article
stringlengths 0
745k
| abstract
stringlengths 0
92.7k
|
|---|---|
for the past decade or so , the study of first - order phase transitions in cosmology has been the focus of much interest due to their possible relevance to the physics of the early universe .
some well - known examples are inflationary models @xcite , the quark - hadron transition @xcite and , more recently , the generation of the cosmological baryon asymmetry in the electroweak phase transition @xcite . in a first - order phase transition
, the initial metastable phase decays to the stable phase by the nucleation of bubbles larger than a critical size .
this decay may be triggered by either quantum or thermal fluctuations , depending on how the ambient temperature compares to the nucleation barrier @xcite . within a cosmological context
, the cooling is provided by the expansion of the universe ; the long - wavelength modes of the order parameter responsible for the symmetry breaking transition are coupled to the `` environment '' , which is assumed to be in local thermal equilibrium at some temperature @xmath0 .
( here , we are mainly concerned with `` late '' transitions , for which the typical fluctuation time - scales are much shorter than the expansion rate . ) of great relevance to the understanding of the evolution of the phase transition is the determination of the bubble nucleation rate per unit volume .
this is a well - known problem in classical statistical mechanics , with an long history @xcite .
phenomenological field - theoretic treatments were developed by cahn and hilliard @xcite , and by langer @xcite in the context of a time - dependent coarse - grained ginzburg - landau model .
classical homogeneous nucleation theory within a field theoretic context has been recently shown by numerical experiments to successfully predict the nucleation barrier @xcite . in the case of zero - temperature quantum field theory , the study of metastable vacuum decay was initiated with the work of voloshin , kobzarev , and okun @xcite , and was put onto firm theoretical ground by coleman and callan in the late seventies @xcite .
finite temperature corrections to the vacuum decay rate were first considered by linde @xcite , who argued that temperature corrections to the nucleation rate are obtained recalling that finite temperature field theory ( at sufficiently high temperatures ) in @xmath1-dimensions is equivalent to @xmath2-dimensional euclidean quantum field theory with @xmath3 substituted by @xmath0 .
thus , in @xmath1 dimensions , the nucleation rate is proportional to @xmath4 $ ] , where @xmath5 is the @xmath2-dimensional euclidean action evaluated at its extremum ( specifically , a saddle point ) , the critical bubble , or bounce , @xmath6 .
the usual expression for the nucleation rate per unit volume used in the literature is @xcite @xmath7 } { \det ' [ - \nabla^{2 } + v_{\rm { eff}}''(\varphi_b(r , t),t ) ] } \right\}^ { \frac{1}{2 } } { \rm exp}\left [ - { { s_e^3 ( \varphi_b(r , t),t)}\over t}\right ] \ : , \label{badrate}\ ] ] where @xmath8 is the value of the field @xmath9 at the metastable minimum , and the prime in the determinant in the denominator is a reminder that one should omit the zero and negative eigenvalues , associated with the translation symmetry of the bubble and with its instability ( being a saddle point configuration ) , respectively .
@xmath10 is the one - loop approximation to the finite temperature effective potential , and @xmath11 .
there are three important points here .
the first is that in order to estimate the determinantal prefactor ( the `` equilibrium '' part of the prefactor ; there is a dynamic factor which can not be obtained by using equilibrium arguments ) one usually proceeds by invoking dimensional arguments to approximate it by a term of order @xmath12 ( @xmath13 is the critical temperature ) .
how good is this approximation ? clearly , in most cases it is impossible to evaluate the determinants exactly .
but can one obtain a better approximation than the simple use of dimensional arguments ? the second , and most important , point is that the critical bubble configuration @xmath14 used to evaluate the nucleation barrier , denoted above by @xmath15 , was obtained from an effective potential which includes corrections coming from scalar loops .
hence the temperature dependence in @xmath16
. we will show here that this procedure is not in general justified and is only a good approximation if the corrections from scalar loops are negligible . finally , in the expression for the temperature corrected barrier in eq .
( [ badrate ] ) , @xmath17 , one uses the _ temperature corrected _ effective potential , @xmath18 as opposed to the tree level potential .
thus , it is claimed that @xmath17 is equivalent to the free energy of the temperature dependent bounce , given by @xmath19 \ : .
\label{badact}\ ] ] as far as we know , apart from the work of affleck in the context of finite temperature quantum mechanics @xcite , this point has never been properly addressed in the literature .
how did the temperature corrected potential appear in the exponent ? is the exponentiation of the massless modes sufficient ?
in fact , most of the work done on cosmological phase transitions in which temperature effects are important ( including some by the present authors ) simply invokes linde s results .
given the many applications of finite temperature vacuum decay in cosmology , we feel that this important question should not be left unscrutinized .
this concern has also been expressed in recent works by csernai and kapusta @xcite , and by buchm@xmath20ller , helbig , and walliser @xcite .
both works attempted to improve on linde s results , by generalizations of langer s work .
csernai and kapusta obtained an expression for the dynamical prefactor by using a relativistic hydrodynamic approach , while buchm@xmath20ller _ et al .
_ obtained an approximate expression for the decay rate in scalar electrodynamics ( and more recently , with z. fodor , in the standard electroweak model ) by integrating out the electromagnetic degrees of freedom from the partition function .
however , a more detailed analysis of the nucleation barrier and how it compares to the usual result is still lacking . in this paper we address the three points raised above
. we will be mostly interested in the regime in which thermal fluctuations are much larger than quantum fluctuations .
this way we avoid the question of how to match continuously the two regimes , although we believe this to be a very important question @xcite .
( see also refs . @xcite and @xcite . )
the hope is that in most situations of interest the transition will be dominated by one or the other regime . by a saddle - point evaluation of the partition function in the case of a self - interacting scalar field , it is possible to show that the temperature corrections to the nucleation barrier can be interpreted as entropic contributions due to stable vibrational modes on the _ tree - level _ bounce configuration , @xmath6 .
in other words , the first corrections to the energy of the critical bubble configuration come from temperature induced stable fluctuations on the bubble , which will modify its volume and surface energies .
we will show that these corrections are given by the temperature corrected effective action evaluated at the tree - level bounce @xmath6 . in expression ( [ badrate ] )
, the bounce is obtained from the effective potential which includes scalar loops .
the difference between the two nucleation barriers will be important whenever scalar loops are not negligible .
we will show that they become particularly important within the so - called thin - wall limit , that is , in the vicinity of the critical temperature for the transition .
this is perfectly consistent with the fact that large entropic corrections are expected near the critical temperature .
we will obtain this result by a perturbative evaluation of the determinantal prefactor . in principle
, the determinantal prefactor can be evaluated in two ways .
clearly , the computation can be done directly if we know the eigenvalues related to a given bubble configuration .
this method is not very useful in practice , since we in general do not know the eigenvalues .
( unless , of course , we obtain them numerically . )
writing down explicitly the eingenvalue equations , and using a thin - wall approximation to the bubble configuration , we show how the temperature corrections to the nucleation barrier originate from fluctuations about the critical bubble configuration .
even though the thin - wall approximation is not very useful in realistic situations , there is no reason to believe that thicker wall bubbles will behave any differently .
( unless the transition becomes too weak , in which case nucleation of critical bubbles may not be the relevant mechanism for the transition @xcite . )
the second approach we use to evaluate the prefactor relies on a perturbative expansion of the determinants . within first - order ,
it is again possible to show how the prefactor accounts for the temperature corrections to the nucleation barrier .
the paper is organized as follows . in section 2
we briefly review langer s formalism for obtaining nucleation rates , adapted to field theory at finite temperatures .
that is , we obtain the partition function for the metastable phase plus a nucleating fluctuation by a saddle - point evaluation of the functional integral . in section 3
we show how the determinantal prefactor can account for the finite temperature corrections to the nucleation barrier . for simplicity
, the calculation is performed in the context of the thin - wall approximation for the bubble profile , although in principle one could obtain results for any configuration . in sections 2 and 3 , for the sake of clarity , the discussion is somewhat oversimplified .
we _ assume _ that the system is initially in a metastable state and study only the scalar degrees of freedom in the problem .
this situation is not unrealistic , as it can be reproduced in numerical simulations of vacuum decay @xcite . in section 4
we study a model of a scalar field coupled to fermions .
this example is particularly interesting as it illustrates how a thermal state evolves into a metastable state due to radiative corrections , very much like in the standard electroweak model .
( recall that in a cosmological context the cooling is provided by the expansion of the universe . )
a related problem has been recently studied by e. weinberg , in the context of massless scalar models for which symmetry breaking occurs due to radiative corrections . in the regime dominated by quantum fluctuations ,
weinberg showed how radiative corrections induce a metastable state and how it is possible to evaluate its decay rate@xcite .
we show how to obtain an effective partition function for the scalar field by integrating out the fermionic modes , and proceed to obtain the decay rate .
we then compare our results for the nucleation barrier to the results obtained using eq .
( [ badrate ] ) .
conclusions are presented in section 5 and two appendices are included to clarify a few technical points .
consider a scalar field model with four - dimensional euclidean action @xmath21 where @xmath22 is the euclidean lagrangian density given by @xmath23 and the potential in ( [ lphih ] ) has a metastable minimum at @xmath24 and a stable minimum at @xmath25 , as shown in fig . 1 .
[ we will only consider potentials with two minima here . ]
assume _ that the system is prepared initially in the metastable phase , without worrying for the moment about how this is done .
( see section 4 . )
the metastable phase will decay into the stable phase by the nucleation of bubbles larger than a critical size .
( for a review see , e.g. , @xcite . ) as is well - known , in order to study the decay of the false vacuum at finite temperature we impose the periodic boundary condition ( anti - periodic for fermions ) @xmath26 , so that the euclidean action becomes @xcite @xmath27=\int_0^{\beta}d\tau\int d^3x\left [ { 1\over 2 } \left ( { { \partial \phi}\over { \partial \tau}}\right ) ^2+{1\over 2 } \left ( \nabla\phi \right ) ^2 + v(\phi ) \right ] \ : . \label{seuclt}\ ] ] the partition function of the system is given by a functional integral over all possible field configurations weighted by their euclidean action , @xmath28 following langer @xcite , we describe the nucleation of bubbles of the stable phase inside the metastable phase under the assumption that a dilute gas approximation for these droplets is valid .
unless the transition is weakly first - order , this should be a very good approximation to describe the early stages of the transition , when bubble collisions and other complicated kinetic effects can be neglected .
the critical configuration is an extremum of the euclidean action , @xmath29 being thus a solution of the equation of motion , @xmath30 with boundary conditions , @xmath31 , and @xmath32 .
coleman , glaser , and martin @xcite , have shown that the configuration with minimum energy , _
i.e. _ , the minimum of all the maxima , will have @xmath33-symmetry . as argued by linde @xcite , for sufficiently high temperatures
the problem becomes effectively three - dimensional , and the saddle point will be given by the @xmath34-symmetric , or static , solution of @xmath35 with boundary conditions , @xmath36 and @xmath37 .
note that the potential in ( [ eulersph ] ) is the _ tree - level _ potential . for future reference
we note that when the false vacuum energy density [ @xmath38 is much smaller than the barrier height [ @xmath39 , see fig . 1 ] , the bubble radius @xmath40 is much larger than the wall thickness @xmath41 , where @xmath42 is a typical mass scale in the problem . in this case , the solution to eq .
( [ eulersph ] ) can be estimated by the so - called thin - wall approximation and is given by @xmath43 which describes a bubble of radius @xmath40 of the stable phase @xmath44 embedded in the metastable phase @xmath45 .
@xmath46 describes the bubble wall separating the two phases .
the main advantage of langer s approach is that in a dilute gas of bubbles one can infer the thermodynamics of the system from the knowledge of the partition function of a single bubble .
we can write the partition function for the system with a bubble of the stable vacuum inside the metastable vacuum as @xmath47 where @xmath48 and @xmath49 are the partition functions of the system for the vacuum field configuration @xmath45 and for the bubble field configuration @xmath50 , respectively @xcite .
the generalization of ( [ z1bubb ] ) for several bubbles is given by @xmath51 + z ( \varphi_{f } ) \frac{1}{2 ! } \left [ \frac{z(\varphi_{b})}{z(\varphi_{f } ) } \right]^{2 } + \ldots \nonumber \\ & \simeq & z(\varphi_{f } ) \exp \left [ \frac{z(\varphi_{b})}{z(\varphi_{f } ) } \right ] \ : .
\label{zmany}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the proof of ( [ zmany ] ) can be found in the work of arnold and mclerran @xcite , who studied the properties of a dilute gas of sphalerons .
they expressed the multiple - sphaleron configurations as the superposition of many single sphalerons , with partition function approximated as above . the partition functions in ( [ zmany ] )
can be evaluated by the saddle - point method , expanding the lagrangian field in ( [ zphih ] ) as @xmath52 for @xmath49 and @xmath53 for @xmath48 . @xmath54 and @xmath55 are small perturbations around the classical field configurations @xmath56 and @xmath57 , respectively .
these perturbations around each configuration bring the temperature corrections to the nucleation barrier into the problem , as we shall see . up to 1loop order one keeps the quadratic terms in the fluctuations @xmath54 and @xmath55 in the expansion of the scalar field in the partition function ( [ zphih ] ) .
this way one can write the following expressions for @xmath49 and @xmath48 , respectively , @xmath58 \eta \right\ } \label{zphib}\ ] ] and @xmath59 \zeta \right\ } \ : , \label{zphif}\ ] ] where @xmath60 and @xmath61 . performing the functional gaussian integrals in ( [ zphib ] ) and ( [ zphif ] )
one gets the following expression for the ratio between the partition functions , @xmath62 , appearing in ( [ zmany ] ) : @xmath63^{-\frac{1}{2 } } e^{-\delta s } \ : , \label{ratiodet}\ ] ] where @xmath64^{- \frac{1}{2 } } \equiv \int d \eta \exp \left\ { - \int_{0}^{\beta } d \tau \int d^{3 } x \frac{1}{2 } \eta [ m ] \eta \right\}$ ] and @xmath65 is the difference between the euclidean actions for the field configurations @xmath50 and @xmath45 .
note that @xmath66 , and hence @xmath67 , _ does not include any temperature corrections . _ from ( [ zmany ] ) and ( [ ratiodet ] ) , the free energy of the system
, @xmath68 can be written as @xmath69^{-\frac{1}{2 } } e^{-\delta s } \ : .
\label{energy}\ ] ] as is well - known , the determinantal prefactor evaluated for the bounce configuration has one negative eigenvalue , signalling the presence of a metastable state , and also three zero eigenvalues related with the translational invariance of the bubble in three - dimensional space . because of the negative eigenvalue , the free energy @xmath70 is imaginary . as shown by langer @xcite
( see also ref .
@xcite ) , the decay rate is proportional to the imaginary part of @xmath70 @xmath71 where @xmath72 is the single negative eigenvalue .
in general it depends on non - equilibrium aspects of the dynamics , such as the coupling strength to the thermal bath .
in this section we compute the ratio of the determinants appearing in the decay rate , and show how it provides a finite temperature correction to the nucleation barrier .
first recall that for static field configurations @xmath67 is given by @xmath73 = \frac{\delta e}{t } \ : , \label{deltas}\ ] ] where @xmath74 is simply the nucleation _ energy _ barrier , that is , the energy of a critical nucleation within the metastable phase . for example , in the thin - wall approximation of eq .
( [ bubble ] ) , @xmath74 is @xmath75 where @xmath76 is the tree - level surface tension of the bubble wall ( _ i.e. _ with no corrections due to fluctuations around the bubble wall field configuration @xmath77 ) @xmath78 \ : .
\label{sigma0}\ ] ] using ( [ deltas ] ) in eqs .
( [ energy ] ) and ( [ gamma ] ) we can write the decay rate as @xmath79^{-\frac{1}{2 } } { \rm exp } \left ( -{{\delta e } \over t}\right ) \ : . \label{gamma2}\ ] ] the determinantal prefactor in ( [ gamma2 ] ) will provide the temperature corrections to the nucleation barrier .
this should come as no surprise , given that the determinant is obtained from integrating over thermally induced fluctuations about the tree - level bubble configuration .
( recall that we are only considering the regime in which thermal fluctuations are much larger than quantum fluctuations . )
once the negative and zero eigenvalues are taken care of , the positive eigenvalues are easily associated with entropic contributions to the activation energy due to stable deformations of the bubble s shape , as in classical nucleation theory .
we now proceed to show how to incorporate temperature corrections to the nucleation barrier .
this can be done without an explicit evaluation of the eigenvalues of the operators in the determinants . as we show next ,
all that we need is to separate consistently the positive eigenvalues from the negative and zero eigenvalues , and then show how the former can be exponentiated . in principle , the computation of the determinantal prefactor in ( [ energy ] ) can be performed by two different methods .
the first involves obtaining directly ( analytically , or more realistically , numerically ) the eigenvalues for the determinants in eq .
( [ energy ] ) .
the second method consists in developing a consistent perturbative expansion for the ratio of the determinants .
we now examine both these possibilities .
consider the eigenvalue equations for the differential operators that appear in the determinantal prefactor , @xmath80 \phi_{f}(i ) = \varepsilon_{f}^{2}(i ) \phi_{f}(i ) \label{valuephif}\ ] ] and @xmath81 \phi_{b}(i ) = \varepsilon_{b}^{2}(i ) \phi_{b}(i ) \ : .
\label{valuephib}\ ] ] in momentum space one writes , @xmath82 , where @xmath83 , for bosons ( for fermion fields @xmath84 ) . from ( [ valuephif ] ) and ( [ valuephib ] ) one can write the determinant ratio in ( [ energy ] ) as @xmath85^{\frac{1}{2 } } & = & \exp \left\ { \frac{1}{2 } \ln \left [ \frac { \det ( -\box_{e } + v''(\varphi_{f}))_{\beta } } { \det ( -\box_{e } + v''(\varphi_{b}))_{\beta } } \right ] \right\ } = \nonumber \\ & = & \exp \left\ { \frac{1}{2 } \ln \left [ \frac { \prod_{n=- \infty}^{+ \infty } \prod_{i } \left ( \omega_{n}^{2 } + e_{f}^{2}(i ) \right ) } { \prod_{n= - \infty}^{+ \infty } \prod_{j } \left ( \omega_{n}^{2 } + e_{b}^{2}(j ) \right ) } \right ] \right\ } \ : . \label{ratio}\end{aligned}\ ] ] using the identity , @xmath86 and taking into account that we have in the denominator of ( [ ratio ] ) one negative and three zero eigenvalues , one obtains ( for details see appendix a ) @xmath85^{\frac{1}{2 } } & = & { \cal v}\frac{t^{4}}{i |e_{-}| } \frac{\beta \frac{|e_{-}|}{2 } } { \sin \left ( \beta \frac{|e_{-}|}{2 } \right ) } \left [ \frac{\delta e}{2 \pi t } \right]^{\frac{3}{2 } } \nonumber \\ & \times & \exp \left\ { \sum_{i } \left [ \frac{\beta}{2 } e_{f}(i ) + \ln \left ( 1 - e^{- \beta e_{f}(i ) } \right ) \right ] \right .
\nonumber \\ & - & \left .
\sum_{j } \ ; ' \left [ \frac{\beta}{2 } e_{b}(j ) + \ln \left ( 1 - e^{- \beta e_{b}(j ) } \right ) \right ] \right\ } \ : .
\label{eigenratio}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the factor @xmath87^{\frac{3}{2 } } $ ] in the right hand side of eq .
( [ eigenratio ] ) comes from the contribution of the zero eigenvalues , which can be handled as in ref .
@xcite , through the use of collective coordinates corresponding to the position of the bubble .
@xmath88 is the volume of three space , while the prime in @xmath89 is a reminder that we have excluded the negative and the three zero eigenvalues from the sum .
thus , the argument of the exponential incorporates only the contributions from the stable vibrational modes on the bubble , very much like in langer s result @xcite .
substituting eq .
( [ eigenratio ] ) in ( [ gamma2 ] ) one obtains the following expression for the nucleation rate per unit volume , @xmath90 , as defined in eq .
( [ gamma ] ) : @xmath91 \ : , \label{endgamma}\ ] ] where we have denoted by @xmath92 the dimensionless factor @xmath93 note that the zero - mode contribution in the prefactor depends on the energy barrier of the critical nucleation , and not on its free energy as in eq .
( [ badrate ] ) . in eq .
( [ endgamma ] ) we have incorporated the exponential contribution from the prefactor into the definition of the temperature corrected nucleation barrier , which we call @xmath94 . within the thin - wall approximation
we can write @xmath95 where @xmath96 - \nonumber \\ & - & t \int \frac{d^{3 } k}{(2 \pi)^{3 } } \ln \left [ 1 - e^{- \beta \sqrt { \vec{k}^ { 2 } + m^{2}(\varphi_{t } ) } } \right ] \label{deltau}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath97 - \right .
\nonumber \\ & - & \left .
\sum_{i } \left [ \frac { \beta}{2 } e_{f}(i ) + \ln \left ( 1 - e^{- \beta e_{f}(i ) } \right ) \right ] \right\ } \ : . \label{sigmat}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in eq .
( [ deltau ] ) we have substituted the discrete sums by integrals over momenta . [ for field configurations @xmath45 and @xmath44 , we have the continuum eigenvalues , @xmath98 and @xmath99 , respectively , with @xmath100 and @xmath101 , from eq .
( [ deltau ] ) since they can always be handled by the introduction of the usual counterterms @xcite . in eq .
( [ sigmat ] ) @xmath102 are the eigenvalues related with the bubble wall field configuration @xmath77 .
thus , within the thin - wall approximation , the problem is reduced to the computation of these eigenvalues for a field configuration describing the bubble wall , a non - trivial task .
it is possible , however , that the temperature corrections to the surface density are negligible . for example , in the context of the qcd transition , the surface density is obtained from lattice calculations , and is shown not to be very sensitive to temperature @xcite .
it is easy to see from eq .
( [ deltau ] ) that @xmath103 is the usual 1-loop approximation to the finite temperature false vacuum energy density @xcite .
the second term in the right hand side of ( [ sigmat ] ) comes from the finite temperature 1-loop contribution to the surface tension @xmath76 , due to thermal fluctuations on the bubble wall .
thus , by exponentiating the contribution from the stable modes , the activation energy for the critical bubble becomes indeed an activation free energy .
note however , that contrary to eq .
( [ badrate ] ) , the free - energy functional is evaluated for the tree - level bounce . in section 4
we will compare the results obtained with the two approaches . a second approach to the computation of the determinantal prefactor in ( [ gamma2 ] ) consists in developing a perturbative expansion for it .
first we write the determinantal ratio as @xmath104^{\frac{1}{2 } } & = & \exp \left\ { \frac{1}{2 } { \rm tr } \ ; \ln \left[-\box_{e } + v''(\varphi_{f } ) \right]_{\beta } - \right .
\nonumber \\ & - & \left .
\frac{1}{2 } { \rm tr ' } \ ; \ln \left[-\box_{e } + v''(\varphi_{b } ) \right]_{\beta } \right\ } \ : , \label{fieldratio}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used in ( [ fieldratio ] ) the identity @xmath105 and the prime in both sides denote that the negative and the zero modes have been omitted .
( they are treated as in previous section . )
we rewrite ( [ fieldratio ] ) as @xmath106^{\frac{1}{2 } } = \exp \left\ { - \frac{1}{2 } { \rm tr } \ ; \ln \bigl [ 1 + g_{\beta}(\varphi_{f } ) \left [ v''(\varphi_{b } ) - v''(\varphi_{f } ) \right ] \bigr ] \right\ } \ : , \label{expratio}\ ] ] where @xmath107 is just the propagator for the scalar field @xmath9 , with @xmath108 . expanding the logarithm in ( [ expratio ] ) in powers of @xmath109 $ ]
, we obtain the graphic representation , @xmath110 \right \ } = \ols \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! \ !
+ \olr + \olk + \ : \ : \ldots \ : , \label{graphic}\ ] ] where the dashed lines correspond to the background `` field '' @xmath111 $ ] and the internal lines denote the propagator @xmath112 . the expression ( [ graphic ] )
can be written as @xmath113 \right\ } & = & \sum_{m=1}^{+ \infty } \frac { ( -1)^{m+1 } } { m } \int d^{3 } x \left[v''(\varphi_{b } ) - v''(\varphi_{f } ) \right]^{m } \times \nonumber \\ & \times & \sum_{n= -\infty}^{+ \infty } \int \frac { d^{3 } k } { ( 2 \pi)^{3 } } \frac{1 } { \left [ \omega_{n}^{2 } + \vec{k}^{2 } + m^{2}(\varphi_{f } ) \right]^{m } } \ : .
\label{traceln}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the sum in @xmath42 can be performed and one obtains @xmath114 \right\ } = \int d^{3 } x \sum_{n= -\infty}^{+ \infty } \int \frac { d^{3 } k } { ( 2 \pi)^{3 } } \ln \left [ 1 + \frac { v''(\varphi_{b } ) - v''(\varphi_{f } ) } { \omega_{n}^{2 } + \vec{k}^{2 } + m^{2}(\varphi_{f } ) } \right ] \ : .
\label{endtrln}\ ] ] this expression can be further simplified by means of the identity , ( @xmath115 , and @xmath116 ) @xmath117 & = & \beta e_{b}(\vec{k } ) + 2 \ln \left ( 1 - e^{- \beta e_{b}(\vec{k } ) } \right ) - \nonumber \\ & - & \beta e_{f}(\vec{k } ) - 2 \ln \left ( 1 - e^{- \beta e_{f}(\vec{k } ) } \right ) \ : .
\label{sumln}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the terms proportional to @xmath118 can be renormalized .
we are left with the familiar temperature corrected effective potential ( we neglect terms coming from zero temperature quantum corrections ) @xcite , @xmath119 within the thin - wall limit , using ( [ sumln ] ) into ( [ endtrln ] ) , and substituting into eq .
( [ expratio ] ) , we obtain , from eq .
( [ gamma2 ] ) the temperature corrected barrier , @xmath120 where @xmath121 \label{deltaveff}\ ] ] and @xmath122 \ : .
\label{fieldsigmat}\ ] ] expression ( [ deltaveff ] ) for the temperature corrected false vacuum energy density can be easily identified with @xmath103 , as defined in eq .
( [ deltau ] ) . also , expression ( [ fieldsigmat ] ) for @xmath123 can be identified with the temperature corrected surface tension of the bubble wall , by writing it as @xmath124 \ : , \label{defsigmat}\ ] ] with @xmath125 where @xmath126 is the free energy for the field configuration @xmath127 .
@xmath123 , as given by ( [ defsigmat ] ) , is then the free energy difference ( per unit area of the bubble ) between the two configurations ( @xmath77 and @xmath45 ) , which defines the surface tension . as shown in ref .
@xcite , the expressions for the free energies in ( [ defsigmat ] ) , at 1-loop order give ( [ fieldsigmat ] ) .
in the previous two sections we have obtained the temperature effects on the nucleation barrier by _ assuming _ that the system becomes trapped in a metastable phase as the temperature drops below the critical temperature @xmath13 . this assumption is not very realistic , and was addopted so that we could stress the main points of the calculation without having to worry about the effects of interactions of the order parameter with other fields .
however , in models of interest within a cosmological context , such as the standard electroweak model and some of its extensions , the universe becomes trapped in a metastable phase due to the interactions of the higgs field ( or effective scalar order parameter ) with other massless fields , such as gauge bosons or fermions .
in fact , it is possible to formulate this statement in terms of conditions that a general effective potential must satisfy , if it is to develop a metastable phase below @xmath13 @xcite .
basically , the condition states that the mass gap between the symmetric and broken - symmetric phases must be large enough so that massive fluctuations away from the symmetric minimum are suppressed .
since the mass gap is given in terms of the ( temperature dependent ) vacuum expectation value of the higgs field and of its coupling to other fields , the condition states that the transition can not be too weakly first order .
the question then is what effective potential should be considered when calculating the decay rate . as recently shown by e. weinberg for the zero - temperature coleman - weinberg models ( which exhibit symmetry breaking only due to radiative corrections ) , the effective potential relevant in the calculation of the bounce solution
is obtained by integrating over all fields _ but _ the scalar field ; the radiative corrections coming form these fields modify the vacuum structure of the model , making metastability possible . in this section
, we argue that the same procedure must be followed when calculating the nucleation rate at finite temperature .
we first review , in general terms , how to take into account the interactions of the scalar field with other fields in the calculation of the decay rate .
( for details see , ref . @xcite . )
then we apply our method to an example involving fermions , explicitly comparing our results to those obtained from eq .
( [ badrate ] ) .
let us consider a system described by a scalar field @xmath9 and a set of fields @xmath128 ( bosonic or fermionic fields ) which are coupled to @xmath9 .
the partition function of the system is given by @xmath129 where @xmath130 is the euclidean action of the system and the functional integration is carried over field configurations subject to periodic boundary conditions , @xmath131 , for bosons or antiperiodic , @xmath132 , for fermion fields .
if one integrates out the @xmath128 fields in ( [ zphixi ] ) , the partition function can be written as @xmath133 where @xmath134 @xmath135 can be viewed as an effective action for the scalar field @xmath9 , where only @xmath128-loop terms are included .
note that these @xmath128-loop terms introduce finite temperature corrections in ( [ wfunc ] ) .
@xmath136 in ( [ zphixi ] ) and ( [ wfunc ] ) includes renormalization counter - terms and , if one or more of the @xmath128-fields is a gauge field , @xmath137 also includes the gauge fixings and the corresponding ghost terms .
the procedure is now , in principle , straightforward .
we evaluate the partition function in eq .
( [ zwphi ] ) semiclassically by expanding the effective action @xmath135 around its extremum configuration , which will be the bounce .
note that the bounce will include the radiative corrections coming from the fields that couple to @xmath9 , _ but not from @xmath9 itself . _ the determinantal prefactor can be evaluated as before , by considering the negative and zero eigenvalues separately from the positive eigenvalues . however , as pointed out by weinberg @xcite , @xmath135 can not always be obtained in closed form , being in general a nonlocal functional .
he proposes to resolve this difficulty by considering a local action @xmath138 which is close enough to the original one . from a derivative expansion of @xmath135 , @xmath139
is found to be @xmath140 \ : , \label{wphi0}\ ] ] where @xmath141 includes the tree level potential @xmath142 and the 1-loop contributions coming _ only _ from the @xmath128-field integration .
the bounce solution can then be obtained from ( [ wphi0 ] ) .
@xmath139 should be a good approximation to @xmath135 as long as the typical interaction length scale set by the field(s ) @xmath128 is shorter than the scale for the nonlocality of @xmath135 . in what follows
we will apply the above formalism to a specific example of a scalar field coupled to fermions . for large enough yukawa couplings
, this model has been shown to satisfy the conditions for metastability specified in ref .
[ gleiser ] . consider a model of a real scalar field @xmath9 coupled to fermion fields with a lagrangian density @xmath143 with @xmath142 given by @xmath144 where @xmath145 and @xmath146 are positive , dimensionless constants and @xmath147 is a ( mass)@xmath148 parameter .
a large enough coupling to fermions guarantees that a metastable phase is possible as the system is cooled below @xmath13 ; the high temperature minimum of the 1-loop effective potential , @xmath149 , lies to the left of the maximum of the potential at @xmath150 , and thermal fluctuations away from the symmetric minimum are suppressed .
numerical values for the couplings satisfying these conditions can be found in ref .
[ gleiser ] . the partition function for this model
is given by @xmath151 as the fermion fields appear quadratically in ( [ zphipsi ] ) , they can be integrated out , giving @xmath152 where @xmath153 - { \rm tr } \ln ( - \not{\ ! \partial } - i g \phi)_{\beta } \ : , \label{wbetaphi}\ ] ] and @xmath154 thus , @xmath139 can be written as @xmath155 \ : , \label{wbeta}\ ] ] where , for sufficiently smooth fields ( see appendix b ) , the effective potential obtained after integrating over the fermions and renormalizing is ( we will drop all zero temperature quantum corrections ) @xmath156 the temperature dependent term accounts for finite temperature corrections coming from fermion loops .
@xmath157 is the potential we should use to compute the bounce .
note that , neglecting the @xmath158 quantum corrections , the high - temperature limit of @xmath157 is approximately @xmath159 so that for @xmath160 , a condition which is easily satisfied for reasonable values of the couplings , the high - temperature minimum is @xmath161 .
once we have the action @xmath139 , the bounce is obtained as a solution of @xmath162 thus , for a static , spherically symmetric configuration , the bounce configuration @xmath6 will be a solution of @xmath163 with boundary conditions , @xmath164 and @xmath165 .
( from now on @xmath45 and @xmath44 should be understood as being the minima of ( [ vbetaphi ] ) and not the minima of the tree - level potential @xmath166 . )
the procedure is now identical to that of sections 2 and 3 . having a bounce solution we can evaluate the partition function written in eq .
( [ zwscalar ] ) semiclassically , exactly as was done in eqs .
( [ zphib ] ) and ( [ zphif ] ) , by expanding around @xmath167 and @xmath168 .
we then obtain , from eqs .
( [ energy ] ) and ( [ gamma ] ) , the nucleation rate , @xmath169^{-\frac{1}{2 } } e^{- \delta w_0 } \ : , \label{gammaw}\ ] ] where @xmath170 , with @xmath171 obtained above .
@xmath172 is given by @xmath173 where @xmath174 was defined in eq .
( [ wbeta ] ) . in order to proceed , we must rewrite the determinantal prefactor explicitly isolating the negative and zero modes from the positive modes .
this is done following the same steps of section 3 , although now we must handle the fermionic contribution to the determinants .
the details of the perturbative expansion for the fermionic determinantal prefactor are given in appendix b. we can then write the nucleation rate per unit volume as @xmath175^{\frac{3}{2 } } \exp \left [ - \frac { \delta f(t ) } { t } \right ] \ : , \label{endgammaw}\ ] ] where @xmath94 , the bubble activation free energy in the 1-loop approximation , is given by @xmath176 \right\ } \ : .
\label{dft}\ ] ] as usual , the sum over @xmath177 can be performed and we get , @xmath178 \ : , \label{veff}\ ] ] where the effective potential @xmath179 , is given by ( neglecting zero temperature quantum corrections ) @xmath180 where @xmath166 is the tree level potential ( [ vphi ] ) and the mass term appearing in the scalar loop contribution is @xmath181 in leading order in the fermion loops .
it is instructive to contrast this result with that obtained for self - coupled scalars , eq .
( [ veffren ] ) .
the coupling to fermions modifies the scalar mass propagating in the loops .
this effect naturally improves the infrared behavior of the theory , and can be of importance in weak first - order transitions .
we will say more about this later .
note also a crucial difference between this expression for the free energy barrier and the expression for the free energy barrier in eq .
( [ badrate ] ) : here , the bounce is obtained with the effective potential that does not include the corrections coming from scalar loops .
the corrections from scalar loops which appear in the last term of eq .
( [ hatveff ] ) are thermally induced fluctuations about the bounce solution computed with @xmath182 . in the usual expression for the nucleation barrier
the bounce is obtained from the full effective potential including the scalar loops .
the two expressions are definetely not equivalent , even though for small scalar self - couplings the differences are negligible . in order to illustrate the differences
let us look at a specific example . in fig .
2 we contrast the two approaches by comparing the nucleation barriers as a function of the temperature for a fixed set of coupling constants .
the barriers in the figure were obtained by a numerical integration of the bounce equation including the relevant loops according to each approach . for clarity
let us call the nucleation barrier obtained in the usual approach , _
i.e. _ , by including the scalar loops in the bounce calculation , the scalar barrier .
the nucleation barrier obtained without including the scalar loops we call the fermionic barrier . in fig .
2 we take @xmath183 , and @xmath184 . since @xmath145 controls the strength of the scalar corrections ,
we expect the differences between the two barriers to be noticeable .
we find that this is indeed the case , noting that as we approach the critical temperature ( that is , as we move closer to the thin - wall limit ) the differences between the two barriers increase , with the scalar barrier _ always larger _ than the fermionic barrier .
this is precisely what one expects if the scalar corrections are entropic corrections to the nucleation barrier .
thus , the nucleation barrier used in expression eq .
( [ badrate ] ) is overestimated for large enough scalar corrections .
finally , we point out two additional differences between the results .
first note that the contribution from the zero modes to the prefactor depends on @xmath185 , as opposed to @xmath94 .
this could be important for weak transitions in which the prefactor may play a relevant rle .
most importantly , the expression for @xmath186 , eq .
( [ hatveff ] ) , differs from the usual 1-loop finite temperature effective potential by the mass term for the scalar field loops , @xmath187 .
since we have used the stationary points of @xmath139 , eq .
( [ wbeta ] ) , as opposed to the stationary points of @xmath188 , as the effective `` background '' fields in the saddle - point evaluation of the partition function , the scalar field propagator carries the finite temperature mass @xmath189 .
the propagator is dressed by the quantum corrections due to fermion loops . in the usual 1-loop finite temperature
effective potential , the stationary points are obtained from the tree level action , with mass term for scalar loops , @xmath190 .
this results in the usual negative mass terms related to the change in convexity of the effective potential between the inflection points , and , in the case of very shallow potentials , in bad infrared behavior near @xmath8 .
the incorporation of the fermionic corrections to the scalar propagator , which is demanded by our method of calculation atenuates these problems . in the example above , the scalar mass gets dressed by fermionic loops , being given by @xmath191 , where @xmath166 is the tree - level potential ( [ vphi ] ) .
the temperature term in @xmath192 works as the infrared regulator for small values of @xmath190 .
this result is independent of the particular model studied .
similar conclusions have been obtained in ref .
@xcite for scalar electrodynamics .
in this paper we examined in some detail the computation of false vacuum decay rates at finite temperatures in the regime in which quantum fluctuations are negligibly small compared to thermal fluctuations .
we have shown that temperature corrections to the nucleation barrier can be obtained from a saddle - point evaluation of the partition function in a dilute gas approximation .
in fact , the temperature corrections are simply due to the positive eigenvalues from stable fluctuations around the critical bubble .
that is , they are the entropic contributions due to thermally induced deformations on the bubble . even though this result has been known in classical statistical mechanics for more than two decades @xcite , we believe that a consistent treatment within field theory is still lacking .
although we left many questions unanswered , we hope to have clarified some of the issues involved in the calculation of finite - temperature decay rates . of particular importance
is the fact that the bounce is _ not _ obtained from the full 1-loop corrected effective potential , but from the potential excluding the scalar loops .
thus , for a self - interacting scalar , the bounce is obtained from the tree - level potential .
the full finite temperature potential appears in the exponent only after properly accounting for the positive eigenvalues of the determinantal prefactor .
that is , the scalar contributions account for entropic corrections to the nucleation barrier .
we obtained a temperature corrected nucleation barrier which can differ from the usual result .
we showed this to be particularly true for sufficiently large scalar self - couplings in the vicinity of the critical temperature for the transition .
also , we found that the interaction with other fields gives rise to a potential which is better behaved in the infrared .
( see also ref .
this result is the finite - temperature equivalent to what e. weinberg found for the zero - temperature case , once the integration over the other fields is performed @xcite .
the reader may be wondering if our results will have any consequences to current work on the electroweak phase transition .
the answer depends on the higgs mass . for a sufficiently light higgs
it is consistent to neglect the contribution from scalar loops to the effective potential . in this case , the usual estimate for the nucleation barrier is a valid approximation .
however , the situation may change for a heavier higgs .
given that the experimental lower bound on the higgs mass is now above 60 gev , we believe it worthwhile to study this question in more detail , keeping in mind that the transition becomes weaker as the higgs mass increases .
we would like to thank a. linde for many important discussions on these and related issues .
we would like to thank the institute for theoretical physics in santa barbara where , during the program on cosmological phase transitions , this work begun . at itp
this work was supported in part by a national science foundation grant no .
phy89 - 04035 at itp .
( mg ) was supported in part by a national science foundation grant no .
( gcm ) aknowledges financial support from fapesp ( so paulo , brazil ) and ( ror ) from conselho nacional de desenvolvimento cientfico e tecnolgico - cnpq ( brazil ) .
* figure 1 : * a typical asymmetric double - well potential . + * figure 2 : * a comparison of the nucleation barrier as a function of temperature , in units of mass parameter @xmath193 , obtained by including ( stars ) and excluding ( dots ) scalar loops in the computation of the bounce . the parameters in the tree - level potential are @xmath194 . + * figure 3 : * a comparison of the terms @xmath195 and @xmath196 appearing in appendix b. the parameters in the tree - level potential are @xmath197 .
+ where the prime in @xmath199 means that the negative eigenvalue , @xmath200 , and the three zero eigenvalues , @xmath201 , are now excluded from the product . the term for @xmath202 in @xmath203 , can be handled as in ref .
@xcite , resulting in the factor @xmath204^{\frac{3}{2}}$ ] in eq .
( [ eigenratio ] ) . separating the @xmath202 modes both in the numerator and the denominator of ( [ aratio ] ) , and using the identity ( [ idenpi ] ) , we get , @xmath205^{\frac{3}{2 } } \exp\left\{\left(-4 + \sum_{i } - \sum_{j}\ ; ' \right ) { \rm ln } \prod_{n=1}^{+\infty } \omega_{n}^{2 } - { \rm ln } \left ( e_{-}^{2 } \right)^{1/2 } - { \rm ln } \left [ \frac{\sin(\frac{\beta}{2 } |e_{-}|)}{\frac{\beta}{2 } |e_{-}| } \right ] + \right .
& + & \left . \left(\sum_{j}\
; ' - \sum_{i}\right ) { \rm ln } \beta + \sum_{i } \left [ \frac{\beta}{2 } e_{f}(i ) + { \rm ln } \left ( 1 - e^{- \beta e_{f}(i ) } \right ) \right ] + \right .
\nonumber \\ & - & \left .
\sum_{j } \ ; ' \left [ \frac{\beta}{2 } e_{b}(j ) + { \rm ln } \left ( 1 - e^{- \beta e_{b}(j ) } \right ) \right ] \right\ } \ : .
\label{aexplicity}\end{aligned}\ ] ] & + & \left .
\sum_{i } \left [ \frac{\beta}{2 } e_{f}(i ) + { \rm ln } \left ( 1 - e^{- \beta e_{f}(i ) } \right ) \right ] - \sum_{j } \ ; ' \left [ \frac{\beta}{2 } e_{b}(j ) + { \rm ln } \left ( 1 - e^{- \beta e_{b}(j ) } \right ) \right ] \right\ } \label{aendexplicitly}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath213^{2 } & = & \det ( - \not{\ ! \partial } -i g \varphi).\det ( - \not{\ ! \partial } +
i g \varphi ) = \nonumber \\ & = & \det \left [ ( -\box_{e } + g^{2 } \varphi^{2 } ) 1_{4 \times 4 } - i g \gamma_{e}^{\mu } \partial_{\mu } \varphi \right ] \ : , \label{bident}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath227_{\beta } + { \rm tr } \ln \left [ - \box_{e } + g^{2 } \varphi_{b}^{2 } - g \frac { \partial \varphi_{b}}{\partial r } \right]_{\beta } - \right .
\nonumber \\ & - & \left . 2 { \rm tr } \ln \left [ - \box_{e } + g^{2 } \varphi_{f}^{2 } \right]_{\beta } \right\ } \ : .
\label{bdetbf}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath228 \right ] + \right .
\nonumber \\ & + & \left . { \rm tr } \ln \left [ 1 + s_{\beta}(\varphi_{f } ) \left [ g^{2 } ( \varphi_{b}^{2 } - \varphi_{f}^{2 } ) - g \frac
{ \partial \varphi_{b}}{\partial r } \right ] \right ] \right\ } \ : , \label{bexpratio}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath230 \right ] & = & \sum_{m= 1}^{+ \infty } \frac{(-1)^{m+1}}{m } \int d^{3}x \left [ g^{2 } ( \varphi_{b}^{2 } - \varphi_{f}^{2 } ) \pm g \frac
{ \partial \varphi_{b}}{\partial r } \right]^{m } \times \nonumber \\ & \times & \sum_{n= -\infty}^{+ \infty } \int \frac{d^{3 } k } { ( 2 \pi)^{3 } } \frac{1 } { \left [ \bar{\omega}_{n}^{2 } + \vec{k}^{2 } + g^{2 } \varphi_{f}^{2 } \right]^{m } } \ : , \label{btraceln}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath231 . as before , ( [ btraceln ] ) can be expressed as a graphic expansion similar to ( [ graphic ] ) , with the propagators @xmath112 replaced now by @xmath232 and the external lines given by @xmath233 or @xmath234 .
the determinant factor in ( [ gammaw ] ) , coming from the functional integration of the scalar field , can be evaluated by the same methods of sec .
3 . in ( [ gammaw ] ) , the determinant term @xmath235_{\beta}$ ] , with @xmath236 , has a negative eigenvalue , @xmath200 , associated with the instability of the critical bubble , and the three zero eigenvalues , associated with the translational invariance of the bubble .
these eigenvalues can be handled as usual , giving the preexponential term in ( [ endgammaw ] ) .
the part of the determinant involving the positive eigenvalues can be written as an expansion exactly as in ( [ traceln ] ) , @xmath237^{- \frac{1}{2 } } = \exp \left\ { - \frac{1}{2 } { \rm tr } \ ; \ln \bigl [ 1 + \hat{g}_{\beta}(\varphi_{f } ) \left [ \hat{v}_{\psi}''(\varphi_{b } ) - \hat{v}_{\psi}''(\varphi_{f } ) \right ] \bigr ] \right\ } \ : , \label{bdetbos}\ ] ] @xmath239 \right\ } & = & \sum_{m=1}^{+ \infty } \frac { ( -1)^{m+1 } } { m } \int d^{3 } x \left[\hat{v}_{\psi}''(\varphi_{b } ) - \hat{v}_{\psi}''(\varphi_{f } ) \right]^{m } \times \nonumber \\ & \times & \sum_{n= -\infty}^{+ \infty } \int \frac { d^{3 } k } { ( 2 \pi)^{3 } } \frac{1 } { \left [ \omega_{n}^{2 } + \vec{k}^{2 } + m_{\beta}^{2 } ( \varphi_{f } ) \right]^{m } } \ : .
\label{btrlnw}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the sum in @xmath42 in both ( [ btraceln ] ) and ( [ btrlnw ] ) can be performed as in eq .
( [ traceln ] ) ) .
therefore , from eqs .
( [ bexpw ] ) , ( [ btraceln ] ) and ( [ btrlnw ] ) , we can write the relevant part of eq .
( [ gammaw ] ) as @xmath240^{- \frac{1}{2 } } e^{- \delta w_0 } = \left [ \frac { \det ( -\box_{e } + \hat{v}_{\psi}''(\varphi_{b}))_{\beta } } { \det ( -\box_{e } + \hat{v}_{\psi}''(\varphi_{f}))_{\beta } } \right]^{- \frac{1}{2 } } \ : \ : \frac { \det ( - \not{\ ! \partial } - i g \varphi_{b } ) _ { \beta } } { \det ( - \not{\ ! \partial } - i g \varphi_{f } ) _ { \beta } } \ : \ : e^{-\delta s } = } \nonumber \\ & & = { \cal v}\frac{t^{4}}{i |e_{-}| } \frac{\beta \frac{|e_{-}|}{2 } } { \sin \left ( \beta \frac{|e_{-}|}{2 } \right ) } \left [ \frac{\delta w_0 } { 2 \pi } \right]^{\frac{3}{2 } } \exp \left\ { - \delta s + \int d^{3 } x \sum_{n= -\infty}^{+ \infty } \int \frac{d^3 k}{(2 \pi)^3 } \left [ \ln \left ( 1 + \frac{g^2 ( \vp_{b}^{2 } - \vp_{f}^{2 } ) + g \frac{\partial \vp_{b}}{\partial r}}{\bar{\omega}_{n}^{2 } + \vec{k}^2 + g^2 \vp_{f}^{2 } } \right ) + \right .
\nonumber \\ & & + \left . \left .
\ln \left ( 1 + \frac{g^2 ( \vp_{b}^{2 } - \vp_{f}^{2 } ) - g \frac{\partial \vp_{b}}{\partial r}}{\bar{\omega}_{n}^{2 } + \vec{k}^2 + g^2 \vp_{f}^{2 } } \right ) - \frac{1}{2 } \ln \left ( 1 + \frac{m_{\beta}^2 ( \vp_{b } ) - m_{\beta}^{2 } ( \vp_{f}^{2 } ) } { \omega_{n}^{2 } + \vec{k}^2 + m_{\beta}^{2 } ( \vp_{f}^{2 } ) } \right ) \right ] \right\ } \ : , \label{bdeterminantal}\end{aligned}\ ] ] apart from the derivative terms @xmath243 , the momentum integral reproduces the finite temperature corrections to the the tree - level potential appearing in @xmath67 . when we wrote the expression for @xmath244 in eq .
( [ dft ] ) , these terms were not included in the effective potential @xmath245 .
there are two reasons for negleting this term .
first , due to the graphic expansion we used for the determinants , it is easy to see that at least at the tadpole level , their contribution cancels .
since the tadpole gives the dominant temperature contribution to the potential , terms that depend on @xmath243 will be sub - dominant .
second , it is possible to explicitly compare the terms @xmath246 and @xmath247 , by obtaining @xmath6 numerically .
we have performed this comparison for the same set of parameters used in figs . 2 and 3 , and convinced ourselves that the derivative term will indeed be sub - dominant .
a typical example is shown in fig .
neglecting the term @xmath243 , we can use eqs .
( [ bdeterminantal ] ) and ( [ finaldeltaw ] ) to obtain the expression for @xmath94 in ( [ dft ] ) .
m. gleiser and e. w. kolb , _ phys .
lett . _ * 69 * , 1304 ( 1992 ) ; fermilab preprint no .
pub-92/222-a ; _ int .
phys . _ * c3 * , 773 ( 1992 ) ; m. gleiser , e. w. kolb , and r. watkins , _ nucl .
phys . _ * b364 * , 411 ( 1991 ) . c. a. carvalho , g. c. marques , a. j. silva and i. ventura , _ nucl .
* b265 * , 45 ( 1986 ) ; c. a. carvalho , d. bazeia , o. j. p. eboli , g. c. marques , a. j. silva and i. ventura _ phys . rev . _ * d31 * , 1411 ( 1985 ) ; | we examine the computation of the nucleation barrier used in the expression for false vacuum decay rates in finite temperature field theory . by a detailed analysis of the determinantal prefactor
, we show that the correct bounce solution used in the computation of the nucleation barrier should not include loop corrections coming from the scalar field undergoing decay .
temperature corrections to the bounce appear from loop contributions from other fields coupled to the scalar field .
we compute the nucleation barrier for a model of scalar fields coupled to fermions , and compare our results to the expression commonly used in the literature .
we find that , for large enough self - couplings , the inclusion of scalar loops in the expression of the nucleation barrier leads to an underestimate of the decay rate in the neighborhood of the critical temperature .
pacs number(s ) : 98.80.cq , 64.60.qb .
+ e - mail : [email protected] ; [email protected] ; [email protected] . |
when two systems are immersed in an environment , then , besides and at the same time with the quantum decoherence phenomenon , the environment can also generate a quantum entanglement of the two systems @xcite . in certain circumstances , the environment enhances the entanglement and in others it suppresses the entanglement and the state describing the two systems becomes separable .
the structure of the environment may be such that not only the two systems become entangled , but also such that the entanglement is maintained for a definite time or a certain amount of entanglement survives in the asymptotic long - time regime . in the present paper we investigate , in the framework of the theory of open systems based on completely positive quantum dynamical semigroups , the dynamics of the continuous - variable entanglement for a subsystem composed of two identical harmonic oscillators interacting with an environment .
we are interested in discussing the correlation effect of the environment , therefore we assume that the two systems are independent , i.e. they do not interact directly .
the initial state of the subsystem is taken of gaussian form and the evolution under the quantum dynamical semigroup assures the preservation in time of the gaussian form of the state .
the organizing of the paper is as follows . in sec .
2 we write and solve the equations of motion in the heisenberg picture for two independent harmonic oscillators interacting with a general environment . then , by using the peres - simon necessary and sufficient condition for separability of two - mode gaussian states @xcite , we investigate in sec .
3 the dynamics of entanglement for the considered subsystem . in particular , with the help of the asymptotic covariance matrix , we determine the behaviour of the entanglement in the limit of long times .
we show that for certain classes of environments the initial state evolves asymptotically to an equilibrium state which is entangled , while for other values of the parameters describing the environment , the entanglement is suppressed and the asymptotic state is separable .
a summary is given in sec .
we study the dynamics of the subsystem composed of two identical non - interacting oscillators in weak interaction with an environment . in the axiomatic formalism based on completely positive quantum dynamical semigroups , the irreversible time evolution of an open system
is described by the following general quantum markovian master equation for an operator @xmath0 ( heisenberg representation ) @xcite : @xmath1+{1\over 2\hbar}\sum_j(v_j^{\dagger}[a(t ) , v_j]+[v_j^{\dagger},a(t)]v_j).\label{masteq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath2 denotes the hamiltonian of the open system and the operators @xmath3 defined on the hilbert space of @xmath4 represent the interaction of the open system with the environment .
being interested in the set of gaussian states , we introduce such quantum dynamical semigroups that preserve this set .
therefore @xmath2 is taken to be a polynomial of second degree in the coordinates @xmath5 and momenta @xmath6 of the two quantum oscillators and @xmath7 are taken polynomials of first degree in these canonical observables . then in the linear space spanned by the coordinates and momenta there exist only four linearly independent operators @xmath8 @xcite : @xmath9 where @xmath10 the hamiltonian @xmath2 of the two uncoupled identical harmonic oscillators of mass @xmath11 and frequency @xmath12 is given by @xmath13 the fact that the evolution is given by a dynamical semigroup implies the positivity of the following matrix formed by the scalar products of the four vectors @xmath14 whose entries are the components @xmath15 respectively : @xmath16 we take this matrix of the following form , where all coefficients @xmath17 ... and @xmath18 are real quantities ( we put , for simplicity , @xmath19 ) : @xmath20 it follows that the principal minors of this matrix are positive or zero . from the cauchy - schwarz inequality the following relations for the coefficients defined in eq .
( [ coef ] ) hold : @xmath21 the matrix of the coefficients ( [ coef ] ) can be conveniently written as @xmath22 in terms of @xmath23 matrices @xmath24 , @xmath25 and @xmath26 .
this decomposition has a direct physical interpretation : the elements containing the diagonal contributions @xmath27 and @xmath28 represent diffusion and dissipation coefficients corresponding to the first , respectively the second , system in absence of the other , while the elements in @xmath29 represent environment generated couplings between the two , initially independent , oscillators . we introduce the following @xmath30 bimodal covariance matrix : @xmath31 with the correlations of operators @xmath32 and @xmath33 defined by using the density operator @xmath34 , describing the initial state of the quantum system , as follows : @xmath35 by direct calculation we obtain @xcite ( @xmath36 denotes the transposed matrix ) : @xmath37 where @xmath38 the time - dependent solution of eq .
( [ vareq ] ) is given by @xcite @xmath39 where the matrix @xmath40 has to fulfill the condition @xmath41 in order that this limit exists , @xmath42 must only have eigenvalues with negative real parts .
the values at infinity are obtained from the equation @xcite @xmath43
the two - mode gaussian state is entirely specified by its covariance matrix ( [ covar ] ) , which is a real , symmetric and positive matrix with the following block structure : @xmath44 where @xmath0 , @xmath45 and @xmath46 are @xmath23 matrices .
their entries are correlations of the canonical operators @xmath47 , @xmath0 and @xmath45 denote the symmetric covariance matrices for the individual reduced one - mode states , while the matrix @xmath46 contains the cross - correlations between modes .
the elements of the covariance matrix depend on @xmath42 and @xmath48 and can be calculated from eqs .
( [ covart ] ) , ( [ covarinf ] ) .
since the two oscillators are identical , it is natural to consider environments for which the two diagonal submatrices in eq .
( [ subm ] ) are equal , @xmath49 and the matrix @xmath29 is symmetric , so that in the following we take @xmath50 then both unimodal covariance matrices are equal , @xmath51 and the entanglement matrix @xmath46 is symmetric .
first we analyze the existence of entanglement in the limit of large times . with the chosen coefficients ,
we obtain from eq .
( [ covarinf ] ) the following elements of the asymptotic entanglement matrix @xmath52 : @xmath53 @xmath54 @xmath55 the elements of matrices @xmath56 and @xmath57 are obtained by putting @xmath58 in the previous expressions .
we calculate the determinant of the entanglement matrix and obtain : @xmath59.\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is interesting that the general theory of open quantum systems allows couplings via the environment between uncoupled oscillators .
according to the definitions of the environment parameters , the diffusion coefficients above can be different from zero and therefore can simulate an interaction between the uncoupled oscillators .
indeed , gaussian states with @xmath60 are separable states , but for @xmath61 it may be possible that the asymptotic equilibrium states are entangled , as will be shown next .
on general grounds , one expects that the effects of decoherence , counteracting entanglement production , be dominant in the long - time regime , so that no quantum correlation ( entanglement ) is expected to be left at infinity .
nevertheless , there are situations in which the environment allows the presence of entangled asymptotic equilibrium states . in order to investigate whether an external environment can actually entangle the two independent systems , we use the partial transposition criterion @xcite
: a state is entangled if and only if the operation of partial transposition does not preserve its positivity .
for the particular case of gaussian states , simon @xcite obtained the following necessary and sufficient criterion for separability : @xmath62 where @xmath63- \frac{1}{4}(\det a+\det b ) \label{sim1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath64 is the @xmath23 symplectic matrix @xmath65 in the following we consider an environment characterized by diffusion coefficients of the form @xmath66 this corresponds to the case when the asymptotic state is a gibbs state @xcite .
then simon expression ( [ sim1 ] ) takes the following form in the limit of large times : @xmath67 for environments characterized by such coefficients that the expression @xmath68 ( [ sim2 ] ) is strictly negative , the asymptotic final state is entangled . in particular , for @xmath69 we obtain that @xmath70 i.e. the asymptotic final state is entangled , for the following range of values of the coefficient @xmath71 characterizing the environment @xcite : @xmath72 where the diffusion coefficient @xmath73 satisfies the condition @xmath74 equivalent with the unimodal uncertainty relation .
we remind that , according to inequalities ( [ coefineq ] ) , the coefficients have to fulfill also the constraint @xmath75 if the coefficients do not fulfil the inequalities ( [ insep ] ) , then @xmath76 and the asymptotic state of the considered system is separable .
we apply the measure of entanglement based on negative eigenvalues of the partial transpose of the subsystem density matrix . for a gaussian density operator ,
the negativity is completely defined by the symplectic spectrum of the partial transpose of the covariance matrix . the logarithmic negativity @xmath77 $ ] determines the strength of entanglement for @xmath78 if @xmath79
then the state is separable . here
@xmath80 ^ 2-\det\sigma}\right)^{1/2}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in our case
the asymptotic logarithmic negativity has the form @xmath81.\end{aligned}\ ] ] it depends only on the diffusion and dissipation coefficients characterizing the environment and does not depend on the initial gaussian state . as an example , in figure 1 we represent the asymptotic logarithmic negativity @xmath82 versus diffusion coefficients @xmath83 and @xmath84 we notice that for some range of these coefficients , @xmath82 takes strictly positive values , measuring the degree of entanglement of the corresponding asymptotic entangled states .
again , the coefficients have to fulfill the constraint @xmath85 so that in figure 1 only the part of the plot corresponding to @xmath86 has a physical meaning for our model . in order to describe the dynamics of entanglement
, we have to analyze the time evolution of the simon function ( [ sim1 ] ) .
we consider separately the two cases , according to the type of the initial gaussian state : separable or entangled .
\1 ) to illustrate a possible generation of the entanglement , we represent in figure 2 the function @xmath87 versus time and diffusion coefficient @xmath88 for a separable initial gaussian state with initial correlations @xmath89 we notice that , according to peres - simon criterion , for relatively small absolute values of the coefficient @xmath90 the initial separable state remains separable for all times , while for larger absolute values of @xmath90 at some finite moment of time the state becomes entangled . in some cases
the entanglement is only temporarily generated and the state becomes again separable after a certain moment of time .
in other cases , namely for even larger absolute values of the coefficient @xmath90 the generated entangled state remains entangled forever , including the asymptotic final state .
\2 ) the evolution of an entangled initial state is illustrated in figure 3 , where we represent the function @xmath87 versus time and diffusion coefficient @xmath91 for an initial entangled gaussian state with initial correlations @xmath92 we notice that for relatively large absolute values of the coefficient @xmath90 the initial entangled state remains entangled for all times , while for smaller absolute values of @xmath90 at some finite moment of time the state becomes separable .
this is the well - known phenomenon of entanglement sudden death .
depending on the values of the coefficient @xmath91 , it is also possible to have a repeated collapse and revival of the entanglement .
in the framework of the theory of open quantum systems based on completely positive quantum dynamical semigroups , we investigated the existence of the quantum entanglement for a subsystem composed of two uncoupled identical harmonic oscillators interacting with a general environment . by using the peres - simon necessary and sufficient condition for separability of two - mode gaussian states ,
we have described the generation and evolution of entanglement in terms of the covariance matrix for an arbitrary gaussian input state .
for some values of diffusion and dissipation coefficients describing the environment , the state keeps for all times its initial type : separable or entangled . in other cases , entanglement generation or entanglement collapse ( entanglement sudden death ) take place or even one can notice a repeated collapse and revival of entanglement .
we have also shown that , independent of the type of the initial state , for certain classes of environments the initial state evolves asymptotically to an equilibrium state which is entangled , while for other values of the coefficients describing the environment , the asymptotic state is separable .
we determined also the logarithmic negativity characterizing the degree of entanglement of the asymptotic state .
the existence of quantum correlations between the two considered harmonic oscillators interacting with a common environment is the result of the competition between entanglement and quantum decoherence . due to the increased interest manifested towards the continuous - variable approach to quantum information theory , these results , in particular the possibility of maintaining a bipartite entanglement in a diffusive - dissipative environment for asymptotic long times , might be useful in controlling the entanglement in open systems and also for applications in quantum information processing and communication .
the author acknowledges the financial support received within the project ceex 68/2005 . | in the framework of the theory of open systems based on completely positive quantum dynamical semigroups , we give a description of the continuous - variable entanglement for a system consisting of two independent harmonic oscillators interacting with a general environment . using peres - simon necessary and sufficient criterion for separability of two - mode gaussian states , we describe the generation and evolution of entanglement in terms of the covariance matrix for an arbitrary gaussian input state .
for some values of diffusion and dissipation coefficients describing the environment , the state keeps for all times its initial type : separable or entangled . in other cases , entanglement generation or entanglement collapse ( entanglement sudden death ) take place or even a periodic collapse and revival of entanglement .
we show that for certain classes of environments the initial state evolves asymptotically to an entangled equilibrium bipartite state , while for other values of the coefficients describing the environment , the asymptotic state is separable .
we calculate also the logarithmic negativity characterizing the degree of entanglement of the asymptotic state . |
in the last 20 years and especially in the most recent ones , considerable progress has been achieved both theoretically and experimentally in the investigation of nuclear reaction dynamics and thermodynamics in the fermi energy regime @xcite . from a theoretical point of view
, strong efforts have been devoted to the understanding of the nuclear equation of state ( eos ) either with transport theories or statistical approaches . from an experimental point of view
new generation @xmath2 detectors have been developed and are now operating at different accelerator facilities ( dubna , ganil , gsi , lnl , lns , msu , texas a - m ) .
they are producing a huge amount of exclusive data and new kind of analyses .
very rich information has already been extracted from experimental studies on intermediate energy heavy ion collisions .
experiments have shown that the final state can be constrained to select the dynamics of the collision and isolate events that populate states closely compatible with equilibrium .
several investigations have demonstrated that excited nuclear systems produced in such collisions undergo in a short time scale ( 100 fm / c ) bulk multifragmentation characterized by final states containing several intermediate mass fragments ( imf,@xmath3 3 ) .
a considerable progress has been accomplished on the theoretical as well as on the experimental side in order to define and collect a converging ensemble of signals connecting multifragmentation to the nuclear liquid - gas phase transition @xcite and locating it in the phase diagram of nuclear matter @xcite .
the opening of the high fragment multiplicity channel , the onset of collective expansion , the flattening of the caloric curves , the fossile signal of spinodal decomposition , a negative branch of the heat capacity , the bimodal distribution of exclusive observables and the finite size and fisher law scalings have been observed and tentatively related to the equation of state of the nuclear matter .
the possibility of new radioactive beams ( rib ) facilities is now prompting exciting theoretical advances of the isospin aspects of the eos , like the density dependence of the symmetry energy and the modifications to the spinodal instability @xcite .
experimentally , first studies on the dependence of the isoscaling parameters on the isospin of the decaying system @xcite already started exploiting stable beams .
these works seem to indicate an isospin distillation in asymmetric systems .
all these signals can be considered as circumstantial evidences of a phase transition , but some of them are still controversial and need to be further experimentally investigated before the phase transition can be definitely assessed .
this work is a contribution to this aim , but only next generation experiments will allow to reach a comprehensive and detailed understanding of the phase transition and the nuclear eos .
in order to perform thermodynamical analyses , one has to collect a data sample which corresponds as closely as possible to an homogeneous population of the phase space .
data must be selected such as to isolate a portion of the cross section where the entire system ( or the quasi - projectile ) properties keep a negligeable memory of the entrance channel dynamics .
this can be experimentally verified checking that for a given source the fragmentation pattern is determined by the size , charge , energy and average freeze - out volume solely , independent of the way the source has been formed , e.g. different impact parameters . in this case
the thermodynamics we can access is a microcanonical thermodynamics with energy , number of protons and neutrons , and average volume as state variables .
indeed the excitation energy can be measured on an event - by - event basis by calorimetric techniques .
for any shape of the excitation energy distribution the events can thus be sorted in constant energy bins , i.e. in microcanonical ensembles . in the following we present thermodynamical studies performed on quasi - projectile events from peripheral 35 a mev @xmath4 collisions @xcite and central events from 25 a mev @xmath5 , 25 and 35 a mev @xmath6 and 35 a mev @xmath4 collisions @xcite , measured at the k1200-nscl cyclotron of the michigan state university with the multics - miniball apparatus .
[ hbt ] single source almost complete events have been selected with a constant value for the collected charge in each energy bin @xcite .
the possible pollution from other sources has been minimized for central collisions through a shape analysis and in the case of @xmath1 quasi - projectile by substituting the backward light particle emission by the symmetric of the forward emission in the quasi - projectile reference frame . the observed event isotropy ( fig .
[ costcm ] ) indicates that the directed flow component coming from a memory of the entrance channel is negligible . the close similarity between statistical models @xcite and data @xcite , together with the isotropy of fragment emission , already suggest that these sets of data are close to a statistical equilibrium .
[ bhtp ] to progress on this point , we can also compare different data sets .
central events correspond to a narrow distribution of the excitation energy , while the quasi - projectile data supply a widely spread excitation function .
therefore it is possible to find for these data sets common values for the energy deposited in the source and to compare charge distributions and charge partitions . in the left four panels of fig .
[ 3938 ] the charge distribution of all the reaction products , but the largest one , masured for central @xmath5 events at 25 a mev , @xmath6 at 25 , 35 a mev and @xmath4 at 35 a mev ( top left , top right , bottom left , bottom right panels , respectively ) are compared to the quasi - projectile distributions at the same excitation energy .
the calorimetric values of the energy deposited in the systems cover a wide range .
indeed their values are 1.6 , 3.1 , 4.7 and 7.4 a mev , respectively . moreover , the comparison among the charge distributions of the heaviest fragment in each event ( fig .
[ 3938 ] ) allows to check the scaling of higher moments like the variances , even in more detail .
a very good scaling behaviour is also obtained by comparing the presented sets of data and the charge distributions measured by the fasa collaboration for the reactions @xmath7 at 8.1 , 4 and 14.6 gev @xcite and by the indra collaboration for @xmath8 reaction at 32 a mev incident energy @xcite .
the remarkable scaling between different sets of data means that these data samples can be analyzed , at least in a good first approximation , within statistical microcanonical methods . since the early 80 s
, size distributions have been fitted with power laws @xcite , and more sophisticated critical analyses have been performed following theoretical concepts coming from percolation theory .
more recently , an astonishing good scaling behaviour has been observed in the eos data @xcite and tentatively associated to the critical point of the nuclear liquid - gas phase transition expected to occur in nuclear matter in the framework of the fisher droplet model @xcite .
the debate on the order of the transition has been further animated by a very recent analysis of the eos and isis data @xcite which shows a high quality scaling of the fragment size distribution over a wide range of charges and deposited energies with an ansatz for the scaling function taken from the fisher droplet model .
the fermi gas `` critical '' temperature ( about 8 mev ) extracted in these papers is identified as the temperature of the thermodynamical critical point and the whole coexistence line of the nuclear phase diagram is reconstructed under the assumption that the fisher model gives a good description of the multifragmentation phenomenon @xcite . in this interpretation , multifragmentation would correspond to the critical point of the nuclear matter eos ( with a lower temperature due to finite size and coulomb effects ) , i.e. to a second order phase transition .
however , the experimental observation of a flattening of the caloric curve @xcite and recent studies @xcite in the framework of the smm model @xcite ( in which the resulting critical temperature is about 20 mev ) point rather to a first order phase transition , and this is also suggested by other thermodynamical statistical multifragmentation models @xcite . one may also wonder what physical meaning can be attributed to a fermi gas estimator of the temperature at excitation energies of several a mev .
indeed for the @xmath1 quasi - projectile data we are discussing , the temperature , evaluated from an isotope and a kinetic energy thermometer @xcite , strongly deviates from the fermi gas ansatz ( left part of fig . [ qp ] ) .
surprisingly enough , a comparable quality of scaling ( fig .
[ qp ] ) and a consistent set of critical exponents can also be extracted from the @xmath1 qp data samples , for which the heat capacity evaluation points to a first order phase transition @xcite , and the quality of the scaling does not depend the ansatz adopted for the @xmath9 parameter .
the same ansatz for the scaling function applied to central events @xcite gives similar exponents and points to the same critical - like energy .
however , critical exponents and scale invariance are compatible with many different physical phenomena and are not necessarily linked to a thermodynamic second order phase transition @xcite .
in particular the observed signals of critical behavior can be compatible with a first order phase transition , since in different statistical models size distributions that mimic a scale invariant behavior are observed inside the coexistence zone of small systems @xcite .
this means that scaling _ per s
_ does not demonstrate the existence of a phase transition , and even less defines its order or allows to localize the system on the phase diagram . on the other hand , the fact that all the analyzed reactions behave as a universal multifragmentation process independent of the entrance channel and directly correlated with the available energy only , is a strong indication of a microcanonical equilibrium .
it has been shown @xcite that for a given total energy the average partial energy stored in a subsystem of the microcanonical ensemble is a good thermometer while the fluctuations associated to the partial energy can be used to evaluate the heat capacity .
an example of such a decomposition is given by the kinetic @xmath10 and the interaction @xmath11 energies .
in particular first order phase transitions are marked by singularities and negative heat capacities @xcite , corresponding to fluctuations anomalously larger than the canonical expectation .
if the system is in statistical equilibrium , a measurement of anomalous fluctuations at a given energy is an unambiguous proof of a thermal first order phase transition .
experimentally , the total energy @xmath12 deposited in the system can be evaluated event by event by calorimetry .
if one is also able to reasonably estimate for multifragmentation data the relation between the measured charge and mass of the reaction products and the value of the freeze - out volume , one can obtain the event - by - event q - value and the coulomb energy , and thus the interaction energy , according to : @xmath13 where m is the total multiplicity , @xmath14 ( @xmath15 ) are the mass excess of the primary products ( of the source ) .
the interaction energy fluctuation can then be studied as a function of the total energy and the heat capacity can be evaluated according to : @xmath16 where @xmath17 is the fluctuation of the interaction energy @xmath11 from eq.([e_int ] ) , @xmath9 is the temperature , and @xmath18 is the kinetic heat capacity that can be evaluated by taking the numerical derivative of @xmath19 with respect to @xmath9
. eq.([57 ] ) shows that a negative heat capacity corresponds to partial energy fluctuations in the microcanonical ensemble that exceed the corresponding fluctuations in the canonical ensemble ( @xmath20 ) .
the average freeze - out volume can be determined @xcite from the detected fragment kinetic energies through a many - body coulomb trajectory calculation ( fig .
[ vfo ] ) . for the sets of data here
presented , a volume close to three times the normal volume reproduces the measured kinetic energies . only for the central @xmath4 collisions ,
the interplay between the coulomb energy and the radial flow ( about 1 a mev ) gives an uncertainty in the determination of the freeze - out volume .
indeed , the fragment kinetic energies would also be compatible with zero radial flow and an increased coulomb repulsion from a more compact configuration .
this ambiguity , however , does not affect our main conclusions , as is evident from the results shown in fig.[cneg ] .
an estimator of the microcanonical temperature @xmath9 can be obtained by inverting the kinetic equation of state : @xmath21 the unknown parameters of eq.([temp ] ) are the average side feeding correction @xmath22 on the fragment masses @xmath23 , and the level density parameter @xmath24 of primary fragments .
since the coulomb energy is positively correlated with the charged products multiplicity , the value obtained for the freeze - out volume in each excitation energy bin depends on the side feeding correction .
this means that @xmath25 and the percentage of evaporated particles have to be fixed consistently with an iterative procedure .
when this is done @xcite , we find that the microcanonical temperature , evaluated through eq.([temp ] ) results in agreement with the measured isotope temperature ( left panel of fig . [ qp ] ) . in order to minimize spurious fluctuations due to unmeasured quantities ,
a constant side feeding correction is applied in each excitation energy bin , and no volume fluctuations are allowed @xcite .
the partial energy fluctuation overcomes the canonical expectation approximately at the same values of @xmath12 for peripheral and central collisions data .
the same thing is true for central @xmath26 collisions from 32 to 50 a mev , measured with the indra device @xcite .
therefore , the different data sets are fully compatible , the results do not depend neither on the detector , nor on the data selection .
sophisticated experimental devices , with low energy threshold , high granularity and isotopic resolution will bring a detailed understanding of the phase transition and will allow to locate the position of the observed multifragmentation in the phase diagram of nuclear matter @xcite .
recent investigations on the opening of the multifragmentation channel , on the caloric curve and on the limiting temperature for @xmath27 systems started at moderate incident energies ( @xmath28 15 a mev ) at infn laboratori nazionali di legnaro with the garfield apparatus .
first results @xcite indicate that already at an excitation energy about 3 a mev , multifragmentation events with nearly equal size fragments represent a non negligible fraction of the decay channels .
the very good mass resolution of the garfield si - csi telescopes ( fig.[compil2 ] ) allows an isotope analysis .
the dependence on the isospin of the entrance channel is apparent .
isoscaling analyses , now in progress , will bring information on the isospin distillation at the onset of the multifragmentation @xcite .
99 p. chomaz , nucl . phys . * a 685 * ( 2001 ) 274 ; proceedings of inpc2001 , aip proceedings vol.no.610 ( 2002 ) 167 .
et al . _ ,
phys . rev . * c 65 * 34618 , ( 2002 ) .
e. geraci , contribution to this conference and nucl.phys.a ( to be published ) .
m.dagostino et al . , nucl.phys .
a650 ( 1999 ) 329 .
m.dagostino et al . , nucl.phys .
a724 ( 2003 ) 455 .
j. p. bondorf , a. s. botvina , a. s. iljinov , i. n. mishustin , k. sneppen , phys . rep . * 257 * 133 , ( 1995 ) .
s. p. avdeyev _ et al .
_ , nucl.phys .
* a709 * ( 2002 ) 392 .
m. f. rivet _ et indra collaboration _ ,
* b430 * ( 1998 ) 217 ; g. tabacaru _ et al .
_ nucl - ex/0212018 and epja(2003 ) in press .
j. e. finn _
et al _ , phys .
lett . * 49 * , 1321 ( 1982 ) ; phys . lett . *
b118 * , 458 ( 1982 ) ; a.s.hirsch _ et al _ , nucl . phys . *
a418 * , 267 ( 1984 ) ; m.mahi _ et al _ , phys .
* 60 * , 1936 ( 1988 ) ; a.d.panagiotou , m. w. curtin , h. toki , d. k. scott and p. j. siemens , phys .
lett . * 52 * , 496 ( 1984 ) ; x. campi , j.desbois , e.lipparini , phys.lett . *
138b * , 353 ( 1984 ) .
_ , phys.lett . *
b418 * , 34 ( 1998 ) ; r.p.scharenberg _ et al . _ ,
phys.rev.*c64 * 054602 , ( 2001 ) . m. e. fisher , physics vol . 3 ( 1967 ) 255 .
et al . _ ,
* 88 * ( 2002 ) 042701 ; phys.rev .
* c67 * ( 2003 ) 024609 .
j. pochodzalla _
et al _ , phys .
* 75 * , 1040 ( 1995 ) . v. a. karnaukhov _ et al .
_ , phys .
c67r * ( 2003 ) 011601 ; r. ogul and a. s. botvina , phys .
rev.*c 66r * ( 2002 ) 051601 .
d.h.e.gross , phys.rep . 279
( 1997 ) 119 , zeit .
fur phys .
* d39 * ( 1997 ) 75 .
et al . _ , phys.lett . *
b473 * 219 , ( 2000 ) , nucl .
phys.*a699 * 795 , ( 2002 ) .
x. campi , phys . lett . *
b208 * , 351 ( 1988 ) ; x.campi , h.krivine , zeit.phys . * 344a * 81 , ( 1992 ) ; x.campi , h.krivine , n.sator , nucl.phys . * a 681 * 458 , ( 2001 ) .
f.gulminelli , ph.chomaz , phys.rev.lett . * 82 * 1402 , ( 1999 ) ; int.journ.mod.phys.e * 8 * 1 , ( 1999 ) ; c. b. das , s. das gupta and a. majumder , phys . rev . *
c65 * 34608 , ( 2002 ) ; c. b. das _
et al . _ ,
rev . * c66 * ( 2002 ) 044602 ; j. m. carmona , j. richert , p. wagner , phys
b531 * 71 , ( 2002 ) ; a.h.raduta _ et al .
c * 65 * ( 2002 ) 034606 .
chomaz and f. gulminelli , nucl . phys .
* a647 * ( 1999 ) 153 .
f. gramegna _ et al .
_ , fizika * b 12 * ( 2003 ) 39 . | the connection between the thermodynamics of charged finite nuclear systems and the asymptotically measured partitions is presented .
some open questions , concerning in particular equilibrium partitions are discussed .
we show a detailed comparison of the decay patterns in @xmath0 central collisions and in @xmath1 quasi - projectile events .
observation of abnormally large fluctuations in carefully selected samples of data is reported as an indication of a first order phase transition ( negative heat capacity ) in the nuclear equation of state . _
8th international conference on nucleus - nucleus collisions , moscow 2003 _ |
since their experimental discovery , graphite monolayers , also known as graphene , have attracted a huge amount of interest among both experimentalists and theorists due to the linear low energy dispersion and various properties stemming from this unusual dispersion @xcite .
for instance , graphene has opened new perspectives for mesoscopic physics , such as pseudodiffusive conductance at the dirac point @xcite , specular andreev reflection @xcite , or the signatures of symmetries of the graphene hamiltonian in the conductance of diffusive wires @xcite and ballistic cavities @xcite .
mesoscopic rings can be considered as prototypical devices in mesoscopic physics , as they show one of the most basic coherence effects , namely the aharonov - bohm ( ab ) effect @xcite : oscillations of the transmission , or dimensionless conductance , @xmath0 as a function of the magnetic flux @xmath1 through the ring .
the reason for these oscillations is the phase difference @xmath2 between electrons travelling along the different arms of the ring . here
, @xmath3 is the magnetic flux quantum .
fifty years after its discovery , the ab effect is one of the most well - known manifestations of quantum interference within and beyond the field of condensed matter physics .
hence it is rather surprising that the ab effect in graphene has up to now received only a little attention in the literature .
most notably , there are only two experiments on graphene ab rings manufactured by electron beam lithography @xcite , one of them leaving many open questions on the physical origin of some of the observed effects @xcite . from the theory side
, there is only one numerical study of the ab effect in graphene rings ; it focuses on the effects of valley - polarized currents , i.e. on the few - mode or low - doping regime in the leads @xcite . in this work
, we will in contrast also consider the many - mode or high - doping regime .
in addition to these studies focusing on the transport properties of _ open _ rings , there has been a proposal to use the aharonov - bohm effect in _ closed _ rings to form qubits : the energy spectrum of a closed graphene ring with infinite mass boundary condition @xcite has been calculated in reference @xcite , where the authors find that the valley degeneracy of the energy levels is lifted as soon as a magnetic flux pierces the ring .
this effect has also been found for chaotic graphene quantum dots @xcite .
note that this aspect is not present in ab rings realized e.g. in semiconductor heterostructures and metals .
it is connected to a special antiunitary symmetry of the dirac hamiltonian , which describes graphene well for low fermi energies . in this work
, we will show that the lifting of the valley degeneracy is also visible in the transport properties of graphene rings .
the paper is organized as follows : in the first part , we investigate the ab effect of graphene structures by numerically calculating the transmission of rings attached to infinitely extended leads .
we study both small rings in the one - mode regime and large rings with many modes propagating in both the leads and arms of the ring . in the latter we especially consider the high - field regime and the effects of disorder . in the second part of this work
, we show that the breaking of valley - degeneracy by a magnetic field is also visible in the transport properties of graphene rings .
we do this by numerically calculating the transmission of graphene rings that are weakly coupled to two leads .
this transmission shows peaks as a function of the fermi energy @xmath4 which correspond to the energy levels of a closed ring ; the lifting of their degeneracy can be observed as a splitting of the transmission peaks upon applying a magnetic field perpendicular to the ring . for our numerical work
, we use a tight binding model taking into account the @xmath5-orbitals of the carbon atoms , leading to the hamiltonian @xmath6 with @xmath7 and @xmath8 beeing nearest neighbor sites in the first sum . the magnetic field
is included via the peierls substitution @xmath9 .
the second term accounts for a staggered on - site potential , i.e. @xmath10 is positive ( negative ) if @xmath11 is located on sublattice a ( b ) .
such a staggered potential corresponds to a mass term in the effective dirac equation and will be used in the second part of this paper to suppress the inter - valley scattering that breaks the valley degeneracy @xcite .
the lattice points are determined by cutting a ring out of the graphene sheet [ cf .
figure [ fig : ringscheme2](b ) ] . in order to solve the transport problem to obtain the dimensionless conductance @xmath12 within this tight - binding model
, we use an adaptive recursive green function method @xcite .
and @xmath13 , respectively , and the width @xmath14 of the infinitely extended leads .
the dashed line marks the points where the mass term used in section [ sec : vdeg ] is zero .
( b ) example of a system defined by cutting a ring out of a graphene sheet [ the system was used for figure [ fig : smallab ] ( a ) and ( c ) ] .
, width=340 ] we now investigate the transmission of graphene rings with two attached leads under the influence of a perpendicular magnetic field @xmath15 , giving rise to a flux @xmath1 through the ring . in the following we define @xmath16 as the flux through a circle with the average ring radius @xmath17 ( cf .
figure [ fig : ringscheme2 ] ) . because electrons can travel along one or the other arm of the ring , the transmission @xmath18 is expected to oscillate with periods @xmath19 , as mentioned in the introduction .
the reason why more than one single period , namely @xmath20 , may occur is that the electrons do not necessarily have to leave the ring after traversing an arm once , but rather they may circle around the ring several times before exiting , giving rise to higher harmonics with @xmath21 .
we begin by considering small graphene rings in the one - mode regime . in figure
[ fig : smallab](a ) and ( b ) we show the numerically calculated transmission as a function of @xmath1 for two small rings with radii of about @xmath22 nm and widths of about @xmath23 nm ( see figure caption for details ) .
one of the rings has zigzag type leads while the other has armchair type leads . for both , one can clearly see the ab oscillations with period @xmath24 . to expose a few more details of the frequency content of our data ,
we show the power spectra of the ab oscillations in figure [ fig : smallab](c ) and ( d ) .
there we find pronounced peaks for the fundamental frequency and for several higher harmonics ( we show only the first five ) .
note that we plot the spectra on a logarithmic scale , since the fundamental frequency is strongly dominating over the higher ones .
the peaks in the spectrum lie very close to multiple values of @xmath25 . because of the finite width of the rings , one has certain allowed deviations from these values .
for example , for the system of figure [ fig : smallab](a ) , the fundamental frequency is expected to lie between @xmath26 and @xmath27 , obtained from the inner and outer ring radii @xmath28 and @xmath13 , respectively .
the fact that the peaks are slightly shifted to frequencies lower than @xmath29 means that the effective radius of our rings is slightly smaller than the average radius @xmath30 .
we also performed calculations for various systems with different parameters and found the same behavior irrespective of the details like radii , width or lead type . and corresponding power spectra [ ( c),(d ) ] of small rings in the one - mode regime .
( a),(c ) ring with zigzag type leads and @xmath31 nm , @xmath32 nm , @xmath33 nm . ( b ) , ( d ) ring with armchair type leads and @xmath31 nm , @xmath34 nm , @xmath35 nm . @xmath36 is the fourier transform of @xmath18 where @xmath37 is the period of the oscillation related to the fourier transform variable by @xmath38.,width=340 ] next , we turn to the case of larger graphene rings in the many - mode regime , i.e. for high values of doping .
this is the regime applicable to the available experiments of refs .
@xcite . in the numerical simulations we consider rings with an average radius @xmath39 nm . while this size is still smaller than in the experiments ( @xmath40 nm in ref .
@xcite and @xmath41-@xmath42 nm in ref .
@xcite ) , the rings contain more than a hunded thousand atoms and hence can be considered as mesoscopic objects .
therefore , we do not expect that larger rings would show any fundamentally different physical properties than the systems considered here .
nm , @xmath43 nm and @xmath44 nm for a wide range of the magnetic flux @xmath1 ( solid black line ) in the multi - mode regime .
the red dashed line shows the number of occupied transverse channels in the leads .
the insets show power spectra for different regimes : left inset @xmath45-@xmath46 , right inset @xmath47-@xmath48.,width=415 ] in figure [ fig : ablarge185 ] , we show the magnetoconductance of a large ring for a wide range of the magnetic flux , up to the quantum hall regime . up to a flux of about @xmath49
, we see ab oscillations with amplitudes approximately in the range @xmath50 [ see also figure [ fig : ablarge](a ) ] . for fluxes larger than @xmath49 ,
the oscillation amplitude becomes significantly smaller ( @xmath51 ) , while for even higher values of @xmath1 the oscillations vanish completely and the transmission is equal to the maximum value given by the number of quantum hall edge channels in the leads .
this behavior can be understood by the following picture .
the cyclotron diameter @xmath52 in ( bulk ) graphene is given by @xmath53 where @xmath4 is the fermi energy and @xmath54 is the fermi velocity . in our case @xmath55 and the width of the ring arms is @xmath56 nm .
this means , that at a flux of @xmath57 , the cyclotron diameter is equal to an arm s width .
when @xmath1 becomes comparable to this value , it becomes more probable that the electron enters one arm than the other , because the magnetic field dictates the direction of classical propagation .
therefore , interference is reduced .
when the magnetic field gets larger and larger , it becomes more and more unlikely for the electron to enter the second arm , and finally the interference vanishes when the quantum hall edge channels fully form . since backscattering is also strongly reduced at large magnetic fields , the transmission is only limited by the number of propagating lead channels .
this number however is reduced for a fixed fermi energy as the magnetic field is increased ( the distance between the landau levels increases with @xmath15 ) , which leads to the step - like transmission in this regime . furthermore ,
classical cyclotron effects are also important at the entrance to the ring . at low fields , a large part of the wavefunction entering the ring
is simply reflected back into the lead by the inner wall of the ring . as the field gets higher , the probability to turn around the corner into one of the arms increases .
this scenario is shown in figure [ fig : current ] : the absolute value of the current density in the ring is given for values of the flux @xmath1 corresponding to the different regimes . for @xmath58 [ figure [ fig : current](a ) ] the low transmission regime the current flows more or less equally through both arms . as the flux is increased , the electrons are forced more and more into the upper arm , and at very high fluxes , when electrons are essentially travelling only along the upper arm , interference gets suppressed and finally vanishes . note
that also the quantum hall edge channels become clearly visible at high fluxes .
it is worth noting that the small ab oscillations in the regime where @xmath59 are not due to electrons entering the lower arm of the ring from the left lead .
if this were true , the current in figure [ fig : current](c ) would be localized at the inner border of the lower arm , which is obviously not the case . in this regime ,
the interference is due to paths going along the upper arm and leaving the ring after a half circle interfering with paths which also start along the upper arm but which go around the ring one more time before exiting .
such paths also give rise to oscillations with period @xmath20 .
note that this effect is present only because the lead width in the chosen geometry is somewhat smaller than the width of the ring , as then the quantum hall edge channels in the ring arms may be scattered at the lead opening and enter the opposite arm .
hence , this regime corresponds to interferometry with quantum hall edge channels .
when the lead width is larger than the ring arm width , scattering at the lead openings is suppressed , and no interference is observed . the power spectra shown as insets in figure [ fig : ablarge185 ] also support this picture : for low fields , several higher harmonics are present , whereas at high fields only the fundamental frequency is visible because multiple windings around the ring are strongly suppressed in the quantum hall regime . .
the electrons enter the ring from the left lead .
blue means low and red means high current density .
( a ) @xmath58 ( b ) @xmath60 ( c ) @xmath61 ( d ) @xmath62.,width=415 ] the magnitude of the conductance seen in the quantum hall regime an odd integer times @xmath63 ( see figure [ fig : ablarge185 ] ) is consistent with the bulk quantum hall effect @xcite as well as with theoretical results obtained for graphene nanoribbons @xcite .
( recall that in a two terminal geometry the conductance shows the quantization of @xmath64 . )
the steps of magnitude 2 are easily understood in terms of the valley degeneracy of the subbands in the leads .
the quantization at odd rather than even integers is explained by a berry phase effect involving the pseudospin associated with the sub - lattice degree of freedom @xcite . in the experimental work of ref.@xcite ,
a significant increase of the ab oscillation amplitude was observed at high fields when @xmath65 .
note that our data in figure [ fig : ablarge185 ] does not show any such increase ( if anything , it shows the opposite ) . to investigate this further , figure [ fig : ablarge ]
shows the oscillating part of the magnetoconductance for a range of @xmath1 near the value where the cyclotron diameter becomes equal to the width of a ring arm [ around @xmath66 according to ( [ eq : cycd ] ) ] .
the authors of @xcite speculate that an asymmetry between the two ring arms could be responsible for the increase of the oscillation amplitude .
our numerical calculations , however , do not confirm this : for figure [ fig : ablarge](b ) we reduced the width of one arm by 10 percent , but also in this case , an inrease of the oscillation amplitude at high magnetic fields is absent .
has been subtracted from @xmath18 to obtain @xmath67 .
top panel : system of figure [ fig : ablarge185 ] .
lower panel : same system as in the top panel , but the outer radius of one ring arm is reduced from @xmath68 nm to @xmath69 nm which results in a difference in the arm widths of 10 percent.,width=415 ] the formation of quantum hall edge channels in a clean system happens for @xmath70 , as observed in our simulations ( figure [ fig : ablarge185 ] ) . in the data of ref .
@xcite , however , ab oscillations are still visible even for much higher magnetic fields , when @xmath71 .
furthermore , despite being ten times larger than the rings considered in our numerical studies , the average conductance in the highly doped regime is only on the order of a few @xmath72 .
these two features are a strong indication that these experiments are in the strongly disordered regime . ,
@xmath73 and @xmath74 in the multi - mode regime ( solid black lines ) .
the insets show corresponding power spectra .
( a ) ring with edge disorder . here , we employed the etching disorder model of ref .
@xcite with @xmath75 and @xmath76 for @xmath77 ( for the details on the parameters of this model , see ref .
( b ) ring with bulk disorder . for the bulk disorder , we choose a gaussian disorder potential with @xmath78 , @xmath79 and @xmath80 ( for the details on the parameters of this model , see ref .
note that although the gaussian disorder potential is smooth on the lattice scale and hence does not scatter the valleys , valley scattering nevertheless happens at the abrupt termination of the lattice at the edges.,width=491 ] hence , we now turn to briefly discussing the effects of disorder on the ab oscillations . for this , we consider both edge disorder ( employing the model of edge disorder from ref .
@xcite ) and bulk disorder ( using gaussian disorder as in ref .
figure [ fig : disorder](a ) and ( b ) show the magnetoconductance for edge and bulk disorder , respectively . in the case of edge disorder
only , we still observe an increase of the transmission with magnetic field due to classical cyclotron effects as in the clean case . in addition , the onset of quantized hall conductance is only shifted slightly to higher fields .
in fact , since the interior of the ring arms is ballistic , we still expect quantum hall edge channels to form for @xmath70 . moreover , as in the clean case we observe interference of quantum hall edge states for @xmath81 .
in contrast , for bulk disorder the transmission probability remains
apart from conductance fluctuations virtually unchanged as the magnetic field increases . in this case
, the disorder broadens the landau levels enough to prevent the formation of edge channels .
the similariy of this behavior to that of the experiments reported in ref .
@xcite suggests that the experiments are in the `` dirty limit '' , dominated by bulk disorder .
such a conclusion is also in agreement with ref .
@xcite where their experimental results for ab rings are explained in terms of diffusive metallic transport .
.,width=415 ] further characteristics of the diffusive limit include that the system remains isotropic for higher fields , both ring arms carry an equal amount of current , and higher harmonics are suppressed in comparison to the clean case ( see figure [ fig : ablarge185 ] ) .
finally , figure [ fig : disorder2 ] shows the oscillating part of the magnetoconductance in the vincinity of @xmath82 .
again , the size of the oscillations remains essentially unchanged with increasing magnetic flux .
a closer inspection of the oscillations reveals that in the case of edge disorder , there are also aperiodic oscillations on top of the periodic ab oscillations for @xmath83 , where we observe the onset of edge channel formation .
these aperiodic oscillations are presumably due to localization and resonant tunneling at the disordered edge , since there is still backscattering among the not fully formed edge states .
this interpretation is supported by the fact that the aperiodic oscillations are absent in the case of bulk disorder , where the edge channel formation is completely suppressed .
furthermore , note that aperiodic oscillations are also present ( although to a less degree ) for @xmath84 in the clean rings , as the abrupt lattice termination also serves as a source of _ local _ disorder .
in the following , we demonstrate numerically that the lifting of the valley degeneracy of eigenstates in rings by a magnetic field perpendicular to the ring is also visible in transport properties of the ring . in ref .
@xcite , the authors calculate the energy spectrum of a closed graphene ring with infinite mass boundary condition @xcite within the effective dirac theory .
the energy levels @xmath85 are labeled by a radial quantum number @xmath86 , an angular momentum quantum number @xmath87 , valley index @xmath88 and the sign of the energy . at zero magnetic field ,
the authors find from their calculation the degeneracy @xmath89 , which is not present when a perpendicular magnetic field is applied .
it is worth to point out that this is due to the fact that in addition to the usual time reversal ( tr ) operator @xmath90 , there is another antiunitary operator commuting with the hamiltonian at zero magnetic field , namely @xmath91 .
in contrast to @xmath92 , @xmath93 is associated with a symplectic symmetry , since @xmath94 .
this ensures the degeneracy of both valleys ( kramer s degeneracy @xcite ) .
note that this reasoning holds only if the boundary condition preserves the symmetry connected with @xmath93 ; such is the case for the infinite mass boundary condition used in ref .
@xcite but is not the case , for example , for valley mixing armchair boundaries . once a magnetic field pierces the ring , the @xmath93 symmetry is broken and the valley degeneracy is lifted . this mechanism has been numerically observed in ballistic graphene quantum dots with smooth mass confinement @xcite , where the amplitude of universal conductance fluctuations was considered .
here we follow a different idea to probe the effect of breaking valley degeneracy with a magnetic field , namely we calculate numerically the conductance of a ring weakly coupled to two leads .
the conductance is then expected to be peaked at values of the fermi energy that match the energies of eigenstates of the closed ring . ) and @xmath31 nm , @xmath95 nm , @xmath96 nm , with leads that are strongly ( black ) and weakly ( blue ) coupled to the system as a function of the fermi energy in the two - mode regime ( transverse lead channels are twofold valley degenerate).,width=340 ] in order to have valley degenerate states at zero magnetic field , we have to avoid scattering at local armchair boundaries , as mentioned above .
to model the infinite mass boundary numerically , we use smooth mass confinement as introduced in @xcite . due to the finite escape time of electrons injected into the ring from one lead ,
the effects of inter - valley scattering will be suppressed in such a system , provided the mass confinement is smooth enough .
we use a mass term that is zero in the middle of the ring and increases quadratically towards the boundaries [ cf .
figure [ fig : ringscheme2](a ) ] : @xmath97 , where @xmath98 for a ring with average radius @xmath30 centered at @xmath99 . in the leads we use a consistent mass term , with @xmath100 for leads in the @xmath101-direction . in the region where the leads are attached
, we match both terms in a smooth way . in this region
we also introduce a mass - induced barrier , that can be varied in height , in order to tune the coupling strength between leads and ring .
figure [ fig : couplings ] shows the transmission of rings with both strong and and weak coupling as a function of the fermi energy @xmath4 .
we checked that the transmission is insensitive to the orientation of the system with respect to the lattice orientation at the energies considered .
this means that the detailed edge structure of ring and leads do not play a role , and implies that the mass confinement is smooth enough to suppress inter - valley scattering . upon reducing the coupling strength , the oscillations in the transmission of the ring with strongly coupled leads turn into sharp peaks .
the system studied is a ring with @xmath31 nm , @xmath95 nm and width @xmath96 nm .
note that the effective width of leads and ring is reduced due to the mass confinement .
the mass potential is @xmath102 at the physical borders of the system for the value of @xmath103 used ( see caption of figure [ fig : couplings ] ) . for zero flux ( blue dashed lines ) and a flux @xmath104 ( red solid lines ) .
( b ) shows a zoom on the 6 ( or 12 , respectively ) rightmost peaks of ( a).,width=377 ] to find out , wether the energy spectrum of our ring shows the valley degeneracy connected with the symmetry described by @xmath93 , we try to break this supposed degeneracy by applying a magnetic field perpendicular to the ring .
figure [ fig : brokendeg_2](a ) shows the numerical results , where the magnetic flux through the area @xmath105 with @xmath106 nm is @xmath107 ( dashed lines ) and @xmath104 ( solid lines ) , respectively .
we find that the transmission peaks split and that their heights are in general reduced .
this is the behavior expected from degeneracy lifting , as the weight of each split peak now corresponds to only a single , non - degenerate level .
note that for @xmath108 the peaks partially overlap ; the splitting of the valley degeneracy is particularly clear for @xmath109 where the peaks are well seperated , as shown in figure [ fig : brokendeg_2](b ) .
these results show unambiguously that the lifting of the valley - degeneracy by a magnetic flux in weakly coupled graphene rings can also be observed in the transport properties .
in this work we have investigated two different aspects of mesoscopic graphene rings : first , we have numerically studied the aharonov - bohm effect in rings cut out of the graphene lattice . both small rings with a single mode as well as large rings supporting many modes exhibit clear @xmath110 aharonov - bohm oscillations .
although disorder has a strong influence on the average transmission of graphene rings especially in the high field regime , the aharonov - bohm oscillations are influenced only very little by both edge and bulk disorder .
second , we have shown that the signature of the splitting of the valley - degeneracy by a magnetic field in rings with a mass confinement can also be observed in the transport properties of rings that are weakly coupled to leads .
jw acknowledges support from deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft within grk 638 , and mw and kr support from deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft within sfb 689 .
the work at duke was supported in part by the u.s .
nsf ( dmr-0506953 ) and the daad .
we would like to thank inan adagideli , patrik recher , adam rycerz and bjrn trauzettel for helpful discussions .
+ j. wurm , a. rycerz , i. adagideli , m. wimmer , k. richter , and h. u. baranger .
symmetry classes in graphene quantum dots : universal spectral statistics , weak localization , and conductance fluctuations . , 102(5):056806 , 2009 .
s. russo , j. b. oostinga , d. wehenkel , h. b. heersche , s. s. sobhani , l. m. k. vandersypen , and a. f. morpurgo .
observation of aharonov - bohm conductance oscillations in a graphene ring .
, 77(8):085413 , 2008 .
k. s. novoselov , a. k. geim , s. v. morozov , d. jiang , m. i. katsnelson , i. v. grigorieva , s. v. dubonos , and a. a. firsov .
two - dimensional gas of massless dirac fermions in graphene .
, 438(7065):197200 , november 2005 . | we study the conductance of mesoscopic graphene rings in the presence of a perpendicular magnetic field by means of numerical calculations based on a tight - binding model .
first , we consider the magnetoconductance of such rings and observe the aharonov - bohm effect .
we investigate different regimes of the magnetic flux up to the quantum hall regime , where the aharonov - bohm oscillations are suppressed .
results for both clean ( ballistic ) and disordered ( diffusive ) rings are presented .
second , we study rings with smooth mass boundary that are weakly coupled to leads .
we show that the valley degeneracy of the eigenstates in closed graphene rings can be lifted by a small magnetic flux , and that this lifting can be observed in the transport properties of the system . |
a very active investigation of excitons in coupled quantum wells for more than two decades was first motivated by the possibility to reach bose condensation and superfluidity in this system .
further experiments discovered a very large number of related phenomena and quite rich physics of the system ( see refs.@xcite and references therein ) .
theory predicts the existence of many phases with different and unusual properties.@xcite the most expected and searched for is the settling in of coherence in such 2d exciton systems .
a coherence of the exciton bose condensate has to reveal itself in some coherent properties of the exciton luminescence .
investigation of the luminescence led to discovery of not only its coherence @xcite but also a number of patterns not completely understood so far @xcite . a substantial role in these phenomena
is played by the interaction between excitons .
typically , interaction between bosons ( @xmath0he atoms and alkali - atoms ) is of a short range and the theory of non - ideal bose gas has been developed for contact interaction . @xcite in coupled quantum wells where the electrons and holes are separated in the two adjacent layers , all the indirect , dipolar excitons that are formed by the coulomb binding of pairs of these spatially separated electrons and holes are polarized in the same way and their interaction is mainly dipole
dipole repulsion , fig.[fig : x_in_cqw ] .
contrary to the contact interaction the dipole
dipole interaction has a significant tail and due to this tail the exciton gas in some respects is dramatically different from bose gas with contact - like interactions .
excitons in coupled quantum wells .
@xmath1 is the separation between the centers of the wells ( given @xmath1 the dependence of the exciton - exciton interaction on the well widths is very weak @xcite ) . @xmath1 and the average separation between excitons
are assumed to be larger than the exciton radius @xmath2 . ]
the dipole
dipole repulsion increases the exciton energy and leads to a blue shift of its luminescence line .
the blue shift is usually evaluated as an average value of the exciton interaction energy with other excitons and can be easily obtained with the help of the mean field approximation that produces `` plate capacitor formula''@xcite @xmath3 where @xmath4 is the exciton 2d concentration , @xmath1 is the separation between the centers of the wells , and @xmath5 is the dielectric constant .
this formula can be understood in the following way .
equal concentration @xmath4 of electrons and holes in two wells creates potential difference @xmath6 between them .
creation of one more indirect exciton in these wells requires transfer of an electron or a hole from one well to the other . in the presence of other excitons
this increases the necessary energy by @xmath7 that gives eq.([eq:1 ] ) .
this expression is typically used in experiments for an estimate of the exciton concentration from the measured blue shift of the luminescence .
recently zimmermann and schindler @xcite noticed , however , that dipole
dipole repulsion leads to a significant exciton pair correlation .
the repulsion prevents excitons to come very close to each other and creates a depleted region around each exciton .
the pair correlation leads to a reduction of the coefficient in eq.([eq:1 ] ) by about 10 times ( depending on the excitons temperature).@xcite this means that previous experimental estimates of the exciton concentration based on the capacitor formula underestimated the concentration by up to 10 times !
it makes sense to note that the reduction of the pair correlation function to zero at small distance in a bose gas with repulsion has been noticed long ago and used in the construction of a many particle variational wave function.@xcite it is well known in exact solutions for one dimensional bose gas.@xcite in the exciton gas with dipole
dipole repulsion this behavior of the pair correlation function was noticed by astrakharchik et al.@xcite .
this behavior was also used by kash et al to explain a narrowing of the exciton luminescence line at low temperature.@xcite the significant pair correlation between excitons substantially affects our understanding of the behavior of this system .
this motivated us to develop a general picture of the interaction and correlation between excitons in the whole temperature concentration plane .
this is the subject of this paper .
we show that eq.([eq:1 ] ) has a very limited region of applicability and limited accuracy . with a decrease of the temperature and an increase of the concentration
the role of the pair correlation becomes crucial for interpretation of such phenomena as the blue shift .
it appears also that the degeneracy of the exciton system at any small concentration is accompanied by setting in of not pair but multi - particle correlation characteristic for liquids . in other words , a consistent theory of a quantum coherent state has to include multi - exciton correlation at any dilute gas .
more than this , at higher concentrations the dipole dipole repulsion reduces the overlap of the wave functions of different excitons . as a result
the exciton system can be considered as classical liquid down to temperature well below than the temperature of quantum degeneracy of a system with contact interaction .
our main purpose is to develop a qualitative understanding of the structure of the system of interacting bosons .
therefore we do nt pursue a high accuracy of the results but instead use simplified models and qualitative arguments .
although the results of such an approach are really accurate only in extreme cases with respect to some large or small parameters , they allow us to make analytical calculations and produce a very clear physical picture of relevant phenomena .
availability of such a picture facilitates precise calculations when they are necessary . in the next section we consider in detail the applicability of the mean field approximation that neglects any correlation between excitons
an exciton gas at lower temperatures where strong pair correlation is important but quantum correlations are still negligible is considered in sec.[sec : cxg ] .
further reduction of temperature at low exciton concentrations , when the exciton wavelength becomes larger than the characteristic scale of exciton - exciton interaction , leads to an important role of quantization in the exciton - exciton scattering while the exciton gas itself is still statistically non - degenerate .
this situation is considered in sec.[sec : xgqs ] . in sec.[sec : lsxs ] we consider the situation where multi - exciton correlation is important .
this happens at low enough temperature in a dilute system and in a more wide range of temperatures in a dense system .
it appears that with a temperature decrease in a dilute system degeneracy is accompanied by a set in of a multi - exciton correlation .
contrary , in a dense system the classical multi - exciton correlations appear to be more important for the blue shift than the quantization of exciton dynamics . in the last section we discuss the obtained results .
the discussion of exciton correlation in different parts of the concentration - temperature plane involves quite a large number of physical parameters . to facilitate reading of the paper we present here the list of main parameters with their physical definitions .
exact mathematical definitions , if necessary , will be given as soon as the corresponding parameter comes into the discussion .
.[tab : parameters]the main parameters characterizing an exciton gas in coupled quantum wells [ cols="^,<,^ , < " , ] two of the lines in fig.[fig : nt ] , between regions iii and iv and between regions ii and v , actually comprise one line at which the gas parameter condition is violated .
the gas parameter is the product of the concentration and the scattering crosssection squared . between regions
ii and v this crosssection is classical , @xmath8 , while between regions iii and iv it is quantum , @xmath9 .
the other two lines , between regions ii and iii and between regions iv and v , separate classical and quantum interactions between excitons . also , it is necessary to note that at the bottom of region v some quantum coherent phenomena are possible .
it is important to note that the lines separating different regions in fig.[fig : nt ] do not correspond to sharp transitions .
crossing of one of the lines by changing the temperature or the concentration leads to a gradual change of the correlation between excitons .
fig.[fig : nt ] demonstrates only the role of correlation but not phases of the system .
we studied an exciton system in coupled quantum wells where electrons and holes are confined in different wells and the main interaction between excitons is a dipole dipole repulsion .
we found that in the most part of the temperature concentration plane the system is characterized by a strong exciton exciton correlation . at some parts of this plane the system behaves as a gas with a strong pair correlation .
in other parts where the gas parameter condition is violated , i.e. , where the probability to find more than two excitons close to each other becomes of the order of unity , the correlation is multi - excitonic and the system has to be considered as a liquid . in particular , at low concentrations degeneracy of the system is accompanied by a setting in of multi - exciton correlations . at high concentration the strong confinement of each exciton wave function due to repulsion between excitons suppresses quantum correlations .
the blue shift of the exciton luminescence has a different value and a different dependence on the exciton temperature and concentration depending on how close excitons can come to each other .
therefore it is a sensitive tool for measuring of the exciton exciton correlations .
b.l . appreciates discussions with m. stern and a. l. efros .
here the problem of the exciton - exciton scattering is considered under the condition of small energy of relative motion , under the condition eq.([eq : xxs.1a ] ) the minimal distance between excitons is much larger than @xmath1 ( i.e. , at @xmath15 the wave function is negligibly small ) and the interaction potential can be approximated with eq.([eq : cxg.7 ] ) .
the condition of a very long exciton wavelength , eq.([eq : xxs.1b ] ) , makes it possible to simplify eq.([eq : xxs.4 ] ) in two regions . in the region where the distance between excitons is much smaller than the wavelength of their relative motion ,
@xmath16 , the coordinate dependence of the wave function comes only from the potential energy and the characteristic scale @xmath17 . at this scale
the kinetic energy can be neglected and eq.([eq : xxs.4 ] ) is reduced to @xmath18 when the distance between the excitons is much larger than @xmath19 the interaction energy is small compared to the kinetic energy and @xmath20 due to @xmath21 the two regions overlap at @xmath22 .
solutions to both eqs.([eq : xxs.5 ] ) and ( [ eq : xxs.6 ] ) are expressed in bessel functions . when @xmath23 only s scattering is important and it is enough to find angular independent solution of eq.([eq : xxs.5 ] ) .
the solution that goes to zero at @xmath24 is @xmath25 the solution to eq.([eq : xxs.6 ] ) describing scattering is @xmath26 making use of asymptotes @xcite where @xmath28 is the euler constant it is easy to match the solutions in the intermediate region @xmath29 : @xmath30 .
\label{eq : xxs.10}\ ] ] this gives @xmath31 according to eq.([eq : xxs.1b ] ) the argument of the logarithm is small and with the logarithmic accuracy @xmath32 m. stern , v. garmider , v. umansky , and i. bar - joseph , phys .
* 100 * , 256402 ( 2008 ) ; m. stern , v. garmider , e. segre , m. rappaport , v. umansky , y. levinson , and i. bar - joseph , phys .
lett . * 101 * , 257402 ( 2008 ) .
j. fernndez - rossier , c. tejedor , l. muoz and l. via , phys .
b * 54 * , 11582 ( 1996 ) ; j. fernndez - rossier and c. tejedor , phys . rev
* 78 * , 4809 ( 1997 ) ; phys .
solidi ( a ) * 164 * , 343 ( 1997 ) .
g. e. astrakharchik , j. boronat , i. l. kurbakov , and yu .
e. lozovik , phys .
lett . * 98 * , 060405 ( 2007 ) ; yu .
e. lozovik , i. l. kurbakov , g. e. astrakharchik , j. boronat , and m. willander , arxiv:0801.0150v1 [ cond-mat.str-el ] 30 dec 2007 .
l. v. butov , a. c. gossard and d. s. chemla , nature * 418 * , 751 ( 2002 ) ; l. v. butov , c. w. lai , a. l. ivanov , a. c. gossard , and d. s. chemla , nature * 417 * , 47 ( 2002 ) ; l.v .
butov , l. s. levitov , a.v .
mintsev , b. d. simons , a.c .
gossard , and d. s. chemla , phys .
lett . * 92 * , 117404 ( 2004 ) .
d. snoke , s. denev , y. liu , l. pfeiffer , and k. west , nature * 418 * , 754 ( 2002 ) ; d. snoke , y. liu , s. denev , l. pfeiffer , and k. west , solid state commun . * 127 * , 187 ( 2003 ) ; d. snoke , phys . stat .
solidi b * 238 * , 389 ( 2003 ) . | in this paper we present a study of an exciton system where electrons and holes are confined in double quantum well structures . the dominating interaction between excitons in such systems
is a dipole - dipole repulsion .
we show that the tail of this interaction leads to a strong correlation between excitons and substantially affects the behavior of the system . making use of qualitative arguments and estimates
we develop a picture of the exciton - exciton correlations in the whole region of temperature and concentration where excitons exist .
it appears that at low concentration degeneracy of the excitons is accompanied with strong multi - particle correlation so that the system can not be considered as a gas . at high concentration
the repulsion suppresses the quantum degeneracy down to temperatures that could be much lower than in a bose gas with contact interaction .
we calculate the blue shift of the exciton luminescence line which is a sensitive tool to observe the exciton - exciton correlations . |
at the time of the birth of general relativity ( gr ) , experimental confirmation was almost a side issue .
einstein did calculate observable effects of general relativity , such as the deflection of light , which were tested , but compared to the inner consistency and elegance of the theory , he regarded such empirical questions as almost peripheral . but
today , experimental gravitation is a major component of the field , characterized by continuing efforts to test the theory s predictions , to search for gravitational imprints of high - energy particle interactions , and to detect gravitational waves from astronomical sources .
the modern history of experimental relativity can be divided roughly into four periods , genesis , hibernation , a golden era , and the quest for strong gravity .
the genesis ( 18871919 ) comprises the period of the two great experiments which were the foundation of relativistic physics the michelson - morley experiment and the etvs experiment and the two immediate confirmations of gr the deflection of light and the perihelion advance of mercury .
following this was a period of hibernation ( 19201960 ) during which relatively few experiments were performed to test gr , and at the same time the field itself became sterile and stagnant , relegated to the backwaters of physics and astronomy .
but beginning around 1960 , astronomical discoveries ( quasars , pulsars , cosmic background radiation ) and new experiments pushed gr to the forefront .
experimental gravitation experienced a golden era ( 19601980 ) during which a systematic , world - wide effort took place to understand the observable predictions of gr , to compare and contrast them with the predictions of alternative theories of gravity , and to perform new experiments to test them .
the period began with an experiment to confirm the gravitational frequency shift of light ( 1960 ) and ended with the reported decrease in the orbital period of the binary pulsar at a rate consistent with the general relativity prediction of gravity - wave energy loss ( 1979 ) . the results all supported gr , and most alternative theories of gravity fell by the wayside ( for a popular review , see ref . ) .
since 1980 , the field has entered what might be termed a quest for strong gravity .
many of the remaining interesting weak - field predictions of the theory are extremely small and difficult to check , in some cases requiring further technological development to bring them into detectable range .
the sense of a systematic assault on the weak - field predictions of gr has been supplanted to some extent by an opportunistic approach in which novel and unexpected ( and sometimes inexpensive ) tests of gravity have arisen from new theoretical ideas or experimental techniques , often from unlikely sources .
examples include the use of laser - cooled atom and ion traps to perform ultra - precise tests of special relativity , and the startling proposal of a `` fifth '' force , which led to a host of new tests of gravity at short ranges .
several major ongoing efforts also continue , principally the stanford gyroscope experiment , known as gravity probe - b . instead ,
much of the focus has shifted to experiments which can probe the effects of strong gravitational fields . at one extreme
are the strong gravitational fields associated with planck - scale physics
. will unification of the forces , or quantization of gravity at this scale leave observable effects accessible by experiment ?
dramatically improved tests of the equivalence principle or of the `` inverse square law '' are being designed , to search for or bound the imprinted effects of planck scale phenomena . at the other extreme
are the strong fields associated with compact objects such as black holes or neutron stars .
astrophysical observations and gravitational - wave detectors are being planned to explore and test gr in the strong - field , highly - dynamical regime associated with the formation and dynamics of these objects . in these lectures
, we shall review theoretical frameworks for studying experimental gravitation , summarize the current status of experiments , and attempt to chart the future of the subject .
we shall not provide complete references to work done in this field but instead will refer the reader to the appropriate review articles and monographs , specifically to _ theory and experiment in gravitational physics _
@xcite , hereafter referred to as tegp .
additional recent reviews in this subject are refs . , , and .
other references will be confined to reviews or monographs on specific topics , and to important recent papers that are not included in tegp .
references to tegp will be by chapter or section , `` tegp 8.9 '' .
[ eep ] the principle of equivalence has historically played an important role in the development of gravitation theory .
newton regarded this principle as such a cornerstone of mechanics that he devoted the opening paragraph of the _ principia _ to it . in 1907 , einstein used the principle as a basic element of general relativity .
we now regard the principle of equivalence as the foundation , not of newtonian gravity or of gr , but of the broader idea that spacetime is curved .
one elementary equivalence principle is the kind newton had in mind when he stated that the property of a body called `` mass '' is proportional to the `` weight '' , and is known as the weak equivalence principle ( wep ) .
an alternative statement of wep is that the trajectory of a freely falling body ( one not acted upon by such forces as electromagnetism and too small to be affected by tidal gravitational forces ) is independent of its internal structure and composition . in the simplest case of dropping two different bodies in a gravitational field , wep states that the bodies fall with the same acceleration .
a more powerful and far - reaching equivalence principle is known as the einstein equivalence principle ( eep ) .
it states that ( i ) wep is valid , ( ii ) the outcome of any local non - gravitational experiment is independent of the velocity of the freely - falling reference frame in which it is performed , and ( iii ) the outcome of any local non - gravitational experiment is independent of where and when in the universe it is performed . the second piece of eep is called local lorentz invariance ( lli ) , and the third piece
is called local position invariance ( lpi ) .
for example , a measurement of the electric force between two charged bodies is a local non - gravitational experiment ; a measurement of the gravitational force between two bodies ( cavendish experiment ) is not .
the einstein equivalence principle is the heart and soul of gravitational theory , for it is possible to argue convincingly that if eep is valid , then gravitation must be a `` curved spacetime '' phenomenon , in other words , the effects of gravity must be equivalent to the effects of living in a curved spacetime . as a consequence of this argument ,
the only theories of gravity that can embody eep are those that satisfy the postulates of `` metric theories of gravity '' , which are ( i ) spacetime is endowed with a symmetric metric , ( ii ) the trajectories of freely falling bodies are geodesics of that metric , and ( iii ) in local freely falling reference frames , the non - gravitational laws of physics are those written in the language of special relativity . the argument that leads to this conclusion simply notes that , if eep is valid , then in local freely falling frames , the laws governing experiments must be independent of the velocity of the frame ( local lorentz invariance ) , with constant values for the various atomic constants ( in order to be independent of location ) .
the only laws we know of that fulfill this are those that are compatible with special relativity , such as maxwell s equations of electromagnetism .
furthermore , in local freely falling frames , test bodies appear to be unaccelerated , in other words they move on straight lines ; but such `` locally straight '' lines simply correspond to `` geodesics '' in a curved spacetime ( tegp 2.3 ) .
general relativity is a metric theory of gravity , but then so are many others , including the brans - dicke theory .
the nonsymmetric gravitation theory ( ngt ) of moffat is not a metric theory , neither is superstring theory ( see sec . [ newinteractions ] ) .
so the notion of curved spacetime is a very general and fundamental one , and therefore it is important to test the various aspects of the einstein equivalence principle thoroughly .
a direct test of wep is the comparison of the acceleration of two laboratory - sized bodies of different composition in an external gravitational field .
if the principle were violated , then the accelerations of different bodies would differ . the simplest way to quantify such possible violations of wep in a form suitable for comparison with experiment
is to suppose that for a body with inertial mass @xmath0 , the passive gravitational mass @xmath1 is no longer equal to @xmath0 , so that in a gravitational field @xmath2 , the acceleration is given by @xmath3 .
now the inertial mass of a typical laboratory body is made up of several types of mass - energy : rest energy , electromagnetic energy , weak - interaction energy , and so on .
if one of these forms of energy contributes to @xmath1 differently than it does to @xmath0 , a violation of wep would result .
one could then write @xmath4 where @xmath5 is the internal energy of the body generated by interaction @xmath6 , and @xmath7 is a dimensionless parameter that measures the strength of the violation of wep induced by that interaction , and @xmath8 is the speed of light .
a measurement or limit on the fractional difference in acceleration between two bodies then yields a quantity called the `` etvs ratio '' given by @xmath9 where we drop the subscript i from the inertial masses .
thus , experimental limits on @xmath10 place limits on the wep - violation parameters @xmath7 .
many high - precision etvs - type experiments have been performed , from the pendulum experiments of newton , bessel and potter , to the classic torsion - balance measurements of etvs , dicke , braginsky and their collaborators . in the modern torsion - balance experiments ,
two objects of different composition are connected by a rod or placed on a tray and suspended in a horizontal orientation by a fine wire .
if the gravitational acceleration of the bodies differs , there will be a torque induced on the suspension wire , related to the angle between the wire and the direction of the gravitational acceleration @xmath11 .
if the entire apparatus is rotated about some direction with angular velocity @xmath12 , the torque will be modulated with period @xmath13 . in the experiments of etvs and his collaborators , the wire and @xmath11 were not quite parallel because of the centripetal acceleration on the apparatus due to the earth s rotation ; the apparatus was rotated about the direction of the wire . in the princeton ( dicke ) , and moscow ( braginsky ) experiments , @xmath11 was that of the sun , and the rotation of the earth provided the modulation of the torque at a period of 24 hr ( tegp 2.4(a ) ) .
beginning in the late 1980s , numerous experiments were carried out primarily to search for a `` fifth force '' ( see sec .
[ newinteractions ] ) , but their null results also constituted tests of wep . in the `` free - fall galileo experiment '' performed at the university of colorado , the relative free - fall acceleration of two bodies made of uranium and copper was measured using a laser interferometric technique .
the `` et - wash '' experiment carried out at the university of washington used a sophisticated torsion balance tray to compare the accelerations of beryllium and copper toward local topography on earth , movable laboratory masses , the sun and the galaxy.@xcite the resulting upper limits on @xmath10 are summarized in figure 1 ( tegp 14.1 ; for a bibliography of experiments , see ref . .
the second ingredient of eep , local lorentz invariance , can be said to be tested every time that special relativity is confirmed in the laboratory
. however , many such experiments , especially in high - energy physics , are not `` clean '' tests , because in many cases it is unlikely that a violation of lorentz invariance could be distinguished from effects due to the complicated strong and weak interactions .
however , there is one class of experiments that can be interpreted as `` clean '' , high - precision tests of local lorentz invariance .
these are the `` mass anisotropy '' experiments : the classic versions are the hughes - drever experiments , performed in the period 1959 - 60 independently by hughes and collaborators at yale university , and by drever at glasgow university ( tegp 2.4(b ) ) .
dramatically improved versions were carried out during the late 1980s using laser - cooled trapped atom techniques ( tegp 14.1 ) .
a simple and useful way of interpreting these experiments is to suppose that the electromagnetic interactions suffer a slight violation of lorentz invariance , through a change in the speed of electromagnetic radiation @xmath8 relative to the limiting speed of material test particles ( @xmath14 , chosen to be unity via a choice of units ) , in other words , @xmath15 ( see sec .
[ c2formalism ] ) .
such a violation necessarily selects a preferred universal rest frame , presumably that of the cosmic background radiation , through which we are moving at about 300 km / s .
such a lorentz - non - invariant electromagnetic interaction would cause shifts in the energy levels of atoms and nuclei that depend on the orientation of the quantization axis of the state relative to our universal velocity vector , and on the quantum numbers of the state .
the presence or absence of such energy shifts can be examined by measuring the energy of one such state relative to another state that is either unaffected or is affected differently by the supposed violation .
one way is to look for a shifting of the energy levels of states that are ordinarily equally spaced , such as the four @xmath16 ground states of the @xmath17li nucleus in a magnetic field ( drever experiment ) ; another is to compare the levels of a complex nucleus with the atomic hyperfine levels of a hydrogen maser clock .
these experiments have all yielded extremely accurate results , quoted as limits on the parameter @xmath18 in figure 2 . also included for comparison
is the corresponding limit obtained from michelson - morley type experiments .
recent advances in atomic spectroscopy and atomic timekeeping have made it possible to test lli by checking the isotropy of the speed of light using one - way propagation ( as opposed to round - trip propagation , as in the michelson - morley experiment ) . in one experiment , for example ,
the relative phases of two hydrogen maser clocks at two stations of nasa s deep space tracking network were compared over five rotations of the earth by propagating a light signal one - way along an ultrastable fiberoptic link connecting them ( see sec .
[ c2formalism ] ) .
although the bounds from these experiments are not as tight as those from mass - anisotropy experiments , they probe directly the fundamental postulates of special relativity , and thereby of lli .
( tegp 14.1 ) .
the principle of local position invariance , the third part of eep , can be tested by the gravitational redshift experiment , the first experimental test of gravitation proposed by einstein . despite the fact that einstein regarded this as a crucial test of gr , we now realize that it does not distinguish between gr and any other metric theory of gravity , instead is a test only of eep .
a typical gravitational redshift experiment measures the frequency or wavelength shift @xmath19 between two identical frequency standards ( clocks ) placed at rest at different heights in a static gravitational field .
if the frequency of a given type of atomic clock is the same when measured in a local , momentarily comoving freely falling frame ( lorentz frame ) , independent of the location or velocity of that frame , then the comparison of frequencies of two clocks at rest at different locations boils down to a comparison of the velocities of two local lorentz frames , one at rest with respect to one clock at the moment of emission of its signal , the other at rest with respect to the other clock at the moment of reception of the signal .
the frequency shift is then a consequence of the first - order doppler shift between the frames .
the structure of the clock plays no role whatsoever .
the result is a shift @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the difference in the newtonian gravitational potential between the receiver and the emitter .
if lpi is not valid , then it turns out that the shift can be written @xmath22 where the parameter @xmath23 may depend upon the nature of the clock whose shift is being measured ( see tegp 2.4(c ) for details ) .
the first successful , high - precision redshift measurement was the series of pound - rebka - snider experiments of 1960 - 1965 , that measured the frequency shift of gamma - ray photons from @xmath24fe as they ascended or descended the jefferson physical laboratory tower at harvard university . the high accuracy achieved
one percent was obtained by making use of the mssbauer effect to produce a narrow resonance line whose shift could be accurately determined . other experiments since 1960 measured the shift of spectral lines in the sun s gravitational field and the change in rate of atomic clocks transported aloft on aircraft , rockets and satellites .
figure 3 summarizes the important redshift experiments that have been performed since 1960 ( tegp 2.4(c ) ) .
the most precise experiment to date was the vessot - levine rocket redshift experiment that took place in june 1976 .
a hydrogen - maser clock was flown on a rocket to an altitude of about 10,000 km and its frequency compared to a similar clock on the ground .
the experiment took advantage of the masers frequency stability by monitoring the frequency shift as a function of altitude . a sophisticated data acquisition scheme accurately eliminated all effects of the first - order doppler shift due to the rocket s motion , while tracking data were used to determine the payload s location and the velocity ( to evaluate the potential difference @xmath21 , and the special relativistic time dilation )
. analysis of the data yielded a limit @xmath25 . a `` null '' redshift experiment performed in 1978 tested whether the _ relative _ rates of two different clocks depended upon position .
two hydrogen maser clocks and an ensemble of three superconducting - cavity stabilized oscillator ( scso ) clocks were compared over a 10-day period . during this period ,
the solar potential @xmath26 changed sinusoidally with a 24-hour period by @xmath27 because of the earth s rotation , and changed linearly at @xmath28 per day because the earth is 90 degrees from perihelion in april .
however , analysis of the data revealed no variations of either type within experimental errors , leading to a limit on the lpi violation parameter @xmath29 .
this bound is likely to be improved using more stable frequency standards .
@xcite the varying gravitational redshift of earth - bound clocks relative to the highly stable millisecond pulsar , caused by the earth s motion in the solar gravitational field around the earth - moon center of mass ( amplitude 4000 km ) , has been measured to about 10 percent , and the redshift of stable oscillator clocks on the voyager spacecraft caused by saturn s gravitational field yielded a one percent test .
the solar gravitational redshift has been tested to about two percent using infrared oxygen triplet lines at the limb of the sun , and to one percent using oscillator clocks on the galileo spacecraft ( tegp 2.4(c ) and 14.1(a ) ) .
modern advances in navigation using earth - orbiting atomic clocks and accurate time - transfer must routinely take gravitational redshift and time - dilation effects into account .
for example , the global positioning system ( gps ) provides absolute accuracies of around 15 m ( even better in its military mode ) anywhere on earth , which corresponds to 50 nanoseconds in time accuracy at all times . yet
the difference in rate between satellite and ground clocks as a result of special and general relativistic effects is a whopping 40 _ microseconds _ per day ( @xmath30s from the gravitational redshift , and @xmath31s from time dilation ) . if these effects were not accurately accounted for , gps would fail to function at its stated accuracy .
this represents a welcome practical application of gr ! local position invariance also refers to position in time .
if lpi is satisfied , the fundamental constants of non - gravitational physics should be constants in time . table 1 shows current bounds on cosmological variations in selected dimensionless constants . for discussion and references to early work ,
see tegp 2.4(c ) . [ variation ] .bounds on cosmological variation of fundamental constants of non - gravitational physics .
for references to earlier work , see tegp 2.4(c ) . [ cols= " < , < , < " , ] _ psr 1534 + 12_. this is a binary pulsar system in our galaxy .
its pulses are significantly stronger and narrower than those of psr 1913 + 16 , so timing measurements are more precise , reaching @xmath32 accuracy .
its parameters are listed in table 6.@xcite the orbital plane appears to be almost edge - on relative to the line of sight ( @xmath33 ) ; as a result the shapiro delay is substantial , and separate values of the parameters @xmath34 and @xmath35 have been obtained with interesting accuracy . assuming general relativity ,
one infers that the two masses are virtually identical at @xmath36 .
the rate of orbit decay @xmath37 agrees with gr to about 15 percent , the precision limited by the poorly known distance to the pulsar , which introduces a significant uncertainty into the subtraction of galactic acceleration .
_ psr 2127 + 11c .
_ this system appears to be a clone of the hulse - taylor binary pulsar , with very similar values for orbital period and eccentricity ( see table 7 ) .
the inferred total mass of the system is @xmath38 .
because the system is in the globular cluster m15 ( ngc 7078 ) , it will suffer doppler shifts resulting from local accelerations , either by the mean cluster gravitational field or by nearby stars , that are more difficult to estimate than was the case with the galactic system psr 1913 + 16 .
this may make a separate , precision measurement of the relativistic contribution to @xmath37 impossible .
_ psr 1855 + 09_. this binary pulsar system is not particularly relativistic , with a long period ( 12 days ) and highly circular orbit .
however , because we observe the orbit nearly edge on , the shapiro delay is large and measurable , as reflected in the post - keplerian parameters @xmath34 and @xmath35 .
soon after the discovery of the binary pulsar it was widely hailed as a new testing ground for relativistic gravitational effects . as we have seen in the case of gr , in most respects , the system has lived up to , indeed exceeded , the early expectations . in another respect , however , the system has only partially lived up to its promise , namely as a direct testing ground for alternative theories of gravity .
the origin of this promise was the discovery that alternative theories of gravity generically predict the emission of dipole gravitational radiation from binary star systems .
this additional form of gravitational radiation damping could , at least in principle , be significantly stronger than the usual quadrupole damping , because it depends on fewer powers of the parameter @xmath39 , where @xmath40 is the orbital velocity and @xmath8 is the speed of light , and it depends on the gravitational binding energy per unit mass of the bodies , which , for neutron stars , could be as large as 40 per cent . as one fulfillment of this promise , will and eardley worked out in detail the effects of dipole gravitational radiation in the bimetric theory of rosen , and , when the first observation of the decrease of the orbital period was announced in 1978 , the rosen theory suffered a terminal blow ( tegp 12.3 ) . a wide class of alternative theories also fail the binary pulsar test because of dipole gravitational radiation .
on the other hand , the early observations already indicated that , in gr , the masses of the two bodies were nearly equal , so that , in theories of gravity that are in some sense `` close '' to gr , dipole gravitational radiation would not be a strong effect , because of the apparent symmetry of the system ( technically , the amount of dipole radiation depends on the difference between the gravitational binding energy per unit mass for the two bodies ) .
the rosen theory , and others like it , are not `` close '' to general relativity , except in their predictions for the weak - field , slow - motion regime of the solar system .
when relativistic neutron stars are present , theories like these can predict strong effects on the motion of the bodies resulting from their internal highly relativistic gravitational structure ( violations of the strong equivalence principle ) . as a consequence
, the masses inferred from observations such as the periastron shift may be significantly different from those inferred using general relativity , and may be different from each other , leading to strong dipole gravitational radiation damping .
by contrast , the brans - dicke theory , which was the basis for eardley s discovery of the dipole radiation phenomenon , is `` close '' to gr , roughly speaking within @xmath41 of the predictions of the latter , for large values of the coupling constant @xmath42 ( henceforth this notation for the coupling constant is adopted to avoid confusion with the periastron angle ) .
thus , despite the presence of dipole gravitational radiation , the binary pulsar provides at present only a weak test of brans - dicke theory , not yet competitive with solar - system tests . making the usual assumption that both members of the system are neutron stars , and using the methods summarized in tegp chapters 1012 , one can obtain formulas for the periastron shift , the gravitational redshift / second - order doppler shift parameter , and the rate of change of orbital period , analogous to equations [ e43][e45 ] .
these formulas depend on the masses of the two neutron stars , on their self - gravitational binding energy , represented by `` sensitivities '' @xmath35 and @xmath43 and on the brans - dicke coupling constant @xmath42 .
first , there is a modification of kepler s third law , given by @xmath44 then , the predictions for @xmath45 , @xmath46 and @xmath37 are @xmath47 where , to first order in @xmath48 , we have @xmath49 \ , , \label{e55}\\ g(e ) & = & ( 1-e^2 ) ^{-5/2 } ( 1 + { 1 \over 2 } e^2 ) \ , , \label{e56}\\ { \cal s } & = & s_1 - s_2 \ , , \label{e57}\\ { \cal g } & = & 1 - \xi ( s_1 + s_2 - 2s_1 s_2 ) \ , , \label{e58}\\ { \cal p } & = & { \cal g } [ 1 - { 2 \over 3 } \xi + { 1 \over 3 } \xi ( s_1 + s_2 -2s_1 s_2 ) ] \ , , \label{e59}\\ \alpha_2^ * & = & 1 - \xi s_2 \ , , \label{e60}\\ \eta_2^ * & = & ( 1 - 2s_2 ) \xi \ , , \label{e61}\\ \kappa_1 & = & { \cal g}^2 [ 12(1 - { 1 \over 2 } \xi ) + \xi \gamma^2 ] \ , , \label{e62}\\ \kappa_2 & = & { \cal g}^2 [ 11(1 - { 1 \over 2 } \xi ) + { 1 \over 2 } \xi ( \gamma^2 - 5 \gamma \gamma^\prime - { 15 \over 2 } \gamma^{\prime 2 } ) ] \ , , \label{e63}\\ \gamma & = & 1 - 2(m_1 s_2 + m_2 s_1 ) /m \ , , \label{e64}\\ \gamma^\prime & = & 1 - s_1 - s_2 \ , . \label{e65}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the quantities @xmath50 and @xmath51 are defined by @xmath52 and measure the `` sensitivity '' of the mass @xmath53 and moment of inertia @xmath54 of each body to changes in the scalar field ( reflected in changes in @xmath55 ) for a fixed baryon number @xmath56 ( see tegp 11 , 12 and 14.6(c ) for further details ) .
the first term in @xmath37 ( equation [ e54 ] ) is the effect of quadrupole and monopole gravitational radiation , while the second term is the effect of dipole radiation .
equations [ e51][e57 ] are quite general , applying to a class of `` conservative '' theories of gravity whose equations of motion for compact objects can be described by a lagrangian ( tegp 11.3 ) .
the forms of the variables in the remaining equations are specific to brans - dicke theory . in order to estimate the sensitivities @xmath57 , @xmath58 , @xmath59 and @xmath43
, we must adopt an equation of state for the neutron stars .
we restrict attention to relatively stiff neutron star equations of state in order to guarantee neutron stars of sufficient mass , approximately @xmath60 ; the m and o equations of state of arnett and bowers give similar results .
the lower limit on @xmath42 required to give consistency among the constraints on @xmath45 , @xmath61 and @xmath37 as in figure 6 is 105 .
the combination of @xmath45 and @xmath61 give a constraint on the masses that is relatively weakly dependent on @xmath62 , thus the constraint on @xmath62 is dominated by @xmath37 and is directly proportional to the measurement error in @xmath37 ; in order to achieve a constraint comparable to the solar system value of @xmath63 , the error in @xmath64 would have to be reduced by more than a factor of ten .
damour and esposito - farse @xcite have devised a scalar - tensor theory in which two scalar fields are tuned so that their effects in the weak - field slow - motion regime of the solar system are suppressed , so that the theory is identical to general relativity in the post - newtonian approximation . yet in the regime appropriate to binary pulsars , it predicts strong - field sep - violating effects and radiative effects that distinguish it from gr .
it gives formulae for the post - keplerian parameters of equations [ e52][e54 ] as well as for the parameters @xmath34 and @xmath35 that have corrections dependent upon the sensitivities of the relativistic neutron stars .
the theory depends upon two arbitrary parameters @xmath65 and @xmath66 ; gr corresponds to the values @xmath67 .
it turns out that the binary pulsar psr 1913 + 16 alone constrains the two parameters to a narrow but long strip in the @xmath68-plane that includes the origin ( gr ) but that could include some highly non - general relativistic theories .
the sensitivity of psr 1534 + 12 to @xmath34 and @xmath35 provides an orthogonal constraint that cuts the strip . in this class of theories , then , _ both _
binary pulsars are needed to provide a strong test .
interestingly , it is the strong - field aspects of psr 1534 + 12 , not gravitational radiation , that provide the non - trivial new constraint . in scalar - tensor theories subject to `` spontaneous - scalarization '' in neutron - star interiors ,
the bounds from binary pulsars can be significantly stronger than those from the solar - system.@xcite
some time in the next decade , a new opportunity for testing relativistic gravity may be realized , with the completion and operation of kilometer - scale , laser interferometric gravitational - wave observatories in the u.s .
( ligo project ) , europe ( virgo and geo-600 projects ) and japan ( tama 300 project ) .
gravitational - wave searches at these observatories are scheduled to commence around 2002 .
the ligo broad - band antennae will have the capability of detecting and measuring the gravitational waveforms from astronomical sources in a frequency band between about 10 hz ( the seismic noise cutoff ) and 500 hz ( the photon counting noise cutoff ) , with a maximum sensitivity to strain at around 100 hz of @xmath69 ( rms ) .
the most promising source for detection and study of the gravitational - wave signal is the `` inspiralling compact binary '' a binary system of neutron stars or black holes ( or one of each ) in the final minutes of a death dance leading to a violent merger .
such is the fate , for example of the hulse - taylor binary pulsar psr 1913 + 16 in about 300 m years . given the expected sensitivity of the `` advanced ligo '' ( around 2007 ) , which could see such sources out to hundreds of megaparsecs , it has been estimated that from 3 to 100 annual inspiral events could be detectable .
other sources , such as supernova core collapse events , instabilities in rapidly rotating nascent neutron stars , signals from non - axisymmetric pulsars , and a stochastic background of waves , may be detectable ( for reviews , see ref .
and articles in this volume ) .
detailed observation of gravitational waves from such sources may provide the means to test general relativistic predictions for the polarization and speed of the waves , and for gravitational radiation damping .
several of these tests can be realized using gravitational - waves from inspiralling compact binaries .
the analysis of gravitational - wave data from such sources will involve some form of matched filtering of the noisy detector output against an ensemble of theoretical `` template '' waveforms which depend on the intrinsic parameters of the inspiralling binary , such as the component masses , spins , and so on , and on its inspiral evolution .
how accurate must a template be in order to `` match '' the waveform from a given source ( where by a match we mean maximizing the cross - correlation or the signal - to - noise ratio ) ? in the total accumulated phase of the wave detected in the sensitive bandwidth , the template must match the signal to a fraction of a cycle . for two inspiralling neutron stars , around 16,000 cycles
should be detected ; this implies a phasing accuracy of @xmath70 or better . since @xmath71 during the late inspiral , this means that correction terms in the phasing at the level of @xmath72 or higher are needed .
more formal analyses confirm this intuition.@xcite because it is a slow - motion system ( @xmath73 ) , the binary pulsar is sensitive only to the lowest - order effects of gravitational radiation as predicted by the quadrupole formula .
nevertheless , the first correction terms of order @xmath39 and @xmath74 to the quadrupole formula , were calculated as early as 1976 ( tegp 10.3 ) .
these are now conventionally called `` post - newtonian '' ( pn ) corrections , with each power of @xmath39 corresponding to half a post - newtonian order ( 1/2pn ) , in analogy with post - newtonian corrections to the newtonian equations of motion.@xcite but for laser - interferometric observations of gravitational waves , the bottom line is that , in order to measure the astrophysical parameters of the source and to test the properties of the gravitational waves , it is necessary to derive the gravitational waveform and the resulting radiation back - reaction on the orbit phasing at least to 2pn , or second post - newtonian order , @xmath75 $ ] , beyond the quadrupole approximation , and probably to 3pn order .
the generation of gravitational radiation is a long - standing problem that dates back to the first years following the publication of gr , when einstein calculated the gravitational radiation emitted by a laboratory - scale object using the linearized version of gr . shortly after the discovery of the binary pulsar psr 1913 + 16 in 1974
, questions were raised about the foundations of the `` quadrupole formula '' for gravitational radiation damping ( and in some quarters , even about its quantitative validity ) .
these questions were answered in part by theoretical work designed to shore up the foundations of the quadrupole approximation,@xcite and in part ( perhaps mostly ) by the agreement between the predictions of the quadrupole formula and the _ observed _ rate of damping of the pulsar s orbit . in 1976 , the post - newtonian corrections to the quadrupole formula were of purely academic , rather than observational interest .
the challenge of providing accurate templates for ligo - virgo data analysis has led to major efforts to calculate gravitational waves to high pn order .
three approaches have been developed .
the bdi approach of blanchet , damour and iyer is based on a mixed post - newtonian and `` post - minkowskian '' framework for solving einstein s equations approximately , developed in a long series of papers by damour and colleagues.@xcite the idea is to solve the vacuum einstein equations in the exterior of the material sources extending out to the radiation zone in an expansion ( `` post - minkowskian '' ) in `` nonlinearity '' ( effectively an expansion in powers of newton s constant @xmath55 ) , and to express the asymptotic solutions in terms of a set of formal , time - dependent , symmetric and trace - free ( stf ) multipole moments.@xcite then , in a near zone within one characteristic wavelength of the radiation , the equations including the material source are solved in a slow - motion approximation ( expansion in powers of @xmath76 ) that yields a set of stf source multipole moments expressed as integrals over the `` effective '' source , including both matter and gravitational field contributions .
the solutions involving the two sets of moments are then matched in an intermediate zone , resulting in a connection between the formal radiative moments and the source moments .
the matching also provides a natural way , using analytic continuation , to regularize integrals involving the non - compact contributions of gravitational stress - energy , that might otherwise be divergent .
an approach called dire is based on a framework developed by epstein and wagoner ( ew)@xcite , and extended by will , wiseman and pati .
we shall describe dire briefly below .
a third approach , valid only in the limit in which one mass is much smaller than the other , is that of black - hole perturbation theory .
this method provides numerical results that are exact in @xmath39 , as well as analytical results expressed as series in powers of @xmath39 , both for non - rotating and for rotating black holes . for non - rotating holes ,
the analytical expansions have been carried to _ 5.5 _ pn order.@xcite in all cases of suitable overlap , the results of all three methods agree precisely . like the bdi approach ,
dire involves rewriting the einstein equations in their `` relaxed '' form , namely as an inhomogeneous , flat - spacetime wave equation for a field @xmath77 , whose formal solution can be written @xmath78 where the source @xmath79 consists of both the material stress - energy , and a `` gravitational stress - energy '' made up of all the terms non - linear in @xmath77 , and the integration is over the past flat - spacetime null - cone @xmath80 of the field point @xmath81 ( see fig . 7 )
the wave equation is accompanied by a harmonic or dedonder gauge condition @xmath82 , which serves to specify a coordinate system , and also imposes equations of motion on the sources . unlike the bdi approach , a _ single _
formal solution is written down , valid everywhere in spacetime .
this formal solution , is then iterated in a slow - motion ( @xmath83 ) , weak - field ( @xmath84 ) approximation , that is very similar to the corresponding procedure in electromagnetism .
however , because the integrand of this retarded integral is not compact by virture of the non - linear field contributions , the original ew formalism quickly runs up against integrals that are not well defined , or worse , are divergent .
although at the lowest quadrupole and first few pn orders , various arguments can be given to justify sweeping such problems under the rug,@xcite they are not very rigorous , and provide no guarantee that the divergences do not become insurmountable at higher orders . as a consequence , despite efforts to cure the problem , the ew formalism fell into some disfavor as a route to higher orders ,
although an extension to 3/2pn order was accomplished.@xcite the resolution of this problem involves taking literally the statement that the solution is a _ retarded _ integral , _
i.e. _ an integral over the
_ entire _ past null cone of the field point.@xcite to be sure , that part of the integral that extends over the intersection @xmath85 between the past null cone and the material source and the near zone is still approximated as usual by a slow - motion expansion involving spatial integrals over @xmath86 of moments of the source , including the non - compact gravitational contributions , just as in the bdi framework ( fig . 8) .
but instead of cavalierly extending the spatial integrals to infinity as was implicit in the original ew framework , and risking undefined or divergent integrals , we terminate the integrals at the boundary of the near zone , chosen to be at a radius @xmath87 given roughly by one wavelength of the gravitational radiation . for the integral over the rest of the past null cone exterior to the near zone ( `` radiation zone '' ) ,
we neither make a slow - motion expansion nor continue to integrate over a spatial hypersurface , instead we use a coordinate transformation in the integral from the spatial coordinates @xmath88 to quasi - null coordinates @xmath89 , @xmath90 , @xmath91 , where @xmath92 to convert the integral into a convenient , easy - to - calculate form , that is manifestly convergent , subject only to reasonable assumptions about the past behavior of the source : @xmath93 ^ 2 d^2 \omega^\prime \,.\ ] ] this transformation was suggested by earlier work on a non - linear gravitational - wave phenomenon called the christodoulou memory.@xcite not only are all integrations now explicitly finite and convergent , one can show that all contributions from the finite , near - zone spatial integrals that depend upon @xmath87 are actually _ cancelled _ by corresponding terms from the radiation - zone integrals , valid for both positive and negative powers of @xmath87 and for terms logarithmic in @xmath87.@xcite thus the procedure , as expected , has no dependence on the artificially chosen boundary radius @xmath87 of the near - zone .
in addition , the method can be carried to higher orders in a straightforward manner .
the result is a manifestly finite , well - defined procedure for calculating gravitational radiation to high orders .
the result of the dire or bdi calculations is an explicit formula for two - body systems in general orbits , for the transverse - traceless ( tt ) part of the radiation - zone field , denoted @xmath94 , and representing the deviation of the metric from flat spacetime . in terms of an expansion beyond the quadrupole formula , it has the schematic form , @xmath95 \right\ } _ { tt } \
, , \label{1 - 1}\ ] ] where @xmath96 is the reduced mass , @xmath97 is the distance to the source , and @xmath98 represents two time derivatives of the mass quadrupole moment tensor ( the series actually contains multipole orders beyond quadrupole ) .
the expansion parameter @xmath99 is related to the orbital variables by @xmath100 , where @xmath34 is the distance between the bodies , @xmath40 is the relative velocity , and @xmath101 is the total mass ( @xmath102 ) .
the 1/2pn and 1pn terms were derived by wagoner and will,@xcite the 3/2pn terms by wiseman.@xcite the contribution of gravitational - wave `` tails '' , caused by backscatter of the outgoing radiation off the background spacetime curvature , at @xmath103 , were derived and studied by several authors .
the 2pn terms including 2pn tail contributions were derived by two independent groups and are in complete agreement ( see refs . for details and references to earlier work ) .
there are also contributions to the waveform due to intrinsic spin of the bodies , which occur at @xmath103 ( spin - orbit ) and @xmath104 ( spin - spin ) ; these have been calculated elsewhere.@xcite given the gravitational waveform , one can compute the rate at which energy is carried off by the radiation ( schematically @xmath105 , the gravitational analog of the poynting flux ) .
for the special case of non - spinning bodies moving on quasi - circular orbits ( _ i.e. _ circular apart from a slow inspiral ) , the energy flux through 2pn order has the form @xmath106 \ ; , \label{edot}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath107 .
the first term is the quadrupole contribution , the second term is the 1pn contribution , the third term , with the coefficient @xmath108 , is the `` tail '' contribution , and the fourth term is the 2pn contribution first reported jointly by blanchet _
et al._@xcite calculation of the 3pn contributions is nearing completion .
similar expressions can be derived for the loss of angular momentum and linear momentum .
these losses react back on the orbit to circularize it and cause it to inspiral .
the result is that the orbital phase ( and consequently the gravitational - wave phase ) evolves non - linearly with time .
it is the sensitivity of the broad - band ligo and virgo - type detectors to phase that makes the higher - order contributions to @xmath109 so observationally relevant .
a ready - to - use set of formulae for the 2pn gravitational waveform template , including the non - linear evolution of the gravitational - wave frequency ( not including spin effects ) have been published@xcite and incorporated into the gravitational radiation analysis and simulation package ( grasp ) , a publically available software toolkit.@xcite a laser - interferometric or resonant bar gravitational - wave detector measures the local components of a symmetric @xmath110 tensor which is composed of the `` electric '' components of the riemann tensor , @xmath111 .
these six independent components can be expressed in terms of polarizations ( modes with specific transformation properties under null rotations ) .
three are transverse to the direction of propagation , with two representing quadrupolar deformations and one representing a monopole `` breathing '' deformation .
three modes are longitudinal , with one an axially symmetric stretching mode in the propagation direction , and one quadrupolar mode in each of the two orthogonal planes containing the propagation direction .
general relativity predicts only the first two transverse quadrupolar modes , independently of the source , while scalar - tensor gravitational waves can in addition contain the transverse breathing mode .
more general metric theories predict up to the full complement of six modes ( tegp 10.2 ) .
a suitable array of gravitational antennas could delineate or limit the number of modes present in a given wave .
the strategy depends on whether or not the source direction is known .
in general there are eight unknowns ( six polarizations and two direction cosines ) , but only six measurables ( @xmath111 ) .
if the direction can be established by either association of the waves with optical or other observations , or by time - of - flight measurements between separated detectors , then six suitably oriented detectors suffice to determine all six components . if the direction can not be established , then the system is underdetermined , and no unique solution can be found .
however , if one assumes that only transverse waves are present , then there are only three unknowns if the source direction is known , or five unknowns otherwise .
then the corresponding number ( three or five ) of detectors can determine the polarization .
if distinct evidence were found of any mode other than the two transverse quadrupolar modes of gr , the result would be disastrous for gr .
on the other hand , the absence of a breathing mode would not necessarily rule out scalar - tensor gravity , because the strength of that mode depends on the nature of the source .
although some of the details of implementing such polarization observations have been worked out for arrays of resonant cylindrical , disk - shaped , and spherical detectors ( tegp 10.2 , ref . ) only initial work has been done to assess whether the ground - based laser - interferometers ( ligo , virgo , geo600 , tama300 ) could perform interesting polarization measurements .
the results depend sensitively on the relative orientation of the detectors arms , which are now cast ( literally ) in concrete . according to gr , in the limit
in which the wavelength of gravitational waves is small compared to the radius of curvature of the background spacetime , the waves propagate along null geodesics of the background spacetime , _
i.e. _ they have the same speed , @xmath8 , as light ( henceforth , we do not set @xmath112 ) .
in other theories , the speed could differ from @xmath8 because of coupling of gravitation to `` background '' gravitational fields .
for example , in the rosen bimetric theory with a flat background metric @xmath113 , gravitational waves follow null geodesics of @xmath113 , while light follows null geodesics of @xmath114 ( tegp 10.1 ) .
another way in which the speed of gravitational waves could differ from @xmath8 is if gravitation were propagated by a massive field ( a massive graviton ) , in which case , @xmath115 would be given by , in a local inertial frame , @xmath116 where @xmath117 and @xmath118 are the graviton rest mass and energy , respectively . for a recent review of the idea of a massive graviton see ref . .
the most obvious way to test this is to compare the arrival times of a gravitational wave and an electromagnetic wave from the same event , _
e.g. _ a supernova . for a source at a distance @xmath119 , the resulting value of the difference
@xmath120 is @xmath121 where @xmath122 is the `` time difference '' , where @xmath123 and @xmath124 are the differences in arrival time and emission time , respectively , of the two signals , and @xmath125 is the redshift of the source . in many cases
, @xmath124 is unknown , so that the best one can do is employ an upper bound on @xmath124 based on observation or modelling .
the result will then be a bound on @xmath120 . for a massive graviton , if the frequency of the gravitational waves is such that @xmath126 , where @xmath127 is planck s constant , then @xmath128 , where @xmath129 is the graviton compton wavelength , and the bound on @xmath120 can be converted to a bound on @xmath130 , given by @xmath131 the foregoing discussion assumes that the source emits _ both _ gravitational and electromagnetic radiation in detectable amounts , and that the relative time of emission can be established to sufficient accuracy , or can be shown to be sufficiently small .
however , there is a situation in which a bound on the graviton mass can be set using gravitational radiation alone.@xcite that is the case of the inspiralling compact binary . because the frequency of the gravitational radiation sweeps from low frequency at the initial moment of observation to higher frequency at the final moment , the speed of the gravitons emitted will vary , from lower speeds initially to higher speeds ( closer to @xmath8 ) at the end
this will cause a distortion of the observed phasing of the waves and result in a shorter than expected overall time @xmath123 of passage of a given number of cycles .
furthermore , through the technique of matched filtering , the parameters of the compact binary can be measured accurately , ( assuming that gr is a good approximation to the orbital evolution , even in the presence of a massive graviton ) , and thereby the emission time @xmath124 can be determined accurately .
roughly speaking , the `` phase interval '' @xmath132 in eq .
( [ eq4 ] ) can be measured to an accuracy @xmath133 , where @xmath134 is the signal - to - noise ratio .
thus one can estimate the bounds on @xmath130 achievable for various compact inspiral systems , and for various detectors . for stellar - mass inspiral ( neutron stars or black holes )
observed by the ligo / virgo class of ground - based interferometers , @xmath135 , @xmath136 , and @xmath137 .
the result is @xmath138 . for supermassive binary black holes ( @xmath139 to @xmath140 )
observed by the proposed laser - interferometer space antenna ( lisa ) , @xmath141 , @xmath142 , and @xmath143 .
the result is @xmath144 .
a full noise analysis using proposed noise curves for the advanced ligo and for lisa weakens these crude bounds by factors between two and 10 .
these potential bounds can be compared with the solid bound @xmath145 , derived from solar system dynamics , which limit the presence of a yukawa modification of newtonian gravity of the form @xmath146 , @xcite and with the model - dependent bound @xmath147 from consideration of galactic and cluster dynamics @xcite .
this plays an important role only in the inspiral of compact objects .
the equations of motion of inspiral include the non - radiative , non - linear post - newtonian corrections of newtonian motion , as well as radiation back - reaction and its non - linear post - newtonian corrections .
the evolution of the orbit is imprinted on the phasing of the inspiral waveform , to which broad - band laser interferometers are especially sensitive through the use of matched filtering of the data against theoretical templates derived from gr.@xcite a number of tests of gr using matched filtering of binary inspiral have been discussed , including putting a bound on scalar - tensor gravity @xcite , measuring the non - linear `` tail term '' in gravitational radiation damping @xcite ( the `` @xmath108 '' term in eq .
( [ edot ] ) ) , and testing the gr `` no hair '' theorems by mapping spacetime outside black holes @xcite .
for example , the dipole gravitational radiation predicted by scalar - tensor theories results in modifications in gravitational - radiation back - reaction . the effects are strongest for systems involving a neutron star and a black hole .
double neutron star systems are less promising because the small range of masses available near @xmath148 results in suppression of dipole radiation by symmetry .
double black - hole systems turn out to be observationally identical in the two theories .
for example , for a @xmath149 neutron star and a @xmath150 ( @xmath151 ) black hole at 200 mpc , the bound on @xmath42 could be 600 ( 1800 ) ( using advanced ligo noise curves ) .
the bound increases linearly with signal - to - noise ratio .
if one demands that this test be performed annually , thus requiring observation of frequent , and therefore more distant , weaker sources , the bounds on @xmath42 will be too weak to compete with existing bounds .
however , if one is prepared to wait 10 years for the lucky observation of a nearby , strong source , the resulting bound could exceed the current bound .
the bounds are illustrated in figure 10 by the curves marked @xmath152 and @xmath153 .
figure 10 assumes a double - neutron - star inspiral rate of @xmath154 per year per galaxy , and a black - hole - neutron - star rate @xmath155 times that , where @xmath155 is highly uncertain .
in 1998 we find that general relativity has held up under extensive experimental scrutiny .
the question then arises , why bother to continue to test it ?
one reason is that gravity is a fundamental interaction of nature , and as such requires the most solid empirical underpinning we can provide .
another is that all attempts to quantize gravity and to unify it with the other forces suggest that the standard general relativity of einstein is not likely to be the last word .
furthermore , the predictions of general relativity are fixed ; the theory contains no adjustable constants so nothing can be changed .
thus every test of the theory is either a potentially deadly test or a possible probe for new physics .
although it is remarkable that this theory , born 80 years ago out of almost pure thought , has managed to survive every test , the possibility of finding a discrepancy will continue to drive experiments for years to come .
this work was supported in part by the national science foundation , grant number phy 96 - 00049 .
c. m. will _ was einstein right ? _
( basic books , new york , 1993 ) . c. m. will
, _ theory and experiment in gravitational physics _
( cambridge university press , cambridge , 1993 ) . c. m. will , in _ 300 years of gravitation _ ,
edited by s. w. hawking and w. israel , 80127 ( cambridge university press , cambridge , 1987 ) , p. 80 . c. m. will , int j. mod .
d * 1 * , 13 ( 1992 ) . c. m.
will , in _ general relativity : proceedings of the 46th scottish universities summer school in physics _ , ed .
g. s. hall and j. r. pulham ( institute of physics publishing , bristol , 1996 ) , p. 239 .
t. damour , in _ proceedings of the 5th hellenic school on elementary particle physics _ , in press
( gr - qc/9606079 ) .
y. su , b. r. heckel , e. g. adelberger , j. h. gundlach , m. harris , g. l. smith , and h. e. swanson , phys .
d * 50 * , 3614 ( 1994 ) .
e. fischbach , g. t. gillies , d. e. krause , j. g. schwan , and c. talmadge , metrologia * 29 * , 213 ( 1992 ) .
a. godone , c. novero , and p. tavella , phys .
d * 51 * , 319 ( 1995 ) .
j. d. prestage , r. l. tjoelker , and l. maleki , phys .
lett . * 74 * , 3511 ( 1995 ) .
f. dyson and t. damour , nucl .
b480 * , 37 ( 1996 ) ( hep - ph/9606486 ) .
m. j. drinkwater , j. k. webb , j. d. barrow , and v. v. flambaum , mon . not .
. soc . * 295 * , 457 ( 1998 ) ( astro - ph/9711290 ) .
r. a. malaney and g. mathews , phys . rep . * 229 * , 147 ( 1993 ) ; h. reeves , rev .
phys . * 66 * , 193 ( 1994 ) .
c. m. will , phys .
d * 45 * 403 ( 1992 ) .
e. fischbach and c. talmadge , nature * 356 * , 207 ( 1992 ) .
c. m. will , sky and telescope * 80 * , 472 ( 1990 ) .
e. g. adelberger , b. r. heckel , c. w. stubbs , and w. f. rogers , ann .
particle sci . * 41 * , 269 ( 1991 ) . c. w. misner , k. s. thorne , and j. a. wheeler , _ gravitation _ ( freeman publishing co , san francisco , 1973 ) . s. w. weinberg s w , _ gravitation and cosmology _ ( wiley , new york , 1992 )
. t. damour and g. esposito - farse , class .
quantum grav .
* 9 * , 2093 ( 1992 ) .
t. damour and k. nordtvedt , phys .
70 * , 2217 ( 1993 ) ; phys .
d * 48 * , 3436 ( 1993 ) .
p. j. steinhardt and c. m. will , phys .
d * 52 * , 628 ( 1995 ) ( astro - ph/9409041 ) .
t. damour and g. esposito - farse , phys.rev .
d * 54 * , 1474 ( 1996 ) ( gr - qc/9602056 ) .
t. m. eubanks , d. n. matsakis , j. o. martin , b. a. archinal , d. d. mccarthy , s. a. klioner , s. shapiro , and i. i. shapiro , bull . am . phys . soc .
, abstract # k 11.05 ( 1997 ) , unpublished m. froeschl , f. mignard and f. arenou , in _ proceedings of the hipparcos venice 1997 symposium _ , in press .
k. nordtvedt , icarus * 114 * , 51 ( 1995 ) .
t. damour and d. vokrouhlick , phys .
d , * 53 * , 6740 ( 1996 ) ( gr - qc/9606076 ) .
j. o. dickey , p. l. bender , j. e. faller , x x newhall , r. l. ricklefs , j. g. ries , p. j. shelus , c. veillet , a. l. whipple , j. r. wiant , j. g. williams , and c. f. yoder , science * 265 * , 482 ( 1994 ) ; j. g. williams , x x newhall , and j. o. dickey , , 6730 ( 1996 ) . j. f. bell and t. damour , class .
quantum grav .
* 13 * , 3121 ( 1996 ) ( gr - qc/9606062 )
. j. f. bell , f. camilo , t. damour , astrophys .
j. * 464 * , 857 ( 1996 ) ( astro - ph/9512100 ) . c. m. will , astrophys j * 204 * , 224 ( 1976 ) . c. m.
will , astrophys j. lett . *
393 * , l59 ( 1992 ) . for information about the project ,
see http://einstein.stanford.edu/. i. ciufolini , e. pavlis , f. chieppa , e. fernandes - vieira , and j. pirez - mercader , science * 279 * , 2100 ( 1998 ) . k. s. thorne , in _ proceedings of the snowmass 95 summer study on particle and nuclear astrophysics and cosmology _ , edited by e. w. kolb and r. peccei ( world scientific , singapore , 1995 ) , p. 398
( gr - qc/9506086 ) .
r. a. hulse , rev .
* 66 * , 699 ( 1994 ) .
j. h. taylor , rev .
phys . * 66 * , 711 ( 1994 ) .
t. damour , 1987 , in _ 300 years of gravitation _ , eds hawking s w and israel w , 128198 ( cambridge university press , cambridge )
. m. kramer , astrophys .
j. , in press ( astro - ph/9808127 ) .
a. wolszczan , class .
quantum grav . * 11 * , a227 ( 1994 ) .
i. h. stairs , z. arzoumanian , f. camilio , a. g. lyne , d. j. nice , j. h. taylor , s. e. thorsett , and a. wolszczan , astrophys . j. , in press ( astro - ph/9712296 ) . l. s. finn and d. f. chernoff , phys .
d * 47 * , 2198 ( 1993 ) ( gr - qc/9301003 ) ; c. cutler and .
e. flanagan , phys .
d * 49 * , 2658 ( 1994 ) ( gr - qc/9402014 ) ; e. poisson and c. m. will , phys .
d * 52 * , 848 ( 1995 ) ( gr - qc/9502040 ) .
this convention holds sway , despite the fact that pure newtonian gravity predicts no gravitational radiation .
it is often the source of confusion , since the energy carried by the lowest - order `` newtonian '' quadrupole radiation manifests itself in a ( post)@xmath156-newtonian , or @xmath157 $ ] correction in the equation of motion .
m. walker and c. m. will , phys
* 45 * , 1741 ( 1980 ) ; j. l. anderson , phys .
* 45 * , 1745 ( 1980 ) ; t. damour , phys .
51 * , 1019 ( 1983 ) ; d. christodoulou and b. g. schmidt , commun .
phys . * 68 * , 275 ( 1979 ) ; r. a. isaacson , j. s. welling , and j. winicour , phys . rev
* 53 * , 1870 ( 1984 ) .
l. blanchet , t. damour , phil .
london * a320 * , 379 ( 1986 ) ; l. blanchet and t. damour , phys . rev .
d * 37 * , 1410 ( 1988 ) ; l. blanchet and t. damour , ann .
h. poincar ( phys
. theorique ) * 50 * , 377 ( 1989 ) ; t. damour and b. r. iyer , ann .
h. poincar ( phys
. theorique ) * 54 * , 115 ( 1991 ) ; l. blanchet , phys .
d * 51 * , 2559 ( 1995 ) ( gr - qc/9501030 ) ; l. blanchet and t. damour , phys
d * 46 * , 4304 ( 1992 ) .
k. s. thorne , rev .
phys . * 52 * , 299 ( 1980 ) .
r. epstein and r. v. wagoner , astrophys .
j. * 197 * , 717 ( 1975 ) ( ew ) .
e. poisson , phys .
d * 47 * , 1497 ( 1993 ) ; e. poisson and m. sasaki , phys . rev .
d * 51 * , 5753 ( 1995 ) ( gr - qc/9412027 ) ; c. cutler , l. s. finn , e. poisson , and g. j. sussman , phys .
d * 47 * , 1511 ( 1993 ) ; m. sasaki , prog .
theor . phys . *
92 * , 17 ( 1994 ) ( gr - qc/9402042 ) ; h. tagoshi and m. sasaki , prog .
. phys . * 92 * , 745 ( 1994 ) ( gr - qc/9405062 ) ; t. tanaka , h. tagoshi , and m. sasaki , prog .
* 96 * , 1087 ( 1996 ) ( gr - qc/9701050 ) .
r. v. wagoner and c. m. will , astrophys .
j. * 210 * , 764 ( 1976 ) .
a. g. wiseman , phys .
d * 46 * 1517 ( 1992 ) . c. m. will and a. g. wiseman , phys .
d * 54 * , 4813 ( 1996 ) ( gr - qc/9608012 ) .
a. g. wiseman and c. m. will , phys .
d * 44 * , r2945 ( 1991 ) . c. m. will and m. e. pati , papers in preparation .
l. blanchet , t. damour , and b. r. iyer , phys .
d * 51 * , 5360 ( 1995 ) ( gr - qc/9501029 ) .
l. e. kidder , c. m. will , and a. g. wiseman , phys .
d * 47 * , r4183 ( 1993 ) ( gr - qc/9211025 ) ; l. e. kidder , phys .
d * 52 * , 821 ( 1995 ) ( gr - qc/9506022 ) .
l. blanchet , t. damour , b. r. iyer , c. m. will and a. g. wiseman , phys .
lett . * 74 * , 3515 ( 1995 ) ( gr - qc/9501027 ) .
l. blanchet , b. r. iyer , c. m. will , and a. g. wiseman , class .
quantum grav .
* 13 * , 575 ( 1996 ) ( gr - qc/9602024 ) .
see http://www.ligo.caltech.edu/ligo_web/collaboration/manual.pdf .
j. a. lobo , , 591 ( 1995 ) .
m. visser , gen .
, in press ( gr - qc/9705051 )
. c. m. will , , 2061 ( 1998 ) ( gr - qc/9709011 ) . c. talmadge , j .-
berthias , r. w. hellings , and e. m. standish , phys .
rev . lett . * 61 * , 1159 ( 1988 ) . c. cutler , t. a. apostolatos , l. bildsten , l. s. finn , .
e. flanagan , d. kennefick , d. m. markovi , a. ori , e. poisson , g. j. sussman , and k. s. thorne , phys .
lett . * 70 * , 2984 ( 1993 ) ( astro - ph/9208005 ) . c. m.
will , 6058 ( 1994 ) ( gr - qc/9406022 )
. l. blanchet and b. s. sathyaprakash , class .
quantum grav . * 11 * , 2807 ( 1994 ) ; phys .
lett . * 74 * , 1067 ( 1995 ) .
f. d. ryan , , 5707 ( 1995 ) ; e. poisson , , 5939 ( 1996 ) ( gr - qc/9606024 ) . | the status of experimental tests of general relativity and of theoretical frameworks for analysing them are reviewed .
einstein s equivalence principle ( eep ) is well supported by experiments such as the etvs experiment , tests of special relativity , and the gravitational redshift experiment .
future tests of eep will search for new interactions arising from unification or quantum gravity .
tests of general relativity have reached high precision , including the light deflection , the shapiro time delay , the perihelion advance of mercury , and the nordtvedt effect in lunar motion .
gravitational wave damping has been detected to half a percent using the binary pulsar , and new binary pulsar systems promise further improvements .
when direct observation of gravitational radiation from astrophysical sources begins , new tests of general relativity will be possible . |
figure [ rho_t ] shows the temperature dependence of @xmath4-axis resistivity at zero and 45 t fields . at zero field
, @xmath11 is metallic all the way down to @xmath0 .
this represents a clear contrast with the semiconductinglike upturn in @xmath14 observed at lower dopings of bi@xmath2sr@xmath2cacu@xmath2o@xmath15 @xcite in the pseudogap state @xcite .
we can examine our data within the overall temperature dependence @xmath16 which reproduces the temperature dependence of @xmath13 @xcite .
also , it can be as easily fitted by a power law with the exponent 1.3 ( @xmath17 ) ( inset in fig .
[ rho_t ] ) . regardless of the choice
, the temperature dependence is not @xmath7-quadratic as in a conventional fl ; it marks an n - fl state even in the heavily overdoped region .
when we apply 45 t along the @xmath4 axis , the superconductivity is destroyed and the entire temperature dependence up to 100 k can now be fitted with the simple fl form @xmath18 .
this clearly demonstrates that sufficiently high magnetic fields destroy all remnants of the n - fl behavior , recovering the all familiar fermi - liquid metal ; _ i.e. _ in this overdoped cuprate there exists _ a field - induced transformation from the n - fl to fl state_. to follow the temperature dependence of @xmath14 at different fields we plot it against @xmath1 in fig .
[ rho_t2 ] .
it is evident that the @xmath19 dependence is observed below a field - dependent temperature @xmath20 indicated by the arrows . at higher temperatures
the @xmath11 data deviate from the @xmath1 behavior as can be seen more clearly by subtracting @xmath21 in the upper panel .
we note that although the change is gradual , the power in the temperature dependence unmistakably changes from 2 at low temperatures ( @xmath22 ) to less than 2 at high temperatures ( @xmath23 ) .
the field dependence of the @xmath20 is depicted in the @xmath7-@xmath24 diagram in fig .
[ t_h ] . at 45
t , fl state extends up to 100 k , and at lower fields the fermi liquid breaks down crossing to an n - fl behavior above @xmath20 .
with decreasing field @xmath25 decreases linearly and extrapolates to zero in the vicinity of the upper critical field @xmath26 [ see below ] , terminating at a putative qcp .
we conclude then that in zero temperature limit , the normal state above @xmath27 in tl@xmath2ba@xmath2cuo@xmath3 is a fermi liquid , in agreement with the recent observation in this system of the wiedemann - franz law @xcite .
next we examine the field dependence of @xmath14 at constant temperatures , plotted in fig .
[ rho_h](a ) . at low temperatures ,
the resistivity is zero below the so - called irreversibility field @xmath28 @xcite in the vortex solid state .
we note that above @xmath28 the magnetoresistance is always _
positive_. we recall that in less - doped pseudogapped bi@xmath2sr@xmath2cacu@xmath2o@xmath15 the observed magnetoresistance is _ negative _ over a large field range @xcite , consistent with filling of the low - energy states within the pseudogap in the applied magnetic field .
we surmise then , that at this doping the pseudogap is either way below the superconducting energy scale , or perhaps entirely absent .
the superconducting coherence can survive up to a characteristic field @xmath29 , above which the quasiparticle conductivity overcomes the vortex contribution @xcite .
this often underestimates the upper critical field @xmath27 near @xmath0 in high-@xmath0 cuprates ; it is notoriously difficult to obtain from transport owing to large thermal fluctuations .
however , previous studies of @xmath4-axis magnetotransport @xcite revealed that in the overdoped regime in the low-@xmath7 limit , @xmath27 is very near @xmath30 . in our sample
we evaluate @xmath31 t. above this limiting field @xmath32 at low-@xmath7 is strictly @xmath24-linear in the normal state over the entire field range . to take a closer look at higher @xmath7
, we subtract the high - field linear term from @xmath32 and obtain @xmath33 , which quantifies the deviation from the @xmath24-linear dependence .
this analysis highlights a noticeable deviation from the field - linearity below a temperature - dependent characteristic field @xmath34 , see fig .
[ rho_h](b ) .
the obtained @xmath35 is also plotted in fig .
[ t_h ] . remarkably and _ consistently _ it follows the @xmath25 line within the experimental error bars .
we surmise then , while the @xmath24-linear and large magnetoresistance is a non - trivial finding in its own right that needs to be further understood , here it clearly is a phenomenon of the fermi - liquid .
indeed , several theoretical accounts within the fermi - liquid picture derive large @xmath24-linear @xmath32 @xcite .
we remark that at low temperatures below 5 k the standard fl state is confirmed by the classical kohler s rule for magnetoresistance , see fig .
[ rho_h](c ) . at higher temperatures , where the low field data below @xmath34 [ including @xmath36 no longer follow what is expected in the simple fl state
, the scaling is clearly violated . and while the violation of kohler s rule at high temperatures can be caused by other mechanisms , the low temperature data are consistently in correspondence with the field - induced fl state .
the temperature - dependent violation further indicates that here the magnetoresistance is not simply governed by @xmath37 ( a product of the cyclotron frequency and scattering time ) . from this
we conclude that the observed field - induced @xmath19 behavior is an intrinsic effect and not an artifact due to @xmath37 . at finite temperatures the observed field - induced transformation appears to be crossover - like .
so now we will ask whether the @xmath38 k terminus of @xmath35 indicates a true phase transition at qcp .
we note the conspicuously strong field dependence of the fl coefficient @xmath39 : it increases with decreasing field and decreasing @xmath20 , see inset of fig .
indeed we find that the field dependence can be fitted to @xmath40 where @xmath41 and @xmath42 are constants and @xmath43 and @xmath44 are the relevant parameters of the fit .
as we discussed earlier , in zero field @xmath11 can be analyzed either by a power law or by the @xmath45 dependence . in the analysis of the field dependence
the two different forms would require different values of @xmath41 in eq .
( 1 ) . in the former case ,
we take @xmath46 @xmath47cm / k@xmath48 and we can fit the @xmath49 by @xmath50 and @xmath51 t. in the latter case , we use the finite coefficient @xmath52 @xmath47cm / k@xmath48 ( see fig .
[ rho_t ] ) and the fit gives @xmath53 and @xmath54 t. thus , experimental @xmath49 algebraically diverges at @xmath44 . within fermi liquid theory , as @xmath55 k the energy dependence of the total scattering rate near the fermi surface takes the form @xmath56 ( @xmath57 comes from the impurity scattering , @xmath58 is a constant in energy @xmath59 , and @xmath60 is the fermi energy ) @xcite . at the qcp
the singularity of @xmath61 will mirror that of @xmath49 the two coefficients are related through the quasiparticle - quasiparticle scattering cross section .
the found divergence of @xmath39 thus gives us confidence in assigning @xmath44 as the qcp field , and @xmath43 as the exponent characterizing quantum criticality .
we remark that strongly correlated electron systems commonly obey kadowaki - woods relation @xmath62 @xcite , where @xmath63 is the electronic coefficient of specific heat and a measure of the effective mass @xmath64 of a landau quasiparticle . while this relation is complex ( and sometimes violated @xcite ) , we note that with large ( @xmath65 @xcite ) resistivity anisotropy in tl@xmath2ba@xmath2cuo@xmath3 , the obtained @xmath39 values near @xmath44 imply enhanced @xmath66 mj / mol - k@xmath48 , comparable to that e.g. in superconducting sr@xmath2ruo@xmath67 @xcite , where similarly anisotropic @xmath39 values between the @xmath4-axis and in - plane resistivities have been observed .
this enhancement of @xmath39 and a lack of saturation may also be related to the enhanced susceptibility @xmath68 in the overdoped tl@xmath2ba@xmath2cuo@xmath3 @xcite .
we surmise then that at finite temperatures the system is governed by the quantum fluctuations , generating the n - fl state which crosses over to the conventional fl above @xmath34 . the n - fl state with non-@xmath1 dependence of resistivity @xcite and
a violation of kohler s rule @xcite has also been observed in heavy - fermion superconductors having strong antiferromagnetic fluctuations .
notably , in cecoin@xmath69 with quasi - two dimensional electronic structure , a quite similar field - induced qcp has been identified by the transport and specific heat measurements @xcite . in high magnetic fields ,
the resistivity recovers the @xmath19 dependence at low temperatures in a similar manner near the upper critical field @xmath26 ( @xmath70 t ) .
it has been pointed out @xcite that the underlying antiferromagnetic fluctuations @xcite become critical in the immediate vicinity of the superconductivity , preventing development of magnetic order .
we note that anisotropic violation of the wiedemann - franz law in cecoin@xmath69 was recently found near the qcp @xcite , where the fl renormalization parameter @xmath71 @xmath72 tends to zero in the @xmath4 direction but remains finite in the @xmath12 plane .
this suggests that the @xmath4 direction is more susceptible to instabilities related to qcp .
an intriguing question to ask is whether field - induced @xmath73 in a highly overdoped cuprate is a shear coincidence or are they inherently linked . in particular
, one may ask whether an extended regime of superconducting fluctuations can promote the observed n - fl state . in the heavy - fermion superconductor cecoin@xmath69
, fl coefficient @xmath39 also diverges at the qcp located very near @xmath26 , with @xmath43 close to unity @xcite . by applying pressure @xmath44
is strongly suppressed and is no longer coincident with @xmath26 @xcite .
this rather compellingly points to a qcp controlled by a competing order , most likely related to antiferromagnetism @xcite . in cuprates , neutron scattering experiments @xcite show that magnetic field can _ induce _ a distinct static magnetic order , and a surprisingly much enhanced spin fluctuations at low @xmath7 within the vortex cores , also detected by a spatially resolved nmr @xcite .
thus , spin correlations in cuprates seem to experience a field - induced boost .
our work , in a departure from previous studies , probes the high - field regime at very high hole doping much distanced from the antiferromagnetic ` mother order ' . that the antiferromagnetic fluctuations @xcite could have such long reach @xcite and play a role in the uncovered field - induced qcp is quite extraordinary .
we expect that the true nature of the quantum critical fluctuations that produce the n - fl state in the highly overdoped tl@xmath2ba@xmath2cuo@xmath3 is complex , since here we are not far from the superconductivity s charge - doping end point @xcite . from our experiments , with salient similarities found between a cuprate and a heavy - fermion compound , all evidence here points to a spin - controlled qcp universal to these strongly correlated electron systems .
single crystals of tl@xmath2ba@xmath2cuo@xmath3 were grown by a flux method @xcite . in this system ,
the doping can be tuned by oxygen content covering a range from somewhat overdoped ( @xmath74 k ) up to heavily overdoped ( @xmath75 k ) @xcite . in our study
, we used a homogeneous highly - overdoped crystal with a sharp transition at @xmath9 k ( see fig . [ rho_t ] ) .
the @xmath4-axis resistivity @xmath76 was measured in the 45-t hybrid magnet at nhmfl ( comprising a 11.5 t superconducting outsert and 33.5 t resistive insert magnets ) by the standard four - probe method using an ac resistance bridge @xcite .
the temperature at high fields was controlled to @xmath77 mk by using a capacitance censor at low temperatures , where the magnetoresistance of cernox resistive sensors is not negligible .
* acknowledgments . *
we thank a. i. buzdin , s. chakravarty , s. fujimoto , n. e. hussey , h. kontani , and c. m. varma for discussions , and b. brandt for technical assistance at nhmfl .
this work was supported in part by grants - in - aid for scientific research from jsps , and for the 21st century coe
center for diversity and universality in physics " from mext , japan .
nakajima y _ et al . _
( 2007 ) non - fermi liquid behavior in the magnetotransport of ce@xmath78in5 ( @xmath78 : co and rh ) : striking similarity between quasi two - dimensional heavy fermion and high-@xmath0 cuprates . _
j phys soc jpn _ 76:024703
. grigera sa _
( 2004 ) disorder - sensitive phase formation linked to metamagnetic quantum criticality .
_ science _ 306:1154 - 1157 .
( 1999 ) evidence for quantum critical behavior in the optimally doped cuprate bi@xmath2sr@xmath2cacu@xmath2o@xmath79 .
_ science _ 285:2110 - 2113 .
kubo y , shimakawa y , manako t , igarashi h ( 1991 ) transport and magnetic properties of tl@xmath2ba@xmath2cuo@xmath80 showing a @xmath81-dependent gradual transition from an 85-k superconductor to a nonsuperconducting metal .
_ phys rev b _
43:7875 - 7882 .
wilson sd _ et al . _
( 2007 ) quantum spin correlations through the superconducting - to - normal phase transition in electron - doped superconducting pr@xmath86lace@xmath87cuo@xmath88 . _
proc natl acad sci usa _ 104:15259 - 15263 .
kakuyanagi k , kumagai k , matsuda y , hasegawa m ( 2003 ) antiferromagnetic vortex core in tl@xmath2ba@xmath2cuo@xmath80 studied by nuclear magnetic resonance .
_ phys rev lett _
scalapino dj ( 1995 ) the case for @xmath89 pairing in the cuprate superconductors .
_ phys rep _ 250:330 - 365 .
kawakami t , shibauchi t , terao y , suzuki m , krusin - elbaum l ( 2005 ) evidence for universal signatures of zeeman - splitting - limited pseudogaps in superconducting electron- and hole - doped cuprates .
_ phys rev lett _ 95:017001 .
-axis resistivity @xmath14 in an overdoped crystal of tl@xmath2ba@xmath2cuo@xmath3 under zero ( black solid line ) and a 45 t field ( squares ) .
red dashed and solid curves are the fits to @xmath90 and @xmath91 , respectively .
inset : @xmath14 vs @xmath92 at zero field .
solid line is a linear fit .
, width=340 ] -axis resistivity @xmath14 as a function of @xmath1 at fixed fields .
upper panel : @xmath14 with the fermi - liquid contribution subtracted highlights the non - fermi - liquid behavior for @xmath23 ( marked by arrows ) .
lower panel : @xmath14 fitted to the @xmath19 dependence ( dashed lines ) for @xmath22 .
onsets of the deviation from @xmath19 have error bars indicated in fig . [ t_h ] .
inset shows an expanded view of the low temperature region.,width=340 ] , and open squares , @xmath35 , separate fermi - liquid ( fl ) and non - fermi - liquid ( n - fl ) states .
red squares are the onset of superconductivity ( sc ) .
thick red line represents @xmath93 , which in cuprates varies exponentially with @xmath7 @xcite .
red hatched area outlines @xmath94 .
inset : the fermi - liquid coefficient @xmath39 as a function of @xmath24 .
the data can be fitted to eq .
( 1 ) as shown by blue - solid and red - dashed lines corresponding to two choices of @xmath41 , see text .
, width=321 ] -axis resistivity @xmath14 .
( a ) @xmath14 vs field @xmath24 at fixed temperatures .
dashed line is a linear fit to the 1.5 k data .
below @xmath29 the downward rounding of @xmath14 signifies the onset of superconductivity , and @xmath14 is zero below the irreversibility field @xmath28 .
( b ) @xmath95 obtained by subtracting the @xmath24-linear part from @xmath32 at fixed @xmath7 .
each curve is shifted vertically for clarity .
@xmath35 , marked by arrows [ also in ( c ) ] , are the deviation points from @xmath24-linear magnetoresistance ( mr ) .
( c ) kohler plot of normal - state mr against @xmath96 .
@xmath97 is the normal - state zero - field @xmath11 [ dashed line in fig .
[ rho_t ] ] .
, width=351 ] | in high transition temperature ( @xmath0 ) superconductivity , charge doping is a natural tuning parameter that takes copper oxides from the antiferromagnet to the superconducting region . in the metallic state above @xmath0
the standard landau s fermi - liquid theory of metals as typified by the temperature squared ( @xmath1 ) dependence of resistivity appears to break down . whether the origin of the non - fermi - liquid behavior is related to physics specific to the cuprates is a fundamental question still under debate .
we uncover a new transformation from the non - fermi- to a standard fermi - liquid state driven not by doping but by magnetic field in the overdoped high-@xmath0 superconductor tl@xmath2ba@xmath2cuo@xmath3 . from the @xmath4-axis resistivity measured up to 45 t
, we show that the fermi - liquid features appear above a sufficiently high field which decreases linearly with temperature and lands at a quantum critical point near the superconductivity s upper critical field with the fermi - liquid coefficient of the @xmath1 dependence showing a power - law diverging behavior on the approach to the critical point .
this field - induced quantum criticality bears a striking resemblance to that in quasi - two dimensional heavy - fermion superconductors , suggesting a common underlying spin - related physics in these superconductors with strong electron correlations .
uantum criticality refers to a phase transition process between competing states of matter governed not by thermal but by quantum fluctuations demanded by heisenberg uncertainty principle @xcite .
it has emerged at the front and center of the physics of strongly correlated electron systems known to host competing quantum orders , and is witnessed by a proliferation of reports on heavy fermions @xcite , itinerant ( quantum ) magnets @xcite , and high - transition - temperature ( high-@xmath0 ) superconductors @xcite , with quantum matter tuned ( at times arguably ) through a transition by pressure , magnetic field , or doping . arguably ,
since one has to rely on long shadows cast by quantum criticality far above zero temperature @xcite , for , obviously , @xmath5 k can not ever be attained .
the often - invoked hallmark of quantum criticality is an unconventional behavior of resistivity . for resistivity contribution , the standard fermi liquid ( fl ) theory of metals
predicts a quadratic temperature dependence @xmath6 at low temperatures . in high-@xmath0 cuprates
, however , the baffling @xmath7-linear resistivity over a huge temperature range near optimal ( hole ) doping has been observed @xcite , flagging , in this sense , a non - fermi liquid ( n - fl ) behavior in the metallic state above @xmath8 .
this has led to new theoretical concepts , some related ( e.g. , phenomenology of marginal fermi liquid " @xcite ) and some unrelated ( e.g. , strange metal " state @xcite ) to quantum criticality . in most considerations of cuprates near quantum critical points ( qcps )
the tuning parameter is charge doping @xcite . and
while there is some experimental support @xcite for a doping - driven qcp , it is still to be broadly confirmed .
thus , it is of primary import to probe experimentally how the n - fl state transforms into the conventional fl state , and whether and how charge or spin degrees of freedom are involved . here
we report on the transformation from such ` strange ' n - fl state to the conventional fl metallic state in high-@xmath0 superconductors in high magnetic fields .
our experiments measuring charge transport in overdoped tl@xmath2ba@xmath2cuo@xmath3 reveal an unanticipated quantum criticality in a cuprate that is not doping- but field - induced .
the results are in close correspondence with the quantum criticality in the quasi - two dimensional heavy - fermion superconductors having strong antiferromagnetic fluctuations , suggesting common fundamental physics of magnetic origin responsible for the observed qcp . to have access to large regions of the metallic regime at low temperatures , we use magnetic fields to destroy superconductivity in heavily doped tl@xmath2ba@xmath2cuo@xmath3
( @xmath9 k ) .
this material has a single cuo@xmath2 layer per unit cell and is relatively clean among cuprates as evidenced by the high @xmath0 ( up to 93 k ) that can be controlled with oxygen content .
we focus here on the @xmath4-axis longitudinal magnetotransport ( @xmath10 ) , since it should be less affected by orbital contributions than the transverse geometry , and since in our overdoped system it is expected that fermi surface is three - dimensional - like and coherent @xcite , as revealed by the fact that the temperature dependence of @xmath4-axis resistivity @xmath11 can be well scaled by that of @xmath12-plane resistivity @xmath13 [ see below ] . |
and its sister source , , were the first objects dubbed `` micro - quasars '' .
their spectra are typical of galactic black hole candidates ( bhcs ) , and they are associated with time variable cores of double - lobed radio sources , reminiscent of extra - galactic radio sources .
this morphology , seen on a parsec scale within the milky way , earned them their nickname . and are the brightest persistent sources in the galactic bulge above @xmath550 kev @xcite .
their timing characteristics are typical of the black hole low / hard state @xcite , and they consistently emit near their brightest observed levels , although they vary over times of days to years .
their emission properties are readily likened to the canonical bhc , cyg x-1 .
in fact , together with cyg x-1 , they are the only known persistent , low - state bhcs , and all three sources have maximum luminosities around @xmath6ergs s@xmath7 .
radio jets have now been observed in cyg x-1 , furthering the similarity @xcite . and are , however , quite different from the galactic _ superluminal _ radio sources more typically thought of as micro - quasars : grs 1915 + 105 and gro j1655 - 40 .
the emission from these objects is much brighter and more spectacularly variable .
their radio jets , too , are much brighter and are highly variable , being unresolved or absent except during exceptional ejection events which last only weeks . in contrast , the radio lobes of and are quite stable @xcite .
[ f_lc ] .[t_obs]observations [ cols="<,^,^,^,^ " , ]
during more than 5 years monitoring with the _ rxte _ prior to 2001 march , the hard spectrum was always dominated by a hard power law with photon index @xmath8 @xcite with occasional appearance of a weak thermal component @xcite . as shown in figure [ f_lc ] , made an abrupt state change in 2001 march .
the hard flux dropped by an order of magnitude in a few days , leaving the thermal component seen in figure [ f_spec ] .
based on relative luminosity , however , the current soft state is not a _ high_/soft state . rather it is significantly less luminous than the low / hard state in this source .
this can be contrasted to cyg x-1 and the soft transients , where the _
high_/soft state is more luminous .
rather , this seems to be a low - luminosity state which is fading into quiescence ( figure [ f_lc ] ) . finally , we note that the measured column density is consistent with previous measurements @xcite since strong jet ejections are generally associated with the `` very high state '' and transitions from the `` off '' to high / soft states in transients @xcite , it is perhaps not surprising that no jet emission appeared in our low / hard state observations ( sep - oct 2000 ) and the recent transition observation ( mar 2001 ) .
perhaps our best opportunity will come when ( if ? ) makes a transition once again to its normal , low / hard state .
we have an approved _ chandra_cycle 3 proposal to monitor the morphology of and hope to observe a jet ejection . | we observed the `` micro - quasar '' four times with _ chandra_. two hrc - i observations were made in 2000 september - october spanning an intermediate - to - hard spectral transition ( identified with _ rxte _ ) .
another hrc - i and an acis / hetgs observation were made in 2001 march following a hard - to - soft transition to a very low flux state .
the accurate position ( j2000 ) of the source is ra @xmath0 18 01 12.40 , dec @xmath0 @xmath125 44 36.0 ( 90% confidence radius @xmath0 0.6 ) , consistent with the purported variable radio counterpart .
all images are consistent with being a point source , indicating that any bright jet is less than 1light - month in projected length , assuming a distance of 8.5kpc .
the march spectrum is well - fit with a multi - color disk - blackbody with an inner temperature of @xmath2kev , interstellar absorption of @xmath3 , and ( un - absorbed ) 1@xmath110kev luminosity of @xmath4 .
no narrow emission lines are apparent in the spectrum and upper limits to line equivalent widths are given .
# 1_#1 _ # 1_#1 _ = # 1 1.25 in .125 in .25 in |
diseases spread over networks .
the spreading dynamics are closely related to the structure of networks . for this reason network epidemiology
has turned into of the most vibrant subdisciplines of complex network studies .
@xcite a topic of great practical importance within network epidemiology is the vaccination problem : how should a population be vaccinated to most efficiently prevent a disease to turn into an epidemic ? for economic reasons it is often not possible to vaccinate the whole population .
some vaccines have severe side effects and for this reason one may also want to keep number of vaccinated individuals low .
so if cheap vaccines , free of side effects , does not exist ; then having an efficient vaccination strategy is essential for saving both money and life . if all ties within the population is known , then the target persons for vaccination can be identified using sophisticated global strategies ( cf .
@xcite ) ; but this is hardly possible for nation - wide ( or larger ) vaccination campaigns . in a seminal paper cohen _ et al . _
@xcite suggested a vaccination strategy that only requires a person to estimate which other persons he , or she , gets close enough to for the disease to spread to i.e .
, to name the `` neighbors '' in the network over which the disease spreads .
for network with a skewed distribution of degree ( number of neighbors ) the strategy to vaccinate a neighbor of a randomly chosen person is much more efficient than a random vaccination . in this work
we assume that each individual knows a little bit more about his , or her , neighborhood than just the names of the neighbors : we also assume that an individual can guess the degree of the neighbors and the ties from one neighbor to another .
this assumption is not very unrealistic people are believed to have a good understanding of their social surroundings ( this is , for example , part of the explanation for the `` navigability '' of social networks ) @xcite .
finding the optimal set of vaccinees is closely related to the attack vulnerability problem @xcite .
the major difference is the dynamic system that is confined to the network
disease spreading for the vaccination problem and information flow for the attack vulnerability problem . to be able to protect the network
efficiently one needs to know the worst case attacking scenario .
large scale network attacks are , presumably , based on local ( rather than global ) network information .
so , a grave scenario would be in the network was attacked with the same strategy that is most efficient for vaccination .
we will use the vaccination problem as the framework for our discussion , but the results applies for network attack as well .
in our discussion we will use two measures of network structure : the _ clustering coefficient _ @xmath0 of the network defined as the ratio of triangles with respect to connected triples normalized to the interval @xmath1 $ ] .
@xcite if @xmath2 there is a maximal number of triangles ( given a set of connected triples ) ; if @xmath3 the graph has no triangles .
we also measure the degree - degree correlations through the _ assortative mixing coefficient _ defined as @xcite @xmath4 where @xmath5 is the degree of the @xmath6th argument of an edge in a list of the edges , and @xmath7 denotes average over that edge - list .
we let @xmath8 denote the number of vertices and @xmath9 the number of edges .
we will test the vaccination strategies we propose on both real - world and model networks .
the first real - world network is a scientific collaboration network @xcite .
the vertices of this network are scientists who have uploaded manuscripts to the preprint repository arxiv.org .
an edge between two authors means that they have coauthored a preprint .
we also study two small real - world social networks : one constructed from an observational study of friendships in a karate club , another based on an interview survey among prisoners .
the edges of these small networks are , probably , more relevant for disease spreading than the arxiv network , but may suffer from finite size effects .
the three model networks are : 1 . the holme - kim ( hk ) model @xcite that produces networks with a power - law degree distribution and tunable clustering . basically , it is a barabsi - albert ( ba ) type growth model based on preferential attachment @xcite just as the ba model it has one parameter @xmath10 controlling the average degree and one ( additional ) parameter @xmath11 $ ] controlling the clustering
. we will use @xmath12 and @xmath13 giving the maximal clustering for the given @xmath8 and @xmath9 .
2 . the networked seceder model , modeling social networks with a community structure and exponentially decaying degree distributions @xcite . briefly
, it works by sequentially updating the vertices by , for each vertex @xmath14 , rewiring all @xmath14 s edges to the neighborhood of a peripheral vertex . with a probability @xmath15 an edge of @xmath14
can be rewired to a random vertex ( so @xmath15 controls the degree of community structure ) .
we use the parameter values @xmath16 ,
@xmath17 and @xmath18 iterations on an erds - rnyi network @xcite .
the watts - strogatz ( ws ) model @xcite generates networks with exponentially decaying degree distributions and tunable clustering .
the ws model starts from the vertices on a circular topology with edges between vertices separated by 1 to @xmath19 steps on the circle .
then one goes through the edges and rewire one side of them to randomly selected vertices with a probability @xmath20 .
we use @xmath21 and @xmath22 .
.statistics of the networks .
note that the arxiv , prison and seceder model networks are not connected the largest connected components contains @xmath23 , @xmath24 and @xmath25 nodes respectively . [ cols="<,<,<,<,<",options="header " , ]
now we turn to the definition of the strategies .
we assume a fraction @xmath26 of the population is to be vaccinated . as a reference we consider random vaccination ( rnd , equivalent to site percolation ) .
we use the above mentioned _ neighbor vaccination _ ( rnb)to vaccinate the neighbor of randomly chosen vertices and the trivial improvement @xcite if knowledge about the neighbors degrees are included : pick a vertex at random and vaccinate one ( randomly chosen ) of its highest - degree neighbors ( we call it deg ) . to avoid overvaccination of a neighborhood one can consider to vaccinate neighbors of a vertex @xmath14 with a maximal number of edges out of @xmath14 s neighborhood ( out ) . for all strategies except rnd
we also consider `` chained '' versions were one , instead of vaccinating a neighbor of a randomly chosen vertex , vaccinates a neighbor of the vertex vaccinated in the previous time step ( if all neighbors are vaccinated a neighbor of a random vertex is chosen instead ) .
for the acronyms of the chained versions a suffix `` c '' is added .
the results of this paper are presented in three sections : first we study how the number of vertices in the largest connected subgraph @xmath27 depends on the fraction @xmath26 of vaccinated vertices .
then we show that the conclusions from @xmath27 also hold for dynamical simulations of disease spreading . to interpret the results we also investigate @xmath27 for a fixed @xmath26 as a function of the clustering and assortative mixing coefficients . as a static efficiency measure we consider the size of the average largest connected component of susceptible ( non - vaccinated ) vertices , @xmath27 .
we average over @xmath28 runs of the vaccination procedures .
the model networks are also averaged over @xmath29 network realizations .
( smaller or larger @xmath30 and @xmath31 does not make any qualitative difference . ) in fig .
[ fig : s1 ] we display @xmath27 as a function of @xmath26 .
for all except the ws model network the deg and out ( chained and unchained versions ) form the most efficient set of strategies . within this group
the order of efficiency varies : for the arxiv network the out strategy is more than twice as efficient as any other for @xmath32 . for the hk and seceder model networks the chained strategies are considerably more efficient than the unchained ones .
we note that the difference between the chained and unchained versions of out and deg is bigger than between out and deg ( or outc and degc ) .
out do converge to deg in the limit of vanishing @xmath0 but all networks we test have rather high clustering .
another interesting observation is that even if the degree distribution is narrow , such as for the seceder model of fig .
[ fig : s1](e ) ( where @xmath33 ) the more elaborate strategies are much more efficient than random vaccination .
this is especially clear for higher @xmath26 which suggests that the structural change of the network of susceptible vertices during the vaccination procedure is an important factor for the overall efficiency . for the ws model network
the chained algorithms are performing poorer than random vaccination .
this is in contrast to all other networks .
we conclude that epidemiology related results regarding the ws model networks should be cautiously generalized to real - world systems .
static measures of vaccination efficiency are potential over - simplifications
there is a chance that the interplay between disease dynamics and the underlying network structure has a significant role . to motivate the use of @xmath27 we also investigate the sis and sir models @xcite on vaccinated networks . in the sis model
a vertex goes from `` susceptible '' ( s ) to `` infected '' ( i ) and back to s. in the sir model is just the same , except that an infected vertex goes to the `` removed '' ( r ) state and remain there .
the probability to go from @xmath34 to @xmath35 ( per contact ) is zero for vaccinated vertices and @xmath36 for the rest .
the i state lasts @xmath37 time steps .
we use synchronous updating and one randomly chosen initially infected person .
the disease dynamics are averaged @xmath38 times for all @xmath28 runs of the vaccination schemes . in fig .
[ fig : dyn](a ) we plot the average number of individuals that at least once have been infected during an outbreak @xmath39i.e . , until there are no i - vertices left , or ( for sis ) has reached an endemic state ( defined in the simulations as when there are no susceptible vertices that have not had the disease at least once)for the arxiv network .
other networks and simulation parameters give qualitatively similar results .
qualitatively , the large picture from the @xmath27 calculations remains the chained and unchained deg and out strategies are very efficient , and the chained versions are more efficient than the unchained .
a difference is that the unchained rnb also performs rather well .
quantitatively , the differences between the strategies are huge , this is a result of the threshold behaviors of the sis and sir models @xcite .
the conclusion of fig .
[ fig : dyn ] ( and similar plots for other networks ) is that the order of the strategies efficiencies are largely the same as concluded from the @xmath40-curves .
but if high resolution is required , the measurement of network fragility has to be specific for the studied system . to gain some insight how the network structure govern the relative efficiencies of the strategies we measure @xmath41 for varying assortative mixing and clustering coefficients .
the results hold for other small @xmath26 values .
we keep the size and degree sequence constant to the values of the arxiv network .
to perform this sampling we rewire pairs of edges @xmath42 and @xmath43 to @xmath44 and @xmath45 ( unless this would introduce a self - edge or multiple edges ) . to ensure that the @xmath46 rewiring realizations are independent we start with rewiring @xmath47 pairs of edges .
then we go through pairs of edges randomly and execute only changes that makes the current @xmath15 or @xmath0 closer to their target values . when the value of @xmath15 or @xmath0 are within @xmath48 of the target value the iteration is braked .
the results seen in fig . [ fig : rew ] shows that , just as before the out and deg strategies , chained or unchained , are most efficient throughout the parameter space .
the unchained versions are most efficient for @xmath49 .
an explanation is that , for high @xmath15 , the chained versions will effectively only vaccinate the high - connected vertices ( that are grouped together for very high @xmath15 ) and leave chains of low - degree vertices unvaccinated . the @xmath0-dependence plotted in fig .
[ fig : rew](b ) shows that the unchained versions outperform the chained versions for @xmath50 .
this is possibly a result of that the chains , for combinatorial reasons , get stuck in one part of the network .
it is not an effect of biased degree - degree correlations since if the rewiring procedure is conditioned to a fixed @xmath15 fig .
[ fig : rew](b ) remains essentially unaltered .
we note that the structure of the original arxiv network differs from the rewired networks .
for example , at @xmath51 of fig .
[ fig : s1](a ) the out is 22% more efficient than outc , but in fig . [
fig : rew ] the out and outc curves differ very little . for the rnb strategy the chained version is better than the unchained throughout the range of @xmath15 and @xmath0 values .
to summarize , we have investigated strategies for vaccination and network attack that are based only on the knowledge of the neighborhood information that humans arguably possess and utilize .
both static and dynamical measures of efficiency are studied . for most networks , regardless of the number of vaccinated vertices , the most efficient strategies are to choose a vertex @xmath14 and vaccinate a neighbor of @xmath14 with highest degree ( deg ) , or the neighbor of @xmath14 with most links out of @xmath14 s neighborhood ( out ) .
@xmath14 can be picked either as the lastly vaccinated vertex ( chained selection ) or at random ( unchained selection ) . for real - world networks
the chained versions tend to outperform the unchained ones , whereas this situation is reversed for the three types of model networks we study .
we investigate the relative efficiency of chained and unchained strategies further by sampling random networks with a fixed degree sequence and varying assortative mixing and clustering coefficients .
we find that the unchained strategies are preferable for networks with a very high clustering or strong positive assortative mixing ( larger values than in seen in real - world networks ) . in ref .
@xcite the authors propose the strategy to vaccinate a random neighbor of a randomly selected vertex .
this strategy ( rnb ) requires less information of the neighborhood than deg and out do .
thus the practical procedure gets simpler : one only has to ask a person `` name a person you meet regularly '' rather than `` name the acquaintance of yours who meet most people you are not acquainted with regularly '' ( for out ) .
( `` meet with regularly '' should be replaced with some phrase signifying a high risk of infection transfer for the pathogen in question . ) on the other hand , if the information of the neighborhoods is incomplete deg and out will , effectively , be reduced to rnb ( and thus not perform worse than rnb ) .
to epitomize , choosing the people to vaccinate in the right way will save a tremendous amount of vaccine and side - effect cases .
the best strategy can only be selected by considering both the structure of the network the pathogen spreads over , and the disease dynamics . if nothing of this is known the outc strategy our recommendation it is better , or not much worse , than the best strategy in most cases .
together with degc , outc is most efficient for low clustering and assortative mixing coefficients , which is the region of parameter space for sexually transmitted diseases the most interesting case for network based vaccination schemes ( due to the well - definedness of sexual networks ) .
the author is grateful for comments from m. rosvall and acknowledges support from the swedish research council through contract no.2002 - 4135 . | we study how a fraction of a population should be vaccinated to most efficiently stop epidemics .
we argue that only local information ( about the neighborhood of specific vertices ) is usable in practice , and hence we consider only local vaccination strategies .
the efficiency of the vaccination strategies is investigated with both static and dynamical measures . among other things
we find that the most efficient strategy for many real - world situations is to iteratively vaccinate the neighbor of the previous vaccinee that has most links out of the neighborhood . |
in qcd or the massive schwinger model in @xmath3 vacuum @xcite , it is well known that the scalar operator condense while the pseudoscalar does not ; @xmath4 where the second equation follows from parity symmetry . however ,
if we have a non - zero @xmath5 term , which violates parity symmetry , both of them have non - zero expectation values ; @xmath6 which indicates that @xmath7 meson should have a long - range correlation as @xmath8 we would like to present our numerical results of the 2-flavor massive schwinger model with a @xmath1 term .
we investigate @xmath9 condensates and the @xmath0 meson correlators in each topological sector .
it is also found that they are non - trivially related each other to reproduce the @xmath5 dependence .
we find that their behavior is well understood by the intuitive picture based on the clustering decomposition and the statistical mechanics .
in particular , our study shows that the accurate contributions from higher topological sectors are essential in order to assure parity symmetry , which never allows the long - range correlation of the @xmath0 meson correlators .
moreover , it is also shown that the origin of the fluctuations of disconnected diagram is from pseudoscalar condensates in each topological sector .
our strategy to calculate the @xmath5 vacuum effects is to separate the integral of the gauge fields into topological sectors ; @xmath10 where @xmath11 denotes a coupling constant and @xmath12 and @xmath13 denote the expectation value and the partition function in a fixed topological sector respectively .
the expectation values with a fixed topological charge ; @xmath12 are evaluated by generating link variables with the following gauge action @xcite ; @xmath14 where @xmath15 denotes a plaquette and @xmath16 is a fixed constant .
this action impose the lscher s bound @xcite on the gauge fields , which realize an exact topological charge on the lattice , that is never changed in each step of the the hybrid monte carlo updation .
@xmath17 normalized by that of zero topological sector can be evaluated by decomposing it into three parts ; @xmath18 where @xmath19 denotes the classical minimum of the gauge action with topological charge @xmath20 , @xmath21 denotes the moduli integral , and @xmath22 , all of which are numerically calculable @xcite .
we choose the domain - wall fermion action with pauli - villars regulators for sea quarks .
the link variables are updated by the hybrid monte carlo algorithm .
the parameters are chosen as @xmath23 , @xmath24 .
we take @xmath25 and @xmath26 lattice where @xmath27 denotes the size of the extra dimension of domain - wall fermions .
50 molecular dynamics steps with a step size @xmath28 are performed in one trajectory .
configurations are updated every 10 trajectories . for each topological sector
, around 500 trajectories are taken for the thermalization staring from the initial configuration which is the classical instanton solution with topological charge @xmath20 .
we generate 300 configurations in @xmath29 sectors for the measurements and from 1000 to 10000 for the reweighting factors at various @xmath30 , where @xmath31 at @xmath32 and @xmath33 at @xmath34 .
the topological charge dependence of pseudoscalar condensates is derived by the anomaly equation ; @xmath35 where @xmath36 denotes the volume of the torus . as seen in fig .
[ fig : condaxq ] , our data show a good agreement with this equation .
then the @xmath0 meson correlators should have long - range correlations . from the clustering decomposition , this can be expressed as @xmath37 where @xmath38 means the expectation value with the topological charge @xmath39 in the region @xmath40 which denote the half of the large box , where the pseudoscalar operators reside , respectively and @xmath41 denotes the probability of the distribution where @xmath39 instantons appear in the box @xmath42 and @xmath43 appear in the box @xmath44 . in @xmath45 case , one obtains @xmath46 where we assume @xmath47 and use the anti - symmetry;@xmath48 as seen in fig .
[ fig : condaxq ] . on the other hand , at large @xmath20 ,
assuming the distribution @xmath41 to be gaussian around @xmath49 , the correlation can be evaluated as follows , @xmath50 where @xmath51 is a numerical constant . as seen in fig [ fig : longq ] , it is surprising that these very simple arguments describe the data quite well .
@xmath5 dependence of the @xmath0 correlators are evaluated by substituting the data into eq.([eq : exp ] ) .
[ fig : etaproptheta ] shows the result .
it is obvious that there are long - range correlations at @xmath1 while @xmath3 case is consistent with zero , which suggests our reweighting method works well at small @xmath5 .
we study @xmath20 and @xmath5 dependence of the pseudoscalar condensates and the @xmath0 meson correlators . we find
that pseudoscalar does condense in each topological sector ; @xmath52 and there exists a long - range correlation of @xmath0 meson ; @xmath53 which are well understood by the clustering properties .
it is also found that each contribution from different topological sectors plays very important role to produce non - trivial @xmath5 dependence of these observables . in particular , the cancellation the long - range correlation of @xmath0 meson requires accurate measurements of higher topological sectors .
it is also obvious that the fluctuation of the disconnected diagrams originates from these pseudoscalar condensates .
s. r. coleman , r. jackiw and l. susskind , annals phys .
* 93 * , 267 ( 1975 ) .
s. r. coleman , annals phys .
* 101 * , 239 ( 1976 ) .
a. v. smilga , phys .
d * 55 * , 443 ( 1997 ) j. e. hetrick , y. hosotani and s. iso , phys .
b * 350 * , 92 ( 1995 ) . | we study the chiral condensates and the @xmath0 meson correlators of the massive schwinger model in @xmath1 vacuum .
our data suggest that the pseudoscalar operator does condense in a fixed topological sector and gives long range correlations of the @xmath0 meson .
we find that this is well understood from the clustering decomposition and statistical picture .
our result also indicates that even in @xmath2 case , the long range correlation of @xmath0 meson receives non - zero contributions from all the topological sectors and that their cancellation is non - trivial and requires accurate measurement of the reweighting factors as well as the expectation values .
it is then clear that the fluctuation of the `` disconnected '' diagram originates from the pseudoscalar condensates . |
a basic prediction of @xmath5cdm galaxy - formation models is the existence of a hot ( @xmath6k ) halo of gas accreted from the intergalactic medium around milky way - sized galaxies ( extending to the virial radius ) , which forms as infalling gas is heated to the virial temperature at an accretion shock ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
these halos may provide most of the fuel for long - term star formation in these galaxies @xcite , but their predicted properties are sensitive to the input physics , which can be constrained by the measurable properties of the gas . based on work over the past several years , we know that these extended halos exist , including around the milky way @xcite .
the extent and luminosity of the hot gas implies that it has a similar mass to the stellar disk , and therefore could play an important role in galaxy evolution .
thus , it is important to measure the properties of the hot gas beyond mass and temperature ( such as metallicity and density or velocity structure ) .
however , hot halos are faint and the measurable x - ray luminosity can be dominated by stellar feedback ejecta near the disk @xcite , which makes these measurements difficult . only in the milky way can one measure the structure , temperature , metallicity , and kinematics of the hot gas through emission and absorption lines @xcite , but kinematic constraints from prior studies @xcite are weak .
recent developments in the calibration of the x - ray grating spectrometers and the accumulation of multiple high quality data sets for individual objects have made it possible to determine line centroids to an accuracy of tens of kms@xmath4 , which enables us to improve the constraints on the kinematics of the gas by measuring doppler shifts in lines that trace the hot gas .
the @xmath721.602 resonance absorption line @xcite is the best candidate , since it is sensitive to temperatures of @xmath8k ( which includes much of the galactic coronal gas ) and it is detected at zero redshift towards a large number of background continuum sources ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
the _ emission _
lines produced by the same species are useful for determining the structure and temperature of the hot gas @xcite , but they are too faint for high resolution spectroscopy . in this paper
we constrain , for the first time , the radial and azimuthal velocity of the hot gas by measuring the doppler shifts in lines detected towards bright sources outside the disk of the milky way .
to measure the global velocity of the million - degree gas around the galaxy , one needs to measure doppler shifts towards a range of sources across the sky in lines sensitive to this temperature .
this gas is detected in x - ray emission and absorption , but the emission lines are far too faint for a focused grating observation .
x - ray imaging ccds measure the energies of incoming photons and are thus also low resolution spectrometers , but their spectral resolution is far too low to measure doppler shifts of tens of kms@xmath4 .
the only instruments capable of this accuracy are the _ chandra _ low / high - energy transmission grating ( letg / hetg ) spectrometers and the _ xmm - newton _ reflection grating spectrometer ( rgs ) , and the 21.602 line is the only line that probes the relevant temperatures and is detected at @xmath9 towards many background continuum sources . the oviii line at 18.96 probes slightly hotter gas and is only detected towards a few objects .
our initial sample included all archival letg and rgs data sets where the line has been detected in the literature .
the letg has modestly better spectral resolution at 21.6 ( @xmath10 ) than the rgs ( @xmath11 ) , but it only has a third of the effective area at this wavelength ( 15@xmath12 for the letg , 45@xmath12 for the rgs ) . in addition , unlike the letg the rgs is always on ( it has a dedicated telescope , whereas the gratings must be moved into the focal plane on _ chandra _ ) , and thus has accumulated many more spectra .
these factors lead to many more detected lines in the rgs , so we only use the letg data towards several calibration sources as a check on the wavelength solution ( see below ) .
our analysis sample includes 37 known absorbers at @xmath9 with rgs data @xcite ( table [ table.velocities ] ) .
these include agns as well as several x - ray binaries in the milky way s halo and magellanic clouds .
we tried to include all sources known to be outside the disk with reported absorption lines , but we excluded three sources : ngc 3783 , pks @xmath13 , and swift j@xmath14 .
ngc 3783 has an intrinsic oxygen line with a p cygni profile where we can not disentangle the galactic line , pks @xmath13 has a broad line that suggests blending or a non - galactic origin , and the line in swift j@xmath14 is only detected in two of four high @xmath15 exposures .
we include ngc 5408 x-1 ( which is an x - ray binary , not an agn ) and ngc 4051 , but these systems have redshifts smaller than 1000kms@xmath4 so the lines may be intrinsic . ngc 4051 and mcg-6 - 30 - 15 also have known outflows ; as they have lines attributed to the galaxy in some prior studies ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) we include them here , but we show below that excluding them does not strongly change our results .
the data for each target were reprocessed using standard methods in the _ xmm - newton _ science analysis software ( sas v14.0.0 ) with the appropriate calibration files .
this included excluding hot , cold , and `` cool '' pixels , and data from periods when the background count rate exceeds 3@xmath16 from the mean .
we applied the ( default ) empirical correction for the sun angle of the spacecraft and its heliocentric motion @xcite .
we used the highest precision coordinates available rather than the proposal coordinates , which improves the accuracy of the wavelength scale . for each object
, we merged the first - order rgs1 spectra and response matrices into a `` stacked '' spectrum .
standard processing resamples the data from native bins ( about 0.011 at 21.6 ) into a user - specified bin size .
we binned the data to 0.02 ( one resolution element is about 0.055 ) .
this resampling causes small but stochastic changes in the bin assignment for some events , leading to variation under the same protocols , which we quantify by processing each object ten times in the same way . to measure the doppler shifts ,
we fit a model consisting of a power law and an absorption line to the spectrum in the 21 - 22 bandpass using xspec v12.9.0 @xcite .
we exclude an instrumental artifact between 21.7521.85 in each spectrum , and in several spectra there are one or more bad channels in the bandpass that we also exclude .
the parameters of the absorption - line model include the line centroid , the line width , and the line strength , but we fix the line width at the instrumental line - profile width because we do not expect detectable line broadening , an assumption we validated in the brightest sources .
the best - fit centroid is converted to a velocity using the best - fit line energy from a stacked spectrum of capella as a reference , corrected for the radial velocity of the star ( described below ) .
we measured the velocity for each of the ten stacked spectra per object , and we report the mean value with its 1@xmath16 uncertainty in table [ table.velocities ] , including the resampling uncertainty . the systematic uncertainty in the wavelength scale limits the accuracy of our measurements , and recent improvements in the calibration of the wavelength scale @xcite and multiple high @xmath15 spectra for the objects in our sample are largely what enable this study . here
we show the accuracy of the wavelength solution for the protocols we adopt and briefly describe the sources of uncertainty and their magnitudes .
we created spectra for the active stars capella and hr 1099 following the protocols above , then measured the ( emission ) line centroids for strong , mostly unblended lines , and compared them to their laboratory rest wavelengths ( figure [ figure.capella_wavelength ] ) .
we accounted for the radial velocity of each star ( @xmath17kms@xmath4 for capella and @xmath18kms@xmath4 for hr 1099 ; * ? ? ?
we find no systematic offset in the 5 - 30 bandpass or change over time .
the wavelength offsets in @xmath721.602 for stacked spectra are @xmath19m ( capella ) and @xmath20m ( hr 1099 ) .
these correspond to @xmath21 and @xmath22kms@xmath4 .
to verify that stacking does not introduce artificial offsets , we also measured centroids in each individual exposure ( 16 for capella and 14 for hr 1099 ) and computed the weighted mean .
the offsets are consistent with the stacked spectrum : @xmath23 and @xmath24kms@xmath4 for capella and hr 1099 .
we also checked the wavelength solution against the letg and hetg data for these stars .
we reduced te data using the chandra interactive analysis of observations software ( ciao v4.7 ) , and we found good agreement with spectra from the reduced data available through the tgcat project @xcite .
we co - added the @xmath25first - order spectra and stacked all observations .
the letg offsets are @xmath26kms@xmath4 ( capella ) and @xmath27kms@xmath4 ( hr 1099 ) , whereas the hetg medium energy grating offsets are @xmath28kms@xmath4 ( capella ) and @xmath29kms@xmath4 ( hr 1099 ) .
these results agree with the rgs and the laboratory wavelength ( figure [ figure.capella_wavelength ] ) .
we also compared velocity measurements between the rgs and letg in the four brightest quasars @xcite .
the letg and rgs centroids agree to within the 1@xmath16 error bar .
these results show that the wavelength scale is sufficiently accurate for our measurement , but it is important to note that there is a substantial systematic scatter that makes _ individual _ observations unreliable , and also that there will be systematic differences between our measurements and those reported for the same data using an earlier version of sas or using incorrect source coordinates .
different observations of the same object have a systematic scatter of @xmath305m in the wavelength solution around the true mean value .
this corresponds to 70kms@xmath4 at 21.602 , and leads to the standard quoted systematic uncertainty of 100kms@xmath4 .
the reason for this scatter is not clear , but about 3m could be explained by limits in the pointing accuracy of the telescope @xcite . in any case , the scatter is normally distributed ( based on measurements from many exposures of calibration stars such as capella ) , and can thus be strongly mitigated with multiple observations of the same source . to reduce the scatter to within 20kms@xmath4
requires 15 - 20 independent spectra ( assuming equal @xmath15 and a @xmath31m ) .
the sources in our sample have between 2 - 60 observations , and at the low end the reported 1@xmath16 statistical errors ( 200kms@xmath4 or more ) are much larger than a 70kms@xmath4 systematic error . for the bright quasars with many observations
, we estimate a typical systematic error due to this scatter of @xmath32kms@xmath4 . .
two models are shown for comparison with the data ( black points ) : a stationary model ( blue points ) and a corotating model ( red points ) .
error bars are 1@xmath16 ( standard deviation ) .
the four objects with the smallest error bars are labeled 1 - 4 .
the velocities of the lines towards mrk 421 and ngc 4051 ( labeled ` 2 ' and ` 3 ' ) suggest some intrinsic scatter .
, scaledwidth=50.0% ] in addition to the scatter , there are systematic offsets produced by the sun angle of the telescope and its projected heliocentric motion ( possibly an inaccuracy in the star - tracker ) that were measured and corrected by @xcite ; we refer the reader to their paper for a detailed description .
the earliest version of sas that conained these corrections was v13.0.0 , and it was not enabled by default until v14.0.0 ; all prior absorption - line halo studies using the rgs used an earlier version or did not mention the correction .
we measured line centroids with and without these corrections , and found centroid shifts in our sample with magnitudes between @xmath33kms@xmath4 ( higher for weak lines ) . to show the effect of not including them , we show the measured centroids without these corrections in table [ table.velocities ] .
finally , if we used the default ( proposal ) coordinates instead of the simbad coordinates , we measured offsets of @xmath34kms@xmath4 .
thus , we would expect our measured centroids to be correlated with prior results but perhaps significantly different relative to the statistical errors .
for example , there is a systematic offset of about 60kms@xmath4 between our measurements and @xcite for the several systems where it can be measured .
this offset can not be entirely explained by the sun angle and heliocentric motion corrections , but it is consistent with shifts seen relative to prior versions of sas @xcite .
they do not report the line centroids for active stars , as they only need to measure the centroids to sufficient accuracy to identify halo absorbers .
thus , we do not regard the apparent inconsistency as reflecting an inherent uncertainty in line centroid measurements .
lcccccccccc mkn 421 & 179.832 & 65.031 & 0.0300 & @xmath35 & @xmath36 & @xmath37 & @xmath38 & @xmath38 & [email protected] & 232 + 3c 273 & 289.951 & 64.360 & 0.1580 & @xmath39 & @xmath40 & @xmath41 & @xmath42 & @xmath43 & [email protected] & 55 + pks 2155 - 304 & 17.730 & @xmath44 & 0.1160 & @xmath45 & @xmath46 & @xmath47 & @xmath48 & @xmath49 & [email protected] & 95 + mkn 509 & 35.971 & @xmath50 & 0.0340 & @xmath51 & @xmath52 & @xmath53 & @xmath38 & @xmath54 & [email protected] & 48 + ngc 4051 & 148.883 & 70.085 & 0.0023 & @xmath55 & @xmath56 & @xmath57 & @xmath58 & @xmath59 & [email protected] & 33 + mcg -06 - 30 - 15 & 313.292 & 27.680 & 0.0077 & @xmath60 & @xmath61 & @xmath62 & @xmath63 & @xmath64 & [email protected] & 38 + ark 564 & 92.138 & @xmath65 & 0.0247 & @xmath66 & @xmath67 & @xmath42 & @xmath68 & @xmath69 & [email protected] & 50 + eso 141 - 55 & 338.183 & @xmath70 & 0.0371 & @xmath71 & @xmath72 & @xmath73 & @xmath74 & @xmath75 & [email protected] & 18 + h1426 + 428 & 77.487 & 64.899 & 0.1290 & @xmath76 & @xmath77 & @xmath78 & @xmath79 & @xmath80 & [email protected] & 25 + 1h 0707 - 495 & 260.169 & @xmath81 & 0.0405 & @xmath82 & @xmath83 & @xmath84 & @xmath85 & @xmath86 & [email protected] & 22 + pks 0558 - 504 & 257.962 & @xmath87 & 0.1370 & @xmath88 & @xmath89 & @xmath57 & @xmath43 & @xmath90 & [email protected] & 32 + ngc 4593 & 297.483 & 57.403 & 0.0090 & @xmath91 & @xmath92 & @xmath93 & @xmath48 & @xmath94 & [email protected] & 13 + mrk 335 & 108.763 & @xmath95 & 0.0258 & @xmath96 & @xmath97 & @xmath98 & @xmath99 & @xmath100 & [email protected] & 22 + pg 1211 + 143 & 267.552 & 74.315 & 0.0809 & @xmath101 & @xmath102 & @xmath103 & @xmath104 & @xmath105 & 40.3@xmath2511 .
& 7 + pg 1244 + 026 & 300.041 & 65.214 & 0.0482 & @xmath106 & @xmath107 & @xmath108 & @xmath109 & @xmath110 & 40.8@xmath2511 . & 10 + mkn 501 & 64.600 & 38.860 & 0.0337 & @xmath111 & @xmath112 & @xmath113 & @xmath114 & @xmath115 & 25.2@xmath2510 . &
22 + 1es 1028 + 511 & 161.439 & 54.439 & 0.3600 & @xmath116 & @xmath117 & @xmath118 & @xmath84 & @xmath119 & 36.4@xmath2511 .
& 12 + eso 198 - 24 & 271.639 & @xmath120 & 0.0455 & @xmath121 & @xmath122 & @xmath123 & @xmath124 & @xmath125 & 62.2@xmath2519 .
& 7 + ngc 2617 & 229.300 & 20.939 & 0.0142 & @xmath126 & @xmath127 & @xmath128 & @xmath129 & @xmath130 & [email protected] & 10 + pg 1553 + 113 & 21.909 & 43.964 & 0.3600 & @xmath131 & @xmath132 & @xmath133 & @xmath134 & @xmath135 & [email protected] & 13 + h1101 - 232 & 273.190 & @xmath136 & 0.1860 & @xmath137 & @xmath138 & @xmath139 & @xmath140 & @xmath141 & 45.5@xmath2517 . &
8 + 3c 390.3 & 111.438 & 27.074 & 0.0561 & @xmath142 & @xmath143 & @xmath84 & @xmath80 & @xmath144 & 25.0@xmath2510 . & 10 + 1h 0419 - 577 & 266.963 & @xmath145 & 0.1040 & @xmath146 & @xmath147 & @xmath148 & @xmath149 & @xmath150 & 39.9@xmath2516 . & 6 + fairall 9 & 295.073 & @xmath151 & 0.0470 & @xmath152 & @xmath153 & @xmath154 & @xmath63 & @xmath155 & 37.2@xmath2515 . & 6 + iras 13224 - 3809 & 310.189 & 23.979 & 0.0660 & @xmath156 & @xmath157 & @xmath158 & @xmath159 & @xmath160 & 45.1@xmath2519 . & 7 + ngc 5408 x-1 & 317.149 & 19.496 & 0.0017 & @xmath161 & @xmath162 & @xmath68 & @xmath163 & @xmath64 & 30.4@xmath2514 . & 7 + pds 456 & 10.392 & 11.164 & 0.1840 & @xmath164 & @xmath165 & @xmath166 & @xmath167 & @xmath59 & 60.0@xmath2529 .
& 7 + mrk 279 & 115.042 & 46.865 & 0.0305 & @xmath168 & @xmath169 & @xmath37 & @xmath113 & @xmath170 & [email protected] & 15 + e1821 + 643 & 94.003 & 27.417 & 0.2970 & @xmath171 & @xmath172 & @xmath173 & @xmath174 & @xmath175 & 35.7@xmath2518 . &
7 + ic 4329a & 317.496 & 30.920 & 0.0160 & @xmath176 & @xmath177 & @xmath178 & @xmath179 & @xmath180 & 38.3@xmath2520 . & 7 + pg 0804 + 761 & 138.279 & 31.033 & 0.1000 & @xmath181 & @xmath182 & @xmath43 & @xmath178 & @xmath183 & 28.5@xmath2515 . & 6 + ngc 5548 & 31.960 & 70.496 & 0.0172 & @xmath184 & @xmath185 & @xmath114 & @xmath186 & @xmath59 & 18.0@xmath2510 . & 13 + mrk 766 & 190.681 & 82.270 & 0.0129 & @xmath187 & @xmath188 & @xmath189 & @xmath38 & @xmath190 & [email protected] & 27 + lmc x-3 & 273.576 & @xmath191 & - & @xmath192 & @xmath193 & @xmath186 & @xmath194 & @xmath195 & [email protected] & 36 + 4u 1957 + 11 & 51.308 & @xmath196 & - & @xmath197 & @xmath198 & @xmath199 & @xmath200 & @xmath201 & [email protected] & 22 + maxi j0556 - 032 & 238.939 & @xmath202 & - & @xmath203 & @xmath204 & @xmath205 & @xmath206 & @xmath207 & [email protected] & 33 + smc x-1 & 300.414 & @xmath208 & - & @xmath209 & @xmath210 & @xmath211 & @xmath148 & @xmath212 & [email protected] & 13 + in addition to the wavelength grid , there are a few sources of systematic uncertainty and some fitting choices that affect our final results but where we believe there is a correct choice .
we briefly describe these here .
[ [ cool - pixels ] ] _ cool pixels _ + +
+ + + + + + + + + + + there are several `` cool '' pixels in the vicinity of 21.6 that have a lower than expected signal ( by about 20% ) . by default
, these pixels are included in the spectrum .
we exclude them because they can affect weak absorption features .
the typical velocity shift between keeping and excluding them is @xmath213kms@xmath4 in bright sources .
[ [ binning - and - resampling ] ] _ binning and resampling _ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the native rgs binning is about 11m at 21.6 , but the default processing resamples the events onto a user - specified grid , with a default value of 10m .
this resampling is probabilistic with a random element ( normally distributed ) , which means that running the same protocol on a given data set multiple times will result in slightly different spectra .
the magnitude of the velocity shift is strongly dependent on the line strength and the continuum @xmath15 , so we reprocessed each data set ten times per reduction protocol set .
we then added the standard deviation in the measured velocities in quadrature to the statistical error , since it behaves in essentially the same way .
the bin sizes also affect the measured velocities , with a mean line centroid shift of @xmath214kms@xmath4 between bins of 10m and 20m in bright systems ( we use the latter ) . [ [ stacking ] ] _ stacking _ + +
+ + + + + + + + temporal changes in the instrumental response or changes in the spectral shape of the source can bias the results of stacked spectra . on the other hand ,
jointly fitting several low-@xmath15 spectra with the continuum shape as a free parameter leads to poorer constraints on the velocity of a line based on spectral bins far from the absorption line .
we stack the spectra to improve the continuum @xmath15 , but to determine if this provides systematic bias we measured the line shift between joint fits and stacked spectra in our brightest sources and the calibration sources .
we find a typical @xmath215kms@xmath4 because the instrumental response in these regions does not appear to have temporal changes .
[ [ line - profile - and - fixed - line - width ] ] _ line profile and fixed line width _
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + for lines with doppler @xmath216kms@xmath4 , we do not expect to measure reliable line widths ( however , see the doppler @xmath217 measurements in some of the same lines in * ? ? ?
since the rgs line - spread function is best described as a lorentzian near the core , we fit our spectra using a lorentzian profile with the width fixed at the instrumental line width .
if we use a gaussian line profile instead but keep the width fixed , the line shift is consistent with zero in most cases but can be up to @xmath218kms@xmath4 in weak lines ( statistical errors greater than 200kms@xmath4 ) .
when the line width is a free parameter , we find shifts in the lorentzian centroids of @xmath219kms@xmath4 ( the shift magnitude is negatively correlated with @xmath15 ) and @xmath220kms@xmath4 in the gaussian case .
however , for the gaussian lines the best - fit line widths tend to be @xmath221 times the instrumental resolution , and the statistical error also increases .
these fits are usually not significantly better than with a fixed line width , so in our view a non - zero line width is not required by the data , and these line widths reflect some small curvature in the continuum .
[ [ bandpass ] ] _ bandpass _ + + + + + + + + + + the fitting bandpass is important because the continuum model needs to fit well even if the result is unphysical .
typically , one fits the local continuum , but in the literature for the line this can vary from a fitting interval less than 1 wide to about 5 wide .
our choice of fitting bandpass ( 21 - 22 ) is motivated by strong instrumental features below 21and above 22 , but if we ignore these features and expand our bandpass by @xmath251 , the typical velocity shift is @xmath222kms@xmath4 .
[ [ bad - columns - near-21.6 ] ] _ bad columns near 21.6 _
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + there is asymmetry in the line - spread function ( lsf ) , which is the instrumental response to a @xmath223-function , near the line .
this is not the same as the well known asymmetry in the lsf at the 1% level in the line wings ( which is not important ) , but rather due to bad columns that are not included in the cool pixel list ( figure [ figure.lsf_error ] ) . for an arbitrarily strong @xmath223-function line , the offset in the measured centroid from this defect can range from @xmath224kms@xmath4 depending on where the true line centroid is .
however , if the line is unresolved but has some physical width ( so that incident photons would be dispersed over multiple bins even before the lsf spreads them out ) , the error is strongly mitigated .
we used xspec simulations to determine the error as a function of doppler @xmath217 parameter , and for @xmath225kms@xmath4 ( about the thermal width even without turbulence ) , the typical error is reduced to 15kms@xmath4 ( figure [ figure.lsf_error ] ) .
we expect the galactic halo lines to be in this regime .
alternatively , one can ignore the columns , but because of their proximity to the region of interest , this will also bias the results .
overall , the systematic error should allow measurements to better than 30kms@xmath4 accuracy with sufficient @xmath15 .
for the high @xmath15 lines we estimate a typical systematic error of 15 - 20kms@xmath4 , and for lines weaker than about 4@xmath16 , the systematic error is dominated by the statistical error .
we used a simple halo model for comparison to the data .
we adopted an extended density profile @xcite in which @xmath226 where @xmath227@xmath228kpc@xmath229 and @xmath230 , computed on a grid with 0.05kpc cells .
this model describes a large , all - sky sample of 649 and oviii emission lines @xcite well .
we then imposed global bulk radial ( @xmath231 ) or azimuthal ( @xmath232 ) velocities , assuming that these are constant with radius .
these are the free parameters in the model .
we likewise assume a constant metallicity ( @xmath233 ) and a doppler @xmath217 parameter of 85kms@xmath4 due to random turbulent motion in each cell , based on hydrodynamic simulations @xcite
. we also account for the possibility of intrinsic scatter ( resulting from hydrodynamic flows ) about any model by adding a velocity dispersion to the velocities when comparing to the models .
this dispersion is not the same as line _ broadening _ , but refers to the typical value for a distribution of centroid shifts .
we obtain model velocities for each object by integrating from the position of the sun outward along each line of sight , computing the line - of - sight velocity component and broadening for each cell and summing the resultant voigt profiles ( a more detailed description is given in * ? ? ?
we convolve the result with the lsf , compute the centroid , and add the solar reflex motion for comparison to the observations . in other words ,
the velocities are compared in the frame of the local standard of rest . for this model ,
at least 50% of the total absorption comes from beyond 7kpc from the sun , and 90% from within 50kpc . in the simplest case of a stationary halo ,
the galactic rotation of the local standard of rest @xcite ( @xmath234kms@xmath4 ) is reflected in the measured doppler shifts : @xmath235 , where @xmath236 is the galactic longitude and @xmath217 the galactic latitude .
the product @xmath237 corresponds to the sun moving directly towards or away from that direction , resulting in a doppler shift of @xmath238kms@xmath4 .
another simple case is a corotating halo ( @xmath239 ) , in which case the doppler shifts will be closer to zero .
figure [ figure.velocities ] shows the measured velocities with the stationary and corotating models .
the best - fit @xmath231 and @xmath232 values were obtained from a markov - chain monte carlo ( mcmc ) approach , using the @xmath240 statistic as a goodness - of - fit parameter . for zero dispersion ,
the best model has a prograde rotation velocity of @xmath241kms@xmath4 and a global inflow of @xmath242kms@xmath4 , corresponding to a net accretion rate of @xmath243yr@xmath4 ( figure [ figure.results ] ) .
this is a formally acceptable fit , whereas the stationary halo is rejected with 99.95% probability and the corotating halo is marginally rejected with 95% probability .
the velocity dispersion for which the reduced @xmath240 is closest to 1.0 is about 50kms@xmath4 ( figure [ figure.results ] ) ; substantially more than this produces a @xmath240 that is too small for the observed line centroids .
the apparent inflow is not statistically significant , and the suggestion of inflow primarily results from mrk 421 ( figure [ figure.velocities ] ) , which has a small uncertainty and is near @xmath244 .
taking these results at face value , the large @xmath232 and extent of the halo imply that the total angular momentum of the hot gas within 50kpc is comparable to that in the stars and gas in the disk of the galaxy @xcite ( figure [ figure.momentum ] ) .
the spread in recent measurements of @xmath245kms@xmath4 @xcite leads to @xmath246kms@xmath4 , which does not change the picture of a lagging halo with prograde rotation .
in addition to parameter fitting , we used nonparametric statistical tests to test the hypothesis that some rotation is necessary .
we tested the stationary and corotating models using the sign test and the kolmogorov - smirnov ( ks ) test , which compare distributions and are less sensitive to scatter .
the sign test asks whether the medians of the measured and model velocities are consistent with each other ( assuming a binomial distribution and a 50% probability that the model velocity exceeds the measured velocity ) .
the left panel of figure [ figure.nonpar ] shows the residuals from subtracting the data from the stationary model values , and the strong asymmetry rules out the stationary model with 99.87% probability . the ks test compares the cumulative distributions of the measured and model velocities , and this test rules out the stationary halo with 98.5% probability .
the corotating model is acceptable in the sign test ( 43% rejection probability ) and not in the ks test ( 99.8% probability ) .
the rejection of the stationary halo is model independent .
if we exclude weak lines with @xmath247kms@xmath4 , a stationary model is still ruled out at more than 99.4% probability .
if we exclude ambiguous lines ( such as those towards ngc 5408 x-1 , ngc 4051 , and mcg-6 - 30 - 15 ) , a stationary model is ruled out at about 98% probability in the ks test and 99.6% in the sign test .
excluding ngc 4051 ( with its small error bars ) increases the range of acceptable @xmath232 in the parametric fits , but the best - fit @xmath231 does not change much as the error bars for mrk 421 are even smaller .
we investigated the sensitivity of the best - fit parameters and the implied angular momentum to the model assumptions .
first , the assumption of constant velocity must break down at some radius .
an effort to measure the galactic rotation curve to 200kpc using disk and non - disk objects found @xcite that @xmath232 is flat to 80kpc , while a measurement from disk stars in the sloan digital sky survey found @xcite that @xmath232 in the disk declines by 15% from @xmath248 at 10 - 20kpc and remains constant from 20 - 55kpc ( the maximum probed ) .
thus , the assumption of a constant @xmath249 or @xmath232 within @xmath250kpc appears to be reasonable , and more than 80% of the cumulative equivalent width comes from within this region ( figure [ figure.momentum ] ) .
when we considered a model with a constant @xmath232 within 50kpc and @xmath251kms@xmath4 beyond , the best - fit @xmath232 is nearly identical to the reported value . for a 10kpc cutoff , the best - fit @xmath232 increases .
second , there may be a metallicity gradient in the hot gas , in which case the cumulative equivalent width will be even more dominated by nearby gas .
this would impact the inferred mass and total angular momentum of the halo gas . constraints from o vii and oviii and pulsar dispersion measures towards the large magellanic cloud are consistent @xcite with a gradient of @xmath252 with @xmath253 at 1kpc and @xmath254 at 10kpc .
the uncertainty is large , but the gradient is shallow enough that gas beyond a few kpc contributes 50% or more of the equivalent width .
finally , even a single - component hot halo is probably not isothermal and may also have flows arising from satellite galaxy motions or gaseous inflows and outflows . since the combined emission- and absorption - line data favor an extended halo and its temperature is near the virial temperature , the gas is probably volume filling .
hydrodynamic flows in such a halo will primarily induce scatter of the type described above , which does not strongly affect our @xmath232 measurement ( figure [ figure.results ] ) .
thus , the measured halo rotation probably extends to tens of kpc and possibly to 100kpc , and this gas will have a substantial angular momentum .
however , the angular momentum values ( figure [ figure.momentum ] ) are strongly model dependent , especially due to the assumption of constant @xmath255 .
the interpretation of the measured doppler shifts as a rotation signature depends on the validity of our single - component halo model .
this depends on the following assumptions : ( 1 ) a volume - filling spherical halo is an approximately accurate representation of most of the hot gas around the galaxy ; ( 2 ) there is no strong local absorber that we have ignored ; ( 3 ) the spherical halo has bulk global motion ; ( 4 ) the assumption of @xmath256 is reasonable within about 50kpc ; and ( 5 ) the doppler shift measurements are accurate .
the fourth and fifth assumptions were addressed above , so here we focus on the first three .
two basic models are suggested in the literature for the structure of the hot halo : an extended , spherical distribution or an exponential disk with a scale height of a few kpc . when using individual sight lines or small samples @xcite , the observed and absorption and emission line strengths are consistent with an exponential disk model with a scale height of a few kpc .
they are also consistent with a spherical model .
however , larger samples of absorption lines ( @xmath3040 sight lines ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) and the all - sky emission - line intensities ( @xmath2571,000 sight lines * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) favor a spherical model .
similar analyses on independent observables that also probe the hot gas , such as the pulsar dispersion measure towards the large magellanic cloud and the ram - pressure stripping of milky way satellites favor an extended halo @xcite .
finally , a recent analysis of both galactic and extragalactic sightlines for @xmath258 galaxies finds that the traces hot gas @xcite .
thus , we adopted the spherical density profile of @xcite .
however , these analyses are based on single - component models , and from basic galaxy models we expect at least two x - ray absorbing components : infalling gas that is shock heated to the virial temperature ( @xmath259k for the milky way ) and forms an extended halo ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , and supernova - driven outflows from the disk ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . in the latter case
, we expect an exponential disk of hot gas with a scale height set ( for a given galactocentric radius ) by the temperature at the midplane . it is worth noting that
for @xmath260k , the scale height at the solar circle is larger than the galactocentric distance , so the distribution of outflowing gas could also be spherical , if not very extended ; the true shape depends on how widespread the outflows are in the disk , the actual midplane temperature , and the amount of radiative cooling . within the galaxy disk itself ,
supernovae contribute to the hot interstellar medium , much of which is confined within the disk . since x - ray absorption covers a wider temperature range than emission , we are also weakly sensitive to cooler gas ( described in the following subsection ) .
these components may be kinematically distinct , as is seen in the warm gas by @xcite , but at the relatively low resolution of the rgs , we expect them to be blended .
this complicates the interpretation of the measured centroids , which are the weighted average of the offsets for each component along that line of sight . at a qualitative level
, we expect the gas confined in the galaxy disk to rotate with it ( although depending on the distances to the absorbers , there may not be any rotation signature ) and the gas in supernova - driven outflows to rotate in the same direction but lagging the disk as it reaches larger heights or radii . to constrain the column and thus the influence on the line centroids from a disk component , we extended the analysis of @xcite to fit a disk@xmath261halo model to the same data set they used : 648 emission lines from @xcite , which are filtered for contamination from solar - wind charge exchange and ignore most of the galactic plane .
we refer the reader to @xcite for a more detailed explanation of the modeling procedure , but we summarize our model components here .
the sun exists in a region known as the local bubble , which emits soft x - rays ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , and we adopt for the bubble a temperature of @xmath262k , a variable path length between 100 - 300pc , and a density @xmath263@xmath228 .
the nature of the bubble and the density remain debatable because of the contribution from solar - wind charge exchange ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
? * ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
we have ignored hot interstellar gas confined within the galaxy disk other than the local bubble .
constraints from the intensity of the soft x - ray background imply that our sight lines will incur only a small column from this material , and the emission - line sample excludes the galactic plane .
for the extended halo component , we assume an isothermal ( @xmath264k ) plasma with a density profile described by equation [ equation.beta_model ] .
for the exponential disk component , we assume a form for the density of @xmath265 where @xmath266 is the scale height .
the temperature declines in an analogous way , and we fix the midplane temperature and its scale height to @xmath267k and 5.6kpc , respectively @xcite because we do not model the line ratios as a temperature diagnostic .
the free parameters are the normalizations , @xmath268 , and @xmath266 , which we constrain using the same mcmc method as @xcite .
we assume that each component is optically thin and compute its contribution to the intensity along each line - of - sight @xmath269 : @xmath270 where @xmath271 is the volumetric line emissivity from the apec thermal plasma code @xcite .
finally , the line intensities from @xcite do not account for absorption due to galactic hi , so to compare our model intensities to theirs we apply photoelectric absorption using the neutral hydrogen column from @xcite to the halo and disk components : @xmath272 where @xmath16 is the absorption cross - section and @xmath273 is the intensity from the local bubble .
figure [ figure.disk_halo ] shows the results from the mcmc analysis as marginalized posterior probability distributions for each of the free parameters .
the model is not a significant improvement on the pure halo model , and the best - fit parameters for the halo ( @xmath274@xmath228kpc@xmath229 , @xmath275 ) are consistent with the results in @xcite .
the disk parameters are poorly constrained and indicate that _ the exponential disk contributes at most 10% of the total column density .
_ this corroborates the @xcite result .
in contrast , the @xcite disk model ( which assumes the halo gas can be described entirely by a disk and is based on one sightline ) finds @xmath276 and @xmath277kpc .
@xcite , who include some sight lines near the galactic plane and some outside the plane , find that the column is consistent with @xmath278@xmath228 and a scale height of @xmath279kpc , but the authors acknowledge that mixing results from sight lines towards nearby x - ray binaries at low latitudes and those at high latitudes can lead to a strong bias ; the hot material confined to the galaxy disk is not part of the exponential disk structure that we have modeled , but it can contribute at low latitudes .
thus , the impact of the disk component on the measured centroids must be small , since 80 - 90% of the column density will come from the spherical component .
assuming that the two components are kinematically distinct , for the latter to be stationary and consistent with the measured centroids requires a disk speed much faster than co - rotation .
we verified this by modeling a rotating disk and a stationary halo where the disk contributes 10% of the column . since this is inconsistent with models where the gas originates in the galaxy disk , the data probe motion in the spherical component . for reference ,
if the @xcite disk model is adopted instead of the @xcite model or our disk@xmath261halo model , the best - fit azimuthal and radial velocities are @xmath280kms@xmath4 and @xmath281kms@xmath4 . we have assumed that , to first order , the spherical component moves as a solid body with some @xmath232 and @xmath231
. there may be second - order effects such as the internal flows mentioned above ( perhaps due to satellite motions or infalling clouds ) or modes in the fluid , which would add scatter to the velocity measurements .
however , if the halo is volume filling and in steady state , then large scale disturbances will tend to dissipate in a sound - crossing time ( which could be a long time if the halo is very extended ) , and the gas ( if stationary ) will tend towards hydrostatic equilibrium .
multiple major kinematic components are therefore not expected , although we would expect differential rotation . in this case , the measured rotation velocity is some average but still provides useful information .
also , if the material is fresh infall from the cosmic web then it likely accretes along filaments , which lead to a preferential orbital angular momentum axis .
finally , gas ejected from the disk ( either cold or hot ) could spin up the halo @xcite , although perhaps not to the velocity that we infer .
it is possible that there is a layer of warm - hot gas near the galactic plane ( in addition to the local bubble ) that affects every sight line out of the galaxy , but to which our models are not sensitive because we ignore data close to the galactic plane ( where dust , supernova remnants , and other features make modeling very difficult ) . characterizing the structure and filling factor of the hot interstellar medium
has been a major effort by itself ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) and is beyond the scope of this paper , but if there is such a layer ( possibly a disk with a scale height of a few hundred pc ) with a high density , the rotation signature in the rgs data could be misattributed to the halo . on the other hand , for plausible path lengths , oxygen column densities , and foreground absorption column densities this layer should also produce emission in excess of the local bubble contribution to the soft x - ray background . to summarize , the halo models that are based on many data points as opposed to a few sightlines favor a spherical halo ( especially in emission ) as the dominant component .
any contribution to the column density from a kinematically distinct ( thick ) exponential disk is small in this scenario , so the doppler shifts support a non - stationary extended halo .
reinterpreting these shifts will be necessary if future data or analyses rule out a spherical halo ( or at least a volume - filling one ) or a high resolution x - ray spectrometer resolves the lines into components inconsistent with rotation . also , we reiterate that the parametric fit strongly depends on the few agns with the highest @xmath15 , but the nonparametric tests indicate rotation at some level .
the ion fraction is high between @xmath282k , so the cooler ( non - coronal ) gas seen in and around the galaxy in with _ fuse _ @xcite will also absorb .
the lines towards background objects reveal galactic and high - velocity absorbers @xcite .
the galactic absorbers ( also seen towards stars ) are consistent with an exponential disk of scale height 1 - 4kpc @xcite , whereas the high - velocity absorbers may come from the halo or outside the galaxy .
if the column densities of these absorbers are high , then their lines could bias our results . since the disk component will rotate , we are most concerned about contamination from this gas .
@xcite measured column densities for about 150 sight lines around the galaxy and found a typical column of @xmath283@xmath284 .
for the sight lines in our sample , we expect @xmath285@xmath284 .
if the absorbers are at @xmath286k and in collisional ionization equilibrium , the o vii/ ratio is 1.7 , which leads to an expected contribution of @xmath287@xmath284 .
in contrast , the typical column ( assuming an optically thin plasma ) is @xmath288@xmath284 @xcite .
hence , the contribution directly from absorbers in the galaxy is at most 15% .
it is likely lower , since @xcite and @xcite argue that the lines are not optically thin .
the bias from the absorbers also declines at higher latitude , since the column declines more slowly than the column with increasing @xmath217 ( corroborated in _ emission _ by * ? ? ?
for most of our sight lines we estimate that the local and disk contribution to the column is less than 10% .
even a 10% contribution is important for measuring the true halo velocity , but compared to the uncertainty in our best - fit velocity parameters , it is small .
more importantly , as with the hot disk considered above , it can not by itself account for the measured velocities if we assume that the million - degree halo is stationary . we have measured a signature of rotation in the line around the milky way using 37 sight lines towards background agns and archival rgs data .
the parametric fit strongly depends on the brightest agns , but nonparametric tests indicate that the absorbers are not stationary , even when removing suspect lines . from larger samples of emission and absorption lines , we believe that an extended halo is more consistent with the data than an exponential ( thick ) disk , and in this case this halo rotates at some velocity smaller than @xmath248 . taken at face value
, this implies that the million - degree gas has a comparable angular momentum to the galaxy disk .
it is possible that both components exist , in which case the rgs lines are blends of kinematically distinct components .
we use a large sample of emission lines to constrain the contribution of each component to the column density , and find that an exponential disk accounts for no more than 10% of the column density .
thus , the measured doppler shifts are dominated by the motion of the gas in the extended halo , which is consistent with prograde rotation .
even if a disk were to dominate ( which , for our data , produces an unacceptable @xmath240 value ) , the best - fit azimuthal velocities imply that it is rotating at nearly the same speed and with a comparable amount of angular momentum to the spherical model .
this conclusion depends on assumptions about the underlying model .
measuring the true velocity and separating the x - ray absorbers into their various components requires a high - resolution x - ray instrument with a large effective area ( e.g. _ arcus _ , * ? ? ?
* ) , which would also give important information on their line shapes that could constrain the optical depth and doppler @xmath217 parameters @xcite , as well as reveal the contribution to the total column from the disk and the coronal halo gas seen in x - ray emission .
the recent work on calibrating the conversion of dispersion angle to a wavelength grid for the rgs @xcite and stacking multiple observations of the same object enables a wavelength accuracy of tens of kms@xmath4 for the first time ( figure [ figure.capella_wavelength ] ) . after investigating a variety of systematic issues , we find that the statistical uncertainty ( due to the low @xmath15 in many spectra and the relatively small sample ) remains the major source of error .
the inferred halo velocity and angular momentum are strongly model dependent ( and the uncertainties that we report are large ) , but the basic conclusion that the hot gas distribution rotates is less so .
several scenarios could produce a rotating halo that lags behind the disk , depending on the geometry .
these include a galactic fountain of cool gas that spins up hot gas @xcite , a hot galactic fountain of superbubble ejecta that produces an exponential disk before cooling , or infall from the cosmic web with some preferential direction .
our measurements can not , by themselves , distinguish between these models ( which may not be mutually exclusive ) , but they are an important kinematic constraint for future halo and galaxy formation models .
we thank eric bell for analysis suggestions and constructive criticism , and oleg gnedin for information on the galaxy s angular momentum .
frits paerels provided technical advice regarding the rgs .
we thank the referees for substantial comments that significantly improved the manuscript .
we gratefully acknowledge financial support from the nasa adap program , through grant nnx11ag55 g . , r. k. , ackermann , m. , allured , r. , et al .
2014 , in society of photo - optical instrumentation engineers ( spie ) conference series , vol . 9144 , society of photo - optical instrumentation engineers ( spie ) conference series , 4 | the hot gaseous halos of galaxies likely contain a large amount of mass and are an integral part of galaxy formation and evolution .
the milky way has a @xmath0 k halo that is detected in emission and by absorption in the resonance line against bright background agns , and for which the best current model is an extended spherical distribution . using xmm - newton rgs data
, we measure the doppler shifts of the absorption - line centroids toward an ensemble of agns .
these doppler shifts constrain the dynamics of the hot halo , ruling out a stationary halo at about @xmath1 and a co - rotating halo at @xmath2 , and leading to a best - fit rotational velocity @xmath3kms@xmath4 for an extended halo model .
these results suggest that the hot gas rotates and that it contains an amount of angular momentum comparable to that in the stellar disk .
we examined the possibility of a model with a kinematically distinct disk and spherical halo . to be consistent with the emission - line x - ray data the disk must contribute less than 10% of the column density , implying that the doppler shifts probe motion in the extended hot halo . |
optimal control theory is concerned with the analysis of controlled dynamical systems , where one aims at steering such a system from a given configuration to some desired target one by minimizing or maximizing some criterion . the pontryagin maximum principle ( denoted in short pmp ) , established at the end of the fifties for finite dimensional general nonlinear continuous - time dynamics
( see @xcite , and see @xcite for the history of this discovery ) , is the milestone of the classical optimal control theory .
it provides a first - order necessary condition for optimality , by asserting that any optimal trajectory must be the projection of an extremal .
the pmp then reduces the search of optimal trajectories to a boundary value problem posed on extremals . optimal control theory , and in particular the pmp , have an immense field of applications in various domains , and it is not our aim here to list them .
we refer the reader to textbooks on optimal control such as @xcite for many examples of theoretical or practical applications of optimal control , essentially in a continuous - time setting . right after this discovery
the corresponding theory has been developed for discrete - time dynamics , under appropriate convexity assumptions ( see e.g. @xcite ) , leading to a version of the pmp for discrete - time optimal control problems .
the considerable development of the discrete - time control theory was motivated by many potential applications e.g. to digital systems or in view of discrete approximations in numerical simulations of differential controlled systems .
we refer the reader to the textbooks @xcite for details on this theory and many examples of applications .
it can be noted that some early works devoted to the discrete - time pmp ( like @xcite ) are mathematically incorrect .
many counter - examples were provided in @xcite ( see also @xcite ) , showing that , as is now well known , the exact analogous of the continuous - time pmp does not hold at the discrete level .
more precisely , the maximization condition of the pmp can not be expected to hold in general in the discrete - time case .
nevertheless a weaker condition can be derived , see ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 42.1 p. 330 ) .
note as well that approximate maximization conditions are given in ( * ? ? ?
* section 6.4 ) and that a wide literature is devoted to the introduction of convexity assumptions on the dynamics allowing one to recover the maximization condition in the discrete case ( such as the concept of _ directional convexity _ assumption used in @xcite for example ) .
the _ time scale _ theory was introduced in @xcite in order to unify discrete and continuous analysis .
a time scale @xmath2 is an arbitrary non empty closed subset of @xmath1 , and a dynamical system is said to be posed on the time scale @xmath2 whenever the time variable evolves along this set @xmath2 .
the continuous - time case corresponds to @xmath3 and the discrete - time case corresponds to @xmath4 .
the time scale theory aims at closing the gap between continuous and discrete cases and allows one to treat more general models of processes involving both continuous and discrete time elements , and more generally for dynamical systems where the time evolves along a set of a complex nature which may even be a cantor set ( see e.g. @xcite for a study of a seasonally breeding population whose generations do not overlap , or @xcite for applications to economics ) .
many notions of standard calculus have been extended to the time scale framework , and we refer the reader to @xcite for details on this theory . the theory of the calculus of variations on time scales , initiated in @xcite , has been well studied in the existing literature ( see e.g. @xcite ) .
few attempts have been made to derive a pmp on time scales . in @xcite
the authors establish a _ weak _ pmp for shifted controlled systems , where the controls are not subject to any pointwise constraint and under certain restrictive assumptions .
a strong version of the pmp is claimed in @xcite but many arguments thereof are erroneous ( see remark [ remzhan ] for details ) .
the objective of the present article is to state and prove a strong version of the pmp on time scales , valuable for general nonlinear dynamics , and without assuming any unnecessary lipschitz or convexity conditions .
our statement is as general as possible , and encompasses the classical continuous - time pmp that can be found e.g. in @xcite as well as all versions of discrete - time pmp s mentioned above . in accordance with
all known results , the maximization condition is obtained at right - dense points of the time scale and a weaker one ( similar to ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 42.1 p. 330 ) ) is derived at right - scattered points .
moreover , we consider general constraints on the initial and final values of the state variable and we derive the resulting transversality conditions .
we provide as well a version of the pmp for optimal control problems with parameters .
the article is structured as follows . in section [ part1 ] ,
we first provide some basic issues of time scale calculus ( subsection [ section1 ] ) .
we define some appropriate notions such as the notion of stable @xmath0-dense direction in subsection [ sec_topoprelim ] . in subsection [ section2 ]
we settle the notion of admissible control and define general optimal control problems on time scales .
our main result ( pontryagin maximum principle , theorem [ thmmain ] ) is stated in subsection [ section2bis1 ] , and we analyze and comment the results in a series of remarks . section [ part3 ] is devoted to the proof of theorem [ thmmain ] .
first , in subsection [ section10 ] we make some preliminary comments explaining which obstructions may appear when dealing with general time scales , and why we were led to a proof based on ekeland s variational principle
. we also comment on the article @xcite in remark [ remzhan ] . in subsection
[ section3 ] , after having shown that the set of admissible controls is open , we define needle - like variations at right - dense and right - scattered points and derive some properties . in subsection [ section4 ] , we apply ekeland s variational principle to a well chosen functional in an appropriate complete metric space and then prove the pmp .
let @xmath2 be a time scale , that is , an arbitrary closed subset of @xmath1 .
we assume throughout that @xmath2 is bounded below and that @xmath5 .
we denote by @xmath6 . for every subset @xmath7 of @xmath1 ,
we denote by @xmath8 .
an interval of @xmath2 is defined by @xmath9 where @xmath10 is an interval of @xmath1 . the backward and forward jump operators @xmath11 are respectively defined by @xmath12 and @xmath13 for every @xmath14 , where @xmath15 and @xmath16 whenever @xmath2 is bounded above .
a point @xmath14 is said to be _ left - dense _
( respectively , _
left - scattered _ , _ right - dense _ or _ right - scattered _ ) whenever @xmath17 ( respectively , @xmath18 , @xmath19 or @xmath20 ) . the graininess function @xmath21 is defined by @xmath22 for every @xmath14 .
we denote by @xmath23 the set of all right - scattered points of @xmath2 , and by @xmath24 the set of all right - dense points of @xmath2 in @xmath25 .
note that @xmath23 is a subset of @xmath26 , is at most countable ( see ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 3.1 ) ) , and note that @xmath24 is the complement of @xmath23 in @xmath25 . for every @xmath27 and every @xmath28 , we set @xmath29_\t \}.\ ] ] note that @xmath30 is not isolated in @xmath31 . [
[ dd - differentiability . ] ] @xmath32-differentiability .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + we set @xmath33 whenever @xmath2 admits a left - scattered maximum , and @xmath34 otherwise .
let @xmath35 ; a function @xmath36 is said to be @xmath32-differentiable at @xmath37 if the limit @xmath38 exists in @xmath39 , where @xmath40 . recall that , if @xmath37 is a right - dense point of @xmath2 , then @xmath41 is @xmath32-differentiable at @xmath42 if and
only if the limit of @xmath43 as @xmath44 , @xmath45 , exists ; in that case it is equal to @xmath46 . if @xmath37 is a right - scattered point of @xmath2 and if @xmath41 is continuous at @xmath42 , then @xmath41 is @xmath32-differentiable at @xmath42 , and @xmath47 ( see @xcite ) . if @xmath48 are both @xmath32-differentiable at @xmath37 , then the scalar product @xmath49 is @xmath32-differentiable at @xmath42 and @xmath50 ( leibniz formula , see ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 1.20 ) ) .
[ [ lebesgue - dd - measure - and - lebesgue - dd - integrability . ] ] lebesgue @xmath32-measure and lebesgue @xmath32-integrability .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + let @xmath51 be the lebesgue @xmath32-measure on @xmath2 defined in terms of carathodory extension in ( * ? ? ?
* chapter 5 ) .
we also refer the reader to @xcite for more details on the @xmath51-measure theory . for all @xmath52
such that @xmath53 , there holds @xmath54 . recall that @xmath55 is a @xmath51-measurable set of @xmath2 if and only if @xmath7 is an usual @xmath56-measurable set of @xmath1 , where @xmath56 denotes the usual lebesgue measure ( see ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 3.1 ) ) .
moreover , if @xmath57 , then @xmath58 let @xmath55 .
a property is said to hold @xmath32-almost everywhere ( in short , @xmath32-a.e . ) on @xmath7 if it holds for every @xmath59 , where @xmath60 is some @xmath51-measurable subset of @xmath2 satisfying @xmath61 .
in particular , since @xmath62 for every @xmath63 , we conclude that if a property holds @xmath32-a.e .
on @xmath7 , then it holds for every @xmath64 .
let @xmath35 and let @xmath57 be a @xmath51-measurable subset of @xmath2 . consider a function @xmath41 defined @xmath32-a.e .
on @xmath7 with values in @xmath39 .
let @xmath65r,\sigma(r)[_{r \in a \cap \rr}$ ] , and let @xmath66 be the extension of @xmath41 defined @xmath56-a.e . on @xmath67 by @xmath68 whenever @xmath69 , and by @xmath70 whenever @xmath71r,\sigma(r)[$ ] , for every @xmath64 . recall that @xmath41 is @xmath51-measurable on @xmath7 if and only if @xmath66 is @xmath56-measurable on @xmath67 ( see ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 4.1 ) ) .
the functional space @xmath72 is the set of all functions @xmath41 defined @xmath32-a.e .
on @xmath7 , with values in @xmath39 , that are @xmath51-measurable on @xmath7 and bounded almost everywhere .
endowed with the norm @xmath73 , it is a banach space ( see ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 2.5 ) ) .
here the notation @xmath74 stands for the usual euclidean norm of @xmath39 .
the functional space @xmath75 is the set of all functions @xmath41 defined @xmath32-a.e . on @xmath7 , with values in @xmath39 , that are @xmath51-measurable on @xmath7 and such that @xmath76 .
endowed with the norm @xmath77 , it is a banach space ( see ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 2.5 ) ) .
we recall here that if @xmath78 then @xmath79 ( see ( * ? ? ? * theorems 5.1 and 5.2 ) ) .
note that if @xmath7 is bounded then @xmath80 .
the functional space @xmath81 is the set of all functions @xmath41 defined @xmath32-a.e . on @xmath82 , with values in @xmath39 , that are @xmath51-measurable on @xmath82 and such that @xmath83 for all @xmath52 such that @xmath84 .
[ [ absolutely - continuous - functions . ] ] absolutely continuous functions .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + let @xmath35 and let @xmath85 such that @xmath84 . let @xmath86_\t,\r^n)$ ] denote the space of continuous functions defined on @xmath87_\t$ ] with values in @xmath39 . endowed with its usual uniform norm @xmath88 , it is a banach space .
let @xmath89_\t,\r^n)$ ] denote the subspace of absolutely continuous functions .
let @xmath90_\t$ ] and @xmath91_\t \rightarrow \r^n$ ] .
it is easily derived from ( * ? ? ? * theorem 4.1 ) that @xmath92_\t,\r^n)$ ] if and only if @xmath41 is @xmath32-differentiable @xmath32-a.e .
on @xmath93 and satisfies @xmath94 , and for every @xmath95_\t$ ] there holds @xmath96 whenever @xmath97 , and @xmath98 whenever @xmath99 .
assume that @xmath100 , and let @xmath101 be the function defined on @xmath87_\t$ ] by @xmath102 whenever @xmath103 , and by @xmath104 whenever @xmath105 .
then @xmath106_\t)$ ] and @xmath107 @xmath32-a.e .
on @xmath93 .
note that , if @xmath92_\t , \r^n ) $ ] is such that @xmath108 @xmath32-a.e .
on @xmath93 , then @xmath41 is constant on @xmath87_\t$ ] , and that , if @xmath109_\t , \r^n ) $ ] , then @xmath110_\t , \r ) $ ] and the leibniz formula is available @xmath32-a.e . on @xmath93 . for every @xmath100 ,
let @xmath111 be the set of points @xmath112 that are @xmath32-lebesgue points of @xmath41 . there holds @xmath113 , and @xmath114 for every @xmath115 , where @xmath116 is defined by .
[ footnotelebesguepoints ] note that the analogous result for @xmath117 is not true in general .
indeed , let @xmath100 and assume that there exists a point @xmath118 .
since @xmath119 , one has @xmath120 .
nevertheless the limit @xmath121 as @xmath122 with @xmath123 , is not necessarily equal to @xmath124 .
for instance , consider @xmath125 \cup \ { 2 \}$ ] , @xmath126 and @xmath41 defined on @xmath2 by @xmath127 for every @xmath128 and @xmath129 .. [ rem18h05 ] recall that two distinct derivative operators are usually considered in the time scale calculus , namely , the @xmath32-derivative , corresponding to a forward derivative , and the @xmath130-derivative , corresponding to a backward derivative , and that both of them are associated with a notion of integral . in this article , without loss of generality we consider optimal control problems defined on time scales with a @xmath32-derivative and with a cost function written with the corresponding notion of @xmath32-integral .
our main result , the pmp , is then stated using the notions of right - dense and right - scattered points .
all problems and results of our article can be as well stated in terms of @xmath130-derivative , @xmath130-integral , left - dense and left - scattered points .
let @xmath131 and let @xmath0 be a non empty closed subset of @xmath132 . in this section we define the notion of stable @xmath0-dense direction . in our main result
the set @xmath0 will stand for the set of pointwise constraints on the controls .
let @xmath133 and @xmath134 . 1 .
we set @xmath135 .
note that @xmath136 .
we say that @xmath137 is a @xmath0-dense direction from @xmath138 if @xmath30 is not isolated in @xmath139 .
the set of all @xmath0-dense directions from @xmath138 is denoted by @xmath140 .
we say that @xmath137 is a stable @xmath0-dense direction from @xmath138 if there exists @xmath141 such that @xmath142 for every @xmath143 , where @xmath144 is the closed ball of @xmath132 centered at @xmath138 and with radius @xmath145 .
the set of all stable @xmath0-dense directions from @xmath138 is denoted by @xmath146 .
note that @xmath147 means that @xmath137 is a @xmath0-dense direction from @xmath148 for every @xmath149 in a neighbourhood of @xmath138 . in the following ,
we denote by @xmath150 the interior of a subset .
we have the following easy properties . 1 . if @xmath151 , then @xmath152 .
2 . if @xmath153 then @xmath154 ; 3 .
if @xmath0 is convex then @xmath155 for every @xmath133 . for every @xmath133 ,
we denote by @xmath156 the closed convex cone of vertex @xmath138 spanned by @xmath146 , with the agreement that @xmath157 whenever @xmath158 .
in particular , there holds @xmath159 for every @xmath133 .
although elementary , since these notions are new ( up to our knowledge ) , before proceeding with our main result ( stated in section [ section2 ] ) we provide the reader with several simple examples illustrating these notions . since @xmath160 for every @xmath151 , we focus on elements @xmath161 in the examples below .
assume that @xmath162 .
the closed convex subsets @xmath0 of @xmath1 having a nonempty interior and such that @xmath163 are closed intervals bounded above or below and not reduced to a singleton . if @xmath0 is bounded below then @xmath164 , and if @xmath0 is bounded above then @xmath165-\infty,\max\omega]$ ] .
assume that @xmath166 and let @xmath0 be the convex set of @xmath167 such that @xmath168 , @xmath169 and @xmath170 ( see figure [ fig1 ] ) .
the stable @xmath0-dense directions for elements @xmath161 are given by : * if @xmath171 , then @xmath172 ; * if @xmath173 with @xmath174 , then @xmath175 ; * if @xmath176 with @xmath174 , then @xmath177 ; * if @xmath178 , then @xmath179 and @xmath180 ; * if @xmath181 , then @xmath182 and @xmath183 ; * if @xmath184 with @xmath174 , then @xmath146 is the union of @xmath185 and of the strict hypograph of @xmath186 , and @xmath156 is the hypograph of @xmath186 . let @xmath0 be a non empty closed convex subset of @xmath132 and let @xmath187 denote the smallest affine subspace of @xmath132 containing @xmath0 .
for every @xmath188 that is not a corner point , @xmath189 is the half - space of @xmath187 delimited by the tangent hyperplane ( in @xmath187 ) of @xmath0 at @xmath138 , and containing @xmath0 .
[ ex1 ] assume that @xmath166 and let @xmath0 be the set of @xmath167 such that @xmath190 ( see figure [ fig2 ] ) .
the stable @xmath0-dense directions for elements @xmath161 are given by : * if @xmath191 with @xmath192 , then @xmath193 ; * if @xmath191 with @xmath194 , then @xmath195 ; * if @xmath171 , then @xmath196 , @xmath197 ; note that , in all cases , @xmath198 is a closed convex cone of vertex @xmath138 and therefore @xmath199 .
[ ex2 ] assume that @xmath166 and let @xmath0 be the set of @xmath167 such that @xmath200 ( see figure [ fig3 ] ) .
let @xmath201 and let @xmath202 denote the graph of the tangent to @xmath0 at the point @xmath203 .
it is easy to see that @xmath140 is the hypograph of @xmath186 , that @xmath146 is the strict hypograph of @xmath186 ( note that @xmath204 ) , and that @xmath189 is the hypograph of @xmath186 .
the above example shows that it may happen that @xmath204 .
actually , it may happen that @xmath158 .
for example , if @xmath0 is the unit sphere of @xmath205 , then @xmath158 for every @xmath133 , and hence @xmath206 . [ ex3 ]
assume that @xmath166 .
we set @xmath207 , where @xmath208 for every @xmath209 , and @xmath210 ( see figure [ fig4 ] ) .
note that @xmath0 has an empty interior .
denote by @xmath211 .
we have the following properties : * if @xmath212 with @xmath213 , then @xmath214 ; * if @xmath215 with @xmath213 , then @xmath216 ; * if @xmath217 with @xmath218 , then @xmath219 and @xmath220 , and thus @xmath221 ; * if @xmath222 , then @xmath223 and @xmath220 , and thus @xmath224 ; * if @xmath225 , then @xmath226 and @xmath227 .
let @xmath228 and @xmath229 be nonzero integers , and let @xmath0 be a non empty closed subset of @xmath230 . throughout the article
, we consider the general nonlinear control system on the time scale @xmath2 @xmath231 where @xmath232 is a continuous function of class @xmath233 with respect to its two first variables , and where the control functions @xmath234 belong to @xmath235 . before defining an optimal control problem associated with the control system ,
the first question that has to be addressed is the question of the existence and uniqueness of a solution of , for a given control function and a given initial condition @xmath236 . since there
did not exist up to now in the existing literature any cauchy - lipschitz like theorem , sufficiently general to cover such a situation , in the companion paper @xcite we derived a general cauchy - lipschitz ( or picard - lindelf ) theorem for general nonlinear systems posed on time scales , providing existence and uniqueness of the maximal solution of a given @xmath32-cauchy problem under suitable assumptions like regressivity and local lipschitz continuity , and discussed some related issues like the behavior of maximal solutions at terminal points .
setting @xmath237 , let us first recall the notion of a solution of , for a given control @xmath238 ( see ( * ? ? ?
* definitions 6 and 7 ) ) .
the couple @xmath239 is said to be a solution of if @xmath9 is an interval of @xmath2 satisfying @xmath240 and @xmath241 , if @xmath242_\t,\r^n)$ ] and holds for @xmath32-a.e .
@xmath243 , for every @xmath244 .
according to ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 1 ) , for every control @xmath238 and every @xmath245 , there exists a unique maximal solution @xmath246 of , such that @xmath247 , defined on the maximal interval @xmath248 . the word _ maximal _ means that @xmath246 is an extension of any other solution . note that @xmath249 for every @xmath250 ( see ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 1 ) ) , and that either @xmath251 , that is , @xmath246 is a _
global _ solution of , or @xmath252 where @xmath253 is a left - dense point of @xmath2 , and in this case , @xmath246 is not bounded on @xmath254 ( see ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 2 ) ) .
these results are instrumental to define the concept of admissible control .
[ defadm ] for every @xmath255 , the control @xmath238 is said to be _
admissible _ on @xmath256 for some given @xmath253 whenever @xmath246 is well defined on @xmath257_\t$ ] , that is , @xmath258 .
we are now in a position to define rigorously a general optimal control problem on the time scale @xmath2 .
let @xmath259 and @xmath260 be a non empty closed convex subset of @xmath261 .
let @xmath262 be a continuous function of class @xmath233 with respect to its two first variables , and @xmath263 be a function of class @xmath233 . in what follows the subset @xmath260 and the function @xmath264 account for constraints on the initial and final conditions of the control problem . throughout the article
, we consider the optimal control problem on @xmath2 , denoted in short @xmath265 , of determining a trajectory @xmath266 defined on @xmath267_\t$ ] , solution of and associated with a control @xmath268 , minimizing the cost function @xmath269 over all possible trajectories @xmath270 defined on @xmath257_\t$ ] , solutions of and associated with an admissible control @xmath271 , with @xmath272 , and satisfying @xmath273 . the final time can be fixed or not . if it is fixed then @xmath274 in @xmath265 . in the statement below ,
the _ orthogonal _ of @xmath260 at a point @xmath275 is defined by @xmath276 it is a closed convex cone containing @xmath30 .
the _ hamiltonian _ of the optimal control problem @xmath265 is the function @xmath277 defined by @xmath278 [ thmmain ] let @xmath279 .
if the trajectory @xmath266 , defined on @xmath267_\t$ ] and associated with a control @xmath268 , is a solution of @xmath265 , then there exist @xmath280 and @xmath281 , with @xmath282 , and there exists a mapping @xmath283_\t,\r^n)$ ] ( called adjoint vector ) , such that there holds @xmath284 for @xmath32-a.e .
@xmath285 . moreover , there holds @xmath286 for every @xmath287 and every @xmath288 , and @xmath289 for @xmath32-a.e .
@xmath290 .
besides , one has the transversality conditions on the initial and final adjoint vector @xmath291 and @xmath292 .
furthermore , if the final time @xmath293 is not fixed in @xmath265 , and if additionally @xmath293 belongs to the interior of @xmath2 for the topology of @xmath1 , then @xmath294 and if @xmath295 is moreover autonomous ( that is , does not depend on @xmath42 ) , then @xmath296 theorem [ thmmain ] is proved in section [ part3 ] .
[ rempmpparam ] before proceeding with a series of remarks and comments , we provide a version of the pmp for optimal control problems with parameters .
let @xmath297 be a banach space .
we consider the general nonlinear control system with parameters on the time scale @xmath2 @xmath298 where @xmath299 is a continuous function of class @xmath233 with respect to its three first variables , and where @xmath238 as before .
the notion of admissibility is defined as before .
let @xmath300 be a continuous function of class @xmath233 with respect to its three first variables , and @xmath301 be a function of class @xmath233 .
we consider the optimal control problem on @xmath2 , denoted in short @xmath302 , of determining a trajectory @xmath266 defined on @xmath267_\t$ ] , solution of and associated with a control @xmath268 and with a parameter @xmath303 , minimizing the cost function @xmath304 over all possible trajectories @xmath270 defined on @xmath257_\t$ ] , solutions of and associated with @xmath305 and with an admissible control @xmath306 , with @xmath272 , and satisfying @xmath307 .
the final time can be fixed or not .
the _ hamiltonian _ of @xmath302 is the function @xmath308 defined by @xmath309 if the trajectory @xmath266 , defined on @xmath267_\t$ ] and associated with a control @xmath310 and with a parameter @xmath303 , is a solution of @xmath302 , then all conclusions of theorem [ thmmain ] ( except ) hold , and moreover @xmath311 this additional statement is proved as well in section [ part3 ] .
as is well known , the lagrange multiplier @xmath312 ( and thus the triple @xmath313 ) is defined up to a multiplicative scalar .
defining as usual an _ extremal _ as a quadruple @xmath314 solution of the above equations , an extremal is said to be _ normal _ whenever @xmath315 and _ abnormal _ whenever @xmath316 .
the component @xmath317 corresponds to the lagrange multiplier associated with the cost function . in the normal case
@xmath315 it is usual to normalize the lagrange multiplier so that @xmath318 .
finally , note that the convention @xmath319 in the pmp leads to a maximization condition of the hamiltonian ( the convention @xmath320 would lead to a minimization condition ) .
as already mentioned in remark [ rem18h05 ] , without loss of generality we consider in this article optimal control problems defined with the notion of @xmath32-derivative and @xmath32-integral .
these notions are naturally associated with the concepts of right - dense and right - scattered points in the basic properties of calculus ( see section [ section1 ] ) .
therefore , when using a @xmath32-derivative in the definition of @xmath265 one can not hope to derive in general , for instance , a maximization condition at left - dense points ( see the counterexample of remark [ footnotelebesguepoints ] ) . in the classical continuous - time setting
, it is well known that the maximized hamiltonian along the optimal extremal , that is , the function @xmath321 , is lipschitzian on @xmath267 $ ] , and if the dynamics are autonomous ( that is , if @xmath295 does not depend on @xmath42 ) then this function is constant . moreover ,
if the final time is free then the maximized hamiltonian vanishes at the final time . in the discrete - time setting and a fortiori in the general time scale setting
, none of these properties do hold any more in general ( see examples [ ex00 ] and [ ex000 ] below ) .
the non constant feature is due in particular to the fact that the usual formula of derivative of a composition does not hold in general time scale calculus .
the pmp is derived here in a general framework .
we do not make any particular assumption on the time scale @xmath2 , and do not assume that the set of control constraints @xmath0 is convex or compact . in section [ section10 ] , we discuss the strategy of proof of theorem [ thmmain ] and we explain how the generality of the framework led us to choose a method based on a variational principle rather than one based on a fixed - point theorem .
we do not make any convexity assumption on the dynamics @xmath322 . as a consequence , and as is well known in the discrete case ( see e.g. @xcite ) , at right - scattered points the maximization condition does not hold true in general and must be weakened into ( see remark [ rem8h22 ] ) .
[ remcoad ] the inequality , valuable at right - scattered points , can be written as @xmath323 in particular , if @xmath324 then @xmath325 .
this equality holds true at every right - scattered point if for instance @xmath326 ( and also at right - dense points : this is the context of what is usually referred to as the _ weak pmp _ , see @xcite where this weaker result is derived on general time scales for shifted control systems ) .
if @xmath0 is convex , since @xmath327 , then there holds in particular @xmath328 for every @xmath329 .
note that , if the inequality is strict then @xmath330 satisfies a local maximization condition on @xmath331 ( see also @xcite ) .
[ rem8h22 ] in the classical continuous - time case , all points are right - dense and consequently , theorem [ thmmain ] generalizes the usual continuous - time pmp where the maximization condition is valid @xmath56-almost everywhere ( see ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 6 p. 67 ) ) . in the discrete - time setting ,
the possible failure of the maximization condition is a well known fact ( see e.g. @xcite ) , and a fortiori in the time scale setting the maximization condition can not be expected to hold in general at right - scattered points ( see counterexamples below ) .
many works have been devoted to derive a pmp in the discrete - time setting ( see e.g. @xcite ) .
since the maximization condition can not be expected to hold true in general for discrete - time optimal control problems , it must be replaced with a weaker condition , of the kind , involving the derivative of @xmath295 with respect to @xmath234 .
such a kind of inequality is provided in ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 42.1 p. 330 ) for finite horizon problems and in @xcite for infinite horizon problems .
our condition is of a more general nature , as discussed next . in @xcite
the authors assume _ directional convexity _ , that is , for all @xmath332 and every @xmath333 $ ] , there exists @xmath334 such that @xmath335 for every @xmath336 and every @xmath14 ; and under this assumption they derive the maximization condition in the discrete - time case ( see also @xcite and @xcite ) .
note that this assumption is satisfied whenever @xmath0 is convex , the dynamics @xmath337 is affine with respect to @xmath234 , and @xmath338 is convex in @xmath234 ( which implies that @xmath295 is concave in @xmath234 ) .
we refer also to @xcite where it is shown that , in the absence of such convexity assumptions , an approximate maximization condition can however be derived .
note that , under additional assumptions , implies the maximization condition .
more precisely , let @xmath329 and let @xmath339 be the optimal extremal of theorem [ thmmain ] .
let @xmath329 .
if the function @xmath340 is concave on @xmath132 , then the inequality implies that @xmath341 if moreover @xmath342 ( this is the case if @xmath0 is convex ) , since @xmath343 , it follows that @xmath344 therefore , in particular , if @xmath295 is concave in @xmath234 and @xmath0 is convex then the maximization condition holds as well at every right - scattered point . [ remihp ]
it is interesting to note that , if @xmath295 is convex in @xmath234 then a certain minimization condition can be derived at every right - scattered point , as follows . for every @xmath133 ,
let @xmath345 denote the symmetric of @xmath189 with respect to the center @xmath138 .
it obviously follows from that @xmath346 for every @xmath329 and every @xmath347 .
if @xmath295 is convex in @xmath234 on @xmath132 , then the inequality implies that @xmath348 we next provide several very simple examples illustrating the previous remarks . [ ex00 ] here we give a counterexample showing that , although the final time is not fixed , the maximized hamiltonian may not vanish .
set @xmath349 , @xmath350 , @xmath351 , @xmath352 , @xmath353 $ ] , @xmath354 , @xmath355 and @xmath356 .
the corresponding optimal control problem is the problem of steering the discrete - time control one - dimensional system @xmath357 from @xmath358 to @xmath359 in minimal time , with control constraints @xmath360 .
it is clear that the minimal time is @xmath361 , and that any control @xmath234 such that @xmath362 , @xmath363 , and @xmath364 , is optimal . among these optimal controls ,
consider @xmath365 defined by @xmath366 and @xmath367 .
consider @xmath368 , @xmath319 and @xmath369 the adjoint vector whose existence is asserted by the pmp . since @xmath370 , it follows from that @xmath371 .
the hamiltonian is @xmath372 , and since it is independent of @xmath41 , it follows that @xmath369 is constant and thus equal to @xmath30 . in particular , @xmath373 and hence @xmath374 . from the nontriviality condition
@xmath282 we infer that @xmath315 .
therefore the maximized hamiltonian at the final time is here equal to @xmath317 and thus is not equal to @xmath30 .
[ ex0 ] here we give a counterexample ( in the spirit of ( * ? ? ?
* examples 10.1 - 10.4 p. 5962 ) ) showing the failure of the maximization condition at right - scattered points .
set @xmath375 , @xmath350 , @xmath376 , @xmath377 , @xmath353 $ ] , @xmath378 , @xmath379 and @xmath380 .
any solution of the resulting control system is such that @xmath358 , @xmath381 , @xmath382 , and its cost is equal to @xmath383 .
it follows that the optimal control @xmath365 is unique and is such that @xmath384 and @xmath367 .
the hamiltonian is @xmath385 .
consider @xmath368 , @xmath319 and @xmath369 the adjoint vector whose existence is asserted by the pmp . since @xmath264 does not depend on @xmath386 , it follows that @xmath387 , and from the extremal equations we infer that @xmath388 and @xmath389 .
therefore @xmath374 and hence @xmath390 ( nontriviality condition ) and we can assume that @xmath318 .
it follows that the maximized hamiltonian is equal to @xmath391 at @xmath392 , whereas @xmath393 .
in particular , the maximization condition is not satisfied at @xmath394 ( note that it is however satisfied at @xmath395 ) .
note that , in accordance with the fact that @xmath295 is convex in @xmath234 and @xmath396-\infty,0]$ ] and @xmath397 , the minimization condition is indeed satisfied ( see remark [ remihp ] ) .
[ ex000 ] here we give a counterexample in which , although the hamiltonian is autonomous ( independent of @xmath42 ) , the maximized hamiltonian is not constant over @xmath2 .
set @xmath375 , @xmath350 , @xmath398 , @xmath399 , @xmath378 , @xmath379 , @xmath400 , @xmath353 $ ] and @xmath401 .
any solution of the resulting control system is such that @xmath402 , @xmath381 , @xmath382 , and its cost is equal to @xmath403 .
it follows that any control @xmath234 such that @xmath404 is optimal ( the value of @xmath405 is arbitrary ) . consider the optimal control @xmath365 defined by @xmath406 , and let @xmath266 be the corresponding trajectory
. then @xmath407 and @xmath408 .
the hamiltonian is @xmath409 .
consider @xmath368 , @xmath319 and @xmath369 the adjoint vector whose existence is asserted by the pmp . since @xmath264 does not depend on @xmath386 , it follows that @xmath387 , and from the extremal equations we infer that @xmath388 and @xmath410 .
in particular , from the nontriviality condition one has @xmath315 and we can assume that @xmath318 .
therefore @xmath411 and @xmath412 , and it easily follows that that the maximization condition holds at @xmath413 and @xmath395 .
this is in accordance with the fact that @xmath295 is concave in @xmath234 and @xmath0 is convex .
moreover , the maximized hamiltonian is equal to @xmath414 at @xmath413 , and to @xmath30 at @xmath395 and @xmath415 .
there exist several proofs of the continuous - time pmp in the literature .
mainly they can be classified as variants of two different approaches : the first of which consists of using a fixed point argument , and the second consists of using ekeland s variational principle .
more precisely , the classical ( and historical ) proof of @xcite relies on the use of the so - called needle - like variations combined with a fixed point brouwer argument ( see also @xcite ) .
there exist variants , relying on the use of a conic version of the implicit function theorem ( see @xcite or @xcite ) , the proof of which being however based on a fixed point argument .
the proof of @xcite uses a separation theorem ( hahn - banach arguments ) for cones combined with the brouwer fixed point theorem
. we could cite many other variants , all of them relying , at some step , on a fixed point argument .
the proof of @xcite is of a different nature and follows from the combination of needle - like variations with ekeland s variational principle .
it does not rely on a fixed point argument . by the way note that this proof leads as well to an approximate pmp ( see @xcite ) , and withstands generalizations to the infinite dimensional setting ( see e.g. @xcite ) note that , in all cases , needle - like variations are used to generate the so - called pontryagin cone , serving as a first - order convex approximation of the reachable set .
the adjoint vector is then constructed by propagating backward in time a lagrange multiplier which is normal to this cone .
roughly , needle - like variations are kinds of perturbations of the reference control in @xmath416 topology ( perturbations with arbitrary values , over small intervals of time ) which generate perturbations of the trajectories in @xmath417 topology . due to obvious topological obstructions ,
it is evident that the classical strategy of needle - like variations combined with a fixed point argument can not hold in general in the time scale setting .
at least one should distinguish between dense points and scattered points of @xmath2 .
but even this distinction is not sufficient . indeed , when applying the brouwer fixed point theorem to the mapping built on needle - like variations ( see @xcite ) , it appears to be crucial that the domain of this mapping be convex . roughly speaking
, this domain consists of the product of the intervals of the spikes ( intervals of perturbation ) .
this requirement obviously excludes the scattered points of a time scale ( which have anyway to be treated in another way ) , but even at some right - dense point @xmath418 , there does not necessarily exist @xmath141 such that @xmath419\subset\t$ ] .
at such a point we can only ensure that @xmath30 is not isolated in the set @xmath420 . in our opinion
this basic obstruction makes impossible the use of a fixed point argument in order to derive the pmp on a general time scale .
of course to overcome this difficulty one can assume that the @xmath51-measure of right - dense points not admitting a right interval included in @xmath2 is zero .
this assumption is however not very natural and would rule out time scales such as a generalized cantor set having a positive @xmath56-measure .
another serious difficulty that we are faced with on a general time scale is the technical fact that the formula , accounting for lebesgue points , is valid only for @xmath421 such that @xmath422 . actually if @xmath423 then is not true any more in general ( it is very easy to construct a time scale @xmath2 for which fails whenever @xmath423 , even with @xmath424 ) .
note that the concept of lebesgue point is instrumental in the classical proof of the pmp in order to ensure that the needle - like variations can be built at different times ( see @xcite ) . on a general time scale
this technical point would raise a serious issue is locally convex .
the proof that we present further does not require such an assumption . ] .
the proof of the pmp that we provide in this article is based on ekeland s variational principle , which permits to avoid the above obstructions and happens to be well adapted for the proof of a general pmp on time scales .
it requires however the treatment of other kinds of technicalities , one of them being the concept of stable @xmath0-dense direction that we were led to introduce .
another point is that ekeland s variational principle requires a complete metric space , which has led us to assume that @xmath0 is closed ( see footnote [ footnote_omegaclosed ] ) .
[ remzhan ] recall that a weak pmp ( see remark [ remcoad ] ) on time scales is proved in @xcite for shifted optimal control problems ( see also @xcite ) .
a similar result can be derived in an analogous way for the non shifted optimal control problems considered here . since then , deriving the ( strong ) pmp on time scales was an open problem . while we were working on the contents of the present article ( together with the companion paper @xcite ) , at some step we discovered the publication of the article @xcite , in which the authors claim to have obtained a general version of the pmp . as in our work , their approach is based on ekeland s variational principle . however , as already mentioned in the introduction , many arguments thereof are erroneous , and we believe that their errors can not be corrected easily .
although it is not our aim to be involved in controversy , since we were incidentally working in parallel on the same subject ( deriving the pmp on time scales ) , we provide hereafter some evidence of the serious mistakes contained in @xcite .
note that , in order to derive a maximization condition @xmath32-almost everywhere ( even at right - scattered points ) , as in @xcite the authors of @xcite assume directional convexity of the dynamics ( see remark [ rem8h22 ] for the definition ) .
a first serious mistake in @xcite is the fact that , in the application of ekeland s variational principle , the authors use two different distances , depending on the nature of the point of @xmath2 under consideration ( right - scattered or dense ) .
as is usual in the proof of the pmp by ekeland s principle , the authors deduce from considerations on sequences of perturbation controls @xmath425 the existence of lagrange multipliers @xmath426 and @xmath427 ; the problem is that these multipliers are built separately for right - scattered and dense points ( see ( * ? ? ?
* ( 32 ) , ( 43 ) , ( 52 ) , ( 60 ) ) ) , and thus are different in general since the distances used are different . since the differential equation of the adjoint vector @xmath368 depends on these multipliers , the existence of the adjoint vector in the main result ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 3.1 ) can not be established .
a second serious mistake is in the use of the directional convexity assumption ( see ( * ? ? ?
* equations ( 35 ) , ( 36 ) , ( 43 ) ) ) .
the first equality in ( 35 ) can obviously fail : the term @xmath428 is a convex combination of @xmath429 and @xmath430 since @xmath431 is assumed to be convex , but the parameter of this convex combination is not necessarily equal to @xmath432 as claimed by the authors ( unless @xmath337 is affine in @xmath234 and @xmath338 is convex in @xmath234 , but this restrictive assumption is not made ) .
the nasty consequence of this error is that , in ( 43 ) , the limit as @xmath432 tends to @xmath30 is not valid .
a third mistake is in ( * ? ? ?
* ( 57 ) , ( 60 ) , ( 62 ) ) , when the authors claim that the rest of the proof can be led for dense points similarly as for right - scattered points .
they pass to the limit in ( 60 ) as @xmath145 tends to @xmath30 and get that @xmath433 tends to @xmath434 , where @xmath435 is defined by ( 57 ) and @xmath436 is defined similarly .
however , this does not hold true .
indeed , even though @xmath437 ( ekeland s distance ) tends to @xmath30 , there is no guarantee that @xmath429 tends to @xmath438 .
the above mistakes are major and can not be corrected even through a major revision of the overall proof , due to evident obstructions .
there are many other minor ones along the paper ( which can be corrected , although some of them require a substantial work ) , such as : the @xmath32-measurability of the map @xmath439 is not proved ; in ( 45 ) the authors should consider subsequences and not a global limit ; in ( 55 ) , any arbitrary @xmath440 can not be considered to deal with the @xmath32-lebesgue point @xmath441 , but only with @xmath442 ( recall that the equality of our paper is valid only if @xmath443 , and that , as already mentioned , on a general time scale lebesgue points must be handled with some special care ) . in view of these numerous issues
, it can not be considered that the pmp has been proved in @xcite .
the aim of the present article ( whose work was initiated far before we discovered the publication @xcite ) is to fill a gap in the literature and to derive a general strong version of the pmp on time scales .
finally , it can be noted that the authors of @xcite make restrictive assumptions : their set @xmath0 is convex and is compact at scattered points , their dynamics are globally lipschitzian and directionally convex , and they consider optimal control problems with fixed final time and fixed initial and final points . in the present article
we go far beyond these unnecessary and not natural requirements , as already explained throughout .
let @xmath253 .
following the definition of an admissible control ( see definition [ defadm ] in section [ section2 ] ) , we denote by @xmath444 the set of all @xmath445 such that @xmath234 is an admissible control on @xmath257_\t$ ] associated with the initial condition @xmath446 .
it is endowed with the distance @xmath447 throughout the section , we consider @xmath448 with @xmath449 and the corresponding solution @xmath246 of with @xmath247 .
this section [ section3 ] is devoted to define appropriate variations of @xmath450 , instrumental in order to prove the pmp .
we present some preliminary topological results in section [ section30 ] .
then we define needle - like variations of @xmath234 in sections [ section32 ] and [ section33 ] , respectively at a right - scattered point and at a right - dense point and derive some useful properties .
finally in section [ section34 ] we make some variations of the initial condition @xmath446 . in the first lemma below
, we prove that @xmath444 is open .
actually we prove a stronger result , by showing that @xmath444 contains a neighborhood of any of its point in @xmath416 topology , which will be useful in order to define needle - like variations . before proving this lemma ,
let us recall a time scale version of gronwall s lemma ( see ( * ? ? ?
* chapter 6.1 ) ) .
the generalized exponential function is defined by @xmath455 , for every @xmath456 , every @xmath457 and every @xmath458 , where @xmath459 whenever @xmath460 , and @xmath461 whenever @xmath462 ( see ( * ? ? ?
* chapter 2.2 ) ) .
note that , for every @xmath456 and every @xmath457 , the function @xmath463 ( resp .
@xmath464 ) is positive and increasing on @xmath465 ( resp .
positive and decreasing on @xmath466_\t$ ] ) , and moreover there holds @xmath467 , for every @xmath456 and all @xmath468 such that @xmath469 .
[ lemgronwall ] let @xmath470 such that @xmath84 , let @xmath471 and @xmath472 be nonnegative real numbers , and let @xmath473_\t , \r ) $ ] satisfying @xmath474 , for every @xmath95_\t$ ] .
then @xmath475 , for every @xmath95_\t$ ] .
let @xmath451 .
by continuity of @xmath246 on @xmath257_\t$ ] , the set @xmath476_\t\ \vert \ \vert x - q(t , u , q_a ) \vert_{\r^n } { \leqslant}1 \}\ ] ] is a compact subset of @xmath477 .
therefore @xmath478 and @xmath479 are bounded by some @xmath456 on @xmath480 and moreover @xmath481 is chosen such that @xmath482 for all @xmath483 and @xmath484 in @xmath480 .
let @xmath485 and @xmath486 such that @xmath487 .
note that @xmath480 , @xmath481 , @xmath488 and @xmath489 depend on @xmath490 .
let @xmath491 .
we denote by @xmath492 the interval of definition of @xmath493 satisfying @xmath494 and @xmath495 .
it suffices to prove that @xmath496 . by contradiction , assume that the set @xmath497_\t\ \vert \
\vert q(t , u',q'_a ) - q(t , u , q_a ) \vert_{\r^n } > 1 \}$ ] is not empty and set @xmath498 .
since @xmath2 is closed , @xmath499_\t$ ] and @xmath500_\t \subset i'_\t \cap [ a , b]_\t$ ] . if @xmath501 is a minimum then @xmath502 .
if @xmath501 is not a minimum then @xmath503 and by continuity we have @xmath504 . moreover there holds @xmath505 since @xmath506 .
hence @xmath507 for every @xmath508
. therefore @xmath509 and @xmath510 are elements of @xmath480 for @xmath32-a.e .
since there holds @xmath511 for every @xmath512_\t$ ] , it follows from and from lemma [ lemgronwall ] that , for every @xmath513_\t$ ] , @xmath514 this raises a contradiction at @xmath515 .
therefore @xmath7 is empty and thus @xmath493 is bounded on @xmath516_\t$ ] .
it follows from ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 2 ) that @xmath496 , that is , @xmath517 .
[ rmk ] let @xmath491 . with the notations of the above proof , since @xmath516_\t = [ a
, b]_\t$ ] and @xmath7 is empty , we infer that @xmath518 , for every @xmath519_\t$ ] .
therefore @xmath520 for every @xmath491 and for @xmath32-a.e .
@xmath243 .
[ prop30 - 1 - 1 ] with the notations of lemma [ prop30 - 1 ] , the mapping @xmath521{lrcl}f_{(u , q_a , r ) } : & ( \e(u , q_a , r),d_{\uu } ) & \longrightarrow & ( \cc([a , b]_\t,\r^{n}),\vert \cdot \vert_\infty)\\&(u',q'_a ) & \longmapsto & q(\cdot , u',q'_a ) \end{array}}\ ] ] is lipschitzian . in particular , for every @xmath491 , @xmath493 converges uniformly to @xmath246 on @xmath257_\t$ ] when @xmath522 tends to @xmath234 in @xmath523 and @xmath524 tends to @xmath446 in @xmath39 .
let @xmath525 and @xmath526 be elements of @xmath527 .
it follows from remark [ rmk ] that @xmath528 and @xmath509 are elements of @xmath480 for @xmath32-a.e .
following the same arguments as in the previous proof , it follows from and from lemma [ lemgronwall ] that , for every @xmath519_\t$ ] , @xmath530 the lemma follows .
let @xmath329 and let @xmath531 .
we define the needle - like variation @xmath532 of @xmath234 at the right - scattered point @xmath533 by @xmath534 for every @xmath535 .
it follows from section [ sec_topoprelim ] that @xmath536 .
[ lem32 - 1 - 1 ] the mapping @xmath521{lrcl}f_{(u , q_a,\pi ) } : & ( \d(u(r),y ) \cap [ 0,\alpha_0],\vert \cdot \vert ) & \longrightarrow & ( \cc([a , b]_\t,\r^{n}),\vert \cdot \vert_\infty)\\&\alpha & \longmapsto & q ( \cdot , u_\pi ( \cdot,\alpha),q_a ) \end{array}}\ ] ] is lipschitzian . in particular , for every @xmath539 $ ] , @xmath548 converges uniformly to @xmath549 on @xmath257_\t$ ] as @xmath550 tends to @xmath30 .
we use the notations of proof of lemma [ lem32 - 1 ] .
it follows from lemma [ prop30 - 1 - 1 ] that there exists @xmath551 ( the lipschitz constant of @xmath552 ) such that @xmath553 for all @xmath554 and @xmath555 in @xmath556 $ ] .
the lemma follows .
we define the so - called _ variation vector _ @xmath557 associated with the needle - like variation @xmath532 as the unique solution on @xmath558_\t$ ] of the linear @xmath32-cauchy problem @xmath559 the existence and uniqueness of @xmath557 are ensured by ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 3 ) .
[ prop32 - 1 ] the mapping @xmath521{lrcl}f_{(u , q_a,\pi ) } : & ( \d(u(r),y ) \cap [ 0,\alpha_0],\vert \cdot \vert ) & \longrightarrow & ( \cc ( [ \sigma(r),b]_\t,\r^{n}),\vert \cdot \vert_\infty)\\&\alpha & \longmapsto & q ( \cdot , u_\pi ( \cdot,\alpha),q_a ) \end{array}}\ ] ] is differentiable and we speak of its differential at @xmath30 in this sense . ] at @xmath30 , and there holds @xmath560 .
we use the notations of proof of lemma [ lem32 - 1 ] . recall that @xmath561 for every @xmath546 $ ] and for @xmath32-a.e .
@xmath243 , see remark [ rmk ] . for every @xmath5620,\alpha_0]$ ] and every @xmath563_\t$ ] , we define @xmath564 it suffices to prove that @xmath565 converges uniformly to @xmath30 on @xmath566_\t$ ] as @xmath550 tends to @xmath30 . for every @xmath5620,\alpha_0]$ ] , the function @xmath565 is absolutely continuous on @xmath558_\t$ ] , and @xmath567 for every @xmath563_\t$ ] , where @xmath568 for @xmath32-a.e .
it follows from the mean value theorem applied for @xmath32-a.e .
@xmath569 to the function defined by @xmath570 for every @xmath571 $ ] , that there exists @xmath572 , belonging to the segment of extremities @xmath573 and @xmath574 , such that @xmath575 since @xmath576 for @xmath32-a.e .
@xmath569 , it follows that @xmath577 , where @xmath578 therefore , one has @xmath579 for every @xmath580_\t$ ] .
it follows from lemma [ lemgronwall ] that @xmath581 , for every @xmath580_\t$ ] , where @xmath582 .
to conclude , it remains to prove that @xmath583 converges to @xmath30 as @xmath550 tends to @xmath30 .
first , since @xmath584 converges uniformly to @xmath246 on @xmath558_\t$ ] as @xmath550 tends to @xmath30 , and since @xmath585 is uniformly continuous on @xmath480 , we infer that @xmath586 converges to @xmath30 as @xmath550 tends to @xmath30 .
second , it is easy to see that @xmath587 converges to @xmath30 as @xmath550 tends to @xmath30 .
the conclusion follows .
[ lem32 - 2 ] let @xmath588 and let @xmath589 be a sequence of elements of @xmath590 . if @xmath591 converges to @xmath234 @xmath32-a.e
. on @xmath256 and @xmath592 converges to @xmath446 in @xmath39 as @xmath593 tends to @xmath594 , then @xmath595 converges uniformly to @xmath596 on @xmath558_\t$ ] as @xmath593 tends to @xmath594 . consider the absolutely continuous function defined by @xmath597 for every @xmath209 and every @xmath598_\t$ ] .
let us prove that @xmath599 converges uniformly to @xmath30 on @xmath558_\t$ ] as @xmath593 tends to @xmath594 .
one has @xmath600 for every @xmath580_\t$ ] and every @xmath209 . since @xmath601 for every @xmath209 , it follows from remark [ rmk ] that @xmath602 and @xmath603 for @xmath32-a.e .
hence it follows from lemma [ lemgronwall ] that @xmath604 for every @xmath580_\t$ ] , where @xmath605 since @xmath606 , @xmath607 converges to @xmath608 as @xmath593 tends to @xmath594 .
moreover , @xmath609 converges to @xmath450 in @xmath610 and , from lemma [ prop30 - 1 - 1 ] , @xmath611 converges uniformly to @xmath246 on @xmath257_\t$ ] as @xmath593 tends to @xmath594 .
we infer that @xmath612 converges to @xmath30 as @xmath593 tends to @xmath594 , and from the lebesgue dominated convergence theorem we conclude that @xmath613 converges to @xmath30 as @xmath593 tends to @xmath594 .
the lemma follows .
the definition of a needle - like variation at a lebesgue right - dense point is very similar to the classical continuous - time case .
let @xmath617 and @xmath618 .
we define the needle - like variation @xmath619 of @xmath234 at @xmath620 by @xmath621 for every @xmath622 ( here , we use the notations introduced in section [ section1 ] ) .
note that @xmath623 .
[ lem33 - 1 - 1 ] the mapping @xmath521{lrcl}f_{(u , q_a,\amalg ) } : & ( \v^b_s \cap [ 0,\beta_0],\vert \cdot \vert ) & \longrightarrow & ( \cc([a , b]_\t,\r^{n}),\vert \cdot \vert_\infty)\\&\beta & \longmapsto & q ( \cdot , u_\amalg ( \cdot,\beta),q_a ) \end{array}}\ ] ] is lipschitzian . in particular , for every @xmath632 , @xmath633 converges uniformly to @xmath246 on @xmath257_\t$ ] as @xmath421 tends to @xmath30 .
we use the notations of proof of lemma [ lem33 - 1 ] . from lemma [ prop30 - 1 - 1 ] , there exists @xmath551 ( lipschitz constant of @xmath552 ) such that @xmath634 for all @xmath635 and @xmath636 in @xmath637 $ ] .
the lemma follows .
according to ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 3 ) , we define the _ variation vector _ @xmath638 associated with the needle - like variation @xmath619 as the unique solution on @xmath639_\t$ ] of the linear @xmath32-cauchy problem @xmath640 [ prop33 - 1 ] for every @xmath641 , the mapping @xmath521{lrcl}f^\delta_{(u , q_a,\amalg ) } : & ( \v^b_s \cap [ 0,\beta_0],\vert \cdot \vert ) & \longrightarrow & ( \cc ( [ s+\delta , b]_\t,\r^{n}),\vert \cdot \vert_\infty)\\&\beta & \longmapsto & q ( \cdot , u_\amalg ( \cdot,\beta),q_a ) \end{array}}\ ] ] is differentiable at @xmath30 , and one has @xmath642 .
we use the notations of proof of lemma [ lem33 - 1 ] . recall that @xmath643 and @xmath644 belong to @xmath480 for every @xmath626 $ ] and for @xmath32-a.e .
@xmath243 , see remark [ rmk ] . for every @xmath6450,\beta_0]$ ] and every @xmath646_\t$ ] , we define @xmath647 it suffices to prove that @xmath648 converges uniformly to @xmath30 on @xmath649_\t$ ] as @xmath421 tends to @xmath30 ( note that , for every @xmath641 , it suffices to consider @xmath650 ) . for every @xmath6450,\beta_0]$ ] , the function @xmath648 is absolutely continuous on @xmath649_\t$ ] and @xmath651 , for every @xmath646_\t$ ] , where @xmath652 for @xmath32-a.e .
@xmath653 . as in the proof of proposition
[ prop32 - 1 ] , it follows from the mean value theorem that , for @xmath32-a.e .
@xmath653 , there exists @xmath654 , belonging to the segment of extremities @xmath573 and @xmath655 , such that @xmath656 since @xmath657 for @xmath32-a.e .
