr]^{cd } & & & .\ar[ru]^{\overline{ab}(cd ) } & \\ & & & & \\ & .\ar@{-->}[uuu]_{a(bc)}\ar@{-->}[rrr]^{(bc)d } & & & .\ar[uuu]^{a(b\overline{cd})}\\ \circ\ar[uuu]_{ab}\ar@{-->}[ru]_{bc}\ar[rrr]^{cd } & & & .\ar[ru]^{b\overline{cd}}\ar[uuu]^{ab } & } \ ] ] + the proof then proceeds by iteratively `` clearing '' edges shared by two squares with the same sign by rewriting terms involving that edge s label contributed by one square using the cobounding and cocycle condition from the other square sharing the edge until the expression is reduced to two copies of the obstruction - type expression on an equatorial hexagon , with opposite signs .
this observation , that gerstenhaber s proof can be encoded by such a figure , then motivates a sequence of definitions and lemmas that allow for similar encoding of more general and complex proofs of the same sort .
shrestha s technique @xcite is most quickly and rigorously described by labeling 1-cells of certain pasting schemes and computads ( cf .
@xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) with well - formed expressions in a particular ( essentially ) algebraic theory : a _ directed polygon _
@xmath174 is a 2-computad with a single 2-cell , all of whose 0- and 1-cells lie in the boundary of the 2-cell .
a _ whiskered polygon _
@xmath175 is a 2-computad with a single 2-cell @xmath174 , whose underlying 1-computad is the union of two 1-dimensional pasting schemes ( directed paths ) , with the same 0-domain and 0-codomain , whose underlying cell complex is contractible .
we refer to the 1-dimensional pasting scheme consisting of the path from the 0-domain of @xmath175 to the 0-domain of @xmath174 as the _ domain whisker _
( note : it may be simply a 0-cell ) , and the 1-dimensional pasting scheme consisting of the path from the 0-codomain of @xmath174 to the 0-codomain of @xmath175 as the _ codomain whisker _
( again it may simply be a 0-cell ) .
a _ tiled sphere _ is a 3-computad with a single 3-cell , all of whose 0- , 1- and 2-cells lie in the boundary of the 3-cell . in applying the method in a given circumstance
, one needs to label the edges of tiled spheres with arrow - valued operations from a theory associated to the pasting diagram ( or more general structure ) .
for the present application the following suffice : [ theory_of_diagram ] to any pasting diagram @xmath3 , _ theory of _
@xmath3 , @xmath176 , is the essentially algebraic theory with types @xmath177 and @xmath178 for each category @xmath52 in the diagram ( the objects of @xmath52 and the arrows of @xmath52 respectively ) and operations * @xmath179 of arity @xmath177 and type @xmath178 , * @xmath180 and @xmath181 of arity @xmath178 and type @xmath177 , and * @xmath182 of arity @xmath183 and type @xmath178 for each category @xmath52 in @xmath3 ; * @xmath184 of arity @xmath177 and type @xmath185 and * @xmath186 of arity @xmath178 and type @xmath187 for each functor @xmath188 in @xmath3 ; and * @xmath28 of arity @xmath177 and type @xmath187 for each natural transformation @xmath60 for @xmath189 in @xmath3 . and , with axioms the equations expressing the axioms of categories for each 6-tuple @xmath190 , the functoriality of each @xmath191 and the naturality of each @xmath28 .
we term operations of type @xmath178 for any @xmath52 `` arrow - valued '' and those of type @xmath177 for any @xmath52 `` object - valued '' , and refer to the model of @xmath176 given by @xmath3 as the `` tautologous model '' . in other applications of the method , as in @xcite @xmath176 may be replaced with an extension of the theory ( for instance including operations of arity @xmath192 and type @xmath193 encoding monoidal product of two arrows ) .
we conjecture that broader generalizations , for instance to deformations of @xmath163-tuple categories and ( weak ) @xmath163- categories with a @xmath0-linear structure on their @xmath163-arrows , and to suitable pasting diagrams of these , or even to models of other sorts of essentially algebraic theories ( cf .
@xcite ) with appropriate linearizations of parts of the structure , can be described , but do not pursue this possibility here .
notice a subtlety in the description of the axioms of @xmath176 in definition [ theory_of_diagram ] : the only axioms are those inherited from the axioms of categories , functors and natural transformations . in the definition [ parallels ] , on the contrary ,
all of the equations which hold in the diagram @xmath3 are enforced .
[ parallels ] the _ theory of parallels _ @xmath194 for a pasting diagram @xmath3 is the essentially algebraic theory with the same types and object valued operations as @xmath176 and with arrow - valued operations given by all set functions @xmath195 with the same domain and codomain as the instantiation of an arrow - valued operation @xmath196 of @xmath176 in the tautologous model and satisfying @xmath197 and @xmath198 ( we call @xmath195 _ a parallel _ for @xmath196 ) , and all equations that hold among ( iterated generalized ) compositions of these functions as axioms
. notice in neither definition did we include any addition or scalar multiplication operations induced by the @xmath0-linear structure on the categories , even though we are only applying these constructions to pasting diagrams of @xmath0-linear categories , @xmath0-linear functors and natural transformations .
however , when applied to such a pasting diagram , the vector space structure on the hom - sets induces a vector space structure on the set of parallels for any arrow - valued operation @xmath196 of @xmath176 .
given a ( countably infinite ) stock of variables of each type in the theory it is evident what is meant by a well - formed formula ( wff ) of the theory .
we now make some technical definitions : an _ equivalent _ of a wff is any wff of the same type in the same variables such that for every instantiation of the variables in the two formulas , the values are equal . in what follows , for brevity we will refer to well - formed subformulas of a wff as wfss .
when considered as wfss of a fixed wff @xmath175 , repetitions of equal wffs are considered distinct wfss . with this convention ,
the following ( a generality about wfss of a wff in any formal system ) is immediate : the wfss of a wff @xmath175 form a partially ordered set @xmath199 under @xmath200 when @xmath201 is a wfs of @xmath202 , and the incidence diagram of @xmath199 is a tree .
thus @xmath199 admits a natural number valued depth function @xmath203 for which @xmath204 and whenever @xmath202 covers @xmath201 , @xmath205 .
the minimal elements ( in the order - theoretic sense , not just those of maximum depth ) for @xmath199 are instances of variables .
we denote the subposet of non - minimal wfss of @xmath175 by @xmath206 a _ well - formed labeling _ of a whiskered polygon ( resp .
tiled sphere ) is an assignment @xmath207 to each directed 1-cell of arrow - valued wff in @xmath176 for some pasting diagram ( or an appropriate extension of this theory ) with the properties * edges are not labeled with variables ( i.e. all labels involve an operation in the theory ) . * for each 1-pasting scheme ( directed path ) @xmath208 from the 0-domain of the whiskered polygon ( resp .
tiled sphere ) the labels @xmath209 can be iteratively replaced , beginning at the 0-codomain , with labels @xmath210 such that * * if the only proper wfss of @xmath211 are variables then @xmath212 .
* * for all @xmath213 @xmath214 is equivalent to @xmath211 .
* * in the list of replacement labels @xmath210 , for each @xmath214 , if @xmath215 is a wff occuring @xmath216 times as a non - minimal wfs of @xmath214 , then there exist @xmath216 distinct @xmath217 s with @xmath218 such that @xmath219 .
* if @xmath208 is a maximal directed path in a whiskered polygon ( resp .
tiled sphere ) , the replacement labels @xmath210 are precisely the non - minimal wfss of @xmath220 .
* for every 2-cell , and every maximal extension of the 2-cell to a whiskered polygon , the labels of the final edges of the two paths from the 0-domain to the 0-codomain of the whiskered polygon are equivalents .
( note this condition is vacuously true unless the 0-codomain of the 2-cell is the 0-codomain of the whiskered polygon . )
the following is then immediate : for any maximal path @xmath208 in a whiskered polygon ( resp .
tiled sphere ) the totally ordered set of wff s @xmath221 is a totalization of the partially ordered set @xmath222 .
# 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 3885,7414)(1816,-7874 ) ( 2206,-5356 ) ( 0,-1)1275 ( 2206,-6646 ) ( 4,-3)1112 ( 3316,-7456 ) ( 1 , 0)1530 ( 4426,-4186 ) ( 4,-3)1080 ( 5536,-5041 ) ( 0,-1)1605 ( 5558,-6669)(-1,-1)735 ( 2926,-4111)(-2 , 3)750 ( 2206,-2956 ) ( 0 , 1)1275 ( 2206,-1666 ) ( 4 , 3)1112 ( 3316,-856 ) ( 1 , 0)1530 ( 4426,-4126 ) ( 4 , 3)1080 ( 5536,-3271 ) ( 0 , 1)1605 ( 5558,-1643)(-1 , 1)735 ( 3016,-4156 ) ( 1 , 0)1350 ( 3001,-4261 ) ( 0,-1)1350 ( 2963,-5657)(-3,-4)642 ( 3031,-4231 ) ( 1,-1)765 ( 3841,-5011 ) ( 1 , 0)1560 ( 3061,-5641 ) ( 3,-2)675 ( 3751,-5056 ) ( 0,-1)975 ( 3796,-6091 ) ( 3,-4)945 ( 2251,-2986 ) ( 1 , 0)1320 ( 3946,-1696 ) ( 1 , 0)1485 ( 3871,-1726)(-2 , 3)550 ( 3608,-2913 ) ( 1 , 4)285 ( 4321,-4111)(-2 , 3)750 ( 1831,-2326)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2176,-1126)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2641,-2806)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3871,-2371)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3706,-1246)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3661,-631)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2161,-3706)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5296,-1096)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3991,-3361)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3241,-3976)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5041,-3886)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5686,-2566)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2071,-4621)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5071,-4501)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5671,-6061)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1831,-6046)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2161,-7411)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3541,-7801)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5356,-7261)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2746,-5131)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4426,-5281)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2581,-6391)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3496,-4516)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3841,-5581)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2971,-6121)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4201,-6406)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2416,-5491)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2956,-3421)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4111,-4606)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4351,-1981)(0,0)[lb ] an example of a well - formed labeling of a tiled sphere is given in figure [ functor_obstructions_are_cocycles ] .
( the boundaries of the two octogons bordering the unbounded region should be identified along the edges with the same labels , and the 3-cell inserted to fill the resulting topological sphere . )
this particular example arises in applying the method to show that the obstructions to deforming ( the arrow part of ) a functor , when the compositions in its source and target categories are also being deformed , are cocycles .
note that in the labeling , at one point notation has been abused and @xmath223 has been used in place of either of the equivalent wffs @xmath224 or @xmath225 .
it is also easy to see along which paths the label - replacement axiom wf1 results in non - trival replacements of labels ( as , for instance along any path ending in the top right - most edge in which @xmath226 occurs , rather than @xmath227 : the label of the top right - most edge must be replaced with @xmath228 ) .
now each arrow - valued operation is a part of the algebraic structure which is subject to infinitesimal deformation , by being replaced by a formal power - series ( or polynomial in @xmath229 with @xmath230 for some @xmath163 ) whose coefficients are arrow - valued operations of the same type and arity ( e.g. the arrow part of a functor @xmath188 is replaced with @xmath231 where for each @xmath232 , @xmath233 is a map from @xmath234 to @xmath235 ) . from this
, we abstract consider any set of arrow - valued operations @xmath236 in @xmath176 for some @xmath3 .
fix @xmath237 .
to each arrow - valued operation @xmath238 associate a sequence of parallels @xmath239 in the sense of definition [ parallels ] ( truncated at @xmath240 if @xmath241 ) with @xmath242 .
we call @xmath239 _ the degree @xmath0 parallel of @xmath243 _ , and a choice @xmath244 of such a sequence for every operation in @xmath236 , _ a degree @xmath163 family of parallels for @xmath236 _ now , for any well - formed labeling of a whiskered polygon or tiled sphere with , let @xmath236 be the set of all arrow - valued operations occuring in the labels of the edges , closed under equivalence . every family of parallels for @xmath236 , then gives rise to many labelings of the maximal paths of the whiskered polygon or tiled sphere by wffs from @xmath194 by replacing the labels along the path using wf1 , then for each edge , chosing a degree @xmath0 and replacing the last - applied operation @xmath243 in the label on that edge with @xmath239 in the label for that edge and all edges later in the path for which the label on the given edge as a wfs . in particular , any such choice of degrees for each edge along a path from the 0-domain to the 0-codomain creates a new wff in @xmath194 .
suppose the sequence of labels on a maximal path was @xmath245 , where each @xmath246 denotes a well - formed expression all of whose iterated inputs have an equivalent among the labels earlier in the sequence , and by abuse of notion also that well - formed expression s last - applied operation .
a choice of degrees @xmath247 then produces a new sequence of well - formed expression @xmath248 in which each instance of an operation has been replaced with its parallel of the chosen degree in that and all later edge - labels .
note : in general these new labelings are not well - formed labelings . at this point ,
recall that all of this is taking place in a linear setting , so that parallel arrows ( and thus parallels ) can be added .
we will now define several different expressions which a system of parallels associates to a whiskered polygon .
[ conditions_and_obstructions ] for any well - formed labeling of a whiskered polygon @xmath175 , @xmath236 the set of operations occuring in the replacement labelings of both paths , and @xmath244 a family of parallels for @xmath236 , let @xmath249 ( resp .
@xmath250 ) be the replacement labeling on the maximal path which traverses domain ( resp .
codomain ) of the 2-cell .
the _ cocycle - type condition _ associated to @xmath175 is the equation @xmath251 the _
@xmath252 order obstruction - type expression _ associated to @xmath175 is the expression @xmath253 and , the _
@xmath252 order cobounding - type condition _ associated to @xmath175 is the expression @xmath254 in each case , the string of parallels should be understood as naming the well - formed experssion obtained by the iterated substitution of the named parallel for the corresponding operation in the well - formed expression labeling the last edge of the path .
the following then provides the basis for shrestha s method : [ elementary ] for any well - formed labeling of a tiled sphere @xmath255 with 3-cell @xmath256 , @xmath236 the set of operations occuring in the replacement labelings of all paths , and @xmath244 a family of parallels for @xmath236 , the domain ( resp .
codomain ) of @xmath256 can be expressed as the union of whiskered polygons with the same 0-domain and 0-codomain as @xmath255 , one with each 2-cell in @xmath257 ( resp .
@xmath258 ) as its 2-cell in such a way that the sum of the @xmath252 order obstruction - type expressions for the whiskered polygons is the @xmath252 order obstruction - type expression for the ( whiskered ) polygon consisting of a single 2-cell and the union of the 1-pasting schemes @xmath259 and @xmath260 . once the combinatorial structure of power s proof of the the uniqueness of pasting compositions @xcite is recalled , the result is immediate
sums cancel in pairs leaving only the difference giving the desired @xmath252 order obstruction - type expression .
unfortunately , as it stands , the result is not immediately applicable . recall the cube encoding gerstenhaber s proof .
any face is part of a whiskered polygon ( with one whisker having one edge , and the other having none ) .
the @xmath252 order obstruction is given by @xmath261 the terms in its coboundary are _ not _ @xmath252 order obstruction - type expressions associated to the faces of their cubes with their whiskers . the @xmath252 order obstruction type expressions are , instead , instances of @xmath262 with the obstruction and a variable as inputs , or instances of the obstruction with one of its variables replaced with @xmath262 applied to two variables .
what then is the relationship between actual @xmath252 order obstructions and @xmath252 order obstruction - type expressions ? if one considers one of the whiskered polygons in the example , it is easy to see that the terms in the @xmath252 order obstruction - type expression which do not correspond to terms from the coboundary of the obstruction have a label of positive degree on the edge of the whisker . if we fix the label on the whisker edge to be of degree @xmath263 , the terms with this label are then the condition that @xmath264 cobound the degree @xmath265 obstruction ( or the cocycle condition if @xmath266 ) with @xmath267 of two variables as argument ( resp . used as input to an instance of @xmath267 ) when the non - trivial whisker is the domain ( resp .
codomain ) whisker . in this case , provided the system of parallels is describing the terms of an associative deformation , the @xmath252 order obstruction - type expression is thus equal to the corresponding term in the coboundary of the @xmath252 order obstruction , since its extra terms all vanish by the cocycle and cobounding conditions . to imitate this in general , we need conditions depending only on the labels on the domain and codomain of the 2-cell in a whiskered polygon which ensures that the cocycle- and cobounding - type conditions in all lower degrees hold . as in definition [ conditions_and_obstructions ]
consider a whiskered polygon @xmath175 with 2-cell @xmath174 and let @xmath249 ( resp .
@xmath250 ) be the replacement labeling on the maximal path which traverses domain ( resp .
codomain ) of @xmath174 .
suppose the first @xmath268 edges lie in the domain whisker . in this case , for @xmath269 , @xmath246 and @xmath270
are equivalents , and the orderings on the edge labels of the domain whisker induced by restricting the partial orderings on @xmath271 and @xmath272 coincide .
let @xmath273 be the resulting partially ordered set of equivalence classes of wffs .
[ strong_vanishing ] given a well - formed labeling of a whiskered polygon @xmath175 with 2-cell @xmath174 , let @xmath236 be the set of operations occuring in the replacement labelings of both paths , and @xmath244 a family of parallels for @xmath236 .
recall that @xmath274 is the theory of parallels for @xmath175 ( and thus includes the elements of @xmath244 .
let @xmath268 and @xmath273 be as in the discussion above . and
suppose the last @xmath275 edges of each path lie in the codomain whisker .
the _ @xmath252 order strong vanishing condition _ associated to @xmath175 ( for @xmath276 ) is the condition that @xmath277 where the hatting of wffs indicates the result of the following process : for each maximal element of @xmath273 select a variable of the same type which does not occur in among the variables used in the labeling ; the hatted wff is the result of replacing all wfss in that equivalence class with the corresponding variable ; and the universal quantification ranges over all parallels in @xmath274 to the labels on the corresponding edge of the codomain whisker .
we then have [ strong_works ] for any well - formed labeling of a whiskered polygon @xmath175 with operations @xmath278 and a family of parallels @xmath279 , the @xmath280 order strong vanishing condition implies the cocycle - type condition , the @xmath281 order strong vanishing condition implies the @xmath281 order cobounding - type condition , and , moreover , if the @xmath281 order vanishing conditions hold for all @xmath282 , then the @xmath252 order coboundary - type expression is equal to @xmath283 where @xmath268 and @xmath275 are as in the previous definition and the meanings of the sequences of wffs are as in definition [ conditions_and_obstructions ] .
the cocycle - type condition simply an instantiation of the @xmath280 order strong vanishing condition , while the @xmath281 order cobounding - type condition is the sum of all instantiations of the @xmath281 order strong vanishing condition ranging over all choices of parallels for the labels of edges in the whiskers . for the last statement ,
notice that the terms in the @xmath252 order coboundary - type expression which are not represented in the expression of the proposition all have at least one label on an edge of one of the whiskers which is of positive degree .
these terms can be partitioned into subsets which according to the degrees of the labels in the whiskers . for each choice of degrees for the labels in the whiskers , the terms are an instatiation of the strong cocycle - type condition , and thus add to zero .
two sorts of whiskered polygons satisfying the strong vanishing conditions arise in practice : `` non - trivial '' whiskered polygons in which the strong vanishing conditions follow from the well - formedness of the labeling and deformation theoretic cocycle and cobounding conditions satisfied by the parallels of the labels in the boundary of the 2-cell , and `` trivial '' whiskered polygons in which the sets of edge labels on the domain and codomain of the 2-cell differ only by changing the choice of totalization of the partial order on wfss of the final label in the path and substitution of equivalent wffs .
we formalize this in the following propositions : [ nontrivial ] given a well - formed labeling of a whiskered polygon @xmath175 with 2-cell @xmath174 , let @xmath236 be the set of operations occuring in the replacement labelings of both paths , and @xmath244 a family of parallels for @xmath236 .
let @xmath268 , @xmath275 , @xmath0 , @xmath284 and @xmath273 and the hatting of wffs be as definition [ strong_vanishing ] .
if @xmath285 and @xmath286 are a well - formed labeling of the directed polygon @xmath174 , then @xmath175 satisfies the @xmath287 order strong vanishing condition .
if , moreover , this labeling of @xmath174 and the system of parallels satisfy the cocycle - type condition ( resp .
the @xmath252 order cobounding - type condition ) then the well - formed labeling of @xmath175 and system of parallels satisfies the @xmath280 order ( resp .
@xmath252 order strong vanishing condition ) .
notice first that the condition that the labeling of @xmath174 be well - formed means that the wff labeling the two edges incident with the 0-codomain of @xmath174 are equivalents , and thus their difference ( as an arrow - valued operation ) vanishes .
the well - formedness may thus be viewed as a zeroth order analogue of the cocycle - type and cobounding - type relations .
the proposition is immediate once it is observed that at each order the strong vanishing condition on @xmath175 is simply the result of applying the parallels to labels on the codomain whisker to the terms of the expression of that order which vanishes on @xmath174 . in practice
the labels on @xmath174 come from an equational condition ( associativity , functoriality , or naturality in the present work ) and the cocycle - type and cobounding - type conditions are actual cocycle and cobounding conditions derived from the requirement that deformations preserve the equational condition , while the whiskers arise in taking coboundaries of the corresponding obstruction . [ trivial ] given a well - formed labeling of a whiskered polygon @xmath175 with 2-cell @xmath174 , let @xmath268 , @xmath275 , @xmath0 , @xmath284 , and @xmath273 and the hatting of wffs be as definition [ strong_vanishing ] .
if @xmath288 and @xmath285 is obtained from @xmath286 by changing the totalization of the partial ordering on the wfss of the label on the edge(s ) incident with the 0-codomain of @xmath175 and replacing wffs with equivalents , then the well - formed label of @xmath175 satisfies the strong vanishing conditions of all orders for any system of parallels . in this case for any choice of parallels labels on edges of the codomain whisker , and of degrees in a system of parallels for the corresponding @xmath289 and @xmath290 , the resulting expressions for the two paths are equivalent and thus their difference is zero , and summing over all such choices of total order @xmath291 gives the @xmath281 order strong vanishing condition for @xmath175 .
we refer to whiskered polygons equipped with a labeling satifying the hypotheses of proposition [ trivial ] as trivial whiskered polygons .
finally , we need to describe in general the relationship between the cohomological description of infinitesimal deformations and the evident expression of the same data in terms of systems of parallels and the various expressions given by labeling of ( whiskered ) polygons and tiled spheres . if @xmath3 is a @xmath0-linear pasting diagram , @xmath176 its theory , or an extension thereof with the same types , its deformation theory is _ polygonizable _ if the cochain group in which cocycles specify first order deformations admits a direct sum decomposition indexed a family of equational axioms of the theory each of which can be expressed as the vanishing of the difference of the values of the paths in a well - formed labeling of a directed polygon ( we call such a polygon equipped with its well - formed labeling an _ axiomatic polygon _ ) , and which , moreover satisfy * the vanishing of each direct summand of the cocycle is precisely the cocycle - type condition associated to the axiomatic polygon indexing the direct summand . * each direct summand of the @xmath252 order obstruction is the obsturuction - type expression associated to the axiomatic polygon indexing the direct summand .
* the cobounding condition for the extension of a deformation to the next degree is the direct sum of the cobounding - type conditions associated to the axiomatic polygons . * and the coboundary of an obstruction admits a direct sum decomposition in which each direct summand is a signed sum of expressions specified by labeling whiskered polygons with the polygon labeled by the obstruction , and the whiskers labeled by operations of @xmath176 ( degree 0 labels in the system of parallels naming the deformation terms ) .
we are now in a position to state a theorem which encapsulates shrestha s polygonal method for our purposes : if @xmath176 is the theory of a pasting diagram , or an extension thereof , and admits a polygonizable deformation theory , then all obstructions are cocycles , provided for each direct summand of the coboundary of the obstruction , there exists a tiled sphere , and a well - formed labeling of the tiled sphere with the properties * each whiskered polygon naming a summand in the signed sum of p4 occurs exactly once in the tiled sphere either in the domain ( resp .
codomain ) if its sign is positive ( resp .
negative ) , or with its domain and codomain swapped and in the codomain ( resp .
domain ) if its sign is positive ( resp .
negative ) .
* every 2-cell which is not part of the whiskered polygons of s1 is trivial in the sense of proposition [ trivial ] this follows immediately from propositions [ elementary ] , [ strong_works ] , [ nontrivial ] and [ trivial ] .
figures 1 through 6 then establish the following : [ singlecomposition ] if @xmath3 is a pasting diagram with a single instance of composing two natural transformations or of composing a natural transformation with a functor , then all obstructions to its deformation are cocycles . in principal , it appears , one could apply the polygonal method to directly show that obstructions to the deformation of any given ( arbitrarily complicated ) pasting diagram are cocycles however a metatheorem to this effect has proved to be beyond the authors capabilities . instead , we will approach the general problem indirectly by reducing the deformations of any pasting diagram to deformations of a related pasting diagram all of whose cells are one of a small finite set of forms , provided one can specify that certain cells are deformed trivially : the composition - free pasting diagrams for which the result was established in @xcite , those of [ singlecomposition ] and a short list of diagrams in which specified cells are deformed trivially : triangles and solid tetrahedra all of whose faces are identity natural transformations and are deformed trivially , and two diagrams derived from those of examples [ equalspost1comp ] and [ equalspre1comp ] by replacing the ( degenerate ) square labeled by @xmath13 with a bigon whose edged are labeled by the composite functors and two triangles labeled with the identity arrows of the composite functors , which must be deformed trivially .
# 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 6350,8297)(721,-8943 ) ( 1741,-4486 ) ( 3,-1)1365 ( 3091,-4906 ) ( 1 , 0)1785 ( 4936,-4891 ) ( 4 , 1)1352 ( 6271,-4531 ) ( 1 , 2)788 ( 916,-6886 ) ( 1 , 2)810 ( 1741,-5326 ) ( 3 , 1)1365 ( 3091,-4906 ) ( 1 , 0)1785 ( 4936,-4921 ) ( 4,-1)1352 ( 6271,-5281 ) ( 1,-2)788 ( 916,-6916 ) ( 1,-2)810 ( 1741,-8476 ) ( 3,-1)1365 ( 3091,-8896 ) ( 1 , 0)1785 ( 4936,-8881 ) ( 4 , 1)1352 ( 6271,-8521 ) ( 1 , 2)788 ( 916,-2986 ) ( 1 , 2)810 ( 1741,-1426 ) ( 3 , 1)1365 ( 3091,-1006 ) ( 1 , 0)1785 ( 4936,-1021 ) ( 4,-1)1352 ( 6271,-1381 ) ( 1,-2)788 ( 1699,-5302 ) ( 1,-2)825 ( 1717,-8464 ) ( 1 , 2)773 ( 5446,-6871 ) ( 1 , 2)773 ( 5461,-6901 ) ( 1,-2)803 ( 2581,-6916 ) ( 1 , 0)2775 ( 946,-2986 ) ( 1 , 0)1620 ( 2551,-2986 ) ( 1 , 1)795 ( 2573,-3023 ) ( 1,-1)795 ( 4906,-2281 ) ( 3,-1)2100 ( 4872,-3732 ) ( 3 , 1)2100 ( 3301,-2236 ) ( 1 , 0)1590 ( 3391,-3796 ) ( 1 , 0)1455 ( 3076,-1036 ) ( 1,-4)293 ( 3046,-4876 ) ( 1 , 4)259 ( 4861,-1036 ) ( 0,-1)1170 ( 4876,-4906 ) ( 0 , 1)1065 ( 871,-2011)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1921,-1021)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3961,-766)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5461,-886)(0,0)[lb ] ( 6856,-1891)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1681,-2806)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2356,-1651)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2461,-2521)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3961,-2026)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4966,-1651)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5521,-2281)(0,0)[lb ] ( 811,-3961)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2281,-3496)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2056,-4501)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2296,-4171)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3916,-3616)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3751,-4741)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5176,-3346)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3916,-6691)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3886,-8686)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4966,-4366)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5521,-4531)(0,0)[lb ] ( 6766,-3886)(0,0)[lb ] ( 766,-6031)(0,0)[lb ] ( 736,-7831)(0,0)[lb ] ( 6766,-8101)(0,0)[lb ] ( 6871,-5986)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2191,-5446)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5236,-5371)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5206,-8626)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2266,-8551)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1651,-7516)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1696,-6361)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5191,-6091)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5191,-7756)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3991,-1456)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4066,-4276)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1441,-6856)(0,0)[lb ] # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 7742,9379)(331,-10274 ) ( 1096,-8626 ) ( 1,-1)900 ( 2026,-9526 ) ( 4,-1)1364 ( 3481,-9871 ) ( 1 , 0)2010 ( 5566,-9871 ) ( 3 , 1)1245 ( 6841,-9376 ) ( 1 , 1)735 ( 736,-7081 ) ( 1 , 1)930 ( 1726,-6106 ) ( 3 , 1)1230 ( 5450,-5673 ) ( 3,-1)1170 ( 6750,-6177 ) ( 4,-3)1260 ( 691,-4111 ) ( 1 , 4)360 ( 1096,-2656 ) ( 1 , 1)900 ( 2026,-1756 ) ( 4 , 1)1364 ( 3481,-1411 ) ( 1 , 0)2010 ( 5566,-1411 ) ( 3,-1)1245 ( 6841,-1906 ) ( 1,-1)735 ( 7606,-2701 ) ( 1,-3)455 ( 736,-4201 ) ( 1,-1)930 ( 1726,-5176 ) ( 3,-1)1230 ( 3016,-5611 ) ( 1 , 0)2325 ( 5450,-5609 ) ( 3 , 1)1170 ( 6750,-5105 ) ( 4 , 3)1260 ( 766,-4171 ) ( 4 , 1)1352 ( 2116,-3781 ) ( 1 , 3)370 ( 1981,-1876 ) ( 2,-3)470 ( 2596,-2656 ) ( 1 , 0)1950 ( 4597,-2668 ) ( 3,-1)1245 ( 5896,-3091 ) ( 2,-1)2056 ( 2116,-3886 ) ( 2,-1)1170 ( 3016,-5536 ) ( 1 , 4)251 ( 6016,-4591 ) ( 4 , 1)1800 ( 3316,-4531 ) ( 1 , 0)2655 ( 5371,-5566 ) ( 2 , 3)620 ( 1126,-8521 ) ( 3 , 4)900 ( 1681,-6241 ) ( 1,-3)350 ( 1186,-8581 ) ( 1 , 0)1290 ( 2506,-8611 ) ( 3,-4)888 ( 2056,-7321 ) ( 4,-1)1064 ( 2491,-8566 ) ( 2 , 3)640 ( 3136,-7621 ) ( 1 , 0)2655 ( 5881,-7591 ) ( 1 , 2)728 ( 5836,-7681 ) ( 2,-1)1740 ( 7600,-8509 ) ( 1 , 3)455 ( 5447,-1464)(-3,-4)822 ( 6725,-1905)(-3,-4)822 ( 4051,-5401)(0,0)[lb ] ( 6181,-1411)(0,0)[lb ] ( 6196,-9901)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4531,-4471)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5281,-2791)(0,0)[lb ] ( 346,-3226)(0,0)[lb ] ( 961,-2146)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1246,-3826)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2011,-1336)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3901,-1066)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2371,-3346)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2266,-2071)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3136,-2941)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3646,-1981)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5086,-2251)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5581,-3616)(0,0)[lb ] ( 7231,-1906)(0,0)[lb ] ( 6076,-3166)(0,0)[lb ] ( 7291,-9271)(0,0)[lb ] ( 6211,-7621)(0,0)[lb ] ( 436,-8071)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1156,-9286)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2161,-10006)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4051,-10201)(0,0)[lb ] ( 736,-4831)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2056,-5086)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3286,-5041)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2686,-3976)(0,0)[lb ] ( 736,-6466)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2176,-6286)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4846,-5086)(0,0)[lb ] ( 6256,-4201)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5851,-5221)(0,0)[lb ] ( 7591,-4741)(0,0)[lb ] ( 6061,-5776)(0,0)[lb ] ( 7501,-6541)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4426,-7426)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1996,-6781)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1276,-7726)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2491,-7306)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1471,-8476)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2371,-8101)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3016,-9121)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5521,-6691)(0,0)[lb ] ( 6031,-8296)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1261,-6991)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2056,-7891)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2146,-9226)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4351,-5086)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5746,-1921)(0,0)[lb ] # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 7968,9132)(1309,-10003 ) ( 5963,-2333 ) ( 1 , 1)1095 ( 4366,-2341 ) ( 1 , 0)1485 ( 7051,-4726 ) ( 4 , 1)2116 ( 6151,-4171 ) ( 3,-2)840 ( 3496,-4981 ) ( 3 , 1)1242.900 ( 4739,-4567 ) ( 3 , 1)1322.100 ( 1430,-4293 ) ( 3,-1)2085 ( 7051,-3526 ) ( 4,-1)2116 ( 6151,-4081 ) ( 3 , 2)840 ( 3496,-3271 ) ( 3,-1)1242.900 ( 4739,-3685 ) ( 3,-1)1322.100 ( 1430,-3959 ) ( 3 , 1)2085 ( 3264,-7066 ) ( 1 , 1)1095 ( 5941,-5949 ) ( 1,-1)1095 ( 4344,-5941 ) ( 1 , 0)1485 ( 1321,-4111 ) ( 2 , 3)1970 ( 3361,-1201 ) ( 1 , 0)3750 ( 7126,-1216 ) ( 3,-4)2139 ( 1332,-4135 ) ( 2,-3)1970 ( 7100,-6996 ) ( 3 , 4)2139 ( 3331,-7081 ) ( 1 , 0)3750 ( 5911,-2386 ) ( 1,-1)1140 ( 3451,-3196 ) ( 1 , 1)855 ( 3474,-5019 ) ( 1,-1)855 ( 5850,-5881 ) ( 1 , 1)1140 ( 3286,-9961 ) ( 1 , 0)3750 ( 2327,-8497 ) ( 2 , 3)900 ( 2372,-8590 ) ( 2,-3)900 ( 7066,-7126 ) ( 2,-3)900 ( 7021,-9871 ) ( 2 , 3)900 ( 3046,-2776)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3406,-4156)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3031,-5716)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5071,-1681)(0,0)[lb ] ( 7261,-4096)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1876,-5881)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1906,-2221)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3661,-3646)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3751,-4651)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2356,-4441)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3541,-1891)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2356,-3436)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5266,-4711)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5131,-5716)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4951,-2236)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4951,-991)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5056,-6886)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3916,-6586)(0,0)[lb ] ( 6496,-6271)(0,0)[lb ] ( 6541,-1951)(0,0)[lb ] ( 8116,-2146)(0,0)[lb ] ( 8326,-5881)(0,0)[lb ] ( 6511,-5461)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4006,-5356)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4006,-2881)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5206,-3661)(0,0)[lb ] ( 6106,-3676)(0,0)[lb ] ( 6001,-4621)(0,0)[lb ] ( 7576,-3421)(0,0)[lb ] ( 7186,-4396)(0,0)[lb ] ( 6436,-2656)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4951,-9781)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2611,-7306)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2251,-9376)(0,0)[lb ] ( 7651,-7621)(0,0)[lb ] ( 7606,-9421)(0,0)[lb ] # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 6519,9027)(961,-9493 ) ( 1726,-8701 ) ( 2,-1)1516 ( 3316,-9451 ) ( 1 , 0)2610 ( 5896,-9421 ) ( 3 , 4)1542 ( 3256,-841 ) ( 3,-2)1335 ( 4636,-1756 ) ( 4 , 3)1200 ( 3316,-5131 ) ( 3 , 2)1335 ( 4696,-4216 ) ( 4,-3)1200 ( 1756,-1651 ) ( 4,-1)2144 ( 3901,-2221 ) ( 3 , 2)645 ( 3976,-2296 ) ( 3,-2)1005 ( 1351,-2941 ) ( 1 , 4)341 ( 1726,-1561 ) ( 2 , 1)1516 ( 3316,-811 ) ( 1 , 0)2610 ( 5896,-841 ) ( 3,-4)1542 ( 1756,-4281 ) ( 4 , 1)2144 ( 3901,-3711 ) ( 3,-2)645 ( 3976,-3636 ) ( 3 , 2)1005 ( 1366,-7321 ) ( 1 , 4)341 ( 1741,-5941 ) ( 2 , 1)1516 ( 5911,-5221 ) ( 3,-4)1542 ( 1381,-3031 ) ( 1,-4)341 ( 1756,-4411 ) ( 2,-1)1516 ( 3346,-5161 ) ( 1 , 0)2610 ( 5926,-5131 ) ( 3 , 4)1542 ( 4981,-3016 ) ( 1 , 0)2400 ( 1021,-3721)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2461,-3916)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3841,-3226)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1081,-2161)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2371,-2116)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3766,-2641)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1636,-1036)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4501,-601)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3901,-1126)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4276,-2176)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3076,-1516)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5131,-1651)(0,0)[lb ] ( 6781,-1471)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5491,-2806)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4516,-5116)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3631,-4726)(0,0)[lb ] ( 976,-6721)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1006,-8131)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1651,-9391)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4321,-9391)(0,0)[lb ] ( 6661,-8896)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1621,-4861)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1561,-5581)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4261,-3841)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5281,-4471)(0,0)[lb ] ( 6781,-4291)(0,0)[lb ] ( 6796,-6046)(0,0)[lb ] # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 4974,5145)(904,-5071 ) ( 3226,-4761 ) ( 1 , 0)1215 ( 4470,-4750 ) ( 4 , 3)1396 ( 931,-3681 ) ( 3,-2)1185 ( 2131,-591 ) ( 3 , 1)1005 ( 3226,-291 ) ( 1 , 0)1215 ( 4470,-302 ) ( 4,-3)1396 ( 931,-1371 ) ( 3 , 2)1185 ( 916,-3656 ) ( 1 , 0)1335 ( 2326,-3641 ) ( 1 , 0)1005 ( 3406,-3641 ) ( 1 , 0)1080 ( 4516,-3641 ) ( 1 , 0)1350 ( 916,-3641 ) ( 3 , 2)1185 ( 916,-1396 ) ( 1 , 0)1335 ( 2326,-1411 ) ( 1 , 0)1005 ( 3406,-1411 ) ( 1 , 0)1080 ( 4516,-1411 ) ( 1 , 0)1350 ( 2116,-2861 ) ( 3 , 1)1005 ( 4455,-2572 ) ( 4,-3)1396 ( 916,-1411 ) ( 3,-2)1185 ( 2116,-2191 ) ( 3,-1)1005 ( 3211,-2491 ) ( 1 , 0)1215 ( 4455,-2480 ) ( 4 , 3)1396 ( 1036,-796)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2116,-226)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2266,-2041)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3706,-61)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3736,-1201)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5266,-436)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4591,-1201)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5281,-2056)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1546,-1261)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1066,-2011)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1111,-3091)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1561,-3526)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1171,-4321)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2356,-1231)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2311,-3001)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2461,-3511)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2071,-4921)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3796,-3541)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3706,-5056)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3676,-2386)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5251,-2971)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5056,-4636)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4666,-3436)(0,0)[lb ]
in @xcite deformations of a functor @xmath41 ( resp . a natural transformation @xmath19 ) in which the source and target are left undeformed ( or to say the same thing differently deformed trivially in the strong sense ) were shown to be governed by the hochschild complex @xmath292 ( resp .
@xmath1 ) . for the desired reduction we will need to consider deformations of pasting diagrams in which a natural transformation ( in particular the identity natural transformation ) is deformed trivially in the strong sense while its domains and codomains are deformed , possibly nontrivially . as a warm - up and for potential use in other applications , let us consider first the problem of deforming the ( pasting ) diagram @xmath3 consisting of two categories @xmath42 and @xmath109 and a functor @xmath38 , subject to the requirement that @xmath41 be deformed trivially . without the restriction that @xmath41
be deformed trivially , a(n @xmath293 order ) deformation would be determined by a family of parallels for the set of operations @xmath294 , the compositions in @xmath42 and @xmath109 and the arrow - part of @xmath41 satisfying the usual cocycle and cobounding conditions .
the restriction that @xmath41 be deformed trivially requires that all of the positive order parallels to @xmath41 be zero .
cohomologically , the triples of degree @xmath0 parallels @xmath295 ( in the absence of the triviality requirement ) lie in @xmath155 , the mapping cone on @xmath296 and satisfy cocycle ( @xmath297 ) and cobounding ( @xmath298 ) conditions .
the requirement that @xmath299 together with the coboundary condition thus implies that @xmath300 lies in @xmath301 .
in fact we have first order deformations of the ( pasting ) diagram @xmath3 consisting of two categories @xmath42 and @xmath109 and a functor @xmath38 , subject to the requirement that @xmath41 be deformed trivially are classified by the second cohomology of @xmath301 .
moreover all obstructions to deforming @xmath3 with @xmath41 deformed trivially are cocycles in the third cochain group of @xmath301 and an @xmath293 order deformation with @xmath41 deformed trivially can be extended to an @xmath302 order deformation with @xmath41 deformed trivially if and only if there is a degree 2 cochain in @xmath301 cobounding the degree @xmath163 obstruction .
the classification of first order deformations follows from the remarks above .
the rest of the proposition follows from the corresponding result in @xcite without the triviality restriction once it is shown that all obstructions , which _ a priori _ lie in the cone on @xmath303 lie in the kernel ( considered as a subcomplex under the obvious inclusion ) . as observed above
, @xmath300 lies in @xmath301 .
so suppose as an induction hypothesis that for all @xmath304 @xmath305 lies in @xmath301 ( or equivalently and more usefully @xmath306 ) .
the degree @xmath163 obstruction @xmath168 in the cone then has coordinates @xmath307,\ ] ] @xmath308,\ ] ] and @xmath309 the last vanishes since each term involves @xmath310 for some @xmath311 ( and in the latter sum all the @xmath312 are bilinear ) .
it thus remains only to show that @xmath313 of the first coordinate equals @xmath314 of the second .
computing @xmath315)\ ] ] @xmath316\ ] ] @xmath317\ ] ] in each case the equality holds by the induction hypothesis , and in the second case the bilinearity @xmath312 for each @xmath0 .
thus the proposition holds .
a similar result holds for deformations of a diagram consisting of two parallel functors @xmath49 and a natural transformation @xmath19 between them which is to be deformed trivially : without the triviality restriction , the deformation complex is the cone on @xmath318 . with the restriction , @xmath319 becomes the deformation complex : first order deformations of the pasting diagram @xmath3 consisting of two categories a pair of parallel functors @xmath49 , their sources and target and a natural transformation @xmath19 subject to the requirement that @xmath28 be deformed trivially are classified by the second cohomology of @xmath319 .
moreover all obstructions to deforming @xmath3 with @xmath28 deformed trivially are cocycles in the third cochain group of @xmath319 and an @xmath293 order deformation with @xmath28 deformed trivially can be extended to an @xmath302 order deformation with @xmath28 deformed trivially if and only if there is a degree 2 cochain in @xmath319 cobounding the degree @xmath163 obstruction .
the argument is essentially identical to that for the previous proposition , except for the calculation showing that obstructions , which _ a priori _ lie in the full deformation complex of @xmath3 lie in @xmath319 . to see that all obstructions lie in @xmath319 , consider figure [ naturality_obstructions_are_cocycles ] .
the condition that degree @xmath163 obstruction lies in @xmath319 is precisely the condition that the signed sum of the degree @xmath163 obstruction - type expressions associated to the non - trivial faces other than the three hexagons vanish , when all higher order parallels of @xmath28 are instantiated as 0 . but
observe that the other faces are all trivial or evaluate to 0 , in all degrees greater than 0 , trivially under the hypothesis that all higher order parallels of @xmath28 are 0 , so the result follows from the general principles of the polygonal method .
applying the same argument _ mutatis mutandis _ to figure [ nat_from_composition_obstructions_are_cocycles ] shows [ trivialtriangle ] first order deformations of the pasting diagram @xmath3 consisting of three categories @xmath320 and @xmath321 three functors @xmath38 , @xmath322 and @xmath323 and a natural transformation @xmath324 subject to the requirement that @xmath28 be deformed trivially are classified by the second cohomology of @xmath325 , where @xmath326:{\frak c}^\bullet(\partial d ) \rightarrow c^\bullet(g(f),h ) .\ ] ] where @xmath327 is the diagram obtained by omitting @xmath28 .
moreover all obstructions to deforming @xmath3 with @xmath28 deformed trivially are cocycles in the third cochain group of @xmath325 and an @xmath293 order deformation with @xmath28 deformed trivially can be extended to an @xmath302 order deformation with @xmath28 deformed trivially if and only if there is a degree 2 cochain in @xmath325 cobounding the degree @xmath163 obstruction . in the special case where @xmath328 and @xmath329 , it is intuitively clear that the deformations of @xmath3 in which @xmath28 is deformed trivially are completely determined by the deformation complex of the simpler diagram @xmath330 .
in fact we have [ reducestotwoedges ] in the deformation complex of the pasting diagram @xmath3 consisting of three categories @xmath320 and @xmath321 three functors @xmath38 , @xmath322 and @xmath331 and the natural transformation @xmath332 the complex @xmath325 where @xmath75 is as in proposition [ trivialtriangle ] is isomorphic to the deformation complex of the subdiagram @xmath330 . the obvious quotient map from the deformation complex of @xmath327 to @xmath333 is split by the obvious inclusion .
the kernel of the quotient map is easily seen to be isomorphic to @xmath325 , while the quotient of the inclusion is easily seen to be the deformation complex of @xmath334 . combining propositions [ uniontopushout ] , [ trivialtriangle ] and [ reducestotwoedges ] then gives [ trivialthreecell ] let @xmath3 be a pasting diagram which could arise by the following construction : begin with a computad consisting of a composable 1-pasting diagram with any number of edges , a single edge with the same domain and codomain as the 1-pasting diagram , a pair of 2-cells both with the resulting circle as boundary ( and a 3-cell , or not ) . now , triangulate each 2-cell in a way corresponding to any parenthesization of the edges of the original 1-pasting diagram . apply a map of pasting schemes to the underlying pasting scheme of @xmath335 such that the value of every 2-cell is an identity natural transformation with domain given by two composable functors and codomain given by their composition .
if @xmath3 is such a pasting diagram , then the single edge in the initial part of the construction is labeled with the composition of the initial 1-pasting diagram , and if , moreover , @xmath70 is the chain map from the deformations complex @xmath155 to the direct sum indexed by the triangular 2-cells of @xmath3 whose coordinate for a 2-cell @xmath336 with edges labeled by a composable pair of functors @xmath38 and @xmath322 and their composition @xmath337 is given by projection onto @xmath338 followed by the map @xmath75 of proposition [ trivialtriangle ] onto @xmath339 , then @xmath340 classifies the deformations of @xmath3 in which all of the identity natural transformations are deformed trivially , and is isomorphic to the deformation complex of the original composable 1-pasting diagram .
the key thing to note here is that because all triangulations of disks are shellable , the pasting diagram can be constructed out of the trivial triangles of proposition [ trivialtriangle ] by iterated pushouts with diagrams previously so constructed until a pushout of the two triangulated disks along their boundary is made , and that once the triviality condition are imposed the presence or absence of the 3-cell makes no difference to the kernel .
note also that a 2-dual form of proposition [ trivialthreecell ] in which all of the identity natural transformations have the composition as their domain and two composable functors as their codomain also holds with the same proof .
the proofs of propositions [ trivialtriangle ] and [ reducestotwoedges ] can be extended to show [ fatpost1comp ] let @xmath3 be the pasting diagram consisting of three categories @xmath341 , functors @xmath342 , the composite functors @xmath343 and @xmath344 , natural transformations @xmath19 , @xmath345 labeling bigons , and @xmath346 and @xmath347 labeling triangles with two edges labeled by the composands as domain and one edge labeled by the composition as codomain , and a single 3-cell asserting the commutativity of the diagram . letting @xmath70
be the map with one coordinate for each triangle given by @xmath75 of proposition [ trivialtriangle ] for that 2-cell , @xmath340 classifies the deformations of @xmath3 in which the two identity natural transformations are deformed trivially , and is isomorphic to the complex of example [ equalspost1comp ] . and
[ fatpre1comp ] let @xmath3 be the pasting diagram consisting of three categories @xmath341 , functors @xmath348 , the composite functors @xmath349 and @xmath350 , natural transformations @xmath19 , @xmath351 labeling bigons , and @xmath352 and @xmath353 labeling triangles with two edges labeled by the composands as domain and one edge labeled by the composition as codomain , and a single 3-cell asserting the commutativity of the diagram . letting @xmath70 be the map with one coordinate for each triangle given by @xmath75 of proposition [ trivialtriangle ] for that 2-cell , @xmath340 classifies the deformations of @xmath3 in which the two identity natural transformations are deformed trivially , and is isomorphic to the complex of example [ equalspre1comp ] .
observe , that the conclusion of both proposition [ fatpost1comp ] and [ fatpre1comp ] hold regardless of which part of the boundary ( two composable functors or their composition ) is the domain and which is the codomain of each of the triangular faces labeled with identity natural transformations .
we are now in a position to prove the main result : that the deformations of any pasting diagram are classified by deformation complex in which all obstructions to extending a deformation of order @xmath163 to a deformation of order @xmath354 are cocycles . to do this we will replace the diagram with a more complex diagram with simpler parts , whose deformation theory , when some of the 2-cells are required to be deformed trivially , coincides with that of the original pasting diagram .
a pasting diagram is _ finely divided _
if every 2-cell is either a bigon or a triangle labeled with the identity natural transformation , and every 3-cell is of one of the following forms : * a composition - free pillow with bigonal cross - section ( imposing the equality of two natural transformations between the same pair of functors ) * a diagram of the form in proposition [ trivialthreecell ] or its 2-dual * a `` triangular pillow '' as in example [ triangularpillow ] * a diagram of the form in example [ equalspost1comp ] * a diagram of the form in proposition [ fatpost1comp ] * a diagram of the form in example [ equalspre1comp ] * a diagram of the form in proposition [ fatpre1comp ] every pasting diagram @xmath3 can be replaced with a finely divided pasting diagram @xmath355 whose underlying cell complex is a subdivision of the underlying cell complex of @xmath3 and whose deformations when all identity natural transformations labeling triangles are deformed trivially are equivalent to deformations of @xmath3 .
begin by subdividing each 2-cell as follows : insert a bigon with 1-cells labeled by the 1-composition of the domain and codomain of the 2-cell and labeled by the same natural transformation as the original 2-cell , making the domain ( resp .
codomain ) of the bigon coincide with that of the original 2-cell if the domain ( resp .
codomain ) consists of a single 1-cell .
label the complementary cell(s ) with identity natural transformations to be deformed trivially .
now each of the complementary cells has a domain ( resp .
codomain ) which is a sequence of 1-cells labeled by functors and a codomain ( resp .
domain ) which is a single 1-cell labeled with their composition .
choose a parenthesization of the composition and subdivide the 2-cell in the usual way corresponding to a parenthesization , labeling the new 1-cells with the appropriate pairwise compositions of labels already present and all 2-cells with identity natural transformation ( to be deformed trivially ) .
now , for each 3-cell which is not already of one of the forms specified in the proposition , choose an order of pasting composition for the domain ( resp .
codomain ) , and use this to create a subdivision of the 3-cell as follows : iteratively , for each 1-composition of a natural transformation with a functor , insert a diagram of the form in proposition [ fatpost1comp ] or [ fatpre1comp ] as appropriate and for each binary 2-composition , insert a triangular pillow .
when this has been done for both the domain and codomain , there will be bigons labeled with the pasting compostion of the domain and codomain of the original 3-cell .
identify their domains ( resp .
codomains ) .
the 3-cells of the resulting subdivision are now those explicitly inserted in the construction , a composition - free pillow with bigonal cross - section , and , we claim , 3-cells all of the form in proposition [ trivialthreecell ] .
verifying the claim is a matter of keeping track of the triangular faces in such a way as to organize them into the pairs of triangulated disks with appropriate boundaries : note that immediately after the subdivision of 2-cells into a bigon and triangles , the triangulated cell(s ) ( if any the original 2-cell could have been a bigon ) are of the desired form : they have a domain ( resp .
codomain ) consisting of a composable 1-pasting diagram and codomain ( resp .
domain ) consisting of a single edge labeled with the composition .
call such a triangulated 2-cell a `` nicely triangulated 2-cell '' .
thus the remainder of the construction begins with the original 2-cells decomposed into a family of nicely triangulated 2-cells and family of bigons . throughout the rest of the construction the family of nicely triangulated 2-cells
will be iteratively replaced with families with fewer nicely triangulated 2-cells ( but with more triangles in the newer ones ) .
for addition of a 3-cell of the forms in propositions [ fatpost1comp ] or [ fatpre1comp ] , the triangles will have as two of their edges the single edge labeled with the composition from previously constructed nicely triangulated 2-cells .
for each of the triangles , replace these two nicely triangulated 2-cells with the union of the triangle and the two nicely triangulated 2-cells , noticing that it is nicely triangulated . when the triangular pillows and the bigonal pillow are adjoined , the family of nicely triangulated 2-cells is unchanged .
thus , when the construction ends , the remaining 3-cells in the decomposition must each be bounded by the union of two nicely triangulated 2-cells .
we can now prove the main result ( recalling the dimension conventions of @xcite which leaves the deformation cohomology of a pasting digram in dimension @xmath356 ) : [ main ] for any pasting diagram @xmath3 of @xmath0-linear categories , @xmath0-linear functors and natural transformations , the deformations of @xmath3 are classified by the @xmath356-cohomology of the @xmath340 , where @xmath70 is the map from the deformation complex @xmath357 given by the same description as in proposition [ trivialthreecell ] , and all obstructions to extension of a degree @xmath163 deformation to a degree @xmath354 deformation are 0-cocycles . for the classification statement , first observe that the proof of proposition [ uniontopushout ] applies equally well to taking unions of pasting diagrams in which some 2-cells have been specified as deforming trivially ( provided that cells in the intersection are specified as deforming trivially in both pasting diagrams of which the union is being taken ) .
the isomorphisms of propositions [ trivialthreecell ] , [ fatpost1comp ] and [ fatpre1comp ] then combine by universal property of pushouts to give an isomorphism between @xmath155 and @xmath340 in the category of chain complexes . that all obstructions are cocycles is a condition local to each cell together with its boundary , and all cells of @xmath355 are either deformed trivially , so that the obstruction vanishes by triviality , are of the forms which were shown to have vanishing obstructions in theorem [ singlecomposition ] , or are composition - free and thus have vanishing obstructions by the results of @xcite .
the primary purpose of this paper , to complete the deformation theory for pasting diagrams of @xmath0-linear categories described in @xcite , was accomplished by theorem [ main ] .
its primary importance , however , may lie less in the result than in the techniques used .
it is the authors intent to apply the deformation theory of pasting diagrams to the still - open problem of providing a complete deformation theory for monoidal categories in which all arrow - valued elements are deformed simultaneously , rather than just the structure maps as in @xcite .
this will require using extensions of @xmath358 hinted at above , in which monoidal prolongations are included as additional operations , as the basis of the polygonal method .
it will also avoid the difficulties in @xcite arising from the need to intuit the correct formulas for higher differentials in a multicomplex from the scant data provided by the instances arising in the deformation theory . likewise , although for the present purpose there is something unsatisfying about our detour though finely divided pasting diagrams with specified trivially - deformed identity cells
we believe the direct result , that all obstructions in the deformation complex of any pasting diagram as defined in @xcite are cocycles , though it is beyond our present ability to prove like the polygonal technique , this detour may have other applications .
the difficulty with the direct result was that although 2-categories , and the pieces of them corresponding to direct summands in deformation complexes are inherently `` globular '' , pasting diagrams are `` opetopic '' .
the reduction of the opetopic to trivial ( mostly simplicial ) elements and globular elements might well find application in connecting the zoo of opetopic definitions of weak n - categories with the globular approach of batanin . | we continue the development of the infinitesimal deformation theory of pasting diagrams of @xmath0-linear categories begun in @xcite . in @xcite
the standard result that all obstructions are cocycles was established only for the elementary , composition - free parts of pasting diagrams . in the present work we give a proof for pasting diagrams in general . as tools we use the method developed by shrestha @xcite of representing formulas for obstructions , along with the corresponding cocycle and cobounding conditions by suitably labeled polygons , giving a rigorous exposition of the previously heuristic method , and deformations of pasting diagrams in which some cells are required to be deformed trivially .
[ multiblock footnote omitted ] |
since the celebrated paper by edwards and anderson@xcite , mean - field theory of spin glass ( sg ) has been extensively investigated .
the replica theory@xcite is one of the most successful achievement that has revealed the nature of the low temperature phase of mean - field sg models .
parisi s pioneering work provided the replica method with implementation of replica symmetry breaking ( rsb ) .
originally , @xmath0 step rsb ( @xmath0rsb ) was proposed as `` a sequence of approximated solutions '' to the true solution and the full rsb solution was derived as a @xmath4 limit .
this approach has actually proven to be exact recently@xcite for the sherrington - kirkpatrick ( sk ) model@xcite . although this introduction of rsb is motivated by de almeida - thouless ( at ) condition@xcite , which is the instability of replica symmetric ( rs ) solution with respect to replica couplings , it should be noted that at instability is only one of the possible scenario for rsb@xcite and that the origin of rsb is in general model - dependent .
in addition , a 1rsb solution for various mean - field sg models@xcite is stable with respect to further rsb perturbation , and @xmath0rsb rarely appears for @xmath5 .
these facts suggest that there is another mechanism to break the replica symmetry and it distinguishes 1rsb from full rsb ( frsb ) .
recently , the authors have shown@xcite that @xmath6-body sk model , which is a typical model to exhibit a sg transition to 1rsb phase , actually has another reason to break the replica symmetry above the gardner temperature@xcite .
it is the monotonicity condition of the cumulant generating function of the free energy @xmath7 , whose limiting value at @xmath8 is the averaged free energy , rather than the at condition that causes rsb@xcite .
the relevance of these conditions is reversed at the gardner temperature , where the transition between 1rsb and full rsb takes place .
furthermore , it is proved that if the monotonicity is broken in the absence of external field , which ensures the smallest overlap parameter @xmath9 , then the correct 1rsb solution is given by the rs solution at @xmath10 , which is defined as the monotonicity breaking point , @xmath11 , @xmath12 .
this has revealed that the continuation of the cumulant generating function @xmath7 to @xmath13 is strongly restricted by a kind of thermodynamic constraints and that it naturally induces the 1rsb solution in the case of a fully connected mean - field sg model . regarding @xmath14 as a fictitious inverse temperature
, we can resort to the thermodynamics for extracting high - temperature , or replica , limit(@xmath15 ) from low - temperature behavior(@xmath16 ) .
these facts strongly suggest that 1rsb is a consequence of the monotonicity breaking and frsb is that of at stability breaking .
finite connectivity sg model has been considered as a first non - trivial extension of the mean - field theory , and challenged in many literatures . as a straight - forward extension from the case of fully connected model ,
perturbation theories in the region of the large connectivity or near the transition temperature have been studied in the replica formalism@xcite .
another replica calculation@xcite has succeeded to derive an exact expression of the free energy under a non - trivial ansatz called factorized ansatz .
the difficulty in these works appears in the search for an rsb saddle - point , because rsb is defined using the symmetry of a saddle - point in the theory .
in contrast , the cavity method turned out to be an alternative and promising approach to study the finite connectivity models within 1rsb scheme@xcite .
the key concept of this method is the complexity@xcite , logarithm of a number of the pure states , which enables one to deeply understand the microscopic structure of configuration space .
it is found that the non - negativity condition of the complexity is relevant for the 1rsb cavity scheme , that provides a general procedure for mean - field type models including finite connectivity sg . in this paper
, we further examine the possibility of 1rsb scenario suggested in our previous work , which might be important for a better understanding of the sg theory and also the replica method itself .
the model discussed is a finite - connectivity ising sg model with @xmath0-body interactions .
the reason why this model is considered as a good example is twofold . first our construction of 1rsb solution is applicable to the finite - connectivity sg model , because rs solution can be explicitly obtained .
second , we see a direct correspondence between the guiding principle of introducing 1rsb in the replica method and the cavity method@xcite . the organization of this paper is as follows . in sec .
[ sec : rep ] , we review our previous work@xcite for complete and detailed instructions of our scheme , in which a construction of a 1rsb solution from rs ansatz is explained . then a sg model defined on a sparse random graph is introduced and the 1rsb solution for the model obtained by our scheme is presented .
we also discuss a relationship between our scheme based on the replica theory and the cavity method for the model . in sec.[sec
: num ] , we compare the 1rsb solution to the result by mc simulation . finally sec .
[ sec : sum ] is devoted to our conclusions and discussions .
in this section , we briefly review our previous work@xcite and explain our scheme for the construction of a 1rsb solution in a general manner . for a given hamiltonian @xmath17 ,
equilibrium statistical mechanics requires to calculate the partition function @xmath18 , where tr denotes the sum over all possible configurations of the dynamical variables and @xmath19 is the inverse temperature .
in the case of disordered system , one may evaluate @xmath20 for quenched disorder @xmath21 and take average of @xmath22 over @xmath21 with an appropriate weight . using the replica method@xcite , the averaged free energy @xmath23
$ ] is rewritten as a limit of cumulant generating function @xmath7 of @xmath24 as @xmath25 = \lim_{n\to 0}\left\{-\frac{1}{n\beta n}\log[z^n]\right\ } = : \lim_{n\to 0 } \phi(n ) , \label{repid}\ ] ] where @xmath26 $ ] denotes the average with respect to the quenched disorder . in case where @xmath14 is a real number , to proceed the calculation of the right hand side in eq .
( [ repid ] ) needs some ansatz . a typical one is replica symmetric ( rs ) ansatz , which is considered to be correct only for sufficiently large @xmath14 .
we denote the solution based on the rs ansatz as rs solution @xmath27 .
thus , the limit of @xmath7 we are interested in becomes nontrivial when we have no alternatives except the rs solution . in general
, however , the function @xmath7 is restricted by the following conditions : @xmath28(monotonicity ) , @xmath29(convexity ) , and at stability .
the two former conditions , monotonicity and convexity , come from a thermodynamic restriction if the replica number @xmath14 is regarded as a `` temperature '' .
in particular , they lead to the following proposition@xcite : if @xmath12 for @xmath30 , + then @xmath31 for @xmath32 . therefore ,
if the rs solution is valid for @xmath33 , the limit @xmath34 is performed by this proposition .
figure [ sch1rsb ] shows how the function @xmath35 is connected to the origin .
it is also shown@xcite that the solution @xmath36 corresponds to the 1rsb solution for a wide class of models with @xmath9 , not restricted to the fully connected models .
this relationship has already been pointed out in a solvable model@xcite .
the proposition provides us a simple construction of a 1rsb solution using only the rs solution .
we summarize our procedure for the 1rsb construction as follows : 1 . calculate the rs solution @xmath27 as a function of the finite replica number @xmath14 .
2 . find the value @xmath10 which satisfies @xmath37 .
3 . set @xmath38 while the right hand side of eq .
( [ nackofrep ] ) is analytically tractable but doubtful for @xmath39 because of the rs ansatz , the left hand side is equal to the free energy as stated in eq .
( [ repid ] ) but analytically intractable .
one may notice that this procedure is analogous to the original saddle - point method , if one identifies the replica number with the breaking parameter .
we consider this correspondence as the reason why we have to maximize with respect to the breaking parameter in literatures .
it should be noted that this procedure can apply to any model in which the rs solution is explicitly obtained for any real @xmath14 .
our procedure does not require overlap matrix or the introduction of breaking parameter . as a function of the replica number @xmath14 .
this shows the construction of a 1rsb solution using monotonicity and convexity condition .
the dashed line represents rs solution , which breaks the monotonicity condition at @xmath40 . below @xmath10 , @xmath7 becomes a constant function down to zero , corresponding to the 1rsb solution . ]
hereafter we deal with a finite - connectivity ising sg model .
the hamiltonian with @xmath0-spin interactions on a regular random graph with connectivity @xmath41 is defined as : @xmath42 where @xmath43 here @xmath44 represents ising spins on the random graph with @xmath45 sites .
the interactions @xmath46 take @xmath47 with equal probability which gives the unit of energy and temperature .
@xmath48 are quenched variables , satisfying the condition @xmath49 for each site @xmath50 , namely all the sites having the same number of the neighbors @xmath41 .
we calculate the cumulant generating function of the model described above within the framework of sec .
[ sec21 ] . following the calculation@xcite ,
@xmath7 under the rs ansatz is evaluated as @xmath51 where @xmath52 differentiating @xmath53 with respect to @xmath54 and @xmath55 , we have the saddle - point equations @xmath56 we solve eqs .
( [ iter1 ] ) and ( [ iter2 ] ) for each @xmath14 numerically and obtain the saddle - point functions @xmath57 and @xmath58 .
details for the numerical method we use to solve these equations are shown in appendix [ apppi ] . inserting the saddle - point functions into eq .
( [ eq : phirs ] ) , we evaluate @xmath27 as a function of @xmath14 .
[ funcphi ] shows an example of @xmath27 plotted against @xmath14 for @xmath3 and @xmath59 at @xmath60 , which is well below the expected sg transition temperature , @xmath61 . as shown in the figure
, @xmath27 violates the monotonicity condition at a certain value @xmath62 which is defined by @xmath63 .
following our scheme mentioned above , this is enough to construct a 1rsb solution .
the 1rsb free energy per site @xmath64 is given as @xmath65 .
it would be interesting to see the information of finite replica number is used to describe the 1rsb free energy .
this is a consequence of the thermodynamic construction , with which the rs solution is connected to the physical limit @xmath15 .
we have evaluated @xmath27 at @xmath66 for @xmath1 and @xmath3 , which yields temperature dependence of the 1rsb free energy shown later . for comparison
, we also evaluate an rs free energy , which is defined as @xmath67 .
temperature dependence of @xmath10 for some values of @xmath41 is plotted for @xmath1 and @xmath2 in fig .
[ fig - nm ] .
we also show the parameter @xmath68 for @xmath1 and @xmath59 in fig .
[ fig - nm ] , evaluated in ref . .
they are in good agreement with each other .
the transition temperature for @xmath1 is derived from the condition that the instability condition of @xmath69 and then @xmath10 begin to deviate from zero .
the estimate of @xmath70 is consistent with the known expression @xmath71@xcite considering an appropriate factor @xmath72 . for @xmath3 , @xmath70
is determined by an onset temperature at which the monotonicity breaking point emerges .
then , @xmath10 deviates from unity , that is often observed in some models exhibiting 1rsb transition .
while the analytic expression of @xmath70 for @xmath3 has not known yet , the estimate for @xmath59 and @xmath73 is consistent with that obtained by the cavity method@xcite .
here we compare our scheme to the established cavity method , in particular for the finite connectivity ising sg model@xcite .
the saddle - point equations , eqs .
( [ iter1 ] ) and ( [ iter2 ] ) , in our scheme are the same as the recursion equation derived as eqs .
( a.3 ) and ( a.4 ) in ref .
, when the functions @xmath54 and @xmath74 are identified as the distribution of cavity field and cavity bias , respectively . while the parameter @xmath14 is determined by the monotonicity condition @xmath75 , the 1rsb parameter @xmath68 in the cavity context is determined by the non - negativity condition of the complexity @xmath76 : @xmath77 within the formalism of monasson@xcite .
this means that these two methods are equivalent when the complexity is a well - defined quantity . in the previous works@xcite ,
it is shown that the result of the cavity method corresponds to that of the replica method with a factorized ansatz for the finite connectivity models .
thus , our construction is also equivalent to the replica theory with the factorized ansatz . in the formalism
, the replica number @xmath14 is substituted for the breaking parameter @xmath68 in the expression of free energy without taking the limit @xmath15 .
then , the maximization of the free energy with respect to the overlap parameter @xmath78 and breaking parameter @xmath68 is equivalent to the monotonicity breaking condition in our scheme .
this reasoning does not give a correctness proof of the factorized ansatz ( and also our ) solution , but we convince ourselves that it reveals the reason why the factorized ansatz gives numerically correct solution .
dependence of @xmath27 of a finite - connectivity ising sg for @xmath3 and @xmath59 at @xmath60 . ] for @xmath1 ( top panel ) and for @xmath3 ( bottom panel ) .
temperature is scaled as @xmath79 .
each mark represents @xmath10 for connectivity @xmath59 , @xmath80 and @xmath73 .
the solid line represents @xmath10 for @xmath0-body sherrington - kirkpatrick model with gaussian interaction . in the top panel , thermodynamic value of 1rsb parameter for @xmath1 and @xmath59 evaluated in ref
is also shown in filled circle .
, title="fig : " ] for @xmath1 ( top panel ) and for @xmath3 ( bottom panel ) .
temperature is scaled as @xmath79 .
each mark represents @xmath10 for connectivity @xmath59 , @xmath80 and @xmath73 .
the solid line represents @xmath10 for @xmath0-body sherrington - kirkpatrick model with gaussian interaction . in the top panel , thermodynamic value of 1rsb parameter for @xmath1 and @xmath59 evaluated in ref
. is also shown in filled circle .
, title="fig : " ]
in the previous section , we obtain the 1rsb solution for the ising sg model with @xmath0-body interactions by using our scheme .
this is the true solution if the at instability or others would not occur above @xmath10 , but it is difficult to examine the validity of @xmath27 .
this situation is similar to the case of the cavity method . instead
, here we verify our 1rsb solution by comparing it to monte carlo ( mc ) data .
we use exchange mc method@xcite in order to accelerate relaxation time to equilibrium .
the number of temperatures is fixed to be 30 and the lowest temperature is down to 0.5 for all the system sizes @xmath45 and @xmath0 .
the simulation parameters for @xmath1 and @xmath3 are presented in table [ 24mcs ] and [ 34mcs ] , respectively .
equilibration of the mc simulations is confirmed by seeing that the observed quantities are stable within range of error by doubling mc steps . by using the mc simulation
we measure the energy @xmath81 per site and calculate the free energy @xmath82 per site by thermodynamic integration : @xmath83 and the entropy @xmath84 per site as @xmath85 through the data at discrete temperatures obtained by the exchange mc method , the energy as a continuous function of @xmath86 is evaluated by reweighting formula@xcite : @xmath87 where @xmath88 denotes the mc average at the inverse temperature @xmath89 .
we apply this formula by setting @xmath90 as actually simulated temperature and @xmath89 as required one .
we choose @xmath90 as the nearest temperature to @xmath89 from the whole set of simulated temperatures . .
parameters of simulation in the case of @xmath1 and @xmath59 .
the total number of monte carlo steps @xmath91 and the total number of samples @xmath92 are presented for each size @xmath45 .
the first @xmath93 are discarded for equilibration and the subsequent @xmath93 are used in measurement . [
cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] to see thermodynamic properties , we extrapolate our mc data with finite sizes to the thermodynamic limit @xmath94 . because finite - size correction terms and its exponent are a priori unknown in sg models , an extrapolation method itself should be investigated .
we assume that the leading finite - size correction terms for the energy , free energy and entropy are expressed as @xmath95 where @xmath96 , @xmath97 and @xmath98 are the thermodynamic limit of the respective quantities , and the correction exponent @xmath99 is assumed to be independent of the quantities .
as shown in the previous work@xcite , the ground - state energy of the ising sg model for @xmath1 defined on a regular random graph is scaled with @xmath100 .
thus , we assume that the exponent @xmath101 holds for @xmath1 at finite temperatures and is independent of physical quantities .
[ enext24 ] show the thermodynamic quantities as a function of @xmath102 for @xmath1 at @xmath103 , which is the lowest observed temperature .
the data are fitted well with the assumption @xmath100 as shown in the figure .
the extrapolated values by the best fit and the results by the 1rsb and the rs solutions are shown in table [ bestfit ] .
the thermodynamic values by mc results agree with those by the 1rsb solution rather than the rs one .
the energy extrapolated in a wide range of temperature is displayed in fig .
[ k2temp ] .
this also suggests that the 1rsb solution is consistent with numerical results . and @xmath59 . the extrapolated value from mc data is marked by filled square .
the 1rsb , rs and paramagnetic solutions are represented by solid , long - dashed and short - dashed lines , respectively .
the inset is an enlarged view at low temperatures . ] and
the filled squares and cross marks are the extrapolated value from mc data with the extrapolation form including the leading correction term and up to the next correction terms , respectively .
the 1rsb , frozen and paramagnetic solutions are represented by solid , long - dashed and short - dashed lines , respectively . long - short - dashed line is the result of the cavity method in ref . .
the iso - complexity energy obtained in ref . is also shown by dotted line .
the inset is an enlarged view at low temperatures . ]
we turn to the case of @xmath3 , where the value of @xmath99 is not known even at zero temperature .
although a naive way to suppress higher order corrections is to study the system for large sizes and/or at lower temperatures apart from critical temperature , it has not been feasible to perform the mc simulation below @xmath104 for @xmath105 in moderate cpu time because of extremely slow relaxation especially in the case of @xmath3 .
this is contrast to @xmath1 model .
however , for relatively smaller systems , the distribution function of the energy is found to be almost a delta function with the weight at the lowest energy .
this implies that vthe distribution depends weakly only on temperature @xmath86 below @xmath106 .
this fact enables us to obtain the energy at temperatures down to @xmath107 using the reweighting method@xcite .
we evaluate the correction exponent @xmath99 for the energy by the least - squares estimation at @xmath108 and @xmath106 with a form of eq .
( [ eqn : efenegy ] ) .
the estimate of @xmath99 is not compatible with @xmath100 used in the case of @xmath1 , and is rather close to @xmath109 .
this tendency is enhanced by omitting the smallest size @xmath110 from the analysis .
these findings suggest that @xmath111 and higher order corrections are not negligible .
therefore , we extrapolate the mc result for @xmath3 by assuming the forms of eqs .
( [ eqn : efenegy ] ) , ( [ eqn : ffenegy ] ) and ( [ eqn : sfenegy ] ) for @xmath109 with the next leading correction term @xmath112 .
the data for @xmath110 are omitted from the extrapolation analysis .
figures [ enext34 ] shows the result of the thermodynamic quantities for @xmath3 and @xmath59 at @xmath108 .
the extrapolated values , presented in table [ bestfitk3 ] , are consistent with those of the 1rsb solution by taking into account the next leading correction term .
we also show the thermodynamic value of the energy for @xmath3 as a function of @xmath86 in fig .
[ k3temp ] .
the extrapolated values by the form including the next leading correction term are consistent with those by the paramagnetic solution at @xmath113 and those by the 1rsb solution at low temperatures , though a systematic deviation still remains around @xmath70 because of the critical fluctuation . as shown in the inset of fig .
[ k3temp ] , the agreement between the extrapolated value and the value of 1rsb solution is held at very low temperatures and the limiting value of energy at zero temperature coincides with that obtained by zero - temperature calculations@xcite . for the case of @xmath3 ,
the result of the cavity method is also shown in fig .
[ k3temp]@xcite .
analytic results are in good agreement with the mc data at low temperatures .
these support the validity of the scheme also for @xmath3 . before closing this section
, we would like to mention mc algorithm for studying sg models . in recent works@xcite
, it is claimed that in annealing simulations a slow annealing limit of the energy often leads to the iso - complexity energy , significantly above the static equilibrium energy in glassy systems .
this has been confirmed for @xmath3 by an annealing simulation@xcite .
in contrast , as shown in fig .
[ k3temp ] , the energy extrapolated to the infinite - volume limit in our exchange mc results is well lower than the iso - complexity energy and is compatible with that of the 1rsb solution at low temperatures .
this suggests that the exchange mc is suitable for equilibration of the sg system even when the system have the iso - complexity energy separated from the static one .
we have studied a construction of a 1rsb solution for quench disordered systems .
our construction is based on thermodynamic conditions for the cumulant generating function @xmath7 of free energy , which are derived as a necessary condition in the replica analysis .
the only requirement for our construction is to obtain the replica symmetric solution for @xmath7 as a function of @xmath14 .
this is a quite general scheme which may provide an unified way to give a correct solution for 1rsb systems .
in fact , our scheme reproduces the well - known 1rsb solution for fully connected mean - field sg models such as @xmath6-spin model@xcite and potts glass model@xcite . as a non - trivial example
we have applied our scheme to study a 1rsb solution for finite - connectivity ising sg models with @xmath0-spin interactions .
the thermodynamic quantities are explicitly evaluated from numerically obtained rs solution with finite replica number @xmath14 using our scheme .
the saddle - point equations to be solved in our scheme are found to be equivalent to recursion equations of the cavity - field distributions in the 1rsb cavity formalism for this model . in a sense ,
our scheme based on the replica theory can be regarded as a reinterpretation of the 1rsb cavity method . while the cavity method can predict the microscopic detail of a model through complexity , which is an interesting quantity in glassy physics , one can not obtain such a quantity with our scheme at present .
this would be discussed as a remaining issue .
in contrast , we can construct the 1rsb theory irrespective of details of the model , even non - mean - field model in principle , because our scheme does not rely on the microscopic details , or complexity .
since the pure state in finite dimensions is difficult to formulate in a tractable manner , this complexity - independent formalism of 1rsb may be useful to investigate nature of rsb in finite dimensions@xcite .
because the replica method itself is originally independent of calculus of spin variables , this theoretical flexibility would give another perspective if rsb is formulated within macroscopic level .
therefore , we consider that the cavity method and our method are complementary in order to understand the nature of sg .
the correspondence of their results in this model has a significance because they should provide the same result in the intersection of their validity range .
unfortunately , the validity of our 1rsb solution could not be established within the scheme because of the lack of at analysis .
some at analyses for finite - connectivity models are recently proposed in the previous works@xcite .
they are to be resolved for our model and compared with each other in future study . to confirm the validity of our scheme in the present work ,
equilibrium mc simulations with the help of extended ensemble method have been performed for the model with @xmath1 and @xmath2 .
it is shown that for @xmath1 , the resulting thermodynamic quantities by our scheme are in agreement with those obtained by mc simulation within statistical error . for @xmath3 , assuming that the size dependence of the thermodynamic quantities is expressed as a polynomial of @xmath114 , we have concluded that our 1rsb solution is also consistent with those extracted from the finite - size mc data .
if we have the correction exponent @xmath99 a priori , we can promote the accuracy of our extrapolation .
optimization techniques for ground - state search would be a promising approach for estimating the value of @xmath99 for @xmath3 . as a by - product of the mc simulations , it is found that a coefficient of the first finite - size - correction term is positive .
namely , the finite - size data reach their thermodynamic value from above with increasing the system size .
this suggests that fluctuations on the positive side of the thermodynamic value is relevant for the finite - size corrections in these models . on the other hand ,
the probability of large deviations which can be calculated using the replica theory with @xmath115 is the negative side for the free energy in the fully connected sk model@xcite .
the replica theory with @xmath116 for the large deviations is required to evaluate the finite - size correction .
the key ingredient in our scheme for constructing the 1rsb solution is the thermodynamic constraints as a necessary condition in the replica theory .
this is compared to the fact that the standard replica method introduces rsb scheme through the symmetry of the saddle point .
another thermodynamic constraint , thermodynamic homogeneity , has been discussed in ref . .
one might stress the importance of such a thermodynamical approach which leads to an universal framework irrespective of microscopic models .
actually , our scheme is rather general and quite simple .
it only needs the function @xmath27 which is constructed in the way of replica symmetric analysis .
thus , we can avoid the arbitrariness to introduce breaking parameter in the replica theory .
one can find further applications in related statistical - mechanical systems in which the rs solution can be constructed .
we would like to thank y. kabashima for helpful comments and discussions , and for explaining the details of algorithm for solving the saddle - point equations@xcite .
we are also grateful to f. krzakala for making his numerical data in ref .
@xcite available to us .
tn also gratefully acknowledges k. mimura for the kind and helpful lecture .
he is strongly inspired by the lecture .
this work was supported by the grant - in - aid for scientific research on the priority area `` deepening and expansion of statistical mechanical informatics '' ( no .
1807004 ) by ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology , japan .
for @xmath117 and @xmath118 . ] in this appendix , we explain details of the numerical method we used to solve the saddle - point equations ( [ iter1 ] ) and ( [ iter2 ] ) .
we use an iteration method , introduced in ref . .
the saddle - point functions @xmath57 and @xmath119 are approximated by a large @xmath120 number of samples from @xmath54 and @xmath55 .
the algorithm for evaluating the function @xmath57 and @xmath121 is as follows : 1 .
give an appropriate array @xmath122 as an initial condition to @xmath54 .
2 . sample @xmath123 independent values of @xmath124 @xmath125 from @xmath57 by generating a random integer @xmath126 uniformly distributed from 1 to @xmath120 and setting @xmath127 , and evaluate @xmath128 .
3 . put the sign chosen with probability 1/2 to @xmath129 and get @xmath130 , which corresponds to a sample of @xmath55 .