@xmath653 , it follows that @xmath658 , where @xmath659 therefore , one has @xmath660 for every @xmath646_\t$ ] , and it follows from lemma [ lemgronwall ] that @xmath661 , for every @xmath646_\t$ ] , where @xmath662 . to conclude , it remains to prove that @xmath663 converges to @xmath30 as @xmath421 tends to @xmath30 .
first , since @xmath664 converges uniformly to @xmath246 on @xmath649_\t$ ] as @xmath421 tends to @xmath30 and since @xmath585 is uniformly continuous on @xmath480 , we infer that @xmath665 converges to @xmath30 as @xmath421 tends to @xmath30 .
second , let us prove that @xmath666 converges to @xmath30 as @xmath421 tends to @xmath30 . by continuity , @xmath667 converges to @xmath668 as @xmath421 to @xmath30 .
moreover , since @xmath633 converges uniformly to @xmath246 on @xmath257_\t$ ] as @xmath421 tends to @xmath30 and since @xmath337 is uniformly continuous on @xmath480 , it follows that @xmath669 converges uniformly to @xmath670 on @xmath257_\t$ ] as @xmath421 tends to @xmath30 .
therefore , it suffices to note that @xmath671 converges to @xmath672 as @xmath421 tends to @xmath30 since @xmath620 is a @xmath32-lebesgue point of @xmath670 and of @xmath673 .
then @xmath674 converges to @xmath30 as @xmath421 tends to @xmath30 , and hence @xmath663 converges to @xmath30 as well .
[ lem33 - 2 ] let @xmath588 and let @xmath589 be a sequence of elements of @xmath590 . if @xmath591 converges to @xmath234 @xmath32-a.e
. on @xmath256 and @xmath592 converges to @xmath446 as @xmath593 tends to @xmath594 , then @xmath675 converges uniformly to @xmath676 on @xmath639_\t$ ] as @xmath593 tends to @xmath594 .
[ lem34 - 1 - 1 ] the mapping @xmath521{lrcl}f_{(u , q_a , q'_a ) } : & ( [ 0,\gamma_0],\vert \cdot \vert ) & \longrightarrow & ( \cc([a , b]_\t,\r^{n}),\vert \cdot \vert_\infty)\\&\gamma & \longmapsto & q ( \cdot , u , q_a+\gamma q'_a ) \end{array}}\ ] ] is lipschitzian . in particular , for every @xmath681 $ ] , @xmath685 converges uniformly to @xmath549 on @xmath257_\t$ ] as @xmath686 tends to @xmath30 .
according to ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 3 ) , we define the _ variation vector _ @xmath691 associated with the perturbation @xmath692 as the unique solution on @xmath257_\t$ ] of the linear @xmath32-cauchy problem @xmath693 [ prop34 - 1 ] the mapping @xmath521{lrcl}f_{(u , q_a , q'_a ) } : & ( [ 0,\gamma_0],\vert \cdot \vert ) & \longrightarrow & ( \cc ( [ a , b]_\t,\r^{n}),\vert \cdot \vert_\infty)\\&\gamma & \longmapsto & q ( \cdot , u , q_a+\gamma q'_a ) \end{array}}\ ] ] is differentiable at @xmath30 , and one has @xmath694 .
we use the notations of proof of lemma [ lem33 - 1 ] . note that , from remark [ rmk ] , @xmath695 for every @xmath681 $ ] and for @xmath32-a.e . @xmath243 . for every @xmath6960,\gamma_0]$ ] and every @xmath519_\t$ ] , we define @xmath697 it suffices to prove that @xmath698 converges uniformly to @xmath30 on @xmath257_\t$ ] as @xmath686 tends to @xmath30 . for every @xmath6960,\gamma_0]$ ] , the function @xmath698 is absolutely continuous on @xmath257_\t$ ] , and @xmath699 , for every @xmath519_\t$ ] , where @xmath700 for @xmath32-a.e . @xmath243 . as in the proof of proposition
[ prop32 - 1 ] , it follows from the mean value theorem that , for @xmath32-a.e .
@xmath243 , there exists @xmath701 , belonging to the segment of extremities @xmath573 and @xmath702 , such that @xmath703 since @xmath704 for @xmath32-a.e .
@xmath243 , it follows that @xmath705 where @xmath706 hence @xmath707 for every @xmath519_\t$ ] , and it follows from lemma [ lemgronwall ] that @xmath708 , for every @xmath519_\t$ ] , where @xmath709 to conclude , it remains to prove that @xmath710 converges to @xmath30 as @xmath686 tends to @xmath30 .
first , since @xmath711 converges uniformly to @xmath246 on @xmath257_\t$ ] as @xmath686 tends to @xmath30 and since @xmath585 is uniformly continuous on @xmath480 , we infer that @xmath712 tends to @xmath30 when @xmath713 .
second , it is easy to see that @xmath714 for every @xmath6960,\gamma_0]$ ] .
the conclusion follows .
[ lem34 - 2 ] let @xmath451 and let @xmath589 be a sequence of elements of @xmath590 . if @xmath591 converges to @xmath234 @xmath32-a.e
. on @xmath256 and @xmath592 converges to @xmath446 in @xmath39 as @xmath593 tends to @xmath594 , then @xmath715 converges uniformly to @xmath691 on @xmath257_\t$ ] as @xmath593 tends to @xmath594 . throughout this section
we consider @xmath265 with a fixed final time @xmath717 .
we proceed as is very usual ( see e.g. @xcite ) by considering the _ augmented control system _ in @xmath718 @xmath719 with @xmath720 , the augmented state , and @xmath721 , the augmented dynamics , defined by @xmath722 .
the additional coordinate @xmath723 stands for the cost , and we will always impose as an initial condition @xmath724 , so that @xmath725 . the function @xmath726 is defined by @xmath727 , where @xmath728 for @xmath729 . note that @xmath730 does not depend on @xmath723 and that @xmath731 does not depend on @xmath732 nor on @xmath733 .
note as well that the hamiltonian of @xmath265 is written as @xmath734 . with these notations
, @xmath265 consists of determining a trajectory @xmath735 defined on @xmath257_\t$ ] , solution of and associated with a control @xmath736 , minimizing @xmath737 over all possible trajectories @xmath738 defined on @xmath257_\t$ ] , solutions of and associated with an admissible control @xmath271 and satisfying @xmath739 . in what follows , let @xmath740 be such an optimal trajectory .
set @xmath741 .
we are going to apply first ekeland s variational principle to a well chosen functional in an appropriate complete metric space , and then , using needle - like variations as defined previously ( applied to the augmented system , that is , with the dynamics @xmath730 ) , we are going to derive some inequalities , finally resulting into the desired statement of the pmp .
[ lemekeland ] let @xmath742 be a complete metric space and @xmath743 be a lower semi - continuous function which is bounded below .
let @xmath744 and @xmath745 such that @xmath746 .
then there exists @xmath747 such that @xmath748 and @xmath749 for every @xmath750 .
recall from lemma [ prop30 - 1 ] that , for @xmath751 , the set @xmath752 defined in this lemma is contained in @xmath444 . to take into account the set @xmath0 of constraints on the controls , we define @xmath753 using the fact that @xmath0 is closed closed
is used ( only ) here in a crucial way . in the proof of the classical continuous - time pmp this assumption is not required because the ekeland distance which is then used is defined by @xmath754\ \vert\ u(t)\neq v(t)\}$ ] ) , and obviously the set of measurable functions @xmath755\rightarrow\omega$ ] endowed with this distance is complete , under the sole assumption that @xmath0 is measurable . in the discrete - time setting and a fortiori in the general time scale setting , this distance can not be used any more . here
we use the distance @xmath756 defined by but then to ensure completeness it is required to assume that @xmath0 is closed.[footnote_omegaclosed ] ] , it clearly follows from the ( partial ) converse of lebesgue s dominated convergence theorem that @xmath757 is a complete metric space . before applying ekeland s variational principle in this space ,
let us introduce several notations and recall basic facts in order to handle the convex set @xmath260 .
we denote by @xmath758 the distance function to @xmath260 defined by @xmath759 , for every @xmath760 .
recall that , for every @xmath761 , there exists a unique element @xmath762 ( projection of @xmath763 onto @xmath260 ) such that @xmath764 .
it is characterized by the property @xmath765 for every @xmath766 . moreover ,
the projection mapping @xmath767 is @xmath768-lipschitz continuous .
furthermore , there holds @xmath769 for every @xmath761 ( where @xmath770 is defined by ) .
we recall the following obvious lemmas .
we are now in a position to apply ekeland s variational principle . for every @xmath744 such that @xmath779
, we consider the functional @xmath780 defined by @xmath781 since @xmath782 ( by lemma [ prop30 - 1 - 1 ] ) , @xmath731 and @xmath783 are continuous , it follows that @xmath784 is continuous on @xmath785 .
moreover , one has @xmath786 and @xmath787 for every @xmath788 .
it follows from ekeland s variational principle that , for every @xmath744 such that @xmath779 , there exists @xmath789 such that @xmath790 and @xmath791 for every @xmath788 .
in particular , @xmath792 converges to @xmath365 in @xmath793 and @xmath794 converges to @xmath795 as @xmath145 tends to @xmath30 .
besides , setting @xmath796 and @xmath797 note that @xmath798 and @xmath799 . using a compactness argument , the continuity of @xmath782 and the @xmath233 regularity of @xmath800 , and the ( partial ) converse of the dominated convergence theorem , we infer that there exists a sequence @xmath801 of positive real numbers converging to @xmath30 such that @xmath802 converges to @xmath365 @xmath32-a.e . on @xmath256
, @xmath803 converges to @xmath795 , @xmath804 converges to @xmath805 , @xmath806 converges to @xmath807 , @xmath808 converges to some @xmath809 , and @xmath810 converges to some @xmath811 as @xmath593 tends to @xmath594 , with @xmath812 and @xmath813 ( see lemma [ lemconvex ] ) .
in the three next lemmas , we use the inequality respectively with needle - like variations of @xmath802 at right - scattered points and then at right - dense points , and variations of @xmath803 , and infer some crucial inequalities by taking the limit in @xmath593 .
note that these variations were defined in section [ section3 ] for any dynamics @xmath337 , and that we apply them here to the augmented system , associated with the augmented dynamics @xmath730 .
[ lemfondamscattered ] for every @xmath329 and every @xmath814 , considering the needle - like variation @xmath532 at the right - scattered point @xmath533 as defined in section [ section32 ] , there holds @xmath815 where the variation vector @xmath816 is defined by ( replacing @xmath337 with @xmath730 ) .
since @xmath802 converges to @xmath365 @xmath32-a.e . on @xmath256 , it follows that @xmath817 converges to @xmath330 as @xmath593 tends to @xmath594 .
hence @xmath818 and @xmath819 for @xmath593 sufficiently large .
fixing such a large integer @xmath593 , we recall that @xmath820 for every @xmath821 , and @xmath822 and @xmath823 therefore @xmath824 for every @xmath821 sufficiently small .
it then follows from that @xmath825 and thus @xmath826 using proposition [ prop32 - 1 ] , since @xmath731 does not depend on @xmath733 , we infer that @xmath827 since @xmath828 converges to @xmath829 as @xmath550 tends to @xmath30 , using and it follows that @xmath830 by letting @xmath593 tend to @xmath594 , and using lemma [ lem32 - 2 ] , the lemma follows .
denote by @xmath831 the set of ( lebesgue ) times @xmath243 such that @xmath832 , such that @xmath833 for every @xmath213 , and such that @xmath834 converges to @xmath835 as @xmath593 tends to @xmath594 . there holds @xmath836 .
[ lemfondamdense ] for every @xmath837 and any @xmath838 , considering the needle - like variation @xmath619 as defined in section [ section33 ] , there holds @xmath839 where the variation vector @xmath840 is defined by ( replacing @xmath337 with @xmath730 ) . for every @xmath209 and any @xmath622 , we recall that @xmath841 and @xmath842 and @xmath843 therefore @xmath844 for @xmath622 sufficiently small .
it then follows from that @xmath845 and thus @xmath846 using proposition , since @xmath731 does not depend on @xmath733 , we infer that @xmath847 since @xmath848 converges to @xmath829 as @xmath550 tends to @xmath30 , using and it follows that @xmath849 by letting @xmath593 tend to @xmath594 , and using lemma [ lem33 - 2 ] , the lemma follows .
[ lemfondampoint ] for every @xmath850 , considering the variation of initial point as defined in section [ section34 ] , there holds @xmath851 where the variation vector @xmath852 is defined by ( replacing @xmath337 with @xmath730 ) . for every @xmath209 and every @xmath853
, one has @xmath854 therefore @xmath855 for @xmath853 sufficiently small .
it then follows from that @xmath856 and thus @xmath857 using proposition , since @xmath731 does not depend on @xmath732 and @xmath733 , we infer that @xmath858 since @xmath859 converges to @xmath829 as @xmath686 tends to @xmath30 , using and it follows that @xmath860 by letting @xmath593 tend to @xmath594 , and using lemma [ lem34 - 2 ] , the lemma follows . at this step ,
we have obtained in the three previous lemmas the three fundamental inequalities , and , valuable for any @xmath861 .
recall that @xmath812 and @xmath813 . then , considering a sequence of real numbers @xmath862 converging to @xmath594 as @xmath863 tends to @xmath594 , we infer that there exist @xmath864 and @xmath281 such that @xmath865 converges to @xmath866 and @xmath867 converges to @xmath368 as @xmath863 tends to @xmath594 , and moreover @xmath868 and @xmath869 ( since @xmath870 is a closed subset of @xmath261 ) . for every @xmath329 , and every @xmath814 , there holds @xmath873 where the variation vector @xmath816 associated with the needle - like variation @xmath532 is defined by ( replacing @xmath337 with @xmath730 ) ; for every @xmath874 , and every @xmath618 , there holds @xmath875 where the variation vector @xmath840 associated with the needle - like variation @xmath619 is defined by ( replacing @xmath337 with @xmath730 ) ; for every @xmath850 , there holds @xmath876 where the variation vector @xmath852 associated with the variation @xmath877 of the initial point @xmath878 is defined by ( replacing @xmath337 with @xmath730 ) .
we define @xmath879 as the unique solution on @xmath257_\t$ ] of the backward shifted linear @xmath32-cauchy problem @xmath880 the existence and uniqueness of @xmath881 are ensured by ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 6 ) .
since @xmath730 does not depend on @xmath723 , it is clear that @xmath882 is constant , still denoted by @xmath317 ( with @xmath883 ) .
let @xmath329 and @xmath814 . since the function @xmath884 is absolutely continuous , it holds @xmath885 @xmath32-almost everywhere on @xmath886 from the leibniz formula and hence the function @xmath887 is constant on @xmath558_\t$ ] .
it thus follows from that @xmath888 and since @xmath889 , we finally get @xmath890 since this inequality holds for every @xmath891 , we easily prove that it holds as well for every @xmath288 .
this proves .
let @xmath874 and @xmath618 . since @xmath892 is an absolutely continuous function , the leibniz formula yields @xmath893 @xmath32-almost everywhere on @xmath894 , and hence this function is constant on @xmath639_\t$ ] .
it thus follows from that @xmath895 and since @xmath896 , we finally get @xmath897 since this inequality holds for every @xmath618 , the maximization condition follows .
the transversality condition on the adjoint vector @xmath898 at the final time @xmath899 has been obtained by definition ( note that @xmath869 as mentioned previously ) . let us now establish the transversality condition at the initial time @xmath716 ( left - hand equality of ) .
let @xmath850 . with the same arguments as before , we prove that the function @xmath900 is constant on @xmath257_\t$ ] .
it thus follows from that @xmath901 and since @xmath902 , we finally get @xmath903 since this inequality holds for every @xmath850 , the left - hand equality of follows .
assume that the final time is not fixed in @xmath265 , and let @xmath293 be the final time associated with the optimal trajectory @xmath266 .
we assume moreover that @xmath293 belongs to the interior of @xmath2 for the topology of @xmath1 .
the proof of then goes exactly as in the classical continuous - time case , and thus we do not provide any details .
it suffices to consider variations of the final time @xmath899 in a neighbourhood of @xmath293 , and to modify accordingly the functional of section [ section41 ] to which ekeland s variational principle is applied . to derive
, we consider the change of variable @xmath904 .
the crucial remark is that , since it is an _ affine _ change of variable , @xmath32-derivatives of compositions work in the time scale setting as in the time - continuous case .
then it suffices to consider the resulting optimal control problem as a parametrized one with parameter @xmath899 lying in a neighbourhood of @xmath293 . then follows from the additional condition of the pmp with parameters ( see remark [ rempmpparam ] ) , which is established hereafter . to obtain the statement it suffices to apply the pmp to the control system associated with the dynamics defined by @xmath905 , with the extended state @xmath906 . in other words ,
we add to the control system the equation @xmath907 ( this is a standard method to derive a parametrized version of the pmp ) . applying
the pmp then yields an adjoint vector @xmath908 , where @xmath898 clearly satisfies all conclusions of theorem [ thmmain ] ( except ) , and @xmath909 @xmath32-almost everywhere . from this last equation
it follows that @xmath910 , and then follows from the already established transversality conditions . | in this article we derive a strong version of the pontryagin maximum principle for general nonlinear optimal control problems on time scales in finite dimension .
the final time can be fixed or not , and in the case of general boundary conditions we derive the corresponding transversality conditions . our proof is based on ekeland s variational principle . our statement and comments clearly show the distinction between right - dense points and right - scattered points .
at right - dense points a maximization condition of the hamiltonian is derived , similarly to the continuous - time case . at right - scattered points
a weaker condition is derived , in terms of so - called stable @xmath0-dense directions .
we do not make any specific restrictive assumption on the dynamics or on the set @xmath0 of control constraints .
our statement encompasses the classical continuous - time and discrete - time versions of the pontryagin maximum principle , and holds on any general time scale , that is any closed subset of @xmath1 .
* keywords : * pontryagin maximum principle ; optimal control ; time scale ; transversality conditions ; ekeland s variational principle ; needle - like variations ; right - scattered point ; right - dense point .
* ams classification : * 34k35 ; 34n99 ; 39a12 ; 39a13 ; 49k15 ; 93c15 ; 93c55 . |
this measurement is the first step towards a high - statistics dalitz - plot analysis of the @xmath1 decay .
the latter could give insight into the controversy on the s - wave @xmath5 contribution in these decays @xcite , as well as a sensitive study of the @xmath6 violation in the neutral d meson system .
knowledge of @xmath0(@xmath7)/@xmath0(@xmath8 ) ( also based on the @xmath1 dalitz analysis ) could improve our understanding of the apparent discrepancy of the measured two - body branching fractions ( @xmath9 kk , @xmath10 ) with the theoretical expectations @xcite .
the accuracy of the value of @xmath0(@xmath1 ) as reported in pdg04 @xcite is poor .
using a large data sample of @xmath11 decays accumulated with the belle detector , we provide a significantly improved measurement using the @xmath2 decay mode for normalization . since both decay modes involve a neutral pion and the same number of charged tracks in the final state , several sources of the systematic uncertainties are avoided in a determination of the relative branching fraction .
the obtained result can then be compared to recent measurements by the cleo @xcite and babar @xcite collaborations . a detailed study of the @xmath1 decay as well as of other @xmath11 @xmath6-symmetric final states , can be used to further improve statistics for the measurement of the angle @xmath12 ( @xmath13 ) of the ckm - matrix .
the belle detector is a large - solid - angle magnetic spectrometer located at the kekb @xmath4 storage rings , which collide 8.0 gev electrons with 3.5 gev positrons and produce @xmath14(4s ) at the energy of 10.58 gev .
closest to the interaction point is a silicon vertex detector ( svd ) , surrounded by a 50-layer central drift chamber ( cdc ) , an array of aerogel cherenkov counters ( acc ) , a barrel - like arrangement of time - of - flight ( tof ) scintillation counters , and an electromagnetic calorimeter ( ecl ) comprised of csi ( tl ) crystals .
these subdetectors are located inside a superconducting solenoid coil that provides a 1.5 t magnetic field .
an iron flux - return yoke located outside the coil is instrumented to detect @xmath15 mesons and identify muons . the detector is described in detail elsewhere @xcite .
for this analysis , we used a data sample of 357 fb@xmath3 accumulated with the belle detector .
@xmath11 candidates are selected from @xmath16 decays where the charge of the @xmath17 tags the @xmath11 flavour : @xmath18 .
@xmath19 s originate mainly from continuum .
although we do not apply any topological cuts , the yield of @xmath19 s from @xmath20-meson decays is negligible ; such events are rejected by other kinematical cuts such as the strong @xmath21(@xmath19 ) requirement .
@xmath11 mesons are reconstructed from combinations of two oppositely charged pions ( or a charged pion and kaon in the case of @xmath22 ) and one neutral pion .
the latter is reconstructed from two @xmath13 candidates satisfying the @xmath23 mass requirement given below .
+ the following kinematic criteria are applied to the charged track candidates : the distance from the nominal interaction point to the point of closest approach of the track is required to be within 0.15 cm in the radial direction ( @xmath24 ) and 0.3 cm along the beam direction ( @xmath25 ) .
we also require the transverse momentum of the track @xmath26 @xmath27 0.050 gev / c to suppress beam background .
kaons and pions are separated by combining the responses of the acc and the tof with the @xmath28 measurement from the cdc to form a likelihood @xmath29 where @xmath30 is a pion or a kaon .
charged particles are identified as pions or kaons using the likelihood ratio @xmath31 . for charged pion identification , we require @xmath32 .
this requirement selects pions with an efficiency of 93% and misidentified kaons with an efficiency of 9% . for the identification of charged kaons ,
the requirement is @xmath33 ; in this case , the efficiency for kaon identification is 86% and the probability to misidentify a pion is 4% .
+ we impose conditions on the energies of the photons constituting the @xmath23 candidate ( @xmath34 @xmath27 0.060 gev ) , the two - photon invariant mass ( @xmath35 gev / c@xmath36 gev / c@xmath37 ) and the @xmath23 s momentum in the laboratory frame ( @xmath38(@xmath23 ) @xmath27 0.3 gev / c ) to suppress combinatorial @xmath23 s .
+ the mass difference of @xmath19 and @xmath11 candidates should satisfy the restrictions : @xmath39 gev / c@xmath40 gev / c@xmath37 and @xmath41 gev / c@xmath42 gev / c@xmath37 . the momentum of the @xmath19 in the center - of - mass frame of the @xmath43 must lie in the range : @xmath44 gev / c@xmath45 gev / c .
the lower cut is applied to suppress slow fake @xmath19 s reconstructed from combinatorial background that originates from @xmath20 decays .
the upper cut restricts @xmath46 to the region where the monte carlo ( mc ) distribution is in good agreement with the data ( see fig
. 1 , left ) . to eliminate background from the @xmath47 decays ,
the following veto on @xmath48 is applied : @xmath49 gev@xmath37/c@xmath50 gev@xmath37/c@xmath51 .
to obtain detection efficiencies , about 1.2@xmath52 phase - space distributed mc events have been generated for each of the two modes , processed using the geant based detector simulation @xcite and reconstructed with the same selection criteria as the data .
+ to obtain a more realistic @xmath11 decay model than a uniform dalitz - plot distribution , the events of both signal mc samples have been weighted using matrix elements based on decay models obtained by cleo @xcite in the framework of a 3-resonance model ( @xmath53 , @xmath54 , @xmath55 and a nonresonant contribution ) for @xmath1 and in the framework of a 7-resonance model ( @xmath53 , @xmath56 , @xmath57 , @xmath58 , @xmath59 , @xmath60 , @xmath61 and a nonresonant contribution ) for the case of @xmath2 @xcite ( see fig .
+ the obtained yield is normalized to the same mc data but before detector simulation and before application of selection criteria . since for the relative branching fraction measurement only the ratio of @xmath62 and @xmath22 efficiencies is needed , we only generate events in the @xmath63 range from 3.5 to 4.3 gev / c where mc is in good agreement with the data ( see fig . 1 , left ) .
the obtained efficiencies are : @xmath64 @xmath65
to describe the background shape in the @xmath66 signal region , a sample of generic mc , equivalent to @xmath67250 fb@xmath3 , has been processed with the same selection criteria as data .
the contributions of @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath70 , @xmath71 and @xmath72 backgrounds have been summed up . for the @xmath71 sample signal events
were excluded .
figure 3 shows the individual contributions to the @xmath66 distribution where also a partial data sample , corresponding to the luminosity of mc , is shown .
the @xmath66 background distribution is fitted with a @xmath73 order polynomial multiplied by an error function ( kaon misidentification region ) plus a @xmath74 order polynomial ( combinatoric background ) and a small gaussian peak in the signal region ( see fig .
3 , right ) .
the gaussian contribution is mainly due to combinations of a correctly reconstructed @xmath11 and a random @xmath17 candidate .
+ most of the background is from e@xmath75e@xmath76 @xmath71 ; the @xmath72 background is negligible and @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath70 backgrounds are linearly distributed in the @xmath66 signal region . among the @xmath71 background sources
@xmath77 is dominant : charged kaons are misidentified as pions and @xmath78 is typically shifted downwards by @xmath79 gev / c@xmath37 thus being well separated from the signal .
+ the background shape in the @xmath80 distribution is obtained using a generic mc sample .
the level of background in this mode is low but still has a nontrivial structure ( see fig .
4 , right ) .
the distribution has three distinctive peaks : the rightmost one is due to misidentified pions from @xmath1 , the central one has the same origin as the one in the @xmath81 case ( random @xmath17 ) , the leftmost feature originates mainly from @xmath82 where @xmath83 .
the distribution is fitted by the sum of a @xmath73 order polynomial and a @xmath73 order polynomial multiplied by an error function ( left peak ) and two gaussians .
the shape of the signal peak in the experimental @xmath62 invariant mass distribution ( see fig . 5 , left ) is partially fixed to the mc one @xcite : the latter was fitted with a bifurcated hyperbolic gaussian @xcite and a regular gaussian ( see fig .
1 , right ) . the obtained shape with floating normalization and @xmath84 s , together with the background shape with its floating normalization ( i.e. 5 free parameters ) is then used as the fit function for the measured @xmath66 distribution . + to fit the experimental @xmath85 invariant mass distribution we use a @xmath85 background shape with floating normalization and the sum of two bifurcated and a regular gaussian for the signal peak ( see fig .
4 , right ) . here , the parameters of the signal peak are free in the fit since the level of background is low and statistics are large enough . + the yields of signal events in each channel , as obtained from the fit , are given in table [ t7 ] : [ t7 ] .number of signal events and efficiencies [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] + finally , we can compare our measurement of the ratio with the ratio obtained from the latest world average values of @xmath86 and @xmath0(@xmath87 ) @xcite .
our result ( 9.71 @xmath88 0.31)% is consistent with the world average one ( 9.29 @xmath88 0.54)% and has better accuracy . by choosing the normalization mode
@xmath2 we avoid many sources of systematic uncertainty including the @xmath23 detection efficiency and uncertainty in the tracking efficiency .
the pid efficiency partially cancels out .
using 357 fb@xmath3 of data collected with the belle detector , the first direct measurement of the relative branching fraction @xmath0(@xmath1)/ @xmath0(@xmath2 ) has been performed .
our preliminary result @xmath89 is compatible with the world average @xmath90 and is more precise .
the belle result differs by @xmath91 from the value recently obtained by babar @xcite : @xmath92 .
the corresponding value of the absolute branching fraction @xmath0(@xmath1 ) is ( 13.69 @xmath88 0.66)@xmath93 .
we thank the kekb group for the excellent operation of the accelerator , the kek cryogenics group for the efficient operation of the solenoid , and the kek computer group and the national institute of informatics for valuable computing and super - sinet network support .
we acknowledge support from the ministry of education , culture , sports , science , and technology of japan and the japan society for the promotion of science ; the australian research council and the australian department of education , science and training ; the national science foundation of china and the knowledge innovation program of the chinese academy of sciences under contract no .
10575109 and ihep - u-503 ; the department of science and technology of india ; the bk21 program of the ministry of education of korea , the chep src program and basic research program ( grant no .
r01 - 2005 - 000 - 10089 - 0 ) of the korea science and engineering foundation , and the pure basic research group program of the korea research foundation ; the polish state committee for scientific research ; the ministry of science and technology of the russian federation ; the slovenian research agency ; the swiss national science foundation ; the national science council and the ministry of education of taiwan ; and the u.s.department of energy .
99 ( cleo collaboration ) , phys .
d * 72 * , 031102 ( 2005 ) .
j.m . link _
_ ( focus collaboration ) , phys .
b * 585 * , 200 ( 2004 ) .
b * 379 * , 249 ( 1996 ) .
s. eidelman _
et al_. , phys .
b * 592 * , 1 ( 2004 ) .
( cleo collaboration ) , phys .
96 * , 081802 ( 2006 ) .
( babar collaboration ) , hep - ex/0608009 .
et al . _ ( belle collaboration ) , nucl .
instrum . and meth . a * 479 * , 117 ( 2002 ) .
z.natkaniec _ et al . _
( belle svd2 group ) , nucl . instr . and meth . a * 560 * , 1 ( 2006 ) .
geant , r. brun _ et al .
_ , geant 3.21 , cern report dd / ee/84 - 1 , 1984 . s. kopp _
( cleo collaboration ) , phys . rev .
d * 63 * , 092001 ( 2001 ) . w .-
_ et al_. , j. phys .
g * 33 * , 1 ( 2006 ) .
( cleo collaboration ) , hep - ex/0306048 . | we report a high - statistics measurement of the relative branching fraction @xmath0(@xmath1)/ @xmath0(@xmath2 ) .
a 357 fb@xmath3 data sample collected with the belle detector at the kekb asymmetric - energy @xmath4 collider was used for the analysis .
the relative branching fraction @xmath0(@xmath1)/ @xmath0(@xmath2 ) is determined with an accuracy comparable to the latest world average value . |
the packing of a long flexible rod of diameter @xmath0 into a finite quasi - two - dimensional domain of height @xmath1 yields a network of loops which is a pattern of folds that belongs to a new class of light - weight cellular materials with variable degrees of rigidity and with great potential for application in technology @xcite .
the general problem of a flexible rod confined in a two - dimensional cavity belongs to the context of elastic rods constrained to move on surfaces @xcite .
the structures formed in these circumstances have a high surface / bulk ratio , and they extend the field of evolving non - equilibrium cellular systems composed of interacting domains separated by thin boundaries endowed with line energy @xcite
. new results on this subject may also be of interest in the study of shape memory materials using elastoplastic alloy wires @xcite among others @xcite .
since the rod bends when inserted into the cavity and divides the available area into geometric domains , we can perform a direct comparison between the continuous packing and the discrete number of cells . in this context , the present study deals with the length @xmath2 required to build a given number @xmath3 of loops ( domains with one vertex ) . at the beginning of the injection ,
the number of loops is equal to the number of self - contact points along the rod , but with the evolution of the process the contacts extend along segments of non - zero measure .
different morphological conformations are observed for confined rods @xcite , and they depend on the plasticity and on the friction at the rod - cavity interface , as well as between different parts of the rod . for the tight - packing in a given area
, it has been conjectured @xcite that the topology of the cavity regulates an effective temperature of the system : the smaller the number of avoided regions , the greater the packed length , the higher the temperature .
the following results stand out : ( _ i _ ) the successful application of an exponential description @xcite also for annular cavities ; ( _ ii _ ) the observation of a new `` instability '' phenomenon ; and ( _ iii _ ) a new context in which the physical rigidity of the rod imposes an effective fractal dimension that is always smaller than 2 for the tight - packing conformations .
this paper is divided as follows : in sec .
[ secii ] the experiment of packing a single rod into annular cavities is detailed .
an exponential model that fits the experimental data is discussed in some detail in sec .
[ seciii ] .
our results are reported in sec .
[ seciv ] from the point of view of the formation of each loop ( sec .
[ subseciva ] ) and from the point of view of tight - packing measurements ( sec .
[ subsecivb ] ) .
the conclusions are summed up in sec .
the cavity is composed of the superposition of two acrylic plates of 10 mm thickness . a circular groove of diameter @xmath4 mm allows us to accommodate only one layer of the flexible rod of diameter @xmath5 mm .
two opposite parallel slits compose the injection channels .
the rod is then packed into the cavity from an injection channel and can be recovered by the other . the cavity is the same as used in previous studies @xcite , but here we change its topology by adding a set of central aluminum disks ( fig . [ fig1 ] ) with a selected interval of more than one decade in diameter @xmath6 mm or more than three decades in the excluded area .
( a ) generation of four loops from the packing of a flexible rod ( diameter @xmath0 ) inside an annular cavity of inner ( external ) diameter @xmath7 ( @xmath8 ) .
( b ) the initial conformation with @xmath9 in length .
( c ) the formation of the first loop , whose length is @xmath10 [ eq . ( [ eq3 ] ) ] . ]
the total area available to the rod is @xmath11 for comparison , the experiment is also performed in a simply connected cavity ( without the central disk ) .
inside mathematical expressions we mention simply connected cavity as `` scc '' .
it is important in this study that @xmath12 in eq .
( [ eq1 ] ) because in this limit we can distinguish the contribution of the topology .
the flexible rod is a typical nylon fishing line of diameter @xmath13 mm with a young s modulus of about @xmath14 gpa .
the initial conformation is shown in fig .
[ fig1](b ) . at the outer ends of the rod
a mark in made with a permanent marker .
the distance between these marks indicates the length of the rod in this initial condition , @xmath9 .
once injected , the rod bends continuously changing its geometric pattern .
a loop is a closed geometric teardrop shape composed of a vertex and a bulge .
the first loop arises when the rod makes the first self - contact as shown in fig .
[ fig1](c ) . during the injection
more loops are created inside the cavity , with several sizes and positions .
our experiment consists of measuring the length needed to add a new loop to the total geometric pattern .
when a new self - contact arises , the injection is stopped in order to mark the length on the rod with the marker .
the injection speed is about @xmath15 cm / s , but a pause is taken to dry the ink and to carefully remove the excess .
all injections are performed in a dry regime .
compared to the simply connected cavity the presence of a central obstacle changes the disposition of the loops to the periphery of the cavity .
the region close to the injection channel presents a denser concentration of the rod than in the opposite region of the cavity , behind the obstacle , which becomes scarcely available to the rod even at small values of @xmath7 .
the size of the loops varies with the diameter of the central disk and therefore the total length needed to create @xmath3 loops depends on the area of the annulus .
we are interested in investigating the total length needed to create a given quantity of loops in a global geometric pattern . assuming that the length needed to build @xmath3 loops is @xmath16 ,
then the length @xmath17 needed to create a new loop is @xmath18 and the total length can be computed by summing up the distances between successive marks along the rod .
the instrumental uncertainties are fixed for @xmath19 and increase with @xmath20 for @xmath16 ( although never more than @xmath21 ) .
the injection ends when the system becomes jammed . in general the last mark on the rod
does not indicate the tight - packing , because the system can become jammed after the formation of the last loop .
the last mark corresponds to the total length needed to create @xmath22 loops in the cavity .
after the injection , the rod is extracted through the opposite channel .
the whole experiment consists of 10 identical realizations of packing of the flexible rod into an annular cavity .
a total of 3907 loops are observed in 110 realizations .
earlier studies claimed that the relationship between the number of loops and the length of the rod follows a power law @xcite .
however , the length of branches of the rod between successive self - contacts follows exponential distributions @xcite . for regular folding @xcite , the successive bending of a rod of length @xmath23 in the middle yields @xmath24 pieces of length @xmath25 between successive kinks , with @xmath26 and @xmath27 , which corresponds to a power - law scaling @xmath28 .
we have observed that , since each loop has an individual length ( @xmath29 ) , the number of loops must be identified as the iteration of the process , and therefore we propose an exponential scaling .
indeed , a recent study of the subject @xcite introduces successfully an exponential law in order to describe the unpacking of a copper wire . in the present paper ,
an exhaustive experimental analysis substantiates the exponential description of the packing of a flexible rod and an examination of its limitations demonstrates instabilities not reported before .
this approach also enables a different point of view about the fractal behavior usually found for tight - packing configurations .
figures [ fig2](a ) and [ fig2](c ) show the length @xmath19 and figs .
[ fig2](b ) and [ fig2](d ) show the total length @xmath16 as functions of the number of loops @xmath3 for generic injections with @xmath30 mm [ figs .
[ fig2](a ) and [ fig2](b ) ] and @xmath31 mm [ figs .
[ fig2](c ) and [ fig2](d ) ] . the first experimental point in fig .
[ fig2 ] corresponds to the injected length @xmath9 which is associated with the initial condition of the rod in the annulus [ eq . ( [ eq2 ] ) ] .
however , the counting of loops must start from a given length @xmath32 which is initially unknown . as a consequence
, one can not consider @xmath9 for theoretical fits and one must find @xmath32 from extrapolation of all the data .
the relationship between the cumulative length @xmath16 and the length between successive loops @xmath19 can be written as @xmath33 and it is in agreement with eq .
( [ eq3 ] ) where @xmath34 . since @xmath32 is unknown
, @xmath35 is initially unknown and it is different from the experimental value , @xmath36 . for annular cavities , generally @xmath37 and the theoretical fit for @xmath16 passes above the first data point ( see fig .
[ fig2 ] ) . as an immediate consequence ,
the value of @xmath38 is higher than predicted by the theoretical line , i.e. , @xmath39 .
the data for @xmath19 are very well described by an exponentially decreasing function of @xmath3 , as expected from simple arguments .
consider the existence of a maximum length @xmath40 that can be injected inside the cavity .
it is reasonable to suppose that the new loop is created by consuming a fraction of the available length @xmath41 : @xmath42 this equation can be iteratively used together with eqs .
( [ eq3 ] ) and ( [ eq4 ] ) to obtain @xmath43 the total length @xmath16 [ eq . ( [ eq4 ] ) ] needed to create @xmath3 loops is then a limited quantity .
for the formation of infinite loops we have @xmath44
. we can write @xmath45 where @xmath46 .
our model thus yields an equation with three physical parameters : ( _ i _ )
@xmath32 , a length of reference ; ( _ ii _ )
@xmath47 , the saturation length ; and ( _ iii _ ) @xmath48 , a characteristic number of loops .
these parameters are obtained from fits .
the solid lines in figs .
[ fig2](b ) and [ fig2](d ) show the best fit of eq .
( [ eq7 ] ) over the experimental data . from
the same fits the solid line in fig .
[ fig2](a ) and [ fig2](c ) are obtained by applying eq .
( [ eq3 ] ) .
the exponential description works very well for the injection of the flexible rod into all cavities used in the experiment .
the model is appropriate to describe the length of the rod which is adaptive to the whole structure within the cavity . in practice ,
the elastic interaction among branches of the rod is followed up by internal movements .
friction is responsible for intermittencies due to the stick - slip phenomenon .
when the structure has enough loops and the insertion of a new one becomes uncertain due to the high rigidity , two situations are observed : ( _ i _ ) the system is tightly packed , and it is impossible to inject the rod further ; or ( _ ii _ ) the structure slides and a new area of the cavity becomes accessible ( fig .
[ fig3 ] ) .
we denote the latter case `` instability '' .
naturally , after one or more instabilities the system becomes jammed at some stage of the packing .
insertion of @xmath3 loops in an annular cavity of @xmath49 mm and @xmath4 mm .
( a ) the loops decrease exponentially in size .
( b ) as the packing proceeds , the route of progressively smaller loops becomes unstable and new branches of larger loops can appear . ] returning to fig .
[ fig2 ] , we can now examine a consequence of these instabilities : the length @xmath17 needed to insert the next loop is relatively large . as a consequence , there is a discontinuity in @xmath16 . in our experiment
this occurs rather unpredictably ( 36% of realizations ) , and to the best of our knowledge , it has not been reported before in the literature on confined wires . the dry injection and the roughness of the cavities are pointed out as possible promoters of those instabilities . in cases of discontinuities , the theoretical fit is performed until a given number @xmath50 , immediately before the instability .
the values of @xmath51 vary between @xmath52 for larger cavities ( with @xmath53 mm ) and @xmath54 for small cavities ( with @xmath55 mm ) .
our experiment was projected to precisely evaluate the exponential growth , and discontinuities were found as unexpected ( unpredictable ) outcomes .
for this reason , although we can carry out a qualitative discussion , we do not have enough data for a suitable investigation focused on those instabilities .
while the total length of the rod plays the central physical role in determining the mass or the global rigidity of the system , the number of loops plays the role of time in the dynamic , in the sense that all physical quantities evolves when new loops are created .
this model treats the packing of a rod as a discrete dynamical system .
we discuss our results in two parts .
the formation of loops is modeled by an exponential growth given by eq .
( [ eq7 ] ) for all 110 experimental realizations until a given number of loops @xmath51 . in sec .
[ subseciva ] we discuss how the parameters of this exponential fitting change when the inner diameter @xmath7 of the annulus varies . since the injection becomes progressively harder the system jams at some stage of the packing . in sec .
[ subsecivb ] , we discuss the dependence of the number @xmath51 with the total area of the cavity .
this allows us to understand why all experiments on packing in two - dimensional cavities present a complex structure whose fractal dimension @xmath56 is slightly smaller than 2 .
we described the initial length @xmath9 corresponding to fig .
[ fig1](b ) by two components : a straight one , which links the channels to the ( tangent ) inner disk ; and a curved one , which follows the circular arc of the central disk . the resulting expression
, @xmath57 describes very well the length @xmath9 for any diameter @xmath7 , and also for the simply connected cavity @xmath58 , as shown in fig .
[ fig4](a ) by the solid line .
please observe that eq .
( [ eq2 ] ) is not obtained through a fit from experimental data but , instead , from a simple geometrical reasoning .
( a ) the initial length @xmath9 increases with the inner diameter @xmath7 as expected from inspection of fig .
[ fig1](b ) .
however , all fit parameters in eq .
( [ eq7 ] ) ( b ) @xmath32 , ( c ) @xmath59 , and ( d ) @xmath48 decrease with @xmath7 .
the first data point corresponds to the simple connected cavity .
the solid lines are curves obtained from the theoretical description : ( a ) eq .
( [ eq2 ] ) , ( b ) eq . ( [ eq9 ] ) , ( c ) eq . ( [ eqa ] ) , and ( d ) eq . ( [ eq10 ] ) . ] the parameters @xmath32 , @xmath47 , and @xmath48 in eq .
( [ eq7 ] ) are obtained from a single fit over @xmath51 experimental points and then averaged among 10 realizations .
the outcome is shown in fig .
[ fig4](b ) , [ fig4](c ) and [ fig4](d ) , where their numeric values are shown . the continuous lines are not fits but obtained from more fundamental quantities which depend only on features of the rod and cavity . in the next paragraphs we focus on these quantities .
the network of loops starts with the creation of the biggest loop . in simply connected ( circular ) cavities it is expected that the length needed to create the first loop , @xmath35 , is proportional to the size of the cavity ( the pattern is simply rescaled ) , so @xmath60 @xcite .
here we discuss the impact of a single obstacle in the center of the cavity .
figure [ fig5](a ) shows the directly measured length @xmath61 and fig .
[ fig5](b ) shows the proper length @xmath35 as functions of the inner diameter of the annulus .
the directly measured length @xmath61 is found to be proportional to the available area of the cavity , @xmath62 , as shown by the dashed line in fig .
[ fig5](a ) .
the first point corresponds to the first loop in a simply connected cavity whose value is the same , @xmath63 .
the value for @xmath35 is computed from the parameters of the exponential fitting @xmath64 and it is found to be fixed , @xmath65 mm , as shown by the dashed line in fig .
[ fig5](b ) .
the first point corresponds to the first loop in a simply connected cavity whose value is the same within the error bars , @xmath66 mm .
this suggests that , although @xmath35 depends on the external diameter @xmath8 , it is unresponsive to the inner diameter @xmath7 of the annulus .
all together , these results allow us to write @xmath67 as a function of the inner diameter @xmath7 .
equation ( [ eq9 ] ) describes implicitly the dependence of the fitting parameter @xmath68 and produces the solid line shown in fig .
[ fig4](b ) .
we can write @xmath69 for the simply connected cavity since similar relations are valid for each term on the right - hand side of eq .
( [ eq9 ] ) .
therefore , this parameter does not change between the two topologies .
the length needed to build the first loop .
( a ) the directly measured value @xmath61 is proportional to the available area of the cavity , @xmath70 .
( b ) the model yields a fixed length , @xmath71 mm . ]
the exponential model predicts a saturation length @xmath72 which can be obtained by fitting the experimental data for each annular cavity of inner diameter @xmath7 .
the pattern of infinite loops inside the cavity is regarded as a mathematical fractal , which is impossible to reach by physical constraints imposed by the plasticity and thickness of the rod .
the range of the exponential model in length , @xmath73 , is found to be proportional to the available area of the annulus ( see inset in fig .
[ fig6 ] ) . from the proportionality
constant we define the packing fraction @xmath74 , which is approximately fixed for all annular cavities ( fig . [ fig6 ] ) .
the packing fraction @xmath74 corresponds to the fraction of available area covered by the rod in the ideal configuration of infinity loops .
this conformation characterizes the thermodynamic limit of this system .
the saturation length @xmath75 varies linearly with the available area in the limit of larger cavities ( @xmath76 ) .
equation ( [ eqa ] ) describes the dependence of the fitting parameter @xmath77 and produces the solid line shown in fig .
[ fig4](c ) .
the dashed line in fig [ fig6 ] illustrates the mean value @xmath78 found for annular cavities with inner diameter @xmath7 .
the packing fraction is approximately fixed for all annular cavities , @xmath78 .
the first point is relative to the simply connected cavity , which has a bigger packing fraction @xmath79 .
inset : the interval of existence of loops @xmath80 is found to be proportional to the available area of the annulus . ] in the examination of the `` stacking '' of loops of decreasing size on top of each other , it is quite interesting that the same area fraction of the cavity is filled , no matter how large the obstacle in the middle .
using polar coordinates whose origin coincides with the center of the annulus , we observe that a fixed packing fraction @xmath74 can be well explained by treating the rod ( with infinite loops ) as covering a fixed angular sector .
of course , this picture is inappropriate for a circular cavity without obstacles . the first point in fig .
[ fig6 ] represents the data for a simply connected cavity whose packing fraction is @xmath79 .
this result , @xmath81 , quantifies the impact of a non - simply connected topology on the total number of states accessible for the rod .
it was conjectured by gomes _
et al . _
@xcite that the packing of the rod can be described by a non - equilibrium thermodynamics where the number of obstacles regulates the effective temperature @xmath82 of the system . in this sense , the data from annular cavities are dispersed over an isotherm , and any change in the total length of the rod is a contribution uniquely of the available area . the results illustrated in figs .
[ fig5 ] and [ fig6 ] allow us to write the dependence of the exponential parameters on the inner diameter @xmath7 .
the characteristic number of loops as defined in eq .
( [ eq7 ] ) is a fitting parameter whose dependence on @xmath7 is very well described by @xmath83 as shown by the solid line in fig .
[ fig4](d ) .
the characteristic number of loops depends on the physical properties of the material through @xmath35 and @xmath74 . together with the ideas previously discussed ,
where @xmath60 and @xmath84 , eq .
( [ eq10 ] ) has two interesting physical limits . for larger cavities ,
the thermodynamic limit gives us that @xmath85 , where @xmath86 is defined as the packing fraction associated with the first loop , @xmath87 . in the opposite limit , if the cavity is too narrow such that @xmath88 then the exponential behavior falls off and loops must no longer be observed !
indeed , this special situation was found in a recent study using rectangular cavities @xcite .
for the set of annular cavities discussed here , we estimate that the central disk must have approximately @xmath89 of the diameter @xmath8 of the cavity in order to inhibit the formation of loops .
the exponential model described in this article is in agreement with previous studies of tight - packing in crumpled systems and regular folding , and it yields some predictions . the equality @xmath90 = 1 - \left ( \frac{l_n - l_0}{l_\infty - l_0 } \right ) = \frac{\lambda_n}{\lambda_0 } , \label{eqb}\ ] ] where @xmath91 , has a connecting role between these approaches . in the regular folding case ,
the force scales with the compaction as @xmath92 @xcite , because the force increases in order to bend progressively smaller pieces of the rod . on the other hand , in the jamming approach the velocity of the injection decreases as the density of the rod increases close to the injection channel .
the physical effect is that the force scales with the total length inside the cavity as @xmath93 @xcite , where we can identify @xmath94 and @xmath95 .
following eq .
( [ eqb ] ) both approaches are suitable for describing this system , and we find @xmath96 .
we can also estimate the dependence of @xmath48 on the bending stiffness @xmath97 of the rod as follows .
the force associated with the first loop must be proportional to the bending stiffness ; then @xmath98 , that is , @xmath99 must increase linearly with @xmath100 .
this prospect means that @xmath48 is a very slowly decreasing function of @xmath97 .
our non - completely ordered packing of loops in two dimensions has a complementary relation with the amorphous disk packings originally called `` random close packed '' , whose densities are @xmath101(@xmath102 ) for the monodisperse ( bidisperse ) case @xcite .
more recently , amorphous collectively jammed disk packings dominated by large triangular grains seem to have significantly higher densities , close to @xmath103 @xcite .
coincidentally , the packing fractions @xmath104 , averaged over 10 different genus 1 cavities , and @xmath105 , for genus 0 cavities shown in fig .
[ fig6 ] , are closely complementary ( that is , @xmath106 ) to the amorphous arrangements of circles studied .
the discontinuity between the packing densities in simply connected cavities and in cavities with a central excluded domain , shown in fig .
[ fig6 ] , where @xmath107 , is interpreted as a difference in the entropy between the configurations , once the entropy scales linearly with the length of the injected rod and , consequently , with the packing density @xcite .
the inclusion of an excluded region , irrespective of its size , lowers the entropy of the packing . in this view , that discontinuity is connected with a first - order phase transition , as the entropy is the first derivative of the associated free energy : it is a topological transition ; the existence of an exclusion region , even of size @xmath108 , leads to a configuration of the rod with a substantially different packing density compared with that obtained with the simply connected cavity .
this section concerns the lengths associated with @xmath3 loops in the intermediary ( before the instabilities ) stage of the packing .
the quantities @xmath35 and @xmath74 were obtained from fit parameters [ eq . ( [ eq7 ] ) ] , while @xmath38 and @xmath9 are directly measured along the rod .
it was observed that these geometrical quantities are dependent only on properties of the rod and cavity ( available before the experiment ) and , therefore , are more fundamental quantities .
conversely , the fit parameters in eq .
( [ eq7 ] ) can be estimated from these quantities using eqs .
( [ eq9 ] [ eq10 ] ) .
this allows the estimation of the length associated with @xmath3 loops for any annular cavity of inner diameter @xmath7 .
our results stress that the topology of the cavity only affects @xmath74 , that is , the porosity of the global pattern . as an implication of a fixed packing fraction @xmath74 ,
the fractal dimension of the global pattern in the infinite limit might be @xmath109 .
this is admissible from the point of view of a rod distributed in a fixed angular sector of the annulus , which has a two - dimensional shape .
however , a previous study pointed out a slightly smaller fractal dimension , @xmath110 , for the tight - packing of copper wires into circular cavities @xcite .
another investigation found @xmath111 for a more plastic wire of the alloy sn@xmath112pb@xmath113 , but presented theoretical reasoning predicting that this exponent should be 2 @xcite , linking this system with long molecular chains densely packaged as dna in chromosomes , or in virus capsids . in this subsection
we examine why these studies found @xmath114 for the tight - packing of wires in the context of the exponential model described above . in short ,
we point out that the physical limit for the force implies that the system gets jammed with a finite number of loops @xmath51 , and then the total length under this condition @xmath115 does not scale linearly with the available area .
there is also a spatial limit .
we can see the reason or even estimate the jamming of the system through the radii of curvature for the smallest loops , immediately next to the injection channel , which are of the order of the gauge @xmath0 of the rod .
the fits analyzed in sec . [ subseciva ] are valid until a given number of loops @xmath51 , at which either the system gets jammed or an instability occurs .
the determination of @xmath51 is easily visually performed from graphs as in fig .
a more objective criterion can be elaborated , for instance , calculating the relative growth of the loops , @xmath116 , a negative quantity supposed to be independent of @xmath3 . in practice
, the relative growth is a small fluctuating quantity .
this quantity is suitable to detect instabilities because in such cases the length @xmath17 is large compared to @xmath19 .
we choose a threshold value , @xmath117 , which determines the occurrence of instabilities : if @xmath118 , then the jump is detected and @xmath51 is recorded . throughout the whole experiment the choice @xmath117 agrees @xmath119 with the visual criteria .
smaller values , @xmath120 , would indicate statistical fluctuations as discontinuities and larger values , @xmath121 , would not detect some of the conspicuous instabilities .
each realization of the experiment yields a particular geometric pattern and a total number of loops @xmath122 , which vary considerably among different reproductions . on the other hand , the numbers of loops @xmath51 are close to each other such that we can compute an average value in order to illustrate all similar realizations with a given diameter @xmath7 .
we found @xmath51 as a decreasing function of @xmath7 similar to the characteristic number of loops @xmath48 [ eq . ( [ eq10 ] ) ] .
figure [ fig7 ] shows the ratio @xmath123 as an increasing function of the diameter @xmath124 , which reveals a relatively better fit for a narrower annulus .
the ratio @xmath125 illustrates the range of validity of the exponential fitting in the experimental data . in realizations on annular cavities ,
the exponential fit becomes better when the annulus is narrow ( larger @xmath124 ) .
] the total length inserted in order to generate @xmath51 loops in the global packing pattern is @xmath126 , given by eq .
( [ eq7 ] ) with @xmath127 .
since @xmath125 is not fixed among the cavities , the total length @xmath126 is not simply proportional to the available area of the cavity . from the experimental data we found that the ratio @xmath125 linearly decreases with the logarithm of the available area , that is , @xmath128 where @xmath129 is found by the best fit ( see dashed line in fig .
[ fig7 ] ) . as a direct consequence , we can write @xmath130 where @xmath74 , @xmath131 and @xmath132 do not depend on @xmath7 . the plot in fig
. [ fig8](a ) shows the experimental data and the curve described by eq .
( [ eq12 ] ) ( solid line ) . in the packing of infinite loops , the last term in eq .
( [ eq12 ] ) vanishes [ see eq .
( [ eq7 ] ) ] and the length @xmath126 is essentially proportional to the available area ( see the dashed line in fig .
[ fig8 ] ) . tight - packing measures .
( a ) area @xmath133 covered by the rod inserted in the cavity and ( b ) corresponding packing fraction @xmath134 .
the dashed line indicates the limit of infinite loops and the solid line shows the theoretical value given by eq .
( [ eq12 ] ) . ]
we observe that eq .
( [ eq12 ] ) can be understood as the relation between the total mass of the flexible rod , @xmath135 , and the size of the cavity , @xmath136 , in the tight - packing limit . from the mass - size relationship
, we can obtain the fractal dimension @xmath56 of the global pattern as @xmath137 .
equation ( [ eq12 ] ) suggests that the fractal dimension of a pattern of infinite loops is @xmath138 .
however , the physical limit of rigidity in the tight - packing imposes a deviation from the configuration of infinite loops and the tight - packing of a flexible rod in two - dimensional cavities gives an apparent fractal dimension @xmath139 as reported in the literature @xcite . the plot in fig .
[ fig8](b ) shows the packing fraction @xmath140 as a function of the inner diameter of the annulus . from tight - packing measures
, our result shows that the packing fraction is an increasing function when the initial length @xmath32 is ignored .
this is the opposite effect of increasing the number of obstacles , which decreases the total packing fraction of the rod @xcite .
a divergence for @xmath141 is expected because an annulus of this width yields an initial packing fraction of @xmath142 .
although we can not study the instabilities in greater detail , we report some results of interest .
the number of experimental realizations with instabilities does not shown any tendency when the inner diameter @xmath7 changes . among all the realizations for a given @xmath7 ,
there was at least one with instabilities , and on the other hand , there were at least three cases with no instabilities at all .
the length of the rod inserted from the instability to the last loop is @xmath143 and it accumulates all discontinuities in the range @xmath144 . on average , @xmath145 corresponds to an increment @xmath146 in the packing fraction .
however , the unpredictable behavior after the instabilities allows few realizations where @xmath145 can sum to about @xmath147 of the length inserted in the exponential domain @xmath148 .
we point out that the exponential behavior is suitable for describing the formation of loops with the injection of flexible elastic rods into two - dimensional cavities .
the global patterns have a clear size gradient characteristic of what has been called _ classical morphology _ @xcite . for less elastic filaments , one expects more instabilities to occur .
we stress that further studies of those discontinuities will lead to better descriptions of the formation of loops in patterns of _ plastic morphology_.
in this paper we report an exhaustive experimental study and analysis of the formation of loops in the packing of a flexible rod into annular cavities .
the packing is treated as a discrete dynamical process that obeys an exponential model valid in simply connected cavities as well as in annular cavities .
the length of formation of the first loop @xmath35 and the length of the rod needed to build infinite loops @xmath47 define the exponential parameters , given a reference length @xmath32 where the loops starts counting .
the model points out that there are discontinuities in the total length for a number of loops @xmath3 larger than the threshold @xmath51 in @xmath149 of realizations .
the tight - packing is also analyzed and we show that the physical limit for the rigidity of the system imposes an apparent fractal dimension that is always smaller than two as previously found in different experimental studies .
our results in annular cavities are in agreement with previous claims which include changes in entropy due to the topology of the cavity and constant packing fraction for the effective isotherm curve of this system @xcite .
approximate complementary relationships of the packing problems discussed here with the classical problems of the random close packing of disks , and the jammed disk packing are pointed out .
we urge that additional study of the system examined in this article is needed in order to clarify the influence of plasticity and elasticity in the phenomenon and , in particular , to further the examination of the origin of the discontinuities reported here , and the possible connection of the appearance of instabilities with traditional studies of dynamical systems .
the authors acknowledge important suggestions from two anonymous referees .
t. a. s. thanks professor jos a. soares jr . , universidade federal do cear , fortaleza , brazil , for his hospitality .
this work was supported by grant no .
302251/2010 - 3 of cnpq ( conselho nacional de desenvolvimento cientfico e tecnolgico ) and by grant no . mct / cnpq / facepe , apq-1330 - 1.05/10 of pronex ( programa de ncleos de excelncia ) , all brazilian agencies .
18ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12
& 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.66.015102 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.101.094101 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/s10659 - 015 - 9555 - 0 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.91.052408 [ * * , ( ) ] http://stacks.iop.org/0034-4885/56/i=6/a=002 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.actamat.2015.06.018 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.92.052401 [ * * , ( ) ] http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/ncomms5437 [ * * ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.81.031127 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.87.052103 [ * * , ( ) ] http://stacks.iop.org/1742-5468/2010/i=11/a=p11027 [ * * , ( ) ] http://stacks.iop.org/0295-5075/95/i=3/a=34002 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1371/journal.pone.0128568 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.110.104301 [ * * , ( ) ] http://stacks.iop.org/0022-3727/48/i=33/a=335305 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.27.1053 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1063/1.1633647 [ * * , ( ) ] http://www.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=s0103-50532008000200014&nrm=iso [ * * , ( ) ] | the continuous packing of a flexible rod in two - dimensional cavities yields a countable set of interacting domains that resembles non - equilibrium cellular systems and belongs to a new class of light - weight material .
however , the link between the length of the rod and the number of domains requires investigation especially in the case of non - simply connected cavities , where the number of avoided regions emulates an effective topological temperature . in the present article
we report the results of an experiment of injection of a single flexible rod into annular cavities in order to find the total length needed to insert a given number of loops ( domains of one vertex ) . using an exponential model to describe the experimental data
we quite minutely analyze the initial conditions , the intermediary behavior , and the tight - packing limit .
this method allows the observation of a new fluctuation phenomenon associated with instabilities in the dynamic evolution of the packing process .
furthermore , the fractal dimension of the global pattern enters the discussion under a novel point of view .
a comparison with the classical problems of the random close packing of disks , and jammed disk packings is made .
keywords : : folded structures , 2d systems , complex packing . |
cavity quantum electrodynamics ( cqed ) has continued to develop rapidly , driven both by recent experimental successes and by the promise of exciting new applications .
advances in atom cooling techniques , as well as development of high - q optical cavities with large dipole coupling , have enabled testing of the strong - coupling regime of cqed @xcite .
single - atom experiments are now feasible @xcite , and the possibility of trapping atoms in optical cavities is tantalisingly close @xcite .
potential applications include quantum logic gates @xcite .
applications of cqed rely critically on the quantum effects , namely the entanglement between the field degree of freedom and the internal electronic state of the atom @xcite .
this entanglement is not only challenging to achieve , it is also difficult to probe . in the optical regime of cqed ,
photon coincidence spectroscopy ( pcs ) has been proposed as a feasible and unambiguous method for detecting genuine quantum effects in cqed .
this technique employs a multichromatic driving field acting on the combined atom - cavity system and detects multiphoton decays by detecting photon coincidences in the cavity output field @xcite .
a difficulty arises in determining whether emitted photons are coincident or not .
let us consider a single two - level atom ( 2la ) coupled to a single mode of an optical cavity , and @xmath0 is the angular frequency of both the cavity mode and the 2la .
multi - atom effects can be ignored provided that the atomic density is sufficiently small @xcite . in the electric dipole and rotating - wave approximations , the hamiltonian is @xmath1 with @xmath2 the position of the atom , @xmath3 the position - dependent dipole coupling strength , @xmath4 and @xmath5 the annihilation and creation operators for photons in the cavity field , @xmath6 , @xmath7 , and @xmath8 the 2la raising , lowering and inversion operators , respectively , and @xmath9 .
the spectrum for this hamiltonian is depicted in fig .
[ fig : ladder ] and is the well - known jaynes - cummings spectrum , or ` ladder ' @xcite . the ` dressed states ' of the combined atom - cavity system are designated by the lowest - energy state @xmath10 a positive integer , @xmath11 where @xmath12 is the fock state of the cavity mode and @xmath13 is the ground ( excited ) state of the 2la .
here we are concerned with two - photon coincidence spectroscopy ( 2pcs ) which proceeds , first by driving the atomic beam with a bichromatic field which causes two - photon excitation to the second couplet of the jc ladder , followed by two - photon decay from the atom - cavity system .
the objective is to count photon pairs emitted from the cavity as the frequencies of the driving field are varied .
when the sum frequency is @xmath14 , we expect to see a resonantly enhanced two - photon count rate ( 2pcr ) .
of course , @xmath15 is a random variable due to beam fluctuations , and this leads to inhomogeneous broadening . despite these difficulties
, 2pcs appears to be a feasible method for detecting the characteristic splitting in the jc model @xcite .
however , improvements in the procedure are important to ensure that the detection process is optimised .
in the following analysis we investigate the appropriate window time for counting photon pairs .
photon pairs are not emitted from the cavity simultaneously due to the randomness of photoemission from an optical cavity .
the detection of a photon pair thus depends on identifying a window time @xmath16 such that , for two photons detected with temporal separation @xmath17 such that @xmath18 , the two photons are deemed to be members of a pair , and , if @xmath19 , are deemed to be independent single photons ( not members of a pair ) . here
we determine the optimal window time @xmath20 which maximises the counting rate of genuine pairs relative to the rate of false pair counts .
the hamiltonian ( [ jch ] ) for the combined atom - cavity system ignores the driving field emission of photons from the system .
the hamiltonian is useful in so far as it yields the spectrum for the combined atom - cavity system , but the full quantum master equation is necessary to calculate the quantities relevant to experiments , namely the two - photon count rate ( 2pcr ) .
the experiment proceeds by measuring the 2pcr as a function of the bichromatic driving field s scanning field frequency .
two - photon excitation is provided by driving the atom directly with a bichromatic field , characterised by the time - dependent variable @xmath21 the angular frequency @xmath22 is fixed and resonantly excites the atom - cavity system from the ground state @xmath23 to the excited state @xmath24 for the subensemble @xmath25 .
that is , provided that @xmath26 the bichromatic driving field will resonantly excite the subensemble of atom - cavity systems for which @xmath25 .
of course subensembles for which @xmath27 can also be excited , but these excitations are non - resonant and hence less significant . the second frequency , @xmath28 , is scanned over a particular frequency range .
the purpose of the second component of the bichromatic field is to excite to one of the two states in the second couplet of the jaynes - cummings ladder , namely @xmath29 .
thus , the range of scanning frequencies for @xmath28 must include the @xmath30 transition frequencies , @xmath31 respectively .
the amplitudes of the two chromatic components must be large enough to ensure sufficient occupation of the excited state but not large enough that significant stark shifting or nonnegligible occupation of the higher - order states occurs .
enhanced rates of photon pair detection are then sought as the scanning frequency @xmath28 is varied .
the enhanced 2pcr occurs at the resonances shown in fig .
[ fig : ladder ] .
in addition to a driving term , loss terms must also be included .
the born - markov approximation is applied to both radiation reservoirs : the reservoir for the field leaving the cavity and the reservoir for direct fluorescence of the 2la from the sides of the cavity . the cavity damping rate is @xmath32 , and the emission rate into free space is @xmath33 , where @xmath33 is the inhibited spontaneous emission rate due to the restriction of modes by the cavity .
the master equation @xcite can be expressed as @xmath34 for @xmath35 the liouvillean superoperator .
more specifically the liouvillean superoperator can be expressed as the sum of a time - independent liouvillean operator , a time - dependent liouvillean operator and a ` jump ' term . by defining @xmath36 , in the rotating picture of @xmath37
the master equation is @xmath38 \rho(t;\delta , g)\ ] ] for @xmath39 a non - hermitian hamiltonian , the first term is @xmath40,\ ] ] the time - dependent term is @xmath41,\ ] ] and the jump term is @xmath42 the atom - field coupling strength @xmath15 depends on the atomic position @xmath43 . provided that the atoms move sufficiently slowly through the cavity @xcite , the atom can be treated as if it were at rest at some randomly located position @xmath43 .
the interaction of the atom with the cavity is then described by the master equation in the asymptotic large time ( @xmath44 ) . as the position @xmath43 is a randomly varying quantity ,
the value of the coupling strength @xmath15 itself is also random .
hence , a coupling strength distribution @xmath45 can be constructed @xcite .
the resultant density matrix is given by @xmath46 where @xmath47 is the coupling strength at a cavity node and @xmath48 is the effective lower bound cut - off for the coupling @xmath49 .
the effect of averaging over @xmath45 is an inhomogeneous spectral broadening .
this broadening is due to atomic position variability . in fig .
[ fig : p(g ) ] two typical distributions @xmath45 are depicted , one for the case of a uniformly distributed atomic beam entering the cavity and the second for an atomic beam initially passing through a rectangular mask @xcite . in both cases we assumed a single - mode cavity supporting a tem@xmath50 mode . for a bichromatic driving field , the density matrix ( [ density : matrix ] ) does not settle to a steady state value .
the time - dependence of the density matrix in the long - time limit can be treated by making a bloch function expansion of the density matrix @xcite . in the bloch function expansion
, the density matrix is written as the sum @xmath51 with @xmath52 time - dependent matrices . in the long - time limit , @xmath53 and @xmath54
can thus be regarded as time - independent . as the photocount integration time
is expected to be long compared to the frequency @xmath55 , it is reasonable to approximate @xmath56 by truncating the expansion ( [ bloch ] ) .
the two - photon count rate ( 2pcr ) can be obtained in more than one way .
ideally one would have a perfectly efficient photodetector which detects all photons leaving one side of the cavity .
the photodetector would then provide a complete record of photon emissions from the cavity as a function of @xmath17 .
a perfect coincidence would then arise as two simultaneously detected photons at some time @xmath17 . however , there are two problems .
one problem is that there does not exist a perfectly efficient photodetector .
therefore , some pairs of photons are observed as single - photon emissions because one member of the pair escapes observation . in fact
some pairs are missed altogether because both photons escape detection .
the other problem concerns the detection of two simultaneously created photons . although created simultaneously , the emission from the cavity is not simultaneous due to the randomness of the emission time which is characterised by the cavity lifetime @xmath57 . a better and more accurate way to describe two - photon detections is to employ the 2pcr . to begin with ,
we consider two photons to be coincident provided that they arrive within a time interval @xmath16 , the ` window time ' .
the choice of window time is not obvious , and it is our aim here to determine what the window time should be . as the two simultaneous photons can be separated by a time of order @xmath58 , as discussed above , the window time @xmath16 might be expected to be on the order of @xmath58 . however , our purpose here is to consider the choice of @xmath16 in detail and to identify the optimal choice of window time @xmath16 which will produce the best measure of the 2pcr .
the choice of optimal window time is further complicated by the method of detecting nearly simultaneous photons . in the ideal case discussed above of a perfect photodetector yielding a record of all photon emissions from the cavity , one
can then define a two - photon event as taking place if a second photon arrives between times @xmath59 and @xmath60 , _ conditioned _ on a photodetection at time @xmath59 .
we refer to this rate as the _ conditional _ 2pcr and define this rate to be @xmath61 the number operator in eq ( [ 2pcr : con ] ) is defined as @xmath62 , and ` @xmath63 ' refers to normal ordering .
the averaging is performed for the density matrix of eq ( [ master ] ) .
the conditional 2pcr for a window time @xmath64 was used in the quantum trajectory analysis of pcs in ref .
@xcite .
another natural way to measure the 2pcr is by counting all photon pairs defined as being separated by an interval less than @xmath16 .
this 2pcr is referred to as the _ unconditional _ 2pcr and does not rely on starting the count for the second photon conditioned on detecting the first photon .
the definition of the unconditional 2pcr is @xmath65 as shown in appendix a , this expression can be simplified to read @xmath66 we solve analytically for two extreme cases in appendix a. the window time can be extremely long @xmath67 , yielding expression ( [ long : time ] ) , or extremely short @xmath68 , yielding expression ( [ short : time ] ) for both conditional and unconditional 2pcr .
the short window time ( @xmath69 0 ) was the basis of the analysis of 2pcs in ref .
@xcite . in this treatment both
the conditional and unconditional 2pcr at time @xmath17 is approximated by @xmath70 . in the long - time limit
the 2pcr is dominated by poissonian statistics .
the choice of optimal window time @xmath20 depends on the technique for observing two - photon coincidences , but another factor must also be considered . the purpose of 2pcs is to observe two - photon decay resonances from the combined atom - cavity system . as explained in refs @xcite , there are three peaks in the 2pcr as a function of the scanning frequency @xmath55 . these peaks are shown in fig .
[ adadaa ] as a function of the normalised scanning field frequency @xmath71 the choice of @xmath16 will depend on which peak is being observed .
however , the best peak for observing a two - photon decay resonance occurs for @xmath72 this resonance corresponds to the transition @xmath73 .
this peak does not occur in a semiclassical description of intensity correlations in the cavity output field and therefore serves as a signature of a genuine quantum field effect in cqed .
moreover , this peak can be observed without the added complication of having to perform the experiment twice , once with a bichromatic field and once again with a monochromatic field , in order to perform the signal enhancement technique of background subtraction @xcite .
finally detection of this peak is the most feasible of the three dominant peaks in the two - photon spectrum .
hence , we consider specifically @xmath16 for this peak at @xmath74 given by eq ( [ delta : peak ] ) . in fig .
[ adadaa ] we observe that the 2pcr peak sits on a background 2pcr which is largely independent of @xmath74 and occurs at @xmath75 .
let us characterise the quality of this 2pcr peak by the ratio of the peak height to the height of the background 2pcr .
we can understand this ratio in terms of signal to noise , where signal is the 2pcr from the sought - for two - photon decay events , and the background noise corresponds to two - photon decays arising from unwanted off - resonance two - quantum excitations and decay events .
the peak - to - valley ratio ( pvr ) is determined by the height of the peak to the height of the background ( or valley ) 2pcr .
the optimal window time @xmath76 is defined such that the pvr for this 2pcr is maximal .
that is , either a larger or a smaller choice of the window time would reduce the value of the pvr making the peak more difficult to detect
. there are other concerns besides the pvr in choosing the window time .
for example , choosing a much shorter window time could improve the pvr but also lengthen the run time of the experiment in order to accumulate enough signal .
that is , the absolute height of the peak is also a matter of concern in determining the feasibility of the experiment and is determined by the allowable timescale of the experiment .
the minimum height would need to be on the order of @xmath77 for @xmath78 the timescale of the data collection .
the pvr is obtained numerically .
the matrix continued fraction method is used to solve the master equation to determine the peak height .
the background , or valley , can be solved analytically though by treating the detuning of the scanning field as large .
the details are provided in appendix b. the 2pcr for large @xmath74 is given by expressions ( [ offres : c2pcs ] ) and ( [ offres:2pcs ] ) .
the peak - to - valley ratio 2pcr is thus @xmath79 where @xmath80 . in fig .
[ fig : surfpvr ] surface plots of the pvr _ vs _ @xmath15 and @xmath16 reveals that the pvr increases as @xmath15 decreases .
this is due to the background signal of two - photon coincidences for @xmath74 large becoming negligible as shown in fig .
[ adadaa ] .
although the pvr improves as @xmath15 decreases , the signal of two photon coincidences within the window time @xmath16 decreases .
this decrease is due to the fact that the resonant frequency for the transition @xmath81 is @xmath82 , but we have constrained the pump field frequency by ( [ gf ] ) .
hence , as @xmath15 decreases , the pump field drives the system more and more off resonance .
the window time @xmath16 for achieving the optimal pvr is an order of magnitude smaller than @xmath58 .
the optimal time @xmath20 exhibited in fig .
[ fig : optvsg ] is a function of coupling strength and in fig .
[ fig : resopt ] is a function of @xmath83 ( averaged over @xmath45 ) .
we are concerned specifically with the 2pcr and the pvr for the system with a coupling constant distribution based on the tem@xmath50 mode @xcite .
the coupling strength distribution is depicted in fig .
[ fig : p(g ) ] , and we treat the masked beam case which enhances the large - coupling effect . in fig .
[ fig : avgpvr ] we present the pvr for the density matrix @xmath84 of expression ( [ density : matrix ] ) , averaged over @xmath45 .
there is a peak of the pvr for each @xmath85 given by @xmath86 ( the optimal time window for observing the peak ( [ delta : peak ] ) ) .
these values of @xmath20 are plotted in fig .
[ fig : optvsg ] for @xmath87 for a range of values of @xmath33 . of particular interest here is the very weak dependence of @xmath20 on @xmath33 where @xmath33 is varied by a factor of @xmath88 .
moreover , @xmath20 is generally decreasing as @xmath85 increases .
in fig . [ fig : avgpvr ] we observe a maximum of the pvr for each of the assumed @xmath45 in fig . [
fig : p(g ) ] .
this peak occurs at @xmath89 for the conditional 2pcr and at @xmath90 for the unconditional 2pcr .
we can understand the location of these peaks by referring to fig .
[ fig : optvsg ] . in fig .
[ fig : optvsg](a ) the values of @xmath91 for the conditional 2pcr are predominantly between @xmath92 and @xmath93 , but the value of @xmath91 in the vicinity of @xmath94 is between @xmath95 and @xmath92 . due to the resonance condition ( [ gf ] ) this region of the @xmath91 _ vs _
@xmath85 curve is more significant .
hence , the dependence of @xmath20 on @xmath33 as depicted in fig .
[ fig : resopt ] is dominated by the @xmath94 region of figs .
[ fig : optvsg ] .
similarly , we can estimate the precise value of @xmath20 for the unconditional 2pcr from the dashed line of fig .
[ fig : resopt ] in the context of the values of @xmath20 in fig .
[ fig : optvsg](b ) . the linear dependence of @xmath20 on @xmath33 , as seen in fig .
[ fig : resopt ] yields a correlation of 0.9983 for the conditional 2pcr , and a correlation of 0.9995 for the unconditional 2pcr . in the conditional case @xmath96 and in the unconditional case
@xmath97 the low values of the slopes are indicative of the weak dependence on @xmath33
. formulae ( [ av : ctopt ] ) and ( [ av : topt ] ) can be used to fine - tune the choice of optimal window time , and the linear relationship simplifies the task of interpolating to obtain @xmath20 .
we have determined expressions for the optimal window time @xmath20 for both conditional and unconditional 2pcr .
these expression provide an optimal pvr for the 2pcr peak at @xmath98 corresponding to the @xmath99 transition .
although we have determined @xmath20 for certain parameters and for the coupling - strength distribution @xmath45 ( solid line of fig .
[ fig : p(g ) ] ) , the algorithm presented here is sufficiently general to allow calculation of @xmath20 for other parameters and other coupling - strength distributions . in general @xmath20 is smaller than @xmath58 by an order of magnitude for both the conditional and unconditional 2pcr .
there is some dependence on @xmath33 , but this dependence is weak and is close to linear in the cases studied here .
analyses of optimal window times are aided by studies of @xmath20 for particular values of @xmath15 , that is , for the coupling - strength distribution @xmath45 corresponding to @xmath100 for some @xmath101 . these calculations provide good estimates of the optimal window time for general @xmath45 .
a longer window time may be desirable , however , if the timescale for collecting enough data is not experimentally feasible .
a compromise between the two objectives of optimising the pvr and of accumulating sufficient data to produce a large peak height may be necessary .
an important technique discussed in refs .
@xcite was background subtraction .
the principle behind this method is to remove the unwanted two - photon off - resonance excitation to the second couplet .
background subtraction is particularly important to improve the pvr for 2pcr peaks .
however , we choose to study detection of the most promising peak experimentally ( [ delta : peak ] ) . in our simulations
we determine the pvr for this peak both by performing background subtraction and without background subtraction , and we obtain plots in agreement with figs . [
fig : surfpvr ] and [ fig : avgpvr ] .
these results confirm the assertion in ref .
@xcite that `` the resonance frequency lies outside the inhomogeneous line and the resonance should be resolved even in the presence of the two - photon background '' .
hence , background subtraction is not necessary to obtain optimal window times for resolving the peak ( [ delta : peak ] ) .
dr s. m. tan has provided matlab@xmath102 programs to us which was used initially to double check our simulations of the monochromatically driven jaynes - cummings system . we have benefited from valuable discussions with h. j. carmichael , j. d. cresser , z. ficek , k .-
marzlin , and s. m. tan .
this research has been supported by australian research council large and small grants and a macquarie university research grant .
in the long - time limit , the conditional two - photon count rate ( 2pcr ) is given by @xmath103 if the time window @xmath16 is large , compared to @xmath58 ( the cavity lifetime ) , the two photons are highly decorrelated , and we can approximate @xmath104 thus , @xmath105 this count rate reflects the poissonian nature of the count statistics for long window times .
on the other hand , for @xmath106 , the correlation between photon pairs can not be neglected .
hence , the count rate reduces to @xmath107 which is the approximation employed in ref @xcite .
similarly , in the long - time limit , the unconditional 2pcr is @xmath108 this expression can be simplified as we show below .
first we make the substitution @xmath109 .
we also introduce the notation @xmath110 and let @xmath111 be the union of the two regions @xmath112 and @xmath113 this substitution transforms the above double integral into the sum of two double integrals : @xmath114 the advantage of this expression is that the two - time photon number correlation depends on only one term in the double integral instead of both terms in the double integral .
greater simplification is possible and desirable for studying the short and long window time @xmath16 .
substituting @xmath115 transforms eq ( [ two : arrange ] ) to @xmath116 \nonumber \\ & & \left\langle : \hat{n}(0 ) \hat{n } ( w_+ ) : \right\rangle ( \delta , g)\end{aligned}\ ] ] which reduces to @xmath117 for large ( @xmath118 ) and small ( @xmath119 ) window times @xmath120 reduces identically to @xmath121 as shown in equations ( [ long : time ] ) and ( [ short : time ] ) .
for the scanning field far off resonance ( @xmath55 large ) , the time - dependent component of the liouvillean ( [ l(t ) ] ) can be ignored . in the interaction picture ,
the master equation can be written as @xmath122 with @xmath35 time - independent .
if @xmath84 is expressed as a vector , then @xmath35 can be expressed as a complex matrix with @xmath123 the set of eigenvalues for @xmath124 the number of levels in the jaynes - cummings ladder retained after truncation .
the density matrix can be approximated by the sum @xmath125 for @xmath126 a set of time - independent @xmath127 matrices .
thus , the conditional 2pcr ( [ 2pcr : con ] ) can be written as @xmath128 } \nonumber \\ & = & \ !
c_0(g ) \ ! \ ! + \ !
\sum_{n=1}^{n^2 } \ !
\frac { c_n ( g ) } { \mu_n(g ) } \ !
\left \ { \ !
1- e^ { -\mu_n ( g ) \ ! } \right \ } \ ! \ ! .\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath129 scalar constants @xmath130 and @xmath129 constants @xmath131 where @xmath132 as well . in the long window time limit ,
we equate @xmath133 expansion ( [ offres : c2pcs ] ) provides a useful method for calculating @xmath134 .
the function @xmath135 is monotonically increasing because @xmath136 if @xmath137 .
thus , @xmath138 as the function approaches the limit given by ( [ limit : delta ] ) . in the same way , the unconditional 2pcr can be obtained : @xmath139 } = c_0(g ) \nonumber \\ & & + \ ! 2 \ !
\sum_{n=1}^{n^2 } \frac { c_n ( g ) } { \mu_n ( g ) } \ !
\left\ { \ ! \frac { e^ { -\mu_n ( g ) } - 1 } { \mu_n ( g ) } + 1 \ ! \right\}\ ! .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] r. j. thompson , q. a. turchette , o. carnal and h. j. kimble , phys .
a , * 57 * , 3084 ( 1998 ) . c. j. hood , m. s. chapman , t. w. lynn and h. j. kimble , phys .
* 80 * , 4157 ( 1998 ) .
h. mabuchi , j. ye and h. j. kimble , j. appl .
b unpublished ( 1998 ) . a. s. parkins and h. j. kimble unpublished .
q. a. turchette , c. j. hood , w. lange , h. mabuchi and h. j. kimble , phys .
* 75 * , 4710 ( 1995 ) .
h. j. carmichael , p. kochan , and b. c. sanders , phys .
* 77 * , 631 ( 1996 ) .
m. brune , f. schmidt - kaler , a. maali , j. dreyer , e. hagley , j. m. raimond , and s. haroche , phys . rev
. lett . * 76 * , 1800 ( 1996 ) .
b. c. sanders , h. j. carmichael , b. f. wielinga , phys .
a * 55 * , 1358 ( 1997 ) .
l. horvath , b. c. sanders and b. f. wielinga , j. opt .
b : quant . and semiclassical opt .
( accepted ) .
h. j. carmichael and b. c. sanders , phys .
a , ( accepted ) .
e. t. jaynes and f. w. cummings , proc .
ieee * 51 * , 89 ( 1963 ) . | photon coincidence spectroscopy relies on detecting multiphoton emissions from the combined atom - cavity system in atomic beam cavity quantum electrodynamics experiments .
these multiphoton emissions from the cavity are nearly simultaneous approximately on the cavity lifetime scale .
we determine the optimal time for the detection window of photon pairs in two - photon coincidence spectroscopy .
if the window time is too short , some photon pairs will not be detected ; if the window time is too long , too many nearly coincident independent single photons will be falsely interpreted as being a photon pair . |
the differential emission measure ( dem ) diagnostic technique offers crucial information about the thermal structuring of the solar and stellar atmospheres , providing a measure of the temperature distribution of the plasma along the line of sight ( los ) .
however , to derive the dem from a set of observations is a complex task , due to the inverse nature of the problem , and the understanding of its robustness and accuracy is still relevant today ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
spectrometers are by nature better suited to dem analysis than broad band imagers .
but , because these latter generally offer a higher signal to noise ratio over a larger field of view ( fov ) , dem codes have nevertheless been applied to the three coronal bands of the extreme - ultraviolet imaging telescope ( eit ) @xcite or the transition region and coronal explorer ( trace , * ? ?
however , these instruments were shown not to constrain the dem enough to reach conclusive results . in recent years , the multiplication of passbands in instruments such as the x - ray telescope ( xrt ) on _ hinode _
@xcite and the atmospheric imaging assembly ( aia ) telescope @xcite has brought new prospects to reliably estimate the dem simultaneously over a large fov .
case studies of the properties of the inversion using these instruments have been published by e.g. , @xcite or @xcite .
building on these results , the central objective of the work presented in this series of papers is to provide a systematic characterization of the dem reconstruction problem to assess both its accuracy and robustness . using our technique ,
the capabilities of a given instrument can be evaluated , and new tools facilitating the dem interpretation are presented .
we illustrate our methodology in the specific case of the six coronal bands of aia , but the same principle can be applied to any set of broad band or spectroscopic measurements . initially introduced for element abundance measurements ,
then further developed by , e.g. , @xcite and @xcite , the dem formalism has been extensively used in the past decades , on most types of coronal structures , such as polar coronal holes @xcite , polar plumes ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , streamers ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , prominences ( e.g. * ? ?
? * ; * ? ? ?
* ) quiet sun ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , bright points @xcite or active regions ( e.g. * ? ? ?
the thermal structuring of the stellar coronae is also investigated using the dem analysis ( e.g. * ? ? ?
in particular , the dem is one of the tools commonly used to study the thermal stability of the coronal structures just mentioned , and to diagnose the energy source balancing the observed radiative losses .
for example , it can help to discriminate between steady or impulsive heating models predicting different loop thermal structures ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
one of the approaches is to establish the cross field thermal structure of resolved loops which is then compared to the dem simulated for unresolved multi - stranded and monolitic loops , impulsively or steadily heated . but
reliably inferring the dem from observations has proved to be a genuine challenge .
the fundamental limitations in the dem inversion have been discussed by , e.g. , @xcite , including measurement noises , systematic errors , the width and shape of the contribution functions , and the associated consequences of multiple solutions and limited temperature resolution .
many dem inversion algorithms have been proposed to cope with these limitations , each with its own strengths and weaknesses ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . in parallel to these developments ,
authors have been attentive early on to estimate the accuracy of the inversions ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , eventually comparing several algorithms ( e.g. * ? ? ?
. due to the intrinsic underconstraint of inverse problems and to the inevitable presence of random and systematic measurement errors , multiple physical solutions consistent with the observations exist , even if mathematical uniqueness and stability can be ensured via , e.g. , regularization .
it is nevertheless possible to quantify the amount of knowledge , or ignorance , on the physical parameter of interest by rigorously defining levels of confidence in the possible solutions or classes of solutions that can explain the observations within the uncertainties .
this is a desirable feature for any inversion scheme if it is to be able , for example , to discriminate or even to define , isothermality and multithermality .
in this perspective , we developed a technique to systematically explore the whole space of solutions , in order to determine their respective probabilities and quantify the robustness of the inversion with respect to plasma parameters , random and systematic errors .
we used data simulated with simple dem forms to systematically scan a wide range of plasma conditions , from isothermal to broadly multithermal , and several inversion hypotheses . comparing the dem solutions to the input of the simulations ,
it is possible to quantify the quality of the inversion . following this strategy ,
we are able to completely characterize the statistical properties of the inversion for several parametric dem distributions .
we argue that even though the specifics may vary , the main conclusions concerning the existence of multiple solutions and the ability to distinguish isothermality from multithermality also apply to more generic forms of dem distributions . in this first paper
, we focus on the response of aia to isothermal plasmas . the properties of the isothermal inversion thus observed will serve as building blocks for the interpretation of the more complex dem solutions studied in the second paper ( hereafter paper ii ) .
section [ sec_2 ] describes the general methodology and the practical implementation in the case of aia , including the data simulation , the inversion scheme , the sources of random and systematic errors , and the different dem distribution models considered .
results for isothermal plasmas are presented and discussed in section [ sec : iso_response ] .
a summary introducing the treatment of more generic dem forms is given in conclusion .
under the assumption that the observed plasma is optically thin , integration along the line of sight ( los ) of collisional emission lines and continua produces in the spectral band @xmath1 of an instrument an intensity @xmath2 where @xmath3 , the response of the instrument to a unit volume of plasma of electron number density @xmath4 and temperature @xmath5 , is given by @xmath6 the first term of the right member accounts for each spectral line @xmath7 of each ionic species @xmath8 of abundance @xmath9 , and the second term represents the contribution of the continua .
@xmath10 is the spectral sensitivity of the band @xmath1 of the instrument .
the respective contribution functions @xmath11 and @xmath12 of the lines and continua contain the physics of the radiation emission processes ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) and can be computed using the relevant atomic data . as long as one considers total line intensities , equations ( [ eq_1 ] ) and ( [ eq_2 ] ) are generic and apply to imaging telescopes as well as to spectrometers .
summarizing the original reasoning of @xcite , since the function @xmath3 is generally weakly dependent on the density and is peaked with temperature , @xmath13 gives a measure of @xmath14 where the integration is now limited to the portions @xmath15 of the los where the temperature is such that significant emission is produced .
if measurements are available at several wavebands , it is possible to plot @xmath14 as a function of the bands peak temperatures .
generalizing this logic into a differential form , and assuming that the element abundances are constant , equation ( [ eq_1 ] ) can be reformulated as @xmath16 where @xmath17 is the dem , that provides a measure of the amount of emitting plasma as a function of temperature ) .
the dem can also be defined in linear scale as @xmath18 .
there is a factor @xmath19 between the two conventions . ] .
as demonstrated by @xcite , @xmath20 is the mean square electron density over the regions @xmath21 of the los at temperature @xmath5 , weighted by the inverse of the temperature gradients in these regions . the total emission measure ( em )
is obtained by integrating the dem over the temperature @xmath22 solving the dem integral equation ( [ eq_3 ] ) implies reversing the image acquisition , los integration and photon emission processes to derive the distribution of temperature in the solar corona from observed spectral line intensities
. we will now investigate the properties of this inversion .
let us consider a plasma characterized by a dem @xmath23 .
the corresponding intensities observed in @xmath24 spectral bands are noted @xmath25 . in order to solve the dem inverse problem - estimating @xmath26 from the observations -
one uses a criterion @xmath27 that defines the distance between the data @xmath28 and the theoretical intensities @xmath29 computed using equations ( [ eq_2 ] ) and ( [ eq_3 ] ) for any dem @xmath30 . by definition
the dem @xmath31 solution of the inversion is the one that minimizes this criterion : @xmath32 since the @xmath28 are affected by measurement noises and the @xmath33 by systematic errors in the calibration and atomic physics , the inversion can yield different solutions @xmath34 of probabilities @xmath35 for a given dem @xmath26 of the plasma .
bayes theorem then gives @xmath36 which is the conditional probability that the plasma has a dem @xmath26 knowing the result @xmath34 of the inversion .
@xmath37 is the total probability of obtaining @xmath34 whatever @xmath26 . in the bayesian framework
, @xmath38 is called the _
prior_. it is uniformly distributed if there is no _ a priori _ information on the dem @xmath26 of the plasma .
conversely , _ a priori _ knowledge or assumptions on the plasma are represented by a varying @xmath38 .
for example , zero probabilities can be assigned to non physical solutions .
@xmath39 contains all the information that can be obtained from a given set of measurements on the real dem @xmath26 of the plasma and as such , it is a desirable quantity to evaluate . indeed ,
if the dem is to be used to discriminate between physical models , as it is for example the case in the coronal heating debate , finding a solution that minimizes the criterion is necessary , but it is not sufficient .
it is also crucial to be able to determine if other solutions are consistent with the uncertainties , what are their respective probabilities , and how much they differ from each other . in principle , and without _ a priori _ on the plasma , @xmath35 and thus @xmath39 can be estimated for any minimization scheme using monte - carlo simulations @xcite . for each @xmath26 ,
the @xmath24 observed @xmath25 are simulated using equations ( [ eq_2 ] ) and ( [ eq_3 ] ) and adding photon and instrumental noises .
systematic errors are incorporated to the @xmath33 and the resulting criterion is minimized .
@xmath35 is then evaluated from the @xmath40 solutions @xmath34 corresponding to @xmath40 realizations of the random variables .
but since several @xmath26 can potentially yield the same @xmath34 , the derivation of @xmath39 from equation ( [ eq_6 ] ) requires to know @xmath41 , the probability to obtain @xmath34 whatever @xmath26 .
this is generally not possible , for it requires the exploration of an infinite number of plasma dems .
this is why dem inversion research often focuses on the minimization part of the problem , @xmath39 being supposed to be well behaved because of the proper choice of _ prior _ and the multiplication of passbands or spectral lines .
however , @xmath39 can be computed if the dem @xmath26 of the plasma can be described by a limited number of parameters . in this case
, one can scan the whole parameter space and use the monte - carlo simulations to estimate @xmath35 for all possible @xmath26 .
the possibility that multiple @xmath26 yield an identical inversion solution @xmath34 being now taken into account , one can determine @xmath41 and thus derive @xmath39 from equation ( [ eq_6 ] ) .
this limitation of the complexity of the dems that can be considered corresponds to adopting a non - uniform _ prior _ @xmath38 , while probabilistic treatments were justly developed with the opposite objective of relaxing such non - physical assumptions ( e.g. the mcmc method of * ? ? ?
but rather than the development of a generic dem inversion method , our objective is to study the behaviour of @xmath39 in controlled experiments . and
if the parameterization is properly chosen , the @xmath26 can still represent a variety of plasma conditions , from isothermal to broadly multithermal .
in addition , we did not make any assumption on the number and properties of the spectral bands , nor on the definition of the criterion nor on the algorithm used to minimize it .
the method described to compute @xmath39 can therefore be used to characterize any inversion scheme in the range of physical conditions covered by the chosen @xmath26 distributions .
devising an efficient way to locate the absolute minimum of the criterion is not trivial .
for example , without further assumption , its definition alone does not guarantee that it has a single minimum , so that iterative algorithms may converge to different local minima depending on the initial guess solution .
furthermore , if the value of the minimum itself is a measure of the goodness of fit , it does not provide information on the robustness of the solution .
how well the solution is constrained is instead related to the topography of the minimum and its surroundings ; the minimum may be deep or shallow and wide or narrow with respect to the different parameters describing the dem curve .
the number of dems resulting in significantly different sets of intensities within the dynamic range of an instrument is potentially extremely large .
however , a systematic mapping of the criterion aimed at revealing its minima and their topography is possible if the search is restricted to a subclass of all possible dem forms . indeed ,
if the dem is fully determined by a limited number of parameters , one can regularly sample the parameter space and compute once and for all the corresponding theoretical intensities @xmath29 .
the criterion , i.e. the distance between the @xmath33 and the measured @xmath28 , is thus computable as a function of the dem parameters for any given set of observations .
it is then trivial to find its absolute minimum and the corresponding dem solution @xmath34 , or to visualize it as a function of the dem parameters .
the procedure used to compute @xmath39 is summarized in figure [ fig : method ] .
the parametric dem forms are described in section [ sec : dem_models ] .
the intensities @xmath28 observed in @xmath24 bands are the sum of average intensities @xmath42 and random perturbations @xmath43 due to photon shot noise and measurement errors @xmath44 the @xmath42 are equal to the theoretical intensities @xmath33 in the case of a hypothetically perfect knowledge of the instrument calibration and atomic physics . in practice however , the @xmath33 are affected by systematic errors @xmath45 @xmath46 since there is no way of knowing whether the intensities that can be computed from equations ( [ eq_2 ] ) and ( [ eq_3 ] ) for any dem @xmath47 are overestimated or underestimated , we identify them , in which case we obtain the @xmath42 by adding systematic errors .
the only difference between the two conventions is the sign of @xmath45 .
the criterion and therefore the results are identical in both cases . ] to the reference theoretical intensities @xmath42 .
the distributions of random and systematic errors are discussed in section [ sec : uncertainties ] .
the detail of the calculation of the @xmath42 is given in section [ sec : theoretical_intensities ] .
from these , we can either simulate observations @xmath28 by adding measurement noises @xmath43 ( equation ( [ eq : iobs ] ) ) , or obtain various estimates of the @xmath33 by adding perturbations representing the systematics @xmath45 ( equation ( [ eq : ith ] ) ) .
the criterion @xmath27 and the corresponding minimization scheme are described in section [ sec : criterion ] . for any plasma dem @xmath26 , monte - carlo realizations of the noises
@xmath43 and systematics @xmath45 yield several estimates @xmath34 , from which we compute @xmath35 .
finally , @xmath39 is obtained after scanning all possible plasma dems ( section [ sec : monte - carlo ] ) .
ensuing the discussions of sections [ sub_sec_2_2 ] and [ sub_sec_2_3 ] , the @xmath26 and @xmath34 are both constrained to belong to one of the three following classes of dem distributions defined by two or three parameters : * isothermal @xmath48 where the dem is reduced to a dirac @xmath49 function centred on the temperature @xmath50 .
@xmath51 is the total emission measure defined by equation ( [ eq_4 ] ) .
* gaussian in @xmath0 @xmath52 the plasma is here predominantly distributed around a central temperature @xmath50 with a width @xmath53 . * top hat in @xmath0 @xmath54 the plasma
is uniformly distributed over a width @xmath53 around @xmath50 .
there is no reason for the solar plasma to follow one of these distributions , nor are they the only possible choices .
but even though they are simple enough to allow a detailed analysis of the properties of the dem inversion , they can nonetheless represent a variety of plasma conditions .
the conclusions drawn can therefore help understand the behaviour of more generic dem forms .
furthermore , since the class of solution dems @xmath34 does not have to be the same as that of the plasma dems @xmath26 , it is possible to investigate the impact of a wrong assumption on the shape of the dem .
for example , one can compute @xmath39 for isothermal solutions @xmath34 while the plasma dem @xmath26 is multithermal ( see paper ii ) .
equations ( [ eq_2 ] ) and ( [ eq_3 ] ) are used to compute the reference theoretical intensities @xmath55 for any dem @xmath47 .
they are then used to form both simulated observations and various estimates of the theoretical intensities with equations ( [ eq : iobs ] ) and ( [ eq : ith ] ) . from equations ( [ eq : dem_iso ] ) , ( [ eq : dem_gauss ] ) and ( [ eq : dem_hat ] ) , we derive the expressions of these reference intensities as a function of the parameters @xmath51 , @xmath50 and @xmath53 for the three types of dem distributions . *
isothermal @xmath56 * gaussian @xmath57 * top hat @xmath58 we note that in all cases , the reference theoretical intensities are equal to the convolution product of the instrument response function @xmath59 by the chosen dem @xmath30
. the @xmath42 are pre - computed for all possible combinations of parameters @xmath51 , @xmath50 , and @xmath53 .
the appropriate range and resolution to be used for each parameter can be determined from plausible plasma properties and taking into account the instrument characteristics .
the responses @xmath59 of the six aia coronal bands are computed using equation ( [ eq_2 ] ) .
the contribution functions @xmath60 are obtained using the version 7.0 of the chianti atomic database @xcite .
we used the chianti ionization balance and the extended coronal abundances .
the summation is extended over the 5 nm to 50 nm spectral range for all bands .
the instrument sensitivity @xmath10 is obtained as a function of wavelength in units of @xmath61 by calling the function ` aia_get_response ` provided in the aia branch of the interactive data language ( idl ) _ solar software _
( ssw ) package with the ` /dn ` , ` /area ` and ` /full ` keywords .
this function implements the aia pre - flight calibration as described in @xcite .
since photon shot noise must be taken into account in the error budget ( section [ sec : uncertainties ] ) , the @xmath55 must be computed for given exposure times and not per second .
we used the standard aia exposures of 2 s for the 17.1 nm and 19.3 nm bands , and 2.9 s for the others .
the contribution functions are computed using chianti from @xmath62 to @xmath63 in steps of @xmath64 , oversampling the chianti grid by a factor 10 using cubic spline interpolations .
the emission measure varies over a wide range from @xmath65 to @xmath66 in steps of @xmath67 .
the dem width varies linearly in 80 steps from @xmath68 to @xmath69 .
this choice of sampling leads to pre - computing @xmath70 groups of 6 aia intensities , which represents easily manageable data cubes .
uncertainties due to random and systematic errors are at the heart of the problem of the dem inversion .
the two affect the observations and their interpretation in different manners ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
observations are mostly affected by random errors caused by both poisson photon shot noise and nearly gaussian detection noises like thermal and read noise .
these noises vary randomly from pixel to pixel and from exposure to exposure . on the other hand ,
the errors made on the calibration and atomic physics systematically skew the interpretation of all observed intensities by the same amount and in the same direction .
it is possible to realistically simulate in the @xmath28 the statistical properties of the noises affecting the data .
the reference intensities @xmath42 have units of digital numbers ( dn ) .
the number of electrons collected in each pixel over the exposure time is obtained by multiplying these values by the gains ( in @xmath71 ) of the detectors analog to digital converters listed in ssw .
the number of detected photons is then obtained by dividing the result by the quantum yield of the detector , _ i.e. _ the number of photoelectrons produced per interacting photon where 3.65 is the energy in ev required to create an electron hole pair , @xmath72 is the elementary charge , @xmath73 is the speed of light in vacuum and @xmath74 is planck s constant .
note that in this calculation we assume that all interacting photons have the same wavelength .
however , since the full width at half maximum of the aia bands is comprised between 0.2 and 1.0 nm , the error made is only a few @xmath75 . ] .
these photon intensities are then perturbed by poisson noise and converted back to photoelectrons .
22 @xmath76 rms of gaussian ccd read noise @xcite are finally added before conversion to dn .
determining the statistical properties of the systematic errors is more challenging .
the tabulated calibration and atomic physics provides a single estimate of the instrument response @xmath77 , but systematics nonetheless have a probability distribution .
indeed , the calibration is the result of laboratory measurements themselves affected by random and systematic errors .
if we could recalibrate the instrument a number of times in different facilities we would obtain a distribution of instrumental sensitivities @xmath10 , the adopted calibration corresponding to one of them .
likewise , different atomic physics codes will give different estimates of the contribution functions @xmath78 , the chianti output being one of them .
it is however difficult to characterize these two probability distributions .
they are generally implicitly assumed to be gaussian and the adopted values to be the most probable .
but the distributions may in fact be uniform , or asymmetric , or biased , _
etc_. the calibration involves a complex chain of measurements , the uncertainties of which are difficult to track and estimate .
after independent radiometric calibrations , comparable euv instruments on soho were found to agree only within about 25% @xcite .
subsequent comparisons could not resolve the discrepancies nor identify their origin in random errors or biases in the individual calibrations .
we can only say that the adopted calibration of every soho instrument introduces a systematic error in the data analysis but without being able to tell how much and in what direction .
it is likely that inter - calibration between aia and other instruments would run into similar limitations .
errors in the contribution functions are a major contributor to the uncertainties ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . since the properties of the known atomic transitions are derived either from measurements or modelling , they are not infinitely accurate .
missing transitions lead to underestimated contributions functions , as it is the case for the 9.4 nm channel of aia ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the abundances are affected by about 10% uncertainties @xcite , not taking into account possible local enhancements of high fip elements @xcite .
these imply that , at least in some cases , the abundances are not constant along the line of sight , as assumed in the dem analysis
. the plasma may not be in ionization balance , in which case the chianti calculations of transition rates are not valid .
the response functions @xmath77 of aia are also not independent from the electron number density , which is one of the assumptions made in deriving the dem expression from equations ( [ eq_1 ] ) to ( [ eq_3 ] ) . when using spectrometers , the spectral lines are chosen so that this hypothesis is effectively verified .
we plot in figure [ fig : g - vs - n ] the normalized maximum of @xmath79 versus electron number density . in the aia field of view
, @xmath4 can vary from about @xmath80 in coronal holes at @xmath81 ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) to about @xmath82 in dense coronal loops ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) . in this range ,
only the 9.4 nm band ( solid line ) is completely independent on the density .
the response function of all other bands decreases as the density increases , the variation reaching about 35% for the 17.1 nm band ( short dashed line ) .
since the contribution functions have to be computed for a constant electron number density ( we chose @xmath83 ) , they are respectively under or over - estimated if the observed structures are more or less dense .
the impact can be mitigated if one has independent knowledge of the range of densities on the los , but it nonetheless represents an additional source of uncertainty compared to using density insensitive spectral lines .
finally , these various sources of uncertainties do not affect all spectral bands by the same amount . rigorously estimating the properties of the probability distributions of the systematic errors would thus require a detailed analysis of the calibration process and of the atomic physics data and models that is beyond the scope of this paper .
in these conditions , we make the simplifying assumption that all systematics are gaussian distributed and unbiased . according to @xcite , uncertainties on the pre - flight instrument calibration are of the order of 25% .
this is thus interpreted as a gaussian probability distribution centred on the tabulated values with a 25% standard deviation .
likewise , we used 25% uncertainty on the atomic physics for all bands , typical of the estimates found in the literature .
calibration and atomic physics uncertainties were added quadratically for a net 35% uncertainty on the response functions @xmath77 .
the @xmath33 are thus obtained by adding gaussian random perturbations to the @xmath42 . since
instrumental noises and systematic errors are assumed to be gaussian distributed , we use a least square criterion @xmath84 normalized to the total standard deviation @xmath85 of the uncertainties in each band .
@xmath85 is obtained by summing quadratically the standard deviations of the four individual contributions : photon noise , read noise , calibration and atomic physics ( section [ sec : uncertainties ] ) .
the value of the minimum of @xmath27 corresponding to the solution @xmath34 is noted @xmath86 from equations ( [ eq : ith ] ) and ( [ eq : iobs ] ) we get @xmath87 if the family of solutions ( dirac , gaussian or top hat ) is identical to that of the plasma dem @xmath26 , then in the absence of noise @xmath88 and the solution @xmath34 given by equation ( [ eq_5 ] ) is strictly equal to @xmath26 .
however , in the presence of random and systematic errors or if the assumed dem form differs from that of the observed plasma , @xmath89 is not likely to be zero and the corresponding @xmath34 may be different from @xmath26 , for random fluctuations of @xmath43 and @xmath45 can compensate a difference between @xmath90 and @xmath91 . as discussed in section [ sec : fit_test ] , properly interpreting the value of @xmath89 provides a means of testing the pertinence of a given dem model .
folding equation ( [ eq : ith_iso ] ) , ( [ eq : ith_gauss ] ) or ( [ eq : ith_hat ] ) into equation ( [ eq : criterion ] ) , we obtain the expression of @xmath27 for the corresponding dem distributions .
given a set of observed intensities and a dem model , the criterion can therefore be easily computed for all possible combinations of the parameters @xmath51 , @xmath50 , and @xmath53 using the @xmath55 tabulated as described in section [ sec : theoretical_intensities ] .
finding its minimum and thus the solution @xmath34 is simplified to the location of the minimum of the @xmath27 matrix .
this minimization scheme is not fast compared to , e.g. , iterative gradient algorithms , but it ensures that the absolute minimum of the criterion is found whatever its topography .
furthermore , this operation can be efficiently implemented on the graphics processing units ( gpu ) of modern graphics cards by using their cuda capability .
we implemented a scheme in which each gpu core is in charge of computing an element of the @xmath27 matrix , with all gpu cores running in parallel .
the search of the minimum of @xmath27 is also performed by the gpu , thus reducing the transfers between gpu to cpu to the values of @xmath89 and @xmath34 .
restricting @xmath26 and @xmath34 to belong to one of the dem classes described in section [ sec : dem_models ] , @xmath35 and @xmath39 are evaluated from monte - carlo simulations . for every combination of the two or three parameters defining @xmath26 ( the ranges and resolutions being given in [ sec : dem_models ] ) , 5000 independent realizations of the random and systematic errors are obtained . for each of the corresponding sets of six simulated aia intensities , the inversion code returns the values of the parameters defining @xmath34 ( equation ( [ eq_5 ] ) ) corresponding to the absolute minimum of the criterion ( equation ( [ eq : criterion ] ) ) . from the resulting 5000 @xmath34
we estimate the conditional probability @xmath35 with a resolution defined by the sampling of the parameters .
integration over @xmath26 gives @xmath41 and using bayes theorem we obtain @xmath39 .
in order to understand the fundamental properties of the dem inversion of the aia data , we first applied the method to investigate the behaviour of the isothermal solutions to simulations of isothermal plasmas . the electron temperatures and emission measures of the plasmas are noted @xmath92 and @xmath93 respectively .
the corresponding inverted quantities are noted @xmath94 and @xmath95 .
the probabilities @xmath96 and @xmath97 are stored in matrices of dimension 4 . to maximize the clarity of the results , and since the thermal content of the plasma is the main object of dem analysis , we reduce the number of dimensions by fixing the emission measure of the simulated plasmas to be @xmath98 .
furthermore , the probabilities are always presented whatever the emission measure by integrating them over @xmath95 , even though @xmath95 is of course solved for in the inversion process .
the chosen @xmath93 is typical of non flaring active regions ( e.g. * ? ? ?
figure [ fig : valid_bands_iso ] shows as a function of @xmath92 and @xmath93 the number of aia bands in which a plasma produces more than 1 dn ( detection threshold ) and less than 11000 dn ( saturation ) .
the left panel is for isothermal plasmas , the right panel for gaussian dems with @xmath99 . at the chosen @xmath93 , and
since we did not implement the detector saturation in our simulations , we always have exploitable signal in all six aia coronal bands , except below a few @xmath100 k. conversely , solar structures outside the white areas produce signal only in some of the six bands , unless spatial or temporal summation is used .
therefore , the results presented in the following sections correspond to optimum conditions outside of which the combination of higher noise and possible lower number of valid bands will always lead to weaker constraints on the dem .
we first present inversion results using only three bands as an illustration of the situation encountered with previous euv imaging telescopes like eit , trace or euvi .
the 17.1 nm and 19.5 nm coronal passbands of eit and trace have direct equivalents in aia , but the 28.4 nm band does not .
after comparison of its isothermal response ( see , e.g. , figure 9 of * ? ? ? * ) with those of aia ( figure [ fig : aia_iso_response ] ) , we chose the 21.1 nm band as its closest aia counterpart .
the three bands configuration is also similar to having six bands and a low emission measure plasma . indeed , at @xmath101 and @xmath102 k
, values typical of coronal loops , only three of the six aia coronal bands produce more than 1 dn ( see figure [ fig : valid_bands_iso ] ) , the others providing only upper limit constraints to the dem .
panel ( a ) of figure [ fig:3bands ] shows a map of the probability and @xmath103 . ]
it is worth noting that , as explained in section [ sub_sec_2_2 ] , @xmath105 and thus @xmath106 could be evaluated only because the limitation to simple parameterized dem forms allowed the computation of @xmath104 .
the plot of @xmath105 ( and thus the horizontal structures in panel ( a ) ) shows that some temperature solutions @xmath94 are more probable than others for any plasma temperature @xmath92 . in the case of real observations ,
this can be misinterpreted as the ubiquitous presence of plasma at the most likely temperatures .
this caveat was already analysed by @xcite in the case of the 19.5 to 17.3 nm trace band ratio and we will discuss it further in paper ii for multithermal plasmas . both probability maps exhibit a diagonal from which several branches bifurcate .
below @xmath107 k and above @xmath70 k the diagonal disappears because since the bands have little sensitivity in these regions , the signal is dominated by noises and the inversion output is thus independent from the temperature . the general symmetry with respect to the diagonal reflects the equality @xmath108 .
the diagonal is formed by the solutions @xmath94 that are close to the input @xmath92 , while the branches correspond to significant deviations from the input . in @xmath104 ,
these branches imply that two or more solutions @xmath94 can be found for a same plasma temperature @xmath92 .
conversely , reading horizontally the @xmath106 image , a given temperature solution @xmath94 can be coherent with two or more plasma temperatures @xmath92 .
the ( b ) and ( c ) plots give the probability of the solutions for two plasma temperatures . at @xmath109
k , the solution may be @xmath110 k or @xmath111 k. at the typical coronal temperature @xmath112 k , the inversion can yield @xmath102 k but also @xmath107 k or @xmath70 k. it is thus possible to incorrectly conclude to the presence of cool or hot coronal plasma while observing an average million degree corona .
this ambiguity has far reaching implications since the detection of hot plasma is one of the possible signatures of nano - flares ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) .
since by definition they correspond to the absolute minimum of the criterion , all solutions are fully consistent with the data given the uncertainties .
one or more of the multiple solutions can be rejected only based on additional independent _ a priori _ information .
for example , the high temperature solution corresponds to an emission measure of @xmath113 ( right panel of figure [ fig : criterion ] ) , which is extremely high considering the present knowledge of the corona .
if no such information is available however , both low and high temperature solutions can still be correctly interpreted as also compatible with a @xmath102 k plasma with the aid of the @xmath114 and @xmath115 probability profiles ( f ) and ( g ) .
the reason for the formation of these branches is illustrated by figure [ fig : criterion ] . on both panels , the background image is the value of the criterion @xmath27 for a @xmath112 k plasma as a function of @xmath50 and @xmath51 .
the absolute minimum of the criterion , the arguments of which are the inverted parameters @xmath94 and @xmath95 ( equation ( [ eq_5 ] ) ) , corresponds to the darkest shade of grey and is marked by a white plus sign .
the criterion is the sum of three components , one per waveband ( equations ( [ eq : criterion ] ) and ( [ eq : criterion_dev ] ) ) .
the three superimposed curves are the loci emission measure curves for each band @xmath1 , i.e. the location of the ( @xmath50 , @xmath51 ) pairs for which the theoretical intensities @xmath33 equal the measured ones @xmath28 . below the loci curves ,
the criterion is almost flat because at lower emission measures the @xmath33 are much smaller than the constant @xmath28 .
conversely , the criterion is dominated by the @xmath116 at high emission measures .
the darkest shades of gray and thus the minimum of the criterion are located between these two regions .
the two panels correspond to two independent realizations of the random and systematic errors .
for each draw , the loci curves are randomly shifted along the @xmath51 axis around their average position . in the absence of errors , the three loci curves would cross in a single point at the plasma temperature @xmath92 , giving a criterion strictly equal to zero . in the left panel , with random and systematic errors
included , they do not intersect at a single point but the non - zero absolute minimum of @xmath117 , where they are the closest together , is around @xmath92 . however , the criterion has two other local minima , around @xmath107 k and around @xmath70 k , where two or three of the loci curves also bundle up . in the right panel , a different random draw shifts the curves closest together around the high temperature local minimum that thus becomes the new absolute minimum . for this @xmath102
k plasma , the inversion thus yields solutions randomly located around the several local minima with respective probabilities given by the profile of figure [ fig:3bands](c ) .
when scanning the plasma temperatures , the positions of the minima vary , thus building the branches in the probability maps . in addition , depending on their location the minima can be more or less extended along one or the other axes , which results in a varying dispersion around the most probable solutions .
systematic errors are simulated with random variables while they are in fact identical for all measurements .
thus , the computed @xmath118 does not give the probability of solutions @xmath94 for the practical estimates of the calibration and atomic physics .
in reality the output of the inversion is biased towards one or the other of the multiple solutions , but we do not know whether the calibration and atomic physics are under or over - estimated . therefore , in order to deduce the probability that the plasma has a temperature @xmath92 from an inverted temperature @xmath94 , we must account for the probabilities of the systematics as defined in section [ sec : uncertainties ] .
the randomization samples their distribution , which ensures that the estimated @xmath119 are the probabilities relevant to interpret @xmath94 .
figure [ fig:6bands ] is the same as figure [ fig:3bands ] , but now including the six aia coronal bands in the analysis .
some secondary solutions persist at low probabilities but compared to the three bands case , most of the solutions are now concentrated on the diagonal .
this illustrates that the robustness of the inversion process increases with the number of bands or spectral lines .
comparison with figure [ fig:3bands ] quantifies the improvement brought by aia over previous instruments . neglecting the low probability solutions ,
if independent _ a priori _ knowledge justifies the isothermal hypothesis , the six aia bands thus provide an unambiguous determination of the plasma temperature .
the temperature resolution of the inversion can be estimated from the width at half maximum of the diagonal .
it varies over the temperature range between 0.03 and 0.11 @xmath120 .
it is of course be modified if we assumed different uncertainties on the calibration and atomic physics than the ones chosen in section [ sec : uncertainties ] .
we tested the sensitivity of the temperature resolution to the level of uncertainties @xmath85 , from 10 to 55% .
the higher the uncertainties , the lower the temperature resolution and the more probable the secondary solutions . for an estimated temperature @xmath94 of 1 mk
, the temperature resolution of the inversion varies between 0.02 for 10% error and 0.08 @xmath120 for 55% error . in the worst case , for 55% errors , the temperature resolution decreases to @xmath121 for the temperature interval between 0.5 and 0.9 mk . at 1 mk ,
the resolution is proportional to the uncertainty level with a coefficient of 0.15 ( @xmath122 ) .
since by definition our method always finds the absolute minimum of the least square criterion of equation ( [ eq : criterion ] ) , the derived temperature resolution is an intrinsic property of the data and not of the inversion scheme .
it is the result of the combination of the random and systematic errors and the shapes the contribution functions .
its value is directly comparable with the findings of @xcite .
these authors showed that the temperature resolution of the mcmc code of @xcite applied to isothermal plasmas is 0.05 log @xmath123 .
their tests were made on simulated observations of a @xmath124 k plasma in 45 isolated spectral lines with 20% random errors .
assuming that the mcmc method does converge towards solutions consistent with the limitations of the data , the fact that the temperature resolution is comparable for 6 aia bands and 45 spectral lines suggests that , in the isothermal case , it is driven by the uncertainties level rather than the number of observables .
this conclusion is consistent with the isothermal limit of figure 6 of @xcite .
the probability maps presented in the above sections are valid for a given hypothesis on the plasma dem distribution , but they would be useless without a test of its validity .
the pertinence of the dem model chosen to interpret the observations can be assessed by analyzing the distribution of the sum of squared residuals defined by equations ( [ eq : criterion ] ) and ( [ eq : chi2 ] ) . if applying our inversion scheme to real data , we could compare the resulting residuals to the distribution derived from simulations for a given dem model and thus quantify the probability that the data is consistent with the working hypothesis ( e.g. isothermal or gaussian ) .
the solid line histogram of figure [ fig : chi2_iso ] shows the distribution of @xmath89 values corresponding to the plots of figure [ fig:6bands ] .
the distribution is close to a degree 4 @xmath89 distribution ( solid curve ) although not a perfect match , with a peak shifted to the left and an enhanced wing .
the most probable value of the squared residuals is @xmath125 and @xmath126% of them are comprised between 0 and 15 .
whatever the actual plasma dem , any inversion made with the isothermal hypothesis and yielding a @xmath89 value in this range can thus be considered consistent with an isothermal plasma given the uncertainties .
this isothermality test is similar to that recommended by @xcite , identifying our @xmath89 to their @xmath127 and our maximum acceptable @xmath89 to their @xmath128 .
this does not imply however that isothermality is the only nor the best possible interpretation of the data , for different dems can produce similar @xmath89 values .
the discrimination between dem models will be discussed in paper ii .
the properties of the empirical distribution of squared residuals can be explained as follows . since we simulated observations of a purely isothermal plasma
, an isothermal model can always represent the data .
without errors , there would always be one unique couple ( @xmath94 , @xmath95 ) corresponding to six intensities perfectly matching the six aia observations , thus giving zero residuals . with errors ,
if we forced the solution ( @xmath94 , @xmath95 ) to be the input ( @xmath92 , @xmath93 ) , the summed squared residuals resulting from a number of random draws should have by definition the probability density function ( pdf ) of a degree six @xmath89 distribution ( dotted curve of figure [ fig : chi2_iso ] ) , for we have six independent values of @xmath129 and we normalized the residuals to the standard deviation @xmath85 of the uncertainties .
but since we solve for two parameters ( @xmath94 , @xmath95 ) by performing a least squares minimization at each realization of the errors , the solution is not exactly the input ( @xmath92 , @xmath93 ) and we should expect a pdf with two degrees of freedom less ( dashed curve ) . instead of being a pure degree 4 , the observed distribution
is slightly shifted toward a degree 3 because of two factors .
first , the errors are a combination of poisson photon noise and gaussian read noise , while the @xmath89 distribution is defined for standard normal random variables .
second , as discussed below , the six residuals are not completely independent .
figure [ fig : aia_iso_response ] shows the response functions @xmath59 of the aia bands to isothermal plasmas with electron temperatures from @xmath100 to @xmath130 k for a constant electron number density of @xmath83 . for each band ,
the thick curve is the total response , and the labeled thin curves are the partial responses for the ions that contribute the most for at least one temperature . the fraction of the total response not accounted for by those dominant ions is shown below each main plot .
ionization stages common to several bands are found across the whole range of temperatures .
dominates the response at @xmath131 k in the 17.1 nm , 19.3 nm and 21.1 nm bands . around 1 mk ,
is found in the 17.1 nm , 19.3 nm and 21.1 nm responses , and contributes to the 94 nm , 21.1 nm and 33.5 nm bands . at 2 mk , is common to the 21.1 nm and 33.5 nm bands .
this is consistent with the analysis of the aia bands by @xcite .
because of this redundancy , the response functions tend to have similar shapes in the regions of overlap , resulting in a correlation between the residuals .
by restricting the solutions to functional forms described by a limited number of parameters , we obtained a complete statistical characterization of the dem inversion . even though they are not expected to accurately describe real coronal properties
, these simple dem distributions can nonetheless model a wide range of plasma conditions .
the results presented in this series of papers can thus be fruitfully used to demonstrate many important properties and guide the interpretation of the output of generic dem inversion codes .
we illustrated the method by applying it to the six coronal bands of the aia telescope .
in this first paper , we limited ourselves to isothermal plasmas and isothermal solutions .
the case presented in section [ sec:3bands ] demonstrates the existence of multiple solutions if the number of bands is limited either by design of the instrument or by lack of signal .
however , since our method provides the respective probabilities of the multiple solutions , it is possible to properly interpret the solutions as compatible with several plasma temperatures . even if some of these properties have been illustrated in case studies , we provide here a systematic analysis of a wide range of plasma parameters .
the computed distribution of squared residuals can be used to test the coherence of real aia data with the isothermal hypothesis .
this type of analysis can also be help to determine the optimum data acquisition parameters for aia ( e.g. spatial binning and exposure time ) ensuring that no secondary solution is present . in section [ sec:6bands ]
, we showed that , with enough signal , the six aia coronal bands provide a robust reconstruction of isothermal plasmas with a temperature resolution comprised between 0.03 and 0.11 @xmath0 .
the comparison with the three bands case gives a quantification of the improvement brought by the new generation of instruments .
the same method can be applied to other instruments with different response functions and different numbers of bands or spectral lines .
this naturally requires the computation of the corresponding probability matrices and distribution of residuals .
the temperature resolution , and more generally the details of the probability matrices presented in sections [ sec:3bands ] and [ sec:6bands ] , depend on the amplitude and distribution of the random and systematic errors .
we found the resolution to be proportional to the uncertainty level ( at 1 mk , @xmath122 ) .
we simulated plasmas with high emission measures typical of active regions . depending on the temperature , either the photon noise or the uncertainties on the calibration and atomic physics dominate .
the illustrated properties of the inversion , from the multiplicity of solutions to the temperature resolution , are thus driven by both random systematic errors . while the photon noise can be reduced by increasing the exposure time or binning the data , reducing the systematics
requires better atomic data and photometric calibration , which is not trivial .
s.p . acknowledges the support from the belgian federal science policy office through the international cooperation programmes and the esa - prodex programme and the support of the institut dastrophysique spatiale ( ias ) .
f.a . acknowledges the support of the royal observatory of belgium .
the authors would like to thank j. klimchuk for fruitful discussions and comments .
aschwanden , m. j. , & nightingale , r. w. 2005 , , 633 , 499 aschwanden , m. j. , & boerner , p. 2011
, , 732 , 81 asplund , m. , grevesse , n. , sauval , a. j. , & scott , p. 2009
, , 47 , 4816 boerner , p. , edwards , c. , lemen , j. , et al .
2012 , sol .
phys . , 275(1 - 2 ) , 41 brown , j. c. , dwivedi , b. n. , sweet , p. a. , & almleaky , y. m. 1991 , , 249 , 277 brosius , j. w. , rabin , d. m. , thomas , r. j. , & landi , e. 2008 , , 677 , 781 cargill , p. j. 1994 , , 422 , 381 craig , i. j. d. , & brown , j. c. 1976 , , 49 , 239 craig , i. j. d. , & brown , j. c. 1986 , inverse problems in astronomy : a guide to inversion strategies for remotely sensed data , research supported by serc .
bristol , england and boston , ma , adam hilger , ltd .
del zanna , g. , & mason , h. e. 2003 , , 406 , 1089 del zanna , g. , bromage , b. j. i. , & mason , h. e. 2003 , , 398 , 743 delaboudinire , j .- p . ,
artzner , g. e. , brunaud , j. , et al .
1995 , , 162 , 291 dere , k. p. 1978 , 70 , 439 dere , k. p. , landi , e. , mason , h. e. , monsignori fossi , b. c. , & young , p. r. 1997 , , 125 , 149 dere , k. p. , landi , e. , young , p. r. , et al .
2009 , , 498(3 ) , 915 fludra , a. , & sylwester , j. 1986 , , 105 , 323 foster , a. r. , & testa , p. 2011
, , 740(2 ) , l52 guhathakurta , m. , fludra , a. , gibson , s. e. , biesecker , d. , & fisher , r. r. 1999 , , 104(a5 ) , 9801 golub , l. , deluca , e. , austin , g. et al .
2007 , , 243 , 63 goryaev , f. f. , parenti , s. , urnov , a. m. , et al .
2010 , , 523 , a44 hahn , m. , landi , e. , & savin , d. w. 2011 , , 736 , 101 handy , b. n. , acton , l. w. , kankelborg , c. c. , et al . 1999 , , 187 , 229 hannah , i. g. , & kontar , e. p. 2012
, , 539 , a146 huber , m. c. e. , pauhluhn , a. , & von steiger ,
r. 2002 , esa sp , 508 , 213 jefferies , j. t. , orrall , f. q. , & zirker , j. b. 1972 , , 22 , 307 jordan , c. 1976 , royal society of london philosophical transactions series a , 281 , 391 judge , p. g. , hubeny , v. , & brown , j. c. 1997 , , 475 , 275 kashyap , v. , & drake , j. j. 1998 , , 503 , 450 klimchuk , j. a. 2006 , , 234 , 41 landi , e. , & landini , m. 1997 , , 327 , 1230 landi , e. , & landini , m. 1998 , , 340 , 265 landi , e. , & klimchuk , j. a. 2010 , , 723 , 320 landi , e. , reale , f. , & testa , p. 2012
, , 538 , a111 lang , j. , mcwhirter , r. w. p. , & mason , h. e. 1990 , , 129 , 31 lemen , j. r. , title , a. m. , akin , d. j. , et al .
2012 , , 275(1 - 2 ) , 17 mason , h. e. , & monsignori fossi , b. c. 1994 , , 6 , 123 martinez - sykora , j. , de pontieu , b. , testa , p. , & hansteen , v. 2011 , , 743(1 ) , 23 metropolis , n. , & ulam , s. 1949 , journal of the american statistical association , 44(247 ) , 335 mcintosh , s. w. 2000 , , 533 , 1043 odwyer , b. , del zanna , g. , mason , h. e. , weber , m. a. , & tripathi , d. 2010 , , 521 , a21 odwyer , b. , del zanna , g. , badnell , n. r. , mason , h. e. , & storey , p. j. 2011 , , 537 , a22 parenti , s. , bromage , b. j. i. , poletto , g. , et al .
2000 , , 363 , 800 parenti , s. , & vial , j .- c .
2007 , , 469 , 1109 pottasch , s. r. 1963 , , 137 , 945 pottasch , s. r. 1964 , , 3 , 816 reale , f. 2002 , , 580(1 ) , 566 reale , f. , testa , p. , klimchuk , j. , & parenti , s. 2009 , , 698 , 756 reale , f. 2010 , living rev . in sol .
sanz - forcada , j. , brickhouse , n. s. , & dupree , a. k. 2003 , , 145 , 147 schmelz , j. t. , nasraoui , k. , rightmire , l. a. , et al .
2009 , , 691 , 503 susino , r. , lanzafame , a. c. , lanza , a. f. , & spadaro , d. 2010 , , 709 , 499 taylor , j. 1997 , published by university science books , 648 broadway , suite 902 , new york , ny 10012 testa , p. , de pontieu , b. , martinez - sykora , j. , hansteen , v. , & carlsson , m. 2012 , arxiv:1208.4286 warren , h. p. , & brooks , d. h. 2009 , , 700 , 762 warren , h. p. , brooks , d. h. & winebarger , a. r. 2011 , , 734(2 ) , 90 weber , m. a. , deluca , e. e. , golub , l. , & sette , a. l. 2004 , in iau symposium , vol .
223 , multi - wavelength investigations of solar activity , ed .
a. v. stepanov , e. e. benevolenskaya , & a. g. kosovichev , 321 weber , m. a. , schmelz , j. t. , deluca , e. e. , & roames j. k. 2005 , , 635 , l101 winebarger , a. r. , schmelz , j. t. , warren , h. p. , saar , s. h. , & kashyap , v. l. 2011 , , 740 , 2 wiik , j. e. , dere , k. , & schmieder , b. 1993 , , 273 , 267 withbroe , g. l. 1975 , , 45 , 301 young , p. r. 2005 , , 439 , 361 | dem analysis is a major diagnostic tool for stellar atmospheres . but both its derivation and its interpretation are notably difficult because of random and systematic errors , and the inverse nature of the problem .
we use simulations with simple thermal distributions to investigate the inversion properties of sdo / aia observations of the solar corona .
this allows a systematic exploration of the parameter space and using a statistical approach , the respective probabilities of all the dems compatible with the uncertainties can be computed . following this methodology ,
several important properties of the dem inversion , including new limitations , can be derived and presented in a very synthetic fashion . in this first paper
, we describe the formalism and we focus on isothermal plasmas , as building blocks to understand the more complex dems studied in the second paper .
the behavior of the inversion of aia data being thus quantified , and we provide new tools to properly interpret the dem .
we quantify the improvement of the isothermal inversion with 6 aia bands compared to previous euv imagers .
the maximum temperature resolution of aia is found to be 0.03 @xmath0 , and we derive a rigorous test to quantify the compatibility of observations with the isothermal hypothesis .
however we demonstrate limitations in the ability of aia alone to distinguish different physical conditions . |
the method of very long baseline interferometry ( vlbi ) first proposed by @xcite allows us to derive source positions with nanoradian precision ( 1 nrad @xmath1 0.2 mas ) . since 1971
when the first catalogue of source coordinates determined with vlbi was published @xcite , the number of extragalactic compact radio sources which positions were derived using vlbi under absolute astrometry observing programs grew from 35 objects to 7215 in 2012 . for 95% these sources , accuracies of their positions are in a range of 0.05 to 6.5 mas with the median 0.5 mas .
these sources form a dense grid on the sky that can be used for many applications , such as differential astrometry , phase - referencing vlbi observations of weak objects , space navigation , earth orientation parameter determination , and space geodesy .
however , high accuracy of positions of these objects can be exploited _ directly _ only by applications that utilize the vlbi technique .
applications that use different observational techniques can benefit from the high accuracy of vlbi positions only _ indirectly _ by observing common objects from the vlbi catalogue with instruments at other wavelengths .
the european space agency space - born astrometry mission _ gaia _ , scheduled to be launched in 2013 , according to @xcite promises to reach sub - mas accuracies of determining positions of quasars of 1620 magnitude that will rival accuracies of absolute astrometry vlbi . since position catalogues produced with _ gaia _ and vlbi will be completely independent , their mutual rotations , zonal differences and possibly other systematic effects can be interpreted as errors of one of the techniques after resolving the differences due to a misalignment of centers of optic and radio images of quasars and a frequency - dependent core - shift @xcite .
investigation of systematic differences will be very important for the assessment of the overall quality of _ gaia_results and , possibly , the errors in the vlbi position catalogue .
this comparison will produce valuable results if 1 ) it will be limited to those common sources which vlbi positions are known with errors smaller than several tenths of a milliarcsecond ; 2 ) the number of sources will be large enough to derive meaningful statistics ; and 3 ) the sources will be uniformly distributed over the sky .
however , the number of quasars that have a compact core and are bright in both optical and radio wavelengths , and therefore , can be detected with both techniques , currently is rather limited .
the observing program for densification of the list of such objects was launched in 2006 @xcite with the eventual goal of deriving highly accurate position of sufficiently radio - loud quasars from vlbi observations in the absolute astrometry mode .
the original observing sample consisted of 447 optically bright , relatively weak extragalactic radio sources with declinations above @xmath2 .
the detailed observing scheme of this project is presented in @xcite .
the first vlbi observing campaign in 2007 resulted in detection of 398 targets with the european vlbi network ( evn ) @xcite , although no attempt to derive their positions or produce images was made . during the second observing campaign a subset of 105 sources detected in the previous campaign
was observed with the global vlbi network that comprises the vlba and evn observing stations with the goal of revealing their morphology on milliarcsecond scales from vlbi images @xcite for consecutive screening the objects with structure that potentially may cause non - negligible systematic position errors .
their positions were derived by @xcite and formed the obrs1 catalogue . in 20102011 remaining 290 sources
have been observed in the third campaign , hereafter called obrs-2 , with the global network that comprises the vlba and evn observing stations in a mode similar to the second campaign .
i present here results of data analysis of this observations . observations and their analysis are described in sections [ s : obs ] and [ s : anal ] .
the position catalogue is presented in section [ s : cat ] and discussed in section [ s : discussion ] .
concluding remarks are given in section [ s : summ ] .
during obrs2 campaign there were three observing sessions with 10 vlba stations and 56 evn stations from this list : eflsberg , medicina , onsala60 , yebes40 m , dss63 , hartrao , noto .
first four evn stations participated in every experiment , three remaining stations participated in some experiments .
each program source was observed in one session , in 34 scans , each 5 minutes long .
two sources , 1148@xmath3387 and 1203@xmath3109 , were observed in two sessions in 5 scans .
in addition to 290 program sources , 8 strong calibrators were observed .
.summary of observing sessions [ cols= " < , < , < , > " , ] the positions of 295 sources observed in obrs2 experiment are listed in table [ t : cat ] .
the 1st and 2nd columns provide the ivs source name ( b1950 notation ) and iau name ( j2000 notation ) .
the 3rd and 4th columns give source coordinates at the equinox on the j2000 epoch .
columns 5 and 6 give reweighted source position uncertainties in right ascension and declination in mas ( without @xmath4 factor ) , and column 7 gives the correlation coefficient between the errors in right ascension and declination .
column 8 shows band i d of the solution that was used to derive position of a given source .
the number of group delays used in analysis is listed in columns 9 and 10 .
columns 11 and 12 provide the median value of the correlated flux density in jansky at s band at baseline projection lengths shorter than 900 km and at baseline projection lengths longer than 5000 km .
the latter estimate serves as a measure of the correlated flux density of an unresolved source component .
columns 13 and 14 provide the median of the correlated flux density at x band at baselines shorter than 900 km and longer than 5000 km .
if no information about correlated flux density is available , @xmath5 is used as a placeholder .
the last two columns have flags whether an image is available for s and x bands : `` m '' if available , blank if not .
the semi - major axes of error ellipses range from 2.1 to 200 mas , with the median 3.2 mas , and for 80% sources the position errors are under 5.2 mas .
the major factor that results in position uncertainty exceeding 5 mas is a lack of detections at long baselines .
sources with large position uncertainties are either highly resolved or very weak moderately resolved objects . *
0154@xmath331a/0154@xmath331b * has two components @xmath6 apart .
component a is compact and was detected at 5 mjy level at x band at intercontinental baselines with effelsberg .
it was not detected at intercontinental baselines at s band . since the sensitivity of baselines with effelsberg is a factor of 45 worse at s band than at x band ,
this can be explained if a source has a spectral index steeper than @xmath7 ( @xmath8 ) .
component b is stronger at s band , but has only three detections at 5 mjy level at x band at short baselines only .
cross - matching against wide - field infrared survey explorer ( wise ) infra - red catalogue of point sources @xcite revealed wise [email protected] object with magnitude 13.9 at 3.6 @xmath9 within @xmath10 of 0154@xmath331a . *
0809@xmath3483/0809@xmath348b/0809@xmath348c * has three components within @xmath11 . components b and c coincide with extended radio - lobes visible at the vla image ( figure [ f : j0813 + 4813 ] ) . compact component a that has x - band flux density 5 mjy at intercontinental baselines is located between radio lobes .
wise [email protected] with magnitude 13.5 at 3.6 @xmath9 was found within @xmath12 of component a. 483/0809@xmath348b/0809@xmath348c vla image at 4.86 ghz on epoch 1995.10.15 with beam size @xmath13 , project as561 , is shown as a contour map .
vlbi positions are shown with filled circles .
component a is the most compact and has flux density 5 mjy at intercontinental baselines .
components b and c are resolved and visible only at short baselines .
, scaledwidth=40.0% ] * 1323@xmath365a/1323@xmath365b * has two components with separation @xmath14 .
although component b is 5 times stronger at x band at the vla image ( figure [ f : j1325 + 6515 ] ) than component a 21 mjy versus 4 mjy , it is not detected at vlba scale at x band .
component a with correlated flux density 4 mjy at intercontinental baselines lies within @xmath15 of wise [email protected] which has magnitude 14.6 at 3.6 @xmath9 .
65a/1323@xmath365b vla image at 8.4 ghz on epoch 1999.08.08 with beam fwhm @xmath16 , project ar415 , is shown as a contour map .
although component b is stronger at the vla image , it is resolved out at x band at vlba resolution .
component a has flux density 27 mjy at both bands .
, scaledwidth=48.0% ] * 1335@xmath1706a/1335@xmath1706b * has two components @xmath18 apart .
component b , associated with a radiolobe ( figure [ f : j1338 - 0627 ] ) was detected at s band only .
compact component a with flux density 7 mjy at x band is within of @xmath19 of wise [email protected] , which has magnitude 13.9 at 3.6 @xmath9 .
65a/1323@xmath365b at the vla image at 1.4 ghz on epoch 2001.04.29 with beam size @xmath20 , project ab950 ( first ) , is shown as a contour map .
component b was detected in obrs2 only at s band .
, scaledwidth=40.0% ] * 1340@xmath360a/1340@xmath360b * has two components separated at @xmath21 .
the source looks elongated at the vla image at 1.4 ghz ( figure [ f : j1340 + 6021 ] ) .
component b was detected at s band only .
component a is within @xmath22 of wise [email protected] which has magnitude 14.2 at 3.6 @xmath9 .
60a/1340@xmath360b vla image at 1.4 ghz on epoch 2002.02.07 with beam size @xmath23 , project ab950 ( first ) , is shown as a contour map .
component b was detected only at s band .
, scaledwidth=40.0% ]
position accuracy , 25 mas for 80% obrs2 sources , is too coarse to make a meaningful comparison with _ gaia _ because the frequency setup was not favorable for precise absolute astrometry .
cross - referencing the cumulative catalogue of radio sources detected with vlbi in the absolute astrometry mode at 8 ghz against the optical catalogue of active galaxy nuclea , including quasars , of @xcite , i found that 1676 objects , or 23% , have a counterpart within a @xmath24 search radius .
of them , 825 objects are brighter v @xmath25 mag . of them ,
377 , or 46% , were observed in obrs1 or obrs2 programs , and 293 of them were observed only in these two programs .
five obrs2 sources , 0012@xmath3305 , 0232@xmath17042 , 0744@xmath3092 , 1146@xmath3249 , 1632@xmath3198 have position offsets with respect to the optical catalogue of quasars of @xcite exceeding @xmath24 . since their offsets with respect to wise catalogue are in a range of @xmath26@xmath27 , i consider that their positions in the optical catalogue had an error .
figure [ f : v_flux ] shows the dependence of the correlated flux density versus v magnitude for the entire sample of radio - optic associations and for the sub - sample observed in the obrs1 and obrs2 programs .
there is no sign of obvious correlation between optical brightness and radio brightness .
we see that the obrs1/obrs2 sources are systematically weaker than those observed in other programs .
of 400 sources detected in obrs1 and obrs2 , only 148 have an unresolved component at x band stronger than 30 mjy , while the total number of radio sources associated with quasars brighter v @xmath25 mag and with unresolved component stronger than 30 mjy is 683 .
if a source is too weak at long baselines , the position uncertainty 0.1 mas will not be achieved for a reasonable integration time because of the thermal noise .
the median semi - major axis of the position error ellipse of obrs1/obrs2 sources without reweighting is 2.2 mas .
the frequency sequence used in these observing programs results in a group delay uncertainty at a given snr that is a factor of 11.2 greater than the group delay uncertainty of regular geodetic observations under rdv program .
even if obrs programs were observed with the same frequency sequence as rdv experiments , the median position uncertainty due to the thermal noise would have been 0.2 mas .
therefore , future observations for improving source positions associated with optically bright quasars should be focused on observing compact radio sources with a strong unresolved core . _
the majority _ of such objects were detected in program _ other _ than obrs1/obrs2 .
therefore , program obrs can be considered as partially successful . observing sources known as weak from the evn detection survey @xcite
was not warranted for the goal of the project .
selection of a frequency sequence that is unfavorable for astrometry degraded position accuracy by one order of magnitude but did not bring any merit .
the vlbi catalogue is complete only to flux densities 180 mjy @xcite .
figure [ f : v_flux ] suggests there may exist other strong radio sources associated with optically bright quasars .
systematic surveys targeted to sources with correlated flux densities at long baselines in a range of 50180 mjy promise to reveal new radio loud quasars . if to observe each target source for 2 minutes at 512 mbit / s at x / s in two scans each at the vlba , @xmath28 sources with correlated flux densities down to 25 mjy could be observed for 242 hours allotted for obrs1 , obrs2 , and the evn detection survey .
this approach is an alternative to the strategy adopted for obrs project .
analysis of the second dual - band s / x vlba campaign of the program for observing optically bright extragalactic radio sources allowed me to determine positions of 295 target sources and make images of 285 of them . because of using the frequency setup unfavorable for absolute astrometry , the position uncertainties ranged from 2 to 200 mas with the median value of 3.2 mas .
many these sources are suitable as phase calibrators .
this position accuracy is sufficient for using these sources as phase calibrators , but not sufficient for drawing meaningful conclusions from comparison of _ gaia _ and vlbi positions .
approximately 1/3 of observed sources have strong unresolved core and their positions can be determined with accuracies better than 0.1 mas in future vlbi observing programs with appropriate frequency setup . the national radio astronomy observatory is a facility of the national science foundation operated under cooperative agreement by associated universities , inc .
this publication makes use of data products from the wide - field infrared survey explorer , which is a joint project of the university of california , and the jpl / california institute of technology , funded by the nasa . | it is anticipated that future space - born missions , such as _ gaia _ , will be able to determine in optical domain positions of more than 100 , 000 bright quasars with sub - mas accuracies that are comparable to very long baseline interferometry ( vlbi ) accuracies . comparisons of coordinate systems from space - born missions and from vlbi will be very important , first for investigation of possible systematic errors , second for investigation of possible shift between centroids of radio and optical emissions in active galaxy nuclea . in order to make such a comparison more robust , a program of densification of the grid of radio sources detectable with both vlbi and _ gaia _ was launched in 2006 . in the second observing campaign a set of 290 objects from the list of 398 compact extragalactic radio sources with declinations @xmath0 was observed with the vlba+evn in 20102011 with the primary goal of producing their images with milliarcsecond resolution .
these sources are brighter than 18 magnitude at v band . in this paper
coordinates of observed sources have been derived with milliarcsecond accuracies from analysis of these vlbi observations following the method of absolute astrometry and their images were produced .
the catalogue of positions of 295 target sources and estimates of their correlated flux densities at 2.2 and 8.4 ghz is presented .
the accuracies of source coordinates are in a range of 2 to 200 mas , with the median 3.2 mas . |
one of the main phenomenological attractions of using d - branes is that they permit a `` bottom - up '' approach to constructing the standard model from type ii string theory .
open strings that begin and end on a stack @xmath6 of @xmath12 d - branes generate the gauge bosons of a ( supersymmetric ) @xmath13 gauge theory living in the world volume of the d - branes . in the original bottom - up models
@xcite a stack of d3-branes is placed at an orbifold @xmath14 singularity and the standard model gauge group ( possibly augmented by additional @xmath15 factors ) is obtained by choosing a suitable embedding @xmath16 of the action of the generator @xmath17 of the orbifold point group @xmath18 on the chan - paton indices of the d3-branes . besides the gauge bosons , fermionic matter also survives the orbifold projection .
so long as only d3-branes are retained , the fermion spectrum generally makes the non - abelian gauge symmetries anomalous , reflecting the fact that a general collection of d3-branes has uncancelled ramond - ramond ( rr ) tadpoles .
the required cancellation is achieved by introducing d7-branes , which generate further gauge symmetries , and additional fermions . when all tadpoles are cancelled , so are the gauge anomalies .
however , we showed in an earlier paper @xcite that all such models , whether utilising fixed points on an orbifold or an orientifold , have electroweak higgs content that is non - minimal , both for the ( non - supersymmetric ) standard model or its supersymmetric extension , the mssm . as a consequence
there is a generic flavour changing neutral current ( fcnc ) problem in such models , and we conclude that such models are not realistic .
( see , however , @xcite , which argues that a supersymmetric , standard - like model with three higgs doublets , derived from compactifying the @xmath19 heterotic string on a @xmath20 orbifold , _ can _ circumvent the fcnc problem without an excessively heavy higgs sector . ) an alternative approach that also uses d - branes is `` intersecting brane '' model building @xcite . in these models
one starts with two stacks , @xmath6 and @xmath7 with @xmath21 and @xmath22 , of d4- , d5- or d6-branes wrapping the three large spatial dimensions plus respectively 1- , 2- and 3-cycles of the six - dimensional internal space ( typically a torus @xmath23 or a calabi - yau 3-fold ) on which the theory is compactified .
these generate the gauge group @xmath24 , and the non - abelian component of the standard model gauge group is immediately assured .
further , ( four - dimensional ) fermions in bifundamental representations @xmath25 of the gauge group can arise at the multiple intersections of the two stacks .
these are precisely the representations needed for the quark doublets @xmath26 of the standard model .
for d4- and d5-branes , to get _ chiral _ fermions the stacks must be at a singular point of the transverse space .
in general , intersecting branes yield a non - supersymmetric spectrum , so that , to avoid the hierarchy problem , the string scale associated with such models must be low , no more than a few tev . then
, the high energy ( planck ) scale associated with gravitation does not emerge naturally .
nevertheless , it seems that these problems can be surmounted @xcite , and indeed an attractive model having just the spectrum of the standard model has been constructed @xcite .
it uses d6-branes that wrap 3-cycles of an orientifold @xmath27 , where @xmath28 is the world - sheet parity operator . the advantage and , indeed
, the necessity of using an orientifold stems from the fact that for every stack @xmath29 there is an orientifold image @xmath30 . at intersections of @xmath6 and @xmath7
there are chiral fermions in the @xmath31 representation of @xmath32 , where the @xmath33 has charge @xmath34 with respect to the @xmath35 in @xmath36 , and the @xmath37 has charge @xmath38 with respect to the @xmath39 in @xmath40 .
however , at intersections of @xmath6 and @xmath9 there are chiral fermions in the @xmath41 representation , where the @xmath42 has @xmath39 charge @xmath43 . in the model of @xcite ,
the number of intersections @xmath5 of the stack @xmath6 with @xmath7 is 2 , and the number of intersections @xmath8 of the stack @xmath6 with @xmath9 is 1 .
thus , as required for the , there are 3 quark doublets .
these have net @xmath35 charge @xmath44 , and net @xmath39 charge @xmath45 .
tadpole cancellation requires that overall both charges , sum to zero , so further fermions are essential , and indeed required by the .
6 quark - singlet states @xmath46 and @xmath47 belonging to the @xmath48 representation of @xmath49 , having a total of @xmath50 are sufficient to ensure overall cancellation of @xmath51 , and these arise from the intersections of @xmath6 with other stacks @xmath52 having just a single d6-brane .
similarly , 3 lepton doublets @xmath53 , belonging to the @xmath54 representation of @xmath55 , having a total @xmath39 charge of @xmath56 , are sufficient to ensure overall cancellation of @xmath57 , and these arise from the intersections of @xmath7 with other stacks having just a single d6-brane .
in contrast , had we not used an orientifold , the requirement of 3 quark doublets would necessitate having the number of intersections @xmath58 .
this makes no difference to the charge @xmath44 carried by the quark doublets , but instead the @xmath39 charge carried by the quark doublets is @xmath59 , which can not be cancelled by just 3 lepton doublets @xmath53 .
consequently , additional vector - like fermions are unavoidable unless the orientifold projection is available .
this is why the orientifold is essential if we are to get just the matter content of the or of the mssm .
actually , an orientifold can allow the standard - model spectrum without vector - like matter even when @xmath58 and @xmath60 @xcite .
this is because in orientifold models it is also possible to get chiral matter in the symmetric and/or antisymmetric representation of the relevant gauge group from open strings stretched between a stack and its orientifold image .
both representations have charge @xmath61 with respect to the relevant @xmath15 .
the antisymmetric ( singlet ) representation of @xmath62 can describe a lepton single state @xmath63 , and 3 copies contribute @xmath64 units of @xmath39 charge .
if there are also 3 lepton doublets @xmath53 belonging to the bifundamental representation @xmath54 representation of @xmath55 , each contributing @xmath65 as above , then the total contribution is @xmath66 which * can * be cancelled by 3 quark doublets @xmath26 in the @xmath31 representation of @xmath32 .
thus , as asserted , orientifold models can allow just the standard - model spectrum even when @xmath67 . despite the attractiveness of the model in @xcite
, there remain serious problems in the absence of supersymmetry .
a generic feature of intersecting brane models is that flavour changing neutral currents are generated by four - fermion operators induced by string instantons @xcite .
the severe experimental limits on these processes require that the string scale is rather high , of order @xmath68 tev .
this makes the fine tuning problem very severe , and the viability of such models highly questionable .
further , in non - supersymmetric theories , such as these , the cancellation of rr tadpoles does not ensure neveu schwarz - neveu schwarz ( nsns ) tadpole cancellation .
nsns tadpoles are simply the first derivative of the scalar potential with respect to the scalar fields , specifically the complex structure and khler moduli and the dilaton .
a non - vanishing derivative of the scalar potential signifies that such scalar fields are not even solutions of the equations of motion .
thus a particular consequence of the non - cancellation is that the complex structure moduli are unstable @xcite .
one way to stabilise these moduli is for the d - branes to wrap an orbifold @xmath69 rather than a torus @xmath23 .
the fcnc problem can be solved and the complex structure moduli stabilised when the theory is supersymmetric .
first , a supersymmetric theory is not obliged to have the low string scale that led to problematic fcncs induced by string instantons .
second , in a supersymmetric theory , rr tadpole cancellation ensures cancellation of the nsns tadpoles @xcite .
an orientifold is then constructed by quotienting the orbifold with the world - sheet parity operator @xmath28 .
( as explained above , an orientifold is necessary to allow the possibility of obtaining just the spectrum of the supersymmetric standard model . )
several attempts to construct the mssm using d6-branes and a @xmath70 , @xmath71@xmath72 or @xmath73 orientifold have been made @xcite .
the most successful attempt to date is the last of these @xcite , which uses d6-branes intersecting on a @xmath73 orientifold to construct an @xmath74 supersymmetric standard - like model using 5 stacks of branes .
we shall not discuss this beautiful model in any detail except to note that the intersection numbers for the stacks @xmath6 , which generates the @xmath3 group , and @xmath7 , which generates the @xmath4 , are @xmath75 . in this case
it is impossible to obtain lepton singlet states @xmath63 as antisymmetric representations of @xmath62 .
further , it was shown , quite generally , that it is impossible to find stacks @xmath6 and @xmath7 such that @xmath76 or @xmath77 .
thus , as explained above , it is impossible to obtain exactly the ( supersymmetric ) spectrum .
the question then arises as to whether the use of a different orientifold could circumvent this problem . in this paper
we address this question for the @xmath1 orientifold .
we do not attempt to construct a standard(-like ) mssm .
instead , we merely see whether there are any stacks @xmath2 that simultaneously satisfy the supersymmetry constraints , the absence of chiral matter in symmetric representations of the gauge groups ( see below ) , which have not too much chiral matter in antisymmetric representations of the gauge groups ( see below ) , and which have @xmath76 or @xmath77 .
we do not pursue the alternative that @xmath78 or @xmath79 , since such models , with 3 lepton singlet states arising on the @xmath62 stack , do not have the standard - model couplings of these states to the higgs multiplet .
with @xmath80 we explained above why @xmath81 is sufficient to ensure that no vector - like matter is necessary to ensure that the net @xmath39 charge @xmath57 is zero , and the same is obviously the true if @xmath82 ; it amounts to interchanging @xmath7 and @xmath9 .
intersection numbers @xmath83 or @xmath84 are equally acceptable , since negative intersection numbers correspond to opposite chiralities .
thus @xmath85 , where underlining signifies any permutation , is sufficient . for calculational purposes
it is convenient to let _ either _ stack @xmath6 or @xmath7 generate the @xmath3 gauge group , so that @xmath86
. interchanging @xmath6 and @xmath7 gives @xmath87 .
thus the intersection numbers are generally required to satisfy @xmath88 . if @xmath89 and @xmath90 have the same sign , then @xmath21 and @xmath22 ; otherwise @xmath91 and @xmath92 . in what follows we parallel quite closely the treatment @xcite of honecker & ott for the @xmath73 orientifold .
we assume , as is customary , that the torus @xmath23 factorises into three 2-tori @xmath93 .
the three 2-tori @xmath94 are parametrised by three complex coordinates @xmath95 .
the action of the generator @xmath17 of the point group @xmath96 on the coordinates @xmath97 is given by z_k = e^2i v_k z_k where ( v_1,v_2,v_3)= ( 1,2,-3 ) for _ 6 [ z61vk ] to calculate the number of independent bulk 3-cycles we need the betti number @xmath98 which is the dimension of the third homology group @xmath99 of the space . because of the duality of the homology and cohomology groups we can as well compute the number of independent invariant 3-forms .
then b_3=b^3=_p+q=3 b^p , q where @xmath100 is the number of independent invariant @xmath101 forms , _ i.e._with @xmath102 holomorphic and @xmath103 anti - holomorphic variables . for @xmath96 ,
the invariant forms are @xmath104 , @xmath105 and their complex conjugates , so @xmath106 and @xmath107 .
hence , the untwisted sector contributes b^(0)_3(t^6/ _ 6)=4 [ b3z6prime ] to the betti number .
the point group action must be an automorphism of the lattice , so in @xmath108 we may take an @xmath109 lattice .
specifically we define the basis 1-cycles in @xmath108 by @xmath110 and @xmath111 in @xmath112 and @xmath113 and @xmath114 in @xmath115 .
the orientation of @xmath116 relative to the real and imaginary axes of @xmath117 is arbitrary .
since @xmath118 acts as a reflection in @xmath119 the lattice , with basis 1-cycles @xmath120 and @xmath121 , is arbitrary .
the point group action on the basis 1-cycles is then _ 1 = _ 2 & and & _ 2 = _
2-_1 [ theta12 ] + _ 3 = _
4 -_3 & and & _ 4 = -_3 [ theta34 ] + _ 5=-_5 & and & _ 6 = -_6 [ thetaz6 ] now we construct a basis of invariant 3-cycles . with @xmath122 where @xmath123 we define the @xmath1 invariant 3-cycle _ 1 & & ( 1 + + ^2 + ^3 + ^4 + ^5 ) _
1,3,5 + & = & 2(1 + + ^2 ) _ 1,3,5 + & = & 2(_1,3,5 + _ 2,3,5 + _ 1,4,5 - 2 _ 2,4,5 ) [ rho1 ] in the same way
_ 2 & & 2(1 + + ^2 ) _ 2,3,5 + & = & 2(-_1,3,5 + 2_2,3,5 + 2_1,4,5 - _ 2,4,5 ) and _ 3 & & 2(1
+ + ^2 ) _ 2,4,5 + & = & 2(-2_1,3,5 + _ 2,3,5 + _ 1,4,5 + _ 2,4,5 ) [ rho3 ] + & = & _ 2-_1 similarly , replacing @xmath124 , we get _ 4 & = & 2(_1,3,6 + _ 2,3,6 + _ 1,4,6 - 2 _ 2,4,6 ) [ rho4 ] + _ 5&=&2(-_1,3,6 + 2_2,3,6 + 2_1,4,6 - _ 2,4,6 ) + _ 6&=&2(-2_1,3,6 + _ 2,3,6 + _ 1,4,6 + _ 2,4,6 ) [ rho6 ] + & = & _ 5-_4 thus we can use the four cycles @xmath125 as the basis of the ( untwisted ) bulk 3-cycles , incidentally verifying ( [ b3z6prime ] ) .
the most general invariant bulk 3-cycle is
2(1 + + ^2 ) + = a_1_1 + a_3 _ 3 + a_4_4 + a_6 _ 6 [ genbulk ] where @xmath126 are the ( coprime ) wrapping numbers on the @xmath127th torus , and a_1= ( n_1n_2+n_1m_2 + m_1n_2)n_3 [ a1 ] + a_3= ( m_1m_2+n_1m_2 + m_1n_2)n_3 + a_4= ( n_1n_2+n_1m_2 + m_1n_2)m_3 + a_6= ( m_1m_2+n_1m_2 + m_1n_2)m_3 [ a6 ] the intersection number is defined as _
a _ b ( _ i=0 ^ 5 ^i _ a ) ( _ j=0 ^ 5 ^j _ b ) [ piaopib ] which gives _ 1 _ 3=&0&= _ 4 _ 6 + _ 1 _ 4=-4 , & & _ 1 _ 6=2 + _ 3 _ 4=2 , & & _ 3 _ 6=-4 in general , if @xmath128 has wrapping numbers @xmath129 @xmath130 , and @xmath131 has wrapping numbers @xmath132 , then the intersection number of the orbifold - invariant 3-cycles @xmath133 and @xmath134 generated from @xmath128 and @xmath131 is _ a _ b = -4(a^a_1a^b_4&-&a^a_4a^b_1)+ 2(a^a_1a^b_6-a^a_6a^b_1 ) + 2(a^a_3a^b_4-a^a_4a^b_3 ) - + & -&4(a^a_3a^b_6-a^a_6a^b_3 ) f(a^a_p , a^b_p ) [ pia0pib ] which is always even . here
@xmath135 relate to @xmath136 and are given by ( [ a1 ] ) - ( [ a6 ] ) with the wrapping numbers @xmath129 , and similarly for the @xmath137 which relate to @xmath134 . besides the ( untwisted ) bulk 3-cycles discussed above , there are also exceptional 3-cycles associated with ( some of ) the twisted sectors of the orbifold .
they arise in twisted sectors in which there is a fixed torus , and consist of a collapsed 2-cycle at a fixed point times a 1-cycle in the invariant plane . for the @xmath1
orbifold the @xmath138 and @xmath139 twisted sectors leave @xmath119 invariant , and the @xmath140 twisted sector leaves @xmath115 invariant . in the @xmath138 and @xmath139 twisted sectors ,
there is a @xmath20 symmetry which has nine fixed points at e_i , j ( e_1+e_2 ) ( e_3+e_4 ) where @xmath141 , @xmath142 and @xmath143 are the basis lattice vectors in @xmath112 , and @xmath144 and @xmath145 are the basis lattice vectors in @xmath115 .
the @xmath146 generator @xmath17 acts on the fixed points as ( e_1+e_2)=-(e_1+e_2 ) + ( e_3+e_4)=(e_3+e_4 ) exceptional cycles in these sectors have the form @xmath147 .
the action of the point group is given by e_i , j ( n_3 _ 5+m_3 _ 6 ) & & e_i , j ( n_3 _ 5+m_3 _ 6 ) + & = & e_-i , j ( -n_3 _ 5-m_3 _ 6 ) thus there are six invariant 3-cycles in each @xmath148 twisted sector . as a basis
we may choose ^(n ) _ j ( e^(n)_1,j - e^(n)_2,j ) _ 5 , ^(n ) _ j ( e^(n)_1,j - e^(n)_2,j ) _ 6 ( j=0,1,2 ) [ etaj ] where @xmath149 is the collapsed 2-cycle at the fixed point @xmath150 in the @xmath151 twisted sector .
the intersection numbers of these 2-cycles may be computed by blowing up the @xmath20 singularities @xcite .
this yields an intersection matrix which is the cartan matrix @xmath152 of the lie algebra of @xmath153 .
then , using the intersection numbers of the 1-cycles on @xmath119 , we find that ^(m)_j ^(n)_k = -_jk a_(2)^mn [ etaj0k ] where _
( 2)= ( rr 2 & -1 + -1 & 2 ) exceptional cycles also occur in the @xmath140 sector .
there is a @xmath154 symmetry acting in @xmath112 and @xmath119 and this has sixteen fixed points at f_i , j ( _ 1 e_1 + _
2e_2 ) ( _ 1 e_5 + _
2e_6 ) [ fij ] where @xmath155 , and , using the notation of reference @xcite , @xmath156 correspond to the pairs @xmath157 or @xmath158 1 ~(0,0 ) , 4 ~(1,0 ) , 5 ~(0,1 ) , 6 ~(1,1 ) [ 1456 ] the @xmath146 generator @xmath17 acts on the fixed points as ( _ 1e_1+_2e_2)&= & + ( _ 1e_5+_2e_6)&=&-(_1e_5+_2e_6)=(_1e_5+_2e_6 ) so f_1,j = f_1,j , f_4,j = f_5,j [ f14j ] + f_5,j = f_6,j , f_6,j = f_4,j [ f56j ] the exceptional cycles are then @xmath159 . using ( [ theta34 ] ) we construct the orbifold invariant exceptional 3-cycles : ( 1++^2 ) f_1,j _ 3 & = & 0 = ( 1++^2 ) f_1,j _ 4 + ( 1++^2 ) f_6,j _ 3 & = & ( f_6,j - f_4,j )
_ 3 + ( f_4,j - f_5,j ) _ 4 _ j [ epsj ] + ( 1++^2 ) f_4,j _ 3 & = & ( f_4,j - f_5,j ) _ 3 + ( f_5,j - f_6,j ) _ 4 _ j [ epstilj ] + ( 1++^2 ) f_5,j _ 3 & = & ( f_5,j - f_6,j ) _ 3 + ( f_6,j - f_4,j ) _ 4 + & = & -_j - _ j it is easy to see that @xmath160 generate the same orbifold invariants , so there are just eight independent orbifold - invariant exceptional 3-cycles @xmath161 and @xmath162 . the non - zero intersection numbers for the invariant combinations ( [ epsj ] ) and ( [ epstilj ] ) are given by _ j
_ k=-2 _ jk [ eps0jk ] using the self - intersection number of @xmath163 for an exceptional 2-cycle at the @xmath154 fixed point @xmath164 and the intersection numbers of the 1-cycles on @xmath115 .
the relation between fixed points and exceptional cycles is shown in table [ fpex ] . .
[ fpex ] relation between fixed points and exceptional 3-cycles .
[ cols="^,^",options="header " , ] the factor of 12 that appears in the function @xmath165 in table [ latfnfg ] for this lattice too again ensures that any solution is guaranteed to have no antisymmetric ( or symmetric ) matter on either stack . again
@xmath5 and @xmath8 have opposite sign in all solutions , so that @xmath92 and the gauge particles of @xmath166 live on @xmath7 .
the supersymmetry constraint requires that the complex structure @xmath167 , so that @xmath119 is an @xmath109 lattice in this case . as for the * abb * lattice ,
the first and third pair of solutions are distinct since the exceptional parts of @xmath6 differ .
we have shown that , unlike the @xmath73 orientifold , the @xmath1 orientifold _ can _ support supersymmetric stacks @xmath6 and @xmath7 of d6-branes with intersection numbers satisfying @xmath76 or @xmath77 .
stacks having this property are an indispensable ingredient in any intersecting brane model that has _ just _ the matter content of the ( supersymmetric ) standard model .
the number of branes , @xmath168 in stacks @xmath2 is required to be @xmath80 or @xmath169 so as to produce the gauge groups @xmath166 and @xmath62 from which the qcd @xmath3 and the electroweak @xmath4 gauge fields emerge . by construction , in all of our solutions there is no matter in symmetric representations of the gauge groups on either stack .
however , some of the solutions _ do _ have matter , quark singlets @xmath170 or lepton singlets @xmath63 , in the antisymmetric representation of gauge group on one of the stacks .
this is not possible on the @xmath73 orientifold because all supersymmetric d6-branes wrap the same bulk 3-cycle as the o6-planes , from which it follows that @xmath171 .
then , requiring the absence of symmetric matter necessarily entails the absence of antisymmetric matter too .
in contrast , on the @xmath1 orientifold there exist supersymmetric 3-cycles that do not wrap the o6-planes .
thus , there is more latitude in this case , and the solutions with antisymmetric matter exploit this feature .
unfortunately , however , none of the solutions of this nature that we have found can be enlarged to give just the standard - model spectrum , since the overall cancellation of the relevant @xmath15 charge can not be achieved with just this matter content .
nevertheless , some of our solutions have no antisymmetric ( or symmetric ) matter on either stack .
we shall attempt in a future work to construct a realistic ( supersymmetric ) standard model using one of our solutions .
the presence of singlet matter on the branes in some , but not all , of our solutions is an important feature of our results .
it is clear that different orbifold point groups produce different physics , as indeed , for the reasons just given , our results also illustrate .
the point group must act as an automorphism of the lattice used , but it is less clear that realising a given point group symmetry on different lattices produces different physics .
our results indicate that different lattices may produce different physics , since , for example , the solutions with no antisymmetric ( or symmetric ) matter on either stack occur only on the * abb * and * bbb * lattices , and we understand why any acceptable solutions without symmetric matter must also lack antisymmetric matter .
the observation that the lattice does affect the physics suggests that other lattices are worth investigating in both the @xmath73 and @xmath1 orientifolds . in particular
, since @xmath172 can be realised on a @xmath173 lattice , as well as on an @xmath109 lattice , one or more of all three @xmath109 lattices in the @xmath73 case , and of the two on @xmath108 in the @xmath174 case , could be replaced by a @xmath173 lattice .
we shall explore this avenue too in future work
. the construction of a realistic model will , of course , entail adding further stacks of d6-branes @xmath175 , with just a single brane in each stack , arranging that the matter content is just that of the supersymmetric standard model , the whole set satisfying ( one of ) the conditions ( [ rrbulkaaa]) ... ([rrbulkbbb ] ) and the corresponding condition in ( [ rrexaaa]) ... ([rrexbbb ] ) for rr tadpole cancellation . in a supersymmetric orientifold rr tadpole cancellation
ensures that nsns tadpoles are also cancelled , but some moduli , ( some of ) of the complex structure moduli , the khler moduli and the dilaton , remain unstabilised .
recent developments have shown how such moduli may be stabilised using rr , nsns and metric fluxes @xcite , and indeed cmara , font & ibez @xcite have shown how models similar to the ones we have been discussing can be uplifted into ones with stabilised khler moduli using a `` rigid corset '' . in general ,
such fluxes contribute to tadpole cancellation conditions and might make them easier to satisfy .
in contrast , the rigid corset can be added to any rr tadpole - free assembly of d6-branes in order to stabilise all moduli .
thus our results represent an important first step to obtaining a supersymmetric standard model from intersecting branes with all moduli stabilised .
we are grateful to gabriele honecker for helpful correspondence and informative discussions , and especially for pointing out the error in the first version of this paper concerning the intersection numbers for exceptional cycles in the @xmath176 and @xmath139 twisted sectors .
we thank also the referee for pointing out that the intersection numbers @xmath177 allow the standard model spectrum when antisymmetric representations of @xmath62 are present , and also for suggesting several other helpful clarifications .
this work was funded in part by pparc .
as in [ 11 ] , the fixed points involved are @xmath180 and @xmath181 or @xmath182 ( 45)(16 ) & & ( 45)(16) = ( 45)(45 ) ( 45)(45) = + & = & ( -1)^^a _ 0 + ^b _ 0 + 12[m^a_2m^b_2+n^a_2m^b_2+m^a_2n^b_2 + ( -1)^^a_1 + 1(n^a_2n^b_2+n^a_2m^b_2+m^a_2n^b_2 ) + + & + & ( -1)^^b_1 + 1(n^a_2n^b_2+m^a_2n^b_2+n^a_2m^b_2 ) + ( -1)^^a_1+^b_1(n^a_2n^b_2-m^a_2m^b_2 ) ] + ( 45)(16 ) & & ( 45)(45) = ( 45)(45 ) ( 45)(16) = + & = & ( -1)^^a _ 0 + ^b _ 0 + ^a_2+^b_2 + 12 in this case @xmath180 and @xmath181 or @xmath182 , as in [ 10 ] . consider first the exceptional brane ( 56)(14)&=&(-1)^^a _ 0 \ { [ -(n^a_2 + m^a_2)+(-1)^^a _ 1n^a_2 ] [ _ 1+(-1)^^a _ 2_4 ] - + & - & [ n^a_2+(-1)^^a _ 1m^a_2 ] [ _ 1+(-1)^^a _ 2 _ 4 ] } [ 5614 ] and its orientifold dual on the * aab * lattice ( 56)(14)&=&(-1)^^a _ 0 \ { [ n^a_2 + m^a_2-(-1)^^a _ 1n^a_2 ] [ _ 1+(-1)^^a _ 2_4 ] - + & - & [ m^a_2-(-1)^^a _ 1(n^a_2+m^a_2 ) ] [ _ 1+(-1)^^a _ 2 _ 4 ] } [ 5614 ] since @xmath184 on this lattice ( 56)(14)=(_1 + _ 4 ) 2 + ( 56)(14)=(_1 + _ 4 ) 2 + likewise ( 56)(56)=(_5 + _ 6 ) 2 + ( 56)(56)=(_5 + _ 6 ) 2 + it follows that for all of the allowed exceptional branes in this sector ( i^a_1,i^a_2)(j^a_1,j^a_2)(i^b_1,i^b_2)(j^b_1,j^b_2)=0 8 + ( i^a_1,i^a_2)(j^a_1,j^a_2)(i^b_1,i^b_2)(j^b_1,j^b_2)=0 8 the first of these may be verified from the results in [ 10 ] , using @xmath185 .
further , @xmath186 and @xmath187 in this sector .
in fact , since @xmath188 , it follows that @xmath189
. then @xmath190 . hence , from ( [ aob ] ) and ( [ aob ] )
, we see that @xmath191 and we can not obtain the required odd intersection number from this sector .
we therefore omit the calculations of @xmath178 in this sector . as in [ 1011 ] , @xmath194 or @xmath182 , and @xmath195 or @xmath196 .
( 56)(14 ) & & ( 45)(16) = ( -1)^^a_2(56)(14)(45)(45)= + & = & ( -1)^^a_2+^b_2 ( 56)(56 ) ( 45)(45)=(-1)^^b_2(56)(56 ) ( 45)(16) = + & = & ( -1)^^a _ 0 + ^b _ 0 + 12 [ 5645ab ]
as in [ 11 ] , @xmath198 and @xmath199 or @xmath196 .
( 45)(16 ) & & ( 45)(16)
= ( 45)(45 ) ( 45)(45) = + & = & ( -1)^^a _ 0 + ^b _ 02 + ( 45)(16 ) & & ( 45)(45) = ( 45)(45 ) ( 45)(16) = + & = & ( -1)^^a _ 0 + ^b _ 0 + ^a_2+^b_22 as in
[ 10 ] , the relevant fixed points are @xmath180 and @xmath200 or @xmath182 .
it follows from ( [ 5614 ] ) that , since @xmath201 on this lattice ( 56)(14)=(_1 + _ 4 ) 2 and , using table [ reps2 ] , that ( 56)(14)=(_1 + _ 4 ) 2 likewise ( 56)(56)=(_5 + _ 6 ) 2 + ( 56)(56)=(_5 + _ 6 ) 2 + thus , as in [ 10 ] , for all of the allowed exceptional branes in this sector ( i^a_1,i^a_2)(j^a_1,j^a_2)(i^b_1,i^b_2)(j^b_1,j^b_2)=0 8 + ( i^a_1,i^a_2)(j^a_1,j^a_2)(i^b_1,i^b_2)(j^b_1,j^b_2)=0 8 again , the first of these may be verified from the results of [ 10 ] using @xmath202 .
further , @xmath203 and @xmath204 in this sector . since @xmath205 , it follows that @xmath206 , and again @xmath190 .
thus , from ( [ aob ] ) and ( [ aob ] ) , we see that @xmath191 and , as before , we can not obtain the required odd intersection number from this sector .
as in [ 1011 ] , the relevant fixed points are the fixed points involved are @xmath194 or @xmath182 , and @xmath195 or @xmath196 .
( 56)(14 ) & & ( 45)(16) = ( -1)^^a_2(56)(14)(45)(45)= + & = & ( -1)^^a_2+^b_2 ( 56)(56 ) ( 45)(45)=(-1)^^b_2(56)(56 ) ( 45)(16) = + & = & ( -1)^^a _ 0 + ^b _ 0 + 12
the fixed points involved are the same as for the * bab * ( and the * aab * ) lattice .
although the change in lattice _ does _ affect the calculations of @xmath208 , it does so only trivially . from table
[ reps2 ] , we see that the only difference between the * bab * lattice and the * abb * lattice is that there is an overall minus sign in the orientifold image of the exceptional branes . thus , the results for this sector are trivially obtained by changing the overall sign for the calculations of @xmath208 in [ bab ] . of course
, this does not imply that the value @xmath8 is also reversed in sign , since the contribution @xmath209 from the bulk branes is the same for both lattices .
as in [ 11 ] , @xmath198 and @xmath199 or @xmath196 .
( 45)(16 ) & & ( 45)(16)
= ( 45)(45 ) ( 45)(45) = + & = & ( -1)^^a _ 0 + ^b _ 02 + ( 45)(16 ) & & ( 45)(45) = ( 45)(45 ) ( 45)(16) = + & = & ( -1)^^a _ 0 + ^b _ 0 + ^a_2+^b_22 as in
[ 10 ] , the relevant fixed points are @xmath180 and @xmath181 or @xmath182 .
it follows from ( [ 5614 ] ) and table [ reps2 ] that , since @xmath210 on this lattice ( 56)(14)=(_1 + _ 4 + _ 1 + _ 4 ) 2 + ( 56)(14)=(_1 + _ 4 + _ 1 + _ 4 ) 2 + likewise ( 56)(56)=(_5 + _ 6 + _ 5 + _ 6 ) 2 + ( 56)(56)=(_5 + _ 6 + _ 5 + _ 6 ) 2 + thus , as in [ 103 ] , for all of the allowed exceptional branes in this sector ( i^a_1,i^a_2)(j^a_1,j^a_2)(i^b_1,i^b_2)(j^b_1,j^b_2)=0 8 + ( i^a_1,i^a_2)(j^a_1,j^a_2)(i^b_1,i^b_2)(j^b_1,j^b_2)=0 8 however , @xmath211 and @xmath212 in this sector , from which we can _ not _ conclude that either @xmath213 or @xmath209 is @xmath214 . in this case , therefore , we must compute @xmath215 . ( 56)(14 ) & & ( 56)(14) = ( -1)^^b_2 ( 56)(56 ) ( 56)(56) = + & = & ( -1)^^a _ 0 + ^b _ 0 + 12[1+(-1)^^a_2 + ^b_2 ] + ( 56)(14 ) & & ( 56)(56) = 0 = ( 56)(56 ) ( 56)(14) as in [ 1011 ] , the relevant fixed points are the fixed points involved are @xmath194 or @xmath182 , and @xmath195 or @xmath196 . (
56)(14 ) & & ( 45)(16) = ( -1)^^a_2(56)(14)(45)(45)= + & = & ( -1)^^a_2+^b_2 ( 56)(56 ) ( 45)(45)=(-1)^^b_2(56)(56 ) ( 45)(16) = + & = & ( -1)^^a _ 0 + ^b _ 0 + 12 d. bailin and a. love , non - minimal higgs content in standard - like models from d - branes at a z(n ) singularity , phys . lett .
b * 598 * ( 2004 ) 83 [ hep - th/0406031 ] .
n. escudero , c. muoz and a. m. teixeira , phenomenological viability of orbifold models with three higgs families , hep - ph/0512301 . for a review ,
see d. lst , intersecting brane worlds : a path to the standard model ?
, class .
* 21 * ( 2004 ) s1399 [ hep - th/0401156 ] . l. e. ibez , f. marchesano and r. rabadn , getting just the standard model at intersecting branes , jhep * 0111 * ( 2001 ) 002 [ hep - th/0105155 ] .
r. blumenhagen , b. kors , d. lust and t. ott , `` the standard model from stable intersecting brane world orbifolds , '' nucl .
b * 616 * ( 2001 ) 3 [ arxiv : hep - th/0107138 ] .
s. a. abel , o. lebedev and j. santiago , flavour in intersecting brane models and bounds on the string scale , nucl .
b * 696 * ( 2004 ) 141 [ hep - ph/0312157 ] .
g. honecker , chiral supersymmetric models on an orientifold of z(4 ) x z(2 ) with intersecting d6-branes , nucl .
b * 666 * ( 2003 ) 175 [ hep - th/0303015 ] .
g. honecker , chiral n = 1 4d orientifolds with d - branes at angles , mod .
a * 19 * ( 2004 ) 1863 [ hep - th/0407181 ] .
g. honecker and t. ott , getting just the supersymmetric standard model at intersecting branes on the z(6)-orientifold , phys .
d * 70 * ( 2004 ) 126010 [ erratum - ibid .
d * 71 * ( 2005 ) 069902 ] [ hep - th/0404055 ] .
t. ott , catching the phantom : the mssm on the z6-orientifold , fortsch .
* 53 * ( 2005 ) 955 [ hep - th/0505274 ] .
r. blumenhagen , v. braun , b. krs and d. lst , orientifolds of k3 and calabi - yau manifolds with intersecting d - branes , jhep * 0207 * ( 2002 ) 026 [ hep - th/0206038 ] .
j. p. derendinger , c. kounnas , p.
m. petropoulos and f. zwirner , superpotentials in iia compactifications with general fluxes , nucl .
b * 715 * ( 2005 ) 211 [ hep - th/0411276 ] .
s. kachru and a. k. kashani - poor , moduli potentials in type iia compactifications with rr and ns flux , jhep * 0503 * ( 2005 ) 066 [ hep - th/0411279 ] .
t. w. grimm and j. louis , the effective action of type iia calabi - yau orientifolds , nucl . phys .
b * 718 * ( 2005 ) 153 [ hep - th/0412277 ] .
g. villadoro and f. zwirner , n = 1 effective potential from dual type - iia d6/o6 orientifolds with jhep * 0506 * ( 2005 ) 047 [ hep - th/0503169 ] .
o. dewolfe , a. giryavets , s. kachru and w. taylor , type iia moduli stabilization , jhep * 0507 * ( 2005 ) 066 [ hep - th/0505160 ] .
g. cmara , a. font and l. e. ibez , fluxes , moduli fixing and mssm - like vacua in a simple iia orientifold , jhep * 0509 * ( 2005 ) 013 [ hep - th/0506066 ] .
g. aldazabal , p. g. cmara , a. font and l. e. ibez , more dual fluxes and moduli fixing , hep - th/0602089 . | we construct @xmath0 supersymmetric fractional branes on the @xmath1 orientifold . intersecting stacks of such branes
are needed to build a supersymmetric standard model .
if @xmath2 are the stacks that generate the @xmath3 and @xmath4 gauge particles , then , in order to obtain _ just _ the chiral spectrum of the ( supersymmetric ) standard model ( with non - zero yukawa couplings to the higgs mutiplets ) , it is necessary that the number of intersections @xmath5 of the stacks @xmath6 and @xmath7 , and the number of intersections @xmath8 of @xmath6 with the orientifold image @xmath9 of @xmath7 satisfy @xmath10 or @xmath11 .
it is also necessary that there is no matter in symmetric representations of the gauge group , and not too much matter in antisymmetric representations , on either stack .
we provide a number of examples having these properties .
different lattices give different solutions and different physics .
0.35 cm 0.2 cm _ department of physics & astronomy , university of sussex + _ _ brighton bn1 9qh , u.k . +
_ 2.5 cm |
entanglement of formation ( eof)@xcite and relative entropy of entanglement ( ree)@xcite are two major entanglement monotones for bipartite systems . for pure states @xmath0 the eof @xmath1 is defined as a von neumann entropy of its subsystem @xmath2 . on the contrary , ree is defined as minimum value of the relative entropy with separable states ; @xmath3 where @xmath4 is a set of separable states , it is called `` distance entanglement measure '' .
another example of the distance entanglement measure is a geometric entanglement measure defined as @xmath5 , where @xmath6 is a maximal overlap of a given state @xmath7 with the nearest product state@xcite . ] .
it was shown in ref.@xcite that @xmath8 is a upper bound of the distillable entanglement@xcite .
the separable state @xmath9 , which yields a minimum value of the relative entropy is called the closest separable state ( css ) of @xmath10 .
surprising fact , at least for us , is that although definitions of eof and ree are completely different , they are exactly same for all pure states@xcite .
this fact may indicate that they are related to each other although the exact connection is not revealed yet .
the main purpose of this paper is to explore the veiled connection between eof and ree . for mixed states
@xmath10 eof is defined via a convex - roof method@xcite ; @xmath11 where the minimum is taken over all possible pure - state decompositions with @xmath12 and @xmath13 .
the ensemble that gives the minimum value in eq.([two3 ] ) is called the optimal decomposition of the mixed state @xmath10 .
thus , the main task for analytic calculation of eof is derivation of an optimal decomposition of the given mixture .
few years ago , the procedure for construction of the optimal decomposition was derived@xcite in the two - qubit system , the simplest bipartite system , by making use of the time - reversal operation of spin-1/2 particles appropriately . in these references
the relation @xmath14 is used , where @xmath15 is a binary entropy function @xmath16 and @xmath17 is called the concurrence .
this procedure , usually called wootters procedure , was re - examined in ref.@xcite in terms of antilinearity .
introduction of antilinearity in quantum information theory makes it possible to derive concurrence - based entanglement monotones for tripartite@xcite and multipartite systems@xcite . due to the discovery of the closed formula for eof in the two - qubit system ,
eof is recently applied not only to quantum information theory but also to many scientific fields such as life science@xcite . while eof is used in various areas of science
, ree is not because of its calculational difficulty . in order to obtain ree
analytically for given mixed state @xmath10 one should derive its css , but still we do nt know how to derive css@xcite even in the two - qubit system except very rare cases@xcite . in ref.@xcite
ree for bell - diagonal , generalized vedral - plenio@xcite , and generalized horodecki states@xcite were derived analytically through pure geometric arguments@xcite .
due to the notorious difficulty some people try to solve the ree problem conversely .
let @xmath9 be a two - qubit boundary states in the convex set of the separable states . in ref.@xcite authors derived entangled states , whose css are @xmath9 .
this converse procedure is extended to the qudit system@xcite and is generalized as convex optimization problems@xcite .
however , as emphasized in ref.@xcite still it is difficult to find a css @xmath9 of given entangled state @xmath10 although the converse procedure may provide some useful information on the css@xcite . in this paper
we will try to find a css for given entangled two - qubit state without relying on the converse procedure .
as commented , eof and ree are identical for bipartite pure states although they are defined differently .
this means that they are somehow related to each other .
if this connection is unveiled , probably we can find css for arbitrary two - qubit mixed states because we already know how to compute eof through wootters procedure . to explore this issue
is original motivation of this paper .
we will show in the following that ree of many mixed symmetric states can be analytically obtained from eof if one follows the following procedure : 1 . for entangled two - qubit state @xmath10
let @xmath18 be an optimal decomposition for calculation of eof .
since @xmath19 are pure states , it is possible to obtain their css @xmath20 .
thus , it is straight to derive a separable mixture @xmath21 .
if @xmath22 is a boundary state in the convex set of separable states , the procedure is terminated with @xmath23 .
if @xmath22 is not a boundary state , we consider @xmath24 . by requiring
that @xmath25 is a boundary state , one can fix @xmath26 , _ say _ @xmath27 .
then we identify @xmath28 .
this procedure is schematically represented in fig
. 1 . in order to examine the validity of the procedure we have to apply the procedure to the mixed states
whose ree are already known .
thus , we will choose the bell - diagonal , generalized vedral - plenio and generalized horodecki states , whose ree were computed in ref.@xcite through different methods .
also , we will apply the procedure to the less symmetric mixed states such as vedral - plenio - type and horodecki - type states whose ree were computed in ref.@xcite by making use of the the converse procedure introduced in ref.@xcite .
the paper is organized as follows . in section
ii we show that the procedure generates the correct css for bell - diagonal states . in section
iii and section iv we show that the procedure generates the correct css for generalized vedral - plenio and generalized horodecki states , respectively . in section
v we consider two less symmetric states , vedral - plenio - type and horodecki - type states .
it is shown that while the procedure generates a correct css for the former , it does not give a correct one for the latter .
in section vi a brief conclusion is given .
in appendix we prove that eof and ree are identical for all pure states by making use of the schmidt decomposition .
the schmidt bases derived in this appendix are used in the main body of this paper .
in this section we will show that the procedure mentioned above solves the ree problem of the bell - diagonal states : @xmath29 where @xmath30 , and @xmath31 the css and ree of @xmath32 were obtained in many literatures@xcite through various different methods .
if , for convenience , @xmath33 , the css and ree of @xmath32 are @xmath34 now , we will show that the procedure we suggested also yields the same result .
following wootters procedure , one can show that the optimal decomposition of @xmath32 for @xmath35 , @xmath32 is a separable state . ]
is @xmath36 where @xmath37 and @xmath38 all @xmath39 have the same concurrence @xmath40 and , hence , the same @xmath41 ( defined in eq . (
[ def-2 - 2 ] ) ) as @xmath42 the schmidt bases of @xmath43 can be explicitly derived by following the procedure of appendix a and the result is @xmath44 \nonumber \\ & & { \lvert 1_a \rangle } = \frac{-1}{n_- } \left [ \left(\sqrt{1 - \lambda_3 } - \sqrt{\lambda_4}\right ) { \lvert 0 \rangle } - \left(\sqrt{\lambda_1 } - i \sqrt{\lambda_2}\right ) { \lvert 1 \rangle } \right ] \\
\nonumber & & { \lvert 0_b \rangle } = \frac{1}{n_+ } \left [ \left(\sqrt{\lambda_1 } + i \sqrt{\lambda_2}\right ) { \lvert 0 \rangle } + \left(\sqrt{1 - \lambda_3 } + \sqrt{\lambda_4}\right ) { \lvert 1 \rangle } \right ] \nonumber \\ & & { \lvert 1_b \rangle } = \frac{1}{n_- } \left [ \left(\sqrt{\lambda_1 } + i \sqrt{\lambda_2}\right ) { \lvert 0 \rangle } - \left(\sqrt{1 - \lambda_3 } - \sqrt{\lambda_4}\right ) { \lvert 1 \rangle } \right ] , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the normalization constants @xmath45 are @xmath46 thus the css of @xmath43 , say @xmath47 , can be straightforwardly computed by making use of eq .
( [ result-2 ] ) ; @xmath48 where @xmath49 similarly , one can derive the schmidt bases for other @xmath50 and the corresponding css @xmath20 .
then , one can show that the separable state @xmath51 with @xmath52 for all @xmath53 is @xmath54 this is a boundary state in the convex set of the separable states , because the minimal eigenvalue of its partial transposition , _ say _
@xmath55 , is zero .
thus , the procedure mentioned in the introduction is terminated with identifying @xmath23 .
in fact , it is easy to show that @xmath22 is exactly the same with @xmath56 in eq .
( [ bd-3 ] ) .
thus , the procedure we suggested correctly derives the css of the bell - diagonal states .
in this section we will derive the css of the generalized vedral - plenio ( gvp ) state defined as @xmath57 by following the procedure mentioned above .
in fact the css and ree of the gvp were explicitly derived in ref.@xcite using a geometric argument , which are @xmath58 where @xmath59.\ ] ] now , we define @xmath60 and @xmath61 $ ] .
we also define the unnormalized states @xmath62 , where @xmath63 are eigenstates of @xmath64 ; @xmath65 \\
\nonumber & & { \lvert \lambda_{- } \rangle } = \frac{1}{n } \left[\lambda_1 { \lvert 01 \rangle } - \left ( \sqrt{\lambda_1 ^ 2 + \left(\lambda_2 - \lambda_3\right)^2 } + ( \lambda_2 - \lambda_3 )
\right ) { \lvert 10 \rangle } \right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] in eq . ( [ vp-5 ] )
@xmath66 is a normalization constant given by @xmath67 then , following ref.@xcite , the optimal decomposition of @xmath64 for eof is @xmath68 , where @xmath69 and @xmath70 \left ( { \lvert v_+ \rangle } + i { \lvert v_- \rangle } \right ) \\
\nonumber & & { \lvert \psi_2^{vp } \rangle } = \frac{-i}{\omega } \left [ 2b + i \left\{\sqrt{(a - c)^2 + 4 b^2 } - ( a - c ) \right\ } \right ] \left ( { \lvert v_+ \rangle } - i { \lvert v_- \rangle } \right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] following appendix a one can derive the css for @xmath71 directly .
then , one can realize that @xmath72 and @xmath73 have the same css , which is identical with @xmath74 .
thus , the procedure also gives a correct css for the gvp states .
in this section we will show that the procedure also generates the correct css for the generalized horodecki states @xmath75 with @xmath76 and @xmath77 , @xmath78 becomes a separable state . ] .
the css and ree of @xmath79 were derived in ref.@xcite using a geometrical argument and the results are @xmath80 following ref.@xcite one can straightforwardly construct the optimal decomposition of @xmath79 for eof , which is @xmath81 , where @xmath82 and @xmath83 in order to treat @xmath84 as an unified manner let us consider @xmath85 . then , @xmath41 defined in eq .
( [ def-2 - 2 ] ) is @xmath86 where @xmath87 .
since @xmath41 is independent of @xmath88 , this fact indicates that @xmath41 of @xmath84 are equal to eq.([gh-4 ] ) for all @xmath53 . following appendix a , it is straightforward to show that the schmidt bases of @xmath89 are @xmath90 } } { \lvert 0 \rangle } + \sqrt{\frac{r - \left(\sqrt{\lambda_2 } - \sqrt{\lambda_3 } \right)}{2 r } } e^{-i \theta } { \lvert 1 \rangle } \nonumber \\ & & { \lvert 1_a \rangle } = -\sqrt{\frac{\lambda_1}{r \left[r + \left(\sqrt{\lambda_2 } - \sqrt{\lambda_3 } \right ) \right ] } } { \lvert 0 \rangle } + \sqrt{\frac{r + \left(\sqrt{\lambda_2 } - \sqrt{\lambda_3 } \right)}{2 r } } e^{-i \theta } { \lvert 1 \rangle } \\
\nonumber & & \hspace{3.0 cm } { \lvert 0_b \rangle } = e^{i \theta } { \lvert 0_a \rangle } \hspace{1.0 cm } { \lvert 1_b \rangle } = -e^{i \theta } { \lvert 1_a \rangle}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] then the css @xmath91 of @xmath89 is @xmath92 where @xmath93 \\ \nonumber & & { \cal b } = \frac{\sqrt{2 \lambda_1}}{4 r^2 } \left[2 \sqrt{\lambda_3 } + \left(\sqrt{\lambda_2 } + \sqrt{\lambda_3 } \right)\left(\lambda_1 - 2 \sqrt{\lambda_2 \lambda_3}\right ) \right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus , the css @xmath20 of @xmath84 can be obtained by letting @xmath94 , @xmath95 , @xmath96 , respectively
. then , @xmath97 with @xmath98 reduces @xmath99 however , @xmath22 is not a boundary state in the convex set of the separable states , because the minimum eigenvalue of @xmath55 is positive .
thus , we define @xmath100 the condition that the minimum eigenvalue of @xmath101 is zero fixes @xmath102 as @xmath103 inserting eq.([gh-10 ] ) into @xmath9 , one can show that @xmath9 reduces to @xmath104 .
thus , our procedure gives a correct css for the generalized horodecki states .
in the previous sections we have shown that the procedure generates the correct css and ree for various symmetric states such as bell - diagonal , gvp , and generalized horodecki states . in this section we will apply the procedure to the less symmetric states .
the first quantum state we consider is @xmath105 where @xmath106 and @xmath107 .
of course , if @xmath108 , @xmath109 , and @xmath110 , @xmath111 reduces to @xmath64 in eq .
( [ vp-1 ] ) .
thus , we call @xmath111 as vedral - plenio - type state . in order to apply the procedure to @xmath111
we introduce @xmath112 \hspace{1.0 cm } \lambda_2 = \frac{1}{2 } \left[\left ( a_2 + a_3\right ) - r \right ] \\
\nonumber & & { \lvert \lambda_1 \rangle } = \cos \theta { \lvert 01 \rangle } + \sin \theta { \lvert 10 \rangle } \hspace{1.0 cm } { \lvert \lambda_2 \rangle } = \sin \theta { \lvert 01
\rangle } - \cos \theta { \lvert 10 \rangle}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] applying ref.@xcite , it is possible to derive the optimal decomposition of @xmath111 for eof ; @xmath113 , where @xmath114 \hspace{1.0 cm } p_2 = \frac{1}{2 } \left[1 - \frac{a_2 - a_3}{\sqrt{1 - 4 d^2 } } \right]\ ] ] and @xmath115 \\ \nonumber & & { \lvert w_2 \rangle } = \frac{1}{{\mathcal y}_- } \left [ \left(\sqrt{\xi_+ \eta_- } - \sqrt{\xi_- \eta_+ } \right ) \sqrt{\lambda_1 } { \lvert \lambda_1 \rangle } - \left(\sqrt{\xi_+ \eta_+ } + \sqrt{\xi_- \eta_- } \right ) \sqrt{\lambda_2 } { \lvert \lambda_2 \rangle } \right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] in eq .
( [ vpt-4 ] ) @xmath116 , @xmath117 , and @xmath118 are @xmath119.\end{aligned}\ ] ] following appendix a , one can derive the css @xmath47 and @xmath120 of @xmath121 and @xmath122 after long and tedious calculation .
the final results are @xmath123 ^ 2 { \lvert 01 \rangle } { \langle 01 \lvert } \nonumber \\ & + & \left[\frac{\sin \theta \sqrt{\lambda_1 } \left(\sqrt{\xi_+ \eta_+ } + \sqrt{\xi_- \eta_- } \right ) - \cos \theta \sqrt{\lambda_2 } \left(\sqrt{\xi_+ \eta_- } - \sqrt{\xi_- \eta_+ } \right ) } { { \mathcal y}_+}\right]^2 { \lvert 10 \rangle } { \langle 10 \lvert } \\
\nonumber \sigma_2&= & \left[\frac{\cos \theta \sqrt{\lambda_1 } \left(\sqrt{\xi_+ \eta_- } - \sqrt{\xi_- \eta_+ } \right ) - \sin \theta \sqrt{\lambda_2 } \left(\sqrt{\xi_+ \eta_+ } + \sqrt{\xi_- \eta_- } \right ) } { { \mathcal y}_-}\right]^2 { \lvert 01 \rangle } { \langle 01 \lvert } \\ \nonumber & + & \left[\frac{\sin \theta \sqrt{\lambda_1 } \left(\sqrt{\xi_+ \eta_- } - \sqrt{\xi_- \eta_+ } \right ) + \cos \theta \sqrt{\lambda_2 } \left(\sqrt{\xi_+ \eta_+ } + \sqrt{\xi_- \eta_- } \right ) } { { \mathcal y}_-}\right]^2 { \lvert 10 \rangle } { \langle 10 \lvert}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] then , @xmath124 simply reduces to @xmath125 this is manifestly boundary state in the convex set of separable states .
thus , the procedure states that @xmath22 is a css of @xmath111 .
this is exactly the same with theorem @xmath126 of ref.@xcite .
the second less symmetric quantum state we consider is @xmath127 where @xmath128 and @xmath129 .
if @xmath130 , @xmath131 , and @xmath132 , @xmath133 reduces to @xmath78 in eq .
( [ gh-1 ] ) .
thus , we call @xmath133 as horodecki - type state . applying ref.@xcite
, one can derive the optimal decomposition of @xmath133 for eof as @xmath134 , where @xmath52 for all @xmath53 and @xmath135 in order to consider @xmath136 all together , we define @xmath137 for @xmath138 the schmidt bases are @xmath139 \nonumber \\ & & { \lvert 1_a \rangle } = \frac{1}{2 { \mathcal z}_- } \bigg [ \sqrt{2 } \left ( \sqrt{a - d } \sqrt{1 + { \mathcal c } } - \sqrt{a + d } \sqrt{1 - { \mathcal c } } \right ) { \lvert 0 \rangle } \\ \nonumber & & \hspace{2.0 cm } + e^{-i \theta } \left\ { \left(\sqrt{a_1 } + \sqrt{a_4 } \right ) \sqrt{1 + { \mathcal c } } + \left(\sqrt{a_1 } - \sqrt{a_4 } \right ) \sqrt{1 - { \mathcal c } } \right\ } { \lvert 1 \rangle } \bigg ] \\
\nonumber & & { \lvert 0_b \rangle } = \frac{1}{2 { \mathcal z}_+ } \bigg [ \sqrt{2 } e^{i \theta}\left\ { \sqrt{a + d } \left(\sqrt{a_1 } + \sqrt{a_4 } \right ) + \sqrt{a - d } \left(\sqrt{a_1 } - \sqrt{a_4 } \right ) \right\ } { \lvert 0 \rangle } \\ \nonumber & & \hspace{4.0 cm } + \left\ { - \left(a_1 - a_4 \right ) + 2 \sqrt{a^2 - d^2 } + \sqrt{1 - { \mathcal c}^2 } \right\ } { \lvert 1 \rangle}\bigg ] \\
\nonumber & & { \lvert 1_b \rangle } = \frac{1}{2 { \mathcal z}_- } \bigg [ \sqrt{2 } e^{i \theta}\left\ { \sqrt{a + d } \left(\sqrt{a_1 } + \sqrt{a_4 } \right ) + \sqrt{a - d } \left(\sqrt{a_1 } - \sqrt{a_4 } \right ) \right\ } { \lvert 0 \rangle } \\
\nonumber & & \hspace{4.0 cm } + \left\ { - \left(a_1 - a_4 \right ) + 2 \sqrt{a^2 - d^2 } - \sqrt{1 - { \mathcal c}^2 } \right\ } { \lvert 1 \rangle}\bigg],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath140 and @xmath141.\ ] ] thus , the css @xmath142of @xmath138 is @xmath143 similarly , it is straightforward to derive the css @xmath144 of @xmath145
. then , one can show @xmath146 \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{2.0 cm } = \left ( \begin{array}{cccc } a_1 & 0 & 0 & 0 \\ 0 & a & d & 0 \\ 0 & d & a & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 0 & a_4 \end{array } \right)\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath147 \nonumber \\ & & a_4 = \frac{1}{4 ( 1 - { \mathcal c}^2 ) } \bigg [ ( 1 + { \mathcal c } ) \left(\sqrt{a_1 } + \sqrt{a_4 } \right)^2 + ( 1 - { \mathcal c } ) \left(\sqrt{a_1 } - \sqrt{a_4 } \right)^2 \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{9.0 cm } - 2 ( 1 - { \mathcal c}^2 ) \left(a_1 - a_4 \right ) \bigg ] \\ \nonumber & & a = \frac{1}{2 ( 1 - { \mathcal c}^2 ) } \left [ ( 1 + { \mathcal c } ) \left(a - d \right ) + ( 1 - { \mathcal c } ) \left(a + d \right ) \right ]
\\ \nonumber & & d = \frac{2 a \sqrt{a_1 a_4 } + d \left ( a_1 + a_4 \right)}{1 - { \mathcal c}^2}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] one can show that if @xmath130 , @xmath131 , and @xmath132 , @xmath148 reduces to eq .
( [ gh-8 ] ) .
since @xmath148 is not a boundary state in the set of separable states , we define @xmath149 then , the css condition of @xmath150 is @xmath151 \left[x \left(a_4 - a_4 \right ) + a_4 \right ] = \left[x ( d - d ) + d \right]^2.\ ] ] in the horodecki state limit eq .
( [ ht-10 ] ) gives a solution ( [ gh-10 ] ) .
using @xmath152 and @xmath153 where @xmath154 the solution of @xmath102 , _ say _
@xmath155 , can be obtained by solving the quadratic equation ( [ ht-10 ] ) .
inserting @xmath155 in eq .
( [ ht-9 ] ) , one can compute @xmath150 explicitly , which is a candidate of css for @xmath133 . the css of @xmath133 was derived in the theorem @xmath156 of ref.@xcite by using the converse procedure introduced in ref.@xcite .
the explicit form of the css is @xmath157 where @xmath158 \\ \nonumber & & r_4 = \frac{1}{f } \left[2a_4 ( a_2 + a_4 ) ( a_1 + a_2 + a_4 ) + d^2 ( a_1 - a_4 ) + \delta \right ] \\
\nonumber & & r = \frac{1}{f } \left [ 2(a_1 + a_2 ) ( a_2 + a_4 )
( a_1 + a_2 + a_4 ) - d^2 ( a_1 + 2 a_2 + a_4 ) - \delta \right]\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath159 . in eq . (
[ th-2 - 3 ] ) @xmath160 and @xmath161 are @xmath162 our candidate @xmath163 does not coincide with the correct css @xmath164 .
thus , the procedure does not give a correct ree for @xmath133 , although it gives correct ree for bell - diagonal , gvp , generalized horodecki , and vedral - plenio - type states .
in this paper we examine the possibility for deriving the closed formula for ree in two - qubit system without relying on the converse procedure discussed in ref.@xcite .
since ree and eof are identical for all pure states in spite of their different definitions , we think they should have some connection somehow . in this context
we suggest a procedure , where ree can be computed from eof .
the procedure gives correct ree for many symmetric states such as bell - diagonal , gvp , and generalized horodecki states .
it also generates a correct ree for less symmetric states such as @xmath111 .
however , the procedure failed to produce a correct ree for the less symmetric states @xmath133 .
this means our procedure is still incomplete for deriving the closed formula of ree .
we think still the connection between eof and ree is not fully revealed .
if this connection is sufficiently understood in the future , probably the closed formula for ree can be derived .
we hope to explore this issue in the future . * acknowledgement * : this research was supported by the basic science research program through the national research foundation of korea(nrf ) funded by the ministry of education , science and technology(2011 - 0011971 ) .
99 c. h. bennett , d. p. divincenzo , j. a. smokin and w. k. wootters , _ mixed - state entanglement and quantum error correction _ , phys .
rev . * a 54 * ( 1996 ) 3824 [ quant - ph/9604024 ] .
v. vedral , m. b. plenio , m. a. rippin and p. l. knight , _ quantifying entanglement _
* 78 * ( 1997 ) 2275 [ quant - ph/9702027 ] . v. vedral and m. b. plenio , _ entanglement measures and purification procedures _ , phys
. rev . * a 57 * ( 1998 ) 1619 [ quant - ph/9707035 ] .
a. shimony , _ degree of entanglement _ , in d. m. greenberg and a. zeilinger ( eds . ) , fundamental problems in quantum theory : a conference held in honor of j. a. wheeler , ann . n. y. acad .
* 755 * ( 1995 ) 675 ; h. barnum and n. linden , _ monotones and invariants for multi - particle quantum states _ , j. phys .
a : math . gen . * 34 * , ( 2001 ) 6787 [ quant - ph/0103155 ] ; t .- c . wei and p. m. goldbart , _ geometric measure of entanglement and application to bipartite and multipartite quantum states _ , phys . rev . * a 68 * ( 2003 ) 042307 [ quant - ph/0307219 ] .
a. uhlmann , _ fidelity and concurrence of conjugate states _ ,
phys . rev . * a 62 * ( 2000 ) 032307 [ quant - ph/9909060 ] .
s. hill and w. k. wootters , _ entanglement of a pair of quantum bits _ ,
* 78 * ( 1997 ) 5022 [ quant - ph/9703041 .
w. k. wootters , _ entanglement of formation of an arbitrary state of two qubits _ , phys .
lett . * 80 * ( 1998 ) 2245 [ quant - ph/9709029 ] . v. coffman , j. kundu and w. k. wootters , _
distributed entanglement _ ,
phys . rev . * a 61 * ( 2000 ) 052306 [ quant - ph/9907047 ] .
a. osterloh and j. siewert , _
constructing @xmath66-qubit entanglement monotones from antilinear operators _ , phys . rev . * a 72 * ( 2005 ) 012337 [ quant - ph/0410102 ] ; d. .
dokovi and a. osterloh , _ on polynomial invariants of several qubits _
, j. math .
* 50 * ( 2009 ) 033509 [ arxiv:0804.1661 ( quant - ph ) ] .
m. sarovar , a. ishizaki , g. r. fleming , k. b. whaley , _ quantum entanglement in photosynthetic light harvesting complexes _ , nature physics , * 6*(2010 ) 462 [ arxiv:0905.3787 ( quant - ph ) ] and references therein .
o. krueger and r. f. werner , _ some open problems in quantum information theory _ , quant - ph/0504166 .
r. horodecki and m. horodecki , _ information - theoretic aspects of inseparability of mixed states _ , phys
. rev . * a 54 * , ( 1996 ) 1838 [ quant - ph/9607007 ] .
h. kim , m. r. hwang , e. jung and d. k. park , _ difficulties in analytic computation for relative entropy of entanglement _ , phys .
* a 81 * ( 2010 ) 052325 [ arxiv:1002.4695 ( quant - ph ) ] .
d. k. park , relative entropy of entanglement for two - qubit state with @xmath165-directional bloch vectors , int .
* 8 * ( 2010 ) 869 [ arxiv:1005.4777 ( quant - ph ) ] . m. horodecki , p. horodecki , and r. horodecki , in _ quantum information : an introduction to basic theoretical concepts and experiments _ , edited by g. alber _
( springer , berlin , 2001 ) , p. 151 .
a. miranowicz and s. ishizaka , _ closed formula for the relative entropy of entanglement _ , phys . rev .
* a78 * ( 2008 ) 032310 [ arxiv:0805.3134 ( quant - ph ) ] .
s. friedland and g gour , _ closed formula for the relative entropy of entanglement in all dimensions _ , j. math .
* 52 * ( 2011 ) 052201 [ arxiv:1007.4544 ( quant - ph ) ] .
m. w. girard , g. gour , and s. friedland , _ on convex optimization problems in quantum information theory _ , arxiv:1402.0034 ( quant - ph ) . in this section
we will show that ree and eof are identical for two - qubit pure states .
this fact was already proven in theorem @xmath166 of ref.@xcite .
we will prove this again more directly , because explicit schmidt bases are used in the main body of the paper .
let us consider a general two - qubit pure state @xmath167 with @xmath168 .
then , its concurrence is @xmath169 .
now , we define @xmath170 where @xmath171 \hspace{1.0 cm } { \cal n}_{\pm}^2 = |\alpha_1^ * \alpha_2 + \alpha_3^ * \alpha_4|^2 + |\lambda_{\pm } - ( |\alpha_1|^2 + |\alpha_3|^2)|^2.\ ] ] now , we consider @xmath172 matrix @xmath173 , whose components @xmath174 are @xmath175 then schmidt bases for each party are defined as @xmath176 where @xmath177 using eq .
( [ schmidt-1 ] ) , one can show straightforwardly that @xmath178 reduces to @xmath179 .
thus , its css @xmath9 are simply expressed in terms of the schmidt bases as @xmath180 applying eq .
( [ ree-1 - 1 ] ) , one can show easily @xmath181 , which is exactly the same with eof . | it is well - known that entanglement of formation ( eof ) and relative entropy of entanglement ( ree ) are exactly identical for all two - qubit pure states even though their definitions are completely different .
we think this fact implies that there is a veiled connection between eof and ree . in this context , we suggest a procedure , which enables us to compute ree from eof without relying on the converse procedure .
it is shown that the procedure yields correct ree for many symmetric mixed states such as bell - diagonal , generalized vedral - plenino , and generalized horodecki states .
it also gives a correct ree for less symmetric vedral - plenio - type state .
however , it is shown that the procedure does not provide correct ree for arbitrary mixed states . |
in this supplementary section we present a list of virtual processes that contribute to the first term of eq.(9 ) in the main text .
table i corresponds to the single - level anderson model , whereas tables ii - iv dwell on the universal hamiltonian .
in addition , we present the dimensionless integral that gives rise to @xmath21 ( defined by eq .
15 in the main text ) : @xmath166 where @xmath167 and @xmath168 .
( [ eq : f ] ) can be derived by adding the @xmath169 transition amplitudes of tables ii - iv along with the second and third term of eq.(9 ) in the main text , with @xmath136 .
the derivation is simplified by exploiting time - reversal as well as particle - hole symmetry , although similar integrals may be derived in absence of particle - hole symmetry .
note that the sum and integral in eq .
( [ eq : f ] ) are uv - finite , even though numerous individual amplitudes in tables ii - iv are uv - divergent ; the delicate cancellation between different uv divergences adds considerable confidence on the veracity of our results .
moreover , we find that the main contribution to @xmath21 originates from states with @xmath170 and @xmath171 .
these observations together justify our assumption of energy - independent tunneling amplitudes and uniform energy - level spacings . in other words ,
our assumptions hold provided that the tunneling - amplitudes and the energy - level spacings vary slowly on energy scales of order @xmath14 , which is typically much smaller than the fermi energy . | we develop a general method to evaluate the kondo temperature in a multilevel quantum dot that is weakly coupled to conducting leads .
our theory reveals that the kondo temperature is strongly enhanced when the intradot energy - level spacing is comparable or smaller than the charging energy .
we propose an experiment to test our result , which consists of measuring the size - dependence of the kondo temperature . _
introduction. _ the kondo effect , a many - body phenomenon that emerges from the interaction between localized and itinerant fermionic degrees of freedom , is characterized by a low - temperature infrared ( ir ) divergence in perturbative calculations of physical observables such as resistivity and magnetic susceptibility@xcite .
this ir divergence is controlled by an ultraviolet ( uv ) cutoff @xmath0 that appears in the expression for the kondo temperature via @xmath1 , where @xmath2 is the kondo coupling and @xmath3 is the fermi level density of states per spin for itinerant carriers . such expression for @xmath4
is generally valid for @xmath5 and can be derived perturbatively starting from the venerable kondo hamiltonian @xcite , @xmath6
. an accurate microscopic theory of @xmath2 and @xmath0 provides crucial guidance for experimental explorations of strongly correlated electron systems . a precise way to quantify
@xmath4 is to work with a `` first - principles '' microscopic model that reduces to @xmath7 at energy scales below @xmath0 .
quite generally this first - principles hamiltonian can be written as @xmath8 , where @xmath9 captures the hybridization between the localized and itinerant degrees of freedom .
a perturbation theory calculation of physical observables in @xmath9 then yields hallmark kondo - like divergences , with @xmath0 and @xmath2 unequivocally determined in terms of the microscopic parameters of @xmath10 .
perhaps the first author to successfully implement the aforementioned scheme was haldane@xcite , who evaluated the magnetic susceptibility for the single - level anderson hamiltonian to fourth order in the hybridization amplitude @xmath11 . in the local - moment regime and for an infinite bandwidth in the continuum he obtained @xmath12 and @xmath13 , where @xmath14 is the coulomb charging energy . over time , haldane s formula @xmath15 has remained as the norm for the interpretation of experimental studies of the kondo effect in quantum dots@xcite , even though its applicability in these devices is _ a priori _ unclear .
a primary concern regarding haldane s formula is that it makes no reference to the multiple energy levels present in real dots .
this concern was first addressed by inoshita et al .
@xcite , who suggested that the dense energy spectrum of quantum dots should enhance @xmath4 by several orders of magnitude .
nevertheless , no such giant enhancement has been observed@xcite .
more recently , aleiner _
et al .
_ @xcite argued that , in real quantum dots with an average single - particle spacing @xmath16 , the main modification from haldane s formula should consist of replacing @xmath17 by @xmath18 .
the conclusions of refs .
[ , ] rely on effective kondo hamiltonians , and are thus less rigorous than the `` first - principles '' approach described above . in this paper
we follow the spirit of ref . [ ] and construct a precise theory for @xmath4 in real quantum dots that are weakly coupled to conducting leads .
we adopt the _ universal hamiltonian _ @xcite as an appropriate `` first - principles '' model for real quantum dots , and reach results that differ qualitatively from those of refs .
[ , , ] . in the infinite bandwidth limit we conclude that @xmath19 for @xmath20 , where @xmath21 is a function of @xmath22 ( fig .
1 ) . this result predicts an unconventional dependence of @xmath4 on the size of the quantum dot .
is a lengthscale defined in the text .
_ inset _ : the function @xmath21 of eq .
( [ eq : l_dot ] ) for a quantum dot with infinite equally - spaced energy levels . ] _ method. _ our calculation centers on spin - flip matrix elements of an effective hamiltonian , @xmath23 where @xmath24 and @xmath25 are degenerate eigenstates of @xmath26 , and @xmath27 is the effective hamiltonian derived from degenerate perturbation theory in @xmath9 .
@xmath24 and @xmath25 are tensor products of a target ( i.e. the localized degrees of freedom ) and a projectile ( i.e. an itinerant particle that scatters off the target ) .
both the spin of the projectile and the spin of the target are flipped in the course of spin - flip processes .
the calculation of eq .
( [ eq : a ] ) is considerably simpler than that of the magnetic susceptibility in ref .
[ ] because it requires neither partition functions nor external magnetic fields .
in spite of its relative simplicity , eq .
( [ eq : a ] ) is closely connected to the scattering t - matrix and thus to a physical observable , namely the scattering rate . in view of the above connection
, our approach exploits the long - known fact@xcite that in the kondo model the spin - flip matrix elements of the t - matrix produce the `` running '' kondo coupling @xmath28 where @xmath29 is the temperature .
the computation of eq .
( [ eq : a ] ) from a `` first - principles '' model and its subsequent identification with eq .
( [ eq : kondo ] ) produces the desired explicit expression for @xmath2 and @xmath0 in terms of microscopic parameters .
_ effective hamiltonian. _ given a hamiltonian @xmath8 , where @xmath26 has a degenerate energy spectrum , there exists a perturbative green s function technique@xcite to construct its exact eigen energies . according to this approach ,
the key eigenvalue equation to be solved is @xmath30 where @xmath31 is the projection operator onto the degenerate subspace spanned by the eigenvectors of the unperturbed energy @xmath32 , @xmath33 are the eigenvalues of @xmath10 and @xmath34 are the projections of the corresponding eigenvectors onto the projected subspace .
hence @xmath35 , which is hermitian on the projected subspace , may be identified with an effective hamiltonian . also , @xmath36 and @xmath37 for non - negative integers @xmath38 . in eq .
( [ eq : un ] ) , @xmath39 if @xmath40 and @xmath41 if @xmath42 .
in addition , @xmath43 .
@xmath44 is extended over all sets of non - negative integers @xmath45 satisfying the conditions @xmath46 @xmath47 and @xmath48 . from eq .
( [ eq : eigen ] ) it follows@xcite that @xmath49 _ single - level anderson model. _ in order to verify that eq .
( [ eq : a ] ) produces the correct @xmath0 and @xmath2 , we employ the simplest first - principles model for which rigorous results have been long established@xcite . using the standard notation ,
the anderson hamiltonian is @xmath8 , where @xmath50 we evaluate @xmath51 to fourth order in the hybridization amplitude @xmath11 .
we choose @xmath52 as the initial and final scattering states .
@xmath53 is the fermi sea in the continuum and @xmath54 denotes the empty state of the localized level .
the momentum of the projectile is assumed to be close to the fermi surface ( i.e. @xmath55 ) . @xmath24 and
@xmath25 can be connected only via spin - flip processes ; this choice is convenient in that it filters out spin - independent scattering .
the effective hamiltonian may be evaluated using eq .
( [ eq : messiah ] ) and noting that @xmath31 projects onto a two - dimensional subspace spanned by @xmath24 and @xmath25 ; the outcome reads @xmath56 with @xmath57 and @xmath58 where we have exploited @xmath59 and defined @xmath60 .
our @xmath27 connects states with equal energy and thus contains less information than the effective hamiltonian derived from a fourth - order schrieffer - wolff@xcite transformation , with which it agrees when @xmath61 . at any rate
, this limitation has no practical consequences because all observable properties are determined by @xmath62 and @xmath63 located at the fermi surface . from eq .
( [ eq : h_eff ] ) the lowest order contribution to @xmath51 reads @xmath64 where @xmath65 denotes virtual intermediate states that satisfy @xmath66 . also , @xmath67 and @xmath68 ( @xmath69 as we focus on elastic scattering ) .
each time @xmath9 acts on a state it changes the number of particles by one both in the continuum and in the localized level , yet it conserves the total number of particles and the total spin . accordingly @xmath70 and @xmath71 .
next , we compute the 4th order contribution to the scattering amplitude using @xmath72 in eq .
( [ eq : h_eff ] ) : @xmath73 where @xmath74 . the second and third terms in eq .
( [ eq : t4 ] ) were derived by inserting @xmath75 between two subsequent @xmath31 operators in eq .
( [ eq : h_eff ] ) .
in particular , the second term in eq .
( [ eq : t4 ] ) is uv divergent and plays a crucial role in ensuring that @xmath51 remains uv finite even when the bandwidth of the continuum states is taken to infinity .
\{@xmath76,@xmath77,@xmath78 } label intermediate states , which are collected in table i of the supplementary material .
summing over all contributions and assuming an infinite bandwidth in the continuum we obtain @xmath79 where @xmath3 is the fermi surface density of states in the continuum and @xmath80 is the infrared energy cutoff .
for the present zero - temperature calculation @xmath81 .
@xmath82 can be identified ( modulo a factor @xmath83 ) with eq .
( [ eq : kondo ] ) , which yields @xmath84 and @xmath85 .
these expressions agree with those of ref .
[ ] .
_ connection with scattering theory. _ here we show that eq .
( [ eq : a ] ) is closely linked to a physical observable . according to standard scattering theory@xcite
, the spin - dependent scattering amplitude in the anderson model is given by @xmath86 where @xmath87 and @xmath88 label the spin of the projectile , @xmath89 and @xmath90 are eigenstates of the full hamiltonian @xmath10 in absence of projectiles and @xmath91 is the exact ground state energy , i.e. @xmath92 and @xmath93 . in the local moment regime and for a large system containing an odd number of electrons
@xmath89 and @xmath90 are spin 1/2 ground states . at @xmath94
the spin resides on the localized level but for @xmath95 the magnetization is spatially delocalized@xcite .
below we use @xmath96 and @xmath97 to denote the spin direction ( @xmath98 or @xmath99 ) of @xmath89 and @xmath90 , respectively .
we evaluate spin - flip matrix elements perturbatively for the real part of eq .
( [ eq : t_lan ] ) with @xmath55 .
it is immediate to see that the leading order contribution agrees with @xmath100 .
the fourth order term involves expanding @xmath89 , @xmath90 , @xmath10 and @xmath91 to second order in @xmath9 ; the result agrees with eq .
( [ eq : t4_and ] ) .
in particular , the @xmath101 ( re)normalization of @xmath89 and @xmath90 @xcite coincides with the last term in eq .
( [ eq : t4 ] ) .
this easily - overlooked term is essential for the correct evaluation of the t - matrix . in sum , @xmath102 for @xmath55 .
the su(2 ) symmetry of the anderson hamiltonian dictates @xmath103 , where @xmath104 is a vector of pauli matrices and we ignore spin - independent scattering .
the imaginary part of the t - matrix , which quantifies the electronic scattering rate off the localized level , can then be extracted by virtue of the optical theorem : @xmath105 ^ 2 \propto j^2 + 2 j^3 \log(\lambda/\omega)+ ... $ ] _ multilevel quantum dots. _ we are now ready to evaluate @xmath0 and @xmath2 for real quantum dots via eq .
( [ eq : a ] ) . the universal hamiltonian of a quantum dot that is weakly connected to a conducting lead can be written as @xmath8 , where @xmath106 @xmath107 labels the discrete single - particle energy levels in the dot , @xmath108 is the number operator for dot electrons , @xmath109 is the gate charge , @xmath14 is the charging energy , and we have neglected intradot exchange interactions . for simplicity we take @xmath110 and @xmath111 for @xmath112 .
these simplifications are partly justified because our theory is uv - finite ( see below and the suppl .
material ) .
the unperturbed initial and final scattering states are @xmath113 , where @xmath53 is the fermi sea in the lead , @xmath114 creates a projectile in the lead just above the fermi surface , @xmath115 is an eigenstate of the dot containing @xmath116 electrons and @xmath117 creates an electron in the dot at level `` 0 '' located immediately above the highest ( @xmath118-th ) doubly - occupied level ( @xmath119 ) .
the unperturbed energy is @xmath120 , where @xmath121 is the kinetic energy of the filled fermi seas ( herein @xmath122 ) and @xmath123 is the kinetic energy for the singly - occupied level `` 0 '' ( tunable by a gate voltage ) .
@xmath124 is the coulomb energy cost for adding @xmath125 electrons to the dot ; we have chosen @xmath126 without loss of generality by shifting all @xmath127 by a constant .
we begin by recognizing that @xmath128 and that eq .
( [ eq : h_eff ] ) remains valid .
therefore @xmath100 and @xmath129 are given by eqs .
( [ eq : t2_0 ] ) and ( [ eq : t4 ] ) , respectively . for the former
we find @xmath130 where we used @xmath131 and defined @xmath132 .
next , we focus on @xmath129 .
its computation requires considering numerous sets of intermediate states ; these are listed in tables ii , iii and iv of the supplementary material . for simplicity
we start by separating out the contribution from the @xmath133 ( singly occupied ) level in the dot . assuming an infinite bandwidth in the lead we arrive at @xmath134 where @xmath135 .
eqs .
( [ eq : a2d ] ) and ( [ eq : m0_3 ] ) are independent of @xmath16 and essentially identical to those of the single - level anderson model . finally , we sum the contributions from @xmath136 levels .
these depend on @xmath16 and encode the influence of the multilevel energy spectrum in the kondo physics . tables ii and iii show that individual virtual processes involving @xmath136 levels are plagued with ir and uv divergences . remarkably , different divergences end up cancelling one another , partly assisted by the last two terms in eq .
( [ eq : t4 ] ) . on one hand ,
the cancellation of @xmath136 infrared divergences corroborates that kondo correlations arise only from processes involving the singly occupied level in the dot . on the other hand
, the cancellation of @xmath136 ultraviolet divergences confirms that high - energy excited states in the dot and lead do not alter the physics of the kondo effect . in spite of being divergence free ,
the influence of @xmath136 levels is important and makes the kondo coupling @xmath16-dependent . in the infinite bandwidth limit and in proximity to the particle - hole symmetric point ( @xmath137 )
we obtain @xmath138,\ ] ] where @xmath21 is a dimensionless function of @xmath22 evaluated numerically ( fig . 1 and suppl .
material ) . when @xmath139 , @xmath140 and multilevel effects are negligible
; in the opposite limit @xmath141 and multilevel effects are important .
the sum of eqs .
( [ eq : a2d ] ) , ( [ eq : m0_3 ] ) and ( [ eq : a4 ] ) can be arranged as @xmath142 .
for @xmath143 we obtain @xmath144 where @xmath145 is the kondo coupling corresponding to a single - level dot and @xmath146 is the width of the energy levels in the dot .
eq .
( [ eq : l_dot ] ) is valid for @xmath147 , i.e. @xmath148 , and constitutes the main result of this paper .
we selected @xmath0 on physical grounds so that it sets the energy scale below which ( i ) the universal hamiltonian maps onto the kondo hamiltonian , ( ii ) the renormalization group flow for @xmath2 is that of the simple kondo model . _
experimental implications. _ from eq .
( [ eq : l_dot ] ) , the kondo temperature for a multilevel quantum dot is @xmath149 , for any @xmath22 insofar as @xmath148 ( this condition implies that the broadening of the many - body energy eigenvalues of the isolated dot is much smaller than the energy spacing between them ) .
fig .
1 displays @xmath4 as a function of the linear dot dimension @xmath150 . introducing a lengthscale @xmath151 such that @xmath152 and @xmath153
, it follows that @xmath154 and @xmath155 .
@xmath156 is kept fixed ( independent of @xmath150 ) and we take @xmath157 and @xmath158 ; these are reasonable extrapolations based on available experimental data .
clearly haldane s single - level formula is accurate for smallest dots with @xmath139 ; in contrast , the multilevel enhancement of the kondo temperature becomes important for larger dots with @xmath159 . for @xmath160
, @xmath21 is so large that @xmath20 is possible only for a very small value of @xmath161 , which in turn results in an unmeasurably low @xmath4 .
therefore eq .
( [ eq : l_dot ] ) is experimentally relevant for dots with @xmath162 , wherein the multilevel enhancement is more modest yet still noticeable ( @xmath163 ) . in conclusion ,
we have developed a method to evaluate the kondo temperature of real quantum dots with unprecedented precission .
our theory predicts an unconventional and potentially measurable size - dependence of @xmath4 in dots with @xmath164 .
our formalism is valid and our results readily generalizable for models that incorporate energy - dependence in the dot - lead tunneling amplitude as well as non - uniform distribution of energy levels in the dot . _
acknowledgements. _ we are indebted to a. andreev , o. entin - wohlman , j. folk and l. glazman for helpful conversations .
this research has been supported by nserc and cifar .
50 for a review see e.g. p. coleman , _ many - body physics _ , http://www.physics.rutgers.edu/@xmath165coleman/mbody.html .
f.d.m .
haldane , j. phys .
c * 11 * , 5015 ( 1978 ) .
d. goldhaber - gordon _ et al .
_ , nature * 391 * , 156 ( 1998 ) ; s.m .
cronenwett _
et al . _ ,
science * 281 * , 540 ( 1998 ) .
t. inoshita _
et al . _ ,
phys .
rev .
b * 48 * , 14725 ( 1993 ) .
d. goldhaber - gordon _ et al .
_ , phys .
rev .
lett . * 81 * , 5225 ( 1998 ) ; w.g .
van der wiel _
et al . _ ,
science * 289 * , 2105 ( 2000 ) .
i.l . aleiner _
et al . _ ,
phys . rep . *
358 * , 309 ( 2002 ) .
h. suhl , phys . rev . * 138 * , a515 ( 1965 ) ; h. suhl in _ theory of magnetism in transition metals _ , ed .
w. marshall ( academic press , new york , 1967 ) .
see e.g. a. messiah , _ quantum mechanics ( vol .
ii ) _ ( north - holland publishing co. , amsterdam , 1962 ) .
d.c .
langreth , phys .
rev . * 150 * , 516 ( 1966 ) .
e.s .
sorensen and i. affleck , phys .
rev .
b * 53 * , 9153 ( 1996 ) .
j.j .
sakurai , _ modern quantum mechanics _
( addison - wesley , reading , ma , 1994 ) . |
this paper describes constraints on possible new spin - coupled interactions using a torsion pendulum containing @xmath31 polarized electrons .
several rather different considerations motivated this work . general relativity ( the classical theory that forms the standard model of gravity ) does not in itself make predictions about the gravitational properties of intrinsic spin a quantum mechanical effect with no classical analog .
because the classic equivalence - principle and inverse - square - law experiments all used unpolarized test bodies they can shed no light on this issue .
in addition , these `` fifth force '' experiments were completely insensitive to the purely spin - dependent forces arising from the first - order exchange of unnatural parity ( @xmath32 , @xmath33 , etc ) bosons .
lastly , the spin pendulum provided a means to search for a new class of preferred - frame effects that involve intrinsic spin .
we established very tight bounds on long - range @xmath1-violating interactions and on velocity - dependent forces by searching for the effects of unnatural - parity bosons exchanged between the electrons in our pendulum and unpolarized matter in the earth and in the sun .
similarly , we made sensitive searches for preferred - frame effects defined by the entire cosmos . in this case
, we checked whether the spins in our pendulum preferred to orient themselves in a direction fixed in inertial space , or if they had a generalized helicity defined by their velocity with respect to the rest - frame of the cosmic microwave background .
finally , we investigated non - commutative space - time geometries and obtained constraints that lie far beyond the reach of any proposed accelerator . in each case , our bounds are interesting because of their high sensitivity .
a letter on the first results from this apparatus has already appeared@xcite .
this paper , which supercedes ref .
@xcite , reports additional data and more powerful constraints , provides a complete account of the experimental work , and presents a more extensive discussion of our constraints .
it seems natural to us , when testing possible lorentz - violating preferred - frame scenarios , to let the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) define the fundamental inertial frame .
we consider , in turn , three types of preferred - frame effects involving spin .
first , we consider an interaction that violates rotational invariance and produces a laboratory potential @xmath34 where @xmath18 is a preferred direction with respect to the cosmos as a whole next , we consider a helicity - generating interaction that violates boost invariance as well , _
i.e. _ a lab - frame interaction @xmath35 where @xmath8 is the velocity of the spin with respect to the cmb rest - frame .
this velocity has two significant components the velocity of the earth with respect to the sun ( @xmath36 ) and the velocity of the sun with respect to the cmb rest frame ( @xmath37 ) ; the small velocity due to the earth s rotation is neglected .
finally , following the general ideas of kosteleck and coworkers@xcite , we consider a tensor helicity - generating term that produces a laboratory interaction @xmath38 we take cartesian equatorial coordinates for our inertial frame , where @xmath39 points north along the earth s spin axis , @xmath40 points from the earth to the sun at the 2000 vernal equinox , and @xmath41 .
these possible spin - dependent cosmic preferred - frame effects differ from the known cmb preferred - frame effect in two important ways .
first , if @xmath18 is a time - even polar vector , @xmath42 a time - even scalar and @xmath22 a time - even tensor ( untestable assumptions even in principle ) , then the interactions in eqs .
[ eq : def a ] , and either [ eq : def b ] or [ eq : def c ] violate time - reversal and parity , respectively .
second , if such spin - dependent preferred - frame effects exist , they could be observed within an opaque box that shielded out any normal information about the outside world .
although we naively expect that any such preferred - frame effects to be suppressed by the planck scale and therefore of order @xmath43 ev , our results are sufficiently sensitive to probe such tiny effects .
kosteleck and coworkers@xcite have developed a preferred - frame scenario in which spin-1 and spin-2 fields were spontaneously generated in the early universe and were subsequently inflated to enormous extents .
these fields clearly violate lorentz symmetry but in a very gentle way .
rotations and boosts of an observer remain lorentz invariant , but the same operations on a particle ( but not the universe ) obviously do not respect the invariance principle .
the lorentz non - invariance invalidates the pauli - luders theorem , allowing kosteleck et al . to construct a field theory with @xmath44-violating effects ( the standard - model extension or sme ) that has been widely used to quantify the sensitivity of various @xmath44 and preferred - frame tests involving photons , leptons , mesons and baryons ( ref .
@xcite has an extensive set of references to this work ) .
our @xmath18 coefficient is identical to the sme coefficient @xmath45 which contains contributions from @xmath44-violating as well as @xmath1-violating terms@xcite .
the sme has similar terms to our @xmath22 coefficients , but they are conventionally expressed in sun - fixed coordinates . to facilitate sme analyses and to compare our results with other work based on sme analyses
, we also quote results in which the sun s velocity with respect to the cmb rest frame is ignored .
arkani - hamed and colleagues have developed a consistent dynamical mechanism for the spontaneous breaking of lorentz symmetry that , in effect , proposes a pervasive , massless , aether - like fluid consisting of nambu - goldstone bosons associated with the broken time - diffeomorphism symmetry@xcite .
the bosons form a `` ghost condensate '' because the assumption of translational invariance demands a negative kinetic term in the lagrangian .
they form a condensate because higher - order terms are needed to stabilize the negative kinetic term .
this fluid has remarkable properties . unlike a classical aether
, it can be excited .
it modifies newtonian gravity at long ranges and late times in the evolution of the universe .
it behaves like a cosmological constant and is capable of accelerating the expansion of the universe , but maximally violates the equivalence principle .
it defines a preferred frame that converges with the rest frame of the cmb as it reaches equilibrium , and as it evolves to its final state it mimics dark matter .
cosmological tests of gravity limit the diffeomorphism symmetry - breaking scale @xmath46 to be less than 10 mev .
interesting physics is possible within this constraint ; if @xmath46 were @xmath47 ev the condensate could drive the observed acceleration of the universe ; if @xmath46 were @xmath48 ev it would mimic the observed dark matter .
particularly interesting in the present context , a fermion moving with respect to the ghost condensate experiences an interaction @xmath49 where @xmath50 is a mass scale associated with the coupling of the fermion to the condensate , and @xmath8 is the fermion s velocity with respect to the condensate , which we assume to be at rest in the frame where the cmb is essentially isotropic .
equation [ eq : thaler mu ] has the same form as eq .
[ eq : def b ]
. preferred - frame effects also occur in non - commutative space - time geometries@xcite that can arise in @xmath51-brane models . in these geometries ,
the space - time coordinates @xmath52 do not commute , but instead satisfy @xmath53=i\theta_{\mu\nu}~ , \label{eq : non - comm def}\ ] ] where @xmath54 is a real , antisymmetric tensor that has dimensions of length squared and @xmath55 represents the smallest `` observable '' patch of area .
it is often assumed that @xmath56 to avoid problems with causality .
we make the usual additional assumption that @xmath54 is constant over the space - time region spanned by our experiment , so that it defines a preferred direction @xmath57 .
one consequence of eq .
[ eq : non - comm def ] is that a spinning electron experiences a @xmath1-violating interaction@xcite @xmath58 where @xmath59 is a cutoff conventionally taken to be @xmath60 tev , and @xmath61 is the fine structure constant . equation [ eq : non - comm effect ] is equivalent to @xmath62 which has the same general form as eq .
[ eq : def a ] .
the exchange of pseudoscalar particles produces spin - dependent forces that vanish between unpolarized bodies . as a consequence , there are few experimental constraints on such forces .
moody and wilczek@xcite discussed the forces produced by the exchange of low - mass , spin-0 particles and pointed out that particles containing @xmath1-violating @xmath63 and @xmath64 admixtures would produce a macroscopic , @xmath1-violating `` monopole - dipole '' interaction between a polarized electron and an unpolarized atom with mass and charge numbers @xmath13 and @xmath12 @xmath65~ , \label{eq : mw}\ ] ] where @xmath66 is the mass of the hypothetical spin-0 particle , @xmath67 and @xmath68 are its pseudoscalar and scalar couplings , and @xmath69 . for simplicity
, we assume below that @xmath70 and @xmath71 so that @xmath72 ; constraints for other choices of the scalar couplings can be readily obtained by scaling our limits .
recently dobrescu and mocioiu@xcite classified the kinds of potentials , constrained only by rotational and translational invariance , that might arise from exchange of low - mass bosons .
our work is sensitive to 3 of their potentials ; in addition to a potential equivalent to eq . [
eq : mw ] , we probe the two velocity - dependent potentials @xmath73e^{-r/\lambda}~ , \label{eq : bd}\ ] ] where @xmath74 is the relative velocity in units of @xmath75 . both terms can be generated by one - boson exchange in lorentz - invariant theories .
the parity - conserving @xmath76 term can arise from scalar or vector boson exchange , while the parity - violating @xmath77 term can be induced by spin-1 bosons that have both vector and axial couplings to electrons , giving @xmath78 .
we constrain the parameters of eq .
[ eq : bd ] by studying the interaction between the polarized electrons in our pendulum and unpolarized nucleons in the sun and moon .
this measurement used a substantially upgraded version of the et - wash rotating torsion balance that was used for a previous test@xcite of the equivalence principle .
this device , in turn , was an improved version of the instrument described in detail in ref .
the essential features of this balance are shown in fig .
[ fig : ew balance ] .
briefly , a vacuum vessel containing a torsion pendulum and its associated optical readout system was rotated uniformly about a vertical axis .
the pendulum hung in a region of very low magnetic fields and gravity gradients , and the entire instrument was temperature - controlled ( stability @xmath79 mk ) .
magnetic fields and gradients were reduced by a stationary set of helmholtz coils and 4 layers of co - rotating mu - metal shielding .
gravity gradients were canceled as described in ref .
@xcite , with a precision that was limited by the fluctuating water content of the ground outside our laboratory . for this measurement
, we made several substantial improvements to the instrument used in ref .
the turntable was upgraded by a `` feet - back '' system , described in more detail in appendix [ ap : feetback ] , that kept its rotation axis vertical to better than 10 nanoradians .
the autocollimator system that monitored the pendulum twist was upgraded from that described in ref .
@xcite by using the `` two bounce '' geometry discussed in ref .
we also improved the resolution of the temperature monitoring system and upgraded the co - rotating magnetic shielding .
the overall performance of the rotating balance is shown in fig .
[ fig : fft ] . except for signals at integer multiples of the turntable frequency caused by reproduceable irregularities in the turntable drive system ,
the noise in the twist signal is close to the thermal value expected from internal losses in the tungsten suspension fiber .
systematic errors associated with the turntable signals were eliminated by combining data taken with different orientations of the pendulum within the rotating apparatus .
the heart of our apparatus is a spin pendulum , shown in fig .
[ fig : spin pendulum ] , that contains a substantial number of polarized electrons while having a negligible external magnetic moment and high gravitational symmetry .
the spin pendulum is constructed from 4 octagonal `` pucks '' .
one half of each puck is alnico 5 ( a conventional , relatively `` soft '' ferromagnet in which the magnetic field is created almost entirely by electron spins ) and the other half is grade 22 sm@xmath28co@xmath29 ( a `` hard '' rare - earth magnet in which the orbital magnetic moment of the electrons in the sm@xmath80 ion nearly cancels their spin moment@xcite ) .
the trapezoidal elements of the pucks were fabricated by electric - discharge machining and kept in precise alignment by aluminum frames .
thin plates glued to the sides of the alnico pieces compensated for their lower density , @xmath81 g/@xmath82 versus 8.3 g/@xmath82 for sm@xmath28co@xmath83 .
after each puck was assembled , we magnetized the alnico to the same degree as the sm@xmath28co@xmath83 by monitoring the external @xmath42 fields as appropriate current pulses were sent through coils temporarily wound around the pucks . by stacking 4 such pucks as shown in fig .
[ fig : spin pendulum ] , we placed the effective center of the spin dipole in the middle of the pendulum , reduced systematic magnetic - flux leakage , averaged out the small density differences between alnico and sm@xmath28co@xmath83 , and canceled any composition dipole that would have made us sensitive to violation of the weak equivalence principle .
the pucks were surrounded by a gold - coated mu - metal shield that supported 4 mirrors equally spaced around the azimuth .
the 107 g pendulum was suspended at the end of a 75 cm long tungsten fiber which in turn hung from a mode spoiler that damped the pendulum s `` wobble '' , `` swing '' and `` bounce '' oscillations but had essentially no effect on the torsional mode . during the course of this experiment 4 different fibers were employed with diameters of either @xmath84 m or @xmath85 m .
the upper attachment of the suspension fiber could be rotated to place any of the pendulum s 4 mirrors in the beam of the autocollimator system that monitored the pendulum s twist .
we measured @xmath86 , the field inside the pucks , by arranging 11 of the trapezoidal sm@xmath28co@xmath83 elements in straight line , and used an induction coil to determine the field inside the sm@xmath28co@xmath83 .
we found @xmath87 kg which was consistent with the suppliers@xcite specification of 9.85 kg .
the absolute calibration of the twist to torque conversion was done by observing the pendulum s response to an abrupt change in the turntable rotation rate as shown in fig .
[ fig : caleot ] .
the pendulum s free torsional oscillation frequency , @xmath88 mhz for this @xmath85 m diameter fiber , together with its calculated rotational inertia , determined the fiber s torsional constant @xmath89 dyne - cm / radian .
polarized neutron elastic scattering studies@xcite on sm@xmath28co@xmath29 have shown that the room - temperature magnetic moment of the sm@xmath80 ion is extremely small , @xmath90 compared to the @xmath91 moment of the five cobalts ( see appendix [ ap : spin content ] ) .
it is therefore an excellent approximation that the magnetization of sm@xmath28co@xmath83 is due entirely to the co. if we make the additional approximation ( which we relax below ) that the co and alnico magnetizations arise entirely from spins , then the net number of polarized spins in our pendulum is simply @xmath92 where @xmath86 is the magnetic field inside a puck , @xmath93 is the ratio of sm to co spin moments in room - temperature sm@xmath28co@xmath29 ( a negative quantity because the sm and co spins are directed oppositely ) , @xmath94 accounts for the puck s octagonal shapes and @xmath95 @xmath82 is the total volume of sm@xmath28co@xmath83 . as discussed in appendix
[ ap : spin content ] , we used the sm ion wavefunctions deduced from elastic neutron scattering@xcite on sm@xmath28co@xmath83 to predict that at room - temperature the spin contribution to the sm magnetic moment in sm@xmath28co@xmath83 is @xmath96 .
using data from this and other rare - earth / cobalt alloys , we estimate that the 5 co s in sm@xmath28co@xmath83 have @xmath97 and obtain @xmath98 . on the other hand , a compton scattering experiment on sm@xmath28co@xmath29 with circularly polarized synchrotron radiation@xcite , which directly probes the spin distribution rather than the magnetic field , gives @xmath99 .
we assume that @xmath93 is equally likely to lie anywhere in the interval between @xmath100 and @xmath101 with a mean value and equivalent gaussian spread of @xmath102 which implies @xmath103 .
however , as discussed in appendix [ ap : spin content ] , experiments have shown that the magnetization of alnico and of co in sm@xmath28co@xmath83 is not entirely due to spins as we assumed above . defining @xmath104 as the fractional contribution of spin to the total magnetic moment
, we obtain an improved estimate @xmath105 \nonumber\ ] ] @xmath106 where @xmath107 and @xmath108 are taken from eqs .
[ eq : f alnico ] and [ eq : f co ] below .
we show in sec .
[ sec : np calib ] below that the earth s rotation acting on the pendulum s angular momentum provided an internal calibration of @xmath109 in very good agreement with the value in eq .
[ eq : npol ] .
the potentials of interest ( eqs . [ eq : def a ] , [ eq : def b ] , [ eq : def c ] , [ eq : non - com pot ] , [ eq : mw ] and [ eq : bd ] ) all imply that the pendulum s energy has the form @xmath110 where @xmath111 represents the orientation of the pendulum s spin , and @xmath112 has a value in the laboratory frame that may depend on time .
this potential applies a torque @xmath113 on the pendulum that can be detected by measuring its induced twist .
however , only vertical torques , which are resisted by the very soft torsion spring constant , @xmath114 , produce a measurable twist ; torques in the horizontal plane are resisted by the vastly stronger gravitational spring " with an effective constant @xmath115 where @xmath46 is the pendulum mass and @xmath116 cm is the vertical distance from the pendulum s center of mass to the fiber attachment point . as a result , the pendulum s spin is confined to the local horizontal plane and rotates along with the turntable about a vertical axis .
although the pendulum does not exactly follow the turntable angle because external torques on the pendulum twist the suspension fiber by angles @xmath117 radians , to an excellent approximation , the pendulum twist , @xmath118 , as a function of turntable angle , @xmath119 , has the form @xmath120 here @xmath121 is the projection of @xmath112 on the horizontal plane , @xmath122 its azimuthal angle , and @xmath123 and @xmath124 are the north and east components of @xmath125 .
we use the convention that all angles are measured counterclockwise as seen from above , and that @xmath126 points north . the procedure for converting our twist measurements into values for @xmath123 and @xmath124
is discussed in section [ sec : extracting ] below .
the scenarios we test in this paper have signatures where @xmath112 is fixed in the laboratory ( eq . [ eq : mw ] ) , and others where @xmath112 is fixed in inertial space ( eqs .
[ eq : def a ] and [ eq : non - com pot ] ) or depends on the orientation and/or velocity of the earth s motion around the sun ( eqs . [ eq : def b ] , [ eq : def c ] and [ eq : bd ] ) .
these time - varying signatures were computed using astronomical formulae given by meeus.@xcite we neglected the earth s radius and the surface velocity associated with its spin in comparison to the astronomical unit and the earth s orbital velocity , respectively .
we constrained the rotational symmetry violating parameters of eqs .
[ eq : def a ] and [ eq : non - com pot ] by searching for a @xmath112 fixed in inertial space . even though we are sensitive only to the two horizontal components of @xmath112 , the earth s rotation allowed us to probe all three components in the inertial frame , @xmath127 \nonumber \\ & = & -(a_x\cos \omega t + a_y\sin \omega t)\sin \psi + a_z \cos\psi \nonumber \\
e}(t)&= & [ a_x\;t^{\rm e}_x(t ) + a_y\;t^{\rm e}_y(t)+a_z\;t^{\rm e}_z(t ) ] \nonumber \\ & = & -a_x \sin \omega t + a_y\cos \omega t ~. \label{eq : sidereal}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the @xmath128 coefficients project the equatorial @xmath129 system onto local n , e horizontal coordinates ; @xmath130 deg is the latitude of our laboratory , @xmath131d is the sidereal frequency and @xmath132 is the local apparent sidereal time .
we measured the boost parameters in eqs .
[ eq : def b ] and [ eq : def c ] using the motion of the earth with respect to the entire cosmos ( neglecting the much smaller velocity of our laboratory with respect to the center of the earth ) .
the velocity of the earth with respect to the rest frame of the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) is @xmath133 where @xmath134 is the velocity of the earth with respect to the sun and @xmath135 is the velocity of the sun in the cmb rest frame . in equatorial coordinates @xmath136 where @xmath137 degrees is the inclination of the ecliptic .
the ecliptic coordinate @xmath138 is perpendicular to the plane of the earth s orbit , @xmath139 , and @xmath140 so that @xmath141 where @xmath142 , the true longitude of the sun , and @xmath143 , the geocentric distance to the sun , were computed using expressions given by meeus@xcite . converting @xmath134 from ecliptic to equatorial coordinates , we have @xmath144 and @xmath145 figure [ fig : boost signals ] shows the signatures of boost - symmetry violating terms with @xmath146 ev and with @xmath147 ev .
figure [ fig : xx boost signal ] shows how the @xmath124 signature varies over the course of a year .
the boost - violating signatures , which are modulated at the sidereal , annual and annual times sidereal frequencies , can be distinguished from a violation of rotational - invariance which have only a sidereal modulation . note that the signatures of @xmath148 as well as @xmath149 , @xmath150 and @xmath151 do not have daily modulations and must be extracted from lab - fixed @xmath123 s . a @xmath1-violating monopole - dipole interaction ( eq .
[ eq : mw ] ) between the spin pendulum and the earth would give time - independent @xmath123 and @xmath124 values that depend upon the range , @xmath152 , of the interaction .
@xmath153 where @xmath154\frac{k\rho(\bm{r})}{u}d^3\bm{r}~ , \label{eq : earth source}\ ] ] where @xmath155 points from the pendulum to a source mass element with density @xmath156 , @xmath157 is a unit vector pointing n or e , @xmath158 and @xmath159 is the atomic mass unit .
this integral is , to within a constant factor , identical to that needed to evaluate the et - wash equivalence principle results@xcite , so we adopted the source integrations of those works .
as explained in refs .
@xcite , the integral can be reliably computed in two regimes : 1 m @xmath160 km ( where information from local topography and boreholes is sufficient , and @xmath161 km where smooth , layered models of the entire earth are adequate .
it is difficult to evaluate the integral in the gap region , and we have not done so .
the integrals are displayed in fig .
[ fig : source int ] . a @xmath1-violating monopole - dipole interaction ( eq .
[ eq : mw ] ) between the spins in our pendulum and the sun would give modulated @xmath123 and @xmath124 values @xmath162 where @xmath163 and @xmath164 are the altitude and azimuth ( measured eastward from north ) of the sun .
for a uniformly dense sun of mass @xmath165 and radius @xmath166 , the source integral becomes@xcite @xmath167\!\ ! \left [ \frac{r_{\odot}}{\lambda}\!+\!1 \right ] \exp\left[-\frac{r_{\odot}}{\lambda}\right]~ , \label{eq : source 1}\ ] ] where @xmath168 .
we searched for the long - range velocity - dependent boson - exchange interactions of eq .
[ eq : bd ] using the earth s velocity around the sun .
we needed , in addition to the velocity given in eq .
[ eq : velocities ] and @xmath169 , the term @xmath170 , and the source integral @xmath171 \exp\left[-\frac{r_{\odot}}{\lambda}\right]~. \label{eq : source 2}\ ] ] then @xmath172 where @xmath173 and @xmath174 are the laboratory altitude and azimuth of the ecliptic unit vectors @xmath175 , @xmath176 and @xmath177 . when evaluating the @xmath152-dependence of the couplings @xmath178 , @xmath77 and @xmath76 of eqs .
[ eq : mw ] and [ eq : bd ] , we approximated the factors @xmath93 in eqs .
[ eq : source 1]-[eq : source 2 ] by their average value @xmath179 au .
we improved our @xmath77 and @xmath76 constraints for @xmath180 au by using the moon s motion about the earth .
the moon s coordinates and velocity were evaluated using expressions from chapter 47 of meeus@xcite to compute generalizations of eqs .
[ eq : bd sun ] which are more complicated because the moon s motion does not lie in the ecliptic plane and is strongly perturbed by the gradients in the sun s field . because the pendulum s magnetic flux was confined entirely within the pucks , the stationary pendulum necessarily contained a net total angular momentum @xmath181 , where @xmath182 is the pendulum s net spin .
the magnetic fields in the two materials , @xmath183 were equal and opposite so that the net magnetic field in the pendulum s @xmath184 direction vanished .
this requires that @xmath185 where we make the excellent approximation that @xmath186 .
this implies @xmath187 to keep @xmath188 fixed in the frame of the rotating earth , the fiber has to apply a steady torque , @xmath189 , given by @xmath190 where @xmath191 is sidereal rotation frequency and @xmath192 is the local vertical .
the pendulum twists until @xmath193 , i.e. @xmath188 tries to point toward true north with a torque @xmath194 where @xmath195 is defined in eq .
[ eq : sidereal ] .
this is equivalent to a small negative ( because @xmath181 ) value @xmath196 which formed a steady , precisely known background in our study of lab - fixed signals , and allowed us to calibrate the spin content of our pendulum .
the data for this paper were taken in two distinct sets .
runs in set i were taken over a span of 18 months between august 2004 and january 2006 .
data were taken with the autocollimator beam reflected by each of the pendulum s 4 mirrors . during this period , along with acquiring normal spin - pendulum data , we made extensive studies of systematic effects from gravity - gradient and magnetic couplings and from turntable imperfections . despite considerable effort , that included changing suspension fibers and mode spoilers , we were unable to understand a slowly - varying systematic effect , and as a result
our laboratory - fixed constraints were dominated by poorly understood systematics .
this work formed the basis of our brief publication@xcite .
we then decided to tackle the problem of slowly varying systematics by constructing the 93 g `` zero - moment '' pendulum shown in fig .
[ fig : zero moment ] .
this aluminum pendulum had no net spin , was nonmagnetic and had the same moment of inertia as the spin pendulum .
it coupled negligibly to gravity gradients because it had cylindrical symmetry and very small @xmath197 , @xmath198 and @xmath199 mass moments .
in addition , we modified the fiber attachment to the pendulum so that we could reproduceably rotate the pendulum with respect to its suspension system .
as discussed below , this device revealed an unexpected systematic effect associated with the suspension system that could be canceled by combining results taken with opposite orientations of the pendulum with respect to the suspension system .
we added the new rotatable fiber attachment mechanism to the spin pendulum , and set ii runs occured between september 2006 and march 2008 .
data were taken with the light beam reflecting from each of the 4 mirrors and for 4 equally spaced angles between the pendulum and the suspension system .
the results from set ii gave much tighter lab - fixed constraints , and when combined with the set i data improved the sidereal and solar signals published in ref .
over the course of this experiment the turntable rotation frequency , @xmath104 , was set at values between @xmath202 and @xmath203 , where @xmath204 is the free - oscillation frequency of the pendulum .
we recorded the pendulum twist angle @xmath118 as a function of the angle @xmath119 of the turntable ( measured counter clock - wise from north ) , and converted it to torque , as described in ref .
briefly , data were divided into `` cuts '' each of which contained exactly 2 revolutions of the turntable , lasted no more than 3800 s and typically contained 254 data points .
a simple digital filter was applied to suppress the free oscillations .
the twist data from each cut were then fitted by 2nd - order polynomial `` drift '' terms ( typical drift was @xmath205rad / h ) and harmonic terms @xmath206 our signal was contained in the @xmath207 coefficients that we denote below as @xmath208 and @xmath209 , where @xmath210 is the angle of the pendulum ( normally its spin dipole ) with respect to the turntable and @xmath211 is the angle between the pendulum and its suspension system .
we converted the @xmath212 and @xmath213 signals for each cut into @xmath123 and @xmath124 values using @xmath214= \left[\ !
\begin{array}{rr}\cos \phi_{\rm d } & \sin \phi_{\rm d } \\
-\sin \phi_{\rm d } & \cos \phi_{\rm d } \end{array}\!\right]\!\ ! \left[\ ! \begin{array}{r } \delta_{\rm
\delta_{\rm e } \end{array}\!\right ] + \left[\
! \begin{array}{r }
\delta_{\rm n}^{\rm t}(\phi_{s } ) \\\delta_{\rm e}^{\rm t}(\phi_{s } ) \end{array}\!\right ] + \nonumber \\
\left[\ ! \begin{array}{rr }
\cos(\phi_{\rm d}\!+\!\phi_{\rm s } ) & \sin(\phi_{\rm d}\!+\!\phi_{\rm s } ) \\
-\sin(\phi_{\rm d}\!+\!\phi_{\rm s } ) & \cos(\phi_{\rm d}\!+\!\phi_{\rm s})\end{array}\!\right]\!\!\left[\ ! \begin{array}{r }
\delta_{\rm n}^{\rm s } \\ \delta_{\rm e}^{\rm s}\end{array}\!\right]~. \label{eq : lab - fixed decomp}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the fit parameters ( @xmath215 , @xmath216 ) are the twists associated with the pendulum itself , so that @xmath217 while ( @xmath218 , @xmath219 ) and ( @xmath220 , @xmath221 ) are spurious twists associated with the orientations of the suspension system and turntable rotation - rate irregularities , respectively . for data taken with the @xmath222 m fiber , @xmath223 nrad corresponds to @xmath224 ev . when analyzing our results for astronomically modulated signals , it was sufficient to ignore the last matrix product term on the right hand side of eq .
[ eq : lab - fixed decomp ] .
we adopted the strategy of ref .
@xcite and assumed that @xmath112 s modulated at daily , sidereal or yearly periods could be treated as essentially constant during any one cut .
this approximation attenuated sidereal signals by at most 0.3% and was neglected .
we used linear regression to fit these measured @xmath112 s with the expected signatures at the midpoint of each cut .
our input consisted of 93 data sets ( with durations ranging from 1 to 5 days ) containing 8471 cuts and spanned a total of 1110 days .
we minimized our sensitivity to slow drifts in our signals by zeroing the average values of the twist signals in each data set as well as any steady average value of the predicted signatures .
the individual data sets were weighted by the inverse - squares of the spread of the @xmath225 s in that set .
we constrained @xmath226 in eq .
[ eq : def a ] by fitting our data with the two free parameters @xmath227 and @xmath228 given in eq .
[ eq : sidereal ] .
figure [ fig : typical data ] shows a typical data set and the fit .
the helicity term in eq .
[ eq : def b ] was constrained by fitting eq .
[ eq : b signal ] with the single free parameter @xmath42 .
an analysis with 6 free parameters provided the constraints on the 6 modulated boost - symmetry violating @xmath229 terms in eqs .
[ eq : def c ] and [ eq : c signal ] ( only 6 of the 9 @xmath230 s produce modulated signals because spins pointing along @xmath184 give a vanishing e signal and a steady n signal ) .
limits on the boson exchange potentials defined in eqs .
[ eq : mw ] and [ eq : bd ] obtained using the sun as a source were found by fitting eqs .
[ eq : cp sun ] and [ eq : bd sun ] with the 3 free parameters @xmath231 , @xmath76 and @xmath77 .
because of the inclination of the earth s rotation axis , these torques have components modulated with a 24 hour period as well as annual modulations .
in every case , the resulting fit had @xmath232 . because the individual data sets were normalized to @xmath233 , a @xmath232 for the combined 93 data sets showed that there was no evidence for any anomalous behavior .
the sidereal or solar modulation of the signatures eliminated many systematic effects that were fixed in the lab ; as a consequence our bounds on @xmath234 and @xmath235 and on the 6 modulated @xmath236 terms are tighter than those on @xmath148 or @xmath149 , @xmath150 and @xmath151 which are based on the lab - fixed limits discussed below ( see tables [ tab : a params ] and [ tab : c params ] in sec .
[ sec : results ] ) .
we analyzed our @xmath123 and @xmath124 data for torques fixed in the lab frame by combining the signals observed for 4 equally - spaced angles , @xmath210 , of the spin dipole within the rotating apparatus .
as described in ref .
@xcite , we observed a scatter that was larger than our statistical uncertainties .
this prompted us to study lab - fixed systematic effects with the `` zero - moment '' pendulum .
we analyzed data taken on all 4 mirrors and with two opposite orientations of the suspension system with respect to the pendulum using eq .
[ eq : lab - fixed decomp ] , where the @xmath210 was defined by a ficticious zero mark on the pendulum .
the results , shown in fig . [ fig : ballcone ] , revealed an unexpected systematic effect associated with the pendulum suspension system , along with the known turntable systematic .
figure [ fig : ballcone ] shows that @xmath220 and @xmath221 changed slightly every time we stopped the turntable and opened the vacuum system to change @xmath211 .
therefore those parameters are shown as functions of @xmath211 in eq .
[ eq : lab - fixed decomp ] .
there was no resolvable systematic effect associated with the pendulum .
we therefore base all our lab - fixed constraints on the set ii data , which did not suffer from the suspension systematic .
spin - pendulum data were acquired with 4 orientations of the pendulum with respect to the rotating apparatus , and for 2 or 4 orthogonal orientations of of the suspension system with respect to the pendulum .
three such measurements were taken : measurement 1 ( centered around october 15 , 2006 ) , measurement 2 ( centered around june 15 , 2007 ) , and measurement 3 ( centered around march 8 , 2008 ) .
we used eqs .
[ eq : lab - fixed decomp ] and [ eq : betas ] to extract from each of these measurement `` true '' @xmath123 and @xmath124 values that depended only on the orientation of the spin dipole .
the extracted values of @xmath123 and @xmath124 for one of these measurements are plotted in fig .
[ fig : phase ii lab fixed ] .
a highly significant signal was observed ( see table [ tab : phase ii lab fixed ] below ) that points within @xmath237 degrees of due south ; it agrees well with the expected gyro - compass effects discussed in sec .
[ sec : gyro ] .
the interactions in eqs . [ eq : def a]@xmath238[eq : bd ] all produce 1@xmath239 twist signals .
any other mechanism that can produce a 1@xmath239 signal is a potential source of systematic error .
we present below systematic error analyses for two types of such effects : lab - fixed signals whose amplitude and phase are constant in time and astronomical signals whose amplitude and phase vary as the earth rotates relative to the astronomical source .
( average daily variations of some important environmental parameters are given in table [ tab : daily var ] ) .
in addition to such `` false effects '' , we evaluate scale factor uncertainties in @xmath109 , the number of polarized electrons in our pendulum . .average daily components the systematic effects [ cols="^,^ " , ] [ tab : phase ii lab fixed ] our complete constraint on the electron s lorentz - symmetry violating rotation parameter @xmath18 is displayed in table [ tab : a params ] ;
it is roughly two orders of magnitude more restrictive than previous work by hou _
et al._@xcite , ccc parameter & this work & hou et al.@xcite + + @xmath234 & @xmath240 & @xmath241 + @xmath235 & @xmath242 & @xmath243 + @xmath148 & @xmath244 & @xmath245 + [ tab : a params ] lrlrlr parameter & value & parameter & value + + @xmath246 & @xmath247 & @xmath248 & @xmath249 + @xmath250 & @xmath251 & @xmath252 & @xmath253 + @xmath254 & @xmath255 & @xmath256 & @xmath257 + @xmath149 & @xmath258 & & & + @xmath150 & @xmath259 + @xmath151 & @xmath260 & & [ tab : c params ] and substantially below the benchmark value @xmath17 ev . our @xmath14 constraint on the electron s helicity - generating parameter @xmath42 is @xmath261 table [ tab : c params ] displays our limits on the electron s generalized helicity tensor @xmath22 .
we are not aware of any comparable measurements of either @xmath42 or @xmath236 .
the minimal standard model extension or sme incorporates the possibility of lorentz and @xmath44 violation by invoking pervasive , feeble , static spin 1 and spin 2 fields that are defined in the heliocentric frame ( for electrons in minkowski spacetime 44 free parameters are involved ) .
we follow conventional experimental practice@xcite and first ignore possible violations of boost symmetry .
then our constraints on @xmath262 ( table [ tab : a params ] ) translate directly to constraints on the sme parameters @xmath263 .
table [ tab : kost params e , p , n ] compares the electron s @xmath264 parameters to the corresponding proton and neutron parameters determined from hydrogen maser@xcite and dual @xmath265xe/@xmath266he maser measurements@xcite .
the neutron and electron parameters have comparable upper limits .
the hydrogen maser results have an uncertainty @xmath267 times greater so , in effect , they place a substantially weaker limit on @xmath264 of the proton . cccc parameter & electron & proton & neutron + + @xmath268 & @xmath240 & @xmath269 & @xmath270 + @xmath271 & @xmath242 & @xmath269 & @xmath272 + @xmath273 & @xmath244 & & + [ tab : kost params e , p , n ] we constrained boost terms in the sme by reevaluating our limits after setting the velocity of the sun to zero .
the resulting boost - dependent coefficients are denoted by primes .
the sidereally modulated data were fitted with 6 free parameters , @xmath234 , @xmath235 , @xmath274 , @xmath275 , @xmath276 and @xmath277 .
in addition , we used the lab - fixed results in table [ tab : phase ii lab fixed ] to constrain @xmath148 , @xmath278 and @xmath279 the @xmath13 and @xmath280 coefficients determine@xcite the following combinations of sme parameters @xmath281/2 \nonumber\\ c^{\prime}_{xy}&\!= & ( \tilde{d}_{xy}-\tilde{h}_{zt})+\tan{\epsilon}\,\tilde{h}_{yt } \nonumber\\ % c^{\prime}_{xz}&\!= & \sin{\epsilon}\tilde{h}_{yt } \nonumber \\ c^{\prime}_{yx}&\!= & \tilde{h}_{zt}\nonumber\\ c^{\prime}_{yy}&\!= & \![2\tilde{g}_c-\tilde{g}_t-\tilde{b}_t+4\tilde{d}_{+}-\tilde{d}_- -\tilde{d}_q]/2 + \nonumber \\ & ~&~\tan\epsilon\,[\tilde{d}_{yz}-\tilde{h}_{xt } ] \nonumber \\ % c^{\prime}_{yz}&\!=&\sin\epsilon[\tilde{d}_{yz}-\tilde{h}_{xt } ] \nonumber \\ c^{\prime}_{zx}&\!= & \tilde{h}_{yt}-\tilde{d}_{zx}~~\;\;\;\;\;\;\;\;\;\;~~ c^{\prime}_{zy}\!= -\tilde{h}_{xt } \nonumber\\ c^{\prime}_{zz}&\!= & [ \tilde{g}_t-2\tilde{d}_+ + \tilde{d}_q]~.\end{aligned}\ ] ] our values for these parameters are listed in table [ tab : b hat e , n ] . lr parameter & electron value ( gev ) + + @xmath234 & @xmath282 + @xmath235 & @xmath283 + @xmath148 & @xmath284 + @xmath285 & @xmath286 + @xmath287 & @xmath288 + @xmath289 & @xmath290 + @xmath291 & @xmath292 + @xmath293 & @xmath294 + @xmath295 & @xmath296 + [ tab : b hat e , n ] the result in eq .
[ eq : b value ] provides a limit on @xmath297 ( see eq . [ eq : thaler mu ] ) of @xmath298 which improves on the value given in ref .
@xcite by three orders of magnitude .
the corresponding 95% confidence constraint on the `` ghost condensate parameter '' @xmath299 is shown as a function of @xmath46 in fig .
[ fig : thaler ] .
a condensate - mediated spin - spin interaction with a strength comparable to gravity would have the ghost condensate parameter @xmath300@xcite .
inserting the constraint on @xmath301 from table [ tab : a params ] into eq .
[ eq : non - com pot ] , we obtain an @xmath14 upper limit on @xmath55 , the minimum observable patch of area , @xmath302 tev , corresponds to energy scales of @xmath303 gev for @xmath304 or @xmath305 and @xmath306 gev for @xmath307 . many theorists ( see refs .
@xcite for a recent review ) have speculated that the reimann geometry of general relativity should be replaced by the more general reimann - cartan geometry that contains an additional non - symmetric field called torsion .
torsion does not directly couple to unpolarized matter and hence is difficult to detect ; however torsion s fully - antisymmetric axial component @xmath308 is minimally coupled through covariant derivatives to fermion spins .
lmmerzahl@xcite noted that results from hughes - drever experiments can place useful bounds on @xmath309 , and kosteleck , russell and tasson@xcite recently showed how experiments , such as the one we report here , determine all three spatial components of @xmath308 . following ref .
@xcite , we find for minimal coupling ( ref .
@xcite considers more complex cases as well ) that our results in table [ tab : a params ] constrain any background torsion field ( assumed to be roughly constant over the region of the solar system ) to @xmath310 the constraints on @xmath1-violating monopole - dipole interactions extracted from our lab - fixed and solar and lunar - source data are shown in fig .
[ fig : constraints ] ( see also table [ tab : dobr params ] ) .
this new work improves over previous work@xcite by factors of up to @xmath267 .
the limits on velocity - dependent boson - exchange forces , extracted from our experimental bounds on interactions between the spin pendulum and the sun are given in table [ tab : dobr params ] .
figure [ fig : fermilab range dependence ] shows range - dependence of the velocity - dependent couplings @xmath77 and @xmath76 .
we are not aware of any previous measurements of such forces .
lcc parameter & solar constraint & lunar constraint + + @xmath311 & @xmath312 & @xmath313 + @xmath314 & @xmath315 & @xmath316 + @xmath317 & @xmath318 & @xmath319 [ tab : dobr params ] it may be of some interest to interpret our constraints as an `` equivalence - principle '' test for intrinsic spin , i.e. to ask if the gravitational mass of an electron with its spin pointing toward the sun is identical to that of an electron whose spin points away from the sun . in this case
the relevant parameter is @xmath320_{\rm
t}-[m_g]_{\rm a}}{\frac{1}{2}([m_g]_{\rm t}+[m_g]_{\rm a})}=\frac{2\beta_{\rm sun}}{v_n}~,\ ] ] where the subscripts t and a refer to an electron whose spin points toward or away from the sun , @xmath321 is the component of our signal @xmath112 that tracks the sun , and @xmath322 ev is the newtonian potential energy of a laboratory electron in the field of the sun .
we find that @xmath323 ev , which leads to @xmath324 where the errors are @xmath14 .
a considerably tighter limit comes from considering electrons falling toward the center of our galaxy . in this case @xmath325 where @xmath326 km / s is the velocity of the solar system around the center of the galaxy , which gives @xmath327 ev . in this case
we find @xmath328 ev , which leads to @xmath329 the absolute `` gyrocompass '' calibration of the spin content of our pendulum in eq .
[ eq : np from gyro ] provides a clean comparison of the spin density , @xmath330 , of room - temperature grade 22 smco@xmath29 to that of alnico 5 , @xmath331 when the smco@xmath29 and alnico have identical magnetizations of @xmath332 kg .
the quantities @xmath333 and @xmath334 are defined in eq .
[ eq : npol 0th approx ] .
we have neglected the very small measured magnetic moment ( @xmath335 ) of sm in smco@xmath29 compared to the co moment ( @xmath336 ) , so that the equality of the magnetic fields in the two materials implies that the magnetizations satisfied @xmath337 .
the spin density in alnico is @xmath338 where @xmath339 is taken from eq .
[ eq : f alnico ] . therefore @xmath340
we have shown that a torsion balance fitted with a spin pendulum can achieve a constraint of @xmath341 ev on the energy required to flip an electron spin about an arbitrary direction fixed in inertial space .
this is comparable to the electrostatic energy of two electrons separated by 90 au .
we then use this and related constraints to set sensitive limits on preferred - frame effects and non - commutative spacetime geometries .
our upper limits on the electron s rotation - noninvariant parameters @xmath342 ev and @xmath343 ev are substantially smaller than previous work@xcite and up to 5 orders of magnitude below the benchmark value @xmath344 ev .
corresponding constraints on preferred - frame effects involving protons and neutrons are given in refs .
@xcite and @xcite .
interpreting our results as a constraint on non - commutative geometries we find that the minimum `` observable '' area is @xmath345 or @xmath346 m@xmath347 , which corresponds to a length scale @xmath348 where @xmath349 .
( our limit @xmath350 m@xmath347 is weaker because it is derived from a lab - fixed signal which has a larger scale factor uncertainty . )
these limits assume that the electron remains point - like up to an energy scale of 1 tev . by analyzing 17 months of data
, we obtained the first constraint on all 9 components of the lorentz violating `` boost '' parameter @xmath22 for any particle .
our upper limits on the absolute values of these components ranges between @xmath351 and @xmath352 ev . to facilitate sme analyses
, we also present constraints on @xmath353 , the tensor helicity with respect to the sun .
our electron constraints have roughly the same sensitivity as related neutron constraints obtained with a dual - gas maser@xcite . our constraints on @xmath1-violating monopole - dipole interactions , derived from laboratory - fixed and solar - source signals , improve on previous work by factors of up to @xmath267 , while our results for interactions between the spin pendulum and the sun or moon provide the first sensitive test for exotic spin - and - velocity - dependent interactions of electrons .
finally , our observation of the gyrocompass effect on the electron spins provides a precise result bearing on the electronic spin structure of sm@xmath354co@xmath29 . if we assume that effects from exotic physics are negligible , our measurements determine the density of polarized electrons in sm@xmath354co@xmath29 is @xmath355 at a field of 9.6 kg .
we are now taking a new series of measurements that probe the interaction between two spins .
this work is motivated by the recent development of a consistent model of gravity with spontaneous lorentz - symmetry violation@xcite that predicts dramatic new spin - spin forces .
these new experiments also probe the velocity - independent spin - spin forces@xcite that can arise from generic boson exchange .
michael harris and stefan baeler developed earlier versions of this apparatus .
their work provided us with essential experience that made this result possible .
jens gundlach and cd hoyle made useful comments about this experiment and erik swanson helped prepare some of the figures .
we thank nilendra deshpande , bogdan dobrescu , david kaplan , alan kosteleck and jesse thaler for inspiring conversations , and tom murphy , jr for advice on the astronomical calculations .
this work was supported by nsf grants phy0355012 and phy0653863 and by doe funding for the center for experimental nuclear physics and astrophysics .
cec is grateful for an nsf fellowship .
the composition of alnico 5 by weight is 51% fe , 24% co , 14% ni , 8% al and 3% cu and its magnetization arises primarily from the polarized spins of 3d electrons in the fe and co. the orbital moment of these electrons is small because of quenching in the inhomogeneous crystalline electric fields@xcite .
the polarized spins are confined to small , needle - shaped regions of fe - co alloy that precipitate out during heat treatment .
although we are not aware of direct measurements of the spin and orbital moments of alnico 5 , we can infer the spin fraction from `` einstein - de haas '' measurements@xcite of the magneto - mechanical factors , @xmath356 , of magnetically `` softer '' fe - co alloys .
the @xmath356 measurements determine , @xmath104 , the fractional spin contribution to the magnetic moment via @xmath357 table [ tab : spin fraction ] gives the measured spin fractions in various fe - co alloys .
we adopt the mean and standard deviation of these values for the alnico spin fraction , @xmath358 cccc % fe & % co & @xmath356 & @xmath104 + + 75 & 25 & @xmath359 & 0.957 + 50 & 50 & @xmath360 & 0.956 + 25 & 75 & @xmath361 & 0.949 + [ tab : spin fraction ] although the magnetization of cobalt in sm@xmath28co@xmath29 , as that of alnico , arises primarily from polarized 3d electrons , the orbital moments are not as fully quenched because the rare earth atom alters the crystal lattice structure .
neutron@xcite and photon@xcite scattering studies , as well as nmr experiments@xcite , have shown that the co atoms in r@xmath28co@xmath29 ( r is one of the rare earth elements ) occupy two different crystal sites ; 2 atoms in the 2c site ( co@xmath362 ) and 3 in the 3 g site ( co@xmath363 ) .
although the spin fraction of the co magnetization in sm@xmath28co@xmath29 has not been measured , experiments consistently find that the co magnetic moments in r@xmath28co@xmath29 compounds are independent of temperature and , as shown in table [ tab : spin fraction co ] , vary only slightly across the rare earth series .
we assume that the co spin fractions also vary only slightly with r to infer @xmath364 and @xmath365 for sm@xmath366co@xmath29 as given in table [ tab : spin fraction co ] . lcccc compound & @xmath367 ) & @xmath364 & @xmath368 & @xmath365 + + y@xmath28co@xmath29 & @xmath369 & 0.74(5 ) & @xmath370 & 0.84(4 ) + ce@xmath28co@xmath29 & & 0.76 & & 0.90 + sm@xmath28co@xmath29 & @xmath371 & 0.72(6 ) & @xmath372 & 0.85(6 ) + nd@xmath28co@xmath29 & @xmath373 & 0.67(5 ) & @xmath374 & 0.80(3 ) [ tab : spin fraction co ] the total spin moment of the 5 co atoms @xmath375 which implies that @xmath376 the sm atoms in sm@xmath28co@xmath29 are in the @xmath377 ionic state with a @xmath378 electronic configuration .
hund s rules predict that the free sm@xmath80 ion s orbital momentum has the largest possible antisymmetric value of @xmath379 and that the spins are in the symmetric @xmath380 state .
therefore one expects large orbital as well as spin contributions to the magnetic moment .
one also expects that the ion s ground state has @xmath381 and @xmath382 coupled to the minimum @xmath383 .
this simple model predicts @xmath384 , @xmath385 and @xmath386 .
however , the sm ions are embedded in a lattice and the crystalline and exchange fields alter this simple picture .
neutron scattering experiments@xcite on sm@xmath28co@xmath29 find that @xmath387 at a temperature of 4.2k .
however , at room temperature , @xmath388 becomes comparable to the splitting of the magnetic substates and thermal population of the various @xmath389 states causes the measured sm magnetic moment to be very small , @xmath390@xcite . using the sm wavefunctions in ref .
@xcite , we calculate that at the temperature maintained during our experiments @xmath391 the x - ray magnetic compton scattering measurement reported in ref .
@xcite probes the spin moment of sm in sm@xmath28co@xmath29 directly , but provides no information about the total magnetic moment . the ratio of co to sm spin moments from this measurement , @xmath392 , together with eq .
[ eq : mu_s co ] , corresponds to @xmath393 our calculation of the number of polarized electrons in our pendulum , eq .
[ eq : npol ] , depends on @xmath93 , the ratio of sm to co spin moments .
the neutron scattering results in eqs .
[ eq : mu_s sm ] and [ eq : mu_s co ] give @xmath394 on the other hand the photon scattering work@xcite directly gives @xmath395 we accomodate this difference by assuming that @xmath93 is equally likely to lie anywhere between these two values .
we developed a digital feedback system that continuously corrects for the varying tilt of the laboratory floor and imperfections in the turntable itself .
it analyses inputs from an orthogonal pair of co - rotating electronic tilt sensors and , every 2 complete revolutions of the turntable , computes the tilt as a function of turntable angle and cancels this predicted tilt by controlling the length of feet that support the turntable .
the performance of the leveling system is shown in fig . [ fig : feetback ] which demonstrates that the system compensates not only for the slowly - varying tilt of the laboratory floor but also for the more rapid variations caused by imperfections in the turntable bearing .
the tilt is measured by applied geomechanics inc .
inclinonometers ( agi s ) mounted on the rotating apparatus close to the upper attachment point of the pendulum s suspension fiber .
a constant tilt of the rotation axis appears as a 1@xmath239 signal on each agi , with a @xmath396 phase difference between the two units .
the analog signals of the agi s are digitized by the data acquisition system and analyzed to determine the tilt with a precision of @xmath397 .
this tilt is then removed by adjusting the lengths of 2 of the 3 feet upon which the apparatus rests .
the lengths of the two feet are are controlled by varying their temperatures .
figure [ fig : feet design ] shows a cross section through one foot .
the expanding and shrinking components of a foot consist of two lead rings ( 1 ) which are soldered to a copper disk ( 2 ) .
thermal energy can be pumped into or out of the copper disk by a peltier element ( 3 ) thermally coupled to a brass block ( 4 ) that is held at constant temperature by circulating water from a temperature - stabilized reservoir .
two g10 rings ( 5 ) thermally isolate the lead rings from the laboratory floor and from a stainless steel disk on top , upon which the apparatus rests .
the peltier element and the brass block are clamped to the copper disk by one bolt ( 6 ) .
specially formed g10 pieces provide thermal isolation between the bolt , the copper disk and the brass block .
the thermal capacity and thermal resistance of the copper disk and the lead rings produce a 14-second delay in the expansion of the lead rings compared to the change in the heat flux provided by the peltier element .
in addition , the thermal conductivity of the peltier element , which connects the copper disk to the temperature reservoir , affects the time constant of the response . taking these factors into account
, we developed a model , shown in fig .
[ fig : thermal model ] , to predict a foot s response to a change in heat flux delivered by its peltier element .
the model poses no problem for a real - time calculation because it can be solved analytically .
the delayed response of the feet together with an 8-second integration time of the agi s leads to a low - pass behavior of the leveling system .
therefore the response of the feet to fast changes of the tilt caused by imperfections of the ball bearings in the turntable is limited .
the tilt caused by the imperfections of the bearing is periodic in the turntable angle .
this allowed us to express the bearing tilt in fourier coefficients of the turntable angle .
once these fourier coefficients are calculated , they are fed forward to compensate for the bearing imperfections . a simplified flow chart of the feedback loop is shown in fig .
[ fig : thermal model ] . with
the feetback switched on , a typical tilt of a few @xmath398rad per day is reduced to less than @xmath399nrad .
after the simple model described above was implemented , we found it necessary to add one further refinement .
the dc offsets of the agi s drift slowly in time . a feedback system that holds constant the agi signals does not guarantee true level . with the feedback on , a drifting offset produces a 1@xmath239 agi signal with the opposite phase lag between the two sensors compared to a true tilt .
our model extracts this fourier component and uses it to determine the agi readings that correspond to true level .
et al . _ ,
lett . * 97 * , 021603 ( 2006 ) .
d. colladay and v. a. kosteleck , phys .
d * 55 * , 6760 ( 1997 ) ; phys .
d * 58 * , 116002 ( 1998 ) ; v. a. kosteleck , phys .
d * 69 * , 105009 ( 2004 ) . v. a. kosteleck and n. russell , arxiv:0801.0287 ( 2008 ) .
r. bluhm and v. a. kosteleck , phys .
* 84 * , 1381 ( 2000 ) . n.
arkani - hamed _
_ , j. high energy phys . * 0405 * , 074 ( 2004 ) .
n. arkani - hamed h - c .
cheng , m. luty , and j. thaler , j. high energy phys . * 07 * , 029 ( 2005 ) .
carroll , j.a .
harvey , v.a .
kosteleck , c.d . lane and t.
okamoto , phys .
* 87 * , 141601 ( 2001 ) .
i. hinchliffe , n. kersting and y.l .
ma , int . j. mod
. phys . * a19 * , 179 ( 2004 ) ; hep - ph/0205040 .
a. anisimov , t. banks , m. dine and m. graesser , phys .
d * 65 * , 085032 ( 2002 ) ; hep - ph/0106356 .
j. e. moody and f. wilczek , phys .
d * 30 * , 130 ( 1984 ) .
b. a. dobrescu and i. mocioiu , j. high energy phys .
* 0611 * , 5 ( 2006 ) ; hep - ph/0605342 . s. baeler _
et al_. , phys .
. lett . * 83 * , 3585 ( 1999 ) .
et al . _ ,
d * 50 * , 3614 ( 1994 ) . c. d. hoyle _
et al . _ ,
d * 70 * , 042004 ( 2004 ) .
d. givord , j. laforest , j. schweizer and f. tasset , j. appl . phys .
* 50 * , 2008 ( 1979 ) .
p. tils , m. loewenhaupt , k. h. j. buschow and r. s. eccleston , j. alloys and compounds * 289 * , 28 ( 1999 ) .
a. koizumi , n. sakai , n. shirai and m. ando , j. phys .
japan * 66 * , 318 ( 1997 ) .
magnet sales and manufacturing , inc .
( www.magnetsales.com ) .
j. meeus , _ astronomical algorithms , 2nd edition _ , willman - bell , richmond va ( 1998 ) .
e. g. adelberger _
et al . _ , phys .
d * 42 * , 3267 ( 1990 ) .
m. m. nieto , t. goldman and r.j .
hughes , phys .
d * 36 * , 3688 ( 1987 ) .
l. s. hou , w. t. ni , and yu - chum .
li , phys .
* 90 * , 201101 - 1 ( 2003 ) .
d. f. phillips _ et al_. , phys .
d * 63 * , 111101(r ) ( 2001 ) .
m. a. humphrey _
a * 68 * , 063807 ( 2003 ) .
et al_. , phys .
* 93 * , 230801 ( 2004 ) .
v. a. kosteleck , private communication ( 2007 ) .
a. n. youdin , d. krause , k. jagannathan , l. r. hunter and s. k. lamoreaux , phys .
lett . * 77 * , 2170 ( 1996 ) . w. t. ni , s. s. pan , h. c. yeh , l. s. hou and j. wan , , phys . rev
. lett . * 82 * , 2439 ( 1999 ) .
d. j. wineland , j. j. bollinger , d. j. heinzen , w. m. itano , m. g. raizen , phys . rev .
* 67 * , 1735 ( 1991 ) .
i.l . shapiro , phys . rep .
, * 357 * , 113 ( 2002 ) . c. lmmerzahl , phys .
a * * 2**28 , 233 ( 1997 ) .
kosteleck , n. russell and j.d .
tasson , phys .
lett . * 100 * , 111102 ( 2008 ) .
r. m. bozorth , _ ferromagnetism _ , van nostrand , new york , ny ( 1951 ) . g. g. scott and h. w. sturner , phys . rev . * 184 * , 490 ( 1969 ) . j. schweizer and f. tasset , j. phys
. f , * 10 * , 2799 ( 1980 ) .
d. givord , j. laforest , r. lemaire and q. lu , j. mag . and
mag . mat . * 31 - 34 * , 191 ( 1983 ) .
h. yoshie _ et al .
_ , j. phys .
japan * 57 * , 2525 ( 1988 ) .
h. mller _
et al . _ ,
* 99 * , 050401 ( 2007 ) . | we used a torsion pendulum containing @xmath0 polarized electrons to search new interactions that couple to electron spin .
we limit cp - violating interactions between the pendulum s electrons and unpolarized matter in the earth or the sun , test for rotation and boost - dependent preferred - frame effects using the earth s rotation and velocity with respect to the entire cosmos , and search for exotic velocity - dependent potentials between polarized electrons and unpolarized matter in the sun and moon .
we find @xmath1-violating parameters @xmath2 and @xmath3 for @xmath4au .
we test for preferred - frame interactions of the form @xmath5 , @xmath6 , or @xmath7 , where @xmath8 is the velocity of the earth with respect to the cmb restframe and @xmath9 represent the equatorial inertial coordinates @xmath10,@xmath11 and @xmath12 .
we constrain all 3 components of @xmath13 , obtaining @xmath14 upper limits @xmath15 ev and @xmath16 ev that may be compared to the benchmark value @xmath17 ev . interpreting our constraint on @xmath18 in terms of non - commutative geometry , we obtain an upper bound of @xmath19 on the minimum observable area , where @xmath20 gev ) is the grand unification length . we find that @xmath21 ev .
all 9 components of @xmath22 are constrained at the @xmath23 to @xmath24 ev level .
we determine 9 linear combinations of parameters of the standard model extension ; rotational - noninvariant and boost - noninvariant terms are limited at roughly the @xmath25 gev and @xmath26 gev levels , respectively .
finally , we find that the gravitational mass of an electron spinning toward the galactic center differs by less than about 1 part in @xmath27 from an electron spinning in the opposite direction . as a byproduct of this work , the density of polarized electrons in sm@xmath28co@xmath29 was measured to be @xmath30 at a field of 9.6 kg . |
light beams propagating in optically uniaxial crystals , with two principal dielectric indexes , exhibit birefringence or double refraction , _
i.e. _ decomposition of an input beam into ordinary ( o ) and extraordinary ( e ) beams with orthogonal linear polarizations .
the extraordinary beam is laterally shifted with respect to the ordinary one , being this shift equal to zero when the input beam propagates along the optic axis .
the intensity distribution between the o- and e- beams , expressed by the malus law , depends only on one parameter : the relative orientation of the crystal with respect to the polarization plane of the input beam .
biaxial crystals ( bcs ) , with three different principal dielectric indexes and two optic axes , also exhibit double refraction .
nevertheless , propagation of light beams along the optic axis is substantially different from the uniaxial case .
hamilton predicted that , in this case , the beam should propagate conically inside the crystal and emerge as a hollow cylinder yielding an annular transverse intensity pattern or light ring of internal conical refraction ( cr ) @xcite . simultaneously to this prediction , hamilton also demonstrated that an infinity of wave - vectors distributed on a hollow cone entering in the a biaxial crystal along the biradial propagate with common poynting vector along the latter one , the so - called external conical refraction . soon afterwards
hamilton s prediction , lloyd reported the first experimental observation of both internal and external cr @xcite and since then few experimental works have further studied cr experimentally ( see @xcite and references therein ) .
recently , internal cr has been applied to the laser technique @xcite , for optical micromanipulation @xcite and for free space optical communications @xcite .
firsts theoretical efforts to describe precisely the internal conical refraction phenomenon were started by portigal and burstein @xcite .
the complete calculation according to fourier analysis was performed by lalor @xcite and by schell and bloembergen @xcite and later on rewritten by belsky and khapalyuk @xcite , belsky and stepanov @xcite and berry and jeffrey @xcite . from the experimental point of view , the full validation of the internal cr was given by fve and coworkers @xcite .
however , a simple analytical formulation capable of predicting the transverse intensity pattern at the lloyd ( focal ) plane after a light beam propagates along or near the optic axis of a biaxial crystal ( or a cascade of bcs @xcite ) is still lacking . in this article
, we experimentally address this last need by analyzing the wave - vector and polarization dependence of the internal cr phenomenon . in the following
we will refer to internal cr simply as cr .
our experimental scheme is based on the propagation of elliptical beams ( ebs ) along the optic axis of a bc .
ebs do not possesses continuous cylindrical symmetry , at variance with gaussian beams typically used in conical refraction experiments . in section 2
, we demonstrate that ebs do not produce the otherwise expected transverse annular intensity pattern when they propagate through the bc , but split into two refracted beams with orthogonal linear polarizations .
simple phenomenological expressions for the position and the intensity of the refracted beams are derived in section 3 .
worth noticing , we show that the position of the refracted beams is defined not only by the crystal orientation , but also by the input beam properties , in particular , by the orientation of the preselected plane of input wave - vectors . additionally , we demonstrate that the intensity distribution between the two refracted beams can be well described with a single angular parameter . when the biaxial crystal is rotated , the intensity distribution between the two refracted beams follows the transformation law recently pointed out by loiko _ et al . _
@xcite for cr filtered beams , that differs from the well known malus law for double refraction in uniaxial crystals . to verify the usefulness of the phenomenological transformation rules
, we apply them in section 4 to calculate the resulting intensity pattern for an incident axicon beam and confirm our approach with experimental results .
section 5 summarizes the main results and conclusions of the work .
conical refraction has been reported only for input beams with intensity pattern possessing continuous cylindrical ( rotation ) symmetry around the propagation axis , see fig . [ fig1](a ) and fig .
[ fig1](c ) .
this has been motivated by hamilton s prediction of the cr within the ray optics description , where rays are always associated with cylindrically symmetric collimated beams .
real beams of finite size can be modeled as a bundle of rays with propagation directions isotropically distributed around the beam axis . on the one hand , according to the modified hamilton theory @xcite , cr can be interpreted as a wave - vector and polarization dependent type of double refraction , when each ray of the input bundle refracts into two rays at the entrance crystal surface and all refracted rays form a cone . in this process ,
the two refracted rays go to opposite points on the cr ring .
on the other hand , it has been also demonstrated that in cr the transverse wave - vector components are conserved @xcite .
this means that all input rays ( plane waves ) with wave - vectors confined in a certain plane defined by an azimuthal angle @xmath0 refract to a plane with the same azimuthal angle at the lloyd plane , _
i.e. _ into two opposite points on the cr ring .
therefore , double refraction along the optic axis of a bc and , in particular , the wave - vector and polarization dependence of the cr , can be studied with linearly polarized beams composed from plane waves whose wave - vectors are confined in a certain plane .
such beams are known as cylindrical beams and elliptical beams ( ebs ) provide their finite size approximation .
the latter ones can be obtained from collimated gaussian beams focused by a cylindrical lens .
indeed , we have observed that an eb passing through the bc does not generate the cr ring , but splits into two beams ( in case of circularly polarized input beams ) oppositely placed along the otherwise expected cr ring and tangent to it , see fig .
[ fig1](d ) . the form and orientation of the refracted beams resemble the transverse intensity pattern and orientation of the input eb .
below , using ebs we will obtain phenomenological laws that describe double refraction along the optic axis in biaxial crystals .
in this section , we will investigate the position and the relative intensity of the two refracted beams produced when an input eb propagates along the optic axis of a bc .
the experimental set - up shown in fig .
[ fig2](a ) is used . the initial circularly polarized gaussian beam with waist radius of @xmath1
is obtained from a @xmath2 diode laser coupled to a monomode fiber .
then a linear polarizer is introduced to fix the polarization plane in a well defined direction .
the resulting linearly polarized beam is focused by a cylindrical lens of @xmath3 focal length with its flat face oriented strictly perpendicular to the beam propagation direction .
the cylindrical lens only focuses the gaussian beam in one direction , so that it transforms its transverse circular shape to an elliptical one with a ratio 3/100 of the semi - axes of the ellipse . as a consequence ,
the divergence of the generated eb is different along the focused and unfocused directions ( @xmath4 , @xmath5 ; @xmath6 , @xmath7 , where _ f _ and _ uf _ subscripts refer to _ focused _ and _ unfocused _ directions , respectively ) .
the eb is characterized by its polarization plane , represented by the azimuthal angle @xmath8 , and by its plane of wave - vectors ( or @xmath9-plane ) , represented by azimuthal angle @xmath10 ; see fig . [
fig2](b ) .
different ebs are obtained by rotating either the cylindrical lens or the linear polarizer .
the bc is @xmath11 long and it was cut from a monoclinic centrosymmetric kgd(wo@xmath12)@xmath13 crystal .
its polished entrance surfaces ( cross - section @xmath14 , parallelism 10 arc seconds ) are perpendicular to one of the optic axes ( misalignment angle @xmath15 ) and positioned strictly perpendicular to the beam propagation direction , so that the incoming beam to the bc passes along its optic axis .
both the orientation of the optic axis of the bc and the cylindrical lens are well controlled in the @xmath16 and @xmath17 directions in 3d spherical coordinates by a micrometer positioning system .
the resulting pattern is captured by a ccd camera at the lloyd ( focal ) plane behind the bc @xcite .
first , we briefly outline the cr annular pattern observed at the lloyd plane with an input gaussian beam . while the complete cr ring is observed for circular polarization of the input gaussian beam , as it is shown in fig .
[ fig1](d ) , a crescent ring with one point of the ring being of zero intensity appears for linear polarization . in both cases , the center of the cr ring is laterally shifted with respect to the incident beam .
this shift can be represented by a vector @xmath18 that belongs to the plane of the crystal optic axes and is perpendicular to them @xcite .
its modulus is equal to the ring radius @xmath19 ( in our set - up @xmath20 ) , given by a product of the length and the conical refraction semiangle of the bc ( @xmath21 for kgd(wo@xmath12)@xmath13 ) @xcite .
now we will experimentally deduce the lateral shift of the refracted beams for ebs propagated through a bc . in fig .
[ fig3 ] two series of images present the transverse intensity pattern at the lloyd plane recorded varying either @xmath8 ( @xmath22 ) ( a ) or @xmath10 ( @xmath23 ) ( b ) from @xmath24 to @xmath25 in @xmath26 intervals , when the crystal orientation remains fixed at @xmath27 . the geometric center of the refracted beams coincides with the center of the otherwise expected cr ring , since it is shifted from the position of the initial eb by the vector * g*. this shift is shown schematically in fig .
[ fig3](c ) , and it is subtracted in fig . [ fig3](a ) and fig . [ fig3](b ) . from fig .
[ fig3 ] it is clear that in a local frame with origin at the ring center , the position of the two refracted beams does not depend on the input beam polarization , @xmath8 , but rotates linearly with @xmath10 .
moreover , the azimuthal angles @xmath28 of the refracted beams are defined by the wave - vector plane , @xmath10 , of the input eb , namely , @xmath29 since @xmath10 and @xmath30 describe the same wave - vector plane , the latter expressions mean conservation of the wave - vectors @xmath9-planes .
rotation of the crystal , _
i.e. _ change of @xmath31 , does not affect the angles @xmath28 , but it affects the position of the center of the refracted beams and redistributes the intensity between the refracted beams as it will be shown in the next subsection . summarizing , in the @xmath32 laboratory coordinates , the positions of the refracted beams @xmath33 at the lloyd plane can be written as follows :
@xmath34 where @xmath35 .
@xmath36 denotes the position at the lloyd plane where the initial eb would be focused in the absence of the bc , see fig .
[ fig3](c ) .
in other words , the two refracted beams are located at diagonal positions of the otherwise expected cr ring .
ebs obtained from the same gaussian beam have the same initial position @xmath36 , _
i.e. _ @xmath36 does not depend on @xmath37 in this case . as a final comment , eqs .
( [ eq1 ] ) generalize the geometrical approach @xcite .
now we report how the intensity of the input eb is distributed between the two refracted beams . in the experiments ,
three parameters can be varied independently : @xmath38 , @xmath8 and @xmath10 , associated to the crystal orientation represented by @xmath39 and to the polarization and wave - vectors planes of the incident ebs . below
we show that only one combination of these angles governs the relative intensity distribution between the two refracted beams . with this purpose
, we have repeated the experiments shown in fig .
[ fig3](a ) and fig .
[ fig3](b ) for different orientations of the bc . symbols ( black crosses and red circles ) in fig .
[ fig4](a ) fig .
[ fig4](b ) show the corresponding experimental results for the intensities @xmath40 of the two refracted beams normalized with respect to the intensity of the incident beam .
black solid and red dashed curves represent their analytical fittings given by the following expressions : @xmath41 @xmath42 and @xmath43 are the intensities of the beams refracted at angles @xmath44 and @xmath45 and located diagonally at the both ends of the cr ring at positions @xmath46 and @xmath47 respectively , following eq.([eq1 ] ) .
( [ eqexp1 ] ) and ( [ eqexp2 ] ) can be rewritten in a unified simple form , giving the next formula for the relative intensity distribution between the two refracted beams with only one governing parameter @xmath48 : @xmath49 from eq .
( [ eqintensity ] ) it follows that , with respect to the relative energy distribution the only significant parameters of the input eb is @xmath50 .
therefore , the intensity splitting under cr can be expressed in terms of the difference between the parameter @xmath50 and the orientation of the bc , given by @xmath38 .
we would like to highlight here that the expression @xmath51 that we have obtained experimentally , corrects the theoretical result derived in @xcite , where a plus sign was considered instead of a minus one . eqs .
( [ eq1 ] ) and ( [ eqintensity ] ) describe also recent experimental results on the propagation of cr filtered beams @xcite along the optic axis of a bc . in that case , @xmath52 , where @xmath53 denotes the orientation of an initial biaxial crystal that produces a cr ring with lateral shift given by vector @xmath54 .
then , a pinhole placed at angle @xmath0 on the cr ring produces a cr filtered beam with polarization @xmath55 and plane of wave - vectors @xmath56 that also splits into two beams after passing along the optic axis of a biaxial crystal .
( [ eq1 ] ) and ( [ eqintensity ] ) constitute the transformation rules of conical refraction . for different polarization of the input beams they allow explaining the ratio of intensities for any pair of diagonally opposite points of the cr ring .
these results corroborate with experimental observations that the complete cr ring appears only for beams with azimuthally continuous symmetric distribution of wave - vectors . as a proof of usefulness of the formalism introduced in this work , in the next section
we apply the derived transformation rules to an axicon input beam .
the experimental set - up is sketched in fig .
a linearly polarized conical beam is prepared when an initial circularly polarized gaussian beam passes through a linear polarizer and an axicon lens .
the axicon beam is focused by a spherical lens into the bc .
the resulting pattern is captured with a ccd camera at the focal plane . as in previous experiments , the orientation of the optic axis of the bc , the spherical lens and the axicon lens are well controlled in the @xmath16 and @xmath17 directions in 3d spherical coordinates by a micrometer positioning system .
each infinitesimally thin azimuthal sector of the axicon lens characterized by azimuthal angle @xmath0 forms a thin prism that produces a wave with particular wave - vector whose transverse projection comprise an angle @xmath57 .
the axicon lens generates , therefore , a continuous collection of beams with @xmath58 . after the axicon , the refracted beams , following snell law , have the same inclination angle @xmath59 with respect to the @xmath60-axis . at the focal plane of the lens they form a ring such that each point can be characterized by wave - vector plane , @xmath61 , and polarization plane , @xmath8 .
in other words , each point of the axicon ring is an eb . in this case
all these eb have their polarization plane fixed at @xmath62 and their wave - vector plane @xmath0 is varying continuously along the ring as shown in fig .
[ fig6](a ) . behind the bc
, the refraction pattern can be calculated by applying eq .
( [ eq1 ] ) to every point of the input axicon annular beam taking into account the initial positions as given by @xmath63 ( where @xmath64 is the radius of the axicon light ring ) . therefore , from eq .
( [ eq1 ] ) one can obtain the refracted pattern for an axicon beam : @xmath65 these expressions , with @xmath0 scanned from @xmath24 to @xmath66 , parameterize two concentric rings with radii @xmath67 laterally shifted by @xmath39 relatively to the axicon ring axis .
the intensity distribution is calculated from eq .
( [ eqintensity ] ) .
all points of the incident axicon beam have the same intensity , which is distributed between the two refracted rings as follows : @xmath68 where we have taken @xmath69 being @xmath70 a constant parameter .
in addition , since both rings have different radii , normalization factors @xmath71 have been introduced to @xmath40 to assure energy conservation .
[ fig6](a ) shows the intensity pattern of the axicon beam with polarization and @xmath9-plane distribution . the experimental refraction pattern behind the bc is shown in fig . [ fig6](b ) .
the pattern is formed by two concentric rings oppositely polarized , with polarization distribution analogous to that one obtained in a cascaded cr configuration @xcite .
polarization of the ring points with minimum ( zero ) and maximum intensities are orthogonal and parallel respectively to that of the input axicon beam .
[ fig6](c ) presents the theoretical prediction of the light refraction pattern from eqs.([eqaxicon ] ) and ( [ eqintaxicon ] ) .
comparison between fig .
[ fig6](b ) and fig .
[ fig6](c ) shows that the theoretical prediction and the experiment ( see fig . [ fig6](b ) ) are in complete agreement .
it is well known that an input gaussian beam produces a light ring after propagating along the optic axis of a biaxial crystal . in this paper
we have experimentally addressed the wave - vector and polarization dependence of the internal conical refraction phenomenon in biaxial crystals .
we have experimentally proved that this phenomenon is only one particular case of refraction associated to beams possessing continuous axial cylindrical symmetry .
in fact , we have reported that elliptical beams obtained by focusing a gaussian beam with a cylindrical lens do not generate the complete characteristic light ring of conical refraction when they propagate along an optic axis of a biaxial crystal but split , in general , into two beams .
we have phenomenologically obtained expressions for the positions and relative intensities of the resulting refracted beams .
these expressions play an analogous role as the malus law but for biaxial crystals and can be used to predict the transverse intensity pattern of much more involved incident beams as it has been demonstrated here for an input axicon beam .
the authors gratefully acknowledge financial support through spanish micinn contracts fis2010 - 10004-e and fis2011 - 23719 , and the catalan government contract sgr2009 - 00347 .
a. t. acknowledges financial support through grant ap2010 - 2310 from the micinn .
jos luis martnez is also acknowledged for his helpful comments . a. j. schell and n. bloembergen , `` laser studies of internal conical diffraction . i. quantitative comparison of experimental and theoretical conical intensity distribution in aragonite , '' j. opt .
68 * , 10931098 ( 1978 ) .
y. loiko , m. a. bursukova , t. k. kalkanjiev , e. u. rafailov , and j. mompart , `` fermionic transformation rules for spatially filtered light beams in conical refraction , '' in _ complex light and optical forces v _ , d. l. andrews , e. j. galvez , j. glckstad , eds .
spie * 7950 * , 79500d79500d-9 ( 2011 ) . | we experimentally address the wave - vector and polarization dependence of the internal conical refraction phenomenon by demonstrating that an input light beam of elliptical transverse profile refracts into two beams after passing along one of the optic axes of a biaxial crystal , _
i.e. _ it exhibits double refraction instead of refracting conically .
such double refraction is investigated by the independent rotation of a linear polarizer and a cylindrical lens .
expressions to describe the position and the intensity pattern of the refracted beams are presented and applied to predict the intensity pattern for an axicon beam propagating along the optic axis of a biaxial crystal . + * ocis * : ( 160.1190 ) anisotropic optical materials ; ( 260.1180 ) crystal optics ; ( 260.1140 ) birefringence . |
physicists have recently shown that network analysis is a powerful tool to study the statistical properties of complex biological , technological and social systems of diverse kinds@xcite .
many networks exhibit a scale - free degree distribution in which the probability @xmath0 that a vertex is connected to @xmath1 other vertices falls as a power @xmath2 .
this property is not sufficient to completely describe natural networks because such systems also exhibit degree correlations the degrees of the vertices at the end points of any given edge are not independent @xcite .
it is not surprising that natural systems depend on properties that do not appear explicitly in degree distributions . in particular , protein interaction networks depend on the availability of sufficient binding free energy@xcite to cause interactions to occur ( links between vertices to exist ) .
caldarelli _ et al .
_ @xcite and sderberg @xcite proposed models in which vertices are characterized by a fitness parameter assigned according to a chosen probability distribution .
then , pairs of vertices are independently joined by an undirected edge with a probability depending on the fitnesses of the end points .
@xcite generalized these models as a class of models with hidden variables and presented a detailed formalism showing how to compute network properties using the conditional probability ( propagator ) that a vertex with a given value of a hidden variable is connected to other @xmath1 vertices .
this formalism , valid for any markovian ( binary ) network , provides the generating function for the propagator , but not the propagator itself .
the purpose of this paper is twofold .
we first use a mean field approximation to derive a general analytic formula for the propagator , therefore finding a general approximate solution to to the inversion problem .
this enables one to compute network properties without the use of a simulation procedure , thereby simplifying the computational procedure and potentially broadening the ability of scientists from all fields to use network theory .
the validity of the method is assessed by comparing the results of using our approximation with published results .
we then use this method to compute clustering coefficients of a specific hidden variable model for protein - protein interaction networks ( pin ) from several organisms developed by us@xcite that previously had obtained degree distributions in agreement with measured data .
we show that two models with the same degree distribution have very different clustering coefficients .
we outline this in more detail .
[ sec : formalism ] reviews the hidden variable formalism and our approximate solution to the inversion problem . we distinguish between sparse ( which have been solved in ref .
@xcite ) and non - sparse networks which are solved here .
the next section [ sec : models ] studies the models of refs .
@xcite and @xcite .
our averaging procedure is found to work well for most situations .
our own model@xcite is presented in [ sec : pin ] .
we present an analytic result for the average connection probability and extend the results of @xcite to computing the clustering coefficients .
the final section [ sec : summary ] is reserved for a brief summary and discussion .
we present the formalism for hidden variable models @xcite . the probability that a node has a hidden continuous variable @xmath3 is given by @xmath4 , normalized so that its integral over its domain is unity .
this function is chosen to be an exponential in @xcite and a gaussian in @xcite .
the connection probability for two nodes of @xmath5 is defined to be @xmath6 .
this is taken as a step function in @xcite , and a fermi function in @xcite .
the two functions @xmath4 and @xmath6 can be chosen in a wide variety of ways to capture the properties of a given network .
reference @xcite presents the probability generating function , @xmath7 , that determines @xmath0 in terms of the generating function for the propagator , @xmath8 , as g_0(z)= dg(g ) _ 0(z , g),[bog1]where _ 0(z , g)= ndg ( g)(1-(1-z)p(g , g ) ) .
[ gbog]the propagator @xmath9 giving the conditional probability that a vertex of hidden variable @xmath3 is connected to @xmath1 other vertices is given implicitly by _
0(z , g)=_k=0^z^kg_0(k , g ) . [ g0 kg ]
knowledge of @xmath9 determines the conditional probability @xmath10 that a node of degree @xmath1 is connected to a node of degree @xmath11 , @xcite ( as well as @xmath0 ) , and those two functions completely define a markovian network .
once @xmath9 is the determined , all of the properties of the given network are determined .
the most well - known example is the degree distribution @xmath0 : p_k=_0^dg _ ( g)g_0(k , g ) .
it would seem that determining @xmath9 from eq .
( [ gbog ] ) is a simple technical matter , but this is not the case@xcite .
the purpose of the present section is to provide a simple , analytic and accurate method to determine @xmath9 .
we obtain @xmath9 from eq .
( [ gbog ] ) by using the tautology p(g , g)=
|p(g ) + ( p(g , g)-|p(g)[exp ] ) in eq . ( [ gbog ] ) , choosing @xmath12 so as to eliminate the effects of the second term , and then treating the remaining higher powers of @xmath13 as an expansion parameter . using eq .
( [ exp ] ) in eq .
( [ gbog ] ) yields & & _ 0(z , g)= _ 0(z , g)=(1-(1-z)|p(g))^n- n(1-z)dg(g)(|p(g)-p(g , g))1-(1-z)|p(g ) & & -n_n=2^dg(g)(p(g , g)-|p(g))1-(1-z)|p(g))^n .
[ gbog01 ] in analogy with the mean - field ( hartree ) approximation of atomic and nuclear physics , we find that the second term of eq .
( [ gbog01 ] ) vanishes if we choose @xmath12 to be the average of @xmath6 over @xmath14 : |p(g)=dg(g)p(g , g).[pave]with eq .
( [ pave ] ) the effects of the term of first order in @xmath13 vanish .
we therefore obtain the result : _ 0(z , g)=(1-(1-z)|p(g))^n - n_n=2^dg(g)(p(g , g)-|p(g))1-(1-z)|p(g))^n , [ gbog1 ] with the putative term with @xmath15 vanishing by virtue of eq .
( [ pave ] ) .
we treat the first term of eq .
( [ gbog1 ] ) as the leading order ( @xmath16 ) term and regard the remainder as a correction .
the validity of this approach can be checked by comparison with simulations , or ( in certain cases ) with analytic results .
numerical results for the pin of current interest @xcite indicate that the corrections to the _ lo _ terms induce errors in @xmath0 of no more than a few percent and that the approximation becomes more accurate for large values of @xmath1
. therefore we use the _ lo _ approximation . using exponentiation and the binomial theorem in the first term of eq .
( [ gbog1 ] ) leads to the result ^(lo)_0(k , g)= ( cn + k ) ( 1-|p(g))^n - k|p(g)^k,[glo]which is of the form of a random binomial distribution in which the connection probability depends on the hidden variable @xmath3 .
( [ glo ] ) is our central new general result that can be used for any hidden variable network .
this binomial distribution has both the normal gaussian and poisson @xmath17 distributions as limiting cases . ref .
@xcite explained the difference between sparse and nonsparse networks .
sparse networks have a well - defined thermodynamic limit for the average degree , while this quantity diverges as the network size @xmath18 approaches infinity .
@xcite defines criteria for sparseness by pointing out the relevance of @xmath19 of eq .
( [ pave ] ) in determining whether or not a network is sparse . given this quantity
the average degree is k = dg ( g)|p(g)= dgdg ( g)p(g , g)(g).if the @xmath4 is independent of @xmath18 the only way to obtain a non - divergent value @xmath20 is for the connection probability @xcite to scale as @xmath21 : p^sparse(g , g)=c(g , g)n , .[sparse ] under the specific assumption that eq .
( [ sparse ] ) holds , ref .
@xcite finds a very interesting result . in our notation , this amounts to using eq .
( [ sparse ] ) in eq .
( [ gbog ] ) and taking the limit that @xmath18 approaches infinity . then g_0^sparse(z , g)=(z-1)dg(g)c(g , g ) .
this shows that the poisson limit of eq .
( [ glo ] ) is obtained for the very special case of sparse networks in which the connection probability scales as @xmath21 .
none of the models of interest here @xcite are sparse , so it is our present result ( [ glo ] ) that is widely applicable . turning to the use of the use of the propagator
, we obtain the degree distribution as p_k = dg ( g ) g_0(k , g)dg ( g ) g_0^(lo)(k , g ) .
[ ours]this expression can be thought of as averaging a binomial distribution over the hidden variable and is a natural generalization of classical graph theory .
a similar expression for @xmath0 has been obtained , in the poisson limit , in ref .
@xcite . in that work
, @xmath0 is presented as an integral of the poisson distribution for @xmath22 multiplied by the `` @xmath23 representation '' of a density matrix .
comparing eq .
( [ glo ] ) with the result ( 3 ) of @xcite shows that our propagator is proportional to the @xmath23 representation , essentially our @xmath4 .
@xcite shows , how under certain assumptions , to use @xmath24 to determine the @xmath23 representation .
our method allows underlying network properties , denoted by @xmath4 and @xmath6 , to predict various network properties . the clustering coefficient which measures transitivity @xcite :
if vertex @xmath25 is connected to vertex @xmath26 and vertex @xmath26 to vertex @xmath27 , there is an increased probability that vertices @xmath25 and @xmath27 are connected . in graph theory , the clustering coefficient @xmath28 is the ratio of the number of triangles to the number of pairs , computed for nodes of degree @xmath1 .
@xcite shows that & & c(k)= dg ( g)g_0(k , g)c(g ) [ eq:21 ] + & & c(g)= dg dg(g)p(g , g)|p(g ) p(g , g)(g)p(g,g)|p(g).[cofg ] our calculations replace @xmath29 by @xmath30 of eq .
( [ glo ] ) .
one way to verify the _ lo _ approximation is to show that it reproduces analytic results for previously published models .
we consider the models of @xcite and @xcite in this section . in both of these models
@xmath6 is taken as a step function ( the 0 temperature limit of our model ) : p(g , g)= ( g+g-).[sharp]the two models differ in their choice of @xmath4 , but the use of eq .
( [ sharp ] ) allows one to obtain compact general expressions for the generating functions @xmath31 and @xmath28 .
we present these first and discuss specific details of the individual models in separate sub - sections . the use of eq .
( [ sharp ] ) in eq .
( [ gbog ] ) yields _ 0(z , g)= n(z)=n|p(g)(z ) , [ gbogsharp ] so that _ 0(z , g)=z^n|p(g).[gsharp ] it is interesting to observe that eq .
( [ gbog1 ] ) reduces to the above result .
this is because powers of @xmath32 for eq .
( [ sharp ] ) , so that the integration appearing in eq .
( [ gbog1 ] ) leads to an expression that is a function of @xmath33 then the use of the binomial theorem allows the second term of eq . ( [ gbog1 ] ) to be expressed as a summable power series in @xmath19 which ultimately leads to the result eq .
( [ gsharp ] ) . if we follow @xcite and treat @xmath1 as a continuous variable ( which requires large values of @xmath1 ) we find _ 0(k , g)=(k - n|p(g ) ) = , , [ gdelta ] + where @xmath34 is the solution of the equation k = n|p(g).[gn]note that for @xmath35 , @xmath34 can take on any value greater than @xmath36 .
the result eq .
( [ gdelta ] ) is the same as eq.(34 ) of @xcite , but written in a more compact form . the use of eq .
( [ gdelta ] ) in eq .
( [ ours ] ) and eq .
( [ eq:21 ] ) yields the results p_k=(g_n(k))n|p(g_n(k ) ) + this model is defined by using @xmath37 , but we generalize to take the form _ ( g)=(-g).ref .
@xcite works out this model using their green s function formalism .
our purpose here is to compare the results of our averaging approximation with their results . for this model
the average interaction probability @xmath12 is given by |p(g)=_0^dg ( g+g-)= ( g- ) + ( -g).[pbarss]then our approximation eq .
( [ ours ] ) for the degree distribution @xmath0 is given by p_k= ( cn + k ) _ 0^dg ( 1- ) ^n - kdefine the integration variable @xmath38}$ ] so that & & p_k= ( cn + k ) e^-_t_0 ^ 1 dtt^2t^k(1-t)^n - k , t_0e^- + & & p_k>1= ( cn + k ) e^-((n+1-k)(k-1)(n)-b_t_0(k-1,n+1-k)),[pkif ] + & & p_k=1=n e^-(1-t_0)^nn_2f_1(1,n;n+1,1-t_0)where @xmath39 is the confluent hypergeometric function and @xmath40 is the incomplete beta function ( and with @xmath41 the beta function ) : b_z(a , b)_0^z dt t^a-1 ( 1-t)^b-1,b_1(a , b)=b(a , b).consider the case 1<k,10,(the latter is typical of our biological model ) so that the second term of eq
. ( [ pkif ] ) can be neglected .
evaluating the remaining gamma functions gives p_k = e^-nk(k-1).[cutus]ref .
@xcite computes the degree distribution for this model in analytic manner , using the approximation eq .
( [ gdelta ] ) in which @xmath1 is treated as a continuous variable and therefore `` is expected to perform poorly for small values of @xmath1 '' .
the result of @xcite @xmath42 is p_k^bps = e^-nk^2 + e^-(k- n)[cutum]which corresponds to agreement ( for @xmath43 ) within the stated domain of accuracy of ref .
the confluence of eq .
( [ cutus ] ) and eq .
( [ cutum ] ) provides a verification of the accuracy of the averaging approximation . the results for @xmath35 seem to disagree ,
so we examine this more closely . use eq .
( [ gsharp ] ) directly to obtain the generating function @xmath44 as @xmath45 .
one obtains a result @xmath46 for all values of @xmath3 ( @xmath47 ) such that @xmath48 .
using this generating function yields the result p_k = n = dg(g ) ( g-).the specific value of the integral depends on the choice of @xmath4 , but the result is a finite number for any choice of @xmath4 that satisfies the normalization condition that its integral over its domain is unity .
thus we believe that the correct result of using the propagator ( eq(34 ) of @xcite in their eq(11 ) ) is p_k^bps = e^-nk^2[cutum1]instead of eq .
( [ cutum ] ) , which is in agreement with our result .
our approximation works very well in reproducing the computed clustering coefficient of @xcite .
in particular , we evaluate @xmath49 of eq .
( [ cofg ] ) to find that ( 2g-+1)).numerical evaluation of this approximate expression accurately reproduces the result of fig . 3 of ref .
thus our mean field approximation is accurate for both our model@xcite and the model of ref .
our principal application is to the the pin of ref .
this model is based on the concept of free energy of association . for a given pair of proteins the association free energy ( in units of @xmath50 )
is assumed to deviate from an average value a number contributed by both proteins additively as @xmath51 .
this is a unique approximation to first - order in @xmath3 and @xmath52 .
thermodynamics and the assumption that the interaction probability is independent of concentration allows us to write p(g , g)=1/ ( 1+e^-g - g),[pdef]which reduces to a step function in the zero temperature limit , but otherwise provides a smooth function . increasing the value of @xmath36 weakens the strength of interactions , and previous results @xcite showed the existence of an evolutionary trend to weaker interactions in more complex organisms .
the probability that a protein has a value of @xmath3 is given by the probability distribution _
( g)=ee^-g , -1g+,[rhodef]where the positive real value of @xmath53 governs the fluctuations of @xmath3 .
we previously chose the species - dependent values of @xmath53 and @xmath36 so as to reproduce measured degree distributions obtained using the yeast two - hybrid method ( y2h ) that reports binary results for protein - protein binding under a controlled setting@xcite .
those parameters are displayed in table i. the impact of the parameters @xmath53 and @xmath36 are explained in ref .
@xcite and displayed in fig .
3 of that reference . increasing the value of @xmath53 increases the causes a more rapid decrease of @xmath0the slope of @xmath0 increases in magnitude . increasing the value of @xmath36 decreases the magnitude of @xmath0 without altering the slope much for values of @xmath1 greater than about 10 .
the ability to vary both the slope and magnitude of @xmath0 gives this model flexibility that allows us to describe the available degree distributions for different species .
[ table1 ] .parameters obtained in ref .
@xcite [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] we obtain an analytic form for the for @xmath12 eq . ( [ pave ] ) of this model .
given eq .
( [ rhodef ] ) and eq .
( [ pdef ] ) we find an analytic result : |p(g,)=_2f_1(1,;+1;-),[analpbar]where @xmath39 is the confluent hypergeometric function .
the special case @xmath54 yields a closed form expression : obtained in contrast with the result of the sharp cutoff model eq . ( [ pbarss ] ) .
this shown in fig . [
fig : pbar ] .
.95 cm ( 10,10)(5,0 ) ( color online ) average connection probability @xmath54 , @xmath55 .
solid ( red ) : result of eq .
( [ special ] ) ; dashed ( blue ) ( containing the step function ) result of eq .
( [ pbarss ] ) .
the approach to unity is smooth for eq .
( [ special]).,title="fig:",width=10,height=377 ] it is useful to define the variable > 0 , and note that an integral representation@xcite _
2f_1(n,;+1;-)=_0 ^ 1dtt^-1(1+t)^-n,[alg]is convenient for numerical evaluations .
knowledge of the propagator eq .
( [ glo ] ) allows us to compute the clustering coefficients of diverse species .
the resulting degree distributions of @xmath0 ( shown for the sake of completeness ) and the newly computed clustering coefficients @xmath56 for yeast _ s. cerevisiae _ @xcite , worm _ c. elegans _
@xcite and fruit fly
_ d. melanogaster _
@xcite are shown in fig .
the parameters @xmath53 and @xmath36 are those of @xcite , so the calculations of the clustering coefficients represent an independent major new prediction of our model .
results of numerical simulations and our analytic procedure are presented .
the excellent agreement between the two methods verifies the @xmath16 approximation .
more importantly , the agreement between our calculations and the measured clustering coefficients is generally very good , so our model survives a very significant test .
this bolsters the notion that the properties of a pin are determined by a distribution of free energy . the clustering coefficient for yeast drops rapidly for large values of @xmath1 ( where statistics are poor ) , a feature not contained in our model .
it is worthwhile to compare our model with that of @xcite .
that work chooses a gaussian form of @xmath4 , based on hydrophobicity , a step function form of @xmath6 , and is applied only to yeast .
we found @xcite that @xmath0 of @xcite is scale free only for a narrow range of parameters , and we could not reproduce the data for diverse species using that model .
.95 cm ( 10,10)(2,-1 . )
( color online ) degree distributions @xmath0 and clustering coefficients @xmath57 of diverse species .
degree distributions @xmath0 : the solid ( red ) curves are derived from the @xmath16 theory .
the black dots are the results of experimental data as referenced in the text .
the small ( blue ) circles are the results of a numerical simulation using the procedure of @xcite . clustering coefficients @xmath57 : the solid ( red ) curves are derived from the @xmath16 theory .
the small ( blue ) dots are the results of a numerical simulation using the procedure of @xcite and the heavy ( black ) dots represent the measured data .
, title="fig:",width=10,height=566 ] the human interactome is of special interest .
[ hdegc]a shows the human degree distributions computed with two sets of parameters , one from ref .
@xcite ( table i ) and the other using values of @xmath58 shown in the caption .
the degree distributions are essentially identical , so only one curve can be shown .
each is approximately of a power law form and each describes the measured degree distribution very well@xcite .
calculations of degree correlations allows one to distinguish the two parameter sets .
figure [ hdegc]b shows that the cluster coefficients differ by a factor of two .
we find that @xmath56 decreases substantially as @xmath53 increases .
the increase in @xmath53 reduces the allowed spread in the value of @xmath3 and reduces the value of integrand of eq .
( [ eq:21 ] ) .
it is interesting to note that the two existing measurements of the human @xmath56 differ by a factor of about an order of magnitude with the measurements of ref.@xcite obtaining much smaller values than those of @xcite .
the results of @xcite are closer to our computed @xmath56 results for @xmath59 .
in contrast with the results for other species , our @xmath56 lie significantly above the data . however ,
the two data sets disagree substantially ( by a factor of as much as 100 for certain values of @xmath1 ) and both show a clustering coefficient that is generally significantly smaller than that of the other species . several possibilities may account for the discrepancies between these two measurements of @xmath56 in humans and also for the differences between our model predictions and the experimental results .
i ) the human studies sample a limited subset of links of the complete network and this could bias the results .
ii ) the human protein subsets used in the two studies differ .
iii ) the human interactome is truly less connected than that of other species .
this demonstrates the importance of measuring degree correlations to determine the underlying properties of the network .
the current model and these considerations suggest the need for better design of future pin studies that will not only include other species , but also comparisons between the pins of different organs of a given species .
furthermore , comparisons between normal and malignant tissues could also be very fruitful .
.9 cm ( color online ) human degree distribution @xmath0 ; the solid ( red ) curve is obtained using both set a @xmath60 and set b @xmath59 .
the black dots represent the experimental data .
the data set is that of @xcite , but nearly identical data is obtained from @xcite .
human cluster coefficient @xmath56 : the solid ( red ) curve is computed using set a @xmath60 and the dashed ( green ) using set b @xmath59 . measured human clustering coefficients are from @xcite triangles ( blue ) and @xcite heavy dots ( pink ) .
, title="fig:",width=9 ]
in summary , this work provides a method to obtain the properties of hidden variable network models . the use of the approximation eq .
( [ pave ] ) , used to obtain the propagator eq .
( [ glo ] ) , provides an excellent numerical approximation to exact results for the models considered here . if necessary
, the method can be systematically improved through the calculation of higher order corrections .
our principal example is the pin of ref .
@xcite . not only does the use of eq .
( [ glo ] ) provide an accurate numerical result , but the model correctly predicts the clustering coefficients of most species . for the human interactome ,
two different parameter sets yield nearly the same degree distribution but very different clustering coefficients , showing the importance of measuring degree correlations to determine the underlying nature of the network .
99 s. h. strogatz , nature ( london ) * 410*,268 ( 2001 ) .
r. albert and a .- l.barabsi , rev .
mod . phys .
* 74*,47 ( 2002 ) , siam rev .
* 45 * , 167 ( 2003 ) .
pastor - satorras , a. vzquez , and a. vespignani , phys .
lett . * 87 * , 258701 ( 2001 ) .
b. alberts _ et al .
_ , _ the cell _ , ( garland science , new york 2002 )
. g. caldarelli , a. capocci , p.delosrios , and m. a. muoz , phys .
* 89 * , 258702 ( 2002 ) .
b. sderberg , phys .
e * 66 * , 066121 ( 2002 ) .
m. bogu and r. pastor - satorras , phys .
e * 68 * , 036112 ( 2003 ) .
yi y. shi , g.a .
miller , h. qian , and k. bomsztyk , proc .
sci . * 103 * , 11527 ( 2006 ) .
deeds , o. ashenberg , and e.i .
shakhonovich , proc .
sci . * 103 * , 311 ( 2006 ) .
m. abramowitz and i. a. stegun , _ handbook of mathematical functions _ , ( dover , new york 1970 ) . s. abe and s. thurner , phys .
e * 72 * , 036102 ( 2005 ) ; s. abe and s. thurner , int . j. mod
c * 17 * , 1303 ( 2006 ) .
s. fields and s. song , nature * 340 * , 245 ( 1989 ) .
networks / resources / protein / bo.dat.qz s. li , _ et al .
_ , science * 303 * , 540 ( 2004 ) .
l. giot _ et al .
_ , science * 302 * , 1727 ( 2003 ) .
the value of @xmath61 is a testable result of our model , even though experimentalists do not measure this quantity .
the predicted number of proteins with no interactions is @xmath62 , where the value of @xmath18 is given in table i. the experimentalists conventionally normalize their distributions as @xmath63 , so we multiply our computed @xmath0 by a factor of @xmath64 so that the computed sum @xmath65 is unity .
rual , _ et al .
_ nature * 437 * , 1173 ( 2005 ) u. stelzl , _ el al .
_ cell * 122 * , 957 ( 2005 ) | the properties of certain networks are determined by hidden variables that are not explicitly measured .
the conditional probability ( propagator ) that a vertex with a given value of the hidden variable is connected to k of other vertices determines all measurable properties .
we study hidden variable models and find an averaging approximation that enables us to obtain a general analytical result for the propagator .
analytic results showing the validity of the approximation are obtained .
we apply hidden variable models to protein - protein interaction networks ( pins ) in which the hidden variable is the association free - energy , determined by distributions that depend on biochemistry and evolution .
we compute degree distributions as well as clustering coefficients of several pins of different species ; good agreement with measured data is obtained . for the human interactome
two different parameter sets give the same degree distributions , but the computed clustering coefficients differ by a factor of about two .
this shows that degree distributions are not sufficient to determine the properties of pins .
= 10000 0.5 cm |
it was proposed by efimov in 1970 that if two spinless neutral bosons interact resonantly then the addition of a third identical particle leads to the appearance of an infinite number of bound three - body energy levels @xcite .
this occurs simultaneously with the divergence of the @xmath1-wave scattering length @xmath2 , associated with appearance of an additional zero - energy two - body bound state .
hence highly exotic efimov states appear when there is a zero or near - zero energy two - body bound state . for a long time
there was no clear signature of efimov states in any naturally occuring trimer system .
efimov states are not possible in atomic systems due to the long range coulomb interaction , however it may exist in the system of spinless neutral atoms .
even though the efimov effect was predicted four decades ago @xcite , evidence of its existence in ultracold caesium and potassium trimers has been experimentally established only very recently @xcite .
however , these trimers are obtained by manipulating two - body forces through feshbach resonances and are not naturally occuring .
therefore , it is of great interest to search for the efimov effect in a naturally occuring trimer , like @xmath3he trimer .
so far no experimental confirmation has been reported .
the near - zero energy ( @xmath4 1 mk ) bound state ( which is also the only bound state ) of @xmath0he dimer opens the possibility of the existence of an efimov - like state in @xmath0he trimer .
several authors remarked that the @xmath0he trimer may be the most promising candidate .
earlier theoretical calculations show that the trimer has a @xmath5 = 0 ground state at 126 mk and a near - zero energy excited state ( @xmath6 2mk ) @xcite .
the excited state has been claimed to be an efimov state .
a controversy arises from the fact that the number of efimov states is highly sensitive to the binding energy of the dimer and even a very small decrease of the strength of two - body interaction makes the system unbound .
strikingly , it also disappears when the two - body interaction strength is _
increased_. however in contrast with theoretical investigations , no evidence of efimov trimer has been found experimentally @xcite . in the experiments
, @xmath0he trimer has been observed in its ground state only .
no experimental evidence of the excited state has been reported so far .
+ in principle @xmath0he trimer may be considered as a very simple three - body system consisting of three identical bosons .
but its theoretical treatment is quite difficult .
first , the he - dimer potential is not uniquely known .
very small uncertainities in the dimer potential may lead to different conclusions .
secondly , the strong short - range interatomic repulsion in the he - he interaction causes large numerical errors .
as @xmath0he systems are strongly correlated due to large @xmath0he@xmath0he repulsion at short separation , the effect of interatomic correlation must be taken properly into account .
+ in the present communication , we revisit the problem using a correlated basis function known as potential harmonics ( ph ) basis which takes care of two - body correlations @xcite . in order to include the effect of highly repulsive he - he core
, we multiply the ph basis with a suitable short - range correlation function which reproduces the correct short - range behavior of the dimer wavefunction .
although this correlated ph basis ( cph basis ) correctly reproduces the dimer and trimer properties , we could not find any efimov like state in trimer with the actual dimer interaction @xcite .
we point out that the calculation of such a near - zero energy excited state in the shallow and extended trimer potential may involve severe numerical errors and we may miss it .
thus an alternative accurate procedure is desirable . here
, we apply the supersymmetric isospectral formalism for an accurate treatment . for
any given potential , families of strictly isospectral potentials , _ with very different shape _ but having desirable and adjustable features are generated by supersymmetric isospectral formalism @xcite .
the near - zero energy bound state will be more effectively bound in the deep narrow well of the isospectral potential and will facilitate an easier and more accurate calculation of the near - zero energy excited state . following the steps of supersymmetric quantum mechanics @xcite , for any given potential @xmath7 , one can construct a class of potentials @xmath8 , where @xmath9 represents a set of one or more continuously variable real parameters .
the potential @xmath10 is isospectral in the sense that @xmath11 and @xmath10 have identical spectrum , reflection and tranmission coefficients .
for simplicity we consider only one parameter @xmath12 family of isospectral potentials .
we will see later that @xmath13 can take real values @xmath14 and @xmath15 . for @xmath16 ,
one gets back the original potential .
although the set of isospectral potentials are strictly isospectral with the original potential , they have different shapes depending on the parameter @xmath13 @xcite
. + fig .
1 ( color online ) the effective potential @xmath7 ( red solid curve ) and isospectral potentials @xmath17 corresponding to two values of @xmath13 : @xmath18 ( green dashed curve ) and @xmath19 ( blue dotted curve ) for the @xmath3he trimer .
all energies are in mk and @xmath20 in a.u .
the horizontal line indicates the energy of the first excited state in @xmath7 . in fig . 1 ,
we demonstrate how an original potential , @xmath7 shown by the solid ( red ) curve , changes in the isospectral potential @xmath17 for two values of the parameter @xmath13 , _ viz .
_ @xmath18 ( green dashed curve ) and @xmath19 ( blue dotted curve ) .
we introduce this figure here for a qualitative understanding of the features of the isospectral potentials .
a complete discussion of how such isospectral potentials are calculated will be presented in sections iic and iii .
although all three potentials produce identical energy spectrum , their shapes are seen to be very different .
the original potential [ @xmath7 ] has a shallow and wide well with a short range repulsion .
by contrast , both the isospectral potentials have a deep and narrow _ attractive _
well ( naw ) at smaller @xmath20 , while the long range part does not differ much from @xmath7 . one can also notice that as @xmath13 decreases , the narrow attractive well becomes deeper , while the intermediate barrier becomes higher .
hence , the near - zero energy ( indicated in fig . 1 by a horizontal line ) excited state in @xmath7 will be at the _ same energy value _ in the isospectral potentials , but now that state will lie _ deep within the naw_. thus , while this state is weakly bound and spatially extended in the original potential , it will be strongly bound and well localized in the naw of the isospectral potential , at the same energy . clearly , computation of the wave function and its energy ( equal to the energy of the first excited state in the original potential ) will be easier .
furthermore , this state becomes more strongly bound , as @xmath13 decreases . in general , as @xmath13 decreases continuously from @xmath22 to @xmath23 , @xmath10 starts developing a local minimum which shifts towards @xmath20=0 and becomes deeper and narrower .
consequently , a shallow potential transforms into one having a narrow and deep potential well near the origin in the isospectral potential .
the surface barrier also becomes high .
such interesting properties of @xmath10 can be useful to solve near - zero energy states .
such a state lies near the top of the original potential well and its wave function is spatially very extended , while the isospectral state lies well within the naw .
hence the latter is strongly bound and well localized within the narrow well of @xmath24 .
the parameter @xmath13 controls these features and a suitable optimum value can be chosen ( see later ) .
+ thus our approach consists of two steps . first ,
to apply a correlated quantum many - body theory for a highly correlated system like @xmath0he - trimer and second , to use the isospectral formalism for the accurate determination of the first excited state , whose energy is just a few mk .
+ the paper is organized as follows . in section ii , we present a brief review of the correlated potential harmonics expansion method , choice of potential and the isospectral formalism .
section iii presents the results of our numerical calculation .
finally we draw our conclusions in section iv .
for a realistic calculation , one needs an accurate he - he interaction potential .
several sophisticated he - he potentials have been proposed @xcite . among these ,
the commonly used ones are : tang , tonnies and yiu ( tty ) @xcite , lm2m2 @xcite , and hfd - he2 @xcite potentials .
these potentials reproduce all known two - body he - he data . in the present work ,
we select the more popular and sophisticated tty potential .
this potential has the form @xcite @xmath71,\ ] ] where @xmath72 represents the interparticle distance .
the part @xmath73 has the form @xmath74 = @xmath75 wih @xmath76 = @xmath77 .
the other part @xmath78 is given as @xmath79 = @xmath80 .
the coefficients @xmath81 are calculated using the recurrence relation @xmath81 = @xmath82 ; @xmath83 = 1.461 , @xmath84 = 14.11 , @xmath85 = 183.5 , @xmath86 = 315766.2067 @xmath65 , d= 7.449 and @xmath87 = 1.3443 @xmath88 . the function @xmath89 is given by @xmath90 = @xmath91 with @xmath92= @xmath93 - @xmath94 . + for our numerical solution ,
the set of cdes [ eq . ( 8) ] is solved by hyperspherical adiabatic approximation ( haa ) @xcite . in haa
, one assumes that the hyperradial motion is slow compared to the hyperangular motion .
the effective potential for the hyperradial motion ( obtained by diagonalizing the potential matrix together with the diagonal hypercentrifugal repulsion for a fixed value of @xmath20 ) is obtained as a parametric function of @xmath20 .
we choose the lowest eigenpotential ( @xmath7 ) as the effective potential .
thus in haa , energy and wavefunction are obtained approximately by solving a single uncoupled differential equation @xmath95 \zeta_{0}(r)=0,\ ] ] subject to appropriate boundary conditions on @xmath96 .
the principal advantage of the present method is two - fold .
firstly , the cph basis set correctly takes care of the effect of strong short range correlation produced by the he - he interaction .
secondly , the use of haa basically reduces the multidimensional problem to an effective one dimensional problem introducing the effective potential .
the effective potential @xmath97 gives a clear qualitative as well as quantitative picture . for our numerical calculation
we investigate the @xmath98 state and truncate the cph basis to a maximum value @xmath65 = @xmath99 , requiring proper convergence .
+ the ground state properties of @xmath0he dimer is obtained as a numerical solution of two - body schrdinger equation by runga - kutta algorithm .
the dimer energy @xmath100 using tty potential , as well as the results from other references are presented in table i. @xmath101 & present method & -1.254 + mk & dmc [ 23 ] & -1.243 + [ 27 ] & other [ 11 ] & -1.309 + & other [ 8 ] & -1.313 + although in our earlier calculation @xcite we reported the dimer and trimer ground state properties , we include them here for completeness of the discussion .
calculated rms value of @xmath55 is @xmath102 a.u .
the extremely small binding energy of the dimer and the large spatial extension of the ground state wave function imply that the ground state of helium dimer is very loosely bound .
the trimer ground state energy , as well as the results obtained in earlier investigations by other authors are presented in table ii for different potentials .
the r.m.s .
value of hyperradius is 21.389 @xmath103 thus our correlated ph basis successfully reproduces the energy values which are in very close agreement with other sophisticated calculations @xcite .
+ dmc + tty & 125.51 & 126.40[24 ] & 126.4 [ 7 ] & - & 125.46 [ 25 ] + lm2m2 & 126.37 & 126.40 [ 25 ] & 126.4 [ 7 ] & 125.2 [ 6 ] & + hfdhe2 & 120.28 & & 117.1 [ 7 ] & 98.1 [ 5 ] & + although we have done detailed calculation of @xmath0he trimer ground state energy , we failed to obtain any trimer excited state with this choice of two - body interaction .
very recently we have analyzed in details the behavior of @xmath0he trimer excited states as a function of pairwise interaction @xmath104 where @xmath105 controls the strength of two - body interaction .
@xmath105 = 1 is the physical value of the dimer interaction and @xmath105=0 corresponds to free particle limit when neither two - body nor three - body bound states appear .
we found that by increasing @xmath105 from a small value , the trimer starts to support an excited state at @xmath105 = 0.978 @xcite .
binding energy of the excited state gradually increases with increase in @xmath105 , attains its maximum value at @xmath105 = 0.984 , then it decreases gradually and disappears which indicates dissociation to trimer fragments as a dimer and monomer .
thus the disappearance of the first excited state due to both increasing and decreasing @xmath105 clearly show that the state is an efimov state .
but the value of @xmath105 for which this happens , does not correspond to the actual physical dimer interaction ( @xmath106 ) .
the efimov property of other excited states are also discussed in our earlier study @xcite .
however we did not claim that the trimer excited state does not exist at all , as there is a large body of work in this direction @xcite .
so this is still an ongoing issue as there is considerable controversy in the earlier discussions found in refs @xcite .
thus our earlier work could not resolve the problem .
it may be the limitation of our basis set which is unable to produce such an elusive state .
so it needs further study .
+ for an accurate determination of the elusive near - zero energy excited state , we use the supersymmetric isospectral formalism mentioned earlier .
note that this state lies near the top of the potential well @xmath7 and is very extended spatially .
consequently , a convergent calculation requires a very large number of hyperspherical partial waves ( corresponding to very large @xmath99 ) . on the other hand ,
the trimer ground state lies near the bottom of this well , is well bound and localized ; it therefore converges relatively easily .
now the isospectral potential @xmath107 with sufficiently small positive @xmath13 will have a deep well near the origin , followed by a high barrier ( see below ) .
the near - zero energy state sought after is now strongly trapped within this narrow well , _
i.e. _ it is sharply localized .
hence its convergence is achieved easily enough .
the isospectral potential is obtained in terms of the trimer ground state wave function ( see below ) , which by the above argument is determined with a fair degree of confidence and it offers easier calculation of the excited state .
+ since isospectral formalism is not a common topic , we briefly explain how an isospectral potential is obtained for a given potential @xcite .
for the given potential @xmath7 having a normalized ground state @xmath108 with energy @xmath109 , [ see eq .
( 11 ) ] , a superpotential @xmath110 is defined as @xmath111 then it can easily be seen that @xmath112 and one can define a supersymmetric partner potential @xmath113 through @xmath114 such that @xmath7 and its partner have the same energy spectra , except that the ground state of @xmath7 is absent in the spectrum of its partner @xcite .
+ now , for the given partner potential @xmath113 , eq . ( 15 ) can be considered as a non - linear differential equation satisfied by the unknown function @xmath110 ( called riccati equation ) . with this @xmath110
, we can get back @xmath7 , using eq . ( 14 ) .
but solution of the non - linear eq .
( 15 ) is not unique . for simplicity
, we use the units in which @xmath115
. then the most general solution is @xcite @xmath116 where @xmath13 is an integration constant and @xmath117 is a function of @xmath20 , parametrically dependent on @xmath13 .
@xmath118 is given by @xmath119}^{2 } dr^{\prime}.\ ] ] then the family of potentials @xmath120 given by @xmath121 for all allowed values of @xmath13 ( see below ) , has the _ same partner _ @xmath113 .
hence the family of potentials given by eq .
( [ isp ] ) all have identical spectrum . since @xmath108 is normalized , @xmath122 .
hence from eq .
( [ mgsp ] ) , one notices that the interval @xmath123 is not allowed . for all other values of @xmath13 , @xmath17 is strictly isospectral with @xmath7 @xcite . for @xmath124 , @xmath17 becomes @xmath7 . for small positive values of @xmath13
, the isospectral potential @xmath17 develops an attractive well near the origin . as @xmath125 ,
this well becomes deeper followed by a high barrier , before the shallower part .
note that the ground state of @xmath7 , _ viz .
_ @xmath108 , is necessary to calculate the family of isospectral potentials . in the present study
the ground state of @xmath7 is fairly accurately calculated .
we will see in the next section that different eigen states are transformed differently .
therefore this transformation can not be considered as a generalized rotation in the hilbert space .
thus the transformation from the original hamiltonian to the isospectral hamiltonian is different from a standard unitary transformation , even though the entire energy spectrum is preserved .
first we calculate the lowest effective potential @xmath7 in the hyperradial space by hyperspherical adiabatic approximation ( haa ) as stated in sec .
iib . to calculate the energy @xmath126 and wave function @xmath108 of the original potential we solve the single uncoupled equation , eq .
( 11 ) , with appropriate boundary conditions .
as stated earlier , although our calculated ground state energy @xmath109 and wave function are in good agreement with other calculations , we fail to get the first excited state in such a shallow potential . here
the isospectral formalism will be an effective technique to calculate several isospectral potentials of gradually varying shape , which will facilitate easier calculation of the very weakly bound state .
we calculate @xmath118 from eq .
( 17 ) and then the isospectral potential for a specific value of @xmath13 is calculated from eq . ( 18 ) .
+ in fig . 1 ,
the effective potential @xmath7 calculated by the cph method is shown as a continuous ( red ) curve .
this has a a soft repulsion at smaller @xmath20 , followed by a shallow minimum which supports the ground state at @xmath127 mk .
as stated earlier , we fail to get the first excited state in this effective potential , by our numerical calculation .
next we calculate the isospectral potential @xmath17 , for chosen values of @xmath13 .
we checked that for large values of @xmath13 , calculated @xmath17 is practically indistinguishable from @xmath7 . for small values of @xmath13 ,
the isospectral potential develops a deep and narrow well near the origin ( left side well , lsw ) with a barrier ( intermediate barrier , ib ) separating it from the shallow well ( right side well , rsw ) .
as @xmath13 decreases towards zero , lsw becomes deeper , narrower and closer to the origin and at the same time , ib becomes higher .
& @xmath128 & @xmath129 & @xmath130 & @xmath131 & @xmath132 & @xmath133 + @xmath22 & & & & & 8.999 & -3.238 + 0.00010 & 4.607 & -1.897 & 5.327 & 8.333 & 9.087 & -2.848 + 0.00005 & 4.527 & -8.119 & 5.137 & 10.23 & 9.087 & -2.847 + 0.00002 & 4.457 & -22.133 & 4.943 & 13.874 & 9.085 & -2.846 + 0.00001 & 4.417 & -40.254 & 4.817 & 18.019 & 9.085 & -2.846 + in table iii , we present numerical values of the parameters of the original ( corresponding to @xmath124 ) and isospectral potentials @xmath17 for @xmath134 and @xmath135 . for each isospectral potential , we give values of the position ( @xmath136 ) and value ( @xmath137 ) of the minimum of lsw , position ( @xmath130 ) and value ( @xmath131 ) of the maximun of ib , and position ( @xmath138 ) and value ( @xmath139 ) of the minimum of rsw .
we have checked by numerical calculation that the energy of both the ground and the first excited state remains independent of the choice of @xmath13 , as theory predicts . however , very small values of @xmath13 are not convenient for numerical calculation of the energy of the excited state , as numerical errors creep in , due to extreme narrowness of the lsw , in which the excited state resides .
thus a judicious choice of the value of @xmath13 is necessary . by careful investigations for different values of @xmath13
, we find that the range @xmath140 for the value of @xmath13 is optimum for minimizing errors .
as two typical cases demostrating the behavior of isospectral potentials , we plot @xmath141 for @xmath19 ( blue , dotted curve ) and @xmath18 ( green , dashed curve ) in fig .
1 . the very weakly bound first excited state in the original shallow potential @xmath7 now becomes strongly bound within the deep and narrow lsw of @xmath17 .
the deep well and the adjacent high barrier strongly localizes this state in the isospectral potential .
we solve eq .
( 11 ) , with @xmath7 replaced by @xmath17 , subject to appropriate boundary conditions to calculate the energy of the first excited state . following this isospectral technique
, we do indeed get a bound first excited state .
we also verified that its energy is the same , within estimated numerical errors , for values of @xmath13 lying within the chosen range .
the binding energy of the first excited state of trimer is thus found to be @xmath142 mk .
we present this result , together with results of other sophisticated calculations reported so far in table iv .
+ ref [ 11 ] & -2.282 + ref [ 7 ] & -2.280 + ref [ 8 ] & -2.277 + present method & -2.270 + here we remark that the isospectral formalism is an efficient tool to calculate near - zero energy states in shallow potential which supports at least one bound state . in the supersymmetric isospectral formalism , one can in principle calculate the energy value as well as the wave function . in our earlier calculation of the resonances of halo nuclei
, we used the wave function of the isospectral potential .
we calculated the probability of the system to be trapped in the well - barrier combination which facilitates the accurate determination of resonance energy @xcite .
we have observed that the resonance energy is independent of @xmath13 . however in the present application to calculate the bound state wave function in the isospectral potentials and to calculate other physical observables we should take a different approach . from fig . 1 , we see that decreasing @xmath13 gradually keeps the long - range part of the isospectral potentials almost unchanged whereas the short - range part has a drastic change .
naturally the wave functions of the isospectral family are now @xmath13 dependent and obviously the calculated physical observables [ e.g. average radius of the system ] will be @xmath13 dependent . in the susy isospectral formalism @xcite , it is possible to calculate the wave function of the original potential @xmath7 from the wave functions of the isospectral potential @xmath17 .
the ground state @xmath143 and the first excited state @xmath144 of the isospectral potential @xmath17 corresponding to the energies @xmath109 and @xmath145 respectively are related to the ground state @xmath108 and the first excited state @xmath146 of the original potential @xmath7 by @xcite @xmath147 and @xmath148 where @xmath149 is the wronskian and @xmath108 and @xmath146 are well - behaved functions .
we can calculate the ground state wave function @xmath143 of the isospectral potential @xmath17 from the original gound state wave function @xmath108 ( which is known as we calculated it to construct the family of isospectral potentials ) using eq .
alternatively we can obtain @xmath143 directly by solving for the isospectral potential @xmath17 .
also we can obtain @xmath150 by solving for the isospectral potential @xmath17 with energy @xmath145 .
thus eq .
( 20 ) is a first order differential equation in @xmath146 and we can solve it subject to proper boundary conditions @xmath151 and @xmath152 to obtain @xmath146 . with these wave functions
we can calculate any physical properties of the system and this time they will be independent of the @xmath13
. however usually in the susy isospectral formalism , people are interested only in the bound state energy and in this paper we are also interested only in the energy of the elusive first excited state . + next
we discuss in detail about the choice of @xmath13 parameter . as in our earlier works @xcite
, we observe that the energy is independent of the parameter @xmath13 . but making @xmath13 too small , may create large numerical error in the numerically calculated wave function @xmath150 , as the well becomes extremely narrow and very deep .
then the wave function changes very rapidly over a very small interval .
clearly its derivatives are inaccurate , which in turn affects the accuracy of the wave function at the next mesh point .
the errors accumulate .
as we solve the isospectral potential numerically , large numerical error will result for very small @xmath13 .
this may mask the overall accuracy .
thus the accuracy of the results are very crucially dependent on the choice of @xmath13 .
there is no prescribed rule to choose @xmath13 .
it is in general chosen by trial .
one can choose finer mesh interval within the lsw for a small @xmath13 .
but the cumulative error at successive mesh point , increases as the total number of mesh points increases . using the error estimate of the integration procedure ( we use runga - kutta algorithm ) we optimize the values of @xmath13 and mesh interval to minimize the error . in our earlier calculations @xcite for @xmath153 state of @xmath154he
, the shallowness of the effective potential is removed for @xmath13 = 10 , whereas @xmath13 = 0.1 was required for @xmath155 state of the same system to get the expected behavior of the isospectral potential .
thus the optimum choice of @xmath13 depends on the choice of the system and its state .
+ now in principle the ground state energy can also be recalculated using the isospectral potentials , in which the ground state of the original potential now lies in the very deep well of the isospectrals .
but , when we solve the isospectral potential numerically , large error may creep due to the extreme narrowness of the well , as discussed above .
thus when we use the isospectral formalism for the real many - body problems , ground state energy is more accurate when determined by the original potential and the excited states and resonance states are more accurate when we solve the isospectral potentials .
in conclusion , we remark that the isospectral potential with a judiciously chosen value of @xmath13 can be very useful for an accurate calculation of near - zero energy states in a shallow potential and also the resonance states of halo and highly unstable systems .
the present application to the very weakly bound and highly elusive first excited state in @xmath0he trimer demonstrates the novelty and practical utility of this technique .
+ this work has been partially supported by fapesp ( brazil ) , cnpq ( brazil ) , department of science and technology ( dst , india ) and department of atomic energy ( dae , india ) .
b.c . wishes to thank fapesp ( brazil ) for providing financial assistance for her visit to the universidade de so paulo , brazil , where part of this work was done .
skh wishes to thank the council of scientific and industrial research ( csir ) , india for a junior research fellowship . t.k.d .
acknowledges the university grants commission ( ugc , india ) for the emeritus fellowship .
+ references v. efimov , phys .
b * 33 * , 563 ( 1970 ) .
v. efimov , nucl .
a * 210 * , 157 ( 1973 ) .
t. kraemar _
et al _ , nature * 440 * , 315 ( 2006 ) ; s. knoop _
et al _ , nature phys .
lett . * 5 * , 227 ( 2009 ) ; m. zaccanti _
et al _ , nature phys . * 5 * , 586 ( 2009 ) .
t. cornelius and w. glckle , j. chem .
phys . * 85 * , 3906 ( 1986 ) .
b. d. esry , c. d. lin , and c. h. greene , phys .
a * 54 * , 394 ( 1996 ) .
e. nielsen , d. v. fedorov and a. s. jensen , j. phys .
b * 31 * , 4085 ( 1998 ) v. roudnev and s. yakovlev , chem . phys . lett .
* 328 * , 97 ( 2000 ) .
p. barletta and a. kievsky , phys .
a * 64 * , 042514 ( 2001 ) .
w. sandhas , e. a. kolganova , y. k. ho and a. k. motovilov , few - body syst .
* 34 * , 137 ( 2004 ) .
t. gonzlez - lezana _ et al .
* 82 * , 1648 ( 1999 ) .
a. k. motovilov , w. sandhas , s. a. sofianos and e. a. kolganova , eur .
j. d * 13 * , 33 ( 2001 ) .
h. suno and b. d. esry , phys . rev .
a * 78 * , 062701 ( 2008 ) .
e. braaten , h. w. hammer , d. kang , and l. platter , phys .
a * 78 * , 043605 ( 2008 ) .
w. schllkopf and j. p. toennies , science * 266 * , 1345 ( 1994 ) .
r. brhl _ et al .
* 95 * , 063002 ( 2005 )
. m. fabre de la ripelle , ann .
( n.y . ) * 147 * , 281 ( 1983 ) .
t. k. das , b. chakrabarti and s. canuto , j. chem .
* 134 * , 164106 ( 2011 ) .
f. cooper , a. khare and u. sukhatme , phys .
251 * , 267 ( 1995 ) .
t. k. das and b. chakrabarti , phys .
a * 70 * , 063601 ( 2004 ) .
t. k. das _
et al._,phys .
a * 373 * , 258 ( 2009 ) .
a. r. janjen and r. a. aziz , j. chem .
103 * , 9626 ( 1995 ) .
k. t. tang , j. p. toennies , c. l. yiu , phys .
* 74 * , 1546 ( 1995 ) .
r. a. aziz and m. j. slaman , j. chem .
phys . * 94 * , 8047 ( 1991 ) .
r. a. aziz , v. p. s. nain , j. s. carley , w. l. taylor , and g. t. mcconville , j. chem .
* 70 * , 4330 ( 1979 ) .
t. k. das , h. t. coelho and m. fabre de la ripelle , phys .
c * 26 * , 2281 ( 1982 ) .
m. lewerenz , j. chem .
* 106 * , 4596 ( 1997 ) .
_ j. chem .
phys . * 112 * , 717 ( 2000 ) .
d. blume and c. h. greene , j. chem .
phys . * 112 * , 8053 ( 2000 ) .
r. grisenti , w. schllkopf and j. p. toennies , phys .
* 85 * , 2284 ( 2000 ) .
t. k. das and b. chakrabarti , phys .
letts a * 288 * , 4 ( 2001 )
. s. k. dutta , t. k. das , m. a. khan and b. chakrabarti few - body systems * 35 * , 33 ( 2004 ) .
s. k. dutta , t. k. das , m. a. khan and b. chakrabarti , j. phys .
g : nucl . part
* 29 * , 2411 ( 2003 ) .
b. chakrabarti , proceedings of conference on non - hermitian hamiltonian in quantum physics , barc , india , june 13 - 16 , 2009 [ pramana , journal of physics , * 73 * , 405 ( 2009 ) ] . | we propose a novel mathematical approach for the calculation of near - zero energy states by solving potentials which are isospectral with the original one . for any potential , families of strictly isospectral potentials ( with very different shape ) having desirable and adjustable features
are generated by supersymmetric isospectral formalism .
the near - zero energy efimov state in the original potential is effectively trapped in the deep well of the isospectral family and facilitates more accurate calculation of the efimov state . application to the first excited state in @xmath0he trimer is presented . |
spin qubits confined in semiconductor quantum dots are promising candidates for quantum computing@xcite due to their demonstrated long coherence time , high control fidelities@xcite as well as expected scalability .
a natural approach , proposed by loss and divincenzo,@xcite is to encode one qubit using the spin up and down states of a single electron .
however , difficulties in performing esr - type single electron spin rotations@xcite in this type of the qubit have led researchers to propose alternative ways to encode qubits in the collective states of two or more electrons.@xcite the singlet - triplet qubit is the simplest qubit that can be controlled all - electrically via the exchange interaction,@xcite but its full control still requires a magnetic field gradient.@xcite in a seminal paper,@xcite divincenzo proposed a qubit employing certain three - spin states as the qubit , which can be controlled solely by the exchange interaction , and is thus termed as the `` exchange - only '' qubit .
the exchange - only qubit , together with its variant the resonant exchange qubit , has been experimentally demonstrated at the single - qubit level.@xcite nevertheless , hyperfine - mediated nuclear spin fluctuations@xcite as well as charge noises@xcite contribute to decoherence , preventing the implementation of more complicated operations required to operate two or more qubits , despite extensive theoretical studies on the two qubit gates.@xcite a comprehensive understanding of the interaction between noises and controls is therefore of crucial importance for the field to progress .
dynamically corrected gates@xcite ( dcgs ) are useful measures to combat decoherence .
inspired by the dynamical decoupling technique developed in the field of nmr quantum control,@xcite dcgs have been successfully developed to reduce both hyperfine and charge noise in the singlet - triplet qubit@xcite as well as the exchange - only qubit.@xcite the fundamental assumption of dcgs is the non - markovianity of noises , i.e. the noises are assumed to vary with a much longer time scale than typical gate operations . with this assumption ,
the dcgs are tailored under the static noise model , usually by canceling the effect of noise on the evolution operator up to certain orders using piecewise constant pulses . in realistic situations ,
the dcgs should work well for the low frequency components of the noises but not high frequency parts .
theoretical validation of this approximation has been performed through the randomized benchmarking@xcite for the singlet - triplet qubits@xcite under the @xmath0 noise,@xcite the power spectral density of which is proportional to @xmath1 .
it has been shown there that the dcgs offer great error reduction for @xmath6 but no error cancellation otherwise , where for the dcgs developed for the singlet - triplet qubit system@xcite the critical @xmath7 .
the validity of dcgs can then be assessed by measuring the noise spectra before they are actually being implemented , the feature of which is very useful for their experimental realization because the noise spectra are typically easier to be mapped out@xcite than actually carrying out the relatively complicated composite sequences.@xcite on the other hand , however , benchmarking of dcgs for the exchange - only qubits under realistic noises has been lacking in the literature .
this is an important open question because there are considerable differences between the exchange - only qubits and singlet - triplet qubits .
firstly , the pulse sequences now involve two exchange interactions thus is more complicated.@xcite secondly , the hyperfine noise not only causes dephasing as in other types of spin - qubit,@xcite but also leads to leakage outside of the computational subspace.@xcite third , the pulse sequences are longer than those of the singlet - triplet qubit.@xcite one may therefore speculate that the sequences proposed in ref .
would require noises with a larger @xmath8 compared to ones for singlet - triplet qubits , namely the noise must be more correlated for the dcgs to work in the exchange - only qubit .
it is unknown , without any qualitative results , that whether @xmath8 would exceed the experimentally measured value , for example @xmath9 ( cf .
ref . ) , rendering the dcgs useless .
it is therefore an important problem to study the effect of dcgs undergoing realistic noise for the exchange - only qubit system , in particular the determination of @xmath8 , which implies the range of the noise spectra with which the dcgs work . in this paper
, we perform a numerical study on how dcg pulses perform under @xmath0 noises for the exchange - only qubit .
we focus on the sequences developed in ref . which correct the hyperfine noise .
we numerically simulate the randomized benchmarking,@xcite comparing sequences composed of uncorrected and corrected single - qubit clifford gates respectively .
we find that the critical noise exponent for the dcgs developed in ref .
is @xmath10 .
although this value is larger than that found for the supcode sequences of singlet - triplet qubits , it is still lower than the experimentally measured ones available in the literature,@xcite reaffirming the noise - compensating power of the dcg sequences .
we also discuss the filter transfer functions@xcite , which offer complementarily useful information to the benchmarking.@xcite the remainder of this paper is organized as follows . in sec .
[ sec : model ] we give a summary of the model of an exchange - only qubit , the noise involved , and the dcgs that we are going to employ in this work .
[ sec : results ] presents our results , including the randomized benchmarking , fidelity decay constant , the improvement ratio of the dcgs and the filter transfer functions .
we conclude in sec .
[ sec : conclusion ] .
the exchange - only qubit is encoded in the @xmath11 and @xmath12 subspace of the three - electron system as @xmath13 and @xmath14 ( cf .
ref . ) .
inhomogeneous fluctuations in the magnetic field cause the qubit states to leak to an @xmath15 , @xmath12 state @xmath16 via the hyperfine coupling @xmath17 , where @xmath18 is the spin operator in the @xmath19-direction for the @xmath20th electron , and @xmath21 the hyperfine field.@xcite the hamiltonian of an exchange - only qubit can then be written under the basis @xmath22 .
it contains two parts , @xmath23 , each of which can be expressed in terms of the gell - mann matrices,@xcite @xmath24 , as@xcite @xmath25 with @xmath26 and @xmath27 here , @xmath28 and @xmath29 signify the inhomogeneity of the magnetic field stemming from the hyperfine fluctuations , which have been denoted as @xmath30 and @xmath31 in previous literature.@xcite @xmath32 is the exchange interaction between electrons in dots @xmath33 and @xmath20 which are controlled electrostatically [ a schematic picture is shown in fig . [
fig : pulseexample](a ) ] . in the absence of leakage , @xmath34 and @xmath35
implement rotations on the bloch sphere around two non - perpendicular axes , @xmath36 and @xmath37 , respectively .
these ideal rotations are denoted as @xmath38 and @xmath39 , which can then be utilized to implement arbitrary single - qubit rotations .
operations of an exchange - only qubit are subject to two major channels of noises .
the nuclear noise , @xmath40 , causes dephasing within the logical subspace and leakage to state @xmath41 . the charge noise , on the other hand , results in errors of the the control .
dynamically corrected gates are developed in order to combat these noises and improve the fidelity of the gate control , with the fundamental idea being the `` self - compensation '' of error . in particular , for the exchange - only qubits , it has been shown that cancellation of the leading order error arising from the hyperfine noise can be achieved by a composite pulse sequence containing 18 pieces .
further , if simultaneous resilience of charge noise and hyperfine noise is desired , a longer composite pulse consists of 13 properly combined hyperfine - noise - corrected sequence can cancel both noises to their leading orders.@xcite these composite pulses are theoretically tailored based on a complete cycle of permutation between different spins , the symmetry property of which has greatly simplified the problem .
an important assumption behind the family of dynamically corrected gates is the non - markovianity of noises .
while this quasi - static - noise approximation is justified by the fact that the time scale with which the noise varies is much longer than the typical gate operation time , it remains necessary to benchmark these gate sequences in a more realistic time - dependent noise environment , for example the @xmath0 noise.@xcite this practice has been done for the supcode sequence developed for the singlet - triplet qubit,@xcite and the conclusion is that the dcgs will generally offer improvement for the noise exponent @xmath42 but not otherwise .
however , the benchmarking remains to be done for the exchange - only qubit because there are important differences .
as mentioned above , the pulse sequences for the exchange - only qubit involve two - axis exchange control and are longer than supcode .
moreover , there is one additional channel of error the leakage which needs to be treated .
it is therefore conceivable that the critical noise exponent , @xmath8 may be higher for the dcg of the exchange - only qubit than the supcode .
a quantitative evaluation of this statement is one of the main purposes of this paper .
( a ) , canceling the leading order contribution from the hyperfine noise .
@xmath43 is an arbitrary time unit.,title="fig : " ] ( b ) , canceling the leading order contribution from the hyperfine noise .
@xmath43 is an arbitrary time unit.,title="fig : " ] in order to clarify this issue , we numerically performed the randomized benchmarking of the 24 single - qubit clifford gates . in this work
, we focus on the hyperfine - noise - corrected sequence only.@xcite the sequences which cancel both hyperfine and charge noise are much longer@xcite ( which needs rotation around the bloch sphere by a total angle of about @xmath44 ) and is unlikely to provide substantial error reduction compared to the hyperfine - noise - corrected one for similar noises .
further optimization is required for this type of sequences . to facilitate the discussion
, we explicitly give the pulse sequence corresponding to a net rotation of @xmath45 @xmath46 which cancels hyperfine noise as follows .
the sequence , denoted by @xmath47 , can be expressed as @xmath48 ^ 2 \\
= r_{12}(\phi ) + \mathcal{o}\left[\left(\delta_a+\delta_b\right)^2\right],\label{eq : hfcorrdu12}\end{gathered}\ ] ] where @xmath49 is defined as @xmath50 and @xmath51 is the evolution according to the hamiltonian eq . under the hyperfine noise
@xmath52 an example of the composite pulse sequence for a rotation @xmath53 is shown in fig .
[ fig : pulseexample](b ) . for the corresponding sequence of @xmath54 , one simply interchanges the indices 12 and 23 in eq . .
we now explain how we construct the 24 single - qubit clifford gates using the available rotations around the @xmath19-axis and another @xmath55 apart from it .
note that arbitrary single - qubit rotation of angle @xmath56 around the unit vector @xmath57 , @xmath58 , can be decomposed into rotations around the @xmath59 and @xmath19 axis as @xmath60 [ cf . ref . ] and @xmath61 . in order to express @xmath62 in terms of @xmath63 and @xmath64 ,
we first decompose @xmath65 in the same way : @xmath66 finding the exact values of @xmath67 and @xmath68 . then , @xmath62 is simply @xmath69 where @xmath70 and @xmath71 .
a complete list of the single - qubit cliiford gates expressed in terms of @xmath63 and @xmath64 rotations are presented in the appendix .
noise used in the simulation . ( a ) noise as a function of time.(b ) the power spectral density corresponding to ( a ) , @xmath72 .
the noise amplitude @xmath73 has been scaled such that @xmath74 . ]
[ fig : noises example ] shows an example of the time - dependent noise that we are using in this work .
the @xmath0 noise has a power spectral density @xmath75 where @xmath2 is the noise exponent that determines the extent to which the noise is correlated , and @xmath73 is the amplitude .
the @xmath0 noise is typically generated by summing random telegraph signals,@xcite which in principle is capable of producing noises with exponent @xmath76 , but in practice good convergence is only achieved for a more limited range @xmath77 . therefore in this work we use the method described in ref .
, capable to generate @xmath0 noises with exponent @xmath78 .
[ fig : noises example](a ) shows @xmath79 , the noise as a function of time , while fig .
[ fig : noises example](b ) shows the corresponding power spectral density with @xmath80 . to facilitate the discussion
, we also introduce @xmath43 as the time unit throughout this work . the dimensionless control field , @xmath81 ( where @xmath82 is either @xmath83 or @xmath84 ) , takes value between 0 to 1 .
assuming that in experiments @xmath82 ranges between 100 mhz and 1 ghz , the time unit @xmath43 should be taken as @xmath85 ns . noises with different noise exponents @xmath2 as indicated .
@xmath86 is the number of gates and @xmath87 indicates the fidelity .
the results for uncorrected and corrected gates are shown as blue and red lines , respectively .
the noise amplitudes for each panel are ( a ) @xmath88 , ( b ) @xmath89 , ( c ) @xmath90 , ( d ) @xmath91 , ( e ) @xmath92 , and ( f)@xmath93 . ]
while the fidelities or errors of individual quantum gates are of great interest , they can not be straightforwardly used to predict the fidelity of a quantum algorithm , which involves a number of such gates . moreover , when the noises are time - dependent , the duration of one quantum gate is typically too short for the noise to exhibit the desired spectrum .
a widely - used approach to this problem is the randomized benchmarking.@xcite the benchmarking is implemented by averaging the gate fidelities over random sequences of gates drawn from a subset of quantum gates the clifford group undergoing different realizations of noises .
the average gate fidelity is then obtained by performing an exponential fit to the fidelity decay curve .
this practice avoids the error introduced during the initialization and read - out , and focuses on the gate operations . in this work ,
we numerically simulate the randomized benchmarking of single - qubit clifford gates for the exchange - only qubit under the hyperfine noise of @xmath0 type . in each run the fluctuations in @xmath94 and @xmath95 [ cf .
eq . ] are assumed to have the same spectrum but are independent . in order to ensure convergence ,
we have averaged the fidelities of at least 500 random gate sequences undergoing different noise realizations for a given noise spectrum before the exponential fit is made .
[ fig : fidplot ] shows the results of the randomized benchmarking of the single - qubit clifford gates , comparing the uncorrected ones and ones corrected against the hyperfine noise .
the fidelities decay approximately exponentially , and they saturate at a value of @xmath96 .
this is consistent with the theoretical investigation of situations involving leakage.@xcite the gate error inferred from the decay of the fidelity is therefore a combination of the dephasing and leakage error .
[ fig : fidplot](a ) shows the case with @xmath97 , meaning that the noise is very much similar to a white noise and one does not expect that the composite pulse should offer any improvement .
in fact , the steep initial drop of the red line indicates that the corrected sequences have much larger error compared to the uncorrected pulses , represented by the smoothly decaying blue line . in fig .
[ fig : fidplot](b ) where @xmath98 , it is still the case that the error is larger for the corrected sequences , but the differences from the uncorrected pulse are smaller .
as @xmath2 further increases , the noise concentrates more at low frequencies and the composite pulses work better , as can be seen in fig .
[ fig : fidplot](c)-(f ) . to make the comparison clear , we have chosen the amplitudes for noises with different exponents such that the error for the uncorrected pulses are comparable for these panels .
we note that it is difficult to make a direct comparison between noises with different @xmath2 values because they have different energies .
therefore we show typical results for noises with specific amplitudes in fig .
[ fig : fidplot ] , but consider the dependences of gate error on the noise amplitudes in the next step . for @xmath80 [ fig .
[ fig : fidplot](c ) ] , the error for uncorrected and corrected sequences are comparable , although that for the corrected sequences is still a little larger than the uncorrected ones for the amplitude @xmath99 . at @xmath100 [ fig .
[ fig : fidplot](d ) ] the corrected sequences start to offer improvements , and the improvements becomes much more pronounced as @xmath2 becomes even larger .
for @xmath101 [ fig .
[ fig : fidplot](e ) ] , the gate error has been substantially suppressed by the corrected sequence so that after 500 gates the fidelity is still larger than 0.5 . in the case of @xmath102 [ fig .
[ fig : fidplot](f ) ] , the fidelity is maintained above 80% after 500 gate operations , indicating the strong power of the noise - corrected sequences .
we fit the fidelity decaying curves as shown in fig . [
fig : fidplot ] to @xmath103 where the fidelity decay constant @xmath104 is related to both the dephasing and leakage error of the quantum gates .
it is difficult and unnecessary to separate the two for this work , since our main focus is to investigate the improvement of the overall gate fidelity by composite pulses under different noise conditions .
we will therefore use the fidelity decay constant @xmath104 as a measure of the gate error , without distinguishing different kinds of error . in fig .
[ fig : aveerror ] we show the dependence of the fitted fidelity decay constant @xmath104 on the noise amplitude @xmath73 .
this can be considered as a summary of all benchmarking results , among which only representative results have been shown in fig .
[ fig : fidplot ] . for small @xmath2 ,
the noise is similar to the white noise and dynamically corrected gates will not reduce the error but rather increase it , as can be seen from fig .
[ fig : aveerror](a ) and ( b ) . for an intermediate value of @xmath80 , uncorrected and corrected pulses
have similar performances . as @xmath2 increases ,
the noises become more correlated and the corrected sequences outperform the uncorrected ones .
[ fig : aveerror](d ) shows that for @xmath100 and small enough noise @xmath105 the dynamically corrected gates have reduced the error by about an order of magnitude , while in fig .
[ fig : aveerror](e ) , we see that the error reduction becomes about two orders of magnitude for the case of @xmath101 .
the reduction is almost three orders of magnitude when @xmath2 is as large as 3 , in which case the noise becomes slowly varying and is similar to the quasi - static noise originally conceived in the development of the dynamically corrected gates .
these are consistent with the qualitative consideration that dcgs work better for low frequency noises but would produce even larger errors than uncorrected pulses if the noise contains a substantial higher - frequency part . in order to further understand how the improvement made by dynamically corrected gates relates to the structure of the noise , we define an improvement ratio @xmath106 as the ratio between errors resulted from the uncorrected and corrected pulses under the same noise condition . we observe from fig .
[ fig : aveerror ] that for noises with small enough amplitudes the two curves becomes two parallel lines , and a ratio between them is well defined .
the reason is that while the dynamically corrected gates can fully cancel zero frequency noise and can compensate the majority of the contributions from low frequencies , it can not fully remove the effect of low frequency noises , let alone higher frequency parts .
therefore the first - order correction to the evolution operator due to the noises , proportional to @xmath73 , always exist and such dependence will be made clear when @xmath73 is sufficiently small .
therefore the defined improvement ratio @xmath106 is essentially the ratio between the coefficients of the leading - order error in the gate fidelity for uncorrected and corrected sequences .
note that for @xmath102 [ fig .
[ fig : fidplot](f ) ] , the two lines are not parallel for @xmath107 and the error shows different scaling . here
, the noise varies so slowly and the dcgs works so well that compared to the second order error in the evolution operator , the first order error is almost removed by the dynamically corrected gates . nevertheless , for sufficiently small @xmath73 ( in this case one must go down to @xmath108 ) the two lines will still become parallel . in practice due to
the lower bound to @xmath73 and @xmath104 imposed by the machine precision the range that the two lines are approximately parallel is much narrower than other cases , but we have still been able to obtain a meaningful @xmath106 for this situation . in any case , if @xmath106 is taken before the two lines becomes parallel then the actual improvement can only be larger than that value .
therefore one may consider that such a fit may slightly underestimate the improvement afforded by the dynamically corrected gates . in fig .
[ fig : ratio ] we show the improvement ratio @xmath106 versus the noise exponent @xmath2 .
this is the core result of this paper as it provides useful information to the experimentalists who are to implement the dcgs developed in ref . .
from the figure we can clearly see that for small @xmath2 ( white - like noise ) , @xmath110 , meaning that dynamically corrected gates produce larger error than the uncorrected ones due to their prolonged gate time . for large @xmath2 ( quasi - static noise )
dynamically corrected gates offer great improvements as seen by the large @xmath106 value in fig .
[ fig : ratio ] .
it is therefore important to know the critical exponent @xmath8 where the two situation cross .
we have found that for the dcgs developed to combat the hyperfine noise in the exchange - only qubit,@xcite @xmath5 . this value is larger than the @xmath8 previously found for the singlet - triplet qubits.@xcite the reasons that dcgs for the exchange - only qubit requires a more correlated noise than the singlet - triplet qubit case to take effect possibly include the complexity of the pulse sequences ( two control pulses for the exchange - only versus one for the singlet - triplet qubits ) , and most likely the presence of an additional channel of decoherence , the leakage .
fortunately , experimentally measured noise exponent for gaas systems are still much larger than @xmath5 ( in refs .
@xmath2 has been measured to be @xmath111 ) . in ref .
, the noise spectrum has been measured to be @xmath112 where @xmath113 .
converting to our units it implies that @xmath114 . taking @xmath115 then @xmath116 . comparing to fig .
[ fig : aveerror](e ) we see that this is in a range where the dynamically corrected gates offer about two orders of magnitude reduction in the error induced by the hyperfine noise .
these qualitative considerations indicate that the dynamically corrected gates , proposed in ref . , are very useful to cancel hyperfine noises in actual experiments .
another important characterization of the noise - canceling ability of quantum gates is the filter transfer function.@xcite the filter transfer function was introduced in systems involving two states and because of the presence of a leaked state in our case , the formalism needs to be slightly modified .
provides a pedagogical review of the filter function formalism and we start from there .
( 10 ) , the control matrix , of ref . should be modified in our case as @xmath117/2,\ ] ] where @xmath118 run from 1 though 8 and @xmath119 s are the gell - mann matrices mentioned in the previous section .
the error vector , denoted by @xmath120 in ref . , is now an 8-dimensional vector with @xmath121,@xmath122,@xmath123,@xmath124 , and all other elements being zero .
the spectral density of these elements can be expressed as @xmath125 using the relationship between @xmath126 and @xmath127 , we may define @xmath128 and @xmath129 where the @xmath73 and @xmath130 , as mentioned above , are used to simplify the subscripts @xmath131 and @xmath132 in refs . .
with these definitions of the correlation functions of the hyperfine noises , we may write the fidelity with leading order correction as @xmath133,\label{eq : fqaqb}\ ] ] where @xmath134 and @xmath135 are the filter functions corresponding to noise channels @xmath73 and @xmath130 , which can be further broken down as @xmath136 and @xmath137 here , @xmath138 is related to the fourier transform of the control matrix [ cf .
( 24 ) in ref . ] as @xmath139 one can also readily verify that @xmath140 , @xmath141 , @xmath142 , and @xmath143 all vanish for our problem .
we note here that to a certain extent , @xmath144 s give separate characterization of dephasing and leakage errors due to the structure of the hyperfine hamiltonian eq . .
in particular , contributions of @xmath145 and @xmath146 relate to dephasing , and those of @xmath147 and @xmath148 relate to leakage .
eq . and can therefore be interpreted that contributions to the hyperfine - noise - induced gate error from leakage is about twice as large as dephasing error .
figure [ fig : filtfunc ] shows the results of these filter transfer functions for a chosen quantum gate , the hadamard gate @xmath149 .
the filter transfer functions for other gates are very similar and are thus not shown here .
the blue lines show the filter transfer functions for the uncorrected sequences while red ones correspond to the dcgs corrected against the hyperfine noise .
the difference in scaling is apparent for all cases because the corrected pulses completely suppress leading order errors , and in realistic situations one must multiply the filter functions and the noise spectra to obtain the corrections to the fidelity as eq . .
it is hard to directly compare the results between the output of eq . and
the gate error derived from the randomized benchmarking , because the former is for individual gates while the latter is an average for a sequence of gates .
nevertheless , we have verified that the two results are of the same order of magnitude , offering a rough cross - check between the two methods .
representative results comparing the the average gate errors ( the fidelity decay constant @xmath104 ) for the singlet - qubit clifford gates extracted from the randomized benchmarking and the errors of a specific gate , @xmath149 , calculated from integrating the product of the noise spectra and the filter functions according to eq . are shown in table [ tab : comprbfilt ] for two different @xmath2 values .
we see that the errors are of the same order of magnitude for noises with the same amplitude and exponent , providing an independent check for our results of randomized benchmarking as well as the filter transfer functions .
before we end this section , we note that in practice when one replaces for example @xmath45 by @xmath150 , care must be exercised in regards to the domain of @xmath151 ( between @xmath152 and @xmath153 ) so that @xmath154 s may be required to be added or subtracted to or from @xmath56 .
65ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.57.120 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/nphys174 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1126/science.1116955 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/nphys1856 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.105.266808 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/nature10707 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/nature11449 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1038/nature05065 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.89.147902 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/nphys1424 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.105.216803 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.107.146801 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.110.177602 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1038/35042541 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.82.075403 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.111.050501 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1126/sciadv.1500214 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.91.205434 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.91.235411 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.93.121410 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.111.050502 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.111.050503 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.89.085314 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.90.045306 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.92.125409 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.93.075436 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.80.032314 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.104.090501 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.86.042329 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/ncomms2003 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.109.020501 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.88.052326 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrev.80.580 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrev.94.630 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.1716296 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.98.100504 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.110.140502 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.89.022310 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.90.155306 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.77.012307 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.85.042311 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.84.075339 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.108.086802 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) http://stacks.iop.org/1367-2630/15/i=9/a=095004 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.93.022303 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ , ed .
( , ) @noop * * , ( ) | we study theoretically the responses of the dynamically corrected gates to time - dependent noises in the exchange - only spin qubit system .
we consider @xmath0 noises having spectra proportional to @xmath1 , where the exponent @xmath2 indicates the strength of correlation within the noise .
the quantum gate errors due to noises are extracted from a numerical simulation of randomized benchmarking , and are compared between the application of uncorrected operations and that of dynamically corrected gates robust against the hyperfine noise .
we have found that for @xmath3 , the dynamically corrected gates offer considerable reduction in the gate error and such reduction is approximately two orders of magnitude for the experimentally relevant noise exponent . on the other hand ,
no improvement of the gate fidelity is provided for @xmath4 .
this critical value @xmath5 is comparatively larger than that for the cases for the singlet - triplet qubits .
the filter transfer functions corresponding to the dynamically corrected gates are also computed and compared to those derived from uncorrected pulses .
our results suggest that the dynamically corrected gates are useful measures to suppress the hyperfine noise when operating the exchange - only qubits . |
after many years of intensive research in the `` quantum chaos area '' it is now commonly accepted that the quantum behavior of complex systems may be strongly correlated with the character of their classical motion @xcite . even such a purely quantum phenomenon as tunneling
may be profoundly affected by chaotic classical dynamics . for regular systems a smooth dependence of the tunneling rate on parameters
is expected . in the presence of chaotic motion ,
the tunneling rates typically strongly fluctuate , the game is then to identify both the average behavior and the statistical properties of the fluctuations .
imagine the situation when the wavefunction is predominantly localized in a region of regular motion .
the tunneling to the chaotic sea surrounding the regular island , called `` chaos assisted tunneling '' ( cat ) has been quite thoroughly studied @xcite .
it may be characterized by the statistics of tunneling rates , or directly measurable quantities such as tunneling splittings between doublets of different symmetries @xcite or tunneling widths @xcite where the tunneling to the chaotic sea leads eventually to decay ( e.g. to ionization of atomic species ) .
model based on random matrix theory ( rmt ) @xcite show that distributions of both quantities are closely correlated with both the splittings @xcite and _ square roots _ of the widths @xcite having a common cauchy ( lorentzian - like ) distribution with an exponential cutoff for extremely large events .
such a situation occurs for sufficiently small @xmath0 ( in the semiclassical regime ) when the tunneling coupling is much smaller than the mean level spacing in a given system .
another possibility occurs when virtually all accessible phase space ( at a given energy ) is chaotic : the tunneling occurs through a potential ( rather than dynamical as in the previous case ) barrier
. then a standard rmt based answer leads to the porter - thomas distribution of widths ( or its appropriate many channel extension ) as applied in various areas from nuclear physics @xcite , mesoscopics @xcite or chemical reactions @xcite to name a few .
creagh and whelan @xcite developed a semiclassical approach to tunneling ( for a semiclassical treatment concentrating on other aspects of tunneling see e.g. @xcite ) which enabled them to give an improved statistical distribution of tunneling rates @xcite .
the distribution has been tested on a model system and shown to faithfully represent the tunneling splitting distribution provided the classical dynamics is sufficiently chaotic . however
, this distribution fails for systems when scarred @xcite wavefunctions dominate the process . in order to take into account scarring ,
the same authors @xcite developed a more complicated semiclassical theory which , in a model system , accurately describes the numerically observed tunneling rates .
the aim of this paper is twofold .
firstly , we propose a simpler approach to the effect of scarring than that in @xcite .
our approach is less general , as it is limited to the case when only one channel contributes to tunneling .
this is , however , a very frequent situation : because tunneling typically decays exponentially with some parameter , most contributions are often hidden by a single dominant one . the formulas that we obtain are also much simpler .
secondly , we consider the tunneling rate distribution in a challenging , realistic system - a hydrogen atom in parallel electric and magnetic fields .
as mentioned by creagh and whelan , one expects there the above mentioned problems due to scar - dominated tunneling . here
again we test the proposed distribution on a vast set of numerical data .
thirdly , in contrast with most of the previous studies , we do not consider here a situation where tunneling manifests itself as a quasi - degeneracy between a pair of even - odd states , but rather the case when tunneling is followed by a subsequent ionization of the system and manifests itself in the widths ( ionization rates ) of resonances .
the analysis for both cases is similar , but not identical .
let us recall first shortly the analysis of chaotic tunneling used in @xcite , which makes it possible to predict the distribution of tunneling rates in terms of classical quantities .
this approach is based on the standard semiclassical expansion of the green function as a sum over classical orbits ( which is used e.g. in periodic orbit theory _ la gutzwiller _ ) , but incorporates in addition some complex orbits , that is orbits where time , position and momentum can be made complex .
such orbits may tunnel through the potential well and eventually lead to escape at infinity ; they are essential for the calculation of tunneling rates . in the one - dimensional case
, it is well understood that tunneling can be quantitatively described using a single complex orbit known as the instanton : the orbit propagates under the potential well with a purely real position , and purely imaginary time and momentum , until it emerges in the real phase space when the potential barrier is crossed ( it can be visualized as a standard real orbit in the inverted potential ) .
the action @xmath1 of the instanton is then purely imaginary @xmath2 and the tunneling rate is , not surprisingly , essentially described by the @xmath3 contribution . for a multidimensional system ,
the situation is somehow comparable , except that there are now several instanton orbits .
it also turns out that the structure of the tunneling complex orbits can be extremely complicated @xcite .
however , because of the exponential decrease of the tunneling rate , in the semiclassical limit @xmath4 there are cases when the instanton orbit with the smallest imaginary action will give the dominant contribution .
creagh and whelan succeeded in expressing the tunneling rate in terms of the action and stability exponent of the instanton orbit @xcite .
they were able to describe the situation of a symmetric double well , where tunneling manifests itself through the existence of pairs of quasi - degenerate states , i.e. to calculate the splitting of the doublets .
comparison with exact " numerical results for a model system showed a very good agreement @xcite .
they were also able to describe the situation of tunneling outside a single potential well ( with chaotic dynamics inside the well ) followed by ionization " , that is particle directly escaping toward infinity .
the quantity of interest is the weighted " density of states , where the weight is given by the widths @xmath5 of the resonances with energies @xmath6 : @xmath7 in the semiclassical approximation , it can be written in the spirit of periodic orbit theory as the sum of smooth and oscillatory terms : @xmath8 explicitly , the smooth term reads @xmath9 where @xmath10 is the ( imaginary ) action of the periodic instanton ( that is the full orbit back and forth across the potential well ) , @xmath11 the number of freedoms of the system and @xmath12 the @xmath13 stability matrix of the instanton .
the oscillatory term is not explicitly written by creah and whelan , but it is rather simple to calculate it from their papers . in the simple case where the classical orbit which is the real continuation of the instanton inside the potential well is a periodic orbit ( this is for example the case when the instanton is along a symmetry axis of the potential ) , it is not surprising that the oscillatory terms will be governed by the properties of this real periodic orbit .
indeed , it is known that the eigenstates inside the well will be scarred by such an orbit , thus showing either an increased or decreased probability density at the point where the instanton emerges .
it is thus reasonable to expect that scarred ( resp .
anti scarred ) states will show an increased ( resp .
decreased ) tunneling probability .
the modulations of the weighted density of states are thus related to the action of the real periodic orbit .
more specifically , one gets : @xmath14}}{\sqrt{(-1)^{d-1}\det(wm^j - i ) } } } \label{cw4}\ ] ] where @xmath15 is the ( real ) action of the periodic orbit in the well and @xmath16 its stability matrix .
the sum over @xmath17 just takes into account the repetitions of this orbit .
this approach is restricted to a low tunneling rate , when repetitions of the instanton give negligible contributions .
the fact that , in the contribution of the instanton , there is a @xmath18 prefactor , half the prefactor for the oscillatory term , is not trivial , but explained in ref . @xcite .
we consider a hydrogen atom placed in static parallel magnetic and electric fields .
the hamiltonian of the system is ( for infinite mass of the nucleus , neglecting relativistic and qed corrections , in atomic units ) @xmath19 where @xmath20 stands traditionally for the magnetic field in atomic units ( @xmath21 tesla ) while @xmath22 is the static electric field ( in atomic units of @xmath23 v / m ) assumed to be oriented , together with the magnetic field , along the @xmath24 axis .
the system obeys cylindrical symmetry and @xmath25 is a constant of motion .
the last , zeeman term in the hamiltonian gives thus a constant shift ( for a given @xmath25 ) and will be omitted for simplicity .
classically , the atom may ionize for energies @xmath26 .
note that ionization occurs in the @xmath27 direction - the diamagnetic term provides a two - dimensional harmonic oscillator binding potential in the perpendicular directions .
the character of the classical motion depends on the energy as well as on the relative magnitude of electric and magnetic fields , as discussed long time ago in @xcite .
in fact the system obeys the standard classical scaling laws @xcite .
explicitly , scaling with respect to the magnetic field as @xmath28 , @xmath29 , @xmath30 , @xmath31 , @xmath32 , leads to a new hamiltonian dependent on two parameters only , the scaled energy @xmath33 and scaled electric field @xmath34 @xmath35 later on we shall drop the @xmath36 sign using classically scaled variables only . with this scaling and for @xmath37 ( pure magnetic field ) ,
the motion is predominantly regular for small @xmath38 ; for larger @xmath39 a gradual transition to chaos takes place so that , for @xmath40 practically all the available phase space becomes chaotic @xcite .
this character of the motion is basically preserved for @xmath41 , provided @xmath42 i.e. , below the classical ionization threshold .
quantum mechanics does not preserve the scaling . instead of finding , however , eigenenergies at given values of magnetic @xmath20 and electric @xmath22 fields
, it is a celebrated tradition now to consider scaled spectra @xcite , i.e. choose values of external fields as to obtain eigenenergies at fixed @xmath33 .
this procedure is straightforward .
rewriting the schrdinger equation , one may obtain a generalized eigenvalue problem for fixed @xmath33 ( and @xmath34 in our case ) from which quantized field values @xmath43 are obtained .
if one were to get back to the original problem , then a given @xmath44 value together with the definition of @xmath33 yields the energy @xmath6 which is an eigenvalue of the original schrdinger equation for that @xmath44 field value .
the set of @xmath44 obtained for a fixed values of @xmath33 and @xmath34 corresponds to the very same classical dynamics while different @xmath43 play the role of different values of the effective planck constant @xmath45 .
one may then expect that to study quantum tunneling in the semiclassical regime with a well defined classical mechanics , it is sufficient to diagonalize a standard scaled problem .
this is , however , not completely true : indeed , because tunneling implies that the electron ionizes , the energy spectrum is not a discrete spectrum of bound states , but rather composed of resonances . far below the classical ionization threshold ,
the widths of the resonances are extremely small and can be neglected
. then diagonalization of the hamiltonian in a convenient basis set may produce a discrete energy spectrum which very well approximates the true resonances .
on the other hand , far above the ionization threshold , the spectrum is continuous and basically unstructured .
we are interested in the intermediate situation , in the vicinity of the classical ionization threshold , where the resonances have a small but significant width due to tunneling followed by ionization .
the treatment of tunneling resonances necessitates a further standard extension , known from the pure magnetic field case above the ionization threshold @xcite : a complex rotation approach @xcite .
the idea is to apply the following complex scaling ( or rotation if viewed in the complex plane ) : @xmath46 , @xmath47 to the hamiltonian of the system , where @xmath48 is a real positive parameter representing the complex rotation angle ( typically of the order of 0.1 rad ) .
the transformed hamiltonian is no longer an hermitian operator , and its diagonalization yields complex eigenvalues @xmath49 where @xmath6 is the energy of the resonance and @xmath5 its width , i.e. the inverse of its lifetime .
well below the classical ionization threshold , eq .
( [ classth ] ) , the widths should be vanishingly small ; with increasing @xmath50 some states , notably those extended in @xmath27 direction , i.e. , along the `` ionization direction '' , should have increased imaginary parts indicating tunneling ionization . above the threshold , eq .
( [ classth ] ) , ionization becomes classically allowed and the widths are expected to be large .
moreover , in the tunneling regime , the widths should on the average exponentially decrease in magnitude with decreasing @xmath0 according to an @xmath51 law with @xmath10 being a characteristic tunneling action .
the expectations described in the previous section are based on a rough classical analysis of the ionization process . in order to test these ideas and the semiclassical prediction for the widths of the resonances
, we have performed extensive numerical studies of the energy spectrum of the system .
the matrix representing the complex rotated hamiltonian in a sturmian basis set @xcite is easily obtained , as matrix elements have strong selection rules and are all known as simple analytic expressions .
the matrix in then diagonalized using the lanczos algorithm @xcite , producing several hundreds or thousands fully converged eigenvalues .
we have carefully checked that all eigenvalues presented in this paper are fully converged .
the only limitation is that the calculation is performed in double precision , yielding about 12 significant digits .
this also implies that widths ( tunneling rates ) smaller than @xmath52 can not be accurately computed .
it turns out that , below the classical ionization threshold , eq . ( [ classth ] ) , the widths of the resonances are usually very small . moreover , as we are interested in the situation when the classical dynamics inside the potential well is chaotic , we have to use a rather large value of the scaled energy @xmath33 typically @xmath53 which in turns correspond to a rather small value of the scaled electric field at the ionization threshold , that is typically @xmath54 from eq .
( [ classth ] ) . for these values
, we observed that the numerically computed widths are all vanishingly small , smaller than the @xmath52 accuracy of the numerics .
this can be understood from eq .
( [ cw3 ] ) .
indeed , the stability exponent of the instanton orbit is in our specific case enormous .
the reason is that the potential in the vicinity of the saddle point is very anisotropic .
it is strongly bounded by the diamagnetic term in the transverse @xmath55 plane but has a only a very smooth potential maximum in the field @xmath56 direction .
the instanton can be seen as a real orbit propagating in the inverted potential .
this inverted potential has a shallow minimum in the @xmath27 direction but falls down very rapidly in the transverse directions : the instanton moves along a sharp potential ridge and is thus extremely unstable .
we show in the appendix how to calculate the action @xmath10 and stability matrix @xmath12 of the instanton . for small @xmath34 ( the regime we are interested in ) ,
the following approximate expressions are sufficient : @xmath57 and @xmath58 for @xmath59 the denominator in eq .
( [ cw3 ] ) is thus of the order of @xmath60 which explains that the widths can not be measured in a numerical experiment .
an alternative , equivalent , quantum " explanation can be given .
the magnetic field term in the hamiltonian is responsible for a harmonic potential in the direction perpendicular to the fields .
thus the quantum mechanical energy of the motion in the @xmath61 plane can not be smaller than the energy of the lowest state of the corresponding oscillator .
for @xmath62 the energy in question is the ground state energy @xmath63 while for other ( conserved ) @xmath64 values it is @xmath65 . reaching the energy of the classical ionization threshold
is thus not sufficient for the quantum system to ionize .
it requires the additional zero - point energy @xmath66 to be able to overcome the potential barrier .
as the harmonic potential is quite strong , this excess energy is rather high and has the effect of tremendously reducing the ionization probability .
for the scaled problem , the energy shift @xmath66 translate into a shift of the scaled energy : @xmath67 the equivalence of the two points of view can be established by noting that the expression ( [ denum ] ) has itself an exponential dependence , which can be combined with the numerator in eq .
( [ cw3 ] ) .
we obtain : @xmath68}\ ] ] which can also be written as : @xmath69 } \label{f0}\ ] ] where ( here for @xmath70 ) @xmath71 the physical meaning of these equations is rather clear . in effect
, tunneling can be described with a standard exponential[action/@xmath45 ] , provided the amount @xmath73 of energy is subtracted from the total available energy @xmath74 the global effect of the degrees of freedom transverse to the instanton is nothing but a shift of the energy available for tunneling by the zero - point energy in the transverse direction .
such an analysis does not take into account the azimuthal symmetry around the fields axis and the fact that the contributions of the various @xmath64 values can be separated in the numerical calculation .
not surprisingly , tunneling is much more effective for @xmath70 states which are not repelled from the @xmath27 axis by a centrifugal potential and thus feel more efficiently the instanton . in the quantum point of view ,
such states have the lowest transverse zero - point energy @xmath75 for other @xmath64 values , the treatment of creagh and whelan has to be adapted : instead of considering the full semiclassical green function of the system , one must expand it on the various @xmath64 subspaces and use only the relevant component in each subspace .
a similar problem occurs in periodic orbit theory when one is interested in the contribution to the density of states of an orbit along the @xmath27 axis .
how to deal with such a problem has been described in a general manner by bogomolny @xcite and in a specific case by shaw and coworkers @xcite .
the rule is that higher powers of the stability matrix come into play , for example @xmath76 instead of @xmath16 for the real orbit .
the situation is similar for the instanton , resulting in the denominator being raised to power @xmath77 the net effect is again taken into account by shifting the scaled energy by @xmath78 i.e. the transverse zero - point energy in the @xmath64 subspace .
thus results in an effective quantum ionization threshold : @xmath79 because of the transverse zero - point energy , in the presence of magnetic field , _ larger _ electric field strengths are necessary to observe the same ionization yield , or , conversely , larger scaled energy is required for a fixed electric field strength .
we have thus performed numerical diagonalization of the scaled hamiltonian _ above _ the classical ionization threshold , eq .
( [ classth ] ) .
the results is shown in fig .
[ scaled ] , where the widths of the resonances are plotted versus the quantized value of @xmath80 the inverse of the effective planck s constant . at low @xmath81 i.e. large @xmath82
the transverse zero - point energy is so large that the quantum ionization threshold , eq .
( [ qth ] ) , is far above the scaled energy of the state which consequently has a vanishingly small ionization rate .
this corresponds to the region @xmath83 in fig .
[ scaled](a ) , where the widths are smaller than the numerical accuracy . as @xmath84
is increased , the quantum ionization threshold decreases and significant tunneling takes place , as observed in the range @xmath85 finally , at sufficiently high @xmath84 value , the scaled energy is higher than the quantum ionization threshold and direct ionization takes place .
there , the ionization rates are large , comparable to the spacing between consecutive resonances and the tunneling regime is left . in the figure , the @xmath84 value where the quantum ionization threshold is reached is marked by the dotted line , and agrees with the numerical results .
the two values of @xmath33 for @xmath70 and @xmath86 have to be chosen quite different in order to observe the transition within the range of @xmath84 available from numerical diagonalization .
let us note that also in the pure magnetic field case , the statistics of level spacings in the vicinity of the ionization threshold is sensitive to the very same quantum threshold law @xcite .
the behavior observed in fig . [
scaled ] has important consequences . to study tunneling
, we should consider only the region just below the threshold ; this region is very small and the tunneling rate changes very rapidly with @xmath20 .
thus , scaled spectroscopy is not appropriate for the analysis of statistical properties of tunneling .
as it is clear from the discussion above and the examples depicted in the figures , the proper parameter characterizing the spectrum is not @xmath33 but rather @xmath87 . in order to overcome the difficulty described in the previous section , a simple solution is thus to scale the problem following the effective quantum ionization threshold instead of the classical one .
one then gets rid of the huge denominator due to the transverse motion and may more easily concentrate on the interesting dynamics , namely the interplay between the instanton and the chaotic dynamics inside the potential well .
we will thus solve the schroedinger equation , not at constant scaled energy @xmath33 , but at constant modified scaled energy @xmath88 , eq .
( [ hat_epsilon ] ) .
this results in the following generalized ( non linear ) eigenvalue problem for the effective planck s constant @xmath89 and the eigenstates @xmath90 @xmath91 with @xmath92 the laplace operator .
this equation is solved by expansion over a sturmian basis and a modified version of the lanczos algorithm adapted to such a generalized eigenvalue problem @xcite .
we have been able to obtain a few thousands of resonance widths for a given @xmath64 value , all lying in the tunneling regime .
an example is presented in fig .
[ unscaled ] . as expected from eq .
( [ f0 ] ) , the ionization rate shows an overall exponential decrease with @xmath93 the rate of this decrease is directly related to the tunneling action of the instanton : the prediction of eq .
( [ f0 ] ) is shown as a dashed line in the figure .
obviously , the agreement is excellent .
it should be noted that the semiclassical prediction is entirely obtained from classical ingredients and free of any parameter .
note also the existence of very large fluctuations
characteristic of chaotic tunneling around the mean value . in order to make a more quantitative test , we remove the global exponential decrease and define , following @xcite , a rescaled width : @xmath94 where @xmath95 is the density of states . from its definition ,
the @xmath96 should have average value unity in the semiclassical limit .
the distribution of the @xmath96 ( same data than in fig .
[ unscaled ] ) is shown in fig .
[ rescaled ] , on a linear scale .
it has very large fluctuations
several orders of magnitude with a large proportion of very small ionization rates but we checked that the average value of @xmath96 is constant across the spectrum within a few percent ( although the @xmath5 themselves vary over five orders of magnitude ) and equal to @xmath97 this is only slightly smaller than unity .
the difference might be due to deviations from harmonicity of the potential in the vicinity of the saddle point ( an assumption made in our calculation ) .
another plausible source of deviation is the assumption made in the calculation of creagh and whelan that every electron which tunnels through the barrier will eventually ionize ; although this is very likely to happen , the channel along the @xmath27 axis may also reflect a small part of the electronic wavefunction , even after tunneling took place .
this would manifest itself by the @xmath96 being smaller than unity .
the main point remains that semiclassics is able to predict quantitatively the average behavior of the ionization rates in the tunneling regime .
beyond the average behavior discussed in the previous section , we are also interested in the fluctuations of the ionization rates . the most probable origin of these fluctuations is the fact that the classical dynamics inside the potential well is chaotic .
this implies that the resonance wavefunctions in the well display apparently erratic fluctuations from state to state .
states with a large probability density near the classical saddle point are more likely to tunnel and ionize that the ones with small probability density . as a simple approximation , the tunneling probability and
thus the ionization rate is proportional to the squared overlap between the eigenstate and a wavepacket optimally tuned for tunneling , i.e. built to follow the instanton trajectory .
creagh and whelan have shown how to explicitly build such a wavepacket @xcite . for a quantum chaotic system ,
the simplest model for describing the statistical properties of the energy spectrum and eigenstates is to use random matrix theory ( rmt ) @xcite .
there , it is assumed that any unknown matrix element will be statistically described by a gaussian distribution . in our case , although the system is not time - reversal invariant ( because of the magnetic field ) , it has a generalized time - reversal symmetry and the gaussian orthogonal ensemble ( goe ) of random matrices must be used .
thus the matrix element is purely real and its square , and consequently the ionization rate , will be described by a porter - thomas distribution @xcite : @xmath98 where @xmath99 is the mean value of @xmath100 , unity in our case . in fig .
[ stat - m3 ] , we show the numerically obtained distribution for the @xmath86 series compared with the porter - thomas prediction , on a double - logarithmic scale which is more convenient to display the large fluctuations .
the agreement is excellent , which proves that the distribution of ionization rates in our realistic problem can be quantitatively predicted , using a combination of semiclassics ( for the mean value ) and random matrix theory ( for the fluctuations ) .
the results for the @xmath70 series are shown in fig .
[ stat - m0 ] .
the overall agreement is rather good , with a clear @xmath101 behavior at small @xmath100 and an exponentially small tail at large @xmath102 however , a significant deviation is clearly visible at intermediate values .
what is the origin of this deviation ?
we have been able to show that it is directly related to the unstable periodic orbits inside the chaotic potential well .
the quantitative interpretation is based on the semiclassical prediction , eqs .
( [ cw1]-[cw4 ] ) .
a clue is provided by a careful inspection of fig .
[ unscaled ] which shows that fluctuations around the average trend are not random but clearly display a short - range oscillation ( about 100 oscillations in the covered range ) .
the simplest way of measuring this oscillations is to perform a fourier transform with respect to @xmath103 a standard tool in periodic orbit theory .
we define : @xmath104 where the sum is taken over some range of @xmath105 of length @xmath106 the function @xmath107 is shown in fig .
[ ft ] both for @xmath70 and @xmath108 as expected , @xmath109 is very close to unity ( this proves that the actual average width is well predicted by the semiclassical formula , eq .
( [ f0 ] ) .
@xmath107 has a very large peak around @xmath110 with harmonics at integer multiples , but also smaller peaks at other values . from eq .
( [ cw4 ] ) , the peaks are expected to take place at the actions of the periodic orbits inside the well which are real continuations of the imaginary instanton . in our case , this orbit is entirely along the @xmath27 axis and its classical action @xmath111 is easily computed .
we find @xmath112 for the parameters of the figure , in perfect agreement with the numerical quantum calculation .
it should be noticed that we use for the classical calculation the scaled energy -0.1005 ,
i.e. the value of the _ modified _ scaled energy of the quantum calculation .
values used in our calculation , the scaled energy is far _ above _ the classical threshold . ]
the fact that both agree validates our correction and fully confirms the important role of the zero - point transverse energy .
the semiclassical formula ( [ cw4 ] ) also predicts the amplitude of the peak that should be observed in the fourier transform @xmath113 there is however an important subtlety here .
the monodromy matrix of the real orbit along the @xmath27 axis enters the formula .
it turns out that , because the orbit is very close to the saddle point ( reached at @xmath114 it undergoes an infinite series of bifurcation as @xmath115 at closely spaced @xmath33 values , the orbit loses and regains stability . at each bifurcation
, a new periodic orbit is born , which is off the @xmath27 axis , but close to it .
such a phenomenon is well known when a particle either approaches a saddle point ( see for example the henon - heiles model in @xcite ) or explores a channel with a long - range potential , as for example is the case for a rydberg series converging to an ionization threshold @xcite .
we show in fig .
[ trace ] the trace of the stability matrix of the @xmath27 orbit as a function of the scaled energy @xmath33 for @xmath59 which clearly shows this series of stable - unstable bifurcations .
however , we also plot on the same figure the denominator of the semiclassical contribution , eq .
( [ cw4 ] ) , to the ionization rate , whose calculation is detailed in the appendix .
the fact that what counts is not the real orbit itself but its combination with the instanton completely eliminates the series of bifurcations and gives a smooth contribution as the scaled energy is varied , as observed in the numerical quantum experiment .
moreover , the semiclassical formula ( [ cw4 ] ) predicts for @xmath107 a peak at @xmath112 with amplitude 0.592 , while the numerical result is @xmath116 in excellent agreement .
similarly , the harmonics of the peak form approximately a geometric series with amplitude @xmath117 for the @xmath118 repetition of the primitive real orbit .
the physical interpretation is clear : because the motion in the inner potential well is chaotic , each time the quantum particle leaves the vicinity of the saddle point ( along the @xmath27 axis ) , it explores some part of the chaotic phase space and roughly only 59% of the electronic density is reflected by the nucleus back along the @xmath27 axis .
it is important to remark that the oscillations of the widths , eq .
( [ cw4 ] ) , induced by the orbit along the @xmath27 axis and all its repetitions add _ coherently_. indeed , if we assume for simplicity that the @xmath118 repetition contributes with amplitude @xmath119 ( with @xmath120 in our case ) and phase @xmath121 , the series , including the smooth term @xmath122 can be summed exactly , leading to the following contribution to the ionization width : @xmath123 this , in turn , predicts that the average normalized widths are not uniformly distributed , but should follow the distribution : @xmath124 the physical interpretation of this distribution is simple .
it is nothing , but the function giving the intensity transmitted through a fabry - perot optical cavity with reflexion coefficients @xmath125 for the combination of the two mirrors , phase shift @xmath126 at the reflections and optical length @xmath127 in units of the wavelength .
this is of course a _ periodic _ function of the variable @xmath105 with period @xmath128 it has maxima at @xmath129 equal to an integer multiple of @xmath130 where the value of the function is @xmath131 and minima at half - integer multiples where the function is @xmath132 if @xmath125 is large , the maxima are sharp peaks .
the analogy with the fabry - perot cavity is more than formal : it actually describes how the electronic density can be resonantly trapped inside the inner potential well along the @xmath27 axis , resulting in enhanced tunneling amplitude and ionization rate . because the dynamics is chaotic
, such a resonant enhancement is only partial ( @xmath125 must be smaller than unity ) resulting in scarring of the wavefunction rather than complete localization . in order to test whether this distribution adequately describes the numerical result ,
we have folded " all the numerical values @xmath96 inside a single free spectral range " of the fabry - perot cavity , by plotting them against : @xmath133 where @xmath134 denotes the fractional part of the number @xmath135 the result is shown in fig .
[ fp ] . clearly the largest @xmath96 values are grouped around a well defined @xmath136 value , as expected .
large fluctuations still exist ; in order to smooth them , we plot also the running average ( over 100 values ) which clearly presents a resonant behavior around @xmath137 the semiclassical prediction , using the @xmath125 value deduced from the classical stability of the orbit , is shown as a dashed line and agrees fairly well with the numerical result .
this proves that the orbit along the @xmath27 axis plays the dominant role in our problem . to be completely honest
, we must mention that the phase @xmath138 , which is directly related to the position of the maximum in the plot , has not been extracted from the classical dynamics but fitted to the numerical data .
the last step is to characterize precisely the fluctuations of the _ individual _ widths that appear on top of the global exponential decrease and the modulations discussed above .
such fluctuations are thought to be unavoidable in a chaotic system , and are even a signature of the presence of chaos . in a semiclassical point of view , they can be seen as the effect of the whole set of ( unstable ) periodic orbits in the inner potential well .
each orbit approaching the saddle point contributes an oscillatory term analogous to eq .
( [ cw4 ] ) to the width and the individual widths are just the result of the superposition of plenty of such terms which oscillate rapidly : it results in apparently random fluctuations around the mean value .
a number of peaks are visible in the fourier transformed spectra in fig . [
ft ] ; semiclassical theory tells us that they appear at the actions of periodic orbits . in our specific case ,
it is visible that most of them are clustered at actions slightly smaller than the action of the @xmath27 orbit and its repetitions .
physically , they correspond to orbits mainly located close to the @xmath27 axis , born from the @xmath27 orbit at the bifurcations discussed above .
there is actually a very large number of such orbits with similar shapes , but differing by small details .
thus , it is in general difficult to associate a peak in the fourier transform with a single periodic orbit .
except for the lowest members , we could not assign unambiguously such peaks .
this is not a simple problem : indeed , many orbits are very close in phase space and , for a finite value of @xmath139 can not be considered as isolated in the sense that the saddle point approximation around each orbit a key ingredient of periodic orbit theory is not valid .
in such circumstances , it is not possible to separate the contributions of the various orbits which have to be grouped together using for example a uniform approximation @xcite .
note that this is a fundamental difficulty of periodic orbit theory , not a practical problem related to the proliferation of the number of orbits .
an interesting illustration of this problem may be obtained by launching a bunch of trajectories from the section @xmath140 close to the saddle point . following the real trajectories ( all started with positive momentum in @xmath27 )
until they hit again the same plane @xmath140 with positive momentum one can get a feeling of the relevant dynamics .
for a fully chaotic system one could naively expect that a plot of say actions calculated along the trajectory versus the initial momentum along the @xmath27 axis will not show any structure .
this is not true in our system as visualized in fig .
[ traj ] . observe a strongly not ergodic behaviour with allowed actions forming almost parallel strips .
a clear accumulation of actions in strips correlate nicely with peaks in the fourier transform , fig .
[ ft](a ) , in the range just below the second repetition at @xmath141 of the straight line periodic orbit . to each strip , apart from other non - periodic trajectories , several periodic orbits contribute which slightly differ in shape ( and action ) .
as mentioned already this makes a clear association between peaks in the fourier transform and given periodic orbits impossible .
the basic assumption , usual in studies of quantum chaos , is that the effect of long periodic orbits is to create fluctuations well described by random matrix theory . as
see above the ionization rate appears as the square of some real matrix elements , the simplest hypothesis is to assume that the fluctuations are described by a porter - thomas distribution , eq .
( [ pt ] ) . however , the mean value @xmath99 is now taken as predicted by the semiclassical theory , i.e. eq . ( [ ysc ] ) . as the @xmath142 values are uniformly distributed ,
this results in a global statistical distribution : @xmath143 where @xmath144 this distribution is plotted in fig .
[ stat - m0 ] as a solid line .
it clearly very significantly improves over the porter - thomas distribution and is in excellent agreement with our numerical data .
especially , it correctly describes the excess of large ionization widths .
the same approach can be used for the data in other @xmath64 series . however , as is obvious in fig .
[ ft](b ) , the contribution of the @xmath27 orbit is much smaller in e.g. the @xmath86 series .
as mentioned above , this is well understood semiclassically . in simple words ,
as the centrifugal term is more important , it keeps the electron away from the @xmath27 axis and strongly diminishes the contribution of this orbit .
the @xmath125 parameter for the @xmath86 series can be extracted from the fourier transform in fig .
[ ft](b ) and is close to 0.1 . the semiclassical prediction , which can be calculated in the spirit of refs .
@xcite and @xcite , is @xmath145 ^ 4\approx 0.12 $ ] in reasonably good agreement .
for such a small @xmath125 value , the deviation of the distribution ( [ modified_pt ] ) from porter - thomas is very small .
this explains why the porter - thomas distribution correctly reproduces the results of the numerical experiment , see fig .
[ stat - m3 ] .
we have also obtained results for the @xmath146 and @xmath147 series , shown in figs .
[ stat - m1 ] and [ stat - m2 ] .
significant deviations from porter - thomas are observed , although smaller than for the @xmath70 series .
again , the modified distribution , eq .
( [ modified_pt ] ) , agrees very well with the numerical results .
an alternative approach to the statistical properties of the ionization widths is possible . from the semiclassical approach , we know both the average trend and the modulations ; we can thus subtract ( or rather divide ) these factors out in order to concentrate on the fluctuations .
we thus rescale the numerical data to the expected average+oscillatory behavior , that is define : @xmath148 with @xmath99 is defined in eq .
( [ ysc ] ) . the statistical distribution of the @xmath27 variable is shown in fig .
[ pz - m0 ] , for the @xmath70 series .
as can be seen , it agrees very well with a pure porter - thomas distribution .
this fully confirms that , once the average and oscillatory behavior have been properly taken into account , only the standard fluctuations described by random matrix theory persist .
finally , we have studied a slightly less realistic system : the two - dimensional hydrogen atom in parallel electric and magnetic fields , obtained from the previous system by imposing that the motion takes place in the @xmath149 plane .
the classical dynamics is _ exactly _ the same than for @xmath70 states ( obviously the motion is planar for such cases ) .
one could thus naively expect the same properties for the ionization widths for the quantum system .
this is however not entirely true for two reasons : * the zero - point transverse motion is now in one dimension instead of two .
thus , the shift energy is reduced by a factor 2 compared to eq .
( [ shift ] ) : @xmath150 the modified scaled energy , eq .
( [ hat_epsilon ] ) , must be modified accordingly . *
the stability matrix is a @xmath151 matrix instead of a @xmath152 matrix .
as explained in the appendix , this results in a denominators in eqs .
( [ cw1])-([cw4 ] ) , to be square roots of the three - dimensional results for @xmath153 the net effect is that the instability of the real orbit in the potential well is significantly reduced , simply because there is less space for the electron to escape far from the @xmath27 axis .
the analysis is similar to the three - dimensional @xmath70 case , with the parameter @xmath125 being now taken at power 1/2 , i.e. @xmath154 instead of @xmath155 stronger deviations from the porter - thomas distribution are thus expected for the @xmath156 figs .
[ stat-2d ] and [ pz-2d ] show that it is indeed the case .
once more , the agreement with the modified porter - thomas distribution , eq .
( [ modified_pt ] ) is very good .
in this paper , we have studied the widths ( ionization rates ) of resonances of a realistic system , the hydrogen atom in parallel electric and magnetic fields , in conditions where the classical dynamics is chaotic .
we have shown that , using a semiclassical approach without any adjustable parameter but only with classical ingredients , we are able to predict analytically the average behavior of the widths .
we have also shown the existence of a modulation of the average width associated with a periodic orbit and calculated quantitatively its properties , again using only classical ingredients .
finally , the residual fluctuations have been shown to be accurately described by a random matrix model .
this proves that a proper combination of semiclassics and random matrix theory can _ predict _ the behavior of the system vs. ionization .
our results are comparable to the ones obtained on a model system in @xcite .
for example , their fig . 1 is clearly comparable to our fig .
note however that , due to the specificities of our _ realistic _ system , the expressions we obtain have a simpler form . on a different model system ,
bies et al .
@xcite observed also deviations from the porter - thomas distribution .
part of the deviation is due to the relatively small value of the effective planck constant , but another part is certainly due to scarring . their figs .
4 and 5 are again very comparable to our fig .
[ fp ] . because they do not consider a scaling system , the classical dynamics and consequently the properties of the periodic orbits
change with energy which makes a comparison with our distribution rather difficult .
we however have little doubt that the basic process at work is similar to ours .
we are grateful to niall whelan and stephen creagh for an initial stimulation to look at tunneling in parallel fields problem .
we thank w.e .
bies , l. kaplan and e.j .
heller for permission to use their data for our manipulations .
support of kbn under project 5p03b-08821 ( jz ) is acknowledged .
the additional support of the bilateral polonium and pics programs is appreciated .
laboratoire kastler brossel de luniversit pierre et marie curie et de lecole normale suprieure is umr 8552 du cnrs .
cpu time on various computers has been provided by idris .
in this appendix , we discuss how the various classical quantities which enter the semiclassical formula can be calculated in our specific system , the hydrogen atom in parallel electric and magnetic fields . as we are interested in highly excited states lying in the immediate vicinity of the saddle point energy , it is convenient to expand the hamiltonian at second order around the saddle point . the normal modes of this harmonic approximation are along the @xmath27 axis and in the @xmath61 plane . in the @xmath61 plane ,
the saddle point is a potential minimum associated with a vibration frequency : @xmath159 because of the azimuthal symmetry around the fields axis , this mode is degenerate . in order to have a chaotic motion in the inner potential well ,
the scaled energy must be large , typically of the order of -0.1 , which in turns implies that @xmath34 is rather small .
in most cases , one can thus forget the @xmath34 dependence in eq .
( [ omegarho ] ) and use the approximation : @xmath160 along the @xmath27 axis , the saddle point is a potential _ maximum_.
it is thus associated with an eigenmode with purely imaginary frequency @xmath161 where : @xmath162 the corresponding imaginary period is nothing , but the period of the instanton .
alternatively , @xmath163 can be viewed as the vibration frequency around the saddle point in the _ inverted _ potential . in an harmonic potential ,
the action of an orbit is simply ( within a @xmath130 factor ) the ratio of its excitation energy ( with respect to the equilibrium point ) to the frequency .
this yields the ( imaginary ) action of the instanton given by eq .
( [ k ] ) .
the harmonic approximation around the saddle point can also be used for the calculation of the stability matrix of the instanton .
indeed , as the harmonic potential separates completely in a transverse and a longitudinal component , the monodromy matrix of the instanton in each transverse direction , after propagation during time @xmath164 is simply of the form : @xmath165 the stability matrix of the instanton is obtained by evaluating the monodromy matrix at the period of the instanton @xmath166 @xmath167 for the three - dimensional hydrogen atom , the stability matrix is a @xmath170 matrix which actually splits in two @xmath151 identical blocks ( along the @xmath136 and @xmath100 directions ) of type ( [ w ] ) .
thus , the contribution ( [ det ] ) must be squared to get the correct semiclassical contribution .
in contrast , for the simplified two - dimensional model , there is only one such contribution .
the last ingredient in the semiclassical approximation is the stability matrix of the real periodic orbit in the inner potential well .
as explained in the main text , the series of bifurcations taking place in the vicinity of the saddle point energy implies that this matrix changes rapidly with @xmath74 on the other hand , when @xmath33 is varied , the dynamics inside the potential well is only weakly affected : the main effect is that the electron spends less or more time in the immediate vicinity on the saddle point .
as the transverse potential is there rather steep , the stability matrix varies a lot .
these modifications are essentially described by a multiplication by a matrix similar to ( [ mono ] ) .
a small variation of the period of the orbit is enough to affect strongly the matrix .
however , it is the product of the stability matrices of the instanton and the real periodic orbit which describes the semiclassical contribution , eq .
( [ cw4 ] ) .
as it is the very same matrix type ( [ mono ] ) which contributes to the two stability matrix , it turns out that the _ modulus _ of @xmath171 actually depends weakly on @xmath33 as shown in fig .
[ trace ] .
d. delande , in _ chaos et physique quantique chaos and quantum physics _ , les houches , cole dt de physique thorique 1989 , session lii , edited by m. giannoni , a. voros , and j. zinn - justin ( north - holland , amsterdam , 1989 ) , pp . 665726 . | statistics of tunneling rates in the presence of chaotic classical dynamics is discussed on a realistic example : a hydrogen atom placed in parallel uniform static electric and magnetic fields , where tunneling is followed by ionization along the fields direction .
depending on the magnetic quantum number , one may observe either a standard porter - thomas distribution of tunneling rates or , for strong scarring by a periodic orbit parallel to the external fields , strong deviations from it .
for the latter case , a simple model based on random matrix theory gives the correct distribution . |
neutrino physics is entering a new era of precision measurements of oscillation parameters .
the measured value of the atmospheric neutrino mass splitting is such that current and future accelerator neutrino beams are best tuned to oscillation physics with neutrino energies in the few - gev region .
however , the precision of neutrino interaction cross - sections is not commensurate with the goals of the next generation of neutrino oscillation experiments @xcite .
moreover , recent measurements have exposed serious shortcomings in the current theoretical models describing neutrino - nucleus interactions .
one of the largest interaction processes in the few - gev region is quasi - elastic scattering ( ) , .
the process is important because it is the signal reaction for oscillation experiments with neutrino energies below @xmath02 gev and because the simple final state allows accurate neutrino energy reconstruction using only the measured energy and angle of the outgoing lepton . in this report
, we will cover measurements released since neutrino 2008 , by miniboone , sciboone , minos and nomad .
the neutrino - nucleon scattering cross - section is most commonly written according to the llewellyn - smith prescription @xcite , which parameterises the cross section in terms of several form factors that are functions of the square of the four - momentum transferred to the nucleon , @xmath1 .
many of the form factors can be taken from electron scattering experiments .
however , the axial form factor can best be measured at non - zero 2 in neutrino scattering .
most experiments assume a dipole form for the axial form factor @xmath2 , such that @xmath3 , and use reconstructed 2 distributions to extract a value for the axial mass parameter . to approximate the nuclear environment , the relativistic fermi gas ( rfg ) model of smith and moniz
is used by most experiments @xcite .
this model assumes that nucleons are quasi - free , with an average binding energy and fermi momentum specific to the particular target nucleus .
pauli blocking is included in the model .
bodek and ritchie s extension to the relativistic fermi gas model @xcite is employed by some experiments .
these models are predicated on the impulse approximation , which assumes that the neutrino nucleus interaction can be treated as an incoherent sum of scattering processes with the individual nucleons .
while such simple models have been demonstrated inadequate for electron scattering experiments , previous neutrino scattering measurements were not sufficicient to demonstrate model deficiencies .
more details of the theory of neutrino - nucleus scattering , and especially progress in new models , are discussed elsewhere in these proceedings @xcite .
neutrino cross - section measurements require estimates of the neutrino fluxes ; these estimates have proven to be extremely difficult since the advent of accelerator neutrino beams .
most previous experiments perform some calculations of neutrino fluxes based on estimates of the secondary pion spectra ; these estimates in the past have had extremely high uncertainties . because of this , many past experiments employed a circular bootstrapping method of estimating the fluxes . to illustrate the difficulty of estimating neutrino fluxes , figure [ fig : hadron_flux ] shows four examples of predicted neutrino flux spectra at the miniboone detector @xcite .
each flux prediction was produced using exactly the same monte carlo ( mc ) simulation of the neutrino target , horn , and secondary beamline , with the only difference being the primary pion production in each .
the largest flux estimate is a factor of four higher than the lowest , illustrating the problem in rather dramatic fashion . because of the importance of accurate neutrino flux predictions for precise cross - section measurements ,
several experiments have been performed and planned to make accurate measurements of primary hadron production cross - sections .
all the measurements discussed herein use detailed neutrino flux predictions based on precise hadron production data and/or secondary beam measurements .
table [ tab : hadprod ] summarises the beamline characteristics for the accelerator neutrino beams used to make the measurements in this report .
.[tab : hadprod]_*accelerator neutrino beam characteristics * _ [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] miniboone analysers find that two - dimensional plots of the cosine of the muon angle versus the muon kinetic energy disagree with their monte carlo ( mc ) simulation .
furthermore , they find that the discrepancy follows lines of constant 2 , not lines of constant , which suggests that the source of the disagreement lay with the cross section model , not the neutrino flux prediction .
based on shape - only comparisons , the miniboone data show reduced production at low 2 ( below @xmath00.1 2 ) and increased production above that . by fitting the reconstructed 2 distribution miniboone finds the value of to be [email protected] 2 .
the high value of corrects the discrepancies in the 2 distribution and improves the normalization agreement between data and mc .
the minos near detector is a 980 t iron calorimeter with a @xmath0 1 t toroidal magnetic field .
combined with the intense flux of the numi beam the near detector has recorded an enormous neutrino data set . for their measurement , minos analysers select cc events with low hadronic shower energy . similar to miniboone , they find their data show a deficit compared to their mc simulation at low 2 ( below @xmath00.1 2 ) but prefer a flatter spectrum above that .
they perform fits of their reconstructed 2 distributions and extract a value of @xmath5 gev / c@xmath6@xcite at mean neutrino energy 3 gev .
minos analysers are currently working on fits that use non - dipole form factors and developing methods for constraining the non - qe backgrounds with data .
the nomad detector comprised 2.7 t of active drift chamber targets inside a @xmath7 t dipole magnet .
the excellent resolution provided by the drift chambers allows the analysers to make stringent cuts on particle identification parameters and final state configurations .
they select 1-track and 2-track ( ) event samples .
the nomad analysis @xcite proceeds by using the measured yield of deep inelastic scattering ( dis ) events , which have a well known cross - section at high energy , to convert the measured yield of events into a cross - section measurement in bins of neutrino energy .
the measured value of the cross - section in each bin is used to infer the value of . as cross checks
, they also fit the shape of the reconstructed 2 to extract and use the yield of inverse muon decay ( imd ) events to normalize the cross - section . both cross checks produce consistent values of .
table [ tab : m_a ] summarises the recent measurements of .
we see that the measurements on nuclei in the @xmath01 gev region are significantly higher than the world average taken from neutrino - deuterium scattering , and also larger than the high energy measurement on carbon made by nomad .
we stress that the miniboone and minos results ( as well as the previously published k2k results ) are based on fits to the shapes of the 2 distributions .
sciboone uses its 15 t fine - grained plastic scintillator vertex detector ( scibar ) in combination with its muon range detector ( mrd ) for its analysis .
charged - current neutrino candidates are selected by matching tracks originating in the fiducial volume of scibar and penetrating into the mrd ; the muons are tagged by their penetration into the mrd .
the analysers separate events based on the number of tracks coming out of the neutrino interaction vertex .
one track events have no tracks other than the muon candidate .
two track events are separated into and samples using particle identification based on the energy deposited along the second track .
the one - track and samples are predominantly events , and the sample is predominantly events so the analysis constrains the background fraction with data .
sciboone fits reconstructed @xmath8 distributions in the three data samples ( single @xmath9 , and ) simultaneously to extract the cross section versus neutrino energy @xcite .
as mentioned above , nomad actually directly measures the cross - section as a function of neutrino energy , not .
miniboone measures the cross - section as a function of neutrino energy separately from the 2 shape fits used to extract .
figure [ fig : enu ] compares the measured cross - sections versus neutrino energy from these experiments .
it can be seen that the miniboone and sciboone results , near 1 gev , are consistent with each other and are significantly higher than the nomad results which span 3 - 100 gev .
we note that the sciboone and miniboone results are obtained directly from the measured event yields and proton - on - target - normalized neutrino flux predictions , not by extracting via a cross - section ratio with a different ( assumed ) cross - section .
these are the world s first such pot - normalized neutrino cross - section measurements . due to the theoretical uncertainties associated with modeling the nuclear environment , the previous measurements necessarily have some model - dependence . to allow for the development of new models , measurements with no model dependence
are needed .
figure [ fig : pmu - thetamu ] shows miniboone s flux - averaged double differential cross - section measurement , @xmath10 .
this is the most complete information about the neutrino cross - section that can be obtained using the outgoing muon s kinematics .
miniboone has been on the frontier of model - independent measurements and we hope that future experiments will follow the example .
because of the dipole form assumed for @xmath2 , changing @xmath11 from @xmath12 2 to @xmath13 2 changes not only the 2 spectrum but also increases the normalization by approximately 20% .
the miniboone data actually favor an additional normalization increase of @xmath14 on top of the larger than expected normalization implied by the high value of @xmath11 . as shown in figure [ fig : enu ] , the preliminary sciboone analysis is consistent with increased cross - section at neutrino energy near 1 gev . in contrast
, the nomad measurement shows good agreement with the normalization expected from a value of near 1.0 2 .
there is some reason to believe that the impulse approximation may be inadequate in the 1 gev region .
some recent theory papers predict an increased cross - section in medium sized nuclei @xcite near 1 gev .
other attempts to fit the miniboone double differential data indicate that new ideas are needed @xcite .
more discussion of this topic can be found elsewhere in these proceedings @xcite .
in addition to the harder @xmath15 spectra observed by recent experiments with near 1 gev ( which lead to the high values of @xmath11 ) , @xmath16 data have also shown suppressed cross - section at very low @xmath15 .
several different approaches to dealing with his have been employed by recent experiments .
for example , the miniboone collaboration inserted a scale factor into the rfg model that expands the available phase space for pauli blocking @xcite and reduces the predicted interaction rate at low @xmath15 .
the minos collaboration achieves a similar effect by scaling the fermi momentum for events with @xmath17 ( gev / c)@xmath6 @xcite . in their differential analysis ,
miniboone largely mitigated the low @xmath15 data deficit by constraining the backgrounds with their own data .
this indicates the problem lies with the model for predicting background events , and the observation is supported by sciboone @xcite and minos @xcite data .
new and better measurements of production are therefore needed to understand scattering ; recent measurements are discussed in some detail elsewhere in these proceedings @xcite . we note that many in the theory community blame this low @xmath15 model / data discrepancy on the simplicity of the rfg nuclear model employed by most experiments . in this @xmath15 region ,
the wavelength of the boson propagator exceeds the size of the nucleon and so the assumptions of the impulse approximation break down @xcite .
to meet the demands of the current , and future , generation of neutrino oscillation experiments , serious effort is being put into improved measurements of neutrino scattering cross - sections .
we have shown that recent measurements of the process on nuclei near 1 gev independently show significant disagreements with the traditional models of neutrino scattering .
interestingly , recent measurements at high energy do not show the same disagreements . to solve this puzzle ,
there is increasing consensus that the neutrino scattering community needs to provide model - independent measurements of neutrino cross - sections .
miniboone has led the way in developing such analyses with sciboone following suit now as well .
we look forward to new data from miner@xmath18a , argoneut , t2k and microboone to help us solve this latest neutrino conundrum .
y. itow , nucl .
* 112 * , 3 ( 2002 ) .
d. a. harris _ et al . _
[ minerva collaboration ] , arxiv : hep - ex/0410005 . c. h. llewellyn smith , phys .
rept . * 3 * , 261 ( 1972 ) .
r. a. smith and e. j. moniz , nucl .
b*43 * , 605 ( 1972 ) , erratum - ibid .
b * 101 * , 547 ( 1975 ) .
a. bodek and j. l. ritchie , phys . rev .
d * 23 * , 1070 ( 1981 ) .
l. alvarez - ruso , these proceedings .
d. w. schmitz , phd dissertation , columbia university ( 2008 ) , fermilab - thesis-2008 - 26 .
p. astier _ et al .
_ [ nomad collaboration ] , nucl .
instrum .
a * 515 * , 800 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/0306022 ] .
s. e. kopp , aip conf .
proc . * 967 * , 49 ( 2007 ) .
a. a. aguilar - arevalo _ et al . _ [ miniboone collaboration ] , phys .
d * 79 * , 072002 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0806.1449 [ hep - ex ] ] .
m. bishai , these proceedings .
a. a. aguilar - arevalo _ et al . _ [ miniboone collaboration ] , phys . rev .
d * 81 * , 092005 ( 2010 ) a. a. aguilar - arevalo _ et al . _ [ miniboone collaboration ] , phys .
lett . *
103 * , 081801 ( 2009 ) .
[ arxiv:0904.3159 [ hep - ex ] ] .
a. bodek , s. avvakumov , r. bradford and h. s. budd , eur .
j. c * 53 * , 349 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0708.1946 [ hep - ex ] ] .
r. gran _
[ k2k collaboration ] , phys .
d * 74 * , 052002 ( 2006 ) x. espinal and f. sanchez , aip conf .
proc . * 967 * , 117 ( 2007 ) .
m. dorman [ minos collaboration ] , aip conf .
proc . * 1189 * , 133 ( 2009 ) .
v. lyubushkin _ et al . _
[ nomad collaboration ] , eur .
j. c * 63 * , 355 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0812.4543 [ hep - ex ] ] .
j. l. alcaraz - aunion and j. walding [ sciboone collaboration ] , aip conf .
proc . * 1189 * , 145 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0909.5647 [ hep - ex ] ] .
m. martini , m. ericson , g. chanfray and j. marteau , phys .
c * 80 * , 065501 ( 2009 ) a. v. butkevich , [ arxiv:1006.1595 [ nucl - th ] ] .
o. benhar , p. coletti and d. meloni , [ arxiv:1006.4783 [ nucl - th ] ] . c. juszczak , j. t. sobczyk and j. zmuda , [ arxiv:1007.2195 [ nucl - th ] ] .
a. a. aguilar - arevalo _ et al . _ [ miniboone collaboration ] , phys . rev
. lett . *
100 * , 032301 ( 2008 ) .
j. j. walding , fermilab - thesis-2009 - 57 . | we present recent measurements of neutrino charged current quasi - elastic ( ) scattering , .
measurements of on carbon near 1 gev by miniboone and sciboone , as well as measurements on iron at 3 gev by minos , disagree with current interaction models , while measurements at higher energies on carbon by nomad show excellent agreement with those same models .
neutrino , cross - section , charged - current quasi - elastic |
the stellar population properties of early - type galaxies ( e.g. age , metallicity and @xmath0-element abundance [ e / fe ] ) provide crucial clues to their evolutionary history .
most work to date has concentrated on galaxy central regions . while useful , such data only sample a small fraction of the galaxy mass and do not provide any radial gradient information .
radial gradients can help discriminate between different formation models .
for example , dissipational collapse models ( larson 1974 ; carlberg 1984 ; kawata & gibson 2003 ) predict strong metallicity gradients that correlate with galaxy mass , whereas mergers tend to result in shallow gradients ( white 1980 ; bekki & shioya 1999 ) with little galaxy mass dependence . as [ e / fe ]
may be an indicator of star formation timescale , a positive gradient indicates outside - in formation and a negative one the opposite ( e.g. ferreras & silk 2002 ) .
age gradients indicate whether any young stars are confined to the central regions , and hence an indication of their mass contribution .
kobayashi & arimoto ( 1999 ) compiled a list of 80 early - type galaxies with radial metallicity gradient measurements ; the average value being 0.3 dex per dex . for coma cluster ellipticals , mehlert et al .
( 2003 ) confirmed significant radial metallicity gradients but , on average , found no radial age or [ e / fe ] gradients .
in contrast , snchez - blzquez et al .
( 2006a ) found significant age gradients in a sample of cluster , group and field early - type galaxies . a weak correlation between metallicity gradient and galaxy mass
was found by snchez - blzquez et al .
( 2007 ) and forbes , snchez - blzquez & proctor ( 2005 ) for cluster ellipticals .
the number of studies that have focused on the stellar populations of early - type galaxies in very low density environments is small .
kuntschner et al . (
2002 ) obtained spectra of three e and six s0 galaxies in low density environments ( i.e. they had less than two bright neighbours within 1.3 mpc and @xmath5350 km / s ) .
five of their nine galaxies revealed emission indicating ongoing star formation . using lick absorption lines and vazdekis ( 1999 ) single stellar population ( ssp ) models they found their galaxies to be on average younger and more metal - rich than cluster galaxies .
however , they noted the dominance of s0s in their sample .
they also found a similar [ e / fe ] vs velocity dispersion relation as for cluster galaxies .
collobert et al .
( 2006 ) extended the kuntschner et al .
work with spectra of 22 galaxies , for hubble types ranging from s0/a to pure e. half came from the 2dfgrs survey ( with no bright companions within 1 mpc ) and half from the low density sample of colbert et al .
( 2001 ) ( no rc3 catalogued galaxies within 1 mpc and @xmath51000 km / s ) . after applying emission line corrections to 7 of their 22 galaxies , they applied thomas , maraston & bender ( 2003 ) models to 7 lick absorption lines with a @xmath6 fitting technique .
they found a spread to younger ages than for cluster ellipticals , but no clear [ e / fe ] vs velocity dispersion relation .
they speculated that isolated ellipticals _ assembled _ quite recently .
both studies only probed the central regions of their sample galaxies . here
we extend the previous work by examining the radial stellar population properties to around 1 effective radius in a sample of a 12 isolated galaxies .
the sample presented here comes from the well - defined and highly isolated sample of early - type galaxies from reda et al .
our new data are supplemented by data for 5 isolated galaxies from the literature .
we also utilize the latest ssp models and fitting methods .
in reda et al . ( 2004 ) , we defined a sample of 36 isolated early - type galaxies in the local universe ( @xmath7 ) . here
we present new data on the stellar populations of a subsample for 12 galaxies from that sample .
the basic data of these galaxies and their sources are summarised in table 1 .
we supplement our data with data from the literature for other isolated galaxies of reda et al .
( 2004 ) .
denicol et al .
( 2005a ) extracted 21 lick spectral indices for the central r@xmath8 region for a sample of 86 early - type galaxies .
six of our 36 isolated galaxies were included in their study .
denicol et al .
applied an emission correction to the indices where the galaxy spectra show evidence of emission lines . comparing their extracted stellar population parameters to the literature ,
their measurements tend to be younger and more metal - rich ( denicol et al .
2005b ) . using their published indices of the six isolated galaxies , and applying the multi - index @xmath6 minimization technique which we are using for our observations and the same ssp model ( see sec .
2.5 ) , we have extracted the central stellar population parameters for these galaxies which are listed in table 2 .
the spatially resolved stellar population of the isolated galaxy ncg 821 was previously studied by proctor et al .
here we used their data to extract the central values of the age , total metallicity [ z / h ] and @xmath0-elements abundance [ e / fe ] within r@xmath8 which are also listed in table 2 .
these measurements of the central parameters are consistent to our measurements using the indices from denicol et al .
( 2005a ) .
we also measured the radial gradient of these parameters , considering all apertures beyond the seeing limit , to be [email protected] , @xmath90.03 , @xmath100.04 for log(age ) , [ e / fe ] and [ z / h ] respectively .
llcllrll + galaxy & dist . &
@xmath11 & @xmath12 & @xmath12 & @xmath13 & @xmath5 & @xmath13 + & ( mpc ) & ( mag ) & ( mag ) & source & ( pc ) & & source + ngc 682 & 73 & 24.88 & 19.9 & paper i & 3.73 & 0.10 & ps97 + ngc 1045 & 60 & 25.02 & 20.9 & paper i & 3.66 & 0.10 & paper i + ngc 1162 & 51 & 24.53 & 20.7 & paper i & 3.63 & 0.10 & 2mass + ngc 2271 & 32 & 23.84 & 20.0 & paper ii & 3.47 & 0.07 & paper ii + ngc 2865 & 35 & 24.26 & 20.7 & paper i & 3.68 & 0.01 & paper i + ngc 4240 & 26 & 22.71 & 18.8 & paper i & 3.29 & 0.10 & 2mass + eso 153-g003 & 84 & 25.04 & 20.9 & paper ii & 3.62 & 0.06 & paper ii + eso 218-g002 & 54 & 24.51 & 20.9 & paper i & 3.76 & 0.11 & paper i + eso
318-g021 & 62 & 24.43 & 20.7 & paper ii & 3.77 & 0.01 & paper ii + mcg-01 - 27 - 013 & 121 & 25.08 & 21.4 & paper i & 3.98 & 0.05 & paper
i + mcg-02 - 13 - 009 & 73 & 24.58 & 21.3 & paper i & 3.67 & 0.10 & 2mass + mcg-03 - 26 - 030 & 119 & 25.79 & 21.7 & paper i & 3.92 & 0.02 & paper i + note : distances are obtained using the virgo corrected recession velocities ( from leda ) with h@xmath14 = 75 km s@xmath15 mpc@xmath15 . @xmath11 and @xmath12 are the absolute magnitudes in the @xmath16 and @xmath17-bands respectively .
@xmath11 are from 2mass catalogue and @xmath12 from reda et al .
( 2004 , paper i ) and reda et al .
( 2005 , paper ii ) .
effective radius r@xmath18 from the 2mass catalogue is the isophotal radius @xmath19 in the @xmath16-band ( via leda database ) converted to effective radius using the correlation in jarrett et al .
( 2003 , fig .
11 ) . for ngc 682
the effective radius is derived from the fundamental plane ( prugniel & simien 1997 ; ps97 ) [ basic ] lccccc + + galaxy & log(@xmath20 ) ( km / s ) & age@xmath1 ( gyr ) & [ e / fe]@xmath1 & [ z / h]@xmath1 + ngc 821 & 2.33@xmath5 0.06 & 4.7 @xmath5 1.9 & 0.15@xmath5 0.02 & 0.48@xmath5 0.05 + ngc 1045 & 2.36@xmath5 0.06 & 5.3 @xmath5 1.4 & 0.12@xmath5 0.02 & 0.43@xmath5 0.03 + ngc 1132 & 2.37@xmath5 0.05 & 11.2 @xmath5 4.7 & 0.36@xmath5 0.04 & 0.10@xmath5 0.07 + ngc 2128 & 2.25@xmath5 0.06 & 2.8 @xmath5 1.2 & 0.27@xmath5 0.03 & 0.48@xmath5 0.09 + ngc 6172 & 2.13@xmath5 0.05 & 2.5 @xmath5 0.5 & 0.00@xmath5 0.03 & 0.13@xmath5 0.04 + ngc 6411 & 2.25@xmath5 0.03 & 10.6 @xmath5 0.8 & 0.18@xmath5 0.04 & 0.05@xmath5 0.02 + ngc 821 & 2.29@xmath5 0.01 & 5.6 @xmath5 0.5 & [email protected] & 0.41@xmath5 0.06 + notes : parameters of the first six galaxies are obtained using the published lick indices of denicol et al .
( 2005a ) and refit to a ssp model for this work .
for ngc 821 , the parameters are the average of all apertures within r@xmath21r@xmath8 from proctor et al .
( 2005 ) .
[ centr1 ] our spectroscopic observations were carried out using efosc2 at the eso 3.6 m telescope on the la silla observatory in two observing runs , 2002 jan .
16 - 18 and 2004 dec .
the observational set up and slit position are described in detail by hau & forbes ( 2006 ) .
lick and spectrophotometric standard stars were observed at the parallactic angle .
the observing nights were photometric and the seeing was generally better than @xmath22 .
observations of the first run ( 2002 ) were collected using a slit of @xmath23 length and @xmath24 width which was positioned along the major axis of each galaxy , with exception for the s0 galaxy eso 153-g003 where the slit was positioned along the minor axis to avoid the disc . using the eso grism#8 of 600 line
/ mm provides a spectral resolution of 9.3 fwhm .
the accumulated exposure time was 2 @xmath25 1200 seconds for each galaxy . in the 2004 run
we used a @xmath26 slit which provides a spectral resolution of 7.8 fwhm .
the accumulated exposure time was 3 @xmath25 1200 seconds for each galaxy .
the multiple observations of each galaxy are combined to increase the s / n ratio . additionally , a number of spectrophotometric stars were observed for flux calibration and lick standard stars ( of type between k0 and k5 ) to be used as templates for velocity dispersion measurements and for calibration of the line - strength indices to the lick / ids system .
a number of bias , dark current and dome flat were recorded each night .
observations of all galaxies and stars gave a wavelength coverage of 4300 - 6300 .
data reduction , including bias , dark current and flat field subtraction , is performed using tasks within iraf .
wavelength calibration is done using helium - argon lamp and is good to within 0.5 , while the flux standard stars are used to calibrate the spectra .
the 2-d spectra are corrected for the s - distortion and sky subtracted . for more details about the data reduction
refer to hau & forbes ( 2006 ) .
finally the 2-d spectra of the galaxies are spatially binned using the starlink task extract to obtain 1-d spectra of s / n ratio greater than 20
. we will refer to these 1-d spectra of each galaxy as _
apertures_. the heliocentric recession velocity of the standard stars
are obtained by comparing their spectra to the solar spectrum .
the _ fxcor _
task within iraf is used to fit a gaussian to the cross - correlation function to determine the maximum peak .
the position of the maximum peak centre gives the required heliocentric recession velocity of the stars .
once the heliocentric recession velocity of the standard stars were measured , the redshifts and velocity dispersions of the galaxies are determined by comparing their spectra to the spectra of the standard stars .
the _ fxcor _ task of iraf is used to compute the cross - corelation of the galaxy spectra with the spectra of each template star .
once the correlation is computed , the position of the maximum peak centre gives the recession velocity v@xmath27 and the velocity dispersion @xmath28 .
the final v@xmath27 and @xmath28 are the average of the values estimated from all the template stars .
the radial kinematics for the same sample of galaxies are discussed in hau & forbes ( 2006 ) .
lc|cc|cc| + & & & + index & unit & mean & error of & mean & error of + & & offset & the mean & offset & the mean + fe4383 & & 0.031 & 0.329 & 0.229 & 0.120 + ca4455 & & 0.214 & 0.152 & 0.054 & 0.171 + fe4531 & & 0.163 & 0.132 & 0.342 & 0.103 + c4668 & & 0.828 & 0.097 & 0.598 & 0.187 + h@xmath29 & & 0.018 & 0.088 & 0.041 & 0.113 + fe5015 & & 0.284 & 0.079 & 0.357 & 0.185 + mg@xmath30 & mag & 0.013 & 0.002 & 0.019 & 0.007 + mg@xmath31 & mag & 0.019 & 0.003 & 0.018 & 0.006 + mg@xmath32 & & 0.083 & 0.071 & 0.039 & 0.195 + fe5270 & & 0.135 & 0.053 & 0.412 & 0.147 + fe5335 & & 0.214 & 0.093 & 0.274 & 0.215 + fe5406 & & 0.121 & 0.035 & 0.302 & 0.059 + fe5709 & & 0.006 & 0.128 & 0.031 & 0.065 + fe5782 & & 0.084 & 0.026 & 0.027 & 0.067 + na@xmath33 & & 0.058 & 0.132 & 0.239 & 0.138 + tio@xmath30 & & 0.004 & 0.005 & 0.006 & 0.003 + [ offs ] we adopted the definition of lick / ids absorption line indices from trager et al .
they defined each index using a pair of pseudocontinua bracketing the line feature and the central passbands of the line itself .
our observations cover a wavelength range of 4300 - 6300 which includes 16 lick / ids index .
these are one balmer index ( h@xmath29 ) , three magnesium indices ( mg@xmath30 , mg@xmath31 and mg@xmath32 ) , calcium ( ca4455 ) , sodium ( nad ) , titanium oxide ( tio@xmath30 ) indices plus nine iron indices fe4383 , fe4531 , fe4668 ( referred to as c4668 ) , fe5015 , fe5270 , fe5335 , fe5406 , fe5709 and fe5782 . a number of lick standard stars were observed during each observing run and will be used in the following sections to calibrated the measured indices to the lick system .
lick absorption indices are affected by a wavelength dependent instrumental resolution .
this resolution ranges from minimum value of @xmath34 in the range 4900- 5400 and degrade at the blue and red sides reaching above @xmath35 ( see fig .
7 in worthey & ottaviani 1997 ) .
our observed instrumental resolutions ( 9.3 and 7.8 for 2002 and 2004 runs respectively ) are different from those of the standard lick system .
the galaxy velocity dispersion will also alter the observed resolution of the absorption lines . to transform to the standard lick system , two different methods are used according to the observed total resolution of the spectra ( including both instrumental and velocity dispersion effects ) . for indices with combined resolution higher than that of the lick system ,
spectra are degraded to the resolution of the lick / ids library by convolving the spectra with a wavelength dependent gaussian .
while for indices with resolution lower than the lick / ids system , a correction factor is measured by convolving the spectra of five lick standard stars with a series of gaussians widths from 0 to 500 km / s . comparing the indices from the artificially broadened stellar spectra to the un - broadend indices , we estimate the index corrections for the broadening effect of velocity dispersion in galaxies .
this factor is then used to transform the indices measured in the galaxies of low resolution spectra to the lick resolution ( proctor & sansom 2002 ; proctor et al .
2004 ) .
furthermore , the original lick / ids spectra were not flux calibrated while our spectra are . to compensate for the resulting effect on the shape of the spectral continuum ,
the differences between the measured and the published indices values are obtained for each observed calibration star . for each index , the values from all stars are averaged and compared to the literature values to give the mean offset .
the error of the mean is obtained as : @xmath36 where @xmath37 is the @xmath38 of the scatter about offset and @xmath39 is the number of the standard stars .
the adopted offset of each index and its error are given in table 3 .
the age , total metallicity [ z / h ] and @xmath0-element abundance [ e / fe ] properties of our sample galaxies are estimated by comparing the lick absorption lines indices to the single stellar population ( ssp ) model of thomas , maraston & korn ( 2004 , tmk04 ) .
the [ e / fe ] parameter measures the ratio of the @xmath0-elements ( n , o , mg , na , si , ti ) to the fe - peak elements ( cr , mn , fe , co , ni , cu , zn ) . the multi - index @xmath6 minimization technique ( proctor & sansom 2002 ; proctor et al .
2004 ) is used to obtain the corresponding ssp model values of the age , [ z / h ] and [ e / fe ] abundance ratios for the galaxies . in this technique
as many indices as possible are fit to the model . because most indices contain some information regarding each of the stellar parameters ( proctor & sansom 2002 ) , using this fitting technique has advantages of including all possible information recorded in all absorption line indices to measure these parameters .
another advantage of this fitting technique is that it identifies indices that are highly deviant from model values , permitting their exclusion from the fitting process .
in addition , we note that parameters measured in this way are less prone to uncertainties in data reduction such as flux calibration , stray cosmic ray and also less prone to weak emission effects ( proctor , forbes & beasley 2004 ) .
therefore we start by fitting all 16 indices . the indices which deviate by more than @xmath40 are clipped and the @xmath6 fit recalculated .
after clipping the highly deviated indices ( @xmath41 ) , we notice that , for some apertures within each galaxy , the fitting is still not stable and the estimated values of the age , metallictiy and [ e / fe ] are significantly affected by clipping different indices .
also , after this initial fitting process , many spectral indices show a significant range of deviations from the best fitting values . considering ngc 2271 as a typical galaxy of the sample , the left panel of fig .
[ chi ] shows the average deviation in units of error ( i.e. @xmath42 ) of the 16 indices from the best fit values .
furthermore , we notice that some indices lie outside the model grid which can be due to residual offsets between the measured indices and the standard system , unknown dependencies of the line strength predictions on any abundance ratio or inaccuracies in ssp models . to eliminate the effects of the remaining offsets
, we implemented the technique described by kelson et al .
( 2006 ) to shift the zero points of the model to our data .
kelson et al .
defined the reference point as a set of previously published stellar population parameters for the central massive early - type galaxy in the cluster of their study .
to apply this technique to our galaxy sample we define a local reference point for each galaxy by choosing two central apertures with high s / n ratios that show higher stability during the initial fitting to the model .
the initial measured age , [ z / h ] and [ e / fe ] of these two central apertures are considered as a reference zero point for that galaxy .
we measure the offset between each index from the corresponding values in the model , at fixed age and metallicity as estimated by the initial fit .
then we apply similar shifts to the indices of all other apertures . after applying this shift ,
the number of highly deviant indices from the model is reduced and consequently larger number of indices are used during the fitting process which become much faster . examining the extracted stellar population parameters before and after shifting the indices , we find that they are similar .
that means applying kelson et al .
method only reduces the scatter of the indices around the model .
[ chi ] shows the average deviation of the indices before and after applying kelson et al .
errors in the derived parameters are estimated using monte carlo type realizations of the best - fitting ssp models perturbed by the index error estimates .
hence , the average estimated errors of stellar population parameters based on the observational errors are about @xmath43 dex for the log(age ) , [ z / h ] and [ e / fe ] and @xmath44 for log(@xmath28 ) .
the weak [ o iii ] and/or h@xmath29 emission in the two galaxies eso318-g021 and mcg-02 - 13 - 009 ( hau & forbes 2006 ) is found to have no significant effect on our measurements of the stellar population parameters , again because of our use of all available indices and the multi - index @xmath6 minimization technique to fit the indices to the ssp model .
the central stellar population parameters of each galaxy are obtained by averaging the values of all apertures within the central @xmath45 .
the values are listed in table 4 with the error on the mean . in the following sections we will investigate these values and their correlations compared to those for galaxies in high density environments ( hdes ) .
the stellar populations of three isolated galaxies ngc 821 , ngc 1045 and ngc 2865 were previously measured in the literature .
comparing our measurements of ngc 2865 to those of snchez - blzquez et al .
( 2007 ) , we found comparable values of the central age ( 1.7 vs. 1.0 gyrs ) , [ z / h]@xmath1 ( 0.48 vs. 0.52 ) and [ e / fe]@xmath1 ( 0.07 vs. 0.13 ) . on the other hand , comparing our measurements for ngc 1045 to those obtained by using the data of denicol et al .
( 2005a ) , their data indicate a younger age ( 5 vs. 10 gyrs ) , more metal - rich ( 0.43 vs. 0.31 ) and less enhanced [ e / fe]@xmath1 ( 0.12 vs. 0.36 ) .
we note that this galaxy does not show emission lines and denicol et al .
did not apply any emission corrections to its indices . for ngc 821 , both measurements of proctor et al .
( 2005 ) and those we obtained by using the data of denicol et al .
( 2005a ) are comparable ( see table 2 ) . through out this paper we will consider our measurements for ngc 1045 and ngc 2865 and proctor et al .
values for ngc 821 .
lcccc + galaxy & log(@xmath20 ) & age@xmath1 ( gyr ) & [ e / fe]@xmath1 & [ z / h]@xmath1 + ngc 682 & 2.30 @xmath5 0.01 & 8.0 @xmath5 0.6 & 0.30 @xmath5 0.01 & 0.33 @xmath5 0.02 + ngc 1045 & 2.42 @xmath5 0.01 & 10.4 @xmath5 0.6 & 0.36 @xmath5 0.02 & 0.31 @xmath5 0.02 + ngc 1162 & 2.29 @xmath5 0.01 & 6.8 @xmath5 0.4 & 0.31 @xmath5 0.01 & 0.29 @xmath5 0.02 + ngc 2271 & 2.37 @xmath5 0.01 & 11.5 @xmath5 0.5 & 0.14 @xmath5 0.01 & 0.44 @xmath5 0.02 + ngc 2865 & 2.25 @xmath5 0.02 & 1.7 @xmath5 0.1 & 0.07 @xmath5 0.01 & 0.48 @xmath5 0.05 + ngc 4240 & 2.09 @xmath5 0.01 & 7.4 @xmath5 0.5 & 0.07 @xmath5 0.01 & 0.23 @xmath5 0.02 + eso153-g003 & 2.34 @xmath5 0.01 & 11.2 @xmath5 0.4 & 0.28 @xmath5 0.01 & 0.19 @xmath5 0.01 + eso218-g002 & 2.43 @xmath5 0.01 & 14.8 @xmath5 0.1 & 0.26 @xmath5 0.01 & 0.35 @xmath5 0.01 + eso318-g021 & 2.37 @xmath5 0.01 & 8.9 @xmath5 0.9 & 0.08 @xmath5 0.01 & 0.34 @xmath5 0.03 + mcg-01 - 27 - 013 & 2.39 @xmath5 0.01 & 8.0 @xmath5 1.6 & 0.03 @xmath5 0.01 & 0.34 @xmath5 0.04 + mcg-02 - 13 - 009 & 2.33 @xmath5 0.02 & 9.6 @xmath5 1.2 & 0.05 @xmath5 0.02 & 0.36 @xmath5 0.02 + mcg-03 - 26 - 030 & 2.47 @xmath5 0.01 & 14.5 @xmath5 0.2 & 0.15 @xmath5 0.03 & 0.27 @xmath5 0.01 + including the additional data from table 2 , the seventeen isolated galaxies show a range of central luminosity - weighted ages .
roughly half ( 9 out of 17 ) are older than 9 gyr , five galaxies are between 5 and 8 gyrs , and 3 with ages younger than 3 gyrs .
the sample has an average age of @xmath46 gyrs .
this is younger than the average age of about 11 gyr for galaxies in the coma cluster found by mehlert et al .
younger average luminosity - weighted ages for galaxies in low density environments were also found by proctor et al .
( 2004 ; see also references therein ) in comparison of galaxies in high density environments ( hdes ) such as clusters and hickson compact groups to those in loose groups and field .
similar results were also found in the large sample study of terlevich & forbes ( 2002 ) . on average
, our isolated galaxies have central luminosity - weighted total metallicities of [ z / h]@xmath47 .
mehlert et al .
( 2003 ) quotes values of @xmath48 and @xmath49 for the coma cluster galaxies of types e and e / s0 respectively and collobert et al . (
2006 ) found an average of [ z / h]@xmath50 for their cluster galaxies . using the published stellar population parameters in thomas et al .
( 2005 ) , we find that the early - type galaxies in their hde subsample have an average of [ z / h]@xmath51 , while their galaxies in low density environments are more metal - rich by about 0.05 - 0.1 dex .
the average central luminosity - weighted [ e / fe]@xmath1 of our isolated galaxies is @xmath3 . comparing to the mean value of [ e / fe]@xmath52 reported by mehlert et al .
( 2003 ) for cluster galaxies , our isolated galaxies show lower values by order of 0.1 dex .
although , if we arbitrarily divide our sample in half , then 8 out of 17 of our galaxies are significantly enhanced with @xmath53[e / fe]@xmath54 .
these eight galaxies are comparable to those measured by proctor et al .
( 2004 ) for galaxies in massive and compact groups ( [ e / fe]@xmath55 ) .
the other nine galaxies resemble the solar element abundance with [ e / fe]@xmath56 which is lower than what proctor et al .
obtained for field galaxies ( [ e / fe]@xmath57 ) . above
we have compared the central stellar population parameters of the isolated galaxies with their counterparts in hdes .
however , such parameters are known to vary with galaxy velocity dispersion ( e.g. kuntschner et al .
2001 , 2002 ; mehlert et al .
2003 ; collobert et al . 2006 ; snchez - blzquez et al .
2006b ; brough et al .
next we compare the correlations between central stellar population parameters of our isolated galaxies to those in hdes .
bernardi et al .
( 2006 ) identified a sample of 490 early - type galaxies in hdes from the sdss at redshifts of @xmath58 .
they define the hdes as those galaxy systems of total luminosity more than 10 times the luminosity of a typical early - type galaxy .
to obtain a high s / n ratio for their spectra , they co - added similar objects by using narrow bins in luminosity , size , velocity dispersion , and redshift ( bernardi et al .
the 490 galaxies produced 105 composite spectra of s / n@xmath59 . using
their published stellar population parameters and correlations between those parameters , we have measured the @xmath60 scatter of their galaxies about these correlations . in fig .
[ centr ] , solid lines are the best fit relation from bernardi et al . , and
dotted lines represent the @xmath60 scatter calculated by us .
similar trends to bernardi et al . were found for galaxies in hdes by previous studies ( e.g. kuntschner et al .
2002 ; mehlert et al .
2003 ; collobert et al .
2006 ; snchez - blzquez et al
. 2006b ) . for our isolated galaxies , trends between the stellar population parameters in the central regions and the central velocity dispersion ( a proxy for mass ) are examined in fig .
[ centr ] ( a),(b ) and ( d ) , while panels ( c ) and ( e ) show correlations of [ z / h ] and [ e / fe ] with age .
isolated galaxies follow similar trends to those in hdes with more massive galaxies being older , more metal - rich and with higher [ e / fe]@xmath1 than less massive ones .
isolated galaxies show slightly higher scatter towards younger ages , higher [ z / h]@xmath1 and lower [ e / fe]@xmath1 for their velocity dispersion than those in hdes . in panels ( d ) and ( e ) ,
the two galaxies ngc 4240 and mcg-01 - 27 - 013 are the most deviant galaxy from the correlations with very low [ e / fe]@xmath1 for their velocity dispersion and age . similarly , comparing galaxies in low density environments with those in fornax cluster , kuntschner et al .
( 2002 ) found that both samples follow similar log(@xmath20)-metallicity trends , although galaxies in low density environments show higher metallicities by @xmath61 dex .
panel ( c ) shows the observed age - metallicity relation for the isolated galaxies .
although the correlated errors of the age and metallicity may be partly responsible for this correlation ( e.g. kuntschner et al .
2001 ) , our isolated galaxies follow a similar correlation to hde galaxies . while the effect of the correlated errors is expected to reduce the measured metallicity of old galaxies , we note that the oldest three of our galaxies ( eso218-g002 , mcg-03 - 26 - 030 and ngc 2271 ) with age @xmath62 gyrs , tend to be more metal - rich than the average galaxy . on the other hand
, the galaxy ngc 6172 tends to be younger and less metal - rich than the general trend of the correlation .
the stellar population of this galaxy is extracted from the emission corrected lick absorption indices from denicol et al .
( 2005a ) , which perhaps leads to measuring a younger age . as a function of central age ,
panel ( e ) shows that many of the isolated galaxies have low [ e / fe]@xmath1 for their age compared to their counterparts in hdes .
low values of [ e / fe]@xmath1 have been previously reported by collobert et al .
( 2006 ) for their galaxies in low density environments .
in summary , isolated galaxies in our sample span a large range of ages .
scaling relations between central stellar parameters are similar to those for galaxies in higher density environments albeit with a tendency to younger central ages , higher [ z / h ] and lower [ e / fe ] . [ test2 ] [ test3 ] the radial recession profile of the stellar population parameters are fit with a weighted least squares method to measure the gradient for all apertures beyond the seeing limit of @xmath63 .
these fits are listed in table 5 .
we note that our measurements of [ z / h ] and [ e / fe ] gradients of the galaxy ngc 2865 are comparable to those found by snchez - blzquez et al .
( 2007 ) , although they found a steeper age gradient of @xmath64 . throughout this paper
we use our measurements for this galaxy which is shown in all plots as a solid triangle . in the following sections we examine the radial profile of each parameter in detail .
lccc + galaxy & log(age ) & [ e / fe ] & [ z / h ] + ngc 682 & 0.03 @xmath5 0.08 & 0.01 @xmath5 0.03 & 0.25 @xmath5 0.03 + ngc 1045 & 0.19 @xmath5 0.04 & 0.05 @xmath5 0.03 & 0.24 @xmath5 0.03 + ngc 1162 & 0.29 @xmath5 0.07 & 0.02 @xmath5 0.04 & 0.44 @xmath5 0.03 + ngc 2271 & 0.03 @xmath5 0.07 & 0.07 @xmath5 0.05 & 0.05 @xmath5 0.04 + ngc 2865 & 0.63 @xmath5 0.07 & 0.03 @xmath5 0.03 & 0.47 @xmath5 0.05 + ngc 4240 & 0.16 @xmath5 0.12 & 0.01 @xmath5 0.06 &
0.30 @xmath5 0.06 + eso153-g003 & 0.02 @xmath5 0.08 & 0.03 @xmath5 0.07 & 0.22 @xmath5 0.05 + eso218-g002 & 0.04 @xmath5 0.04 & 0.04 @xmath5 0.07 & 0.28 @xmath5 0.04 + eso318-g021 & 0.16 @xmath5 0.11 & 0.06 @xmath5 0.07 & 0.01 @xmath5 0.07 + mcg-01 - 27 - 013 & 0.07 @xmath5 0.25 & 0.14 @xmath5 0.13 & 0.05 @xmath5 0.14 + mcg-02 - 13 - 009 & 0.58 @xmath5 0.27 & 0.13 @xmath5 0.10 & 0.15 @xmath5 0.15 + mcg-03 - 26 - 030 & 0.01 @xmath5 0.04 & 0.05 @xmath5 0.08 & 0.10 @xmath5 0.02 + the detailed kinematics of our sample of galaxies including the radial velocity and velocity dispersion profiles of the galaxies have been previously studied by hau & forbes ( 2006 ) .
reproducing the velocity profiles ( see sec 2.3 ) , we confirm their findings of kinematic substructures in some of these galaxies .
rapidly rotating cores are detected in seven galaxies , three reveal fast rotating outer discs , while three galaxies show central peaked velocity dispersion profiles ( see hau & forbes for details ) .
although having a wide range of ages , figs [ test1 ] show that the majority of our sample of isolated early - type galaxies show statistically insignificant age gradients with an average of @xmath65 dex per dex .
four of these galaxies ( ngc 2271 , eso153-g003 , eso218-g002 and mcg03 - 26 - 030 ) have uniform ages older than 10 gyrs indicating a formation epoch at @xmath66 .
two galaxies , eso318-g021 and mcg01 - 27 - 013 , show intermediate ages of 8.9 and 8.0 gyrs which indicate an extended star formation history to @xmath67 .
although two galaxies , ngc 682 and ngc 4240 , show insignificant age gradients , they are composed of both old and relatively younger populations , which suggests a secondary star formation epoch for these two galaxies .
ngc 682 shows a global age of @xmath68 gyrs , with a younger population of about @xmath69 gyrs in the region around @xmath70(@xmath71)@xmath72 .
the stellar kinematics at the same region and outwards indicates the presence of a rotating disk with a rotational velocity of 150 km / s combined with a low velocity dispersion which declines from about 200 km / s at @xmath73 reaching 130 km / s at the outer regions . for ngc 4240 , despite its statistically insignificant age gradient of @xmath74 , it has evidence for younger stars ( @xmath75 gyr ) in the central regions at @xmath76 .
remarkable positive gradients , with the central regions being younger , are seen in two galaxies .
the galaxy ngc 1162 shows a gradient of @xmath77 with the central stellar population having an intermediate age of about @xmath78 gyr for @xmath79 compared to an age @xmath80 gyr in the outer regions .
ngc 2865 is the youngest member of our sample with a central stellar population as young as 1.7 gyr for @xmath81 and intermediate age stars of @xmath82 gyr outwards .
this galaxy shows the steepest overall age gradient of @xmath83 .
the kinematics of the central ( r@xmath84 ) regions of these two galaxies suggest rotationally supported cores ( hau & forbes 2006 ) .
ngc 1045 and mcg-02 - 13 - 009 show negative age gradients of @xmath85 and @xmath86 respectively .
the former galaxy has a population of intermediate age stars ( @xmath87 gyr ) beyond @xmath88 .
this galaxy also shows asymmetrical rotation and a declining velocity dispersion profile outwards indicating velocity substructure ( see also hau & forbes 2006 ) . while the later galaxy shows a steady age decrease outwards , a peaked central velocity dispersion and a slowly rotating body .
we note that in the hde of the coma cluster , mehlert et al .
( 2003 ) measured insignificant age gradients for 91 per cent of their galaxies .
the mean metallicity gradient of the 17 isolated galaxies is @xmath89 .
the two youngest galaxies of the sample ngc 1162 and ngc 2865 , both have steep positive age gradients , and show steep metallicity gradients of @xmath90 and @xmath91 respectively .
ngc 821 also has a young central stellar population and a very steep [ z / h ] gradient of @xmath92 ( proctor et al .
2005 ) .
on the other hand , three galaxies ( eso318-g021 , mcg -01 - 27 - 013 and mcg-02 - 13 - 009 ) which show statistically insignificant age gradients , also show negligible change of the metallicity between the centre and the outer regions with average radial gradients of @xmath93 .
the flat metallicity gradient of these three galaxies , can perhaps be due to the short coverage of our spectra , i.e. only to r@xmath94 . while mehlert et al .
( 2003 ) measure on average zero age gradients for galaxies in the coma cluster , the total metallicity gradient was more pronounced ( although with a large scatter ) with their galaxies having a mean negative gradient of @xmath95 .
snchez - blzquez et al .
( 2007 ) measure an average [ z / h ] gradient of @xmath96 for a sample of galaxies in mostly hdes .
figs [ test1 ] show that our sample galaxies have insignificant radial gradients of [ e / fe ] with an average of @xmath97 . despite the measured flat gradient of [ e / fe ] for the galaxy ngc 2865
, visual inspection reveals fluctuations between [ e / fe]=0.1 and 0.1 which may be related to the shell structure of this galaxy .
insignificant radial gradients of [ e / fe ] were also found by mehlert et al .
( 2003 ) for the early - type galaxies in the coma cluster with an average of @xmath98 .
although most of our galaxies reveal statistically insignificant age gradients , fig .
[ grdage1 ] shows that while galaxies older than 11 gyrs show no age gradients ( i.e. uniformally old stellar populations ) , the age gradients of young galaxies are strongly anti - correlated with the central age . no significant dependence of the age gradient on the central velocity dispersion , [ z / h]@xmath1 or [ e / fe]@xmath1 was found .
this suggests that galaxy mass and star formation timescale plays little role in establishing age gradients .
thus as a young starburst evolves , the age gradient flattens from positive to almost zero .
[ grdz1 ] panel ( a ) shows the total metallicity gradient as a function of its central value .
the dashed line represents the trend found by snchez - blzquez et al .
( 2007 ) for galaxies mostly in hdes of clusters and groups . excluding galaxies with flat metallicity gradients ( see sec . [ z_profile ] ) , our galaxies follow the trend .
this trend indicates that galaxies with steeper gradients have more metal - enriched inner regions .
the galaxy ngc 2271 is the most deviant from the relation with a very shallow gradient for its central metallicity .
a correlation between the metallicity gradient and central age was detected in many previous studies for galaxies in different environments ( e.g. snchez - blzquez , gorgas & cardiel 2006a ; snchez - blzquez et al .
2007 ) . excluding the three galaxies with flat metallicity gradients
( see sec .
[ z_profile ] ) , fig .
[ grdz1 ] ( b ) shows that our galaxies follow similar trends as those found by snchez - blzquez et al .
( 2007 ) for galaxies in higher density environments .
galaxies with young central ages tend to have steep metallicity gradients while galaxies with uniform old stellar populations reveal shallower metallicity gradients . since the galaxies with young central ages are those with the steepest age gradients ( fig .
[ grdage1 ] ) , we expect the gradient of the total metallicity and the age gradient to be strongly correlated .
[ gzgage ] shows that galaxies of steep positive age gradients also show steep negative metallicity gradients .
this implies that the young central stellar populations are also more metal - rich than the old metal - poor stars in the outer regions of the galaxies .
[ mass1 ] shows that galaxies of smaller mass ( lower log(@xmath20 ) ) tend to reveal steeper metallicity gradients than more massive galaxies ( larger log(@xmath20 ) ) .
a hint of a similar trend was found by snchez - blzquez et al .
( 2007 ) for galaxies of log(@xmath20 ) @xmath99 ( @xmath100 km / s ) .
a change in the trend direction at this velocity dispersion , has been reported in several studies ( see snchez - blzquez et al .
2007 and references therein ) .
thus for galaxies with log(@xmath20 ) @xmath101 , metallicity gradients appear to get shallower for _ lower _ mass ( e.g. forbes et al . 2005 ) .
we note that ngc 4240 ( log(@xmath20)@xmath102 ) is consistent with this suggestion . examining the correlation of the metallicity gradient with galaxy dynamical mass log(@xmath103 ) and the absolute magnitude in the k - band ( as other proxies of mass ) gives similar trends to that of fig .
[ mass1 ] . for a sample of early - type galaxies
ferreras & silk ( 2002 ) found a correlation between [ e / fe ] gradient and its central value .
a steep negative gradient for low [ e / fe ] galaxies changes to a steep positive gradient for enhanced [ e / fe ] galaxies . using a simple model of star formation and a standard prescription for the rates of supernovae type ii and ia
, ferreras & silk found that negative gradients imply inside - out formation which is suggestive of a dissipative collapse formation . on the other hand ,
a positive gradient is a sign of outside - in formation which may be a result of a past merger events which induce central star formation in the merger remnant .
our isolated galaxies show statistical insignificant [ e / fe ] gradients on average .
furthermore , fig .
[ grdefe1 ] shows that there is no obvious correlation between [ e / fe ] gradient and its central value or the central age .
several galaxies in our isolated sample reveal a number of features such as tidal tails , dust , shells , discy and boxy isophotes and highly rotating central discs ( reda et al .
2004 , 2005 ; hau & forbes 2006 ) .
these structures indicate recent merger / accretion events during the evolutionary history of these galaxies . measuring
the age of the stellar populations of the isolated galaxies reveals that several galaxies have central young stars which also requires a recent gaseous accretion or merger .
if isolated galaxies formed purely by dissipative collapse we would expect uniformly old stellar ages .
we find both young central ages and age gradients in some isolated galaxies .
collapse models ( e.g. carlberg 1984 ; chiosi & carraro 2002 ; kawata & gibson 2003 ) predict steeper metallicity gradients in more massive galaxies . for the bulk of our sample , with velocity dispersions
@xmath104 km / s , we find the opposite behaviour with more massive galaxies have shallower metallicity gradients .
a collapse also implies a largely inside - out formation with the inner galaxy regions forming first which predicts a negative [ e / fe ] gradient ( e.g. ferreras & silk 2002 ) .
we find isolated galaxies to reveal no overall [ e / fe ] gradient .
thus we conclude that pure dissipative collapse can not explain our sample of relatively massive isolated early - type galaxies .
the expectations for stellar population parameters in a hierarchical merger scenario are more varied depending on the gas fraction of the progenitors and their mass ratio ( e.g. kobayashi 2004 ) .
gas - rich mergers are expected to induce central star formation ( e.g. mihos & hernquist 1996 ; springel 2000 ) .
the gradients of age and metallicity are predicted to correlate strongly with central young stars that are also metal - rich ( bekki & shioya 1999 ) . the metallicity gradient is also predicted to be shallower for a merger remnant ( e.g. kobayashi 2004 ) .
the age gradient for the majority of our isolated galaxies ( 11 out of 13 ) are found to range from flat to positive .
these age gradients are also correlated with the central age which implies that a young burst dominates the luminosity in the central region where it takes place , and thus produces a steep gradient .
as these young populations get older and fade , the observed gradient of the luminosity - weighted age becomes shallower .
however , two galaxies ( ngc 1045 and mcg-02 - 13 - 009 ) show significant negative age gradients .
the radial age profile of ngc 1045 reveals a stellar population of intermediate age at @xmath105 and outward , which implies a secondary star formation event induced in the outer regions of the galaxy . that suggests either a late gas accretion or merger with a gas - rich satellite galaxy ( kobayashi 2004 ) .
such accretion may form a star forming ring .
deep imaging of this galaxy reveals strong boxy isophotes and extensive extra tidal light ( reda et al . 2004 ) which argues in favour of a recent merger .
while deep imaging is not available for mcg-02 - 13 - 009 , its negative age gradient and flat metallicity gradient in the central region is predicted by the simulations of kobayashi ( 2004 ) to be the result of late gas accretion rather than a major merger .
most of our isolated galaxies ( 8 out of 13 ) are found to have negative metallicity gradients , as galaxies with central metal - rich stars tend to have steeper metallicity gradients .
the three galaxies ngc 1162 , ngc 2865 and ngc 821 have both significant age gradients as well as metallicity gradients , with the young central stellar population also being more metal - rich than the old metal - poor stars in the outer regions .
ngc 1162 has an intermediate central age of 6.8 gyrs suggesting a secondary star formation event .
a major merger of two massive progenitors is expected to produce a more metal - rich stellar population and shallower metallicity gradient than observed . however , a minor merger with a satellite of mass less than 0.2 times that of the primary galaxy is more likely to explain the intermediate central metallicity and the gradient ( kobayashi 2004 ) .
the galaxy ngc 2865 is the youngest ( 1.7 gyrs ) and most metal - rich ( [ z / h]@xmath106 ) galaxy of our sample .
its central velocity dispersion of 178 km / s indicates an intermediate mass galaxy .
deep imaging revels a surrounding shell structures ( hau , carter & balcells 1999 ; reda et al .
2004 ) and kinematics reveal a kinematically decoupled core in the central 4 arcsec or 6.4 kpc ( hau , carter & balcells 1999 ; hau & forbes 2006 ) . the kinematics and stellar population of this galaxy suggest a gas - rich accretion or merger origin for the shell and kinematics structures ( hau et al . 1999 ) . however , the steep metallicity gradient of 0.47 prefers a gas - rich accretion by a metal - rich parent galaxy .
the galaxy ngc 821 has a central stellar population of 5.6 gyrs old and a high metallicity of [ z / h]@xmath107 , which indicates a secondary star burst .
gas accretion or a minor merger would produce a lower central metallicity , while a major merger would have reduced the very steep metallicity gradient of 0.72 . in the detailed study of proctor et al .
( 2005 ) , ngc 821 is speculated to consume its own gas to fuel a secondary central burst of star formation .
the metallicity gradient of isolated galaxies are found to be steeper for less massive galaxies .
this result is consistent with a major merger history for the massive galaxies ( e.g. bekki & shioya 1999 ) . during the merger process ,
the high metallicity stars in the centre of the galaxy are transported to the outer regions which dilutes the metallicity gradient ( bekki & shioya 1999 ) . on the other hand , the induced star formation during the merger at the centre of the merger remnant
is expected to maintain the metallicity gradient to some extent .
the final metallicity gradient of the merger remnant is shallower than the progenitors and the newly formed central stars will also produce relatively steep age gradients for these galaxies ( kobayashi 2004 ) .
the gas - rich merger simulation of bekki & shioya ( 1999 ) predicts a one - to - one correlation between the age gradient and metallicity gradient .
however , our isolated galaxies show a correlation of slope @xmath108 .
both isolated galaxies , and those in hdes , show similar age - mass relations as more massive galaxies are older than smaller ones . that suggests either the less massive galaxies have had successive star formation events ( bursts induced by mergers ) continuing until recent epochs , while more massive galaxies did not suffer such events .
alternatively , all galaxies started forming their stars in a single burst ( similar to a dissipative collapse ) at the same epoch which stopped earlier in more massive galaxies , while less massive galaxies continue forming new stars for extended epochs .
several mechanisms have been introduced to suppress the star formation processes in more massive galaxies such as a central active galactic nuclei ( e.g. springel , di matteo & hernquist 2005 ; de lucia et al .
the dependence of the star formation efficiency on the circular velocity of the galaxy can also delay the star formation in small galaxies relative to more massive galaxies ( e.g. de lucia et al . 2004 ) .
the old galaxies in our sample ( ngc 2271 , eso153-g003 , eso218-g002 and mcg-03 - 26 - 030 ) with central age @xmath109 11 gyrs show flat age gradients which indicates that all stars are formed at same time at @xmath110 .
they also tend to be the most massive galaxies .
this can be a result of a single burst of star formation during a rapid collapse of a single cloud ( larson 1974 , 1975 ; calberg 1984 ) .
the observed metallicity gradient of these galaxies ( @xmath111 ) is much less than the predicted gradients of the dissipative collapse models .
the major merger scenario can explain the shallow metallicity gradients of these galaxies but not their uniform old populations .
another mechanism such as developing central active galactic nuclei ( e.g. springel , di matteo & hernquist 2005 ; de lucia et al .
2006 ) is necessary to stop any further star formation after the merger .
the low metallicity of eso153-g003 ( [ z / h]@xmath112 ) suggests progenitors of relatively small size for this galaxy .
the galaxy ngc 2271 has the highest metallicity among these galaxies ( [ z / h]@xmath113 ) with a flat metallicity gradient of .
it also shows elongated shape ( @xmath114 ) and a solid body rotation with ( @xmath115 ( hau & forbes 2006 ) which may indicate amassive disk progenitor .
the shallow metallicity gradients of the two galaxies ngc 682 and ngc 4240 indicate past major mergers . on the other hand ,
their uniform luminosity weighted intermediate ages suggest a very small fraction of induced star formation . the magnitude of the metallicity gradients are found to correlate to the age gradient .
the suggested mechanism causing these gradients is that each star formation event will enrich the ism , followed by radial inflow , causing the subsequent stellar generations at the galaxy centre to be more metal - rich , as well as younger .
a natural result of this process is the observed age - metallicity relation .
the dynamical effect of supernova feedback is expected to be relatively weaker in more massive galaxies , consequently the star formation rate is more efficient in these galaxies than in less massive ones .
the deep potential well of massive galaxies maintains their gas long enough to perform more complete chemical processes to produce higher metallicities ( e.g. arimoto & yoshii 1987 ; edmunds 1990 ; matteucci 1994 ) resulting in the observed mass - metallicity relation .
independent of the galaxy mass , or the details of the merging process , the observed correlation between the metallicity gradient and its central value can be reproduced by the gas - rich merger simulations of bekki & shioya ( 1999 ) .
the results of these models are also consistent with the observed insignificant gradients of [ e / fe ] within 1 effective radius of the isolated galaxies . the parameter [ e / fe]@xmath1 measures the abundance ratio of the @xmath0-element to the fe - peak elements which are predicted to be released to the interstellar medium by supernovae type ii and ia and on different time scales .
in that sense , [ e / fe]@xmath1 is commonly used to quantify the duration of star formation ( worthey , faber & gonzalez 1992 ; matteucci 1994 ; thomas , greggio & bender 1999 ; thomas et al .
2005 ) . for the isolated galaxies as well as in hdes , the lower [ e / fe]@xmath1 of the less massive galaxies points to extended star formation for these galaxies
however , the isolated early - type galaxies tend to have younger ages and lower [ e / fe]@xmath1 for their central velocity dispersion than their counterparts in hdes .
furthermore , we also note that isolated galaxies of intermediate ages tend to have lower [ e / fe]@xmath1 than the galaxies in hdes .
this is expected if the extended star formation is triggered with recent mergers which have stopped in hdes at higher redshifts but continue to recent epochs for galaxies in low density environments such as our isolated galaxies .
isolated galaxies show a wide range of ages , [ z / h ] and [ e / fe ] for their central stellar populations .
more massive galaxies tend to be older , more metal - rich and more @xmath0-element enhanced than less massive galaxies in the same sense as galaxies in high density environments .
although isolated galaxies tend to be slightly younger , more metal - rich and lower [ e / fe ] for their mass . the majority of the isolated galaxies in our sample show insignificant gradients of both age and [ e / fe ] .
although a correlation between the age gradient and central age indicates the tendency of the newly formed stars to locate closer to the galaxy centre .
the metallicity gradient ranges from very steep to flat .
metallicity gradients are found to correlate with parameters of the central stellar populations such as central metallicity , age and velocity dispersions .
metallicity gradients also show a remarkable correlation with the age gradients .
the formation scenario of a single dissipative collapse cloud can not explain the spatial distribution of the stellar population and kinematic properties found for isolated galaxies .
mergers at different redshifts of progenitors of different mass ratios and gas fractions are needed to reproduce the observed properties of the galaxies .
arimoto n. , yoshii y. , 1987 , a&a , 173 , 23 + bekki k. , shioya y. , 1999 , apj , 513 , 108 + bernardi et al .
, 2003 , aj , 125 , 1882 + bernardi m. , nichol r. c. , sheth r. k. , miller c. j. , brinkmann j. , 2006 , aj , 131 , 1288 + brough et al . , 2006 , supmitted to mnras + carlberg r.g . , 1984 ,
apj , 286 , 403 + chiosi c. , carraro g. , 2002 , mnras , 335 , 335 + colbert j. w. , mulchaey j. s. , zabludoff a. i. , 2001 , aj , 121 , 808 + collobert m. , sarzi m. , davies r. l. , kuntschner h. , colless m. , 2006 , mnras , 370 , 1213 + de lucia g. , kauffmann g. , white s. d. m. , 2004 , mnras , 349 , 1101 + de lucia g. , springel v. , white s. d. m. , croton d. , kauffmann g. , 2006 , mnras , 366 , 499 + denicol g. , terlevich r. , terlevich e. , forbes d. a. , terlevich a. , 2005b , mnras , 358 , 813 + denicol g. , terlevich r. , terlevich e. , forbes d. a. , terlevich a. , carrasco l. , 2005a , mnras , 356 , 1440 + edmunds m. g. , 1990 , mnras , 246 , 678 + ferreras i. , silk j. , 2002 , mnras , 336 , 1181 + forbes d. a. , snchez - blzquez p. , proctor r. , 2005 , mnras , 361 , l6 + hau g. k. t. , carter d. , balcells m. , 1999 , mnras , 306 , 437 + hau g. k. t. , forbes d. a. , 2006 , mnras , 371 , 633 + jarrett t. h. , chester t. , cutri r. , schneider s. e. , huchra j. p. , 2003
, aj , 125 , 525 + kawata d. , gibson b. k. , 2003 , mnras , 346 , 135 + kelson d. d. , illingworth g. d. , franx m. , van dokkum p.g . , 2006 , astro - ph/0606642 + kobayashi c. , 2004 , mnras , 347 , 740 + kobayashi c. , arimoto n. , 1999 , apj , 527 , 573 + kuntschner h. , lucey j. r. , smith r. j. , hudson m. j. , davies r. l. , 2001 , mnras , 323 , 615 + kuntschner h. , smith r. j. , colless m. , davies r. l. , kaldare r. , vazdekis a. , 2002 , mnras , 337 , 172 + larson r. b. , 1974 , mnras , 166 , 585 + matteucci f , 1994 , a&a , 288 , 57 + mehlert d. , thomas d. , saglia r. p. , bender r. , wegner g. , 2003 , a&a , 407 , 423 + mihos j. c. , hernquist l. , 1996 , apj , 464 , 641 + proctor r. n. , forbes d. a. , beasley m. a. , 2004 , mnras , 355 , 1327 proctor r. n. , forbes d. a. , forestell a. , gebhardt k. , 2005 , mnras , 362 , 857 + proctor r. n. , forbes d. a. , hau g. k. t. , beasley m. a. , de silva g. m. , contreras r. , terlevich a. i. , 2004 , mnras , 349 , 1381 + proctor r. n. , sansom a. e. , 2002 , mnras , 333 , 517 + prugniel p. , simien f. , 1997 , a&a , 321 , 111 + reda f. m. , forbes d. a. , beasley m. a. , osullivan e. j. , goudfrooij p. , 2004
, mnras , 354 , 851 + reda f. m. , forbes d. a. , hau g. k. t. , 2005 , mnras , 360 , 693 + snchez - blzquez p. , forbes d. a. , strader j. , brodie j. , proctor r. , 2007 , submitted to mnras + snchez - blzquez p. gorgas j. , cardiel n. , 2006a , a&a , 457 , 823 + snchez - blzquez p. , gorgas j. , cardiel n. , gonzalez j. j. , 2006b , a&a , 457 , 809 + springel v. , 2000 , mnras , 312 , 859 + springel v. , di matteo t , hernquist l. , 2005 , apj , 620 , l79 + terlevich a. i. , forbes d. a. , 2002 , mnras , 330 , 547 + thomas d. , greggio l. , bender r. , 1999 , mnras , 302 , 537 + thomas d. , maraston c , bender r. , 2003 , mnras , 339 , 897 + thomas d. , maraston c , bender r. , de oliveira c. m. , 2005 , apj , 621 , 673 + thomas d. , maraston c. , korn a. , 2004 , mnras , 351 , l19 ( tmk04 ) + trager s. c. , worthey g. , faber s. m. , burstein d. , gonzalez j. j. , 1998 , apjs , 116 , 1 + vazdekis a. , 1999 , apj , 513 , 224 + white s. d. m. , 1980 , mnras , 191,1 + worthey g. , faber s. m. , gonzalez j. j. , 1992 , apj , 398 , 69 + worthey g. , ottaviani d. l. , 1997 , apjs , 111 , 377 + | we present radial stellar population parameters for a subsample of 12 galaxies from the 36 isolated early - type galaxies of reda et al . using new long - slit spectra ,
central values and radial gradients for the stellar age , metallicity [ z / h ] and @xmath0-element abundance [ e / fe ] are measured .
similarly , the central stellar population parameters are derived for a further 5 isolated early - type galaxies using their lick indices from the literature . on average
, the seventeen isolated galaxies have mean central [ z / h]@xmath1 and [ e / fe]@xmath1 of @xmath2 and @xmath3 respectively and span a wide range of ages from 1.7 to 15 gyrs .
we find that isolated galaxies follow similar scaling relations between central stellar population parameters and galaxy velocity dispersion to their counterparts in high density environments .
however , we note a tendency for isolated galaxies to have slightly younger ages , higher metallicities and lower abundance ratios . such properties are qualitatively consistent with the expectation of an extended star formation history for galaxies in lower density environments .
generally we measure constant age and [ e / fe ] radial gradients .
however , three galaxies show remarkable positive age gradients and two galaxies have negative age gradients .
we find that the age gradients anti - correlate with the central galaxy age .
thus as a young starburst evolves , the age gradient flattens from positive to almost zero .
metallicity gradients range from near zero to strongly negative . for our high mass galaxies ( @xmath4 km / s )
metallicity gradients are shallower with increasing mass .
such behaviour is not predicted in dissipational collapse models but might be expected in multiple mergers .
the metallicity gradients are also found to be correlated with the central age and metallicity , as well as to the age gradients . in conclusion ,
our stellar population data for a sample of isolated early - type galaxies are more compatible with an extended merger / accretion history than early dissipative collapse .
galaxies : elliptical and lenticular , cd - galaxies : abundances - galaxies : formation - galaxies : evolution - galaxies : kinematic and dynamics |
the production of solar flares , the evolution and migration of sunspots , and the very origin of the sun s magnetic field are all believed to be associated with differential rotation beneath and at the solar surface . to test models of stellar dynamos , measurements of differential rotation in other stars are necessary for correlation with other parameters like magnetic variability and chromospheric activity .
surface differential rotation ( sdr ) can be easily observed in the sun with detailed observations going back to @xcite and subsurface rotation has been inferred from helioseismic data of the sun s 5-minute p - mode oscillations ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
however , it is a challenge to observe sdr directly at the surfaces of other stars . with the notable exception of ek dra , where two spot modulations differing in period by 5.5% are simultaneously visible @xcite , evidence for sdr in most solar - type stars with prominent starspots is seen only by comparing data over many years .
light variations ascribed to rotational modulation sometimes change in period from epoch to epoch , and the most natural explanation is that the dominant spot systems appear at different latitudes and move with different rotation periods ( e.g. , @xcite ; @xcite ) .
doppler imaging of some solar - type stars from epoch to epoch has also revealed evidence for sdr ( see reviews by @xcite and @xcite ) and in at least one case , the rapidly rotating k dwarf ab doradus , sdr was observed in the doppler maps in only a few consecutive rotations ( @xcite ) .
so far , there have not yet been measurements of solar - type acoustic oscillations in any star other than the sun with sufficient frequency resolution to explore its interior rotation .
the most ( microvariability & oscillations of stars ) satellite @xcite was pointed at @xmath0 ceti as part of the commissioning phase of the mission , to obtain useful science during engineering tests and debugging of the most systems .
our space - based photometry has sufficient time coverage and precision to reveal sdr which is easily evident even in only three equatorial rotations of the star .
the data also set the first meaningful limits on the amplitudes of p - mode oscillations in this star .
@xmath0 ceti was chosen because of ( 1 ) its brightness and location in the sky at the time of these tests , ( 2 ) previous indications of spot migration and hyperactivity , and ( 3 ) its g5v spectral type , which made it a possible candidate for solar - type oscillations ; we describe the star more fully in section [ kappa ] .
the most observations are discussed in section [ obs ] .
the most - orbit binned data produce a light curve which reveals the flux rotational modulation of a young active sun - like star in unprecedented completeness and precision ( section [ lc ] ) .
we are able to relate the photometric modulations of spot visibility to periodic rotational variations of chromospheric activity seen in high - resolution spectroscopic observations of the ca ii k emission in 2002 and 2003 ( section [ caii ] ) , the latter obtained just before the most observations ; the same data provided a new accurate determination of @xmath7 for the star .
the full temporal resolution most photometry is used to set meaningful limits on the oscillation amplitudes in this star in section [ p - mode ] .
@xmath0 cet ( hd 20630 , hip 15457 , hr 996 ; @xmath8 , @xmath9 ) is a nearby ( @xmath10 pc , @xcite ) g5v dwarf .
its variability with a period of 9.09 days was detected by the _
mission @xcite .
since then , several studies were aimed at reconciling apparent changes in the period , changes which can be explained by different latitudes of spot formation in different years . as a mk spectral classification standard @xcite ,
@xmath0 ceti is one of the most frequently observed stars .
although sometimes considered a `` very strong lined '' late - type dwarf , its metallicity may be only slightly higher than solar , @xmath11=+0.05 \pm 0.05 $ ] ( for full references , see @xcite ) . as far as it has been possible to establish , it is a single star and does not possess any large planets @xcite .
its radial velocity of + 18.9 km s@xmath12 combined with the _ hipparcos _ proper motions leads to a rather moderate spatial velocity relative to the sun , suggesting young disk population membership ( the two available estimates disagree slightly : @xcite , @xmath13 , @xmath14 and @xmath15 ; @xcite @xmath16 , @xmath17 and @xmath18 ) .
@xcite estimated an age of 750 myr from the relatively rapid rotation of 9.2 days seen in the spot modulation and suggested that the star is a likely member of the hyades moving group .
however , @xcite considered seven moving groups of nearby young stars , but were unable to associate @xmath0 ceti with any of them . the young age of the star was the reason for @xcite to include @xmath0 ceti in the _ the sun in time _ project which attempts to characterize young solar - type stars in terms of temporal changes taking place particularly at the epochs before terrestrial life formation @xcite .
in the group of 6 such stars , with the youngest being 130 myr old , @xmath0 ceti is one of the most advanced ones with an estimated age in the @xcite study of about 650 myr .
the difference in the age of 100 myr versus 750 myr of @xcite can be traced to the current uncertainty of estimates based on the rotation rate .
( note : the 8.9 day rotation period found in this paper may be taken as an indication of an even younger age ) . as is observed for stars with activity somewhat moderated with age
, the star shows an activity cycle .
@xcite monitored the narrow - band ca ii h & k chromospheric fluxes photoelectrically from 1967 to 1991 expressing them in terms of the @xmath19 index .
they found a rotational period of @xmath20 days @xcite with a chromospheric activity cycle of 5.6 years @xcite ; the quality of the latter determination was described as `` fair '' and longer term trends were noted .
using broad band photometry , @xcite observed a photometric activity cycle of of @xmath21 years between 1990 and 1999 , with a rotational period of 9.214 days . on 24 january 1986
, @xcite caught the signature of a massive flare in he i d@xmath22 which @xcite subsequently estimated had an energy @xmath23 ergs .
@xcite speculated that such massive flares on a single solar - type star might be triggered by the magnetic field of a close giant planet such as those in 51 peg - type systems .
neither @xcite nor @xcite detected any long - term periodic variability over many years in their precise radial velocity ( prv ) measurements , so there exist no dynamical perturbations consistent with a close - in giant planet ( unless the orbit is highly inclined ) . on the other hand , @xcite did find ( their figure 2 ) a rapid rv change of + 80 m s@xmath12 in 1988.5 which was accompanied by an equally rapid increase in chromospheric activity in the ca ii @xmath248662 line . while the rv change could be modeled by the close approach of a giant planet in a highly elliptical orbit , the tight correlation of the rv with chromospheric activity ( both positive and negative rv excursions )
pointed to a change intrinsic to the star . in section [ rv ]
we point out that , within the scatter of existing rv measurements , @xmath0 ceti could harbor in a close , high inclination orbit .
the photometric observations discussed in this paper were obtained by the most ( microvariability & oscillations of stars ) microsatellite @xcite between november 5 and december 5 , 2003 , during the commissioning phases of the mission ( constraints and limitations of these phases are described in the next section [ comm ] ) .
most is canada s first orbiting space telescope , launched in june 2003 to study ( 1 ) acoustic oscillations in solar - type and magnetic peculiar stars , ( 2 ) rapid variability in hot massive stars ; and ( 3 ) reflected light from close - in giant exoplanets .
the most instrument is an optical telescope ( aperture 15 cm ) feeding a ccd photometer through a single broadband optical filter ( 350 700 nm ) .
thanks to its polar sun - synchronous orbit ( altitude 820 km ) , most can monitor stars in a zodiacal band of sky about @xmath25 wide for up to 8 weeks without interruption .
starlight from primary science targets , such as @xmath0 ceti , i.e. brighter than @xmath26 , is projected onto the ccd as a fixed image of the telescope pupil covering about 1500 pixels for high photometric stability and insensitivity to detector flatfield and radiation effects on individual pixels .
as has already been demonstrated for procyon @xcite , most is capable of reaching in that mode a photometric precision of about @xmath27 part per million ( ppm ) to search for oscillations in very bright stars . despite limitations during commissioning ( see the next section ) , the most data of @xmath0 ceti achieved a duty cycle of about 96% over a time span of 30.5 days ( with only three gaps of a few hours each ) , with 40-second exposures obtained approximately once per minute . at the time these data were obtained , this was the longest uninterrupted observational coverage of any star other than the sun .
( most has since exceeded this duty cycle and time coverage on other targets , including procyon : @xcite . )
most was designed to be highly stable photometrically over periods of hours and self - calibrating ( see the discussion in @xcite ) , consequently the measurements are non - differential . for
some primary science targets , fainter secondary science targets in the adjacent direct - focus field may allow us to search for systematic drifts in the photometry , but no such stars were observed with a sufficient s / n for @xmath0 ceti .
the most photometry is performed in a single spectral band , with a filter about twice as wide as the johnson @xmath28 filter and slightly redward of it @xcite , without reference to comparison stars or flux standards .
thus , there is no direct connection to any photometric system and hence , no absolute calibration of the most photometry .
because of this , the original data ( expressed in analog - to - digital intensity units or adu ) were normalized to unity at the maximum observed flux of the star , occurring at jd 2,452,953.0 .
all variation amplitudes in this paper are also expressed in these relative units . to investigate rotational modulation in @xmath0 ceti
, the 40-second exposures were binned according to the 101.4-min orbital period of the most satellite , increasing the signal - to - noise per data point and minimizing the influence of orbital variations in the photometric background due to stray earthlight .
the electronic - version table [ tab1 ] lists the most orbit - averaged photometry , and those points are plotted in the upper panel of figure [ fig1 ] .
the formal mean standard error of a single data point is 0.77 mmag ( 770 parts per million or ppm ) , which is about twice the error calculated from the detected photon shot - noise .
the simple average of 101 individual 40 sec integrations would give an error of @xmath29 ppm , which is not far from what is observed as the actual scatter of about 200 ppm which includes the intrinsic variability of the star .
some of the photometric noise is certainly intrinsic to the star ( e.g. , granulation variations , given the star s activity ) and some is undoubtedly due to a non - poisson instrumental noise resulting from the significant pointing scatter and the removal of the ( noisy ) stray light background signal ( see the next section ) .
the sky background removed from the data shown in figure [ fig1 ] varied from about 21 to 25% of the maximum flux measured from the star ( on jd 2,452,953 ) ; the background variations are plotted in figure [ fig2 ] .
the background light is due primarily to light entering the instrument from the illuminated limb of the earth which is exposed to the face of the satellite with the telescope entrance aperture . during commissioning
, the most team was still investigating the background and exploring ways to mitigate it for future targets ( e.g. , choosing the optimum `` roll '' orientation for the satellite ) . to correct for the sky background , which is modulated with the satellite orbital period , but varies slightly from orbit to orbit , a running averaged background phased with the orbital period was subtracted from the data . during the @xmath0
ceti observing run , the moon approached within about @xmath30 of the most target field , but we observe no correlation of the sky background with the angular separation of the moon and the target , or with the lunar phase ( see the lower panels of figure [ fig2 ] ) .
the main results of this paper are not particularly sensitive to any residual background variations which may be present .
although the sky background variability is probably the fundamental limit to the long - term precision of the @xmath0 ceti photometry , we note that the 8.9-day period light photometric cycle was highly stable in the final light curve ( section [ lc - most ] ) , indicating that the background was correctly accounted for in the most data over the duration of the @xmath0 ceti observing run .
a brief description of the `` commissioning '' observations is given below as a record and explanation of certain limitations of these observations compared to the normal scientific operations of most which were initiated in january 2004 , not long after the @xmath0 ceti data were obtained .
the precise photometry that most was designed to obtain is based on integrating the signal in a large image of the telescope pupil ( covering about 1500 pixels of the ccd ) projected by a fabry microlens and field stop enclosing the incoming stellar beam . in normal operations ,
a resolved sub - raster of the ccd with that pupil image is downloaded for every science exposure , along with fabry images of the adjacent sky backgrounds , for processing on the ground .
this is known as science data stream 2 or sds2 . as a data backup
, we also perform the pupil image signal integrations on board the satellite and store that information there for several days in case of extended loss of contact with our ground station network .
these data are part of science data stream 1 ( sds1 ) . during commissioning
, there was an unrecognized problem with a small fraction of the onboard memory which led to computer crashes occurring roughly every @xmath31 days if both sds2 and engineering telemetry were being sent to earth .
this resulted in a fraction of about 21% data sent as the fully resolved sds2 files ; the rest of our @xmath0 ceti photometry is based on sds1 data .
the lack of spatially resolved fabry image data restricts our options of sky background and stray light removal .
however , our later experience ( see @xcite , for the example of procyon ) shows that the quality of sds1 photometry is comparable to sds2 , although the latter is preferred . even with our routine of downloading only sds1 data ,
the onboard memory problem led to occasional computer crashes , which interrupted the data flow for one or more satellite orbits at a time , and accounts for most of the gaps in the light curve of figure [ fig1 ] .
the small percentage of corrupt memory locations has since been identified , and we avoid storing data there , so this problem no longer affects the most mission . at the commissioning phase of the mission , we had not yet optimized the spacecraft pointing .
the mean pointing errors were 4.5 arcsec _
rms _ in @xmath32 and 6.2 arcsec in @xmath33 , so this image wander across the fabry microlens ( with a field stop radius of 30 arcsec ) led to larger photometric errors than were later obtained during normal scientific operations . also , this limited our ability to center the target within the field stop .
jitter of the star within the field stop increases noise .
these are no longer serious issues for most .
upgrades to the attitude control system software have led to steady improvements in pointing .
observations of procyon in january
february 2004 were made with pointing errors of 1.3 and 3.1 arcsec rms in @xmath32 and @xmath33 respectively ; the current pointing performance has been improved to about 1.0 arcsec rms in both axes .
the current explanation of the variability observed in @xmath0 ceti is that stellar spots cause light changes at the level of 0.02 to 0.04 magnitude .
the changes have been observed by several ground - based observers to have characteristic time scales of about 9 days .
the most extensive studies were done by @xcite and @xcite . from 20 years of literature data ,
@xcite found several periods ranging between 9.14 and 9.46 days , each with uncertainty at the level of 0.03 0.05 days .
@xcite conducted a careful study over 6 seasons and determined individual periods ranging between 9.045 and 9.406 days , with typical uncertainties of 0.02 0.05 days .
the simplest explanation for such period changes is that spots are forming at , or migrating to different stellar latitudes , rotating with different angular velocities . by relating the spot modulation periods to the photometric cycle
, @xcite suspected that @xmath0 ceti shows an `` anti - solar '' pattern in which the period of the rotation modulation tends to increase steadily during the activity cycle .
the photometric data discussed here consist of the orbit - averaged observations ( binned by intervals of 101.4 min ) corrected for sky background , as presented in table [ tab1 ] and the upper panel of figure [ fig1 ] . a double - wave variation is clearly evident , consisting of deep minima with a depth of about 0.04 of the maximum light , interspersed with moderately shallow depressions with amplitudes of about @xmath34 .
the shallow minima progressively move relative to the deeper ones as if two close periodicities were involved .
the photometry only covers about three cycles of the dominant variation , so fourier analysis is relatively ineffective at accurately identifying the periodic content of the variations .
we formally recover two significant peaks at frequencies of 0.1146 and 0.2170 day@xmath12 , corresponding to periods of 8.72 and 9.22 days ( actually @xmath35 ) . because of the short duration of the observing run
, these periods can not be established to better than about @xmath36 day ( figure [ fig3 ] ) . instead of using the formal values of the derived periods , we use two periods , 8.9 and 9.3 days , which are derived by a simple folding of the data in a sequential decomposition of the light curve , starting from the largest and most regular variation : 1 .
the most obvious is a periodic pattern reminiscent of an eclipsing light curve or a spot curve , the latter due to a spot or a group of spots with probably well defined edges covering a moderately large fraction of the stellar surface .
this pattern has an amplitude reaching 0.04 of the maximum observed flux and a period of @xmath37 days .
an average of three cycles gives a relatively stable light curve , as shown in the phase diagram of figure [ fig4 ] .
when the 8.9 day pattern is removed , another periodic variation becomes visible .
this is shown in the middle panel of figure [ fig1 ] .
this pattern is less regular than the 8.9-day variation , with the minima becoming progressively deeper from about 0.005 to 0.01 over the three complete cycles .
( there is evidence that the next cycle , which is incomplete , is shallower than the preceding one . ) .
the three times of minima give an approximate period of 9.3 days , where the uncertainty is harder to estimate due to the variable shapes of the dips .
the middle panel of figure [ fig1 ] suggests that either the 9.3 day pattern evolved over time or there existed residual variability from some other source , especially at the beginning of the most run .
the variability was most probably intrinsic to the star , judging by the progression of the depths of the 9.3 day pattern , and the excellent agreement between the phased minima of the 8.9 day pattern .
we observe no correlation in the sky background variations , shown in figure [ fig2 ] , with the deviations from regular 9.3 day periodic pattern , shown in the middle panel of figure [ fig1 ] ; this may be taken as indication that the sky background variations were not the cause of these irregularities .
the observed periodic variations can be explained by spots formed at different stellar latitudes and carried by the rotation of the star with different angular velocities . with single - band photometry , little
can be said about the type of spots , if they are hotter or cooler than the surrounding photosphere .
however , two of the authors did develop two simple , entirely independent geometric spot models to try reproduce the observed light curve .
the models differed in approach in that the first used the minimum number of parameters and ended up describing only the larger spot which apparently did not evolve during the most observations ; only a very simplified description could be derived for the smaller spot .
the second model utilized a full set of 12 parameters required to describe two spots and the geometry of their visibility on the star .
the second model was under - constrained , but its basic results fully confirmed the first model in its description of the larger spot . in the simplest terms : the larger of the two spots , with a rotation period of 8.9 days and a relative flux amplitude of 0.039 , if entirely black and circular , would have a radius of 19% of the stellar radius or an angular radius from the star center of 11@xmath38 .
the mean 8.9-day light curve is shown in figure [ fig4 ] .
since the light variations take place over slightly more than half of the rotation and the `` flat top '' is shorter than half of the rotation , the spot appears to be situated above the equator . the smaller spot , causing the 9.3-day ( or slightly longer ) periodicity ,
also if black and circular , must be about 12% of the stellar radius ( angular radius @xmath39 ) .
any model must face the limitation that the parameter without any constraint is the unperturbed level of the light curve , @xmath40 ; we arbitrarily assumed it to be at the highest observed level ( see figure [ fig1 ] ) , but some small spots may have been present on the surface at all times . while the spot longitude ( @xmath24 ) can be removed from the parameter list by an appropriate adjustment of the phases , even the simplest model involves several adjustable parameters : the rotation axis inclination ( @xmath41 ) , the limb darkening coefficient ( @xmath42 ) , the latitude ( @xmath43 ) , the size or the angular radius as seen from the center of the star ( @xmath44 ) , as well as the darkness ( @xmath45 ) of the spot .
the darkness ( @xmath46 ) of the spot can not be estimated from the single - color data , so that the minimum size of the spot can be estimated assuming a black spot , @xmath47 .
even such a highly simplified model , with several parameters fixed contains at least three fully adjustable geometrical parameters : @xmath41 , @xmath43 , @xmath44 .
the best model of the larger spot fits the primary variation to better than 0.001 ( figure [ fig4 ] ) .
the relevant parameters for the star and the larger spot are ( the symbol @xmath48 means a fixed parameter ) : @xmath49 the 8.9-day spot is relatively large , and may be larger if not entirely black , so that the assumption of it being circular especially in view of the clear evidence of the shearing differential rotation is highly disputable .
therefore , this solution should be taken as indicative rather than of much physical significance .
the second model assumed two independent spots with different rotation periods .
it was specified by the rotational inclination @xmath41 of the star and the limb darkening parameter @xmath42 , with all parameters describing the two spots : the radii and flux contrasts , and the latitude , initial longitude , and the rotation period for each spot .
such a model required extensive tests of different combinations of parameters . while the results are inconclusive in details because of the large number ( 12 ) of weakly constrained parameters , they are fully consistent with the minimum - parameter model described above in the description of the first , 8.9-day spot . the second spot in the extended model appears to have a longer period , perhaps as long as 9.7 days , although uncertainty of the period is large and results from the obvious evolution of the second spot over time and a complex coupling with values of the remaining parameters .
the models have been unable to define accurate latitudes of both spots , although the second , more complex model suggested a higher latitude for the smaller , 9.3 day spot , a situation which would correspond to the solar surface differential rotation pattern . however , there is no question from both independent analyses that the two spots have unambiguously different periods , supporting the interpretation of sdr with @xmath50 % .
this is a clear evidence of surface differential rotation on @xmath0 ceti , and only the second after ek dra @xcite where two spots were also simultaneously visible .
all other inferences were based on apparent period changes @xcite , interpretation of subtle broadening effects in spectral lines , so far detectable only in the most rapidly rotating stars @xcite or doppler imaging from epoch to epoch @xcite ; for general reviews of these techniques and their limitations , see @xcite , @xcite and @xcite .
the most orbit - averaged data were also searched for short - lived variations which might be associated with transits of a close - in giant planet or with white - light flares .
the latter seemed more likely given the history of activity of @xmath0 ceti .
no candidates for transits or flares were found in the data .
we can set useful limits on such events over the month that we observed the star .
there were no flare events or transits with peak - to - valley variations @xmath51 mmag with durations longer than 200 minutes and none with variations @xmath52 mmag with durations between 2 and 200 min . for planetary transits ,
this limits the size of any possible transiting bodies with orbital periods of about 30 days or less to approximately @xmath53 of the stellar radius , about half the size of jupiter .
however , our spot modeling and measurements of @xmath7 indicate that the rotational inclination of the star is not close to @xmath6 so it is not expected that the orbital plane of any planets in the @xmath0 ceti system would be coincident with the line - of - sight .
several of us ( d.b . ,
s.r . , e.s . , g.w . ) monitored the ca ii h & k reversals of a number of 51 peg systems @xcite as well as several active , single stars with the gecko spectrograph on the canada france hawaii 3.6-m telescope ( cfht ) .
the intention was to detect chromospheric activity synchronized with the planetary orbits .
as a by - product , we determined radial velocities ( rvs ) for these stars with @xmath5420 m s@xmath12 @xcite . here
we present the various results for @xmath55 ceti .
the dates of the observations are listed in table [ tab2 ] .
they were acquired on four observing runs in 2002 and 2003 with the gecko coud spectrograph , fiber fed from the cassegrain focus of the cfht .
single spectra were recorded at a resolution of 110,000 spanning 60 and centered at 3947 ( see figure [ fig5 ] ) .
the signal - to - noise was @xmath56 500 per pixel in the continuum and 150 in the h & k cores .
full details of the data reduction are given in @xcite .
@xmath0 ceti shows moderate broadening of lines due to rotation at the rate of about 9 days .
the broadening is detectable in our high - resolution spectroscopy .
combined with the rotation period and the value of the radius , @xmath7 can be used to set a constraint on the rotational axis inclination @xmath41 which is one of free parameters in the spot models .
the previous determinations of @xmath7 were 3.9 km s@xmath12 @xcite , 4.3 km s@xmath12 @xcite , 5.6 km s@xmath12 @xcite and 3.8 km s@xmath12 @xcite .
we determined the value of @xmath7 by analyzing the broadening of the photospheric lines in the region of ca ii 3933/3968 in our cfht spectra .
we used the broadening function formalism @xcite of the deconvolution of photospheric spectra of rotating stars with spectra of sharp - line , slowly - rotating stars .
the approach leads to removal of all common agents of line broadening , not only of the instrumental component , but also of the tangential turbulence and of all other components which are the same for the program and the template stars . for @xmath0 ceti
, we used @xmath57 ceti which is a slightly cooler dwarf , g8v , and rotates very slowly , @xmath58 km s@xmath12 @xcite . for determination of the broadening function
, the spectra must be rectified and normalized . as shown in figure [ fig5 ] , the rich photospheric spectrum in both @xmath0 ceti and @xmath57 ceti is superimposed on strongly variable far wings of the ca ii absorption .
we removed sections of the spectrum where the wings fall below 1/3 of the maximum flux and applied a simple , upper - envelope rectification between high points of the quasi - continuum .
figure [ fig6 ] shows the broadening function for one of the cfht spectra , obtained on august 26 , 2003 ( see table [ tab2 ] ) . instead of least - squares fits of the limb - darkened rotational profile @xcite to the broadening functions ( with the limb darkening coefficient assumed @xmath59 , appropriate for the uv in late - type stars ) ,
we matched the half - widths at half maximum ; such @xmath7 determinations are less sensitive to the residual uncertainties at the base of the broadening function .
our average @xmath60 km s@xmath12 is compatible with previous determinations .
we note that @xcite , using an almost identical value of @xmath61 km s@xmath12 , interpreted it as implying @xmath62 .
the main spot in both model fits is located at moderate stellar latitude above the equator .
if the period of @xmath37 days were ascribed to the stellar equator , then the best fitting inclination of @xmath63 and the measured @xmath7 combine to give a stellar radius of @xmath64 , which is certainly reasonable for a g5v star .
the 7 region centered on the k - line which was used in the analysis is shown for a single spectrum in figure [ fig7 ] where spectral intensity is normalized to unity at the wavelength limits . in figure [ fig8 ] the residuals from the average normalized spectra are shown for each night ( where pairs of spectra on the same night have been averaged ) .
activity is confined entirely to the reversals , within about 0.94 around the center of the emission core or within @xmath65 km s@xmath12 .
if this broadening is caused by the velocity field , it is some 7.7 times larger than @xmath7 . to visualize the changes in the reversals , the integrated flux residuals shown in figure [ fig9 ]
are expressed in relative to the restricted continuum height shown in figure [ fig7 ] .
this height corresponds to about 1/3 of the local photospheric continuum around the ca ii lines so that the integrated residuals are proportional , but not identical , to the emission equivalent width .
they are listed in column 4 of table [ tab2 ] .
the best fitting periodic variation for the k residuals in table [ tab2 ] over the four observing runs in 2002 and 2003 has a period of @xmath66 days .
the residuals are plotted as a function of phase in figure [ fig9 ] with the arbitrary initial epoch of the minimum residual flux at @xmath67 ( the minimum flux epoch can be estimated to @xmath36 days ) .
the data from 2002 are shown as open symbols and those from september 2003 are solid .
although the data from 2002 cover only 3 rotations , with the data from 2003 the span in the rotations is extended to 44 .
since the period is largely defined by the 2002 observations , figure [ fig9 ] implies that the rotation associated with the enhanced ca ii activity has remained quite stable .
the 9.332 day period is entirely compatible with that found by @xcite ( @xmath20 day ) suggesting that the enhanced activity has in fact been stable at the same latitude for at least 36 years ( over 1400 rotations ) .
this period is also compatible with the 9.3 day period of the less prominent spot that we see in the most observations ( see section [ lc - most ] ) .
given this apparent stability , it is reasonable to extrapolate variations in the k - line residuals to the epoch of the most photometry which corresponds to only 7 additional rotations .
the bottom panel of figure [ fig1 ] shows the k - line flux changes which can be related to the photometric variations due to the 9.3 day spot seen in the most photometry .
the maxima of the two curves coincide .
the interpretation of this coincidence is not obvious as the enhanced ca ii could be expected to accompany the dark spot , unless what we see as the 9.3 day photometric signal is actually a bright spot and the minima are due to disappearance of the bright plage region .
radial velocities were estimated from @xmath56 20 of the photospheric spectrum ( @xmath68 , see figure [ fig5 ] ) with the `` fxcor '' routine in iraf , with th / ar comparison lines providing dispersion correction . more detail
is given in @xcite .
the first spectrum of the series in 2002 acted as the template from which differential radial velocities ( @xmath69rv ) were measured for all the spectra .
the @xmath69rv values are listed in table [ tab2 ] .
they are plotted against the 9.332 day rotational phase determined from the k - line residuals in figure [ fig9 ] where the open symbols correspond to data from 2002 and the solid points to september 2003 .
there is a remarkable consistency between the @xmath69rvs from both years suggesting that the underlying @xmath69rv technique is highly stable even without an imposed fiducial ( such as iodine vapor ) . from the 2002 data we derive @xmath7021.8 m s@xmath12 and 23.6 m s@xmath12 when combined with 2003 .
these values are very similar to @xmath7024.4 m s@xmath12 , found over 11 years by @xcite . for comparison ,
a planet which induces a reflex radial velocity variation @xmath71 m s@xmath12 and is tidally synchronized to the star , would have @xmath72 and a = 0.084 au .
consequently , @xmath0 ceti could still harbor a giant planet in a tidally locked orbit which we would not have detected . in 2003
the @xmath69rvs appear significantly different between the two nights , something which seems to be reinforced by the consistency within the pairs of @xmath69rvs .
while a planetary perturbation can not be ruled out by the 2002 data and other precision radial velocity studies , the difference in 2003 might be associated with the velocity field of the star itself .
the increase of velocity with increasing k - line strength is consistent with the extreme event in 1988.5 seen by @xcite
. however , the data are insufficient to discuss the point further here .
in figure [ fig10 ] , we present the fourier amplitude spectrum of the complete set of unbinned photometry ( at full temporal resolution of about one minute ) , in which the lower frequency modulations have been filtered from the data . also , the known satellite orbital frequency and its harmonics have been removed from the data , to avoid any confusion with residual stray light variations . although the spectrum is plotted only to a frequency of 4 mhz ( period = 4.17 min ) , the noise is level out to the nyquist frequency of about 8 mhz , and there are no significant periodic signals detected in that range .
the white dashed line represents the theoretical poisson noise for the data .
although there are a few peaks visible at frequencies below 1 mhz , there is no evidence for the pattern of nearly equal spacing associated with p - mode oscillations of low degree and high overtone ( as are seen in the sun ) .
there are several isolated peaks in the range 0.1 1.0 mhz ( periods of 2.8 hr to 17 min ) which may be real but are too few and widely separated to attempt a meaningful fit to a model . at a detection level of @xmath73
, we exclude coherent oscillations larger than about 27 ppm around 1 mhz , 26 ppm at 2 mhz , and 24 ppm at 3 mhz .
( the last is in the frequency range of the solar oscillations . )
thus , we would not expect to detect p - mode oscillations in @xmath0 ceti if they were at the level observed in photometry of integrated light of the sun ; i.e. , about 4 10 ppm @xcite .
however , knowledge of the nature of p - mode oscillations in other stars is very limited , and the first space - based photometry of procyon @xcite obtained by most yielded an unexpected null result despite a detection limit at least twice as good as in these commissioning data of @xmath0 ceti .
we are only beginning to explore the characteristics of p - mode oscillations in luminosity for stars beyond the sun .
the moderately young age of @xmath0 ceti , its relatively rapid rotation compared to the sun , and its later - than - solar spectral type may be contributing factors to the absence of large - amplitude ( i.e.,@xmath74 ppm ) p - modes in this star .
we have presented data on the photometric and spectroscopic variability of the moderately young , solar - type star @xmath0 ceti .
we describe our continuous photometric observations over one month in november 2003 using the most satellite and our high - resolution spectroscopic cfht observations over four observing runs in 2002 and 2003 .
the most data ( averaged over the 101.4-min orbital period of the satellite ) have an estimated point - to - point accuracy of @xmath75 millimagnitude or @xmath76 parts per million , and an unprecedented temporal coverage of 30.5 days with a completeness of 96% .
the most orbit - averaged photometry of @xmath0 ceti shows two distinctly different periodicities a well - defined 8.9-day variation and a smaller , less regular variation whose period appears to be around 9.3 days or slightly longer .
the best interpretation of these variations is that two spots ( or compact spot groups ) are at different latitudes on the stellar surface , moving at angular rates which are different by @xmath77 % .
this is one of the most direct evidences of surface differential rotation in a cool star other than the sun and the second such after ek dra @xcite .
all other measurements of sdr in other stars have been more indirect , either through season - to - season variations in spot period variability or through subtle broadening effects in spectral line profiles , so far observable only in the most rapidly rotating stars .
the details of the smaller slower moving spot on @xmath0 ceti depend on how one describes and removes the larger spot , 8.9 day , variability and on the treatment of the slowly varying residuals .
the multi - parametric modeling of the spots suggests that the smaller spots is located at a higher latitude , which would suggest a solar - like sdr pattern .
however , independent spectroscopy of the star , some of which was obtained only a few variation cycles before the most photometry , reveals that maxima of the ca ii k - line emission reversals are synchronized with a period of about 9.3 days , lending support to that period identification for the second spot . while showing significant evolution in size , shape and/or flux contrast even during our month of observations , the 9.3-day spot may in fact be the more stable one and perhaps visible over decades , based on earlier observations of @xmath0 ceti in the literature .
the shorter , 8.9 day , periodicity suggests that @xmath0 ceti rotates faster than previously supposed and thus may be even younger , based on the correlation between equatorial rotation period and age in solar - type stars .
the unbinned most photometry , with an integration time of 40 seconds and a sampling of once per minute , sets limits on ( 1 ) the presence of p - mode oscillations , ( 2 ) the eruptions of flares over one month of monitoring of this historically active star , and ( 3 ) the occurrence of planetary transits in the system .
the data effectively rule out p - mode oscillations larger than 25 parts per million ( ppm ) at the 3@xmath3 limit .
there were no flares with durations from 2 to 200 min whose white - light amplitudes could be larger than 2 3 mmag
. there can be no planets with orbital periods shorter than 30 days larger than about 0.5 jupiter diameter in an orbit plane which would lead to transits as seen from earth . within the value of @xmath7823 m s@xmath12
we determine , there could be a close jupiter - mass companion in an inclined orbit .
the information gleaned from this early set of most data , obtained before the satellite performance was optimized for normal operations on a target which was not part of the original planned scientific program , indicates the tremendous power of precise , nearly continuous photometry spanning many weeks , which is possible from a dedicated instrument in the right orbit in space .
there are many more applications like the ones described in this paper , and instruments like most can be an effective tool in studying the surface properties of rapidly rotating solar - type stars .
the most project is funded and supervised by the canadian space agency .
we are grateful to the engineers at dynacon inc . , the university of toronto institute for aerospace studies space flight laboratory , the university of british columbia department of physics and astronomy , and the university of vienna and austrian technical university for their contributions to the success of the most mission .
, a.f.j.m .
, g.a.h.w .
were supported by the natural sciences and engineering research council canada .
is also supported by fcar ( qubec ) .
w.w.w . received support from the austrian space agency and the austrian science fund ( p14984 ) .
this research has made use of the simbad database , operated at the cds , strasbourg , france and accessible through the canadian astronomy data centre , which is operated by the herzberg institute of astrophysics , national research council of canada .
baliunas , s. l. , hartmann , l. , noyes , r. w. , vaughan , h. , preston , g. w. , frazer , j. , lanning , h. , middelkoop , f. , mihalas , s. , 1983 , , 275 , 752 baliunas , s. l. , horne , j. h. , porter , a. , duncan , d. k. , frazer , j. , lanning , h. , misch , a. , mueller , j. , noyes , r. w. , soyumer , d. , vaughan , a. h. , woodard , l. , 1985 , , 294 , 310 baliunas , s. l. , donahue , r. a. , soon , w. h. , horne , j. h. , frazer , j. , woodard - eklund , l. , bradford , m. , rao , l. m. , wilson , o. c. , zhang , q. , bennett , w. , briggs , j. , carroll , s. m. , duncan , d. k. , figueroa , d. , lanning , h. h. , misch , t. , mueller , j. , noyes , r. w. , poppe , d. , porter , a. c. , robinson , c. r. , russell , j. , shelton , j. c. , soyumer , t. , vaughan , a. h. , whitney , j. h. , 1995 , , 438 , 269 benz , w. & mayor , m. 1984 , , 138 , 183 carrington , r. c. 1860 , , 20 , 254 collier cameron , a. 2002 , astron .
nachr . , 323 , 336 collier cameron , a. , donati , j .- f . & semel , m. 2002 , , 330 , 699 cumming , a. , marcy . g. w. & butler , r. p. 1999
, , 526 , 890 donati , j .- f . & collier cameron , a. 1997 , , 291 , 1 donati , j .- f .
, collier cameron , a. , hussain , g. a. j. & semel , m. 1999 , , 302 , 437 dorren , j. d. & guinan , e. f. 1994 , , 428 , 805 european space agency . 1997 .
the hipparcos and tycho catalogues ( esa sp-1200)(noordwijk : esa ) ( hip ) fekel , f. c. 1997 , , 109 , 514 frhlich , c. et al . 1997 , solar phys . , 170 , 1 gaidos , e. j. , henry , g. w. & henry , s. m. 2000 , , 120 , 1006 gizon , l. & solanki , s. k. 2004 , , 220 , 169 gray , d. f. 1992 , the observation and analysis of stellar photospheres , second ed .
, cambridge univ . press , chapter 17 .
gray , r. o. , napier , m. g. , & winkler , l. i. 2001 , , 121 , 2148 gdel , m. , guinan , e. f. , & skinner , s. l. , 1997 , , 483 , 947 guinan , e. f. , ribas , i. , & harper , g. m. 2003 , , 594 , 561 halbwachs , j. l. , mayor , m. , udry , s. & arenou , f. 2003 , , 397 , 159 hall , d. s. & busby , m. r. 1990 , in active close binaries , nato asic proceedings 319 , nato advance study institute , p. 377 henry , g. w. , eaton , j. a. , hamer , j. & hall , d.s .
1995 , , 97 , 513 heiter , u. & luck , r. e. 2003 , , 126 , 201 matthews , j. m. , kuschnig , r. , guenther , d. b. , walker , g. a. h. , moffat , a. f. j. , rucinski , s. m. , sasselov , d. , & weiss , w. w. , 2004 , nature , 430 , 51 messina , s. , rodon & guinan , e. f. 2001 , , 366 , 215 messina , s. & guinan , e. f. 2002 , , 393 , 225 messina , s. & guinan , e. f. 2003 , , 409 , 1017 montes , d. , lopez - santiago , j. , galvez , m. c. , fernandez - figueroa , m. j. , de castro , e. , & cornide , m. 2001 , , 328 , 45 rice , j. b. 2002 , astron .
, 323 , 220 robinson , c. r. , & bopp , b.w . , 1988 , in cool stars , stellar systems , and the sun , eds .
linsky & r.e .
stencel , ( berlin : springer - veralg ) , 509 rucinski , s. m. 1999 , in precise stellar radial velocities , ed . j. b. hearnshaw & c. d. scarfe , asp conf . ser . 185 , 82 rucinski , s. m. 2002 , , 124 , 1746 schaefer , b. e. , king , j. r. , 2000 , , 529 , 1026 shkolnik , e. , walker , g. a. h. , bohlender , d.a . , 2003 , , 597,1092 soderblom , d. r. , pendleton , j. & pallavicini , r. 1989 , , 97 , 539 strassmeier , k. g. 2004 , in stars as suns : avtivity , evolution , and planets , eds .
a. k. dupree & a. o. benz , iau symp .
, 219 , 11 thompson , m. j. et al , 1996 , science , 272 , 1300 walker , g. a. h. , walker , a. r. , irwin , a. w. , larson , a. m. , yang , s. l. s. , richardson , d. c. , 1995 , icarus , 116 , 359 walker , g. a. h. , matthews , j. m. , kuschnig , r. , johnson , r. , rucinski , s. , pazder , j. , burley , g. , walker , a. , skaret , k. , zee , r. , grocott , s. , carroll , k. , sinclair , p. , sturgeon , d. , harron , j. , 2003a , , 115 , 1023 walker , g. a. h. , shkolnik , e. , bohlender , d. a. , yang , s. , 2003b , , 115 , 700 ccccccl 7/28/2002 & 2452484.0907 & @xmath790.110 & @xmath790.0074 & 0.0000 + 7/28/2002 & 2452484.1062 & @xmath790.108 & @xmath790.0075 & 0.0460 + 7/30/2002 & 2452486.1395 & 0.110 & @xmath790.0048 & @xmath790.0085 + 8/20/2002 & 2452507.1459 & 2.360 & 0.0394 & 0.0104 + 8/21/2002 & 2452508.1227 & 2.465 & 0.0301 & @xmath790.0283 + 8/21/2002 & 2452508.1371 & 2.467 & 0.0233 & @xmath790.0317 + 8/23/2002 & 2452510.1235 & 2.680 & 0.0085 & @xmath790.0147 + 8/23/2002 & 2452510.1379 & 2.681 & 0.0078 & @xmath790.0256 + 8/23/2002 & 2452510.1524 & 2.683 & 0.0034 & @xmath790.0084 + 8/26/2002 & 2452513.1172 & 3.000 & @xmath790.0143 & @xmath790.0097 + 8/27/2002 & 2452514.1330 & 3.109 & @xmath790.0222 & @xmath790.0186 + 9/09/2003 & 2452892.1321 & 43.615 & 0.0164 & 0.0278 + 9/09/2003 & 2452892.1465 & 43.616 & 0.0172 & 0.0389 + 9/12/2003 & 2452895.1384 & 43.937 & @xmath790.0311 & @xmath790.0105 + 9/12/2003 & 2452895.1529 & 43.939 & @xmath790.0331 & @xmath790.0035 + | about 30.5 days of nearly uninterrupted broadband photometry of the solar - type star @xmath0 ceti , obtained with the most ( microvariability & oscillations of stars ) satellite , shows evidence for two large starspots with different rotation periods of 8.9 and approximately 9.3 days ( @xmath1 ) .
ground based measurements in 2002 and 2003 of ca ii h & k emission reveal variations in chromospheric activity with a period of about 9.3 days .
the data were obtained during the most commissioning phase . when the data are combined with historical observations ,
they indicate that the 9.3-day spot has been stable in its period for over 30 years .
the photometry , with a sampling rate of approximately once per minute , was also used to search for acoustic ( p - mode ) oscillations in the star .
we detect no clear evidence for p - modes in the @xmath0 ceti photometry , with a noise level around 7 9 @xmath2mag at frequencies in the range 0.5 4 mhz ( 3@xmath3 detection limit of 21 27 @xmath2mag ) .
there were no flares or planetary transits during the 30.5 days of most monitoring with light amplitudes greater than 2 mmag ( durations greater than 200 minutes ) and 3 mmag ( @xmath4 min durations ) . while this rules out any close - in planets of @xmath50.5 jupiter diameters with an orbital inclination close to @xmath6 , the scatter in differential radial velocities permit a close giant planet in a more highly inclined orbit |
the steep gradients related to the edge transport barrier in tokamak h - mode plasmas facilitate the growth of edge localised modes ( elms ) involving repetitive eruption of particles and energy @xcite .
the largest and most vehement of such events , classified as `` type - i '' elms , are commonly associated with the onset of ideal or peeling ballooning modes in edge pedestals @xcite . in future large tokamak devices like iter , the heat flux associated with type i elms
is estimated to seriously damage the plasma facing components ( pfcs ) and methods for the suppression or at least effective mitigation of the disruptions are essential for an economic steady state operation @xcite .
one of the most promising elm mitigation methods is the external application of resonant magnetic perturbations ( rmps ) which has been observed to increase the elm frequency and to reduce the heat load on the pfcs @xcite .
models for the physics underlying the elm mitigation by rmps have been developed @xcite .
however , the successful mitigation even by nonresonant magnetic perturbations renews questions about the acting mechanisms @xcite .
numerical computations are an important tool to analyse the physics and mode structure of elms .
ballooning elm scenarios have been investigated in nonlinear simulations based on magnetohydrodynamic ( mhd ) @xcite , two - fluid @xcite , and gyrofluid @xcite models .
the magnetic structure has an essential part for development and transport of elms .
in addition , numerical investigations of the interaction between elms and externally applied rmps will require a detailed knowledge of the parallel mode structure and the resulting magnetic flutter associated with the elm evolution in the perturbation - free case .
the present work focuses on nonlinear gyrofluid computation of the dynamical magnetic field structure associated with ideal ballooning elms .
the formation of magnetic islands and the development of ergodic magnetic field regions , both observed in mhd simulations @xcite , is reassessed with a gyrofluid code that in addition allows the consistent treatment of the small - scale turbulent blow - out @xcite .
it is found that an ideal ballooning elm involves a distinct ergodisation of the entire edge region .
the decrease of the ergodicity in the turbulent aftermath mainly depends on the evolution of plasma beta in the collapsing edge region .
the paper is organized as follows : in secs .
[ sec : gem]-[sec : advmagtransp ] , an overview of the model equations , geometry and code is given , and suitable expressions for the evaluation of ergodicity in the numerical results are defined . the simulation setup and the model for the initial h - mode state
are discussed in sec .
[ sec : setup ] .
the results for the elm induced magnetic field structure and the associated formation of ergodic magnetic field regions are presented in secs .
[ sec : magnstruct]-[sec : transp ] . in sec .
[ sec : summary ] , the results are summarized and discussed .
the simulations presented in this work are performed with the nonlinear gyrofluid electromagnetic model and code gemr @xcite . in the following we review model equations and geometry .
gemr includes six moment equations each for electrons and ions ( labelled with @xmath0 ) , which are coupled by a polarisation equation and an induction equation @xcite .
the dependent variables are density @xmath1 , parallel velocity @xmath2 , parallel temperature @xmath3 , perpendicular temperature @xmath4 , parallel component of the parallel heat flux @xmath5 , perpendicular component of the parallel heat flux @xmath6 , electric potential @xmath7 , and parallel magnetic potential @xmath8 .
the full set of model equations are treated in refs .
@xcite .
here we use normalised quantities @xcite : the perpendicular spatial scales are given in units of the minor plasma radius @xmath9 .
the time scale is normalised by @xmath10 , where @xmath11 is a reference plasma sound speed . here
, @xmath12 denotes the ion mass and @xmath13 is a reference electron temperature .
the dependent variables are normalised by @xmath14 , @xmath15 , @xmath16 , @xmath17 , @xmath18 , @xmath19 , where @xmath20 represents a reference density , @xmath21 is a reference temperature , @xmath22 denotes the elementary charge , @xmath23 represents the equilibrium magnetic flux density , @xmath24 is the drift scale , and @xmath25 is a reference value for the electron dynamical beta . here , @xmath26 denotes the reference electron pressure .
the magnetic flux density is normalised by @xmath27 .
the model dynamically evolves the full profiles of the dependent variables , where the inner ( source ) and outer ( sink ) radial boundaries are given by neumann and dirichlet conditions , respectively .
the computational domain includes an edge pedestal closed - flux - surface region with consistent quasi - periodic parallel - perpendicular boundary conditions , and a scrape - off - layer ( sol ) where the parallel boundary conditions represent a debye sheath limiter placed at the bottom side of a circular torus @xcite .
the main model parameters are the electron dynamical beta @xmath28 , the normalised drift scale @xmath29 , and the collisionality @xmath30 , where @xmath31 denotes a reference value for the braginskii electron collision time @xcite .
the evolution of the profiles is self - consistently coupled to the magnetic shafranov equilibrium for circular flux surfaces .
both the safety factor @xmath32 and the shafranov shift are evolved in each time step @xcite .
the geometry is described in terms of field - aligned , unit - jacobian hamada coordinates @xmath33 through @xmath34 where @xmath35 is the volume enclosed by the flux surface with major radius @xmath36 and minor radius @xmath37 , and @xmath38 ( @xmath39 ) and @xmath40 ( @xmath41 ) are the unit - cycle poloidal and toroidal hamada angles ( see ref .
@xcite for their definition ) .
@xmath35 is given in units of @xmath42 , and @xmath43 and @xmath37 are normalised by @xmath9 .
in oder to avoid magnetic shear deformation of grid cells , the @xmath44-coordinate is shifted by @xmath45 , i.e. @xmath46 is chosen to make @xmath47 and @xmath48 locally orthogonal at @xmath49 @xcite .
the initial magnetic equilibrium is computed from a prescribed safety factor profile @xmath50 .
the temporal evolution of the shafranov shift and @xmath51 are determined by the pfirsch - schlter current and the associated zonal ( @xmath52 ) component of @xmath8 .
the change of @xmath51 in each time step is given by @xcite @xmath53 where the brackets @xmath54 denote the zonal average over @xmath44 and @xmath55 , and the factors @xmath56 and @xmath28 enter due to the applied normalisation scheme .
the shafranov shift is incorporated into the coordinate grid by modifying the metric elements according to the s-@xmath57 model .
the resulting relevant part of the coordinate metric is given by @xmath58 where the prime denotes a derivative with respect to @xmath37 , @xmath59 and @xmath60 are given to lowest order in @xmath61 , and @xmath62 represents the local magnetic shear given by the pfirsch - schlter current . in order to make @xmath60 locally vanish at @xmath49 , the shift in the @xmath44-coordinate is defined as @xmath63 , where @xmath64 is given by @xmath65 the transformation ensures that magnetic field changes arising from the axisymmetric component of @xmath8 are placed on the coordinate grid . to avoid that this field component is considered twice ,
the axisymmetric part of @xmath8 is subtracted when the magnetic flutter is determined @xcite .
the focus of the present work is on the influence of edge localised ideal ballooning mode bursts on the magnetic field structure .
the fluctuating magnetic potential enters into the macroscopic magnetic equilibrium through its zonal average via eq .
[ eq : dq ] and sideband in eq .
[ eq : ds ] .
the magnetic shear is accordingly determined by @xmath66 and the shafranov shift ( eq . [ eq : ds ] ) .
the perpendicular magnetic flutter , which enters into the parallel nonlinearities , results from the spatial variation of the non - axisymmetric part @xmath67 of the parallel magnetic potential .
the magnetic fluctuations in direction of the perpendicular unit vectors @xmath68 and @xmath69 are given by @xmath70 where the factor @xmath71 results from the normalisation scheme .
[ eq : bx ] and [ eq : by ] were derived by assuming @xmath72 and using the approximation @xmath73 , where @xmath74 .
the magnetic flutter field is divergence free in good approximation . for the present work the corrections resulting from the addition of lower order terms ensuring an exactly divergence free magnetic flutter field
were found to be negligible .
the contravariant components of the magnetic flutter allow to evaluate the field line equation @xmath75 which will be used to visualize the magnetic field structure in terms of poincar plots .
ergodic magnetic field regions develop when magnetic fluctuations destroy the nested magnetic equilibrium surfaces .
the level of ergodicity can be measured by the average radial field line displacement defined by @xcite @xmath76 where @xmath77 denotes the number of considered field lines starting from a reference flux surfaces with radius @xmath78 , @xmath79 represents the length of a field line measured with respect to its starting point on the reference flux surface , and @xmath80 gives the radial position of the @xmath81th field line after a length @xmath79 .
radial electromagnetic turbulent transport of heat and particles can occur by fluid - like perpendicular @xmath82 advection , or through parallel motion along perpendicularly perturbed magnetic field lines .
the differential formulation of the advective transport of ion density is given in field aligned coordinates by @xmath83 where the area element @xmath84 is oriented in radial direction .
@xmath85 is the @xmath86 velocity , and @xmath87 and @xmath88 include the ion finite larmor radius ( flr ) corrected potentials @xmath89 and @xmath90 .
the screening operators @xmath91 for @xmath92 with @xmath93 are defined via the gyroaveraging operator @xmath94 @xcite .
the gyro averaging and screening operations are performed in fourier space , and would in pad approximation be given by @xmath95 .
the advective electron heat transport is @xmath96 where @xmath97 and @xmath98 denote the linearised pressure in parallel and perpendicular direction , respectively .
the magnetic flutter transport of ion density is given by @xmath99 where @xmath100 denotes the radial component of the fluctuating magnetic field .
correspondingly , the magnetic flutter transport of electron heat is defined by @xmath101 the ion density transport in eq .
[ eq : fie ] and [ eq : fim ] is normalised by @xmath102 . the electron heat transport in eq .
[ eq : qee ] and [ eq : qem ] is given in units of @xmath103 .
the onset of edge localised ideal ballooning modes is associated with the steep pressure gradient ( @xmath104 ) in an h - mode pedestal . the present edge turbulence model like any other available first - principles based model is not able to obtain a self - sustained edge transport barrier with experimentally realistic steep flow and pressure profiles .
in contrast to mhd models , the presence of the finite - beta ion - temperature - gradient instability at all values of beta and collisionality remove the familiar mhd threshold from the model .
the h - mode edge state can however be prescribed as an initial condition , and the blow - out of one ideal ballooning event ( destroying the transport barrier ) can be computed from that .
the procedure to obtain and start from such an initial h - mode like state with gemr has been described in ref .
@xcite .
the initial ( reference ) mid - pedestal values for density , temperature , and magnetic field are motivated by an exemplary asdex upgrade h - mode shot ( # 17151 ) @xcite , and are given as @xmath105 , @xmath106 , @xmath107 , and @xmath108 .
major radius , minor radius , and gradient lengths for density and temperature correspond to @xmath109 , @xmath110 , @xmath111 , and @xmath112 .
the radial simulation domain has an extension of @xmath113 around the separatrix located at @xmath114 , spanning both the pedestal and sol regions .
the initial @xmath32-profile is prescribed by @xmath115 , which corresponds to a reference safety factor of @xmath116 and a reference magnetic shear of @xmath117 . the electron dynamical beta and the drift scale resulting from the local reference parameters
are @xmath118 and @xmath119 .
the braginskii electron collision time is @xmath120 .
an evaluation of the mhd ballooning parameter gives @xmath121 ; thus the prescribed parameter set is expected to be ideal ballooning unstable .
the lundquist number has the value @xmath122 , where @xmath123 is the alfvn speed , @xmath124 represents the plasma resistivity , and a characteristic length @xmath125 was assumed .
the high lundquist number indicates the possibility to include low-@xmath126 ideal mhd modes @xcite .
the initial pedestal profiles for density @xmath127 and temperature @xmath128 are modelled by @xmath129 for pre - processing of the initial state a reduced grid resolution is used and the nonlinearities associated with the @xmath82 advection and the parallel derivative are shut off , while the profiles are gradually ramped up @xcite .
a random turbulent pseudo - spectrum of density fluctuations with a relative amplitude of @xmath130 was seeded on the background only inside the closed flux surface region . excluding seeding on ( and in the very vicinity of ) the separatrix helps to reduce the onset spurious growth of ion temperature gradient ( itg ) separatrix modes during the further ( full scale ) initial linear growth phase of the simulation .
it was however found to be necessary to additionally pin the initial profiles of ion density and ( thus cutting off neoclassical and parallel sol transport around the separatrix ) during the first stage of the ideal ballooning mode growth phase to completely avoid contamination by such unphysical separatrix itg modes .
as soon as the ballooning instability enters the nonlinear regime and starts to perturb the equilibrium quantities , all profiles are allowed to evolve self - consistently . for this linear growth and nonlinear blow - out phase of the simulation a grid of @xmath131 points in radial ( @xmath132 ) , perpendicular ( @xmath44 ) and parallel ( @xmath55 ) direction
is used . the resolution in @xmath133 down to @xmath134 corresponding to @xmath135 .
the time step is set to @xmath136 , corresponding to @xmath137 .
convergence during the mhd growth phase has been tested by doubling the space and time resolution , with a deviation of less than 5% .
the rapid nonlinear transition from ideal ballooning mode to turbulent transport during a blow - out event has been characterised in ref . @xcite . in the following
the perturbed magnetic field structure of ibm bursts is analysed .
both the changes in the magnetic equilibrium ( i.e. the variation of the @xmath32-profile ) and the magnetic flutter ( i.e. the magnetic perturbations evolving from local current fluctuations ) are considered .
[ fig : plctrsne ] shows the time evolution of the density field @xmath138 of an ibm blow - out in the outboard midplane at various times of the computation , starting from the initial conditions described above . at @xmath139 ( @xmath140 ) in fig .
[ fig : plctrsne ] ( a ) the fluctuations are randomly distributed within the closed flux surface region in the left half space of the ( @xmath141 ) domain .
the ballooning instability starts to grow where the pressure gradient is steepest , around @xmath142 .
the linear growth phase , shown in ( b ) for @xmath143 ( @xmath144 ) , is characterised by periodic density fluctuations with mode number @xmath145 .
it is found that the dominant mode number depends on the pre - defined @xmath32-profile , but for various computations with different initial conditions the mode numbers all were in the range of @xmath146 .
after the peak growth phase nonlinear saturation takes over .
saturation occurs by energy transfer to drift - wave and itg driven turbulence , which has been demonstrated in the fluctuation spectra shown in fig .
6 of ref . @xcite . in ( c ) for @xmath147 ( @xmath148 ) the radial finger - like interchange density perturbations show their most marked appearance . in the turbulent aftermath , shown in ( d ) at @xmath149 ( @xmath150 ) ,
the system transitions into a fully developed turbulent state with a mixed drift wave and itg character .
the mhd mode starts perturbing the profiles at @xmath151 ( @xmath152 ) . the blowout phase ( i.e. the induced erosion of density and temperature profiles ) ends at @xmath153 ( @xmath154 ) and has thus a duration of about @xmath155 . the effect of an ibm burst on the magnetic equilibrium ( @xmath156 ) structure is assessed via the change of the @xmath51-profile according to eq .
[ eq : dq ] . fig .
[ fig : plequil ] shows the temporal evolution of changes in ( a ) safety factor ( @xmath157 ) , and ( b ) magnetic shear ( @xmath158 ) .
significant deviations from the initially prescribed values arise during the blow - out phase and persist in the turbulent aftermath .
the difference between the time dependent @xmath32-profile and the initial profile @xmath159 in ( a ) is in the range @xmath160 .
the nonlinear growth phase is characterised by positive deviations in the central radial domain and negative deviations near both radial boundaries .
in contrast , the turbulent aftermath exhibits positive deviations in the sol and around the separatrix , and negative deviations in the closed field line region .
the @xmath32-profile reflects the shafranov shift : positive deviations from @xmath161 indicate a decreasing , negative deviations an increasing shift .
the deviations of the magnetic shear in ( b ) are in the range @xmath162 . during the blow - out phase ,
the shear deviations are essentially positive in the closed field line region ( except for the inner boundary ) and essentially negative in the sol . in the turbulent aftermath
positive deviations dominate around the separatrix .
the positive shear deviation until @xmath163 is due to the local magnetic shear contribution ( eq .
[ eq : ds ] ) in the initial equilibrium state .
the equilibrium part of magnetic field changes has been determined by the pfirsch - schlter current and the associated axisymmetric @xmath156 toroidal mode number component of the parallel magnetic potential .
the blowout reduces the pfirsch - schlter equilibrium current by about 60% .
another contribution to the dynamical magnetic structure is due to the perpendicular magnetic perturbations resulting from the @xmath164 components of @xmath165 .
the time variation of this magnetic flutter is examined by evaluating eqs .
[ eq : bx ] and [ eq : by ] . figs .
[ fig : plspecbx ] and [ fig : plspecby ] show toroidal mode number spectra obtained from a fourier transform of the magnetic flutter on the outboard midplane ( @xmath166 ) .
the radial magnetic flutter @xmath167 in the @xmath166 plane is shown in fig .
[ fig : plspecbx ] at various times , comparable to the evolution of structures in fig .
[ fig : plctrsne ] .
initially at ( a ) @xmath139 the perturbations extend over a broad spectrum including mode numbers in the range @xmath168 across the seeded confinement region .
the linear growth phase at @xmath143 in ( b ) is dominated by perturbations with mode number @xmath145 . the neighbouring mode with @xmath169
is excited as well .
the transition in ( c ) to nonlinear saturation at @xmath147 involves a radial extension of the radial magnetic flutter , reflecting the formation of interchange fingers far into the sol , and the second harmonic of the dominant mode becomes noticeably excited . in ( d ) the turbulent aftermath at @xmath149 is characterised by nonlinear excitation of multiple modes distributed over a broad range of mode numbers .
these signatures are also visible in the fluctuation spectrum as given in fig . 6 of ref
. @xcite .
the evolution of the magnetic flutter component @xmath170 at @xmath166 , shown in fig .
[ fig : plspecby ] , is similar to that of @xmath171 .
remarkable differences concern the radial distribution of the perturbations during the ( b ) linear growth phase and ( c ) nonlinear blow - out phase , and the excitation of @xmath172 modes during the blow - out phase and the turbulent aftermath in ( d ) . the amplitude of the magnetic flutter increases until the ibm instability saturates .
the magnetic flutter is largest at @xmath173 , where @xmath174 .
the subsequent turbulent mixing involves a decrease of the magnetic perturbation level .
the magnetic flutter in the linear growth phase is also well characterised by the structure of the parallel current and the related parallel magnetic potential .
[ fig : plctrst18 ] shows the fluctuations in the parallel current @xmath175 , the related fluctuations in the parallel magnetic potential @xmath176 , and the resulting magnetic flutter terms @xmath177 and @xmath178 in the outboard midplane during the linear growth phase at @xmath143 .
the distinct periodic structure in @xmath179 , shown in ( a ) , reflects the growth of the @xmath145 density perturbation .
the magnetic potential @xmath180 in ( b ) is coupled to the current through ampre s law .
the resulting structure in both magnetic flutter components in ( c ) and ( d ) explains the radial distribution of the magnetic flutter found in fig .
[ fig : plspecbx ] ( b ) and [ fig : plspecby ] ( b ) .
the periodic structure in the magnetic flutter leads to the question whether the linear growth of the ibm instability involves the formation of magnetic islands at resonant rational flux surfaces . integrating eq .
[ eq : fieldline ] , the magnetic field structure can be visualised in terms of poincar sections . fig . [
fig : plpcsec ] shows poincar sections of the total simulation domain at two simulation times . for each plot , 160 field lines were traced over 4000 toroidal turns .
note that the requirement of a divergence - free magnetic field means that , despite the implemented limiter , the magnetic field lines in the sol are closed .
hence , field lines can be traced over the entire radial simulation domain . in the linear phase at @xmath143 , shown in fig .
[ fig : plpcsec ] ( a ) , the magnetic flux surfaces in the closed - flux - surface region have an essentially laminar structure .
several chains of small scale magnetic islands with island widths @xmath181 do not significantly perturb the flux surfaces . by contrast , applying the field line integration on the sol ( unphysically ) exhibits larger , partly overlapping islands of widths @xmath182 .
the largest islands in the sol occur at rational surfaces with @xmath183 ( i.e. at @xmath184 ) and are thus resonant with the linear ibm instability .
the formation of magnetic islands in the sol during the linear ibm growth phase is actually not physically reasonable .
the computed large amplitudes of islands in the sol are likely an artefact of the local @xmath185 model , which overestimates @xmath186 and the electromagnetic response during the linear growth phase in the sol ( see sec .
[ sec : summary ] for a discussion on that point ) . at the transition to the nonlinear phase at @xmath163 , shown in fig .
[ fig : plpcsec ] ( b ) , most of the magnetic flux surfaces are destroyed and replaced by ergodic field regions .
note that the temporal onset of ergodicity coincides with the formation of finger - like interchange perturbations .
[ fig : plpolavpe ] shows electron pressure contours in the poloidal plane . in the linear phase at @xmath143 , shown in fig .
[ fig : plpolavpe ] ( a ) , the iso - pressure surfaces coincide with the magnetic flux surfaces found in fig . [
fig : plpcsec ] ( a ) . at @xmath163 ,
the remaining laminar magnetic flux surfaces still follow the electron pressure . hence , as long as the pressure fluctuations are small compared to the equilibrium profiles , the magnetic field satisfies the frozen - in condition of ideal mhd .
as soon as nonlinear saturation takes over , resistive effects increase . in order to quantify the time - dependent level of ergodicity
, we evaluated the average radial displacement of a magnetic field line , as defined by eq .
[ eq : raddispl ] .
[ fig : plddr ] shows the time dependent average radial displacement of a magnetic field line after one toroidal turn in units of the drift scale @xmath134 .
the average was formed by tracing 1000 field lines per flux surface .
[ fig : plddr ] ( a ) shows the displacement in dependence on radial coordinate and time . in fig . [ fig : plddr ] ( b ) the average displacement in both closed - flux - surface region and sol is plotted on a logarithmic scale . the linear growth phase is characterized by an exponential increase of the field line displacement . the maximum displacement of @xmath187 coincides with the formation of the finger - like interchange perturbations at @xmath188
well after the elm crash at @xmath189 , the displacement has reduced by 75% with respect to its maximum value . a comparison of the mean radial field line displacement with the poincar sections shown in fig .
[ fig : plpcsec ] shows that the ibm instability causes ergodic field regions if @xmath190 . in the post - elm turbulent phase for @xmath191 a broad spectrum of modes contributes to the magnetic flutter and the threshold for magnetic
ergodicity is lower .
indeed , the elm blow - out induces an enduring ergodicity across the entire computation domain . even at @xmath192 ( @xmath193 after the elm crash ) , where @xmath194 , most of of the magnetic flux surfaces are destroyed .
here , the question arises of whether the ergodicity of the magnetic field is even maintained in a saturated quasi l - mode - like post - elm turbulent state .
as the time scale of an elm crash is much slower than the decrease of the profiles associated with the turbulent transport , the computation of the ibm blow - out was performed without density and heat sources . in the following
we discuss a series of simulations including l - mode - like sources in the equations for density and temperature .
the reduced pedestal density and temperature in an l - mode or post - elm state ( compared to the h - mode transport barrier state ) implies a reduction of the electron dynamical beta and the drift scale , and an increase of the electron collisionality .
accordingly , we first investigated the scaling of the mean radial field line displacement with the free model parameters @xmath28 , @xmath195 , and @xmath196 . in a series of simulations
, we varied @xmath28 , @xmath195 , and @xmath196 parameter - inconsistently , and evaluated @xmath197 for the respective saturated states .
as the sources control the plasma fluctuation level , and consequently the amplitude of the magnetic flutter , the dependence on the magnitude of the source flux was investigated as well .
[ fig : plddrvar ] ( a ) illustrates the scaling of the mean radial field line displacement with the electron dynamical beta @xmath28 , the electron collisionality @xmath195 , the drift parameter @xmath196 , and the source level @xmath198 .
each point in the plot , represents an average over a time interval @xmath199 ( @xmath200 ) .
except for the particular varied parameters and the addition of sources @xmath201 , the nominal parameters @xmath202 , @xmath203 , and @xmath204 correspond to those of the previous ibm case .
the sources comprise a positive flux of density and heat acting near the inner radial boundary .
the variation values of the free model parameters were selected according to their density and temperature dependence ( i.e. @xmath205 , @xmath206 , and @xmath207 ) .
we considered the cases with @xmath208 , @xmath209 and @xmath210 ( parameter set p1 ) , @xmath211 , @xmath212 and @xmath213 ( parameter set p2 ) , and @xmath214 , @xmath215 and @xmath216 ( parameter set p3 ) .
the variation of the plasma parameters shown in fig .
[ fig : plddrvar ] ( a ) shows that @xmath197 decreases by 84% if the electron dynamical beta is decreased from @xmath217 to @xmath218 . on the other hand , a decrease of the drift scale from @xmath219 to @xmath220 results in a increase of @xmath197 by 9% .
the increase of the collisionality from @xmath221 to @xmath222 involves an insignificant decrease of @xmath197 by 1% . finally , a reduction of the source flux from @xmath210 to @xmath216 results in an decrease of @xmath197 by 59% .
the above results indicate that the level of magnetic ergodicity is strongly influenced by the values of the local plasma parameters , especially by the plasma beta and the source level . a trend to lower ergodicity when going to l - mode - like values
is indicated . in order to verify this trend in parameter - consistent simulations , we computed the mean radial field line displacement for parameter - consistent , saturated l - mode - like states characterized by the parameter sets p1 , p2 , and p3 . fig .
[ fig : plddrvar ] ( b ) shows that @xmath197 decreases by 88% if the reference values for density and temperature
are parameter - consistently reduced to @xmath214 and @xmath215 and the source level is lowered from @xmath210 to @xmath216 .
considering the poincar plots of the saturated state characterized by the parameter set p3 , we find a slightly ergodized magnetic field .
thus , even l - mode - like turbulence can cause an ergodisation of the magnetic field .
note that this ergodicity is dynamically evolving with the turbulence .
as the ibm blow - out involves a distinct ergodicity of the magnetic field , an increased magnetic transport of density and heat may be expected . in order to compare the magnetic transport ( superscript @xmath223 ) with the @xmath82 advective transport ( superscript @xmath224 ) ,
the ion density transport @xmath225 and the electron heat transport @xmath226 are analysed .
the motivation for considering @xmath225 instead of @xmath227 is that the bulk of mass is transported by the ions . on the other hand
, the higher mobility of the electrons implies that @xmath228 , so that only @xmath226 is of interest .
[ fig : pldgdw ] shows the volume averaged transport quantities @xmath229 , @xmath230 , @xmath231 and @xmath232 for both closed - flux - surface region and sol . the ion density transport shown in ( a ) and ( b ) is clearly dominated by @xmath82 advection .
the ratio between magnetic transport and @xmath82 transport is less than @xmath233 , and the only relevant magnetic contributions are restricted to the time interval @xmath234 around and shortly after the peak ibm mode phase .
in contrast , the electron heat transport shown in ( c ) and ( d ) exhibits a significant magnetic component . in the closed - flux - surface region after the peak ibm mode phase for times @xmath235 , the ratio between average magnetic and advective electron heat transport is between the values @xmath236 .
the magnetic transport in the sol is by approximately one order of magnitude smaller than in the closed - flux - surface region so that the ratio @xmath237 has values around @xmath238 in the sol . in the case of a saturated l - mode - state based on plasma parameters which reflect post - elm conditions ( reduced plasma beta and drift parameter , increased electron collisionality )
, the magnetic transport of electron heat is , on average , by two orders of magnitude lower than the @xmath82 advective transport .
likewise , the magnetic density transport is by three orders of magnitude smaller then the @xmath82 transport .
thus , the only regime where the magnetic transport substantially contributes to the total transport , is the peak ibm mode phase and the following transition to a turbulent state at times @xmath239 . the time - dependent total elm energy loss , quantified by the loss fraction of the equilibrium pedestal energy @xmath240 , is shown in fig . [ fig : plwped ] .
at @xmath241 , which can be considered as the end of the elm crash , the energy loss amounts to about 42% . at that time , the average pedestal density of both electrons and ions has dropped by 41% with respect to the initial equilibrium state .
the electron temperature at @xmath241 has decreased by half and the ion temperature by a third . as the advective transport of electron and ion heat is nearly equal in magnitude , the larger decrease of the electron temperature compared to the ion temperature
can be ascribed to the additional magnetic transport which is negligibly small for the ions .
the magnetic field structure associated with edge localised ideal ballooning mode ( ibm ) bursts was investigated computationally using the nonlinear gyrofluid electromagnetic model gemr .
the simulation setup was geared to exemplary asdex upgrade h - mode conditions .
both the ibm induced changes in the magnetic equilibrium and the magnetic flutter due to local plasma fluctuations were investigated .
the formation of magnetic islands and ergodic magnetic field regions was visualized by poincar sections . in order to discuss the level of magnetic ergodicity associated with the ibm blow - out and the subsequent turbulent aftermath ,
the average radial displacement of a magnetic field line was evaluated .
the level of ergodicity was investigated for several saturated turbulent states in which the electron dynamical beta , the electron collisionality , the drift scale and the magnitude of the source flux were varied .
furthermore , the mean radial field line displacement was evaluated for parameter - consistent , saturated l - mode - like states .
finally , the volume averaged magnetic transport of ion density and electron heat was compared to the corresponding @xmath82 transport and the total elm energy loss was discussed .
the main results can be summarized as follows : 1 .
the ibm induced changes in the safety factor profile amount up to 1% of the initially prescribed value @xmath161 ( @xmath242 ) . due to the spatial variation of the safety factor profile ( short - scale transitions from negative to positive deviations ) and the additional local shear piece resulting from the shafranov shift , the corresponding changes in the magnetic shear amount up to 100% of the initially prescribed value @xmath243 ( @xmath244 ) .
the time - dependent toroidal mode number spectra of both perpendicular magnetic flutter components reflect the evolution of the initially dominant @xmath145 mode .
the different spatial variation of the magnetic flutter components is due to the structure in the pressure fluctuations and the related current fluctuations .
the magnitude of the magnetic flutter increases until the ibm instability nonlinearly saturates ( @xmath245 ) .
3 . the linear growth of the ibm instability involves the formation of small scale magnetic islands in the closed - flux - surface region ( @xmath181 ) .
the laminar structure of the magnetic surfaces in the closed - flux - surface region is not significantly perturbed .
the formation of resonant magnetic islands in the sol can be ascribed to the use of a local @xmath185 model , which implies that the electromagnetic response in the sol during the linear growth phase is highly overestimated .
ergodic magnetic field regions form near the end of the linear phase when the ibm instability starts to perturb the equilibrium profiles .
the level of magnetic ergodicity ( measured by the average radial field line displacement ) increases until the ibm instability saturates .
the turbulent aftermath of the burst results in an enduring ergodicity across the simulation domain
. 6 . even in a saturated turbulent l - mode - like post - elm state
the magnetic field remains ergodized .
however , the level of ergodicity decreases if the plasma parameters are adjusted to the reduced post - elm profiles .
the ibm induced magnetic transport of ion density can be neglected in comparison to the corresponding @xmath82 transport . by contrast , the magnetic transport of electron heat can amount up to 80% of the corresponding @xmath82 transport .
the magnetic transport of electron heat is significant during the blow - out phase and the subsequent transition to a turbulent state . in a saturated l - mode - like post elm state
the magnetic contribution to the electron heat transport is negligibly small .
the total pedestal energy loss of the ibm burst amounts to about 40% of the equilibrium pedestal energy .
considering these points we can conclude that the ideal ballooning elm scenario involves an enduring ergodisation of the entire edge region .
moreover , the l - mode like post - elm state is also characterized by a non vanishing degree of magnetic ergodicity . for correct interpretation of the results we have to discuss several limitations of the present local ( `` @xmath185 '' ) turbulence model .
the code gemr evolves the profiles as part of the dependent variables but the derivation of the model equations is based on local parameters .
the discrepancy between radially varying profiles and inconsistent local plasma parameters increases with the distance from the flux surface for which the plasma parameters were defined .
this implies that especially in the sol the deviation from the consistent plasma parameters is large . for the simulations presented in this work
this means that the plasma beta is unrealistically high when considering the range around the separatrix and the sol .
hence , the electromagnetic response and , in particular , the magnetic flutter are overestimated in the sol . especially during the linear growth phase of the ibm instability , where the profiles in the sol are close to zero
, the plasma beta in the sol is highly overestimated as self - consistent values would be close to zero .
the formation of resonant magnetic islands and ergodic field regions in the sol during the linear growth phase can be ascribed to this model inconsistency .
the discrepancy between profiles and plasma parameters also concerns the transition from the peak ibm blow - out phase resulting from h - mode - like plasma parameters to an l - mode - like turbulent post - elm state which is characterized by a decreased plasma beta .
we have shown that the mean radial field line displacement decreases up to one order of magnitude if the nominal simulation parameters are changed to describe a saturated l - mode - like post - elm state .
our results that the magnetic heat transport during the elm crash and the subsequent turbulent state is always smaller than the heat transport by @xmath82 advection seems to disagree with the fact that the magnetic field is ergodized at all times during and after the elm blow - out .
this apparent contradiction can be solved by comparing the radial @xmath82 velocity with the radial velocity associated with the motion of an electron along a perturbed magnetic field line .
considering the mean radial field line displacement after one toroidal turn and assuming an electron moving with thermal velocity , we find that the average radial velocity associated with the magnetic flutter during and after the peak blow - out phase is about one order of magnitude smaller than the radial @xmath82 velocity .
hence , the magnetic fraction of the electron heat transport can be small although the magnetic field is ergodised .
the point is that the magnetic flutter and the resulting ergodicity is continuously changing with time such that an electron within one simulation time step sees only a fraction of the magnetic snapshot visualized in a poincar plot .
thus , an ergodic region in a poincar plot is not necessarily indicative of a dominant magnetic transport .
the elm induced ergodicity of the magnetic field was earlier investigated by mhd simulations @xcite . while mhd models more readily allow for the implementation of a realistic x - point - geometry , the present gyrofluid simulations ( including turbulent scales ) are based on a simplified circular geometry .
still , the present results regarding the elm induced formation of an ergodic edge region as well as the associated magnetic transport are in qualitative agreement with mhd results . in the present gemr modelling
the major novel results concern the small - scale dominated turbulent aftermath immediately following the ibm burst .
we thank t.t . ribeiro for valuable discussions on the model , code and results , and f.p .
gennrich for routines for preparation of the initial state .
this work was partly supported by the austrian science fund ( fwf ) y398 ; by the austrian ministry of science bmwf as part of the uniinfrastrukturprogramm of the forschungsplattform scientific computing at lfu innsbruck ; and by the european commission under the contract of association between euratom and aw carried out within the framework of the european fusion development agreement ( efda ) .
the views and opinions expressed herein do not necessarily reflect those of the european commission . | the magnetic field structure associated with edge localised ideal ballooning mode ( elm ) bursts is analysed by nonlinear gyrofluid computation .
the linear growth phase is characterised by the formation of small scale magnetic islands .
ergodic magnetic field regions develop near the end of the linear phase when the instability starts to perturb the equilibrium profiles .
the nonlinear blow - out gives rise to an ergodisation of the entire edge region .
the time - dependent level of ergodicity is determined in terms of the mean radial displacement of a magnetic field line .
the ergodicity decreases again during the nonlinear turbulent phase of the blow - out in dependence on the degrading plasma beta in the collapsing plasma pedestal profile . |
in this section , we explain how we check equilibration in our monte carlo ( mc ) simulations .
since our simulations are performed at very low temperatures , an appropriate check of equilibration is crucially important .
the standard check might be to monitor the stability of various observables as a function of mc time for successively longer observation times , which we do perform .
in addition to this standard test , we also perform the following procedure for an additional check of equilibration . .
, width=302 ] as mentioned in the main text , we take our data based on the combination of the heat - bath ( hb ) method and the over - relaxation method .
( the temperature - exchange technique often useful in , _
e.g. _ , spin - glass problems , is not very efficient here at such low temperatures . ) to be sure that our data are fully thermalized , we also take the data of the same physical quantities based on the so - called wang - landau method @xcite and check whether the data taken by the two different methods agree within the errors .
note that the wang - landau method directly computes the density of states , and the temperature comes into physical quantities in a way very different from the heat - bath ( + over - relaxation ) method .
thus , the agreement of the datasets taken by these two different methods should yield a stringent test of equilibration . in fig.5
, we show the temperature dependence of the specific heat for the case of @xmath28 calculated either by the heat - bath ( + over - relaxation ) method or by the wang - landau method for the sizes @xmath82 and 24 . as can be seen from the figure , the two kinds of datasets agree completely , demonstrating that our data are a fully thermalized even at the lowest temperature studied . for larger sizes ,
the wang - landau method is very much time - consuming , and we are unable to obtain the data for larger sizes . yet , even for smaller sizes of @xmath82 and 24 shown here , the existence of the growing specific - heat peak is already clear , demonstrating the occurrence of an equilibrium phase transition at this very low temperature .
in this section , we show how the chiral domain walls are thermally generated in our model both above and below @xmath35 . in fig.6 , we give typical snapshots of the chiral domain - wall configurations below @xmath35 , @xmath83 [ left figure ] and above @xmath35 , @xmath84 [ upper figure ] for a system of the distortion parameter @xmath28 where @xmath85 .
free boundary conditions ( bc ) are applied here , because in general incommensurate cases periodic bc applied to finite lattices force the system to introduce a pair of chiral domain walls which are extended in the perpendicular direction . by contrast , no such constraint exists in free bc which we adopt here .
chiral domain walls , defined at a lattice point @xmath64 connecting two bonds ( @xmath86 ) and ( @xmath87 ) in line in the manner as explained in the main text , are depicted in the figure as blue segments perpendicular the bond and passing the site @xmath64 . , @xmath83 [ upper figure ] , and above @xmath35 , @xmath84 [ lower figure ] .
the distortion parameter is @xmath28 .
free bc are applied for a system of linear size @xmath43 .
, title="fig:",width=302 ] , @xmath83 [ upper figure ] , and above @xmath35 , @xmath84 [ lower figure ] .
the distortion parameter is @xmath28 .
free bc are applied for a system of linear size @xmath43 .
, title="fig:",width=302 ] chiral domain walls may be classified into two types : an extended wall spanning the entire lattice from one end to the other perpendicular to the @xmath12-bond direction and a closed - loop wall .
note that a closed - loop wall costs a small but nonzero energy , while a perfectly straight - line wall perpendicular to the @xmath12-bond direction costs no energy ( zero mode ) owing to the large degeneracy of the ground state of the @xmath88 kagome heisenberg model . as can be seen from the figure ,
both types of chiral domain walls are present below and above @xmath35 , whereas their number density increases rapidly as the temperature is increased across @xmath35 .
as can be seen from the upper figure , an extended wall running along the perpendicular direction seems to persist in small number even below @xmath35 ( note that free bc are applied here so that the observed chiral domain wall is not the one forced by periodic bc ) .
it may be no wonder that extended walls remain in small number even at low temperatures , since they are zero - energy modes so long as they run straight along the perpendicular direction .
in this section , we explain some of the basic properties of the @xmath61 vortex , together with the way how we identify the spatial position of the @xmath61 vortex ( more precisely , the position of its core ) in our simulations .
the @xmath61 vortex is a topologically stable point defect inherent to two - dimensional frustrated heisenberg systems with the noncollinear spin order .
it possesses a parity - like @xmath61 ( @xmath89 ) topological quantum number depending on whether there is a vortex or no vortex . as such ,
a winding number , familiar as a good topological quantum number characterizing the standard vortex , is not a good topological quantum number here .
the properties of the @xmath61 vortices were discussed in some detail in ref.[2 ] in the context of the classical heisenberg antiferromagnet ( af ) on the triangular - lattice with the nearest - neighbor coupling .
the @xmath61 vortex might be regarded as a vortex formed by the chirality vector .
it was suggested in refs.@xcite that the triangular heisenberg af might exhibit a thermodynamic phase transition at a finite temperature driven by the binding - unbinding of the @xmath61 vortices , keeping the standard spin correlation length to be finite . in the previous studies , as an order parameter characterizing the @xmath61-vortex transition , either a wilson - loop ( a vorticity function ) @xcite or a vorticity modulus @xcite has been proposed .
the vorticity modulus @xmath90 might be defined as the total free - energy cost against a vortex formation @xmath91 divided by @xmath92 , @xmath93 . in the triangular - lattice heisenberg af in its thermodynamic limit
, @xmath90 should become zero in the high - temperature phase where there exist free vortices , while @xmath90 should take a nonzero value in the low - temperature phase where all vortices are paired with no free vortices . in case of our kagome model
, the existence of the chiral domain - wall excitations would modify the nature of the vortex transition as we shall see in the next section . in our simulations on a ( distorted ) kagome heisenberg af , we monitor the spatial position of the @xmath61 vortex following the procedures of ref.@xcite .
the triangular lattice consists of three interpenetrating triangular sublattices , and one might take an elementary plaquette a minimum upward triangle consisting of the three sublattice sites . at low temperatures ,
the local spin structure at each plaquette is approximately a @xmath94-degrees structure . in ref.@xcite , an @xmath95 local ` frame '
was assigned to each such elementary plaquette , and a @xmath61 vortex is identified for every minimum triangular loop consisting of three such plaquettes .
we modify such a procedure of the local vortex identification to our kagome system .
first , an elementary plaquette is taken again as a minimum upward triangle consisting of three spins , which coincides with a crystallographic unit cell of the kagome lattice .
the lattice formed by these elementary plaquettes also forms the triangular super - lattice consisting of the three triangular sublattices a , b and c. the spin structure here is an incommensurate spiral state close to the @xmath5 state , as demonstrated in the main text . in the perfect @xmath5 state ,
the 120-degrees structure on an elementary plaquette would exhibit a uniform arrangement on each sublattice a , b and c. in view of this , we assign our local ` frame ' to an elementary plaquette on one of these three sublattices , say , on a , and identify an elementary @xmath61 vortex for every minimum triangular loop consisting of three such plaquettes of the sublattice a. while the true spin structure generally deviates from the @xmath5 structure , this deviation hardly affects the definition of the @xmath61 vorticity since only the topological character matters in the definition . in computing the spatial distribution of the @xmath61 vortices in the following section
, we use this definition of the local @xmath61 vorticity .
vortices for the two kinds of sites , the site attached to the chiral domain wall and the site away from the chiral domain wall .
the distortion parameter is @xmath28 , periodic bc being applied .
the inset represents the temperature dependence of the number density of the @xmath61 vortices for the two kinds of chiral domain - wall sites , the site attached to an extended , system - spanning wall , and the site attached to a closed - loop wall .
the arrow indicates the transition point .
, width=340 ]
in this section , we explain the manner how the @xmath61 vortices and the chiral domain walls interact with each other both above and below @xmath35 . in fig.7 , we show the temperature dependence of the number density ( or the appearance probability ) of @xmath61 vortices , @xmath96 , for the two kinds of sites , the site attached to the chiral domain wall and the site away from the chiral domain wall . the distortion parameter is set @xmath28 .
as can immediately be seen from the figure , the sites attached to the chiral domain wall allow higher density of @xmath61 vortices .
namely , the @xmath61 vortices are generated primarily at or near the chiral domain walls .
it means that there exists an effective _ attractive _ interaction between the @xmath61 vortices and the chiral domain walls .
the inset represents the temperature dependence of the number density of @xmath61 vortices for the two kinds of chiral domain - wall sites , the site attached to an _ extended _ , system - spanning domain wall and the site attached to a _ closed - loop _ wall .
one can see from the inset that at lower temperatures an extended chiral domain wall accommodates a @xmath61 vortex preferably .
-vortex configurations both below @xmath35 , @xmath83 [ top and middle figures ] , and above @xmath35 , @xmath84 [ bottom figure ] , depicted by black dots .
chiral domain wall are also shown by blue lines .
the distortion parameter is @xmath28 , periodic bc being applied .
all figures are parts of the @xmath43 lattice .
the top figure is a part of the lattice containing an extended chiral domain wall , whereas the middle figure is another part of the same lattice not containing an extended chiral domain wall , _ i.e. _ , containing closed loops only .
below @xmath35 , while an extended wall allows isolated , apparently free @xmath61 vortices , @xmath61 vortices appear always in bound pairs at closed - loop wall sites .
, title="fig:",width=279 ] -vortex configurations both below @xmath35 , @xmath83 [ top and middle figures ] , and above @xmath35 , @xmath84 [ bottom figure ] , depicted by black dots .
chiral domain wall are also shown by blue lines .
the distortion parameter is @xmath28 , periodic bc being applied .
all figures are parts of the @xmath43 lattice .
the top figure is a part of the lattice containing an extended chiral domain wall , whereas the middle figure is another part of the same lattice not containing an extended chiral domain wall , _ i.e. _ , containing closed loops only .
below @xmath35 , while an extended wall allows isolated , apparently free @xmath61 vortices , @xmath61 vortices appear always in bound pairs at closed - loop wall sites .
, title="fig:",width=279 ] -vortex configurations both below @xmath35 , @xmath83 [ top and middle figures ] , and above @xmath35 , @xmath84 [ bottom figure ] , depicted by black dots .
chiral domain wall are also shown by blue lines .
the distortion parameter is @xmath28 , periodic bc being applied .
all figures are parts of the @xmath43 lattice .
the top figure is a part of the lattice containing an extended chiral domain wall , whereas the middle figure is another part of the same lattice not containing an extended chiral domain wall , _ i.e. _ , containing closed loops only .
below @xmath35 , while an extended wall allows isolated , apparently free @xmath61 vortices , @xmath61 vortices appear always in bound pairs at closed - loop wall sites .
, title="fig:",width=279 ] we note that the existence of an effective attractive interaction acting between the chiral domain walls and the @xmath61 vortices might provide a possible explanation of the observed first - order transition .
as the temperatures is increased , both the chiral domain walls and the @xmath61 vortices tend to be thermally excited .
if there is a strong attractive interaction between these two topological excitations as we have demonstrated above , one would expect a positive feed - back effect operative in their thermal generation : _ i.e. _ , the generation of one induces the generation of the other .
thus , the observed first - order transition might be a consequence of such _ cooperative _ thermal generation of the chiral domain walls and the @xmath61 vortices . in fig.8 , we show snapshots of the @xmath61-vortex configurations both below @xmath35 , @xmath83 [ top and middle figures ] , and above @xmath35 , @xmath84 [ bottom figure ] , together with the corresponding chiral domain - wall configurations .
the distortion parameter is set @xmath28 .
all figures are parts of the @xmath43 lattice .
the top and the middle figures represent different parts of the same lattice measured at exactly the same mc time .
the top figure is a part of the lattice containing an extended chiral domain wall , whereas the middle figure is a part not containing an extended chiral domain wall , _ i.e. _ , a part containing closed - loop walls only .
as can be seen from the top figure , an extended wall allows isolated , apparently free @xmath61 vortices even below @xmath35 in addition to @xmath61-vortex pairs , whereas closed - loop walls bear only @xmath61-vortex pairs below @xmath35 . above @xmath35 ,
as can seen from the bottom figure , free vortices are generated not only at extended - wall sites but also at closed - loop wall sites , whereas the number of @xmath61 vortices becomes large and the distinction between free vortices and vortex - pairs become somewhat obscure here .
f. wang and d.p .
landau , phys .
lett . * 86 * , 2050 ( 2001 ) .
h. kawamura and s. miyashita , j. phys .
54 * 4530 ( 1985 ) .
h. kawamura , a.yamamoto , and t. okubo , j. phys .
. jpn . * 79 * , 023701 ( 2010 ) .
h. kawamura and m. kikuchi , phys . rev . b*47 * , 1134 ( 1993 ) . | motivated by the recent experiment on kagome - lattice antiferromagnets , we study the zero - field ordering behavior of the antiferromagnetic classical heisenberg model on a uniaxially distorted kagome lattice by monte carlo simulations . a first - order transition , which has no counterpart in the corresponding undistorted model , takes place at a very low temperature .
origin of the transition is ascribed to a cooperative proliferation of topological excitations inherent to the model .
renewed interest has recently been paid to novel ordering properties of geometrically frustrated magnets @xcite .
two - dimensional ( 2d ) kagome lattice , a corner - sharing network of regular triangles , is a typical example of such geometrically frustrated lattices .
many theoretical works have been performed to elucidate the ordering of the antiferromagnetic ( af ) heisenberg model on this lattice for both cases of quantum @xmath0 @xcite and classical @xmath1 @xcite spins . in the quantum @xmath0 case , although there seems to be a consensus among researchers that the ground state of the model lacks in the conventional af long - range order , there still exists a considerable diversity in the view about the nature of its ground state @xcite . in the classical @xmath1 case ,
any combination of the local 120-degrees spin structure on a constituent triangle is allowed as its ground state , leading to the massive degeneracy .
the effect of `` order from disorder '' is operative at low temperatures , which favors at the harmonic level the coplanar states , or the spin nematic states , where all spins are contained on a common plane in the spin space @xcite .
yet , the coplanar ground states themselves are heavily degenerate , the degeneracy of @xmath2 ( @xmath3 the number of spins ) . in order to determine which coplanar state is realized in the @xmath4 limit , nonlinear excitations beyond the harmonic level need to be invoked .
the model selects among them the so - called @xmath5 state @xcite .
experimentally , there have been few realizations of heisenberg kagome afs . only recently ,
several possible realizations of @xmath0 heisenberg kagome afs were reported , _
e.g. _ , herbertsmithite @xcite , volborthite @xcite and vesigniete @xcite .
volborthite cu@xmath6v@xmath7o@xmath8(oh)@xmath92h@xmath7o and vesigniete bacu@xmath6v@xmath7o@xmath10(oh)@xmath7 are structurally distorted from the perfect kagome lattice in a uniaxial manner where the regular triangle is distorted to isosceles triangles .
this structural distortion gives rise to two distinct exchange couplings , @xmath11 and @xmath12 , as demonstrated in the inset of fig.1(b ) , where the extent of the distortion may be represented by the parameter @xmath13 .
whether @xmath14 is greater or smaller than unity in volborthite has not fully been determined experimentally , though the bond distance seems to favor @xmath15 @xcite .
an interesting recent experimental finding is that this compound exhibits a thermodynamic phase transition at @xmath16k , with a slowly fluctuating ordered state @xcite . under such circumstances ,
it remains most interesting to clarify what type of ordering behavior is expected in the kagome heisenberg af _ under uniaxial distortion_. in the present paper , we address this issue for the classical model in zero field .
in particular , we wish to clarify what type of spin structure is chosen in the @xmath4 limit , and whether a finite - temperature transition is ever possible .
only a few theoretical works have been made on the af classical heisenberg model on the distorted kagome lattice in the past . y.b .
kim _
et al _ studied the model by an effective `` chirality '' hamiltonian approach , and suggested that the so - called `` chirality - stripe '' state might be selected in the low - temperature limit @xcite .
kaneko _
et al _ studied the in - field properties of the model by monte carlo ( mc ) simulations , and observed a field - induced phase transition with a weak ( zero)-field state being the @xmath17 state @xcite .
in the present paper , we study the zero - field ordering properties of the model by means of extensive mc simulations , paying particular attention to the low - temperature regime which was not examined in previous works .
surprisingly , we find a clear first - order transition , which has no counterpart in the undistorted model , in the extremely low - temperature regime .
the model we consider is the classical af heisenberg model on a uniaxially distorted kagome lattice with two distinct af nearest - neighbor couplings @xmath11 and @xmath18 as shown in the inset of fig.1(b ) .
the hamiltonian is given by @xmath19 in the undistorted case @xmath20 , the ground - state of a single triangle is the 120-degrees spin structure , whereas , in the distorted case @xmath21 , it is distorted such that a spin - canting angle at the @xmath11-bond becomes @xmath22 .
the ground state of the distorted model is highly degenerate in that any combination of the local ground state on a triangle yields a ground state of the entire lattice @xcite .
order from disorder effect due to harmonic excitations then selects coplanar states as in the undistorted case .
the coplanar states are still heavily degenerate , but the amount of degeneracy is much reduced from that in the undistorted case , from the extensive number of @xmath2 to the subextensive number of @xmath23 ( @xmath24 the linear dimension ) @xcite .
it should be noticed that the @xmath5 state , which is the @xmath4 state of the undistorted model , can not be a ground state of the distorted model any more . in order to determine which state is favored in the @xmath4 limit in the distorted model , we perform an extensive mc simulation at low temperatures .
our mc simulation is a combination of the heat - bath and the over - relaxation methods .
a unit mc sweep consists of single heat - bath sweep and subsequent 10 over - relaxation sweeps .
various lattice sizes are studied up to @xmath25 with total @xmath26 spins .
we generate @xmath27 mc steps per spin ( mcs ) at each temperature , both cooling and warming runs being made . for our check of equilibration , see the online supplemental material @xcite .
we apply several types of boundary conditions ( bc ) , including periodic , free , `` fixed '' and `` vortex '' boundaries ( to be explained below ) .
most extensive calculations are performed for @xmath28 , while other values of @xmath15 are also studied . under periodic bc , either calculated from the energy fluctuation or from the temperature difference of the energy .
in the inset , the data for @xmath29 are compared with the corresponding data of the undistorted model @xmath20 in a wider temperature range .
( b ) the temperature dependence of the energy of the distorted model of @xmath28 for @xmath25 both for the cooling and warming runs .
the inset illustrates a distorted kagome lattice .
, title="fig:",width=302 ] under periodic bc , either calculated from the energy fluctuation or from the temperature difference of the energy . in the inset ,
the data for @xmath29 are compared with the corresponding data of the undistorted model @xmath20 in a wider temperature range .
( b ) the temperature dependence of the energy of the distorted model of @xmath28 for @xmath25 both for the cooling and warming runs .
the inset illustrates a distorted kagome lattice .
, title="fig:",width=302 ] in fig.1(a ) , we show the temperature dependence of the specific heat for the cooling runs for the case of @xmath28 . in the inset ,
the data are compared with those of the undistorted model @xmath20 .
a sharp peak absent in the undistorted case appears , growing rapidly with @xmath24 .
the data turn out to be reversible for smaller sizes of @xmath30 , while a weak hysteresis is observed for larger sizes of @xmath31 . in fig.1(b ) , we show the temperature dependence of the energy for @xmath25 , where a clear hysteresis is observed in the transition region signaling the first - order nature of the transition .
this is consistent with the sharp peak of the specific heat growing rapidly with @xmath24 .
the first - order transition is extremely weak in that the latent heat is only @xmath32 ( in units of @xmath11 ) .
it is remarkable that such a small energy scale is generated in the model which has only @xmath33 energy scale
. a closer look of the data reveales that the specific heat exhibits , in addition to the sharp main peak , additional small peaks ( or weak structures ) at @xmath24-dependent temperatures .
these small peaks are associated with a discontinuous shift of the @xmath34-value characterizing an incommensurate spiral in finite systems under periodic bc , and are expected to vanish in the thermodynamic limit : see below . )
plane of the distorted model of @xmath28 at a temperature below @xmath35 , @xmath36 .
outer ( inner ) hexagon represents the first brillouin zone of the triangular lattice of a lattice constant @xmath37 ( @xmath38 ) .
main panel plots @xmath39 versus @xmath40 in the vicinity of the @xmath41 point @xmath42 for several temperatures across @xmath35 .
the lattice size is @xmath43 with free bc .
the vertical dotted lines represent the @xmath41-point wavevector ( right ) and the incommensurate wavevector at @xmath44 ( left ) .
( b ) the temperature and size dependence of the nematic order parameter of the distorted model of @xmath28 under periodic bc . in the inset ,
the @xmath29 data are compared with the corresponding data of the undistorted model of @xmath20 .
, title="fig:",width=302 ] ) plane of the distorted model of @xmath28 at a temperature below @xmath35 , @xmath36 .
outer ( inner ) hexagon represents the first brillouin zone of the triangular lattice of a lattice constant @xmath37 ( @xmath38 ) .
main panel plots @xmath39 versus @xmath40 in the vicinity of the @xmath41 point @xmath42 for several temperatures across @xmath35 .
the lattice size is @xmath43 with free bc .
the vertical dotted lines represent the @xmath41-point wavevector ( right ) and the incommensurate wavevector at @xmath44 ( left ) .
( b ) the temperature and size dependence of the nematic order parameter of the distorted model of @xmath28 under periodic bc . in the inset , the @xmath29 data are compared with the corresponding data of the undistorted model of @xmath20 .
, title="fig:",width=302 ] the inset of fig.2(a ) exhibits the spin structure factor @xmath45 in the @xmath46 plane calculated at a temperature below the bulk trnasition temperature @xmath47 , where @xmath34 is measured in units of @xmath48 ( @xmath37 the nearest - neighbor distance of the kagome lattice ) .
the strongest intensity appears at a wavevector along the @xmath12-bond direction slightly off the @xmath41 point , corresponding to an incommensurate spiral state .
the observed peak has only a finite width reflecting a finite spin correlation length of the 2d heisenberg model at finite @xmath49 .
such an incommensurate spiral state is certainly a ground state of the distorted model , which reduces to the @xmath5 state in the undistorted limit @xmath50 . in the main panel of fig.2(a ) , we plot @xmath39 versus @xmath40 in the vicinity of the main peak for several temperatures across @xmath35 .
free bc are applied here in order to minimize the finite - size effect associated with the incommensurability .
as one approaches @xmath35 , the peak position gradually shifts from the @xmath41 point to an incommensurate position .
this shift of the peak position is observed already above @xmath35 for larger @xmath24 .
when one applies periodic bc , the ensuing discretization of @xmath34 in units of @xmath51 often hampers the observation of such a shift for small @xmath24 .
this might explain the reason why the peak was located just at the @xmath41 point in the simulation of ref.@xcite .
for relatively large but finite @xmath24 , such a discretization effect of the periodic bc causes , with varying the temperature , a sudden jump in the @xmath34-value . in any case , the low - temperature state of the model turns out to be an incommensurate spiral state , distinct from the chiral - spiral state inferred in ref.@xcite , or from the @xmath5 state suggested in ref.@xcite . under periodic bc .
inset exhibits a typical chiral - wall configuration .
the symbols represent the upward and downward chirality vectors .
( b ) the temperature and the size dependence of the vortex energy @xmath52 ( the vortex free energy @xmath53 ) in the main panel ( in the inset ) .
, title="fig:",width=302 ] under periodic bc .
inset exhibits a typical chiral - wall configuration .
the symbols represent the upward and downward chirality vectors .
( b ) the temperature and the size dependence of the vortex energy @xmath52 ( the vortex free energy @xmath53 ) in the main panel ( in the inset ) .
, title="fig:",width=302 ] in fig.2(b ) , we show the temperature dependence of the nematic order parameter @xmath54 representing the extent of the spin coplanarity @xmath55 where @xmath56 is the number of upward triangles and the vector chirality @xmath57 at each upward triangle @xmath58 is given by @xmath59 where three spins @xmath60 are arranged in a counter - clockwise manner on a triangle . in any 2d heisenberg model ,
the nematic order parameter should vanish at any finite @xmath49 in the thermodynamic limit .
yet , it gives a measure of the nematic short - range order ( sro ) .
as can be seen from fig.2(b ) , the nematic order or the spin coplanarity sets in almost simultaneously with the first - order transition for the case of @xmath28 .
additional step - wise structures of the data are due to the jump in the @xmath34-value associated with the incommensurability effect in finite systems under periodic bc mentioned above .
this onset of the nematic sro occurs at a temperature significantly lower than that of the undistorted model : see the inset
. establishing the existence of a first - order transition , we further examine what is responsible for this transition . for this purpose , we study the behavior of two types of topological excitations inherent to the model .
one is a _ chiral - domain wall _ , and the other is a _
@xmath61 vortex_. the chiral domain wall is a wall - like excitation , which might be obtained by connecting the reversal points of the vector chirality .
it is a zero - mode arising from the coplanar nature of the low-@xmath49 spin state . in the present distorted model ,
the chiral wall becomes a zero - mode only for a straight - line wall of system size @xmath24 running perpendicular to the @xmath12-bond direction , in sharp contrast to the undistorted case where chiral walls of various sizes and shapes are possible including closed loops .
fig.3(a ) exhibits the temperature dependence of the total number density of chiral walls .
here we assign the vector chirality at each nearest - neighbor bond ( @xmath62 ) along the @xmath12-bond direction as @xmath63 , and suppose that a lattice site @xmath64 is included in the chiral wall when the condition @xmath65 is met .
as the temperature is lowered across @xmath35 , the number of chiral walls diminishes rapidly .
typical snapshots of the chiral wall configurations are given in the online supplemental material @xcite .
we also study the behavior of another topological excitation , @xmath61 vortex @xcite , a point defect inherent to the frustrated 2d heisenberg model with the noncollinear spin order @xcite . for this purpose ,
we introduce two different bc : one is the fixed bc where we fix the boundary spins so that they match the expected ground - state spin configuration of an incommensurate spiral lying on the ( @xmath66 ) plane .
the other is the `` vortex '' bc where the boundary spins are fixed in the manner to accommodate a single vortex on top of the fixed - bc spin configuration , _
i.e. _ , a spin rotation of @xmath67 around the @xmath68-axis is applied to the boundary spins @xcite .
then , we calculate the energy difference @xmath52 between the total energies of the fixed and the vortex bc , together with the total free - energy difference @xmath53 evaluated by integrating @xmath52 with respect to @xmath49 @xcite .
fig.3(b ) exhibits @xmath52 calculated in this way .
a sharp peak is observed just at @xmath35 , indicating that a strong anomaly occurs at @xmath35 in the vortex sector .
the calculated free - energy difference @xmath53 is shown in the inset , which indicates that the vortex tends to stiffen below @xmath35 .
thus , the transition turns out to accompany a significant change in the state of topological excitations , _
i.e. _ , accompany a proliferation ( or a rapid increase in number ) of both chiral walls and @xmath61 vortices .
indeed , as demonstrated in the online supplemental material @xcite , there is an effective _ attractive _ interaction acting between the chiral domain walls and the @xmath61 vortices , which might cause a cooperative thermal generation of these topological excitations possibly leading to the observed first - order transition .
the @xmath61-vortex transition often becomes of first order when it accompanies a simultaneous symmetry - breaking of other degrees of freedom @xcite . )
plane .
the undistorted model corresponds to @xmath20 .
the crossover line is conventionally drawn at a point where @xmath54 for @xmath69 is equal to 0.01 .
the asymptotic behavior of the transition line near the undistorted limit is presently not clearly determined .
, width=302 ] we have performed similar simulations for other values of @xmath15 , and the resulting phase diagram is given in fig.4 in the distortion @xmath14 vs. the temperature @xmath49 plane .
together with the first - order transition line @xmath70 , the crossover line associated with the onset of the nematic order is also shown .
interestingly , this crossover line coincides with the first - order transition line for @xmath71 , while it is separated from the @xmath35-line for @xmath72 , lying well above it . for smaller @xmath73
, we can not identify the transition directly .
this is either the transition itself is absent for smaller @xmath14 , or @xmath35 becomes so low that we simply can not observe it in our simulations . in the range @xmath74 , @xmath35 varies almost linearly with @xmath14 .
linear extrapolation yields a critical value @xmath75 below which we no longer have a finite-@xmath49 transition .
however , the difficulty to get reliable data at low temperatures in this small @xmath14 region hampers us to reliable determine the fate of the transition line in the @xmath50 limit , _
i.e. _ , whether i ) it hits the @xmath44 axis at @xmath76 , or ii ) shows a nonlinear behavior in the smaller @xmath14 region reaching the @xmath44 axis only at @xmath20 , or iii ) ends at a finite @xmath49 exhibiting a critical end point at ( @xmath77 , @xmath78 ) .
finally , we discuss the possible relation of the finite-@xmath49 transition observed in our simulation to the zero - field transition of volborthite .
the curie temperature of the present model is estimated to be @xmath79 for @xmath28 .
if one matches it with the corresponding experimental value of volborthite @xmath80k @xcite , @xmath35 is estimated to be @xmath81k , which is an order of magnitude smaller than the experimental value , 1k .
several possible causes for this discrepancy are conceivable : i ) the experimental value of the distortion @xmath14 is largely unknown which could explain at least a part of the discrepancy .
ii ) volborthite is a @xmath0 system .
quantum effect neglected here might give significant correction .
iii ) real material is 3d .
weak interplane coupling neglected here might push up the @xmath35-value significantly .
iv ) the dzyaloshinskii - moriya interaction neglected here might change the ordering behavior significantly .
further studies are then required to clarify the true relation between the transition found here and the experimental one . in summary
, we studied the ordering of the classical heisenberg af on a distorted kagome lattice by mc simulations .
we have found that the model exhibits a thermodynamic first - order transition at an extremely low but finite temperature .
cooperative generation of the chiral domain walls and the @xmath61 vortices might be responsible for this first - order transition .
the authors are thankful to z. hiroi , h. yoshida , and m. yoshida for useful discussion .
this study was supported by grand - in - aid for scientific research on priority areas `` novel states of matter induced by frustration''(19052006 ) .
we thank supercomputer center , issp , university of tokyo for providing us with the cpu time .
99 special topics on novel states of matter induced by frustration , edited by h. kawamura , j. phys .
. jpn .
* 79 * , 011001 ( 2010 ) .
edited by c. lacroix , p. mendels , and f. mila , ( springer , berlin , 2011 ) . c. waldtman , h .- u .
everts , b. bernu , c. lhuillier , p. sindzingre , p. lcheminant and l. pierre , eur .
phys .
j. b * 2 * , 501 ( 1998 ) .
h.c .
jiang , z.y .
weng and d.n .
sheng , phys .
rev .
lett .
* 101 * , 117203 ( 2008 ) . h. nakano and t. sakai , j. phys .
. jpn . * 80 * , 053704 ( 2011 ) .
r.r.p . singh and d.a .
huse , phys .
rev .
b * 76 * , 180407 ( 2007 ) . j.t . chalker , p.c.w .
holdsworth and e.f .
shender , phys .
rev .
letters * 68 * , 855 ( 1992 ) .
j.n .
reimers and a.j .
berlinsky , phys .
rev .
b * 48 * , 9539 ( 1993 ) .
m.e .
zhitomirsky , phys .
rev .
letters * 88 * , 057204 ( 2002 ) .
m.e .
zhitomirsky , phys .
rev .
b * 78 * , 094423 ( 2008 ) .
j. robert , b. canals , v. simonet and r. ballou , phys .
rev .
letters * 101 * , 117207 ( 2008 ) .
m.p .
shores , e.a .
nytko , b.m .
bartlett and d.g .
nocera , j. am .
chem .
soc . * 127 * , 13462 ( 2005 ) .
p. mendels and f. bert , in novel states of matter induced by frustration , jpsj special topics , j. phys .
. jpn . * 79 * , 011001 ( 2010 ) , and references cited therin .
h. yoshida , y. okamoto y. tayama , t. sakakibara , t. tokunaga , m. matsuo , a. narumi , y. kindo , k. yoshida , m. takigawa and z. hiroi j. phys .
. jpn . * 78 * , 043704 ( 2009 ) .
m. yoshida , m. takigawa , h. yoshida , y. okamoto and z. hiroi , phys .
rev .
lett . * 103 * , 077207 ( 2009 ) .
s. yamashita , t. moriura , y. nakazawa , h. yoshida , y. okamoto and z. hiroi , j. phys .
soc .
jpn . * 79 * , 083710 ( 2010 ) .
y. okamoto , h. yoshida and z. hiroi , j. phys .
. jpn . * 78 * , 033701 ( 2009 ) .
f. wang , a. vishwanath and y.b .
kim , phys .
rev .
b * 76 * , 094421 ( 2007 ) .
r. kaneko , t. misawa and m. imada , j. phys .
. jpn . * 79 * , 073708 ( 2010 ) .
see supplemental material for the details of our test of equilibration of monte carlo simulations .
see supplemental material for typical snapshopts of the chiral wall configurations below and above @xmath35 .
see supplemental material for the properties of the @xmath61 vortex .
h. kawamura and s. miyashita , j. phys .
. jpn . * 54 * 4530 ( 1985 ) .
h. kawamura , a.yamamoto , and t. okubo , j. phys .
. jpn .
* 79 * , 023701 ( 2010 ) .
h. kawamura , j. phys .
. ser . * 320 * , 012002 ( 2011 ) .
h. kawamura and m. kikuchi , phys .
rev . b*47 * , 1134 ( 1993 ) .
see supplemental material for the manner how the @xmath61 vortices and the chiral domain walls interact with each other below and above @xmath35 .
j.c .
domange , c. lhuillier , l. messio , l. pierre and p. viot , phys .
rev .
b * 77 * , 172413 ( 2008 ) .
r. tamura and n. kawashima , j. phys .
. jpn . * 80 * , 074008 ( 2011 ) .
z. hiroi , m. hanawa , n. kobayashi , m. nohara , h. takagi , y. kato and m. takigawa , j. phys .
. jpn . * 70 * , 3377 ( 2001 ) . supplemental material in this supplemental material , we explain some of the details about ( i ) the equilibration check of our monte carlo simulations , ( ii ) the states of the chiral domain walls , ( iii ) the properties of the @xmath61 vortices , and ( iv ) the manner how the @xmath61 vortices and the chiral domain walls interact with each other in our model . |
given a diagram @xmath2 of a link and a modulus @xmath3 , a ( fox ) coloring ( @xcite ) is an assignment of integers modulo @xmath0 to the arcs of @xmath2 such that at each crossing twice the color assigned to the over - arc equals the sum of the colors assigned to the under - arcs , modulo @xmath0 ( see figure [ fig : xtop ] ) .
for each diagram and for each modulus @xmath3 there is always at least one solution to this problem namely by assigning the same color ( i.e. , integer modulo @xmath0 ) to each and every arc of the diagram ; thus there are exactly @xmath0 such solutions modulo @xmath0 .
these are the trivial solutions modulo @xmath0 i.e. , the so - called trivial @xmath0-colorings of the diagram .
the non - trivial @xmath0-colorings are the solutions , modulo @xmath0 , which involve at least two distinct colors . * remark*. we remark that it is well known that this system of equations is also a system of relations for the first homology group of the 2-fold branched covering along the link ( @xcite , theorem 3.3 ) . in fact
, the fundamental group of the @xmath4-fold branched covering along a link is presented by labeling the arcs of the unoriented link diagram and having relations of the form @xmath5 read off at each crossing when @xmath6 is the label of the over - crossing line .
it then follows that @xmath7 ( the first homology group of the @xmath4-fold branched covering along the link @xmath8 ) has presentation with @xmath9 , where @xmath10 are the corresponding elements in the abelianization of the fundamental group ( @xcite ) .
should one set the color of one of the arcs equal to @xmath11 then there would be a bijective correspondence between this set of colorings and @xmath12 .
it is interesting to remark that the fundamental group of the @xmath4-fold branched covering along the link is itself a non - abelian generalization of the fox coloring .
while we do not use this aspect of the topology here , we are aware of it and it may be of use in later work . for more background on this material
see @xcite .
if a diagram endowed with an @xmath0-coloring undergoes a reidemeister move , there is a unique reassignment of colors to the arcs involved in the move such that the new assignment is an @xmath0-coloring of the resulting diagram .
since these reassignments are reversible there is a bijection between the @xmath0-colorings before and after the performance of a finite number of reidemeister moves .
furthermore , these reassignments preserve trivial @xmath0-colorings and thus they preserve also non - trivial @xmath0-colorings . therefore the number of @xmath0-colorings is a link invariant ; the fact that a diagram of a link admits or not non - trivial @xmath0-colorings is an invariant of that link .
it is known that there are links which do not admit non - trivial colorings over a given modulus .
for example , the trefoil only admits non - trivial colorings over moduli divisible by @xmath13 . in the course of our work on colorings , we have observed that for some choices of a modulus @xmath3 and a link admitting non - trivial @xmath0-colorings , the following occurs .
there are distinct non - trivial @xmath0-colorings , @xmath14 ( realized on an otherwise arbitrary diagram @xmath2 of this link ) and there is a permutation @xmath15 of the @xmath0 colors such that , for each arc @xmath16 of @xmath2 , the colors assigned to @xmath16 in the coloring @xmath17 , say @xmath18 , and in the coloring @xmath19 , say @xmath20 , satisfy : @xmath21 two such colorings will be said `` related '' .
an instance where this occurs is depicted in figure [ fig:9_40tri ] . on the other hand
it is not true that any permutation transforms the colors of a coloring into the colors of another coloring ( see figure [ fig:9_40bis ] ) .
moreover , given non - trivial @xmath0-colorings @xmath17 and @xmath19 , realized on the same diagram , it may happen that there is no permutation @xmath15 of the @xmath0 colors such that for each arc @xmath16 of @xmath2 @xmath21 we will then say `` @xmath19 is essentially distinct from @xmath17 '' , in the given modulus , and the colorings split into equivalence classes ( to be elaborated upon below ) . in figure [ fig:9_40 ] we list representatives of the distinct equivalence classes of the non - trivial @xmath22-colorings of @xmath23 .
we will be primarily concerned with permutations that preserve the coloring equation at each crossing for these are the ones that actually give us a corresponding coloring of the link and we will show that the relation sketched above among @xmath0-colorings of a diagram is an equivalence relation ( see below ) .
we remark that the articles @xcite and @xcite address the same topic as the current article .
their definition of equivalent colorings assumes one has a list of all non - trivial @xmath0-colorings for a given diagram and states simply that any two of these colorings are equivalent provided there is a permutation of the @xmath0 colors that , for each arc in the diagram , sends the color in this arc in the source coloring to the color in the same arc in the target coloring .
this is equivalent to our definition .
unfortunately , for the purposes of counting equivalence classes of colorings in generic cases , the methodology in @xcite and @xcite seems to resort to generating classes of colorings by letting the symmetric group on the @xmath0 colors act on a given @xmath0-coloring .
as we see in figure [ fig:9_40bis ] , there are assignments of colors to a diagram obtained in this way that do not constitute colorings .
the formulas in the articles referred to above predict in general less equivalence classes than ours due to their over - counting of the elements on each orbit .
the equivalence classes of colorings constitute a topological invariant and in this article we provide combinatorial information about them .
we hope this will prove to be useful for topological purposes .
in section [ sect : prelim ] we discuss preliminaries such as the nullity and the generating arcs of a coloring ( subsection [ subsect : nullity ] ) , and the definition of the equivalence classes ( subsection [ subsect : equivclass ] ) . in section [
sect : results ] we calculate the number of equivalence classes in an infinite number of instances .
consider a link , @xmath8 , along with a diagram @xmath24 for that link . regarding the arcs of this diagram as algebraic variables we write the homogeneous system of linear equations consisting of the equations read off each crossing as illustrated in figure [ fig : xtop ] .
we call the matrix of the coefficients of this homogeneous system of linear equations * the coloring matrix of @xmath24*. any coloring matrix is made up of integers .
specifically , along each row one finds exactly two 1 s and one -2 , the rest being perhaps 0 s .
thus , adding all the columns of a coloring matrix we obtain a column made up of 0 s .
it follows that the determinant of any coloring matrix is 0 . upon performance of reidemeister moves on a diagram ,
the changes on the original coloring matrix are realized by operations that constitute a subset of the following operations on integer matrices .
these operations are generated by 1 .
multiplication of a row ( column ) by @xmath25 ; 2 .
addition to one row ( column ) of integer linear combinations of other rows ( columns ) ; 3 .
insertion ( deletion ) of a row and column made up of 0 s except for a 1 at the diagonal entry ; 4 .
permutations of rows ( columns ) .
these are the operations which relate equivalent matrices over the integers ( see @xcite , page 50 ) .
so the equivalence class of a coloring matrix is a topological invariant of the link under study . for each of these equivalence classes of matrices over the integers
there is an outstanding representative which is called the smith normal form ( see @xcite ) .
although the smith normal form ( snf ) is a familiar object we elaborate here slightly about it in order to bring out some connections with colorings of knots which we do not find in the literature . an integer matrix in smith normal form is a matrix such that its entries are all zero except perhaps along the diagonal . along the diagonal the entries are non - negative ( without loss of generality ) and the @xmath26-th entry divides the @xmath27-th entry , up to a certain index @xmath28 , and after that , the entries are all @xmath11 s : @xmath29 the @xmath30 s
are called the * invariant factors * of the equivalence class ; their name reflects the fact that the multi - set formed by them is an invariant of the equivalence class .
this multi - set is then a topological invariant if it originates from a coloring matrix .
moreover , the smith normal form of a coloring matrix is sure to have a @xmath11 at the last entry of the diagonal since we proved above that the determinant of a coloring matrix is @xmath11 .
the product of the remaining entries of the diagonal of the smith normal form of a coloring matrix is * the determinant of the link * under study .
this is also a topological invariant .
( in passing , it is known that for knots i.e. , @xmath31-component links , the determinant of the knot is an odd integer , see @xcite . )
we denote the smith normal form of a matrix @xmath32 by @xmath33 .
being an element of the equivalence class of @xmath32 , @xmath33 is obtained by a finite number of the operations listed above .
we may then collect all the information concerning the row operations into an invertible matrix called @xmath34 and likewise for the column operations into an invertible matrix called @xmath35 to state ( @xcite ) @xmath36 with the juxtaposition of pairs of consecutive symbols on the right - hand side of the equation denoting matrix multiplication .
let us now fix an otherwise arbitrary link along with one of its diagrams .
let us then relate the smith normal form ( and its invariant factors ) of the coloring matrix of this diagram to the corresponding system of linear homogeneous equations and its solutions .
there are always solutions of this system of equations namely by assigning the same integer to each arc .
this corresponds to the fact that the determinant of the coloring matrix is @xmath11 .
one of the algebraic variables may take on any value and if there is no other zero entry along the diagonal of the smith normal form , then the remaining variables are uniquely determined once the former variable has been assigned a value . going back to the original system of equations we obtain the so - called trivial solutions i.e. , those solutions that assign the same value to each and every arc of the diagram .
the invariant factors associated to our coloring matrix via its smith normal form allow us to do something else .
suppose we choose a factor @xmath0 of one of these invariant factors and decide to work over the integers modulo @xmath0 .
then our smith normal form in this new setting acquired at least one more @xmath11 along the diagonal .
then , there is at least one more variable which can take on any value , modulo @xmath0 .
going back to the original system of equations , there are at least two arcs which can take on any value modulo @xmath0 .
hence , we now have polychromatic colorings i.e. , solutions where at least two distinct arcs take on two distinct colors that is , values modulo @xmath0 . had we chosen an @xmath0 which does not possess common factors with the invariant factors , then modulo @xmath0 there would have been only trivial colorings . [ prop : genarcsp]let @xmath37 be an odd prime .
let @xmath2 be a link diagram .
the number of @xmath11 s @xmath38modulo @xmath39 along the diagonal of the smith normal form of the coloring matrix , @xmath32 , of @xmath2 , equals the least number of arcs of @xmath2 that can independently receive colors modulo @xmath37 , and generate each @xmath37-coloring of @xmath2 . proof .
if the smith normal form exhibits @xmath40 @xmath11 s modulo @xmath37 , this means that the space of solutions has dimension @xmath40 ; working modulo a prime implies we are doing linear algebra over a field so it makes sense to talk about dimensions of spaces and bases
. then matrix @xmath35 in ( [ eqn : eqn ] ) above operates a change of basis taking us back to algebraic variables equivalent to the arcs of the original diagram .
then @xmath40 of these arcs have to generate all the colorings ( i.e. , all the solutions of the indicated system of equations modulo @xmath37 ) in terms of a basis of coloring vectors .
[ def : pnul ] the number @xmath40 in the proof of proposition [ prop : genarcsp ] is called the @xmath37-nullity @xmath38or the rank mod @xmath42 of the coloring matrix of @xmath2 .
any set of @xmath40 arcs that can independently receive colors modulo @xmath37 and so generate each @xmath37-coloring of the diagram under study is said a set of generating arcs @xmath38of this diagram , with respect to this modulus@xmath43 .
we keep the notation of proposition [ prop : genarcsp ] .
if the @xmath37-nullity of a link is @xmath40 then there are @xmath44 @xmath37-colorings of the link , and @xmath45 non - trivial @xmath37-colorings of this link .
there are @xmath37 integers mod @xmath37 so there are always @xmath37 trivial @xmath37-colorings and @xmath44 @xmath37-colorings .
@xmath41 let @xmath0 be a composite positive integer .
let @xmath2 be a link diagram .
each zero @xmath38modulo @xmath46 along the diagonal of the smith normal form of the coloring matrix , @xmath32 , of @xmath2 contributes with a factor @xmath0 for the number of solutions .
each zero divisor , @xmath47 , of @xmath0 along the diagonal contributes with a factor @xmath48 to the number of solutions . with @xmath49 for the number of @xmath11 s @xmath38modulo @xmath46 along the diagonal in @xmath33 , and @xmath50 for the set the of invariant factors of @xmath32 which are zero divisors of @xmath0 , the formula for the number of @xmath0-colorings of @xmath2 is : @xmath51 proof .
the contribution of the @xmath49 zero s ( modulo @xmath0 ) along the diagonal of the smith normal form to the number of solutions is clear . for the contribution of the zero divisors along the diagonal to the number of solutions
see @xcite , page 40 .
this concludes the proof .
@xmath41 in this section
we introduce equivalence classes of colorings as orbits of actions of certain groups of permutations on the set of colorings of a diagram . in order for this notion
to be topological we require a special kind of permutation which we call a * coloring automorphism*. these are permutations which comply with the coloring operation , @xmath52 in a pre - assigned modulus @xmath0 .
this operation generalizes to the quandle operation , generalizing also the notion of coloring ( @xcite ) . in the particular instance
@xmath53 we are dealing with the so - called dihedral quandles , one per integer modulus @xmath0 .
[ def : auto ] given an integer @xmath54 , we define a coloring automorphism of @xmath55 to be a permutation , @xmath56 , of @xmath55 such that @xmath57 for all @xmath58 , with @xmath59 @xmath38mod @xmath60 , for every @xmath61 . in @xcite
we find the following facts .
for a given integer @xmath54 , each coloring automorphism of @xmath55 is given by : @xmath62 with @xmath63 and @xmath64 , the set of units of @xmath55 .
the set of all these coloring automorphisms of @xmath55 equipped with composition of functions , constitutes a group isomorphic to the affine group over @xmath55 i.e. , isomorphic to the semi - direct product @xmath65 .
we denote it @xmath66 . for any integer @xmath54 the inner coloring automorphism group of @xmath55
is generated by the automorphisms of the form @xmath67 .
it is easy to see that this group consists of the elements of the form , @xmath68 if @xmath0 is even this subgroup is isomorphic to the dihedral group of order @xmath0 and @xmath69 can take on only `` even '' values from @xmath55 .
if @xmath0 is odd , this subgroup is isomorphic to the dihedral group of order @xmath70 and @xmath69 can take on any value from @xmath55 .
we denote it @xmath71 .
this information about coloring automorphisms of @xmath55 is contained in @xcite . in the sequel ,
we will write `` automorphism '' ( respectively , `` inner automorphism '' ) instead of the longer `` coloring automorphism of @xmath55 '' ( respectively , `` inner coloring automorphism of @xmath55 '' ) since these are the only automorphisms of @xmath55 we consider in this article i.e. , the permutations of elements of @xmath55 that comply with the coloring operation .
specifically , we will use the expression * automorphism * to designate a permutation of the form @xmath62 with @xmath63 and @xmath64 , and * inner automorphism * to designate a permutation of the form @xmath68 with @xmath69 taking on only `` even '' values from @xmath55 if @xmath0 is even ; with @xmath69 taking on any value from @xmath55 if @xmath0 is odd .
we remark that it is well known that for a quandle @xmath72 and a diagram @xmath2 , the set of diagram colorings by elements of @xmath73 , @xmath74 is a q - quandle set , where the action of @xmath73 on @xmath74 is given by @xmath75 for a coloring @xmath76 and @xmath77 ( kamada was the first proponent of this language ) .
our considerations for dihedral quandles are related to this .
let @xmath78 be an integer .
let @xmath8 be a link admitting non - trivial @xmath0-colorings .
let @xmath2 be a diagram of @xmath8 .
we let @xmath79 stand for the set of * non - trivial * @xmath0-colorings of @xmath2 .