4 . repeat the steps 2 and 3 @xmath120 times and obtain the @xmath120 samples of @xmath55 , @xmath131 .
sample @xmath132 independent values of @xmath133 @xmath134 by a procedure similar to that of step 2 and evaluate @xmath135 .
accept @xmath136 obtained in step 5 with probability @xmath137 and accumulate a new set of @xmath138 of @xmath54 till the number reaches @xmath120 . 7 .
return to 2 . | an one - step replica - symmetry - breaking solution for finite connectivity spin - glass models with @xmath0 body interaction is constructed at finite temperature using the replica method and thermodynamic constraints . in the absence of external fields ,
this construction provides a general extension of replica symmetric solution at finite replica number to one - step replica - symmetry - breaking solution .
it is found that this result is formally equivalent to that of the one - step replica - symmetry - breaking cavity method . to confirm the validity of the obtained solution , monte carlo simulations are performed for @xmath1 and @xmath2 .
the thermodynamic quantities of the monte carlo results extrapolated to a large - size limit are consistent with those estimated by our solution for @xmath1 at all simulated temperatures and for @xmath3 except near the transition temperature . |
the frequent association of flat or inverted radio spectra with the parsec - scale knots in the jets of luminous active galactic nuclei ( agn ; bl lacertae objects and quasars ) is commonly interpreted in terms of synchrotron self - absorption ( ssa ) effects .
a combination of very long baseline interferometry ( vlbi ) measurements of the angular size and flux density near the frequency of ssa , with the x - ray flux density expected from synchrotron self - compton scattering , then yields the values of the magnetic field , @xmath2 , and the doppler factor , @xmath3 $ ] , for the knots , where @xmath4 is the bulk lorentz factor and @xmath5 is the viewing angle to the axis of the flow ; @xmath1 has a maximum value equal to 2@xmath4 ( e.g. , marscher 1987 ; ghisellini et al .
evidence for spectral flattening at lower radio frequencies , possibly attributable to free - free absorption in the nuclear region , has also been discussed in the context of a few superluminal agn ( e.g. , matveyenko et al .
1980 ; britzen et al .
2001 ; kellermann 2003 , and references therein ) . here
we point out that a significant spectral flattening of the superluminal radio knots could also arise from a low - energy cut - off ( lec ) of the relativistic electron population and , within a plausible range of parameters for some vlbi components , this can mimic ssa even in spectral regions that are essentially free from ssa .
the resulting extra attenuations of the radio flux and apparent brightness temperature may have interesting implications , and seem to provide useful clues to some observational trends revealed by recent vlbi surveys , which are briefly pointed out below .
from the basic theory of synchrotron emission it is well known that an energy distribution of relativistic electrons truncated at low energies gives rise to a spectral turnover toward lower frequencies , attaining a spectral index @xmath6 ( defined so that the flux density , @xmath7 ) ( e.g. ginzburg & syrovatskii 1969 ; pacholczyk 1970 ) . in the rest frame of the emitting region
this cutoff frequency , @xmath8 , where @xmath9(hz ) = @xmath10 , where @xmath2 is in units of gauss , @xmath11 , in ergs , is the lec for the electron distribution , and @xmath12 is the mean pitch angle of the electrons with respect to the magnetic field .
if we assume a nearly isotropic distribution of electrons in the rest frame of the emitting region , we find that the spectrum turns over below an observed frequency @xmath13 with @xmath14 the cosmological redshift of the agn .
a few rare examples for which hints of such a low - frequency spectral turnover have been reported include the hot spots of the bright radio galaxy cyg a , from which @xmath15 has been inferred ( biermann , strom & falcke 1995 ) .
similar values ( @xmath16 ) have been inferred by @xcite for cyg a and by @xcite for 3c 196 ; leahy , muxlow & stephens ( 1989 ) give indications of a lec in other hot spots .
however , hot spot evidence for a lec remains weak , mainly because one really needs flux measurements with arcsecond resolution well below the turnover frequency @xmath17 200 mhz .
given the practical difficulty of obtaining detailed images at such low frequencies , we explore here the possibility of investigating this phenomenon using the radio knots in agn jets whose apparent superluminal motion can push the spectral turnover peak due to lec ( near @xmath18 ) into the readily accessible centimeter / millimeter waveband .
it may thus become much more feasible to trace the observational signatures of lec .
clearly , any such evidence would hold vital clues to the particle acceleration mechanism in agn and also shed some light on other basic questions concerning the energetics of the agn jets .
probably the most secure example of a mildly inverted radio spectrum arising from lec is the nuclear source of our own galaxy , sgr a@xmath19 , whose radio spectrum has a slope close to @xmath6 .
this has been interpreted in terms of a quasi mono - energetic distribution of the radiating electron population , peaked near 10@xmath20 mev ( duschl & lesch 1994 ; beckert & duschl 1997 ; falcke , mannheim & biermann 1993 ) .
one specific proposal that yields such a lec invokes hadronic interactions near the inner edge of the accretion disk around a rapidly spinning central black hole where it connects to the jet ( falcke , malkan & biermann 1995 ; donea & biermann 1996 ) .
this mechanism produces a pair plasma embedded in a normal plasma ; the lec would correspond to the pion mass , at least near the zone of creation , subject to adiabatic losses and reacceleration along the jet . in the context of blazars , an early hint for lec ( with @xmath21 mev ) came from the observed lack of faraday depolarization in the vlbi emission regions ( wardle 1977 ; jones & odell 1977 ) .
interestingly , this value of @xmath22 is also the typical energy of electrons radiating near the self - absorption frequency ( e.g. , celotti & fabian 1993 ) .
@xcite argue that synchrotron emission in vlbi scale jets may well arise from @xmath23 pairs and obtain a good fit , taking a lec of around 50 mev .
@xcite conversely argue that energetics constraints indicate that radio jets are ` heavy ' and are composed of protons and electrons , but they still need to invoke a lec .
each of these arguments is model - dependent , and the value of @xmath22 is yet to be firmly established .
likewise , the mechanism responsible for a lec remains to be understood .
it was argued long ago @xcite that the existence of a lec favors models in which radiating relativistic particles are accelerated in relativistic blasts ( e.g. , blandford & mckee 1976 ) or by strong electromagnetic acceleration ( e.g. , lovelace 1976 ) , rather than through stochastic acceleration , since the latter mechanism should produce many electrons with only modestly relativistic lorentz factors .
but neither of these approaches naturally produces a lec around 50100 mev .
the arguments presented here are quite independent of the specific mechanism for a lec . for a homogeneous , spherical source of incoherent synchrotron emission ssa
leads to a rather sharp spectral turnover near a frequency ( e.g. , ginzburg & syrovatskii 1969 ; kellermann & pauliny - toth 1969 ) @xmath24 where @xmath25 is the peak flux density ( in units of janskys ) of the knot , observed at @xmath26 , @xmath27 ( in milli - arcseconds ) is its angular size at @xmath26 , @xmath2 is in units of gauss , and @xmath28 is the co - moving doppler factor of the knot . from eq ( 1 ) and eq ( 2 ) we get @xmath29 here @xmath30 is a measure of the apparent surface brightness , and @xmath31 .
the critical doppler factor for which @xmath32 is given by @xmath33 if @xmath34 then lec is important for flux attenuation .
although our picture of the knots is admittedly oversimplified , as any gradients in the lec could complicate the analysis , it should suffice to illustrate the relevance of lec induced spectral effects .
clearly , for the knots with @xmath35 , the onset of ( a mild ) spectral turnover toward lower frequencies will be led by lec , not ssa .
thus , the larger the value of @xmath36 , the greater would be the suppression of the peak flux that would have otherwise been attained by the knot , provided the limiting factor were indeed ssa . considering the mildly positive slope ( @xmath37 ) at @xmath38 and a typical spectral index @xmath39 in the unabsorbed / uncutoff part of the spectrum , the flux suppression factor measured at @xmath26 is @xmath40 .
the source parameters on which @xmath36 and @xmath41 depend include the magnetic field in the vlbi knot , for which estimates are rather model dependent .
for the radio jets up to distances of @xmath42 pc from the core , @xmath2 = 0.1 0.3 g has been estimated from independent analyses of the detailed vlbi observations ( lobanov 1998 ; piner et al .
somewhat higher values have been adopted by @xcite in their modeling of the superluminal cores .
we adopt @xmath43 g as a fiducial value , but consider the plausible range below .
as noted above , most observations and models give values of @xmath44 , so we take 1 as its fiducial value . the other important physical parameter in eqs ( 3 ) and
( 4 ) is the surface brightness , @xmath45 .
a recent data set relevant to this quantity is based on 15 ghz very long baseline arrary ( vlba ) imaging of 160 flat - spectrum sources ( kellermann et al .
1998 ; zensus et al . 2002 ) .
these observations , with baselines out to 440 million wavelengths ( with angular resolution , @xmath46 mas ) have shown that @xmath4790% of the sources have an unresolved flux density greater than @xmath48 jy ( i.e. , @xmath49 ) , whereas @xmath4745% of the sources have unresolved structures stronger than 0.5 jy ( i.e. , @xmath50 ) @xcite .
there is presently little evidence in the vlbi samples for a sizable population of agn having @xmath51 @xcite .
this is further corroborated by the ongoing space vlbi survey of compact agn , using the vlbi space observatory programme @xcite .
a possible explanation for the lack of extremely high values of @xmath45 ( @xmath52 ) is that such extreme objects will form rarely to begin with , and that any such components would be very strongly self - absorbed at typical vlbi frequencies , and therefore relativistic beaming would be much less effective for flux boosting ( see kellermann 1994 ) .
thus , we shall adopt here @xmath53 . taking @xmath43 g , and @xmath54 ( see above ) , we then have from eq ( 4 ) , @xmath55 = @xmath56 , where @xmath57 2 , 4 , and 9 , for @xmath45 = 3 , 30 , and 300 , respectively , a range that includes the vast majority of the bright vlbi knots .
evidently , for many radio emission regions close to the nucleus , lec induced flux suppression is expected to set in already at frequencies that are too high for ssa to be significant , even if the knots are only modestly superluminal .
but the same lec dominance would require larger doppler factors in the case of knots having higher surface brightnesses and/or redshifts .
1 illustrates the variation of @xmath18 and @xmath26 across the @xmath58
@xmath59 plane , for the plausible ranges of @xmath45 and @xmath2 .
it is interesting to note that for most values of @xmath59 ( i.e. , @xmath60 ) , @xmath18 lies above the typical frequency range of vlbi observations ( 5 15 ghz ) if @xmath61 g , and hence these observations are usually made below the spectral turnover due to lec ( although the spectral turnover due to ssa is yet to set in for most of the knots ) . for the brighter , albeit comparatively rare , knots with @xmath62 , the typical range of vlbi frequencies would always lie within the ssa - dominated regime , for practically the entire plausible range of @xmath59 ( fig . 1 ) .
in recent years , a few vlbi imaging observations have also been possible at higher frequencies , e.g. , 4386 ghz ( e.g. , krichbaum et al . 2001 ; jorstad & marscher 2003 ) . for such cases ,
the lec - induced spectral flattening would set in for @xmath63 , except for the brightest vlbi knots ( @xmath64 ) which would nonetheless be synchrotron self - absorbed .
thus , it appears that in typical vlbi observations , made at 5 or 15 ghz , most of the emission regions in proximity to the nucleus ( at distances @xmath65 pc , where the brightest and the fastest moving knots are normally expected to be found ) would appear dimmed either from flux suppression due to lec , or alternatively , in the few cases of extreme brightness , due to ssa . as can be seen from fig . 1 and eq ( 3 ) , the flux suppression would increase rapidly with doppler factor ( @xmath1 ) , but its significance would diminish for the knots having lower magnetic field and/or higher redshift , or if the value of @xmath22 were smaller . an observational consequence of the depression of the peak flux density by a factor @xmath41 ( 2 ) , arising from such ( pre - mature ) spectral flattening , would be a reduction in brightness temperatures , @xmath66 , of the vlbi knots , compared to the situation in which ssa alone were significant . for the latter case , @xcite has deduced a realizable limit of @xmath67 k ( assuming equipartition ; also see singal & gopal - krishna 1985 ) , which is about a sixth of the diamagnetic limit calculated by @xcite .
other theoretical limits proposed for @xmath66 are @xmath68 k , arising from catastrophic inverse compton cooling @xcite and greater than @xmath69 k , arising from relativistic induced compton scattering @xcite .
evidence for brightness temperatures being found to typically be lower than these theoretically expected intrinsic brightness temperatures comes from the vlba 2 cm sample of 48 superluminal sources , whose distribution in the ` doppler factor proper motion ' plane is best fitted by a peak intrinsic @xmath70 k @xcite .
this is roughly half of the equipartition value , and an order of magnitude below the stricter inverse compton scattering limit .
the lec - induced flux suppression could possibly account for the deficit observed vis - - vis the equipartition value .
note that even though the best - fit value of the intrinsic brightness temperatures found by @xcite , is just a factor of 2 3 below the equipartition temperature limit , it makes a huge difference in the energetics .
the increase in the energies for such reductions in @xmath71 is @xmath72 times @xcite . to recapitulate , for the typical magnetic field of 0.1 g and usual vlbi observing frequency ( @xmath73 5 15 ghz )
, most radio knots with medium - to - low surface brightness ( @xmath74 ) would suffer a marked suppression of flux density as a result of lec , if @xmath28 exceeds @xmath475 and @xmath75 .
thus , in such vlbi surveys one would expect a deficit of knots with high doppler factors ( and , correspondingly , of high lorentz factors , given the rather tight correspondence expected between the two , cf .
table 1 in jorstad & marscher 2003 ) .
this selection bias would gradually ease for vlbi surveys made at higher frequencies and/or higher @xmath14 ( which corresponds to higher observing frequencies in the rest frame of the sources ) .
interestingly , such statistical trends may indeed be seen in the recent large vlbi surveys .
for instance , for a large sample of flat - spectrum sources , the caltech
jodrell bank - flat ( cjf ) sample , the measured apparent velocities of the vlbi components at 5 ghz show a positive correlation with redshift ( fig . 1 in vermeulen et al .
2003 ) . while , clearly , this result does not exclude alternative explanations , it is interesting that there is also evidence for a _ statistical _ increase in the apparent velocities of superluminal knots with the frequency of the vlbi measurements , even as the apparent velocity of a given vlbi knot observable at multiple frequencies would be the same at all of those frequencies . as already pointed out by @xcite , the apparent velocities for a cjf sample at 5 ghz are nearly a factor of 2 smaller , on average , than those found in the 15 ghz vlba survey of the same sample @xcite , and these , in turn , are only about half as fast as the velocities found in a vlbi survey of 33 blazars at 22 and 43 ghz by @xcite .
their high frequency survey yielded mean apparent velocity of @xmath4711@xmath76 , ( taking @xmath77 km s@xmath78 mpc@xmath78 and @xmath79 ) .
@xcite suggest that a decrease in mean apparent velocity with decreasing frequency might result from changing ssa turnovers if these measurements corresponded to an increase in average size or distance from the core .
@xcite have ascribed the higher velocities for their sample to be an intrinsic property of their sources , which are @xmath80-ray emitting blazars . in our scenario , their finding abnormally high velocities for that sample may be directly related to the unusually high observing frequency of their vlbi survey .
one observational test of our hypothesis would be possible by vlbi monitoring of @xmath80-ray blazars at moderate frequencies , say 5 or 10 ghz ; we understand that such data are likely to become available in the near future , making a detailed check possible .
a crisp prediction of our scenario , which can be tested by quasi - simultaneous multi - frequency vlbi , is that the knots affected by lec should have only a weakly inverted spectrum below @xmath18 , with a slope of @xmath81 down to @xmath26 .
the presence of a lec could also have interesting implications for the kiloparsec scale jets of quasars , for which bulk relativistic motion has been inferred recently from x - ray observations ( e.g. , tavecchio et al .
2000 ; celotti , ghisellini & chiaberge 2001 ) .
in such extended jets the photon energy density is dominated by the cosmic microwave background radiation ( cmbr ) photons , which , after inverse compton collisions with the relativistic jet particles , would be observed at a frequency @xmath82{\rm hz}$ ] , with @xmath83 the angle between the jet and the observer in the jet s rest frame @xcite . for a typical @xmath84 , and taking even a fairly modest value of @xmath85 , which is close to the expectation value for @xmath86 ( e.g. , vermeulen & cohen 1994 ; jorstad & marscher 2003 ) , it can be seen that @xmath87 mev translates into a spectral turnover of the inverse compton scattered radiation occurring at energies of a few kev .
thus , for many jets detected with the _ chandra _ and _ xmm - newton _ telescopes , signatures of the lec may well be present in their x - ray measurements , in the form of suppressed soft x - ray flux , i.e. , a hardened x - ray spectrum .
moreover , one can expect rapid , correlated variations of x - ray flux and spectral slope as @xmath1 changes .
clearly , these effects would be stronger for extended jets with faster bulk motions and/or higher redshifts ; a search for these trends would provide valuable clues .
the flux suppression would render the detection of extended x - ray jets at higher redshifts more difficult , even though the expected surface brightness diminution with @xmath14 is exactly compensated for by the corresponding increase in the cmbr energy density ( see schwartz et al .
2000 ) .
beckert , t. , & duschl , w. j. 1997 , a&a , 328 , 95 biermann , p. l. , strom , r. g. , & falcke , h. 1995 , a&a , 302 , 429 blandford , r. d. , & mckee , c. 1976 , phys .
fluids , 19 , 1130 bloom , s. d. , & marscher , a. p. 1996 , apj , 461 , 657 britzen , s. , witzel , a. , krichbaum , t. p. , macslow , t. , & matveyenko , l. i. 2001 , astrl , 27 , 1 carilli , c. l. , perley , r. a. , dreher , j. w. , & leahy , p. 1991 , apj , 383 , 554 celotti , a. , & fabian , a. c. 1993 , mnras , 264 , 22 celotti , a. , ghisellini , g. , & chiaberge , m. 2001 , mnras , 321 , l1 cohen , m. h. , et al .
2003 , in asp conf .
300 , radio astronomy at the fringe , ed .
j. a. zensus , m. h. cohen , & e. ros ( san francisco : asp ) , 177 donea , a. c. , & biermann , p. l. 1996 , a&a , 316 , 43 duschl , w. j. , & lesch , h. 1994 , a&a , 286 , 431 falcke , h. , malkan , m. a. , & biermann , p. l. 1995 , a&a , 298 , 375 falcke , h. , mannheim , k. , & biermann , p. l. 1993 , a&a , 278 , l1 ghisellini , g. , celotti , a. , george , i. m. , & fabian , a. c. 1992 , mnras , 258 , 776 ginzburg , v. l. , & syrovatskii , s. i. 1969 , araa , 7 , 375 hardcastle , m. j. 2001 , a&a , 373 , 881 harris , d. e. , & krawczynski , h. 2002 , apj , 565 , 244 hirabayashi , h. , et al .
2000 , pasj , 52 , 997 jones , t. w. , & odell , s. l. 1977 , a&a , 61 , 291 jorstad , s. , & marscher , a. p. 2003 , in asp conf .
300 , radio astronomy at the fringe , ed .
j. a. zensus , m. h. cohen , & e. ros ( san francisco : asp ) , 89 kellermann , k. i. 1994 , in compact extragalactic radio sources , eds .
j. a. zensus & k. i. kellermann ( green bank : nrao ) , 245 kellermann , k. i. 2003 , in asp conf .
300 , radio astronomy at the fringe , ed .
j. a. zensus , m. h. cohen , & e. ros ( san francisco : asp ) , 185 kellermann , k. i. , & pauliny - toth , i. i. k. 1969 , apj , 155 , l71 kellermann , k. i. , vermeulen , r. c. , zensus , j. a. , & cohen , m. h. 1998 , aj , 115 , 1295 kovalev , y. y. 2003 , in asp conf .
300 , radio astronomy at the fringe , ed .
j. a. zensus , m. h. cohen , & e. ros ( san francisco : asp ) , 65 krichbaum , t. p. , graham , d. a. , witzel , a. , zensus , j. a. , greve , a. , grewing , m. , marscher , a. , & beasley , a. j. 2001 , in asp conf .
250 , particles and fields in radio galaxies , ed .
r. a. laing & k. m. blundell ( san francisco : asp ) , 184 leahy , j. p. , muxlow , t. w. b. , & stephens , p. w. 1989 , mnras , 239 , 401 lobanov , a. p. 1998 , a&a , 330 , 79 lovelace , r. v. e. 1976 , nature , 262 , 649 marscher , a. p. 1987 , in superluminal radio sources , ed .
j. a. zensus & t. j. pearson ( cambridge : cambridge up ) , 280 matveyenko , l. i. et al .
1980 , sval , 6 , 42 pacholczyk , a. g. 1970 , radio astrophysics ( san francisco : freeman ) piner , b. g. , unwin , s. c. , wehrle , a. e. , zook , a. c. , urry , c. m. , & gilmore , d. m. 2003 , apj , 588 , 716 readhead , a. c. s. 1994 , apj , 426 , 51 schwartz , d. a. , et al .
2000 , apj , 540 , l69 sincell , m. w. , & krolik , j. h. 1994 , apj , 430 , 550 singal , a. k. 1988 , a&a , 155 , 242 singal , a. k. , & gopal - krishna 1985 , mnras , 215 , 383 tavecchio , f. , maraschi , l , sambruna , r. m. , & urry , c. m. 2000 , apj , 544 , l23 vermeulen , r. c. , & cohen , m. h. 1994 , apj , 430 , 467 vermeulen , r. c. , britzen , s. , taylor , g. b. , pearson , t. j. , readhead , a. c. s. , wilkinson , p. n. , & browne , i. w. a. 2003 , in asp conf .
300 , radio astronomy at the fringe , ed .
j. a. zensus , m. h. cohen , & e. ros ( san francisco : asp ) , 43 wardle , j. f. c. 1977 , nature , 269 , 563 zensus , j. a. , ros , e. , kellermann , k. i. , cohen , m. h. , vermeulen , r. c. , & kadler , m. 2002 , aj , 124 , 662 zensus , j. a. , et al .
2003 , in asp conf .
300 , radio astronomy at the fringe , ed .
j. a. zensus , m. h. cohen , & e. ros ( san francisco : asp ) , 27 | although the possibility of a low - energy cut - off ( lec ) of the relativistic electron population ( e@xmath0 gev ) in the different components of radio galaxies has been discussed in the literature , from both theoretical and observational viewpoints , its possible role in causing a distinct spectral flattening , and thus reducing the apparent brightness temperature of the radio nucleus , has thus far not been explicitly discussed . here
we point out that such an effect may in fact be quite significant for the parsec - scale , superluminal emission regions associated with the inner radio jets .
this is because the observed frequency of the spectral turnover arising from the lec increases linearly with the bulk doppler factor ( @xmath1 ) of the jet flow , whereas the frequency of synchrotron self - absorption ( the well - known cause of spectral flattening and turnover at low frequencies ) shows a mild decrease as @xmath1 rises . for an observationally relevant range of source parameters , we investigate here the role of the lec .
we argue that some statistical trends revealed by the recent very long baseline interferometry ( vlbi ) surveys can in fact be understood in terms of effects arising from lec , including the faster superluminal motion found in the vlbi surveys at higher frequencies , and the apparent inability of most radio cores to even attain the brightness temperatures consistent with the equipartition condition .
we also point out some possible implications of the lec for x - ray observations of kiloparsec scale relativistic jets of quasars . submitted 29 december 2003 ; accepted by astrophysical journal letters on 21 january 2004 |
investigation on anisotropy of extremely high energy cosmic rays is one of the most important aspects to reveal their origin . in energies
@xmath5 10@xmath0ev , cosmic rays slightly deflect in the galactic magnetic field if they are protons of galactic origin , so that one could observe the correlation of their arrival directions with the galactic structure . especially in the highest observed energy range ,
correlation of cosmic rays with the local structure of galaxies may be expected if their origins are nearby astrophysical objects and the intergalactic magnetic field is less than 10@xmath6 gauss . in the 1980 s , wdowczyk , wolfendale and their collaborators ( @xcite )
have shown that excess of cosmic rays from the direction of the galactic plane increases systematically with energy until a little above 10@xmath0ev , though the available data was not statistically enough at that time .
gillman and watson ( 1993 ) have summarized anisotropies in right ascension and galactic latitude combining the haverah park data set with the data sets from the arrays at volcano ranch ( @xcite ) , sydney ( @xcite ) and yakutsk ( @xcite ) .
no convincing anisotropies were observed ; but large amplitude of the second harmonics at ( 4 8) @xmath1 10@xmath7ev was reported .
ivanov ( 1998 ) showed , with the yakutsk data set , a north - south asymmetry in the galactic latitude distribution which is the southern excess with 3.5 @xmath8 deviation from an isotropic distribution in ( 5 20 ) @xmath1 10@xmath7ev .
recently , we have shown a significant anisotropy with first harmonic amplitude of @xmath9 4 % in ( 0.8 2.0 ) @xmath1 10@xmath7ev , which corresponds to the chance probability of 0.2 % due to fluctuation of an isotropic distribution ( @xcite ) .
this anisotropy shows broad cosmic - ray flow from the directions of the galactic center and the cygnus regions . in the higher energies ,
no significant large - scale anisotropy was found .
bird et al .
( 1998 ) have shown the galactic plane enhancement in the similar energy range .
these experiments show that significant fraction of cosmic rays around 10@xmath7ev come from galactic sources . in the much higher energy range
@xmath10 4 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev , stanev et al .
( 1995 ) have claimed that cosmic rays exhibit a correlation with the direction of the supergalactic plane and the magnitude of the observed excess is 2.5 2.8 @xmath8 in terms of gaussian probabilities .
their result was mainly based on the haverah park data set . in the same energy range ,
such large - scale correlation with the supergalactic plane was not observed in the data sets of the agasa ( @xcite ) , sugar ( @xcite ) and fly s eye ( @xcite ) experiments .
however , agasa observed three pairs of cosmic rays above 4 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev within a limited solid angle of the experimental accuracy and the chance probability is 2.9 % if cosmic rays distribute uniformly in the agasa field of view .
two out of three are located nearly on the supergalactic plane .
if cosmic rays in each of these pairs come from the same source , the detailed study on energy , arrival time and direction distribution of these clusters may bring information on their source and the intergalactic magnetic field ( @xcite ) . in the observed energy spectrum ,
there are two distinctive energies : @xmath11 @xmath9 10@xmath0ev and 4 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev .
the former is the energy where the spectral slope changes ( @xcite ) .
this is interpreted as transition from galactic to extragalactic origin .
the latter is the energy where the gzk effect ( @xcite ) , which is a series of energy loss through interaction with the cosmic microwave background photons , becomes important on their propagation from sources .
it is important to study whether the arrival direction distribution of cosmic rays changes at these energies .
recent result of the agasa energy spectrum shows the extension beyond the expected gzk cutoff ( @xcite ) . since the distance to sources of cosmic rays above the expected gzk cutoff
is limited to 50 mpc ( @xcite ) , their arrival directions may be correlated with luminous matter distribution if they are astrophysical source origin such as hot spots of radio galaxies ( @xcite ) , active galactic nuclei ( @xcite ) , accretion flow to a cluster of galaxies ( @xcite ) , relativistic shocks in gamma - ray bursts ( @xcite ) , and so on .
there is another possibility that most energetic cosmic rays are generated through decay of supermassive `` x '' particles related to topological defects ( @xcite , reference therein ) . in this case ,
arrival directions of most energetic cosmic rays are not necessarily associated with luminous matters .
if such particles are the part of dark matter and are concentrated in the galactic halo , anisotropy associated with our galactic halo is expected ( @xcite ) . in this paper
, we first examine large - scale anisotropy in terms of various coordinates using the data set of the akeno giant air shower array ( agasa ) until august 1998 , including the old data set of the akeno 20 km@xmath12 array ( a20 ) before 1990 .
then we search for the small - scale anisotropy above 10@xmath0ev with the agasa data set .
the akeno observatory is situated at 138@xmath3 30@xmath13 e and 35@xmath3 47@xmath13 n. agasa consists of 111 surface detectors deployed over an area of about 100 km@xmath12 , and has been in operation since 1990 ( @xcite ) .
a20 is a prototype detector system of agasa , operated from 1984 to 1990 ( @xcite ) , and is a part of agasa after 1990 .
each surface detector consists of plastic scintillators of 2.2 m@xmath12 area .
the detectors are placed with a separation of about 1 km .
they are controlled and operated from a central computer through optical fiber network .
relative time difference among the detectors are measured with 40 nsec accuracy ; all clocks at detector sites are synchronized to the central clock and signal - propagation time in cables and electronic devices are regularly measured at start of each run ( twice a day ) .
the details of the agasa instruments have been described in chiba et al .
( 1992 ) and ohoka et al .
( 1997 ) .
the accuracy on determination of shower parameters are evaluated through the analysis of a large number of artificial events .
these artificial events are generated with taking account of air shower features and fluctuation determined experimentally .
figure [ fig : acc_dir ] shows the accuracy on arrival direction determination for cosmic - ray induced air showers as a function of energies .
the vertical axis denotes the opening angle @xmath14 between input ( simulated ) and output ( analyzed ) arrival directions .
the opening angles including 68 % and 90 % of data are plotted . by analyzing artificial events with the same algorithm used above
, the accuracy on energy determination is estimated to be @xmath15 30 % above 10@xmath0ev ( @xcite ) .
table [ tbl : num_events ] lists the number of selected events , n(e ) , with zenith angles smaller than 45@xmath3 and with core locations inside the array area .
events below 10@xmath0ev are used only a reference analysis in this paper .
the difference of n(e @xmath10 3.2 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev ) @xmath16 n(e @xmath10 10@xmath0ev ) between a20 and agasa arises from the difference of detection efficiency of each system .
seven events are observed above 10@xmath2ev , including one event after takeda et al .
figure [ fig : equ1900](a ) shows arrival directions of cosmic rays with energies above 10@xmath0ev on the equatorial coordinates .
dots , open circles , and open squares represent cosmic rays with energies of ( 1 4 ) @xmath1 10@xmath0ev , ( 4 10 ) @xmath1 10@xmath0ev , and @xmath10 10@xmath2ev , respectively .
the shaded regions indicate the celestial regions excluded in this paper due to the zenith angle cut of @xmath17 45@xmath3 .
the galactic and supergalactic planes are drawn by the dashed lines . ``
gc '' designates the galactic center .
figure [ fig : equ1900](b ) shows arrival directions of cosmic rays only above 4 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev on the galactic coordinates .
details of the cosmic rays above 4 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev are listed in table [ tbl:40eev ] . in order to search for cosmic ray anisotropy
, it is required to compare observed and expected event frequencies at each region .
an expected frequency is easily estimated as far as the exposure in each direction can be obtained ; the uniformity of observation time on solar time for several years , which results in the uniform observation in right ascension , is expected for a surface array detection system operating in stable like agasa .
the fluctuation of the observation time on the local sidereal time is ( 0.2 @xmath15 0.1 ) % which is small enough compared with anisotropy in this energy range , so that the exposure ( observation time @xmath1 collection area ) in right ascension is quite uniform .
figure [ fig : harmo ] shows results of the first ( left ) and second ( right ) harmonics in right ascension .
the amplitude ( top ) , the phase ( middle ) , and the chance probability ( bottom ) are shown in each energy bin . in the top panels of the harmonic amplitude , the shaded region
is expected from statistical fluctuation of an isotropic distribution with the chance probability larger than 10 % .
no significant anisotropy above this level is found above 3.2 @xmath1 10@xmath7ev .
this is consistent with our previous paper ( @xcite ) , in which zenith angles up to 60@xmath3 were used .
figure [ fig : dec1900 ] shows the declination distribution of events above 10@xmath0ev ( light shaded histogram ) and 10@xmath2ev ( dark shaded histogram ) .
a solid curve is a third order polynomial function fitted to the light shaded histogram .
this curve is consistent with the zenith angle dependence of the agasa exposure and considered to be the expected distribution if cosmic rays distribute isotropically on the celestial sphere . since the trigger efficiency is independent of energy above 10@xmath0ev and zenith angle less than 45@xmath3 , this distribution is applied to in higher energies .
excess with 2.5 @xmath8 deviation is found in @xmath18 @xmath19 [ 30@xmath3 , 40@xmath3 ] and this will be discussed later .
if cosmic rays have origin associating with nearby astrophysical objects , we may expect cosmic - ray anisotropy correlated with the galactic or supergalactic plane .
figure [ fig : lat_gsg ] shows the latitude distribution on the galactic ( left ) and supergalactic ( right ) coordinates in three energy ranges of ( 1 2 ) @xmath1 10@xmath0ev ( top ) , ( 2 4 ) @xmath1 10@xmath0ev ( middle ) , and @xmath10 4 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev ( bottom ) .
a solid line in each panel indicates the cosmic - ray intensity expected from an isotropic distribution . in order to examine any preference for arrival directions along the galactic and supergalactic planes ,
the plane enhancement parameter @xmath21 introduced by wdowczyk and wolfendale ( 1984 ) was used .
the @xmath21 value characterizes the anisotropy expressed by : @xmath22 where @xmath23 is galactic or supergalactic latitude in radians , @xmath24 and @xmath25 are observed and expected intensities at latitude @xmath23 .
a positive @xmath21 value suggests a galactic or supergalactic plane enhancement , @xmath26 indicates that arrival direction distribution is isotropic , and a negative @xmath21 shows depression around the plane .
figure [ fig : fe_gsg ] shows the dependence of @xmath21 on the primary energy for the galactic ( left ) and supergalactic ( right ) coordinates .
some excess can be seen around the supergalactic plane in the seventh energy bin ( @xmath27(e[ev ] ) @xmath19 [ 19.1 , 19.2 ] ) , where @xmath28 .
in other energies , the arrival direction distribution is consistent with an isotropic distribution .
figure [ fig : axhist_gc ] shows the @xmath30(@xmath29 ) distribution , where @xmath29 is the opening angle between the cosmic - ray arrival direction and the galactic center direction , with energies above 10@xmath0ev ( top ) , 2 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev ( middle ) , and 4 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev ( bottom ) .
histograms are the observed distribution and the solid curves are expected from an isotropic distribution .
the observed distribution is consistent with the solid curve in all energy ranges .
the dashed and dotted curves are expected from the dark matter halo model ( @xcite ) and will be discussed in section [ ssect : berezinsky ] .
there is no statistically significant large - scale anisotropy in the above one - dimensional analyses . here , we search for two - dimensional anisotropy with taking account of the angular resolution event by event
. figures [ fig : dmap1900 ] and [ fig : dmap1960 ] show the contour maps of the cosmic - ray excess or deficit with respect to an isotropic distribution above 10@xmath0ev and 4 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev , respectively .
a bright region indicates that the observed cosmic - ray intensity is larger than the expected intensity and a dark region shows a deficit region . for each observed event , we calculate a point spread function which is assumed to be a normalized gaussian probability distribution with a standard deviation of the angular resolution @xmath31 obtained from figure [ fig : acc_dir ] .
the probability densities of all events are folded into cells of 1@xmath3 @xmath1 1@xmath3 in the equatorial coordinates .
at each cell , we sum up densities within 4.0@xmath3 radius for figure [ fig : dmap1900 ] and 2.5@xmath3 for figure [ fig : dmap1960 ] .
these radii are obtained from @xmath32 , and they would make excess regions clearer .
the reference distribution is obtained from an isotropic distribution . in these figures , small statistics of observed and expected events
result in bright regions at the lower and higher declination and hence bright spots below @xmath33 are not significant .
two distinctive bright regions are found in figure [ fig : dmap1900 ] , which are broader than the angular resolution .
they are referred to as broad clusters , such as the bc1 ( 20@xmath3450@xmath35 , 32@xmath3 ) and bc2 ( 1@xmath3440@xmath35 , 35@xmath3 ) .
the member events within 4@xmath3 radius of bc1 are listed in table [ tbl : clst_1900 ] .
four brighter regions in the middle declination are found in figure [ fig : dmap1960 ] : the c1
c4 clusters which are noted in the eighth column of table [ tbl:40eev ] .
c3 clusters follow the notation used in our previous analysis ( @xcite ) .
the c2 cluster is observed in both energy ranges . in figure
[ fig : dmap1900 ] , the contour map has eight steps in [ @xmath36 , @xmath37 ; lower two steps below @xmath38 are absent .
the significance of deviation from an isotropic distribution are estimated to be 2.4 @xmath8 at the c2 cluster , 2.7 @xmath8 at the bc1 cluster , and 2.8 @xmath8 at the bc2 cluster .
the arrival directions of cosmic rays around the bc1 cluster are shown in figure [ fig : clst_c0](a ) , and a radius of each circle corresponds to the logarithm of its energy . shaded circles have energies above 10@xmath0ev and open circles below 10@xmath0ev .
figure [ fig : clst_c0](b ) shows the arrival time
energy relation , and open circles denote members of the bc1 cluster .
the members of the bc1 cluster have energies between 10@xmath0ev and 2.5 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev and no excess of cosmic rays are observed below 10@xmath0ev around this direction .
five members of the bc1 cluster are observed around mjd 50,000 .
this cluster is in the direction of a famous supernova remnant the cygnus loop which extends about 3@xmath3 around ( 20@xmath3450@xmath35 , 30@xmath3 34@xmath13 ) .
the bc2 cluster is the broader cluster without a clear boundary .
the bc1 and bc2 clusters contribute the excess around @xmath39 shown in figure [ fig : dec1900 ] .
the c2 and bc2 clusters are located near the supergalactic plane and lead the largest @xmath40 value in section [ ssect : fe ] . for small statistics of observed events ,
figure [ fig : dmap1960 ] reflects the arrival directions of individual events ( open squares and open circles in figure [ fig : equ1900 ] ) .
the brightest peak is at the c2 cluster where three cosmic rays are observed against expected 0.05 events .
it is possible that some of these clusters are observed by a chance coincidence .
it should be noted , however , that two of these clusters the doublet ( c1 ) including the agasa highest energy event and the triplet ( c2 ) lie near the supergalactic plane , as pointed in our previous analysis ( @xcite ) .
the arrival directions ( left ) and arrival time
energy relation ( right ) for the c1 ( top ) and c2 ( bottom ) clusters are shown in figure [ fig : clst_1960 ] .
a radius of each circle in the left panels corresponds to the logarithm of its energy , and open circles in the right panels denote members of the c1 and c2 clusters . around the c2 cluster ,
several lower energy cosmic rays are observed very close to the c2 cluster .
the threshold energy of 4 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev is one distinctive energy where the gzk effect becomes large as mentioned in section [ sect : intro ] .
it is , however , quite important to examine what kind of dependence on threshold energy is operating . to begin with ,
we estimate the chance probability of observing one triplet and three doublets from 47 cosmic rays above 4 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev . a cluster of cosmic rays is defined as
follows : 1 .
define the @xmath41-th event ; 2 . count the number of events within a circle of radius 2.5@xmath3 centered on the arrival direction of the @xmath41-th event ; 3 . if this number of events exceeds a certain threshold value @xmath42 , the @xmath41-th event is counted as a cluster .
this procedure was repeated for total 47 events and then the total number of clusters with @xmath43 was determined .
the chance probability @xmath44 of observing this number of clusters under an isotropic distribution is obtained from the distribution of the number of clusters using 10,000 simulated data sets .
these simulated data sets were also analyzed by the same procedure described above . out of 10,000 simulations ,
32 trials had equal or more doublets ( @xmath45 ) than the observed data set , so that @xmath46 . and @xmath47 for triplets ( @xmath48 ) . then , the energy dependence for observing ( a ) doublets and ( b ) triplets are estimated and the results are shown in figure [ fig : clst_edep ] . when a new cluster is added above a threshold energy ,
a histogram changes discontinuously at that energy . at the maximum threshold energy where the triplet is detected , we find @xmath44 @xmath19 0.16 % in figure [ fig : clst_edep](b ) .
the narrow peaks of @xmath44 @xmath9 0.1 % above 4 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev in figures [ fig : clst_edep](a ) result from the c1 , c3 and c4 doublets , and another doublet c5 is found just below 4 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev . here , these chance probabilities are estimated without taking the degree of freedom on the threshold energy into account .
however , the chance probabilities are smaller than 1 % and do nt vary abruptly with energies above 4 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev .
this means that the threshold energy of 4 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev for doublet and triplet in figure
[ fig : dmap1960 ] may indicate any critical energy , and suggests that their sources are not very far being different from those below this energy .
seven events have been observed with energies above 10@xmath2ev , and their energies and coordinates are also listed in table [ tbl:40eev ] .
their declination are near @xmath49 while an isotropic distribution is shown by the solid curve in figure [ fig : dec1900 ] . to check whether these seven events distribute isotropically or not , we compare celestial distribution of seven 10@xmath2ev events with that for events between 10@xmath0ev and 10@xmath2ev in ten different coordinates .
the kolmogorov - smirnov ( ks ) test ( @xcite ) was used for avoiding any binning effect .
the results are summarized in table [ tbl:100eev_ks ] .
the smallest ks probability in table [ tbl:100eev_ks ] is 2.5 % for the declination distribution ; but this probability becomes larger using data set above 6.3 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev .
one interesting feature is that five 10@xmath2ev cosmic rays come from south - west of the agasa array , where the strength of the geomagnetic field component which is perpendicular to an air shower axis is larger than the other directions ( @xcite ) .
above 3 @xmath1 10@xmath7ev , no large - scale anisotropy has been found with the harmonic analysis and the @xmath50 fit .
gillman and watson ( 1993 ) summarized the @xmath50 values using the data sets obtained mainly from the haverah park experiment .
they obtained no significant deviation from @xmath51 . the result from the fly s eye experiment ( @xcite ) is consistent with an isotropic distribution of cosmic rays with e @xmath5 10@xmath0ev .
the analysis with the yakutsk data set ( @xcite ) shows no significant galactic plane enhancement above 10@xmath7ev .
the results from all experiments are consistent with this work on no correlation of cosmic rays above 10@xmath0ev with the galactic plane .
this may implicate the extragalactic origin of cosmic rays above 10@xmath0ev if they are mostly protons .
the bc1 , bc2 and c1
c5 clusters are found with energies @xmath10 10@xmath0ev or @xmath5 4 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev .
the c2 and bc2 clusters lead the small preference along the supergalactic plane in the energy range of @xmath27(e[ev ] ) @xmath19 [ 19.1 , 19.2 ] . with the data sets of haverah park , yakutsk , and valcano ranch ( @xcite ) and agasa ,
another triplet is found at the position of the c1 cluster within experimental error box on arrival direction determination .
this triplet at the c1 cluster position includes the agasa highest energy event and a 10@xmath2ev haverah park event .
it should be noted that these triplets at the c1 and c2 positions are close to the supergalactic plane .
kuzmin and rubakov ( 1997 ) and berezinsky et al . (
1997 ) have suggested a cosmic - ray source model associated with dark matter distribution in our galactic halo . in this model
, most energetic cosmic rays are generated through decay of supermassive particles which are trapped in the galactic halo and thus distribute symmetrically around the galactic center .
the arrival directions of most energetic cosmic rays , therefore , exhibit anisotropy at the earth ( @xcite ) . from recent studies by berezinsky and mikhailov ( 1998 ) and medina tanco and watson ( 1998 ) ,
a significant anisotropy would be expected in the first harmonics of right ascension distribution , the amplitude of 40 % at phase about 250@xmath3 , which is independent of the iso and nfw models of dark matter distribution in the galactic halo .
the iso and nfw models are described in kravtsov et al .
( 1997 ) and navarro , frenk and white ( 1996 ) , respectively .
this expected anisotropy is consistent with the results of the harmonic analysis above 4 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev as shown in figure [ fig : harmo ] .
however , this amplitude is explained with statistical fluctuation of an isotropic distribution .
as shown by the dashed and dotted curves in figure [ fig : axhist_gc ] , the iso and nfw models of dark matter distribution in the galactic halo lead excess toward the galactic center .
table [ tbl : gal_halo ] shows the reduced-@xmath52 values of the observed @xmath4 distribution with the isotropic , iso and nfw models .
although the distribution expected from the iso and nfw models are quite different from the observed distribution in energies above 10@xmath0ev , the reduced-@xmath52 values are close to one another above 2 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev and 4 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev . above 2 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev , all three models are acceptable and it is hard to distinguish one from another . in section [ ssect : cluster ] , we calculated the chance probability of observing clusters under an isotropic distribution .
if cosmic rays are astrophysical source origin , the non - uniform distribution of galaxies or luminous matters should be taken into account , as claimed by medina tanco ( 1998 ) .
he calculated trajectories of cosmic rays above 4 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev in the intergalactic magnetic field under the assumption that flux of cosmic rays is proportional to the local density of galaxies .
the expected distribution of cosmic - ray intensity is no more uniform and this may result in a strong anisotropy .
this is different from the results in this paper so that our estimation of the chance probability of observing clusters under an isotropic distribution is experimentally reliable .
however , his calculation shows important results : the c2 cluster is on top of a maximum of the arrival probability for sources located between 20 and 50 mpc ; and the c1 cluster locates on a high arrival probability region for sources at more than 50 mpc .
this suggests the possibility that the members of these clusters are generated at different sources .
one need accumulate further statistics to make arrival direction , time and energy relation to be clear ( @xcite ) to distinguish whether the members of clusters come from a single source or unrelated sources . as mentioned in section [ ssect : cluster ] ,
the bc1 cluster is in the direction of the cygnus loop ( ngc6992/95 ) . from the hillas confinement condition of ( magnetic field @xmath1 size ) for cosmic ray acceleration ( @xcite ) , the magnetic field in the shock of the cygnus loop is too small to accelerate cosmic rays up to 10@xmath0ev . and the observed energy distribution and bunch of arrival time of the cluster members do nt favor the diffusive shock acceleration .
another possible candidate is psr 2053@xmath5336 with the period of 0.2215 sec and the magnetic field of about 3 @xmath1 10@xmath54 gauss ( @xcite )
. it may be plausible that such highly magnetized pulsar has accelerated cosmic rays up to 10@xmath0ev within a short time ( @xcite ) .
it is highly desired to search for any signals from this direction in other energy range around mjd 50,000 . for the c1
c5 clusters and 10@xmath2ev cosmic rays , coincidence with known astrophysical objects are searched for from three catalogs which are the second egret catalog ( @xcite ) , the cfa redshift catalog ( @xcite ) , and the eighth extragalactic redshift catalog ( @xcite ) .
the selection criteria are the following : ( i ) the separation angles within 4.0@xmath3 from a member of each cluster , and 2.5@xmath3 for the 10@xmath2ev cosmic ray ; ( ii ) the redshift within 0.02 . in the cfa catalog ,
only qsos / agns are selected .
candidate objects are listed in table [ tbl : correlate ] .
out of these objects , mrk 40 ( vv 141 , arp 151 ) is an interacting galaxy and may be most interesting .
it should be noted that al - dargazelli et al .
( 1996 ) claimed that nearby colliding galaxies are most favored as the sources of clusters ( regions of excess events ) defined by them using the world data available before 1996 .
in conclusion , there is no statistically significant large - scale anisotropy related to the galactic nor supergalactic plane .
the slight supergalactic plane enhancement is observed just above 10@xmath0ev and arises mainly from the bc2 and c2 clusters . above 4 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev ,
one triplet and three doublets are found and the probability of observing these clusters by a chance coincidence is smaller than 1 % . especially the triplet is observed against expected 0.05 events . out of these clusters , the c2 ( agasa triplet ) and c1 ( doublet including the agasa highest energy event or triplet together with the haverah park 10@xmath2ev event ) clusters are most interesting ; they are triplets found in the world data sets and are located near the supergalactic plane .
one should wait for the further high - rate observation to distinguish whether the members of clusters come from a single source or different sources .
the @xmath4 distribution expected from the dark matter halo model fits the data as well as an isotropic distribution above 2 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev and 4 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev , but is a poorer fit than isotropy above 10@xmath0ev .
the arrival direction distribution of the 10@xmath2ev cosmic rays is consistent with that of cosmic rays with lower energies and is uniform .
it is noteworthy that three of seven 10@xmath2ev cosmic rays are members of doublets .
the bc1 cluster is in the direction of the cygnus loop or psr 2053@xmath5336 region .
it is desirable to examine any signals from this direction in other energy band around mjd 50,000 .
we hope other experiments in tev pev regions to explore the c1
c5 clusters and 10@xmath2ev cosmic ray directions .
we are grateful to akeno - mura , nirasaki - shi , sudama - cho , nagasaka - cho , ohizumi - mura , tokyo electric power co. and nihon telegram and telephone co. for their kind cooperation .
the authors are indebted to other members of the akeno group in the maintenance of the agasa array .
the authors are grateful to prof .
v. berezinsky for his suggestions on the analysis of the dark matter halo hypothesis .
m.takeda acknowledges the receipt of jsps research fellowships .
the authors thank paul sommers for his valuable suggestion on the preparation of the manuscript .
berezinsky , v. , and grigoreve , s. i. 1988 , , 199 , 1 .
berezinsky , v. , kachelriess , m , and vilenkin , a. 1997 , , 79 4302 .
berezinsky , v. 1998 , nucl .
suppl . , 70 , 419 .
berezinsky , v. , and mikhailov , a. 1998 , _ astro - ph/9810277 _ bhattacharjee , p. , and sigl , g. 1998 , _ astro - ph/9811011 _ biermann , p. l. , and strittmatter , p. a. , 1987 , , 322 , 643 .
bird , d. j. _ et al .
_ 1994 , , 424 , 491 .
bird , d. j. _ et al .
_ 1998 , _ astro - ph/9806096_. blanford .
, r. d. , 1976 , , 176 , 465 .
chiba , n. _ et al .
_ 1992 , nucl .
instr . and meth . , a 311 , 338 . efimov , n. n. _ et al .
_ 1988 , _ catalogue of highest energy cosmic rays _ ,
efimov , n. n. _ et al .
_ 1991 , _ astrophysicsal aspects of the most energetic cosmic rays _ , eds . m. nagano and f. takahara ( world scientific ) p.20 .
gillman , m. s. , and watson , a. a. 1993 , _ proc .
23rd icrr ( calgary ) _ , 2 , 47 .
goldreich , p. , and julian , w. h. 1969 , 157 , 869 .
greisen , k. , 1966 , , 16 748 .
gunn , j. e. , and ostriker , j. p. 1969
, , 22 , 728 .
hayashida , n. et al .
1996 , , 77 , 1000 .
hayashida , n. _ et al .
_ 1998 , astroparticle physics , _ to be published_. hill , c. t. , and schramm , d. n. 1985 , , 31 , 564 .
hillas , a. m. , 1984 , , 22 , 425 .
huchra , j. p. _ et al .
_ 1995 , harvard - smithsonian center for astrophysics .
ivanov , a. a. _ et al .
_ 1997 , prog . of 24th icrc ( durban ) og6.3.6 .
ivanov , a. a. 1998 , j. phys .
phys . , 24 , 227 .
kang , h. , rachen , p. , and biermann , p. l. 1997 , , 286 , 257 .
kewley , l. j. , clay , r. w. , and dawson , b. r. 1996 , astroparticle physics , 5 , 69 .
kravtsov , a. v. _ et al .
_ 1998 , , 502 , 48 .
kuzmin , v. a. , and rubakov , v. a. , 1998 , phys . atom .
61 , 1028 .
61 , 1122 ] lawrence , m. a. , reid , r. j. o. , and watson , a. a. 1991 , j. phys .
linsley , j. 1980 , _ catalogue of highest energy cosmic rays _
lovelace , r. v. e. , 1976 , , 262 , 649 .
manchester , r.n . and
taylor , j. h. 1981 , .
86 , 1953 .
medina tanco , g. a. 1998 , _ astro - ph/9801060_. medina tanco , g. a. , and watson , a. a. 1998 , astroparticle physics , _ to be published_. navarro , j. f. , frenk , c. s. , and white s. d. m. 1997 , , 490 , 493 .
ohoka , h. _ et al .
_ 1997 , nucl .
instr . and meth . , a 385 , 268
ostrowski , m. , 1998 , , 335 , 134 .
press , w. h. _ et al .
_ 1988 , in _ numerical recipes in c _ , ( cambridge university press ) .
rachen , p. , and biermann , p. l. 1993 , , 272 , 161 .
rees , m. j. et al .
1982 , , 295 , 17 .
sigl , g. , and lemoine , m. 1998 , astropart .
phys . 9 , 65 .
stanev , t. _ et al .
_ 1995 , , 75 , 3056 .
stanev , t. , and vankov , h. p. 1997
, , 55 , 1365 .
szabelski , j. , wdowczyk , j. , and wolfendale , a. w. 1986 , j. phys .
, 12 , 1433 .
takahara , f. , 1990 , prog .
phys . , 83 , 1071l .
takeda , m. _ et al .
_ 1998 , , 81 , 1163 .
teshima , m. _ et al .
_ 1986 , nucl .
instr . and meth . , a 247 , 399
thompson , d. j. _ et al .
_ 1995 , , 101 , 259 .
thompson , d. j. _ et al .
_ 1996 , , 107 , 227 .
uchihori , y. _ et al .
_ 1996 , _ proc .
symposium on extremely high energy cosmic rays : astrophysics and future observations _ , edited by m. nagano ( inst .
of cosmic ray research , university of tokyo ) , p.50 .
veron - cetty , m. p. , and veron , p. 1998
, eso scientific report 18 .
vietri , m. , 1995 , , 453 , 883 .
waxman , e. , 1995 , , 75 , 386 .
winn , m. m. _ et al .
_ 1986 , _ catalogue of highest energy cosmic rays _ , p.68 .
wdowczyk , j. , and wolfendale , a. w. 1984 , j. phys .
, 10 , 1453 .
yoshida , s. , and teshima , m. 1993 , prog .
yoshida , s. _ et al .
_ 1995 , astropart .
phys . 3 , 105 .
zatsepin , g. t. , and kuzmin , v. a. 1966 , zh .
, 4 , 114 [ jetp letters , 4 , 78 ] .
lllrrrrc 84/12/12 & 14:18:02 & 6.81 @xmath1
10@xmath0 ev & 22@xmath34 21@xmath35 & 38.4@xmath55 & 93.3@xmath55 & @xmath5615.7@xmath55 & + 84/12/17 & 10:28:16 & 9.79 & 18@xmath34 29@xmath35 & 35.3@xmath55 & 63.5@xmath55 & 19.4@xmath55 & + 86/01/05 & 19:31:03 & 5.47 & 4@xmath34 38@xmath35 & 30.1@xmath55 & 170.4@xmath55 & @xmath5611.2@xmath55 & c4 + 86/10/23 & 14:25:15 & 6.22 & 14@xmath34 02@xmath35 & 49.9@xmath55 & 96.8@xmath55 & 63.4@xmath55 & + 87/11/26 & 17:49:20 & 4.82 & 21@xmath34 57@xmath35 & 27.6@xmath55 & 82.1@xmath55 & @xmath5621.1@xmath55 & + 89/03/14 & 02:45:39 & 5.27 & 13@xmath34 48@xmath35 & 34.7@xmath55 & 68.3@xmath55 & 75.6@xmath55 & + 89/08/16 & 08:32:01 & 4.07 & 5@xmath34 51@xmath35 & 58.5@xmath55 & 154.5@xmath55 & 15.6@xmath55 & + 90/11/25 & 11:05:39 & 4.51 & 16@xmath34 17@xmath35 & @xmath567.2@xmath55 & 6.1@xmath55 & 29.6@xmath55 & + 91/04/03 & 00:32:40 & 5.09 & 15@xmath34 47@xmath35 & 41.0@xmath55 & 65.7@xmath55 & 51.5@xmath55 & + 91/04/20 & 08:24:49 & 4.35 & 18@xmath34 59@xmath35 & 47.8@xmath55 & 77.9@xmath55 & 18.4@xmath55 & c3 + & & & & & & & + 91/05/31 & 13:07:04 & 5.53 & 3@xmath34 37@xmath35 & 69.5@xmath55 & 136.6@xmath55 & 11.2@xmath55 & + 91/11/29 & 14:53:03 & 9.10 & 19@xmath34 06@xmath35 & 77.2@xmath55 & 108.8@xmath55 & 25.6@xmath55 & + 91/12/10 & 18:59:10 & 4.24 & 0@xmath34 12@xmath35 & 78.6@xmath55 & 121.0@xmath55 & 15.9@xmath55 & + 92/01/07 & 03:16:49 & 4.51 & 9@xmath34 36@xmath35 & 38.6@xmath55 & 184.3@xmath55 & 48.0@xmath55 & + 92/01/24 & 12:26:17 & 4.88 & 17@xmath34 52@xmath35 & 47.9@xmath55 & 74.8@xmath55 & 29.4@xmath55 & + 92/02/01 & 17:20:52 & 5.53 & 0@xmath34 34@xmath35 & 17.7@xmath55 & 117.2@xmath55 & @xmath5645.0@xmath55 & + 92/03/30 & 03:05:30 & 4.47 & 17@xmath34 03@xmath35 & 31.4@xmath55 & 53.6@xmath55 & 35.6@xmath55 & + 92/08/01 & 13:00:47 & 5.50 & 11@xmath34 29@xmath35 & 57.1@xmath55 & 143.2@xmath55 & 56.6@xmath55 & c2 + 92/09/13 & 08:59:44 & 9.25 & 6@xmath34 44@xmath35 & 34.9@xmath55 & 180.5@xmath55 & 13.9@xmath55 & + 93/01/12 & 02:41:13 & & 8@xmath34 17@xmath35 & 16.8@xmath55 & 206.7@xmath55 & 26.4@xmath55 & + & & & & & & & + 93/01/21 & 07:58:06 & 4.46 & 13@xmath34 55@xmath35 & 59.8@xmath55 & 108.8@xmath55 & 55.5@xmath55 & + 93/04/22 & 09:39:56 & 4.42 & 1@xmath34 56@xmath35 & 29.0@xmath55 & 139.8@xmath55 & @xmath5631.7@xmath55 & + 93/06/12 & 06:14:27 & 6.49 & 1@xmath34 16@xmath35 & 50.0@xmath55 & 127.0@xmath55 & @xmath5612.7@xmath55 & + 93/12/03 & 21:32:47 & & 1@xmath34 15@xmath35 & 21.1@xmath55 & 130.5@xmath55 & @xmath5641.4@xmath55 & c1 + 94/07/06 & 20:34:54 & & 18@xmath34 45@xmath35 & 48.3@xmath55 & 77.6@xmath55 & 20.9@xmath55 & c3 + lllrrrrc 94/07/28 & 08:23:37 & 4.08 @xmath1 10@xmath0 ev & 4@xmath34 56@xmath35 & 18.0@xmath55 & 182.8@xmath55 & @xmath5615.5@xmath55 & + 95/01/26 & 03:27:16 & 7.76 & 11@xmath34 14@xmath35 & 57.6@xmath55 & 145.5@xmath55 & 55.1@xmath55 & c2 + 95/03/29 & 06:12:27 & 4.27 & 17@xmath34 37@xmath35 & @xmath561.6@xmath55 & 22.8@xmath55 & 15.7@xmath55 & + 95/04/04 & 23:15:09 & 5.79 & 12@xmath34 52@xmath35 & 30.6@xmath55 & 117.5@xmath55 & 86.5@xmath55 & + 95/10/29 & 00:32:16 & 5.07 & 1@xmath34 14@xmath35 & 20.0@xmath55 & 130.2@xmath55 & @xmath5642.5@xmath55 & c1 + 95/11/15 & 04:27:45 & 4.89 & 4@xmath34 41@xmath35 & 29.9@xmath55 & 171.1@xmath55 & @xmath5610.8@xmath55 & c4 + 96/01/11 & 09:01:21 & & 16@xmath34 06@xmath35 & 23.0@xmath55 & 38.9@xmath55 & 45.8@xmath55 & c5 + 96/01/19 & 21:46:12 & 4.80 & 3@xmath34 52@xmath35 & 27.1@xmath55 & 165.4@xmath55 & @xmath5620.4@xmath55 & + 96/05/13 & 00:07:48 & 4.78 & 17@xmath34 56@xmath35 & 74.1@xmath55 & 105.1@xmath55 & 29.8@xmath55 & + 96/10/06 & 13:36:43 & 5.68 & 13@xmath34 18@xmath35 & 52.9@xmath55 & 113.8@xmath55 & 63.7@xmath55 & + & & & & & & & + 96/10/22 & 15:24:10 & & 19@xmath34 54@xmath35 & 18.7@xmath55 & 56.8@xmath55 & @xmath564.8@xmath55 & + 96/11/12 & 16:58:42 & 7.46 & 21@xmath34 37@xmath35 & 8.1@xmath55 & 62.7@xmath55 & @xmath5631.3@xmath55 & + 96/12/08 & 12:08:39 & 4.30 & 16@xmath34 31@xmath35 & 34.6@xmath55 & 56.2@xmath55 & 42.8@xmath55 & + 96/12/24 & 07:36:36 & 4.97 & 14@xmath34 17@xmath35 & 37.7@xmath55 & 68.5@xmath55 & 69.1@xmath55 & + 97/03/03 & 07:17:44 & 4.39 & 19@xmath34 37@xmath35 & 71.1@xmath55 & 103.0@xmath55 & 21.9@xmath55 & + 97/03/30 & 07:58:21 & & 19@xmath34 38@xmath35 & @xmath565.8@xmath55 & 33.1@xmath55 & @xmath5613.1@xmath55 & + 97/04/28 & 13:46:18 & 4.20 & 2@xmath34 18@xmath35 & 13.8@xmath55 & 152.9@xmath55 & @xmath5643.9@xmath55 & + 97/11/20 & 07:23:25 & 7.21 & 11@xmath34 09@xmath35 & 41.8@xmath55 & 171.2@xmath55 & 64.6@xmath55 & + 98/02/06 & 00:12:26 & 4.11 & 9@xmath34 47@xmath35 & 23.7@xmath55 & 207.2@xmath55 & 48.6@xmath55 & + 98/03/30 & 08:17:26 & 6.93 & 17@xmath34 16@xmath35 & 56.3@xmath55 & 84.5@xmath55 & 35.3@xmath55 & + & & & & & & & + 98/04/04 & 20:07:03 & 5.35 & 11@xmath34 13@xmath35 & 56.0@xmath55 & 147.5@xmath55 & 56.2@xmath55 & c2 + 98/06/12 & 06:43:49 & & 23@xmath34 16@xmath35 & 12.3@xmath55 & 89.5@xmath55 & @xmath5644.3@xmath55 & + 97/04/10 & 02:48:48 & 3.89 & 15@xmath34 58@xmath35 & 23.7@xmath55 & 39.1@xmath55 & 47.8@xmath55 & c5 + cllrrrr bc1 & 95/10/09 & 1.47 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev & 20@xmath34 50@xmath35 & 30.8@xmath3 & 73.9@xmath3 & @xmath56 8.2@xmath3 & 95/11/23 & 1.68 & 20@xmath34 54@xmath35 & 34.2@xmath3 & 77.1@xmath3 & @xmath56 6.8@xmath3 & 95/07/18 & 1.31 & 20@xmath34 42@xmath35 & 33.2@xmath3 & 74.8@xmath3 & @xmath56 5.5@xmath3 & 95/09/24 & 1.33 & 20@xmath34 41@xmath35 & 34.1@xmath3 & 75.4@xmath3 & @xmath56 4.8@xmath3 & 91/07/02 & 1.10 & 20@xmath34 55@xmath35 & 35.1@xmath3 & 77.9@xmath3 & @xmath56 6.4@xmath3 & 96/08/02 & 2.29 & 20@xmath34 55@xmath35 & 32.4@xmath3 & 75.9@xmath3 & @xmath56 8.1@xmath3 & 97/05/28 & 1.06 & 20@xmath34 50@xmath35 & 34.7@xmath3 & 77.1@xmath3 & @xmath56 5.9@xmath3 & 97/06/20 & 1.11 & 21@xmath34 02@xmath35 & 33.7@xmath3 & 77.8@xmath3 & @xmath56 8.4@xmath3 bc2 & & & 1@xmath34 40@xmath35 & 35@xmath3 & 134@xmath3 & @xmath5627@xmath3 lcclc azimuth angle ( @xmath57 ) & 0.268 & & zenith angle ( @xmath58 ) & 0.867 right ascension ( @xmath59 ) & 0.202 & & declination ( @xmath18 ) & 0.025 ecliptic longitude & 0.085 & & ecliptic latitude & 0.449 galactic longitude ( @xmath60 ) & 0.182 & & galactic latitute ( @xmath61 ) & 0.540 supergalactic longitude ( @xmath62 ) & 0.654 & & supergalactic latitude ( @xmath63 ) & 0.167 | with the akeno giant air shower array ( agasa ) , 581 cosmic rays above 10@xmath0ev , 47 above 4 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev , and 7 above 10@xmath2ev are observed until august 1998 .
arrival direction distribution of these extremely high energy cosmic rays has been studied . while no significant large - scale anisotropy is found on the celestial sphere , some interesting clusters of cosmic rays are observed . above 4 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev
, there are one triplet and three doublets within separation angle of 2.5@xmath3 and the probability of observing these clusters by a chance coincidence under an isotropic distribution is smaller than 1 % . especially the triplet is observed against expected 0.05 events .
the @xmath4 distribution expected from the dark matter halo model fits the data as well as an isotropic distribution above 2 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev and 4 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev , but is a poorer fit than isotropy above 10@xmath0ev .
arrival direction distribution of seven 10@xmath2ev cosmic rays is consistent with that of lower energy cosmic rays and is uniform .
three of seven are members of doublets above about 4 @xmath1 10@xmath0ev . |
compact muon solenoid ( cms ) experiment @xcite has been collecting data successfully since the start of the first large hadron collider ( lhc ) physics run in 2009 . during two future long shutdown periods of the accelerator , the cms collaboration intends to upgrade several subsystems of its detector @xcite .
in particular , the muon system as depicted in fig . [
fig : cmsmuonsystem ] will be extended by completing rings 2 and 3 in the fourth station in both endcaps to ensure efficient muon triggering and reconstruction in that region as the lhc instantaineous luminosity continues to increase . during the first long shutdown presently scheduled for 2013 - 2014
, this fourth endcap station will be equipped with resistive plate chambers ( rpcs ) up to @xmath6 .
for the latter subsystem , which is a dedicated cms muon trigger detector , the very forward region beyond @xmath7 will remain empty and could in principle be instrumented up to @xmath8 as is already the case for the cathode strip chamber ( csc ) system that serves as muon tracker in the endcap region .
however , the present design of the endcap rpcs , made of a double bakelite gas gap and operating in avalanche mode , is not expected to be suitable for the particle rates amounting to several tens of khz/@xmath3 in the scenario of an lhc luminosity going up to @xmath9 @xmath10s@xmath11 . here
, we report on an ongoing feasibility study to insert gas electron multiplier ( gem ) detectors in the vacant space of the rpc endcap system beyond @xmath7 . in general ,
gem detectors feature excellent spatial ( @xmath12100 @xmath13 m ) and timing ( @xmath125 ns ) resolution and are proven to be able to withstand particle rates up to 10 mhz/@xmath3 . furthermore
, in the specific case of cms , the use of such detector technology could in principle allow the combination of muon triggering and tracking capabilities into one single subsystem . generally desired for a trigger / tracker detector in the cms high @xmath0 region
are a time resolution better than 5 ns , a spatial resolution in the range of 200 - 400 @xmath13 m and an overall detector efficiency exceeding 97 % .
[ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] in the course of this project that was initiated in 2009 , several different types of small triple - gem prototypes were produced and then studied using x - rays in the rd51 @xcite lab of the cern detector technology group ( dt ) and/or particle beams at the cern sps .
table [ tab : smallprototypes ] specifies the small detectors that were produced so far along with their main construction parameters .
the first three small triple - gems listed in the table were extensively tested during 2009 - 2010 using the 150 gev pion / muon beam of the cern sps h4 beam line .
the main test results are summarized below ; more details can be found in @xcite .
the `` timing gem '' was mainly used to study the time resolution that could be obtained with such detectors , as function of the used gas mixture , and the drift and induction fields .
a time resolution of 4 ns could be reached with an ar / co@xmath14/cf@xmath15 45/40/15 gas mixture and a 3/1/2/1 mm ( drift , tranf.1 , transf.2 , ind . )
gap size configuration , which meets the requirement for the cms muon triggering system . adopting a geometry for the gems similar to the rpcs in the cms endcap disks ,
the smallest active gem detector area needed by cms is of the order of 50x100 @xmath3 . for such sizes , the standard double - mask technique to produce
the gem foils is not ideal as it suffers from alignment problems of the two masks on either side of the foils during the photolitographic hole etching process .
the single - mask technique @xcite overcomes this problem and was used to produce the `` single - mask gem '' prototype .
the performance of the single - mask gem was quite similar to our `` timing gem '' .
an efficiency up to 98 % was measured , albeit for a slightly higher gain than for the double - mask gem .
nevertheless , the single - mask technique appears quite mature and was chosen for the production of our large prototypes .
depending on how many endcap disks would be instrumented with gems , the number of detectors needed for cms could amount to several 100s . for such quantities , the time and certainly the cost of the detector production becomes an issue .
the most time - consuming and labor - intensive part of triple - gem production is the foil stretching and the gluing of the spacer frames . to avoid these steps in the production process
, two novel assembly procedures were tested as described below .
the `` honeycomb gem '' produced in 2010 , was assembled using honeycomb structures as spacers in the detector gaps between the gem foils , which avoids the need to stretch the foils .
although this prototype could be operated without any problems , very localized efficiency losses were observed at the position of the honeycomb structures .
with honeycomb cell sizes of ( 6/12/12/12)mm or ( 6/0/0/0)mm in the ( drift , transf.1 , transf.2 , ind . )
gap , an overall detector efficiency of about 75 % was obtained .
an important development in 2011 was the introduction of another new gem assembly technique , here referred to as the _ self - stretching _ technique .
the procedure is demonstrated in fig .
[ fig : ss ] showing a few photographs taken during the assembly at cern of the first @xmath16 @xmath3 triple - gem , `` cms proto iii '' , prototype using this new technique .
the gem foils are produced with a pattern of holes in the edge on each of the four sides .
the foils are then placed on a detector structure which has a set of alignment pins matching the hole pattern in the foil edges .
next , using a special external frame that is placed around the ensemble , the foils are mechanically stretched and then fixed with screws to the detector structure . in the end , once the foils have been completely stretched and fixed , the readout board can be mounted , closing the detector . clearly , compared to the standard assembly procedure , the _ self - stretching _ technique offers many advantages .
no gluing nor soldering is required during the assembly procedure and the detector is produced without the need to place any spacers in the active area , in the gaps between the foils .
the technique is very fast , for example this small prototype was assembled in only 1 hour . as an additional benefit ,
if needed , it allows for the detector to be re - opened in order to make modifications or repairs , or to replace a gem foil .
the small `` cms proto iii '' prototype was tested using an x - ray gun with a cu target in the rd51 lab . with an ar / co@xmath14 70/30 gas mixture ,
the detector exhibited stable operation for a measured gain up to at least @xmath17 .
the detector response was also observed to be very uniform across the gem surface .
given these promising results , another prototype with dimensions @xmath18
@xmath3 was just recently ( sept . 2011 ) produced with the new technique .
initial tests of its performance are ongoing .
besides the small prototypes described above , two full - size triple - gem prototypes were produced , called `` cms proto i '' ( april 2010 ) and `` cms proto ii '' ( march 2011 ) .
the design of the first prototype was reported earlier in @xcite .
the large prototypes have a trapezoidal shape with a gem active area of @xmath19 mm@xmath5 .
their geometry follows the design that was foreseen for the rpcs to be installed in the first endcap disks in the high-@xmath0 region , ie .
re1/1 in fig .
[ fig : cmsmuonsystem ] .
in fact , the gem detectors are embedded in a similar aluminum cover box as was designed for the rpcs in that area .
the chambers each cover a 10@xmath20 sector of the endcap disks .
[ fig : ge11diagram_a ] shows an exploded view of `` cms proto i '' , while fig .
[ fig : ge11diagram_b ] displays the general layout and gap size configuration of both detectors .
the gem foils for both large - area prototypes were produced at cern using a photolithographic process with a 50 @xmath13 m thick kapton sheet with a 5 @xmath13 m copper cladding on both sides . given the size of these large prototypes , the single - mask technique had to be used to produce the foils . to limit the discharge probability ,
the foils are divided in 35 sectors of about 100 @xmath3 each .
the drift electrodes , made of a 300 @xmath13 m kapton foil with a 5 @xmath13 m copper cladding , were glued directly to the 3 mm thick bottom aluminum plate of the detector cover boxes .
the readout planes provide a one - dimensional readout with radial strips , i.e. pointing to the lhc beam line , with a pitch varying from 0.8 ( short side ) to 1.6 mm ( long side ) for `` cms proto
i '' and from 0.6 to 1.2 mm for `` cms proto ii '' .
the first prototype was divided into four @xmath0-partitions with 256 strips per partition , while the second had eight partitions with 384 strips each . following the results obtained with the small prototypes on the gem timing performance , the gap size configuration for the second large prototype was 3/1/2/1 mm ( drift , transf.1 , transf.2 , induction ) in contrast to the 3/2/2/2 mm configuration for the first prototype
. different steps of the assembly procedure of the large prototypes are depicted in fig .
[ fig : largeprotoassembl ] . fig .
[ fig : ge11_gain ] shows the gain curve for `` cms proto i '' , measured with an x - ray gun in the rd51 lab .
the large prototypes were tested in 150 gev pion / muon beams at the cern sps h2 and h4 beamlines during several campaigns in october 2010 , and from june to september 2011 .
[ fig : cmslargeprototb_a ] shows the first large - area prototype installed at the sps h4 beam line in october 2010 . a special mounting frame allowed to move the detector in the transverse plane with respect to the beamline , such that the beam could be pointed at different locations along the gem surface in order to study the uniformity of the detector response .
the influence of a magnetic field on the performance of the prototypes was also tested by inserting them in the m1 magnet at the sps h2 beamline .
this magnet can produce fields up to 3 t. inside the cms detector , the gems would be installed at a location where the magnetic field can reach up to 1.5 t with an angle between the magnetic field and the gem electric field less than 8@xmath20 . fig .
[ fig : ge11_i_results ] shows a few results obtained with `` cms proto i '' in the october 2010 campaign . using an ar / co@xmath14 70/30 gas mixture , with the beam pointing at the detector @xmath0-sector with the smallest average pitch size , ie .
1.05 mm , a spatial resolution near the value expected from the strip pitch ( @xmath21 @xmath13 m ) , and a detector efficiency above 98 % were obtained .
the uniformity of the detector response across the gem active area was found to be very good . in fig .
[ fig : ge11_ii_srs ] some results are shown for the `` cms proto ii '' detector , which has a smaller strip pitch than `` cms proto i '' , obtained during the august 2011 test beam campaign . with the detector flowing an ar / co@xmath14/cf@xmath15 45/15/40 gas mixture ,
the data were taken with the h4 pion beam pointing at the region with the smallest strip pitch , i.e. 573 @xmath13 m . an average cluster size of about 3 strips was found and for the space resolution an upper limit of 103 @xmath13 m could be derived using the information on the charge sharing among adjacent strips , which is significantly better than the resolution expected from a purely digital readout ( as used for the result in fig . [ fig : ge11_i_results_a ] ) , i.e. @xmath22 @xmath13 m . in fig .
[ fig : ge11_m1 ] the measured shift in the average strip cluster position due to a magnetic field is shown for `` cms proto ii '' inside the m1 magnet .
measurements were performed in june and july 2011 using the sps h2 150 gev muon beam , with the detector flowing an ar / co@xmath14/cf@xmath15 45/15/40 gas mixture .
the angle between the gem electric field and the external magnetic field could be varied by rotating the detector inside the m1 magnet .
the data are in good agreement with a garfield / magboltz @xcite simulation performed for a 90@xmath20 angle between the magnetic field and the gem electric field . the measurement at 1.5 t was performed for an angle of 30@xmath20 , which explains the observed small deviation between data and simulation for that point . up until recently
, the readout of both the small and large prototypes was based on the turbo front - end electronics with the vfat @xcite chip that produces digital output for its 128 analogue input channels .
efforts are ongoing to design a new , enhanced version of the vfat2 chip to replace the present system .
furthermore , in the august - september 2011 campaigns the prototypes were for the first time successfully operated with the apv25 chip in combination with the scalable readout system ( srs ) @xcite that is being developed by the rd51 collaboration .
the results shown in fig . [ fig : ge11_ii_srs ] were obtained with this system . more details on test beam results obtained with the two large - area prototypes can be found in @xcite .
one of the possible scenarios that is presently under investigation for the installation of gems in the cms detector , proposes the use of double chambers in each endcap disk , i.e. two chambers installed face - to - face .
this would double the total number of detection layers and would thus greatly improve the tracking capability of the system .
in such a scenario , to equip the @xmath1 region of the first and second cms endcap disks , ie . the disks closest to the beam interaction point on either side , a total gem foil area of order 500 m@xmath5 would be needed .
in such a case , an industrialized production process becomes imperative . with the ever - increasing demand for gems at cern ,
the production facility will be significantly expanded in 2011 - 2013 .
a completely new production line with machines suitable for large numbers of large - area gems , up to about @xmath23 m@xmath5 , is presently being put into place . in the end
, the new facility will be housed in a dedicated building ( # 107 ) at cern . with this new setup
, it is expected that the production cost of large - area gems could be lowered to about 1 kchf / gem , with a production rate of 240 gems / year .
recently , an alternative gem production facility was put in place at the new flex company near seoul in south korea .
initial contacts with this company were made by cern in november 2008 and in june 2011 a full technology transfer from cern to new flex was organized . in the meantime , the company has produced its very first @xmath24
@xmath3 double - mask triple - gem , complete with voltage divider .
the `` korean i '' prototype ( see table [ tab : smallprototypes ] ) was tested with a cu target x - ray gun in the rd51 lab .
the detector and voltage divider exhibited very stable operation with an ar / co@xmath14 70/30 gas mixture ; smooth exponential gain curves were measured , similar to the cern gems .
the company is now progressing towards the production of large - area gems .
the cms monte carlo simulation package is used to study and quantify the improvements in the trigger and muon reconstruction performance of an extended muon system in the cms forward region as proposed here . as a starting point
the geometry of the rpcs as described in the cms muon technical design report @xcite is taken ( @xmath25 ) . to mimic the gem spatial resolution ,
the strip widths of the rpcs in the forward region @xmath26 are gradually increased ( @xmath27 ) for the first two endcap stations . using single - muon monte carlo simulation samples the effect of the gem spatial resolution on the muon reconstruction can be studied .
examples of first results on the reconstructed muon momentum resolution and track residuals are shown in fig .
[ fig : triggersim ] for various simulated gem spatial resolutions . for a @xmath28 tev muon ,
up to a strip segmentation a factor 8 higher than in the current rpcs , the tracking resolution is dominated by the strip width ; for even smaller strip widths the residual distribution becomes gaussian .
these initial simulations are now being extended to study the improvements in the cms muon trigger system .
the effect of the extended muon system on the detector acceptance for various physics channels under study at cms is also being addressed .
simulations of the gem detectors themselves are also being pursued @xcite .
the modeling of the gem is based on ansys , while the garfield / magboltz packages are used to simulate the electron avalanches and interactions with the material . with these simulations
the gem gain is studied , and possible influences on the gain from various construction parameters , such as the outer hole diameter ( see fig .
[ fig : gemsim_a ] ) , the drift and induction field , the thickness of the metal layers , and also the penning effect for the ar / co@xmath14 gas mixture are addressed .
detailed studies of the electron avalanches also allow to study electron losses due to the gem geometry or attachment to gas molecules . as an example , fig .
[ fig : gemsim_b ] shows the position coordinates of electrons lost in the gem material .
finally , the effect of an external magnetic field on the gem performance is also studied in detail .
after intense studies on small - size prototypes , two fully operational large - area triple - gem detectors were designed and assembled during 2010 - 2011 . with several test beam campaigns at the cern sps h2 and h4 muon / pion beam lines it was demonstrated that these @xmath29 mm@xmath5 prototypes exhibit stable and reliable operation and can be run with high gain and detector efficiency .
the prototypes were tested inside a 1.5 t magnetic field , and could also be operated successfully with the rd51 scalable readout system .
gem detectors based on these full - size prototypes are being proposed for the extension of the cms muon endcap system in the forward region .
simulation studies of the improved cms trigger and physics performance with this system are ongoing .
this work has partly been performed in the framework of the rd51 collaboration .
the authors that are members of the cms collaboration would like to explicitly thank the rd51 collaboration for its continuous support of this work , for the many fruitful discussions , for the close collaboration during the test beam campaigns and for dedicating part of their lab space at cern to this project .
s. chatrchyan _
_ , the cms collaboration , _ the cms experiment at the cern lhc _ , j. instrum
. 3 ( 2008 ) s08004 the cms collaboration , _ technical proposal for the upgrade of the cms detector through 2020 _ , cern - lhcc-2011 - 006 ; cms - ug - tp-1 ; lhcc - p-004 the rd51 collaboration , http://rd51-public.web.cern.ch/rd51-public/ d. abbaneo _ et al .