[ prop : action ] let @xmath78 be an integer .
let @xmath8 be a link admitting non - trivial @xmath0-colorings and let @xmath2 be a diagram of @xmath8 .
let @xmath80 be a subgroup of @xmath81 .
then @xmath80 acts on @xmath82 by permutations .
specifically , given @xmath83 and @xmath84 , an @xmath0-coloring of @xmath2 with colors @xmath85 , then @xmath86 is the @xmath0-coloring of @xmath2 obtained by replacing each color @xmath85 by @xmath87 .
moreover , this action is faithful and if @xmath0 is prime this action is also free .
* proof*. we keep the notation of the statement .
we regard @xmath88 as the map which assigns colors to the arcs of @xmath2 in such a way that , @xmath89 , where @xmath90 designates the index of the over - arc of the crossing where under - arcs with indices @xmath26 and @xmath91 meet , see figure [ fig : xtop ] ( where now each @xmath92 should be read @xmath93 ) .
so , given @xmath83 and @xmath88 , then @xmath86 is such that @xmath94 so @xmath86 is again an @xmath0-coloring of @xmath2 . clearly , the identity element @xmath95 is such that @xmath96 .
furthermore , for any two @xmath97 , the composition of functions guarantees that @xmath98 .
we now prove that this action is faithful i.e. , we prove that given a non - identity @xmath83 there exists a coloring @xmath88 such that @xmath99 .
we recall that the elements of @xmath80 are , in particular , permutations of the elements of @xmath55 .
so given a non - identity element of @xmath80 which moves @xmath100 , then the coloring obtained by assigning @xmath26 to one of the generating arcs of the diagram is transformed via @xmath101 into a coloring where now this generating arc is assigned @xmath102 .
we now prove that this action is free i.e. , that if given @xmath103 there exists a coloring @xmath88 such that @xmath104 then @xmath105 .
we recall that , for some @xmath106 and @xmath107 , @xmath108 , @xmath109 for any @xmath110 .
since @xmath104 then there exists two distinct colors in @xmath55 , say @xmath111 such that @xmath112 and @xmath113 .
more precisely , @xmath114 since @xmath115 and @xmath0 is prime .
thus @xmath105 .
this concludes the proof .
@xmath41 [ def : gequivd ] let @xmath80 be a subgroup of @xmath66 .
the @xmath80-equivalence classes of @xmath0-colorings of @xmath2 are , by definition , the @xmath80-orbits over @xmath82 . we will next prove that this notion provides topological invariants ( in particular , the number of equivalence classes of @xmath0-colorings of a link ) .
it is well known that , given any two diagrams of the same link , there is a bijection between the two sets of @xmath0-colorings of these diagrams ( @xcite , @xcite , lemma @xmath116 ) . moreover , this bijection takes trivial @xmath0-colorings to trivial @xmath0-colorings and non - trivial @xmath0-colorings to non - trivial @xmath0-colorings .
this bijection is realized by the `` colored reidemeister moves '' .
the colored reidemeister moves apply to a diagram endowed with an @xmath0-coloring ; a reidemeister move is applied to the diagram and a local adjustment of the coloring is performed .
these adjustements are unique and reversible thereby proving the bijection between the two sets of @xmath0-colorings of any two diagrams of the same link .
[ prop : equivtop ] let @xmath0 be an integer greater than @xmath31 .
let @xmath8 be a link admitting non - trivial @xmath0-colorings and let @xmath2 and @xmath117 be two diagrams of @xmath8 .
let @xmath80 be a subgroup of @xmath66 .
there is a bijection from @xmath82 to @xmath118 , which preserves the @xmath80-equivalence classes . *
proof * : from @xcite we know that the colored reidemeister moves realize a bijection from the set of @xmath0-colorings of @xmath2 to the set of @xmath0 colorings of @xmath117 , taking non - trivial colorings to non - trivial colorings .
we now prove that the colored reidemeister moves take distinct elements of @xmath82 along a @xmath80-equivalence class , to distinct elements of @xmath118 along a @xmath80-equivalence class .
specifically , for @xmath83 and @xmath88 , we prove that the `` colored reidemeister moves '' take @xmath88 to @xmath119 and @xmath120 to @xmath121 .
the proofs of these statements for the individual `` colored reidemeister moves '' of type i , ii , and iii are displayed in figures [ fig : r1 ] , [ fig : r2 ] , and [ fig : r3 ] .
the @xmath122 associates horizontally colorings on distinct diagrams related by a colored reidemeister move .
vertically we display colorings @xmath84 and @xmath86 ( @xmath123 and @xmath124 , respect . ) for diagram @xmath2 ( @xmath117 , respect . ) . in figures [ fig : r1 ] and [ fig : r2 ] circles with dotted lines were drawn to bring out the local nature of the transformation .
this was not done in figure [ fig : r3 ] in order not to overburden the figure .
@xmath41 * remark .
* proposition 2.3 can also be seen by regarding mod - m colorings as elements of @xmath125 .
[ cor : numbers ] let @xmath8 be a link and @xmath2 one of its diagrams .
let @xmath3 be an integer .
the number of @xmath80-equivalence classes of @xmath0-colorings of @xmath2 is a topological invariant .
the multi - set whose elements are the number of @xmath0-colorings per @xmath80-equivalence class of @xmath0-colorings of @xmath2 is a topological invariant .
* proof*. this is a straight - forward consequence of proposition [ prop : equivtop ] .
@xmath41 we remark that in the sequel @xmath80 , the subgroup of @xmath66 , will be either @xmath66 itself or @xmath71 .
figure [ fig : fig8 ] illustrates the fact that in general there are more inner equivalence classes than equivalence classes ( for the same link and for the same modulus ) .
in this section we apply the theory developed above to specific situations . *
we use @xmath37-nullity as in definition [ def : pnul ] . * [ prop : numberequivclasscol]let @xmath37 be an odd prime and @xmath40 an integer greater than @xmath31 . a link @xmath8 with @xmath37-nullity @xmath40
has @xmath126 equivalence classes of @xmath37-colorings . *
proof*. as discussed right after definition [ def : auto ] , an automorphism of @xmath127 @xmath128 depends on two parameters @xmath129 and @xmath130 . since @xmath131 and @xmath132 , there are then exactly @xmath133 automorphisms for @xmath127 .
now suppose @xmath17 is in @xmath134 , where @xmath2 is a diagram of @xmath8 . since the action of @xmath135 is free ( [ prop : action ] ) each orbit of the action has exactly @xmath133 elements . since there are @xmath45 elements in @xmath134 , there are then @xmath136 orbits of this action which is the number of equivalence classes of @xmath37-colorings for link @xmath8 .
@xmath41 [ cor : mincol ] we keep the notation of proposition [ prop : numberequivclasscol ]
. 1 . if a diagram @xmath2 of link @xmath8 admits a non - trivial @xmath37-coloring with the least number of colors ( over all diagrams , over all non - trivial @xmath37-colorings ) , then there are at least @xmath133 such @xmath37-colorings of @xmath2 .
if the nullity of @xmath8 mod @xmath37 is @xmath4 and a diagram @xmath2 of @xmath8 admits a non - trivial @xmath37-coloring with @xmath137 colors , then any other non - trivial @xmath37-coloring of @xmath2 uses @xmath137 colors .
in particular , if @xmath2 is a diagram of @xmath8 where a non - trivial @xmath37-coloring is realized with the least number of colors , then any other non - trivial @xmath37-coloring of this diagram uses also the least number of colors .
proof . 1 . since the automorphisms are permutations of the @xmath37 colors they preserve the number of distinct colors
so if a non - trivial @xmath37-coloring of a diagram uses @xmath137 colors , then along its equivalence class the non - trivial @xmath37-colorings use @xmath137 colors each and there are @xmath133 non - trivial @xmath37-colorings per equivalence class .
if a diagram @xmath2 of link @xmath8 admits a non - trivial @xmath37-coloring with the least number of colors then along its equivalence class the non - trivial @xmath37-colorings use the same number of colors each .
if the nullity of @xmath8 mod @xmath37 is @xmath4 then there is only @xmath31 equivalence class ( mod @xmath37 ) .
then the arguing of @xmath138 is valid for the @xmath133 non - trivial @xmath37-colorings in this orbit .
@xmath41 [ cor : d ] let @xmath8 be a link with the following property .
the smith normal form of a@xmath38ny@xmath43 coloring matrix of @xmath8 has only one @xmath11 and only one @xmath139 along the diagonal . then for any prime @xmath37 such that @xmath140
, there is only one equivalence class of @xmath37-colorings .
in particular , rational links satisfy this property .
working mod @xmath37 the smith normal form of the coloring matrix will exhibit exactly two zeros .
hence the @xmath37-nullity is @xmath4 and the result follows from proposition [ prop : numberequivclasscol ] . @xmath41
[ cor : otherd ] the following links have only one class of @xmath37-colorings for each prime @xmath37 for which they admit non - trivial @xmath37-colorings .
1 . links whose determinant is prime .
links of non - zero determinant whose smith normal form of the coloring matrix displays different primes on different diagonal entries @xmath38besides the @xmath11 entry and possible @xmath31s@xmath43 .
knots whose knot group can be presented using one relator @xmath38 in particular , torus knots@xmath43 .
proof . @xmath138 and @xmath141 are particular cases of corollary [ cor : d ] . as for @xmath142 , since the deficiency of knot groups is one then knot groups which can be presented with one relator only need two generators
. then the smith normal form of the coloring matrix is @xmath143 where @xmath144 is the determinant of the knot .
@xmath41 let @xmath37 be an odd prime and @xmath40 an integer greater than @xmath31 .
a link @xmath8 with @xmath37-nullity @xmath40 has @xmath145 inner - equivalence classes of @xmath37-colorings .
* proof*. as discussed right after definition [ def : auto ] , an inner - automorphism of @xmath127 is of the form @xmath146 with @xmath130 .
there are then exactly @xmath147 inner - automorphisms for @xmath127 .
the rest of the proof goes through as in the proof of proposition [ prop : numberequivclasscol ] leading to the following number of inner - orbits @xmath148 @xmath41 [ cor : innerd ] let @xmath8 be a link with the following property .
the smith normal form of a@xmath38ny@xmath43 coloring matrix of @xmath8 has only one @xmath11 and only one @xmath139 along the diagonal . then for any prime @xmath37 such that @xmath140 , there are @xmath149 equivalence class of @xmath37-colorings . in particular
, rational links satisfy this property . proof .
adapt the proof for corollary [ cor : d ] .
@xmath41 [ cor : innerotherd ] the following links have @xmath149 classes of @xmath37-colorings for each prime @xmath37 for which they admit non - trivial @xmath37-colorings . 1
. links whose determinant is prime .
links of non - zero determinant whose smith normal form of the coloring matrix displays different primes on different diagonal entries @xmath38besides the @xmath11 entry and possible @xmath31s@xmath43 .
knots whose knot group can be presented using one relator @xmath38 in particular , torus knots@xmath43 .
adapt the proof for corollary [ cor : otherd ] .
in the context of quandles this work has to do with homomorphisms from the fundamental quandle of the knot to the dihedral quandles ( @xcite ) .
we organize these homomorphisms into equivalence classes . in future work
we plan to generalize this work to other classes of target quandles , other than the dihedral quandles .
j.g . thanks for support from nsfc ( grant no . 11171279 and no .
11271307 ) . p.l . acknowledges support from fct ( fundao para a cincia e a tecnologia ) , portugal , through project number ptdc / mat/101503/2008 , `` new geometry and topology '' . p.l .
also thanks the school of mathematical sciences at the university of nottingham for hospitality .
l. h. kauffman , _ knots and physics _ , first edition , second edition , third edition , fourth edition ,
series on knots and everything * 1 , 53 * , world scientific publishing co. pte . ltd . ,
singapore and river edge and hackensack , new jersey 1991,1994,2001,2013 . | for any link and for any modulus @xmath0 we introduce an equivalence relation on the set of non - trivial @xmath0-colorings of the link ( an @xmath0-coloring has values in @xmath1 ) . given a diagram of the link , the equivalence class of a non - trivial @xmath0-coloring is formed by each assignment of colors to the arcs of the diagram that is obtained from the former coloring by a permutation of the colors in the arcs which preserves the coloring condition at each crossing .
this requirement implies topological invariance of the equivalence classes .
we show that for a prime modulus the number of equivalence classes depends on the modulus and on the rank of the coloring matrix ( with respect to this modulus ) .
keywords : links , colorings , equivalence classes of colorings msc 2010 : 57m27 |
coarsening has been a object of intensive study over the last decades not only because of its experimental relevance but also because it constitutes what is maybe the simplest case of out - of - equilibrium dynamics . for a scalar order parameter ,
one generally distinguishes the non - conserved case , e.g. the ising model with glauber dynamics ( model a according to the widely - used classification of @xcite ) , from the conserved case , e.g. the ising model with kawasaki dynamics ( model b ) .
it is now well - established that in these cases phase ordering is characterized by a single lengthscale @xmath3 growing algebraically with time ( @xmath4 ) with the growth exponent @xmath5 taking two different values , @xmath1 for the non - conserved / model a case , and @xmath0 for conserved order parameter systems like model b @xcite . here
we are interested in the more complicated and therefore less well understood case of a non - conserved order parameter coupled to a conserved concentration ( so - called model c ) .
examples of this situation can be found in various physical systems , e.g. , intermetallic alloys ( see @xcite and references therein ) , adsorbed layers on solid substrates @xcite and supercooled liquids @xcite . in these systems ,
the decomposition process ( described by the conserved concentration @xmath6 ) and the ordering process ( described by the non - conserved order parameter @xmath7 ) are coupled .
let us consider an @xmath8 alloy on a square lattice in order to illustrate this .
a state in which all @xmath9 atoms are surrounded by @xmath10 atoms is energetically favorable .
the ordered state thus consists of two symmetric sublattices , and we can define an order parameter @xmath7 as half of the difference between the @xmath9-concentration in each sublattice . in this way , @xmath11 when all the @xmath9 atoms are on the one sublattice and @xmath12 when they are on the other . at high temperature ,
a disordered state @xmath13 arises .
it is now easy to realize that for asymmetric initial conditions ( i.e. an unequal amount of @xmath9 and @xmath10 atoms ) the system will not be able to completely order ( strictly speaking , this is only true at low - enough temperature ) .
hence , as opposed to model a , the disordered phase can coexist with the two ordered phases . on a typical equilibrium phase diagram in the concentration - temperature ( @xmath6-@xmath14 ) plane ( fig .
[ f1 ] ) , one can thus distinguish , apart from a disordered region and an ordered region , a coexistence region .
the dashed line separating the ordered and disordered regions marks a second - order phase transition . in the spinodal region inside the coexistence region (
dotted line ) , the three phases are thermodynamically unstable .
models have been proposed to account for various aspects of the morphology and of the kinetics of the experimental systems ( see for instance @xcite and references therein ) . from the more theoretical point of view of universality issues , the situation is not quite satisfactory .
for instance , the critical exponents , and in particular the dynamic critical exponent , are still debated @xcite .
a renormalization group analysis turns out to be more delicate than in the case of model a @xcite .
our goal here is to clarify the a priori simpler problem of domain growth below criticality , when the system is quenched down from a high - temperature state .
notable but partial results , somewhat scattered in the literature , have been obtained in the past .
for quenches into the spinodal region with droplet morphology ( quench q2 of fig .
[ f1 ] ) san miguel et al .
@xcite have predicted the model b exponent @xmath0 .
numerical simulations in the context of a oono - puri `` cell model '' have been found to be consistent with this prediction@xcite . on the other hand , elder et al .
@xcite have predicted @xmath1 for quenches above the tricritical temperature , i.e. in the ordered region ( quench q4 ) . to the best of our knowledge
, this has not been verified numerically .
our goal here is to give a complete picture of ( non - critical ) domain growth in model c , considering , within a single system introduced in section [ s2 ] , all four possible types of quenches illustrated in fig .
this is done in section [ s3 ] . in section [ s4 ] , in the sake of comprehensiveness , we come back to the two following unsettled issues discussed recently in works about model c systems .
the microcanonical @xmath2 model @xcite , is a type of model c since the order parameter is coupled to the ( conserved ) energy .
zheng has suggested in a recent paper @xcite that domain growth is characterized by a non - trivial value of @xmath5 ( @xmath15 ) .
a more careful study by us showed that the data are in fact consistent with the model a exponent @xmath1 @xcite . here
we detail to which phase of model c the microcanonical @xmath2 model belongs .
the morphology of domains and the related `` wetting '' issues have also been a point of contention in the past . in experiments
, it has been observed that neighboring ordered domains do not merge @xcite .
a possible explanation proposed in @xcite is that the domains are different variants of the same ordered structure .
the simulations of @xcite seem to indicate that ordered domains do not join but `` stay separated by narrow channels of the disordered phase '' : the antiphase boundaries appear to be wetted by the disorder phase . but somoza and sagui @xcite have found on the contrary that inside the coexistence region the two ordered phases may be in direct contact .
we revisit their work and resolve the controversy .
a summary of our results is given in section [ s5 ] .
we choose one of the simplest versions of model c which can be written as follows : @xmath16 here @xmath17 and @xmath18 are kinetic coefficients , @xmath19 and @xmath20 represent thermal noise and @xmath21 $ ] is the ginzburg - landau free energy functional which takes generally the following form : @xmath22 = \!\int\ !
d^n r \left [ f(c,\psi ) + \frac{k_c}{2 } ( \nabla c)^2 + \frac{k_{\psi}}{2 } ( \nabla \psi)^2 \right],\ ] ] where @xmath23 and @xmath24 are diffusion constants .
the function @xmath25 should satisfy a few constraints .
firstly it has to be symmetric in @xmath7 : @xmath26 .
it should also allow for the coexistence of a disordered phase @xmath27 with the ordered phases @xmath28 @xcite .
these points correspond to minima in the free energy landscape .
a possible choice is @xcite @xmath29 where @xmath30 governs the coupling between the two fields .
the minima are then @xmath31 corresponding to the disordered phase and @xmath32 corresponding to the ordered phase .
it is instructive to analyze the model in terms of its uniform fixed points @xmath33 .
they lie on the curves where @xmath34 which are the @xmath6-axis @xmath35 and the polynomial @xmath36 .
their stability is determined by the signs of @xmath37 and @xmath38 @xcite .
fixed points on the @xmath6-axis change stability at the so - called ordering spinodal @xmath39 : they are stable for @xmath40 . the point on the second curve where stability changes is the conditional spinodal @xmath41 .
stability occurs when @xmath42 .
consider now the evolution of a two - dimensional system starting from random initial conditions disordered around @xmath13 with some fixed concentration @xmath43 .
we briefly present the expected follow - up of quenches at various @xmath43 values before describing our corresponding numerical results in the next section . for @xmath44 ( disordered phase ) , the system evolves towards the stable point @xmath45 .
for @xmath46 , the three phases @xmath47 and @xmath48 can in principle coexist . for @xmath49 ( quench q1 ) , however , @xmath45 is still stable and it will be reached if initial fluctuations are small enough . inside the region @xmath50 ( quench q2 ) , the system necessarily undergoes spinodal decomposition . for @xmath51 ( quench q3 ) , even though the ordered fixed points are now stable , nothing is changed since the initial conditions ( chosen around @xmath13 ) lead to the formation of disordered domains . for initial concentrations @xmath52 ( quench q4 ) , the system will not phase separate but will order , so we identify this region with the ordering regime .
in order to investigate the late stages of domain growth , eqs .
( [ c1]-[c2 ] ) are now studied numerically .
we perform quenches from the high - temperature disordered phase to @xmath53 .
( the noise term in eqs .
( [ c1]-[c2 ] ) can be set equal to zero , since the growth exponent is expected to be determined by the `` @xmath53 fixed point '' @xcite . ) in practice , initial conditions are randomly distributed around @xmath45 .
more specifically , we choose @xmath54 $ ] and @xmath55 $ ] . equations ( [ c1]-[c2 ] ) are numerically solved on a two - dimensional grid . for the time integration
we use euler s method and we approximate the laplacian by : @xmath56\ ] ] where @xmath57 and @xmath58 are the sets of nearest and next - nearest neighbors of site @xmath59 . in most regimes
studied below , @xmath60 and @xmath61 allow for a smooth representation of both fields . without loss of generality ,
we set : @xmath62 and @xmath63 .
we record the typical domain size @xmath3 of both the order parameter and the concentration fields , as determined by the mid - height value of @xmath64 , the normalized two - point correlation function calculated for simplicity along the principal axes of the lattice using the the reduced `` spin '' variables @xmath65 and @xmath66 : @xmath67 quenches within the disordered regime being uninteresting , we first discuss q1 quenches , i.e. quenches into the coexistence region , but left of the spinodal ( @xmath68 ) . here
the system possesses a stable fixed point @xmath45 but will be able to locally reach the ordered fixed points if initial fluctuations are large enough .
the precise dependence on initial conditions is in fact a non - trivial problem that we have not studied systematically .
this shows that the spinodal lines do not have a strict meaning in the presence of fluctuations , a well - known fact ( see for instance @xcite ) .
when decomposition occurs , the ordered phase is the minority phase , and , similarly to what is observed in model b , droplets of either ordered phases form .
a similar configuration is shown in fig .
the growth of ordered droplets is constrained by the conservation law .
the smallest droplet disintegrates to the benefit of the larger ones .
we thus expect a lifshitz - slyozov growth law @xmath69 . in our simulations , this behavior is not easily observed , due to the presence of a long transient during which the ordered domains `` nucleate '' out of the metastable state .
in particular , the growth of the typical lengthscales @xmath70 does not show the expected scaling although the trend at large times is good . in this regime ,
though , the droplet morphology of the ordred domains can be exploited to provide a more direct measurement of growth . in fig .
[ f3 ] , we show the evolution of the total number of the ordered droplet , s @xmath71 , and of the average droplet volume @xmath72 .
these quantities scale respectively as @xmath73 and @xmath74 . due to a long crossover ,
the expected behavior is only clearly seen when plotting @xmath72 and @xmath75 against @xmath74 ( fig.[f3]b ) .
the same scenario is observed for q2 quenches provided the ordered phase be the minority phase , i.e. for @xmath76 .
a typical snapshot is shown in fig .
we have also verified that indeed a growth exponent @xmath0 is observed .
now the crossover is shorter and we see that the local slope of @xmath77 vs @xmath78 approaches @xmath79 at late times ( see fig
. [ f5]ab ) .
the same conclusion is reached studying the total number of domains and their average volume ( fig .
[ f5]cd ) . due to the coupling to the non - conserved order parameter
, the symmetry between high and low concentration phases , which exists in model b , is broken .
for @xmath80 the minority phase ( now the low concentration phase ) does not form droplets but is instead concentrated along lines which correspond to interfaces of the non - conserved field . in the context of alloys
one speaks of `` wetting of antiphase boundaries '' .
looking at the non - conserved field , we first observe model a like coarsening which then slows down , since the interfacial regions separating ordered domains get wider ( made of the disordered phase , their volume is conserved ) .
we thus again encounter the situation where the ordering is constrained by the conservation law , but with the difference that the disordered phase has a particular morphology .
it is therefore not obvious that the growth exponent will be @xmath0 .
the derivation of @xcite is only valid in the case of isolated droplets .
however , the lifshitz - slyozov law is known to apply more generally , provided that 1 ) coarsening is driven by surface tension , 2 ) transport is by diffusion through the bulk and 3 ) the length scale that describes the coarsening process is the only relevant length scale in the system @xcite .
it is easy to convince oneself that the first two conditions are fulfilled . at first sight
, however , it appears that there are two lengthscales : one associated with the thickness of the disordered domains , @xmath81 ( equivalently of the interfaces between ordered domains ) , the other with their curvature ( equivalent to the lengthscale of the ordered domains ) , @xmath3 .
one has to realize that the total interface length @xmath82 is inversely proportional to @xmath3 .
since the volume occupied by the interface is conserved we also have @xmath83 , and therefore @xmath84 .
one thus expects again a growth exponent @xmath0 .
the above discussion not only applies to q2 quenches ( @xmath85 ) , but also to q3 quenches ( @xmath86 ) .
a uniform configuration @xmath33 is then stable , but for symmetric initial conditions there are always interfaces where @xmath13 and where it is thus more favorable to have @xmath87 . in the `` ordered '' domains @xmath6
will then increase such that we will end up with all the three phases .
all this is confirmed by our numerical results . in fig .
[ f6 ] we show snapshots of order parameter and concentration at late times for @xmath88 and @xmath89 . in fig .
[ f7 ] we plot , for the same concentrations , the typical lengthscale of ordered domains and disordered domains .
they behave similarly .
we can also identify two transient effects .
initially , rapid growth takes place due to the ordering process .
after that , when the antiphase bounderies are wetted , the growth will actually be slower than @xmath90 .
since the disordered phase has a large surface compared to its volume , surface diffusion will dominate at short times , and this is known to lead to a @xmath91 growth law @xcite . for @xmath92 ( q4 quenches )
no spinodal decomposition occurs .
if initially a domain of the disordered phase exists , it disappears . although the concentration is not completely uniform but somewhat lower at the interfaces of the ordered domains , as seen in fig .
[ f8 ] , this does not have any influence on the coarsening of the order parameter .
thus , the model a exponent @xmath1 should be observed for @xmath93 .
again this is confirmed in our simulations .
we have measured the typical domain size for the order parameter around @xmath94 . as can be seen in fig .
[ f8 ] a growth exponent @xmath0 is still observed for @xmath43 slightly below @xmath94 , at @xmath95 . at @xmath96 , growth is clearly faster but the local exponent ( inset of fig .
[ f8]c ) does not reach @xmath97 in accessible times .
the behavior , though , is consistent with @xmath1 .
this is most clearly observed plotting @xmath3 againt @xmath98 ( fig .
increasing @xmath43 beyond @xmath94 , the crossover is now short enough and the @xmath1-behavior is apparent even in a log - log plot ( fig .
the microcanonical @xmath2 model has lately received renewed attention largely because it offers an interesting bridge between statistical mechanics and deterministic dynamics @xcite .
its equations of motion derive from the well known lattice @xmath2 hamiltonian .
they can be written : @xmath99 where the sum is over the 4 nearest neighbors of site @xmath59 on a square lattice . as stated before ,
this model is believed to be in the model c universality class since the order parameter @xmath100 is coupled to the conserved energy .
@xcite indeed , looking at snapshots of the order parameter and the local energy , defined as : @xmath101 one observes that @xmath102 is higher at the interfaces of ordered domains ( fig .
[ fig - phi4]a ) as observed in our model c around the coexistence concentration @xmath94 .
given the results described above , the question of the precise relationship between the microcanonical @xmath2 model and model c now boils down to whether we are in the interconnected ( @xmath103 ) or the ordered regime ( @xmath104 ) of model c , i.e. whether the interfaces ( equivalently the disordered domains ) will thicken or not . our observation that , in fact , @xmath1 @xcite indicates that we are in the ordered regime
this implies that the conserved field does not undergo spinodal decomposition .
the snapshots of the order parameter and the local energy taken during coarsening ( fig .
[ fig - phi4 ] ) reveal that the width of the `` antiphase boundaries '' does not grow .
instead , energy flows into the bulk of domains in the form of kinetic energy , as observed in @xcite .
the increase of kinetic energy compensates the energy lost due to the decrease of the total interface length .
we believe this constitutes further support to our result @xmath1 , at least for the parameter values studied in @xcite and @xcite . whether a coexistence regime in the @xmath2-model exists for other parameter values remains , strictly speaking , an open question .
in fact , since the system is isolated , the total energy and the `` temperature '' can not be varied independently . upon increasing the energy ,
the temperature , which can be identified with the kinetic energy , will also increase .
we therefore only have access to a line in the @xmath105-plane of fig .
( note that increasing the energy corresponds to decreasing the concentration . )
investigations of the critical behavior of the model , where it is a priori important whether one enters the disordered region from the coexistence region or from the ordered region , are under way @xcite .
a few years ago , somoza and sagui have investigated the effect of interfacial properties on the morphology of domains in a model c system @xcite .
they came to the conclusion that apart from a `` complete wetting '' regime where two `` ordered '' domains ( @xmath106 ) are always separated by a disordered layer ( @xmath13 ) , there exist also a `` partial wetting '' and even a `` partial drying '' regime where ordered domains of opposite sign can be in direct contact .
these regimes were observed by varying the diffusion constants @xmath23 and @xmath24 keeping @xmath107 and @xmath108 fixed
. thus diffusion of one quantity was enhanced with respect to the other .
we first repeated the simulations of somoza and sagui using @xmath109 .
the ordered domains are in direct contact but the corresponding interfaces are not smooth , an indication that the equations are not well resolved .
next , we performed the same quench but at a higher numerical resolution ( @xmath110 ) .
as shown in fig .
[ f9]b , no direct contact between ordered domains can be observed .
the argument put forward in @xcite is that in the partial drying regime the surface tension is lower between the two ordered phases than between the ordered and disordered phases .
this surface tension was measured by calculating the free energy of a numerically obtained interface profile @xcite .
it must be noted , however , that this procedure is only correct when the obtained profile is the equilibrium profile .
an order - order interface for instance will desintegrate into two disorder - order interfaces when the surface tension of the latter is lower .
the speed at which this happens depends on the diffusion constants , since some amount of the conserved quantity has to diffuse away from the interface .
one could thus have the impression that an order - order interface is stable , when in fact it is very slowly disintegrating .
we have provided a comprehensive account of domain growth in two - dimensional model c systems , unifying and sometimes correcting partial results present in the literature .
quenches into the coexistence region ( @xmath111 ) all lead to @xmath0 domain growth governed by the conserved field , independent of the morphology of domains , but subjected to the strength of initial fluctuations when @xmath112 .
quenches into the ordered region are asymptotically dominated by the ordering process , leading to @xmath1 growth after a crossover from slower @xmath0 coarsening .
we also clarified the status of the microcanonical @xmath2 model and showed that in this case sub - critical domain growth correspond to quenches into the ordered region of model c. the picture that thus emerges is that domain growth in model c systems below criticality is governed by the growth exponent of either model a or model b. at criticality , on the other hand , one may expect exponents different from model a or b. the natural question that then arises is how the exponents depend on on the initial concentration .
another issue open for further investigation is the behavior of the so - called persistence probability @xmath113 , defined as the probability for a spin to have remained in its initial phase from @xmath114 up to time @xmath115 ( see @xcite for a review ) . in the case of model
a and b this quantity decays algebraically with an exponent @xmath116 , estimated to be @xmath117 @xcite and @xmath118 @xcite .
the universality of these exponents is an ongoing debate .
measurements of the persistence exponent in model c , especially in the interconnected regime where one would expect the model b value , might help to settle this issue . | we present a comprehensive picture of ( non - critical ) domain growth in model c systems where a non - conserved scalar order parameter is coupled to a conserved concentration field . for quenches into the region
where the ordered and disordered phases coexist , we confirm earlier partial numerical results and find a growth exponent @xmath0 . for quenches into the ordered region , we confirm the theoretical prediction @xmath1 .
finally we discuss the implications of our results for domain growth in the microcanonical @xmath2-model and we offer some criticism of the work of somoza and sagui on the morphology and wetting properties of domains . 2 |
the purpose of this contribution is twofold : to review how an su(n ) transformation can be experimentally realized using optical elements , and to show how such an experimental realization can be used to investigate the cyclic evolution of a state over the manifold su(n)/u(n-1 ) .
the bulk of the results will be presented explicitly for su(3 ) ( see @xcite for further details ) and su(4 ) , although it will become clear that the method can be applied to any su(n ) .
recall that cyclic evolution of a wave function yields the original state plus a phase shift , and this phase shift is a sum of a dynamical phase @xmath0 and a geometric ( or topological , or quantal , or berry ) phase @xmath1 shift@xcite .
the geometric phase shift is important not just for quantum systems but also for all of wave physics . thus far , controlled geometric phase experiments , both realized and proposed , have been exclusively concerned with the abelian geometric phase arising in the evolution of u(1)invariant states @xcite here , we generalize the above results to an abelian geometric phase which arises from geodesic transformations of u(n-1)invariant states in su(n)/u(n-1 ) space .
the scheme employs a sequence of optical element , henceforth called su(n ) elements because they perform transformations described by an su(n ) matrix , arranged so that the net result of the sequence cyclically evolves an initial state back to itself up to a phase .
it will be seen that the decomposition of an su(n ) transformation into a product of appropriate su(2 ) subgroup transformations is the prescription to construct each su(n ) element as a sequence of su(2 ) elements .
it is important to distinguish the evolution of states in the geometric space su(n)/u(n-1 ) from the transformations of the optical beam as it progresses through the interferometer .
it is possible to set up the experiment so as to eliminate the dynamical phase associated with these optical transformations , thus making the dynamical phase irrelevant for our purpose .
the cyclic evolution described here occurs in the geometric space , and the geometric phase of interest is related to this evolution .
consider an optical element which mixes two input beams .
it is , formally , a black box which performs some transformation , as the output is not the same as the input .
we are here interested by optical elements which mix the input beams in a linear way , _
i.e. _ the output is a linear combination of the inputs .
furthermore , we will assume that the optical element is passive , _
i.e. _ it does not globally create or annihilate photons .
the optical elements the enter in the construction of su(n ) device are beam splitters , mirrors and phase shifters .
a phase shifter is essentially a slab of material which increases the optical path lenght of one beam relative to the other .
a beam splitter is a partially silvered mirror which lets photons through with some probability .
provided that losses can be ignored , each of these optical elements can be associated with an su(2 ) unitary transformation@xcite .
it is therefore advantageous to factorize each su(n ) transformation into a product of su(2)@xmath2 subgroup transformations mixing fields @xmath3 and @xmath4 .
an optical element mixing two fields is associated with an su(2 ) transformation in the following way .
suppose that _ one _ photon enters the black box .
we may assume that it will enter the optical system either via beam one or beam two .
thus the hilbert space of input states is two dimensional .
as the transformation is linear , the set of all possible output states will also be a two dimensional space .
clearly this conclusion does not change if the input state is a general state @xmath5 , where the photon has probability @xmath6 of being in beam 1 and probability @xmath7 of being in beam 2 ( @xmath8 , @xmath9 are complex numbers ) .
suppose now that _ two _ photons enter the black box .
then , we can have one of three possibilities : two photons enter in beam 1 , one photon enters in each beam , or both photons enter in beam 2 . in this case , the hilbert space of states is three dimensional .
continuing in this way , and using the fact that the input photons are indistinguishable , one rapidly works out that , in a system containing @xmath10 photons , the relevant hilbert space is of dimension @xmath11 .
the conservation of photon number leads to the following constraint on the possible form of the linear transformation .
consider first the case of a single photon .
the optical transformation @xmath12 with @xmath13 complex numbers , transforms a general state @xmath14 into the output state @xmath15 such that @xmath16 taking the transpose complex conjugate of that to find @xmath17 , multiplying from the right by @xmath15 , we find that , if the number of photon ( = 1 ) is to be conserved for any input state , @xmath18 implies that @xmath19 , the unit matrix .
thus , @xmath20 is a @xmath21 unitary transformation . because we are only interested in the relative phase between the beams , the determinant of @xmath20 can chosen without loss generality to be + 1 , so that @xmath20 is an su(2 ) matrix .
if the black box performs a transformation @xmath20 that is an su(2 ) transformation when there is a single photon in the system , it must also perform an su(2 ) transformation when there are @xmath22 photons in the system : the transformtation effected by the black box can not depend on the number of photons in the system ( at least not in the regimes that we are considering ) .
thus , in a system of two photons , where state space is three dimensional , @xmath20 will be @xmath23 representation of the relevant su(2 ) transformation . in a system containing @xmath10 photon
, @xmath20 will be an su(2 ) matrix of dimension @xmath24@xcite .
it is well known that an su(2 ) transformation can be factored into a product of three subtransformations : @xmath25 this factorization is a prescription on how to construct the su(2 ) device : a slab of material is inserted in one beamline so as to create a relative phase shift of @xmath26 , a partially silvered mirror which lets @xmath27 photons from beam 1 through is then inserted , and another phase shifter completes the design .
in an su(3 ) interferometer , an general su(3 ) matrix is decomposed into a product of three su(2 ) matrices
@xcite : @xmath28 where @xmath29 .
this factorization , symbolically written @xmath30 , is a _ de facto _ prescription on how to build the su(3 ) device : fields @xmath31 and @xmath32 are mixed followed by a mixing of the output field @xmath31 with the field in channel @xmath33 , and , finally , the output field @xmath31 is mixed with field @xmath32 . as it is possible to factorize an su(n ) matrix in terms of su(2 ) submatrices @xcite , the process of constructing a general su(n ) device is perfectly obvious and follows the lines illustrated explicitly for the su(3 ) device .
for instance , the appropriate factorization of an su(4 ) matrix is a product of the type @xmath34 where @xmath35 is an su(2 ) matrix mixing fields @xmath36 and @xmath37 .
the factorization of an su(n ) matrix into su(2 ) subgroup matrices is not unique , and the number of su(2 ) elements required to construct an su(n ) device can vary according to the parametrization : an estimate of the number of su(2 ) devices required to construct an su(n ) element was given in @xcite .
finally , we mention that su(3 ) and su(4 ) devices have been constructed but with an aim to study non - classical statistics @xcite .
the total phase @xmath38 acquired by a state during a generic cyclic evolution is the sum of @xmath39 .
a special type of evolution is the geodesic evolution@xcite ; by transforming the output state along geodesic paths in the geometric space , the geometric phase shift along each path is zero .
an essential property of geodesic evolutions is that they are not transitive : the product of two such evolutions is not necessary another geodesic evolution .
this is most easily illustrated by drawing three points on a plane at random .
it is well known that the geodesic on a plane is a straight line .
let @xmath40 and @xmath41 denote the three points .
then it is clear that , even if @xmath42 is the straight ( geodesic ) line that connects @xmath43 and @xmath44 , and even if @xmath45 is the straight line that connect @xmath46 and @xmath41 , the combined segment @xmath47 is _ not _ a geodesic between @xmath48 and @xmath41 .
this property makes it possible to construct a cyclic evolution from a sequence of geodesic legs : the geometric phase acquired during the circuit is then a global property of the entire circuit . for definiteness ,
let us consider su(3 ) .
there , the evolution of the state @xmath49 to the state @xmath50 via 3 geodesic paths in the geometric space can be described by 3 one
parameter su(3 ) group elements @xmath51 , with @xmath52 an evolution parameter .
these transformations satisfy the conditions that @xmath53 is the identity element and @xmath54 for some fixed end values @xmath55 of the evolution parameters .
we consider evolutions @xmath56 of the form @xmath57 with @xmath58 an element of su(3 ) satisfying @xmath59 the form of the one
parameter subgroup @xmath60 with real entries was guided by the definition of a geodesic curve between two states @xmath61 and @xmath62 , which can be written in the form @xcite @xmath63 with @xmath64 . as it is always possible to choose unit vectors @xmath61 such that @xmath65 is real and positive
, it is straightforward to show that any @xmath66 of the form given by eq .
( [ eq : decomposeu ] ) satisfying @xmath67 real and positive gives evolution along a geodesic curve in su(3)/u(2 ) .
the form of the geodesic evolution makes it easy to obtain its physical interpretation .
the transformation @xmath60 is a transformation of appropriate length along some reference geodesic ( some generalized greenwich meridian on su(3)/u(2 ) ) .
the transformation @xmath58 is a principal axis transformation which correctly orients the reference geodesic so that it passes through @xmath68 and @xmath69 . @xmath58
therefore depends on the initial and final states .
the three states in su(3)/u(2 ) must be chosen in a sufficiently general way to ensure that they can represent any triangle in su(3)/u(2 ) @xcite . since the latter is of dimension @xmath70 , there are @xmath70 free parameters to be chosen
. the first state can be chosen , wlog , to be the `` north pole '' state .
again wlog , the second state can always be chosen to lie along the reference geodesic some distance away from the initial state .
the last state must therefore contain the remaining @xmath32 parameters . in short , the vertices of a geodesic triangle in su(3)/u(2 ) can , in general , be chosen as @xmath71 with @xmath72 , @xmath73 , @xmath8 and @xmath9 arbitrary . since @xmath74
, the geometric phase for the complete circuit is extracted from the overlap real positive overlap @xmath75 .
this works out immediately to @xmath76 the generalization to su(4 ) is immediate : the form of eq.([eq : decomposeu ] ) remains the same , but the matrix of eq.([eq : rt ] ) is augmented to a @xmath77 matrix : @xmath78 the condition of eq.([eq : geocurve ] ) remains .
as we have argued , the first two vertices of the geodesic triangle remain unchanged , but the last vertex now depends on the @xmath79 parameters of su(4)/u(3 ) : @xmath80 a form which obviously reduces to the su(3 ) case if @xmath81 . for su(4)/u(3 ) , the berry phase is again related to the inner product of @xmath82 through @xmath83 and can be seen to depend on the required number of parameters .
an optical su(n ) transformation can be realized by a n channel optical interferometer@xcite .
the su(2)@xmath84 matrix @xmath85 in eq .
( [ eq : rt ] ) is a special case of the generalized lossless beam splitter transformation for mixing channels @xmath33 and @xmath31 .
more generally a beam splitter can be described by a unitary transformation between two channels@xcite .
for example , a general su(2)@xmath86 beam splitter transformation for mixing channels @xmath31 and @xmath32 is of the form @xmath87 with @xmath88 and @xmath89 the transmitted and reflected phase shift parameters , respectively , and @xmath90 the beam splitter transmission .
a generalized beam splitter can be realized as a combination of phase shifters and 50/50 beam splitters in a mach
zehnder interferometer configuration .
the goal of the following is to construct an su(3 ) optical transformations in terms of su(2 ) elements which realize the geodesic evolution in the geometric space by appropriately adjusting parameters of the interferometer
. it will be convenient to write @xmath91 in eq.([vertices ] ) as @xmath92 , where @xmath93 , @xmath94 , @xmath95 and @xmath96 are functions of @xmath72 , @xmath73 , @xmath8 and @xmath9 , the parameters of @xmath91 in eq .
( [ vertices ] ) .
following our factorization scheme , the geodesic evolution operators @xmath66 , connecting @xmath61 to @xmath62 , can be expressed as @xmath97 with @xmath85 given by eq .
( [ eq : rt ] ) , the parameters @xmath52 ranging from @xmath98 , and @xmath99 .
note that @xmath100 and , in fact , all the parameters of @xmath101 are fixed by the requirement that @xmath102 also note that , for each @xmath36 , @xmath53 is the identity in su(3 ) and @xmath103 as required . once it is observed that @xmath104 , it is trivial to verify that each evolution satisfies eq .
( [ eq : geocurve ] ) and is therefore geodesic .
the geometric phase for the cyclic evolution @xmath105 is given explicitly by eq.([berryphase ] ) .
this phase depends on four free parameters in the experimental scheme : @xmath72 , @xmath73 , @xmath8 and @xmath9 , which describe a general geodesic triangle in su(3)/u(2 ) .
the interferometer configuration for realizing the necessary evolution about the geodesic triangle is depicted in fig .
[ fig : config ] .
this configuration consists of a sequence of su(2)@xmath2 transformations , and we use the shorthand notation @xmath106 to designate the three parameters associated with the generalized beam splitter .
the three
channel interferometer consists of a sequence of nine su(2)@xmath2 transformations .
the field enters port @xmath107 , and the vacuum state enters ports @xmath108 and @xmath109 .
= 6.0 cm for su(4 ) , the first evolution is the same , but the second will depend on more parameters as the dimensionality of su(4)/u(3 ) is larger than that of su(3)/u(2 ) .
briefly , we have : @xmath110 where @xmath111 and where @xmath112 is an su(3 ) matrix of the form @xmath113 whose details are unimportant for our purposes . although su(3 ) and su(4 ) interferometry have been considered in some details , the methods employed here can be extended to su(n ) , or n channel , interferometry@xcite .
the schemes discussed above employing such a device would produce and enable observation of the geometric phase shift for geodesic transformations of states
invariant under subgroups of states in the dimensional coset space .
this contribution is a summary of recent theoretical work on the possibility of measuring berry phases using optical elements .
the scheme depends on the optical realization of su(n ) transformations in the optical domain ; this is possible because the lie algebra su(n ) can be realized in terms of boson creation and destruction operators which have immediate interpretation as photon field operators .
there also exists the possibility of realizing sp(2n,@xmath114 ) transformation using optical elements @xcite : the lie algebra sp(2n,@xmath114 ) also has a realization in terms of boson operators .
the setup to measure berry phase in an optical experiment is interesting because it provides a very practical realization of otherwise abstract ideas and allows one to do `` experimental differential geometry '' over su(n)/u(n-1 ) .
this contribution has dealt exclusively with the optical realization of abelian berry phase : even if states are invariant under u(n ) , two states are equivalent if they differ by a u(1)phase .
it is possible to enlarge the equivalence class to obtain the so called non - abelian berry phase @xcite , which has been studied in the context of degenerate states .
it is possible to study the non - abelian version of the results presented here by using polarization : two states of different polarization are declared equivalent .
the larger equivalence class comes about because a rotation of the polarization plane is an su(2 ) transformation .
the experimental aspects of this remain , at the moment , unclear .
an optical experiment to measure an su(2 ) phase would require optical devices which perform `` tunable '' polarization dependent transformation .
the theoretical aspects of this questions are currently under investigation .
this work has been supported by two macquarie university research grants and by an australian research council large grant .
bcs appreciates valuable discussions with j. m. dawes and a. zeilinger , and hdg acknowledges the support of fonds f.c.a.r . of the qubec government .
m. v. berry , proc .
( lond . ) * 392 * , 45 ( 1984 ) .
b. simon , phys.rev.lett * 51 * , 2167 ( 1983 ) ; f. wilczek and a. shapere , _ geometric phases in physics _ , advanced series in mathematical physics - vol .
* 5 * ( world scientific , singapore , 1989 ) .
a. tomita and r. y. chiao , phys.rev.lett * 57 * , 937 ( 1986 ) ; r. y. chiao , a. antaramian , k. m. ganga , h. jiao , s. r. wilkinson , and h. nathel , phys.rev.lett * 60 * , 1214 ( 1988 ) ; d. suter , k. t. mueller , and a. pines , phys.rev.lett * 60 * , 1218 ( 1988 ) .
g. kwiat and r. y. chiao , phys.rev.lett * 66 * , 588 ( 1991 ) .
r. simon and n. mukunda , phys.rev.lett * 70 * , 880 ( 1993 ) .
b. yurke , s. l. mccall , and j. r. klauder , phys.rev.a * 33 * , 4033 ( 1986 ) .
r. a. campos , b. e. a. saleh and m. c. teich , phys.rev.a * 40 * , 1371 ( 1989 ) .
d. j. rowe , b. c. sanders and h. de guise , j. math .
phys . * 40 * , 3604 ( 1999 ) .
m. reck , a. zeilinger , h. j. bernstein , and p. bertani , phys.rev.lett * 73 * , 58 ( 1994 ) ; b. c. sanders , h. de guise , d. j. rowe and a. mann , j. phys .
a : math . gen . * 32 * , 7791 ( 1999 ) .
t. h. chyba , l. j. wang , l. mandel , and r. simon , opt .
* 13 * , 562 ( 1988 ) ; r. simon , h. j. kimble and e. c. g. sudarshan , phys.rev.lett * 61 * , 19 ( 1988 ) .
arvind , k. s. mallesh , and n. mukunda , j. phys .
a : math . gen . * 30 * , 2417 ( 1997 ) j. anandan , phys .
a * 133 * , 171 ( 1988 ) , f. wilczek and a. zee , phys .
lett . * 52 * , 2111 ( 1984 ) . | an interferometric scheme to study abelian geometric phase shift over the manifold su(n)/su(n-1 ) is presented . #
1/#2.1em .5ex-.1em /-.15em.25ex # 1 # 1 |
the experimentally clean signatures of @xmath0 and @xmath1bosons make the measurement of these processes in association with jets well suited to test perturbative qcd at the lhc .
the processes allow for comparisons of multi jet production with predictions either from the parton shower approach or from exact multi parton matrix elements ( @xmath5 ) matched with parton showers . in addition , full next to leading order ( @xmath6 ) calculations are also available for comparison with many of the results .
the @xmath7 processes also differ from pure qcd multi jet processes with respect to the scale of the hard interaction , due to the large mass of the electroweak gauge bosons .
measurements of @xmath0/@xmath1+jets are also important to control backgrounds to other measurements at the lhc . in the standard model context ,
one example is the top quark cross section measurements , where @xmath0+jet is often the dominant background .
also several beyond the standard model searches , such as the zero lepton susy search , suffer from irreducible background from either @xmath0+jets or @xmath1+jets , or both . here
we report on the atlas @xmath1+jets and @xmath0+jets cross section measurements @xcite based on data recorded during 2010 .
the analyses include the electron and muon decay channels and are based on an integrated luminosity of 33 pb@xmath8 .
the atlas detector systems were all fully operational during this data taking period and the detector acceptance considered was approximately determined by the following constraints .
electrons were used within the inner detector acceptance ( @xmath9 ) , whereas reconstructed muons were considered inside the acceptance of the trigger chambers ( @xmath10 ) .
the electron ( muon ) @xmath11 ( @xmath4 ) was required to be larger than 20 gev , in order to be well inside the highly efficient plateau of the triggers .
jets were reconstructed inside the main calorimeters ( @xmath12 ) and missing transverse energy was based on the full calorimeter acceptance ( @xmath13 ) .
the cross section measurements were made within the kinematic region defined by the event selection , which was well covered by the atlas detector acceptance , * @xmath14 * @xmath15 * @xmath16 * @xmath17 * @xmath18 note that here the jet @xmath4 requirement , as well as the rapidity variable , differs between the @xmath0 ( 20 gev ) and @xmath1 analysis ( 30 gev ) .
the @xmath19 criteria refers to the leptons and all selected jets and the @xmath1 selection also require the two leptons to be of opposite charge .
the results were then corrected for detector effects , using a bin by bin unfolding method , and compared with theory ( @xmath20 ) predictions inside the same kinematic region .
for the theory results , jets were reconstructed using the same algorithm based on all final state particles with a lifetime larger than 10 ps , except the leptons from the @xmath7 decays .
lepton momenta also included any photons radiated within @xmath21 .
a good agreement was generally found between the selected data candidates and predictions from mc , for both @xmath1 and @xmath0 events in both the electron and muon channels . regarding the background for these measurements , the background coming from qcd
was estimated based on a data driven method whereas the electroweak and top backgrounds were estimated from mc .
the background contamination of the selected @xmath1+jets samples was of the order of 1% for the muon channel , as well as 5% for the electron channel . in the @xmath0+jets samples ,
the background was in the order of 10% .
the main source of uncertainty in these measurements comes from the jet energy scale , which contributes with approximately 10% , followed by pile up corrections ( @xmath22% ) and luminosity ( @xmath23% ) .
more details about the analysis are found in @xcite .
the obtained number of events were then used to measure the differential cross section times branching ratio with respect to a number of different quantities .
all the results correspond to inclusive measurements , corrected for detector effects , within the kinematic region defined by the event selection above .
as function of the number of jets ( left ) .
cross section for @xmath24 as function of @xmath4 of the leading jet ( right).[fig : zw2],title="fig : " ] as function of the number of jets ( left ) .
cross section for @xmath24 as function of @xmath4 of the leading jet ( right).[fig : zw2],title="fig : " ] the differential cross section with respect of the number of selected jets was measured both using @xmath0 and @xmath1 events . the absolute cross section and the ratio of cross sections from events with @xmath25 jets over @xmath26 jets
were measured .
some of the uncertainties are reduced in the ratios .
figure [ fig : zw2 ] ( left ) shows the @xmath27 cross section as a function of number of selected jets .
the measured values show a good agreement with the nlo predictions , here represented by results obtained by mcfm .
the results are also in good agreement with expectations from the multi parton me programs ( alpgen and sherpa ) , which have been normalized to the inclusive nnlo cross sections obtained by the fewz program .
the results do on the other hand show poor agreement with the lo plus parton shower results ( pythia ) for events with more than one jet .
this is due to the combination of a not properly covered phase space ( @xmath1s are not produced by the parton shower ) together with using the parton shower approach for the hard jets .
the results are shown together with the corresponding ratios between the results obtained from data over predictions from the mc programs mcfm , alpgen and sherpa .
as function of @xmath4 of the second leading jet ( left ) .
cross section for @xmath28 as function of @xmath3 ( right).[fig : zw3],title="fig : " ] as function of @xmath4 of the second leading jet ( left ) .
cross section for @xmath28 as function of @xmath3 ( right).[fig : zw3],title="fig : " ] figure [ fig : zw2 ] ( right ) shows the differential cross section with respect to the leading jet @xmath4 for @xmath24 .
the measurement is performed separately for events with 1 to 4 jets .
the results from the @xmath0+jets measurements are also compared against nlo predictions from blackhat
sherpa , where @xmath0 + 3jets predictions at nlo is compared with lhc data for the first time .
the results are shown together with the corresponding ratios between results from mc over data , for events with 1 and 2 selected jets . again
a good agreement was found between the measurement and the mc predictions .
the differential cross sections were also measured with respect to the @xmath4 of the other selected jets in the event , using the 2 leading jets in @xmath1 events and up to 4 leading jets in the @xmath0 analysis . the cross section with respect to the @xmath4 of the second leading jet
is shown in figure [ fig : zw3 ] ( left ) for @xmath29 . a good agreement is shown and similar agreements were also found with respect to the other jets , both in the @xmath0 and @xmath1 results . in the @xmath0 analysis the cross section was also measured with respect to @xmath3 .
this quantity corresponds to the scalar sum of the @xmath4 from the jets as well as leptons , i.e. muon , electron and neutrinos , in the event , and this is the quantity which was used to characterize the scale of the hard process in the mc simulations .
the results from @xmath28 are shown in figure [ fig : zw3 ] ( right ) , which are produced separately for event with 1 to 4 jets .
the ratios between the results from mc over data are shown and a generally good agreement was found in both the electron as well as the muon channel . | we report on the measurements of inclusive @xmath0+jets and @xmath1+jets cross sections in proton proton collisions at @xmath2 tev with the atlas detector .
cross sections , in both the electron and muon decay modes of the bosons , are presented as a function of jet multiplicity , the transverse momentum of the jets and the quantity @xmath3 which is the scalar sum of the @xmath4 in the event .
measurements are also presented of the ratios of cross sections .
the measured cross sections are compared to different particle
level predictions , based on perturbative qcd , where the measured @xmath0 + 3jet cross section is for the first time compared with next to leading order calculations .
address = cavendish laboratory , university of cambridge , cambridge , uk . |
the black hole candidate gx3394 was discovered by markert et al .
( 1973 ) with the oso7 satellite and was soon noted for its similarity in x - rays to the classical black hole candidate cygx1 ( market et al .
1973 ; maejima et al . 1984 ; dolan et al . 1987 ) .
the source exhibits aperiodic and quasi - periodic modulations on time scales spanning from milliseconds to years over a wide range of wavelengths .
it spends most of the time in the so - called x - ray low state ( ls ) which has a power - law spectrum with spectral index @xmath5 ( ricketts 1983 ; maejima et al .
1984 ) and strong ( 3040% rms ) band - limited noise ( nowak et al . 1999
; belloni et al .
1999 ) . in the high state ( hs )
, it becomes brighter ( in the 210 kev band ) and exhibits an ultra - soft spectral component plus a steeper power - law ( maejima et al .
1984 ; belloni et al .
1999 ) , while the temporal variability is only a few percent rms ( grebenev et al . 1993 ; belloni et al .
it also shows a very high state ( vhs ; miyamoto et al .
1991 ) with broad band noise of 115% rms and 310 hz quasi - periodic oscillations ( qpos ) seen in its fast time variability , but with a higher x - ray luminosity than in the hs .
recently , an intermediate state ( is ) was reported by mndez and van der klis ( 1997 ) and its spectral and timing properties are similar to the vhs but with a much lower luminosity .
finally , an ` off ' state has also been reported ( see markert et al . 1973 ; motch et al .
1985 ; ilovaisky et al .
1986 ; asai et al .
1998 ) , in which the x - ray fast time variability is consistent with that seen in the ls ( mndez & van der klis 1997 ) while the energy spectrum ( power law with @xmath6 of 1.52 ) is similar to the ls but with a 210kev flux which is @xmath7 times lower or even fainter than in the ls .
it has already been suspected that the ` off ' state is in fact a weak ls ( see e.g. van der klis 1995 ) .
a summary of the different states and their properties is given in table 1 .
the optical counterpart of gx3394 was identified by doxsey et al .
( 1979 ) as a @xmath8 blue star , but subsequent observations showed that it exhibited a wide range of variability from @xmath9 to 20.2 ( motch et al .
1985 ; corbet et al . 1987 ) in its x - ray ls and ` off ' state , while @xmath10 ( motch et al . 1985 ) in the x - ray hs .
simultaneous optical / x - ray observations also showed a remarkable anti - correlation in the optical and soft x - ray ( 36 kev ) fluxes during a transition from x - ray ls to hs ( motch et al .
1985 ) , the cause of which is unknown .
however , ilovaisky et al . ( 1986 ) showed that there are times when the optical flux can be correlated with the x - ray luminosity .
a possible orbital period of 14.8 hr from optical photometry was reported by callanan et al .
( 1992 ) . at present
, there is no dynamical mass estimate available for the compact object ( which would establish the black - hole nature of the compact object ) , since there has not yet been a spectroscopic detection of the mass - losing star . in this letter
, we report on recent _ bepposax _ and optical observations of gx3394 during its current x - ray ` off ' state and compare these data with black hole soft x - ray transients ( bhsxts ) in quiescence .
[ cols="<,<,^,^,^",options="header " , ] @xmath11 black - body temperature + @xmath12 in 0.510 kev + @xmath13 @xmath14 in 300700 nm + @xmath15 assumed spectrum + references : ( 1 ) asai et al .
1998 ; ( 2 ) menou et al . 1999 ; ( 3 ) parmar et al .
1997 ; ( 4 ) narayan et al . 1997a + our observed luminosity in the 0.510 kev band is comparable to the bhsxt gs2023 + 338 and 4u163047 in quiescence ( asai et al .
1998 ; menou et al .
1999 ; parmar et al .
the quiescent x - ray luminosities and x - ray / optical luminosity ratios of several bhsxts are given in table 3 for comparison .
note that the quiescent spectrum of a062000 can be fitted either by a power law or black - body model , presumably due to the narrow energy range of _
rosat_. all the objects except 4u163047 in table 3 have firm detections such that the spectra can be determined . we note that bhsxts can be fitted with a power law spectrum in general , while neutron star sxts ( nssxts ) can be fitted by power law or black - body models ( see asai et al .
recently , rutledge et al . ( 1999 ) fitted the spectra from nssxts with a hydrogen atmosphere model and found that the derived parameters ( radius and kt ) of a062000 and gs2023 + 338 were different from those found for nssxts .
although the results are based on _ rosat _ data , asai et al .
( 1998 ) show similar findings by re - analysing _ asca _ data .
it suggests that the quiescent x - ray spectrum can provide additional information to distinguish between black holes and neutron stars .
significant x - ray variability in quiescence was observed in gs2023 + 338 ( wagner et al .
1994 ) , 4u163047 ( parmar et al . 1997 ) and a062000 ( asai et al .
1998 ; menou et al .
1999 ) , while we have obtained a similar result for gx3394 ( i.e. by comparing with asai et al .
1998 and other ` off ' state observations ) .
this is a strong indication that the bhsxts in quiescence are not totally turned off and that the ` off ' state of gx3394 is an extended ls , as discussed above .
gx3394 is similar to the quiescent state of bhsxts , as will also be discussed below .
we convert the optical magnitude into an optical ( 300700 nm ) luminosity of @xmath16 erg s@xmath2 ( assuming @xmath17 and @xmath18 ; zdziarski et al .
. the ratio of the soft x - ray ( 0.510 kev ) and optical ( 300700 nm ) luminosities , @xmath19 is @xmath20 , which is higher than other bhsxts ( see table 3 ) .
this could be due to a somewhat higher x - ray luminosity for gx3394 ( see table 3 ) .
all these results resemble the quiescent state spectrum predicted by advection - dominated accretion flow models ( adaf ; see narayan & yi 1995 ; esin et al .
in the current adaf model for bhsxts in quiescence , the viscously dissipated energy is stored in the gas and advects into the black hole so as to account for the low luminosity of bhsxts in quiescence .
this model is in good agreement with the observed optical , uv and x - ray emission of systems such as gs2023 + 338 and a062000 ( narayan et al .
1996 ; narayan et al .
more recently , fender et al .
( 1999 ) and wilms et al .
( 1999 ) have applied adaf models to explain the observed x - ray emission of gx3394 in the ls .
narayan et al .
( 1997b ) point out that the adaf luminosity depends significantly on the accretion rate .
therefore gx3394 maintains a certain accretion rate in the ls for most of the time , but the ` off ' state reported here represents a sudden decrease in the accretion rate .
it therefore suggests that the source is not totally turned off , as is observed .
following narayan et al .
( 1997 ) , the mass accretion rate of gx3394 in the ` off ' state corresponds to @xmath21 g s@xmath2 .
it is also consistent with the @xmath22 g s@xmath2 predicted by binary - evolution models ( king et al .
1996 ; menou et al . 1999 ) , assuming an orbital period of 14.8 h ( callanan et al . 1992 ) and black hole mass of 5 @xmath23 ( zdiarski et al .
this accretion rate is very similar to that of gs2023 + 338 ( narayan et al .
1997a ) in quiescence .
this relatively large accretion rate could be due to an evolved companion star like gs2023 + 338 which supports the possibility of an evolved subgiant in gx3394 ( callanan et al .
more detailed adaf modelling may be needed in order to study the nature of the ` off ' state of gx3394 and make a direct comparison with bhsxts in quiescence .
note that apart from the above , the observed range in @xmath24 magnitude of gx3394 is similar to the expected outburst amplitude for an sxt with an orbital period of 14.8 hr ( shahbaz & kuulkers 1998 ) .
together with the evidence for the similarity of the spectrum and luminosity , we suggest the ` off ' state of gx3394 to be equivalent to bhsxts in quiescence . the result is important since gx3394 undergoes state transitions on much shorter timescales , while most of the bhsxts exhibit outbursts every 1020 years .
finally , we note that we will need a good radial velocity measurement of gx3394 in its ` off ' state when the contamination of the x - ray irradiated disc is at a minimum , so as to measure or constrain the black hole mass .
we are grateful to the _ bepposax _ sdc science team for their assistance in the data reduction .
we thank robert rutledge and lars bildsten for constructive comments .
ek thanks rob fender for stimulating discussions .
this paper utilizies quick - look results provided by the asm / rxte team .
akhk is supported by a hong kong oxford scholarship .
asai k. , dotani t. , hoshi r. , tanaka y. , robinson c.r .
, terada k. , 1998 , pasj , 50 , 611 .
belloni t. , mendez , van der klis m. , lewin w.h.g . , dieters s. , 1999 , apj , 519 , 159 .
boella g. , butler r.c .
, perola g.c . , piro l. , scarsi l. , bleeker j.a.m . , 1997 , a&as , 122 , 299 .
bradt h. v. , rothschild r. e. , swank j. h. , 1993 , a&as , 97 , 355 .
callanan p.j .
, charles p.a . ,
honey w.b . , thorstensen j.r . , 1992 , mnras , 259 , 395 .
corbel s. , fender r.p .
, tzioumis a.k . , mcintyre v. , nowak m. , durouchoux p. , sood r. , 1999 , a&a , submitted .
corbet r.h.d . ,
thorstensen j.r .
, charles p.a . , honey w.b . ,
smale a.p . , menzies j.w . , 1987 , mnras , 227 , 1055
dolan j.f . ,
crannell c.j . , bennis b.r .
, orwig l.e . , 1987 , apj , 322 , 324 .
doxsey r. , bradt h. , johnston , m. , griffiths r. , leach r. , schwartz d. , schwarz j. , grindlay j. , 1979 , apj , 228 , l67 .
, mcclintock j.e .
, narayan r. , 1997 , apj , 489 , 865 .
fender r. , corbel s. , tzioumis t. , mcintyre v. , campbell - wilson d. , nowak m. , sood r. , hunstead r. , harmon a. , durouchoux p. , heindl w. , 1999 , apj , 519 , l165 .
fiore f. , guainazzi m. , grandi p. , 1999
, cookbook for bepposax nfi spectral analysis , version 1.2 .
frontera f. , et al .
, 1997 , a&as , 122 , 357 .
grebenev s. , et al .
, 1993 , a&as , 97 , 281 .
guainazzi m. , parmar a.n .
, segreto a. , stella l. , dal fiume d. , oosterbroek t. , a&a , 339 , 802 .
han x. , hjellming r.m . , 1992 ,
apj , 400 , 304 .
levine a. m. , bradt h. v. , cui w. , jernigan j. g. , morgan e. h. , remillard r. , shirley r. e. , smith d. a. , 1996 , apj , 469 , l33 .
ilovaisky s.a .
, chevalier c. , motch c. , chiappetti l. , 1986 , a&a , 164 , 67 .
ilovaisky s.a . , 1981 , iauc 3586 .
, kolb u. , burderi l. , 1996 , apj , 464 , l127 .
makishima k. , maejima y. , mitsuda k. , bradt h.v . ,
remillard r.a .
, touhy i.r .
hoshi r. , nakagawa m. , 1986 , apj , 308 , 635 .
maejima y. , makishima k. , matsuoka m. , ogawara y. , oda m. , tawara y. , doi k. , 1984 , apj , 285 , 712 .
markert t.h .
, canizares c.r . , clark g.w .
, lewin w.h.g . , schnopper h.w . ,
sprott g.f . , 1973 ,
apj , 184 , l67 . manzo g. , et al . , 1997 ,
a&as , 122 , 341 .
mndez m. , van der klis m. , 1997 , apj , 479 , 926 .
menou k. , esin a.a .
, narayan r. , garcia m.r .
, lasota j .-
, mcclintock j.c
. , 1999 , apj , 520 , 276 .
miyamoto s. , kimura k. , kitamoto s. , dotani t. , ebisawa k. , 1991 , apj , 383 , 784 .
motch c. , ilovaisky s.a .
, chevalier c. , 1982 , a&a , 109 , l1 .
motch c. , ilovaisky s.a .
, chevalier c. , 1985 , sp .
, 40 , 219 .
narayan r. , yi i. , 1995 , apj , 444 , 231 .
narayan r. , mcclintock j.e .
yi , i. , 1996 , apj , 457 , 821 .
narayan r. , barret d. , mcclintock j.e .
, 1997a , 482 , 448 .
narayan r. , garcia m.r .
, mcclintock j.e . , 1997b , apj , 478 , l79 .
nolan p.l . ,
gruber d.e . ,
knight f.k .
, matteson j.l . , peterson l.e . , levine a.m. , lewin w.h.g . ,
primini f.a . , 1982 ,
apj , 262 , 727 .
nowak m.a . , wilms j. , dove j.b . , 1999 , apj , 517 , 355 .
odonoghue d. , 1995 , baltic astronomy , 4 , 519 .
parmar a.n . , et al . , 1997 ,
a&as , 122 , 309 .
parmar a.n .
, oosterbroek y. , orr a. , guainazzi m. , shane n. , freyberg m.j . , ricci d. , malizia a. , 1999 , a&as , 139 , 407 .
parmar a.n .
, williams o.r .
, kuulkers e. , angelini l. , white n.e . , 1997 , a&a , 319 , 855 .
remillard r.a .
, mcclintock j.e . , 1987 , iauc 4383 .
ricketts m. , a&a , 1983 , 118 , l3 .
rutledge r.e . ,
bildsten l , brown e.f . ,
pavlov g.g .
, zavlin v.e . , 1999 , apj , in press shahbaz t. , kuulkers e. , 1998 , mnras , 295 , l1 .
stetson p.b . , 1987 , pasp , 99 , 191 .
van der klis m. , 1995 , in x - ray binaries , eds .
lewin , j. van paradijs & e.p.j .
van der heuvel , cup , p.252 .
vrtilek s.d . ,
swank j.h . ,
kallman t.r . , 1988 ,
apj , 326 , 186 .
wagner r.m .
, starrfield s.g . , hjellming r.m . , howell s.b . ,
kreidl t.j . , 1994 , apj , 429 , l25 .
wilms j. , nowak m.a .
, dove j.b . , fender r.p .
, di matteo t. , 1999 , apj , 522 , 460 .
zdiarski a. , andrzej a. , poutanen j. , mikolajewska j. , gierlinski m. , ebisawa k. , johnson w.n . , 1998 , mnras , 301 , 435 . | we report _ bepposax _ and optical observations of the black hole candidate gx3394 during its x - ray ` off ' state in 1999 . the broad - band ( 0.850 kev ) x - ray emission can be fitted by a single power law with spectral index , @xmath0 .
the observed luminosity is @xmath1 erg s@xmath2 in the 0.510 kev band , which is at the higher end of the flux distribution of black hole soft x - ray transients in quiescence , comparable to that seen in gs2023 + 338 and 4u163047 .
an optical observation just before the _ bepposax _ observation shows the source to be very faint at these wavelengths as well ( @xmath3 , @xmath4 ) . by comparing with previously reported ` off ' and low states ( ls ) , we conclude that the ` off ' state is actually an extension of the ls , i.e. a ls at lower intensities .
we propose that accretion models such as the advection - dominated accretion flows are able to explain the observed properties in such a state .
# 1to 0pt#1 accretion , accretion disks binaries : close black hole physics stars : individual ( gx3394 ) x - rays : stars |
systems of self - gravitating semi - degenerate fermions in general relativity were studied in @xcite and more recently with applications to dark matter in galaxies in @xcite .
it was shown that , for a given central temperature parameter ( @xmath5 ) in agreement with the corresponding observed halo circular velocity , there are lower bounds for the central degeneracy parameter ( @xmath6 ) and particle mass ( @xmath7 kev ) above which the _ observed _ halo mass and radius are fulfilled .
the density profiles solutions in this approach present a novel core - halo morphology composed by a quantum degenerate core followed by a low degenerate plateau until they reach the @xmath0 boltzmannian regime .
this interesting overall morphology provides the flat rotation curves in the outermost part of the galaxies as well as a possible alternative to massive black holes in their centers ( see @xcite and @xcite ) .
the system of einstein equations are written in a spherically symmetric space - time metric @xmath8 , where @xmath9 and @xmath10 depend only on the radial coordinate @xmath11 , together with the thermodynamic equilibrium conditions of tolman @xcite , and klein @xcite , @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the temperature , @xmath14 the chemical potential , @xmath1 the particle mass and @xmath15 the speed of light .
we then write the system of einstein equations in the following dimensionless way , @xmath16 the variables of the system are the mass @xmath17 , the metric factor @xmath9 , the temperature parameter @xmath18 and the degeneracy parameter @xmath19 .
the dimensionless quantities are : @xmath20 , @xmath21 , @xmath22 and @xmath23 , with @xmath24 and @xmath25 the planck mass . the mass density @xmath26 and pressure @xmath27 are given by fermi - dirac statistics ( see also @xcite ) .
this system is solved for a fixed particle mass @xmath1 in the kev range , with initial conditions @xmath28 , and given parameters @xmath29 ( depending on the chosen central degeneracy ) , and @xmath5 .
we thus construct a sequence of different thermodynamic equilibrium configurations where each point in the sequence has different central temperatures @xmath30 and central chemical potential @xmath31 , so that satisfy the @xmath6 fixed condition .
defining the core radius @xmath32 of each equilibrium system at the first maximum of its rotation curve , or equivalently at the degeneracy transition point in which @xmath33 , we represent the results obtained for each sequence in a central density ( @xmath2 ) vs. core mass ( @xmath3 ) diagram ( see fig.[fig:1 ] ) .
it is shown that the critical core mass @xmath34 is reached at the maximum of each @xmath35 curve . ) vs. core mass ( @xmath3 ) diagram .
the critical core mass is reached at the maximal value of @xmath3 .
each sequence is built for selected values of @xmath36 and different values of @xmath37 varying accordingly . ]
it is important to emphasize that we are not interested in follow the history of equilibrium states of one specific system .
thus , the standard stability analysis as done for compact stars or in dense stellar cluster ( see e.g. @xcite ) , which is based on the constancy of the entropy per nucleon ( s / n ) along the equilibrium sequence of a given configuration , does not apply here . nonetheless , in computing the @xmath35 curves in fig .
[ fig:1 ] we have explored the full range of @xmath38 and @xmath39 parameters ( including the critical ones ) .
then the equilibrium sequences with constant specific entropy ( s / n ) , which differ from the ones with constant @xmath6 considered here , necessarily must be contained within the full ( @xmath40 ) parameter space covered in fig .
[ fig:1 ] . in table [ table:1 ] we show a set of central critical parameters of the model together with the correspondent critical core masses , for a very wide range of fixed central degeneracy parameters @xmath6 and @xmath41 kev@xmath42 . .critical temperature parameter and normalized chemical potential at the center of each different critical configuration , for different fixed central degeneracies . [ cols="^,^,^,^ " , ] [ table:2 ]
the results obtained in tables i and ii imply a marked division in two different families depending on the value of @xmath34 .
_ i _ ) the first family : the critical mass has roughly a constant value @xmath43 .
this family corresponds to large values of the central degeneracy ( @xmath44 ) , where the critical temperature parameter is always lower than @xmath45 and the critical chemical potential @xmath46 const .
physically , these highly degenerate cores are entirely supported against gravitational collapse by the degeneracy pressure . in this case the critical core mass is uniquely determined by the particle mass according the relation @xmath4 ( see also section iii ) . _ ii _ ) the second family : the critical core mass increases from @xmath43 up to @xmath47 .
this case corresponds to critical cores with a lower central degeneracy compared with the former family ( @xmath48 ) . here
the critical temperature parameter ( @xmath49 ) , is closer to the relativistic regime with respect to the first family .
this result physically indicates that the thermal pressure term has now an appreciable contribution to the total pressure , which supports the critical core against gravitational collapse . in this case
@xmath34 is completely determined by the particle mass @xmath1 , the central temperature @xmath50 and the central chemical potential @xmath51 ( see section iii ) . in figs .
( [ fig:2 ] ) and ( [ fig:3 ] ) we show a critical metric factor @xmath52 and a critical temperature @xmath53 as function of the radius for the two different families mentioned above . and @xmath54
. the dashed line corresponds to the isothermality condition , @xmath55 . ] and
the red line corresponds to the isothermality condition , @xmath55 . ]
we will now attempt to use the critical configurations obtained before to explain the dm distribution in galactic halos , as well as providing an alternative candidate to the standard central black hole paradigm .
from now on , we will use a fixed particle mass of @xmath578.5 kev@xmath42 , being this choice motivated by the fact we want to deal with super massive dark objects having critical core masses of the order @xmath58 . in figs .
( [ fig:4 ] ) , ( [ fig:5 ] ) and ( [ fig:6 ] ) we show different critical density profiles , critical rotation curves and critical mass profiles respectively , for a wide range of different central degeneracy parameters . with the correspondent critical temperature parameters @xmath59 . ] as given in fig .
[ fig:4 ] . to note the high values of @xmath60 km / s in the flat parts of each curve due to the high critical temperature parameters @xmath59 . ] as given in figs .
[ fig:4][fig:5 ] . ] from fig .
[ fig:5 ] and table ii we see that critical configuration of self - gravitating fermions with central degeneracies ranging from @xmath61 ( i.e. mainly thermal pressure supported cores ) up to @xmath62 ( i.e. mainly degeneracy pressure supported cores ) , have flat rotation velocities @xmath63 km / s .
this is , well above any observed value .
however , since larger values of @xmath6 imply lower values for @xmath59 , as shown in table i , there is a point ( at @xmath64 and so @xmath65 ) where the _ halo _ rotation curves reach the typical observed value of @xmath66 km / s . nonetheless , since even for @xmath62 we see ( fig .
[ fig:5 ] ) that the _ halo _ radius is larger than 10 gpc with total critical mass larger than @xmath67 , this is again well above than any observed galactic halo .
we then conclude that any critical configuration belonging to this model is not able to reproduce the halo of galaxies .
moving now to a completely different size scale , this is @xmath68 pc , even though at this scales the critical core masses are of the order of the more massive supermassive black holes in the center of active galactic nuclei ( agn ) ( see table i ) , the outer part of the system is either too large or have extremely large velocities compared to observations as explained before . even inferred maser velocities on agns , with values up to 1000 km / s on a sub - parsec scale are always below the critical velocity for any value of @xmath6 as seen from fig .
[ fig:5 ] .
we conclude therefore that critical configurations of semi - degenerate self - gravitating fermions can not be used to model agns .
it is useful to find an analytical formula for the critical mass to try to understand the physics behind it . for this we will use the newtonian hydrostatic equilibrium equation corresponding to the last stable configuration , where the pressure due to gravity is balanced by a high relativistic semi - degenerate fermi gas : @xmath69 where @xmath70 is the ultra relativistic approximation of a highly relativistic fermi gas ( @xmath71 ) , which has been expanded up to second order in temperature around @xmath72 ( see e.g. @xcite ) .
we have used in [ lastequil ] the fermi energy ( @xmath73 ) with the rest energy substracted - off in consistency with the theoretical formulation of our model . considering that the density in the cores is nearly constant ( see fig . [ fig:4 ] ) ,
i.e. , @xmath74 , we can write the core radius as @xmath75 . with this
, we can rewrite ( [ lastequil ] ) as follows , @xmath76 finally , we write the central mass density as @xmath77 , where @xmath78 is the ultra - relativistic particle number density . with this expression for @xmath79 in ( [ lastequil1 ] ) we can directly give @xmath34 in terms of @xmath6 as : @xmath80 it is clear from this equation that for high central degenerate systems ( @xmath81 ) , the critical core mass @xmath34 is independent of @xmath6 and then proportional to @xmath82 .
however , for low values of the central degeneracy ( @xmath83 ) the second term in ( [ mcranalyt ] ) starts to be relevant , showing the finite temperature effects .
in fact , using @xmath84 , we have @xmath85 , just a 2% difference with the numerical result of @xmath86
. however , for @xmath87 we have @xmath88 , almost a factor 2 above the numerical value of @xmath89 obtained in table i. this shows that our approximation of an ultra - relativistic fermi gas in newtonian equilibrium breaks down and a fully relativistic treatment is needed . | we study an isothermal system of semi - degenerate self - gravitating fermions in general relativity .
such systems present mass density solutions with a central degenerate core , a plateau and a tail which follows a power law behaviour @xmath0 .
the different solutions are governed by the free parameters of the model : the degeneracy and temperature parameters at the center , and the particle mass @xmath1 .
we then analyze in detail the free parameter space for a fixed @xmath1 in the kev regime , by studying the one - parameter sequences of equilibrium configurations up to the critical point , which is represented by the maximum in a central density ( @xmath2 ) vs. core mass ( @xmath3 ) diagram .
we show that for fully degenerate cores , the known expression for the critical core mass @xmath4 is obtained , while instead for low degenerate cores , the critical core mass increases showing the temperature effects in a non linear way .
the main result of this work is that when applying this theory to model the distribution of dark matter in galaxies from the very center up to the outer halos , we do not find any critical core - halo configuration of self - gravitating fermions , which be able to explain the super massive dark object in their centers together with an outer halo simultaneously . |
abstractive summarization has gained popularity due to its ability of generating new sentences to convey the important information from text documents .
an abstractive summarizer should present the summarized information in a coherent form that is easily readable and grammatically correct .
readability or linguistic quality is an important indicator of the quality of a summary . several text - to - text ( t2 t ) generation techniques that aim to generate novel text from textual input
have been developed @xcite . however , to the best of our knowledge , none of the above methods explicitly model the role of linguistic quality and only aim at maximizing information content of the summaries . in this work ,
we address readability by assigning a log probability score from a language model as an indicator of linguistic quality . more specifically
, we build a novel optimization model for summarization that jointly maximizes information content and readability .
extractive summarizers @xcite often lose a lot of information from the input as they only `` extract '' a few important sentences from the documents to create the final summary .
we prevent information loss by aggregating information from multiple sentences .
we generate clusters of similar sentences from a collection of documents .
multi - sentence compression ( msc ) @xcite can be used to fuse information from sentences in a cluster .
however , msc might generate sentences that convey similar information from two different clusters .
by contrast , our integer linear programming ( ilp ) based approach prevents redundant information from being included in the summary using a inter - sentence redundancy constraint .
consequently , our experiments reveal that our method generates more informative and readable summaries than msc .
our proposed approach to abstractive summarization consists of the following two steps : ( 1 ) aligning similar sentences from multiple - documents and ( 2 ) generating the most informative and linguistically well - formed sentence from each cluster , and then appending them together . in multi - document summarization ,
all documents are not equally important ; some documents contain more information on the main topics in the document set .
our first step estimates the importance of a document in the whole dataset using _ lexrank _
@xcite , _ pairwise cosine similarity _ and _ overall document collection similarity_. each sentence from the most important document are initialized into separate clusters .
thereafter , each sentence from the other documents are assigned to the cluster that has the highest similarity with the sentence . in the generation step ,
we first generate a word - graph structure from the sentences in each cluster and construct @xmath0 shortest paths from the graph between the start and end nodes .
we formulate a novel integer linear programming ( ilp ) problem that maximizes the information content and linguistic quality of the generated summary .
our ilp problem represents each of the @xmath0 shortest paths as a binary variable .
the coefficients of each variable in the objective function is obtained by combining the information score of the path and the linguistic quality score .
we introduce several constraints into our ilp model .
we ensure that only one sentence is generated from each cluster .
second , we avoid redundant sentences that carry the same or similar information from different clusters .
the solution to the optimization problem decides the paths that would be included in the final abstractive summary . on the duc2004 and duc2005 datasets
, we demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed method .
our proposed method outperforms not only some popular baselines but also the state - of - the - art extractive summarization systems .
rouge scores @xcite obtained by our system outperforms the best extractive summarizer on both the datasets .
our method also outperforms an abstractive summarizer based on multi - sentence compression @xcite when measured by rouge-2 , rouge - l and rouge - su4 scores .
further , manual evaluation by human judges shows that our technique produces summaries with acceptable linguistic quality and high informativeness .
several researchers have developed abstractive summarizers .
genest and lapalme used natural - language - generation ( nlg ) systems .
however , nlg requires a lot of manual effort in terms of defining schemas as well as using deeper natural language analysis .
wang and cardie and oya _ et al . _ induced templates from the training set in their meeting summarization tasks .
such induction of templates , however , is not very effective in news summarization because of the variability in topics . unlike these methods
, our method does not induce any templates but generates summaries in an unsupervised manner by combining information from several sentences on the same topic .
berg - kirkpatrick _ et al . _
used an ilp formulation that jointly extracts and compresses sentences to generate summaries .
however , their method is supervised and requires significant manual effort to define features for subtree deletions , which is required to compress sentences .
graph - based techniques have also been very popular in summarization .
et al . _ employed a graph - based approach to generate concise abstractive summaries from highly redundant opinions . compared with their opinionated texts such as product reviews ,
the target documents in multi - document summarization do not contain such high level of redundancy .
more recently , mehdad _ et al . _ proposed a supervised approach for meeting summarization , in which they generate an entailment graph of sentences .
the nodes in the graph are the linked sentences and edges are the entailment relations between nodes ; such relations help to identify non - redundant and informative sentences .
their fusion approach used msc @xcite , which generates an informative sentence by combining several sentences in a word - graph structure .
however , filippova s method produces low linguistic quality as the ranking of generated sentences is based on edge weights calculated only using word collocations . by contrast , our method selects sentences by jointly maximizing informativeness and readability and generates informative , well - formed and readable summaries .
figure [ approach - general ] shows our proposed abstractive summarization approach , which consists of the following two steps : * _ sentence clustering _ , * _ summary sentence generation_. given a document set @xmath1 , that consists of @xmath2 documents ( @xmath3 , @xmath4 , @xmath5 , ... , @xmath6 ) , our approach first generates @xmath7 clusters ( @xmath8 , @xmath9 , @xmath10 , ... , @xmath11 ) of similar sentences , and then use the individual clusters to create word - graphs .
a maximum of one novel sentence is generated from each word - graph with the goal of maximizing information content and linguistic quality of the entire summary .
the sentence clustering step ( s1 ) has two important components : the first ( s1 - 1 ) identifies the most important document @xmath12 in @xmath1 before the final cluster generation step ( s1 - 2 ) that generates clusters of similar sentences .
we experiment with several techniques to identify @xmath12 , and then align sentences from other documents to the sentences in @xmath12 .
it proves to be a simple , yet effective technique for generating clusters containing similar information .
our approach is inspired by the findings of wan that showed how the incorporation of document impact can improve the performance of summarization . in ( s2 ) , we create a directed word - graph structure from the sentences in each cluster . in the word - graph ,
the nodes represent the words and the edges define the adjacency relations in the sentences . from the word - graph ,
multiple paths between the start and the end nodes can be extracted .
we extract @xmath0 shortest paths from each cluster , and finally retain the paths that maximize information content and linguistic quality using an ilp based approach .
we impose constraints on the maximum number of sentences that are generated from each cluster and also impose constraints to avoid redundancies such that similar information from different clusters are not included in the summary .
information content is measured using textrank @xcite , which scores sentences based on the presence of keywords .
we measure linguistic quality using a 3-gram language model that assigns confidence values to sequences of words in the sentences . in this section ,
we describe both steps s1 and s2 .
we initialize clusters of sentences using each sentence from the most important document , @xmath12 , in a document set @xmath1 .
our intuition behind this approach is that @xmath12 consists of the most important content relevant across all the documents in @xmath1 . in other words ,
the document that is most close to the central content of the collection is the most informative .
we propose several techniques to identify @xmath12 .
* lexrank ( @xmath13 ) : * lexrank @xcite constructs a graph of sentences where the edge weights are obtained by the inter - sentence cosine similarities . while the original lexrank constructs a graph of sentences ,
we construct a graph of documents to compute document importance .
equation ( [ lpr - equation2 ] ) shows how lexrank scores are computed using weighted links between the nodes ( documents ) .
this equation measures the salience of a node in the graph , which is the importance of the document in the entire document collection .
let @xmath14 be the centrality of node @xmath15 .
lexrank is then defined as follows : @xmath16}\frac{\textrm{idf - modified - cosine}(u , v)}{\sum_{z\in adj[v]}\textrm{idf - modified - cosine}(z , v)}p(v),$}\ ] ] where @xmath17 $ ] and @xmath18 are the set of nodes that are adjacent to @xmath15 and the total number of nodes in the graph , respectively .
the damping factor @xmath19 is usually set to 0.85 , and we set @xmath19 to this value in our implementation .
@xmath12 is determined as the document that has the highest lexrank score in @xmath1 once the above equation converges .
* pairwise cosine similarity ( @xmath20 ) : * this method computes the average cosine similarity between the target document @xmath21 and the other documents in the dataset .
the average similarity is calculated using the following formula : @xmath22 where @xmath23 denotes the number of documents in the document set @xmath1 . *
overall document collection similarity ( @xmath24 ) : * this method computes the cosine similarity between the target document and the whole document set .
we create the whole document set by concatenating text from all the documents in @xmath1 .
this method is defined as follows : @xmath25 in @xmath26 , @xmath27 , and @xmath28 mentioned above , we select the document @xmath12 with the highest score as the most important one in the dataset @xmath1 .
next , we generate the clusters by aligning sentences and re - ordering them based on original positions of the sentences in the documents .
the sentences from each of the other documents ( @xmath29 ) in @xmath1 are assigned to the clusters one - by - one based on cosine similarity measure .
our approach computes pairwise cosine similarity of each sentence in @xmath21 to all the sentences in @xmath12 .
for example , a sentence in @xmath21 , @xmath30 has the highest similarity with @xmath31 , a sentence in @xmath12 .
then , we assign @xmath30 to cluster @xmath32 , in which @xmath31 was initially assigned . some sentences in @xmath21 might not be similar to any of the sentences in @xmath12 .
hence , we only align sentences when the similarity @xmath33 .
further , we only retain clusters that have at least @xmath34 sentences , assuming that a content is relevant only if it exists in half of the documents in @xmath1 .
* cluster ordering : * we implement two _ cluster ordering _ techniques that reorder clusters based on the original position of the sentences in the documents . 1 .
_ majority ordering ( mo ) : _ given two clusters , @xmath35 and @xmath32 , the set of common documents from which the sentences are assigned to the two clusters are identified .
if @xmath35 and @xmath32 have sentences @xmath30 and @xmath36 ( @xmath37 ) , respectively , where @xmath21 is the common document , then @xmath35 precedes @xmath32 . the final order is determined based on overall precedence of the sentences of one cluster over the others .
_ average position ordering ( apo ) : _ the sentences @xmath38 in any cluster @xmath35 are each assigned a normalized score . for example , the normalized score of @xmath39 is computed as the ratio of the original position of the sentence and the total number of sentences in @xmath21 ( here , @xmath39 belongs to document @xmath21 ) . when ordering two clusters , the cluster that has the lower score obtained by averaging the normalized scores of all the sentences is ranked higher than the others . in order to generate a one - sentence representation from a cluster of redundant sentences , we use multi - sentence compression .
we generate multiple sentences from a cluster using a word - graph @xcite .
suppose that a cluster @xmath35 contains @xmath40 sentences , @xmath41 . a directed graph is created by adding sentences from @xmath42 to the graph in an iterative fashion .
each sentence is connected to dummy _ start _ and _ end _ nodes to mark the beginning and ending of the sentences .
the vertices or nodes are the words along with the parts - of - speech ( pos ) tags .
we connect adjacent words in the sentences with directed edges .
once the first sentence is added , words from the following sentences are mapped onto a node in the graph provided that they have exactly the same word form and the same pos tag .
the sequence of rules used for the word - graph construction is as follows : the context of the words are taken into consideration if multiple mappings are possible , and the word is mapped to that node that has the highest directed context .
we also add punctuations to the graph .
figure [ fig : word - graph - generation ] shows a simple example of the word - graph generation technique .
we do not show pos and punctuations in the figure for clarity .
consider the following two sentences as an illustration of our generation approach : as shown in the examples above , the two sentences contain similar information , but they are syntactically different .
the solid directed arrows connect the nodes in eg.1 , whereas the dotted arrows join the nodes in eg.2 .
we can obtain several shortest paths between the start and end nodes . in figure
[ fig : word - graph - generation ] , we highlight one such path using gray rectangles .
several other paths are possible , for example : the original input sentences from the cluster are also valid paths between the _ start _ and _ end _ nodes .
to ensure pure abstractive summarization , we remove such paths that are same or very similar ( cosine similarity @xmath43 0.8 ) to any of the original sentences in the cluster .
similar to filippova s word - graph construction , we set the minimum path length ( in words ) to eight to avoid incomplete sentences .
finally , we retain a maximum of 200 randomly selected paths from each cluster to reduce computational overload of the ilp based approach .
our aim is to select the best path from all available paths . from 200 paths in each cluster ,
we choose at most one path that maximizes information content and linguistic quality together .
let @xmath44 be each path in a cluster @xmath32 , namely , @xmath45 , where the total number of shortest paths is equal to @xmath0=@xmath46 $ ] where @xmath47 refers to the maximum number of paths that can be generated from a cluster .
we argue that the shortest paths that we select in the final summary should be informative as well as linguistically readable .
hence , we introduce two factors _ informativeness _ ( @xmath48 ) and _ linguistic quality _
( @xmath49 ) . [ cols="<,^,^,<,^,^ " , ] * informativeness : * in principle
, we can use any existing method that computes the importance of a sentence to define _ informativeness_. in our model , we use textrank scores @xcite to generate an importance value of a sentence within a cluster .
textrank creates a graph of words from the sentences .
the score of each node in the graph is calculated as shown in equation ( [ lpr - textrank ] ) : where @xmath50 represents the words , @xmath51 denotes the adjacent nodes of @xmath50 and @xmath19 is the damping factor set to 0.85 .
the computation converges to return final word importance scores .
the informativeness score of a path ( @xmath48 ) is obtained by adding the importance scores of the individual words in the path . *
linguistic quality : * in order to compute _ linguistic quality _
, we use a language model .
more specifically , we use a 3-gram ( trigram ) language model that assigns probabilities to sequence of words .
suppose that a path contains a sequence of @xmath52 words @xmath53 .
the score @xmath49 assigned to each path is defined as follows : where @xmath54 is defined as : as can be seen from equation ( [ eqn : ll ] ) , we obtain the conditional probability of different sets of 3-grams in the sentence .
the scores are combined and averaged by @xmath55 , the number of conditional probabilities computed .
the @xmath56 scores are negative ; with higher magnitude implying lower readability .
therefore , in equation ( [ eqn : ll2 ] ) , we take the reciprocal of the logarithmic value with smoothing to compute @xmath49 . in our experiments
, we used a 3-gram model that is trained on the english gigaword corpus[multiblock footnote omitted ] . to select the best paths from the clusters , we combine informativeness @xmath48 and linguistic quality @xmath49 in an optimization framework .
we maximize the following objective function : each @xmath44 represents a binary variable , that can take 0 or 1 , depending on whether the path is selected in the final summary or not .
in addition , @xmath57 , the number of tokens in a path , is also taken into consideration and the term @xmath58 assigns more weight to shorter paths so that the system can favor shorter informative sentences .
we introduce several constraints to solve the problem .
first , we ensure that a maximum of one path is selected from each cluster using equation ( [ eqn : maxone ] ) .
we introduce equation ( [ eqn : sim ] ) so that we can prevent similar information ( cosine similarity @xmath43 0.5 ) from being selected from different clusters . in figure
[ fig : word - graph - generation ] , this constraint ensures that only one of the several possible paths mentioned in the example is included in the final summary as they contain redundant information .
we evaluated our approach on the duc 2004 and 2005 datasets on multi - document summarization .
we use rouge ( recall - oriented understudy of gisting evaluation ) @xcite for automatic evaluation of summaries ( compared against human - written model summaries ) as it has been proven effective in measuring qualities of summaries and correlates well to human judgments .
we proposed three document importance measures and two different sentence ordering techniques as described in section [ sec : method ] .
hence , we have six different systems in total . to the best of our knowledge ,
no publicly available abstractive summarizers have been used on the duc dataset .
therefore , we compare our system to msc @xcite that generates a sentence from a collection of similar sentences using only syntactical information from the source sentences . in msc ,
the input is a pre - defined cluster of similar sentences .
therefore , we compare our ilp based technique with msc using the same set of input clusters obtained by our system . table [ table : comprouge ] shows the following rouge scores for our evaluation : the summaries generated by the baselines and the state - of - the - art extractive summarizers on the duc 2004 data were collected from @xcite .
rouge-2 and rouge - su4 scores have been found to be highly correlated with human judgments @xcite .
therefore , we computed rouge-2 and rouge - su4 scores of the other systems on the duc2004 summaries directly using rouge . however , the system - generated summaries ( baselines and state - of - the - arts ) were not available for the duc 2005 dataset .
hence , we used rouge scores of the various systems as reported in @xcite . according to table [
table : comprouge ] , all of the rouge scores obtained by our systems outperform all the baselines on both datasets . hereafter , we refer to the best performing system as * ilpsumm*. we perform paired t - test and observe that ilpsumm shows statistical significance compared to all the baselines .
the summarization method using @xmath59 measure as the most informative document and ranked by majority ordering ( mo ) outperforms all of the other techniques .
the document that has the highest similarity to the total content captures the central idea of the documents .
the clustering scheme that works best with msc is @xmath13 + apo .
ilpsumm also outperforms the msc - based method , i.e. , our approach can generate more informative summaries by globally maximizing content selection from multiple clusters of sentences . in summary , content selection of our proposed abstractive systems work at par with the best extractive systems .
* discussion : * our proposed system identifies the most important document , which is a general human strategy for summarization .
the majority ordering strategy prioritizes clusters that contain sentences which should be mentioned earlier in a summary .
other systems tackle redundancy as a final step ; however , we integrate linguistic quality and informativeness to select the best sentences in the summary using our ilp based approach .
we performed the rest of our experiments only on the duc 2004 dataset as it has been widely used for multi - document summarization .
we also determine readability of the generated summaries by obtaining ratings from human judges . following liu and liu ,
we ask 10 evaluators to rate 10 sets of four summaries on two different factors _ informativeness _ and _ linguistic quality_. the ratings range from 1 ( lowest ) to 5 ( highest ) .
all the evaluators have a good command of english and seven of them are native speakers .
evaluators were asked to rate the summaries based on informativeness ( the amount of information conveyed ) and linguistic quality ( readability of the summary ) .
we randomized the sets of summaries to avoid any bias .
0.52l|cc|c * type * & * inf * & * lq * & * avg.ll * + human written & 4.42 & 4.35 & -129.02 + extractive ( dpp ) & 3.90 & 3.81 & -142.70 + abstractive ( msc ) & 3.78 & 2.83 & -210.02 + abstractive ( ilpsumm ) & 4.10 & 3.63 & -180.76 + the four summaries provided to the evaluators are human - written summary ( one summary collected randomly from four model - summaries per cluster ) , extractive summary ( dpp ) , abstractive summary generated using msc ( msc ) and abstractive summary generated using our ilp based method ( ilpsumm ) .
we asked each evaluator to complete 10 such tasks , each containing four summaries as explained above .
we normalize ratings of different evaluators to the same scale .
table [ tab : humaneval ] shows the results obtained by manual evaluation .
according to the judges , the linguistic quality of * ilpsumm * ( 3.63 ) is significantly better than that of * msc * ( 2.83 ) .
further , our summaries ( ilpsumm ) are more informative than dpp ( 3.90 ) and msc ( 3.78 ) .
dpp is extractive in nature , hence linguistically , the sentences are generally more readable . to obtain a coarse estimate of grammaticality
, we also compute the confidence scores of the summaries using the stanford dependency parser @xcite .
a language model assigns probabilities to sequence of words ; in contrast , the confidence score of a parser assigns probabilities to grammatical relations .
the values ( the lower the magnitude , the better ) are shown in the column _ avg.ll_. _
avg.ll _ obtained by ilpsumm ( -180.76 ) is better than that obtained by msc ( -210.02 ) , indicating that the language model based linguistic quality estimation helps generate more readable summaries than the msc method .
table [ tab : samplesumm ] shows a comparison of summaries from the different systems using the duc 2004 dataset . as can be seen , the linguistic quality of the abstractive summaries ( ilpsumm ) is acceptable , and the content is well - formed and informative . our ilp framework can combine information from various sentences and present a fairly well - formed readable summary .
p0.45 ' '' '' * abstractive summary ( ilpsumm ) : * hun sen s cambodian people s party won 64 of the 122 parliamentary seats in july .
opposition ally sam rainsy charged that hun sen s party has rejected allegations of intimidation and fraud .
hun sen and ranariddh are to form working groups this week to divide remaining government posts . but
a deal reached between hun sen and his chief rival , prince norodom ranariddh s ally , sam rainsy . +
* extractive summary ( dpp ) : * ranariddh and sam rainsy have charged that hun sen s victory in the elections was achieved through widespread fraud .
hun sen said his current government would remain in power as long as the opposition refused to form a new one .
cambodian leader hun sen , who heads the cpp , has offered to share the legislature s top job with the royalist funcinpec party of prince norodom ranariddh in order to break the impasse . + * human - written summary : * cambodian prime minister hun sen rejects demands of 2 opposition parties for talks in beijing after failing to win a 2/3 majority in recent elections .
sihanouk refuses to host talks in beijing .
opposition parties ask the asian development bank to stop loans to hun sen s government .
ccp defends hun sen to the us senate .
funcinpec refuses to share the presidency .
hun sen and ranariddh eventually form a coalition at summit convened by sihanouk . ' '' '' ' '' '' * abstractive summary ( ilpsumm ) : * lebanese foreign minister kamal kharrazi made the mediation offer sunday , in a telephone conversation with his syrian counterpart , farouk al - sharaa .
egyptian president hosni mubarak met here sunday with syrian president hafez assad to show lebanon s support for syria and turkey . in a show of force on friday
, turkish troops were deployed this week on the turkish - syrian border to eradicate krudish rebel bases .
+ * extractive summary ( dpp ) : * egyptian president hosni mubarak met here sunday with syrian president hafez assad to try to defuse growing tension between syria and turkey .
the talks in damascus came as turkey has massed forces near the border with syria after threatening to eradicate kurdish rebel bases in the neighboring country .
egypt already has launched a mediation effort to try to prevent a military confrontation over turkish allegations that syria is harboring turkish kurdish rebels . +
* human - written summary : * tensions between syria and turkey increased as turkey sent 10,000 troops to its border with syria . the dispute comes amid accusations by turkey that syria helping kurdish rebels based in syria .
kurdish rebels have been conducting cross border raids into turkey in an effort to gain kurdish autonomy in the region . ' '' '' * error analysis : * there is still room for improvement in the linguistic quality of the generated summaries .
we analyzed the summaries that were given lower ratings than the other options on the basis of linguistic quality .
consider the following sentence in a system generated summary , which received low scores from human judges : as can be seen , the phrase `` killed 270 people killed '' is not coherent .
the language model fails to identify such cases as the 3-gram sequences of _ killed 270 people _ and _ 270 people killed _ are both grammatically coherent .
in addition to a language model , we can also use a dependency parser to assign lower weights to paths that have redundant dependencies on the same nodes . consider the following example : + the last phrase `` a government formed '' , is grammatically incoherent in the context of the sentence .
linguistically correct modifications could be
_ a government being formed _ or _ a government formation_. in future work , we plan to address such issues of grammaticality using dependency parses of sentences rather than just adjacency relations when building the word - graph .
we have proposed an approach to generate abstractive summaries from a document collection .
we capture the redundant information using a simple yet effective clustering technique .
we proposed a novel ilp based technique to select the best shortest paths in a word - graph to maximize information content and linguistic quality of a summary .
experimental results on the duc 2004 and 2005 datasets show that our proposed approach outperforms all the baselines and the state - of - the - art extractive summarizers . based on human judgments ,
our abstractive summaries are linguistically preferable than the baseline abstractive summarization technique . in future work
, we plan to use paraphrasing techniques to further enhance quality of the generated summaries .
we also plan to address phrase level redundancies to improve coherence .
this material is based upon work supported by the national science foundation under grant no . 0845487 . | abstractive summarization is an ideal form of summarization since it can synthesize information from multiple documents to create concise informative summaries . in this work
, we aim at developing an abstractive summarizer .
first , our proposed approach identifies the most important document in the multi - document set .
the sentences in the most important document are aligned to sentences in other documents to generate clusters of similar sentences .
second , we generate @xmath0-shortest paths from the sentences in each cluster using a word - graph structure . finally , we select sentences from the set of shortest paths generated from all the clusters employing a novel integer linear programming ( ilp ) model with the objective of maximizing information content and readability of the final summary .
our ilp model represents the shortest paths as binary variables and considers the length of the path , information score and linguistic quality score in the objective function .
experimental results on the duc 2004 and 2005 multi - document summarization datasets show that our proposed approach outperforms all the baselines and state - of - the - art extractive summarizers as measured by the rouge scores .
our method also outperforms a recent abstractive summarization technique . in manual evaluation ,
our approach also achieves promising results on informativeness and readability . |
although the @xmath0cdm model is quite successful on supragalactic scales@xcite , its predictions of galactic properties differ markedly with observation .
there has been an excellent fit to observations over 1 mpc by flat cosmological models with a mixture of baryons , dark matter and the cosmological constant .
however , on smaller scales on the order of galaxy and subgalactic , simulations have failed with the assumption that cold dark matter has weak self - interactions and weak baryonic interactions .
cold dark matter should form triaxial halos with dense cores and other dense halo substructures . yet
it has been found that central regions on galactic scales have nearly spherical low density cores
. also dwarf irregular galaxies have low density cores with shallower profiles than predicted .
high surface brightness galaxies have persistence of bars that imply that galaxies such as our own milky way also have low density cores .
our local group has less than one hundred galaxies while theory and simulations predict about one thousand discrete dark matter halos .
these and other problems led spergel and steinhardt to propose that there was a feedback relation so that dark matter could see itself@xcite .
they proposed cold dark matter that is self - interacting with a large scattering cross section and negligible annihilation or dissipation .
their key proposal was a mean free path in the range of @xmath1 kpc to @xmath1 mpc at the solar radius , where the dark matter density is @xmath2 .
they estimated dark matter in the range @xmath3 mev .
after further analysis they came up with a dark matter particle very much like an ordinary hadron .
although this may solve problems with rotation curves and too numerous sub - clumps in large dark matter halo simulations @xcite , most of the other difficulties remain .
simulations of galaxy formation usually start with a set of hot gravitating point particles with given initial conditions which are then stepped forward in time using huge computer resources .
the jeans mass is thought to be the point at which gravity overcomes pressure and expansion to form galactic structure .
collapse dynamics produces different post collapse densities , circular speeds and disk asymmetries .
since this approach has resulted in many virtually insurmountable problems which have recently been compiled by sellwood and kosowsky @xcite , another approach is necessary for galaxy formation .
in a previous paper @xcite , there was a model of a hot and cold baryon bounce in the big bang . in this paper
is an explanation of how a shell of cold baryonic matter could became galactic black holes and how the hot expanding core was captured by these newly formed black holes . the deeper the gravitational wells , the higher the velocity and mass of hot hydrogen - helium that could be captured .
one of the earliest spiral galaxy correlations involved the tully - fisher relation which originated in 1977 .
@xmath4 where @xmath5 is the characteristic spiral galaxy luminosity and @xmath6 is the circular velocity @xmath7 .
this equation is most accurate in the infra - red range and thus @xmath8 .
mass is proportional to luminosity ( from captured hydrogen and helium).the corresponding relation for elliptical galaxies is the faber - jackson relation . @xmath9 the fundamental plane relations using @xmath10 has increased the accuracy of faber - jackson .
the luminous diameter @xmath11 is defined as the diameter within the galaxy with mean surface brightness and @xmath12 the internal velocity dispersion .
subsequently , ferrarese and meritt found a very tight correlation in both elliptical and spiral galaxies between the galactic supermassive black hole masses @xmath13 and the velocity dispersions of an elliptical galaxy or the spiral bulge velocities @xmath14@xcite .
@xmath15 ferrarese and merritt have found that this correlation is so precise that only measurement errors are contained .
this then is the fundamental relation for galaxy formation and further work in this paper will be based on it .
there are too many close correlations to utilize collapse dynamics at any rate .
a more logical starting place is the supermassive galactic black holes .
hot big bang models , with the history of a scale factor close to a singularity , could not produce such galaxies all with corresponding rotational energies .
outside the immediate area of black hole influence , capturing of matter streaming to the area of influence of each black hole is due to the amount of energy each particle possesses .
large kinetic energies result in hyperbolic or parabolic type orbits with the ability to escape the gravitational well .
lower energies result in stable elliptical or circular orbits .
@xmath16 where e is the total energy , both kinetic and potential .
@xmath17 is the angular momentum , @xmath18 is the central nuclear mass and and @xmath19 is the rotational mass .
the matter that can be captured will have a total kinetic energy less than the potential energy .
matter with more energy than this , such as hyperbolic or parabolic orbits will be considered as having too much energy for capture in a galactic well of this size .
the orbits are differentiated by the following equation from classical mechanics@xcite based on the energy and angular momentum .
@xmath20 if @xmath21 and @xmath22 , the orbit is a hyperbola and the matter contains enough energy to escape the galactic well . if @xmath23 and @xmath24 , the orbit is a parabola and the matter may escape . if @xmath25 and @xmath26 , the orbit is an ellipse and the matter has not the energy to escape the galactic gravity .
circular orbits where @xmath27 and @xmath28 have even less energy . since matter that is surely captured has the potential energy greater than the kinetic , @xmath29 and @xmath25 . expanding the total kinetic energy @xmath30 in the equation for @xmath31 ,
@xmath32 we want @xmath25 and real .
if we let the angular momentum @xmath33 and @xmath34 , the equation for @xmath31 is @xmath35 to simplify this equation , we can use @xmath36 .
the equation for @xmath31 becomes @xmath37 from rotational newtonian physics @xmath38 , then then the galactic well will deepen as @xmath39 or @xmath40 .
the last term in equation 9 becomes @xmath41 .
when this term is dominant , it will allow capturing matter with @xmath42 to increase as the fourth power when the galactic black hole @xmath18 increases . the black hole capturing cross sectional area @xmath43 since both scale as @xmath44 .
to explain why the tully - fisher and ferrarese - merritt equations do not exactly relate the galactic luminosity or nuclear black hole mass to the circular velocity to the fourth power , we note the following . during galaxy formation matter
will be accreted onto the galactic nucleus depending on collisional losses , ionized plasma repulsion and magnetic interference .
any of these factors along with a trajectory directed within ten schwarzschild radii of the nucleus ( as described below ) , will lead to accretion with resultant quasar or active galactic nuclear manifestations .
some decrease in the fourth power of circular velocity will result in tully - fisher equations as well as an increase in ferrarese - merritt as matter is transferred to the black hole .
elliptical galaxies , probably formed by galactic mergers , still can exhibit similar properties .
effective potential for motion in schwarzschild geometry@xcite with a mass @xmath18 , energy in units of rest mass @xmath45 of the particle is @xmath46 and angular momentum is @xmath47 .
the quantity @xmath48 in the next equations is the schwarzschild coordinate .
@xmath49 and therefore @xmath50 stable orbits are possible for @xmath51 .
it should be remembered that the above equations are for nonrotating or slowly rotating black holes . for an unbound orbit ,
the impact parameter @xmath52 is @xmath53 the capturing cross section for a nonrelativistic particle @xmath54 where @xmath55 is the velocity relative to light . for relativistic particles
could cold baryons be the proverbial dark matter ? there is much evidence that this is indeed the case . with entirely hot models of the big bang such as inflation
, no such possibility could be considered . yet
a cold baryonic shell along with hot core baryons at the big bang can explain nucleosynthesis @xcite as well as galaxy formation .
the following galaxy formation problems@xcite are solved by the capture of core and shell baryons by primordial supermassive black holes originating in the shell .
an entirely baryonic model explains why the circular orbital speed from luminous matter , which dominates the inner regions , is so similar to dark matter at larger radii . with many stars in the center areas , initial conditions for dark and luminous matter no longer have to be closely adjusted to produce a flat rotation curve .
a core based blast wave captured by the same size black holes explains why there are similiar circular speeds in all galaxies of a given luminosity no matter how the luminous matter is spaced . the overall mass to light ratio rises with decreasing surface brightness so as to preserve the tully - fisher relation between total luminosity and circular speed . the depth of the gravitational well determines the circular speed and luminosity as noted above .
the hot and cold matter discrepancies are detectable only at accelerations below @xmath57 since they are all baryons .
the halo parameters are related to the luminous mass distribution since all were captured by a given size black hole .
the angular momentum of collapse models are an order of magnitude less than that observed since collapse dynamics were never involved .
the peak phase space density of the halo varies so markedly .
this is the case since baryonic dark matter is not collisionless and not homogeneously distributed .
both shell and core baryons are included .
the predicted circular speed at a given luminosity is high .
this is caused by the capture with the slower velocity matter gaining kinetic energy during a fall into the gravitational well .
it is not directly related to mass to light ratio or halo density .
the number of predicted subclumps in the halos is so much greater than observed as well as predicted clumps compared to satellite galaxies because of capturing rather than collapse dyamics .
the luminosity is related to circular velocity to the fourth power .
the galaxy formation process is so efficient because the black holes acted like vacuum cleaners removing intergalactic and intercluster matter as the universe expanded .
supermassive black holes @xmath58 , the great attractor can be formed from shell fragments .
it takes a different model of the big bang to solve seemingly insurmountable problems of galaxy formation .
evidence for early galaxy formation at @xmath59 in hubble and deep herschel fields has been published@xcite .
this model views the cosmic background radiation as mostly recaptured accretion photons .
the big bang does not having the energy to disturb its planck spectrum .
thus the cbr does not reflect the picture at matter and energy decoupling .
hopefully , a baryon bounce model will be now given a fair consideration . | the tight correlation of galactic velocity distribution to both luminosity and black hole mass , the relation of halo parameters to luminous mass distribution can not be due to collapse dynamics .
a baryonic big bang shell can solve galaxy formation problems by forming the supermassive black holes necessary to capture the initial blast wave in a coordinated pattern . |
searches for evidence of nonextensive @xcite , @xcite properties at the period - doubling onset of chaos in logistic maps - the feigenbaum attractor - have at all times yielded affirmative responses , from the initial numerical studies @xcite , to subsequent heuristic investigations @xcite , and the more recent rigorous results robledo1 , @xcite . however a critical analysis and a genuine understanding of the basis for the validity at this attractor of the nonextensive generalization @xcite , @xcite of the boltzmann - gibbs ( bg ) statistical mechanics - here referred as @xmath0-statistics - is until now lacking . here
we clarify the circumstances under which the features of @xmath0-statistics are observed and , most importantly , we demonstrate that the mechanism by means of which the tsallis entropic index @xmath2 arises is provided by the occurrence of dynamical phase transitions of the kind described by the formalism of mori and colleagues @xcite .
these transitions , similar to first order thermal phase transitions , are associated to trajectories that link different regions within a multifractal attractor .
the onset of chaos is an incipiently chaotic attractor , with memory preserving , nonmixing , phase space trajectories . because many of its properties are familiar , and well understood since many years ago
, it is of interest to explain how previous knowledge fits in with the new perspective .
the feigenbaum attractor is the classic one - dimensional critical attractor with universal properties in the renormalization group ( rg ) sense , i.e. shared by all unimodal ( one hump ) maps with the same degree of nonlinearity .
the static or geometrical properties of this attractor are understood since long ago @xcite - @xcite , and are represented , for example , by the generalized dimensions @xmath3 or the spectrum of dimensions @xmath4 that characterize the multifractal set @xcite , @xcite .
the dynamical properties that involve positions within the attractor also display universality and , as we see below , these are conveniently given in terms of the discontinuities in feigenbaum s trajectory scaling function @xmath1 that measures the convergence of positions in the orbits of period @xmath5 as @xmath6 @xcite .
let us first recall that the feigenbaum attractor has a vanishing ordinary lyapunov coefficient @xmath7 and that the sensitivity to initial conditions @xmath8 does not converge to any single - valued function and displays fluctuations that grow indefinitely grassberger1 , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite . for initial positions at the attractor
@xmath8 develops a universal self - similar temporal structure and its envelope grows with @xmath9 as a power law grassberger1 , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite .
we are interested here in determining the detailed dependence of the aforementioned structure on _ both _ the initial position @xmath10 and the observation time @xmath9 as this dependence is preserved by the infinitely lasting memory .
therefore we shall not consider the effect of averaging with respect to @xmath10 and/or @xmath9 , explored in other studies @xcite @xcite , as this would obscure the fine points of the dynamics .
the central assertion of the @xmath0-statistics with regards to the dynamics of critical attractors is a sensitivity to initial conditions @xmath8 associated to the @xmath0-exponential functional form , i.e. the @xmath0-deformed exponential function @xmath11^{-1/(q-1)}$ ] . from such @xmath12 a @xmath0-generalized lyapunov coefficient @xmath13 can be determined just as @xmath7 is read from an exponential @xmath8 .
the @xmath13 is presumed to satisfy a @xmath0-generalized identity @xmath14 @xcite @xcite where @xmath15 is an entropy production rate based on the tsallis entropy @xmath16 , defined in terms of the @xmath0-logarithmic function @xmath17 , the inverse of @xmath18 . unlike @xmath7 for ( ergodic ) chaotic attractors , the coefficient @xmath13 is dependent on the initial position @xmath10 and therefore @xmath13 constitutes a spectrum ( and also @xmath15 ) that can be examined by varying this position .
the _ fixed _ values of the entropic index @xmath0 are obtained from the universality class parameters to which the attractor belongs . for the simpler pitchfork and tangent bifurcations
there is a single well - defined value for the index @xmath0 for each type of attractor as a single @xmath0-exponential describes the sensitivity @xcite . for multifractal critical attractors
the situation is more complicated and there appear to be a multiplicity of indexes @xmath0 but with precise values given by the attractor scaling functions .
as shown below , the sensitivity takes the form of a family of interweaved @xmath0-exponentials .
the @xmath0-indexes appear in conjugate pairs , @xmath0 and @xmath19 , as these correspond to switching starting and finishing trajectory positions .
we show that @xmath0 and @xmath20 are related to the occurrence of pairs of dynamical @xmath0-phase transitions that connect qualitatively different regions of the attractor @xcite @xcite .
these transitions are identified as the source of the special values for the entropic index @xmath0 . for the feigenbaum attractor
an infinite family of such transitions take place but of rapidly decreasing strength . in the following section we recall the essential features of the statistical - mechanical formalism of mori and colleagues @xcite to study dynamical phase transitions in attractors of nonlinear maps and follow this by a summary of expressions of the @xmath0-statistics .
then , in subsequent sections we present known properties and develop others for the dynamics within the feigenbaum attractor . amongst these
we derive the sensitivity @xmath12 in terms of the trajectory scaling function @xmath1 , and use this to make contact with both mori s and tsallis schemes .
we discuss our results .
during the late 1980 s mori and coworkers developed a comprehensive thermodynamic formalism to characterize drastic changes at bifurcations and at other singular phenomena in low dimensional maps @xcite .
the formalism was further adapted to study critical attractors and was illustrated by considering the specific case of the period - doubling onset of chaos in the logistic map @xcite , @xcite , @xcite . for critical attactors the scheme involves the evaluation of fluctuations of the generalized finite - time lyapunov coefficient @xmath21 where @xmath22 is here the logistic map , or its extension to non - linearity of order @xmath23 , @xmath24 we denote by @xmath25 the value of the control parameter @xmath26 at the onset of chaos , with @xmath27 . notice the replacement of the customary @xmath9 by @xmath28 in eq .
( [ lyapunovdef ] ) , as the ordinary lyapunov coefficient @xmath7 vanishes for critical attractors , here at @xmath29 , @xmath30 .
the density distribution for the values of @xmath31 , at @xmath32 , @xmath33 , is written in the form @xcite
@xcite @xmath34 where @xmath35 is a concave spectrum of the fluctuations of @xmath36 with minimum @xmath37 and is obtained as the legendre transform of the free energy function @xmath38 , defined as @xmath39 where @xmath40 is the dynamic partition function @xmath41 the coarse - grained function of generalized lyapunov coefficients @xmath42 and the variance @xmath43 of @xmath44 are given , respectively , by @xmath45 @xcite @xcite .
notice the special weight @xmath46 in @xmath40 and in the quantities derived from it .
the functions @xmath38 and @xmath35 are the dynamic counterparts of the renyi dimensions @xmath3 and the spectrum @xmath47 that characterize the geometric structure of the attractor @xcite . as with ordinary thermal 1st order phase transitions , a
@xmath0-phase
transition is indicated by a section of linear slope @xmath48 in the spectrum ( free energy ) @xmath35 , a discontinuity at @xmath49 in the lyapunov function ( order parameter ) @xmath50 , and a divergence at @xmath0 in the variance ( susceptibility ) @xmath43 . for the onset of chaos at @xmath51 a single @xmath0-phase transition
was numerically determined @xcite - @xcite and found to occur at a value close to @xmath52 .
arguments were provided mori1 - @xcite for this value to be @xmath53 , where @xmath54 is one of the feigenbaum s universal constants .
our analysis below shows that this initial result gives a broad picture of the dynamics at the feigenbaum attractor and that actually an infinite family of @xmath0-phase transitions of decreasing magnitude takes place at @xmath29 .
independently , tsallis and colleagues proposed @xcite that for critical attractors the sensitivity to initial conditions @xmath8 ( defined as @xmath55 where @xmath56 is the initial separation of two orbits and @xmath57 that at time @xmath9 ) , has the form @xmath58 , \label{sensitivity1}\ ] ] that yields the customary exponential @xmath8 with @xmath7 when @xmath59 . in eq .
( [ sensitivity1 ] ) @xmath0 is the entropic index and the initial - position - dependent @xmath60 are the @xmath0-generalized lyapunov coefficients .
tsallis and colleagues also suggested @xcite that the identity @xmath61
@xmath7 @xcite , where the rate of entropy production @xmath62 is given by @xmath63 and @xmath64 for an ensemble of trajectories with instantaneous distribution @xmath65 , would be generalized to @xmath66 @xmath13 , where the @xmath0-generalized rate of entropy production @xmath15 is defined via @xmath67 and where @xmath68 is the tsallis entropy .
these properties have been corroborated to hold at @xmath69 numerically @xcite , @xcite for sets of trajectories with @xmath10 spread throughout @xmath70 and analytically for specific classes of trajectories starting near @xmath71 and observed at specific times of the form @xmath72 , @xmath73 and @xmath74 @xcite - @xcite .
we explain the rationale for these particular choices of @xmath10 and @xmath9 in the following section where we examine the structure of trajectories inside the attractor .
see fig . 1 .
in fig . 1a we have plotted ( in logarithmic scales ) the first few absolute values of iterated positions @xmath75 of the orbit at @xmath76 starting at @xmath71 where the labels indicate iteration time @xmath9 .
notice the structure of horizontal bands , and that in the top band lie half of the attractor positions ( odd times ) , in the second band a quarter of the attractor positions , and so on .
the top band is eliminated by functional composition of the original map , that is by considering the orbit generated by the map @xmath77 instead of @xmath78 .
successive bands are eliminated by considering the orbits of @xmath79 .
the positions of the top band ( odd times ) can be reproduced approximately by the positions of the band below it ( times of the form @xmath80 , @xmath81 ) by multiplication by a factor equal to @xmath82 , e.g. @xmath83 .
likewise , the positions of the second band are reproduced by the positions of the third band under multiplication by @xmath84 , e.g. @xmath85 , and so on . in fig .
1b we show a logarithmic scale plot of @xmath86 @xmath87 that displays a band structure similar to that in fig .
1a , in the top band lie again half of the attractor positions ( even times ) and below the other half ( odd times ) is distributed in the subsequent bands .
this time the positions in one band are reproduced approximately from the positions of the band lying below it by multiplication by a factor @xmath88 , e.g. @xmath89 .
the properties amongst bands of iterate positions merely follow from repeated composition and rescaling of the map and represent a graphical construction of the feigenbaum rg transformation @xmath90 , where @xmath91 also , the trajectory with initial condition @xmath71 maps out the feigenbaum attractor in such a way that the absolute values of succeeding ( time - shifted @xmath92 ) positions @xmath93 form subsequences with a common power - law decay of the form @xmath94 with @xmath95 , with @xmath96 when @xmath97 . see how positions fall along straight diagonal lines in fig .
1a . that is
, the _ entire _ attractor can be decomposed into position subsequences generated by the time subsequences @xmath98 , each obtained by running over @xmath99 for a fixed value of @xmath100 noticeably , the positions in these subsequences can be obtained from those belonging to the superstable periodic orbits of lengths @xmath5 , i.e. the @xmath5-cycles that contain the point @xmath101 at @xmath102 @xcite . specifically , the positions for the main subsequence @xmath103 , that constitutes the lower bound of the entire trajectory ( see fig .
1a ) , can be identified to be @xmath104 @xmath105 , where @xmath106 is the @xmath107-th principal diameter defined at the @xmath5-supercycle , the distance of the orbit position nearest to @xmath101 schuster1 .
the main subsequence can be expressed as @xmath108 with @xmath109 .
interestingly this analytical result for @xmath75 can be seen to satisfy the dynamical fixed - point relation , @xmath110 with @xmath111 .
see @xcite , @xcite for @xmath97 and robledo3 for general @xmath23 .
we now work out the relationship between the trajectory scaling function @xmath112 and the sensitivity @xmath8 at @xmath29 . to begin with we recall @xcite the general definition of the diameters @xmath113 that measure the bifurcation forks that form the period - doubling cascade sequence .
the @xmath113 in these orbits are defined as the distances of the elements @xmath114 , @xmath115 , to their nearest neighbors @xmath116 , i.e. @xmath117 for large @xmath107 , @xmath118 ; @xmath119 . further , feigenbaum @xcite constructed the auxiliary function @xmath120 to quantify the rate of change of the diameters and showed that in the limit @xmath121 it has finite ( jump ) discontinuities at all rationals of the form @xmath122 .
so , considering the variable @xmath123 one obtains @xcite @xcite , omitting the subindex @xmath107 , @xmath124 , but @xmath125 , and through the antiperiodic property @xmath126 , also @xmath127 , but @xmath128 .
other discontinuities in @xmath129 appear at @xmath130,@xmath131etc . in most cases
it is only necessary to consider the first few as their magnitude decreases rapidly .
see , e.g. fig .
31 in ref .
the discontinuities of @xmath132 can be suitably obtained by first generating the superstable orbit @xmath133 at @xmath29 and then plotting the position differences @xmath134 for times of the form @xmath135 , @xmath99 , in logarithmic scales .
the distances that separate positions along the time subsequence correspond to the logarithm of the diameters @xmath113 .
1a and 1b where the constant spacing of positions along the main diagonal provide the values for @xmath136 and @xmath137 , respectively .
the constant slope @xmath138 of the resulting time subsequence data is related to @xmath139 , i.e. @xmath140 .
1a and 1b where the slopes of the main diagonal subsequences have the values @xmath141 and @xmath142 , respectively . from these two slopes
the value of the largest jump discontinuity of @xmath132 is conviniently determined .
a key factor in obtaining our results is the fact that the sensitivity @xmath143 can be evaluated for trajectories within the attractor via consideration of the discontinuities of @xmath129 .
our strategy for determining @xmath144 is to chose the initial and the final separation of the trajectories to be the diameters @xmath145 and @xmath146 , @xmath147 , respectively .
then , @xmath143 is obtained as @xmath148 notice that in this limit @xmath149 , @xmath30 _ and _ the @xmath5-supercycle becomes the onset of chaos ( the @xmath150-supercycle ) .
then , @xmath144 can be written as @xmath151 where we have used @xmath152 and @xmath153 .
notice that for the inverse process , starting at @xmath154 and ending at @xmath155 , with @xmath156 one obtains @xmath157 given the known properties of @xmath132 we can readily extract those for @xmath158 for general non - linearity @xmath23 . taking into account only the first @xmath159 , @xmath160 discontinuities of @xmath132 we have the antiperiodic step function @xmath161 with @xmath162 , and
this implies that @xmath163 when @xmath164 is continuous at @xmath165 , and @xmath166 when @xmath132 has a discontinuity at @xmath167 .
as we make clear below , these behaviors for the sensitivity reflect the multi - region nature of the multifractal attractor and the memory retention of these regions in the dynamics .
thus , @xmath163 ( or @xmath168 ) corresponds to trajectories that depart and arrive in the same region , while the power laws in eq .
( [ sensitivity ? ] ) correspond to a departing position in one region and arrival at a different region and vice versa , the trajectories expand in one sense and contract in the other .
we now make explicit the mentioned link between the occurrence of mori s @xmath0-phase transitions and the @xmath0-statistical dynamical properties at @xmath169 .
consider @xmath170 , the simplest approximation to @xmath132 , yet it captures the effect on @xmath8 of the most dominant trajectories within the attractor .
this is to assume that half of the diameters scales as @xmath171 ( as in the most crowded region of the attractor , @xmath172 ) while the other half scales as @xmath173 ( as in the most sparse region of the attractor , @xmath174 ) . with use of the identity @xmath175 @xmath176 , @xmath177 ,
@xmath178 can be rewritten as the @xmath0-exponential @xmath179\ , \label{sensitivity3a}\ ] ] where @xmath180 and where @xmath181 the @xmath182 term in @xmath183 arises from the time shift involved in selecting different initial positions @xmath184 .
l and ref .
similarly , the sensitivity for the trajectories in the inverse order yields @xmath185\ , \label{sensitivity3b}\ ] ] where @xmath186 , and where @xmath187 . the factor of @xmath188 in @xmath189 appears because of a basic difference between the orbits of periods @xmath5 and @xmath150 . in the latter case , to reach @xmath190 from @xmath191 at times @xmath156 the iterate necessarily moves into positions of the next period @xmath192 , and orbit contraction is twice as effective than expansion .
notice that the relationship between the indexes @xmath186 for the couple of conjugate trajectories stems from the property @xmath193 . for
@xmath97 one obtains @xmath194 and @xmath195 , this latter value agrees with that obtained in several earlier studies @xcite - @xcite . from the results for @xmath183 and @xmath189
we can construct the two - step lyapunov function @xmath196 for @xmath97 one has @xmath197 and @xmath198 .
2a . when the next discontinuities of importance in @xmath129 are taken into account new information on @xmath144 is obtained in the form of additional pairs of @xmath0-exponentials as in eqs .
( [ sensitivity3a ] ) and ( [ sensitivity3b ] ) . in the next approximation for @xmath132
there are four scaling factors , @xmath171 , @xmath199 , @xmath200 , @xmath201 , where @xmath202 ( with @xmath203 for @xmath97 ) and @xmath204 ( with @xmath205 for @xmath97 ) .
these last values are associated to the two midway regions between the most crowded and next most sparse regions of the attractor .
we have now three values for the @xmath0 index , @xmath206 , @xmath207 and @xmath208 ( together with the conjugate values @xmath186 , @xmath209 and @xmath210 for the inverse trajectories ) .
for each value of @xmath0 there is a set of @xmath0-lyapunov coefficients running from a maximum @xmath211 to zero ( or a minimum @xmath212 to zero ) . from the results for @xmath213 and @xmath214 ,
@xmath215 we can construct three lyapunov functions @xmath216 , @xmath217 , each with two jumps located at @xmath218 and @xmath219 .
similar results are obtained when more discontinuities in @xmath132 are taken into account .
direct contact can be established now with the formalism developed by mori and coworkers and the @xmath0-phase transition reported in ref .
each step function for @xmath50 can be integrated to obtain the spectrum @xmath38 ( @xmath220 ) and from this its legendre transform @xmath35 ( @xmath221 ) .
we illustrate this with the @xmath132 approximated with only two scale factors and present specific values when @xmath222 . the free energy functions @xmath38 and @xmath35 obtained from the two - step @xmath50 determined above and shown in fig .
2a are given by @xmath223 and @xmath224 see fig .
the constant slopes of @xmath35 represent the @xmath0-phase transitions associated to trajectories linking two regions of the attractor , @xmath225 and @xmath174 , and their values @xmath226 and @xmath227 correspond the index @xmath206 obtained for the @xmath0-exponentials @xmath228 in eqs .
( [ sensitivity3a ] ) and ( [ sensitivity3b ] ) . the slope @xmath229 coincides with that originally detected in refs .
mori2 , @xcite .
when we consider also the next discontinuities of importance in @xmath129 at @xmath230 , @xmath231 we obtain a couple of two @xmath0-phase transitions for each of the three values of the @xmath0 index , @xmath206 , @xmath232 and @xmath208 .
the constant slope values for the @xmath0-phase transitions at @xmath226 and @xmath233 appear again , but now we have two other pairs of transitions with slope values @xmath234 and @xmath235 , and , @xmath236 and @xmath237 , that correspond , respectively , to orbits that link the most crowded region of the attractor to the medium crowded region , and to orbits that link this medium crowded region with the medium sparse region of the attractor .
next , we verify the equality between the @xmath0-lyapunov coefficients @xmath238 and the @xmath0-generalized rates of entropy production @xmath239 .
we follow the same procedure as in ref . @xcite .
consider a large number @xmath240 of trajectories with initial positions uniformly distributed within a small interval of length @xmath56 containing the attractor point @xmath10 .
a partition of this interval is made with @xmath241 nonintersecting intervals of lengths @xmath242 ( @xmath243 ) .
for @xmath56 sufficiently small , after @xmath147 , or @xmath244 , iterations these interval lengths transform according to @xmath245 ( recall @xmath132 has a discontinuity at @xmath167 ) .
we observe that the interval ratios remain constant , that is , @xmath246 , since the entire - interval ratio @xmath247 scales equally with @xmath9 .
thus , the initial number of trajectories within each interval @xmath248 remains fixed in time , with the consequence that the original distribution stays _ uniform _ for all times @xmath249 , where @xmath250 as @xmath149 .
we can now calculate the rate of entropy production .
this is more easily done with the use of a partition of @xmath251 equal - sized cells of length @xmath252 .
if we denote by @xmath253 the number of cells that the ensemble occupies at time @xmath9 and by @xmath57 the total length of the interval@xmath131these cells form , we have @xmath254 or @xmath255 , and in the limit @xmath256 , @xmath257 we obtain the simple result @xmath258 @xmath8 . as the distribution is uniform , and recalling that eq .
( [ sensitivity1 ] ) for @xmath8 holds in all cases , the @xmath0-entropy is given by @xmath259 while @xmath260 , as @xmath261 .
it is important to clarify the circumstances under which the equalities @xmath262 are obtained as these could be interpreted as shortcomings of the formalism .
first of all , the rate @xmath15 does not generalize the trajectory - based kolmogorov - sinai ( ks ) entropy @xmath263 that is involved in the well - known pesin identity @xmath264 @xcite - @xcite .
presumably , the @xmath0-generalized ks entropy @xmath265 would be defined in the same manner as @xmath266 with the use of @xmath16 in place of @xmath267 .
the rate @xmath15 is determined from values of @xmath16 only at two different times @xcite .
the relationship between @xmath266 and @xmath62 has been investigated for several chaotic maps @xcite and it has been established that the equality @xmath268 occurs during an intermediate stage in the evolution of the entropy @xmath269 , after an initial transient dependent on the initial distribution of positions and before an asymptotic approach to a constant saturation value . here
we have seemingly looked into the analogous intermediate regime in which one would expect @xmath270 , as we explain below , however , the answer to this question is not analyzed in this occasion .
we have only considered initial conditions within small distances outside the positions of the feigenbaum attractor and have not focused on the initial transient behavior referred to in the above paragraph .
as for the final asymptotic regime mentioned above it should be kept in mind that the distance between trajectories , from which we obtain @xmath13 , always saturates because of the finiteness of the available phase space ( the multifractal subset of @xmath271 $ ] that is the feigenbaum attractor ) .
it is widely known @xcite that special care needs to be taken in determining @xmath7 from a time series to avoid saturation due to folding and similar limitations occur for @xmath272 .
separation of incipiently chaotic trajectories , just as separation of chaotic ones , undergo two different processes , stretching which leads to the @xmath0-exponential regime in @xmath8 and folding which keeps the orbits bounded .
therefore for @xmath9 sufficiently large eq .
( [ sensitivity1 ] ) would be no longer valid , just like the exponential @xmath8 of chaotic attractors .
this is the reason there is a saturation time @xmath273 in our determination of @xmath272 and this consequently supports our use of the rates @xmath274 in @xmath275 .
our most striking finding is that the dynamics at the onset of chaos is constituted by an infinite family of mori s @xmath0-phase transitions , each associated to orbits that have common starting and finishing positions located at specific regions of the attractor .
each of these transitions is related to a discontinuity in the @xmath1 function of diameter ratios , and this in turn implies a @xmath0-exponential @xmath8 and a spectrum of @xmath0-lyapunov coefficients - equal to the tsallis rate of entropy production - for each set of attractor regions .
the transitions come in pairs with specific conjugate indexes @xmath0 and @xmath19 , as these correspond to switching starting and finishing orbital positions .
since the amplitude of the discontinuities in @xmath1 diminishes rapidly , in practical terms there is only need of evaluation for the first few of them .
the dominant discontinuity is associated to the most crowded and sparse regions of the attractor and this alone provides a very reasonable description of the dynamics , as found in earlier studies @xcite - @xcite .
the special values for the tsallis entropic index @xmath0 in @xmath8 are equal to the special values of the variable @xmath0 in the formalism of mori and colleagues at which the @xmath0-phase transitions take place .
therefore , we have identified the cause or source for the entropic index @xmath0 observed at the feigenbaum attractor .
we found that the sensitivity to initial conditions at the onset of chaos does not have the form of a single @xmath0-exponential but of infinitely many interlaced @xmath0-exponentials .
more precisely , we found a hierarchy of such families of interlaced @xmath0-exponentials .
an intricate state of affairs that befits the rich scaling features of a multifractal attractor .
this dynamical organization is difficult to resolve from the consideration of a straightforward time evolution , i.e. starting from an arbitrary position @xmath276 within the attractor and recorded at every time @xmath9 . in this case
what is observed @xcite are strongly fluctuating quantities that persist in time with a tangled pattern structure that presents memory retention . on the other hand , if specific initial positions with known location within the multifractal are chosen , and subsequent positions are observed only at pre - selected times , when the trajectories visit another region of choice , a well - defined @xmath0-exponential form for @xmath8 emerges . the specific value of @xmath0 and the associated lyapunov spectrum @xmath277 can be clearly determined . for each case the value of @xmath0 is given by the values of the trajectory scaling function @xmath1 at one of its discontinuities , while the corresponding spectrum @xmath13 reflects all starting positions in the multifractal region where the trajectories originate .
we remind the reader that the results presented here are independent from the dynamics of approach to the attractor as we have not considered the time evolution of initial positions @xmath10 outside the attractor and leave this case for future attention .
interestingly , the crossover from @xmath0-statistics to bg statistics can be observed for control parameter values in the vicinity of the onset of chaos , @xmath278 , when the attractor consists of @xmath5 bands , @xmath279 large .
the lyapunov coefficient @xmath7 of the chaotic attractor decreases with @xmath280 @xmath29 as @xmath281 , @xmath282 , where @xmath283 is the second feigenbaum constant @xcite .
the chaotic orbit consists of an interband periodic motion of period @xmath5 and an intraband chaotic motion .
the expansion rate @xmath284 grows as @xmath28 for @xmath285 but as @xmath9 for @xmath286 @xcite , @xcite .
this translates as tsallis dynamics with @xmath287 for @xmath285 but bg dynamics with @xmath288 for @xmath286 . in summary ,
we have obtained further understanding about the nature of the dynamics at the onset of chaos in logistic maps .
we exhibited links between original developments , such as feigenbaum s @xmath1 function and mori s @xmath0-phase transitions , with more recent advances , such as @xmath0-exponential sensitivity to initial conditions @xcite and @xmath0-generalized identity between lyapunov coefficients and rate of entropy change @xcite .
chaotic orbits possess a time irreversible property that stems from mixing in phase space and loss of memory , but orbits within critical attractors are non - mixing and have no loss of memory .
our results apply to many other unimodal one - parameter families of maps .
one example is the exponential function map @xmath289 studied in ref .
@xcite as the simple ( monotonic ) change of variable @xmath290 indicates .
comparable results would be expected to hold for the two other routes to chaos @xcite , intermittency and quasiperidicity , in low - dimensional maps as these exhibit both @xmath0-phase transitions @xcite and @xmath0-sensitivity to initial conditions @xcite , @xcite .
clearly , our results establish a new feasible numerical scheme to determine the family of values for the entropic index @xmath0 associated to a critical multifractal attractor ( here via the diameter function @xmath1 ) .
conversely , the computation of the sensitivity @xmath8 at the onset of chaos offers an original means to evaluate feigenbaum s trajectory scaling function @xmath1 or its equivalent for other critical attractors .
additionally and remarkably , the perturbation with noise of this attractor brings out the main features of glassy dynamics in thermal systems robledo5 . for recent reviews see , _ nonextensive entropy interdisciplinary applications _ , m. gell - mann and c. tsallis , eds . , ( oxford university press , new york , 2004 ) .
see http://tsallis.cat.cbpf.br/biblio.htm for full bibliography . | we uncover the basis for the validity of the tsallis statistics at the onset of chaos in logistic maps .
the dynamics within the critical attractor is found to consist of an infinite family of mori s @xmath0-phase transitions of rapidly decreasing strength , each associated to a discontinuity in feigenbaum s trajectory scaling function @xmath1 .
the value of @xmath0 at each transition corresponds to the same special value for the entropic index @xmath0 , such that the resultant sets of @xmath0-lyapunov coefficients are equal to the tsallis rates of entropy evolution . |
an image of the milky way , taken by an observer in another galaxy would probably reveal a spiral structure dotted with many bright hii regions .
the milky way is believed to be spiral galaxy , and a best `` educated guess '' is that it is a barred sb to sc galaxy @xcite .
however , since we are inside the milky way , it has proved very difficult to properly characterize its structure @xcite .
originally , studies of hi emission offered the opportunity to map the structure of the milky way @xcite .
hi emission on longitude - velocity plots clearly demonstrated that there were some coherent , large - scale structures , which were probably spiral arms in the milky way .
however , determining accurate distances to hi clouds proved problematic , and this made the task of turning longitude - velocity data into a true plan - view of the milky way very uncertain @xcite .
later , millimeter - wave observations of molecules , such as co , also revealed coherent , large - scale structures with higher contrast than seen in hi @xcite .
but , again , uncertain distances to molecular clouds precluded making a true map of the milky way with sufficient accuracy map the spiral structure of the milky way .
@xcite published a `` plan - view '' model of the spiral structure of the milky way . this approach involved combining optical observations of young stars and radio data of hi cloud and hii region emissions .
luminosity distances to nearby stars were used where available and kinematic distances elsewhere , mostly for more distant hii regions .
more recently , @xcite have modeled pulsar dispersion measures to refine the georgelin & georgelin model . while subject to very significant uncertainties from kinematic distances , the georgelin & georgelin model has remained the basis for the `` standard '' model of the spiral structure of the milky way for over 30 years .
the primary goal of our project is to reinforce the foundations of models of the spiral structure of the milky way by measuring distances directly to regions of massive star formation across large portions of the milky way .
this paper is the first ( paper i ) in a series , including papers ii through v @xcite published in this volume .
we are using the nrao very long baseline array ( vlba ) to determine trigonometric parallaxes of strong methanol maser sources , which are associated with regions of massive star formation and their attendant hii regions . sampling spiral arms roughly every kpc
should determine the true locations of arms , and allow us to use other databases to `` interpolate '' between the star forming regions measured with masers .
with accurate distances to some of the largest star forming regions , we should be able to verify the existence and determine the locations of the postulated perseus , carina
sagittarius , crux
scutum , and norma spiral arms .
ultimately , we hope to extend these measurements with a larger sample , including a similar study in the southern hemisphere , and produce a map of the 3-dimensional structure of bright material associated with massive young stars that defines spiral structure .
in addition to distances , the observations used to determine trigonometric parallaxes yield excellent measurements of secular proper motions , with accuracies of @xmath4 @xcite . combining radial velocity measurements with proper motions ( and distances ) yields full 3-dimensional velocities , relative to the motion of the sun . thus , through this project and other vlbi efforts , notably the japanese project vera @xcite
, we hope to determine the full kinematics of massive star forming regions in the milky way , which will accurately define the rotation curve of the milky way and , in turn , its enclosed mass as a function of galactocentric radius .
finally , we should be able to show how material in spiral arms actually moves , to characterize kinematic anomalies ( such as in the perseus arm ) and , hopefully , to understand why these anomalies occur .
methanol ( ) masers are excellent astrometric targets for parallax measurements . class ii methanol masers ( 6.7 and 12 ghz transitions ) are widespread and associated with newly formed stars in regions of high - mass star formation .
the masers generally are compact ( @xmath6 mas ) , slow moving , and vary slowly , which minimizes the possibility of brightness variations mimicking position shifts . while the 6.7 ghz masing transition is generally stronger than the 12 ghz transition ,
there are dozens of 12 ghz sources with peak flux densities @xmath7 jy , which is sufficient to serve as a phase - reference for the vlba . also , the 12 ghz transition is at a high enough frequency to offer minimal sensitivity to unmodeled ionospheric fluctuations and to minimize interstellar scatter broadening .
however , once all 12 ghz masers have been measured , the 6.7 ghz methanol masers will be attractive targets .
we note that 22 ghz masers are also good astrometric targets ; they are compact , strong , widespread , and the high frequency of the transition minimizes ionospheric fluctuations and interstellar scattering problems . however , masers can be variable on time scales as short as weeks to months and , since parallax observations are best made over a timespan of 1 yr , this can be problematic .
water masers are generally associated with high - velocity outflows from young stellar objects . since , for well - planned measurements ,
parallax and proper motion are essentially uncorrelated , parallax estimates should not be affected by the magnitude of the proper motion .
however , one of the most astrophyscially interesting by - products of maser astrometry is the determination of the full space - motions of the associated young stellar objects .
if there are fast internal motions , then one needs to understand details of the outflows in order to transform from measured maser motions to a frame tied to the central stellar object .
the accuracy of this transformation is typically better than a few for slowly expanding methanol masers @xcite , but can be of order 10 for the rapidly expanding masers @xcite . since astrometric accuracy is enhanced by finding background sources ( ie , qsos ) as close in angle to the maser sources as possible , we first conducted surveys for background sources near potential maser targets . using the sustainable recording rate of 128 mbits s@xmath8 of the vlba in 2006 (
which is being substantially upgraded ) , we are able to use background sources as weak as a few mjy .
we identified candidate background sources by selecting all sources in the nrao vla sky survey ( nvss ) that were nearly unresolved ( at @xmath9 resolution ) and within @xmath10 of a maser target .
typically we found @xmath11 candidates stronger than @xmath12 mjy for any maser target .
these candidate sources were observed in snap - shot mode with the vla at 8 and 15 ghz to determine a spectral index and further test compactness .
candidates that remained unresolved with these observations and displayed a synchrotron spectral index are likely to be extragalactic and have compact cores that can be imaged with vlba observations .
typically we find between 1 and 3 suitable qsos within about 1.5 degrees of a target methanol maser source @xcite . when possible we re - observed with these sources with the vla a- or b - configurations to determine absolute positions to better than 30 mas .
the main source of systematic error for cm - wave phase - referenced observations is uncompensated interferometric delays introduced by the earth s atmosphere and ionosphere .
the model used in the vlba correlator is a seasonally - averaged calculation that does not take into account variations in atmospheric pressure , total water - vapor content , nor the delay induced by the ionosphere . at a frequency of 12
ghz the correlator model will typically be in error by about 0.2 to 0.4 nsec of delay , corresponding to 5 to 10 cm of excess path length , for sources at high elevation angles .
substantial gains in reducing systematic errors owing to atmospheric mis - modeling can be obtained by directly measuring and removing these effects . for the last decade
, we have been working to understand better our sources of systematic error and to find methods of correcting our data for these errors @xcite currently , we use observations of extragalactic sources spread over the sky to measure broad - band delays . for sources with well determined positions ( better than 1 mas )
, residual delays measured by the vlba will be dominated by the effects of atmospheric mis - modeling .
typically , we observe @xmath13 such sources over a range of source azimuths and elevations in rapid succession over a time span of about 40 min .
the choice of sources and the observing sequence were determined by computer code with the following procedure : we generated a candidate source list starting with the icrf catalog @xcite and keeping only the 60 sources that had been observed @xmath14 times , had coordinate uncertainties @xmath15 mas , and had little structure at 8 ghz ( structural indexes of 1 or 2 ) .
trial schedules were generated by randomly skipping though the candidate source list ; we required that a source was above an elevation of @xmath16 at a minimum of 6 vlba stations and that no station missed more than a total of 5 sources . for each trial schedule , we generated fake data and performed a least - squares fit solving for zenith atmospheric delays and clock offsets for all stations .
we generally examined 1000 trial schedules and chose the one that minimized the largest of the formal zenith delay uncertainties among the 10 stations .
we placed these `` geodetic '' blocks before the start , in the middle , and after the end of our phase - reference observations , in order to monitor slow changes in the total atmospheric delay for each telescope .
the data were taken in left circular polarization with eight 4-mhz bands that spanned 480 mhz of bandwidth between 12.10 and 12.58 ghz ; the bands were spaced in a `` minimum redundancy configuration '' to uniformly sample , as best as possible , all frequency differences .
this was accomplished with bands spaced by 0 , 1 , 4 , 9 , 15 , 22 , 32 and 34 times 14 mhz .
the data were correlated , corrected for ionospheric delays using total electron content measurements @xcite , and residual multi - band delays and fringe rates were determined for all sources .
the multi - band delays and fringe rates were modeled as owing to a vertical atmospheric delay and delay - rate , as well as a clock offset and clock drift rate , at each antenna .
owing to the short ( 1 min ) integration times , the fringe rates are fairly uncertain and the multi - band delays carry most of the weight in the solutions . in order to protect the fitting process from occasional bad data , we used an iterative approach that down - weights outliers relative to the previous solution . specifically , after each iteration , the uncertainty assigned to the each delay or fringe rate datum was increased by a factor of @xmath17 $ ] , where @xmath18 is the post - fit residual divided by the original uncertainty .
this procedure heavily down - weights @xmath19 outliers . typically , only a few percent of the input data were significantly down - weighted .
sample data , model , and residuals from our first epoch observations are shown in fig .
[ fit_geodetic ] . in some cases ,
the delay residuals indicated departures from the linear ( in time ) model ; an example can be seen in the non - zero mean delay residuals ( _ red crosses _ ) in fig .
[ fit_geodetic ] for the interferometer baseline formed by vlba antennas ov and pt .
we believe this is due to unusually large , quasi - random , changes in the zenith delay at antenna 8 during this observation . in order to improve the calibration
, we then solved for zenith delays and clock offsets for each 40-min block separately .
calibration of the phase - referencing data was done by linearly interpolating between these three solutions . using our least - squares fitting program , we estimated zenith atmospheric path - delays with accuracies typically @xmath20 cm ( @xmath21 ) .
independent comparisons of our technique with those using global positioning system ( gps ) data and an image - optimization approach confirm this accuracy @xcite .
correction for atmospheric delays results in significant improvement in relative position accuracy , compared to observations that rely solely on the vlba correlator model . finally , using more than one background reference source , at different offsets and position angles with respect to the target maser source , when phase - referencing further reduces sensitivity to any residual systematic errors from atmospheric mis - modeling .
when conducting phase - referenced observations , it is important that the position of the reference source is well determined @xcite . a position error , @xmath22 , for the reference source results in residual phases shifts that are sinusoidal with a 24 hour period and an amplitude of @xmath23 turns , where @xmath24 is the interferometer fringe spacing .
when applied to a target source , offset from the reference source by @xmath25 , the reference phases can no longer be perfectly modeled as a position shift ( at the position of the target source ) .
this results in a second - order position shift of @xmath26 , as well a degradation of the imaging . while the second - order position shift , in principle , can be constant from epoch to epoch and not affect a parallax measurement
, the image degradation can be serious and even preclude detection of a weak source .
we attempted to determine the absolute positions of our sources to better than @xmath27 mas accuracy .
the 12 ghz methanol masers for which we sought to measure parallaxes contain some bright , compact spots that serve as good astrometric targets .
since we used strong maser signals as the phase reference , in order to allow the detection of weak background sources close in angle on the sky , we needed to measure the maser positions . because the 12 ghz methanol masers are often spread over a region of @xmath28 , we had to determine their positions from our vlba data .
we accomplished this in one of two ways .
if one of the background sources had a well determined position ( @xmath29 mas ) and we could image it after phase referencing to the maser ( even with a poorly determined _ a priori _ maser position ) , then we iteratively refined the maser position to a similar accuracy . when the maser position can not be measured against a known source by phase referencing
, one can take advantage of the excellent correlator model and map of a strong maser spot by simply fourier transforming the data , following amplitude calibration and atmospheric model correction , but _ without _ phase referencing ( after calibration `` step 3 '' describe in [ calib ] ) .
this produces a very crude image , which resembles optical speckles , owing to the large phase excursions introduced mostly by short - term fluctuations in the atmospheric delay . for our data ,
the brighter speckles were concentrated in a region of about 50 to 100 mas radius , and we were able to estimate the centroid of the speckle distribution to an accuracy of about 10 to 20 mas .
table [ table : positions ] lists the absolute positions the maser and background continuum sources , as well as the observed brightness and restoring beam sizes at the first epoch .
lllcrlc .............. & 06 08 53.3395 & + 21 38 29.100 & ... & ... & @xmath30 & 10.8 + j0603 + 2159 ... & 06 03 51.55708 & + 21 59 37.6982 & 1.2 & @xmath31 & 0.080 & ... + j0607 + 2129 ... & 06 07 59.5657 & + 21 29 43.720 & 0.3 & @xmath32 & 0.005 & ... + j0607
+ 2218 ... & 06 07 17.4360 & + 22 18 19.080 & 0.5 & @xmath33 & 0.008 & ... + j0608
+ 2229 ... & 06 08 34.3109 & + 22 29 42.981 & 0.2 & @xmath34 & 0.056 & ... + + ..... & 07 32 09.7833 &
@xmath3516 58 12.589 & ... & ... & @xmath36 & 22.8 + j0735@xmath351735 ... & 07 35 45.81246 & @xmath3517 35 48.5027 & 1.1 & 126 & 0.29 & ... + j0729@xmath351636 ... & 07 29 23.93 & @xmath3516 36 56.2 & 0.8 & @xmath37 & ... & ... + [ table : positions ]
our observations were conducted under vlba program br100b . we observed and over 8-hour tracks at four epochs : 2005 october 13 , 2006 april 6 and october 4 , and 2007 march 25 .
these dates well sample the peaks of the sinusoidal trigonometric parallax signature in right ascension .
the declination signature is significantly smaller than that for right ascension , and we made no effort to detect it .
this sampling provides maximum sensitivity for parallax detection and ensures that we can separate the secular proper motion ( caused by projections of galactic rotation , as well as any peculiar motion of the masers and the sun ) from the sinusoidal parallax effect .
for we observed four background sources , while for we observed two background sources .
table 1 lists the positions of these sources .
we alternated between two @xmath12 min blocks , each consisting of observations of a maser target and its background sources . within a block
, we switched sources every 40 s , typically achieving 30 s of on - source data .
the observing sequence for the block was four repetitions of , j0607 + 2129 , , j0607 + 2218 , , j0608 + 2229 , , j0603 + 2159 .
a similar sequence was used for the block ; however , with only two background sources , we used eight repetitions of such a cycle .
we used the methanol maser as the phase - reference source , because it is considerably stronger than the background sources and could be detected on individual baselines in the available on - source time .
we placed observations of two strong sources ( j0530 + 1331 and j0555 + 3948 ) near the beginning , middle and end of the observations in order to monitor delay and electronic phase differences among the if bands . in practice , however , we found minimal drifts and used only a single scan for this calibration .
we also used data from these strong sources to check the variations in phase across the bandpasses and found them to vary by @xmath38 across the central 90% of the band . since the masers were observed near band center and we discarded the outer channels for the continuum sources , we made no bandpass corrections .
the rapid - switching observations employed four adjacent frequency bands of 4 mhz bandwidth and recorded both right and left circularly polarized signals .
the four ( dual - polarized ) bands were centered at local standard of rest velocities ( @xmath39 ) of 108.54 , 10.00 , @xmath40 and @xmath41 for , and at 120.54 , 22.00 , @xmath42 and @xmath43 for . for both sources , the masers were contained in the second band .
the raw data recorded on tape ( or more recently on transportable disks ) at each antenna were shipped to the vlba correlation facility in socorro , nm . the data from individual antenna pairs were cross - correlated with an integration time of 0.92 sec .
integration times were kept short to allow position shifting of the data to accommodate a priori uncertainties in the maser positions . at this integration time
, we could not process all eight frequency bands in one pass with sufficient spectral resolution for the maser band , without exceeding the maximum correlator output rate .
thus , we correlated the data in two passes .
one pass was processed with 16 spectral channels for each of the eight frequency bands .
this data was used for the geodetic blocks ( to determine atmospheric delays and clock drifts ) and for the background continuum sources observed in rapid - switching ( phase - referencing ) mode .
another pass was processed with 256 spectral channels , but only for the single ( dual - polarized ) frequency band containing the maser signals , giving a velocity resolution of 0.38 , assuming a rest frequency of 12178.597 mhz for the @xmath44 e transition of methanol .
we calibrated the correlated data using the nrao astronomical image processing system ( aips ) .
the calibration sequence included four steps .
step 1 involved correction of interferometer delays and phases for the effects of diurnal feed rotation ( parallactic angle ) , for errors in the values of the earth s orientation parameters used at the time of correlation , and for any small position shifts in the a priori coordinates of either the maser or background sources . since the vlba correlator model includes no ionospheric delays , we used global total electron content models to remove ionospheric effects . at this point
, we also corrected the data for residual zenith atmospheric delays and clock drifts ( determined from the geodetic block data ) .
in step 2 we adjusted interferometer visibility amplitudes for the small ( few % ) effects of biases in the threshold levels of the data samplers at each station .
we also entered system temperature and antenna gain curve information into calibration tables , which allow conversion of correlation coefficients to flux density units . in step 3
, we performed a `` manual phase - calibration '' to remove delay and phase differences among all eight 4-mhz bands .
this was done by selecting one scan on a strong calibrator , fitting fringe patterns to the data for each frequency band , and then shifting delays and phases to remove offsets . at this point ,
the interferometer data had delay errors less than @xmath45 nsec ( @xmath46 cm of excess path ) for sources observed at high elevations .
finally , we shifted the frequency axes of the maser interferometer spectra to compensate for the doppler shift caused by changing projection of the earth s orbit and spin toward the source , in order to keep a constant in any given spectral channel .
after step 3 , the visibility phases are calibrated for all known effects and residual phases are typically dominated by short - term atmospheric variations of @xmath47 cm and nearly constant absolute position errors usually less than @xmath47 mas ( see [ abs_pos ] and table [ table : positions ] ) .
atmospheric variations cancel , to first order in the source separations ( typically @xmath48 or 0.02 radians on the sky ) , when constructing phase differences ( `` phase - referencing '' ) between the target maser and the background continuum source .
absolute position errors are largely constant over our observations and cancel over time when fitting for a parallax .
( only the time - variable position changes , owing to parallax and proper motion , will not cancel in time .
typical galactic proper motions of @xmath46 result in differential position shifts of typically 0.02 mas , when the galactic source ( maser ) is used as the phase reference . )
the final calibration , step 4 , involved selecting a maser phase - reference .
we used a single spectral channel of the maser source , selected to be strong on the longest interferometer baselines , and hence compact .
the reference phases from spectral channel 128 at @xmath49 of are shown in fig . [ s252_phases ] .
the flux density of this maser was typically @xmath50 jy . for most antennas at most times the phases were easily `` connected '' and interpolated to the time of the background source observations .
( there was one background source observation between each pair of phase - reference observations . ) when the differences between adjacent reference phases exceeded @xmath51 , the data between those times was discarded .
the limit of @xmath51 was chosen to be large enough to allow for ( calibratable ) short - term atmospheric fluctuations , but not too large so as to encounter turn ambiguities when interpolating between reference phases .
note that this editing was done on baseline ( not antenna ) phases , since baseline phases are what are ultimately used when calibrating data . for ,
the sole strong maser feature presented as a asymmetric double with the strongest component having a flux density of @xmath52 jy ( see inset in fig .
[ g232_overlay ] ) . using this spectral channel as a phase reference initially resulted in the appearance of a false double - structure in the background continuum source image . to remedy this problem
, we performed an iterative self - calibration sequence on the maser channel in order to construct a good image of that maser double .
we then used this image to remove the effects of the maser structure when calculating reference phase tables .
after calibration , we fourier transformed the gridded , using the aips task imagr , to make images of the maser emission in all spectral channels and the background continuum sources .
the images were deconvolved with the point - source response using the clean algorithm . in order to provide the data needed to measure parallax and proper motions , we fitted an elliptical gaussian brightness distribution to the brightest maser spots and the background continuum sources at all four epochs , using the task jmfit
. in general , our background sources are compact and appear dominated by a single component .
the ( generally weak ) extragalactic continuum sources we find usually are very compact and have little internal structure that could complicate astrometric accuracy .
this is in contrast to well known quasars with bright jets , such as superluminal sources , for which structural changes would be problematic . the change in position of the maser spot(s ) relative to the background continuum source(s )
was then modeled by the parallax sinusoid in both coordinates , completely determined by one parameter ( the parallax ) and a secular proper motion in each coordinate .
the model included the effects of the ellipticity of the earth s orbit .
the choice of data and their weighting in the parallax and proper motion fitting is complicated by two issues .
firstly , some maser spots are blended in position and frequency and the intensity of the blended components can vary with time . generally , we fitted positions in all spectral channels where the maser spots looked to be good candidates for astrometry ( compact emission , minimal blending , etc . ) .
we then fitted a parallax and proper motion to each spot separately in order to assess its astrometric quality , based on the magnitude of the post - fit residuals .
usually only a small number of maser spots were passed along for final fitting .
secondly , the formal position uncertainties were often unrealistically small , since ( a priori unknown ) sources of systematic error often dominate over random noise .
the north - south components of relative positions often have greater uncertainty than the east - west components , because ( 1 ) interferometer beams are generally larger in the north - south direction and ( 2 ) systematic errors from unmodeled atmospheric delays usually are more strongly correlated with north - south positions @xcite . in order to allow for such systematic errors
, we assigned independent `` error floors '' to the east - west and north - south position data and added these floors in quadrature with the formal position - fitting uncertainties .
trial parallax and proper motion fits were conducted and a separate reduced @xmath53 ( per degree of freedom ) statistic was calculated for the east - west and north - south residuals .
the error floors were then adjusted iteratively so as to make the reduced @xmath54 for each coordinate .
individual maser spots were allowed to have different proper motions , owing to internal motions that are typically a few for 12-ghz methanol masers . however , since we expect no detectable proper motion for the extragalactic sources , in the cases where we had more than one extragalactic source , we constrained the proper motion of any given maser spot to be the same when measured against all extragalactic sources .
note that we used a single east - west and north - south error floor in any least - square fit and these floors are the same for the combined and the individual fits .
the small differences in error floors among the fits can result in the combined fit parameters differing slightly from a simple combination of the individual fit values .
[ [ section ] ] for the sources , the interferometer ( `` dirty '' ) beam had a fwhm of 1.3 by 0.6 mas at a pa of @xmath55 east of north . in the deconvolution ( `` clean '' ) step , we used a round restoring beam of 1.0 mas in order to simplify the fitting of potentially close maser spots .
lllll 10.8 ...... & j0603 + 2159 & @xmath56 & @xmath57 & @xmath58 + 10.8 ...... & j0607 + 2218 & @xmath59 & @xmath60 & @xmath61 + 10.8 ...... & j0608 + 2229 & @xmath62 & @xmath63 & @xmath64 + 11.5 ...... & j0603 + 2159 & @xmath65 & @xmath60 & @xmath66 + 11.5 ...... & j0607 + 2218 & @xmath67 & @xmath68 & @xmath69 + 11.5 ...... & j0608 + 2229 & @xmath70 & @xmath71 & @xmath72 + + 10.8 ...... & combined & @xmath0 & @xmath73 & @xmath74 + 11.5 ...... & & & @xmath75 & @xmath76 + [ table : s252_ppm ] in fig .
[ s252_overlay ] , we show vla archive data of 8.4 ghz continuum emission from an associated hyper - compact hii region , with the first epoch image of the maser emission integrated over all spectral channels with detectable emission . in fig .
[ s252_qsos ] , we show an image at the first epoch of the four background radio sources .
the small departures from a point - like image at the lowest contour levels is probably a result of small imperfections in the phase calibration transfered from the maser data . the position data from three of the four background continuum sources produced consistent results with small residuals .
the data for j0607 + 2129 , our weakest source , yielded significantly larger post - fit residual and was not used for the final parallax and proper motion fitting .
the fitting results are presented in table [ table : s252_ppm ] .
our measured parallax for is @xmath77 mas ; the quoted uncertainty is the formal error multiplied by @xmath78 to allow for the possibility of correlated position variations for the two maser spots .
this could result from small variations in the background source or from unmodeled atmospheric delays , both of which would affect the two maser spots nearly identically .
our parallax for corresponds to a distance of @xmath1 kpc .
the average proper motion of the two astrometric maser spots is @xmath79 toward the east and @xmath80 toward the north . at the distance implied by the parallax measurement
, these motions correspond to @xmath81 and @xmath82 eastward and northward , respectively .
completing the full space velocity , the average lsr velocity of the spots is @xmath83 , which corresponds to a heliocentric radial velocity of @xmath84 .
the space motion of the two masers spots are almost identical , and , since internal motions of methanol masers are typically small @xcite , we expect the maser space motions to follow that of the central young stellar object to within about @xmath85 .
[ [ section-1 ] ] for , the reference maser spot was considerably larger than in , and we could only effectively use the inner five vlba stations for imaging .
the dirty beam was about 8 by 3 mas at a pa of @xmath86 . because of the limited interferometer data for this low declination source , we used a restoring beam equal to the fwhm of the dirty beam . in fig .
[ g232_qso ] , we show an image from the first epoch of of the background radio source j0735 - 1735
. the second background source observed , j0729 - 1636 , was not detected .
we plot the position of the = 22.8 maser spot relative to j0735 - 1735 in fig .
[ g232_fits ] .
our measured parallax for is @xmath87 mas , which corresponds to a distance of @xmath3 kpc .
the proper motion of the single maser spot is @xmath88 toward the east and @xmath89 mas toward the north . for the measured parallax
, the proper motions correspond to @xmath90 and @xmath91 eastward and northward , respectively . unlike for , where we had multiple spots and background sources , for we found only one maser and one background source suitable for astrometric measurements .
the vlba calibrator survey shows that in 2002 at 8.6 ghz the background source , j07351735 , had a second component of @xmath92 jy beam@xmath8 separated by @xmath93 mas at a position angle of @xmath94 east of north from the strongest component of @xmath95 jy beam@xmath96 at 12.2 ghz we found j07351735 to be dominated by a single component with peak brightnesses of 0.29 , 0.24 , 0.31 and 0.32 jy beam@xmath8 at our four epochs .
the apparent variations in brightness are small and consistent with a nearly constant brightness source that is imaged in the presence of typical calibration errors , especially variable phase - referencing coherence losses at different epochs . in light of the potential limitations of a single background source and a single maser spot , and
because there was effectively only one degree of freedom in the fit , which is dominated by the east - west data , we have doubled the formal uncertainties as a precaution .
table [ table : g232_ppm ] summarizes the parameters of the parallax and proper motion fits .
lllll 22.8 ...... & j07351735 & @xmath87 & @xmath88 & @xmath97 + [ table : g232_ppm ]
in order to study the 3-dimensional motion of the maser sources in the galaxy , we need to convert their radial and proper motions from the equatorial heliocentric reference frame in which they are measured into a galactic reference frame .
a convenient galactic frame is one rotating with a circular velocity @xmath98 at the position of the source : ie , a `` local standard of rest '' at the location of maser
. we will describe this procedure in detail in @xcite .
conversion to a rotating galactic reference frame depends upon several parameter values .
the iau standard value for the distance of the sun to the galactic center is @xmath99 kpc and for the rotation speed of the lsr is @xmath100 .
we assume a flat rotation curve , @xmath101 .
( the effects of a non - flat rotation curve will be considered paper vi . ) finally , we use the solar motion values @xmath102 , @xmath103 and @xmath104 , derived from hipparcos data by @xcite . for these parameter values , our parallax , and proper motion results for imply `` peculiar motions '' ( relative to circular motion ) of @xmath105 toward the galactic center , @xmath106 in the direction of galactic rotation , and @xmath107 toward the north galactic pole . for
we find peculiar motion components of of @xmath105 toward the galactic center , @xmath108 in the direction of galactic rotation , and @xmath109 toward the north galactic pole .
thus , both sources are orbiting the galaxy slower than it spins ( slower than circular rotation ) .
we note that evidence from proper motion of sgr a * , the super - massive black hole at the center of the galaxy , strongly suggests that @xmath110 kpc@xmath8 , with an uncertainty less than 1% @xcite .
thus , were we to adopt @xmath111 kpc @xcite , this would require @xmath112 .
for these galactic parameters , the peculiar velocity components change only slightly : for they become @xmath113 toward the galactic center , @xmath114 in the direction of galactic rotation , and @xmath115 toward the north galactic pole , and for they become @xmath116 toward the galactic center , @xmath117 in the direction of galactic rotation , and @xmath116 toward the north galactic pole . thus , changing and by amounts consistent with current levels of uncertainty would not change the conclusion that these star forming regions orbit the galaxy slower than it spins .
research on the structure of the galaxy in nanjing university is supported by the national science foundation of china under grants 10133020 , 10103003 and 10373025 , and a. brunthaler is supported by dfg priority programme 1177 .
bash , f. n. , 1981 , , 250 , 551 beasley , a. j. & conway , j. e. 1995 , aspc , 82 , 328 blitz , l. , fich , m. , kulkarni , s. 1983 , _ science _
, 220 , 1233 brunthaler , a. , reid , m. j. , menten , k. m. , zheng , x. w. , moscadelli , l. & xu , y. ( 2009 ) , this volume , ( paper v ) .
burton , w. b. 1988 , in `` galactic and extragalactic radio astronomy ( 2@xmath118 edition ) , eds .
k. i. kellermann & g. l verschuur , '' springer - verlag , berlin and new york , p. 295 - 358
dame , t. m. , hartmann , d. & thaddeus , p. 2001
, , 547 , 792 dehnen , w. & binney , j. j. 1998 , , 298 , 387 fey , a. l. et al .
2004 , , 127 , 3587 georgelin , y. m. & georgelin , y. p. 1976
, , 49 , 57 gerhard , o. 2002 , _ ssrv _ , 100 , 129 hachisuka , k. 2006 , , 645 , 337 honma , m. , tamura , y. & reid , m. j. 2008 , to appear in pasj kobayashi , h. 2005 , in `` transits of venus : new views of the solar system and galaxy , '' proceedings of iau colloquium no .
cambridge : cambridge university press , p.496 - 496 moscadelli , l. , menten , k. m. , walmsley , c. m. & reid , m. j. 2002 , , 564 , 813 moscadelli , l. , reid , m. j. , menten , k. m. , brunthaler , a. , zheng , x. w. & xu , y. ( 2009 ) , this volume , ( paper ii ) .
oort , j. h. , kerr , f. j. , westerhout , g. 1958 , , 118 , 379 reid , m. j. 1993 , , 31 , 345 reid , m. j. & brunthaler , a. , 2004 , , 616 , 872 reid , m. j. , readhead , a. c. s. , vermeulen , r. c. & treuhaft , r. n. , 1999 , , 524 , 816 reid , m. j. , brunthaler , a. , menten , k. m. , moscadelli , l. , xu , y. , zhang , b. & zheng , x. w. ( in preparation ) , paper vi .
taylor , j. h. & cordes , j. m. 1993 , , 411 , 674 walker , c. & chatterjee , s. , 2000 , vlba scientific memo 23 , http://www.nrao.edu/memos/sci/gps_ion.html xu , y. , reid , m. j. , zheng , x. w. & menten , k. m. 2006a , _ science _
, 311 , 54 xu , y. , reid , m. j. , menten , k. m. & zheng , x. w. 2006b , , 166 , 526 xu , y. , reid , m. j. , menten , k. m. , brunthaler , a. , zheng , w. w. & moscadelli , l. ( 2009 ) , this volume , ( paper iii ) .
zhang , b. , zheng , x. w. , reid , m. j. , menten , k. m. , xu , y. , moscadelli , l. & brunthaler , a. ( 2009 ) , this volume , ( paper iv ) . | we are conducting a large program with the nrao very long baseline array ( vlba ) to measure trigonometric parallaxes of massive star - forming regions across the milky way . here
we report measurement of the parallax and proper motion of methanol masers in and .
the parallax of is @xmath0 mas ( @xmath1 kpc ) , placing it in the perseus spiral arm .
the parallax of is @xmath2 mas ( @xmath3 kpc ) , placing it between the carina - sagittarius and perseus arms , possibly in a local ( orion ) spur of the carina - sagittarius arm . for both sources , kinematic distances
are significantly greater than their parallax distances .
our parallaxes and proper motions yield full space motions accurate to @xmath4 .
both sources orbit the galaxy @xmath5 slower than circular rotation . |
a fundamental problem in analysis is the existence and/or uniqueness of the solutions to the equation @xmath1 in the unknown @xmath2 .
the function @xmath3 relates two spaces @xmath4 with some structure , otherwise we are impotent . from the other side , the concrete case where @xmath4 are subsets of the n - space @xmath5
is often too restrictive , and actually many applications arise in more general spaces .
we especially think about injectivity and surjectivity problems in differential equations which are not discussed in this paper but constitute one of the reasons of our discussion .
the books prodi and ambrosetti [ 31 ] , and chow and hale [ 9 ] , give the proof of global inversion theorems in general spaces and show applications to differential equations .
let us also refer to invernizzi and zanolin [ 21 ] , brown and lin [ 6 ] , and radulescu and radulescu [ 33 ] among the papers which could be mentioned for results in differential equations obtained by means of the inversion of functions in infinite dimensional banach spaces .
finite dimensional problems are also important .
the research field of the jacobian conjectures deals with deep questions of invertibility linked to global stability problems , see olech [ 27 ] , meisters [ 23 ] , meisters and olech [ 25 ] , [ 26 ] , and the references contained therein .
the inversion of functions , of course , also plays a role in the applied sciences , e.g. economics and network theory .
more references are listed at the end of the paper with no claim to completeness .
the present paper is not a survey on the rich literature on these topics .
section 1 below is devoted to the following theorem which we call after hadamard and caccioppoli since hadamard was probably the first to have the idea in finite dimension , and caccioppoli was perhaps the most important author in the process of clarification and generalization to abstract spaces ( but other mathematicians also gave a contribution ) . .
let @xmath3 be a local homeomorphism with @xmath4 path connected hausdorff spaces and @xmath6 simply connected . then @xmath7 is a homeomorphism onto @xmath6 if and only if it is a proper function , namely if and only if the inverse image @xmath8 of any compact set @xmath9 is compact .
the proof below uses , in a crucial way , the concept of @xmath0-limit set .
this is perhaps the main novelty of our approach .
the statements of the theorem in the books of prodi and ambrosetti [ 31 ] , and chow and hale [ 9 ] ( whose treatment of this topic is based on [ 31 ] ) , seem different from theorem 1 at a first glance since they mention possible singular points of @xmath7 ; however those statements actually follow at once from the one above .
incidentally , those books state the theorem in metrizable spaces .
we believe that the more general framework of hausdorff spaces does not cost more than usual presentations in metrizable spaces even if these are , of course , the relevant case for applications .
and generality usually favours understanding the essence of a subject .
the framework of theorem 1 is somehow essential , in particular it is false in non - hausdorff topological spaces as a simple counterexample will show .
finally we show an application of the theorem to algebra , due to gordon .
namely we show , following [ 14 ] , that there can not be a product in @xmath5 for @xmath10 ( see proposition 1.3 below for a precise formulation ) .
this is related to the fact that @xmath11 is simply - connected if and only if @xmath10 .
we quote this application to convince the reader of the depth of the hadamard - caccioppoli theorem in a concise way .
in section 2 we deal with local homeomorphisms @xmath12 from an open connected set of a banach space @xmath13 to a banach space @xmath6 . in order to briefly mention the ideas discussed there ,
let us here refer to the particular case of a local diffeomorphism @xmath7 .
then the celebrated waewski equation with parameter @xmath14 , @xmath15 is often used in the literature to deal with invertibility problems .
waewski introduced ( 0.1 ) in [ 40 ] , for @xmath16 , to give an estimate for a ball , around a given point @xmath17 , where the inverse function can be defined .
instead of ( 0.1 ) we consider @xmath18 whose trajectories are also trajectories of the family of equations ( 0.1 ) ( as @xmath19 ) but with different parametrization ( incidentally , remark that the family ( 0.1 ) has many more trajectories ) .
the point @xmath20 is an asymptotically stable equilibrium for ( 0.2 ) and its attraction basin @xmath21 will be proved to coincide with the maximal open subset of @xmath22 , containing @xmath20 , such that @xmath23 is injective and , at the same time , the image @xmath24 is star - shaped with respect to @xmath25 . using these ideas we show some criteria for the injectivity of @xmath7 .
moreover , we shall see that the solutions to the equation ( 0.2 ) are all defined on the whole @xmath26 if and only if @xmath7 is a global homeomorphism onto @xmath6 .
in particular , this fact leads to the following : let @xmath3 be a local diffeomorphism with @xmath4 banach spaces . then @xmath7 is a diffeomorphism onto @xmath6 if there exists a continuous ( weakly ) increasing map @xmath27 such that @xmath28 in particular this holds if , for some @xmath29 , we have @xmath30 this theorem was discovered by hadamard in @xmath31 .
then it was generalized by levy to infinite dimension under condition ( 0.4 ) with @xmath32 .
meyer dealt with the full condition ( 0.4 ) , and finally plastock gave a proof for the general statement . in the literature
it is often named after hadamard only .
finally , we deal with the injectivity of @xmath7 ( together with the star - shape of the image ) by means of global lyapunov functions .
we extend to general banach spaces some results previously obtained in [ 17 ] by two of the authors for @xmath31 .
our approach to the invertibility of functions , by means of attraction basins for ( 0.2 ) , is one of the ingredients used in [ 26 ] by meisters and olech to prove one of the results in that paper , namely the global asymptotic stability for certain polynomial vector fields .
we hope that it can lead to further consequences , in particular for the differential equations .
in this section @xmath33 will always be topological hausdorff spaces . .
as is well known the function @xmath3 is called a local homeomorphism at @xmath34 if there exist open neighbourhoods @xmath35 of @xmath20 and @xmath25 respectively , such that @xmath36 and the restriction @xmath37 is a homeomorphism . then @xmath38 is called a local inverse of @xmath7 at @xmath39 .
moreover we say that @xmath3 is a local homeomorphism if it is a local homeomorphism at any @xmath40 .
such a mapping is clearly continuous and open , namely inverse - images and images of open sets are open sets .
* lifting*. let @xmath3 be a local homeomorphism and let @xmath41 be a continuous function .
a continuous function @xmath42 is called a lifting of @xmath43 by @xmath7 whenever @xmath44 , that is if the following diagram commutes : @xmath45 ( uniqueness ) .
let @xmath3 be a local homeomorphism between hausdorff spaces and let @xmath46 be continuous with @xmath47 connected . if @xmath48 are both liftings of @xmath43 then either @xmath49 or @xmath50 for every @xmath51 .
_ let @xmath52 .
let us see that @xmath53 is open in @xmath47 . if @xmath54 then it is open ; otherwise take @xmath55 and let @xmath56 .
moreover let @xmath35 and @xmath57 be as in the definition of local homeomorphism above .
the set @xmath58 is an open neighbourhood of @xmath59 and we have @xmath60 .
thus @xmath61 and @xmath53 is open .
now , @xmath62 is open by an easy standard argument ( which uses that @xmath13 is hausdorff ) , so we are done since @xmath47 is connected . .
we say that the local homeomorphism @xmath3 lifts the paths if , for every continuous function @xmath63\to y$ ] , with @xmath64 ( called a path in @xmath6 with origin in @xmath65 ) , and for every @xmath66 , there exists a lifting @xmath67\to x$ ] of @xmath68 with @xmath69 . by lemma 1.1 ,
if @xmath7 lifts the paths then it does it with uniqueness , that is the @xmath70 above is unique . .
a continuous map @xmath71\to y$ ] is called a homotopy with base @xmath72 , @xmath73 .
we say that @xmath3 lifts the homotopies if , for any such @xmath74 , and any continuous map @xmath75 such that @xmath76 ( @xmath77 is a lifting of the base of the homotopy ) , there exists a continuous lifting @xmath78 with base @xmath79 , that is @xmath80 and @xmath81 for all @xmath82 .
the path - lifting property is clearly a particular case of the homotopy - lifting property , with @xmath47 a one - point space .
it is then remarkable the following ( path - lifting @xmath83 homotopy - lifting ) .
if the local homeomorphism between hausdorff spaces @xmath3 lifts the paths , then it lifts the homotopies . _
proof_. with the notations as in the above definitions , let @xmath84 be the unique lifting of the path @xmath85 , with origin @xmath86 , for any @xmath51 .
clearly @xmath87 , and @xmath88 .
so starting from @xmath74 and @xmath77 as above , we have defined @xmath78 , all we are left to prove is its continuity on @xmath89 $ ] .
take @xmath90 , and let @xmath22 be the subset of @xmath91 $ ] consisting of all @xmath92 $ ] such that @xmath78 is not continuous at @xmath93 .
we argue by contradiction : assuming @xmath22 non empty , @xmath22 has an infimum @xmath94 ; since @xmath95 is continuous , given any neighborhood @xmath96 of @xmath97 in @xmath13 there exists an interval @xmath98 , an open neighborhood of @xmath99 in @xmath91 $ ] , such that @xmath100 for every @xmath101 . by restricting @xmath96
if necessary we can assume @xmath96 open , and that @xmath7 induces a homeomorphism @xmath102 onto a neighborhood @xmath103 of @xmath104 .
by continuity of @xmath74 there exists a neighborhood @xmath105 of @xmath59 in @xmath47 , and another interval @xmath106 , open neighborhood of @xmath99 in @xmath91 $ ] , such that @xmath107 .
let @xmath108 , and pick @xmath109 , with @xmath110 if @xmath111 ; if @xmath112 let @xmath32 ; in both cases @xmath113 is continuous at @xmath59 ( as a function from @xmath47 to @xmath13 ) , and since @xmath114 , with @xmath96 open , there exists a neighborhood @xmath115 of @xmath59 in @xmath47 such that @xmath116 ; put @xmath117 .
we claim that @xmath118 in fact these functions coincide on @xmath119 ; but then , for every @xmath120 the functions defined on @xmath121 by @xmath122 , @xmath123 are liftings of @xmath85 which coincide on @xmath109 , an hence coincide on all of @xmath121 .
the equality just proved shows that @xmath78 is continuous at @xmath93 , for every @xmath124 , contradicting the minimality of @xmath99 .
( simply connected codomain ) .
let @xmath3 be a local homeomorphism between hausdorff spaces which lifts the paths .
if @xmath4 are path connected and @xmath6 is simply connected , then @xmath7 is a homeomorphism . _
proof_. first of all let us see the surjectivity .
let @xmath125 , @xmath126 , and let @xmath127\to y$ ] be a path with @xmath128 and @xmath129 .
there exists a ( unique ) lifting @xmath130 of @xmath68 with @xmath131 .
the formula @xmath132 gives @xmath133 .
now , let us see the injectivity of @xmath7 .
let @xmath134 satisfy @xmath135 . since @xmath13 is path connected we can consider a path @xmath136\to x$ ] joining @xmath137 , that is with @xmath138 and @xmath139 . the formula @xmath140 defines a circuit in @xmath6 ( i.e. a closed path ) with @xmath141 . since @xmath6 is simply connected there exists a homotopy with fixed end - points @xmath142 between @xmath68 and the constant path @xmath91\to y , t\mapsto y_0 $ ] , namely a continuous function @xmath143 ^ 2 \to y$ ] such that @xmath144 , @xmath145 for all @xmath146 $ ] , and @xmath147 , for all @xmath148\,$ ] ( see the figure below ) .
since @xmath7 lifts paths , then , by lemma 1.2 , there exists a unique @xmath149 ^ 2\to x$ ] which lifts @xmath142 and which satisfies @xmath150 , for all @xmath151 $ ] . in the rest of the proof we use
the following important fact : a constant path is lifted to a constant path ( which works being continuous and which is the unique lifting by lemma 1.1 ) . thus @xmath152 , @xmath153 , for all @xmath154 $ ] ; and since @xmath155 is also constant , we have @xmath156 .
* maximal path - lifting*. let @xmath3 be a local homeomorphism , let @xmath63\to y$ ] be a path with @xmath157 , and let @xmath158 .
we define the maximal lifting @xmath159 of @xmath68 with @xmath160 in the following way .
there certainly exists a continuous map @xmath161 , with @xmath162 $ ] , such that @xmath163 and latexmath:[$f\circ \phi_i=\alpha @xmath121 of all the intervals @xmath165 . .
let @xmath166 be a continuous function .
then the following formula , where ` @xmath167 ' denotes the closure in @xmath13 , defines the @xmath0-limit set of @xmath168 : @xmath169 equivalently , @xmath170 if and only if @xmath2 is a cluster point of a sequence @xmath171 , for some sequence @xmath172 which converges to @xmath173 ; in the particular case of @xmath13 metrizable , @xmath174 if and only if there exists a sequence @xmath175 with @xmath176 such that @xmath177 and @xmath178 as @xmath179 .
if @xmath168 were a solution of an autonomous differential equation @xmath180 , then the terminology ` @xmath0-limit set ' would be usual .
this concept has paramount importance since one of the main goal of dynamics is precisely to say what is the destiny of the motions ( incidentally , recall that @xmath0 is the last letter of the greek alphabet ) .
( @xmath0-limit set of a maximal path lifting ) .
let @xmath3 be a local homeomorphism between hausdorff spaces , and let @xmath159 be the maximal lifting of @xmath63\to y$ ] with @xmath181 . if @xmath182 $ ] then it is open to the right , i.e. @xmath183 with @xmath1840,1]$ ] , and the @xmath0-limit set of @xmath168 is empty : @xmath185 . _
proof_. we argue by contradiction by assuming that @xmath186 $ ] with @xmath187 .
we consider a local inverse of @xmath7 at @xmath188 and we easily extend @xmath168 to a lifting defined on a larger domain , this contradicts the maximality of @xmath168 .
so @xmath189 for a suitable @xmath1840,1]$ ] .
now , let us contradict @xmath185 and let @xmath190 . then
@xmath191 since by continuity @xmath192 and @xmath193)=\{\alpha(b)\}\ ] ] ( in metric spaces we could just argue with sequences ) .
consider open neighbourhoods @xmath35 , of @xmath20 and @xmath194 respectively , such that @xmath102 be a homeomorphism , and let @xmath195 be the inverse function .
we can consider @xmath196 such that @xmath197)\subset v$ ] , and such that @xmath198 .
moreover , we can define @xmath199\to x$ ] lifting of @xmath200 $ ] by @xmath201=\phi |[0,a]$ ] and by @xmath202a , b]=g\circ \alpha |]a , b]$ ] .
this contradicts the maximality of @xmath168 .
now we are ready to prove theorem 0.1 of the introduction .
* proof of the hadamard - caccioppoli theorem*. let @xmath7 be proper ( in the other sense the theorem is trivial ) .
we are going to prove that @xmath7 lifts the paths .
this gives the theorem by means of lemma 1.3 .
we argue by contradiction by assuming the existence of a path @xmath63\to y$ ] and a point @xmath158 such that the maximal lifting @xmath168 of @xmath68 , with @xmath160 , is defined on @xmath203 , with @xmath204 ( but not on @xmath91 $ ] ) .
then lemma 1.4 says that @xmath185 .
but @xmath205))$ ] and this last set is compact since @xmath7 is proper . since every finite family of closed sets @xmath206 has nonempty intersection , then @xmath207 a contradiction .
* closed local homeomorphisms*. the hypothesis of properness of @xmath7 can be replaced by closedness of @xmath7 : that is , a local homeomorphism between hausdorff spaces which maps closed subsets of @xmath13 into closed subsets of @xmath6 has the path lifting property . to see this ,
argue as above : to prove that @xmath208 is non - empty , take a sequence @xmath172 converging to @xmath173 and such that @xmath209 consists of distinct points , and is never equal to @xmath210 ( such a sequence certainly exists , unless @xmath68 is constant on some left neighborhood of @xmath173 ) . if the sequence @xmath171 has no cluster point , then its range @xmath211 is a closed set in @xmath13 ; but then @xmath212 is closed in @xmath6 ; this is plainly absurd , since @xmath213 , but @xmath214 converges to @xmath210 .
there are relations between properness and closedness , see proposition 1.1 below . * a counterexample*. we are going to show that the preceding theorem is not true if we drop the hausdorff property .
let @xmath215 with @xmath216 with the following topology : the open sets in @xmath26 , @xmath217 , with @xmath218 open neighbourhood of @xmath219 in @xmath26 , and @xmath220 .
the topological space @xmath221 can be said ` the line with two origins ' , it is path connected but the hausdorff property does not hold true .
we easily check that the function @xmath222 whose restriction to @xmath26 is the identity , and with @xmath223 , is a proper local homeomorphism but it is not injective .
incidentally , also simple connectedness is essential , at least for locally well behaved spaces .
now , let us state two propositions , whose proofs are easy , to remind what proper functions are in the context of metrizable spaces and for maps @xmath224 .
( proper maps in metrizable spaces ) .
let @xmath3 be a continuous function between the metrizable spaces @xmath4 .
then @xmath7 is proper if and only if every sequence @xmath225 in @xmath13 admits a converging subsequence whenever @xmath226 converges .
moreover , if such a function @xmath7 is proper then it is closed . finally , a closed local homeomorphism between metrizable spaces without isolated points is a proper map .
( proper maps between euclidean spaces ) .
a continuous function @xmath227 is proper if and only if it is coercive , namely @xmath228 .
( nonexistence of a product in @xmath229-space for @xmath230 ) .
the @xmath229-space @xmath31 with @xmath230 can not be endowed of a product operation @xmath231 , @xmath232 which has the following properties for any @xmath233 and any @xmath234 * ( i)@xmath235 * ( ii)@xmath236 * ( iii)@xmath237 either @xmath238 or @xmath239 * ( iv)@xmath240 . in other words
: @xmath31 , with @xmath230 , does not have a commutative algebra structure without zero divisors .
remark that the associative property @xmath241 is not required . _
proof_. we again argue by contradiction , and we denote by @xmath242 the product .
consider the function @xmath243 , @xmath244 , with @xmath245 .
first , note that @xmath7 is a @xmath246 function on @xmath13 : if @xmath247 , where @xmath248 is the standard base of @xmath31 , then @xmath249 , a quadratic polynomial function , hence @xmath246 .
next , denoting by @xmath250 the minimum , respectively the maximum , value of @xmath251 when @xmath2 ranges over the unit sphere of @xmath31 , we have @xmath252 this follows from @xmath253 , valid for every @xmath254 ( note that , by ( i ) , @xmath255 for every non - zero real number @xmath256 ) , and readily implies that @xmath7 is a proper map .
the differential of @xmath7 is given by @xmath257 , for every @xmath258 and @xmath259 .
in fact , by ( i ) and ( ii ) , @xmath260 by ( iv ) we then have @xmath261 , so that @xmath262 by ( iii ) , @xmath263 imply @xmath264 .
thus @xmath265 is nonsingular , for every @xmath258 . now all the hypotheses of the hadamard - caccioppoli theorem are satisfied ( in particular @xmath6 is simply connected ) , and so @xmath7 is a homeomorphism , in particular it is injective ; but clearly @xmath266 , a contradiction .
_ remark to the proof_. @xmath267 is simply connected
if and only if @xmath10 , and actually commutative division algebra structures exist on @xmath31 if @xmath268 ; the quaternions prove that commutativity is essential for the above result ( what fails is that @xmath265 , now given by @xmath269 , is singular for some @xmath258 ) .
in this section @xmath4 will always be banach spaces , @xmath22 an open connected set , with @xmath270 , and @xmath271 a local homeomorphism . .
let @xmath17 , and @xmath272 .
we are going to define a flow @xmath273 which will be our tool in investigating the invertibility of @xmath7 around @xmath20 .
the basic properties of @xmath274 , so that it is called a flow in @xmath22 , are the following : * \(i ) @xmath275 is an open subset of @xmath276 , and @xmath277 is continuous ; * \(ii ) for all @xmath278 , the set @xmath279 is an interval containing @xmath219 ; * \(iii ) @xmath280 ; * \(iv ) @xmath281 and @xmath282 for all @xmath278 , @xmath283 . to define @xmath274 we start from the following dynamical system in @xmath6 : @xmath286 whose trajectories are the half - lines hinged at @xmath39 , but with an exponential parameter instead of a linear one , so that @xmath287 , @xmath288 as @xmath289 .
it is indeed a dynamical system , because @xmath290 .
( the auxiliary flow ) .
let @xmath4 be banach spaces , let @xmath291 be open and connected , let @xmath17 , and let @xmath12 be a local homeomorphism .
then there exists a flow @xmath292 which satisfies the following formula and two such flows coincide in the intersection of their domains ( so @xmath274 will be maximal in the sequel ) . in the particular case where @xmath7 is a local diffeomorphism ( namely it is also @xmath294 together with all its local inverses ) , the mapping @xmath274 is @xmath294 and it is the flow of the following differential equation @xmath295 _ proof .
_ fix @xmath278 and consider the continuous function @xmath299 @xmath300 .
by similar arguments as in section 1 we prove the existence of a unique maximal lifting @xmath301a(x),b(x)[\to d$ ] , @xmath302 , with @xmath298 , @xmath303 .
let @xmath304a(x),b(x)[$ ] .
all the properties above are easy to check except ( i ) which requires some arguments .
we consider the subset @xmath305 only ; the set @xmath306-\infty,0]$ ] is handled similarly .
let @xmath17 be given .
first consider the supremum @xmath307 of all real numbers @xmath308 such that @xmath309 is contained in the interior of @xmath310 ( if no such @xmath311 exists , then @xmath312 ) .
next , define @xmath313 to be the set of all real @xmath314 $ ] such that @xmath274 is not continuous at @xmath315 ; arguing as in lemma 1.2 one easily sees that @xmath313 is empty . and still arguing as in lemma 1.2 , with @xmath307 in place of @xmath99 , it is also easy to see that @xmath316 , hence that @xmath310 is open . * the attraction basin*. let @xmath12 , @xmath20 , @xmath274 be as in lemma 2.1 ( in the general case ) , and let @xmath272 .
let @xmath96 be an open neighbourhood of @xmath20 where @xmath7 is injective and let @xmath317 .
for any small @xmath318 , the ball @xmath319 ( with center at @xmath39 and radius @xmath320 ) is contained in @xmath321 , and for such @xmath320 let @xmath322 .
then @xmath323 is a neighbourhood of @xmath20 , and for all @xmath324 the trajectories @xmath325 of @xmath274 are defined globally in the future , belong to @xmath323 for all @xmath326 and converge to @xmath20 as @xmath289 .
then @xmath20 is an _ attractor _ namely it attracts a whole neighbourhood ( any @xmath323 will do ) , and it is _ stable _ that is any of its neighbourhoods contains a positively invariant neighbourhood with global existence in the future , indeed again we can consider @xmath323 , with small enough @xmath320 ( we remind that positive invariance means that @xmath327 for any @xmath324 and @xmath311 , such that @xmath328 ) .
so we just proved that @xmath20 is asymptotically stable , i.e. a stable attractor .
the maximal neighbourhood @xmath21 of @xmath20 such that , for all @xmath329 , the trajectories @xmath325 of @xmath274 are defined globally in the future , belong to @xmath21 for all @xmath326 , and converge to @xmath20 as @xmath289 , is called the basin of attraction of @xmath20 . *
\(i ) the restriction of @xmath7 to @xmath21 is injective , * \(ii ) @xmath24 is star - shaped with respect to @xmath25 , and * \(iii ) @xmath21 is the maximal connected subset of @xmath22 which contains @xmath20 and has the properties ( i ) and ( ii ) . to prove that @xmath7 is injective on @xmath21 ,
let @xmath331 be such that @xmath332 .
then for all @xmath333 @xmath334 since , for large @xmath256 , both @xmath335 and @xmath336 enter a neighbourhood of @xmath20 where @xmath7 is injective , we have that @xmath337 for large @xmath256 .
thus for large @xmath256 we have @xmath338 .
the image @xmath24 is star - shaped with respect to @xmath39 because @xmath339 ( bijectivity @xmath340 @xmath285 ) .
let @xmath13 and @xmath6 be banach spaces , let @xmath291 be open and connected , let @xmath17 , let @xmath12 be a local homeomorphism , and let @xmath274 be the auxiliary flow as above .
then @xmath7 is a global homeomorphism onto @xmath6 if and only if the flow @xmath274 is a global dynamical system .
_ suppose first that @xmath7 is a global homeomorphism onto @xmath6 .
then the inverse mapping @xmath341 is defined and continuous on @xmath6 and the expression @xmath342 is defined and continuous for all @xmath343 .
conversely , suppose that @xmath285 .
let @xmath344 and @xmath345 such that @xmath346 , and let @xmath347 .
then @xmath348 and @xmath23 is proved to be onto @xmath6 . to verify that @xmath7 is also one - to - one on all of @xmath22 , i.e. , that @xmath349 , it suffices to prove that @xmath21 is a closed subset of @xmath22 , because we already know that it is open and nonempty .
let then @xmath350 be a sequence converging to @xmath278 .
since @xmath351 , there exists @xmath352 such that @xmath353 . recalling that @xmath354 is continuous , from @xmath355 we get that @xmath356 , whence @xmath357 . *
proof of the hadamard - levy theorem*. by the preceding proposition 2.3 we can just show that the solutions to the equation ( 2.3 ) are defined on the whole @xmath26 .
first remark that by ( 2.1 ) , and ( 2.2 ) , @xmath358
so this is bounded whenever @xmath256 ranges on a bounded interval .
then , along a trajectory @xmath359a , b[\to d$ ] , @xmath360 , defined in a bounded interval of time @xmath301a , b[$ ] , we have the following estimate for the vector field in ( 2.3 ) : @xmath361 for a suitable @xmath362 ( the function @xmath363 was introduced in ( 0.3 ) ) . from now on the arguments
are standard , however we prefer to complete the proof to be self - contained .
let @xmath364 .
then for @xmath365 we have @xmath366 the function @xmath367 is lipschitz continuous and the function @xmath368 is @xmath294 ( remind that @xmath7 is a local diffeomorphism in the present theorem ) , so that @xmath369 is locally absolutely continuous and it has derivative almost everywhere . by the previous estimate , dividing by @xmath370 and going to the limit we have @xmath371 almost everywhere .
now , for @xmath372a , b[$ ] @xmath373 then @xmath374 for @xmath375a , b[$ ] is bounded from above by any @xmath376 large enough to give @xmath377 ( remind the first formula in ( 0.3 ) ) .
using again the inequality ( 2.4 ) and this time the monotonicity of @xmath363 we see that @xmath378 .
then @xmath368 is lipschitz continuous on @xmath301a , b[$ ] and it can be extended by continuity to @xmath99 and @xmath173 .
( on @xmath379 the trajectories have finite life ) .
let us assume the hypotheses of the first part of lemma 2.1 .
then the attraction basin @xmath21 is invariant , namely @xmath380 @xmath381 @xmath382 for all @xmath256 such that @xmath328 , and also @xmath383 ( the boundary of @xmath21 in @xmath22 ) is invariant .
moreover , there is not global existence in the future for @xmath384 if @xmath385 .
_ first of all let us see that @xmath386 the set @xmath21 is open in @xmath13 and @xmath7 is a one - to - one local homeomorphism on @xmath21 , so that @xmath24 turns out to be open , too , and @xmath387 is a homeomorphism .
@xmath388 is contained in the closure of @xmath24 because @xmath7 is continuous .
let @xmath389 be a point in the closure of @xmath21 such that @xmath390 , i.e. , @xmath391 for some @xmath392 . let @xmath393 , @xmath394 , be a sequence of points of @xmath21 converging to @xmath389 . by continuity of @xmath7
we have @xmath395 , and by continuity of @xmath396 we have @xmath397 , so that @xmath398 . from ( 2.5 ) and
the fact that @xmath24 is a neighbourhood of @xmath272 , there exists @xmath345 such that it is obvious from its definition that @xmath21 is invariant for the flow @xmath400 .
the same holds for @xmath383 : in fact , let @xmath385 , @xmath350 , @xmath401 , @xmath402
. then @xmath403 for all large @xmath229 , because @xmath310 is open , and , by continuity @xmath404 .
the point @xmath405 belongs to the closure of @xmath21 , but not to @xmath21 , because otherwise @xmath406 itself would be in @xmath21 . *
trapped trajectories*. we need to guarantee that the trajectories of @xmath274 which are trapped into a closed and bounded subset of @xmath22 are defined globally in the future ( condition ( c ) in lemma 2.3 below ) .
this is familiar and always true for solutions to differential equations which are ` trapped ' into compact sets in finite dimension .
the following lemma 2.3 shows few technical conditions each of which implies this property . in the statement
we denote by @xmath409\subset y\;$ ] the line segment from @xmath194 to @xmath410 .
( trapped trajectories never die ) .
let @xmath13 and @xmath6 be banach spaces , let @xmath291 be open and connected , let @xmath17 , let @xmath12 be a local homeomorphism , and let @xmath274 be the auxiliary flow as above . consider the following conditions : * ( a-1 ) the restriction @xmath411 is proper for any set @xmath412 closed and bounded in @xmath22 ; * ( a-2 ) @xmath7 is a local @xmath294 diffeomorphism and for each bounded and closed set @xmath413 we have @xmath414 * \(b ) for any @xmath412 , closed and bounded subset of @xmath22 , and any @xmath415 , the connected components of @xmath416)\cap b$ ] are compact ; * \(c ) for any @xmath412 , closed and bounded subset of @xmath22 , and any @xmath415 , if @xmath417 for all @xmath311 such that @xmath328 , then the trajectory through @xmath2 is global in the future ( in other words : trajectories which are eventually in bounded closed sets never die ) . _ proof . _
the proof is trivial except for ( a-2 ) @xmath418 ( b ) .
let @xmath419 be a component of @xmath416)\cap b$ ] .
pick @xmath420 , and let @xmath421 . if @xmath264 , then @xmath422 $ ] consists of the single point @xmath194 and @xmath419 is then also a singleton , since @xmath7 is a local homeomorphism .
assume then @xmath423 .
since @xmath424 is connected , the set @xmath425 is a bounded interval @xmath165 of @xmath26 containing @xmath219 .
let @xmath426 be the maximal lifting of the path @xmath427 with origin @xmath428 . since @xmath7 is a local diffeomorphism ,
such an @xmath68 is differentiable , and differentiating @xmath429 we get @xmath430 , whence @xmath431 . since @xmath432 is finite , @xmath433 is bounded on its maximal interval @xmath121 of existence ; thus the @xmath0-limit set of @xmath68 is nonempty , and it is contained in the closed set @xmath419 .
it follows that @xmath434 , and by the same token , that @xmath435 , and @xmath436 , that is , @xmath165 is compact .
it is now obvious that @xmath7 induces a homeomorphism of @xmath419 onto @xmath424 , which has @xmath437 as inverse .
thus @xmath419 is compact , since @xmath424 is homeomorphic to @xmath165 _ via _ @xmath438 . *
a class of functions satisfying ( a-1)*. the condition ( a-1 ) is fulfilled if @xmath439 with @xmath43 proper and @xmath440 compact , i.e. , mapping closed bounded sets to compact sets . indeed , remind proposition 1.1 , and consider a sequence @xmath225 in the closed bounded set @xmath412 , with @xmath226 convergent . since @xmath440 is compact , it maps a subsequence @xmath441 to a convergent sequence @xmath442 , thus @xmath443 converges and finally @xmath441 has a convergent subsequence since @xmath43 is proper .
* global lyapunov functions*. in our framework the function @xmath446 is called a global lyapunov function for the flow @xmath274 above , if it is continuous , nonnegative , coercive , and weakly decreasing along the trajectories , namely @xmath447 weakly decreases for all @xmath278 .
( injectivity and star - shaped image by lyapunov functions ) .
let @xmath4 be banach spaces , let @xmath291 be open and connected , let @xmath17 , and let @xmath12 be a local homeomorphism .
then @xmath7 is injective , and the image @xmath448 is star - shaped with respect to @xmath194 , if there exists a global lyapunov function for @xmath274 , and @xmath7 satisfies any of the conditions ( a-1 ) , ( a-2 ) , ( b ) , ( c ) in lemma 2.3 .
it is enough to show that the boundary @xmath379 ( of @xmath21 in @xmath22 ) is empty .
we argue by contradiction and assume that @xmath450 by lemma 2.2 the maximal positive trajectory through @xmath2 , @xmath451 , @xmath384 , lies in @xmath383 , and has a finite life : @xmath452 , and @xmath453 .
the lyapunov function @xmath454 is coercive and , in particular , @xmath455)$ ] is bounded in @xmath22 .
moreover , @xmath456 is decreasing and so @xmath457 .
now lemma 2.3 says that condition ( c ) above holds true , namely @xmath458 , a contradiction .
the preceding result , as well as the following one , extend some results in [ 17 ] ( by two of the authors ) where the finite dimensional case is treated . that paper also shows that the converse of proposition 2.3 holds true in @xmath31 ( and proves other related facts ) . in the following statement
we consider an hilbert space @xmath13 with scalar product ` @xmath459 ' , and @xmath460 will denote the open ball @xmath461 .
we could formulate an analogous fact in general banach spaces but it would be more complicated to be stated ( but not to be proved ) .
( a criterion of injectivity on a ball ) .
let @xmath13 be a hilbert space , @xmath34 , @xmath6 be a banach space , @xmath462 be a local @xmath294 diffeomorphism satisfying any of the conditions of lemma 2.3 .
then the following two conditions are equivalent : _ proof . _ the left - hand side of ( 2.8 ) is the derivative with respect to @xmath256 at @xmath467 of the scalar function @xmath468 asking it to be nonnegative is the same as asking the scalar function @xmath469 to be weakly decreasing along the flow @xmath274 , which in turn is the same as requiring the same from each of the functions @xmath470 on @xmath460 , @xmath471 .
these last functions have the advantage of being coercive on @xmath460 .
hence condition ( b ) is satisfied , proposition 2.6 can be applied to get condition ( a ) .
conversely , if condition ( a ) holds , then the sets @xmath460 are positively invariant for @xmath274 and the ( square ) norm of @xmath405 must be a weakly decreasing function of @xmath256 , whence inequality ( 2.8 ) . g.h .
meisters , inverting polynomial maps of @xmath229-space by solving differential equations , in _ fink , miller , kliemann editors , delay and differential equations : proceedings in honour of george seifert on his retirement _ , world sci . pub .
co. , 107166 ( 1992 ) .
meisters and c. olech , solution of the global asymptotic stability jacobian conjecture for the polynomial case , in : _ analyse mathmatique et applications _ , gauthier - villars , paris , 373381 ( 1988 ) . | this is an exposition of some basic ideas in the realm of global inverse function theorems .
we address ourselves mainly to readers who are interested in the applications to differential equations .
but we do not deal with those applications and we give a ` self - contained ' elementary exposition . the first part is devoted to the celebrated hadamard - caccioppoli theorem on proper local homeomorphisms treated in the framework of the hausdorff spaces . in the proof , the concept of ` @xmath0-limit set ' is used in a crucial way and this is perhaps the novelty of our approach . in the second part we deal with open sets in banach spaces .
the concept of ` attraction basin ' here is the main tool of our exposition which also shows a few recent results , here extended from finite dimensional to general banach spaces , together with the classical theorem of hadamard - levy which assumes that the operator norm of the inverse of the derivative does not grow too fast ( roughly at most linearly ) . |
after the discovery of the mssbauer effect in 1958 , quantitative measurements of relativistic time dilation were carried out in the 1960s based on this effect @xcite-@xcite , and the interest in such measurements lasts to this day @xcite,@xcite . the experiments @xcite-@xcite reported full agreement with the time dilation predicted by einstein s theory of relativity . in the experiments @xcite-@xcite ,
the mssbauer source was placed at the center of a fast rotating disk and an absorber at the rim of the disk . in the analyses of these experiments ,
it was assumed that the absorption line of the rotating absorber stays lorentzian with same width as at rest , and is shifted only by the time dilation factor .
based on the generalized principle of relativity and the ensuing symmetry , in @xcite it was shown that there are only two possible types of transformations between uniformly accelerated systems . the validity of the _ clock hypothesis _ is crucial to determining which one of the two types of transformations is obtained .
the clock hypothesis , as stated in @xcite , maintains that the rate of an accelerated clock is equal to that of a co - moving unaccelerated clock .
if the clock hypothesis is not true , then the transformation is of lorentz - type and implies the existence of a universal maximal acceleration @xmath1 and an additional time dilation due to the acceleration of the clock . by _ acceleration _
, we mean the proper acceleration defined @xcite as @xmath2 , where @xmath3 is the proper time . in this case
, it was shown in @xcite that a doppler type shift for an accelerated source will be observed .
this doppler type shift is similar to the doppler shift due to the velocity of the source .
the formulas for this shift are the same as those for the velocity doppler shift , with @xmath4 replaced by @xmath5 .
consider an absorber placed on a disk , rotating with angular velocity @xmath6 at the distance @xmath7 from the center .
if this absorber is exposed to radiation of frequency @xmath8 through the center of the disk , then , since the velocity of the absorber is perpendicular to the radiation direction , the radiation will undergo a transverse doppler shift @xmath9 due to the time dilation of the absorber .
if the conjecture about the existence of a shift due to acceleration is true , there will be an additional shift @xmath10 , which is longitudinal , since the acceleration is in the direction of the radiation .
kndig s experiment @xcite measured the transverse doppler shift for a rotating disk by means of the mssbauer effect . in ( only )
this experiment , the absorption line of the rotating absorber was obtained .
this experiment , as reanalyzed by kholmetskii _
et al _ @xcite , showed a significant deviation of about @xmath11 of the shift observed from the one predicted by special relativity .
this deviation was explained in @xcite by the additional shift due to the acceleration .
moreover , the value of the maximal acceleration @xmath1 was estimated to be about @xmath12 .
this value of the maximal acceleration implies that the ratio of the new shift ( due to acceleration ) to the transversal one due to the velocity is @xmath13 where @xmath7 is the distance ( @xmath14 in @xcite ) of the absorber from the center of the disk .
kndig s experiment was not designed to test the acceleration shift , and the recalculation by kholmetskii _ et al _ is not direct .
thus , the corrected kndig s result may serve only as an indication of the existence of a maximal acceleration and an estimate of its value .
note that in other time dilation experiments , the value of @xmath7 was about @xmath15 , implying that the ratio of the new shift to the known one is @xmath16 .
how was such a deviation not observed in @xcite-@xcite ?
the reason for this is that their analyses did not take into account the broadening of the absorption curves during the rotation , as is explained below .
we show here that the absorption line of a rotating mssbauer absorber gets broader during the rotation , even in the case when the absorber moves in the perpendicular direction to the radiation .
this is due to the fact that the slit for the radiation beam leaving the source and the opening slit of the detector must have a finite width .
therefore , the velocity of the absorber is not perpendicular to all individual rays .
hence , these rays undergo a longitudinal doppler shift in addition to the expected transversal one .
this shift is very significant even for very small slits for the radiation beam and for detector , and leads to broadened non - lorentzian absorption lines .
choose the direction of the radiation beam to be in the direction of the @xmath17-axis , and place the origin at center of the source and the detector at @xmath18 .
denote by @xmath19 the velocity of the absorber . in order for the transversal doppler shift @xmath20 to be observed ,
the velocity must be at least @xmath21 a ray leaves the source at the point @xmath22 and enters the detector at a point @xmath23 .
the component of the velocity of the absorber in the direction @xmath24 of the ray , for @xmath25 , is @xmath26 , which may be significant even for very small width of the slits ( 2d in figure 1 ) .
this implies that most rays will also be exposed to a longtitudal doppler shift and will change completely the shape of the mssbauer absorption line .
one should observe a decrease in the absorption amplitude and a non - lorentzian broadening of the absorption spectrum .
we choose again the direction of the radiation beam to be in the direction of the @xmath17-axis .
we place the origin at the center of the rotating disk ( @xmath27 ) .
the radiation leaves the source at the point @xmath28 and enters the detector at a point @xmath23 .
the equation of the radiation line is @xmath29 and has the direction @xmath30 , and intersects the @xmath31-axis at the point @xmath32 , where @xmath33 and @xmath34 obviously may have any value between @xmath35 and @xmath36 .
denote the distance of the absorber to the center by @xmath7 , and denote the intersection point of our ray with the absorber by @xmath37 .
since this point is on our radiation line , it satisfies the equation @xmath38 the velocity of the absorber at @xmath39 is @xmath40 , where @xmath6 is the angular velocity of the disk .
thus , from equation ( [ absorbpos ] ) , we get that the component of the velocity of the absorber in the direction of the ray is @xmath41 which , for @xmath25 , is approximately equal to @xmath42 , and even then the velocity @xmath43 is extremely large for @xmath44 and @xmath45 , in comparison to the natural full width at half absorption intensity ( @xmath46 ) of the @xmath47 mssbauer absorption single line spectrum . a typical absorption curve is obtained by placing the source on a transducer and moving it with a velocity @xmath48 in the direction of the @xmath17-axis .
this velocity is of order up to several millimeters per second . for such velocities
, we may assume that the source velocity in the radiation direction @xmath24 is approximately equal @xmath49 .
the absorption curve @xmath50 of an absorber rotating with angular velocity @xmath6 describes the rate of the radiation absorbed as a function of the velocity @xmath49 of the source . for a thin absorber with no chemical shift ,
a typical absorption curve for an absorber at rest is a lorentzian function @xmath51 , of half width @xmath0 , absorption amplitude @xmath52 , and resonance at @xmath53 , as the one shown in figure 3a for @xmath54 . for a rotating absorber , the total doppler shift that the ray undergoes consists of a longitudinal shift due to the relative velocity of the source and the absorber and a transversal shift due to the time dilation of the absorber .
all together are equivalent to a longitudinal shift of a source with velocity @xmath55 since the spread in @xmath43 is increasing with angular velocity , it contributes significantly to the spread of the observed absorption mssbauer line . using ( [ vn ] ) and ( [ tildets ] )
, the absorption curve of the rotating absorber will be @xmath56 where the integral has to be taken over the source emission intensity at @xmath57 and absorption by detector at @xmath58 .
this curve can be calculated analytically , if we assume that the distributions along @xmath57 and @xmath58 are uniform on interval @xmath59 $ ] , @xmath25 and @xmath60 . under these assumptions @xmath61 . denoting @xmath62 and defining a function @xmath63 such that @xmath64
, we get @xmath65@xmath66 thus , @xmath67 if @xmath68 and @xmath69 , implying that the absorption curve of the rotating absorber will be @xmath70 , which is a shift of the absorption curve of the non - rotating absorber .
this was assumed in the experiments @xcite-@xcite .
it is obvious that @xmath71 is symmetric and @xmath72 is symmetric with respect to @xmath73 .
the results of the calculated absorption spectra using equation ( [ absorrotatingabs ] ) , using numerical integration , or using the analytic function ( [ aomega ] ) yield the same results , shown as transmission rate spectra line @xmath74 in figure 3 .
the simulations show that even for small @xmath75 , if @xmath6 becomes large enough the absorption line broadens drastically and even becomes unobservable .
these curves have the same type of widening and shift as the absorption curves obtained experimentally in @xcite . in the experiments @xcite-@xcite,@xcite ,
the value of @xmath76 was measured only in the case in which the source and the absorber were relatively static , corresponding to @xmath53 . obviously in their experiments
@xmath77 , ( they do not specify ) , and their analysis did not consider the changes in shape of the absorption line as a function of @xmath6 .
thus we can not rely on their conclusions .
if the distributions of source emission intensity is @xmath57 dependent and the detection is @xmath58 dependent , but symmetric in the interval @xmath59 $ ] , one will still observe under the rotation a symmetric broadening .
if the distribution is not symmetric and has non - zero average , we will get an additional shift , but such a shift can be compensated for by reversing the direction of the rotation . *
conclusions : * in order to measure the transverse doppler shift by conventional msbauer spectroscopy with source mounted on a static transducer and the absorber moving on a fast rotating disc , one should take care of the following : ( a ) : : one must measure the full spectrum of the absorption line .
( b ) : : one must measure this spectrum in both angular directions of the absorber .
but most important ; ( c ) : : one must put collimators on source and detector to reduce the slits to minimal dimensions , which will still allow a spectrum measurement in a reasonable time span . only the experiment of w. kndig @xcite
obeyed at least ( a ) and ( b ) . in his experiment he used a source of @xmath78 against a @xmath47 enriched iron absorber .
thus both were almost identical and in both the iron nuclei were exposed to a strong magnetic field ( 33 t ) causing the emission and absorption spectra to be composed of six line patterns , which lead to observed multiline spectra as shown in fig.4 ( bottom ) , for various rotational frequencies of the absorber . since kndig scanned the spectra in the range of about -1 to + 1 mm / s , he observed only the central line with reduced intensity and line broadening , as the lines simulated in fig.4 ( middle and top ) .
thus he actually observed the line broadening due to the finite slits , but interpreted them as due to rotor vibrations affecting the absorber .
nevertheless this experiment seems to be still the most accurate transverse doppler shift experiment using the @xmath47 mssbauer effect .
his results with the corrected analysis reported in @xcite indicates that the observed shift in this experiment is larger and deviates @xmath79 from that expected by special relativity theory .
einstein time dilation formula was verified by several experiments @xcite- . in w.
kndig experiment the absorber was exposed to a significant acceleration .
in @xcite it was indicated that the deviation of the shift in the experiment may be due to a longitudinal doppler shift caused by the acceleration of the absorber .
it led to an estimate of a universal maximal acceleration of order @xmath12 and an indication of non - validity of the einstein clock hypothesis @xcite . for a long time ,
b. mashhoon argued against the clock hypothesis and developed nonlocal transformations for accelerated observers ( see the review article @xcite ) .
note that time dilation mssbauer effect experiments have an advantage in identifying relatively small shift due to acceleration , since in these experiments the shift due to the velocity is of second order while the shift due the acceleration is of first order .
thus we recommend mssbauer spectroscopy scientists to perform an accurate experiment measuring the shift of the absorption line for a fast rotating absorber which may reveal a new fundamental law @xcite , with a monumental effect on whole of physics . h. j. hay _
et al _ , phys .
lett . * 4 * ( 1960 ) 165 h. j. hay , proc .
2nd conf . on the mssbauer effect , ed a. schoen and d. m. t. compton , wiley , ( 1962 ) 225 t. e. cranshaw , j. p. schiffer and p. a. egelstaff , phys .
lett . * 4 * ( 1960 ) 163 t. e. granshaw and h. j. hay , proc .
school of physics ,
enrico fermi " academic press , ( 1963 ) 220 d.c .
champeney and p. b. moon , proc .
* 77 * ( 1961 ) 350 d.c .
champeney , g. r. isaak and a. m. khan , proc .
* 85 * ( 1965 ) 583 w. kndig , phys
* 129 * ( 1963 ) 2371 a.l .
kholmetski , t. yarman and o.v .
missevitch , physica scripta * 77 * ( 2008 ) 035302 a. l. kholmetskii , t. yarman , o. v. missevitch and b. i. rogozeva physica scripta * 79 * ( 2009 ) 065007 y. friedman , yu .
gofman , physica scripta , * 82 * ( 2010 ) 015004 .
a. einstein , ann .
* 35 * ( 1911 ) 898 w. rindler , _ relativity : special , general and cosmological _ , oxford university press ( 2004 ) y. friedman , ann . phys .
( berlin ) * 523 * ( 2011 ) 408 j. bailey et al . ,
nature * 268 * ( 1977 ) 301 r. w. mcgowan , d. m. giltner , s. j. stelnberg and s. au lee , phys .
letters * 70 * ( 1993 ) 251 s. reinhardt et al . , nature physics * 3 * ( 2007 ) 861 c. lmmerzah , nature physics * 3*(2007 ) 831 b. mashhoon , annalen phys . * 17*(2008 ) 705 - 727 . | the einstein time dilation formula was tested in several experiments .
many trials have been made to measure the transverse second order doppler shift by mssbauer spectroscopy using a rotating absorber , to test the validity of this formula .
such experiments are also able to test if the time dilation depends only on the velocity of the absorber , as assumed by einstein s clock hypothesis , or the present centripetal acceleration contributes to the time dilation .
we show here that the fact that the experiment requires @xmath0-ray emission and detection slits of finite size , the absorption line is broadened ; by geometric longitudinal first order doppler shifts immensely . moreover , the absorption line is non - lorenzian .
we obtain an explicit expression for the absorption line for any angular velocity of the absorber . the analysis of the experimental results , in all previous experiments which did not observe the full absorption line itself , were wrong and the conclusions doubtful .
the only proper experiment was done by kndig ( phys .
rev . 129
( 1963 ) 2371 ) , who observed the broadening , but associated it to random vibrations of the absorber .
we establish necessary conditions for the successful measurement of a transverse second order doppler shift by mssbauer spectroscopy .
we indicate how the results of such an experiment can be used to verify the existence of a doppler shift due to acceleration and to test the validity of einstein s clock hypothesis . _
pacs _ : 76.80.+y , 03.30.+p _ keywords _ : mssbauer effect ; absorption line ; time dilation experiments ; transverse doppler shift ; einstein s clock hypothesis |
the discovery of the higgs boson at atlas and cms experiments @xcite made a revolutionary impact on the field of particle physics .
it not only confirmed the so - called higgs mechanism for the electroweak symmetry breaking , but also opened a new possibility to perform a precise test of the standard model ( sm ) by studying the properties of the higgs boson . in the sm ,
the coupling constants of the higgs boson with other particles are well understood using the fact that the masses of quarks , leptons , and weak bosons originate in the vacuum expectation value ( vev ) of the higgs field , resulting in the prediction of the partial decay widths of the higgs boson into various particles . in models with physics beyond the sm ( bsm ) ,
measurements of the higgs couplings provide even exciting possibilities . in large class of bsm models
, there exist new particles at the electroweak to tev scale , which affect the properties of the higgs boson .
thus , with the detailed study of the higgs properties at collider experiments , we have a chance to observe a signal of bsm physics .
such a study will be one of the major subjects in forthcoming collider experiments , i.e. , the lhc and future @xmath1 colliders like ilc and tlep @xcite .
low energy supersymmetry ( susy ) is a well - motivated candidate of bsm physics .
compared to the sm , the particle content is enlarged in susy models . even in the minimal setup ,
i.e. , in the minimal susy sm ( mssm ) , there exist two higgs doublets , @xmath8 and @xmath9 , as well as superparticles .
the lightest higgs boson @xmath10 , which plays the role of the `` higgs boson '' discovered by atlas and cms , is a linear combination of the neutral components of @xmath8 and @xmath9 , while there exist other heavier higgses . in the case where the mass scales of the heavier higgses and the superparticles are high enough ,
the properties of @xmath10 are close to those of the sm higgs boson . on the contrary , if the heavier higgses or superparticles are relatively light , deviations of the higgs properties from the sm predictions may be observed by future collider experiments . with the precise measurement of the partial decay widths ( or branching ratios ) of the higgs boson , information about the heavy higgses and/or superparticles
may be obtained even if those heavy particles can not be directly discovered . in this paper , we discuss how low the mass scales of the heavier higgs bosons and superparticles should be to observe a deviation . we evaluate the partial decay widths of the lightest higgs boson in the mssm , taking account of the following phenomenological constraints : higgs mass , flavor constraints of the @xmath11 mesons , stability of the electroweak ( sm - like ) vacuum against the transition to charge and color breaking ( ccb ) vacua , and perturbativity of coupling constants up to a high scale .
these constraints exclude large fraction of the parameter region giving rise to a significant deviation .
even so , we will see that the deviations of the partial widths from the sm predictions can be of @xmath12 for some of the decay modes in the parameter region allowed by the above - mentioned constraints .
in particular , the deviations may be large enough to be observed by future future @xmath1 colliders like ilc and tlep even if superparticles are so heavy that they would not be observed at the lhc .
the organization of this paper is as follows . in sec .
[ sec : mssm ] , we briefly overview the properties of the higgs bosons in the mssm .
we also summarize the phenomenological constraints that are taken into account in our analysis .
then , in sec . [ sec : width ] , we calculate the partial decay widths of the lightest higgs boson in the mssm and discuss how large the deviation from the sm prediction can be .
[ sec : discussion ] is devoted for conclusions and discussion .
we review some of the important properties of the higgs sector in the mssm .
there are two higgs doublets , @xmath8 and @xmath9 .
as the neutral components acquire vevs , the electroweak symmetry breaking ( ewsb ) occurs .
the ratio of the two higgs vevs is parameterized by @xmath13 . assuming no cp violation in the higgs potential , the mass eigenstates are classified as lighter and heavier cp - even higgs bosons ( denoted as @xmath10 and @xmath14 , respectively ) , cp - odd ( pseudo - scalar ) higgs @xmath15 , and charged higgs @xmath16 . in the following , we concentrate on the case where the masses of the heavier higgses ( @xmath14 , @xmath15 , and @xmath16 ) are much larger than the electroweak scale . then
, the lightest higgs boson @xmath10 should be identified as the one observed by the lhc . on the other hand ,
the masses of the heavier higgses are almost degenerate .
we parameterize the heavier higgs masses using the pseudo - scalar mass @xmath17 . at the tree level ,
the lightest higgs mass is predicted to be smaller than the @xmath18-boson mass , while it is significantly pushed up by radiative corrections @xcite .
the mass matrix of the neutral cp - even higgs bosons is denoted as @xmath19 where @xmath20 represents radiative corrections . at the one - loop level
, the top - stop contribution dominates the radiative correction to the lightest higgs mass , and is approximated as @xmath21,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath22 is the sm higgs vev , @xmath23 is the top - quark mass , @xmath24 ( with @xmath25 and @xmath26 being the lighter and heavier stop masses , respectively ) , and @xmath27 ( with @xmath28 and @xmath29 being the tri - linear scalar couplings for stop and the susy invariant higgsino mass parameter , respectively ) . in this paper
, we adopt the convention of the slha format @xcite .
the top - stop contribution can significantly enhance the lightest higgs mass .
on the other hand , the bottom - sbottom contribution to the lightest higgs mass becomes sizable when the bottom yukawa coupling is large .
it is likely to decrease the lightest higgs mass .
when stop masses are @xmath30 , there are up to four solutions for @xmath28 to satisfy the observed value of the higgs mass @xmath31 , for which we use @xmath32 @xcite .
let us call these four solutions as * ns : negative @xmath28 with smaller @xmath33 , * nl : negative @xmath28 with larger @xmath33 , * ps : positive @xmath28 with smaller @xmath33 , * pl : positive @xmath28 with larger @xmath33 .
assuming universal sfermion masses at the susy scale , the value of @xmath33 is typically a few times larger than the stop mass for nl and pl cases .
such a large value of @xmath33 has significant phenomenological implications , as we will discuss in the next section .
since the one - loop correction to the higgs mass is comparable to the tree - level value , higher order corrections are necessary to obtain reliable results .
in particular , qcd correction , which appears at the two - loop level , and a large hierarchy between the susy scale and the electroweak scale require the resummation of the leading and sub - leading logarithms .
we use feynhiggs 2.10.2 @xcite for the precise evaluation of the higgs masses ( as well as the mixing parameters and the partial decay widths of @xmath10 ) . at the tree level , @xmath8 ( @xmath9 ) couples only to up - type quarks ( down - type quarks as well as leptons ) .
however , this is not the case once radiative corrections due to superparticles are taken into account .
the higgs couplings to bottom quark and tau lepton can be subject to sizable corrections even when susy breaking scale is very large .
let us parameterize the effective @xmath34 and @xmath35 vertices including radiative corrections as @xcite @xmath36 where @xmath37 , @xmath38 , and @xmath39 are right - handed bottom , right - handed top , and third - generation quark - doublets , respectively .
in addition , @xmath40 , @xmath41 and @xmath42 are @xmath43 indices , while the color indices are omitted for simplicity . here ,
@xmath44 and @xmath45 are non - holomorphic radiative corrections to the yukawa coupling constants . for a detailed treatment of the non - holomorphic corrections ,
see refs . @xcite . after the electroweak symmetry breaking
, the yukawa couplings are related to the quark masses as these relations hold at the susy breaking scale .
thus , the quark masses and yukawa couplings in the formula should be understood as the running parameters at the scale .
@xmath46 where , at the leading order in the mass - insertion approximation , @xmath47 is given by @xmath48 \tan\beta , \\
\delta_t & \simeq \left [ \frac{2\alpha_s}{3\pi } m_3 \mu\ , i(m_{\tilde t_1}^2,m_{\tilde t_2}^2,m_3 ^ 2 ) + \frac{y_b^2}{16\pi^2 } \mu a_b\ , i(m_{\tilde b_1}^2,m_{\tilde b_2}^2,\mu^2 ) \right ] \cot\beta,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath49 being the gluino mass .
the loop integral is defined as @xmath50 notice that @xmath51 is enhanced when @xmath52 is large , while @xmath53 is suppressed by @xmath54 .
the mass eigenstates of the higgs bosons are given by linear combinations of @xmath8 and @xmath9 .
the cp - even parts of their neutral components are related to the mass eigenstates as @xmath55 the mixing angle @xmath56 depends on the pseudo - scalar mass @xmath17 , and shows a decoupling behaviour , i.e. , @xmath57 as @xmath58 . in this limit , @xmath10 behaves as the sm higgs boson . using eq .
, we obtain @xcite @xmath59 in fig . [
fig : cosba ] , we show the behavior of @xmath60 as a function of @xmath17 with the masses of superparticles being fixed . here , all the sfermion mass parameters , @xmath61 , @xmath62 , @xmath63 , @xmath64 , and @xmath65 ,
are taken to be universal at the susy scale @xmath66 , where these mass parameters are soft susy breaking masses of sfermions with gauge quantum numbers of @xmath67 , @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath70 , and @xmath71 , respectively , with the numbers in the parenthesis being quantum numbers for @xmath72 , @xmath43 , and @xmath73 . throughout our study
, we take @xmath74 . in addition
, the sfermion masses are assumed to be universal in generation indices .
we can see that radiative corrections can enhance @xmath60 by an order of magnitude when @xmath28 is large , while it is comparable to the tree - level value with the smaller @xmath33 solutions .
is plotted as a function of @xmath17 with @xmath75 , @xmath76 , and the approximate gut relation among gaugino masses ( see eq . ) .
all the sfermion masses are assumed to be universal at @xmath66 , and are also taken to be @xmath77 .
the red and blue lines correspond to the cases of the pl and ps solutions of @xmath28 , respectively .
the black dashed line is the tree - level value . ] denoting @xmath78 coupling ( with @xmath79 being the sm fermions ) as @xmath80 we obtain the @xmath34 coupling constant as @xmath81 g_{h\bar{b}b}^{\rm ( sm ) } , \label{g_hbb}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the superscript `` ( sm ) '' is used for the sm prediction .
when @xmath17 is relatively large , @xmath82 is almost unity , while the second term proportional to @xmath60 induces a sizable deviation from the sm value .
similar relation holds for @xmath83 vertex , and @xmath84 is approximately given by @xmath85 with @xmath86 being the wino mass .
quantitatively , @xmath84 is smaller than @xmath51 in the parameter space of our study . as we will see later
, @xmath87 and @xmath88 may show sizable deviations from the sm predictions even if @xmath17 is above tev .
the @xmath35 coupling constant is obtained as @xmath89 g_{h\bar{t}t}^{\rm ( sm)}. \label{g_htt}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the deviation from the sm value mainly comes from the second term in the bracket and is not enhanced by @xmath52 , since @xmath53 is proportional to @xmath54 .
the gauge - boson final states are also important . in order to calculate the partial decay widths of the higgs to gauge bosons ,
we have modified feynhiggs 2.10.2 package to properly take account of the effect of non - holomorphic correction to the higgs interaction .
we use eq . for the @xmath34 coupling to calculate the partial decay widths of @xmath90 , @xmath91 and @xmath92 .
we found that the factor of @xmath93 was missing in feynhiggs 2.10.2 package ( see eq . ) .
we have also modified the package to take the @xmath94 approximation @xcite for calculating the partial widths , in which the renormalization scale of the higgs wave functions is set to be @xmath95 , and the effects of radiative corrections are included in the mixing between the light and heavy higgs bosons . then , as we will see below , the partial decay widths show proper decoupling behavior in the large @xmath17 limit . in particular
, the partial width @xmath96 converges to the sm value in the limit of large @xmath17 and squark masses .
this behavior looks inconsistent with the result shown in ref .
the processes induced by triangle loops , @xmath97 and @xmath98 , have been important for the higgs discovery at the lhc .
they are also important in studying new particles that couple to the higgs boson . in susy models ,
the stop and sbottom loops contribute to the @xmath99 coupling .
it is expressed by an approximate formula ( cf .
@xcite ) @xmath100 up to @xmath101-term and bottom - loop contributions . here , @xmath102 .
in the right - hand side , the first term comes from the top loop , while the second term is given by the stop and sbottom loops .
the correction is positive in the non - mixing limit ( i.e. , @xmath103 ) , whereas it becomes negative when the mixing terms are sizable .
we also note here that @xmath104 couplings ( with @xmath105 and @xmath106 ) are approximately given by @xmath107 .
this ratio is very close to unity , and hence the deviations in these modes are very small . before discussing the possibility of observing a deviation of the higgs partial widths from the sm prediction at future colliders , we summarize phenomenological constraints on the mssm parameter space which are adopted in our analysis . in the sm , the flavor - changing decay ,
@xmath108 , proceeds by virtual exchanges of the @xmath18 and @xmath109 bosons .
they are suppressed by the final - state helicity .
in contrast , susy contributions can be enhanced considerably by large @xmath52 , when virtual exchanges of the heavy higgs boson contribute to the decay @xcite .
the branching ratio is expressed as @xcite @xmath110,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath111 is the fermi constant , @xmath112 is the @xmath113-meson mass , @xmath114 is the decay constant of @xmath113 , @xmath115 is the muon mass , @xmath116 is the lifetime of @xmath113 , and @xmath117 is cabbino - kobayashi - maskawa matrix element . in the above expression ,
@xmath118 , @xmath119 and @xmath120 are the wilson coefficients of the effective operators , @xmath121 , @xmath122 , and @xmath123 , respectively , while @xmath124 are obtained by flipping chiralities , @xmath125 . among them
, the sm contribution appears only in @xmath118 .
including higher order contributions and taking account of effects of the @xmath126 oscillation , the sm prediction becomes @xcite @xmath127 this can be compared with the lhcb measurements @xcite @xmath128 defining @xmath129 , where the first term in the right - hand side includes both the susy and sm contributions , the 95% c.l . bound
is estimated as @xmath130 we will adopt this constraint in our numerical analysis . even when superparticles are heavy , they affect the branching ratio through non - holomorphic contributions to the heavy higgs couplings . including radiative corrections and diagonalizing the quark mass matrices , effective couplings of the heavy higgs bosons to the down - type fermions become @xcite @xmath131 where @xmath132 .
the flavor - changing coupling is induced by @xmath133 as @xmath134 here , soft scalar masses are assumed to be universal in generation , and @xmath135 is obtained by substituting @xmath136 in eq . .
then , the wilson coefficients receive higgs - mediated contributions , @xmath137 where @xmath138 is the bottom - quark mass , @xmath139 is the weinberg angle , and @xmath140 .
the non - holomorphic correction @xmath133 as well as @xmath51 does not decouple even for very heavy superparticles .
we will see later that the corrections to @xmath141 can be sizable and that the constraint excludes some part of the parameter space of our interest .
the branching ratio of the inclusive decay of @xmath142 may also be sensitive to the non - decoupling contributions to the ( charged ) higgs boson .
in the numerical analysis , defining @xmath143 , we adopt the 95% c.l .
bound , @xmath144 where the experimental value @xmath145 @xcite and the sm prediction @xmath146 @xcite are combined . at the current accuracies , @xmath147 imposes more stringent bound on the parameter space than @xmath142 except when superparticles are light . in the numerical analysis ,
superiso 3.4 @xcite is used for evaluating the susy contributions to the branching ratios as well as the sm predictions . in our analysis , we assume that the squark masses are universal in generations . if the squark masses are non - universal , there are extra contributions to @xmath133 , and the flavor constraints are affected ( see e.g. , ref .
@xcite ) . such a non - universality is expected even in the model with the universal scalar masses at the gut scale .
thus , it should be noted that the flavor constraints that we will show below are just for a particular choice of the squark - mass parameters and may change if the squark mass matrices have non - universal structures . with sufficiently large @xmath33 ,
ccb vacua arise , and the minimum of the scalar potential with the correct ewsb becomes a false vacuum @xcite .
when @xmath148 , stop and the up - type higgs fields acquire large vevs at the ccb vacua , while the vevs of other fields are relatively small .
recently , the decay rate of the sm - like vacuum has been studied in detail for such a case @xcite . on the other hand ,
if @xmath29 is as large as the stop masses , the down - type higgs boson also has a large vev at the ccb vacua due to the tri - linear scalar coupling among stops and the down - type higgs , which is proportional to @xmath149 .
the vacuum stability condition is important in such a case because significant deviations of the higgs partial widths from the sm prediction may occur .
in order to study the sm - like vacuum stability , we consider the tree - level scalar potential in the field space involving @xmath150 , @xmath151 , @xmath152 and @xmath153 ( which are canonically normalized scalar fields embedded in the left - handed stop , right - handed stop , the up - type higgs and the down - type higgs , respectively ) . the relevant part of the potential is given by @xmath154 where @xmath155 when the ccb vacua become deeper than the sm - like vacuum , the latter is not stable .
the vacuum decay rate per unit volume is calculated in the semi - classical approximation , and is expressed as @xmath156 where @xmath157 is the euclidean action of the so - called bounce solution @xcite . for the decay of the sm - like vacuum , @xmath158 is estimated to be @xmath159 . in order for the lifetime of the sm - like vacuum to be longer than the present age of the universe
, the euclidean action is required to satisfy @xmath160 in our numerical analysis , cosmotransition 2.0a1 @xcite is used to find the bounce solution in the four - dimensional field space parameterized by @xmath153 , @xmath152 , @xmath161 and @xmath162 , and to calculate the euclidean bounce action @xmath157 .
the calculation is done at zero temperature , and therefore thermal effects are not taken into account .
the model parameters such as the tri - linear and top yukawa couplings are evaluated at the susy scale @xmath66 . in fig .
[ fig : se ] we show the contours of constant @xmath157 for the ps and pl solutions on @xmath17 vs. @xmath29 plane . here , @xmath163 , while sfermion masses , @xmath63 , @xmath64 and @xmath65 , are taken to be @xmath164 ( see sec .
[ sec : width ] ) . in each plot , the region between the solid ( dashed ) green lines satisfies @xmath165 ( @xmath166 ) . for the ps solution
, these lines appear only for @xmath167 . on the other hand ,
the upper bound on @xmath168 is comparable to the stop masses for the pl solution . and @xmath169 on @xmath17 vs. @xmath29 plane for the ps and pl solutions of @xmath28 . here , @xmath163 , @xmath170 , and @xmath171.,title="fig : " ] and @xmath169 on @xmath17 vs. @xmath29 plane for the ps and pl solutions of @xmath28 . here , @xmath163 , @xmath170 , and @xmath171.,title="fig : " ] + the tree - level potential eq .
is used for our numerical analysis .
radiative corrections may change the scalar potential particularly around the sm - like vacuum . in order to study their effects
, we also estimated the decay rate of the sm - like vacuum by including the top - stop and bottom - sbottom one - loop correction to the higgs potential .
a better treatment would be to introduce full one - loop radiative corrections to the potential involving stop , sbottom and the higgs boson so that the potential is stable against the renormalization scale at least at the one - loop level .
we found that the euclidean action tends to increase by about 10
20% for @xmath172 from that of the tree - level potential .
in order to see the sensitivity of @xmath157 to @xmath29 , we show the contours of @xmath173 in the same plot . when both @xmath29 and @xmath52 are large , we might have to consider other ccb vacua in the sbottom - higgs direction , which is driven by the tri - linear coupling of @xmath174 ( where @xmath175 and @xmath176 are left- and right - handed sbottoms , respectively ) ( cf .
if both @xmath29 and @xmath177 are large , the bottom yukawa coupling can be enhanced not only by @xmath52 but also by @xmath178 ( see eq . ) . however , when the squark masses are universal , such a parameter region is already excluded by the other constraints discussed in this section . therefore we do not consider the constraint coming from the ccb vacuum involving the sbottom sector in this paper .
when @xmath52 is very large , the bottom yukawa coupling is sizable .
we can impose an upper bound on @xmath52 by requiring perturbativity of the yukawa coupling constants up to , for instance , the gut scale . in the mssm ,
the bottom yukawa coupling constant @xmath179 is proportional to @xmath178 , and hence , @xmath179 is enhanced when @xmath51 is negative ( see eq . ) . consequently , the bound on @xmath52 is more severe when @xmath180 . in our numerical analysis
, we estimate the bottom yukawa coupling constant using the following relation : in discussing the perturbative bound , we neglect holomorphic corrections to the yukawa coupling constant , which are orders - of - magnitude smaller than the tree - level value of the yukawa coupling constant for @xmath181 .
@xmath182 then , we follow the evolutions of coupling constants by solving the renormalization group equations at the one - loop level and impose a condition that the bottom yukawa coupling is perturbative up to the grand unified theory ( gut ) scale @xmath183 . numerically , we require @xmath184 where we take @xmath185 .
this constraint excludes a large @xmath52 region especially when @xmath186 .
notice that @xmath51 is a non - decoupling parameter , and hence , this constraint is important even in the limit of heavy superparticles .
in this section , we discuss the partial decay width of the lightest higgs boson @xmath10 .
we define the ratio of the partial decay width of the lightest higgs boson to that of the sm prediction : @xmath187 where @xmath188 denotes a specific final state . in the following ,
we show how much @xmath189 can deviate from the sm prediction ( @xmath190 ) for various final states .
as we have mentioned , feynhiggs 2.10.2 is used to calculate the partial decay widths of the higgs boson , in which full one - loop contributions are taken into account for the fermionic final states .
in the package , a resummation of the @xmath51 corrections is also included in calculating the partial decay width for @xmath191 @xcite . in our numerical calculation , we adopt ( approximate ) gut relation among the @xmath72 , @xmath43 , and @xmath73 gaugino masses : @xmath192 all the phases in the mssm parameters are assumed to be negligible , and we adopt the convention of @xmath193 . for simplicity , we also assume that the sfermion masses are universal with respect to the generation indices .
( left ) and @xmath194 ( right ) are shown as functions of @xmath195 ; here all the fermion masses , @xmath49 , and @xmath168 are equal to @xmath195 , and @xmath196 .
( the sign of @xmath29 is taken to be negative , while wino and bino masses are given by using the approximate gut relation . ) in the left ( right ) plot , the black , red , and blue lines correspond to @xmath197 ( @xmath198 ) , @xmath199 ( @xmath200 ) , and @xmath97 , respectively .
the solid ( dashed ) lines correspond to the pl ( ps ) solutions of @xmath28 .
note that the constraints in sec .
[ sec : constraint ] are not taken into account .
, title="fig : " ] ( left ) and @xmath194 ( right ) are shown as functions of @xmath195 ; here all the fermion masses , @xmath49 , and @xmath168 are equal to @xmath195 , and @xmath196 .
( the sign of @xmath29 is taken to be negative , while wino and bino masses are given by using the approximate gut relation . ) in the left ( right ) plot , the black , red , and blue lines correspond to @xmath197 ( @xmath198 ) , @xmath199 ( @xmath200 ) , and @xmath97 , respectively .
the solid ( dashed ) lines correspond to the pl ( ps ) solutions of @xmath28 .
note that the constraints in sec .
[ sec : constraint ] are not taken into account .
, title="fig : " ] first , we show the soft mass dependence of @xmath201 without taking the phenomenological constraints into account . in fig .
[ fig : msoft ] , @xmath201 are shown for @xmath202 , @xmath203 , @xmath92 , @xmath198 , and @xmath200 as functions of @xmath195 , taking @xmath204 and @xmath196 .
we have checked that @xmath205 holds in the parameter region of our study . by choosing negative @xmath29 with @xmath206 , the correction to
the bottom yukawa coupling becomes significant .
remarkably , even though @xmath195 is around several tev , the partial decay widths for @xmath207 , @xmath200 and @xmath92 deviate from the sm prediction by more than @xmath208% for the pl solution
. however , susy contributions to the other widths are smaller .
note that @xmath209 is as about twice as @xmath210 for the pl solution , which is due to the difference between @xmath51 and @xmath211 .
we also note here that the partial decay widths have an appropriate decoupling behaviour , i.e. , @xmath212 as the masses of superparticles and the heavy higgs bosons become infinitely large .
are shown for the ps , ns , pl , and nl solutions of @xmath28 . here , all the sfermion masses , @xmath49 , and @xmath168 are taken to be @xmath77 , and the sign of @xmath29 is set to be negative .
the left regions of the blue lines are excluded by @xmath213 , while those of the green solid ( dashed ) lines are constrained by the vacuum stability condition , @xmath214 ( 360 ) .
the bottom yukawa coupling becomes non - perturbative below the gut scale in the region above the red line.,title="fig : " ] are shown for the ps , ns , pl , and nl solutions of @xmath28 . here
, all the sfermion masses , @xmath49 , and @xmath168 are taken to be @xmath77 , and the sign of @xmath29 is set to be negative .
the left regions of the blue lines are excluded by @xmath213 , while those of the green solid ( dashed ) lines are constrained by the vacuum stability condition , @xmath214 ( 360 ) .
the bottom yukawa coupling becomes non - perturbative below the gut scale in the region above the red line.,title="fig : " ] + are shown for the ps , ns , pl , and nl solutions of @xmath28 . here
, all the sfermion masses , @xmath49 , and @xmath168 are taken to be @xmath77 , and the sign of @xmath29 is set to be negative .
the left regions of the blue lines are excluded by @xmath213 , while those of the green solid ( dashed ) lines are constrained by the vacuum stability condition , @xmath214 ( 360 ) .
the bottom yukawa coupling becomes non - perturbative below the gut scale in the region above the red line.,title="fig : " ] are shown for the ps , ns , pl , and nl solutions of @xmath28 . here
, all the sfermion masses , @xmath49 , and @xmath168 are taken to be @xmath77 , and the sign of @xmath29 is set to be negative .
the left regions of the blue lines are excluded by @xmath213 , while those of the green solid ( dashed ) lines are constrained by the vacuum stability condition , @xmath214 ( 360 ) .
the bottom yukawa coupling becomes non - perturbative below the gut scale in the region above the red line.,title="fig : " ] next , let us include the phenomenological constraints discussed in sec .
[ sec : constraint ] . in fig .
[ fig : matanb ] , contours of @xmath209 are shown on @xmath17 vs. @xmath52 plane . here ,
all the sfermion masses , @xmath49 , and @xmath168 are set to be @xmath77 . in the cases of the ps and pl solutions , the contours end at around @xmath215 .
this is because , when @xmath52 is large , there is no solution for @xmath28 to satisfy @xmath32 .
the bottom - sbottom loop contribution interferes destructively with the top - stop contribution , and thus , larger ( smaller ) @xmath28 is required for the ps ( pl ) solution .
then , @xmath216 and @xmath217 merge into a single solution at certain @xmath52 , which is the value where the top - stop contributions can not raise the higgs mass anymore for fixed @xmath195 .
note that , @xmath51 is negative when @xmath218 and @xmath219 .
in such a case , @xmath179 is significantly larger than the tree - level value , and thus , the bottom - sbottom loop contributions are enhanced . in fig .
[ fig : matanb ] , the constraints from @xmath220 , the vacuum stability , and the perturbativity of the bottom yukawa couplings are shown .
wide parameter region is excluded when @xmath28 is large , i.e. , in the pl and nl panels .
the constraints from @xmath141 and the vacuum stability become weaker for large @xmath17 , while that from the perturbativity is not . for the pl solution , the constraints from @xmath141 and the vacuum stability change drastically as we vary @xmath52 for @xmath221 , where the bottom yukawa coupling is much larger than the tree - level value .
.expected accuracies of the determinations of the partial decay widths of the higgs boson in units of percents @xcite .
the accuracies of the widths are assumed to be twice the accuracies of the determinations of couplings . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ]
even if the masses of superparticles are relatively large ( i.e. , @xmath77 ) , @xmath209 can be as large as @xmath208% .
such a large deviation may be within the reach of future collider experiments .
expected accuracies at the future experiments have been discussed ( see table 1 - 16 of ref .
@xcite and ref .
@xcite ) ; the numbers are summarized in table [ table : experiments ] .
the accuracies of @xmath222 , @xmath223 , and @xmath224 are claimed to be achievable at @xmath1 colliders ultimately .
therefore , it is found that , even if the superparticles are kinematically unaccessible at the lhc , we may observe the mssm signal by studying the partial decay widths of @xmath10 in detail . for the pl solution , it is also found that the partial width of @xmath191 can deviate from the sm prediction by about 2% even for @xmath225 . on the other hand
, we checked that @xmath226 is smaller by about 1% than @xmath227 at the same parameter point , because the non - holomorphic correction @xmath228 is bigger than @xmath229 at this model point .
when @xmath52 is smaller , the difference between @xmath227 and @xmath226 decreases , since @xmath51 is approximately proportional to @xmath52 ; in such a case both @xmath227 and @xmath226 are well approximated by @xmath230 .
( blue ) and @xmath226 ( red ) with small @xmath33 solutions ( i.e , the ps and ns solutions for @xmath28 ) .
we take @xmath231 , 3 , 4 and @xmath77 .
other sfermion masses are set to be @xmath232 .
the partial widths are constrained by @xmath233 , the vacuum stability condition ( @xmath214 ) , and the perturbativity of the bottom yukawa coupling ( @xmath234 ) .
the black region corresponds to the tree - level prediction for @xmath235@xmath236 .
the black dashed line is the sm prediction .
, title="fig : " ] ( blue ) and @xmath226 ( red ) with small @xmath33 solutions ( i.e , the ps and ns solutions for @xmath28 ) .
we take @xmath231 , 3 , 4 and @xmath77 .
other sfermion masses are set to be @xmath232 .
the partial widths are constrained by @xmath233 , the vacuum stability condition ( @xmath214 ) , and the perturbativity of the bottom yukawa coupling ( @xmath234 ) .
the black region corresponds to the tree - level prediction for @xmath235@xmath236 .
the black dashed line is the sm prediction .
, title="fig : " ] + ( blue ) and @xmath226 ( red ) with small @xmath33 solutions ( i.e , the ps and ns solutions for @xmath28 ) .
we take @xmath231 , 3 , 4 and @xmath77 .
other sfermion masses are set to be @xmath232 .
the partial widths are constrained by @xmath233 , the vacuum stability condition ( @xmath214 ) , and the perturbativity of the bottom yukawa coupling ( @xmath234 ) .
the black region corresponds to the tree - level prediction for @xmath235@xmath236 .
the black dashed line is the sm prediction .
, title="fig : " ] ( blue ) and @xmath226 ( red ) with small @xmath33 solutions ( i.e , the ps and ns solutions for @xmath28 ) .
we take @xmath231 , 3 , 4 and @xmath77 .
other sfermion masses are set to be @xmath232 .
the partial widths are constrained by @xmath233 , the vacuum stability condition ( @xmath214 ) , and the perturbativity of the bottom yukawa coupling ( @xmath234 ) .
the black region corresponds to the tree - level prediction for @xmath235@xmath236 .
the black dashed line is the sm prediction .
, title="fig : " ] , but with all the solutions of @xmath28.,title="fig : " ] , but with all the solutions of @xmath28.,title="fig : " ] + , but with all the solutions of @xmath28.,title="fig : " ] , but with all the solutions of @xmath28.,title="fig : " ] let us see how much @xmath227 and @xmath226 can change in the parameter space consistent with the phenomenological constraints .
we have performed the scan in the following parameter space of the mssm : * @xmath231 , @xmath237 , @xmath238 , and @xmath77 , * @xmath170 , * @xmath239 , @xmath240 , @xmath216 , @xmath217 , * @xmath241 , * @xmath242 , or @xmath243 , * @xmath244 . here , @xmath28 is determined to satisfy @xmath245 .
the other tri - linear couplings ( e.g. , @xmath177 and @xmath246 ) are assumed to be equal to @xmath28 ; we checked that our numerical results are insensitive to this assumption .
we take @xmath247 , while sfermion masses other than @xmath61 and @xmath62 are set to be equal to @xmath248 .
we have checked that @xmath227 and @xmath226 are almost insensitive to these scalar masses unless they are very small . however , when @xmath168 is much larger than @xmath63 , @xmath64 , and @xmath65 , bottom and stau mixings become sizable which causes additional complexity to our parameter scan , and/or lighter stau become tachyonic .
the values of @xmath63 , @xmath64 , and @xmath65 are chosen to avoid this problem .
if @xmath168 would become much larger than squark masses ( e.g. , @xmath249 ) , the higgs partial widths could deviate from the sm prediction sizably , since the higgs mixing angle would be enhanced by radiative corrections .
however , the vacuum stability condition excludes significant amount of the parameter region with large @xmath168 , as we have shown in fig .
[ fig : se ] . in our scan , we set @xmath250 ; this upper bound is large enough to cover the whole region allowed by the vacuum stability . in figs .
[ fig : rbbtaus ] and [ fig : rbbtau ] , we show the minimal and maximal values of @xmath227 and @xmath226 as functions of @xmath17 and @xmath195 , taking into account the phenomenological constraints discussed in the previous section . fig .
[ fig : rbbtaus ] corresponds to the small @xmath28 solutions ( ns and ps ) .
the largest and smallest values of @xmath227 and @xmath226 are achieved when @xmath168 and @xmath52 are large and are marginally allowed by the phenomenological constraints .
the deviations mainly come from radiative corrections to the higgs mixing angle and @xmath51 .
in particular , the maximal value of @xmath227 is larger than that of @xmath226 for large @xmath251 . as discussed earlier
, @xmath51 becomes negative and sizable with @xmath252 , which results in a significant enhancement of @xmath227 .
[ fig : rbbtau ] shows the minimal and maximal values of @xmath227 and @xmath226 , taking all the solutions of ns , ps , nl , and pl into consideration .
they change significantly compared to fig .
[ fig : rbbtaus ] .
the partial widths become extremum when @xmath28 takes the nl or pl solution except the maximal value for small @xmath17 . for @xmath253 ,
the ns or ps solutions give the maximal value , since the phenomenological constraints , especially the vacuum stability condition , are too severe for the nl and pl solutions ( see fig .
[ fig : matanb ] ) . as in the case of fig .
[ fig : rbbtaus ] , the maximal value of @xmath227 is much larger than that of @xmath226 because @xmath254 .
the maximal value of @xmath227 has a non - trivial bump - like structure . when @xmath17 is small , medium ( i.e. , around the peak of the bump ) , and large , the partial decay width is bounded by the vacuum stability , flavor constraint , and the perturbativity of @xmath179 , respectively .
the measurement of the higgs couplings may provide an evidence of bsm , because the values of @xmath227 and @xmath226 may show significant deviation from the sm prediction . in future experiments
, the partial decay widths of @xmath255 and @xmath256 may be measured at the @xmath257 level ( see table [ table : experiments ] ) . in the case of the ps and ns solutions , @xmath209 can be as large as 2% ( 3% ) if @xmath17 is @xmath258 ( @xmath259 ) for @xmath260 , and @xmath261 ( @xmath262 ) for @xmath263 .
on the other hand , @xmath210 becomes larger than 2% ( 3% ) when @xmath17 is smaller than @xmath264 ( @xmath265 ) for @xmath260 , and @xmath262 ( @xmath266 ) for @xmath263 . including the pl and nl solutions , deviations of @xmath267
@xmath237% level are achieved with larger value of @xmath17 .
for example , with @xmath263 , @xmath268 can be achieved with @xmath269 .
( left ) and @xmath270 ( right ) are shown as functions of @xmath62 .
the parameters are scanned in the same manner as fig .
[ fig : rbbtau ] , but @xmath17 is fixed to be @xmath77 while @xmath62 is varied . here , all the solutions of @xmath28 are included in the scan with imposing the phenomenological constraints discussed in sec .
[ sec : constraint ] .
the black dashed line is the sm prediction.,title="fig : " ] ( left ) and @xmath270 ( right ) are shown as functions of @xmath62 .
the parameters are scanned in the same manner as fig .
[ fig : rbbtau ] , but @xmath17 is fixed to be @xmath77 while @xmath62 is varied . here , all the solutions of @xmath28 are included in the scan with imposing the phenomenological constraints discussed in sec .
[ sec : constraint ] .
the black dashed line is the sm prediction.,title="fig : " ] in fig .
[ fig : msoft2 ] , we show the sfermion mass dependence of @xmath201 with taking the phenomenological constraints into account .
the parameter scan is performed in the same setup as fig .
[ fig : rbbtau ] , but @xmath62 is varied . here
, @xmath17 is fixed to be @xmath77 . in the left plot ,
the minimal and maximal values of @xmath227 and @xmath226 are shown .
they are achieved by the pl or nl solution . since @xmath17 is fixed , the decoupling behaviour is not observed .
rather , the non - decoupling contribution to @xmath51 enhances @xmath227 as @xmath62 increases , since larger @xmath33 is required to satisfy @xmath245 for the solutions . on the other hand
, it is found that radiative corrections to the higgs mixing angle do not change so much even if @xmath62 increases . in the right panel of fig .
[ fig : msoft2 ] , the minimal and maximal values of @xmath270 are displayed .
the maximal value occurs for the ps or ns solution , while the minimal value is achieved by the pl or nl solution .
we can see the decoupling behavior , i.e. , @xmath270 approaches to unity as @xmath62 increases .
the partial decay width of @xmath97 can deviate from the sm prediction by about 3% for @xmath271 , while it decreases rapidly and becomes 1% for @xmath272 .
we have also checked that these values do not change so much for @xmath273 .
( however , they change significantly if @xmath17 is smaller , since the phenomenological constraints exclude the parameter space severely . )
according to table [ table : experiments ] , the partial width of @xmath97 is expected to be measured at the @xmath274 accuracy in future experiments .
thus , as far as superparticles are relatively light , we may observe a signal of the mssm in the measurements of this partial width even if the heavier higgses are out of the reach of the lhc . as a function of @xmath17 ( green histogram ) , as well as that of model points allowed by the phenomenological constraints ( dotted histogram ) .
upper - right : the number of model points allowed by the phenomenological constraints on @xmath17 vs. @xmath52 plane .
lower - left : the number of model points accessible with ilc by @xmath275 .
lower - right : the number of model points accessible with ilc by @xmath276 .
, title="fig : " ] as a function of @xmath17 ( green histogram ) , as well as that of model points allowed by the phenomenological constraints ( dotted histogram ) .
upper - right : the number of model points allowed by the phenomenological constraints on @xmath17 vs. @xmath52 plane .
lower - left : the number of model points accessible with ilc by @xmath275 .
lower - right : the number of model points accessible with ilc by @xmath276 .
, title="fig : " ] + as a function of @xmath17 ( green histogram ) , as well as that of model points allowed by the phenomenological constraints ( dotted histogram ) .
upper - right : the number of model points allowed by the phenomenological constraints on @xmath17 vs. @xmath52 plane .
lower - left : the number of model points accessible with ilc by @xmath275 .
lower - right : the number of model points accessible with ilc by @xmath276 .
, title="fig : " ] as a function of @xmath17 ( green histogram ) , as well as that of model points allowed by the phenomenological constraints ( dotted histogram ) .
upper - right : the number of model points allowed by the phenomenological constraints on @xmath17 vs. @xmath52 plane .
lower - left : the number of model points accessible with ilc by @xmath275 .
lower - right : the number of model points accessible with ilc by @xmath276 .
, title="fig : " ] finally , we show how large fraction of the parameter space can be covered by future @xmath1 colliders . for this purpose
, we define the @xmath277 variable as @xmath278 ^ 2 } { [ \delta\gamma(h\rightarrow f)]^2},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath279 is the expected accuracies of the determinations of the higgs partial decay widths at ilc with @xmath280 and @xmath281 ( see table [ table : experiments ] ) .
based on this quantity , we define the parameter region which is accessible with ilc at @xmath282 .
we perform a parameter scan and study if each model point is accessible with ilc and satisfies the phenomenological constraints .
the mssm parameters are scanned in the ranges of @xmath283 ( with the step size of @xmath284 ) , @xmath285 ( with the step size of @xmath286 ) , and @xmath287 ( with the step size of @xmath288 ) .
thus , for each set of @xmath289 , 384 model points are studied , taking account of positive and negative values of @xmath29 as well as all four solutions of @xmath28 .
in addition , we adopt the relations @xmath290 , and @xmath291 .
concentrating on the parameter space where the lhc will have a difficulty in finding superparticles , @xmath62 is taken to be @xmath237 , @xmath238 , and @xmath77 . in fig .
[ fig : scan ] , the ilc coverage of the parameter space of our scan is displayed . in the upper - left panel ,
we show the distribution of the number of model points accessible with ilc by any of the decay modes of @xmath10 as a function of @xmath17 .
the green histogram is a distribution of the number of model points which satisfy @xmath292 and the phenomenological constraints , while the dotted one is that satisfying the phenomenological constraints without imposing @xmath293 .
we find that the number reduces drastically at @xmath294 . in the upper - right panel
, we show the number of model points which survive the phenomenological constraints on @xmath17 vs. @xmath52 plane . here
, @xmath282 is not imposed .
then , in the lower panels , we show the numbers of model points which can be accessed by the decay modes of @xmath275 ( lower - left ) and @xmath276 ( lower - right ) with taking account of the phenomenological constraints .
they reduce significantly for @xmath295 irrespective of @xmath52 .
the accessible points for @xmath295 are mostly with pl or nl solution .
in this paper , we have studied the partial decay widths of the lightest higgs boson in the mssm . taking account of relevant phenomenological constraints , i.e. , higgs mass , flavor constraints , vacuum stability , and the perturbativity of coupling constants up to the gut scale
, we have calculated the expected deviations of the partial decay widths from the sm predictions .
the partial decay widths are enhanced if the @xmath29-parameter is relatively large .
however , such a choice may conflict with some of the phenomenological constraints . in particular , the vacuum - stability condition imposes a stringent constraint on the parameter space .
we have found that , with too large @xmath168 , there show up ccb vacua where the down - type higgs field as well as the up - type higgs and stop fields acquire large vevs ; existence of such ccb vacua was not seriously considered in the previous studies .
in addition , when @xmath296 is large , non - holomorphic correction to the bottom yukawa interaction becomes so large that the bottom yukawa coupling constant becomes non - perturbative below the gut scale .
large value of @xmath296 may also cause too large flavor - violating decay of @xmath11-mesons . by taking these constraints into account ,
the maximal and minimal possible values of the higgs partial widths are restricted .
we found that the deviations of the partial decay widths from the sm predictions can be of @xmath208% for some of the decay modes .
in particular , those of @xmath87 and @xmath88 may show significant deviations even if the superparticles are out of the reach of 14tev lhc .
in addition , the deviation of @xmath96 may also be sizable if the superparticles are relatively light .
we emphasize that , although our scan is limited to some part of the mssm parameter space , we have found the regions where the deviations from the sm predictions are within the reach of proposed @xmath1 colliders even if superparticles would not be observed at the lhc .
_ acknowledgements _ : the authors would like to thank yasuhiro shimizu for the collaboration in the early stage of this project .
the authors also acknowledge yitp for their hospitality , at which this work was initiated .
this work is supported by jsps kakenhi no .
23740172 ( m.e . ) , no .
26400239 ( t.m . ) , and no .
26287039 ( m.m.n . ) .
the work is supported by grant - in - aid for scientific research from the ministry of education , science , sports , and culture ( mext ) , japan , no .
23104008 ( t.m . ) and no .
23104006 ( m.m.n . ) , and also by world premier international research center initiative ( wpi initiative ) , mext , japan .
g. aad _ et al . _ [ atlas collaboration ] , phys .
b * 716 * ( 2012 ) 1 [ arxiv:1207.7214 [ hep - ex ] ] .
s. chatrchyan _ et al . _
[ cms collaboration ] , phys .
b * 716 * ( 2012 ) 30 [ arxiv:1207.7235 [ hep - ex ] ] .
s. dawson , a. gritsan , h. logan , j. qian , c. tully , r. van kooten , a. ajaib and a. anastassov _ et al .
_ , arxiv:1310.8361 [ hep - ex ] . y. okada , m. yamaguchi and t. yanagida , prog . theor . phys . * 85 * ( 1991 ) 1 .
y. okada , m. yamaguchi and t. yanagida , phys .
b * 262 * , 54 ( 1991 ) .
j. r. ellis , g. ridolfi and f. zwirner , phys .
b * 257 * ( 1991 ) 83 .
j. r. ellis , g. ridolfi and f. zwirner , phys .
b * 262 * , 477 ( 1991 ) .
h. e. haber and r. hempfling , phys .
* 66 * ( 1991 ) 1815 .
z. skands , b. c. allanach , h. baer , c. balazs , g. belanger , f. boudjema , a. djouadi and r. godbole _ et al .
_ , jhep * 0407 * ( 2004 ) 036 [ hep - ph/0311123 ]
. k. a. olive et al .
( particle data group ) , chin .
c , * 38 * , 090001 ( 2014 ) .
s. heinemeyer , w. hollik and g. weiglein , comput .
commun .
* 124 * , 76 ( 2000 ) [ hep - ph/9812320 ] .
s. heinemeyer , w. hollik and g. weiglein , eur .
j. c * 9 * , 343 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ph/9812472 ] .
g. degrassi , s. heinemeyer , w. hollik , p. slavich and g. weiglein , eur .
j. c * 28 * , 133 ( 2003 ) [ hep - ph/0212020 ] .
m. frank , t. hahn , s. heinemeyer , w. hollik , h. rzehak and g. weiglein , jhep * 0702 * , 047 ( 2007 ) [ hep - ph/0611326 ] .
t. hahn , s. heinemeyer , w. hollik , h. rzehak and g. weiglein , phys .
* 112 * ( 2014 ) 14 , 141801 [ arxiv:1312.4937 [ hep - ph ] ] . l. j. hall , r. rattazzi and u. sarid , phys
. rev .
d * 50 * , 7048 ( 1994 ) [ hep - ph/9306309 , hep - ph/9306309 ] .
r. hempfling , phys .
d * 49 * , 6168 ( 1994 ) .
m. s. carena , m. olechowski , s. pokorski and c. e. m. wagner , nucl .
b * 426 * , 269 ( 1994 ) [ hep - ph/9402253 ] .
m. s. carena , s. mrenna and c. e. m. wagner , phys .
d * 60 * , 075010 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ph/9808312 ] .
h. eberl , k. hidaka , s. kraml , w. majerotto and y. yamada , phys . rev .
d * 62 * , 055006 ( 2000 ) [ hep - ph/9912463 ] .
m. s. carena , d. garcia , u. nierste and c. e. m. wagner , nucl .
b * 577 * , 88 ( 2000 ) [ hep - ph/9912516 ] .
l. hofer , u. nierste and d. scherer , jhep * 0910 * , 081 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0907.5408 [ hep - ph ] ] .
d. noth and m. spira , phys . rev .
* 101 * , 181801 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0808.0087 [ hep - ph ] ] .
m. s. carena , h. e. haber , h. e. logan and s. mrenna , phys .
d * 65 * ( 2002 ) 055005 [ erratum - ibid .
d * 65 * ( 2002 ) 099902 ] [ hep - ph/0106116 ] .
a. arvanitaki and g. villadoro , jhep * 1202 * , 144 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1112.4835 [ hep - ph ] ] .
m. reece , new j. phys . *
15 * , 043003 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1208.1765 [ hep - ph ] ] .
e. bagnaschi , r. v. harlander , s. liebler , h. mantler , p. slavich and a. vicini , jhep * 1406 * , 167 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1404.0327 [ hep - ph ] ] .
s. heinemeyer , w. hollik and g. weiglein , eur .
j. c * 16 * ( 2000 ) 139 [ hep - ph/0003022 ] .
m. cahill - rowley , j. hewett , a. ismail and t. rizzo , phys .
d * 90 * ( 2014 ) 9 , 095017 [ arxiv:1407.7021 [ hep - ph ] ] .
k. s. babu and c. f. kolda , phys .
* 84 * , 228 ( 2000 ) [ hep - ph/9909476 ] .
s. r. choudhury and n. gaur , phys .
b * 451 * , 86 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ph/9810307 ] .
g. buchalla and a. j. buras , nucl .
b * 400 * , 225 ( 1993 ) .
m. misiak and j. urban , phys .
b * 451 * , 161 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ph/9901278 ] . c. bobeth , t. ewerth , f. kruger and j. urban , phys .
d * 64 * , 074014 ( 2001 ) [ hep - ph/0104284 ] . c. bobeth , a. j. buras , f. kruger and j. urban , nucl .
b * 630 * , 87 ( 2002 ) [ hep - ph/0112305 ] . c. bobeth , m. gorbahn , t. hermann , m. misiak , e. stamou and m. steinhauser , phys .
* 112 * ( 2014 ) 101801 [ arxiv:1311.0903 [ hep - ph ] ] .
v. khachatryan _ et al . _
[ cms and lhcb collaborations ] , arxiv:1411.4413 [ hep - ex ] .
y. amhis _ et al .
_ [ heavy flavor averaging group ( hfag ) collaboration ] , arxiv:1412.7515 [ hep - ex ] .
m. misiak , h. m. asatrian , k. bieri , m. czakon , a. czarnecki , t. ewerth , a. ferroglia and p. gambino _ et al .
_ , phys .
lett . * 98 * , 022002 ( 2007 ) [ hep - ph/0609232 ] .
f. mahmoudi , comput .
commun .
* 180 * ( 2009 ) 1579 [ arxiv:0808.3144 [ hep - ph ] ] .
w. altmannshofer , m. carena , n. r. shah and f. yu , jhep * 1301 * ( 2013 ) 160 [ arxiv:1211.1976 [ hep - ph ] ] . j. m. frere , d. r. t. jones and s. raby , nucl . phys .
b * 222 * , 11 ( 1983 ) .
j. f. gunion , h. e. haber and m. sher , nucl .
b * 306 * , 1 ( 1988 ) .
j. a. casas , a. lleyda and c. munoz , nucl . phys .
b * 471 * , 3 ( 1996 ) [ hep - ph/9507294 ] .
a. kusenko , p. langacker and g. segre , phys .
d * 54 * , 5824 ( 1996 ) [ hep - ph/9602414 ] .
j. e. camargo - molina , b. oleary , w. porod and f. staub , jhep * 1312 * , 103 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1309.7212 [ hep - ph ] ] .
d. chowdhury , r. m. godbole , k. a. mohan and s. k. vempati , jhep * 1402 * , 110 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1310.1932 [ hep - ph ] ] . n. blinov and d. e. morrissey , jhep * 1403 * , 106 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1310.4174 [ hep - ph ] ] . j. e. camargo - molina , b. garbrecht , b. oleary , w. porod and f. staub , phys .
b * 737 * , 156 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1405.7376 [ hep - ph ] ] .
s. r. coleman , phys .
d * 15 * ( 1977 ) 2929 [ erratum - ibid .
d * 16 * ( 1977 ) 1248 ] . c. g. callan , jr . and s. r. coleman , phys .
d * 16 * ( 1977 ) 1762 . c. l. wainwright , comput .
commun .
* 183 * ( 2012 ) 2006 [ arxiv:1109.4189 [ hep - ph ] ] .
k. e. williams , h. rzehak and g. weiglein , eur .
j. c * 71 * , 1669 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1103.1335 [ hep - ph ] ] .
m. e. peskin , arxiv:1312.4974 [ hep - ph ] . | motivated by future collider proposals that aim to measure the higgs properties precisely , we study the partial decay widths of the lightest higgs boson in the minimal supersymmetric standard model with an emphasis on the parameter region where all superparticles and heavy higgs bosons are not accessible at the lhc . taking account of phenomenological constraints such as the higgs mass , flavor constraints , vacuum stability , and perturbativity of coupling constants up to the grand unification scale ,
we discuss how large the deviations of the partial decay widths from the standard model predictions can be .
these constraints exclude large fraction of the parameter region where the higgs widths show significant deviation from the standard model predictions
. nevertheless , even if superparticles and the heavy higgses are out of the reach of @xmath0 lhc , the deviation may be large enough to be observed at future @xmath1 collider experiments .
ut-15 - 02 + ipmu-15 - 0018 + kek - th-1795 + february , 2015 + .75 in * footprints of supersymmetry on higgs decay * .75 in motoi endo@xmath2 , takeo moroi@xmath2 , and mihoko m. nojiri@xmath3 0.25 in @xmath4 _ department of physics , university of tokyo , tokyo 113 - 0033 , japan _ 0.1 in @xmath5 _ kavli ipmu ( wpi ) , university of tokyo , kashiwa , chiba 277 - 8583 , japan _ 0.1 in @xmath6
_ kek theory center , ipns , kek , tsukuba , ibaraki 305 - 0801 , japan _ 0.1 in @xmath7 _ the graduate university of advanced studies ( sokendai ) , + tsukuba , ibaraki 305 - 0801 , japan
_ .5 in |
the authors of ref . @xcite investigated the effects of the variation of the mass parameter @xmath1 on the thick branes .
they used a real scalar field , which has a potential of the @xmath4 model , as the background field of the thick branes .
it was found that the number of the bound states ( in the case without gravity ) or the resonant states ( in the case with gravity ) increases with the parameter @xmath1 .
that work considered the simplest yukawa coupling @xmath2 , where @xmath3 is the coupling constant .
the authors stated that as the value of @xmath1 is increasing , the maximum of the matter energy density splits into two new maxima , and the distance of the new maxima increases and the brane gets thicker .
the authors also stated that the brane with a big value of @xmath1 would trap fermions more efficiently . in this paper , we reinvestigated the effect of the variation of the mass parameter @xmath1 on the thick branes , because the above investigation does not analyze the zero mode in details and contains some misconceptions .
we only focus attention in the case with gravity .
we find that the variation of @xmath1 on the thick brane is associated to the phenomenon of brane splitting . from the static equation of motion
, we analyze the asymptotic behavior of @xmath5 and find that the zero mode for left - handed fermions can be localized on the brane depending on the value for the coupling constant @xmath3 and the mass parameter @xmath1 .
we also show that as the value of @xmath1 is increasing the simplest yukawa coupling does not support the localization of fermions on the brane , as incompletely argued in ref . @xcite .
the action for our system is described by @xcite @xmath6,\ ] ] where @xmath7 , @xmath8 is the 5d bulk cosmological constant and the scalar potential @xmath9 is given by @xcite @xmath10 where @xmath11 .
there are three minima for @xmath9 , one is at @xmath12 ( local minima ) corresponding to a disordered bulk phase and the other two are at @xmath13 ( global minima ) with @xmath14 they are degenerated and correspond to ordered bulk phases . as @xmath15 ( @xmath16 ) , @xmath17 , @xmath9 has three degenerated global minima . for the case with gravity ,
the critical value of @xmath1 is not @xmath18 but a smaller effective critical value @xmath19 . in this case , @xmath20 @xcite .
the line element in this model is considered as @xmath21 where @xmath22 , @xmath23 , and @xmath24 is the so - called warp factor .
we suppose that @xmath25 and @xmath26 . for this model ,
the equations of motion are @xmath27 @xmath28 @xmath29 it is possible to rewrite ( [ em2b ] ) and ( [ em3b ] ) as @xmath30 the boundary conditions can be read as follows @xmath31 @xmath32 the matter energy density has the form @xmath33.\ ] ] at this point , it is also instructive to analyze the matter energy of the toy model @xmath34 substituting ( [ de ] ) in ( [ ephi ] ) , we get @xmath35\,,\ ] ] using ( [ em3b ] ) and ( [ em3c ] ) , we obtain the value of the matter energy given by @xmath36-\lambda\int^{\infty}_{-\infty}dy% \mathrm{e}^{2a(y)}.\ ] ] as @xmath37 , the value of the matter energy depends on the asymptotic behavior of the warp factor . if @xmath38 then @xmath39 and by the analysis to eq .
( [ em2b ] ) , we can see that @xmath40 .
therefore , @xmath41 and the value of the matter energy is zero .
this fact is the same to the case of branes with generalized dynamics @xcite .
the scalar curvature ( or ricci scalar ) is given by @xmath42 the profiles of the matter energy density is shown in fig .
( [ fde ] ) for some values of @xmath1 .
figure ( [ fde ] ) clearly shows that for @xmath43 the matter energy density has not a single - peak around @xmath44 .
the core of the brane is localized at @xmath44 for @xmath43 , because this region has a positive matter energy density . on the other hand , as the value of @xmath1 is increasing , we can see that the single brane splits into two sub - branes and as @xmath45 each sub - brane is a thick brane .
this phenomenon is so - called of brane splitting @xcite . from the peak of the matter energy density
is evident know where the core of the branes are located .
therefore , the brane does not get thicker with the increases of the value of the mass parameter @xmath1 , as argued in ref .
the profiles of the matter energy density and the ricci scalar are shown in fig .
( [ desc ] ) for @xmath46 .
note that the presence of regions with positive ricci scalar is connected to the capability to trap matter near to the core of the brane @xcite and it reinforces the conclusion of the analyzes from the matter energy density .
also note that far from the brane , @xmath47 tends to a negative constant , characterizing the @xmath48 limit from the bulk . , @xmath49 , @xmath43 ( thin line ) , @xmath46 ( dashed line ) and @xmath50 ( dotted line).,width=264 ] , @xmath49 and @xmath46.,width=264 ] the action for a dirac spinor field coupled with the scalar fields by a general yukawa coupling is @xmath51\,,\ ] ] where @xmath3 is the positive coupling constant between fermions and the scalar field .
moreover , we are considering the covariant derivative @xmath52 , where @xmath53 and @xmath54 , denote the local lorentz indices and @xmath55 is the spin connection . here
we consider the field @xmath56 as a background field .
the equation of motion is obtained as @xmath57 at this stage , it is useful to consider the fermionic current .
the conservation law for @xmath58 follows from the standard procedure and it becomes @xmath59 where @xmath60 .
thus , if @xmath61 then four - current will be conserved .
the condition ( [ cj0 ] ) is the purely geometrical assertion that the curved - space gamma matrices are covariantly constant . using the same line element ( [ metric ] ) and the representation for gamma matrices @xmath62
, the condition ( [ cj0 ] ) is trivially satisfied and therefore the current is conserved .
the equation of motion ( [ dkp ] ) becomes @xmath63\psi=0.\ ] ] now , we use the general chiral decomposition @xmath64 with @xmath65 and @xmath66 . with
this decomposition @xmath67 and @xmath68 are the left - handed and right - handed components of the four - dimensional spinor field , respectively . after applying ( [ dchiral ] ) in ( [ em ] ) , and demanding that @xmath69 and @xmath70
, we obtain two equations for @xmath71 and @xmath72 @xmath73\alpha_{l_{n}}=m_{n}\mathrm{e}^{-a}\alpha_{r_{n}}\,,\ ] ] @xmath74\alpha_{r_{n}}=-m_{n}\mathrm{e}^{-a}\alpha_{l_{n}}\,.\ ] ] inserting the general chiral decomposition ( [ dchiral ] ) into the action ( [ ad ] ) , using ( [ ea1 ] ) and ( [ ea2 ] ) and also requiring that the result take the form of the standard four - dimensional action for the massive chiral fermions @xmath75 where @xmath76 and @xmath77 , the functions @xmath71 and @xmath72 must obey the following orthonormality conditions @xmath78 implementing the change of variables @xmath79 @xmath80 and @xmath81 , we get @xmath82 @xmath83 where @xmath84 using the expressions @xmath85 and @xmath86 , we can recast the potentials ( [ vefa ] ) and ( [ vefb ] ) as a function of @xmath87 @xcite-@xcite @xmath88,\label{vya } \\
v_{r}(z(y ) ) & = & v_{l}(z(y))|_{\eta\rightarrow-\eta}\,.\label{vyb}\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is worthwhile to note that we can construct the schrdinger potentials @xmath89 and @xmath90 from eqs .
( [ vya ] ) and ( [ vyb ] ) . at this stage , it is instructive to state that with the change of variable ( [ cv ] ) we get a geometry to be conformally flat @xmath91 now we focus attention on the condition ( [ cj0 ] ) for the line element ( [ cm ] ) . in this case
we obtain @xmath92 therefore , the current is no longer conserved for the line element ( [ cm ] ) @xcite .
it is known that , in general , the reformulation of the theory in a new conformal frame leads to a different , physically inequivalent theory .
this issue has already a precedent in cosmological models @xcite . under this arguments ,
we only use the change of variable ( [ cv ] ) to have a qualitative analysis of the potential profiles ( [ vya ] ) and ( [ vyb ] ) , which is a fundamental ingredient for the fermion localization on the brane . now we focus attention on the calculation of the zero mode . substituting @xmath93 in ( [ ea1 ] ) and ( [ ea2 ] ) and using @xmath80 and @xmath81 , respectively ,
we get @xmath94,\ ] ] @xmath95.\ ] ] this fact is the same to the case of two - dimensional dirac equation @xcite . at this point
is worthwhile to mention that the normalization of the zero mode and the existence of a minimum for the effective potential at the localization on the brane are essential conditions for the problem of fermion localization on the brane .
this fact was already reported in @xcite . in order to guarantee the normalization condition ( [ orto ] ) for the left - handed fermion zero mode ( [ mzl ] )
, the integral must be convergent , _
i.e _ @xmath96<\infty.\ ] ] this result clearly shows that the normalization of the zero mode is decided by the asymptotic behavior of @xmath97 .
furthermore , from ( [ vya ] ) and ( [ vyb ] ) , it can be observed that the effective potential profile depends on the @xmath97 choice .
this fact implies that the existence of a minimum for the effective potential @xmath98 or @xmath99 at the localization on the brane is decided by @xmath97 .
this point will be more clear when it is considered a specific yukawa coupling .
therefore , the behavior of @xmath97 plays a leading role for the fermion localization on the brane @xcite .
having set up the two essential conditions for the problem of fermion localization on the brane , we are now in a position to choice some specific forms for yukawa couplings . from now on
, we mainly consider the simplest case @xmath100 .
first , we consider the normalizable problem of the solution . in this case
, we only need to consider the asymptotic behavior of the integrand in ( [ cono ] ) .
it becomes @xmath101\,.\ ] ] by the analysis from eq .
( [ em2b ] ) , we obtain that @xmath102 . for the integral @xmath103
, we only need to consider the asymptotic behavior of @xmath56 for @xmath38 @xcite and as @xmath104 the equation ( [ in ] ) becomes @xmath105\,.\ ] ] this result clearly shows that the zero mode of the left - handed fermions is normalized only for @xmath106 .
now , under the change @xmath107 ( @xmath108 ) we obtain that the right - handed fermions can not be a normalizable zero mode .
the shape of the potentials @xmath89 and @xmath90 are shown in fig .
( [ pe ] ) for some values of @xmath1 .
figure [ pe](a ) shows that the effective potential @xmath89 , is indeed a volcano - like potential for @xmath43 .
as @xmath1 increases the well structure of @xmath89 gets a double well .
figure [ pe](b ) shows that the potential @xmath90 has also a well structure , but the minimum of @xmath90 is always positive , therefore the potential does not support a zero mode .
the shapes of the matter energy density , @xmath89 potential and @xmath109 are shown in fig .
[ a](a ) ( @xmath43 ) shows that the zero mode is localized on the brane .
on the other hand , fig .
[ a](b ) ( @xmath50 ) clearly shows that the normalizable zero mode is localized between the two sub - branes , as a consequence the zero mode is not localized on the brane .
therefore , we can conclude that the zero mode of the left - handed fermions is localized on the brane only as @xmath110 .
+ + + +
we have reinvestigated the effects of the variation of the mass parameter @xmath1 on the thick branes as well as the localization of fermions .
we showed that the variation of @xmath1 is associated to the phenomenon of brane splitting , therefore the brane does not get thicker with the increases of the value of @xmath1 , as argued in ref .
we can conclude that the appearance of two sub - branes is associated to phase transition for @xmath111 ( a disordered phase between two ordered phases ) .
also , we showed that the value of the matter energy depends on the asymptotic behavior of the warp factor . from the static equation of motion
we have analyzed the asymptotic behavior of @xmath5 and showed that the zero mode of the left - handed fermions for the simplest yukawa coupling @xmath2 is normalizable under the condition @xmath106 and it can be trapped on the brane only for @xmath110 , because the zero mode has a single - peak at the localization of the brane .
we also showed that as @xmath45 the zero mode has a single - peak between the two sub - branes and as a consequence the normalizable zero mode is not localized on the brane .
therefore , the brane with a big value of @xmath1 would not trap fermions more efficiently , in opposition to what was adverted in ref . @xcite .
this work completes and revises the analyzing of the research in ref .
@xcite , because in that work does not analyze the zero mode in full detail and contain some misconceptions .
additionally , we showed that the change of variable @xmath112 leads to a non conserved current , because the curved - space gamma matrices are not covariantly constant .
an interesting issue will be investigate the effects of non - conserved current on resonances modes and bear out the main conclusion of ref .
@xcite .
a.s . de castro and m.b .
hott , phys .
a * 351 * , 379 ( 2006 ) ; l.b . castro and a.s . de castro , j. phys .
a : math . theor . * 40 * , 263 ( 2007 ) ; l.b . castro and a.s .
de castro , phys .
scr . * 75 * , 170 ( 2007 ) ; l.b .
castro and a.s
. de castro , int .
e * 16 * , 2998 ( 2007 ) ; l.b .
castro , a.s .
de castro and m.b .
hott , int . j. mod
e * 16 * , 3002 ( 2007 ) ; l.b .
castro and a.s
. de castro , phys .
scr . * 77 * , 045007 ( 2008 ) . | in a recent paper published in this journal , zhao and collaborators [ phys .
rev .
d * 82 * , 084030 ( 2010 ) ] analyze a toy model of thick branes generated by a real scalar field with the potential @xmath0 , and investigate the variation of the mass parameter @xmath1 on the branes as well as the localization and resonances of fermions . in that research
the simplest yukawa coupling @xmath2 was considered . in that work
does not analyze the zero mode in details and also contains some misconceptions . in this paper ,
the effect of the variation of the mass parameter @xmath1 on the brane is reinvestigated and it is associated to the phenomenon of brane splitting .
furthermore , it is shown that the zero mode for the left - handed fermions can be localized on the brane depending on the values for the coupling constant @xmath3 and the mass parameter @xmath1 . |
non - radiating motion of extended charge distributions in classical electrodynamics has been known to exist for some time ( c.f . @xcite and references therein , and @xcite ) . on the other hand , for systems with a few _ point charges _ , larmor s radiation of energy at a rate proportional to the squared modulus of the acceleration plagues classical electrodynamics . to construct orbits that do not radiate , and hence are without acceleration ,
a simple option are constant velocity motions , which imply unbounded motion .
along _ bounded _ two body motions supported by mutual action at a distance , we expect acceleration to be needed to change velocities , unless velocities are allowed to change discontinuously .
for example , periodic polygonal orbits with piecewise constant velocity segments have vanishing radiation fields .
here we extend wheeler - feynman electrodynamics @xcite to include motion with discontinuous velocities .
this is a natural extension provided by the variational boundary value problem @xcite .
the resulting extended electrodynamics has several appealing physical features : ( i ) there exists a scalar function ( the finite action @xcite ) , and the condition for a minimizer demands that the partial derivatives of the action , with respect to each particle s four - velocity , be continuous along minimal orbits .
these continuous four - component linear currents are analogous to the dirac - equation of quantum mechanics , thus endowing the extended wheeler - feynman electrodynamics with spin .
this is a feature not present in any other classical electrodynamics of point - charges ; ( ii ) besides naturally including non - radiating orbits , the extended electrodynamics can be shown to lead simply to a de broglie length for double - slit scattering upon detailed modeling @xcite ; ( iii ) the absorber hypothesis , first idealized to hold as an average over an infinite universe@xcite , has no known solutions @xcite for many - body motion in wheeler - feynman theory @xcite with which it is consistent .
here we show that the variational electrodynamics allows a concrete realization of the absorber hypothesis for a two - particle universe , i.e. , there exists a non - empty class of two - body motions with vanishing far - fields , so that we do not need either large universes or randomization @xcite ; and ( iv ) two - body orbits with vanishing far - fields were used in ref .
@xcite to predict spectroscopic lines for hydrogen with a few percent precision . since the speed of light is constant in inertial frames , the equations of motion for point - charges are state dependent differential delay equations .
more specifically , wheeler - feynman electrodynamics @xcite has mixed - type state - dependent neutral differential delay equations of motion for the two - body problem .
the theory of delay equations is still incomplete bellenzennaro , hans - otto but it is known that purely - retarded differential delay equations with generic @xmath0 initial histories have continuous solutions with a discontinuous derivative at the initial time . the derivative becomes continuous at the next breaking point @xcite and progresses from @xmath1 to @xmath2at successive breaking points .
on the other hand , a purely retarded neutral differential delay equation with a generic @xmath0 initial history @xcite can have continuous solutions with discontinuous derivatives at _ all _ breaking points .
if one wants to use the electromagnetic neutral differential delay equations with arbitrary boundary data , solutions with discontinuous derivatives must be expected and accommodated .
surprisingly , this same neutrality is compatible with the recently developed boundary - value - variational method for wheeler - feynman electrodynamics @xcite . for orbits where the acceleration is not defined at a few points ,
the variational method offers a well - posed alternative to define trajectories beyond those satisfying a newtonian - like neutral differential delay equation _ everywhere_.
the variational method involves an integral that requires only piecewise - defined velocities , generalizing naturally to continuous orbits with discontinuous derivatives at breaking points .
our generalized electrodynamics contains the @xmath3 orbits of the wheeler - feynman theory .
as shown in ref .
@xcite , if boundary data are such that the extremum orbit is piecewise @xmath3 with _ continuous _ velocities , the wheeler - feynman equations hold everywhere with the exception of a countable set of points where accelerations are discontinuous ( which is a set of measure zero for the action integral ) . we henceforth define a breaking point as a point where velocity or acceleration are discontinuous . here
we show that continuous orbits with discontinuous velocities are possible minimizers if these satisfy further continuity - conditions .
these continuity conditions are non - local , unlike the conditions for an extremum of the variational methods of classical mechanics , which do _ not _ allow discontinuous velocities .
finally , if the extremum is not piecewise @xmath3 , the variational method defines minimizers that are not described by piecewise - defined - wheeler - feynman neutral differential delay equations ( which are not studied here ) . to discuss the relationship
to maxwell s electrodynamics it is important to keep in mind that : ( i ) wheeler - feynman electrodynamics is a theory of _ trajectories _ , where fields are only _ derived quantities _ ; and ( ii ) the boundary - value - variational - method defines only a _ finite _ segment of a trajectory , rather than a global trajectory @xcite .
the variational equations along piecewise @xmath3 orbits include the electromagnetic fields in the euler - lagrange equations @xcite , which are used here to give a derived operational meaning to the electromagnetic fields @xcite .
the electromagnetic fields appear as coupling terms of the variational equations and are defined _ on _ trajectory segments by the usual electromagnetic formulae @xcite .
in our generalization we use the linard - wierchert electromagnetic formulae to define fields by extension at all space - time - points for which future and past lightcones fall in the finite segment of the minimizer trajectory . for continuous trajectories with discontinuous velocities , and/or accelerations on sets of measure zero ,
we construct the electromagnetic fields only for points having a future and past lightcone , leaving the fields undefined where the past or future lightcones have a discontinuous velocity / acceleration ( usually another set of measure zero ) .
we further introduce the concept of short - range orbits as localized orbits with far - fields vanishing almost everywhere .
this bears a close relation to the electromagnetic notion of radiation @xcite . in their original articles , wheeler and
feynman @xcite attempted to derive an electrodynamics with retarded - only fields from the hypothesis that the universal far - fields vanish at all times ( the absorber hypothesis ) fey - whe . here
we generalize the absorber hypothesis @xcite to include fields that can be undefined on sets of measure zero , thus arriving at the _ generalized absorber hypothesis _ ( gah ) that the far - fields vanish _ almost everywhere_. we show that short - range - two - body - orbits _ must _ involve discontinuous derivatives on a countable set of points .
one advantage of our generalization is to include spatially - bounded - globally - defined - continuous - orbits with far - fields vanishing almost everywhere , which we call short - range orbits .
this generalization presents itself naturally as the next option after one shows that there are no @xmath3 localized orbits with far - fields vanishing everywhere .
the short - range piecewise @xmath3 continuous orbits are naturally described by the variational method in the same way as the globally @xmath3 continuous orbits
. however , the former are minimizers inside a larger family of boundary - data , which is the second advantage of our generalization .
this extended class of orbits includes orbits that are limits of cauchy sequences of orbits with far - fields disturbing the universe less and less , i.e. , the vanishing - far - field - limit of the gah .
in this paper we use the word `` minimizer '' meaning a generalized critical point of the variational method , that could be either a minimum or a saddle point .
the paper is divided as follows : in section ii we discuss the variational method for piecewise - defined continuous orbits with discontinuous derivatives .
we show that the variational method prescribes a continuous momentum current at each breaking point in addition to euler - lagrange equations from each side of the breaking point .
we discuss how the non - local - momentum - currents can be conserved even in the presence of velocity discontinuities along sewing chains " . in section
iii we prove that globally - defined short - range bounded orbits must have discontinuous velocities on a sewing chain of breaking points by giving the general solution to a neutral differential delay equation for the far - fields . in section
iv we discuss the physics of generalized minimizers along with some open questions and differences from bounded orbits to unbounded scattering orbits .
the variational method @xcite is well defined for continuous trajectories @xmath4 and @xmath5 @xmath6 that are piecewise @xmath0 . the boundary conditions for the variational method @xcite are illustrated in figure 1 , i.e. , the initial point @xmath7 for trajectory @xmath8 plus the segment of trajectory @xmath9 inside the lightcone of @xmath7 , and the endpoint @xmath10 for the trajectory @xmath9 plus the segment of trajectory of particle @xmath8 inside the lightcone of @xmath10 . for variations of trajectory @xmath8
the action functional @xcite reduces to @xmath11where @xmath12 depends only on trajectory @xmath9 and quantities of particle @xmath9 are defined at times @xmath13 according to the implicit condition for the advanced / retarded light cones of @xmath14 , i.e.,@xmath15 in eq .
( [ action1 ] ) the @xmath16 are the distances from @xmath17 to the respective advanced / retarded position @xmath18 along trajectory @xmath9 , unit vector @xmath19 points from @xmath20 to the respective advanced / retarded position @xmath21 , i.e. , @xmath22 @xmath23 and last @xmath24 .
notice that eq .
( [ action1 ] ) is an integral over the velocities , and is a well - defined operation even for trajectories with discontinuous velocities ( and even more general types of continuous trajectories with square - integrable velocities that are not studied here ) .
here we extend wheeler - feynman electrodynamics to trajectories with discontinuous velocities on a countable set of points using the boundary - value - variational - method .
for piecewise @xmath0 trajectories ( _ and _ piecewise @xmath0 histories ) it is possible to define disjoint intervals @xmath25 @xmath26 $ ] , with @xmath27 , @xmath28for @xmath29 , where the continuous trajectory @xmath4 and delayed arguments @xmath30 are piecewise @xmath0 .
the upper plus in @xmath31 indicates the right - limit of the @xmath32 breaking point while the upper minus in @xmath33 indicates the left - limit of the @xmath34 breaking point .
these are not to be confused with the lower indices used to denote quantities evolving in future and past light cones . of trajectory @xmath8 plus the segment of trajectory @xmath9 inside the lightcone of @xmath7 , i.e. , from point @xmath35 to point @xmath36 and the endpoint @xmath10 of trajectory @xmath9 plus the segment of trajectory of particle @xmath8 inside the lightcone of @xmath37 , i.e. , from point @xmath38 to point @xmath39 .
the trajectory of particle @xmath8 of the variational method goes from @xmath7 to @xmath38 ( blue line ) while the trajectory of particle @xmath9 goes from @xmath36 to @xmath10 ( green line ) .
the first breaking point is point @xmath36which generates a forward sewing chain of breaking points @xmath40 while endpoint @xmath41 is a breaking point generating a backward sewing chain of breaking points @xmath42 . ]
the variations of trajectory @xmath8 for the action ( [ action1 ] ) are defined piecewise @xmath0 with fixed endpoints , i.e.,@xmath43where and overdot denotes a time - derivative and the boundary conditions are @xmath44 if the continuous and piecewise @xmath0 perturbation @xmath45 has a discontinuous derivative in another set of intervals @xmath25 @xmath46 , then the perturbed trajectory @xmath47 is continuous and piecewise @xmath0 in the extended set of intervals defined by all intersections of the sets @xmath48 and @xmath49 .
this simply increases the number of piecewise intervals @xmath50 up to @xmath51 and the boundary condition for @xmath52 of eq .
( [ boundaries ] ) reads @xmath53 substituting the perturbed trajectory ( [ perturb ] ) into the action ( [ action1 ] ) and making a linear expansion about the orbit defines the frecht derivative , i.e. , @xmath54dt_{1}+o(|\boldsymbol{\ b}_{1}| ) , \label{frechet}\ ] ] where a
@xmath55 " indicates the scalar product in @xmath56 and @xmath57 is the sup - norm for the banach space of piecewise @xmath0 variations @xcite . in particular
if the orbit @xmath58 @xmath59\rightarrow % tcimacro{\u{211d } } % % beginexpansion \mathbb{r } % endexpansion ^{3}$ ] is piecewise @xmath3 then @xmath47 is continuous and piecewise @xmath0 on the same extended set of intervals
. we can integrate eq .
( [ frechet ] ) by parts in each interval yielding@xmath60)dt_{1 } \label{extra } \\ & & + \sum\limits_{\sigma = 1}^{\sigma = m}\int_{l_{\sigma -1}^{+}}^{l_{\sigma } ^{-}}\frac{d}{dt_{1}}(\mathbf{b}_{1}(t_{1})\cdot \frac{\partial \mathscr{l } } { \partial \mathbf{v}_{1}})dt_{1}. \notag\end{aligned}\]]since @xmath45 is continuous we can re - arrange the second term of the right - hand - side of eq . ( [ extra ] ) to give @xmath60)dt_{1 } \label{arranje } \\ & & -\sum\limits_{\sigma = 1}^{\sigma = m-1}(\mathbf{b}_{1}(l_{\sigma } ^{-})\cdot \frac{\partial \mathscr{l } } { \partial \mathbf{v}_{1}}% @xmath61equation ( [ disc ] ) defines the momentum jump at @xmath62 , i.e. , the first ( second ) term on the right - hand - side of eq .
( [ disc ] ) is the momentum evaluated from the right ( left ) of @xmath62 .
the conditions for a critical point in the class of continuous piecewise @xmath63 orbital variations of the piecewise @xmath3 continuous orbit are : ( i ) satisfy the euler - lagrange equations piecewise , to make the first term on the right - hand - side of eq .
( [ arranje ] ) vanish ; and ( ii ) have a continuous momentum @xmath64 at the breaking points so each term of the sum of the right - hand - side of eq .
( arranje ) vanishes for arbitrary @xmath65 , i.e. , @xmath66 as is usual in the neighborhood of breaking points one defines derivatives from the left - hand - side and from the right - hand - side @xcite . for the local lagrangians of classical mechanics one usually has @xmath67 , which combined with eq .
( [ current ] ) along a continuous trajectory would imply that _ each velocity _ is continuous .
continuity of velocity along a piecewise @xmath3 continuous orbit combined with the euler - lagrange equations from each side of the breaking point further determine a continuous acceleration , so that the orbit is actually @xmath3 at the breaking point .
therefore , in classical mechanics the restriction to piecewise @xmath3 orbits _ implies _ globally @xmath3 orbits . however , for eq .
( [ action1 ] ) , or the lagrangian given in eq .
( 14 ) of ref @xcite , the continuous momentum term is@xmath68which displays a surprising difference compared with the result obtained from variational methods in classical mechanics . as illustrated in figure @xmath8
, a simple piecewise - defined orbit has the sewing chain " of breaking points @xmath69 @xmath70 ) , where one velocity can jump _ if _ the other velocity has jumped at either the past or future breaking point . the two - body - noether - momentum ( formula ( a23 ) of ref .
@xcite ) , involves an integral that is insensitive to velocity jumps plus two non - local momentum terms given by eq .
( [ mv1 ] ) ( see eqs .
( a25 ) and ( a26 ) of ref .
@xcite ) , that _ are _ sensitive to jumps .
therefore , the two - body - noether - momentum is conserved as long as eq .
( [ mv1 ] ) is continuous across the jumps .
the first term on the right - hand - side of eq . ( [ arranje ] ) is the wheeler - feynman equation of motion for particle @xmath8 @xcite ( i,.e . , the usual euler - lagrange equation restricted here to piecewise segments ) .
minimization respect to variations of trajectory @xmath9 yields the neutral differential delay equation of motion for particle @xmath9 , and an analogous continuity with indices @xmath8 and @xmath9 exchanged .
notice that this surprising difference compared with the results from variational principles in classical mechanics requires a _ minimum of two bodies and a non - local lagrangian_. we note that the electromagnetic variational method has a parametrization - invariance - symmetry that allows the action ( [ action1 ] ) to be expressed in minkowski - four - space using four - velocities respect to an arbitrary evolution parameter @xcite .
the derivative of the parametrization - invariant - lagrangian with respect to the first - component of the four - velocity is,@xmath71equation ( [ mt ] ) represents the time - component of the four - momentum which must be continuous at the breaking points of a minimizing trajectory .
this is a generalization of the argument leading to eq .
( [ mv1 ] ) .
there is a four - current associated with the minimization respect to each particle s trajectory .
last , after solving for velocity discontinuities along sewing chains of breaking points , the second condition for a minimizer are the piecewise - restricted wheeler - feynman equations of motion .
these hold at each side of a breaking point and involve the limiting accelerations from the two sides of that breaking point .
the discontinuous velocities satisfying eqs .
( [ mv1 ] ) and ( [ mt ] ) , when substituted into the wheeler - feynman equations at each side of a breaking point , then define a condition to be satisfied by the acceleration discontinuities .
since this condition involves a singular matrix @xcite , acceleration discontinuities are not fully determined by velocity discontinuities . in general ,
velocity discontinuities cause acceleration discontinuities , even though there can be special orbits with continuous velocities and discontinuous accelerations along the null direction of the singular matrix @xcite . only in that case
our generalization is equivalent to piecewise restricted wheeler - feynman equations , otherwise completion by a finite action@xcite includes other types of trajectories . in either case , along a piecewise defined orbit , continuity of the spinor currents ( [ mv1 ] ) and ( [ mt ] ) ensure the well - posed continuation of the minimizer across each breaking point .
for example , solutions with continuous velocities yield trivially continuous momenta ( [ mv1 ] ) and ( [ mt ] ) , so that any finite portion of a global solution of the piecewise - restricted wheeler - feynman equations with continuous velocities is a minimizer of the finite variational method with suitable boundaries . for solutions with discontinuous velocities , continuation to a global trajectory is possible using the ( discontinuous ) velocity determined by solving conditions ( [ mv1 ] ) and ( [ mt ] ) for the most advanced velocity ( to be shown elsewhere )
wheeler - feynman electrodynamics is a theory of direct interaction between charges @xcite .
the boundary - value - variational - method ( previous section and fig .
1 ) defines minimizers with a vanishing frecht derivative ( [ frechet ] ) between the time - spans of fig .
1 , rather than globally - defined trajectories . as shown in ref .
@xcite , the two - body - euler - lagrange equations can be cast in the form of newtonian equations of motion with each acceleration multiplied by the mass on the left - hand - side , while the right - hand - side has the form of a lorentz -force - law .
it is precisely these euler - lagrange - equations that define the electromagnetic fields of wheeler - feynman theory as _ derived _
quantities evaluated _ on _ trajectories . extending these fields defined by the lorentz - sector - of - euler - lagrange - equations to fields on positions outside trajectories is tricky , because in a theory of trajectories one should : ( i ) add a third particle to the variational problem ; and ( ii ) arrange things such that the third trajectory passes by the desired point . obviously , a third charge changes the minimization problem and perturbs the original two - body - orbit , unless it can be placed so far that its couplings to the original two - body - orbit are small .
a bounded gah two - body - orbit is special because its far - fields vanish almost everywhere and a third trajectory can be placed reasonably near without disturbing the two - body - orbit . keeping in mind that the far - fields are the strongest couplings to a third charge
, we investigate the existence of such ( localized ) short - range - two - body - orbits ( gah ) .
we now adopt a unit system in which the speed of light is @xmath72 and apply the usual formulae of electrodynamics to piecewise - defined - trajectories with the exception of points where past / future velocities / accelerations are undefined , i.e. , the fields are undefined on a set of measure zero .
we consider continuous piecewise @xmath3 trajectories @xmath73 enclosed by a sphere of radius @xmath74 in an inertial frame .
we specify space - time points @xmath75 on the sphere by a time @xmath76 and unit vector @xmath77 normal to the surface of the sphere , and introduce an index @xmath78 to label the charges .
the far - electric field of a point charge in the wheeler - feynman electrodynamics is the sum of the half - advanced / half - retarded fields fey - whe , @xmath79while the far - magnetic field is given by @xmath80the unit vectors @xmath81 point respectively from the charge s advanced / retarded position to the position @xmath82 on the sphere @xcite .
trajectories are assumed to be bounded such that @xmath83 , so that for each charge we have @xmath84 .
the retarded far - electric and far - magnetic fields of a charge @xmath85 at the space - time point @xmath75 are piecewise - defined by the linard - wiechert formulas @xcite @xmath86}{% ( 1-\mathbf{n}\cdot \mathbf{v}_{k})^{3 } } , \label{far - electric1}\ ] ] and @xmath87 in eq .
( [ far - electric1 ] ) we have used the far - field - limit in which the light cone distance @xmath88is equal to @xmath74 since @xmath89 . in eq .
( far - electric1 ) @xmath90 and @xmath91 @xmath92 are respectively the charge s velocity and charge s acceleration at the retarded time @xmath93 defined implicitly and piecewise by the _ _ retardation condition__@xmath94where @xmath95 denotes cartesian distance
. equation ( [ cone1 ] ) defines @xmath96 as an implicit function of time @xmath76 with a piecewise defined derivative @xmath97 using eq .
( [ far - electric1 ] ) to evaluate the far - magnetic field ( far - magnetic1 ) yields@xmath98 .
\label{newb}\]]the trajectory @xmath73 is a function of @xmath76 from eq .
( lightcone1 ) so using the chain rule and eq .