_ , _ characterization of gem detectors for application in the cms muon detection system _ , 2010 ieee nucl .
rec 1416 - 1422 ; rd51 note 2010 - 005 ;
arxiv:1012.3675v1 [ physics.ins-det ] s. duarte pinto _
et al . _ , jinst 4 ( 2009 ) p12009 ; m. villa _
et al . _ ,
instr . and meth .
a628 ( 2011 ) 182 - 186 d. abbaneo _ et al .
_ , _ construction of the first full - size gem - based prototype for the cms high-@xmath0 muon system _ , 2010 ieee nucl .
rec . 1909 - 1913 ; rd51 note 2010 - 008 ; arxiv:1012.1524v2 [ physics.ins-det ] r. veenhof , _ garfield - simulation of gaseous detectors _ , http://garfield.web.cern.ch/garfield/ ; s. biagi , _ magboltz - transport of electrons in gas mixtures _ , http://consult.cern.ch/writeups/magboltz/ p. aspell _ et al .
_ , _ vfat2 : a front - end system on chip providing fast trigger information , digitized data storage and formatting for the charge sensitive readout of multi - channel silicon and gas particle detectors _ , proc . of the topical workhop on electronics for particle physic ( twepp2007 ) , prague , czech republic , september 3 - 7 , 2007 s. martoiu _
_ , _ front - end electronics for the scalable readout system of rd51 _ , contribution n43 - 5 to this conference d. abbaneo _ et al .
_ , _ test beam results of the ge1/1 prototype for cms high - eta muon system future upgrade _ , contribution np5.s-221 to this conference the cms collaboration , _ the muon project , cms technical design report _ ,
cern / lhcc 97 - 32 ; cms - tdr-003 t. moulik , _ simulation of a triple - gem detector for a potential cms muon tracking and trigger upgrade _ , submitted to the proc . of the technology and instrumentation in particle physics 2011 ( tipp 2011 ) conference , 9 - 14 june , 2011 , chicago , il , usa | at present , part of the forward rpc muon system of the cms detector at the cern lhc remains uninstrumented in the high-@xmath0 region .
an international collaboration is investigating the possibility of covering the @xmath1 region of the muon endcaps with large - area triple - gem detectors .
given their good spatial resolution , high rate capability , and radiation hardness , these micro - pattern gas detectors are an appealing option for simultaneously enhancing muon tracking and triggering capabilities in a future upgrade of the cms detector . a general overview of this feasibility study will be presented .
the design and construction of small ( @xmath2 @xmath3 ) and full - size trapezoidal ( @xmath4 m@xmath5 ) triple - gem prototypes will be described . during detector assembly ,
different techniques for stretching the gem foils were tested .
results from measurements with x - rays and from test beam campaigns at the cern sps will be shown for the small and large prototypes .
preliminary simulation studies on the expected muon reconstruction and trigger performances of this proposed upgraded muon system will be reported . |
our aim in physics is not only to calculate some observable and get a correct number but mainly to understand a physical picture responsible for the given phenomenon .
it very often happens that a theory formulated in terms of fundamental degrees of freedom can not answer such a question since it becomes overcomplicated at the related scale .
thus a main task in this case is to select those degrees of freedom which are indeed essential .
for instance , the fundamental degrees of freedom in crystals are ions in the lattice , electrons and the electromagnetic field . nevertheless , in order to understand electric conductivity , heat capacity , etc .
we instead work with `` heavy electrons '' with dynamical mass , phonons and their interaction . in this case
a complicated electromagnetic interaction of the electrons with the ions in the lattice is `` hidden '' in the dynamical mass of the electron and the interactions among ions in the lattice are eventually responsible for the collective excitations of the lattice - phonons , which are goldstone bosons of the spontaneously broken translational invariance in the lattice of ions . as a result ,
the theory becomes rather simple - only the electron and phonon degrees of freedom and their interactions are essential for all the properties of crystals mentioned above .
quite a similar situation takes place in qcd .
one hopes that sooner or later one can solve the full nonquenched qcd on the lattice and get the correct nucleon and pion mass in terms of underlying degrees of freedom : current quarks and gluon fields .
however , qcd at the scale of 1 gev becomes too complicated , and hence it is rather difficult to say in this case what kind of physics , inherent in qcd , is relevant to the nucleon mass and its low - energy properties . in this lecture
i will try to answer this question .
i will show that it is the spontaneous breaking of chiral symmetry which is the most important qcd phenomenon in this case , and that beyond the scale of spontaneous breaking of chiral symmetry light and strange baryons can be viewed as systems of three constituent quarks which interact by the exchange of goldstone bosons ( pseudoscaler mesons ) , vector and scalar mesons ( which could be considered as a representation of a correlated goldstone boson exchange ) and are subject to confinement .
at low temperatures and densities the @xmath6 chiral symmetry of qcd lagrangian is spontaneously broken down to @xmath7 by the qcd vacuum ( in the large @xmath8 limit it would be @xmath9 ) .
a direct evidence for the spontaneously broken chiral symmetry is a nonzero value of the quark condensates for the light flavors @xmath10 which represent the order parameter . that this is indeed so , we know from three sources : current algebra , qcd sum rules , and lattice gauge calculations .
there are two important generic consequences of the spontaneous breaking of chiral symmetry ( sbcs ) .
the first one is an appearance of the octet of pseudoscalar mesons of low mass , @xmath11 , which represent the associated approximate goldstone bosons ( in the large @xmath8 limit the flavor singlet state @xmath12 should be added ) .
the second one is that valence ( practically massless ) quarks acquire a dynamical mass , which have been called historically constituent quarks .
indeed , the nonzero value of the quark condensate itself implies at the formal level that there should be rather big dynamical mass , which could be in general a moment - dependent quantity .
thus the constituent quarks should be considered as quasiparticles whose dynamical mass comes from the nonperturbative gluon and quark - antiquark dressing .
the flavor - octet axial current conservation in the chiral limit tells that the constituent quarks and goldstone bosons should be coupled with the strength @xmath13 @xcite , which is a quark analog of the famous goldberger - treiman relation .
we can not say at the moment for sure what is the microscopical mechanism for sbcs in qcd .
any sufficiently strong scalar interaction between quarks will induce the sbcs ( e.g. the instanton - induced interaction contains the scalar part , or it can be generated by monopole condensation , etc . ) .
all these general aspects of sbcs are well illustrated by the nambu and jona - lasinio model @xcite , where the constituent mass is generated by the scalar part of some nonperturbative local gluonic interaction between current quarks while its pseudoscalar part gives rise to a relativistic deeply - bound pseudoscalar @xmath14 systems as goldstone bosons .
accordingly one arrives at the following interpretation of light and strange baryons in the low - energy regime .
the highly nonperturbative gluodynamics gives rise to correlated quark - antiquark structures in the baryon sea ( virtual mesons ) . at the same time the current valence quarks get dressed by the quark condensates and by the meson loops .
the strongly - correlated quark - antiquark pairs in the pseudoscalar channel manifest themselves by virtual pseudoscalar mesons , while the weakly - correlated pairs in other channels - by vector , etc mesons .
when one integrates over the meson fields in the baryon wave function one arrives at the simple qqq fock component with confined constituent quarks and with residual interaction between them mediated by the corresponding meson fields @xcite .
the complimentary description of the vector - meson fields as well as of the scalar ones as arising from the correlated goldstone bosons is also possible , which does not contradict , however , to their interpretation as weakly bound @xmath14 systems .
the coupling of the constituent quarks and the pseudoscalar goldstone bosons will ( in the @xmath15 symmetric approximation ) have the form @xmath16 within the nonlinear realization of chiral symmetry ( it would be @xmath17 within the linear @xmath18-model chiral symmetry representation ) .
a coupling of this form , in a nonrelativistic reduction for the constituent quark spinors , will to lowest order give rise the @xmath19 structure of the meson - quark vertex , where @xmath20 is meson momentum .
thus , the structure of the potential between quarks `` @xmath21 '' and `` @xmath22 '' in momentum representation is @xmath23 where @xmath24 is dressed green function for chiral field which includes both nonlinear terms of chiral lagrangian and fermion loops , @xmath25 is meson - quark formfactor which takes into account the internal structure of quasiparticles . at big distances ( @xmath26 ) , one has @xmath27 and @xmath28 .
it then follows from ( [ 2 ] ) that @xmath29 , which means that the volume integral of the goldstone boson exchange ( gbe ) interaction should vanish , @xmath30 this sum rule is not valid in the chiral limit , however , where @xmath31 and , hence , @xmath32 .
the sum rule ( [ 1 ] ) is trivial for the tensor component of the pseudoscalar - exchange interaction since the tensor force component automatically vanishes on averaging over the directions of @xmath33 .
but for the spin - spin component the sum rule ( [ 1 ] ) indicates that there must be a strong short - range term .
indeed , at big interquark separations the spin - spin component of the pseudoscalar - exchange interaction is @xmath34 , it then follows from the sum rule above that at short interquark separations the spin - spin interaction should be opposite in sign as compared to the yukawa tail and very strong : @xmath35 _ it is this short - range part of the goldstone boson exchange ( gbe ) interaction between the constituent quarks that is of crucial importance for baryons : it has a sign appropriate to reproduce the level splittings and dominates over the yukawa tail towards short distances .
_ in a oversimplified consideration with a free klein - gordon green function instead of the dressed one in ( [ 2 ] ) and with @xmath36 , one obtains the following spin - spin component of @xmath37 interaction : @xmath38 in the chiral limit only the negative short - range part of the gbe interaction survives .
as a representation of a multiple correlated goldstone - boson - exchange one can include the exchange by a scalar flavor - singlet `` @xmath18''-meson as well as by vector mesons .
the `` @xmath18''-meson exchange does not play a principal role in baryons since it does not contain the spin - spin and tensor - force component .
its attractive central potential as well as a weak spin - orbit force can be effectively included into confining interaction in baryons . however , these forces are of significant importance in nn system at medium range .
the coupling of constituent quarks with the octet vector meson field @xmath39 in the @xmath40 - symmetric approximation is @xmath41 where @xmath42 and @xmath43 are the vector- and tensor coupling constants . a coupling of this form - to lowest order - will give rise the spin - spin , tensor , spin - orbit , and central interactions between the constituent quarks .
it is very instructive to compare signs of the spin - spin and tensor components of pseudoscalar- and vector - exchange interactions .
the spin - spin and tensor components of the pseudoscalar - exchange interaction arise from the @xmath44 structure of the pseudoscalar - meson constituent quark vertex as : @xmath45 . \label{3.2}\ ] ] the coupling of the vector - meson to constituent quark gives @xmath46 structure of the vertex .
therefore the spin - spin and tensor components of the vector - meson exchange interaction arise as @xmath47 . \label{3.3}\ ] ] comparing ( [ 3.2 ] ) with ( [ 3.3 ] ) one observes that the spin - spin component of the vector - exchange has the same sign as the spin - spin component of the pseudoscalar - exchange interaction and is `` two times stronger '' while their tensor components have opposite signs . the @xmath46 structure of the vector - meson constituent quark vertex also suggests that the spin - spin component of the vector - meson - exchange interaction should satisfy the same sum rule ( [ 1 ] ) as the pseudoscalar - exchange interaction .
then similar to pseudoscalar - exchange interaction there should be a short - range term in the vector - meson exchange interaction of the form ( [ 1.1 ] ) .
again , if one neglects the spatial structure of the meson - quark vertex and uses a free green function for the vector - meson field , this short range term is described by a @xmath48 - function piece similar to equation ( [ 3 ] ) .
summarizing , both vector- and pseudoscalar - exchange interactions produce the short - range spin - flavor force ( [ 1.1 ] ) while their tensor forces largely cancel each other in baryons .
this observation is crucial for the present model .
+ the spin - orbit component associated with the vector - meson exchange interaction is big and empirically very important in nn system .
so the question is why this spin - orbit force is big in nn system and becomes inessential in baryons , where the spin - orbit splittings are generally very small ( see e.g. at @xmath49 , @xmath50 , ... ls multiplets ) .
the reason for this remarkable phenomenon is an explicit flavor dependence of the vector - meson - exchange ls force .
consider for simplicity the @xmath51 case , i.e. an exchange by @xmath2- and @xmath3-mesons between u and d quarks .
the @xmath2-meson is isovector and the @xmath2-meson exchange potential contains the factor @xmath52 .
the @xmath3-meson is isoscalar and the @xmath3-exchange interaction does not contain the isospin - dependent factor . in @xmath53
nn partial wave the isospin of the two - nucleon system is @xmath54 and the isospin matrix element for the @xmath2-meson exchange potential is @xmath55 . thus both @xmath3- and @xmath2-meson exchange spin - orbit forces contribute with the same sign in nn system . numerically the contribution from @xmath3-exchange is 2.5 - 3 times bigger than from the @xmath2-meson exchange spin - orbit force .
now let us consider @xmath53 state of two light quarks in baryon .
in the present case the isospin of the quark pair is @xmath56 , due to the presence of the color part of wave function .
then for the @xmath2-meson exchange one obtains @xmath57 .
thus the @xmath2-meson exchange spin - orbit force obtains opposite sign and becomes strongly enhanced in baryons . as a result one observes a strong cancellation of the @xmath2- and @xmath3-meson exchange spin - orbit forces in baryons and the net weak spin - orbit interaction does not induce appreciable splittings in baryons .
numerical details about both the tensor- and spin - orbit force cancellation in baryons can be found in ref .
summarizing previous sections one concludes that the pseudoscalar- and vector - meson exchange interactions produce strong flavor - spin interaction ( [ 1.1 ] ) at short range while the net tensor and spin - orbit forces are rather weak .
that the net spin - orbit and tensor interactions between constituent quarks _ in baryons _ should be weak also follows from the typically small splittings in ls - multiplets , which are of the order 10 - 30 mev .
these small splittings should be compared with the hyperfine splittings produced by spin - spin force , which are of the order of @xmath58 splitting .
thus , indeed , in baryons it is the spin - spin interaction ( [ 1.1 ] ) between constituent quarks is of crucial importance .
consider first , for the purposes of illustration , a schematic model which neglects the radial dependence of the potential function @xmath59 in ( [ 1.1 ] ) , and assume a harmonic confinement among quarks as well as @xmath60 . in this model
@xmath61 note , that contrary to the color - magnetic interaction from perturbative one - gluon exchange , the chiral interaction is explicitly flavor - dependent .
it is this circumstance which allows to solve the long - standing problem of ordering of the lowest positive - negative parity states .
if the only interaction between the quarks were the flavor- and spin - independent harmonic confining interaction , the baryon spectrum would be organized in multiplets of the symmetry group @xmath62 . in this case
the baryon masses would be determined solely by the orbital structure , and the spectrum would be organized in an _ alternative sequence of positive and negative parity states , _ i.e. in this case the spectrum would be : ground state of positive parity ( @xmath63 shell , @xmath64 is the number of harmonic oscillator excitations in a 3-quark state ) , first excited band of negative parity ( @xmath65 ) , second excited band of positive parity ( @xmath66 ) , etc . the hamiltonian ( [ 4 ] ) , within a first order perturbation theory , reduces the @xmath62 symmetry down to @xmath67 , which automatically implies a splitting between the octet and decuplet baryons ( e.g. the @xmath68 resonance becomes heavier than nucleon ) .
let us now see how the pure confinement spectrum above becomes modified when the gbe hamiltonian ( [ 4 ] ) is switched on . for the octet states
@xmath69 , @xmath70 , @xmath71 , @xmath72 ( @xmath63 shell ) as well as for their first radial excitations of positive parity @xmath73 , @xmath74 , @xmath75 , @xmath76 ( @xmath66 shell ) the expectation value of the hamiltonian ( [ 4 ] ) is @xmath77 .
for the decuplet states @xmath68 , @xmath78 , @xmath79 , @xmath80 ( @xmath63 shell ) the corresponding matrix element is @xmath81 . in the negative parity excitations ( @xmath65 shell ) in the @xmath69 , @xmath70 and @xmath71 spectra ( @xmath82 - @xmath83 , @xmath84 - @xmath85 and @xmath86 - @xmath87 ) the contribution of the interaction ( [ 4 ] ) is @xmath88 . the first negative parity excitation in the @xmath70 spectrum ( @xmath65 shell ) @xmath89 - @xmath90 is flavor singlet and , in this case , the corresponding matrix element is @xmath91 .
the latter state is unique and is absent in other spectra due to its flavor - singlet nature .
these matrix elements alone suffice to prove that the ordering of the lowest positive and negative parity states in the baryon spectrum will be correctly predicted by the chiral boson exchange interaction ( [ 4 ] ) .
the constant @xmath92 may be determined from the n@xmath93 splitting to be 29.3 mev .
the oscillator parameter @xmath94 , which characterizes the effective confining interaction , may be determined as one half of the mass differences between the first excited @xmath95 states and the ground states of the baryons , which have the same flavor - spin , flavor and spin symmetries ( e.g. @xmath73 - @xmath69 , @xmath74 - @xmath70 , @xmath75 - @xmath71 ) , to be @xmath96 mev .
thus the two free parameters of this simple model are fixed and we can make now predictions . in the @xmath69 , @xmath70 and @xmath71 sectors the mass difference between the lowest excited @xmath97 states ( @xmath73 , @xmath74 , and @xmath75 ) and @xmath98 negative parity pairs ( @xmath82 - @xmath83 , @xmath84 - @xmath85 , and @xmath86 - @xmath87 , respectively ) will then be @xmath99 whereas for the lowest states in the @xmath70 system ( @xmath74 , @xmath89 - @xmath90 ) it should be @xmath100 this simple example shows how the chiral interaction provides different ordering of the lowest positive and negative parity excited states in the spectra of the nucleon and the @xmath70-hyperon .
this is a direct consequence of the symmetry properties of the boson - exchange interaction @xcite .
namely , completely symmetric fs state in the @xmath73 , @xmath74 and @xmath75 positive parity resonances from the @xmath66 band feels a much stronger attractive interaction than the mixed symmetry state in the @xmath82 - @xmath83 , @xmath84 - @xmath85 and @xmath86 -@xmath87 resonances of negative parity ( @xmath65 shell ) .
consequently the masses of the positive parity states @xmath73 , @xmath74 and @xmath75 are shifted down relative to the other ones , which explains the reversal of the otherwise expected `` normal ordering '' .
the situation is different for @xmath89 - @xmath90 and @xmath74 , as the flavor state of @xmath89 - @xmath90 is totally antisymmetric . because of
this the @xmath89 - @xmath90 gains an attractive energy , which is comparable to that of the @xmath74 , and thus the ordering suggested by the confining oscillator interaction is maintained .
note that the problem of the relative position of positive - negative parity states can not be solved with other types of hyperfine interactions between constituent quarks ( the colour - magnetic and instanton - induced ones ) .
in the semirelativistic chiral constituent quark model @xcite the dynamical part of the hamiltonian consists of linear pairwise confining interaction with the string tension fixed to the known value 1 gev / fm from regge slopes ( which also follows from the heavy quarkonium spectroscopy and lattice calculations ) , and the chiral interaction , mediated by pseudoscalar , scalar and vector - meson exchanges . both the flavor - octet and flavor - singlet pseudoscalar- and
vector - meson exchanges are taken into account .
the coupling constants of constituent quarks with mesons are fixed from the empirically known @xmath101 , @xmath102 , and @xmath103 coupling constants .
the `` sigma - meson '' constituent quark coupling constant is taken to be equal the pion
constituent quark coupling constant , as constrained by chiral symmetry . for the constituent quark
masses one takes typical values @xmath104 mev , @xmath105 mev and do not fit them .
the short - range behaviour of the interaction is determined by the cut - off parameters @xmath70 in the constituent quark meson form - factors , which are taken in monopole form . in order to avoid a proliferation of free parameters , by assuming independent values of @xmath70 for each meson , we adopt the linear scaling prescription @xmath106 , where @xmath107 is meson mass , for pseudoscalar- and vector mesons . the kinetic - energy operator is taken in relativistic form , @xmath108 .
the semirelativistic three - quark hamiltonian was solved along the stochastical variational method @xcite in momentum space . for the whole q - q potential the model involves a total of 4 free parameters whose numerical values
are determined from the fit to all 35 confirmed low - lying states . in fig .
1 we present the ground states as well as low - lying excited states in @xmath64 , @xmath68 , @xmath70 , @xmath71 , @xmath72 , and @xmath80 spectra . from the results of fig .
1 it becomes evident that within the chiral constituent quark model a unified description of both nonstrange and strange baryon spectra is achieved in good agreement with phenomenology .
it is instructive to learn how the spin - spin interaction ( [ 1.1 ] ) affects the energy levels when it is switched on and its strength is gradually increased ( fig .
2 ) . starting out from the case with confinement only , one observes that the degeneracy of states is removed and the inversion of ordering of positive and negative parity states is achieved in the @xmath64 spectrum , as well as for some states in the @xmath70 spectrum , while the ordering of the lowest positive - negative parity states is opposite in @xmath64 and @xmath70 spectra .
it is clear that the fock components @xmath109 ( including meson continuum ) can not be completely integrated out in favour of the meson - exchange @xmath37 potentials for some states above or near the corresponding meson thresholds .
such components in addition to the main one @xmath110 could explain e.g. an exceptionally big splitting of the flavor singlet states @xmath111 , since the @xmath89 lies below the @xmath112 threshold and can be presented as @xmath112 bound system @xcite .
note , that in the case of the present approach this old idea is completely natural and does not contradict a flavor - singlet @xmath110 nature of @xmath89 , while it would be in conflict with naive constituent quark model where no room for mesons in baryons .
an admixture of such components will be important in order to understand strong decays of some excited states .
while technically inclusion of such components in addition to the main one @xmath110 in a coupled - channel approach is rather difficult task , it should be considered as one of the most important future directions .
what is an intuitive picture of the nucleon in the low - energy regime ?
the goldstone bosons as well as vector meson fields couple to valence quarks .
thus the nucleon consists mostly of 3 constituent quarks which are very big objects due to their meson clouds ( see fig .
3 ) . these constituent quarks are all the time in strong overlap inside the nucleon .
that is why the short - range part of chiral interaction ( which is represented by the contact term in the oversimplified representation ) is so crucially important inside baryons .
when constituent quarks are well separated and there is a phase space for meson propagation , the long - range yukawa tails of meson - exchange interactions become very important .
it is these parts of meson exchange which produce the necessary long- and intermediate - range attraction in two - nucleon system .
if one ascribes a short - range central repulsion in the nn system to the central part of @xmath3 exchange between nucleons , then one should increase the @xmath103 coupling constant by factor 3 as compared to its empirical value , as it is usually done in phenomenological one - boson - exchange nn potentials .
evidently the short - range repulsion in the nn system should be connected with the nucleon structure in the low - energy regime and within the quark picture should be related to fermi - nature of constituent quarks and to the specific interactions between them .
so far , all studies of the short - range @xmath4 interaction within the constituent quark model were based on the one - gluon exchange interaction between quarks .
they explained the short - range repulsion in the @xmath4 system as due to the colour - magnetic part of oge combined with quark interchanges between 3q clusters @xcite .
it has been shown , however , that there is practically no room for colour - magnetic interaction in light baryon spectroscopy and any appreciable amount of colour - magnetic interaction , in addition to chiral interaction , destroys the spectrum @xcite .
this conclusion is confirmed by recent lattice qcd calculations @xcite .
if so , the question arises which interquark interaction is responsible for the short - range @xmath4 repulsion .
below i show that the same short - range part of chiral interaction ( [ 1.1 ] ) which causes e.g. @xmath113 splitting and produces good baryon spectra , also induces a short - range repulsion in @xmath4 system when the latter is treated as 6q system @xcite . at present
one can use only a simple nonrelativistic @xmath114 ansatz for the nucleon wave function when one applies the quark model to @xmath4 interaction .
thus one needs first an effective nonrelativistic parametrization of chiral interaction interaction which would provide correct nucleon mass , @xmath113 splitting and the nucleon stability with this ansatz . for that one can use the nonrelativistic parametrization @xcite which satisfies approximately the conditions above . where @xmath116 is a collective ( generator )
coordinate which is the separation distance between the two wells ( it should not be mixed with the relative motion jacobi coordinate ) , @xmath117 is the lowest expectation value of the 6q hamiltonian at fixed @xmath116 , and @xmath118 is a mass of two well - separated nucleons ( @xmath119 ) calculated with the same hamiltonian . at the moment we are interested in what is the @xmath4 interaction at zero separation between nucleons .
it has been proved by harvey that when @xmath120 , then in both @xmath121 and @xmath122 partial waves in the @xmath4 system only two types of orbital 6q configurations survive @xcite : @xmath123_o>$ ] and @xmath124_o>$ ] , where @xmath125_o$ ] is young diagram , describing spatial permutational symmetry in 6q system .
there are a few different flavor - spin symmetries , compatible with the spatial symmetries above : @xmath126_o[33]_{fs}$ ] , @xmath127_o[33]_{fs}$ ] , @xmath127_o[51]_{fs}$ ] , @xmath127_o[411]_{fs}$ ] , @xmath127_o[321]_{fs}$ ] , and @xmath127_o[2211]_{fs}$ ] .
thus , in order to evaluate the @xmath4 interaction at zero separation between nucleons it is necessary to diagonalize a @xmath5 hamiltonian in the basis above and use the procedure ( [ 6 ] ) . from the adiabatic born - oppenheimer approximation ( [ 6 ] ) we find that @xmath128 is highly repulsive in both @xmath121 and @xmath122 partial waves , with the core being of order 1 gev .
this repulsion implies a strong suppression of the @xmath4 wave function in the nucleon overlap region . due to the specific flavor - spin symmetry of chiral interaction between
quarks the configuration @xmath129_o[51]_{fs}$ ] becomes highly dominant among other possible 6q configurations at zero separation between nucleons ( however , the `` energy '' of this configuration is much higher than the energy of two well - separated nucleons , that is why there is a strong short - range repulsion in @xmath4 system ) .
the symmetry structure of this dominant configuration induces `` an additional '' effective repulsion , related to the `` pauli forbidden state '' in this case , and the s - wave @xmath4 relative motion wave function has a node at short range@xcite .
the existence of a strong repulsion , related to the energy ballance , discussed above , suggests , however , that the amplitude of the oscillating @xmath4 wave function at short range will be strongly suppressed .
thus , within the chiral constituent quark model one has all the necessary ingredients to understand microscopically the @xmath4 interaction .
there appears strong short - range repulsion from the same short - range part of chiral interaction which also produces hyperfine splittings in baryon spectroscopy .
the long- and intermediate - range attraction in the @xmath4 system is automatically implied by the yukawa part of pion - exchange and correlated two - pion exchanges ( @xmath18-exchange ) between quarks belonging to different nucleons .
the necessary tensor and spin - orbit force comes from the pseudoscalar- and vector - exchange yukawa tails .
what will be a short - range interaction in other @xmath130 and @xmath131 systems ? in the chiral limit there is no difference between all octet baryons : @xmath132 .
thus if one explains a strong short - range repulsion in @xmath4 system as related mostly to the spontaneous breaking of chiral symmetry , as above , then the same short - range repulsion should persist in other @xmath130 and @xmath131 systems @xcite .
of course , due to the explicit chiral symmetry breaking the strength of this repulsion should be essentially different as compared to that one in @xmath4 system .
one can naively expect that it will be weaker .
it is my pleasure to thank d.o.riska , z.papp , w.plessas , k.varga , r. wagenbrunn , fl .
stancu , and s. pepin , in collaboration with whom different results discussed in this talk have been obtained .
i also thank organizers of the school for the invitation to give this lecture .
a. manohar and h. georgi , nucl
b234 * ( 1984 ) 189 ; d. i. diakonov and v. yu .
petrov , nucl . phys .
* b272 * ( 1986 ) 457 .
y. nambu and g. jona - lasinio , phys .
* 122 * ( 1961 ) 345 ; u. vogl and w. weise , progr .
* 27 * ( 1991 ) 195 ; s. p. klevansky , rev . mod .
* 64 * ( 1992 ) 649 ; t. hatsuda and t. kunihiro , phys . rep .
* 247 * ( 1994 ) 221 .
glozman and d. o. riska , physics reports * 268 * ( 1996 ) 263 .
glozman , w. plessas , k. varga , r. wagenbrunn , in preparation .
glozman , w. plessas , k. varga , r. wagenbrunn , hep - ph/9706507 . k. varga and y. suzuki , phys . rev . * c52 * ( 1995 ) 2885 ; k. varga , y. ohbayasi , and y. suzuki , phys . lett .
* b396 * ( 1997 ) 1 .
r. h. dalitz and a. deloff , j. phys . * g 17 * ( 1991 ) 289 ( and references therein ) .
m. oka and k. yazaki , int .
, vol . 1 ( quarks and nuclei , ed
. w. weise ) , world scientific , singapore , p. 490
glozman , z. papp , w. plessas , k. varga , and r. wagenbrunn , phys .
* c57 * ( 1998 ) [ nucl - th/9705011 ] .
k. f. liu and s. j. dong - paper in preparation ( for a preliminary result see hep - lat/9411067 ) .
glozman , z. papp , and w. plessas , phys .
* b381 * ( 1996 ) 311 .
stancu , s. pepin , and l. ya .
glozman , phys . rev .
* c56 * ( 1997 ) 2779 . m. harvey , nucl . phys .
* a352 * ( 1981 ) 301 .
v. g. neudatchin , yu . f. smirnov , and r. tamagaki , progr .
. phys . * 58 * ( 1977 ) 1072 .
stancu , s. pepin , and l. ya .
glozman , phys . rev .
* d57 * ( 1998 ) 4393 . | in the low - energy regime light and strange baryons should be considered as systems of constituent quarks with confining interaction and a chiral interaction that is mediated by goldstone bosons as well as by vector and scalar mesons .
the flavor - spin structure and sign of the short - range part of the spin - spin force reduces the @xmath0 symmetry down to @xmath1 , induces hyperfine splittings and provides correct ordering of the lowest states with positive and negative parity .
there is a cancellation of the tensor force from pseudoscalar- and vector - exchanges in baryons .
the spin - orbit interactions from @xmath2-like and @xmath3-like exchanges also cancel each other in baryons while they produce a big spin - orbit force in nn system .
a unified description of light and strange baryon spectra calculated in a semirelativistic framework is presented .
it is demonstrated that the same short - range part of spin - spin interaction between the constituent quarks induces a strong short - range repulsion in @xmath4 system when the latter is treated as @xmath5 system .
thus one can achieve a simultaneous understanding of a baryon structure and baryon - baryon interaction in the low - energy regime .
-1 cm -0.5 cm -1 cm 23 cm * baryons in a chiral constituent quark model * l. ya .
glozman _ institute for theoretical physics , university of graz , austria _ |
the baker - campbell - hausdorff formula is the expansion of @xmath3 in terms of nested commutators for the non - commuting variables @xmath1 and @xmath2 , where the commutator of @xmath4 and @xmath5 is defined as @xmath6 : = ab - ba$ ] .
the explicit combinatorial form of it was given by dynkin in his 1947 paper @xcite . by considering the linear extension of the map @xmath7 defined by @xmath8 , @xmath9 , @xmath10 ,
@xmath11 $ ] and @xmath12 $ ] he proved that @xmath13 this series is related to lie s third theorem and the history around it is too rich to be retold here ,
so we refer the reader to the recent monograph @xcite and references therein for a historical account .
the baker - campbell - hausdorff formula , as well as many other results in lie theory , firmly belongs to associative algebra .
however , after the work of mikheev and sabinin on local analytic loops @xcite and the description of the primitive operations in non - associative algebras by shestakov and umirbaev @xcite , associativity does not seem to be as essential for the lie theory as previously thought @xcite . in this paper
we address the problem of determining @xmath14 in @xmath15 where @xmath16 in terms of shestakov - umirbaev operations for the primitive elements of the non - associative algebra freely generated by @xmath1 and @xmath2 .
our approach uses a generalization of the magnus expansion ( see @xcite for a readable survey ) , that is , we will study the differential equation @xmath17 where @xmath18 stands for @xmath19 and both @xmath20 and @xmath21 belong to a non - associative algebra .
the differential equation @xmath22 satisfied by @xmath21 ( corollary [ cor : magnus ] ) is obtained with the help of a non - associative version of the dynkin - specht - wever lemma ( lemma [ lem : dsw ] ) .
this equation leads to a recursive formula for computing the expansion of @xmath14 , which gives , in degrees smaller than 5 , the following expression : @xmath23\\ & \quad + \frac{1}{12}[x,[x , y ] ] - \frac{1}{3}\langle x;x , y\rangle -\frac{1}{12 } [ y,[x , y ] ] - \frac{1}{6 } \langle y ; x , y \rangle -\frac{1}{2}\phi(x;y , y ) \\ & \quad -\frac{1}{24}\langle x ; x , [ x , y]\rangle - \frac{1}{12 } [ x,\langle x;x , y\rangle ] - \frac{1}{8}\langle x , x;x , y\rangle \\ & \quad + \frac{1}{24}[[x,[x , y]],y ] - \frac{1}{24}[x,\langle y;x , y\rangle ] -\frac{1}{4}\phi(x , x;y , y ) - \frac{1}{4}[x,\phi(x;y , y ) ] \\ & \quad -\frac{1}{24}[\langle x;x , y\rangle , y ] -\frac{1}{24}\langle x ; [ x , y],y\rangle - \frac{1}{6}\langle x , y;x , y\rangle + \frac{1}{24}\langle y , x;x , y\rangle \\ & \quad + \frac{1}{12 } [ \phi(x;y , y),y ] + \frac{1}{24}\langle y ; y,[x , y]\rangle - \frac{1}{24 } \langle y , y;x , y\rangle - \frac{1}{6}\phi(x;y , y , y ) \\ &
\quad + \dots\end{aligned}\ ] ] when all the operations apart from @xmath24 $ ] vanish we recover the usual baker - campbell - hausdorff formula . a different approach to the non - associative baker - campbell - hausdorff formula has appeared in @xcite ; it does not explicitly use the dynkin - specht - wever lemma or the magnus expansion . for the treatment of the subject from the point of view of differential geometry
see @xcite ; actually , geometric considerations also motivate a different type of a baker - campbell - hausdorff formula , see @xcite ; although it is of importance for the non - associative lie theory , we shall not consider it here .
our results are presented for the unital @xmath25-algebra of formal power series @xmath26 in two non - associative variables @xmath1 and @xmath2 .
readers with background in non - associative structures will realize that a more natural context for the baker - campbell - hausdorff formula is the completion of the universal enveloping algebra of a relatively free sabinin algebra on two generators .
the extension of our results to that context is rather straightforward .
readers familiar with free lie algebras might wonder about the existence , behind of the scenes , of certain non - associative lie idempotents responsible for some of our formulas .
the answer is affirmative ; however , this topic is not discussed in the present paper since it requires some knowledge of sabinin algebras and treating it would significantly increase the length of text . very briefly , the context for the non - associative lie idempotents is as follows .
one can start with a variety @xmath27 of loops containing all the abelian groups and define a relatively free sabinin algebra @xmath28 associated to the variety @xmath27 and freely generated by @xmath29 .
let @xmath30 be the universal enveloping algebra of @xmath28 .
this algebra is a non - associative graded hopf algebra @xmath31 once we set @xmath32 .
the convolution @xmath33 defines a non - associative product on the space of @xmath25-linear maps @xmath34 .
the subalgebra generated by the projections @xmath35 of @xmath30 onto @xmath36 ( where @xmath37 ) with respect to this convolution product , which in the associative setting is anti - isomorphic to solomon s descent algebra , is isomorphic as a graded hopf algebra to @xmath30 .
therefore , @xmath30 is a non - associative hopf algebra with an extra associative ( inner ) product inherited from the composition in @xmath34 . in the associative case
, this is the subject of study in the theory of non - commutative symmetric functions , so a similar theory seems possible in the non - associative setting .
eulerian , dynkin and klyachko idempotents , among others , are easily understood in @xmath30 as particular examples of primitive elements with respect to the comultiplication that , in addition , are idempotent with respect to the associative inner product , and they ultimately explain some of the formulas in this paper . throughout this paper
the characteristic of the base field @xmath25 is zero .
the unital associative @xmath25-algebra freely generated by a set of generators @xmath38 will be denoted by @xmath39 while @xmath40 will stand for the unital associative algebra of formal power series on @xmath38 with coefficients in @xmath25 .
their non - associative counterparts , namely , the unital non - associative @xmath25-algebra freely generated by @xmath38 and the unital non - associative @xmath25-algebra of formal power series on @xmath38 with coefficients in @xmath25 , will be denoted by @xmath41 and @xmath42 respectively . for any algebra @xmath43 , @xmath44 $ ] will denote the algebra of formal power series in @xmath45 with coefficients in @xmath43 .
the parameter @xmath45 commutes and associates with all the elements in @xmath44 $ ] .
finally , we will stick to the following order of parentheses for powers : @xmath46 ( @xmath47 times ) .
a coalgebra @xmath48 is a vector space equipped with two linear maps @xmath49 ( _ comultiplicaton _ ) and @xmath50 ( _ counit _ ) such that @xmath51 where @xmath52 stands for @xmath53 ( _ sweedler notation _ ) .
coassociative and cocommutative coalgebras are those coalgebras @xmath48 that , in addition , satisfy @xmath54 ( _ coassociativity _ ) and @xmath55 ( _ cocommutativity _ ) where @xmath56 .
coassociativity ensures that @xmath57 so we can safely write @xmath58 for any of the sides of this equality . for coassociative coalgebras the result of the iterated application @xmath47 times of @xmath59 to @xmath1 does not depend on the selected factors
and it is denoted by @xmath60 .
cocommutativity ensures that we can freely permute the factors of @xmath60 without altering the value of this expression @xcite . in this paper , by a _
( non - associative ) hopf algebra _
@xmath61 we shall mean a cocommutative and coassociative coalgebra @xmath62 endowed with the following linear maps : a _ product _
@xmath63 , a _ unit _
@xmath64 , a _ left division _ @xmath65 and a _ right division _
@xmath66 so that @xmath67 , @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath70 and @xmath71 where @xmath72 and @xmath73 is the unit element ( see @xcite for a survey on non - associative hopf algebras ) . in case that @xmath43 is associative then the left and right divisions can be written as @xmath74 and @xmath75 where @xmath76 is the antipode .
however , non - associative hopf algebras lack antipodes in general .
the most important example of a non - associative hopf algebra in this paper is the unital non - associative algebra @xmath77 freely generated by @xmath78 .
the maps @xmath79 and @xmath80 ( @xmath81 ) induce homomorphisms of unital algebras @xmath82 and @xmath83 so that @xmath84 is a coassociative and cocommutative coalgebra . by induction on the degree of @xmath1 , the formulas ( [ eq : left_division ] ) and ( [ eq : right_division ] ) uniquely determine the left and the right division in @xmath77
. for instance , @xmath85 implies @xmath86 and @xmath87 etc .
the operations @xmath59 , @xmath88 , @xmath89 and @xmath90 , together with the product and the unit , provide @xmath77 with the structure of a non - associative hopf algebra . far from being a fancy feature ,
the divisions are a valuable tool for computations .
an element @xmath4 in a hopf algebra @xmath43 such that @xmath91 is called _ primitive _ ; the subspace of all such elements is denoted by @xmath92 . while for associative hopf algebras this subspace is a lie algebra with the commutator product @xmath93:= xy - yx$ ] , shestakov and umirbaev @xcite realized that if @xmath43 is non - associative , many more operations are required to describe its algebraic structure completely .
let @xmath94 , @xmath95 and @xmath96 be disjoint sets of symbols that we take to be the free generators of @xmath97 .
write @xmath98 , @xmath99 and define @xmath100 in @xmath97 , where @xmath101 denotes the associator @xmath102 of @xmath103 and @xmath104 .
each of the elements @xmath105 is primitive . considered as non - associative polynomials , @xmath106 can be evaluated in any algebra @xmath107 so we can think of them as of new multilinear operations derived from the binary product of @xmath107 .
define @xmath108 & : = xy - yx \\
\langle x_1,\dots , x_m ; y , z \rangle & : = -p(x_1,\dots , x_m;y;z ) + p(x_1,\dots , x_m ; z;y)\\ \phi(x_1,\dots , x_m ; y_1,\dots , y_n ; y_{n+1 } ) & : = \\ & \hskip -2.5 cm \frac{1}{m!(n+1 ) ! } \sum_{\sigma
\in s_n , \tau \in s_{m+1 } } p(x_{\sigma(1)},\dots , x_{\sigma(m ) } ; y_{\tau(1)},\dots , y_{\tau(n ) } ; y_{\tau(n+1)})\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath109 and @xmath110 stands for the symmetric group on @xmath111 .
in order to simplify the notation , for @xmath112 we write @xmath113.\ ] ] with this convention , ( [ eq : p ] ) gives @xmath114 shestakov and umirbaev proved that @xmath115 thus , while ( [ eq : dynkin_formula ] ) can be written in terms of commutators , the natural language to write its non - associative counterpart uses @xmath116 and @xmath117 . the algebra @xmath118 ( respectively , @xmath119 ) of formal power series in @xmath1 with coefficients in @xmath25 is a topological hopf algebra with the continuous extension of the operations of the hopf algebra @xmath120 ( respectively , @xmath121 ) . since @xmath122 ,
the _ group - like _ elements of @xmath119 , that is , the elements @xmath123 such that @xmath124 and @xmath125 , are of the form @xmath126 with @xmath127 .
therefore , @xmath128 is , in a sense , canonical among all of them .
however , @xmath129 is infinite - dimensional and @xmath130 has an infinite number of group - like elements that could rightfully be considered as the non - associative analogs of the exponential series .
apart from the most obvious non - associative versions of the exponential @xmath131 other series have been proposed as non - associative analogs of @xmath132 , each leading to a different logarithm @xcite .
a group - like element @xmath133 is a _
base for logarithms _ if its homogeneous component @xmath134 of degree one in @xmath1 is not zero .
we say that the base for logarithms @xmath135 is _ normalized _ if @xmath136 .
associated with any base for logarithms @xmath135 there exists a primitive element @xmath137 determined by @xmath138 the _ exponentiation _ on @xmath42 _ with base _ @xmath135 and the _ logarithm on @xmath139 to the base @xmath135 _ are the maps @xmath140 where @xmath141 denotes the space of formal power series with zero constant term . both maps are inverse to each other and give a bijection between the primitive and the group - like elements in @xmath139 .
the logarithms to the bases @xmath142 and @xmath143 will be denoted by @xmath144 and @xmath145 , respectively .
any base for logarithms @xmath135 determines a baker - campbell - hausdorff series in @xmath26 : @xmath146 the element @xmath147 is primitive so it can be written in terms of the shestakov - umirbaev operations @xmath116 and @xmath148 .
since these operations are defined via the left - normed products @xmath149 and @xmath150 , the base @xmath142 is better adapted to recursive computations . in @xcite @xmath151 has been described as follows .
for @xmath152 set @xmath153 .
if @xmath154 is a non - associative monomial in @xmath1 , there is only one way of writing @xmath155 as a product @xmath156 .
set @xmath157 and @xmath158 where @xmath159 is the @xmath160th bernoulli number . with this notation
we have @xmath161 the baker - campbell - hausdorff series for different bases are related in a straightforward manner .
if @xmath162 and @xmath163 are two bases for logarithms , the series @xmath164 is a primitive element of @xmath130 whose term of degree 1 is non - zero . in particular , it has a composition inverse @xmath165 such that @xmath166 .
it is then clear that @xmath167 moreover , for any baker - campbell - hausdorff series @xmath168 and any primitive @xmath169 with @xmath170 , the series @xmath171 is also a baker - campbell - hausdorff series for some base .
let @xmath172 be a derivation of @xmath77 that preserves @xmath173 , that is @xmath174 define @xmath175 ; thus , @xmath176 for all @xmath177 .
the proof of the following result was inspired by @xcite .
[ lem : dsw ] let @xmath172 be a derivation of @xmath77 that preserves @xmath173 , @xmath177 and @xmath178 .
we have @xmath179 let us compute @xmath180 in two ways : @xmath181 so that by ( [ eq : brackets ] ) @xmath182 using ( [ eq : left_division ] ) , divide by @xmath183 to get the result .
let us compute the expansion @xmath184 up to degree @xmath185 in terms of the shestakov - umirbaev operations with the help of the dynkin - specht - wever lemma . since , up to the summands of degree @xmath186 , we have @xmath187 the expansion of @xmath188 up to degree @xmath185 is @xmath189 + \frac{1}{3}x^2y - \frac{1}{4}x(xy)+\frac{1}{4 } x(yx ) -\frac{5}{12 } ( xy)x + \frac{1}{12}(yx)x\\ + \frac{1}{2 } xy^2 -\frac{5}{12}(xy)y + \frac{1}{12}(yx)y - \frac{1}{4}y(xy ) - \frac{1}{6}y^2x + \frac{1}{4}y(yx ) + \cdots\end{gathered}\ ] ] now , apply lemma [ lem : dsw ] with @xmath190 , where @xmath191 denotes the degree of @xmath192 , for homogeneous @xmath193 .
first , observe that @xmath194 , @xmath195 and @xmath196 applying @xmath197 to the homogeneous summands in ( [ eq : bch3 ] ) and dividing by their degree , we can write ( [ eq : bch3 ] ) as @xmath198 + \frac{1}{12}[x,[x , y ] ] - \frac{1}{3}\langle x;x , y\rangle -\frac{1}{12 } [ y,[x , y ] ] + \frac{1}{6 } \langle y ; y , x \rangle -\frac{1}{2}\phi(x;y , y ) + \cdots\ ] ] the differential equation @xmath199 when @xmath18 and @xmath20 do not necessarily commute ( for instance , @xmath18 may belong to a matrix lie group and @xmath20 to the corresponding lie algebra ) has been studied since long ago @xcite . a fruitful approach is to look for solutions of the form @xmath200 for some @xmath21 , where @xmath128 denotes the usual exponential .
the solution @xmath21 is determined by the initial condition and by the differential equation @xmath201 where @xmath202 denotes the @xmath47-th bernoulli number .
take @xmath203 ; then @xmath204 so we can use ( [ eq : magnus_recursion ] ) in order to study @xmath205
. however , in a non - associative setting there are some details to be taken care of , since , for instance , equality @xmath2061@xmath207 above requires the associativity .
let @xmath43 be a unital algebra , @xmath133 a base for logarithms and @xmath208 with @xmath209 $ ] such that @xmath210 .
for any @xmath211 $ ] the solution @xmath21 to the equation @xmath212 satisfies @xmath213 where @xmath214 is defined by @xmath215 evaluating at @xmath216 and @xmath217 we get @xmath218 if @xmath219 then @xmath220 for some @xmath221 and there exists @xmath222 such that @xmath223 .
therefore @xmath224 .
in order to compute @xmath225 in terms of the shestakov - umirbaev operations , we will use the dynkin - specht - wever lemma . consider the derivation @xmath226 of @xmath26 determined by @xmath227 by induction on the degree @xmath228 of @xmath192
we can check that @xmath229 so that @xmath230 preserves @xmath231 and it is related to @xmath232 via @xmath233 now , in order to apply the dynkin - specht - wever lemma recursively @xmath135 should be a linear combination of left - normed products of primitive elements .
this is the main reason for restricting ourselves to @xmath142 .
[ lem : tau ] the component @xmath234 of degree @xmath47 in @xmath1 of @xmath235 is @xmath236 where @xmath237 .
the expansion of @xmath238 can be easily obtained from the expansion of @xmath235 . given a tuple @xmath239 with @xmath240
define @xmath241 the concatenation @xmath242 of @xmath243 and @xmath244 will be denoted by @xmath245 .
[ thm : degoneexpansion ] in @xmath26 we have @xmath246 where @xmath247 runs over all possible tuples with entries @xmath248 and @xmath249 let @xmath226 be the derivation of @xmath26 determined by ( [ eq : derivation ydeltax ] ) .
the dynkin - specht - wever lemma implies @xmath250 so @xmath251 and @xmath252 since @xmath253 , the result follows .
[ cor : magnus ] let @xmath43 be a unital algebra and @xmath211 $ ] .
the solution @xmath209 $ ] of the equation @xmath212 with @xmath254 and @xmath210 satisfies @xmath255 where @xmath247 runs over all possible tuples with the components @xmath248 .
we will use the formula for @xmath256 in theorem [ thm : degoneexpansion ] to describe , in terms of the shestakov - umirbaev operations , the differential equation satisfied by @xmath257 . [
prop : bch ] let @xmath135 be a normalized base for logarithms .
in @xmath26 we have @xmath258 consider @xmath259 .
since @xmath260 evaluating at @xmath261 , we get @xmath262 so @xmath263 . in the case
when @xmath135 is @xmath142 or @xmath143 , proposition [ prop : bch ] was proved in @xcite .
the components of degree @xmath264 and @xmath185 of @xmath235 are @xmath265 , @xmath266 , @xmath267 and @xmath268 .
thus , the component of degree one in @xmath2 in @xmath184 is @xmath269 we can compute directly the coefficient of @xmath270 in @xmath184 , for instance . since @xmath271 then theorem [ thm : degoneexpansion ] ensures that this coefficient equals @xmath272 .
@xmath273 [ prop : bchrecurr ] let @xmath274 . in @xmath275
$ ] we have @xmath276 we have @xmath277
so @xmath278 .
the result follows from theorem [ thm : degoneexpansion ] .
the component of @xmath184 of degree @xmath279 in @xmath1 and degree @xmath280 in @xmath2 is @xmath281 + \frac{1}{6}\langle y;y , x\rangle - \frac{1}{2}\phi(x;y , y).\end{aligned}\ ] ] based on proposition [ prop : bchrecurr ] we can compute the initial terms of the expansion of @xmath184 . [
thm : bch ] the expansion of @xmath184 in @xmath26 is @xmath282\\ & \quad + \frac{1}{12}[x,[x , y ] ] - \frac{1}{3}\langle x;x , y\rangle -\frac{1}{12 } [ y,[x , y ] ] - \frac{1}{6 } \langle y ; x , y \rangle -\frac{1}{2}\phi(x;y , y ) \\ & \quad -\frac{1}{24}\langle x ; x , [ x , y]\rangle - \frac{1}{12 } [ x,\langle x;x , y\rangle ] - \frac{1}{8}\langle x , x;x , y\rangle \\ & \quad + \frac{1}{24}[[x,[x , y]],y ] - \frac{1}{24}[x,\langle y;x , y\rangle ] -\frac{1}{4}\phi(x , x;y , y ) - \frac{1}{4}[x,\phi(x;y , y ) ] \\ & \quad -\frac{1}{24}[\langle x;x , y\rangle , y ] -\frac{1}{24}\langle x ; [ x , y],y\rangle - \frac{1}{6}\langle x , y;x , y\rangle + \frac{1}{24}\langle y , x;x , y\rangle \\ & \quad + \frac{1}{12 } [ \phi(x;y , y),y ] + \frac{1}{24}\langle y ; y,[x , y]\rangle - \frac{1}{24 } \langle y , y;x , y\rangle - \frac{1}{6}\phi(x;y , y , y)\end{aligned}\ ] ] plus terms of degree @xmath186 .
formulas ( [ eq : magnus_recursion ] ) and ( [ eq : nonassociative_magnus_recursion ] ) give an alternative point of view on the relation between the numbers @xmath283 and @xmath284 which has been established in @xcite .
we have @xmath285 by definition , @xmath286 and @xmath287 vanish in any associative algebra , with the only exception of @xmath288 .
thus , after projecting from @xmath26 , in @xmath289 we get @xmath290 since it is well - known that @xmath291 holds in @xmath289 we get the result ; the sign @xmath292 in the latter formula comes from our choice @xmath293 instead of @xmath294 .
in @xcite woon gave an algorithm to compute @xmath295 with the help of the binary tree ( v1 ) at ( -1,3 ) @xmath296 $ ] ; ( v2 ) at ( -3,2 ) @xmath297 $ ] ; ( v3 ) at ( 1,2 ) @xmath298 $ ] ; at ( 5,3 ) level 1 ; at ( 5,2 ) level 2 ; ( v4 ) at ( -4,1 ) @xmath299 $ ] ; ( v5 ) at ( -2,1 ) @xmath300 $ ] ; ( v6 ) at ( 0,1 ) @xmath301 $ ] ; ( v7 ) at ( 2,1 ) @xmath302 $ ] ; ( v1 ) edge ( v2 ) ; ( v1 ) edge ( v3 ) ; ( v2 ) edge ( v4 ) ; ( v2 ) edge ( v5 ) ; ( v3 ) edge ( v6 ) ; ( v3 ) edge ( v7 ) ; at ( -1,1 ) @xmath303 ; at ( 5,1 ) @xmath303 ; here , the nodes are labeled by @xmath304 $ ] ; the root is @xmath296 $ ] and at any node we have ( v1 ) at ( 0,2 ) @xmath304 $ ] ; ( v2 ) at ( -2,1 ) @xmath305 $ ] ; ( v3 ) at ( 2,1 ) @xmath306 $ ] ; ( v1 ) edge ( v2 ) ; ( v1 ) edge ( v3 ) ; the factorial of the node @xmath307 $ ] is @xmath308 .
woon proved the equality @xmath309 for @xmath310 , where @xmath311 runs over the nodes in the level @xmath160 . in @xcite fuchs extended this construction as follows .
consider the _
general pi binary tree _ ( v1 ) at ( -1,3 ) @xmath312 ; ( v2 ) at ( -3,2 ) @xmath313 ; ( v3 ) at ( 1,2 ) @xmath314 ; at ( 5,3 ) level 1 ; at ( 5,2 ) level 2 ; at ( 5,1 ) @xmath303 ; ( v4 ) at ( -4,1 ) @xmath315 ; ( v5 ) at ( -2,1 ) @xmath316 ; ( v6 ) at ( 0,1 ) @xmath317 ; ( v7 ) at ( 2,1 ) @xmath318 ; ( v1 ) edge ( v2 ) ; ( v1 ) edge ( v3 ) ; ( v2 ) edge ( v4 ) ; ( v2 ) edge ( v5 ) ; ( v3 ) edge ( v6 ) ; ( v3 ) edge ( v7 ) ; at ( -1,1 ) @xmath303 ; with root @xmath312 and at each node @xmath319 for any sequence @xmath320 of complex numbers change the node @xmath321 by @xmath322 . then define @xmath323 to be the sum of the nodes in the @xmath160-th level .
this value depends on the sequence @xmath320 . in the case when @xmath324 we get the tree ( v1 ) at ( -1,3 ) @xmath325 ; ( v2 ) at ( -3,2 ) @xmath326 ; ( v3 ) at ( 1,2 ) @xmath327 ; ( v4 ) at ( -4,1 ) @xmath328 ; ( v5 ) at ( -2,1 ) @xmath329 ; ( v6 ) at ( 0,1 ) @xmath330 ; ( v7 ) at ( 2,1 ) @xmath331 ; ( v1 ) edge ( v2 ) ; ( v1 ) edge ( v3 ) ; ( v2 ) edge ( v4 ) ; ( v2 ) edge ( v5 ) ; ( v3 ) edge ( v6 ) ; ( v3 ) edge ( v7 ) ; at ( -1,1 ) @xmath303 ; and for each @xmath160 we have @xmath332 . to relate these constructions to the numbers @xmath333 in theorem [ thm : degoneexpansion ] we use a binary tree to collect the summands involved in @xmath334 .
consider associative but non - commutative indeterminates @xmath335 and the tree ( v1 ) at ( -1,3 ) @xmath336 ; ( v2 ) at ( -3,2 ) @xmath337 ; ( v3 ) at ( 1,2 ) @xmath338 ; ( v4 ) at ( -4,1 ) @xmath339 ; ( v5 ) at ( -2,1 ) @xmath340 ; ( v6 ) at ( 0,1 ) @xmath341 ; ( v7 ) at ( 2,1 ) @xmath342 ; ( v1 ) edge ( v2 ) ; ( v1 ) edge ( v3 ) ; ( v2 ) edge ( v4 ) ; ( v2 ) edge ( v5 ) ; ( v3 ) edge ( v6 ) ; ( v3 ) edge ( v7 ) ; at ( -1,1 ) @xmath303 ; at ( 5,3 ) level 1 ; at ( 5,2 ) level 2 ; at ( 5,1 ) @xmath303 ; where at any node on the level @xmath343 we have ( v1 ) at ( 0,2 ) @xmath344 ; ( v2 ) at ( -2,1 ) @xmath345 ; ( v3 ) at ( 2,1 ) @xmath346 ; ( v1 ) edge ( v2 ) ; ( v1 ) edge ( v3 ) ; consider a sequence of numbers @xmath347 .
define for @xmath348 the number @xmath349 and replace any node @xmath344 with @xmath350 .
the sum of the nodes in the level @xmath47 of the resulting tree is @xmath351 . in case that @xmath352 , in the previous construction we can replace the label @xmath353 by @xmath354 without losing information . with these new labels , at any node on the level @xmath343 of the tree we have ( v1 ) at ( 0,2 ) @xmath321 ; ( v2 ) at ( -2,1 ) @xmath355 ; ( v3 ) at ( 2,1 ) @xmath356 ; ( v1 ) edge ( v2 ) ; ( v1 ) edge ( v3 ) ; which essentially gives the general pi binary tree .
the number that we attach to the node @xmath357 is @xmath358 , so we recover the construction of fuchs .
in this section we briefly study the coefficients of the non - associative monomials in the series @xmath184 .
unfortunately , these monomials are not left - normed so we can not directly apply the dynkin - specht - wever lemma to them to get a closed form of the baker - campbell - hausdorff formula similar to ( [ eq : dynkin_formula ] ) .
given a monomial @xmath359 , that we can identify with a binary planar rooted tree , any tuple @xmath360 of monomials satisfying @xmath361 with @xmath362 will be called a _ cut _ of @xmath363 recall that @xmath364 denotes the degree of @xmath365 in @xmath1 .
attached to @xmath366 there is the set @xmath367 . the pair @xmath368 is a _ branch _ of @xmath363 . sometimes we will refer to @xmath369 as a branch of @xmath363 , although this is an abuse of notation since we should specify the positions that the branch occupies inside @xmath363 .
monomials @xmath370 are represented by binary planar rooted trees with leaves decorated with @xmath1 or @xmath2 .
the element @xmath375 in @xmath26 is expanded in terms of monomials @xmath376 with @xmath377 .
unfortunately , monomials @xmath376 might represent the same monomial @xmath378 for different values of @xmath155 and @xmath379 one way of computing the coefficient of @xmath378 in the series @xmath184 is to determine the cuts of @xmath378 where every branch is of the form @xmath380 ( _ bch - cuts _ ) .
if we denote by @xmath381 the set of all bch - cuts of @xmath378 , the coefficient in @xmath184 of the monomial @xmath378 is @xmath382 where @xmath383 is the coefficient of @xmath155 in @xmath151 .
the set @xmath381 can be easily determined since lemma [ lem : branches ] implies that there exists a unique @xmath384 with minimal @xmath385 .
the branches of any @xmath386 can be obtained as the branches in a bch - cut of the monomials @xmath387 ,
, @xmath388 .
each monomial @xmath389 produces @xmath390 ( @xmath391 ) , @xmath392 ( @xmath393 ) or @xmath394 ( @xmath395 ) bch - cuts . using @xmath396
$ ] to delimit branches and writing @xmath397,\dots,[x^{i_{\vert\tau\vert } } y^{j_{\vert\tau\vert}}])$ ] instead of @xmath398 , some bch - cuts are @xmath399 , [ x^2][y ] , ( [ x][x])[y ] \\ \hline x(xy ) & [ x][xy ] , [ x]([x][y ] ) \\ \hline x(yx ) & [ x]([y][x ] )
\\ \hline ( xy)x & [ xy][x ] , ( [ x][y])[x ] \\ \hline \vdots & \vdots \\ \hline \end{array}\ ] ] thus , for instance , the coefficient of @xmath400 in @xmath184 is @xmath401 while the coefficient of @xmath402 is @xmath403 in a similar way , the coefficient of @xmath404 is @xmath405 finally , let us compute the coefficient of @xmath406 with @xmath407 .
the bch - cuts are @xmath408 $ ] and @xmath409[x])\cdots [ x])(([y^j][y])\cdots[y])$ ] @xmath410 and @xmath411 .
hence , the coefficient is @xmath412 however , we observe that the coefficients of the monomials in the expansion of @xmath413 agree with those in @xmath184 ( take @xmath414 ) . the coefficient in @xmath413 of @xmath415 ( @xmath416 )
is @xmath417 however , @xmath418 so this coefficient is @xmath419 .
therefore , the coefficient of @xmath406 in @xmath184 is @xmath420 | we address the problem of constructing the non - associative version of the dynkin form of the baker - campbell - hausdorff formula ; that is , expressing @xmath0 , where @xmath1 and @xmath2 are non - associative variables , in terms of the shestakov - umirbaev primitive operations .
in particular , we obtain a recursive expression for the magnus expansion of the baker - campbell - hausdorff series and an explicit formula in degrees smaller than 5 .
our main tool is a non - associative version of the dynkin - specht - wever lemma .
a construction of bernouilli numbers in terms of binary trees is also recovered . |
superconducting nanowire single - photon detectors ( snspd s ) are promising devices for the detection of single photons because of their fast response time , broadband sensitivity , and low dark - count rate@xcite .
a variety of materials are currently being used , with the common denominator that their resistivity in the normal state is unusually large , consistent with an electronic mean free path in the order of the interatomic distance .
these materials are chosen for their high critical temperature and fast electron - phonon scattering . in view of the increased interest ,
the need for reproducible device - fabrication has become an issue .
it has been found that often variations of detection efficiency occur from device to device@xcite and as a function of position on a single device@xcite , which are not easily understood .
part of this lack of control may signal the need for improved materials control on an atomic level .
however , since snspd s are made from highly resistive superconductors , an intrinsic cause might be present as well . due to the short elastic - scattering length , localization is competing with superconductivity , and a tendency to an insulating state is accompanied by a tendency to become superconducting
it is predicted that intrinsic electronic inhomogeneities are formed irrespective of the specific atomic inhomogeneity@xcite .
recent experimental work on tin has clearly demonstrated the occurrence of such electronic inhomogeneities by measuring the local values of the superconducting energy - gap by scanning tunneling microscopy@xcite .
stimulated by these observations , we have recently studied the microwave electrodynamics of such films@xcite , and analyzed the data in the context of a recent theory proposed by feigelman and skvortsov@xcite .
unfortunately , for snspd s a limited number of parameters is available to characterize them : the critical temperature , the critical current , the resistivity and the resistive transition .
it is , however , reasonable to assume that variations of the superconducting gap , as observed by sacp _
_ play a role in the observed variation of detection efficiency from device to device and from position to position on the device . in this manuscript ,
we focus on one of the few available extra sources of information ; the return of the device to the superconducting state , the so - called retrapping current ( fig .
[ vi_currcrow ] ) , which is known to vary from sample to sample and shows a clear steplike structure .
m - long , 1 @xmath0m - wide , and 8 nm - thick wires , including the gradually widening contact pads@xcite . ]
the measurements described in this paper , were performed on the same nbtin wires described in @xcite , where the reduction of the critical current due to current crowding was studied .
the nbtin films have a thickness @xmath1 of @xmath28 nm , a critical temperature @xmath3 of 9.5 k , and a resistivity @xmath4 of 170 @xmath5 . the wires have a width @xmath6 of 1 @xmath0 m . we have chosen this width , though it is wider than typical snspd devices , since wider wires are less sensitive to fabrication defects and show stronger current - crowding effects .
similar results were obtained for samples as narrow as 50 nm .
the length @xmath7 is 20 @xmath0 m . four different wire geometries were studied : straight wires , corners with optimally designed inner curves , corners with sharp inner curves , and a straight line that included a stub extending 1 @xmath0 m to one side . for each of the devices
the current - voltage characteristics were measured in a 4.2 k liquid helium dipstick .
the samples were mounted on a ceramic pcb that was in direct contact with a copper sample stage with thermally anchored wires , to ensure a temperature equal to the sample - stage .
the temperature of the sample stage itself was controlled by a heater element and measured by a temperature sensor embedded in the sample stage .
the measurements reported here are all current - biased in a two - point measurement configuration .
the wires were driven into the normal state by applying a current above the critical current of the wire .
then we monitored for each sample for decreasing current the return from the normal state into the superconducting state .
fig . [ vi_currcrow ] shows the retrapping characteristics for four geometries .
this set of measurements was taken at 4.2 k. in all samples a stepwise transition from the normal state to the superconducting state is observed .
the intermediate states between the normal and superconducting state of the wire are stable for long periods of time ( measured up to @xmath210 minutes ) if the bias current is kept stable at this point .
the specific pattern of a wire is reproducible over multiple measurements .
we observe similar stepwise retrapping characteristics in 100 nm wide nbtin and tin nanowires .
we find that the presence and stability of these steps does not depend on the geometrical shape of the wire .
all geometries show stepwise retrapping patterns .
this shows that , for these geometries , the presence of a geometrical ` constriction ' does not dominate the retrapping characteristics .
this is clearly different from the superconducting to normal - state transition , where the critical current is significantly suppressed in geometries with sharp features@xcite .
the available evidence suggests that these disordered superconducting wires have a tendency to become superconducting by forming one or more superconducting domains , which expand in a steplike discontinuous way .
we have recently performed a detailed study of a model system consisting of a superconducting wire between two normal reservoirs .
the analysis was executed taking the full non - equilibrium processes into account@xcite . in the strongly disordered wires of nbtin ( and tin ) the origin of the steps needs to be determined prior to a more detailed analysis .
it has been theoretically suggested that for a superconductor with homogeneous disorder the superconducting state tends to develop mesoscopic fluctuations in the value of the energy gap and a flattening of the peak in the density of states@xcite .
scanning tunneling microscopy measurements on thin films of tin , with a resistivity even higher than our films : @xmath8 cm , show such a variation of the gap energy over the film@xcite .
the maximum variation of the gap energy is about 20% of the total gap energy , and the typical size of the regions is about 50 nm , much larger than the grain size of the films .
variations in the geometry of the nanowire , such as thickness variations due to steps in the underlying substrate , might lead to similar behavior as modeled here@xcite .
we use sem - inspection to guaranty the homogeneity of the width .
we observe similar behavior in ald - deposited tin nanowires on an amorphous silicon oxide substrate .
the persistent presence of these steplike features for wires that appear ` perfect ' , leads us to conjecture that electronic inhomogeneities play a role .
we assume that the transition occurs by the formation of expanding superconducting domains , with the observed resistance given by the backscattering resistance in the remaining normal part of the wire . in principle , for a driven system consisting of superconducting and normal domains one would have to include current conversion processes at the interfaces .
since we are interested in the possible influence of random electronic inhomogeneities , we use the much more tractable thermal model of the superconducting wire introduced by skocpol , beasley , and tinkham @xcite . in fig .
[ model ] we illustrate our model .
the bulk contacts are assumed to be in the superconducting state and both the electron- and phonon - temperature are taken to be at the bath temperature of 4.2 k at the contacts ( at @xmath9 and @xmath10 in fig .
[ model](a ) ) . the heat flow model in each segment of length @xmath11
is shown in fig .
[ model](b ) .
we assume that in each slice of the wire the electrons and phonons each have a thermal distribution , with temperatures @xmath12 and @xmath13 respectively .
the wire is biased with a constant current @xmath14 , and has a normal state resistance @xmath15 .
we also assume the temperature is constant over the width of the wire .
the electron system looses heat by diffusion along the wire and by electron - phonon interaction .
the phonon system looses energy by phonon - diffusion along the wire and escape of phonons from the film to the substrate .
we write a static heat balance equation for both the electron and phonon baths : @xmath16 we describe the heat transport by electron and phonon diffusion with fourier s law : @xmath17 with @xmath18 the wire cross section , and @xmath19 and @xmath20 the electron and phonon heat transfer coefficients : @xmath21 with @xmath22 the normal state conductivity , @xmath23 the phonon heat capacity , and @xmath24 the phonon diffusion coefficient . assuming two - dimensional phonons , the phonon heat capacity is given by @xmath25 with @xmath26 the number of phonon modes per unit volume , and @xmath27 the debye temperature .
the phonon diffusion coefficient is given by @xmath28 with @xmath29 the speed of sound in the material , and @xmath1 the film thickness .
the electron - phonon coupling is parameterized by a time constant @xmath30 .
the energy flows are given by @xmath31 with @xmath32 the electronic heat capacity , estimated with the fermi free electron gas model , with @xmath33 the electronic diffusion constant .
phonon escape to the substrate , which is assumed to be at the bath temperature , is also parameterized by an escape time @xmath34 : @xmath35 in this straightforward model , the crucial part is the electron temperature and electronic heat flow .
assuming that electronic inhomogeneities play a role , it may lead to random variations in @xmath3 .
however , we find that the resistive transition @xmath36 curves of the wires are very sharp ( inset fig .
[ vi_currcrow ] ) .
an alternative source of fluctuations might be contained in the electronic heat conductivity , which would then also be present in the resistivity . in principle , the superconducting state is insensitive to elastic scattering .
variations in elastic scattering can easily be tolerated , while maintaining a uniform @xmath3@xcite . however , in these strongly disordered films the superconducting properties do depend on disorder and a variation of @xmath3 with position is possible@xcite . for simplicity , we have chosen to model the intrinsic electronic inhomogeneities by letting the critical temperature vary randomly along the length of the wire . at points at which the electron temperature exceeds the local critical temperature ,
the wire is considered to be in the normal state and ohmic dissipation is present . at points
at which the electron temperature is lower than the critical temperature , the wire is considered to be in the superconducting state and no dissipation is present : @xmath37 several parameters play a role but many are known by design ( the geometric parameters @xmath6 , @xmath1 , and @xmath7 ) , or can be measured independently ( @xmath33 , @xmath15 , @xmath22 ) .
the following parameters were estimated from literature values for thin nbn films and applied to our nbtin films : * @xmath30 .
we use an empirical relation @xmath38 ps , that was reported for nbn thin films@xcite .
we use the value _ at _ @xmath3 and ignore the slight temperature dependence .
* @xmath34 .
the value reported for 3.5 nm nbn on sapphire is @xmath39 ps@xcite .
* @xmath26 .
this value is taken equal to the atomic density , for nbn this is @xmath40@xcite .
* @xmath27 .
the two - dimensional debye temperature is @xmath41.@xcite the value of the latter is @xmath42@xcite .
* @xmath43 for nbn@xcite .
a ( blue ) .
the black line represents the randomly varying critical temperature along the wire . the stepwise transition from normal state to superconducting state
can be seen from the temperature profiles in which only a part of the wire has an electron - temperature above the critical temperature . ] in fig .
[ tempprof ] , we show two sets of electron temperature profiles for a 20 @xmath0 m long , 1 @xmath0 m wide , 8 nm thick , nbtin wire , simulated using the model described in section [ sec : model ] .
the black line represents the critical temperature , which varies randomly around the experimentally determined value @xmath44 k. the used parameters are @xmath45 k , where @xmath46 , with @xmath47 a random number between @xmath48 and @xmath49 .
the length of the @xmath3 regions of the random pattern is @xmath50 nm , a value arbitrarily chosen but suggested by the experiments by sacepe _ _ et al.__@xcite . in the two panels of fig .
[ tempprof ] a different random pattern with the same parameters is chosen , clearly leading to a different approach to the superconducting state .
the bias current is decreased from @xmath51 @xmath0a , at which the entire wire is normal .
as the current is lowered , the electron temperature in the wire decreases smoothly , until a stepwise jump occurs in which the superconducting regions at the boundary increase to a new stable position .
this continues until finally the entire wire is in the superconducting state .
the phonon - temperature follows the same profile as the electron - temperature . in the normal region
it lies between 5.9 and 6.3 k for the currents shown . because of the low electronic diffusion constant for our films , @xmath52 , and strong electron - phonon coupling , the energy flow is dominated by energy transfer to the substrate via the phonon system . in other words , the size of the normal regions is always much larger than the thermal healing length in the wire .
therefore , under current - bias , the electron- and phonon - temperatures are constant over the normal region and their value is independent of the size of the normal region .
[ vi_sim ] shows the current - voltage characteristics which results from the electron - temperature profiles in fig .
[ tempprof ] .
elements of the wire where the electron temperature is above the critical temperature are taken to be in the normal state , with a resistance , whereas elements of the wire where the electron temperature is below the critical temperature are taken to be in the superconducting state .
jumps in the transition from the normal state to the superconducting state can be seen around 95 @xmath0a .
the precise value of the retrapping current differs from the experimentally observed value of @xmath53a .
however , we are not aiming for a quantitatively accurate prediction of the retrapping current , since a number of thermal parameters are not well - known .
we are aiming for possible contributions to the observed steplike features .
the exact shape depends on the particular random inhomogeneity pattern of the sample .
steps in the current - voltage characteristics are also reported in @xcite , where they are ascribed to phase slip centers .
these current - voltage characteristics are however qualitatively different from the ones we observe . in @xcite ,
the stepwise transition occurs mainly in the increasing current branch , in which we observe an immediate transition from the superconducting- to the normal - state . .
steps in the transition from the normal to the superconducting state are seen for decreasing current - bias . ]
we observe a persistent stepwise transition from the normal to the superconducting state under decreasing current - bias in nbtin wires , for all wire geometries .
it is argued that the stepwise pattern may be due to disorder fluctuations or electronic inhomogeneities intrinsic to disordered superconductors , modeled by local variations in the critical temperature .
the authors would like to thank karl berggren for stimulating discussions .
we acknowledge support from the foundation for fundamental research on matter ( fom ) , microkelvin ( no . 228464 , capacities specific programme ) , and the teradec program of nwo - rfbr .
a. j. kerman , e. a. dauler , j. k. w. yang , k. m. rosfjord , v. anant , k. k. berggren , g. n. goltsman , and b. m. voronov , `` constriction - limited detection efficiency of superconducting nanowire single - photon detectors , '' _ appl .
_ , vol . 90 , p. 101110
, 2007 .
m. rosticher , f. r. ladan , j. p. maneval , s. n. dorenbos , t. zijlstra , t. m. klapwijk , v. zwiller , a. lupacu , and g. nogues , `` a high efficiency superconducting nanowire single electron detector , '' _ appl .
_ , vol .
97 , p. 183106
, 2010 .
b. sacp , c. chapelier , t. i. baturina , v. m. vinokur , m. r. baklanov , and m. sanquer , `` disorder - induced inhomogeneities of the superconducting state close to the superconductor - insulator transition , '' _ phys .
_ , vol . 101 , p. 157006
, 2008 .
e. f. c. driessen , p. c. j. j. coumou , r. r. tromp , p. j. de visser , and t. m. klapwijk , `` strongly disordered tin and nbtin @xmath55-wave superconductors probed by microwave electrodynamics , '' _ phys
109 , p. 107003
, 2012 .
h. l. hortensius , e. f. c. driessen , t. m. klapwijk , k. k. berggren , and j. r. clem , `` critical - current reduction in thin superconducting wires due to current crowding , '' _ appl .
100 , p. 182602
, 2012 .
n. vercruyssen , t. g. a. verhagen , m. g. flokstra , j. p. pekola , and t. m. klapwijk , `` evanescent states and nonequilibrium in driven superconducting nanowires , '' _ phys .
b _ , vol . 85 , p. 224503
, 2012 .
y. noat , t. cren , c. brun , f. debontridder , v. cherkez , k. ilin , m. siegel , a. semenov , h. hbers , and d. roditchev , `` break - up of long - range coherence due to phase fluctuations in ultrathin superconducting nbn films , '' _ arxiv:1205.3408 _ , 2012 .
y. p. gousev , g. n. goltsman , a. d. semenov , e. m. gershenzon , r. s. nebosis , m. a. heusinger , and k. f. renk , `` broadband ultrafast superconducting nbn detector for electromagnetic radiation , '' _ j. appl
_ , vol . 75 , p. 3695
, 1994 .
k. s. ilin , m. lindgren , m. currie , a. d. semenov , g. n. goltsman , r. sobolewski , s. i. cherednichenko , and e. m. gershenzon , `` picosecond hot - electron energy relaxation in nbn superconducting photodetectors , '' _ appl .
_ , vol .
76 , p. 2752
, 2000 .
a. d. semenov , r. s. nebosis , y. p. gousev , m. a. heusinger , and k. f. renk , `` analysis of the nonequilibrium photoresponse of superconducting films to pulsed radiation by use of a two - temperature model , '' _ phys .
b _ , vol . 52 , p. 581
, 1995 .
a. k. elmurodov , f. m. peeters , d. y. vodolazov , s. michotte , s. adam , f. de menten de horne , l. piraux , d. lucot , and d. mailly , `` phase - slip phenomena in nbn superconducting nanowires with leads , '' _ phys .
b _ , vol . 78 , p. 214519 | the voltage - carrying state of superconducting nbtin nanowires , used for single - photon detectors , is analyzed . upon lowering the current
, the wire returns to the superconducting state in a steplike pattern , which differs from sample to sample .
elimination of geometrical inhomogeneities , such as sharp corners , does not remove these steplike features .
they appear to be intrinsic to the material .
since the material is strongly disordered , electronic inhomogeneities are considered as a possible cause .
a thermal model , taking into account random variations of the electronic properties along the wire , is used as an interpretative framework . |
the first metal enrichment in the universe was made by the supernova ( sn ) explosions of population ( pop ) iii stars . despite the importance of pop iii stars in the evolution of the early universe ,
their properties are still uncovered .
the main issues is the typical masses of pop iii stars .
some studies have suggested that the initial mass function ( imf ) differs from the present day imf ( e.g. , top - heavy imf ; @xcite ) and that a large number of stars might be so massive as to explode as pair - instability sne ( e.g. , @xcite ) . on the other hand , @xcite suggested an imf that is peaked in the range of massive stars that exploded as core - collapse sne . in the early universe , the enrichment by a single sn can dominate the preexisting metal contents ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
the pop iii sn shock compresses the sn ejecta consisting of heavy elements , e.g. , o , mg , si , and fe , and the circumstellar materials consisting of h and he , and thus the abundance pattern of the enriched gas may reflect nucleosynthesis in the sn . the sn compression will initiate a sn - induced star formation ( e.g. , @xcite ) and the second - generation stars will be formed from the enriched gas . among the second generation stars , low mass ( @xmath9 ) stars have long life - times and might be observed as extremely metal - poor ( emp ) stars with [ fe / h ] @xmath7 @xcite .
( here [ a / b ] @xmath10 , where the subscript @xmath11 refers to the solar value and @xmath12 and @xmath13 are the abundances of elements a and b , respectively . )
therefore the emp stars should conserve the nucleosynthetic results of the pop iii sn and can constrain the yields of the sn .
the elements ejected by various sne are gradually mixed and the abundance patterns of the galaxy becomes homogeneous with time .
the abundance patterns of the newly formed stars reflect averaged nucleosynthesis over various sne .
it is important to know when the transition from inhomogeneous to homogeneous mixing occurs .
the timing of this transition can be informed from chemical evolution calculations with hierarchical models ; @xcite has suggested that a halo ism is unmixed and inhomogeneous at [ fe / h ] @xmath14 , intermediate between unmixed and well mixed at @xmath15 [ fe / h ] @xmath16 , and well mixed at [ fe / h ] @xmath17 ; @xcite has suggested that the mean number of reflected sne is 10 at @xmath18 } \sim -2.8 $ ] .
the previous observations ( e.g. , mcwilliam et al .
1995a , b ; @xcite ) provide the abundance patterns of the emp stars that show interesting trends of elemental abundance ratios [ cr / fe ] , [ mn / fe ] , [ co / fe ] , [ zn / fe ] with decreasing [ fe / h ] , although dispersions are rather large . these trends , except for the absolute values of some elements , can be explained by the differences of the progenitors masses and the explosion energies assuming the sn - induced star formation ( @xcite ; umeda & nomoto 2002a , 2005 , hereafter @xcite , @xcite ) .
recent observations for @xmath19 } \lsim -2 $ ] by cayrel et al.(2004 , hereafter @xcite ) confirmed these trends shown by the previous studies with much smaller dispersions ( see , however honda et al .
2004 , hereafter @xcite , for the difference in [ cr / fe ] at @xmath20 } \lsim -2 $ ] ) , except for much flatter trends of [ mg / fe ] and [ mn / fe ] than the previous studies . @xcite and @xcite suggested the following interpretation of the observed small dispersions : the elements have been already mixed homogeneously in the halo even below [ fe / h ] @xmath7 and the trends are due to the difference of the lifetime of progenitors with different masses .
homogeneous mixing is required because previous sn yields that have been used [ e.g. , woosley & weaver ( 1995 , hereafter @xcite ) ; @xcite ; @xcite ; and chieffi & limongi ( 2002 , hereafter @xcite ) ] show a large scatter in [ @xmath21/fe ] ( where @xmath21 represents @xmath21-elements , for example , o , ne , mg , si , e.g. , @xcite ) .
however , this interpretation may not be consistent with the galactic chemical evolution models that suggest inhomogeneous mixing in such early phases ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
also , @xmath22-process nuclei observed in the emp stars show too large scatters @xcite to be reproduced by the homogeneous mixing model @xcite , unless there exist a major site of @xmath22-process synthesis other than sn explosions ( see @xcite , who concluded core - collapse sne are more preferable sites of @xmath22-process elements than neutron - star mergers ) .
in the regime of inhomogeneous mixing , @xcite have succeeded to reproduce the observed trends of the ratios , [ cr / fe ] , [ mn / fe ] , [ co / fe ] , and [ zn / fe ] , as a result of chemical enrichment of various sn models including hyper - energetic explosions ( @xmath23 : hypernovae , hereafter hne ) . in their approach ,
variation of @xmath6 and the mixing - fallback process are important @xcite .
the mixing - fallback model can solve the disagreement between [ @xmath21/fe ] and [ ( fe - peak element)/fe ] ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
traditionally , core - collapse sne were considered to explode with @xmath24 as sn 1987a @xcite , sn 1993j @xcite , and sn 1994i @xcite before the discoveries of hne sn 1997ef ( @xcite ) and sn 1998bw ( patat er al .
2001 ; @xcite ) . after these discoveries
, the number of pop i hne has been increasing , and the association with gamma - ray bursts ( grbs ) has been established as grb 980425/sn 1998bw ( galama et al .
1998 ; iwamoto et al .
1998 ; woosley et al . 1999 ; nakamura et al .
2001a ) , grb 030329/sn 2003dh ( stanek et al .
2003 ; hjorth et al . 2003 ; matheson et al . 2003 ; mazzali et al .
2003 ; lipkin et al .
2004 ; deng et al .
2005 ) , and grb 031203/sn 2003lw ( thomsen et al .
2004 ; gal - yam et al . 2004 ; cobb et al .
2004 ; malesani et al . 2004
; mazzali et al .
though it is an interesting issue how much fraction of the core - collapse sne explode as hne ( e.g. , podsiadlowski et al . 2004 ) , non - negligible number of hne occurred at least at present days .
nucleosynthesis in hne is characterized by the large amount of @xmath25ni production ( @xmath26 , e.g. , @xcite ) .
two sites of @xmath25ni synthesis have been suggested : the shocked stellar core ( e.g. , @xcite ) and the accretion disk surrounding the central black hole ( e.g. , macfadyen & woosley 1999 ) .
we investigate the former site because the light curve and spectra of sn 1998bw favor the @xmath25ni synthesis in the shocked stellar core @xcite . in this paper
, we construct core - collapse sne models of the pop iii 13 50 @xmath1 stars for various explosion energies of @xmath27 ergs . by applying the mixing - fallback model to the hn models ,
we show that the yields of these pop iii sne and hne are in good agreements with the observed abundance patterns and trends with reasonably small dispersions @xcite .
we do not consider pair - instability sne because previous studies ( @xcite ; umeda & nomoto 2003 , hereafter @xcite ; @xcite ) found that there has been no evidence of the pair - instability sn abundance patterns in the emp stars , although they might have existed before our galaxy become metal - rich - enough to form low - mass stars ( see also @xcite for core - collapse very massive stars ) . in
[ sec : model ] , we describe our progenitor and explosion models . in [ sec : individual ] , we show that the abundance patterns of the emp stars are reproduced by hn models and that the abundance patterns of the vmp stars are reproduced by normal sn models or an imf - integrated model . in [ sec : trend ] , we show that the trends with small dispersions can be reproduced by pop iii sn models with various progenitors masses and explosion energies assuming a sn - induce star formation .
the scatters in our models are almost consistent with the observed ones . in [ sec : improve ] , we examine how the agreements of sc / fe , ti / fe , mn / fe , and co / fe are improved by modifying the distributions of the neutron - proton ( n / p ) ratio and the density in the presupernova models . in
[ sec : discuss ] , summary and discussion are given .
the calculation method and other assumptions are the same as described in umeda et al .
( 2000 , hereafter @xcite ) , @xcite , and @xcite .
the isotopes in the reaction network for explosive nuclear burning include 280 species up to @xmath28br as in @xcite .
we calculate the evolutions of pop iii progenitors , whose main - sequence masses are @xmath29 13 , 15 , 18 , 20 , 25 , 30 , 40 , 50 @xmath1 , and their sn explosions as summarized in table [ tab : models ] . the mass loss rate from stars with metallicity @xmath30 is assumed to be proportional to @xmath31 @xcite , so that pop iii @xmath32 models experience no mass loss .
sn hydrodynamical calculations include nuclear energy generation with the @xmath21-network .
the yields are obtained by detailed nucleosynthesis calculations as a post - processing .
there are various ways to simulate the explosion .
for example , @xcite assumed an approximate analytic formula to describe the radiation - dominated shock , although their recent modeling applied full hydrodynamics ( @xcite ) . @xcite and
@xcite injected energy as a piston .
their piston model could mimic the time delay until the deposited energy by neutrino reaches a critical value .
however , since the explosion mechanism of core - collapse sne have not been well uncovered , one still does not know what is the most realistic way to inject explosion energy .
further , the yields do not strongly depend on how to generate the shock @xcite .
therefore , in our calculation , the explosion is initiated as a thermal bomb with an arbitrary explosion energy , i.e. , we elevate temperatures of an inner most region of the progenitor .
we determine the explosion energy with referring to the relation between the main - sequence mass and the explosion energy ( @xmath33 ) as obtained from observations and models of sne ( fig .
[ fig : ccsn]a ) .
this relation is obtained from pop i sne , but we assume that the same @xmath34 relation holds for pop iii sne because the fe core masses are roughly the same between pop i and pop iii stars @xcite . according to the observed relation , the massive stars with @xmath35 are assumed to explode as hypernovae ( hne ) , which are hyper - energetic explosions and expected to leave black holes behind @xcite , and the explosion energies of the models for @xmath29 20 , 25 , 30 , 40 , 50 @xmath1 are @xmath36 10 , 10 , 20 , 30 , 40 , respectively .
the stars smaller than 20 @xmath1 are considered to explode as normal sne with @xmath37 .
the explosion energy of normal sn models ( @xmath37 ) is consistent with that of sn 1987a ( @xmath38 , @xcite ) .
figures [ fig : snhn]a and [ fig : snhn]b show the abundance distributions in the ejecta of the @xmath39 normal sn ( @xmath40 ) and hn ( @xmath41 ) models , respectively .
nucleosynthesis in hne with large explosion energies takes place under high entropies and show the following characteristics @xcite .
\(1 ) both complete and incomplete si - burning regions shift outward in mass compared with normal supernovae . as seen in figures [ fig : snhn]a and [ fig : snhn]b , the mass in the complete si - burning region becomes larger , while the incomplete si - burning region does not change much . as a result , higher energy explosions produce larger [ ( zn , co , v)/fe ] and smaller [ ( mn , cr)/fe ] .
\(2 ) in the complete si - burning region of hypernovae , elements produced by @xmath21-rich freezeout are enhanced because of high entropies .
hence , elements synthesized through the @xmath21-capture process , such as @xmath42ti , @xmath43cr , and @xmath44ge are more abundant .
these species decay into @xmath42ca , @xmath43ti , and @xmath44zn , respectively .
\(3 ) oxygen burning takes place in more extended regions for the larger explosion energy .
then more o , c , al are burned to produce a larger amount of burning products such as si , s , and ar . as a result
, hypernova nucleosynthesis is characterized by large abundance ratios of [ ( si , s)/o ] ( @xcite ) . the mass cut is defined to be a boundary between the central remnant and the sn ejecta and thus corresponds to the mass of the compact star remnant . the sn yield is an integration over the ejecta outside the mass cut . in 1d spherically symmetric models
, the mass cut can be determined hydrodynamically as a function of the explosion energy @xcite .
however , such 1d hydrodynamical determinations may not be relevant because sn explosions are found to be aspherical ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
we take into account approximately the aspherical effects with a mixing - fallback model ( see appendix for detail ) parameterising the aspherical sn explosions with three parameters , i.e. , the initial mass cut @xmath45 , the outer boundary of the mixing region @xmath46 and the ejection factor @xmath47 .
the initial mass of the central remnant is represented by @xmath45 . during the explosion
, an inversion of the abundance distribution and a fallback of the materials above @xmath45 onto the central remnant might occur in the aspherical explosions ( e.g. , @xcite ) , in contrast to the spherical explosions .
the inversion is represented by the mixing of the materials between @xmath45 and @xmath46 and the fraction of materials ejected from the mixing region is parameterized by the ejection factor @xmath47 . as a consequence
, the final mass of the central remnant @xmath48 is derived with equation ( 7 ) in appendix .
the parameters of the mixing - fallback model should essentially be derived from the mechanisms of sn explosions , e.g. , the rotation , the asphericity , and the way to inject energy from the central region . however , the explosion mechanisms of sne have not been clarified .
thus the parameters are constrained from the observed fe ( @xmath25ni ) mass or from the comparison between the yield and the observed abundance pattern . for normal sn models , we determine the mass cuts to yield @xmath49 because the ejected @xmath25ni mass of the observed normal sne are clustered around this value ( fig .
[ fig : ccsn]b , e.g. , sn 1987a , @xcite ; sn 1993j , @xcite ; sn 1994i , @xcite ) .
we also assume that the whole materials above the mass cut are ejected without the mixing - fallback process .
this corresponds to the ejection factor @xmath50 in the mixing - fallback model ( see appendix ) . for hn models ,
we apply the mixing - fallback model and determine parameters to yield [ o / fe ] @xmath51 ( case a ) for all hn models or [ mg / fe ] @xmath52 ( case b ) for massive hn models ( @xmath53 ) as described in appendix .
while case a is similar to @xcite , case b is to reproduce [ mg / fe ] @xmath54 plateau for [ fe / h ] @xmath55 in @xcite .
the plateau had not been observed by the previous studies .
since case b has larger amount of fallback , i.e. , larger @xmath46 and smaller @xmath47 than case a , both of small [ mg / fe ] and [ fe / h ] is realized in case b. the applied mixing - fallback parameters are summarised in tables [ tab : models ] , [ tab : modelsye ] , and [ tab : modelsyelow ] and the final yields are summarised in tables [ tab : yield ] , [ tab : yield2 ] , [ tab : yieldye ] , [ tab : yield2ye ] , [ tab : yieldyelow ] , and [ tab : yield2yelow ] .
we assume that [ fe / h ] of a star formed by the sn shock compression is determined by the ratio between the ejected fe mass @xmath56(fe ) and the swept - up h mass @xmath56(h ) @xcite . according to @xcite ,
the swept - up h mass is given as @xmath57 where @xmath58 is the mass fraction of h in the primordial gases , @xmath59 is the total amount of the swept - up materials , and @xmath60 is the number density of the circumstellar medium . here
we adopt @xmath61 as obtained from _
wilkinson microwave anisotropy probe _ @xcite and standard big bang nucleosynthesis @xcite .
[ fe / h ] of the star is approximated as @xmath62 } & = & \log_{10}(m{\rm ( fe)}/m{\rm ( h ) } ) \\
\nonumber & & -\log_{10}{(x{\rm ( fe)}/x{\rm ( h)})_\odot } \\ & \simeq & \log_{10}\left({m({\rm fe})/{{m_{\odot}}}\over{e_{51}^{6/7}}}\right)-c .
\label{eq : snsf}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath63 is the solar abundance ratio in mass between fe and h @xcite and @xmath64 is assumed to be a constant value of 1.4 , which corresponds to @xmath65 @xmath66 . resulting values of [ fe / h ] are summarised in tables [ tab : models ] , [ tab : modelsye ] , and [ tab : modelsyelow ] .
[ fe / h ] of stars formed from the ejecta of hne and normal sne can be consistent with the observed [ fe / h ] of the emp and vmp stars , respectively .
@xcite provided abundance patterns of 35 metal - poor stars with small error bars for @xmath67}\lsim-2 $ ] . each emp star may be formed from the ejecta of a single pop iii sn , although some of them might be the second or later generation stars . the yields of sne with the progenitors of [ fe / h ] @xmath68 can be well - approximated by those of pop iii sne since they are similar @xcite .
in this subsection , the theoretical yields are compared with the averaged abundance pattern of four emp stars , cs 22189 - 009 , cd-38:245 , cs 22172 - 002 and cs 22885 - 096 , which have low metallicities ( @xmath69}<-3.5 $ ] ) and normal [ c / fe ] @xmath70 .
stars with large [ c / fe ] ( @xmath71 ) , called c - rich emp stars , are discussed in @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite .
the origin of some of those stars may be a faint sn , being different from those of [ c / fe ] @xmath70 stars ( see [ sec : c ] ) .
also some of the c - rich emp stars might be originated from the mass transfer from the c - rich companion in close binaries ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
comparisons between the hn yields and the abundance pattern of the emp stars are made in figures [ fig : emp]a-[fig : emp]e . in the mixing - fallback model , both [ ( fe - peak elements)/fe ] and [ @xmath21/fe ] give good agreements with the observations , except for some elements , e.g. , k , sc , ti , cr , mn
, and co. possible ways to improve these elements are discussed in [ sec : improve ] .
@xcite also provided the abundance patterns of the vmp stars whose metallicities ( [ fe / h ] @xmath72 ) are higher than the emp stars . the observed abundance pattern is represented by the averaged abundance pattern of five stars bd+17:3248 , hd 2796 , hd 186478 , cs 22966 - 057 and cs 22896 - 154 , which have relatively high metallicities ( @xmath73}<-2.0 $ ] ) .
since these metallicities correspond to those of normal sn models according to equation ( [ eq : snsf ] ) for the sn - induced star formation model , we first compare the observations with normal sn yields ( figs . [
fig : vmp]abc ) .
the mass cuts of normal sn models are determined so that the ejected fe ( @xmath25ni ) mass is @xmath74 . on the other hand , most vmp stars are considered to have the abundance pattern averaged over imf and metallicity of the progenitors , thus we also compare with the imf - integrated yield ( fig .
[ fig : imf ] ) .
since the yields of sne with the progenitors of [ fe / h ] @xmath68 are quite similar to those of pop iii sne @xcite , we use the pop iii yields for these stars as well .
the imf integration is performed from 10 @xmath1 to 50 @xmath1 with 8 models , 13 , 15 , 18 , 20 , 25 , 30 , 40 , 50 @xmath1 and the extrapolations .
we make the power - law imf integrations as follows : @xmath75 where @xmath76 is the number of stars within the mass range of [ @xmath77 , @xmath78 is a normalization constant , and @xmath79 is an integration index ( salpeter imf has @xmath80 ) .
the integration is performed and normalized by the total amount of gases forming stars as follows : @xmath81 where @xmath82 is an integrated mass fraction of an element , a , @xmath83 is mass fraction of a in a model interpolated between the nearest models , and @xmath84 is an ejected mass interpolated between the nearest models or the nearest model and the edge of the imf - integrated mass range . here
we assume @xmath85 and @xmath86 stars do not yield any materials as type ii sne or hne , i.e. , @xmath87 . comparing the integrated yield with the salpeter s imf with the abundance pattern of the vmp stars ( fig .
[ fig : imf ] ) , most elements show reasonable agreements , except for n , k , sc , ti , and mn .
the integrated yields are summarised in table [ tab : imf ] .
figures [ fig : vmp]a-[fig : vmp]c and [ fig : imf ] show that n is underproduced in our models .
there are two possible explanations ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) for this discrepancy : \(1 ) n was actually underproduced in the pop iii sn as in our models , but was enhanced as observed during the first dredge - up in the low - mass red - giant emp stars ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
observationally , the emp and vmp stars in @xcite are giants and some of them show evidences of the deep mixing , i.e. , the dilution of li and the low @xmath88c/@xmath89c ratio @xcite . on the other hand , the emp and vmp stars with no evidence of the deep mixing show relatively small [ n / fe ] ( @xmath90 , @xcite ) .
however , [ n / fe ] in our models are even smaller than the smallest [ n / fe ] observed in the emp and vmp stars @xcite .
thus the following mechanism might be important .
\(2 ) n was enhanced in massive progenitor stars before the sn explosion .
n is mainly synthesized by the mixing between the he convective shell and the h - rich envelope ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
the mixing can be enhanced by rotation @xcite .
suppose that the pop iii sn progenitors were rotating faster than more metal - rich stars because of smaller mass loss , then [ n / fe ] was enhanced as observed in the emp stars .
[ o / fe ] of the 18 @xmath1 and the imf - integrated model are in good agreement with the observations ( figs .
[ fig : vmp]c and [ fig : imf ] ) , while [ o / fe ] of the 13 and 15 @xmath1 models are lower than the observations ( figs .
[ fig : vmp]a and [ fig : vmp]b ) . in the abundance determination of o ,
however , uncertain hydrodynamical ( 3d ) effects are important @xcite and @xcite applied the 3d correction for dwarfs to the metal - deficient giants .
if the observed values of [ o / fe ] in the figures are correct , this may indicate that the contribution of a single normal sn from a small - mass progenitor to the chemical enrichment in the vmp stars is small .
we assumed all massive stars with @xmath91 explode as hne .
however , there is a suggestion that the fraction of hne to whole sne ( @xmath92 ) is @xmath93 ( @xcite ) .
if @xmath93 , [ ( c , n , o)/fe ] and [ zn / fe ] are slightly larger and smaller , respectively , than the case with @xmath94 , but these are still in good agreement with the observation ( fig . 12 in @xcite ) . on the other hand ,
if the contribution of the faint sne ( @xmath91 ) to reproduce the abundance patterns of the c - rich emp stars is large enough ( see [ sec : c ] ; @xcite ) , [ ( c , n , o)/fe ] is enhanced .
this is because the faint sne produce large [ ( c , n , o)/fe ] due to a small amount of fe ejection .
the contribution of the faint sne , however , might be small , since [ mg / fe ] is close to the upper limit of the observations without the contribution of the faint sne . in order to estimate the ratios of hne and faint sne relative to all core - collapse sne , further investigations are necessary .
in [ sec : emp ] and [ sec : vmp ] , we show that the observed abundance patterns can be reasonably reproduced by the mixing - fallback model .
@xcite showed not only the abundance patterns of individual stars but also the existence of certain trends of the abundance ratios with respect to [ fe / h ] . in this section
, we compare the observed trends with our models in tables [ tab : models]-[tab : yield2 ] . in figure
[ fig : trend ] , the observed abundance ratios [ x / fe ] against [ fe / h ] are compared with yields of individual sn models in table [ tab : models ] and the imf - integrated yield described in
[ sec : vmp ] . here
[ fe / h ] of individual sn models are determined by equation ( [ eq : snsf ] ) , while [ fe / h ] of the imf - integrated abundance ratios are assumed to be same as normal sn models ( [ fe / h ] @xmath95 ) .
we note that the observed abundance ratios of most elements are roughly constant for @xmath96 [ fe / h ] @xmath97 .
this can be interpreted that the sn ejecta had been mixed homogeneously in the halo at @xmath96 [ fe / h ] .
this is consistent with the chemical evolution models in @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite . according to the sn - induced star formation model ( eq . [ eq : snsf ] )
, our models cluster around [ fe / h ] @xmath98 and only a few model exists around [ fe / h ] @xmath99 , because we applied only one explosion energy for each mass . in reality , the explosion energies of hne may depend , e.g. , on the rotation of the progenitors , even if the progenitors masses of hne are similar .
the progenitors of sne 1997ef and 2003dh , for instance , have similar masses , but the explosion energies are @xmath100 ergs and @xmath101 ergs , respectively @xcite .
variations of the explosion energy for the same stellar mass lead to variations of [ fe / h ] . in order to produce a model with @xmath18}\sim-3 $ ] , therefore , we add the @xmath39 model with @xmath102 ( see fig .
[ fig:25e5 ] for its abundance pattern ) .
the trends of most elements can be well reproduced by our models , except for k , sc , ti , cr , mn , and co. in the followings , we discuss the trend of each element in more detail .
the ratio c / fe in our models are clustered around [ c / fe ] @xmath70 , while the observed [ c / fe ] of the emp stars are scattered ( see fig . [
fig : trend ] ) .
the large [ c / fe ] ( @xmath103 ) can be interpreted as originated from the faint sne that are characterised by a small ejection factor @xmath47 and the resultant large [ ( c , n , o)/fe ] @xcite .
in fact , figure [ fig : faint ] shows that the abundance pattern of the c - rich emp stars ( cs 29498043 : @xcite ) can be reproduced by our 25 @xmath1 faint sn model with a normal explosion energy @xmath37 and small @xmath104 ( model 25f in tables [ tab : models]-[tab : yield2 ] ) . in this faint sn model , n / fe is too small but can be enhanced as described in [ sec : no ] .
we should note that the large [ co / fe ] of cs 29498043 is difficult to be reproduced by the faint sn model of @xmath37 .
the parent sn of cs 29498043 might be a faint sn with high - entropy jets @xcite .
alternative explanation is that the production of c in other sites is important , that is , c is produced not only from sne but also from mass - losing wolf - rayet ( wr ) stars .
fast rotating stars may undergo strong mass - loss and enter the wr phase , even if their metallicities are considerably low @xcite .
also , the c - enhancement can be realized by transferring mass from the c - rich binary companion ( e.g. , @xcite ) . the ratio mg / fe in @xcite is less - scattered around [ mg / fe ] @xmath105 which is smaller than [ mg / fe ] @xmath106 obtained by @xcite and other previous studies .
case a models , whose ejection factor @xmath47 is set to produce [ o / fe ] @xmath51 , appear around @xmath107 [ fe / h ] @xmath108 and @xmath109 [ mg / fe ] @xmath110 .
these are larger by 0.1 dex than observed [ mg / fe ] in @xcite but consistent with these in the previous studies .
we also consider case b models to reproduce the [ mg / fe ] @xmath105 plateau in @xcite at [ fe / h ] @xmath111 , although the plateau had not been observed by the previous studies .
[ ( si , ca)/fe ] in @xcite and @xcite are slightly less - scattered than in previous studies . [ ( si , ca)/fe ] in our models are in good agreements with the observations and the widths of the scatter in our models are consistent with the observations . the small scatters of [ ( mg , si , ca)/fe ] in our present model are different from previous yields ( @xcite ; thielemann et al .
this difference stems from the following different assumption .
the previous yields assumed the ejected fe mass ( @xmath112 ) depends weakly on the progenitors masses .
therefore [ @xmath21/fe ] in massive star models depends mainly on the @xmath21-element abundances , which strongly depend on the stellar mass .
this leads to the large scatters . in the present stars ,
the emp stars with [ fe / h ] @xmath7 are produced by hne only ( @xmath113 ) , and those hn models produce fe much more than @xmath114 . instead , we assume [ o / fe ] @xmath51 or [ mg / fe ] @xmath52 for @xmath113 models .
our approach suggests that the observed small scatter of [ @xmath21/fe ] implies that larger amount of fe is produced in more massive stars .
this is consistent with the observations that typical hne eject larger amount of fe than normal sne ( fig .
[ fig : ccsn]b )
. [ ti / fe ] in our models is smaller than the observations .
there are no clear trend in [ ti / fe ] in our models as in the observations and the scatter is similar to the observations .
[ ti / fe ] may be enhanced by nucleosynthesis in high - entropy environments as will be discussed in
[ sec : improve ] ( a `` low - density '' modification , see also @xcite ) or in a jet - like explosion @xcite .
the abundances of na and al in @xcite are different from previous studies .
this is partly because @xcite took into account non - lte ( nlte ) effects ( @xmath115 dex and @xmath116 dex ) .
the @xcite result shows a trend in [ na / fe ] against [ fe / h ] . in figure
[ fig : trend ] , our results also show such a trend , although na / fe is slightly smaller than the observations in the hn models , especially in @xmath117 models . because all our models are pop iii models , the trend is not due to the metallicity effect but due to the combination of the progenitors masses and the explosion energies .
the trend stems from the fact that more massive stars produce smaller @xmath118(na ) and that more energetic explosions burn more na .
[ al / fe ] is also smaller by 0.5 dex than in @xcite , especially in the hn model .
however our models are in good agreements with [ al / fe ] in @xcite .
the difference in the observed [ al / fe ] between @xcite and @xcite may be mainly because @xcite does not take into account nlte effects .
the larger @xmath46 in case b enhances na / fe but reduces al / fe .
this is because na and al are mainly synthesized near the outer and the inner edges of the o - rich region , respectively
. only [ al / fe ] of model 40b is in reasonable agreement with @xcite because the 40 @xmath1 progenitor star produce large @xmath118(al ) . both na and al
are mostly synthesized in c shell - burning , and the produced amount depends on the overshooting at the edge of the convective c - burning shell @xcite . in the present presupernova evolution models , no overshooting is included .
if the nlte correction of al is correct , it might be needed to consider convective overshooting in the c - burning shell .
this could enhance na / mg and al / mg , thus weakening the odd - even effect in the abundance patterns and leading to a better agreement with @xcite .
[ k / fe ] and [ sc / fe ] in our models are much smaller than in @xcite and @xcite .
possible improvements are discussed in detail in
[ sec : improve ] .
k / fe is slightly enhanced by the `` low - density '' modification as described in
[ sec : improve ] , but still not large enough .
iwamoto et al .
( in preparation ) suggests that the model with large @xmath8 ( @xmath119 ) in the inner region can produce enough k. sc / fe can be enhanced by the `` low - density '' modification ( see [ sec : improve ] ; @xcite ) .
further enhancement can be realized if @xmath120 .
recently , @xcite and @xcite calculated nucleosynthesis based on the core - collapse sn simulations with neutrino transport . in their models , neutrino absorption enhances @xmath8 near the mass cut of the ejecta . according to their results , sc / fe in the normal sn model
is enhanced to [ sc / fe ] @xmath70 due to the large @xmath8 ( @xmath121 ) and high - entropy ( @xmath122 , where @xmath123 denotes the the entropy per nucleon and @xmath124 is the boltzmann constant ) .
[ cr / fe ] in our models is larger than @xcite but consistent with @xcite .
the difference between @xcite and @xcite stems from the use of the different cr lines (: @xcite and : @xcite ) in obtaining [ cr / fe ] .
it is still uncertain which line is better to use in estimating [ cr / fe ] . if gives reliable abundance , cr in our models is overproduced , although the trend in our models is similar to the observations .
since cr is mostly produced in the incomplete si - burning region , the size of this region relative to the complete si - burning region should be smaller than the present model in order to produce smaller cr / fe .
we also need to examine the nuclear reaction rates related to the synthesis of @xmath125 that decays into @xmath126 .
[ mn / fe ] and [ co / fe ] in our models are smaller than the observations , although the trend of [ co / fe ] in our models is similar to the observations .
the negligibly small dependence of [ mn / fe ] on [ fe / h ] in @xcite is different from previous observations that [ mn / fe ] significantly decreases toward smaller [ fe / h ] @xcite .
they can be improved by the n / p modification as discussed in [ sec : ye ] . also , mn can be efficiently enhanced by a neutrino process ( see [ sec : yelowtrend ] ; @xcite ; t. yoshida et al .
, in preparation )
. therefore the mn / fe ratio is important to constrain the physical processes during the explosion .
[ ni / fe ] and [ zn / fe ] in our models are in good agreement with the observations , although [ ni / fe ] is slightly smaller than the observation .
ni / fe is higher if @xmath127 is smaller ( i.e. , the mass cut is deeper ) because @xmath128ni , a main isotope of stable ni , is mainly synthesized in a deep region with @xmath129 .
however , a smaller @xmath127 tends to suppress zn / fe ( see appendix ) , thus requiring more energetic explosions to produce large enough zn / fe .
the good agreement of [ zn / fe ] with observations strongly supports the sn - induced star formation model and suggests that the emp stars with smaller [ fe / h ] are made from the ejecta of hne with higher explosion energies and larger progenitor s masses .
this is because higher explosion energies lead to larger [ zn / fe ] and smaller [ fe / h ] .
other possible production sites of zn include the neutrino - driven wind from a proto - neutron star ( e.g. , @xcite ) and the accretion disk of a black hole ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
further studies are needed to see how large the contributions of these sites to the zn production are . in order to reproduce the trend and small scatter of [ zn / fe ]
, there must be some `` hidden '' relations between the explosion energy and nucleosynthesis in the neutrino - driven wind or the accretion disk models .
if the vmp stars with [ fe / h ] @xmath72 is made from normal sne with @xmath130 , zn is underproduced in our models .
nucleosynthesis studies with neutrino transport @xcite suggested that zn in the normal sn model is enhanced to [ zn / fe ] @xmath70 .
however , the enhancement is not large enough to explain the large [ zn / fe ] ( @xmath103 ) in the emp stars .
in this section , we present the models based on the modified presupernova distributions of the `` n / p ratio ( i.e. , @xmath8 ) '' and the `` density '' .
we then discuss how these modifications improve sc , ti , mn , and co. the imf - integrated yields , the parameters , and the yields of the individual sne are summarised in tables [ tab : imf]-[tab : yield2yelow ] . in the above discussion ,
we assume that @xmath8 in the presupernova model is kept almost constant during the explosion .
however , recent studies ( e.g. , @xcite ) have suggested that @xmath8 may be significantly varied by the neutrino process during explosion .
further , the region , where the neutrino absorption and @xmath8 variation occur , is rayleigh - taylor unstable because of neutrino heating , so that there exists a large uncertainty in @xmath8 and its distribution .
we apply the following @xmath8 profile that was found to produce reasonable results in @xcite , i.e. , @xmath131 in the complete si burning region and @xmath132 in the incomplete si burning region .
the @xmath8 profile is modified by adjusting the isotope ratios of si . according to the recent explosion calculations with the neutrino effect ( e.g. , @xcite ) , materials with large @xmath8 ( @xmath133 )
may be ejected .
however , @xmath8 might be diluted by mixing , and our @xmath8 profile might mimic such dilution .
the adopted high @xmath8 in the complete si - burning region and low @xmath8 in the incomplete si - burning region lead to large co / fe and mn / fe , respectively .
figures [ fig : ye]a-[fig : ye]j show better agreements between the models and the observations .
here we applied the same @xmath45 as in the models without the @xmath8 modification .
the imf - integrated yield , the parameters , and the yields of the individual sne are summarised in tables [ tab : imf]-[tab : yield2ye ] . since the variation of @xmath8 is considered to be due to the @xmath134-process , the @xmath8 modification might be applied to any core - collapse sne . in the `` low - density '' modification , the density of the presupernova progenitor
is artificially reduced without changing the total mass . @xcite
assumed that such a low density would be realized if the explosion is induced by multiple jets consisted of the primary weak jets and the main strong sne jets .
the primary weak jets expand the interior of the progenitor before the sn explosions driven by the main jets ( as described in appendix in @xcite ) .
alternate explosion mechanism that realizes `` low - density '' is a delayed explosion ( e.g. , @xcite , who investigated explosive nucleosynthesis induced by a black hole forming collapse comparing a direct collapse and a delayed collapse caused by fallback ) .
the `` low - density '' is presumed to be realized in the jet - like or delayed explosions involving fallback , thus being applied only to the hn models but not to the normal sn models .
other mechanism to realize `` low - density '' was suggested by @xcite , i.e. , the l model using `` low '' @xmath88c(@xmath21 , @xmath135)@xmath136o rate @xcite .
they showed that the `` low '' @xmath88c(@xmath21 , @xmath135)@xmath136o rate leads the higher c abundance ( i.e. , larger c / o ratio ) and more active c - shell burning .
as a consequence , the average density in the complete and incomplete si - burning region is lower than the `` high '' @xmath88c(@xmath21 , @xmath135)@xmath136o rate case @xcite . if this mechanism is valid , the `` low - density '' will be realized in whole sne .
however , the large c / o ratio leads to overproduce ne and na at the solar metallicity @xcite .
explosive nucleosynthesis in the model with the `` low - density '' modification takes place at higher entropy ( @xmath137 ) than in the model without modification ( @xmath138 ) , thus enhancing the @xmath21-rich freeze - out compared with the standard model . as a result ,
the sc / fe and ti / fe ratios are particularly enhanced .
figure [ fig : yelow]a shows that the sc / fe and ti / fe ratios in the emp stars can be better reproduced by the model of @xmath139 and @xmath140 with the `` low - density '' modification , whose presupernova density is reduced by a factor of 2 .
here we applied the @xmath8 modification and the same @xmath45 as in the models without the @xmath8 modification .
the other hn models with both the @xmath8 and `` low - density '' modifications are also in good agreement with the abundance pattern of the emp stars ( figs .
[ fig : yelow]b-[fig : yelow]g ) . because the degree of `` low - density '' is likely to be different in each explosion
, we assume the `` low - density '' factor so that each model reproduces [ sc / fe ] of the emp stars as given in table [ tab : modelsyelow ] .
the imf - integrated yield , the parameters , and the yields of the individual sne are summarised in tables [ tab : imf ] and [ tab : modelsyelow]-[tab : yield2yelow ] .
the good agreements suggest that the @xmath8 and `` low - density '' modifications might actually be realized in the sn explosions . in the present study ,
we consider the global enhancement of entropy due to the jet - like or delayed explosion , but such high - entropy region is also realized locally in the neutrino - driven wind or the accretion disk .
neutrino - driven wind nucleosynthesis @xcite for @xmath141 and @xmath142 produces [ sc / fe ] ( @xmath143 ) being consistent with that of the emp stars but smaller [ co / fe ] and [ zn / fe ] than those of the emp stars ; for @xmath144 and @xmath145 , smaller [ sc / fe ] ( @xmath90 ) is produced than that of the emp stars .
accretion disk nucleosynthesis ( @xmath146 and @xmath147 , @xcite ) produces much larger [ sc / fe ] ( @xmath148 ) than that of the emp stars and does not produce simultaneously [ co / fe ] @xmath106 and [ zn / fe ] @xmath106 as observed in the emp stars .
the above models show that it seems difficult to reproduce the overall abundance pattern of the emp stars only with nucleosynthesis in the neutrino - driven wind or the accretion disk .
however , if some contributions from these sites can be added to our models , it could enhance sc / fe . in order to obtain
[ sc / fe ] @xmath149 , the sn ejecta should have @xmath150 @xcite .
when about @xmath151 of fe and little sc are ejected as in our model of @xmath152 and @xmath140 , [ sc / fe ] @xmath149 is obtained by the ejection of extra @xmath153 from either the neutrino - driven wind or the accretion disk .
figure [ fig : trendyelow ] shows the trends resulting from the @xmath8 modification made for all models and the `` low - density '' modification applied only for hn models .
each comparison between the model and the observation is shown in figures [ fig : ye]a-[fig : ye]c , and [ fig : yelow]a-[fig : yelow]g . while [ ( k , cr)/fe ] still do not explain the observations well , the trends of [ ( sc , ti , mn , co)/fe ] are in much better agreement with the observations than the models without the modifications
. other elements also show good agreements and small scatters .
the sc / fe and ti / fe ratios in normal sn models are lower than the observations .
this is partly because the `` low - density '' modification is not applied to normal sne . to reproduce the observed high sc / fe and ti / fe ratios
, there might be some mechanisms to realize the high entropy ( @xmath137 ) even for normal sne . in this connection
, it is interesting to note that the recent x - ray flash grb 060218 was found to be associated with sn 2006aj ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
the properties of sn 2006aj are close to normal sne ; the progenitor s main - sequence mass and the explosion energy were estimated to be @xmath154 and @xmath155 @xcite .
this suggests that the `` low - density '' modification could be realized in some normal sne .
such explosions might contribute to enhance sc / fe and ti / fe .
[ cr / fe ] and [ mn / fe ] in our models are larger and smaller than @xcite , respectively , while [ co / fe ] is in good agreement with @xcite .
[ mn / fe ] could also be enhanced by the following @xmath134-process in the complete si - burning region and the subsequent radioactive decay : @xmath156 ( @xcite ; t. yoshida et al .
, in preparation ) .
in this paper we performed the hydrodynamical and nucleosynthesis calculations of pop iii 13
50 @xmath1 core - collapse sne and provided the yields by adopting the mixing - fallback model . we show that our yields are consistent with the observed abundance patterns of the emp and vmp stars @xcite .
the trends of [ x / fe ] vs. [ fe / h ] with small scatters can be reproduced by our models as a sequence resulting from the combination of different progenitors masses ( @xmath5 ) and explosion energies ( @xmath6 ) .
this is because we adopt the empirical relation that a larger amount of fe is ejected by massive hne ( @xmath113 ) than normal sne .
this indicates that the observed trends with small scatters do not necessarily mean the homogeneous mixing in the interstellar medium , but can be reproduced by the `` inhomogeneous '' chemical evolution model , in which the emp stars are enriched by the individual sne with different ( @xmath5 , @xmath6 ) . in our model ,
yields of more massive hne correspond to the emp stars with smaller [ fe / h ] ( @xmath7 ) .
we should stress that this is not because hne were dominant among pop iii sne , but because the second generation stars produced by pop iii core - collapse sne with higher explosion energies tend to have smaller [ fe / h ] as @xmath18 } \simeq \log_{10}\left({m({\rm fe})\over{{m_{\odot}}}}/{e_{\rm 51}^{6/7}}\right ) -c$ ] ( eq .
[ eq : snsf ] ) .
almost all stars in @xcite and @xcite can be reasonably well reproduced by core - collapse sne yields , but none by the pure pair - instability sn yields ( e.g. , @xcite ) . in other words ,
the emp stars in @xcite show no clear features of top - heavy imf .
further , the vmp stars ( [ fe / h ] @xmath72 ) can be well - reproduced by integrating the yields of pop iii sne over the salpeter s imf . this also implies that the imf of pop iii stars was not top - heavy , but approximately salpeter s . to constrain the imf of pop iii stars , we need more complete set of the observed data as well as inhomogeneous chemical evolution models which properly take into account our model , especially the @xmath157-[fe / h ] relation ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) . we also investigate the yields of the models with the @xmath8 and `` low - density '' modifications suggested in @xcite and
show that the yields are in better agreement with the observed abundance patterns than those without such modifications .
the good agreements suggest that such modifications might be realized in the actual core - collapse sn explosions .
we suggest that the @xmath8 and `` low - density '' modifications are actualized by the neutrino effects and the jet - like or delayed explosions , respectively .
the neutrino - driven wind and the accretion disk are other possible nucleosynthesis sites for sc because they can actualize the @xmath8 ( @xmath121 ) and `` low - density '' modifications
. however , nucleosynthesis in the neutrino - driven wind and the accretion disk might not be dominant sites of fe synthesis because they can not reproduce the abundance ratios among the fe - peak elements of the emp stars .
we thus suggest that the progenitor s presupernova nucleosynthesis and explosive nucleosynthesis are predominant synthesis sites of most elements , while some elements ( e.g. , sc , ti , mn , and co ) can be enhanced by the @xmath8 and `` low - density '' modifications .
we would like to thank c. kobayashi for valuable discussion .
the author n.t . is supported through the jsps ( japan society for the promotion of science ) research fellowship for young scientists .
this work has been supported in part by the grant - in - aid for scientific research ( 17030005 , 17033002 , 18104003 , 18540231 ) and the 21st century coe program ( quest ) from the jsps and mext of japan .
the mixing - fallback model proposed by @xcite and @xcite can successfully reproduce the abundance patterns of the hyper metal - poor ( he01075240 : @xcite , he13272326 : @xcite ) and emp @xcite stars .
the mixing - fallback model assumes the following situation : first , inner materials are mixed by some mixing process ( e.g. , rayleigh - taylor instabilities and/or aspherical explosions ) during the shockwave propagations in the star ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
later , some fraction of materials in the mixing region undergoes fallback onto the central remnant by gravity ( e.g. , @xcite ) , and the rests are ejected into interstellar space .
the fallback mass depends on the explosion energy , the gravitational potential , and asphericity .
the mixing - fallback model can solve a problem associated with the ratios between the fe - peak elements and fe in the emp stars , [ ( fe - peak)/fe ] .
the large zn / fe ratio implies an energetic explosion as a hn and a deep mass cut , but these lead to eject too large amount of fe to reproduce small [ fe / h ] and the large enough [ @xmath21/fe ] ratio , if ones assume that the whole material above the mass cut are ejected .
however , one can realize both the deep mass cut and the small amount of ejected fe with the mixing - fallback model . in the spherical models , @xcite found that the fallback takes place if the explosion energy is less than @xmath158 for the 25 @xmath1 star and obtained a relation between @xmath159 and the final remnant mass , @xmath48
, i.e. , smaller @xmath159 leads to a larger @xmath48 .
for example , @xmath160 and @xmath161 for the 25 @xmath1 star lead to the final remnant mass @xmath162 and @xmath163 , respectively .
it is difficult for a spherical hn explosion to initiate a fallback , although for a larger star the fallback can occur even for a larger explosion energy because of a deeper gravitational potential .
for instance , the fallback is found to occur for @xmath164 in the 50 @xmath1 star .
however , fallback can take place not only for relatively low energy explosions but for very energetic jet - like explosions @xcite .
in fact , @xcite have simulated jet - induced explosions and showed that the resultant yields can reproduce the abundance patterns of the emp stars as the mixing - fallback model .
the mixing - fallback model mimics such aspherical explosions , although the spherical model tends to require larger explosion energies than the jet model to obtain similar yields @xcite .
* @xmath45 : initial mass cut , which is corresponding to the inner boundary of the mixing region .
* @xmath46 : outer boundary of the mixing region .
* @xmath47 : a fraction of matter ejected from the mixed region .
it determines [ @xmath21/fe ] .
figures [ fig : mf]ab illustrate these parameters for spherical and aspherical models .
the final remnant mass , @xmath48 , is determined by the above three parameters @xmath165 in this paper , we determine these parameters as follows .
* @xmath45 : the initial mass cut is adopted so that [ zn / fe ] attains maximum , thus locates at the bottom of the @xmath166 layer ( fig .
[ fig:25e20ad ] ) where is very close to the surface of fe core of the progenitors .
figure [ fig:25e20ad ] shows the abundance distribution of the 25 @xmath1 star with @xmath140 around the complete si burning region .
for population iii sne , the dominant isotope of zn is @xmath44zn , which is the decay product of @xmath44ge .
@xmath44zn is mostly produced in the complete si burning region where @xmath167 and the zn / fe ratio decreases for lower @xmath8 ( see fig . 4 in @xcite ) .
therefore , as the mass cut decreases , [ zn / fe ] in the ejecta first increases and then decreases .
this choice of @xmath45 tends to give a smaller estimate of @xmath159 to fit to the observed zn / fe , because zn / fe is larger for larger @xmath159 . * @xmath46 and @xmath47 : we study two case as follows .
case b is an additional model for massive star models .
the abundance distribution of the 30 @xmath1 , @xmath168 model is shown in figure [ fig:30e20ad ] illustrating the mixing region in both cases .
+ case `` a '' : : : we assume that the mixing occurs in the si burning region and thus @xmath46 is where @xmath169 .
@xmath47 is chosen to yield [ o / fe ] @xmath51 . for most case , @xmath170 .
case `` b '' : : : for the @xmath171 models , we consider another case . in this case , we assume that @xmath46 is 2/3 of the o - rich layer , and determine @xmath47 so that [ mg / fe ] @xmath52 to be consistent with the [ fe / h ] @xmath55 stars in @xcite . in this paper , we consider two cases a and b for @xmath172 stars .
[ mg / fe ] in case b is smaller than in case a but the ejected fe mass in case b is smaller than in case a ( tables [ tab : models ] , [ tab : modelsye ] , and [ tab : modelsyelow ] ) .
this is because case b has larger amount of fallback , i.e. , larger @xmath46 and smaller @xmath47 , than case a. such large fallback which reaches the mg - rich layer decreases the amount of ejected mg and leads to a smaller mg / fe for case b than case a in spite of a smaller amount of ejected fe .
the observed hne have variations of the ejected fe mass .
case a corresponds to typical hne like sn 1998bw that ejected @xmath173 @xcite and case b corresponds to hne like sn 1997ef that ejected @xmath174 @xcite
. alternative interpretation of [ mg / fe ] @xmath54 is to eject a larger amount of fe than case a for the same amount of ejected mg . in this case , because of larger fe , larger explosion energies ( @xmath175 ) are needed for this model to reproduce the small [ fe / h ] ( @xmath176 ) , as long as [ fe / h ] is determined by equation ( [ eq : snsf ] ) ( i.e. , the same constant @xmath64 ) of the sn - induced star formation model .
the explosion energies are considerably larger than those of pop i sne .
we thus do not consider such a possibility in this paper .
cccccccccccc 13 & 1 & 0.07 & 0.09 & @xmath1772.55 & @xmath1770.08 & 0.37 & 1.57 & & & 1 & fig . [ fig : vmp]a + 15 & 1 & 0.07 & 0.07 & @xmath1772.55 & 0.15 & 0.27 & 1.48 & & & 1 & fig .
[ fig : vmp]b + 18 & 1 & 0.07 & 0.16 & @xmath1772.55 & 0.41 & 0.63 & 1.65 & & & 1 & fig .
[ fig : vmp]c + 20 & 10 & 0.08 & 0.17 & @xmath1773.34 & 0.50 & 0.58 & 1.90 & 1.52 & 2.05 & 0.28 & fig .
[ fig : emp]a + 25 & 5 & 0.11 & 0.14 & @xmath1772.97 & 0.50 & 0.41 & 2.45 & 1.79 & 2.69 & 0.26 & fig . [ fig:25e5 ] + 25 & 10 & 0.10 & 0.15 & @xmath1773.27 & 0.50 & 0.48 & 2.86 & 1.79 & 3.07 & 0.16 & fig .
[ fig : emp]b + 25f & 1 & 0.0008 & 0.03 & @xmath1774.50 & 2.40 & 1.81 & 4.20 & 1.79 & 4.21 & 0.004 & fig .
[ fig : faint ] + 30a & 20 & 0.16 & 0.22 & @xmath1773.31 & 0.50 & 0.41 & 3.27 & 1.65 & 3.59 & 0.17 & fig .
[ fig : emp]c + 30b & 20 & 0.05 & 0.04 & @xmath1773.81 & 0.55 & 0.20 & 6.73 & 1.65 & 7.01 & 0.05 & fig . [ fig : emp]c + 40a & 30 & 0.26 & 0.34 & @xmath1773.25 & 0.50 & 0.39 & 5.53 & 2.24 & 6.00 & 0.12 & fig .
[ fig : emp]d + 40b & 30 & 0.11 & 0.09 & @xmath1773.63 & 0.46 & 0.20 & 10.70 & 2.24 & 11.16 & 0.05 & fig .
[ fig : emp]d + 50a & 40 & 0.36 & 0.57 & @xmath1773.22 & 0.50 & 0.47 & 3.76 & 1.89 & 4.49 & 0.28 & fig .
[ fig : emp]e + 50b & 40 & 0.23 & 0.20 & @xmath1773.40 & 0.35 & 0.20 & 11.01 & 1.89 & 13.05 & 0.18 & fig .
[ fig : emp]e + crrrrrrrrrrrrr p & 6.59e+00 & 7.58e+00 & 8.43e+00 & 8.77e+00 & 1.06e+01 & 1.06e+01 & 1.06e+01 & 1.17e+01 & 1.17e+01 & 1.40e+01 & 1.40e+01 & 1.63e+01 & 1.63e+01 + d & 1.49e@xmath17716 & 1.69e@xmath17716 & 1.28e@xmath17716 & 8.66e@xmath17717 & 2.04e@xmath17716 & 2.06e@xmath17716 & 2.02e@xmath17716 & 1.09e@xmath17714 & 1.09e@xmath17714 & 1.66e@xmath17714 & 1.66e@xmath17714 & 1.24e@xmath17715 & 1.24e@xmath17715 + @xmath178he & 4.12e@xmath17705 & 4.09e@xmath17705 & 3.33e@xmath17705 & 4.76e@xmath17705 & 2.11e@xmath17704 & 2.11e@xmath17704 & 2.11e@xmath17704 & 2.06e@xmath17704 & 2.06e@xmath17704 & 2.56e@xmath17705 & 2.56e@xmath17705 & 2.86e@xmath17705 & 2.86e@xmath17705 + @xmath179he & 4.01e+00 & 4.40e+00 & 5.42e+00 & 5.96e+00 & 8.03e+00 & 8.02e+00 & 8.03e+00 & 9.54e+00 & 9.51e+00 & 1.18e+01 & 1.18e+01 & 1.56e+01 & 1.55e+01 + @xmath180li & 3.29e@xmath17723 & 1.28e@xmath17722 & 4.52e@xmath17723 & 1.36e@xmath17722 & 2.28e@xmath17720 & 4.26e@xmath17720 & 2.68e@xmath17721 & 3.50e@xmath17717 & 3.50e@xmath17717 & 5.39e@xmath17717 & 5.39e@xmath17717 & 2.02e@xmath17718 & 2.02e@xmath17718 + @xmath181li & 2.17e@xmath17710 & 2.94e@xmath17710 & 7.34e@xmath17711 & 2.79e@xmath17710 & 5.68e@xmath17709 & 5.68e@xmath17709 & 5.68e@xmath17709 & 2.36e@xmath17708 & 2.36e@xmath17708 & 3.42e@xmath17711 & 3.42e@xmath17711 & 8.78e@xmath17712 & 8.78e@xmath17712 + @xmath182be & 1.77e@xmath17720 & 3.22e@xmath17722 & 1.05e@xmath17722 & 4.83e@xmath17720 & 5.00e@xmath17717 & 3.69e@xmath17717 & 1.24e@xmath17717 & 3.09e@xmath17718 & 3.09e@xmath17718 & 9.03e@xmath17718 & 9.03e@xmath17718 & 6.04e@xmath17717 & 6.04e@xmath17717 + @xmath183b & 3.16e@xmath17721 & 3.92e@xmath17720 & 2.86e@xmath17720 & 2.88e@xmath17719 & 2.79e@xmath17715 & 2.05e@xmath17713 & 2.67e@xmath17718 & 1.05e@xmath17714 & 1.05e@xmath17714 & 9.41e@xmath17715 & 9.41e@xmath17715 & 1.72e@xmath17717 & 7.85e@xmath17718 + @xmath184b & 2.89e@xmath17716 & 3.55e@xmath17716 & 1.59e@xmath17714 & 1.19e@xmath17715 & 6.09e@xmath17714 & 5.27e@xmath17713 & 1.90e@xmath17716 & 9.61e@xmath17714 & 9.16e@xmath17714 & 9.41e@xmath17713 & 9.40e@xmath17713 & 2.49e@xmath17711 & 1.62e@xmath17711 + @xmath88c & 7.41e@xmath17702 & 1.72e@xmath17701 & 2.18e@xmath17701 & 1.90e@xmath17701 & 2.79e@xmath17701 & 2.67e@xmath17701 & 2.74e@xmath17701 & 3.16e@xmath17701 & 2.86e@xmath17701 & 3.72e@xmath17701 & 3.51e@xmath17701 & 1.56e+00 & 1.17e+00 + @xmath89c & 8.39e@xmath17708 & 6.21e@xmath17708 & 2.63e@xmath17709 & 1.18e@xmath17708 & 2.90e@xmath17708 & 6.94e@xmath17708 & 1.05e@xmath17708 & 6.32e@xmath17708 & 6.03e@xmath17708 & 8.18e@xmath17708 & 7.84e@xmath17708 & 2.38e@xmath17707 & 1.70e@xmath17707 + @xmath185n & 1.83e@xmath17703 & 1.86e@xmath17703 & 1.89e@xmath17704 & 5.42e@xmath17705 & 5.92e@xmath17704 & 5.96e@xmath17704 & 5.91e@xmath17704 & 4.18e@xmath17705 & 4.17e@xmath17705 & 3.39e@xmath17706 & 3.33e@xmath17706 & 4.38e@xmath17704 & 4.37e@xmath17704 + @xmath186n & 6.38e@xmath17708 & 6.86e@xmath17708 & 2.40e@xmath17708 & 2.96e@xmath17708 & 1.64e@xmath17707 & 1.75e@xmath17707 & 7.17e@xmath17708 & 2.20e@xmath17707 & 1.16e@xmath17707 & 6.54e@xmath17707 & 6.51e@xmath17707 & 3.33e@xmath17707 & 8.27e@xmath17708 + @xmath136o & 4.50e@xmath17701 & 7.73e@xmath17701 & 1.38e+00 & 2.03e+00 & 2.60e+00 & 2.37e+00 & 1.52e+00 & 3.92e+00 & 1.37e+00 & 6.32e+00 & 2.40e+00 & 8.81e+00 & 4.02e+00 + @xmath187o & 1.69e@xmath17706 & 1.57e@xmath17706 & 2.79e@xmath17707 & 7.13e@xmath17708 & 1.49e@xmath17706 & 1.49e@xmath17706 & 1.48e@xmath17706 & 3.81e@xmath17708 & 2.64e@xmath17708 & 1.23e@xmath17708 & 8.65e@xmath17709 & 8.60e@xmath17706 & 8.56e@xmath17706 + @xmath188o & 5.79e@xmath17708 & 4.89e@xmath17706 & 4.63e@xmath17706 & 2.33e@xmath17708 & 4.66e@xmath17707 & 3.87e@xmath17707 & 6.73e@xmath17707 & 5.03e@xmath17707 & 5.02e@xmath17707 & 2.93e@xmath17707 & 2.92e@xmath17707 & 6.00e@xmath17706 & 5.99e@xmath17706 + @xmath189f & 1.17e@xmath17710 & 1.97e@xmath17709 & 7.91e@xmath17709 & 2.12e@xmath17709 & 1.43e@xmath17709 & 1.67e@xmath17709 & 1.01e@xmath17709 & 7.88e@xmath17709 & 6.41e@xmath17709 & 1.17e@xmath17707 & 1.16e@xmath17707 & 8.49e@xmath17709 & 4.06e@xmath17709 + @xmath190ne & 1.53e@xmath17702 & 3.27e@xmath17701 & 4.94e@xmath17701 & 7.49e@xmath17701 & 3.91e@xmath17701 & 2.85e@xmath17701 & 3.16e@xmath17701 & 5.20e@xmath17701 & 2.60e@xmath17701 & 2.64e@xmath17701 & 2.19e@xmath17701 & 2.48e+00 & 1.30e+00 + @xmath191ne & 5.42e@xmath17707 & 3.76e@xmath17705 & 9.12e@xmath17705 & 3.58e@xmath17705 & 1.47e@xmath17705 & 1.22e@xmath17705 & 3.05e@xmath17706 & 3.51e@xmath17705 & 2.26e@xmath17705 & 1.41e@xmath17705 & 1.07e@xmath17705 & 2.40e@xmath17704 & 1.14e@xmath17704 + @xmath192ne & 1.98e@xmath17707 & 1.61e@xmath17705 & 2.57e@xmath17705 & 5.51e@xmath17705 & 1.30e@xmath17705 & 8.62e@xmath17706 & 1.27e@xmath17705 & 3.52e@xmath17705 & 1.98e@xmath17705 & 1.66e@xmath17705 & 1.45e@xmath17705 & 2.10e@xmath17704 & 1.08e@xmath17704 + @xmath193na & 1.44e@xmath17704 & 2.45e@xmath17703 & 2.08e@xmath17703 & 2.31e@xmath17703 & 6.74e@xmath17704 & 4.42e@xmath17704 & 6.61e@xmath17704 & 7.36e@xmath17704 & 3.24e@xmath17704 & 3.28e@xmath17704 & 1.66e@xmath17704 & 4.27e@xmath17703 & 1.99e@xmath17703 + @xmath194 mg & 8.62e@xmath17702 & 6.82e@xmath17702 & 1.57e@xmath17701 & 1.65e@xmath17701 & 1.43e@xmath17701 & 1.53e@xmath17701 & 2.70e@xmath17702 & 2.17e@xmath17701 & 4.20e@xmath17702 & 3.37e@xmath17701 & 8.99e@xmath17702 & 5.70e@xmath17701 & 1.97e@xmath17701 + @xmath195 mg & 1.56e@xmath17704 & 2.98e@xmath17704 & 5.83e@xmath17704 & 1.07e@xmath17704 & 4.52e@xmath17705 & 4.57e@xmath17705 & 1.29e@xmath17705 & 1.45e@xmath17704 & 9.00e@xmath17705 & 5.95e@xmath17704 & 4.11e@xmath17704 & 3.10e@xmath17704 & 1.16e@xmath17704 + @xmath196 mg & 7.07e@xmath17705 & 3.98e@xmath17704 & 8.73e@xmath17704 & 2.09e@xmath17704 & 4.31e@xmath17705 & 3.89e@xmath17705 & 1.48e@xmath17705 & 8.00e@xmath17705 & 2.62e@xmath17705 & 6.90e@xmath17705 & 1.22e@xmath17705 & 2.32e@xmath17704 & 9.70e@xmath17705 + @xmath196al & 9.92e@xmath17707 & 1.11e@xmath17706 & 3.33e@xmath17706 & 1.02e@xmath17706 & 1.21e@xmath17706 & 1.28e@xmath17706 & 5.34e@xmath17709 & 2.92e@xmath17706 & 1.33e@xmath17706 & 3.80e@xmath17705 & 3.43e@xmath17705 & 5.46e@xmath17706 & 1.40e@xmath17706 + @xmath197al & 3.78e@xmath17703 & 1.37e@xmath17703 & 3.14e@xmath17703 & 1.50e@xmath17703 & 8.59e@xmath17704 & 8.93e@xmath17704 & 9.78e@xmath17705 & 1.55e@xmath17703 & 1.59e@xmath17704 & 7.52e@xmath17703 & 1.34e@xmath17703 & 3.29e@xmath17703 & 8.07e@xmath17704 + @xmath198si & 8.08e@xmath17702 & 7.18e@xmath17702 & 1.07e@xmath17701 & 9.15e@xmath17702 & 2.21e@xmath17701 & 1.97e@xmath17701 & 2.07e@xmath17703 & 2.44e@xmath17701 & 3.11e@xmath17702 & 7.17e@xmath17701 & 2.28e@xmath17701 & 3.61e@xmath17701 & 1.18e@xmath17701 + @xmath199si & 7.50e@xmath17704 & 2.38e@xmath17704 & 4.36e@xmath17704 & 2.89e@xmath17704 & 5.12e@xmath17704 & 5.23e@xmath17704 & 3.96e@xmath17706 & 8.85e@xmath17704 & 4.89e@xmath17705 & 3.72e@xmath17703 & 1.29e@xmath17703 & 9.32e@xmath17704 & 1.80e@xmath17704 + @xmath200si & 1.42e@xmath17703 & 1.49e@xmath17704 & 3.50e@xmath17704 & 1.12e@xmath17704 & 5.90e@xmath17705 & 6.13e@xmath17705 & 2.66e@xmath17706 & 1.47e@xmath17704 & 9.97e@xmath17706 & 2.82e@xmath17703 & 4.83e@xmath17704 & 2.10e@xmath17704 & 5.04e@xmath17705 + @xmath201p & 4.88e@xmath17704 & 5.66e@xmath17705 & 1.31e@xmath17704 & 7.30e@xmath17705 & 5.44e@xmath17705 & 5.03e@xmath17705 & 1.68e@xmath17706 & 1.18e@xmath17704 & 7.87e@xmath17706 & 1.01e@xmath17703 & 2.24e@xmath17704 & 1.75e@xmath17704 & 4.26e@xmath17705 + @xmath202s & 2.36e@xmath17702 & 3.24e@xmath17702 & 4.45e@xmath17702 & 3.71e@xmath17702 & 1.00e@xmath17701 & 7.52e@xmath17702 & 8.10e@xmath17704 & 8.49e@xmath17702 & 1.49e@xmath17702 & 2.60e@xmath17701 & 6.11e@xmath17702 & 1.41e@xmath17701 & 6.23e@xmath17702 + @xmath203s & 9.00e@xmath17705 & 7.48e@xmath17705 & 9.49e@xmath17705 & 1.31e@xmath17704 & 2.06e@xmath17704 & 1.99e@xmath17704 & 9.32e@xmath17707 & 3.02e@xmath17704 & 1.59e@xmath17705 & 8.44e@xmath17704 & 1.29e@xmath17704 & 3.89e@xmath17704 & 7.15e@xmath17705 + @xmath204s & 2.79e@xmath17704 & 2.01e@xmath17704 & 2.59e@xmath17704 & 1.46e@xmath17704 & 5.13e@xmath17705 & 2.47e@xmath17705 & 5.83e@xmath17707 & 2.70e@xmath17704 & 1.78e@xmath17705 & 2.08e@xmath17703 & 1.32e@xmath17704 & 6.60e@xmath17705 & 2.92e@xmath17705 + @xmath205s & 1.48e@xmath17708 & 1.43e@xmath17709 & 5.34e@xmath17709 & 8.33e@xmath17710 & 6.69e@xmath17711 & 5.25e@xmath17711 & 1.35e@xmath17712 & 1.41e@xmath17709 & 7.70e@xmath17711 & 5.04e@xmath17708 & 2.63e@xmath17709 & 4.52e@xmath17711 & 8.39e@xmath17712 + @xmath206cl & 5.48e@xmath17705 & 1.44e@xmath17705 & 2.42e@xmath17705 & 3.28e@xmath17705 & 2.01e@xmath17705 & 1.68e@xmath17705 & 1.83e@xmath17707 & 4.51e@xmath17705 & 6.11e@xmath17706 & 1.80e@xmath17704 & 2.46e@xmath17705 & 6.89e@xmath17705 & 3.30e@xmath17705 + @xmath207cl & 3.11e@xmath17706 & 5.62e@xmath17706 & 7.80e@xmath17706 & 1.52e@xmath17705 & 2.26e@xmath17705 & 2.02e@xmath17705 & 2.21e@xmath17707 & 2.37e@xmath17705 & 1.29e@xmath17706 & 7.92e@xmath17705 & 4.28e@xmath17706 & 3.29e@xmath17705 & 6.06e@xmath17706 + @xmath205ar & 3.18e@xmath17703 & 5.53e@xmath17703 & 7.26e@xmath17703 & 6.04e@xmath17703 & 1.67e@xmath17702 & 1.15e@xmath17702 & 1.54e@xmath17704 & 1.18e@xmath17702 & 2.71e@xmath17703 & 3.62e@xmath17702 & 6.08e@xmath17703 & 2.29e@xmath17702 & 1.23e@xmath17702 + @xmath208ar & 5.23e@xmath17705 & 6.18e@xmath17705 & 1.45e@xmath17704 & 6.35e@xmath17705 & 4.55e@xmath17705 & 8.35e@xmath17706 & 6.11e@xmath17707 & 9.06e@xmath17705 & 5.58e@xmath17706 & 7.83e@xmath17704 & 4.15e@xmath17705 & 1.81e@xmath17705 & 7.26e@xmath17706 + @xmath209ar & 8.01e@xmath17711 & 1.78e@xmath17711 & 3.95e@xmath17711 & 3.77e@xmath17711 & 5.17e@xmath17712 & 3.77e@xmath17712 & 1.40e@xmath17713 & 1.87e@xmath17711 & 2.69e@xmath17712 & 2.68e@xmath17710 & 1.99e@xmath17711 & 1.38e@xmath17712 & 3.41e@xmath17713 + @xmath210k & 5.14e@xmath17706 & 7.23e@xmath17706 & 1.59e@xmath17705 & 1.06e@xmath17705 & 1.61e@xmath17705 & 8.69e@xmath17706 & 2.08e@xmath17707 & 2.05e@xmath17705 & 2.88e@xmath17706 & 1.31e@xmath17704 & 1.07e@xmath17705 & 2.52e@xmath17705 & 1.47e@xmath17705 + @xmath209k & 1.14e@xmath17709 & 9.07e@xmath17710 & 1.84e@xmath17709 & 3.95e@xmath17709 & 1.82e@xmath17709 & 4.46e@xmath17710 & 2.89e@xmath17711 & 2.52e@xmath17709 & 1.32e@xmath17710 & 1.18e@xmath17708 & 6.14e@xmath17710 & 7.09e@xmath17710 & 1.30e@xmath17710 + @xmath211k & 3.72e@xmath17707 & 7.43e@xmath17707 & 1.51e@xmath17706 & 2.63e@xmath17706 & 5.94e@xmath17706 & 4.00e@xmath17706 & 7.98e@xmath17708 & 3.63e@xmath17706 & 2.04e@xmath17707 & 2.12e@xmath17705 & 1.14e@xmath17706 & 1.72e@xmath17706 & 4.78e@xmath17707 + @xmath209ca & 2.82e@xmath17703 & 4.72e@xmath17703 & 6.14e@xmath17703 & 4.39e@xmath17703 & 1.43e@xmath17702 & 9.20e@xmath17703 & 1.36e@xmath17704 & 8.77e@xmath17703 & 2.45e@xmath17703 & 2.97e@xmath17702 & 5.60e@xmath17703 & 1.87e@xmath17702 & 1.20e@xmath17702 + @xmath212ca & 9.80e@xmath17707 & 1.21e@xmath17706 & 3.15e@xmath17706 & 1.34e@xmath17706 & 1.11e@xmath17706 & 1.76e@xmath17707 & 1.65e@xmath17708 & 1.62e@xmath17706 & 8.48e@xmath17708 & 1.97e@xmath17705 & 1.02e@xmath17706 & 2.29e@xmath17707 & 7.46e@xmath17708 + @xmath213ca & 6.66e@xmath17708 & 4.76e@xmath17708 & 3.48e@xmath17708 & 2.59e@xmath17707 & 4.68e@xmath17708 & 7.12e@xmath17708 & 3.33e@xmath17710 & 1.71e@xmath17707 & 5.33e@xmath17708 & 1.40e@xmath17707 & 5.32e@xmath17708 & 7.31e@xmath17707 & 4.75e@xmath17707 + @xmath42ca & 1.70e@xmath17705 & 2.17e@xmath17705 & 1.40e@xmath17705 & 1.25e@xmath17704 & 4.26e@xmath17705 & 6.82e@xmath17705 & 1.82e@xmath17707 & 1.80e@xmath17704 & 5.67e@xmath17705 & 1.76e@xmath17704 & 7.16e@xmath17705 & 6.08e@xmath17704 & 3.95e@xmath17704 + @xmath214ca & 1.07e@xmath17712 & 1.75e@xmath17712 & 9.26e@xmath17712 & 1.15e@xmath17711 & 2.61e@xmath17712 & 1.80e@xmath17711 & 1.18e@xmath17713 & 9.25e@xmath17712 & 7.64e@xmath17712 & 3.69e@xmath17711 & 2.45e@xmath17711 & 2.66e@xmath17713 & 6.72e@xmath17714 + @xmath43ca & 1.99e@xmath17717 & 4.21e@xmath17714 & 4.21e@xmath17716 & 5.87e@xmath17716 & 8.89e@xmath17712 & 8.91e@xmath17712 & 9.58e@xmath17712 & 8.16e@xmath17713 & 8.15e@xmath17713 & 1.27e@xmath17711 & 1.27e@xmath17711 & 1.56e@xmath17713 & 5.63e@xmath17714 + @xmath215sc & 2.16e@xmath17708 & 3.53e@xmath17708 & 4.82e@xmath17708 & 1.44e@xmath17707 & 1.77e@xmath17707 & 1.24e@xmath17707 & 2.44e@xmath17709 & 6.09e@xmath17708 & 1.06e@xmath17708 & 6.15e@xmath17707 & 4.34e@xmath17708 & 6.31e@xmath17708 & 3.69e@xmath17708 + @xmath214ti & 6.21e@xmath17706 & 2.56e@xmath17706 & 3.41e@xmath17706 & 5.59e@xmath17706 & 2.21e@xmath17706 & 2.88e@xmath17706 & 8.20e@xmath17709 & 6.13e@xmath17706 & 1.80e@xmath17706 & 1.11e@xmath17705 & 1.99e@xmath17706 & 1.40e@xmath17705 & 9.07e@xmath17706 + @xmath216ti & 8.72e@xmath17706 & 3.68e@xmath17706 & 4.68e@xmath17706 & 9.77e@xmath17706 & 8.14e@xmath17706 & 9.89e@xmath17706 & 2.42e@xmath17708 & 2.06e@xmath17705 & 6.47e@xmath17706 & 2.59e@xmath17705 & 1.08e@xmath17705 & 5.85e@xmath17705 & 3.80e@xmath17705 + @xmath43ti & 6.32e@xmath17705 & 8.94e@xmath17705 & 9.35e@xmath17705 & 1.59e@xmath17704 & 1.37e@xmath17704 & 1.41e@xmath17704 & 1.09e@xmath17706 & 2.88e@xmath17704 & 9.07e@xmath17705 & 3.53e@xmath17704 & 1.47e@xmath17704 & 7.84e@xmath17704 & 5.09e@xmath17704 + @xmath217ti & 2.24e@xmath17706 & 2.79e@xmath17706 & 9.83e@xmath17707 & 2.65e@xmath17706 & 1.89e@xmath17706 & 2.22e@xmath17706 & 1.02e@xmath17708 & 3.44e@xmath17706 & 1.08e@xmath17706 & 5.00e@xmath17706 & 1.89e@xmath17706 & 3.93e@xmath17706 & 2.55e@xmath17706 + @xmath218ti & 1.18e@xmath17712 & 9.24e@xmath17713 & 1.62e@xmath17712 & 8.98e@xmath17713 & 1.92e@xmath17712 & 1.96e@xmath17712 & 5.20e@xmath17713 & 2.49e@xmath17712 & 2.09e@xmath17712 & 3.37e@xmath17711 & 2.94e@xmath17711 & 1.45e@xmath17712 & 5.46e@xmath17713 + @xmath218v & 1.36e@xmath17711 & 1.04e@xmath17711 & 3.08e@xmath17711 & 1.44e@xmath17711 & 7.71e@xmath17712 & 2.13e@xmath17712 & 2.17e@xmath17713 & 9.03e@xmath17712 & 7.15e@xmath17713 & 1.20e@xmath17710 & 2.76e@xmath17711 & 1.14e@xmath17712 & 2.83e@xmath17713 + @xmath219v & 1.63e@xmath17705 & 8.53e@xmath17706 & 8.97e@xmath17706 & 2.36e@xmath17705 & 1.01e@xmath17705 & 1.59e@xmath17705 & 1.74e@xmath17708 & 3.24e@xmath17705 & 1.02e@xmath17705 & 3.06e@xmath17705 & 1.26e@xmath17705 & 7.13e@xmath17705 & 4.63e@xmath17705 + @xmath218cr & 1.02e@xmath17705 & 7.43e@xmath17706 & 6.90e@xmath17706 & 8.43e@xmath17706 & 2.89e@xmath17706 & 2.79e@xmath17706 & 1.70e@xmath17708 & 5.18e@xmath17706 & 1.40e@xmath17706 & 2.57e@xmath17705 & 3.29e@xmath17706 & 9.36e@xmath17706 & 6.06e@xmath17706 + @xmath220cr & 8.66e@xmath17704 & 1.17e@xmath17703 & 1.35e@xmath17703 & 6.79e@xmath17704 & 1.55e@xmath17703 & 1.30e@xmath17703 & 1.47e@xmath17705 & 1.61e@xmath17703 & 5.06e@xmath17704 & 2.82e@xmath17703 & 1.18e@xmath17703 & 3.13e@xmath17703 & 2.03e@xmath17703 + @xmath221cr & 4.97e@xmath17705 & 5.66e@xmath17705 & 1.87e@xmath17705 & 3.03e@xmath17705 & 3.18e@xmath17705 & 4.17e@xmath17705 & 1.60e@xmath17707 & 5.58e@xmath17705 & 1.76e@xmath17705 & 9.62e@xmath17705 & 3.94e@xmath17705 & 4.87e@xmath17705 & 3.16e@xmath17705 + @xmath222cr & 2.38e@xmath17710 & 3.84e@xmath17710 & 7.70e@xmath17710 & 1.35e@xmath17710 & 2.15e@xmath17710 & 3.78e@xmath17711 & 1.45e@xmath17712 & 9.63e@xmath17711 & 1.16e@xmath17711 & 3.51e@xmath17709 & 2.09e@xmath17710 & 6.61e@xmath17712 & 1.72e@xmath17712 + @xmath223mn & 1.39e@xmath17704 & 9.01e@xmath17705 & 3.74e@xmath17705 & 4.77e@xmath17705 & 3.70e@xmath17705 & 3.05e@xmath17705 & 1.44e@xmath17707 & 2.77e@xmath17705 & 8.68e@xmath17706 & 1.28e@xmath17704 & 4.80e@xmath17705 & 2.87e@xmath17705 & 1.86e@xmath17705 + @xmath222fe & 7.23e@xmath17704 & 5.00e@xmath17704 & 2.70e@xmath17704 & 1.85e@xmath17704 & 2.14e@xmath17704 & 8.50e@xmath17705 & 4.48e@xmath17707 & 3.94e@xmath17705 & 1.17e@xmath17705 & 1.31e@xmath17703 & 2.42e@xmath17704 & 2.51e@xmath17705 & 1.63e@xmath17705 + @xmath25fe & 7.00e@xmath17702 & 7.00e@xmath17702 & 7.00e@xmath17702 & 8.30e@xmath17702 & 1.07e@xmath17701 & 9.70e@xmath17702 & 7.93e@xmath17704 & 1.60e@xmath17701 & 5.04e@xmath17702 & 2.58e@xmath17701 & 1.08e@xmath17701 & 3.61e@xmath17701 & 2.34e@xmath17701 + @xmath224fe & 1.01e@xmath17703 & 1.08e@xmath17703 & 7.98e@xmath17704 & 1.77e@xmath17703 & 1.54e@xmath17703 & 1.55e@xmath17703 & 9.27e@xmath17706 & 3.03e@xmath17703 & 9.53e@xmath17704 & 4.17e@xmath17703 & 1.74e@xmath17703 & 7.35e@xmath17703 & 4.77e@xmath17703 + @xmath128fe & 5.96e@xmath17711 & 1.56e@xmath17710 & 2.76e@xmath17710 & 1.32e@xmath17710 & 5.82e@xmath17710 & 1.21e@xmath17710 & 3.68e@xmath17712 & 9.17e@xmath17711 & 6.18e@xmath17712 & 3.30e@xmath17709 & 2.33e@xmath17710 & 1.53e@xmath17711 & 4.52e@xmath17712 + @xmath225co & 1.75e@xmath17704 & 1.30e@xmath17704 & 1.49e@xmath17704 & 3.72e@xmath17704 & 1.96e@xmath17704 & 2.42e@xmath17704 & 4.36e@xmath17707 & 5.14e@xmath17704 & 1.62e@xmath17704 & 5.19e@xmath17704 & 2.16e@xmath17704 & 1.34e@xmath17703 & 8.70e@xmath17704 + @xmath128ni & 3.79e@xmath17704 & 3.55e@xmath17704 & 2.92e@xmath17704 & 8.45e@xmath17704 & 4.56e@xmath17704 & 5.44e@xmath17704 & 1.30e@xmath17706 & 1.15e@xmath17703 & 3.62e@xmath17704 & 1.28e@xmath17703 & 4.84e@xmath17704 & 2.76e@xmath17703 & 1.79e@xmath17703 + @xmath226ni & 2.14e@xmath17703 & 1.56e@xmath17703 & 1.44e@xmath17703 & 2.99e@xmath17703 & 2.74e@xmath17703 & 2.78e@xmath17703 & 1.89e@xmath17705 & 5.43e@xmath17703 & 1.71e@xmath17703 & 8.37e@xmath17703 & 3.49e@xmath17703 & 1.31e@xmath17702 & 8.49e@xmath17703 + @xmath227ni & 3.68e@xmath17705 & 3.03e@xmath17705 & 1.95e@xmath17705 & 6.27e@xmath17705 & 3.66e@xmath17705 & 4.19e@xmath17705 & 2.33e@xmath17707 & 8.54e@xmath17705 & 2.69e@xmath17705 & 9.87e@xmath17705 & 4.12e@xmath17705 & 2.18e@xmath17704 & 1.42e@xmath17704 + @xmath228ni & 1.92e@xmath17705 & 1.47e@xmath17705 & 1.23e@xmath17705 & 4.24e@xmath17705 & 2.25e@xmath17705 & 2.86e@xmath17705 & 2.00e@xmath17707 & 5.68e@xmath17705 & 1.79e@xmath17705 & 6.74e@xmath17705 & 2.81e@xmath17705 & 1.43e@xmath17704 & 9.31e@xmath17705 + @xmath44ni & 2.18e@xmath17715 & 2.67e@xmath17713 & 1.35e@xmath17714 & 8.70e@xmath17713 & 3.73e@xmath17712 & 9.60e@xmath17712 & 1.84e@xmath17712 & 3.38e@xmath17712 & 2.41e@xmath17712 & 2.46e@xmath17711 & 2.46e@xmath17711 & 6.72e@xmath17712 & 1.67e@xmath17712 + @xmath229cu & 4.86e@xmath17706 & 3.45e@xmath17706 & 3.58e@xmath17706 & 1.19e@xmath17705 & 6.41e@xmath17706 & 8.18e@xmath17706 & 2.02e@xmath17708 & 1.70e@xmath17705 & 5.34e@xmath17706 & 2.06e@xmath17705 & 8.60e@xmath17706 & 4.44e@xmath17705 & 2.88e@xmath17705 + @xmath230cu & 2.24e@xmath17707 & 2.33e@xmath17707 & 1.50e@xmath17707 & 7.21e@xmath17707 & 4.92e@xmath17707 & 5.77e@xmath17707 & 3.71e@xmath17709 & 1.37e@xmath17706 & 4.32e@xmath17707 & 1.86e@xmath17706 & 7.75e@xmath17707 & 4.37e@xmath17706 & 2.83e@xmath17706 + @xmath44zn & 1.26e@xmath17704 & 1.18e@xmath17704 & 8.72e@xmath17705 & 3.79e@xmath17704 & 2.04e@xmath17704 & 2.58e@xmath17704 & 9.63e@xmath17707 & 5.77e@xmath17704 & 1.82e@xmath17704 & 6.88e@xmath17704 & 2.87e@xmath17704 & 1.56e@xmath17703 & 1.01e@xmath17703 + @xmath231zn & 7.74e@xmath17707 & 1.03e@xmath17706 & 4.67e@xmath17707 & 5.05e@xmath17706 & 1.66e@xmath17706 & 2.44e@xmath17706 & 1.14e@xmath17708 & 6.98e@xmath17706 & 2.20e@xmath17706 & 6.90e@xmath17706 & 2.88e@xmath17706 & 2.29e@xmath17705 & 1.48e@xmath17705 + @xmath232zn & 1.73e@xmath17708 & 2.30e@xmath17708 & 1.20e@xmath17708 & 1.94e@xmath17707 & 2.66e@xmath17708 & 5.83e@xmath17708 & 3.99e@xmath17711 & 1.89e@xmath17707 & 5.95e@xmath17708 & 1.18e@xmath17707 & 4.93e@xmath17708 & 5.60e@xmath17707 & 3.63e@xmath17707 + @xmath233zn & 2.85e@xmath17708 & 3.16e@xmath17708 & 3.66e@xmath17708 & 8.93e@xmath17708 & 1.25e@xmath17707 & 1.21e@xmath17707 & 1.07e@xmath17709 & 2.67e@xmath17707 & 8.40e@xmath17708 & 4.86e@xmath17707 & 2.03e@xmath17707 & 8.45e@xmath17707 & 5.48e@xmath17707 + @xmath234zn & 3.04e@xmath17716 & 3.03e@xmath17714 & 7.45e@xmath17715 & 1.08e@xmath17713 & 2.04e@xmath17713 & 2.90e@xmath17712 & 1.82e@xmath17716 & 8.49e@xmath17713 & 6.00e@xmath17713 & 1.95e@xmath17711 & 1.95e@xmath17711 & 1.00e@xmath17711 & 5.36e@xmath17712 + @xmath235ga & 7.59e@xmath17709 & 5.50e@xmath17709 & 5.55e@xmath17709 & 1.77e@xmath17708 & 1.91e@xmath17708 & 2.12e@xmath17708 & 1.41e@xmath17710 & 4.04e@xmath17708 & 1.27e@xmath17708 & 8.95e@xmath17708 & 3.74e@xmath17708 & 1.08e@xmath17707 & 7.00e@xmath17708 + @xmath236ga & 1.00e@xmath17714 & 8.31e@xmath17714 & 3.35e@xmath17714 & 1.53e@xmath17712 & 1.60e@xmath17712 & 2.95e@xmath17711 & 1.05e@xmath17714 & 3.79e@xmath17712 & 2.38e@xmath17712 & 1.57e@xmath17710 & 1.57e@xmath17710 & 2.30e@xmath17711 & 1.06e@xmath17711 + @xmath234ge & 8.90e@xmath17709 & 6.27e@xmath17709 & 4.35e@xmath17709 & 2.41e@xmath17708 & 1.04e@xmath17708 & 1.41e@xmath17708 & 6.21e@xmath17711 & 2.92e@xmath17708 & 9.20e@xmath17709 & 3.75e@xmath17708 & 1.57e@xmath17708 & 8.09e@xmath17708 & 5.23e@xmath17708 + @xmath237ge & 7.42e@xmath17715 & 7.63e@xmath17713 & 5.90e@xmath17713 & 5.95e@xmath17712 & 2.83e@xmath17712 & 2.09e@xmath17711 & 3.85e@xmath17714 & 7.43e@xmath17712 & 3.96e@xmath17712 & 7.11e@xmath17711 & 7.10e@xmath17711 & 4.76e@xmath17711 & 1.59e@xmath17711 + @xmath238ge & 1.37e@xmath17714 & 1.84e@xmath17713 & 1.36e@xmath17713 & 3.73e@xmath17712 & 5.55e@xmath17712 & 3.95e@xmath17711 & 7.15e@xmath17715 & 6.59e@xmath17712 & 4.98e@xmath17712 & 9.15e@xmath17711 & 9.15e@xmath17711 & 3.12e@xmath17711 & 1.26e@xmath17711 + @xmath239ge & 3.77e@xmath17715 & 5.05e@xmath17714 & 5.80e@xmath17714 & 2.14e@xmath17713 & 1.16e@xmath17712 & 1.45e@xmath17711 & 9.96e@xmath17714 & 2.47e@xmath17712 & 1.68e@xmath17712 & 4.28e@xmath17711 & 4.28e@xmath17711 & 6.22e@xmath17712 & 1.98e@xmath17712 crrrrrrrrrrrrr @xmath192na & 1.51e@xmath17707 & 7.70e@xmath17706 & 1.68e@xmath17705 & 4.65e@xmath17705 & 9.97e@xmath17706 & 6.54e@xmath17706 & 8.98e@xmath17706 & 2.70e@xmath17705 & 1.34e@xmath17705 & 1.37e@xmath17705 & 1.19e@xmath17705 & 1.77e@xmath17704 & 9.12e@xmath17705 + @xmath196al & 9.80e@xmath17707 & 1.10e@xmath17706 & 3.32e@xmath17706 & 8.93e@xmath17707 & 1.21e@xmath17706 & 1.26e@xmath17706 & 5.34e@xmath17709 & 2.87e@xmath17706 & 1.32e@xmath17706 & 2.13e@xmath17705 & 1.76e@xmath17705 & 5.34e@xmath17706 & 1.32e@xmath17706 + @xmath211ca & 3.72e@xmath17707 & 7.42e@xmath17707 & 1.51e@xmath17706 & 2.63e@xmath17706 & 5.94e@xmath17706 & 4.00e@xmath17706 & 7.98e@xmath17708 & 3.63e@xmath17706 & 2.04e@xmath17707 & 2.12e@xmath17705 & 1.14e@xmath17706 & 1.72e@xmath17706 & 4.78e@xmath17707 + @xmath42ti & 1.70e@xmath17705 & 2.17e@xmath17705 & 1.40e@xmath17705 & 1.25e@xmath17704 & 4.26e@xmath17705 & 6.82e@xmath17705 & 1.82e@xmath17707 & 1.80e@xmath17704 & 5.67e@xmath17705 & 1.76e@xmath17704 & 7.16e@xmath17705 & 6.08e@xmath17704 & 3.95e@xmath17704 + @xmath226fe & 4.47e@xmath17716 & 2.44e@xmath17714 & 4.24e@xmath17715 & 1.10e@xmath17713 & 1.54e@xmath17713 & 1.10e@xmath17712 & 1.01e@xmath17715 & 2.10e@xmath17712 & 1.95e@xmath17712 & 2.44e@xmath17711 & 2.44e@xmath17711 & 1.11e@xmath17712 & 3.86e@xmath17713 + @xmath25ni & 7.00e@xmath17702 & 7.00e@xmath17702 & 7.00e@xmath17702 & 8.30e@xmath17702 & 1.07e@xmath17701 & 9.70e@xmath17702 & 7.93e@xmath17704 & 1.60e@xmath17701 & 5.04e@xmath17702 & 2.58e@xmath17701 & 1.08e@xmath17701 & 3.61e@xmath17701 & 2.34e@xmath17701 + @xmath224ni & 1.01e@xmath17703 & 1.08e@xmath17703 & 7.98e@xmath17704 & 1.77e@xmath17703 & 1.54e@xmath17703 & 1.55e@xmath17703 & 9.27e@xmath17706 & 3.03e@xmath17703 & 9.53e@xmath17704 & 4.17e@xmath17703 & 1.74e@xmath17703 & 7.35e@xmath17703 & 4.77e@xmath17703 crrrrrr p & 3.28e@xmath17702 & 3.28e@xmath17702 & 3.27e@xmath17702 & 3.27e@xmath17702 & 3.28e@xmath17702 & 3.28e@xmath17702 + d & 8.97e@xmath17718 & 8.97e@xmath17718 & 8.97e@xmath17718 & 8.97e@xmath17718 & 1.22e@xmath17715 & 1.22e@xmath17715 + @xmath178he & 2.72e@xmath17707 & 2.72e@xmath17707 & 2.72e@xmath17707 & 2.72e@xmath17707 & 2.72e@xmath17707 & 2.72e@xmath17707 + @xmath179he & 2.31e@xmath17702 & 2.31e@xmath17702 & 2.30e@xmath17702 & 2.30e@xmath17702 & 2.33e@xmath17702 & 2.32e@xmath17702 + @xmath180li & 2.75e@xmath17720 & 2.75e@xmath17720 & 2.75e@xmath17720 & 2.75e@xmath17720 & 4.04e@xmath17718 & 4.04e@xmath17718 + @xmath181li & 1.14e@xmath17711 & 1.14e@xmath17711 & 1.12e@xmath17711 & 1.12e@xmath17711 & 1.14e@xmath17711 & 1.14e@xmath17711 + @xmath182be & 2.40e@xmath17720 & 2.40e@xmath17720 & 2.50e@xmath17720 & 2.50e@xmath17720 & 2.09e@xmath17719 & 2.09e@xmath17719 + @xmath183b & 8.94e@xmath17717 & 8.94e@xmath17717 & 4.80e@xmath17717 & 4.80e@xmath17717 & 7.70e@xmath17718 & 7.70e@xmath17718 + @xmath184b & 2.74e@xmath17715 & 1.95e@xmath17715 & 7.68e@xmath17716 & 7.64e@xmath17716 & 4.17e@xmath17716 & 4.14e@xmath17716 + @xmath88c & 8.27e@xmath17704 & 7.76e@xmath17704 & 8.35e@xmath17704 & 7.84e@xmath17704 & 8.56e@xmath17704 & 8.07e@xmath17704 + @xmath89c & 2.24e@xmath17710 & 2.15e@xmath17710 & 2.26e@xmath17710 & 2.18e@xmath17710 & 2.43e@xmath17710 & 2.36e@xmath17710 + @xmath185n & 3.41e@xmath17706 & 3.41e@xmath17706 & 3.38e@xmath17706 & 3.38e@xmath17706 & 3.41e@xmath17706 & 3.41e@xmath17706 + @xmath186n & 4.89e@xmath17710 & 4.28e@xmath17710 & 4.87e@xmath17710 & 4.27e@xmath17710 & 4.99e@xmath17710 & 4.40e@xmath17710 + @xmath136o & 7.32e@xmath17703 & 4.91e@xmath17703 & 7.40e@xmath17703 & 4.98e@xmath17703 & 7.62e@xmath17703 & 5.23e@xmath17703 + @xmath187o & 4.23e@xmath17709 & 4.22e@xmath17709 & 4.16e@xmath17709 & 4.15e@xmath17709 & 4.23e@xmath17709 & 4.22e@xmath17709 + @xmath188o & 6.25e@xmath17709 & 6.24e@xmath17709 & 6.26e@xmath17709 & 6.26e@xmath17709 & 6.24e@xmath17709 & 6.24e@xmath17709 + @xmath189f & 4.18e@xmath17711 & 4.08e@xmath17711 & 4.18e@xmath17711 & 4.09e@xmath17711 & 1.80e@xmath17711 & 1.70e@xmath17711 + @xmath190ne & 1.37e@xmath17703 & 1.16e@xmath17703 & 1.38e@xmath17703 & 1.17e@xmath17703 & 1.41e@xmath17703 & 1.21e@xmath17703 + @xmath191ne & 1.24e@xmath17707 & 1.07e@xmath17707 & 1.25e@xmath17707 & 1.08e@xmath17707 & 1.22e@xmath17707 & 1.08e@xmath17707 + @xmath192ne & 8.56e@xmath17708 & 7.03e@xmath17708 & 8.59e@xmath17708 & 7.05e@xmath17708 & 8.53e@xmath17708 & 7.11e@xmath17708 + @xmath193na & 4.57e@xmath17706 & 4.17e@xmath17706 & 4.58e@xmath17706 & 4.19e@xmath17706 & 4.55e@xmath17706 & 4.23e@xmath17706 + @xmath194 mg & 5.54e@xmath17704 & 3.91e@xmath17704 & 5.59e@xmath17704 & 3.95e@xmath17704 & 5.50e@xmath17704 & 3.87e@xmath17704 + @xmath195 mg & 9.14e@xmath17707 & 8.27e@xmath17707 & 9.16e@xmath17707 & 8.28e@xmath17707 & 8.23e@xmath17707 & 7.43e@xmath17707 + @xmath196 mg & 8.94e@xmath17707 & 8.47e@xmath17707 & 8.95e@xmath17707 & 8.48e@xmath17707 & 9.02e@xmath17707 & 8.54e@xmath17707 + @xmath196al & 1.60e@xmath17708 & 1.41e@xmath17708 & 1.63e@xmath17708 & 1.43e@xmath17708 & 1.83e@xmath17708 & 1.15e@xmath17708 + @xmath197al & 9.94e@xmath17706 & 7.54e@xmath17706 & 9.96e@xmath17706 & 7.56e@xmath17706 & 1.02e@xmath17705 & 7.49e@xmath17706 + @xmath198si & 6.09e@xmath17704 & 3.78e@xmath17704 & 6.48e@xmath17704 & 4.06e@xmath17704 & 5.55e@xmath17704 & 3.49e@xmath17704 + @xmath199si & 2.84e@xmath17706 & 1.81e@xmath17706 & 2.88e@xmath17706 & 1.84e@xmath17706 & 2.36e@xmath17706 & 1.50e@xmath17706 + @xmath200si & 2.57e@xmath17706 & 1.87e@xmath17706 & 2.58e@xmath17706 & 1.88e@xmath17706 & 2.73e@xmath17706 & 1.85e@xmath17706 + @xmath201p & 9.63e@xmath17707 & 6.98e@xmath17707 & 9.74e@xmath17707 & 7.06e@xmath17707 & 9.85e@xmath17707 & 6.83e@xmath17707 + @xmath202s & 2.25e@xmath17704 & 1.38e@xmath17704 & 2.38e@xmath17704 & 1.46e@xmath17704 & 2.14e@xmath17704 & 1.35e@xmath17704 + @xmath203s & 6.90e@xmath17707 & 3.64e@xmath17707 & 7.33e@xmath17707 & 3.97e@xmath17707 & 6.16e@xmath17707 & 3.54e@xmath17707 + @xmath204s & 1.27e@xmath17706 & 6.41e@xmath17707 & 1.39e@xmath17706 & 7.29e@xmath17707 & 1.40e@xmath17706 & 7.13e@xmath17707 + @xmath205s & 3.25e@xmath17711 & 1.91e@xmath17711 & 3.25e@xmath17711 & 1.91e@xmath17711 & 3.25e@xmath17711 & 1.97e@xmath17711 + @xmath206cl & 1.67e@xmath17707 & 1.07e@xmath17707 & 1.91e@xmath17707 & 1.25e@xmath17707 & 2.10e@xmath17707 & 1.31e@xmath17707 + @xmath207cl & 5.80e@xmath17708 & 2.72e@xmath17708 & 6.86e@xmath17708 & 3.46e@xmath17708 & 7.43e@xmath17708 & 3.87e@xmath17708 + @xmath205ar & 3.34e@xmath17705 & 2.10e@xmath17705 & 3.42e@xmath17705 & 2.12e@xmath17705 & 3.46e@xmath17705 & 2.19e@xmath17705 + @xmath208ar & 4.35e@xmath17707 & 2.02e@xmath17707 & 6.24e@xmath17707 & 3.29e@xmath17707 & 6.09e@xmath17707 & 2.58e@xmath17707 + @xmath209ar & 2.06e@xmath17713 & 1.33e@xmath17713 & 2.10e@xmath17713 & 1.37e@xmath17713 & 2.00e@xmath17713 & 1.33e@xmath17713 + @xmath210k & 7.01e@xmath17708 & 3.03e@xmath17708 & 1.08e@xmath17707 & 5.71e@xmath17708 & 1.02e@xmath17707 & 4.33e@xmath17708 + @xmath209k & 8.63e@xmath17712 & 4.66e@xmath17712 & 9.77e@xmath17712 & 5.44e@xmath17712 & 9.60e@xmath17712 & 5.28e@xmath17712 + @xmath211k & 1.15e@xmath17708 & 4.72e@xmath17709 & 1.45e@xmath17708 & 6.74e@xmath17709 & 1.25e@xmath17708 & 5.65e@xmath17709 + @xmath209ca & 2.71e@xmath17705 & 1.77e@xmath17705 & 2.66e@xmath17705 & 1.69e@xmath17705 & 2.92e@xmath17705 & 1.85e@xmath17705 + @xmath212ca & 9.76e@xmath17709 & 4.13e@xmath17709 & 1.55e@xmath17708 & 7.88e@xmath17709 & 1.60e@xmath17708 & 5.63e@xmath17709 + @xmath213ca & 4.19e@xmath17710 & 3.30e@xmath17710 & 3.87e@xmath17710 & 3.05e@xmath17710 & 8.50e@xmath17710 & 5.80e@xmath17710 + @xmath42ca & 2.86e@xmath17707 & 1.94e@xmath17707 & 2.33e@xmath17707 & 1.55e@xmath17707 & 6.98e@xmath17707 & 4.00e@xmath17707 + @xmath214ca & 3.20e@xmath17714 & 2.80e@xmath17714 & 3.78e@xmath17714 & 3.38e@xmath17714 & 2.04e@xmath17714 & 1.77e@xmath17714 + @xmath43ca & 7.40e@xmath17715 & 7.39e@xmath17715 & 6.30e@xmath17715 & 6.29e@xmath17715 & 3.85e@xmath17715 & 3.85e@xmath17715 + @xmath215sc & 3.73e@xmath17710 & 1.98e@xmath17710 & 7.31e@xmath17710 & 5.15e@xmath17710 & 1.25e@xmath17708 & 6.35e@xmath17709 + @xmath214ti & 1.94e@xmath17708 & 1.49e@xmath17708 & 3.08e@xmath17708 & 2.43e@xmath17708 & 3.11e@xmath17708 & 2.21e@xmath17708 + @xmath216ti & 4.10e@xmath17708 & 3.00e@xmath17708 & 6.41e@xmath17708 & 4.86e@xmath17708 & 4.90e@xmath17708 & 3.88e@xmath17708 + @xmath43ti & 5.58e@xmath17707 & 4.06e@xmath17707 & 4.62e@xmath17707 & 3.34e@xmath17707 & 9.10e@xmath17707 & 5.76e@xmath17707 + @xmath217ti & 9.45e@xmath17709 & 7.63e@xmath17709 & 1.33e@xmath17708 & 1.05e@xmath17708 & 6.87e@xmath17708 & 3.94e@xmath17708 + @xmath218ti & 1.38e@xmath17714 & 1.25e@xmath17714 & 1.33e@xmath17714 & 1.19e@xmath17714 & 7.05e@xmath17715 & 5.30e@xmath17715 + @xmath218v & 7.70e@xmath17714 & 4.89e@xmath17714 & 1.11e@xmath17713 & 7.21e@xmath17714 & 1.35e@xmath17713 & 6.19e@xmath17714 + @xmath219v & 6.87e@xmath17708 & 5.36e@xmath17708 & 1.03e@xmath17707 & 8.07e@xmath17708 & 1.23e@xmath17707 & 9.00e@xmath17708 + @xmath218cr & 3.25e@xmath17708 & 2.47e@xmath17708 & 7.81e@xmath17708 & 5.93e@xmath17708 & 1.03e@xmath17707 & 6.57e@xmath17708 + @xmath220cr & 4.66e@xmath17706 & 3.72e@xmath17706 & 4.45e@xmath17706 & 3.53e@xmath17706 & 5.28e@xmath17706 & 3.97e@xmath17706 + @xmath221cr & 1.75e@xmath17707 & 1.44e@xmath17707 & 2.44e@xmath17707 & 1.96e@xmath17707 & 3.14e@xmath17707 & 2.33e@xmath17707 + @xmath222cr & 1.89e@xmath17712 & 9.63e@xmath17713 & 9.03e@xmath17712 & 6.09e@xmath17712 & 1.14e@xmath17711 & 3.10e@xmath17712 + @xmath223mn & 2.92e@xmath17707 & 2.63e@xmath17707 & 6.64e@xmath17707 & 5.29e@xmath17707 & 7.88e@xmath17707 & 5.88e@xmath17707 + @xmath222fe & 1.64e@xmath17706 & 1.34e@xmath17706 & 5.10e@xmath17706 & 3.82e@xmath17706 & 5.31e@xmath17706 & 3.74e@xmath17706 + @xmath25fe & 3.81e@xmath17704 & 2.89e@xmath17704 & 3.82e@xmath17704 & 2.92e@xmath17704 & 3.91e@xmath17704 & 2.95e@xmath17704 + @xmath224fe & 6.33e@xmath17706 & 4.69e@xmath17706 & 4.98e@xmath17706 & 3.59e@xmath17706 & 5.25e@xmath17706 & 3.73e@xmath17706 + @xmath128fe & 1.32e@xmath17712 & 4.56e@xmath17713 & 4.26e@xmath17712 & 2.48e@xmath17712 & 5.62e@xmath17712 & 1.24e@xmath17712 + @xmath225co & 1.03e@xmath17706 & 7.78e@xmath17707 & 1.58e@xmath17706 & 1.25e@xmath17706 & 2.77e@xmath17706 & 1.94e@xmath17706 + @xmath128ni & 2.33e@xmath17706 & 1.74e@xmath17706 & 2.81e@xmath17706 & 2.13e@xmath17706 & 5.35e@xmath17706 & 3.50e@xmath17706 + @xmath226ni & 1.16e@xmath17705 & 8.52e@xmath17706 & 1.21e@xmath17705 & 8.96e@xmath17706 & 1.38e@xmath17705 & 9.82e@xmath17706 + @xmath227ni & 1.86e@xmath17707 & 1.42e@xmath17707 & 1.34e@xmath17707 & 1.01e@xmath17707 & 1.60e@xmath17707 & 1.14e@xmath17707 + @xmath228ni & 1.16e@xmath17707 & 8.64e@xmath17708 & 1.27e@xmath17707 & 9.99e@xmath17708 & 1.61e@xmath17707 & 1.12e@xmath17707 + @xmath44ni & 1.30e@xmath17714 & 1.21e@xmath17714 & 9.99e@xmath17715 & 9.24e@xmath17715 & 7.71e@xmath17715 & 6.32e@xmath17715 + @xmath229cu & 3.28e@xmath17708 & 2.40e@xmath17708 & 3.93e@xmath17708 & 2.97e@xmath17708 & 6.47e@xmath17708 & 4.41e@xmath17708 + @xmath230cu & 2.38e@xmath17709 & 1.61e@xmath17709 & 1.76e@xmath17709 & 1.16e@xmath17709 & 3.46e@xmath17709 & 2.03e@xmath17709 + @xmath44zn & 1.04e@xmath17706 & 7.43e@xmath17707 & 9.53e@xmath17707 & 6.75e@xmath17707 & 1.83e@xmath17706 & 1.15e@xmath17706 + @xmath231zn & 1.13e@xmath17708 & 7.72e@xmath17709 & 7.09e@xmath17709 & 4.81e@xmath17709 & 2.32e@xmath17708 & 1.35e@xmath17708 + @xmath232zn & 2.96e@xmath17710 & 2.13e@xmath17710 & 2.41e@xmath17710 & 1.73e@xmath17710 & 2.26e@xmath17709 & 1.28e@xmath17709 + @xmath233zn & 4.57e@xmath17710 & 2.87e@xmath17710 & 5.14e@xmath17710 & 3.23e@xmath17710 & 2.75e@xmath17710 & 1.94e@xmath17710 + @xmath234zn & 7.74e@xmath17715 & 7.23e@xmath17715 & 7.44e@xmath17715 & 7.20e@xmath17715 & 5.12e@xmath17715 & 4.64e@xmath17715 + @xmath235ga & 7.83e@xmath17711 & 5.08e@xmath17711 & 8.78e@xmath17711 & 5.67e@xmath17711 & 8.48e@xmath17711 & 5.51e@xmath17711 + @xmath236ga & 5.87e@xmath17714 & 5.70e@xmath17714 & 5.44e@xmath17714 & 5.36e@xmath17714 & 1.85e@xmath17714 & 1.74e@xmath17714 + @xmath234ge & 5.90e@xmath17711 & 4.33e@xmath17711 & 5.35e@xmath17711 & 3.90e@xmath17711 & 8.06e@xmath17711 & 5.34e@xmath17711 + @xmath237ge & 3.81e@xmath17714 & 3.40e@xmath17714 & 4.45e@xmath17714 & 4.05e@xmath17714 & 1.34e@xmath17714 & 1.01e@xmath17714 + @xmath238ge & 4.78e@xmath17714 & 4.56e@xmath17714 & 4.46e@xmath17714 & 4.18e@xmath17714 & 2.23e@xmath17714 & 2.01e@xmath17714 + @xmath239ge & 1.91e@xmath17714 & 1.84e@xmath17714 & 1.50e@xmath17714 & 1.45e@xmath17714 & 8.33e@xmath17715 & 7.80e@xmath17715 cccccccccccc 13 & 1 & 0.07 & 0.09 & @xmath1772.55 & @xmath1770.08 & 0.37 & 1.57 & & & 1 & fig .