( [ dt1dt ] ) twice we can re - write the far - magnetic - field ( [ newb ] ) as @xmath99 . \label{farman1}\]]the far - electric field is a linear function of the far - magnetic field obtained using eq .
( [ far - magnetic1 ] ) and the transversality property @xmath100 of the far - electric field ( [ far - electric1 ] ) , i.e. , @xmath101 in view of eq .
( [ reconstruct ] ) , it suffices to study the vanishing of the retarded - far - magnetic - fields .
we further assume a symmetry that the time - reversed orbit yields the same orbit rotated about an axis .
for these reverse rotate - symmetric orbits the vanishing of the retarded far - fields implies the vanishing of the advanced far - fields . from now on charge @xmath8
is taken to be positive and equal to @xmath102 while charge @xmath9 is negative and equal to @xmath103 .
the gah along a bounded piecewise @xmath3 orbit is then expressed almost everywhere by @xmath104 in the family of orbits with discontinuous velocities one can readily construct bounded orbits with vanishing far - fields ; e.g. piecewise - constant - velocity orbits with trajectories consisting of polygonal lines
. these are bounded orbits with each acceleration vanishing piecewise , so that the radiation fields vanish .
the question that needs to be answered is do we need these velocity discontinuities ? "
. equation ( [ vanishing ] ) is a ( linear ) _ neutral differential delay equation _ with piecewise - linear continuous solutions defined on the intervals @xmath105 , with @xmath106 by @xmath107where the @xmath108 and @xmath109 are arbitrary bounded functions and the @xmath110 are bounded and piecewise @xmath3 .
it is possible to choose @xmath111 and adjust @xmath112 in each interval to make the left - hand - side of eq .
( [ dipole ] ) continuous . along
a spatially bounded orbit , eq .
( [ lightcone1 ] ) is approximated for large values of @xmath74 by @xmath113notice that eqs .
( [ cone1 ] ) yield an implicit relation between @xmath14 and @xmath114 , @xmath115given the trajectories @xmath17 and @xmath116 , eq . ( [ t1t2 ] ) and the implicit function theorem yield @xmath14 as a function of @xmath114 and @xmath77 .
define the _ influence interval _ of point @xmath117 by the interval containing @xmath14 when @xmath77 varies arbitrarily in equation ( [ t1t2 ] ) , i.e. , @xmath118 the time span ( [ tspan ] ) is from the retarded lightcone - time of @xmath119 to the advanced lightcone - time of @xmath120 , as along the sewing chain illustrated in fig .
1 . notice that the future lightcone appeared naturally in the two - particle problem , even though we were dealing only with the retardation conditions ( [ cone1 ] ) .
it follows from eqs .
( [ t1t2 ] ) and ( [ dipole ] ) that@xmath121and we can therefore re - write eq .
( [ dipole ] ) as@xmath122where @xmath123 .
since linear growth in a constant direction is unbounded , the only globally @xmath3 orbit must have @xmath124 @xmath125 , and it follows from eq .
( [ newdipole ] ) with @xmath126 that @xmath127the derivative of eq .
( [ express ] ) respect to time yields @xmath128where@xmath129 equation ( [ t1t2 ] ) allow us to move @xmath77 in a cone with axis along @xmath130 in a way that fixes @xmath14 and @xmath114 while changing @xmath76 with eqs . ( [ cone1 ] ) . on the other hand , for fixed @xmath14 and @xmath114 the left - hand - side of eq .
( velocity ) spans a plane of the _ fixed _
vectors @xmath131 and @xmath132 , so that eq .
( [ velocity ] ) can hold only if @xmath133 , which combined with eqs .
( [ velocity ] ) and ( [ defk ] ) yields @xmath134equation ( [ rest12 ] ) defines globally - constant velocities along a fixed direction , which in turn implies unbounded motion unless @xmath135 , as discussed in ref .
this impossibility follows if velocities are to be continuous .
nontrivial alternatives to this unsatisfactory conclusion necessitate the introduction of discontinuities by varying the direction of the piecewise - velocity - like term @xmath136 of eq .
( [ newdipole ] ) in each interval .
the piecewise derivative of eq .
( newdipole ) respect to time yields@xmath137notice that @xmath138 is still given by eq .
( [ defk ] ) and with nonzero @xmath139 the right - hand - side of eq .
( novoplane ) forms a complete 3-dimensional basis to express any vector ( inside or outside the plane of @xmath131 and @xmath140 ) .
equation ( [ t1t2 ] ) still allows one to move @xmath77 in a cone with axis along @xmath130 in a way that fixes @xmath14 and @xmath114 while @xmath76 changes with eqs .
( cone1 ) . by choosing @xmath138 and a nonzero @xmath141 for each @xmath25 @xmath142 we can describe any vector on the left - hand - side of eq .
( [ novoplane ] ) , so that there is no inconsistency . as an example , time - reversible orbits satisfying eq .
( [ novoplane ] ) are piecewise - constant - velocity orbits generated by having one velocity jump at a given time while the other velocity jumps either in the backward or forward lightcone - times symmetrically , as well as at every time in the forward and backward light - cones of a discontinuity time ( the sewing chain illustrated in fig .
1 ) . these piecewise - linear polygonal orbits can be shown to satisfy eq .
( [ vanishing ] ) by direct substitution and use of eq .
( dt1dt ) . in the following
we show that eq .
( [ newdipole ] ) and the implicit function theorem yield a consistent piecewise - defined trajectory @xmath143 from a given piecewise - defined trajectory @xmath144 .
notice that for given continuous and piecewise @xmath0 @xmath145 , @xmath108 and @xmath146 , in general eq .
( [ newdipole ] ) determines only a function @xmath147 of the _ two variables _ @xmath148 through @xmath149the implicit function theorem further determines @xmath114 and @xmath76 as functions of @xmath14 and @xmath77 from eqs . ( [ cone1 ] ) , ( [ t1t2 ] ) and ( [ x1t1n ] ) . for the implicit function theorem to yield a consistent trajectory
, we must satisfy the consistency requirement that @xmath150 determined by eq .
( [ x1t1n ] ) is a function of @xmath151 only , i.e. , @xmath152 condition ( [ consistency ] ) applied to the right - hand - side of eq .
( x1t1n ) is the extra condition determining a consistent trajectory . since condition ( [ consistency ] ) must hold for all values of @xmath14 in each piecewise interval of the orbit , we must also have inside each piecewise interval that @xmath153which can be expressed as@xmath154=0 .
\label{compatibility}\]]the general solution to eq .
( [ compatibility ] ) involves an arbitrary piecewise - defined function @xmath155 , i.e. , @xmath156a symmetric condition follows by exchanging indices @xmath8 and @xmath9 in eq.(compatibility ) , introducing an arbitrary @xmath157 and changing the sign of @xmath158 , yielding @xmath159the partial derivatives in eqs .
( [ generalt1 ] ) and ( [ generalt2 ] ) can be evaluated using eqs .
( [ cone1 ] ) , yielding @xmath160where again @xmath138 is defined by eq .
( [ defk ] ) .
notice that eqs .
( [ final1 ] ) and ( [ final2 ] ) with @xmath161 and @xmath162 bring back eq .
( [ novoplane ] ) as the single necessary condition to construct a consistent piecewise @xmath0 continuous trajectory @xmath17 from a given piecewise @xmath0 continuous trajectory @xmath116 by the implicit function theorem .
we stress that velocity discontinuities are _ absolutely necessary_. the discontinuities introduced by the nonzero @xmath158 in each piecewise interval play an essential role in the solution as discussed below eq .
( novoplane ) . trying to solve either eq .
( [ final1 ] ) or eq .
( [ final2 ] ) with @xmath163 stumbles with the former obstruction that rotation of @xmath77 with fixed @xmath14 and @xmath114 places @xmath77 either outside the plane of @xmath155 and @xmath164 or outside the plane of @xmath157 and @xmath165 .
the nonzero @xmath158 provides the third linearly independent direction forming a complete basis to express @xmath77 in eqs .
( [ final1 ] ) and ( [ final2 ] ) .
it can be seen that piecewise - constant - velocity polygonal orbits can be constructed using the suitable @xmath166 defined by eq .
( [ novoplane ] ) , after which the implicit function theorem constructs consistent continuous piecewise @xmath0 trajectories .
it would be desirable to find bounded minimizer orbits of the variational method @xcite satisfying the vanishing far - field conditions ( [ final1 ] ) and ( final2 ) , as first conjectured for the orbits studied in ref .
stiff - hydrogen .
the justification to generalize to trajectories with discontinuous derivatives is to include short - range bounded gah orbits in the family of physically possible orbits .
this was used in ref .
stiff - hydrogen to predict spectroscopic lines of hydrogen within a few percent agreement with the predictions of quantum mechanics .
the fact that accelerations are discontinuous is expected because the wheeler - feynman equations of motion are explicitly neutral for the accelerations .
consequently , it could seem that a theory of piecewise - restricted wheeler - feynman equations of motion should have only acceleration discontinuities , a fact that already introduces discontinuous fields _ and _ demands a generalization of electrodynamics .
we have seen that generalizing to trajectories with discontinuous accelerations is not sufficient to include bounded two - body orbits with vanishing far - fields .
our analysis starting from the variational method as the fundamental principle has shown that , in general , the velocities are also expected to be discontinuous at the same `` generalized breaking points '' along the minimizer orbits .
our analysis , using the variational method as a boundary - value problem , shows that the most general solution of the wheeler - feynman neutral differential delay equations has discontinuous accelerations _ and _ velocities .
the form of eq .
( [ mt ] ) is reminiscent of the energy operator used formally in quantum mechanics .
since the evolution parameter is arbitrary , the same parameter can be used in a lorentz - transformed frame , such that the momentum currents transform by like a four - vector .
the existence of four components that must be continuous and given by the partial derivatives of a scalar invariant is again analogous to the quantum dirac equation and suggests a property analogous to spin for the point charges .
it is remarkable that wheeler - feynman electrodynamics completed with a finite action endows the point charges with a spin - like property .
the existence of a spinorial four - component momentum current ( eqs .
( [ mv1 ] ) and ( [ mt ] ) ) is due to the parametrization - invariance symmetry of the electromagnetic variational method @xcite .
otherwise a generic action with delayed interaction has only three momentum currents continuous at breaking points of minimizer orbits . in ref .
@xcite only globally @xmath3 solutions were sought for the seemingly non - neutral one dimensional motion , so that piecewise - defined solutions with discontinuous velocities awaited study . in considering this ,
it is important that the electromagnetic - action - functional ( [ action1 ] ) of ref .
@xcite yields a _ neutral - boundary - value - variational - method _ , as opposed to the non - neutral variational methods of classical mechanics .
the variational principles of classical mechanics are two - point boundary value problems that are equivalent to an initial - value problem with initial velocity chosen to hit the final trajectory point . moreover , in the classical problem there is no issue of velocity continuity , because the history " for a finite - dimensional ode is a point . on the contrary , for the electromagnetic variational method ,
choosing the initial velocity " to shoot the final point either requires a velocity discontinuous with the past boundary history _ or _ the trajectory arrives at the final point with the wrong velocity .
the generalization to discontinuous velocities extends the solvability of the electromagnetic - boundary - value - problem to a larger class of boundary value data , which is the second advantage of our extension of wheeler - feynman electrodynamics .
electromagnetism was originally formulated with the integral laws of ampere , gauss and faraday , and only much later differential equations holding everywhere were introduced by maxwell .
the requirement of a second derivative existing everywhere is actually not needed for particle dynamics , where one is concerned only with the integral of the force along the trajectory .
the variational method is a step back from maxwell s equations in the sense of weak solutions . replacing maxwell s equations by the vanishing of the frecht derivative ( [ frechet ] ) along a continuous trajectory with boundaries in future and past yields solutions defined only on bounded time - intervals . from these segments of orbits
one can construct the fields as _ derived quantities _ @xcite . since fields constructed in this fashion involve a retarded and a advanced position , before defining fields everywhere in space we need to extend to a global trajectory .
extension is possible using conditions ( [ mv1 ] ) and ( [ mt ] ) and in general involves velocity and acceleration discontinuities .
it is then tempting to translate our generalized electrodynamic quantities into the concepts of maxwell s electrodynamics , but it must be done carefully ; the derivation of the differential form of maxwell s equations given in @xcite holds only in regions where the extended fields are @xmath63 .
consequently , poynting s theorem in integral form holds in regions where the fields are @xmath0 .
nevertheless , quantities like energy flux and field energy in a volume have a meaning even for discontinuous fields , so that a statistical interpretation could be sought in the case of discontinuous fields ; for example , the generalized flux of the poynting vector is an integral that can be evaluated even when fields are undefined on sets of measure zero . the poynting vector @xmath167 evaluated with eqs .
( [ gene ] ) and ( [ genb ] ) at @xmath168 becomes @xmath169where single bars denote the euclidean modulus .
we stress that a condition of non - radiation is weaker than our gah , as follows ; the gah _ implies _ the vanishing of the flux ( [ poyntingx ] ) because @xmath170 _ almost everywhere _ , while the converse is not true , i.e. , the vanishing of the flux integral alone does not imply the gah . for example , the circular orbits of refs .
@xcite do not satisfy the gah , and even though these orbits do not radiate on average , circular orbits have non - vanishing far - fields to disturb a
third charge of the variational method " ( i.e. , are not short - range ) . in ref .
@xcite a model for the neutron was attempted , and even if it had not failed for other reasons , it would yield a neutron with far - fields .
as regards non - vanishing far - fields , a first attempt to overcame the gah - deficiency of circular orbits @xcite was the perturbation theory of ref . @xcite that added high - frequency modes of the tangent dynamics to enforce eq .
( [ vanishing ] ) at the frequency of the circular orbit .
we have shown that our variational method yields a dynamical system even for limiting orbits with discontinuous velocities .
for example , along piecewise - constant - velocity polygonal orbits the variational equations of motion would be applied as follows ; on discontinuity corner points with no acceleration defined , one enforces continuity of momentum only , eq .
( mv1 ) . at other points ,
wherever accelerations _ are _ defined , one uses the usual wheeler - feynman equations of motion .
( notice that piecewise - constant - velocity polygonal orbits have vanishing far - fields but obviously do not satisfy the equations of motion , unless charges are far apart ) .
we have demonstrated five different and important reasons to study orbits with discontinuous derivatives : ( i ) inclusion of bounded gah orbits as short - range orbits ; ( ii ) compatibility with the conservation of noether 's momentum ; ( iii ) compatibility with the neutrality of the equations of motion of the wheeler - feynman electrodynamics ; ( iv ) the fact that the variational method is natural in a space completed to contain orbits with discontinuous velocities ; and ( v ) inclusion of limits of sequences of non - radiating orbits . the physical need for trajectories with discontinuous velocities
is justified as limiting orbits defined by cauchy sequences of bounded orbits which _ must _ develop kinks in the short - range limit ( i.e. , the gah ) . in ref .
@xcite the gah - deficiency of circular orbits was removed with a perturbative fourier series that solved eq .
( [ vanishing ] ) at the first harmonic frequency only . as we have shown here , the perturbative series of ref .
@xcite should converge to an orbit with _ discontinuous velocities_. the short - range condition of ref .
stiff - hydrogen predicted orbits and spectral lines in the atomic magnitude with a surprising precision , so that we can claim agreement with experiment and quantum mechanics .
piecewise - defined minimizers have also been used successfully to explain double - slit diffraction in ref .
@xcite . from our generalized electrodynamics with discontinuous derivatives it should be possible to derive a generalized electrodynamics with delayed - only interactions and self - interaction , using the generalized absorber hypothesis ( gah ) in close analogy with the derivation of wheeler and
feynman fey - whe .
since we expect solutions with velocity discontinuities , taylor expansions of deviating arguments should be avoided or piecewise - restricted .
it is known that many - component delay differential equations behave like neutral differential delay equations when some solution components are discontinuous at breaking points , in the sense that the discontinuous derivatives never smooth out @xcite .
therefore , the third derivative should be generalized by restricting it to a left - derivative and a right - derivative at breaking points . also , the generalized absorber hypothesis with discontinuous fields no longer implies the vanishing of the difference of retarded and advanced universal fields everywhere , as used by wheeler and feynman @xcite .
( [ novoplane ] ) and its advanced version give the corresponding weaker generalization to this former stronger condition of a vanishing difference of retarded and advanced fields everywhere .
we speculate that eq .
( [ novoplane ] ) should be the starting point for a generalized theory of self - interaction free of the pervasive runaways of the two - body problem with the usual self - interaction .
last , we speculate that _ unbounded _ scattering orbits are different from the bounded orbits studied here . along unbounded orbits
( dipole ) contains the extra secular term with a constant @xmath171 .
the dependence on boundary segments and time separation must be investigated for scattering trajectories with discontinuous velocities and accelerations at the boundaries ; for example , even if the history segment @xmath172 @xmath173 of figure 1 is assumed @xmath174 , the forward sewing chain of @xmath36 places a breaking point @xmath175 in the history segment @xmath176 @xmath177 of particle @xmath8 . unless histories are very special so that derivatives are continuous at @xmath36 , in general the history @xmath176
@xmath177 should involve a discontinuous derivative at point @xmath178 .
scattering trajectories are likely to have future continuations involving stiffer jumps at later times , so that particles collide with laboratory boundaries , which can be regarded as a generalized type of radiative loss .
figure 1 : illustrated in red is the initial point @xmath7 of trajectory @xmath8 plus the segment of trajectory @xmath9 inside the lightcone of @xmath7 , i.e. , from point @xmath35 to point @xmath36 and the endpoint @xmath10 of trajectory @xmath9 plus the segment of trajectory of particle @xmath8 inside the lightcone of @xmath37 , i.e. , from point @xmath38 to point @xmath39 .
the trajectory of particle @xmath8 of the variational method goes from @xmath7 to @xmath38 ( blue line ) while the trajectory of particle @xmath9 goes from @xmath36 to @xmath10 ( green line ) .
the first breaking point is point @xmath36which generates a forward sewing chain of breaking points @xmath40 while endpoint @xmath41 is a breaking point generating a backward sewing chain of breaking points @xmath42 . | the electromagnetic two - body problem has _
neutral differential delay _ equations of motion that , for generic boundary data , can have solutions with _ discontinuous _ derivatives . if one wants to use these neutral differential delay equations with _ arbitrary _ boundary data , solutions with discontinuous derivatives must be expected and allowed .
surprisingly , wheeler - feynman electrodynamics has a boundary value variational method for which minimizer trajectories with discontinuous derivatives are also expected , as we show here .
the variational method defines continuous trajectories with piecewise defined velocities and accelerations , and electromagnetic fields defined _ by _ the euler - lagrange equations _ on _ trajectory points .
here we use the piecewise defined minimizers with the linard - wierchert formulas to define generalized electromagnetic fields almost everywhere ( but on sets of points of zero measure where the advanced / retarded velocities and/or accelerations are discontinuous ) . along with this generalization
we formulate the _ generalized absorber hypothesis _ that the far fields vanish asymptotically _ almost everywhere _ and show that localized orbits with far fields vanishing almost everywhere _ must _ have discontinuous velocities on sewing chains of breaking points .
we give the general solution for localized orbits with vanishing far fields by solving a ( linear ) neutral differential delay equation for these far fields .
we discuss the physics of orbits with discontinuous derivatives stressing the differences to the variational methods of classical mechanics and the existence of a spinorial four - current associated with the generalized variational electrodynamics . |
the discrepancy of about @xmath9 between the measured value @xcite and standard model prediction @xcite for the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon , @xmath10 , has attracted considerable attention . after the purely qed contributions , which are now known to five loops @xcite , the next most important term in the standard model prediction is the leading order ( lo ) hadronic vacuum polarization ( hvp ) contribution , @xmath11 .
the error on the dispersive evaluation of this quantity , obtained from the errors on the input @xmath12 cross - sections , is currently the largest of the contributions to the error on the standard model prediction @xcite .
the dispersive approach is , moreover , complicated by discrepancies between the determinations by different experiments of the cross - sections for the most important exclusive channel , @xmath13 @xcite .
the existence of this discrepancy , and the role played by the error on the lo hvp contribution , have led to an increased interest in providing an independent determination of @xmath11 from the lattice @xcite .
such a determination is made possible by the representation of @xmath11 as a weighted integral of the subtracted polarization , @xmath14 , over euclidean momentum - squared @xmath8 @xcite .
explicitly , @xmath15 where , with @xmath16 the muon mass , @xmath17 and @xmath18 , with @xmath19 the unsubtracted polarization , defined from the hadronic electromagnetic current - current two - point function , @xmath20 , via @xmath21 the vacuum polarization @xmath20 can be computed , and hence @xmath19 determined for non - zero @xmath22 , for those quantized euclidean @xmath22 accessible on a given finite - volume lattice .
were @xmath19 to be determined on a sufficiently finely spaced @xmath8 grid , especially in the region of the peak of the integrand , @xmath11 could be determined from lattice data by direct numerical integration .
two facts complicate such a determination .
first , since the kinematic tensor on the rhs of eq .
( [ polndefn ] ) , and hence the entire two - point function signal , vanishes as @xmath23 , the errors on the direct determination of @xmath19 become very large in the crucial low-@xmath8 region .
second , for the lattice volumes employed in current simulations , only a limited number of points is available in the low-@xmath8 region , at least for conventional simulations with periodic boundary conditions . with the peak of the integrand centered around @xmath24 gev@xmath7 , one would need lattices with a linear size of about 20 fm to obtain lattice data near the peak .
the rather coarse coverage and sizable errors at very low @xmath8 make it necessary to fit the lattice data for @xmath19 to some functional form , at least in the low-@xmath8 region .
existing lattice determinations have typically attempted to fit the form of @xmath19 over a sizable range of @xmath8 , a strategy partly predicated on the fact that the errors on the lattice determination are much smaller at larger @xmath8 , and hence more capable of constraining the parameters of a given fit form .
the necessity of effectively extrapolating high-@xmath8 , high - acccuracy data to the low-@xmath8 region most relevant to @xmath11 creates a potential systematic error difficult to quantify using lattice data alone . in ref .
@xcite , this issue was investigated using a physical model for the subtracted @xmath4 polarization , @xmath25 .
the model was constructed using the dispersive representation of @xmath25 , with experimental hadronic @xmath26 decay data used to fix the relevant input spectral function .
the study showed that ( 1 ) @xmath27 has a significantly stronger curvature at low @xmath8 than at high @xmath8 and ( 2 ) , as a result , the extrapolation to low @xmath8 produced by typical lattice fits , being more strongly controlled by the numerous small - error large-@xmath8 data points , is systematically biased towards producing insufficient curvature in the low-@xmath8 region either not covered by the data , or covered only by data with much larger errors . resolving this problem requires an improved focus on contributions from the low-@xmath8 region and a reduction in the impact of the large-@xmath8 region on the low-@xmath8 behavior of the fit functions and/or procedures employed . in this paper
we propose a hybrid strategy to accomplish these goals .
the features of this strategy are predicated on a study of the @xmath4 contribution to @xmath11 corresponding to the model for the @xmath4 polarization function , @xmath25 , introduced in ref .
the results of this study lead us to advocate a combination of direct numerical integration of the lattice data in the region above @xmath28 gev@xmath7 , and the use of pad or other representations in the low-@xmath8 ( @xmath29 ) region .
we will consider two non - pad alternatives for representing @xmath30 at low @xmath8 , that provided by chiral perturbation theory ( chpt ) and that provided by a polynomial expansion in a conformal transformation of the variable @xmath8 improving the convergence properties of the expansion .
the organization of the paper is as follows . in sec .
[ sec2 ] we briefly review the construction of the model , and use the resulting @xmath25 to quantify expectations about both the behavior of the integrand for @xmath31^{i=1}$ ] and the accumulation of contributions to this quantity as a function of the upper limit of integration in the analogue of eq .
( [ amu ] ) .
we also show , with fake data generated from the model using the covariances and @xmath8 values of a typical lattice simulation with periodic boundary conditions , that the contribution to @xmath32 from @xmath8 above @xmath3 can be evaluated with an error well below @xmath5 of the full contribution by direct trapezoid - rule numerical integration for @xmath3 down to at least as low as @xmath33 gev@xmath7 .
the values of @xmath8 covered by state - of - the - art lattice data are too few , and the statistical errors too large , to allow @xmath3 to be lowered much beyond this at present .
such a low @xmath3 , however , implies that the use of fit forms to represent the polarization function below @xmath3 can be restricted to the region @xmath34
gev@xmath7 , where the behavior of @xmath25 is expected to be much easier to parametrize in a simple and reliable manner .
we then show , in sec .
[ sec3 ] , that this expectation is borne out in practice .
explicitly , we demonstrate that , in the region up to about @xmath35 gev@xmath7 , good enough data will allow @xmath25 to be represented with an accuracy sufficient to reduce the systematic error on the low-@xmath8 contribution to @xmath36 to well below the @xmath5 level .
the three functional forms we investigate are low - order pad s , a polynomial representation in a conformally mapped variable , and a next - to - next - to - leading - order ( nnlo ) chpt form supplemented by an analytic nnnlo term . the pad s we will consider are of two types : those constrained explicitly to reproduce the first few derivatives at @xmath37 @xcite , and those obtained by fitting to data in the low-@xmath8 region @xcite . we will be limited to investigating the systematics of these low-@xmath8 representations . the lattice @xmath8 values and covariance matrix employed for fake - data studies in ref .
@xcite do not allow for a meaningful extension of this exploration to include also the statistical component of the uncertainty .
we expect , however , that new lattice data , employing twisted boundary conditions to provide a denser set of @xmath8 values on the lattice @xcite , as well as improved statistics @xcite , will make a more complete investigation possible in the near future . in this section
we also discuss briefly the expected low-@xmath8 behavior of the subtracted isoscalar polarization , @xmath38 , which can be obtained using values for the relevant chiral lecs obtained from a chiral fit to the isovector model data . finally , in sec .
[ sec4 ] , we discuss the relation between the errors on the low-@xmath8 contribution to @xmath32 and those on the slope and curvature at @xmath37 , and argue that a sub - percent determination of the former and few percent determination of the latter should be sufficient to obtain a sub - percent determination of the full contribution to @xmath11 .
this section also contains our conclusions .
the @xmath4 vector polarization function , @xmath39 , satisfies a once - subtracted dispersion relation , @xmath40 where @xmath41 is the pion mass , and @xmath42 the corresponding spectral function . a sensible choice for @xmath43 and the function @xmath42 thus determines a model for @xmath39 .
, of course , has no physical significance , and is sensitive to the precise details of the short - distance regularization of the two - point function . ]
the subtracted polarization represents one such version , in which @xmath43 happens to be equal to @xmath44 .
the spectral function @xmath42 has been measured with high precision , for @xmath45 , in non - strange hadronic @xmath26 decays @xcite . in ref .
@xcite , @xmath25 was determined from eq .
( [ disp ] ) using as input a version of the opal data updated for modern values of the exclusive mode branching fractions . for those @xmath46 not accessible in @xmath26 decay ,
@xmath42 was represented by the 5-loop - truncated dimension @xmath47 perturbative form @xcite , supplemented by a model representation of the residual , duality violating ( dv ) contribution .
an exponentially damped oscillatory form motivated by large-@xmath48 and regge ideas , was used for the latter , based on a model for duality violations developed in refs .
@xcite , inspired by earlier work in refs . @xcite .
where the perturbative+dv form is used for @xmath42 above @xmath49 , the dv contribution is much smaller than the perturbative one , making the model dependence of the resulting version of @xmath25 extremely mild , especially in the low-@xmath8 region where the factor weighting @xmath42 , @xmath50 $ ] , behaves as @xmath51 over most of the spectrum .
our model for @xmath25 is thus a very physical one , especially so in the low-@xmath8 region most relevant to the @xmath32 integral . as such
, it allows the systematics associated with various strategies for the fitting of @xmath14 and evaluation of the integral for @xmath11 to be investigated in a quantitative manner . in taking the lessons from such model studies over to the lattice , one must
, of course , bear in mind that the value of @xmath43 is not known on the lattice , and will have to be determined either through a fit to the data or by using time moments of the two - point function , as will be discussed further below .
+ the physical model for @xmath25 described in the previous section allows us to investigate in detail expectations , first , for the behavior of the integrand in the @xmath4 analogue of eq .
( [ amu ] ) and , second , for how rapidly ( as a function of the upper limit of integration ) the contributions to @xmath32 accumulate . to facilitate the discussion below
, we will denote by @xmath52 $ ] the partial contribution to the @xmath32 integral from the interval @xmath53 . with this notation , @xmath54=\hat{a}_\mu^{\rm lo , hvp}[0,q^2_{max}]$ ]
is the accumulated contribution between @xmath44 and @xmath55 , and @xmath56 $ ] .
figure [ fig1 ] shows the product of the weight @xmath57 appearing in the @xmath11 integral and the model version of the subtracted @xmath4 polarization .
as is well known , this product is strongly peaked at low @xmath8 ; it is thus shown only in the region @xmath58
gev@xmath7 , beyond which it continues to decrease rapidly and monotonically .
the model shows the location of the peak to be around @xmath59 .
lattice data typically does not reach such low @xmath8 , and some form of fitting is thus necessary to extrapolate into the peak region , at least in the conventional lattice approach .
it is also useful to look at the accumulation of the contributions to @xmath32 as a function of the upper limit of integration , @xmath55 .
we display this accumulation , normalized to the integral over all @xmath8 , @xmath32 , in the model , in fig .
we note that over @xmath60 of the contribution is accumulated below @xmath6
gev@xmath7 and over @xmath61 below @xmath62 gev@xmath7 .
it follows that the accuracy required for contributions above @xmath6 or @xmath62 gev@xmath7 is much less than that required for the low-@xmath8 region .
it thus becomes of interest to investigate the accuracy one might achieve for the higher-@xmath8 contributions were one to avoid altogether fitting and/or modelling , and the associated systematic uncertainty that accompanies it , and instead perform a direct numerical integration over the lattice data .
we investigate this question in the next subsection .
+ in this section , we argue that existing lattice data , even those without twisted boundary conditions , are already sufficiently accurate that direct numerical integration of the lattice data can be relied on to produce a value @xmath63 gev@xmath64 $ ] accurate to well below @xmath5 of @xmath32 for @xmath3 down to about @xmath65 gev@xmath7
. the situation will be even better once the results of new data with reduced errors on @xmath19 due to all - mode averaging ( ama ) @xcite and/or denser sets of @xmath8 produced by using twisted boundary conditions @xcite become available .
one practical issue , concerning the constant @xmath43 needed to convert the unsubtracted polarization @xmath39 obtained from the lattice to the corresponding subtracted version @xmath25 needed for the @xmath4 analogue of the integral in eq .
( [ amu ] ) , should be dealt with before continuing with the main investigation of this section .
the issue arises because the model we are working with is one for the _ subtracted _ polarization
. it thus appears to differ from the lattice case , where a determination of @xmath43 and subsequent subtraction would be required .
this issue is , however , easily resolved .
one simply interprets the model , not as one for the subtracted polarization , @xmath25 , but rather as one for the unsubtracted polarization , @xmath39 , happening to have @xmath66 and allows @xmath43 to become a free parameter in fits of data sets based on our model .
to all the subtracted polarization values @xmath25 . in fitting fake data generated from this modified version of the model , @xmath43 will of course need to be included as a fit parameter .
the result obtained for @xmath43 in such a fit will then be exactly equal to the sum of @xmath67 and the result @xmath68 that would be obtained by performing the same fit to the unmodified data with @xmath68 ] left free .
the extent to which the fitted @xmath43 deviates from the known value @xmath44 then quantifies the systematic uncertainty in the determination of @xmath43 for the given fit function form .
fits of @xmath70 $ ] and higher - order pad s on the interval between @xmath44 and @xmath71 gev@xmath7 to the fake data set of ref .
@xcite show that it is possible to obtain @xmath43 from such fits with an uncertainty smaller than @xmath72 .
an uncertainty @xmath73 produces a corresponding uncertainty @xmath74\ , = \ , 4\alpha^2\ , \delta\pi^{i=1}(0)\ , \int_{q^2_{min}}^\infty dq^2\,f(q^2)\ ] ] on the contribution to @xmath32 from @xmath75 .
the rapid decrease of @xmath57 with @xmath8 means this uncertainty falls rapidly with increasing @xmath3 .
figure [ fig3 ] illustrates the impact of this uncertainty on @xmath76 .
the figure shows the @xmath3 dependence of @xmath77 $ ] , as a fraction of @xmath76 , for @xmath78 .
even with this ( what we expect to be rather conservative ) choice for @xmath79 , the error remains safely below @xmath5 for @xmath3 down to @xmath6 gev@xmath7 , where @xmath80 } { \hat{a}_\mu^{\rm lo , hvp}}\ , = \ , 0.0074\ , \left({\frac{\delta\pi^{i=1}(0)}{0.001}}\right)\ .\ ] ] the relatively rapid growth at lower @xmath3 , however , means that careful monitoring of this error for the @xmath79 actually achieved in a given analysis would be required if one wished to push the lower limit of direct numerical integration of the lattice data to below @xmath6 gev@xmath7 .
we now turn to the model study of the accuracy of the direct numerical integration of the subtracted polarization data , assuming that @xmath79 is small enough to allow for a sufficiently precise subtraction . for this purpose
, we employ the fake @xmath4 data set used previously in ref .
the set was constructed from the @xmath26-data - based model discussed above using the covariance matrix for a @xmath81 milc ensemble with periodic boundary conditions , @xmath82 fm and @xmath83 mev @xcite .
the lattice covariance matrix is , by construction , also the covariance matrix of the fake data set . with the fake data and its covariances in hand , we evaluate @xmath63
gev@xmath64 $ ] and its error by direct trapezoid rule integration of the data , and compare the result to the corresponding exact result in the model .
the difference between the two gives the systematic error associated with estimating @xmath63 gev@xmath64 $ ] by direct numerical integration .
gev@xmath7 is somewhat arbitrary , but in our model @xmath84
gev@xmath64 $ ] is 99.74% of @xmath32 . ] in addition to this systematic uncertainty , there is , of course , also the statistical component of the overall uncertainty , obtained by propagating the data covariances through the trapezoid - rule evaluation . in the present model study ,
these covariances are those of the fake data set .
the results for both the systematic and statistical components of the uncertainty on the trapezoid rule evaluation are displayed , as a function of @xmath3 , in fig .
[ fig4 ] . for each @xmath3
, the displayed central value represents the corresponding systematic uncertainty , while the error bar gives the size of the corresponding statistical uncertainty .
the results have been scaled by @xmath32 in order to display the impact of the numerical integration uncertainty on the final error for @xmath32 .
we see that both components are completely negligible above @xmath85 gev@xmath7 .
the systematic component remains below @xmath86 for all points shown .
the statistical component is seen to be dominant for low @xmath3 , reaching about @xmath87 for the lowest value shown ( @xmath88 gev@xmath7 ) .
the growth of the statistical component with decreasing @xmath3 is a consequence of the rapid growth in the data errors for the very low-@xmath8 points , something that would be significantly reduced with improved data @xcite .
the results of this study show that data from existing lattice simulations , even without twisted boundary conditions and/or ama improvement , allow an evaluation of the contributions to @xmath76 from @xmath0 with an accuracy safely below @xmath5 of @xmath76 for @xmath3 down to at least @xmath6 gev@xmath7 . while not yet available , analogous fake data sets constructed from covariance matrices corresponding to lattice data with twisted boundary conditions and ama improvement , will , once available , allow us to quantify the level of improvement made possibly by better statistics and a finer distribution of @xmath8 points .
of course , as explained at the beginning of this subsection , @xmath43 , needed to compute @xmath25 for the numerical integration , will have to be determined with sufficient precision as well .
the fact that @xmath63 gev@xmath64 $ ] can be reliably evaluated by direct numerical integration down to @xmath28 gev@xmath7 greatly simplifies the task of computing the rest of the contribution to @xmath32 .
the reason is that , for @xmath89 gev@xmath7 , one expects fits using low - order pad s of the types proposed in refs .
@xcite , or using the conformal polynomial or chiral representations discussed below ( secs .
[ sec3b ] and [ sec3c ] ) , to provide efficient and reliable representations of the subtracted polarization function .
we show that this is indeed the case in the next section , and investigate the systematic uncertainties on the low-@xmath8 contributions produced by the use of such fit forms .
in the previous section we showed that contributions to @xmath32 from @xmath8 above @xmath90 gev@xmath7 can be obtained with an accuracy better than @xmath5 of @xmath32 by direct numerical integration of existing lattice data . in this section
, we discuss the region between @xmath44 and @xmath90 gev@xmath7 and investigate the reliability of low - order pad , conformally mapped polynomial , and chpt representations of the subtracted polarization in this region .
we focus on the systematic accuracy achievable using these representations for the evaluation of the low-@xmath8 contributions to @xmath32 . as in the previous sections ,
these investigations are performed using the @xmath26-data - based model for @xmath25 . at low @xmath8 ,
fits of lattice data to a functional form are needed to achieve a precise determination of the integral in eq .
( [ amu ] ) . to avoid difficult - to - quantify systematic errors , the form(s ) employed
should be free of model dependence .
here we investigate three such functional forms , one based on a sequence of pad approximants @xcite , one based on a conformally mapped polynomial , and one based on chpt .
an important question is to what order pad , what degree conformally mapped polynomial , and what order in the chiral counting one must go in order to obtain representations of @xmath25 of sufficient accuracy . in addition , there is the question of with what statistical precision these functional forms can then be fit to lattice data . even if in principle a certain functional form provides an accurate representation of @xmath25
, the parameters still have to be determined with sufficient precision . in this article , we address only the first question , leaving an investigation of the second question to the future , when much more precise lattice data at low @xmath8 are expected to become available . in order to probe the accuracy of an approximate functional form in representing the exact function @xmath25
, we need to fix the parameters of that form .
we will do so by constructing the pad , conformal and chiral representations such that they reproduce the values of the the relevant low - order derivatives of @xmath25 with respect to @xmath8 at @xmath37 . in the model case
, these derivatives are known from the dispersive representation of the subtracted polarization , while on the lattice they can be obtained from time moments of the vector current two - point function , as explained in more detail below .
since we are concerned with the systematic uncertainty associated with the use of a given functional form in the low-@xmath8 region , we will assume these derivatives to be exactly known and given by the central values resulting from the dispersive representation .
it will still be necessary to reduce the errors on the low-@xmath8 lattice data in order to bring the corresponding statistical uncertainties under control .
our goal is thus only to identify those functional forms which produce systematic uncertainties at the sub - percent level when used with future improved low-@xmath8 data .
+ as already pointed out in ref .
@xcite , the function @xmath91 is a so - called stieltjes function and , as such , satisfies a number of theorems on convergent representations over compact regions of the complex @xmath8 plane via pad approximants @xcite .
for example , the sequence of @xmath92 $ ] pad s constructed to match the first @xmath93 coefficients of the taylor expansion of @xmath94 about @xmath37 is known to converge to @xmath94 as @xmath95 , and for any @xmath96 , in any compact set in the complex @xmath8-plane not overlapping the cut of @xmath97 @xcite .
moreover , for @xmath98 , the set of such pad s satisfies the inequalities @xcite @xmath99\leq [ 1,2]\leq \cdots \leq [ n , n+1]\leq \phi ( q^2 ) \leq [ n , n]\leq \cdots \leq [ 1,1]\leq [ 0,0]\ .\label{padeineq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] to make contact with the notation employed in ref
. @xcite , let us denote @xmath100 times the @xmath101 $ ] pad in ( [ padeineq ] ) by @xmath102_h$ ] . the inequalities ( [ padeineq ] ) then correspond to the following inequalities for the pad representations of @xmath25 @xmath103_h\leq [ 2,1]_h\leq \cdots \leq [ n+1,n]_h\leq \hat{\pi}^{i=1}(q^2 ) \nonumber\\ & & \qquad\qquad \leq [ n , n]_h\leq \cdots \leq [ 2,2]_h \leq [ 1,1]_h\ .\label{padeineqpr}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in ref . @xcite it has been pointed out that the derivatives of the polarization function at @xmath37 , needed to construct the sequences of pad s in eq .
( [ padeineqpr ] ) , can be determined by evaluating even - order euclidean time moments of the zero - spatial - momentum representation of the relevant vector current two - point function on the lattice .
, see ref . @xcite .
] this idea was implemented for the @xmath104 and @xmath105 vector current polarization functions and the resulting representations used to determine the strange and charm contributions to @xmath11 .
evidence was presented that convergence has been achieved by the time the @xmath106_h$ ] order is reached . however , in the light - quark sector the errors on these moments are expected to be much larger , and to grow rapidly with increasing order , because light - quark correlators are very noisy at large euclidean @xmath107 .
it is , first of all , not clear what order pad would be required for suitable convergence in the light - quark sector and , second , not obvious that the moments needed to construct , _ e.g. _ , the @xmath106_h$ ] pad can be determined with sufficient accuracy to make the computation of the full light - quark contribution to @xmath11 feasible in this approach .
the @xmath26-data - based model for @xmath25 provides a convenient tool for investigating the first of these questions .
first , since the exact values of the derivatives of @xmath25 with respect to @xmath8 at @xmath37 in the model are easily obtained from the dispersive representation , eq .
( [ disp ] ) , it is straightforward to construct the exact - model versions of the pad s of ref .
@xcite and see how well they do in representing @xmath25 .
second , knowing that contributions to @xmath76 from @xmath8 above @xmath90 gev@xmath7 can be accurately determined by direct numerical integration of existing lattice data , we can use the model to explore the obvious question raised by this observation , namely how low an order of pad will suffice if one s goal is to evaluate the contribution to @xmath32 , not for all @xmath8 , but rather only for the restricted region @xmath108
gev@xmath7 .
figure [ fig5 ] shows the comparison of the dispersive results for @xmath25 and the @xmath109_h$ ] , @xmath70_h$ ] , @xmath110_h$ ] , and @xmath106_h$ ] pad s constructed using the exact dispersive results for the derivatives of @xmath25 with respect to @xmath8 at @xmath37 .
the top panel shows the comparison in the inteval @xmath111 gev@xmath7 , the bottom panel the same comparison in the more restricted region @xmath112 gev@xmath7 .
note that the curves shown in this figure follow the pattern of the inequalities in eq .
( [ padeineqpr ] ) .
we see that the @xmath106_h$ ] pad provides a good , though not perfect , representation of @xmath25 over the whole of the range @xmath111 gev@xmath7 .
this is not true of the lower - order pad s .
when one focuses on the low-@xmath8 region , however , it is evident that even the @xmath70_h$ ] pad provides a very accurate representation in the region of current interest , @xmath113 gev@xmath7 . for the problem at hand , of course , it is deviations of the pad representations from @xmath25 in the low-@xmath8 region that are of importance in determining the accuracy of the pad - based estimates for @xmath32 . the impact of the deviations seen in fig .
[ fig5 ] on the contribution @xmath54 $ ] from the region @xmath114 is shown in fig .
[ fig6 ] as a function of @xmath55 .
the upper panel shows the difference between the various order pad estimates and the exact model result , scaled as usual by @xmath32 , for @xmath55 in the interval @xmath115 gev@xmath7 , while the lower panel zooms in on the region below @xmath62 gev@xmath7 of interest here .
we see that , if one insists on using the time moments to evaluate the contributions to @xmath32 from @xmath8 out to @xmath116 gev@xmath7 or above , reducing the systematic error on the evaluation to below @xmath5 will require going to the @xmath106_h$ ] pad .
this would necessitate evaluating time moments with good accuracy out to tenth order , which is likely to be a challenging task for light - quark two - point functions .
we have seen , however , that there is no need to push the moment - based evaluation of @xmath117 $ ] out to @xmath118 gev@xmath7 . in the region below @xmath119
gev@xmath7 which can not be handled by direct numerical integration of the lattice data , one does not need the @xmath106_h$ ] pad to achieve an accurate representation of @xmath25 .
the lower panel of fig .
[ fig6 ] shows that even the @xmath70_h$ ] representation is sufficient in this region , producing an estimate for @xmath54 $ ] accurate to about 0.3% for @xmath120 gev@xmath7 and to about @xmath87 even for @xmath121 gev@xmath7 .
this is a potentially significant advantage since constructing the @xmath70_h$ ] pad requires moments only up to sixth order .
the @xmath110_h$ ] pad lowers the previous errors to @xmath122 and @xmath123 , respectively , but it requires the eighth order moment in its construction .
it is worth emphasizing that another sequence of pad approximants to @xmath39 exists ; these are the multi - point pad s of ref .
@xcite , for which convergence theorems also exist @xcite .
these multi - point pad s actually have the same form as the single - point , @xmath37 pad s discussed in ref .
@xcite .. the pad denoted @xmath101 $ ] in ref .
@xcite corresponds to what is called @xmath102 $ ] in ref .
we employ the alternate notation @xmath102_h$ ] , introduced already above , for the latter in order to distinguish between it and the earlier notation employed in ref .
@xcite . ] fitting the coefficients of such pad s over a relatively low-@xmath8 interval in which the pad in question is known to provide an accurate representation of @xmath25 is thus an alternative to obtaining these coefficients by evaluating the time moments of the two - point function . which of the two approaches will yield the smallest statistical error is a topic for future investigation .
one should , however , bear in mind in this regard that the time moments , in producing the derivatives of the subtracted polarization with respect to @xmath8 at @xmath37 , will yield pad s which , by construction , will be most accurate in the low-@xmath8 region of primary interest for evaluating @xmath32
. the deviations of the pad constructed in this manner from the underlying subtracted polarization will thus lie at higher @xmath8 and have a reduced impact on the error on @xmath32 , if the pad is only used to get the low-@xmath8 contribution .
in contrast , in fitting the coefficients of the pad s using low-@xmath8 data , the fits will inevitably be more heavily constrained by the somewhat larger @xmath8 points in the fit interval , as these will have smaller errors than the points at very low @xmath8 .
the resulting pad may thus be less accurate at very low @xmath8 , and one may need to go to a higher - order pad in comparison to the moment - based approach .
further quantitative investigations of the lattice situation will become possible once covariance matrices corresponding to lattice data with twisted boundary conditions and ama improvement become available .
for now , however , we can investigate this issue only using the @xmath4 model data and associated covariance matrix , the latter being generated by the covariances of the experimental @xmath26-decay data used in constructing the model .
we emphasize that this covariance matrix is very different from what we may expect any covariance matrix coming from lattice data to look like , so the following short exercise can serve only to address systematic issues , and has nothing to say about the statistics that will be required on the lattice .
if we fit the @xmath26-based data on the interval between @xmath6 and @xmath62 gev@xmath7 , where lattice errors will typically be much smaller than those at lower @xmath8 , we find that it is necessary to go to the @xmath110_h$ ] pad if one wishes to reduce the systematic uncertainty on the low-@xmath8 pad determination of @xmath124 gev@xmath64 $ ] to the sub - percent level . as an example , a fit to model data at the points @xmath125 gev@xmath7 using the @xmath110_h$ ] pad form , with @xmath68 a free parameter , yields an estimate for @xmath126 gev@xmath64 $ ] accurate to better than @xmath127 of @xmath32 . even more useful
, though not unexpected in view of the fact that the @xmath110_h$ ] representation is essentially indistinguishable from the underlying model polarization out to @xmath128 gev@xmath7 , @xmath54 $ ] remains accurate to better than @xmath127 out to @xmath121 gev@xmath7 .
this means that , with sufficiently good data in the interval between @xmath129 and @xmath62 gev@xmath7 , one would be able to vary the choice of boundary @xmath130 between the low-@xmath8 and high-@xmath8 regions and obtain combined hybrid determinations of the full contribution to @xmath11 for several choices of @xmath130 , providing further checks on the systematics of the hybrid approach .
the taylor expansion of @xmath39 in the variable @xmath8 converges for @xmath131 .
however , with @xmath132 gev@xmath7 , the radius of convergence is most likely too small to be useful in practice .
we can improve the convergence properties by rewriting @xmath39 first in terms of the variable @xmath133 and then expanding in @xmath134 .
the series @xmath135 should have better convergence properties than the taylor expansion in @xmath136 , because the whole complex @xmath136 plane is mapped onto the unit disc in the complex @xmath134 plane , with the cut @xmath137 $ ] mapped onto the disc boundary .
the expansion ( [ series ] ) thus has radius of convergence @xmath138 . in terms of the variable @xmath8 ,
this includes the positive real axis . for the coefficients @xmath139 needed to construct @xmath140 up to degree @xmath141 , we find , from the derivatives of @xmath39 with respect to @xmath8 at @xmath37 in the model , the values @xmath142 and @xmath143 , @xmath144 and @xmath145 .
the resulting representations of @xmath25 linear , quadratic , cubic and quartic in @xmath134 are compared to the exact model values in fig .
we observe , from figs .
[ fig5 ] and [ fig7 ] , that the pad and conformal polynomial representations with the same number of parameters lie close to one another .
let us look more closely at the values of @xmath54 $ ] obtained from the conformal polynomial representations . the quadratic version , for example , yields estimates for @xmath54 $ ] @xmath146 and @xmath5 below the exact model values for @xmath120 and @xmath62 gev@xmath7 , respectively , while the corresponding errors for the cubic representation are @xmath147 and @xmath148 .
these numbers are to be compared to @xmath127 and @xmath87 for the @xmath70_h$ ] pad ( which has the same number of parameters as the quadratic polynomial ) , and @xmath122 and @xmath123 for the @xmath110_h$ ] pad ( which has same number of parameters as the cubic polynomial ) .
while the higher - order conformal representations discussed above provide very accurate results for @xmath54 $ ] , one should bear in mind that their construction requires as input the values of the derivatives of @xmath14 with respect to @xmath8 at @xmath37 .
as mentioned before , these can , in principle , be obtained from the time moments of the two - point function .
accurate determinations of the relevant moments will thus be required to make the conformal approach useful in this form .
it is , of course , also possible to implement the conformal representation by fitting the coefficients of a truncated version of the expansion in eq .
( [ series ] ) to data on an interval of @xmath8 .
an exploration of this possibility can be meaningfully carried out in the low-@xmath8 region at present only on the @xmath26-data - based model and its covariances . as in the analogous pad study in sec .
[ sec3a ] , we find that a representation one order higher is required to reach the same accuracy for the fitted version as was reached using the corresponding moment approach .
fitting the coefficients of the cubic form to the model data at the points @xmath125 gev@xmath7 , for example , yields estimates for @xmath54 $ ] accurate to between @xmath149 and @xmath150 for @xmath55 in the interval from @xmath6 to @xmath62 gev@xmath7 .
the accuracy of the fitted version in this case , though good , is less so than what was achieved for the analogous @xmath110_h$ ] pad fit .
the pad approach may thus be favored if one is forced to fit coefficients using data over a limited range of @xmath8 , while the conformal approach will be most useful if high - accuracy determinations of the time moments , and hence the derivatives of the polarization at @xmath37 , turn out to be achievable .
+ in the region of interest , @xmath151 gev@xmath7 , @xmath8 is sufficiently small that chpt should be capable of providing an accurate representation of the subtracted polarization .
it has been known for some time that the next - to - leading - order ( nlo ) representation @xcite is not adequate for this purpose , its slope with respect to @xmath8 being much less than what is seen in either lattice data @xcite or the continuum version of the @xmath4 subtracted polarization discussed above .
the source of the problem is the absence , in the nlo representation , of nlo low - energy - constant ( lec ) contributions encoding the large contributions associated with the prominent vector meson peaks in the relevant spectral functions .
these contributions first appear at nnlo .
the nnlo representation of the subtracted @xmath4 polarization function has the form @xcite in the term proportional to @xmath152 . ]
@xmath153_{\rm nnlo}\ , = \ , { \cal r}(q^2;\mu ) \ , + \ , c_9(q^2;\mu ) \ , l_9^r(\mu ) \ , + \ , 8\ , c_{93}^r(\mu ) \
, q^2\ , \label{subpolnnlo}\ ] ] where @xmath154 is the chiral renormalization scale , @xmath155 is one of the renormalized dimensionful nnlo lecs defined in refs .
@xcite , and @xmath156 and @xmath157 , which also depend on @xmath41 , @xmath158 and @xmath159 , are completely known once @xmath8 , @xmath154 , @xmath41 , @xmath158 and @xmath159 are specified .
the nlo lec @xmath160 is well known from an nnlo analysis of @xmath161 and @xmath162 electromagnetic form factors @xcite and we take advantage of this determination in the exploratory fits to the @xmath26-based model data below . in the resonance chpt ( rchpt )
approach @xcite , which one expects to represent a reasonable approximation for vector channels , @xmath155 is generated by vector meson contributions .
the rchpt result , @xmath163gev@xmath164 @xcite , where @xmath165 and @xmath166 are the vector meson decay constant and mass , is expected to be valid at some typical hadronic scale ( usually assumed to be @xmath167 ) .
this rough estimate is well supported by the data , and the term proportional to @xmath155 is , in fact , the dominant contribution to the rhs of eq .
( [ subpolnnlo ] ) for @xmath168 gev@xmath7 . in the @xmath4 channel , assuming @xmath155 to be dominated by the @xmath169 contribution , and expanding the @xmath169 propagator to one higher order in @xmath8 , one obtains an nnnlo contribution of the form @xmath170 which is @xmath171 times the nnlo contribution @xmath172 , yielding @xmath173 gev@xmath174 .
this estimate leads to a significantly larger curvature of @xmath25 than predicted by the known lower - order terms and such a larger curvature is indeed clearly indicated by the low-@xmath8 behavior of the @xmath26-data - based model for @xmath25 .
contributions to @xmath25 from a @xmath170 term with such a value for @xmath67 already become numerically non - negligible at @xmath168 gev@xmath7 . in order to allow accurate chiral fits over the range of interest , we thus need to supplement the nnlo representation of eq .
( [ subpolnnlo ] ) with an additional @xmath175 term .
@xmath176 represents an effective nnnlo lec , which is mass - independent at that order .
would be relevant if one wished to use the results of chiral fits to physical - mass continuum data to make predictions about the low-@xmath8 behavior of the subtracted polarization for lattice simulations corresponding to sufficiently small , but still unphysically heavy , light - quark masses . ]
we will refer to the nnlo representation augmented with the @xmath175 term as the nn@xmath177lo representation below .
the nn@xmath177lo representation is governed by three lecs , @xmath178 , @xmath179 and @xmath176 , the first of which is already known to better than 10% .
the relevant question here is whether , with sufficiently good euclidean time moments of the vector correlation function , or low-@xmath8 data for its fourier transform , this form is capable of producing a representation of @xmath25 accurate enough to allow a sub - percent evaluation of the contribution to @xmath36 from the region @xmath34
it turns out that , at present , the low-@xmath8 errors on data from lattice simulations are still too large , and the @xmath8 coverage too sparse , to allow this question to be sensibly explored using fake data of the type employed in ref .
we thus investigate the systematics of the nn@xmath177lo chpt fit form using the @xmath26-based @xmath4 model following the same approach as employed in secs .
[ sec3a ] and [ sec3b ] for the pad approximant and conformal polynomial forms . in other words , we determine the relevant lecs , and hence the chiral representation , from the values of the derivatives of @xmath25 with respect to @xmath8 at @xmath37 in the model . as mentioned before , in the lattice context these derivatives can , in principle , be determined from the time moments of the euclidean correlation function .
using @xmath180 mev , @xmath181 mev , @xmath182 mev , and @xmath183 mev , as well as @xmath184 from ref .
@xcite , and the exact values for @xmath185 and @xmath186 from our model , we find that @xmath187 gev@xmath164 and @xmath188 [email protected] - based model results for @xmath25 elsewhere . ]
using these values , fig .
[ fig8 ] shows the comparison between the exact model dispersive results for @xmath25 and those obtained from the chiral representation ( [ chiralrep ] ) .
also shown is the chiral representation with the @xmath175 contribution removed .
the necessity of the nnnlo curvature contribution is evident .
using our chiral representation , we can compare the value for @xmath54 $ ] obtained from nn@xmath177lo chpt with the exact - model value . for @xmath120 gev@xmath7 , we find that the chpt value is @xmath146 below the exact value , while for @xmath121 gev@xmath7 , it is @xmath189 below . while the value at @xmath120 gev@xmath7 is acceptable , this is clearly worse than the approximation obtained using a @xmath70_h$ ] pad determined from the same derivatives at @xmath37 .
nnlo chpt , which corresponds to setting @xmath190 , yields values of @xmath191 and @xmath192 above the exact value , at @xmath120 and @xmath62 gev@xmath7 , respectively .
clearly , the nn@xmath177lo form provides a good representation for values of @xmath8 extending up to about @xmath6 gev@xmath7 , but there is evidence for contributions to the curvature in the data at higher @xmath8 beyond that described by the known nlo , nnlo and @xmath175 terms .
this shows up in the deviations from the data of the chiral curve in the region @xmath193
gev@xmath7 in fig .
[ fig8 ] . as in the case of pad s , an alternative method for constructing a chiral representation for @xmath39 is by fits to lattice data at non - zero values of @xmath8 , instead of from derivatives at @xmath37 .
such fits will be most reliable when employed in a fit window involving as low @xmath8 as possible . from fig .
[ fig8 ] and the discussion above , it follows that data at values of @xmath8 below 0.1 gev@xmath7 would be needed . in the case of fits to pad s , we saw in sec .
[ sec3a ] that a sufficiently accurate representation can in principle be obtained from data in an interval farther away from zero , @xmath194 gev@xmath7 if one increases the order of the pad from @xmath70_h$ ] to @xmath110_h$ ] by adding one parameter . in chpt
, such an approach would imply going beyond nnnlo order .
( as it is , even the nn@xmath177lo representation is only a phenomenological version of the nnnlo representation . ) with such high orders not being available , the application of chpt is limited to the moment - based approach , or possibly to fits at @xmath8 values below 0.1 gev@xmath7 .
this means the chpt approach to the low-@xmath8 region , though potentially providing a consistency check , is likely to be less useful than the pad approach .
the former requires small - error data at as low as possible @xmath8 ( something more difficult to accomplish in practice ) while , as shown in sec .
[ sec3a ] , a @xmath110_h$ ] pad representation obtained by fitting to good quality data restricted to the somewhat higher region of @xmath8 between approximately @xmath6 and @xmath62 gev@xmath7 can be employed to obtain a sufficiently accurate value for @xmath54 $ ] out to @xmath121 gev@xmath7 . the pad approach , whether implemented through moments or through fitting , is thus likely to be a more favorable one from a practical point of view . to summarize the conclusions of this subsection
, we have shown that , in the region @xmath195
gev@xmath7 , use of nn@xmath177lo chpt provides a representation of the subtracted polarization accurate enough to allow the evaluation of @xmath196 gev@xmath64 $ ] with a systematic error at the sub - percent level . because lattice data at @xmath8 values below 0.1 gev@xmath7 will be required to reach this level
, however , use of this chpt - inspired fit form is likely to produce results for @xmath196 gev@xmath64 $ ] with larger errors than those obtained from pad - based approaches .
we conclude this subsection with a brief discussion of the low-@xmath8 @xmath197 contributions to @xmath11 .
as discussed above , the nn@xmath177lo fits to the model @xmath25 data fix the lecs @xmath155 and @xmath176 .
it turns out that at nnlo the related subtracted vector isoscalar polarization function , @xmath38 , is determined by the same set of lecs as is @xmath25 @xcite .
this statement remains true of the nn@xmath177lo form as well .
arise at nnnlo from terms in the effective lagrangian involving six derivatives and no quark - mass factors .
such terms will produce @xmath198-flavor - symmetric contributions to the vector current two - point functions . ]
the chiral fit thus also provides us with what should be an accurate expectation for the behavior of @xmath38 in the low-@xmath8 region . in the isospin limit
, @xmath38 determines the @xmath197 contribution to @xmath11 via in the @xmath198-flavor limit , with @xmath25 the subtracted polarization for the flavor @xmath199 @xmath4 vector current . ]
@xmath200^{i=0}\ , = \ , -2\alpha^2\ , \int_0^\infty dq^2\,f(q^2)\ , { \frac{1}{3}}\ , { \hat{\pi}^{i=0}}(q^2)\ .
\label{amuieq0}\ ] ] fig .
[ fig9 ] shows the nn@xmath177lo expectation for the product @xmath201 appearing in the integrand of eq .
( [ amuieq0 ] ) .
the corresponding @xmath4 product @xmath202 is included for comparison .
it is clear that , though the @xmath8 dependence of the two is not identical , the behavior of the @xmath197 integrand is sufficiently similar to that of the @xmath4 integrand that our conclusions regarding the low-@xmath8 @xmath4 contribution to @xmath11 will also hold for the @xmath197 contribution .
we have shown that the problem of determining the lo hvp contribution to @xmath203 on the lattice can be profitably approached through a hybrid strategy in which contributions from @xmath204 are evaluated by direct trapezoid rule numerical integration of lattice data for the subtracted polarization and those from the low-@xmath8 region , @xmath205 , by other methods .
existing lattice data produced in simulations using periodic boundary conditions , even without further improvements such as ama and/or the use of twisted boundary conditions , are already sufficiently precise to allow the @xmath204 contributions to be obtained with systematic and statistical errors well below @xmath5 of @xmath11 for @xmath130 as low as @xmath6 gev@xmath7 . in evaluating contributions from the region of @xmath8 below @xmath206 gev@xmath7 ,
we have shown , by studying a physical model of the @xmath4 vector polarization function , that low - order pad s , conformally mapped polynomials , as well as nn@xmath177lo chpt ( nnlo chpt supplemented by an additional curvature contribution whose physical origin is understood ) provide forms capable of representing the subtracted polarization with sufficient accuracy to reduce the systematic uncertainty arising from computing @xmath207 $ ] using these forms to a level well below @xmath5 of @xmath32 . in the case of the low - order pad s , this conclusion remains in force for @xmath130 out to beyond @xmath62 gev@xmath7 .
in contrast , systematic errors associated with the use of the nn@xmath177lo chpt form grow to about @xmath189 of @xmath32 for @xmath208 gev@xmath7 .
a promising approach to the low-@xmath8 region , from a systematic point of view , appears to be that involving the pad s constructed from the derivatives of the polarization function with respect to @xmath8 at @xmath37 .
these derivatives can be obtained from time moments of the zero - spatial - momentum two - point function @xcite .
the hybrid approach allows use of a lower order than would otherwise be possible , with the @xmath70_h$ ] pad already being sufficient to produce a systematic error on the determination of @xmath209 $ ] safely below @xmath5 for @xmath130 out to beyond @xmath62 gev@xmath7 .
reducing the order of the pad employed has the advantage of reducing the order to which the time moments must be evaluated with good accuracy , and thus represents a practical advantage in view of the expectation that light - quark moment errors will grow rapidly with increasing order .
constructing the @xmath70_h$ ] pad requires moments only out to sixth order .
in contrast , evaluating the contribution to @xmath32 out to @xmath210 gev@xmath7 with sub - percent accuracy , would require at least the @xmath106_h$ ] pad , and hence time moments out to at least tenth order .
we have also shown that a multi - point implementation of the pad approach @xcite , in which the parameters of the pad s are fit rather than obtained from moments , is also feasible .
this version has the advantage that , with sufficiently good data , it can be successfully implemented using only data from the region of @xmath8 between approximately @xmath6 and @xmath62 gev@xmath7 , where lattice data errors are typically significantly smaller than at lower @xmath8 .
to reach sub - percent accuracy in this implementation , however , requires going to the @xmath110_h$ ] pad.$ ] pad in the notation of ref .
@xcite . ]
the approach using polynomials in the conformally transformed variable @xmath134 also looks promising , provided again that moment evaluations of the derivatives of @xmath19 with respect to @xmath8 at @xmath37 reach a sufficient level of accuracy . if one is forced to estimate the polynomial coefficients by fitting , however , this approach looks less favorable than the corresponding pad approach . while in principal also usable , the chpt - based approach appears to us to require better lattice data to reach the same level of precision than do the two pad approaches .
this is a consequence of ( i ) the necessity of performing the nn@xmath177lo fits on intervals restricted to @xmath211 gev@xmath7 if one wishes to keep the associated systematic errors at the sub - percent level , and ( ii ) the fact that errors on lattice data are typically significantly larger below @xmath168 gev@xmath7 than they are in the interval between @xmath6 and @xmath62 gev@xmath7 .
current low-@xmath8 lattice data are not yet sufficiently precise to produce sub - percent level statistical errors on the low-@xmath8 contributions @xmath212 $ ] . to understand what might be required to reach the desired precision , it is convenient to consider the case of the moment approach , specifically the @xmath70_h$ ] pad representation of the subtracted polarization , @xmath213 which we know is sufficient to produce systematic uncertainties well below @xmath5 . errors @xmath214 and @xmath215 on the parameters @xmath216 and @xmath217 produce associated errors @xmath218\ , & & = \ , -4\alpha^2\ , \int_0^{q_{min}^2}dq^2\ , f(q^2)\ , \left ( { \frac{q^2}{1+b_1q^2}}\right)\delta a_1\ , \nonumber\\ \delta_{b_1}a_\mu^{lo , hvp}[q_{min}^2]\ , & & = \ , -4\alpha^2\ , \int_0^{q_{min}^2}dq^2\ , f(q^2)\ , \left ( { -\frac{a_1q^4}{(1+b_1q^2)^2}}\right)\delta b_1\ .
\label{pade11errors}\end{aligned}\ ] ] on @xmath212 $ ] .
let us now consider the @xmath4 analogue , for which we can quantify these uncertainties using our @xmath26-data - based model .
taking the central values for @xmath216 and @xmath217 from the @xmath70_h$ ] pad version obtained from the derivatives of the model polarization with respect to @xmath8 at @xmath37 , scaling the errors , as usual , by @xmath32 , and defining @xmath219 $ ] and @xmath220 $ ] by @xmath221}{\hat{a}_\mu^{\rm lo , hvp } } } \ , & & = \
, c_{a_1}[a_1,b_1,q^2_{min}]\ , { \frac{\delta a_1}{a_1}}\nonumber\\ { \frac{\delta_{b_1}\hat{a}_\mu^{\rm lo , hvp}[q_{min}^2]}{\hat{a}_\mu^{\rm lo , hvp } } } \ , & & = \ , c_{b_1}[a_1,b_1,q^2_{min}]\ , { \frac{\delta b_1}{b_1}}\ , \label{scalederrordefns}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we find , for example , that @xmath222 & = & 0.818\ , \nonumber\\ c_{b_1}[a_1,b_1,\ , 0.1\ \mbox{gev}^2 ] & = & -0.0488\ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath223 & = & 0.913\ , \nonumber\\ c_{b_1}[a_1,b_1,\ , 0.2\ \mbox{gev}^2 ] & = & -0.0724\ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] it follows that a sub - percent error on @xmath216 will be sufficient to obtain a sub - percent error on @xmath207 $ ] for @xmath224 gev@xmath7 , provided the errors on @xmath217 remain at the few percent level , regardless of how correlated the fit parameters @xmath216 and @xmath217 might be .
the parameter @xmath216 is determined by the slope of the subtracted polarization with respect to @xmath8 at @xmath37 , and @xmath217 by the ratio of the curvature to the slope .
a useful rule - of - thumb goal emerging from this exercise is thus that , to reach the sub - percent error level , one should aim at reducing the error on the slope parameter @xmath216 , whether obtained from the fourth - order time moment , or from fitting , to the sub - percent level .
further quantitative studies using our @xmath26-based model will become possible once covariance matrices associated with ama - improved data with twisted boundary conditions become available .
this will allow us to construct fake data sets based on the model but with realistic errors and correlations from the point of view of the lattice .
we like to thank christopher aubin , tom blum and taku izubuchi , as well as other participants of the mainz institute of theoretical physics workshop on the muon @xmath225 for useful discussions .
the authors would like to thank the mainz institute for theoretical physics ( mitp ) for its hospitality and support , and km and sp thank the department of physics and astronomy of san francisco state university for hospitality as well .
mg is supported in part by the us department of energy , km is supported by a grant from the natural sciences and engineering research council of canada , and sp is supported by cicytfeder - fpa2011 - 25948 , sgr2009 - 894 , and the spanish consolider - ingenio 2010 program cpan ( csd2007 - 00042 ) .
see , for instance , f. jegerlehner and a. nyffeler , phys .
rept . *
477 * , 1 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0902.3360 [ hep - ph ] ] ; m. davier , a. hcker , b. malaescu and z.q .
zhang , eur .
j. c * 71 * , 1515 ( 2011 ) [ erratum - ibid .
c * 72 * , 1874 ( 2012 ) ] [ arxiv:1010.4180 [ hep - ph ] ] ; t. blum , a. denig , i. logashenko , e. de rafael , b. lee roberts , t. teubner and g. venanzoni , arxiv:1311.2198 [ hep - ph ] , and references therein .
t. aoyama , m. hayakawa , t. kinoshita and m. nio , phys .
109 * , 111808 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1205.5370 [ hep - ph ] ] .
r. r. akhmetshin _ et al . _
[ cmd-2 collaboration ] , phys .
* b648 * , 28 ( 2007 ) [ hep - ex/0610021 ] . m. n. achasov , k. i. beloborodov , a. v. berdyugin , a. g. bogdanchikov , a. v. bozhenok , a. d. bukin , d. a. bukin and t. v. dimova , _ et al .
_ , j. exp .
* 103 * , 380 ( 2006 ) [ zh . eksp .
fiz . * 130 * , 437 ( 2006 ) ] [ hep - ex/0605013 ] . j. p. lees , _ et al . _ [ babar collaboration ] , phys .
rev . * d86 * , 032013 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1205.2228 [ hep - ex ] ] .
d. babusci , _ et al . _
[ kloe collaboration ] , phys .
* b720 * , 336 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1212.4524 [ hep - ex ] ] .
for a recent review , see t. blum , m. hayakawa and t. izubuchi , pos lattice * 2012 * , 022 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1301.2607 [ hep - lat ] ] .
t. blum , phys .
lett . * 91 * , 052001 ( 2003 ) [ hep - lat/0212018 ] . c. aubin and t. blum , phys .
rev . * d75 * , 114502 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - lat/0608011 ] .
x. feng , k. jansen , m. petschlies and d. b. renner , phys .
lett . * 107 * , 081802 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1103.4818 [ hep - lat ] ] ; x. feng , g. hotzel , k. jansen , m. petschlies and d. b. renner , pos lattice * 2012 * , 174 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1211.0828 [ hep - lat ] ] .
p. boyle , l. del debbio , e. kerrane and j. zanotti , phys .
rev . * d85 * , 074504 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1107.1497 [ hep - lat ] ] .
m. della morte , b. jger , a. jttner and h. wittig , jhep * 1203 * , 055 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1112.2894 [ hep - lat ] ] ; pos lattice * 2012 * , 175 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1211.1159 [ hep - lat ] ] . c. aubin , t. blum , m. golterman and s. peris , phys . rev .
d * 86 * , 054509 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1205.3695 [ hep - lat ] ] .
g. m. de divitiis , r. petronzio and n. tantalo , phys .
b * 718 * , 589 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1208.5914 [ hep - lat ] ] .
x. feng , s. hashimoto , g. hotzel , k. jansen , m. petschlies and d. b. renner , phys . rev . *
d88 * , 034505 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1305.5878 [ hep - lat ] ] .
a. francis , b. jger , h. b. meyer and h. wittig , phys . rev .
* d88 * , 054502 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1306.2532 [ hep - lat ] ] . c. aubin , t. blum , m. golterman and s. peris , phys .
d88 * , 074505 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1307.4701 [ hep - lat ] ] . f. burger , x. feng , g. hotzel , k. jansen , m. petschlies and d. b. renner , jhep * 1402 * , 099 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1308.4327 [ hep - lat ] ] .
m. golterman , k. maltman and s. peris , phys . rev . *
d88 * , 114508 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1309.2153 [ hep - ph ] ] .
h. horch , g. herdoiza , b. jger , h. wittig , m. della morte and a. jttner , pos lattice * 2013 * , 304 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1311.6975 [ hep - lat ] ] .
b. chakraborty , _ et al .
_ , arxiv:1403.1778 [ hep - lat ] .
b. e. lautrup , a. peterman and e. de rafael , phys .
rept . * 3 * , 193 ( 1972 ) .
t. blum , t. izubuchi and e. shintani , phys .
d * 88 * , 094503 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1208.4349 [ hep - lat ] , arxiv:1208.4349 [ hep - lat ] ] .
e. shintani , _ et al .
_ , arxiv:1402.0244 [ hep - lat ] .
r. barate , _ et al . _
[ aleph collaboration ] , z. phys . *
c76 * , 15 ( 1997 ) ; r. barate , _ et al . _
[ aleph collaboration ] , eur .
j * c4 * , 409 ( 1998 ) ; s. schael _
[ aleph collaboration ] , phys .
rep . * 421 * , 191 ( 2005 ) [ hep - ex/0506072 ] .
k. ackerstaff _ et al . _
[ opal collaboration ] , eur .
j. * c7 * , 571 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ex/9808019 ] .
d. boito , _ et al .
_ , phys . rev . *
d85 * , 093015 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1203.3146 ( hep - ph ) ] .
a. baikov , k. g. chetyrkin and j. h. khn , phys .
* 101 * ( 2008 ) 012002 [ arxiv:0801.1821 [ hep - ph ] ] . o. cat , m. golterman and s. peris , jhep * 0508 * , 076 ( 2005 ) [ hep - ph/0506004 ] ; phys . rev . *
d77 * , 093006 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0803.0246 [ hep - ph ] ] .
b. blok , m. a. shifman and d. x. zhang , phys .
rev . * d57 * , 2691 ( 1998 ) [ erratum - ibid . * d59 * , 019901 ( 1999 ) ] [ arxiv : hep - ph/9709333 ] ; i. i. y. bigi , m. a. shifman , n. uraltsev , a. i. vainshtein , phys .
rev . * d59 * , 054011 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ph/9805241 ] ; m. a. shifman , [ hep - ph/0009131 ] ; m. golterman , s. peris , b. phily , e. de rafael , jhep * 0201 * , 024 ( 2002 ) [ hep - ph/0112042 ] .
j. gasser and h. leutwyler , ann .
phys . * 158 * , 142 ( 1984 ) .
j. gasser and h. leutwyler , nucl .
b250 * , 465 ( 1985 ) .
e. golowich and j. kambor , nucl .
b * 447 * , 373 ( 1995 ) [ hep - ph/9501318 ] .
g. amoros , j. bijnens and p. talavera , nucl . phys . *
b568 * , 319 ( 2000 ) [ hep - ph/9907264 ] .
j. bijnens , g. colangelo and g. ecker , jhep * 02 * , 020 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ph/9902437 ] ; ann .
phys . * 280 * , 100 ( 2000 ) [ hep - ph/9907333 ] .
j. bijnens and p. talavera , jhep * 0203 * , 046 ( 2002 ) [ hep - ph/0203049 ] . g. ecker , j. gasser , a. pich and e. de rafael , nucl . phys .
* b321 * 311 ( 1989 ) . | a reliable evaluation of the integral giving the hadronic vacuum polarization contribution to the muon anomalous magnetic moment should be possible using a simple trapezoid - rule integration of lattice data for the subtracted electromagnetic current polarization function in the euclidean momentum interval @xmath0 , coupled with an @xmath1-parameter pad or other representation of the polarization in the interval @xmath2 , for sufficiently high @xmath3 and sufficiently large @xmath1 . using a physically motivated model for the @xmath4 polarization , and the covariance matrix from a recent lattice simulation to generate associated fake `` lattice data , ''
we show that systematic errors associated with the choices of @xmath3 and @xmath1 can be reduced to well below the @xmath5 level for @xmath3 as low as @xmath6 gev@xmath7 and rather small @xmath1 .
for such low @xmath3 , both an nnlo chiral representation with one additional nnnlo term and a low - order polynomial expansion employing a conformally transformed variable also provide representations sufficiently accurate to reach this precision for the low-@xmath8 contribution .
combined with standard techniques for reducing other sources of error on the lattice determination , this hybrid strategy thus looks to provide a promising approach to reaching the goal of a sub - percent precision determination of the hadronic vacuum polarization contribution to the muon anomalous magnetic moment on the lattice . |
neutrino flavor oscillations in vacuum @xcite represent a viable solution @xcite to the observed deficit of the solar neutrino flux @xcite as compared to the predictions of the standard solar model @xcite .
if the oscillations have a wavelength comparable to the earth orbit radius ( just - so oscillations @xcite ) , then significant distortions could arise both in the neutrino energy spectrum @xcite ( as a result of the energy - dependence of the oscillation probability ) and in the time structure of the signal @xcite ( as a result of the earth s orbit eccentricity @xcite ) .
the combination of these two effects , namely time - dependent spectral distortions , could also be observable @xcite .
the four pioneering solar neutrino experiments have not observed such effects .
the three radiochemical experiments @xcite can not observe _ a priori _ spectral distortions since they detect only energy - integrated signals @xcite , and do not show evidence for periodic variations of the detected rates associable to just - so oscillations ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) . the neutrino - electron scattering experiment kamiokande @xcite shows no evidence for distortions in the spectrum of the scattered electrons @xcite either . however , these are low - statistics experiments , and possible vacuum oscillation effects could be hidden by the relatively large uncertainties . much higher statistics ( thousands of events per year ) will be collected with the second - generation experiments superkamiokande @xcite and sudbury neutrino observatory ( sno ) @xcite .
these real - time experiments can test variations in the time structure of the signal , as well as deviations of the solar neutrino energy spectrum from its standard shape .
in particular , information about the @xmath1b solar neutrino spectrum @xmath2 @xcite can be gained through the observation of the electron spectrum @xcite from the reactions @xmath3
\nu_e + d & \;\rightarrow\ ; & p+p + e^- \text { ( sno)}\ .
\label{eq : snoreac}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in this work we study a specific signal of just - so oscillations which involves both time variations and shape distortions of the electron kinetic energy spectrum expected at superkamiokande and sno .
we propose to separate the events detected when the earth is nearest to the sun ( perihelion @xmath0 3 months ) from those detected when the earth is farthest from the sun ( aphelion @xmath0 3 months ) . in sec .
ii we introduce a near - far asymmetry @xmath4 , which is non - zero if just - so oscillations occur . in sec .
iii and iv we apply our calculations of @xmath4 to the kinetic energy spectra of electrons in the superkamiokande and sno experiments respectively .
we show how the sensitivity to the neutrino oscillation parameters can be increased by probing the near - far asymmetry in selected parts of the electron energy spectra . in sec .
v we summarize our work and draw our conclusions .
some technical aspects of our calculations are discussed in the appendices a and b.
in this section we define the near - far asymmetry @xmath4 , introduce briefly the notation for two - family and three - family neutrino oscillations , and express @xmath4 as a function of the neutrino mass - mixing parameters .
details of the calculation are reported in appendix a. the earth orbit radius , @xmath5 , varies periodically around its average value , @xmath6 km , according to @xmath7 where @xmath8 is the orbit eccentricity , and @xmath9 is the orbital phase ( @xmath10 , @xmath11 at the perihelion ) .
variations of @xmath5 with the neutrino production point in the sun are negligible for our purposes ( see appendix b ) . along the earth s orbit ,
the intercepted neutrino flux @xmath12 varies as : @xmath13 let us divide the orbit in two parts , a `` near '' half ( centered at the perihelion , january 4th ) and a `` far '' half ( centered at the aphelion , july 4th ) : @xmath14\ , \\[2 mm ] \text{``far '' semi - orbit } & \;=\;&\text{aphelion $ \pm$ 3 months}\nonumber\\ & \;\rightarrow\;&\vartheta\in [ \pi/2,\,3\pi/2]\ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ eq : semiorbit ] if no oscillations occur , the flux of solar @xmath15 is subject only to a geometrical variation [ eq . ( [ eq : squarelaw ] ) ] . in this case
, the integrated neutrino rate in the near semi - orbit is enhanced by a geometric factor @xmath16 : @xmath17 analogously , the integrated neutrino rate in the far semi - orbit is suppressed by a geometric factor @xmath18 .
it is useful to factorize out this overall geometric correction from the observations and define , if also the background were known in real time and subtracted .
however , background subtraction is better defined for time - integrated signals .
therefore , we prefer to factorize the half - year averaged geometric correction @xmath19 from the integrated rate , instead of factorizing the instantaneous correction @xmath20 from the real - time rate . ]
@xmath21 f&=&\frac{\text{no.~of events in the far semi - orbit}}{1 - 4\varepsilon/\pi}\ .
\label{eq : far}\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ eq : counts ] `` event '' is referred here to as the observation of a solar neutrino induced electron .
the relevant reactions are eq .
( [ eq : skreac ] ) for superkamiokande ( neutrino scattering ) and eq .
( [ eq : snoreac ] ) for sno ( neutrino absorption ) . both experiments can measure the kinetic energy , @xmath22 , of the scattered or recoil electrons through the cherenkov light .
the `` no . of events '' in eq .
( [ eq : counts ] ) may refer either to the whole electron energy spectrum , @xmath23 , or to a selected part of it .
the first option has the advantage of higher statistics ; the second is useful to study possible time - dependent spectral distortions .
the formalism that will be used in sections ii b and ii c is the same in both cases .
further specifications about the electron energy spectrum will be made in sections iii and iv .
we define a near - far asymmetry as @xmath24 the statistical error of @xmath4 , as derived by applying the binomial statistics to the `` near '' and `` far '' classes of events , is @xmath25 , where @xmath26 .
sistematic errors can be expected to cancel to a large fraction in a ratio of rates such as @xmath27 .
the asymmetry @xmath4 is zero if no neutrino oscillations occur , or if oscillations independent of @xmath5 take place .
therefore , a non - zero value of @xmath4 would be a signature of just - so oscillations .
notice that @xmath4 is independent of the solar model and , in particular , of the absolute @xmath1b neutrino flux . in the presence of just - so oscillations ,
the asymmetry @xmath4 is a function of the neutrino mass - mixing parameters .
we consider two cases : two - family @xmath28 oscillations , and three - family @xmath29 oscillations with only one relevant mass scale .
in the two - family case , the electron neutrino @xmath15 is a mixture of two mass eigenstates @xmath30 and @xmath31 , with masses @xmath32 and @xmath33 respectively : @xmath34 \delta m^2 = |m^2_2-m^2_1|\ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath35 is the @xmath36 mixing angle , @xmath37 , and @xmath38 . the @xmath15 survival probability , @xmath39 , is then given by @xmath40 where @xmath41 \lambda_\nu=\frac{4\pi e}{\delta m^2}&= & \text { oscillation length}\ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath42 is the neutrino energy . in the case of three - family neutrino oscillations ,
the state @xmath15 is a mixture of @xmath30 , @xmath31 , and @xmath43 : @xmath44 where @xmath45 and @xmath46 in the standard parametrization of the mixing matrix @xcite .
we make the simplificative hypothesis that the mass gap between @xmath43 and the doublet @xmath47 is very large : @xmath48 .
this hypothesis holds , for instance , if one assumes that @xmath49 is in the range ( @xmath50 ev@xmath51 ) probed by accelerator , reactor , and atmospheric neutrino experiments @xcite . with this assumption
the @xmath49-driven fast oscillations are averaged away , and the @xmath52 survival probability is given by ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) @xmath53 with @xmath54 as in eq .
( [ eq : p2nu ] ) .
a useful representation of the @xmath52 parameter space @xmath55 has been given in @xcite in terms of a `` unitarity triangle . ''
we refer the reader to @xcite for a description of this representation , which will be used to display some of the results in sections iii and iv . in summary : @xmath56 \text{$2\nu$ oscillations}&\;\rightarrow\ ; & a^{2\nu}_{nf}=a^{2\nu}_{nf}(\delta m^2,\,\omega)\ , \label{eq : a2}\\[2 mm ] \text{$3\nu$ oscillations}&\;\rightarrow\ ; & a^{3\nu}_{nf}=a^{3\nu}_{nf}(\delta m^2,\,\omega,\,\phi)\ .\label{eq : a3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the next section we give explicit formulas for eqs .
( [ eq : a2 ] ) and ( [ eq : a3 ] ) . the rates @xmath57 and @xmath58 in eq .
( [ eq : counts ] ) are integrated over a half - year and over all , or part , of the electron energy spectrum .
it follows that the calculation of @xmath4 involves a time integration over the near and far semiorbits , as well as an energy integration weighted by the @xmath1b neutrino spectrum , @xmath2 , and by the @xmath15 and @xmath59 ( @xmath60 ) cross sections , @xmath61 and @xmath62 respectively . in the calculation ,
we discard terms of @xmath63 , but we keep all powers in @xmath64 since @xmath65 may be large
. we also neglect the very small smearing effect over the neutrino production region ( see appendix b ) .
it turns out that the time integration in the two semiorbits can be done analytically , leaving only a numerical integration over @xmath42 to be performed .
we refer the reader to appendix a for the derivation of the final results , that can be expressed in compact form as @xmath66 for @xmath67 oscillations , and as @xmath68 for @xmath52 oscillations . the functions @xmath69 and @xmath70 and the factor @xmath71 in eqs . ( [ eq : a2nu ] ) and ( [ eq : a3nu ] ) are defined as @xmath72\ , f(\delta m^2/e ) } { \int\!de\,\lambda(e)\,\sigma_e(e)}\ , \label{eq : f}\\[2 mm ] g(\delta m^2 ) & = & \frac { \int\!de\,\lambda(e)\,[\sigma_e(e)-\sigma_x(e)]\ , g(\delta m^2/e ) } { \int\!de\,\lambda(e)\,\sigma_e(e)}\ , \label{eq : g}\\[2 mm ] r & = & \frac { \int\!de\,\lambda(e)\,[\sigma_e(e)-\sigma_x(e ) ] } { \int\!de\,\lambda(e)\,\sigma_e(e)}\ , \label{eq : r}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath73 and @xmath74 are non - dimensional functions of @xmath75 ( @xmath76 ) : @xmath77 g & = & \frac{4\varepsilon}{\pi}c + s { \bf h}_0(\varepsilon kl ) -2\varepsilon c { \bf h}_1(\varepsilon kl ) -\frac{4\varepsilon}{\pi } c j_0 ( \varepsilon kl ) \label{eq : g}\ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath78 , @xmath79 . in eqs .
( [ eq : f ] ) and ( [ eq : g ] ) , @xmath80 and @xmath81 are the bessel and struve functions @xcite of order 0 and 1 , respectively .
computer routines for the numerical calculation of these special functions can be found in @xcite .
figure 1 shows the functions @xmath73 and @xmath74 in the relevant range @xmath82 $ ] ev@xmath51/mev .
these functions are detector - independent .
the calculation of @xmath58 and @xmath83 from eqs .
( [ eq : f ] ) and ( [ eq : g ] ) requires instead detector - dependent ingredients such as the interaction cross - sections .
these ingredients are discussed in sec .
iii and iv for superkamiokande and sno , respectively .
in this section we calculate the expected values of @xmath4 for superkamiokande in the presence of @xmath67 and @xmath52 oscillations . the superkamiokande experiment @xcite makes use of a 22 kton ( fiducial volume ) water - cherenkov detector to observe the electrons scattered by solar neutrinos through reaction ( [ eq : skreac ] ) .
the _ measured _ kinetic energy of the electron , @xmath22 , is expected to be distributed around the _ true _ electron energy , @xmath84 , according to the following energy resolution function @xcite : @xmath85\ , \label{eq : resol}\ ] ] where the energy - dependent one - sigma width @xmath86 scales as @xmath87 due to the photon statistics , @xmath88 and the nominal width at 10 mev is @xmath89 mev @xcite .
if the experiment works as expected , a high signal - to - noise ratio will be achieved for @xmath90 mev @xcite .
we adopt @xmath91 mev as a nominal threshold in our analysis . the neutrino cross section for the reaction ( [ eq : skreac ] )
is known to the first order in the radiative corrections @xcite , both for @xmath92 and for @xmath93 @xmath94 .
the standard electron spectrum @xmath23 expected in superkamiokande in the absence of oscillations is given by @xmath95 where @xmath2 is the neutrino spectrum , @xmath96 is the maximum _ true _ kinetic energy allowed by kinematics @xcite , @xmath97 is given in eq .
( [ eq : resol ] ) , and @xmath98 is the @xmath15 differential cross section @xcite .
figure 2 shows the standard spectrum @xmath23 for superkamiokande . as we will see in sec .
iii c , it is also useful to consider selected parts of the electron energy spectrum ( bins ) .
an illustrative choice of bins is shown in fig . 2 .
the first five bins have a width of 1 mev .
the sixth bin collects all events with @xmath99 mev . in the presence of oscillations
, we will calculate the asymmetry @xmath4 using both the total number of events in the spectrum , and the number of events collected in each of the six bins shown in fig . 2 .
the loss of statistics is then traded for an increased sensitivity to the neutrino mass - mixing parameters ( see sec .
iii c ) .
it is useful to introduce a `` reduced '' @xmath15 cross - section for the @xmath100-th bin , @xmath101 , defined as the cross section for a @xmath15 of energy @xmath42 to produce an electron with a _ measured _ energy falling in the @xmath100-th bin range @xmath102 $ ] : @xmath103 an analogous definition can be given for the @xmath59 reduced cross - sections , @xmath104 .
the total cross section @xmath105 for producing an electron with measured energy above the nominal threshold ( @xmath91 mev ) and including the finite energy resolution is : @xmath106 the total cross sections @xmath107 and @xmath108 , or the binned cross sections @xmath101 and @xmath104 , enter the calculation of @xmath4 through the integrals in eqs.([eq : f])([eq : r ] ) , where they are always weighted by the @xmath1b neutrino spectrum @xmath2 . in fig .
3 we show the products @xmath109 ( upper panel ) and @xmath110 ( lower panel ) as a function of @xmath42 .
the curve in the upper panel thus represents the @xmath15 spectrum contribution to the whole electron spectrum in superkamiokande .
analogously , the curves in the lower panel represent the @xmath15 spectrum contribution to each of the six bins shown in fig . 2 . ( not shown in fig .
3 ) would be similar to the @xmath111 curves , but scaled by a factor @xmath112 in height . ]
notice that , although the width of the first five electron energy bins is 1 mev , the corresponding width of the @xmath110 curves is much larger , indicating that there is no tight relation between the measured electron energy @xmath22 and the energy @xmath42 of the parent neutrino .
this is due both to the smearing effect of the energy resolution function [ eq . ( [ eq : resol ] ) ] and to the fact that the differential cross section @xmath113 for @xmath114-@xmath115 scattering is rather flat in @xmath22 @xcite .
the finite energy resolution also allows non - zero values of @xmath110 for @xmath116 . nevertheless , from fig .
3 we learn that it is possible to `` tune , '' to some extent , the typical neutrino energy relevant to @xmath4 by choosing the appropriate bin in the electron energy spectrum .
figure 4 shows curves of iso-@xmath4 ( @xmath117 ) for the unbinned ( whole spectrum ) case , in the presence of @xmath67 oscillations .
the curves are displayed in the usual @xmath118 plane , and are separated by steps of 0.5% in @xmath4 .
the maximum absolute value of @xmath4 ( @xmath119 ) is reached for @xmath120 and @xmath121 ev@xmath51 .
if the statistical errors dominate , a near - far effect of @xmath122 could be detected at superkamiokande after the first year of operation .
the near - far asymmetry can be either positive or negative ( solid and dotted curves , respectively ) .
the positive ( negative ) values of @xmath4 correspond to an energy - averaged @xmath15 survival probability @xmath123 decreasing ( increasing ) with the sun - earth distance .
@xmath4 is @xmath124 at the stationary points of @xmath123 , corresponding approximately to @xmath125 where @xmath126 is the oscillation length in terms of the typical neutrino energy @xmath127 ( @xmath128 mev for fig . 4 ) and @xmath129 is an integer .
the near - far asymmetry tends to zero also for large @xmath130 ( fast oscillations ) , for very small @xmath130 ( oscillation lengths much longer than @xmath131 ) , and for small @xmath132 ( small neutrino mixing ) . if eq .
( [ eq : zeros ] ) is fulfilled for a certain value of @xmath130 , no near - far asymmetry can be observed , independently of the value of @xmath132 . however , as noticed in the previous section , one can change the value of @xmath133 ( and thus the position of the zeros of @xmath4 ) by selecting the events in a specific bin of the electron energy spectrum . in fig .
5 we show curves of iso-@xmath4 calculated for the six bins indicated in fig . 2 .
the typical neutrino energy increases from bin 1 to bin 6 ( see fig . 3 ) and
correspondingly the sensitivity to higher @xmath130 increases .
the positions of the zeros of @xmath4 are also shifted from bin to bin , so that by using two or more bins no `` holes '' in the @xmath130-sensitivity are left .
notice that the near - far asymmetry can reach values as high as 3.5% in favorable cases of large mixing , and that the sensitivity to small mixing is increased in some bins . the comparison of figs .
4 and 5 shows that selecting some intervals ( bins ) of the electron energy spectrum helps to reach higher sensitivities to the neutrino oscillation parameters .
of course , the statistical ( and possibly the systematic ) uncertainties also increase when a subset of the total event sample is used .
an optimal sensitivity - to - uncertainty ratio can be assessed only after the detector performances and the results of the superkamiokande experiment are known in detail . as discussed in sec . ii b , we study @xmath52 oscillations in the simple case of one relevant mass scale .
the corresponding parameter space @xmath55 can be represented , for any fixed value of @xmath130 , through the `` triangular '' representation introduced in @xcite .
figure 6 shows curves of iso-@xmath4 @xmath134 in the triangular representation for @xmath135 ev@xmath51 and @xmath136 .
the calculations refer to the unbinned case ( whole spectrum ) .
we recall @xcite that a generic point in the triangle represents the electron - neutrino state @xmath15 , while the upper , lower right , and lower left corners represent the mass eigenstates @xmath43 , @xmath31 , and @xmath30 respectively .
the triangle is mapped by the ( non - orthogonal ) coordinates @xmath137 and @xmath138 . the asymmetry @xmath4 is maximal ( in absolute value ) on the lower side of the triangle , corresponding to pure @xmath67 oscillations between @xmath30 and @xmath31 . for @xmath139 ,
the @xmath15-@xmath43 mixing tends to suppress the near - far effect , since by hypothesis the oscillations driven by massive state @xmath43 are so fast to be averaged out , giving a time - independent contribution . in short , in order to have a large near - far asymmetry for @xmath52 oscillations , the @xmath35-mixing must be maximal and the @xmath140-mixing must be relatively small . in fig .
6 we have shown only two representative values of @xmath130 .
the range of @xmath130 to which @xmath4 is sensitive for @xmath52 oscillations would be practically the same as for @xmath67 oscillations .
the zeros of @xmath141 and @xmath142 are also reached at the same values of @xmath130 [ compare eqs .
( [ eq : a2nu ] ) and ( [ eq : a3nu ] ) ] .
these `` holes '' in the @xmath130-sensitivity can be `` closed , '' as in the @xmath67 case , by repeating the asymmetry measurement in selected bins of the electron energy spectrum .
in this section we calculate the expected values of @xmath4 at sno in the presence of @xmath67 and @xmath52 oscillations . the sno experiment @xcite makes use of a 1 kton heavy - water cherenkov detector to observe the recoil electrons from neutrino absorption in deuterium [ eq .
( [ eq : snoreac ] ) ] .
the discussion of the detector parameters would be very similar to superkamiokande ( sec .
iii a ) and is not repeated here .
we only report the adopted ( expected ) values for the resolution width at 10 mev , @xmath143 mev , and for the energy threshold , @xmath91 mev @xcite .
the cross section for neutrino absorption in deuterium has been studied in detail in several papers ( see @xcite and references therein ) . no relevant uncertainties are recognized at solar neutrino energies @xcite , apart from a @xmath144 error in the overall normalization that is irrelevant in a ratio of rates like @xmath4 .
a computer code for the calculation of the @xmath114-@xmath145 differential cross section is available in @xcite . the differential cross section @xmath146 for reaction ( [ eq : snoreac ] ) is sharply peaked in the electron energy ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) .
this feature represents a considerable advantage with respect to @xmath114-@xmath115 scattering in superkamiokande [ reaction ( [ eq : skreac ] ) ] , since it results in a tighter correlation between the electron energy @xmath22 and the parent neutrino energy @xmath42 .
figure 7 shows the standard ( i.e. , no oscillation ) electron spectrum for sno . in fig .
7 we also show , as in fig . 3 , the energy bins chosen to illustrate to near - far asymmetry effect in selected parts of the spectrum . figure 8 illustrates the @xmath22-@xmath42 correlation in sno .
this figure is analogous to fig . 4 , but with the appropriate sno neutrino cross - sections ( defined in analogy to eq .
( [ eq : reduce ] ) ) . by changing the electron energy bin ,
the spectrum @xmath147 of parents neutrinos contributing to that bin changes considerably .
the corresponding variations in superkamiokande ( fig .
4 ) are less pronounced .
therefore we expect a greater sensitivity to near - far effects in sno .
another advantage of sno is that the reaction ( [ eq : snoreac ] ) can be initiated only by electron neutrinos : @xmath148 @xmath94 .
it follows that the factor @xmath71 defined in eq .
( [ eq : r ] ) is equal to 1 .
figure 9 shows curves of iso-@xmath4 for sno ( unbinned case ) , in the @xmath67 oscillation plane @xmath118 .
the contours are separated by steps of @xmath149 in @xmath4 .
the shape of the curves in fig .
9 is similar to fig . 4 , since the typical neutrino energy is @xmath150 mev as in superkamiokande .
however , the absolute value of the asymmetry in sno is about twice as large as in superkamiokande , because of the tighter correlation between the observed electron spectrum and the parent neutrino spectrum , as discussed in sec .
iv b. the maximum absolute value of @xmath4 is @xmath151 .
figure 10 shows curves of iso-@xmath4 calculated for the six representative bins shown in fig . 7 . as for superkamiokande
, we note that by changing bin the @xmath130-position of the @xmath4 zeros changes , and higher sensitivities to low mixing angles can also be achieved . a comparison of figs
. 4 , 5 , 9 , and 10 , shows that the superkamiokande and the sno experiment can probe , through measurements of the near - far asymmetry , the range @xmath152 ev@xmath51 for sufficiently large mixing .
figure 11 shows curves of iso-@xmath4 for sno , in the presence of @xmath52 oscillations , for two representative values of @xmath130 . in fig .
11 the same triangular representation of fig . 6 is used .
the shape of the contours in fig .
11 ( sno ) and fig .
6 ( superkamiokande ) are similar , but the near - far asymmetry is larger in the sno experiment , for the same reason as in the @xmath67 case ( see sec .
we have studied the signals of just - so oscillations that can be observed in the superkamiokande and sno solar neutrino experiments by separating the events detected when the earth is nearest to the sun ( perihelion @xmath0 3 months ) from those detected when the earth is farthest from the sun ( aphelion @xmath0 3 months ) .
we have calculated the asymmetry @xmath4 between the near and far signals by factorizing out the trivial geometrical variation of the signal , and using the entire electron energy spectrum as well as representative spectrum bins .
the calculations involve the integration of the @xmath15 survival probability over time and energy .
the time integration over half - year can be performed analitically .
compact expressions for the near - far asymmetry have been given for @xmath67 and @xmath52 oscillations .
the value of @xmath4 is solar model independent , and is different from zero if just - so oscillations occur . in the case of @xmath67 oscillations
, it has been shown that measurements of the near - far asymmetry at sno and superkamiokande can probe the range @xmath153 ev@xmath51 for sufficiently large values of the mixing angle @xmath45 .
a similar range of @xmath130 and @xmath35 can be probed in the presence of @xmath52 oscillations with one relevant mass scale , provided that the second mixing angle @xmath46 is not large .
the sno experiment appears to be about twice as sensitive as superkamiokande to the near - far asymmetry , due to the different energetics of the @xmath114-@xmath145 absorption and @xmath114-@xmath115 scattering reactions . in both experiments , measurements of @xmath4 in selected bins of the electron energy spectrum
may increase the sensitivity to the neutrino oscillation parameters . since the selection of a bin implies a loss of statistics , the net gain of binning the spectrum in measurements of @xmath4 can be assessed only after the experiments have run for some time and the data and their uncertainties are well understood .
we thank p. i. krastev for useful discussions .
one of us ( b.f . ) thanks the dipartimento di fisica and sezione infn di bari for kind hospitality .
the work of e.l . was supported in part by infn and in part by the institute for advanced study through a hansmann membership .
this work has been performed under the auspices of the european theoretical astroparticle network ( tan ) .
in this appendix we prove the basic eqs .
( [ eq : a2nu ] ) and ( [ eq : a3nu ] ) for the near - far asymmetry . in the presence of oscillations , the expected value of the quantity @xmath57 in eq .
( [ eq : n ] ) is given by the sum of the @xmath15 and @xmath59 contributions @xmath154 where @xmath42 is the neutrino energy , @xmath2 is the @xmath1b neutrino spectrum , @xmath105 and @xmath155 are the @xmath15 and @xmath59 ( @xmath60 ) interaction cross - sections , and @xmath156 is the @xmath15 survival probability @xmath157 averaged over the near semiorbit : @xmath158 in the above equation , @xmath20 is given by eq .
( [ eq : squarelaw ] ) , and the denominator on the right hand side is equal to [ eq .
( [ eq : geofactor ] ) ] . for @xmath159 or @xmath160 [ eqs .
( [ eq : p2nu ] ) and ( [ eq : p3nu ] ) ] the numerator can be calculated analitically with the help of the following integrals @xcite : @xmath161 \frac{2}{\pi}\int_0^{\pi/2}\!\!\!d\vartheta \sin(x\cos\vartheta)&=&{\bf h}_0(x)\ , \\[2 mm ] \frac{2}{\pi}\int_0^{\pi/2}\!\!\!d\vartheta \cos\vartheta\sin(x\cos\vartheta)&=&j_1(x)\ , \\[2 mm ] \frac{2}{\pi}\int_0^{\pi/2}\!\!\!d\vartheta \cos\vartheta\cos(x\cos\vartheta)&=&\frac{2}{\pi}-{\bf h}_1(x)\ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath162 and @xmath163 are the bessel and struve functions @xcite of order @xmath129 : @xmath164 { \bf h}_n(x)&=&\left(\frac{1}{2}x\right)^{n+1}\sum_{m=0}^{\infty } \frac{(-1)^m\left(\frac{1}{2}x\right)^{2 m } } { \gamma(m+\frac{3}{2})\gamma(n+m+\frac{3}{2})}\ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] in particular , in the @xmath67 oscillation case the result of the integration is : or higher are neglected .
however , all powers of @xmath165 are kept , since @xmath165 can be of @xmath166 . ]
@xmath167 , \label{eq : bigintegral}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath78 , @xmath79 , and the argument of the functions @xmath162 and @xmath163 is @xmath64 . from eqs .
( [ eq : pn ] ) , ( [ eq : bigintegral ] ) , and ( [ eq : geofactor ] ) , it follows that @xmath168 where @xmath73 and @xmath74 are defined as in eqs .
( [ eq : f ] ) and ( [ eq : g ] ) .
the function @xmath73 ( @xmath74 ) is even ( odd ) in @xmath169 .
the analogous result for the far semiorbit can be simply obtained with the replacement @xmath170 : @xmath171 the derivation for the @xmath52 oscillation case is very similar to the @xmath67 case and gives : @xmath172 \overline{p}_{n}^{3\nu } & = & c^4_\phi+s^4_\phi-2c^4_\phi s^2_\omega c^2_\omega ( f+g)\ . \label{eq:4th}\end{aligned}\ ] ] finally , we group the cross - sections and the probabilities in the expression of near - far asymmetry [ see eqs .
( [ eq : asy ] ) and ( [ eq : near ] ) ] : @xmath173 and divide the numerator and the denominator of the above fraction by @xmath174 . then , using eqs .
( [ eq:1st])([eq:4th ] ) and the definitions in eqs .
( [ eq : f])([eq : r ] ) one easily obtains eqs .
( [ eq : a2nu ] ) and ( [ eq : a3nu ] ) .
in the calculation of @xmath4 we have neglected the effect of smearing the @xmath15 survival probability @xmath175 over @xmath1b neutrino production region in the sun @xcite . already in @xcite
it was recognized that this effect is negligible for just - so oscillations , since the typical oscillation length is much larger than the production region ( see also @xcite ) .
here we rederive and discuss this result in more detail .
let us chart the neutrino production region with polar coordinates @xmath176 , where the angle @xmath177 is zero along the line joining the center of the sun ( @xmath178 ) to the detector .
( the second polar angle is integrated out for the cylindrical symmetry of the problem . )
the distance @xmath179 between the generic neutrino production point and the detector is then given by @xmath180 we find that the @xmath1b neutrino source density in the standard solar model @xcite is approximated very well by the following gaussian distribution : @xmath181 where @xmath182 ( @xmath183 km ) . since @xmath184 , one can effectively take @xmath185 as upper limit in the radial integration , instead of @xmath186 . given eq .
( [ eq : ell1 ] ) and the functional form ( [ eq : rho ] ) for @xmath189 , the smearing of the neutrino oscillation factor @xmath190 [ eq . ( [ eq : p2nu ] ) ] over the production region can be performed analytically : @xmath191 therefore , the damping effect of the spatial smearing on the oscillating term can be absorbed in the exponential suppression factor of eq .
( [ eq : suppress ] ) . for @xmath192 mev and @xmath130 as high as @xmath193 ev@xmath51 , this suppression factor differs from 1 by only @xmath194 .
such a small difference is negligible for our purposes .
the smearing correction is even smaller than the corrections of the order @xmath195 , which can also be neglected in the calculation of the near - far asymmetry .
the idea of @xmath15-@xmath196 mixing @xcite was independently introduced also by y. katayama , k. matumoto , s. tanaka , and e. yamada , prog .
* 28 * , 675 ( 1962 ) ; z. maki , m. nakagawa , and s. sakata , _ ibid .
_ * 28 * , 870 ( 1962 ) .
a. acker , s. pakvasa , and j. pantaleone , phys .
d * 43 * , 1754 ( 1991 ) ; a. acker , a. b. balantekin , and f. loreti , phys .
d * 49 * , 328 ( 1994 ) .
e. calabresu , n. ferrari , g. fiorentini , and m. lissia , astropart .
phys . * 4 * , 159 ( 1995 ) .
r. davis , prog .
32 * , 13 ( 1994 ) ; b. t. cleveland _ et al .
_ , in _ neutrino 94 _ , proceedings of th 16th international conference on neutrino physics and astrophysics , eilat , israel , edited by a. dar , g. eilam , and m. gronau [ nucl .
b ( proc . suppl . )
* 31 * , 47 ( 1995 ) ] .
sage collaboration , j. s. nico _ et al .
_ , in _ ichep 94 _ , proceedings of the 27th international conference on high energy physics , glasgow , scotland , edited by p. j. bussey and i. knowles ( institute of physics publishing , bristol , 1995 ) vol .
ii , p. 965 ; j. n. abdurashitov _ et al .
_ , phys .
b * 328 * , 234 ( 1994 ) .
y. totsuka , in _
taup 95 _ , proceedings of the 4th international workshop on theoretical and phenomenological aspects of underground physics , toledo , spain , edited by a. morales , j. morales , and j. a. villar [ nucl .
b ( proc . suppl . ) * 48 * , 547 ( 1996 ) ] ; a. suzuki , in _ physics and astrophysics of neutrinos _ , edited by m. fukugita and a. suzuki ( springer - verlag , tokyo , 1994 ) , p. 414 .
sno collaboration , g. t. ewan _ et al .
_ , `` sudbury neutrino observatory proposal , '' report no
. sno-87 - 12 , 1987 ( unpublished ) ; `` scientific and technical description of the mark ii sno detector , '' edited by e. w. beier and d. sinclair , queen s university report no . sno-89 - 15 , 1989 ( unpublished ) ; a. b. mcdonald , proceedings of the 9th lake louise winter institute , edited by a. astbury _ et al . _ ( world scientific , singapore , 1994 ) , p. 1 .
fig . 1 .
the detector - independent functions @xmath73 and @xmath74 defined in the text .
fig . 2 .
superkamiokande : standard electron spectrum @xmath23 as a function of the measured electron kinetic energy @xmath22 .
the area under @xmath23 is normalized to 1 .
also shown are the ( numbered ) energy bins used in the analysis of @xmath4 .
superkamiokande : spectra of @xmath15 contributing to the entire standard electron spectrum of fig . 2 or to selected bins .
the neutrino spectra are weighted by the interaction cross sections , taking into account the detector threshold and the energy resolution function .
superkamiokande : curves of iso-@xmath4 for @xmath67 oscillations ( all bins ) .
superkamiokande : curves of iso-@xmath4 for @xmath67 oscillations ( separated bins ) . fig
superkamiokande : curves of iso-@xmath4 for @xmath52 oscillations ( all bins ) , for two representative values of @xmath130 .
the triangular representation is discussed in the text .
sno : standard electron spectrum @xmath23 as a function of the measured electron kinetic energy @xmath22 .
the area under @xmath23 is normalized to 1 .
also shown are the ( numbered ) energy bins used in the analysis of @xmath4 .
sno : spectra of @xmath15 contributing to the entire standard electron spectrum of fig . 7 or to selected bins .
the neutrino spectra are weighted by the interaction cross sections , taking into account the detector threshold and the energy resolution function .
sno : curves of iso-@xmath4 for @xmath67 oscillations ( all bins ) .
fig . 10 .
sno : curves of iso-@xmath4 for @xmath67 oscillations ( separated bins ) . fig . 11 .
sno : curves of iso-@xmath4 for @xmath52 oscillations ( all bins ) , for two representative values of @xmath130 .
the triangular representation is discussed in the text . | we propose to study possible signals of just - so oscillations in new - generation solar neutrino experiments by separating the events detected when the earth is nearest to the sun ( perihelion @xmath0 3 months ) from those detected when the earth is farthest from the sun ( aphelion @xmath0 3 months ) .
we introduce a solar model independent near - far asymmetry , which is non - zero if just - so oscillations occur .
we apply our calculations to the kinetic energy spectra of electrons induced by @xmath1b solar neutrino interactions in the superkamiokande and sudbury neutrino observatory experiments .
we show that the sensitivity to the neutrino oscillation parameters can be increased by probing the near - far asymmetry in selected parts of the electron energy spectra . |
in the accurate evaluation of atomic energy levels not only the nonrelativistic energy , but also relativistic and qed effects have to be calculated with the high precision .
the only approach which consistently accounts for all corrections in small atomic systems is the one based on the expansion of the energy in the fine structure constant @xmath0 @xmath1.\ ] ] each term in this expansion can be expressed as the expectation value of some effective hamiltonian with the nonrelativistic wave function .
namely @xmath2 is the nonrelativistic energy ( in atomic units ) , @xmath3 is the relativistic correction , which for states with the vanishing angular momentum is the expectation value of @xmath4 in eq .
( [ df_h4 ] ) .
@xmath5 and higher order corrections are expressed in terms of matrix elements of some more complicated operators .
they have been calculated for low lying states of the helium atom and helium - like ions up to the order @xmath6 @xcite , and for the particularly important case of @xmath7 splitting up to the order @xmath8 @xcite .
one of the sources of this achievement was the flexibility of the explicitly correlated exponential basis set , which due to its correct analytic properties , makes possible accurate evaluation of matrix elements with complicated and singular operators . in the case of the lithium atom and light lithium - like ions
all corrections up to @xmath5 have been accurately calculated @xcite , but not that of higher orders .
the principal reason for the much slower progress for three - electron atoms is the difficulty in handling integrals with explicitly correlated functions .
the commonly used explicitly correlated gaussian functions do not have right analytic properties , for example they do not satisfy the cusp condition , and therefore can not be used for the calculation of higher order relativistic corrections , like @xmath9 .
hylleraas basis functions have the right analytic behavior : the accuracy in solving the schrdinger equation is the highest among all other basis functions , but it is difficult to handle hylleraas integrals involving quadratic negative powers of two different interparticle distances .
such integrals appear in the evaluation of @xmath9 and for this reason other basis functions have been investigated in the literature .
zotev and rebane in @xcite were the first to apply exponentially correlated functions @xmath10 in variational calculations for ps@xmath11 and the other exotic molecules .
they have found a simplified formula for matrix elements of the nonrelativistic hamiltonian and presented numerical results of variational calculations with a few basis functions . in our recent paper
@xcite we presented an efficient algorithm for the evaluation of integrals involving powers of @xmath12 and @xmath13 @xmath14 with @xmath15 being nonnegative integers .
it is based on recursion relations which start from the master fromm - hill integral @xcite , where all @xmath16 .
we have applied this algorithm to the variational calculations of the ground state of li and be@xmath17 with up to 128 functions .
the comparison of nonrelativistic energies with the ones obtained with much larger number of hylleraas functions indicates that the exponential representation of the three - electron wave function is very efficient . the class of integrals in eq .
( [ df_g ] ) with nonnegative @xmath15 is sufficient for nonrelativistic energies @xcite .
however , it is not sufficient to calculate the leading relativistic effects described by breit - pauli hamiltonian , which for s - states takes the form @xmath18 its matrix elements involve an extended class of integrals with exactly one of @xmath15 equal to @xmath19 , and all others are nonnegative , while that for leading qed effects involve integrals with @xmath20 .
this is well known from calculations with hylleraas basis functions , where all @xmath21 in eq .
( [ df_g ] ) are equal to zero .
hylleraas extended integrals of that kind have been extensively studied in @xcite using multipole - type of expansions and recently by present authors using analytical recurrence approach @xcite .
both methods had been successfully applied in high - precision calculations of leading relativistic and qed corrections to the energy of lithiumlike systems @xcite .
there are no similar studies for exponentially correlated integrals to the best our knowledge , and for the first time we present them in this work . in the calculation of relativistic and qed effects beyond leading order , @xmath9 for example
, another class of integrals appears with two quadratic inverse powers of interparticle distances .
there are only few studies in the literature for three - electron hylleraas integrals @xcite .
the algorithm by king @xcite seems to be too slow for a large scale computation , where integrals with @xmath22 of order 30 have to be performed .
the evaluation of these integrals is quite difficult with the recursion method and have not yet been worked out so far . in the case of exponentially correlated integrals
the problem seems to be even more severe , since the master integral with @xmath23 is much more complicated .
however , being able to optimize nonlinear parameters of each function independly , one does not need to use large powers of interparticle distances in the basis set .
for s - states it is sufficient to use functions of the form ( [ df_phi ] ) . in such a case , having an analytical and thus accurate method for @xmath24 with nonnegative @xmath15 , inverse
negative powers of the interparticle distance can be obtained by the numerical integration with respect to the corresponding parameter @xmath25 or @xmath21 .
it however requires a good control of numerical accuracy of the master integral and of recursion relations in eq .
( [ df_rec ] ) .
the usage the higher precision arithmetic is essential in some critical areas of the integration .
a key feature of our numerical integration strategy is the adapted quadrature , which allows one to get the high accuracy with a very small number of points .
we demonstrate our method on examples with expectation value of various operators on lithium ground state .
results obtained for matrix elements involving single @xmath26 are compared to the most accurate ones obtained with the hylleraas basis set .
good numerical convergence of results for matrix elements involving two negative powers , for example @xmath27 .
indicate that this integration approach can be used for the calculation of higher order relativistic corrections , for example @xmath6 and @xmath8 effects in the hyperfine and fine structure of lithium - like systems .
an important property of integrals defined in eq .
( [ df_g ] ) is the tetrahedral symmetry which is equivalent to the permutation group @xmath28 .
we can assign vertices 1,2,3 to the electrons and 0 to the nucleus as shown in fig .
( [ fig_tetrahedron ] ) , and to edges we assign @xmath29 and @xmath15 parameters of a given integral .
the symmetry group @xmath28 corresponds to 24 renumbering of vertices 0,1,2 , and 3 , which means also a relevant change of parameters on the edges . ) , height=188 ] the generated symmetry relations allow us to reduce the number of recurrence formulas for slater integrals .
it is necessary to derive only one recurrence scheme , and the formulas for the advancement in the other indices can then be obtained by application of the @xmath28 symmetry .
the evaluation method for @xmath24 for the basis class with all nonnegative @xmath15 was first presented by harris in @xcite and later by us in ref .
@xcite . here
we present only a short summary , which is needed for the evaluation of the extended integrals .
the master integral @xmath30 satisfies the following differential equation @xmath31 where the @xmath28 symmetric polynomial @xmath32 is of the form @xmath33 and function @xmath34 is given by @xmath35 \ , \gamma(0,0,-1;u_1+w_2,u_3,u_2+w_1 ) \nonumber \\ & & -u_1\,w_1\,[(u_1 + u_3)^2 - w_2 ^ 2]\,\gamma(0,0,-1;u_1+u_3,w_2,w_1+w_3 ) \nonumber \\ & & + [ u_1 ^ 2\,w_1 ^ 2 + u_2 ^ 2\,w_2 ^ 2 - u_3 ^ 2\,w_3 ^ 2 + w_1\,w_2\,(u_1 ^ 2 + u_2 ^ 2 - w_3 ^ 2)]\,\gamma(0,0,-1;w_1+w_2,w_3,u_1+u_2 ) \nonumber \\ & & + [ u_1 ^ 2\,w_1 ^ 2 - u_2 ^ 2\,w_2 ^ 2 + u_3 ^ 2\,w_3 ^ 2 + w_1\,w_3\,(u_1 ^ 2 + u_3 ^ 2 - w_2 ^ 2)]\,\gamma(0,0,-1;w_1+w_3,w_2,u_1+u_3 ) \nonumber \\ & & -[u_2\,(u_2 + w_1)\,(u_1 ^ 2 + u_3 ^ 2 - w_2 ^ 2 ) - u_3 ^ 2\,(u_1 ^ 2 + u_2 ^ 2 - w_3 ^ 2)]\,\gamma(0,0,-1;u_2+w_1,u_3,u_1+w_2 ) \nonumber \\ & & -[u_3\,(u_3 + w_1)\,(u_1 ^ 2 + u_2 ^ 2 - w_3 ^ 2 ) - u_2 ^ 2\,(u_1 ^ 2 + u_3 ^ 2 - w_2 ^ 2)]\,\gamma(0,0,-1;u_3+w_1,u_2,u_1+w_3 ) \nonumber \\ & & + w_1\,[w_2\,(u_1 ^ 2 - u_2 ^ 2 + w_3 ^ 2 ) + w_3\,(u_1 ^ 2 + w_2 ^ 2 - u_3 ^ 2 ) ] \,\gamma(0,0,-1;w_2+w_3,w_1,u_2+u_3 ) \nonumber \\ & & + w_1\,[u_2\,(u_1 ^ 2 - w_2 ^ 2 + u_3 ^ 2 ) + u_3\,(u_1 ^ 2 + u_2 ^ 2 - w_3 ^ 2)]\,\gamma(0,0,-1;u_2+u_3,w_1,w_2+w_3)\ , , \label{df_pw1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and where the two - electron integral @xmath36 is @xmath37 the recurrence relations for the integrals @xmath38 result from the differential equation ( [ diff ] ) and can be written in a compact form as @xmath39 where we use a newton - like symbol notation @xmath40 and @xmath41 the relation ( [ df_rec ] ) allows one to express the integral @xmath42 with positive index @xmath43 through @xmath38-integrals with smaller nonnegative indices .
derivatives of polynomials in @xmath44 and @xmath45 are calculated explicitly .
the master integral @xmath46 and the two - electron integrals @xmath36 are needed to start the evaluation of @xmath24 from recursion relations .
for @xmath46 we implemented the formula of fromm - hill @xcite in the version improved by harris @xcite .
the calculation of the two - electron @xmath36 functions has been described in detail in refs .
@xcite . in eq .
( [ df_rec ] ) the parameter @xmath47 is distinguished on the right - hand side .
we can define the same recurrence relations with other variables @xmath48 from expressions ( [ df_pw1 ] ) , ( [ df_rec ] ) , and ( [ df_pw1sig ] ) by applying the tetrahedral symmetry .
the proposed recurrence scheme allows us to calculate integrals from higher shells @xmath49 very efficiently . in table
[ tb_ibasis ] we present values in two reference points introduced by fromm and hill in ref .
these are the standard reference point ( srp ) @xmath50 where @xmath51 and the auxiliary reference point ( arp ) @xmath52 with @xmath53 .
values for the last one can be compared to the known hylleraas results .
all presented digits are significant , which confirms the very good stability of the recursions at least at these reference points .
lw1.40 w1.40 & & + @xmath46 & 2.208310154388618874536424144010 ^ -1 & 2.173757633275034284081325213910 ^ -2 + @xmath54 & 2.208310154388618874536424144010 ^ -1 & 1.086878816637517142040662607010 ^ -2 + @xmath55 & 2.587328950655650145088210000910 ^ -1 & 7.126296734072723436203022296410 ^ -3 + @xmath56 & 3.658582716243175207969276574110 ^ -1 & 8.571078153650184467645704204710 ^ -3 + @xmath57 & 3.447454259102525282100115713910 ^ -1 & 6.027278683541261617671441399910 ^ -3 + @xmath58 & 8.803723087040150596505448579710 ^ -1 & 9.316428522373859205286070304710 ^ -3 + @xmath59 & 8.518518518518518518518518518510 ^ 0 & 4.807529762877014687398150589310
^ -3 + @xmath60 & 2.849464173126685211199798289310 ^ 0 & 1.296572573872689431790047714410 ^ -2 + @xmath61 & 2.500000000000000000000000000010 ^ 0 & 4.679985481131151729598237602710 ^ -3 + @xmath62 & 1.176795411671425935279581659010 ^ 1 & 2.205496365095795104480271164610 ^ -2 + @xmath63 & 8.000000000000000000000000000010 ^ 0 & 5.033124034041977640019585799210 ^ -3 + @xmath64 & 5.962899567501152778486008087610 ^ 1 & 4.441445631268318817661363268610
^ -2 + @xmath65 & 4.761568658224658953775935886310 ^ 4 & 1.467676925382090748693886720710 ^ -1 + @xmath66 & 1.998667989835473493169581298310 ^ 7 & 3.793674032518970385528210586410 ^ 1 + @xmath67 & 4.595097600000000000000000000010 ^ 9 & 5.979770415024714287528834619910 ^ 1 + @xmath68 & 1.779533879212729823179024201110 ^ 14 & 6.240107562655131418896693018610 ^ 5 + [ tb_ibasis ] w1.30l w4.35 & & + 0.5773 & @xmath69 & 4.71516898955019987934382116810 ^ -2 + 0.5773502 & @xmath70 & 4.71368401676387147774303933410 ^ -2 + 0.577350269 & @xmath71 & 4.71368197603495946911329791210 ^ -2 + 0.5773502691896 & @xmath72 & 4.71368197042739272421747589010 ^ -2 + 0.577350269189625 & @xmath73 & 4.71368197042665332986870610410 ^ -2 + 0.5773502691896257645 & @xmath74 & 4.71368197042663071918952072610 ^ -2 + 0.5773502691896257645091487 & @xmath75 & 4.71368197042663071891894084210 ^ -2 + 3.^-1/2 & @xmath76 & 4.71368197042663071891893846210 ^ -2 + 0.5773502691896257645091488 & @xmath77 & 4.71368197042663071891893788510 ^ -2 + 0.5773502691896257646 & @xmath78 & 4.71368197042663071623194333110 ^ -2 + 0.577350269189626 & @xmath79 & 4.71368197042662375409475531510 ^ -2 + 0.5773502691897 & @xmath80 & 4.71368197042443514682239754210 ^ -2 + 0.577350270 & @xmath81 & 4.713681946459185584378695888;10 ^ -2 + 0.5773503 & @xmath82 & 4.71368105918606800393008623810 ^ -2 + 0.5774 & @xmath83 &
4.71221140635429710782121023410 ^ -2 + [ tb_ibsing ] the integrals @xmath24 with @xmath32 is close to zero are difficult to evaluate because the recurrence relations are numerically unstable . following harris studies on the master integral @xmath46 in ref .
@xcite , we considered @xmath84 close to @xmath85 where @xmath32 is exactly equal to zero .
as an example we present in table [ tb_ibsing ] values for @xmath63 which needs six evaluations of recursions ( [ df_rec ] ) .
close to the critical point @xmath86 , we used bailey s multiprecision library @xcite .
we control the number of significant digits by dynamical estimating and adjusting the appropriate precision of the arithmetic .
as presented in table [ tb_ibsing ] , we can approach the critical point @xmath86 as close as we need for practical purposes .
this strategy of course slows down the algorithm significantly , but in practical applications the parameters close to the critical point @xmath86 are very rare .
this strategy of controlling precision in the region of instabilities allows one to cross @xmath86 points in the minimization of the nonrelativistic energy . in table
[ tb_nenergy ] we present results for nonrelativistic energies for the ground state of li obtained with global minimization of all nonlinear parameters in the basis length of @xmath87 128 , 256 , 512 respectively .
lw6.19 @xmath88 & + 32 & -7.47805940 + 64 & -7.478060050 + 128 & -7.4780603046 + 256 & -7.47806032131 + 512 & -7.478060323427 + @xmath89 & -7.4780603239101(3 ) + [ tb_nenergy ] the achieved precision is much higher than that from similar number of hylleraas functions . in this section we present an algorithm for calculations of extended integrals with @xmath90 or @xmath91 factors in eq ( [ df_g ] )
this means that some of indices in @xmath24 are equal to @xmath19 .
fully correlated exponent in eq .
( [ df_g ] ) gives the opportunity to obtain extended integrals by using either a single integration over @xmath25 or @xmath21 i.e. @xmath92 or a double integration i.e. @xmath93 the adaptive increase of the arithmetic precision close to critical points @xmath86 is necessary here for the precise evaluation of @xmath24 .
moreover , one is able to perform accurately this integration by using @xmath94-point generalized gaussian quadrature with logarithmic end - point singularity @xcite @xmath95 \nonumber \\ & \approx & \sum_{i=1}^n\,w_i\,\bigl[w_1(x_i ) + \ln(x_i)\,w_2(x_i)\bigr]\ , , \label{df_rokhlin}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath96 are regular functions on the interval @xmath97 .
this quadrature becomes exact for @xmath96 being polynomials of maximal degree @xmath98 , and the example of 30 point quadrature , which is used through out this paper for calculation of mean values , is presented in appendix a. if integration variable @xmath99 in eq .
( [ df_gext1 ] ) is mapped into the interval @xmath97 by the following change of variable @xmath100 then the quadrature with logarithmic end - point singularity is sufficient for one - dimensional integrals in eq .
( [ df_gext1 ] ) , where @xmath101 quadrature allows one to obtain about 30 significant digits as shown in table [ tb_gm ] .
lw1.38 w1.38 & & + @xmath102 ) & 3.8526109339693792401100483699 10 ^ -1 & 9.4965011449474321807842379096 10
^ -2 + @xmath103 & 3.0274491065750503673087022344 10 ^ -1 & 3.7299721607504970523082630217 10
^ -2 + @xmath104 & 2.3607000625522313956962777964 10 ^ -1 & 1.8959531704125592152173744964 10 ^ -2 + @xmath105 ) & 4.3609471946206883105335511105 10 ^ -1 & 2.5192249839637371540146284722 10 ^ -2 + @xmath106 & 2.5033159766308607933164731813 10 ^ -1 & 1.4536704630910349293502698904 10 ^ -2 + @xmath107 ) & 9.6785340147551496917456020657 10 ^ -1 & 2.4524890694290848053802194511 10 ^ -2 + @xmath108 & 4.9659707613623958013638886677 10 ^ -1 & 8.9297797302822616889412986909 10 ^ -3 + @xmath109 & 2.9947348578887085117244187877 10 ^ 0 & 3.1404382342820313478701792788 10 ^ -2 + @xmath110 ) & 1.3333333333333333333333333333 10 ^ 0 & 7.8333658755438375453440942541 10 ^ -3 + @xmath111 ) & 1.2074139867346617936225023579 10 ^ 1 & 5.0034479672553623213173265006 10 ^ -2 + @xmath112 & 5.4365360486346970213258132467 10 ^ 2 & 6.776488986538662624450203053810 ^ -2 + @xmath113 & 1.8200373382961107749251727489 10 ^ 5 & 4.9988265246802575650210555202 10 ^ 0 + @xmath114 & 2.6360153766233766233766233766 10 ^ 6 & 6.6152204494568427610166828475 10 ^ 0 + @xmath115 & 4.3643113437493283642403015117 10 ^ 10 & 6.1833472013309710240673264688 10 ^ 3 [ tb_gm ] the presented values for integrals are obtained at arp and srp points .
some of them can be found in the literature , for example @xmath112 at arp point @xcite , which corresponds to a hylleraas type of integral .
perfect agreement with those results , demonstrates high accuracy is achieved for the extended integrals .
the proposed evaluation method fully relies on properties of the recurrence algorithm for basis integrals , which must be very stable on the integration path over the corresponding parameter . in comparison to the one - dimensional integral in eq .
( [ df_gext1 ] ) , the convergence of two - dimensional integral eq .
( [ df_gext2 ] ) with respect to the number of integration points is much worse .
for this reason we use a slightly different mapping into @xmath97 intervals , which is @xmath116 the numerical convergence of the integral in eq .
( [ df_gext2 ] ) is the worst for the case @xmath117 , where the leading asymptotics includes a square of the logarithm . for @xmath118 convergence improves significantly .
the use of gaussian quadrature adapted to logarithmic end - point singularity with 30 points is enough for practical applications . in table
[ tb_gmm ] we presented numerical values for @xmath119 in arp and srp reference points with the accuracy of @xmath120 . in the case of @xmath117
they have been obtained with 60 point quadrature .
it is possible to obtain even higher accuracy for @xmath118 , but further improvement for @xmath117 requires a more sophisticated integration strategy .
there are no such problems with integration involving parameters which are attached to opposite edges of the tetrahedron , i.e. @xmath121 , see fig .
[ fig_tetrahedron ] , so this case of integral in eq .
( [ df_gext1 ] ) with @xmath117 is the one which limits accuracy of mean values .
lw1.23 w1.23 & & + @xmath122 & 1.88439208815821610 ^ 0 & 8.42489213013438210 ^ -1 + @xmath123 & 9.48566050673996110 ^ -1 & 1.79770931454600810 ^ -1 + @xmath124 & 4.28459651274302810 ^ -1 & 4.61436739597726910 ^ -2 + @xmath125 & 1.16592753941618410 ^ 0 & 8.71217634404870110 ^ -2 + @xmath126 & 6.82929135812158810 ^ -1 & 2.47068462591839710 ^ -2 + @xmath127 & 2.44017808742262310 ^ 0 & 6.78966381628561310 ^ -2 + @xmath128 & 1.46740110027234010 ^ 0 & 1.86891090964663310 ^ -2 + @xmath129 & 7.40070387148909810 ^ 0 & 7.37578237609160510 ^ -2 + @xmath130 & 1.32593253528504510 ^ 2 & 3.78853437442521510 ^ -2 + @xmath131 & 8.89840219369266910 ^ 2 & 3.62896891001036010
^ -1 + [ tb_gmm ] the basis class of integrals ( @xmath132 ) and the class with the one index equal to @xmath19 is sufficient for all mean values of operators like those in the breit - pauli hamiltonian , eq . ( [ df_h4 ] ) . as an example we demonstrate their evaluation for the lithium ground state . in table [ tb_rel ] we present results for the dirac @xmath133 functions using the drachman formulae @xcite @xmath134 where @xmath135 is a total interaction potential .
the similar prescriptions can be used for @xmath136 operator @xmath137 these forms significantly improve accuracy of numerical results in comparison to direct calculations , like those presented in our previous paper @xcite , see table [ tb_rel ] . nevertheless , with 256 functions they are about two digits less accurate than the most precise results obtained from 9564 hylleraas basis functions .
these hyleraas results are slightly more accurate than those in @xcite due to better optimization of the nonrelativistic wave function .
as we have noticed , for the nonrelativistic energy one needs approximately six times smaller basis set of exponentially correlated functions as compared to hylleraas functions to obtain similar accuracy , and the same is confirmed for the mean values of operators .
the achieved accuracy is limited only by the number of basis functions , which nevertheless should be well optimized . in practice
it demands more computing power than we used up to now and a parallel version of the algorithm would be necessary for optimization of a large number of slater functions .
lw1.11w1.12w2.11w1.12w3.8w1.12 & & & & & & + 1 & 30.0827979867 & 4.5064565041 & 13.7645699524 & 0.5364492083 & 625.5828409 & 0.936654826 + 2 & 29.7476086550 & 4.5767695651 & 13.5858596281 & 0.5616478623 & 611.5539967 & 1.138521450 + 4 & 30.1300688464 & 4.4439194210 & 13.7878031290 & 0.5436391751 & 625.4687242 & 0.914892317 + 8 & 30.1874817320 & 4.4214467189 & 13.8157266406 & 0.5435820999 & 627.4078494 & 0.903179423 + 16 & 30.2410787730 & 4.3816810634 & 13.8426372786 & 0.5443189588 & 628.4797182 & 0.871711023 + 32 & 30.2409662868 & 4.3812835938 & 13.8425980633 & 0.5443258043 & 628.4577365 & 0.871331224 + 64 & 30.2408925549 & 4.3812320316 & 13.8425677822 & 0.5443253595 & 628.4513988 & 0.871268418 + 128 & 30.2409871969 & 4.3811865673 & 13.8426170802 & 0.5443248368 & 628.4509048 & 0.871208043 + 256 & 30.2409736058 &
4.3811769473 & 13.8426110883 & 0.5443246849 & 628.4490695 & 0.871196220 + + hyll . &
30.24097272(3 ) & 4.38117664(4 ) & 13.84261086(3 ) & 0.5443246325(7 ) & 628.448985(12 ) & 0.87119562 ( 14 ) [ tb_rel ] in table [ tb_opgmm1 ] we present numerical values for typical operators in higher order perturbation theory i.e. @xmath138 correction to the energy . for these operators
we need to use all the discussed classes of integrals .
@xmath24 integrals with two parameters equal to @xmath19 are obtained with double integration with @xmath139 points and all the presented digits in table [ tb_opgmm1 ] are accurate for the corresponding approximate wave function .
lw4.7w4.7w2.9w3.8w4.7 & & & & & + 1 & 204.916879 & 289.283997 & 1.17747080 & 45.9453381 & 842.720739 + 2 & 211.038011 & 297.213636 & 1.11288776 & 48.0801497 & 891.514656 + 4 & 202.558151 & 284.360921 & 1.07190415 & 45.3862793 & 840.040129 + 8 & 202.665783 & 283.643499 & 1.06613265 & 45.4434625 & 844.843155 + 16 & 202.840737 & 282.053625 & 1.06413154 & 45.2407303 & 853.983531 + 32 & 202.852464 & 282.008017 & 1.06418866 & 45.2367099 & 854.271406 + 64 & 202.862382 & 282.005597 & 1.06417955 & 45.2363427 & 854.374209 + 128 & 202.883252 & 282.002183 & 1.06417817 & 45.2360474 & 854.554104 + [ tb_opgmm1 ]
our primary motivation for developing explicitly correlated exponential basis set is the efficient representation of the wave function in a small number of basis functions .
we applied it for the accurate numerical calculation of expectation values of some operators corresponding to higher order relativistic and qed effects .
they involve integrals with quadratic inverse powers of at least two interparticle distances , which are the most difficult in the evaluation . using this compact and very flexible
correlated exponential basis set , we are aiming to determine @xmath6 and @xmath8 effects in the hyperfine and fine structure of lithium - like systems , which have not been investigated so far .
this work was supported by nist through precision measurement grant pmg 60nanb7d6153 .
99 v. yerokhin and k. pachucki , phys .
a * 81 * , 022507 ( 2010 ) .
k. pachucki and v. yerokhin , phys .
lett . * 104 * , 070403 ( 2010 ) .
f.w . king , d.g .
ballegeer , d.j .
larson , p.j .
pelzl , s.a .
nelson , t.j .
prosa , and b.m .
hinaus , phys .
a * 58 * , 3597 ( 1998 ) .
yan , , w. nrtershuser , g. w. f. drake , phys
* 100 * , 243002 ( 2008 ) .
m. puchalski and k. pachucki , phys .
a * 78 * , 052511 ( 2008 ) .
rebane , v.s .
zotev , opt . spektrosk . * 75 * , 945 ( 1993 ) , [ opt . spectrosc . * 75 * , 557 ( 1993 ) ] .
m. puchalski , d. kedziera , and k.pachucki phys .
a * 80 * , 032521 ( 2009 ) .
d. m. fromm and r.n .
hill , phys .
a * 36 * , 1013 ( 1987 ) .
f. e. harris , phys .
a * 55 * , 1820 ( 1997 ) .
f.w . king , phys .
a * 44 * , 7108 ( 1991 ) .
f.w . king , k.j .
dykema , and a.d .
lund , phys .
a * 46 * , 5406 ( 1992 ) .
a. luchow and h. kleindienst , int .
j. quantum chem . * 45 * , 445 ( 1993 ) .
i. porras and f.w .
king , phys .
a * 49 * , 1637 ( 1994 ) .
yan and g.w.f .
drake , j. phys .
b * 30 * , 4723 ( 1997 ) .
f.w . king , int .
j. quantum chem .
* 72 * , 93 ( 1999 ) .
feldmann , p. j. pelzl , and f. w. king , j. math . phys . * 39 * , 6262 ( 1998 ) . p.j .
pelzl , g.j .
smethells , and f.w .
king phys .
e , * 65 * , 036707 ( 2002 ) . k. pachucki and m. puchalski , phys . rev .
a * 71 * , 032514 ( 2005 ) .
m. puchalski and k. pachucki , phys .
a * 73 * , 022503 ( 2006 ) .
yan and g.w.f .
drake , phys .
lett . * 81 * , 774 1998 .
harris , phys .
a * 79 * , 032517 ( 2009 ) .
r. a. sack , c. c. j. roothaan , and w. kolos , j. math .
phys . 8 , 1093 ( 1967 ) . v. i. korobov , phys .
a * 66 * , 024501 ( 2002 ) .
f. e. harris , a. m. frolov , and v. s. smith , jr . ,
phys . * 121 * , 6323 ( 2004 ) .
d. h. bailey , `` mpfun : a multiple precision floating point computational package '' , available at http://crd.lbl.gov/ dhbailey/ j. ma , v. rokhlin , and s. wandzura , siam j. numer .
33 * , 971 ( 1996 ) .
r. j. drachman , j. phys .
b * 14 * , 2733 , ( 1981 ) .
we present here a set of 30 nodes and corresponding weights for generalized gaussian quadrature with logarithmic end - point singularity @xcite , which was obtained using the algorithm described in appendix a of ref .
we used these quadrature points for numerical integration of extended integrals in tables [ tb_gm ] , [ tb_rel ] , and [ tb_opgmm1 ] .
lw2.38w1.38 & & + 1 & 7.32379744272605707927651215334608 10 ^ -6 & 2.79892154309547416710987828334736 10 ^ -5 + 2 & 1.10044700457774879623368108247943 10 ^ -4 & 2.17365526502541548589108155033626 10 ^ -4 + 3 & 5.46918326183967432457719790539051 10 ^ -4 & 7.20703586534389568501488362593518 10 ^ -4 + 4 & 1.70185751910164118701225273639596 10 ^ -3 & 1.67446096505498972978224436308689 10 ^ -3 + 5 & 4.08386360971437462932298732108869 10 ^ -3 & 3.19128240641146524350794278296664 10 ^ -3 + 6 & 8.30004117688233905931162736411746 10 ^ -3 & 5.35378831352933564469099803155786 10 ^ -3 + 7 & 1.50229781560799959114892646895942 10 ^ -2 & 8.20962136808195567645775658689256 10 ^ -3 + 8 & 2.49539236157545503008513656313159 10 ^ -2 & 1.17680292130848124961801044296255 10 ^ -2 + 9 & 3.87833861710629356474590553368630 10 ^ -2 & 1.59981435048914024332333704241883 10 ^ -2 + 10 & 5.71508984811763898261154101387036 10 ^ -2 & 2.08290410936242947283573768810863 10 ^ -2 + 11 & 8.06057414726551690255082886279043 10 ^ -2 & 2.61515976613093133103470957985343 10 ^ -2 + 12 & 1.09570394234517942760556318344690 10 ^ -1 & 3.18220682694563815827694187138199 10 ^ -2 + 13 & 1.44308373001500812672361144038109 10 ^ -1 & 3.76672559998067174250314484868819 10 ^ -2 + 14 & 1.84897949427531958876501649047717 10 ^ -1 & 4.34910622632233969988331688489985 10 ^ -2 + 15 & 2.31213001548255181588787651651928 10 ^ -1 & 4.90821532284030403760822595772833 10 ^ -2 + 16 & 2.82911960197207748156616199457019 10 ^ -1 & 5.42224286612626157484616606008227 10 ^ -2 + 17 & 3.39435481190852660583946762696458 10 ^ -1 & 5.86959442909769135605447275253662 10
^ -2 + 18 & 4.00013113109450190847537317246366 10 ^ -1 & 6.22979181149364796169604799658096 10 ^ -2 + 19 & 4.63678856939306293165441422602120 10 ^ -1 & 6.48434457072330546001338183346875 10 ^ -2 + 20 & 5.29295142741036253816689241764505 10 ^ -1 & 6.61755598512543778100952715354295 10 ^ -2 + 21 & 5.95584395325645009469243558808251 10 ^ -1 & 6.61722952772004782470943263263082 10 ^ -2 + 22 & 6.61167040396915198682135573185723 10 ^ -1 & 6.47524589229209230876914855177978 10 ^ -2 + 23 & 7.24604528176032770586180257340226 10 ^ -1 & 6.18798583499546375301194127428597 10 ^ -2 + 24 & 7.84445734734941543894377419518002 10 ^ -1 & 5.75658036634420432925717153926242 10 ^ -2 + 25 & 8.39274951478663018317278487334798 10 ^ -1 & 5.18697691924656775668123741331021 10
^ -2 + 26 & 8.87759597617343115537224494301863 10 ^ -1 & 4.48981784955672218807632566389701 10 ^ -2 + 27 & 9.28695795963227580314671288014994 10 ^ -1 & 3.68013625003694933496657925550436 10 ^ -2 + 28 & 9.61050059187409711054297148665964 10 ^ -1 & 2.77688703774135920873618253138605 10 ^ -2 + 29 & 9.83995703521288981120560285698734 10 ^ -1 & 1.80238737841607431150476240903211 10 ^ -2 + 30 & 9.96945958679763051044061968242492 10 ^ -1 & 7.82767019549675700264134910161448 10 ^ -3 + | we demonstrate the applicability of four - body exponentially correlated functions for the accurate calculations of relativistic effects in lithium - like atoms and present results for matrix elements of various operators which involve negative powers of interparticle distances . |
recent cosmological observations have provided strong evidence that a dark - energy component , such as the cosmological constant , comprises as much as 70 per cent of the total energy density of the universe ( @xcite ) . characterizing the nature of the dark energy and its possible
evolution has become a central goal of empirical work in cosmology .
galaxy surveys measure the clustering statistics of galaxies as a function of scale and redshift .
the galaxy power spectrum can be compared to the cmb power spectrum to constrain the growth of structure .
however the amplitude of the galaxy power spectrum depends on the biasing of the particular galaxy sample ; one therefore needs to exercise care in using the full power spectrum for cosmological inferences ( e.g. @xcite ) .
the shape of the power spectrum has been regarded as more robust to biasing effects .
the baryon oscillations in the galaxy power spectrum are imprints from acoustic oscillations in the early universe , prior to recombination .
the same physics produces the dramatic peaks and troughs seen in the cmb power spectrum .
their physical scale is set by the sound horizon at recombination , which has been determined accurately from cmb data ( @xcite ) .
the baryon oscillations in the matter and galaxy power spectra are much weaker features because the dark matter which dominates the mass density did not participate in the acoustic oscillations .
the oscillations are at the level of a few tens of a percent variation about the smoothed power spectrum . with a survey of sufficient size
, these features can be measured accurately .
since the physical length scale of the baryon oscillations is known from the cmb measurement of the sound horizon , a measurement of their apparent size in redshift or angle space leads to a measurement of purely geometric quantities : the hubble parameter and the angular diameter distance , respectively .
we will be concerned with the relation between physical size and angular diameter distance : @xmath0 , where @xmath1 is the angular diameter distance and @xmath2 is the measured angular scale .
this relation can be used for a statistical quantity as well ; for the power spectrum it means that a measurement of an angular wavenumber @xmath3 and its relation to the physical wavenumber @xmath4 yields @xmath5 .
we describe in the next section how @xmath1 constrains models of dark energy .
to measure baryon oscillations , many authors have considered galaxy surveys over different redshift ranges ( @xcite ) . for spectroscopic redshift surveys ,
the tangential and radial components are considered separately since the latter is subject to redshift distortions .
current redshift surveys can map large enough volumes at redshifts well below 0.5 .
it is a great advantage to probe higher redshifts since additional baryon oscillations can then be measured within the linear regime of clustering ( the linear regime extends to smaller physical scales at high redshifts ) . with future redshift surveys , such as the proposed kaos survey ,
such a measurement would be possible .
multi - color imaging surveys are already in progress , e.g. the sdss , the cfh legacy survey , and deeper surveys are proposed for the future , e.g. panstarrs , lsst , snap and others .
these surveys offer the possibility of photometric redshifts as crude redshift estimators . with the sdss providing a large sample of relatively nearby galaxies , and the hubble deep fields and the goods survey providing deep samples of galaxies beyond @xmath6 , many multi - color samples of galaxies
have been studied and used to estimate photometric redshifts . with good
photometry in 45 optical filters , it is expected that a statistical accuracy characterized by an rms of @xmath7 in @xmath8 is achievable for galaxies below @xmath6 . for special samples such as the large red galaxy ( lrg ) sample of the sdss
, one can do significantly better .
similarly it is expected that with more filters and experience with estimating photo-@xmath9 s , the accuracy will improve and extend to higher redshifts .
this is an area of ongoing study ( e.g. @xcite ) .
the accuracy of photometric redshifts determines the bin width in redshift within which angular power spectra can be measured and regarded as being independent of neighboring bins ( i.e. the overlap in the galaxy distribution between neighboring bins is small ) .
this is important because wide bins would cause the baryon wiggle features to be smeared out .
following @xcite we will assume that @xmath10 in @xmath8 .
note that this is not a very stringent requirement ; at @xmath6 , it means the rms error in the photometric redshift is below @xmath11 .
given a large number @xmath12 of galaxies with photo-@xmath9 s , the mean redshift is measured accurately since the error in it is suppressed by @xmath13 , which can be very small even per redshift bin for surveys of several 100 or 1000 square degrees .
however , when the photo-@xmath9 s are estimated in terms of a probability distribution over redshift per galaxy , often the result is bi - modal or worse .
thus there are sometimes large errors in the estimated photo-@xmath9 , and for certain redshift ranges they lead to systematic biases .
while calibration with spectroscopic redshifts of some fraction of the galaxies can be used to limit such a bias , we will explore the sensitivity of our dark - energy constraints to possible biases in the mean bin redshift .
our focus will be on the question : can subtle effects in the biasing of galaxies compromise the dark - energy constraints obtained from them ?
we will use the bispectrum , the fourier transform of the three - point function , as an independent measure of the biasing of galaxies .
the idea of using the bispectrum in addition to the power spectrum on large scales to constrain both the amplitude of the mass power spectrum and bias has been suggested and implemented ( @xcite ) . in this study
we will examine whether it can help constrain a possibly redshift dependent bias that could mimic effects of the cosmological model we are trying to constrain .
we will also compute the gain in signal to noise that the bispectrum provides .
we will use perturbation theory , valid in the weakly nonlinear regime of clustering .
the expansion history of the universe is given by the scale factor @xmath14 in a homogeneous and isotropic universe .
for cosmological purposes , dark energy is associated with a density field , possibly weakly evolving over cosmic time , that affects the expansion rate of the universe , @xmath15 .
the expansion rate at late cosmic times depends on contributions from the density of non - relativistic matter , @xmath16 ( cold dark matter plus baryons ) , and the dark - energy density , @xmath17 .
our notation is such that @xmath16 and @xmath17 denote the present day values in units of the critical density , @xmath18 .
the dark - energy formalism introduces a new , time - dependent density described by the dark - energy equation of state : @xmath19 this density component is allowed to have an arbitrary time dependence ; it must be constrained by theory and observation . due to lack of compelling theoretical models for the dark energy ,
it is typical to introduce a parameterization for @xmath20 to be determined empirically .
we follow @xcite and parameterize the equation of state as @xmath21 note that setting @xmath22 , i.e. , @xmath23 and @xmath24 , corresponds to the equation of state for a cosmological constant .
we assume a flat universe throughout this paper .
the expansion rate for a flat universe with dark energy is given by @xmath25 } \right\}. \label{eq : hubble}\ ] ] the modification in the expansion rate of the universe by a dynamically evolving dark - energy component , as opposed to a cosmological constant for example , alters distance measurements on cosmological scales .
the ( comoving ) distance , @xmath26 , from an observer at redshift zero to a source at scale factor @xmath27 is given by : @xmath28 hence , given a cosmological standard ruler , such as the length scale associated with one of the peaks of baryon - induced oscillations in the power spectrum at a given redshift , one may obtain dark - energy constraints via constraints on the distance function .
dark energy that has negative pressure , i.e. , @xmath29 as observed today , leads to repulsive gravity and therefore does not cluster significantly .
true , we are interested in clustering on large scales in this paper , yet spatial fluctuations in the dark energy are not expected to be significant below the present horizon scale ( @xcite ) , which we do not approach .
we thus treat dark energy as a function only of epoch .
however , since the expansion rate is altered , time - dependent dark energy does modify the redshift evolution of mass clustering . in linear theory ,
all fourier modes of the mass density perturbation , @xmath30 ( relative to the average @xmath31 ) , grow independently and at the same rate , so @xmath32 defines the growth factor , @xmath33 .
the growth factor is obtained by solving the linearized perturbation equation : @xmath34 , where the dot denotes derivative with respect to physical time .
this equation can be manipulated to obtain a differential equation for the growth factor or , alternatively , the growth rate relative to that for a flat , matter - dominated universe , @xmath35 ( @xcite , @xcite ) : @xmath36 \frac{1}{a } \frac{{\rmn{d}}g}{{\rmn{d}}a } = \frac{3}{2 } \left [ w(a ) - 1 \right ] \omega_\rmn{de}(a ) \frac{g}{a^2}.\ ] ] the dark - energy density parameter at epoch @xmath37 is denoted @xmath38 , and is obtained from the relations @xmath39
@xmath40 we restrict our attention to the quasi - linear regime and expand the matter density contrast perturbatively as ( e.g. , @xcite ) : @xmath41 we suppose a biasing prescription to obtain the galaxy density contrast from the matter density : @xmath42 we allow for primordial tilt and run in the linear power spectrum by introducing the spectral index , @xmath43 , and run , @xmath44 , parameters defined at @xmath45 , as in @xcite : @xmath46 for @xmath47 , we use the transfer function of @xcite that includes baryon oscillations . we determine @xmath48 by cmb normalization using the relation @xmath49 ^ 2 \omega_\rmn{m}^{-2 } \left ( \frac{k_0 ^ 3}{2 \pi^2 } \right)^{-1}.\ ] ] that is , the normalization is determined by normalizing the density perturbation amplitude at @xmath45 from the primordial curvature fluctuation contrast , @xmath50 .
the epoch @xmath51 should be representative of the matter - dominated regime .
the normalization is quite insensitive to this choice .
we take @xmath52 .
we will employ the cmb scalar fluctuation amplitude parameter , @xmath53 , whose relation to @xmath50 is @xmath54 we calculate the projected galaxy power spectrum using the limber approximation : @xmath55 where @xmath27 is the scale factor , @xmath56 and @xmath33 is growth factor of the previous section . for the distribution of sample galaxies , @xmath57
, we use the source distribution of @xcite : @xmath58 with @xmath59 .
we separate this distribution into 10 bins over the redshift range from @xmath9 = 0.3 to 1.3 .
all bins have equal width ( 0.1 in redshift ) , as indicated in fig .
[ fig : galaxydist ] .
we project the galaxy distribution for each bin of galaxies separately using eq .
[ eq : p_proj ] .
a more rigorous treatment would convolve the galaxy distribution with an appropriate selection function for a galaxy catalog with photo-@xmath9 information .
our approach is a bit more crude , but we attempt to account for redshift uncertainties by adding a nuisance parameter for the mean redshift of each bin to our fisher matrix , as described in the next section . -axis gives the number density of galaxies per redshift bin of width @xmath60 .
the numbers in the shaded regions indicate the unused galaxy number density in the low-@xmath9 and high-@xmath9 regions .
the square symbols show the signal - to - noise for the power spectrum and the crosses for the bispectrum ( see right side of the @xmath61-axis ) ] since galaxy number is conserved , we may write @xmath62 finally , we rewrite eq .
[ eq : p_proj ] as @xmath63 ^ 2 \frac{1}{\chi^2 } p_\rmn{g } \left ( \frac{l}{\chi } , \ a \right ) , \label{eq : p_g}\ ] ] where we have introduced the index @xmath64 to label the different redshift bins .
we calculate the full - sky bispectrum from the flat - sky bispectrum as @xmath65 with the flat - sky bispectrum likewise given by a limber - style projection : @xmath66 ^ 3 \frac{1}{\chi^4 } b_\rmn{g}\left ( \frac{l_1}{\chi } , \frac{l_2}{\chi } , \frac{l_3}{\chi } , \ a \right ) .
\label{eq : b_g}\ ] ] to @xmath67 , the galaxy bispectrum is given by the sum of two terms : @xmath68 \nonumber \\ & + & \frac{1}{2}b_1 ^ 2 b_2 d^4(a ) \left [ 2 p(k_1 ) p(k_2 ) + \rmn{cyclic } \
k_i \ \rmn{permutations } \right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath69 is the second - order perturbation theory kernel .
note that the two terms have different triangle configuration dependence , and different dependence on @xmath70 and @xmath71 .
the power spectrum covariance for redshift bin @xmath64 ignores the contribution from the trispectrum , which should be small in the linear regime : @xmath72 ^ 2 \delta_{l l'}.\ ] ] here @xmath73 is the fraction of sky coverage for the survey , for which we use the value 0.1 .
@xmath74 is the galaxy density for redshift bin @xmath64 . in our galaxy distribution ( fig .
[ fig : galaxydist ] ) it is 2.4 galaxies per arcmin@xmath75 for the lowest redshift bin , and 5.4 galaxies per arcmin@xmath75 at the peak of the galaxy distribution .
the bispectrum covariance ignores contributions from 3- , 4- , and 6-point functions , which are also expected to be small : @xmath76 \left [ p(l_2 ) + \frac{1}{\bar n_\rmn{g}^i } \right ] \left [ p(l_3 ) + \frac{1}{\bar n_\rmn{g}^i } \right ] \\ & \times \big ( \delta_{l_1 , l'_1 } \delta_{l_2 , l'_2 } \delta_{l_3 , l'_3 } + \delta_{l_1 , l'_1 } \delta_{l_2 , l'_3 } \delta_{l_3 , l'_2 } + \delta_{l_1 , l'_2 } \delta_{l_2 , l'_1 } \delta_{l_3,l'_3 } + \delta_{l_1 , l'_2 } \delta_{l_2 , l'_3 } \delta_{l_3 , l'_1 } + \delta_{l_1 , l'_3 } \delta_{l_2 , l'_1 } \delta_{l_3 , l'_2 } + \delta_{l_1 , l'_3 } \delta_{l_2 , l'_2 } \delta_{l_3 , l'_1 } \big ) .
\end{split}\ ] ] we assume that the likelihood function for the galaxy power spectrum and galaxy bispectrum is gaussian , and employ a fisher matrix analysis to approximate the likelihood near the fiducial cosmological model defined by the parameters in table [ tab : params ] .
.the fiducial cosmological model used throughout this paper . [ cols=">,<,<,<",options="header " , ] as in fig .
[ fig:5params ] , the bispectrum helps primarily in constraining the amplitude and bias parameters .
this is important because poor constraints on the @xmath70 and @xmath71 parameters mean that the dark - energy constraints may not be robust against possibly scale - dependent or nonlinear bias .
the main difference in the level of accuracy achieved compared to the 5-parameter study is due to the bias parameters , since here we allow for two independent parameters in each redshift bin .
constraints on the biasing from other observations , or having some basis to reduce the parameter set from the twenty we use here , would improve dark - energy constraints by up to a factor of two .
[ fig:11params ] illustrates the power of a wide area multi - color survey , in that the full set of parameters gets constrained by the galaxy power spectrum and bispectrum , in conjunction with the cmb .
for example , the constraints on the shape of the primordial power spectrum and on dark - energy parameters are interesting enough that increasing survey area or depth becomes appealing .
we discuss these below .
we performed our analysis for a supergravity ( sugra ) inspired fiducial model , with @xmath77 and @xmath78 . a non - cosmological constant fiducial model results in stronger dark - energy constraints as a result of the redshift coverage of galaxy observations at relatively low redshift , and cmb observations at high redshift ( @xcite ) .
the comparison in fig .
[ fig : w_0-w_a ] shows an improvement of over a factor of two in constraints on dark - energy parameters , though given _
level cmb information galaxy clustering does not add much .
table 2 shows these results , as well as the use of type ia supernovae constraints at the level of snap .
constraints from the fisher matrix analysis of the 11-parameter cosmological model .
the @xmath79-model is compared to the sugra model in the two panels .
note the difference in the range plotted for both parameters the sugra model is constrained much better , though the galaxy statistics add less information to the cmb for this model . ]
we have explored the prospects for obtaining interesting dark - energy constraints from the angular galaxy power spectrum and bispectrum .
the use of the bispectrum adds some new information , though the signal - to - noise is significantly smaller than that of the power spectrum .
however , its value lies in making dark - energy constraints robust against biasing features that can not be measured with the power spectrum alone .
we have shown that using the configuration dependence of the bispectrum , even a nonlinear , redshift - dependent bias characterized by 20 parameters in our study , can be measured and marginalized over .
the dark - energy constraints we obtain are weaker than those expected from type ia supernovae or weak lensing .
an ambitious spectroscopic survey could also do better by using three dimensional information ( e.g. seo & eisenstein 2003 ; linder 2003 ) .
however it is worth emphasising that our requirements of a multi - color imaging survey place no additional burdens over what is needed for weak lensing . surveys such as the cfh legacy survey are already in progress , and several larger surveys are planned for the future .
we have made conservative choices of redshift binning and the maximum redshift used , to ensure that photometric redshift uncertainties would be well below the requirements .
thus we believe that , at the very least , the angular galaxy statistics would provide a useful independent check on dark - energy constraints from imaging surveys . as discussed below , it is possible to improve the constraints to levels competitive with the methods mentioned above by increasing survey area , depth and quality of photometric redshifts .
high redshift ( @xmath80 ) galaxies are important to obtain the parameter constraints at the level advertised here .
this is true for several reasons .
the linear regime extends to smaller scales at higher redshifts because nonlinear evolution progresses to larger scales over time .
this is evident from fig [ fig : peaks ] , which demonstrates that , at higher redshifts , a greater number of the baryon - induced peaks lie in the linear region .
the three dimensional nonlinear scale , @xmath81 , is a factor of two smaller at @xmath82 than at @xmath83 .
further , the two - dimensional nonlinear scale , @xmath84 , depends not only on @xmath81 , but also on the angular diameter distance , which for @xmath82 is a factor of 3 larger than at @xmath83 . for ongoing and future deep imaging surveys
the number density of galaxies in these higher redshifts bins is larger .
this is helpful in that we can select special classes of galaxies with useful properties , such as the luminous red galaxies studied from the sloan digital sky survey .
even if they are a small fraction of the galaxy population , the shot noise contribution is not likely to be a limiting factor as discussed above and by seo & eisenstein ( 2003 ) .
since we wish to learn about the time dependence of the dark - energy equation of state , it is important to sample our statistics over a wide enough range in redshift . in particular , for the equation of state we have used , which is linear in the scale factor , the degeneracy between @xmath85 and @xmath86 is broken by sampling galaxies over several redshift bins across a range of redshifts .
this is illustrated in fig .
[ fig : z_f_sky ] and fig .
[ fig : redshift_scaling ] , where the marginalized 1-@xmath87 constraints for the dark - energy parameters are plotted as a function of survey redshift depth .
the constraints from a survey that extends to @xmath88 are twice as good as one that goes to @xmath89 .
-@xmath85 plane for different values of the maximum redshift bin used for the analysis .
the right panel shows constraints for different survey areas , given by the values of the sky fraction , @xmath73 . ] the right panel of fig .
[ fig : z_f_sky ] shows the dependence of dark - energy constraints on survey area .
while the errors do not scale simply with @xmath73 due to the use of cmb priors , there is a significant improvement with every factor of two in sky coverage . using fig .
[ fig : z_f_sky ] , our fiducial values can be scaled to a range of survey depths and areas .
the ability to use the deep imaging capability of future surveys to go well beyond @xmath90 will depend in part on the accuracy of the photometric redshifts . with low enough scatter in these and even a very small sub - sample of spectroscopic redshifts for calibration
, the methods we have explored can provide much better constraints on dark - energy models , especially models with a larger component of the dark - energy density at higher redshifts . as discussed by seo & eisenstein ( 2003 ) ,
the requirements on photometric redshift scatter are not severe : an rms of @xmath91 in @xmath8 is adequate .
here we have further checked that residual biases in the mean redshift of each bin do not significantly degrade dark - energy constraints ( see fig .
[ fig : z_mean_scaling ] ) .
hence it is not unreasonable to hope that the innermost contour of fig .
[ fig : z_f_sky ] , corresponding to the highest redshift bin at @xmath92 , will be achievable for a high quality survey .
in addition , a smaller rms in the photometric redshifts will mean that we can use effectively smaller redshift bins to improve the constraints .
a rigorous analysis of redshift binning would require the use of cross - spectra and their covariances ; alternatively , the galaxy distribution could be treated as three dimensional , with large errors in the redshift coordinate ( seo & eisenstein 2003 ) . besides the baryon oscillation features , dark - energy parameters affect the overall shape and amplitude of the angular power spectrum and bispectrum . to separate the effects of the oscillations , we calculated galaxy fisher matrices using the `` no - wiggles '' transfer function of @xcite .
if we use just the galaxy clustering information , the constraints for the no - wiggles case are about twice as large . with cmb priors ,
the effect is smaller as the cmb enables the amplitude of the spectra to also provide information .
we do still have a standard ruler in the no - wiggles case : the peak in the power spectrum corresponding to matter - radiation equality ( @xcite ) .
the physical length scale of this ruler is set at decoupling by @xmath93 , which can be well constrained by the cmb .
hence the broad shape of the power spectrum adds information on angular diameter distances .
the amplitude depends on the bias parameter and the growth factor , which is sensitive to the dark energy . using both the galaxy power spectrum and bispectrum with the cmb , the scalar amplitude @xmath53 , the two bias parameters , @xmath94 , and the power spectrum amplitude in each redshift bin , are constrained sufficiently well .
we have tested our choices of fiducial bias parameters and the quasi - linear regime .
we repeated our analysis by setting @xmath84 to half the value used , and find that it leads to a 611 per cent degradation in the dark - energy constraints for galaxy plus cmb information .
thus our results are not very sensitive to the choice of cutoff of the quasi - linear regime and the neglect of non - gaussian contributions to the covariances .
since one of the goals of our formalism is to allow for a nontrivial biasing of the galaxies , we also performed our analysis with @xmath95 as the fiducial value , thus allowing for a nonlinear term in the biasing .
it led to improved constraints on most parameters due to a larger impact of adding bispectrum information , e.g. the 1-@xmath87 uncertainty in the dark - energy parameters was lower by 10 per cent .
more importantly , we find that @xmath71 can be measured sufficiently well for a wide range of fiducial values , so that an effectively nonlinear , scale - dependent bias can be consistently incorporated in our analysis .
this validates our conclusion that bias and dark - energy constraints can be simultaneously obtained by using the bispectrum .
an alternate approach to galaxy biasing and other properties is to use the halo model , which may also enable us to probe smaller scales , as discussed in @xcite .
the analytical models for the bispectrum need to checked and calibrated with @xmath12-body simulations .
a large number of independent realizations would be needed since the covariances in the bispectra need to be accurately measured as well .
we thank gary bernstein , daniel eisenstein , wayne hu , martin white , and alex szalay for helpful discussions .
we are grateful to eric linder for discussions and for providing his supernovae fisher matricies .
this work is supported in part by nasa grant nag5 - 10924 and nsf grant ast03 - 07297 .
bernardeau , f. , colombi , s. , gaztaaga , e. , scoccimarro , r. , 2002 , phys . rep . , 367 , 1 .
blake , c. , glazebrook , k. , 2003 , apj , 594 , 665 .
budavari , t. , et al . , 2003 ,
apj , 595 , 59 .
caldwell , r. r. , dave , r. , steinhardt , p. j. , 1999 , phys .
80 , 1582 .
cooray , a. , hu , w. , huterer , d. , joffre , m. , 2001 , apj , 557 , l7 .
connolly , a. , et al . , 2002 ,
apj , 579 , 48 .
eisenstein , d. j. , in `` wide field multi - object spectroscopy '' , 2003 , asp conference proceedings , ed .
a. dey , 35 .
eisenstein , d. j. , hu , w. , 1998 , apj , 496 , 605 .
feldman , h. a. , frieman , j. a. , fry , j. n. , scoccimarro , 2001 , phys .
lett . , 86 , 1434 .
frieman , j. a. , gaztanaga , e. , 1999 , apj , 521 , l83 .
fry , j. n. , 1994 , phys . rev .
, 73 , 215 .
hu , w. , phys .
d. , 2002 , 65 , 023003 .
hu , w. , haiman , z. , phys .
d. , 2003 , 68 , 063004 .
hu , w. , jain , b. , 2003 , astro - ph/0312395 .
huterer , d. , phys .
d. , 2002 , 65 , 3001 .
kosowsky , a. , turner , m. s. , 1995 , phys .
d , 52 , 1739 .
linder , e. , 2003 , phys .
d , 68 , 083504 .
linder , e. , jenkins , a. , 2003 , mnras , 346 , 573 .
ma , c. p. , caldwell , r. r. , bode , p. , wang , l. , 1999 , apj , 521 , l1 .
matsubara , t. , szalay , a. , 2003 , phys .
, 90 , 021302 .
meiksin , a. , white , m. , peacock , j. a. , 1999 , mnras , 304 , 851 .
mobasher , b. , et al . , 2004 , apj , 600 , l167 .
perlmutter , s. , et .
al . , 1999 , apj , 517 , 565 .
pope , a. , et .
al . , 2004 , apj , 607 , 655 .
riess , a. g. , et .
al . , 1998 , anj , 116 , 1009 .
riess , a. g. , et .
al . , 2001 , apj , 560 , 49 .
seo , h. j. , eisenstein , d. , 2003 , apj , 598 , 720 .
seljak , u. , zaldarriaga , m. , 1996 , apj , 469 , 437 .
spergel , d. n. , et al . , 2003 ,
apjs , 148 , 175 .
takada , m. , jain , b. , 2004 , mnras , 348 , 897 .
tegmark , m. , et .
al , 2004 , phys .
d. , 69 , 103501 .
tonry , j. l. , et .
al . , 2003 , apj , 594 , 1 .
verde , l. , et al .
, 2002 , mnras , 335 , 432 .
wang , l. , steinhardt , p. j. , 1998 , apj , 508 , 483 . | baryonic oscillations in the galaxy power spectrum have been studied as a way of probing dark - energy models .
while most studies have focused on spectroscopic surveys at high redshift , large multi - color imaging surveys have already been planned for the near future . in view of this , we study the prospects for measuring baryonic oscillations from angular statistics of galaxies binned using photometric redshifts .
we use the galaxy bispectrum in addition to the power spectrum ; this allows us to measure and marginalize over possibly complex galaxy bias mechanisms to get robust cosmological constraints . in our parameter estimation
we allow for a weakly nonlinear biasing scheme that may evolve with redshift by two bias parameters in each of ten redshift bins .
we find that a multi - color imaging survey that probes redshifts beyond one can give interesting constraints on dark - energy parameters .
in addition , the shape of the primordial power spectrum can be measured to better accuracy than with the cmb alone .
we explore the impact of survey depth , area , and calibration errors in the photometric redshifts on dark - energy constraints .
[ firstpage ] cosmological parameters distance scale equation of state large - scale structure of universe |
for decades the solar system was assumed to be the prototype for planetary system formation . with the detection of over a thousand confirmed exoplanets and many more candidates , it has become apparent that many planetary systems exist that differ substantially in their structural properties from our solar system .
nevertheless the formation of the solar system is still of special interest for several reasons .
first , it is only for the solar system that we can directly examine material that is left over from the formation process in the form of meteorites .
second , only for the solar system do we have detailed structural information about the entire system including its smaller bodies .
last but not least , it is only for the solar system that we know for sure that life exists .
the three major sources about the formation of the solar system are meteorites , the present solar system structure and contemporary young planet - forming systems .
we start by reviewing the current status of meteorite research concerning the chronology of early solar system formation including the formation of the terrestrial planets in section 2 . in this context
the question of the origin of short - lived radioactive nuclei in these meteorites is of special interest . some of these can only be produced in supernovae events of high - mass stars - different possibilities
are discussed in section 3 .
other sources of information are young stars surrounded by accretion discs from which planetary systems might form . in section 4 the properties of these discs - masses , gas content and chemical composition - are discussed .
estimates of the life times of these discs are given and the consequences for planet formation scenarios are discussed .
section 5 provides a closer look at the different stages of planet formation . starting from dust grains , then considering pebble - sized objects to planetismals the current state of research
is presented .
this is followed by the final step in which planets form . many of these young systems are part of a cluster of stars .
there are several indications that our own solar system also formed as part of a star cluster .
section 6 gives the arguments for such an early cluster environment and discusses the possibilities of finding today stars that formed in the same cluster as our sun did .
not only the location and masses of the planets but also those of the asteroid and kuiper belt are characteristics of our solar system that might potentially give clues to its formation . in section 7 the early dynamical evolution of the kuiper belt
is illustrated .
possible scenarios for the late heavy bombardment between 4.0 and 3.7 gyr ago are discussed .
it is still an open question to what degree the solar system characteristics changed since its formation and how stable the solar system is in the long - run .
the likely long - term evolution of the solar and other planetary systems is discussed in section 8 .
this is followed by a summary in section 9 .
first , we look at the information that meteorites give about the formation of the solar system . in order to do so
a relative age dating of these meteorites is necessary .
studying meteorites from our solar system is the only way to directly constrain timescales of its protoplanetary disc evolution .
most meteorites are older than 4.5 billion years and originate from the asteroid belt .
the asteroid belt between mars and jupiter provides the only vestige of the planetesimals which were the first larger objects in the protoplanetary disc that provided the building materials for the larger planets .
simulations indicate that it is most likely that the larger planets formed via collisions of such first generation planetesimals ( e.g. wetherill 1990 , chambers 2003 ) .
the different groups of meteorites sample these first generation planetesimals and cover the different evolutionary steps of early solar system evolution in great detail . in general ,
three major groups of meteorites can be distinguished .
chondrites represent unprocessed , brecciated early solar system matter , whereas differentiated meteorites such as achondrites and iron meteorites originate from asteroids that have undergone melting and internal differentiation .
these asteroidal melting events were triggered by either decay of short - lived @xmath0al or by impact events . due to the short half life of @xmath0al ( 0.7 myr ) , the first heating mechanism is confined to the first 5 million years of solar system evolution .
the oldest dated solar system matter are ca , al - rich inclusions ( cais ) in chondritic meteorites that have been dated by the u - pb method to 4.567 - 4.568 billion years ( amelin et al . 2002 , 2011 ; bouvier et al .
cais are an important anchor point to constrain the abundance of significant short - lived nuclides such as @xmath0al or @xmath1hf at the beginning of the solar system .
in addition to the long lived u - pb chronometer , short - lived nuclides with their half - lifes of less than 100 million years enable dating of meteorites and their components at an age resolution as low as several tens of thousands of years . based on combined u - pb and al - mg chronometry ,
the ages of chondrules , a major component of chondrites , has been constrained to as late as up to 4 million years after solar system formation ( e.g. bizzarro et al .
2004 ; villeneuve et al .
it is currently contentious , as to whether there is a circa 1.5 million years age gap between the formation of the first cais and the formation of the first chondrules ( see villneuve et al .
2009 ; amelin et al . 2011 ; larsen et al 2011 ; connelly et al .
there is , however , now consensus that the undifferentiated asteroidal parent bodies of chondrites themselves accreted ca .
2 - 4 million years after the beginning of the solar system ( e.g. bizzarro et al . 2005 ; kleine et al .
because of their younger accretion ages , chondrites escape internal heating triggered by @xmath0al ( trieloff et al .
2003 , henke et al .
2013 ) , and thus they preserved their pristine structure .
recent high precision dating using hf - w and al - mg chronometry has shown that some differentiated meteorite groups do in fact predate formation of chondrites . beside cais
, some groups of magmatic iron meteorites that represent the cores of differentiated asteroids have been shown to constitute the oldest solar system objects ( kleine et al .
if corrected for cosmic ray exposure , magmatic iron meteorites can be shown to have differentiated within the first 2 million years of solar system history , and their asteroidal parent bodies must have accreted earlier than 0.5 million years after solar system formation ( kruijer et al .
2013 , 2014 ; wittig et al .
some older groups of achondrites that sample the outer silicate portion of differentiated asteroids differentiated only slightly later than iron meteorites .
the particularly pristine group of angrites ( achondrites consisting mostly of the mineral augite ) is inferred to have differentiated by around 3 - 5 million years after the cais ( larsen et al . 2011 , brennecka & wadhwa 2012 ; kleine et al .
2012 ) . likewise , achondrite groups such as acapulcuites , eucrites , and winonaites as well as non - magmatic iron meteorites differentiated in the time interval between 3 - 5 million years after solar system formations , with inferred accretion ages between 1 and 2 million years after solar system formation ( schulz et al . 2009 , 2010 ) . in summary
, there is now clear evidence from short - lived nuclide and long - lived u - pb chronometry that cais are the oldest solar system objects , followed by magmatic iron meteorites ( differentiation of 1 - 2 million years after solar system formation ) and most achondrite groups and non - magmatic iron meteorites ( differentiation 3 - 5 million years after solar system formation ) .
differentiation of these asteroidal bodies was likely driven by internal heat sources , with decay of @xmath0al being the most important one .
the parent asteroids of chondrites accreted much later ( 2 - 4 million years after solar system formation ) than those of the differentiated asteroids ( less than 2 million years after solar system formation ) .
it is therefore likely that the chondritic parent bodies did not undergo internal differentiation , because the heat supply from short - lived nuclides such as @xmath0al was insufficient , or , alternatively , their parent body size was too small . alternatively
, undifferentiated chondrites may sample the outer layers of planetesimals that differentiated in their interiors . the larger rocky planets in the inner solar system formed much later than the small asteroids , at timescales of tens of millions of years .
hf - w systematics in terrestrial samples and chondrites constrain the age for the earth s growth to at least 38 million years ( kleine et al .
2002 , yin et al . 2002 ; knig et al . 2011 ) and probably as late as 120 million years after solar system formation ( allegre et al . 2008 ; rudge et al .
there are fewer indicators to constrain the age of mars , but estimates reach from 2 to 10 million years after solar system formation ( nimmo & kleine 2007 ; dauphas & pourmand 2011 ) .
the uncertainties of these estimates originate from the parameters that are used to model planetary growth and internal differentiation into metal cores and silicate mantles .
the small size of mars , for instance , has been explained by radial migration of jupiter , suggesting that mars represents a `` starved '' planet that could not accrete further because of interaction with jupiter ( walsh et al .
2011 ) . for constraining the age of the earth ,
the moon - forming giant impact event is of great importance , and physical models explaining the formation of the moon have dramatically changed over the past years ( e.g. canup & asphaug 2001 ; cuk & stewart 2012 ; canup 2012 ) .
likewise , the hf - w and u - pb chronometry of earth s formation has undergone significant reinterpretation .
most earlier studies agreed that both the hf - w and u - pb chronometers date segregation of the earth s core during the final stages of earth s accretion ( e.g. allegre et al .
2008 ; rudge et al .
2010 , wood & halliday 2005 ) .
a combination of experimental and geochemical studies now rather argue that volatile elements such as pb were delivered late to the growing earth , implying that the u - pb systematics of the earth s silicate mantle bear no chronological significance ( albarede 2009 ; ballhaus et al . 2013 ; marty et al .
2012 ; schnbchler et al . 2010 ) .
the geochemical and isotopic inventory of meteorites provides a unique chronological record of early solar system evolution .
it took only less than one million years after condensation of the first solid matter to form the first generation of planetesimals .
these planetesimals underwent internal heating between 1 and 4 million years after solar system formation , largely caused by @xmath0al decay , triggering their differentiation into metal cores and silicate mantles .
the parent asteroids of undifferentiated chondritic meteorites formed 1 - 2 million years later , and therefore these bodies did not differentiate .
formation of the larger terrestrial planets in the inner solar system occurred via collision of smaller asteroidal bodies .
the timescales involved in planetary growth are in the order of tens of million years , with mars being a possible exception due to gravitational interaction with nearby jupiter .
there is growing evidence , that the volatile element inventory of the inner solar system was added late , i.e. during the last stages of planetary growth .
chondrites have not endured any geological activity since they formed during the first million years of our solar system . as such , they record physical processes in the solar protoplanetary disc ( spd ) but also of the molecular cloud stage , which preceded the formation of the proto - sun @xcite .
chondrites are made of cais , chondrules and iron - nickel metal .
all these components are cemented by a fine - grained matrix ( fig .
1 ) . a key property of chondrites is the past presence within their components of short - lived radionculides ( slrs ) .
slrs are radioactive elements , which have half - lives , @xmath2 , smaller than 200 myr and were present in the early solar system @xcite .
though they have now decayed , their past presence in chondrites and other meteorites is demonstrated by excess of their daughter isotopes . since 1962 and
the discovery of @xmath3i ( @xmath2 = 15.7 myr ) , a long list of slrs has been identified in meteorites ( see the table of @xcite ) .
slrs are important because they can potentially help to build an early solar system chronology and are the most likely heat source of the building blocks of planets , planetesimals @xcite .
in addition , they can help decipher the astrophysical context of our solar system formation . in other words , assuming the sun was born as most stars in a ( giant ) molecular cloud , elucidating slrs origin is the only tool to trace back what was the relationship of the sun with other stars born in the same molecular cloud .
the presence in the early solar system of slrs having the longest half - lives is not surprising .
similarly to stable isotopes they have been produced in the interior of stars , which have preceded our sun in the galactic history and were delivered to the interstellar medium ( ism ) by supernova ( sn ) explosions and massive star winds .
their abundance is roughly in line with galactic evolution models @xcite .
the presence of slrs with shorter half - lives ( @xmath2 @xmath4 10 myr ) is more difficult to understand because their half - life is comparable or smaller than the typical timescales of star formation processes @xcite .
obviously , constraining the origin of slrs depends also on their initial abundance , which is not always clearly known .
some slrs have been synthesised via the irradiation of the spd gas / dust by proto - solar cosmic - rays @xcite . as we saw in section 2
this is especially the case of @xmath5be ( @xmath2 = 1.4 myr ) whose abundance in cais is variable @xcite .
independent evidence for early solar system irradiation is given by the variable and intense x - ray emission of protostars @xcite .
other slrs such as @xmath6cl ( @xmath2 = 0.3 myr ) or @xmath7ca ( @xmath2 = 0.1 myr ) could also have been produced by irradiation according to some models @xcite .
we note that the situation for these slrs is complicated by the fact that their initial abundance in the solar system is not well constrained @xcite .
aluminium-26 ( @xmath2 = 0.72 myr ) and iron-60 ( @xmath2 = 2.6 myr ) are probably the slrs , which have attracted the most attention during the last decade .
iron-60 is too rich in neutrons to be produced by irradiation processes @xcite .
as @xmath8fe is absent from massive star winds , its only possible source in the early solar system is - at least one - supernova , which is known to produce large abundances of that slr @xcite .
because the initial abundance of @xmath8fe has long been considered to be elevated ( @xmath8fe/@xmath9fe @xmath10 10@xmath11 @xcite ) , the presence of @xmath8fe has been interpreted as evidence for a nearby supernova @xcite . according to supernova nucleosynthetic models ,
the sn had to be located within a few pc from the nascent solar system @xcite . in n - body simulations of the birth environment of the sun
it is often assumed that the progenitor of this supernova was a star with a mass of @xmath12 25 ( see section 6 ) .
however , from the cosmochemical side there are some difficulties with this scenario .
it is very unlikely to find a protoplanetary disc or a dense core that close to a sn . before they explode as sne
, massive stars carve large ionized regions in the ism ( called hii regions ) where the gas density is too low and temperature too high for star formation to take place .
observations show that even around a massive star that still needs to evolve for 2 myr before it becomes a sn , discs and cores are found only several parsecs away @xcite , too far to incorporate @xmath8fe at the solar abundance .
in addition , because sne ejecta are vastly enriched in @xmath8fe relative to @xmath0al and their respective solar abundances ( woosley & weaver 2007 ) , all models relying on sn injection lead to a @xmath0al/@xmath8fe ratio far lower than the initial solar ratio , unless specific and ad hoc conditions are adopted @xcite . finally , the initial abundance of @xmath8fe has been recently revised downwards by almost two orders of magnitude @xcite .
the revised @xmath8fe abundance is compatible with a * somewhat * enhanced galactic background due to stars born and died in the same molecular cloud as the sun but in a prior generation ( gounelle et al . , 2009 ) .
al in a dense shell created by a massive star wind .
phases 1 and 2 correspond to the collection of interstellar gas and injection of @xmath0al by the wind ( arrows ) .
phase 3 corresponds to the gravitational collapse of the shell and the formation of a new , @xmath0al - rich star and other stars including the sun ( yellow ) .
the whole process lasts a few myr ( see text).,scaledwidth=38.0% ] because supernovae vastly overproduce @xmath8fe relative to @xmath0al , @xmath0al can not originate from a single supernova as first proposed by @xcite .
it also implies @xmath0al can not have a background origin because at the molecular cloud scale , slrs are mainly due to supernovae .
in addition , the @xmath0al distribution in the early solar system seems to have been heterogeneous @xcite , which is incompatible with a global ( molecular cloud ) scale origin @xcite .
the most likely origin for @xmath0al is therefore local , i.e. the wind of a single massive star @xcite .
@xcite proposed that a single runaway wolf - rayet ( wr ) star injected @xmath0al in a shock - induced dense shell .
given the required velocity of the star ( 20 pc / myr ) and gas ambient density ( n @xmath10 100 @xmath13 ) it is however likely the star will have escaped the molecular cloud well before the star collects enough gas and enters the wr phase during which @xmath0al is injected .
this model suffers from the brevity and therefore the rarity of the wr phase .
have proposed that @xmath0al originated in a wind - collected shell around a massive star ( figure 2 ) . in this model , the dense shell collected by the massive star wind
is continuously enriched by @xmath0al brought to the surface of the star by convection promoted by rotation @xcite .
after several myr , the collected shell reaches densities large enough to make it gravitationally unstable and a new star generation forms in the shell . in this model ,
the sun is a second generation star and the massive star having provided @xmath0al can be seen as its parent star .
this mechanism is generic in the sense that this mode of star formation , though not the rule , is relatively common @xcite .
this model constraints the astrophysical context of our sun s formation as it requires that the parent cluster to which belongs the parent star ( baptised _ coatlicue _ ) contained roughly 1200 stars . in conclusion , though the origin of slrs is still a complex and debated issue ( see davis et al .
2014 for a more detailed review ) it seems that three star formation spatial scales are relevant .
slrs with the longest half - lives originate at the scale of star complexes , while @xmath8fe ( @xmath2 = 2.6 myr ) originates at the scale of the molecular cloud and @xmath0al ( @xmath2= 0.72 myr ) at the local massive star wind scale .
the distribution of slrs in the solar system is the record of hierarchical ( in termes of spatial and temporal scales ) star formation in the ism .
another source of potential information about the formation of the solar system are young stars that are currently forming planets from the disc material surrounding them @xcite .
these discs form as a consequence of angular momentum conservation during the star formation process . in the early stages of the star formation process the disc mediates accretion from the parental core to the forming protostar , while at later stages it provides the natural location and material for the planet formation process .
the observational study of the properties and evolution of protoplanetary discs is thus a direct probe of the initial conditions for planet formation .
the presence of protoplanetary discs around young stars was originally inferred from the emission in excess to the stellar photosphere at infrared- and submillimetre - wavelengths ( eg . * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
it was very rapidly understood that the excess emission was likely due to a disc - like distribution of dust located around and heated by the young star at the centre , this interpretation was also consistent with the dynamics of the molecular gas , which could be interpreted as orbiting the star in keplerian fashion .
the inferred sizes ( up to few times 100 au in radius ) and masses ( up to 10 - 20% of the central star mass ) were also consistent with the expected values for a pre - solar nebula .
these ideas were then spectacularly confirmed by the hst silhouette optical absorption images a few years later @xcite . following these initial observations , protoplanetary discs around young solar analogues
have been extensively studied in nearby star forming regions .
the recent review by summarizes most of our current knowledge of the general properties of protoplanetary disc populations in nearby star forming regions .
the current best estimate of the lifetime of the disc , or the timescale for planetesimal and gas giant formation , is derived from the variation of the fraction of stars , which show infrared excess as a function of the age of the star forming regions ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , which is also found to be consistent with the variation of the fraction of young stars that show signs of interactions with the inner disc .
the fraction of young stars with inner disc is found to drop exponentially with an e - folding time of @xmath103 myr .
this estimate is uncertain because of a number of possible systematic and environmental effects , e.g. the uncertainties in the age determination of young stars @xcite , or environmental disc dispersal mechanisms in clusters , which may not be applicable to the progenitors of the bulk of the field stellar population @xcite .
nevertheless , it is obvious that if the majority of stars host planetary systems , the formation process has to occur within a few myr , at least for planet types , which contain significant gaseous envelopes ( gas giants , ice giants and low - density super - earths ) . in large star forming complexes in the magellanic clouds and our own galaxy ,
there is controversial evidence for stars with circumstellar discs at relatively old ages ( up to and even beyond 30 myr * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
while in nearby regions the few existing candidates have not been confirmed so far , it is possible that a small but non - negligible fraction of the stellar population born in large complexes reaccrete a disc and possibly have multiple chances of forming planetary systems .
young protoplanetary discs are gas rich and most of the raw material available for planet formation is in the form of molecular gas , just like in clouds and cores .
most of this mass is in the observationally elusive form of h@xmath14 and can only be traced , indirectly , through the emission of less abundant species .
the molecular gas content , chemistry and emission from protoplanetary discs has been recently reviewed by @xcite , and we refer to that work for a detailed account . the key feature for constraining the conditions for planet formation is that around young solar analogues most of the disc midplane is at low temperature and the most abundant molecular species ( with the obvious exception of h@xmath14 ) are frozen inside the ice mantles of grains . in these conditions ,
the chemistry is likely to be dominated by reactions on ices and may lead to significant production of complex organic and pre - biotic molecules , as observed in laboratory experiments . while complex organic compounds have been revealed in solar system objects , the direct detection and abundance measurements in protoplanetary discs
is challenging .
nevertheless , in the cold disc midplane cosmic - ray induced desorption of ices may release a small fraction of the complex molecules in the gas phase , a process similar to the one that is thought to occur in cold protostellar cores @xcite .
alternative promising locations to search for these complex compounds are the snowlines of the major molecular species , which could carry in the gas phase complex organic molecules as impurities as part of the sublimation process .
the major snowlines that may produce such an effect are the co snowline at @xmath1020k and the h@xmath14o one at @xmath10150k .
the co snowline is now within grasp of the alma observatory in nearby star forming regions , and much work dedicated to the characterisation of this important transition in protoplanetary discs is expected in the coming years .
future instruments may help quantifying gas to dust ratio by combining high spatial and spectral resolution . as a consequence of the complexity of the molecular gas chemistry in discs and the difficulty in observing h@xmath14
, the most reliable mass estimates for protoplanetary discs still come from the measurements of the thermal dust emission .
most of the disc is optically thin at submm and longer wavelengths .
therefore , the thermal dust emission is directly proportional to the mass , which can be readily estimated from the observed fluxes assuming a dust opacity coefficient and a temperature structure for the disc .
the latter is normally computed using a self consistent thermal balance model , for typical accretion rates measured in young pre - main sequence objects the heating from the central star dominates the disc heating and the thermal structure of the dust is usually well constrained by models ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) the disc masses derived with this method are typically between 0.2% and 20% of the mass of the central star , implying that a large fraction of young solar analogues are hosting a disc with a mass well above the minimum mass solar nebula and in principle capable of forming a planetary system similar to our own .
high angular resolution observations allow to resolve the disc emission and estimate the distribution of matter in the disc .
the surface density of solids , traced by the thermal dust emission , are typically found to fall off as @xmath15 with radial distance @xmath16 until a critical radius and then drop sharply , consistently with an exponential fall off .
the observed surface densities of the most massive discs are broadly consistent with the average surface density of our own solar system ( andrews et al .
2009 ) . however , most systems that have a total mass above the minimum mass solar nebula threshold are larger than our own solar system , resulting in a lower surface density .
these estimates are not without uncertainties : firstly , the solids are assumed to trace approximately 1% of the total mass ( following the estimates of the dust to gas ratio in the interstellar medium ) , however this number is highly uncertain in discs and also expected to evolve with time and location , as gas and dust evolve following different pathways ; secondly , the dust opacity coefficient depend on the composition , size , shape , and porosity of the dust grains @xcite . measurements of proto planetary disc masses are relatively rare as of today : up - coming alma observations may be able to provide a statistical view of the distribution of dust surface densities and possibly also gas surface densities . as the dust emission is
optically thin , multi - wavelength observations at submillimetre wavelength allow us to probe the dust opacity coefficient , which in turn can be a powerful probe of the grain population properties . in a protoplanetary disc
, grains are expected to grow and settle onto the midplane ( for a recent review , see * ? ? ?
as grains grow to sizes of the same order or larger than observing wavelengths , the dust opacity coefficient dependence with wavelength changes from the typical value of the sub - micron size interstellar grains ( @xmath17 ) to a much shallower dependence , approaching @xmath18 in the limit of a population of grains all much larger than the observing wavelength @xcite . this argument has been used to constrain the level of grain growth in protoplanetary discs , finding that in most discs around young stars the dust has grown to pebble - size aggregates .
the observational results can be understood in the framework of global dust evolution models in discs , which describe the evolution of dust in the disc environment based on constraints from laboratory measurements of the grain - grain collision outcomes .
more specifically , the emerging observational constraints on the dust grain size distribution as a function of disc radius matches the expectations from the evolutionary models .
this apparent success hides a number of difficulties that still need to be solved , in particular , smooth disc models still predict a radial drift and fragmentation of the large grains that is inconsistent with the observations and require to artificially slow down the radial drift . the planet formation process
then requires that additional growth barriers are overcome , a variety of possibility exist , from pressure traps generated by disc instabilities , localised growth across snowlines , or the efficient accretion of pebbles onto existing planetary cores @xcite .
some of these models predict observational signatures that are within reach of the current generation of observing facilities . indeed the effect of pressure traps induced by planet - disc interaction has been observed in some systems with alma ( e.g. * ? ? ?
an intriguing development in recent years has been the observation by several groups of the possibility of significant dust evolution before the disc stage in prestellar cores and protostars .
if confirmed , these findings would imply a significant revision of our assumptions on the initial conditions for planet formation in protoplanetary discs .
planets from the gas and dust present in protoplanetary discs . in the first stage of planet formation dust and ice particles collide and stick together to form larger aggregates @xcite .
the aggregates maintain a high porosity during the growth , since collision speeds are initially too low to cause restructuring .
particles obtain increasingly higher collision speeds as they grow in size and their frictional coupling with the gas diminishes ( voelk et al . , 1980 ;
ormel & cuzzi , 2007 ) , so that particle pairs decouple from the smallest eddies and thus will have different velocity vectors even when at the same location . an additional contribution to the collision speed is the relative radial and azimuthal drift between different - sized particles @xcite .
silicate dust aggregates in the inner protoplanetary disc are compactified by collisions when they reach approximately mm sizes @xcite . the combination of high collision speeds and low porosity halts growth by direct sticking , since compact particles can not dissipate enough energy during a collision to allow sticking @xcite .
this is referred to as the _ bouncing barrier_. ice monomers are generally stickier than silicate monomers and this increases their resistance against compactification @xcite .
the size of the constituent monomers also plays an important role in determining the collision outcome .
ice aggregates , which consist of very small monomers of @xmath19 @xmath20 m sizes , can stick at up to 50 m / s collision speeds @xcite .
it is nevertheless not known whether such small ice monomers are prevalent in protoplanetary discs or whether sublimation and condensation cycles drive ice particles to much larger sizes .
the continued growth from mm - sizes faces the formidable _ radial drift barrier_. the gas in the protoplanetary disc is slightly pressure supported in the radial direction , since viscous heating and stellar irradiation heat the inner regions more strongly @xcite .
this outwards - directed push on the gas causes the gas to orbit slower than the keplerian speed , by approximately 50 m / s @xcite .
solid particles do not sense the pressure difference from front to back ( since their material density is much higher than the gas density ) , so particles would orbit at the keplerian speed in absence of gas drag .
the drag from the slower moving gas drains particles of their angular momentum and causes them to spiral inwards towards the star . in the asteroid belt the radial drift peaks for m - sized particles , which fall towards the star in a few hundred years , to be destroyed at the silicate sublimation line close to the star .
the peak of the radial drift occurs for cm - sized particles in the outer protoplanetary disc where the giant planets form .
there are three main ways by which particles can cross the radial drift barrier : _ mass transfer_. at collision speeds from 1 to 25 m / s particles can grow by mass transfer . the projectile is destroyed in the collision but leaves up to 50% of its mass attached to the target @xcite .
particles stuck at the bouncing barrier do not collide at such high speeds .
however , artificially injected cm - sized seeds can grow from the sea of bouncing barrier particles through mass transfer @xcite .
the growth rate is nevertheless too low to compete with the radial drift , so formation of planetesimals by direct sticking requires a reduction in the radial drift speed of the particles , e.g. through the presence of a long - lived pressure bump .
such a pressure bump may arise at the inner edge of the dead zone @xcite or around the water ice line where the jump in dust density has been proposed to cause a jump in the turbulent viscosity @xcite , although this requires a very steep viscosity transition at the ice line @xcite .
_ fluffy particles_. ice aggregates consisting of small monomers acquire very low densities during their growth , down to @xmath21 @xcite .
particle growth is only able to outcompete the radial drift if the particle grows larger than the mean free path of the gas molecules and enters the stokes drag force regime . here
the friction time is proportional to the particle radius squared ; hence decoupling is much more rapid than in the epstein regime valid for small particles @xcite .
very fluffy particles are large enough to be in the stokes regime and can cross the radial drift barrier within 10 au by growing in size while drifting radially @xcite . hence this is a way to cross the radial drift barrier , if particles can remain fluffy and avoid compactification and erosion by the gaseous headwind . _ particle concentration_. particles can become strongly concentrated in the turbulent gas , triggering the formation of planetesimals by a gravitational collapse of the overdense regions .
particles concentrate either _ passively _ or _
actively_. for passive concentration the general mechanism is that particles pile up where the gas pressure is high , since any rotating structure in the turbulent gas flow must be in semi - equilibrium between the dominant forces , namely the pressure gradient force and the centrifugal / coriolis force ( barge & sommeria 1995 ) .
particles do not sense gas pressure and must therefore move towards the direction of increasing gas pressure . on the smallest scales of the turbulent flow , approximately km under prevalent conditions in the asteroid belt , mm - sized particles pile up between rapidly over - turning eddies @xcite .
the largest scales of the protoplanetary disc are dominated by the coriolis force , and the turbulence organises into axisymmetric pressure bumps , surrounded by zonal flows @xcite , or elongated vortices @xcite . in the streaming instability scenario
the particles actively drive concentration , by piling up in filaments , which locally accelerate the gas towards the keplerian speed and hence do not drift radially @xcite
. strong particle concentration by the streaming instability is triggered at a metallicity slightly higher than solar @xcite .
the gravitational collapse of overdense regions leads to the formation of planetesimals of sizes from 100 to 1000 km @xcite .
the solar system contains remnant planetesimals from the epoch of planet formation , in the asteroid belt and in the kuiper belt .
these populations of planetesimals can be studied to infer constraints on the actual processes that led to planetesimal formation in the solar system .
the relative lack of asteroids smaller than 100 km in diameter , compared to a direct extrapolation from the largest sizes , does not agree with the formation of asteroids by hierarchical coagulation in a population of km - sized planetesimals ( * ? ? ?
* but see @xcite for an alternative view ) .
asteroids may instead have had birth sizes larger than 100 km , in agreement with gravitational collapse models , while the smaller asteroids that are found in the asteroid belt today are mainly collisional fragments @xcite .
large birth sizes have also proposed to explain a similar lack of small kuiper belt objects @xcite .
planetesimals are the building blocks of both terrestrial planets and the cores of the giant planets . in the _ core accretion _
scenario giant planets form as gas from the protoplanetary disc collapses onto a core that has grown to approximately 10 earth masses by accumulation of planetesimals @xcite . in this picture ,
the ice giants uranus and neptune only manage to attract a few earth masses of gas before the gaseous protoplanetary disc dissipates after a few million years .
core accretion by planetesimals is nevertheless very slow because the number density of planetesimals is low in the region where the giant planets form .
an enhancement of 4 - 6 over the minimum mass solar nebula is needed to form jupiter and saturn within 10 million years in the classical core accretion scenario @xcite . for the considered protoplanet mass , and feed a particle accretion disc orbiting the protoplanet .
figure adapted from @xcite.,width=302 ] core accretion timescales can be decreased when accreting planetesimal _
fragments_. small fragments have their scale heights damped by gas drag and hence the growing core can accrete a much larger fraction of the solid material @xcite .
however , global disc simulations show that a large fraction of the slowly drifting fragments are trapped in resonances with the cores @xcite .
the formation of a system of giant planets is further complicated by the excitation of planetesimal eccentricities and inclinations when scattered by the growing cores .
this leads to a slow oligarchic growth phase with growth rates that are too low to form cores within the life - time of the protoplanetary disc @xcite .
pebbles left over from the planetesimal formation process can be accreted very efficiently by the growing cores @xcite .
the hill sphere of the core denotes the radial distance over which an incoming particle on a faster ( interior ) or slower ( exterior ) orbit is scattered gravitationally by the core .
the core only extends a small fraction of its hill radius ( 0.1% at 5 au , 0.01% at 50 au ) .
gravitational focussing of the incoming planetesimals makes the accretion radius much larger than the physical radius , but planetesimals are still only accreted from about 3% of the hill radius at 5 au .
pebbles of mm - cm sizes experience strong drag during the gravitational scattering and lose enough energy to be gravitationally bound to the core , for any impact parameter up to approximately the hill radius ( see figure [ f : figure6 ] ) .
this leads to very high accretion rates , about 1,000 times faster than classical core accretion at 5 au and 10,000 times faster at 50 au .
such high growth rates are needed to explain the formation of gas giants observed in wide orbits around some young stars ( e.g.hr8799 , * ? ? ?
* ) assuming they are not formed from other means ( like gravitational instability ) .
as detailed in section 4.4 , protoplanetary discs observed at mm- and cm - wavelengths show signs of large populations of mm - cm - sized pebbles , which can boost planet formation .
many of the young stars surrounded by discs are part of a cluster of stars , indeed it seems that most stars are born in a clustered environment ( lada & lada 2003 ) . in the next section we will discuss the possible birth environment of the sun . in particular we consider whether we can constrain the properties of the birth cluster , indeed its possible identity , and whether we can identify solar siblings , i.e. the stars that were born from the same molecular cloud as the sun .
analysis of the isotopic abundances of meteorites reveal that they contain the decay products of the radioactive isotopes @xmath0al and @xmath8fe , which have half lives of 0.7 myr and 2.6 myr @xcite . as mentioned in section 3 the most likely source of these isotopes
are supernovae explosions ( e.g. * ? ? ?
how many is still a matter of debate . given the observed distribution of stellar masses of newly - formed stars follows a power law favouring less - mass stars ( @xmath22 - * ? ? ?
* ) one would need a fairly large group of stars reasonably close to the forming sun to explain the observed abundancies .
there are other indications that the sun once was part of a fairly dense and therefore large stellar cluster .
first , the fairly abrupt cut - off in the mass distribution at 30 - 50au , which is usually not observed in protoplanetary discs , but could be caused by a fly - by during the protoplanetary disc phase .
second , the trans - neptunian objects sedna and 2012 vp@xmath23 ( morbidelli & levison 2004 , kenyon & bromley 2004 , brasser et al .
2006 , trujillo & sheppard 2014 ) with their high excentricities are another property that could be explained by an encounter during the planet forming phase . calculations of encounter probabilities in clusters suggest that the sun was formed in a stellar cluster containing 2000 to 10000 stars ( portegies zwart 2009 ) .
further evidence for the sun having been in a cluster , comes from the measured tilt of the sun s rotation , one suggestion being that the protoplanetary disc was titled by a star - disc interaction ( heller 1993 ; thies et al .
2005 ) .
stellar clusters are potentially dangerous environments for planetary systems .
close encounters between stars are relatively frequent in such crowded places .
the timescale for a particular star to have another star pass within some distance @xmath24 can be approximated by @xcite @xmath25 one can distinguish between different phases during which such an encounter could happen : ( i ) the early phase when the star is surrounded by an accretion disc ( first few myr ) , ( ii ) the planet growth phase , and ( up to 100 myr ) , and ( iii ) after the solar system was fully formed ( up to now ) .
close encounters occurring whilst stars still possess protoplanetary discs could lead to their truncation .
in addition , illumination by massive stars may lead to the early evaporation of protoplanetary discs around young stars .
thus , clusters may inhibit the planet formation process .
planetary systems , once formed , are also affected by other stars within clusters .
fly - by encounters with other stars may perturb otherwise stable planetary systems ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) changes in planetary orbits within a system can lead to the growth in eccentricities until orbits cross .
scattering can then lead to the ejection of planets leaving those remaining on more bound and eccentric orbits . for lower - mass planets on tighter orbits
, orbit crossing tends to lead to collisions between planets ( e.g. * ? ? ?
alternatively , stars hosting planetary systems may exchange into ( wide ) binaries .
the stellar companion may then perturb planets orbits via the kozai - lidov mechanism , where planets orbits periodically pass through phases of high eccentricity .
planetary orbits may then cross leading to scattering or collisions ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . in the early phases the probability of encounters are highest , as afterwards clusters expand and therefore the encounter likelihood decreases .
we have seen above how the measured isotopic abundances in meteorites are well explained by the enrichment of the protosolar - system material from a nearby supernova formed from a relatively massive star or from a combination of supernovae and a massive @xmath26-producing star .
the rarity of such objects in turn led us to argue that the solar system likely formed within a stellar cluster containing at least 2000 stars .
as just discussed , stellar clusters are hazardous environments .
the rate of destructive close stellar encounters tends to increase with increasing cluster mass ( see eq.[mbd_spz_equation1 ] ) .
therefore , there is an optimum stellar cluster containing around a few thousand stars where pollution from supernovae is at least possible whilst at the same time a reasonable fraction of planetary systems may survive unperturbed @xcite .
one can perform n - body simulations of stellar clusters containing one 25 m@xmath27 star to determine the number of solar - like stars , which are 0.1 - 0.3 pc from the 25 m@xmath27 star when it explodes as a supernova .
one can then follow the subsequent trajectories of these polluted stars within the cluster to determine the fraction of them , which avoid both perturbing fly - by encounters and exchange encounters into binaries .
such numerical studies of clusters containing 2100 stars ( including one 25 m@xmath27 star ) reveal that some 25 percent of clusters contain enriched , unperturbed solar - like stars ( i.e. g - dwarfs ) , and usually only one or two per cluster out of a total of 96 g - dwarfs @xcite .
therefore , roughly one percent of g - dwarfs from such clusters are enriched whilst being unperturbed .
if the sun was indeed born in an open cluster , it is rather natural to ask whether this cluster is still around today , and if so , whether we can identify it .
there have been a number of observations of star clusters of different ages dedicated to find planets in them ( meibom et al .
2013 , and references therein ) .
however , planet detection in clusters provides some added difficulties , for example , even nearby clusters are often more distant than the field stars one finds usually planets around ) , thus the frequency of planets in cluster environments compared to that in the field is still an open question . however , probably most clusters in the solar neighbourhood loose a considerable fraction ( @xmath28 70% ) of their stars ( pfalzner & kaczmarek 2013 ) . measuring detailed abundance patterns in stellar atmospheres through high - resolution spectroscopy
offers us the hope of identifying other stars , which originate from the same gas cloud as the sun .
even if the cluster has long since dissolved , stars from it will still share similar orbits whose properties could be measured astrometrically ( e.g. * ? ? ?
the open cluster m 67 is one candidate which we will consider here , though there must have been a number of cluster produced in the milky way having similar ages and galactocentric radii .
m 67 has an age .
of about 3.54.8 gyr and the stars within it also have a composition similar to the sun
. have identified one star in the cluster , which is a better match to our sun than most solar - like stars in the solar neighbourhood .
the analysis of 13 additional stars in m 67 confirm that the abundances of the sun and m 67 are similar .
is the cylindrical radius from the galactic centre and @xmath29 is the distance from the galactic plane ( figure 7 of * ? ? ?
* reproduced with permission of the aas).,width=453 ] however , as pointed out by @xcite the current orbits of m 67 and the sun are very different , as shown in fig .
[ mbd_spz_figure1 ] , where we plot their current orbits in cylindrical coordinates ( figure 7 from * ? ? ?
the radial distance from the galactic centre , @xmath30 , for the sun and m67 are similar . earlier mention of abundance enhancements in the sun compared to its distance from the galactic centre
would indicate that the sun experienced a radial migration of 0.84.1kpc . in that case
m 67 should also have migrated over the same distance .
possibly , the migration happened while the sun was still a member of its birth cluster .
extensive numerical analysis of the orbit of the sun in the galactic potential however indicates that this radial migration in the current galactic potential would be negligible @xcite .
one can see from fig .
[ mbd_spz_figure1 ] that the orbit of m 67 takes the cluster significantly further out of the galactic plane to much larger values of @xmath29 than is experienced by the sun .
if one assumes that m 67 has always had its current orbit and that the sun was ejected from m 67 , this would imply that the sun received a significant kick in order to leave it on its current orbit , residing in the plane of the galaxy @xcite .
the point here is that it is not possible to impart such a large kick whilst keeping the solar system intact .
a possible solution to this problem has been suggested in @xcite .
the key idea is that the orbit of m 67 has changed over time .
the orbit could originally have been more in the galactic plane ( i.e. with lower maximum values of @xmath29 ) allowing the sun to escape from it with a relatively low velocity .
scattering off giant molecular clouds ( gmcs ) could then leave the cluster on the orbit we see today .
simulations of scattering due to gmcs show that it is possible to put m 67 on its current orbit beginning with an orbit similar to the sun s @xcite . in that case
the sun must have left m 67 before the scattering event with a gmc took place .
beyond neptune lies a reservoir of remnant icy planetesimals from the formation of the solar system analogous to the main asteroid belt between mars and jupiter . known as the kuiper belt , this distant population displays an intricate orbital structure that has inspired and constrained a number of ideas on the early evolution of our planetary system .
the high abundance of kuiper belt objects ( kbos ) in mean - motion resonances with planet neptune led to the idea that the ice giant has migrated through the original disc of planetesimals , sweeping a significant fraction into stable resonant orbits @xcite .
the superposition of dynamically hot ( high inclination and eccentricity ) and cold ( low inclination and nearly circular ) orbits suggests that while some kbos have been scattered onto their current orbits @xcite , likely by the outer planets , others have formed in - situ and remained unperturbed @xcite .
an alternative explanantion is provided by an encountering star that scattered the kuiper belt ( ida et al .
the current morphology of the scattered kuiper belt could only be reproduced if the mass of the encountering star @xmath31 had an impact parameter of @xmath32au ( punzo et al .
however , such an encounter would like scatter the entire kuiperbelt .
in addition , cooling off part of the hot population to re - populate the cold population would require some 1000 pluto - mass objects , which are not observed .
the need to explain the dynamical structure of the kuiper belt and to reconcile the orbits of the giant planets with the discovery of hot - jupiters were main drivers in the evolution of planet migration theories . in the solar system
, the current paradigm considers that the giant planets emerged from the protoplanetary disc in a more compact , near - resonant configuration , all within 15 au from the sun @xcite .
angular momentum exchanges with the surrounding disc of planetesimals led to the outward migration of neptune , uranus , and saturn , as they scattered small bodies inwards , while jupiter , sufficiently massive to eject planetesimals from the solar system , migrated predominantly towards the sun @xcite .
the diverging migrations of jupiter and saturn eventually resulted in a mutual resonance crossing and triggered a dynamical instability throughout the solar system , which impulsively expanded the orbits of uranus and neptune to near their current locations and violently scattered the planetesimal disc @xcite .
the late heavy bombardment was also likely caused by this instability event @xcite .
geochronological studies of the lunar rocks returned by the apollo missions yielded the surprising result that all large multi - ring basins on the earth s moon
they are also called mare : orientale , crisium , imbrium , nectaris , humorum , serenitatis originated by giant impacts in an extremely confined time interval between 4.0 and 3.7 gyr ago .
this process is called the lunar ( or late ) heavy bombardment ( lhb ) , as it was completed only 800 myr after solar system formation .
it requires that long after final formation of the terrestrial planets , there was an increased flux of small bodies ( up to about 100 km in size ) in the inner solar system 3.8 gyr ago .
possible evidence of the lhb is also inferred from he d meteorites , which are inferred to come from vesta , and martian meteorites like alha84001 @xcite , although this is not undisputed .
two general scenarios appear plausible for the early solar system impact history : \i ) the lhb was the final phase of terrestrial planet accretion
this requires that the small body flux must have been considerably higher before ( implying somewhat unrealistic total mass estimations of initial small body populations ) , and that the record of earlier impacts must have been erased by the late impact phase 3.8 gyr ago .
\ii ) the lhb was an episodic spike of the influx of asteroidal or cometary bodies , caused by dynamical excitation of small body populations in the asteroid or kuiper belts .
as general explanation for the dynamical excitation , planetary migration processes are promising candidates , in particular the aforementioned resonance crossing of jupiter and saturn @xcite , i.e. in more general terms , the giant planet instability ( morbidelli et al . , 2007 , levison et al . , 2011 ) .
advanced models consider a more prolonged bombardment history induced by planet migration processes ( morbidelli et al .
2012 ) .
however , there is increasing evidence that before the time of the lhb 3.8 gyr ago , there were other episodic times of increased impact rates on the earth - moon system , registered by , e.g. ar - ar and zircon chronology , and also by other meteorite parent bodies , e.g. 4.2 gyr impact events affecting the ll chondrite parent body @xcite .
it was suggested @xcite to consider close stellar encounters as a possible reason for repeated episodic dynamical excitation .
however , there is increasing evidence that before the time of the lhb 3.8 gyr ago , there were other episodic times of increased impact rates on the earth - moon system , with concomitant impact episodes on other inner solar system bodies .
for example , both ar - ar and zircon chronology ( fernandes et al . 2013 , nemchin et al . 2008 ) evidence an increased impact cratering rate 4.2 ga ago , which was also experienced by the ll chondrite parent body ( trieloff et al .
1989 , 1994 , dixon et al .
although the chronological data base has still to be improved , age clustering can only hardly be reconciled with stochastical bias effects , as multiple celestial bodies were affected . as giant planet instabilities can only once trigger bombardments , it was suggested ( trieloff 2014 ) to consider close stellar encounters as a possible reason for repeated episodic dynamical excitation .
however , the corresponding dynamical scenarios are only poorly explored .
kbos possess the most diverse surfaces of any small body population in the solar system @xcite .
this is puzzling , given the low and slowly varying temperatures in the kuiper belt region .
the migration - driven instability event described above offers a plausible solution to this problem by allowing planetesimals formed in the region to be scattered to the current kuiper belt .
however , the stochastic character of this process complicates the mapping of current kbo surface properties to their formation location .
a recent survey of kbos and centaurs using _ herschel _ has built on an earlier _ spitzer _ survey @xcite to produce the largest sample of albedos and sizes for this type of object ( table [ table.one ] ) .
these data reveal that kbos are also extremely diverse in reflectivity , with albedos spanning more than an order of magnitude from about 0.03 to 0.40 .
an interesting trend emerges when combining the kbo colour and albedo data @xcite : an albedo - colour plot ( figure [ fig.as ] ) shows that kbos fall into two main groups : a broad bright - red ( br ) cluster , centred around albedo @xmath100.15 and colour spectral slope @xmath1030% and a more compact dark - neutral ( dn ) clump near albedo @xmath100.05 and colour slope @xmath1010% .
importantly , kbos in dynamical classes believed to originate beyond neptune occupy only the bright - red group , while kbos that may have been scattered out to the kuiper belt from nearer the sun are found in both the bright - red and the dark - neutral groups .
this result hints at a compositional gradient that was present in the planetesimal disc prior to the planetary instability event .
@lllc dynamical class & albedo & colour & surface types + scattered disc & @xmath33 & @xmath34 & dn , br + centaurs & @xmath35 & @xmath36 & dn , br + hot classicals & @xmath37 & @xmath38 & dn , br + plutinos & @xmath39 & @xmath40 & dn , br + outer resonants & @xmath41 & @xmath42 & br + cold classicals & @xmath43 & @xmath44 & br + detached kbos & @xmath45 & @xmath46 & br +
planetary system development is often considered in the context of _ dynamical stability _ , or the ability of a planet , moon , or asteroid to adhere to its regular motion i.e. approximately retain its original orbit over time .
past or future instability can help constrain and explain observations and place our solar system today into context @xcite . in this section
, we ask , are planetary systems - and in particular the solar system - stable as their host stars evolve ? the future orbital evolution of the solar system , like all other planetary systems , can not be determined to infinite precision .
instead , we obtain likelihoods for particular futures through suites of numerical simulations .
qualitatively , the evolutionary behaviour can be split into two parts depending on the state of the sun : ( i ) the main sequence and ( ii ) post - main - sequence phases of solar evolution .
the sun will exist in its present state for about a further 6 gyr before turning off the main sequence . during these 6 gyr , the eight planets will technically evolve chaotically @xcite but realistically are very likely to avoid dynamical instability .
in fact , through a suite of simulations , @xcite determined that the inner four planets have a 98%-99% chance of surviving and not having planetary orbits cross ; 100% of all his simulations yielded survival of the outer four planets .
figure 6 shows how the eccentricity of the earth and mercury evolve over this timescale .
earth s eccentricity remains nearly constant .
mercury s eccentricity gradually increases , but rarely becomes large enough for its orbit to cross that of venus .
after the sun leaves the main sequence , it will simultaneously shed about half of its mass while becoming a red giant star that is nearly 1 au in radius . the increase in radius
can more easily allow the sun to tidally capture objects encountered by the solar envelope @xcite , whereas the mass loss will push out and potentially warp the orbits of surviving bodies @xcite .
the result on the inner three planets will be dramatic , and on the outer five less so .
mercury and venus will be swallowed and earth will suffer an uncertain fate . our home planet will lie on the cusp of being tidally drawn into the sun @xcite . mars s orbit will simply expand .
all 4 outer planets will also survive and expand their orbits such that the ratios of their mutual separations will remain unchanged @xcite . beyond neptune and the kuiper belt , the sun s mass loss will trigger instability in the oort cloud , allowing for objects beyond @xmath47 au to escape the solar system @xcite .
observational data for extrasolar planets are significantly less accurate and precise than those for the solar system planets @xcite .
consequently , the future of exoplanetary systems is not as well constrained .
however , every exoplanetary system so far discovered contains fewer planets than the solar system , simplifying the analysis .
the majority of known planetary systems contain either two or three planets ( www.exoplanets.org ) , motivating study of these two cases in detail . during the main sequence evolution of the host star
two planets will never cross orbits if they are sufficiently far away from each other to be _ hill stable _ @xcite .
a hill stable system could potentially become _ lagrange unstable _ if the inner planet collides with the star or the outer planet escapes the system @xcite .
empirical and analytical estimates for these stability boundaries , even when scaled down in mass to the test particle limit , show good agreement with numerical simulations of the long - term evolution @xcite .
three - planet systems do not appear to admit analytical stability boundaries , and therefore investigations of these systems require a numerical approach .
these studies have yielded portraits of instability times as a function of initial separation , as well as empirical estimates for these times @xcite .
these instabilities can occur any time during the main sequence evolution , and fundamentally change the resulting dynamical architecture , perhaps leading to the establishment of a population of hot jupiters and eccentric planets @xcite .
the study of systems with a higher number of exoplanets produce a similarly - wide variety of outcomes to the three - planet case @xcite . on the y - axis
represents the single - planet hill radius .
the planet mass and the innermost semi - major axis are fixed at 1 @xmath48 and 10 au , respectively .
systems below the black solid line will be unstable on the ms .
systems in the tiny strip between the black solid and the black dotted lines will become unstable at some point between the end of the ms and the end of the asymptotic giant branch ( agb ) .
systems below the red solid line will be unstable during the wd phase , assuming that the star formed at the big bang ; systems above this line must be stable for the age of the universe .
the red dotted and dashed lines show the stability boundaries for wd cooling ages of 1 and 5 gyr .
this plot demonstrates that after the star has become a white dwarf , many more systems can become unstable.,width=302 ] we know that planetary systems do survive the giant branch phases of stellar evolution based on abundant evidence of atmospheric metal pollution in white dwarfs ( wds ) @xcite ; wds , which are the size of the earth but with the mass of the sun , represent the end - product of stellar evolution . in over 35 systems ,
wd atmospheric metal pollution is accompanied by compact accretion discs of gas and/or dust @xcite .
although the precise origin of the pollution and discs have yet to be identified , they must arise from currently dynamically active planetary system remnants . during giant branch mass loss ,
the dynamical stability limits of a multi - body system are changed @xcite .
consequently , two - planet systems , which remained stable throughout the entire main sequence may become unstable either during the giant branch phase , or the wd phase @xcite . for three - planet systems ,
the situation becomes more complex , allowing for multiple instabilities to occur during different phases of stellar evolution @xcite .
see figure 7 for a phase portrait of stability limits through all phases of stellar evolution for three - planet systems .
planets residing close to the giant star will tidally interact in a complex way depending on the pulsations of the giant @xcite .
a likely progenitor of the wd discs are exo - asteroids .
although unobservable during main sequence and giant branch phases , their evolution through these epochs will crucially determine their placement in wd systems .
the effect of mass loss on a single planet and single exo - asteroid belt has been considered in the context of an exo - kuiper belt at about 30 au @xcite and an exo - asteroid belt at about 5 au @xcite .
combining the evidence from these different sources for the early history of the solar system the following picture emerges : the geochemical and isotopic inventory of meteorites provides a unique chronological record of early solar system evolution .
it took less than one million years after condensation of the first solid matter to form the first generation of planetesimals .
these planetesimals underwent internal heating between 1 and 4 million years after the solar system formation , largely caused by @xmath0al decay , triggering their differentiation into metal core and silicate mantle .
the parent asteroids of undifferentiated chondritic meteorites formed 1 - 2 million years later , and therefore these bodies did not differentiate .
formation of the larger terrestrial planets in the inner solar system likely occurred via collisions of smaller asteroidal bodies .
the timescales involved in planetary growth are of the order tens of millions of years , with mars being a possible exception due to gravitational interaction with nearby jupiter .
there is growing evidence that the volatile element inventory of the inner solar system was added later , i.e. during the last stages of planetary growth .
the presence of the remnants of short - lived radioactive nuclei in meteorites was for a long time interpreted as evidence for the formation of the sun in a large star cluster .
it was usually assumed that the different radioactive nuclei were formed in one single event in a supernova explosion .
however , there now exist arguments to support that a sequence of events took place . here
the slrs with the longest half - lives originate from star complexes , while @xmath8fe ( @xmath2 = 2.6 myr ) originates from a molecular cloud and @xmath0al ( @xmath2 = 0.72 myr ) from the wind of a local massive star . in this picture the distribution of slrs in the solar system is the result of sequential star formation in the ism .
the observation of young disc - surrounded stars also imposes constraints on the timescale of planet formation .
the disc fractions in star clusters strongly indicate that most stars dissipate their discs within 2 - 3 myr which would favour rapid planet formation - at least for the gas giants .
however , recent works argue in favour of longer disc dissipation times , of the order of 5 - 10 myr . here
a comparison with the meteorite record could possibly bring clarification in the future . comparing the typical masses of the discs around young stars
it is found a large fraction of young solar analogues are hosting a disc with a mass well above the minimum mass solar nebula and in principle are capable of forming a planetary system similar to our own . for the most massive of these discs
the observed surface densities distribution of the disc mass is roughly consistent with the average surface density of our own solar system .
however , most systems are larger than our own solar system , resulting in a lower surface density .
it is currently unclear whether this difference is real or due to the large uncertainties in the observations .
the formation of planets from dust and ice particles likely proceeds in the initial stages by sticking collision , the so - formed porose aggregates eventually compactify .
the continued growth from mm - sized particles faces the the formidable bouncing and radial drift barrier .
planetesimals form despite these difficult circumstances , likely by a combination of particle sticking and gravitational collapse of regions overdense in pebble - sized particles . the various mechanisms which allow particles to avoid this process have been suggested .
future studies of the properties of the remnant planetesimals in the asteroid belt and in the kuiper belt will be crucial to shed light on this open issue .
in addition , studying protoplanetary discs will help to understand this phase of planet formation better , as populations of mm - cm sized pebbles have been detected in discs around young stars .
it is presently unclear to what degree nearby others stars influence the formation of planetary systems . from the slr abundances and
the size of the solar system it can be concluded that the birth cluster of the sun contained at least 2000 stars . measuring detailed abundance patterns several groups have recently started the search for other stars that originate from the same gas cloud as the sun .
there are currently some candidate siblings , however further studies are required to confirm those results .
the orbital structure of the kuiper belt and the cratering record on the moon are evidence for a dynamically active early solar system .
planetary migration and resonance - driven instabilities have acted on the planetesimal disc to enhance impact rates onto the inner solar system , to boost the mixing of populations formed at different distances from the sun , and to sculpt the dynamics of the main planetesimal reservoirs . on the other hand , external forces from close stellar encounters within the suns parental cluster
could have been the cause of episodic dynamical excitations of minor body populations and impact rates .
the current challenge for understanding the origin of the solar system ( and other planetary systems ) is to seek clues that allow us to see past these dynamical events , to the time when the first planetesimals began to form . what will happen to the solar system in the future ?
after the sun leaves the main sequence mercury and venus will be swallowed and earth will suffer an uncertain fate as it will lie on the cusp of being tidally drawn into the sun .
mars and the 4 outer planets will also survive and expand their orbits . in summary , in recent years
we have seen many new insights into the formation of the solar system . however , there are still a considerable number of open questions where different competing theories exist .
so far the different fields contributing in the investigations to the origin of the solar system have generally worked fairly orthogonally . however
, it would be timely to start combining these seperate efforts , using them to build a more complete pictures .
progress can be expected in determining the actual chronology of events .
we want to thank both referees for their very constructive comments .
sp is supported by the minvera program of the max - planck society .
mbd is supported by the swedish research council ( grant 2011 - 3991 ) .
aj was supported by the knut and alice wallenberg foundation , the swedish research council ( grant 2010 - 3710 ) and the european research council ( erc starting grant 278675 ) .
lt is partly supported by the italian ministero dellistruzione , universita
e ricerca through the grant ialma - progetti premiali 2012 ( cup c52i13000140001 ) .
mt acknowledges support by deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft ( dfg ) , and klaus tschira stiftung ggmbh .
dv is supported from the european research council under the european union s seventh framework programme ( fp/2007 - 2013 ) / erc grant agreement n. 320964 ( wd tracer ) .
, a. & testi , l. 2004 , in astronomical society of the pacific conference series , vol .
323 , star formation in the interstellar medium : in honor of david hollenbach , ed .
d. johnstone , f. c. adams , d. n. c. lin , d. a. neufeeld , & e. c. ostriker , 279 , j. , grundy , w. , brown , m. , cruikshank , d. , spencer , j. , trilling , d. , & margot , j .-
2008 , in the solar system beyond neptune , ed .
m. a. barucci , h. boehnhardt , d. p. cruikshank , & a. morbidelli ( the univ . of arizona press , 2008 ) , 161179 | the solar system started to form about 4.56 gyr ago and despite the long intervening time span , there still exist several clues about its formation .
the three major sources for this information are meteorites , the present solar system structure and the planet - forming systems around young stars . in this introduction
we give an overview of the current understanding of the solar system formation from all these different research fields .
this includes the question of the lifetime of the solar protoplanetary disc , the different stages of planet formation , their duration , and their relative importance .
we consider whether meteorite evidence and observations of protoplanetary discs point in the same direction .
this will tell us whether our solar system had a typical formation history or an exceptional one .
there are also many indications that the solar system formed as part of a star cluster . here
we examine the types of cluster the sun could have formed in , especially whether its stellar density was at any stage high enough to influence the properties of today s solar system .
the likelihood of identifying siblings of the sun is discussed .
finally , the possible dynamical evolution of the solar system since its formation and its future are considered .
november 2014 |
as both internal and motional states of trapped atoms are controlled more and more precisely for their quantum manipulation , it has also become very important to observe those atoms _ in situ _ and individually .
efforts to image fluorescence from single trapped atoms started with those in a magneto - optical trap ( mot ) @xcite .
it was extended to single atoms in a 1d optical lattice with a site - specific resolution using a diffraction - limited imaging system and careful offline analysis @xcite .
these efforts culminated when the individual sites of a 2d optical lattice were imaged using objective lenses with high numerical aperture ( na ) @xcite .
the 2d version is known as a quantum - gas microscope , and it was developed primarily to prepare samples for and read out results from quantum simulation of interacting particles .
initially , these experiments were performed using either @xmath4cs @xcite or @xmath5rb @xcite atoms because molasses beams can be used to simultaneously image and cool heavy alkali - metal atoms . in recent years
, 2d imaging techniques have been extended to fermionic atoms such as @xmath6li @xcite and @xmath7k @xcite , which are better proxies for strongly - interacting electrons .
however , light atoms tend to boil out before scattering sufficient photons for imaging because of their large recoil energy and poor polarization gradient cooling . to overcome this difficulty , raman sideband cooling @xcite and electromagnetically - induced - transparency ( eit ) cooling @xcite have been employed .
this complicates the apparatus and imaging process .
in addition , an exposure time of longer than 1 s is required because raman cooling and eit cooling rely on putting atoms in low - lying dark states .
the energy - lowering stimulated processes are interlaced with brief optical - pumping stages , during which photons are harvested . in the present work , using only doppler - cooling beams , we demonstrate _ in situ _ imaging of single @xmath0li atoms in a 1d optical lattice with single atom precision .
lattice depth @xmath8 turns out to be a critical parameter ; above @xmath9 mk , there is an abrupt increase in the number of photons scattered by an atom before it escapes the lattice .
a simple model of evaporation followed by doppler cooling explains this phenomenon .
although the nearest sites are not resolved in our detection because of small na of 0.22 , our approach can be combined with either a large - na system or spectroscopic identification of individual sites @xcite to facilitate quantum gas microscopy of light atoms . in our measurement at @xmath8 = 2.4 mk , the presence or absence of an atom can be determined with 99.95% probability using a 300-ms exposure time , despite the low photon - collecting efficiency .
a double mot fed by a zeeman slower is used to load lithium atoms to an optical lattice @xcite .
the 1d lattice is formed in an octagonal glass chamber by focusing and retro - reflecting a gaussian beam .
the wavelength @xmath10 is 1064 nm and the @xmath11 intensity radius at the focus is 14 @xmath12 m .
mode matching of the reflected beam is optimized by maximizing the power coupled back to the optical fiber that delivers the lattice beam .
when incident power is 1.3 w , the depth @xmath8 at an antinode is 1 mk or 830@xmath13 , where @xmath14 .
a home - built ytterbium - doped fiber laser provides the single - frequency lattice beam .
mot beams with a radius of 1.6 mm are used as imaging beams .
the fluorescence from lattice atoms is collected by an objective lens with na of 0.22 and refocused to an electron - multiplying charge - coupled device ( emccd ) with unit magnification .
na of 0.22 corresponds to a photon - collecting efficiency of 1.3% and the emccd has a quantum efficiency of 90% at 671 nm . with further reduction by 0.9 owing to scattering and diffraction losses , one out of 100 fluorescent photons
are detected @xcite .
our aim is to detect the fluorescence from lattice - bound atoms with single atom precision .
we collect data from a region of interest ( roi ) , which consists of 3 by 3 pixels of the emccd .
each pixel measures @xmath15 @xmath16 , and the roi corresponds to 100 sites at the center of the lattice .
in the first part of the experiment , we attempt to determine the conditions that allow _ in situ _ imaging of atoms using doppler - cooling beams . in the second part , we reduce the number of atoms to observe stepwise change in integrated fluorescence . typically , we load a thousand atoms to the lattice using the mot with low - power beams of 150 @xmath12w in each direction for both trapping and repumping .
an anti - helmholtz coil is turned off and the mot beams optimized for imaging are illuminated . for @xmath0li ,
the scalar polarizabilities of the @xmath17 and @xmath18 states at @xmath10 = 1064 nm are -270 and -167 in atomic units , respectively @xcite .
the @xmath18 state has a negative polarizability owing to its coupling to the @xmath19 and @xmath20 states , and it is a trappable state .
nevertheless , the @xmath21 @xmath22 @xmath23 transition suffers both frequency shift and inhomogeneous broadening ; the lattice beam causes a blue shift of 8 mhz in the @xmath24 transition when @xmath8 is 1 mk . detuning of the mot trap beam is adjusted for a given @xmath8 to maximize the number of photons @xmath25 scattered by an atom before it escapes from the lattice .
the repump beam is stabilized to the @xmath26 @xmath22 @xmath27 transition with fixed detuning .
illumination of the near - resonant beams results in sites with either one or no atoms owing to photoassociative losses .
we use approximately 50 atoms trapped at the central 100 sites for the fluorescence detection . of the fluorescence signal from the trapped lithium atoms vs.
well depth @xmath8 of the lattice .
@xmath28 increases abruptly for @xmath8 larger than 1.5 mk and it saturates at the vacuum - limited lifetime of 30 s. the fitting curve is obtained using a model of alternating ejection and doppler cooling processes . ] the decay time constant @xmath28 of the fluorescence signal versus @xmath8 is plotted in fig .
2 . for this measurement
, we use 25 @xmath12w in each direction for the trap and repump beams .
@xmath28 is related to the number of scattered photons as @xmath29 , where @xmath30 is the photon scattering rate .
because of the inhomogeneous broadening , @xmath30 depends on @xmath8 and it is on the order of @xmath31 s@xmath2 .
when @xmath8 is below 1.4 mk , li atoms escape the lattice almost instantaneously because of large recoil energy and lack of polarization gradient cooling , as noted earlier .
however , above @xmath9 mk , @xmath28 increases steeply and at @xmath32 mk it reaches 30 s , which is the vacuum - limited trap lifetime @xmath33 .
this behavior may be explained by assuming that the independent processes of boil out and doppler cooling alternate while atoms are imaged .
suppose that the lattice atoms are doppler cooled to temperature @xmath34 and those with energy higher than @xmath8 are ejected .
the ejected fraction @xmath35 is @xmath36 with @xmath37 when the 3d harmonic potential well is isotropic @xcite . in the proposed model
, this ejection occurs instantaneously resulting in a truncated maxwell - boltzmann distribution .
this is followed by another round of doppler cooling , which lasts for @xmath38 to reestablish the distribution at @xmath34 .
this model leads to the following relation : @xmath39 the fitting curve shown in fig .
2 is for @xmath40 @xmath12k , @xmath41 @xmath12s , and @xmath42 s. we note that the doppler cooling limit for lithium is 140 @xmath12k . in the experiment on 2d imaging of @xmath43li in ref .
@xcite , @xmath8 at the antinode is estimated to be 0.8 mk from the quoted trap frequencies , and the raman sideband cooling was indispensable for imaging . in order to demonstrate the single - atom precision , we load only one or two atoms to the central part of the lattice by reducing the loading time and waiting until the roi signal decreases beyond a threshold .
we maintain @xmath8 at 2.4 mk and the imaging power at 25 @xmath12w .
we continue to use the roi of 3 by 3 pixels , but we take data only when the center pixel is the brightest so that the imaged atoms are within @xmath4410 sites from the minimum spot .
the rayleigh range of the lattice beam is 580 @xmath12 m , and these sites can be considered identical .
figure 3 ( a ) shows the evolution of the roi signal as the lattice loses one atom at a time , starting with two atoms .
the exposure time for each data point is 300 ms . in this measurement ,
the single atom stays trapped for 25 s. the count rate of the fluorescence from a single atom is 1.7 khz and that from the scattered imaging beam is 3.8 khz .
we note that the fluorescence count rate corresponds to the photon scattering rate @xmath45 s@xmath2 and it is only 6% of that from a single atom in a mot with the same imaging beam intensities @xcite .
we attribute this reduction to the inhomogeneous broadening of the @xmath24 transition in the lattice .
the histogram of the time - series data is shown in fig . 3 ( b ) . using the gaussian fits
, we obtain an average and standard deviation of 1180 and 35 , respectively , for the zero - atom case , and 1660 and 95 , respectively , for the one - atom case . as was already apparent in fig .
3 ( a ) , the fluorescence signal exhibits considerable noise , which was not observed in the mot fluorescence @xcite . we conclude that this noise is caused by fluctuation in lattice - beam parameters such as power and mode matching . even with the noise , when we use a proper threshold , which is 1340 counts in this case , both the sensitivity of deciding correctly the presence of a single atom and the specificity of deciding correctly the absence of an atom are larger than 99.95% for an exposure time of 300 ms . with the large na of the quantum gas microscopes ,
the exposure time can be reduced by more than an order of magnitude .
in this work , we address the problems in imaging or detecting lithium atoms in an optical lattice . when the potential well is sufficiently deep , simple doppler cooling enables us to obtain a fluorescence signal with single - atom precision while the atoms remain trapped .
we plan to combine this capability with the site - specificity obtained by using an applied magnetic field gradient to achieve site - resolved _ in situ _
imaging for our quantum manipulation experiment on single lithium atoms .
this work was supported by a grant to the atomic interferometer research laboratory for national defense funded by the defense acquisition program administration and agency for defense development in korea .
99 z. hu and h. j. kimble , opt . lett .
* 19 * , 1888 ( 1994 ) .
m. karski , l.frster , j. m. choi , w. alt , a. widera , and d. meschede , phys .
lett . * 102 * , 053001 ( 2009 ) .
w. s. bakr , j. i. gillen , a. peng , s. flling , and m. greiner , nature ( london ) * 462 * , 74 ( 2009 ) .
j. f. sherson , c. weitenberg , m. endres , m. cheneau , i. bloch , and s. kuhr , nature ( london ) * 467 * , 68 ( 2010 ) . m. f. parsons , f. huber , a. mazurenko , c. s. chiu , w. setiawan , k. wooley - brown , s. blatt , and m. greiner , phys .
lett . * 114 * , 213002 ( 2015 ) .
l. w. cheuk , m. a. nichols , m. okan , t. gersdorf , v. v. ramasesh , w. s. bakr , t. lompe , and m. w. zwierlein , phys .
lett . * 114 * , 193001 ( 2015 ) .
e. haller , j. hudson , a. kelly , d. a. cotta , b. peaudecerf , g. d. bruce , and s. kuhr , nature phys .
* 11 * , 738 ( 2015 ) .
d. schrader , i. dotsenko , m. khudaverdyan , y. miroshnychenko , a. rauschenbeutel , and d. meschede , phys .
lett . * 93 * , 150501 ( 2004 ) .
h. kim , h. s. han , and d. cho , phys .
lett . * 111 * , 243004 ( 2013 ) . h.
s. han , s. yoon , and d. cho , j. korean phys .
66 * , 1675 ( 2015 ) .
j. y. kim , j. s. lee , j. h. han , and d. cho , j. korean phys .
soc . * 42 * , 483 ( 2003 ) . m. s. safronova , u. i. safronova , and c. w. clark , phys . rev .
a * 86 * , 042505 ( 2012 ) .
k. b. davis , m. -o .
mewes , w. ketterle , appl .
b * 60 * , 155 ( 1995 ) . | we demonstrate _ in situ _ fluorescence detection of @xmath0li atoms in a 1d optical lattice with single atom precision . even though illuminated lithium atoms tend to boil out , when the lattice is deep , molasses beams without extra cooling retain the atoms while producing sufficient fluorescent photons for detection .
when the depth of the potential well at an antinode is 2.4 mk , an atom remains trapped for 30 s while scattering probe photons at the rate of @xmath1 s@xmath2 .
we propose a simple model that describes the dependence of the lifetime of an atom on well depth .
when the number of trapped atoms is reduced , a clear stepwise change is observed in integrated fluorescence , indicating the detection of a single atom . at a photon - collecting efficiency of only 1.3% owing to small numerical aperture , the presence or absence of an atom
is determined within 300 ms with an error of less than @xmath3 . |
horizontal branch ( hb ) stars are the progeny of low - mass red giant branch stars ( rgb ) burning helium in their cores and hydrogen in a shell around it ( hoyle & schwarzschild 1955 ) .
as first noticed by iben & rood ( 1970 ) , the different hb star colour distributions observed in old stellar systems , is the reflection of the amount of mass lost during the rgb phase .
+ the scientific community agrees from nearly fifty years about the fact that the principal parameter governing the shape of hbs in galactic globular clusters ( ggcs ) is metallicity .
the general rule is that metal - rich systems have red hbs , while in the metal - poor ones stars are distributed on average at higher effective temperatures ( bluer colours ) .
several exceptions have come out during the last decades ; remarkable cases the cases of ngc6388 and ngc6441 ( rich et al .
1997 ) , which despite their metallicity ( @xmath5\sim-0.6 $ ] ) show some of the bluest hbs known among ggcs ( busso et al . 2007
; dalessandro et al .
moreover several clusters , sharing similar metal content , reveal different hb morphologies , typical cases being the pairs ngc5927 - ngc6388 at high metallicities ( @xmath5\sim-0.4 $ ] ) , m3 - m13 at intermediate metallicity regime ( @xmath5\sim-1.5 $ ] ; ferraro et al .
1997 ) and m15 - m92 at low metallicities ( @xmath5\sim-2.3 $ ] ) .
+ these noticeable exceptions have required the introduction of a second ( freeman & norris 1981 ) and possibly a third parameter in order to explain the hb distributions in all ggcs .
what we can call now the _
`` i - th parameter problem '' _ is still a hot topic , as stressed by several authors , we recall the reader to catelan 2009 for a nice review ( see also dotter et al . 2010 and gratton et al . 2010 ; hereafter d10 and g10 respectively ) . +
an accurate knowledge of the physical parameters playing a role in shaping the hb is extremely important also for an appropriate interpretation of distant unresolved stellar populations .
in fact it is well known that the hb morphology can have a strong impact on the integrated light of stellar populations , affecting colours and line indices ( lee et al .
2002 ; schiavon et al .
2004 ; percival & salaris 2011 ; dalessandro et al . 2012 ) . + despite the huge efforts made to address this problem , its solution is not obvious and still different scenarios are proposed .
one of the reasons that complicates the identification of the mechanisms other than metallicity at work in shaping the observed luminosity and effective temperature distribution of stars along the hb is that there are many possible culprits ( mass - loss , age , helium abundance ... ; see rood 1973 for example ) and some of them are not well constrained from theory .
+ age has been identified as the natural global second parameter by many authors in the past years ( lee et al .
1987 , 1988 , 1990 ; lee , demarque & zinn 1994 ; sarajedini & king 1989 ) . according to this interpretation
older clusters tend to have bluer hbs , while younger ones should have on average redder hb morphologies .
this scenario appeared in agreement with the picture for the galaxy formation and its early evolution ( searle & zinn 1978 ; zinn 1985 ) . by means of high resolution hst data for a large sample of ggcs , d10 found that the existence of outer halo gcs with anomalously red hbs fits well the scenario in which age is the second parameter .
in fact , the behaviour of the 4 - 5 relatively younger clusters in their sample could be reproduced in term of correlation between age and hb morphology , while the bulk of the analyzed targets is peaked around old ages ( see ages reported by salaris & weiss 2002 , g10 , d10 ) and does nt show any obvious correlation .
also results by g10 agree on the fact that age is the second main parameter driving the hb morphology .
+ it is also worth noticing that most of these results are based on optical cmds and hb morphology parameters ( like the well known hbr from lee et al .
1994 ) , which tend to minimize the importance of blue tails . on the contrary using proper combinations of ultra - violet ( uv ) and optical filters has an important impact both in term of hb classification and comparison with theoretical models .
still , age is not able to explain exhaustively the hb morphology .
detailed cluster to cluster comparisons have shown that there are systems with similar iron content and age , but remarkably different hb morphologies .
a clear example is given by the three clusters m3 - m13 - m80 , as shown by ferraro et al .
( 1997 , 1998 ) and at present there is hardly a scenario able to give a satisfactory explanation for their different morphologies . + as suggested by buonanno et al .
( 1985 ) and fusi pecci et al .
( 1993 ) , age might be one of many and probably the most important hb second - parameter , but not the only one .
buonanno et al .
( 1995 ) argued that it is not possible to reproduce the complex hb zoology with a single `` global '' parameter , but more likely we can explain it by thinking of a `` global combination '' of `` non - global '' quantities and phenomena related to the formation , chemical and dynamical evolution of each cluster .
+ the necessity of at least a third parameter transpires also from d10 and g10 analyses , in the form of either the luminosity cluster density or stellar density ( @xmath6 ) as already suggested by fusi pecci et al .
( 1993 ) which might correlate with the hot extension of the hbs , or a variation of the initial helium abundance ( y ) , respectively .
+ indeed dantona et al .
( 2005 ) and dalessandro et al .
( 2011 hereafter paperi ) have shown that for ngc2808 the main parameter that determines the hb morphology is y. in particular in paperi we have been able to satisfactory reproduce the cluster complex hb morphology by assuming three different sub - populations with he abundances compatible with what inferred from the multimodal main sequence ( ms ; piotto et al .
2007 ) and spectroscopic analyses ( bragaglia et al . 2010 ; pasquini et al . 2011 ) .
it is worth noticing however that only few clusters show evidences of multiple sub - populations with different he abundances as inferred from their ms or spectroscopic analyses ( ngc2808 , @xmath7 centauri bedin et al . 2004 , ngc6752
milone et al .
2010 , ngc6397
milone et al .
2012 ; ngc1851 gratton et al .
2012 ) + in order to further investigate the _
`` i - th parameter problem '' _ , we selected a triplet of ggcs with similar metallicity ( @xmath5\sim-1.50 $ ] ) and age , namely ngc5272 ( m3 ) , ngc6205 ( m13 ) and ngc1904 ( m79 ) as templates for a comparative analysis of their hbs .
these targets are basically the same used by ferraro et al . ( 1997 , 1998 ) , with the only exception of m80 , which have been replaced by m79 since recent spectroscopic analyses ( carretta et al . 2009 ) show that it is slightly more metal - poor than the others . as shown by ferraro et al .
( 1998 ) , m13 has a very extended hb with two clear gaps ( named g1 and g2 after their analysis ) ; while , the hb of m3 covers a much narrower extension in effective temperature and shows only a mild indication for a gap at the same @xmath8 as g1 in m13 .
m79 represents an intermediate case between the two . +
as already done for ngc2808 ( paper i ) we will use a combination of optical and uv photometric images .
details about data reduction are presented in section 2 . in section 3
we will focus on the long - standing debate about the age - differences between these clusters .
comparisons with theoretical models and cluster - to - cluster differences will be discussed in section 4 and 5 .
the data - set used in the present work consists of hubble space telescope ( hst ) wide field planetary camera 2 ( wfpc2 ) images .
all targets have been observed in the @xmath9 , @xmath10 and @xmath11 bands , the only exception is m3 for which no f160bw data are available .
( see table 1 ) .
images and photometry obtained in other bands are also available for some of the clusters , however as shown in rood et al .
2008 and paper i the combination of @xmath9 , @xmath10 and @xmath11 seems to be the best filters setup to study both rhbs and stars lying at the very hot end of the hb .
the photometric catalogues of m3 and m13 have been already partially presented by ferraro et al .
( 1998 ) , while the photometry of m79 has been already used by lanzoni et al .
. moreover far - uv photometry of m79 and m13 has been presented by rood et al .
( 2008 ) in order to describe in detail the advantages of using the combination of @xmath11 and @xmath9 magnitudes for comparison with hb models .
+ + in all cases the photometric analysis has been performed by using romafot ( buonanno et al .
the reduction strategy has been optimized to be particularly sensitive to hot stars , as already described by ferraro et al .
for the present analysis attention has been paid to the cross - identification of stars detected in the @xmath11 images .
stars observed only in these bands have been force - fitted in the other bands ( see paper i ) .
+ the instrumental magnitudes have been calibrated to the vegamag photometric system by using zero - points and the gain settings reported in table 5.1 of the wfpc2 _ _ data handbook manual__. magnitudes thus obtained have been also corrected for charge transfer efficiency ( cte ) effect by means of the prescriptions by dolphin ( 2000 ) and updated equations listed in the dedicated page of dolphin s web site .
+ the resulting colour magnitude diagrams ( cmds ) for each cluster are shown in both the ( @xmath12 , @xmath13 ) and ( @xmath14 , @xmath15 ) planes in figs [ cmdopt ] and [ cmdfuv ] .
star lists have been reported to the absolute coordinate system by mean of proper roto - traslations .
in particular , for each cluster the instrumental coordinates have been reported to the gscii astrometric standard system by using a large number of primary and secondary standards in common , consisting typically of wide field ground - based data - sets , in the wfpc2 fields of view ( fovs ) ( see lanzoni et al .
2007 for details ) . at the end of the procedure ,
the typical error of the astrometric solution is @xmath16 .
the identification of variable stars lying along the hb is a crucial step to perform a suitable comparison between observations and theoretical models .
this is particularly true in case of m3 , that hosts tens of rr lyrae stars .
+ however , none of the data - sets used here is designed for variability search , both because of the short time baseline covered and number of images acquired . in our cmds ,
variables are basically sampled at random phase .
thus we decided to use publicly available catalogues of variable stars in order to cross - identify them in our photometric catalogues , as already done in paper i. we retrieved position , magnitude , and classification lists from the `` catalogue of variable stars in galactic globular clusters ( 2011 ) '' ( clement et al .
we refer to that paper for all details and references . + we focused only on rrlyrae stars , neglecting all the other different variable types .
we first roto - traslated the catalogues of variables to our reference frames by using cataxcorr , a software developed at the bologna observatory ( montegriffo , private communication ) .
we then looked for stars in common with our photometry .
all the known rrlyrae stars in our fovs have been recovered in our catalogues .
we found 59 rrlyrae in m3 , 7 in m13 and 5 in m79 ( see table 1 ) .
their positions in the optical cmds are shown in figure [ cmdopt ] .
an accurate determination of metallicities and ages is a crucial point for hb morphology studies and for the correct interpretation of comparative analyses .
+ the three ggcs in our sample have a similar iron content : according to the recent reassessment of the gc metallicity scale by carretta et al ( 2009 ) , metallicities are equal to [ fe / h]=@xmath17 , @xmath18 and @xmath19 for m3 , m13 and m79 , respectively .
consistent results were also found by sneden at al .
( 2004 ) who obtained [ fe / h]=@xmath20 and @xmath21 for m3 and m13 ( for homogeneity we report only values obtained from the lick hamilton spectra ) . only in the analysis by cohen & melendez ( 2005 ) m3 and m13
are slightly more metal - rich , i.e. [ fe / h]=@xmath22 and [ fe / h]=@xmath23 .
in addition in this case the observed metallicity difference ( @xmath24[fe / h]@xmath25 ) is larger than the uncertainties .
+ gyr and @xmath26 gyr .
the right panel shows synthetic cmds obtained from the adopted isochrones and the appropriate photometric errors.,width=370 ] on the contrary the determination of their ages is a more debated argument . in literature
there is a quite general consensus that m3 and m79 are old and coeval ggcs .
there is instead more uncertainty about the age of m13 .
ferraro et al . ( 1997 ) put constraints on the possible difference in age between m13 and m3 by comparing their ridge mean lines obtained with the optical cmds used in this work , and theoretical models by dorman et al .
the age difference resulted to be smaller than @xmath27 gyr .
the same conclusions have been reached also by johnson & bolte ( 1998 ) and rosenberg et al .
according to the analysis by grundahl et al .
( 1999 ) m13 may be younger than m3 by @xmath28 gyr , while for rey et al .
( 2001 ) it is older by about @xmath29 gyr .
+ ages reported by other authors for the clusters of our analysis agree quite well within the error bars .
salaris & weiss ( 2002 ) found a typical difference smaller than @xmath30 gyr independently of the metallicity scale used .
ages by d10 obtained using the isochrone - fitting method are basically identical ; in fact t=@xmath31 gyr and t=@xmath32 gyr for m3 and m13 respectively , while m79 is not in their sample .
the same results were obtained by marin - franch et al .
for g10 instead , m13 is older than m3 and m79 of about @xmath33 1.75 gyr .
+ it is worth noticing that even moderate differences of the average y among these three clusters do not affect appreciably the results of the methods employed to determine their relative ages ( see , e.g. , marin - franch et al .
2010 ) . + we investigated any possible age difference by comparing the ( @xmath34 ) cmds of the three clusters of our analysis .
but for m3 and m13.,width=370 ] we used m13 as reference and shifted m79 and m3 according to the difference of @xmath35 values and distance moduli ( see sections 3.2 , 3.3 and 3.4 for details about the values adopted ) .
as apparent from the upper panels of figure [ m13m79 ] and [ m13m3 ] , once relative differences in reddening and distance are taken into account , the cmds match well at the to level and along the rgb , consistently with the fact that they have almost the same age and share a similar metallicity .
+ in the bottom panels we focus on their turn off ( to ) region . also from a close inspection ,
the cmds have been found to nicely overlap at the to and sgb region .
this already rules out any significant age difference between m13 , m3 and m79 .
however in order to perform a more accurate comparison , we also used two isochrones of proper metallicity and different age from the basti database ( pietrinferni et al .
in particular we used as reference the isochrone that best fits the observed cmd ( @xmath36 gyr ) and an additional one that is @xmath37 gyr older .
as apparent from the left bottom panels of figures [ m13m79 ] and [ m13m3 ] , the older isochrone does not match either the to or the sgb .
+ starting from these isochrones , and using the estimated photometric errors we build two synthetic populations of similar size to the observed ones for each comparison . with the typical uncertainties of our hst catalogues at the to magnitude level ,
an age difference of @xmath37 gyr would be clearly visible and detectable .
we then conclude that m13 , m3 and m79 differ in age by less than @xmath38 gyr .
this result is in agreement with estimates by several authors ( johnson & bolte 1998 ; rosenberg et al .
1999 ; salaris and weiss 2002 ; marin - franch et al .
2009 ; d10 ) , while it is incompatible with the age differences proposed by g10 .
it is worth noticing that an age difference of about @xmath39 gyr would be compatible with the observed data only assuming extremely different he abundances ( @xmath40 ) between these clusters .
we have shown that m3 , m13 and m79 have similar metallicities and are coeval within typical uncertainties . therefore in this case , the scenario proposed by g10 and d10 , identifying the _ second parameter _ with age , is not applicable .
we therefore investigate here the possible role of variations of helium abundances in the framework of gcs having experienced multiple formation bursts ( dercole et al .
2008 ; conroy & spergel 2011 ; valcarce & catelan 2011 ) on a short timescale ( @xmath41 myr ) in environments enriched by material polluted by agb stars ( ventura et al .
2002 ) or fast rotating stars ( decressin et al . 2007 ) .
as highlighted before , helium has been proposed also by g10 to be the possible hb _
third parameter_. + as in paper i , we have compared our photometric data with a suitable set of basti @xmath42-enhanced hb tracks ( pietrinferni et al .
we have considered theoretical models for [ fe / h ] = @xmath431.62 , which is the closest value available in the basti database to the clusters spectroscopically determined [ fe / h ] . in our analysis
we take advantage of all initial he - abundances available in the basti database , i.e. y=0.246 , 0.300 , 0.350 and 0.400 .
bolometric corrections and extinction effects have been calculated as in paper i. recently , gratton et al .
( 2011 ) have found spectroscopical evidence of a moderate na - o anti - correlation in stars belonging to the hb of ngc2808 , at @xmath44 below @xmath4512000 , that marks the onset of radiative levitation effects ( see discussion below ) . a similar result has been found for m 4 by marino et al .
( 2011 ) , the general trend being that the bluer hb stars are on average more na - rich and o - poor . as a consequence of these empirical results , we verified by performing a number of tests ( see appendix a ) how adequate is the use of standard @xmath42-enhanced spectra to determine bolometric corrections in this temperature regime .
we found that results obtained by using standard @xmath42-enhanced bolometric corrections , are unaffected by the presence of the observed cnona anti - correlations . regarding the effect of radiative levitation , spectroscopic investigations by behr ( 2003 ) , moehler et al .
( 2003 ) , fabbian et al .
( 2005 ) have disclosed that - similar to the case of ngc2808 - in these three clusters hb stars hotter than @xmath4512000 k display surface abundances of metal species like fe , cr and ti around solar or higher , due to radiative levitation in the atmosphere . also , the surface he abundances are depleted by a factor of ten or more as a consequence of gravitational settling . following the approach used in paper i
, we mimic this effect using standard @xmath42-enhanced hb stellar models by applying bolometric corrections appropriate for [ fe / h]=0.0 ( and scaled - solar mixture ) when @xmath44 is above 12000 k. this is of course a crude approximation , which we are forced to adopt because of the lack of extended grids of both hb stellar evolution and atmosphere models with a large range of chemical compositions , that include consistently the effect of radiative levitation .
the underlying assumptions are that _
( i ) _ the hb model evolutionary lifetimes , _ ( ii ) _ the evolution of @xmath44 and _ ( iii ) _ bolometric luminosity , and _
( iv ) _ the structure of the corresponding model atmospheres are not affected by the radiative levitation , and that the relevant bolometric corrections are determined mainly by the enhanced metals . with these assumptions
the effect of radiative levitation on bolometric corrections makes @xmath12 fainter by about 0.15 and @xmath14 and @xmath46 brighter by about 0.1 and 0.05 respectively .
paper i has shown how this approximation allowed us to recover the three different he - abundances inferred by the multimodal ms , along the blue hb of ngc2808 .
we are therefore confident that a similar procedure will be adequate to constrain the he distribution along the hb of these three clusters , that we are going to discuss separately in the following section .
the theoretical analysis performed in this paper is based on synthetic hb calculations , performed as described in paper i. the analysis of ngc2808 was simplified by the fact that the initial he content of the cluster subpopulations is somewhat quantized , as shown by the observed trimodal ms ( piotto et al .
in case of m13 , m3 and m79 there is no apparent quantization of the ms , and we need to consider the possibility of a continuous distribution of y along the hb .
+ we stress here that in these cases the modeling of the y variations along the hb becomes more uncertain since calculations require more assumptions .
therefore the main goal of this work is not to attempt an exact description of the y distribution , that would be affected by our assumptions , but to understand whether helium plays a role in shaping these very different hbs .
uv filters are much better suited than optical ones to address this issue .
our synthetic hb calculations require the specification of at least 4 parameters , plus the cluster age , that we assume to be equal to 12 gyr ( see section 3 ) .
these four parameters are the minimum value of y ( @xmath47 ) , the range of he abundances ( @xmath48 ) , the mean value of the mass lost along the rgb @xmath49 that in first instance ( and for simplicity ) we assume to be the same for each y and the spread around this mean value ( @xmath50 ) . throughout our analysis
we will assume that y varies according to either a uniform probability distribution , from @xmath47 to @xmath51 , or a gaussian one . in this latter case
@xmath48 is the 1@xmath52 spread around a prescribed mean value . also for the rgb total mass loss we will assume a gaussian distribution around the mean value @xmath49 or a uniform distribution with minimum value equal to @xmath49
the idea behind this type of simulations ( see , e.g. , caloi & dantona 2005 ) is that the colour extension of the hb is driven mainly by the variation of y rather than mass loss efficiency .
a higher initial y implies a lower mass at the tip of the rgb ( for a fixed cluster age ) hence , for a fixed value of @xmath49 , a smaller mass along the hb and a bluer colour ( the he - core mass is affected by the variation of y to a smaller extent ) .
our synthetic hb code first draws randomly a value of y , and determines the initial mass of the star at the rgb tip ( @xmath53 ) from interpolation among the basti isochrones of the prescribed age .
the mass of the corresponding object evolving along the hb ( @xmath54 ) is then given by @xmath55 plus a gaussian random perturbation @xmath50 ( or a uniform probability between @xmath49 and @xmath49+@xmath50 ) .
the wfpc2 magnitudes of the synthetic star are then determined according to its position along the hb track with appropriate mass and y obtained by interpolation among the available set of hb tracks after an evolutionary time t has been randomly extracted .
we determined t assuming that stars reach the zahb at a constant rate .
we employed a flat probability distribution ranging from zero to @xmath56 , where @xmath56 denotes the time spent from the zahb to the he - burning shell ignition along the early agb .
the value of @xmath56 is set by the mass with the longest lifetime ( the lowest masses for a given y and z ) .
this implies that for some synthetic object the randomly selected value of t will be longer than its @xmath56 or , in other words , that they have already evolved to the next evolutionary stages .
finally , the derived synthetic magnitudes are perturbed with a gaussian 1@xmath52 error determined from the data reduction procedure .
we detail now the effects on these results of possible variations of age and chemical composition within the uncertainties described in section 3 . the mass distribution along the hb ( as derived in our analysis )
does not depend on the cluster age , but changing the cluster age changes the mass loss necessary to reproduce the hb mass distribution .
an increase of age of @xmath57 gyr leads to a decrease of the total mass loss along the rgb by @xmath58 ( because of the decreased evolving mass ) .
+ one can simulate the effect of a variation of [ fe / h ] , [ @xmath42/fe ] and/or their sum by considering that at these metallicities scaled solar and @xmath42-enhanced models ( also for the hb ) with the same total global metallicity [ m / h ] are coincident ( salaris et al . 1993 ) .
we have therefore considered a change @xmath59=+0.3 $ ] dex that corresponds to changes of [ fe / h ] or [ @xmath42/fe ] or [ fe / h]+[@xmath42/fe ] .
we have two effects here .
the first one is on the derived mass distribution ( at fixed y ) along the hb . for the redder part of the hb we use the ( @xmath14,@xmath15 ) colour . at fixed colour in the horizontal part of the ( @xmath60 ) cmd , an increase @xmath24[m / h]=0.3 decreases the derived value of @xmath54 by @xmath450.04 @xmath61 . for the blue tails we use the ( @xmath62 )
fixed ( @xmath63 ) an increase @xmath24[m / h]=0.3 decreases the derived value of @xmath54 by @xmath64 @xmath61 .
this means that if a larger mass loss is needed to explain the blue hb stars ( compared to the mass loss needed to explain the redder population ) , an increase of [ m / h ] tends to reduce this mass loss difference .
the second effect is on the rgb mass ( hence on the absolute value of the rgb mass loss ) .
an increase @xmath24[m / h]=0.3 causes an increase of @xmath65 by @xmath66 @xmath61 .
the distribution of y along the observed hbs is basically unaffected by the precise age and [ m / h ] , because it is based on the variation of magnitude ( in @xmath14 and @xmath12 , depending on the star colour ) with y , a differential property that is unaffected by the exact model metallicity and age .
in this section we will discuss separately the theoretical analysis of our three selected clusters .
we stress again that allowing y to vary within individual clusters , increases the number of free parameters needed to match the observed hb star distribution in the cmd . leaving aside for a moment the open problem of the rgb mass loss ,
the distribution of y among stars fed onto the hb will depend on the convolution of the unknown ( at least for these three clusters ) initial y distribution among ms stars , with the y - dependent evolutionary timescales along ms and rgb predicted by stellar models .
as discussed before , in absence of constraints from the ms , we assumed here as a first order approximation either gaussian or uniform probability distribution for y among hb stars .
as a consequence , the derived distribution of y and mass range ( at fixed y ) are most probably just a reasonable approximation to the real ones .
a much more solid result is the total range of y covered by the stars in each individual cluster , because thanks to our uv cmds this is strongly constrained by the observed stellar magnitudes @xmath12 ( when available ) . )
cmd of m13 hb .
zahb sequences for y=0.246 ( solid line ) , 0.300 ( dashed line ) and 0.350 ( dot - dashed line ) are also displayed .
the rectangular box marks the rhb region ( see text for details).,width=317 ] spectroscopic analyses of this cluster reveal a well developed na - o anti - correlation ( sneden et al .
2004 , carretta et al .
2009 ) , comparable to the case of ngc2808 , but photometric analyses currently available do not show evidences for a multimodal ms . here
we analyze our hb photometry with as stated before the main aim of constraining the range of initial he values of the cluster stars .
the use of the f160bw filter not considered in the investigations by caloi & dantona ( 2005 ) and dantona & caloi ( 2008 ) will set strong constraints on the maximum value of y. the first step of our analysis consists in defining the highest possible y value necessary to fit the observed hb . to this purpose
we calculated a synthetic hb with this preliminary set of parameters ( uniform distributions for y and gaussian for m ): @xmath47=0.246 , @xmath48=0.104 , @xmath49=0.21@xmath67 , @xmath50=0.025@xmath67 .
even though this selection of parameters is not optimized for a perfect fit to the observed stellar distribution along the hb , it will suffice to put a first general constraint to the maximum possible range of initial y. the number of stars in this simulation is higher than the observed sample , to reduce the effect of statistical number fluctuations on the synthetic hb .
the parameter @xmath48 has been arbitrarily fixed to reach the maximum he mass fraction y=0.35 .
once @xmath47 is chosen , the mean rgb total mass loss @xmath49 is constrained by matching the red boundary of the observed hb ( the subpopulation with the lowest y has the largest hb mass at fixed age and @xmath49 ) .
the value of @xmath50 then introduces a general dispersion in the relationship between hb colour and local he abundance . the smaller the value of this parameter , the narrower the range of y in a given colour bin along the hb .
we notice that a very small value of @xmath50 ( @xmath50=0.005 for example ) , would produce a sloped hb ( brighter towards bluer colours because of a very tight colour - y relationship ) in the ( @xmath14 , @xmath15 ) cmd at colour ( @xmath15)@xmath68 0.5 , instead of the observed roughly horizontal structure ( see figure [ synthm13_1 ] ) .
but for the ( @xmath62 ) cmd ( see text for details ) . in the right panel
we also show two selected hb tracks corresponding to @xmath69 and @xmath70 for each zahb .
, width=317 ] as done in paper i , we determined the cluster distance modulus by fitting the synthetic data to the observed red hb ( rhb ) ( defined here as the region of the hb contained in the square box plotted in figure [ synthm13_1 ] ) in the ( @xmath71 ) plane .
notice how the rhb is roughly horizontal in this cmd , and allows us to estimate straightforwardly the cluster distance by comparing the synthetic data to the observed number distribution of objects in @xmath14 , assuming a reddening e(b@xmath43v)=0.02 ( see for example ferraro et al .
a fit to both the lower envelope defined as the faintest magnitude bin where the star counts are at least 2@xmath52 above zero of the observed binned distribution in @xmath14 , and the mean value of the @xmath14 rhb magnitudes ( @xmath72=15.26 ) provides @[email protected] , in fair agreement within the uncertainties with ferraro et al .
( 1999 ; @xmath75 ) .
the left and right panels of figure [ synthm13_1 ] show the observed and simulated ( @xmath71 ) cmd , respectively .
we have also over - imposed three zahbs for y=0.246 ( solid line ) , 0.300 ( long dashed line ) and 0.350 ( dot - dashed line ) .
figure [ synthm13_2 ] is equivalent to figure [ synthm13_1 ] , but for the ( @xmath76 ) cmd .
whilst in the ( @xmath77 ) cmd zahb sequences and synthetic stars with differing initial y are largely degenerate along the bluest hb tail as a consequence of the huge increase of the bolometric correction in the optical filters , this same tail appears as a roughly horizontal sequence at ( @xmath63)@xmath78 in the ( @xmath62 ) cmd .
theoretical zahb sequences display here different shapes at varying y ( see also pietrinferni et al .
it is clear from a comparison of the observed and synthetic hb that y=0.35 for the bluest stars is too high .
the lower envelope of the observed stellar distribution lies around the y=0.30 zahb .
this implies that the maximum y ( @xmath79 ) is @xmath450.30 . as a conclusion , in the hypothesis that the colour extension of the hb is due to a range of initial y values , @xmath47=0.246 at the red end of the observed hb implies @xmath800.30 at the blue end , i.e. the initial he - abundance spans a range @xmath810.05
this constraint on @xmath79 is very general ; the critical discriminating factor is provided by the @xmath12 magnitude of the zahb at the blue end of the hb .
but for one realization of the best fit synthetic hb model discussed in the text.,width=317 ] one can of course try a more accurate fit to the stellar distribution along the observed hb by comparing theoretical and observed histograms of star counts as a function of colour and magnitude . in this case
a fine tuned calibration of the set of free parameters is necessary . in the assumption ( for simplicity ) of either uniform or gaussian probability distributions for the mass loss and initial y
, one needs to split the simulation into three different sections , because no single continuous distribution of y and mass allows to match the observed cmds . as
a general method - applied also to m3 and m79 - , for each choice of the free parameters we have produced 100 synthetic distributions , each of them with the same number of objects as in the observational sample . from this ensemble of simulations we have determined the mean value and associated error for each colour or magnitude bin used in their comparison with data .
the star counts along the rhb on the red side of the gap at ( @xmath15)@xmath82 0.5 are best fit with @xmath47=0.246 , @xmath48=0.01 and uniform probability distribution for y , @xmath49=0.21@xmath67 , with a gaussian spread @xmath50=0.01@xmath67 .
the resulting distance modulus is @[email protected] , quite similar to the value obtained from the simulation in figure [ synthm13_1 ] .
the second section of the simulation covers the region from the blue boundary of the gap to a colour ( @xmath83)@xmath82 3.0 along the hb blue tail . in this case one needs a gaussian distribution of y , with mean value @xmath84=0.285 and 1@xmath52 spread @xmath85=0.012 , mass loss @xmath49=0.235 @xmath67 with a gaussian spread @xmath50=0.01@xmath67 .
the last section of the simulation covers the extreme tail of the hb , that is best reproduced with @xmath84=0.300 with a gaussian 1@xmath52 spread @xmath85=0.003 , and @xmath49=0.266 @xmath67 with a gaussian spread @xmath50=0.002@xmath67 .
figure [ synthm13_3 ] and figure [ synthm13_4 ] display a comparison between the observed hb in the ( @xmath60 ) and ( @xmath62 ) cmds , and one realization of the simulations with the parameter choice described before . from the parameters of this simulations ,
it is clear that a good match to the observed star counts can be obtained only by relaxing the assumption of constant @xmath49 for all initial he contents . in particular
, it appears necessary to slightly increase on average @xmath49 when y increases , as already highlighted in paper i for the case of ngc2808 .
however it is important to note that , the maximum y range is fully constrained independently of the assumptions on mass loss .
note that the slight increase of @xmath49 with @xmath86 could be in principle due to an age variation at increasing @xmath86 . in this scenario
the variation of @xmath49 corresponds to a variation of @xmath53 with y , keeping the total rgb mass loss unchanged .
however , these mass differences imply an increase of age with increasing y ( lower mass evolving along the rgb ) of the order of @xmath87 that is hard to justify .
in fact such a large age difference would be detectable from the cluster to and sub - giant branch regions , at odds with the empirical evidence ( figure [ m13m79 ] and figure [ m13m3 ] ) .
the mean he abundance along the hb of this simulation is @xmath84=0.270 , with a 1@xmath52 spread @xmath88=0.02 .
notice that salaris et al .
( 2004 ) determined for this cluster [email protected] from the r - parameter , consistent with the results of the simulation .
but for one realization of the best fit synthetic hb model discussed in the text.,width=317 ] we finally address the question of what happens if @xmath47 in rhb stars is increased . as a test ,
we have first considered a constant y=0.280 for the rhb as proposed by caloi & dantona ( 2005 ) and dantona & caloi ( 2008 ) and produced the corresponding synthetic population by tuning appropriately the value of the mass range along the rhb .
the distance modulus derived from the @xmath14 magnitudes of rhb stars is 0.14 mag larger than the case of our simulation with @xmath47=0.246 .
given that the @xmath12 magnitude along the extreme blue tail of the observed hb increases with increasing y ( see figure [ synthm13_2 ] ) , this higher distance modulus would imply [email protected] along the extreme hb ( ( @xmath63 ) @xmath893.5 ) , i.e. a value lower than along the rhb , a result justifiable only assuming a strong anti - correlation between mass loss and y. + this test also implies that in principle , for a fine tuned @xmath47 intermediate between 0.246 and 0.280 , the whole hb of m13 can be also modeled at least from the point of view of the magnitude levels in @xmath14 and @xmath12 employing a single value of y. we find that when @xmath900.265 , the ( @xmath60 ) and ( @xmath62 ) observed cmds and star counts can be reproduced with a constant he abundance , for a total mass spread of @xmath450.14 @xmath67 .
even if we can not discard this scenario on the basis of the hb analysis , we consider it very unlikely .
in fact it would mean that m13 lost completely its first generation of standard he stars , while preserving most of the he - enriched population .
this would be hardly compatible with results from n - body simulations ( see for example decressin , baumgardt & kroupa 2008 ) . )
cmd of m3 .
the zahb sequences for y=0.246 and y=0.300 are also displayed .
the rectangular box marks the region considered for the fit ( see text for details).,width=317 ] [ [ m3 ] ] m3 ~~ spectroscopic analyses of m3 rgb stars reveal a na - o anti - correlation that is reduced in extension compared to m13 ( see , e.g. , sneden et al .
2004 , johnson et al .
2005 and references therein ) . also in this case
, the currently available photometric data do not show evidence of a multimodal ms .
also , as well known , the hb of m3 displays a much shorter colour extension compared to m13 .
here we discuss its properties only in the ( @xmath60 ) cmd , because no @xmath11 images are available for this cluster . given the way in which hb stars are distributed in all cmds involving @xmath91 , it does nt give any additional information respect to the optical plane . also given the relatively short extension of the hb of m3 , we decided not to use the shorter wavelength @xmath91 filter . + we considered in our analysis all objects within the rectangular box in figure [ synthm3_1 ] .
our synthetic calculations show that all these stars have @xmath44 below the threshold for the onset of radiative levitation .
there are three stars outside the box , that may be genuine hb objects , and appear spread along the bluest tail of the cluster hb , that is vertical also in this cmd .
given their extremely small number compared to the total sample of hb stars , and the fact that their location does not provide any further constraint on the cluster he distribution , we do not consider them in the theoretical analysis . following the same philosophy as for the case of m13 , in the assumption of either uniform or gaussian distributions for the mass loss and initial y , observed star counts as a function of the @xmath14 magnitude and ( @xmath15 ) colour are best reproduced with @xmath47=0.246 , @xmath48=0.02 and uniform probability distribution , a minimum rgb total mass loss @xmath49=0.122@xmath67 with a range ( again uniform probability distribution ) of values @xmath50=9.0 @xmath92 ( y-0.246 ) @xmath67 , where y is the actual initial he mass fraction of the synthetic star .
it is obvious that this dependence of @xmath50 on y not imposed a priori but constrained by the fit to star counts as a function of magnitude and colour implies an increase of the mass loss spread with increasing y , that is required by the observed shape of the cmd in the ( @xmath60 ) plane . )
colour along the hb of m3 ( grey crosses ) and m13 ( black dots).,width=317 ] in fact as shown in figure [ synthm3_1 ] the reddest part of the zahb describes a steeply sloped sequence , before turning horizontal at @xmath93 . to match the observed star counts we need to increase the mass loss spread with increasing y.
this is necessary to reproduce both the steep increase of @xmath14 with decreasing colour when ( @xmath15 ) is larger than @xmath450.2 e.g. , the lower he subpopulations have to cover a relatively small mass range and the almost constant @xmath14 when the colour ( @xmath15 ) is bluer that this limit
e.g. , the higher he subpopulations have to cover an increasingly larger mass range .
the mean he abundance obtained from the synthetic hb is @xmath84=0.256 , with a 1@xmath52 spread @xmath88=0.006 , consistent with the value [email protected] obtained from the r - parameter by cassisi et al .
( 2003 ) . in the synthetic hb calculations
we have disregarded all objects lying in the rrlyrae instability strip , whose red and blue edges have been fixed at , respectively , log@xmath44=3.80 and log@xmath44=3.88 ( see , e.g. , the discussion in dantona & caloi 2008 ) , which define a very narrow colour width of @xmath94 at fixed @xmath14 approximatively in the range @xmath95 .
the distance modulus obtained as described in the case of m13 is @[email protected] with standard reddening value e(b@xmath43v)=0.01 which is fully in agreement with previous estimates ( ferraro et al .
1999 ; harris 1996 catalogue version 2010 ) . in this case
the maximum value of y ( @xmath96 ) is essentially constrained by the brightest limit of the stellar distribution at ( @xmath970.2 .
figure [ synthm3_3 ] displays stellar mass and y distributions as a function of the ( @xmath15 ) colour in one representative synthetic realization of the cluster hb , compared to the corresponding best - fit composite simulation of m13 .
not only the range of he values is obviously much larger in m13 , but also the shape of the y trend with colour is completely different in these two clusters .
the mass distribution forms a very smooth continuous sequence , with the maximum and minimum masses along the hb distribution in m3 being appreciably larger than the corresponding values in m13 . a detailed comparison with recent results by catelan et al ( 2009 ) and caloi & dantona ( 2008 ) is reported in appendix b. )
cmd of m79 hb .
the box marks the region used for the estimate of the cluster distance ( see text for details).,width=317 ] spectroscopic analyses of m79 rgb stars disclose an extension of the na - o anti - correlation that is intermediate between that of m13 and m3 ( see sneden et al . 2004 ,
carretta et al .
2010 ) , and photometric analyses do not reveal evidences of a multimodal ms . also the colour extension of its hb is intermediate between m13 and m3 . following the same approach as for m13 and m3 , we find that observed star counts as a function of magnitudes and colours are best reproduced with @xmath47=0.246 , @xmath48=0.035 and uniform probability distribution , a rgb total mass loss ( at a given y ) ranging from @xmath49=0.11@xmath67 to @xmath49=0.27@xmath67 , with a uniform probability distribution .
one realization of the best fit simulation is displayed in figures [ synthm79_1 ] and [ synthm79_2 ] .
the distance modulus has been determined from the fit to the stars contained within the box displayed in figure [ synthm79_1 ] ( denoted here as rhb ) as described for m13 .
assuming e(b@xmath43v)=0.01 ( harris 1996 ) we have obtained @[email protected] , values well in agreement with both ferraro et al .
( 1999 ) and harris ( 1996 ) . for the rhb stars we determine an average @xmath84=0.263 , with a 1@xmath52 spread @xmath98=0.010 .
the whole hb is characterized by @xmath84=0.265 , with a 1@xmath52 spread @xmath99=0.010 .
this means that the full range of y values is already present in the rhb sample . in the reasonable assumption that the spread of initial y scales with the extension of the na - o anti - correlation
, we should expect to find among rhb stars the full range of na - o abundances observed along the rgb .
a range of he abundances is necessary along the rhb to match the observed thickness in @xmath14 , and the large range of @xmath49 ( at fixed y ) is required to match the extended and almost horizontal structure of the rhb in the ( @xmath100 ) cmd .
figure [ synthm79_5 ] displays the mass and y distribution as a function of the ( @xmath15 ) colour in one representative synthetic realization of the cluster hb , compared to the m13 counterpart .
the range of y and the shape of the trend with colour are very different .
the maximum mass of hb stars in m79 reaches higher values compared to m13 , and the minimum hb mass is also higher than in m13 .
but for the ( @xmath62 ) cmd ( see text for details).,width=317 ] @|p1.1cmc||p0.7cmc||p1.0cmc||p0.6cmc||p0.6cmc||p0.5cmc| cluster & filter & @xmath101 & @xmath102 & @xmath79 & @xmath84 + m3 & f336w & 158 & 59 & 0.266 & 0.256 + & f555w & & & & + m13 & f160bw & 228 & 7 & 0.300 & 0.270 + & f336w & & & & + & f555w & & & & + m79 & f160bw & 130 & 5 & 0.281 & 0.265 + & f336w & & & & + & f555w & & & & + [ tab : tot ]
there is a general consensus that the first parameter shaping the globular cluster hb morphology is metallicity and the second one has been suggested by several authors ( lee et al .
2002 ; g10 ; d10 ) to be the age . while in general this picture may be surely adequate , however it is able to explain only few young clusters in the galaxy , while it fails to reproduce a number of `` classical '' cases where an additional ingredient ( sometime called third parameter ) is required .
the `` third parameter '' has been proposed to be the stellar density or luminosity density ( fusi pecci et al . 1993 ; d10 ) or the initial helium abundance ( g10 ) .
+ in this framework we considered three ggcs with similar age and metallicity , m3 , m13 and m79 , with the aim of studying their hbs . according to g10 , m3 is younger by @xmath45 2gyr than m13 , however we find , in agreement with a number of authors ( salaris & weiss 2002 ; marin - franch et al . 2009 ; d10 ) , that these clusters differ in age by less than @xmath103 .
this triplet is well known to have extremely different hbs , with m13 displaying by far the bluest morphology , and showing also evidence of at least 2 gaps at different effective temperatures , while m3 has been proposed over the years as a prototype of a `` normal '' hb . +
as done in paper i , we compared hst uv and optical cmds with theoretical hb models , with the aim of understanding the impact ( if any ) of cluster - to - cluster y variations on hb morphologies . at odds with the case of ngc2808 ,
the three gcs analyzed in this work , do not show ( so far ) evidences of quantized ms , so our analysis has been performed without any a priori knowledge of the y distribution .
as explained in section 4 , this forced us to enlarge the parameters space : the quantities needed are the minimum value of y ( @xmath104 ) and its full range ( @xmath48 ) , the mean value of the mass lost along the rgb @xmath105 and the dispersion around the mean value . as a consequence ,
it is hard in these cases to determine uniquely a full and detailed representation of the y variations along the observed hbs .
a more stringent and robust derivation involves instead the largest value of y ( @xmath79 ) that is clearly constrained by the distribution of stars in the @xmath106 cmds . for the case of m3 ,
given the shorter extension of its hb , the magnitudes @xmath14 give already a strong constraint on @xmath1 .
+ with these caveat in mind , we performed a detailed analysis by comparing observed cmds with a large set of synthetic cmds and zahbs from the basti database ( pietrinferni et al .
the effects of levitation for stars with @xmath107 k and anti - correlations along the hbs ( marino et al .
2011 ; gratton et al .
2011 ) have been considered . + we find differences @xmath108 between these ggcs .
in particular m13 displays the largest value ( @xmath109 ) , m3 ( @xmath110 ) the smallest one , and m79 is an intermediate case with @xmath111 .
these values are summarized in table 1 .
they seem to qualitatively correlate with the differences in the temperature ( colour ) extensions of the cluster hbs .
it is also interesting to note that our estimates of @xmath79 for these three clusters nicely correlate with the observed range of light - element variations . in particular
, m13 shows the most extreme na - o anti - correlation ( sneden et al .
2004 ) , with stars reaching [ o / fe]@xmath112 and [ na / fe]@xmath113 , while m3 the least extended one , [ o / fe]@xmath114 and [ na / fe]@xmath115 .
this is in line with the strict correspondence between hb colours and na - o abundances observed in ngc2808 by gratton et al .
+ the comparison between m13 and m3 is particularly interesting , because of several previous analyses of their hb morphology and y distribution .
for example catelan ( 2009 ) performed a detailed analysis comparing the mean masses of the hbs of these clusters with age differences proposed by different authors . by using several mass - loss recipes
, he found that there is no way to reproduce the different hbs of m3 and m13 only in terms of age , but at least one additional ingredient should be invoked to account for the blue hb extension observed in m13 .
our best - fit model for m13 requires to split the simulation in three steps , given that no single continuous distribution of y and mass loss allows to match the observed cmds .
thus we divided the hb in three groups : 1 ) the rhb with a typical @xmath116 and a mean mass lost = @xmath117 , 2 ) stars with @xmath118 best reproduced with @xmath119 and @xmath120 and 3 ) stars with @xmath121 which show a @xmath122 and @xmath123 .
a fit with a population of stars with uniform @xmath124 can not be ruled out on the basis of only the hb analysis , while a single population of stars with @xmath125 , as proposed by caloi & dantona ( 2005 ) and dantona & caloi ( 2008 ) , is incompatible with the distribution of stars in our uv cmd .
+ for m3 a single synthetic population with @xmath116 and distributed according to a uniform probability distribution with @xmath126 is required . a total mass loss of @xmath127 and a linear increase as a function of y , as constrained by the fit of star counts as a function of magnitude and colours ,
is needed . in the appendix b
we will discuss the y distribution derived from our simulations in the context of the constraints posed by the analyses by catelan et al .
( 2009 ) and dantona & caloi ( 2008 ) ; it turns out that our estimate of @xmath96 is robust .
+ as highlighted by g10 , while m13 seems to behave as other relatively massive clusters , m3 appears to be peculiar and a more extended hb would have been expected in this case .
the age difference proposed by g10 between these two clusters would justify at least in part the different hb morphology , in the framework in which age is the second parameter .
our results would instead lead to think that m3 and m13 experienced a different amount of enrichment of light elements .
this would be compatible with the scenario proposed by g10 ( see also carretta et al .
2009 ) that invokes a delayed cooling flow in the case of m3 .
in particular the hb simulations and derived @xmath86 distributions would suggest that m13 is qualitatively similar to ngc2808 , and that it likely experienced a similar star formation , while m3 ( and m79 ) probably had a less complex formation history .
+ analyses based on a suitable combination of uv to optical photometry and when available observed rr lyrae period distributions and synthetic hb simulations can provide not only insights on the hb second parameter problem , but in general they can potentially give some clues on the first stages of gcs formation and chemical evolution .
+ we thank the referee aaron dotter for useful comments and suggestions that improved the presentation of this work .
this research is part of the project cosmic - lab funded by the european research council ( under contract erc-2010-adg-267675 ) .
sc acknowledges the financial support of the ministero della ricerca scientifica e delluniversita prin miur 2007 : , the italian theoretical virtual observatory project and prin inaf 2011 * appendix a * + + * the effect of anti - correlations on bolometric corrections * + we checked the impact of cnona anti - correlations on the @xmath42-enanched bolometric corrections by performing a number of tests .
in particular , we have chosen three representative pairs of ( @xmath44 , @xmath128 ) values along our theoretical @xmath42-enhanced zahb with [ fe / h][email protected] , y=0.246 , namely ( 5600 k , 2.40 ) , ( 7000 k , 2.80 ) , ( 10000 k , 3.50 ) . for each of these pairs
we have calculated a synthetic spectrum with the synthe code by r.l .
kurucz ( sbordone et al . 2005 ) in the wavelength range between 1200 and 7500 @xmath129 , including all the atomic and molecular lines available in the latest version of the kurucz / castelli linelist .
the spectra were computed employing the lte , plane - parallel model atmospheres calculated with the atlas12 code ( castelli 2005 ) .
atlas12 adopts the `` opacity sampling '' method in the line opacity calculations , and allows to generate models for arbitrary chemical abundance mixtures .
all the model atmospheres and synthetic integrated spectra were computed with [ fe / h][email protected] and y=0.246 and both the standard [ @xmath42/fe]=0.4 metal distribution used in the stellar evolution models , and the cnona2 mixture by sbordone et al .
this latter mixture displays compared to our reference @xmath42-enhanced mixture enhancements of n and na by 1.44 dex and 0.8 dex by mass , respectively , together with depletions of c and o by 0.6 dex and 0.8 dex , respectively , and unchanged cno sum .
this mixture is representative of extreme values of the cn and nao anti - correlations observed in globular cluster stars ( see sbordone et al .
2011 for details ) .
it is also very important to notice that low - mass stellar evolution models calculated for this mixture turn out to be identical to models calculated with the standard @xmath42-enhanced metal distribution . from the synthetic spectra we have calculated bolometric corrections to the f160bw , f336w and f555w filters used in our analysis , for both metal mixtures .
only at @xmath1305600 k there is a difference for the f336w filter ( we did not consider the f160bw at this low temperature , because our photometry does not register cold hb stars in this passband ) that amounts however to only 0.03 mag ( cnona2 mixture stars appearing fainter ) .
given the small value of this difference and the fact that such extreme values of the anti - correlations appear not to be reached at such low temperatures along the hb , the outcome of our analysis of ngc2808 and the results of this paper , based on standard @xmath42-enhanced bolometric corrections , are unaffected by the presence of the observed cnona anti - correlations .
we have explicitly determined also the effect of he variations ( at fixed metal content ) on the bolometric corrections .
we considered the point with ( 7000 k , 2.80 )
i.e. around the blue edge of the rr lyrae instability strip and calculated spectra for our standard @xmath42-enhanced metal distribution , with y=0.35 . compared to the case with standard y=0.246 , both f336w and f555w bolometric corrections are changed by less than 0.01 mag .
the f160bw filter is affected at this level by less than 0.02 mag .
+ + * appendix b * + + * comparison with previous studies on the hb morphology of m3 . * + we address here two issues that arise from a comparison with recent results from the literature about the hb morphology of m3 .
first of all , the range of y derived from our simulations is about twice the value determined by catelan et al .
( 2009 ) from a comparison of theoretical zahb magnitudes and gravities with both strmgren photometry , and spectroscopically measured surface gravities and @xmath131 .
the size of the sample with spectroscopic gravities and @xmath131 estimates is relatively small , and within the corresponding error bars models with @xmath132 can not be easily ruled out .
more compelling seems to be the constraint from the strmgren cmds .
a fit of theoretical zahb models to the magnitude ( @xmath133 , @xmath134 and @xmath135 ) of the lower envelope of the observed hb at both the red side of the instability strip and at the knee of the stellar distribution beyond the blue edge of the strip , before the sparsely populated and not very extended blue vertical tail where zahbs of different y tend to become degenerate discloses a range of y at most equal to @[email protected] , with y increasing at the blue side of the strip .
this disagreement with our results is however only apparent , for it can be very easily explained by recalling that to any given @xmath0 value corresponds it is associated a dispersion in colour along the hb ( see section 4.1 ) .
figure [ synthm3_4 ] illustrates clearly this point by comparing a theoretical zahb for y=0.256 and @xmath44 larger than the blue edge of the instability strip shifted by our derived distance modulus and assumed reddening to the observed data .
notice how for ( @xmath136 ) , that corresponds to the region of the knee in the strmgren cmds , this zahb fits nicely the observed lower envelope of the cmd , even though the average y in that colour range inferred by the best - fit synthetic model , is 0.260 .
given the existence of a range of hb masses at fixed y , this colour interval is also populated by stars with y as low as @xmath450.255 , that are on average the faintest objects and hence determine the observed lower envelope of the magnitude distribution .
the second issue is related to the cluster rich rrlyrae population .
the period distribution of fundamental rrlyrae is strongly peaked , and in the recent literature attempts have been made to reproduce both the peaked period distribution and the hb colour extension .
castellani , castellani , & cassisi ( 2005 ) have shown that when keeping y constant , a suitable bimodal mass distribution with two different mass dispersions is able to reproduce the observed features . on the other hand , dantona & caloi ( 2008 ) assumed a range of y and a very small mass dispersion for the mass loss along the rgb , and reproduced the observed hb colour extension and rrlyrae periods by calibrating the y distribution ( instead of the hb mass distribution ) .
it is interesting to notice that dantona & caloi ( 2008 ) find from their simulations that 90% of hb stars are expected to have [email protected] , in agreement with our results , and only 10% of objects in their simulations reach y values above our estimated maximum y. here we have considered the synthetic objects in the best fit simulations that fall within the boundary of the instability strip ( using the same @xmath44 boundaries employed by dantona & caloi 2008 ) and were excluded from the comparison with the observed cmd .
we have calculated their pulsational periods using the relationships by di criscienzo et al .
( 2004 ) and compared with the observed distribution ( corwin & carney 2001 ) .
our predicted period distribution does not reproduce the observed ones , which is probably not surprising given our simple assumptions about the distribution of y among stars fed onto the hb . )
cmd of m3 using the y distribution proposed by dantona & caloi ( 2008 ) .
open symbols denote synthetic objects with [email protected] .
the zahb sequences for y=0.246 and y=0.300 are also displayed .
the rectangular box marks the region considered in the comparison ( see text for details).,width=317 ] as a test , we have calculated additional synthetic hb models for m3 , employing this time the @xmath139 y distribution proposed by dantona & caloi ( 2008 see their figure 4 ) to reproduce both the observed period distribution in the instability strip and the @xmath140 colour distribution along the hb , while keeping the same mass loss for all hb stars . as in dantona & caloi ( 2008 )
we employed a gaussian mass distribution ; our adopted mean mass loss is @xmath49=0.160@xmath67 with a small ( as discussed in dantona & caloi 2008 ) gaussian spread @xmath50=0.002@xmath67 , and employed the same reddening and distance modulus as in the previous simulations .
these choices allow to reproduce well the narrow period distribution ( both mean value of the logarithm of the periods and the 1@xmath52 dispersion ) whereas a comparison of the the stellar distribution in the cmd at the blue side of the strip is less satisfactory .
the left and right panels of figure [ synthm3_5 ] show the observed and simulated ( @xmath71 ) cmd . notice how the observed shape of the cmd is reasonably reproduced as long as y is below @xmath450.270 . for higher values of y ,
synthetic stars tend to reach too bright magnitudes ( while in the @xmath141 plane they tend to be located along the more vertical blue part of the hb , at / beyond the knee ) .
this reinforces our estimate of the y range as determined by our previous set of simulations that is the main purpose of our analysis and the need to increase the mass loss spread at the blue side of the instability strip instead of y in order to match the cmd location of the bluer objects . | we present a detailed comparison between far - uv / optical colour magnitude diagrams obtained with high - resolution _
hubble space telescope _ data and suitable theoretical models for three galactic globular clusters : m3 , m13 and m79 .
+ these systems represents a `` classical '' example of clusters in the intermediate metallicity regime that , even sharing similar metal content and age , show remarkably different horizontal branch morphologies . as a consequence
, the observed differences in the colour distributions of horizontal branch stars can not be interpreted in terms of either first ( metallicity ) or a second parameter such as age .
+ we investigate here the possible role of variations of initial helium abundance ( @xmath0 ) .
thanks to the use of a proper setup of far - uv filters , we are able to put strong constraints on the maximum y ( @xmath1 ) values compatible with the data .
we find differences @xmath2 between the clusters with m13 showing the largest value ( @xmath3 ) and m3 the smallest ( @xmath4 ) .
in general we observe that these values are correlated with the colour extensions of their horizontal branches and with the range of the observed na - o anti - correlations .
[ firstpage ] globular clusters : individual ( m3 , m13 , m79 ) ; stars : evolution horizontal branch ; ultraviolet : stars |
during the last few years the physics of isoscalar scalar mesons and in particular of the @xmath0 meson has received an revival of interest due to substantial progress in experimental and theoretical activities @xcite ( for a status report see , for example , ref .
originally , the light scalar meson @xmath0 was introduced as the chiral partner of the pion in the two - flavor linear @xmath0-model @xcite .
the linear @xmath0-model fulfils the chiral commutation relations , contains the partial conservation of the axial current ( pcac ) and has a manifestly renormalizable lagrangian . in approaches based on the linear realization of chiral symmetry ( see , for example , @xcite )
the @xmath0 meson serves to create spontaneous breaking of chiral symmetry , it generates the constituent quark mass and it is a relevant ingredient in explaining low - energy phenomenology ( @xmath11 scattering , @xmath12 enhancement in @xmath13 , attractive interaction between baryons in nuclear matter , etc . ) . on the other hand , the use of the linear or non - derivative @xmath0-model lagrangian leads to well - known difficulties .
for example , current - algebra results can not be reproduced at the tree level and can only be generated by mixing up different orders in the chiral expansion .
for this reason , it was suggested @xcite that the linear @xmath0-model lagrangian is modified in such a fashion that the results of current algebra are already produced at the tree level , while at the same time a clear chiral power counting is obtained .
this modification is based on a unitary , chiral field - dependent transformation of the quark / nucleon field , which eliminates the non - derivative linear coupling of @xmath8 and @xmath0 and replaces it by a nonlinear derivative coupling of the chiral rotation vector , identified as the new pion field .
this construction also serves as a basis for the formulation of chiral perturbation theory ( chpt ) @xcite , which is now considered as the realistic effective theory of low - energy hadron dynamics . in the context of the nonlinear realization of chiral symmetry a light @xmath0-meson
might be treated as a resonance in the @xmath11-system @xcite .
alternatively , for the linear case the @xmath0 can either be described as a member of a 4-quark multiplet @xcite or as quark - antiquark resonance @xcite .
the different mechanisms for generating a light @xmath7 do not necessarily exclude each other , but could in turn be related in a way which is not completely understood yet .
recently , the e791 collaboration at fermilab @xcite and the bes collaboration at bepc @xcite reported on evidence for a light and broad scalar resonance in nonleptonic cascade decays of heavy mesons . in the fermilab experiment it was found that the @xmath0 meson is rather important in the @xmath10 meson decay @xmath14 @xcite . in a coherent amplitude analysis of the @xmath15 dalitz plot the scalar resonance is determined with @xmath16 mev and total width @xmath17 mev .
a fraction @xmath18 of the decay mode @xmath19 is generated by the intermediate @xmath0-resonance channel .
the measured branching ratio of the two - body decay @xmath20 relative to the uncorrelated @xmath15 decay of the @xmath10 meson is then deduced as @xmath21 @xcite . the bes experiment @xcite concentrated on the nonleptonic decay @xmath22 .
the extracted values of the @xmath0 mass and width are : @xmath23 mev and @xmath24 mev .
preliminary analyses of these two experiments were performed in refs .
@xcite . in ref .
@xcite the relevant coupling constants of the respective two - body decays @xmath5 and @xmath4 were extracted from the data of the e791 experiment @xcite .
a direct calculation of the @xmath25 amplitude was done in ref .
@xcite in a constituent quark - meson model .
both analyses neglect the intrinsic momentum dependence of the @xmath26 transition form factor and , in the case of ref .
@xcite , the final state interaction in the three - body decay @xmath27 .
the two approaches @xcite arrive at a disagreement between the analysis of the nonleptonic two- and three - body decays of the @xmath10 meson .
the extracted @xcite or calculated @xcite coupling constant @xmath28 is approximately twice as large as the one deduced from experimental data on the two - body decay @xmath29 @xcite . in ref .
@xcite the effective coupling constant @xmath30 was estimated using the perturbative qcd technique . also , the role of the light @xmath0 as a elementary particle @xcite and as a correlated two - pion state @xcite was examined in @xmath31 decay . in the present paper
we consider the two - body nonleptonic decays involving the light @xmath0-meson with @xmath29 and @xmath32 .
we work in the framework of a qcd motivated , relativistic quark model which implements a linear realization of chiral symmetry @xcite-@xcite . in this context
the formalism also allows to describe the pion as a composite particle . to solidify and extent our considerations , we therefore also present a comprehensive analysis of the electromagnetic form factors of @xmath8 and @xmath0 associated with the transitions @xmath33 , @xmath34 and @xmath3 .
the specific scheme we work in can be viewed as an effective quantum field theory approach based on a lagrangian of light and heavy hadrons ( both mesons and baryons ) interacting with their constituent quarks @xcite-@xcite .
the coupling strength of a specific hadron to its constituent quarks is determined by the compositeness condition @xmath35 @xcite , where @xmath36 is the wave function renormalization constant of the hadron .
the compositeness condition enables to relate theories with quark and hadron degrees of freedom to effective lagrangian approaches formulated in terms of hadron variables only ( as , for example , chiral perturbation theory @xcite and its covariant extension to the baryon sector @xcite ) .
our strategy is as follows .
we start with an effective interaction lagrangian written down in terms of quark and hadron variables .
then , by using feynman rules , the @xmath37-matrix elements describing hadron - hadron interactions are given by a set of quark diagrams .
the compositeness condition is sufficient to avoid double counting of quark and hadron degrees of freedom .
the lagrangian contains only a few model parameters : the masses of light and heavy quarks , and scale parameters which define the size of the distribution of the constituent quarks inside the hadron .
this approach has been previously used to compute exclusive semileptonic , nonleptonic , strong and electromagnetic decays of light and heavy hadrons @xcite-@xcite employing the same set of model parameters . in such a way we consider the @xmath0-meson as a quark - antiquark bound state of the light @xmath38 and @xmath39 flavors .
we assume that the coupling strengths of both the pion and the sigma meson to the constituent quarks are identical in accordance with the linear realization of chiral symmetry .
based on this scheme the @xmath0 meson mass is determined as @xmath1 mev , which is in good agreement with the bes - result .
next we discuss in detail the gauging of the nonlocal meson - quark interaction and , for consistency , calculate the electromagnetic form factor of the pion .
we then proceed with the @xmath2 and @xmath3 processes . here
we obtain explicit expressions for the relevant form factors and evaluate the leading and next - to - leading order for large euclidean photon virtualities . as a result
we also obtain the two - photon decay width of the @xmath0-meson .
we compute the strong decay width for the process @xmath4 and finally turn to the nonleptonic decays @xmath5 and @xmath6 .
all our results are compared to available experimental data and to other theoretical studies .
the layout of the paper is as follows . in sec .
ii we begin by introducing the relativistic quark model which implements a linear realization of chiral symmetry .
iii is devoted to the derivation of the electromagnetic properties of the @xmath8 and @xmath0 mesons . in sec .
iv we examine the strong and nonleptonic decay characteristics of the transitions @xmath4 and @xmath40 . then in sec .
v we turn to a numerical analysis of the processes considered and discuss the quality of results in comparison with experiment and previous model calculations . finally , we summarize our results in sec . vi .
we will consistently employ the relativistic constituent quark model @xcite-@xcite to compute a variety of observables related to the @xmath8 and @xmath0 mesons . in the following
we will present details of the model which is essentially based on an effective interaction lagrangian describing the coupling between hadrons and their constituent quarks . the coupling of a meson @xmath41 to its constituent quarks @xmath42 and @xmath43 is set up by the lagrangian @xmath44 here , @xmath45 and @xmath46 are gell - mann and dirac matrices which inclose the flavor and spin quantum numbers of the meson field @xmath47 .
the function @xmath48 is related to the scalar part of the bethe - salpeter amplitude and characterizes the finite size of the meson . to satisfy translational invariance the function @xmath48 has to fulfil the identity @xmath49 for any 4-vector a. in the following we use a particular form for the vertex function @xmath50 where @xmath51 is the correlation function of two constituent quarks with masses @xmath52 , @xmath53 and @xmath54 .
the coupling constant @xmath55 in eq .
( [ lagr_str ] ) is determined by the so - called _ compositeness condition _ originally proposed in @xcite , and extensively used in @xcite-@xcite,@xcite .
the compositeness condition requires that the renormalization constant of the elementary meson field @xmath47 is set to zero @xmath56 where @xmath57 is the derivative of the meson mass operator . to clarify the physical meaning of this condition , we first want to remind that the renormalization constant @xmath58 is also interpreted as the matrix element between the physical and the corresponding bare state .
for @xmath35 it then follows that the physical state does not contain the bare one and is described as a bound state .
the interaction lagrangian of eq .
( [ lagr_str ] ) and the corresponding free parts describe on the same level both the constituents ( quarks ) and the physical particles ( hadrons ) which are supposed to be the bound states of the constituents . as a result of the interaction , the physical particle is dressed , i.e. its mass and wave function are to be renormalized .
the condition @xmath35 also effectively excludes the constituent degrees of freedom from the physical space and thereby guarantees that double counting for the physical observable under consideration is avoided .
now the constituents exist in virtual states only .
one of the corollaries of the compositeness condition is the absence of a direct interaction of the dressed charged particle with the electromagnetic field .
taking into account both the tree - level diagram and the diagrams with the self - energy insertions into the external legs ( that is the tree - level diagram times @xmath59 ) yields a common factor @xmath36 which is equal to zero .
we refer the interested reader to our previous papers @xcite-@xcite,@xcite where these points are discussed in great details . the meson mass operator appearing in eq .
( [ z=0 ] ) is described by the feynman diagram in fig .
1 . in the case of pseudoscalar @xmath60 and scalar @xmath61 mesons ,
relevant for the present paper , we obtain the expression @xmath62 \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath63 is the fourier - transform of the correlation function @xmath64 and @xmath65 is the quark propagator .
we use free fermion propagators for the valence quarks @xmath66 with an effective constituent quark mass @xmath67 . as discussed in @xcite-@xcite we assume for the meson mass @xmath68 that @xmath69 in order to avoid the appearance of imaginary parts in the physical amplitudes .
the calculational technique for determining the explicit expression of @xmath70 ( [ mass - operator ] ) is outlined in appendix a. the interaction with the electromagnetic field is introduced by two ways .
the free lagrangians of quarks and hadrons are gauging in a standard manner by using minimal substitution : @xmath71 where @xmath72 is a proton charge .
it gives us the first piece of the electromagnetic interaction lagrangian written as @xmath73 the gauging nonlocal lagrangian in eq .
( [ lagr_str ] ) proceeds in a way suggested in @xcite . to guarantee local invariance of the strong interaction lagrangian , in @xmath74 one multiplies each quark field @xmath75 with the gauge field exponentional that gives @xmath76 where @xmath77 it is readily seen that the full lagrangian is invariant under transformations @xmath78 where @xmath79 .
then the second term of the electromagnetic interaction lagrangian @xmath80 arises , when expanding the gauging exponential up to a certain power of @xmath81 , relevant for the order of perturbation theory and for the process we consider .
it seems that the results will be dependent on the path @xmath82 which connects the end - points in the path integral in eq ( [ path ] ) .
however , we need to know only derivatives of such integrals under calculations within the perturbative series .
therefore , we use a formalism @xcite which is based on the path - independent definition of the derivative of @xmath83 : @xmath84\end{aligned}\ ] ] where path @xmath85 is obtained from @xmath82 when shifting the end - point @xmath86 by @xmath87 .
use of the definition ( [ path1 ] ) leads to the key rule @xmath88 which in turn states that the derivative of the path integral @xmath83 does not depend on the path p originally used in the definition .
the non - minimal substitution ( [ gauging ] ) is therefore completely equivalent to the minimal prescription as evident from the identities ( [ path1 ] ) or ( [ path2 ] ) .
the method of deriving feynman rules for a non - local coupling of hadrons to photons and quarks was already developed in refs .
@xcite and will be discussed in the next section , where we apply the formalism to the physical processes considered here . for example , the piece of the lagrangian in eq .
( [ gauging ] ) in the first order over charge reads as @xmath89 transition matrix elements involving composite hadrons are specified in the model by the appropriate quark diagram .
for example , the transition form factor which characterizes the hadronic transition @xmath90 is determined from the feynman integral corresponding to the diagram of fig
. 2 : @xmath91\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where technical details concerning the derivation of integral ( [ lambda_trans ] ) are indicated in appendix a. finally we have to specify the vertex function @xmath92 ( eq . ( [ mass - operator ] ) ) , which characterizes the finite size of the hadrons .
any choice for @xmath92 is appropriate as long as it falls off sufficiently fast in the ultraviolet region of euclidean space to render the feynman diagrams ultraviolet finite .
we employ a gaussian for the vertex function @xmath93 , where @xmath94 is an euclidean momentum .
the size parameters @xmath95 are determined by fitting to experimental data , when available , or to lattice results for the leptonic decay constants @xmath96 where @xmath97 .
the leptonic decay constant @xmath98 is determined from @xcite @xmath99 \ , .\ ] ] to reduce the set of values for @xmath100 , we use a unified size parameter for hadrons with the same flavor content .
the best fit to the decay constants @xmath96 is obtained ( see table i ) when the values of the constituent quark masses and the parameters @xmath100 are choosen as follows @xcite @xmath101 and @xmath102 in this paper we are aiming to explore the properties of pions and light @xmath0-meson .
we write down the relevant interaction lagrangian in accordance with the two - flavor linear @xmath0-model @xcite @xmath103 \
, q(x - y/2 ) \ , .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] here the constraints on the bare couplings @xmath104 and the vertex functions @xmath105 are imposed by chiral symmetry .
we also require that the dressed couplings determined from the compositeness condition of eq.([z=0 ] ) should be equal each other .
this requirement allows us to determine the @xmath0 meson mass by the equality @xmath106 where the physical pion mass @xmath107 is used as an input . with the hadron parameters fixed , from eq .