[ fig : ye]a + 15 & 1 & 0.07 & 0.07 & @xmath1772.55 & 0.15 & 0.27 & 1.48 & & & 1 & fig .
[ fig : ye]b + 18 & 1 & 0.07 & 0.16 & @xmath1772.55 & 0.40 & 0.63 & 1.65 & & & 1 & fig . [ fig : ye]c + 20 & 10 & 0.08 & 0.17 & @xmath1773.34 & 0.50 & 0.58 & 1.88 & 1.52 & 2.02 & 0.28 & fig .
[ fig : ye]d + 25 & 5 & 0.10 & 0.14 & @xmath1772.98 & 0.50 & 0.41 & 2.39 & 1.79 & 2.61 & 0.27 & fig . [ fig : ye]i + 25 & 10 & 0.10 & 0.16 & @xmath1773.25 & 0.50 & 0.48 & 2.90 & 1.79 & 2.99 & 0.07 & fig .
[ fig : ye]e + 30a & 20 & 0.16 & 0.22 & @xmath1773.31 & 0.50 & 0.41 & 3.27 & 1.65 & 3.59 & 0.17 & fig .
[ fig : ye]f + 30b & 20 & 0.05 & 0.04 & @xmath1773.82 & 0.55 & 0.20 & 6.73 & 1.65 & 7.01 & 0.05 & fig .
[ fig : ye]f + 40a & 30 & 0.26 & 0.34 & @xmath1773.26 & 0.50 & 0.39 & 5.53 & 2.24 & 6.00 & 0.12 & fig .
[ fig : ye]g + 40b & 30 & 0.11 & 0.09 & @xmath1773.63 & 0.46 & 0.20 & 10.70 & 2.24 & 11.16 & 0.05 & fig .
[ fig : ye]g + 50a & 40 & 0.36 & 0.57 & @xmath1773.22 & 0.50 & 0.47 & 3.51 & 1.89 & 4.15 & 0.28 & fig .
[ fig : ye]h + 50b & 40 & 0.24 & 0.20 & @xmath1773.40 & 0.35 & 0.20 & 10.99 & 1.89 & 13.05 & 0.18 & fig .
[ fig : ye]h + crrrrrrrrrrrr p & 6.59e+00 & 7.58e+00 & 8.43e+00 & 8.77e+00 & 1.06e+01 & 1.05e+01 & 1.17e+01 & 1.17e+01 & 1.40e+01 & 1.40e+01 & 1.63e+01 & 1.63e+01 + d & 1.49e@xmath17716 & 1.69e@xmath17716 & 1.28e@xmath17716 & 8.66e@xmath17717 & 2.04e@xmath17716 & 2.06e@xmath17716 & 1.09e@xmath17714 & 1.09e@xmath17714 & 1.66e@xmath17714 & 1.66e@xmath17714 & 1.24e@xmath17715 & 1.24e@xmath17715 + @xmath178he & 4.12e@xmath17705 & 4.09e@xmath17705 & 3.33e@xmath17705 & 4.76e@xmath17705 & 2.11e@xmath17704 & 2.11e@xmath17704 & 2.06e@xmath17704 & 2.06e@xmath17704 & 2.56e@xmath17705 & 2.56e@xmath17705 & 2.86e@xmath17705 & 2.86e@xmath17705 + @xmath179he & 4.01e+00 & 4.40e+00 & 5.42e+00 & 5.96e+00 & 8.03e+00 & 7.82e+00 & 9.54e+00 & 9.51e+00 & 1.18e+01 & 1.18e+01 & 1.56e+01 & 1.55e+01 + @xmath180li & 3.65e@xmath17723 & 1.11e@xmath17722 & 4.37e@xmath17723 & 1.36e@xmath17722 & 2.28e@xmath17720 & 2.72e@xmath17720 & 3.50e@xmath17717 & 3.50e@xmath17717 & 5.39e@xmath17717 & 5.39e@xmath17717 & 2.02e@xmath17718 & 2.02e@xmath17718 + @xmath181li & 2.17e@xmath17710 & 2.94e@xmath17710 & 7.34e@xmath17711 & 2.79e@xmath17710 & 5.68e@xmath17709 & 5.12e@xmath17709 & 2.36e@xmath17708 & 2.36e@xmath17708 & 3.42e@xmath17711 & 3.42e@xmath17711 & 8.78e@xmath17712 & 8.78e@xmath17712 + @xmath182be & 1.77e@xmath17720 & 3.22e@xmath17722 & 1.05e@xmath17722 & 4.83e@xmath17720 & 5.00e@xmath17717 & 3.96e@xmath17717 & 3.09e@xmath17718 & 3.09e@xmath17718 & 9.03e@xmath17718 & 9.03e@xmath17718 & 6.04e@xmath17717 & 6.04e@xmath17717 + @xmath183b & 2.92e@xmath17721 & 8.30e@xmath17720 & 3.92e@xmath17721 & 2.88e@xmath17719 & 2.79e@xmath17715 & 8.28e@xmath17714 & 2.95e@xmath17714 & 2.95e@xmath17714 & 1.41e@xmath17714 & 1.41e@xmath17714 & 1.51e@xmath17717 & 5.27e@xmath17718 + @xmath184b & 2.94e@xmath17716 & 3.30e@xmath17716 & 7.14e@xmath17716 & 1.09e@xmath17715 & 5.91e@xmath17714 & 1.06e@xmath17712 & 6.84e@xmath17713 & 6.80e@xmath17713 & 3.25e@xmath17713 & 3.24e@xmath17713 & 2.98e@xmath17714 & 5.55e@xmath17715 + @xmath88c & 7.41e@xmath17702 & 1.72e@xmath17701 & 2.18e@xmath17701 & 1.90e@xmath17701 & 2.79e@xmath17701 & 2.86e@xmath17701 & 3.16e@xmath17701 & 2.86e@xmath17701 & 3.72e@xmath17701 & 3.51e@xmath17701 & 1.56e+00 & 1.17e+00 + @xmath89c & 8.39e@xmath17708 & 6.21e@xmath17708 & 2.63e@xmath17709 & 1.18e@xmath17708 & 2.90e@xmath17708 & 7.43e@xmath17708 & 6.32e@xmath17708 & 6.03e@xmath17708 & 8.19e@xmath17708 & 7.85e@xmath17708 & 2.38e@xmath17707 & 1.70e@xmath17707 + @xmath185n & 1.83e@xmath17703 & 1.86e@xmath17703 & 1.89e@xmath17704 & 5.42e@xmath17705 & 5.92e@xmath17704 & 5.29e@xmath17704 & 4.18e@xmath17705 & 4.17e@xmath17705 & 3.39e@xmath17706 & 3.33e@xmath17706 & 4.38e@xmath17704 & 4.37e@xmath17704 + @xmath186n & 6.38e@xmath17708 & 6.86e@xmath17708 & 2.40e@xmath17708 & 2.95e@xmath17708 & 1.64e@xmath17707 & 1.73e@xmath17707 & 2.20e@xmath17707 & 1.16e@xmath17707 & 6.54e@xmath17707 & 6.51e@xmath17707 & 3.30e@xmath17707 & 8.15e@xmath17708 + @xmath136o & 4.50e@xmath17701 & 7.73e@xmath17701 & 1.38e+00 & 2.03e+00 & 2.60e+00 & 2.55e+00 & 3.92e+00 & 1.37e+00 & 6.32e+00 & 2.40e+00 & 8.86e+00 & 4.04e+00 + @xmath187o & 1.69e@xmath17706 & 1.57e@xmath17706 & 2.79e@xmath17707 & 7.13e@xmath17708 & 1.49e@xmath17706 & 1.33e@xmath17706 & 3.81e@xmath17708 & 2.64e@xmath17708 & 1.23e@xmath17708 & 8.65e@xmath17709 & 8.60e@xmath17706 & 8.56e@xmath17706 + @xmath188o & 5.79e@xmath17708 & 4.89e@xmath17706 & 4.63e@xmath17706 & 2.33e@xmath17708 & 4.66e@xmath17707 & 4.15e@xmath17707 & 5.03e@xmath17707 & 5.02e@xmath17707 & 2.93e@xmath17707 & 2.92e@xmath17707 & 6.00e@xmath17706 & 5.99e@xmath17706 + @xmath189f & 1.17e@xmath17710 & 1.97e@xmath17709 & 7.91e@xmath17709 & 2.12e@xmath17709 & 1.43e@xmath17709 & 1.77e@xmath17709 & 7.88e@xmath17709 & 6.41e@xmath17709 & 1.17e@xmath17707 & 1.16e@xmath17707 & 8.49e@xmath17709 & 4.07e@xmath17709 + @xmath190ne & 1.53e@xmath17702 & 3.27e@xmath17701 & 4.94e@xmath17701 & 7.49e@xmath17701 & 3.91e@xmath17701 & 3.06e@xmath17701 & 5.20e@xmath17701 & 2.60e@xmath17701 & 2.64e@xmath17701 & 2.19e@xmath17701 & 2.48e+00 & 1.30e+00 + @xmath191ne & 5.42e@xmath17707 & 3.76e@xmath17705 & 9.12e@xmath17705 & 3.58e@xmath17705 & 1.47e@xmath17705 & 1.31e@xmath17705 & 3.51e@xmath17705 & 2.26e@xmath17705 & 1.41e@xmath17705 & 1.07e@xmath17705 & 2.40e@xmath17704 & 1.15e@xmath17704 + @xmath192ne & 1.98e@xmath17707 & 1.61e@xmath17705 & 2.57e@xmath17705 & 5.51e@xmath17705 & 1.30e@xmath17705 & 9.24e@xmath17706 & 3.52e@xmath17705 & 1.98e@xmath17705 & 1.66e@xmath17705 & 1.45e@xmath17705 & 2.10e@xmath17704 & 1.08e@xmath17704 + @xmath193na & 1.44e@xmath17704 & 2.45e@xmath17703 & 2.08e@xmath17703 & 2.31e@xmath17703 & 6.74e@xmath17704 & 4.74e@xmath17704 & 7.36e@xmath17704 & 3.24e@xmath17704 & 3.28e@xmath17704 & 1.66e@xmath17704 & 4.27e@xmath17703 & 1.99e@xmath17703 + @xmath194 mg & 8.62e@xmath17702 & 6.82e@xmath17702 & 1.57e@xmath17701 & 1.65e@xmath17701 & 1.43e@xmath17701 & 1.64e@xmath17701 & 2.17e@xmath17701 & 4.20e@xmath17702 & 3.37e@xmath17701 & 9.00e@xmath17702 & 5.70e@xmath17701 & 1.97e@xmath17701 + @xmath195 mg & 1.56e@xmath17704 & 2.98e@xmath17704 & 5.83e@xmath17704 & 1.07e@xmath17704 & 4.52e@xmath17705 & 4.90e@xmath17705 & 1.45e@xmath17704 & 9.00e@xmath17705 & 5.95e@xmath17704 & 4.11e@xmath17704 & 3.10e@xmath17704 & 1.17e@xmath17704 + @xmath196 mg & 7.07e@xmath17705 & 3.98e@xmath17704 & 8.73e@xmath17704 & 2.09e@xmath17704 & 4.31e@xmath17705 & 4.17e@xmath17705 & 8.00e@xmath17705 & 2.62e@xmath17705 & 6.90e@xmath17705 & 1.23e@xmath17705 & 2.32e@xmath17704 & 9.73e@xmath17705 + @xmath196al & 1.01e@xmath17706 & 1.14e@xmath17706 & 3.34e@xmath17706 & 1.32e@xmath17706 & 1.22e@xmath17706 & 1.40e@xmath17706 & 3.01e@xmath17706 & 1.36e@xmath17706 & 3.80e@xmath17705 & 3.43e@xmath17705 & 5.37e@xmath17706 & 1.34e@xmath17706 + @xmath197al & 3.78e@xmath17703 & 1.37e@xmath17703 & 3.14e@xmath17703 & 1.50e@xmath17703 & 8.59e@xmath17704 & 9.58e@xmath17704 & 1.55e@xmath17703 & 1.59e@xmath17704 & 7.52e@xmath17703 & 1.34e@xmath17703 & 3.29e@xmath17703 & 8.12e@xmath17704 + @xmath198si & 8.04e@xmath17702 & 7.32e@xmath17702 & 1.16e@xmath17701 & 1.03e@xmath17701 & 2.62e@xmath17701 & 2.41e@xmath17701 & 2.47e@xmath17701 & 3.17e@xmath17702 & 7.20e@xmath17701 & 2.29e@xmath17701 & 4.77e@xmath17701 & 1.25e@xmath17701 + @xmath199si & 7.50e@xmath17704 & 2.39e@xmath17704 & 4.42e@xmath17704 & 2.95e@xmath17704 & 5.15e@xmath17704 & 5.77e@xmath17704 & 8.85e@xmath17704 & 4.90e@xmath17705 & 3.72e@xmath17703 & 1.29e@xmath17703 & 9.96e@xmath17704 & 1.91e@xmath17704 + @xmath200si & 1.42e@xmath17703 & 1.50e@xmath17704 & 3.45e@xmath17704 & 1.15e@xmath17704 & 5.88e@xmath17705 & 6.90e@xmath17705 & 1.49e@xmath17704 & 1.06e@xmath17705 & 2.82e@xmath17703 & 4.84e@xmath17704 & 2.20e@xmath17704 & 5.21e@xmath17705 + @xmath201p & 4.88e@xmath17704 & 5.65e@xmath17705 & 1.32e@xmath17704 & 7.79e@xmath17705 & 5.34e@xmath17705 & 6.38e@xmath17705 & 1.17e@xmath17704 & 7.55e@xmath17706 & 1.01e@xmath17703 & 2.24e@xmath17704 & 2.13e@xmath17704 & 4.61e@xmath17705 + @xmath202s & 2.37e@xmath17702 & 3.20e@xmath17702 & 4.07e@xmath17702 & 4.27e@xmath17702 & 1.18e@xmath17701 & 9.43e@xmath17702 & 8.49e@xmath17702 & 1.48e@xmath17702 & 2.59e@xmath17701 & 6.11e@xmath17702 & 2.00e@xmath17701 & 6.03e@xmath17702 + @xmath203s & 8.98e@xmath17705 & 7.55e@xmath17705 & 1.03e@xmath17704 & 1.44e@xmath17704 & 2.15e@xmath17704 & 2.47e@xmath17704 & 3.02e@xmath17704 & 1.61e@xmath17705 & 8.45e@xmath17704 & 1.29e@xmath17704 & 5.42e@xmath17704 & 1.02e@xmath17704 + @xmath204s & 2.81e@xmath17704 & 2.03e@xmath17704 & 2.85e@xmath17704 & 1.89e@xmath17704 & 5.43e@xmath17705 & 1.37e@xmath17704 & 2.75e@xmath17704 & 1.92e@xmath17705 & 2.09e@xmath17703 & 1.34e@xmath17704 & 5.94e@xmath17704 & 1.32e@xmath17704 + @xmath205s & 1.48e@xmath17708 & 1.43e@xmath17709 & 5.34e@xmath17709 & 8.33e@xmath17710 & 6.69e@xmath17711 & 5.77e@xmath17711 & 1.41e@xmath17709 & 7.84e@xmath17711 & 5.04e@xmath17708 & 2.66e@xmath17709 & 5.58e@xmath17711 & 1.04e@xmath17711 + @xmath206cl & 5.54e@xmath17705 & 1.56e@xmath17705 & 2.69e@xmath17705 & 4.28e@xmath17705 & 2.33e@xmath17705 & 3.70e@xmath17705 & 4.98e@xmath17705 & 7.51e@xmath17706 & 1.82e@xmath17704 & 2.58e@xmath17705 & 1.50e@xmath17704 & 5.16e@xmath17705 + @xmath207cl & 3.04e@xmath17706 & 5.83e@xmath17706 & 9.12e@xmath17706 & 1.89e@xmath17705 & 2.54e@xmath17705 & 3.10e@xmath17705 & 2.39e@xmath17705 & 1.35e@xmath17706 & 7.96e@xmath17705 & 4.48e@xmath17706 & 7.61e@xmath17705 & 1.46e@xmath17705 + @xmath205ar & 3.24e@xmath17703 & 5.28e@xmath17703 & 5.67e@xmath17703 & 6.79e@xmath17703 & 1.86e@xmath17702 & 1.38e@xmath17702 & 1.15e@xmath17702 & 2.59e@xmath17703 & 3.55e@xmath17702 & 5.86e@xmath17703 & 3.06e@xmath17702 & 1.05e@xmath17702 + @xmath208ar & 5.30e@xmath17705 & 6.32e@xmath17705 & 1.70e@xmath17704 & 1.28e@xmath17704 & 4.98e@xmath17705 & 1.84e@xmath17704 & 9.20e@xmath17705 & 6.00e@xmath17706 & 7.84e@xmath17704 & 4.22e@xmath17705 & 8.75e@xmath17704 & 1.67e@xmath17704 + @xmath209ar & 8.01e@xmath17711 & 1.78e@xmath17711 & 3.96e@xmath17711 & 3.79e@xmath17711 & 5.17e@xmath17712 & 6.41e@xmath17712 & 1.95e@xmath17711 & 3.51e@xmath17712 & 2.77e@xmath17710 & 2.93e@xmath17711 & 3.64e@xmath17712 & 6.74e@xmath17713 + @xmath210k & 5.74e@xmath17706 & 8.88e@xmath17706 & 1.98e@xmath17705 & 2.54e@xmath17705 & 2.27e@xmath17705 & 4.25e@xmath17705 & 2.38e@xmath17705 & 3.90e@xmath17706 & 1.33e@xmath17704 & 1.17e@xmath17705 & 1.71e@xmath17704 & 4.44e@xmath17705 + @xmath209k & 1.14e@xmath17709 & 9.10e@xmath17710 & 1.96e@xmath17709 & 4.40e@xmath17709 & 1.84e@xmath17709 & 1.51e@xmath17709 & 2.52e@xmath17709 & 1.34e@xmath17710 & 1.18e@xmath17708 & 6.21e@xmath17710 & 5.89e@xmath17709 & 1.09e@xmath17709 + @xmath211k & 3.54e@xmath17707 & 8.05e@xmath17707 & 1.72e@xmath17706 & 3.73e@xmath17706 & 6.75e@xmath17706 & 6.94e@xmath17706 & 3.66e@xmath17706 & 2.15e@xmath17707 & 2.13e@xmath17705 & 1.20e@xmath17706 & 1.43e@xmath17705 & 2.82e@xmath17706 + @xmath209ca & 2.92e@xmath17703 & 4.41e@xmath17703 & 4.40e@xmath17703 & 4.77e@xmath17703 & 1.49e@xmath17702 & 1.02e@xmath17702 & 8.22e@xmath17703 & 2.25e@xmath17703 & 2.86e@xmath17702 & 5.18e@xmath17703 & 2.22e@xmath17702 & 8.98e@xmath17703 + @xmath212ca & 9.77e@xmath17707 & 1.23e@xmath17706 & 3.62e@xmath17706 & 3.41e@xmath17706 & 1.29e@xmath17706 & 5.53e@xmath17706 & 1.62e@xmath17706 & 8.49e@xmath17708 & 1.97e@xmath17705 & 1.03e@xmath17706 & 2.75e@xmath17705 & 5.08e@xmath17706 + @xmath213ca & 6.75e@xmath17708 & 4.58e@xmath17708 & 3.65e@xmath17708 & 2.06e@xmath17707 & 5.54e@xmath17708 & 9.96e@xmath17708 & 1.68e@xmath17707 & 5.18e@xmath17708 & 1.50e@xmath17707 & 5.83e@xmath17708 & 4.79e@xmath17707 & 3.10e@xmath17707 + @xmath42ca & 9.55e@xmath17706 & 1.19e@xmath17705 & 8.75e@xmath17706 & 1.09e@xmath17704 & 2.86e@xmath17705 & 5.25e@xmath17705 & 1.49e@xmath17704 & 4.63e@xmath17705 & 1.53e@xmath17704 & 6.28e@xmath17705 & 5.37e@xmath17704 & 3.51e@xmath17704 + @xmath214ca & 1.07e@xmath17712 & 1.76e@xmath17712 & 9.27e@xmath17712 & 1.15e@xmath17711 & 2.61e@xmath17712 & 2.66e@xmath17711 & 8.42e@xmath17712 & 6.77e@xmath17712 & 4.61e@xmath17711 & 3.37e@xmath17711 & 1.04e@xmath17712 & 1.93e@xmath17713 + @xmath43ca & 1.14e@xmath17717 & 4.21e@xmath17714 & 4.17e@xmath17716 & 5.74e@xmath17716 & 8.89e@xmath17712 & 1.08e@xmath17711 & 5.76e@xmath17713 & 5.72e@xmath17713 & 6.20e@xmath17712 & 6.20e@xmath17712 & 7.67e@xmath17714 & 1.42e@xmath17714 + @xmath215sc & 2.09e@xmath17708 & 4.00e@xmath17708 & 5.52e@xmath17708 & 7.30e@xmath17707 & 2.51e@xmath17707 & 2.32e@xmath17707 & 6.85e@xmath17708 & 1.29e@xmath17708 & 6.27e@xmath17707 & 4.89e@xmath17708 & 5.89e@xmath17707 & 1.59e@xmath17707 + @xmath214ti & 8.17e@xmath17706 & 4.97e@xmath17706 & 4.96e@xmath17706 & 1.09e@xmath17705 & 3.38e@xmath17706 & 7.57e@xmath17706 & 8.92e@xmath17706 & 2.65e@xmath17706 & 1.21e@xmath17705 & 2.42e@xmath17706 & 3.38e@xmath17705 & 1.58e@xmath17705 + @xmath216ti & 1.22e@xmath17705 & 8.51e@xmath17706 & 7.79e@xmath17706 & 1.86e@xmath17705 & 1.27e@xmath17705 & 1.82e@xmath17705 & 3.21e@xmath17705 & 9.99e@xmath17706 & 3.18e@xmath17705 & 1.34e@xmath17705 & 8.35e@xmath17705 & 5.47e@xmath17705 + @xmath43ti & 5.66e@xmath17705 & 7.32e@xmath17705 & 7.18e@xmath17705 & 1.23e@xmath17704 & 1.06e@xmath17704 & 1.13e@xmath17704 & 2.36e@xmath17704 & 7.36e@xmath17705 & 3.13e@xmath17704 & 1.31e@xmath17704 & 6.41e@xmath17704 & 4.20e@xmath17704 + @xmath217ti & 2.26e@xmath17706 & 3.30e@xmath17706 & 2.99e@xmath17706 & 3.80e@xmath17706 & 4.13e@xmath17706 & 3.30e@xmath17706 & 5.62e@xmath17706 & 1.75e@xmath17706 & 6.87e@xmath17706 & 2.70e@xmath17706 & 8.37e@xmath17706 & 5.26e@xmath17706 + @xmath218ti & 1.18e@xmath17712 & 9.55e@xmath17713 & 1.72e@xmath17712 & 9.35e@xmath17713 & 1.92e@xmath17712 & 3.02e@xmath17712 & 1.61e@xmath17712 & 1.26e@xmath17712 & 3.10e@xmath17711 & 2.68e@xmath17711 & 1.10e@xmath17712 & 2.03e@xmath17713 + @xmath218v & 1.35e@xmath17711 & 1.05e@xmath17711 & 4.60e@xmath17711 & 2.62e@xmath17711 & 8.16e@xmath17712 & 2.88e@xmath17711 & 9.04e@xmath17712 & 7.27e@xmath17713 & 1.13e@xmath17710 & 2.06e@xmath17711 & 1.42e@xmath17710 & 2.63e@xmath17711 + @xmath219v & 2.00e@xmath17705 & 1.60e@xmath17705 & 1.41e@xmath17705 & 4.05e@xmath17705 & 1.63e@xmath17705 & 2.55e@xmath17705 & 4.90e@xmath17705 & 1.53e@xmath17705 & 3.91e@xmath17705 & 1.63e@xmath17705 & 1.11e@xmath17704 & 7.21e@xmath17705 + @xmath218cr & 1.07e@xmath17705 & 1.61e@xmath17705 & 2.64e@xmath17705 & 1.98e@xmath17705 & 3.29e@xmath17705 & 2.60e@xmath17705 & 1.96e@xmath17705 & 5.88e@xmath17706 & 4.13e@xmath17705 & 9.90e@xmath17706 & 8.80e@xmath17705 & 2.88e@xmath17705 + @xmath220cr & 8.84e@xmath17704 & 1.09e@xmath17703 & 1.13e@xmath17703 & 6.89e@xmath17704 & 1.31e@xmath17703 & 1.17e@xmath17703 & 1.57e@xmath17703 & 4.89e@xmath17704 & 2.75e@xmath17703 & 1.16e@xmath17703 & 3.17e@xmath17703 & 2.07e@xmath17703 + @xmath221cr & 4.96e@xmath17705 & 6.76e@xmath17705 & 6.43e@xmath17705 & 3.34e@xmath17705 & 7.78e@xmath17705 & 6.64e@xmath17705 & 9.04e@xmath17705 & 2.82e@xmath17705 & 1.31e@xmath17704 & 5.46e@xmath17705 & 1.43e@xmath17704 & 8.85e@xmath17705 + @xmath222cr & 2.35e@xmath17710 & 4.13e@xmath17710 & 3.25e@xmath17709 & 2.61e@xmath17709 & 4.15e@xmath17710 & 6.12e@xmath17709 & 9.16e@xmath17711 & 7.16e@xmath17712 & 3.52e@xmath17709 & 2.17e@xmath17710 & 2.76e@xmath17708 & 5.11e@xmath17709 + @xmath223mn & 1.33e@xmath17704 & 1.86e@xmath17704 & 1.74e@xmath17704 & 8.17e@xmath17705 & 2.22e@xmath17704 & 1.86e@xmath17704 & 2.47e@xmath17704 & 7.70e@xmath17705 & 3.69e@xmath17704 & 1.50e@xmath17704 & 3.88e@xmath17704 & 2.25e@xmath17704 + @xmath222fe & 7.29e@xmath17704 & 1.24e@xmath17703 & 1.40e@xmath17703 & 7.18e@xmath17704 & 2.79e@xmath17703 & 1.73e@xmath17703 & 1.74e@xmath17703 & 5.41e@xmath17704 & 3.30e@xmath17703 & 1.09e@xmath17703 & 4.66e@xmath17703 & 1.93e@xmath17703 + @xmath25fe & 7.00e@xmath17702 & 7.00e@xmath17702 & 7.00e@xmath17702 & 8.27e@xmath17702 & 1.04e@xmath17701 & 1.03e@xmath17701 & 1.60e@xmath17701 & 4.97e@xmath17702 & 2.56e@xmath17701 & 1.08e@xmath17701 & 3.59e@xmath17701 & 2.35e@xmath17701 + @xmath224fe & 7.33e@xmath17704 & 6.88e@xmath17704 & 6.60e@xmath17704 & 1.13e@xmath17703 & 1.26e@xmath17703 & 1.40e@xmath17703 & 2.43e@xmath17703 & 7.57e@xmath17704 & 3.80e@xmath17703 & 1.60e@xmath17703 & 6.10e@xmath17703 & 3.99e@xmath17703 + @xmath128fe & 5.67e@xmath17711 & 1.76e@xmath17710 & 8.07e@xmath17710 & 1.28e@xmath17709 & 7.15e@xmath17710 & 2.77e@xmath17709 & 9.22e@xmath17711 & 6.69e@xmath17712 & 3.30e@xmath17709 & 2.25e@xmath17710 & 1.26e@xmath17708 & 2.32e@xmath17709 + @xmath225co & 2.77e@xmath17704 & 3.02e@xmath17704 & 2.30e@xmath17704 & 6.42e@xmath17704 & 2.73e@xmath17704 & 3.57e@xmath17704 & 7.19e@xmath17704 & 2.24e@xmath17704 & 6.15e@xmath17704 & 2.59e@xmath17704 & 1.77e@xmath17703 & 1.16e@xmath17703 + @xmath128ni & 4.06e@xmath17704 & 4.57e@xmath17704 & 3.85e@xmath17704 & 9.68e@xmath17704 & 6.60e@xmath17704 & 8.66e@xmath17704 & 1.32e@xmath17703 & 4.12e@xmath17704 & 1.46e@xmath17703 & 5.67e@xmath17704 & 3.31e@xmath17703 & 2.08e@xmath17703 + @xmath226ni & 2.18e@xmath17703 & 1.68e@xmath17703 & 1.65e@xmath17703 & 2.97e@xmath17703 & 2.94e@xmath17703 & 3.29e@xmath17703 & 5.60e@xmath17703 & 1.75e@xmath17703 & 8.50e@xmath17703 & 3.58e@xmath17703 & 1.30e@xmath17702 & 8.49e@xmath17703 + @xmath227ni & 2.56e@xmath17705 & 1.72e@xmath17705 & 1.46e@xmath17705 & 4.06e@xmath17705 & 2.50e@xmath17705 & 3.68e@xmath17705 & 6.21e@xmath17705 & 1.94e@xmath17705 & 8.14e@xmath17705 & 3.43e@xmath17705 & 1.57e@xmath17704 & 1.03e@xmath17704 + @xmath228ni & 1.94e@xmath17705 & 1.51e@xmath17705 & 1.24e@xmath17705 & 3.99e@xmath17705 & 1.97e@xmath17705 & 6.66e@xmath17705 & 5.26e@xmath17705 & 1.64e@xmath17705 & 6.26e@xmath17705 & 2.64e@xmath17705 & 1.38e@xmath17704 & 9.04e@xmath17705 + @xmath44ni & 2.14e@xmath17715 & 1.01e@xmath17713 & 1.07e@xmath17714 & 8.67e@xmath17713 & 3.73e@xmath17712 & 7.27e@xmath17712 & 3.59e@xmath17712 & 2.59e@xmath17712 & 1.78e@xmath17711 & 1.78e@xmath17711 & 5.33e@xmath17712 & 9.92e@xmath17713 + @xmath229cu & 6.24e@xmath17706 & 5.46e@xmath17706 & 4.49e@xmath17706 & 1.53e@xmath17705 & 6.84e@xmath17706 & 9.48e@xmath17706 & 1.90e@xmath17705 & 5.92e@xmath17706 & 2.10e@xmath17705 & 8.84e@xmath17706 & 5.10e@xmath17705 & 3.34e@xmath17705 + @xmath230cu & 1.40e@xmath17707 & 1.23e@xmath17707 & 1.17e@xmath17707 & 4.78e@xmath17707 & 3.64e@xmath17707 & 4.84e@xmath17707 & 1.03e@xmath17706 & 3.21e@xmath17707 & 1.62e@xmath17706 & 6.81e@xmath17707 & 3.10e@xmath17706 & 2.03e@xmath17706 + @xmath44zn & 1.10e@xmath17704 & 9.81e@xmath17705 & 8.47e@xmath17705 & 3.34e@xmath17704 & 1.86e@xmath17704 & 2.49e@xmath17704 & 5.29e@xmath17704 & 1.65e@xmath17704 & 6.57e@xmath17704 & 2.77e@xmath17704 & 1.43e@xmath17703 & 9.37e@xmath17704 + @xmath231zn & 4.49e@xmath17707 & 4.05e@xmath17707 & 3.65e@xmath17707 & 2.53e@xmath17706 & 1.06e@xmath17706 & 2.47e@xmath17706 & 4.19e@xmath17706 & 1.31e@xmath17706 & 5.33e@xmath17706 & 2.25e@xmath17706 & 1.29e@xmath17705 & 8.47e@xmath17706 + @xmath232zn & 1.49e@xmath17708 & 1.59e@xmath17708 & 1.27e@xmath17708 & 1.56e@xmath17707 & 2.36e@xmath17708 & 4.92e@xmath17708 & 1.53e@xmath17707 & 4.78e@xmath17708 & 1.03e@xmath17707 & 4.36e@xmath17708 & 4.35e@xmath17707 & 2.85e@xmath17707 + @xmath233zn & 2.54e@xmath17708 & 3.22e@xmath17708 & 3.43e@xmath17708 & 1.15e@xmath17707 & 1.20e@xmath17707 & 1.32e@xmath17707 & 3.10e@xmath17707 & 9.66e@xmath17708 & 5.03e@xmath17707 & 2.12e@xmath17707 & 1.13e@xmath17706 & 7.40e@xmath17707 + @xmath234zn & 5.95e@xmath17716 & 3.56e@xmath17714 & 6.44e@xmath17715 & 1.08e@xmath17713 & 2.03e@xmath17713 & 2.15e@xmath17712 & 7.54e@xmath17713 & 4.92e@xmath17713 & 2.23e@xmath17711 & 2.23e@xmath17711 & 1.96e@xmath17712 & 3.68e@xmath17713 + @xmath235ga & 7.27e@xmath17709 & 6.01e@xmath17709 & 5.58e@xmath17709 & 2.02e@xmath17708 & 1.95e@xmath17708 & 2.44e@xmath17708 & 4.77e@xmath17708 & 1.49e@xmath17708 & 9.52e@xmath17708 & 4.02e@xmath17708 & 1.40e@xmath17707 & 9.15e@xmath17708 + @xmath236ga & 7.45e@xmath17715 & 1.01e@xmath17713 & 1.65e@xmath17714 & 1.49e@xmath17712 & 1.58e@xmath17712 & 3.17e@xmath17711 & 6.77e@xmath17712 & 5.92e@xmath17712 & 1.39e@xmath17710 & 1.39e@xmath17710 & 5.49e@xmath17712 & 1.08e@xmath17712 + @xmath234ge & 7.35e@xmath17709 & 4.76e@xmath17709 & 3.96e@xmath17709 & 2.03e@xmath17708 & 8.99e@xmath17709 & 1.64e@xmath17708 & 2.66e@xmath17708 & 8.27e@xmath17709 & 3.59e@xmath17708 & 1.52e@xmath17708 & 7.31e@xmath17708 & 4.78e@xmath17708 + @xmath237ge & 1.71e@xmath17714 & 7.98e@xmath17713 & 5.75e@xmath17713 & 5.96e@xmath17712 & 2.82e@xmath17712 & 3.08e@xmath17711 & 6.76e@xmath17712 & 3.15e@xmath17712 & 8.47e@xmath17711 & 8.45e@xmath17711 & 3.54e@xmath17711 & 6.59e@xmath17712 + @xmath238ge & 1.34e@xmath17714 & 1.19e@xmath17713 & 1.10e@xmath17713 & 3.68e@xmath17712 & 5.53e@xmath17712 & 2.78e@xmath17711 & 1.17e@xmath17711 & 8.68e@xmath17712 & 9.33e@xmath17711 & 9.32e@xmath17711 & 2.28e@xmath17711 & 4.28e@xmath17712 + @xmath239ge & 2.49e@xmath17715 & 1.21e@xmath17713 & 4.90e@xmath17714 & 2.02e@xmath17713 & 1.16e@xmath17712 & 8.92e@xmath17712 & 2.57e@xmath17712 & 2.05e@xmath17712 & 3.65e@xmath17711 & 3.64e@xmath17711 & 3.88e@xmath17712 & 7.32e@xmath17713 crrrrrrrrrrrr @xmath192na & 1.51e@xmath17707 & 7.70e@xmath17706 & 1.68e@xmath17705 & 4.65e@xmath17705 & 9.97e@xmath17706 & 7.01e@xmath17706 & 2.70e@xmath17705 & 1.34e@xmath17705 & 1.37e@xmath17705 & 1.19e@xmath17705 & 1.77e@xmath17704 & 9.14e@xmath17705 + @xmath196al & 9.84e@xmath17707 & 1.12e@xmath17706 & 3.33e@xmath17706 & 9.81e@xmath17707 & 1.21e@xmath17706 & 1.37e@xmath17706 & 2.92e@xmath17706 & 1.33e@xmath17706 & 2.13e@xmath17705 & 1.76e@xmath17705 & 5.24e@xmath17706 & 1.26e@xmath17706 + @xmath211ca & 3.54e@xmath17707 & 8.05e@xmath17707 & 1.72e@xmath17706 & 3.73e@xmath17706 & 6.75e@xmath17706 & 6.94e@xmath17706 & 3.66e@xmath17706 & 2.15e@xmath17707 & 2.13e@xmath17705 & 1.20e@xmath17706 & 1.43e@xmath17705 & 2.82e@xmath17706 + @xmath42ti & 9.55e@xmath17706 & 1.19e@xmath17705 & 8.75e@xmath17706 & 1.09e@xmath17704 & 2.86e@xmath17705 & 5.25e@xmath17705 & 1.49e@xmath17704 & 4.63e@xmath17705 & 1.53e@xmath17704 & 6.28e@xmath17705 & 5.37e@xmath17704 & 3.51e@xmath17704 + @xmath226fe & 4.74e@xmath17716 & 7.17e@xmath17714 & 3.78e@xmath17715 & 1.09e@xmath17713 & 1.53e@xmath17713 & 2.37e@xmath17712 & 1.68e@xmath17712 & 1.11e@xmath17712 & 2.40e@xmath17711 & 2.40e@xmath17711 & 7.78e@xmath17713 & 1.45e@xmath17713 + @xmath25ni & 7.00e@xmath17702 & 7.00e@xmath17702 & 7.00e@xmath17702 & 8.27e@xmath17702 & 1.04e@xmath17701 & 1.03e@xmath17701 & 1.60e@xmath17701 & 4.97e@xmath17702 & 2.56e@xmath17701 & 1.08e@xmath17701 & 3.59e@xmath17701 & 2.35e@xmath17701 + @xmath224ni & 7.33e@xmath17704 & 6.88e@xmath17704 & 6.60e@xmath17704 & 1.13e@xmath17703 & 1.26e@xmath17703 & 1.40e@xmath17703 & 2.43e@xmath17703 & 7.56e@xmath17704 & 3.80e@xmath17703 & 1.60e@xmath17703 & 6.09e@xmath17703 & 3.99e@xmath17703 cccccccccccccccc 20 & 10 & 0.08 & 0.16 & @xmath1773.33 & 0.50 & 0.56 & 1.83 & 1.52 & 2.01 & 0.37 & 1/2 & fig .
[ fig : yelow]a + 25 & 5 & 0.11 & 0.14 & @xmath1772.95 & 0.50 & 0.35 & 2.08 & 1.79 & 2.38 & 0.51 & 1/4 & fig . [ fig : yelow]f + 25 & 10 & 0.10 & 0.14 & @xmath1773.25 & 0.50 & 0.41 & 2.67 & 1.79 & 2.92 & 0.22 & 1/3 & fig .
[ fig : yelow]b + 30a & 20 & 0.16 & 0.21 & @xmath1773.31 & 0.50 & 0.38 & 2.97 & 1.65 & 3.42 & 0.25 & 1/3 & fig .
[ fig : yelow]c + 30b & 20 & 0.05 & 0.04 & @xmath1773.86 & 0.64 & 0.20 & 6.50 & 1.65 & 6.87 & 0.07 & 1/3 & fig .
[ fig : yelow]c + 40a & 30 & 0.28 & 0.38 & @xmath1773.22 & 0.50 & 0.40 & 4.80 & 2.24 & 5.53 & 0.22 & 1/4 & fig .
[ fig : yelow]d + 40b & 30 & 0.12 & 0.10 & @xmath1773.59 & 0.49 & 0.20 & 10.09 & 2.24 & 10.92 & 0.10 & 1/4 & fig .
[ fig : yelow]d + 50a & 40 & 0.37 & 0.51 & @xmath1773.20 & 0.50 & 0.42 & 3.18 & 1.89 & 3.99 & 0.39 & 1/2 & fig .
[ fig : yelow]e + 50b & 40 & 0.26 & 0.22 & @xmath1773.36 & 0.38 & 0.20 & 9.80 & 1.89 & 12.74 & 0.27 & 1/2 & fig .
[ fig : yelow]e + crrrrrrrrr p & 8.77e+00 & 1.06e+01 & 1.06e+01 & 1.17e+01 & 1.17e+01 & 1.40e+01 & 1.40e+01 & 1.63e+01 & 1.63e+01 + d & 8.66e@xmath17717 & 2.10e@xmath17716 & 2.17e@xmath17716 & 4.19e@xmath17714 & 4.19e@xmath17714 & 4.43e@xmath17712 & 4.43e@xmath17712 & 1.23e@xmath17715 & 1.23e@xmath17715 + @xmath178he & 4.76e@xmath17705 & 2.11e@xmath17704 & 2.11e@xmath17704 & 2.06e@xmath17704 & 2.06e@xmath17704 & 2.56e@xmath17705 & 2.56e@xmath17705 & 2.86e@xmath17705 & 2.86e@xmath17705 + @xmath179he & 5.98e+00 & 8.07e+00 & 8.06e+00 & 9.64e+00 & 9.55e+00 & 1.21e+01 & 1.20e+01 & 1.57e+01 & 1.57e+01 + @xmath180li & 1.22e@xmath17722 & 3.06e@xmath17720 & 7.78e@xmath17720 & 1.37e@xmath17716 & 1.37e@xmath17716 & 1.47e@xmath17714 & 1.47e@xmath17714 & 2.00e@xmath17718 & 2.00e@xmath17718 + @xmath181li & 2.79e@xmath17710 & 5.68e@xmath17709 & 5.68e@xmath17709 & 2.36e@xmath17708 & 2.36e@xmath17708 & 3.50e@xmath17711 & 3.50e@xmath17711 & 8.78e@xmath17712 & 8.78e@xmath17712 + @xmath182be & 1.16e@xmath17720 & 3.12e@xmath17717 & 2.90e@xmath17717 & 6.90e@xmath17718 & 6.90e@xmath17718 & 6.87e@xmath17716 & 6.87e@xmath17716 & 9.43e@xmath17717 & 9.43e@xmath17717 + @xmath183b & 2.59e@xmath17719 & 1.95e@xmath17715 & 3.81e@xmath17715 & 5.17e@xmath17716 & 5.17e@xmath17716 & 2.20e@xmath17714 & 2.20e@xmath17714 & 9.04e@xmath17718 & 4.50e@xmath17718 + @xmath184b & 9.41e@xmath17716 & 7.26e@xmath17715 & 5.42e@xmath17713 & 3.94e@xmath17714 & 3.44e@xmath17714 & 6.67e@xmath17713 & 6.65e@xmath17713 & 1.13e@xmath17714 & 3.13e@xmath17715 + @xmath88c & 1.95e@xmath17701 & 2.91e@xmath17701 & 2.77e@xmath17701 & 3.25e@xmath17701 & 2.90e@xmath17701 & 4.26e@xmath17701 & 4.15e@xmath17701 & 1.61e+00 & 1.24e+00 + @xmath89c & 9.95e@xmath17709 & 3.83e@xmath17708 & 7.78e@xmath17708 & 4.32e@xmath17708 & 4.14e@xmath17708 & 1.05e@xmath17707 & 1.04e@xmath17707 & 4.37e@xmath17707 & 3.75e@xmath17707 + @xmath185n & 5.43e@xmath17705 & 5.91e@xmath17704 & 5.93e@xmath17704 & 4.07e@xmath17705 & 4.05e@xmath17705 & 8.90e@xmath17706 & 8.70e@xmath17706 & 4.37e@xmath17704 & 4.37e@xmath17704 + @xmath186n & 3.27e@xmath17708 & 1.77e@xmath17707 & 1.78e@xmath17707 & 2.13e@xmath17707 & 1.05e@xmath17707 & 7.01e@xmath17707 & 6.98e@xmath17707 & 3.05e@xmath17707 & 9.60e@xmath17708 + @xmath136o & 2.05e+00 & 2.79e+00 & 2.50e+00 & 4.03e+00 & 1.54e+00 & 6.96e+00 & 2.85e+00 & 9.07e+00 & 4.80e+00 + @xmath187o & 7.06e@xmath17708 & 1.49e@xmath17706 & 1.49e@xmath17706 & 4.74e@xmath17708 & 3.59e@xmath17708 & 5.24e@xmath17709 & 3.71e@xmath17709 & 8.60e@xmath17706 & 8.57e@xmath17706 + @xmath188o & 2.34e@xmath17708 & 5.27e@xmath17707 & 3.90e@xmath17707 & 2.71e@xmath17707 & 2.70e@xmath17707 & 3.01e@xmath17707 & 3.00e@xmath17707 & 6.80e@xmath17706 & 6.79e@xmath17706 + @xmath189f & 2.01e@xmath17709 & 1.49e@xmath17709 & 1.42e@xmath17709 & 7.54e@xmath17709 & 5.99e@xmath17709 & 2.97e@xmath17708 & 2.94e@xmath17708 & 9.35e@xmath17709 & 4.56e@xmath17709 + @xmath190ne & 7.61e@xmath17701 & 4.24e@xmath17701 & 3.05e@xmath17701 & 5.58e@xmath17701 & 2.86e@xmath17701 & 3.06e@xmath17701 & 2.70e@xmath17701 & 2.48e+00 & 1.43e+00 + @xmath191ne & 3.44e@xmath17705 & 9.09e@xmath17706 & 7.92e@xmath17706 & 3.66e@xmath17705 & 2.67e@xmath17705 & 1.31e@xmath17705 & 1.13e@xmath17705 & 2.35e@xmath17704 & 1.31e@xmath17704 + @xmath192ne & 5.61e@xmath17705 & 1.45e@xmath17705 & 9.07e@xmath17706 & 3.94e@xmath17705 & 2.30e@xmath17705 & 6.34e@xmath17706 & 5.16e@xmath17706 & 2.15e@xmath17704 & 1.25e@xmath17704 + @xmath193na & 2.33e@xmath17703 & 7.58e@xmath17704 & 4.70e@xmath17704 & 7.75e@xmath17704 & 3.92e@xmath17704 & 1.31e@xmath17704 & 7.59e@xmath17705 & 4.24e@xmath17703 & 2.32e@xmath17703 + @xmath194 mg & 1.62e@xmath17701 & 1.35e@xmath17701 & 1.38e@xmath17701 & 2.09e@xmath17701 & 3.80e@xmath17702 & 3.79e@xmath17701 & 1.01e@xmath17701 & 5.12e@xmath17701 & 2.18e@xmath17701 + @xmath195 mg & 1.05e@xmath17704 & 3.47e@xmath17705 & 3.41e@xmath17705 & 1.36e@xmath17704 & 8.47e@xmath17705 & 2.97e@xmath17704 & 1.20e@xmath17704 & 2.96e@xmath17704 & 1.41e@xmath17704 + @xmath196 mg & 2.09e@xmath17704 & 4.74e@xmath17705 & 4.12e@xmath17705 & 8.67e@xmath17705 & 3.03e@xmath17705 & 8.55e@xmath17705 & 2.49e@xmath17705 & 2.34e@xmath17704 & 1.16e@xmath17704 + @xmath196al & 5.29e@xmath17706 & 4.59e@xmath17706 & 4.35e@xmath17706 & 1.17e@xmath17705 & 3.51e@xmath17706 & 2.02e@xmath17705 & 8.02e@xmath17706 & 1.41e@xmath17705 & 8.44e@xmath17706 + @xmath197al & 1.48e@xmath17703 & 8.44e@xmath17704 & 8.72e@xmath17704 & 1.58e@xmath17703 & 1.91e@xmath17704 & 8.56e@xmath17703 & 1.12e@xmath17703 & 2.98e@xmath17703 & 1.01e@xmath17703 + @xmath198si & 9.31e@xmath17702 & 2.83e@xmath17701 & 1.96e@xmath17701 & 2.52e@xmath17701 & 3.31e@xmath17702 & 4.69e@xmath17701 & 9.11e@xmath17702 & 4.21e@xmath17701 & 1.48e@xmath17701 + @xmath199si & 2.69e@xmath17704 & 3.71e@xmath17704 & 4.48e@xmath17704 & 7.86e@xmath17704 & 5.88e@xmath17705 & 2.27e@xmath17703 & 2.37e@xmath17704 & 7.59e@xmath17704 & 2.16e@xmath17704 + @xmath200si & 1.20e@xmath17704 & 7.69e@xmath17705 & 6.95e@xmath17705 & 2.05e@xmath17704 & 1.90e@xmath17705 & 3.29e@xmath17703 & 3.60e@xmath17704 & 2.28e@xmath17704 & 8.25e@xmath17705 + @xmath201p & 8.11e@xmath17705 & 9.14e@xmath17705 & 6.23e@xmath17705 & 1.58e@xmath17704 & 1.53e@xmath17705 & 9.93e@xmath17704 & 1.16e@xmath17704 & 2.19e@xmath17704 & 7.74e@xmath17705 + @xmath202s & 3.91e@xmath17702 & 1.21e@xmath17701 & 7.70e@xmath17702 & 1.03e@xmath17701 & 1.77e@xmath17702 & 1.77e@xmath17701 & 4.24e@xmath17702 & 2.01e@xmath17701 & 7.70e@xmath17702 + @xmath203s & 1.44e@xmath17704 & 2.45e@xmath17704 & 1.76e@xmath17704 & 2.55e@xmath17704 & 1.92e@xmath17705 & 5.77e@xmath17704 & 5.79e@xmath17705 & 5.59e@xmath17704 & 1.58e@xmath17704 + @xmath204s & 1.61e@xmath17704 & 3.50e@xmath17704 & 5.51e@xmath17705 & 5.32e@xmath17704 & 4.36e@xmath17705 & 1.98e@xmath17703 & 2.00e@xmath17704 & 4.74e@xmath17704 & 1.57e@xmath17704 + @xmath205s & 7.55e@xmath17710 & 1.39e@xmath17710 & 6.81e@xmath17711 & 1.23e@xmath17709 & 9.11e@xmath17711 & 5.07e@xmath17708 & 4.88e@xmath17709 & 6.52e@xmath17711 & 1.78e@xmath17711 + @xmath206cl & 4.57e@xmath17705 & 6.31e@xmath17705 & 2.78e@xmath17705 & 9.85e@xmath17705 & 1.47e@xmath17705 & 1.93e@xmath17704 & 3.76e@xmath17705 & 1.61e@xmath17704 & 8.00e@xmath17705 + @xmath207cl & 2.21e@xmath17705 & 4.01e@xmath17705 & 2.24e@xmath17705 & 4.52e@xmath17705 & 6.46e@xmath17706 & 7.46e@xmath17705 & 1.59e@xmath17705 & 9.19e@xmath17705 & 2.76e@xmath17705 + @xmath205ar & 6.53e@xmath17703 & 1.82e@xmath17702 & 1.24e@xmath17702 & 1.82e@xmath17702 & 3.56e@xmath17703 & 2.95e@xmath17702 & 8.45e@xmath17703 & 3.33e@xmath17702 & 1.40e@xmath17702 + @xmath208ar & 7.42e@xmath17705 & 4.06e@xmath17704 & 2.64e@xmath17705 & 4.97e@xmath17704 & 3.75e@xmath17705 & 5.92e@xmath17704 & 6.04e@xmath17705 & 6.26e@xmath17704 & 1.74e@xmath17704 + @xmath209ar & 3.64e@xmath17711 & 1.44e@xmath17711 & 2.59e@xmath17712 & 2.12e@xmath17711 & 2.17e@xmath17712 & 2.45e@xmath17710 & 2.47e@xmath17711 & 5.33e@xmath17712 & 1.44e@xmath17712 + @xmath210k & 1.69e@xmath17705 & 6.74e@xmath17705 & 1.22e@xmath17705 & 9.09e@xmath17705 & 8.93e@xmath17706 & 9.57e@xmath17705 & 1.41e@xmath17705 & 1.14e@xmath17704 & 4.14e@xmath17705 + @xmath209k & 4.18e@xmath17709 & 7.13e@xmath17709 & 8.73e@xmath17710 & 5.14e@xmath17709 & 3.66e@xmath17710 & 9.05e@xmath17709 & 8.66e@xmath17710 & 5.80e@xmath17709 & 1.57e@xmath17709 + @xmath211k & 3.41e@xmath17706 & 1.06e@xmath17705 & 3.71e@xmath17706 & 7.99e@xmath17706 & 6.40e@xmath17707 & 1.30e@xmath17705 & 1.41e@xmath17706 & 1.62e@xmath17705 & 4.52e@xmath17706 + @xmath209ca & 4.73e@xmath17703 & 1.34e@xmath17702 & 1.01e@xmath17702 & 1.62e@xmath17702 & 3.41e@xmath17703 & 2.70e@xmath17702 & 8.62e@xmath17703 & 2.40e@xmath17702 & 1.18e@xmath17702 + @xmath212ca & 1.70e@xmath17706 & 8.77e@xmath17706 & 5.14e@xmath17707 & 1.63e@xmath17705 & 1.16e@xmath17706 & 1.47e@xmath17705 & 1.40e@xmath17706 & 2.05e@xmath17705 & 5.57e@xmath17706 + @xmath213ca & 4.60e@xmath17707 & 2.69e@xmath17707 & 2.02e@xmath17707 & 5.68e@xmath17707 & 1.57e@xmath17707 & 6.15e@xmath17707 & 2.58e@xmath17707 & 9.35e@xmath17707 & 6.54e@xmath17707 + @xmath42ca & 2.05e@xmath17704 & 1.68e@xmath17704 & 1.51e@xmath17704 & 4.93e@xmath17704 & 1.37e@xmath17704 & 8.70e@xmath17704 & 3.69e@xmath17704 & 1.26e@xmath17703 & 8.82e@xmath17704 + @xmath214ca & 1.12e@xmath17711 & 5.12e@xmath17712 & 8.54e@xmath17712 & 2.78e@xmath17712 & 9.64e@xmath17713 & 1.69e@xmath17711 & 9.43e@xmath17712 & 1.55e@xmath17712 & 4.20e@xmath17713 + @xmath43ca & 2.53e@xmath17715 & 1.03e@xmath17711 & 7.92e@xmath17712 & 4.12e@xmath17713 & 4.02e@xmath17713 & 1.71e@xmath17712 & 1.71e@xmath17712 & 3.57e@xmath17714 & 9.67e@xmath17715 + @xmath215sc & 3.20e@xmath17706 & 2.66e@xmath17706 & 3.03e@xmath17706 & 1.13e@xmath17705 & 3.11e@xmath17706 & 1.94e@xmath17705 & 8.13e@xmath17706 & 5.44e@xmath17706 & 3.61e@xmath17706 + @xmath214ti & 8.04e@xmath17706 & 8.24e@xmath17706 & 3.69e@xmath17706 & 1.71e@xmath17705 & 3.07e@xmath17706 & 1.49e@xmath17705 & 4.41e@xmath17706 & 2.69e@xmath17705 & 1.44e@xmath17705 + @xmath216ti & 1.42e@xmath17705 & 1.01e@xmath17705 & 8.39e@xmath17706 & 1.98e@xmath17705 & 5.51e@xmath17706 & 2.25e@xmath17705 & 9.55e@xmath17706 & 5.79e@xmath17705 & 4.07e@xmath17705 + @xmath43ti & 2.30e@xmath17704 & 2.53e@xmath17704 & 2.13e@xmath17704 & 5.35e@xmath17704 & 1.49e@xmath17704 & 1.03e@xmath17703 & 4.39e@xmath17704 & 1.29e@xmath17703 & 9.07e@xmath17704 + @xmath217ti & 1.71e@xmath17705 & 1.86e@xmath17705 & 1.71e@xmath17705 & 5.02e@xmath17705 & 1.39e@xmath17705 & 9.38e@xmath17705 & 3.98e@xmath17705 & 5.62e@xmath17705 & 3.93e@xmath17705 + @xmath218ti & 5.55e@xmath17713 & 1.75e@xmath17712 & 3.58e@xmath17712 & 1.93e@xmath17712 & 8.27e@xmath17713 & 7.21e@xmath17712 & 2.65e@xmath17712 & 1.69e@xmath17712 & 4.57e@xmath17713 + @xmath218v & 1.49e@xmath17711 & 9.90e@xmath17711 & 1.07e@xmath17711 & 1.17e@xmath17710 & 9.31e@xmath17712 & 1.05e@xmath17710 & 1.23e@xmath17711 & 1.44e@xmath17710 & 3.89e@xmath17711 + @xmath219v & 4.18e@xmath17705 & 3.70e@xmath17705 & 2.84e@xmath17705 & 6.22e@xmath17705 & 1.72e@xmath17705 & 8.21e@xmath17705 & 3.48e@xmath17705 & 1.31e@xmath17704 & 9.20e@xmath17705 + @xmath218cr & 2.08e@xmath17705 & 4.53e@xmath17705 & 2.01e@xmath17705 & 7.01e@xmath17705 & 1.30e@xmath17705 & 7.56e@xmath17705 & 2.71e@xmath17705 & 7.67e@xmath17705 & 4.10e@xmath17705 + @xmath220cr & 8.68e@xmath17704 & 1.57e@xmath17703 & 1.33e@xmath17703 & 1.87e@xmath17703 & 5.20e@xmath17704 & 4.58e@xmath17703 & 1.95e@xmath17703 & 3.99e@xmath17703 & 2.81e@xmath17703 + @xmath221cr & 4.44e@xmath17705 & 1.13e@xmath17704 & 9.41e@xmath17705 & 1.21e@xmath17704 & 3.25e@xmath17705 & 2.77e@xmath17704 & 1.17e@xmath17704 & 1.79e@xmath17704 & 1.24e@xmath17704 + @xmath222cr & 2.90e@xmath17710 & 9.47e@xmath17709 & 9.93e@xmath17711 & 1.93e@xmath17708 & 1.37e@xmath17709 & 3.51e@xmath17709 & 3.43e@xmath17710 & 1.59e@xmath17708 & 4.29e@xmath17709 + @xmath223mn & 9.23e@xmath17705 & 2.87e@xmath17704 & 2.26e@xmath17704 & 3.33e@xmath17704 & 8.60e@xmath17705 & 6.30e@xmath17704 & 2.65e@xmath17704 & 3.98e@xmath17704 & 2.68e@xmath17704 + @xmath222fe & 5.65e@xmath17704 & 2.42e@xmath17703 & 1.47e@xmath17703 & 2.94e@xmath17703 & 6.02e@xmath17704 & 3.70e@xmath17703 & 1.42e@xmath17703 & 2.83e@xmath17703 & 1.69e@xmath17703 + @xmath25fe & 8.41e@xmath17702 & 1.13e@xmath17701 & 1.01e@xmath17701 & 1.62e@xmath17701 & 4.51e@xmath17702 & 2.81e@xmath17701 & 1.20e@xmath17701 & 3.71e@xmath17701 & 2.61e@xmath17701 + @xmath224fe & 1.27e@xmath17703 & 1.46e@xmath17703 & 1.38e@xmath17703 & 2.67e@xmath17703 & 7.43e@xmath17704 & 4.27e@xmath17703 & 1.82e@xmath17703 & 6.23e@xmath17703 & 4.38e@xmath17703 + @xmath128fe & 3.22e@xmath17710 & 2.92e@xmath17709 & 1.73e@xmath17710 & 9.60e@xmath17709 & 6.86e@xmath17710 & 2.97e@xmath17709 & 2.99e@xmath17710 & 6.81e@xmath17709 & 1.84e@xmath17709 + @xmath225co & 9.29e@xmath17704 & 9.93e@xmath17704 & 8.51e@xmath17704 & 1.56e@xmath17703 & 4.36e@xmath17704 & 2.19e@xmath17703 & 9.33e@xmath17704 & 3.27e@xmath17703 & 2.30e@xmath17703 + @xmath128ni & 1.54e@xmath17703 & 1.79e@xmath17703 & 1.65e@xmath17703 & 3.39e@xmath17703 & 9.28e@xmath17704 & 5.04e@xmath17703 & 2.12e@xmath17703 & 6.20e@xmath17703 & 4.31e@xmath17703 + @xmath226ni & 3.51e@xmath17703 & 3.60e@xmath17703 & 3.30e@xmath17703 & 7.41e@xmath17703 & 2.07e@xmath17703 & 1.06e@xmath17702 & 4.53e@xmath17703 & 1.59e@xmath17702 & 1.12e@xmath17702 + @xmath227ni & 4.93e@xmath17705 & 4.33e@xmath17705 & 3.71e@xmath17705 & 8.34e@xmath17705 & 2.33e@xmath17705 & 1.22e@xmath17704 & 5.20e@xmath17705 & 1.92e@xmath17704 & 1.35e@xmath17704 + @xmath228ni & 5.51e@xmath17705 & 4.85e@xmath17705 & 4.03e@xmath17705 & 8.84e@xmath17705 & 2.47e@xmath17705 & 1.31e@xmath17704 & 5.59e@xmath17705 & 2.04e@xmath17704 & 1.44e@xmath17704 + @xmath44ni & 4.92e@xmath17713 & 3.38e@xmath17712 & 4.38e@xmath17712 & 4.65e@xmath17712 & 2.08e@xmath17712 & 1.23e@xmath17711 & 1.23e@xmath17711 & 7.15e@xmath17712 & 1.94e@xmath17712 + @xmath229cu & 2.26e@xmath17705 & 2.06e@xmath17705 & 1.70e@xmath17705 & 3.67e@xmath17705 & 1.02e@xmath17705 & 5.59e@xmath17705 & 2.38e@xmath17705 & 8.75e@xmath17705 & 6.15e@xmath17705 + @xmath230cu & 8.36e@xmath17707 & 8.25e@xmath17707 & 7.88e@xmath17707 & 2.37e@xmath17706 & 6.61e@xmath17707 & 4.23e@xmath17706 & 1.80e@xmath17706 & 5.59e@xmath17706 & 3.93e@xmath17706 + @xmath44zn & 5.76e@xmath17704 & 5.24e@xmath17704 & 4.72e@xmath17704 & 1.21e@xmath17703 & 3.39e@xmath17704 & 1.86e@xmath17703 & 7.93e@xmath17704 & 2.58e@xmath17703 & 1.81e@xmath17703 + @xmath231zn & 7.29e@xmath17706 & 6.25e@xmath17706 & 5.68e@xmath17706 & 1.66e@xmath17705 & 4.62e@xmath17706 & 2.83e@xmath17705 & 1.21e@xmath17705 & 3.56e@xmath17705 & 2.51e@xmath17705 + @xmath232zn & 7.52e@xmath17707 & 6.36e@xmath17707 & 5.66e@xmath17707 & 1.73e@xmath17706 & 4.83e@xmath17707 & 2.94e@xmath17706 & 1.25e@xmath17706 & 2.81e@xmath17706 & 1.98e@xmath17706 + @xmath233zn & 7.55e@xmath17708 & 6.89e@xmath17708 & 5.63e@xmath17708 & 1.33e@xmath17707 & 3.72e@xmath17708 & 1.74e@xmath17707 & 7.40e@xmath17708 & 7.00e@xmath17707 & 4.92e@xmath17707 + @xmath234zn & 1.84e@xmath17713 & 1.53e@xmath17713 & 4.52e@xmath17712 & 1.60e@xmath17712 & 1.13e@xmath17712 & 8.04e@xmath17712 & 8.04e@xmath17712 & 4.72e@xmath17712 & 1.28e@xmath17712 + @xmath235ga & 2.63e@xmath17708 & 1.92e@xmath17708 & 1.75e@xmath17708 & 5.19e@xmath17708 & 1.45e@xmath17708 & 8.18e@xmath17708 & 3.49e@xmath17708 & 1.32e@xmath17707 & 9.25e@xmath17708 + @xmath236ga & 7.46e@xmath17713 & 1.23e@xmath17712 & 2.84e@xmath17711 & 2.97e@xmath17712 & 1.72e@xmath17712 & 1.72e@xmath17711 & 1.71e@xmath17711 & 9.27e@xmath17712 & 2.63e@xmath17712 + @xmath234ge & 3.10e@xmath17708 & 2.19e@xmath17708 & 1.81e@xmath17708 & 4.93e@xmath17708 & 1.38e@xmath17708 & 7.30e@xmath17708 & 3.11e@xmath17708 & 1.12e@xmath17707 & 7.87e@xmath17708 + @xmath237ge & 4.43e@xmath17712 & 2.23e@xmath17712 & 1.08e@xmath17711 & 6.56e@xmath17712 & 2.34e@xmath17712 & 6.35e@xmath17712 & 5.98e@xmath17712 & 2.48e@xmath17711 & 6.79e@xmath17712 + @xmath238ge & 1.15e@xmath17712 & 1.52e@xmath17712 & 2.39e@xmath17711 & 6.92e@xmath17712 & 3.62e@xmath17712 & 3.00e@xmath17711 & 2.97e@xmath17711 & 1.47e@xmath17711 & 4.18e@xmath17712 + @xmath239ge & 1.27e@xmath17712 & 7.00e@xmath17713 & 5.45e@xmath17712 & 2.57e@xmath17712 & 1.84e@xmath17712 & 1.54e@xmath17711 & 1.54e@xmath17711 & 3.97e@xmath17712 & 1.11e@xmath17712 crrrrrrrrr @xmath192na & 4.74e@xmath17705 & 1.09e@xmath17705 & 6.81e@xmath17706 & 3.00e@xmath17705 & 1.54e@xmath17705 & 4.11e@xmath17706 & 3.33e@xmath17706 & 1.82e@xmath17704 & 1.06e@xmath17704 + @xmath196al & 8.17e@xmath17707 & 9.13e@xmath17707 & 1.04e@xmath17706 & 2.57e@xmath17706 & 9.78e@xmath17707 & 4.26e@xmath17706 & 1.22e@xmath17706 & 7.45e@xmath17706 & 3.74e@xmath17706 + @xmath211ca & 3.40e@xmath17706 & 1.06e@xmath17705 & 3.69e@xmath17706 & 7.94e@xmath17706 & 6.26e@xmath17707 & 1.30e@xmath17705 & 1.37e@xmath17706 & 1.62e@xmath17705 & 4.52e@xmath17706 + @xmath42ti & 2.05e@xmath17704 & 1.68e@xmath17704 & 1.51e@xmath17704 & 4.93e@xmath17704 & 1.37e@xmath17704 & 8.70e@xmath17704 & 3.69e@xmath17704 & 1.26e@xmath17703 & 8.82e@xmath17704 + @xmath226fe & 2.45e@xmath17713 & 2.25e@xmath17713 & 9.60e@xmath17713 & 5.11e@xmath17713 & 2.34e@xmath17713 & 2.74e@xmath17712 & 2.74e@xmath17712 & 1.69e@xmath17712 & 4.60e@xmath17713 + @xmath25ni & 8.41e@xmath17702 & 1.12e@xmath17701 & 1.01e@xmath17701 & 1.62e@xmath17701 & 4.51e@xmath17702 & 2.81e@xmath17701 & 1.20e@xmath17701 & 3.71e@xmath17701 & 2.61e@xmath17701 + @xmath224ni & 1.27e@xmath17703 & 1.46e@xmath17703 & 1.38e@xmath17703 & 2.66e@xmath17703 & 7.43e@xmath17704 & 4.27e@xmath17703 & 1.81e@xmath17703 & 6.22e@xmath17703 & 4.37e@xmath17703 | we perform hydrodynamical and nucleosynthesis calculations of core - collapse supernovae ( sne ) and hypernovae ( hne ) of population ( pop ) iii stars .
we provide new yields for the main - sequence mass of @xmath0 @xmath1 and the explosion energy of @xmath2 ergs to apply for chemical evolution studies .
our hn yields based on the mixing - fallback model of explosions reproduce the observed abundance patterns of extremely metal - poor ( emp ) stars ( @xmath3 } < -3 $ ] ) , while those of very metal - poor ( vmp ) stars ( @xmath4 } < -2 $ ] ) are reproduced by the normal sn yields integrated over the salpeter initial mass function .
moreover , the observed trends of abundance ratios [ x / fe ] against [ fe / h ] with small dispersions for the emp stars can be reproduced as a sequence resulting from the various combination of @xmath5 and @xmath6 .
this is because we adopt the empirical relation that a larger amount of fe is ejected by more massive hne .
our results imply that the observed trends with small dispersions do not necessarily mean the rapid homogeneous mixing in the early galactic halo at [ fe / h ] @xmath7 , but can be reproduced by the `` inhomogeneous '' chemical evolution model .
in addition , we examine how the modifications of the distributions of the electron mole fraction @xmath8 and the density in the presupernova models improve the agreement with observations . in this connection , we discuss possible contributions of nucleosynthesis in the neutrino - driven wind and the accretion disk . |
the einstein field equation has two parameters , the cosmological constant @xmath9 and the gravitational constant @xmath10 . in 1998 ,
the discovery that the accelerated expansion of the universe is driven by the dark energy ( de ) from the type ia supernovae ( sn ia ) observations ( riess et al .
1998 ; perlmutter et al . 1999 ) greatly astonished the world .
the wilkinson microwave anisotropy probe ( peiris et al . 2003 ; spergel et al . 2007 ) , combined with more accurate sn ia data ( riess et al .
2004 ) indicates that the universe is almost spatially flat and the dark energy accounts for about @xmath11 of the total content of the universe .
however , we know little about the nature of dark energy except for its negative pressure .
observations strongly favour a small and positive value of the effective cosmological constant at the present epoch . among many possible alternatives ,
the simplest and theoretically appealing possibility of dark energy is the energy density stored on the vacuum state of all existing fields in the universe i. e. , @xmath12 .
the variable cosmological constant ( overduin and cooperstock 1998 ; sahni and starobinsky 2000 ; peebles and ratra 2003 ; padmanabhan 2003 , 2008 ; freese 2005 ) is one of the phenomenological ways to explain the dark energy problem , because it is a straightforward modification of the cosmological constant @xmath9 which enable itself to be compatible with observations .
the problem in this approach is to determine the right dependence of @xmath9 upon scale factor @xmath13 or @xmath14 .
motivated by dimensional grounds with quantum cosmology , the variation of cosmological term as @xmath15 is considered by chen and wu ( 1990 ) .
however , several ans@xmath16tz have been proposed in which the @xmath9-term decays with time ( gasperini 1988 ; berman 1990 , 1991 , 2001 ; ratra and peebles 1988 ; abdussattar and vishwakarma 1996 ) .
several authors have recently studied the time dependent cosmological constant in different contexts ( singh et al .
2007 ; pradhan and kumhar 2009 ; pradhan and jotania 2010 , 2011 ; pradhan 2011 ; amirhashchi et al .
2011a , b ; pradhan et al .
2011 , 2013a , b , c ) .
+ the other constant of einstein s field equations i.e. the gravitational constant ( @xmath10 ) plays the role of coupling constant between geometry and matter .
recent observations also incertitude the stability of fundamental constants and `` equivalence principle '' of general relativity .
dirac ( 1937a , b ) was first to introduce the time variation of the gravitational constant @xmath10 in his large number hypothesis and since then it has been used frequently in numerous modifications of general theory of relativity .
@xmath10 has many interesting consequences in astrophysics .
it is shown that g - varying cosmology is consistent with whatsoever cosmological observations available at present ( canuto and narlikar 1980 ) .
several authors have recently investigated and discussed the time dependent @xmath9 and @xmath10 in different contexts ( saha 2001a ; singh et al . 2008 ; singh and kale 2009 ; amirhashchi et al . 2012 ; yadav et al . 2012 ; chawla et al . 2012 ) .
recently , yadav and sharma ( 2013 ) and yadav ( 2012 ) have discussed about transit universe in bianchi type - v space - time with variable g and @xmath9 .
+ anisotropic bianchi type - i universe , which is more general than frw universe , plays a significant role to understand the phenomenon like formation of galaxies in early universe .
theoretical arguments as well as the recent observations of cosmic microwave background radiation ( cmbr ) support the existence of anisotropic phase that approaches an isotropic one . motivated by the above discussions , in this paper , we propose to study homogeneous and anisotropic bianchi type - i transit cosmological models with time dependent gravitational and cosmological `` constants '' .
the paper is organized as follows . in sect .
@xmath17 , the metric and basic equations have been presented .
section @xmath18 deals with solutions of field equations . in sect .
@xmath19 , the results and discussions are described .
the statefinder diagnostic has been discussed in sect .
finally , conclusions are summarized in the last sect . @xmath21 .
we consider the space - time metric of the spatially homogeneous and anisotropic bianchi - i of the form @xmath22 where a(t ) , b(t ) and c(t ) are the metric functions of cosmic time t. + einstein field equations with time - dependent @xmath10 and @xmath9 are given by @xmath23 where the symbols have their usual meaning .
+ for a perfect fluid , the stress - energy - momentum tensor @xmath24 is given by @xmath25 where @xmath26 is the matter density , p is the thermodynamics pressure and @xmath27 is the fluid four - velocity vector of the fluid satisfying the condition @xmath28 in the field equations ( [ eq2 ] ) , @xmath9 accounts for vacuum energy with its energy density @xmath29 and pressure @xmath30 satisfying the equation of state @xmath31 the critical density and the density parameters for matter and cosmological constant are , respectively , defined as @xmath32 @xmath33 @xmath34 we observe that the density parameters @xmath35 and @xmath36 are singular when h = 0 . + in a comoving system of coordinates , the field eqs . ( [ eq2 ] ) for the metric ( [ eq1 ] ) with ( [ eq3 ] ) read as @xmath37 @xmath38 @xmath39 @xmath40 the covariant divergence of eq .
( [ eq2 ] ) yields @xmath41 spatial volume for the model given by eq .
( [ eq1 ] ) reads as @xmath42 we define average scale factor a of anisotropic model as @xmath43 so that generalized mean hubble parameter @xmath44 is given by @xmath45 where @xmath46 are the directional hubble parameters in direction of x , y and z respectively and a dot denotes differentiation with respect to cosmic time t. + from eqs .
( [ eq15 ] ) and ( [ eq16 ] ) , we obtain an important relation @xmath47 expressions for the dynamical scalars such as the expansion scalar @xmath48 , anisotropy parameter @xmath49 and the shear scalar @xmath50 are defined as usual : @xmath51 @xmath52 @xmath53 - \frac{\theta^{2}}{6 } .\ ] ] we define deceleration parameter ( dp ) q as @xmath54
the field eqs . ( [ eq9])@xmath55([eq12 ] ) are a system of four equations with seven unknown parameters @xmath56 , @xmath57 , @xmath58 , @xmath10 , @xmath59 , @xmath26 and @xmath9 .
hence , three additional constraints relating these parameters are required to obtain explicit solution of the system .
+ so firstly , we assume a power - law form of the gravitational constant ( @xmath10 ) with scale factor @xmath60 as proposed by singh and kumar ( 2009 ) and chawla et al .
( 2012 ) @xmath61 where m is a constant . for sake of mathematical simplicity ,
( [ eq22 ] ) may be written as @xmath62 where @xmath63 is a positive constant .
+ secondly , we assume equation of state for perfect fluid as @xmath64 where @xmath65 ( @xmath66 ) is constant .
+ following the technique ( pradhan 2013 ; saha 2001a , b ; saha et al . 2012 ; pradhan and amirhashchi 2011 ) , we get three equations from the field eqs .
( [ eq9])@xmath55([eq11 ] ) @xmath67 @xmath68 @xmath69 where @xmath70 and @xmath71 are constants of integration . finally ,
using @xmath72 , we write the metric functions from eqs . ( [ eq25])@xmath55([eq27 ] ) in explicit form as @xmath73 @xmath74 @xmath75 where constants @xmath76 and @xmath77 satisfy the fallowing two relations : @xmath78 in the particular case @xmath79{d_{1}d_{2 } } , \indent l_{2 } = \sqrt[3]{d_{1}^{-1}d_{3 } } , \indent l_{3 } = \sqrt[3]{(d_{2}d_{3})^{-1}},\ ] ] and @xmath80 now , the metric functions can be determined as functions of cosmic time t if the average scale factor is known .
hence , following ( yadav and sharma 2013 ; yadav 2012 ; pradhan et al .
2013d ) we consider the _ ansatz _ for the scale factor , where increase in term of time evolution is @xmath81 this _ ansatz _ generalizes the one proposed in ( pradhan 2013 ; saha et al .
2012 ; pradhan and amirhashchi 2011 ) .
this choice of scale factor yields a time - dependent deceleration parameter ( see eq .
( [ eq47 ] ) ) such that before dark energy era ( cosmological constant ) , the corresponding solution gives inflation and radiation / matter dominance era with subsequent transition from deceleration to acceleration .
thus , our choice of scale factor is physically acceptable .
the motivation for such consideration is due to observational fact that the universe has accelerated expansion at present as observed in recent observations of type ia supernova ( riess et al .
1998 ; perlmutter et al . 1999 ; tonry et al . 2003 ; clocchiatti et al . 2006 ) and cmb anisotropies ( de bernardis et al . 2002 ; bennett et al . 2003
; hanany et al .
2000 ) and decelerated expansion in the past .
it is well established the transition redshift from decelerating expansion to accelerated expansion is about @xmath82 .
now for a universe which was decelerating in past and accelerating at the present time , the dp must show signature flipping ( padmanabhan and roychowdhury 2003 ; amendola 2003 ; riess et al .
this theme motivates to choose such scale factor ( [ eq34 ] ) that yields a time dependent dp ( [ eq47 ] ) .
+ using eq .
( [ eq34 ] ) in eqs .
( [ eq28])@xmath55([eq30 ] ) , we obtain @xmath83},\ ] ] @xmath84},\ ] ] @xmath85},\ ] ] where @xmath86 from eqs .
( [ eq35])@xmath55([eq37 ] ) , we obtain @xmath87 @xmath88 @xmath89 and + @xmath90 @xmath91 @xmath92 hence the geometry of the universe ( [ eq1 ] ) is reduced to @xmath93 @xmath94.\ ] ]
expressions for physical parameters such as spatial volume ( @xmath95 ) , mean hubble s parameter ( @xmath44 ) , expansion scalar ( @xmath96 ) , shear scalar ( @xmath97 ) and anisotropy parameter ( @xmath98 ) for model ( [ eq41 ] ) are given by @xmath99 @xmath100 @xmath101 @xmath102 @xmath103 where + @xmath104 .
+ from eq .
( [ eq21 ] ) , the deceleration parameter is computed as @xmath105 from eq .
( [ eq47 ] ) , we observe that @xmath106 for @xmath107 and @xmath108 for @xmath109 .
it is observed that for @xmath110 , our model is evolving from decelerating phase to accelerating phase . also , recent observations of sne ia , expose that the present universe is accelerating and the value of dp lies on some place in the range @xmath111 .
it follows that in our derived model , one can choose the value of dp consistent with the observation .
figure @xmath112 depicts the variation of deceleration parameter ( @xmath113 ) versus cosmic time which gives the behaviour of @xmath113 as in accelerating phase at present epoch for different values of @xmath114 which is consistent with recent observations of type ia supernovae ( riess et al .
1998 , 2004 ; perlmutter et al . 1999
; tonry et al . 2003 ; clocchiatti et al . 2006 ) . + vs time @xmath14 for @xmath115 , @xmath116 , @xmath117 vs time @xmath14 for @xmath115 , @xmath116 , @xmath117 from above eq .
( [ eq47 ] ) , present value of deceleration parameter can be estimated as @xmath118 where where @xmath119 is present value of hubble s parameter and @xmath120 is the age of universe at present epoch .
recent observations show that the deceleration parameter of the universe is in the range @xmath121 i.e @xmath122 . for @xmath2
, we obtain @xmath123 which is similar to the observed value of dp at present epoch ( cunha et al .
therefore , we restrict the values of @xmath124 and @xmath125 such that the condition @xmath2 is satisfied for graphical representations of the physical parameters . as a representative case , we have considered four values of @xmath126 as ( 0.25 , 0.9259259260 ) , ( 0.50 , 0.1.851851852 ) , ( 0.75 , 2.77777778 ) and ( 3 , 11.11111111 ) respectively for graphic presentation of figures 1@xmath558 .
+ from eqs .
( [ eq42 ] ) and ( [ eq44 ] ) we observe that the spatial volume is zero at @xmath127 and the expansion scalar is infinite , which show that the universe starts evolving with zero volume at @xmath127 which is big bang scenario . from eqs .
( [ eq35])@xmath55([eq37 ] ) , we observe that the spatial scale factors are zero at the initial epoch @xmath127 and hence the model has a point type singularity ( maccallum 1971 ) .
we observe that proper volume increases with time .
+ from eq .
( [ eq45 ] ) , we observe that at late time when @xmath128 , @xmath129 .
thus , our model has transition from initial anisotropy to isotropy at present epoch which is in good harmony with current observations .
figure @xmath17 depicts the variation of anisotropic parameter ( @xmath98 ) versus cosmic time @xmath14 . from the figure
, we observe that @xmath98 decreases with time and tends to zero as @xmath128 .
thus , the observed isotropy of the universe can be achieved in our model at present epoch .
+ it is important to note here that @xmath130 spread out to be constant .
therefore the model of the universe goes up homogeneity and matter is dynamically negligible near the origin .
this is in good agreement with the result already given by collins ( 1977 ) .
+ vs time @xmath14 for @xmath131 , @xmath115 , @xmath116 , @xmath132 , @xmath133 vs time @xmath14 for @xmath131 , @xmath115 , @xmath116 , @xmath132 , @xmath133 vs time @xmath14 for @xmath115 , @xmath116 , @xmath132 , @xmath133 vs time @xmath14 for @xmath115 , @xmath116 , @xmath132 , @xmath133 vs time @xmath14 for @xmath115 , @xmath116 , @xmath117 vs time @xmath14 for @xmath115 , @xmath116 , @xmath117 vs time @xmath14 for @xmath131 , @xmath115 , @xmath116 , @xmath132 , @xmath134 , @xmath5 ] vs time @xmath14 for @xmath131 , @xmath115 , @xmath116 , @xmath132 , @xmath134 , @xmath5 ] , @xmath36 , @xmath136 vs time @xmath14 for @xmath115 , @xmath116 , @xmath132 , @xmath134 , @xmath5 ] , @xmath36 , @xmath136 vs time @xmath14 for @xmath115 , @xmath116 , @xmath132 , @xmath134 , @xmath5 ] , @xmath36 , @xmath136 vs time @xmath14 for @xmath115 , @xmath116 , @xmath132 , @xmath134 , @xmath5 ] , @xmath36 , @xmath136 vs time @xmath14 for @xmath115 , @xmath116 , @xmath132 , @xmath134 , @xmath5 ] , @xmath36 , @xmath136 vs time @xmath14 for @xmath115 , @xmath116 , @xmath132 , @xmath137 , @xmath5,width=264,height=264 ] using eq .
( [ eq34 ] ) into ( [ eq23 ] ) , the gravitational constant is obtained as @xmath138 from eq .
( [ eq49 ] ) , we observe that @xmath10 is an increasing function of time i.e. , @xmath139 as @xmath140 whereas for @xmath128 , @xmath141 .
this nature of variation of @xmath10 with cosmic time is shown in figure @xmath18 for three values of @xmath142 and @xmath143 . when the universe is required to have expanded from a finite minimum volume ,
the critical density assumption and conservation of energy - momentum tensor dictate that @xmath10 increases in a perpetually expanding universe ( abdel - rahaman 1990 ) .
in most variable g cosmologies ( weinberg 1972 ; norman 1986 ) , g is a decreasing function of time .
but the possibility of an increasing @xmath10 has also been suggested by several authors ( pradhan et al .
2007 ; singh et al . 2008
; singh and kale 2009 ; singh et al .
an appealing feature of this modification in @xmath10 is that it leaves the form of einstein s equations formally unchanged by allowing the variation of @xmath10 to be accompanied by a change in @xmath9 and enables us to solve many cosmological problems such as the cosmological constant problem , inflationary scenario etc .
( sistero 2000 ) .
+ using eqs .
( [ eq24 ] ) , ( [ eq39 ] ) and ( [ eq40 ] ) and solving the field eqs .
( [ eq9])@xmath55([eq12 ] ) , we get the expressions for energy density , pressure and cosmological constant for universe ( [ eq41 ] ) as @xmath144,\ ] ] @xmath145,\ ] ] @xmath146,\ ] ] where + @xmath147 . + we find that the above solutions satisfy eq .
( [ eq13 ] ) identically and hence represent exact solution of einstein s field equations ( [ eq9])@xmath55([eq12 ] ) .
+ from above relations ( [ eq50])@xmath55([eq52 ] ) , we can obtain the expressions of energy density , pressure and cosmological constant for four types of models : * when @xmath148 , we obtain empty model .
* when @xmath149 , we obtain radiation dominated model . * when @xmath150 , we have the degenerate vacuum or false vacuum or @xmath26 vacuum model ( cho 1992 ) . * when @xmath151 , the fluid distribution corresponds with the equation of state @xmath152 which is known as zeldovich fluid or stiff fluid model ( zeldovich 1962 ; barrow 1978 ) . from eq .
( [ eq50 ] ) , it is observed that the energy density @xmath26 is a decreasing function of time and @xmath153 under condition @xmath154 .
the energy density has been graphed versus time in figure @xmath19 for @xmath155 and @xmath112 .
it is evident that the energy density remains positive in all three types of models under appropriate condition .
however , it decreases more sharply with the cosmic time in zeldovich universe , compare to radiation dominated and empty fluid universes .
+ the behavior of the universe in this model will be determined by the cosmological term @xmath9 , this term has the same effect as a uniform mass density @xmath156 which is constant in time .
a positive value of @xmath9 corresponds to a negative effective mass density ( repulsion ) .
hence , we expect that in the universe with a positive value of @xmath9 the expansion will tend to accelerate whereas in the universe with negative value of @xmath9 the expansion will slow down , stop and reverse .
figure @xmath20 is the plot of cosmological term @xmath9 versus time for @xmath155 and @xmath112 . in all three types of models , we observe that @xmath9 is decreasing function of time @xmath14 and it approaches a small positive value at late time ( i.e. at present epoch ) . however , it decreases more sharply with the cosmic time in empty universe , compare to radiation dominated and stiff fluid universes .
recent cosmological observations ( riess et al .
1998 , 2004 ; perlmutter et al . 1999 ; tonry et al . 2003 ; clocchiatti et al .
2006 ) suggest the existence of a positive cosmological constant @xmath9 with the magnitude @xmath157 .
these observations on magnitude and red - shift of type ia supernova suggest that our universe may be an accelerating one with induced cosmological density through the cosmological @xmath9-term .
thus , the nature of @xmath9 in our derived models are supported by recent observations . + the vacuum energy density ( @xmath158 ) , critical density @xmath159 and the density parameters @xmath160 for model ( [ eq41 ] ) read as @xmath161 @xmath162,\ ] ] @xmath163 @xmath164}{3(1+\gamma)\left(\frac{k}{t } + 1 \right)^{2}},\ ] ] @xmath165}{3 ( 1 + \gamma)(\frac{k}{t } + 1)^{2}}.\ ] ] adding eqs .
( [ eq55 ] ) and ( [ eq56 ] ) , we get @xmath166 where @xmath167 . for @xmath168
, we have @xmath169 .
we also observe from eq .
( [ eq57 ] ) that @xmath170 approaches to one for sufficiently large time independent to @xmath171 .
figures @xmath21 and @xmath172 plot the variation of density parameters for matter ( @xmath35 ) and cosmological constant ( @xmath36 ) versus @xmath14 respectively . from these figures
it is clear that the universe is dominated by matter in early stage of evolution whereas the universe is dominated by dark energy ( cosmological constant @xmath9 ) at present epoch .
figure @xmath173 plots the variation of total energy parameter ( @xmath136 ) versus cosmic time @xmath14 . from the fig .
@xmath173 , we observe that @xmath174 at late time for arbitrary value of @xmath171 .
this is in good agreement with the observational results ( spergel 2003 ) .
+ it is worth mentioned here that data in favor of nonzero cosmological constant involves the estimates of the age of the universe as compared with the estimates of the hubble parameter . with taking into account uncertainties in models the best fit to guarantee consensus between all observational constraints ( krauss and turner 1995 ; ostriker and steinhardt 1995 ; bahcall et al .
1999 ) is @xmath175 @xmath176 where @xmath177 , and the critical density @xmath178 , which correspond to @xmath169 , is given by @xmath179 which is in good agreement with observations as discussed in introduction .
confrontation of models with observations in cosmology as well as the inflationary paradigm , compellingly favor treating the cosmological constant as a variable dynamical quantity . + for different values of @xmath125 and @xmath124 , we can generate a class of models of the universe in bianchi type - i space - time with time dependent gravitational and cosmological constants .
we observe that for @xmath4 and @xmath5 , we obtain a class of transit models of the universe from early decelerated to present accelerating phase . for @xmath180 and @xmath5
, we obtain accelerating models at present epoch . for examples : + * if we put @xmath134 in eq .
( [ eq34 ] ) , we obtain @xmath181 . in this case
, we obtain the expressions for different physical and geometric quantities as obtained by pradhan et al .
( 2013d ) .
thus , our investigations generalize the recent results of pradhan et al .
( 2013e ) .
* if we put @xmath134 and @xmath5 in eq . ( [ eq34 ] ) , we obtain @xmath182 . in this case
, we obtain the expressions for different physical parameters and geometric quantities by putting @xmath134 and @xmath5 in eqs .
( [ eq42])@xmath55([eq57 ] ) .
figure @xmath183 depicts the variation of dp with cosmic time for different values of ( @xmath124 , @xmath125 ) . from fig .
@xmath183 , we observe that for @xmath184 and @xmath5 the model has a transition from very early decelerated phase to the present accelerating phase .
we have already mentioned in sect .
@xmath18 that in such type of universe , the dp must show signature interchange ( padmanabhan & roychowdhury 2003 ; amendola 2003 ; riess et al . 2001 ) .
the variation of energy density , cosmological constant and density parameters versus cosmic time @xmath14 have been shown in figs .
@xmath185 , @xmath186 and @xmath187 respectively .
* if we put @xmath137 and @xmath5 in eq .
( [ eq34 ] ) , we obtain @xmath188 . in this case
, we obtain the expressions for different physical parameters and geometric quantities as usual . from fig .
@xmath183 , we observe that for @xmath189 and @xmath5 , the model has transition from early decelerated phase to the present accelerating phase .
the variation of energy density , cosmological constant and density parameters versus cosmic time @xmath14 have been shown in figs .
@xmath190 , @xmath191 and @xmath192 respectively .
the present value @xmath193 of the deceleration parameter obtained from observations are @xmath194 ( schuecker et al .
studies of galaxy from redshift surveys provide a value of @xmath195 , with an upper limit of @xmath196 ( schuecker et al .
recent observations show that the deceleration parameter of the universe is in the range @xmath121 i.e @xmath122 .
first , we set @xmath137 and @xmath5 in eq .
( [ eq48 ] ) , we obtain @xmath197 .
this value is very near to the observed value of dp ( i.e. , @xmath122 ) at present epoch ( cunha et al . 2009 ) .
secondly , if we choose @xmath137 and @xmath5 , we observe that all the values of physical and geometric parameters are easily integrable .
hence this case is important from physical aspects . * if we put @xmath198 and @xmath5 in eq .
( [ eq34 ] ) , we obtain @xmath199 . in this case
, we obtain the expressions for different physical parameters and geometric quantities as usual . from fig .
@xmath183 , one can see that for @xmath198 and @xmath5 the model is accelerating at present epoch .
the other physical parameters have the same property as already discussed . * if we put @xmath6 in eq .
( [ eq34 ] ) , we obtain @xmath200 . in this case
the universe has non - singular origin which seems reasonable to envision the dynamics of future universe . in this case
, we found that energy density ( @xmath26 ) is always negative and hence it is an unphysical case .
we plan to work out a physically viable non - singular model in forthcoming paper .
the various cosmological observational data support the @xmath9 cold dark matter ( @xmath9cdm ) model , in which the cosmological constant @xmath9 plays a role of dark energy in general relativity . at the current stage ,
the @xmath9cdm model is considered to be a standard cosmological model .
sahni et al .
( 2003 ) have introduced a pair of parameters @xmath201 , called statefinder parameters . in fact , trajectories in the @xmath201 plane corresponding to different cosmological models demonstrate qualitatively different behavior .
the statefinder parameters can effectively differentiate between different form of dark energy and provide simple diagnosis regarding whether a particular model fits into the basic observational data .
the above statefinder diagnostic pair has the following form : @xmath202 to differentiate among different form of dark energy . here
@xmath44 is the hubble parameter and @xmath113 is the deceleration parameter .
the two parameters @xmath201 are dimensionless and are geometrical since they are derived from the cosmic scale factor @xmath203 alone , though one can reproduce them in terms of the parameters of dark energy and dark matter .
this pair provides information about dark energy in a model@xmath55independent way , that is , it categorizes dark energy in the context of back - ground geometry only which is not dependent on theory of gravity .
hence , geometrical variables are universal . + for our model , the parameters @xmath201 can be explicitly written in terms of @xmath14 as @xmath204 @xmath205}.\ ] ] from eqs .
( [ eq59 ] ) and ( [ eq60 ] ) we observe that @xmath206 is negative when @xmath207 .
it is observed that the universe starts from an einstein static era ( @xmath208 ) and goes to the @xmath9cdm model ( @xmath209 ) .
in this paper , we have presented a new class of models of accelerating universe and transit universe with gravitational coupling @xmath7 and cosmological term @xmath8 in the framework of general relativity .
the models represent expanding , shearing and non - rotating universe .
the parameters @xmath44 , @xmath96 , and @xmath97 diverge at the initial singularity .
there is a point type singularity ( maccallum 1971 ) at @xmath127 in the models .
the rate of expansion slows down and finally tends to zero at @xmath140 . the pressure , energy density and cosmological term @xmath9 become negligible whereas the scale factors , gravitational constant @xmath10 and spatial volume become infinite as @xmath128 .
the nature of decaying vacuum energy density @xmath8 in our derived models is supported by recent cosmological observations .
we observe that our derived models are isotropic at present epoch which is in good agreement with the current observations .
+ for different choice of @xmath124 and @xmath125 , we can generate a class of viable cosmological models of the universe in bianchi type space - time as well as in frw universe .
for example : if we set @xmath134 in eq .
( [ eq34 ] ) , we find @xmath210 which is used by pradhan and amirhashchi ( 2011 ) in studying the accelerating dark energy models in bianchi type - v space - time and pradhan et al .
( 2012a ) in studying bianchi type - i in scalar - tensor theory of gravitation . if we set @xmath211 in eq .
( [ eq34 ] ) , we find @xmath212 which is utilized by amirhashchi et al .
( 2011b ) in studying interacting two - fluid scenario for dark energy in frw universe . if we set @xmath213 in eq .
( [ eq34 ] ) , we find @xmath214 which is exercised by pradhan et al .
( 2012b ) to study the dark energy model in bianchi type-@xmath215 universe .
it is observed that such models are also in good harmony with current observations .
the present work generalizes the the recent works ( pradhan et al .
2013c , e ) .
+ we observe that our models approach to @xmath9cdm model .
so , from the statefinder parameter @xmath201 the behaviour of different stages of the evolution of the universe has been generated . + in summary ,
the solutions described in this paper may be useful for better understanding of the characteristic of bianchi type - i cosmological models in the evolution of the universe within the framework of time dependent gravitational and cosmological `` constants '' .
a. pradhan would like to thank the laboratory of information technologies , joint institute for nuclear research , dubna , russia for providing facility and supports where this work is done .
a. pradhan also acknowledge conscientiously the support in part by the university grants commission , new delhi , india under the grant project f.no .
41 - 899/2012 ( sr ) .
this work is also supported in part by a joint romanian - lit , jinr , dubna , research project theme no .
05 - 6 - 1060 - 2005/3013 . 000
abdel - rahaman , a .- m.m .
. gravit . * 24 * , 665 ( 1990 ) abdussattar , vishwakarma , r.g .
: pramana - j. phys . *
47 * , 41 ( 1996 ) amendola , l. : mon . not .
. soc . * 342 * , 221 ( 2003 ) amirhashchi , h. , zainuddin , h. , pradhan , a. : int . j. theor . phys . * 50 * , 2531 ( 2011a ) amirhashchi , h. , pradhan , a. , saha , b. : chin .
phys . lett . * 28 * , 039801 ( 2011b ) amirhashchi , h. , zainuddin , h. , pradhan , a. : rom . j. phys . * 57 * , 748 ( 2012 ) bahcall , n.a . ,
ostriker , j.p . , perlmutter , s. , stein - hardt , p.j .
: science * 284 * , 1481 ( 1999 ) barrow , j.d . : nature * 272 * 211 ( 1978 ) bennett , c.l . , et al . : astrophys . j. suppl . *
148 * , 97 ( 2003 ) berman , m.s .
* 29 * , 1419 ( 1990 ) berman , m.s .
: phys . rev .
d * 43 * , 75 ( 1991 ) berman , m.s . : gen . relativ
* 23 * , 465 ( 2001 ) canuto , v.m . ,
narlikar , j.v .
: astrophys .
j. * 236 * , 6 ( 1980 ) chawla , c. , mishra , r.k .
, pradhan , a. : eur .
j. plus * 127 * , 137 ( 2012 ) chen , w. , wu , y.s .
d * 41 * , 695 ( 1990 ) cho , y.m .
lett . * 68 * , 3133 ( 1992 ) clocchiatti , a. , et al .
: astrophys .
j. * 642 * , 1 ( 2006 ) collins , c.b . : j. math .
phys . * 18 * , 2116 ( 1977 ) cunha , c.e . , lima , m. , ogaizu , h. , frieman , j. , lin , h. : mon . not .
. soc . * 396 * , 2379 ( 2009 ) de bernardis , p. , et al . : ap . j. * 564 * , 559 ( 2002 ) dirac , p.a.m . :
nature * 139 * , 323 ( 1937a ) dirac , p.a.m .
: nature * 139 * , 1001 ( 1937b ) freese , k. : new astron .
rev . * 49 * , 103 ( 2005 ) gasperini , m. : class .
* 5 * , 521 ( 1988 ) hanany , s. , et al . , astrophys .
j. * 545 * , l5 ( 2000 ) krauss , l. , turner , m. : astro - ph/9504003 ( 1995 ) maccallum , m.a.h .
20 * , 57 ( 1971 ) norman , e.b . :
am . j. phys .
* 54 * , 317 ( 1986 ) ostriker , j.p . ,
steinhardt , p.j .
: nature * 377 * , 600 ( 1995 ) overduin , j.m . ,
cooperstock , f.i .
d * 58 * , 043506 ( 1998 ) padmanabhan , t. : phys
* 380 * , 235 ( 2003 ) , [ arxiv : hep - th/0212290 ] padmanabhan , t. , roychowdhury , t. : mon . not .
. soc . * 344 * , 823 ( 2003 ) padmanabhan , t. : gen .
* 40 * , 529 ( 2008 ) peebles , p.j.e . ,
ratra , b. : rev .
mod . phys . * 75 * , 559 ( 2003 ) peiris , h.v .
, et al . :
. j. suppl .
* 148 * , 213 ( 2003 ) perlmutter , s. , et al .
: astrophys .
j. * 517 * , 5 ( 1999 ) pradhan , a. , singh , a.k . ,
otarod , s. : rom . j. phys . * 52 * , 445 ( 2007 ) pradhan , a. , kumhar , s.s . : int .
. phys . * 48 * , 1466 ( 2009 ) pradhan , a. , jotania , k. : int . j. theor
. phys . * 49 * , 1719 ( 2010 ) pradhan , a. , jotania , k. : indian j. phys . *
85 * , 497 ( 2011 ) pradhan , a. : commun .
. phys . * 55 * , 931 ( 2011 ) pradhan , a. , amirhashchi , h. , zainuddin , h. : astrophys .
space sci . * 331 * , 679 ( 2011 ) pradhan , a. , amirhashchi , h. : mod .
a * 26 * , 2261 ( 2011 ) pradhan , a. , singh , a.k . ,
amirhashchi , h. : int . j. theor . phys . *
51 * , 3769 ( 2012a ) pradhan , a. , jaiswal , r. , jotania , k. , khare , r.k .
: astrophys .
space sci .
* 337 * , 401 ( 2012b ) pradhan , a. , zia , r. , singh , r.p . :
indian j. phys .
doi : 10.1007/s 12648 - 013 - 0342 - 0 ( 2013a ) pradhan , a. , jaiswal , r. , khare , r.k .
: astrophys .
space sci .
* 343 * , 489 ( 2013b ) pradhan , a. , jaiswal , r. , khare , r.k . :
basic appl .
* 2 * , 50 ( 2013c ) pradhan , a. , singh , a.k . , chauhan , d.s . :
. phys . * 52 * , 266 ( 2013d ) pradhan , a. , pandey , a.k . ,
mishra , r.k .
: preprint ( 2013e ) pradhan , a. : res .
* 13 * , 139 ( 2013 ) ratra , b. , peebles , p.j.e .
d * 37 * , 3406 ( 1988 ) riess , a.g .
j. * 116 * , 1009 ( 1998 ) riess , a.g .
, et al . :
j. * 560 * , 49 ( 2001 ) riess , a.g .
, et al . :
j. * 607 * , 665 ( 2004 ) saha , b. : mod .
a * 16 * , 1287 ( 2001a ) saha , b. : phys .
d * 64 * , 123501 ( 2001b ) saha , b. , amirhashchi , h. , pradhan , a. : astrophys .
space sci . * 342 * , 257 ( 2012 ) sahni , v. , starobinsky , a.a .
d * 9 * , 373 ( 2000 ) sahni , v. , saini , t.d . , starobinsky , a.a . , alam , u. : jetp lett . *
77 * , 201 ( 2003 ) schuecker , r. et al .
: astrophys . j. * 496 * , 635 ( 1998 ) spergel , d.n .
: astrophys .
* 148 * , 175 ( 2003 ) spergel , d.n .
, et al . , astrophys . j. suppl . * 170 * , 377 ( 2007 ) singh , c.p . , kumar , s. , pradhan , a. : class .
quantum grav .
* 24 * , 455 ( 2007 ) singh , c.p . ,
kumar , s. : int . j. theor .
phys . * 48 * , 2401 ( 2009 ) singh , j.p .
, pradhan , a. , singh , a.k .
: astrophys .
space sci .
* 314 * , 83 ( 2008 ) singh , g.p .
, kale , a.y .
. j. theor .
phys . * 48 * , 3158 ( 2009 ) singh , t. , beesham , a. , mbokazi , w.s .
30 * , 537 ( 1998 ) sistero , r.f .
. gravit . * 32 * , 1429 ( 2000 ) tonry , j.l . , et al .
: astrophys .
j. * 594 * , 1 ( 2003 ) weinberg , s. : gravitation and cosmology , wiley : new york ( 1972 ) yadav , a.k .
, pradhan a. , singh , a.k .
: astrophys .
space sci . * 337 * , 379 ( 2012 ) yadav , a.k . , sharma , a. : res .
. astrophys .
* 13 * , 501 ( 2013 ) yadav , a.k . :
* 29 * , 079801 ( 2012 ) zeldovich , ya.b . :
soviet physics - jetp * 14 * , 1143 ( 1962 ) | the present study deals with the exact solutions of the einstein s field equations with variable gravitational and cosmological `` constants '' for a spatially homogeneous and anisotropic bianchi type - i space - time .
to study the transit behavior of universe , we consider a law of variation of scale factor @xmath0 which yields a time dependent deceleration parameter ( dp ) @xmath1 , comprising a class of models that depicts a transition of the universe from the early decelerated phase to the recent accelerating phase .
we find that the time dependent dp is reasonable for the present day universe and give an appropriate description of the evolution of the universe .
for @xmath2 , we obtain @xmath3 which is similar to observed value of dp at present epoch .
it is also observed that for @xmath4 and @xmath5 , we obtain a class of transit models of the universe from early decelerating to present accelerating phase . for @xmath6 , the universe has non - singular origin .
the gravitational constant @xmath7 is permitted to follow a power - law expansion which is suitable for the present evolution of the universe .
the cosmological constant @xmath8 is obtained as a decreasing function of time and approaching a small positive value at present epoch which is corroborated by consequences from recent supernovae ia observations .
we also observed that our solutions approach to the @xmath9-cdm model .
the physical significance of the cosmological models have also been discussed .
+ + + + pacs : 98.80.es , 98.80.-k + keywords : cosmology , transit universe , variable gravitational & cosmological constants , variable deceleration parameter + |
the fully dressed fermionic propagator @xmath105 is calculated from the bare propagator @xmath106^{-1}$ ] via the dyson equation @xmath107 where @xmath108 are fermionic matsubara frequencies , and @xmath109 is the self - energy which captures the interaction effects .
dilute fermi gases are well described in the ladder , or t - matrix , approximation . the bosonic vertex function
is then given by @xmath110^{-1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in terms of the bare coupling @xmath111 , which depends on the uv momentum cutoff @xmath112 ( see below ) , and the pair propagator @xmath113 for bosonic matsubara frequencies @xmath114 .
in the ladder approximation the bosonic vertex function is equivalent to the t matrix , which describes the propagation of bound fermion pairs , or dimers , via dressed fermion - fermion excitations .
finally , the fermionic self - energy describes how fermions scatter off ( virtual ) dimers , @xmath115 the pair propagator @xmath116 has a logarithmic ultraviolet divergence @xcite ; this is regularised by expressing the bare coupling @xmath111 in eq . in terms of the physical binding energy @xmath22 of the two - body bound state which is always present in an attractive 2d fermi gas , @xmath117 note that the existence of a bound state is both necessary and sufficient for pairing in 2d @xcite .
equations constitute a set of coupled integral equations .
the convolution integrals and are computed in fourier space @xmath118 on a logarithmic grid of @xmath119 grid points @xcite to account for the logarithmically slow decay of the t matrix in 2d .
the integral equations are solved by iteration , and once convergence is reached one obtains the self - consistent fermion green s function @xmath120 and the t matrix @xmath121 , respectively .
@xmath120 is analytically continued to real frequencies @xmath122 using pad approximants to determine the spectral function @xmath123 . in the luttinger - ward approach ,
the density is most conveniently obtained from the green s function in fourier space as @xmath124 without the need for analytical continuation .
similarly , in the normal state , the contact density corresponds to the total density of dimers @xcite and can be expressed in terms of the self - consistent t matrix as @xmath125 .
the interaction strength in a purely 2d system is characterized by the physical binding energy @xmath22 , see eq . ,
but different definitions of the scattering length @xmath104 are used in the literature .
we follow the convention that @xmath126 , and hence @xmath23 @xcite . alternatively
, one may use @xmath127 , and consequently @xmath128 , see e.g. @xcite . in a quasi-2d system realized by a harmonic confinement in the third direction ,
as is common for ultracold atomic gases , @xmath22 is related to the confinement length @xmath129 and the 3d scattering length @xmath130 , which can be tuned by a magnetic feshbach resonance @xcite .
@xcite argues that the correct quasi-2d scattering length in the bose limit is obtained by matching the scattering amplitudes of the pure and quasi-2d systems .
the interaction parameter @xmath131 used in that work is related to our definition by @xmath132 for a single - spin density @xmath133 .
the transition temperature @xmath0 is characterised by the thouless criterion , @xmath134 @xcite .
the t matrix is proportional to the green s function @xmath135 of a dilute bose gas as @xmath136 in the bkt limit @xcite , and the bose green s function for an @xmath81-particle system with coherence length @xmath137 approaches @xmath138 @xcite . in our analysis
we therefore consider the thouless criterion @xmath139 for @xmath80 particles typical of current experiments @xcite . | we determine the thermodynamic properties and the spectral function for a homogeneous two - dimensional fermi gas in the normal state using the luttinger - ward , or self - consistent t - matrix , approach .
the density equation of state deviates strongly from that of the ideal fermi gas even for moderate interactions , and our calculations suggest that temperature has a pronounced effect on the pressure in the crossover from weak to strong coupling , consistent with recent experiments .
we also compute the superfluid transition temperature for a finite system in the crossover region .
there is a pronounced pseudogap regime above the transition temperature : the spectral function shows a bogoliubov - like dispersion with back - bending , and the density of states is significantly suppressed near the chemical potential .
the contact density at low temperatures increases with interaction and compares well with both experiment and zero - temperature monte carlo results .
the formation of fermion pairs and superfluidity of such pairs are distinct but related phenomena : in weak - coupling bcs theory , both are predicted to occur at the same temperature @xmath0 .
however , a basic question of many - body physics is how they are related at stronger coupling and in low dimensions , where quantum fluctuations play a large role .
while preformed pairs in the normal phase trivially exist in the strong - coupling bose limit where one has tightly bound dimers , it has been argued that pairing above @xmath0 can also occur in the bcs regime . in this case , one expects a significant suppression of spectral weight at the fermi surface even above @xmath0 .
this so - called pseudogap regime extends up to a crossover temperature @xmath1 , and its spectral and thermodynamic properties deviate strongly from the predictions of fermi - liquid theory @xcite .
recently , pairing and superfluidity have been studied in ultracold atomic gases , which afford accurate control of both the interaction strength and dimensionality , and allow access to the crossover between the bcs and bose regimes @xcite . in these systems
, a pseudogap can be detected through the suppression of the spin susceptibility or directly via the spectral function , which is experimentally accessible by arpes or momentum - resolved rf spectroscopy @xcite .
the possibility of a pseudogap regime has already been investigated both experimentally and theoretically in three dimensions ( 3d ) @xcite . in two - dimensional ( 2d ) fermi gases ,
the pseudogap regime is expected to be much more pronounced than in 3d , and a pairing gap has recently been observed experimentally @xcite . here , we compute the spectral function for the homogeneous 2d fermi gas in the normal phase of the bcs - bose crossover .
we indeed find a strong suppression of the density of states at the fermi surface above @xmath0 , as shown in fig .
[ fig : dos ] .
this allows us to map the extent of the pseudogap regime in the temperature - vs - coupling phase diagram ( fig .
[ fig : tc ] ) , and we find that it extends further than in 3d @xcite . as the binding between fermions increases , the cooper pairs evolve into a bose gas of tightly bound molecules .
long - range fluctuations in 2d are so strong that they inhibit superfluid long - range order at nonzero temperature .
thus , the 2d bose gas exhibits a berezinskii - kosterlitz - thouless ( bkt ) transition at @xmath2 into a quasi - ordered phase with algebraically decaying correlations @xcite .
it is a challenging many - body problem to precisely characterise the crossover between the bosonic bkt and fermionic bcs limits , where the composite nature of the molecules becomes apparent
. , normalised by @xmath3 for the free fermi gas , at interaction @xmath4 for different temperatures : @xmath5 ( top curve at @xmath6 ) to @xmath7 ( bottom ) .
* inset : * spectral function @xmath8 for @xmath9 .
the grey dashed line marks the maximum in the spectral weight of the bottom band .
[ fig : dos ] ] in this work , we present the first computation of the finite - temperature density and pressure equation of state in the crossover regime and find a strong renormalisation already for moderate interactions
see fig .
[ fig : density ] .
the pressure at low temperatures has very recently been measured in experiment @xcite .
we find that the pressure computed at @xmath10 is closer to the experimental data than zero - temperature monte carlo calculations @xcite , offering a resolution of previous discrepancies ( fig .
[ fig : p ] ) .
furthermore , we determine @xmath0 for finite systems ( fig . [
fig : tc ] ) , which is relevant for experiments on quasi-2d atomic gases , in the crossover regime between the known limiting cases @xcite . finally , the contact density agrees well with experiment @xcite and shows surprisingly little variation with temperature ( fig .
[ fig : contact ] ) .
the dilute , two - component ( @xmath11 , @xmath12 ) fermi gas with short - range interactions is described by the hamiltonian @xmath13 where @xmath14 creates a fermion with spin @xmath15 , momentum @xmath16 , and kinetic energy @xmath17 .
the chemical potential @xmath18 is taken to be the same for both species in a spin - balanced gas .
the energy scale is set by the fermi energy @xmath19 for a total density @xmath20 .
the bare attractive contact interaction @xmath21 has to be regularised and is expressed in terms of the physical binding energy @xmath22 of the two - body bound state which is always present in an attractive 2d fermi gas .
we define the 2d scattering length as @xmath23 and parametrise the interaction strength by @xmath24 . in the following we set @xmath25 , @xmath26 , and write @xmath27 .
we investigate the behavior of the strongly interacting fermi gas in the normal state using the luttinger - ward , or _
self - consistent _ t - matrix , approach @xcite , which goes beyond earlier works @xcite by including approximately the interaction between dimers as well as dressed green s functions .
thermodynamic precision measurements for the unitary fermi gas in 3d @xcite have confirmed the accuracy of this method , both for the value of @xmath28 and the bertsch parameter @xmath29 @xcite .
recently , the luttinger - ward approach has been extended to study transport properties @xcite .
the success of this method in three dimensions encourages its application to the homogeneous 2d fermi gas , which is particularly challenging due to the logarithmic energy dependence of the scattering amplitude
. within the luttinger - ward approach , pairs of dressed fermions with green s function @xmath30^{-1}$ ] can form virtual molecules whose dynamics are described by the t matrix @xmath31 .
the fermions can scatter from these molecules , which determines their lifetime and self - energy @xmath32 ( see supplemental material @xcite ) . from the self - consistent solution @xmath33 one obtains the spectral function @xmath34 . of the 2d fermi gas vs chemical potential @xmath35 , for different interaction strengths
@xmath36 ( see legend ) .
since the density is normalised by @xmath37 for the non - interacting gas , the non - monotonic behavior of @xmath38 reflects the impact of interactions , while the compressibility @xmath39 is always positive .
the inset shows a typical trajectory in @xmath40 vs @xmath41 corresponding to the dotted line of fixed @xmath42 . along this line ,
@xmath43 increases with decreasing @xmath40 .
[ fig : density ] ] _ density of states._the density of states @xmath44 describes at which energies fermionic quasiparticles can be excited , and is computed as the momentum average of the spectral function , @xmath45 .
figure [ fig : dos ] shows the density of states for an interaction strength of @xmath46 , which is weak enough that there should be a fermi surface at low temperatures @xcite . for decreasing temperature , we see that the density of states is strongly suppressed at the chemical potential , while it increases on either side of the fermi surface .
this marks the pseudogap regime which is part of the normal phase , but with anomalous properties due to the lack of low - energy fermionic excitations .
there is no uniquely defined temperature associated with this crossover , so for concreteness we define the pseudogap temperature @xmath47 as the temperature where the density of states at the chemical potential drops by @xmath48 of the value at the left fringe . the full spectral function @xmath49 , shown in the inset of fig .
[ fig : dos ] for a temperature of @xmath50 slightly above @xmath0 , shows a bcs - like dispersion with a clear reduction of spectral weight near the fermi energy .
while the upper branch has a minimum at a finite wavevector @xmath51 , the lower branch exhibits `` back - bending '' towards lower energy for large momenta ( cf.ref .
@xcite ) .
we note that back - bending alone is not sufficient to define the pseudogap regime and can arise also for other reasons in the occupied spectral function @xcite .
the two - peak structure of the @xmath52 spectral function qualitatively agrees with the momentum - resolved rf spectrum measured at @xmath53 @xcite , which is the only measurement that may lie within the pseudogap regime @xcite . for stronger attraction ,
the pseudogap regime eventually crosses over into preformed fermion pairs , where the fermi surface is lost ( @xmath54 ) and the spectral function resembles the one predicted using the virial expansion @xcite .
_ density equation of state._the total density of both spin components follows from the density of states as @xmath55 , where @xmath56 is the fermi distribution . in fig .
[ fig : density ] , we plot the density equation of state @xmath57 as a function of @xmath58 for different values of the interaction parameter @xmath36 . this manner of plotting the equation of state allows one to make a direct connection with experiments in trapped gases , since the density versus chemical potential at fixed @xmath36 can be easily extracted from the measured density profile in a trap @xcite . to expose the effects of interactions , we normalise the density @xmath59 by that of the ideal fermi gas , @xmath60 , where @xmath61 is the thermal wavelength . in the high - temperature limit where @xmath62 , all properties approach those of an ideal boltzmann gas
however , with decreasing temperature , we find that @xmath38 eventually exhibits a maximum around @xmath63 , implying that interactions are strongest at intermediate temperatures .
this is easily understood from the fact that decreasing @xmath40 at fixed @xmath64 results in an increasing @xmath41 , as shown in the inset of fig .
[ fig : density ] .
thus , we likewise expect the system to approach a weakly interacting gas in the low temperature regime .
this behavior is qualitatively different from that observed in 3d @xcite , and is a direct consequence of the fact that one can have a _
density_-driven bcs - bose crossover in 2d .
the curves for large @xmath64 are shown up to the critical value @xmath65 where the system is expected to enter the bkt phase . vs interaction strength , normalised by the pressure @xmath66 of an ideal fermi gas of the same density at @xmath67 .
luttinger - ward data at temperature @xmath68 ( top , dotted ) to @xmath69 ( solid ) in comparison with experimental data @xcite ( symbols ) and @xmath67 monte carlo results @xcite ( dashed ) .
[ fig : p ] ] _ pressure._the pressure is obtained by integrating the density according to the gibbs - duhem relation , @xmath70 .
figure [ fig : p ] shows the luttinger - ward data for finite temperatures @xmath68 ( top ) to @xmath71 ( bottom ) : the pressure decreases from the free fermi pressure in the bcs limit to the much lower pressure of a dilute bose gas in the bkt limit .
this is a strong coupling effect beyond the mean - field bcs prediction @xmath72 at @xmath67 @xcite .
as the temperature is lowered , our data approach the @xmath67 monte carlo results @xcite ( dashed ) . a recent measurement at low temperatures @xmath73 @xcite ( symbols ) found a deviation from the @xmath67 pressure in the bcs limit , attributed to mesoscopic effects .
we , however , find that the @xmath74 pressure from the luttinger - ward calculation agrees well with experiment in this regime , thus suggesting that the discrepancy is in large part due to the effect of temperature . vs interaction strength @xmath41 .
the luttinger - ward result for a finite system ( blue solid line ) in the crossover region @xmath75 is compared with analytical limits @xcite .
the red dots marks the crossover temperature @xmath47 to the pseudogap regime for @xmath76 .
[ fig : tc ] ] _ phase diagram of the 2d fermi gas._the berezinskii - kosterlitz - thouless ( bkt ) transition at a finite temperature @xmath0 marks the onset of a nonzero superfluid density @xmath77 and algebraically decaying correlations @xcite .
the jump in @xmath78 at @xmath0 is universal for a bose superfluid and becomes exponentially small of order @xmath79 on the weak - coupling bcs side @xcite .
the transition temperature is characterised by the thouless criterion , where the coefficient of the quadratic term in a ginzburg - landau action for the pairing field changes sign .
in practice , the relevant question is when this transition occurs for a finite system , for instance inside a trapping potential ( see supplemental material @xcite ) . in our analysis
we therefore compute @xmath0 for @xmath80 particles typical of current experiments @xcite , as depicted in fig . [
fig : tc ] . we have checked that different values for @xmath81 lead to small quantitative but not qualitative changes in the @xmath0 curve . in the weak - coupling bcs limit @xmath82 [ @xmath83 ,
the mean - field transition temperature is given by @xmath84 $ ] ( dashed line in fig .
[ fig : tc ] ) , where @xmath85 is euler s constant @xcite .
petrov et al .
@xcite have included gorkov melik - barkhudarov corrections and obtained a lower value @xmath86 $ ] ( dash - dotted line ) .
on the bkt side for strong binding @xmath87 , the thouless criterion fixes @xmath88 and the number equation determines @xmath0 @xcite .
a more elaborate analysis using monte carlo data for the weakly interacting bose gas in 2d @xcite yields a bkt temperature of @xmath89 for @xmath90 @xcite , which decreases for even stronger binding ( left dashed curve in fig .
[ fig : tc ] ) .
this limiting behaviour implies the existence of a maximum @xmath0 in the crossover region ( cf.ref .
@xcite ) , but does not determine its value or the precise crossover behaviour .
the luttinger - ward result for @xmath0 grows monotonically from the bcs limit towards strong coupling @xmath91 : it suggests a maximum @xmath0 at negative @xmath92 , which is unlikely to exceed @xmath93 .
this is consistent with experiments which did not observe signatures of superfluidity down to @xmath94 @xcite , but is considerably lower than a recent calculation for a harmonically trapped gas @xcite .
the red dots in the phase diagram in fig . [ fig : tc ] mark the crossover temperature to the pseudogap regime @xmath47 , where the density of states @xmath44 at the chemical potential drops by @xmath48 of the value at the left fringe . in the weak coupling bcs limit
, @xmath47 approaches @xmath0 since pairing and condensation occur simultaneously , and both @xmath0 and @xmath47 tend towards the dashed weak - coupling result . the large pseudogap regime at strong binding leads to clear signatures in the spin susceptibility and spectral properties well within reach of current experiments .
vs interaction strength @xmath95 at temperature @xmath96 .
we compare our result ( blue solid line ) with the experimental data at @xmath96 @xcite ( red symbols ) , the weak - coupling result ( green dash - dotted line ) , and monte carlo at @xmath67 @xcite ( cyan dashed line ) .
[ fig : contact ] ] _ contact density._the contact density @xmath97 @xcite characterises the probability of finding particles of opposite spin close to each other @xcite .
it determines the _ universal _ high - energy properties of a quantum gas with contact interactions , e.g. , the momentum distribution function @xmath98 at large momenta .
the contact density is related to the variation of the pressure with scattering length by the adiabatic theorem @xcite , @xmath99 using the weak - coupling expansion of the ground state energy in @xmath100 @xcite one obtains at @xmath67 : @xmath101/4 $ ] . in the normal state
the contact density corresponds to the total density of dimers @xcite . in fig .
[ fig : contact ] we show our result for the contact ( solid line ) at @xmath102 and compare with the experimental data at the same temperature from frhlich et al .
@xcite , as well as with the weak - coupling estimate above .
remarkably , our calculation in this low - temperature region is very close to the @xmath67 monte carlo result @xcite ( dashed line ) , showing that the contact has only a weak temperature dependence .
note , further , that while one generally expects the contact to decrease with increasing temperature , our result for larger @xmath41 is higher than the contact at @xmath67 from monte carlo , thus suggesting that @xmath97 is a non - monotonic function of @xmath103 , similarly to 3d @xcite . in conclusion
, we have presented results for the density and pressure equation of state which shed light on a recent pressure measurement @xcite .
the values for the transition temperature @xmath0 and the pseudogap crossover temperature @xmath47 in the phase diagram reveal a large pseudogap regime ; its effect on the spectral function and low - energy density of states are accessible and relevant for current experiments using momentum - resolved rf spectroscopy @xcite .
we find that the contact depends only weakly on temperature , providing a robust interaction gauge .
it will be worthwhile to extend the luttinger - ward technique into the low - temperature bkt phase , which is characterised by binding of vortex - antivortex pairs , and study the signatures of the superfluid phase for a trapped 2d fermi gas .
the bkt transition itself is revealed by a jump in the sound velocities @xcite .
we thank wilhelm zwerger for suggesting the problem , valuable discussions and careful reading of the manuscript .
we acknowledge discussions with marcus barth , stefan baur , gianluca bertaina , rudolf haussmann , selim jochim , michael khl , jesper levinsen , vudtiwat ngampruetikorn , richard schmidt and andrey turlapov .
mb thanks the gates cambridge trust for financial support .
mmp acknowledges support from the epsrc under grant no .
ep / h00369x/2 .
49 m. randeria , proceedings of the international school of physics `` enrico fermi '' course cxxxvi on high temperature superconductors , pp .
5375 ( ios press , amsterdam , 1998 ) ; v. m. loktev , r. m. quick , and s. g. sharapov , phys . rep . * 349 * , 1 ( 2001 )
. i. bloch , j. dalibard , and w. zwerger , rev .
mod .
phys . * 80 * , 885 ( 2008 ) ; w. zwerger , ed . , _ the bcs bec crossover and the unitary fermi gas _ , lecture notes in physics , vol . 836 ( springer , berlin , 2012 )
. j. t. stewart , j. p. gaebler , and d. s. jin , nature * 454 * , 744 ( 2008 ) ; j. p. gaebler , j. t. stewart , t. e. drake , d. s. jin , a. perali , p. pieri , and g. c. strinati , nature physics * 6 * , 569 ( 2010 ) .
m. feld , b. frhlich , e. vogt , m. koschorreck , and m. khl , nature * 480 * , 75 ( 2011 ) .
q. chen , j. stajic , s. n. tan , and k. levin , phys .
rep . * 412 * , 1 ( 2005 ) ; y. he , q. chen , and k. levin , phys .
rev .
a * 72 * , 011602 ( 2005 ) ; q. chen , c. a. regal , m. greiner , d. s. jin , and k. levin , phys .
rev .
a * 73 * , 041601 ( 2006 ) ; a. perali , f. palestini , p. pieri , g. c. strinati , j. t. stewart , j. p. gaebler , t. e. drake , and d. s. jin , phys . rev . lett . * 106 * , 060402 ( 2011 ) . r. watanabe , s. tsuchiya , and y. ohashi , phys . rev .
a * 88 * , 013637 ( 2013 ) .
d. s. fisher and p. c. hohenberg , phys . rev .
b * 37 * , 4936 ( 1988 ) ; z. hadzibabic , p. krger , m. cheneau , b. battelier , and j. dalibard , nature * 441 * , 1118 ( 2006 )
. n. prokofev and b. svistunov , phys .
rev .
a * 66 * , 043608 ( 2002 ) .
m. holzmann , g. baym , j .-
p .
blaizot , and f. lalo , proc .
natl acad .
sci .
usa * 104 * , 1476 ( 2007 ) .
v. makhalov , k. martiyanov , and a. turlapov , phys .
rev .
lett . *
112 * , 045301 ( 2014 ) .
g. bertaina and s. giorgini , phys .
rev .
lett . * 106 * , 110403 ( 2011 ) .
d. s. petrov , m. a. baranov , and g. v. shlyapnikov , phys .
rev .
a * 67 * , 031601 ( 2003 ) .
b. frhlich , m. feld , e. vogt , m. koschorreck , m. khl , c. berthod , and t. giamarchi , phys .
rev .
lett . * 109 * , 130403 ( 2012 ) .
r. haussmann , z. phys .
b * 91 * , 291 ( 1993 ) ; r. haussmann , phys . rev .
b * 49 * , 12975 ( 1994 ) .
r. haussmann , w. rantner , s. cerrito , and w. zwerger , phys .
rev .
a * 75 * , 023610 ( 2007 ) .
p. nozires and s. schmitt - rink , j. low temp .
phys .
* 59 * , 195 ( 1985 ) ; s. schmitt - rink , c. m. varma , and a. e. ruckenstein , phys .
rev .
lett . * 63 * , 445 ( 1989 ) .
m. j. h. ku , a. t. sommer , l. w. cheuk , and m. w. zwierlein , science * 335 * , 563 ( 2012 ) .
t. enss , r. haussmann , and w. zwerger , ann .
phys .
( ny ) * 326 * , 770 ( 2011 ) ; t. enss and r. haussmann , phys .
rev .
lett . * 109 * , 195303 ( 2012 ) .
see supplemental material at url for a description of the luttinger - ward approach , alternative definitions of @xmath104 , and the thouless criterion for finite systems .
v. ngampruetikorn , j. levinsen , and m. m. parish , phys .
rev .
lett . * 111 * , 265301 ( 2013 ) .
w. schneider and m. randeria , phys .
rev . a * 81 * , 021601(r ) ( 2010 ) .
m. barth and j. hofmann , phys .
rev . a * 89 * , 013614 ( 2014 ) .
s. stintzing and w. zwerger , phys .
rev .
b * 56 * , 9004 ( 1997 ) . k. miyake , progr .
. phys . * 69 * , 1794 ( 1983 ) .
c. a. r. s de melo , m. randeria , and j. r. engelbrecht , phys .
rev .
lett . * 71 * , 3202 ( 1993 ) .
m. drechsler and w. zwerger , ann .
phys .
( berlin ) * 1 * , 15 ( 1992 ) .
s. tan , ann . of phys . *
323 * , 2952 ( 2008 ) ; c. langmack , m. barth , w. zwerger , and e. braaten , phys .
rev .
lett . * 108 * , 060402 ( 2012 ) .
e. braaten and l. platter , phys .
rev .
lett . * 100 * , 205301 ( 2008 ) .
s. tan , ann .
phys .
( ny ) * 323 * , 2971 ( 2008 ) ; f. werner and y. castin , phys . rev . a * 86 * , 013626 ( 2012 )
. p. bloom , phys .
rev .
b * 12 * , 125 ( 1975 ) ; j. r. engelbrecht , m. randeria , and l. zhang , phys . rev .
b * 45 * , 10135 ( 1992 ) .
r. haussmann , m. punk , and w. zwerger , phys .
rev .
a * 80 * , 063612 ( 2009 ) ; r. combescot , f. alzetto , and x. leyronas , phys . rev .
a * 79 * , 053640 ( 2009 ) ; y. nishida , phys .
rev .
a * 85 * , 053643 ( 2012 ) .
z. yu , g. m. bruun , and g. baym , phys . rev .
a * 80 * , 023615 ( 2009 ) .
t. ozawa and s. stringari , phys .
rev .
lett . * 112 * , 025302 ( 2014 ) .
j. r. engelbrecht and m. randeria , phys .
rev .
lett . * 65 * , 1032 ( 1990 ) .
m. randeria , j .-
m . duan , and l .- y .
shieh , phys .
rev .
lett . * 62 * , 981 ( 1989 ) . |
long time ago , the observational evidence for ms stars has been the very first challenge for the theory of stellar structure and the prediction for underluminous metal poor ms stars has been among the very first success of the theory . since that time
, the location in the color magnitude ( cm ) diagram of the zero age main sequence ( zams ) and its dependence on the adopted chemical composition keeps being a relevant ingredient for the investigation of stellar clusters and in particular for distance determinations through ms fitting .
the issue is now matter of a renewed interest vis - a - vis the absolute magnitudes made available by the hipparcos satellite for a large amount of stars .
+ in this context , theoretical predictions concerning the zams are also connected with the still open problem of the ratio @xmath4y/@xmath4z marking the enrichment of interstellar medium during the nuclear evolution of galactic matter . from an observational point of view , for any given range of metallicities the location of the related main sequences depends on the corresponding variation in y , which thus governs the observed zams broadening . in spite of the difficulty of the procedure , which is affected by uncertainties on cluster reddening , metallicity and distance modulus , several evaluations of the quoted ratio have been provided in last decades , by using suitable relations between the main sequence thickness and chemical composition variations ( faulkner 1967 , perrin et al .
1977 , pagel 1995 , cayrel de strobel & crifo 1995 , fernandes et al . 1996 ) .
however , one has to notice that the related theoretical scenario appears far from being firmly established , and the diffuse belief that the effects of y and z on the zams location cancel out for @xmath4y/@xmath4z@[email protected] ( see e.g. fernandes et al .
1996 , mermilliod et al .
1997 ) runs against the theoretical evidence recently given by pagel & portinari ( 1998 ) for which @xmath4y/@xmath4z = 6 should produce still a not negligible broadening .
+ owing to the relevance of this issue , in this paper we will revisit theoretical predictions about the location of zams models both in the theoretical ( logl , logt@xmath2 ) and observational ( m@xmath3 , b - v ) diagrams . taking into account the increasing amount of observational data , the investigation will be extended over a rather large range of both z and y values , covering the ranges z=0.0001 - 0.04 and y=0.23 - 0.34 . in sect .
2 we present our models for selected chemical compositions , whereas in sect .
3 we derive suitable analytical relations , discussing the implications for the @xmath4y/@xmath4z ratio .
as usual , in the following we will use the term `` zero age main sequence '' ( zams ) to indicate the hr diagram locus of stellar models which are just starting central h burning with the timescale of h consumption in the stellar interior .
more in detail , the term refers to the first h burning model which has settled in its main sequence phase after having reached the equilibrium of the secondary elements participating in the various h burning reactions .
accordingly , all these `` zero age '' models have already experienced a phase of nuclear burning , with time scales which largely depend on the stellar mass tough , in all cases , much shorter than the expected central h burning ms phase . in this context
, one expects that zams stars will evolve increasing their luminosity , till reaching the exhaustion of central h. however , as discussed by fernandes et al .
( 1996 ) , for any reasonable assumption about the stellar ages , one can safely assume that all the stars fainter than m@[email protected] are practically unaffected by evolution , so that below this luminosity stars are expected to be in any case close to their zams location ( see also lebreton et al .
1997 and pagel & portinari 1998 ) .
bearing in mind such a scenario , we used the franec evolutionary code ( straniero & chieffi 1991 ) to compute zams models for selected choices about the original chemical composition for stellar models covering the mass range 0.6 - 1.2 m@xmath1 .
the input physics , but the equation of state ( eos ) , is as in cassisi et al .
( 1998 ) , who included all the most recent evaluations of the various physical ingredients given in the literature .
the interested reader can find in the above quoted paper a complete description of the adopted physics together with a detailed discussion of the influence of the `` new '' inputs on stellar models . regarding the eos
, one finds that the tabulation by rogers et al .
( 1996 ) used in cassisi et al .
( 1998 ) does not allow a full coverage of the range of pressures and temperatures required by our grid of models . to overcome this problem , we adopted the extended eos tabulation given by straniero ( 1988 ) on the basis of the free - energy minimization method , which takes also into account electron degeneracy and coulomb corrections . in the low temperature region we implemented this eos with the saha equation , which includes the pressure ionization contribution , according to the method described by ratcliff ( 1987 ) .
comparison with ms models computed with opal eos ( rogers et al .
1996 ) , as allowed for selected structures , shows that straniero s eos gives slightly cooler models ( by about 100 k ) with quite a similar dependence on the adopted chemical composition .
comparison with similar models presented in the literature , as given in fig .
[ conf ] , shows that at the larger luminosities our results appear in excellent agreement with the recent computations by pols et al .
( 1998 ) , becoming redder at the lower luminosities .
this is probably due to the different eos , since the above quoted authors adopt an improved version of the eggleton et al .
( eff , 1973 ) equation of state ( see pols et al .
( 1995 ) and christensen - dalsgaard & dappen ( 1992 ) for a discussion on eff eos ) .
the difference with models by fagotto et al .
( 1994 ) has probably a similar origin , though we have not found in the literature a detailed description of the eos used by these authors . since , in principle , our adopted eos should be at least as accurate as the eos adopted in previous investigations on the matter , data in fig .
[ conf ] can be taken as an evidence that a precise location of the zams deserves still more work .
however , comparison among the quoted results discloses a rather good agreement as far as the effects of chemical composition are concerned , so that one can be confident that current models can give a realistic information about the dependence on the chemical composition .
[ ms ] shows the location , in both the theoretical ( left panel ) and the observational ( right panel ) hr diagram , of the present zams , as computed for stellar masses ranging from 0.6 to 1.2 m@xmath1 and for the labeled values of chemical composition .
magnitude and colors have been produced adopting kurucz s ( 1992 ) model atmospheres which , to our knowledge , provide the only available set of models covering the whole range of metallicities ( up to z = 0.04 ) explored in this paper . as well known , at any fixed effective temperature , both the theoretical and the observational zams get fainter as the metallicity decreases or the helium content increases .
however , fig .
[ ms ] shows that such a behavior appears sensitively enhanced in the observational plane , due to the dependence of both the color and the bolometric correction on the star metallicity .
thus the observed ms broadening can not properly be discussed on the basis of the behavior of m@xmath8 only , as sometime given in the literature . again in fig .
[ ms ] one finds that zams run nearly parallel each other over a rather large portion of the diagrams , allowing the derivation of analytical relations for the dependence on y and z we will discuss in the next section . in this context
, one has to notice that the hr diagram location of the models is dependent on the assumption about the efficiency of superadiabatic convection which affects the external layers of most of the models in fig .
[ ms ] . to minimize this problem
we will restrict our investigation ( see sect .
3 ) to the lower portion of the main sequence , where superadiabaticity effects are expected to be negligible ( see , e.g. , vandenberg et al .
1983 , pagel & portinari 1998 ) .
interpolation among the bolometric magnitudes at logt@xmath2=3.70 gives : + @xmath9 @xmath10 which is valid over the whole range of explored compositions with a r.m.s = 0.010 and which can be used to constrain the shift of the zams when varying y and/or z. note that the fit of all the data requires a quadratic dependence on logz .
when considering the dependence of the visual magnitude on y and z at fixed b - v one can not find a reference color for a suitable coverage of the zams all over the explored range of metallicities ( see fig . [ ms ] ) .
thus we choose two b - v values according to selected ranges of metallicities , namely : b - v=0.8 for z @xmath11 0.01 and b - v=1.1 for z @xmath12 0.01 .
the two corresponding relations are : + @xmath13 @xmath14 with a r.m.s.=0.013 .
+ @xmath15 @xmath16 with a r.m.s .
+ however , at m@xmath3=6 mag , one can find an analytical relation connecting the b - v values to y and z , all over the explored range of chemical compositions , as given by : + @xmath17 @xmath18 with a r.m.s.= 0.004 .
+ now we are in the position of discussing the predicted effects of the various correlations between z and y. let us first take as `` reference value '' the bolometric magnitude for the solar zams ( z=0.02 , y=0.27 ) at fixed temperature ( logt@xmath2=3.70 ) to investigate which variation of y could be able to balance a variation in metallicity .
note that this is just a theoretical experiment , since we know that metallicity does cause a spread in the zams location ( see e.g. again pagel & portinari 1998 ) .
[ dydz ] ( left panel ) shows , for each given assumption on z , the values of y for which one has the same bolometric magnitude ( at logt@xmath2=3.70 ) as the z=0.02 y=0.27 zams , that is the value of y for which one would expect no spread of the ms due to chemical composition .
the dashed line indicates the @xmath4y/@xmath4z = 5 relation .
one may notice that in this case present theoretical predictions are in reasonable agreement with the slope @xmath4y/@xmath4z@xmath55 , as often referred in the literature , but only in a restricted metallicity range around z=0.02 .
however , the right panel of fig . [ dydz ] shows the relation between y and z needed to keep unchanged the zams color at m@xmath3=6 .
now one finds that a much larger value of @xmath4y/@xmath4z ( of the order of 7 around the solar metallicity ) would be required in order to avoid a broadening of ms with z , showing the additional contribution of model atmospheres to the spread of visual magnitudes .
such a result appears in agreement with the already quoted pagel & portinari ( 1998 ) finding , for which @xmath4y/@xmath4z = 6 is still not sufficient for avoiding the spread . as a final point
, one may explore the rather popular assumption that the galactic enrichment follows a linear relation between y and z , adopting z=0.0001 y=0.23 for metal poor stars and z=0.02 ,
y=0.27 for the sun , so that @xmath19 . in fig .
[ disco ] we make use of our predictions under the above quoted assumption to repeat the analysis given by pagel and portinari ( 1998 ) for hipparcos ms nearby stars .
one finds that the predicted spread appear in fair agreement with observations .
this is not a surprising result , since pagel and portinari already found a reasonable agreement for the rather large range of values @xmath20 = 3 @xmath212 .
one finds also several concordances concerning the relation between the visual magnitude ( at fixed temperature ) and metallicity .
however , it is difficult to go deeper in such a discussion , owing to the rather large uncertainties still existing in the observational sample .
we have investigated the theoretical scenario for zams stars with different chemical compositions , providing analytical relations connecting the ms location to y and z. we show that the assumption of no ms broadening for @xmath4y/@xmath4z = 5 is supported by theory only for the behavior of bolometric magnitudes . on the contrary , we find that the no - broadening condition can be reached in the observational m@xmath3,b - v plane only if @xmath4y/@xmath4z@xmath227 .
it is a pleasure to thank joao fernandes for useful discussions during the x canary islands winter school of astrophysics and onno pols for kindly providing us with the results of his computations .
this work was partially supported by cnaa through a postdoc research grant to m. marconi
. 9 cayrel de strobel g. , crifo f. , 1995 , in crane p. ed .
`` the light elements abundances '' springer - verlag , berlin , p. 183 cassisi s. , castellani v. , deglinnocenti s. , weiss a. , 1998 , a&a suppl . 129 , 267 .
christensen - dalsgaard j. , dappen w. , 1992 , the astron .
4 , 267 eggleton p.p . , faulkner j. , flannery b.p . , 1973 , a&a 23 , 325 fagotto f. , bressan a. , bertelli g. , chiosi c. 1994 , a&a suppl .
105 , 29 faulkner j. , 1967 , apj 147 , 617 fernandes j. , lebreton y. , baglin a. , 1996 , a&a 311 , 127 kurucz , r. l. 1992 , in iau symp .
149 , the stellar populations of galaxies , eds .
b. barbuy , a. renzini ( dordrecht : kluwer ) , 225 lebreton y. , perrin m.n . ,
fernandes j. et al . , 1997 , hipparcos _
venice 97 : presentation of the hipparcos and tycho catalogues and first astrophysical results of the hipparcos space astrometry mission _
space agency spec .