( [ matching_sigma ] ) , we deduce a @xmath0 mass of @xmath108 the predicted value we obtain is close to the bes result @xcite of @xmath23 mev , which sets the lower scale for the range of mass values compiled in @xcite .
in this section we proceed with the formalism on the electromagnetic properties of @xmath8 and @xmath0 mesons . for consistency
we also include the @xmath8 meson in the discussion , where , in addition , the model predictions will serve to solidify the validity of the previously outlined approach . in the analysis we consider the following related processes : the electromagnetic transition of charged pions , that is @xmath109 , and the form factors characterizing the transitions @xmath2 and @xmath3 for different kinematical regimes of the photons ( real and virtual ) all amplitudes considered are obtained in a manifestly gauge - invariant form .
when gauging ( [ gauging ] ) the nonlocal strong interaction lagrangian @xmath74 , additional `` contact '' vertices are generated , which couple hadrons , quarks and photons , as already discussed in sec .
ii . in particular , for the process @xmath109 we need a vertex describing the coupling of a charged pion , a single photon and two quarks ( fig.3a ) .
the coupling of @xmath0 to a photon and two quarks ( fig.3a ) and to two photons and two quarks ( fig.3b ) will contribute to the transition @xmath3 .
the full set of feynman diagrams for the electromagnetic transition amplitudes considered are summarized in the following : the transition @xmath109 is described by a triangle diagram ( fig.4a ) and the two additional contact diagrams of figs.4b and 4c . as mentioned in sec.ii , the diagram describing the direct coupling of pions to a photon is compensated by the counterterm ( see eq .
( [ l_em_1 ] ) .
the process @xmath2 obtains a contribution by the single diagram of fig.5a .
the transition amplitude @xmath3 is generated by the four diagrams of fig.5 : a triangle diagram ( fig.5a ) and three contact diagrams ( figs.5b - d ) . in the following
we denote diagrams containing a contact vertex with a single photon line ( figs.4b , 4c , 5b and 5c ) as `` bubble''-diagrams and the amplitude of fig.5d as `` tadpole''-diagram .
the dominant contribution to the electromagnetic form factors arises from the leading triangle diagrams ( fig.4a and 5a ) .
we will demonstrate that diagrams containing contact vertices give negligible contribution , but in general they should be kept to guarantee electromagnetic gauge invariance .
feynman rules for the evaluation of the nonlocal vertices of figs.3a and 3b are derived in appendix b. next we will give the definition of the amplitudes for the processes @xmath109 , @xmath2 and @xmath3 and discuss the properties of the relevant form factors .
it is convenient to write down the vertex function for the transition @xmath111 in the form @xmath112 \ , + \
, \lambda^\mu_\perp(p , p^\prime ) \end{aligned}\ ] ] from which the ward - takahashi identity follows immediately @xmath113 for setting up the electromagnetic vertex function of eq .
( [ vertex_pion ] ) we use the pion mass operator @xmath114 with @xmath115 \ , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath116 is the part which is orthogonal to the photon momentum : @xmath117 .
the explicit expression for @xmath116 results from the sum of the gauge - invariant parts of the triangle @xmath118 ( fig.4a ) and of the bubble ( bub ) diagrams ( figs.4b and 4c ) : @xmath119 the separate contributions @xmath120 and @xmath121 are given by @xmath122 ^ 2\biggr ) \ , \tilde\phi\biggl(-\biggl[k+\frac{p^\prime}{2}\biggr]^2\biggr ) \ , { \rm tr}[\gamma^5 s(k + p^\prime ) \gamma_{\perp ; \
, q}^\mu s(k + p ) \gamma^5 s(k ) ] \,,\nonumber\\ i^\mu_{\rm bub_\perp}(p , p^\prime ) & = & \frac{\eta^\mu}{\eta^2 } \ , \int \frac{d^4k}{4\pi^2 i } \ , \tilde\phi(-k^2 ) \ , \int\limits_0 ^ 1 dt \ ,
\tilde\phi^{\ , \prime}\biggl(- k^2 - t\biggl[kq + \frac{q^2}{4}\biggr]\biggr ) \,\ , k\eta \,\ , \biggl\ { d(p ) - d(p^\prime ) \biggr\ } \ , .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath123 .
also , @xmath124 and @xmath125 are orthogonal to the momentum transfer @xmath126 with @xmath127 . in the limit @xmath128
we obtain @xmath129 while , by definition , we also have @xmath130 where @xmath131 is the pion charge form factor at the origin . from the comparison of eqs .
( [ ward_id ] ) and ( [ normaliz ] ) it follows that the compositeness condition ( [ z=0 ] ) is equivalent to the normalization of the pion form factor at the origin with @xmath132 .
the full electromagnetic form factor @xmath110 of the pion is defined by @xmath133 where @xmath134 is the euclidean momentum transfer squared . the electromagnetic radius of the pion , related to the slope of @xmath110 at the origin ,
is then given by @xmath135 the matrix elements for the transitions @xmath2 and @xmath3 can be written in general in the manifestly gauge - invariant form @xmath136 the tensors @xmath137 , @xmath138 and @xmath139 refer to the lorentz structures : @xmath140 while @xmath42 and @xmath141 are the photon four - momenta and @xmath142 is the meson momentum . here , @xmath143 is the @xmath2 form factor .
the transition @xmath3 is characterized by two form factors : @xmath144 and @xmath145 .
usually only one of the form factors , that is @xmath146 , is discussed in the literature . however ,
when both photons are off - shell , constraints set by gauge invariance result in the two terms of the matrix element @xmath147 , proportional to the lorentz structures @xmath138 and @xmath139 .
if at least one of the photons is real , then only the first form factor @xmath146 gives a non - vanishing contribution to the invariant matrix element .
the decay width of the transition @xmath148 with @xmath149 or @xmath0 is given by @xmath150 where @xmath151 is the @xmath152 coupling constant and @xmath153 .
for the evaluation of the @xmath154 form factors we pursue the following strategy .
first we consider the calculation of the form factors @xmath143 , @xmath144 and @xmath145 in so - called local limit . in this case
the dimensional parameter @xmath155 , appearing in the @xmath156 meson vertex function @xmath157 , is taken to infinity or , which is equivalent , @xmath158 .
we obtain analytical expressions for the @xmath154 form factors and show that for the case of @xmath159 the form factor has the incorrect behavior for large photon virtualities in the euclidean region .
then we repeat the derivation using the nonlocal approach and show that the correct asymptotics for the @xmath160 form factor can be reproduced when using the mesonic quark - antiquark wave function . the final numerical analysis for the complete form factors
will be done in a separate section .
the feynman integral corresponding to the local ( l ) triangle diagram is written as @xmath163 where @xmath164 for @xmath8 and @xmath165 for @xmath0 . for simplicity
we drop a common factor of @xmath166 . the complete integral ( [ triangle ] ) is free of the logarithmic ultraviolet ( uv ) divergence .
separate contributions to eq .
( [ triangle ] ) with the uv divergences are treated using dimensional regularization @xcite . in this case
we use the definition for @xmath167 in d dimensions ( see details in @xcite ) to guarantee the fulfilment of two important properties : @xmath168 and @xmath169 . for the pseudoscalar triangle the uv divergency
is completely gone due to the contraction of the divergent integral with the trace @xmath170 , which by definition is zero in any dimension . in the case of the @xmath162 diagram the use of the gauge - invariant regularization ( e.g. , dimensional regularization ) guarantees the cancellation of the uv parts and generates the correct finite part .
the finite part of the @xmath162 diagram is the same for both types of gauge - invariant regularizations .
the master formulas used in dimensional regularization are @xmath171 where @xmath172 with @xmath173 arises when using the @xmath174-parametrization . the integral eq.([triangle ] )
is gauge invariant @xmath175 as can be easily deduced from the ward identity @xmath176 and simple algebra .
the integral of eq.([triangle ] ) is particularly simple for the case of the pion with @xmath177 where the form factor @xmath178 is given by the two - dimensional integral @xmath179 : @xmath180 the double integral @xmath179 can be further reduced to a single one using the t hooft - veltman technique @xcite and can be finally expressed by a combination of spense functions . here
, however , we will stay with the integral representation .
we have @xmath181 } { \lambda^{1/2}\cdot x+q_1 ^ 2-\alpha_0\,p^2 } \right . \\ & & \nonumber\\ & & \left .
- \,\frac{\ln[1-x(1-x)\,q_2 ^ 2/m^2 ] } { \lambda^{1/2}\cdot x - q_1 ^ 2-q_2 ^ 2\,\alpha_0/(1-\alpha_0 ) } + \,\frac{\ln[1-x(1-x)\,q_1 ^ 2/m^2 ] } { \lambda^{1/2}\cdot x+q_1 ^ 2\,(1-\alpha_0)/\alpha_0+q_2 ^ 2 } \right\}\ , , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath182 is a kinematical triangle function and @xmath183 .
all three thresholds can be readily seen from this representation . in particular ,
when both photons are on their mass - shell ( @xmath184 ) we get @xmath185}{x(1-x ) } \\ & & \nonumber\\ & = & \frac{1}{4}\int\limits_0 ^ 1\ !
dv\ , \ln\left(\frac{1+\sqrt{1-v}}{1-\sqrt{1-v}}\right ) \cdot \frac{1}{m^2-v\cdot p^2/4-i\epsilon } \nonumber\\ & & \nonumber\\ & = & \int\limits_{4m^2}^\infty \frac{d\kappa^2}{\kappa^2}\cdot \frac{\rho(\kappa^2)}{\kappa^2-p^2-i\epsilon } = \frac{2}{p^2 } \left({\rm arcsin}\left[\sqrt{\frac{p^2}{4\,m^2}}\right]\right)^2\ , , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath186 is the spectral function .
another interesting limiting case is when one of the photons has large euclidean momentum , for instance , @xmath187 , @xmath188 and @xmath189 . in the limit
@xmath190 the integral eq.([triangle_loc ] ) reduces to @xmath191}{x(1-x ) } \to \frac{\ln^2(q^2/m^2)}{2q^2}. \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that such an asymptotics is in contradiction to the qcd - prediction for the @xmath192 form factor of @xmath193 @xcite . in the following we turn to the evaluation of the @xmath162 diagram in the local limit using dimensional regularization .
the defining integral of eq .
( [ triangle ] ) can be written as @xmath194 with @xmath195 and where the dot - product refers to the contraction of the lorentz indices . using the @xmath174-parametrization we have @xmath196 again , one integration in eq .
( [ coeff_alp1 ] ) can be performed analytically ( the resulting expressions ( [ coeff_res1 ] ) and ( [ coeff_res2 ] ) are indicated in appendix c ) . for the case
@xmath197 we get @xmath198 for a nontrivial , that is nonlocal , meson - quark vertex the evaluation of the relevant feynman diagrams is based on a method outlined in @xcite .
this technique was originally developed to derive a representation for the @xmath161 diagram ( fig.5a ) with a dressed pion - quark vertex , which is described by an arbitrary function @xmath157 decreasing rapidly in the euclidean region .
it also preserves translational and gauge invariance in a manifest way . in our model
the @xmath161 form factor is given by @xmath199 where @xmath200 is the nonlocal ( nl ) quark - loop integral : @xmath201 \left[m^2-(k - p/2)^2\right]\left[m^2-(k+q/2)^2\right ] } \nonumber\\ & & \\ & = & \int\limits_0^\infty\ ! dt \left(\frac{t}{1+t}\right)^2 \int\!d^3\alpha \ , \delta\left(1-\sum\limits_{i=1}^3\alpha_i\right ) \cdot\left\{-\tilde\phi^\prime(z)\right\ } \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath202 .
the argument @xmath203 appearing in the vertex function is written in the form @xmath204 we choose to define the functional dependence of the vertex function as @xmath157 , hence after transition to the euclidean region ( @xmath205 or @xmath206 ) the argument changes sign .
this convention allows a consistent choice of the functional form for @xmath207 in the euclidean region , where we finally perform the integrations .
for example , particular forms of the vertex function are @xmath208 ( gaussian vertex function ) or @xmath209 ( pole vertex function ) , where @xmath210 characterizes the size of the meson .
obviously , the limiting local case @xmath211 can be recovered for @xmath212 .
this limit also serves as a check for the numerical calculations used in the final step of the evaluation .
the following analytical results are obtained for an arbitrary form of @xmath157 . only when turning to the final numerical calculation ,
a specific form of @xmath207 ( gaussian vertex function ) will be used . again , one integration in eq .
( [ pion - nonloc ] ) is performed by linearization of the argument @xmath203 with respect to one of the @xmath174 parameters as it was done in the local case .
the resulting expressions are indicated in appendix d , as given by eqs .
( [ pi_nl1 ] ) and ( [ pi_nl2 ] ) . for the study of the dependence of the @xmath152 form factor on the photon virtualities in the euclidean region it is useful to introduce the variables : @xmath213 and @xmath214 where @xmath215 and @xmath216 are the total virtuality and the asymmetry , respectively should be rescaled as @xmath217 in all further formulas . ] . with this convention
we define the pion form factor as @xmath218 the particular choice @xmath219 corresponds to the physically interesting case where one of the photons is virtual and the other is on its mass - shell .
the corresponding transition form factor @xmath220 has recently been measured by the cleo collaboration @xcite for momentum transfers in the range from 1.5 to 9 gev@xmath221 .
a discussion of previous experiments can also be found in ref .
the cleo data confirmed the predictions of perturbative qcd ( pqcd ) @xcite for the asymptotic behavior of @xmath222 at large @xmath215 : @xmath223 where @xmath224 .
a detailed analysis of the different qcd approaches to the @xmath222 form factor has recently been done in @xcite .
unfortunately , a straightforward calculation of @xmath222 in the context of qcd is either not fully possible , because the operator product expansion ( ope ) fails at small @xmath215 , or contains unknown parameters like the twist - four scale parameter @xmath225 related to the gluon condensate @xcite .
therefore , an analysis of @xmath226 in our qcd - motivated approach seems to be quite reasonable .
information about the @xmath154 form factors for non - trivial photon virtualities is relevant to forthcoming experiments on production of pseudoscalar mesons in @xmath227 collisions . also , there is the project to search for a light scalar meson in very peripheral heavy ion collisions ( for a recent review see ref .
@xcite ) . for the analysis of @xmath228 we perform a systematic expansion in powers of @xmath193 including leading order ( lo ) and next - to - leading order ( nlo ) terms with @xmath229 the expansion coefficients @xmath230 and @xmath231
are given in our approach by @xmath232 the structure integrals @xmath233 and @xmath234 are derived in appendix d applying the chiral limit with @xmath235 and are written as @xmath236 where @xmath237 \ , \pm \ , \ln\left[\frac{1+t\,(1-\omega)}{1+t}\right]\ , , \nonumber\\ d(t,\omega)&\doteq & \frac{t}{[1+t\,(1+\omega)]\,[1+t\,(1-\omega)]}\ , .
\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the derivation of eqs .
( [ pigg_exp ] ) and ( [ jpi_exp ] ) we use the identity @xmath238 relating @xmath239 and the meson - quark coupling constant @xmath240 . from the expressions of eq .
( [ r_pi ] ) it can be readily seen that the expansion coefficients contain only even powers of @xmath216 , which is a consequence of bose - einstein symmetry and charge conjugation invariance . at this stage of the development
we indicate a first comparison of our results for the expansion coefficients calculated at @xmath241 and @xmath242 to the ones predicted by pqcd @xcite . a summary of previous model results for @xmath243 and @xmath244 can be found in ref .
first , we consider the experimentally accessible case @xmath245 , where one of the photons is real and and the other one is virtual . our numerical result for @xmath246 is in very good agreement with the pqcd prediction of @xmath247 @xcite .
the deviation of our value for @xmath243 from 1 is explained by the use of simplest form of quark propagator and meson - quark vertex form factor . in the relativistic quark model
the nlo coefficient @xmath248 is proportional to the constituent quark mass squared and results in @xmath249 gev@xmath221 .
the pqcd approach predicts @xcite @xmath250 where @xmath225 is the twist - four scale parameter related to the gluon condensate @xcite .
originally , this quantity was estimated to have a value of @xmath251 gev@xmath221 using the qcd sum rule approach @xcite . a recent evaluation @xcite results in : @xmath252 gev@xmath221 . by taking into account the value of ref .
@xcite the pqcd prediction is @xmath253 now we turn to the case @xmath242 .
we exactly reproduce the lo coefficient predicted by pqcd @xcite : @xmath254 . for the nlo coefficient
our result is @xmath255 the result of pqcd is again proportional to @xmath225 @xcite : @xmath256 from this comparison we conclude that our prediction for the lo expansion coefficients @xmath243 and @xmath244 are in perfect agreement with the expectation of pqcd .
the nlo coefficients are rather sensitive to the choice of the constituent quark mass . in particular , when using @xmath257 mev in the calculation of @xmath248 and @xmath258 mev in the case of @xmath259 the central values of the nlo coefficients predicted by pqcd can be fitted . for the process
@xmath3 we have to evaluate , in addition to the triangle diagram ( fig.5a ) , the bubble ( figs.5b and 5c ) and tadpole diagrams ( fig.5d ) , which arise from gauging the nonlocal @xmath260 interaction lagrangian .
each particular diagram is not gauge invariant by itself , but the total sum fulfills the gauge invariance requirement . to simplify the calculation we split the contribution of each diagram into a part which is gauge invariant and one which is not .
this separation can be achieved in the following manner . for the @xmath261-matrices and vectors with open lorentz indices @xmath262 and @xmath263 we use the representation : @xmath264 such that @xmath265 and @xmath266 .
expressions for diagrams containing only @xmath267-values are gauge invariant separately .
it is easy to show that the remaining terms , which are not gauge invariant , cancel each other in total .
the gauge - invariant parts of the nonlocal @xmath162-triangle @xmath268 , bubble ( bub ) and tadpole ( tad ) diagrams are given by @xmath269\ , \right\}\nonumber\\ & & \nonumber\\ & + & ( q_1\leftrightarrow q_2,\,\mu\leftrightarrow \nu ) \ , = \
, f^{\sigma}_{\rm bub_\perp}(p^2,q_1 ^ 2,q_2 ^ 2 ) \ , b^{\mu\nu } + g^{\sigma}_{\rm bub_\perp}(p^2,q_1 ^ 2,q_2 ^ 2 ) \ , c^{\mu\nu}\ , , \label{sigma - bub}\\ & & \nonumber\\ i^{\mu\nu}_{\rm tad_\perp}(q_1,q_2 ) & = & \int\!\frac{d^4 k}{4\pi^2 i}{\rm tr}\left[s(\not\ ! k)\right ] \int\limits_0 ^ 1\!d\tau\ , \biggl [ - \ , \frac{c^{\mu\nu}}{4\,q_1 ^ 2\,q_2 ^ 2}\cdot \left\ { \tilde\phi^\prime(- x(0,p ) ) + \tilde\phi^\prime(- x(0,q ) ) \right\ } \nonumber\\ & & \nonumber\\ & + & \tau \ , \int\limits_0 ^ 1\!dl\ , \biggl(k+\frac{q_2}{2}\biggr)^\mu_{\perp ; \ , q_1 } \
, k^\nu_{\perp ; \ , q_2 } \ , \biggl\{\tilde\phi^{\prime\prime}(- x(q_1,q_2 ) ) + \tilde\phi^{\prime\prime}(- x(- q_1,q_2))\biggr\}\biggr]\nonumber\\ & & \nonumber\\ & + & ( q_1\leftrightarrow q_2,\,\mu\leftrightarrow \nu ) \ , = \ , f^{\sigma}_{\rm tad_\perp}(p^2,q_1 ^ 2,q_2 ^ 2 ) \ , b^{\mu\nu}+ g^{\sigma}_{\rm tad_\perp}(p^2,q_1 ^ 2,q_2 ^ 2 ) \ , c^{\mu\nu}\ , , \label{sigma - tad } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath270 applying the @xmath174-parametrization for the gauge - invariant part of the triangle diagram gives @xmath271 , \label{coeff_trn_alp1 } \\ & & \nonumber\\ & & \nonumber\\ g^{\sigma}_{\triangle_\perp } & = & -\,\frac{m}{q_1 ^ 2\,q_2 ^ 2 } \int\limits_0^\infty\ !
dt\,\frac{t^2}{(1+t)^2 } \int d^3\alpha \ , \delta\left(1-\sum\limits_{i=1}^3 \alpha_i\right)\ , \left\{-\tilde\phi^{\ , \prime}(z)\right\}\ , \label{coeff_trn_alp2}\\ & & \nonumber\\ & \times & \left\ { - \ , m^2 + \frac{(1 + 2\,\alpha_1\,t)(1 + 2\,\alpha_2\,t)}{4 ( 1+t)^2}\,p^2 + \frac{t\,(\alpha_1-\alpha_2)}{2 ( 1+t)^2 } \left((1 + 2\,\alpha_1\,t)\,q_1 ^ 2-(1 + 2\,\alpha_2\,t)\,q_2 ^ 2\right ) \right\}\ , .
\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] again , using the thooft - veltman technique one integration in eqs .
( [ coeff_trn_alp1 ] ) and ( [ coeff_trn_alp2 ] ) can be performed .
the resulting expressions are indicated in eqs .
( [ coeff_trn1 ] ) and ( [ coeff_trn2 ] ) of appendix e. the analytical results for the form factors @xmath272 and @xmath273 are given in appendix f ( eqs .
( [ coeff_bub1])-([coeff_tad2 ] ) ) . in the local limit , that is @xmath212
, we obtain @xmath274 we therefore recover the local @xmath162 form factors : @xmath275 which were already indicated in eq .
( [ coeff_alp1 ] ) .
the form factors @xmath146 and @xmath276 are expressed in terms of the functions introduced above as @xmath277\,,\\ g_{\sigma\gamma\gamma}(p^2,q_1 ^ 2,q_2 ^ 2 ) & = & - \ , \frac{5g}{6\pi^2\sqrt{2 } } \ , \biggl [ g^{\sigma}_{\triangle_\perp}(p^2,q_1 ^ 2,q_2 ^ 2 ) \ , + \ , g^{\sigma}_{\rm bub_\perp}(p^2,q_1 ^ 2,q_2 ^ 2 ) \ , + \ , g^{\sigma}_{\rm tad_\perp}(p^2,q_1 ^ 2,q_2 ^ 2 ) \biggr]\ ,
. \end{aligned}\ ] ] in analogy to the case of the pion we define the @xmath162 form factors using the @xmath215 and @xmath216 variables accordingly : @xmath278 the final numerical analysis indicates that the additional nonlocal diagrams ( bubble and tadpole ) are significantly suppressed . for simplicity below
we discuss the power expansion for @xmath279 and @xmath280 in the limit @xmath281 , where only the gauge - invariant part of the triangle diagram is included . in the numerical analysis ( sec .
v ) we will take into account all diagrams and use the value of @xmath282 mev as predicted by our approach . for the power expansion of the @xmath162 form factor
we pull out , with the help of eq .
( [ g_math_fpi ] ) , a common scaling factor @xmath283 : @xmath284 the expansion coefficients @xmath285 , @xmath286 , @xmath287 and @xmath288 are derived in the limit indicated above as @xmath289 where @xmath290 \ , - \ , \frac{3-\omega^2}{\omega^2 } \,\ , { \rm ln}_+(t,\omega ) \,\nonumber\\ & - & \ ,
\frac{1 + 2\,t}{(1+t ) \ , \omega } \,\ , { \rm ln}_-(t,\omega)\biggr\}\,,\\ & & \nonumber\\ r_{\sigma 2}^{\rm nlo}(\omega ) & = & \frac{8 m^2}{(1 - \omega^2 ) } \int\limits_0^\infty\ ! dt \ , \tilde\phi ( m^2 t ) \ , \biggl\ { \ , \frac{t}{t+1 } \ , - \ , \frac{2-\omega^2}{\omega^2 } \,\ , { \rm ln}_+(t,\omega ) \ , - \ , \frac{1}{\omega } \,\ , { \rm ln}_-(t,\omega ) \
, \biggr\}\,.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] final numerical values for the expansion coefficients are : @xmath291 & & j_\sigma^{\rm nlo}(1 ) = 1.18 \,\,\ , { \rm gev}^2\ , , \hspace*{1.9 cm } j_\sigma^{\rm nlo}(0 ) = 0.87 \,\,\ , { \rm gev}^2\ , , \\ & & \nonumber\\ & & k_\sigma^{\rm nlo}(1 ) = 4.61 \,\,\ , { \rm gev}^2\ , , \hspace*{1.8 cm } k_\sigma^{\rm nlo}(0 ) = - 0.09 \,\,\ , { \rm gev}^2\ , . \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ]
in this section we derive the matrix elements describing the strong decay @xmath4 and the nonleptonic decays @xmath292 and @xmath293 .
the strong form factor @xmath294 related to the transition @xmath295 is defined in our approach as @xmath296 ^ 2 \biggr ) \ , \tilde\phi\biggl(- \biggl[k - \frac{p_1}{2}\biggr]^2 \biggr ) \ , \\ & & \nonumber\\ & \times&{\rm tr}\biggl\ { \gamma^5 s\biggl(k + \frac{p}{2}\biggr ) s\biggl(k - \frac{p}{2}\biggr ) \gamma^5 s\biggl(k + \frac{q}{2}\biggr ) \ , .
\biggr\}\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] the @xmath7 momentum is given by @xmath297 , pion momenta are labeled by @xmath42 and @xmath141 with @xmath142 and @xmath298 .
the matrix element of eq .
( [ gsigmapipi ] ) was already introduced in its generic form by eq .
( [ lambda_trans ] ) , when we discussed the model features .
the corresponding evaluation is summarized in appendix a. since the strong modes @xmath299 and @xmath300 dominate the @xmath0 decays , the total width @xmath301 is given by @xmath302 with the coupling constant @xmath303 the total decay width @xmath301 can then be expressed as @xmath304 where @xmath305 was already defined in eq .
( [ lambda_tri ] ) . in our estimate for the @xmath306 form factor and the @xmath0-meson width final state interaction is neglected .
an accurate analysis of the strong decay properties of the @xmath0 meson should also include these effects .
we just refer to two refs .
@xcite where the @xmath0-meson was generated dynamically in the iso - scalar s - wave of @xmath11 scattering in the context of chiral perturbation theory .
the pole identified with the light @xmath0 meson occurs at @xmath307 with @xmath308 mev and @xmath309 600 mev @xcite and 400 mev @xcite . judging from this work
, an inclusion of final state interaction will possibly lead to a further increase of @xmath301 as compared to the value derived in our model .
now we turn to the discussion of the nonleptonic two - body transitions @xmath310 with @xmath311 or @xmath9 .
the effective interaction lagrangian relevant for the nonleptonic two - body decays @xmath312 and @xmath313 is given by @xcite : @xmath314 where @xmath315 is the fermi coupling constant and @xmath316 are the matrix elements of the cabibbo - kabayashi - maskawa quark - mixing matrix ( @xmath317 and @xmath318 ) @xcite .
the four - quark operators @xmath319 are defined as : @xmath320 where @xmath321 are the color indices and label @xmath322 is a short - hand notation for the @xmath323 dirac structure . the couplings @xmath324 are the combination of the wilson coefficients including both the factorizable and the nonfactorizable effects .
we use the following values for the effective couplings @xmath325 : @xmath326 @xcite and @xmath327 @xcite . the corresponding decay width @xmath328 is given by @xmath329 where @xmath330 is the effective weak coupling constant .
the constant @xmath330 is equivalent to the expectation value of the effective hamiltonian @xmath331 as derived from the nonleptonic lagrangian ( [ lagr_nl ] ) @xmath332 where @xmath333 is the weak form factor describing the @xmath334 transition @xcite . in refs .
@xcite the authors included two contributions to the form factor @xmath333 : the direct diagram of fig.6a and the resonance or polar diagram of fig.6b with an intermediate axial meson @xmath335 .
the contribution of the resonance diagram is sizeable and close to the contribution of the direct diagram . as result they overestimated the experimental result for @xmath336 .
therefore , we restrict ourselves to the consideration of the direct diagram ( fig.6a ) only .
we neglect also the suppressed `` annihilation '' diagram , that is the @xmath337 transition , since it involves form factors of light mesons at high momentum transfer ( @xmath338 ) @xcite . note , that the diagram generated by operator @xmath339 is vanishing because the corresponding matrix element is proportional to @xmath340 .
the contribution of the direct diagram ( fig.6a ) to the form factor @xmath333 is given by @xmath341 where @xmath342 is the structure integral : @xmath343 ^ 2 ) \
, \tilde\phi_h ( - ( k + \omega_{qq } p)^2 ) \nonumber\\ & & \nonumber\\ & \times&{\rm tr}\left[s_q(\not\ !
k + \not\ !
p ) \ , \gamma^5 \ , s(\not\ !
k ) \ , s(\not\ ! k + \not\ !
p^{\ , \prime } ) \not\ !
q \gamma^5 \right]\ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath344 .
again , the analytical evaluation of the structure integral , before the final numerical calculation is applied , is indicated in appendix a.
preliminary model results for the pion charge @xmath345 and @xmath222 form factors were already presented in ref .
@xcite . here
we extend our formalism to the case of the @xmath162 form factors and we also perform a comprehensive analysis of the @xmath154 form factors . recently , new and more accurate experimental results for the charged pion electromagnetic form factor @xmath345 were obtained by the jefferson lab @xmath239 collaboration @xcite .
these data for the momentum transfer region of @xmath346 gev@xmath221 were extracted from an analysis of electro - production of pions on the nucleon .
the new results for the pion form factor lie somewhat higher than the older cornell data points @xcite , but are consistent with a monopole parametrization fitted to elastic data at very low @xmath215 and with the @xmath193 scaling law @xcite . in fig.7
we show our results for @xmath345 in the region up to @xmath347 gev@xmath221 . for comparison
we indicate the experimental data , recent results ( @xmath239 collaboration @xcite ) and previous ones ( desy @xcite and cern na7 @xcite collaboration ) .
we also indicate the predictions of other theoretical approaches : qcd sum rules @xcite , light - cone quark model @xcite , njl model with a separable @xmath348 interaction @xcite and qcd modeling approach based on solutions of the dyson - schwinger equations @xcite .
our model predictions provide a rather good description of the available data and are very close to the qcd sum rule result @xcite including @xmath349 correction .
they are also close to the results of the qcd motivated approach @xcite , which is based on a similar physical picture .
in contrast to the work of ref .
@xcite we use , roughly speaking , simple phenomenological prescriptions for the quark propagator ( a free propagator with an effective quark mass instead of a confined one ) and for the meson correlation function .
we also get a reasonable description of the pion charge radius with @xmath350 fm , as obtained in our model .
our result should be compared to the present world average data of @xmath351 fm from pdg2002 @xcite , to the recent experimental result @xmath352 fm of the selex collaboration @xcite and to the prediction of ref .
@xcite with @xmath353 fm .
next we discuss the numerical results for the @xmath354 transition form factor .
first we consider our results for the form factor @xmath222 , which are given in fig .
the data points are taken from @xcite ( cello ) and @xcite ( cleo ) .
other theoretical calculations include the hard scattering approach ( hsa ) @xcite , qcd sum rules @xcite and perturbative light - cone qcd @xcite .
our curve for @xmath355 is in good agreement with the data and approaches the brodsky - lepage limit for large @xmath215 . with the usual definition for the range of a form factor , that is @xmath356 we obtain for the radius of @xmath222 : @xmath357 our result confirms the monopole - type approximation of the cleo data @xcite and is very close to the cello measurement @xcite of @xmath358 fm@xmath221 .
again , our model prediction is close to the result of a similar theoretical approach with @xmath360 fm@xmath221 @xcite .
fig.9 contains our results for the @xmath361 form factor for different values of the asymmetry parameter @xmath362 and @xmath363 .
an increase in @xmath216 leads to a rise of @xmath361 for large @xmath215 .
finally , for the coupling constant @xmath364 and the decay width @xmath365 our approach gives : @xmath366 which is close to the data @xcite of @xmath367 gev@xmath368 and @xmath369 ev .
now we turn to the discussion of the @xmath215 dependence of @xmath370 .
first we consider the limiting case @xmath241 , where one of the photons is virtual and the other one is real .
the corresponding form factor @xmath371 is plotted in fig.10 . in the numerical calculation
all three types of diagrams ( @xmath372 , bubble and tadpole ) are included . as was already stated before
, the @xmath372 diagram gives the dominant contribution , whereas bubble and tadpole diagrams are significantly suppressed .
using eq .
( [ rad_h ] ) we determine the slope of the @xmath373 form factor as @xmath374 for completeness we also present the results for @xmath370 for different values of the asymmetry parameter @xmath362 and @xmath363 in fig .
the coupling constant @xmath375 and , according to eq .
( [ dec_h ] ) , the decay width @xmath376 are given in our approach as : @xmath377 again , the dominant contribution to @xmath375 arises from the triangle diagram .
the separate contributions of the bubble ( bub ) and tadpole ( tad ) diagrams to the coupling constant are @xmath378 a variation of the @xmath0 meson mass in the region of @xmath379 mev does not have much influence on the value for @xmath375 with @xmath380 gev@xmath368 . in the soft meson mass limit
@xmath381 we approximately reproduce the low - energy theorem : @xmath382 the constants @xmath383 calculated for zero meson mass values , @xmath384 gev@xmath368 and @xmath385 gev@xmath368 , are rather close to the quantities predicted at @xmath386 mev and @xmath282 mev .
taking the recent result for the two - photon decay width of @xmath7 or @xmath387 of @xmath388 kev @xcite at face value , our direct result of eq .
( [ sigma_decay ] ) is off by about an order of magnitude .
however , predictions for the decay width depend rather sensitively , that is to the third power , on the value of the scalar meson mass as evident from eq .
( [ dec_h ] ) . using our canonical value of @xmath389 gev@xmath368 ,
which , as discussed , is fairly independent of the mass value , and varying the @xmath0 mass we obtain : @xmath390 the range of prediction can be summarized as @xmath391 kev , which now is in qualitative agreement with the experimental result .
based on the definition given in sec .
[ strongdecay ] , our numerical result for the coupling constant of the strong decay @xmath392 is : @xmath393 the value we obtain is close to the one extracted from the bes experiment @xcite with @xmath394 gev and to the prediction of the linear @xmath0 model : @xmath395 in eq .
( [ gspp ] ) we used the values @xmath282 mev and @xmath396 mev as determined in our approach . using eq .
( [ dec_sigma ] ) for the decay width of the @xmath0 meson we get @xmath397 mev .
this value is smaller than the ones reported by the e791 ( @xmath17 mev ) and the bes ( @xmath398 mev ) collaborations .
again , a variation of the @xmath0 meson mass in the region @xmath399 leads to a range of predictions for @xmath400 . the central value of @xmath401 corresponds to @xmath402 mev , the upper limit to @xmath403 , whereas the minimal value is obtained for a mass value near @xmath404 . substituting the results for @xmath401 as a function @xmath405 into eq.([dec_sigma ] )
we estimate the variation of the @xmath0 meson width as @xmath406 mev .
the lower limit corresponds obviously to the threshold @xmath407 and the largest value to @xmath408 mev .
finally we discuss the results for the nonleptonic decays @xmath29 and @xmath32 .
we first give our predictions for the weak form factors @xmath409 and @xmath410 of eq .
( [ weakform ] ) evaluated at the physical point @xmath411 : @xmath412 with our results for @xmath409 and @xmath410 we get for the effective weak coupling constants ( eq .
( [ eq_gds ] ) ) @xmath413 and finally for the decay widths , originally defined in eq .
( [ weakwidth ] ) , @xmath414 our prediction for the decay width @xmath415 is in agreement with the lower value of the e791 result @xcite of : @xmath416 we also compare our results to previous theoretical calculations done in refs .
a value for @xmath409 was estimated in ref .
@xcite using the @xmath417 data @xcite without properly taking into account the rescattering effects .
the result is @xmath418 , which is twice as large as our prediction and also results in a value for the width @xmath336 larger than the measured one .
obviously , the value for @xmath409 should be directly extracted from the two - body transition @xmath5 . in ref .
@xcite the form factor @xmath409 was calculated ( including direct and polar contributions ) in a quark model similar to ours .
the contribution of the direct diagram @xmath419 is close to our result but the contribution of the polar diagram is very large @xmath420 . with the final result of @xmath421 mev
this approach overestimates the experimental result .
this work was extended in ref .
@xcite to determine the form factor @xmath410 .
the result they obtain is @xmath422 which , again , is about three times larger than our prediction .
in summary , we have applied the relativistic constituent quark model to investigate electromagnetic @xmath8 and @xmath0 meson form factors and a variety of strong and weak decay characteristics involving the @xmath0 .
we start with an effective quark - meson interaction lagrangian , which is based on a linear realization of chiral symmetry .
then we write down the matrix elements describing the meson interactions in terms of a set of quark diagrams .
all model parameters were previously determined @xcite-@xcite in a fit to experimental observables . in a first step we present a detailed analysis of the electromagnetic form factors of the @xmath8 and @xmath0 mesons . to solidify our model considerations , we study the electromagnetic form factor of the charged pion , which was recently measured by the jefferson lab @xmath239 collaboration @xcite .
we also calculate the form factors which govern the transitions @xmath148 with @xmath423 and @xmath0 including different kinematics of the photons .
our results for the pion are in good agreement with the recent experimental data @xcite .
we furthermore give results ( analytical formulas and numerics ) for the asymptotics of the @xmath34 and @xmath3 form factors at large values of space - like photon virtualities .
the behavior of the @xmath424 form factor nicely coincides with the prediction of perturbative qcd @xcite .
expressions for the leading order ( lo ) @xmath425 and the next - to - leading ( nlo ) order @xmath426 expansion coefficients in the form factors are calculated at arbitrary values of large photon virtualities .
we complete the analysis by indicating results for the charge radii .
based on the chiral symmetry construction we determine the @xmath0 meson mass @xmath282 mev and the total width @xmath427 mev .
both values are lower than the experimental values of the e791 @xcite collaboration , but close to the bes @xcite results .
the predicted strong coupling constant @xmath428 gev is fairly stable with respect to variations in the @xmath0 mass , but the total width , due to phase space , depends sensitively on this value . turning to the experimental evidence for the @xmath0 meson we give predictions for the decay characteristics in the nonleptonic @xmath5 and @xmath6 transitions .
both form factors and decays widths are determined .
our result for @xmath429 mev is in agreement with the lower value of data @xcite .
our prediction for the decay width @xmath430 is @xmath431 mev , which is expected to be measured in forthcoming experiments .
, th.g . and v.e.l .
thank the dfg grants fa67/25 - 1 and grk683 for support .
m.a.i . appreciates the partial support by the dfg grants grk683 and 436 rus17/47/02 , the russian fund of basic research grant no .
01 - 02 - 17200 and the heisenberg - landau program .
thanks the alexander von humboldt foundation for financial support .
99 k. hagiwara _ et al .
_ , phys .
d * 66 * , 010001 ( 2002 ) .
n. a. tornqvist , hep - ph/0008135 ; f. e. close , n. a. tornqvist , j. phys .
g * 28 * , r249 ( 2002 ) .
j. schwinger , ann .
( n.y . ) * 2 * , 407 ( 1957 ) .
m. gell - mann and m. levy , nuovo .
cim . * 122 * , 705 ( 1960 ) .
y. nambu and g. jona - lasinio , phys . rev . *
122 * , 345 ( 1961 ) ; * 124 * , 246 ( 1961 ) .
j. schechter and y. ueda , phys . rev .
d * 3 * , 168 ( 1971 ) .
s. weinberg , phys .
lett . * 18 * , 188 ( 1967 ) ; phys . rev . * 166 * , 1568 ( 1968 ) .
s. weinberg , physica a * 96 * ( 1979 ) 327 ; j. gasser and h. leutwyler , ann .
( n.y . ) * 158 * , 142 ( 1984 ) ; nucl .
b * 250 * , 465 ( 1985 ) .
g. colangelo , j. gasser and h. leutwyler , nucl .
b * 603 * , 125 ( 2001 ) .
j. oller , e. oset and j. r. pelaez , phys .
* 80 * ( 1998 ) 3452 .
f. kleefeld , e. van beveren , g. rupp and m. d. scadron , phys .
d * 66 * , 034007 ( 2002 ) .
e791 collaboration , e. m. aitala _ et al .
. lett . * 86 * , 770 ( 2001 ) .
n. wu , hep - ex/0104050 . c. dib and r. rosenfeld , phys .
d * 63 * , 117501 ( 2001 ) .
r. gatto , g. nardulli , a. d. polosa and n. a. trnqvist , phys .
b * 494 * , 168 ( 2000 ) .
w. huo , x. zhang and t. huang , phys .
d * 65 * , 097505 ( 2002 ) .
a. deandrea and a. d. polosa , phys .
lett . * 86 * , 216 ( 2001 ) .
s. gardner and ulf - g .
meissner , phys .
d * 65 * , 094004 ( 2001 ) .
m. a. ivanov , m. p. locher and v. e. lyubovitskij , few - body syst . * 21 * , 131 ( 1996 ) ; m. a. ivanov and v. e. lyubovitskij , phys .
b * 408 * , 435 ( 1997 ) ; i. v. anikin , m. a. ivanov , n. b. kulimanova and v. e. lyubovitskij , z. phys .
c * 65 * , 681 ( 1995 ) .
m. a. ivanov , v. e. lyubovitskij , j. g. krner and p. kroll , phys .
d * 56 * , 348 ( 1997 ) ; m. a. ivanov , j. g. krner , v. e. lyubovitskij and a. g. rusetsky , phys .
d * 57 * , 5632 ( 1998 ) ; d * 60 * , 094002 ( 1999 ) ; phys . lett .
b * 476 * , 58 ( 2000 ) ; m. a. ivanov and p. santorelli , phys .
b * 456 * , 248 ( 1999 ) ; a. faessler , t. gutsche , m. a. ivanov , j. g. korner and v. e. lyubovitskij , phys .
b * 518 * , 55 ( 2001 ) .
a. faessler , t. gutsche , m. a. ivanov , j. g. korner and v. e. lyubovitskij , eur .
j. direct * c4 * , 18 ( 2002 ) .
a. salam , nuovo cim .
* 25 * , 224 ( 1962 ) ; s. weinberg , phys . rev . * 130 * , 776 ( 1963 ) ; k. hayashi _
* 15 * , 625 ( 1967 ) .
g. v. efimov and m. a. ivanov , `` the quark confinement model of hadrons '' , iop publishing , bristol @xmath432 philadelphia , 1993 .
t. becher and h. leutwyler , eur .
j. c * 9 * , 643 ( 1999 ) ; jhep * 0106 * , 017 ( 2001 ) .
s. mandelstam , ann .
* 19 * , 1 ( 1962 ) .
j. terning , phys .
d * 44 * , 887 ( 1991 ) .
s. ryan : nucl .
b ( proc . suppl . ) * 106 * , 86 ( 2002 ) .
s. adler , phys . rev . * 177 * ( 1969 ) 2426 ; + j. bell and r. jackiw , nuovo cimento a * 60 * ( 1969 ) 47 .
g. thooft and m. veltman , nucl .
b * 44 * , 189 ( 1972 ) .
f. j. yndurain , `` quantum chromodynamics '' , springer - verlag publishing , new - york , berlin , heidelberg @xmath432 tokyo , 1986 . g. t hooft and m.j.g .
veltman , nucl .
b * 153 * , 365 ( 1979 ) .
s. j. brodsky and g. p. lepage , phys .
d * 24 * , 1808 ( 1981 ) .
cleo collaboration , j. gronberg _ et al .
_ , phys .
d * 57 * , 33 ( 1998 ) .
a. p. bakulev , s. v. mikhailov and n. g. stefanis , phys .
d * 67 * , 074012 ( 2003 ) .
a. r. zhitnitskij , i. r. zhitnitskij and v. l. chernyak , sov .
j. nucl .
phys . * 38 * , 645 ( 1983 ) .
v. a. novikov , m. a. shifman , a. i. vainstein , m. b. voloshin and v. i. zakharov , nucl .
b * 237 * , 525 ( 1984 ) .
g. baur , k. hencken , d. trautman , s. sadovsky and yu .
kharlov , phys . rep . * 364 * , 359 ( 2002 ) .
p. maris and p. c. tandy , phys .
c * 65 * , 045211 ( 2002 ) .
g. buchalla , a. j. buras and m. e. lautenbacher , rev .
68 * , 1125 ( 1996 ) .
m. bauer , b. stech and m. wirbel , z. phys .
c * 34 * , 103 ( 1987 ) .
hai - yang cheng , eur .
j. c * 26 * , 551 ( 2003 ) .
m. beneke , g. buchalla , m. neubert and c. t. sachrajda , phys . rev
. lett . * 83 * , 1914 ( 1999 ) .
the jefferson @xmath239 collaboration , e. volner _
et al . _ , phys .
* 86 * , 1713 ( 2001 ) . c. j. bebek , phys .
d * 17 * , 1693 ( 1978 ) .
v. a. matveev , r. m. muradyan and a. n. tavkhelidze , lett .
nuovo cim .
* 7 * , 719 ( 1973 ) ; s. j. brodsky and g. r. farrar , phys .
lett . * 31 * , 1153 ( 1973 ) .
p. brauel _ et al .
_ , z. phys .
c * 3 * , 101 ( 1979 ) .
cern na7 collaboration , s. r. amendolia _ et al .
_ , nucl .
b * 277 * , 168 ( 1986 ) .
v. a. nesterenko and a. v. radyushkin , phys .
b * 115 * , 410 ( 1982 ) ; a. v. radyushkin , nucl . phys .
a * 532 * , 141 ( 1991 ) .
f. cardarelli , e. pace , g. salme and s. simula , phys .
b * 357 * , 267 ( 1995 ) .
h. ito , w. w. buck and f. gross , phys .
c * 45 * , 1918 ( 1992 ) .
p. maris and p. c. tandy , phys .
c * 62 * , 055204 ( 2000 ) .
selex collaboration , i. eschrich _ et al .
_ , phys .
b * 522 * , 233 ( 2001 ) .
cello collaboration , h .- j .
behrend _ et al .
_ , z. phys .
c * 49 * , 401 ( 1991 ) .
r. jakob , p. kroll and m. raulfs , j. phys .
g * 22 * , 45 ( 1996 ) .
a. v. radyushkin and r. ruskov , nucl .
b * 481 * , 625 ( 1996 ) .
cao , t. huang and b .- q .
ma , phys .
d * 53 * , 6582 ( 1996 ) .
m. boglione and m. r. pennington , eur .
j. c * 9 * , 11 ( 1999 ) .
we demonstrate the evaluation of matrix elements for the example of the derivative of the meson mass operator ( [ mass - operator ] ) : @xmath433 \ , .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] the technique we use is based on the three main ingredients : after straightforward algebra we get expressions for the coupling constants @xmath437 of pseudoscalar @xmath438 and scalar @xmath439 mesons , which are given by @xmath440^\prime \ , b \biggl ( d_h \frac{m_1 m_2}{\lambda_h^2 } \ , + \ , \frac{m_h^2}{\lambda_h^2 } \ , \frac{a ( 1 - \delta^2 ) + b}{4 a^2 } \biggr)\\ & + & \tilde\phi^2(z_0 ) \biggl(1 - \delta^2 + \frac{3b}{a } \biggr ) \biggr\ } \ , , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath441^\prime = d[\tilde\phi^2(z_0)]/dz_0 $ ] , @xmath442 for pseudoscalar mesons and @xmath443 for scalar mesons .
we also define @xmath444 + \frac{m_h^2 t^2}{4a } ( 2\alpha - 1 + \delta)^2 \ , , \nonumber\\ & & \nonumber\\ a & = & 1+t , \,\,\,\,\ , b = t [ 4\alpha(1-\alpha ) a + ( 2 \alpha - 1 + \delta)^2 ] , \,\,\,\,\ , \delta = w_{21 } - w_{12 } \ , . \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] in analogy we consider the basic vertex function ( [ lambda_trans ] ) : @xmath445\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] here we indicate the resulting expression for the gaussian meson - quark vertex function @xmath446 : @xmath447 where @xmath448 \ , , \nonumber\\ & & \nonumber\\ c_2 & = & \frac{1}{4 } { \rm tr } [ \gamma^\sigma \gamma_{12 } \gamma_\sigma \gamma_{13 } ( m_3 + \not\!\ !
d_3 ) \gamma_{23 } + \gamma^\sigma \gamma_{12 } ( m_1 + \not\!\!d_1 ) \gamma_{13 } \gamma_\sigma \gamma_{23 } + ( m_2 + \not\!\ ! d_2 ) \gamma_{12 } \gamma^\sigma \gamma_{13 } \gamma_\sigma \gamma_{23 } ] , \nonumber \\ & & \nonumber\\ d_1 & = & p_1 - p_t , \,\,\,\,\
, d_2 = p_2 - p_t , \,\,\,\,\ , d_3 = - p_t , \,\,\,\,\ ,
p_t = r_1 p_1 + r_2 p_2 \ , , \nonumber\\ r_1 & = & \frac{1}{a } ( t\alpha_1 + w_{13 } s_{13 } + w_{12 } s_{12 } ) , \,\,\,\,\ , r_2 = \frac{1}{a } ( t\alpha_2 + w_{23 } s_{23 } + w_{12 } s_{21 } ) \ , , \nonumber \\ & & \nonumber\\ z & = & t [ \sum\limits_{i=1}^{3 } \alpha_i m_i^2 - \alpha_1 p_1 ^ 2 - \alpha_2 p_2 ^ 2 ] + a [ ( r_1 + r_2 ) ( r_1 p_1 ^ 2 + r_2 p_2 ^ 2 ) - r_1 r_2 p_3 ^ 2 ] \nonumber\\ & & \nonumber\\ & - & p_1 ^ 2 ( w_{13}^2 s_{13 } + w_{12 } s_{12 } ) - p_2 ^ 2 ( w_{23}^2 s_{23 } + w_{21 } s_{12 } ) + p_3 ^ 2 w_{12 } w_{21 } s_{12 } \ , , \nonumber\\ & & \nonumber\\ \frac{1}{\lambda_{\rm red}^2 } & = & \frac{1}{\lambda_{h_{12}}^2 } + \frac{1}{\lambda_{h_{13}}^2 } + \frac{1}{\lambda_{h_{23}}^2 } , \,\,\,\,\ , s_{ij } = \frac{\lambda_{red}^2}{\lambda_{ij}^2 } \ , .
\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] all further calculations are done by using computer programs written in form for the manipulations of dirac matrices and in fortran for the final numerical evaluations . in the following
we derive the feynman rules for the nonlocal vertices of figs.3a and 3b .
these vertices contain the path integral over the gauge field @xmath83 .
the crucial point is to calculate the expression @xmath449^n\end{aligned}\ ] ] using eq.([path2 ] ) .
the case @xmath450 corresponds to the vertex of fig.3a and @xmath451 to the vertex of fig.3b .
first , we consider the case @xmath450 .
it is readily seen that @xmath452 where @xmath453 .
thus we have to calculate @xmath454 one finds that @xmath455 - p^2 i(x , y , p ) \equiv l(a ) - p^2 i(x , y , p ) \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath456 .
iteration of the last expression @xmath457^{n-1 } \ , l(a ) \ , + \ , ( -p^2)^n i(x , y , p ) \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] finally leads to @xmath458 \ , l(a ) \ , + \ , \tilde\phi(-p^2 ) \ , i(x , y , p)\\ & = & \int \frac{d^4 q}{(2\pi)^4 } \ , a_\mu(q ) \ , \bigg\ { i ( 2p+q)^\mu e^{i q x } \int\limits_0 ^ 1 dt \tilde\phi^\prime [ - ( p+q)^2 t \ , - \ , p^2 ( 1-t ) ] \nonumber\\ & + & \tilde\phi(- p^2 ) \int\limits_y^x
dz^\mu e^{iqz } \biggr\ } \nonumber \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath459 is the fourier - transform of the electromagnetic field and @xmath460 .
the last term in eq.([eqn1_last ] ) containing an integration from @xmath461 to @xmath86 ( path integral ) vanishes due to the delta function @xmath462 in the lagrangian . in complete analogy
, we also obtain for the nonlocal vertex for the case @xmath451 : @xmath463 \nonumber\\ & -&(2p + q_1)^\mu ( 2p + 2q_1 + q_2)^\nu \ , e^{i ( q_1 + q_2 ) x } \ , \int\limits_0 ^ 1 dt \ ,
t \ , \int\limits_0 ^ 1 dl \ , \nonumber\\ & \times&\tilde\phi^{\prime\prime } [ - l ( t(p + q_1 + q_2)^2 \ , + \ , p^2 ( 1-t ) ) - ( 1 - l ) ( t(p + q_1)^2 + ( 1 - t ) p^2 ) ] \nonumber\\ & -&(2p + q_2)^\nu ( 2p + 2q_2 + q_1)^\mu \ , e^{i ( q_1+q_2 ) x } \
, \int\limits_0 ^ 1 dt \ ,
t \ , \int\limits_0 ^ 1 dl \ , \nonumber\\ & \times&\tilde\phi^{\prime\prime } [ - l ( t(p + q_1 + q_2)^2 \ , + \ , p^2 ( 1-t ) ) - ( 1 - l ) ( t(p + q_2)^2 + ( 1 - t ) p^2 ) ] \nonumber\\ & + & i ( 2p+q_1)^\mu e^{i q_1 x } \int\limits_0 ^ 1 dt \tilde\phi^\prime [ - ( p+q_1)^2 t \ , - \ , p^2 ( 1-t ) ] \int\limits_y^x dz^\mu e^{iq_2 z } \nonumber\\ & + & i ( 2p+q_2)^\nu e^{i q_2 x } \int\limits_0 ^ 1 dt \tilde\phi^\prime [ - ( p+q_2)^2 t \ , - \ ,
p^2 ( 1-t ) ] \int\limits_y^x dz^\mu e^{iq_1 z } \nonumber\\ & + & g^{\mu\nu } \tilde\phi(- p^2 ) \int\limits_y^x
dz^\mu e^{iq_1 z } \int\limits_y^x dw^\nu e^{iq_2w } \biggr\ } \ , , \nonumber \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath464 .
again , the last three terms in eq.([eqn2_last ] ) containing integrations from @xmath461 to @xmath86 vanish due to the delta function . [ [ form - factors - characterizing - the - local - sigmatogammagamma - diagram ] ] form factors characterizing the local @xmath3 diagram ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ [ [ two - loop - integral - representation - and - power - expansion - of - i_rm - nl ] ] two - loop integral representation and power expansion of @xmath200 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ @xmath476 \cdot a_1(x ) + 2 \ , d_p \ , \delta_1}\ , \\
& + & \,\ , \frac{1}{r_{q_2}(x ) } \ , \frac{(1-\alpha_0 ) \ , [ u - \delta(x ) + r_{q_2}(x ) ] } { [ u-\delta(x ) + r_{q_2}(x ) ] \cdot a_2(x ) + 2\ , d_{q_2 } \ , \delta_1 } \ ,
\nonumber\\ & + & \,\ , \frac{1 } { r_{q_1}(x ) } \ , \frac{\alpha_0 \ , [ u-\delta(x ) + r_{q_1}(x ) ] } { [ u - \delta(x ) + r_{q_1}(x ) ] \cdot a_3(x ) + 2 \ , d_{q_1 } \ , \delta_1 } \biggr\ } \ , , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ [ form - factors - characterizing - the - gauge - invariant - part - of - the - nonlocal - triangle - sigmatogammagamma - diagram ] ] form factors characterizing the gauge - invariant part of the nonlocal triangle @xmath3 diagram ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ the integrals @xmath491 and @xmath492 are defined in eq .
( [ r_sigma ] ) . the last simple relation between @xmath493 and @xmath494
is derived with the help of the identity @xmath495 where w is defined in eq .
( [ wdef ] ) , and the exchange symmetry @xmath496 . [ [ form - factors - characterizing - the - gauge - invariant - part - of - the - nonlocal - bubble - and - tadpole - sigmagammagamma - diagrams ] ] form factors characterizing the gauge - invariant part of the nonlocal bubble and tadpole @xmath162 diagrams ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ @xmath501 \ , + \ ,
l^2 \ , q_1 ^ 2 \ , + \ ,
q_2 ^ 2\right)\,,\\ w_1 & = & w_3 \ , = \ , w(q_1)\ , , \,\,\,\,\ , w_2 \ , = \ , w_4 \ , = \ , w(q_2)\ , , \\
r_1 & = & r(q_1,q_2,l)\ , , \,\,\,\,\ ,
r_2 \ , = \ , r(q_2,q_1,l)\ , , \,\,\,\,\ ,
r_3 \ , = \ , r(q_1,q_2,-l)\ , , \,\,\,\,\ ,
r_4 \ , = \ , r(q_2,q_1,-l)\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] .
leptonic decay constants @xmath96 ( mev ) used in the least - square fit .
data are either taken from pdg @xmath502 or from the lattice @xmath503 ( quenched ( upper line ) and unquenched ( lower line ) ) . [
cols="<,<,<",options="header " , ] fig.7 : electromagnetic form factor @xmath345 of the pion in comparison to data taken from @xcite ( jlab ) , @xcite ( desy ) , @xcite ( cern ) and to other theoretical calculations : qcd sum rules @xcite , light - cone quark model @xcite , njl model with a separable @xmath348 interaction @xcite and qcd modeling approach based on the solution of the dyson - schwinger equations @xcite .
fig.8 : results for the form factor @xmath507 in comparison to experimental data taken from @xcite ( cello ) , @xcite ( cleo ) and to other theoretical calculations : hard scattering approach ( hsa ) @xcite , qcd sum rules @xcite and perturbative light - cone qcd @xcite . | a variety of strong and electroweak interaction properties of the pion and the light scalar @xmath0 meson are computed in a relativistic quark model . under the assumption that the resulting coupling of these mesons to the constituent quarks is identical ,
the @xmath0 meson mass is determined as @xmath1 mev .
we discuss in detail the gauging of the non - local meson - quark interaction and calculate the electromagnetic form factor of the pion and the form factors of the @xmath2 and @xmath3 processes .
we obtain explicit expressions for the relevant form factors and evaluate the leading and next - to - leading orders for large euclidean photon virtualities . turning to the decay properties of the @xmath0 we determine the width of the electromagnetic @xmath3 transition and discuss the strong decay @xmath4 . in a final step
we compute the nonleptonic decays @xmath5 and @xmath6 relevant for the possible observation of the @xmath7 meson .
all our results are compared to available experimental data and to results of other theoretical studies .
.5 cm .5 cm _ pacs : _
12.39.ki , 13.25.ft , 13.40.gp , 13.40.hq , 14.40.lb .5 cm _ keywords : _ @xmath8 and @xmath0 meson ; @xmath9 and @xmath10 meson ; relativistic quark model ; nonleptonic and electromagnetic decays . |
chiral effective field theory ( eft ) provides a powerful framework to systematically describe low - energy dynamics of few- and many - nucleon systems .
various variants of effective theories for nuclear forces have been explored , see @xcite for recent review articles . up to now
, the most advanced few - nucleon studies have been carried out within a framework based on pions and nucleons as the only explicit degrees of freedom taken into account in the effective lagrangian . within this approach , the nucleon - nucleon ( nn ) force is currently available up to next - to - next - to - next - to leading order ( n@xmath2lo ) in the chiral expansion . at this chiral order
, it receives contributions from one- , two- and three - pion exchange diagrams as well as short - range nn contact interactions with up to four derivatives . as demonstrated in refs .
@xcite , nn phase shifts are accurately described at n@xmath2lo up to laboratory energies of the order of 200 mev .
the theoretical uncertainty due to truncation of the chiral expansion is estimated in ref .
@xcite by means of a cutoff variation . within the spectral function regularization ( sfr )
framework @xcite adopted in ref .
@xcite , the nn potential depends on two ultraviolet cutoffs @xmath3 and @xmath4 .
the first one removes large - mass components in the spectrum of the two - pion exchange potential which can not be correctly described within the chiral eft framework while the other one provides regularization of the lippmann - schwinger equation .
five different combinations of these cut - off parameters are available for the nn potentials of ref .
the residual dependence of low - energy observables on the cutoff choice provides a measure of the importance of higher - order contact interactions and thus may serve as an estimate of the theoretical uncertainty .
parallel to these developments three - nucleon force ( 3nf ) has also been explored within the framework of chiral effective field theory .
the first nonvanishing contributions to the 3nf emerge at next - to - next - to - leading order ( n@xmath5lo ) @xcite from the two - pion exchange and one - pion - exchange - contact diagrams as well as the purely short - range derivative - less three - nucleon contact interaction @xcite , see also ref .
@xcite for a pioneering work along this line .
the resulting n@xmath5lo three - nucleon potential depends on two low - energy constants ( lecs ) @xmath6 and @xmath7 accompanying the short - range @xmath8 and @xmath9 vertices , respectively .
the values of these lecs need to be fixed from a fit to few - nucleon data . among a few possible observables that have been used in this connection
are the triton binding energy and the nucleon - deuteron doublet scattering length @xmath10 @xcite , @xmath11-particle binding energy @xcite , the properties of light nuclei @xcite and the triton beta decay @xcite .
the n@xmath5lo 3nf of @xcite was successfully used in three - body calculations , see refs .
@xcite for a few examples of recent studies . at this order ,
chiral eft yields a good description of elastic scattering and deuteron breakup observables up to energies of about @xmath12 mev .
the accuracy of the results in this regime is comparable with the one that is achieved by realistic phenomenological nn and 3n interactions such as e.g. av18 @xcite 2nf in combination with urbanaix @xcite 3nf or cd - bonn @xcite 2nf in combination with the tucson - melbourne @xcite 3nf , see @xcite .
however , the spread of the results is relatively large for some spin observables which clearly calls for the inclusion of new terms of the nuclear interaction that occur at higher orders of the chiral expansion .
subleading contributions to the 3nf are currently being investigated by several groups . at n@xmath2lo , one has to take into account ( irreducible ) contributions emerging from all possible one - loop three - nucleon diagrams constructed with the lowest order vertices .
in addition , there are ( tree - level ) leading relativistic corrections , see @xcite for an early work on the longest - range relativistic corrections .
note that the tree diagrams involving higher - order vertices from the effective chiral lagrangian do not produce any irreducible pieces .
effects due to two - pion exchange 3nf in elastic nucleon - deuteron scattering were already explored by ishikawa and robilotta @xcite within a hybrid approach and found to be rather small .
the n@xmath2lo contributions feed into five different topologies as will be explained in detail in the next section .
the explicit expressions both in momentum and in coordinate space for the long - range contributions have already been worked out @xcite .
their inclusion in numerical few - body calculations appears to be challenging due to the very rich and complicated operator structure .
the large number of terms in the 3nf at n@xmath2lo , see ref .
@xcite , requires an efficient method of performing the partial wave decomposition .
recently such a method has been proposed @xcite and tested for the tucson - melbourne force @xcite .
here and in what follows , this approach will be referred to as the automatized partial wave decomposition ( apwd ) . in this paper
we apply this method of the numerical partial wave decomposition to the n@xmath2lo 3nf contributions derived in @xcite . for the first time
, the parts of 3nf at n@xmath2lo different from the two - pion exchange force are included in the triton and the scattering length calculations . in order to test the implementations and get a first hint to possible effects of these forces
, we fix the two lecs entering the 3nf from the triton binding energy and the nucleon - deuteron doublet scattering length and explore the effects due to these novel 3nf terms by computing the @xmath2h properties .
although this calculations is still incomplete since not all 3nf contributions at n@xmath2lo are taken into account , it provides an important first step towards the complete n@xmath2lo analysis of 3n scattering and demonstrates our ability to numerically handle the rather complicated structure of the subleading chiral 3nf .
our paper is organized as follows . in sect .
[ section1 ] we describe briefly the structure of the chiral 3nf at n@xmath2lo . in sect .
[ section3 ] we discuss in detail the partial wave decomposition needed in our scattering and bound - state calculations .
next , the procedure of fixing the lecs is described in sect .
[ section4 ] where also the obtained values of lecs are listed .
these results are used in sect .
[ section5 ] to explore some properties of the triton .
finally , our findings are summarized in sec .
[ conclusion ] .
the subleading ( i.e. n@xmath2lo ) contributions to the three - nucleon force @xmath14 can be written in the form @xcite @xmath15 where the individual terms refer , in order , to the two - pion exchange , two - pion - one - pion - exchange , ring ( i.e. one pion being exchanged between each of the three nucleon pairs ) , one - pion - exchange - contact and two - pion - exchange - contact contributions as well as the leading relativistic corrections , see fig . 1 of ref
. @xcite for a diagrammatic representation .
the expressions for the ( static ) long - range part of the 3nf given by the first three terms in the above equation have been worked out in heavy - baryon chiral perturbation theory in ref.@xcite .
the two - pion exchange contribution at the one - loop level has also been calculated within the infrared - regularized version of chiral perturbation theory in ref .
the shorter - range contributions involving two - nucleon contact interactions and relativistic corrections are currently being worked out @xcite . while the two - pion - exchange @xmath16 and one - pion - exchange - contact parts @xmath17 already occur at n@xmath5lo and receive corrections at n@xmath2lo , the remaining topologies first emerge at n@xmath2lo .
it is important to emphasize that all subleading contributions to the 3nf are parameter - free .
thus , the low - energy constants @xmath6 and @xmath7 entering the one - pion - exchange - contact and the purely short - range parts of the 3nf at n@xmath5lo are the only unknown parameters up to n@xmath2lo . here and in what follows , we adopt the notation in which a given 3nf @xmath14 is decomposed into three terms @xmath18 where each @xmath19 is symmetrical under interchanging the nucleons @xmath20 and @xmath21 ( @xmath22 , @xmath23 ) .
clearly , this condition does not specify @xmath24 uniquely . in the following we choose @xmath24 in such a way that the number of operator structures is minimized which is convenient for the apwd .
the operator structure of the 2@xmath25 exchange part @xmath26 at n@xmath2lo remains the same as at n@xmath5lo @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the momentum transfer to the i - th nucleon , @xmath29 and @xmath30 ( @xmath31 ) are pauli spin ( isospin ) matrices for nucleon @xmath32 .
the scalar functions @xmath33 and @xmath34 depend on the lecs @xmath35 which accompany the subleading pion - nucleon vertices .
chiral expansion of @xmath36 and @xmath37 up to n@xmath2lo has the form @xcite @xmath38 with @xmath39 where the loop function @xmath40 is defined as @xmath41 the axial - vector coupling constant , the weak pion decay constant and the pion mass are denoted as @xmath42 , @xmath43 and @xmath44 , respectively .
note that sfr changes @xmath40 ( see @xcite ) .
for the study here we do not need to consider this change since they differ only by higher order polynomials @xcite .
the quantities @xmath45 appearing in the above expressions are related to the n@xmath5lo lecs @xmath46 entering the effective chiral lagrangian via @xmath47 where we have adopted the values for the @xmath46 from ref .
@xcite , namely @xmath48 these values are consistent with the ones determined from pion - nucleon scattering @xcite .
the finite shifts of the lecs @xmath46 in eq .
( [ ci_def ] ) emerge from pion loops at n@xmath2lo .
the @xmath49 interaction at n@xmath2lo has the following operator structure @xmath50 + ( 2 \leftrightarrow 3 ) \,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] with scalar functions @xmath51 .
the interchange of nucleons @xmath52 refers to the interchange of momentum vectors , spin and isospin matrices and arguments of the functions @xmath53 .
explicit expressions for the scalar functions @xmath51 which appear in the @xmath49 can be found in ref .
@xcite .
the @xmath54 force is chosen as @xmath55 where the expressions for the scalar functions @xmath56 and @xmath57 can be found in ref .
@xcite .
the modifications of the one - pion - exchange - contact @xmath58 term arising at n@xmath2lo are in preparation @xcite .
thus , instead of the full @xmath58 interaction we use the lowest - order result for it resulting at n@xmath5lo @xcite : @xmath59 the low energy constant @xmath6 can be expressed as @xmath60 , where @xmath61 is a dimensionless free parameter and the chiral symmetry breaking scale @xmath62 is estimated to be @xmath63 mev . here and in what follows , we use @xmath64 mev for the pion decay constant .
the value of @xmath61 has to be determined from experimental data .
this is described in section [ section4 ] for our fit for the test case of this study .
of course , results of this fit will significantly change when the complete short range interaction is taken into account .
as already pointed out above , the remaining terms @xmath65 and @xmath66 are also not available yet @xcite and thus can not be taken into account in the present study . finally , the purely short - range part of the 3nf has the form @xcite : @xmath67 again , the lec @xmath7 is usually expressed in terms of a dimension - less parameter @xmath68 via @xmath69 which needs to be determined from ( at least ) three - nucleon data . to summarize , in this paper we use the @xmath26 , @xmath49 , @xmath54 n@xmath2lo terms combined with the @xmath70 and @xmath71 terms at n@xmath5lo .
the n@xmath2lo contributions to @xmath58 and @xmath65 and relativistic corrections @xmath66 are not included . finally , the remaining terms @xmath72 and @xmath73 of eq .
( [ e3nf_split ] ) can be obtained from @xmath24 by appropriate permutations of nucleons .
we work in the momentum space using three - nucleon partial - wave states @xmath74 in the @xmath75-coupling @xcite @xmath76 where @xmath77 and @xmath78 are magnitudes of the standard jacobi momenta and @xmath11 denotes a set of discrete quantum numbers defined in the following way : the spin @xmath79 of the subsystem composed from nucleons 2 and 3 is coupled with their orbital angular momentum @xmath80 to the total angular momentum @xmath20 .
the spin @xmath81 of the spectator particle @xmath1 couples with its relative orbital angular momentum @xmath82 to the total angular momentum @xmath83 of nucleon @xmath1 .
finally , @xmath20 and @xmath83 are coupled to the total 3n angular momentum @xmath84 with the projection @xmath85 .
for the isospin part , the total isospin @xmath86 of the subsystem @xmath87 is coupled with the isospin @xmath81 of the spectator nucleon to the total 3n isospin @xmath88 with the projection @xmath89 .
the matrix elements of @xmath90 and @xmath54 forces in the basis @xmath74 are obtained using the recently proposed apwd method @xcite . in this approach the spin - momentum and isospin parts of three - nucleon interactions are calculated using a software for symbolic calculations .
the resulting momentum - dependent functions are then integrated numerically in five dimensions over angular variables . the major advantage of this method is its generality . it can be applied to _ any _ momentum - spin - isospin operator including , in particular , the full operator structure of the 3nf at n@xmath2lo including even the non - local relativisitic corrections .
the only complication emerges in the treatment of the ring contributions to the 3nf due to rather complex expressions for the functions @xmath56 and @xmath57 which involve certain scalar integrals related to the three - point function . for any given values of the arguments , these integrals have to be computed numerically .
this evaluation is too expensive to be carried out on - the - fly during the apwd .
moreover , while the functions @xmath91 and @xmath92 are , of course , finite and smooth for all possible values of their arguments , they are given in ref .
@xcite as linear combinations of terms , some of which are becoming singular under certain kinematical conditions .
their numerical implementation therefore requires special care . in order to deal with these difficulties
, we first evaluate the functions @xmath91 and @xmath92 at a ( fixed ) dense grid of points for their arguments and then use interpolation to compute them for arbitrary values of @xmath93 , @xmath94 and @xmath95 as needed in the apwd approach .
we have carefully checked the stability of this procedure by increasing the density of the grid points .
finally , the partial wave decomposition of @xmath70 and @xmath71 is performed with the standard techniques @xcite but also verified with the new method .
examples of the resulting matrix elements @xmath96 are given in fig .
[ fig1.1 ] as a function of the momentum @xmath77 . here
, we fix the momenta to be @xmath97 @xmath98 , @xmath99 @xmath98 and @xmath100 @xmath98 and consider the following four channel combinations : ( @xmath101 ) , ( @xmath102 ) , ( @xmath103 ) and ( @xmath104 ) .
these channels correspond to the quantum numbers given in tab .
[ tab0 ] .
.the values of the discrete quantum numbers for the selected @xmath11 states ( [ eqn.alpha ] ) with the total angular momentum @xmath105 , the total isospin @xmath106 and its projection @xmath107 . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] last but not least , we emphasize that the expectation values discussed above as well as the separation of the potential energy into the contributions due to the nn potential and 3nf do _ not _ correspond to observable quantities and are expected to show a strong cutoff dependence .
notice further that expectation values of the various 3nf contributions are , strictly speaking , bare quantities .
comparing their size with the one of the n@xmath5lo terms does , therefore , not allow to draw conclusions about the convergence of the chiral expansion @xcite .
it is comforting to see that all expectation values turn out to be of a reasonable size .
we now turn to the two - nucleon correlation function of @xmath2h which is defined as @xcite @xmath108 here , @xmath109 is the relative distance corresponding to the jacobi momentum @xmath110 . in fig .
[ fig5 ] the correlation function is shown for the same combinations of the regularization parameters as in tab.[tab1 ] .
thin lines represent predictions based on nn interactions only while thick ones show the predictions based on nn+3n forces .
as expected , the softest cutoff value @xmath111 mev yields a more flat correlation function with the less amount of the short - range correlations .
the higher @xmath4 values prefer distributions concentrated around the maximum at @xmath112 fm .
the effects of the 3nfs are small for the lowest @xmath4 but increase with increasing @xmath4 . for the lowest @xmath4 there is also a strong dependence of the correlation function on the sfr parameter @xmath113 .
in this paper we , for the first time , included the long - range n@xmath2lo corrections to the 3nf in the faddeev calculations .
these novel two - pion - exchange , two - pion - one - pion and ring interactions supplemented with the one - pion - exchange and contact terms emerging at n@xmath5lo represent , presently , the most advanced chiral 3nf .
we use this force in the triton and the doublet neutron - deuteron scattering length faddeev calculations to fix the two low - energy parameters @xmath61 and @xmath68 for different sets of regularization parameters , which cut off large - momentum or , equivalently , short - range components in the few - nucleon states .
while the value of the lec @xmath61 remains fairly stable , @xmath68 features a stronger sensitivity to regularization parameters
. it will be interesting whether such a behavior is also seen for fits involving the complete n@xmath2lo 3nf .
we also studied the individual contributions of the various topologies to the triton binding energy .
the expectation values of the two - pion - one - pion and ring terms turn out to be smaller than the ones of the dominant two - pion - exchange 3nf for softer values of the regulator .
generally , all expectation values are found to be sizable .
as expected , we observe a strong sensitivity of the expectation values to the regularization parameters .
we also looked at the impact of the used 3nf on the two - nucleon correlation function in the triton .
while our work does not yet correspond to a complete n@xmath2lo analysis due to the shorter - range contributions and relativistic corrections to the 3nf which are not yet available and are still missing in our calculations , it does represent a very important step in this direction and provides a proof - of - principle that the very complex operator structure of the 3nf at n@xmath2lo can be successfully implemented in few - body calculations . in the future
, this study should be extended to explore effects of the novel terms in the 3nf in few - nucleon scattering .
this work is in progress . to complete the analysis of the 3nf at n@xmath2lo the inclusion of full structure of shorter - range @xmath58 , @xmath65 as well as @xmath66 terms should be pursued .
the numerical implementation of the new terms can be straightforwardly performed using the newly developed apwd scheme , which is successfully tested for the long - range terms in the present study .
finally , it should be emphasized that the present work also opens the way for applying the novel chiral nuclear forces in many - body calculations , see e.g. @xcite for some exciting recent developments along these lines based on n@xmath5lo 3nfs .
this work was supported by the polish ministry of science and higher education under grant no .
n n202 077435 .
it was also partially supported by the helmholtz association ( grants vh - ng-222 and vh - vi-231 ) , by the european community - research infrastructure integrating activity `` study of strongly interacting matter '' ( acronym hadronphysics2 , grant agreement n. 227431 ) under the seventh framework programme of eu and the european research council ( erc-2010-stg 259218 nucleareft ) .
the numerical calculations have been performed on the supercomputer cluster of the jsc , jlich , germany and ack - cyfronet , krakw , poland .
e. epelbaum , w. glckle , ulf - g .
meiner , nucl .
a*747 * , 362 ( 2005 ) .
d. r. entem , r. machleidt , phys .
c*68 * , 041001 ( 2003 ) .
e. epelbaum , w. glckle , ulf - g .
meiner , eur .
j. a*19 * , 125 ( 2004 ) .
e. epelbaum , a. nogga , w. glckle , h. kamada , ulf - g .
meiner , h.witaa , phys .
c*66 * , 064001 ( 2002 ) .
u. van kolck , phys . rev .
c*49 * , 2932 - 2941 ( 1994 ) .
e. epelbaum , h. krebs , d. lee and ulf - g .
meiner , phys .
lett . * 106 * , 192501 ( 2011 ) .
p. navratil , v. g. gueorguiev , j. p. vary , w. e. ormand and a. nogga , phys . rev .
lett . *
99 * , 042501 ( 2007 ) .
d. gazit , s. quaglioni and p. navratil , phys .
lett . * 103 * , 102502 ( 2009 ) .
kistryn et al . , phys .
c*72 * , 044006 ( 2005 ) .
t. lesinski , k. hebeler , t. duguet , a. schwenk , arxiv:1104.2955 [ nucl - th ] .
in fact , @xmath114-space potentials generated by the long - range n@xmath2lo contributions are much weaker than the ones emerging from the leading two - pion exchange terms at relative distances of the order of the inverse pion mass . | long - range contributions to the three - nucleon force that have been recently worked out in chiral effective field theory at next - to - next - to - next - to - leading order are for the first time included in the triton and the doublet nucleon - deuteron scattering length calculations .
the strengths of the two short - range terms available at this order in the chiral expansion are determined from the triton binding energy and the neutron - deuteron doublet scattering length .
the structure of the resulting three - nucleon force is explored and effects for the two - nucleon correlation function in the triton are investigated .
expectation values of the individual contributions to the three - nucleon force in the triton are found to be in the range from a few @xmath0 kev to about @xmath1 mev .
our study demonstrates that the very complicated operator structure of the novel chiral three - nucleon forces can be successively implemented in three - nucleon faddeev calculations . |
young and compact radio sources represent the first stage in the evolution of large extragalactic radio sources and constitute an important fraction ( @xmath7 ) of the radio source population ( see , however , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* for problems in selecting genuine young sources against blazars ) .
there are still open questions on the radio source initial phase , concerning its impact on the host galaxy and the evolutionary path from compact to large ( and giant ) radio structures .
+ simulations indicate that during the first phase of the expansion ( which lasts @xmath810@xmath9 yrs ) a powerful radio source can interact with the interstellar medium ( ism ) of its host galaxy , and later on with the intergalactic medium ( igm ) ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) .
observations at radio and optical frequencies reveal signatures of these interactions in nearby radio galaxies ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
both the mechanical and radiative energies released by the young radio source can be relatively high and may have an important impact on the host galaxy ( e.g. influencing the star formation processes , affecting the amount and temperature of the gaseous fraction of ism and igm ) .
measurements of the radio source total power during the initial phase are thus important for unveiling feedback processes at work in the evolving galaxies .
+ according to the current understanding , compact gigahertz - peaked spectrum ( gps ) radio sources evolve into compact steep spectrum ( css ) sources1 and @xmath110 - 15 kpc , respectively , and a power at 1.4 ghz @xmath10 erg s@xmath3 hz@xmath3 .
they typically display convex radio spectra with turn over frequencies between @xmath40.1 and @xmath41 ghz ( see * ? ? ?
* for a review ) .
] and finally become large - scale ( @xmath1120 kpc ) radio sources @xcite .
the presence of a class of even more compact and young radio sources , so - called high frequency peakers ( hfp ) , is still under investigation ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* for a review ) .
the high fraction of young sources in radio samples ( in comparison with the large - scale ones ) suggests a more complex evolutionary picture : intermittency of the radio activity @xcite or the presence of a population of short - lived sources ( never reaching the large - scale stage , e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) are possible explanations .
furthermore , it is not clear which morphology gps and css will finally display , i.e. whether they will evolve into fanaroff - riley type i ( fri ) or type ii ( frii ) sources @xcite .
+ the high - energy domain may provide important clues on the most energetic processes associated with the young source phase .
so far , most of the high - energy investigations have been done in the x - rays ( 0.5 - 10 kev ) using _
chandra _ and _ xmm - newton _ observations @xcite .
these show that young sources are relatively x - ray luminous ( @xmath12 erg s@xmath3 ) . however , the entire radio structure is typically enclosed within angular scales which can not be resolved by x - ray telescopes ( a few arcseconds or smaller ) , thus the x - ray morphology is usually not accessible @xcite .
studies of the origin of the x - ray emission , including an identification of distinct high - energy emission components , rely mainly on the analysis of x - ray spectral features , which is hampered by the limited photon statistics @xcite . as a consequence ,
it is hard to disentangle the contribution of the jet- and lobe - related non thermal emission from the one related to the accretion processes ( either the x - ray thermal emission of the innermost part of the disk or that resulting from comptonization of disk photons by electrons in a hot corona ) . + a significant level of non - thermal x - ray flux can be produced via inverse compton ( ic ) scattering of different seed photons in the compact lobes of gps radio galaxies @xcite . given the typical gps linear sizes ( @xmath11 kpc ) the nuclear photon fields , e.g. optical - uv disk and ir torus photons , are intense enough to provide , when comptonized , x - ray luminosities of the order of @xmath13@xmath14 erg s@xmath3 @xcite .
in the case of gps and css quasars , the closer jet alignment to the line of sight should favor the beamed jet component .
this is certainly observed in the radio band @xcite , while the x - ray behavior remains more elusive .
the jet x - ray emission can be important depending on its parameters ( inclination , bulk motion , intrinsic power ) . in the case of the css quasar 3c 186
, we have shown that the jet could contribute to the total x - ray emission when it develops a complex velocity structure ( see * ? ? ?
+ the @xmath0-ray band can be useful to study many aspects of the physics of young radio sources . at these frequencies
the disk - corona component is expected to rapidly drop in intensity , while both beamed and unbeamed non - thermal emission could be still strong and detectable in powerful sources .
the intensity of the @xmath0-ray flux depends on several factors . for the case of compact symmetric objects ( cso )
, the model presented in @xcite predicts a significant isotropic non - thermal emission in the 0.1 100 gev band produced in the radio lobes , however within a wide range from @xmath15 erg s@xmath3 up to @xmath16 erg s@xmath3 depending on the source parameters . in this scenario ,
the non - thermal high - energy emission may even dominate the total radiative output of the source , and as such it is crucial for constraining the total energetics of the expanding source . @xcite and @xcite have shown that non - thermal ic emission may arise from a shell of shocked ism driven by the expanding radio source .
the estimated gev and tev emission from the mini shells associated with powerful ( i.e. with jet powers of the order of @xmath16 erg s@xmath3 ) and compact ( @xmath45 pc ) sources could be potentially detectable by the next generation of cherenkov telescopes .
the @xmath0-ray emission related to the hadronic component within the compact lobes of cso was discussed in @xcite .
@xcite predict bright gev luminosities produced via bremsstrahlung in the cocoons and radio lobes of cso . in this case , a @xmath0-ray detection with _
fermi _ -lat would be possible for nearby ( @xmath17 mpc ) sources if the jet is powerful and made of e@xmath18 plasma .
+ a dedicated study of the jet component in young radio sources and its possible @xmath0-ray emission has not yet been performed .
we have therefore investigated for the first time the @xmath0-ray properties of a sample of young radio sources using the large area telescope ( lat ) onboard the _ fermi _ satellite ( see * ? ? ?
the goals of the study are : 1- to refine model predictions for the @xmath0-ray emission of the jets of young radio sources ; 2- to constrain the entire non - thermal high - energy emission continua of these objects .
we adopt the following approach : we first set up a general leptonic synchrotron and inverse compton ( ic ) model for the non - thermal emission of jets in compact radio sources ; then we generate a library of their broad - band spectral energy distributions ( sed ) for a wide range of selected jet parameters ( linear sizes , jet powers , jet bulk velocities etc . ) . while previous studies focused on the isotropic emission associated with the extended structures of young sources , i.e. lobes and cocoons , in this work we concentrate on the jet beamed radiation and consider powerful radio quasars .
indeed , an important difference between jet and lobe emission arises from the jet relativistic ( bulk ) motion : the jet emission is relativistically beamed and its detection also depends on the observer viewing angle . in models presented in the literature ( see e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) the emission of the source is consistently calculated by coupling the evolution of the electron distribution to the source dynamical expansion . here , rather than following the evolution of a single source
, we simulate the emission for a distribution of sources assuming a wide range of values for the jet parameters .
these simulations are compared with the analyzed _ fermi _ -lat data for the considered gps and css sample .
we discuss the results of the lat analysis on the sample and the implications for non - thermal models .
we set up a model to evaluate the non - thermal ( beamed ) emission from jets in young radio sources .
the jet emission is computed using a general leptonic radiative model . in the following ,
we describe the main features of the model . + we assume a simple geometry for the emission region ( see figure [ f1 ] for a schematic illustration ) .
the bulk of the jet emission is produced in a spherical knot , located at a distance @xmath19 from the central black hole ( bh ) .
the knot is moving with a bulk lorentz factor @xmath20 .
the electrons in the knot radiate via synchrotron and ic emission .
seed photons for the ic mechanism are the synchrotron emission of the knot and external radiation fields ( synchrotron - self - compton , ssc , and external compton , ec , processes , respectively ) .
the latter are uv photons from the accretion disk ( ec / disk * ? ? ?
* ) or disk emission reprocessed by the dust surrounding the central engine and emitted at ir wavelengths ( ec / dust * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the model also takes into account the high energy emission that may be associated with the presence of a longitudinal velocity structure inside the jet .
this is done by adding a radiative field of synchrotron photons ( ec / syn ) produced outside the knot in a blazar - like component located at the base of the jet , moving with a highly relativistic speed @xmath21 ( see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
. the intensity of ec / syn luminosity can be comparable to the high energy emission potentially produced by the blazar core itself ( e.g. via ssc or compton scattering of the photons of the broad line regions , blr , and of the dusty torus ) .
therefore we included the ec / syn contribution to the total jet high - energy emission only if it is larger than the blazar one for a given parameter set .
the ec luminosity is treated following prescriptions for anisotropic radiation fields in the reference frame of the emitting region ( see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
+ in order to reduce the number of free parameters in the model , we linked together or fixed some of the quantities ( see table [ t1 ] ) .
the height of the emitting knot @xmath19 is equal to the jet linear size , measured from the core to the jet termination ( hereafter ls ) .
the jet has a conical geometry with a semi - aperture angle equal to 0.1 ( r=0.1ls ) , which allows for reasonable sizes of the knot radius r ( 1 pc to 1 kpc ) within the considered linear scales ( ls@xmath2210 kpc ) .
+ the fraction of disk photons reprocessed by nuclear dust in a putative torus is fixed to @xmath23 , in agreement with luminosities found for type 1 quasars @xcite , where the disk emission can be directly observed .
since we are not aiming at a detailed model of the source spectrum , thermal emission from the disk and the dust is simply modeled with a blackbody spectrum .
we set the disk temperature @xmath24 to @xmath25 k. the dust temperature ( @xmath26370 k ) is derived from the observed peak frequency of the ir emission ( @xmath27 hz * ? ? ?
* ) using the formula @xmath28 ( see * ? ? ?
the considered spatial scales are larger than 1 pc , thus we always treat the disk as a point - like source of photons , with the energy density of the disk photons , @xmath29 , scaling as @xmath30 ( and @xmath31 ) . for simplicity , we assumed a thin spherical shell for the dust spatial distribution , the shell radius being @xmath32 cm @xcite .
the dust photon energy density , @xmath33 , is computed using equation ( 21 ) in @xcite when @xmath34 and considering a point - like source of photons when @xmath35 .
the value of @xmath33 at the discontinuity point , @xmath36 , is the average between the dust energy densities immediately inside and outside the shell .
+ we assume a link between the accretion and ejection processes related to the supermassive bh .
the power carried by the jet in radiating particles and poynting flux ( @xmath37 ) is proportional to the disk luminosity , @xmath38 .
a relation between the jet and disk powers in extragalactic radio sources has been considered by @xcite , who found that the average jet kinetic power , necessary to support the radio lobes , is comparable with the accretion disk luminosity . in powerful blazars
, an energetically dominant proton component is required to account for the radiative jet luminosities , and the jet total power can be even larger than the accretion disk luminosity ( @xmath39 * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . in gps
radio galaxies , @xcite inferred @xmath40 based on their modeling of the lobe emission .
+ we set the parameters of the blazar - like blob referring to the estimated ranges of the sample of flat spectrum radio quasars ( fsrq ) @xcite : the blazar blob emits 10% of the jet kinetic power via synchrotron emission and has a bulk motion of @xmath41 .
+ to summarize , in the model @xmath42 , @xmath38 , @xmath20 and the observer viewing angle @xmath43 are free input parameters , @xmath19 is equal to @xmath42 , and the jet kinetic power @xmath37 and the dust emission @xmath44 are both proportional to @xmath38 .
in addition , we assume a moderate dominance of particles over magnetic field energy density in the knot : @xmath45 , @xmath46 being the energy density of the radiating electrons and @xmath47 the magnetic field energy density , respectively .
observations indicate that radio lobes in young sources are in equipartition conditions ( see * ? ? ?
however , in jet knots of frii radio galaxies , radio and x - ray observations point to intensities of the magnetic field below the values expected under the assumption of energy equipartition with the radiating particles , when the x - ray emission is ascribed to ic emission ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) . similarly , sed modeling of multiwavelength emission of fsrq and bl lac objects points to particle dominated jets @xcite .
+ we allow the shape of the electron energy distribution ( hereafter eed ) to be either a simple power law , @xmath48 , or a broken power law . the minimum and maximum electron lorentz factor , @xmath49 and @xmath50 , are fixed to 10 and 10@xmath9 , respectively .
the parameter values of the eed ( @xmath51 for the single power law spectral index ; @xmath52 and @xmath53 and @xmath54 for the spectral indexes of the broken power law and the energy break , respectively ) are derived from observations as discussed in the following section .
the model parameters ( and with the assumed values ) are listed in table [ t1 ] .
we simulate the jets sed for a range of ls and bolometric disk luminosities , @xmath38 .
our simulations cover the range of ls and @xmath38 values of the sample of young radio quasars with an x - ray detection presented in @xcite , @xmath55 kpc and @xmath56 erg s@xmath3 respectively .
in fact , we anticipate that x - rays provide important constraints on the model predicted @xmath0-ray luminosities .
the optical - uv emission of the gps and css quasars displays the typical features of broad - line quasars , with detected uv - bump and broad emission lines , and the measured intrinsic absorption columns in the x - rays are less than a few @xmath57 @xmath58 @xcite .
thus , we do not expect the disk emission to be heavily affected by obscuration .
since the observed disk emission is not modified by other orientation effects , e.g. relativistic beaming , we use it to define the luminosity range of our simulations .
+ mildly to highly relativistic jet velocities are considered , with values of the bulk motion @xmath20 between 1.4 to 10 , where the minimum value refers to the study presented in @xcite .
we allowed observer s viewing angles , @xmath43 , in the 10@xmath59 to 50@xmath59 range so that we exclude the most closely aligned objects ( i.e. blazar sources ) .
inclination angles @xmath110@xmath59 would also imply larger jet linear sizes for the quasars in the sample than typical gps and css sources .
it is however true that single components within the jet ( i.e. a single knot or the inner jet ) might have smaller @xmath43 . + the shape of the eed in young sources is not well known . here
, we consider a single and a broken power law .
the spectral index for the single power law eed is set to the median x - ray photon index ( @xmath60 , @xmath61 ) of the sample of gps and css quasars @xcite . in the broken power law eed
, we set the spectral index below and above the energy break to @xmath62=2.1 and @xmath63=4.0 , respectively .
the low - energy index is consistent ( within the errors ) with the average @xmath64 in radio loud quasars ( @xmath65 and @xmath66 , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ?
* respectively ) .
we refer to @xmath0-ray observations of misaligned radio sources to derive the spectral index above the energy break : we consider the sample of misaligned radio sources detected by _ fermi_-lat and select the central value in the range of their measured @xmath0-ray photon indexes ( @xmath67 * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the energy break is fixed to an intermediate value between the minimum and maximum electron lorentz factor , @xmath54 .
similar eed functions have been inferred by modeling the broad band sed of hot spots ( see the cases of cygnus a , pks 1421 - 490 and 3c 445 in * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* respectively ) and blazar jets @xcite . in this work
, we do not discuss a specific theoretical scenario for the particle acceleration process .
however , it is interesting to note that , in jets , indications for electron injection spectra that deviate from the standard e@xmath68 form ( related to first - order fermi acceleration process in non - relativistic shocks ) come from observations @xcite and simulations ( see e.g. the results of particle in cell simulations presented in * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) . + we allow three jet to disk power ratios , @xmath690.01 , 0.1 and 1.0 , hence , given the assumed @xmath38 values , the minimum and maximum jet powers in our simulations are @xmath70 and @xmath71 erg s@xmath3 , respectively .
these values cover the ratios previously inferred for radio sources , including gps radio galaxies ( e.g. * ? ? ?
we do not consider the case of @xmath72 , which was derived for fsrq and could be possibly associated with flaring states limited in time ( see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* and references therein for a discussion ) .
+ in figure [ f1 ] we show the simulated sed for a jet with @xmath73 erg s@xmath3 , moving with @xmath74 and observed at @xmath43=30@xmath59 .
the sed are for two considered linear sizes , ls=25 pc ( upper panels ) and ls=300 pc ( lower panels ) and for the two assumed functions of the eed ( the single power law in the left panels , and the broken power law in right panels ) .
+ the low energy part of the spectrum includes synchrotron self absorption effects .
the characteristic convex spectral shape observed at radio frequencies in young sources could also be due to free - free absorption by an inhomogeneous ambient medium .
however , such effect is likely to be more important in the radio lobes synchrotron spectrum ( see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . + for the single power law eed ,
the sed of the 25 pc jet above @xmath410@xmath75hz is dominated by one mechanism , i.e. ssc radiation .
for the same linear size , in the broken power law case the x - ray luminosity ( and up to @xmath810@xmath76 hz ) is mainly produced via ssc while the @xmath0-ray luminosity ( @xmath410@xmath77 - 10@xmath78hz ) via ec / syn .
the energy density of the synchrotron photons produced by the blazar - like component scales as @xmath79 ( in the knot rest frame , see * ? ? ?
therefore , the ec / syn luminosity is expected to be intense in powerful jets that decelerate on * scales of * tens of parsecs . in misaligned sources ( e.g. @xmath1120@xmath59 for our model parameters ) , such component can be brighter than the high - energy emission from the inner blazar component .
+ the underlying eed shape determines the observed x - ray to @xmath0-ray spectrum , with a slope of the sed ( for the 25 pc jet ) that is steep for the single power law eed and flat for the broken power law .
the difference between the two sed holds true even when the ec / syn component is not present .
in fact , the ec / disk luminosity peaks in the @xmath0-ray band and still dominates over the ssc @xmath0-ray emission in the broken power law eed case .
+ the radiative output of the jet decreases at all wavelengths for increasing ls .
furthermore , the dominant contributions to the x - ray and @xmath0-ray bands may change as the source expands .
figure [ f1 ] shows that the ec / disk luminosity dominates the high - energy output of the 300 pc jet .
this follows from the model scaling relations for the synchrotron and ic luminosities .
given the jet kinetic power in radiating particles and magnetic field : + @xmath80 where @xmath81 and @xmath82 , the total synchrotron luminosity in the jet comoving frame depends on the jet power and the volume of the emitting region : + @xmath83 the ec luminosities related to the disk emission ( ec / disk , ec / dust ) scale in the same way ( for @xmath84 ) : + @xmath85 for @xmath86 and @xmath35 , i.e. when the emitting knot is out of the torus region ( for @xmath87 : @xmath88 ) , while the ssc luminosity scales as : @xmath89 where @xmath90 is the energy density of the synchrotron photons in the jet / knot rest frame .
+ the ssc luminosity decreases faster than ec luminosities with ls .
this is evident in the sed for the 300 pc jet : for both assumed eed the ec / disk luminosity peak is higher than the ssc one .
interestingly , in the broken power law eed this also changes the x - to-@xmath0-ray luminosity ratio ( and slope ) with respect to the sed of the 25 pc jet .
note that the ec / syn component is not considered at ls=300 pc , as it becomes fainter than the blazar emission .
for each of the simulated sed we computed the synchrotron luminosity at 5 ghz ( @xmath91 ) , the x - ray luminosity at 2 kev ( @xmath92 ) and integrated 100 mev - 10 gev luminosity ( @xmath93 ) in the observer rest frame .
the 2 kev and 100 mev-10 gev luminosities are obtained by adding up all the ic contributions ( ssc , ec / disk , ec / dust and ec / syn ) at each frequency . for the assumed jet parameters ranges
, the synchrotron emission never significantly contributes at 2 kev .
we recall that the external compton emission on the blazar - like synchrotron photons ( ec / syn ) is included only when , for a given parameter set , it is larger than the estimated high - energy emission of the blazar component itself , assuming for the latter ssc and ic on the broad line and dusty torus photons .
this happens in @xmath410% of the cases for the simulated distributions .
+ figure [ f2 ] shows the @xmath0-ray luminosity of the simulated jets as a function of their radio ( @xmath91@xmath93 , upper panels ) and x - ray luminosities ( @xmath92@xmath93 , lower panels ) , for the two considered eed ( left and right panels for the single and the broken power law eed , respectively ) and jet to disk power ratios ( @xmath690.01 , 0.1 and 1.0 ) .
+ figure [ f2a ] illustrates how the input model parameters , @xmath37 , ls , @xmath20 and @xmath43 , shape the simulated @xmath91-@xmath93 distributions .
we use the @xmath691.0 distribution ( in the single power law eed case ) as an example : each trail in the figure highlights the path in the luminosity - luminosity space when varying a single input parameter while keeping the others fixed .
powerful ( @xmath94 erg s@xmath3 ) and small ( ls@xmath410 pc ) sources are the most intrinsically luminous , while low power and large ( ls@xmath410 kpc ) sources are the least intrinsically luminous , as expected from the scalings of the luminosities in ( [ eq2 ] ) , ( [ eq3 ] ) , ( [ eq4 ] ) .
effects related to the jet speed , orientation with respect to the line of sight , and to the selected monochromatic luminosities ( in the observer rest frame ) are also important
. modifications of the emitted luminosities in the observer rest frame due to @xmath43 and @xmath20 are expressed via the doppler factor @xmath95 ( @xmath96 ) .
the intrinsic luminosity transforms in the observer frame as @xmath97 , and the observed luminosity of a jet may change by orders of magnitude for increasing @xmath43 depending on its bulk motion . for @xmath9810 , for instance ,
@xmath95 changes from @xmath45 to @xmath40.3 going from @xmath9910@xmath59 to @xmath9950@xmath59 , with a correspondent variation of more than 4 orders of magnitude in @xmath91 and @xmath93 .
the position of a jet ( with a given set of @xmath42 , @xmath37 and @xmath20 ) can therefore migrate across the @xmath91(@xmath92)@xmath93 space depending on @xmath43 ( see figure [ f2a ] ) .
doppler effects may be particularly relevant for monochromatic ( or band ) luminosities close to the extremes of the synchrotron and ic spectra , where even a small shift along the frequency axis ( @xmath100 , with @xmath101 and @xmath102 the emitted and observed frequency , respectively ) significantly changes the observed luminosity .
+ the @xmath91-@xmath93 distributions ( and the @xmath91-@xmath92 distributions in figure [ f3 ] ) present a fan - like shape , with an increasing spread of the @xmath91-@xmath93 relation for @xmath91@xmath103 erg s@xmath3 . in intrinsically powerful sources
@xmath91 drastically increases when the jet ( and therefore the volume of the emitting region ) expands up to a few hundred parsecs and the 5 ghz frequency shifts from the optically thick to the optically thin part of the synchrotron spectrum .
for ls@xmath11100 pc , @xmath91 progressively declines ( following @xmath104 ) as shown in figure [ f2a ] . in low luminosity sources ,
the turn - over frequency from the optically thick to the optically thin regime is below 5 ghz at all the considered ls , thus @xmath91 simply declines @xmath105 ( when all the other input parameters are fixed ) .
this explains the fact that for lower jet power intervals ( i.e. when @xmath106=0.01 is assumed ) the @xmath91-@xmath93 distributions are more linear , though with dispersion .
+ for decreasing @xmath106 , the whole @xmath91-@xmath93 distribution shifts to lower radio and @xmath0-ray maximum and minimum luminosities .
interestingly , jets with @xmath107 can still be relatively @xmath0-ray luminous ( @xmath93@xmath108 erg s@xmath3 ) .
we also note that , for a fixed @xmath91 , the highest @xmath93 are obtained for the smallest jet - to - disk ratio ( @xmath690.01 ) .
this is due to the fact that ec / disk gives the dominant contribution in the @xmath0-ray band .
finally , the @xmath91-@xmath93 relation shows a lower dispersion for the single power law eed than for the broken power law eed , as expected for a simpler spectral shape .
+ the simulated @xmath93-@xmath92 distributions ( figure [ f2 ] , lower panels ) are linear for all the considered @xmath106 , the x - ray and @xmath0-ray emissions being produced by the same electron population via ic mechanism .
the distributions obtained from the broken power law eed have a larger dispersion than the simple power law eed .
in fact , in the former case @xmath92 and @xmath93 can be related to different ic emissions , e.g. ssc emission in the x - rays and ec in the @xmath0-rays ( as in the example in figure [ f1 ] ) . a dominant ssc contribution in the x - rays
is expected in powerful and small jets ( @xmath109 erg s@xmath3 , ls@xmath410 pc ) , since @xmath110 . for @xmath690.01 and 0.1 , the relative increase of ec / disk and ec / dust over ssc in the x - ray band
reduces the spread of the @xmath92-@xmath93 distribution with respect to the @xmath691.0 case .
in addition , in the @xmath0-ray band attenuation of the ic flux may happen when the scattering occurs in the klein - nishina regime ( which is included in the model computation of the ic spectrum ) .
the simulated @xmath91@xmath93 and @xmath92@xmath93 luminosity distributions provide indications to select candidates for a @xmath0-ray detection , based on radio and x - ray luminosities .
the radio luminosity ( @xmath91 ) alone is not a sufficient selection criterium , in particular for sources with a dominant , luminous ( @xmath91@xmath103 erg s@xmath3 ) jet component .
in fact , for a selected @xmath91 luminosity in the @xmath114 erg s@xmath3 interval , the corresponding allowed @xmath0-ray luminosities span between @xmath115 erg s@xmath3 .
when @xmath91@xmath116 erg s@xmath3 , the @xmath0-ray luminosities are constrained within an interval of @xmath41 - 2 orders of magnitude .
the @xmath92@xmath93 distribution has a constant linearity over several orders of magnitude .
nevertheless , radio observations are certainly needed : classification of young radio sources rely on radio observations , which allow us to probe smaller scales than x - rays and to resolve different radio components .
+ we used the simulated luminosity distributions to derive relations among the three luminosities , @xmath91 @xmath92 and @xmath93 , for the considered jet - to - disk ratios and eed .
a fit of the simulated data applying a linear model , with the coefficients estimated by the least - square method , returned the following relations for the @xmath691.0 distribution in the case of the single power - law eed : @xmath117 and the broken power - law eed : @xmath118 with all the luminosities in units of @xmath13 erg s@xmath3 .
the scatter in @xmath93 at fixed @xmath91 and @xmath92 is 0.16 dex and 0.55 dex for equations [ eq5 ] and [ eq6 ] , respectively .
note that this scatter is derived only from our jet model .
+ the coefficients of the best fit and relative dispersion for all the simulated distributions are reported in table [ t2 ] .
we underline that these relations are indicative of the expected @xmath0-ray luminosities for the assumed jet model and assigned ranges of the parameters .
in order to search for jet - related @xmath0-ray emission in young radio sources , we selected a sample requiring that : 1- all the sources have radio and x - ray observations ; 2- the jet is likely the most relevant contribution to the non - thermal emission .
we considered gps and css radio quasars @xcite , as in young radio galaxies the compact radio lobes could dominate the non - thermal contribution @xcite .
our sample is formed by 13 quasars , 6 classified as gps sources and 7 as css sources .
all the sources were part of a dedicated x - ray study with _
chandra _ observations . the results of the x - ray analysis were presented in @xcite . in table
[ t3 ] , we report the redshift , estimated projected size , radio ( 5 ghz ) , x - ray ( 2 kev ) and estimated bolometric ( @xmath119 ) luminosities of the sample . the sample , though not complete by any means , is the largest sample available of gps and css quasars with x - ray ( and radio ) observations . + before proceeding further , we comment on the nature of gps quasars .
it is known that gps quasar samples are partly contaminated by quasars with a core - jet structure which appears compact only because of projection effects .
@xcite found that large scale emission , indicative of the presence of an extended structure , is often detected in gps quasars .
even though young quasars could display some degree of radio fluctuations , radio variability gives a definite clue for an aligned quasar , i.e. with a blazar - like nature ( see * ? ? ?
an example is the case of pks 1127 - 14 , which was initially classified as a gps quasar .
x - ray and radio observations have revealed the presence of a kiloparsec scale jet @xcite .
this together with the observed multi - band flux variability and superluminal expansion of the core region points to a blazar nature of the source @xcite . we still included the source in our sample for comparison with the other gps / css quasars .
+ in figure [ f3 ] , we plot the @xmath92 of the quasars in the sample as a function of their @xmath91 and compare them with the simulated distributions . here
, we have simply ascribed all the 5 ghz luminosity to the jet .
this approximation is more risky in the case of gps than css sources , because the synchrotron emission of the gps compact ( @xmath11 kpc ) lobes could be important in the ghz - band .
we have also assumed that the bulk of the 2 kev flux is produced by the jet .
this hypothesis is indeed part of the jet scenario that we want to probe by comparing model predictions with observations .
+ the quasars occupy the high - luminosity region of the @xmath91-@xmath92 plot .
this is well - sampled by our simulations when @xmath691.0 ( for both assumed eed ) , while the overlap with the @xmath107 distribution is only marginal .
a significant overestimate of the @xmath91 of the observed sample ( up to 1 - 2 orders of magnitude ) must be considered to reconcile observations and simulated radio and x - ray luminosities for @xmath107 . on the other hand ,
the discrepancy with the simulations becomes even larger if only a fraction of the x - ray emission in the quasars of the sample is produced by the jet .
+ interestingly , the simulations show that the lack of a clear correlation between the @xmath91 and @xmath92 luminosities of the observed sample does not necessary rule out a common ( jet ) origin for them . + in table
[ t3 ] , we report the 100 mev10 gev luminosities estimated using equations [ eq5 ] and [ eq6 ] ( we considered only the @xmath691.0 distribution , which better covers the @xmath91 and @xmath92 of the sample ) .
the predicted @xmath0-ray luminosities span between @xmath810@xmath120 and @xmath810@xmath121 erg s@xmath3 , and the minimum and maximum 100 mev-10 gev fluxes are @xmath122 erg @xmath58 s@xmath3 and @xmath123 . by comparison ,
the three - year _
fermi _ -lat flux sensitivity for point sources with 5@xmath124 detection is @xmath43@xmath12510@xmath126 erg @xmath58 s@xmath3 ( at galactic pole and assuming a power - law spectrum with @xmath127 , see * ? ? ?
seven of the estimated @xmath0-ray fluxes using equation ( [ eq5 ] ) are above or near such threshold , and the number reduces to four for equation ( [ eq6 ] ) . none of the sources in the sample is associated with a @xmath0-ray source in the lat 2-year point source catalogue ( 2fgl * ? ? ?
* except for pks 1127 - 14 , associated with the @xmath0-ray source 2fgl1130.3 - 1448 ) .
however , the 2fgl includes only sources with a minimum @xmath114 @xmath124 detection significance evaluated from the @xmath128 distribution with 4 degrees of freedom ( position and spectral parameters * ? ? ?
the _ fermi_-lat is a pair - production @xmath0-ray telescope sensitive to photons in the energy range from 20 mev to @xmath129300 gev .
its large effective area ( @xmath48000 @xmath58 on axis for @xmath1301 gev ) provides view of 2.4 sr of the full sky with an unprecedented angular resolution at these energies ( the 68% containment angles of the reconstructed incoming photon direction below 10 gev estimated as @xmath131 ) .
it mainly operates in a sky - survey mode and covers the full sky every two orbits ( @xmath43 hours ) .
detailed description of the _ fermi_-lat and of the on - orbit performances are provided in @xcite .
+ we analyzed the _
fermi_-lat data collected during 46 months of operation ( august 2008 to february 2012 ) . for each source , we selected only the events of the pass 7 v6 _ source _ class , which reduces the residual background rate ( see * ? ? ? * ) .
we used the pass7 version 6 of the instrument response functions ( irfs * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the data were analyzed with the lat science tools software package ( version v9r27p1 ) .
we also made use of the lat analysis scripts ( version 0.1.9 ) for part of the analysis .
+ we applied the standard event selections .
time intervals when the rocking angle of _
fermi_-lat was greater than 52@xmath59 were rejected and only events coming from zenith angles smaller than 100@xmath59 were considered in order to minimize the contribution from terrestrial albedo @xmath0-rays .
we considered data in the 0.2 to 100 gev energy range .
though conservative , this energy selection allow us to reduce systematic errors and the position uncertainties .
+ for each source , we selected a circular region of interest ( roi ) of 10@xmath59 radius , centered on the radio position of our candidate . the full _
fermi _ model that we adopted to calculate an unbinned likelihood includes all the point - like and diffuse sources within the roi . due to the energy - dependent size of the _ fermi_-lat point - spread - function ( psf ) , sources falling between 10@xmath59 and
15@xmath59 can contribute to the total counts observed in the roi and therefore were also included in the model .
the emission model also accounts for the galactic and extragalactic ( and instrumental ) diffuse backgrounds . in this work
, we used the ` mapcube ' file ` gal_2yearp7v6_v0.fits ` and the ` iso_p7v6source.txt ` table to describe the emission from the milky way and the isotropic component , respectively .
+ we adopted a power - law spectrum ( @xmath132 ) for our sources and assumed the spectral models and parameters reported in the 2fgl catalog for all the other sources .
we initially fixed the spectral parameters of all the sources located 5@xmath59 away from our target to the best fit value reported in the 2fgl .
we performed a fit using the unbinned maximum likelihood ( _ gtlike _ ) and evaluated the significance of the source detection based on the test statistic value / likelihood@xmath133 ) . ]
( ts , * ? ? ? * ) . when the fit did not converge , we simplified the model in the following way : 1- we fixed the @xmath0-ray photon index of our target to @xmath134 ; 2- we progressively froze the spectral shape parameters of the sources in the inner 5@xmath135 circle starting from the farthest ones , as also all the parameters of weak background sources ( @xmath136 phot @xmath58 s@xmath3 ) .
the results of the _ fermi_-lat analysis are shown in table [ t4 ] . in most of the cases ,
we did not find @xmath0-ray excesses above the background in coincidence with the position of the sources in the sample . for ts values less than 9 ( @xmath13 @xmath124 ) , we calculated the corresponding integral flux upper limit in the range 0.1 - 10 gev at 95% confidence level , setting the photon index of the spectral power - law equal to @xmath134 .
+ when the _
fermi _ likelihood analysis returned ambiguous results , we further proceeded with the analysis and investigated : 1- the spatial distribution of the ts value ( ts map ) in the roi ( using _ gttsmap _ ) ; 2- the temporal distribution of the ts value by producing a 0.2 - 100 gev light curve in the selected period probing bin time of months .
we note that the ts map also allows us to check for the presence of possible new background sources in the 4-year dataset which are not included in the 2fgl . in the case of q1829 + 290
, we obtained a ts value of 20 .
we built a ts map using the best fit model returned by the likelihood analysis which includes all the sources reported in the 2fgl ( without our source ) .
all the parameters of the model were fixed except for the galactic diffuse prefactor and the isotropic diffuse normalization .
the ts map of the residuals ( in figure [ f4 ] , left panel ) shows an excess in the region corresponding to the radio position of q1829 + 290 ( ts@xmath137 ) . in the source field
there are three 2fgl @xmath0-ray sources within 3@xmath59 radius ( 2fglj1829.1 + 2725 at 1.76@xmath59 distance , 2fglj1836.2 + 3137 at 2.72@xmath59 and 2fglj1842.3 + 2740 at 2.83@xmath59 ) and , given the _
fermi_-lat psf in the selected energy band ( @xmath83@xmath59at 200 mev ) , we can not exclude flux contamination .
we produced the @xmath0-ray lightcurve of q1829 + 290 using 4-month time bins and compared it with the lightcurves of the two nearest 2fgl sources . in this case
, we left free to vary only the normalization ( integral and prefactor for the powerlaw2 and powerlaw models , respectively ) parameter of the three sources ( and again normalizations of the galactic and isotropic diffuse and instrumental backgrounds ) .
the likelihood analysis was performed in each time interval : the ts values of each of the three sources was computed and for ts@xmath1389 ( 3@xmath124 ) the flux value was replaced by the upper limit .
the flux lightcurves of the three sources , together with their ts values in each time bin , are shown in figure [ f4 ] .
the ts of q1829 + 290 is below 9 in all the intervals and its flux fluctuations follow those of the nearest 2fgl source ( 2fglj1829.1 + 2725 ) , pointing to flux contamination .
+ pks1127 - 14 is the only object associated with a @xmath0-ray source with a high ts value ( 514 ) .
however , the classification of this source has been revised from a gps to a fsrq @xcite .
its @xmath0-ray lightcurve shows variability , further supporting the interpretation of a blazar - like nature of the core .
we refer to our future paper for a detailed analysis of this source ( and see also * ? ? ?
+ summarizing , there was no statistically significant @xmath0-ray detection of the young radio sources in our sample for the considered _ fermi_-lat data set .
in the case of q1829 + 290 ,
i.e. the only source with a ts value above 9 , we can not exclude flux contamination from near sources in the field .
the primary goal of the study is to investigate the nature of the high energy emission produced by the jet in young radio sources focusing for the first time on the @xmath0-ray band .
the sed simulations have shown that jets of compact sources can be @xmath0-ray luminous : intrinsically powerful jets observed at moderate angles ( @xmath139 @xmath59 ) could reach @xmath93@xmath140 erg s@xmath3 .
the identification of @xmath0-ray luminous young sources is , however , not straightforward , due to our limited knowledge of some of the jet parameters ( e.g. @xmath20 , @xmath43 ) . radio and x - ray observations
are both necessary to select @xmath0-ray candidates among young and bright radio sources ( @xmath91@xmath103 erg s@xmath3 ) . in the following ,
we compare the model predictions and observations for the selected sample of young radio quasars and discuss the implications for the jet emission . the analysis of the _
fermi_-lat observations did not reveal @xmath0-ray emission associated with the sources in our sample .
however , a jet contribution to the high - energy emission is not ruled out . in figure
[ f5 ] , the _ fermi_-lat upper limits are compared to the simulated @xmath0-ray luminosities , @xmath93 , as a function of the linear size , ls ( for the observed sample we used the projected jet linear size derived from the radio data and reported in table [ t3 ] ) . for this comparison , we selected subsamples from each simulated distribution so that the radio and x - ray luminosities are in the range of the observed sample : 10@xmath141@xmath91@xmath2210@xmath142 erg s@xmath3 , 10@xmath141@xmath92@xmath2210@xmath143 erg s@xmath3 ( and 10@xmath144l@xmath14510@xmath121 erg s@xmath3 , 10 pc@xmath22ls@xmath2210 kpc ) .
+ the luminosity selection determines a progressive reduction of the number of simulated sources with increasing ls . specifically , in the subsamples obtained from @xmath690.1 and 0.01 there are no sources with ls larger than @xmath45 kpc and @xmath4200 pc , respectively .
the reason is that the radiative efficiency of the jet depends on ls ( @xmath104 , @xmath146 and @xmath147 ) , thus for the considered parameter intervals only the most powerful jets ( @xmath148 erg s@xmath3 ) can produce the observed radio and x - ray luminosities at kiloparsec scales .
+ the simulated @xmath0-ray luminosities in the subsamples are compatible with the _
fermi_-lat upper limits , although the _
fermi_-lat sensitivity is the main limit for a test of the model predictions .
for a few sources the comparison between observations and simulations ( in the case of a single power law eed ) allows to place constraints on the jet parameters ( upper panel in figure [ f5 ] ) .
the _ fermi_-lat limits on q1143 - 245 and q0741 + 311 rule out the most extreme simulated @xmath0-ray luminosities ( @xmath93@xmath1110@xmath149 erg s@xmath3 ) .
a jet with @xmath107 also appears to produce @xmath93 above the _
fermi_-lat upper limit of q0741 + 311 . similarly , a _
fermi_-lat detection of q0134 + 329 and q1250 + 56 would be likely if the jet has @xmath691.0 ( in the single power law eed case ) .
+ the @xmath0-ray luminosity associated with pks 1127 - 14 , @xmath93@xmath150 erg s@xmath3 , is consistent with the highest predicted @xmath0-ray luminosities for the single power - law eed ( upper panel in figure [ f5 ] ) . the linear size adopted for this source ( ls=12 pc , from * ? ? ?
* ) refers to its initial gps classification ( and corresponds to the inner part of the radio jet ) .
such value can be considered as an upper limit for the distance of the emitting region from the black hole .
in fact , the location of the @xmath0-ray emitting region in blazar sources is under debate and estimates span from sub- to a few tens of parsecs ( see @xcite for a discussion and the cases of the quasar pks 1510 - 089 and the bl lacertae object oj287 in @xcite and @xcite , respectively ) .
interestingly , @xcite proposed that the @xmath0-ray emission of pks 1127 - 14 is produced via compton scattering on the ir photons taking place on parsec scales @xcite . in our simulated distributions , @xmath0-ray luminosities of the order of @xmath14-@xmath71 erg s@xmath3
are obtained via ec / dust in compact ( ls@xmath120 pc ) and powerful jets ( @xmath148 erg s@xmath3 ) . for these parameter values
, the emitting region is still moving through the medium which produces the ir photons ( @xmath151 erg s@xmath3 ) .
the highest ec / dust luminosities ( in the observer rest frame ) are produced for jet bulk motions of @xmath42 - 4 .
for the considered minimum viewing angle ( @xmath43=10@xmath59 ) , large values of @xmath20 ( e.g. 10 - 20 ) would narrow the radiation cone and reduce the observed luminosity .
the observed @xmath0-ray luminosity of pks 1127 - 14 can be reproduced by assuming a single power law for the electron energy distribution ( for all the @xmath106 ratios ) , while it is underpredicted in the broken power law scenario ( though within an order of magnitude ) .
nonetheless , we note that the high energy sed of blazars inferred from x - ray to @xmath0-ray observations typically displays a complex shape @xcite , and a broken power law appears to be a more realistic description of the energy distribution of the radiating particles .
+ we consider the same subsamples of simulated sources to test the model predictions against observations in the x - ray band . in figure [ f6 ]
we show the simulated and observed @xmath92 to @xmath91 ratios as a function of ls .
the simulated ratios have a different evolution with ls depending on the shape of the eed . in the broken power law case the maximum @xmath92 to @xmath91 ratio decreases with ls .
two connected effects cause this trend : 1- at large ls ( @xmath111 kpc ) , intrinsically powerful jets ( @xmath152 erg s@xmath3 and thus @xmath1530.1 ) are needed to produce the observed radio and x - ray luminosities of the css quasars ; 2- the x - ray emission of such powerful jets is dominated by the ssc component , thus @xmath92/@xmath91 scales as @xmath154 at all the considered ls .
+ for the single power law eed , the maximum @xmath92/@xmath91 is ( roughly ) constant for ls@xmath11100 pc ( for @xmath691.0 , see upper panel in figure [ f6 ] ) . above such ls ,
the ec / disk and ec / dust contributions to the x - ray band become dominant over the ssc ( see also figure [ f1 ] ) , and thus @xmath92/@xmath91@xmath155 . when @xmath156 , the relative intensity of the disk - related photon fields ( @xmath29 and @xmath33 ) with respect to the local synchrotron emission ( @xmath90 ) increases , therefore the transition to a constant @xmath92-@xmath91 ratio ( i.e. @xmath157 in x - rays ) happens at smaller ls than for @xmath158 .
the modeled @xmath92-@xmath91 ratios for ls@xmath11 kpc are in good agreement with the ones of the quasar sample . at kiloparsec scales ,
the model underestimates the @xmath92@xmath91 ratios observed in css quasars ( see figure [ f6 ] ) .
the discrepancy is caused by the fact that the simulated sources with ls@xmath159 kpc have x - ray luminosities only marginally comparable with , or below , the observed ones but can be radio luminous , with @xmath91 of the order of @xmath160 erg s@xmath3 or larger .
this result is not in contradiction with the substantial overlap between simulated and observed sources shown in figures [ f3 ] .
in fact , in that case the comparison is limited to two observables only ( @xmath91 and@xmath92 ) , while in figure [ f6 ] we introduce additional information ( i.e the linear size and the relation between the radio and x - ray jet luminosities , i.e. @xmath92/@xmath91 ) .
+ the gap between the observed and simulated sources , though still present , is reduced for the subsamples simulated assuming a single power law eed and when @xmath161 . however , in the @xmath162 distribution the number of kiloparsec scale sources , which abide by the subsample selection criteria , is limited .
we also note that the difference between simulated and observed @xmath92@xmath91 ratios could be even more severe when we consider the true , i.e. not the projected , linear size .
+ bearing in mind the limited size of our sample , we can discuss the differences between the model and observations .
we first consider whether different parameter values and assumptions might change the predictions .
+ a more compact emitting region than the one assumed here ( @xmath82 ) would increase the ssc luminosity .
we tested the case of r=0.01@xmath125ls .
the @xmath92-@xmath91 ratios increase but at kiloparsec scales they are still below the observed ratios .
+ can different doppler factors , @xmath95 , modify the model results in the right directions ? in our simulations @xmath95 is between @xmath40.3 and @xmath45 . for the considered values of @xmath43 ( 10@xmath59 - 50@xmath59 ) , which reasonably sample the viewing angles for quasars
, @xmath20 above the maximum assigned value of 10 would not increase @xmath95 .
furthermore , the observed ssc and synchrotron flux densities have the same dependency on @xmath95 .
thus this factor can not significantly modify the @xmath91/@xmath92 of jets where the ssc luminosity dominates the x - ray emission .
the boosting of the external compton luminosity depends on the arrival direction of the seed photons in the jet comoving frame @xcite .
if the emitting region is still within the putative torus region , for instance , there is a @xmath163 factor between the ec / dust and the synchrotron observed luminosities .
however , for the considered external fields , such effect could be important for small size sources ( tens of parsec ) , without affecting the ratios in the css sample .
+ the discrepancy between observations and simulations holds true for all the simulated subsamples , though to different amplitude , suggesting that it does not strongly depend on the assumed spectral shape of the electron distribution .
+ an increase of the particle to magnetic field energy density ratio is a viable option . in figure
[ f7 ] , we show that simulations assuming @xmath16410@xmath165 ( and @xmath166 ) can reproduce the observed @xmath92@xmath91 ratios .
interestingly , the corresponding simulated @xmath0-ray luminosities for the majority of the sources are above the measured _
fermi_-lat upper limits and would make a @xmath0-ray detection likely
. + the study of the parameters seems to confirm that the observed x - ray emission can be hardly produced by the jet at scales larger than @xmath41 kpc .
this can be interpreted in two ways : 1- the bulk of the jet x - ray emission is always produced at distances smaller than @xmath41 kpc from the central bh ; 2- the observed x - ray emission is due to an additional component not related to the jet , such as the disk - corona emission .
+ in our model , the dissipation region moves along the jet as the source expands : the decrease of the x - ray emission with ls is a consequence of the increasing volume of the emitting region and decrease of the intensities of the nuclear photon field ( @xmath167 ) .
this is certainly a simplified picture , since large ( @xmath12910 kpc ) radio jets may display multiple x - ray knots and diffuse x - ray emission .
however , in our simulations the case of a bright knot located at an intermediate position along an extended jet is accounted for by considering a distribution of linear sizes ( e.g. a knot located at 100 pc in a 10 kpc jet will have the same luminosity of a 100 pc jet with the same jet power ) .
continuous x - ray emission is typically present at lower luminosity levels , and here we aim at modeling the brightest x - ray component of a jet .
+ @xcite found that in gps quasars the origin of the radio emission appears to be close to the core .
this means that either the bulk of the emission is produced by the inner part of the jet or , as pointed out by the authors , it is due to projection effects making the compact and young nature of these sources uncertain .
@xcite investigated the origin of the x - ray emission observed in the gps quasar 3c 287 and concluded that it is likely associated with the inner radio jet , whose axis is closely aligned to the observer line of sight .
the authors argue that the lack of variability , which is typical of blazar sources , might be related to particular physical conditions of the jet in the initial phase . in this scenario , the non detection with _
fermi_-lat can also be in favor of a non - blazar nature . in the css quasar 3c 48 , @xcite reported the presence of a hard x - ray excess which is ascribed to the inner part of the jet and a similar explanation is invoked for the css source pks 2004 - 447 @xcite .
+ as an alternative , the x - ray emission may be primarily contributed by thermal radiation from the innermost region of the accretion disk or comptonization of the disk photons in a hot corona as observed in the x - ray cores of quasars and frii radio galaxies .
@xcite found that the median optical - to - x - ray luminosity parameter ( @xmath168 ) for their sample of gps and css quasars and radio galaxies is [email protected] , in agreement with @xmath168 of radio - quiet quasars @xcite .
in addition , the estimated disk luminosities of the observed quasars suggest a radiatively efficient disk .
an accretion - related origin is also plausible for the x - ray emission of gps radio galaxies , which appears to be highly absorbed ( with equivalent hydrogen column density of @xmath170 @xmath58 , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
an alternative explanation in the framework of non - thermal emission from the lobes is proposed by @xcite and @xcite .
+ a comparison with non - blazar radio sources detected in @xmath0-rays is useful to understand how the jet emission can contribute the x - ray to @xmath0-ray band . here
, we consider the recent @xmath0-ray studies on misaligned agn ( magn ) and broad line radio galaxies ( blrg , * ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . the sample of magn observed by _
fermi_-lat is dominated by low - power fri radio sources , while powerful frii appear to be an elusive @xmath0-ray class .
the different redshift distribution of the two classes , with frii being ( typically ) more distant , seems not sufficient to explain the low rate of detection .
an intrinsic difference in the jet structure and/or emission mechanism responsible for the @xmath0-rays has been proposed as a possible explanation ( * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) .
jets with a complex dynamical structure as well as beaming difference between ssc and ec @xcite processes can account for a smaller number of frii sources than fri . among the 18 blrg investigated in @xcite using two - year _
fermi _ -lat data , only 3c 111 and 3c 120 have @xmath0-ray detections . in these sources ,
the @xmath0-ray emission is ascribed to the unresolved cores and displays variability on month ( or longer ) timescales , with the consequence that the sources are not always @xmath0-ray detected .
+ the sources in our sample are all radio powerful and most of them morphologically resemble frii radio sources .
thus , it is possible that they share the same @xmath0-ray elusiveness .
the results of our study are in agreement with previous findings that the jet does not likely dominate the x - ray core emission . in blrg cores ,
the jet emission can contribute to some fraction of the x - ray emission but it is typically hidden by the emission of the accretion disk and corona @xcite . in the 2 - 10 kev band , @xcite constrain the jet to accretion flow relative contribution to a factor of @xmath1380.7 .
nonetheless , the jet might emerge at higher energies , as confirmed by the @xmath0-ray detections of 3c 111 and 3c 120 .
@xcite evaluate the jet and disk relative contributions in the selected blrg using a composite model of a thermal plus non - thermal templates to reproduce the broadband core emission ( similar to the approach adopted in * ? ? ?
the authors conclude that the total ( observed ) luminosity of the jet is on average not less than 1% of the disk - corona luminosity , and in some sources can even be almost comparable to it .
we investigated the high energy emission produced by jets in young radio quasars , focusing on a sample of gps and css quasars previously detected in x - rays by _
chandra _ . the analysis of @xmath446 month _
fermi_-lat data does not reveal any statistically significant @xmath0-ray detection of the sources , except for the already known case of pks1127 - 14 . for the first time , we compared the _ fermi_-lat and _ chandra _ observations of the sample to @xmath0-ray and x - ray luminosities predicted by a simple jet synchrotron and ic radiative model .
the simulations performed for a reasonable set of model parameters and assumptions have shown that for the analyzed sample : * @xmath1710.01 is required for the range of disk luminosities of the sources : low power jets ( as for the @xmath690.01 case ) fail to produce the majority of the observed radio luminosities ( figure [ f3 ] ) ; * a jet origin of the bulk of the observed x - ray emission is strongly disfavored . specifically , this holds true for x - ray emission associated with kiloparsec jets ( e.g. jets of css quasars ) even when we significantly change our initial assumptions ; * large deviations from energy equipartition ( @xmath172 ) , necessary to produce the observed x - ray luminosities , would imply @xmath0-ray fluxes detectable by _
fermi _ -lat .
our analysis indicates that in the considered sample the bulk of the x - ray emission is either related to the inner ( @xmath1381 kpc ) jet or to a different component , most likely the disk - corona . +
this study also shows that the @xmath0-ray band can be important for the classification of compact radio sources , to distinguish between young and aligned sources : a gps quasar that is radio and x - ray bright but not detected in @xmath0-rays ( at the current level of the lat al sky - survey sensitivity ) is likely to be truly a young compact radio source rather than a blazar with large radio structures observed at small viewing angles .
the authors thank m. sikora and d. e. harris for useful suggestions and comments .
we are grateful to the anonymous referee for critical comments which helped to improve the paper .
this work was supported by the national aeronautics and space administration contract nas8 - 03060 and under the following grants : nnx10ao60 g issued through the fermi guest observer program and go1 - 12145x issued through the chandra x - ray observatory guest observer program .
the authors thank the fermi science support center help desk team for support in the data analysis .
this research has made used of topcatmbt / topcat/ ] @xcite for the preparation and manipulation of the tabular data .
l l c & & + + + + ls & jet linear size ( core to jet termination ) & 10 pc10 kpc + @xmath38 & bolometric disk luminosity & 10@xmath14210@xmath121 erg s@xmath3 + @xmath20 & jet knot bulk lorentz factor & 1.410 + @xmath43 & observer s viewing angle & 10@xmath5950@xmath59 + + + r & knot radius & 0.1ls + z@xmath173 & knot distance from the bh & ls + @xmath37 & jet kinetic power & ( 0.01,0.1,1.0)@xmath38 + @xmath46 & radiating electron energy density & @xmath174 + @xmath47 & magnetic field energy density & @xmath175 + @xmath44 & dust / ir luminosity & 0.1@xmath38 + @xmath176 & dust shell radius & @xmath177 + @xmath178 & synchrotron radiative power of the blazar - like blob & @xmath179 + + + @xmath0@xmath180 & minimum electron lorentz factor & 10 + @xmath0@xmath181 & maximum electron lorentz factor & 10@xmath9 + @xmath0@xmath182 & energy break lorentz factor ( broken power law ) & @xmath183 + @xmath62 & eed index ( single power law ) & 2.68 + & eed low energy index ( broken power law ) & 2.1 + @xmath63 & eed high energy index ( broken power law ) & 4.0 + t@xmath184 & disk blackbody temperature & 3@xmath12510@xmath185 k + t@xmath186 & dust blackbody temperature & 370 k + @xmath21 & blazar - like blob bulk lorentz factor & 10 + columns:1- assumed jet - to - disk ratio ; 2- shape of the eed : sp = single power law , bp = broken power law ; 3- intercept ( @xmath93 are in units of @xmath13 erg s@xmath3 ) ; 4- @xmath187 coefficient ; 5- @xmath188 coefficient ; 6- intrinsic dispersion .
l r r r r c c c & & & & & & & + & & & & & & & + & & & & & & & + + + q0134 + 329/3c 48 & css & 0.367 & 1.27@xmath12510@xmath165 & 43.97 & 44.68 & 45.96 & 45.98/45.04 + q0615 + 820 & gps & 0.71 & 1.80@xmath12510@xmath165 & 43.94 & 44.23 & 45.37 & 45.56/44.74 + q0740 + 380/3c 186 & css & 1.063 & 10@xmath12510@xmath165 & 43.72 & 44.42 & 46.02 & 45.71/44.75 + q0741 + 311 & gps & 0.63 & 30 & 44.31 & 44.51 & 45.11 & 45.85/45.09 + q1127 - 145 & gps@xmath189 & 1.18 & 12 & 44.91 & 45.74 & 46.80 & 47.06/46.17 + q1143 - 245 & gps & 1.95 & 26 & 44.91 & 44.96 & 45.75 & 46.32/45.67 + q1245 - 197 & gps & 1.28 & 2.1@xmath12510@xmath165 & 44.77 & 43.89 & 44.80 & 45.31/44.91 + q1250 + 56/3c 277.1 & css & 0.32 & 3.86@xmath12510@xmath165 & 43.11 & 43.93 & 45.23 & 45.19/44.15 + q1328 + 254/3c 287 & css & 1.055 & 200 & 44.73 & 44.75 & 46.10 & 46.11/45.45 + q1416 + 067/3c 298 & css & 1.439 & 6.35@xmath12510@xmath165 & 44.68 & 45.84 & 46.90 & 47.13/46.12 + q1458 + 718/3c 309.1 & css & 0.905 & 8.25@xmath12510@xmath165 & 44.63 & 45.20 & 47.14 & 46.52/45.69 + q1815 + 614 & gps & 0.601 & & 43.38 & 43.74 & 44.70 & 45.04/44.16 + q1829 + 290 & css & 0.842 & 11.86@xmath12510@xmath165 & 44.06 & 43.23 & 44.96 & 44.63/44.16 + columns : 1 source name ; 2 gps or css radio classification based on @xcite ; 3 redshift ; 4 projected jet linear size ( calculated from @xcite with current cosmology ) ; 5 radio luminosity at 5 ghz ( see * ? ? ? * and references therein ) ; 6 x - ray luminosity at 2 kev @xcite ; 7 bolometric luminosity ; 8 predicted @xmath0-ray ( 100 mev10 gev ) luminosity ( see text ) .
+ @xmath190 : calculated using equation [ eq5 ] for a single power law eed , the scatter is 0.16 ( dex ) .
@xmath191 : calculated using equation [ eq6 ] for a broken power law eed , the scatter is 0.55 ( dex ) .
@xmath189 : classification for this source has been revised ( see text ) .
source & ts@xmath190 & _ fermi_-lat flux@xmath191 & _ fermi_-lat flux + & & @xmath192 phot @xmath58 s@xmath3 & @xmath193 erg @xmath58 s@xmath3 + ( 1 ) & ( 2 ) & ( 3 ) & ( 4 ) + + + q0134 + 329 & @xmath1380 & @xmath1383.5 & @xmath194 + q0615 + 820 & 3 & @xmath1384.9 & @xmath195 + q0740 + 380 & 3 & @xmath1383.7 & @xmath196 + q0741 + 311 & 6 & @xmath1387.9 & @xmath197 + pks1127 - 145 & 514 & 63@xmath1694@xmath198 & [email protected] + q1143 - 245 & 1 & @xmath1383.1 & @xmath199 + q1245 - 197 & @xmath1380 & @xmath1382.1 & @xmath200 + q1250 + 568 & 1 & @xmath1383.6 & @xmath201 + q1328 + 254 & 1 & @xmath1385.9 & @xmath202 + q1416 + 067 & 3 & @xmath1388.0 & @xmath203 + q1458 + 718 & 1 & @xmath1383.6 & @xmath201 + q1815 + 6127 & @xmath1380 & @xmath1381.2 & @xmath204 + q1829 + 290 & 20 & @xmath13819.5@xmath205 & @xmath206 + columns : 1 source name ; 2 test statistic value ; 3,4 _ fermi_lat 100 mev10 gev fluxes .
+ @xmath190 : when ts@xmath1389 ( @xmath207 ) , the reported flux is an upper limit .
@xmath191 : upper limits are calculated in the 100 mev - 10 gev energy band , for a fixed @xmath0-ray spectral index of 2.5 , at 95% confidence interval . @xmath198 : the measured @xmath0-ray spectral index is [email protected] .
@xmath205 : contamination of nearby ( @xmath1383 @xmath59 ) @xmath0-ray sources can not be excluded ( see text and figure [ f4 ] ) , thus even in this case we report to upper limit value .
erg s@xmath3 , @xmath74 , @xmath208 .
left panels : the assumed eed is a simple power law with @xmath209 , @xmath210 , p=2.68 .
right panels : the assumed eed is a broken power law with @xmath209 , @xmath210 , @xmath211 , p=2.1 , p2=4.0 . note that the ec / syn component is not included in the sed of the 300 pc jet ( see text ) . ] 32 0.25 degree bins .
the position of q1829 + 290 and the two nearest 2fgl sources are marked in the map . the position of q1829 + 290
coincides with a residual excess ( ts@xmath417 ) .
right panel : _
fermi_-lat flux lightcurve of q1829 + 290 ( in red ) , and of the two nearest @xmath0-ray sources reported in the 2fgl ( 2fglj1829.1 + 2725 in green and 2fgl1836.2 + 3137 in cyan ) covering the period from 2008 august 4 to 2012 february 23 , using a binning time of 4 months ( upper panel ) .
fluxes are reported in units of 10@xmath212 phot @xmath58 s@xmath3 and replaced by upper limit values for ts@xmath1389 .
the lower panel shows the corresponding ts values of the 3 sources in the time bins .
the ts value of q1829 + 290 ( in red ) is below 9 in all the bins .
, title="fig : " ] 32 0.25 degree bins . the position of q1829 + 290 and
the two nearest 2fgl sources are marked in the map .
the position of q1829 + 290 coincides with a residual excess ( ts@xmath417 ) .
right panel : _
fermi_-lat flux lightcurve of q1829 + 290 ( in red ) , and of the two nearest @xmath0-ray sources reported in the 2fgl ( 2fglj1829.1 + 2725 in green and 2fgl1836.2 + 3137 in cyan ) covering the period from 2008 august 4 to 2012 february 23 , using a binning time of 4 months ( upper panel ) .
fluxes are reported in units of 10@xmath212 phot @xmath58 s@xmath3 and replaced by upper limit values for ts@xmath1389 .
the lower panel shows the corresponding ts values of the 3 sources in the time bins .
the ts value of q1829 + 290 ( in red ) is below 9 in all the bins .
, title="fig : " ] | we investigate the contribution of the beamed jet component to the high energy emission in young and compact extragalactic radio sources , focusing for the first time on the @xmath0-ray band .
we derive predictions on the @xmath0-ray luminosities associated with the relativistic jet assuming a leptonic radiative model .
the high energy emission is produced via compton scattering by the relativistic electrons in a spherical region at the considered scales ( @xmath110 kpc ) .
simulations show a wide range of @xmath0-ray luminosities , with intensities up to @xmath2 erg s@xmath3 depending on the assumed jet parameters . we find a highly linear relation between the simulated x - ray and @xmath0-ray luminosities that can be used to select candidates for a @xmath0-ray detection .
we compare the simulated luminosity distributions in the radio , x - ray and @xmath0-ray regimes with observations for the largest sample of x - ray detected young radio quasars .
our analysis of @xmath44-year _ fermi _ large area telescope ( lat ) data does not give any statistically significant detection .
however , the majority of the model - predicted @xmath0-ray fluxes for the sample are near or below the current _ fermi_-lat flux threshold and compatible with the derived upper limits .
our study gives constraints on the minimum jet power ( @xmath5 ) , on a potential jet contribution to the x - ray emission in the most compact sources ( @xmath6 kpc ) and on the particles to magnetic field energy density ratio in broad agreement with equipartition assumption . |
the paradigm that has emerged for the production of outflows from active galactic nuclei ( agn ) involves the presence of large scale electromagnetic fields which are instrumental in their formation , acceleration and collimation , many gravitational radii from the central supermassive black hole ( nakamura et al , 2008 ; meier et al , 2001 ; blandford , 1976 ; lovelace , 1976 ) .
two models have taken center stage .
blandford & payne ( 1982 ; henceforth bp ) and extensions of this model ( li et al , 1992 and vlahakis & konigl , 2003 ) describe a centrifugally driven outflow of gas originating in a cold accretion disk as a solution to ideal mhd within the context of self - similarity .
if the angle between the poloidal component of the magnetic field and the disk surface is less than 60 degrees , mass - loading of the magnetic field lines occurs , leading to an inbalance between inward gravitational and outward centrifugal forces , with gravity being overwhelmed . unlike the bp mechanism which taps into the gravitational potential energy of the accretion flow , the blandford - znajek ( 1977 ; henceforth bz ) mechanism produces relativistic jets from large scale magnetic fields threading the rotating event horizon by extraction of black hole rotational energy .
the flux - trapping model ( reynolds et al , 2006 ) is an attempt to understand ways in which black hole accretion flows can overcome their diffusive character ( see also bisnovatyi - kogan & lovelace , 2007 and rothstein & lovelace , 2008 ) to produce strong magnetic field on the black hole ( see bisnovatyi - kogan & ruzmaikin , 1976 , for earliest attempt to study the accretion of large - scale ordered magnetic field on black hole ) indicating that if the flux - trapping behavior of the gap / plunge region is valid , the bz mechanism produces greatest power for black hole spin of @xmath0 ( garofalo , 2009 ) . here
we show that the same is true for the bp mechanism .
this means that although the spin dependence of bz and bp power is different overall , they both peak for near maximal retrograde black hole spin .
we motivate the idea that ordinary astrophysical processes will tend to shift near maximal retrograde black hole accretion systems toward more prograde spins ( i.e. accretion and/or spin energy extraction ) .
once formed ( e.g. in galaxy mergers ) , such systems will evolve toward a state of lower power output , which implies that the population density of near maximal retrograde black hole accretion systems that produce outflows and jets , is larger at the redshift of formation of the highly retrograde accretion systems and naturally tends to drop , so that the cosmological evolution of black hole spin is in the direction of prograde spins . in section 2
we describe the basic geometry of the flux - trapping model . in section 3
we discuss its implications for the bp power and those of assuming that outflows and jets in agn are all due to either bz , bp , or a combination of both mechanisms ( meier , 1999 ) . in section [ conclusion ]
we conclude .
the basic feature of our model is illustrated in figure [ blackhole_disk ] where magnetic field lines threading the black hole are separated from those threading the disk by a gap region ( or plunge region ) .
the absence of magnetic field threading the gap region is the fundamental assumption of the flux - trapping model ( reynolds , et al , 2006 ) .
this assumption has implications for both the bz and bp effects of which the former are illustrated in figure [ flxvsspin ] , originating from the numerical solution to the mhd equations in a kerr metric ( garofalo , 2009 ) .
we emphasize the fact that maximum bz power is produced for highly retrograde black hole spin , and extend the flux - trapping model to outflows of the bp type , with the basic point to motivate the existence of a spin dependence in bp power that is also maximized at high retrograde black hole spin values .
the model is further described below . 1 .
our accretion disk is described by a novikov & thorne ( 1974 ) disk truncated at the marginally stable orbit , inwards of which is the gap region .
2 . in the magnetosphere ( the region outside of the black hole and accretion disk )
we assume that the plasma density is negligible and hence that the magnetic field is force free .
we assume that no magnetic flux threads the gap or plunge region of the accretion disk .
any magnetic flux that is advected inwards across the radius of marginal stability is immediately added to the flux bundle threading the black hole .
4 . far away from the black hole and at poloidal angles above the accretion disk
, we assume the large - scale field is uniform .
in this section the focus is on the geometry of the magnetic field as in figure [ blackhole_disk ] and the changes that occur as the spin of the black hole varies . because bp outflows depend on the angle between the magnetic field and the accretion disk surface , the emphasis is on how this angle changes with spin . despite highlighting mhd force balance in the force - free magnetosphere ,
the discussion remains qualitative , limiting the study to identifying the spin value for which bp power is maximized .
magnetic forces between the flux bundle on the hole and that threading the disk compete at latitudes above the equatorial plane where the no - flux boundary condition is imposed ( see arrows in fig .
[ spin_geometry ] ) .
whereas magnetic pressure / tension of magnetic field lines threading the disk tend to push the hole - threading flux bundle onto the horizon , the latter reacts back on the disk - threading magnetic field to limit additional magnetic field advection onto the black hole .
the bend in the magnetic field threading the disk stems from the fact that while the radial inflow of the accreting gas attempts to drag the large scale magnetic field toward the black hole , the aformentioned magnetic forces from the flux bundle already threading the black hole , push the magnetic field lines threading the disk outward .
the greater the magnetic flux bundle on the black hole , the more effective its ability to halt additional advection from the disk , and the greater the bend inflicted on the magnetic field lines threading the disk . as fig .
[ spin_geometry ] illustrates , the magnitude of the black hole - threading flux bundle depends on the ability of the gap region to drag magnetic field inward . for high prograde - spinning black holes ,
the marginally stable circular orbit is close to the black hole horizon in both coordinate and proper distance which makes the gap region ineffective at dragging large magnetic flux to the horizon . in the low - spin or retrograde case , instead , the inner edge of the accretion disk at the marginally stable circular orbit is much further out so the proper distance to the horizon from the disk inner edge is larger .
this means that slowly spinning or retrograde black holes acquire magnetic flux via the gap region further out in radial position compared to their high - spin counterparts , resulting in a larger magnetic flux bundle on the horizon . as bp point out ,
if the magnetic field lines and the disk surface meet at an angle that is 60 degrees or less , a centrifugally - driven mhd wind is possible .
with respect to their high - spin counterparts , then , low - spin or retrograde systems are more likely to exhibit bent magnetic field line configurations which makes them comparatively better candidates for bp outflows .
this behavior is seen in the steady - state magnetic field configurations of the numerical solution ( figures [ spin_negative ] and [ spin_positive ] ) .
we choose a representative set of disk parameters such as disk thickness , accretion rate , prandtl number etc . , and illustrate the geometry of the numerical solution .
we find that the magnetic field lines threading the retrograde system are bent well out into the disk . the high prograde spin system , on the other hand , displays bent magnetic flux contours only in the innermost region of the accretion disk and even there the bend is small . in short , as the spin of the black hole decreases from high prograde toward high retrograde values , the magnetic field lines bend progressively more toward the disk surface .
if we associate this feature with greater bp outflow power , the arguments suggest that the spin dependence of bp power in the flux trapping model increases progressively from high prograde spins to high retrograde spins . therefore , like the bz power , the bp power is maximized for @xmath0 . assuming that the bz and bp mechanisms are the dominant path chosen by nature to produce outflows and jets in agn within the context of the flux - trapping model , leads to the conclusion that retrograde black hole accretion systems threaded by large - scale magnetic fields , tend toward prograde black hole spin systems unless some external factors beyond accretion and black hole rotational energy extraction occur .
accretion in retrograde systems , in fact , adds angular momentum to the hole in the prograde sense .
in addition , the bz power is largest for high retrograde spins which means that greatest spin energy extraction occurs to reduce the absolute value of the hole s angular momentum .
the bp mechanism , on the other hand , does not directly affect the black hole spin . clearly , accretion and spin - energy extraction via bz both operate to increase the spin away from @xmath0 .
how fast it moves away from @xmath0 and whether it crosses @xmath1 depends on the rate at which angular momentum is extracted by the bz mechanism as well as on the rate at which angular momentum is supplied by accretion .
the one thing that is clear , though , is that the most energetic outflows and jets produced in @xmath0 systems are not stable , so the spin must change . thus ,
if flux - trapping via the plunge region occurs in nature , the most powerful agn evolve to lower energies as their black hole spins become more prograde .
this work extends the relativistic flux - trapping model to include outflows of both the bz and bp type in an effort to constrain the cosmological evolution of black hole spin ( e.g. brenneman , 2009 ) and its possible connection to powerful outflows such as those in radio loud galaxies ( evans et al . , 2009 , in press ) .
our current picture of the interaction between black holes in agn and the host galaxy , suggests a coherent two - way conversation in which the host galaxy speaks to the black hole about the galaxy via accretion by funneling matter toward the black hole , and the black hole speaks to the galaxy about the black hole via outflows that leave signatures of its mass ( kormendy & richstone , 1995 ; magorrian et al . 1998 ; marconi & hunt , 2003 ; gebhardt et al .
2000 ; ferrarese & merritt , 2000 ; tremaine et al , 2002 ) .
if the behavior of the gap region is as fundamental as assumed here , this two - way conversation includes more , one in which the more subtle features of the highly non - newtonian aspects of space and time that dominate the region close to the center of galaxies are also revealed .
in fact , the scenario that emerges is one in which the spin parameter of the central supermassive black hole is not simply revealed in the generated outflow , but is an active participant in the dynamics of the latter , to the extent that it sets the scale for the magnitude of the outflow power .
the overall conclusion of the assumption that bp and bz operate within the context of flux - trapping is that galaxy evolution is tightly coupled to black hole spin .
[ conclusion ]
the author thanks david l. meier for detailed discussion on the bp effect . the research described in this paper
was carried out at the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , under a contract with the national aeronautics and space administration .
is supported by the nasa postdoctoral program at nasa jpl administered by oak ridge associated universities through contract with nasa .
bisnovatyi - kogan , g.s . & lovelace , r.v.e . , 2007 ,
apj , 667 , l167 | we explore the connection between black hole spin and agn power by addressing the consequences underlying the assumption in the recent literature that the gap region between accretion disks and black holes is fundamental in producing strong , spin - dependent , horizon - threading magnetic fields . under the additional assumption that jets and outflows in agn are produced by the blandford - znajek and blandford - payne mechanisms ,
we show that maximum jet / outflow power is achieved for accretion onto black holes having highly retrograde spin parameter , an energetically excited yet unstable gravitomagnetic configuration . |
interaction of ultrashort and strong optical laser pulse with solids has been a subject of intensive theoretical and experimental research during the last few decades .
@xcite the interest in this field has grown after experimental realization of short laser pulses with just a few oscillations of optical field , which is comparable to the internal fields of a solid.@xcite such high intensity optical pulses strongly affect the electron dynamics and strongly modify the transport and optical properties of solids within the duration of the pulse,@xcite which is a few femtosecond - long .
the response of electron system of a solid to the optical field of the pulse strongly depends on the band structure of the solid . for dielectrics , the main energy parameter , which determines the interaction of a solid with the laser pulse , is the bandgap @xmath0 between the occupied valence band and the empty conduction band .
if the pulse frequency is small , @xmath1 , then the electron dynamics can be described in terms of the dynamics of the passage through anticrossing points of quasistationary wannier - stark levels of conduction and valence bands in time dependent electric field of the laser pulse.@xcite the passage through such anticrossing points determines whether the electron dynamics is adiabatic or diabatic .
the last anticrossing point corresponds to the electric field of the strength @xmath2 .
such field can also be defined as the field which induces a change in electron potential energy by @xmath3 over the lattice period @xmath4 . for silica with bandgap @xmath5 ev ,
the critical field is @xmath6 v / . at such electric field ,
i.e. at the last anticrossing point of wannier - stark levels , the interband coupling is strong , which results in strong mixing of conduction and valence band states .
such mixing results in strong enhancement of dielectric response of the solid.@xcite in addition to the enhancement of dielectric susceptibility of the solid , the response of the electron system of dielectrics to a strong optical pulse shows another interesting property .
namely , the deviation of electron dynamics from adiabatic one results in finite charge transfer @xmath7 through the system during the pulse.@xcite for an ultrastrong pulse , the effective conductivity calculated from the transferred charge , @xmath8 , is enhanced by almost 18 orders in magnitude compared to its low - field value .
the direction of the charge transfer is the same as the direction of the pulse maximum . for ultrashort laser pulse ,
the electron dynamics is also highly reversible , i.e. the electron system almost returns to its initial state after the pulse ends .
such reversibility was demonstrated both experimentally@xcite and numerically.@xcite thus , within the duration of ultrashort and strong laser pulse , the insulator shows strong enhancement of both dielectric response and electrical conductivity with highly reversible dynamics . in metals , where the conduction band is partially occupied
, the main effect of interaction of ultrashort optical pulse with solid is strong modification of intraband electron dynamics.@xcite the electron dynamics in strong optical pulse shows high frequency bloch oscillations , which is visible in the generated electric current and in the shape of the optical pulse transmitted through the metal nanofilm.@xcite in addition to such oscillations the highly nonlinear electron dynamics in ultrastrong optical pulse results in strong enhancement of the pulse transmittance through the metal nanofilm.@xcite similar to dielectrics , the optical pulse also generates the transferred electric charge , but now the direction of the charge transfer is opposite to the direction of the pulse maximum . in the present paper
we consider interaction of ultrashort laser pulse with graphene monolayer@xcite .
the purely two dimensional electron dynamics in graphene is characterized by unique dispersion relation , the low energy part of which is relativistic with linear dependence of the electron energy on momentum .
the behavior of such low energy electrons is described by the dirac relativistic massless equation .
therefore , graphene is a semimetal with zero bandgap and relativistic low - energy dispersion . in this case
the interaction of the laser pulse with graphene should show some similarity to the behavior of a metal in strong optical pulse , where the intraband electron dynamics determines the response of the electron system .
zero bandgap should also result in strong interband mixing of the states of the valence and conduction bands .
below we consider femtosecond - long laser pulses , for which the duration of the pulse is less than the electron scattering time , which is of the order of 1 ps.@xcite in this case the electron dynamics is coherent and is described by the time - dependent schrdinger equation , where the time dependence is introduced through the time - dependent electric field of the optical pulse .
the dynamics of graphene in long optical pulse with duration of hundred femtosecond , for which the scattering processes become important and the electron dynamics is incoherent , has been studied in ref . within the density matrix approach , where the sensitivity of the hot - electron fermi distribution to the intensity of the optical pulse were reported .
for long circular polarized optical pulses , the interaction of electrons in graphene with periodic electric field results also in formation the floquet states and opening a gap in the energy spectrum of graphene@xcite or graphene - like topological surface states of topological insulator.@xcite
we consider an optical pulse , which is incident normally on graphene monolayer and has the following one - oscillation form @xmath9 where @xmath10 is the amplitude , which is related to the pulse power @xmath11 , @xmath12 is speed of light , @xmath13 , and @xmath14 is the pulse length , which is set @xmath15 fs .
we consider linearly polarized laser pulse , where the plane of polarization is characterized by angle @xmath16 measured relative to axis @xmath17 . here the @xmath17 and @xmath18 coordinate system is introduced in the plane of graphene and are determined by the crystallographic structure of graphene - see fig .
[ graphene ] .
the graphene has hexagonal lattice structure , which is shown in fig .
[ graphene](a ) .
the lattice has two sublattice , say `` a '' and `` b '' , and is determined by two lattice vectors @xmath19 and @xmath20 , where @xmath21 is the lattice constant . the distance between the nearest neighbor atoms of graphene is @xmath22 .
the first brillouin zone of the reciprocal lattice of graphene , which is a hexagon , is shown in fig .
[ graphene](b ) .
the points @xmath23 and @xmath24 , which are the vertices of the hexagon , are the dirac points .
the energy gaps at these points are zero and the low energy spectra near these points are described by the dirac relativistic equation .
the points @xmath25 and @xmath26 correspond to two valley of low energy spectrum of graphene . and
@xmath20 are the direct lattice vectors of graphene . the nearest neighbor coupling , which is characterized by the hopping integral @xmath27 , is also shown .
( b ) the first brillouin zone of reciprocal lattice of graphene .
points @xmath25 and @xmath26 are two degenerate dirac points , corresponding to two valleys of low energy spectrum of graphene .
blue line with arrows shows polarization of the time - dependent electric field of the pulse .
the polarization is characterized by angle @xmath16 .
, scaledwidth=48.0% ] the hamiltonian of an electron in graphene in the field of the optical pulse has the form @xmath28 where @xmath29 is the field - free electron hamiltonian , @xmath30 is a 2d vector , and @xmath31 $ ] . to describe both the conduction and valence bands of graphene within a single hamiltonian , we consider the nearest neighbour tight - binding model of graphene . for such model
the hamiltonian @xmath29 is the tight - binding hamiltonian of graphene,@xcite which describes the tight - binding coupling between two sublattices `` a '' and `` b '' - see fig .
[ graphene ] . in the reciprocal space
the hamiltonian @xmath29 is a @xmath32 matrix of the form@xcite @xmath33 where @xmath34 ev is the hopping integral and @xmath35 the energy spectrum of hamiltonian @xmath29 consists of conduction band ( @xmath36 or anti - bonding band ) and valence bands ( @xmath37 or bonding band ) with the energy dispersion @xmath38 ( conduction band ) and @xmath39 ( valence band ) .
the corresponding wave functions are @xmath40 and @xmath41 where @xmath42 .
the wave functions @xmath43 and @xmath44 have two components belonging to sublattices a and b , respectively . when the duration of the laser pulse is less than the characteristic electron scattering time , which is around 1 ps @xcite , the electron dynamics in external electric field of the optical pulse is coherent and can be described by the time dependent schrdinger equation @xmath45 where the hamiltonian ( [ htotal ] ) has explicit time dependence .
the electric field of the optical pulse generates both interband and intraband electron dynamics .
the interband dynamics introduces a coupling of the states of the conduction and valence bands and results in redistribution of electrons between two bands . for dielectrics , such dynamics results in its metallization , which manifest itself as a finite charge transfer through dielectrics and finite conduction band population after the pulse ends .
it is convenient to describe the intraband dynamics , i.e. the electron dynamics within a single band , in the reciprocal space .
in the reciprocal space , the electron dynamics is described by acceleration theorem , which has the following form @xmath46 the acceleration theorem is universal and does not depend on the dispersion law .
therefore the intraband electron dynamics is the same for both conduction and valence bands . for an electron with initial momentum @xmath47 the electron dynamics
is described by the time dependent wave vector , @xmath48 , which is given by the solution of eq .
( [ acceleration ] ) , @xmath49 the corresponding wave functions are the houston functions , @xcite @xmath50 , @xmath51 } , % \exp \left\{- \frac{i}{\hbar } \int ^t_{-\infty } \!\ !
dt_1 e _ { \alpha } ( \vec{k}_t(\vec{q},t_1 ) ) \right\ } \label{phi_h}\ ] ] where @xmath52 ( valence band ) or @xmath53 ( conduction band ) . using the houston functions as the basis , we express the general solution of the time - dependent schrdinger equation ( [ time_eq1 ] ) in the following form @xmath54 the solution ( [ psi0 ] ) is parametrized by initial electron wave vector @xmath47 . due to universal electron dynamics in the reciprocal space , the states , which belong to different bands ( conduction and valence bands ) and which have the same initial wave vector @xmath47 ,
will have the same wave vector @xmath55 at later moment of time @xmath56 .
since the interband dipole matrix element , which determines the coupling of the conduction and valence band states in external electric field , is diagonal in the reciprocal space , then the states with different initial wave vectors are not coupled by the pulse field . as a result in eq .
( [ psi0 ] ) , for each value of initial wave vector @xmath57 , we need to find only two time - dependent expansion coefficients @xmath58 and @xmath59 .
such decoupling of the states with different values of @xmath47 is the property of coherent dynamics . for incoherent dynamics , the electron scattering couples the states with different wave vectors @xmath47 . in this case
the dynamics is described by the density matrix .
the expansion coefficients satisfy the following system of differential equations @xmath60 where the vector - function @xmath61 is proportional to the interband dipole matrix element @xmath62 e^{- \frac{i}{\hbar } \int ^t_{-\infty } \!\ !
dt_1 \left\ { e_{c } [ \vec{k}_t(\vec{q},t_1 ) ] -e_{v } [ \vec{k}_t(\vec{q},t_1 ) ] \right\ } } , \label{q_vector}\ ] ] where @xmath63 $ ] is the dipole matrix element between the states of the conduction and valence bands with wave vector @xmath64 , i.e. @xmath65 substituting the conduction and valence band wave functions ( [ functionv ] ) and ( [ functionc ] ) into eq .
( [ dipole ] ) , we obtain the following expressions for the interband dipole matrix elements @xmath66 } { 1 + 4 \cos \left ( \frac{ak_y}{2 } \right ) \left [ \cos \left(\frac{3ak_x}{2\sqrt{3 } } \right ) + \cos \left(\frac{ak_y}{2 } \right ) \right ] } \label{dx}\ ] ] and @xmath67 } .
\label{dy}\ ] ] the system of equations ( [ system1])-([system2 ] ) describes the interband electron dynamics and determines the mixing of the conduction band and the valence band states in the electric field of the pulse .
there are two solutions of the system ( [ system1])-([system2 ] ) , which correspond to two initial conditions : @xmath68 and @xmath69 .
these solutions determine the evolution of the states , which are initially in the valence band or in the conduction band , respectively . for undoped graphene
all states of the valence band are occupied and all states of the conduction band are empty . for an electron , which is initially in the valence band the mixing of the states of different bands
is characterized by the time - dependent component @xmath70 .
we can also define the time - dependent total occupation of the conduction band for undoped graphene from the following expression @xmath71 where the sum is over the first bruilluen zone and the solution @xmath72 in eq .
( [ ntotal ] ) satisfies the initial condition @xmath73 .
redistribution of electrons between the conduction and the valence bands in time - dependent electric field also generates electric current , which can be calculated in terms of the operator of velocity from the following expression @xmath74 where @xmath75 and @xmath76 are the matrix elements of the velocity operator @xmath77 between the conduction and valence band states . with the known wave functions ( [ functionv])-([functionc ] ) of the conduction and valence bands the matrix elements of the velocity operator are @xmath78,\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath79 @xmath80,\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath81 the interband matrix elements of the velocity operator , @xmath82 and @xmath83 , are related to the interband dipole matrix elements , @xmath84/\hbar $ ] and @xmath85/\hbar $ ] .
@xcite within the nearest neighbor tight binding model , the graphene has electron - hole symmetry , which results in the relation @xmath86 .
inclusion into the model the higher order tight - binding couplings , e.g. next - nearest neighbor terms , introduced electron - hole asymmetry , which results in different magnitudes of velocity in the conduction and valence bands.@xcite this asymmetry is weak and does not change the main results presented below .
if the direction of electric field of the pulse is along the direction of high symmetry of graphene crystal , then the current ( [ current ] ) is generated along the direction of electric field of the pulse only , @xmath87 .
for graphene , the directions of high symmetry correspond to polarization angles @xmath88 and @xmath89 . if polarization of electric field is not along the direction of high symmetry of graphene , then the current is generated in both the direction of the field , @xmath87 , and in the direction perpendicular to the field , @xmath90 .
the generated current results in charge transfer through the system , which is determined by an expression @xmath91 where @xmath92 or @xmath93 , which corresponds to the charge transfer along the direction of polarization of the laser pulse and in the direction perpendicular to polarization of the pulse , respectively .
the transferred charge is nonzero only due to irreversibility of electron dynamics in the optical pulse . for completely reversible dynamics ,
when the system returns to its initial state , the transferred charge is exactly zero . indeed , since the current can be expressed in terms of polarization @xmath94 of the electron system as @xmath95 , then the transferred charge is determined by the residual polarization of the system , i.e. polarization of the electron system after the pulse ends , @xmath96 .
the residual population is nonzero only for irreversible dynamics .
the electron dynamics in time dependent electric field is determined by two unique properties of graphene : ( i ) zero band gap , which results in strong interband mixing even in a weak electric field , and ( ii ) strong dependence of interband dipole matrix elements on the wave vector .
the interband dipole matrix elements , @xmath97 and @xmath98 , are singular at the dirac points , @xmath25 and @xmath26 . near these points
the dipole matrix elements behave as @xmath99 , where @xmath100 is the deviation of the wave vector from its value at the nearest dirac point .
the dipole matrix element @xmath97 calculated from eq . [ dx ] is shown as a function of the wave vector in fig .
[ z_x_y ] .
the dipole matrix element become large near the dirac points .
the dipole matrix element @xmath98 has similar behavior .
away from the dirac points the dipole matrix elements have a typical value of @xmath101 . at the center of the bruilluen zone ,
i.e. at @xmath102 , the dipole matrix elements are zero , i.e. at this point there is no interband coupling . in an electric field , either constant or time - dependent , the electron dynamics within a single band can be described in terms of time - dependent wave vector @xmath48 , which introduces an electron trajectory in the reciprocal space .
then the effective interband coupling is determined by the average value of dipole matrix elements along the electron trajectory .
is shown as a function of the wave vector @xmath64 .
the red lines show the boundary of the first brillouin zone .
the dipole matrix element is singular near the dirac points ( @xmath25 and @xmath103 points ) .
, scaledwidth=46.0% ] one of the characteristics of electron dynamics in time - dependent electric field of the optical pulse is redistribution of electrons between the conduction and valence band states . in undoped graphene ,
the valence band is initially fully occupied , while the conduction band is empty .
the electric field introduces coupling of the states of conduction and valence bands , which results in finite population of the conduction band . at first
, we characterize the redistribution of the electrons between the valence and conduction bands in terms of the total population of the conduction band , @xmath104 , - see eq .
( [ ntotal ] ) .
the time dependence of the conduction band population @xmath105 is correlated with the time - dependent electric field . in fig .
[ cb_field ] the conduction band population @xmath105 is shown as a function of time together with corresponding time - dependent electric field .
specific feature of this dependence is @xmath106 phase shift between the conduction band population @xmath105 and the electric field @xmath107 .
the maxima of the conduction band population correspond to zeros of the electric field .
such phase shift between @xmath105 and @xmath107 is due to strong wave vector dependence of the interband coupling . for insulators , where the interband coupling has weak dependence on the wave vector ,
the maxima of the conduction band population correspond to the maxima of the absolute value of electric field @xmath108.@xcite
the time - dependence of the conduction band population also illustrates the fact that the electron dynamics is highly irreversible , i.e. the electron system does not return to its original state after the pulse ends .
the residual conduction band population , i.e. population after the pulse ends , is large and comparable to the maximum conduction band population during the pulse .
irreversible dynamics of electron system persists at all pulse intensities .
this property is illustrated in fig .
[ cbs_maximum ] , where the conduction band population is shown for different pulse amplitudes , @xmath10 .
the time - dependent conduction band population , @xmath105 , have the similar time profile for all pulse amplitudes .
the maximum conduction band population is realized at @xmath109 fs , which corresponds to the last local maximum of the magnitude of electric field , @xmath108 . at all pulse amplitudes ,
the residual conduction band population , @xmath110 , is comparable to the maximum population .
both the residual and the maximum populations monotonically increase with increasing peak electric field @xmath10 , see fig . [
cbs_maximum](b ) .
the results shown in figs . [ cb_field ] and [ cbs_maximum ] correspond to polarization of the optical pulse along the @xmath17 axis , i.e. @xmath111 .
the conduction band population has weak dependence on the polarization of the optical pulse , i.e. on the value of angle @xmath112 , and the results similar to figs .
[ cb_field ] and [ cbs_maximum ] are valid for other angles @xmath16 .
, is shown for different intensities ( peak electric fields @xmath10 ) of the optical pulse .
( b ) the maximum and the residual conduction band populations are shown as a function of the pulse amplitude @xmath10 .
the polarization of the pulse is along axis @xmath17 , i.e. @xmath111 .
, scaledwidth=40.0% ] the irreversible electron dynamics and the phase shift between the time - dependent conduction band population and the time - dependent electric field are due to gapless energy dispersion in graphene and strong dependence of the interband dipole matrix elements , @xmath97 and @xmath98 , on the wave vector .
singularity of the dipole matrix elements at the dirac points also results in strongly nonuniform distribution of the conduction band population in the reciprocal space .
such distribution is given by the function @xmath113 and has strong dependence on the wave vector @xmath47 . in fig .
[ population_kxky_time ] the conduction band population is shown in the reciprocal space at different moments of time .
there are strongly localized regions in the reciprocal space with the conduction band population equals almost 1 .
therefore at these points the electrons are completely transferred to the conduction band with zero population of the valence band .
the regions with high conduction band population evolve with time .
such evolution correlates with time dynamics of electrons in the reciprocal space , which is determined by the time - dependent wave vector @xmath114 .
the regions of high conduction band population are concentrated near the dirac points and their arrangement clearly follows the polarization of the optical pulse , which in fig .
[ population_kxky_time ] is along axis @xmath17 .
the dynamics of formation of localized regions of high conduction band population is also shown in fig .
[ population_kxky_time ] .
initially the conduction band population is high within large region of an oval shape in the reciprocal space ( see distribution at @xmath115 fs ) .
then this oval shape becomes broken into small localized regions with high values of the conduction band population .
is shown as a function of the wave vector at different moments of time .
only the first bruilluen zone of the reciprocal space is shown .
the peak electric field of the pulse is @xmath116 v / .
different colors correspond to different values of the conduction band population as shown in the figure .
, scaledwidth=50.0% ] the formation of the localized regions with high conduction band population is due to singularity of the intraband dipole matrix elements at the dirac points .
the interband dipole matrix elements are large near the dirac points and are diverging exactly at the dirac points - see section [ interband ] .
an electron with initial wave vector @xmath47 propagates in the reciprocal space along the direction of the electric field and the electron wave vector at moment of time @xmath56 is given by the function @xmath117 , see eq .
( [ kt ] ) .
the trajectory of such electron is shown schematically in the inset in fig .
[ cb_single_q](a ) , where the electron , which is initially at point `` 1 '' , is transferred along the path `` 1''@xmath118``2''@xmath118``3''@xmath118``2''@xmath118``1 '' during the pulse . since the area under the pulse is zero , the electron returns to the initial point `` 1 '' . along this closed path
the interband coupling , which is proportional to the interband dipole matrix element , is the strongest near the point closest to the dirac points , i.e. near point `` 2 '' .
thus , the strongest mixing of the states of the conduction and valence bands occurs when the electron passes through point `` 2 '' . for the closed path `` 1''@xmath118``3''@xmath118``1 '' there are two passages of point `` 2 '' . as a result
there are two strong changes in the conduction band population .
these two changes can be constructive or destructive , resulting in final large or small conduction band population , respectively .
these two possibilities are shown in fig .
[ cb_single_q ] , where the time - dependent conduction band population is shown for two initial wave vectors @xmath47 .
the time - dependent interband dipole matrix element , @xmath97 , calculated at wave vector @xmath119 is also shown in fig . [ cb_single_q ] .
the two maxima in the time - dependent dipole matrix element correspond to two passages of the point
`` 2 '' shown in the inset in fig .
[ cb_single_q](a ) . for both initial wave vectors [ see fig .
[ cb_single_q ] ( a ) and ( b ) ] the maxima of the dipole matrix element are correlated with large changes in the conduction band population . in fig .
[ cb_single_q](b ) these changes are constructive resulting in large conduction band population after the pulse ends , while in fig .
[ cb_single_q](a ) the changes are destructive , which results in small final conduction band population
. whether changes of the conduction band population constructive or destructive is determined by the phase accumulated between two consecutive passages of point `` 2 '' .
the phase is determined by exponential factor in the expression ( [ q_vector ] ) for the vector - function @xmath61 .
are shown for some initial wave vector @xmath47 of the reciprocal space .
the conduction band population is calculated as @xmath120 and the dipole matrix element is defined as @xmath121 .
two different initial wave vectors in panels ( a ) and ( b ) correspond to small and large residual conduction band populations , respectively .
the inset in panel ( a ) illustrates schematically the electron dynamics in the reciprocal space : the electron is transferred along the path `` 1''@xmath118``2''@xmath118``3''@xmath118``2''@xmath118``1 '' .
the polarization of the optical pulse is along axis @xmath17 .
, scaledwidth=40.0% ] after the pulse ends the localized spots of high conduction band population are accumulated near the dirac @xmath25 and @xmath103 points , which is illustrated in fig .
[ populationnearkpoints ] , where the results shown in fig .
[ population_kxky_time ] are redrawn beyond the first brillouin zone .
the spots of high conduction band population form two parallel arrays oriented along axis @xmath17 , i.e. along the direction of the electric field .
the number of spots in each array depends on the intensity of the optical pulse . in fig .
[ population_kxky_field ] the residual conduction band population is shown as a function of wave vector @xmath64 for different amplitudes @xmath10 of the optical pulse . in all cases
the structure of two arrays of high conduction population spots near the dirac points persists but the number of spots increases with @xmath10 .
this is due to the fact that with increasing the pulse amplitude the electron is transferred over a longer distance in the reciprocal space and the farther points in the reciprocal space can reach the dirac points , where the strong interband coupling is realized . in terms of the schematic diagram shown in the inset in fig .
[ cb_single_q](a ) it means that the distance between points `` 1 '' and `` 2 '' increases with pulse amplitude . and @xmath26 , which correspond to two valley of graphene .
the red dotted line shows the boundary of the first brillouin zone .
different colors correspond to different values of the conduction band population as shown in the figure .
polarization of the optical pulse is along axis @xmath17 .
, scaledwidth=40.0% ] is shown as a function of the wave vector at different amplitudes @xmath10 of the optical pulse .
only the first bruilluen zone of the reciprocal space is shown .
the polarization of electric field is along axis @xmath17 .
different colors correspond to different values of the conduction band population as shown in the figure .
, scaledwidth=50.0% ] another characteristics of the electron redistribution between the conduction and valence bands is the residual conduction band population calculated as a function of electron energy .
such function is defined by the following expression @xmath122 where @xmath123 is the dirac @xmath123-function .
the function @xmath124 is shown in fig .
[ cbpopulation_energy ] for different amplitudes @xmath10 of the optical pulse .
the conduction band population as a function of energy has a single peak structure with well - defined maximum at finite electron energy .
for example , for @xmath125 v / , the maximum of @xmath124 is at @xmath126 ev .
the width of the peak also increases with increasing the pulse amplitude . at @xmath127 v /
the peak occupies the whole conduction band , i.e. after the pulse ends all the conduction band states are partially occupied by electrons .
the conduction band population exactly at the dirac point , i.e. at zero energy , is small .
such behavior is correlated with the distribution of the conduction band population in the reciprocal space shown in fig .
[ population_kxky_field ] . is shown as a function of energy for different amplitudes of the optical pulse .
the polarization of the optical pulse is along axis @xmath17 .
, scaledwidth=48.0% ] the generated time - dependent electric current and the net transferred charge through the graphene layer are another characteristics of interaction of the electron system of graphene with laser pulse . the net transferred charge through the graphene system , which is calculated from expression ( [ qtr ] ) , is determined by the residual state of the system .
namely , the residual polarization of the electron system is equal to the transferred charge . within a single band approximation , when the interband coupling is assumed to be zero , the electron dynamics is completely reversible . in this case
the transferred charge through the system is zero , although the generated time - dependent current during the propagation of the pulse is non - zero .
therefore , the transferred charge is non - zero only due to finite interband coupling , which results in irreversible electron dynamics and finite residual polarization of the electron system . in fig .
[ charge ] the transferred charge is shown as a function of the amplitude @xmath10 of the optical pulse .
the results are shown for different levels of doping of the electron system .
the level of the doping is characterized by the fermi energy , @xmath128 .
the transferred charge has weak dependence on the doping . the data in fig .
[ charge ] are shown for polarization of the optical pulse along axis @xmath17 , i.e. along the axis of symmetry of the crystal structure of graphene .
such polarization corresponds to angle @xmath88 and the charge in this case is transferred only along axis @xmath17 . for other polarization of the optical pulse , @xmath129 , there is non - zero transferred charge in the direction perpendicular to the polarization of the pulse , but it is very small compared to the charge transferred along the direction of polarization .
this property illustrates that the symmetry of the crystal structure of graphene is close to cylindrical .
an interesting property of the transferred charge ( see fig . [ charge ] ) is the change of its sign with increasing pulse amplitude .
while at small pulse intensities , @xmath130 v / , the transferred charge is positive , i.e. the charge is transferred in the direction of the pulse - field maximum , at large pulse intensities , @xmath131 v / , the transferred charge is negative , i.e. it is transferred in the direction opposite to the direction of the pulse maximum .
this is the combination of dielectric and metal behaviors , where for dielectrics the transferred charge is positive , while for metal the transferred charge is negative .
therefore , in terms of the transferred charge the graphene monolayer behaves as a dielectrics at low pulse intensities and as a metal at large intensities . with increasing the dopping , i.e. , with increasing the fermi energy , @xmath128 ,
the positive transferred charge at low intensities decreases , making the graphene system more metallic in terms of the charge transfer .
the origin of the change of the sign of the transferred charge can be understood from the expression for generated electric current . the generated current [ see eq .
( [ current ] ) ] has two contributions : intraband contribution , which is determined by intraband matrix elements of velocity operator , @xmath132 and @xmath133 , and interband contribution , which is proportional to the interband matrix elements of the velocity @xmath134 .
the interband contribution to the current is almost an order of magnitude smaller than the corresponding intraband contribution .
such large difference of these two contributions is due to their different dependence on the expansion coefficients @xmath135 , where @xmath136 or @xmath137 .
the intraband terms in the expression for the current are proportional to @xmath138 $ ] , while the intraband terms are determined by combination @xmath139 . the conduction band population
as a function of the wave vector has a structure of localized spots with large value of @xmath140 ( @xmath141 is almost 1 at these spots ) . at these spots , the terms
@xmath138 $ ] , which determine the intraband current , is almost 1 , while the factors @xmath139 are almost 0 , which results in small generated interband current .
taking into account only intraband contribution to the generated current , we rewrite eq .
( [ current ] ) for the @xmath17 component of the current in the following form @xmath142 where we took into account the electron - hole symmetry of the nearest neighbor model of graphene , i.e. @xmath143 , and used the property @xmath144 . at small pulse amplitudes ,
the main mechanism , which determines the transferred charge , is an increase of the conduction band population , i.e. @xmath141 , due interband electron dynamics .
the corresponding generated current is shown in fig .
[ fcurrent ] for @xmath145 v / . at @xmath146
the current is negative , while at @xmath147 the current is positive .
since the conduction band population at later moments of time ( @xmath147 ) is larger than the conduction band population at @xmath146 [ see fig .
[ cb_field ] ] then the positive component of the current is larger than the negative one , which results in positive transferred charge through the system . at large pulse amplitudes @xmath10 , another mechanism becomes important for the formation of the charge transfer .
namely , due to intraband electron dynamics , the matrix elements of the velocity operator should be calculated at the time - dependent wave vector @xmath48 , which is proportional to the amplitude of the electric field .
since the velocity @xmath148 becomes small away from the dirac points , then at large @xmath10 , when @xmath149 becomes large , there is an additional suppression of the current .
the corresponding generated current is shown in fig .
[ fcurrent ] for @xmath150 v / .
the data clearly show suppression of the positive current at @xmath147 , which results in negative transferred charge .
this mechanism , which is due to intraband electron dynamics , of generating charge transfer , is similar to metals in strong optical pulse.@xcite thus , for graphene , at low amplitudes of the optical pulse , the interband dynamics determines the transferred charge , which is positive in this case , which is similar to dielectrics . at high amplitudes of the pulse ,
the intraband dynamics provides the main contribution to the transferred charge , making it negative similar to metals . .
the transferred charge is shown for different levels of doping of graphene , which is characterized by the electron fermi energy @xmath128 in the conduction band .
the polarization of the optical pulse is along axis @xmath17 .
, scaledwidth=40.0% ] v / and @xmath151 v / .
the transferred charge in these two cases is positive for @xmath145 v / and negative for @xmath150 v / .
the polarization of the optical pulse is along axis @xmath17 .
, scaledwidth=40.0% ]
interaction of ultrashort and strong optical pulse with graphene is determined by unique gapless energy dispersion law of electron system in graphene . such energy dispersion results also in strong dependence of the interband dipole matrix elements on the wave vector in the reciprocal space with singularity of the interband interaction at the dirac points . as a result ,
the electron dynamics in the time - dependent electric field of the laser pulse is irreversible with large residual conduction band population .
the residual conduction band population is also comparable with the maximum conduction band population realized during propagation of the pulse . due to singularity of the interband dipole interaction , the residual conduction band population ,
i.e. the conduction band population after the pulse ends , shows strong dependence on the electron wave vector . in the reciprocal space
the conduction band population shows a few highly localized spots , where the electrons are almost completely transferred from the valence band to the conduction band states .
such spots of high conduction band population are concentrated near the dirac points and the number of the spots depends on the pulse intensity .
another characteristics of interaction of the optical pulse with graphene is generated transferred charge through the system . due to highly irreversible electron dynamics in the optical pulse ,
the transferred charge is nonzero and can be positive or negative depending on the pulse intensity . for the optical pulse with small intensity ,
i.e. with the amplitude @xmath130 v / , the direction of the transferred charge is the same as the direction of the pulse maximum , which is similar to dielectrics . for the pulse with large intensity , @xmath131 v /
, the charge is transferred in the direction opposite to the direction of the pulse maximum , which is the behavior expected in metals .
this property can be used to control the direction of the transfer of the electric charge in graphene in optical pulse by varying the intensity of the pulse . in terms of the direction of the transferred charge
, the graphene behaves as a metal or dielectrics depending on the pulse amplitude .
this work was supported by the max planck society and the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft cluster of excellence : munich center for advanced photonics ( http://www.munich-photonics.de ) .
major funding was provided by grant no .
de - fg02 - 01er15213 from the chemical sciences , biosciences and geosciences division .
supplementary funding came from grant no .
de - fg02 - 11er46789 from the materials sciences and engineering division of the office of the basic energy sciences , office of science , u.s .
department of energy , and grant no .
eccs-1308473 from nsf . | we study the interaction of graphene with ultrashort few femtosecond long optical pulse .
for such a short pulse , the electron dynamics is coherent and is described within the tight - binding model of graphene .
the interaction of optical pulse with graphene is determined by strong wave vector dependence of the interband dipole matrix elements , which are singular at the dirac points of graphene .
the electron dynamics in optical pulse is highly irreversible with large residual population of the conduction band .
the residual conduction band population as a function of the wave vector is nonuniform with a few localized spots of high conduction band population .
the spots are located near the dirac points and the number of spots depends on the pulse intensity .
the optical pulse propagating through graphene layer generates finite transferred charge , which , as a function of pulse intensity , changes its sign . at small pulse intensity
, the charge is transferred in the direction of the pulse maximum , while at large pulse intensity , the direction of the charge transfer is opposite to the direction of pulse maximum .
this property opens unique possibility of controlling the direction of the charge transfer by variation of the pulse intensity .
= 1.5truecm |
the 22-yr cycle of solar activity is a magnetic cycle which consists of two 11-years sunspot cycles .
the 22-yr cycles begin on even sunspot cycles according to the zrich numbering ( @xcite ) and manifest themselves in reversal of polarity of sunspots ( hale s law ) . from one 11-yr cycle to another
, the polarity of the preceding ( @xmath0 ) and following ( @xmath1 ) sunspots reverses .
this reversal corresponds to the changing of the toroidal magnetic field ( @xmath2-component ) . during even - numbered cycles @xmath3 ( the direction of the magnetic vector coincides with the direction of solar rotation ) in the northern ( @xmath4 ) hemisphere and @xmath5 in the southern ( @xmath6 ) hemisphere
this relation is reversed during odd - numbered cycles . in parallel with this , the poloidal magnetic field , or background field ( @xmath7-component ) , shows a 22-yr periodicity ( @xcite ) , and other studies ( @xcite ) have suggested that the low - latitude and polar fields similarly show a 22-yr periodicity .
furthermore , these studies have hinted at a shorter term periodicity of about 2 yr ( high - frequency component ) .
in addition , during the periods of the three - fold polar magnetic field reversals which occur during some sunspot cycle maxima , the temporal separation of the zones of alternated polarity of the magnetic field on @xmath8 charts is approximately equal to 1.52.5 years ( @xcite , @xcite ) .
similar periodicities were found in variations of radio flux on @xmath9 ( @xcite ) , flares and sunspot areas ( @xcite ) . the high - frequency , 2-year , component is substantially weaker than the main 22-year cycle and its intensity varies with time .
the two year component more clearly appeared in northern hemisphere in cycle 20 and in southern hemisphere in cycle 21 ; its value was smaller in cycle 22 ( @xcite ) .
however , the biennial cycle represents a challenge to the solar dynamo theories which usually explain only the main cycle . in this letter
, i present a new evidence of the two components of the solar cycle , and an attempt to explain the results in term of parker s dynamo theory ( @xcite ) .
using kitt peak magnetograph data we show how synoptic ( longitude independent ) magnetic field patterns evolve through cycles 21 and 22 . each of the synoptic maps is represented by the values of @xmath10 as a function sine latitude and carrington longitude .
the carrington coordinate system is a reference frame rotating rigidly at the rate which corresponds to the synodic rotation rate of sunspots at a latitude of about @xmath11 .
the observed line - of - sight components ( @xmath10 ) averaging over all longitudes for each carrington rotation is represented in figure 1b .
the time step in the time set of values @xmath10 corresponds to carrington rotation period ( @xmath12 days ) .
the relative sunspot number is shown in figure 1a .
component @xmath7 ( figure 1c ) , was calculated from observational data assuming that the true average field direction is radial and @xmath13 .
the radial component will be easily found at all latitudes besides near the poles : @xmath14 where @xmath15 is colatitude . to separate the high - frequency component in the data , we apply a difference filter by computing @xmath16 for different time intervals @xmath17 .
this is a reasonable procedure if the poloidal magnetic field consists of two components and is represented as two dynamo waves : @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the amplitude of the low - frequency radial component of the magnetic field ; @xmath20 is ratio between amplitudes of low - frequency and high - frequency components ; @xmath21 is the frequency of the hale s solar cycle ; @xmath22 is the frequency of biennial cycle ; @xmath23 is a phase .
the expression for the @xmath24 can be written as @xmath25 when @xmath26 , @xmath27 as it took place in cycle 20 , then the low - frequency term dominates in the expression for @xmath7 ( equation [ field ] ) and the high - frequency term prevails in the expression for @xmath28 ( equation [ deriv ] ) .
thus , presuming the existence of the double magnetic cycle , one finds that the low - frequency term prevails in the @xmath7-component , while the high - frequency term dominates in @xmath29 .
contour plots of @xmath24 as a function @xmath30(or @xmath31 ) and time , _ t _ , measured in carrington rotation are represented in figure 1d for @xmath32 . during the cycles 21 and 22 the zones of increasing and decreasing strength of the surface magnetic field appear in both the @xmath4 and @xmath6 hemispheres ( see figure 1d ) .
the width of these zones is approximately 2 years .
this result coincides with investigations done earlier based on wilcox and mount wilson synoptic maps .
corresponding power spectra for @xmath24 show that the component with period @xmath33 years is dominant in both hemispheres ( @xcite , @xcite ) .
these results are the basis of our suggestion of a two component of solar cycle .
the possible explanation of the double magnetic cycle is that the magnetic fields are generated by parker s dynamo acting in convective zone .
the low - frequency component is generated at the base of the convective zone due to large scale radial shear @xmath34 ; @xmath35 is the angular velocity .
the high - frequency component may be generated in subsurface regions due to latitudinal shear @xmath36 or due to radial shear .
the recent investigations of solar interior rotation show a significant radial gradient of angular velocity exists in subsurface of the convective zone together with the latitudinal gradient of the angular velocity ( @xcite ) .
for simplicity we use only latitudinal shear for generation of the high - frequency component .
cartesian coordinates are employed , with @xmath37 denoting the radial , @xmath38 the azimuthal and @xmath39 the latitudinal coordinate .
we consider axisymmetrical solutions ( @xmath40 ) . at the base of the convection zone turbulence
is suppressed by strong magnetic field ( @xcite ) and , therefore , diffusivity in the first layer @xmath41 will could be less then @xmath42 in the second layer .
the axisymmetrical mean magnetic field is decomposed into toroidal and poloidal parts .
the following set of equations describe evolution of the magnetic field in thin layers at the levels @xmath43 and @xmath44 : @xmath45 @xmath46 where @xmath47 is the toroidal magnetic field and @xmath48 is the azimuthal vector potential which gives poloidal field , @xmath49 is diffusivity and @xmath50 is a kinetic helicity , @xmath51 is the variable part of kinetic helicity .
the first and the second equations in the both systems ( [ x1 ] ) and ( [ x2 ] ) are a generation of parker s equations for large - scale radial shear @xmath52 and large - scale latitudinal shear @xmath53 correspondingly .
we have used the third equation in the both systems @xmath54 according to kleeorin and ruzmaikin ( 1982 ) in a simple form , for feedback of the magnetic field on the helicity . in these equations
@xmath55 and @xmath56 are parameters of the feedback .
these two non - linear differential equation systems describe the evolution of two independent sources of the magnetic field . in the frame of this model
it is difficult to explain observed variations of the high - frequency component .
therefore , we assume that the erupted low - frequency magnetic field can influence the physical conditions in the region where high - frequency component operates , through modifying the helicity there .
this allows the high - frequency component to vary with time . in this case , the equation for @xmath57 becomes @xmath58 , where the parameter @xmath59 captures the feedback of the low - frequency component of the magnetic field on the helicity in regions where the high - frequency component is found . following weiss et al .
( 1984 ) the solutions of these equations were found as @xmath60 and @xmath61 , i m @xmath62 for @xmath43 level and the same expressions for @xmath44 level where @xmath37 is replaced by @xmath39 .
@xmath63 are complex functions as @xmath64 , @xmath65 .
it is convenient to present the system in dimensionless units .
since there will be an underlying periodicity in all calculations , we use those periods as relative units of time . in relative units
@xmath66 , @xmath67 , @xmath68 , @xmath69 and @xmath70 , where @xmath71 is some mean value of the kinetic helicity .
therefore , @xmath72 and @xmath73 are represented as dynamo numbers in our model .
therefore , set of the partial differential equations reduced to the following equations were then solved numerically .
@xmath74 @xmath75 we have investigated solutions of these two non - linear systems as functions of the parameter @xmath59 .
results for three principal cases , @xmath76 , @xmath77 and @xmath78 are represented in figure 3 , where @xmath79 , @xmath80 , @xmath81 , @xmath82 , @xmath83 , @xmath84 , which are in the reasonable range for the sun . if @xmath85 we have two independent sources of the magnetic field which together generate low - frequency and high - frequency signatures ( fig . 2 a , b ) .
for a weak interaction between these sources ( @xmath86 ) we still get a low and high frequencies response .
. 2 c , d ) .
moreover , the high- frequency component becomes more regular , and consequently is decreased when @xmath59 increases . with further increase of the feedback of the low - frequency magnetic field on the helicity near the top surface
the high - frequency component disappears and only a low - frequency mode regime is established ( fig .
2 e , f ) .
therefore , in the case of weak interaction between two sources of magnetic field it is possible to obtain a stable double magnetic cycle .
our model simulates the double magnetic cycle and temporal variations of the biennial cycles from one 11-year cycle to another . according to the magnetograph data ( @xcite )
the 2-year component more clearly appeared in the northern hemisphere in cycle 20 and in the southern hemisphere in cycle 21 . in cycle 22
it was present in both hemispheres but was of lower amplitude . in our model ,
a reduced high - frequency component occurs when the erupted magnetic field of the main ( hale s ) cycle imposes the helicity in the regions of generation of the high - frequency component .
the high - frequency component is more pronounced when the effect of erupting magnetic fields of the main cycle on helicity in this region is small .
thus , this simple model provides a qualitative explanation of the double magnetic cycle .
the next step to a quantitative model is in development of a 2d model in spherical geometry , since this simple model gives only a qualitative picture of the two - components of the solar magnetic cycle .
i am grateful to dr .
j.w.harvey for providing us the kitt peak magnetograph data and to drs .
p.a.gilman , j.t.hoeksema , a.g.kosovichev and p.h.scherrer for useful discussions and russian federal programme `` astronomy '' , grant 1.5.3.4 . 99 akioka , m. , kubota , j. , suzuki , m. et al . 1987 , , * 112 * , 313 belmont , a.d . , darff , d.c . , ultad , m.s .
j. atmos.sci._ , * 23 * , 314 benevolenskaya , e.e .
1991 , in _ the sun and cool stars : activity , magnetism , dynamos _ , tuominen , i. , moss , d. and rdiger , g. ( eds . ) , springer - verlag , 234 benevolenskaya , e.e .
1995 , , * 161 * , 1 benevolenskaya , e.e .
1996 , , * 167 * , 47 gnevyshev , m.n . , and ohl , a.i .
1948 , , * 25 * , 18 howard , r. , and labonte , b.j . 1981 , , * 74 * , 131 kleeorin , n.i . , and ruzmaikin , a.a .
1982 _ magnitnaya gidrodinamika _ , no 2 , 17 parker , e.n . 1979 , _ cosmic magnetic fields _ , oxford university press parker , e.n .
1993 , , * 408 * , 707 schou , j. , et al .
, 1998 , , in press stenflo , j.o .
1994 , in _ solar surface magnetism _ , rutten , r.j . and schrijver , c.j
, nato advanced research workshop , kluwer waldmeier , m. 1973 , , * 28 * , 389 weiss , n.o .
, cattaneo , f. , jones , c.a .
1984 , _ geophys .
_ , * 30 * , 305 | it has been argued that the solar magnetic cycle consists of two main periodic components : a low - frequency component ( hale s 22-year cycle ) and a high - frequency component ( quasi - biennial cycle ) .
the existence of the double magnetic cycle on the sun is confirmed using stanford , mount wilson and kitt peak magnetograph data from 1976 to 1996 ( solar cycles 21 and 22 ) . in the frame of the parker s dynamo theory a model of the double magnetic cycle is presented .
this model is based on the idea of two dynamo sources separated in space .
the first source of the dynamo action is located near the bottom of the convection zone , and the second operates near the top .
the model is formulated in terms of two coupled systems of non - linear differential equations .
it is demonstrated that in the case of weak interaction between the two dynamo sources the basic features of the double magnetic cycle such as existence of two component and observed temporal variations of high - frequency component can be reproduced .
# 1#2 |
the geometrical phase transition known as percolation ( see , for a review , stauffer and aharony @xcite ) is appreciated by many to be an elegant and simply defined yet fully featured example of a second order phase transition .
a number of variations of the original percolation problem were proposed as better models of some physical phenomena in the past .
this includes the _ backbone _ percolation for studying electrical conduction through random media , _ polychromatic _ percolation for multi - component composites , and _ four - coordinated _ bond percolation for hydrogen - bonded water molecules . in particular , blumberg et al @xcite and gonzalez and reynolds @xcite studied a random bond , site - correlated percolation problem they call four - coordinated percolation on the square lattice .
they conclude that this problem belongs to the same universality class as the ordinary random percolation with the same set of ( static ) exponents . in this paper
, we revisit a problem in this realm , though not exactly the same one .
we define _ fully coordinated percolation _ as the site percolation problem where only the occupied sites all of whose neighboring sites are also occupied can transmit connectivity . since the random element is the site , this problem is slightly different from the bond problem referred to above .
thus , after generating a random site configuration with the independent site occupation probability _
p _ , we only select those occupied sites with all 4 neighbors also occupied on the square lattice and study the clusters formed by nearest neighbor connections among those sites .
it should be noted that this problem is distinct from the so - called bootstrap percolation ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) where sites of less connectivity are iteratively removed . in our problem ,
no iterative procedures are involved ; rather , sites of less than full connectivity are marked first and then all of them removed at one time .
this problem arose in the context of studying the vibrational properties of fractal structures tethered at their boundaries @xcite . in that problem ,
scaling was observed in the normal mode spectrum whose origin may lie in the ratio of 2 length scales , one of which is the size of highly connected regions of a cluster . in this context , we have embarked on revisiting the characteristics of randomly generated , but highly connected geometrical structures . in the next section ,
we summarize the monte carlo and finite size scaling analyses of the static critical properties of fully coordinated percolation . in section 3
, we discuss the normal modes of the _ transition probability matrix _ for tracer diffusion on the structure using the methods of arnoldi and saad ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) .
then in section 4 , we describe the classification of the cluster sites into external boundary , internal boundary , and interior ones and using these to show the major distinctions between the critical clusters of ordinary and fully coordinated percolation .
we summarize the results in the final section .
to determine the static critical behavior of fully coordinated percolation we first performed monte carlo simulations on a square lattice in two dimensions .
each site is occupied with probability @xmath0 independently and subsequent fully coordinated sites are marked and their connectivity searched .
lattice sizes of @xmath1 where @xmath2 , @xmath3 , @xmath4 , and @xmath5 were constructed . for each lattice size
we further made a thousand realizations wherein a different random number seed was used on every run .
the unnormalized susceptibilities , i.e. , @xmath6 where @xmath7 is the number of clusters of size @xmath8 , are calculated on each run and are then summed at the end of the thousand realizations .
the average susceptibilities @xmath9 are calculated by dividing the sum by the number of realizations and the lattice size .
the prime on the summation indicates the fact that the contribution of the largest cluster to @xmath9 near and above what we perceived to be the critical probability @xmath10 has been subtracted as usual @xcite . in fig .
1 we plot the average susceptibilities against the probability @xmath0 for the corresponding lattice sizes .
the data correspond to the values of @xmath2 , @xmath3 , @xmath4 , and @xmath5 from the lowest to highest .
we can see that the effects due to the finite sizes of the lattices are exhibited clearly .
in particular , there are well - defined peaks which scale with lattice sizes as @xmath11 where the known exact value of @xmath12 for the ordinary percolation is @xmath13 . to demonstrate the precision of our calculations , we plot @xmath14 against the corresponding lattice sizes in the inset of fig .
1 . notice that the data follow an excellent power law , leading to a least squares fit of @xmath15 .
the value of @xmath16 found is identical with the ordinary percolation value to within about @xmath17 .
this result confirms previous work@xcite stating that fully coordinated percolation and ordinary percolation belong to the same _ static _ universality class .
the critical behavior of susceptibility is known to scale as @xcite @xmath18 where for ordinary percolation @xmath19 .
notice however that in fig .
1 the peaks are very near @xmath20 .
this would provide data to the right of the peaks in only a small probability interval . in our simulations
, we would therefore use @xmath9 only to the left of the peaks . since the scaling relation in eq .
( [ equ : chi_scaling ] ) is expected only for infinite lattices , we use only the data taken from @xmath21 to test it . since there are two unknowns in eq .
( [ equ : chi_scaling ] ) , we first choose a particular @xmath22 and make a fit to see what value of @xmath23 is obtained .
if we choose @xmath24 we get @xmath25 .
the correlation coefficient , @xmath26 , for this fit is @xmath27 .
the discrepancy between @xmath23 and @xmath28 is around @xmath29 .
choosing @xmath30 we obtain @xmath31 . the discrepancy this time is around @xmath32 and @xmath33 .
so we have an exact fit for this value of @xmath22 and the @xmath23 found is very close to the @xmath28 .
choosing @xmath34 we obtain @xmath35 with an @xmath36 .
the discrepancy for this value of @xmath22 is @xmath37 .
fits done with @xmath22 between @xmath38 and @xmath39 gave @xmath33 ; however , the @xmath23 found when @xmath30 gave the closest value to @xmath28 .
this allows us to conclude that @xmath16 for fully coordinated percolation is the same as that for ordinary percolation while also giving an estimate for the value of @xmath22 close to @xmath40 .
( we will state the experimental uncertainty for @xmath10 after all our analyses are presented . ) from the fit done to examine the scaling in eq .
( [ equ : peaks_scaling ] ) we could further conclude that @xmath41 for fully coordinated percolation should be the same with that for ordinary percolation .
this again confirms the statement that fully coordinated percolation is in the same _ static _ universality class as ordinary percolation .
another universal constant often used to characterize ordinary percolation is the amplitude ratio @xmath42 of susceptibility @xmath9 ( whose value is about 200 in @xmath43 @xcite ) . in fully coordinated percolation , this quantity is unfortunately difficult to calculate accurately because the critical region for @xmath44 is very small ( see below ) .
when we constrain the exponent @xmath16 to be close to @xmath28 and use the @xmath22 estimated in this work , however , we find that @xmath42 is of @xmath45 , which is consistent with the above observation as well .
the contribution of the largest cluster to the susceptibility is not significant when @xmath46 .
however when @xmath47 a significant number of sites will belong to the largest cluster and when @xmath48 the largest cluster is dominant in the whole lattice .
the average susceptibility contribution due to this largest cluster is @xmath49 , where the summation is over @xmath50 realizations and @xmath51 is the size of the largest cluster .
the fractal dimension , @xmath52 , can be obtained from @xmath51 by @xmath53 where @xmath54 is the mean size of the largest cluster at @xmath22 .
@xmath55 should therefore scale as @xmath56 for ordinary percolation on a two dimensional lattice ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) , it is known that @xmath57 and @xmath58 .
for fully coordinated percolation , the scaling in eq .
( [ equ : large_scaling ] ) have two unknowns , @xmath22 and @xmath52 .
similar to what we have done when examining the scaling in eq .
( [ equ : chi_scaling ] ) , we choose trial values for @xmath22 and then perform a least squares fit to obtain the corresponding @xmath59 . by looking for the range of trial @xmath22 that maximizes the regression coefficient @xmath26
, we arrive at an estimate of @xmath22 to be close to @xmath60 where @xmath33 and @xmath61 .
the variation of @xmath26 is about 2 parts in @xmath62 if @xmath22 is varied by 0.0002 , always with less than 1% deviation from the ordinary percolation value of @xmath63 . from these results
we conclude that @xmath52 for fully coordinated percolation is the same as that for ordinary percolation as well as the estimate of about @xmath60 for @xmath22 .
in addition to the above , we have also performed the scaling analysis of the quantity @xmath64 , as both @xmath0 and @xmath65 are varied , in the form of @xmath66 where @xmath67 is a scaling function . using the
exactly known ordinary percolation values of the exponents @xmath52 and @xmath41 ( as they have been shown to be the same for fully coordinated percolation above ) , we obtained the maximum data collapsing in the range of @xmath68 .
independent of the above analyses based on the fully coordinated clusters obtained by monte carlo simulations of fixed - sized square grids , we have also performed monte carlo simulations by growing fully coordinated clusters starting from a seed site using a variant of the _ breadth - first search _
algorithm @xcite .
this latter approach has an advantage that there is no obvious finite - size effects and that statistics taken while a cluster is still growing represents a _ partial sum _ automatically .
that is , we start growing such clusters 10,000 times at each of @xmath69 , 0.884 , 0.885 , and 0.890 , and keep track of how many of them are still growing at predetermined intervals of size ( @xmath70 where @xmath71 , 2 , ... , 15 in our case ) .
this number , say , @xmath72 represents the partial sum @xmath73 since the normalized number of size-@xmath8 clusters , @xmath74 scales as @xmath75 where @xmath76 and @xmath77 , we expect that @xmath72 scales as @xmath78 near @xmath22 and for large @xmath8 . in particular , at @xmath22 , this quantity should be constant independent of ( large ) @xmath8 .
the numerical results are shown in fig . 2 , where the data correspond , from highest to lowest , to @xmath79 , 0.885 , 0.884 , and 0.880 .
the horizontal dashed line drawn to guide the eye makes it clear that data for @xmath80 best approximates a horizontal line as @xmath81 , suggesting that a good estimate of @xmath22 would be 0.885 .
we now consider all the above results together .
the results from scaling in eq .
( [ equ : chi_scaling ] ) indicate a range @xmath82 , and those from scaling in eq .
( [ equ : large_scaling ] ) indicate @xmath83 , while those from scaling in eq .
( [ equ : large_outside_scaling ] ) hints @xmath22 to be in the @xmath84 interval .
another result that could also be used are the values of @xmath0 for the peaks in fig . 1 , which vary from @xmath85 to @xmath86 ( with the peak for the largest grid @xmath21 occurring at @xmath87 ) . combining all these results , our final estimate is @xmath88 .
by dynamic critical behavior here we simply mean the asymptotic long - time behavior of diffusion taking place on an incipient infinite cluster of fully coordinated percolation , or its equivalent _ scalar _ elastic behavior .
this represents the simplest kind of dynamics associated with these complicated geometrical objects and is mainly reflected in the two _ dynamic _ critical exponents called @xmath89 ( spectral dimension ) and @xmath90 ( walk dimension ) .
it is well known that the return - to - the starting point probability of the random walk , @xmath91 , in the long - time limit obeys the power law , @xmath92 where @xmath89 is the spectral dimension of the walk . in a fractal medium
, @xmath89 is less than the space dimension @xmath93 , because the progressive displacement of the random walker further from the starting point is hampered by its encounter with the irregularities of the medium at all scales .
thus , @xmath89 is expected to be greater for environments that provide higher connectivity at large length scales , independently of the fractal dimension itself which is mainly the measure of the overall _ size _ scales or _
how many _ sites are connected , not _ how well _ those sites are connected to each other . for media with long - range loops , @xmath52 ( fractal dimension ) , @xmath89 , and @xmath90 are not independent but are expected to obey the well - known alexander and orbach scaling law @xcite @xmath94 for this reason , we only calculate @xmath89 here though both of @xmath89 and @xmath90 can be conveniently calculated by numerically studying the _ transition probability matrix _ * w * which represent the random walk on a specific fractal medium .
our calculation in this work is only one aspect of such an analysis : finite size scaling of the dominant non - trivial eigenvalue which describes the longest finite time scale of the brownian process .
this approach has already been described in detail elsewhere @xcite , and thus we merely state the main feature and then immediately report our specific numerical results .
the matrix * w * is constructed from the elements @xmath95 being equal to a hopping probability per step ( equal to @xmath96 here ) for available nearest neighbor sites @xmath97 and @xmath98 . for each neighbor site which is not present ,
a probability of @xmath96 is added to the probability for not taking a step for one time period - this is called the _ blind ant _ rule .
many large matrices * w * are obtained by monte carlo simulation ( by growing a fully coordinated percolation cluster from a seed site and stopping the growth when a predetermined desired size is reached ) and their largest eigenvalues are numerically obtained by the so - called _ arnoldi - saad _ method .
the dominant non - trivial eigenvalue @xmath99 is the largest eigenvalue just below the stationary eigenvalue 1 and it is known to satisfy the following finite size scaling law : @xmath100 , 2500 , 5000 , 10000 , and 20000 at each of the three nominal probabilities @xmath101 , 0.885 , and 0.887 , and numerically obtained @xmath99 for each cluster . the main part of fig .
3 shows the data from @xmath80 , the value shown to be closest to @xmath22 in this work .
the figure shows an excellent power law fit ( regression coefficient of -0.99993 ) to eq.([eq : fsfords ] ) with the exponent @xmath102 .
this power translates to @xmath103 which is close to but definitely larger than the corresponding ordinary percolation value of @xmath104 estimated by many independent calculations .
( see , e.g. , @xcite . ) for comparison , a _ loopless _ variant of percolation has exactly the same static exponents as ordinary percolation but has @xmath105 in two dimensions , about twice as much deviation from ordinary percolation in the opposite direction as the present fully coordinated percolation problem .
@xcite in the inset for fig . 3 , we show a normalized @xmath99 by plotting @xmath106 where the circles are for @xmath107 , squares for @xmath80 , diamonds for @xmath101 and the solid line is a horizontal line ( for ordinary percolation ) to guide the eye . in all cases ,
the standard errors of the mean for each set of data are substantially smaller than the size of the symbols used in the figure .
the distribution of @xmath99 in each case appears to be gaussian with the standard deviations scaling in the same way as the means .
> from these results , we conclude that , though the numerical differences are small , there is a high likelihood that the fully coordinated percolation clusters are significantly different from the ordinary percolation counterparts even at long length scales . in the next section , we show that this analysis is vindicated by exposing one dramatic difference in the cluster morphology which will not be obvious to an uncritical observer .
in this section we examine the geometry of fully coordinated percolation clusters more closely .
first , we present fig . 4 which show in grey scale the sites of ( a ) fully coordinated percolation cluster and ( b ) ordinary percolation cluster at respective @xmath22 .
the overall visual impression is that they are very similarly shaped even down to the details of the boundaries and internal holes .
their shapes are also essentially independent of the underlying lattice anisotropy ( as fig .
4(a ) has actually been rotated by 45 degrees with respect to the coordinate axes of the square lattice ) . however , the number and distributions of the especially dark points are evidently quite distinct in ( a ) and ( b ) .
they cluster more and are much more abundant in ( a ) than in ( b ) .
these sites are actually the _ interior _ or fully coordinated sites in the internal part of the cluster .
the remaining sites ( shaded grey ) are either the external _ hull _ sites or internal boundary sites . in fig .
5 quantitative examination is made on the different classes of sites of the two kinds of clusters . in the main part of the figure ,
the average numbers of two kinds of sites are shown , _ interior _ ( diamonds for fully coordinated percolation , crosses for ordinary percolation ) , and _ external _ ( squares for fully coordinated percolation , plusses for ordinary percolation ) .
it is clear that the interior sites are more than 3 times abundant in fully coordinated percolation as is visually suggested by fig .
though this is primarily a local effect due to the full coordination rule , they do have a multiplicative effect at long - range connectivity and thus may well be the source of the small difference in the value of @xmath89 .
of course just the fact that there are more than 3 times as many interior sites ( and correspondingly , much fewer _ hull _ sites ) in fully coordinated percolation must have quantitative consequences ( even if not qualitative ) for any process on the cluster which depend on degrees of connectivity rather than just on the number of connected sites .
an example of the effect of the different numbers of the hull sites may be in oxidation or catalysis of a material through the external embedding phase or even a irregularly shaped breakwater in the form of the external boundary of a percolation cluster .
external _ sites are those which are sometimes called _ hull _ sites and they are known to scale with an exact exponent in ordinary percolation as @xmath108 where @xmath109 and thus the exponent is @xmath110 for ordinary percolation . since this is less than 1 , these sites comprise less and less fraction of the cluster as @xmath81 and the remaining sites ( i.e. , _ interior _ and _ internal boundary _ sites ) eventually dominate the whole cluster .
this is already evident from the greater slopes close to 1 for the _ interior _ sites in fig .
the linear regression fits for the _ hull _ sites in fig .
5 indicate the slopes of about 0.913 for ordinary percolation and 0.922 for fully coordinated percolation with essentially perfect fits , again reinforcing the conclusion that they show the same _ static _ critical behavior .
in summary , we have studied both static and dynamic critical behaviors associated with a model of the highly connected regions of a disordered cluster . the model is a _ site _ variant of the four - coordinated percolation @xcite on the square lattice we call _ fully coordinated percolation_. while the bond version was studied for _ static _ critical behavior ,
neither bond nor site version was previously studied for the dynamic behavior to the best of our knowledge .
we have used various methods such as monte carlo simulations , finite - size scaling and arnoldi - saad approximate diagonalization of large random matrices for this purpose .
though all indications are that the static behavior of this model is exactly the same as the ordinary percolation ( as previous work suggested ) , the dynamic behavior shows a small but significant difference in the values of the universal critical exponents .
we have looked for the cause of this difference and found a three - fold increase in the number and significantly enhanced clustering of the interior sites ( i.e. , those not on the exterior or internal boundaries ) and the associated decrease in the number of boundary sites .
thus , although the deviations from ordinary percolation in terms of the values of the dynamic critical exponents are not large , there will be rather significant differences in any processes that depend sensitively on those numbers .
possible examples of such processes include the oxidation of a material through the external embedding phase and the vibrational normal modes with boundary conditions such as _ clamping _ or _ tethering _ of the external boundaries ( through the contrast in elastic constants of embedding and embedded materials , for example ) .
one of us ( jhk ) wishes to thank the purdue university department of physics for the hospitality during his visit there when part of the work was done .
we are also grateful to d. stauffer and r. ziff for insightful remarks .
present address at the department of physics , kangnung national university , kangnung , kangwon 210 - 702 , south korea .
d. stauffer and a. aharony , `` introduction to percolation theory , '' revised 2nd edition ( taylor and francis , london , 1994 ) .
r. l. blumberg , g. shlifer and h. e. stanley , j. phys .
* 13 , * l147-l152 ( 1980 ) .
a. e. gonzalez and p. j. reynolds , phys , lett .
* 80a * , 357 - 360 ( 1980 ) .
v. privman , p. c. hohenberg , and a. aharony in `` phase transitions and critical phenomena , '' * 14 , * edited by c. domb and j. l. lebowitz ( academic , london , 1991 ) .
s. mukherjee and h. nakanishi , fractals * 4 * , 273 - 278 ( 1996 ) . s. mukherjee and h. nakanishi , private communication ( 1998 ) .
h. nakanishi in `` annual reviews of computational physics , '' * 1 , * edited by d. stauffer ( world scientific , singapore , 1994 )
. s. mukherjee , h. nakanishi , and n. h. fuchs , phys .
e * 49 * , 5032 ( 1994 ) .
s. alexander and r. orbach , j. physique lett .
* 43 * , l625 ( 1982 ) .
s. mukherjee , d. j. jacobs and h. nakanishi , j. phys .
a * 28 * , 291 ( 1995 ) . | we study the geometry of the critical clusters in fully coordinated percolation on the square lattice . by monte carlo simulations ( static exponents ) and
normal mode analysis ( dynamic exponents ) , we find that this problem is in the same universality class with ordinary percolation _ statically _ but not so _ dynamically_.
we show that there are large differences in the number and distribution of the _ interior _ sites between the two problems which may account for the different dynamic nature . |
temporal modes of light @xcite are a burgeoning new subspace for both classical and quantum information encoding @xcite .
the temporal mode ( tm ) bases are discrete and in principle infinite dimensional , and truly orthogonal .
these orthogonal modes have overlapping spectra at the same carrier frequency , fully overlap in time , and share the same polarization and transverse spatial mode properties , making them convenient for long - distance communication and interfacing with optical memories @xcite .
co - propagating tms maintain relative coherence across the entire mode space , and experience the same reversible unitary dispersion during propagation in typical media . in order to fully exploit tms as a resource ,
we need highly tm - selective , high - fidelity devices that can generate , sort , store , measure , and generally manipulate them , even at the single - photon level @xcite .
many optically - pumped processes , such as atomic - ensemble raman memories @xcite and nonlinear optical frequency conversion @xcite via three / four - wave mixing @xcite , are already known to be tm sensitive when using pulsed pumps @xcite , and show tm discriminatory behavior at low coupling strengths @xcite . increasing the pump intensities
causes the tm discrimination to peak and regress to smaller values , thus ultimately limiting the maximum selectivity of straight - forward implementations of such processes @xcite .
this loss in selectivity is understood to be a result of time - ordering effects between interacting temporal wave - packets of the participating fields ( be they electromagnetic , polarization - phononic , acoustic , etc . ) convecting through each other at varied group velocities
@xcite . this selectivity limit , however , can be asymtotically overcome @xcite by using interferometric techniques ( `` tm interferometry '' ) in cascaded setups to enhance tm separability up to @xmath3% , even at large coupling strengths @xcite .
this new capability opens new avenues for information processing , including the complete set of operations needed for linear - optical quantum information processing @xcite .
quantum frequency conversion through @xmath5- or @xmath6- nonlinear media is gaining in usefulness as an all - optical means of implementing a fully - programmeable `` quantum pulse gate , '' whose role is to multiplex and demultiplex tms @xcite . the ability of nonlinear frequency conversion to unitarily reshape , and preserve quantum information stored in the tm basis is well known @xcite .
the tm - selectivity of frequency conversion @xcite suffers from the above - mentioned time - ordering - induced upper limit , necessitating an eventual exploration of tm interferometry .
experimental exploration of tm discrimination is still in its nascent stages @xcite . while the theoretically predicted selectivity limit still stands to be broken , other more specific predictions of said theory have yet to be validated . in this paper , we redress this issue both experimentally and theoretically , as well as provide a simple parameter - set guideline to aid in designing similar processes in other systems and spectral regions . in the following ,
we first model pulsed - pump mediated , second - order - nonlinear - optical frequency conversion between a signal band and an idler band as a set of coupled - mode equations , and define a tm - selectivity figure of merit to characterize the process .
we then showcase high tm selectivity in a parameter regime where the pump and signal pulses propagate with the same group velocity , but the idler group velocity is significantly different .
we illustrate specific predictions of the model for various input conditions , and propose a means of adequately approximating the aforementioned parameter regime by choosing band - carrier frequencies around the ones phase matched for second - harmonic generation ( shg ) in typical off - the - shelf nonlinear waveguides .
we then demostrate tm - selective frequency conversion in a @xmath7 @xmath8 m wide , @xmath7 mm long , mgo : ppln waveguide periodically poled for shg from @xmath9 nm to @xmath10 nm at @xmath11c .
we employ a kerr - modelocked , ultrafast titanium - sapphire laser and a folded treacy - grating pair pulse shaper with a reflective , 2d spatial light modulator , to situate and shape the pump and signal bands at @xmath12 nm and @xmath13 nm respectively , with bandwidths @xmath14 nm .
we use pump pulses with energies of order @xmath15 nj , and pulses of temporal widths of order @xmath1 fs , to verify all the predicted features of our model .
the first two numerically computed , natural schmidt modes of the model achieved a @xmath16-to-@xmath17 contrast ( @xmath18% vs. @xmath19% ) in conversion efficiencies for the two tested pump shapes in both theory and experiment .
while the experiments are carried out using weak coherent - state signals , theory indicates the same conversion efficiencies and tm selectivities would be observed using heralded single - photon wave packets @xcite .
the model for frequency conversion ( fc ) of temporal wave - packet modes in a @xmath5-nonlinear waveguide may be expressed as a pair of coupled - mode equations involving the electric - field envelopes , treated as quantum field operators @xcite .
we designate the letters @xmath20 , @xmath21 , and @xmath22 to denote electromagnetic fields within the three participating frequency bands , namely , the pump , signal , and idler bands , respectively .
the band - central , or carrier frequencies have to be constrained by energy conservation ( @xmath23 ) , and the nonlinear - optical waveguide used for frequency conversion is assumed to be periodically poled to ensure proper phase matching ( @xmath24 , where @xmath25 are wavenumbers and @xmath4 is the poling period ) for the pulses carrier frequencies . if the pulses in question are sufficiently narrowband , we can ignore second- and higher - order dispersion for all three bands , and write the coupled - mode equations as [ eq1 ] @xmath26 here , @xmath27 is a composite parameter denoting the strength of the interaction , and is linearly dependent on the medium nonlinearity ( @xmath5 ) , and the pump - pulse energy , as well as transverse spatial mode - overlap functions .
the parameters @xmath28 are the corresponding group - slownesses ( inverse group velocities ) for the bands @xmath29 , and the operators @xmath30 denote field - annihilation operators for square - normalized , slowly - varying , complex amplitudes of the temporal modes @xcite within the medium at location @xmath31 along the propagation direction . we require no additional noise operators in eqs .
[ eq1 ] since quantum fc is in principle a noiseless , unitary process @xcite . in the single - photon case ,
these operators can be replaced by quantum wavefunction amplitudes @xcite . for weak coherent pulses ( as in the case of our experiment ) ,
they can be replaced by complex functions denoting the classical pulse - envelope shapes , because the same equations hold .
the strong classical pump pulse @xmath32 is assumed to be unchanging during fc .
the medium is of length @xmath33 , and @xmath34 defines its input face .
the nonlinearity of the medium is assumed uniform throughout its length . for given values for all of the parameters defined above , and a known pump - pulse shape @xmath32 , fc in a finite medium
can be treated as a scattering process that relates the input temporal modes @xmath35 to the output modes @xmath36 via a set of green function ( gf ) relations : @xmath37 each output field @xmath38 is linearly dependent on both input fields @xmath39 , where @xmath40 denotes an input time and @xmath41 denotes an output time .
this formalism is convenient for analysis of temporal - mode selectivity @xcite , as the separability of the four green function subkernels can be quantified via their singular - value decomposition @xcite : @xmath42 the functions @xmath43 are the input `` schmidt modes '' and @xmath44 are the corresponding output schmidt modes for the _ r _ and _ s _ bands respectively .
the schmidt modes define the sets of `` natural temporal modes '' for the fc problem given a particular pump shape and medium characteristics . for a given integer index @xmath45 , the quartet of modes
are related to each other in a beamsplitter - like transformation through the schmidt coefficients ( @xmath46 , @xmath47 ) , which obey the unitarity constraint , @xmath48 . in simple terms , if the input state in the @xmath21-band were to be a single photon ( or a weak , coherent pulse ) in the temporal mode @xmath49 , and the @xmath22-band input were to be vacuum , then the probability ( efficiency ) of frequency conversion from @xmath21-band to @xmath22-band would be @xmath50 . the converted component exits in the @xmath22-band in mode @xmath51 , and the unconverted component ( occurring with probability / efficiency @xmath52 ) exits in the @xmath21-band in the mode @xmath53 .
note that each of the four sets of schmidt modes forms a complete basis set for its band and input / output context .
the effect of fc on an arbitrary input temporal mode can be easily computed by expressing said input state in the natural input schmidt - mode basis of the device and employing the schmidt - coefficient beamsplitter relations .
we choose to arrange the schmidt modes in the four sets , and the corresponding schmidt coefficients , in decreasing order of conversion efficiency ( ce ) , such that @xmath54 and so on .
an fc device with perfect mode discrimination would have a non - zero @xmath55 , and @xmath56 , meaning the gf subkernel is separable but not necessarily 100% efficient .
a device with perfect mode _ selectivity _ would have @xmath57 .
to characterize mode - selectivity , we define a figure of merit called selectivity @xmath58 @xcite . it has previously been shown that perfect selectivity can not be achieved in simple inter - pulse interaction systems due to time - ordering corrections @xcite . but
selectivity asymptotically approaching @xmath3% can be achieved in cascaded , multi - stage fc implementations @xcite .
this paper does not address multi - stage fc .
we can condense all of the model parameters into three dimensionless quantities in order to aid mapping settings and results from diverse fc systems to this model . these are @xcite : @xmath59 where @xmath60 is the temporal - width of the pump pulse , and @xmath61 .
@xmath62 is an interband coupling strength .
@xmath63 is the signal - idler inter - pulse walk - off relative to pump width , and @xmath64 is the group - velocity mismatch contrast . through an exhaustive numerical exploration @xcite
, we have previously determined that for good gf separability at low pump energies , as well as the best selectivity ( @xmath65 ) at higher pump energies , the best parameter regime is @xmath66 . by designing the system such that the group - velocity of the pump pulse is identical to that of one of the other bands ( the @xmath21-band , for the definitions in eq . [ eq4 ] ) , and highly different from that of the remaining ( @xmath22 ) band , we can have @xmath67 .
we call this condition the group - velocity matched ( gvm ) regime , and it was first considered in detail in @xcite
. very large @xmath63 , however , are physically inaccessible since realistic nonlinear waveguides have finite length , and the pump pulse needs to remain reasonably narrowband to maintain phase - matching and avoid higher - order dispersion .
the green function solutions for the gvm regime are known in closed analytical form @xcite , which aids in numerical analysis , as well as physical system design .
we have validated these analytical solutions using regime - agnostic wave - mixing simulations based on a numerical split - step implementation of the propagation and interaction of the various fields @xcite . specifically , we propagate the fields and apply dispersion in the fourier domain , and `` mix '' them using fourth - order runge - kutta in the time domain , alternating between the two for every iteration .
we compute the green functions by running the simulation for a basis set of input conditions , and computing the overlap of the resulting outputs with another spanning basis set of functions .
the numerical simulations verify that small deviations from the assumed conditions ( gvm regime , absense of higher - order dispersion , etc . )
do not cause significant departures from the predictions of the analytical solutions .
we present some of these predictions here . in the gvm regime ,
the group - velocity matched signal ( @xmath21-band ) copropagates with the pump pulse in the medium , and the unmatched idler ( @xmath22-band ) pulse falls behind ( or , in the case of anamolous dispersion , speeds ahead ) of the other two pulses . consequently , as long as @xmath68 in addition to the gvm condition , both the input and output @xmath21-band schmidt modes ( @xmath69 , @xmath70 ) will have the same temporal widths as that of the pump pulse , and the @xmath22-band input and output modes ( @xmath71 , @xmath72 ) get temporally stretched by a factor of @xmath63 . in fig .
[ fig01 ] , we plot the first two @xmath21-band input schmidt modes and the first two @xmath22-band output schmidt modes for a low coupling strength ( @xmath73 ) .
the temporal stretching effect between the mode widths of the two bands by a factor of @xmath74 is clearly illustrated .
also note in fig .
[ fig01](c ) that although the ce of the first schmidt mode is miniscule , it is large compared to that of the second schmidt mode . the target tm ( for optimum fc ) , which is the first @xmath21-input schmidt mode in fig .
[ fig01](a ) , is nearly identical to the pump shape , while the second mode is temporally orthogonal to the first .
figure [ fig02 ] shows the same data as in fig .
[ fig01 ] , but for a higher coupling strength ( @xmath75 ) , and two different pump - pulse shapes : gaussian ( fig .
[ fig02](a , b , c ) ) , and first - order hermite gaussian ( fig .
[ fig02](d , e , f ) ) . note that the ce of the second schmidt mode is no longer negligible . in the gvm regime , even at large pump - pulse energies ( coupling strengths ) ,
the complex shape of the pump - pulse envelope fully determines the shape of the dominant @xmath21-band schmidt modes ( fig .
[ fig02](a , d ) ) .
the dominant @xmath22-band schmidt modes , however , are influenced very little by the pump shape , and instead reflect the variation of the medium nonlinearity along the waveguide propagation direction ( fig .
[ fig02](b , e ) ) , which in our case is considered to be uniform . at low pump - pulse energies , or small @xmath62 ,
the first ( @xmath76 ) @xmath21-band input and output schmidt modes are nearly identical to the pump pulse shape ( and the first @xmath22-band modes look like flat , square pulses ) . but at higher @xmath62 , the first schmidt mode changes into a temporally skewed version of the pump pulse ( see fig .
[ fig03 ] ) .
the schmidt coefficients ( and therefore , the schmidt - mode ce ) are independent of the pump - pulse shape .
figure [ fig03](c ) depicts the rapid rise of the ces of the second and higher schmidt modes with increasing @xmath62 , which results in a cap on the maximum achievable selectivity .
curiously , for a given @xmath62 , different orthogonal pump - pulse shapes would result in mutually orthogonal dominant @xmath21-band schmidt modes , even if the modes cease to resemble the original pump shapes . in our experiment , we validate these precise predictions by following two approaches .
firstly , for given pump - pulse shape and energy , we maximize the signal ce by attempting to match the @xmath21-input schmidt modes predicted by theory .
we numerically precompute the first schmidt - mode shape for both gaussian and hermite - gaussian pump pulses for a continuous range of @xmath62 .
then the problem of matching the schmidt mode at a given pump power reduces to ce maximization through a scan of the single parameter @xmath62 . a second means of verifying the model is to keep the signal input pulse shapes static , but delay them with respect to the pump pulse and chart the ce .
for gaussian and first - order hermite - gaussian pump and signal shapes , four surface plots of ce for various input inter - pump - signal delays and pump energies have been numerically generated and plotted in fig .
[ fig04 ] .
the @xmath21-band schmidt mode distortions show up as temporal shifts and lobe - peak asymmetries at higher @xmath62 . in order to take advantage of theoretical predictions
, one must choose the physical system parameters to match the regimes of applicability of said theory .
in the context of tm - selective frequency conversion , the gvm or near - gvm condition ( @xmath66 ) must constrain the selection of waveguide material , length , band central frequencies , and tm bandwidths . at the time of this writing , only two other groups @xcite have addressed experimental frequency conversion in a tm - selective context .
the silberhorn group @xcite use homebuilt , periodically - poled lithium niobate ( ppln ) waveguides with a poling period of about @xmath77 @xmath8 m .
such a period gives the optimum phase - matching for sum frequency generation ( sfg ) from bands centered near @xmath78 nm and @xmath79 nm , into the band around @xmath80 nm . they engineer their waveguide dispersion to achieve perfect gvm ( @xmath67 ) at these wavelengths , and compensate for fabrication errors by tuning the waveguide temperature in the @xmath81c range .
they can thus afford to use longer waveguides ( @xmath82 mm ) and short pulse lengths ( @xmath83 fs ) and obtain large @xmath63 values without having to worry about signal - pump inter - pulse walkoff within the medium during propagation .
although exact gvm is optimum for tm - selectivity , one can deviate from perfect signal - pump gvm and still retain most of its advantages , as long as @xmath66 is satistied .
the kumar / kanter group @xcite hit upon an interesting solution that allows for minor deviation from gvm .
they used a @xmath84 mm long , custom ppln waveguide designed for second - harmonic generation ( shg ) from @xmath85 nm into @xmath86 nm at @xmath87c , and situated their pump ( @xmath88 nm ) and signal ( @xmath89 nm ) bands symmetrically on either side of the shg wavelength , yielding @xmath90 . their pump / signal sources and pulse shapers restricted their temporal widths to around @xmath7 ps , implying @xmath91 .
the theory predicts @xcite that their selectivity would improve significantly with larger pump / signal bandwidths , as we have used here .
we also employ an shg waveguide ( @xmath9 nm to @xmath10 nm at @xmath11c ) for fc by situating the signal and pump bands on either side of the red shg pump band .
typical shg acceptance bandwidths are very narrow . as long as the fc - pump band is sufficiently detuned from the shg - pump wavelength
, so as to avoid pump - only spurious blue - light generation , the relative spectral flatness of normal dispersion ensures near - gvm conditions ( see fig . [ fig05](a ) ) .
one must choose a temporal width that is small enough to ensure @xmath92 ( for large idler - pump walkoff ) , but wide enough to ensure that the pump - signal inter - pulse walkoff within the medium remains a small fraction of the total pulse widths ( @xmath93 ) .
shg waveguides , when pumped at the sum frequency can generate degenerate photon - pairs via spontaneous parametric down conversion ( spdc ) . the joint - spectral amplitude of the pairs are tightly anticorrelated in frequency ( fig .
[ fig05](b ) ) , reflecting the narrowness of the shg red - pump acceptance band @xcite .
but the individual photons of the pair would be wideband , allowing for sum frequency generation from two highly detuned frequency bands on either side of the shg - pump wavelength . here
, sfg is really a band - restricted inverse of spdc .
this behavior makes off - the - shelf waveguides suitable for tm - selective fc experiments .
we derived both our strong pump and weak signal pulses by reshaping the output of a homebuilt , kerr - lens mode - locked , ultrafast ti : sapph laser with pulse duration of about @xmath0 fs .
we tuned the cavity to cause it to lase at @xmath12 nm with a fwhm bandwidth of around @xmath94 nm , at a pulse rate of @xmath95 mhz .
this beam was spatially expanded to a transverse width of @xmath96 mm and sent into a folded , 4@xmath97-configured treacy - grating - pair @xcite pulse shaper , which uses a reflective spatial - light modulator ( slm ) in its fourier plane ( fig .
[ fig06 ] ) .
the pulse shaper utilized a @xmath98 lines / mm holographic grating in near - littrow mode , and a cylindrical lens of focal length @xmath99 mm to focus the wavelets onto the slm .
the lens is cylindrical in order to spread the beam intensity vertically so as to avoid damaging the slm .
this gave us a horizontal spot size of @xmath100 @xmath8 m for a given wavelength .
we used a custom - made biprism to change the height of the forward and reflected light to keep the paths symmetric , whilst sacrificing exact normal incidence on the slm pixels , which are designed for normal incidence . for the slm
, we used a meadowlark 8-bit , 2d , phase - only liquid - crystal spatial light modulator of @xmath101 pixel resolution and array size of @xmath102 mm @xmath103 mm .
the pixels were squares of size @xmath104 @xmath8 m and the fill factor was 95.7% .
the spatial dispersion of the shaper at the slm was @xmath105 nm / pixel , although , the actual shaper resolution is limited by the spot size . in order to modulate both amplitude and phase , we used silberberg group s @xcite first - order approach , where we form a vertical blazed grating pattern on the slm and pick off its @xmath106 reflection as the output .
different phase ramps may be applied to different wavelengths ( at different horizontal positions ) to affect the amount of power in the @xmath106 reflection , and the phases can be manipulated by vertically shifting the blazed grating upwards / downwards .
we used a vertical period of @xmath107 pixels in the pump band , and @xmath108 pixels in the signal band , as shown in fig .
[ fig07 ] . for the bandwidths we chose to work with ( @xmath109 nm ) , the pump band had sufficient power to allow for a frequency - resolved - optical - grating ( frog ) measurement .
a commercial grenouille 8 - 50-usb by swamp optics was employed for this .
this allowed us to characterize and compensate for the frequency chirp suffered through traversal of the beam through multiple optical elements by applying quadratic and quartic phase corrections on the slm phase mask ( fig .
[ fig07](a ) ) .
the resulting reduction in the pulse s temporal width was independently validated on a homebuilt autocorrelator .
similar chirp compensation was optimized for the signal band by maximizing the ce at a low pump power in the nonlinear waveguide .
some linear spectral phases were added to one or both bands to overlap the pulses in time .
the bandwidths for both bands were small enough to overcome any adverse effects from transverse - spatial chirp or pulse - front tilt induced in the beam by the shaper . for frequency conversion
, we used a standard , off - the - shelf , @xmath7 mm long , shg chip made of mgo - doped lithium niobate from advr .
it had been poled at a period of @xmath110 @xmath8 m for type-0 shg from wavelengths around @xmath111 nm , and consisted ( as is typical ) of several waveguides of varying widths .
we chose to work with the @xmath7 @xmath8 m waveguide , which at a temperature of @xmath11c phase - matched shg from @xmath9 nm to @xmath10 nm .
the waveguide was placed in a homebuilt oven whose temperature was controlled using a pid circuit .
we confirmed the narrowness of the shg red - pump acceptance bandwidth ( @xmath112 nm ) as well as the wide sfg acceptance bandwidth ( @xmath113 nm , see fig . [
fig05](b ) ) by scanning the frequencies of single - band and dual - band red inputs generated from the pulse shaper @xcite to generate blue light .
we coupled light into and out of the waveguide using @xmath114 mm aspheric lenses , which after some post - pulse - shaper beam resizing gave us a red - light coupling efficiency of about @xmath115% .
the blue and red beams were separated at the output by a thorlabs dmlp650 longpass dichroic mirror , and the pump and signal bands in the red beam were split by angle - tuning two semrock ff01 - 810/10 bandpass filters . although the shg / sfg process for the phase - matched frequencies dominates when controlled for input powers , imperfections in the waveguide resulted in spurious shg blue light at all `` red '' wavelengths .
our process used a strong pump , but a weak signal , which generated some pump - induced spurious shg ( fig .
[ fig08 ] ) at higher pump powers , thus possibly violating the unchanging , undepleting pump approximation .
the sfg and spurious - shg blue bands were separated by an angle - tuned semrock tbp01 - 400/16 bandpass filter .
the choice of central wavelengths for the pump ( @xmath12 nm ) and the signal ( @xmath13 nm ) bands afforded us @xmath116 .
the pump - pulse width was set by the pulse shaper to be @xmath117 fs , yielding @xmath118 , landing us well within the near - gvm regime .
the pulse shaper allowed us a sufficient range for time shifting the pump and signal pulses independently of each other .
the average signal powers were chosen around @xmath119 @xmath8w ( measured at waveguide output ) , which for a laser pulse rate of @xmath95 mhz , translates to @xmath120 pj per pulse . the pump power coupled into the waveguide
was varied from @xmath121 to @xmath122 mw ( @xmath123 nj per pulse ) , which was sufficient for significant ce @xcite without much pump depletion via spurious shg . in order to compare theoretical predictions with experimental data
, we needed to map the square - root of the pump power to @xmath62 through a proportionality factor @xmath124 .
we fit all the diverse data for different input pulse - shape combinations and inter - pulse delays to a single @xmath124 value of @xmath125 @xmath126 . ) for various @xmath127 ( where @xmath128 /@xmath129 , and @xmath130 is average pump power ) for ( a ) gaussian pump and signal , ( b ) gaussian pump and first - order hermite - gaussian signal , ( c ) first - order hermite - gaussian pump and gaussian signal , and ( d ) first - order hermite - gaussian pump and signal pulse shapes .
note the temporal skewness at higher @xmath62 , as well as asymmetry in lobe peak heights , matching the theoretically predicted trends from fig .
[ fig04 ] .
vertical error bars are all of order @xmath131 , not shown . ] before attempting to create ideal input signal shapes matched to the system s schmidt modes , we first studied the system s behavior when both the pump and signal inputs were gaussian and/or first - order hermite gaussian . figure [ fig09 ] shows the conversion efficiencies recorded for gaussian- and ( first - order ) hermite - gaussian - shaped pump and signal input pulses for various pump powers and initial pump - signal time delays ( @xmath132 ) .
the pump powers were changed by changing the phase - contrast of the vertical gratings in the pump band on the slm .
the pump - signal time delay was scanned in steps of @xmath133 fs by applying a linear spectral phase ramp to the signal band on the slm and changing its slope .
the data reproduces the broad features predicted by theory in fig .
[ fig04 ] , namely , the temporal - shift ( both extent and direction ) of the peaks and troughs for the various shape combinations , as well as the numbers and relative heights of the peaks .
this scan ensures that we are nt seeing an artificial contrast in ce between pump - signal shape - matched vs. shape - mismatched cases owing to a setting dependent , systemically applied , extreme time delay between the pump and signal input pulses .
the vertical error bars are all of order @xmath131 , and are not shown for the sake of clarity .
( @xmath134 ) for various pump and signal input pulse shapes at a fixed `` zero '' delay ( defined as delay that maximizes ce at low pump power ) .
the legend label ( p@xmath135 , s@xmath136 ) denotes @xmath135-th order hermite - gaussian pump pulse , and @xmath136-th order hermite - gaussian signal pulse .
the solid lines are theory and the error bars are measured data . ] for closer comparison , we take a @xmath137 slice of the theoretical graphs and the measured data from figs .
[ fig04 ] and [ fig09 ] respectively , and plot them in fig .
[ fig10 ] .
note that the four possible input shape configurations follow the expected contrasts in ce .
the data points for the first - order hermite - gaussian - shaped pumps are shifted horizontally forward relative to those for the gaussian - shaped pumps .
this is because for a given temporal - width scale , the first - order hermite gaussian spectrum has a slightly larger bandwidth , giving us more available power to be syphoned off from the ultrafast seed laser . also note that for a given pump shape , the signal - shape matched points are shifted horizontally slightly backward relative to the signal - shape mismatched points , and the shift is larger at higher ce .
this is because , due to energy conservation , some amount of power from the pump pulse is lost along with depletion of signal power during fc . the effect , a violation of the undepleting pump approximation , is negligible for weak signals , as demonstrated by the close match of the data with theory .
( @xmath134 ) for @xmath135-th order hermite - gaussian pump pulses ( @xmath138 ) and the corresponding first input schmidt modes ( @xmath139 ) . also shown
are ce with the pump shapes swapped for @xmath140 .
solid lines are theory ( _ th ) , and markers are experiment ( _ ex ) .
error bars ( not shown ) are smaller than marker size . ] in fig .
[ fig11 ] we show the ce vs. @xmath62 for our attempt to match the exact , first input schmidt mode at every @xmath62 via numerically computed tm shapes .
the plotted points are for gaussian , and first - order hermite - gaussian pump pulses .
the solid lines are the theoretical prediction .
the ce with matched ( appropriate to pump shape ) schmidt mode inputs exceeds those of the pure hermite - gaussian - shaped signal inputs from fig .
[ fig10 ] .
the measured data falls short of theory at larger pump powers .
we suspect this is due to pump pulse reshaping within the waveguide due to spurious pump - only second - harmonic generation ( see fig .
[ fig08 ] ) . despite this
, we achieve a ce contrast of @xmath16 to @xmath17 ( @xmath18% vs. @xmath19% ) between the two pump shapes and their corresponding , first schmidt modes .
the error bars are smaller than the plot markers , and are not shown .
we have quantified and demonstrated the importance of group - velocity and temporal - width parameter regimes that enhance temporal - mode selectivity in nonlinear optical frequency conversion in @xmath5-waveguides . we have confirmed kumar / kanter group s @xcite observation of the viability of using standard frequency - doubling waveguides around the shg wavelengths , and shown one such case functioning at near room temperature .
and we have illustrated the use of a single , large , treacy - grating - pair pulse shaper , in conjunction with an ultrafast , titanium - sapphire laser and a reflective spatial - light modulator , to manipulate both the pump and signal fields , shapes and time delays .
and we have demonstrated the accuracy of the coupled - mode model equations in predicting the experimental results .
the mode - separability achieved at @xmath108% conversion is significant enough to advance to cascaded frequency conversion schemes @xcite , and study the gains in high - ce separability from temporal - mode interferometry , thus bringing us a step closer to a highly - selective quantum pulse gate ( qpg ) @xcite .
the use of off - the - shelf waveguides and other ubiquitous resources should empower other groups without access to waveguide fabrication facilities to invest in temporal - mode selective frequency conversion research , which is sorely needed in this new , rapidly evolving field .
we would like to thank benjamin brecht , and prof .
christine silberhorn for thoughtful discussions and help with system design .
we thank phil battle and david walsh from advr for providing the waveguides and replying to our queries .
we acknowledge the support of larry scatena for help with constructing the ultrafast laser , as well as cliff dax and jeffrey graman for designing and building the waveguide ovens and temperature controllers .
lastly , we thank colin mckinstrie for the primary theoretical insights that resulted in the conception of this publication . | quantum frequency conversion ( qfc ) in nonlinear optical media is a powerful tool for temporal - mode selective manipulation of light .
recent attempts at achieving high mode selectivities and/or fidelities have had to resort to multi - dimensional optimization schemes to determine the system s natural schmidt modes .
certain combinations of relative - group velocities between the relevant frequency bands , medium length , and temporal pulse widths have been known to achieve good selectivities ( exceeding @xmath0% ) for temporal modes that are nearly identical to pump pulse shapes , even for high conversion efficiencies . working in this parameter regime using an off - the - shelf , second - harmonic generation , mgo : ppln waveguide , and with pulses on the order of @xmath1 fs at wavelengths around @xmath2 nm
, we verify experimentally that model - predicted schmidt modes provide the high temporal - mode selectivity expected .
this paves the way to the implementation of a proposed two - stage qfc scheme that is predicted to reach near - perfect ( @xmath3% ) selectivity .
10 b. j. smith and m. g. raymer , `` photon wave functions , wave - packet quantization of light , and coherence theory , '' new journal of physics * 9 * , 414 ( 2007 ) . m. g. raymer and k. srinivasan , `` manipulating the color and shape of single photons , '' physics today * 65 * , 32 ( 2012 ) .
j. roslund , r. m. de araujo , s. jiang , c. fabre , and n. treps , `` wavelength - multiplexed quantum networks with ultrafast frequency combs , '' nat .
photonics * 8 * , 109 ( 2014 ) .
v. a. averchenko , v. thiel , and n. treps , `` nonlinear photon subtraction from a multimode quantum field , '' phys .
rev . a * 89 * , 063808 ( 2014 ) .
b. brecht , d. v. reddy , c. silberhorn , and m. g. raymer , `` photon temporal modes : a complete framework for quantum information science , '' phys .
rev .
x * 5 * , 041017 ( 2015 ) .
m. pant and d. englund , `` high - dimensional unitary transformations and boson sampling on temporal modes using dispersive optics , '' phys .
rev .
a * 93 * , 043803 ( 2016 ) .
a. lenhard , m. bock , c. becher , j. brito , and j. eschner , `` coherence and entanglement preservation of frequency - converted heralded single photons , '' arxiv:1703.02879 ( 2017 ) .
j. nunn , i. a. walmsley , m. g. raymer , k. surmacz , f. c. waldermann , z. wang , and d. jaksch , `` mapping broadband single - photon wave packets into an atomic memory , '' phys . rev .
a * 75 * , 011401 ( 2007 ) .
z. zheng , o. mishina , n. treps , and c. fabre , `` atomic quantum memory for multimode frequency combs , '' phys .
rev . a * 91 * , 031802 ( 2015 ) .
l. s. costanzo , a. s. coelho , d. pellegrino , m. s. mendes , l. acioli , k. n. cassemiro , d. felinto , a. zavatta , and m. bellini , `` zero - area single - photon pulses , '' phys .
rev .
lett . * 116 * , 023602 ( 2016 ) .
t. zhong , j. m. kindem , j. rochman , and a. faraon , `` interfacing broadband photonic qubits to on - chip cavity - protected rare - earth ensembles , '' nat . commun . * 8 * , 14107 ( 2017 ) .
a. eckstein , b. brecht , and c. silberhorn , `` a quantum pulse gate based on spectrally engineered sum frequency generation , '' opt .
express * 19 * , 13370 ( 2011 ) .
b. brecht , a. eckstein , a. christ , h. suche , and c. silberhorn , `` from quantum pulse gate to quantum pulse shaperengineered frequency conversion in nonlinear optical waveguides , '' new journal of physics * 13 * , 065029 ( 2011 ) .
b. brecht , a. eckstein , r. ricken , v. quiring , h. suche , l. sansoni , and c. silberhorn , `` demonstration of coherent time - frequency schmidt mode selection using dispersion - engineered frequency conversion , '' phys .
rev . a * 90 * , 030302(r ) ( 2014 ) .
v. ansari , m. allgaier , l. sasoni , b. brecht , j. roslund , n. treps , g. harder , and c. silberhorn , `` temporal - mode tomography of single photons , '' arxiv:1607.03001 ( 2016 ) .
p. manurkar , n. jain , m. silver , y .- p .
huang , c. langrock , m. m. fejer , p. kumar , and g. s. kanter , `` multidimensional mode - separable frequency conversion for high - speed quantum communication , '' optica * 3 * , 13001307 ( 2016 ) .
p. manukar , n. jain , p. kumar , and g. s. kanter , `` programmable optical waveform reshaping on a picosecond timescale , '' arxiv:1612.03263 ( 2016 ) .
v. averchenko , d. sych , and g. leuchs , `` heralded temporal shaping of single photons enabled by entanglement , '' arxiv:1610.03794 ( 2016 ) .
m. karpiski , m. jachura , l. j. wright , and b. j. smith , `` bandwidth manipulation of quantum light by an electro - optic time lens , '' nat .
photonics * 11 * , 53 ( 2017 ) .
v. ansari , g. herder , m. allgaier , b. brecht , and c. silberhorn , `` temporal - mode detector tomography of a quantum pulse gate , '' arxiv:1702.03336 ( 2017 ) .
m. allgaier , g. vigh , v. ansari , c. eigner , v. quiring , r. ricken , b. brecht , and c. silberhorn , `` fast time - domain measurements on telecom single photons , '' arxiv:1702.03240 ( 2017 ) .
y .- s .
ra , c. jacquard , a. dufour , c. fabre , and n. treps , `` tomography of a mode - tunable coherent single - photon subtractor , '' arxiv:1702.02082 ( 2017 ) .
k. hammerer , a. s. srensen , and e. s. polzik , `` quantum interface between light and atomic ensembles , '' rev .
mod .
phys .
* 82 * , 10411093 ( 2010 ) .
p. j. bustard , r. lausten , d. g. england , and b. j. sussman , `` toward quantum processing in molecules : a thz - bandwidth coherent memory for light , '' phys .
rev .
lett . * 111 * , 083901 ( 2013 ) .
k. f. reim , j. nunn , x .-
m .
jin , p. s. michelberger , t. f. m. champion , d. g. england , k. c. lee , w. s. kolthammer , n. k. langford , and i. a. walmsley , `` multipulse addressing of a raman quantum memory : configurable beam splitting and efficient readout , '' phys .
rev .
lett . *
108 * , 263602 ( 2012 ) .
p. c. humphreys , w. s. kolthammer , j. nunn , m. barbieri , a. datta , and i. a. walmsley , `` continuous - variable quantum computing in optical time - frequency modes using quantum memories , '' phys .
rev .
lett . * 113 * , 130502 ( 2014 ) .
p. kumar , `` quantum frequency conversion , '' opt .
lett .
* 15 * , 14761478 ( 1990 ) .
j. huang and p. kumar , `` observation of quantum frequency conversion , '' phys .
rev .
lett . * 68 * , 21532156 ( 1992 ) .
h. j. mcguinness , m. g. raymer , c. j. mckinstrie , and s. radic , `` quantum frequency translation of single - photon states in a photonic crystal fiber , '' phys .
rev .
lett . * 105 * , 093604 ( 2010 ) .
h. j. mcguinness , m. raymer , c. mckinstrie , and s. radic , `` wavelength translation across 210 nm in the visible using vector bragg scattering in a birefringent photonic crystal fiber , '' ieee photon .
technol .
lett .
* 23 * , 109111 ( 2011 ) .
y .- p .
huang and p. kumar , `` mode - resolved photon counting via cascaded quantum frequency conversion , '' opt .
lett .
* 38 * , 468470 ( 2013 ) .
a. s. kowligy , p. manurkar , n. v. corzo , v. g. velev , m. silver , r. p. scott , s. j. b. yoo , p. kumar , g. s. kanter , and y .- p .
huang , `` quantum optical arbitrary waveform manipulation and measurement in real time , '' opt . express * 22 * , 2794227957 ( 2014 ) .
j. m. donohue , m. d. mazurek , and k. j. resch , `` theory of high - efficiency sum - frequency generation for single - photon waveform conversion , '' phys .
rev . a * 91 * , 033809 ( 2015 ) .
h. j. mcguinness , m. g. raymer , and c. j. mckinstrie , `` theory of quantum frequency translation of light in optical fiber : application to interference of two photons of different color , '' opt .
express * 19 * , 1787617907 ( 2011 ) .
l. mejling , c. j. mckinstrie , m. g. raymer , and k. rottwitt , `` quantum frequency translation by four - wave mixing in a fiber : low - conversion regime , '' opt .
express * 20 * , 695697 ( 2012 ) .
d. v. reddy , m. g. raymer , c. j. mckinstrie , l. mejling , and k. rottwitt , `` temporal mode selectivity by frequency conversion in second - order nonlinear optical waveguides , '' opt .
express * 21 * , 1384013863 ( 2013 ) .
n. quesada and j. e. sipe , `` high efficiency in mode - selective frequency conversion , '' opt .
lett . * 41 * , 364367 ( 2016 ) .
d. v. reddy , m. g. raymer , and c. j. mckinstrie , `` efficient sorting of quantum - optical wave packets by temporal - mode interferometry , '' opt . lett . * 39 * , 29242927 ( 2014 ) .
d. v. reddy , m. g. raymer , and c. j. mckinstrie , `` sorting photon wave packets using temporal - mode interferometry based on multiple - stage quantum frequency conversion , '' phys .
rev . a * 91 * , 012323 ( 2015 ) .
j. nunn , s. thomas , j. h. d. munns , k. t. kaczmarek , c. qiu , a. feizpour , e. poem , b. brecht , d. j. saunders , p. m. ledingham , d. v. reddy , m. g. raymer , and i. a. walmsley , `` theory of noise suppression in @xmath4-type quantum memories by means of a cavity , '' arxiv:1601.00157 ( 2016 ) .
s. clemmen , a. farsi , s. ramelow , and a. l. gaeta , `` ramsey interference with single photons , '' phys .
. lett . * 117 * , 223601 ( 2016 ) .
t. kobayashi , d. yamazaki , k. matsuki , r. ikuta , s. miki , t. yamashita , h. terai , t. yamamoto , m. kaoshi , and n. imoto , `` mach - zehnder interferometer using frequency - domain beamsplitter , '' arxiv:1703.08114 ( 2017 ) .
m. raymer , s. van enk , c. mckinstrie , and h. mcguinness , `` interference of two photons of different color , '' opt
. commun . * 283 * , 747 752 ( 2010 ) .
c. j. mckinstrie , l. mejling , m. g. raymer , and k. rottwitt , `` quantum - state - preserving optical frequency conversion and pulse reshaping by four - wave mixing , '' phys . rev .
a * 85 * , 053829 ( 2012 ) .
w. h. louisell , a. yariv , and a. e. siegman , `` quantum fluctuations and noise in parametric processes . i. '' phys . rev . *
124 * , 16461654 ( 1961 ) .
g. strang , _ introduction to linear algebra _
( wellesley - cambridge press , 1998 ) , 3rd ed .
g. j. gbur , _ mathematical methods for optical physics and engineering _ ( cambridge press , 2011 ) . j. b. christensen , d. v. reddy , c. j. mckinstrie , k. rottwitt , and m. g. raymer , `` temporal mode sorting using dual - stage quantum frequency conversion by asymmetric bragg scattering , '' opt .
express * 23 * , 2328723301 ( 2015 ) .
k. laiho , k. n. cassemiro , and c. silberhorn , `` producing high fidelity single photons with optimal brightness via waveguided parametric down - conversion , '' opt .
express * 17 * , 2282322837 ( 2009 ) .
a. m. weiner , `` femtosecond pulse shaping using spatial light modulators , '' review of scientific instruments * 71 * , 19291960 ( 2000 ) .
e. frumker and y. silberberg , `` phase and amplitude pulse shaping with two - dimensional phase - only spatial light modulators , '' j. opt .
soc .
am .
b * 24 * , 29402947 ( 2007 ) .
a. christ , b. brecht , w. mauerer , and c. silberhorn , `` theory of quantum frequency conversion and type - ii parametric down - conversion in the high - gain regime , '' new journal of physics * 15 * , 053038 ( 2013 ) . |
a fundamental idea behind classical statistical mechanics is that we are living in a macroscopic world , which means that we are unable to deal with microstates on a molecular level .
this forces us to distinguish heat from work and to accept the increase of entropy on probabilistic ground , when we formulate the laws of thermodynamics .
however , the border between our macroscopic world and the microscopic world of molecules is becoming vague due to technological developments over the last century .
this has led to a natural question ; i.e. , what would it mean to thermodynamics if it became possible to access and manipulate microstates just as we do macrostates ?
the founders of statistical mechanics were already aware of this problem : for example , maxwell imagined an intelligent being s intervention on a molecular level in his famous thought experiment , now known as maxwell s demon @xcite , and expressed deep concern about the foundation of the second law of thermodynamics .
the szilard engine has been regarded as the simplest implementation of maxwell s demon with a single - particle gas @xcite .
its cycle consists of four processes ; inserting a wall into the center of the box , measuring the position of the particle , expanding the quantum gas isothermally , and finally removing the wall . considering its microscopic nature , it is tempting to translate the cycle into quantum - mechanical language as has been done in refs . and for other engines .
in fact , there are more reasons than that : zurek @xcite , when he discusses jauch and baron s objection that the gas is compressed without the expenditure of energy upon inserting the wall , argues that one has to resort to quantum mechanics to understand the szilard engine @xcite . according to ref .
, this ` apparent inconsistency ' is removed by quantum - mechanical considerations .
therefore , in a sense , it is a matter of theoretical consistency .
kim and coworkers have presented a detailed account for its quantum - mechanical cycle in refs . , with emphasis on the isothermal process .
there seem to remain some subtle issues to settle , however , as shown in the debate on how to deal with the quantum tunneling effect through the wall in a three - boson case @xcite . in this work
, we describe the isothermal expansion of the quantum szilard engine by considering a quantum gas confined in a one - dimensional cylinder @xcite .
although some previous studies , such as refs . , assume that the wall is impenetrable , we will relax that assumption because it is , strictly speaking , experimentally infeasible .
starting from the schrdinger equation , we calculate the energy levels and thereby obtain how much work can be extracted by an isothermal reversible expansion .
we find the following : the amount of reversible work is significantly reduced compared to the claims in refs . and
if we assume full thermal equilibrium inside the box , as is usual in describing isothermal expansion .
this conclusion should not be affected by either the wall s insertion or the measurement before the isothermal expansion because thermal equilibrium does not remember its history . moreover ,
if we put two or three fermions in the box , the free - energy landscape is not monotonic with respect to the wall s position , so that we should sometimes _ perform _ work to expand the gas .
these effects have not been explicitly discussed in previous studies .
this work is organized as follows : an explanation of our basic setting in terms of the schrdinger equation is given in section [ sec : isoexp ] . a numeric calculation of the energy levels and the free energy and a comparison of a single - particle case to the two- and three - particle cases is presented in in section [ sec : work ] .
this is followed by discussion of results and conclusions .
consider the following one - dimensional potential landscape with size @xmath0 : @xmath1 where @xmath2 is the strength of the delta potential and @xmath3 specifies its location @xcite .
we expect the schrdinger equation @xmath4 \psi(x ) = e \psi(x ) \label{eq : schrod}\ ] ] to have a solution with a sinusoidal form .
the boundary conditions at @xmath5 and @xmath6 are satisfied if we set @xmath7 where the coefficients @xmath8 and @xmath9 , as well as the wavenumber @xmath10 , are assumed to be nonzero .
the eigenfunction @xmath11 has the following properties : first , it is continuous over @xmath12 $ ] ; i.e. , @xmath13 with @xmath14 .
second , the change in the derivative of @xmath11 with respect to @xmath15 around @xmath16 is obtained by using @xmath17 dx + \frac{2m}{\hbar^2 } \left [ \int_{pl-\epsilon}^{pl+\epsilon } e \psi(x ) dx - \int_{pl-\epsilon}^{pl+\epsilon } a \psi(x ) \delta(x - pl ) dx \right ] \right\ } = 0,\ ] ] from which it follows that @xmath18 plugging eq .
( [ eq : psi ] ) here and multiplying both sides by @xmath19 to use eq .
( [ eq : cont ] ) , we obtain @xmath20 this formula has also been derived in ref . in a different way .
equation ( [ eq : k ] ) can be numerically solved by using the newton - raphson method to yield the allowed values of @xmath10 .
the method works as follows : first , let us define @xmath21 , and look for its zeros to solve eq .
( [ eq : k ] ) .
starting from @xmath22 , we check whether the sign of @xmath23 changes with increasing @xmath10 by a sufficiently small amount , say , @xmath24 . every time the sign changes between @xmath25 and @xmath26 , we run the following iteration starting from @xmath27 : @xmath28}{f'[k^{(j)}]},\ ] ] where @xmath29 . when @xmath30 has converged to a stationary value @xmath31 , i.e. , if @xmath32 within numerical accuracy , we take it as a solution of eq .
( [ eq : k ] ) and repeat the procedure by checking the sign of @xmath23 from @xmath33 .
each of these solutions is identified with the wavenumber @xmath34 of the @xmath35th eigenmode in an ascending order . for the application of the newton - raphson method numerically , it is convenient to express the quantities in dimensionless units , so we divide eq .
( [ eq : schrod ] ) by @xmath36 , the ground state energy for @xmath37 , to obtain @xmath38 \psi(\eta ) = \epsilon \psi(\eta),\ ] ] where @xmath39 .
then , the potential inside the box is expressed as @xmath40 with @xmath41 .
we can also define a dimensionless wavenumber @xmath42 to rewrite eqs .
( [ eq : k ] ) as @xmath43 .
a little algebra shows that the energy level is given by @xmath44^{-1},\ ] ] where the second term represents the potential energy coming from the overlap between the wavefunction and the delta peak potential .
the numerical solutions for these @xmath45 and @xmath46 are depicted in fig .
[ fig : level5 ] , together with the probability density plots . as a function of @xmath47 , and ( b ) the corresponding energy levels in units of @xmath48 .
the other two panels show the probability densities for the three lowest eigenmodes ( c ) when the wall is in the middle , @xmath49 , and ( d ) when it has moved to @xmath50 . the strength of the potential is set as @xmath51.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] as a function of @xmath47 , and ( b ) the corresponding energy levels in units of @xmath48 .
the other two panels show the probability densities for the three lowest eigenmodes ( c ) when the wall is in the middle , @xmath49 , and ( d ) when it has moved to @xmath50 .
the strength of the potential is set as @xmath51.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] as a function of @xmath47 , and ( b ) the corresponding energy levels in units of @xmath48 .
the other two panels show the probability densities for the three lowest eigenmodes ( c ) when the wall is in the middle , @xmath49 , and ( d ) when it has moved to @xmath50 .
the strength of the potential is set as @xmath51.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] as a function of @xmath47 , and ( b ) the corresponding energy levels in units of @xmath48 .
the other two panels show the probability densities for the three lowest eigenmodes ( c ) when the wall is in the middle , @xmath49 , and ( d ) when it has moved to @xmath50 .
the strength of the potential is set as @xmath51.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ]
we are interested in how much work can be extracted by performing a reversible isothermal process with this system .
let @xmath52 denote the @xmath35th energy level obtained by using the newton - raphson method with @xmath53 so that the ground - state energy is denoted by @xmath54 . for a given value of temperature @xmath55 , where @xmath56 is the boltzmann constant
, we run the calculation to get @xmath57 . the partition function for a single quantum particle
can then be obtained as @xmath58 the free energy is @xmath59 , accompanied by a differential form @xmath60 , where @xmath61 , @xmath62 , and @xmath63 are the entropy , pressure , and volume , respectively .
the classical concepts , such as pressure and work , need careful consideration in quantum mechanics @xcite . to calculate work ,
we begin with the occupation probability of the @xmath35th level given by @xmath64 the change in the internal energy @xmath65 is then expressed as @xmath66 , where @xmath67 and @xmath68 are differentials of heat and work , respectively .
the quantum thermodynamic work is identified with @xmath69 because heat is usually involved with changes in occupation probabilities for given energy levels whereas work is performed when the energy levels themselves change @xcite .
consequently , the amount of reversible work during this process is @xmath70 , which is consistent with the classical case . in units of @xmath48
when the wall , starting from the center of the box , moves to a new position @xmath47 .
the height of the wall is fixed at @xmath71 , and each curve represents a different @xmath72 in units of @xmath73 .
the number of energy levels considered is kept as @xmath74 throughout the free - energy calculations.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] figure [ fig : df ] shows @xmath75 resulting from moving the wall , which was initially located at the center , @xmath49 .
suppose that @xmath72 is so low that @xmath76 .
when the wall is at @xmath77 , only the ground state contributes to the summation in eq .
( [ eq : z ] ) , which means that @xmath78 .
when the wall is at @xmath49 , the ground - state energy equals @xmath79 , and the first excited state also contributes to the partition sum in eq .
( [ eq : z ] ) because it lies close to the ground state [ see fig . [
fig : level5](b ) ] .
the partition function is , therefore , approximated as @xmath80 .
the free - energy difference in this low-@xmath72 region is , thus , given as @xmath81 .
when @xmath82 , for example , the free - energy difference roughly amounts to @xmath83 , which explains the size of the free - energy drop in fig .
[ fig : df ] .
as @xmath72 increases , a plateau develops near the center of the box because @xmath84 does not respond much to the wall s position
. however , the drop in @xmath84 at the end of the process increases with increasing @xmath72 if @xmath85 in units of @xmath86 .
our question is how it grows with @xmath72 .
let us take @xmath87 and @xmath88 .
then , it is the partition function for the initial and final wall positions can be approximated .
the latter case of the final wall position is estimated as @xmath89\label{eq : correction}\\ & = & \sqrt{\frac{\pi}{4\gamma } } - \frac{1}{2},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the summation in eq .
( [ eq : correction ] ) is a first - order correction to the integral approximation .
likewise , the former case of the initial wall position gives @xmath90 = \sqrt{\frac{\pi}{4\gamma } } - 1,\ ] ] where the factor of @xmath91 in front of the summation is due to the fact that every pair of adjacent energy levels becomes degenerate in the limit of @xmath87 .
this effect cancels the factor of @xmath92 inside the exponential arising from the reduced volume @xmath93 .
although @xmath75 does not completely vanish due to the correction , the important point is that @xmath94 for @xmath95 is far less than @xmath91 , in contrast with the claim that @xmath96 in refs . and .
because @xmath97 must be finite in any experimental situation , the particle can , in full thermal equilibrium , be observed on either side of the box , which reduces the amount of extracted work . on the other hand ,
the previous studies on the quantum szilard engine @xcite have assumed that the process is performed within a shorter time scale than required for tunneling through the wall and , therefore , concluded that @xmath98 without the factor of @xmath91 in front .
strictly speaking , their engine undergoes an isothermal process only when partially equilibrated to maintain the confinement and extract @xmath99 .
if two quantum particles are in the box , we should consider their symmetry , i.e. , whether they are fermions or bosons . without any consideration of the spin degree of freedom ,
the elements of the density matrix for the two particles are expressed in the bracket notation as follows : @xmath100 , where @xmath101 is the kronecker delta symbol , and we have a plus sign for bosons and a minus sign for fermions . the two - particle partition function
is then obtained by taking the trace operation : @xmath102 the same applies to the three - particle case .
the density - matrix elements are written as @xmath103 , and the partition function reads @xmath104 figure [ fig : sym ] shows the free - energy differences for the two- and the three - particle cases .
the bosonic cases are qualitatively similar to the single - particle case .
however , we see very different behavior for the fermionic cases where the pauli exclusion principle is in action : at low @xmath72 , we need to perform positive work to move the wall from the center to a certain position @xmath47 [ figs .
[ fig : sym](b ) and ( d ) ] .
obviously , the reason is that it costs free energy to place two fermions close to each other .
in summary , we have considered an isothermal expansion process of a quantum gas , taking the tunneling effect into consideration .
we have found that the amount of reversible work is smaller than @xmath105 in the high-@xmath72 region if the system is fully equilibrated at every moment of the isothermal expansion .
the difference from refs . and arises because they have separated the time scale of tunneling from that of the partial equilibration that occurs on only one side of the wall .
although it was not explicitly stated in previous studies , this separation may be a plausible assumption for the following reason : as we increase the potential height @xmath97 , we may well expect the time scale for tunneling to grow whereas the partial equilibration before tunneling is achieved within a finite amount of time .
the quantum szilard engine will show its expected performance only between these two time scales .
the question is , then , how large a value of @xmath97 one should have to ensure the separation of the time scales , which will be pursued in our future studies .
17ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop * * , ( ) in @noop _ _ , ( , , ) , pp . @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) in @noop _ _ , , vol . , ( , , ) , pp . @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , , ) , pp . @noop * * , ( ) | for an understanding of a heat engine working in the microscopic scale , it is often necessary to estimate the amount of reversible work extracted by isothermal expansion of the quantum gas used as its working substance .
we consider an engine with a movable wall , modeled as an infinite square well with a delta peak inside . by solving the resulting one - dimensional schrdinger equation
, we obtain the energy levels and the thermodynamic potentials .
our result shows how quantum tunneling degrades the engine by decreasing the amount of reversible work during the isothermal expansion . |
recently there has been several efforts to understand the problem of quantum or thermal quench @xcite in strongly coupled field theories using the ads / cft correspondence @xcite .
this approach has been used to explore two interesting issues .
the first relates to the question of thermalization . in this problem
one typically considers a coupling in the hamiltonian which varies appreciably with time over some finite time interval .
starting with a nice initial state ( e.g. the vacuum ) the question is whether the system evolves into some steady state and whether this steady state resembles a thermal state in a suitably defined sense . in the bulk description
a time dependent coupling of the boundary field theory is a time dependent boundary condition .
for example , with an initial ads this leads to black hole formation under suitable conditions .
this is a holographic description of thermalization , which has been widely studied over the past several years @xcite with other initial conditions as well .
many interesting applications of ads / cft duality involve a subset of bulk fields whose backreaction to gravity can be ignored , so that they can be treated in a _
probe approximation_. one set of examples concern probe branes in ads which lead to hypermultiplet fields in the original dual field theory .
even though the background does not change in the leading order , it turns out that thermalization of the hypermultiplet sector is still visible - this manifests itself in the formation of apparent horizons on the worldvolume @xcite .
the second issue relates to quench across critical points @xcite .
consider for example starting in a gapped phase , with a parameter in the hamiltonian varying slowly compared to the initial gap , bringing the system close to a value of the parameter where there would be an equilibrium critical point .
as one comes close to this critical point , adiabaticity is inevitably broken .
kibble and zurek @xcite argued that in the critical region the dynamics reflects universal features leading to scaling of various quantities .
these arguments are based on rather drastic approximations , and for strongly coupled systems there is no theoretical framework analogous to renormalization group which leads to such scaling . for two - dimensional theories which are
_ suddenly _ quenched to a critical point , powerful techniques of boundary conformal field theory have been used in @xcite to show that ratios of relaxation times of one point functions , as well as the length / time scales associated with the behavior of two point functions of different operators , are given in terms of ratios of their conformal dimensions at the critical point , and hence universal . in @xcite
quench dynamics in the critical region of a finite chemical potential holographic critical point was studied in a probe approximation .
the `` phenomenological '' model used was that of @xcite which involves a neutral scalar field with quartic self - coupling with a mass - squared lying in the range @xmath4 in the background of a _ charged _ @xmath5 black brane .
the self coupling is large so that the backreaction of the scalar dynamics on the background geometry can be ignored .
the background maxwell field gives rise to a nonzero chemical potential in the boundary field theory .
in @xcite it was shown that for low enough temperatures , this system undergoes a critical phase transition at a mass @xmath6 .
for @xmath7 the scalar field condenses , in a manner similar to holographic superfluids @xcite .
the critical point at @xmath8 is a standard mean field transition at any non - zero temperature , and becomes a berezinski - kosterlitz - thouless transition at zero temperature , as in several other examples of quantum critical transitions . in @xcite
the critical point was probed by turning on a time dependent source for the dual operator , with the mass kept exactly at the critical value , i.e. a time dependent boundary value of one of the modes of the bulk scalar .
the source asymptotes to constant values at early and late times , and crosses the critical point at zero source at some intermediate time .
the rate of time variation @xmath0 is slow compared to the initial gap .
as expected , adiabaticity fails as the equilibrium critical point at vanishing source is approached .
however , it was shown that for any non - zero temperature and small enough @xmath0 , the bulk solution in the critical region can be expanded in _ fractional _
powers of @xmath0 .
to lowest order in this expansion , the dynamics is dominated by a single mode - the zero mode of the linearized bulk equation , which appears exactly at @xmath8 .
the resulting dynamics of this zero mode is in fact a _ dissipative _ landau - ginsburg dynamics with a dynamical critical exponent @xmath1 , and the order parameter was shown to obey kibble - zurek type scaling .
the work of @xcite is at finite temperature - the dissipation in this model is of course due to the presence of a black hole horizon and is expected at any finite temperature .
it is interesting to ask what happens at zero temperatures .
it turns out that the model of @xcite used in @xcite becomes subtle at zero temperature . in this case
, there is no conventional adiabatic expansion even away from the critical point ( though there is a different low energy expansion , as in @xcite ) .
furthermore , the susceptibility is finite at the transition , indicating there is no zero mode . while it should be possible to examine quantum quench in this model by numerical methods ,
we have not been able to get much analytic insight . in this paper
we study a different model of a quantum critical point , which is a variation of the model of insulator - superconductor transition of @xcite .
the model of @xcite involves a _ charged _ scalar field minimally coupled to gravity with a negative cosmological constant and a maxwell field .
one of the spatial directions is compact with some radius @xmath9 , and in addition one can have a non - zero temperature @xmath10 and a non - zero chemical potential @xmath11 corresponding to the boundary value of the maxwell field . in the absence of the scalar field this model has a line of hawking - page type first order phase transitions in the @xmath10-@xmath11 plane which separates an ( hot ) ads soliton and a ( charged ) black brane .
exactly on the @xmath12 line , the two phases correspond to the ads soliton with a constant maxwell scalar potential , and an extremal black hole . in @xcite
it was shown that in the presence of a minimally coupled charged scalar , the phase diagram changes .
when the charge is large the scalar and the gauge fields can be regarded as probe fields which do not affect the geometry .
now there is a phase with a trivial scalar and a phase with a scalar condensate . in the boundary theory
the latter is a superfluid phase .
this phase transition persists at zero temperature , where it separates an unbroken phase at low chemical potential and a broken phase - in both cases the background geometry is the ads soliton , while the gauge field is non - trivial in the superfluid phase .
the phase diagram is given in figure 9 of @xcite .
the idea now is to probe the dynamics of this insulator - superfluid transition at zero temperature by turning on a time dependent source for the operator dual to the charged field .
so long as the scalar is minimally coupled and the charge @xmath13 is large , this would involve analyzing a coupled set of equations of the scalar field and the gauge field . however , it turns out that a slight modification of the model allows us to ignore the backreaction of the scalar to the gauge field as well .
this involves the introduction of a quartic self coupling of the scalar @xmath14 .
then in the regime @xmath15 and @xmath16 ( where @xmath17 is the gravitational coupling ) , we can consider the dynamics of the charged scalar in isolation . in this work
we first show that in this regime of the parameters the insulator - superfluid transition persists . concretely , for a sufficiently small negative @xmath18 , there is a critical value of the background chemical potential beyond which a nontrivial static solution for the scalar becomes thermodynamically favored . note that unlike other models of holographic superconductors the trivial solution does not become dynamically unstable .
rather the non - trivial solution has lower energy .
the transition is a standard mean field critical transition .
the background geometry remains an ads soliton and the background gauge potential remains a constant , which is the chemical potential @xmath11 . at the transition ,
the linearized equation has a zero mode solution which is regular both at the boundary and at the tip .
we then turn on a time dependent boundary condition and find that the breakdown of adiabaticity for a small rate @xmath0 is characterized by exponents which are appropriate for a dynamical critical exponent @xmath1 . in a way quite similar to @xcite we find that in the critical region there is a new small @xmath0 expansion in fractional powers of @xmath0 , and the dynamics is once again dominated by a zero mode .
the real and imaginary parts of the zero mode now satisfy a coupled set of landau - ginsburg type equation with first order time derivatives .
however the resulting system is oscillatory rather than dissipative - this is expected since the background geometry has no horizon so that we have is a _ closed _ system .
the order parameter is shown to obey a kibble - zurek type scaling .
finally we solve the bulk equations numerically and verify the scaling property obtained from the above small-@xmath0 expansion .
thermal quench in holographic superfluids with backreaction has been recently studied in @xcite .
this work addresses a different issue - here the quench is applied to the system in the ordered phase _
away from the critical point _ and the resulting late time relaxation of the order parameter is studied .
our emphasis is on probing a possible kibble - zurek scaling when the quench crosses the critical point . in section 2
we define the model and discuss its equilibrium phases . in section 3 we study quantum quench in this model by turning on a time dependent source , discuss the breakdown of adiabaticity and show that the critical region dynamics is dominated by the zero mode , leading to scaling behavior . in section 4 we present the results of a numerical solution of the equations , verifying the scaling behavior . in an appendix we discuss a landau - ginsburg model similar to the critical dynamics of our holographic model .
the `` phenomenological '' holographic model we consider is a slight variation of the model of @xcite .
the bulk action in @xmath19-dimensions is s = d^d+2x , [ 1 - 1 ] where @xmath20 is a complex scalar field and @xmath21 is an abelian gauge field , and the other notations are standard . henceforth we will use @xmath22 units .
one of the spatial directions , which we will denote by @xmath23 will be considered to be compact .
we will consider the regime q^2 , ^2 . in this regime
the scalar field is a probe field , and its backreaction to both the metric and the gauge field can be ignored . the background metric and the gauge field can be then obtained by solving the einstein - maxwell equations with the appropriate periodicity condition on @xmath23 . it is well known that there are two possible solutions .
the first is the @xmath24 soliton , ds^2 & = & + r^2 ( -dt^2 + _ i=1^d-1 dx_i^2 ) + r^2 f_sl(r ) d^2 , + f_sl(r ) & = & 1 - ( ) ^d+1 , + a_t & = & , [ 1 - 2 ] with constant parameters @xmath11 and @xmath25 .
the periodicity of @xmath23 in this solution is ~+ , [ 1 - 3 ] while the temperature can be arbitrary .
the second solution is a @xmath24 charged black hole ds^2 & = & -r^2 f_bh(r ) dt^2 + + r^2 ( _ i=1^d-1 dx_i^2 + d^2 ) , + f_bh(r ) & = & 1 - ( ) ^d+1 + ( ) ^2 ( ) ^2d , + a_t & = & .
[ 1 - 4 ] the temperature of this black brane is t = , [ 1 - 5 ] while the period of @xmath23 is arbitrary .
as shown in @xcite , this system undergoes a phase transition between these two solutions when r_0^d+1= r_+^d+1 .
[ 1 - 6 ] the ads soliton is stable when the temperature and the chemical potential are small . at @xmath12
the transition happens at a critical chemical potential @xmath26 given by _
[ 1 - 7 ] consider now the scalar wave equation in the ads soliton background ( [ 1 - 2 ] ) .
we first rescale r , t tr_0 , .
[ 1 - 7a ] in the rest of the paper we will use these rescaled coordinates ( i.e. , @xmath27 ) and chemical potentials . for fields which depend only on @xmath28 and @xmath29 , the equation of motion
is given by - m^2 - ||^2 = 0 .
[ 1 - 8 ] in this paper we will consider @xmath30 .
the asymptotic behavior of the solution at the ads boundary @xmath31 is of the standard form ( r , t ) = j(t ) r^-_- [ 1 + o(1/r^2 ) ] + a(t ) r^-_+ [ 1 + o(1/r^2 ) ] + , [ 1 - 9 ] where _ = .
[ 1 - 10 ] in `` standard quantization '' @xmath32 is the source , while the expectation value of the dual operator is given by = a(t ) .
[ 1 - 11 ] in `` alternative quantization '' the role of @xmath32 and @xmath33 are interchanged . in this mass range
both @xmath34 are positive and both the solutions of the linear equation vanish at the boundary . thus the nonlinear terms in the equation ( [ 1 - 8 ] ) are subdominant - which is why the leading solution near the boundary is the same as those of the linear equation , as written above .
we need to find time independent solutions of the equation ( [ 1 - 9 ] ) . because of gauge invariance , we need to specify a gauge to qualify what we mean by time independence . for the equilibrium solution we require the solution to be _ real _
- this fixes the gauge .
note that the tip of the soliton is locally two - dimensional flat space .
therefore we need to require the solution to be regular at the tip @xmath35 .
this leads to the following boundary condition at @xmath36 ( r ) = _ h + _ h ( r-1 ) + , [ 1 - 12 ] where regularity requires _ h = _ h ( _ h^2 + m^2 ) + _ h ^2 .
[ 1 - 13 ] to examine the phase structure we need to find time independent solutions with a vanishing source .
clearly @xmath37 is always a solution .
we have solved the equations numerically and found that there is a critical value of the chemical potential @xmath38 beyond which there is another solution with a non - trivial @xmath29 dependence which is thermodynamically preferred .
this means that for @xmath39 , the operator dual to the bulk scalar has a vacuum expectation value , i.e. , the global @xmath40 symmetry of the boundary theory is spontaneously broken .
although this could happen both in the standard and alternative quantizations , we need to check the critical value is less that that of the phase transition between the ads soliton and ads black hole : @xmath41 . otherwise , the scalar condensate phase is not available on the ads soliton .
figure [ fig : condensate ] shows the behavior of the expectation value @xmath42 for @xmath43 for standard and quantization .
we are plotting the condensation with respect to @xmath44 and the phase transition happens at @xmath45 , which means the critical chemical potential is very small of order @xmath46 in the probe limit .
it follows from that @xmath38 is always much smaller than @xmath47 and there exists a scalar condensate phase on the ads soliton .
similarly for any given @xmath18 , @xmath48 is a critical point by letting @xmath13 be large enough .
this transition was first found in @xcite for a _ minimally coupled _
complex scalar - in this case the backreaction to the gauge field can not be ignored , and the result follows from an analysis of the coupled set of equations for the scalar and the gauge field . in this case
the gauge field introduces non - linearity in the problem which is necessary for condensation of the scalar .
what we found is that a self - coupling does the same same job .
to get some insight into this transition it is useful to write the equation ( [ 1 - 8 ] ) as a schrdinger problem .
first define a new coordinate = _
r^ , [ 1 - 14 ] which is the `` tortoise coordinate '' for the ads soliton .
@xmath49 is a monotonic function of @xmath29 with the behavior & ~ & 1/r , r , + & & _ + , r 1 .
[ 1 - 14a ] for example , for @xmath50 ( asymptotically @xmath51 spacetime ) soliton @xmath52 .
let us now redefine the field by ( r , t ) = ( ) ^1/2 ( , t ) .
[ 1 - 15 ] then @xmath53 satisfies the equation = - ^2 + ||^2 .
[ 1 - 16 ] the operator @xmath54 is & = & -_^2 + v_0 ( ) , + v_0 ( ) & = & m^2 r^2 + , [ 1 - 17 ] where @xmath29 has to be expressed as a function of @xmath55 using ( [ 1 - 14 ] ) .
the potential @xmath56 has the following behavior near the boundary and the tip v_0 ( ) & = & + o(^2 ) , 0 , + v_0 ( ) & = & - + o(1 ) , _ .
[ 1 - 18 ] the behavior at the boundary @xmath57 is of course the same as in pure @xmath24 .
the behavior near the tip @xmath58 is in fact the correct behavior expected from a flat two dimensional space . near the tip of the soliton the space becomes @xmath59 with @xmath60 playing the role of a radial variable and @xmath23 playing the role of the polar angle . indeed with the redefined field ( y ) = , [ 1 - 19 ] the operator @xmath54 becomes , near @xmath61 , the zero angular momentum laplacian in two dimensions - _ y(y _ y ) = -(_2)^2|_0 + constant .
[ 1 - 20 ] in fact the eigenvalues of the operator @xmath54 which acts on @xmath62 = -(_2)^2|_0 + v_1(y ) , ( v_1(y ) v_0(y ) + ) , are all positive . for @xmath50
the proof is the following .
let us rewrite the potential @xmath63 as follows v_1(y ) = ( m^2 + ) r^2 + v_2(y ) [ 1 - 2 - 1 ] where v_2(y ) = [ 1 - 2 - 2 ] the term @xmath64 is explicitly positive for all @xmath29 .
this may be seen as follows .
the condition for positivity of @xmath64 is - y(r ) 0 the inequality is saturated for @xmath65 ( @xmath35 ) .
furthermore the first derivative of the left hand side becomes this can be explicitly checked to be positive for all @xmath66 ( e.g. by squaring the expression ) .
therefore @xmath67 for all @xmath66 .
the first term in @xmath63 in ( [ 1 - 2 - 1 ] ) is the asymptotic potential in @xmath51 - when @xmath68 ( which is the bf bound ) , this potential does not have any bound state .
since @xmath64 differs from this asymptotic potential by a positive function , the full potential @xmath63 does not have any bound state . to look for a condensate in standard quantization
, we need to find time independent solutions of the equation ( [ 1 - 16 ] ) which satisfy the boundary condition @xmath69 at @xmath57 and is regular at the tip @xmath70 . with these boundary conditions
the operator @xmath54 has a _ discrete _ and _ positive _ spectrum .
this means that for sufficiently large @xmath11 the operator - ^2 , [ 1 - 21 ] will have a negative eigenvalue .
this is what we found numerically . at the critical value @xmath48 the operator
@xmath71 has a zero eigenvalue , i.e. a zero mode which satisfies the appropriate boundary conditions both at the tip and at the boundary .
this zero mode will play a key role in the following . note
that even though the operator @xmath71 has negative eigenvalues in the condensed phase , the trivial solution does not become unstable .
this is clear from ( [ 1 - 16 ] ) and from the fact the spectrum of @xmath54 is positive , which shows that the frequencies of the solutions to the linearized equation are all real . following the arguments of @xcite
it can be easily checked that the transition is standard mean field .
this means that _ j=0 & ~ & , + _
= _ c1 & ~ & |j|^1/3 .
[ 1 - 22 ] we expect that this transition extends to non - zero temperature , though we have not checked this explicitly .
we will now probe the quantum critical point by quantum quench with a time dependent homogeneous source @xmath32 for the dual operator @xmath72 , with the chemical potential tuned to @xmath48 .
the function @xmath32 will be chosen to asymptote to constants at early and late times , e.g. j(t ) = j_0 ( vt ) .
[ 2 - 1 ] note that we are using units with @xmath27 .
the system then crosses the equilibrium critical point at time @xmath73 .
the idea is to start at some early time with initial conditions provided by the _
instantaneous solution _ and calculate the one point function @xmath74 . in standard quantization
this means that we impose a time dependent boundary condition as in ( [ 1 - 9 ] ) and calculate @xmath33 . in alternative
quantization the source should equal @xmath33 . in this paper
we discuss the problem in standard quantization : the treatment in alternative quantization is similar . with a @xmath32 of the form described above ( e.g. ( [ 2 - 1 ] ) ) , one would expect that the initial time evolution is adiabatic for small @xmath0 so long as @xmath75 is not too small .
as one approaches @xmath76 adiabaticity inevitably breaks down and the system gets excited . in this subsection
we determine the manner in which this happens .
an adiabatic solution of ( [ 1 - 16 ] ) is of the form ( , t ) = ^(0)(,j(t))+ ^(1)(,t ) + ^2 ^(2 ) + , [ 2 - 6 ] where @xmath77 is the adiabaticity parameter .
the leading term is the instantaneous solution of ( [ 1 - 16 ] ) , which is ( using the definition ( [ 1 - 21 ] ) ) ^(0 ) + g ( ) here we have defined g ( ) .
[ 2 - 4 ] from ( [ 1 - 22 ] ) we know that for a real @xmath32 , this is real and has a form ^(0 ) ~^j(t ) + ^1- ^1/3 , [ 2 - 8 ] where _ - - d/2 .
[ 2 - 8b ] this follows from the equations ( [ 1 - 14a ] ) , ( [ 1 - 15 ] ) and ( [ 1 - 9 ] ) .
the adiabatic expansion now proceeds by replacing @xmath78 in ( [ 1 - 16 ] ) substituting ( [ 2 - 6 ] ) and equating terms order by order in @xmath77 .
the @xmath79-th order contribution @xmath80 satisfies a _ linear , inhomogeneous _ ordinary differential equation with a source term which depends on the previous order solution @xmath81 .
to lowest order we have the following equations for the real and imaginary parts of @xmath82 ( re ^(1 ) ) & = & 0 , + ( i m ^(1 ) ) & = & 2 _ t ^(0 ) .
[ 2 - 9 ] note that in these equations the time dependence of @xmath32 should be ignored .
the full function @xmath83 must satisfy the boundary condition @xmath84 = j(t ) $ ] .
this means that the adiabatic corrections must start with the subleading terms , @xmath85 as @xmath86 and has to be regular as @xmath87 .
these provide the boundary conditions for solving the equations ( [ 2 - 9 ] ) .
consider first the equation for @xmath88 .
since the time dependence of @xmath89 is entirely through @xmath32 the solution may be written as ^(1 ) ( , t ) = 2 ( t)_0^ _ d^ ( , ^ ) ( ^,j(t ) ) , [ 2 - 10 ] where @xmath90 is the green s function for the operator @xmath91 , @xmath92 where @xmath93 and @xmath94 are solutions of the homogeneous equation @xmath95 \psi_{1,2 } = 0 $ ] which satisfy the appropriate boundary conditions at the tip @xmath96 and at the boundary @xmath57 respectively .
the wronskian @xmath97 for this operator is clearly constant and is conveniently evaluated near the tip . near @xmath58 these solutions behave as _ 1 ~c , _ 2 ~a + b ( _ - ) , [ 2 - 12 ] where @xmath98 are constants which depends on @xmath32 . ) the time is simply a parameter . ]
thus the wronskian is w(_1,_2 ) = -bc .
[ 2 - 13 ] as noted in the previous section , the operator @xmath71 has a zero mode , i.e. @xmath99 $ ] has a zero mode when @xmath100 , i.e. exactly at the equilibrium critical point .
thus , at this point we must have @xmath101 .
this is why the first adiabatic correction @xmath102 diverges at this point .
for small @xmath32 we can use perturbation theory to estimate the value of @xmath103 . for small @xmath104 the zeroth order solution @xmath89
behaves as @xmath105 ( the first term in ( [ 2 - 8 ] ) is subdominant ) .
this is explicit to all orders in the expansion of the solution around the boundary .
however , this is also justified by the results of the next section where we show that in the critical region the dynamics is dominated by a zero mode .
the coefficient of the zero mode can be seen to be proportional to @xmath105 using a regularity argument similar to that in @xcite so that the additional term in the operator behaves as @xmath106^{2/3}$ ] .
this yields @xmath107 as well .
thus the green s function which appears in ( [ 2 - 10 ] ) behaves as @xmath108 so that the correction behaves as ^(1 ) ~ ~ .
[ 2 - 14 ] the same argument shows that @xmath109 , so that @xmath110 as well
. therefore adiabaticity breaks when | ^(1 ) | ~|
^(0 ) | ~j^5/3 .
[ 2 - 15 ] for sources which vanish linearly at @xmath76 , i.e. @xmath111 ( e.g. of the form ( [ 2 - 1 ] ) ) this means that if the source is turned on at some early time , adiabaticity breaks at a time t_adia ~v^-2/5 . [ 2 - 16 ] while at this time the value of the order parameter @xmath112 is ( t_adia)~[j(t_adia)]^1/3 = [ v t_adia]^1/3 ~v^1/5 .
[ 2 - 17 ] with the usual adiabatic - diabatic assumption , these exponents lead to kibble - zurek scaling for a dynamical critical exponent @xmath1 , even though the underlying dynamics is relativistic and non - dissipative . from the above analysis it is clear that this happened because the leading adiabatic correction is provided by the chemical potential term , which multiplies a first order time derivative of the bulk field .
the breakdown of adiabaticity means that an expansion in time derivatives fail . in this subsection
we show , following closely the treatment of @xcite , that we now have a _ different _ small @xmath0 expansion in _ fractional _ powers of @xmath0 during the period when the sources passes through zero . this will lead to a scaling form of the order parameter in the critical region . in the following
we will demonstrate this for the case where @xmath111 near @xmath113 .
however the treatment can be easily generalized to a @xmath114 for any integer @xmath79 . to establish this
, it is convenient to separate out the source term in the field @xmath115 , ( , t ) = ^j(t ) + ( , t ) , = _ - - d/2 , [ 2 - 2 ] where we have used the relation ( [ 1 - 15 ] ) and the fact that near the boundary @xmath116 .
the equation of motion ( [ 1 - 16 ] ) then becomes -_t^2
+ 2i _ t & = & ( ^)j(t ) + + g ( ) + & & + g ( ) + & & + ^ .
[ 2 - 3 ] this separation is useful because we know that in the presence of a constant source @xmath117 , the static solution has the asymptotic form ~^1- + ^+2 , [ 2 - 5 ] which follows from ( [ 1 - 22 ] ) . the scaling relations ( [ 2 - 16 ] ) and ( [ 2 - 17 ] ) suggest that we perform the following rescaling of the time and the field t = v^-2/5 , _ s = v^1/5 .
[ 2 - 18 ] in the critical region we can now use @xmath118 and rewrite ( [ 2 - 3 ] ) as an expansion in powers of @xmath119 , = v^2/5 + o(v^4/5 ) .
[ 2 - 19 ] as noted above , because of the boundary condition at @xmath120 and the regularity condition at @xmath58 the spectrum of @xmath71 is discrete . let @xmath121 be the orthonormal set of eigenfunctions of the operator @xmath71 _ n ( ) = _ n _ n ( ) , n=0,1 , , [ 2 - 20 ] with @xmath122 .
@xmath123 is the zero mode which we discussed earlier .
since @xmath11 has been tuned to be equal to @xmath38 , all the higher eigenvalues are positive .
we now expand ( , ) = _ n _ n ( ) _ n ( ) , [ 2 - 21 ] and rewrite the equation ( [ 2 - 19 ] ) in terms of the modes @xmath124 _ n _ n = v^2/5 + o(v^4/5 ) , [ 2 - 22 ] where we have defined _ n & = & d_n^ ( ) ( ^ ) , + ^n_n_1n_2n_3 & = & d_n^ ( ) _ n_3^ ( ) _ n_2 ( ) _ n_1 ( ) g ( ) .
[ 2 - 23 ] it is clear from ( [ 2 - 22 ] ) that the zero mode part of the bulk field dominates the dynamics in the critical region .
in fact for small @xmath0 a solution is of the form _
n ( ) = _ n0 _ 0 ( ) + v^2/5 _
n + o(v^4/5 ) .
[ 2 - 24 ] the zero mode satisfies a @xmath1 landau - ginsburg equation -2i__0 + ^0_000 |_0|^2 _ 0 + _ 0 = 0 .
[ 2 - 25 ] reverting back to the original variables we therefore have _ s ( , t , v ) = v^1/5 _ s ( , t v^2/5,1 ) , [ 2 - 26 ] which implies a kibble - zurek scaling for the order parameter with @xmath1 ( t , v)= v^1/5 ( v^2/5t,1 ) .
[ 2 - 27 ] note that the effective landau - ginsburg equation ( [ 2 - 25 ] ) is not dissipative because the first order time derivative is multiplied by a purely imaginary constant .
in fact , in the absence of a source term the quantity @xmath125 is independent of time . beyond the critical region , we can not use the approximation @xmath111 and there is no useful simplification in terms of the zero mode .
however , the boundary conditions at the tip are perfectly reflecting boundary conditions ( as appropriate for the origin of polar coordinates in two dimensions ) so that there is a conserved energy in the problem .
this is in contrast to a black hole background where there is a net ingoing flux at the horizon causing the system to be dissipative . indeed in the quench problem considered in @xcite arguments similar to those used in this section also led to an effective landau - ginsburg dynamics with @xmath1 , but which is dissipative . in the appendix
we analyze a landau - ginsburg toy model motivated by the results of this section .
in this section we summarize our numerical results .
we have solved the bulk equation of motion numerically for @xmath50 .
the results for different values of @xmath18 are similar .
we present detailed results for @xmath43 . in this case
the critical value of the chemical potential is @xmath126 .
we discretize the partial differential equations ( pdes ) ( written in the @xmath127-coordinate ) in a radial chebyshev grid to study the numerical problem .
once discretized in radial direction , the pdes become a series of ordinary differential equations ( odes ) in the temporal variable .
the resulting odes are solved with a standard ode solver ( e.g. cvode ) .
the time dependence is chosen to be of the form dependent source as in . in principle one
may study with any kind of time dependent source .
we will consider the problem in two regimes .
the first is the slow " regime where we expect our analytic arguments to be accurate , the other is a fast " regime where there is no adiabatic region whatsoever . in the slow regime
we will try to zoom on the scaling region around the phase transition . in the fast regime
we will find a large deviation from the adiabatic behavior and possible chaotic behavior . since our main interest is quench through the critical point , we concentrate mainly near the phase transition .
we choose @xmath128 , so that the system is critical in the absence of any source . in the presence of a time dependent source of the form ( [ 2 - 1 ] ) we calculate the bulk field @xmath129 and
extract from this the value of @xmath130 of the dual field theory .
a typical plot of the real part of @xmath130 for slow quench through the phase transition is presented in figure [ fig : quench ] . with @xmath131 . ] clearly the late time behavior is oscillatory , reflecting the fact that we are dealing with a closed and non - dissipative system .
we then zoom on the critical region near @xmath76 for various value of @xmath0 to look for any scaling behavior .
one way to look for this is to consider the behavior of @xmath42 at @xmath73 .
equation ( [ 2 - 27 ] ) then predicts a scaling behavior @xmath132 .
figure [ fig : quencho ] shows a plot of @xmath133 for different @xmath0 .
we fit the data points with a function @xmath134 , where @xmath135 is @xmath136 . here
we kept a sublinear ( @xmath137 ) term to understand how the fit function approaches a linear regime . from our analytic argument
we expect @xmath138 .
a fit of the numerical results yields @xmath139 .
changing the number of fit points and range changes the values of fit parameters a bit , however we always get a value of @xmath103 which is close to @xmath140 with only a few percentage deviation .
the imaginary part @xmath141 also satisfies the same scaling . in the fast regime
we see a large deviation from the adiabatic behavior , as shown in figure [ fig : quench2 ] . showing chaotic behavior with a large value of @xmath142 and @xmath143 . ]
the motion in this regime becomes possibly chaotic .
here we have a system with a conserved energy .
once we put some energy in the system , the non - linearity possibly takes the system over the whole phase space ( arnold diffusion ) .
it is expected that if we wait long enough the probe approximation actually breaks down @xcite and we have to consider the fully backreacted problem .
we plan to attack this problem in the near future .
this work is partially supported by national science foundation grants phy-0970069 , phy-0855614 and phy-1214341 .
the work of t.n . was supported in part by the us nsf under grant no.phy-0756966 .
some of these results were presented in the workshop holographic thermalization " at lorentz center , university of leiden , october 8 - 13 , 2012 .
s.r.d . would like to thank m.bhaseen and other participants of the workshop for discussions , and the lorentz center for hospitality .
t.n . is grateful to k.schalm for discussions .
in this appendix , we consider a @xmath144-dimensional toy model which follows the equation 2i+(m^2-^2)+ ||^2 = j(t ) .
[ toy ] the function @xmath32 asymptotes to constants at early and late times and passes through zero in a linear fashion at some intermediate time , e.g. j(t ) = j_0 ( vt ) .
we first derive conditions for breakdown of adiabaticity near the critical point @xmath145 and @xmath146 .
we carry out adiabatic expansion as following : _ t _
t , _ 0 ( j(t))+ _ 1 ( t)+ , where @xmath147 is the ( real ) adiabatic solution given by _ 0(j(t ) ) = [ j(t)]^1/3 .
the solution to @xmath148 is , = _ 0 [ j(t)]+
i + ^2 ( 8 ^ 2(-)- ^2 ) + o(^3 ) . where the breakdown of adiabaticity happens when , & ~ & _ 0 , + ( 8 ^ 2(-)- ^2 ) & ~ & _ 0 , for @xmath149 the above two equations translate into , & ~ & t^5/3 v^2/3 .
thus if @xmath11 is of @xmath150 then the above equations give us , t & ~ & v^2/5 .
now sitting at the critical point we study the behavior of the scaling solution with @xmath151 . from the adiabatic analysis
we expect scaled time , @xmath152 .
+ we write the field @xmath153 as @xmath154 and the source as @xmath155 , where both @xmath156 and @xmath157 go as @xmath158 . to find the scaling exponents we extract the @xmath0 dependencies as , t = v^|t , = v^| , = v^| .
consistency of the equations demand , = - , = , = .
this determines the scaling behavior of the field @xmath153 at @xmath145 and with @xmath11 of @xmath150 as , ( t , v ) = v^1/5 ( v^2/5t,1 ) .
this agrees with our expectation from adiabatic analysis , and also has been confirmed numerically in section 4 . at late times
the source @xmath32 can be treated to be a constant and the solution can be obtained by perturbing around the static solution , @xmath159 .
it is then straightforward to see that the solution @xmath160 is oscillatory with a frequency @xmath161 . for reviews and references
see s. mondal , d. sen and k. sengupta , arxiv:0908.2922 ; j. dziarmaga , arxiv:0912.4034 ; a. polkovnikov , k. sengupta , a .
silva and m. vengalattore , dynamics of closed interacting quantum systems " , arxiv:1007.5331 . p. calabrese and j. l. cardy , j. stat .
mech . * 0504 * ( 2005 ) p010 [ arxiv : cond - mat/0503393 ] ; p. calabrese and j. l. cardy , phys .
* 96 * ( 2006 ) 136801 [ arxiv : cond - mat/0601225 ] p. calabrese and j. cardy , [ arxiv:0704.1880 [ cond-mat.stat-mech ] ] ; s. sotiriadis and j. cardy , j. stat .
( 2008 ) p11003 , [ arxiv:0808.0116 [ cond-mat.stat-mech ] ] ; s. sotiriadis , p. calabrese and j. cardy , epl * 87 * ( 2009 ) 20002 , [ arxiv:0903.0895 [ cond-mat.stat-mech ] ] ; s. sotiriadis and j. cardy , arxiv:1002.0167 [ quant - ph ] .
o. aharony , s. s. gubser , j. m. maldacena , h. ooguri and y. oz , phys . rept .
* 323 * , 183 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9905111 ] .
r. a. janik and r. b. peschanski , phys .
d * 74 * , 046007 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0606149 ] ; r. a. janik , phys .
lett . * 98 * , 022302 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0610144 ] ; p. m. chesler and l. g. yaffe , supersymmetric phys .
lett . *
102 * , 211601 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0812.2053 [ hep - th ] ] ; p. m. chesler , l. g. yaffe , dynamics in n = 4 supersymmetric yang - mills theory , phys .
* d82 * , 026006 ( 2010 ) .
[ arxiv:0906.4426 [ hep - th ] ] ; s. bhattacharyya and s. minwalla , jhep * 0909 * ( 2009 ) 034 [ arxiv:0904.0464 [ hep - th ] ] .
d. garfinkle , l. a. pando zayas , phys .
rev . * d84 * , 066006 ( 2011 ) .
[ arxiv:1106.2339 [ hep - th ] ] . j. abajo - arrastia , j. aparicio , e. lopez , jhep * 1011 * , 149 ( 2010 ) .
[ arxiv:1006.4090 [ hep - th]];h .
ebrahim , m. headrick , [ arxiv:1010.5443 [ hep - th ] ] ; v. balasubramanian , a. bernamonti , j. de boer , n. copland , b. craps , e. keski - vakkuri , b. muller , a. schafer _ et al .
_ , phys .
* 106 * , 191601 ( 2011 ) .
[ arxiv:1012.4753 [ hep - th ] ] ; v. balasubramanian , a. bernamonti , j. de boer , n. copland , b. craps , e. keski - vakkuri , b. muller , a. schafer _ et al .
_ , phys .
rev . * d84 * , 026010 ( 2011 ) .
[ arxiv:1103.2683 [ hep - th ] ] ; e. caceres and a. kundu , jhep * 1209 * , 055 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1205.2354 [ hep - th ] ] ; d. galante and m. schvellinger , jhep * 1207 * , 096 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1205.1548 [ hep - th ] ] .
t. albash , c. v. johnson , electromagnetic quenches , new j. phys .
* 13 * , 045017 ( 2011 ) .
[ arxiv:1008.3027 [ hep - th ] ] ; t. takayanagi , t. ugajin , coarse - graining , jhep * 1011 * , 054 ( 2010 ) . [ arxiv:1008.3439 [ hep - th ] ] ; c. t. asplund , s. g. avery , [ arxiv:1108.2510 [ hep - th ] ] . a. obannon , arxiv:0808.1115 [ hep - th ] .
k. hashimoto , n. iizuka , t. oka , [ arxiv:1012.4463 [ hep - th ] ] ; k. -y .
kim , j. p. shock , j. tarrio , jhep * 1106 * , 017 ( 2011 ) .
[ arxiv:1103.4581 [ hep - th ] ] ; s. prem kumar , phys . rev .
* d84 * , 026003 ( 2011 ) .
[ arxiv:1104.1405 [ hep - th ] ] .
s. janiszewski , a. karch , [ arxiv:1106.4010 [ hep - th ] ] ; c. hoyos , t. nishioka , a. obannon , [ arxiv:1106.4030 [ hep - th ] ] .
s. a. hartnoll , c. p. herzog , g. t. horowitz , jhep * 0812 * , 015 ( 2008 ) .
[ arxiv:0810.1563 [ hep - th ] ] ; s. a. hartnoll , c. p. herzog , g. t. horowitz , phys .
* 101 * , 031601 ( 2008 ) .
[ arxiv:0803.3295 [ hep - th ] ] .
t. nishioka , s. ryu and t. takayanagi , jhep * 1003 * , 131 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:0911.0962 [ hep - th ] ] . k. murata , s. kinoshita and n. tanahashi , jhep * 1007 * , 050 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1005.0633 [ hep - th ] ] ; m. j. bhaseen , j. p. gauntlett , b. d. simons , j. sonner and t. wiseman , arxiv:1207.4194 [ hep - th ] ; p. bizon and a. rostworowski , phys . rev
. lett . * 107 * , 031102 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1104.3702 [ gr - qc ] ] ; o. j. c. dias , g. t. horowitz , d. marolf and j. e. santos , class .
* 29 * , 235019 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1208.5772 [ gr - qc ] ] . | we study quantum quench in a holographic model of a zero temperature insulator - superfluid transition .
the model is a modification of that of arxiv:0911.0962 and involves a self - coupled complex scalar field , einstein gravity with a negative cosmological constant , and maxwell field with one of the spatial directions compact . in a suitable regime of parameters ,
the scalar field can be treated as a probe field whose backreaction to both the metric and the gauge field can be ignored .
we show that when the chemical potential of the dual field theory lies between two critical values , the equilibrium background geometry is a ads soliton with a constant gauge field , while the complex scalar condenses leading to broken symmetry .
we then turn on a time dependent source for the order parameter which interpolates between constant values and crosses the order - disorder critical point . in the critical region adiabaticity
breaks down , but for a small rate of change of the source @xmath0 there is a new small-@xmath0 expansion in fractional powers of @xmath0 .
the resulting critical dynamics is dominated by a zero mode of the bulk field .
to lowest order in this small-@xmath0 expansion , the order parameter satisfies a time dependent landau - ginsburg equation which has @xmath1 , but non - dissipative .
these predictions are verified by explicit numerical solutions of the bulk equations of motion . uk/12 - 12 + pupt-2431 + * quantum quench across a zero temperature holographic superfluid transition * + pallab basu@xmath2 , diptarka das @xmath2 , sumit r. das @xmath2 and tatsuma nishioka @xmath3 @xmath2 _ department of physics and astronomy , + university of kentucky , lexington , ky 40506 , usa
_ + @xmath3_department of physics , + princeton university , princeton , nj 08564 , usa _ |
it is now well - established that a two - dimensional electron gas ( 2deg ) can exist at the interface between perovskite oxides laalo@xmath0 ( lao ) and srtio@xmath0 ( sto ) @xcite .
the 2deg is nominally similar to those in semiconductor heterostructures , but supports additional phases , such as superconductivity and magnetism , which are not observed in conventional 2d electron systems , and which have great fundamental and technological interest @xcite .
the mechanism of formation of this oxide 2deg , however , is not established , and although there is a general consensus that the charge carriers occupy sto conduction bands modified by the presence of the interface @xcite , the origin and density of the 2d carriers , and the details of the electronic bandstructure at the interface are not yet fully understood .
three main scenarios have emerged as the possible source of conduction electrons : electronic reconstruction , where a build - up of electric potential across the polar lao layers is avoided by charge transfer from lao to sto @xcite ; donation of electrons by oxygen vacancies in the heterostructure @xcite ; and cationic intermixing and disorder across the interface @xcite .
the relative contributions of these mechanisms seem to be determined by factors such as the sample growth conditions , the lao layer thickness , and the overall integrity of the crystal structure .
electronic reconstruction is widely proposed to be the dominant mechanism in _ intrinsic _ samples , where defects , impurities and disorder are minimised , but experiments have identified a number of inconsistencies in this simple picture @xcite , and the origin of the conduction electrons and the nature of their confinement at the interface are still unresolved questions .
quantum oscillations in the transport ( or thermodynamic ) properties of metallic and semiconducting materials arise directly from the magnetic field dependence of the conduction electron energies , and are , therefore , a powerful experimental probe of the electronic bandstructure close to the fermi energy @xcite .
they also provide band - specific details of conduction electron properties such as effective mass and mobility .
access to this information in lao / sto is highly desirable , as the bandstructure of the 2deg can be expected to reflect the mechanism of its formation , as well as giving further insight into its behaviour .
previous quantum oscillation experiments on lao / sto @xcite measured the shubnikov - de haas ( sdh ) effect in the resistivity , and could clearly resolve only a single oscillation frequency corresponding to a single conduction band with high mobility charge carriers . in samples with high carrier density ( of order @xmath4 @xmath5 ) @xcite the oscillations were independent of the magnetic field direction , and indicated a three - dimensional fermi surface containing all of the charge carriers .
these samples were grown under conditions of low oxygen partial pressure ( @xmath6 mbar ) , and the high carrier density and mobility were believed to arise from uniform doping of the sto substrate by oxygen vacancies . in references 19 and 20 , measurements were carried out on samples grown or annealed under higher oxygen pressures , with carrier densities of the order of @xmath7 @xmath5 , thought to be characteristic of intrinsic samples with few or no oxygen vacancies .
these groups report slightly different values for the sdh frequency but , in both cases , the observed conduction band is two - dimensional , with very low carrier density compared to the total carrier density extracted from the hall effect ( of order 20@xmath8 ) .
these results raised interesting questions about the presence of conduction channels which do not contribute to the sdh effect , or the possibility of multiple valley and spin degeneracies @xcite , and suggested that the lao / sto conduction - bandstructure is considerably more complex than implied by the single observed sdh frequency .
a complex bandstructure is also predicted by density - functional calculations , which give a large number of subbands , with quite different carrier properties , crossing the fermi energy @xcite . in this work
, we present a detailed magnetotransport investigation of lao / sto - based heterostructures , as a function of temperature and in a range of magnetic field orientations , from perpendicular to parallel to the oxide layers . by using very high magnetic fields and high - mobility 2degs ,
we have been able to measure shubnikov - de haas oscillations with significantly better resolution than previously possible , and have identified and characterised several 2d conduction subbands .
the subbands are separated by a few millielectronvolts , and have different effective masses and mobilities .
we find a total carrier density of @xmath9 @xmath5 contributing to the sdh effect .
we have measured three heterostructures ( labelled s1 , s2 and s3 ) , with the same basic structure , but differing slightly in the number of lao layers or in the oxygen partial pressure during growth .
the samples were grown by pulsed laser deposition , with ten ( s1 , s3 ) or nine ( s2 ) monolayers of lao deposited on a tio@xmath10-terminated sto(001 ) substrate .
a single monolayer of srcuo@xmath10 ( sco ) and two monolayers of sto were grown as capping layers on top of the lao , as illustrated in fig .