402 , noordwijk .
the netherlands : esa publ .
379 - 382 mermilliod j.c .
, turon c. , robichon n. , arenou f. , lebreton y. 1997 , hipparcos _
venice 97 : presentation of the hipparcos and tycho catalogues and first astrophysical results of the hipparcos space astrometry mission _
space agency spec .
402 , noordwijk .
the netherlands : esa publ .
643 - 650 .
pagel b.e.j . , 1995 , in hog e. , seidelmann p.k .
, eds , proc . iau symp .
166 , `` astronomical and astrophysical objectives of sub - milliarcsecond optical astrometry '' kluwer , dordrecht , p. 181 .
pagel b.e.j .
, portinari l. , 1998 , mnras 298 , 747 perrin m.n .
, hejlesen p.m. , cayrel de strobel g. , cayrel r. 1977 , a&a 54 , 779 pols o.r .
, tout c.,a .
, eggleton p.p .
, han z. 1995 , mnras 274 , 964 pols o.r . , schroder k.p . ,
hurley j.r .
, tout c.a .
, eggleton p.p .
1998 , mnras 298 , 525 ratcliff s.j .
, 1987 apj 318 , 196 rogers f.j . ,
swenson f.j .
, iglesias c.a .
1996 , apj 456 , 902 straniero o. 1988 , a&as 76 , 157 straniero o. , chieffi a. 1991 , apjs 76 , 525 vandenberg d.a .
, hartwick f.d.a . ,
dawson p. , alexander d.r .
, 1983 , apj 266,747 | zero age main sequence ( zams ) models with updated physical inputs are presented for selected assumptions about the chemical composition , covering the ranges 0.6 @xmath0 m @xmath0 1.2 m@xmath1 , 0.0001 @xmath0 z @xmath0 0.04 , 0.23 @xmath0 y @xmath0 0.34 .
the hr diagram location of the zams as a function of y and z is discussed both in the theoretical ( logl , logt@xmath2 ) and in the observational ( m@xmath3 , b - v ) diagrams , showing that the v magnitude presents an increased dependence on z to be taken into account when discussing observational evidences .
analytical relations quantifying both these dependences are derived .
implications for the galactic helium to heavier elements enrichment @xmath4y/@xmath4z are finally discussed . |
this work was supported by the canada excellence research chairs ( cerc ) program , the natural sciences and engineering research council of canada ( nserc ) and the uk epsrc . o.s.m.l .
acknowledges support from conacyt and the mexican secretaria de educacion publica ( sep ) .
dklo , jj , and vp acknowledge quisco .
v.p . , f.m.m . , d.k.l.o . and j.j .
developed the theory . f.m.m .
, a.c.l . and r.w.b .
conceived the experiment . m.m . o.s.m.l . and a.c.l .
carried out the experiment .
f.m.m . performed the data analysis .
all authors contributed to writing the paper .
the authors declare no competing financial interests . | in 1924 david hilbert conceived a paradoxical tale involving a hotel with an infinite number of rooms to illustrate some aspects of the mathematical notion of `` infinity '' . in continuous - variable quantum mechanics we routinely make use of infinite state spaces : here we show that such a theoretical apparatus can accommodate an analog of hilbert s hotel paradox .
we devise a protocol that , mimicking what happens to the guests of the hotel , maps the amplitudes of an infinite eigenbasis to twice their original quantum number in a coherent and deterministic manner , producing infinitely many unoccupied levels in the process .
we demonstrate the feasibility of the protocol by experimentally realising it on the orbital angular momentum of a paraxial field .
this new non - gaussian operation may be exploited for example for enhancing the sensitivity of n00n states , for increasing the capacity of a channel or for multiplexing multiple channels into a single one .
the `` hilbert hotel paradox '' demonstrates the counterintuitive nature of infinity @xcite .
the hilbert hotel has infinitely many rooms numbered @xmath0 , all of which are currently occupied .
each new visitor that arrives can be accommodated if every current guest in the hotel is asked to move up one room ( @xmath1 ) .
even if a countably infinite number of new guests arrives at once , they can still be accommodated if each of the existing occupants moves to twice their current room number ( @xmath2 ) leaving the odd - numbered rooms free .
we may ask whether such phenomena can exist physically .
one possibility is in continuous - variables systems where in principle we have infinite ladders of energy eigenstates .
previously @xcite , the first of the hilbert hotel paradoxes ( with a single new guest ) was proposed in cavity qed using the sudarshan - glogower bare raising operator @xmath3 that shifts all the amplitudes up one level leaving the vacuum state unoccupied . here
, we show how we can implement the extended case where every second level of an infinite set of states is vacated .
this can be performed coherently and deterministically , preserving all the initial state amplitudes by remapping them to twice their original levels using a short and simple sequence of instantaneous , dynamic , and adiabatic processes .
we first show how to map the eigenstate amplitudes of a infinite square potential well to twice their original level , and then we report results of a physical implementation of an analogous protocol on the orbital angular momentum ( oam ) eigenstates of light , where we coherently multiply any linear superposition by a fixed integer ( in our case , by three ) . in the supplementary material
we describe further details of the experiment and we show that the square well protocol can be generalised to implement a multiplication of the eigenstate numbers by any positive integer , not only by two .
consider a quantum system with an infinite ladder of energy eigenstates bounded from below , @xmath4 .
an arbitrary state can be then represented as @xmath5 .
our earlier work @xcite has introduced the hilbert hotel operator @xmath6 , transforming @xmath7 to @xmath8 our new aim is to extend the toolbox by an operator @xmath9 , @xmath10 representing the second hilbert hotel paradox by leaving every second energy level vacant .
both operators are non - unitary isometries , as @xmath11 .
we show that we can deterministically implement @xmath9 on a infinite square potential well with initial width @xmath12 with the following operations ( fig .
[ fig : protocol ] ) : _ i _ ) we instantaneously expand the well from @xmath12 to @xmath13 , _ ii _ )
we let it evolve for the original fundamental period , _ iii _ ) we divide the well into two sub - wells of width @xmath12 with a barrier , _ iv _ ) we let each half - well evolve with a relative potential offset , to correct the relative phase , _ v _ ) we merge the half - wells together into one well of width @xmath13 , _ vi _ )
we adiabatically shrink the well back to width @xmath12 .
in general , the amplitudes of an initial state can be mapped to any integer multiple ( @xmath14 ) using a slightly modified procedure ( see supplementary material for details ) . within an infinite square potential
well . * b * , we instantaneously expand the well to twice its original width .
the original wavefunction is not immediately changed but the eigenbasis is different . *
c * , we allow free evolution for a period corresponding to the original fundamental period .
the wavefunction is reflected around the centre of the expanded well , with an undesired phase shift . *
d * , we insert an infinite barrier in the centre ( where the wavefunction is zero ) to split it into two independent wells that evolve separately , an energy shift on one well corrects the relative phase . *
e * , after the phase correction we align the potentials and merge the two halves back together .
* f * , an adiabatic compression of the well maps the eigenstates of the expanded well to those of the original well . the original wavefunction has now been halved and reflected , corresponding to the hilbert hotel operation
@xmath9 being applied to the eigenstates @xmath15.[fig : protocol],width=288 ] ideally steps _ i _ ,
_ iii _ and _ v _ should be instantaneous while step _ vi _ should be adiabatic .
the fidelity of a physical implementation will depend on the accuracy of the timing and the quality of the approximations , especially the maximum effective excitation number @xmath16 of the initial state in comparison to the validity regime of the schrdinger equation approximation in any realistic system under consideration .
the hilbert space of a particle in a well of width @xmath12 consists of the set of square - integrable functions , @xmath17 and the free particle hamiltonian is @xmath18 with boundary conditions @xmath19 .
this describes a one - dimensional particle in an infinite square potential well , but it can also describe other situations , e.g. an ideal two - dimensional optical waveguide within the paraxial wave approximation .
the hamiltonian yields an infinite ladder of nondegenerate energy eigenfunctions of the form @xmath20 with eigenvalues @xmath21 where @xmath22 . the desired operation @xmath9 transforms an initial state @xmath23 into @xmath24 interleaving the amplitudes of the initial state in the energy eigenbasis with zeros .
the first step of the hilbert hotel protocol is to double the width of the well so the original wave function @xmath25 extends from @xmath26 to @xmath27 , filling the new interval by constant zero .
we denote this extended wave function by @xmath28 and the free hamiltonian with the new boundary conditions @xmath29 by @xmath30 .
this hamiltonian has a new set of eigenfunctions @xmath31 which we use to express @xmath32 .
we allow @xmath28 to evolve over a time @xmath33 into @xmath34 where @xmath35 is @xmath36 for even @xmath16 and @xmath37 for odd @xmath16 , thus @xmath38 where @xmath39 is the identity operator and @xmath40 the mirror reflection ( or parity ) operator . therefore , after step
_ ii _ we have ( up to a global phase factor ) the state @xmath41 this resembles the point symmetry extension of @xmath25 to @xmath27 but the phase factor in @xmath42 needs to be corrected . steps _ iii _ , _ iv _ and _ v _ remove the undesired @xmath43 factor while preventing cross - talk between the two sub - wells . after splitting the interval @xmath27 in two ,
each part will evolve separately under the hamiltonian @xmath44 with appropriate boundary conditions .
the two halves can be phase - matched by applying potentials @xmath45 in @xmath26 and @xmath46 in @xmath42 for a time @xmath47 .
after removing the barrier ( step _ v _ ) , the wave function of the system becomes @xmath48 substituting for @xmath49 from , we find that both branches allow for a common analytic expression , as the domain of @xmath31 is twice that of @xmath49 : @xmath50 the final step is an adiabatic compression of the well back to its original width @xmath12 . up to a relative phase due to free evolution , which can be corrected by matching the total time of the evolution to an integer number of full revolutions of the running eigenbasis , this adiabatically
transforms the basis states @xmath31 into @xmath49 of the same @xmath16 , keeping coherent superpositions intact .
this shows the resulting state is indeed .
the crucial step in the hilbert hotel operation is the coherent mapping @xmath51 ( for @xmath52 ) on a countably infinite set of basis states @xmath53 , as described above . instead of a particle in an infinite square potential well , we can use systems that share important characteristics in order to perform analogous operations . in our experimental realisation ( fig .
[ hhsetup ] ) we choose the set of oam eigenstates of a beam of light , denoted by @xmath54 , and the coherent multiplication makes use of two well - known optical devices in a novel configuration : an oam sorter and a `` fan - out '' refractive coherent beam copier @xcite .
the oam multiplier has four steps : _ i _ ) unwrapping the initial azimuthal phase ring into a linear phase ramp with a polar - to - cartesian mapping , _ ii _ ) branching out new copies of the linearised field and correcting their relative phase with a suitable grating , _ iii _ ) demagnifying the juxtaposed copies with a cylindrical lens , and _ iv _ ) wrapping the resulting field back to polar coordinates .
the combination of these four steps amounts to the transformation : @xmath55 where @xmath56 is the number of copies produced in step _
ii_. the first step is achieved by way of an oam sorter @xcite , which unwraps any oam mode into a linear gradient ( and therefore it turns a combination of oam modes into a combination of linear gradients ) by way of an extremely astigmatic lens @xmath57 followed by a phase - correcting element @xmath58 , which effectively stops the unwrapping after the transformation is complete .
these two elements can be described by the phase delay that they impose on the incoming field as a function of position : @xmath59 where @xmath60 is the focal length of the fourier lens connecting near - field and far - field , @xmath61 is the wavelength of the light beam , and the free parameters @xmath62 and @xmath63 determine the scaling and position of the transformation in the fourier plane of coordinates @xmath64 and @xmath65 . at this point
we produce equal - weighted copies of the unwrapped phase ramp using a fan - out element by way of a suitable 1d phase grating on the far field .
it is crucial that the copies have the same intensity in order to obtain the desired oam modes at the end of the process . in our experiment ,
the fan - out grating produces three copies and the equation describing the phase delay of the grating as a function of position in the far field is @xmath66,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath67 .
such a phase mask does not depend on the @xmath68 coordinate , as we are copying a linear field .
this grating is displayed on a spatial light modulator ( slm ) , so the output of the sorter needs to be fourier transformed onto the fan - out slm with a @xmath69 system , followed by another @xmath69 system which images it through a second sorter operated _ in reverse_. in order to wrap the field back correctly without leaving wide gaps or without wrapping more than necessary , we use a cylindrical lens to demagnify the horizontal cartesian coordinate before the beam enters the reverse - sorter . exploiting the flexibility of slms
, we achieve this by adding the phase of a cylindrical lens directly on top of the fan - out grating . in the first part of our experiment we test the coherence of the protocol , i.e. its ability to preserve superpositions .
to do this , we generate balanced superpositions of @xmath70 and @xmath71 , with @xmath72 ranging from 1 to 3 .
such initial modes display @xmath73 maxima , or `` petals '' .
we feed them to the multiplier ( here set to multiply by @xmath74 ) and a successful protocol results in @xmath75 petals with high visibility at the output , as can be seen in fig .
[ petals ] . * coherent oam multiplication . *
top row : near field of input coherent superpositions .
bottom row : tripled output states .
the number of petals is @xmath75 , as expected from a coherent operation.,width=288 ] * oam multiplication performance .
* for each input eigenmode we measure the composition of the multiplied output .
circle size is linearly proportional to the overlap with the output modes .
as can be seen , the small leakage onto the neighbouring output modes is contained within a few adjacent modes .
a sufficiently distant input superposition such as @xmath76 would maintain an effective orthogonality.,width=288 ] in the second part of our experiment we assess the accuracy of the protocol by measuring the leakage onto neighbouring oam eigenmodes . to do this
, we multiply single oam eigenmodes by @xmath74 and projectively measure the oam spectrum of the output .
the results show that the overlap decays quickly enough for suitably distant superpositions to maintain their orthogonality ( fig .
[ dataanalysis ] ) .
for instance , the superposition @xmath76 which ideally maps to @xmath77 , was mapped to a superposition of modes , peaked on @xmath78 , but nevertheless with negligible cross - talk ( details in supplementary material ) . in summary
, we showed how to implement the hilbert hotel `` paradox '' , where the rooms of the hotel are the excitation modes of an infinite square potential well .
we then reported the successful implementation of the core step of the operation ( the coherent multiplication of the basis states of a countably infinite basis ) on the oam eigenmodes of a paraxial beam of light .
we show that the operation is coherent and that even in our proof - of - principle experiment , the multiplication of sufficiently distant modes can be performed with negligible overlap .
mode multiplication could be implemented also in other quantum systems , such as becs in a box potential with predicted talbot carpet features , though nonlinear interactions may spoil the ideal free particle expansion required for perfect wavefunction mirroring @xcite .
nonetheless , we note that this idea could be used to enhance several state production schemes without the need to modify the existing apparatuses , because it can act as an extension .
for instance , it could prove useful in quantum and classical information processing as a means of multiplexing an arbitrary number of input channels into a single output channel , or to enhance the sensitivity of systems that use n00n states , or to distribute ordered gaps in the spectral profile of a state .
99 kragh , h. the true ( ? ) story of hilbert s infinite hotel .
arxiv:1403.0059v2 ( 2014 ) .
oi , d. k. l. , potoek , v. , and jeffers , j. nondemolition measurement of the vacuum state or its complement .
_ phys .
rev .
lett .
_ * 110 , * 210504 ( 2013 ) .
gaunt , a. l. , schmidutz , t. f. , gotlibovych , i. , smith , r. p. , and hadzibabic , z. bose - einstein condensation of atoms in a uniform potential .
_ phys .
rev .
lett . _ * 110 , * 200406 ( 2013 ) .
jenkins , r. m. , devereux , r. w. j. , and heaton , j. m. a novel waveguide mach - zehnder interferometer based on multimode interference phenomena .
_ opt .
comm . _ * 110 , * 410424 ( 1994 ) .
prongu , d. , herzig , h. p. , dndliker , r. , and gale , m. t. optimized kinoform structures for highly efficient fan - out elements .
_ appl
. opt . _ * 31 , * 5706 ( 1992 )
. romero , l. a. , and dickey , f. m. theory of optimal be a splitting by phase gratings . i.
one - dimensional gratings . _ j. opt .
soc .
am .
a _ * 24 , * 2280 ( 2007 ) . berkhout , g. c. g. , lavery , m. p. j. , courtial , j. , beijersbergen , m. w. , and padgett , m. j. efficient sorting of orbital angular momentum states of light .
_ phys .
rev .
lett . _ * 105 , * 153601 ( 2010 ) .
mirhosseini , m. , malik , m. , shi z. , and boyd , r. w. efficient separation of the orbital angular momentum eigenstates of light .
_ nat .
comm . _ * 4 , * 2781 ( 2013 ) .
ruostekoski , j. , kneer , b. , schleich , w. p. , and rempe , g. interference of a bose - einstein condensate in a hard - wall trap : from the nonlinear talbot effect to the formation of vorticity .
_ phys .
rev .
a _ * 63 , * 043613 ( 2001 ) . |
a random tensor is a @xmath0-dimensional array of random variables .
the joint probability distribution is typically chosen to be @xmath1-invariant .
just like unitary invariance in random ( hermitian or complex ) matrices selects matrix traces as natural invariant observables , the invariance under @xmath1 points to a family of invariant observables , which are polynomials in the tensor entries .
those observables are labeled by connected , @xmath0-regular , edge - colored graphs , and one is interested in the large @xmath2 expansion of their expectations . in matrix models
@xcite , expectations of observables @xmath3 can be expanded onto feynman graphs , actually maps whose genus is the exponent of @xmath2 in the expansion at large @xmath2 .
the feynman expansion also applies to random tensors and gives rise to @xmath4-regular edge - colored graphs @xcite .
each feynman graph inherits an @xmath2-dependent weight , the exponent of @xmath2 being called the _ degree _ ( which reduces to the genus at @xmath5 ) .
those graphs are suited for a combinatorial analysis : the classification of colored graphs of fixed degree has been obtained in @xcite and the singularities of the generating functions are now known
. however , the calculation of expectations of invariant polynomials is still a challenging issue . even in the simplest case , i.e. the gaussian distribution , and even if one only asks for the leading order at large @xmath2 of an expectation , it is necessary to @xmath6 identify the exponent of @xmath2 for the dominant contributions , @xmath7 find the numerical coefficient which counts the number of dominant contributions ( dominant wick contractions ) .
both problems are bubble - dependent .
a few cases have been studied .
the so - called melonic polynomials all have a single leading order wick contraction ( as well as a generalization of this family including nearly - melonic polynomials ) @xcite .
a family of polynomials has been found in @xcite whose numbers of leading order wick contractions are numbers of meandric systems .
it is worth emphasizing the importance of the gaussian distribution in random tensor models .
it was proved in @xcite that any @xmath1-invariant distribution satisfying some assumptions on its dependence with @xmath2 becomes gaussian at large @xmath2 ( the covariance does depend on the initial distribution ) models which do not satisfy those assumptions ( and not gaussian at large @xmath2 ) are discussed in @xcite .
moreover , models which do not have a trivial bare covariance , and therefore have a renormalization group flow , tend to be asymptotically free : they have a gaussian fixed point ( this happens surprisingly more often than in ordinary quantum field theory ) @xcite .
it is appealing to think this somehow comes from the universality theorem of @xcite .
in addition to the purely combinatorial analysis of @xcite , matrix model techniques have recently been employed in tensor models .
they apply to models with quartic interactions for which the hubbard - stratanovich transformation leads to multi - matrix models @xcite . furthermore , as argued in @xcite , the behavior of generic models can then be deduced from those of the quartic ones ( universality phenomenon ) .
the relationship of such multi - matrix models to ordinary matrix models has been studied in @xcite where they are described in terms of fully packed loop configurations on random surfaces generated by @xmath8 models .
the results of random tensor theory were applied in this context , leading to a classification of loop configurations which corresponds to the classification of colored graphs .
this basically relied on interpreting a collection of matrices as a tensor . here
we focus on the gaussian distribution instead , and use another direct connection between random tensors and matrices . splitting the set of @xmath0 indices of the tensor into two sets
, we can consider the tensor as a ( typically rectangular ) matrix of size @xmath9 and then use the singular value decomposition .
however , tensor models are not @xmath10 or @xmath11 invariant , meaning that the integrals over the angular degrees of freedom are non - trivial .
when they can be performed at fixed singular values , an effective theory on the singular values is obtained .
although it is a simple idea , it is only the first time that it is applied explicitly to tensor models . as a first step in this program ,
we consider here the case of the calculation of expectations of polynomial observables in a gaussian distribution .
the angular integrals are integrals of polynomials in the unitary matrix elements and the formula of @xcite can be applied . in concrete situations where the degree of the polynomial is not too large
, exact results are obtained .
we also show that large @xmath2 behaviors can be extracted using the diagrammatic method of @xcite on a family of observables which generalize the melonic ones ( basically , trees , like in the melonic case , formed by the gluing of matrix trace - invariants ) .
in addition to providing so far unexplored relationships between random tensors and matrices , the approach of @xcite and the present paper shows the difficulties faced in random tensor theory in the familiar context of matrix models .
the work presented in @xcite relied on the simple observation that a set of matrices with a unitary symmetry among them can be seen as a tensor equipped with independent unitary transformations on its indices .
there is another simple way to relate tensor to matrices , which is to consider a tensor as a ( typically rectangular ) matrix between a subset of indices to the subset of the other indices . for a tensor on @xmath0 indices , seen as a linear form on @xmath12 ,
one picks up a subset @xmath13 and denote its complement @xmath14 .
one defines @xmath15 as a linear application from @xmath16 to @xmath17 .
of course , there are multiple ways to choose @xmath18 , but depending on the observables one is interested in , some choices are better than others .
we recall that a basis of observables is formed by the polynomials @xmath19 labeled by bubbles .
a _ bubble _ is a connected bipartite @xmath0-regular edge - colored graph , with colors @xmath20 such that all @xmath0 colors are incident to each vertex ( see figure [ fig : necklace ] ) .
the polynomial associated to a bubble is built by writing a tensor @xmath21 for each white vertex and its conjugated tensor @xmath22 for each black vertex .
when an edge of color @xmath23 connects a white to a black vertex , the indices in position @xmath23 of the corresponding @xmath21 and @xmath22 are identified ( with a kronecker delta ) and summed over from @xmath24 to @xmath2 .
such polynomials are invariant under @xmath1 , @xcite .
loosely speaking , a `` good '' choice of the subset @xmath18 relative to @xmath19 is one that minimizes the degrees of freedom entering @xmath25 . a natural way of separating the degrees of freedom of @xmath26 is to use the singular value decomposition with respect to @xmath18 , i.e. @xmath27 , where @xmath28 are unitary and @xmath29 is made of a square diagonal matrix completed with some rows or columns of zeros . for a few families of polynomials @xmath25 , the choice of @xmath18 is obvious , e.g. when there exists one such that @xmath30 is a function of the singular values only .
this last situation however requires to focus on polynomials of the form @xmath31 which we call _ necklaces_.
their bubbles consist of single cycles on @xmath32 vertices connected by two types of multiple edges , those with colors in @xmath18 and those with colors in the complementary subset ( see example in figure [ fig : necklace ] ) .
this is the necklace on five colors with @xmath33 and 6 vertices . ]
generically , a polynomial @xmath34 depends on all the degrees of freedom of the singular value decomposition .
this is simply because a polynomial invariant under the action of @xmath35 is generically not invariant under @xmath36 .
notice that the gaussian measure however is independent of the angular matrices @xmath28 , i.e. @xmath37 for any choice of @xmath18
. therefore the _ gaussian _ expectation of a polynomial reads @xmath38 here @xmath39 denotes the set of singular values , @xmath40 the measure inherited from the change of variables , while @xmath41 are the haar measures on unitary matrices of the appropriate sizes . this provides a notion of effective polynomial of @xmath25 with respect to @xmath18 which is a function over the singular values , @xmath42 then , the expectation of @xmath25 is just the expectation of @xmath43 in the complex gaussian wishart ensemble ( also known as the laguerre ensemble , from the family of relevant orthogonal polynomials for this measure ) .
the integral over the angular variables results in an expansion onto @xmath36-invariants , @xmath44 and therefore @xmath45 taking all the tensor indices to have range @xmath2 , the expectation of the product of single - trace invariants factorizes as the product of the expectations in the large @xmath2 limit .
there are two possible cases , @xmath46 the symbol @xmath47 here also means up to some power of @xmath2 and @xmath48 is the @xmath49-th catalan number .
when the matrix is rectangular , it is quite unbalanced since the ratio of its dimensions goes to either zero or infinity , and as a result a single wick contraction survives at large @xmath2 .
when @xmath18 ( or its complement ) is a singlet , it means that @xmath25 is a cycle of melons inserted on a fixed color and the result follows from @xcite . in the other cases ,
it is an application of the results of @xcite to the gaussian distribution ( which rely on the fact that there is a melonic subgraph which visits all the vertices ) . only when @xmath15 is a square matrix one recovers the familiar catalan numbers of gaussian matrix models .
several methods have been developed to deal with integrals over the unitary group , @xcite .
for our purpose , since the function @xmath50 is polynomial in the matrix elements of @xmath51 , the following formula @xcite seems to be the most natural to perform the integral , @xmath52 @xmath53 and @xmath54 run over the symmetric group on @xmath55 elements @xmath56 , and @xmath57 is a weingarten function over @xmath56 . in principle
, this provides a way to compute the effective polynomial @xmath43 , and there even exists a diagrammatic expansion which enables to control the scaling with @xmath2 of the various terms involved in the sums over permutations @xcite . yet in practice , the number @xmath55 of matrix elements of @xmath58 ( and similarly for @xmath59 ) can not be too large as the sum over permutations becomes unmanageable for relatively large @xmath55 .
we now set @xmath60 and @xmath61 and illustrate the method on two examples : a simple , but exact calculation , and a large @xmath2 behavior on a family of observables .
we write @xmath62 where a column of tensor indices represents a index of @xmath15 with range @xmath63 .
therefore @xmath64 is a @xmath65 matrix @xmath66 .
if @xmath25 is a bubble in which the edges of color 2 and 4 always connect the same vertices , then the associated polynomial is a function of @xmath67 .
moreover , the edges of color 2 count the degree in @xmath67 .
we consider the following bubble , with @xmath68 edges of color 2 on the top and @xmath49 at the bottom of the drawing , @xmath69{bubblecatcat.pdf } \end{array } = \operatorname{tr}_1 \bigl(\operatorname{tr}_3(mm^\dagger)^{k}\,\operatorname{tr}_3(mm^\dagger)^{l } \bigr ) = \sum_{a_1,a_3,b_1,b_3=1}^n ( mm^\dagger)^{k}_{\begin{smallmatrix } a_1\\ a_3\end{smallmatrix } \begin{smallmatrix } b_1\\ a_3\end{smallmatrix}}\ ( mm^\dagger)^{l}_{\begin{smallmatrix } b_1\\ b_3\end{smallmatrix } \begin{smallmatrix } a_1\\ b_3\end{smallmatrix}},\ ] ] using an obvious partial trace notation . by writing @xmath70 with @xmath71
, we find @xmath72 the integral over @xmath73 is simple enough since there are only two permutations on two elements , @xmath74 only the cycle structure of the arguments of the weingarten functions is retained ( they are class functions ) , so that @xmath75 is the ( class of the ) identity and @xmath76 the ( class of the ) transposition .
moreover , @xmath77 performing the sums , it comes @xmath78 which is the tensor that has to be contracted with the singular values .
eventually we arrive at @xmath79 the large @xmath2 limit of the expectation can be easily extracted . normalizing the gaussian with a covariance @xmath80 , the double - trace term dominates ( each trace bringing up a factor @xmath63 ) and factorizes , so that @xmath81 ( the scaling factor @xmath82 is due to the fact that the bubble has a single cycle with colors @xmath83 and two cycles of colors @xmath84 , see @xcite . ) when the degree of the polynomial in @xmath58 ( and/or @xmath59 ) which has to be integrated is large , an exact result becomes difficult to extract and largely depend on the combinatorics of the initial bubble .
even the asymptotics seems difficult to evaluate .
however , in some cases , the method can lead to the large @xmath2 limit .
we consider a family of observables built in the following way .
we first define the _ open necklace of color @xmath23 _ as the necklace with a line of color @xmath23 cut into two halves ( see figure [ fig : opennecklace ] ) .
then the construction starts with a necklace of length @xmath85 .
a random edge of color 1 or 3 is deleted and instead an open necklace of the appropriate color is attached so as to get a bipartite graph . on this new graph ,
a randomly chosen edge of color 1 or 3 is removed and replaced by an open necklace of the same color .
the family of interest in this section consists of graphs built by continuing this process recursively a finite number of times . on
the left is a necklace and on the right an open necklace of color 1.,title="fig : " ] on the left is a necklace and on the right an open necklace of color 1.,title="fig : " ] to avoid redundancies in the construction , one can consider the rooted observables .
the construction starts with an open necklace of color 1 .
then the process of piling up open necklaces is similar , except that after an insertion on the color @xmath23 , further insertions on the newly created edge of this color and incident to the black vertex of the inserted open necklace are forbidden .
all other edges of color 1 and 3 are called active edges .
this way , there is a partial order between the open necklaces used to build up the observables .
a necklace ( a child ) is smaller than another one ( a parent ) if it is inserted on an active edge of the other one .
every necklace ( but the root one ) has a single parent .
there is a simple bijection between the set of such rooted observables and a family of rooted , corner - labeled , plane trees .
it is a generalization of the bijection between melonic graphs and trees , explained in @xcite , in the sense that the case of melonic graphs with melons on the colors 1 and 3 only will be recovered by removing the labels on the trees .
the tree associated to an observable simply represents the relations of partial order between the necklaces .
vertices correspond to open necklaces and edges of color 1 and 3 represent the child / parent relationships .
notice that a typical necklace however has several edges of color 1 and 3 so that further decorations are required to keep track of the specific edges on which insertions are performed .
one defines the distance between two edges incident to the same vertex and both connected to children of this vertex as the number of edges of color 2 which separate the two insertions on the necklace corresponding to this vertex .
the distance at a vertex @xmath86 between an edge connected to a children of this vertex and an edge connected to the parent of @xmath86 is the number of edges of color 2 around the necklace corresponding to @xmath86 between the edge incident to a black vertex which goes to the parent necklace and the edge on which the insertion of the children necklace is performed . in the tree , those distances
are included by preserving the cyclic ordering of the insertions around each vertex , so that they label the corners .
an example is given in figure [ fig : treevertex ] .
this represents a typical necklace within an observable , which is mapped to a vertex of the corresponding tree .
if we assume the edge connected to the parent is the open one incident to the black vertex and of color 1 on the left , then the distances labeling the corners ( going counter - clockwise ) read 3 , 2 , 0 , 1 , 3 , 0 .
the final 0 is only here when there is a necklace insertion on the open edge of color 1 on the left , incident to the white vertex . ]
the bubble considered in the equation is represented by the tree with two vertices and a single edge of color 1 between them .
it has two corners , one with label @xmath68 and one with label @xmath49 .
( the necklace itself could be seen as the tree consisting of a single vertex , which has no corner , although an integer is needed for the length . )
if @xmath87 denotes the set of corners of the tree @xmath88 , @xmath89 its set of vertices , and @xmath90 the set of integers attached to the corners of @xmath88 , the total length around the vertex @xmath91 is @xmath92 .
then @xmath93 to prove this , we will show that the removal of a leaf with label @xmath49 and its incident edge in the tree amounts to factorizing the catalan number @xmath48 .
zooming on the explicit dependence of @xmath94 at such a leaf , say with incident edge of color 1 , we have @xmath95_{a_1 b_1}\,\bigl[f(mm^\dagger)\bigr]_{b_1 a_1 } = \sum u_{\begin{smallmatrix } a_1\\ a_3\end{smallmatrix } \begin{smallmatrix } \alpha_2\\ \alpha_4\end{smallmatrix } } \lambda_{\begin{smallmatrix } \alpha_2\\ \alpha_4\end{smallmatrix}}^{2l } \overline{u}_{\begin{smallmatrix } b_1\\ a_3\end{smallmatrix}\begin{smallmatrix } \alpha_2\\ \alpha_4\end{smallmatrix}}\,\bigl[f(ud^2u^\dagger)\bigr]_{b_1 a_1}.\ ] ] here @xmath96 is a matrix - valued function corresponding to chopping off the leaf and half the incident edge . to perform the integral over @xmath58
, we use the diagrammatic method of @xcite .
first , one gets a diagram corresponding to the integrand and then the expansion of the integral is obtained as a sum over decorations of this diagram by additional edges ( akin to wick contractions of feynman diagrams ) .
the matrix element of @xmath58 is represented by an edge between a black vertex ( corresponding to the left indices , of colors 1 , 3 ) and a white vertex ( corresponding to the right indices , of colors 2 , 4 ) . for @xmath97 , the edge
is simply decorated with a star .
the matrix elements of powers of @xmath98 are represented as edges with a box on them .
finally the indices of colors 1 , 3 are drawn explicitly as half - edges . this way , @xmath99{md2mdagger.pdf } \end{array}\ ] ] the integral
is performed using and @xmath55 denotes the number of matrix elements of @xmath58 .
each term in the resulting sum over permutations @xmath100 is represented as a diagram obtained from the one of the integrand by adding a dashed edge for each kronecker delta .
the permutation @xmath53 ( respectively @xmath54 ) is thus represented by dashed edges connecting black ( respectively white ) vertices two by two . each diagram is then weighted with the weingarten function @xmath101 .
consider a diagram where @xmath102 and @xmath103 are not connected to @xmath104 and @xmath105 , but rather to other vertices from other parts of the tree , as in the left of figure [ fig : leafcontraction ] .
the rectangle there stands for an arbitrary configuration of the remaining dashed edges .
we are going to compare this situation to another diagram obtained from it by cutting the four dashed edges in halves and reconnecting them as on the right of figure [ fig : leafcontraction ] ( all dashed lines which are not drawn are untouched ) .
we want to compare their amplitude as a function of @xmath2 .
the @xmath2-dependence is found by counting the number of independent sums of range @xmath2 after applying .
there are several types of independent sums which can all be tracked diagrammatically . *
each cycle consisting of alternating dashed edges and edges of color 1 ( resp .
3 ) corresponds to a sum over an index with the color 1 ( resp .
3 ) , hence it brings a factor @xmath2 .
the number of such cycles is denoted @xmath106 ( resp .
@xmath107 ) .
* each cycle consisting of alternating dashed edges and edges with a box corresponds to a sum over indices with the colors 2 and 4 , hence it brings a factor @xmath63 .
the number of such cycles is denoted @xmath108 . *
the weingarten function @xmath101 is a function of the cycle structure of @xmath109 , which we write @xmath110 ( meaning @xmath111 cycles of length @xmath112 , with @xmath113 ) .
each cycle is represented in the diagram as a cycle consisting of alternating dashed edges and edges of @xmath58 and @xmath97 .
the number of cycles is denoted @xmath114 .
moreover , the weingarten function asymptotically behaves as @xmath115^{p_j}.\ ] ] that implies that each cycle comes with a factor @xmath63 .
we can now evaluate the variation of all those quantities between the left and the right of figure [ fig : leafcontraction ] .
* the two dashed lines incident to the black vertices on the left are parts of either one or two cycles with color 1 ( depending on the details inside the rectangle ) which gives two or one cycles on the right , hence @xmath116 .
* the two dashed lines incident to the black vertices on the left belong to one cycle with color 3 , which splits into two cycles on the right , @xmath117 .
* the two dashed lines incident to the white vertices on the left belong to one cycle of type `` box '' , which splits into two cycles on the right , @xmath118 . * the four dashed lines on the left can either belong to two different cycles of the permutation @xmath109 ( one going along the edge @xmath119 and the other along @xmath120 ) or to the same one . on the right
, we have a cycle @xmath121 and at least another one in the rectangle .
thus , @xmath122 .
therefore the amplitude for the diagram on the right bounds the one for the diagram on the left by at least a factor @xmath123 .
this means that for every configuration like the left hand side of figure [ fig : leafcontraction ] , there is an associated configuration which is enhanced .
the same conclusion is reached by means of similar arguments if instead of the left hand side of figure [ fig : leafcontraction ] there is a dashed edge between @xmath103 and @xmath105 or between @xmath102 and @xmath104 .
the solid , non - colored edges represent matrix elements of @xmath58 , and @xmath97 with a star , edges with boxes represent singular values .
contractions of indices of colors 1 , 3 are represented with edges incident to black vertices and the dashed edges correspond to the kronecker deltas induced by the permutations @xmath124 in .
the vertices @xmath125 represent the matrix indices on a leaf of a tree and the rectangle contains the rest of the tree .
the diagram on the right is obtained from the one of the left by cutting the dashed edges which are drawn and reconnecting them so that @xmath103 is connected to @xmath105 and @xmath102 to @xmath104.,title="fig : " ] the solid , non - colored edges represent matrix elements of @xmath58 , and @xmath97 with a star , edges with boxes represent singular values .
contractions of indices of colors 1 , 3 are represented with edges incident to black vertices and the dashed edges correspond to the kronecker deltas induced by the permutations @xmath124 in .
the vertices @xmath125 represent the matrix indices on a leaf of a tree and the rectangle contains the rest of the tree .
the diagram on the right is obtained from the one of the left by cutting the dashed edges which are drawn and reconnecting them so that @xmath103 is connected to @xmath105 and @xmath102 to @xmath104.,title="fig : " ] as a conclusion , it comes that all dominant contributions to the angular integral have a dashed edge between @xmath103 and @xmath105 and one between @xmath102 and @xmath104 , which fixes one value of @xmath53 and one value of @xmath54 .
it forces @xmath109 to have a fixed point and this cycle contributes to a trivial factor 1 of the weingarten function .
therefore , up to factors of @xmath2 , @xmath126_{b_1 a_1 } \\ & \underset{\text{large $ n$}}{= } \bigl(\sum_{\alpha_2 , \alpha_4 } \lambda_{\begin{smallmatrix } \alpha_2\\ \alpha_4\end{smallmatrix}}^{2l}\bigr ) \int_{u(n^2 ) } du\,\sum_{a_1 } \bigl[f(ud^2u^\dagger)\bigr]_{a_1 a_1}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] the expectation of this product factorizes at large @xmath2 , so that @xmath127 and the trace of @xmath128 is simply the bubble polynomial labeled by the tree @xmath129 , where the two corners incident to the edge on the parent vertex are merged and their labels added .
an induction from the leaves to the root leads to .
in this short note , both approaches of @xcite and @xcite have been pursued : * exploring the relations between tensor and matrix models like in @xcite and using them * to evaluate new gaussian expectations in random tensor theory , in particular for non - melonic polynomials , supplementing the results of @xcite through another method .
the starting point is as simple as that of @xcite : a tensor can be seen as a ( typically rectangular ) matrix with one index being a @xmath130-uple of tensor indices and the other index a @xmath131-uple ( @xmath0 being the total number of indices ) .
just as in @xcite , unitary transformations and symmetries play a major role . but instead of offering a novel presentation of the results of random tensor theory , we rather apply tools from random matrices , namely integrals over the unitary group . in the section [ sec : gaussian ]
, we have embedded our tensor on a matrix space , but the polynomials of interest in tensor theory do not have a group of unitary symmetries as large as the matrix trace - invariants . as a consequence ,
a typical tensor observable depends on the angular degrees of freedom in addition to the singular values of the matrix . in a gaussian distribution ,
integrating the observable over its angular variables leads to a notion of effective observable which writes as a sum of products of traces .
this approach enables exact calculations in concrete cases as shown in section [ sec : exactcalculation ] .
we have shown in section [ sec : catalantrees ] that in more complicated cases ( i.e. when the degree of the polynomial to be integrated over the unitary group can be arbitrarily large ) asymptotic calculations may still be possible .
this was illustrated on a family of observables built from matrix trace - invariants glued together in a tree - like fashion .
as well - known , the large @xmath2 limit of tensor models ( equipped with their standard scaling ) with melonic interactions is gaussian @xcite : from a matrix viewpoint , it is as if the singular values all localize at the minimum of the potential @xcite .
the method used here in [ sec : catalantrees ] allows to evaluate expectations for _ non - melonic _
observables , ones for which the distribution of singular values has a non - vanishing width .
this is a new addition to the toolbox for random gaussian tensors , complementing the meander approach of @xcite which fits a different set of observables .
an open challenge is to take the exponential of such observables , so as to get non - melonic , non - gaussian measures , which as shown in @xcite do have non - gaussian large @xmath2 limit ( but whose entropy exponents are still unknown ) .
even the simplest integral over @xmath132 in the gaussian case was shown to be of degree 4 , implying that the exponential is not of the itzykson - zuber type .
it may be that techniques not considered in the present paper work , like the one developed in @xcite , and this will be investigated elsewhere .
we hope that the relationship we have established between tensor models and loop models can lead to fruitful cross - fertilization .
we would like to eventually mention a more speculatively related idea . the same way the schwinger - dyson equations of ordinary matrix models constitute a set of virasoro constraints , those of tensor models can be cast as a set of constraints generated by operators which form a lie algebra @xcite .
those operators are differential with respect to the coupling constants and are labeled by bubbles .
they basically trade the expectations of bubbles for linear operations . in order to understand this algebra
, it seems natural to gain knowledge of those expectations ( methods as well as exact or approximated evaluations ) . only the large @xmath2 limit and the double scaling limit
are so far understood through schwinger - dyson equations ( they however only include melonic contributions and specific chains ) @xcite .
the calculation of gaussian expectations for more generic bubbles is a first step in that direction .
this is certainly crucial to quantum gravity or rather `` bubble theory '' , as well as to the possible integrable properties of tensor models .
research at perimeter institute is supported by the government of canada through industry canada and by the province of ontario through the ministry of research and innovation .
p. di francesco , p. h. ginsparg and j. zinn - justin , `` 2-d gravity and random matrices , '' phys .
rept . * 254 * , 1 ( 1995 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9306153 ] .
r. gurau , `` the 1/n expansion of colored tensor models , '' annales henri poincare * 12 * , 829 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1011.2726 [ gr - qc ] ] .
r. gurau , `` the complete 1/n expansion of colored tensor models in arbitrary dimension , '' arxiv:1102.5759 [ gr - qc ] .
v. bonzom , r. gurau and v. rivasseau , `` random tensor models in the large n limit : uncoloring the colored tensor models , '' phys .
d * 85 * , 084037 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1202.3637 [ hep - th ] ] .
r. gurau and g. schaeffer , `` regular colored graphs of positive degree , '' [ arxiv:1307.5279 [ math.co ] ] .
r. gurau , `` universality for random tensors , '' arxiv:1111.0519 [ math.pr ] .
v. bonzom , `` new 1/n expansions in random tensor models , '' jhep 1306 ( 2013 ) 062 arxiv:1211.1657 [ hep - th ] .
d. benedetti , j. ben geloun and d. oriti , `` functional renormalisation group approach for tensorial group field theory : a rank-3 model , '' arxiv:1411.3180 [ hep - th ] .
j. ben geloun , `` renormalizable models in rank @xmath133 tensorial group field theory , '' commun . math .
phys . *
332 * , 117 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1306.1201 [ hep - th ] ] .
j. ben geloun , `` two and four - loop @xmath134-functions of rank 4 renormalizable tensor field theories , '' class .
* 29 * , 235011 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1205.5513 [ hep - th ] ] .
s. carrozza , `` group field theory in dimension four minus epsilon , '' arxiv:1411.5385 [ hep - th ] .
s. dartois , r. gurau and v. rivasseau , `` double scaling in tensor models with a quartic interaction , '' jhep * 1309 * , 088 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1307.5281 [ hep - th ] ] .
r. gurau , `` the @xmath135 expansion of tensor models beyond perturbation theory , '' arxiv:1304.2666 [ math - ph ] .
t. delepouve , r. gurau and v. rivasseau , `` borel summability and the non perturbative @xmath135 expansion of arbitrary quartic tensor models , '' arxiv:1403.0170 [ hep - th ] .
v. bonzom , r. gurau , j. p. ryan and a. tanasa , `` the double scaling limit of random tensor models , '' arxiv:1404.7517 [ hep - th ] . v. bonzom and f. combes , `` tensor models from the viewpoint of matrix models : the case of loop models on random surfaces , '' arxiv:1304.4152 [ hep - th ] . b. collins , `` moments and cumulants of polynomial random variables on unitary groups , the itzykson - zuber integral and free probability , '' int . math . res . not . ,
( 17):953 - 982 , 2003 , [ math - ph/0205010 ] . p. w. brouwer and c. w. j. beenakker , `` diagrammatic method of integration over the unitary group , with applications to quantum transport in mesoscopic systems , '' j. math .
phys . * 37 * , 4904 ( 1996 ) [ cond - mat/9604059 ] .
v. bonzom , r. gurau , a. riello and v. rivasseau , `` critical behavior of colored tensor models in the large n limit , '' nucl
* b853 * , 174 - 195 ( 2011 ) .
[ arxiv:1105.3122 [ hep - th ] ] v. bonzom , `` revisiting random tensor models at large n via the schwinger - dyson equations , '' jhep 1303 ( 2013 ) 160 arxiv:1208.6216 [ hep - th ] .
v. a. nguyen , s. dartois and b. eynard , `` an analysis of the intermediate field theory of @xmath136 tensor model , '' arxiv:1409.5751 [ math - ph ] .
r. gurau , `` the double scaling limit in arbitrary dimensions : a toy model , '' phys .
d * 84 * , 124051 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1110.2460 [ hep - th ] ] .
r. gurau , `` a generalization of the virasoro algebra to arbitrary dimensions , '' nucl .
b * 852 * , 592 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1105.6072 [ hep - th ] ] .
r. gurau , `` the schwinger dyson equations and the algebra of constraints of random tensor models at all orders , '' nucl . phys .
b * 865 * , 133 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1203.4965 [ hep - th ] ] . | observables in random tensor theory are polynomials in the entries of tensor of rank @xmath0 which are invariant under @xmath1 .
it is notoriously difficult to evaluate the expectations of such polynomials , even in the gaussian distribution . in this article , we introduce singular value decompositions to evaluate the expectations of polynomial observables of gaussian random tensors .
performing the matrix integrals over the unitary group leads to a notion of effective observables which expand onto regular , matrix trace invariants .
examples are given to illustrate that both asymptotic and exact new calculations of expectations can be performed this way . |
one of the interesting possibilities which open up in theories with more than four spacetime dimensions is to explain the misterious pattern of fermion mass hierarchies @xcite . in previous works @xcite ,
we have shown how a single family of fermions , with vectorlike couplings to the standard model group @xmath0 in 6 dimensions was reduced to @xmath1 _ chiral _ families in 4 dimensions .
this mechanism hinged on a localisation on a vortex in the `` transverse '' dimensions , characterized by a winding number @xmath1 . as a variant , an effective vortex achieving the same result
could be simulated by coupling the fermions to a winding - number 1 scalar elevated to the @xmath1th power .
the value @xmath2 is not favoured in such schemes , and was only invoked for its phenomenological interest .
we also showed how a relatively simple scalar structure ( the usual higgs doublet @xmath3 , supplemented by the vortex - defining field @xmath4 ) suffices to generate the mass hierarchy of the @xmath1 families , while an auxiliary field @xmath5 could be used to generate a mixing taking place mostly between adjacent generations .
the key to the construction is that interaction with a vortex with winding number @xmath1 leads , by the index theorem @xcite , to @xmath1 chiral zero modes in four dimensions , and this for each fermion species coupled to the structure .
we now return to this construction and pay special attention to the case of neutrinos . the simplest attitude ( which was in a way implicit in the previous papers )
would be to treat neutrinos just like the other fermions , that is to include both left- and right - handed fields , say @xmath6 and @xmath7 in four dimensions , and to generalize them to six dimensions .
dirac masses and mixings are then obtained just like those of the charged fermions .
there is nothing fundamental against this approach , except the very small value of the ratio between neutrino and charged fermion masses ( typically less than @xmath8 )
. this would require severe fine tuning , either directly at the level of the yukawa couplings themselves , or in a more covert fashion through a more complicated scalar structure ( see footnote below ) .
we therefore try to explore other ways of getting small neutrino masses .
it has become standard practice @xcite in the context of extra ( flat and compactified ) dimensions , to assume that right - handed neutrions , being gauge singlets , could propagate in the `` bulk '' of space , escaping confinement .
this is of course possible since such particles do not participate directly in the gauge interactions , and therefore do not affect ( at least at tree level , see for instance ref .
@xcite ) the behaviour of electroweak exchanges .
in such a context , the smallness of the neutrino mass stems not from artficially tuned yukawa couplings , but from the severely reduced overlap between the confined and `` bulk '' wave functions .
could such a strategy work here ?
the transcription of such a mechanism in our context involves the introduction of a six - dimensional fermion field , @xmath7 , uncoupled to the vortex field @xmath4 .
this however is in general not sufficient , if the two - dimensional transverse space stays unbounded ( a point which we did not really need to specify this far , since the vortex achieved in any case the localisation of physical fields in a four - dimensional tube ) . using @xmath9 and @xmath10 as variables to describe the two extra dimensions , we should now require @xmath11 , while keeping @xmath12 , to avoid perturbing the previous construction . is this step sufficient ? in principle , if @xmath13 were close to the expected light neutrino mass scale ( say a fraction of an ev ) , we would have a whole set of kaluza - klein towers at hand , each with relatively light states to couple to the @xmath1 left - handed neutrinos .
this line is however somewhat dangerous , since it may lead to a conflict with data on the evolution of supernovae @xcite .
we will avoid this situation by requesting @xmath14 .
for simplicity we may even take @xmath15 gev .
this further requirement however leads us to a pecular situation : we may not have enough light `` right - handed '' partners to provide masses to the @xmath1 neutrinos ! indeed , we typically expect only one fundamental mode of zero mass .
introducing @xmath1 such fermions would of course solve the problem , but would be in opposition to the approach , where at least the charged family multiplication simply results from the topological structure .
fortunately , even with the simplest use of one @xmath7 field , we get easily two light states ( this is a funciton of the chosen charge assignements , see below ) , leaving only @xmath16 degenerate massless @xmath17 states .
since one strictly massless neutrino is no problem ( only differences in masses squared are tested this far ) , the neutrino degeneracy is thus solved for @xmath18 . the scheme presented below uses one extra scalar field to match quantum numbers and generate the neutrino masses .
it is of course also possible to induce mixing terms , but these are probably redundant , since off - diagonal terms are already allowed for in the charged leptons sector .
if different fermionic modes have different wave function profiles in extra dimensions , then their overlaps with the higgs wave function may produce hierarchical structure of masses and mixings @xcite . in the class of models @xcite ,
each multi - dimensional fermion develops three chiral zero modes localized on a four - dimensional brane due to topological properties of the brane background .
the index theorem guarantees that the three zero modes are linearly independent , and thus have different profiles in extra dimensions .
analysis of the equations for these zero modes demonstrates that a hierarchy in the mass matrix indeed appears due to overlaps of the wave functions . for the discussion of this mechanism and comparison with other approaches ,
see ref .
@xcite .
we use conventions of ref .
@xcite throughout the paper .
we will work in a specific realisation of this approach which was suggested in ref .
the model is formulated in six dimensions , and the brane is an abelian vortex made of the gauge field of @xmath19 gauge group and a scalar field @xmath4 .
field content of the model of ref .
@xcite is given in table 1 for easy reference .field content of the model of ref .
@xcite ( scalars and leptons only ) . [ cols=">,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] with these charge assignements , we can write down two interaction terms , y_1 hs|l1-_72n , [ n7 * ] and y_2 hs^*|l1+_72n .
[ n7 * * ] substituting zero modes of @xmath20 and @xmath7 , one gets the effective lagrangian @xmath21 since @xmath3 and @xmath22 have no @xmath9 dependence in their classical profiles , the integral over @xmath9 is non - zero for @xmath23 ( the first term ) and @xmath24 ( the second ) .
thus , the modes @xmath25 and @xmath26 are paired in the mass matrix .
the masses are given by integrals @xmath27 where the norm @xmath28 , @xmath29 being the size of the extra dimensions .
masses of @xmath30 and @xmath31 differ only by yukawa couplings @xmath32 in two terms .
two notes are in order .
first , would we add another scalar with the same quantum numbers as @xmath22 but with winding number 1 , we would receive a more complicated mass matrix ( mixing would appear in the neutrino sector as well as in the sector of charged leptons ) , but not the mass for the third neutrino because we have only two right - handed weyl spinors , @xmath33 and @xmath34 , available .
one linear combination of @xmath35 would still be massless .
second , the eqs .
( [ n7 * ] ) , ( [ n7 * * ] ) mix @xmath35 with nonzero modes of @xmath7 as well .
however , to satisfy simultaneously constraints from weak charge universality and from supernova 1987a , these mixings should be negligible .
in order to count parameters and to estimate the scales involved in the model , we make use of the `` step higgs '' approximation ( full numerical analysis will be presented elsewhere @xcite ) .
first of all , recall that in six dimensions , a scalar field has dimension ( mass)@xmath36 and a fermion field has dimension ( mass)@xmath37 .
this means that the transverse part of the fermion , described by @xmath38 , has dimension ( mass)@xmath39 ( four - dimensional spinors , denoted by letters in bold face , are of course ( mass)@xmath40 ) .
dimensions of coupling constants are @xmath41={\rm ( mass)}^{-3}$ ] , @xmath42={\rm ( mass)}^{-5}$ ] , @xmath43={\rm ( mass)}^{-1}$ ] , @xmath44={\rm ( mass)}^{-2}$ ] .
the fundamental dimensionful parameters of the theory are the vortex scale @xmath45 ( in theories where large extra dimensions are invoked to reformulate the gauge hierarchy problem , @xmath45 is of order multi - dimensional planck mass ) , and the compactification scale @xmath29 .
it is convenient to rescale the parameters of the theory : @xmath46 tilded coupling constants @xmath47 , @xmath48 , @xmath49 , @xmath50 are dimensionless , while @xmath51 , @xmath52 , @xmath53 have dimension ( mass)@xmath39 . in the narrow higgs approximation
, @xmath54 can be substituted by @xmath55 where @xmath56 is the width of @xmath54 which is supposed to be smaller than widths of other profiles .
then , we can use the following approximations for @xmath57 : @xmath58 @xmath59 @xmath60 the coefficients at @xmath61 in fermionic radial functions are determined , approximately , in ref . @xcite . for the scalar fields
@xmath3 , @xmath5 , and @xmath22 , the boundary conditions at @xmath62 are @xmath63 , etc . ; so that @xmath64 , @xmath65 , @xmath66 are to be determined by solving the full nonlinear system @xcite .
we denote @xmath67 , @xmath68 , @xmath69 , where @xmath70 and @xmath71 are coefficients of order one , @xmath72 depends non - trivially on @xmath73 and @xmath45 .
since @xmath73 and @xmath45 are independent parameters of the lagrangian , @xmath72 does not need to be very close to @xmath45 , though we do not wish them to differ too much in order to avoid fine tuning of the parameters .
diagonal elements of the mass matrix of charged leptons are , to this approximation , @xmath74 where @xmath75 should be sufficiently small to provide the mass hierarchy between three generations .
smallness of @xmath76 exactly corresponds to the fact that @xmath54 is more narrow than @xmath77 , @xmath78 .
non - diagonal mass matrix elements are estimated in a similar way , taking into account the behaviour of @xmath79 at small @xmath10 : @xmath80 the result is that @xmath81 where generation - independent constant @xmath82 this corresponds to the mass matrix of charged leptons m_em_0e ( ccc 1&0&0 + & /2&0
+ 0&/2&^2/3 ) , [ 4.3 * ] where the overall constant @xmath83 .
it is straightforward to obtain , to the same approximation , the neutrino mass matrix @xmath84 where @xmath85 and we rescaled , as before , @xmath86 .
the matrix is @xmath87 because we have only two light right - handed modes , @xmath33 and @xmath34 .
thus , up to dimensionless constants of order one , the neutrino mass scale is suppressed by a factor of @xmath88 with respect to the mass scale of charged fermions , @xmath89 .
one can have simultaneously @xmath90 gev , @xmath91 ev , and planck mass relation @xmath92 gev satisfied for @xmath93 tev , @xmath94 tev , @xmath95 mm . in our model , neutrino mass matrix does not contain mixings . in the sector of charged leptons , however , mixing appears , see eq .
( [ 4.3 * ] ) .
three parameters @xmath96 , @xmath76 , and @xmath97 , determine the masses of three charged leptons ; one can fit known values of @xmath98 with @xmath99 mev , @xmath100 , @xmath101 .
the latter value means that mixing is not negligible in the leptonic sector . since all leptonic mixings appear in eq .
( [ 4.3 * ] ) , our model * predicts * values of the neutrino mixing angles which are implicitly determined by masses of charged leptons . in usual notations , they correspond to @xmath102 , @xmath103 , @xmath104 . on the other hand , values of two @xmath105
are predicted only by the order of magnitude since they depend on unknown constants @xmath106 .
in a class of multidimensional models with one vector - like fermionic family , the low - energy effective theory describes three chiral families in four dimensions .
hierarchy of fermionic masses appears without fine tuning of parameters . in this paper
, we have shown that nondegenerate neutrino masses can be incorporated in a model of this class with the help of only one multidimensional dirac fermion .
one of three neutrinos is exactly massless ] while masses of two others are parametrically close to each other .
neutrino mass matrix is diagonal , but mixings in the leptonic sector are present in the mass matrix of charged leptons .
once masses of @xmath107 , @xmath73 , @xmath108 are fixed to their experimental values , the model _ predicts _ neutrino mixing angles , @xmath109 , @xmath110 , @xmath104 .
of course , these values were obtained with very rough approximations , and should not be taken too seriously .
neutrino mass differences are predicted by order of magnitude only , @xmath111 for natural values of parameters .
= 800 the authors are indebted to k.agashe , e.akhmedov , t.gherghetta , m.giovannini , i.gogoladze , a.neronov , e.nugaev , v.rubakov , g.senjanovic , m.shaposhnikov , s.sibiryakov , a.smirnov for helpful discussions on different subjects related to this work .
the work of m.l . and s.t.is supported in part by rffi grant 99 - 02 - 18410a , by the council of presidential grants and state support of leading scientific schools , grant 00 - 15 - 96626 , by crdf award rp1 - 2103 , and by the programme scopes of the swiss national science foundation , project no . 7supj062239 , financed by federal department of foreign affairs .
the work of s.t.is supported in part by swiss science foundation , grant 21 - 58947.99 .
this work was initiated during the visits of m.l . and s.t .
to ulb , which we thank for kind hospitality and partial support by the `` actions de recherche concretes '' of `` communaut franaise de belgique '' and iisn belgium .
thanks high energy group of ictp ( trieste ) for hospitality during his visit , when part of this work was done and numerous discussions were carried out .
in this appendix , we present the solution to the transverse part of dirac equation , @xmath112 where @xmath113 . the general solution for @xmath114
is @xmath115 here , @xmath116 are independent two - component spinors . the solutions regular both at small and large @xmath10 correspond to @xmath117 , eq .
( [ n6 * ] ) . for them ,
the normalization factors @xmath118 , where @xmath29 is the radius of the bulk . for @xmath119 ,
the regular at @xmath62 solution depends on two two - component spinors @xmath120 , @xmath121 for each @xmath122 : n = c * n*_j_p(r)^ip + -*n*_j_p-1(r)^i(p-1 ) + * m*_j_q(r)^iq + * m*_j_q-1(r)^i(q-1 ) .
[ zero_modes_of_n ] a series of eigenvalues @xmath123 are determined by the boundary conditions at large @xmath10 .
the exact eigenvalues depend on the compactification scheme chosen ( see discussion in appendix [ app3 ] ) , but in general , they are of order @xmath124
the compactification scheme defines boundary conditions at large @xmath10 . it should satisfy the following criteria : the second requirement is essentially equivalent to compactification on a ricci - flat manifold ( that is , a manifold with zero scalar curvature @xmath125 ) @xcite .
toroidal compactifications satisfy this requirement since the torus have @xmath126 .
however , the corresponding boundary conditions usually kill one or two of three zero modes because they allow either even or odd winding numbers for a given field .
compactification of a vortex on a sphere preserves three zero modes @xcite but does not satisfy the second requirement : for a sphere , @xmath127 .
this would open an interesting possibility of having three massless neutrinos and explaining observed neutrino anomalies by mixing with kaluza - klein modes only ( this would lead to a nonconventional pattern of oscillations , as was discussed in ref .
@xcite in the frameworks of a toy model ) . however , this possibility is in contradiction with bounds on mixing with kaluza - klein states from supernova evolution .
one can also keep the compactification mechanism unspecified , and consider flat space of finite volume .
this means that the fields will live inside a cilinder of large radius @xmath29 in six dimensions .
the corresponding boundary condition , that is , absence of fermionic current through the boundary , can be reformulated @xcite as @xmath128 for a dirac spinor @xmath129 .
applied to @xmath7 , eq .
( [ zero_modes_of_n ] ) , this boundary condition selects not only constant , but also rather peculiar zero modes which grow up at large @xmath10 . in this case , it is not necessary to introduce the additional field @xmath22 to obtain a second neutrino mass , and it suffices to use the additional mode , alternatively , with the field @xmath22 included , 3 ( even 4 if the model is extended ) neutrino masses can be generated , although the last 2 are then hierarchically smaller than the ones previously defined . at this level however , such modes appear more as a quirk of a particular way to implement the finite volume .
it seems the most promising to have a finite volume in the case of warped transverse dimensions .
particularly interesting is the fact that there exist six - dimensional solutions with gravity localized on an abelian vortex , ref .
these six - dimensional solutions provide also a natural framework for the localization of gauge fields at weak coupling , thus opening the way to fully realistic and calculable models .
99 n. arkani - hamed and m. schmaltz , phys .
* d61 * ( 2000 ) 033005 [ hep - ph/9903417 ] ; + g. dvali and m. shifman , phys . lett .
* b475 * ( 2000 ) 295 [ hep - ph/0001072 ] ; + t. gherghetta and a. pomarol , hep - ph/0003129 ; + d. e. kaplan and t. m. tait , jhep * 0006 * ( 2000 ) 020 [ hep - ph/0004200 ] ; + s. j. huber and q. shafi , hep - ph/0010195 . m. v. libanov and s. v. troitsky , nucl .
b * 599 * , 319 ( 2001 ) [ hep - ph/0011095 ] .
j. m. frere , m. v. libanov and s. v. troitsky , phys .
b * 512 * , 169 ( 2001 ) [ hep - ph/0012306 ] .
e. j. weinberg , phys .
rev . * d24 * ( 1981 ) 2669 ; n. arkani - hamed , s. dimopoulos , g. dvali and j. march - russell , hep - ph/9811448 ; + k. r. dienes , e. dudas and t. gherghetta , nucl .
b * 557 * ( 1999 ) 25 [ hep - ph/9811428 ] .
g. barenboim , g. c. branco , a. de gouvea and m. n. rebelo , hep - ph/0104312 .
a. de gouvea , g. f. giudice , a. strumia and k. tobe , hep - ph/0107156 .
r. barbieri , p. creminelli and a. strumia , nucl .
b * 585 * ( 2000 ) 28 [ hep - ph/0002199 ] ; + a. lukas , p. ramond , a. romanino and g. g. ross , jhep * 0104 * ( 2001 ) 010 [ hep - ph/0011295 ] .
g. dvali and m. shifman , phys . lett .
b * 396 * ( 1997 ) 64 [ erratum - ibid .
b * 407 * ( 1997 ) 452 ] [ hep - th/9612128 ] .
e. k. akhmedov , hep - th/0107223 . s. l. dubovsky and v. a. rubakov , hep - th/0105243 .
k. agashe and g. wu , phys .
b * 498 * ( 2001 ) 230 [ hep - ph/0010117 ] .
e.ya.nugaev , master thesis from the moscow institute of physics and technology , 2001 ; m.v.libanov and e.ya.nugaev , to appear .
e. witten , `` fermion quantum numbers in kaluza - klein theory , '' print-83 - 1056 ( princeton ) . in : _
appelquist , t. ( ed . )
modern kaluza - klein theories , 438 - 511 . _
a. nakamura , s. hirenzaki and k. shiraishi , nucl .
b * 339 * ( 1990 ) 533 ; + a. nakamura and k. shiraishi , mod .
a * 5 * ( 1990 ) 1109 .
n. cosme , j. m. frere , y. gouverneur , f. s. ling , d. monderen and v. van elewyck , phys .
d * 63 * ( 2001 ) 113018 [ hep - ph/0010192 ] .
k. johnson , acta phys .
b * 6 * ( 1975 ) 865 .
t. gherghetta and m. shaposhnikov , phys .
* 85 * ( 2000 ) 240 [ hep - th/0004014 ] ; + m. giovannini , h. meyer and m. shaposhnikov , hep - th/0104118 . | in a class of multidimensional models , topology of the thick brane provides three chiral fermionic families with hierarchical masses and mixings in the effective four - dimensional theory , while the full model contains a single vector - like generation .
we discuss how to incorporate three non - degenerate neutrino masses in these models with the help of only one singlet bulk fermion .
-27pt 8.5 in ( |
we first calculate the electronic spin driven by the effective su(2 ) yang - mills field due to the spin - orbit interaction . to confirm rigorously the su(2 ) gauge covariance
, we consider up to the third - order contribution of the non - abelian spin - orbit gauge potential .
therefore , we will obtain the gauge invariant result after the strict calculation . the diagrammatic representation of the spin density induced by the first order in @xmath7 is shown in fig .
1(a ) , and this contribution is written down @xmath104,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath105 is the system size , @xmath106 denotes the fermi distribution function , @xmath107 ( @xmath108 ) is the impurity - averaged retarded ( advanced ) green s function of free electrons defined as ( @xmath109 ) @xmath110 and @xmath111 represents contribution of the diffusion ladder @xmath112 considering the slowly varying spin - orbit coupling , @xmath113 and @xmath114 , we carry out the gradient expansion and the leading contribution reads @xmath115 \pi_{\omega}({{\bm q}},{\omega } ) \notag \\ & -{{\mathcal a}_t}^a({{\bm q}},{\omega } ) { g^{\rm r}}_{{{\bm k}},{\omega } } { g^{\rm a}}_{{{\bm k}},{\omega } } \bigg [ \frac{i}{\tau } + { \omega}\pi_{\omega}({{\bm q}},{\omega } ) \bigg ] \bigg\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] after integrating the green s function with respect to @xmath38 and @xmath39 , we finally obtain @xmath116 \notag \\ & = \frac{{\sigma_{\rm c}}}{l^d } \int{d^d r ' } \int{d t ' } \sum_{{\bm q}}\sum_{\omega}\frac{e^{i { { \bm q}}\cdot ( { { \bm r}}-{{\bm r } } ' ) -i { \omega}(t - t')}}{d { { \bm q}}^2 -i { \omega } } { { \bm \nabla}}_{{{\bm r } } ' } \cdot \big [ { \partial}_{t ' } { { \bm{\mathcal a}}}^a({{\bm r}}',t ' ) + { { \bm \nabla}}_{{{\bm r } } ' } { { \mathcal a}_t}({{\bm r}}',t ' ) \big ] \notag \\ & \equiv { \sigma_{\rm c}}{{\bm \nabla } \cdot}\langle{{\partial_t}{{\bm{\mathcal a}}}^a + { { \bm \nabla}}{{\mathcal a}_t}^a}\rangle.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the spin current is similarly calculated , @xmath117 { { \rm im}}\big [ k_j ' k_l ' { g^{\rm r}}_{{{\bm k}}',{\omega } } ( { g^{\rm a}}_{{{\bm k}}',{\omega}})^2 \big ] \pi_{\omega}({{\bm q}},{\omega } ) \notag \\ & -i 2 \hbar q_j { \omega}{{\mathcal a}_t}^a({{\bm q}},{\omega } ) { { \rm im}}\big [ k_i k_j { g^{\rm r}}_{{{\bm k}},{\omega } } ( { g^{\rm a}}_{{{\bm k}},{\omega}})^2 \big ] \pi_{\omega}({{\bm q}},{\omega } ) \bigg\},\end{aligned}\ ] ] and results in @xmath118 here we consider the higher - order contribution for the su(2 ) gauge covariance .
we show the feynman diagrams of the second- and third - order contributions in fig .
the same manner to the first - order case is applicable to this higher - order case , and each spin polarization is obtained as @xmath119 -{{\mathcal a}_t}^b s^{(1 ) c } + { { \bm{\mathcal a}}}^b \cdot { { \bm j}}^{(1 ) c } } \big\rangle,\ ] ] and @xmath120 + { { \mathcal a}_t}^b s^{(2 ) c } -{{\bm{\mathcal a}}}^b \cdot { { \bm j}}^{(2 ) c } } \bigg\rangle,\ ] ] respectively .
correspondingly the spin current is also calculated , @xmath121 -d { { \bm \nabla}}s^{(2 ) a } , \\ { { \bm j}}^{(3 ) a } & = \frac{2 e}{\hbar } \epsilon^{abc } \bigg [ \frac{e { \chi_{\rm l}}}{\hbar } \epsilon^{cde } { { \bm{\mathcal a}}}^b \times ( { { \bm{\mathcal a}}}^d \times { { \bm{\mathcal a}}}^e ) + { { \bm{\mathcal a}}}^b s^{(2 ) c } \bigg ] -d { { \bm \nabla}}s^{(3 ) a}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] from all the results , the spin and its current densities are represented in a su(2 ) gauge invariant form @xmath122 } \bigg\rangle \notag \\ & -\frac{2 e}{\hbar } \epsilon^{abc } \big\langle{{{\mathcal a}_t}^b ( s^{(1 ) c } + s^{(2 ) c } ) -{{\bm{\mathcal a}}}^b \cdot ( { { \bm j}}^{(1 ) c } + { { \bm j}}^{(2 ) c})}\big\rangle,\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath123 -d { { \bm \nabla}}s^a,\end{aligned}\ ] ] respectively .
this results are rewritten by the effective yang - mills field , @xmath49 and @xmath55 , @xmath124 we here introduce the covariant derivative as @xmath125 where @xmath126 is an arbitrary function in spin space .
the spin current is simplified using this covariant derivative , @xmath127 and the spin polarization is given by the covariant conservation law of spin , @xmath128
next , we calculate the spin arising from a combination between the effective su(2 ) yang - mills field and the usual u(1 ) maxwell electromagnetic field . the diagrams of this contribution is shown in fig .
although the calculation becomes more and more complicated , spin and spin current densities are straightforwardly derived , @xmath129 \notag \\ & + ( { { \bm \nabla } \times}{{\bm{\mathcal a}}}^a ) \times \big [ { \partial_t}{{\bm a}^{\rm
em}}+{{\bm \nabla}}{\phi}+d { { \bm \nabla}}\big\langle{{{\bm \nabla } \cdot}({\partial_t}{{\bm a}^{\rm em}}+{{\bm \nabla}}{\phi})}\big\rangle \big ] \notag \\ & -({\partial_t}{{\bm a}^{\rm em}}+{{\bm \nabla}}{\phi } ) \big\langle{{{\bm \nabla } \cdot}({\partial_t}{{\bm{\mathcal a}}}^a + { { \bm \nabla}}{{\mathcal a}_t}^a)}\big\rangle -({\partial_t}{{\bm{\mathcal a}}}^a + { { \bm \nabla}}{{\mathcal a}_t}^a ) \big\langle{{{\bm \nabla } \cdot}({\partial_t}{{\bm a}^{\rm em}}+{{\bm \nabla}}{\phi})}\big\rangle \notag \\ & + \frac{1}{d } { \phi}{{\mathcal a}_t}^a + { { \bm \nabla}}\big [ { \phi}\big\langle{{{\bm \nabla } \cdot}({\partial_t}{{\bm{\mathcal a}}}^a + { { \bm \nabla}}{{\mathcal a}_t}^a)}\big\rangle \big ] + { { \bm \nabla}}\big [ { { \mathcal a}_t}^a \big\langle{{{\bm \nabla } \cdot}({\partial_t}{{\bm a}^{\rm em}}+{{\bm \nabla}}{\phi})}\big\rangle \big ] \bigg\rangle , \\ { { \bm j}}^a = & -\frac{e \tau { \sigma_{\rm c}}}{m } \bigg\ { ( { { \bm \nabla } \times}{{\bm a}^{\rm em } } ) \times \big [ { \partial_t}{{\bm{\mathcal a}}}^a + { { \bm \nabla}}{{\mathcal a}_t}^a + d { { \bm \nabla}}\big\langle{{{\bm \nabla } \cdot}({\partial_t}{{\bm{\mathcal a}}}^a + { { \bm \nabla}}{{\mathcal a}_t}^a)}\big\rangle \big ] \notag \\ & + ( { { \bm \nabla } \times}{{\bm{\mathcal a}}}^a ) \times \big [ { \partial_t}{{\bm a}^{\rm em}}+{{\bm \nabla}}{\phi}+d { { \bm \nabla}}\big\langle{{{\bm \nabla } \cdot}({\partial_t}{{\bm a}^{\rm em}}+{{\bm \nabla}}{\phi})}\big\rangle \big ] \notag \\ & -({\partial_t}{{\bm a}^{\rm em}}+{{\bm \nabla}}{\phi } ) \big\langle{{{\bm \nabla } \cdot}({\partial_t}{{\bm{\mathcal a}}}^a + { { \bm \nabla}}{{\mathcal a}_t}^a)}\big\rangle -({\partial_t}{{\bm{\mathcal a}}}^a + { { \bm \nabla}}{{\mathcal a}_t}^a ) \big\langle{{{\bm \nabla } \cdot}({\partial_t}{{\bm a}^{\rm em}}+{{\bm \nabla}}{\phi})}\big\rangle \notag \\ & + \frac{1}{d } { \phi}{{\mathcal a}_t}^a + { { \bm \nabla}}\big [ { \phi}\big\langle{{{\bm \nabla } \cdot}({\partial_t}{{\bm{\mathcal a}}}^a + { { \bm \nabla}}{{\mathcal a}_t}^a)}\big\rangle \big ] + { { \bm \nabla}}\big [ { { \mathcal a}_t}^a \big\langle{{{\bm \nabla } \cdot}({\partial_t}{{\bm a}^{\rm em}}+{{\bm \nabla}}{\phi})}\big\rangle \big ] \bigg\ } -d { { \bm \nabla}}s^a.\end{aligned}\ ] ] this result expressed by the su(2 ) and u(1 ) gauge potentials has a lot of contribution and it is obscure to explain phenomena . to replace each gauge potential with the effective yang - mills field and the electromagnetic field , the equation is simplified as @xmath130 -d { { \bm \nabla}}s^a.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in this calculation , we considered the linear response of the non - abelian spin - orbit gauge potential
. the effective yang - mills field does not contain non - commutative parts proportional to @xmath131 and @xmath88 , and therefore the field turns to @xmath132 and @xmath133 .
however , the non - commutative contribution should exist at the viewpoint of the su(2 ) gauge covariance . since the result depends on the first - order spin - orbit coupling , spin polarization and spin current given by eqs .
( s.26 ) and ( s.27 ) are exactly conserved , @xmath134 considering the non - commutative parts in the yang - mills field , the derivative of this identity is surely replaced by the covariant derivative . | by associating a spin - orbit interaction with a non - abelian gauge potential , we theoretically present a spin polarization in a quite general form using an effective yang - mills field and a usual electromagnetic field . in this gauge invariant result ,
we focus on a purely electrically - induced spin contribution .
we find that both the inverse spin galvanic effect and the spin hall effect arise from the same origin , i.e. , the su(2)@xmath0u(1 ) hall effect .
we also discover that a large effective magnetic field of the order of @xmath1 t is induced in the rashba system .
generation of spin by applying an electric current in the presence of spin - orbit interaction has been investigated with much theoretical and experimental attention in spintronics @xcite .
one of the most successful phenomena of electronic spin - and - charge coupled transport is the spin hall effect @xcite . in a system with spin - orbit interaction
, a spin current appears in the transverse direction to an applied electric current . as a result
, electronic spin accumulates at the edges of the sample . as a similar effect , in the inverse of the spin galvanic effect @xcite a spin polarization
is also induced by applying an electric current .
these two phenomena are different in a direction of an emergent spin polarization . in a case of a two - dimensional electron system without inversion symmetry ,
the induced spin polarization is out - of - plane in the spin hall effect , while the in - plane spin arises in the inverse spin galvanic effect .
although the electronic spin is the well - defined quantity , the theoretical definition of spin current is not uniquely given under the spin - orbit interaction .
in the presence of spin - orbit interaction , electronic spin dynamics always accompanies the relaxation compared with the equation of motion for electric charge .
to resolve this ambiguity in the definition , the non - abelian gauge theory is one of the possible solutions . to connect
the spin - orbit coupling with the non - abelian gauge theory in condensed matters has been the well - known idea for many years @xcite , and a proper definition of spin current is given on the basis of the su(2 ) gauge invariance by treating the spin - orbit interaction as the non - abelian vector potential @xcite . in this context , despite the conservation law for spin is still broken , the electronic spin is covariantly conserved , @xmath2 where @xmath3 is the electronic spin , @xmath4 is the spin current flowing in the @xmath5-direction and spin - polarized in the @xmath6-direction , and @xmath7 represents the non - abelian spin - orbit gauge potential . in recent years , several spin - dependent phenomena based on this non - abelian gauge theory have been actively reported @xcite . following the non - abelian gauge theory ,
time and space derivatives of the spin - orbit coupling are corresponding to effective yang - mills electric and magnetic fields , respectively , which drive spin current and spin polarization . in experiment ,
a spatial and temporal variation of the spin - orbit coupling is feasible . for example , since the rashba effect emerges when the gate voltage breaks the structural inversion symmetry in two - dimensional semiconductor heterostructures @xcite , the alternating gate voltage could change the rashba coupling , and in the specific sample configuration the spatially - varying rashba coupling is realized @xcite .
this space - time dependent spin - orbit coupling is expected to open up the possibilities of electrical spin manipulation . in this paper , we derive analytically a general expression of spin polarization in terms of an effective non - abelian su(2 ) yang - mills field corresponding to the spin - orbit interaction and zeeman effect , and the usual u(1 ) maxwell electromagnetic field .
in particular , we focus on the generation of spins by electric field alone without any magnetic contributions . a related work has been done by gorini _
et al . _ who demonstrated theoretically a su(2)@xmath0u(1 ) covariant boltzmann equation in a space - time dependent two - dimensional rashba system , and derived explicitly electronic spin and charge transport @xcite .
the focus of their work , however , is the spin and charge currents in contrast to the spin polarization in the present paper .
we consider a general disordered electron system coupled to an external electromagnetic field and a spin - orbit interaction in condensed matters whose hamiltonian is represented by @xmath8 \psi({{\bm r}},t ) \big|^2 \notag \\ & -e \int{d^d r } \psi^\dagger({{\bm r}},t ) \big [ { \phi}({{\bm r}},t ) + { { \mathcal a}_t}^a({{\bm r}},t ) { \hat{\sigma}}^a \big ] \psi({{\bm r}},t ) \notag \\ & -{\varepsilon_{\rm f}}\int{d^d r } \psi^\dagger({{\bm r}},t ) \psi({{\bm r}},t ) + h_{\rm
i } , \label{eq : hamiltonian}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath9 is the annihilation operator of conduction electron , @xmath10 denotes the number of dimensions , @xmath11 and @xmath12 are mass and charge of electron , respectively , @xmath13 is the planck constant , @xmath14 is the fermi energy , @xmath15 is the vector of the pauli matrices ( @xmath16 and the caret means a matrix ) , and @xmath17 denotes the spin - independent random impurity scattering which gives rise to the relaxation time of electron , @xmath18 . here , the external electric and magnetic fields are defined using the potential @xmath19 and @xmath20 as @xmath21 and @xmath22 , respectively .
the non - abelian spin - orbit gauge potential @xmath23 ( @xmath24 ) is the first - order relativistic correction of electromagnetic field derived from the dirac equation , and its time and space components are consistent with the zeeman splitting and the spin - orbit coupling , respectively , @xmath25 where @xmath26 is the speed of light and @xmath27 is the antisymmetric tensor . according to the non - abelian gauge theory , the effective yang - mills electric field is defined as @xmath28 , and its magnetic counterpart is @xmath29 .
, the wavy line describes the interaction with general u(1 ) electromagnetic potential , @xmath30 .
the double dotted line is the diffusion ladder due to the impurity scattering described by the single dotted line . ] from the covariant spin conservation law [ eq .
] , we can introduce a covariantly conserved spin current , @xmath31 where @xmath32 denotes trace over spin indices and @xmath33 is the quantum expectation value . using the keldysh green s function @xcite , we carry out the analytic calculation of the spin and its current densities induced by the effective yang - mills field and electromagnetic field .
the electronic spin density is generally defined as @xmath34 $ ] , where @xmath35 is the lesser component of the keldysh green s function . for calculation
, we show feynman diagrams of the spin density in fig .
[ fig : spin ] .
we consider slowly - varying electric and magnetic fields , subject to @xmath36 and @xmath37 ( @xmath38 and @xmath39 are wavenumber and frequency of electromagnetic field , and @xmath40 denotes a mean free path of electrons ) , and we do the gradient expansion .
the calculation on the basis of the quantum many - body theory ( see supplemental material in detail ) yields the following result up to the second order in @xmath30 and @xmath7 ( including the third - order terms which guarantees the gauge covariance ) , @xmath41 this spin polarization is clearly formed in terms of the effective su(2 ) yang - mills field due to spin - orbit coupling and the u(1 ) maxwell electromagnetic field .
this simple equation is one of the main conclusions in the present paper . in eq .
, the angle bracket denotes the average of a diffusive electron motion satisfying the relation @xmath42 ( @xmath43 is the arbitrary function with respect to space and time ) , @xmath44 is the conductivity , @xmath45 is the density of states per volume involving spin degree of freedom , @xmath46 is the diffusion constant , @xmath47 is the landau diamagnetic susceptibility , and @xmath48 is the bohr magneton . the spin polarization and the spin current driven by the yang - mills electric field @xmath49 are defined as @xmath50 and @xmath51 , respectively , and as their u(1 ) counterparts the electric charge and electric current are given by @xmath52 and @xmath53 . in a similar manner , the spin current is also obtained , @xmath54 this result of spin current is consistent with the previous theoretical works @xcite .
the spin polarization and the spin current given by eqs . and , of course ,
satisfy the spin continuity equation [ eq . ] .
we note that the electronic spin is exactly conserved at the linear - order su(2 ) gauge potential . in other words
, spin is conserved in a weak spin - orbit coupling system .
equation is a really compact equation of spin polarization ; however , the effective yang - mills field , @xmath49 and @xmath55 , is inappropriate to explain the real spin - related phenomena .
here we replace the non - abelian spin - orbit gauge potential by the real electromagnetic field using eq . , and therefore the spin polarization in eq .
is rewritten as @xmath56 \notag \\ & + \frac{{\mu_{\rm b}}\tau}{2 m c^2 } \bigg\ { { \sigma_{\rm c}}\big\langle{({{\bm \nabla } \times}{{\bm b}}-{{\bm b}}\times { { \bm \nabla } } ) \times { \partial_t}{{\bm e}}}\big\rangle -\nabla_i \langle{\nabla_i { { \bm e}}\times { { \bm i}}}\rangle \notag \\ & -{\partial_t}\big\langle{\big ( { { \bm \nabla } \times}{{\bm e}}-{{\bm e}}\times { { \bm \nabla}}\big ) \rho}\big\rangle -\nabla_i \big\langle{\big ( { { \bm \nabla } \times}{{\bm e}}-{{\bm e}}\times { { \bm \nabla}}\big ) i_i}\big\rangle \notag \\ & + \frac{2 c^2}{d } \nabla_i \langle{i_i { { \bm b}}}\rangle -2 e^2 \nu c^2 \nabla_i \big [ \big\langle{\big ( { { \bm e}}+d { { \bm \nabla } \times}{{\bm b}}\big)_i \langle{{\partial_t}{\tilde{\bm b}}}\rangle}\big\rangle \notag \\ & + \nabla_i \big\langle{{\phi}\langle{{\partial_t}{\tilde{\bm b}}}\rangle}\big\rangle \big ] \bigg\ } , \label{eq : spin_elemag}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath57 is the magnetic field including the spin - orbit correction . this is a general form of spin polarization induced by electric and magnetic fields in the presence of spin - orbit interaction .
the first term is due to the zeeman field .
the next five terms represent the generalized spin pumping effect . in the usual spin pumping effect @xcite ,
dynamic magnetization or magnetic field induces a flow of spin angular momentum and it is a purely magnetic effect .
we here revealed that the electrical counterpart of the spin pumping effect also occurs thanks to the spin - orbit coupling which converts orbital energy into spin .
the origin of the spin pumping effect is the spin torque .
the usual spin pumping effect comes from a precession of electronic spin around a magnetic field , @xmath58 .
in contrast , the origin of the electrical spin pumping effect is a torque owing to the spin - orbit coupling proportional to @xmath59 . since electrical control of spin is quite important for developing spintronics , we focus on the purely electrical manipulation of electronic spin .
we pick out the electrically induced spin polarization in eq . and
it reads @xmath60 here we ignored the rotation of electric field because the alternating magnetic field must be necessarily applied to generate a rotational electric field based on the faraday s law .
equation expresses a generation of spin by space - time dependent electric field and this is the second main result in this paper .
the first term represents the electrical spin pumping effect and the other contributions originate from the lorentz force of the effective yang - mills electric and magnetic fields , @xmath61 . assuming a case of uniform or stationary electric field , eq .
is useful to demonstrate various spintronic phenomena shown in the following .
let us first consider the spatially uniform case .
in this situation , the induced spin is due to the electrical spin pumping effect shown in the first term of eq . .
since this is due to the second order of spin - orbit coupling , it is usually very weak and hard to detect this phenomenon . as a material effect ,
the rashba spin - orbit interaction is a candidate for realizing experimental observation of the electrical spin pumping effect because the really huge rashba coupling emerges at a boundary or surface of metals @xcite and bulk rashba semiconductors @xcite .
the rashba effect is given by ( @xmath62 is the rashba coupling ) @xmath63 if we consider two kinds of rashba effect : the bulk rashba effect along the @xmath64-axis , @xmath65 , and the time - evolving rashba effect by the gate voltage in the @xmath66-direction , @xmath67 , the induced spin polarization is lying in the @xmath68-direction , @xmath69 we set a weak rashba coupling in a metallic sample , where @xmath70 , @xmath71 ( @xmath72ev and @xmath73@xmath74 being the fermi wavenumber ) , and @xmath75
. then the emergent spin polarization is roughly estimated at @xmath76 t as an effective magnetic field , where @xmath77 is the magnetic permeability in vacuum and @xmath78 is the gyromagnetic ratio .
this effective magnetic field is quite large enough to control magnetization . as a related study
, it was theoretically proposed that a spin is driven by applying two orthogonal gate electric fields on the different sections of a one - dimensional wire @xcite .
next , we investigates the case of steady state in eq . .
here we consider two - dimensional rashba and dresselhaus systems given by @xmath79 ( @xmath80 ) and @xmath81 where @xmath82 represents the dresselhaus coupling @xcite . to assume the injection of electric current along the @xmath66-direction in the present system , the in - plane spin polarization emerges @xmath83 i({{\bm q } } ' ) , \\
s^y({{\bm q}}+{{\bm q } } ' ) & = \frac{m}{\hbar { \varepsilon_{\rm f } } } \frac{q_x + q_x'}{|{{\bm q}}+{{\bm q}}'|^2 } \big [ q_x \beta({{\bm q } } ) -q_y \alpha({{\bm q } } ) \big ] i({{\bm q } } ' ) .
\end{split}\ ] ] the effect is very sensitive to the spatial dependence of the rashba and dresselhaus spin - orbit couplings and the external electric current .
the result becomes changed by whether we take first the limit to the constant spin - orbit coupling , @xmath84 , or the uniform electric current , @xmath85 .
( i ) when we inject the uniform electric current in the spatially - varying rashba and dresselhaus systems , the spin polarization turns to ( @xmath86 ) @xmath87 this effect is well - known as the inverse of the spin galvanic effect @xcite . in the previous theoretical prediction of the inverse spin
galvanic effect in the rashba system @xcite , the constant rashba coupling was treated non - perturbatively , whereas our calculation is carried out by the perturbation expansion and we take account of the spatial dependence of the rashba coupling
. nevertheless these quite distinct calculations are exactly consistent in a condition of the uniform electric current .
( ii ) when the limit to the constant spin - orbit coupling is taken first , the spin is not induced identically . according to the previous work
, the inverse spin galvanic effect should occur even in the spatially uniform rashba system .
it indicates that the inverse spin galvanic effect in the uniform rashba system is a non - perturbative effect , and thus our result can not be applicable to the constant rashba case . in the above discussion
, we omitted the higher - order contribution of electromagnetic field such as the non - commutative contribution of the yang - mills magnetic field , @xmath88 , in the su(2)@xmath0u(1 ) hall effect , @xmath89 .
in fact , this component is related to the spin hall effect @xcite , @xmath90 interestingly the origin of the spin hall effect is exactly same as the inverse spin galvanic effect , and they are connected with the su(2)@xmath0u(1 ) hall effect , @xmath91 .
these effects are classified by whether the non - commutative contribution of the yang - mills magnetic field , @xmath88 , or the other , @xmath92 . in conclusion
, we have analytically derived the general expression of spin polarization arising from electric and magnetic fields in the presence of spin - orbit interaction . as a result
, we obtained the purely electrical spin manipulation , and we have shown that this formula connects different spintronic phenomena which have ever been independently discussed : the inverse spin galvanic effect and the spin hall effect .
we found also that two different time - dependent rashba fields yield a large effective magnetic field .
to handle freely the rashba effect would be a key to the future spintronics .
this work was supported by grant - in - aid for scientific research ( s ) ( grant no .
24224009 ) from the ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology of japan ; strategic international cooperative program ( joint research type ) from japan science and technology agency ; the funding program for world - leading innovative rd on science and technology ( first program ) .
a.t .
is financially supported by the japan society for the promotion of science for young scientists .
99 s.a .
wolf , d.d .
awschalom , r.a .
buhrman , j.m .
daughton , s. von molnr , m.l .
roukes , a.y .
chtchelkanova , and d.m .
treger , science * 294 * , 1488 ( 2001 ) .
i. zuti , j. fabian , and s. das sarma , rev .
mod .
phys . * 76 * , 323 ( 2004 ) .
j.e .
hirsch , phys .
rev .
lett . * 83 * , 1834 ( 1999 ) .
s. murakami , n. nagaosa , and s .- c .
zhang , science * 301 * , 1348 ( 2003 ) .
j. sinova , d. culcer , q. niu , n.a .
sinitsyn .
t. jungwirth , and a.h .
macdonald , pys .
rev .
lett . * 92 * , 126603 ( 2004 ) .
n.a .
sinitsyn , e.m .
hankiewicz , w. teizer , and j. sinova , phys .
rev .
b * 70 * , 081312(r ) ( 2004 ) .
y.k .
kato , r.c .
myers , a.c .
gossard , and d.d .
awschalom , science * 306 * , 1910 ( 2004 ) v.m .
edelstein , solid state commun . * 73 * , 233 ( 1990 ) .
s.d .
ganichev , e.l .
ivchenko , v.v .
belkov , s.a .
tarasenko , m. sollinger , d. weiss , w. wegscheider , and w. prettl , nature * 417 * , 153 ( 2002 ) .
s.d .
ganichev , v.v .
belkov , l.e .
golub , e.l .
ivchenko , p. schneider , s. giglberger , j. eroms , j. de boeck , g. borghs , w. wegscheider , d. weiss , and w. prettl , phys .
rev .
lett . * 92 * , 256601 ( 2004 ) .
s.d .
ganichev , s.n .
danilov , p. schneider , v.v .
belkov , l.e .
golub , w. wegscheider , d. weiss , and w. prettl , j. magn .
magn . mater . * 300 * , 127 ( 2006 ) .
e.i .
rashba , sov .
phys . solid state * 2 * , 1109 ( 1960 ) .
j. nitta , t. akazaki , h. takayanagi , t. enoki , phys .
rev .
lett . * 78 * , 1335 ( 1997 ) .
j. frhlich and u.m .
studer , rev .
mod .
phys . * 65 * , 733 ( 1993 ) .
b.w.a .
leurs , z. nazario , d.i .
santiago , and j. zaanen , ann .
phys . * 323 * , 907 ( 2008 ) .
i.v .
tokatly , phys rev . lett .
* 101 * , 106601 ( 2008 ) .
m. duckheim , d.l .
maslov , and d. loss , phys .
rev .
b * 80 * , 235327 ( 2009 ) . b.a .
bernevig , j. orenstein , and s .- c .
zhang , phys .
rev .
lett .
* 97 * , 236601 ( 2006 ) .
n. hatano , r. shirasaki , and h. nakamura , phys .
rev .
a * 75 * , 032107 ( 2007 ) . c. gorini , p. schwab , r. raimondi , and a.l .
shelankov , phys .
rev .
b * 82 * , 195316 ( 2010 ) . n. sugimoto and n. nagaosa , science * 336 * , 1413 ( 2013 ) .
m. kohda , s. nakamura , y. nishihara , k. kobayashi , t. ono , j .-
i .
ohe , y. tokura , t. mineno , and j. nitta , nat . commun . * 3 * , 1082 ( 2012 ) .
j. rammer and h. smith , rev .
mod .
phys . * 58 * , 323 ( 1986 ) h. haug and a .-
p .
jauho , _ quantum kinetics in transport and optics os semiconductors _ ( springer , new york , 2007 ) . r.h .
silsbee , a. janossy , and p. monod , phys .
rev .
b * 19 * , 4382 ( 1979 ) .
y. tserkovnyak , a. brataas , and g.e.w .
bauer , phys .
rev .
lett . * 88 * , 117601 ( 2002 ) .
s. mizukami , y. ando , and t. miyazaki , phys .
rev .
b * 66 * , 104413 ( 2002 ) .
s. lashell , b.a .
mcdougall , and e. jensen , phys .
rev .
lett . * 77 * , 3419 ( 1996 ) .
c.r .
ast , j. henk , a. ernst , l. moreschini , m.c .
falub , d. pacil , p. bruno , k. kern , and m. grioni , phys .
rev .
lett . * 98 * , 186807 ( 2007 ) .
t. nakagawa , o. ohgami , y. saito , h. okuyama , m. nishijima , and t. aruga , phys .
rev .
b * 75 * , 155409 ( 2007 ) .
k. ishizaka , m.s .
bahramy , h. murakawa , m. sakano , t. shimojima , t. sonobe , k. koizumi , s. shin , h. miyahara , a. kimura , k. miyamoto , t. okuda , h. namatame , m. taniguchi , r. arita , n. nagaosa , k. kobayashi , y. murakami , r. kumai , y. kaneko , y. onose , and y. tokura , nat . mater . * 10 * , 521 ( 2011 ) .
m.s .
bahramy , r. arita , and n. nagaosa , phys .
rev .
b * 84 * , 041202(r ) ( 2011 ) .
y. avishai , d. cohen , and n. nagaosa , phys .
rev .
lett . * 104 * , 196601 ( 2010 ) .
g. dresselhaus , phys . rev .
* 100 * , 580 ( 1955 ) . * supplemental material for `` theory of electrical spin manipulation in spin - orbit coupling systems '' * + akihito takeuchi@xmath93 and naoto nagaosa@xmath94 + _ @xmath95department of applied physics , university of tokyo , hongo , tokyo 113 - 8656 , japan + @xmath96riken center for emergent matter science , wako , saitama 351 - 0198 , japan _
we will show the details of the analytic calculation of the spin polarization and spin current in the presence of non - abelian spin - orbit gauge potential and u(1 ) electromagnetic field .
we carry out the calculation using the keldysh green s function based on the quantum many - body theory , and in terms of the green s function the spin density and spin current are defined as @xmath97,\ ] ] and @xmath98 { \hat{g}}^<({{\bm r}},t ; { { \bm r}}',t ) \bigg\}_{{{\bm r}}'={{\bm r}}},\ ] ] respectively . in calculation , we consider a disordered regime due to the spin - independent impurity scattering , @xmath99 where @xmath100 is the potential of the impurity scattering . this effect is taken into account as a relaxation time , @xmath18 , in the green s function .
the random impurity averaging is given by ( @xmath101 is the impurity concentration and @xmath102 is strength of scattering ) @xmath103 thereby we need include the vertex correction shown in fig .
1(d ) for the ward - takahashi identity . |
in many applications , the input and output of the controller are quantized signals .
this is due to the physical properties of the actuators / sensors and the data - rate limitation of links connected to the controller .
quantized control for linear time - invariant systems actively studied from various point of view , as surveyed in @xcite .
moreover , in the context of systems with discrete jumps such as switched systems and piecewise affine ( pwa ) systems , control problems with limited information have recently received increasing attention . for sampled - data switched systems , a stability analysis under finite - level static quantization has been developed in @xcite , and an encoding and control strategy for stabilization has been proposed in the state feedback case @xcite , whose related works have been presented for the output feedback case @xcite and for the case with bounded disturbances @xcite . also , our previous work @xcite has studied the stabilization of continuous - time switched systems with quantized output feedback , based on the results in @xcite . however ,
relatively little work has been conducted on quantized control for pwa systems . in @xcite ,
a sufficient condition for input - to - state stability has been obtained for time - delay pwa systems with quantization signals , but logarithmic quantizers in @xcite have an infinite number of quantization levels . the main objective of this paper is to stabilize discrete - time pwa systems with quantized signals . in order to achieve the local asymptotic stabilization of discrete - time pwa plants with finite data rates , we extend the event - based encoding method in @xcite .
it is assumed that we are given feedback controllers that stabilize the closed - loop system in the sense that there exists a piecewise quadratic lyapunov function . in the input quantization case
, the controller receives the original state . on the other hand , in the state quantization case , the quantized state and the currently active mode of the plant are available to the controller .
the information on the active mode prevents a mode mismatch between the plant and the controller , and moreover , allows the controller side to recompute a better quantization value if the quantized state transmitted from the quantizer is near the boundaries of quantization regions .
this recomputation is motivated in section 7.2 in @xcite .
we also investigate the design of quantized feedback controllers . to this end , we consider the stabilization problem of discrete - time pwa systems with bounded disturbances ( under no quantization ) . the lypunov - based stability analysis and stabilization of discrete - time pwa systems has been studied in @xcite and @xcite in terms of linear matrix inequalities ( lmis ) and bilinear matrix inequalities ( bmis ) . in proofs that lyapunov functions decrease along the trajectories of pwa systems , the one - step reachable set
, that is , the set to which the state belong in one step , plays an important role . in stability analysis
, the one - step reachable set can be obtained by linear programming . by contrast , in the stabilization case , since the next - step state depends on the control input , it is generally difficult to obtain the one - step reachable set .
therefore many previous works for the design of stabilizing controllers assume that the one - step reachable set is the total state space .
however , if disturbances are bounded , then this assumption leads to conservative results and high computational loads as the number of the plant mode increases .
we aim to find the one - step reachable set for pwa systems with bounded disturbances . to this effect
, we derive a sufficient condition on feedback controllers for the state to belong to a given polyhedron in one step .
this condition can be used to add constraints on the state and the input as well .
furthermore , we obtain a set containing the one - step reachable set by using the information of the input matrix @xmath0 and the input bound @xmath1 .
this set is conservative because the affine feedback structure @xmath2 for mode @xmath3 is not considered , but it can be used when we design the polyhedra that are assumed to be given in the above sufficient condition . combining the proposed condition with results in @xcite for lyapunov functions to be positive and decrease along the trajectories , we can design stabilizing controllers for pwa systems with bounded disturbances .
this paper is organized as follows .
the next section shows a class of quantizer and a basic assumption on stability . in sections iii and iv , we present an encoding strategy to achieve local stability for pwa systems in the input quantization case and the state quantization case , respectively . in section
v , we study the one - step reachable set for the stabilization problem of pwa systems with bounded disturbances . finally , concluding remarks are given in section vi . due to space constraints , all proofs and a numerical example have been omitted and can be found in * ? ? ?
_ notation _ : for a set @xmath4 , we denote by @xmath5 the closure of @xmath6 . for sets
@xmath7 , let @xmath8 denote their minkowski sum .
let @xmath9 and @xmath10 denote the smallest and the largest eigenvalue of @xmath11 .
let @xmath12 denote the transpose of @xmath13 . for @xmath14
, we denote the @xmath15-th entry of @xmath16 by @xmath17 .
let @xmath18 be a vector all of whose entries are one . for vectors @xmath19 , the inequality @xmath20 means that @xmath21 for every @xmath22 .
on the other hand , for a square matrix @xmath23 , the notation @xmath24 ( @xmath25 ) means that @xmath26 is symmetric and semi - positive ( positive ) definite . the euclidean norm of @xmath14 is denoted by @xmath27 .
the euclidean induced norm of @xmath13 is defined by @xmath28 .
the @xmath29-norm of @xmath30^{\top}$ ] is denoted by @xmath31 , and the induced norm of @xmath13 corresponding to the @xmath29-norm is defined by @xmath32 . for @xmath33 , let @xmath34 and @xmath35 .
we consider the following class of discrete - time pwa systems : @xmath36 where @xmath37 is the state and @xmath38 is the control input .
the set @xmath39 is divided into finitely many disjoint polyhedra @xmath40 : @xmath41 .
we denote the index set @xmath42 by @xmath43 . given a feedback gain @xmath44 and an affine term @xmath45 for each mode @xmath46 , the control input is in the affine state feedback form : @xmath47 we assume that @xmath48 if @xmath49 .
we will study the design of @xmath50 and @xmath51 in section v , but for quantized control in sections iii and iv , @xmath50 and @xmath51 are assumed to be given . in this paper
, we use the class of quantizers proposed in @xcite .
let @xmath52 be a set composed of finitely many points in @xmath53 .
a quantizer @xmath54 is a piecewise constant function from @xmath55 to @xmath52 .
geometrically , this means that @xmath56 is divided into a finite number of quantization regions of the form @xmath57 @xmath58 . for the quantizer @xmath54
, we assume that there exist @xmath59 with @xmath60 such that @xmath61 : @xmath62 the quantized value @xmath63 is the data on @xmath64 transmitted to the controller at time @xmath65 . we adjust @xmath66 to obtain detailed information on @xmath64 near the origin .
define @xmath67 which is the one - step reachable set from @xmath68 for the pwa system and the state feedback law without quantization .
define also @xmath69 we assume that the following stability of the closed - loop system is guaranteed by a piecewise quadratic lyapunov function : [ ass : lyapunov_for_qs ] _ consider the pwa system with given affine feedback .
define a function @xmath70 by @xmath71 where @xmath72 and @xmath73 are symmetric matrices .
there exist @xmath74 and @xmath75 for @xmath76 , such that the lypunov function @xmath77 defined by @xmath78 @xmath79 satisfies @xmath80 for every @xmath81 , @xmath82 , and @xmath83 , where @xmath84 is defined by @xmath85 _ in section v , we will discuss how to obtain @xmath84 of in the design process of @xmath50 and @xmath51 .
in this section , we study stabilization with quantized input : @xmath86 the closed - loop system we consider is given by @xmath87 we place the following assumption on the state transition : [ ass : input_ver ] _ define @xmath88 .
for every @xmath81 , the one - step reachable set @xmath89 in satisfies @xmath90 .
_ the condition @xmath91 implies that @xmath92 is invariant for the system , and checking this condition is closely related to how to derive @xmath84 in . in section
v , we will derive sufficient conditions on @xmath50 and @xmath51 for @xmath93 to hold ; see remark [ rem : total_ss_cond ] .
first we fix the zoom parameter @xmath94 .
similarly to @xcite , we show that the lyapunov function decreases until the state gets to the corresponding level set .
[ thm : mktom ] _ consider the pwa system with given @xmath50 and @xmath51 .
let assumptions [ ass : lyapunov_for_qs ] and [ ass : input_ver ] hold .
fix @xmath95 , and define @xmath96 also , let @xmath97 for all @xmath81 , and set @xmath98 define @xmath99 and @xmath100 by @xmath101 if @xmath102 and @xmath103 satisfy @xmath104 then all solutions of that start in @xmath105 enter @xmath100 in a finite time @xmath106 satisfying @xmath107 furthermore , if @xmath108 holds , then the solution @xmath109 belongs to @xmath105 for all @xmath110 .
_ in order to utilize , first we show that if @xmath111 , then there exists @xmath112 such that @xmath113 .
suppose that @xmath111 .
define @xmath114 by @xmath115 .
then we have @xmath116 .
since @xmath117 , it follows that @xmath118 .
moreover , @xmath119 implies @xmath120 , and hence @xmath121 from and @xmath122 .
we therefore obtain @xmath123 therefore , from assumption [ ass : input_ver ] , there exists @xmath124 such that @xmath125 combining and , we have @xmath126
. thus @xmath82 by definition . in
what follows , for simplicity of notation , we omit the indices @xmath3 and @xmath127 of @xmath128 , @xmath129 , @xmath130 , @xmath131 , and @xmath132 .
define @xmath133 and @xmath134 .
since holds , we have @xmath135 & \qquad \quad+ 2|\bar a_i^{\top}q_j e_k| \cdot |x_k| + e_k^{\top}q_je_k + 2 h_{ij } ^{\top } e_k \\ & = -\varepsilon \gamma |x_k|^2 - ( 1\!-\ !
\varepsilon ) ( 1\!-\!\delta ) \gamma \left ( |x_k| \!-\ !
\frac{|\bar a_i^{\top}q_j e_k|}{(1\!-\!\varepsilon ) ( 1\!-\!\delta ) \gamma } \right)^2 \\[-2pt ] & \qquad \quad - ( 1\!-\ ! \varepsilon ) \delta \gamma |x_k|^2 + e_k^{\top}q_je_k + \frac{|\bar a_i^{\top}q_j e_k|^2 } { ( 1\!-\ !
\varepsilon ) ( 1\!-\ !
\delta ) \gamma } + 2h_{ij}^{\top}e_k \\ & \leq -\varepsilon \gamma |x_k|^2 - \upsilon , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath136 if @xmath119 , then @xmath137 hence , noticing @xmath138 , we have @xmath139 therefore @xmath140 for every @xmath81 , we obtain @xmath141 whenever @xmath142 .
note that the most right side of is independent of the plant mode @xmath3 . by , we have @xmath143 in conjunction with
, this shows that if the initial state @xmath144 belongs to @xmath99 , then @xmath145 holds for some integer @xmath106 satisfying .
let us next prove that @xmath146 is an invariant region for the system . from , @xmath147 until @xmath148 .
once @xmath149 , we have @xmath150 therefore if holds , then @xmath151 leads to @xmath152 .
the state trajectories again go to @xmath153 while belonging to @xmath99 since assumption [ ass : input_ver ] gives @xmath154 for all @xmath110 , we see that @xmath155 for all @xmath110 . as in @xcite
, we can achieve the state convergence to the origin by adjusting the zoom parameter @xmath156 : [ thm : input_convergence ] _ consider the pwa system with given @xmath50 and @xmath51 .
let assumptions [ ass : lyapunov_for_qs ] and [ ass : input_ver ] hold .
let the initial state @xmath157 and the initial zoom parameter @xmath158 .
assume that and hold , and define @xmath159 adjust @xmath156 by @xmath160 when @xmath109 gets to @xmath161 , and send to the plant the quantized input @xmath162 at time @xmath65 if @xmath117 .
this event - based update strategy of @xmath156 leads to @xmath163 . _
first we prove that as long as the quantizer does not saturate , the state trajectory belongs to @xmath39 and the holds for all @xmath110 .
define @xmath164 } : = \ { b_i d : |d|_{\infty } \leq \omega^p \delta \}$ ] . since @xmath164 } \subset \mathcal{b}_i$ ] , if assumption [ ass : input_ver ] holds , then @xmath165 } \subset { \bf x } $ ] @xmath166 for every @xmath167 .
hence @xmath154 for all @xmath110 unless the quantizer saturates
. moreover , if we define @xmath168}$ ] by the set consisting of all @xmath124 satisfying @xmath169 as in , then @xmath168 } \subset \mathcal{s}_i^{[0 ] } = \mathcal{s}_i$ ] . thus holds for every @xmath81 and @xmath170}$ ] , and hence we have for all @xmath110 unless the quantizer saturation occurs .
let an update occur at @xmath171 , i.e. , @xmath172 and @xmath173 .
then we have @xmath174 therefore @xmath175 defined by @xmath176 satisfies @xmath177 . since @xmath172 , it follows that @xmath178 .
hence theorem [ thm : mktom ] shows that for all @xmath110 , @xmath179 , which means @xmath180 and the quantizer does not saturate for every @xmath110 .
moreover , the update period does not exceed @xmath181 in .
since @xmath182 , it follows that @xmath183 as @xmath184 . thus @xmath185 as @xmath184 . for _ continuous - time _
systems , the level sets @xmath99 and @xmath100 are invariant regions of the state trajectories @xcite . however , for _ discrete - time _ systems , @xmath100 may not be invariant .
we therefore need the event - based adjustment of the zoom parameter as in ( * ? ? ?
* section iii ) and @xcite .
let us next study stabilization of pwa systems with quantized state feedback .
we assume that the controller receives the information on the quantized state and the active mode .
[ ass : con_qs_am ] under assumption [ ass : con_qs_am ] , the control @xmath186 is given by @xmath187 the closed - loop system we consider can be written in this way : @xmath188 we place an assumption similar to assumption [ ass : input_ver ] .
[ ass : state_ver ] _ define @xmath189 . for every @xmath81 ,
the one - step reachable set @xmath89 in satisfies @xmath90 .
_ see remark [ rem : total_ss_cond ] for the condition @xmath190 . as in the input quantization case ,
we first fix @xmath191 and obtain a result similar to theorem [ thm : mktom ] , based on the technique in @xcite .
[ thm : mtom ] _ consider the pwa system with given @xmath50 and @xmath51 .
let assumptions [ ass : lyapunov_for_qs ] and [ ass : state_ver ] hold .
fix @xmath95 .
define @xmath192 and @xmath193 as in and respectively , and define @xmath131 and @xmath132 by @xmath194 set @xmath195 , @xmath196 , @xmath102 , @xmath197 , and @xmath198 as in theorem [ thm : mktom ] , and set @xmath199 define @xmath200 and @xmath201 by @xmath202 if @xmath203 satisfies @xmath204 then all solutions of that start in @xmath205 enter @xmath201 in a finite time @xmath106 satisfying @xmath206 and @xmath207 can be observed from @xmath208 .
furthermore , if @xmath209 then the solution belongs to @xmath205 for all @xmath110 .
_ if we define @xmath210 , then the proof follows the same lines as that of theorem 3.7 until .
we see that the lyapunov function decreases if the initial state belongs to @xmath205 and if the state does not arrive at @xmath153 . we show that the quantized state @xmath211 gets to @xmath212 at @xmath213 as follows .
suppose , on the contrary , that @xmath214 for all @xmath215 .
if @xmath216 , we have @xmath217 from @xmath218 .
therefore we have @xmath219 for all @xmath220 .
however , if @xmath219 for all @xmath221 , then the lyapunov function decreases as , and hence @xmath222 .
this implies that @xmath223 , which leads to a contradiction . from @xmath217
, we observe that @xmath224 and hence that @xmath225 .
[ fig : state_trajectory ] illustrates the regions used in this proof .
the invariance of @xmath205 for the state trajectories can be proved as in theorem [ thm : input_convergence ] .
this completes the proof . in the input quantization case of theorem [ thm : input_convergence ]
, we use the _ original _ state for the adjustment of the zoom parameter @xmath156 .
by contrast , in the state quantization case , we can achieve the asymptotic stability by adjusting @xmath156 with the _ quantized _ state .
[ thm : state_convergence ] _ consider the pwa system with given @xmath50 and @xmath51 .
let assumptions [ ass : lyapunov_for_qs ] and [ ass : state_ver ] hold .
let the initial state @xmath226 and the initial zoom parameter @xmath158 .
assume that and hold , and define @xmath227 adjust @xmath156 by @xmath160 when @xmath228 gets to @xmath229 , where @xmath230 , and send to the controller the quantized state @xmath231 at time @xmath65 .
this event - based update strategy of @xmath156 leads to @xmath163 . _
if we observe @xmath232 at time @xmath65 , then @xmath233 , where @xmath234 .
hence we obtain @xmath235 after the update @xmath236 .
the other part of the proof follows in the same line as that of theorem [ thm : input_convergence ] , so we omit it .
another approach to stabilize the pwa system with the quantized state feedback is to combine the plant and the quantizer . in this case , we consider the following pwa system : @xmath237 the difficulty of this approach is that we need to stabilize pwa systems with output feedback @xmath238 .
output feedback stabilization of pwa systems has been studied in @xcite and the reference therein , but the output structure in these previous works is @xmath239 . in general , it is difficult to design stabilizing controllers for the system .
moreover , if we adjust the quantizer , then the system becomes time varying . to avoid technical issues , we do not proceed along this lines . as in (
* section 7.2 ) , a better quantization value can be computed in the controller side if the state is near switching boundaries . for the recompution of a new quantization value
, we make the following assumption : [ ass : qrp ] _ the controller has the information on the switching regions @xmath240 .
all quantization regions @xmath241 are polyhedra
. _ if the quantized state @xmath211 is in a quantization region that has no switching boundary , then the controller uses @xmath211 . on the other hand , in order to achieve better performance , if the corresponding quantization region contains a switching boundary , then the controller can generate a new quantized value from the information on the quantized state and the currently active mode as follows
. let the switching region corresponding to the active mode be @xmath68 and let the quantization region of the transmitted quantized state be @xmath241 .
then the state belongs to @xmath242 .
suppose that @xmath242 is bounded . otherwise , the controller does not recompute a new quantization value .
since both regions are polyhedra , @xmath242 is a polyhedron .
let us denote its closure by @xmath243 . since @xmath244
, the controller computes a new quantized state latexmath:[\[q_{\text{new } } : = { \mathop{\rm argmin}}_{\xi \in \mathbb{r}^{\sf n } } \max_{x \in \mathcal{a } } @xmath243 .
the next theorem shows that @xmath246 can be obtained by linear programming and that the quantization error by using @xmath246 as the new quantized state is always less than or equal to the quantization level @xmath247 in .
[ thm : new_quntize ] _ let the vertices of @xmath243 be @xmath248 . the new quantization value @xmath249 is computed by the following linear program : @xmath250 moreover , if @xmath251 , then @xmath249 satisfies @xmath252 _ it is well known that for every @xmath253 , @xmath254
; see also appendix .
hence the linear program gives @xmath246 .
since @xmath255 , it follows from that if @xmath256 , then @xmath257 where @xmath258 is the original quantization value of @xmath241 . * ( a ) * if the original quantization region @xmath241 is a polyhedron , then the zoomed - in quantization region @xmath259 is also a polyhedron .
we can therefore compute the new quantization value @xmath246 after adjusting the zoom parameter @xmath156 as well . *
( b ) * the use of @xmath246 does not affect the stability analysis in theorems [ thm : mtom ] and [ thm : state_convergence ] , because its quantization error does not exceed @xmath247 . to obtain @xmath246
, we need to solve the linear program .
if the computation is not finished by the time when the control input is generated , then the controller can use the original quantization value @xmath258 .
for quantized control , here we aim to find a feedback gain @xmath50 and an affine term @xmath51 satisfying and for every @xmath81 , @xmath82 , and @xmath83 . to this effect , we show how to obtain a set containing @xmath260 in with less conservatism .
let us consider discrete - time pwa systems with affine state feedback control under no quantization .
theorem 1 in @xcite shows that in order to stabilize the pwa system , it is enough to find a feedback gain @xmath50 and an affine term @xmath51 for every @xmath81 such that @xmath261 ( @xmath83 ) and the piecewise lyapunov function @xmath262 satisfies and @xmath263 for some @xmath264 .
define @xmath78 ( @xmath83 ) , with a function @xmath265 .
the sufficient condition of used for the stability analysis in @xcite is that @xmath266 for all @xmath83 and @xmath124 with @xmath267 , where @xmath89 is the one - step reachable set defined in .
however , it is generally difficult to obtain @xmath50 and @xmath51 satisfying this condition in a less conservative way .
this is because @xmath127 , namely , the polyhedron to which @xmath268 may belong is dependent of the unknown variables @xmath50 , @xmath51 . to circumvent this difficulty ,
it is assumed , e.g. , in @xcite that the state can reach every polyhedron in one step , but this assumption makes the controller synthesis conservative if disturbances are bounded .
in addition to that , checking the condition for every pair @xmath269 leads to computational complexity for pwa systems with large number of modes .
therefore the objective here is to obtain a set to which the state go in one step under bounded disturbance . consider a pwa system with bounded disturbances given by @xmath270 where the disturbance @xmath114 satisfies @xmath271 for all @xmath110 .
the next lemma gives a motivation of studying the set @xmath84 defined in in terms of practical input - state - stability in addition to quantized control in the previous sections .
a proof is provided for completeness .
_ let @xmath272 .
define @xmath273 and @xmath274 . for
every @xmath81 , assume that @xmath275 .
if the piecewise lyapunov function @xmath78 ( @xmath83 ) , with a function @xmath265 , satisfies for some @xmath276 and there exist @xmath277 and @xmath278 such that for every @xmath81 and @xmath82 and for every @xmath83 and @xmath279 , @xmath280 then we have @xmath281 where @xmath282 . _ since @xmath283 for all @xmath117 , it follows that if @xmath117 , then @xmath113 for some @xmath82 . therefore and
give @xmath284 and hence @xmath285 using again , we obtain from .
first we study the case when @xmath50 and @xmath51 are known .
the lemma below gives a condition equivalent to @xmath286 in the definition of @xmath84 .
[ lem : min_sum_trans ] _ define @xmath287 . for arbitrary sets
@xmath288 , we have @xmath289 _ it suffices to show that if there exists @xmath290 satisfying @xmath291 , then we have @xmath292 such that @xmath293 since @xmath294 , it follows that @xmath295 for some @xmath296 and for some @xmath279 , and also that @xmath297 .
moreover , since @xmath298 , we have @xmath299 the desired conclusion holds with @xmath300 .
we see from lemma [ lem : min_sum_trans ] that @xmath301 is equivalent to @xmath302 .
therefore @xmath84 in satisfies @xmath303 the following theorem gives a set containing @xmath84 , which can be obtained by linear programing : [ lem : set_containing_si ] _ using suitable @xmath304 and @xmath305 , we can write the closure of @xmath68 as @xmath306 define @xmath84 as in .
if we define @xmath307 by @xmath308 then @xmath309 . _ first of all , we see that there exists @xmath310 satisfying both @xmath311 and @xmath312 if and only if there exists @xmath83 such that @xmath313 , where @xmath314 and @xmath315 . by definition , @xmath316 is equivalent to @xmath317 for some @xmath318 and @xmath319 satisfying @xmath320 and @xmath321 . therefore @xmath316 is equivalent to @xmath322 for some @xmath319 .
thus we obtain the following fact : if @xmath323 , then @xmath324 noticing that @xmath124 satisfies if and only if @xmath325 , we have that @xmath309 .
the conservatism of theorem [ lem : set_containing_si ] is due to only @xmath326 .
if we allow more conservative results , then we can use the set @xmath327 below , which can be obtained with less computational cost by removing the disturbance term @xmath328 .
a similar idea is used for the analysis of reachability with bounded disturbance in @xcite .
[ cor : tilde_sei ] _ let @xmath329 be the sum of the absolute value of the elements in @xmath15-th row of @xmath330 and define @xmath331^{\top}$ ] , where @xmath332 is the number of rows of @xmath333 . if we define @xmath334 by @xmath335
then @xmath84 in satisfies @xmath336 .
_ it suffices to prove that @xmath337 indeed , if holds , then @xmath323 implies @xmath338 where @xmath339 and @xmath340 .
this leads to @xmath336 .
let us study the first element of @xmath341 .
let @xmath342 , @xmath343 , and @xmath344 be the @xmath345-th entry of @xmath346 , @xmath333 and the first entry of @xmath347 , respectively .
also let @xmath348 and @xmath349 be the @xmath15-th element of @xmath350 and @xmath328 , respectively .
if @xmath351 and @xmath279 , then the first element @xmath352 of @xmath341 satisfies @xmath353 since we have the same result for the other elements of @xmath341 , it follows that holds .
let us next investigate the case when @xmath50 and @xmath51 are unknown .
the set @xmath307 given in theorem [ lem : set_containing_si ] works for stability analysis in the presence of bounded disturbances , but @xmath307 is dependent on the feedback gain @xmath50 and the affine term @xmath51 .
hence we can not use it for their design . here
we obtain a set @xmath354 , which does not depend on @xmath50 , @xmath51 .
moreover , we derive a sufficient condition on @xmath50 , @xmath51 for the state to belong to a given polyhedron in one step .
let @xmath355 be the polyhedron defined by @xmath356 and we make an additional constraint that @xmath357 for all @xmath110 . similarly to @xcite , using the information on the input matrices @xmath0 and the input bound @xmath355 , we obtain a set independent of @xmath50 , @xmath51 to which the state belong in one step .
[ coro : si_sufficient_with_disturbance ] _ assume that for each @xmath81 , @xmath358 and @xmath45 satisfy @xmath359 and @xmath360 if @xmath83 and @xmath279 . let the closure of @xmath68 be given by . define @xmath361 then we have @xmath362 for all @xmath83 and @xmath279 , and hence @xmath84 in satisfies @xmath363 . _
define @xmath364 . to show
, it suffices to prove that for all @xmath83 and @xmath279 , there exists @xmath365 such that @xmath366 .
suppose , on the contrary , that there exist @xmath83 and @xmath279 such that @xmath367 for every @xmath365 .
since @xmath368 , it follows that @xmath369 for some @xmath124 . also , by definition @xmath370 since @xmath83 , @xmath371 , @xmath279 , and @xmath372 , it follows that @xmath365 .
hence we have @xmath372 for some @xmath365 .
thus we have a contradiction and holds for every @xmath83 and @xmath279 .
let us next prove @xmath363 .
let @xmath82 . by definition , there exists @xmath83 and @xmath279 such that @xmath373 . also , we see from that there exists @xmath374 such that @xmath375 . hence we have @xmath376 , which implies @xmath377 .
thus we have @xmath363 .
see remark [ rem : total_ss_cond ] for the assumption that @xmath378 and @xmath379 for all @xmath380 . *
( a ) * in theorem [ coro : si_sufficient_with_disturbance ] , we have used the counterpart of @xmath307 given in theorem [ lem : set_containing_si ] , but one can easily modify the theorem based on @xmath334 in corollary [ cor : tilde_sei ] . *
( b ) * if @xmath0 is full row rank , then for all @xmath381 , @xmath382 , and @xmath279 , there exists @xmath383 such that @xmath384 . in this case
, we have the trivial fact : @xmath385 .
theorem [ coro : si_sufficient_with_disturbance ] ignores the affine feedback structure @xmath386 ( @xmath83 ) , which makes this theorem conservative .
since the one - step reachable set depends on the unknown parameters @xmath50 and @xmath51 , we can not utilize the feedback structure unless we add some conditions on @xmath50 and @xmath51 . in the next theorem ,
we derive linear programming on @xmath50 and @xmath51 for a bounded @xmath68 , which is a sufficient condition for the one - step reachable set under bounded disturbances to be contained in a given polyhedron .
[ thm : add_cond_ki ] _ let a polyhedron @xmath387 , and let @xmath68 be a bounded polyhedron .
let @xmath388 and @xmath389 be the vertices of @xmath390 and @xmath391 , respectively .
a matrix @xmath358 and a vector @xmath45 satisfy @xmath392 for all @xmath83 and @xmath393 if linear programming @xmath394 is feasible for every @xmath395 and for every @xmath396 .
_ define @xmath364 . relying on the results ( * ? ? ? * chap .
6 ) ( see also @xcite ) , we have @xmath397 where @xmath398 means the convex hull of a set @xmath399 .
we therefore obtain @xmath400 for all @xmath381 and @xmath393 if and only if @xmath401 , or , holds for every @xmath395 and @xmath402 .
thus the desired conclusion is derived . *
( a ) * to use theorem [ thm : add_cond_ki ] , we must design a polyhedron @xmath403 in advance .
one design guideline is to take @xmath403 such that @xmath404 for some @xmath405 , where @xmath406 is defined in theorem [ coro : si_sufficient_with_disturbance ] . *
( b ) * as in theorem [ lem : set_containing_si ] , the conservatism in theorem [ thm : add_cond_ki ] arises only from @xmath407 . *
( c ) * theorem [ thm : add_cond_ki ] gives a trade - off on computational complexity : in order to reduce the number of pairs such that holds , we need to solve the linear programming problem . *
( d ) * when the state is quantized , then @xmath408 in , and hence @xmath409 depends on @xmath50 linearly .
in this case , however , theorem [ thm : add_cond_ki ] can be used for the controller design .
[ rem : total_ss_cond ] assumptions [ ass : input_ver ] , [ ass : state_ver ] and theorem [ coro : si_sufficient_with_disturbance ] require conditions on @xmath50 and @xmath51 that @xmath410 and @xmath360 for all @xmath83 and all @xmath279 . if @xmath411 and @xmath412 , then these conditions always hold . if @xmath413 but if @xmath68 is a bounded polyhedron , then theorem [ thm : add_cond_ki ] gives linear programming that is sufficient for @xmath410 to hold .
also , theorem [ thm : add_cond_ki ] with @xmath414 , @xmath415 , and @xmath416 can be applied to @xmath360 .
if @xmath410 and @xmath360 hold for bounded @xmath417 and @xmath355 , then we can easily set the quantization parameter @xmath203 in to avoid quantizer saturation .
similarly , we can use theorem [ thm : add_cond_ki ] for constraints on the state and the input . by theorems [ coro : si_sufficient_with_disturbance ] and [ thm :
add_cond_ki ] , we obtain linear programing on @xmath50 and @xmath51 for a set containing the one - step reachable set under bounded disturbances .
however , in lmi conditions of @xcite for and , @xmath50 is obtained via the variable transformation @xmath418 , where @xmath419 and @xmath420 are auxiliary variables . without variable transformation / elimination ,
we obtain only bmi conditions for to hold as in theorem 7.2.2 of @xcite .
the following theorem also gives bmi conditions on @xmath50 for and to hold , but we can apply the cone complementary linearization ( ccl ) algorithm @xcite to these bmi conditions : [ thm : pwa_lmi ] _ consider the pwa system with control affine term @xmath421 . let a matrix @xmath422 satisfy @xmath423 if @xmath416 and @xmath424 and if there exist @xmath425 , @xmath50 , and @xmath426 with all elements non - negative such that @xmath427 and @xmath428 hold for all @xmath76 and @xmath82 , then there exist @xmath429 such that @xmath430 ( @xmath83 ) satisfies and for every @xmath76 , @xmath82 , and @xmath83 . _ furthermore , consider the case @xmath431 and @xmath432 . for
given @xmath433 with @xmath434 , if there exist @xmath425 , @xmath50 , and @xmath426 with all elements non - negative such that @xmath435 and @xmath428 hold for all @xmath76 and @xmath82 , then there exist @xmath436 such that @xmath430 ( @xmath83 ) satisfies and for every @xmath76 , @xmath82 , and @xmath83 .
since the positive definiteness of @xmath437 implies , it is enough to show that and lead to and , respectively . for @xmath438 satisfying the second lmi in and
, we have @xmath439 .
furthermore , @xmath440 if and only if @xmath441 .
define @xmath442 .
applying the schur complement formula to the lmi condition in , we have @xmath443 since @xmath444 , there exists @xmath75 such that @xmath445 for every @xmath83 .
hence we obtain . as regards
, it follows from theorem 3.1 in @xcite that holds for some @xmath446 if @xmath447 pre- and post - multiplying @xmath448 and using the schur complement formula , we obtain the first lmi in .
since @xmath449 , the conditions in theorem [ thm : pwa_lmi ] are feasible if the problem of minimizing @xmath450 under / has a solution @xmath451 .
in addition to lmis and , we can consider linear programming for the constraint on the one - step reachable set .
the ccl algorithm solves this constrained minimization problem .
the ccl algorithm may not find the global optimal solution , but , in general , we can solve the minimization problem in a more computationally efficient way than the original non - convex feasibility problem @xcite .
consider a pwa system in with quantized state feedback , where @xmath452 the matrix @xmath304 and the vector @xmath305 in characterizing the region @xmath68 are given by @xmath453 let @xmath454 and let us use a uniform - type quantizer whose parameters in are @xmath455 and @xmath456 . by using theorems [ thm : add_cond_ki ] and [ thm : pwa_lmi ] , we designed feedback gains @xmath50 such that the lyapunov function @xmath430 ( @xmath83 ) satisfies and for every @xmath76 , @xmath82 , and @xmath83 , and the following constraint conditions hold @xmath457 the resulting @xmath50 were given by @xmath458 and we obtained the decease rate @xmath459 in of the `` zoom '' parameter @xmath156 with @xmath460 and @xmath461 .
[ fig : state_trajectory_example ] shows the state trajectories with initial states on the boundaries @xmath462 and @xmath463 .
we observe that all trajectories converges to the origin and that the constraint conditions and are satisfied in the presence of quantization errors .
we have provided an encoding strategy for the stabilization of pwa systems with quantized signals . for the stability of the closed - loop system
, we have shown that the piecewise quadratic lyapunov function decreases in the presence of quantization errors .
for the design of quantized feedback controllers , we have also studied the stabilization problem of pwa systems with bounded disturbances . in order to reduce the conservatism and the computational cost of controller designs , we have investigated the one - step reachable set . here
we give the proof of the following proposition for completeness : _ let @xmath464 be a bounded and closed polyhedron , and let @xmath248 be the vertices of @xmath243
. for every @xmath465 , we have @xmath466 _ choose @xmath244 arbitrarily , and let @xmath467 let @xmath468-th entry of @xmath469 , @xmath350 , and @xmath470 be @xmath471 , @xmath472 , and @xmath473 , respectively .
for every @xmath468 , we have @xmath474 hence @xmath475 this completes the proof .
the first author would like to thank dr .
k. okano of university california , santa barbara for helpful discussions on quantized control for pwa systems .
the authors are also grateful to anonymous reviewers whose comments greatly improved this paper .
m. xiaowu and g. yang , `` global input - to - state stabilization with quantized feedback for discrete - time piecewise affine systems with time delays , '' _ j. syst .
sci . complexity _ , vol .
26 , pp . 925939 , 2013 .
j. qiu , g. feng , and h. gao , `` approaches to robust @xmath477 static output feedback control of discrete - time piecewise - affine systems with norm - bounded uncertainties , '' _ int .
j. robust and nonlinear control _ , vol .
21 , pp . 790814 , 2011 .
l. e. ghaoui , f. oustry , and m. aitrami , `` a cone complementarity linearization algorithm for static output - feedback and related problems , '' _ ieee trans .
11711176 , 1997 . | this paper studies quantized control for discrete - time piecewise affine systems . for given stabilizing feedback controllers
, we propose an encoding strategy for local stability .
if the quantized state is near the boundaries of quantization regions , then the controller can recompute a better quantization value .
for the design of quantized feedback controllers , we also consider the stabilization of piecewise affine systems with bounded disturbances . in order to derive a less conservative design method with low computational cost
, we investigate a region to which the state belong in the next step . |
graphene has been long studied as a theoretical toy model not only to understand it s appealing physical properties,@xcite but also as a basic building block of various carbon allotropes like graphite,@xcite and more recently fullerenes and nanotubes.@xcite while graphite is the three dimensional allotrope of carbon and could be formed by the bernal stacking of graphene sheets , fullerene and nanotubes are the zero and one dimensional allotropes , formed by introducing pentagonal impurities and rolling the graphene sheets , respectively . after its experimental isolation in 2004,@xcite there has been a renewed interest in studying various properties of graphene sheet ,
both theoretically and experimentally , as well as due to potential technological applications.@xcite graphene consists of a single sheet of carbon atoms arranged on a honeycomb lattice .
basic properties of graphene are well described by a tight - binding model for the @xmath3-orbitals which are perpendicular to the graphene plane at each carbon atom .
the effective low - energy theory states that the charge carriers in graphene are massless dirac fermions , characterized by a linear dispersion relation and a linear energy dependence of the density of states which vanishes at the fermi level implying a semi - metallic behaviour for graphene.@xcite graphene has attracted a lot of attention recently not only due to its potential technological applications but also for understanding of physics in 2d systems@xcite .
its low energy description mimics ( 2 + 1)-dimensional quantum electrodynamics and hence graphene could act as a testing ground for various relativistic phenomena.@xcite early experiments on graphene have revealed that the conductivity at low temperatures is directly proportional to the carrier concentration ( or gate voltage ) except for very low carrier concentration . for zero gate voltage ,
the conductivity approaches a robust minimum universal value proportional to @xmath4.@xcite this could not be explained by the born approximation which predicts a conductivity independent of carrier concentration.@xcite other interesting properties include anomalous integral quantum hall effect and suppression of weak localization.@xcite recent experiments , however , show that the dependence of conductivity on carrier concentration could vary from sub linear to superlinear for different carrier concentrations.@xcite it has been argued that presence of impurities in graphene is the main contributor towards its electronic properties.@xcite the importance of disorder in graphene could most easily be emphasized by observing that the universal conductivity suggested by the theoretical studies on defectless graphene sheet is 2 - 20 times smaller than the observed conductivity close to the dirac points.@xcite the boltzmann conductivity for graphene is given by @xmath5 . the observed conductivity rises linearly with carrier concentration in graphene and @xmath6 , where @xmath7 is the density of states at the fermi energy and @xmath8 is the carrier density .
this implies that the scattering rate , @xmath9 . on the other hand , for weak local scatterers ,
born approximation predicts @xmath10 where @xmath11 is the impurity concentration.@xcite in view of this discrepancy , various investigations , both theoretical and numerical , have been carried out in order to understand the behavior of graphene under various types of disorder,@xcite such as vacancies,@xcite charged carriers,@xcite on - site disorder,@xcite long range on - site disorder,@xcite off - diagonal disorder,@xcite off - diagonal disorder with sign change probability in the hopping term.@xcite vacancies have been proposed to induce localized states , extended over many lattice sites , which are sensitive to the electron - hole symmetry breaking@xcite detailed studies in the presence of both compensated and uncompensated defects reveal that they could modify the low energy spectrum in graphene drastically like there could be quasi - localized zero modes and introduction of gap in the dos.@xcite for charged scatterers , nomura _
@xcite have argued on the basis of boltzmann transport theory that the linear dependence of conductivity on carrier concentration could be explained .
they find that states close to the dirac point are delocalized leading to @xmath12 .
also , one could observe antilocalization if the inter - valley scattering is weak . on the other hand , if inter - vally scattering is large , all states could be localized due to accumulation of berry phases .
conductivity in the presence of random charged impurity is also studied by hwang _ _ et al.__@xcite they find linear dependence of conductivity on carrier concentration for high carrier density .
however , for low carrier density , they argue , that system develops some inhomogenities ( random electron - hole puddles ) which implies that this domain is dominated by localization physics .
they also conclude that change of bias voltage may change the average distance between graphene sheet and the impurity in the substrate which could lead to sub- and super - linear conductivity dependence on carrier concentraion .
_ @xcite have argued that there could be a `` critical coupling '' distinguishing strong and weak coupling regimes in the presence of unscreened coulomb charges .
they also find bound states and strong renormalization of van hove singularities in the dos .
_ @xcitehave argued that the intrinsic conductivity of graphene ( ambipolar system ) is dominated by strong electron - hole scattering .
it has a universal value independent of temperature .
it is shown that conductivity could be proportional to v or @xmath13 depending on the other scattering mechanisms present like those on phonons by charged defects . in the unipolar system , it is argued that electron - hole scattering is not important and conductivity is proportional to @xmath14 .
_ @xcite have reported an analytical calculation for boltzmann conductivity with screened coulomb scatterers and both electron - hole coherent and incoherent solutions .
they find that the experimentally observed dependence of conductivity on @xmath8 could be explained by the electron - hole coherent solution . for diagonal disorder
, it is found that beyond a certain threshold disorder strength , bound states appear beyond the band continuum and resonant states could appear at low energies . in the infinite disorder strength limit , results match with that of vacancies . in the off - diagonal disorder case ,
strong low - energy resonances appear .
there are , however , no bound states.@xcite localization studies on graphene with on - site disorder carried out by xiong _ _ et al.__@xcite reveal that all states are localized in the case of random diagonal disorder which is consistent with anderson localization .
lherbier _ _
et al.__@xcite have also studied the energy dependent elastic mean free path , charge mobilities and semi - classical conductivity in the presence of anderson - type disorder , using real space order n kubo formalism , for both two - dimensional graphene and graphene nano - ribbons ( gnrs ) .
it was found that the systems undergo a conventioanl anderson transition in the zero temperature limit .
lewenkopf _ et al .
_ @xcite have studied long range diagonal disorder ( gaussian scatteres ) at finite concentration .
they find that conductivity increases as disorder strength is decreased .
it is shown that conductivity depends only on disorder strength and ratio of the system size to disorder correlation length .
this dependence could vary between sublinear to superlinear depending on disorder strength . for fixed disorder strength , conductivity increases with doping concentration . in the presence of strong long - range impurities , zhang _
_ et al.__@xcite have shown that states close to the dirac points are localized for sufficiently strong disorder strength and kosterlitz - thouless transition between localized and delocalized states is proposed which is seen in terms of the current flow vector . in the case of random off - diagonal disorder ( hopping disorder ) , localization studies by xiong _
_ et al.__@xcite reveal that states close to the dirac point are delocalized due to chiral symmetry .
they find that the off - diagonal disorder leads to a shape - dependent conductivity depending on the length to width ratio .
however , if a sign change probability is introduced , they find that the conductivity becomes shape independent
_ et al.__@xcite have shown that for disorder strength less than the hopping strength i.e. @xmath15 , there is no localization .
disorder @xmath1 slows down the dirac quasi particles but preserves their nature . for @xmath16 ,
localization sets in for states close to the fermi energy , gap at energy close to the dirac point and for @xmath17 existence of mobility edge is proposed which starts at fermi energy and moves towards the edges .
states close to the fermi energy are extended .
they also propose the existence of disorder induced gap defined as the distance between the upper and lower mobility edges around the fermi point .
it should be noted that in all these works , the inter - valley scattering is assumed to be very small and hence not contributing towards conductivity .
however , klos _ _ et al.__@xcite have done a comparative study of conductivity using the tight - binding(tb ) landauer approach and on the basis of the boltzmann theory and find a discrepancy between that results obtained by tb calculation and boltzmann approach .
despite all the efforts , the issue of localization in graphene is currently highly debated from a theoretical standpoint .
the obsered minimal conductivity @xmath18 over a range of mobilities remains to be fully understod . in view of a recent experiment by ponomarenko _
_ et al.__@xcite and katoch _ _ et al.__@xcite , which explores the dominant scatterers in graphene , and horng__et al.__@xcite , which measures the high - frequency conductivity in graphene , unlike believed so far , the primary reason for the linear rise of conductivity with carrier concentration is also debatable . in the present work
, we will investigate the finite - frequency electrical conductivity and localization properties of graphene in the presence of diagonal ( on - site ) disorder for various disorder strengths .
our exact - eigenstates approach implicitly takes into account the inter - valley as well as the intra - valley scatterings .
this paper is organized into eight sections . in section ii and iii ,
we introduce the two sub - lattice basis and evaluate the exact single - particle green s function within the t - matrix approach for a single impurity on either sublattice . in section iv , we consider disordered graphene . disorder is introduced via random fluctuation of the on - site energies of the @xmath3-orbitals . in section
v , we use the kubo - greenwood formula to calculate the frequency - dependent conductivity for different disorder strengths and for different system sizes .
the system - size dependence is employed to perform a renormalization group analysis , and for moderate disorder strength contact is made with the weak localization result of abraham s _ et al._. later on , focus on the weak disorder strength .
we study the frequency dependence of the averaged current matrix element squared for different locations in the band ( fermi energies ) and hence calculate conductivity and mobility for low - disordered graphene samples .
we also study the dependence of energy resolved current matrix elements squared on system size and disorder strength . in section
vi , we study the average current matrix elements squared over a range of disorder strength and for different system sizes in order to gain a better insight into disorder induced localization in graphene . in section vii , we make a comparision between graphene and square lattice .
we compare the normalized conductivity between the two .
we also show the intensity plots for both the lattices for different values of disorder strength .
finally , our conclusions are presented in section viii .
as already mentioned above , graphene is a single layer of carbon atoms on a honeycomb lattice .
a honeycomb lattice , which is not a bravais lattice , could be viewed as a composed of two kinds of sub - lattices .
nearest neighbor hopping takes electron from one sub - lattice to another .
we start with the tight - binding(tb ) hamiltonian : @xmath19 \label{tbham}\ ] ] where the sum is over the nearest neightbours .
this could be written in the two sub - lattice basis as : @xmath20 \label{ham1}\ ] ] where , the hopping term in k - space is : @xmath21\ ] ] it should be noted that this hamiltonian is ( @xmath22 ) and mixes the dirac points .
the energy eigenvalues are given by @xmath23 in this basis , the low energy spectrum provides six dirac points in the extended brilluoin zone .
these points are located at @xmath24 and @xmath25 .
expanding around the dirac points , we find the linear dispersion for carriers in graphene .
the free particle green s function is given by the expression : @xmath26 \frac{1}{\omega^2\ ! -\ !
e_{\mathbf k}^2 } % \end{displaymath } } \ ] ] where @xmath27 is the energy eigenvalue derived earlier .
the density of single particle states would then be given by @xmath28 & \mbox{if } e > e_f \\
-\frac{1}{\pi}{\sum_{\mathbf k } } im[g^0(\mathbf k,\omega ) ] & \mbox{if } e < e_f \end{array}\right.\ ] ] fig.([fig : dos , gii ] ) shows the density of states ( dos ) for pure graphene ( fig.([fig : dos]))and also the real and imaginary part of the green s function ( fig.([fig : gii ] ) )
in the presence of impurities , the free particle green s function gets modified .
we shall , at this stage , look at the effect of a single impurity on the green s function .
we shall employ the t - matrix approach which gives exact result in the case of single impurity . as from the scattering theory ,
the modified green s function based on the diagrams in fig.([fig : t - matrix ] ) is be given by : @xmath29 where the t - matrix is given as @xmath30 $ ] , v is the strength of the impurity .
the index @xmath31 and @xmath32 denotes the impurity site and the lattice sites respectively .
-matrix approximations for the self energy .
the `` x '' , dotted line and line with arrow signify the impurity , impurity potential and the green s function respectively . ]
information regarding additional poles is contained in the t - matrix .
this implies that there are possibilities of existence of new states if there is an intersection of @xmath33 $ ] and 1/v .
the imaginary part is small but finite .
if the strength of impurity is small or even moderate , there shall be no intersection with the @xmath34 line .
it is only when the strength of the impurity is large , some intersection is expected and this might lead to a new state . therefore , for some value of @xmath35
, a resonance state occurs at the impurity site .
this new state would be localized at the impurity site .
the full gren s function is given by : @xmath36}{i - v[g^{0}_{ii}(\omega)]}\ ] ] around either @xmath37 or @xmath38 points ( dirac points ) , the @xmath39 has the following form .
@xmath40\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath27 is the energy , @xmath41 is the momentum cutoff , @xmath42 is the fermi velocity and @xmath43 is the impurity site .
one should note that the free green s function contributes equally for an impurity sitting on either sub - lattice a or b. also , as , @xmath44 , the @xmath45 term in front provides a cut - off to the log divergence .
imaginary part gives the density of states as already mentioned above .
real part of the above expression is small .
if we introduce a magnetic impurity at the some site @xmath43 , there could again be appearance of new states for sufficiently large impurity strength .
however , the intersection could now be either above or below the @xmath45 axis .
however , since the nature of intersection is same as for the single non - magnetic impurity , the physics is expected to remain same .
we will now include diagonal ( on - site ) disorder and consider the following tight - binding hamiltonian : @xmath46 \label{ham2}\ ] ] on a honeycomb lattice . here
the random on - site energies @xmath47 are chosen from a uniform distribution on @xmath48 .
the second term is the hopping term with summation over nearest - neighbour pairs of sites . from the matrix realization of the above hamiltonian on a finite lattice with periodic boundary condition in both directions ,
we numerically obtain the eigenfunctions @xmath49 and the eigenvalues @xmath50 of the hamiltonian in eq.([ham2 ] ) by exact diagonalization of the hamiltonian matrix .
one should note that the spin index simply runs through the calculation and shall be considered while making comparisions with the experiments . in the following
, we have set the hopping term @xmath51 as the unit of energy . from the exact eigenvalues we obtain the local density of states ( ldos ) using : @xmath52 where @xmath53 is the total number of lattice points in the system .
fig.([fig : dos_dis ] ) shows the ldos for various disorder strengths .
clearly , the van hove singularities in the pure graphene dos are softened with increasing disorder strength .
for very small disorder strength , the dos is still linear .
however , for @xmath54 , the density of states becomes independent of @xmath45 .
this could be understood on the basis of intersection of @xmath55 $ ] and 1/v , as argued in the previous section .
we are interested in calculating finite - frequency conductivity for graphene .
we use the kubo - greenwood formula@xcite for conductivity which uses the eigenvalues @xmath50 and the eigenfunctions @xmath49 calculated earlier .
the kubo - greenwood formula is given by : @xmath56 where , the current matrix element @xmath57 is given by : @xmath58 where @xmath59 and @xmath60 are the eigenstates with @xmath61 and @xmath62 is the angle between the @xmath63-axis and the two other nearest neighbors at each site as shown in fig.([fig : theta ] ) .
summation , @xmath64 is over nearest neighbors . here
@xmath65 and @xmath66 are the number of unit cells and area of each unit cell , respectively .
( 2.3,-1.00)(4.3,3.05 ) ( 1.00,1.00)(6.00,1.00 ) ( 3.00,-1.00)(3.00,3.00 ) ( 5.00,1.00)(3.00,1.00 ) ( 3.00,1.00)(2.00,2.732 ) ( 3.00,1.00)(2.00,-0.732 ) ( 5.00,1.00 ) ( 3.00,1.00 ) ( 2.00,2.732 ) ( 2.00,-0.732 ) ( 3.05,1.0)0.520.0120.0 ( 3.57,1.73)@xmath62 ( 3.25,0.75)i ( 5.05,0.75)j ( 1.75,2.732)j ( 1.75,-0.732)j ( 6.25,1.00)x ( 3.00,3.20)y the summation over @xmath67 in eq.([kg ] ) is carried out by considering each pair of states @xmath59 and @xmath60 such that the energy difference , @xmath68 , remains fixed .
we shall first consider the case for @xmath1 = 5 . when the density of states is independent of @xmath45 ( refer fig . [
fig : dos_dis ] , w=5 ) , the energy levels are nearly equally spaced . for a given random distribution of on - site impurity potentials ,
the contribution to the matrix elements from each energy pair of eigenvalues with fixed energy difference , @xmath68 could simply carried out by keeping @xmath69 fixed .
we average the total contribution by the number of such paired states considered and the number of random configurations , typically 5000 samples of the matrix elements in all .
the expression for the finite - frequency conductivity then reduces to : @xmath70 where @xmath71 is the averaged matrix element squared and @xmath72 is the averaged density of states per site at the dirac points .
we now define the normalized conductivity @xmath73 which is convenient for plotting the data .
( [ fig : normcond1 ] ) is the data for a ( 20,24 ) lattice for various values of @xmath1 . at high frequency
the normalized conductivity is approximately one . for higher @xmath1
, the conductivity falls off at low frequency .
this reduction of the low - frequency conductivity can be ascribed to the effects of localization .
we show in fig.([fig : normcond2 ] ) the normalized conductivity versus frequency for different system sizes at fixed @xmath1(@xmath74 ) .
we observe that the conductivity decreses with increasing system size which exhibits the renormalization group at work .
we also note that , despite the fact that the lattice is not symmetric about @xmath63 and @xmath75 axes , the conductivity behaviour turns out to be similar in both directions ( not shown ) .
this is due to the fact that the spectrum of graphene is conical . versus @xmath45 for various impurity strengths for a ( 20,24 ) system .
in all the cases , the dos is flat .
the curves are drawn as a guide to the eye .
some data points are omitted for clarity . ]
versus@xmath45 for various system sizes . in all the cases ,
the dos is flat ( w=5 ) .
the curves are drawn as a guide to the eye .
some data points are omitted for clarity . ]
we now turn to the macroscopic renormalization - group ( mrg ) calculation .
we start with a certain set of hamiltonian parameters ( @xmath76 and @xmath1 ) and calculate the appropriate macroscopic physical quantites as a function of lattice parameter .
the hamiltonian parameters are then renormalized to preserve the physical quantites as the lattice parameter is varied .
we consider specifically two systems with different lattice spacing ( @xmath77 and @xmath78 ) but same physical size .
for these two systems to represent the same physical problem with different microscopic length scales , we demand that the hamiltonian parameters be so related that the physical properties are preserved .
the appropriate physical quantites to be preserved for the localization problem are the one - electron dos at the fermi energy , @xmath72 and the low - frequency electrical conductivity
we define the dimensionless conductance which depends only on @xmath1 .
@xmath79 then , the one - parameter rg recursion relation is : @xmath80 the other mrg relation : @xmath81 fixes the absolute magnitude of @xmath76 to preserve the dos . for weak disorder , the weak localization scaling theory result in 2d is@xcite @xmath82 where , l is the length scale . for @xmath74
, we compare the ( 20,24 ) lattice with ( 12,14 ) lattice and find that @xmath83 which matches well with the above value : @xmath84 .
thus , for @xmath74 , the scaling theory of weak localization is completely obeyed .
we now turn our attention to the case when the density of states is not flat ( e.g. for w=2 , refer fig .
[ fig : dos_dis ] ) . the earlier method of obtaining the average current matrix elements squared does not work here since the ldos is linear .
we , therefore , average the current matrix elements squared , @xmath85 over all @xmath86 and @xmath87 states such that the energy difference @xmath88 lies in a given range ( binning ) .
we have checked that for @xmath1=5 the @xmath89 obtained by this method matches with the earlier one . for weak disorder strength
, we study the d.c .
limit of average current matrix elements squared for different locations in the band .
we consider a narrow band of states centred at different energy eigenvalues and calculate their contribution to @xmath90 in the limit @xmath44 .
it could be directly seen from the fig.([fig : energyres](a ) ) that in the limit @xmath44 for @xmath1=5 , contribution from all the energy states to conductivity is nearly equal .
this implies that all the states are of the similar nature .
however , in the same limit for @xmath1=2 , the states close to the fermi energy have a larger contribution and the contribution decreases as we move away from the band centre as seen in fig .
( [ fig : energyres](b ) ) .
this implies that , close to band centre , the states are more extended ( compared to the states away from the band centre ) .
we shall return to the issue of localization in the next section .
+ v / s @xmath50 for a ( 16,20 ) graphene lattice and w=2 .
the curve is a @xmath91 fit with a= 0.0010 and b = 0.002 ] we may now ask : what is dependence of @xmath92 for @xmath1=2 on energy eigenvalues as we move along the band ? we polynomial fit the data and find ( fig.([fig : omega ] ) ) that the behaviour is inversly proportional to the square of the energy eigenvalue . the dependence is of the form @xmath93 . for w = 2 and system size ( 16,20 )
, we find that @xmath94 , and @xmath95 .
we study the scaling behaviour of the constants @xmath96 and @xmath97 with increasing system size .
[ fig : scaling ] ) .
we have plotted the behaviour of @xmath96 and @xmath97 versus @xmath98 .
it could be seen that there is not a significant change in the value of @xmath96 and @xmath97 as we increase the system size and the dependence of these quantities on @xmath98 is almost linear . as @xmath99 ,
the values of @xmath96 and @xmath97 are 1.06157 and 3.8294 respectively .
the first term ( @xmath100 ) is what is expected from the boltzmann theory .
the other term , independent of @xmath50 is the non - boltzmann contribution .
a particle with the hamiltonian described by eq.([tbham ] ) , which supports both positive and negative energy states(positive and negative bands ) , could be in a linear combination of the positive and negative energy eigenstates .
the boltzmann term arises out of transition between term in the same band .
off - diagonal terms in the velocity operator correspond to the transition between the same @xmath101 but belonging to different bands and is responsible for the non - boltzmann contributions to the conductivity .
the origin of this term could also be understood from the fact that the velocity operator is non - diagonal in the helicity basis .
an analytical calculation for boltzmann conductivity with screened coulomb scatterers and incorporating the off - diagonal terms in the velocity operator was carried out by trushin _ _
et al.__@xcite in order to study d.c .
conductivity , we go back to eq.([kg ] ) whereby d.c .
conductivity could be written as the product of the current matrix elements squared in the limit @xmath44 and dos squared . in order to do this , we polynomial fit the dos squared and the average current matrix elements squared in the d.c . limit . for @xmath1
= 2 , we have seen that dos @xmath102 .
carrier concentration , @xmath8 is defined as @xmath103 @xmath104 . putting in the values of the parameters , @xmath76 = 2.8ev and @xmath77 = 1.42 @xmath105 , together with the the bahavior of @xmath106 versus @xmath50 ( obtained in the previous subsection ) and @xmath8 versus @xmath50 , we obtain conductivity as a function of the carrier concentration . here the factor of two for spin multiplicity
has already been taken into account . for large carrier concentration
, we notice that as @xmath50 increases , the constant term ( `` @xmath107 '' ) in the fit dominates the current matrix element contribution .
this together with the dos shows a linear dependence on the carrier concentration .
we also note that for n @xmath108 zero , the conductivity does not go to zero .
it turns out that for small @xmath1 , both the @xmath85 and the dos together conspire to give a non - zero d.c .
conductivity ( @xmath12 ) , independent of @xmath109 , close to the dirac point .
comparision of different system size suggests that as the system size is increased the lesser number of eigensatates contribute to @xmath12 for very small doping concentration .
however , the @xmath100 dependence is still retained .
this translates to the fact that as we increase the system size , the @xmath2 shifts towards the fermi energy as seen in fig.([fig : energyres_w2 ] ) . the value of this minimal conductivity , @xmath12 @xmath110 @xmath111 in confirmity with the previous results obtained with scba@xcite .
we also compare this behaviour with respect to the system size and find that for larger system size , the number of such extended states decreases as shown in fig .
( [ fig : energyres_w2 ] ) but still retaining its @xmath100 dependence .
thus , away from the zero doping concentration , one obtains a linear dependence of conductivity on the doping concentration in confirmity with the experimental findings .
however , there is a quantitative difference between the two .
the slope of the @xmath112 v / s @xmath8 ( fig.([fig : sigma_n ] ) ) is very small compared to the experimental results .
the dependence if a.c .
conductivity on @xmath45 can be obtained from the energy resolved matrix elements squared . for a fixed energy , the dependence of @xmath113 .
this together with the _ mobility _ is defined as : @xmath114 . since
, @xmath112 goes linearly as @xmath8 , @xmath115 should nearly be a constant for energies away from the dirac points . since @xmath116 , from eq.([sigma ] ) , we find that @xmath117 .
@xmath118 in fig.([fig : mobility ] ) , we plot @xmath115 versus gate voltage , @xmath119 where @xmath120 .
we find that the mobility rises sharply close to the dirac point .
this sharp rise around the dirac points is in a very good qualitative agreement with the experiments .
however , the values of mobility is around 1000 times lower than the experimental results .
we would like to add that , in the adopted formalism , it is impossible to distinguish the effect of inter - valley scattering or to determine it s contribution towards conductivity .
however , since we are dealing with very short range scatterers , it would be impossible to avoid large momentum interactions and hence inter - valley scattering .
in order to study localization , we looked at ipr versus energy eigenvaluei(not shown ) and found that ipr is not sensitive enough to capture signatures of localization for small @xmath1 .
therefore , we , again , turn towards the energy resolved studies of averaged current matrix elements squared , ( fig .
[ fig : energyres ] ) .
as mentioned earlier , for a few states close to the band centre have a very large averaged current matrix element squared value .
this implies that these state are extended .
we notice that this is the case independent of the system size .
also , the experimental finding of a universal zero - bias minimum conductivity , @xmath12 suggests that the states close to the band centre should be extended , as we find which is in conformity with the findings of amini _ _ et al.__@xcite .
this , however , is in contradiction with the findings of xiong _ _ et al.__@xcite .
one might , also , question the @xmath121 dependence on the energy eigenvalues , @xmath50 since it could very well be a finite - size effect . for low disorder strength , the localization length
, @xmath122 varies exponentially with the inverse of disorder strength i.e. @xmath123 and in order to see the effects of localization , one needs to change the system size exponentially.we note that the @xmath124 behaviour is present at all system sizes starting from system containing nearly 300 lattice points((8,10 ) ) to nearly 3000 lattice points((24,30 ) ) . also , that for @xmath1=3 , the @xmath125 is independent of @xmath50 ( not shown ) suggesting a disorder induced crossover from localized to delocalized phase for @xmath126 .
we check this by studying the averaged current matrix element squared over a range of @xmath1 for different system sizes , at a fixed energy .
we have fixed the energy at @xmath127 and have considered ten states around this energy .
we study the contribution of these ten states towards the @xmath125 .
the results are shown in fig.([fig : m_w ] ) .
the inset of fig.([fig : m_w ] ) shows the plot between averaged current matrix element squared over a range of @xmath1 for three different system sizes ( 16,20),(20,24 ) and ( 24,30 ) .
the cross - over is highlighted in the main panel which shows the logarithm of averaged current matrix elements squared versus @xmath1 .
we indeed find a crossover around @xmath1=3 .
however , this crossover is not between localized and delocalized phases but from localized to a very weakly localized behaviour .
this is in agreement with the scaling theory of localization which predicts that all states in 2d are localized .
we , now , compare the normalized conductivity , @xmath128 between square lattice and graphene for @xmath1 = 5 . this comparision has been shown in fig.([fig : comparsq ] ) .
we observe that the conductivity matches well at large frequencies for both the lattices .
however , at low frequencies , the grahene has a lower conductivity suggesting that the states are more localized .
this could mean that the states in graphene are more susceptible to localized when subject to disorder , as also suggested by xiong _ _
et al.__@xcite we also compare the intensity plots for graphene and square lattice for different values of disorder strengths and fixed system size .
the results are shown in fig([fig : comparsq2 ] ) .
we find that there is no signature fo puddle formation for square lattice .
the reason for the formation of puddle for low carrier concentration in graphene is yet to be understood .
in conclusion , we have studied the finite - frequency electrical conductivity in graphene under diagonal ( on - site ) disorder of various strength and in the presence of inter - valley scattering using kubo - greenwood foumula . for moderate disorder strength
, we find that for differnt system sizes , fixed @xmath1 , scaling theory is at work .
we made contact with the weak localization result of abrahams _ _ et al.__@xcite and found a very good agreement which means that for @xmath74 , logarithmic scaling is obeyed .
we compare normalized conductivity of graphene with that of a square lattice and find that graphene is more susceptible to localization when subject to disorder .
we have established that , for low disorder strength , @xmath129 , the states away from the band centre are more localized comared to the ones close to the band centre . for low disorder strength
, we have calculated the conductivity for low - disordered graphene and have found the results are in disagreement with that of boltzmann conductivity .
also , the conductivity and mobility are in qualitative agreement with experiments . also , for weak disorder strength , it is the competition between @xmath130 and dos which gives rise to a universal conductivity minimum .
the linear rise of conductivity with carrier concentration is due to a term unaccounted for in the boltzmann expression for conductivity .
we have also established that , for low disorder strength , @xmath129 , the states close to the band centre are extended and that there exists a crossover at @xmath1 @xmath110 3 .
comparative study of intensity plots for states close to the band centre for graphene with square lattice shows clear signatures of puddle formation in graphene .
although we have studied a simple disorder model in graphene , some of the feature studied could be generic .
j. w. klos , and i. v. zozoulenko phys .
b * 82 * , 081414(r ) ( 2010 ) . l. a. ponomarenko , r. yang , t. m. mohiuddin , s. m. morozov , a. a. zhukov , f. schedin , e. w. hill , k. s. novoselov , m. i. katsnelson , and a. k. geim phys . rev
. lett . * 102 * , 206603 ( 2009 ) .
jyoti katoch , j - h .
chen , ryuichi tsuchikawa , c. w. smith , e. r. mucciolo , and masa ishigami phys . rev .
b * 82 * , 081417(r ) ( 2010 ) .
jason horng , chi - fan chen , baisong geng , caglar girit , yuanbo zhang , zhao hao , hans a. bechtel , michael martin , alex zettl , michael f. crommie , y. ron shen , feng wang , arxiv:1007.4623 | we employ the exact eigenstate basis formalism to study electrical conductivity in graphene , in the presence of short - range diagonal disorder and inter - valley scattering .
we find that for disorder strength , @xmath0 5 , the density of states is flat .
we , then , make connection , using the mrg approach , with the work of abrahams _ et al . _ and find a very good agreement for disorder strength , @xmath1 = 5 . for low disorder strength , @xmath1 = 2 , we plot the energy - resolved current matrix elements squared for different locations of the fermi energy from the band centre .
we find that the states close to the band centre are more extended and falls of nearly as @xmath2 as we move away from the band centre .
further studies of current matrix elements versus disorder strength suggests a cross - over from weakly localized to a very weakly localized system .
we calculate conductivity using kubo greenwood formula and show that , for low disorder strength , conductivity is in a good qualitative agreement with the experiments , even for the on - site disorder .
the intensity plots of the eigenstates also reveal clear signatures of puddle formation for very small carrier concentration .
we also make comparison with square lattice and find that graphene is more easily localized when subject to disorder . |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.