[ data](d ) .
oxygen partial pressure of @xmath11 mbar was used during lao growth for s1 and s2 , and this was reduced to @xmath12 mbar for s3 .
full details of the growth procedure and parameters are given as supplementary information .
the role of the sco layer is , at present , not fully understood , but we find that it considerably increases the mobility of the lao / sto interface ( compared to samples prepared in an identical way , but without sco ) @xcite .
we find no evidence of a conducting channel at isolated sco / lao or sco / sto interfaces , and assume that the single monolayer of sco in our heterostructures does not contribute directly to the conductivity by supporting an additional 2deg .
rather , the sco layer is thought to indirectly enhance the mean free path of mobile electrons at the lao / sto interface by somehow reducing the density of defect donor states in the structure .
a detailed investigation of the effect of the sco layer is presented elsewhere @xcite .
our samples had dimensions of 5 mm @xmath13 5 mm in the @xmath14 plane , with electrical contacts made by wire bonding through the top surface in a van der pauw geometry .
resistance was measured using a standard ac technique with excitation currents of 1 or 2 @xmath15a .
experiments were carried out in a dilution refrigerator and a pumped @xmath16he system with a rotatable sample stage . in samples
s1 , s2 and s3 .
( a)(c)(ii ) : the oscillations in ( i ) with background removed .
an example of the background subtracted in each case is shown as a dashed line in the insets .
( c)(iii ) : hall effect of sample s3 .
the inset shows the quantum oscillations after subtraction of the linear background .
( d ) : sketch of the sto / sco / lao / sto structure . ] fig .
[ data](a)(i)(c)(i ) shows the longitudinal magnetoresistance @xmath17 of our samples at various temperatures , for magnetic fields aligned perpendicular to the @xmath14 plane .
clear oscillations with strongly temperature - dependent amplitudes are apparent in each case .
the complex periodicities indicate that several frequencies are superposed .
[ data](a)(ii)(c)(ii ) show the same data as in ( i ) , but with a smooth background removed .
an example of the background subtracted for each sample is shown as a dashed line in the insets of these figures .
the hall effect @xmath18 of each sample showed quantum oscillations similar to those in @xmath17 , on a large , approximately linear background .
[ data](c)(iii ) shows data from s3 .
apart from the oscillation amplitudes , @xmath18 is independent of temperature . by performing all measurements with both positive and negative magnetic field polarities ,
we exclude the possibility that the oscillatory hall effect arises from an admixture of @xmath17 in @xmath18 , or vice versa .
observable quantum oscillations in the hall effect are relatively unusual , but arise from the same landau level - related phenomena as sdh oscillations in @xmath17 @xcite .
previous observations of this effect have been well documented , for example , in semi - metals @xcite and , recently , as the first confirmed example of quantum oscillations in the high temperature cuprate superconductors @xcite . between the magnetic field direction and the normal to the interface
is shown beside each of the curves .
( a ) sdh oscillations at different tilt angles for sample s2 , ( b ) sdh oscillations for sample s2 up to @xmath19 ( from ( a ) ) , as a function of the perpendicular field component @xmath20 .
( c ) sdh oscillations at different tilt angles for sample s3 .
the curves are offset vertically for clarity . ]
[ angle_data ] shows the dependence of @xmath17 on the angle @xmath21 between the magnetic field direction and the @xmath22-axis of the sample for s2 and s3 ( data as a function of magnetic field orientation are not available for s1 ) .
the oscillations are rapidly suppressed , with a change in periodicity , as the magnetic field is tilted away from 0@xmath23 . over the wider range of angles measured for s2 ,
we see the background magnetoresistance change from positive to negative , and observe the development of a pronounced feature in parallel field ( @xmath24 ) at @xmath25 t.
we first focus on analysis of the sdh oscillations in @xmath17 at @xmath26 , as shown in fig .
these oscillations have amplitudes of the order of 10% of the total resistance , which suggests that landau levels are not fully resolved in these systems , i.e. there is considerable overlap of levels .
in this situation , sdh oscillations are sinusoidal in inverse magnetic field @xmath27 , and are described by the general expression @xcite @xmath28 where @xmath29 is temperature , and @xmath30 and @xmath31 are the frequency and phase of the oscillations ; @xmath32 is the harmonic number .
the amplitude factors contain the term @xmath33 , and allow the effective mass @xmath34 , and dingle temperature @xmath35 of the charge carriers to be extracted from the temperature and magnetic field dependence of the signal @xcite .
@xmath35 is a measure of the quantum mobility @xmath15 , and can be expressed as @xmath36 . in units of @xmath1 .
the solid lines are fits to @xmath37 .
some of the data are rescaled so that all the data for each sample can be shown clearly on a single plot .
[ analysis ] ] to analyse the @xmath17 data in fig .
[ data ] , we subtracted a smoothly varying background from each of the curves to obtain @xmath38 , as shown , and performed fourier transforms ( fts ) in the inverse magnetic field .
[ analysis](a)(c ) gives the resulting fourier spectra for the three samples , and shows that five peaks are visible in the ft for s1 and s3 , and four for s2 , corresponding to five or four distinct oscillation frequencies in the sdh signals .
the very low frequency oscillations , resolved as ft peaks at 7 t or 8 t , may be subject to some uncertainty due to the difficulty of achieving perfect background subtraction .
however , in all three samples , the background has very weak or negligible temperature dependence , compared to the strong temperature dependence of the amplitude of the 7 or 8 t peak , and none of the background curves we subtracted show any periodic component .
we therefore treat the lowest frequency ft peak as a genuine component of the sdh signal in our samples . in the absence of harmonic content , which we will discuss below
, the ft results indicate that five ( s1 , s3 ) or four ( s2 ) high mobility conduction subbands contribute to the quantum transport in our samples .
the observation of only four subbands for sample s2 may be a result of lower resolution in the ft due to the smaller magnetic field range of the measurement ( 0 - 20 t for s2 , compared to 0 - 30 t for s1 and s3 ) , or may be related to the slightly different structure of s2 , which has one fewer lao layers than s1 and s3 . by fitting the temperature dependence of the ft peak amplitudes to @xmath37 , we extracted the carrier effective mass in each case ( see fig .
[ analysis](d)(f ) ) .
fts were taken over several magnetic field ranges for each sample , and the effective mass extracted for each range .
the masses quoted in fig .
[ analysis](d)(f ) are the mean values of @xmath34 resulting from this procedure . in all cases ,
the experimental temperature dependence is well - described by the theoretical curves , and the errors given reflect the spread in the values of @xmath34 over the full field range , rather than the quality of the fits .
if the sdh signal contains harmonics of a given oscillation , both the measured frequencies _ and _ the temperature dependence ( we actually extract @xmath39 from the fits of @xmath37 ) should scale with the harmonic number @xmath32 .
this is not the case for any of the oscillations we observe in our samples , and we conclude that the peaks in the fts correspond to fundamental frequencies , implying independent conduction channels .
the frequencies and effective masses obtained from our analysis of the sdh oscillations are summarised in the first two columns of table [ table ] .
we note that analysis of both the conductivity , calculated as @xmath40 , and the oscillations in @xmath18 , gave the same results as analysis of @xmath17 for a given sample , within the experimental errors .
0.8[b]@lccccc sample & @xmath34&@xmath41 & @xmath42 & @xmath35 & @xmath15 + & ( @xmath1 ) & ( 10@xmath43@xmath5 ) & ( mev ) & ( k ) & ( @xmath3/vs ) + s1 & & & & + @xmath44 = 88 t & 1.5(2 ) & @xmath45 & 6.9 & 3.55 & 401 + @xmath46 = 63 t & 1.2(2 ) & @xmath47 & 6.0 & 2.50 & 713 + @xmath48 = 39 t & 1.7(1 ) & @xmath49 & 2.7 & 0.40 & 3144 + @xmath50 = 21 t & 2.0(2 ) & @xmath51 & 1.2 & 0.38 & 2813 + @xmath52 = 7 t & 2.0(1 ) & @xmath53 & 0.4 & - & - * + [ 0.5ex ] s2 & & & & & + @xmath44 = 83 t & 2.0(3 ) & @xmath54 & 4.8 & 1.86 & 558 + @xmath46 = 36 t & 0.9(1 ) & @xmath55 & 4.5 & 2.19 & 1085 + @xmath48 = 20 t & 0.9(1 ) & @xmath51 & 2.6 & 0.92 & 2609 + @xmath50 = 8 t & 0.9(1 ) & @xmath56 & 1.0 & 2.80 & 821 + s3 & & & & & + @xmath44 = 79 t & 2.6(2 ) & @xmath57 & 3.5 & - & - + @xmath46 = 65 t & 2.5(2 ) & @xmath58 & 3.0 & - & - + @xmath48 = 44 t & 2.8(2 ) & @xmath59 & 2.9 & - & - + @xmath50 = 26 t & 1.8(2 ) & @xmath60 & 1.7 & - & - + @xmath52 = 8 t & 1.9(2 ) & @xmath56 & 0.5 & - & - + [ table ] ) to @xmath38 for ( a ) s1 and ( b ) s2 , using @xmath61 and @xmath62 from the fourier transforms .
the grey points show the measured data , and the solid lines represent the fits .
[ lk_fits ] ] as a check of our fourier analysis , we attempted to directly fit the oscillatory magnetoresistance with expression ( [ lk ] ) using the frequencies and values of @xmath62 extracted from the fts .
@xmath63 , @xmath64 and an overall field - independent amplitude were used as fit parameters .
the fits for s1 and s2 are shown in fig .
[ lk_fits ] .
although the fits are not perfect at very low field , they reproduce the data rather well , and suggest that the results of the ft are reliable .
we can also use these fits of expression ( [ lk ] ) to extract @xmath65 , and hence calculate approximate values of @xmath15 for each of the subbands in s1 and s2 .
these results are given in the final two columns of table [ table ] .
we emphasise that the values of @xmath65 and @xmath66 are approximate , but they clearly show that the mobilities are different for different subbands .
moreover , the highest values of @xmath66 in each sample are in keeping with the magnetic field of @xmath67 5 t at which the quantum oscillations begin to appear .
( this onset field depends broadly on the ratio of landau level width to cyclotron energy , and is inversely proportional to the mobility of the carriers in the relevant subband . )
although reasonable fits of expression ( [ lk ] ) could be obtained for s1 and s2 , it was not possible to achieve even a moderately good fit to @xmath38 for s3 , and we were therefore unable to extract values for @xmath65 and @xmath66 .
sdh oscillations in s3 start to become resolvable just below 2 t , which indicates that the mobility of at least one subband in this sample must be considerably higher than in s1 or s2 . in the limit of well - resolved landau levels , with little or no overlap between neighbouring levels , sdh oscillations are still periodic in @xmath27 but are no longer sinusoidal , and the lk expression ( [ lk ] ) ceases to be valid .
it is therefore possible that the failure of ( [ lk ] ) for s3 is related to the higher mobility of carriers in this sample . as a brief comment on the possible contribution of spin - splitting to the sdh signals in our lao / sto samples , we note that for the usual , field - linear zeeman splitting of the fermi surface , quantum oscillations can only provide information about spin - splitting and the @xmath68-factor of a system in certain specific circumstances
: when so - called spin - zeroes are observed ; when the _ absolute _ oscillation amplitudes are accurately known ; or when the signals contain significant harmonic content @xcite .
none of these circumstances apply in our measurements , and we are not aware of any evidence of non - linear splitting of the fermi surface in lao / sto . we therefore conclude that spin - splitting does not contribute in a resolvable way to the sdh signals we observe , so that , even though the zeeman effect may be relatively large , we can not extract information about the @xmath68-factor in our samples .
we now consider the magnetotransport in tilted magnetic fields .
[ angle_data](a ) shows @xmath17 for sample s2 as the magnetic field orientation is rotated from perpendicular to parallel to the plane of the lao / sto interface .
the suppression of the sdh oscillations as @xmath21 is increased shows that the conduction electrons are confined to the interface plane , such that quantum oscillations are generated only by the perpendicular component of the applied field . in the case of a single occupied subband , landau level separation , and hence the period of the sdh oscillations , would be expected to scale with @xmath69 .
when multiple 2d subbands are occupied , however , mixing of landau quantisation with the confinement potential leads to anti - crossings of discrete levels from different subbands as the field is tilted @xcite .
landau level energies therefore show a complicated magnetic field dependence , which progressively modifies the periodicity of sdh oscillations as a function of @xmath21 . the data in fig .
[ angle_data](a ) show just this behaviour , which can be clearly seen as a function of the perpendicular field component in fig .
[ angle_data](b ) , and confirm both the two - dimensionality of the electron system and the contribution to transport of multiple occupied subbands .
we do not have data in tilted magnetic fields for sample s1 , but data for s3 ( fig .
[ angle_data](c ) ) show the same 2d , multi - subband behaviour .
it can be further seen from fig .
[ angle_data](a ) that , as @xmath21 is increased towards @xmath70 , the magnetoresistance of sample s2 becomes strongly negative and develops a significant drop at @xmath25 t. similar behaviour in multi - subband semiconductor 2degs is attributed to a decreasing contribution of inter - subband scattering to the total resistance , as the parallel field component @xmath71 shifts the size confinement energies and depopulates the higher subbands .
the so - called _ diamagnetic shift _ is given by @xmath72 where the final term is the square of the spread of the electron wavefunction in the confinement direction for the @xmath73 subband @xcite .
when the highest occupied subband is shifted across the fermi energy , it depopulates completely and becomes unavailable to scattering processes , leading to a plateau and subsequent drop in @xmath17 @xcite . in order to estimate the diamagnetic shifts expected in sample s2 , we have used a very simple model of a uniform triangular confining potential at the interface .
the similar masses measured for the three highest subbands in s2 suggest that they are split from the same conduction band , and , based on their energy spacing , we calculate an approximate value of @xmath74 v / for the electric field confining the charge carriers in these three highest subbands .
( the details of this calculation are given in the supplementary information . )
the consequent energy shift would cause the highest subband to empty completely at @xmath75 t , which is quite close to the drop in resistance we observe at @xmath76 t , and supports a description of the magnetoresistance in terms of reduction of inter - subband scattering and depopulation of the highest subband as @xmath71 is increased .
this suggests a very close analogy between the behaviour of the lao / sto 2deg and that of multi - subband semiconductor 2degs .
a significant implication of this observation is that reducing the number of occupied subbands by other techniques , for example , via electric field control of the carrier density , should also lead to reduced inter - subband scattering and thus to higher mobility samples . for a 2-dimensional electron system with parabolic conduction bands and circular fermi surface sections ,
the frequency @xmath61 of quantum oscillations is proportional to the carrier density in a given subband @xmath77 , where @xmath78 and @xmath79 are valley and spin degeneracy , respectively .
we use this relation , assuming a single valley and twofold spin degeneracy , to calculate the carrier density for each of the subbands we have measured .
we also use the corresponding 2d density of states to calculate the energies of the subband edges relative to the fermi energy , @xmath80 .
these values are given in columns 3 and 4 of table [ table ] .
the total carrier density contributing to the sdh effect is similar for all three samples : @xmath81@xmath5 .
this is considerably higher than @xmath82 measured previously in lao / sto @xcite , and is close to the saturation density generally observed in conducting samples believed to be free from extrinsic carriers @xcite .
we can not , however , straightforwardly extract values for the total carrier densities from our hall effect data for comparison , as the hall coefficient is necessarily a combination of contributions from multiple subbands with different mobilities , and must also comprise the effects of inter - subband scattering @xcite .
naive calculations of @xmath18 based only on @xmath83 and @xmath66 extracted from our sdh results show poor agreement with the experimental hall data ( see supplementary information ) . ]
[ subbands ] shows the subband energies @xmath84 versus density of states for each of our samples .
the most striking aspect of these subband structures is the small energy scale involved .
the lowest subband edge is only a few millielectronvolts below the fermi energy in each sample , and the separation of the subbands is mostly @xmath85 mev or less .
we emphasise the observation of this small energy scale , as bandstructure calculations predict energies of at least an order of magnitude larger , in the range of tens to hundreds of mev , for the occupied conduction subbands in lao / sto @xcite .
the calculated bandstructures assume that a full electronic reconstruction takes place at the interface , with the transfer from lao to sto of 0.5 electrons per 2-dimensional unit cell @xcite .
the large discrepancy between our measurement and calculated subband energies raises questions about both the predicted evolution of the conduction bandstructure , and the total carrier density possible in the 2deg . although previous measurements on lao / sto could clearly resolve only a single sdh frequency @xcite , and so were unable to provide any information about the overall subband structure , sdh experiments on @xmath86-doped sto @xcite reveal frequencies and effective masses in a similar range to those we observe in lao / sto , and imply a similar energy scale for the subband structure .
the subbands in electric - field - induced sto 2degs @xcite were also found to be only a few mev below the fermi energy for carrier densities close to @xmath87 @xmath5 .
2degs on the cleaved surface of sto , however , studied by angle - resolved photoemission ( arpes ) experiments , have subband structures with band edges 100200 mev below the fermi energy and energy splitting of order tens to 100 mev @xcite , perhaps suggesting a different character of the 2deg in these surface systems .
we note that the subband energies we observe in lao / sto are at the limits of resolution for arpes and related experiments , and may shed light on the failure , so far , to resolve the bandstructure at the lao / sto interface using these techniques . the relatively weak confining potential implied by the small subband energies
may also be reflected in the lower than expected core - level shifts observed in photoemission studies @xcite .
[ subbands ] and the results summarised in table [ table ] show that there are small differences in both the bandstructure and the properties of the charge carriers between our three samples .
we attribute this primarily to the differences in structure and growth conditions for each of the samples ( see supplementary information ) , as varying the amount of lao in the heterostructure , or the oxygen pressure during growth , has been shown to modify the properties of the 2deg in several ways @xcite .
of particular relevance to this work is that the number of lao layers deposited and the density of defects such as oxygen vacancies affect the electric field which builds up across the polar lao , and can thus be expected to directly affect the conduction band energies at the interface @xcite .
the different effective masses we observe in a given sample are suggestive of subbands with different orbital character .
the conduction bandstructure of bulk sto consists of three degenerate bands with minima at the gamma - point of the brillouin zone , arising from the ti 3@xmath88 , @xmath89 and @xmath90 orbitals .
the degeneracy of these bulk bands is lifted by a low temperature structural transition and by spin - orbit coupling @xcite , and further splitting into 2d subbands is expected with the introduction of the lao interface and associated confinement potential .
the @xmath91-derived subbands are symmetric in the interface plane and give circular fermi surfaces with light masses , whereas the @xmath92 subbands are expected to be weakly dispersing along one of the in - plane directions , and should lead to elliptical fermi surfaces and heavy effective masses @xcite .
arpes results on sto surface 2degs have yielded values of @xmath93 and 1020 @xmath1 for the light and heavy masses , respectively @xcite .
the masses we observe , however , are in a small range from @xmath67 13 @xmath1 , and suggest that in lao / sto we measure carriers in hybridised subbands , with mixed orbital character and masses intermediate between light and heavy
. the differences between masses in different subbands should thus reflect the degree of hybridisation , and can be expected to depend sensitively on factors such as the detailed bandstructure and the spin - orbit coupling in a particular sample .
even though we have measured three slightly different samples , the overall consistency of the picture we extract from our sdh results is notable . the number of subbands and the values of the sdh frequencies are very similar for the three samples , indicating similar fermi surfaces as well as a comparable total carrier density in each case .
the effective masses fall within a small range between @xmath67 1 and 3 @xmath1 , and , in all samples , the energy gaps between subbands are a few mev or less , with the lowest occupied subband less than @xmath67 7 mev below the fermi energy .
the general continuity of our results , despite the differences in sample structure and growth conditions , suggests that we are probing the instrinsic electronic behaviour of these lao / sto 2degs . by revealing the detailed conduction bandstructure and the properties of the high mobility charge carriers ,
the results we have presented provide an opportunity to considerably advance our understanding of the formation and behaviour of this 2-dimensional electron system , and strongly motivate further related experimental and theoretical studies .
we have shown that multiple 2d subbands , with different effective masses and mobilities , are responsible for conduction in the lao / sto 2deg .
we observed sdh oscillations consistent with those in previous work @xcite , but have resolved and characterised several additional subbands and a correspondingly higher density of carriers contributing to quantum transport .
this has allowed us to calculate the energies of successive subband edges , and reveals an energy scale more than an order of magnitude smaller than predicted by bandstructure calculations . in tilted magnetic fields we find evidence of significant inter - subband scattering modified by a diamagnetic shift of the subband energies .
this observation strengthens the analogy between lao / sto and the behaviour of semiconductor 2degs , and suggests that reducing the number of occupied subbands may be a route to even higher mobility 2degs in this oxide system .
this work has been supported by the stichting fundamenteel onderzoek der materie ( fom ) with financial support from the nederlandse organisatie voor wetenschappelijk onderzoek ( nwo ) .
amc acknowledges support from a marie curie iif grant .
10 santander - syro a f , copie o , kondo t , fortuna f , pailhs s , weht r , qiu x g , bertran f , nicolaou a , taleb - ibrahimi a , fvre p l le , herranz g , bibes m , reyren n , apertet y , lecoeur p , barthlmy a , and rozenberg m j 2011 _ nature _ * 469 * 189 . publishers , 1976 ) .
+ @xmath135 $ ] e zaremba , phys .
b * 45 * , 14143 ( 1992 ) .
+ @xmath136 $ ] w beinvogl , a kamgar and j f koch , phys .
b * 14 * , 4274 ( 1976 )
. + @xmath137 $ ] j c portal , r j nicholas , m a brummell , a y cho , k y cheng and t p pearsall , ( 1983 ) .
+ @xmath139 $ ] f stern , phys .
b * 5 * , 4891 ( 1972 ) .
+ @xmath140 $ ] t ando , a b fowler , and f stern , rev .
phys . * 54 * , 437 ( 1982 ) .
+ @xmath141 $ ] b gregory , j arthur , and g seidel , phys .
b * 14 * , 4274 ( 1976 ) .
+ @xmath142 $ ] n reyren , s thiel , a d caviglia , l fitting kourkoutis , g hammerl , c richter ,
the srtio@xmath0/srcuo@xmath10/laalo@xmath0/srtio@xmath0 heterostructures used in our study were grown by pulsed laser deposition , with the growth process monitored _ in situ _ by reflection high energy electron diffraction ( rheed ) .
laalo@xmath0 was deposited on a tio@xmath10-terminated single crystal srtio@xmath0(001 ) substrate at 850 @xmath94c in an oxygen environment .
either the oxygen pressure during growth , or the number of laalo@xmath0 layers was varied slightly between samples , as follows : + + + + + the sample was cooled from 850 @xmath94c to 600 @xmath94c in the laalo@xmath0 growth pressure at a rate of 50 @xmath94c / min , and a single monolayer of srcuo@xmath10 and two monolayers of srtio@xmath0 were then deposited at 600 @xmath94c in @xmath95 mbar of oxygen for all samples .
this part of the growth procedure also acts as an annealing step for the laalo@xmath0 .
the fluence of the laser pulses was 1.3 j/@xmath3 , the spot size was 1.76 mm@xmath96 and the repetition rate was 1 hz . the target - substrate distance was 50 mm .
after growth , the samples were slowly cooled to room temperature in @xmath95 mbar oxygen at a rate of 10 @xmath94c / min .
in figure 1 we show hall effect data ( solid lines ) from all three samples . as described in the main paper , the hall effect shows quantum oscillations , but is otherwise temperature independent and approximately linear in magnetic field - there is a slight change of slope between 3 t and 5 t in samples s1 and s2 . the dotted lines in ( a ) and ( b )
show the expected hall effect for s1 and s2 calculated using the multiband model ( 1 ) and the mobilities and carrier densities for these samples extracted from the quantum oscillations .
( @xmath97 for s1 is estimated , see text . ) using the relaxation - time approximation to the boltzmann transport equation , it is straightforward to derive the hall effect expected in a multi - subband system [ s1 ] , which can be expressed in terms of the carrier densities and mobilities of each subband as follows : @xmath98 the multiband hall effect has , in general , a complicated dependence on the applied magnetic field , but reduces to a more familiar linear field dependence in the extreme low field / low mobility or high field / high mobility limits : + @xmath99 @xmath100 we note that @xmath101 , where @xmath102 is the cyclotron frequency , and @xmath103 is the time between scattering events , or relaxation time , in a given subband .
the wide magnetic field range in our measurements means that the full expression ( 1 ) for @xmath18 should be the relevant one . in figures 1(a ) and ( b ) we show , as dotted lines , @xmath18 calculated using this expression with @xmath66 and @xmath83 extracted from the sdh data for s1 and s2 ( main paper , table 1 ) .
@xmath97 for s1 is not available from our measurements , but is estimated as 1000 @xmath3/v s. due to the low carrier density in this subband , the value of @xmath97 has a very weak influence on the shape of the curve . for sample s3 , we do not have values for @xmath66 but we can estimate the behaviour in the high field limit based on expression ( 3 ) .
this gives a high field hall coefficient @xmath104 m@xmath16/c , where @xmath105 , and the @xmath83 for s3 are given in table 1 of the main paper .
the slope of the experimental hall signal for s3 , shown in figure 1(c ) , is considerably _ steeper _ , at @xmath106 m@xmath16/c .
the discrepancies between the calculated and experimental curves suggest that effects such as inter - subband scattering [ s2 ] , or the presence of additional occupied subbands which do not contribute to the sdh effect , may need to be taken into account in any description of the hall effect in this system .
it is clear from expression ( 1 ) that an oscillatory hall coefficient can be expected in a system with multi - band transport , where one or more of the bands have an oscillatory conductivity ( mobility ) .
the oscillatory hall effect therefore has the same origin as the sdh effect in @xmath17 .
as can be seen from figure 1 , the oscillations we observe in our samples are very small compared to the large non - oscillatory hall signal ( of order 1% or less ) , but their amplitudes are comparable to the amplitudes of the oscillations in @xmath17 for each sample .
for sample s2 in tilted magnetic fields , we observe a strong negative magnetoresistance which develops a plateau and downward step for @xmath76 t ( see fig . 2 of the main paper ) .
this behaviour typically indicates the reduction of inter - subband scattering and depopulation of the highest subband due to diamagnetic shift of the subband energies in a magnetic field parallel to the 2deg [ s3 , s4 , s5 ] . the diamagnetic shift expected for electrons in the @xmath73 subband
is given by @xmath107 which is expression ( 2 ) in the main paper .
@xmath108 is the square of the spread of the electron wavefunction in the @xmath22-direction . in order to try and quantify this effect in our sample
, we have constructed a very simple model of the confinement at the interface based on a band model of 2d electrons which are free in the @xmath14-plane and confined in the @xmath22-direction , in analogy to the well - known situation in semiconductor heterostructures .
the three highest subbands in s2 have similar effective masses of @xmath109 ( table 1 , main paper ) , which suggests that they are split from the same bulk conduction band due to confinement at the interface .
the energy spacing we have measured for these subbands implies a triangular confining potential @xmath110 , where @xmath111 is the electric field at the interface .
the wavefunctions in a triangular potential are airy functions and their solutions are well known to be @xmath112 [ s6 , s7 ] , with eigenvalues @xmath113 these wavefunctions and eigenvalues depend on @xmath114 , rather than the in - plane effective mass @xmath115 that we extract from our sdh data . the lightest charge carriers in lao / sto ( and in bulk sto ) are expected to occupy conduction bands with @xmath91 symmetry and @xmath116 .
we do not have values of @xmath114 for our samples , and therefore use a ratio of @xmath117 , based on sdh results in bulk ( nb doped ) sto [ s8 ] .
although the lowest subband in s2 has a heavier effective mass of @xmath118 , this is still relatively light , and we assume that this subband also has predominantly @xmath14 character . for convenience ,
we label the subbands ( @xmath119 ) ( for @xmath120 ) and ( @xmath121 ) ( for @xmath122 ) . using the energy spacing of the three ( @xmath119 )
subbands ( column 4 of table 1 in the main paper ) , and assuming @xmath123 and @xmath124 , we calculate a value of @xmath125 v / for s2 . the potential well structure described by this model is shown in figure 2(b ) , including sketches of the wavefunction for each subband .
we emphasise that this model is approximate , but comparison with figure 2(a ) , which shows the measured subband structure for s2 ( taken from fig . 5 in the main paper )
, shows that it reproduces the overall spacing of the subbands rather well .
taking the average values @xmath126 and @xmath127 [ s6 , s7 ] , we then calculate the diamagnetic shifts expected for each of the subbands , based on the potential well in figure 2(b ) .
figure 2(c ) gives the resulting subband energies as a function of magnetic field parallel to the interface , and shows that the highest subband is expected to empty completely at @xmath128 t. the value of @xmath129 t is in quite good agreement with the drop in magnetoresistance we observe in sample s2 at @xmath76 t ( fig .
2(a ) , main paper ) , and supports an explanation of this feature as arising from depopulation of the highest subband . in the triangular potential shown in figure 2(b ) , the @xmath130 1 , 2 subbands with @xmath131 would also be expected .
these are not observed , but lower mobilities for the slightly heavier carriers may explain their absence , as these carriers would then contribute only weakly , or not at all , to the sdh oscillations .
the presence of these subbands would not significantly affect our estimate of @xmath132 , only shifting it to slightly lower field .
the model potential well in figure 2(b ) also provides an estimate of the thickness of the electron gas , and we show the average distance of carriers from the interface @xmath133 with the spatial extent of each wavefunction at the right hand side of the figure .
these values are consistent with the thicknesses of lao / sto 2degs measured by other techniques [ s9 , s10 ] , particularly when we consider that 80% of the carriers we observe are accommodated in the lowest two subbands .
finally , we note that there is growing evidence of a large number of localised charge carriers in the lao / sto 2deg [ s11 , s12 , s13 ] , and that these carriers are expected to be more closely confined to the interface than the mobile carriers contributing to transport [ s14 , s15 ] .
this would suggest a real confining potential which is non - uniform , and considerably steeper at the bottom of the well , with the localised carriers occupying lower - lying subbands than those we observe in the sdh effect .
we do not consider this picture in detail , but such a scenario is not expected to significantly affect the conclusions we have drawn here about the high - mobility carriers we have measured in this lao / sto system . | we have performed high field magnetotransport measurements to investigate the interface electron gas in laalo@xmath0/srtio@xmath0 heterostructures .
shubnikov - de haas oscillations reveal several 2d conduction subbands with carrier effective masses between 1 and 3 @xmath1 , quantum mobilities of order @xmath2 @xmath3/v s , and band edges only a few millielectronvolts below the fermi energy .
measurements in tilted magnetic fields confirm the 2d character of the electron gas , and show evidence of inter - subband scattering . |
inasmuch as studies of the interaction between a particle and a quantum field are basic to particle physics and field theory , understanding the interaction between an atom and a quantum field is essential to current atomic and optical physics research @xcite .
the interaction of an accelerated charge or detector ( an object with some internal degrees of freedom such as an atom or harmonic oscillator ) in a quantum field is a simple yet fundamental problem with many implications in quantum field theory @xcite , thermodynamics @xcite and applications in radiation theory and atomic - optical physics .
it is common knowledge that accelerating charges give rise to radiation @xcite .
but it is not entirely straightforward to derive the radiation formula from quantum field theory .
how are vacuum fluctuations related to the emitted radiation ?
when an atom or detector moves at constant acceleration , according to unruh @xcite , it would experience a thermal bath at temperature @xmath0 , where @xmath1 is the proper acceleration .
is there emitted radiation with an energy flux in the unruh effect ?
unruh effect , and the related effect for moving mirrors studied by davies and fulling @xcite , were intended originally to mimic hawking radiation from black holes .
because of this connection , for some time now there has been a speculation that there is real radiation emitted from a uniformly accelerated detector ( uad ) under steady state conditions ( i.e. , for atoms which have been uniformly accelerated for a time sufficiently long that transient effects have died out ) , not unlike that of an accelerating charge @xcite . in light of pending experiments both for electrons in accelerators @xcite and for accelerated atoms in optical cavities @xcite this speculation has acquired some realistic significance .
there is a need for more detailed analysis for both the uniform acceleration of charges or detectors and for transient motions because the latter can produce radiation and as explained below , sudden changes in the dynamics can also produce emitted radiation with thermal characteristics .
after unruh and wald s @xcite earlier explication of what a minkowski observer sees , grove @xcite questioned whether an accelerated atom actually emits radiated energy .
raine , sciama and grove @xcite ( rsg ) analyzed what an inertial observer placed in the forward light cone of the accelerating detector would measure and concluded that the oscillator does not radiate .
unruh @xcite , in an independent calculation , basically concurred with the findings of rsg but he also showed the existence of extra terms in the two - point function of the field which would contribute to the excitation of a detector placed in the forward light cone .
massar , parantani and brout @xcite ( mpb ) pointed out that the missing terms in rsg contribute to a polarization cloud " around the accelerating detector . for a review of earlier work on accelerated detectors ,
see e.g. , @xcite . for work after that ,
see , e.g. , hinterleitner @xcite , audretsch , mller and holzmann @xcite , massar and parantani @xcite .
our present work follows the vein of raval , hu , anglin ( rha ) and koks @xcite on the minimal coupling model and uses some results of lin @xcite on the unruh - dewitt model @xcite . with regard to the question is there a radiation flux emitted from an unruh detector ? "
the findings of rsg , unruh , mpb , rha and others show that , at least in ( 1 + 1 ) dimension model calculations , _ there is no emitted radiation from a linear uniformly accelerated oscillator under equilibrium conditions _ , even though , as found before , that there exists a polarization cloud around it .
hu and johnson @xcite emphasized the difference between an equilibrium condition ( steady state uniform acceleration ) where there is no emitted radiation , and nonequilibrium conditions where there could be radiation emitted .
nonequilibrium conditions arise for non - uniformly accelerated atoms ( for an example of finite time acceleration , see raval , hu and koks ( rhk ) @xcite ) , or during the initial transient time for an atom approaching uniform acceleration , when its internal states have not yet reached equilibrium through interaction with the field .
hu and raval ( hr ) @xcite presented a more complete analysis of the two - point function , calculated for two points lying in arbitrary regions of minkowski space .
this generalizes the results of mpb in that there is no restriction for the two points to lie to the left of the accelerated oscillator trajectory .
they show where the extra terms in the two - point function are which were ignored in the rsg analysis . more important to answering the theme question ,
they show that at least in ( 1 + 1 ) dimension the stress - energy tensor vanishes everywhere except on the horizon .
this means that there is no net flux of radiation emitted from the uniformly accelerated oscillator in steady state in ( 1 + 1)d case .
most prior theoretical work on this topic was done in ( 1 + 1 ) dimensional spacetimes .
however since most experimental proposals on the detection of unruh effect are designed for the physical four dimensional spacetime , it is necessary to do a detailed analysis for ( 3 + 1 ) dimensions .
although tempting , one can not assume that all ( 3 + 1 ) results are equivalent to those from ( 1 + 1 ) calculations .
first , there are new divergences in the ( 3 + 1 ) case to deal with .
second , the structure of the retarded field in ( 3 + 1 ) dimensional spacetime is much richer : it consists of a bound field ( generalized coulomb field ) and a radiation field with a variety of multipole structure , while the ( 1 + 1 ) case has only the radiation field in a different form .
third , an earlier work of one of us @xcite showed that there is some constant negative monopole radiation emitted from a detector initially in the ground state and uniformly accelerated in ( 3 + 1)d minkowski space , and claimed that this signal could be an evidence of the unruh effect .
this contradicts the results reported by hr @xcite and others from the ( 1 + 1)d calculations .
we need to clarify this discrepancy and determine the cause of it , by studying the complete process from transient to steady state .
in particular , since radiation only exists under nonequilibrium conditions in the ( 1 + 1 ) case , it is crucial to understand the transient effects in the ( 3 + 1 ) case to gauge our expectation of what could be , against what would be , observed in laboratories . in conceptual terms
, one is tempted to invoke stationarity and thermality conditions for the description of an uad .
this is indeed a simple and powerful way to understand its physics if the detector undergoes uniform acceleration and interacts with the field all throughout ( e.g. , because of the stationarity of the problem in the rindler proper time it is guaranteed that the total boost energy - operator is conserved ) .
however , this argument is inapplicable for transient epochs during which the physics is quite different ( see , e.g. , the inertial to uniform acceleration motion treated in @xcite ) .
likewise , one can invoke the thermality condition ( i.e. , the thermal radiance experienced by a uad is equivalent to that of an inertial detector in a thermal bath ) to obtain results based on simple reasonings .
but then we note that the thermality condition does not uniquely arise from uniform acceleration conditions .
for example if the motion is rapidly altered @xcite the radiation produced can be approximately thermal .
this thermality in emitted radiation ( e.g. , from sudden injection of atoms into a cavity ) is similar to those encountered in cosmological particle creation @xcite , but has a different physical origin from unruh effect which is similar to particle creation from black holes ( hawking effect ) @xcite ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) . in terms of methodology , instead of using the more sophisticated influence functional method as in the earlier series of papers on accelerated detectors @xcite and moving charges @xcite
, our work here follows more closely the work of hr who used the heisenberg operator method to calculate the two - point function and the stress - energy tensor of a massless quantum scalar field . in our analysis
based on the ( 3 + 1)d unruh - dewitt detector theory we found the full and exact dynamics of the detector and the field in terms of their heisenberg operator evolution , thus making available the complete quantum and statistical information for this detector - field system , enabling us to address the interplay of thermal radiance in the detector , vacuum polarization cloud around the detector , quantum fluctuations and radiation , and emitted flux of classical radiation .
the paper is organized as follows . in sec.ii
we introduce the unruh - dewitt detector theory .
then in sec.iii we describe the quantum dynamics of the detector - field system in the heisenberg picture , yielding the expectation values of the detector two - point function with respect to the minkowski vacuum and a detector coherent state in sec.iv . with these results
we derive the two - point function of the quantum field and describe what constitutes the vacuum polarization " around the detector in sec.v . then in sec.vi we calculate the quantum expectation values of the stress - energy tensor induced by the uniformly accelerated detector .
this allows us to explore the conservation law and derive the quantum radiation formula .
a comparison with the results in ref.@xcite follows in sec.vii .
finally , we summarize our findings in sec.viii .
the total action of the detector - field system is given by @xmath2 where @xmath3 is the internal degree of freedom of the detector , assumed to be a harmonic oscillator with mass @xmath4 and a ( bare ) natural frequency @xmath5 : @xmath6.\ ] ] here @xmath7 is the detector s proper time .
henceforth we will use an overdot on @xmath3 to denote @xmath8 .
the scalar field @xmath9 is assumed to be massless , @xmath10 the interaction action @xmath11 for the unruh - dewitt ( ud ) detector theory has the form @xcite , @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the coupling constant .
this can be regarded as a simplified version of an atom . below we will consider the ud detector moving in a prescribed trajectory @xmath14 in a four - dimensional minkowski spacetime with metric @xmath15 diag@xmath16 and line element @xmath17 . by
prescribed " we mean the trajectory of the detector is not considered as a dynamical variable , thus we ignore the backreaction effect of the field on the trajectory .
( see ref.@xcite for an example where the trajectory and the field are determined self - consistently by each other . )
the detector is made ( by the act of an external agent ) to go along the worldline @xmath18 parametrized by its proper time @xmath7 .
this is the trajectory of a uniformly accelerated detector situated in rindler wedge r ( the portion @xmath19 and @xmath20 of minkowski space ; see chapter 4 of ref.@xcite ) .
the conjugate momenta ( @xmath21 ) of dynamical variables ( @xmath22 ) are defined by @xmath23 by treating the above dynamical variables as operators and introducing the equal time commutation relations , @xmath24 & = & i\hbar , \label{qpcm } \\ \left .
[ \hat{\phi}(t,{\bf x}),\hat{\pi } ( t,{\bf x ' } ) ] \right . &
= & i\hbar\delta^3 ( { \bf x}-{\bf x'}),\label{phipicm}\end{aligned}\ ] ] one can write down the heisenberg equations of motion for the operators and obtains @xmath25 which have the same form as the classical euler - lagrange equations
. suppose the system is prepared before @xmath26 , and the coupling @xmath11 is turned on precisely at the moment @xmath26 when we allow all the dynamical variables to begin to interact and evolve under the influence of each other .
( the consequences of this sudden switch - on and the assumption of a factorizable initial state for the combined system a quantum brownian oscillator plus oscillator bath is described in some details in @xcite ) . by virtue of the linear coupling @xmath27 ,
the time evolution of @xmath28 is simply a linear transformation in the phase space spanned by the orthonormal basis @xmath29 , that is , @xmath30 can be expressed in the form @xmath31+f^q(x)\hat{q}(0)+ f^p(x)\hat{p}(0 ) .
\label{defphi}\ ] ] here @xmath32 and @xmath33 are c - number functions of spacetime .
similarly , the operator @xmath34 can be written as @xmath35 + q^q(\tau ) \hat{q}(0)+ q^p(\tau ) \hat{p}(0 ) , \label{defq}\ ] ] with c - number functions @xmath36 and @xmath37 . for the case with initial operaters being the free field operators , namely , @xmath38 , @xmath39 , @xmath40 and @xmath41 , one can go further by introducing the complex operators @xmath42 and @xmath43 : @xmath44 , \\
\hat{\pi}_0({\bf x } ) & = & \int { d^3k\over ( 2\pi)^3 } \sqrt{\hbar\over
2\omega}(-i\omega ) \left [ e^{i{\bf k\cdot x } } \hat{b}_{\bf k}-e^{-i{\bf k\cdot x}}\hat{b}^\dagger_{\bf k}\right]\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath45 , and @xmath46 note that , instead of @xmath5 , we use the renormalizd natural frequency @xmath47 ( to be defined in @xmath48 ) in the definition of @xmath43 .
then the commutation relations @xmath49 and @xmath50 give @xmath51=1 , \;\;\;\;\ ; [ \hat{b}_{\bf k } , \hat{b}_{\bf k'}^\dagger ] = ( 2\pi)^3\delta^3({\bf k}-{\bf k'}),\ ] ] and the expressions @xmath52 and @xmath53 can be re - written as @xmath54 where @xmath55,\label{phiv}\\ \hat{\phi}_a(x ) & = & \sqrt{\hbar \over 2\omega_r m_0}\left[f^a(t,{\bf x } ) \hat{a}+ f^{a*}(t,{\bf x})\hat{a}^\dagger \right ] , \label{phib}\\ \hat{q}_b(\tau ) & = & \int { d^3 k\over ( 2\pi)^3}\sqrt{\hbar\over 2\omega } \left[q^{(+)}(\tau,{\bf k})\hat{b}_{\bf k } + q^{(-)}(\tau,{\bf k})\hat{b}_{\bf k}^\dagger\right],\label{qv } \\
\hat{q}_a(\tau ) & = & \sqrt{\hbar\over 2\omega_r m_0}\left [ q^a(\tau)\hat{a}+q^{a*}(\tau)\hat{a}^\dagger \right ] .\label{qb}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the whole problem therefore can be transformed to solving c - number functions @xmath56 and @xmath57 from @xmath58 and @xmath59 with suitable initial conditions .
since @xmath60 and @xmath61 are hermitian , one has @xmath62 and @xmath63 . hence it is sufficient to solve the c - number functions @xmath64 , @xmath65 , @xmath66 and @xmath67 . to place this in a more general setting ,
let us perform a lorentz transformation shifting @xmath68 to @xmath69 , and define @xmath70 this does not add any complication to our calculation .
now the coupling between the detector and the field would be turned on at @xmath69 .
we are looking for solutions with the initial conditions @xmath71 the method to solve for @xmath74 and @xmath75 are analogous to what we did in classical field theory .
first , we find an expression relating the harmonic oscillator and the field amplitude right at the detector . then substituting this relation into the equation of motion for the oscillator
, we obtain a complete equation of motion for @xmath75 with full information of the field .
last , we solve this complete equation of motion for @xmath75 , and from its solution determine the field @xmath74 consistently .
eq.@xmath59 implies that @xmath76 the general solution for @xmath72 reads @xmath77 where @xmath78 is the free field solution , and @xmath79 is the retarded solution , which looks like the retarded field in classical field theory . here
@xmath80 and the retarded green s function @xmath81 in minkowski space is given by @xmath82 with @xmath83 .
applying the explicit form of the retarded green s function , one can go further to write @xmath84 where @xmath85 with @xmath86 , @xmath87 and @xmath88 .
the formal retarded solution @xmath89 is singular on the trajectory of the detector . to deal with the singularity , note that the ud detector here is a quantum mechanical object , and
the detector number would always be one .
this means that at the energy threshold of detector creations , there is a natural cutoff on frequency , which sets an upper bound on the resolution to be explored in our theory .
thus it is justified to assume here that the detector has a finite extent @xmath90 , which will introduce the back reaction on the detector .
let us regularize the retarded green s function by invoking the essence of effective field theory : @xmath91 ( for more details on this regularization scheme , see refs.@xcite . ) with this , right on the trajectory , the retarded solution for large @xmath92 is @xmath93,\ ] ] where @xmath94 . substituting the above expansion into @xmath58 and neglecting @xmath90 terms , one obtains the equation of motion for @xmath73 with back reaction , @xmath95 fortunately
, there is no higher derivatives of @xmath75 present in the above equation of motion . now
@xmath73 behaves like a damped harmonic oscillator driven by the vacuum fluctuations of the scalar field , with the damping constant @xmath96 and the renormalized natural frequency @xmath97 in @xmath98 , the solution for @xmath73 compatible with the initial conditions @xmath99 is @xmath100 where @xmath101 has been given in @xmath102 , @xmath103 and @xmath104 are defined as @xmath105 with @xmath106 throughout this paper we consider only the under - damped case with @xmath107 , so @xmath108 is always real .
similarly , from @xmath58 , @xmath59 , @xmath111 and @xmath112 , the equations of motion for @xmath109 and @xmath110 read @xmath113 the general solutions for @xmath109 , similar to @xmath114 , is @xmath115 however , according to the initial condition @xmath116 , one has @xmath117 , hence @xmath118 again , the value of @xmath109 is singular right at the position of the detector . performing the same regularization as those for @xmath73 ,
@xmath119 becomes ( cf .
@xmath98 ) @xmath120 which describes a damped harmonic oscillator free of driving force .
the solution consistent with the initial condition @xmath121 and @xmath122 reads @xmath123 .
\label{qb}\ ] ]
as shown in the previous section , as @xmath60 evolves , some non - zero terms proportional to @xmath61 and @xmath124 will be generated .
suppose the detector is initially prepared in a state that can be factorized into the quantum state @xmath125 for @xmath3 and the minkowski vacuum @xmath126 for the scalar field @xmath9 , that is , @xmath127 then the two - point function of @xmath3 will split into two parts , @xmath128 \left[\hat{q}_b(\tau ) + \hat{q}_a(\tau)\right]\left|\right.q\left .
\right > |0_m\left.\right > \nonumber\\ & = & \left<\right.q \,|\ , q\left.\right > \left < \right . q(\tau)q(\tau')\left.\right>_{\rm v}+ \left < \right .
q(\tau)q(\tau')\left.\right>_{\rm a}\left < 0_m| 0_m\right>. \label{splitqq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where , from @xmath112 , @xmath129 similar splitting happens for every two - point function of @xmath30 as well as for the stress - energy tensor
. observe that @xmath130 depends on the initial state of the field , or the minkowski vacuum , while @xmath131 depends on the initial state of the detector only .
one can thus interpret @xmath132 as accounting for the response to the vacuum fluctuations , while @xmath133 corresponds to the intrinsic quantum fluctuations in the detector . in the following
, we will demonstrate the explicit forms of some two - point functions we have obtained and analyze their behavior . to distinguish the quantum or classical natures of these quantities
, the initial quantum state @xmath134 will be taken to be the coherent state @xcite , @xmath135 where @xmath136 is the @xmath137-th excited state for the free detector , and @xmath138 with a constant @xmath139 .
the representation of @xmath134 in @xmath3-space reads @xmath140 which is a wave - packet centered at @xmath139 with the spread identical to the one for the ground state . along the trajectory @xmath14 in @xmath141 , performing a fourier transformation with respect to @xmath7 on @xmath102 ,
one has @xmath142 where the frequency spectrum of the minkowski mode from the viewpoint of the uad , @xmath143 is not trivial any more . given the result of the integration , @xmath144 a planck factor with the unruh temperature @xmath145 emerges .
then from @xmath146 , @xmath147 and @xmath148 , one has @xmath149
\left [ e^{w^*_{j'}(\tau'-\tau'_0)}-e^{i\kappa(\tau'-\tau'_0)}\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the integrand has poles at @xmath150 and @xmath151 , @xmath152 .
let @xmath153 and taking the coincidence limit , one obtains @xmath154\nonumber\\ & - & { 1\over 4}\left [ \left({i\omega\over\gamma}+
e^{-2\gamma\eta } \left({i\omega\over\gamma}+1 -e^{-2i\omega\eta}\right)\right ) \left ( \psi_{\gamma+i\omega}+ \psi_{-\gamma - i\omega}\right)\right .
\nonumber\\ & & \left.\left .
- \left(-{i\omega\over\gamma}+ e^{-2\gamma\eta}\left({i\omega\over\gamma}+1 -e^{-2i\omega\eta } \right)\right)i\pi\coth{\pi\over a}(\omega - i\gamma)\right]\right\}. \label{q^2v}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath155 is defined by the hyper - geometric function as @xmath156 and @xmath157 is the poly - gamma function .
the divergent @xmath158-term is produced by the coincidence limit : as @xmath159 , @xmath160 with the euler s constant @xmath161 .
since @xmath162 characterizes the time scale that the interaction is turned on , @xmath158 could be finite in real processes . in any case , for every finite value of @xmath158
, the first line of the result in @xmath163 vanishes as @xmath164 .
( dotted line , eq.(@xmath165 ) with @xmath158-term excluded ) , @xmath166 ( dashed line , eq.(@xmath167 ) ) , and the sum of these two ( @xmath168 , solid line ) . here
we have taken @xmath169 , @xmath170 , @xmath171 and @xmath172 .
, width=302 ] in fig .
[ qqvseta ] , we show the @xmath173 without @xmath158-term in dotted line . roughly speaking the curve saturates exponentially in the detector s proper time . as @xmath164 , @xmath174 saturates to the value @xmath175.\label{qqsat}\ ] ] for @xmath176 , the time scale of the rise is about @xmath177 , which can be read off from the @xmath178 in @xmath163 . from there one can also see that the small oscillation around the rising curve has a frequency of @xmath179 . for @xmath180
, it will be clear that what is interesting for the calculation of the flux is the combined quantities like @xmath181 .
notice that @xmath182 with the result of @xmath183 , this calculation is straightforward
. let us turn to the two - point functions of @xmath184 .
similar to @xmath183 , one has @xmath185
\left [ w^*_{j'}e^{w^*_{j'}(\tau'-\tau'_0)}- i\kappa e^{i\kappa(\tau'-\tau'_0)}\right ] \label{qtqt'}\end{aligned}\ ] ] from @xmath147 , @xmath148 and @xmath186 .
the coincidence limit of the above two - point function reads @xmath187 \right . \nonumber\\ & + & { a\over 2}(\gamma+i\omega)^2 e^{-(\gamma + a)\eta } \left[{f_{\gamma+i\omega } ( e^{-a\eta } ) \over \gamma+i\omega+a}\left ( { i\omega\over\gamma}\right ) e^{-i\omega\eta } + { f_{-\gamma - i\omega}(e^{-a\eta})\over \gamma + i\omega - a}\left ( \left(1-{i\omega\over\gamma}\right)e^{i\omega\eta } -e^{-i\omega\eta}\right ) \right]\nonumber\\ & + & { 1\over 4 } ( \gamma + i\omega)^2\left[\left ( { i\omega\over\gamma}+ e^{-2\gamma\eta}\left({i\omega\over\gamma}-1+e^{-2i\omega\eta}\right)\right ) \left(\psi_{\gamma+i\omega}+ \psi_{-\gamma - i\omega}\right)\right.\nonumber\\ & & \left.\left .
-\left(-{i\omega\over\gamma}+e^{-2\gamma\eta } \left({i\omega\over\gamma}-1+e^{-2i\omega\eta}\right)\right)i\pi\coth { \pi\over a}(\omega - i\gamma)\right]\right\ } , \label{dotq^2v}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath188 can be subtracted safely .
this will be justified later .
( dotted line , eq.(@xmath189 ) ) , @xmath190 ( dashed line , eq.(@xmath191 ) ) and their sum ( @xmath192 , solid line).,width=302 ] the subtracted @xmath193 is illustrated in fig . [ ppvseta ] ( in which @xmath158-term has also been excluded ) .
one can immediately recognize that @xmath194 when @xmath195 approaches zero ; a new divergence occurs at @xmath196 .
mathematically , this logarithmic divergence comes about because the divergences in the hyper - geometric functions in @xmath197 do not cancel each other , unlike in @xmath198 .
physically , this divergence at the initial time @xmath199 could be another consequence of the sudden switch - on at @xmath69 or @xmath200 .
we expect that these ill - behaviors at the start could be tamed if we turn on the coupling adiabatically .
( see @xcite for a discussion on this issue . ) for large @xmath195 , the behavior of the dotted curve in fig .
[ ppvseta ] is quite similar to the one in fig .
[ qqvseta ] for @xmath201 .
it saturates to @xmath202 - 4\gamma \omega \ln a \right\}. \label{ppsat}\ ] ] comparing @xmath197 and @xmath163 , their time scales of saturation ( @xmath177 for @xmath203 ) and the frequency of the small ripples on the rising curve ( @xmath179 ) are also the same .
note that when @xmath204 and @xmath1 is finite , @xmath205 and @xmath206 implies @xmath207 which justifies the subtraction of @xmath208-term in @xmath197 .
we now derive the expectation values of the detector two - point functions with respect to the coherent state @xmath209 .
subsituting @xmath210 into @xmath211 and using @xmath212 and @xmath209 , one finds that @xmath213 where @xmath214{\rm re}\left[q^a(\tau')\right ] = \bar{q}(\tau)\bar{q}(\tau'),\label{barq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the mean value @xmath215 while the qm " term is of purely quantum nature , the
cl " term is of classical nature : @xmath216 is real and @xmath217 does not involve @xmath218 .
thus the cl " term is identified as the semiclassical part of the two - point functions .
the coincidence limits of the above two - point functions are @xmath219,\label{q2bqm}\ ] ] and @xmath220 . similarly , it is easy to find @xmath221 : @xmath222 % { \rm re}\left[\dot{q}^{\rm a}(\tau')\right]= \dot{\bar{q}}(\tau)\dot{\bar{q}}(\tau'),\end{aligned}\ ] ] and their coincidence limit , @xmath223 , \label{dotq2aqm}\ ] ] and @xmath224
. also one has @xmath225 .
( see eq.@xmath226 and below ) .
its behavior is quite different from the quantum part shown in the previous figures .
here we take @xmath227 , with other parameters unchanged .
, width=302 ] note that the above two - point functions with respect to the coherent state are independent of the proper acceleration @xmath1 . @xmath166 and the variance ( squared uncertainty ) of @xmath3 , @xmath228 ^ 2\left.\right > = \left<\right .
q ( \eta)^2\left.\right>_{\rm v}+ \left<\right.q(\eta)^2\left.\right > _ { \rm a}^{\rm qm}\ ] ] have been shown in fig .
[ qqvseta ] .
@xmath229 decays exponentially due to the dissipation of the zero - point energy to the field .
as @xmath230 decays , @xmath231 grows and compensates the decrease , then saturates asymptotically .
similar behavior can be found in fig .
[ ppvseta ] , in which @xmath232 ^ 2\left.\right > = \left<\right .
( \eta)^2\left.\right>_{\rm v}+ \left<\right.\dot{q}(\eta)^2\left.\right > _ { \rm a}^{\rm qm}\ ] ] is illustrated . in fig .
[ qqclvseta ] we show the semiclassical two - point funciton @xmath233 .
its behavior is quite different from the quantum part shown in the previous figures .
the saturated value @xmath234 in eq.@xmath206 is the late - time variance of @xmath3 , namely , @xmath235 .
its dependence on the proper acceleration @xmath1 is shown in fig .
[ qqvsa ] . against the proper acceleration @xmath1 ( solid line , eq.(@xmath236 ) ) with other parameters the same as fig .
[ qqvseta ] . for small @xmath1 ,
the value of @xmath237 is less than @xmath238 ( dotted line , see eq.(@xmath239 ) ) . for large @xmath1
, @xmath234 is nearly proportional to @xmath1.,width=302 ] one can see that , when @xmath1 is large , @xmath240 is nearly proportional to @xmath1 , while in the zero - acceleration limit @xmath241 with @xmath242 , the saturated value goes to a positive number . from @xmath206 and @xmath243 ,
one finds that @xmath244 thus @xmath245 is smaller than @xmath246 for every @xmath247 when @xmath248 .
in other words , for a non - accelerated detector , whose unruh temperature is zero , the variance of @xmath3 in the detector - field coupled system is still finite and smaller than the one for the ground state in the free theory .
actually , @xmath249 will become smaller than @xmath250 whenever @xmath1 is small enough . observing fig .
[ qqvsa ] , there is a critical value of @xmath1 that gives the late - time variance identical to the initial one ( @xmath251 in fig . [ qqvsa ] ) .
does this mean that the @xmath3-component of the final wave - packet with @xmath252 is in the original ground state of the free theory ?
the answer is no .
what happens is that the quantum state of @xmath3 has been highly entangled with the quantum state of @xmath9 at late times , and the value of @xmath253 simply represents the width of the projection of the whole wave - packet ( in the @xmath3-@xmath9 representation of the state ) onto the @xmath3-axis .
there is actually no factorizable @xmath3-component of the wave - packet , and the final configuration of the wave - packet in @xmath3-@xmath9 space looks totally different from the initial one . indeed , with the same critical value of @xmath1 , @xmath254 is not equal to @xmath255 for every @xmath256 .
but one can still imagine that , at @xmath200 , the coherent state for the free detector is an ensemble of particles with a distribution function like @xmath257 in @xmath3-space .
@xmath258 is the width of this distribution function . when @xmath259 , due to the dissipation which comes with the coupling , all particles in the ensemble are going to fall into the bottom of the potential of @xmath3 , so @xmath260 shrinks to zero . on the other hand , the vacuum fluctuations of the field act like a pressure which can push the ensemble of particles outwards , so that the width of the projection of the wave - packet in @xmath3-space , @xmath261 , remains finite .
a larger @xmath1 gives a higher unruh temperature , and a higher outward pressure , so eventually the wave - packet reaches equilibrium with a wider projection in the potential well of @xmath3 .
a natural definition of the energy of the dressed detector ( a similar concept is that of a dressed atom " , see e.g. , ref .
@xcite ) is @xmath262 , \label{grounde}\ ] ] with @xmath263 and @xmath264 according to @xmath265 . in figs .
[ qqvseta]-[qqclvseta ] , one can see that @xmath216 , @xmath266 and @xmath267 eventually die out .
so the late - time energy of the dressed detector is @xmath268\nonumber\\ & = & { \hbar\over 2\pi}\left\ { a-2{\rm re}\left [ ( \gamma+ i\omega ) \psi_{\gamma+i\omega}\right]-2\gamma \ln a\right\}\end{aligned}\ ] ] from @xmath206 and @xmath205 .
this is actually the true ground - state energy of the dressed detector , with the vacuum fluctuations of the field incorporated .
the first term in @xmath269 could be interpreted as the total energy of a harmonic oscillator in thermal bath , @xmath270 , with the unruh temperature @xmath271 .
the ground - state energy of the dressed detector is not identical to the one for the free detector , @xmath272 . in particular ,
if @xmath1 is small enough , the subtracted @xmath269 is lower than @xmath273 , though there is an ambiguity of a constant in determining the value of the energy .
this is analogous to the lamb shift in atomic physics @xcite .
similar to the two - point functions of the detector , for the initial quantum state @xmath274 , the two - point function of @xmath9 could be split into two parts , @xmath275\left[\phi_a(x')+\phi_b(x')\right ] \left|\right.q\left .
\right > |\left .
0_m\right > \nonumber\\ & = & g_{\rm v}(x , x ' ) + g_{\rm a}(x , x ' ) , \label{twopt}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where , from @xmath52 and @xmath111 , @xmath276 eqs.@xmath114-@xmath277 and @xmath278 suggest that @xmath279 accounts for the back reaction of the vacuum fluctuations of the scalar field on the field itself , while @xmath280 corresponds to the dissipation of the zero - point energy of the internal degree of freedom of the detector .
substituting @xmath114 into @xmath281 , @xmath279 can be decomposed into four pieces , @xmath282 in which @xmath283 are defined by @xmath284 with @xmath285 .
@xmath286 is actually the green s function for free fields , which should be subtracted to obtain the renormalized green s function for the interacting theory , namely , @xmath287 since @xmath288^*$ ] by definition , it is sufficient to calculate @xmath289 and @xmath290 in the following .
the structure of @xmath291 is quite simple . comparing @xmath89 , @xmath292 and the definition @xmath293 ,
one concludes that @xmath294 the result @xmath295 can be substituted directly to get the coincidence limit of @xmath291 . by definition ,
@xmath296 accounts for the interference between the retarded solution @xmath297 and the free solution @xmath101
. since we are interested in the coincidence limit of @xmath296 , and @xmath298 vanishes in the l - wedge ( @xmath299 , @xmath300 ) and p - wedge ( @xmath301 ) of minkowski space , below only the @xmath302 with @xmath303 and @xmath304 in the f - wedge ( @xmath305 ) and r - wedge would be calculated .
it has been given in ref.@xcite that @xmath306,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath307 , @xmath308 and @xmath309 for @xmath303 in r and f - wedges , should have been on the right hand side of @xmath310 .
] respectively , @xmath311 and @xmath312 were defined in @xmath313 and @xmath314 , and @xmath315 hence , from @xmath89 and @xmath102 , one has @xmath316
\left [ e^{i\kappa\eta_-'}-z(\kappa)e^{i\kappa\eta_+'}\right ] \label{formalg10}\ ] ] with @xmath317 .
the coincidence limit of @xmath296 reads @xmath318\right\ } , \label{g10v}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath319 and @xmath320 for @xmath303 in r and f - wedges , respectively .
near the event horizon @xmath321 , @xmath322 diverges , and the last two terms in @xmath323 vanish . as for @xmath324 , since @xmath325 , one has @xmath326 , and only @xmath327 contributes to @xmath280 .
inserting @xmath278 into @xmath328 and comparing with @xmath329 , one finds that @xmath330 it can also be divided into a quantum part @xmath331 and a semiclassical part @xmath332 according to @xmath329 and below . in our ( 3 + 1 ) dimensional ud detector theory ,
the coincidence limit of the quantum part of @xmath333 reads @xmath334 owing to @xmath335 , @xmath336 and @xmath337 . collecting the results in @xmath338 , @xmath323 and @xmath339
, it is found that @xmath340 is singular at @xmath341 , and one has to be more cautious .
as can be seen from @xmath338 and @xmath339 , @xmath342 and @xmath343 look like the squares of the retarded field with effective squared scalar charge @xmath344 and @xmath345 , respectively . since the detector is accelerating , these two terms do carry radiated energy ( this will be shown explicitly later ) .
the interfering term @xmath346 , is more intriguing : at first glance , it acts like a polarization in the medium , which screens the radiation field carried by @xmath342 and @xmath343 .
however , the interfering term @xmath347 does not respond to @xmath348 at all it is independent of @xmath109 and impervious to any information about the quantum state of @xmath3 .
hence the interfering term can not be interpreted as the polarization in the medium .
the total effect is simply a destructive interference between the field induced by the vacuum fluctuations , and the vacuum fluctuations themselves . for physical interpretations one should group @xmath347 and @xmath291 together and leave @xmath348 alone .
( dashed line ) , @xmath349 ( dotted line ) and their sum ( solid line ) against @xmath350 near the event horizon @xmath351 .
other parameters are the same as those in fig .
[ qqvseta ] .
one can see the feature that positive @xmath352 is screened by negative @xmath353.,width=302 ] ( dashed line ) , @xmath354 ( dotted line ) and their sum ( solid line ) against @xmath355 at @xmath356 and @xmath357 .
the cusp in the right ( @xmath358 in this plot ) locates at the position of the detector with @xmath359 .
it is due to the weaker divergence than @xmath360 for @xmath347.,width=302 ] these quantities , together with their sum , are illustrated in figs .
[ gtot2 ] and [ gtot3 ] . in fig .
[ gtot2 ] , one can see that , soon after the coupling is turned on at @xmath361 , @xmath362 build up and pull the solid curve down . observing @xmath323 , the time scale ( in proper time of the detector ) of this pull - down is about @xmath363 , which is shorter than the time scale @xmath177 for @xmath344 and @xmath364 , since we take @xmath365 here . in fig .
[ gtot3 ] , one can also see that @xmath366 diverge as @xmath367 around the trajectory , while the divergence of @xmath353 as @xmath368 is a bit weaker than @xmath367 , such that @xmath369 goes to zero on the trajectory of the detector
. in prior work for ( 1 + 1)d spacetime @xcite the counterpart of @xmath370 has been considered as evidence for the existence of a vacuum polarization cloud " around the detector @xcite .
this is because @xmath370 around the detector does not vanish even after the system reaches equilibrium , it exchanges particles with the detector , and the mean energy it carries is zero . nevertheless , vacuum polarization is a concept pertinent to field - field quantum interacting systems . in quantum electrodynamics ,
electrons are described in terms of a field , which distributes in the whole spacetime , so vacuum polarization is pictured as the creation and annihilation of virtual electron - positron pairs everywhere in spacetime .
these virtual electron - positron pairs do modify the field strength around the location of a point charge , yielding a non - vanishing variance of the electromagnetic ( em ) field .
but in the ud detector theory , at the level of precision explored here , the detector - field interaction ( hence the virtual processes ) only occurs on the trajectory of the detector .
there is no virtual detector or scalar charge at any spatial point off the location of the ud detector .
hence in ud detector theory vacuum polarization cloud " is not a precise description of @xmath370 in steady state . at late times
@xmath370 simply shows the characteristics of the field in the true vacuum state , in contrast to @xmath371 for the true ground state of the detector .
in classical theory , the modified stress - energy tensor for a massless scalar field @xmath9 in minkowski space is @xcite @xmath372 = \left ( 1 - 2\xi\right)\phi_{,\mu}\phi_{,\nu}-2\xi\phi \phi_{;\mu\nu } + \left ( 2\xi -{1\over 2}\right)g_{\mu\nu}\phi^{,\rho}\phi_{,\rho } + { \xi\over 2}g_{\mu\nu}\phi\box\phi , \label{tmnxi}\ ] ] where @xmath373 is a field coupling parameter , set to zero here .
denote @xmath374 as the four velocity of the detector , and define the null distance @xmath375 and the spacelike unit vector @xmath376 by @xmath377 @xcite with normalization @xmath378 and @xmath379 ( see fig .
[ defr ] ) .
then the stress - energy tensor for the classical retarded field @xmath380 induced by the ud detector moving along the trajectory @xmath381 can be written as @xcite @xmath382_{\xi=0 } = { \lambda_0 ^ 2\over ( 4\pi)^2 } \theta(\eta_-)\left\{{1\over r^4 } q^2(\tau_-)\left ( -{1\over 2 } g_{\mu\nu}+u_\mu u_\nu\right)\right.\nonumber\\&&+{1\over r^3 } q(\tau_-)\left [ \dot{q}(\tau_- ) + q(\tau_- ) a_\rho u^\rho\right ] \left ( -g_{\mu\nu}+2 u_\mu u_\nu + u_\mu v_\nu + v_\mu u_\nu\right ) \nonumber\\ & & + \left .
{ 1\over r^2}\left [ \dot{q}(\tau_-)+ q(\tau_- ) a_\rho u^\rho\right]^2(u_\mu + v_\mu)(u_\nu + v_\nu ) \right\ } .
\label{tmnret}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the @xmath383 term in the above expression corresponds to the radiation field , which carries radiated power given by @xcite @xmath384 ^ 2 \label{dwdtoii}\ ] ] to the null infinity of minkowski space . here
the @xmath3-term corresponds to dipole radiation ( @xmath385 , @xmath386 in multipole expansion of the radiation field ) with the angular distribution @xmath387 , in the modified stress - energy tensor . for @xmath388 ,
the angular distribution is @xmath389 , which is the same as the one for the em radiation emitted by a electric charge in electrodynamics . ] while the @xmath184-term corresponds to monopole radiation ( @xmath390 ) isotropic in the rest frame instantaneously for the ud detector at @xmath312 .
the solid angle @xmath391 could be further integrated out , then one obtains the classical radiation formula @xmath392 , \label{eloss}\ ] ] which is the counterpart of the larmor formula for em radiation .
the second term is the usual radiation formula for the massless scalar field emitted by a constant , point - like scalar charge in acceleration @xcite .
naively , one may expect that the quantum version of the radiation formula could look like @xmath393 $ ] . in the following
, we shall calculate the quantum expectation value of the flux @xmath394 , from which we will see that the quantum radiation formula is more complicated than expected .
the expectation value of the renormalized stress - energy tensor @xmath395 is obtained by calculating @xmath396\right>_{\rm ren } = \lim_{x'\to x } \left [ { \partial\over \partial x^\mu}{\partial\over\partial x'^\nu } -{1\over 2}g_{\mu\nu } g^{\rho\sigma}{\partial\over \partial x^\rho } { \partial\over\partial x'^\sigma}\right ] g_{\rm ren}(x , x ' ) , \label{exptmn}\ ] ] according to @xmath397 with @xmath398 . with the results in the previous section ,
it is straightforward to obtain @xmath399 induced by the uad : @xmath400\right>_{\rm ren } & = & { \lambda_0 ^ 2\theta(\eta_-)\over(2\pi)^2 a^2 x^2}\left [ g_\mu{}^\rho g_\nu{}^\sigma -{1\over 2}g_{\mu\nu}g^{\rho\sigma}\right ] \times\nonumber\\ & & \left [ \eta_{-,\rho}\eta_{-,\sigma } \left<\right .
\dot{q}(\tau_-)^2\left.\right>_{\rm tot } + { x_{,\rho } x_{,\sigma}\over x^2}\left<\right.q(\tau_-)^2\left.\right>_{\rm tot } \right.\nonumber\\ & & - { x_{,\rho}\over x}\eta_{-,\sigma}\left<\right .
q(\tau_-)\dot{q}(\tau_-)\left.\right>_{\rm tot}- \eta_{-,\rho}{x_{,\sigma}\over x}\left < \right.\dot{q}(\tau_- ) q(\tau_-)\left.\right>_{\rm tot}\nonumber\\ & & \left .
+ \left(\eta_{-,\rho}\eta_{+,\sigma}+ \eta_{+,\rho}\eta_{-,\sigma}\right){\hbar\theta_{+-}\over 2\pi m_0 } - \left({x_{,\rho}\over x}\eta_{+,\sigma } + \eta_{+,\rho}{x_{,\sigma}\over x}\right ) { \hbar\theta_{+x}\over 2\pi m_0}\right].\label{tmnren}\end{aligned}\ ] ] upon collecting @xmath401 and @xmath402 as well as those from @xmath403 .
here @xmath404 , @xmath405 and @xmath406 with @xmath407 defined in @xmath408-@xmath409 . to see the properties of quantum nature , we define
the total variances by subtracting the semiclassical part from @xmath410 as @xmath411 their evolution against @xmath412 are illustrated in figs .
[ qqtot1 ] and [ pptot1 ] . ,
@xmath413 and @xmath375.,width=302 ] in our case , the minkowski coordinate @xmath414 of a spacetime point in f and r - wedge can be transformed to the coordinate @xmath415 by @xmath416 , \label{vtor}\\ u & = & r e^{-a\tau_-}\left [ 1 - \cos\theta - ( ar)^{-1}\right ] , \label{utor}\end{aligned}\ ] ] so that @xmath417 . also one has @xmath418 with @xmath419 .
now eq.@xmath420 can be directly compared with @xmath421 and @xmath422 .
one can see clearly that the @xmath423 term has the same angular distribution as the one for the @xmath424 term in @xmath421 , hence would be recognized as a monopole radiation by the minkowski observer .
the angular distributions of the remaining terms in @xmath420 are , however , much more complicated because of their dependence on @xmath425 .
we have mentioned in the previous section that @xmath348 and @xmath291 in @xmath339 and @xmath338 carry radiated energy , now this becomes clear . observing that what correspond to @xmath426 $ ] are those proportional to @xmath427 in @xmath428 terms of @xmath420 .
these terms contribute a positive flux .
nevertheless , due to the presence of the interfering terms @xmath407 , most of this positive flux of quantum nature will be screened when the system reaches steady state as @xmath429 .
( eq.@xmath430 ) near the event horizon for the detector ( @xmath431 ) .
this plot is virtually the same as fig .
[ gtot2 ] except the time " variable is @xmath412 here .
the values of parameters are still the same as before .
the total variance finally saturates to the value @xmath432 .
one can compare this plot with fig .
[ qqvseta ] directly and see the suppression.,width=302 ] as shown in fig .
[ qqtot1 ] , the total variance @xmath433 near the event horizon @xmath351 drops exponentially in proper time ( power - law in the minkowski time ) after the coupling is turned on .
note that @xmath434 is proportional to @xmath340 defined in @xmath435 , and @xmath311 is independent of @xmath350 on the event horizon , so fig . [ qqtot1 ] is virtually the same plot as fig .
[ gtot2 ] except that the time variable here is @xmath412 .
thus , similar to the behavior of @xmath436 near the event horizon , @xmath437 ( @xmath438 ) builds up and the total variance @xmath439 is pulled down during the time scale @xmath363 ( for @xmath440 ) according to @xmath163 , @xmath243 and @xmath441 .
then @xmath442 turns into a tail ( @xmath443 in fig .
[ qqtot1 ] ) which exponentially approaches the saturated value @xmath444 with the time scale @xmath177 .
( eq.@xmath445 ) with the same parameters .
note that @xmath446 is independent of @xmath322 , and this plot is not restricted around the event horizon .
one can compare with fig .
[ ppvseta ] and see the suppression.,width=302 ] for @xmath447 and @xmath448 , their behaviors are similar ( see fig .
[ pptot1 ] ) .
in particular , @xmath449 goes to zero at late times from @xmath197 , @xmath450 and @xmath408 with @xmath451 , so the corresponding monopole radiation vanishes after the transient . from the calculations of ref.@xcite based on perturbation theory ,
it was suggested that the existence of a monopole radiation could be an experimentally distinguishable evidence of the unruh effect .
here we find from a non - perturbative calculation that , in fact , only the transient of it could be observed .
( a comparison of both results will be given in sec.vii . )
this appears to agree with the claim that for a uad in ( 1 + 1)d , emitted radiation is only associated with nonequilibrium process @xcite .
the negative tail of @xmath447 in fig .
[ pptot1 ] and the corresponding quantum radiation could last for a long time with respect to the minkowski observer ( @xmath452 ) , but this is essentially a transient .
the interference between the quantum radiation induced by the vacuum fluctuations and the vacuum fluctuations themselves totally screens the information about the unruh effect in this part of the radiation .
what is the physics behind the interfering term in @xmath453 ? by inserting our results into @xmath454 and @xmath445 , one can show that , @xmath455,\label{econserv}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for all proper time interval after the interaction is turned on @xmath456 .
the left hand side of this equality is the energy - loss of the dressed detector from @xmath457 to @xmath458 , while the right hand side is the radiated energy via the monopole radiation corresponding to @xmath453 during the same period .
therefore @xmath459 is simply a statement of energy conservation between the detector and the field _ in this channel _ , and the interfering terms @xmath460 must be included so that @xmath461 is present on the right hand side instead of the naively expected @xmath462 . a simpler but more general derivation of this relation is given in appendix @xmath463 .
eq.@xmath459 also justifies that @xmath454 is indeed the correct form of the internal energy of the dressed detector . with the relation @xmath459
we can make two observations pertaining to results and procedures given before .
first , while the @xmath158-terms in @xmath464 ( eq.(@xmath165 ) ) and @xmath465 ( eq.(@xmath189 ) ) are not included in any figure of this paper , they are consistent with the conservation law @xmath459 .
actually the @xmath158-term in @xmath163 satisfy the driving - force - free equation of motion @xmath466 , just like the semiclassical @xmath216 does .
second , eq.@xmath459 implies that all the internal energy of the dressed detector dissipates via a monopole radiation , and the external agent which drives the detector along the trajectory @xmath141 has no additional influence on this channel . transforming @xmath420 to the form of @xmath421 by applying @xmath467-@xmath468
, one can calculate the radiation power @xmath469 following a similar argument in classical theory . before calculating ,
let us observe the behavior of the steady - state @xmath470 in the forward light cone .
as @xmath375 increses , the developments of two terms in late - time @xmath471 are illustrated in figs .
[ thxx1 ] and [ thpm1 ] .
it turns out that both are regular and non - vanishing at the null infinity of minkowski space ( @xmath472 ) even in steady state ( @xmath473 )
[ thxx1 ] and [ thpm1 ] also indicate that , near the the null infinity of minkowski space , almost all the equal-@xmath375 surface lies in the f - wedge , except the region around @xmath474 is still in the r - wedge .
the contribution to the integral around @xmath474 can be totally neglected because the value of @xmath470 is regular there while the measure for this portion in the angular integral is zero when @xmath472 .
so the radiation power can be written as @xmath475 \right\ } , \label{qradformula1}\ ] ] by inserting @xmath420 , @xmath476 and @xmath477 into @xmath478 .
this is the quantum radiation formula for the massless scalar field emitted by the uad in ( 3 + 1)d spacetime . at late times ( eq.([qtot ] ) with @xmath479 ) as the null distance @xmath375 increases .
the values of parameters are the same as before except that here we choose @xmath480 .
the horizontal line indicates the saturated value of @xmath481 shown in fig .
[ qqtot1 ] .
when @xmath375 starts with @xmath482 , @xmath483 decreases from @xmath484 ( top - left ) .
the light cone hits the event horizon at @xmath485 when @xmath486 , and @xmath487 always has the value @xmath432 at the event horizon ( top - right , the curve and the horizontal line intersect right at the event horizon ) . as @xmath375 further increases , @xmath488 sinks more and more ( bottom - left ) , and some oscillations begin to develop near @xmath485 . finally @xmath489 is non - vanishing at the null infinity @xmath490 , with the value smaller than @xmath444 whenever @xmath491 ( bottom - right).,title="fig:",width=226 ] at late times ( eq.([qtot ] ) with @xmath479 ) as the null distance @xmath375 increases .
the values of parameters are the same as before except that here we choose @xmath480 .
the horizontal line indicates the saturated value of @xmath481 shown in fig .
[ qqtot1 ] .
when @xmath375 starts with @xmath482 , @xmath483 decreases from @xmath484 ( top - left ) .
the light cone hits the event horizon at @xmath485 when @xmath486 , and @xmath487 always has the value @xmath432 at the event horizon ( top - right , the curve and the horizontal line intersect right at the event horizon ) . as @xmath375 further increases , @xmath488 sinks more and more ( bottom - left ) , and some oscillations begin to develop near @xmath485 .
finally @xmath489 is non - vanishing at the null infinity @xmath490 , with the value smaller than @xmath444 whenever @xmath491 ( bottom - right).,title="fig:",width=226 ] at late times ( eq.([qtot ] ) with @xmath479 ) as the null distance @xmath375 increases .
the values of parameters are the same as before except that here we choose @xmath480 .
the horizontal line indicates the saturated value of @xmath481 shown in fig .
[ qqtot1 ] .
when @xmath375 starts with @xmath482 , @xmath483 decreases from @xmath484 ( top - left ) .
the light cone hits the event horizon at @xmath485 when @xmath486 , and @xmath487 always has the value @xmath432 at the event horizon ( top - right , the curve and the horizontal line intersect right at the event horizon ) . as @xmath375 further increases , @xmath488 sinks more and more ( bottom - left ) , and some oscillations begin to develop near @xmath485 . finally @xmath489 is non - vanishing at the null infinity @xmath490 , with the value smaller than @xmath444 whenever @xmath491 ( bottom - right).,title="fig:",width=226 ] at late times ( eq.([qtot ] ) with @xmath479 ) as the null distance @xmath375 increases .
the values of parameters are the same as before except that here we choose @xmath480 .
the horizontal line indicates the saturated value of @xmath481 shown in fig .
[ qqtot1 ] .
when @xmath375 starts with @xmath482 , @xmath483 decreases from @xmath484 ( top - left ) .
the light cone hits the event horizon at @xmath485 when @xmath486 , and @xmath487 always has the value @xmath432 at the event horizon ( top - right , the curve and the horizontal line intersect right at the event horizon ) . as @xmath375 further increases , @xmath488 sinks more and more ( bottom - left ) , and some oscillations begin to develop near @xmath485 . finally @xmath489 is non - vanishing at the null infinity @xmath490 , with the value smaller than @xmath444 whenever @xmath491 ( bottom - right).,title="fig:",width=226 ] ( eq.(@xmath492 ) ) at late times as @xmath375 increases .
parameters are the same as those in fig .
[ thxx1 ] . when @xmath375 starts with @xmath482 , @xmath493 grows from @xmath482 ( top - left ) .
after the light cone hits the event horizon , @xmath493 keeps regular on the event horizon ( top - right , the vertical line indicates the position of the event horizon ) .
as @xmath375 further increases , a nodal point enters from the right ( bottom - left ) . then more and more nodal points can be seen .
finally @xmath493 is non - vanishing at the null infinity @xmath472 , with infinitely many nodal points close to @xmath485 ( bottom - right).,title="fig:",width=226 ] ( eq.(@xmath492 ) ) at late times as @xmath375 increases .
parameters are the same as those in fig .
[ thxx1 ] .
when @xmath375 starts with @xmath482 , @xmath493 grows from @xmath482 ( top - left ) .
after the light cone hits the event horizon , @xmath493 keeps regular on the event horizon ( top - right , the vertical line indicates the position of the event horizon ) .
as @xmath375 further increases , a nodal point enters from the right ( bottom - left ) . then more and more nodal points can be seen .
finally @xmath493 is non - vanishing at the null infinity @xmath472 , with infinitely many nodal points close to @xmath485 ( bottom - right).,title="fig:",width=226 ] ( eq.(@xmath492 ) ) at late times as @xmath375 increases .
parameters are the same as those in fig .
[ thxx1 ] . when @xmath375 starts with @xmath482 , @xmath493 grows from @xmath482 ( top - left ) .
after the light cone hits the event horizon , @xmath493 keeps regular on the event horizon ( top - right , the vertical line indicates the position of the event horizon ) .
as @xmath375 further increases , a nodal point enters from the right ( bottom - left )
. then more and more nodal points can be seen .
finally @xmath493 is non - vanishing at the null infinity @xmath472 , with infinitely many nodal points close to @xmath485 ( bottom - right).,title="fig:",width=226 ] ( eq.(@xmath492 ) ) at late times as @xmath375 increases .
parameters are the same as those in fig .
[ thxx1 ] . when @xmath375 starts with @xmath482 , @xmath493 grows from @xmath482 ( top - left ) .
after the light cone hits the event horizon , @xmath493 keeps regular on the event horizon ( top - right , the vertical line indicates the position of the event horizon ) .
as @xmath375 further increases , a nodal point enters from the right ( bottom - left )
. then more and more nodal points can be seen .
finally @xmath493 is non - vanishing at the null infinity @xmath472 , with infinitely many nodal points close to @xmath485 ( bottom - right).,title="fig:",width=226 ] at late times , while @xmath494 ceases , it still remains a positive radiated power flow @xmath495 \right\}\nonumber\\ & & = { \hbar\lambda_0 ^ 2 \over 8\pi^2 m_0 } \left\ { { a^3\over 3\omega_r^2 } -a % \right.\nonumber\\ & & \left .
-{2\over 3}\left [ { a^3\over \omega_r^2}-a + 2\gamma + { \rm
re}\left[{i(\gamma+i\omega)\over a\omega } \left [ ( \gamma+i\omega)^2-a^2\right ] \psi^{(1 ) } \left({\gamma+i\omega \over a}\right)\right]\right ] \right\ } \label{qmrad}\end{aligned}\ ] ] to the null infinity of minkowski space .
thus we conclude that there exists a steady , positive radiated power of quantum nature emitted by the detector even when the detector is in steady state
. for large @xmath1 , the first term in @xmath496 dominates , and the radiated power is approximately @xmath497 where @xmath498 is the unruh temperature .
this could be interpreted as a hint of the unruh effect .
note that it does not originate from the energy flux that the detector experiences in unruh effect , since the internal energy of the dressed detector is conserved only in relation to the radiated energy of a monopole radiation corresponding to @xmath494 .
learning from the em radiation emitted by a uniformly accelerated charge @xcite , we expect that the above non - vanishing radiated energy of quantum origin could be supplied by the external agent we introduced in the beginning to drive the motion of the detector .
further analysis on the quantum radiations of the detector involving the dynamics of the trajectory is still on - going .
we can recover the results in ref.@xcite , which is obtained by perturbation theory , as follows . in ref.@xcite , the first order approximation of the flux @xmath499 through the event horizon
@xmath351 has been calculated . here
, the expectation value of @xmath500 near the event horizon reads , from @xmath420 , @xmath501 g_{\rm ren}(x , x')|_{u\to 0}\nonumber\\ & = & { 2\lambda_0 ^ 2\over ( 2\pi)^2 a^4 \left(\rho^2+a^{-2}\right)^2 } \theta\left[-{1\over a}\ln { a\over v}\left(\rho^2+a^{-2}\right)-\tau_0\right ] \left\ { { 1\over v^2}\left<\right.\dot{q}(\tau_-)^2\left.\right>_{\rm tot}+ \right.\nonumber\\ & & \left.\left .
{ \rho^2\over ( \rho^2+a^{-2})^2 } \left [ a^2 \left<\right.q(\tau_-)^2\left.\right>_{\rm tot } + a \left < \right . \dot{q}(\tau_-)q(\tau_-)+q(\tau_-)\dot{q}(\tau_-)\left.\right>_{\rm tot } + \left<\right.\dot{q}(\tau_-)^2\left.\right>_{\rm tot}\right ] \right\ } \right|_{u\to 0},\label{powerflux}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in which @xmath502 and @xmath503 terms vanish . by letting @xmath504 with @xmath412 finite ,
then taking @xmath505 , the total variance @xmath445 becomes @xmath506\right\ } \nonumber\\ & \stackrel{\eta_-\to \infty}{\longrightarrow } & { \hbar\omega_r\over m_0(1-e^{2\pi\omega_r / a } ) } , \label{wrong}\end{aligned}\ ] ] owing to @xmath197 , @xmath450 and @xmath408 .
this is identical to the corresponding part of eq.(66 ) in ref.@xcite , @xmath507 by noting that there , @xmath172 , @xmath508 , and @xmath509 there is equal to @xmath510 here .
the monopole radiation corresponding to @xmath511 looks like a constant negative flux since @xmath512 .
accordingly it was concluded in ref.@xcite that such a quantum monopole radiation could be experimentally distinguishable from the bremsstrahlung of the detector . at first glance
this constant monopole radiation seems to contradict the knowledge gained from ( 1 + 1)d results .
but actually similar results for ( 1 + 1)d cases were also obtained by massar and parentani ( mp ) @xcite , who found that a detector initially prepared in the ground state and coupled to a field under a smooth switching function does emit radiation during thermalization .
they pointed out that the radiated flux in what they refered to as the golden rule limit " ( @xmath164 with @xmath513 small , while the switching function becomes nearly constant ) is approximately a constant negative flux for all @xmath514 . in spite of the long interaction time and the nearly constant radiated flux
, the detector will remain in dis - equilibrium .
note that the initial conditions in @xcite are similar to those in sec.ii of mp , and the limiting condition for obtaining @xmath515 is exactly what mp assumed there .
hence , the constant negative flux in @xcite is essentially a transient effect , which exists only in the period that the above stated condition holds .
when the interaction time @xmath195 exceeds @xmath516 , this approximation breaks down . to obtain the correct late - time behavior
, one should take the limit @xmath505 before @xmath504 .
then @xmath517 goes to zero .
in this paper , we consider the unruh - dewitt detector theory in ( 3 + 1 ) dimensional spacetime .
a uniformly accelerated detector is modeled by a harmonic oscillator @xmath3 linearly coupled with a massless scalar field @xmath9 . the cases with the coupling constant @xmath518 less than the renormalized natural frequency @xmath519 of the detector are considered .
we solved exactly the evolution equations for the combined system of a moving detector coupled to a quantum field in the heisenberg picture , and from the evolution of the operators we can obtain complete information on the combined system . for the case
that the initial state is a direct product of a coherent state for the detector and the minkowski vacuum for the field , we worked out the exact two - point functions of the detector and similar functions of the field . by applying the coherent state for the detector , we can distinguish the classical behaviors from others .
the quantum part of the coincidence limit of two - point functions , namely , the variances of @xmath3 and @xmath9 , are determined by the detector and the field together . from the exact solutions , we were able to study the complete process from the initial transient to the final steady state . in particular , we can identify the time scales of transient behaviors analytically . when the coupling is turned on ,
the zero - point fluctuations of the free detector dissipates exponentially , then the vacuum fluctuations take over .
the time scales for both processes are the same .
eventually the variance of @xmath3 saturates at a finite value , where the dissipation of the detector is balanced by the input from the vacuum fluctuations of the field . even in the zero - acceleration limit , the variances of @xmath3 and @xmath184 , thus the ground state energy of the interacting detector , shifted from the ones for the free detector .
this fluctuations - induced effect share a similar origin with that of the lamb shift .
the variance of @xmath3 yields an effective squared scalar charge , which induce a positive variance in the scalar field .
this variance of the field contributes a positive radiated energy at the quantum level .
however , the interference between the vacuum fluctuations and the retarded solution induced by the vacuum fluctuations screens part of the emission of quantum radiation .
the time scale of the screening is proportional to @xmath363 for @xmath520 , where @xmath1 is the proper acceleration and @xmath521 is the damping constant proportional to @xmath522 .
after the screening the renormalized green s functions of the field are still non - zero in steady state . a quantum radiation formula determined at the null infinity of minkowski space has been derived .
we found that even in steady state there exists a positive radiated power of quantum nature emitted by the uniformly accelerated ud detector . for large @xmath1
the radiated power is proportional to @xmath523 , where @xmath498 is the unruh temperature .
this could be interpreted as a hint of the unruh effect .
however , the nearly constant negative flux obtained in ref.@xcite for ( 3 + 1)d case is essentially a transient effect .
only part of the radiation is connected to the internal energy of the detector .
the total energy of the dressed detector and the radiated energy of a monopole radiation from the detector is conserved for every proper time interval after the coupling is turned on .
the external agent which drives the detector s motion has no additional influence on this channel .
since the corresponding monopole radiation of quantum nature ceases in steady state , the hint of the unruh effect in the late - time radiated power is not directly from the energy flux experienced by the detector in unruh effect .
this extends the result in ref.@xcite that there is no emitted radiation of quantum origin in unruh effect in ( 1 + 1 ) dimensional spacetime . since all the relevant quantum and statistical information about the detector ( atom ) and
the field can be obtained from the results presented here , when appropriately generalized , they are expected to be useful for addressing issues in atomic and optical schemes of quantum information processing , such as quantum decoherence , entanglement and teleportation .
these investigations are in progress .
@xmath524 * acknowledgments * blh thanks alpan raval and mei - ling tseng for discussions in an earlier preliminary attempt on the 3 + 1 problem .
we appreciate the referees queries and suggestions for improvements on the presentation of this paper . this work is supported in part by the nsc taiwan under grant nsc93 - 2112-m-001 - 014 and by the us nsf under grant phy03 - 00710 and phy-0426696 .
from @xmath291 in @xmath338 , it is easy to see that @xmath525 . \label{phi1phi1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the @xmath526-functions at @xmath527 , coming from the derivative of the step functions , have been neglected here . with @xmath347
, one can write down in closed form of the interfering terms in the r - wedge of the rindler space . under the coincidence limit , it looks like , @xmath528 + ( x\leftrightarrow x')\right\}\nonumber\\&= & { \hbar\lambda_0 ^ 2\theta(\eta_-)\over(2\pi)^3 m_0 a^2 x^2 } \left[\eta_{-,\mu}\eta_{-,\nu}\theta_{--}+ { x_{,\mu}x_{,\nu}\over x^2}\theta_{xx } -{x_{,\mu}\over x}\eta_{-,\nu}\theta_{x- } - \eta_{-,\mu}{x_{,\nu}\over x } \theta_{-x}\right.\nonumber\\ & & \left .
+ \eta_{-,\mu}\eta_{+,\nu}\theta_{-+}+ \eta_{+,\mu}\eta_{-,\nu}\theta_{+- } - { x_{,\mu}\over x}\eta_{+,\nu } \theta_{x+ } - \eta_{+,\mu}{x_{,\nu}\over x}\theta_{+x}\right].\label{xterm}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath529,\label{th11}\\ \theta_{xx } & = & % -{a\over \omega_r^2 } ? ? + { 2\over \omega } { \rm re } \left [ i\psi_{\gamma+i\omega}+ { ia\over\gamma+i\omega+a } e^{-(\gamma+i\omega+a)\eta_- } f_{\gamma+i\omega}(e^{-a\eta_- } ) \right]+2 { \cal f}_0(x),\label{th00}\\ \theta_{-x}&= & \theta_{x- } = -{a\over\omega}{e^{-\gamma\eta_-}\over e^{a\eta_-}-1 } \sin\omega\eta_- + { \cal f}_1(x),\label{thmx}\\ \theta_{+x } & = & \theta_{x+ } = { a\over\omega}{e^{-\gamma\eta_-}\over \pm e^{a\eta_+}-1 } \sin\omega\eta_- - { \cal f}_1(x),\label{thpx}\\ \theta_{+- } & = & \theta_{-+}= -{a\over\omega}{e^{-\gamma\eta_-}\over \pm e^{a\eta_+}-1 } \left(\gamma\sin\omega\eta_-
-\omega\cos\omega\eta_-\right)- { a \over \pm e^{a(\eta_+-\eta_-)}-1 } + { \cal f}_2(x),\label{thpm}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath530 \right\},\ ] ] with @xmath531 and @xmath532 for @xmath303 in r and f - wedge , respectively .
note that @xmath460 is independent of @xmath322 .
@xmath437 is actually proportional to @xmath296 in @xmath323 .
another observation is that , combining @xmath401 and @xmath402 , one finds that the divergent @xmath208 term in @xmath460 is canceled by the one in @xmath533 . as for @xmath403 ,
the result is similar to @xmath401 with @xmath534 being replaced by @xmath535 .
again it splits into the quantum and semiclassical parts as in sec.iv b.
the conservation law @xmath459 is directly obtained by arranging our somewhat complicated results .
it can also be derived in a simpler way as follows . from the definition of the ground - state energy @xmath454 of the dressed detector ,
its first derivative of @xmath7 is @xmath536\ ] ] introducing the equations of motion @xmath98 and @xmath119 to eliminate @xmath537 , one has @xmath538\right>_{\rm v } + \omega_r^2 \left<\right.q(\tau)\dot{q}(\tau)\left.\right>_{\rm v}\right .
\nonumber\\ & & \left.+ \left<\dot{q}(\tau)\left[-2\gamma\dot{q}(\tau)- \omega_r^2 q(\tau)\right]\right>_{\rm a}+ \omega_r^2 \left<\right.q(\tau)\dot{q}(\tau)\left.\right>_{\rm a}\right\}\nonumber\\ & = & -2\gamma m_0 \left<\right.\dot{q}^2(\tau)\left.\right > + \lambda_0 { \rm re}\left<\right.\dot{q}(\tau)\phi_0(y(\tau))\left.\right>_{\rm v } , \label{dotenergy}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the last term is a short - hand for @xmath539 ( there is an additional term @xmath540 if a background field @xmath541 is present . ) substituting @xmath147 and @xmath148 into @xmath542 , integrating out @xmath543 with the help of eq.@xmath186 , then comparing with @xmath544 in @xmath402 where @xmath545 has the formal expression @xmath546 , one finds that @xmath542 is actually identical to @xmath547 .
hence @xmath548 integrating both side from @xmath549 to @xmath550 , one ends up with eq.@xmath459 . c. r. galley and b. l. hu , phys .
rev . * d72 * , 084023 ( 2005 ) ; c. r. galley , b. l. hu and s .- y .
lin , electromagnetic and gravitational self - force on a relativistic particle from quantum fields in curved space " [ gr - qc/0603099 ] . | in this paper we analyze the interaction of a uniformly accelerated detector with a quantum field in ( 3 + 1)d spacetime , aiming at the issue of how kinematics can render vacuum fluctuations the appearance of thermal radiance in the detector ( unruh effect ) and how they engender flux of radiation for observers afar .
two basic questions are addressed in this study : a ) how are vacuum fluctuations related to the emitted radiation ?
b ) is there emitted radiation with energy flux in the unruh effect ?
we adopt a method which places the detector and the field on an equal footing and derive the two - point correlation functions of the detector and of the field separately with full account of their interplay . from the exact solutions , we are able to study the complete process from the initial transient to the final steady state ,
keeping track of all activities they engage in and the physical effects manifested .
we derive a quantum radiation formula for a minkowski observer .
we find that there does exist a positive radiated power of quantum nature emitted by the detector , with a hint of certain features of the unruh effect .
we further verify that the total energy of the dressed detector and a part of the radiated energy from the detector is conserved .
however , this part of the radiation ceases in steady state .
so the hint of the unruh effect in radiated power is actually not directly from the energy flux that the detector experiences in unruh effect . since all the relevant quantum and statistical information about the detector ( atom ) and
the field can be obtained from the results presented here , they are expected to be useful , when appropriately generalized , for addressing issues of quantum information processing in atomic and optical systems , such as quantum decoherence , entanglement and teleportation . |
the chiral potts model was originally introduced @xcite to model the full phase diagram of krypton monolayers , including the epitaxial and incommensurate ordered phases . in addition to being useful in the analysis of surface layers , the chiral potts model has become an important model of phase transitions and critical phenomena .
we have studied the chiral spin - glass potts system with @xmath0 states in @xmath1 and 3 spatial dimensions by renormalization - group theory and calculated the global phase diagrams in temperature , chirality concentration @xmath2 , and chirality - breaking concentration @xmath3 , also quantitatively determining phase chaos and phase - boundary chaos . in the @xmath9 ,
the system has ferromagnetic , left - chiral , right - chiral , chiral spin - glass , and disordered phases .
the phase boundaries to the ferromagnetic , left- and right - chiral phases show , differently , an unusual , fibrous patchwork ( microreentrances ) of all four ( ferromagnetic , left - chiral , right - chiral , chiral spin - glass ) ordered phases , especially in the multicritical region .
the chaotic behavior of the interactions , under scale change , is determined in the chiral spin - glass phase and on the boundary between the chiral spin - glass and disordered phases , showing lyapunov exponents in magnitudes reversed from the usual ferromagnetic - antiferromagnetic spin - glass systems . at low temperatures , the boundaries of the left- and right - chiral phases become thresholded in @xmath2 and @xmath3 . in the @xmath1 ,
the chiral spin - glass system does not have a spin - glass phase , consistently with the lower - critical dimension of ferromagnetic - antiferromagnetic spin glasses .
the left- and right - chirally ordered phases show reentrance in chirality concentration @xmath2 .
the chiral potts model is defined by the hamiltonian @xmath10,\ ] ] where @xmath11 , at site @xmath12 the spin @xmath13 can be in @xmath14 different states with implicit periodic labeling , e.g. @xmath15 implying @xmath16 , the delta function @xmath17 for @xmath18 , and @xmath19 denotes summation over all nearest - neighbor pairs of sites .
the upper and lower subscripts of @xmath20 give left - handed and right - handed chirality ( corresponding to heavy and superheavy domain walls in the krypton - on - graphite incommensurate ordering @xcite ) , whereas @xmath21 gives the non - chiral potts model ( relevant to the krypton - on - graphite epitaxial ordering @xcite ) . in the chiral potts spin - glass model studied here ,
the chirality of each nearest - neighbor interaction is randomly either left - handed , or right - handed , or zero .
this randomness is frozen ( quenched ) into the system and the overall fraction of left- , right- , and non - chirality is controlled by the quenched densities @xmath2 and @xmath3 as described below .
thus , the hamiltonian of the chiral potts spin - glass model is @xmath22,\end{gathered}\ ] ] where , for each pair of nearest - neighbor sites @xmath23 @xmath24 ( non - chiral ) or 1 ( chiral ) . in the latter case , @xmath25 ( left - handed ) or 0 ( right - handed ) .
thus , non - chiral , left - chiral , and right - chiral nearest - neighbor interactions are frozen randomly distributed in the entire system . for the entire system ,
the overall concentration of chiral interactions is given by @xmath2 , with @xmath26 . among the chiral interactions ,
the overall concentrations of left- and right - chiral interactions are respectively given by @xmath3 and @xmath27 , with @xmath28 .
thus , the model is chiral for @xmath29 and chiral - symmetric @xmath6 , chiral - symmetry broken for @xmath30 .
the global phase diagram is given in terms of temperature @xmath5 , chirality concentration @xmath2 , and chirality - breaking concentration @xmath3 .
under the renormalization - group transformations described below , the hamiltonian given in eq.(2 ) maps onto the more general form @xmath31,\end{gathered}\ ] ] where for each pair of nearest - neighbor sites @xmath32 , the largest of the interaction constants @xmath33 is set to zero , by subtracting a constant g from each of @xmath33 , with no effect to the physics .
we solve the chiral potts spin - glass model with @xmath0 states by renormalization - group theory , in @xmath34 spatial dimension and with the length rescaling factor @xmath35 .
our solution is , simultaneously , the migdal - kadanoff approximation @xcite for the cubic lattice and exact @xcite for the @xmath34 hierarchical lattice based on the leftmost graph of fig .
2 . hierarchical lattice . for the @xmath36 ,
the number of parallel strands is 2 instead of 4 shown here . ]
to which all of the points in the chiral spin - glass phase are attracted under renormalization - group transformations , a.k.a .
the sink of the chiral spin - glass phase .
the average interactions @xmath37 diverge to negative infinity as @xmath38 , where @xmath39 is the number of renormalization - group iterations and @xmath40 is the runaway exponent , while @xmath41 ( see sec .
ii ) . the other two distributions @xmath42 and @xmath43 have the same sink distribution . thus , in the chiral spin - glass phase , chiral symmetry is broken by local order , but not globally . ]
the local renormalization - group transformation is achieved by a sequence , shown in fig . 1 , of decimations @xmath44 where @xmath45 , etc . , and @xmath46 is the subtractive constant mentioned in the previous section , and bond movings @xmath47 where primes mark the interactions of the renormalized system .
the starting trimodal quenched probability distribution of the interactions , characterized by @xmath2 and @xmath3 as described above , is not conserved under rescaling .
the renormalized quenched probability distribution of the interactions is obtained by the convolution @xcite @xmath48 } \delta(\textbf{j}(i'j')-\textbf{r}(\left\{\textbf{j}(ij)\right\})),\end{gathered}\ ] ] where @xmath49 and @xmath50 represents the bond decimation and bond moving given in eqs.(4 ) and ( 5 ) .
similar previous studies , on other spin - glass systems , are in refs .
exact calculations on hierarchical lattices @xcite are also currently widely used on a variety of statistical mechanics problems @xcite . for numerical practicality , the bond moving of eq .
( 5 ) is achieved by two sequential pairwise combination of interactions , each pairwise combination leading to an intermediate probability distribution resulting from a pairwise convolution as in eq.(6 ) .
furthermore , due to our convention of zeroing the largest interaction constant in each local triplet of interactions , the quenched probability distribution of three interactions @xmath51 is conveniently just composed of the three probability distributions of two interactions , @xmath52 , where @xmath53 has the ( largest ) interaction @xmath54 etc . , which also considerably simplifies the numerical calculation .
we effect this procedure numerically , by representing each probability distribution by histograms , as in previous studies @xcite .
the probability distributions of two interactions @xmath53 , @xmath42 , and @xmath55 are represented via bivariate histograms with two - dimensional vectors @xmath56 for @xmath57 , etc .
the number of histograms grow rapidly with each renormalization - group transformation , so that for calculational purposes , the histograms are binned when the number of histograms outgrow @xmath58 bins . in the calculation of chiral spin - glass phase - sink fixed distribution of fig . 5
, the histograms are binned after @xmath59 histograms .
the different thermodynamic phases of the model are identified by the different asymptotic renormalization - group flows of the quenched probability distribution . for all renormalization - group flows ,
originating inside the phases and on the phase boundaries , eq.(6 ) is iterated until asymptotic behavior is reached .
thus , we are able to calculate the global phase diagram of the chiral potts spin - glass model .
the calculated global phase diagram of the @xmath34 chiral potts spin - glass system , in temperature @xmath5 , chirality concentration @xmath2 , and chirality - breaking concentration @xmath3 , is given in fig .
the ferromagnetically ordered ( f ) phase occurs at low temperature and low chirality @xmath2 .
the chiral spin - glass ordered ( s ) phase occurs at intermediate chirality @xmath2 for all @xmath3 and at high chirality @xmath2 for intermediate @xmath3 . the left- and right - chirally ordered phases l and r occur at high chirality @xmath2 and values of chirality - breaking @xmath3 away from 0.5 .
the disordered phase ( d ) occurs at high temperature .
the global phase diagram is mirror - symmetric with respect to the chirality - breaking concentration @xmath6 , so that only @xmath60 is shown in fig .
1 . in the ( not shown ) mirror - symmetric @xmath8 portion of the global phase diagram , the right - chirally
ordered phase ( r ) occurs in the place of the left - chirally ordered phase ( l ) seen in fig .
different cross - sections of the global phase diagram are shown in in figs . 3 and 4 .
under renormalization - group transformations , all points in the spin - glass phase are attracted to a fixed probability distribution of the quenched random interactions @xmath61 , namely to the sink of the chiral spin - glass phase . as explained in sec .
iii , @xmath61 is composed of three distributions , @xmath53 , @xmath42 , and @xmath43 . of these , @xmath53 gives the quenched probability distribution of nearest - neighbor interactions in which the ferromagnetic interaction @xmath62 is dominant .
similarly , @xmath42 and @xmath43 give the quenched probability distributions of nearest - neighbor interactions in which , respectively , the left - chiral interaction @xmath63 and the right - chiral interaction @xmath64 are dominant .
( as explained in sec .
ii , by subtraction of an overall constant , the dominant interaction is set to zero and the other two , subdominant interactions are therefore negative , with no loss of generality . )
the sink fixed distribution for @xmath53 is given in fig . 5 , where the average interactions @xmath37 diverge to negative infinity as @xmath65 , where @xmath39 is the number of renormalization - group iterations and @xmath40 is the runaway exponent , while conserving the shape of the distribution shown in fig .
5 . the other two distribution @xmath42 and @xmath43 have the same sink distribution .
thus , in the chiral spin - glass phase , chiral symmetry is broken by local order , but not globally . and the average interaction diverges as @xmath66 , where @xmath39 is the number of renormalization - group iterations and @xmath40 is the runaway exponent .
top panel : at the phase boundary between the chiral spin - glass and disordered phases .
the corresponding lyapunov exponent is @xmath67 and the average non - zero interaction is fixed at @xmath68 .
the relative value of the lyapunov exponents is unusual for spin - glass systems . ] in spin - glass phases , at a specific location in the lattice , the consecutive interactions , encountered under consecutive renormalization - group transformations , behave chaotically @xcite .
this chaotic behavior was found @xcite and subsequently well established @xcite in spin - glass systems with competing ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic interactions .
we find here that the chaotic rescaling behavior also occurs in our current spin - glass system with competing left- and right - chiral interactions , as shown in fig .
in fact , the chaotic rescaling behavior occurs not only within the spin - glass phase , but also , quantitatively distinctly , at the phase boundary between the spin - glass and disordered phases @xcite .
this chaotic behavior at the phase boundary is also seen in the chiral system here and also shown in fig .
it has been shown that chaos in the interaction as a function of rescaling implies chaos in the spin - spin correlation function as a function of distance @xcite .
chaos in the spin - glass phase and at its phase boundary are identified and distinguished by different lyapunov exponents @xcite .
we have calculated the lyapunov exponent @xcite @xmath69 where @xmath70 at step @xmath71 of the renormalization - group trajectory .
the sum in eq.(7 ) is to be taken within the asymptotic chaotic band , which is renormalization - group stable or unstable for the phase or its boundary , respectively .
thus , we throw out the first 100 renormalization - group iterations to eliminate the transient points outside of , but leading to the chaotic band . subsequently , typically using 1,000 renormalization - group iterations in the sum in eq.(7 )
assures the convergence of the lyapunov exponent value .
we have calculated the lyapunov exponents @xmath72 and 1.94 respectively for the chiral spin - glass phase and for the boundary between the chiral spin - glass and disordered phases . at the chiral spin - glass phase - sink fixed distribution
, the average interaction diverges to negative infinity as @xmath73 , where @xmath39 is the number of renormalization - group iterations and @xmath40 is the runaway exponent . at the fixed distribution of the phase boundary between the chiral spin - glass and disordered phases ,
the average interaction remains fixed at @xmath74 .
interestingly , chaos is stronger at the boundary ( larger lyapunov exponent ) than inside the chiral spin - glass phase .
the opposite is seen in the usually studied @xmath75 ferromagnetic - antiferromagnetic spin glass @xcite . by contrast , in each of the ferromagnetic ( f ) , left - chiral ( l ) , and right - chiral ( r ) ordered phases , under consecutive renormalization - group transformations , the quenched probability distribution of the interactions sharpens to a delta function around a single value receding to negative infinity , for the respective pairs of interactions , namely ( @xmath76 , and @xmath77 .
there is no asymptotic chaotic behavior under renormalization - group in these phases f , l , and r. cross - sections of the global phase diagram , in temperature @xmath5 and chirality concentration @xmath2 , are given in fig .
the chirality - breaking concentration @xmath3 is indicated for each cross - section .
note that , as soon as the chiral symmetry of the model is broken by @xmath78 , a narrow fibrous patchwork ( microreentrances ) of all four ( ferromagnetic , left - chiral , right - chiral , chiral spin - glass ) ordered phases intervenes at the boundaries between the ferromagnetically ordered phase f and the spin - glass phase s or the disordered phase d. this intervening region is more pronounced close to the multicritical region where the ferromagnetic , spin - glass , and disordered phases meet .
the interlacing phase transitions inside this region are more clearly seen in the right - hand side panels of fig .
3 , where only the phase boundaries are drawn in black . this intervening region gains importance as @xmath3 moves away from 0.5 .
but it is only at higher values of the chirality - breaking concentration @xmath3 , such as @xmath79 on the figure , that the chirally ordered phase appears as a compact region at @xmath80 . in this case , again all four ( ferromagnetic , left - chiral , right - chiral , chiral spin - glass ) ordered phases intervene in a narrow fibrous patchwork at the boundaries of the chirally ordered phases l and r , the latter mirror symmetric and not shown here . for @xmath81 ,
for which all interactions of the system are , with respective concentrations @xmath82 and @xmath2 , either ferromagnetic , or left - chiral , the phase diagram becomes symmetric with respect to @xmath83 as in standard ferromagnetic - antiferromagnetic spin - glass systems @xcite , except that the chirally ordered phases dominate the fibrous patchwork on both sides of the phase diagram .
cross - sections , in chirality concentration @xmath2 and chirality - breaking concentration @xmath3 , of the global phase diagram are given in fig .
4 . the temperature @xmath5 is given on each cross - section . note the narrow fibrous patches of all four ( ferromagnetic , left - chiral , right - chiral , chiral spin - glass ) phases intervening at the boundaries of the ferromagnetically ordered phase f and at the boundaries of the chirally ordered phases l and r. it is seen here that , within these regions , the chirally ordered phases l and r form elongated lamellar patterns .
the interlacing phase transitions inside this region are more clearly seen in the right - hand side panels of the figure , where only the phase boundaries are drawn in black .
it is again seen that the symmetry around @xmath83 at the upper horizontal frame @xmath84 of each panel is broken inside the panel @xmath85 .
also note the temperature - independent square shape , at low temperatures , of the phase boundary of the chirally ordered phases l and r , creating the threshold value of @xmath86 and @xmath87 or 0.16 into l or r , respectively .
this is also visible in the three - dimensional fig . 1 .
the global phase diagram of the @xmath1 chiral potts spin - glass system is given in fig .
representative cross - sections in temperature @xmath5 and chirality concentration @xmath2 are shown .
the chirality - breaking concentration @xmath3 is given on each cross - section .
the ferromagnetically ordered phase ( f ) , the left - chirally ordered phase ( l ) , and the disordered phase ( d ) are marked .
no chiral spin - glass phase occurs in @xmath1 and no fibrous patchwork is seen at the phase boundaries .
the chirally ordered phase appears for very high chirality - breaking concentration @xmath3 ( seen here for @xmath88 , but not seen for @xmath89 ) and shows reentrance @xcite in chirality concentration @xmath2 .
this reentrance disappears as @xmath90 is approached . for @xmath81 ,
for which all interactions of the system are , with respective concentrations @xmath82 and @xmath2 , either ferromagnetic , or left - chiral , the phase diagram becomes symmetric with respect to @xmath83 as in standard ferromagnetic - antiferromagnetic spin - glass systems @xcite .
the absence of the chiral spin - glass phase in @xmath36 is consistent with standard ferromagnetic - antiferromagnetic ising spin - glass systems , where the lower - critical dimension for the spin - glass phase is found around 2.5 @xcite . below this dimension ,
no spin - glass phase appears ( unless some nano - restructuring is done to the system @xcite ) .
we have thus obtained the global phase diagram of the chiral spin - glass potts system with @xmath0 states in @xmath34 and 2 spatial dimensions by renormalization - group theory that is approximate for the cubic lattice and exact for the hierarchical lattice .
unusual features have been revealed in @xmath34 .
the phase boundaries to the ferromagnetic , left- and right - chiral phases show , differently , an unusual , fibrous patchwork ( microreentrances ) of all four ( ferromagnetic , left - chiral , right - chiral , chiral spin - glass ) ordered phases , especially in the multicritical region . in @xmath34 , there is a chiral spin - glass phase .
quite unusually , the phase boundary between the chiral spin - glass and disordered phases is more chaotic than the chiral spin - glass phase itself , as judged by the magnitudes of the respective lyapunov exponents . at low temperatures ,
the boundaries of the left- and right - chiral phases become temperature - independent and thresholded in chirality concentration @xmath2 and chirality - breaking concentration @xmath3 . in the @xmath1
, the chiral spin - glass system does not have a spin - glass phase , consistently with the lower - critical dimension of ferromagnetic - antiferromagnetic spin glasses .
the left- and right - chirally ordered phases show reentrance in chirality concentration @xmath2 .
s. ostlund , phys . rev . * 24 * , 398 ( 1981 ) .
m. kardar and a. n. berker , phys .
* 48 * , 1552 ( 1982 ) .
d. a. huse and m. e. fisher , phys .
rev . lett . * 49 * , 793 ( 1982 ) .
d. huse and m. e. fisher , phys .
* 29 * , 239 ( 1984 ) .
r. g. caflisch , a. n. berker , and m. kardar , phys .
b * 31 * , 4527 ( 1985 ) .
a. n. berker , s. ostlund , and f. a. putnam , phys . rev .
b * 17 * , 1508 ( 1976 ) . a. n. berker and s. ostlund , j. phys .
c * 12 * , 4961 ( 1979 ) .
r. b. griffiths and m. kaufman , phys .
b * 26 * , 5022r ( 1982 ) .
m. kaufman and r. b. griffiths , phys .
b * 30 * , 244 ( 1984 ) . s. r. mckay and a. n. berker , phys . rev .
b * 29 * , 1315 ( 1984 ) .
m. hinczewski and a. n. berker , phys .
e * 73 * , 066126 ( 2006 ) .
m. j. p. gingras and e. s. srensen , phys .
b. * 46 * , 3441 ( 1992 ) .
g. migliorini and a. n. berker , phys .
b. * 57 * , 426 ( 1998 ) .
m. j. p. gingras and e. s. srensen , phys .
b. * 57 * , 10264 ( 1998 ) .
m. hinczewski and a.n .
berker , phys .
b * 72 * , 144402 ( 2005 ) . c. n. kaplan and a. n. berker , phys . rev .
lett . * 100 * , 027204 ( 2008 ) . c. gven , a. n. berker , m. hinczewski , and h. nishimori , phys .
e * 77 * , 061110 ( 2008 ) .
m. ohzeki , h. nishimori , and a. n. berker , phys .
e * 77 * , 061116 ( 2008 ) . v. o. zelik and a. n. berker , phys
e * 78 * , 031104 ( 2008 ) .
g. glpinar and a. n. berker , phys .
e * 79 * , 021110 ( 2009 ) .
kaplan , m. hinczewski , and a.n .
berker , phys .
e * 79 * , 061120 ( 2009 ) .
e. ilker and a. n. berker , phys .
e * 87 * , 032124 ( 2013 ) .
e. ilker and a. n. berker , phys .
e * 89 * , 042139 ( 2014 ) .
e. ilker and a. n. berker , phys .
e * 90 * , 062112 ( 2014 ) .
m. demirta , a. tuncer , and a. n. berker , phys .
e * 92 * , 022136 ( 2015 ) .
m. kaufman and h. t. diep , phys .
e * 84 * , 051106 ( 2011 ) .
m. kotorowicz and y. kozitsky , cond .
matter phys .
* 14 * , 13801 ( 2011 ) .
j. barre , j. stat .
146 * , 359 ( 2012 ) . c. monthus and t. garel , j. stat .
mech . - theory and experiment , p05002 ( 2012 ) .
z. z. zhang , y. b. sheng , z. y. hu , and g. r. chen , chaos * 22 * , 043129 ( 2012 ) . s .-
chang and r. shrock , phys .
a * 377 * , 671 ( 2013 ) .
xu , l .- s .
wang , and x .- m . kong , phys .
a * 87 * , 012312 ( 2013 ) .
s. hwang , d .- s .
lee , and b. kahng , phys .
e * 87 * , 022816 ( 2013 ) .
r. f. s. andrade and h. j. herrmann , phys .
e * 87 * , 042113 ( 2013 ) .
r. f. s. andrade and h. j. herrmann , phys .
e * 88 * , 042122 ( 2013 ) . c. monthus and t. garel , j. stat .
phys . - theory and experiment , p06007 ( 2013 ) . o. melchert and a. k. hartmann , eur .
j. b * 86 * , 323 ( 2013 ) .
fortin , j. phys .- condensed matter * 25 * , 296004 ( 2013 ) .
y. h. wu , x. li , z. z. zhang , and z. h. rong , chaos solitons fractals * 56 * , 91 ( 2013 ) .
p. n. timonin , low temp . phys . * 40 * , 36 ( 2014 ) .
b. derrida and g. giacomin , j. stat .
* 154 * , 286 ( 2014 ) .
m. f. thorpe and r. b. stinchcombe , philos .
royal soc . a - math .
sciences * 372 * , 20120038 ( 2014 ) .
a. efrat and m. schwartz , physica * 414 * , 137 ( 2014 ) . c. monthus and t. garel , phys .
b * 89 * , 184408 ( 2014 ) . t. nogawa and t. hasegawa , phys . rev .
e * 89 * , 042803 ( 2014 ) .
m. l. lyra , f. a. b. f. de moura , i. n. de oliveira , and m. serva , phys .
e * 89 * , 052133 ( 2014 ) . v. singh and s. boettcher , phys .
e * 90 * , 012117 ( 2014 ) .
xu , x. zhang , z .- q .
liu , k. xiang - mu , and r. ting - qi , eur .
j. b * 87 * , 132 ( 2014 ) .
y. hirose , a. oguchi , and y. fukumoto , j. phys .
japan * 83 * , 074716 ( 2014 ) .
v. s. t. silva , r. f. s. andrade , and s. r. salinas , phys .
e * 90 * , 052112 ( 2014 ) .
y. hotta , phys .
e * 90 * , 052821 ( 2014 ) .
s. boettcher , s. falkner , and r. portugal , phys .
rev . a * 91 * 052330 ( 2015 ) .
s. boettcher and c. t. brunson , eur .
* 110 * , 26005 ( 2015 ) .
y. hirose , a. ogushi , and y. fukumoto , j. phys .
japan * 84 * , 104705 ( 2015 ) .
s. boettcher and l. shanshan , j. phys .
a * 48 * , 415001 ( 2015 ) .
a. nandy and a. chakrabarti , phys
. lett . * 379 * , 43 ( 2015 ) .
s. r. mckay , a. n. berker , and s. kirkpatrick , phys .
lett . * 48 * , 767 ( 1982 ) .
s. r. mckay , a. n. berker , and s. kirkpatrick , j. appl .
phys . * 53 * , 7974 ( 1982 ) . a. n. berker and s. r. mckay , j. stat
* 36 * , 787 ( 1984 ) .
a. j. bray and m. a. moore , phys .
lett . * 58 * , 57 ( 1987 ) .
e. j. hartford and s. r. mckay , j. appl .
70 , 6068 ( 1991 ) .
m. nifle and h. j. hilhorst , phys .
lett . * 68 * , 2992 ( 1992 ) . m. nifle and h. j. hilhorst , physica a * 194 * , 462 ( 1993 ) . m. cieplak , m. s. li , and j. r. banavar , phys . rev .
b * 47 * , 5022 ( 1993 ) .
f. krzakala , europhys . lett . * 66 * , 847 ( 2004 ) .
f. krzakala and j. p. bouchaud , europhys . lett . * 72 * , 472 ( 2005 ) .
m. sasaki , k. hukushima , h. yoshino , and h. takayama , phys .
* 95 * , 267203 ( 2005 ) .
j. lukic , e. marinari , o. c. martin , and s. sabatini , j. stat .
mech . : theory exp .
l10001 ( 2006 ) .
le doussal , phys .
lett . * 96 * , 235702 ( 2006 ) .
t. rizzo and h. yoshino , phys .
b * 73 * , 064416 ( 2006 ) . h. g. katzgraber and f. krzakala , phys . rev
. lett . * 98 * , 017201 ( 2007 ) .
h. yoshino and t. rizzo , phys .
b * 77 * , 104429 ( 2008 ) . j. h. pixley and a. p.
young , phys rev b * 78 * , 014419 ( 2008 ) .
t. aspelmeier , phys .
lett . * 100 * , 117205 ( 2008 ) .
t. aspelmeier , j. phys .
a * 41 * , 205005 ( 2008 ) .
t. mora and l. zdeborova , j. stat .
phys . * 131 * , 1121 ( 2008 ) . n. aral and a. n. berker , phys . rev .
b * 79 * , 014434 ( 2009 ) .
q. h. chen , phys .
b * 80 * , 144420 ( 2009 ) .
t. jrg and f. krzakala , j. stat .
mech . : theory exp .
l01001 ( 2012 ) .
w. de lima , g. camelo - neto , and s. coutinho , phys .
a * 377 * , 2851 ( 2013 ) .
w. wang , j. machta , and h. g. katzgraber , phys .
b * 92 * , 094410 ( 2015 ) . v. martin - mayor and i. hen , scientific repts . * 5 * , 15324 ( 2015 ) z. zhu , a. j. ochoa , s. schnabel , f. hamze , and h. g. katzgraber , phys .
a * 93 * , 012317 ( 2016 ) .
w. wang , j. machta , and h. g. katzgraber , phys .
b * 93 * , 224414 ( 2016 )
. l. a. fernandez , e. marinari , v. martin - mayor , g. parisi , and d. yllanes , arxiv:1605.03025 [ cond-mat.dis-nn ] ( 2016 ) .
p. collet and j .- p .
eckmann , _ iterated maps on the interval as dynamical systems _
( birkhuser , boston , 1980 ) .
r. c. hilborn , _ chaos and nonlinear dynamics _ , 2nd ed .
( oxford university press , new york , 2003 ) .
e. cladis , phys .
lett . * 35 * , 48 ( 1975 ) .
f. hardouin , a. m. levelut , m. f. achard , and g. sigaud , j. chim . phys .
* 80 * , 53 ( 1983 ) .
j. o. indekeu and a. n. berker , physica a * 140 * , 368 ( 1986 )
. j. o. indekeu , a. n. berker , c. chiang , and c. w. garland , phys .
a * 35 * , 1371 ( 1987 ) .
r. r. netz and a. n. berker , phys .
lett . * 68 * , 333 ( 1992 ) .
s. kumari and s. singh , phase transitions * 88 * , 1225 ( 2015 ) .
s. franz , g. parisi , and m.a .
virasoro , j. physique i * 4 * , 1657 ( 1994 ) .
s. boettcher , phys .
lett . * 95 * , 197205 ( 2005 ) . c. amoruso , e. marinari , o. c. martin , and a. pagnani , phys .
* 91 * , 087201 ( 2003 ) .
bouchaud , f. krzakala , and o. c. martin , phys .
b * 68 * , 224404 ( 2003 ) . | the chiral spin - glass potts system with @xmath0 states is studied in @xmath1 and 3 spatial dimensions by renormalization - group theory and the global phase diagrams are calculated in temperature , chirality concentration @xmath2 , and chirality - breaking concentration @xmath3 , with determination of phase chaos and phase - boundary chaos . in the @xmath4 ,
the system has ferromagnetic , left - chiral , right - chiral , chiral spin - glass , and disordered phases .
the phase boundaries to the ferromagnetic , left- and right - chiral phases show , differently , an unusual , fibrous patchwork ( microreentrances ) of all four ( ferromagnetic , left - chiral , right - chiral , chiral spin - glass ) ordered ordered phases , especially in the multicritical region .
the chaotic behavior of the interactions , under scale change , are determined in the chiral spin - glass phase and on the boundary between the chiral spin - glass and disordered phases , showing lyapunov exponents in magnitudes reversed from the usual ferromagnetic - antiferromagnetic spin - glass systems . at low temperatures ,
the boundaries of the left- and right - chiral phases become thresholded in @xmath2 and @xmath3 . in the @xmath1 ,
the chiral spin - glass system does not have a spin - glass phase , consistently with the lower - critical dimension of ferromagnetic - antiferromagnetic spin glasses .
the left- and right - chirally ordered phases show reentrance in chirality concentration @xmath2 .
chiral potts spin glass , in temperature @xmath5 , chirality concentration @xmath2 , and chirality - breaking concentration @xmath3 .
note that the upper and lower figures are rotated with respect to each other . the ferromagnetically ordered phase ( f ) , the chiral spin - glass phase ( s ) , the left - chirally ordered phase ( l ) , and the disordered phase ( d ) are marked .
the global phase diagram is mirror - symmetric with respect to the chirality - breaking concentration @xmath6 , so that only @xmath7 is shown . in the ( not shown ) mirror - symmetric @xmath8 portion of the global phase diagram , the right - chirally ordered phase ( r )
occurs in the place of the left - chirally ordered phase ( l ) seen in this figure .
different cross - sections of this global phase diagram are shown in figs . 3 and 4 . |
detecting the qcd phase transition is of primary interest in current nuclear and particle physics .
experiments have shown that a new form of strongly interacting matter is created in high - energy nuclear collisions at the relativistic heavy ion collider ( rhic ) top energy and the large hadron collider ( lhc ) energies @xcite .
theoretical arguments and experimental signals imply that this matter is a quark - gluon plasma ( qgp ) created well above a transition temperature at almost zero baryon chemical potential .
the lattice qcd calculations have confirmed that the transition from hadronic matter to qgp is a crossover at zero baryon density @xcite .
the next challenge is to discover the first and/or second - order phase transition of qcd matter .
several effective model and approximate calculations of qcd suggest the existence of the first - order phase boundary and the critical point at finite chemical potentials @xcite .
various observables , such as collective flows , particle ratios , moment of the distributions of conserved charges , have been measured at various incident energies to find evidences of a phase transition and a critical point @xcite .
particularly , we shall focus on the observation of collapse of directed flow by the star collaboration @xcite , which might be a signal of a first - order phase transition at high baryon density region between hadronic matter and quark gluon plasma @xcite .
the collective transverse flow @xcite has been utilized to explore the properties of hot and dense matter , since it reflects the properties of the equation of state ( eos ) in the early stages of nuclear collisions @xcite .
the existence of bounce off , one of the collective flows , in heavy - ion collisions was first suggested in hydrodynamics @xcite and examined in experiments at bevalac @xcite at lawrence berkeley national laboratory .
later , the presence of the softest point near the phase transition in the eos @xcite was discussed as a signal for the first - order phase transition , where the softest point is a local minimum of the ratio of pressure to energy density @xmath2 as a function of energy density , leading to a small sound velocity defined by @xmath3 . in ref .
@xcite , baryon density dependence of the ratio @xmath2 was investigated within a quasi - particle model .
the softest point of the crossover eos at vanishing chemical potential is not very pronounced , but it is predicted that the eos with a first order phase transition exhibits a very pronounced softest point at large chemical potentials .
considerations of heavy ion collisions at rhic energy have raised the question whether the physics of the often speculated first - order phase transition or the `` softest point '' should better be studied at moderate energies @xcite in which the collapse of the directed flow at @xmath47 - 9 gev was speculated . presumably , the eos of baryon rich matter is the softest at moderate energy densities of a few gev/@xmath5
. particularly , the excitation function of the directed flow slope with respect to rapidity @xmath6 decreases at @xmath7 @xcite and is predicted to exhibit a minimum at a certain collision energy in hydrodynamical calculations using an eos with a first - order qcd phase transition @xcite , where the @xmath8 is defined as the first fourier component in the azimuthal angle distribution with respect to the reaction plane , @xmath9 .
the negative slope of @xmath8 , called the third flow @xcite or the anti - flow of the nucleon @xcite emerges as a consequence of a tilted ellipsoid with respect to the beam axis from which negative flow builds up if matter passes through the softening point .
thus the collapse of the directed flow slope to a negative value might signal the first - order phase transition from hadron phase to quark - gluon phase , and was recently observed in the beam energy scan ( bes ) program performed at rhic @xcite .
a negative slope of proton @xmath8 at midrapidity has been found in the microscopic transport models rqmd @xcite , urqmd @xcite , and phsd / hsd @xcite in which sign change is purely geometrical and only happens at large impact parameters and sufficiently higher collision energies .
note that such microscopic transport models do not show a negative slope of the proton @xmath8 at midrapidity at bombarding energies of @xmath10 gev @xcite , and thus the negative slope of the proton @xmath8 at @xmath11 and 19.6 gev observed by the star collaboration @xcite is incompatible with the predictions by the standard hadronic transport models .
we also note that the hadronic transport model with momentum dependent mean field significantly improves the description of the directed flow data from e895 @xcite and na49 data @xcite , but inclusion of the hadronic mean field does not lead to the negative proton @xmath6 @xcite .
this gives indirect evidence of the phase transition around such collision energies .
the excitation function of the directed flow slope was investigated also in a transport + hydrodynamics hybrid approach @xcite , where it was found that there is no sensitivity of the directed flow on the eos , and there is no minimum in the excitation function of the directed flow slope .
in contrast , strong sensitivities of the directed flow to the eos are found in a three - fluid model @xcite .
the three - fluid calculations indicate that the crossover deconfinement transition is consistent with the directed flow data of energy range up to @xmath12 gev .
however , the phsd transport model which incorporates crossover eos does not show the experimentally observed minimum @xcite .
thus it is not yet clear whether the negative slope of @xmath8 signals the softening of the eos in hybrid approaches . in the present paper , we investigate the directed flow in the bes energy region within the microscopic transport model jam @xcite by imposing attractive orbits for each two - body scattering to simulate effects of a softening of the eos .
the hadronic transport model jam @xcite has been developed based on resonance and string production and their decay , which is similar to other transport models @xcite .
secondary products from decay can interact with each other by binary collisions .
a detailed description of the jam model can be found in ref .
@xcite .
we take into account nuclear eos effects within a microscopic transport approach by changing the standard stochastic two - body scattering style , which is normally implemented so as not to contribute to the pressure . for example
, we can simulate repulsive @xmath13 potential effects by allowing only repulsive orbits in the two - body collisions @xcite , instead of choosing the scattering angle randomly as in a standard cascade .
it is reported that directed flow at bevalac and alternating gradient synchrotron ( ags ) energies are well described by this approach @xcite .
later , attractive orbits were introduced to effectively incorporate the softening of the eos @xcite guided by the virial theorem @xcite . in this way , different treatment of scatterings can modify the eos .
we impose attractive orbits for each two - body hadron - hadron scattering to reduce the pressure of the system .
the pressure of a system , in which particles are interacting with each other only by two - body scattering , is given by the virial theorem as @xcite @xmath14 where @xmath15 corresponds to the free streaming contribution .
the second term represents the pressure generation from all two - body scatterings between the pair of particles @xmath16 and @xmath17 , where @xmath18 is the momentum transfer and @xmath19 and @xmath20 are the coordinate of colliding particles .
@xmath21 is the volume of the system , and @xmath22 is a time interval over which the system is measured .
thus , pressure generation by the two - body collisions is related to the scattering style ; the repulsive orbit @xmath23 enhances the pressure , while the attractive orbit @xmath24 reduces the pressure .
note that an attractive potential softens the eos @xcite , which leads to an attractive orbit .
attractive orbits are realized in the simulation as follows .
each orbit is selected randomly as in the standard simulation , but in the case where the orbit is repulsive , we change it to an attractive one by exchanging the momentum of two particles in the two - body cener - of - mass ( c.m . )
thus the scattering rate remains the same . while in reality modification of the scattering style
should depend for example , on variables such as local energy density , we impose a modified scattering style for all hadron - hadron @xmath25 scatterings in order to see an effect of the softening , instead of trying to fit the data .
thus there is no adjustable free parameter in our current approach unlike ref .
@xcite in which repulsive trajectories are selected for colliding baryons with some probability in order to generate more pressure at ags energies .
an energy density dependent implementation of attractive orbits will be examined shortly in sec .
[ sec : eosdep ]
we now discuss directed flows in the bes energy region . in the simulation , we choose the impact parameter range @xmath26 fm for mid - central and @xmath27 fm for central collisions for the star data @xcite .
-27 gev from the jam cascade mode ( dashed lines ) and the jam cascade with attractive orbits ( solid lines ) in comparison with the star data @xcite.,width=340 ] in fig .
[ fig : starv1mid ] we show the calculated directed flow @xmath8 of protons and pions in mid - central collisions from the standard jam cascade ( dotted lines ) and the jam cascade with attractive orbits ( solid line ) in au+au collisions at @xmath28 and 27 gev in comparison with the data from star collaboration @xcite .
the standard jam cascade calculation agrees with the 7.7 gev data .
however , it is seen that @xmath8 from the standard jam cascade calculations for beam energies of 11.5 and 19.6 gev yields much larger @xmath8 than the star data .
the proton slope from jam turns out to be negative at @xmath29 gev .
this is because of the geometrical reason pointed out in ref .
@xcite , and is not related to the softening of the eos within our transport approach .
we note that our results are consistent with other microscopic transport approaches @xcite . by comparison ,
attractive orbit scatterings drastically reduce the @xmath8 slope , and explain the star data at @xmath30 as shown in fig .
[ fig : starv1mid ] ( solid lines ) ; at @xmath11 and @xmath31 gev , the @xmath8 slope becomes almost zero and negative , respectively . at lower energy @xmath32 ,
results with attractive orbits are far from the data , and there should not be large eos softening . from this analysis , we find that the softening of the eos affects the directed flow of protons at midrapidity and should emerge in the beam energy range of @xmath30 , but its effects should be small at @xmath32 . since na49 data at @xmath33 gev may also indicate evidence of softening of the eos @xcite ,
the onset beam energy of the softening might be lower than 10 gev .
therefore , detailed experimental studies are needed around the beam energies of @xmath34 gev .
unfortunately , the eos softening effects are not easy to see when the @xmath8 slope is already negative in the standard cascade . as seen in fig .
[ fig : starv1mid ] , the proton @xmath8 slope at @xmath35 and pion @xmath8 slopes are negative in the standard cascade from geometrical non - qgp effects @xcite and from absorption by baryons @xcite , respectively .
it should be noted , however , that jam with attractive orbits overestimates the negative slope of the proton @xmath8 indicating the need to reharden the eos , i.e. ; matter created at this collision energy reaches well above the transition region or weak softening of the eos due to less net baryonic density . , but for central collisions ( 0 - 10% ) .
, width=340 ] we now discuss the directed flows in central collisions in order to distinguish the geometrical effects from phase transition .
since sign change of the proton @xmath8 is purely geometrical and only happens at large impact parameters in standard hadronic transport models , it is possible to find the effects of the softening sharply in central collisions .
we show directed flows in central collisions in fig .
[ fig : starv1cent ] . star data on the proton @xmath8 do not show negative slope for central collisions .
the standard jam cascade describes well the data at 7.7 gev , indicating that the hadronic description may be reasonable at 7.7 gev .
it is seen that the proton @xmath8 at 27 gev from both jam with attractive orbits and standard jam simulation yield negative slope .
thus 7.7 and 27 gev data do not show a hint of the softening of the eos within our analysis .
on the other hand , one sees that jam with attractive orbits again quite reasonably describes the data at 11.5 and 19.6 gev , while the standard jam cascade overestimates the data . therefore , star data on the proton directed flow for both central and mid - central collisions indicate evidence of the softening of the eos . gev . in the jam calculations ,
momentum dependent hadronic mean - field potentials are included ( jam / ms ) .
the dotted lines correspond to the result from the standard jam / ms model , while the solid lines are for jam / ms with attractive orbit results .
symbols show star data @xcite . , width=340 ] it is also necessary to examine the influence of the nuclear mean field on the directed flow at midrapidity , since the mean field can also modify the flows .
nuclear mean fields of hadrons are included based on the framework of simplified version of relativistic quantum molecular dynamics ( rqmd / s ) in ref .
density dependent skyrme - type and momentum dependent yukawa potentials are employed as in ref .
@xcite , but with slightly different parameter sets which yields the incompressibility of @xmath36 mev @xcite . in fig .
[ fig : ms11 ] , we show the calculated results of the directed flow of protons and pions at @xmath11 gev from jam with momentum dependent potentials ( jam / ms ) together with the star data .
the mean field slightly reduces the proton directed flow , but the basic trend is the same as the jam cascade result .
it is interesting to see that attractive orbits supplemented by the mean field yields negative slope , and provides a better description of the data than the cascade calculation at midrapidity . and 27 gev .
full ( open ) circles and full ( open ) diamonds represent the pressures @xmath37 at from standard jam ( jam with attractive orbits ) at 7.7 and 27 gev , respectively .
triangles and boxes represent the transverse part of the pressure @xmath38 for the jam standard at 7.7 and 27 gev , respectively .
the dashed and sold lines represent the eos from hadron gas and the eos with a first - order phase transition used in ref .
, width=321 ] we would like to see how much pressure is suppressed by imposing attractive orbits .
the free streaming part of the local isotropic pressure @xmath39 can be computed from the the energy - momentum tensor @xmath40 as @xmath41 , with the projector of @xmath42 , where @xmath43 is a hydrodynamics velocity defined by the landau and lifshitz definition that may be solved iteratively @xcite .
the pressure difference @xmath44 from the free streaming @xmath39 caused by the two - body collision between particles @xmath16 and @xmath17 at the space - time coordinates of @xmath45 and @xmath46 is estimated based on the formula given by ref .
@xcite : @xmath47 where @xmath48 is the lorentz invariant local particle density , @xmath49 is the proper time interval between successive collisions , and @xmath50 is the energy - momentum change of the particle @xmath16 .
we extract the `` effective eos '' by accumulating statistics by computing local pressure @xmath51 and energy density @xmath52 at each collision point in the jam simulation in the central region of the reaction zone specified by the longitudinal region @xmath53 fm and the transverse radius of less than 3 fm in au+au collisions at @xmath54 , 11.5 , 19.6 , and 27 gev .
we have checked that the volume dependence on the eos extracted from the simulation is very weak . in fig . [
fig : eosatt ] , pressure @xmath37 is plotted as a function of energy density @xmath55 from jam simulations as well as the ideal hadron gas eos and the eos with a first - order phase transition ( eos - q ) @xcite at vanishing baryon chemical potential .
we first discuss the eos in the standard jam simulation .
we see some beam energy dependence of the effective eos as reported in ref .
@xcite in which the eos was extracted to be @xmath56 from ags to super proton synchrotoron ( sps ) energies that is quite similar to our results .
there is a deviation of the effective eos from the hadron resonance gas eos at higher energy densities , which is mainly due to the nonequilibrium evolution of the system since the high energy density parts are extracted from early times where the system is far from the equilibrium state . in particular , pressure in the compression stage of
the reaction tends to be much higher than the values expected from the equilibrium eos .
we note that the transverse pressure @xmath57 , where @xmath58 is the energy - momentum tensor at a local rest frame , is lower than the equilibrium hadron resonance gas eos in high energy density regions as seen in our results in fig .
[ fig : eosatt ] which are also reported in ref .
it is expected that the deviation of the effective pressure in jam compared to the equilibrium hadron gas mainly comes from the bulk viscous pressure and/or chemical composition .
note that the difference between transverse and longitudinal pressure ( shear - stress tensor ) should not contribute to the isotropic pressure defined through the isotropic projection of the energy - momentum tensor . in the compression phase
, the bulk pressure should give a positive correction to the equilibrium pressure , but in the expansion stage , the sign should change .
judging by fig .
[ fig : eosatt ] , such sign change is , at least , not very pronounced .
so it indicates that the main contribution to the hardening of the eos at high energy densities in jam is from the chemical composition ; namely , the system at early stages of the reaction is highly out of the chemical equilibrium state . at lower energy densities , transverse pressure @xmath38 is close to the isotropic pressure @xmath37 , showing the kinetic equilibration of the system , and transverse pressure departs from isotropic pressure above @xmath59 gev/@xmath5 depending on the beam energy .
chemical equilibrium of the system in the time evolution of hadron transport models was investigated in ref .
@xcite , and it was found that it reaches at late times , which is consistent with the finding here that the effective eos from standard jam is close to the ideal hadron resonance eos at lower energy densities .
after equilibration , pressure from standard jam approaches values close to the ideal hadron resonance gas eos which is seen in fig .
[ fig : eosatt ] when the energy density is less than 1 gev/@xmath5 .
as energy density drops further , the standard jam yields slightly less pressure than that of the ideal gas eos , because of the chemical freeze - out @xcite .
the effective eos from jam with attractive orbits is compared with the eos from the standard jam simulation in fig .
[ fig : eosatt ] .
when attractive orbits are selected for all two - body scatterings in jam , we see a significant reduction of the pressure , yielding a similar amount of softening in the transition region as eos - q , although our effective eos does not exhibit a sharp first - order phase transition , since we do not impose any specific condition to allow for an attractive orbit . we will examine
which part of the eos is responsible for the collapse of proton directed flow in the next sections .
let us now examine where the negative slope is generated .
time evolution of the sign weighted directed transverse momentum integrated over the rapidity range of @xmath60 , @xmath61 for baryons is displayed in fig . [ fig : v1evol ] in semicentral au+au collision for both the standard jam cascade and jam with attractive orbits . in the standard jam cascade ,
directed flow of baryons rises in the early states of the reaction before two nuclei pass through each other , and decreases with time . at late times , it rises slowly again with time .
integrated over midrapidity for baryons in semicentral au+au collisions for @xmath62 gev from ( a ) standard jam and ( b ) jam with attractive orbits simulations .
time evolutions of normalized net - baryon density and energy density from the standard jam calculations are shown in the panels ( c ) and ( d ) , respectively . baryon density and energy density
are averaged over a cylindrical volume of transverse radius 3 fm and longitudinal distance of 1 fm centered at the origin . those particles which have not interacted
yet are not included in the calculations of @xmath63 , @xmath64 , and @xmath55 .
, width=302 ] in the jam cascade with attractive orbits , on the other hand , it is observed that directed flow is strongly modified to be negative by the reduction of pressure at early times , especially at lower energies , and directed flow always increases as a function of reaction time .
we note that the slope of directed flow stays negative also in the rescattering stages of the reaction ; the period long after two nuclei pass through each other . as expected ,
directed flow becomes smaller as collision energy becomes higher , due to less interaction time @xcite .
the range of beam energies covered by bes is quite interesting .
the crossing times of the two gold nuclei in the c. m. frame are approximately 3.27 , 2.15 , 1.25 , and 0.906 fm/@xmath65 at @xmath66 and 27 gev , respectively .
thus , hadronic rescatterings start in au+au collisions before passing through two nuclei at @xmath54 gev , because crossing time is much longer than the hadronization time from string fragmentation which is typically 1 fm/@xmath65 .
on the other hand , at @xmath29 gev , most of the hadronic rescattering among produced particles occur after two nuclei pass through each other . in ref .
@xcite , a wiggle structure in the rapidity dependence of proton directed flow was predicted at @xmath67 gev in which initial nucleon - nucleon collisions are well isolated from the late hadronic rescatterings , and it is argued that a wiggle structure appears as a result of the correlation between the position of a nucleon and its stopping power due to initial glauber type nucleon - nucleon collisions .
the negative directed flow seen in the hadronic transport models at @xmath29 gev is due to the same reason . at energies @xmath68 gev ,
this correlation is contaminated by meson - baryon collisions , since mesons and baryons start interacting with each other before the two nuclei pass though each other .
we now look at the effects of rescatterings between mesons and baryons in the bes energy region . in fig .
[ fig : v1bb ] , we show the rapidity dependence of @xmath8 for both protons and pions for the jam simulation without meson - baryon , and meson - meson collisions .
we see the wiggle structure in the rapidity dependence of the proton @xmath8 for all of the beam energies , and pion directed flow is very small but slightly positive .
the appearance of wiggle structure at lower beam energies when one switches off meson - baryon scatterings may be partly due to the similar mechanism as pointed out by ref . @xcite . thus we conclude that baryon - baryon collisions alone generates negative proton directed flow at midrapidity , and meson - baryon collisions bring the proton directed flow to the positive side and the pion directed flow to the negative side .
this implies that strong negative directed flow must be generated at the initial stages of nuclear collisions to get the negative proton flow at freeze - out . , but jam cascade simulations with only baryon - baryon collisions .
, width=302 ] in order to examine further in detail how @xmath8 is generated , we plot in fig .
[ fig : v1evolbb ] the time evolution of @xmath69 from the jam simulations by switching off all baryon - meson and meson - meson collisions ( jam bb only ) . the upper panel of fig .
[ fig : v1evolbb ] shows the time evolutions of @xmath63 from jam simulations with only baryon - baryon collisions .
it shows that positive directed flow is first generated before two nuclei pass though each other , and then it becomes negative in the expansion stages of the reaction .
the lower beam energy yields larger negative directed flow .
this is because of the effect of spectators as well as the increasing number of baryon - baryon collisions at lower beam energies .
the average number of baryon - baryon collisions @xmath70 in au+au semicentral collisions is larger at lower beam energy : @xmath71 , and 310 for @xmath28 and 27 gev , respectively . in the middle panel of fig .
[ fig : v1evolbb ] , we display the time evolution of @xmath63 in jam bb only with attractive orbits . as in the case of full simulation , strong negative directed flow is generated in the early stages of the reaction and it rises in time , then it stays the same value at later times because of the absence of hadronic rescatterings .
the question then arises , which part of the reaction stage is more relevant for the negative directed flow of protons ? for protons and pions in semicentral au+au collisions for @xmath11 gev from jam simulation in which attractive orbits are imposed at different time intervals ; the solid line corresponds to the simulation with attractive orbits for time @xmath72 fm/@xmath65 , the dashed line for @xmath73 fm/@xmath65 , and the dotted line for @xmath74 fm/@xmath65 .
, width=321 ] to try to answer the question , we plot in fig .
[ fig : v1tcut ] the rapidity dependence of @xmath8 in au+au semicentral collision for three different jam simulations at @xmath11 gev by noting that the crossing time of two nuclei is about 2.15 fm/@xmath65 : ( 1 ) jam with attractive orbits only for compression stages of the reaction until two nuclei reach full overlap , i.e. time less than 1 fm/@xmath65 ; ( 2 ) jam with attractive orbits at the reaction time between 1 and 2 fm/@xmath65 which corresponds to the time range with largest baryon densities .
( 3 ) jam with attractive orbits at times later than 2 fm/@xmath65 ; and as we expect , when attractive orbits are imposed at times later than 2 fm/@xmath65 , it is too late to generate negative flow , and the result is almost identical to the standard jam simulation .
furthermore , it is very interesting to see that the effect of attractive orbits at times earlier than 1 fm/@xmath65 is small and its effect alone can not explain the strong suppression of the flow . to see this point more clearly , time evolution of @xmath63 is displayed in fig .
[ fig : v1tcuteos ] .
one see that strong negative directed flow generated in the earliest stages of
the reaction quickly disappears with a much faster rate than the one shown in the lower panel of fig .
[ fig : v1evol ] .
thus initial scatterings at the compression stage of the reaction are not important in generating negative @xmath8 .
finally , it is shown that what is responsible for the strong suppression of the proton flow is the effect of attractive orbits in the time interval @xmath75 fm/@xmath65 , which coincides with the highest baryon density in the course of the reaction at @xmath11 gev .
this effect can be further confirmed in the time evolution of @xmath63 in fig .
[ fig : v1tcuteos ] .
attractive orbits at this stage are important to suppress the rise of @xmath8 due to the hadronic rescatterings . for baryons ( upper panel ) and
effective eos ( lower panel ) in au+au collision at @xmath11 gev from jam simulations in which attractive orbits are imposed at different time intervals ; the circles correspond to the simulation with attractive orbits for time @xmath72 fm/@xmath65 , the squares for @xmath73 fm/@xmath65 , and the triangles for @xmath74 fm/@xmath65 .
, title="fig:",width=321 ] for baryons ( upper panel ) and effective eos ( lower panel ) in au+au collision at @xmath11 gev from jam simulations in which attractive orbits are imposed at different time intervals ; the circles correspond to the simulation with attractive orbits for time @xmath72 fm/@xmath65 , the squares for @xmath73 fm/@xmath65 , and the triangles for @xmath74 fm/@xmath65 .
, title="fig:",width=302 ] effective eos for each simulation are plotted together with the eos of the standard jam simulation in the lower panel of fig .
[ fig : v1tcuteos ] .
the effect of the attractive orbits for @xmath76 fm/@xmath65 is the slight reduction of pressure at high energy densities ; on the other hand , attractive orbits for @xmath77 fm/@xmath65 reduce the pressure at lower energy densities .
attractive orbits at @xmath78 fm/@xmath65 strongly reduces the pressure at high energy densities which results in the collapse of proton directed flow .
however , it does not necessarily imply that the equilibrium eos at high energy density at high baryon density needs to be very soft for the negative @xmath8 , since most of pressures at energy densities above 4 gev/@xmath5 are extracted from preequilibrium stages of the reaction in the jam simulation .
nonequilibrium effects need to be examined .
nevertheless , it suggests the need of a nonstandard dynamical effect which is related to the reduction of pressure at high baryon densities .
this analysis strongly suggests the importance of reaction dynamics at high baryon density .
the time period of @xmath78 fm / c at @xmath11 gev relevant to the negative flow corresponds to the preequilibrium stage in the jam hadronic transport approach , even though produced hadrons start to interact with each other .
we do not have partonic interactions , unlike the phsd model @xcite .
the effects of partonic interactions in the early stages of the reaction should be examined elsewhere in order to understand the dynamical effects on the directed flow . in order to see systematics on the use of the attractive orbits in the scattering style ,
it is important to check other flow harmonics such as elliptic flow @xmath79 . in fig .
[ fig : v2ch ] , jam cascade results are compared with the pseudorapidity dependence of @xmath80 for charged hadrons in midcentral ( 10 - 40% ) au+au collisions at @xmath28 and @xmath81 gev @xcite . it is seen that @xmath80 at midrapidity is not modified by the attractive orbits scattering style , but it underestimates the data about 2030% . therefore , we do not see any softening effects on @xmath80 within our approach .
underestimation of @xmath80 by our approach suggests the need of partonic interactions in the early stages of the reactions .
we have also studied other inclusive hadronic observables such as transverse momentum distributions and rapidity distributions and found that the effect of attractive orbits on them is very small .
it is also important to examine other observables such as the net - baryon number cumulants in the same energy range @xcite .
if the softening of the eos comes from criticality around the critical point , divergence of cumulants appears as oscillating behavior as a result of smearing by the finite quark mass @xcite or finite volume @xcite .
thus it is an interesting question whether dynamical model calculations with the eos softening can describe the observed nonmonotonic behavior of cumulant ratios @xcite .
recently , it was shown that jam with attractive orbits as well as nuclear mean - field effects does not describe the observed large enhancement of cumulant ratios @xcite .
so far , we implement attractive orbits in jam for all hadron - hadron @xmath25 scatterings without any restrictions . as a result ,
our equation of state is soft for all energy densities as shown in fig .
[ fig : eosatt ] .
we now explore the eos dependence of the directed flow . for this purpose , instead of imposing attractive scattering all the way , we select attractive orbits at each two - body scattering with the probability @xmath82 given by @xmath83 where @xmath84 is a pressure as a function of energy density @xmath55 from a given eos , and @xmath39 is the local pressure at the collision point computed from the energy - momentum tensor as in sec .
[ sec : eos ] .
the qcd equation of state at high baryon densities is not well understood . as a first step ,
we use the eos which does not depend on baryon density for simplicity , since our purpose here is to check the systematics of our approach that modifies the scattering style .
we test the eos with crossover from lattice qcd ( @xmath85-v1.1 ) taken from ref .
@xcite , and the eos with a first - order phase transition similar to that of eos - q with the modification of the slope in the qgp phase to @xmath86 ( instead of the massless ideal gas eos @xmath87 ) so that pressure at high energy densities is consistent with the lattice eos as shown in fig . [
fig : jameos ] .
we also show in fig .
[ fig : jameos ] the results which are extracted from jam simulations to ensure that our simple approach is consistent with a given eos .
it is seen that our simple approach works very well to modify the eos of the system . for protons and pions in semicentral au+au collisions for @xmath11 gev from jam simulations with different eos .
the solid line presents the jam result with the eos with fist - order phase transition , and the dashed line presents the jam result with the crossover eos .
the dotted line is for the standard jam result.,width=321 ] in fig .
[ fig : v1eos ] , we plot the rapidity dependence of the directed flow of protons ( upper panel ) and pions ( lower panel ) in au+au semicentral collision at @xmath11 gev obtained from the eos with crossover and first - order phase transition .
while pion flow is not sensitive to the eos , one sees that both eoss yield the suppression of proton directed flow compared to the standard cascade simulation , since both eoss are softer than the effective eos from the standard jam cascade simulation as compared in fig . [ fig : v1eos ] .
proton flow at midrapidity @xmath88 is not sensitive to the eos , but two eos give different behavior for larger rapidities indicating that the softening point of the current eos is responsible to the rapidity @xmath89 at @xmath11 gev , and explicit eos dependence of the directed flow may be observable in the experiments .
it remains for further work to establish the eos dependence of the directed flow by utilizing a fully baryon density dependent eos .
the interactions used here do not employ any baryon density dependent interactions , @xmath90 , as one may want to use in relativistic mean - field models of high baryon density matter .
it is also possible that @xmath91 matter with slightly nonuniversal scalar attraction can easily cause a first - order phase transition without mentioning any high baryon density qcd .
we will present a detailed systematic study of the eos dependence of the directed flow elsewhere .
in summary , we have investigated the effect of the softening of the eos on the directed flow of protons and pions within a microscopic transport approach .
the transport model jam with standard stochastic two - body scattering style predicts the large positive slope of proton @xmath8 at collision energy below @xmath92 gev , and the negative slope of proton @xmath8 only at higher collision energy @xmath93 gev , which disagree with the star data .
however , softening effects of the eos simulated by attractive orbit scatterings lead to a dramatic change in the dynamics , and yield significant reduction of proton @xmath8 which well describe the star data around the minimum of @xmath6 at @xmath94 gev .
the softening effects were not needed in the present approach at lower energies , @xmath32 .
we found that attractive orbit scattering style does not modify elliptic flow at mid - rapidity .
we show that this softening effect is needed only at early stages of the reaction where the system reaches the high baryon density state at midrapidity .
we also proposed a simple recipe to simulate a given eos within a hadronic transport model , and compared two different eos .
we saw an eos dependence of the proton directed flow in the forward rapidities .
more detailed systematic studies are needed , using a fully baryon density dependent eos , in order to draw a conclusion that the minimum of @xmath6 is a result of the softening of the eos which may be caused by a first - order phase transition @xcite .
a possible scenario to fully explain the beam energy dependence of the directed flow may be described as follows .
we assume that there exists the softest point in the energy density range reachable at @xmath95 .
hadrons will feel an attractive force when they go across the surface of the soft region .
this additional force can be simulated by introducing the attractive orbit scatterings among hadrons , as we have demonstrated in the present work , and negative @xmath6 emerges . one may need to introduce new degrees of freedom other than hadrons to understand the rehardening at higher energies .
it seems obvious to infer a softening of the eos from the experimentally observed collapse of net - proton flow when the c.m .
energy is increased from 7 to 11 gev .
however , the statement of a discovery of the `` softening '' of the eos from the net - proton @xmath8 data shows even more convincing evidence for the `` phase transition '' as we observe the rebound at higher energies ; namely the star - observed second change of sign of the @xmath8 values of the net protons at @xmath96 gev back to positive @xmath8 at higher energies @xcite .
this shows that the soft region is overcome , and the directed flow picks up steam again , due to the rehardening of the eos at considerably larger energy densities .
in the near future , a more detailed analysis of the softening effect should be addressed by employing a realistic eos which is consistent with the lattice qcd result .
because of the nonequilibrium evolution , the pressure generation due to the two - body collision @xmath44 depends in the current study not only on the difference between the equilibrium eoss , but also on the dynamical evolution of the system .
perhaps a more justified way of fixing the eos would be to look at a fully equilibrated system in a box , and then determine the probabilities for attractive orbits as a function of the energy of the colliding particles , so that a given ( equilibrium ) eos would be reproduced ; then the microscopic dynamics would tell how the system looks in out - of - equilibrium situations .
it is expected that properties of the eos at high baryon density may be probed sensitively by using the flow .
future experiments such as the bes ii at rhic @xcite , fair @xcite , nica @xcite , and j - parc @xcite should clarify this point at lower collision energies @xmath97 gev .
we would like to thank adrian dumitru for valuable comments . h.s .
thanks nu xu , zangbu xu , declan keane , and paul sorensen for numerous useful discussions .
thanks the frankfurt institute of advanced studies where part of this work was done .
this work was supported in part by the grants - in - aid for scientific research from jsps ( no .
15k05079 , no .
15h03663 and no .
15k05098 ) , the grants - in - aid for scientific research on innovative areas from mext ( no . 24105001 and no .
24105008 ) , and by the yukawa international program for quark - hadron sciences .
has received funding from the european union s horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under marie sklodowska - curie grant agreement no .
655285 and from the helmholtz international center for fair within the framework of the loewe program launched by the state of hesse .
l. adamczyk _ et al . _ [ star collaboration ] , phys . rev
. lett .
* 112 * , no .
16 , 162301 ( 2014 ) .
i. arsene _ et al . _
[ brahms collaboration ] , nucl .
phys . a * 757 * , 1 ( 2005 ) ; b. b. back _ et al . _ , nucl . phys . a * 757 * , 28 ( 2005 ) ; j. adams _ et al . _ [ star collaboration ] , nucl . phys . a * 757 * , 102 ( 2005 ) ; k. adcox _ et al . _ [ phenix collaboration ] , nucl . phys . a * 757 * , 184 ( 2005 ) .
y. aoki , g. endrodi , z. fodor , s. d. katz and k. k. szabo , nature * 443 * , 675 ( 2006 ) .
d. h. rischke , prog .
* 52 * , 197 ( 2004 ) ; m. a. stephanov , prog .
suppl . * 153 * , 139 ( 2004 ) [ int .
j. mod .
a * 20 * , 4387 ( 2005 ) ] ; k. fukushima and t. hatsuda , rept .
phys . * 74 * , 014001 ( 2011 ) ; k. fukushima and c. sasaki , prog .
* 72 * , 99 ( 2013 ) .
h. stoecker , nucl .
a * 750 * , 121 ( 2005 ) .
h. g. baumgardt , j. u. schott , y. sakamoto , e. schopper , h. stoecker , j. hofmann , w. scheid and w. greiner , z. phys .
a * 273 * , 359 ( 1975 ) .
w. scheid , h. mller and w. greiner , phys .
lett . * 32 * , 741 ( 1974 ) ; j. kapusta and d. strottman , phys .
b * 106 * , 33 ( 1981 ) ; h. stoecker _ et al . _ ,
c * 25 * , 1873 ( 1982 ) .
h. a. gustafsson _ et al .
lett . * 52 * , 1590 ( 1984 ) . y. b. ivanov , e. g. nikonov , w. noerenberg , a. a. shanenko and v. d. toneev , heavy ion phys . *
15 * , 117 ( 2002 ) ; v. d. toneev , e. g. nikonov , b. friman , w. norenberg and k. redlich , eur .
j. c * 32 * , 399 ( 2003 ) .
l. p. csernai and d. rohrich , phys .
b * 458 * , 454 ( 1999 ) .
l. p. csernai , a. anderlik , c. anderlik , v. k. magas , e. molnar , a. nyiri , d. rohrich and k. tamosiunas , acta phys . hung .
a * 22 * , 181 ( 2005 ) .
j. brachmann , s. soff , a. dumitru , h. stoecker , j. a. maruhn , w. greiner , l. v. bravina and d. h. rischke , phys .
c * 61 * , 024909 ( 2000 ) . j. brachmann , a. dumitru , h. stoecker and w. greiner , eur .
phys . j. a * 8 * , 549 ( 2000 ) .
h. appelshauser _ et al .
_ [ na49 collaboration ] , phys . rev .
lett . * 80 * , 4136 ( 1998 ) . c. alt _ et al . _
[ na49 collaboration ] , phys .
c * 68 * , 034903 ( 2003 ) .
m. isse , a. ohnishi , n. otuka , p. k. sahu and y. nara , phys .
c * 72 * , 064908 ( 2005 ) .
y. nara , n. otuka , a. ohnishi , k. niita and s. chiba , phys .
c * 61 * , 024901 ( 2000 ) .
h. sorge , phys .
c * 52 * , 3291 ( 1995 ) .
s. a. bass _ et al .
. part .
* 41 * , 255 ( 1998 ) .
m. bleicher _ et al .
_ , j. phys .
g * 25 * , 1859 ( 1999 ) .
m. gyulassy , k. a. frankel and h. stoecker , phys .
b * 110 * , 185 ( 1982 ) .
d. e. kahana , d. keane , y. pang , t. schlagel and s. wang , phys .
lett . * 74 * , 4404 ( 1995 ) ; d. e. kahana , y. pang and e. v. shuryak , phys . rev .
c * 56 * , 481 ( 1997 ) .
h. sorge , phys .
lett . * 82 * , 2048 ( 1999 ) .
p. danielewicz and s. pratt , phys .
c * 53 * , 249 ( 1996 ) .
s. a. bass , c. hartnack , h. stoecker and w. greiner , phys .
c * 51 * , 3343 ( 1995 ) doi:10.1103/physrevc.51.3343 [ nucl - th/9501002 ] .
p. f. kolb , j. sollfrank and u. w. heinz , phys .
b * 459 * , 667 ( 1999 ) ; p. f. kolb , j. sollfrank and u. w. heinz , phys .
c * 62 * , 054909 ( 2000 ) ; h. song and u. w. heinz , phys .
c * 77 * , 064901 ( 2008 ) .
l. v. bravina _ et al .
_ , phys .
c * 60 * , 024904 ( 1999 ) ; phys .
c * 78 * , 014907 ( 2008 ) . | we analyze the directed flow of protons and pions in high - energy heavy - ion collisions in the incident energy range from @xmath0 to 27 gev within a microscopic transport model .
standard hadronic transport approaches do not describe the collapse of directed flow below @xmath1 gev .
by contrast , a model that simulates effects of a softening of the equation of state describes well the behavior of directed flow data recently obtained by the star collaboration @xcite .
we give a detailed analysis of how directed flow is generated .
particularly , we found that softening of the effective equation of state at the overlapping region of two nuclei , i.e. the reaction stages where the system reaches high baryon density state , is needed to explain the observed collapse of proton directed flow within a hadronic transport approach . |
the strong couplings among soft qcd gluons manifest themselves in a variety of complex long - distance phenomena .
most of them are thoroughly entwined with the vacuum state , as illustrated by such prominent examples as quark confinement , spontaneous chiral symmetry breaking , vacuum tunneling processes , the ensuing @xmath0 structure as well as large gluon condensates . despite the apparent diversity of these and other effects
, however , the essence of the underlying dynamics is often expected to involve just a few soft gluonic modes .
the quest for these long - wavelength excitations began shortly after the inception of qcd and has inspired the development of various kinds of vacuum models , based e.g. on glueball condensation @xcite , gaussian stochastic processes @xcite , gluonic domains @xcite and instanton @xcite as well as meron @xcite ensembles . over the last decade , lattice simulations increasingly assisted in the search for predominant infrared ( ir ) gluon fields , mostly by means of numerical `` filtering '' @xcite and gauge - fixing @xcite techniques .
these simulations are now beginning to generate quantitative insights into the role of instantons and their size distribution @xcite , and into the classic confinement scenarios based on ( gauge - projected abelian ) monopole @xcite or center vortex @xcite condensation .
nevertheless , at present no mechanism involving soft vacuum gluons can be uniquely or systematically related to qcd , and many crucial questions regarding the underlying fields , their stability , gauge - independent physical interpretation , mutual interactions , relations to other vacuum fields etc .
remain unanswered .
analytical progress in this realm has been particularly slowed by the inevitable gauge dependence of the generally rather complex classical gluon field configurations on which most of the existing proposals are based .
similarly , approaches which reformulate non - abelian gauge theory in terms of gauge - independent loop variables @xcite or resolve the gauge constraints explicitly ( e.g. in coulomb gauge @xcite ) , are often technically too involved for direct practical applications . in the present paper
, we circumvent such complications by developing an approach in which not the contributions of single gauge fields but rather those of gauge invariant classes are treated jointly .
these classes gather contributions from dominant gauge field orbits to low - energy yang - mills amplitudes and thus represent collective gluonic ir degrees of freedom . technically , they are the saddle points of a soft mode action for gauge invariant matrix fields and therefore also provide the principal input for a systematic saddle point expansion of soft yang - mills amplitudes .
manifest gauge invariance is maintained throughout all calculations by working in the hamiltonian formulation of yang - mills theory in the `` coordinate '' schrdinger representation and by making use of explicit gauge projection operators . the schrdinger picture is adopted mainly because it restricts gauge transformations to a fixed reference time , thereby effectively decoupling them from the dynamical time evolution , and because it often renders the impact of topological gluon properties particularly transparent ( even without recourse to the semi - classical approximation ) @xcite .
for the reasons already alluded to , we will focus on gluonic effects and work in pure gauge theory without quarks .
the individual ir degrees of freedom , i.e. the solutions of the saddle point equations , turn out to comprise a diverse range of specific features .
additionally , they have several important properties in common , including stability against scale transformations ( an indispensable prerequisite for the saddle point expansion which is ensured by a virial theorem ) and characteristic topological properties inherited from the gauge group .
the topology will turn out to be particularly useful for establishing relations between specific saddle - point families and the instanton and meron solutions of the classical yang - mills equation .
our approach maintains explicitly traceable links between the soft collective fields and the underlying gluon fields .
the resulting ir dynamics is at an intermediate level of complexity , somewhere inbetween the microscopic theory itself and effective theories ( e.g. for polyakov loops ) which just share the symmetries of the fundamental dynamics while coupling parameters have to be fitted to experimental ( or lattice ) data .
our soft - mode lagrangian , in contrast , follows uniquely from the adopted vacuum wave functional and combines a reasonable amount of transparency with accessibility to essentially analytical treatment .
the paper is organized as follows : in sec .
[ voa ] we recapitulate the definition of the vacuum overlap amplitude in the schrdinger picture .
we then implement a gauge - projected vacuum wave functional on the basis of the gaussian approximation and rewrite the overlap in terms of a bare action which had previously emerged in a variational context . in sec .
[ sge ] , we take advantage of known 1-loop results to integrate out the hard - mode contributions to the bare action perturbatively . by means of a controlled derivative expansion , the renormalized soft - mode action density
is then transformed it into a local lagrangian which lends itself to direct analytical treatment . in sec .
[ spex ] we build on these results by establishing the ir - sensitive saddle point expansion for the functional integral over the soft modes and by deriving the saddle point equations whose nontrivial solutions constitute the new gluonic ir degrees of freedom . important generic properties of these ir variables are established in sec .
[ sps ] , including their scale stability due to a virial theorem , three topological quantum numbers and a lower bound of bogomolnyi type on their action . in sec .
[ solncl ] , several classes of the more symmetric and most important saddle point solutions are found explicitly .
they comprise topological soliton solutions of hedgehog type , which are related to classical solutions of the yang - mills equation , and solutions which carry different types of topological information and seem to have no obvious counterparts in classical yang - mills theory .
one of the most interesting solution classes consists of solitonic links , twisted links and knots .
those emerge from a generalization of faddeev - niemi theory which turns out to be embedded in our soft - mode lagrangian . in sec .
[ qspi ] we classify all hedgehog soliton solutions , find their most important representatives explicitly , and establish the role of the regular solutions as mainly summarizing contributions from instanton and meron gauge orbits to the vacuum overlap . in sec .
[ suc ] , finally , we collect our principal results , comment on evaluating the contributions of the gluonic ir degrees of freedom to relevant amplitudes , and suggest directions for future work .
the vacuum overlap amplitude of @xmath1 yang - mills theory ( without matter fields ) in the schrdinger coordinate
representation @xcite reads @xmath2 \psi_{0}\left [ \vec{a},t_{-}\right ] .\label{zprime}%\ ] ] the vacuum wave functional ( vwf ) @xmath3 depends on half of the canonical variables , i.e. on the static gauge fields @xmath4 .
its gauge invariance , like that of any other physical state and wave functional , is dictated by gau law .
this crucial requirement can be imposed on a given functional by simply projecting out its gauge - singlet component , i.e. by integration over the ( compact ) gauge group @xcite . starting from an approximate and therefore generally gauge dependent wave functional @xmath5 , one then obtains the associated vwf @xmath6 = \sum_{n}e^{iq\theta}\int d\mu\left ( u^{\left ( q\right ) } \right ) \psi_{0}\left [ \vec{a}^{u^{\left ( q\right ) } } \right ] = : \int du\psi_{0}\left [ \vec{a}^{u}\right ] \label{ginvvwf}%\ ] ] ( @xmath7 is the invariant haar measure of the gauge group , @xmath8 is the homotopy degree or winding number of the group element @xmath9 , and @xmath0 is the vacuum angle ) for which gau law is manifest .
the vacuum energy has been set to zero .
after interchanging the order of integration over gauge fields and gauge group in eq .
( [ zprime ] ) , it becomes obvious that a gauge group volume can be factored out of @xmath10 , i.e. @xmath11 \psi_{0}\left [ \vec{a}^{u_{-}}\right ] = : z\int du_{-},\ ] ] since the @xmath12-integral is gauge invariant .
in fact , the group volume @xmath13 is left over when the two un - normalized gauge projectors in the matrix element @xmath10 are multiplied into one .
the integrand of the remaining integral over the gauge group is naturally rewritten as a boltzmann factor , i.e. @xmath14 \right ) , \label{z}%\ ] ] which defines the 3-dimensional euclidean bare action @xmath15 as a functional of the `` relative '' gauge orientation @xmath16 only .
owing to the gauge invariance of the gluon field measure , @xmath15 is gauge invariant as well and takes the explicit form @xmath17 = -\ln\int d\vec{a}\psi_{0}^{\ast}\left [ \vec { a}^{u}\right ] \psi_{0}\left [ \vec{a}\right ] .\label{gammab}%\ ] ] this action describes the dynamical correlations which the gauge projection of the functional @xmath5 in eq .
( [ ginvvwf ] ) has generated .
hence it would become trivial , i.e. @xmath18-independent , if @xmath5 were gauge invariant by itself .
more specifically , @xmath19 $ ] gathers all those contributions to @xmath20 whose approximate vacua @xmath5 at @xmath21 differ by the relative gauge orientation @xmath18 .
the variable @xmath18 thus represents the contributions of a specifically weighted ensemble of all gluon field orbits to the vacuum overlap and is gauge invariant by construction . to proceed in an analytically tractable fashion
, we now adopt the standard gaussian approximation @xmath22 = \exp\left [ -\frac{1}% { 2}\text { } \int d^{3}x\int d^{3}ya_{i}^{a}\left ( \vec{x}\right ) g^{-1ab}\left ( \vec{x}-\vec{y}\right ) a_{i}^{b}\left ( \vec{y}\right ) \right ] \label{ga}%\ ] ] for the unprojected vwf , which was discussed in ref .
@xcite . a minimal gauge - invariant extension of the exponent in eq .
( [ ga ] ) characterizes the ground state of yang - mills theory in 2 + 1 dimensions @xcite . ] which has the decisive advantage of allowing integrals over @xmath12 to be done exactly .
as expected from a ground state wave functional , @xmath23 has no nodes .
it describes a `` squeezed '' state , i.e. an oscillator - type extension of the unstable coherent gluon states @xcite and thus the simplest natural candidate for the vacuum functional .
in fact , eq . ( [ ga ] ) turns into the exact ground state for @xmath24 gauge theory ( up to color factors ) if the `` covariance '' @xmath25 is taken to be the inverse of the static vector propagator .
several additional properties indicate that gaussian vwfs with suitably adapted covariances capture crucial features of the yang - mills dynamics as well .
indeed , with an appropriate choice for @xmath25 ( see below ) the wave functional ( [ ga ] ) becomes exact at high momenta and incorporates asymptotic freedom .
moreover , it is known from variational analyses that gaussian vwfs generate a dynamical mass gap and possibly confinement @xcite .
( mass generation and most other features of 2 + 1 dimensional compact photodynamics are also reproduced @xcite . )
additional support for the gaussian approximation will emerge from our results below .
after specializing the expression ( [ gammab ] ) for the bare action to @xmath23 , the functional integral over the gluon fields becomes gaussian and can readily be carried out .
the result takes the form of a 3-dimensional , bilocal nonlinear sigma model @xcite , @xmath17 = \frac{1}{2g_{b}^{2}}\int d^{3}x\int d^{3}% yl_{i}^{a}\left ( \vec{x}\right ) d^{ab}\left ( \vec{x}-\vec{y}\right ) l_{i}^{b}\left ( \vec{y}\right ) .\label{effact}%\ ] ] ( above we have omitted a term of higher order in the small bare coupling @xmath26 which vanishes at the saddle points in which we will be interested below . ) the @xmath18-dependence enters @xmath15 both via the one - forms@xmath27 i.e. the lie - algebra valued , left - invariant maurer - cartan `` currents '' ( with real components @xmath28 ) , and through higher - order corrections to the bilocal operator @xmath29 ^{ab}\simeq\frac{1}% { 2}g^{-1}\delta^{ab}+ ... \ ] ] where @xmath30 , @xmath31 and @xmath32 .
the above reformulation of the yang - mills vacuum overlap on the basis of a gauge - invariant gaussian vwf was employed in ref . @xcite as the starting point for a variational approach .
alternatively , it can be obtained from a saddle point evaluation of the functional integral @xcite in eq .
( [ gammab ] ) which becomes exact for the gaussian vwf .
since center elements of @xmath1 act trivially on the gauge fields .
we refrain from making this restriction manifest here , although it could be implemented in the action ( [ effact ] ) and may become relevant , e.g. , for the discussion of center vortices . ]
although the nonlinear sigma model ( [ effact ] ) is easier to handle than the original yang - mills theory , its exact non - perturbative treatment remains beyond analytical reach @xcite .
nevertheless , the parametric enhancement of the action ( [ effact ] ) by the factor @xmath33 suggests that a useful approximation may be obtained from a saddle point expansion of the functional integral ( [ z ] ) . in order to render this approximation practical
, however , one has to deal with the nonlocality of the bare action ( [ effact ] ) which encumbers the identification and evaluation of the saddle points .
we will show in the following section that this can be efficiently accomplished by combining a renormalization group evolution of the bare action ( which removes the explicit uv modes ) with a subsequent derivative expansion to transform the ir dynamics into an approximately local soft - mode action .
for the reasons outlined in the introduction , we are mainly interested in soft yang - mills amplitudes with external momenta @xmath34 smaller than a typical hadronic scale @xmath35 ( the lowest glueball mass , for example ) .
this restricted focus permits us to recast the bare action ( [ effact ] ) into a form which only retains soft field modes explicitly and which can be systematically approximated by a local lagrangian .
the present section describes the derivation and some useful features of this soft - mode action .
since the action ( [ effact ] ) incorporates asymptotic freedom ( for proper choices of @xmath36 , see below ) , the bare coupling @xmath26 is small at the large cutoff scale @xmath37 where the theory is originally defined .
the hard modes of the @xmath18 field with momenta @xmath38 can therefore be integrated out of the functional integral ( [ z ] ) perturbatively , down to values of the infrared scale @xmath35 where the renormalized coupling @xmath39 ceases to be much smaller than unity . in practice , this may be done for instance by wilson s momentum - shell technique @xcite , after factorizing @xmath18 into contributions from high- and low - frequency modes . to one - loop order
, the resulting renormalization of the action just amounts to the replacement of the bare coupling @xmath26 by the running coupling @xmath39 .
this was confirmed in ref .
@xcite where the one - loop coupling was obtained as @xmath40 ( for @xmath41 at @xmath42 ) .
the scaling behavior of @xmath39 makes asymptotic freedom explicit and reaffirms that the gaussian vwf reproduces the qualitative uv behavior of yang - mills theory .
in fact , eq . ( [ g(mu ) ] ) equals the one - loop yang - mills coupling up to a small correction factor @xmath43 which arises from the absence of transverse gluons and could be avoided by introducing an anisotropic component for @xmath25 @xcite .
the one - loop integration over the high - momentum modes was found to be reliable down to @xmath44 gev @xcite which provides a useful benchmark for numerical estimates . in the valid range of @xmath35 values
( [ effact ] ) turns into the renormalized soft - mode action @xmath45 = \frac{1}{4g^{2}\left ( \mu\right ) } \int d^{3}x\int d^{3}yl_{<,i}^{a}\left ( \vec{x}\right ) g^{-1}\left ( \vec{x}% -\vec{y}\right ) l_{<,i}^{b}\left ( \vec{y}\right ) \label{gamless}%\ ] ] where the subscript @xmath46 indicates that @xmath18 contains only @xmath47 modes .
the action ( [ gamless ] ) is still nonlocal .
however , this nonlocality is substantially weaker than in the bare action ( [ effact ] ) since the soft @xmath18 fields in the integrand vary too little to resolve details of @xmath25 over distances smaller than @xmath48 .
this observation can be turned into a controlled , _
approximation scheme for the soft - mode action ( [ gamless ] ) by exploiting the fact that the gradients of @xmath49 are bounded by the ir gluon mass scale , @xmath50 indeed , this bound suggests to expand the nonlocality of @xmath25 into derivatives @xmath51 which will act upon @xmath49 after partial integration . using the isotropy of @xmath52 (
as mentioned above , an anisotropic component could be allowed in principle and would lead to somewhat more general expressions ) , one has @xmath53 \delta^{3}\left ( \vec{x}-\vec{y}\right ) .
\label{gexp}%\ ] ] the dimensionless constants @xmath54 encode the low - momentum behavior of @xmath25 and could , e.g. , be determined variationally . for our present purposes ,
however , it will be sufficient to adopt the standard expression @xmath55 which approximates the solution of schwinger - dyson equations and variational estimates @xcite and incorporates both asymptotic freedom and a dynamical mass gap .
the corresponding @xmath54 can be read off directly from the fourier transform @xmath56 ( @xmath57 is a mcdonald function @xcite ) , i.e. @xmath58 @xmath59 @xmath60 etc .
the combination of the above results leads to the intended reformulation of the nonlocal dynamics ( [ effact ] ) . as anticipated , the bilocal action density for the soft modes in eq .
( [ gamless ] ) becomes a ( `` quasi''- ) local lagrangian @xmath61 and the action takes the familiar form @xmath45 = \int d^{3}x\mathcal{l}\left ( \vec{x}\right ) .\label{gamsoft}%\ ] ] the lagrangian is an expansion into powers of @xmath62 and therefore belongs to the class of generalized nonlinear sigma models . when expressed in terms of the cartan - maurer currents
@xmath63 , it reads ) could immediately be generalized to arbitrary @xmath25 by restoring the original @xmath54 dependence from eq .
( [ gexp]).]@xmath64 we have omitted total derivatives @xmath65 from the higher - order terms of @xmath66 since they do not affect the field equations .
nevertheless , they may generate non - vanishing surface terms due to infinite - action configurations which are generally irrelevant for the saddle point expansion .
to lowest order,@xmath67 + ...
\right\ } .\label{sfterm}%\ ] ] the gradient expansion in eq .
( [ efflagr ] ) is controlled by increasing powers of the parametrically small @xmath68 . for practical purposes
it can therefore be reliably truncated , at an order which is determined by the desired accuracy of the approximation to the exact action .
below , we will be interested in specific field configurations ( saddle points ) which we are going to find explicitly . for
those one may directly check _ a posteriori _ whether the full action is sufficiently well reproduced and , if not , include contributions from higher gradients . based on such tests and a virial theorem ( see sec . [ virth ] ) , we found the truncation at @xmath69 to yield a generally sufficient approximation ( at the few percent level ) to the full action ( [ gamless ] ) .
the first term in the lagrangian ( [ efflagr ] ) has the standard form of a 3-dimensional nonlinear @xmath70-model ( or principal chiral model ) .
the second one , with four derivatives acting on @xmath49 s , is reminiscent of a similar term in the skyrme model @xcite .
however , the identity@xmath71 ^{2}+\partial_{i}l_{j}\partial_{j}l_{i}\label{commplus}%\ ] ] shows that the four - derivative contribution to eq .
( [ efflagr ] ) contains , besides the commutator or skyrme term , a part which qualitatively alters the character of the euler - lagrange equations .
while the commutator generates only second - order terms to the field equations ( see below ) , the piece without equivalent in the skyrme model leads to additional fourth - order terms which allow for new types of solutions .
( several families of topological soliton solutions from the lagrangian ( [ efflagr ] ) will nevertheless turn out to resemble static skyrmions .-
field arises from yang - mills theory even without quarks , and that its physical interpretation ( representing gauge fields of a fixed relative color orientation ) is completely different from that in the skyrme model where @xmath18 represents fluctuations around the chiral order parameter . ] ) we end this section by emphasizing that the construction of an analogous gradient expansion in terms of the original gauge fields @xmath12 would require the ( residual ) gauge freedom to be completely fixed and thus give rise to all the associated conceptual and calculational complications .
( otherwise a `` soft '' gauge field could just be turned into a `` hard '' one by a suitable gauge transformation and would spoil the `` convergence '' of the derivative expansion . ) the locality and structural simplicity of the soft - mode lagrangian ( [ efflagr ] ) can therefore be regarded as a benefit of reformulating the dynamics in terms of the gauge invariant @xmath18 field variables .
our next task will be to set up the saddle point ( or , more specifically , steepest descent ) expansion of the functional integral over the soft modes , @xmath72 \right ) , \label{zsoft}%\ ] ] where the vacuum overlap @xmath20 serves as the prototype for similar integrals in other soft amplitudes .
this expansion is based on the ir saddle point fields @xmath73 , i.e. the local minima of the soft - mode action ( [ gamsoft ] ) .
the search for these minima is simplified by the fact that all finite - action @xmath18-field configurations , including most saddle points , fall into disjoint topological classes ( cf .
[ top ] and below ) .
since fields which carry different topological charges - for now summarily denoted by @xmath8 - can not be continuously deformed into each other , the local variation of the action may be performed in each topological sector separately .
this amounts to solving the saddle point equations@xmath74 } { \delta u_{<}\left ( \vec { x}\right ) } \right| _ { u_{<}=\bar{u}_{i}^{\left ( q\right ) } } = 0\label{spaeq}%\ ] ] at fixed @xmath8 . to leading order ,
the saddle - point expansion for the vacuum overlap @xmath20 can then be assembled by summing the contributions from the solutions @xmath75 of eq .
( [ spaeq ] ) , i.e. @xmath76 \exp\left ( -\gamma\left [ \bar{u}_{i}^{\left ( q\right ) } \right ] \right ) , \label{zspa}%\ ] ] where the pre - exponential factors @xmath77 are generated by zero - mode contributions which typically arise if continuous symmetries of the action are broken by the solutions .
the sum over the saddle points , labeled by @xmath78 , symbolically includes integrals with the appropriate measure when the saddle points come in continuous families .
functional integrals for more complex amplitudes , including the gluonic green functions , receive contributions from the same saddle points and are obtained by differentiating @xmath20 with respect to suitably implemented sources .
higher - order corrections to the approximation ( [ zspa ] ) can be systematically calculated from the ( nondegenerate ) fluctuations around the solutions @xmath75 .
the reliability of the leading - order approximation ( [ zspa ] ) increases with the action values of the saddle points because @xmath79 \gg1 $ ] prevents the saddle point contributions from being rendered insignificant by the fluctuations of @xmath80 around them . in our case ,
compliance with this criterion is reinforced by the overall factor @xmath81 ( for @xmath82 gev ) in the lagrangian ( [ efflagr ] ) which parametrically enhances the action . ) since @xmath83 . ] for the explicit solution of the saddle - point equation ( [ spaeq ] ) , as well as for part of our general analysis below , it is practically necessary to adopt a parametrization of the @xmath1 group elements @xmath18 which allows to work directly with their @xmath84 independent degrees of freedom .
we will use the exponential representation @xmath85 \label{uparam}%\ ] ] for this purpose , where the coefficient vector of the lie algebra generators is decomposed into its direction , specified by the vector field @xmath86 with @xmath87 ( which parametrizes the coset @xmath88 where @xmath89 is the cartan subgroup of the gauge group ) , and its length * * @xmath90 . for simplicity
, we will also specialize our following discussion to @xmath91 .
the soft - mode lagrangian ( [ efflagr ] ) can then be rewritten in terms of the unit vector field @xmath86 and the spin-0 field @xmath90 as @xmath92 where , for the reasons discussed in the paragraph below eq .
( [ sfterm ] ) , all terms of the gradient expansion with up to four derivatives on the @xmath18 fields are retained .
the two - derivative part @xmath93 , i.e. the standard nonlinear @xmath70-model , becomes@xmath94\ ] ] while the four - derivative contributions turn into@xmath95 .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the general expressions above show that @xmath96 , as required for the existence of the functional integral ( [ zsoft ] ) .
the same remains true if higher orders of the derivative expansion ( [ efflagr ] ) are included ( as long as @xmath97 , of course ) .
for the analysis of some generic saddle point solution properties , including their behavior under scale transformations ( cf . sec .
[ sps ] ) , it will prove useful that both @xmath93 and @xmath98 are even individually nonnegative . by varying the action ( [ gamsoft ] ) of the lagrangian ( [ l24d ] ) with respect to @xmath90 and @xmath86 ,
the saddle point equation ( [ spaeq ] ) turns into a nonlinear system of four coupled partial differential equations . for @xmath90 one
directly obtains@xmath99 } { \delta\phi\left ( \vec{x}\right ) } & = \partial^{4}\phi-2\partial^{2}% \phi\left ( \partial_{i}\hat{n}^{a}\right ) ^{2}-4\partial_{i}\phi\partial _ { i}\partial_{k}\hat{n}^{a}\partial_{k}\hat{n}^{a}-4\cos\phi\left ( \partial_{i}\partial_{j}\phi\partial_{i}\hat{n}^{a}+\partial_{j}\phi \partial^{2}\hat{n}^{a}+\partial_{i}\phi\partial_{i}\partial_{j}\hat{n}% ^{a}\right )
\partial_{j}\hat{n}^{a}\nonumber\\ & + 2\sin\phi\left [ \left ( \partial_{i}\phi\partial_{i}\hat{n}^{a}\right ) ^{2}-\left ( 1-\cos\phi\right ) \left ( \partial_{i}\hat{n}^{a}\partial _ { j}\hat{n}^{a}\right ) ^{2}-2\partial_{i}\hat{n}^{a}\partial_{i}\partial ^{2}\hat{n}^{a}-\left ( \partial_{i}\partial_{j}\hat{n}^{a}\right ) ^{2}+\left ( \partial_{i}\hat{n}^{a}\right ) ^{2}\left ( \partial_{j}\hat { n}^{b}\right ) ^{2}\right ] \nonumber\\ & -\sin\phi\cos\phi\left ( \partial_{i}\hat{n}^{a}\right ) ^{2}\left ( \partial_{j}\hat{n}^{b}\right ) ^{2}-\sin\phi\left ( \delta^{ab}+\hat{n}% ^{a}\hat{n}^{b}\right ) \partial^{2}\hat{n}^{a}\partial^{2}\hat{n}^{b}% -2\mu^{2}\left [ \partial^{2}\phi-\sin\phi\left ( \partial_{i}\hat{n}% ^{a}\right ) ^{2}\right ] = 0.\label{omeq}%\end{aligned}\ ] ] the three equations for the components of the @xmath100 field , on the other hand , have to be derived by a constrained variation whose task it is to preserve the unit length of @xmath100 . as a consequence , they can be cast into the succinct form @xmath101 } { \delta\hat{n}^{a}\left ( \vec{x}\right ) } = 0\label{neq}%\ ] ] where the projection operator ensures that the action is only affected by those variations @xmath102 which maintain orthogonality to @xmath103 .
the evaluation of the functional derivative with respect to @xmath104 yields @xmath105 } { \delta\hat{n}^{a}\left ( \vec{x}\right ) } & = -\left ( 1-\cos\phi\right ) \left ( \partial^{2}\hat{n}^{a}\hat{n}^{c}\partial^{2}\hat{n}^{c}\right ) + \partial_{i}\left\ { \sin\phi\partial^{2}\phi\partial_{i}\hat{n}^{a}\right .
-\sin\phi\partial_{i}\phi\partial^{2}\hat{n}^{a}-2\cos\phi\partial_{i}% \phi\partial_{j}\phi\partial_{j}\hat{n}^{a}\nonumber\\ & + \cos\phi\partial_{i}\phi\partial_{k}\phi\partial_{k}\hat{n}^{a}+\sin \phi\partial_{i}\partial_{k}\phi\partial_{k}\hat{n}^{a}+\sin\phi\partial _ { k}\phi\partial_{i}\partial_{k}\hat{n}^{a}+\sin\phi\partial_{i}\phi\left ( \partial^{2}\hat{n}^{a}-\hat{n}^{a}\hat{n}^{c}\partial^{2}\hat{n}^{c}\right ) \nonumber\\ & + \left ( 1-\cos\phi\right ) \left [ \partial_{i}\partial^{2}\hat{n}% ^{a}-\hat{n}^{c}\partial_{i}\hat{n}^{a}\partial^{2}\hat{n}^{c}-\hat{n}% ^{a}\partial_{i}\hat{n}^{c}\partial^{2}\hat{n}^{c}-\hat{n}^{a}\hat{n}% ^{c}\partial_{i}\partial^{2}\hat{n}^{c}-\left ( \partial_{j}\phi\right ) ^{2}\partial_{i}\hat{n}^{a}-2\mu^{2}\partial_{i}\hat{n}^{a}\right ] \nonumber\\ & -\sin^{2}\phi\partial_{i}\hat{n}^{a}\left ( \partial_{i}\hat{n}^{c}\right ) ^{2}-2\left ( 1-\cos\phi\right ) ^{2}\left [ \partial_{i}\hat{n}^{a}\left ( \partial_{j}\hat{n}^{c}\right ) ^{2}-\partial_{i}\hat{n}^{c}\partial_{j}% \hat{n}^{c}\partial_{j}\hat{n}^{a}\right ] \left . { }
\right\ } .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the saddle point equations ( [ omeq ] ) and ( [ neq ] ) are independent of the coupling @xmath106 because it enters the action only through the overall factor @xmath107 . in general
, their solutions have to be found numerically .
however , we will demonstrate below that several nontrivial analytical solutions exist and that further important solution classes with a rather high degree of symmetry can be obtained by solving substantially simplified field equations .
moreover , essential qualitative solution properties can be derived without solving the saddle point equations explicitly ( cf .
[ sps ] ) .
each topological charge sector contains at least one action minimum , for example , i.e. one solution of eqs .
( [ omeq ] ) and ( [ neq ] ) .
the requirement of finding and including all of them would render the saddle point expansion practically useless .
fortunately , however , this turns out to be unnecessary . below we will establish lower bounds on the action of the saddle points which are monotonically increasing functions of their topological charges .
hence contributions from saddle points in high topological charge sectors can generally be ignored .
before actually solving the saddle - point equations ( [ omeq ] ) and ( [ neq ] ) in secs . [ solncl ] and [ qspi ] , it will be useful to obtain a few general insights into the topological structure and stability properties of the solutions .
this is the objective of the present section . in order to analyze the scaling behavior of the extended saddle point solutions and to establish the underlying virial theorem ,
we define the scaled fields @xmath108 for real @xmath109 and note that @xmath35 is the only mass scale in the field equations ( [ omeq ] ) and ( [ neq ] ) .
this immediately implies that the solutions of the saddle point equations with scaled parameter @xmath110 can be obtained by rescaling the original solutions @xmath111 to @xmath112 . in the following ,
however , we will keep @xmath35 fixed .
the scale - transformed extended solutions then cease to solve the field equations , and this simple observation together with two basic properties of the lagrangian ( [ l24d ] ) can be turned into a virial theorem .
the first step towards its derivation consists in establishing the relation between the actions of scaled and unscaled fields ( as long as they stay finite ) , which can be read off from the 2- and 4-derivative parts of the lagrangian ( [ l24d ] ) separately :
@xmath113 = \gamma_{2d}\left ( \lambda\right ) + \gamma_{4d}\left ( \lambda\right ) = \frac{1}{\lambda}\gamma_{2d}\left ( 1\right ) + \lambda \gamma_{4d}\left ( 1\right ) .\label{gamlam}%\ ] ] the second relevant property of the action based on eq .
( [ l24d ] ) is its strict positivity for extended , i.e. not translationally invariant field configurations ( cf .
[ spex ] ) , @xmath114 the remaining step is to specialize the fields under consideration to the saddle point solutions . since those extremize the action under arbitrary small variations - which of course include infinitesimal scale transformations - one immediately has @xmath115 and consequently the virial theorem @xmath116 eq .
( [ vth ] ) clearly exhibits the crucial role of the four - derivative terms @xmath117 in guaranteeing the stability of the saddle point solutions : for @xmath118 the remaining nonlinear @xmath70-model action would be minimized by sending @xmath119 ( cf .
( [ gamlam ] ) ) , i.e. by the scale collapse of the solutions which derrick s theorem predicts @xcite .
our truncation of the gradient expansion ( [ efflagr ] ) at @xmath120 therefore turns out to be the minimal approximation which can support localized , stable soliton solutions . )
one might therefore suspect that their contributions could destabilize the extended solutions .
however , this would just indicate an incorrect truncation of the gradient expansion .
indeed , if a localized solution is small enough to be significantly affected by higher - derivative terms , those would have to be added to the field equations in the first place .
( a somewhat analogous situation is encountered in one - loop coleman - weinberg potentials : their physically relevant local minima are stable only as long as fluctuations remain small , i.e. as long as the underlying truncation of the loop expansion is justified @xcite . ) ] furthermore , @xmath121 implies that the scaling extrema are indeed action minima and that solutions with @xmath122 are points of inflection .
finally , it is worth emphasizing that the coexistence of terms with different numbers of derivatives in the lagrangian ( [ efflagr ] ) , and thus ultimately the virial theorem ( [ vth ] ) and the existence of stable solutions , is brought about by the mass scale @xmath35 which reflects the short - wavelength quantum fluctuations integrated out in sec .
this situation is reminiscent of the classical instanton solutions to the yang - mills equation whose typical size scale must likewise be generated by quantum fluctuations . to summarize ,
we have established a virial theorem which ensures that the extended solutions of eqs .
( [ omeq ] ) and ( [ neq ] ) are stable against scale transformations . in our context
this is an indispensable property since unstable solutions would prohibit a useful saddle point expansion . as a side benefit ,
the virial theorem also provides stringent tests for the numerical solutions of the saddle point equations . as a three - dimensional principal chiral model with stabilizing higher - derivative terms
, the soft - mode lagrangian ( [ l24d ] ) allows for topological soliton solutions . in the present section
we discuss three topological invariants or charges which such solutions and more general continuous fields @xmath18 may carry @xcite .
the most fundamental topological classification arises from the fact that all @xmath18-fields with a finite action @xmath123 based on any truncation of the lagrangian ( [ efflagr ] ) have to approach the same constant at @xmath124 . as a higher - dimensional analog of the stereographic projection
, this compactifies their domain to a three - sphere @xmath125 .
all @xmath18 s with finite @xmath123 therefore describe continuous maps from @xmath125 into the `` topologically active '' part of the group manifold .
for @xmath1 the latter is the trivially embedded subgroup @xmath126 .
the resulting maps @xmath127 fall into disjoint homotopy classes , the elements of the third homotopy group @xmath128 , which are characterized by a topological degree or charge@xmath129 = \frac{1}{24\pi^{2}}\int d^{3}x\varepsilon_{ijk}tr\left\ { u^{\dagger}\partial_{i}uu^{\dagger}\partial_{j}uu^{\dagger}\partial _ { k}u\right\ } .\label{q}%\ ] ] ( the integrand can be shown to be a total derivative , as expected for a topological `` charge density '' . ) for finite - action fields @xmath130 . in terms of the @xmath131 parametrization ( [ uparam ] ) for @xmath132 ,
( [ q ] ) reduces to@xmath133 = \frac{1}{2^{4}\pi^{2}}\int d^{3}x\left ( \cos\phi-1\right ) \varepsilon_{ijk}\varepsilon^{abc}\partial_{i}\phi\hat { n}^{a}\partial_{j}\hat{n}^{b}\partial_{k}\hat{n}^{c}.\label{qomn}%\ ] ] two additional topological quantum numbers of @xmath18 are carried solely by its @xmath100-field component .
the first is the homotopy degree of the maps @xmath86 from the space boundary @xmath134 ( where @xmath135 ) into the unit sphere @xmath136 on which @xmath86 takes values .
continuous maps of this sort are classified by the elements of the homotopy group @xmath137 .
( the same topology characterizes the magnetic charge of wu - yang monopoles @xcite . )
an explicit integral representation of their degree is @xmath138 = \frac{1}{8\pi}\int_{\partial r^{3}}d\sigma _ { i}\varepsilon_{ijk}\varepsilon^{abc}\hat{n}^{a}\partial_{j}\hat{n}% ^{b}\partial_{k}\hat{n}^{c}\label{qm}%\ ] ] where the integral extends over the closed surface @xmath139 at @xmath140 . as expected , @xmath141 is @xmath90-independent .
the third topological invariant owes its existence to the fact that all @xmath100 fields of finite action are required to approach a constant unit vector at spacial infinity . as above
, this requirement compactifies @xmath142 into @xmath125 and thereby turns @xmath143 into continuous maps @xmath144 .
such maps carry a hopf charge @xmath145 which labels the elements of the homotopy group @xmath146 , i.e. the hopf bundle @xcite .
an explicit integral representation for @xmath145 can be constructed by means of the local isomorphism between the nonlinear @xmath147 and @xmath148 fields which expresses @xmath86 in terms of a complex 2-component field @xmath149 with unit modulus @xmath150 as @xmath151 .
then one has @xmath152 = \frac{1}{4\pi^{2}}\int d^{3}x\varepsilon_{ijk}\left ( \chi^{\dagger}\partial_{i}\chi\right ) \left ( \partial_{j}\chi^{\dagger}\partial_{k}\chi\right ) .\label{qh}%\ ] ] ( a _ local _ integral representation for @xmath145 directly in terms of the @xmath100-field does not exist . ) in contrast to the topological charges @xmath8 and @xmath141 which are of winding - number type , the hopf invariant @xmath145 is a linking number .
the underlying topological structure enables and classifies the link and knot solutions to be encountered in sec .
[ fn ] . finally , we recall that the @xmath18 field topology - as summarized in the conserved topological quantum numbers @xmath8 , @xmath141 and @xmath145 - characterizes not only the saddle point solutions but a much larger class of continuous field configurations with finite and in some cases even infinite ( see below ) action . the distribution of the solutions to eqs .
( [ omeq ] ) and ( [ neq ] ) over a denumerably infinite set of topological charge sectors allows for the existence of more saddle points than could be handled in practical applications of the expansion ( [ zspa ] ) .
hence additional criteria are required to select the most relevant saddle points in a controlled fashion .
such criteria will be established below , in the form of action bounds which are monotonically increasing functions of the absolute topological charge values .
these bounds imply that contributions from saddle points with higher topological quantum numbers to functional integrals are increasingly suppressed by the boltzmann factor @xmath153 and can be systematically neglected . in the present section
we establish the action bound for fields which carry finite values of @xmath8 . a similar bound for fields with nonvanishing hopf charge
will be obtained in sec .
[ fn ] .
the lower bound on the action of the lagrangian ( [ l24d ] ) for any field @xmath18 with a well - defined homotopy degree ( [ q ] ) can be derived from the lie - algebra valued expression@xmath154 where @xmath155 and @xmath156 are the components of the maurer - cartan one - form ( [ l ] ) . with the help of the maurer - cartan identity@xmath157\ ] ] one obtains for its square@xmath158 which obeys the basic inequality @xmath159 ( recall from eq .
( [ l ] ) that the @xmath156 are expanded into anti - hermitean generators . ) after specializing the bound ( [ trmm ] ) to @xmath160 and @xmath161 , in eq .
( [ gexp ] ) could be accomodated by modifying the values of @xmath162 and @xmath163 and would result in a different factor in front of @xmath164 in the bogomolnyi bound . ] multiplying by @xmath165 , integrating over @xmath166 and using the integral representation ( [ q ] ) for @xmath8 , one arrives at@xmath167 .\label{prebnd}%\ ] ] the more stringent of these inequalities results from the lower ( upper ) sign on the right - hand side if @xmath168 ( @xmath169 ) .
their left - hand side amounts to the action which is produced by the first two terms ) in @xmath123 . after specializing to @xmath160 and @xmath170
, the obvious identity @xmath171 then results in @xmath172 = -\frac{\mu}{2g^{2}\left ( \mu\right ) } \int d^{3}xtr\left\ { l_{i}% l_{i}-\frac{1}{2\mu^{2}}l_{i}\partial^{2}l_{i}\right\ } \geq\mp\frac{12\pi ^{2}}{g^{2}\left ( \mu\right ) } q\left [ u\right ] + \int d^{3}x\delta \mathcal{l}\left ( \vec{x}\right ) .$ ] ] of the lagrangian ( [ efflagr ] ) .
hence the expressions ( [ prebnd ] ) for both signs combine into an inequality of bogomolnyi type,@xmath173 \geq\frac{12\pi^{2}}{g^{2}\left ( \mu\right ) } \left| q\left [ u\right ] \right| .\label{bb}%\ ] ] this is the desired lower bound on the action of any sufficiently smooth @xmath18 field with well - defined degree @xmath8 .
it is saturated by those fields which obey the bogomolnyi - type equation @xmath174 where the lower ( upper ) sign again refers to @xmath168 ( @xmath169 ) .
the equations ( [ beq ] ) can be considered as analogs of the self-(anti)-duality equations of yang - mills theory and have the interesting consequence that the rescaled maurer - cartan currents @xmath175 of minimal - action fields in any @xmath8-sector become generators of the @xmath176 lie algebra , @xmath177 = i\varepsilon_{ijk}\tilde{l}_{k}.\ ] ] translationally invariant solutions ( cf .
[ classvac ] ) , for example , have @xmath178 and therefore trivially saturate the bound in the @xmath179 sector .
it remains to be seen whether nontrivial solutions in sectors with larger @xmath164 exist as well can only be saturated on a hyperspherical domain @xmath180 , for example @xcite . ] the large factor multiplying @xmath164 in the inequality ( [ bb ] ) indicates that contributions from saddle points with higher @xmath181 are strongly suppressed .
in fact , they seem safely negligible in most amplitudes which receive nonvanishing contributions from the @xmath179 sector .
however , one should keep in mind that even contributions with extremely small `` fugacities '' can sometimes have an important qualitative impact on the partition function . a case in point
are the decisive monopole contributions in the 2 + 1 dimensional yang - mills - higgs model @xcite .
the physical interpretation of the @xmath182 solutions and their analogs in yang - mills theory will be discussed in sec .
in the following sections we are going to solve the four saddle point equations ( [ omeq ] ) and ( [ neq ] ) explicitly . as already mentioned , our main focus will be on solutions with a relatively high amount of symmetry since their typically smaller action values enhance their contributions to the saddle point expansion .
besides playing a predominant role in most amplitudes , these solutions can often be obtained either analytically or with moderate numerical effort .
the simplest solutions of the saddle point equations ( [ omeq ] ) and ( [ neq ] ) are the @xmath166-independent matrices@xmath183 = const.\ ] ] where @xmath184 and @xmath185 are both constant .
these solutions form the complete vacuum manifold of the dynamics ( [ l24d ] ) , i.e. the set of all fields which attain the absolute action minimum@xmath186 = 0.\ ] ] due to a redundancy in the parametrization ( [ uparam ] ) , the subset of vacua in the center of the gauge group is completely @xmath86-independent : @xmath187 in addition , those are the only vacua which do not break the global @xmath188 symmetry of the lagrangian ( [ l24d ] ) spontaneously .
a glance at the integral representation ( [ qomn ] ) shows that none of the @xmath189 carries topological charges @xmath190 .
any constant vector @xmath86 solves the saddle point equation ( [ neq ] ) identically and reduces the other one , eq .
( [ omeq ] ) for @xmath90 , to the linear field equation@xmath191 obviously , the solutions of this equation constitute families of new saddle points which differ by an additive constant and have degenerate action values .
( this trivially ensures periodicity in @xmath90 . ) alternatively , eq .
( [ omeqconstn ] ) and the action of its solutions can be derived from the reduced lagrangian , its contributions to @xmath20 remain nontrivial since the haar measure generates interactions among the @xmath90 modes.]@xmath192 .\label{lconstn}%\ ] ] the presence of the 4th - order term in eq .
( [ omeqconstn ] ) allows for solution types which have no equivalent in skyrme models .
( indeed , the commutator or skyrme term ( cf . eq .
( [ commplus ] ) ) alone leads to a laplace equation for @xmath90 , without a mass scale and with only constant regular finite - action solutions on @xmath142 . )
a glance at the integrals ( [ qomn ] ) - ( [ qh ] ) shows that solutions with constant @xmath100 do not carry any topological quantum numbers , i.e. @xmath193 all solutions of the linear field equation ( [ omeqconstn ] ) can be constructed by standard green function techniques .
the perhaps most straightforward approach is to fold the static klein - gordon propagator@xmath194 with a `` scalar potential '' @xmath195 which is defined both to be a solution of the laplace equation , @xmath196 , and to act as the inhomogeneity of the static klein - gordon equation @xmath197 the field equation ( [ omeqconstn ] ) is recovered from eq .
( [ inhomkg ] ) by applying the laplacian to both sides .
since the potential @xmath195 plays the role of a source for the @xmath90 field , inversion of the klein - gordon operator immediately yields the general solution @xmath198 of course , the regular finite - action solutions form but a small subset of those comprised in eq .
( [ gensolconstn ] ) .
spherically symmetric solutions can be obtained more directly by restricting the angular dependence of @xmath90 , i.e. by substituting the ansatz @xmath199 with @xmath200 into the general equation ( [ omeqconstn ] ) and ignoring for the moment potential singularities at the origin .
this yields the radial equation @xmath201 ( radial derivatives @xmath202 are denoted by a prime ) whose four linearly independent solutions can be found analytically : @xmath203 the subset of regular finite - action solutions is therefore of the form@xmath204 the associated potential@xmath205 shows that the expression ( [ phineqc ] ) in fact solves a generalization of the homogeneous field equation ( [ omeqconstn ] ) , with an additional delta - function singularity at the origin .
( [ phineqc ] ) is therefore a solution of eq .
( [ omeqconstn ] ) everywhere except at @xmath206 and , strictly speaking , one of its green functions . a representative of this solution class is drawn in fig
. 1 . after insertion into eq .
( [ gamsoft ] ) , based on the lagrangian ( [ l24d ] ) , and use of the virial theorem ( [ vth ] ) one finds the solutions ( [ phineqc ] ) to have the action @xmath207 = \frac{2\pi\mu}{g^{2}\left ( \mu\right ) } \int_{0}^{\infty}dr\left ( r\phi^{\left ( \hat{n}=c\right ) \prime}\right ) ^{2}=\frac{\pi}{\sqrt{2}% } \frac{c_{2}^{2}}{g^{2}\left ( \mu\right ) } .\ ] ] this action is not subject to topological bounds and reaches the absolute minimum @xmath208 for @xmath209 where the constant-@xmath100 solutions turn into the translationally invariant vacua of sec .
[ classvac ] .
( in contrast to the center elements ( [ omck ] ) , however , the value of @xmath90 remains unrestricted here . ) due to their partly very small action values , the constant-@xmath100 solutions may have a strong impact on the saddle point expansion which should be explored in detail by studying their contributions to suitable amplitudes .
in addition to the translationally invariant saddle points of sec . [ classvac ] , there are other and less trivial solutions of the field equations ( [ omeq ] ) and ( [ neq ] ) with constant @xmath90 fields . among them , the most intriguing class has the general form @xmath210 which satisfies eq .
( [ omeq ] ) identically and carries no topological charge @xmath8 .
in fact , the nontrivial topology of @xmath211 ( as that of any other constant-@xmath90 field configuration ) has to reside exclusively in the @xmath212-dependence of its @xmath100 field , whose dynamics is governed by the ( @xmath213-independent ) equation @xmath214 = 0.\label{knoteq}%\ ] ] the field equation ( [ knoteq ] ) follows from the general saddle point equation ( [ neq ] ) by substituting @xmath215 and simultaneously plays the role of a ( static ) continuity equation for the conserved @xmath216 current .
alternatively , it can be obtained by directly varying the reduced lagrangian@xmath217 \label{ln}%\ ] ] which follows from eq .
( [ l24d ] ) after specialization to @xmath215 and reproduces the action ( [ gamsoft ] ) for the @xmath218 .
remarkably , the lagrangian ( [ ln ] ) is a generalization of the static skyrme - faddeev - niemi ( sfn ) model @xcite @xmath219 in contrast to the sfn model , however , which was postulated on the basis of qualitative symmetry and renormalization group arguments @xcite , our lagrangian ( [ ln ] ) follows uniquely from the yang - mills dynamics and the gaussian approximation to the vacuum wave functional .
all coefficients are therefore fixed in terms of the ir scale @xmath35 and the coupling @xmath220 , i.e. eq . ( [ ln ] ) does not contain free parameters .
particular solutions of equation ( [ knoteq ] ) are @xmath221 , which belong to the class of translationally invariant vacua ( cf . sec .
[ constn ] ) , and @xmath222 ( except at @xmath223 ) which is an example from the `` hedgehog '' solution family whose detailed discussion will be the subject of the following sections .
the @xmath224 hedgehog has infinite action ( since @xmath225 develops a monopole - type singularity at @xmath226 cf .
[ shs ] ) and its lagrangian reduces exactly to the faddeev - niemi form ( [ fnl ] ) .
( [ knoteq ] ) does probably also have cylindrically symmetric vortex solutions which are analogs of the `` baby skyrmion '' solutions @xcite in similar models . the most interesting and many - faceted solution classes of the field equation ( [ knoteq ] ) ,
however , are expected to be twists , linked loops and knots made of closed fluxtubes .
indeed , an intriguing variety of such topological soliton solutions was found numerically for the sfn part ( [ fnl ] ) of the lagrangian ( [ ln ] ) in refs .
these solutions generally lack axial symmetry and carry a finite hopf charge in the sub - model ( [ ln ] ) , it might be possible to `` unwind '' and thus destabilize them by excitations into the @xmath90 direction of the complete theory .
this possibility deserves further investigation . ]
moreover , their number and complexity increases strongly with the value of @xmath228 . as in the higher-@xmath164 solution sectors
discussed previously , a practically useful saddle point expansion thus requires an effective means for selecting the relevant contributions in a controlled fashion . as anticipated in sec .
[ bogbnd ] , such a means can be provided by establishing that the action @xmath229 based on the lagrangian ( [ ln ] ) is bounded from below by a monotonically increasing function of @xmath230 .
actually , this just requires a straightforward adaptation of a known bound on the sfn action @xcite .
one combines the obvious inequalities @xmath231 & \geq\frac{\mu}{g^{2}\left ( \mu\right ) } \int d^{3}x\left [ \left ( \partial_{i}\hat{n}^{a}\right ) ^{2}+\frac{1}{\mu^{2}}\left ( \varepsilon^{abc}\partial_{i}\hat{n}^{b}% \partial_{j}\hat{n}^{c}\right ) ^{2}\right ] \\ & \geq\frac{2}{g^{2}\left ( \mu\right ) } \left [ \int d^{3}x\left ( \partial_{i}\hat{n}^{a}\right ) ^{2}\right ] ^{1/2}\left [ \int d^{3}x\left ( \varepsilon^{abc}\hat{n}^{a}\partial_{i}\hat{n}^{b}\partial_{j}\hat{n}% ^{c}\right ) ^{2}\right ] ^{1/2}%\end{aligned}\ ] ] ( the first one holds because the omitted term in the lagrangian ( [ ln ] ) is manifestly non - negative ; the second one is a consequence of @xmath232 for any real @xmath233 ) with the sobolev - type inequality @xcite@xmath234 \right| ^{3/2}\leq\frac{1}{2^{6}\sqrt { 2}3^{3/4}\pi^{4}}\int d^{3}x\sqrt{\left ( \varepsilon^{abc}\hat{n}% ^{a}\partial_{i}\hat{n}^{b}\partial_{j}\hat{n}^{c}\right ) ^{2}}\int d^{3}x\left ( \varepsilon^{abc}\hat{n}^{a}\partial_{i}\hat{n}^{b}\partial _ { j}\hat{n}^{c}\right ) ^{2}\label{soi}%\ ] ] and a simple inequality due to ward @xcite , @xmath235 ^{2}\geq2\left ( \varepsilon^{abc}\hat{n}^{a}\partial_{i}\hat{n}^{b}\partial_{j}\hat{n}% ^{c}\right ) ^{2},\ ] ] to end up with the bound@xmath236 \geq\frac{2^{9/2}3^{3/8}\pi^{2}}% { g^{2}\left ( \mu\right ) } \left| q_{h}\left [ \hat{n}\right ] \right| ^{3/4}.\label{vkb}%\ ] ] ( @xmath237 ) this bound is rather rough and could probably be made more stringent by incorporating the 3rd term of the lagrangian ( [ ln ] ) and by refining the sobolev bound ( [ soi ] ) which is expected to remain valid with about half of the factor on its right - hand side @xcite .
the probably most important lesson of the present section is a new physical interpretation for faddeev - niemi - type knot solutions . in our framework , they reemerge as gauge invariant ir degrees of freedom which represent gluon field ensembles with a nonvanishing `` collective '' hopf charge in the vacuum overlap and other amplitudes .
this new interpretation may actually put the tentative identification of knot solutions with glueballs , advocated as a natural generalization of the fluxtube picture for quark - antiquark mesons in refs .
@xcite , on a more solid basis . indeed , the original association of refs .
@xcite is obscured by the interpretation of the @xmath100 field as a gauge - dependent local color direction .
our @xmath100 field , on the other hand , is manifestly gauge invariant .
field is that one does not have to deal with unwanted , colored goldstone bosons if the @xmath147 symmetry of the lagrangians ( [ l24d ] ) and ( [ ln ] ) is spontaneously broken .
] moreover , glueballs are anyhow natural candidates for gluonic ir degrees of freedom in the @xmath179 sector , so that their ( perhaps partial or indirect ) appearance in the saddle point solution spectrum would not be unexpected .
an additional advantage of our new framework for the knot dynamics is that it allows the investigation of potential relations between the solutions of eq .
( [ knoteq ] ) and specific yang - mills fields which may play important roles in the vacuum , including e.g. topologically nontrivial pure - gauge fields in a non - linear maximally abelian gauge @xcite and center vortices @xcite .
if such relations exist , they could perhaps be qualitatively traced by analytical methods .
a full quantitative survey of the knot solution sector , however , will require a devoted numerical effort . )
is impeded by the fact that the obvious anstze tend to fail .
a few numerical knot solutions with small @xmath230 are probably sufficient for the saddle point expansion , however , since contributions to physical amplitudes are severely limited by the stringent action bound ( [ vkb ] ) , especially when @xmath238 solutions contribute as well . ] the existence of skyrmions @xcite in nonlinear @xmath70-models with higher - derivative interactions suggests that our field equations ( [ omeq ] ) and ( [ neq ] ) have topological soliton solutions of `` hedgehog '' type , @xmath239 ( @xmath240 , @xmath241 ) , as well .
their @xmath242 `` grand spin '' symmetry characterizes the invariance of the corresponding @xmath18 fields under simultaneous spatial and internal rotations and implies a substantial simplification of their dynamics .
( for larger gauge groups @xmath1 with @xmath243 , the three components of @xmath244 form the part of the @xmath86 field which parametrizes the trivially embedded @xmath242 subgroup . ) in the present section , we discuss general properties of the hedgehog fields and derive their reduced lagrangian and saddle point equation .
in the subsequent sections [ anhh ] and [ qspi ] , we find the most important solution classes explicitly and determine their physical interpretation .
the principal topological characteristic of the hedgehog configurations ( [ hh ] ) is their @xmath245 winding number @xmath8 .
for fields of the form ( [ hh ] ) , its integral representation ( [ qomn ] ) reduces to @xmath246 & = \frac{1}{2\pi}\int _ { 0}^{\infty}\phi^{\left ( hh\right ) \prime}\left ( \cos\phi^{\left ( hh\right ) } -1\right ) dr\nonumber\\ & = \frac{1}{2\pi}\left [ \sin\phi^{\left ( hh\right ) } \left ( \infty\right ) -\sin\phi^{\left ( hh\right ) } \left ( 0\right ) + \phi^{\left ( hh\right ) } \left ( 0\right ) -\phi^{\left ( hh\right ) } \left ( \infty\right ) \right ] .\label{hq}%\end{aligned}\ ] ] ( as expected from a topological invariant , it depends only on the boundary values of the @xmath90 field . ) in sec .
[ top ] we established that finite action fields carry integer values of @xmath8 , and eq .
( [ hq ] ) confirms this explicitly .
indeed , the parametrization ( [ uparam ] ) for hedgehog fields ( [ hh ] ) implies that well - defined @xmath18 fields necessitate the boundary condition @xmath247 and that finite - action fields must additionally satisfy @xmath248 ( see below ) where @xmath249 and thus @xmath250 are integers .
nevertheless , it is instructive to consider the more general boundary conditions @xmath251 = \frac{n - m}{2}\label{q - hh}%\ ] ] ( @xmath252 integer ) which admit infinite - action fields with half - integer winding numbers as well ( for either @xmath253 or @xmath254 odd ) .
we will show in sec .
[ qspi ] that hedgehog solutions to the saddle point equations ( [ omeq ] ) , ( [ neq ] ) under the boundary conditions ( [ q - hh ] ) , both with finite and infinite action , can indeed be found .
the hedgehog solutions with @xmath255 will be of particular importance since they probably dominate all @xmath190 contributions to the saddle point expansion .
this follows from the bound ( [ bb ] ) and from skyrme - model type arguments @xcite which suggest that the minimal - action solutions in the @xmath256 sectors are hedgehogs .
in addition , all hedgehog fields carry one unit of a second topological quantum number , the monopole - type charge @xmath257 .
this becomes explicit when evaluating the ( @xmath90 independent ) integral representation ( [ qm ] ) for @xmath141 with @xmath222 : @xmath258 = \frac{1}{4\pi}\int d\sigma_{i}\frac{\hat{x}_{i}}{r^{2}}=1.\ ] ] obviously , @xmath259 is independent of the boundary conditions for @xmath90 and therefore of @xmath8 .
the field with @xmath260 ( the `` anti - monopole '' ) is obtained by replacing @xmath261 by @xmath262 , which corresponds to @xmath263 for fixed @xmath90 .
( [ qh ] ) reveals , finally , that the hopf charge of all hedgehog configurations vanishes .
the dynamics of the hedgehog fields is governed by the soft - mode lagrangian ( [ l24d ] ) . since @xmath244 is an identical solution of the general field equation ( [ neq ] ) for @xmath100 , eq .
( [ l24d ] ) can be directly specialized to @xmath222 .
hence the integration over angles becomes trivial and the hedgehog action turns into@xmath264 = \int_{0}^{\infty } dr\mathcal{l}^{\left ( hh\right ) } \left ( r\right)\ ] ] where @xmath265 is a @xmath266-dependent radial lagrangian .
after substituting the ansatz ( [ hh ] ) into the full lagrangian ( [ l24d ] ) , dropping total derivatives , suppressing the superscript of @xmath267 and again denoting radial derivatives @xmath202 by a prime , one arrives at the explicit expression @xmath268 .\label{lrad}%\ ] ] all terms in @xmath265 are nonnegative .
this has the consequence that each of them must vanish individually at any absolute action minimum .
the complete set of hedgehog vacua is therefore @xmath269 and forms a subset of the translationally invariant center elements ( [ omck ] ) .
as anticipated , any finite - action solution of the form ( [ hh ] ) has to approach one of these constant minima when @xmath270 .
the constant solutions @xmath271 , on the other hand , are maxima of the action .
a representative of this type was already encountered in sec .
[ fn ] .
the radial equation for @xmath267 can be derived by inserting the ansatz ( [ hh ] ) into the general field equation ( [ omeq ] ) or , more directly , by varying the radial lagrangian ( [ lrad ] ) .
either way , the result is@xmath272 i.e. an ordinary nonlinear differential equation of fourth order and of fuchsian type .
the associated boundary value problem can be solved numerically with rather moderate computer resources .
the exploration of the full solution space is aided by two discrete symmetries of eq .
( [ eqrad ] ) which imply that any solution @xmath273 gives rise to the additional solutions @xmath274 and @xmath275 .
the former is a consequence of @xmath172 = \gamma\left [ u^{\dagger}\right ] $ ] while the latter simply reflects the periodicity in the angular variable @xmath90 .
not surprisingly , the field equation ( [ eqrad ] ) comprises the gribov equation @xcite .
it consists of the terms proportional to @xmath276 which originate from the nonlinear-@xmath70-model part of the lagrangian ( [ lrad ] ) and dominate when @xmath35 becomes the largest scale and/or when the higher derivatives become small .- independent terms of eq .
( [ eqrad ] ) are not negligible .
this makes stable soliton solutions possible . ]
the analogy between the nonlinear potential term @xmath277 and a one - dimensional pendulum in a gravitational field , with the logarithmic variable @xmath278 . ] often used to characterize the solution spectrum of the gribov equation , therefore applies to eq .
( [ eqrad ] ) as well .
the stable ( unstable ) equilibrium positions of the `` pendulum '' are @xmath279 ( @xmath280 ) , modulo a multiple of @xmath281 which represents additional full turns .
it will be shown in sec .
[ qspi ] that this analogy suffices to understand the qualitative behavior of all numerical solutions .
the @xmath131 parametrization ( [ uparam ] ) of the @xmath18 field implies that regular solutions @xmath267 of the radial hedgehog equation ( [ eqrad ] ) approach a multiple of @xmath281 at the origin .
their small-@xmath282 behavior can therefore be determined analytically , either by expanding the nonlinearity of eq .
( [ eqrad ] ) into powers of small deviations @xmath283 from the constant action minima @xmath284 or by expanding the @xmath282 dependence of the full solution into a frobenius series .
similarly , finite - action solutions can be obtained for @xmath270 by asymptotically expanding around the hedgehog vacua . inside their regions of validity , these expansions provide useful insights into the qualitative behavior of the hedgehog solutions as well as quantitative checks on the numerical solutions to be found in sec .
[ qspi ] .
we start by deriving the solutions of the linearized hedgehog equation and the corresponding power series expansion around the origin . inserting the ansatz @xmath285 into the radial saddle point equation ( [ eqrad ] ) and retaining only terms up to first order in @xmath286 , one arrives at the fourth - order linear differential equation @xmath287 which can be solved analytically by standard techniques .
the general solution is a superposition of four linearly independent base solutions @xmath288 , @xmath289 whose real , dimensionless coefficients @xmath290 remain undetermined and have to be specified by imposing initial or boundary conditions .
the base solutions @xmath291 are @xmath292 the requirements of regularity and uniqueness on the solutions at the origin dictate two of the boundary conditions . the first one , @xmath293 , implies @xmath294 and thus ensures uniqueness at @xmath223 while the second one , @xmath295 , is then imposed by the behavior of the base solutions ( [ pbas ] ) .
accordingly , the small-@xmath282 behavior of the general regular solution is restricted to @xmath296 where the constants @xmath297 are linear combinations of the @xmath298 whose values can e.g. be specified by providing initial data for @xmath299 and @xmath300 .
all higher - order coefficients of the expansion are then fixed .
alternatively , one can obtain the solutions of the full , nonlinear saddle point equation ( [ eqrad ] ) towards @xmath301 by analytical continuation into a frobenius series . a somewhat tedious calculation yields @xmath302 r^{7}+o\left ( r^{9}\right ) \label{sersoln}%\ ] ] where
the coefficients @xmath303 and @xmath304 are again left to be determined by initial conditions .
even - order derivatives of @xmath90 ( or equivalently the coefficients @xmath305 ) vanish at @xmath223 while those of odd order , @xmath306 , can be expressed in terms of @xmath303 and @xmath304 . a comparison between eqs .
( [ linsoln ] ) and ( [ sersoln ] ) shows that the solutions of the exact radial equation start to differ from those of the linearized equation at @xmath307 .
hence the series solution ( [ sersoln ] ) permits a more accurate check of the numerical solutions over a larger radial interval .
analogous expansions around the constant action minima @xmath308 exist asymptotically , i.e. towards @xmath270 , for all finite - action solutions .
infinite - action solutions of eq .
( [ eqrad ] ) , finally , can be linearized around the constant solutions @xmath309 which they approach at one or both ends of the radial domain .
the resulting equation for @xmath286 differs from eq .
( [ lineq ] ) only in the sign of the @xmath286 term .
its solutions are linear combinations of generalized hypergeometric functions .
we now turn to the numerical solution of the hedgehog saddle point equation ( [ eqrad ] ) . due to the periodicity in @xmath90 , the considered range of boundary values
can be limited without loss of generality to @xmath310 0,2\pi\right ] $ ] .
regularity at the origin then further specifies @xmath311 and imposes @xmath312 ( see sec .
[ anhh ] ) .
the value of the topological charge @xmath8 fixes a third boundary condition , @xmath313 owing to eq .
( [ hq ] ) . hence all regular hedgehog solutions in a given @xmath8-sector can be found by just varying the value of a fourth boundary condition . in the following ,
we use the initial slope @xmath314 for this purpose . at the end of the section
, we will also find irregular solutions with @xmath315 .
we begin our exploration of the hedgehog solution space by searching for the regular finite - action solutions of eq .
( [ eqrad ] ) which , as established in sec .
[ top ] , carry integer values of @xmath8 .
the numerical analysis shows ( and the pendulum analogy in sec .
[ shs ] will explain ) that only one solution of this type exists in each @xmath8 sector .
in the simplest case , @xmath179 , this is just the translationally invariant vacuum solution @xmath316 . for @xmath317
we find the prototypical nontrivial hedgehog solution , depicted in fig .
2 . in order to clarify its physical interpretation , we note that it shares the @xmath245 homotopy classification , encoded in the topological charge @xmath318 $ ] of the relative gauge orientation @xmath319 , with the yang - mills instanton @xcite .
of course , both also share the saddle point property , as the instanton minimizes the classical euclidean yang - mills action in the @xmath317 sector . in order to trace their association
further , we inspect the relative gauge orientation @xmath320 of a yang - mills instanton with size @xmath321 .
it is of hedgehog form as well , and its @xmath166-dependence in ( euclidean ) temporal gauge is known to be @xcite @xmath322 in the parametrization ( [ hh ] ) . for a direct comparison with our @xmath317 solution , we have included @xmath323 with @xmath324 as the dashed curve in fig .
2 ( and adapted it to our periodicity interval convention by adding @xmath281 ) .
the radial dependence of both can be seen to be surprisingly similar .
this implies that the dominant contributions from all @xmath317 gauge field orbits to the vacuum overlap have a relative gauge orientation close to that of the yang - mills instanton and indicates that the @xmath317 hedgehog solution primarily summarizes contributions from the instanton orbit .
( of course , one would not expect exact agreement since our solutions contain scale - symmetry breaking quantum corrections and contributions from other @xmath317 gauge fields as well . ) accordingly , and generalizing the above findings to multi - instanton solutions , we will refer to the unique regular finite - action solution of eq .
( [ eqrad ] ) with integer @xmath8 as the `` @xmath8-instanton class '' .
our hedgehog saddle point equation ( [ eqrad ] ) and its instanton class solutions derive from the gradient - expanded soft - mode lagrangian ( [ efflagr ] ) .
it is instructive to compare this approach with a variational estimate of one - instanton contributions to the bare action ( [ gammab ] ) in ref .
@xcite . by approximately minimizing the bare action with one - parameter families of trial functions similar to the instanton profile ( [ omin ] ) and using qualitative scaling properties
, it was argued in ref .
@xcite that radiative corrections can stabilize the instanton size .
our exact saddle point solutions make the dynamical size stabilization manifest . we have already traced the underlying mechanism to the virial theorem ( [ vth ] ) which is independent of most specific features of the soft - mode dynamics and thus overcomes the chronic infrared instability of dilute instanton gases @xcite in a rather generic way .
for @xmath325 gev , the size @xmath326 and the average instanton size might be related to an effective ir fixed point of the type considered in ref .
] of the 1-instanton class solution agrees inside errors with the results of instanton liquid model @xcite and lattice @xcite simulations .
it also assures that the two leading terms of the gradient expansion ( [ gexp ] ) yield a sufficiently accurate approximation to the instanton action ( cf .
the comments below eq .
( [ sfterm ] ) ) .
our 1-instanton class profile function @xmath327 is rather similar to the one found by approximately minimizing the bare action ( [ gammab ] ) variationally @xcite .
this indicates that the bulk of the instanton s physics and size distribution is generated by soft modes , as one would intuitively expect .
our approach therefore provides a well - adapted and efficient framework for the treatment of these and other vacuum fields .
in contrast to variational approaches , furthermore , it allows to systematically find _ all _ saddle points exactly ( including those which are not of hedgehog form ) . already in the hedgehog sector , for example , we will find solutions with more complex and unprecedented shapes than eq .
( [ omin ] ) .
since there is little guidance for the choice of suitable trial functions in these and other cases , such solutions would be difficult to find variationally . according to eq .
( [ q - hh ] ) , all monotonic hedgehog solutions with @xmath168 ( @xmath169 ) have negative ( positive ) slopes @xmath328 at the origin . the anti - instanton class with @xmath329 , in particular
, results from changing the sign of the instanton boundary value , @xmath330 , and can be obtained without further calculation : it simply results from the combined action of the two symmetry transformations @xmath331 and @xmath332 on the instanton class solution . hence the @xmath255 instanton classes have degenerate action values , precisely as their yang - mills counterparts .
multi - instanton class solutions are characterized by an integer topological charge @xmath333 .
the modulus @xmath334 of their ( negative ) initial slope grows monotonically with @xmath8 , i.e. @xmath335 as in the 1-instanton case , the action - degenerate multi - antiinstanton classes with @xmath336 can be constructed by flipping the sign of the corresponding multi - instanton classes and adding @xmath337 .
the initial slopes of the multi-(anti)instanton solutions are therefore related by @xmath338 the @xmath339 hedgehog solutions correspond to special arrangements of the underlying yang - mills multi-(anti)instantons .
in fact , the relative gauge orientation @xmath319 of a multi - instanton configuration is of hedgehog type only if all individual ( anti)instantons are centered at the origin .
this raises the question whether @xmath340 yang - mills instanton solutions with separated individual positions are at least approximately represented by other solutions of the saddle point equations ( [ omeq ] ) and ( [ neq ] ) .
experience from skyrme - type models , whose analogous @xmath339 skyrmion solutions are well approximated by rational @xcite or harmonic @xcite maps , might suggest that similar types of non - hedgehog field configurations approximate higher-@xmath8 solutions of eqs .
( [ omeq ] ) and ( [ neq ] ) as well .
the action of the 1-instanton class solution is large ( @xmath341 at@xmath342 gev ) , in analogy with the large action of typical yang - mills instantons , and its direct impact on the saddle point expansion is therefore small . ) and hence does not solve the bogomolnyi - type equation ( [ beq ] ) .
this is in constrast to the yang - mills instanton which is the absolute minimum of the euclidean yang - mills action in the @xmath317 sector and therefore self - dual .
] moreover , the action bound ( [ bb ] ) implies that higher-@xmath8 instanton classes should be irrelevant for most amplitudes , with potentially important exceptions as mentioned in sec .
[ bogbnd ] .
instanton `` liquid '' vacuum models ( ilms ) @xcite are built on the same premise and suggest that physically far more relevant contributions originate instead from ensembles of instantons and anti - instantons with equal average densities .
it would be important to determine whether contributions of this sort are approximately represented by nontrivial @xmath179 solutions of eqs .
( [ omeq ] ) and ( [ neq ] ) as well . in any case , our above results imply that they can not be of hedgehog type .
we now extend our search to hedgehog solutions with infinite action .
although their relevance for the saddle point expansion is not obvious , one might speculate that their infinite - action suppression could be overcome by some additional mechanism ( see below ) .
our chief motivation for discussing them here , however , derives from their association with the infinite - action meron solutions @xcite of the classical ( euclidean ) yang - mills equation .
hedgehog solutions with infinite action are far more the rule than the exception . in fact , all regular ( @xmath311 ) solutions of eq .
( [ eqrad ] ) with initial slopes @xmath343 inbetween the discrete set of instanton - class values @xmath344 have infinite action since they approach one of the constant fields @xmath345 towards spacial infinity .
the latter carry a nonzero action density ( cf .
( [ lrad ] ) ) and furthermore imply that the corresponding , asymptotic @xmath18 fields @xmath346 remain angle - dependent . exactly the same behavior characterizes the relative gauge orientations @xmath319 of yang - mills merons in temporal gauge , which are of hedgehog form as well .
furthermore , eq . ( [ phihhinf ] ) shows that solutions with @xmath347 carry half - integer topological charge @xmath8 , again as the yang - mills merons . in analogy with the instanton - class solutions of the previous section
, we will therefore call these solutions `` @xmath348-meron classes '' . the profile function @xmath349 of a typical 1-meron class solution with @xmath350 is drawn in fig .
a direct comparison with the corresponding profile of the yang - mills meron in temporal gauge , @xmath351 ( where @xmath0 is the step function ) , is complicated by the fact that the classical meron is pointlike while our solutions incorporate quantum effects which break dilatation symmetry and stabilize their size at a finite value .
such effects are expected to smoothen the singularity of the yang - mills meron , too , and probably cause our solution @xmath349 to become non - monotonic by overshooting in the transition region .
we therefore draw the yang - mills meron profile in fig .
3 ( dashed curve ) with the finite size @xmath352 of the instanton class solutions ( and adapt it to our periodicity interval convention ) .
our nomenclature for multi - meron classes with @xmath353 includes only solutions with half - integer topological charge because solutions with even `` meron number '' and correspondingly integer @xmath8 coincide with the @xmath8-instanton classes .
this is expected since the relative gauge orientation @xmath354 of the underlying yang - mills multi - merons is of hedgehog type only if all individual merons sit on top of each other .
such configurations , when carrying integer overall values of @xmath8 , coalesce into the corresponding yang - mills instantons and those are represented by the @xmath8-instanton class solutions in our framework .
the behavior of the multi - meron class solutions with @xmath355 is qualitatively rather similar to that of the 1-meron class , although size and strength scales may differ substantially . as an example , fig .
4 shows a typical 3-meron class solution .
an important general property of all solutions with half - integer @xmath8 is that they come in families of continuously varying sizes .
as already alluded to , this is because their size depends on a second mass scale @xmath356 ( in addition to @xmath35 ) and because solutions for all values of @xmath357 in the finite intervals@xmath358 ( where @xmath359 , i.e. @xmath360 , and @xmath361 are implied ) can be found . as in the instanton sector
, multi - anti - meron classes with negative @xmath8 are obtained from the positive-@xmath8 solutions by changing their sign and adding @xmath337 .
the variable mass scale @xmath357 in the meron sectors implies that there are infinitely more meron than instanton class solutions .
this makes it tempting to speculate that the meron `` entropy '' contributions to the weight function of functional integrals over @xmath18 might be able to overcome the infinite - action suppression .
if so , it would shed new light on the physical interpretation not only of our solutions but also of the yang - mills merons themselves , whose potential role remains controversial .
furthermore , it would suggest a modified saddle point expansion in which action and entropy are minimized jointly .
these issues deserve further investigation . above
we have classified all regular hedgehog solutions , i.e. those which satisfy the initial condition @xmath311 .
we are now going to examine the remaining solution classes of the radial field equation ( [ eqrad ] ) .
its members share the alternative initial condition @xmath315 , may display a rather complex spacial structure and are characterized by a monopole - type singularity at the origin , i.e. they solve eq .
( [ eqrad ] ) everywhere except at @xmath206 . in order to understand the qualitative behavior of both regular and irregular hedgehog solution classes from a common perspective , it is useful to elaborate on the analogy between the hedgehog equation ( [ eqrad ] ) and the pendulum equation which was mentioned in sec .
[ hhtype ] . according to this analogy
, the instanton classes correspond to exactly @xmath8 full turns of the pendulum , where the sign of @xmath8 indicates the direction of the rotation .
the pendulum mass starts in the unstable equilibrium position at time @xmath362 with just enough initial speed @xmath363 to finally end up there again for @xmath364 .
this analogy implies , in particular , that there is exactly one regular hedgehog solution for each integer @xmath8 and that the constant @xmath365 is the only regular solution with @xmath179 .
the meron class solutions start from the unstable equilibrium position as well .
however , their initial velocity @xmath343 is insufficient for completing all turns in full .
the last turn remains uncompleted , i.e. the pendulum swings back , oscillates around and finally settles into the stable equilibrium position .
hence all meron class solutions have half - integer @xmath8 and are non - monotonic . for the irregular solutions , on the other hand , the pendulum starts at the stable equilibrium position @xmath279 .
when not provided with sufficient initial speed @xmath343 to complete a full turn , it just performs damped oscillations around @xmath279 .
the corresponding solution has @xmath179 and is depicted in fig .
5 . when @xmath366 is sufficiently large , however , the pendulum can perform @xmath8 full turns before settling into the stable equilibrium position . as a consequence , all these solutions have integer @xmath190 and infinite action ( cf . eq .
( [ lrad ] ) ) .
pursuing the analogy further , one would also expect irregular solutions which have an initial value @xmath299 exactly as needed to end up at the unstable equilibrium position when @xmath270 ( after possibly completing a number of full turns ) .
such configurations would carry a half - integer topologically charge @xmath8 and a finite action .
for obvious reasons they turn out to be highly sensitive to variations of the initial condition , however , and therefore difficult to establish numerically .
in contrast to the instanton and meron classes , the singular hedgehog solutions do not seem to have obvious analogs among the solutions of the classical yang - mills equation .
as opposed to the instanton ( meron ) classes , furthermore , the irregular integer-@xmath8 ( half - integer-@xmath8 ) solutions have infinite ( finite ) action .
this allows for nontrivial hedgehog solutions with @xmath179 , which are necessarily irregular at the origin .
the physical interpretation of all irregular hedgehog solutions and their relevance for the saddle point expansion remain to be clarified .
the main results of this paper are a practicable saddle point expansion for the yang - mills vacuum overlap amplitude in terms of gauge invariant , local matrix fields and the identification of new gluonic ir degrees of freedom in this framework . after adopting a gauge - projected gaussian approximation to the vacuum wave functional ,
the ir degrees of freedom can be obtained explicitly as the saddle points of a soft - mode action which gather contributions from dominant gluon field families to soft yang - mills amplitudes and thus represent collective properties of the yang - mills dynamics .
since their gauge invariant definition makes no reference to specific amplitudes , furthermore , the ir degrees of freedom are universal .
they provide both new structural insights into the organization of the low - energy yang - mills dynamics and the principal input for a systematic saddle point expansion of soft amplitudes .
our survey of the saddle point solution space uncovered a diverse spectrum of ir degrees of freedom which carry several topological charges with associated bogomolnyi - type action bounds and obey a virial theorem which guarantees their scale stability .
solutions with a relatively high degree of symmetry were obtained either analytically or with modest numerical effort . since solutions of this type
are generally characterized by small action values and hence play a dominant role in the saddle point expansion , we have investigated their properties in some detail . besides translationally invariant vacua and analytical solutions with a fixed relative gauge orientation
, we have found topological solitons of hedgehog , ( vortex ) link and knot types .
some of the ir degrees of freedom have a transparent physical interpretation directly in terms of the underlying gluon fields .
the contributions from the gauge orbits of yang - mills instanton and merons , in particular , are gathered by saddle point fields of hedgehog type which share their ( integer or half - integer ) topological charge and represent vacuum tunneling processes in the hamiltonian formulation of non - abelian gauge theory .
although our saddle point solutions contain quantum effects and potentially relevant contributions from other gauge fields , those in the instanton class turn out to reproduce the relative gauge orientation between the in- and out - vacua of the yang - mills instanton rather closely .
the finite extent of our meron solution classes , on the other hand , is generated by quantum effects which smoothen the singularities of the classical , pointlike yang - mills merons .
nevertheless , our meron classes turn out to share the infinite action of their yang - mills counterparts . among all those ir fields which carry one unit of topological ( instanton ) charge , the single ( anti- ) instanton classes
are expected to attain the minimal action value . as a consequence of the action bound
, they should therefore dominate the saddle point expansion in all topological charge sectors .
similar configurations emerged in a variational treatment along with qualitative arguments in favor of their size stabilization . in our approach , this stabilization is manifest in the exact instanton class solutions themselves .
in fact , their size turns out to be fixed at about twice the inverse ir gluon mass scale and agrees inside errors with instanton liquid model and lattice results . the underlying virial theorem and the soft gluon mass generation therefore provide new insight into the mechanism by which the chronic infrared diseases of dilute yang - mills instanton gases are overcome .
the sizes of the meron class solutions with half - integer topological charge turn out to be of a more complex origin . besides the dynamical gluon mass they depend on a second , variable mass scale which is encoded in a boundary condition .
hence meron classes exist within large and continuous size ranges and consequently form a far more extensive solution family than the instanton classes .
this opens up the hypothetical possibility for their entropy to overcome their infinite action suppression in functional integrals .
such a mechanism would not only help to clarify the physical impact of our solutions but also shed new light on the still controversial role of the yang - mills merons themselves .
in addition to the instanton and meron classes , finally , there exists a third class of hedgehog solutions which contains a monopole - type singularity at the origin .
these irregular solutions can carry half - integer and integer ( including zero ) topological charges as well , and generally have infinite action .
hence their potential physical relevance seems to depend on the existence of additional mechanisms which could both smoothen their singularity and overcome their infinite - action suppression .
several other remarkable families of ir degrees of freedom turn out to be represented by topological solitons of faddeev - niemi type , i.e. by ( potentially twisted ) links and knots .
in fact , our saddle point dynamics contains a specific generalization of the faddeev - niemi lagrangian and shows explicitly how it is embedded in the gaussian approximation to the yang - mills vacuum wave functional .
this puts faddeev - niemi theory into a new perspective , as the effective dynamics of dominant sets of gauge field orbits with a collective hopf charge , and provides the underlying unit - vector field with a manifestly gauge invariant meaning .
the latter would well accord with the tentative interpretation of knot solutions as glueballs by faddeev , niemi and coworkers .
this and other interpretations could be tested in our framework by directly evaluating the impact of the knot saddle points on suitable amplitudes , e.g. on glueball correlation functions . more generally , the saddle point expansion allows the systematic calculation of contributions from all relevant ir degrees of freedom to functional integrals which represent soft yang - mills amplitudes .
first calculations of this type , focusing on fundamental vacuum properties including gluon condensates and the topological susceptibility , are underway .
in addition , our approach makes it possible to analyze the gauge field content of any ir variable individually by applying standard functional techniques to the integrals over gluon fields with which they are associated .
investigations of this sort would not only provide further structural insight into specific ir degrees of freedom and their physical role but may also shed new light on the dynamical mechanisms by which soft gauge fields organize themselves into collective degrees of freedom .
the diverse topological properties of the ir variables demonstrate that the gauge - projected gaussian wave functional not only captures the homotopy structure of the gauge group but also implements `` derivative '' topologies which further characterize the saddle point families .
due to the typical robustness of such topological properties , the related results are expected to remain at least qualitatively valid beyond the gaussian approximation . moreover , the saddle point expansion engenders the means to test this expectation quantitatively , by mapping out limitations of the underlying vacuum wave functional in comparison with lattice data .
extensions of our framework to suitable supersymmetric gauge theories would even permit analytical tests of this sort , e.g. by tracing vestiges of the monopole - based confinement mechanism in the vacuum functional .
the insights gained from such investigations may also provide specific guidance for the development of improved collective - mode actions and consequently generate systematic corrections to the ir variables .
our ir saddle point expansion can be extended in several directions .
a first important task would be a more exhaustive survey of the saddle - point solution space which should encompass potentially relevant approximate solutions .
the extension to qcd proper requires the generalization to the gauge group @xmath367 and the implementation of quarks into the gaussian wave functional , both of which pose no conceptual problems .
most topological properties , in particular , reside in the trivially embedded @xmath368 subgroup of the full color group and will remain unchanged .
a sufficiently complete treatment of the quark - gluon interactions and their impact on the effective action , however , appears to be more challenging .
our approach opens up a variety of directions for future research .
besides those already mentioned , it would for example be interesting to explore relations between the gauge - invariant ir degrees of freedom and gauge - dependent gluonic structures ( monopoles , vortices , branes etc . ) and amplitudes ( e.g. the 2-dimensional nonlocal gluon condensate and green functions ) which appear in gauge - fixed formulations .
another useful endeavor would be the calculation of those higher - dimensional vacuum condensates which provide the principal input for the operator product expansion of glueball correlators .
duality sum rules could then link the contributions from different ir degrees of freedom with the low - lying glueball spectrum @xcite , e.g. as a precursor and complement to a direct saddle - point evaluation of glueball correlation functions . financial support by the conselho nacional de desenvolvimento cientfico e tecnolgico ( cnpq ) of brazil as well as the hospitality and a visiting scientist grant of the ect * in trento ( italy ) are gratefully acknowledged . 1 . an example of the @xmath369 solution class . as in all following figures , we display the solution at @xmath370 gev .
other values of @xmath35 can immediately be accommodated by scaling the @xmath282-axis .
our conventions for the periodicity interval of @xmath90 restrict its initial value to @xmath371 0,2\pi\right ] $ ] .
2 . the canonical 1-instanton class solution with @xmath317 .
3 . a typical meron - class solution with @xmath350 .
4 . a 3-meron class solution with @xmath372 . 5 .
an example for a nontrivial @xmath179 hedgehog solution with monopole - type behavior at the origin .
t. schaefer and e.v .
shuryak , rev .
phys . * 70 * , 323 ( 1998 ) ; d.i .
diakonov , prog .
. phys . * 51 * , * * 173 ( 2003 ) . for an elementary introduction to instantons
see h. forkel , _ a primer on instantons in qcd _ , hep - ph/0009136 .
v. de alfaro , s. fubini and g. furlan , phys .
* b 65 * , 163 ( 1976 ) ; phys . lett .
* b 72 * , 203 ( 1977 ) ; c.g .
callan , r.g .
dashen and d.j .
gross , phys .
66b * , 375 ( 1977 ) ; phys .
d * 17 * , 2717 ( 1978 ) ; * 19 * , 1826 ( 1979 ) ; f. lenz , j.w .
negele and m. thies , phys .
d * 69 * , 074009 ( 2004 ) ; hep - lat/0409083 .
j. hoek , m. teper and j. waterhouse , nucl . phys .
* b 288 * , 589 ( 1987 ) ; a. hasenfratz , t. degrand , and d. zhu , nucl . phys .
* b 478 * , 349 ( 1996 ) ; p. de
forcrand , m.g .
perez , i .- o . stamatescu , nucl .
. suppl . * 53 * , 557 ( 1997 ) .
chernodub , m.i .
polikarpov , lectures given at nato advanced study institute on confinement , duality and nonperturbative aspects of qcd , cambridge , england , 23 jun - 4 jul 1997 , arxiv : hep - th/9710205 ; g. bali , talk given at 3rd international conference on quark confinement and the hadron spectrum ( confinement iii ) , newport news , va , jun 1998 , hep - ph/9809351 ; r. haymaker , phys .
rep . * 315 * , 153 ( 1999 ) .
see , for example , e .-
ilgenfritz , m.l .
laursen , g. schierholz , m. mller - preussker , h. schiller , nucl .
* b 268 * , 693 ( 1986 ) ;
chu , j.m .
grandy , s. huang and j. negele , phys .
d * 49 * , 6039 ( 1993 ) ; p.
de forcrand , m. g. perez , i .- o .
stamatescu , nucl . phys .
* b 499 * , 409 ( 1997 ) ; d.a .
smith and m.j .
teper , phys .
d * 58 * , 014505 ( 1998 ) ; a. hasenfratz and c. nieter , nucl .
* 73 * , 503 ( 1999 ) ; a. ringwald and f. schrempp , phys .
b * 459 * , 249 ( 1999 ) ; e .-
ilgenfritz et al , nucl .
119 * , 754 ( 2003 ) ; c. gattringer et al . , nucl .
* 129 * , 653 ( 2004 ) , f. bruckmann et al .
, contribution to lattice 2004 , batavia , illinois ( 2004 ) , hep - lat/0408036 .
g. t hooft , in high energy physics , edited by a. zichichi , editrice compositori , bologna , ( 1976 ) ; s. mandelstam , phys .
reports * * 23**c , 245 ( 1976 ) ; g. t hooft , nucl . phys . * b190 * , 455 ( 1981 ) ; a. kronfeld , g. schierholz and u. j. wiese , nucl . phys . *
b293 * , 461 ( 1987 ) ; g. ripka , lecture notes in physics 639 , springer , berlin ( 2004 ) .
makeenko and a.a .
migdal , nucl .
b188 * , 269 ( 1981 ) ; a.a .
migdal , phys .
rep . * 102 * , 199 ( 1983 ) ; a. dubin and yu .
makeenko , in _ at the frontier of particle physics _ ,
vol . 4 , p. 2479 ed . m. shifman , world scientific , singapore ( 2002 ) .
r. jackiw , in `` _ _ field theory and particle physics _ _ '' , proceedings of the 5th jorge andre swieca summer school , campos do jordao , brazil , eds .
eboli , m. gomes , a. santoro , world scientific , singapore 1990 , p. 731 .
a.m. polyakov , phys .
b * 72 * , 477 ( 1978 ) ; l. susskind , phys . rev .
d * 20 * , 2610 ( 1979 ) ; b. svetitsky , phys . rep .
132 , 1 ( 1986 ) , m. lscher , r. narayanan , p. weisz and u. wolff , nucl .
* b 384 * , 168 ( 1992 ) .
see e.g. proceedings of the intl .
variational calculations in quantum field theory _ ,
wangerooge , germany , eds .
l. polley and d.e.l .
pottinger , world scientific , singapore ( 1988 ) .
see also j.o .
akeyo , h.f .
jones and c.s .
parker , phys .
d * 51 * , 1298 ( 1995 ) for a correspondig lattice ansatz of the trial action .
wilson and j.b .
kogut , phys . rep .
* 12 * , 75 ( 1974 ) ; for a textbook exposition see m. e. peskin and d.v .
schroeder , _ an introduction to quantum field theory _ , addison - wesley , reading , ma , usa ( 1995 ) .
faddeev , _ quantization of solitons _
, institute for advanced study preprint ias-75-qs70 ; in _ einstein and several contemporary tendencies in the field theory of elementary particles , relativity , quanta and cosmology _ , vol .
m. pantaleo and f. de finis ) , 185 ( johnson reprint , 1979 ) .
c. michael and p.s .
spencer , phys .
d * 52 * , 4691 ( 1995 ) ; t. degrand , a. hasenfratz and t.g .
kovacs , nucl .
* b 505 * , 417 ( 1997 ) ; ph .
de forcrand , m. garcia perez and i .- o .
stamatescu , nucl . phys .
* b 499 * , 409 ( 1997 ) ; m.j .
teper , phys .
d * 58 * , 014505 ( 1998 ) . | we set up a new calculational framework for the yang - mills vacuum transition amplitude in the schrdinger representation . after integrating out hard - mode contributions perturbatively ,
we perform a gauge invariant gradient expansion of the ensuing soft mode action which renders a subsequent saddle point expansion for the vacuum overlap manageable .
the standard `` squeezed '' approximation for the vacuum wave functional then allows for an essentially analytical treatment of physical amplitudes .
moreover , it leads to the identification of dominant and gauge invariant classes of gauge field orbits which play the role of gluonic infrared ( ir ) degrees of freedom . those emerge as a rich variety of ( mostly solitonic ) solutions to the saddle point equations which are characterized by a common relative gauge orientation of the underlying gluon fields .
we discuss their scale stability , guaranteed by a virial theorem , and other general properties including topological quantum numbers and action bounds .
we then find important saddle point solutions explicitly and examine their physical impact .
some of them are related to tunneling solutions of the classical yang - mills equation , i.e. to instantons and merons , while others appear to play unprecedented roles .
a remarkable new class of ir degrees of freedom comprises vortex and knot solutions of faddeev - niemi type , potentially related to glueballs . |
to study dynamics of super yang - mills theory , a lattice formulation is an attractive tool .
there are some approaches , however limited , not exact , realization has done @xcite .
why do we stress the exact symmetry ?
it is because the point of our approach , the scenario is that the exact fermionic symmetry on lattice with keeping @xmath0 symmetry in the continuum limit , then it s just susy if it is not brs symmetry .
so , the first step of our trial is to construct exact fermionic , not brs - like symmetry on lattice .
we present new lattice models with an exact fermionic symmetry .
we start with considering in the system with minimal degrees of freedom , realized as one - cell model , derive the fermionic transformation , which is expected to contain the continuum supersymmetry .
then it is extended to the entire lattice in a non - trivial way , it is multi - cell model . we perform it by introducing the particular lattice structure with a special pattern called ` ichimatsu ' pattern in japanese . also using that pattern , we give another model , which we call pipe model . finally , we reach cell and pipe mixed model .
first , we consider a fundamental lattice .
let us refer it as a cell .
the action consists of gauge and fermion part : @xmath1 @xmath2 the gauge action @xmath3 is the plaquette action , here @xmath4 is the gauge coupling constant . for the fermion part
, we put real staggered fermion on each site .
the fermion action @xmath5 consists of terms which corresponds to fermions located at neighbouring sites connected by link variables .
the coefficient @xmath6 is a sign factor for the staggered fermion .
we introduce a fermionic transformation for which mixes the fermion and the link variables .
we assume the form to realize the ordinary susy transformation in a continuum limit .
let us call our transformation as pre - susy transformation .
the susy transformation of a fermion is to give the field strength , @xmath7 , hence , our ansatz of the fermion transformation is given as @xmath8 where @xmath9 is a grassmann - odd parameter .
we chose the transformation of the link variables in order the operator from fermion action under the fermion transformation , to balance the one which produced from the change of the gauge action .
@xmath10 where @xmath11 is a grassmann - odd parameter .
now we are going to check the action invariance under pre - susy transformation .
the variation of the action under the pre - susy contains terms cubic and linear in the fermion variables . for the action to be invariant
, these two sets of terms should vanish separately : @xmath12
corresponding to these conditions , we obtain two types of relations between introduced parameter : @xmath13 @xmath14 we can check out exact symmetry in this one - cell model . solving these relations , we find there are @xmath15 independent parameters for each site .
then , we consider our model with pre - susy in an entire lattice space . since naive extension only produces @xmath16 symmetry , to be discussed later , here we take a sophisticated way .
we put a restriction on the plaquette variables . in the simplest 2-dimensional space ,
the allowed plaquette variables form ` ichimatsu ' pattern as fig .
[ 2d - ichimatsu ] .
contrary to the ordinary lattice theory , not all the possible plaquette variables are included in this extension .
all the fermion and link variables are included , while only the plaquette variables are restricted .
even in arbitrary space dimension , we can do this multi - cell extension in the way that there presents the same pattern on any two - dimensional surfaces . by taking same steps in the one - cell case
, one can find that the action invariance under pre - susy transformation in multi - cell included model with the ichimatsu pattern .
however , it is easy to suppose that in the cell model , the perturbative picture is not present , since the interaction between cells is introduced through the fermion variables , which belong to two neighbouring cells .
( details are reported in our previous paper @xcite . ) by the way , here we construct another model , by exchanging the allowed and discarded plaquette variables , since there are two ways to put the ichimatsu pattern on a two - dimensional surface .
now let us call this alternative model , pipe model , from its structure in 3-dim . case .
the pipe model is present for any dimension , ( anyhow this distinction is meaningless in 2-dim . )
its plaquette variables are arranged in the complimentary to the cell model .
it may say that we decomposed ordinary lattice space using the ichimatsu pattern .
+ this model differs from the cell model only in the gauge sector .
however , repeating the same procedure as the cell model , we find the presence of the pre - susy in the pipe model .
we do not encounter the difficulty in the cell model even when we remove the fermion variables .
however , we may show that the pipe model without fermion variables do not have an appropriate continuum limit ( can be shown equivalent to trivial model statistical mechanically ) .
so far , we consider these two models separately .
now we are going to consider its mixed model to overcome the difficulties . in defining the mixed model ,
we assign different coupling constants to two sets of plaquette variables in the gauge action , @xmath17 is for those of the cell model and @xmath18 is for the pipe model .
@xmath19 + s_{g}^{pipe}[\beta_p]\ ] ] while in the pre - susy transformation , the fermion transformation that produces the plaquette variables is influenced to be producing two sets of plaquette variables : @xmath20 where @xmath21 ( @xmath22 ) means plaquette variables of the cell ( pipe ) model .
although it is not so obvious whether we may keep the fermionic symmetry or not , we can find exact fermionic symmetry even in the mixed model .
we note two important features here .
first , the mixed model may be treated properly even in a perturbative way , since there included all the plaquette variable same as in the ordinary lattice .
second , when we introduced our pre - susy transformation , we assumed the form of the fermion transformation to be related to the continuum susy .
considering the naive continuum limit of eq .
( [ equ : dxi ] ) , we find it becomes @xmath23 where @xmath24 are grassmann - odd parameters related to the parameter @xmath25 .
it is proportional to the field strength , but is also proportional to the difference of the two coupling constants @xmath17 and @xmath18 .
this shows two couplings , @xmath17 and @xmath18 must differ to have proper continuum limit , is the reason for the transformation will be higher order and vanish in the limit in the ordinary lattice model .
if the fermionic symmetry is really related to the expected susy , the continuum limit is to be studied with the cell and pipe mixed model .
first result of pure gauge system with the ichimatsu structure is reported in @xcite .
we presented new lattice models with an exact fermionic symmetry , as a step towards the super yang - mills theory on lattice . in the last cell and pipe mixed model
, we find the crucial condition towards the continuum susy and the ichimatsu pattern plays an important role in our models .
we may confirm that our models satisfy reasonable requirements for a proper lattice theory , such as translational and rotational invariance and the reflection positivity , also by the property of the ichimatsu pattern .
we also work on the realization of the staggered majorana fermion , however the complete realization of spinor structure still remains as an unsolved question .
now , the recovery of the spinor structure and the doubling problem are crucially important and most difficult .
some discussions will be given in our forthcoming paper @xcite .
9 g. curci and g. veneziano , nucl .
b292 ( 1987 ) 555 .
d. b. kaplan and martin schmaltz , chin .
38 ( 2000 ) 543
. k. itoh , m. kato , h. sawanaka , h. so and n. ukita , prog .
( 2002 ) 363 .
k. itoh , m. kato , m. murata , h. sawanaka and h. so , _ vacuum structure of the ichimatsu - decomposed lattice models _ , these proceedings .
k. itoh , m. kato , h. sawanaka , h. so and n. ukita , in preparation . | we present the lattice models with exact fermionic symmetries relating fermions and link variables .
the plaquettes are distributed in an ichimatsu pattern ( chequered ) .
we explain this peculiar structure allows us to have a translation in the algebra of the fermionic symmetries . |
measurement of the surface impedance @xmath8 in high-@xmath9 superconductors ( hts ) in the microwave frequency range is one of the most effective and frequently used methods to study electron properties and mechanisms of superconductivity in these materials .
such measurements , performed on high quality hts single crystals or perfect single - crystalline films , allow to obtain in a straightforward way the temperature and frequency dependencies of the complex ac conductivity of the materials @xmath10 in the microwave frequency range , that in turn yield a complimentary information on microscopic electron properties of hts , such as low - energy quasiparticle excitations from the superfluid condensate , their scattering rate and density of states , the symmetry of cooper pairing , etc .
numerous experimental and theoretical studies of the microwave response carried out during the last decade have revealed a lot of interesting features of the superconducting state in hts metal - oxide compounds and partly shed a light on the nature of superconductivity in these materials ( e.g. , _
d_wave type of cooper pairing).@xcite however , up to date there is no comprehensive understanding of microwave response in hts . in particular
, this concerns the temperature dependence of surface resistance @xmath11 in highly perfect single crystals and epitaxial films , where nonmonotonous character of this dependence with a wide peak below @xmath9 was observed by many investigators .
unfortunately , there are still some difficulties in its understanding and explanation in the framework of existing theoretical models.@xcite in the present work we demonstrate for the first time that the nonmonotonous character of @xmath4 in epitaxially - grown single - crystalline ybco films can be even more complicated than it was suggested before : in our experiments @xmath4 curves have two distinct rather narrow peaks at quite different temperatures @xmath12 ( @xmath13 = 2530 k , @xmath14 k ) .
this observation clearly indicates that the microscopic scenario of electron properties in hts ( ybco ) is more intriguing and sophisticated than it was assumed before .
the temperature dependence of microwave surface resistance , @xmath4 , in ybco perfect single crystals@xcite and epitaxially grown single - crystalline thin films@xcite observed in a number of experiments performed by different groups , turned out to be nonmonotonous and revealed a pronounced broad peak at @xmath15 .
the temperature position and height of the peak depend on frequency and crystal quality .
it was shown also that the peculiarity of @xmath4 is very sensitive to the crystal defect density .
for instance , impurities ( point defects ) suppress the peak of @xmath4.@xcite analysis of these experimental data , based on the phenomenological approach assuming the drude form of microwave conductivity for thermally excited quasiparticles @xmath16 ^{-1}$],@xcite sheds a light on the nature of observed @xmath17 peaks and explains also ( at least qualitatively ) its frequency dependence and suppression of the peak by impurities.@xcite this approach allows also to extract the value of quasiparticle relaxation time @xmath18 directly from microwave measurements of @xmath4 .
the @xmath18 value in perfect single crystals appears to be strongly increasing with the temperature lowering and reaching the saturation value of order @xmath19@xmath20 s at low temperatures ( below 20 k).@xcite in the present work the @xmath21 dependencies are studied experimentally and theoretically for the most perfect ybco films in order to establish relation between the microwave response and the defect nanostructure .
the first observation of two - peak behavior of the @xmath11 as well as @xmath22 dependencies is presented and a relevant theoretical model is developed .
two - peak temperature dependencies of microwave surface resistance , @xmath4 , have been observed for the first time in _ c_oriented perfect ybco thin films of various thickness ( @xmath23 150480 nm ) deposited by off - axis dc magnetron sputtering onto ceo@xmath1-buffered r - cut single - crystalline sapphire substrates of 14 @xmath24 14 mm@xmath25 size .
microwave measurements were performed with a use of cylindrical pure copper cavities 2 , 4 and 8 mm in diameter .
one of flat bases of the cavity was a film under study .
the measurements were performed using @xmath2 mode at the frequencies of 134 , 65 and 34 ghz .
several dc off - axis magnetron sputtered ( ms ) , as well as pulse laser deposited ( pld ) , ybco films have been measured in the temperature range from 18 to 100 k. some films revealed a distinct two - peak structure of @xmath4 and @xmath5 dependencies with peaks at 2530 k and 4851 k ( figs .
[ fig.1 ] , [ fig.4 ] ) .
the peaks are much more pronounced at the lower frequency , while their temperature positions remain almost unchanged at any frequency . for less perfect films ( e.g. , pld ) characterized by a higher density of crystal lattice defects ,
the @xmath4 and @xmath5 dependencies appear to be monotonous ( power law ) and similar to those obtained in previous works.@xcite the two - peak peculiarity observed for both @xmath4 and @xmath5 is believed to be an intrinsic electronic feature of perfect quasi - single - crystalline ybco films .
the two - peak behavior is not detected in much smaller ybco single crystals and in experiments with a use of strip - line resonator measurement technique , which requires film patterning .
temperature dependencies of the surface resistance @xmath26 for three films ( # 48 , # 35 and # 10 ) at 34 ghz .
@xmath26 for cu is shown for comparison . ]
temperature dependencies of the penetration depth @xmath27 for the film # 35 at three different frequencies . ]
the observed dependence differs from that for perfect ybco single crystals , for which only one much broader frequency dependent peak of @xmath4 was detected.@xcite some peculiarities of the two - peak character of @xmath4 and @xmath5 dependencies are shown in figs .
[ fig.4][fig.5 ] .
the two - peak dependencies of @xmath28 for one of the most perfect ybco film are presented in fig .
[ fig.2 ] for three different frequencies , while fig .
[ fig.3 ] shows these dependencies normalized by @xmath29 .
the corresponding dependencies of penetration depth @xmath30 for the same film are shown in fig .
[ fig.4 ] for the same three frequencies .
[ fig.5 ] demonstrates the effect of aging and the influence of applied dc magnetic field on the two - peak structure of @xmath4 .
one can see that the specimen aging as well as application of dc magnetic field lead to smearing of the peaks .
moreover , dc magnetic field shifts the peak positions to slightly higher temperatures .
@xmath26 dependencies for the most perfect film ( # 35 ) at three different frequencies . ]
@xmath26 dependencies for the same film and frequencies as in fig .
[ fig.2 ] normalized by @xmath29 . ]
effects of aging and applied dc magnetic field on the @xmath26 dependence of the film # 35 at 34 ghz . ]
it is well known@xcite that in superconductors at microwave frequencies and not too high temperatures ( @xmath31 ) usually one has @xmath32 , where @xmath33 is the real part of microwave conductivity of superconductor @xmath34 .
so , the observed scaling of the @xmath35 curves shown in fig . [ fig.3 ] means that @xmath33 , which is determined by the contribution of thermally excited quasiparticles , almost does not depend on frequency within the studied frequency range : @xmath36 except the vicinity of peaks , where it is falling down rapidly with the increase of frequency .
the @xmath37 behavior is rather similar as it is shown in fig .
[ fig.4 ] .
thus , our experiments on perfect single - crystalline ybco films have revealed the new type of nonmonotonous two - peak temperature dependence of @xmath38 , essentially different from the single - peak nonmonotonous behavior observed before for perfect single crystals and films .
it should be noted also , that these observed for the first time two peaks of @xmath7 dependence for the most perfect films are much more narrow in the temperature scale than the single peak of @xmath7 for single crystals mentioned above.@xcite quite similarly to the case of single crystals , these peaks become suppressed , when frequency increases or for less perfect specimens .
the substantial difference between @xmath11 values of ybco epitaxially - grown highly biaxially - oriented films and ybco single crystals is shown to exist , increasing with temperature , @xmath39 .
this difference is supposed to be due to essentially different crystal defect spectra in ybco epitaxial films and single crystals .
perfect quasi - single - crystalline yba@xmath40cu@xmath41o@xmath42 films exhibit several times higher microwave surface resistance than ybco single crystals .
a different dimensionality of crystal defects in ybco single crystals and thin films is supposed to be responsible for the difference . in general ,
two major types of crystal defects ( point and planar , i.e. , oxygen vacancies and twins ) are known to be most essential for electromagnetic behavior of ybco single crystals . the nonmonotonous @xmath43 dependence with a large broad peak is mostly pronounced in untwined crystals , where only point defects are essential for electron scattering at low temperatures.@xcite in a contrast , _
c_oriented extended defects , such as out - of - plane dislocations@xcite and twin boundaries , which in the case of ybco films usually form much more dense network than in single crystals,@xcite are currently shown to be the most important ones for perfect epitaxially grown ybco films . despite the perfect crystallinity , different types of linear defects ( dislocations ) , as well as dislocation arrays , have been identified by tem / hrem in these films.@xcite in order to understand the high - frequency electromagnetic behavior of these films , the existence of edge dislocations arrays should be taken into account , in particular , out - of - plane edge dislocations , associated with low - angle tilt dislocation boundaries .
tem / hrem / xrd / afm characterization of the films under study revealed a smooth surface ( peak - to - valley is 2 nm ) , high average in - plane density of out - of - plane edge dislocations ( @xmath44@xmath45 @xmath46 ) and a big size of single - crystalline domains ( @xmath47 = 250 nm ) , which are separated by low - angle dislocation boundaries . in - plane misalignment of the domains
is as low as 0.51.0@xmath48.@xcite basing on this difference of defect structures of ybco perfect films and single crystals , in the next section we will suggest a model , which can explain ( at least qualitatively ) the main features of the observed two - peak nonmonotonous behavior of @xmath4 dependence in perfect ybco films , as well as the difference from a single - peak @xmath4 dependence in single crystals .
the value of microwave surface resistance @xmath11 in a linear regime of microwave response of superconductor at zero applied dc magnetic field is directly determined by the real part @xmath33 of high - frequency electron conductivity @xmath10 of superconductor : @xmath49 while the surface reactance @xmath22 is determined by the ac penetration depth @xmath37 , which in principle may be different from the london penetration depth @xmath50 : @xmath51 @xmath52 where @xmath53 is the contribution of excited quasiparticles to the screening properties of superconductor .
thus , the observed peaks of @xmath4 dependence reveal also the temperature dependence of @xmath33 , because the london penetration depth @xmath50 in eq .
( [ rs ] ) is a monotonous function of temperature .
similarly , peaks in @xmath5 and @xmath27 dependencies accordingly to eqs .
( [ xs ] ) , ( [ lambda ] ) are related also to the contribution of the normal component of electron fluid .
the @xmath54 value is generally ascribed to the contribution of `` normal '' component of electron fluid to the ac conductivity in the framework of so - called `` two - fluid '' model of superconductor .
it should be mentioned that the phenomenological `` two - fluid '' model , which is frequently used for description of microwave properties of superconductors , @xcite also follows from the microscopic bcs theory .
a very essential feature of the microscopic approach is that the role of normal component of electron fluid in superconductor is played by a gas of bogolyubov quasiparicles , which are determined as a superposition of electron and hole states in a normal fermi liquid . due to this circumstance
, the normal electron fluid in superconductors has quite different properties comparatively to those in a normal metal.@xcite we will take into account the peculiarities of the `` normal '' electron fluid of bogolyubov quasiparticles in superconductor and will show that the principal features of hts microwave response , including the observed two peaks of @xmath4 and @xmath5 dependencies , can be qualitatively explained using the boltzman kinetic equation approach for bogolyubov quasiparticles with a few additional assumptions about the symmetry of superconducting state in hts and its dependence on the concentration of static defects ( impurities , oxygen vacancies , dislocations , etc . ) .
namely , we will assume that the case of anisotropic _
s_+_d _ pairing is realized@xcite ( see fig . [ fig.6 ] ) : schematic representation of anisotropic pairing and scattering processes : ( a ) 3d scattering on point - like defects ; ( b ) in - plane scattering on extended defects ; ( c ) scattering of quasiparticles in the momentum space in the case of _
s_+_d _ pairing . ] @xmath55 and the relation between angle - dependent components @xmath56 of the pairing potential @xmath57 described by eq .
( [ delta ] ) is rather sensitive to the defect concentration and to different kind of borders ( e.g. , film surfaces and twin boundaries).@xcite in order to calculate the contribution of bogolyubov quasiparticles to the conductivity value at microwave frequencies we will use the boltzman kinetic equation for nonequilibrium distribution function of quasiparticles @xmath58 .
this approach is well known and was widely used for theoretical consideration of electron kinetic properties in normal metals.@xcite due to its relative simplicity it allows in principle to take into account peculiarities of electron spectrum and fermi surface in hts@xcite as well as different mechanisms of electron scattering .
this approach was argued on the base of microscopic bcs theory in the quasiclassical limit for quasiparticles in superconducting state.@xcite the boltzman equation in this case may be written in the form:@xcite @xmath59 where @xmath60 is the energy of quasiparticles ; @xmath61 is the energy of a normal electron in a vicinity of the fermi surface , @xmath62 and @xmath63 are the fermi velocity and momentum , respectively , @xmath64 is the equilibrium fermi distribution function of quasiparticles , @xmath65 is the group velocity of quasiparticles , @xmath66 is the quasiparticle charge , which is different from the normal electron charge @xmath67 , because a bogolyubov quasiparticle is a superposition of electron and hole states in the fermi liquid,@xcite @xmath68 is the relaxation time of quasiparticles , which in the case of elastic scattering by static defects can be calculated from the following well known expression:@xcite @xmath69 integration in eq .
( [ tau ] ) is performed in the vicinity of the fermi surface .
@xmath70 is the matrix element of electron scattering on the defect .
@xmath71 is the so - called `` coherence factor '' : @xmath72 which describes the difference between scattering of quasiparticles comparatively to usual electrons in the framework of bcs theory@xcite and provides a strong dependence of the relaxation time on the quasiparticle energy even in the case of elastic scattering on static defects . in the case of isotropic
@xmath73wave pairing and scattering on point - like defects this dependence can be estimated as:@xcite @xmath74 so , @xmath75 diverges at the edge of the gap when @xmath76 and the group velocity @xmath77 goes to zero . for the sake of simplicity we have assumed in eq .
( [ tau ] ) that all defects in the crystal lattice are identical and can be characterized by the same matrix element @xmath70 .
if there are several kinds of scattering defects , e.g. , point - like ( oxygen vacancies ) and extended ones ( dislocations , twin boundaries ) oriented along the @xmath78axis , as they usually are in the case of epitaxial films and as it was discussed in the previous section , it follows from eq .
( [ tau ] ) that : @xmath79 the energy dependencies of the relaxation rates in the right hand side of eq .
( [ tau1 ] ) for point - like and extended defects may be quite different because point like defects can scatter electrons in all directions of momentum space , while scattering on extended defects can proceed only with a conservation of momentum along the @xmath78axis .
this becomes especially important for layered hts materials , where electrons move mainly within cu - o layers . in the case of _ d_wave or assumed _ s_+_d _ ( or other type ) anisotropic pairing ,
an additional strong dependence of the relaxation time on the quasiparticles energy @xmath80 has to appear due to a confinement of momentum space , where the quasiparticle can be scattered , with a decrease of @xmath80 .
this effect follows directly from eq .
( [ tau ] ) due to the @xmath81function term in the integrand . in a certain sense , this effect can be considered as an analogue of andreev reflection of quasiparticles in the momentum space ( fig .
[ fig.6 ] ) .
the confinement of momentum space for quasiparticle scattering is mostly essential for the scattering on extended defects , leading to a very rapid increase of @xmath82 , when @xmath83 decreases and approaches the value @xmath84 ( @xmath85 ) as it is shown in fig .
[ fig.7 ] : @xmath86 energy dependence of the relaxation rate @xmath87 for the case of _ d_ or _
s_+_d_electron pairing and predominant scattering on extended linear defects . ] the general solution for the quasiparticle ac conductivity can be obtained from eq .
( [ boltz ] ) by a usual manner.@xcite the real part @xmath88 can be written in form : @xmath89 a strong temperature dependence of @xmath33 as well as its frequency dependence arise usually due to the @xmath90 term in the integrand of eq .
( [ sigma ] ) .
quite formally this solution can be rewritten in the drude - like form : @xmath91 where @xmath92 is the effective concentration of thermally excited quasiparticles , @xmath93 denotes thermal averaging . as it was originally supposed in refs.@xcite , the nonmonotonous character and appearance of @xmath26 peak dependence as well as its frequency dependence can be explained properly by a strong increase of quasiparticle relaxation time with temperature lowering according to the drude expression for the ac conductivity @xmath33 .
the peak position corresponds to the condition @xmath94 .
we suppose that this explanation is valid also in our case , when two peaks are observed . the emergence of two peaks instead of one can be explained by existence of two different @xmath84 values for the assumed case of _
s_+_d _ pairing ( see fig . [ fig.6 ] ) , while the sharpness of these peaks comparatively to the peak in single crystals is determined by a very strong energy dependence of the relaxation time ( eq . ( [ tau2 ] ) ) , when quasiparicles are scattered preferably by extended defects ( see fig . [ fig.7 ] ) .
this strong energy dependence of @xmath95 transforms into sharp peaks of @xmath96 according to eq .
( [ drude ] ) .
the present model can explain also some additional features of the microwave response of ybco films , such as ( i ) smearing of peaks with the frequency increase , ( ii ) lowering of @xmath26 and smearing of peaks with an increase of point - like defect concentration , ( iii ) general quasi - linear behavior of @xmath26 at moderate temperatures .
the obtained results shown in figs . [ fig.1][fig.5 ] , that is the nonmonotonous two - peak structure of @xmath38 in perfect single - crystalline ybco epitaxial films , is a strong argument for the scenario of anisotropic electron pairing in hts .
the observed for the first time two - peak peculiarity of @xmath7 dependence for the most perfect single - crystalline ybco films , as well as the difference from nonmonotonous @xmath38 dependence for perfect single crystals ( and also some less perfect films ) , can be explained , using just two assumptions : ( i ) the anisotropic _ s_+_d _ character of electron pairing and ( ii ) the dominant role of extended _ c_oriented defects in electron scattering processes .
these assumptions look quite natural with regard to thin films , where surfaces and/or twin boundaries can lead to more complicated character of electron pairing than the pure _ d_wave pairing in perfect single crystals.@xcite on the other hand , the extended @xmath78oriented linear or planar defects ( most probably , out - of - plane edge dislocations and twins ) can play a dominant role in electron scattering . in the case of untwined single crystals
there are no extended defects .
therefore , only point defects are essential for electron scattering at low temperatures .
the above two assumptions , which seem to be specific for thin films , distinguish them from single crystals and , thus , provide the difference in microwave response : one broad peak of @xmath4 for single crystals and two sharp peaks for perfect films . for less perfect films with a higher number of point defects and in the case when only pure _ d_wave pairing takes place , their behavior at microwave frequencies is rather similar to that of single crystals .
the observed two peaks of @xmath4 are much more narrow comparatively to the single peak for perfect single crystals due to different defect structures in films and single crystals as it was discussed above .
namely , a large number of extended defects along with an anisotropic pairing can lead to emergence of a sharp peak at @xmath97 as it follows from eq .
( [ sigma ] ) .
the second peak at a lower temperature is caused by the anisotropy of pairing potential ( existence of two different values @xmath84 for different directions in momentum space in the case of _
s_+_d _ electron pairing as it is shown schematically in fig . [ fig.6 ] ) .
the present model for quasiparticle conductivity allows also to understand the frequency dependence of the observed peculiarities and their smearing , when the number of point - like defects increases leading to an increase of @xmath98 .
it should be noted , that in a contrast to suggestions made in some theoretical works , it does not seem to be necessary to take into account a contribution of inelastic quasiparticle scattering by collective excitations ( magnons , phonons , etc . ) .
the two - peak temperature dependence of @xmath33 can occur in accordance to eq .
( [ drude ] ) even in the case of elastic scattering by extended static defects due to additional effect of anisotropy caused by anisotropic _
s_+_d_wave pairing , which leads to the confinement of momentum space available for scattered quasiparticles as it was discussed above .
the observed two - peak character of @xmath26 dependence is an feature of the most perfect quasi - single - crystalline ybco films , characterized by a smooth surface , low concentration of defects , large domain size and low - angle boundaries between them .
the @xmath26 dependence in less perfect films is monotonous .
we suppose that the two - peak character of @xmath26 , observed experimentally for the first time , is an intrinsic fundamental property and reveals the peculiarities of anisotropic electron pairing , which manifests in the microwave electron response and can be properly described using the boltzman kinetic equation approach for bogolyubov quasiparticles .
p. j. turner , r. harris , s. kamal , m. e. hayden , d. m. broun , d. c. morgan , a. hosseini , p. dosanjh , g. mullins , j. s. preston , r. liang , d. a. bonn , and w. n. hardy , phys .
* 90 * , 237005 ( 2003 ) .
v. m. pan , v. s. flis , v. a. komashko , o. p. karasevska , v. l. svetshnikov , m. lorenz , a. n. ivanyuta , g. a. melkov , e. a. pashitskii , and h. w. zandbergen , ieee trans .
supercond . *
11 * , 3960 ( 2001 )
. b. dam , j. m. huijbregtse , f. c. claassen , r. c. f. van der geest , g. doornbos , j. h. rector , a. m. testa , s. freisem , j. c. martinez , b. stauble - pumpin , and r. griessen , nature ( london ) * 399 * , 439 ( 1999 ) .
a. g. aronov , yu .
m. galperin , v. l. gurevich , and v. i. kozub , in _ nonequilibrium superconductivity _ , edited by d. n. langenberg and a. i. larkin ( elsevier science publishers b.v . , amsterdam , 1986 ) , p. 325
phys . * 30 * , 539 ( 1981 ) . | temperature dependencies of microwave surface impedance , @xmath0 , were measured for perfect _ c_-oriented ybco thin films deposited on ceo@xmath1buffered sapphire substrates .
the measurements were performed with a use of three copper cylindrical resonators operating at @xmath2 mode ( @xmath3 = 34 , 65 , 134 ghz ) , which incorporated the studied ybco films as end plates .
the measurements revealed a distinct two - peak structure of @xmath4 and @xmath5 dependencies with peaks at 2830 k and 50 k. the peaks become smeared at higher frequencies as well as in applied dc magnetic field ( @xmath6 koe ) , while the peak positions remain almost unchanged . for less perfect , e.g. , pld films , @xmath4 and @xmath5 dependencies are monotonous ( power law ) .
the two - peak @xmath7 dependencies for ybco films differ from those for high quality ybco single crystals , where only one much broader frequency - dependent peak of @xmath4 was detected earlier .
the two - peak @xmath7 behavior is believed to be an intrinsic electron property of extremely perfect quasi - single - crystalline ybco films .
a theoretical model is suggested to explain the observed anomalous @xmath7 behavior .
the model is based on the boltzman kinetic equation for quasiparticles in layered hts cuprates .
it takes into account the supposed _
s_+_d_wave symmetry of electron pairing and strong energy dependent relaxation time of quasiparticles , determined mainly by their elastic scattering on extended defects parallel to the _ c_axis ( e.g. , _ c_oriented dislocations and twin boundaries ) . |
we consider ideal mhd in twodimensional space , @xmath2 the dependent variables @xmath3 denote the fluid s density , pressure , and velocity .
in addition to , the magnetic field @xmath4 satisfies @xmath5 the fluid is assumed to be polytropic , @xmath6 , and have a constant temperature @xmath7 , so that @xmath8 with constant sound speed @xmath9 . by scaling , we assume without loss of generality that @xmath10 we abbreviate as @xmath11 with @xmath12 using , we also write it as a symmetric hyperbolic system , @xmath13 with @xmath14 , @xmath15 , and @xmath16 applying the chain rule , we rewrite as @xmath17 where @xmath18 with @xmath19 note that , as we have used on the way from to , the matrices @xmath20 and @xmath21 in are _ not _ the jacobians of the fluxes @xmath22 and @xmath23 .
ideal mhd shock waves , in their prototypical form , have the structure @xmath24 where @xmath25 is the direction of propagation and @xmath26 the speed of the shock wave .
function being a weak solution of is equivalent to the rankine - hugoniot conditions @xmath27 due to rotational and galilean invariance it is without loss of generality that we henceforth assume that @xmath28 i. e. we exclusively consider shock waves of the form @xmath29 and the rankine - hugoniot conditions read @xmath30 note now first that for waves , as for any solutions of whose spatial dependence is only via @xmath31 , the divergence - free condition reduces to @xmath32 we assume and simply write @xmath33 instead of @xmath34 . in this paper , we are interested in lax shocks . following @xcite , two states @xmath35 that satisfy the rankine - hugoniot conditions constitute a @xmath36 and a @xmath37 two states do satisfy the rankine - hugoniot conditions
if and only if the two quadruples @xmath38 and @xmath39 have coinciding images under the mapping @xmath40 that @xmath22 induces by omitting its forth , trivial component , in other words if both quadruples satisfy the four equations @xmath41 for the same values of the four parameters @xmath42 . as simple arguments or @xmath43 give no lax shocks ] show , we lose no generality in assuming that @xmath44 using in and inserting the result and in then yields @xmath45 as for every solution @xmath46 of , relations , , provide unique associated values for @xmath47 and @xmath48 , understanding will give a complete picture .
one distinguishes two cases .
_ @xmath49 : parallel shocks .
_ in this case , has two solutions @xmath50 the corresponding states constitute a @xmath51 and a @xmath52 the fact that the value of @xmath53 has no influence on the @xmath54 components of parallel shocks is easily understood by noticing that they have @xmath55 and thus are purely gas dynamical .
_ @xmath56 : non - parallel shocks .
_ in this case , @xmath57 tends to @xmath58 not only for @xmath59 und @xmath60 , but also for @xmath61 .
thus for every @xmath62 has two solutions @xmath63 that consitute a slow shock .
similarly , for every @xmath64 there are two solutions @xmath65 that define a fast shock .
according to majda s theory @xcite on the persistence of shock fronts , the local - in - time stability of the planar discontinous wave is determined by the behaviour of the lopatinski determinant @xmath66 where @xmath67 . while _ uniform stability
_ corresponds to the non - vanishing of @xmath68 on all of @xmath69 , shocks with @xmath70 are _ neutrally stable _ or _ strongly unstable _ , respectively .
the ingredients of the lopatinski determinant are @xmath71 where @xmath72 denote @xmath73 .
the theory of hyperbolic initial - boundary value problems @xcite implies that @xmath74 are well - defined bundles of constant dimension . to be precise , it is on @xmath75 that the _ lopatinski matrices _ @xmath76 have constantly trivial neutral spaces and thus `` consistent splitting '' , i. e. , stable and unstable spaces of constant dimensions , so that in particular @xmath77 are constant ; for points @xmath78 with purely imaginary values of @xmath79 , the @xmath80 are defined as limits from the interior of @xmath69 @xcite . from the one - dimensional ` lax counting ' of characteristic speeds @xcite , we know that @xmath81 while @xmath82 the lopatinski determinant @xmath68 being degree - one homogeneous in @xmath83 , we from now on fix the transverse wave number to @xmath84 to avoid abundant notation , we also fix from now , again without loss of generality , @xmath85 and use the two parameters @xmath86 instead of the three paramters @xmath87 . for parallel shocks ,
our choice implies @xmath88 in this paper we concentrate on slow shocks .
the following is a key observation . for slow parallel mhd shocks in , with and @xmath89 , @xmath90 interesting manipulations
show that one can take @xmath91 together with @xmath92 , this yields @xmath93.\ ] ] , cf .
theorem 1 .
the black boundary is the lax condition : @xmath94 . ]
the situation of parallel shocks is degenerate as it possesses a reflectional symmetry in the transverse ( @xmath95-)direction . for the lopatinski determinant
this symmetry means that @xmath96 vanishes exactly if @xmath97 does .
perturbing the parameter @xmath9 away from @xmath98 breaks this symmetry , and the zero of @xmath68 that we found , for @xmath99 at @xmath100 , splits . for all values of @xmath101 that permit a ( then unique ) slow mhd shock wave , we write @xmath102 for the corresponding lopatinski determinant . starting from theorem 1 , we found the following .
there are an @xmath103 and two functions , @xmath104 both defined on @xmath105 , such that @xmath106 for some values of @xmath9 between @xmath107 and @xmath108 .
the red curve corresponds to @xmath99 and thus to the red curve in fig . 1 .
] a detailed description of the numerics is postponed to a later publication .
do unstable modes emerge in families of shock waves that correspond to parameter values which cross the critical manifold ?
the following is what we conclude from numerical computations . .
both from a physics perspective and as the evans function for non - ideal shock waves is intimately related to the lopatinski determinant for their non - ideal counterparts @xcite , one expects the _ gallopping instability _ described in this paper to occur also in the presence of viscosity and and electrical resistivity .
s. k. godunov : lois de conservation et intgrales dnergie des quations hyperboliques .
_ nonlinear hyperbolic problems , proceedings st .
etienne 1986_. 135 - 148 .
lecture notes in mathematics 1270 , springer : berlin etc . , 1987 . | this note studies classical magnetohydrodynamic shock waves in an inviscid fluidic plasma that is assumed to be a perfect conductor of heat as well as of electricity . for this mathematically prototypical material
, it identifies a critical manifold in parameter space , across which slow classical mhd shock waves undergo emergence of a complex conjugate pair of unstable transverse modes . in the reflectionally symmetric case of parallel shocks
, this emergence happens at the spectral value @xmath0 , and the critical manifold possesses a simple explicit algebraic representation .
results of refined numerical treatment show that for only _ almost _ parallel shocks the unstable mode pair emerges from _ two _ spectral values @xmath1 .
= 1 |
ngc 6946 , a nearby starburst spiral galaxy , also known as the `` fireworks galaxy '' because of its prolific supernova production , is embedded in an enormous hi halo ( pisano 2014 ) .
the galaxy has a high star formation rate and a number of unusual star - forming regions , such as enigmatic hodge complex which contains a young super star cluster @xcite .
ngc 6946 is famous also for hosting the record number of observed sne .
we found that apart from the above mentioned peculiarities , this galaxy hosts one more strange object , which in common images is seen as just one of its many hii regions .
however , in deep high - resolution images this object is really wonderful .
one of the best existing optical picture of ngc 6946 is the data , obtained with the suprime - cam on the subaru 8.2-m telescope . using this beautiful image from the subaru telescope press - release , one of us ( yu.e . ) has found an unusual red ellipse inside the isolated northern spiral arm ; this color might be caused by emission , what we do establish in this paper .
the ellipse is assumed to be within ngc 6946 , because it is within the chain of hi clouds , h ii regions , and luminous stars comprising the isolated northern arm of this galaxy ( fig .
[ fig_image ] ) . at a distance
to ngc 6946 of 5.9 mpc , the ellipse has a very large size of approximately @xmath1 pc . in this paper
, we present the results of spectroscopic study of this elliptical nebulae on the 6-m telescope of the special astrophysical observatory of the russian academy of sciences ( sao ras ) .
the red ellipse was found at the color image presented in the subaru 8.2-m telescope press - release .
the data were obtained by the subaru observation experience program team in the period of aug 28 - sep 3 , 2008 with the suprime - cam imaging camera and have not been published in peer - review journals yet .
the image presents an excellent combination of a large field ( @xmath2 arcmin ) and high spatial resolution ( pixel size @xmath3 arcsec ) .
figure [ fig_image ] ( bottom right ) shows the fragment of the subaru press - release composite color -band filter ( centered on 0.45 @xmath4 ) , the green channel is the @xmath5 filter ( centered on 0.55 @xmath4 ) image , and the red channel presents data in the ia651 narrow - band filter centered on 0.651 @xmath4 ( + [ nii]+continuum ) .
the seeing value estimated as fwhm of single stars in the @xmath5 band was @xmath6 arcsec .
later on , we found that the enigmatic ellipse is also well seen in the color image obtained at the kitt peak national observatory ( kpno ) 4-m mayall telescope with the mosaic camera on sep 5 , 2008 .
[ fig_image ] , top right ) .
the composite color image presents the @xmath7 band ( blue channel ) , @xmath5 band ( green channel ) , and + [ nii ] continuum ( red channel ) images .
the pixel size was similar with the subaru data ( @xmath8 arcsec ) , while the seeing was @xmath9 arcsec in the @xmath5 band .
we use the subaru and kpno press - release images to consider the morphological structure of the nebulae without photometric estimations .
the astrometry grid was created using the astrometry.net project web - interface .
the ne part of the red ellipse has a short parallel arc , as well as many other red and white details ( fig .
[ fig_image ] ) .
the ellipse slightly resembles a large supernova remnant somewhat similar to the ultraluminous supernova remnant complex ( mf 16 ) in the ne arm of ngc 6946 , studied by @xcite with hst wfpc2 images .
that ellipse , however , is only about @xmath10 pc ( in spite of being the largest snr in ngc 6946 known until now ) and has strong x - ray emission associated with it . in any case , the elliptical ring is not a supernova remnant , because there is no [ fe ii ] or x - ray emission , as follows from the data shown by @xcite .
the red ellipse is ten times larger and much brighter than the mf 16 , and this fact alone casts strong doubt on the identification of the red ellipse as a snr .
was accepted to the continuum brightness peak within the slit , i.e. , the bright star cluster centre .
, scaledwidth=50.0% ] long - slit spectral observations were carried out at the prime focus of the sao ras 6-m big telescope alt - azimuthal ( bta ) with the scorpio-2 multimode focal reducer @xcite in the night of 6/7 november 2015 .
the slit was 6.1 arcmin in length and 1 arcsec in width , the grism vphg1200@540 provided a spectral resolution of about 4.5 - 5 in the spectral range of 36507250 with a mean reciprocal dispersion of 0.8 per pixel , and with a spatial sampling of 0.36 arcsec per pixel along the slit .
the total integration time was 2400 sec under seeing @xmath11 .
we put the slit across the nebula major axis ( @xmath12 ) , see fig .
[ fig_slitpos ] .
the object data and spectrum of the spectrophotometric standard star observed at the same night were reduced and calibrated using the idl - based software developed at the sao ras , ( see , for instance , * ? ? ?
* ) the parameters of the emission lines ( integrated flux , line - of - sight velocity , fwhm ) were calculated from a single - gaussian fitting using a similar technique described in @xcite . the doublets ( [ nii]@xmath13 , [ oiii]@xmath14 , and [ sii]@xmath15 ) were fitted by a pair of gaussians with the same velocities and fwhm .
we estimated the errors of the measured parameters by analyzing the synthetic spectra degraded by noise with the same signal - to - noise ratio as in the corresponding observational spectrum . to increase the signal - to - noise ratio for weak emission regions , we binned spectrograms into 2 pixels bins along the slit prior to emission line analysis .
the final spatial scale was 0.7 arcsec per pixel in a good accordance with the atmospheric seeing value .
a multicomponent structure of the emission - line profiles was not detected .
also , the fwhm of the main emission lines is in a good agreement with the width of the nearest airglow emission lines , we can only conclude that the actual ( free from instrumental contour broadening ) fwhm of the lines is smaller than 5070@xmath16 .
[ [ section ] ] [ [ sec_intspec ] ] figure [ fig_spectrum ] shows the integrated spectrum around ( @xmath17 ) of the star cluster .
the spectrum appears to be typical of an hii region ; however , weak helium lines are also detected including the low - contrast broad bump around heii@xmath18
. therefore , some emission - line hot stars like of or even wr could belong to the cluster .
noise on the spectrum shown on fig .
[ fig_spectrum ] grows up significantly at the short wavelength , .
level.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] [ [ section-1 ] ] only a few of the brightest emission lines are detected in the nebula outside the star cluster regions including the balmer ( , h@xmath19 ) and forbidden ( [ sii]@xmath15 , [ nii]@xmath13 , [ oiii]@xmath14 ) lines . changes of their parameters across the slit are shown in fig .
[ fig_lines ] .
the coordinates along the slit ( @xmath20 ) are positive in ws directions with the coordinate origin in the star cluster photometric centre according to the ruler denoted in fig .
[ fig_slitpos ] .
hereafter , we use a term `` the main part '' of the nebulae / red ellipse for points in the coordinate range @xmath21 corresponding to the bright borders of the objects in -images , see figs .
[ fig_image ] and [ fig_slitpos ] . also , our spectrograms allow us to study weak extended diffuse gas around the red ellipse .
note a significant light pollution from the galaxy foreground star at @xmath22 near the sw border of the red ellipse .
we can make the following conclusions based on the changes of emission - line parameters along the slit : * the velocities of the forbidden and balmer lines are in a good agreement ; their values across the red ellipse nebula lie in the range of 3060@xmath16 that is in a good agreement with the hi observations ( 4555@xmath16 , see below sec .
[ sec_discussion ] ) .
if velocity variations in the main part of the red ellipse ( @xmath23 ) are caused by nebula expansion , the corresponding expansion velocity should be less than 1520@xmath16 .
* behaviors of the forbidden - to - recombination lines ratio are different in the different lines . the relative flux in [ oiii]@xmath24 increases in the ne side of the red ellipse ( around the star cluster ) , while it decreases to the sw arcs , where the [ sii]/ and [ nii]/ ratios grow ( hereafter , we use [ n ii]/and [ s ii]/ to denote the [ n ii]@xmath25/ and [ s ii](@xmath26)/ line flux ratios respectively ) .
obviously , the growth of a temperature - sensitive [ o iii ] emission line is related to the ionization radiation of hot massive stars in the cluster .
[ [ section-2 ] ] we used the ratios of neighboring emission lines independent of interstellar extinction to probe the gas ionization state .
all points in the main part of the nebulae satisfy the case of photoionization by young stars according to the popular criteria @xmath27/$]@xmath28 and @xmath29/$]@xmath30 @xcite .
however these ratios exceed 0.40.5 in diffuse gas outside the bright nebulae ( @xmath31 , see fig .
[ fig_lines ] ) .
similar behaviors of gas excitation inside / outside the red ellipse are also seen in the classical bpt diagram @xcite present @xmath32/$ ] and @xmath29/$ ] versus @xmath33/\mbox{h}\beta$ ] ratio ( fig .
[ fig_ratio ] , top panels ) .
indeed , most points which belong to the red ellipse are located below the conventional lines @xcite separated gas photoionized in the hii - regions and the regions , where gas is ionized by shocks or by hard uv photos from active galactic nuclei ( agn ) . while the points corresponding to the diffuse gas surrounding the main nebulae are located on the border dividing the different excitation mechanisms or even above the line , i.e. , in the shock / agn region .
this fact indicates that shocks contribute to the gas ionization , which is not surprising for warm diffuse gas surrounding sites of current star formation .
also , the border line is occupied by points with @xmath34 from the vicinity of the star cluster , where the densest cloud of neutral gas is located according to the hi column density map ( see below sec .
[ sec_discussion ] and fig .
[ fig_multiwave ] ) . as it was mentioned above , this region
is characterized by relatively bright [ o iii ] emissions , indicating high temperature of gas ionized by hot massive stars including shocks generated by stellar winds from wr and of emission - line stars . also , we considered diagnostic diagrams separating different types of nebulas ( snr , hii - regions , and pn ) using electron density - depended ratio of sulfur dublet components [ sii ] @xmath35 versus /[nii ] and /[sii ] lines ratio @xcite .
bottom panels in fig .
[ fig_ratio ] show that the points from the main part of the red ellipse avoid the region of galactic and extragalactic snr .
these points are within the range of the lines ratios which is corresponded to hii - regions and the border snr / hii .
the observed data are distributed along vertical axis in the directions of high ratio @xmath36 corresponding to the electron densities @xmath37 ( for @xmath38 k according * ? ? ?
some points are located even above the line ratio 1.44 that is formally forbidden by this ` standard ' @xmath35@xmath39 relation .
it implies that the mean @xmath39 in the red ellipse is smaller then in the typical hii regions , this fact together with the ionization by hot stars and small contribution of shock points to superbubble created by collective actions of massive stars in the ne star cluster , as the most likely explanation of the red ellipse origin .
@xcite were among the first to study star formation in the extreme outer regions of disc galaxies including ngc 6946 .
their -image shows the region of the red ellipse as an unresolved bright source .
they infer that the star formation rate is fairly constant from the inner to the outer disc in ngc 6946 , although , the covering factor of star formation in the outer disc is quite low , so the overall azimuthally averaged star formation rate abruptly drops in the outer regions . nevertheless , the outer northern spiral arm containing the red ellipse has the highest hi column density of any region in the outer galaxy , with a value of @xmath40 @xcite .
it also has an unusual inward bulk motion of 30@xmath16 , which led @xcite to suggest that this arm was compressed and moved by ram pressure from an intergalactic cloud .
this cloud appears in the hi map of @xcite .
we might infer that this ram pressure has triggered the super star cluster , which resulted in supernovae leading to formation of a giant ( even supergiant for a snr ) elliptical ring ; anyway , we know that sne may arise in a poor cluster as well ( such as sn 1987a , the probable member of a small open cluster in the lmc @xcite .
the most intriguing feature of the nebula is its very regular elliptical shape similar to some snr or galactic ring nebulae around wr or of stars .
however , the size of the red ellipse ( @xmath0 pc along major axis ) is comparable to wind blown structures related to giant hii - regions . other arguments against snr origin of the red ellipse are the following : ( i ) the lack of the x - ray and synchrotron radio emission ; ( ii ) the contribution of shocks in gas ionization is very modest , as follows from our diagnostic diagrams .
the multi - wavelength archive images of the nebula ( fig .
[ fig_multiwave ] ) clearly demonstrate that _ galex _ uv , _ spitzer _ mir , and 6-cm radio emission are directly related to the star cluster in the base of the red ellipse .
the hi line - of - sight velocities are in a good agreement with our estimation in the ionized gas if the difference of spatial resolutions will be taken into account .
the hi velocity variations through the nebulae are modest and do not exceed a few @xmath16
. the extended diffuse regions of the nebulae are not detected in the present multi - wavelength data set with exception of _ spitzer _ data .
indeed , _ spitzer _ 4.5 and 5.8 @xmath4 images reveal weak counterparts in sw side of the red ellipse , where the cavern of low - density gas appears on the hi density map .
we suggest that this feature could be related with warp dust emission , including polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons contributions which are usually observed in hii regions of active star formation .
the red ellipse seems to be a nebula created by collective actions of sn explosions and winds of massive stars in the ne stellar cluster
the presence of wr or of stars is evident on the star cluster spectrum .
however , even in this case , the regular and closed morphology of the red ellipse is unusual .
it is possible that we observe a rare interplay between pre - existed distribution of cold and dense interstellar medium and hot gas ejected from young stellar group . indeed ,
the cavern in the hi distribution according to the thing data matches the emission - line bubble ( fig .
[ fig_multiwave ] ) . a `` wall '' with the hi surface density observed near
the sw border of the red ellipse can prevent its further expansion . a similar ( but not the same ) example is the well - known s3 giant bipolar nebula ( two bubbles about 100 and 200 pc in diameter ) created by a single wo star in the dwarf galaxy ic 1613 .
@xcite have shown that the unique structure of s3 is caused by stellar wind of the wo star embedded in a dense layer at the boundary of hi supercavity .
does the similar scenario work also in the case of the red ellipse ?
new observations , first of all integral - field data in the optical or / and nir ranges together with the detailed simulations of feedback processes on the outskirts of ngc 6946 are crucial for the final conclusion .
the strange shape of this nebula remains enigmatic .
the observations at the 6-meter bta telescope were carried out with the financial support of the ministry of education and science of the russian federation ( agreement no . 14.619.21.0004 , project i d rfmefi61914x0004 ) . in this research
, we used the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology under contract with the national aeronautics and space administration .
the _ galex _
image presented in this paper was obtained from the mikulski archive for space telescopes ( mast ) .
stsci is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc .
, under nasa contract nas5 - 26555 .
the support for mast for non - hst data is provided by the nasa office of space science via grant nnx09af08 g and by other grants and contracts .
we also note very useful collection of the ngc 6946 images obtained at the kpno on the mayall 4-m telescope with the mosaic camera . this study has been carried out under the financial support of the russian science foundation ( project no .
14 - 22 - 00041 ) .
we are very grateful to debra elmegreen and bruce elmegreen for useful discussions and also to the anonymous referee for the constructive comments and suggestions that helped us to improve and clarify our result .
we thank roman uklein and dmitri oparin for assisting in the 6-m telescope observations .
sabbadin f. , minello s. , bianchini a. , 1977 , a&a , 60 , 147 stasiska g. , cid fernandes r. , mateus a. , sodr l. , asari n. v. , 2006 , mnras , 371 , 972 walter f. , brinks e. , de blok w. j. g. , et al . , 2008 ,
aj , 136 , 2563 | ngc 6946 , known as the fireworks galaxy because of its high supernova rate and high star formation , is embedded in a very extended hi halo .
its northern spiral arm is well detached from the galactic main body .
we found that this arm contains a large ( @xmath0 pc in size ) red ellipse , .
the ellipse is accompanied by a short parallel arc and a few others still smaller and less regular ; a bright star cluster is seen inside these features .
the complicated combination of arcs seems to be unique , it is only a bit similar to some snrs .
however , the long - slit spectral data obtained with the russian 6-m telescope did not confirm the origin of the nebula as a result of a single sn outburst .
the emission - line spectrum corresponds to the photoionization by young hot stars with a small contribution of shock ionization .
the most likely explanation of the red ellipse is a superbbuble created by a collective feedback of massive stars in the star cluster located in the ne side of the red ellipse .
however , the very regular elliptical shape of the nebulae seems strange .
[ firstpage ] hii regions galaxies : spiral galaxies : individual : ngc 6946 ism : supernova remnants galaxies : star formation |
the starobinsky model of inflation @xcite with an @xmath11 interaction term is of interest as it requires no extra scalar fields but relies on the scalar degree of the metric tensor to generate the inflaton potential .
the @xmath12 starobinsky model gives rise to a plateau potential of the inflaton when transformed to the einstein frame .
this model was favored by the planck constraint on the tensor to scalar ratio which ruled out potentials like @xmath13 and @xmath14 .
in addition the starobinsky model could be mapped to the higgs - inflation models with @xmath15 theory @xcite .
the characteristic feature of the starobinsky equivalent models was the prediction that the tensor to scalar ratio was @xmath16 .
bicep2 reported a large value of @xmath17 @xcite but the recent joint analysis by planck + bicep2 + keck array give only an upper bound of @xmath18 @xcite . in an analysis of the genus structure of the b - mode polarisation of planck + bicep2 data by colley
et al . put the tensor to scalar ratio at @xmath19 @xcite . in the light of the possibility that @xmath20 can be larger than the starobinsky model prediction of @xmath21 , generalisations of the starobinsky model are of interest .
we study a general power law @xmath22 correction to the einstein gravity and compute the scalar and tensor power spectrum as a function of the two dimensionless parameters @xmath23 and @xmath24 .
it is well known that the @xmath11 model is equivalent to the @xmath15 higgs - inflation model as they led to the same scalar potential in the einstein frame @xcite .
one can find similar equivalence between generalized higgs - inflation models and the power law starobinsky model whose common feature is violation of the global weyl symmetry . a general scalar curvature coupled @xmath25 model was studied in @xcite .
the quantum correction on @xmath26-potential in jordan frame was studied in @xcite where they have shown the equivalence of the @xmath27 model with @xmath28 model . the generalized starobinsky model with @xmath29 correction
has been studied in the ref .
in general scalar - curvature theories the scalar plays the role of the inflaton after transforming to einstein frame whereas in pure curvature theories like @xmath30 model the longitudinal part of the graviton is the equivalent scalar in the einstein frame plays the role of inflaton .
the higher order curvature theories arise naturally in theories of supergravity .
the supergravity embedding of the higgs - inflation @xcite does not produce a slow roll potential in mssm but a potential suitable for inflation is obtained in nmssm @xcite .
the potential in nmssm however has a tachyonic instability in the direction orthogonal to the slow roll @xcite .
this instability can be cured by the addition of quartic terms of the fields in the khler potential @xcite . in the context of a supergravity embedding of the starobinsky model ,
it was shown by cecotti@xcite that quadratic ricci curvature terms can be derived in a supergravity theory by adding two chiral superfields in the minimal supergravity .
a no - scale sugra@xcite model with a modulus field and the inflation field with a minimal wess - zumino superpotential gives the same f - term potential in the einstein frame as the starobinsky model @xcite .
the symmetry principle which can be invoked for the sugra generalization of the starobinsky model is the spontaneous violation of superconformal symmetry @xcite .
the quadratic curvature can also arise from d - term in a minimal - sugra theory with the addition of a vector and chiral supermultiplets @xcite .
the starobinsky model has been derived from the d - term potential of a sugra model @xcite .
quartic powers of ricci curvature in the bosonic lagrangian can also be obtained in a sugra model by the d - term of higher order powers of the field strength superfield @xcite . in this paper
we give a sugra model for the general power law @xmath31 model .
we show that adding a @xmath32 term to the minimal no - scale khler potential and with a wess - zumino form of the superpotential @xmath33 yields the same potential in the einstein frame as the generalised starobinsky model . in the limit
@xmath34 the starobinsky limit @xmath1 is obtained .
we derive the relations between the two parameters of the power - law starobinsky model and the two parameters of our sugra model .
the interesting point about the generalization is that small deviations from the starobinsky limit of @xmath35 can produce large shifts in the values of @xmath20 .
many sugra models have been constructed which can yield a range of @xmath20 from @xmath36 by changing the parameters of the khler potential and the superpotential @xcite .
we also show in this paper that our 2-parameter sugra model which we relate to the 2-parameter @xmath37 model is the most economical representation of the 5-parameter scalar - curvature coupled inflation models @xmath38 in terms of the number of parameters .
the organization of this paper is as follows : in the section ( [ power - law ] ) , we calculate an equivalent scalar potential in the einstein frame for @xmath39 gravity .
we then find the parameter @xmath23 and @xmath24 values which satisfy the observed amplitude @xmath40 , spectral index @xmath41 and tensor to scalar @xmath20 .
we fix model parameters for two cases : one with running of @xmath42 and another without running of @xmath42 . in the section ( [ sugra ] ) ,
we give a sugra embedding of the @xmath28 model with a specific choice of the khler potential @xmath43 and superpotential @xmath44 . in the section ( [ higgs - inflation ] ) , we show that the generalized curvature coupling model @xmath38 is equivalent to @xmath45 model and give the relation between the parameters of these two generalized models .
finally we conclude in section ( [ concl ] ) .
we start with a @xmath10 action of the form @xcite @xmath46 where @xmath47 , @xmath48 is the determinant of the metric @xmath49 and @xmath23 is a dimensionless real parameter .
the subscript @xmath50 refers to jordan frame which indicates that the gravity sector is not the einstein gravity form .
the action ( [ eq1 ] ) can be transformed to an einstein frame action using the conformal transformation @xmath51 , where @xmath52 is the conformal factor and tilde represents quantities in the einstein frame . under conformal transformation the ricci scalar @xmath53 in the two frames is related by r=(+3 -^ _ _ ) [ rex ] where @xmath54 .
if one choose the conformal factor to be @xmath55 and introduce a new scalar field @xmath56 defined by @xmath57 , using ( [ rex ] ) , the action ( [ eq1 ] ) gets transform to an einstein hilbert form : @xmath58 \label{ein}\ ] ] where @xmath59 is the einstein frame potential given by @xmath60 which , by using the @xmath10 form ( [ eq1 ] ) and @xmath61 , can be given explicitly in terms of model parameters @xmath23 and @xmath24 as u ( ) & = & ( ) ^ + & & ^[u1 ] where we have taken @xmath62 and from here onwards we shall work in @xmath62 units . also we see that in the limit @xmath63 potential ( [ u1 ] ) reduces to exponentially corrected flat plateau potential of the starobinsky model . assuming large field limit @xmath64 and @xmath65 , the potential ( [ u1 ] ) reduces to u ( ) ( ) ^ [ u2 ] we shall use eq.([u2 ] ) later in the section ( [ sugra ] ) to compare with sugra version of the power law potential in the large field limit . in fig.[fig1 ] we plot the potential for small deviations from the starobinsky model value @xmath1 .
we see that the potential is very flattest for @xmath1 but becomes very steep even with small deviation from starobinsky model value @xmath1 .
the scalar curvature perturbation @xmath66 is fixed from observations which implies that the magnitude of the potential @xmath59 would have to be larger as @xmath67 increases for steep potential .
the tensor perturbation which depends on the magnitude of @xmath59 therefore increases rapidly as @xmath24 varies from @xmath68 .
the variation of @xmath20 with @xmath24 is shown in the fig.[fig3 ] . from eq.([u1 ] ) , in the large field approximation , the slow roll parameters in einstein frame can be obtained as & = & ( ) ^2 + & & ^2 [ slow1 ] & = & + & & & = & + & & the field value @xmath69 at the end of inflation can be fixed from eq.([slow1 ] ) by using the end of inflation condition @xmath70 . and the initial scalar field value @xmath71 corresponding to @xmath72 e - folds before the end of inflation , when observable cmb modes leave the horizon , can be fixed by using the e - folding expression @xmath73 . under slow - roll approximation
we use the standard einstein frame relations for the amplitude of the curvature perturbation @xmath74 , the spectral index @xmath75 , the running of spectral index @xmath76 and the tensor to scalar ratio @xmath77 to fix the parameters of our model .
note that the superscript @xmath78 indicates that the the observables are evaluated at the initial field value @xmath71 . we know from cmb observations , for 8-parameter @xmath79+@xmath20+@xmath80 model , that if there is a large running of the spectral index @xmath81 at ( @xmath82 , plancktt+lowp ) then the amplitude is @xmath83 , the spectral index is @xmath84 and tensor to scalar ratio is @xmath85 ( @xmath86 , plancktt+lowp ) @xcite . also a joint bicep2/keck array and planck analysis
put an upper limit on @xmath18 .
since the scalar potential @xmath59 depends on both the parameters @xmath23 and @xmath24 whereas the slow roll parameters depend only on @xmath24 , therefore parameter @xmath23 affects only the scalar amplitude @xmath87 whereas @xmath20 , @xmath42 and @xmath80 which depend only on slow roll parameters remain unaffected by @xmath23 . therefore taking amplitude from the observation and fixing the number of e - foldings @xmath88 fixes the value of @xmath23 and @xmath24 .
we find numerically that for the best fit parameter values @xmath89 and @xmath90 , the e - foldings turns out to be @xmath91 .
the tensor to scalar ratio can be further reduced to @xmath92 for @xmath93 , @xmath94 but e - foldings still comes out to be low @xmath95 , see fig.[fig2](upper panel ) . therefore constraining model parameters using running data
implies that cosmological problems like horizon and flatness problems which require a minimum of @xmath96 e - foldings can not be solved with the power law generalization of the starobinsky model . also from cmb observations , for 7-parameter @xmath79+@xmath20 model , when there is no scale dependence of the scalar and tensor spectral indices the bound on @xmath20 becomes tighter @xmath97 ( @xmath86 , plancktt+lowp ) and the amplitude and the spectral index become @xmath98 and @xmath99 respectively at ( @xmath82 , plancktt+lowp ) @xcite .
we find that the values of @xmath100 and @xmath101 which satisfy the amplitude and the spectral index for @xmath102 gives large @xmath103 .
also we see that for @xmath89 and @xmath104 tensor to scalar ratio can be reduced to @xmath105 but it increases @xmath106 , see fig.[fig2](lower panel ) .
in this section we give a sugra model of the power law starobinsky model .
we shall derive a model where the scalar potential in the einstein frame is the same as eq.([u2 ] ) which we have shown in the section ( [ power - law ] ) is equivalent to the power law starobinsky model @xmath107 .
the f - term scalar potential in sugra depends upon the combination of the khler potential @xmath108 and the superpotential @xmath109 as @xmath110 , where @xmath111 are the chiral superfields whose scalar component are @xmath112 @xcite . the effective potential and kinetic term in the einstein frame are given by v = e^g[lv ] and _ k = k_i^j * _ ^i ^^*_j [ lk ] respectively , where @xmath113 is the inverse of the khler metric @xmath114 .
a no - scale sugra model @xcite with a choice of the khler potential @xmath115 $ ] and a minimal wess - zumino superpotential with a single chiral superfield @xmath116 w()= ^2- ^3 [ sp ] gives the same f - term potential in the einstein frame as the starobinsky model which give vanishing tensor to scalar ratio @xmath117 for specific choice @xmath118 .
a slight change in the ratio @xmath119 can increase @xmath20 upto @xmath120 but it gives large @xmath121 . to get a no - scale sugra model corresponding to power law starobinsky model which can give a larger @xmath20
, we choose the minimal wess - zumino form of the superpotential ( [ sp ] ) and a minimal no - scale khler potential with an added @xmath122 term as k = -3 [ kp ] which can be motivated by a shift symmetry @xmath123 , @xmath124 with @xmath125 real , on the khler potential . here
@xmath126 is a modulus field and @xmath127 is a matter filed which plays the role of inflaton .
we calculate eq.([lv ] ) and eq.([lk ] ) for chosen khler potential ( [ kp ] ) and superpotential ( [ sp ] ) .
we assume that the @xmath126 field gets a vev @xmath128 and @xmath129 .
we write @xmath127 in terms of its real and imaginary parts @xmath130 . if we fix the imaginary part of the inflaton field @xmath127 to be zero then @xmath131 and for simplicity we replace @xmath132 by @xmath127 , the effective lagrangian in the einstein frame is given by _
e & = & |_|^2 + & & - ||^2 [ le1 ] to make the kinetic term canonical in the @xmath133 , we redefine the field @xmath127 to @xmath56 with = - [ chiphi ] assuming that @xmath134 and the large field limit @xmath135 during inflation , integrating eq.([chiphi ] ) gives ( ) [ phi1 ] now substituting from eq.([sp ] ) and eq.([phi1 ] ) into the potential term of eq.([le1 ] ) and simplifing , we get the effective scalar potential in the einstein frame as v & = & + & & ^2 [ v3 ] which , assuming @xmath136 , in the large field limit @xmath137 is equivalent to v [ v4 ] we see that in the limit @xmath138 and with the specific choice @xmath139 , the potential ( [ v3 ] ) reduces to starobinsky model potential .
we can now compare the power law potential ( [ u2 ] ) and sugra potential ( [ v4 ] ) for inflaton to show the relation between the parameters of the two model .
comparing the constant coefficient and exponent in the two potentials we get = [ beta1 ] and m^2 = ^-1 .
[ m1 ] numerically we find the sugra model parameter values ( in @xmath140 unit ) for three values of @xmath24 corresponding to running and without running of spectral index @xmath42 as depicted in fig.[fig2 ] and for starobinsky limit @xmath1 as shown in the table[[sugrapara ] ] .
.the sugra model parameter values ( in @xmath140 unit ) for three values of @xmath24 corresponding to running and without running of spectral index @xmath42 as depicted in fig.[fig2 ] and for starobinsky limit @xmath1 .
[ cols="<,<,<,<,<",options="header " , ]
in this section we will show that generalized non - minimally coupled inflation models @xmath141 @xcite with the quantum corrected @xmath8-potential @xcite can be reduced to the power law starobinsky form .
we consider the generalised non - minimal coupling @xmath141 and the quantum correction to quartic scalar potential @xmath142 into the action s_j & = & d^4x ( -- .
+ & & . + g^__+ ) [ action_j1 ] where the scalar field @xmath116 is the inflaton field .
since during inflation potential energy of the scalar field is dominant therefore kinetic term in the action @xmath143 can be neglected w.r.t .
potential , the action reduces to d^4x ( - -+)[action_j2 ] we may integrate out the scalar field through its equation of motion @xmath144 @xcite , which implies ( ) ^ [ phi1 ] using eq.([phi1 ] ) for @xmath116 , the action ( [ action_j2 ] ) reduces to power law starobinsky action d^4x ( ) ( r + ) where the two parameters @xmath24 and @xmath23 of the power law model are identified in terms of @xmath145 , @xmath146 , @xmath147 , @xmath148 and @xmath149 as = [ beta2 ] and m^2 = ( ) ^ [ m2 ] which for @xmath150 , i.e at @xmath151 , reduces to higgs inflation - starobinsky case @xmath152 . also with @xmath153 results of the references @xcite are obtained .
we have explored a generalization of the starobinsky model with a @xmath28 model and fit @xmath154 and @xmath23 from cmb data .
we find that to fit the amplitude @xmath155 and the spectral index @xmath42 ( with no running ) from observations @xcite we require @xmath90 and @xmath101 for @xmath156 but these parameter values gives large @xmath103 .
also we find that the parameters @xmath24 and @xmath23 deviates from the @xmath157 and @xmath151 of the original starobinsky model which could fit the amplitude and the spectral index but predicted very small value of @xmath158 .
when large running of the spectral index @xmath159 is considered we find that the best fit parameter values are @xmath89 and @xmath90 which gives @xmath91 .
this implies that the standard cosmological problems like horizon and flatness problems which require a minimum of @xmath96 e - foldings can not be solved with the power law generalization of the starobinsky model .
we have shown that the 5-parametes generalised non - minimal scalar - curvature coupled inflation models with the quantum correction to quartic scalar potential i.e. @xmath160 are actually equivalent to 2-parameter power law starobinsky model @xmath28 .
therefore we see that in terms of number of parameters the power law model is the most economical parametrization of the class of scalar - curvature models with quantum corrected @xmath8-potential . in this paper
we have given a sugra model for the general power law @xmath31 model by adding a @xmath32 term to the minimal no - scale khler potential and with a wess - zumino form of the superpotential @xmath33 .
in the limit @xmath34 the starobinsky limit @xmath1 is obtained .
we derive the relations between the two parameters of the power - law starobinsky model and the two parameters of our sugra model .
the interesting point about the generalisation is that the small deviations from the starobinsky limit of @xmath35 can produce value of @xmath161 which is consistent with the joint planck+bicep2+keck array upper bound on @xmath162 .
generalisations of the starobinsky model which can explain a possible larger value of @xmath20 are therefore of interest .
f. l. bezrukov and m. shaposhnikov , phys .
b * 659 * , 703 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0710.3755 [ hep - th ] ] .
p. a. r. ade _ et al .
_ [ bicep2 collaboration ] , arxiv:1403.3985 [ astro-ph.co ]
. p. a. r. ade _ et al .
_ [ bicep2 and planck collaborations ] , phys .
lett . * 114 * , no .
10 , 101301 ( 2015 ) [ arxiv:1502.00612 [ astro-ph.co ] ] .
p. a. r. ade _ et al .
_ [ planck collaboration ] , arxiv:1502.02114 [ astro-ph.co ] .
p. a. r. ade _ et al .
_ [ planck collaboration ] , arxiv:1502.01589 [ astro-ph.co ] .
w. n. colley and j. r. gott , mon . not .
soc . * 447 * , no . 2 , 2034 ( 2015 ) [ arxiv:1409.4491 [ astro-ph.co ] ] .
t. p. sotiriou and v. faraoni , rev .
phys . * 82 * , 451 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:0805.1726 [ gr - qc ] ] .
a. kehagias , a. moradinezhad dizgah and a. riotto , phys .
d * 89 * , 043527 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1312.1155 [ hep - th ] ] .
g. chakravarty , s. mohanty and n. k. singh , int .
j. mod .
d * 23 * , no . 4 , 1450029 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1303.3870 [ astro-ph.co ] ] .
j. joergensen , f. sannino and o. svendsen , arxiv:1403.3289 [ hep - ph ] .
a. codello , j. joergensen , f. sannino and o. svendsen , arxiv:1404.3558 [ hep - ph ] .
x. gao , t. li and p. shukla , arxiv:1404.5230 [ hep - ph ] . k. s. stelle , gen .
* 9 * , 353 ( 1978 ) j. d. barrow and s. cotsakis , phys .
b * 258 * , 299 ( 1991 )
. j. martin , c. ringeval and v. vennin , arxiv:1303.3787 [ astro-ph.co ] . l. sebastiani , g. cognola , r. myrzakulov , s. d. odintsov and s. zerbini , phys . rev .
d * 89 * , 023518 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1311.0744 [ gr - qc ] ] .
r. costa and h. nastase , arxiv:1403.7157 [ hep - th ] . y. -f .
cai , j. -o . gong and s.
pi , arxiv:1404.2560 [ hep - th ] .
m. b. einhorn and d. r. t. jones , jhep * 1003 * , 026 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:0912.2718 [ hep - ph ] ]
. s. ferrara , r. kallosh , a. linde , a. marrani and a. van proeyen , phys .
d * 82 * , 045003 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1004.0712 [ hep - th ] ] .
h. m. lee , jcap * 1008 * , 003 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1005.2735 [ hep - ph ] ] . s. ferrara , r. kallosh , a. linde , a. marrani and a. van proeyen , phys . rev .
d * 83 * , 025008 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1008.2942 [ hep - th ] ] .
s. cecotti , phys .
b * 190 * , 86 ( 1987 ) .
e. cremmer , s. ferrara , c. kounnas and d. v. nanopoulos , phys .
b * 133 * , 61 ( 1983 ) .
j. r. ellis , c. kounnas and d. v. nanopoulos , nucl .
b * 247 * , 373 ( 1984 ) .
a. b. lahanas and d. v. nanopoulos , phys .
rept . *
145 * , 1 ( 1987 ) .
j. ellis , d. v. nanopoulos and k. a. olive , phys .
* 111 * ( 2013 ) 111301 [ erratum - ibid .
* 111 * ( 2013 ) 12 , 129902 ] [ arxiv:1305.1247 [ hep - th ] ] .
r. kallosh and a. linde , jcap * 1306 * , 028 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1306.3214 [ hep - th ] ] .
s. cecotti , s. ferrara , m. porrati and s. sabharwal , nucl .
b * 306 * , 160 ( 1988 ) .
w. buchmuller , v. domcke and k. kamada , phys .
b * 726 * , 467 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1306.3471 [ hep - th ] ] .
s. ferrara , r. kallosh , a. linde and m. porrati , phys .
d * 88 * , no .
8 , 085038 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1307.7696 [ hep - th ] ] .
f. farakos , a. kehagias and a. riotto , nucl .
b * 876 * , 187 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1307.1137 ] .
s. ferrara , r. kallosh , a. linde and m. porrati , jcap * 1311 * , 046 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1309.1085 [ hep - th ] , arxiv:1309.1085 ] .
r. kallosh and a. linde , jcap * 1011 * , 011 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1008.3375 [ hep - th ] ] .
k. nakayama , f. takahashi and t. t. yanagida , phys .
b * 725 * , 111 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1303.7315 [ hep - ph ] ] . k. nakayama , f. takahashi and t. t. yanagida , jcap * 1308 * , 038 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1305.5099 , arxiv:1305.5099 [ hep - ph ] ] . t. li , z. li and d. v. nanopoulos , jcap * 1402 * , 028 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1311.6770 [ hep - ph ] ] . c. pallis , jcap
* 1404 * , 024 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1312.3623 [ hep - ph ] ] . s. cecotti and r. kallosh , jhep * 1405 * , 114 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1403.2932 [ hep - th ] ] .
s. ferrara , a. kehagias and a. riotto , arxiv:1403.5531 [ hep - th ] . c. pallis , arxiv:1403.5486 [ hep - ph ] .
k. harigaya and t. t. yanagida , phys .
b * 734 * , 13 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1403.4729 [ hep - ph ] ] .
j. ellis , m. a. g. garca , d. v. nanopoulos and k. a. olive , jcap * 1405 * , 037 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1403.7518 [ hep - ph ] ] . k. hamaguchi , t. moroi and t. terada , phys . lett .
b * 733 * , 305 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1403.7521 [ hep - ph ] ] .
r. kallosh , a. linde and a. westphal , arxiv:1405.0270 [ hep - th ] .
j. ellis , m. a. g. garcia , d. v. nanopoulos and k. a. olive , arxiv:1405.0271 [ hep - ph ] .
j. ellis , m. a. g. garcia , d. v. nanopoulos and k. a. olive , arxiv:1409.8197 [ hep - ph ] .
j. ellis , h. j. he and z. z. xianyu , arxiv:1411.5537 [ hep - ph ] .
g. a. diamandis , b. c. georgalas , k. kaskavelis , p. kouroumalou , a. b. lahanas and g. pavlopoulos , arxiv:1411.5785 [ hep - th ] . k. harigaya , m. kawasaki and t. t. yanagida , arxiv:1410.7163 [ hep - ph ] .
a. de felice and s. tsujikawa , living rev .
* 13 * , 3 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1002.4928 [ gr - qc ] ] .
s. i .
nojiri and s. d. odintsov , phys .
rept . * 505 * , 59 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1011.0544 [ gr - qc ] ] .
r. easther and h. peiris , jcap * 0609 * , 010 ( 2006 ) [ astro - ph/0604214 ] .
e. cremmer , b. julia , j. scherk , s. ferrara , l. girardello and p. van nieuwenhuizen , nucl .
b * 147 * , 105 ( 1979 ) . c. l. bennett , d. larson , j. l. weiland , n. jarosik , g. hinshaw , n. odegard , k. m. smith and r. s. hill _ et al .
_ , arxiv:1212.5225 [ astro-ph.co ] .
planck collaboration , [ arxiv:1303.5076 ] . | we consider a power law @xmath0 correction to einstein gravity as a model for inflation .
the interesting feature of this form of generalization is that small deviations from the starobinsky limit @xmath1 can change the value of tensor to scalar ratio from @xmath2 to @xmath3 .
we find that in order to get large tensor perturbation @xmath4 as indicated by bkp measurements , we require the value of @xmath5 thereby breaking global weyl symmetry . we show that the general @xmath6 model can be obtained from a sugra construction by adding a power law @xmath7 term to the minimal no - scale sugra khler potential .
we further show that this two parameter power law generalization of the starobinsky model is equivalent to generalized non - minimal curvature coupled models with quantum corrected @xmath8- potentials i.e. models of the form @xmath9 and thus the power law starobinsky model is the most economical parametrization of such models .
inflation , cmb , b - mode , starobinsky model , @xmath10-theory , supergravity |
ultra - cool dwarfs , low - mass objects of low temperature extending beyond the classical main sequence , have been identified in significant numbers from recent large optical and near infrared surveys , such as the deep near infrared survey @xcite , the sloan digital sky survey @xcite , and the two micron all - sky survey @xcite .
two new spectral type ( l , t ) have been added to classify those extremely cool objects , and these are now widely in use , with several hundred l and t dwarfs classified to date @xcite .
most stars classified as l and t dwarfs are relatively metal - rich , and associated with the galactic disk population .
one also expects the solar neighborhood to be host to ultra - cool members of the galactic halo ( population ii ) .
however pop ii stars are rare in the vicinity of the sun , where they account for roughly one out of every 200 stars .
conversely , one expects ultracool _ subdwarfs _ ( sdl , sdt ) to be equally rare . in any case , old metal - poor stars and brown dwarfs are expected to display a distinct spectral signature , making their identification straightforward . in stars of spectral type m
, metal depletion is known to result in a weakening of metal oxide bands , usually prominent in m stars @xcite .
m subdwarfs are thus organized following distinct classification sequences as subdwarfs ( sdm ) , extreme subdwarfs ( esdm ) , and ultrasubdwarfs ( usdm ) , depending of the magnitude of metal - depletion effects in their spectra @xcite .
note that spectroscopically confirmed m subdwarfs number only in the hundreds @xcite , compared with the tens of thousands of stars now classified as m dwarfs .
very few subdwarfs of spectral subtype sdm7 or later ( `` ultra - cool subdwarfs '' ) have been identified to date .
most have been discovered in follow - up spectroscopic surveys of faint stars with very large proper motions @xcite , others from the massive sloan digital sky survey spectroscopic database @xcite . extending the m subdwarf sequence to subtypes later than sdm7/esdm7/usdm7 has been straightforward as the metal - poor stars display the same weakening of the tio bands as document for earlier subtypes .
more challenging has been the identification of metal - poor stars beyond the spectral type m , in the range of surface temperature characteristic of the l and t stars , and designated as l and t subdwarfs ( sdl , sdt ) . the first star to be unambiguously identification as a subdwarf
spectral type l is 2mass 0532 + 8246 @xcite .
the optical spectrum had mixed spectral features corresponding to early and late l spectral types .
the nir spectrum have strong collision induced absorption ( cia ) due to molecules , giving a blue color similar to a t dwarf .
another star with similar features ( 2mass 1626 + 3925 ) was discovered by @xcite and also tentatively classified as sdl . a third object ,
the star lhs 1610 - 0040 , was initially claimed to be an early - type subdwarf @xcite , but further analysis has failed to substantiate the claim @xcite ; the star is now believed to be a peculiar late - type dwarf , possibly displaying anomalous metal abundances @xcite . in this paper
we present the discovery of another object with spectral characteristic consistent with a metal - poor `` l subdwarf '' .
the star was identified from the sloan digital sky survey spectroscopic database , and is found to be significantly cooler than all known m subdwarfs , but warmer than 2mass 0532 + 8246 and 2mass 1626 + 3925 . we examine the spectral characteristics and kinematics of the star .
the sloan digital sky survey obtains spectra from a variety of objects based on various color and magnitude selection cuts @xcite .
the survey is not complete in most of the star categories , as a limited number of fibers ( 640 ) are used in each of the sdss fields , and stellar targets are assigned only after the primary categories ( qsos , galaxies ) .
the spectra cover the full 3300-9500 wavelength range , which includes the main molecular features used to identify cool dwarfs and subdwarfs . the sdss second data release ( dr2 ) listed 13,379 spectra of sources identified as cool and ultra - cool stars ( spectral subtype m and later ) .
the dr2 covered a total survey area of 2627 square degrees or a little over 6.5% of the sky . in an attempt to detect ultra - cool l subdwarfs from this sample
, we have systematically examined the spectra form all stellar sources with very red optical - to - infrared color .
first , we identified all possible counterparts to the 13,379 late - type stars in the 2mass all - sky catalog of point source @xcite .
then we assembled spectra of all the stars with magnitude @xmath318 and color @xmath46.0 , which eliminating from the sample most objects with spectral subtypes m6 or earlier .
we visually inspected all the spectra in search of any star with a peculiar spectral energy distribution .
all spectra were found to be consistent with either late - type m dwarfs or l dwarfs , except for only one which clearly stood out from the group : the spectrum of the star .
sloan photometry shows to be very faint in the optical , but it has relatively bright counterparts in both the 2mass and denis infrared catalogs ; the object is clearly very red .
it is undetected in the digital sky survey blue ( iiiaj ) and red plates ( iiiaf ) , but has a counterpart on the infrared ( ivn ) plates and is thus registered in the supercosmos sky archive ( ssa ) .
data on this unusual object are recorded in table 1 .
the very red spectrum of is displayed in figure 1 .
the star shows many spectral features typical of late - m and l dwarfs , which confirms that it is a very cool object and not a background star affected by reddening . the dominant feature is a deep k
i doublet at 7700 , with strong pressure broadened wings , similar to what is observed in mid - type l dwarfs @xcite .
the spectrum also displays strong bands of crh and feh at 8600 and atomic lines of rbi , all typically observed in l dwarfs . paradoxically , also displays well - defined bands of cah and tio around 7050 , which are usually observed in m dwarfs and are normally absent in subtypes later than m9 , due to the condensation of oxides into dust grains .
indeed redward of 7500 the spectrum is strongly reminiscent of a late - type m dwarf .
overall , the spectrum does not fit within the standard m / l dwarf classification scheme @xcite , and appears to be a hybrid of m - type and l - type spectral features .
however , the spectrum is strikingly similar to the optical spectrum of the `` sdl '' star 2mass 1626 + 3925 @xcite , with prominent bands of tio and cah redward of 7500 in what looks in all other respect like an l dwarf .
the lingering presence of tio bands in those ultra - cool objects is interpreted as the signature of a metal - poor atmosphere in which dust formation is inefficient , and which maintains metal oxides in gaseous form even at very low temperature .
in any case , is too cool to be classified an m subdwarf . with @xmath5 , is significantly redder in the optical than the coolest known m subdwarfs @xcite . but again paradoxically , the optical - to - infrared colors are significantly bluer than in field l dwarfs , and the @xmath6 is more in line with subtype m6-m7 @xcite .
furthermore , the infrared colors of are unusual : with @xmath70.66 , is significantly bluer that any known field l dwarfs , which all have @xmath8 @xcite .
the same blue @xmath9 color is observed in the l subdwarf 2mass 0532 + 82 @xcite , which further suggest they are of a similar class . in 2mass 0532@xmath1082 the blue ir color is found to be due to a strong collision induced absorption ( cia ) band from . such unusually strong cia
is also suggested to be a consequence of low - metallicity @xcite , and results in a significant redistribution of the flux in the optical .
all in all , the photometry of also supports the idea that it a metal - depleted , ultra - cool dwarf .
& 12@xmath11 56@xmath12 37.1@xmath13 & sdss - dr6 + decl . &
-022452.5 & sdss - dr6 + @xmath14 & @xmath15 mas yr@xmath1 & + @xmath16 & @xmath17 mas yr@xmath1 & + u & [email protected] mag & sdss - dr6 + g & [email protected] mag & sdss - dr6 + r & [email protected] mag & sdss - dr6 +
i & [email protected] mag & sdss - dr6 + z & [email protected] mag & sdss - dr6 + extinction_r & 0.06 mag & @xcite + i & 18.02 mag & ssa - dss 2 + i & 18.36 mag & ssa - dss 2 + j & [email protected] mag & 2mass + h & [email protected] mag & 2mass + k@xmath19 & 15.44 : mag & 2mass + rv & -90@xmath1840&sdss - dr2 + distance & @xmath20 pc & + u & -17 & + v & -143 & + w & + 43 & + we found an unusually strong feh bandhead at 8692 , relative to crh at 8611 .
@xcite found that the crh band peaks at spectral type l7 and the feh band peaks at l2-l4 , consistent with a condensation temperature for crh about few hundred degrees cooler than for feh .
however crh and feh are equally strong at l0 , and crh / feh just marginally increase at l2 and the bands become equal again at l4 . then crh / feh increase again , but around l6 both feh and crh start to grow weaker . in sdss
j125637@xmath210224 , for the first time , we see feh stronger than crh . in 2mass
0532@xmath108246 , the l subdwarf identified by @xcite , crh and feh are of equal strength ; however one naturally expects a stronger crh band relative to feh in this very cool object ( @xmath22l7 ) , as observed also in denis 0205@xmath211159ab @xcite .
the most likely explanation for the larger feh in is that it reflects a low relative abundance of cr to fe , compared with solar metallicity l dwarfs .
indeed , in abundance analyses of halo stars of low metallicities ( [ fe / h]@xmath231.0 ) , cr has been found to be under - abundant by about 0.4 @xmath24 relative to fe @xcite . with all evidence pointing to an ultra - cool subdwarf , and based on the spectral energy distribution in the optical and the breadth of the k
i doublet , we classify as a mid - type l - subdwarf ( tentatively `` sdl4 '' ) although complete sequences of such objects would be required to formally establish spectral subtypes .
lrrr 14/03/1987 & 12 56 37.60 & -02 24 48.0 & serc i - ukst + 15/05/1996 & 12 56 37.27 & -02 24 50.7 & denis + 31/05/1997 & 12 56 37.22 & -02 24 50.3 & poss - ii n + 11/03/1999 & 12 56 37.14 & -02 24 51.6 & ukst + 11/02/1999 & 12 56 37.17 & -02 24 52.2 & 2mass + 30/05/2000 & 12 56 37.13 & -02 24 52.4 & sdss - dr2 + the denis and sdss images on which is identified are separated by @xmath25yr , which is sufficient to extract a proper motion .
we compared the denis and sdss positions of all the stars within @xmath26 of to determine any offset between the denis and sdss coordinate systems , and to estimate the astrometric errors .
for the background stars , we found mean offset consistent with a shift of -108 mas yr@xmath1 in r.a . and
-65 mas yr@xmath1 in decl . between the two epochs , with a 1-@xmath27 dispersion of 64 mas yr@xmath1 in both coordinates . for
we find a significantly larger offset which , after correcting for the mean offset , indicates a proper motion relative to background stars of [ @xmath28 = [ @xmath29 @xmath30 yr@xmath1 ( figure 2 ) .
radial velocity for is obtained directly from the sdss pipeline , where it is measured by cross - correlation with a template from a star of similar spectral energy distribution ( most likely an l dwarf ) , and is reduced to the heliocentric frame after correcting for earth s motion .
the quoted radial velocity is 90@xmath1840 .
we have verified this value by cross - correlating the spectrum with l3 and l5 templates @xcite , and obtained 127and 109respectively . in both cases
the cross correlation width is @xmath31 . without any parallax measurement ,
any distance estimate for should be considered with caution .
because of its unusual spectral energy distribution , it is unclear whether any of the color - magnitude relationships defined for m and l dwarfs should apply . assuming to be analogous to a mid - type l subdwarf
, we apply the color - magnitude relationships of @xcite and @xcite . for an l4 dwarf ,
the typical absolute j magnitude is @xmath32 , which we assume to be a reasonable estimate . in any case
, it seems unlikely that should be more luminous than a late - type m dwarf ( @xmath33 ) , and it should be somewhat more luminous than a late - type l dwarf ( @xmath34 ) .
based on these values , we estimate a spectroscopic distance of about 42 pc , with an actual distance possibly ranging between 21 pc and 79 pc .
we derive the space velocities , following the equations from @xcite , and find [ u , v , w]=[-16 , -142 , + 43]for the 42 pc distance .
if we vary the distance , we obtain somewhat different values , but the component of v remains consistently large ( @xmath35 km / s ) which rules out membership in the young disk , and again suggests that is relatively old .
the space velocities are more consistent with inner halo kinematics @xcite and are similar to the known m subdwarfs @xcite .
we compared the evolutionary models of @xcite for a age of 10 - 15gyrs , and found that for a temperature of about 1800k for l4 spectral type
@xcite the initial mass is just at the hydrogen burning limit .
there are only three l subdwarf known at present and the classification schemes based on colors and spectral line indexes is difficult based on three objects .
the theoretical spectrum synthesis models are in the preliminary stages , due to the complicated , dust chemistry and molecular formation at low temperatures .
this makes it difficult to formally characterize sdss j125637@xmath210224 , but evidence strongly suggest the star should be classified as a mid - type l subdwarf ( tentatively `` sdl4 '' ) .
this discovery adds up to the only two other objects also tentatively classified as `` sdl '' @xcite .
clear morphological difference between this object and normal l dwarfs shows it is possibility to detect such objects at low resolution
. also stands out in the nir , with bluer colors than solar metallicity l dwarfs . however
since those colors are similar to field m dwarfs , photometric identification would be a challenge without proper motion data .
proper motion surveys in the infrared and spectroscopic surveys in the optical and nir of extreme red objects would provide the best chance at identifying more objects of this kind and establishing proper classification sequences .
ts acknowledge the support from nsf with grant nsf ast-0705139 , nasa with grants nnx07ap14 g , the ucf - uf sri program , and university of florida .
this work is funded by the virtual observatory india , hosted by inter university centre for astronomy and astrophysics .
sl is supported grant ast-0607757 from the united states national science foundation .
ast we would like to thank sonali kale and the persistent systems private ltd .
for customizing the voplot utility to our need , which helped in choosing the samples for this study .
this research made use of sdss data archive , 2mass data archive and supercosmos science archive .
funding for the creation and distribution of the sdss archive has been provided by the alfred p. sloan foundation , the participating institutions , the nasa , the nsf , the us doe , the japanese monbukagakusho , and the max planck society .
the sdss is managed by the astrophysical research consortium ( arc ) for the participating institutions .
the participating institutions are the university of chicago , fermilab , the institute for advanced study , the japan participation group , johns hopkins university , los alamos national laboratory , the max planck institute for astronomy , the max planck institute for astrophysics , new mexico state university , the university of pittsburgh , princeton university , the us naval observatory , and the university of washington .
m. f. is supported in part by the grant - in - aid from the ministry of education .
the two micron all sky survey , is a joint project of the university of massachusetts and the infrared processing and analysis center / california institute of technology , funded by the national aeronautics and space administration and the national science foundation .
the supercosmos science archive is prepared and hosted by the wide field astronomy unit , institute for astronomy , university of edinburgh , which is funded by the uk particle physics and astronomy research council . | we report the discovery of a high proper motion l subdwarf ( @xmath0 yr@xmath1 ) in the sloan digital sky survey spectral database . the optical spectrum from the star sdss j125637 - 022452 has mixed spectral features of both late - m spectral subtype ( strong tio and cah at 7000 ) and mid - l spectral subtype ( strong wings of ki at 7700 , crh and feh ) , which is interpreted as the signature of a very low - mass , metal - poor star ( ultra - cool subdwarf ) of spectral type sdl .
the near infrared ( nir ) @xmath2 ) colors from 2mass shows the object to be significantly bluer compared to normal l dwarfs , which is probably due a strong collision induced absorption ( cia ) due to molecule .
this is consistent with the idea that cia from is more pronounced at low metallicities .
proper motion and radial velocity measurements also indicate that the star is kinematically `` hot '' and probably associated with the galactic halo population . |
spots on the host stars of transiting planets have generally been regarded as a nuisance .
they interfere with the determination of the planet s properties , by causing variations in the transit depth , producing chromatic effects that can be mistaken for atmospheric absorption , and causing anomalies in individual light curves when spots are occulted by the planet ( see , e.g. , rabus et al .
2009 , knutson et al .
2009 , carter et al . 2011 ) .
silva - valio ( 2008 ) pointed out that starspots may be helpful in one respect : observations of spot - occultation anomalies in two closely - spaced transits can be used to estimate the stellar rotation period . in effect , the planet is used to reveal the longitude of the spot during each transit . for the particular case of corot-2 , silva - valio et al .
( 2010 ) used this method to estimate the rotation period and study the distribution , shape and intensity of the spots .
likewise , dittmann et al . ( 2009 ) estimated the rotation period of tres-1 using starspot anomalies . in this paper
we show how the recurrence ( or not ) of starspot anomalies can also be used to test whether the stellar rotation axis is aligned with the planet s orbital axis . specifically , starspot anomalies are an alternative means of measuring or bounding @xmath1 , the angle between the sky projections of the angular momentum vectors corresponding to stellar rotation and orbital motion . the spot modeling of silva - valio et al . ( 2010 ) and dittmann et al . ( 2009 )
was restricted to values of @xmath1 that were permitted by prior observations of the rm effect , but as we will show , it is possible to obtain tighter constraints on @xmath1 using only spot anomalies .
as many authors have pointed out , measurements of stellar obliquities are important clues about the processes of planet formation , migration , and subsequent tidal evolution ( see , e.g. , queloz et al .
2000 ; ohta et al . 2005 ; winn et al .
2005 , 2010a ; fabrycky & winn 2009 ; triaud et al .
2010 ; morton and johnson 2011 ) . the other main method for measuring @xmath1 is the rossiter - mclaughlin ( rm ) effect , an anomalous doppler shift that is observed during transits due to the partial eclipse of the rotating star ( see , e.g. , queloz et al . 2000 ,
ohta et al . 2005 ,
gaudi & winn 2007 ) .
knowledge about spin - orbit alignment can also be gained from statistical studies of projected rotation rates ( schlaufman 2010 ) , asteroseismology ( wright et al . 2011 ) , and interferometry ( le bouquin et al .
2009 ) .
the particular system studied here is wasp-4b , a giant planet discovered by wilson et al .
( 2008 ) that transits a g7v star with a period of 1.34 days .
refined parameters for this system were presented by winn et al .
( 2009 ) , gillon et al .
( 2009 ) , and southworth et al .
observations of the rm effect by triaud et al .
( 2010 ) revealed the orbit to be prograde but gave only weak constraints on the projected obliquity : @xmath2 .
this paper is organized as follows . in section 2
we report on observations of four transits of wasp-4b . in section 3
we identify the anomalies that are interpreted as spot - crossing events , and use the remaining data to compute new system parameters . in section 4
we model the light curves by taking the star spot to be a circular disk with a lower intensity than the surrounding photosphere . in section 5
we determine @xmath1 using a simpler geometrical model , which does not make strong assumptions about the size or shape of the spots .
finally , in section 6 we discuss the results and possible future applications of this method .
lcccccc 2009 aug 02 & 260 & 369 & 56 & @xmath3 & 442 & 316 + 2009 aug 06 & 263 & 406 & 56 & @xmath4 & 452 & 315 + 2009 aug 10 & 266 & 365 & 55 & @xmath5 & 487 & 318 + 2009 sep 26 & 301 & 355 & 41 & @xmath6 & 588 & 373
we observed the transits of ut 2009 august 02 , 06 and 10 , and also 2009 september 26 , with the magellan ( baade ) 6.5 m telescope at las campanas observatory in chile .
we used the raymond and beverly sackler magellan instant camera ( magic ) and its site @xmath7 pixel ccd detector , with a scale of 0@xmath8069 pixel@xmath9 . at the start of each night
, we verified that the time stamps recorded by magic were in agreement with gps - based times to within one second . to reduce the readout time of the ccd from 23 s to 10 s
, we used the same technique used by winn et al .
( 2009 ) : we read out a subarray of @xmath10 pixels aligned in such a manner as to encompass wasp-4 and a nearby bright comparison star of similar color .
the telescope was strongly defocused to spread the light over many pixels , thereby allowing for longer exposures without saturation and reducing the impact of natural seeing variations . on each night
we obtained repeated @xmath11-band exposures of wasp-4 and the comparison star for about 5 hr bracketing the predicted transit time .
autoguiding kept the image registration constant to within 10 pixels over the course of each night . on the first , second , and fourth nights the skies were nearly cloud - free .
the third night was partly cloudy for a short duration , and the data from that time range were disregarded . in all cases
the observations bracketed the meridian crossing of wasp-4 and the maximum airmass was 1.5 .
we used custom idl procedures for overscan correction , trimming , flat - field division and photometry .
the flat field function for each night was calculated from the median of 80 - 100 @xmath11-band exposures of a dome - flat screen .
we performed aperture photometry of wasp-4 and the comparison star , along with annular sky regions surrounding each star .
then we divided the flux of wasp-4 by the flux of the comparison star .
trends in the out - of - transit ( oot ) data were observed and attributed to color - dependent differential extinction , for which a correction was applied in the form @xmath12 where @xmath11 is the airmass , @xmath13 is the observed magnitude difference between the target and comparison star , @xmath14 is the corrected magnitude difference , @xmath15 is a constant and @xmath16 is the coefficient of differential extinction .
table [ tbl : log ] is a summary of the observations , including the standard deviation of the oot flux , and the theoretical poisson noise .
table [ tbl : data ] gives the final time series .
figure [ fig : magtrans ] shows the light curves , along with four light curves published previously by southworth et al .
( 2009 ) .
[ fig : magtrans ]
the magellan light curves are well - fitted by a standard transit model except for two anomalies that are visible in the third dataset ( @xmath17 , @xmath18 hr from midtransit ) and the fourth dataset ( @xmath19 , @xmath20 hr ) .
each anomaly is interpreted as the temporary brightening of the system as the planet moves away from an unspotted portion of the stellar disk and onto a starspot . because the starspot is relatively cool and dark compared to the surrounding photosphere , the fractional loss of light due to the planet is temporarily reduced and the received flux slightly rises .
the amplitude of the anomalies ( about 0.1 - 0.2% ) corresponds to the fractional loss of light due to the starspot , i.e. , the fractional area of the starspot multiplied by the intensity contrast relative to the surrounding photosphere .
the first step in our analysis was to excise the anomalous data and use the rest of the data to update the basic system parameters .
for this purpose we fitted the four new data sets simultaneously with the two datasets presented by winn et al .
( 2009 ) , which were obtained with the same telescope and instrument .
we used mandel & agol s ( 2002 ) model with a quadratic limb - darkening law .
we assumed the orbit to be circular , since no eccentricity has been detected with any of the existing radial - velocity data ( wilson et al .
2008 , madhusudhan & winn 2009 , pont et al .
2011 ) or occultation data ( beerer et al .
there were 30 adjustable parameters : 6 midtransit times , 6 transit depths ( since unocculted starspots may cause variations in transit depth ) , 2 limb - darkening coefficients , the impact parameter ( @xmath21 ) , the stellar radius in units of the orbital distance ( @xmath22 ) , and 2 parameters per time series for the differential extinction corrections .
we refer the reader to the description by winn et al .
( 2009 ) for a detailed explanation of the parameter estimation method , which is based on the monte carlo markov chain technique .
the procedure takes correlated noise into account using the `` time - averaging '' method , in which the ratio @xmath23 is computed between the standard deviation of time - averaged residuals , and the standard deviation one would expect assuming white noise .
this method gave values of @xmath24 , 1.15 , 1.00 , and 1.39 for the four new light curves .
the best - fitting light curves are shown in figure [ fig : magtrans ] , and the results for the parameters are in tables [ tbl : individual ] and [ tbl : params ] .
all the results for the parameters agree with the previously published values .
the theoretical limb darkening coefficients obtained from claret ( 2004 ) are @xmath25 and @xmath26 , which are about 2@xmath27 away from our results .
the data prefer a smaller center - to - limb variation ( smaller @xmath28 ) than the tabulated limb - darkening law .
the six individual transit depths [ i.e. , the individual values of @xmath29 had a mean of 0.02386 and a standard deviation of 0.00029 , as compared to 1@xmath27 uncertainties of about 0.00014 .
this suggests that the transit depth is variable at the level of @xmath300.00025 or 1% .
such variations could be produced by starspots that are not necessarily on the transit chord . during each transit
, a different pattern of starspots may appear on the visible hemisphere of the star , causing variations in the fractional loss of light due to the planet .
since the light - curve anomalies implicate individual spots with a fractional loss of light of only 0.1 - 0.2% , the observed transit depth variations of @xmath301% would have to be caused by larger individual spots , or multiple spots .
the detection of the two anomalies in the magellan data prompted us to search for similar anomalies in previously published data .
the only sufficiently precise light curves we found were the single @xmath11-band light curve presented by gillon et al .
( 2009 ) , which does not display any obvious anomalies ; and the four @xmath31-band light curves by southworth et al .
( 2009 ) , two of which display anomalies similar to those we found in the magellan data .
all four of the southworth et al .
( 2009 ) light curves are shown in figure [ fig : magtrans ] . compared to the magellan data ,
the @xmath31-band data have a scatter that is 40% larger and a sampling rate three times slower , but anomalies can still be seen in the second dataset at @xmath32 hr and ( less obviously ) in the third dataset at @xmath33 hr . southworth et al .
( 2009 ) also noted these anomalies and the possibility that they were caused by starspot occultations .
to refine the transit ephemeris , and search for any departures from strict periodicity , we fitted the midtransit times with a linear function of epoch . before doing so we checked on the robustness of the uncertainties by employing an alternative technique , a bootstrap method based upon cyclic permutations of the residuals .
the differences between the two methods of estimating uncertainties were no greater than 20% . to be conservative ,
the ephemeris was computed using the larger of the two uncertainty estimates .
the uncertainties quoted in table [ tbl : params ] also represent the larger uncertainties .
figure [ fig : timings ] shows the observed minus calculated ( o@xmath34c ) midtransit times .
the best fit to the 6 magellan transit times gives @xmath35 with 4 degrees of freedom .
when we also included the other 9 data points reported by southworth et al .
( 2009 ) , to bjd@xmath36 . ]
we found @xmath37 with 13 degrees of freedom .
the probability of obtaining such a large @xmath38 with only random gaussian noise is only @xmath39 .
there appears to be a scatter of 5 - 10 seconds in excess of the measurement uncertainties .
one possibility is that the transiting planet s orbit is being perturbed by the gravity of another planet or satellite .
another possibility is that the light curves are affected by low - level starspot anomalies ( not visually recognized and excised ) which are biasing the estimates of the midtransit times .
the order - of - magnitude of the apparent timing anomalies caused by occulted spots can be estimated as follows .
we write the observed light curve as @xmath40 , where @xmath41 is the fractional loss of light due to the planet , and @xmath42 is the anomaly due to the occultation of a starspot . then the shift in the centroid of the light curve due to the spot anomaly is @xmath43 ( t - t_c)~dt}{\int \left [ 1 - \delta(t ) + \delta_s(t ) \right]~dt } \approx \frac{\int \delta_s(t)~(t - t_c)~dt}{\int [ 1-\delta(t ) ] ~dt } , \ ] ] where @xmath44 is the centroid of the idealized light curve .
the simplification of the numerator is due to definition of @xmath44 , and the simplification of the denominator assumes the perturbation is small .
the spot anomaly @xmath42 can be modeled as a triangular function of amplitude @xmath45 , duration @xmath46 and midpoint @xmath47 . for a spot smaller than the planet ,
the duration @xmath46 is approximately @xmath48 , where @xmath49 is the time between the ingress and egress midpoints . in such cases
@xmath50 , and eqn . (
[ eq : deltat_spot ] ) simplifies to @xmath51 and for a spot anomaly at ingress or egress ( @xmath52 ) , @xmath53 where the numerical factors are based on the observed wasp-4 parameters ( see the next two sections and table [ tbl : spots ] , giving the results of photometric spot modeling ) .
the spot anomalies we identified have @xmath54 ppm , but if the very same spot had been crossed on the limb of the star rather than near the center of the disk , the anomaly would have been reduced by a factor of a 3 - 5 due to limb darkening and geometrical foreshortening , giving @xmath55 300 - 500 ppm . such a small anomaly would not have been readily detected as a clear `` bump '' in our data , and according to eqn .
( [ eq : timing - noise ] ) it would have produced timing noise of order 5 - 10 s , which is consistent with the excess scatter observed in the calculated transit midpoints . and added a spot model @xmath42 based on the same spot parameters that were inferred from the actual data , but centered on the ingress rather than near midtransit .
we then added gaussian noise to mimic the actual data and fitted the resulting time series to derive the midtransit time .
the offset was 8 s. ] we conclude that timing offsets due to starspot anomalies are a plausible explanation for some ( and perhaps all ) of the excess timing noise that was observed . confirming the alternate hypothesis of gravitational perturbations would require the detection of a clear pattern in the residuals rather than just excess scatter ( see , e.g. , holman et al .
2010 ) , and is not possible with this relatively small number of data points .
table [ tbl : params ] gives the results for the reference epoch and orbital period , based on the 15-point fit , and with uncertainties based on the internal errors of the linear fit multiplied by @xmath56 , where @xmath57 is the number of degrees of freedom .
lccc 2454697.710091 & 1.00020 & 0.00067 & 1.083 + 2454697.710564 & 1.00047 & 0.00067 & 1.082 + 2454697.711039 & 0.99977 & 0.00067 & 1.081 lccc 2008 aug 19 & @xmath58 & @xmath59 & @xmath60 + 2008 oct 09 & @xmath61 & @xmath62 & @xmath63 + 2009 aug 02 & @xmath64 & @xmath65 & @xmath66 + 2009 aug 06 & @xmath67 & @xmath68 & @xmath69 + 2009 aug 10 & @xmath70 & @xmath71 & @xmath72 + 2009 sep 26 & @xmath73 & @xmath74 & @xmath75 lcc reference epoch [ bjd@xmath36 ] & @xmath77 & @xmath78 + orbital period [ days ] & @xmath79 & @xmath80 + planet - to - star radius ratio , @xmath81 & @xmath82 & @xmath83 + orbital inclination , @xmath84 [ deg ] & @xmath85 & @xmath86 , @xmath87 + scaled semimajor axis , @xmath88 & @xmath89 & @xmath90 , @xmath91 + transit impact parameter , @xmath92 & @xmath93 & @xmath94 , @xmath95 + transit duration [ hr ] & @xmath96 & @xmath97 , @xmath98 + transit ingress or egress duration [ hr ] & @xmath99 & @xmath100 , @xmath101 + linear limb - darkening coefficient , @xmath102 & @xmath103 & @xmath104 + quadratic limb - darkening coefficient , @xmath105 & @xmath106 & @xmath107 + mass of the star , m@xmath108 [ m@xmath109 & @xmath110 & @xmath111 + semimajor axis [ au ] & @xmath112 & @xmath113 + radius of the star , @xmath114 [ r@xmath109 & @xmath115 & @xmath116 , @xmath117 + radius of the planet , @xmath118 [ r@xmath119 & @xmath120 & @xmath121
a central question for our study is whether each pair of starspot anomalies was caused by occultation of the _ same _ spot .
one issue is whether a spot could last long enough to be occulted twice .
the two anomalies seen in our data were separated in time by 47 days , and the two anomalies in the southworth et al .
( 2009 ) data were separated by 31 days . on the sun , individual spots last from hours to months , with a lifetime proportional to size following the so - called gw rule ( gnevyshev 1938 , waldmeier 1955 ) : @xmath122 , where @xmath123 is the maximum spot size in msh ( micro - solar hemispheres ) , @xmath49 is the lifetime in days , and @xmath124 ( petrovay & van driel - gesztelyi 1997 ) .
the amplitudes of the wasp-4 anomalies are @xmath301500 ppm , suggesting that the spot area is of order 2000 msh and giving a gw lifetime of 180 days .
however , the application of this rule to wasp-4 requires an extrapolation , since the implied spot size is several times larger than most sunspots ( solanki 2003 ) .
henwood et al .
( 2010 ) studied larger spots , and found them to follow the same rule , but with a relatively small sample size .
from this perspective it is plausible that each pair of anomalies represents two passages of the planet over the same spot .
however , the spot that was observed with magellan is not likely to be the same spot that was observed by southworth et al .
( 2009 ) because those two groups of observations were conducted one year apart .
this conclusion is borne out by the modeling described below .
another issue is whether the _ amplitudes _ and _ durations _ of both events in a pair are consistent with passage over a single spot .
a photometric spot model will make specific predictions regarding the observable anomalies , based on the stellar limb - darkening law , the geometrical foreshortening of the spots and the orbital velocity of the planet .
we are reluctant to take such a model too seriously , given the unknown shape of the spot and the potential for time variations in its shape and intensity . in the case of the sun , spots reach their maximum size within a few days and then shrink with time at a rate of about 30 msh day@xmath9 ( solanki 2003 ) .
another complication is that spots can migrate to different latitudes , although for the sun this migration amounts to fewer than 5 degrees ( henwood et al .
nevertheless we used a model with static spot properties to perform a consistency check on the hypothesis that the same spot was occulted twice .
the orientation of the star was parameterized by @xmath1 , the sky - projected spin - orbit angle , and @xmath125 , the inclination of the stellar rotation axis with respect to the line of sight , using the coordinate system of ohta et al .
the visible hemisphere of the star was pixellated with a @xmath126 cartesian grid ( enough to allow for fast computations with tolerable discretization error ) , and the pixels were assigned intensities using a quadratic limb - darkening law .
the planet s trajectory was computed from the known orbital parameters , and zero intensity was assigned to those pixels covered by the planet s silhouette .
the spot was taken to be a circle of lower intensity on the stellar photosphere , and its geometrical foreshortening was taken into account in assigning intensities to the affected pixels .
the intensity distribution within the spot was taken to be a gaussian function with a truncation radius equal to three times the standard deviation of the distribution .
( we also tried modeling spots with a constant intensity , which gave qualitatively similar results . )
the model had seven adjustable parameters : the stellar orientation angles @xmath1 and @xmath125 , the rotation period of the spot , the spot intensity and radius , and the initial longitude and latitude of the spot at the time of the first anomaly . for simplicity we studied the well - aligned case @xmath127 , @xmath128 .
the best - fitting model is displayed in figure [ fig : spots ] .
the amplitudes and durations of the anomalies are fitted well , and the optimized rotation period is 22.2 days , i.e. , the second anomaly was observed slightly more than two complete rotations after the first anomaly .
this is within the broad range of periods , 20 - 40 days , that is expected for a main - sequence g7 star ( see , e.g. , barnes 2007 , schlaufman 2010 ) .
in addition , this value for the rotation period agrees with the value that can be estimated from the sky - projected rotation rate @xmath129 and the stellar radius @xmath114 according to @xmath130 where we have used @xmath131 km s@xmath9 from the work of triaud et al .
( 2010 ) , and @xmath132 @xmath133 from our analysis . in the best - fitting model
, the spot s intensity profile has a maximum contrast of 32% with respect to the surrounding photosphere .
modeling both the photosphere and the spot as blackbodies , and using @xmath134 k for the photosphere ( wilson et al .
2010 ) , the corresponding spot temperature is 4900 k. the spot radius is @xmath135 , implying that it is significantly smaller than the planet ( @xmath136 ) . the spot radius and intensity contrast are highly correlated ; only their product is well determined .
the fit seems reasonable in all respects and correctly predicts the nondetection of anomalies during the first and second nights of observations .
other local minima in @xmath38 can be found involving a larger number of rotations between anomalies , with @xmath137 or @xmath138 days , but these give @xmath139 relative to the global minimum and rotation periods outside of the expected range . a similar analysis of the southworth et al .
( 2009 ) data shows that the spot is about the same size , and gives possible rotation periods of 25.5 days and 14.0 days , of which the former is closer to the magellan result and to the expected value .
we concluded from this exercise that each dataset ( ours and that of southworth et al .
2009 ) is consistent with a single spot and a star that is well - aligned with the orbit .
we decided not to pursue the implications of this photometric starspot model further , given that the simplifying assumptions ( such as a circular , unchanging spot ) lead to more significant uncertainties than the photometric uncertainties .
in particular , the results for @xmath1 and its uncertainty would depend on the assumed shape of the spot , because the planet trajectories with @xmath140 could graze the spot at different angles during each encounter .
instead we used a simplified model constrained almost exclusively by the timings of the anomalies , as described in the next section .
[ fig : spots ]
the recurrence of the anomaly at a later phase of the transit favors the configuration where the orbital angular momentum and the axis of rotation of the star are aligned , because in such a situation the trajectories of the spot on the surface and the planet would be almost parallel .
the purpose of the geometric model described in this section is to quantify this statement , based only the observed times of the anomalies , without attempting to model complicated and largely irrelevant aspects of the situation such as the full range of possibilities for the spot size , intensity , and possible nonuniform motions . to measure the times and gain an appreciation of the statistical significance of each feature
, we used a simple triangular model for each anomaly .
the triangular model is overplotted upon the residuals in figure [ fig : magtrans ] .
table [ tbl : spots ] gives the results for the parameter values .
as shown in the last few rows of that table , the first three spot anomalies ( the two magellan anomalies , and the first southworth et al .
anomaly ) are detected with relatively high confidence .
the spot model includes 3 extra free parameters , and improves the fit by @xmath141 , 34 and 25 , for each of the first three transits , as compared to the best - fitting model with no spots .
the fourth is marginal , with @xmath142 .
was computed assuming flux uncertainties that have been enlarged by the red - noise factor @xmath23 .
the number of data points and number of degrees of freedom for each case are given in table [ tbl : spots ] .
] the weaker amplitude of the fourth event is consistent with the spot model , as the anomaly occurred near the egress where limb darkening and geometrical foreshortening both reduce the amplitude of the photometric effect .
however , it remains possible that the `` anomaly '' is a spurious statistical detection .
next we defined a likelihood function for @xmath1 and @xmath125 , given the observed times of anomalies as well as the observed time ranges of nondetections .
the basic idea is to assume that the spot is located within the planet s shadow at the time of the first anomaly , and then compute the position of the spot at the other relevant times for a given choice of the parameters @xmath143 ( a purely geometric calculation ) .
the model is rewarded for producing spot - planet coincidences at the appropriate times , and penalized for producing coincidences at inappropriate times .
each of the two spots the one observed in 2008 , and the one observed in 2009is given an independent value of @xmath144 to allow for possible differential rotation or peculiar motions of the spots ( see section [ sec : discussion ] for discussion ) .
a further constraint is imposed to enforce agreement with the spectroscopic determination of @xmath145 by triaud et al .
mathematically , we used a likelihood @xmath146 with @xmath147 ^ 2 + { \rm ndp } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath148 is the index specifying one of the two anomalies , and @xmath149 is the distance on the stellar disk between the center of the planet and the center of the spot .
thus , high likelihoods are assigned to spot - planet coincidences within 0.5 @xmath118 at the correct times .
this factor is based on the estimation of the size of the spot given by the photometric model , and it would require modification if the spot were bigger than the planet .
the factor ndp is the nondetection penalty : models that produce spot - planet coincidences at times when they were not observed are ruled out by incrementing @xmath38 by 1000 ( an arbitrary number chosen to be large enough to exact a severe penalty ) . based on our studies of the amplitude of the spots with the more sophisticated model of section 3 ,
the nondetection penalty was only applied for coincidences within 0.9 @xmath114 of the center of the stellar disk . for the outer 0.1 @xmath114 ( near the limb )
the combined effects of limb - darkening and foreshortening would have made such an anomaly undetectable .
we used an mcmc algorithm , with the gibbs sampler and metropolis - hastings criterion , to sample from the posterior probability distribution for the parameters , with uniform priors on @xmath1 and @xmath150 ( i.e. , isotropic in the stellar orientation ) .
we restricted @xmath151 , given the finding of triaud et al .
( 2010 ) that the orbit is prograde , based on the rossiter - mclaughlin effect .
given our finding of multiple minima in the photometric model ( section [ sec : model - photometric ] ) , we also performed a dense grid search in the two - dimensional space of @xmath152 and @xmath153 .
this identified four relevant local minima with periods @xmath15410 days ( smaller periods were rejected as unlikely for a star of the observed mass and age ) .
a markov chain was initiated from each of these 4 minima .
[ fig : chi2plots ] [ fig:3dsphere ] figure [ fig : chi2plots ] shows the 2-d probability distribution for @xmath1 and @xmath125 for all four possible solutions , after marginalizing over the rotation periods .
the first thing to notice is that small values of @xmath1 are favored in all cases , while @xmath125 is poorly constrained .
the completely aligned case ( upper left corner of the panel ) is the global minimum , with @xmath155 , but none of the other solutions can be firmly ruled out . these results can be understood by visualizing the various solutions , as we have done in figure [ fig:3dsphere ] .
the four different configurations shown in that figure correspond to the four local minima .
( one of the minima actually gave a bimodal distribution , as shown in the upper right panel of figure [ fig : chi2plots ] ; for that case figure [ fig:3dsphere ] shows the small-@xmath125 solution . )
the upper right panel shows the completely aligned case .
this type of solution is always possible whenever two anomalies from the same spot are observed at different transit phases , unless it is ruled out by the nondetection of anomalies that should be present in other light curves . in our case ,
the model predicts an anomaly during the ingress of the @xmath156 transit , and also right at the ingress of the @xmath157 transit .
neither of these anomalies would have been detectable in our data .
the other three panels show how an appropriate combination of @xmath1 and @xmath125 causes the trajectory of the spot to move outside the transit chord and then back inside in time for the second anomaly .
the well - aligned case is favored not only because of the lower @xmath38 , but also because the corresponding rotation periods ( 22 and 26 days ) are within the expected range of 2040 days , as opposed to the shorter periods associated with the other solutions .
one could also argue that for any observational campaign involving only a few transits , the detection of multiple spot anomalies is _ a priori _ more likely for a well - aligned system than for a misaligned system , because in the former case the spot spends a much larger fraction of the time on the transit chord . for simplicity ,
though , we report a determination of @xmath1 based on the simple concatenation of all the markov chains corresponding to the four local minima , giving @xmath158 degrees .
lcccc amplitude ( ppm ) & 1790 & 1470 & 2400 & 1190 + duration ( hours ) & 0.34 & 0.38 & 0.56 & 0.54 + time of event ( bjd@xmath36 ) & 2455053.7658 & 2455100.6288 & 2454701.7938 & 2454732.6172 + epoch @xmath159 & 266 & 301 & 3 & 26 + rms residual ( ppm ) & 523 & 580 & 765 & 722 + number of data points & 365 & 355 & 126 & 88 + @xmath38 ( @xmath57 ) for no - spot model & 435 ( 358 ) & 220 ( 348 ) & 102 ( 119 ) & 69.4 ( 81 ) + @xmath38 ( @xmath57 ) with spot model & 350 ( 355 ) & 186 ( 345 ) & 77 ( 116 ) & 61.4 ( 78 ) + @xmath160 & 85 & 34 & 25 & 8
in this paper , we report the observations of four new transits of the wasp-4b planet , observations that lead to a significant improvement on the errors of the system parameters and the transit ephemerides .
short - lived photometric anomalies , transit timing variations and transit depth variations were all observed , all of which can potentially be explained by the effects of starspots . in particular we have interpreted the photometric anomalies as occultations of starspots by the planet . we have described a simple method for assessing the orientation of a star relative to the orbit of its transiting planet through the analysis of spot occultations .
this method has certain advantages and disadvantages compared to observations of the rm effect , the main method for such determinations . on the positive side ,
the spot method works well for slowly - rotating stars , for which the rm amplitude is smallest .
the spot method also has no particular problem with low impact parameters , unlike the rm effect .
these two factors help to explain why the spot method gives tighter constraints on @xmath1 than did the rm observations of triaud et al .
( 2010 ) , for the case of wasp-4 .
the spot method requires that the star be moderately active .
this too is complementary to rm observations , which rely on precise doppler spectroscopy and are hindered by stellar activity .
in addition , the spot method is photometric rather than spectroscopic , and as such it does not require a high - resolution spectrograph nor special efforts to achieve accurate radial - velocity precision . on the negative side
, many transits must be observed to have a reasonable chance of detecting multiple anomalies , and to be sure that multiple anomalies are caused by a single spot , rather than distinct spots . in the case of wasp-4 ,
a few more transit observations during the summers of either 2008 or 2009 could have allowed for a more secure validation of the single - spot hypothesis , and removed the four - way degeneracy of the resulting constraints on the stellar orientation .
furthermore , spots are not well - behaved deterministic entities : they have irregular shapes that form and dissolve , governed by poorly understood physical principles .
regarding that subject , it is interesting to note that all four of the solutions shown in figure [ fig : chi2plots ] involve slightly but significantly different rotation periods for the spot seen in 2008 as compared to the one seen in 2009 .
this could be a sign of differential rotation .
assuming wasp-4 has @xmath127 and has the same differential rotation profile as the sun , spots on the top and bottom of the transit chord would have periods differ by 10% , as compared to the 10 - 15% differences seen in our model results .
thus , differential rotation is a realistic possibility .
another contributing factor may be peculiar motions of spots , i.e. , motions of the spot relative to the surrounding photospheres .
on the sun , individual spots at a given latitude are observed to have rotation periods differing by a few percent ( rudjak et al .
2005 ) . for wasp-4 ,
the small value of @xmath1 is further evidence that this is a low - obliquity system .
such findings have been interpreted as constraints on the process of planet migration : the mechanism that brought this gas giant planet from its birthplace ( presumably a few au ) to its close - in orbit .
low obliquities are suggestive of disk migration , in which the orbit shrinks due to tidal interactions with the protoplanetary gas disk ; while large obliquities would favor theories in which close - in orbits results from gravitational interactions with other bodies followed by tidal dissipation .
the complicating factor of tidal reorientation was thought to be negligible , but this possibility was recently raised by winn et al .
( 2010a ) as a possible explanation for the tendency for high - obliquity stars to be `` hot '' and low - obliquity stars to be `` cool '' , with a boundary at around 6250 k. here we will not remark further on the theory underlying this hypothesis , but simply note that wasp-4 conforms to the empirical pattern , as a cool and low - obliquity system .
looking forward , an opportunity exists to implement this method for other systems using the data from the _ corot _ and _ kepler _ space missions .
the corot-2 system in particular has a highly spotted star ( see , e.g. , silva - valio et al .
2010 , silva - valio & lanza 2011 ) for which our method might be applicable , although the spots are so numerous and influential on the light curve that more complex models may be necessary .
kepler _ employs a 1 m space telescope to monitor 150,000 stars with photon - limited precision down to level of @xmath3010 parts per million ( borucki et al .
2010 , 2011 ) .
the data released in february 2011 displays a limiting precision of about 10 ppm in 6 hr combined integrations at _ kepler _ magnitude 10 ( approximately @xmath161 ) , and a limiting precision of about 100 ppm for a more typical target star magnitude of 15 .
besides high precision , the great advantage of the space missions is nearly - continuous data collection . for a system resembling wasp-4 , _ kepler
_ would observe hundreds of consecutive transits , resulting in much greater power to track individual spots .
furthermore , the brightness variations observed outside of transits will allow for an independent estimate of the stellar rotation period , as well as additional constraints on spot longitudes .
a potentially serious problem with the application to _ kepler _ is that most stars are observed with a cadence of 30 min , which may be too long to pin down the times of starspot anomalies with the required precision .
a subset of targets are observed at the much more favorable cadence of 1 min .
already there is one transit - hosting star in the _ kepler _ field , hat - p-11 , that is being observed with 1 min cadence and will assuredly yield interesting results , as @xmath1 was found to be approximately @xmath162 by winn et al .
( 2010b ) and hirano et al .
( 2011 ) , and the star has long - lived , sizable spots ( bakos et al . 2010 ) .
we thank the anonymous referee for a comprehensive and helpful report on the manuscript .
we gratefully acknowledge support from the nasa origins program through awards nnx09ad36 g and nnx09ab33 g , and the mit class of 1942 . r.s . received financial support through the `` la caixa '' fellowship grant for post - graduate studies , caixa destalvis i pensions de barcelona `` la caixa '' , barcelona , spain .
j.a.c . acknowledges support for this work by nasa through hubble fellowship grant hf-51267.01-a awarded by the space telescope science institute , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc .
, for nasa under contract nas 5 - 26555 . | we present photometry of 4 transits of the exoplanet wasp-4b , each with a precision of approximately 500 ppm and a time sampling of 40 - 60 s. we have used the data to refine the estimates of the system parameters and ephemerides . during two of the transits we observed a short - lived , low - amplitude anomaly that we interpret as the occultation of a starspot by the planet .
we also found evidence for a pair of similar anomalies in previously published photometry .
the recurrence of these anomalies suggests that the stellar rotation axis is nearly aligned with the orbital axis , or else the star spot would not have remained on the transit chord . by analyzing the timings of the anomalies we find the sky - projected stellar obliquity to be @xmath0 degrees .
this result is consistent with ( and more constraining than ) a recent observation of the rossiter - mclaughlin effect .
it suggests that the planet migration mechanism preserved the initially low obliquity , or else that tidal evolution has realigned the system .
future applications of this method using data from the _ corot _ and _ kepler _ missions will allow spin - orbit alignment to be probed for many other exoplanets . |
modes of fundamental significance to nonlinear optics @xcite and plasmonics plas1,plas3,plas4,plas5,plas6,plas7,plas8,plas9,marini , korea are dissipative spatial solitons that result from the simultaneous balance among diffraction , self - focusing nonlinearity , loss , and compensating gain .
stability is a crucially important issue in the theoretical analysis of dissipative solitons .
an obvious necessary condition for the stability of localized modes is the stability of the zero background around them .
the basic complex ginzburg - landau ( cgl ) equation , which includes the bandwidth - limited linear gain and nonlinear loss acting on a single field , is unable to produce stable dissipative solitons , since the action of the linear gain on the zero background makes it unstable . on the other hand , dissipative solitons can be fully stabilized in systems of linearly coupled cgl equations @xcite modeling dual - core waveguides , with the linear gain and loss acting in different cores marini , dual1,dual2,dual3,dual4,dual5 , including the @xmath0-symmetric version of the system that features the balance between the gain and loss @xcite .
stable solitons can also be generated by a single cgl equation with cubic gain sandwiched " between linear and quintic losses , which may be realized in optics as a combination of linear amplification and power - dependent absorption cq1,cq2,cq3,cq4,cq5,cq6,cqgle1,cqgle2,cqgle3,cqgle4,cqgle5 .
another method for creating stable localized modes makes use of linear gain applied at a hot spot " ( hs , i.e. a localized amplifying region embedded into an ordinary lossy waveguide @xcite or a bragg grating @xcite ) .
models with multiple hss spotsexact1,spots1,spots2,spots3,spotsexact2 , and similar extended amplifying structures @xcite , have been studied as well .
hss can be built by implanting gain - producing dopants into a narrow segment of the waveguide @xcite , or , alternatively , by focusing an external pump beam at the designated position of the hs in a uniformly - doped waveguide .
in addition to models with the localized direct ( phase - insensitive ) gain , systems including the localization of parametric gain was developed as well @xcite .
dissipative solitons can be stably pinned to the hs due to the balance between the local gain and uniform loss in the bulk waveguide . for narrow hss modeled by the delta - functional distribution of the gain , solutions for the pinned dissipative solitons
are available in analytical form hsexact , spotsexact1,spotsexact2 .
furthermore , models with mutually balanced gain and loss applied in the form of @xmath1-functions at separated points @xcite , or at a single location , in the form of a gain - loss dipole described by the derivative of the @xmath1-function thawatchai , make it possible to find solution for @xmath0-symmetric solitons pinned to these points .
other one- and two - dimensional ( 1d and 2d ) hs - pinned modes , including stable vortices fed by the gain confined to an annular - shaped area @xcite , can be found numerically @xcite . while dissipative solitons in uniform media are always unstable against the blowup in the absence of the higher - order ( quintic ) nonlinear losses kramer , ml , it is worthy to note a counter - intuitive result @xcite demonstrating that _ stable _ dissipative localized modes in uniform linearly - lossy media may be supported by _ unsaturated _ localized cubic gain alone .
stable dissipative solitons were also predicted in a setting that combines the uniformly - distributed linear gain in the @xmath2-dimensional space and nonlinear loss growing from the center to periphery faster than @xmath3 , where @xmath4 is the radial coordinate @xcite .
the class of models with the localized gain includes lattice systems . in ref .
@xcite , the 1d model was introduced for a linear lossy lattice with a single or two amplified ( active ) sites embedded into it , which represent the hss in the discrete setting .
it was assumed that the nonlinearity was carried solely by the same active sites .
this system , which may be considered as a variety of discrete cgl equations discrcgl1,discrcgl2,discrcgl3,discrcgl4,discrcgl5,discrcgl6,discrcgl7,discrcgl8,discrcgl9,discrcgl10,discrcgl11 , can be implemented in the experiment using arrays of optical waveguides @xcite or arrayed plasmonic waveguides plasmon - array1,plasmon - array2,plasmon - array3 . in particular , it suggests possibilities for selective excitation of particular core(s ) in the arrayed waveguides , if the system is uniformly doped , but only the selected cores are pumped by an external laser beam . in ref .
@xcite , discrete solitons pinned to the hs in the lattice system were found in an analytical form , similar to the soliton solutions available in the discrete linear schrdinger equation with embedded nonlinear elements @xcite , and the stability of the localized models was investigated by means of numerical methods .
the present work aims to extend the analysis for the 2d lattice system , with one or two active nonlinear sites embedded into the linear lossy bulk lattice .
the experimental realization of such a 2d medium is also possible in nonlinear optics , using waveguiding arrays permanently written in bulk silica @xcite .
an essential distinction from the 1d counterpart @xcite mentioned above is that 2d localized lattice modes can not be found analytically , even if only a single nonlinear site is embedded into the linear matrix .
nevertheless , we demonstrate that semi - analytical solutions can be obtained for truncated ( finite - size ) lattices .
the paper is organized as follows .
the discrete 2d cgl equation is introduced in sec . [
sec : gov ] .
section [ sec : trun ] presents semi - analytical results for the truncated lattices .
results of the linear - stability analysis for the hs - pinned lattice solitons against small perturbations are reported in sec .
[ sec : stab ] . in sec .
[ sec : onset ] we extend the stability analysis , considering the crucially important issue of the onset of the zero - solution instability .
a brief consideration of the double - hs system is presented in sec .
[ sec : dual ] .
the paper is concluded by sec .
[ sec : con ] .
as said above , we consider the 2d generalization of the 1d lattice model introduced in ref .
@xcite : @xmath5 \delta _ { m,0}\delta _ { n,0}u_{m , n}\ ; , \label{eq : gl}\end{gathered}\]]where @xmath6 , @xmath7 , @xmath8 , ... are discrete coordinates on the lattice , @xmath9 and @xmath10 are the kronecker s symbols , and the coefficient of the linear coupling between adjacent cores is scaled to unity .
further , @xmath11 is the linear loss in the bulk lattice , @xmath12 and @xmath13 account for the linear gain and linear potential applied at the hs site ( @xmath14 ) , while @xmath15 and @xmath16 account for the kerr nonlinearity and nonlinear loss / gain ( for @xmath17 ) acting at the hs . in optics , the 2d discrete equation , as well as its 1d counterpart , can be derived by means of well - known methods chr , discrcgl1,discrcgl2,discrcgl3,discrcgl4,discrcgl5,discrcgl6,discrcgl7,discrcgl8,discrcgl9,discrcgl10,discrcgl11,review . in the application to 2d arrays of plasmonic waveguides , which can be built as a set of metallic nanowires embedded into a bulk dielectric plasmon - array1,plasmon - array2,plasmon - array3 , eq .
( [ eq : gl ] ) can be derived in the adiabatic approximation , with the exciton field eliminated in favor of the photonic one .
it is relevant to mention that the well - known _ staggering transformation _
@xcite , @xmath18 , where the asterisk stands for the complex conjugate , simultaneously reverses the signs of @xmath13 and @xmath15 , thus rendering the self - focusing and defocusing signs of the nonlinearity , which correspond to @xmath19 and @xmath20 , respectively , mutually convertible .
this circumstance is essential , in particular , for modeling arrays of plasmonic waveguides , where the intrinsic excitonic nonlinearity is always self - repulsive .
below , we fix the signs of @xmath13 and @xmath15 by setting @xmath21 , i.e. the corresponding linear potential at the hs is _ attractive _ , while @xmath15 may be positive ( self - focusing ) , negative ( self - defocusing ) , or zero . unless @xmath22 , this coefficient is normalized to be @xmath23 .
these two cases are considered separately below , along with the case of @xmath22 , when the nonlinearity is represented solely by the cubic dissipation localized at the hs .
we seek solutions to eq .
( [ eq : gl ] ) for stationary localized modes with real propagation constant @xmath24 as @xmath25outside of the hs site , @xmath14 , eq .
( [ eq : gl ] ) gives rise to the linear stationary equation,@xmath26which , unlike its 1d counterpart ( cf .
@xcite ) , does not admit exact analytical solutions .
an approximate solution can be constructed on a truncated lattice . the simplest version of the truncation is shown in fig .
[ sketch ] , where four independent amplitudes obeying eq .
( [ u ] ) are defined : @xmath27 ( at the center ) , @xmath28 ( in the first rhombic layer surrounding the center ) , and @xmath29 ( two independent amplitudes in the second rhombic layer ) .
the amplitudes in all other layers are neglected : @xmath30 . at @xmath31 , the so truncated eq .
( [ u ] ) yields : @xmath32where central amplitude @xmath27 is defined to be real , and the complex coefficient is @xmath33 the remaining nonlinear equation ( [ eq : gl ] ) at the hs site , @xmath14 , reduces to a complex equation relating real peak intensity @xmath34 and propagation constant @xmath24:@xmath35which can be solved numerically .
subsequently , the amplitudes in the surrounding layers are obtained from eq .
( [ 3210 ] ) .
the accuracy of the truncated - lattice analysis can be improved by including more rhombic layers in the calculation . although the respective version of eqs .
( [ 3210 ] ) and ( [ 0 ] ) become more complicated , they are still easy to solve numerically . table [ tab1 ] shows numerically found @xmath27 and @xmath36 for the different truncation settings at two different sets of parameters .
naturally , convergence of the solutions for the localized modes is observed with the increase of the number of the rhombic layers .
.numerical solutions for different versions of the truncated lattice at @xmath37 , @xmath38 , @xmath39 , and @xmath40 . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^ " , ]
we have introduced the 2d discrete dynamical system based on the bulk linear lossy lattice , into which one or two nonlinear sites with the linear gain ( hss , hot spots " ) are embedded .
the system can be implemented in the form of an array of optical or plasmonic waveguides , admitting , in particular , selective excitation of individual cores , by the local application of the external pump to the uniformly doped array .
the analysis of localized modes pinned to the hss was developed both semi - analytically ( using truncated lattices ) and numerically .
it has been found that , in the case of the self - focusing nonlinearity at the single hs , the pinned modes are stable ( unstable ) when the nonlinearity acting at the hs contains the cubic loss ( gain ) . on the other hand , it is worthwhile to note that , in the case of the self - defocusing nonlinearity , the hs with an unsaturated cubic gain supports stable modes , in a rather small parameter region , and bistability occurs in the case of weak cubic loss .
symmetric and antisymmetric modes pinned to dual hss were also discussed briefly . a challenging issue for the subsequent analysis is the possibility of the existence of asymmetric modes supported by the symmetric dual hss .
on the other hand , a natural extension maybe to embed one or two hss into a nonlinear lossy lattice .
partial financial supported has been provided by the hong kong research grants council through general research fund contract hku 711713e .
abdullaev , f. k. , konotop , v. v. , salerno , m. , & yulin , a. v. 2010 dissipative periodic waves , solitons , and breathers of the nonlinear schrdinger equation with complex potentials .
e _ 82 , 056606 .
skarka , v. , aleksi , n. b. , leblond , h. , malomed , b. a. , & mihalache , d. 2010 varieties of stable vortical solitons in ginzburg - landau media with radially inhomogeneous losses .
_ 105 , 213901 .
mohamadou , a. , jiotsa , a. k. , & kofane , t. c. 2005 modulational instability and unstable patterns in the discrete complex cubic ginzburg - landau equation with first and second neighbor couplings .
e _ 72 , 036220 .
karachalios , n. i. , nistazakis , h. e. , and yannacopoulos , a. n. 2007 asymptotic behavior of solutions of complex discrete evolution equations : the discrete ginzburg - landau equation .
_ discrete .
_ 19 , 711 - 736 .
christ , a. , tikhodeev , s. g. , gippius , n. a. , kuhl , j. , & giessen , h. 2003 waveguide - plasmon polaritons : strong coupling of photonic and electronic resonances in a metallic photonic crystal slab .
_ 91 , 183901 .
christ , a. , zentgraf , t. , kuhl , j. , tikhodeev , s. g. , gippius , n. a. , & giessen , h. 2004 optical properties of planar metallic photonic crystal structures : experiment and theory . _ phys .
b _ 70 , 125113 .
bian , y. s. , zheng , z. , zhao , x. , su , y. l. , liu , l. , liu , j. s. , zhu , j. s. , & zhou , t. 2012 guiding of long - range hybrid plasmon polariton in a coupled nanowire array at deep - subwavelength scale .
_ ieee phot .
_ 24 , 1279 - 1281 .
szameit , a. , burghoff , j. , pertsch , t. , nolte , s. , tnnermann , a. , & lederer , f. 2006 two - dimensional soliton in cubic fs laser written waveguide arrays in fused silica .
_ optics express _ 14 , 6055 - 6062 .
minardi , s. , eilenberger , f. , kartashov , y. v. , szameit , a. , rpke , u. , kobelke , j. , schuster , k. , bartelt , h. , nolte , s. , torner , l. , lederer , f. , tnnermann , a. , & pertsch , t. 2010 three - dimensional light bullets in arrays of waveguides .
_ 105 , 263901 . | we introduce a system with one or two amplified nonlinear sites ( hot spots " , hss ) embedded into a two - dimensional linear lossy lattice .
the system describes an array of evanescently coupled optical or plasmonic waveguides , with gain applied to selected hs cores .
the subject of the analysis is discrete solitons pinned to the hss .
the shape of the localized modes is found in quasi - analytical and numerical forms , using a truncated lattice for the analytical consideration .
stability eigenvalues are computed numerically , and the results are supplemented by direct numerical simulations . in the case of self - focusing nonlinearity ,
the modes pinned to a single hs are stable and unstable when the nonlinearity includes the cubic loss and gain , respectively .
if the nonlinearity is self - defocusing , the _ unsaturated _ cubic gain acting at the hs supports _ stable _ modes in a small parametric area , while weak cubic loss gives rise to a _
bistability _ of the discrete solitons .
symmetric and antisymmetric modes pinned to a symmetric set of two hss are considered as well . |
in this work we calculate the free energy of qcd on the lattice , up to three loops in perturbation theory .
we employ wilson gluons and the @xmath2 improved sheikholeslami - wohlert ( clover ) @xcite action for fermions .
the purpose of this action is to reduce finite lattice spacing effects , leading to a faster approach to the continuum .
dynamical simulations employing the clover action are currently in progress by the cp - pacs / jlqcd @xcite and ukqcdsf @xcite collaborations and therefore perturbative studies of properties of the qcd action with clover quarks are worthy of being undertaken .
the free energy , in the simpler case of wilson fermions , was studied in @xcite .
the free energy in qcd on the lattice can be related to the average plaquette .
the results find several applications , for example : a ) in improved scaling schemes , using an appropriately defined effective coupling which depends on the average plaquette ( see , e. g. , @xcite ) , b ) in long standing efforts , starting with @xcite , to determine the value of the gluon condensate , c ) in studies of the interquark potential @xcite , and d ) as a test of perturbation theory , at its limits of applicability . indeed , regarding point ( d ) above , the plaquette expectation value is a prototype for additive renormalization of a composite , dimensionful operator .
the vacuum diagrams contributing to such a calculation are power divergent in the lattice spacing and may well dominate over any nonperturbative signal in a numerical simulation .
starting from the wilson formulation of qcd on the lattice , with the addition of the clover ( sw ) fermion term , the action reads in standard notation : @xmath3 , \nonumber \\ s_f & = & \sum_{f}\sum_{x } ( 4r+m_b)\bar{\psi}_{f}(x)\psi_f(x ) \nonumber \\ & & -{1\over 2}\sum_{f}\sum_{x,\,\mu } \left [ \bar{\psi}_{f}(x)\left ( r - \gamma_\mu\right ) u_{\mu}(x)\psi_f(x+\hat{\mu})+ \bar{\psi}_f(x+\hat{\mu})\left ( r + \gamma_\mu\right ) u_{\mu}(x)^\dagger \psi_{f}(x)\right]\nonumber \\ & & + { i\over 4}\,c_{\rm sw}\,\sum_{f}\sum_{x,\,\mu,\,\nu } \bar{\psi}_{f}(x ) \sigma_{\mu\nu } { \hat f}_{\mu\nu}(x ) \psi_f(x ) \label{latact}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath4 here @xmath5 is the usual product of @xmath1 link variables @xmath6 along the perimeter of a plaquette in the @xmath7-@xmath8 directions , originating at @xmath9 ; @xmath10 denotes the bare coupling constant ; @xmath11 is the wilson parameter , which will be assigned its standard value @xmath12 ; @xmath13 is a flavor index ; @xmath14 $ ] .
powers of the lattice spacing @xmath15 have been omitted and may be directly reinserted by dimensional counting .
the clover coefficient @xmath16 is a free parameter for the purposes of the present calculation and our results will be presented as a polynomial in @xmath16 , with coefficients which we compute .
preferred values for @xmath16 have been suggested by both perturbative ( 1-loop ) @xcite and non - perturbative @xcite studies .
we use the standard covariant gauge - fixing term @xcite ; in terms of the vector field @xmath17 @xmath18 $ ] , it reads : @xmath19 having to compute a gauge invariant quantity , we chose to work in the feynman gauge , @xmath20 .
covariant gauge fixing produces the following action for the ghost fields @xmath21 and @xmath22 @xmath23 + \frac{i\,g_0}{2 } \,\left[q_{\mu}(x ) , \delta^+_{\mu}\omega(x ) \right ] \nonumber\\ & & - \frac{g_0 ^ 2}{12 } \,\left[q_{\mu}(x ) , \left [ q_{\mu}(x ) , \delta^+_{\mu}\omega(x)\right]\right]\nonumber\\ & & - \frac{g_0 ^ 4}{720 } \,\left[q_{\mu}(x ) , \left[q_{\mu}(x ) , \left[q_{\mu}(x ) , \left [ q_{\mu}(x ) , \delta^+_{\mu}\omega(x)\right]\right]\right]\right ] + \cdots \bigr)\biggr\ } , \nonumber\\ & \delta^+_{\mu}\omega(x ) \equiv \omega(x +
{ \hat \mu } ) - \omega(x)&\end{aligned}\ ] ] finally the change of integration variables from links to vector fields yields a jacobian that can be rewritten as the usual measure term @xmath24 in the action : @xmath25 in @xmath26 and @xmath27 we have written out only terms relevant to our computation .
the full action is : @xmath28 the average value of the action density , @xmath29 , is directly related to the average plaquette . for the gluon part
we have : @xmath30 as for @xmath31 , it is trivial in any action which is bilinear in the fermion fields , and leads to : @xmath32 ( @xmath33 : number of fermion flavors ) .
we will calculate @xmath34 in perturbation theory : @xmath35 the @xmath36-loop coefficient can be written as @xmath37 where @xmath38 is the contribution of diagrams without fermion loops and @xmath39 comes from diagrams containing fermions .
the coefficients @xmath38 have been known for some time up to 3 loops @xcite ( also in 3 dimensions @xcite , where they are applied to `` magnetostatic '' qcd @xcite and to dimensionally reduced qcd @xcite ) .
independent estimates of higher loop coefficients have also been obtained using stochastic perturbation theory @xcite .
the fermionic coefficients @xmath39 are known to 2 loops for overlap fermions @xcite and up to 3 loops for wilson fermions @xcite ; in the present work we extend this computation to the clover action .
the calculation of @xmath40 proceeds most conveniently by computing first the free energy @xmath41 , where @xmath42 is the full partition function : @xmath43 \exp(-s ) \label{z}\ ] ] then , @xmath34 is extracted through @xmath44 in particular , the perturbative expansion of @xmath45 : @xmath46 leads immediately to the relations : @xmath47
a total of 62 feynman diagrams contribute to the present calculation , up to three loops .
the first 36 diagrams are totally gluonic , and the others have both gluon and fermion contributions ; these are shown in appendix a. the involved algebra of lattice perturbation theory was carried out using our computer package in mathematica . the value for each diagram is computed numerically for a sequence of finite lattices , with typical size @xmath48 .
certain diagrams must be grouped into infrared - finite sets , before extrapolating their values to infinite lattice size ( diagrams 11 + 12 + 13 , 22 through 36 , 43 + 53 , 44 + 52 + 58 , 46 + 56 , 51 + 57 , 55 + 60 , 61 + 62 ) .
extrapolation leads to a ( small ) systematic error , which is estimated quite accurately ; a consise description of the procedure is provided in ref .
@xcite .
diagrams in the shape of a triangular pyramid ( 18 , 19 , 20 , 49 , 50 ) are the most cpu demanding , since integration over the 3 loop momenta can not be factorized ; these diagrams were necessarily evaluated for smaller @xmath49 , but fortunately @xmath50 was already sufficient for a very stable extrapolation in these cases . diagram 40 vanishes identically by color antisymmetry .
we have calculated @xmath56 , @xmath57 for typical values of the lagrangian ( unrenormalized ) fermion mass parameter @xmath0 , which is connected to the familiar hopping expansion parameter @xmath58 .
our results are listed in appendix b. a complete _ per diagram _ breakdown of the results would be far too lengthy to present ; instead , for potential comparisons , we provide in appendix b a breakdown only for a particular value of @xmath0 .
we list below some examples of values for @xmath34 , setting @xmath61 .
for @xmath63 we have : @xmath64 for two degenerate flavors ( @xmath62 ) and @xmath65 ( corresponding to @xmath66 ) : @xmath67 c_{\rm sw } = 2.0 : \ & e_g = ( 1/3)\ , g^2 & + 0.013663456(3 ) g^4 & + 0.0110200(13 ) g^6 \end{array } \label{m-0.518106}\ ] ] for @xmath62 and @xmath68 : @xmath69 c_{\rm sw } = 1.3 : \ & e_g = ( 1/3)\ , g^2 & + 0.025219798(9 ) \ g^4 & + 0.0129659(5 ) \
g^6 , \\[0.5ex ] c_{\rm sw } = 2.0 : \ & e_g = ( 1/3)\ , g^2 & + 0.01800170(1 ) \ g^4 & + 0.012948(1 ) \ g^6 \end{array } \label{m0.038}\ ] ] it is seen that the 3-loop coefficients are quite pronounced for typical values of @xmath10 used in numerical simulations . for convenience , the behaviour of @xmath34 versus @xmath70 is also presented in fig .
3 , for the same parameter values as in eqs .
( [ m-0.518106],[m0.038 ] ) .
the detailed results , tabulated in appendix b for arbitrary values of @xmath71 , @xmath33 , @xmath16 , show a very smooth behaviour as a function of @xmath0 ; consequently , one is able to reconstruct @xmath34 also for arbitrary values of @xmath0 by naive interpolation , to excellent precision .
figure 4 depicts all diagrams contributing to the free energy at 1 loop ( diagram 1 ) , 2 loops ( 2 - 6 , 37 - 38 ) , and 3 loops ( 7 - 36 , 39 - 62 ) .
solid ( curly , dashed ) lines represent fermions ( gluons , ghosts ) , and the filled square is the contribution from the measure part of the action . the filled circle , corresponding to the non - fermionic part of the 1-loop gluon self - energy , is given in figure 5
. tables i - iv provide a _ per diagram _ breakdown of our results , at a given value of @xmath0 ( @xmath68 ) , in order to allow for potential comparisons and cross checks .
the total results for the coefficients @xmath56 , @xmath72 , @xmath73 , @xmath74 are listed in tables v - viii , respectively , for a wide selection of @xmath0 values which are used in the literature .
given the smooth dependence of all these coefficients on @xmath0 , interpolations to other intermediate values of @xmath0 can be performed with great accuracy . | we calculate the perturbative value of the free energy in lattice qcd , up to three loops .
our calculation is performed using wilson gluons and the sheikholeslami - wolhert ( clover ) improved action for fermions . the free energy is directly related to the average plaquette . to carry out the calculation ,
we compute all relevant feynman diagrams up to 3 loops , using a set of automated procedures in mathematica ; numerical evaluation of the resulting loop integrals is performed on finite lattice , with subsequent extrapolation to infinite size .
the results are presented as a function of the fermion mass @xmath0 , for any @xmath1 gauge group , and for an arbitrary number of fermion flavors . in order to enable independent comparisons
, we also provide the results on a _ per diagram _ basis , for a specific mass value .
lattice perturbation theory , free energy , average plaquette , clover action , 11.15.ha , 12.38.gc , 12.38.bx |
two subgroups @xmath5 and @xmath7 of a group @xmath0 are _ commensurable _ if the intersection @xmath8 has finite index in both @xmath5 and @xmath7 .
the _ commensurator _ of @xmath9 in @xmath0 is the group @xmath10 note that @xmath11 contains the normalizer @xmath12 .
it is a classical fact that if @xmath0 is a connected semisimple lie group , with trivial center and no compact factors , and @xmath9 is an irreducible lattice , then either @xmath13 is finite index in @xmath14 or @xmath14 is dense in @xmath0 ( see @xcite ) .
moreover margulis @xcite proved that @xmath13 is arithmetic if and only if @xmath14 is dense .
a semisimple lie group is a locally compact topological group . if @xmath1 is a locally finite , simply connected polyhedral complex , then the group @xmath15 is also locally compact .
it turns out that a subgroup @xmath9 is a uniform lattice in @xmath0 if and only if @xmath13 acts cocompactly on @xmath1 with finite cell stabilizers ( see section [ ss : lattices ] ) .
lattices in such groups @xmath0 share many properties with lattices in semisimple lie groups , but also exhibit new and unexpected phenomena ( see the surveys @xcite and @xcite ) . in this setting , the one - dimensional case is @xmath1 a locally finite tree .
liu @xcite proved that the commensurator of the standard uniform lattice " @xmath5 is dense in @xmath16 ; here @xmath5 is a canonical graph of finite cyclic groups over the finite quotient @xmath17 .
in addition , leighton @xcite and bass kulkarni @xcite proved that all uniform lattices in @xmath0 are commensurable ( up to conjugacy ) .
hence all uniform tree lattices have dense commensurators . in dimension two ,
haglund @xcite showed that for certain @xmath18dimensional davis complexes @xmath19 , the coxeter group @xmath20 , which may be regarded as a uniform lattice in @xmath16 , has dense commensurator .
we consider higher - dimensional cases , focusing on regular right - angled buildings @xmath1 ( see section [ ss : rabs ] ) .
such buildings exist in arbitrary dimension .
examples include products of finitely many regular trees , and bourdon s building @xmath21 , the unique @xmath18complex in which every @xmath18cell is a regular right - angled hyperbolic @xmath22gon and the link of each vertex is the complete bipartite graph @xmath23 ( see @xcite ) .
the standard uniform lattice " @xmath24 , defined in section [ ss : complexes_of_groups ] below , is a canonical graph product of finite cyclic groups , which acts on @xmath1 with fundamental domain a chamber .
our main result is : let @xmath0 be the automorphism group of a locally finite regular right - angled building @xmath1 , and let @xmath5 be the standard uniform lattice in @xmath0 .
then @xmath25 is dense in @xmath0 .
this theorem was proved independently and using different methods by haglund @xcite .
in contrast , we show in section [ s : norm ] below that for all @xmath16 with @xmath1 a locally finite polyhedral complex ( not necessarily a building ) , and all uniform lattices @xmath9 , the normalizer @xmath12 is discrete .
hence for @xmath0 as in the density theorem , the density of @xmath26 does not come just from the normalizer . for most regular right - angled buildings @xmath1 ,
it is not known whether all uniform lattices in @xmath16 are commensurable ( up to conjugacy ) .
witkowski @xcite have established commensurability of a class of lattices in @xmath0 which includes @xmath5 , where each such lattice is a graph product of finite groups . hence by the density theorem , each such lattice has dense commensurator . for bourdon
s building @xmath21 , haglund @xcite proved that if @xmath27 , then all uniform lattices in @xmath28 are commensurable ( up to conjugacy ) .
thus by the density theorem , all uniform lattices in @xmath0 have dense commensurators . on the other hand , for @xmath1 a product of two trees , burger mozes @xcite constructed a uniform lattice @xmath29 which is a simple group .
it follows that @xmath30 , which is discrete .
thus there are cases ( when @xmath31 ) in which not all uniform lattices @xmath32 have dense commensurators .
in fact , it is an open problem to determine whether the only possibilities for @xmath14 are discreteness or density . as for commensurators of nonuniform lattices in @xmath16 , hardly anything is known , even for @xmath1 a tree ( see @xcite ) .
if the building @xmath1 can be equipped with a @xmath33 metric , then the density theorem may be combined with the commensurator superrigidity theorem of burger mozes @xcite for @xmath33 spaces , to give rigidity results for lattices in @xmath16 which are commensurable to @xmath5 .
regular right - angled buildings with piecewise hyperbolic @xmath33 metrics exist in arbitrarily high dimensions @xcite .
we now outline the proof of the density theorem , which is given in full in section [ s : proof ] below . fix a basepoint @xmath34 . denote by @xmath35 the combinatorial ball of radius @xmath36 about @xmath37 in @xmath1 .
we first reduce the theorem to showing that for all @xmath38 and for all @xmath39 , there is a @xmath40 such that @xmath41 agrees with @xmath42 on the ball @xmath35 .
we then construct a canonical uniform lattice @xmath6 with fundamental domain the ball @xmath35 , and show that @xmath6 is a finite index subgroup of @xmath5 . by considering the restriction of @xmath42 to @xmath35 , we are then able to build a uniform lattice @xmath43 which contains a suitable element @xmath41 . by our construction ,
the lattice @xmath6 is a finite index subgroup of @xmath43 .
that is , @xmath43 and @xmath5 have a common finite index subgroup @xmath6 , as sketched on the left of figure [ f : lattice_inclusions ] below .
thus @xmath43 is commensurable to @xmath5 , and so @xmath41 lies in @xmath26 , as required . our lattices @xmath6 and @xmath43 are fundamental groups of complexes of groups ( see @xcite and section [ ss : complexes_of_groups ] below ) .
the finite index lattice inclusions on the left of figure [ f : lattice_inclusions ] are induced by finite - sheeted coverings of complexes of groups , as shown on the right of figure [ f : lattice_inclusions ] .
the necessary covering theory for complexes of groups is recalled in section [ ss : covering_theory ] below ( see also @xcite and @xcite ) . to construct the sequence of lattices @xmath6 , in section [ s : unfolding ] below we introduce a new tool , that of _ unfoldings _ of complexes of groups .
the standard uniform lattice @xmath5 may be viewed as the fundamental group of a complex of groups @xmath44 over a chamber @xmath45 of @xmath1 . by
unfolding " along `` sides '' of successive unions of chambers starting from @xmath45 , and defining new local groups appropriately , we obtain a canonical family of complexes of groups @xmath46 over the combinatorial balls @xmath47 .
the fundamental group @xmath6 of @xmath46 is a uniform lattice in @xmath15 , and each @xmath6 is a finite index subgroup of @xmath5 .
we prove these properties of unfoldings inductively by combinatorial arguments , involving careful consideration of the local structure of @xmath1 , together with facts about coxeter groups , and the definition of a building as a chamber system equipped with a @xmath20distance function ( see section [ ss : rabs ] ) .
the other main tool in our proof of the density theorem is that of _ group actions on complexes of groups _ , which was introduced by the second author in @xcite ( see section [ ss : group_actions ] below ) .
this theory is used to construct the sequence of lattices @xmath43 , containing suitable elements @xmath41 , as fundamental groups of complexes of groups @xmath48 such that there are finite - sheeted coverings @xmath49 .
we describe in section [ ss : new_lattices ] below how our two main tools , unfoldings and group actions on complexes of groups , may be combined to construct many uniform lattices in addition to the sequences @xmath6 and @xmath43 used in the proof of the density theorem . to our knowledge ,
the lattices so obtained are new .
in particular , they do not come from " tree lattices , unlike the lattices in @xcite . in section [ s :
applications ] below , we give two further applications of the technique of unfoldings .
first , in theorem [ t : autom_gp_intro ] below , we characterize the regular right - angled buildings @xmath1 such that @xmath16 is nondiscrete ( the lattice theory of @xmath0 is otherwise trivial ) . as we recall in section [ ss : rabs ] , the building @xmath1 is determined by a right - angled coxeter system @xmath50 , and a family of positive integers @xmath51 which give the number of chambers of @xmath1 which meet at common faces . a polyhedral complex @xmath52 is said to be _ rigid _ if for any @xmath53 , if @xmath42 fixes the star in @xmath52 of a vertex @xmath54 of @xmath52 , then @xmath42 fixes @xmath52 .
we prove : [ t : autom_gp_intro ] let @xmath1 be a regular right - angled building of type @xmath55 and parameters @xmath56 .
let @xmath16 and let @xmath57 be the group of type - preserving automorphisms of @xmath1 . 1 . if there are @xmath58 such that @xmath59 and @xmath60 then @xmath61 and @xmath0 are both nondiscrete .
if for all @xmath62 with @xmath63 we have @xmath64 for all @xmath65 , then @xmath61 is discrete , and @xmath0 is nondiscrete if and only if the nerve @xmath52 of @xmath55 is not rigid . if all @xmath66 then the building @xmath1 is the davis complex for @xmath55 , in which case this result is due to haglund
paulin @xcite .
the second main result of section [ s : applications ] is : [ t : transitive ] let @xmath0 be the automorphism group of a regular right - angled building @xmath1 .
then the action of @xmath0 on @xmath1 is strongly transitive .
a group @xmath0 is said to act strongly transitively on a building @xmath1 if it acts transitively on the set of pairs @xmath67 , where @xmath68 is a chamber of @xmath1 , and @xmath69 is an apartment of @xmath1 containing @xmath68 ( see section [ ss : rabs ] ) . by a theorem of tits ( see @xcite ) , if @xmath1 is a thick building , it follows that the group @xmath0 has a @xmath70pair .
for example , bourdon s building @xmath21 is thick for all @xmath71 .
theorem [ t : transitive ] was sketched for the case @xmath72 by bourdon in ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 2.3.3 ) .
we would like to thank indira chatterji and benson farb for advice and encouragement , kenneth s. brown , g. christopher hruska , shahar mozes , and boris okun for helpful conversations , karen vogtmann for comments on this manuscript , and the university of chicago , msri and cornell university for supporting travel by both authors .
in section [ ss : lattices ] we briefly describe the natural topology on @xmath0 the automorphism group of a locally finite polyhedral complex @xmath1 and characterize uniform lattices in @xmath0 .
we present some necessary background on coxeter groups and davis complexes in sections [ ss : coxeter_groups ] and [ ss : davis_complexes ] respectively , then discuss right - angled buildings in section [ ss : rabs ] .
next in section [ ss : complexes_of_groups ] we recall the basic theory of complexes of groups and use this to construct the standard uniform lattice @xmath5 in the automorphism group of a regular right - angled building @xmath1 .
finally , section [ ss : covering_theory ] contains necessary definitions and results from covering theory for complexes of groups , and section [ ss : group_actions ] recalls the theory of group actions on complexes of groups .
let @xmath0 be a locally compact topological group . recall that a discrete subgroup @xmath9 is a _ lattice _ if @xmath73 carries a finite @xmath0invariant measure , and that @xmath9 discrete is a _ uniform _
lattice if @xmath73 is compact .
let @xmath1 be a connected , locally finite polyhedral complex , and let @xmath16 be the group of automorphisms , or cellular isometries , of @xmath1 .
then @xmath0 , equipped with the compact - open topology , is a locally compact topological group . in this topology , a countable neighborhood basis of the identity in @xmath0
consists of automorphisms which fix larger and larger combinatorial balls in @xmath1 .
a subgroup @xmath13 of @xmath0 is discrete if and only if , for each cell @xmath54 of @xmath1 , the stabilizer @xmath74 is a finite group . using a normalization of the haar measure on @xmath0 due to serre @xcite , and by the same arguments as for tree lattices ( see chapter 1 of @xcite ) ,
if @xmath75 is compact , then @xmath9 is a uniform lattice in @xmath0 exactly when @xmath13 acts cocompactly on @xmath1 with finite cell stabilizers .
we recall some necessary definitions and results .
our notation and terminology in this section mostly follow davis @xcite .
a _ coxeter group _ is a group @xmath20 with a finite generating set @xmath76 and presentation of the form @xmath77 where @xmath78 for all @xmath79 , and if @xmath80 then @xmath81 is an integer @xmath82 or @xmath60 , meaning that there is no relation between @xmath83 and @xmath84 .
the pair @xmath55 is called a _
coxeter system_. given a coxeter system @xmath55 , a _ word _ in the generating set @xmath76 is a finite sequence @xmath85 where each @xmath86 .
we denote by @xmath87 the corresponding element of @xmath20 .
a word @xmath88 is said to be _ reduced _ if the element @xmath89 can not be represented by any shorter word .
tits proved that a word @xmath88 is reduced if and only if it can not be shortened by a sequence of operations of either deleting a subword of the form @xmath90 , or replacing an alternating subword @xmath91 of length @xmath81 by the alternating word @xmath92 of the same length @xmath81 ( see theorem 3.4.2 @xcite ) .
in particular , this implies : [ l : coxeter ] any word in @xmath76 representing some @xmath93 must involve all of the elements of @xmath76 that are used in any reduced word representing @xmath94 .
a coxeter group @xmath20 , or a coxeter system @xmath55 , is said to be _ right - angled
_ if all @xmath81 with @xmath80 are equal to @xmath18 or @xmath95 . that is , in a right - angled coxeter system , every pair of generators either commutes or has no relation .
[ egs : racg ] many later definitions and constructions will be illustrated by the following examples of right - angled coxeter groups . 1 .
[ e : free_product ] let @xmath20 be the free product of @xmath36 copies of @xmath96 .
then @xmath20 is a right - angled coxeter group with presentation @xmath97 in particular , if @xmath98 , then @xmath20 is the infinite dihedral group .
[ e : mixed_dimension ] let @xmath20 be the free product of @xmath96 with the direct product @xmath99 .
then @xmath20 is a right - angled coxeter group with presentation @xmath100 3 .
[ e : hexagon ] let @xmath20 be the group generated by reflections in the sides of a regular right - angled hyperbolic hexagon in the hyperbolic plane .
then @xmath20 is a right - angled coxeter group with presentation @xmath101 where the subscripts of the @xmath102 are numbered cyclically .
let @xmath55 be a coxeter system ( not necessarily right - angled ) .
in this section we recall the construction of the davis complex @xmath69 for @xmath55 , mostly following @xcite . for each subset @xmath103 of @xmath76 , we denote by @xmath104 the _ special subgroup _ of @xmath20 generated by the elements @xmath105 . by convention , @xmath106 is the trivial group .
a subset @xmath103 of @xmath76 is _ spherical _ if @xmath104 is finite , in which case we say that @xmath104 is a _
spherical special subgroup_. denote by @xmath107 the set of all spherical subsets of @xmath76
. then @xmath107 is partially ordered by inclusion .
the poset @xmath108 is an abstract simplicial complex , denoted by @xmath52 , and called the _
nerve _ of @xmath55 . in other words ,
the vertex set of @xmath52 is @xmath76 , and a nonempty set @xmath103 of vertices spans a simplex @xmath109 in @xmath52 if and only if @xmath103 is spherical .
the nerves @xmath52 of examples [ egs : racg ] above are as follows . 1 . the @xmath36 vertices @xmath110 , with no higher - dimensional simplices .
2 . a vertex @xmath111 , and an edge joining the vertices @xmath112 and @xmath113 .
3 . a hexagon with vertices labeled cyclically @xmath114 . we denote by @xmath115 the geometric realization of the poset @xmath107 .
equivalently , @xmath115 is the cone on the barycentric subdivision of the nerve @xmath52 of @xmath55 .
note that @xmath115 is compact and contractible , since it is the cone on a finite simplicial complex .
each vertex of @xmath115 has _ type _ a spherical subset of @xmath76 , with the cone point having type @xmath116 . for each @xmath79 let @xmath117 be the union of the ( closed )
simplices in @xmath115 which contain the vertex @xmath118 but do not contain the cone point .
in other words , @xmath117 is the closed star of the vertex @xmath118 in the barycentric subdivision of @xmath52 .
note that @xmath117 and @xmath119 intersect if and only if @xmath81 is finite .
the family @xmath120 is a _ mirror structure _ on @xmath115 , meaning that @xmath121 is a family of closed subspaces of @xmath115 , called _ mirrors_. we call @xmath117 the _ @xmath83mirror _ of @xmath115 .
[ l : mirrors ] let @xmath55 be a coxeter system and let @xmath115 be the geometric realization of the poset @xmath107 of spherical subsets . 1 .
for each spherical subset @xmath103 , the intersection of mirrors @xmath122 is contractible .
2 . for each nonempty
spherical subset @xmath103 , the union of mirrors @xmath123 is contractible . for any spherical subset @xmath103 of @xmath76
, we call the intersection of mirrors @xmath122 a _ face _ of @xmath115 , and the _ center _ of this face is the unique vertex of @xmath115 of type @xmath103 . in particular , the center of the @xmath83mirror @xmath117 is the vertex @xmath118 . for each @xmath124 , put @xmath125 now define an equivalence relation @xmath126 on the set @xmath127 by @xmath128 if and only if @xmath129 and @xmath130 . the _ davis complex _ @xmath69 for @xmath55 is then the quotient space : @xmath131 the types of vertices of @xmath115 induce types of vertices of @xmath69 , and the natural @xmath20action on @xmath127 descends to a type - preserving action on @xmath69 .
we identify @xmath115 with the subcomplex @xmath132 of @xmath69 .
then @xmath115 , as well as any one of its translates by an element of @xmath20 , will be called a _ chamber _ of @xmath69 .
the subcomplexes @xmath117 of @xmath115 , or any of their translates by elements of @xmath20 , will be called the _ mirrors _ of @xmath69 , and similarly for faces . for examples [ egs : racg ] above : 1 .
as shown in figure [ f : davis_complex_tree ] for @xmath133 , the chamber @xmath115 is the cone on @xmath36 vertices .
the davis complex @xmath69 is the barycentric subdivision of the @xmath36regular tree , and its mirrors are the midpoints of the edges of this tree . if @xmath98 then @xmath69 is homeomorphic to the real line .
the davis complex @xmath69 for this example is sketched in figure 1.2 of @xcite ; @xmath69 has both one - dimensional and two - dimensional maximal cells . 3 .
the davis complex @xmath69 for this example is homeomorphic to the barycentric subdivision of the tesselation of the hyperbolic plane by regular right - angled hexagons .
the mirrors are the edges of these hexagons .
we first discuss general chamber systems and buildings in section [ sss : chambers ] , before specializing to the right - angled case in section [ sss : rabs ] .
the local structure of right - angled buildings , which is important for our proofs , is described in section [ sss : local ] .
again , we mostly follow davis @xcite .
a _ chamber system _ over a set @xmath76 is a set @xmath134 of _ chambers _ together with a family of equivalence relations on @xmath134 indexed by the elements of @xmath76 . for each @xmath135 ,
two chambers are _
@xmath83equivalent _ if they are equivalent via the equivalence relation corresponding to @xmath83 , they are _
@xmath83adjacent _ if they are @xmath83equivalent and not equal .
two chambers are _ adjacent _ if they are @xmath83adjacent for some @xmath79 .
a _ gallery _ in @xmath134 is a finite sequence of chambers @xmath136 such that @xmath137 is adjacent to @xmath138 for @xmath139 .
a chamber system is _ gallery - connected _ if any two chambers can be connected by a gallery .
the _ type _ of a gallery @xmath136 is the word @xmath140 , where @xmath137 is @xmath141adjacent to @xmath142 for @xmath139 , and a gallery is _ minimal _ if its type is a reduced word .
for @xmath55 a coxeter system , the _ abstract coxeter complex _
@xmath143 of @xmath20 is the chamber system with chambers the elements of @xmath20 , and two chambers @xmath94 and @xmath144 being @xmath83adjacent , for @xmath79 , if and only if @xmath145 .
suppose that @xmath55 is a coxeter system .
building of type @xmath55 _ is a chamber system @xmath134 over @xmath76 such that : 1 . for all @xmath79 ,
each @xmath83equivalence class contains at least two chambers ; and 2 .
there exists a _
@xmath20valued distance function _
@xmath146 , that is , given a reduced word @xmath147 , chambers @xmath68 and @xmath148 can be joined by a gallery of type @xmath88 in @xmath134 if and only if @xmath149 .
let @xmath134 be a building of type @xmath55 .
then @xmath134 is _ spherical _ if @xmath20 is finite .
the building @xmath134 is _ thick _ if for all @xmath79 , each @xmath83equivalence class of chambers contains at least three elements ; a building which is not thick is _
thin_. the building @xmath134 is _ regular _ if , for all @xmath79 , each @xmath83equivalence class of chambers has the same number of elements .
the abstract coxeter complex @xmath143 of @xmath20 is a regular thin building , with @xmath20distance function @xmath150 given by @xmath151 .
suppose @xmath134 is a building of type @xmath55 .
apartment _ of @xmath134 is an image of the abstract coxeter complex @xmath143 , defined above , under a map @xmath152 which preserves @xmath20distances .
the building @xmath134 has a _ geometric realization _ ,
which we denote by @xmath1 , and by abuse of notation we call @xmath1 a _ building of type @xmath55 _ as well . by definition of the geometric realization , for each chamber of @xmath134 ,
the corresponding subcomplex of @xmath1 is isomorphic to the chamber @xmath115 defined in section [ ss : davis_complexes ] above , and for each apartment of @xmath134 , the corresponding subcomplex of the building @xmath1 is isomorphic to the davis complex @xmath69 for @xmath55 .
the copies of @xmath69 in @xmath1 are referred to as the _ apartments _ of @xmath1 , and the copies of @xmath115 in @xmath1 are the _ chambers _ of @xmath1 .
note that each vertex of @xmath1 thus inherits a type @xmath103 a spherical subset of @xmath76 .
the copies of @xmath117 , @xmath79 , in @xmath1 are the _ mirrors _ of @xmath1 , so that two chambers in @xmath1 are @xmath83adjacent if and only if their intersection is a mirror of type @xmath83 .
the _ faces _ of @xmath1 are its subcomplexes which are intersections of mirrors .
each face has type @xmath103 a spherical subset of @xmath76 , and a face of type @xmath103 contains a unique vertex of type @xmath103 , called its _
center_. the building @xmath1 may be metrized as follows : [ t : metrize ]
let @xmath55 be a coxeter system and let @xmath1 be a building of type @xmath55 . 1 .
[ t : buildcat0 ] the building @xmath1 may be equipped with a piecewise euclidean structure , such that @xmath1 is a complete @xmath153 space .
[ t : buildcat-1 ] the building @xmath1 can be equipped with a piecewise hyperbolic structure which is @xmath33 if and only if @xmath55 satisfies moussong s hyperbolicity condition : 1 .
there is no subset @xmath154 such that @xmath104 is a euclidean reflection group of dimension @xmath82 ; and 2 .
there is no subset @xmath155 such that @xmath156 for nonspherical subsets @xmath157 . unless stated otherwise , we equip buildings @xmath1 with the @xmath153 metric of part of theorem [ t : metrize ] . in this section we specialize to right - angled buildings .
a building @xmath1 of type @xmath55 is _ right - angled _ if @xmath55 is a right - angled coxeter system .
note that part of theorem [ t : metrize ] above implies that a piecewise hyperbolic @xmath33 structure exists for a right - angled building @xmath1 if and only if the nerve @xmath52 has no squares without diagonals ( `` satisfies the no@xmath158 condition '' ) . the following result classifies regular right - angled buildings .
[ t : rabeu ] let @xmath55 be a right - angled coxeter system and @xmath159 a family of cardinalities . then , up to isometry , there exists a unique building @xmath1 of type @xmath55 , such that for all @xmath79 , each @xmath83equivalence class of @xmath1 contains @xmath160 chambers . in the @xmath18dimensional case ,
this result is due to bourdon @xcite . according to @xcite ,
theorem [ t : rabeu ] was proved by m. globus , and was known also to m. davis , t. januszkiewicz , and j. witkowski .
we will refer to a right - angled building @xmath1 as in theorem [ t : rabeu ] as a _ building of type @xmath55 and parameters @xmath161_. in section [ ss : complexes_of_groups ] below , we recall a construction , appearing in haglund
paulin @xcite , of regular right - angled buildings @xmath1 as universal covers of complexes of groups .
the following definition will be important for our proofs below .
let @xmath1 be a building of type @xmath55 .
fix @xmath115 some chamber of @xmath1 .
we define the _ combinatorial ball _
@xmath35 of radius @xmath36 in @xmath1 inductively as follows . for @xmath162 , @xmath163 , and for @xmath164 , @xmath35 is the union of @xmath165 with the set of chambers of @xmath1 which have nonempty intersection with @xmath165 . 1 .
let @xmath55 be the free product of @xmath36 copies of @xmath166 , as in part of examples [ egs : racg ] above .
for @xmath167 let @xmath168 be a positive integer .
then the right - angled building @xmath1 of type @xmath55 and parameters @xmath169 is a locally finite tree .
each mirror @xmath170 is a vertex of @xmath1 of valence @xmath171 .
the remaining vertices of @xmath1 are the centers of chambers and have valence @xmath36 . if @xmath98 then @xmath1 is the barycentric subdivision of the @xmath172biregular tree , and each chamber of @xmath1 is the barycentric subdivision of an edge of this tree .
figure [ f : rab_tree ] depicts the combinatorial ball @xmath173 of radius @xmath18 in @xmath1 for an example with @xmath174 .
2 . in low dimensions , there are right - angled buildings @xmath1 which are also hyperbolic buildings , meaning that their apartments are isometric to a ( fixed ) tesselation of hyperbolic space @xmath175 . for this ,
let @xmath176 be a compact , convex , right - angled polyhedron in @xmath175 ; such polyhedra @xmath176 exist only for @xmath177 , and this bound is sharp ( potyagailo vinberg @xcite ) .
let @xmath55 be the right - angled coxeter system generated by reflections in the codimension one faces of @xmath176 , and let @xmath1 be a building of type @xmath55 . by theorem [ t : metrize ]
above , @xmath1 may be equipped with a piecewise hyperbolic structure which is @xmath33 .
moreover , in this metric the apartments @xmath69 of @xmath1 are the barycentric subdivision of the tesselation of @xmath175 by copies of @xmath176 .
thus @xmath1 is a hyperbolic building .
for example ,
bourdon s building @xmath21 ( see @xcite ) is of type @xmath55 and parameters @xmath161 , where @xmath20 is generated by reflections in the sides of @xmath176 a regular right - angled hyperbolic @xmath22gon ( @xmath178 ) , and each @xmath179 .
figure [ f : oneballipq ] below shows the combinatorial ball @xmath180 of radius @xmath181 in @xmath182 . in our proofs
below , we will rely on the following observations concerning the links of vertices in right - angled buildings .
let @xmath1 be a regular right - angled building of type @xmath55 and parameters @xmath159 .
suppose @xmath54 is a vertex of @xmath1 , of type a _ maximal _
spherical subset @xmath103 of @xmath76
. then the link of @xmath54 in @xmath1 , denoted by @xmath183 , is the ( barycentric subdivision of the ) join of @xmath184 sets of points , denoted @xmath185 , of cardinalities @xmath186 for each @xmath187 .
for example , the link of each vertex of bourdon s building @xmath21 is the complete bipartite graph @xmath23 , which may be thought of as the join of @xmath18 sets of @xmath188 points .
in fact , @xmath183 is a ( reducible ) spherical building , of type @xmath189 .
now consider @xmath68 a chamber of @xmath1 such that the vertex @xmath54 is in @xmath68 .
denote by @xmath190 the subcomplex of the link @xmath183 corresponding to simplices in @xmath1 which are contained in the chamber @xmath68 . for example , in bourdon s building @xmath21 , @xmath190 is an edge of the graph @xmath23 . by abuse of terminology
, we call @xmath190 a _ maximal simplex _ of @xmath183 .
( this is justified by recalling that the chamber @xmath191 is the cone on the barycentric subdivision of the nerve @xmath52 , hence @xmath68 is homeomorphic to the cone on @xmath52 . moreover , the maximal simplices of @xmath52 are correspond precisely to the maximal spherical subsets of @xmath76 . ) two chambers @xmath68 and @xmath148 of @xmath1 containing @xmath54 are adjacent in @xmath1 if and only if the corresponding maximal simplices @xmath190 and @xmath192 in @xmath183 share a codimension one face in @xmath183 .
hence , a gallery of chambers in @xmath1 , each chamber of which contains @xmath54 , corresponds precisely to a gallery of maximal simplices in the spherical building @xmath183 . in this section
we sketch the theory of complexes of groups , due to haefliger @xcite .
the sequence of examples in this section constructs the regular right - angled building @xmath1 of theorem [ t : rabeu ] above , as well as the standard uniform lattice @xmath3 in @xmath193 .
we postpone the definitions of morphisms and coverings of complexes of groups to section [ ss : covering_theory ] below .
all references to @xcite in this section are to chapter iii.@xmath194 . in the literature , a complex of groups @xmath195
is constructed over a space or set @xmath196 belonging to various different categories , including simplicial complexes , polyhedral complexes , or , most generally , _
scwols _ ( small categories without loops ) : [ d : scwol ] a _ scwol _
@xmath1 is the disjoint union of a set @xmath197 of vertices and a set @xmath198 of edges , with each edge @xmath199 oriented from its initial vertex @xmath200 to its terminal vertex @xmath201 , such that @xmath202 .
a pair of edges @xmath203 is _ composable _ if @xmath204 , in which case there is a third edge @xmath205 , called the _ composition _ of @xmath199 and @xmath206 , such that @xmath207 , @xmath208 , and if @xmath209 and @xmath210 then @xmath211 ( associativity ) .
we will always assume scwols are _ connected _ ( see section 1.1 , @xcite ) .
[ d : action_on_scwol ] an _ action of a group @xmath0 on a scwol @xmath1 _ is a homomorphism from @xmath0 to the group of automorphisms of the scwol ( see section 1.5 of @xcite ) such that for all @xmath212 and all @xmath213 : 1 .
@xmath214 ; and 2 .
[ c : no_inversions ] if @xmath215 then @xmath216 .
suppose @xmath1 is a right - angled building of type @xmath55 , as defined in section [ ss : rabs ] above .
recall that each vertex @xmath217 has a type @xmath218 .
the edges @xmath198 are then naturally oriented by inclusion of type .
that is , the edge @xmath199 joins a vertex @xmath219 of type @xmath103 to a vertex @xmath220 of type @xmath221 , with @xmath222 and @xmath223 , if and only if @xmath224 .
it is clear that the sets @xmath197 and @xmath198 satisfy the properties of a scwol .
moreover , if @xmath196 is a subcomplex of @xmath1 , then the sets @xmath225 and @xmath226 also satisfy definition [ d : scwol ] above . by abuse of notation , we identify @xmath1 and @xmath196 with the associated scwols .
note that a group of type - preserving automorphisms of @xmath1 acts according to definition [ d : action_on_scwol ] , and that if @xmath16 is not type - preserving we may replace @xmath1 by a barycentric subdivision , with suitably oriented edges , on which @xmath0 does act according to definition [ d : action_on_scwol ] .
we now define complexes of groups over scwols . a _ complex of groups _ @xmath227 over a scwol @xmath196 is given by : 1 . a group @xmath228 for each @xmath229 , called the _ local group _ at @xmath219 ; 2 . a monomorphism @xmath230 along the edge @xmath199 for each @xmath231 ; and 3 .
for each pair of composable edges , a twisting element @xmath232 , such that @xmath233 where @xmath234 is conjugation by @xmath235 in @xmath236 , and for each triple of composable edges @xmath237 the following _ cocycle condition _ holds : @xmath238 a complex of groups is _ simple _ if each @xmath235 is trivial .
let @xmath1 be a regular right - angled building of type @xmath55 and parameters @xmath159 , where each @xmath160 is an integer @xmath239 .
we construct @xmath1 and the standard uniform lattice @xmath240 using a simple complex of groups @xmath241 , which we now define . [
d : gxy_0 ] let @xmath242 be the cone on the barycentric subdivision of the nerve @xmath52 of @xmath55 ( see section [ ss : davis_complexes ] above ) .
the simple complex of groups @xmath241 over @xmath45 is defined as follows . for
each @xmath79 let @xmath243 be the cyclic group @xmath244 .
the local group at the vertex of type @xmath116 of @xmath45 is the trivial group .
the local group at the vertex of type @xmath103 a nonempty spherical subset of @xmath76 is defined to be the direct product @xmath245 all monomorphisms between local groups are natural inclusions , and all @xmath235 are trivial .
figures [ f : complex_of_groups_tree ] and [ f : complex_of_groups_ipq ] below show this complex of groups for the right - angled coxeter systems in examples [ egs : racg ] above .
suppose a group @xmath0 acts on a scwol @xmath1 , as in definition [ d : action_on_scwol ] above
. then the quotient @xmath246 also has the structure of a scwol , and the action of @xmath0 on @xmath1 induces a complex of groups @xmath195 over @xmath196 , as follows .
let @xmath247 be the natural projection . for each @xmath229
, choose a lift @xmath248 with @xmath249 .
the local group @xmath250 of @xmath195 is then defined to be the the stabilizer of @xmath251 in @xmath0 , and the monomorphisms @xmath252 and the elements @xmath235 are defined using further choices . a complex of groups is _ developable _ if it is isomorphic ( see definition [ d : morphism ] below ) to a complex of groups @xmath195 induced by such an action .
complexes of groups , unlike graphs of groups , are not in general developable .
we now discuss a sufficient condition for developability .
let @xmath196 be a scwol equipped with the metric structure of a polyhedral complex .
an example is @xmath196 a subcomplex of a right - angled building @xmath1 .
each vertex @xmath219 of @xmath196 has a _ local development _ in @xmath195 , which is , roughly speaking , a simplicial complex determined combinatorially by the cosets in @xmath250 of the local groups at vertices adjacent to @xmath54 .
the local group @xmath228 acts naturally on the local development at @xmath54 , with quotient the star of @xmath219 in @xmath196 .
( the links of local developments for the complex of groups @xmath241 are described in the next example . )
the metric on @xmath196 induces a metric on the local development at @xmath54 .
we say that @xmath195 has _ nonpositive curvature _ if , for every @xmath229 , this induced metric on the local development at @xmath219 is locally @xmath153 .
a nonpositively curved complex of groups @xmath195 is developable ( theorem 4.17 , @xcite ) .
[ e : developable ] we continue the notation of definition [ d : gxy_0 ] above , and show that @xmath241 is nonpositively curved and thus developable . by section 4.20 of @xcite , it is enough to check that the local development at each vertex @xmath54 of @xmath45 , of type @xmath103 a _ maximal _ spherical subset of @xmath76 , is locally @xmath153 . by
gromov s link condition ( see @xcite ) , for this , it suffices to show that the link of the local development at @xmath54 in @xmath241 is @xmath253 .
now , for each proper subset @xmath221 of @xmath103 , there is a unique vertex of @xmath45 adjacent to @xmath54 of type @xmath221 . in particular , for each @xmath187 , there is a unique vertex of @xmath45 adjacent to @xmath54 of type @xmath254 .
it follows , by the construction of @xmath241 and section 4.20 of @xcite , that the link of the local development at @xmath54 is the join of @xmath184 sets of points , of respective cardinalities @xmath255 .
that is , the link of the local development at @xmath54 is the same as the link of a vertex of type @xmath103 in the building @xmath1 . as described in section [ sss : local ] above , the vertices of type @xmath103 in @xmath1 have links which are spherical buildings .
so these links are @xmath253 .
hence @xmath241 is nonpositively curved , and thus developable .
the _ fundamental group @xmath256 _ of a complex of groups @xmath195 is defined so that if @xmath195 is a simple complex of groups and @xmath196 is simply connected , then @xmath256 is isomorphic to the direct limit of the family of groups @xmath228 and monomorphisms @xmath252 .
since the chamber @xmath257 is contractible , the fundamental group @xmath258 is the graph product of the finite cyclic groups @xmath259 .
that is , @xmath5 is the quotient of the free product of the groups @xmath259 by the normal subgroup generated by all commutators of the form @xmath260 $ ] with @xmath261 , @xmath262 and @xmath64 .
if @xmath195 is a developable complex of groups , then it has a _ universal cover _ @xmath263 .
this is a connected , simply - connected scwol , equipped with an action of @xmath256 , so that the complex of groups induced by the action of the fundamental group on the universal cover is isomorphic to @xmath195 . for each vertex @xmath54 of @xmath196 ,
the star of any lift of @xmath54 in @xmath263 is isomorphic to the local development of @xmath195 at @xmath54 . by the discussion in example [ e : developable ] above
, the complex of groups @xmath241 is developable . by abuse of notation ,
denote by @xmath1 the universal cover of @xmath241 . since the vertices of @xmath45 are equipped with types @xmath218 ,
the complex of groups @xmath241 is of _ type @xmath55 _ in the sense defined in section 1.5 of gaboriau
paulin @xcite . as discussed above , the links of vertices of @xmath45 in their local development
are @xmath253 spherical buildings . by an easy generalization of theorem 2.1 of @xcite
, it follows that the universal cover @xmath1 is a building of type @xmath55 .
( section 3.3 of @xcite treats the case of right - angled hyperbolic buildings . ) by construction , the building @xmath1 is regular , with each mirror of type @xmath83 contained in exactly @xmath264 distinct chambers .
hence by theorem [ t : rabeu ] above , @xmath1 is the unique regular right - angled building of type @xmath55 and parameters @xmath265 .
let @xmath195 be a developable complex of groups over @xmath196 , with universal cover @xmath1 and fundamental group @xmath13 .
we say that @xmath195 is _ faithful _ if the action of @xmath13 on @xmath1 is faithful , in which case @xmath13 may be identified with a subgroup of @xmath193 .
if @xmath1 is locally finite , then with the compact - open topology on @xmath193 , by the discussion in section [ ss : lattices ] above the subgroup @xmath266 is discrete if and only if all local groups of @xmath195 are finite , and a discrete subgroup @xmath13 is a uniform lattice in @xmath193 if and only if the quotient @xmath267 is compact . since the local group in @xmath241 at the vertex of type @xmath116 of @xmath45 is trivial , the fundamental group @xmath3 acts faithfully on the universal cover @xmath1 .
since @xmath241 is a complex of finite groups , @xmath3 is discrete , and since @xmath45 is compact , @xmath3 is a uniform lattice in @xmath193 .
we call @xmath3 the _ standard uniform lattice_. in this section we state necessary definitions and results from covering theory for complexes of groups . as in section
[ ss : complexes_of_groups ] above , all references to @xcite are to chapter iii.@xmath194 .
we first recall the definitions of morphisms and coverings of complexes of groups . in each of the definitions below ,
@xmath196 and @xmath268 are scwols , @xmath269 is a simple complex of groups over @xmath196 , and @xmath270 is a complex of groups over @xmath268 .
( we will only need morphisms and coverings from simple complexes of groups @xmath195 . )
[ d : morphism ] let @xmath271 be a morphism of scwols ( see section 1.5 of @xcite ) .
a _ morphism _ @xmath272 over @xmath273 consists of : 1 . a homomorphism @xmath274 for each @xmath229 , called the _ local map _
at @xmath54 ; and 2 .
[ i : commuting ] an element @xmath275 for each @xmath231 , such that the following diagram commutes @xmath276 ^ -{\phi_{i(a ) } } \ar[rrr]^{\psi_a } & & & g_{t(a ) } \ar[d]^-{\phi_{t(a ) } } \\
h_{f(i(a ) ) } \ar[rrr]^{{\ensuremath{\operatorname{ad}}}(\phi(a))\circ \theta_{f(a ) } } & & & h_{f(t(a ) ) } } \ ] ] and for all pairs of composable edges @xmath203 in @xmath226 , @xmath277 a morphism is _ simple _ if each element @xmath278 is trivial .
if @xmath273 is an isomorphism of scwols , and each @xmath279 an isomorphism of the local groups , then @xmath134 is an _ isomorphism of complexes of groups_. [ d : covering ] a morphism @xmath280 over @xmath281 is a _ covering of complexes of groups _ if further : 1 .
each @xmath279 is injective ; and 2 .
[ i : covbijection ] for each @xmath229 and @xmath282 such that @xmath283 , the map of cosets @xmath284 induced by @xmath285 is a bijection .
we will need the following general result on functoriality of coverings , which is implicit in @xcite , and stated and proved explicitly in @xcite .
[ t : coverings ] let @xmath195 and @xmath286 be complexes of groups over scwols @xmath196 and @xmath268 and let @xmath280 be a covering of complexes of groups . if @xmath195 has nonpositive curvature ( hence is developable ) then @xmath286 has nonpositive curvature , hence @xmath286 is developable .
moreover , @xmath134 induces a monomorphism of fundamental groups @xmath287 and an @xmath288equivariant isomorphism of universal covers @xmath289 see @xcite for the definition of an @xmath36sheeted covering of complexes of groups , and the result that if @xmath290 is an @xmath36sheeted covering then the monomorphism @xmath291 in theorem [ t : coverings ] above embeds @xmath256 as an index @xmath36 subgroup of @xmath292 .
the theory of group actions on complexes of groups was introduced in @xcite .
let @xmath195 be a complex of groups .
an _ automorphism _ of @xmath195 is an isomorphism @xmath293 .
the set of all automorphisms of @xmath195 forms a group under composition , denoted @xmath294 .
a group _ @xmath295 acts on @xmath195 _ if there is a homomorphism @xmath296 .
if @xmath295 acts on @xmath195 , then in particular @xmath295 acts on the scwol @xmath196 in the sense of definition [ d : action_on_scwol ] above , so we may say that the @xmath295action on @xmath196 _ extends to an action on @xmath195_. denote by @xmath297 the automorphism of @xmath195 induced by @xmath298 .
we say that the _ @xmath295action on @xmath195 is by simple morphisms _ if each @xmath297 is a simple morphism .
[ t : group_action ] let @xmath195 be a simple complex of groups over a connected scwol @xmath196 .
suppose that the action of a group @xmath295 on @xmath196 extends to an action by simple morphisms on @xmath195 .
then the @xmath295action on @xmath195 induces a complex of groups @xmath286 over @xmath299 , well - defined up to isomorphism of complexes of groups , such that : * if @xmath195 is faithful and the @xmath295action on @xmath196 is faithful then @xmath286 is faithful ; * there is a covering of complexes of groups @xmath290 ; and * if @xmath286 is developable and @xmath295 fixes a point of @xmath196 , then @xmath300 .
in particular , if the covering @xmath290 is finite - sheeted , as occurs for example if @xmath195 is a complex of finite groups over a finite scwol @xmath196 , then @xmath256 is a finite index subgroup of @xmath292 .
let @xmath0 be the group of automorphisms of a locally finite polyhedral complex @xmath1 ( not necessarily a building ) , and suppose @xmath17 is compact . in this section
we show that for any uniform lattice @xmath13 of @xmath0 , the normalizer @xmath12 is discrete .
recall from section [ ss : lattices ] above that a uniform lattice @xmath13 in @xmath16 acts cocompactly on @xmath1 , and fix a compact fundamental domain @xmath301 for this action .
[ l : zdiscrete ] the centralizer of @xmath13 in @xmath0 , denoted @xmath302 , is discrete in @xmath0 .
suppose otherwise .
then there is a sequence @xmath303 with @xmath304 .
since @xmath301 is compact , it follows that for @xmath305 sufficiently large @xmath306 .
let @xmath307 . as @xmath301 is a @xmath13fundamental domain , @xmath308 for some @xmath309 , that is , @xmath310 .
it follows that @xmath311 , so @xmath312 as @xmath313 .
thus @xmath314 for all @xmath307 so @xmath315 , a contradiction .
[ p : ndiscrete ] the uniform lattice @xmath13 is a finite index subgroup of its normalizer @xmath12 . in particular , @xmath12 is discrete in @xmath0 . by lemma [ l : zdiscrete ] , it follows directly from proposition 6.2(c ) of @xcite that @xmath12 is also discrete .
since @xmath316 , the group @xmath12 is also a uniform lattice in @xmath0 .
the ratio of covolumes of @xmath13 and @xmath12 gives the index of @xmath13 in @xmath12 .
in particular , this index is finite .
we now sketch an alternative argument for @xmath12 being discrete , which was suggested to us by g. christopher hruska , and uses the theory of group actions on complexes of groups ( section [ ss : group_actions ] above ) .
a uniform lattice @xmath13 of @xmath16 is the fundamental group of a complex of groups @xmath195 , where @xmath317 is compact and the local groups of @xmath195 are finite .
thus the group @xmath294 of automorphisms of @xmath195 is a finite group .
any element @xmath318 induces an automorphism of @xmath196 , and this automorphism extends to an action on the complex of groups @xmath195 ( not necessarily by simple morphisms ) .
the induced action of @xmath42 on @xmath195 is trivial if and only if @xmath319 , so we have an isomorphism @xmath320 , hence @xmath12 is discrete .
we now introduce the technique of unfolding " , which will be used in our proofs in sections [ s : proof ] and [ s : applications ] below .
let @xmath1 be a regular right - angled building .
we first , in section [ ss : clumps ] , define _ clumps _ , which are a class of subcomplexes of @xmath1 that includes the combinatorial balls @xmath47 . for each clump
@xmath194 we then construct a canonical complex of groups @xmath321 over @xmath194 , and we define a clump @xmath194 to be _ admissible _ if @xmath321 is developable with universal cover @xmath1 . in section [ ss :
unfoldingclumps ] , we define the _ unfolding _ of a clump @xmath194 . the main result of this section is proposition [ p : unfolding_admissible ] , which shows that if @xmath194 is admissible then any unfolding of @xmath194 is also admissible . finally , in section [ ss : unfoldingscover ] , we prove in proposition [ p : unfoldings_cover ] that if @xmath194 is a clump obtained by a finite sequence of unfoldings of the chamber @xmath45 , then there is a covering of complexes of groups @xmath322 . as a corollary , we obtain a sequence @xmath6 of uniform lattices in @xmath16 , such that each @xmath6 has fundamental domain @xmath35 , and is of finite index in the standard uniform lattice @xmath5 .
let @xmath1 be a regular right - angled building of type @xmath55 . in this section ,
we define clumps , and for each clump @xmath194 construct a canonical complex of groups @xmath321 over @xmath194 .
we will say that two mirrors of @xmath1 are _ adjacent _ if the face which is their intersection has type @xmath103 with @xmath323 . since @xmath55 is right - angled , it is immediate that : if two adjacent mirrors are of the same type , then they are contained in adjacent chambers .
if two adjacent mirrors are of different types , then there is a chamber of @xmath1 which contains both of these mirrors .
[ d : clump ] let @xmath1 be a regular right - angled building of type @xmath55 . *
a _ clump _ in @xmath1 is a gallery - connected union of chambers @xmath194 such that at least one mirror of @xmath194 is contained in only one chamber of @xmath194 . *
the _ boundary _ of a clump @xmath194 , denoted @xmath324 , is the union of all the mirrors in @xmath194 each of which is contained in only one chamber of @xmath194 . * two mirrors in @xmath325
are _ type - connected _ if they are of the same type and are equivalent under the equivalence relation generated by adjacency . *
if @xmath194 is a clump , then a maximal union of type - connected mirrors in @xmath324 will be called a _ type - connected component _ or _ side _ of @xmath194 , and
the _ type _ of the side is the type of the mirrors in the side .
let @xmath194 be a clump in @xmath1 .
for a vertex @xmath326 of type @xmath103 , the _ boundary type _ of @xmath54 is the subset @xmath327 note that if @xmath328 , then the boundary type of @xmath54 is @xmath116 .
we now define a simple complex of groups @xmath321 over @xmath194 . for @xmath329 ,
let @xmath243 be the cyclic group @xmath330 .
for a vertex @xmath54 in @xmath194 , we denote by @xmath331 the local group at @xmath54 in @xmath321 .
then @xmath321 is defined as follows : * the local group @xmath331 at each vertex @xmath332 is trivial . *
the local group @xmath331 at a vertex @xmath333 of boundary type @xmath103 is the direct product @xmath334 * the monomorphisms @xmath252 are natural inclusions , for each edge @xmath199 in @xmath194 . *
the twisting elements @xmath235 are all trivial .
a clump @xmath194 is _ admissible _ if @xmath321 is developable and its universal cover is ( isomorphic to ) @xmath1 .
if @xmath194 is an admissible clump , then we may identify @xmath194 with a fundamental domain in @xmath1 for the fundamental group of @xmath321 .
the _ preimage _ or _ lift _ of a vertex @xmath335 in @xmath194 is the unique vertex @xmath336 of @xmath194 which is in the same orbit as @xmath54 under the action of the fundamental group of @xmath321 on @xmath1 .
lifts of edges and of chambers in @xmath194 are defined similarly .
the chamber @xmath257 is an admissible clump since @xmath241 is precisely the defining complex of groups for the standard uniform lattice @xmath5 ( see section [ ss : complexes_of_groups ] above ) .
figure [ f : nonadmissible ] below depicts the complex of groups @xmath321 over a clump @xmath194 in the product @xmath337 of regular trees of valences @xmath160 and @xmath338 respectively .
this clump is nonadmissible , since the link of the vertex @xmath54 in the local development of @xmath321 at @xmath54 is not a complete bipartite graph , so this link is not the same as the link of a vertex in @xmath1 . given an admissible clump , we now define a process , called _ unfolding _ , that yields larger admissible clumps .
in particular , as shown in lemma [ l : unfoldingyn ] below , by starting with @xmath45 and iterating this process , one can obtain each of the combinatorial balls @xmath35 .
the main result of this section is proposition [ p : unfolding_admissible ] below , which shows that if @xmath194 is admissible then any unfolding of @xmath194 is admissible .
hence each @xmath35 is admissible .
let @xmath194 be an admissible clump in @xmath1 , and let @xmath339 be a side of @xmath194 of type @xmath340 .
the _ unfolding _ of @xmath194 along @xmath339 is the clump @xmath341 [ l : unfoldingyn ] the combinatorial ball @xmath35 can be obtained by a sequence of unfoldings beginning with a base chamber @xmath45 . by induction
, it suffices to show that the combinatorial ball @xmath35 can be obtained from @xmath165 by a sequence of unfoldings .
let @xmath342 , @xmath343 denote the sides of @xmath165 .
first unfold @xmath165 along @xmath342 to obtain a new clump @xmath344 .
for @xmath345 , if @xmath346 does not intersect @xmath342 , then @xmath346 is also a side of @xmath344 .
otherwise , replace @xmath346 by the side of @xmath344 containing @xmath346 .
then unfold along the ( potentially extended ) side @xmath347 .
iterating this process , the clump @xmath194 obtained by unfolding along each of the ( extended ) sides @xmath348 is the combinatorial ball @xmath35 .
figure [ f : unfolding_ipq ] below illustrates this process for obtaining @xmath180 from @xmath45 in bourdon s building @xmath349 .
we say that a vertex @xmath54 in a clump @xmath350 is _ fully interior _ if every chamber in @xmath1 containing @xmath54 is in @xmath194 .
note that if some @xmath351 , then a vertex can be in @xmath352 without being fully interior .
however , if @xmath194 is admissible , then since @xmath1 is the universal cover of @xmath321 , but interior local groups in @xmath321 are all trivial , it follows that every interior vertex of @xmath194 is fully interior
. we call the local development at a vertex @xmath54 in @xmath321 _ complete _ if it is the same as the local development of a vertex of the same type in @xmath241 , that is , if it is the star of @xmath54 in @xmath1 .
we note that : [ l : complete_one_chamber ] if @xmath54 is a vertex of @xmath194 such that @xmath54 is contained in only one chamber of @xmath194 , then the local development of @xmath321 at @xmath54 is complete .
we next prove several lemmas which will be used in this section and in section [ ss : unfoldingscover ] below .
[ l : boundary_type ] let @xmath194 be an admissible clump and let @xmath333 be a vertex of type @xmath103 and boundary type @xmath353 . if @xmath354 , then every mirror of type @xmath83 in @xmath194 containing @xmath54 is actually contained in @xmath355 , and there are exactly @xmath356 such mirrors .
since @xmath194 is admissible , the local development of @xmath321 at @xmath54 is complete , so the link @xmath357 of @xmath54 in @xmath194 is the quotient of the link @xmath358 of @xmath54 in @xmath1 by the action of the local group @xmath359 .
now , as discussed in section [ sss : local ] above , @xmath183 is the join of @xmath184 sets of vertices @xmath185 for @xmath360 , of cardinalities respectively @xmath186 . by construction of @xmath321 ,
the action of the local group @xmath361 on @xmath183 is transitive on each set @xmath185 with @xmath362 , and is trivial on the sets @xmath185 for @xmath363 .
it follows that @xmath357 is also a join of @xmath184 sets of vertices : it is the join of a singleton set for each @xmath362 , along with the sets @xmath185 for @xmath363 . for each @xmath364 ,
the faces in @xmath365 corresponding to the @xmath83mirrors of @xmath194 which contain @xmath54 are precisely those faces in @xmath365 which are a join of @xmath366 vertices : the singleton sets corresponding to each @xmath367 , together with one vertex from each of the sets @xmath185 for @xmath363 .
there are @xmath368 such faces .
now , by construction of @xmath321 , a face @xmath369 in @xmath357 of type @xmath354 corresponds to a mirror in the boundary of @xmath194 if and only if its stabilizer in @xmath359 is nontrivial . since the action of @xmath359 fixes each vertex in the sets @xmath185 for @xmath363
, it follows that all such mirrors must be on the boundary of @xmath194 .
note that lemma [ l : boundary_type ] implies that for an admissible clump @xmath194 , the boundary type of a vertex @xmath54 of type @xmath103 is actually equal to @xmath370 this is not necessarily true in nonadmissible clumps .
for example , in figure [ f : nonadmissible ] , @xmath83 and @xmath84 are in the boundary type of @xmath54 even though neither every @xmath83 nor every @xmath84mirror in @xmath194 containing @xmath54 is contained in @xmath355 .
suppose @xmath371 is an admissible clump , that @xmath339 is a side of @xmath371 of type @xmath340 , and that @xmath372 .
let @xmath54 be a vertex in @xmath324 of type @xmath103 and let @xmath336 be the lift of @xmath54 to @xmath371 .
[ l : precedingboundarytype ] if @xmath373 denotes the boundary type of @xmath336 in @xmath371 and @xmath374 is the boundary type of @xmath54 in @xmath194 , then @xmath375 .
suppose @xmath376 .
then there are at least two @xmath83adjacent chambers in @xmath194 whose intersection contains @xmath54 .
the lifts of these chambers to @xmath371 are then @xmath83adjacent chambers in @xmath371 containing @xmath336 .
hence @xmath377 .
let @xmath378 denote the set of chambers in @xmath372 that are not also in @xmath371 , that is , @xmath378 is the set of `` new chambers '' in @xmath194 .
a _ sheet _ of chambers in @xmath378 is an equivalence class of chambers under the equivalence relation generated by @xmath379 adjacency in @xmath378 .
so two chambers in @xmath378 are in the same sheet if and only if there is a gallery of chambers in @xmath378 such that the type of each adjacency is in @xmath379 .
[ l : sheets ] if @xmath339 is a side of @xmath371 of type @xmath340 , there are @xmath380 sheets in @xmath378 .
choose @xmath381 a mirror of type @xmath340 .
there are @xmath380 chambers in @xmath378 glued along @xmath382 .
call these chambers @xmath383 .
since @xmath339 is type - connected , any @xmath384 is in the same sheet as some @xmath385 .
now suppose there are @xmath386 such that @xmath385 and @xmath142 are in the same sheet .
then there is a gallery of chambers in @xmath378 from @xmath385 to @xmath142 with the type of each consecutive adjacency being an element of @xmath379 .
the chambers @xmath385 and @xmath142 are @xmath340adjacent , since they are both glued to the mirror @xmath382 , so the sequence ( @xmath385 , @xmath142 ) is also a gallery in @xmath1 . by the definition of a building , and , more specifically , using the @xmath20valued distance function , it follows that @xmath340 is equal to a product of elements in @xmath379 .
this is a contradiction , since @xmath387 .
hence there are exactly @xmath380 sheets in @xmath378 , namely the equivalence classes of each of @xmath388 , @xmath389 , , @xmath390 .
we now prove the main result of this section , that unfolding preserves admissibility .
[ p : unfolding_admissible ] let @xmath391 be an admissible clump in @xmath1 .
if @xmath194 is a clump obtained from @xmath391 through a finite sequence of unfoldings , then @xmath194 is an admissible clump . by induction
, it suffices to show that if @xmath371 is an admissible clump and @xmath339 is a side of @xmath371 of type @xmath340 , then the clump @xmath392 is admissible , that is , that @xmath321 is developable with universal cover @xmath1 . we will show that for each maximal spherical subset @xmath154 , the local development at each vertex @xmath393 of type @xmath103 is complete .
it will then follow that @xmath321 is developable with universal cover @xmath1 , by similar arguments to those used for @xmath241 in section [ ss : complexes_of_groups ] above .
let @xmath54 be a vertex of @xmath194 of type @xmath103 a maximal spherical subset of @xmath76 . if @xmath394 , then the set of chambers in @xmath194 containing @xmath54 is the same as the set of chambers in @xmath371 containing @xmath54 .
thus the local development of @xmath321 at @xmath54 is the same as that of @xmath395 at @xmath54 , since the neighboring local groups are also all the same in the two complexes of groups .
hence by induction the local development at @xmath54 is complete .
thus it remains to consider the local developments of vertices in the side @xmath339 of @xmath371 and in @xmath396 .
we consider separately the three cases : case 1 : : @xmath397 case 2 : : @xmath398 case 3 : : @xmath399 as depicted in figure [ f : unfolding_cases ] below .
case 1 : : suppose @xmath397 is a vertex of type @xmath103 , and let @xmath353 be the boundary type of @xmath54 in @xmath194 .
if @xmath54 is contained in only one chamber of @xmath194 , then by lemma [ l : complete_one_chamber ] above we are done . otherwise , we first prove : + [ l : center ] let @xmath397 and suppose @xmath54 is contained in more than one chamber of @xmath194 .
then there is a unique vertex of type @xmath400 adjacent to @xmath54 in @xmath194 .
+ let @xmath388 and @xmath389 be two chambers of @xmath194 which contain @xmath54 .
let @xmath401 and @xmath402 be the lifts of @xmath388 and @xmath389 respectively to @xmath371 , and let @xmath336 be the lift of @xmath54 to @xmath371 .
+ since @xmath371 is admissible , the link @xmath403 of @xmath336 in @xmath371 is a join .
therefore there is a gallery @xmath404 in @xmath371 from @xmath401 to @xmath402 , of type say @xmath405 , such that each chamber of the gallery @xmath404 contains the vertex @xmath336 . without loss of generality
, we may assume that @xmath404 is a minimal gallery .
thus @xmath405 is a reduced word .
the vertex @xmath336 is of type @xmath103 , and every chamber in the gallery @xmath404 contains @xmath336 , hence every letter in the reduced word @xmath405 must be an element of @xmath103 .
+ the two chambers @xmath401 and @xmath402 both contain a mirror in the side @xmath339 .
since @xmath339 is a type - connected component of mirrors of @xmath371 , there is also a gallery @xmath406 in @xmath371 from @xmath401 to @xmath402 , such that every chamber in the gallery @xmath406 contains a mirror in the side @xmath339 .
let @xmath407 be the type of the gallery @xmath406 .
since @xmath339 is of type @xmath340 , it follows that every letter in @xmath407 commutes with @xmath340 .
+ we now have two galleries @xmath406 and @xmath404 from @xmath401 to @xmath402 in @xmath371 , of respective types @xmath407 and @xmath405 . by lemma [ l : coxeter ] above , since @xmath405 is reduced , every letter in @xmath405 appears in @xmath407 .
hence every letter in @xmath405 is contained in @xmath103 and commutes with @xmath340 .
+ now every letter in the type @xmath405 of @xmath404 commutes with @xmath340 , and the initial chamber @xmath388 of @xmath404 contains a mirror in the side @xmath339 .
so by induction , every chamber in the gallery @xmath404 contains a mirror in the side @xmath339 .
+ we claim that every letter in @xmath405 is actually contained in @xmath400 , where @xmath353 is the boundary type of @xmath54 in @xmath194 .
so suppose there is some @xmath408 such that @xmath84 appears in the reduced word @xmath405 .
denote by @xmath409 the boundary type of @xmath336 in @xmath371 . by lemma [ l : precedingboundarytype ]
, we have that @xmath410 .
so assume first that @xmath411 .
by lemma [ l : boundary_type ] , since @xmath371 is admissible , every mirror of @xmath371 of type @xmath84 which contains @xmath336 is in the boundary @xmath412 .
but the gallery @xmath404 is contained in @xmath371 , and every chamber in @xmath404 contains the vertex @xmath336 , so the gallery @xmath404 can not cross any mirror of type @xmath84 which also contains @xmath336 .
so @xmath84 can not be contained in @xmath409 .
+ we now have @xmath413 .
since @xmath408 , by definition there must be some chamber @xmath414 of @xmath194 which contains @xmath54 , such that the @xmath84mirror of @xmath414 is only contained in one chamber of @xmath194 .
let @xmath415 be a chamber of @xmath1 which is @xmath84adjacent to @xmath414 , and note that @xmath415 is not in @xmath194 .
let @xmath416 be the lift of @xmath414 to @xmath371 . since @xmath414 is in @xmath378 , the chambers @xmath414 and @xmath416 are @xmath340adjacent .
since @xmath371 is admissible and @xmath417 , there is a chamber say @xmath418 of @xmath371 such that @xmath418 is @xmath84adjacent to @xmath416 .
now , the letter @xmath84 commutes with @xmath340 , and @xmath416 has its @xmath340mirror contained in the side @xmath339 of @xmath371 .
hence the chamber @xmath418 of @xmath371 also has its @xmath340mirror contained in the side @xmath339 .
consider the gallery @xmath419 in @xmath1 .
this gallery has type @xmath420 . since @xmath84 commutes with @xmath340 , we have @xmath421 .
hence @xmath415 and @xmath418 are @xmath340adjacent .
therefore the @xmath340mirror of @xmath415 is contained in @xmath339 . but
this implies that @xmath415 is in @xmath194 , a contradiction .
we conclude that @xmath422 , as claimed .
+ we now have a minimal gallery @xmath404 of type @xmath405 from @xmath401 to @xmath402 in @xmath371 , such that every chamber in the gallery @xmath404 contains @xmath336 , every chamber in @xmath404 contains a mirror in the side @xmath339 , and every letter in @xmath405 is contained in @xmath400 and commutes with @xmath340 .
+ next consider the gallery @xmath423 from @xmath388 to @xmath389 obtained by concatenating the galleries @xmath424 , @xmath404 and @xmath425 .
let @xmath88 be the type of @xmath423 .
then since every letter in @xmath405 commutes with @xmath340 , @xmath426 since @xmath405 is a reduced word , it follows that there is a gallery , say @xmath427 , in @xmath1 from @xmath388 to @xmath389 of type @xmath405 .
but every letter in @xmath405 commutes with @xmath340 , so every chamber in @xmath427 has a mirror contained in the side @xmath339 .
thus the gallery @xmath427 is contained in @xmath194 .
that is , there is a minimal gallery @xmath427 from @xmath388 to @xmath389 in @xmath194 , of type @xmath405 , such that every letter in @xmath405 is in @xmath400 .
+ let @xmath428 and @xmath429 be the vertices of types @xmath400 in @xmath388 and @xmath389 respectively .
then since every letter in @xmath405 is in @xmath400 , every chamber in the gallery @xmath427 contains @xmath428 .
in particular , the chamber @xmath389 contains @xmath428 . hence @xmath430 .
we conclude that there is a unique vertex of type @xmath400 adjacent to @xmath54 in @xmath194 .
+ by lemma [ l : center ] and lemma [ l : boundary_type ] above , the link @xmath365 is a join of @xmath431 sets of vertices @xmath185 of cardinality @xmath338 for each @xmath432 , and a singleton @xmath433 for each @xmath354 .
this is precisely the quotient of the link @xmath358 of @xmath54 in @xmath1 by the group @xmath359 .
it follows that the local development of @xmath321 at @xmath54 is complete .
case 2 : : suppose @xmath434 .
recall that the side @xmath339 has type @xmath340 .
let @xmath329 be in the boundary type of @xmath54 in @xmath371 .
then there is a mirror @xmath435 of type @xmath83 containing @xmath54 .
if @xmath436 , then @xmath437 , so @xmath333 , a contradiction .
hence the boundary type of @xmath54 in @xmath371 is @xmath438 .
so the local group @xmath439 at @xmath54 in @xmath395 is @xmath440 .
note that if the type of @xmath54 in @xmath1 is also @xmath438 , then @xmath54 is the center of a @xmath340mirror in @xmath339 , so all the chambers in @xmath1 containing @xmath54 are in @xmath194 , by definition of the unfolding across @xmath339 .
suppose then that the type of @xmath54 is not @xmath438 .
let @xmath441 be a vertex of type @xmath340 in @xmath371 that is adjacent to @xmath54 . since @xmath441 is in @xmath339 , the local group at @xmath441 in @xmath395 is also @xmath440 , so in particular has index @xmath181 in the local group @xmath442 . by induction ,
the local development at @xmath54 in @xmath395 is complete , so it follows that every vertex of type @xmath340 adjacent to @xmath54 is in @xmath371 .
that is , every mirror of type @xmath340 containing @xmath54 is in @xmath371 .
thus every chamber of @xmath1 containing @xmath54 is either in @xmath371 or is adjacent to @xmath371 along @xmath339 .
hence every such chamber is contained in @xmath194 , so @xmath54 is fully interior in @xmath194 , and it follows that the local development of @xmath321 at @xmath54 is complete .
case 3 : : suppose finally that @xmath399 and let @xmath409 be the boundary type of @xmath54 in @xmath371 .
then the boundary type of @xmath54 in @xmath194 is so its local group in @xmath321 is @xmath443 .
now , since interior vertices of @xmath194 have trivial local groups in @xmath321 , the number of chambers in the local development of @xmath321 at @xmath54 is @xmath444 by lemma [ l : boundary_type ] , the number of chambers in the admissible clump @xmath371 containing @xmath54 is @xmath445 .
so by unfolding , we see that there are precisely @xmath446 chambers in @xmath194 containing @xmath54 .
it follows that the number of chambers in the local development of @xmath321 at @xmath54 is precisely @xmath447 .
in fact , we can describe the local structure at @xmath54 . + since @xmath371 is admissible , the link @xmath448 of @xmath54 in @xmath371 is @xmath449 .
this is the join of the sets @xmath185 for @xmath450 and singletons @xmath451 for @xmath452 . now
the local construction of @xmath194 from @xmath371 at @xmath54 consists of adding @xmath380 chambers along each @xmath340mirror in @xmath339 containing @xmath54 , so the link @xmath357 of @xmath54 in @xmath194 is as in lemma [ l : boundary_type ] above ; it is the join of the @xmath184 sets of vertices @xmath185 for @xmath432 and @xmath451 for @xmath362 .
it follows that the local development of @xmath321 at @xmath54 is complete , as required .
this completes the proof of proposition [ p : unfolding_admissible ] .
recall from section [ ss : complexes_of_groups ] above that the standard uniform lattice @xmath5 is the fundamental group of the complex of groups @xmath241 over a single chamber @xmath45 . in this section ,
we show that uniform lattices obtained via a sequence of unfoldings starting with @xmath241 are finite index subgroups of @xmath5 .
the main result is the following proposition : [ p : unfoldings_cover ] let @xmath453 , and suppose that , for all @xmath454 , @xmath455 is a clump obtained by unfolding @xmath456 along a side @xmath457 .
then there is a covering of complexes of groups @xmath458 . in particular ,
the fundamental group of @xmath459 is a finite index subgroup of @xmath5 . by lemma [ l : unfoldingyn ] above
, the combinatorial balls @xmath47 can be obtained by a sequence of unfoldings of @xmath45 .
let @xmath6 be the fundamental group of @xmath460 .
then @xmath6 is a uniform lattice in @xmath193 , and proposition [ p : unfoldings_cover ] immediately implies : [ c : gamma_n ] the lattices @xmath6 are finite index subgroups of @xmath5 .
a key step in the proof of proposition [ p : unfoldings_cover ] is provided by proposition [ p : labeling ] below , the proof of which is at the end of this section
. it will be convenient to think of all groups @xmath461 for @xmath154 as natural subgroups of the direct product @xmath462 .
[ p : labeling ] let @xmath455 be as in proposition [ p : unfoldings_cover ] above .
let @xmath463 be the natural morphism of scwols which sends a vertex of @xmath455 to the unique vertex of @xmath391 of the same type .
then there is an edge labeling @xmath464 satisfying all of the following : 1 .
[ i : one ] @xmath465 for each @xmath466 .
[ i : two ] for each pair of composable edges @xmath203 in @xmath467 , @xmath468 3 .
[ i : three ] for each @xmath469 and @xmath470 such that @xmath471 , the map @xmath472 induced by @xmath473 is a bijection .
we construct a covering @xmath474 over the natural morphism @xmath475 .
the local maps @xmath476 are defined to be the identity map ( if @xmath54 is of type the empty set , or if the boundary type of @xmath54 equals its regular type ) , or natural inclusions ( if @xmath54 is an interior vertex of type @xmath103 not the empty set , or if the boundary type of @xmath54 is a proper subset of its regular type ) . note that the maps @xmath476 so defined are injective ; by abuse of notation , we write @xmath42 for @xmath477 .
we now use the edge labeling @xmath478 provided by proposition [ p : labeling ] above to complete the definition of @xmath479 . since all local groups are abelian and the local maps @xmath476 are the identity or natural inclusions , the morphism diagram ( see ( 2 ) of definition [ d : morphism ] ) commutes no matter what the value of the @xmath480 .
from the properties of @xmath478 guaranteed by proposition [ p : labeling ] , it thus follows that @xmath479 is a covering of complexes of groups .
we proceed by induction on @xmath481 and write @xmath482 for the labeling of the edges of @xmath455 .
see figure [ f : labeling ] for an example . given an edge @xmath466 such that @xmath201 is a vertex of type @xmath103
, we will choose an element @xmath483 of @xmath484 .
recall that @xmath461 is the direct product of the cyclic groups @xmath485 for @xmath360 .
so , we can think of an element of @xmath461 as an ordered @xmath184tuple of elements of the cyclic groups @xmath485 . to define @xmath483
, it thus suffices to define elements @xmath486 for each @xmath360 .
we will refer to @xmath487 as the _ @xmath84component _ of @xmath483 . to begin the induction ,
let @xmath488 , with @xmath201 of type @xmath103 .
we define @xmath489 to be the identity element in @xmath461 .
properties ( 1)(3 ) in the statement of proposition [ p : labeling ] then hold trivially for @xmath490 with this labeling .
suppose now that we inductively have a labeling @xmath491 of @xmath492 satisfying properties in the statement of proposition [ p : labeling ] , and suppose @xmath455 is obtained from @xmath456 by unfolding along a side @xmath493 of type @xmath340 .
we first use the labeling @xmath491 to label the edges of @xmath494 .
that is , for all @xmath495 , define @xmath496 .
next , since @xmath456 is admissible , as in the proof of admissibility of unfoldings ( proposition [ p : unfolding_admissible ] above ) , we may think of @xmath455 as a subcomplex of the universal cover of @xmath497 .
for each edge @xmath498 there is then a unique preimage @xmath499 .
define @xmath500 . if @xmath501 then this is the labeling we choose for @xmath199 , that is , we set @xmath502 .
if @xmath503 but @xmath504 , then for @xmath505 we define the @xmath83component of @xmath483 to be the same as that of @xmath506 .
the @xmath340component @xmath507 is then defined as follows .
choose @xmath381 a mirror of type @xmath340 and let @xmath508 be the edge with initial vertex of type @xmath116 and terminal vertex the center of @xmath382 .
put @xmath509 , that is , @xmath42 is the @xmath340component of @xmath510 .
there are @xmath380 chambers in @xmath378 glued along @xmath382 .
call these chambers @xmath383 . for each of these new chambers ,
we assign distinct elements of @xmath511 , say @xmath512 is assigned to @xmath385 for @xmath513 , so that @xmath514 .
now , for all edges @xmath515 such that @xmath516 but @xmath517 , we define the @xmath340component @xmath518 .
we then extend these @xmath340components along the @xmath380 sheets of new chambers described in lemma [ l : sheets ] above .
that is , for a chamber @xmath384 in the same sheet as @xmath142 , and for @xmath519 such that @xmath520 but @xmath504 , we define @xmath521 .
we must verify that this is well - defined .
suppose @xmath522 for some other @xmath523 .
we will show that @xmath68 and @xmath148 are in the same sheet .
consider the link @xmath524 of @xmath200 in @xmath455 .
as in the proof of proposition [ p : unfolding_admissible ] above , since @xmath455 is admissible , this is the join of sets of vertices . in particular , the chambers @xmath68 and @xmath148 correspond to maximal simplices @xmath190 and @xmath192 in this join . a gallery in @xmath455 from @xmath68 to @xmath148 and containing
@xmath200 then corresponds to a sequence of maximal simplices in @xmath524 from @xmath190 to @xmath192 , which sequentially intersect along codimension one faces , that is , to a gallery in @xmath524 .
such a sequence exists since @xmath524 is a join .
hence there is a gallery in @xmath455 from @xmath68 to @xmath148 each chamber of which contains the vertex @xmath200 . since @xmath525
, this gallery can not cross @xmath339 .
it follows that @xmath68 and @xmath148 are in the same sheet , as required .
thus our assignment of the @xmath340component of @xmath483 , for edges @xmath526 with @xmath503 but @xmath525 , is well - defined .
this completes the definition of the labeling @xmath482 .
we now verify that @xmath482 satisfies properties in the statement of proposition [ p : labeling ] . for
, suppose @xmath466 .
that @xmath527 follows immediately from the above construction . for , for each pair of composable edges @xmath203 in @xmath467 we must show that @xmath528 .
if both @xmath199 and @xmath206 are in @xmath492 , then this follows by induction .
since pairs of composable edges occur in chambers , the only other possibility is that @xmath199 and @xmath206 are edges in the same chamber in @xmath378 .
it suffices to check that @xmath529 for all @xmath329 .
let @xmath530 and @xmath531 be the preimages of @xmath199 and @xmath206 in @xmath492 . by induction , @xmath532 .
the only possible difference between the labels @xmath483 and @xmath533 is in the @xmath340component , and similarly for @xmath206 and @xmath205 ( recall that the side @xmath339 along which we unfolded is of type @xmath340 ) .
hence it suffices to show that @xmath534 . by construction of @xmath482 ,
the only edges whose labels have different @xmath340components from those of their preimages are edges with terminal but not initial vertex in @xmath339 . for these edges
, we have shown that the @xmath340component is determined by the chamber containing the edge . moreover , for a pair of composable edges @xmath203 , either none of @xmath199 , @xmath206 , and @xmath205 have terminal but not initial vertex in @xmath339 , or @xmath205 and exactly one of @xmath199 and @xmath206 do . in the latter case , by construction ,
the @xmath340component of @xmath205 is equal to the @xmath340component of the other edge ( @xmath199 or @xmath206 but not both ) with terminal but not initial vertex in @xmath339 .
it follows that @xmath535 , as required . finally , for property in the statement of proposition [ p : labeling ]
, we show that for each @xmath469 and @xmath470 such that @xmath471 , the map of cosets @xmath536 induced by @xmath537 is a bijection . for this
, we assume that : @xmath538 so the codomain of @xmath539 is @xmath540 , and if @xmath541 then @xmath200 has type @xmath542 .
suppose @xmath543 . then by induction and the construction of @xmath482
, @xmath544 is bijective .
suppose next that @xmath545 .
recall that @xmath339 is a side of type @xmath340 .
if @xmath546 is the boundary type of @xmath54 in @xmath456 and @xmath547 the boundary type of @xmath54 in @xmath455 , then @xmath548 .
hence for all @xmath545 , @xmath549 denote by @xmath550 and @xmath551 the natural type - preserving morphisms of scwols .
assume first that @xmath552 .
then by lemma [ l : boundary_type ] above , since @xmath456 is admissible , @xmath553 for all edges @xmath199 in this set , by construction @xmath554 and @xmath555 by induction , the map @xmath556 is bijective .
therefore by equations and it follows that @xmath557 is bijective , as required .
now assume that @xmath558 .
then for all @xmath559 with @xmath560 , we have @xmath525 .
consider an edge @xmath561 with @xmath562 .
since @xmath563 , we now have @xmath564 . after unfolding ,
there are @xmath565 images of @xmath530 in @xmath378 , which we denote by @xmath566 . put @xmath567 .
then by construction , @xmath568 , and for each @xmath569 we have @xmath570 . using equation above
, there is thus a natural bijection @xmath571 induced by @xmath572 .
note also that , by construction of the labeling @xmath482 , we have @xmath573 for some element @xmath574 .
let @xmath575 be the disjoint union of the maps @xmath576 .
then @xmath575 is a bijection from the domain of @xmath557 to the domain of @xmath556 . by induction
@xmath556 is bijective . by equation above , the map @xmath557 factors through @xmath575 .
hence @xmath557 is bijective , as required .
we have now proved that @xmath557 is a bijection for all @xmath577 . for @xmath578 ,
let @xmath336 denote the unique preimage of @xmath54 in @xmath456 . if @xmath579 , then the local structure at @xmath54 in @xmath455 ( meaning the set of edges with terminal vertex @xmath54 , the local groups at the initial vertices of these edges , and the labels of these edges ) is identical to that at @xmath336 in @xmath456 .
it follows by induction that @xmath557 is bijective .
it remains to prove that @xmath557 is bijective for @xmath580 .
( note that @xmath54 is the same kind of vertex as in case 1 in the proof of proposition [ p : unfolding_admissible ] above . )
let @xmath547 be the boundary type of @xmath54 in @xmath455 .
[ l : uwell - defined ] suppose @xmath466 with @xmath581 , and that @xmath200 is of type @xmath582 where @xmath583 then the boundary type @xmath584 of @xmath200 in @xmath455 is given by @xmath585 in particular , for all such edges @xmath199 , the local group at @xmath200 in @xmath459 is the same .
if @xmath582 is the empty set then the boundary type @xmath586 is also empty and we are done .
so suppose there is some @xmath587 .
then there is an @xmath83mirror @xmath117 in @xmath455 which contains @xmath200 .
since @xmath588 and @xmath581 , the mirror @xmath117 also contains @xmath54 . by lemma [ l : boundary_type ] , since @xmath455 is admissible , @xmath83 is in @xmath589 if and only if @xmath590 .
it follows that @xmath83 is in the boundary type of @xmath200 if and only if @xmath83 is also in the boundary type of @xmath54 .
[ l : unique_tau ] let @xmath591 then there is a unique vertex of type @xmath582 in @xmath455 adjacent to @xmath54 .
since @xmath592 and @xmath455 is a gallery - connected union of chambers , there is at least one such vertex , say @xmath593 . by definition ,
the local group at @xmath54 in @xmath459 is @xmath594 and the local group at @xmath593 in @xmath459 is @xmath595 . since @xmath459 is admissible , there are thus @xmath596 vertices of type @xmath582 adjacent to @xmath54 in @xmath1 that lift to @xmath593 in @xmath455 .
but by admissibility of @xmath597 , the total number of vertices of type @xmath582 adjacent to @xmath54 in @xmath1 is @xmath598 .
since by lemma [ l : uwell - defined ] above @xmath599 it follows that @xmath593 is unique . for a subset @xmath600 ,
the _ projection _ of an element @xmath601 to @xmath602 , or the _ @xmath602projection _ of @xmath42 , is the projection of the ordered @xmath603tuple @xmath42 to the components corresponding to @xmath602 . to simplify notation , write @xmath604 .
[ l : coset_bijectivity_condition ] the map @xmath557 is bijective if and only if the set of labels @xmath605 has pairwise distinct projections to @xmath606 . by admissibility of @xmath455 ,
the two sets @xmath607 are finite sets of the same size .
so @xmath608 is a bijection if and only if it is injective .
note that @xmath609 and that by lemma [ l : uwell - defined ] above , for all @xmath610 with @xmath581 , we have @xmath611 .
let @xmath612 and @xmath613 be distinct edges in @xmath614 with @xmath615 .
suppose @xmath616 .
now @xmath617 if and only if @xmath618 . since @xmath461 is abelian , this equality of cosets holds if and only if @xmath619 .
so if @xmath539 is injective , then in particular , putting @xmath620 , it follows that for all @xmath621 , we have @xmath622 . hence @xmath623 .
that is , @xmath624 and @xmath625 have distinct @xmath606 projections .
conversely , suppose @xmath539 is not injective .
then there are edges @xmath612 and @xmath613 and elements @xmath626 such that @xmath627 .
then @xmath628 and so the two labels @xmath624 and @xmath625 have the same @xmath606 projections .
thus to prove that @xmath539 is a bijection , it suffices by lemma [ l : coset_bijectivity_condition ] to show that : for each pair of distinct edges @xmath629 with @xmath630 and @xmath631 , the labels @xmath624 and @xmath625 have distinct @xmath606 projections .
let @xmath632 , @xmath633 , and @xmath336 be the lifts of @xmath612 , @xmath613 , and @xmath54 , respectively , to @xmath456 , and let @xmath634 be the boundary type of @xmath336 in @xmath456 . by induction and lemma [ l : coset_bijectivity_condition ] ,
the @xmath635 projections of @xmath636 and @xmath637 are distinct . since @xmath638 , the labels @xmath624 and @xmath625 are the same as the labels @xmath636 and @xmath639 , respectively .
hence the @xmath635 projections of @xmath624 and @xmath625 are distinct .
now let @xmath593 be the unique vertex of type @xmath640 in @xmath455 adjacent to @xmath54 , as guaranteed by lemma [ l : unique_tau ] above .
let @xmath641 be the edge of @xmath455 with @xmath642 and @xmath643 .
since @xmath644 , there are edges @xmath645 and @xmath646 of @xmath455 such that @xmath647 and @xmath648 are vertices of type @xmath542 , and @xmath649 is of type @xmath582 .
we then have compositions of edges @xmath650 and @xmath651 , so by the already proved property ( 2 ) of the labeling @xmath482 , we find that @xmath652 and @xmath653 .
thus @xmath654 .
note that by definition of @xmath582 and lemma [ l : uwell - defined ] , @xmath655 .
so @xmath624 and @xmath625 have the same @xmath656 projections .
since they have different @xmath657 projections , it follows from lemma [ l : precedingboundarytype ] above that they have different @xmath606 projections , as required .
this completes the proof of proposition [ p : labeling ] .
we are now ready to complete the proof of the density theorem .
the main results we use are those of sections [ ss : covering_theory ] and [ ss : group_actions ] above , on coverings of complexes of groups and group actions on complexes of groups , and those of section [ s : unfolding ] above , on unfoldings . after proving the density theorem , in section [ ss : new_lattices ] below
we sketch how these techniques may be used to construct uniform lattices in addition to those needed for the proof .
let @xmath1 be a regular right - angled building of type @xmath55 with parameters @xmath161 ( see section [ ss : rabs ] ) .
let @xmath16 and let @xmath2 be the standard uniform lattice ( see section [ ss : complexes_of_groups ] ) .
let @xmath35 be the combinatorial ball in @xmath1 of radius @xmath39 , and let @xmath37 be the center of the chamber @xmath45 .
we first establish the following reduction : [ l : reduction1 ] to prove the density theorem , it suffices to show that for any @xmath658 , and for any integer @xmath39 , there is a @xmath659 such that @xmath660 let @xmath241 be the complex of groups defined in section [ ss : rabs ] above , with fundamental group @xmath5 .
let @xmath57 be the group of type - preserving automorphisms of @xmath1 .
then @xmath661 is the chamber @xmath45 . with the piecewise euclidean metric on @xmath1 provided by theorem [ t : metrize ] above
, the action of the full automorphism group @xmath0 on @xmath1 must preserve the cardinality of types of faces in @xmath1 .
hence the quotient @xmath17 is a further quotient of @xmath45 , by the action of the finite ( possibly trivial ) group of permutations @xmath662 let @xmath663 . by construction of @xmath241 , the action of @xmath295 on @xmath45 naturally extends to an action by simple morphisms on the complex of groups @xmath241 .
let @xmath664 be the complex of groups induced by the @xmath295action on @xmath241 .
let @xmath665 be the fundamental group of @xmath664 . by theorem [ t : group_action ] above , there is an induced finite - sheeted covering of complexes of groups @xmath666 .
hence by covering theory for complexes of groups , @xmath665 is a finite index subgroup of @xmath5 . in particular
, @xmath665 is commensurable to @xmath5 .
so @xmath667 .
since @xmath668 , it follows that @xmath669 thus we have equality of orbits @xmath670 , and so @xmath671 hence to show that @xmath26 is dense in @xmath0 , it is enough to show that @xmath672 is dense in @xmath673 . and for this , it suffices to prove the statement of this lemma . to continue with the proof of the density theorem , fix @xmath658 and @xmath39 , and
let @xmath460 be the canonical complex of groups over the combinatorial ball @xmath35 , as defined in section [ ss : clumps ] above .
let @xmath674 be the finite group obtained by restricting the action of @xmath675 on @xmath1 to @xmath35 , and note that @xmath676 .
[ p : action_extends ] the action of @xmath674 on @xmath35 extends to an action by simple morphisms on the complex of groups @xmath460 .
we first show : [ l : sides ] for all sides @xmath339 of @xmath35 and all @xmath677 , the image @xmath678 is also a side of @xmath35 .
that is , the action of @xmath674 takes sides to sides .
let @xmath339 be a side of @xmath35 , of type @xmath679 .
the automorphism @xmath680 of @xmath35 preserves the boundary @xmath681 , so for each mirror @xmath119 contained in @xmath339 , the mirror @xmath682 is in @xmath681 as well .
also , @xmath680 preserves adjacency of mirrors in @xmath35 ( recall that two mirrors are adjacent if their intersection is of type @xmath103 with @xmath323 ) . thus it suffices to show that if two @xmath84mirrors @xmath119 and @xmath683 of @xmath339 are adjacent , then the mirrors @xmath682 and @xmath684 have the same type .
let @xmath685 and @xmath686 be the chambers of @xmath35 containing @xmath119 and @xmath683 , respectively . as @xmath119 and @xmath683 are adjacent and of the same type , there is a unique @xmath79 , with @xmath64 , such that @xmath685 is @xmath83adjacent to @xmath686 .
thus the images @xmath687 and @xmath688 are @xmath689adjacent , for some @xmath690 . hence @xmath691 is a gallery of type @xmath689 in @xmath35 .
suppose the type of @xmath682 is @xmath340 and that of @xmath684 is @xmath692 , with @xmath693 .
since the mirrors @xmath682 and @xmath684 are adjacent and of distinct types , there is a chamber @xmath68 of @xmath1 ( not necessarily in @xmath35 ) which contains both @xmath682 and @xmath684 .
thus there is a gallery @xmath694 of type @xmath695 in @xmath1 .
but by the definition of the @xmath20distance function on @xmath1 , this means @xmath696 , which is impossible .
hence @xmath697 , as required .
we now , for each @xmath677 , define a simple isomorphism of complexes of groups @xmath698 . for each @xmath79 , fix a generator @xmath699 of the cyclic group @xmath700 .
let @xmath54 be a vertex of @xmath35 . by definition of the complex of groups
@xmath460 , if @xmath54 is in @xmath701 then @xmath702 is the trivial group .
now the vertex @xmath703 is in the boundary @xmath681 if and only if @xmath704 , so for all @xmath705 we may define the local map @xmath706 to be the trivial isomorphism .
if @xmath54 is in @xmath681 then @xmath707 to define the local map @xmath708 for @xmath704 , let @xmath709 be the boundary type of @xmath54 in @xmath35 and let @xmath710 be the boundary type of @xmath703 in @xmath35 .
let @xmath711 . then @xmath54 is contained in a side @xmath339 of @xmath35 of type @xmath84 . by lemma [ l : sides ] above , the image @xmath678 is a side of @xmath35
. denote by @xmath712 the type of the side @xmath678 . since @xmath680 is an automorphism of @xmath35 ,
the map @xmath713 is a bijection @xmath714 .
since @xmath680 is the restriction of an automorphism of @xmath1 to @xmath35 , for all @xmath715 , we have @xmath716 .
we may thus define the local map @xmath717 to be the isomorphism of groups @xmath718 induced by @xmath719 for each @xmath711 .
recall that all monomorphisms @xmath252 along edges in the complex of groups @xmath460 are the identity or natural inclusions . using this , it is not hard to verify that
@xmath297 so defined is a simple morphism of complexes of groups .
since @xmath680 is an isomorphism of @xmath35 and each local map @xmath720 an isomorphism of groups , it follows that @xmath297 is a simple isomorphism of the complex of groups @xmath460 .
moreover , for all @xmath721 , from the definition of composition of simple morphisms ( see @xcite ) it is immediate that @xmath722 .
hence the group @xmath674 acts on the complex of groups @xmath460 by simple morphisms .
to finish proving the density theorem , let @xmath6 be the fundamental group of @xmath460 . by corollary
[ c : gamma_n ] above , @xmath6 is a finite index subgroup of @xmath3 .
let @xmath723 , let @xmath48 be the complex of groups induced by the action of @xmath674 on @xmath460 , and let @xmath43 be the fundamental group of @xmath48 . since the induced covering of complexes of groups @xmath724 is finite - sheeted , @xmath6 is a finite index subgroup of @xmath43 .
therefore @xmath43 and @xmath5 are commensurable .
now the group @xmath674 is , by definition , the restriction of the group @xmath675 to the combinatorial ball @xmath35 .
hence @xmath674 fixes the basepoint @xmath37 , and so by theorem [ t : group_action ] above , @xmath674 injects into @xmath43 . since @xmath676
, it follows that there is an element @xmath725 such that @xmath726 .
but since @xmath43 and @xmath5 are commensurable , @xmath727 . by the reduction established in lemma [ l : reduction1 ] above , this completes the proof of the density theorem .
let @xmath1 be a regular right - angled building and let @xmath16 .
in this section we sketch how the techniques of unfoldings and group actions on complexes of groups may be combined to construct uniform lattices in @xmath0 in addition to the sequences @xmath6 and @xmath43 above .
let @xmath196 be any subcomplex of @xmath1 obtained by unfolding the chamber @xmath45 finitely many times .
let @xmath728 be the canonical complex of groups over @xmath196 defined in section [ ss : clumps ] above .
by proposition [ p : unfolding_admissible ] above , the fundamental group @xmath13 of @xmath195 is a uniform lattice in @xmath0 .
the possible fundamental domains @xmath196 for @xmath13 include many subcomplexes which are not combinatorial balls in @xmath1 .
now suppose @xmath295 is any ( finite ) group of automorphisms of the subcomplex @xmath196 . as in proposition
[ p : action_extends ] above , the action of @xmath295 on @xmath196 extends to an action by simple morphisms on the complex of groups @xmath195 .
let @xmath729 be the fundamental group of the induced complex of groups over @xmath730 .
then @xmath729 is also a uniform lattice in @xmath0 .
this construction thus yields many additional uniform lattices in @xmath0 .
in this section we give two further applications of the technique of unfoldings , which was developed in section [ s : unfolding ] above .
let @xmath1 be a regular right - angled building of type @xmath55 and parameters @xmath161 , as defined in section [ ss : rabs ] above .
let @xmath16 and let @xmath731 be the group of type - preserving automorphisms of @xmath1 . in section [ ss : discreteness ] we determine exactly when @xmath0 and @xmath61 are nondiscrete groups ( theorem [ t : autom_gp_intro ] of the introduction ) .
we then in section [ ss : strongly_transitive ] prove theorem [ t : transitive ] of the introduction , which states that @xmath0 acts strongly transitively on @xmath1 .
let @xmath52 be a polyhedral complex . recall that @xmath52 is _ rigid _ if for any @xmath53
, if @xmath42 fixes the star in @xmath52 of a vertex @xmath732 , then @xmath733 . if @xmath52 is not rigid it is said to be _
flexible_. for example , a complete graph is rigid , while a complete bipartite graph @xmath734 , with @xmath735 , is flexible .
[ t : autom_gp ] let @xmath1 be a regular right - angled building of type @xmath55 and parameters @xmath56 .
let @xmath16 and let @xmath57 be the group of type - preserving automorphisms of @xmath1 .
suppose @xmath20 is infinite and let @xmath52 be the nerve of @xmath55 . 1 .
[ i : both_nondiscrete ] if there are @xmath58 such that @xmath59 and @xmath60 then @xmath61 and @xmath0 are both nondiscrete .
[ i : mixed ] if all @xmath66 , then @xmath61 is discrete , and @xmath0 is nondiscrete if and only if @xmath52 is flexible .
[ i : last_case ] if there is some @xmath736 , and for all @xmath62 with @xmath63 we have @xmath64 for all @xmath65 , then @xmath61 is discrete , and @xmath0 is nondiscrete if and only if @xmath52 is flexible .
several results of @xcite imply that in case , the group @xmath61 is nondiscrete .
for example , the set of covolumes of lattices in @xmath61 contains arbitrarily small elements .
since a subgroup of a discrete group is discrete , the full automorphism group @xmath0 is thus nondiscrete as well .
suppose next that all @xmath66 .
then @xmath1 is just the davis complex @xmath69 for @xmath55 .
assume @xmath737 fixes a chamber @xmath68 of @xmath1 pointwise .
then for each @xmath79 , since @xmath66 there is a unique chamber @xmath738 of @xmath1 such that @xmath738 is @xmath83adjacent to @xmath68 . since @xmath739 preserves types and fixes @xmath68 pointwise , the element @xmath739 fixes each adjacent chamber @xmath738 pointwise as well .
by induction , @xmath739 fixes the building @xmath1 pointwise .
hence @xmath61 is discrete .
paulin @xcite proved that the full automorphism group @xmath740 is nondiscrete exactly when the nerve @xmath52 of @xmath55 is flexible .
suppose finally that we are in case . then in particular the set @xmath741 is a nonempty spherical subset of @xmath76 .
let @xmath194 be the clump obtained by unfolding the chamber @xmath45 along all of its mirrors of types @xmath187 ( in some order ) .
more precisely , @xmath194 is the clump obtained by unfolding @xmath45 along some sequence of ( possibly extended ) sides of types @xmath187 , as in the proof of lemma [ l : unfoldingyn ] above . by proposition [ p : unfolding_admissible ] above , the complex of groups @xmath321 is admissible .
hence @xmath194 is a strict fundamental domain for the action of a uniform lattice @xmath742 on @xmath1 , and so we may think of @xmath1 as tesselated by copies of @xmath194 . by lemma [ l : mirrors ] above , since @xmath103 is a nonempty spherical subset of @xmath76 , the union of mirrors @xmath743 of @xmath45 is contractible and thus connected .
therefore , every mirror of @xmath194 of type @xmath187 is in the interior of @xmath194 .
thus every side of @xmath194 is of type @xmath744 .
now suppose @xmath745 fixes @xmath194 pointwise .
let @xmath68 be a chamber of @xmath1 which is @xmath83adjacent to a chamber in @xmath194 , for some @xmath744 .
then since @xmath66 and @xmath739 is type - preserving , @xmath739 must fix the chamber @xmath68 pointwise . for each @xmath187 ,
let @xmath746 be the @xmath84mirror of @xmath68 . by hypothesis , @xmath64
, so the mirror @xmath746 of @xmath68 is adjacent to a mirror ( of type @xmath83 ) in @xmath325 .
thus any chamber of @xmath1 which is @xmath84adjacent to @xmath68 is @xmath83adjacent to a chamber in @xmath194 .
since @xmath66 , it follows that any chamber of @xmath1 which is @xmath84adjacent to @xmath68 , for @xmath187 , must also be fixed pointwise by the element @xmath739 .
hence @xmath739 fixes pointwise the copy of @xmath194 in @xmath1 which contains the chamber @xmath68 .
we have shown that for all @xmath744 , every copy of @xmath194 in @xmath1 which is @xmath83adjacent to the original clump @xmath194 is also fixed pointwise by @xmath739 . by induction , @xmath747 .
thus the group @xmath61 of type - preserving automorphisms of @xmath1 is discrete .
the proof that @xmath15 is nondiscrete if and only if @xmath52 is flexible is by similar arguments to those of haglund
paulin @xcite .
since @xmath61 acts transitively on the set of chambers of @xmath1 , it is enough to show .
we fix an increasing sequence of subcomplexes @xmath751 of @xmath1 such that @xmath751 is a clump obtained by @xmath36 unfoldings of @xmath453 and @xmath752 . [
l : transitive ] let @xmath69 and @xmath753 be distinct apartments of @xmath1 which contain @xmath45 . let @xmath754 be the smallest integer such that @xmath755 .
then there is an element @xmath756 such that @xmath757 fixes pointwise the clump @xmath758 , and @xmath759 .
suppose @xmath760 is obtained from @xmath761 by unfolding along a side @xmath339 of type @xmath340 .
recall from lemma [ l : sheets ] above that @xmath378 , the set of new chambers " in @xmath760 , consists of @xmath762 sheets .
since @xmath755 , the sets of chambers @xmath763 and @xmath764 belong to different sheets in @xmath378 .
now , for each sheet in @xmath378 , the set of chambers in this sheet is in bijection with the set of mirrors in @xmath339 .
hence , for any two sheets in @xmath378 , there is a type - preserving element @xmath765 such that @xmath766 fixes @xmath761 pointwise , and @xmath766 exchanges these two sheets .
since @xmath767 , the set of mirrors in @xmath339 contained in @xmath69 is equal to the set of mirrors in @xmath339 contained in @xmath753 .
thus @xmath766 exchanges the sets of chambers @xmath768 and @xmath764 .
so @xmath766 fixes @xmath761 pointwise , and @xmath769 .
consider the group @xmath770 generated by @xmath766 . by similar arguments to the proof of proposition [ p : action_extends ] above , the action of @xmath770 on @xmath760 extends to an action by simple morphisms on the complex of groups @xmath771 .
since the group @xmath772 fixes @xmath758 pointwise , in particular it fixes the point @xmath37 . by theorem [ t : group_action ] above , the group @xmath772 thus injects into the fundamental group of the induced complex of groups .
denote by @xmath757 the image of @xmath766 in this fundamental group . by construction
, @xmath757 fixes @xmath773 pointwise , hence @xmath756 , and @xmath774 as required . to construct the sequence @xmath781 ,
let @xmath782 be the smallest integer such that @xmath783 .
for each @xmath784 we define @xmath775 to be @xmath785 .
let @xmath757 be the element of @xmath786 constructed in lemma [ l : transitive ] above .
then for each @xmath787 we have @xmath776 , and for all @xmath788 we have @xmath789 .
for @xmath790 , assume inductively that for @xmath791 there are elements @xmath792 in @xmath786 such that @xmath793 , and @xmath794 . to construct the next element @xmath795 , note that since @xmath796 the apartments @xmath797 and @xmath753 have the same intersection with @xmath798 .
if in addition the apartments @xmath797 and @xmath753 have the same intersection with the next clump @xmath799 , we put @xmath800 and are done . if not , then @xmath801 is the smallest integer such that the apartments @xmath797 and @xmath753 have distinct intersection with @xmath799 .
hence by lemma [ l : transitive ] above , there is an element @xmath802 such that @xmath803 fixes pointwise @xmath804 , and @xmath805 .
we then define @xmath806 to be the product @xmath807 , and have that @xmath808 since @xmath803 fixes pointwise @xmath798 , the restriction of @xmath809 to the clump @xmath798 is the same as that of @xmath810 .
hence the element @xmath811 has the required properties .
we have thus constructed a sequence @xmath781 satisfying and above . by definition of the topology on @xmath61 ,
the compact subgroup @xmath786 of @xmath61 is complete .
the sequence @xmath781 in @xmath786 that we have constructed is a cauchy sequence , by above .
hence there is an element @xmath812 such that @xmath813 .
we conclude that @xmath786 acts transitively on the set of apartments containing @xmath45 .
b. farb , g. c. hruska , and a. thomas , _ problems on automorphism groups of nonpositively curved polyhedral complexes and their lattices _ , to appear in festschrift for robert zimmer s 60th birthday , arxiv:0803.2484 .
a. lubotzky , _ tree - lattices and lattices in lie groups _ , combinatorial and geometric group theory ( edinburgh , 1993 ) , 217232 , london math .
lecture note ser .
, 204 , cambridge univ . press , cambridge , 1995 . | let @xmath0 be the automorphism group of a regular right - angled building @xmath1 .
the
standard uniform lattice " @xmath2 is a canonical graph product of finite groups , which acts discretely on @xmath1 with quotient a chamber .
we prove that the commensurator of @xmath3 is dense in @xmath0 . for this
, we develop a technique of unfoldings " of complexes of groups .
we use unfoldings to construct a sequence of uniform lattices @xmath4 , each commensurable to @xmath5 , and then apply the theory of group actions on complexes of groups to the sequence @xmath6 . as further applications of unfoldings ,
we determine exactly when the group @xmath0 is nondiscrete , and we prove that @xmath0 acts strongly transitively on @xmath1 . |
the gaas / algaas quasi two - dimensional electron system has served as the basis for many interesting developments in modern condensed matter physics.@xcite in the recent past , photo - excited transport studies in this system have become a topic of experimental@xcite and theoretical@xcite interest since the observation of zero - resistance states and associated magneto - resistance oscillations in the microwave excited two - dimensional electron system.@xcite .
periodic in @xmath3 radiation - induced magnetoresistance oscillations , which lead into the radiation - induced zero - resistance states , are now understood to be a consequence of radiation - frequency ( @xmath4 ) , and magnetic field ( @xmath5 ) dependent , scattering at impurities @xcite and/or a change in the distribution function,@xcite while vanishing resistance is thought to be an outcome of negative resistance instability and current domain formation.@xcite although there has been much progress in this field , there remain many aspects , such as indications of activated transport , the overlap with quantum hall effect , and the influence of the scattering lifetimes , that could be better understood from both the experimental and theoretical perspectives .
a further topic of experimental interest is to examine the possibility of electron heating , as theory has,@xcite in consistency with common experience , indicated the possibility of microwave - induced electron heating in the high mobility 2des in the regime of the radiation - induced magnetoresistance oscillations .
not surprisingly , under steady state microwave excitation , the 2des can be expected to absorb energy from the radiation field . at the same time
, electron - phonon scattering can serve to dissipate this surplus energy onto the host lattice .
al @xcite have determined the electron temperature , @xmath6 , by balancing the energy dissipation to the lattice and the energy absorption from the radiation field , while including both intra - landau level and inter - landau level processes .
in particular , they showed that the electron temperature , @xmath6 , the longitudinal magnetoresistance , @xmath7 , and the energy absorption rate , @xmath8 , can exhibit remarkable correlated non - monotonic variation vs. @xmath9 , where @xmath0 is the cyclotron frequency , and @xmath10 , with @xmath4 the radiation frequency.@xcite in such a situation , some questions of experimental interest then are : ( a ) how to probe and measure electron heating in the microwave - excited 2des ?
( b ) what is the magnitude of electron heating under typical experimental conditions ? finally , ( c ) is significant electron heating a general characteristic in microwave radiation - induced transport ?
an approach to the characterization of electron - heating could involve a study of the amplitude of the shubnikov - de haas ( sdh ) oscillations , that also occur in @xmath7 in the photo - excited specimen .
typically , sdh oscillations are manifested at higher magnetic fields , @xmath5 , than the radiation - induced magnetoresistance oscillations , i.e. , @xmath11 , especially at low microwave frequencies , say @xmath12 at @xmath13 . on the other hand , at higher @xmath4 , sdh oscillations can extend into the radiation - induced magneto - resistance oscillations . in a previous study , ref.@xcite has reported that sdh oscillation amplitude scales linearly with the average background resistance in the vicinity of the radiation - induced resistance minima , indicating the sdh oscillations vanish in proportion to the background resistance at the centers of the radiation - induced zero - resistance states .
kovalev et .
al @xcite have reported the observation of a node in the sdh oscillations at relatively high-@xmath4 .
@xcite discuss sdh damping and a strong suppression of magnetoresistance in a regime where microwaves induce intra - landau - level transitions .
both ref.@xcite and ref .
@xcite examined the range of @xmath14 , whereas ref.@xcite examined the @xmath15 regime . from the theoretical perspective , lei et al .
have suggested that a modulation of sdh oscillation amplitude in @xmath7 results from microwave - electron heating .
further , they have shown that , in @xmath16 regime , both @xmath6 and @xmath8 exhibit similar oscillatory features , while in @xmath17 regime , both @xmath6 and @xmath8 exhibit a relatively flat response .
= 2.5 in = 2.5 in = 2.5 in = 2.5 in here , we investigate the effect of microwaves on the sdh oscillations over @xmath18 , i.e. , @xmath19 , where @xmath20 , @xmath21 is the effective electron mass , and @xmath22 is the electron charge@xcite . in particular , we compare the relative change in the sdh oscillation amplitude due to lattice temperature changes in the dark , with changes in the sdh amplitude under microwave excitation at different microwave power levels , at a constant bath temperature .
from such a study , we extract the change in the electron temperature , @xmath23 , induced by microwaves . in good agreement with theory ,
the results indicate @xmath24 over the examined regime .
the lock - in based electrical measurements were performed on hall bar devices fabricated from high quality gaas / algaas heterostructures .
experiments were carried out with the specimen mounted inside a waveguide and immersed in pumped liquid helium .
the frequency spanned @xmath25 at source power levels @xmath26 .
magnetic - field - sweeps of @xmath7 vs. @xmath27 were carried out at @xmath28 at @xmath29 , and at @xmath30 at @xmath31 and @xmath32 .
microwave - induced magneto - resistance oscillations can be seen in fig . 1 at @xmath33 t , as strong sdh oscillations are also observable under both the dark and irradiated conditions for @xmath34 .
over the interval @xmath18 , where the sdh oscillations are observable , one observes small variations in the background @xmath7 at higher power levels .
thus , a smooth @xmath7 background was subtracted from the magneto - resistance data .
figure 2 ( a ) - ( f ) shows the background subtracted @xmath7 , i.e. , @xmath35 , measured without ( fig .
2(a ) ) and with ( fig .
2(b)-2(f ) ) microwave radiation versus the inverse magnetic field , @xmath3 . to extract the amplitude of the sdh oscillations
, we performed a standard nonlinear least square fit ( nlsf ) on @xmath36 data with a exponentially damped sinusoid , i.e. , @xmath37 . here , @xmath38 is the amplitude , @xmath39 is the sdh frequency , and @xmath40 is the damping factor .
the fit results for the dark - specimen @xmath35 data are shown in the fig .
2 ( a ) as a solid line . this panel suggests good agreement between data and fit in the dark condition .
similarly , we performed nlsfs of the @xmath35 sdh data taken with the microwave power spanning approximately @xmath41 , see fig .
2(b)- 2(f ) . since the parameters @xmath40 and @xmath39 are insensitive to the incident radiation at a constant temperature
, we fixed @xmath40 and @xmath39 to the dark - specimen constant values . in fig .
2 , panels ( b ) @xmath42 ( f ) show the @xmath43 @xmath35 data ( open circles ) and fit ( solid line ) obtained with @xmath44 for different power levels .
the sdh amplitude @xmath38 extracted from the nlsfs are exhibited vs. the microwave power in fig .
here , @xmath38 decreases with increasing microwave power .
our analysis of other power - dependent data ( not shown ) yielded similar results .
next , we examine the influence of temperature on the sdh oscillation amplitude . thus , fig.3(a ) shows @xmath7 vs. @xmath5 with the temperature as a parameter .
it is clear , see the black solid lines , that increasing the temperature rapidly damps the sdh oscillations at these low magnetic fields . in order to extract the sdh amplitude from these data
, we used the same fitting model , @xmath45 , as described previously .
but , for the @xmath46-dependence analysis , @xmath40 was separated into two parts , @xmath47 and @xmath48 , i.e. , @xmath49 , since we wished to relate the change in the sdh amplitude for a temperature increment to the observed change in the sdh amplitude for an increment in the microwave power at a fixed @xmath4 . here
@xmath47 represents the damping at the base temperature , and @xmath48 is the additional damping due to the temperature increment , @xmath50 = @xmath51 .
now the fit function becomes @xmath35 = @xmath52 = -@xmath53 .
here , @xmath54 represents the change in the sdh oscillation amplitude due to the @xmath50 .
note that the parameters @xmath47 and @xmath39 can be extracted from the @xmath7 fit at the lowest @xmath46 and set to constant values .
data fits to @xmath36 = -@xmath55 are included in fig .
3(a ) as colored solid lines .
thus , the nlsf served to determine @xmath56 at each temperature .
3(b ) shows the temperature dependence of @xmath56 , while the inset of fig .
3(b ) shows a semi - log plot of @xmath56 vs. @xmath46 .
the inset confirms an exponential dependence for @xmath56 on @xmath46 , i.e , @xmath57 .
experiments indicate that increasing the source - power monotonically decreases the sdh oscillation amplitude at the examined frequencies including @xmath31 ( see fig.2(g ) ) , @xmath32 and @xmath58 ( see fig.4(a ) ) . since increasing the temperature also decreases the sdh oscillation amplitude ( see fig.3(b ) ) , one might extract the electron temperature change under microwave excitation by inverting the observed relationship between @xmath56 and @xmath46 , i.e. , since @xmath59 , @xmath60 , where @xmath61 is a constant .
thus , the dark measurement of the sdh amplitude vs. the temperature serves to calibrate the temperature scale vs. the sdh amplitude , and the slope of the solid line in fig .
4(b ) reflects the inverse slope of fig .
3(b ) . also plotted as solid symbols in fig.4(b ) are the @xmath38 under microwave excitation at various frequencies and power levels . here
, one observes that the change in sdh amplitude induced by microwave excitation over the available power range is significantly smaller than the change in sdh amplitude induced by a temperature change of 0.9k . by transforming the observed change in @xmath38 between minimum- and maximum- power at each @xmath4 to a @xmath23
, we can extract the maximum @xmath23 induced by photo - excitation at each @xmath4 , and this is plotted in fig.4(c ) . although the power at the sample can vary with @xmath4 , even at the same source power ,
fig.4(c)indicates that the maximum @xmath23 scales approximately linearly with the peak source microwave power ( see fig.4(c ) solid guide line ) . from fig.4(c ) , it appears that @xmath62 .
according to theory,@xcitesteady state microwave excitation can heat a high mobility two - dimensional electron system .
the energy gain from the radiation field is balanced by energy loss to the lattice by electron - phonon scattering . in ref .
@xcite , lei et al .
suggest that longitudinal acoustic ( la ) phonons provide for more energy dissipation than the transverse acoustic ( ta ) phonons in the vicinity of @xmath63 in the gaas / algaas system , if one neglects the surface or interface phonons . at such low temperatures and modest microwave power , away from the cyclotron resonance condition , where the resonantly absorbed power from the microwave radiation is not too large , and the electron temperature remains well below about @xmath64 , the longitudinal optical(lo ) phonons do not influence the resistivity since the energy scale associated with lo - phonons is large compared to the energy scale for acoustic phonons . within their theory , lei et al.@xcite show that the electron temperature follows the absorption rate , exhibiting rapid oscillatory behavior at low @xmath5 , i.e. , @xmath65 , followed by slower variation at higher @xmath5 , i.e. , @xmath66 . indeed , even at the very high microwave intensities , @xmath67 , e.g. @xmath68 at @xmath32 , theory does not show a significant change in the electron temperature for @xmath69 except at @xmath70 .
thus , theory indicates that the electron temperature is nearly the lattice temperature in low @xmath67 limit especially for @xmath69 , i.e. , @xmath71 . in comparison , in these experiments , the source power satisfied @xmath72 , with @xmath73 , while the power at the sample could be as much as ten times lower due to attenuation by the hardware .
remarkably , we observe strong microwave induced resistance oscillations ( see fig.1 ) in the @xmath74 regime at these low intensities .
the results , see fig .
4(c ) , indicate just a small rise , @xmath75 , in the electron temperature , @xmath6 , above the lattice temperature , @xmath46 .
in summary , this experimental study indicates that the perceptible effect of the incident microwave radiation on the amplitude of the sdh oscillations over the regime @xmath2 , when the microwave excitation is sufficient to induce strong microwave induced resistance oscillations , corresponds to a relatively small increase in the electron temperature , in good agreement with theoretical predictions . | we examine the influence of microwave photoexcitation on the amplitude of shubnikov - de haas ( sdh ) oscillations in a two dimensional gaas / algaas electron system in a regime where the cyclotron frequency , @xmath0 , and the microwave angular frequency , @xmath1 , satisfy @xmath2 .
a sdh lineshape analysis indicates that increasing the incident microwave power has a weak effect on the amplitude of the sdh oscillations , in comparison to the influence of modest temperature changes on the dark - specimen sdh effect .
the results indicate negligible electron heating under modest microwave photoexcitation , in good agreement with theoretical predictions . |
ebola virus disease ( evd ) is caused by a genus of the family _ filoviridae _ called _ ebolavirus_. the first recorded outbreak took place in sudan in 1976 with the longest most severe outbreak taking place in west africa during 2014 - 2015 @xcite .
studies have estimated disease growth rates and explored the impact of interventions aimed at reducing the final epidemic size @xcite . despite these efforts , research that improves and increases our understanding of evd and the environments where it thrives is still needed @xcite . +
this chapter is organized as follows : section 2 reviews past modeling work ; section three introduces a single patch model , its associated basic reproduction number @xmath0 , and the final size relationship ; section four introduces a two - patch model that accounts for the time spent by residents of patch @xmath1 on patch @xmath2 ; section 5 includes selected simulations that highlight the possible implications of policies that forcefully restrict movement ( _ cordons sanitaires_);and , section 6 collects our thoughts on the relationship between movement , health disparities , and risk .
chowell et _ al . _
@xcite estimated the basic reproduction numbers for the 1995 outbreak in the democratic republic of congo and the 2000 outbreak in uganda .
model analysis showed that control measures ( education , contact tracing , quarantine ) if implemented within a reasonable window in time could be effective .
legrand et _ al . _
@xcite built on the work in @xcite through the addition of hospitalized and dead ( in funeral homes ) classes within a study that focused on the relative importance of control measures and the timing of their implementation .
lekone and finkenstdt @xcite made use of an stochastic framework in estimating the mean incubation period , mean infectious period , transmission rate and the basic reproduction number , using data from the 1995 outbreak .
their results turned out to be in close agreement with those in @xcite but the estimates had larger confidence intervals .
the 2014 outbreak is the deadliest in the history of the virus and naturally , questions remain @xcite .
chowell et _ al_. in @xcite recently introduced a mathematical model aimed at addressing the impact of early detection ( via sophisticated technologies ) of pre - symptomatic individuals on the transmission dynamics of the ebola virus in west africa .
patterson - lomba et _ al_. in @xcite explored the potential negative effects that restrictive intervention measures may have had in guinea , sierra leone , and liberia .
their analysis made use of the available data on ebola virus disease cases up to september 8 , 2014 .
the focus on @xcite was on the dynamics of the``effective reproduction number '' @xmath3 , a measure of the changing rate of epidemic growth , as the population of susceptible individuals gets depleted .
@xmath3 appeared to be increasing for liberia and guinea , in the initial stages of the outbreak in densely populated cities , that is , during the period of time when strict quarantine measures were imposed in several areas in west africa .
their report concluded , in part , that the imposition of enforced quarantine measures in densely populated communities in west africa , may have accelerated the spread of the disease . in @xcite
, the authors showed that the estimated growth rates of evd cases were growing exponentially at the national level .
they also observed that the growth rates exhibited polynomial growth at the district level over three or more generations of the disease .
it has been suggested that behavioral changes or the successful implementation of control measures , or high levels of clustering , or all of them may nave been responsible for polynomial growth .
a recent review of mathematical models of past and current evd outbreaks can be found in @xcite and references therein .
inspired by these results , we proceed to analyze the effectiveness of forcefully local restrictions in movement on the dynamics of evd .
we study the dynamics of evd within scenarios that resemble evd transmission dynamics within locally interconnected communities in west africa .
_ cordons sanitaire _ or `` sanitary barriers '' are designed to prevent the movement , in and out , of people and goods from particular areas .
the effectiveness of the use of _ cordons sanitaire _ have been controversial .
this policy was last implemented nearly one hundred years ago @xcite . in desperate attempts to control disease ,
ebola - stricken countries enforced public health officials decided to use this medieval control strategy , in the evd hot - zone , that is , the region of confluence of guinea , liberia and sierra leone @xcite . in this chapter , a framework that allows , in the simplest possible setting , the possibility of assessing the potential impact of the use of a _ cordon sanitaire _ during an evd outbreak , is introduced and `` tested '' .
the population of interest is subdivided into susceptible ( @xmath4 ) , latent ( @xmath5 ) , infectious ( @xmath6 ) , dead ( @xmath7 ) and recovered ( @xmath8 ) . the total population ( including the dead ) is therefore @xmath9 .
the susceptible population is reduced by the process of infection , which occurs via effective `` contacts '' between an infectious ( @xmath6 ) or a dead body ( @xmath7 ) at the rate of @xmath10 and susceptible .
evd - induced dead bodies have the highest viral load , that is , more infectious than individuals in the infectious stage ( @xmath6 ) ; and , so , it is assumed that @xmath11 .
the latent population increases at the rate @xmath12 . however
since some latent individuals may recover without developing an infection @xcite , it is assumed that exposed individuals develop symptoms at the rate @xmath13 or recover at the rate @xmath14 .
the population of infectious individuals increases at the rate @xmath15 and decreases at the rate @xmath16 .
further , individuals leaving the infectious stage at rate @xmath17 , die at the rate @xmath18 or recover at the rate @xmath19 .
the @xmath8 class includes recovered or the removed individuals from the system ( dead and buried ) . by definition the @xmath8-class increases , the arrival of previously infected , grows at the rate @xmath20 .
a flow diagram of the model is in fig .
[ flow1 ] , the definitions of parameters are collected in table [ tab : par ] , including the parameter values used in simulations where .variables and parameters of the contagion model . [ cols="<,<,^",options="header " , ] the mathematical model built from fig .
[ flow1 ] , that models evd dynamics is given by the following nonlinear systems of differential equations : @xmath21 the total population is constant and the set @xmath22 is a compact positively invariant , that is , solutions behave as expected biologically .
hence model ( [ ebolaasym ] ) is well - posed . following the next generation operator approach @xcite ( on @xmath5 , @xmath6 and @xmath7 ) ,
we find that the basic reproductive number is given by @xmath23 that is , @xmath0 is given by the sum of the secondary cases of infection produced by infected and dead individuals during their infection period .
the final epidemic size relation that includes dead ( to simplify the maths ) being given by @xmath24
the work of eubank _ et al . _
@xcite , sara de valle _ et al . _
@xcite , chowell _ et al . _
@xcite , and @xcite analyze heterogeneous environments .
castillo - chavez and song @xcite , for example , highlight the importance of epidemiological frameworks that follow a lagrangian perspective , that is , models that keep track of each individual ( or at least its place of residence or group membership ) at all times .
the figure [ lagmov ] represents a schematic representation of the lagrangian dispersal between two patches .
bichara _ et al . _
@xcite uses a general susceptible - infectious - susceptible ( sis ) model involving n - patches given by the following system of nonlinear equations : @xmath25 where @xmath26 , @xmath27 and @xmath28 denote the per - capita birth , natural death and recovery rates respectively .
infection is modeled as follows : @xmath29= \underbrace{\beta_j}_{\textbf{the risk of infection in patch $ j$ } } \times \underbrace{p_{ij}s_i}_{\textbf{susceptible from patch $ i$ who are currently in patch $ j$ } } \ ] ] @xmath30 where the last term accounts for the _ effective _ infection proportion in patch @xmath2 at time .
the model reduces to the single n - dimensional system @xmath31 with a basic reproduction number @xmath32 that it is a function of the risk vector @xmath33 and the residence times matrix @xmath34 , @xmath35 , where @xmath36 denotes the proportion of the time that an @xmath1-resident spends visiting patch @xmath2 . in @xcite
, it is shown that when @xmath37 is irreducible ( patches are strongly connected ) , the disease free state is globally asymptotically stable if @xmath38 ( g.a.s . ) while , whenever @xmath39 there exists a unique interior equilibrium which is g.a.s .
the patch - specific basic reproduction number is given by @xmath40 where @xmath41 are the _ local _ basic reproduction number when the patches are isolated .
this patch - specific basic reproduction number gives the dynamics of the disease at patch level @xcite , that is , if @xmath42 the disease persists in patch @xmath1 .
moreover , if @xmath43 for all @xmath44 and @xmath45 whenever @xmath46 , it has been shown @xcite that the disease dies out form patch @xmath1 if @xmath47 .
the authors in @xcite also considered a multi - patch sir single outbreak model and deduced the final epidemic size .
the sir single outbreak model considered in @xcite is the following : @xmath48 where @xmath49 , and @xmath50 and @xmath51 denotes the population of susceptible , infected and recovered immune individuals in patch @xmath1 , respectively .
the parameter @xmath52 is the recovery rate in patch @xmath1 and @xmath53 , for @xmath54 . in this chapter
we will be making use of this modeling framework , but with a slightly different formulation , to test under what conditions the movement of individuals from high risk areas to nearby low risk areas due to the use of _ cordon sanitaire _ , is effective in reducing _ overall _ transmission by considering two - patch single outbreak that captures the dynamics of ebola in a two - patch setting .
it is assumed that the community of interest is composed of two adjacent geographic regions facing highly distinct levels of evd infection .
the levels of risk account for differences in population density , availability of medical services and isolation facilities , and the need to travel to a lower risk area to work .
so , we let @xmath55 denote be the population in patch - one ( high risk ) and @xmath56 be the population in patch - two ( low risk ) . the classes @xmath57 , @xmath58 , @xmath59 , @xmath51 represent respectively , the susceptible , exposed , infectious and recovered sub - populations in patch @xmath1 ( @xmath54 ) .
the class @xmath60 represents the number of disease induced deaths in patch @xmath1 .
the dispersal of individuals is captured via a lagrangian approach defined in terms of residence times @xcite , a concept developed for communicable diseases for @xmath61 patch setting @xcite and applied to vector - borne diseases to an arbitrary number of host groups and vector patches in @xcite .
+ we model the new cases of infection per unit of time as follows : * the density of infected individuals mingling in patch 1 at time t , who are only capable of infecting susceptible individuals currently in patch 1 at time @xmath62 , that is , the _ effective _ infectious proportion in patch 1 is given by @xmath63 where @xmath64 denotes the proportion of time residents from patch 1 spend in patch 1 and @xmath65 the proportion of time that residents from patch 2 spend in patch 1 .
* the number of new infections within members of patch 1 , in patch 1 is therefore given by @xmath66 * the number of new cases of infection within members of patch 1 , in patch 2 per unit of time is therefore @xmath67 where @xmath68 denotes the proportion of time that residents from patch 1 spend in patch 2 and @xmath69 the proportion of time that residents from patch 2 spend in patch 2 ; given by the effective density of infected individuals in patch 1 @xmath70 while the _ effective _ density of infected individuals in patch 2 is given by @xmath71 further , since , @xmath72 and @xmath73 then we see that the sum of ( * ) and ( * * ) gives the density of infected individuals in both patches , namely , @xmath74 as expected .
if we further assume that infection by dead bodies occurs only at the local level ( bodies are not moved ) then , by following the same rationale as in model [ ebolaasym ] , we arrive at the following model : @xmath75 the difference , in the formulation of the infection term , from the one considered in @xcite is the _ effective _ density of infected . here ,
the _ effective _ density of infected in patch 1 , for example , is @xmath76 whereas in @xcite , it is @xmath77 focusing on the changes on @xmath78 and @xmath79 and making use of the next generation approach we arrive at the basic reproductive number for the entire system , namely , @xmath80 we see , for example , that whenever the residents of patch @xmath2 ( @xmath81 ) live in communities where travel is not possible , that is , when @xmath82 or @xmath83 , then the populations decouple and , consequently , we have that @xmath84 where @xmath85 for @xmath86 ; that is , basic reproduction number of patch @xmath1 , @xmath54 , if isolated . we keep track of the dead to make the mathematics simple .
that is , to assuming that the population within each patch is constant . and
so , from the model , we get that @xmath87 with initial conditions @xmath88
@xmath89 we use the above model to find an `` approximate '' final size relationship .
we make use of the notation @xmath90 for @xmath91 and @xmath92 for @xmath93 .
we see that our analysis results guarantee that if @xmath94 is a positive decreasing function then @xmath95 . since @xmath96 , then @xmath97 and since @xmath98
then @xmath99 .
if we now consider that @xmath100 then it follows that @xmath101 .
similarly , it can be shown that @xmath102 focusing on the first two equations of system ( [ ebopatchyfin ] ) , we arrive at @xmath103 consequently , since @xmath104 , we have that @xmath105 and therefore @xmath106 using the equation for @xmath107 , we find that @xmath108 similarly , we can deduce the analogous relationships for patch 2 , namely that , @xmath109 from the equation for susceptible populations in patch 1 , we have that @xmath110 and , therefore that , @xmath111 for the second patch , we have that @xmath112 rewriting the expressions of @xmath113 and @xmath114 in terms of @xmath115 , @xmath116 , @xmath117 and @xmath118 , we arrive at the following two - patch `` approximate '' ( since we are counting the dead ) , the final size relation . more precisely , with @xmath119 , we have that @xmath120 @xmath121 or in vectorial notation , we have that where @xmath122 furthermore , we note that @xmath123 also appears in the next generation matrix , used to compute @xmath124 .
further , we also have that , @xmath125 @xmath126 note that the vector in ( [ fsematrix ] ) is given by @xmath127 representing the proportion of people in patches one and two able to transmit ebola including transmission from handling dead bodies .
@xmath128 , @xmath129 , we conclude that the matrix @xmath130 and the next generation matrix have the same eigenvalues , a result also found in @xcite .
the basic model parameters used in the simulations are taken directly from the literature @xcite .
we consider two patches and , for simplicity , it is assumed that they house the same number of individuals , namely , @xmath131 .
however , implicitly , it is assumed that the density is considerably higher in the high risk area .
we assume that an outbreak starts in the high risk patch 1 with @xmath132 .
it propagates into patch 2 , low risk , defined by @xmath133 .
the difference between @xmath134 and @xmath135 or @xmath136 provides a rough measure of the capacity to transmit , treat and control ebola within connected two - patch systems .
the initial conditions are set as @xmath137 .
the local basic reproductive numbers for each patch under isolation are @xmath138 and @xmath139 .
we chose to report on three different mobility scenarios : one way movement , symmetric and asymmetric mobility .
for the first case , only residents from patch 1 travel , that is @xmath140 and @xmath141 . given
that patch 1 is facing an epidemic , it is reasonable to assume that people in patch 2 prefer to avoid traveling to patch 1 , and so , it is reasonable to assume that @xmath141 .
mobility is allowed in both directions in a symmetric way , that is , residents of patch 1 spend the same proportion of time in patch 2 that individuals from patch 2 spend in patch 1 ; i.e. @xmath142 .
the third scenario assumes that mobility is asymmetric , and so , we make use , in this case , of the relation @xmath143 .
simulations show that when only individuals from patch 1 are allowed to travel , the prevalence and final size are lower that under a cordon sanitaire .
figure [ owinfected ] , shows the levels of patch prevalence when @xmath144 and @xmath145 . for low @xmath68 s
, prevalence decreases in patch 1 but remains high in both patches , which as expected , has a direct impact in the final size of the outbreak . and
@xmath141 , with parameters : @xmath146 . ] in figure [ owfinal ] , simulations show that the total final size is only greater than the cordoned case when @xmath147 , possibly the result of the assumption that @xmath148 and @xmath149 . however , we see under the assumption of higher body disposal rates in patch 2 , that the total final size under @xmath147 may turn out to be smaller than in the cordoned case . that is , it is conceivable that a safer patch 2 , may emerge as a result of a better health care infrastructure and efficient protocols in the handling of dead bodies . and
@xmath141 , with parameters : @xmath146 . ] finally , figure [ owfinal ] shows that mobility can produce the opposite effect ; that is , reduce the total final epidemic size , given that ( for the parameters used ) the residence times are greater than @xmath150 but smaller than @xmath151 .
simulations under symmetric mobility show that prevalence and final size are severely affected when compared to the cordoned case .
figure [ sinfected ] shows that the prevalence in patch 1 exhibits the same behavior as in the one way scenario .
however , in this case the prevalence in patch 1 is decreasing at a slower rate due to the secondary infections produced by individuals traveling from patch 2 . on the other hand ,
prevalence in patch 2 is much bigger than in the one way scenario , the result of secondary infections generated by individuals traveling from patch 2 to patch 1 . and
@xmath141 , with parameters : @xmath146 . ]
we saw that final size in patch 1 decreases when residency increases while an increment of the final size in patch 2 .
that is , the total final size curve may turn out to be greater than in the cordoned case for almost all residence times . as seen in figure
[ sfinal ] , allowing symmetric travel would negatively affect the total final size ( almost always ) . and
@xmath141 , with parameters : @xmath146 . ]
in order to clarify the effects of residence times and mobility on the total final size .
we analyze its behavior under one way and symmetric mobility ( figure [ maxonew ] ) .
figure [ maxonew](a ) shows , one way mobility , the existence of a proportional resident time interval when the total final size is reduced below that generated under the cordoned case . for residence times between @xmath152 and @xmath153 .
in particular , the best case scenario takes place when @xmath154 , that is , when the final size reaches its all time minimum . .
] figure [ maxonew](b ) shows that under symmetric mobility , the total final size increases for almost all resident times .
therefore traveling under these initial conditions has a deleterious effect to the overall population for almost all residence times .
it is important to notice that reductions in the total final size are related not only to residence times and mobility type but also to the prevailing infection rates . in figure
[ betas ] simulations show the existence of an interval of residence times for which the total final size is less than the final size under the cordoned case under @xmath155 . .
] simulations ( see figure [ ro ] ) show that mobility is always beneficial , that is , it reduces the global @xmath32 .
however , mobility on its own is not enough to reduce @xmath32 below the threshold ( less than @xmath156 ) .
bringing @xmath157 would require reducing local risk , that is , getting a lower @xmath135 . with parameters
: @xmath158 .
a west - africa calibrated two - patch model of the transmission dynamics of evd is used to show that the use of _ cordons sanitaires _ not always leads to the best possible global scenario and neither does allowing indiscriminate mobility .
mobility may reduced the total epidemic size as long as the low risk patch 2 is `` safe enough '' , otherwise mobility would produce a detrimental effect . having an infection rate @xmath159 in patch 2 guarantees ( under our simulations ) the existence of non - trivial residence times that reduce the total final size under one way mobility .
the global basic reproductive number may be brought bellow one by mobility , whenever a the transmission rate in patch 2 is low enough .
finally , the choice of non zero @xmath14 , that is , the recovery rate of asymptomatic that do not develop infection , bring the reproduction number @xmath32 below one much faster for one way mobility than the case of @xmath160 for a wide range of residence times . .
10 , _ a final size relation for epidemic models _ , math .
eng . , 4 ( 2007 ) , pp
. 159175 . , _ symptomless infection with ebola virus _ , the lancet , 355 ( 2000 ) , pp .
2178 2179 .
, _ ebola control : effect of asymptomatic infection and acquired immunity _ , the lancet , 384 ( 2014 ) .
, _ vector - borne diseases models with residence times - a lagrangian perspective _ , arxiv preprint arxiv:1509.08894 , ( 2015 ) . , _ sis and sir epidemic models under virtual dispersal _ , the bulletin of mathematical biology , doi : 10.1007/s11538 - 015 - 0113 - 5 , ( 2015 ) .
, _ some simple epidemic models _ , math .
eng . , 3 ( 2006 ) .
height 2pt depth -1.6pt width 23pt , _ age of infection and final epidemic size _ , math .
eng . , 5 ( 2008 ) , pp .
681690 . , _ mathematical models in population biology and epidemiology _ , vol .
40 of texts in applied mathematics , springer - verlag , new york , 2001 . ,
_ age of infection epidemic models with heterogeneous mixing _ , j biol dyn , 3 ( 2009 ) , pp . 32430 .
, _ encyclopedia of pestilence , pandemics , and plagues : am _ , vol . 1 , abc - clio , 2008 . , _ molecular evolution of viruses of the family filoviridae based on 97 whole - genome sequences _ , j virol , 87 ( 2013 ) , pp .
260816 . ,
_ an epidemic model with virtual mass transportation : the case of smallpox _ , bioterrorism : mathematical modeling applications in homeland security , 28 ( 2003 ) , p. 173 . ,
_ modelling the effect of early detection of ebola _ , the lancet infectious diseases , 15 ( 2015 ) , pp
. 148149 . , _ the basic reproductive number of ebola and the effects of public health measures : the cases of congo and uganda _ , j. theoret .
biol . , 229 ( 2004 ) , pp .
119126 . , _ scaling laws for the movement of people between locations in a large city _
, physical review e , 68 ( 2003 ) , p. 066102 .
, _ transmission dynamics and control of ebola virus disease ( evd ) : a review _ , bmc medicine , 12 ( 2014 ) , p. 196 . , _ the western africa ebola virus disease epidemic exhibits both global exponential and local polynomial growth rates _ , plos currents , 7 ( 2014 ) .
, _ risk behavior - based model of the cubic growth of acquired immunodeficiency syndrome in the united states _ ,
proceedings of the national academy of sciences , 86 ( 1989 ) , pp . 47934797 . , _ on the definition and the computation of the basic reproduction ratio @xmath161 in models for infectious diseases in heterogeneous populations _ , j. math .
. , 28 ( 1990 ) , pp .
365382 . ,
_ nyt : using a tactic unseen in a century , countries cordon off ebola - racked areas _ , august 12 , 2014 . , _ modelling disease outbreaks in realistic urban social networks _ , nature , 429 ( 2004 ) , pp .
180184 . ,
_ guidance for safe handling of human remains of ebola patients in us hospitals and mortuaries _ , 2014 . ,
_ sars control and psychological effects of quarantine , toronto , canada _ , emerg infect dis , 10 ( 2004 ) , pp . 12061212 . , _ low seroprevalence of igg antibodies to ebola virus in an epidemic zone : ogoou - ivindo region , northeastern gabon , 1995 _ , j infect dis , 191 ( 2005 ) , pp
. 964968 . , _ the mathematics of infectious diseases _ , siam rev . ,
42 ( 2000 ) , pp .
599653 ( electronic ) .
, _ epidemiological dynamics of ebola outbreaks _ , elife , 3 ( 2014 ) . , _ a contribution to the mathematical theory of epidemics _ , proc .
r. soc . , a115 ( 1927 ) , pp .
700721 . , _ a three - scale network model for the early growth dynamics of 2014 west africa ebola epidemic _ , plos currents : outbreaks , ( 2014 ) .
, _ understanding the dynamics of ebola epidemics _ , epidemiol infect , 135 ( 2007 ) , pp .
61021 . , _ statistical inference in a stochastic epidemic seir model with control intervention : ebola as a case study _ , biometrics , 62 ( 2006 ) , pp .
11701177 . , _ human asymptomatic ebola infection and strong inflammatory response _ , the lancet , 355 ( 2000 ) , pp .
221015 .
, _ early transmission dynamics of ebola virus disease ( evd ) , west africa , march to august 2014 _ , euro survei , 36 ( 2014 ) . , _ strategies for containing ebola in west africa _ , science , 346 ( 2014 ) , pp
. 991995 . , _ an introduction to ebola : the virus and the disease _ , j infect dis , 179 ( suppl 1 ) ( 1999 ) , pp .
ix xvi . , _ spatial dynamics of pandemic influenza in a massive artificial society _ , journal of artificial societies and social simulation , 10 ( 2007 ) , p. 9 . , _
emerging disease dynamics : the case of ebola _ , april 2014 . , _ temporal variations in the effective reproduction number of the 2014 west africa ebola outbreak _ , plos currents : outbreaks , 1 ( 2014 ) . , _ reproduction numbers and sub - threshold endemic equilibria for compartmental models of disease transmission _ , math .
biosci . , 180 ( 2002 ) , pp .
, _ ebola virus disease _ , april 2015 .
the total population of system ( [ ebolaasym ] ) is constant , we can consider only the system @xmath169 we suppose @xmath170 . by summing the first two equations of ( [ ebola2 ] )
, we have : @xmath171 .
this implies that @xmath172 .
similarly by adding the first three and first four equations , we will have @xmath173 and @xmath174 .
+ by integrating the first 2 equations , we have @xmath175 . hence @xmath176 | we formulate a two - patch mathematical model for ebola virus disease dynamics in order to evaluate the effectiveness of _ cordons sanitaires _ , mandatory movement restrictions between communities while exploring their role on disease dynamics and final epidemic size .
simulations show that severe restrictions in movement between high and low risk areas of closely linked communities may have a deleterious impact on the overall levels of infection in the total population .
* keywords : * ebola virus disease , asymptomatic , final size relation , residence times . |
mixed - valent manganites of formulation re@xmath0ae@xmath1mno@xmath2 ( re being a trivalent rare - earth ion , and ae a divalent alkaline - earth ion ) exhibit a great variety of fascinating properties , such as charge ordering ( real - space ordering of the mn@xmath3and mn@xmath4species ) and colossal magnetoresistance ( collapse of the resistivity by several orders of magnitude under application of an external magnetic field).@xcite charge ordering is often accompanied by a long - range ordering of the mn@xmath5 e@xmath6 orbitals , leading to prominent structural distortions . in pr@xmath7ca@xmath1mno@xmath2 compounds with @xmath8 , the small a - site cationic radius and the mn@xmath9mn@xmath3 ratio close to 1
contribute to the setting up of a particular groundstate , which is both charge and orbitally ordered , insulating and antiferromagnetic of ce type ( hereafter referred to as afcoo ) .
application of magnetic fields can affect the subtle energy balance in these systems , and trigger the development of a ferromagnetic , conducting state ( hereafter referred to as f ) .
this process is at the origin of the most spectacular effects of colossal magnetoresistance in manganites .
however , very high magnetic fields are required to melt the robust afcoo state present for @xmath10 ( about 25 t at 4 k).@xcite for compositions shifted towards @xmath11 , lower fields are needed ( e.g. , about 5 t for @xmath12).@xcite mn - site substitutions can also weaken the afcoo state,@xcite making it susceptible to undergo an afcoo - f transition at low - t under moderate fields .
recently , we observed very intriguing metamagnetic transitions in such pr@xmath13ca@xmath14mn@xmath15m@xmath16o@xmath2 compounds , m being a magnetic or nonmagnetic cation.@xcite in some cases , the virgin magnetization curve at low - t indeed displays successive , abrupt steps as the field is increased .
this staircase - like shape of the @xmath17 curves disappears as @xmath18 is increased above about 10 k. similar features were observed in resistivity and specific heat measurements.@xcite in this paper , we investigated by isothermal magnetization loops several aspects of this staircase effect : sample dependence , role of temperature , cycling effects , mode of field variation , role of microstructure , type of disorder affecting the afcoo stability . most of the experiments were carried out on a set of samples of the composition pr@xmath14ca@xmath14mn@xmath19ga@xmath20o@xmath2 .
complementary measurements were also performed at very low temperatures in pr@xmath0ca@xmath1mno@xmath2 compounds with @xmath21 .
all the samples used in this study are ceramics , except one crystal which was grown in a mirror furnace . the pr@xmath14ca@xmath14mn@xmath19ga@xmath22o@xmath2 and pr@xmath0ca@xmath1mno@xmath2 ceramic samples were prepared by conventional solid - state reaction .
stoichiometric mixtures of the oxides pr@xmath23o@xmath24 , cao , mno@xmath25 and ga@xmath25o@xmath2 were intimately ground and the powders , first heated at 1000 @xmath26c , were pressed in the form of bars .
the sintering was made at 1200@xmath26c and at 1500@xmath27c for 12 h , then the bars were slowly cooled to 800@xmath26c at 5@xmath28c / h , before being quenched to room temperature .
a pr@xmath29ca@xmath30mno@xmath2 crystal was cut out of the central part of a several - cm - long specimen grown in a mirror furnace using a floating - zone method .
physical characterizations of this crystal were previously reported.@xcite the purity of all samples was attested to by x - ray powder diffraction and electron diffraction studies .
energy - dispersive x - ray microanalyses yielded cationic compositions in agreement with the nominal ones , within the accuracy of this technique .
electron diffraction investigations also revealed the existence of twinning domains in all samples , including the single crystal .
the magnetic measurements were carried out by means of a quantum design extraction magnetometer , with fields up to 9 t and temperatures down to 2.5 k. all hysteresis loops were recorded after a zero - field cooling from room temperature .
it must be noted that room temperature ( rt ) is larger than all transition temperatures -corresponding to spin , charge or orbital orderings- that can be encountered in these materials .
even for the unsubstituted , half - doped pr@xmath14ca@xmath14mno@xmath2 , the charge and orbital ordering takes place at @xmath31 k , well below rt .
the hysteresis loops were registered according to the following procedure : the magnetic field was increased from 0 to 9 t , and then decreased down to 0 t , with equally spaced values ( 0.25 t in most cases ) ; a waiting time is imposed between the end of the field installation and the beginning of the measurements ( 1 min in most cases ) ; then , three measurements are successively recorded ( all shown in the figures ) .
complementary experiments were carried out to investigate the influence of field spacing and waiting time values . for pr@xmath14ca@xmath14mn@xmath19ga@xmath22o@xmath2 , that is the compound used for most of the experiments , we studied four ceramic samples coming from the same batch , and having nearly the same mass and shape .
the first measurement recorded on each of these four samples -hereafter labelled as a , b , c and d- was an hysteresis loop at 5 k. this allowed us to properly address the question of reproducibility , by considering only samples being in a _
pure _ virgin state , i.e. , without any previous application of high fields at low temperature .
figure 1 shows hysteresis loops , recorded at 5 k , in pr@xmath14ca@xmath14mn@xmath32ga@xmath22o@xmath2 and pr@xmath14ca@xmath14mno@xmath2 [ hereafter denoted as ( prca50)ga5% and prca50 , respectively ] . in prca50
, one observes a linear , reversible curve up to 9 t , consistent with the fact that this compound stays in a pure afcoo state within this field range . in ( prca50)ga5%
, the field - increasing branch of the loop also exhibits a linear behavior for magnetic fields lower than about 4 t. however , the slope is significantly larger than in prca50 .
this was confirmed by low - field ac - susceptibility curves , which also revealed the existence of a cusp around 50 k in the mn - site substituted compounds.@xcite such a cusp suggests that the introduced disorder on the mn - sublattice allows the development of competing ferromagnetic interactions within the antiferromagnetic matrix .
these results point to the setting of a very weakened afcoo groundstate in ( prca50)ga5% as compared to prca50 . for fields larger than 4 t
, the curve of ( prca50)ga5% ( sample a ) exhibits three large jumps , separated by almost flat plateaus .
approaching 9 t , the magnetization undergoes a small increase from the last plateau , leading to a value of 3.25 @xmath33@xmath34 @xmath35 f.u .. since the expected magnetization for full polarization of the mn spins in ( prca50)ga5% is 3.3 @xmath33@xmath34 @xmath35 f.u.,@xcite the sample under 9 t is virtually in a saturated magnetic state . as the field
is decreased , one observes a rather flat curve down to about 2 t , followed by a rapid drop of magnetization yielding a remanent value of about 0.15 @xmath33@xmath34 @xmath35 f.u .. the inset of fig .
1 displays following field - scans recorded on this sample , first by extending the field decrease down to -9 t , and then by re - increasing it up to 9 t. the curve between 0 and -9 t is symmetrical to the reverse leg of the first quadrant .
furthermore , the curve recorded when increasing the field from -9 t to 9 t is almost superimposed on the one obtained when decreasing from 9 t to -9 t. after the first application of 9 t , the sample thus seems to behave as a bulk , reversible ferromagnet . before going further ,
it is essential to check the reproducibility of the staircase - like behavior . hysteresis loops at 5 k were recorded on four virgin samples belonging to the same batch . for the sake of clarity , figure 2
just shows the field - increasing parts of the loops .
first , one can point out the remarkable superimposition of the linear regimes found between 0 and 4 t , attesting to the good homogeneity of the cationic composition within this set of samples .
for each of them , three large steps occur within the field range 4 - 9 t , and the magnetization reaches about 3.25 @xmath33@xmath34 @xmath35 f.u . under 9 t in all cases .
however , it is clear that the characteristic fields associated with the steps slightly differ from sample to sample . a significant scatter exists also about the magnetization values corresponding to each plateau , especially for the first one .
these results demonstrate that the staircase effect only exhibits a semi - quantitative reproducibility .
figure 3 displays hysteresis loops recorded on sample b at 5 , 7.5 and 10 k. all curves have nearly the same initial slope , saturation value and remanent magnetization , but the steps have completely disappeared for @xmath36 k. at this temperature , the metamagnetic transition rather has a smooth , @xmath37-shape centered around 5 t. for @xmath38 k , the transition exhibits several steps ( observed down to our lowest temperature @xmath39 k ) .
the curve at 7.5 k well illustrates the crossover in temperature . as compared to lower temperatures , the curve is smoothed out from both sides of the field range , leaving just one step in the middle of the transition .
this behavior is basically different from a simple broadening of the steps seen at 5 k. one can also notice that the curves with steps seem to `` zigzag '' around the one at 10 k , a behavior suggesting that this last curve might be representative of an underlying equilibrium @xmath17 curve at low - t . in our first report of the staircase effect,@xcite we already mentioned the existence of some variations in the pattern of steps as the sample is cycled between low-@xmath18 and rt . to get a direct insight into this point ,
we have successively recorded on sample c five hysteresis loops at 5 k , each of them starting from a zero - field cooled state .
the results are shown in fig .
4 . for the first three loops , the step structure is well reproducible .
one just observes small variations in the height of the second plateau and in the third step field ( @xmath40 ) .
in contrast , a marked evolution takes place in between the third and fourth runs : one observes clear upward shifts in the step fields @xmath41 and @xmath42 , while the third step is replaced by a smooth tail .
then , the fifth loop remains well superimposed on the preceding one .
along these five runs , the initial slope and remanent magnetization remain constant , whereas there is a systematic , small decrease of the maximum magnetization .
all these features have been observed in other samples , except that `` switches '' , such as that seen in fig . 4 between runs 3 and 4 , can occur sooner or later .
all previously shown data were recorded by using a field spacing ( @xmath43 ) equal to 2500 oe and a waiting time ( @xmath44 ) equal to 1 min .
figure 5 shows three loops successively recorded on sample c at @xmath45 k , following different procedures : ( 1 ) @xmath46 oe with @xmath47 min ( run 5 of fig .
4 ) ; ( 2 ) @xmath48 oe with @xmath47 min ; ( 3 ) @xmath46 oe with @xmath49 min .
the last two runs lead to the same average sweep rate ( 35 mt / min ) , including field installation , waiting time and data acquisition . for a constant waiting time ( 1 min )
, one observes that using smaller field spacings pushes the steps to higher fields .
these shifts in the @xmath50 values are accompanied by upward shifts of the corresponding plateaus .
run 3 registered with @xmath51 oe and @xmath49 min yields a curve nearly superimposed on that of run 1 obtained for @xmath52 oe and @xmath47 min .
thus one can conclude that : ( i ) the shifts in @xmath50 observed between runs 1 and 2 can actually be ascribed to the variation in @xmath43 , and not just to a cycling effect ( as in fig .
4 ) ; ( ii ) the impacts of increasing the average sweep rate via @xmath43 or @xmath53 are completely different .
it turns out that the field spacing is actually the relevant parameter at the origin of the difference between run 1 and 2 . up to now
, the staircase effect has only been observed in mn - site substituted prca50 samples .
one can wonder whether this property is related to the weakening of the afcoo state , or more specifically to a disordering of the mn sublattice .
thus , we re - investigated pr@xmath0ca@xmath1mno@xmath2 compounds with @xmath54 values yielding afcoo states able to be destabilized under moderate fields .
we studied two ceramic samples with @xmath55 and @xmath56 , as well as a crystal with @xmath57 . for all of them ,
smooth metamagnetic transitions were observed for temperatures down to 5 k. at 2.5 k , in contrast , the hysteresis loops display very steep transitions , as shown in fig .
the ceramics with @xmath58 and @xmath55 present a unique , large step at the transition , while a multisteps structure takes place for the crystal with @xmath57 .
this staircase effect is exactly the same as that encountered in mn - site substituted compounds with @xmath59 .
this is an important piece of information which demonstrates that the multisteps behavior is not basically related to the disordering of the mn - sublattice induced by magnetic or nonmagnetic foreign cations .
in other respects , one can wonder why the prca37 crystal behaves differently than the ceramics having bordering compositions .
these issues will be addressed below .
let us try to consider the various , possible interpretations of the staircase - like metamagnetic transitions presently observed in antiferromagnetic , charge and orbitally ordered ( afcoo ) manganites .
first , one must notice that multisteps metamagnetic transitions are not rare in the literature on antiferromagnets.@xcite this is connected to the existence of a `` ferrimagnetic '' domain at low-@xmath18 in the phase diagram , containing one or several intermediate magnetic arrangements in between the antiferromagnetic and paramagnetic phases . in such cases , it must be emphasized that the step fields are true _
critical fields _ given by combinations of different exchange fields present in the system .
therefore , they must be well reproducible and independent of the measuring procedure , in contrast to the behaviors found in afcoo manganites .
in addition , the magnetization of each plateau should also have well defined values , a feature which again strongly departs from our observations .
the literature provides us with another series of results that could be relevant to our situation . in site - diluted antiferromagnets
, it was indeed shown that metamagnetic transitions can display several abrupt steps .
this was well illustrated in the case of fe@xmath0mg@xmath1cl@xmath25 for which experimental and simulated @xmath17 curves bear close resemblance to ours.@xcite this behavior was interpreted in terms of avalanches of spin reversals in the af structure .
random distribution of magnetic vacancies ( mg@xmath60 ions ) generates a great variety of local situations in the spin lattice .
different values of external field are required to flip a spin in these various neighborhoods .
as it is increased , the field first reaches a value inducing spin reversals within the most disturbed regions , probably close to clusters of magnetic vacancies .
once a first spin has been flipped , it modifies the environment of its neighbors which can themselves flip , and so on .
this flipping process can propagate as a _ domino - like wave _ within the spin structure,@xcite resulting in sizeable avalanches .
simulations showed that these avalanches can be blocked by regions locally free of defects or by clusters of previously flipped spins.@xcite then , the field can be further increased over a wide range without triggering new spin reversal , leading to almost constant magnetization .
this process yields @xmath17 curves with large , sharp steps connected by plateaus , just like in our case
. nevertheless , some experimental results cast doubts on the relevancy of this mechanism to our situation .
firstly , we have found that the staircase effect also exists in pr@xmath29ca@xmath61mno@xmath2 , i.e. , without substitution on the spin lattice itself .
secondly , the mechanism described above involves true critical fields , each of them being associated to a particular local arrangement ( number and spatial distribution of adjacent vacancies).@xcite these critical fields are expected to be reproducible for a given sample .
once again , the modifications in the pattern of steps resulting from cycling or varying procedure can not be accounted for in the frame of such a scenario .
actually , the whole set of data indicates that the staircase effect is rather dealing with a succession of metastable states ( corresponding to the plateaus ) , separated by boundaries ( the step fields ) which values can not be perfectly reproducible . keeping this in mind ,
let us turn back to the specific case of our afcoo manganites . in such compounds , the metamagnetic transition is widely recognized to proceed through nucleation and growth of f domains within the af matrix .
the most natural idea about the occurrence of multisteps structures consists in invoking additional mechanisms which could impede the development of these nucleation / growth processes .
when such a competition involves opposing trends which are very different in nature , it can yield a discontinuous response in various physical systems .
for instance , it is the case in ferromagnets where barkhausen noise results from jerky motions of domain walls , a behavior often attributed to pinning by defects .
related phenomena are also encountered in martensitic transformations ( the so - called acoustic emission effect ) . in manganites , it turns out that transitions involving the coo state could have a martensitic - like character .
this analogy was previously pointed out in recent publications.@xcite a martensitic transformation ( mt ) is basically a first - order transition ( fot ) involving a shear - induced lattice distortion between a high-@xmath18 phase ( austenite ) and a low-@xmath18 phase ( martensite ) . because of a significant change in shape of the unit cell , the nucleation of first martensitic domains upon cooling induces long - range , anisotropic strains developing from the martensite / austenite interfaces.@xcite the resulting increase of elastic energy can transitorily block further growth of martensitic phase under continuous lowering of temperature ( the external parameter driving the fot in this case ) .
significant undercooling is actually required to make the transition starting again .
this sequential process repeats itself along the course of the transformation . finally , despite its intrinsic first - order character
, the mt is spread over a large range of temperature between @xmath62 and @xmath63 ( start and finish temperatures of the austenite to martensite transformation , respectively ) .
the settling of coo in manganites is well known to result in significant distortions of the unit cell .
this originates from cooperative jahn - teller effects , giving rise to long - range ordering of the mn@xmath3 e@xmath6 orbitals .
it must be noted that such phenomena related to internal strains can be in play during either the setting or the collapse of coo domains .
furthermore , similar effects can be expected when coo domains coexist with either paramagnetic or ferromagnetic ( f ) phases .
the previous studies invoking the martensitic analogy referred to temperature - driven transitions between the paramagnetic and coo phases at @xmath64.@xcite in the present paper , we rather consider the afcoo - f transition , driven by application of magnetic field at low-@xmath18 .
the two phases involved in this transition have very different cell parameters , which can justify a martensitic - like character of the transformation . in order to quantify this point ,
let us compare the results of neutron diffraction data recorded at 10 k under zero field ( 3t2 at llb , saclay , france ) inprca50 ( a good reference for the afcoo phase ) and ( prca50)cr5% ( which is ferromagnetic at low-@xmath18 even under zero field).@xcite when going from the afcoo ( prca50 ) to the f phase ( prca50cr5% ) , @xmath65 and @xmath66 parameters ( @xmath67 space group ) are decreased by 0.6% and 0.8% , respectively , while @xmath68 is increased by about 1.7% .
since the cell parameters of the two components are not strictly equal at 300 k , it is still more reliable to compare a distortion parameter , such as @xmath69 , where a@xmath70 refers to the three cell parameters , and @xmath71 is the average value . while the @xmath72 values of both compounds are similar in the paramagnetic phase at 300 k [ 0.11 and 0.17 for ( prca50)cr5% and prca50 , respectively ] , these values are totally different in the ordered phases at 10 k : @xmath73 in ( prca50)cr5% , and @xmath74 in prca50 .
these structural evolutions clearly indicate that large , anisotropic strains must develop at the f / coo interfaces during the metamagnetic transformation . in a canonical mt
, the austenite phase transforms into the martensite upon lowering temperature or applying external stress . in our case ,
the roles of austenite and martensite are played by the coo and f phases , respectively , while increasing magnetic field just acts as lowering temperature or increasing stress .
contrary to the case of standard mt , note that the most distorted phase is the `` austenite '' in this analogy .
let us now try to describe the occurrence of multisteps on @xmath17 curves in the frame of such a martensitic scenario . at low-@xmath18 and under zero - field ,
the coo ( austenite ) phase is extremely predominant , as attested to by the linearity of the @xmath75 ) curves .
for sufficiently high magnetic fields , f domains ( martensite ) start growing .
a slight deviation from linearity can be detected on the curves above about 3.5 t. this upward curvature , however , is very small , which can be ascribed to the inhibiting effect of the strains at the f / coo interfaces . as the field
is continuously increased , the driving force acting on the spins increases .
there is a field value for which this force becomes high enough to locally overcome the elastic constraints , triggering a sudden motion of f / coo interfaces in a part of the sample .
this , in turn , destabilizes the local stress field and , in an avalanche - like way , it can result in spreading the f state over large regions of the sample .
such an abrupt increase of the martensite volume fraction ( f phase in our case ) yields a sizeable increase of magnetization . along this avalanche process ,
the magnetic energy decreases while the elastic one increases , a balance which can lead the system to be frozen in another metastable state . the overall transition may thus proceed by successive jumps between metastable states , which directly yield a staircaselike shape on @xmath17 curves .
one could argue that the discontinuous character of the transition in most mt takes place at small scales , making it hardly visible on the evolution of bulk quantities . however , there are some cases for which mt develops by successive `` bursts '' .
for instance , the volume fraction of martensite versus temperature in ni - ti alloys can increase by macroscopic steps,@xcite a behavior consistent with the existence of the staircase effect seen in @xmath17 curves of our manganites .
let us now test more precisely the consistency of this martensitic - like scenario with the whole set of experimental results .
martensitic transformations are known to be basically sensitive to defects , which can influence the nucleation and growth of the product phase within the parent one ( pre - existing defects or defects induced by previous transformations ) .
such a role of defects can explain some slight variations from sample to sample as shown in fig .
the evolution observed between successive @xmath17 curves can also be ascribed to the influence of defects created by the lattice distortions along the coo - f transformations . in mt , prominent cycling effects are observed when scanning the transition either by temperature or stress variations . in most cases
, it was shown that defects produced by thermal cycling act as obstacles making the martensitic transformation more and more difficult.@xcite this leads to a decrease of @xmath62 , which is qualitatively consistent with the increase of the step fields shown in fig .
4 . figure 5 shows that the field spacing can affect the location of the steps . as a general rule ,
the collapse of any _ brittle _ metastable state can be expected to be slightly delayed by smoothly varying the driving ( destabilizing ) parameter ( i.e. , the field in our case ) .
the results of fig .
5 are qualitatively consistent with such a behavior since one observes that smaller field increments tend to push up the breakdown fields ( just as in sandpile experiments , when adding grains of sand one by one instead of by packs ) .
another important result one has to face is displayed in fig .
why does one observe a staircase effect in the prca37 crystal and not in the prca35 and prca40 ceramics ?
is it related to the @xmath54 value or to the sample nature ?
as soon as @xmath54 departs from 0.5 , there must be some disorder in the charge and orbital ordering .
in disordered systems for which an underlying first - order transition proceeds through avalanches , the degree of disorder was found to critically influence the development of the transition.@xcite for low levels of disorder , the transition takes place as a single infinite avalanche , while for high levels of disorder , it has a smooth shape made of tiny avalanches ( undetectable on the hysteresis loop of a magnetic system , for instance ) . in between these situations
, there is a critical value of disorder for which the transition proceeds through superimposition of avalanches of all sizes .
one might thus speculate that some levels of disorder just below the critical value could lead to the appearance of several macroscopic steps on @xmath17 curves .
nevertheless , this interpretation is made unlikely by the fact that both prca35 and prca40 exhibit similar shapes of @xmath17 , that are consistent with low disorders .
actually , it seems more plausible to rather invoke the difference of microstructure between crystals and ceramics .
our ceramics are made of grains of typical size close to 100 @xmath33 m .
a role of the grain size was previously reported in the development of martensitic - like transitions in manganites .
upon cooling across @xmath64 , it was found that large grains are more favorable to the establishment of the coo phase.@xcite this was ascribed to a better accommodation ability of the martensitic strains as the grain size increases . in our case , the results of fig .
5 rather suggest that accommodation is more difficult in the crystal than in the ceramics .
the literature of mt in metallic alloys shows that there are antagonist effects associated to grain size , leading to various global behaviors .
there are cases where the width of the martensitic transition ( @xmath76 ) was found to increase with the grain size.@xcite this suggests that the hindering effects associated to internal stresses can increase with size , a feature which might be consistent with our results .
the influence of microstructure on the staircase effect in manganites obviously deserves further investigations .
the staircase effect recently discovered in some antiferromagnetic , charge and orbitally ordered ( afcoo ) manganites , has been extensively studied by magnetic measurements ( isothermal @xmath77 versus @xmath78 loops ) .
various parameters were investigated : reproducibility from sample to sample ; influence of the temperature ; cycling effects ; measuring procedure .
experimental results allowed us to discard some of the interpretations which could be a priori considered .
an important point is that the step fields can not be regarded as `` pure critical fields '' .
these characteristic fields rather separate metastable states , and their precise values can change with many parameters .
it is also determinant to point out that the afcoo to f transformation involves large structural distortions . actually , there are striking analogies with the martensitic transformations encountered in metallic alloys .
we found that all our experimental features can be reasonably well accounted for within such a scenario .
although a staircase effect was first evidenced in mn - site substituted compounds , the exact role of defects in this phenomenon appears to be quite complex .
firstly , we found that this effect can also take place in `` pure '' mn compounds .
secondly , our martensitic interpretation is based on structural distortions which also take place in the absence of any disorder .
the facts remain that the presence of disorder can be determinant since it favors the creation of deep metastable states separated by large barriers in the energy landscape , a situation well suited to the development of large avalanches.@xcite a lot of aspects of the staircase effect will have to be further investigated .
for instance , one will have to check whether it could also be observed in the metamagnetic transitions of other kinds of af groundstates encountered in manganites , such as the a- or c - types .
relaxation experiments ( under fixed @xmath18 and @xmath78 ) should also be carried out to investigate further the role of temperature , addressing in particular the question of the athermal@xcite ( or not ) character of these multisteps transitions .
the authors thank l. herv ( crismat , caen ) for the crystal growth , and r. mahendiran for useful discussions about martensitic transformations . for a review ,
see _ colossal magnetoresistance , charge ordering and related properties of manganese oxides , _ edited by c. n. r.rao and b. raveau ( world scientific , singapore , 1998 ) and _ colossal magnetoresistance oxides _ , edited by y. tokura ( gordon & breach , london , 1999 ) .
m. tokunaga , n. miura , y. tomioka , and y. tokura , phys .
b. * 57 * , 5259 ( 1998 ) ; m. respaud , a. llobet , c. frontera , c. ritter , j. m. broto , h. rakoto , m. goiran , and j. l. garca - muoz , _ ibid . _ * 61 * , 9014 ( 2000 ) .
m. r. lees , j. barratt , g. balakrishnan , d. mck .
paul , and m. yethiraj , phys .
b. * 52 * , r14 303 ( 1995 ) ; y. tomioka , a. asamitsu , h. kuwahara , y. morimoto , and y. tokura , _ ibid . _ * 53 * , r1689 ( 1996 ) .
b. raveau , a. maignan and c. martin , j. solid state chem .
* 130 * , 162 ( 1997 ) .
s. hbert , v. hardy , a. maignan , r. mahendiran , m. hervieu , c. martin , and b. raveau , j. solid state chem . * 165 * , 6 ( 2002 ) .
s. hbert , a. maignan , v. hardy , c. martin , m. hervieu , and b. raveau , submitted to solid state commun .. v. hardy , a. wahl , c. martin , and ch .
simon , phys .
b * 63 * , 224403 ( 2001 ) ; v. hardy , a. wahl , and c. martin , _ ibid . _
* 64 * , 064402 ( 2001 ) . in a pr@xmath14ca@xmath14mn@xmath0m@xmath1o@xmath2 compound ,
where m@xmath79 is a nonmagnetic cation , the expected magnetization for full polarization of the mn spins is ( in @xmath80 / f.u .
): @xmath81 .
note that the magnetization value at saturation can be slightly larger owing to an additional contribution from the pr spins .
e. stryjewski and n. giordano , adv . phys . * 26 * , 487 ( 1977 ) .
j. kushauer , r. van bentum , w. kleemann , and d. bertrand , phys .
b * 53 * , 11 647 ( 1996 ) . c. martin , a. maignan , m. hervieu , c. autret , b. raveau , and d. i. khomskii , phys . rev .
b * 63 * , 174402 ( 2001 ) .
m. uehara and s .- w .
cheong , europhys .
lett . * 52 * , 674 ( 2000 ) .
r. mahendiran , b. raveau , m. hervieu , c. michel , and a. maignan , phys .
b * 64 * , 064424 ( 2001 ) .
v. podzorov , b. g. kim , v. kiryukhin , m. e. gershenson , and s .- w .
cheong , phys .
b * 64 * , 140406(r ) ( 2001 ) .
e. vives , j. ortn , l. maosa , i. rfols , r. prez - magran , and a. planes , phys .
lett . * 72 * , 1694 ( 1994 ) .
f. damay , c. martin , a. maignan , m. hervieu , b. raveau , g. andr , and f. boure , appl .
* 73 * , 3772 ( 1998 ) .
z. jirk , f. damay , m. hervieu , c. martin , b. raveau , g. andr , and f. boure , phys .
b * 61 * , 1181 ( 2000 ) .
b. skrotzki , j. phys .
iv * 1 * , c4 - 367 ( 1991 ) . j. van humbeeck , j. phys .
iv * 1 * , c4 - 189 ( 1991 ) . e. vives and a. planes , phys .
b * 50 * , 3839 ( 1994 ) ; k. dahmen and j. sethna , _ ibid .
_ * 53 * , 14 872 ( 1996 ) . p. levy , f. parisi , g. polla , d. vega , g. leyva , h. lanza , r. s. freitas and l. ghivelder , phys . rev .
b * 62 * , 6437 ( 2000 ) . h. sakamoto , k. meguro , a. tanaka , and a. imai , j. phys .
iv * 5 * , c8 - 581 ( 1995 ) ; m. hayakawa , t. okuda , and m. oda , _ ibid . _
* 5 * , c8 - 1127 ( 1995 ) .
f. j. prez - reche , e. vives , l. maosa , and a. planes , phys .
lett . * 87 * , 195701 ( 2001 ) .
fig . 1 . : : magnetization loops at 5 k in pr@xmath14ca@xmath14mn@xmath19ga@xmath22o@xmath2 ( circles ) and pr@xmath14ca@xmath14mno@xmath2 ( squares ) .
inset displays complete scans between 9 and -9 t in pr@xmath14ca@xmath14mn@xmath19ga@xmath22o@xmath2 .
2 . : : first magnetization curves at 5 k in four virgin pr@xmath14ca@xmath14mn@xmath19ga@xmath22o@xmath2 samples coming from the same batch .
the arrows just mark the average values of the three step fields .
3 . : : magnetization loops in pr@xmath14ca@xmath14mn@xmath19ga@xmath82o@xmath2 at various temperatures . fig .
4 . : : five successive magnetization loops at 5 k in pr@xmath14ca@xmath83mn@xmath19ga@xmath22o@xmath2 .
the labels refer to the run numbering .
each loop was recorded after a zero - field cooling from room temperature .
5 . : : high - field parts of hysteresis loops at 5 k in pr@xmath14ca@xmath83mn@xmath19ga@xmath22o@xmath2 .
they were successively recorded using different values of the field spacing ( @xmath43 ) and of the waiting time ( @xmath44 ) after each field installation ( first loop : circles ; second loop : squares ; third loop : diamonds ) .
: : magnetization loops at 2.5 k in three `` pure - mn '' manganites : a pr@xmath29ca@xmath61mno@xmath2 crystal , as well as pr@xmath84ca@xmath85mno@xmath2 and pr@xmath86ca@xmath87mno@xmath2 ceramics . | this paper reports on peculiar metamagnetic transitions which take place in antiferromagnetic , charge and orbitally ordered ( afcoo ) manganites . at very low temperatures , the virgin magnetization curves of some of these compounds
exhibit several , sharp steps giving rise to a staircase - like shape .
this staircase effect is shown to be sensitive to various experimental parameters .
several potential interpretations of the staircase effect are discussed in relation to this set of results . a martensitic - like scenario , involving a leading role of the structural distortions associated to the collapse of the orbital ordering , is found to be the most plausible interpretation . |
the use of a muon storage ring as an intense source of neutrinos has attracted renewed attention : it is a natural stepping stone toward a muon collider , and it would offer a wealth of opportunities for doing physics both of neutrinos ( long baseline ) , and with neutrinos ( front - end ) . whereas the physics of neutrino oscillations , and in particular the possibility of discovering cp violation in the neutrino sector provide some of the strongest motivations for a neutrino factory , a sizable part of the physics program at such a facility should be devoted to the use of the neutrino beam as a probe of matter .
end physics at a neutrino factory is based on the realization that , because of the flavor and spin structure of the coupling of neutrinos to weak currents , a neutrino beam has a greater physics potential than conventional electron or muon beams , and it can be used to perform tests of unsurpassed precision of the standard model , and as a probe of hadron structure of unique sensitivity . here
we will briefly review the potential of neutrino beams as probes of matter .
first , we will review deep - inelastic scattering ( dis ) with neutrino beams , and show that it can be used to sort out the flavor structure of parton distributions of the nucleon , both polarized and unpolarized .
then , we will consider increasingly less inclusive measurements , and see how they can be used to shed light on various other aspects of hadron structure , such as fragmentation functions and generalized parton distributions .
the results discussed here are based on a recent detailed quantitative study performed by a cern working group @xcite ; quantitative estimates given here are taken from there unless otherwise stated , and are based on the ` cern scenario ' @xcite for a neutrino factory : specifically , a 50 gev @xmath0 beam , with @xmath1 muon decays per year along a 100 m straight section . for other studies on the physics potential of neutrino factories
see ref .
@xcite ; a recent status report on the neutrino factory / muon collider project is in ref .
inclusive dis is the standard way of accessing the parton content of hadrons .
the use of neutrino beams allows one to study dis mediated by the weak , rather than electromagnetic interaction . the neutrino - nucleon deep - inelastic cross section for charged current interactions , up to corrections suppressed by powers of @xmath2
is given by [ disxsec ] & & = \
{ -2_p } , where @xmath3 are the lepton and proton helicities ( assuming longitudinal proton polarization ) , and the kinematic variables are @xmath4 ( lepton fractional energy loss ) , @xmath5 ( bjorken @xmath6 ) . the neutral current cross
section is found from eq .
( [ disxsec ] ) by letting @xmath7 and multiplying by an overall factor @xmath8 ^ 2 $ ] .
the advantage of @xmath9 and @xmath10-mediated dis over conventional @xmath11 dis is clear when inspecting the parton content of the polarized and unpolarized structure functions @xmath12 and @xmath13 .
up to @xmath14 corrections , in terms of the unpolarized and polarized quark distribution for the @xmath15th flavor @xmath16 and @xmath17 [ cols="^,^,^ " , ] charged - current event rates for several detector and beam configurations ( left ) , and expected errors on the determination of the individual nucleon structure functions ( right ) for one year of running.,title="fig : " ] -.5 cm charged - current event rates for several detector and beam configurations ( left ) , and expected errors on the determination of the individual nucleon structure functions ( right ) for one year of running.,title="fig : " ] -.5
cm -.5 cm -.6 cm here @xmath18 are the electric charges and @xmath19 , @xmath20 are the weak charges of the @xmath15th quark flavor .
if @xmath21 ( incoming @xmath22 beam ) , then @xmath23 . the structure functions @xmath24 , @xmath25 and @xmath26 are parity violating , and therefore not accessible in virtual photon scattering .
of course , beyond leading order in the strong coupling each quark or antiquark flavor s contribution receives @xmath27 corrections proportional to itself and to all other quark , antiquark and gluon distributions .
the gluon correction is flavor blind , and thus decouples from the parity violating structure functions @xmath24 , @xmath25 and @xmath26 .
hence , thanks to the weak couplings , more independent linear combination of individual quark and antiquark distributions are accessible .
a further advantage of a neutrino factory follows from the fact that the neutrino beam has a broad - band energy spectrum ( fig .
[ strfun ] ) . because @xmath28 , at fixed @xmath6 and @xmath29 , @xmath30 only varies with the beam energy . hence , at a neutrino factory it is possible to disentangle the individual structure functions which make up the cross section eq .
( [ strfun ] ) by measuring the neutrino energy on an event - by event basis , and then fitting the @xmath30 dependence of the data for fixed @xmath6 and @xmath29 ( fig .
[ strfun ] ) unpolarized parton distributions are a necessary ingredient in the computation of any collider process . however , only the up , down and gluon distributions can be determined in a reasonably accurate way from present - day dis data @xcite . also , only the combination @xmath31 can be extracted from @xmath11-mediated inclusive dis .
some information on strangeness can be extracted @xcite from neutrino data , while some less inclusive observables ( such as @xmath9 production , or drell yan ) provide some constraints on the relative size of the @xmath32 and @xmath33 distributions , but the results are at best semi quantitative ( see fig . [ pdfec ] ) .
percentage errors ( left , solid ) and correlation coefficients ( right ) of parton distributions at a @xmath34 factory compared to present day @xcite errors ( left , dashed ) .
, title="fig : " ] -.7 cm percentage errors ( left , solid ) and correlation coefficients ( right ) of parton distributions at a @xmath34 factory compared to present day @xcite errors ( left , dashed ) .
, title="fig : " ] -.7 cm -.7 cm -.65 cm thanks to the availability of more independent combinations of parton distributions , full flavor separation would be possible at a neutrino factory . in fig .
[ pdfec ] error estimates on individual partons at a neutrino factory are compared to the extant knowledge .
note that no current errors on strange and antiquark distributions are given , since the present results largely depend on theoretical prejudice . in fig .
[ pdfec ] we further show that the point by
point correlation of individual distributions determined at a neutrino factory is uniformly quite low , indicating that a model
independent flavor and antilabor separation is possible to 10%20% accuracy in most of the accessible kinematic range . such detailed knowledge of the flavor content of the nucleon , besides providing interesting clues on the nucleon structure , is crucial in extracting information on possible new physics signal from experimental data . for example
, recently a @xmath35 discrepancy has been found between the determination of the weinberg angle from the total @xmath34 dis cross section @xcite and the best fit standard model prediction . however , the most likely explanation of the effect @xcite is a difference in shape between @xmath36 and @xmath37 distributions , which was disregarded in the analysis of ref .
this @xmath38 difference is compatible with current uncertainties , and favored by the analysis of ref .
@xcite , but essentially impossible to determine accurately with present - day data .
this kind of situation is bound to become increasingly more common as subtle new physics effects will have to be disentangled from the huge standard background at future hadron colliders .
it is unlikely that any other hadron physics facility ( such as , for instance , the planned electron - ion collider @xcite ) could be competitive with a neutrino factory for flavor and quark - antiquark separation , and reach the level of accuracy of fig .
[ pdfec ] .
polarized dis has recently attracted considerable attention @xcite because of the unexpected smallness of the proton s singlet axial charge @xmath39 . in the naive parton model
the singlet axial charge is the fraction of the nucleon spin which is carried by quarks .
the zweig rule predicts that it should be approximately equal to the octet axial charge @xmath40 , which differs from it because of the strange contribution , expected to be small in a nucleon .
the octet charge can be determined using su(3 ) from baryon @xmath41decay constants : @xmath42 , so the zweig rule leads to expect that the quark spin fraction is around 60% .
however , the experimental value is compatible with zero .
clearly , this result points to a peculiar role of strangeness in the nucleon , but the issue is made more subtle by the inclusion of qcd corrections .
indeed , beyond leading order the axial charge is given by @xcite [ anomeq ] a_0= - g , where @xmath43 is the scale invariant quark spin fraction , and @xmath44 is the gluon spin fraction .
the latter , due to the axial anomaly , gives an effectively leading order contribution to @xmath39 eq .
( [ anomeq ] ) . on the other hand ,
gluons decouple from the octet charge @xmath40 .
so , a first possibility is that gluons are responsible for the difference : @xmath44 is large enough that the quark spin @xmath45 even though @xmath46 .
( ` anomaly ' scenario ) .
a different option ( ` instanton ' scenario @xcite ) is that @xmath47 because of a large contribution from sea quarks ( @xmath48 ) whose polarization is anticorrelated to that of valence quarks , possibly because of ` instanton ' qcd vacuum configurations .
yet another possibility ( ` skyrmion ' scenario @xcite ) is that @xmath47 is small because of a large contribution from ` valence ' strange quarks @xmath49 . at present ,
flavor separation is only possible in the isotriplet sector , and only the total quark and gluon spin fractions can be extracted from nc dis data @xcite , and then with modest accuracy : @xmath50 , @xmath51 .
it is of course impossible to polarize the kind of targets which are required for present day neutrino dis experiments , so little information on strangeness and no information at all on the quark antiquark separation is available in the polarized case . at a neutrino factory ,
significant rates could be achieved with small targets @xcite : with a detector radius of 50 cm , 100 m length , the structure functions @xmath52 , @xmath26 could be independently measured to an accuracy which is about one order of magnitude better than that with which @xmath52 is determined in present charged lepton dis experiments . on the basis of such data ,
the distinct scenarios could be well separated from each other @xcite : for instance in an ` instanton ' scenario @xmath53(1,1\,{\rm gev}^2)=-0.007\pm0.007 $ ] ; while in a ` skyrmion' scenario one would observe @xmath53(1,1\,{\rm gev}^2)=-0.106\pm0.008 $ ] .
in fact full flavor separation at the level of first moments would be possible .
again , the same result could be hardly achieved anywhere else , since forthcoming experiments are unlikely to determine @xmath54 and @xmath55 better than current experiment determined the unpolarized @xmath37 and @xmath36 .
-.5 cm -2.cm semi - inclusive experiments are a large fraction of the physics program of present - day electron scattering experiments such as compass @xcite and hermes @xcite . at a neutrino factory ,
semi - inclusive charm production would be copious and easy to detect , because of the pair of opposite - sign muons in the final state which characterize the charm decay .
a precise determination of the unpolarized and polarized tagged charm structure functions would be possible , since [ cstrf ] f^_1,c ( x , q^2 ) = |v_cs|^2 s ( , _ c^2 ) + |v_cd|^2 d ( , _ c^2 ) ; g^_1,c ( x , q^2 ) = direct determination of the strange distribution ( see fig . [ f2c ] ) , though in the polarized case one should worry about possible large gluon corrections , similarly to eq .
( [ anomeq ] ) .
also , one could perform accurate studies of deep - inelastic charm production close to threshold , which is theoretically quite interesting in perturbative qcd @xcite due to the simultaneous presence of two hard scales ( @xmath29 and @xmath56 ) . -.7
cm -.6 cm
semi - inclusive production of specific particles offers information on both parton distributions and fragmentation functions .
an example is polarized @xmath57 production : the @xmath57 polarization can be determined from the angular distribution of its decay , and one can construct asymmetries which are directly sensitive to polarized fragmentation functions . the latter are currently poorly known , and can only be determined on the basis of theoretical assumptions @xcite : that they are su(3 ) flavor symmetric , or on the contrary that the octet combination is much larger than the singlet , in analogy to what happens for the proton spin fraction .
predictions for the asymmetry @xmath58 as a function of the momentum fraction @xmath59 carried by the fragmenting quark are shown in fig .
[ lampol ] for fragmentation functions based on different theoretical assumptions , and for @xmath60 dis ( compass ) or @xmath34 dis . just as for structure functions ,
the flavor dependence of @xmath34 couplings makes results with a @xmath34 beam significantly more sensitive to the flavor structure of the fragmenting hadron .
l0.5 -1.8 cm -.3 cm -.7 cm hard qcd factorization can be generalized to several less inclusive processes by introducing generalized parton distributions @xcite ( gpd ) @xmath61 .
these quantities interpolate between the usual nucleon form factor @xmath62 ( which is related to the first @xmath6moment of @xmath63 ) and parton distribution @xmath64 ( related to the @xmath65 limit of @xmath63 ) .
an example of such process is exclusive @xmath66 production ( fig .
[ spd ] ) . in the kinematic region where the virtuality @xmath29 of the @xmath9 boson is large compared to the nucleon momentum transfer @xmath67 and all masses , the cross section for the process factorizes as [ gpdfact ] ( w^-+nd^-_s+n)=h_df , where @xmath68 is the cross section for the underlying hard perturbative parton subprocess , @xmath69 is the @xmath70 fragmentation function , and @xmath63 is the gpd .
the estimated cross section for this process is @xmath71 pb . the chorus collaboration has observed one such event , but in the region @xmath72 gev@xmath73 . at a neutrino factory
, one would observe @xmath74 event / yr , thus offering the possibility of a good determination of the gpd .
the focus of studies of the structure of hadrons is currently moving toward either precision measurements ( for parton distributions ) or rare processes ( for generalized parton distributions ) .
both are well served by the peculiar features of a neutrino beam , namely the availability of a probe which depends both on spin and flavor .
the physics potential of such a beam can only be exploited given high enough intensity . however
, a high intensity neutrino beam opens the possibility to a class of measurements which are essentially impossible at any other facility .
even though the time scale for a neutrino factory is greater than ten years , it is unlikely that many relevant issues of hadron physics , such as the proton spin puzzle , will find a satisfactory experimental answer elsewhere .
+ * acknowledgement : * i thank e. de sanctis for inviting me to participate in this stimulating meeting .
-.5 cm m. l. mangano _ et al .
_ , hep - ph/0105155 .
i. i. bigi _ et al .
_ , hep - ph/0106177 ; + t. adams _ et al .
_ , hep - ph/0111030
. m. m. alsharoa _ et al .
_ , hep - ex/0207031 .
j. pumplin , d. r. stump , j. huston , h. l. lai , p. nadolsky and w. k. tung , jhep * 0207 * ( 2002 ) 012 ; + a. d. martin , r. g. roberts , w. j. stirling and r. s. thorne , eur .
j. c * 23 * ( 2002 ) 73 .
s. i. alekhin , phys .
d * 63 * ( 2001 ) 094022 .
v. barone , c. pascaud and f. zomer , eur .
j. * c12 * , 243 ( 2000 ) .
s. davidson , s. forte , p. gambino , n. rius and a. strumia , jhep * 0202 * ( 2002 ) 037 .
g. p. zeller _ et al . _
[ nutev collaboration ] , phys .
* 88 * ( 2002 ) 091802 .
a. l. deshpande , nucl .
* 105 * ( 2002 ) 178 ; see also r. milner , these proceedings .
see s. forte , hep - ph/9409416 ; g. altarelli and g. g. ross , ; s. forte , ; . s. j. brodsky , j. ellis and m. karliner , .
r. d. ball , d. a. harris and k. s. mcfarland , hep - ph/0009223 .
s. forte , m. l. mangano and g. ridolfi , nucl . phys .
* b602 * ( 2001 ) 585 .
g. altarelli , r. d. ball , s. forte and g. ridolfi , _ acta phys . pol .
_ * b29 * ( 1998 ) 1145 .
f. bradamante [ compass collaboration ] , nucl .
a * 622 * ( 1997 ) 50c .
e. c. aschenauer [ hermes collaboration ] , in `` qcd@work '' ( aip , new york 2001 ) ; see also k. rith , these proceedings .
w. k. tung , s. kretzer and c. schmidt , j. phys .
g * 28 * ( 2002 ) 983 .
d. de florian , m. stratmann and w. vogelsang , phys .
d * 57 * ( 1998 ) 5811 .
m. anselmino , m. boglione , u. dalesio and f. murgia , eur .
j. c * 21 * ( 2001 ) 501 ; see also m. anselmino , these proceedings a. v. radyushkin , hep - ph/0101225 ; see also a. radyushkin , these proceedings . | we review the way intense neutrino beams at the front
end of a muon storage ring can be used to probe the structure of hadrons .
specifically , we discuss how the polarized and unpolarized flavor structure of the nucleon can be disentangled in inclusive deep - inelastic scattering , and how less inclusive measurements can shed light on various aspects of hadron structure such as fragmentation functions or generalized parton distributions .
hep - ph/0207209 + rm3th/02 - 10 + .3 cm * hadron physics at a neutrino factory * .5 cm stefano forte .3 cm _ infn , sezione di roma iii , + via della vasca navale 84 , i00146 roma , italy _
* abstract * we review the way intense neutrino beams at the front
end of a muon storage ring can be used to probe the structure of hadrons .
specifically , we discuss how the polarized and unpolarized flavor structure of the nucleon can be disentangled in inclusive deep - inelastic scattering , and how less inclusive measurements can shed light on various aspects of hadron structure such as fragmentation functions or generalized parton distributions .
2.5 cm invited talk at * qcd - n02 * + ferrara , italy , april 2002 + _ to be published in the proceedings _ |
the @xmath0-function introduced by fox @xcite , will be represented and defined in the following manner : @xmath1 & = h_{p , q}^{m , n } \left\lbrack x \bigg| \begin{array}{@{}l@ { } } ( a_{1 } , \alpha_{1 } ) , \ldots , ( a_{p } , \alpha_{p})\\[.2pc ] ( b_{1 } , \beta_{1 } ) , \ldots , ( b_{q } , \beta_{q } ) \end{array}\right\rbrack\nonumber\\[.2pc ] & = \frac{1}{2 \pi i } \int_{l }
\frac{\prod_{j = 1}^{m } \gamma ( b_{j } - \beta_{j } \xi ) \prod_{j = 1}^{n } \gamma ( 1 - a_{j } + \alpha_{j } \xi)}{\prod_{j = m + 1}^{q } \gamma ( 1 - b_{j } + \beta_{j } \xi ) \prod_{j = n + 1}^{p } \gamma ( a_{j } - \alpha_{j } \xi ) } x^{\xi } \ { \rm d}\xi.\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the nature of contour @xmath2 in ( 1.1 ) , the convergence , existence conditions and other details of the @xmath0-function , one can refer to @xcite .
the general class of polynomials introduced by srivastava @xcite is defined in the following manner : @xmath3 = \sum\limits_{k = 0}^{[v / u ] } \frac{(-v)_{uk } a ( v , k)}{k ! } x^{k } , \quad v = 0 , 1 , 2 , \ldots,\ ] ] where @xmath4 is an arbitrary positive integer and coefficients @xmath5 are arbitrary constants , real or complex .
@xmath6^{-\nu } h_{p , q}^{m , n } [ y \ { x + a + ( x^{2 } + 2ax)^{1/2 } \}^{-\mu}]\nonumber\\ & \qquad\qquad \times s_{v}^{u } [ z \ { x + a + ( x^{2 } + 2ax)^{1/2 } \}^{-\alpha } ] \hbox{d}x\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath7 } ( -v)_{uk } a ( v , k ) \frac{(z / a^{\alpha})^{k}}{k ! } h_{p + 2 , q + 2}^{m , n + 2}\nonumber\\[.2pc ] & \quad\ , \times \left\lbrack ya^{-\mu } \bigg| \begin{array}{@{}l@ { } } ( -\nu - \alpha k , \mu ) , ( 1 + \lambda - \nu - \alpha k , \mu ) , ( a_{1 } , \alpha_{1 } ) , \ldots , ( a_{p } , \alpha_{p})\\[.2pc ] ( b_{1 } , \beta_{1}),\ldots,(b_{q } , \beta_{q } ) , ( 1 - \nu - \alpha k , \mu ) , ( -\nu - \alpha k - \lambda , \mu ) \end{array } \!\right\rbrack,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where 1 .
@xmath8 , 2 .
@xmath9 . to obtain the result ( 2.1 ) , we first express fox @xmath0-function involved in its left - hand side in terms of contour integral using eq .
( 1.1 ) and the general class of polynomials @xmath10 $ ] in series form given by eq . ( 1.2 ) . interchanging the orders of integration and summation ( which is permissible under the conditions stated with ( 2.1 ) ) and evaluating the @xmath11-integral with the help of the result given below @xcite : @xmath12^{-\nu } { \rm d}x\\ & \quad\ = 2 \nu a^{-\nu } \left(\frac{1}{2}a\right)^{z } [ \gamma ( 1 + \nu + z)]^{-1 } \gamma ( 2z ) \gamma ( \nu - z),\quad 0 < \hbox{re } ( z ) < \nu,\end{aligned}\ ] ] we easily arrive at the desired result ( 2.1 )
if in the integral ( 2.1 ) we reduce @xmath10 $ ] to unity and fox @xmath0-function to gauss hypergeometric function @xcite , we arrive at the following result after a little simplification : @xmath13^{-\nu}\nonumber\\ & \qquad\ \times { _ { 2}f_{1 } } ( a , b ; c ; y ( x + a + ( x^{2 } + 2ax)^{1/2})^{-1}){\rm d}x\nonumber\\ & \quad\ = 2^{1 - \lambda } \nu \gamma ( 2 \lambda ) a^{\lambda - \nu } \frac{\gamma ( \nu - \lambda)}{\gamma ( \nu + \lambda + 1)}\nonumber\\ & \qquad\ \times { _ { 4}f_{3 } } ( a , b , \nu - \lambda , \nu + 1 ; c , \nu , \nu + \lambda + 1 ; y / a),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath14 the importance of the result given by ( 3.1 ) lies in the fact that it not only gives the value of the integral but also ` augments ' the coefficients in the series in the integrand to give a @xmath15 series as the integrated series
. a number of other integrals involving functions that are special cases of fox @xmath0-function @xcite and/or the general class of polynomials @xcite can also be obtained from ( 2.1 ) but we do not record them here .
the authors are thankful to the worthy referee for his very valuable suggestions .
the first author is thankful to the university grants commission , new delhi for providing necessary financial assistance to carry out the present work .
the authors are thankful to k c gupta , jaipur for his useful suggestions . | in the present paper we derive a unified new integral whose integrand contains products of fox @xmath0-function and a general class of polynomials having general arguments . a large number of integrals involving various simpler functions follow as special cases of this integral .
= msam10 at 10pt = mtgub at 10.4pt = tibi at 10.4pt [ theore]*theorem * [ theore]proposition [ theore]lemma [ theore]definition [ theore]corollary [ theore]remark [ theore]example |
initial states of color gauge fields ( glasma ) produced immediately after high energy heavy - ion collisions have recently received much attention . the gauge fields are longitudinal classical color electric and magnetic fields ;
their field strengths are given by the square of the saturation momentum @xmath2 .
the presence of such classical gauge fields has been discussed on the basis of a fairly reliable effective theory of qcd at high energies , that is , a model of color glass condensate ( cgc)@xcite .
it is expected that the decay of the glasma leads to thermalized quark gluon plasma ( qgp ) .
the glasma is homogeneous in the longitudinal direction and inhomogeneous in the transverse directions .
hence , we may view that it forms electric and magnetic flux tubes extending in the longitudinal direction . in the previous papers@xcite
we have shown a possibility that the famous nielsen - olesen instability@xcite makes the color magnetic field @xmath4 decay .
the possibility has been partially confirmed by the comparison between our results and numerical simulations@xcite .
such decay is a first step toward the generation of qgp .
on the other hand we have also discussed@xcite the decay of the color electric field ; the decay is caused by schwinger mechanism@xcite , that is , the pair production of quarks and anti - quarks .
the mechanism has been extensively explored@xcite since the discovery of klein paradox . among them , the pair production in the expanding glasma has been discussed@xcite .
a new feature in the glasma is that it is composed of not only electric field but also magnetic field parallel to the electric field .
such a feature has also been explored .
in particular , recently there are studies of the back reaction of the particles on the electric field under the presence of the magnetic field@xcite .
the back reaction is essentially important for the decay of the electric field .
our originality@xcite for the investigation of the decay is to use chiral anomaly .
as is well known , the anomaly is effective when collinear magnetic and electric fields are present .
this is the very situation in the glasma .
when we use the chiral anomaly , we can discuss schwinger mechanism without detail calculations@xcite of wave functions but simply by solving classical anomaly equation and maxwell equations .
in particular , when the strong magnetic field is present , the anomaly is much simplified because the quarks are effectively massless and only relevant states are ones in the lowest landau level . ( both @xmath5 and @xmath6 in the glasma are much larger than mass of quarks . ) since the motions of the quarks in transverse directions are frozen , only possible motion is along the longitudinal direction .
thus , the anomaly equation is reduced to the one in two dimensional space - time . with the simplification
, we can find important quantities even in complicated realistic situations for which the investigations have not yet performed .
actually , we have discussed the decay of axial symmetric electric flux tube by taking account of the azimuthal magnetic field around the tube .
the field is generated by the current carried by the pair created quarks and anti - quarks .
although the electric field loses its energy by the pair creation and the generation of the azimuthal magnetic field , it never decays . the field oscillating with time propagates to the infinity in the axial symmetric way@xcite .
this is because the quarks are free particles and there is no energy dissipation .
( in the case of homogeneous electric field , the field simply oscillates with time . ) in this paper we wish to discuss the decay of the color electric field @xmath7 by taking account of energy dissipation in heat baths .
the dissipation arises due to the presence of finite electric conductivity .
namely , the pair production generates color electric current @xmath8 , which dissipates its energy owing to the interaction between the quarks and the surrounding ; the surrounding is composed of quarks and gluons . actually , we assume ohm law @xmath9 with electric conductivity @xmath10 .
the conductivity is calculated by using boltzmann equation in the relaxation time approximation . in the approximation a relaxation time
is obtained by calculating electron s scattering rates .
then , we can show that the quarks are thermalized immediately after their production as far as their temperature is much smaller than @xmath11 ; the relaxation time of a slightly deformed momentum distribution of quarks becoming the equilibrium fermi distribution is much shorter than the life time @xmath12 of the field . as numerical calculations
have shown@xcite , the longitudinal momentum distribution of the free particles produced in the vacuum is almost equal to the equilibrium one , that is fermi distribution at zero temperature .
thus , even in non zero but low temperature , the momentum distribution is nearly equal to the equilibrium one .
our relaxation time approximation in boltzmann equation may holds in such a situation .
therefore , owing to the energy dissipation by the scattering between electrons and positrons , the electric field decays and never oscillates . for simplicity , we examine homogeneous electric and magnetic fields of u(1 ) gauge theory instead of su(3 ) gauge theory .
thus , we use terminology of electron or positron instead of quark or anti - quark . the generalization of our results to the case of su(3 ) gauge theory is straightforward done simply by assuming maximal abelian group of su(3)@xcite .
we assume that both the electric and magnetic fields are much larger than the square of the electron mass .
thus , they are taken to be massless . in the next section
we explain how the chiral anomaly is useful for the discussion of schwinger mechanism .
we apply the anomaly to the discussion of the pair production with energy dissipation in the section @xmath13 . in the discussion we use the conductivity of electron - positron gas under strong magnetic field .
the detail calculation of it is shown in the appendix .
we first make a brief review of the utility of the chiral anomaly . as we will show below , only by simple calculations we can obtain most of important results of schwinger mechanism , which was derived previously by detail calculations .
under the homogenous magnetic field @xmath4 , massless fermions with charge @xmath14 occupy the states characterized by landau level and momentum @xmath15 parallel to the magnetic field .
their energies are given by @xmath16 where integer @xmath17 denotes landau level .
the term of parallel " ( anti - parallel " ) implies magnetic moment parallel ( anti - parallel ) to @xmath18 . the magnetic moment of electrons ( positrons ) is antiparallel ( parallel ) to their spin .
thus , electrons ( positrons ) with spin anti - parallel ( parallel ) to @xmath18 can have zero energy states in the lowest landau level ; their energy spectrum is given by @xmath19 .
on the other hand , the other states can not be zero energy states .
hence only relevant states for the pair production are states with energy @xmath20 in the limit of strong magnetic field .
hereafter , we consider only such states .
the equation of the chiral anomaly for the states leads to @xmath21 where @xmath22 ( @xmath23 ) denotes number density of right ( left ) handed chiral fermions ; @xmath24 in which the expectation value is taken by using the states in the lowest landau level .
we have used spatial uniformness of the chiral current @xmath25 , that is , @xmath26 .
we note that electrons move to the direction anti - parallel to @xmath27 while positrons move to the direction parallel to @xmath27 after their pair production . therefore ,
both the electrons and positrons have right handed helicity when @xmath27 being parallel to @xmath18 .
( right or left handed helicity means the state with momentum parallel or antiparallel to spin , respectively . ) since chirality is equivalent to helicity of massless fermions , @xmath28 and @xmath29 where @xmath30 is the number density of electrons .
( when @xmath27 is anti - parallel to @xmath18 , @xmath31 and @xmath32 . )
therefore , the anomaly equation describes the pair production rate of electron and positrons under @xmath7 and @xmath4 , @xmath33 for example , we suppose that the electric field @xmath34 is switched on at @xmath35 .
then , solving this equation with initial condition @xmath36 , we can obtain the number density of electrons@xcite ; @xmath37 .
when @xmath7 is constant , @xmath30 increases linearly with time . in this estimation , the back reaction of the produced particles to the electric field
is not taken into account .
when we take account of the back reaction , we can find that the electric field oscillates with time .
the back reaction is that the energy of electric field decreases owing to the acceleration of the charged particles .
it can be included by solving a maxwell equation , @xmath38 along with the anomaly equation . to solve the equations , we need to express the electric current @xmath8 in terms of @xmath30 .
this can be done by considering the energy conservation .
namely , the total energy of the electric field and the charged particles @xmath39 is conserved , @xmath40 where the energy density of electrons or positrons is given such that @xmath41 with fermi momentum @xmath42 for @xmath43 .
namely , we assume the energy of free electrons and positrons .
their momentum distributions are supposed to be @xmath44 for positrons or @xmath45 for electrons .
we have used the formula @xmath46 in eq([4 ] ) .
thus , from the equation we obtain the electric current @xmath47 for @xmath43 .
obviously , there is no energy dissipation . using the maxwell equation and the anomaly equation we derive the equation of the number density , @xmath48
we can see that after the switch on of @xmath7 , @xmath7 gradually decreases with time , while @xmath30 increases . eventually , these quantities oscillate with the frequency @xmath49 ( plasma oscillation ) as shown in fig.1 .
the oscillation can be understood in the following .
( dash ) and electric field ( line ) with arbitrary scale , width=245 ] when @xmath7 ( @xmath50 ) parallel to @xmath4 is switched on at @xmath35 with @xmath36 , the number @xmath30 of the particles increases while @xmath7 decreases .
when @xmath7 vanishes , @xmath30 takes the maximum .
after that @xmath7 changes its sign , namely , @xmath7 becomes negative ( anti - parallel to @xmath4 . )
then , the particles are forced to move to the direction inverse to the one in the case of @xmath43 .
thus , the pair annihilation occurs and @xmath30 begins to decrease .
the energy of the particles is transmitted to the energy of the electric field . actually , according to the anomaly equation
, @xmath51 becomes large with time .
when @xmath30 vanishes , @xmath51 takes the maximum ( @xmath52 ) .
subsequently , the pair creation occurs and @xmath30 increases according to the anomaly equation([ch ] ) but with @xmath53 .
this is a plasma oscillation shown in the figure .
the energy of the electric field is transmitted to the particles and then the energy of the particles goes back to the electric field .
the plasma oscillation is a natural consequence of the absence of the dissipation .
we should make a comment on the scales involved in the discussion .
the above result ( plasma oscillation ) holds in the limit of @xmath54 where only the states in the lowest landau level are relevant . on the other hand when @xmath55 , states in higher landau levels become important since the energy @xmath56 of electrons can be much larger than @xmath57 . in the glasma we have both @xmath58 and @xmath59 ( square of electron mass ) .
but states in higher landau levels are still not important according to the following reason .
when some of electrons in the lowest landau level are accelerated and their energies reach the energy @xmath60 , they may make a transition to a state in a higher landau level with energy @xmath61 .
such electrons are the ones produced in the very early stage of the pair production .
the number of the electrons is still a fraction .
most of electrons whose energies are less than @xmath57 , occupy the lowest landau level .
it has recently been shown@xcite that the decay of the electric field is mainly caused by particles in the lowest landau level .
thus , our result is approximately correct . in this way
, we obtain the number density of electrons simply by using the chiral anomaly .
it is important to note that the anomaly equation involves all of quantum effects .
thus , by simply solving the classical anomaly equation , we can obtain the quantities resulting from the purely quantum effect , i.e. schwinger mechanism . in the standard manipulation@xcite of schwinger mechanism , we need to find wave functions of electrons under the electric and magnetic fields in order to obtain such quantities .
when the time dependence of the electric field is complicated , it is very difficult to obtain the wave functions . on the other hand ,
the anomaly equation is a very simple and powerful tool for investigating schwinger mechanism .
up to now , we have not taken into account energy dissipation of electrons and positrons produced by the electric field .
we proceed to analyse the schwinger mechanism in heat bath , especially , the case with energy dissipation .
we assume that the particles are immediately thermalized after their production .
( later we see that relaxation time , within which slightly deformed particle distribution becomes equilibrium distribution , is much shorter than the typical scale @xmath62 as far as the system is in low temperature . as numerical calculations have shown@xcite , the momentum distribution of the produced particles is nearly equal to the fermi distribution at zero temperature . )
thus , the number density @xmath30 is given by @xmath63 with @xmath64 , where @xmath65 is the inverse of temperature @xmath66 and @xmath67 is chemical potential of electrons or positrons .
the number density @xmath30 depends on two parameters , @xmath68 and @xmath67 , which may be functions of time .
hereafter , we consider only the case that the chemical potential @xmath67 vanishes due to non - conservation of electron number .
it is caused by frequent pair annihilation or creation of electrons and positrons after their production . since initial states have no lepton number , the chemical potential vanishes .
( this corresponds to the situation in the glasma where the pair annihilation or creation of quarks and anti - quarks frequently take place after the pair creation by schwinger mechanism . )
thus , the number density is only a function of the temperature and is given by @xmath69 .
similarly , the energy density is given by @xmath70 with @xmath71 .
since the temperature @xmath1 represents an average energy of the particles , it is reasonable that we have @xmath72 ; the energy density is equal to the number density times the average energy of a particle .
the electric field produces electrons and positrons and generates their electric currents . when the electric current flows , the current dissipates its energy due to the finite electric conductivity of these particles . thus , the electric field dissipates its energy . here
we may assume that the electric current @xmath8 satisfies the ohm law @xmath73 where @xmath10 denotes electric conductivity .
obviously , the ohm law represents the energy dissipation of the electric field @xmath74 .
as we will show in the appendix , the electric conductivity @xmath10 of the charged particles in the lowest landau level is given by @xmath75 where @xmath76 denotes the momentum distribution of the charged particles .
the conductivity depends on the relaxation time @xmath77 ; the time needed for a momentum distribution to become the equilibrium one @xmath78 .
the relaxation is realized by scattering of the charged particles so that it can be expressed by their scattering amplitudes .
the detail calculation shows that @xmath79 in the limit of low temperature @xmath80 .
( this fact makes valid our assumption of the immediate thermalization in the low temperature where the relaxation time is small . )
thus , the conductivity depends on the temperature such as @xmath81 in the limit ( @xmath82 is a numerical constant ) .
thus , using the maxwell equation @xmath83 and the anomaly equation @xmath84 ( @xmath85 ) , we find that @xmath86 setting @xmath87 , we obtain the equation of the electric field @xmath88 with initial conditions @xmath89 and @xmath90 .
the number density @xmath91 can be obtained by integrating the solution @xmath92 such that @xmath93 .
the equation ( [ x ] ) describes a motion of a classical particle with the potential energy @xmath94 ; @xmath95 denotes the coordinate of the particle . starting at @xmath96 ,
the particle goes down to @xmath97 along the slope of the potential .
it means that @xmath98 .
namely , the electric field vanishes with the life time of the typical scale @xmath99 .
( the life time of the electric field is sufficiently short to be consistent with phenomenology@xcite of qgp . ) since @xmath100 , the number density @xmath30 or the temperature @xmath66 monotonically increases with time and reaches its maximum .
this is contrasted with the case of no dissipation in which both @xmath7 and @xmath30 oscillate .
these behaviors are shown in the fig.2 .
( dash ) and electric field ( line ) with arbitrary scale , width=245 ] we can roughly estimate the attainable number density @xmath30 , temperature @xmath66 and average energy of the particles @xmath101 in the pair creation , @xmath102 where we set @xmath103 which corresponds to gauge coupling constant @xmath104 in qcd with the energies at rich or lhc . we should make a comment .
the result has been derived in the limit of the low temperature .
the relaxation time @xmath105 is sufficiently short in the limit so that we can use the equilibrium momentum distribution
. the temperature increases with time from zero after the switch - on of the electric field .
therefore , the result is reliable in the early stage of the pair creation .
however , when it becomes comparable to @xmath106 , the assumption does not hold .
then , we can not use the formula @xmath107 , @xmath105 and the equilibrium momentum distribution .
hence , the result of the saturation in the number density at the late stage of the evolution can not be reliable .
but , as the temperature increases and becomes comparable to @xmath106 , the conductivity is almost constant in time , then , we find that @xmath108 from the equation @xmath109 and that @xmath110 from the anomaly equation .
the number density is saturated and never oscillate .
( to obtain this result we do not use the equilibrium momentum distribution .
namely , the assumption of the particles being immediately thermalized is not necessary . ) actually , when the temperature or the average energy of the particles is comparable with @xmath106 , the electric conductivity may depends weakly on the time because only dimensional quantity in @xmath10 is @xmath106 or the average energy . consequently , we find that the number density ( temperature ) gradually increases in the early stage and is saturated at the late stage .
it never oscillates unlike the case with no energy dissipation . to put it another way ,
in the early stage when the pair creation starts , the particles are thermalized soon because the relaxation time is short .
thus , the temperature can be defined .
the temperature or the average energy of the particles is much less than @xmath111 . but in the stage when relaxation time is not sufficiently short for the particles to be thermalized soon , the temperature can not be defined . in the stage
all of the typical energy scales are of the order of @xmath2 .
thus , the electric conductivity is also of the order of @xmath2 .
this leads to the above result of the saturation @xmath110 .
the stage is not early stage but may be late stage in the pair creation . in this way
we understand that the results shown in fig.2 are reliable .
we have shown that the color electric field decays into the quarks and anti - quarks under the color magnetic field .
they occupy only the states in the lowest landau level .
we have also discussed that the average energy of the particles is of the order of the saturation momentum @xmath2 .
namely , the fermi momentum , which is the longitudinal momentum , is given by @xmath2 .
the particles obtain the longitudinal momentum with the acceleration by the electric field .
we remind you that the glasma has only transverse momentum of the order of @xmath2 and has no longitudinal momentum owing to the homogeneity in the direction . thus , initially there is anisotropy in momentum distribution . but
owing to the decay of the electric field , the particles have longitudinal momenta of the order of @xmath2 .
thus , the longitudinal and transverse momenta become almost identical to each other .
this is a step toward the isotropy of the momenta or thermalization of the quarks .
the life time of the electric field has been found to be of the order of @xmath0 , while that of the magnetic field by a decay mechanism of nielsen olesen instability is much longer@xcite than @xmath0 .
we may speculate that the magnetic field also decay rapidly due to schwinger mechanism .
this is because azimuthal electric field is generated by the expansion of the longitudinal magnetic flux tube and this electric field decays by schwinger mechanism .
the expansion in the transverse direction of the magnetic flux tube is simply a result of maxwell equations@xcite .
similarly , azimuthal magnetic field is also generated by the expansion of the longitudinal electric flux tube .
thus , both azimuthal magnetic and electric fields are generated around the longitudinal flux tubes
. then , the azimuthal electric field decays in the way as we have shown .
the field strengths of these longitudinal and transverse ( azimuthal ) fields have been shown@xcite to become the same order of magnitudes at about the time @xmath0 after the high energy heavy ion collisions . in this way
, the longitudinal magnetic flux may decay rapidly through the decay of the azimuthal electric field generated by the expansion of the magnetic flux .
such a rapid decay of the magnetic field as well as the electric field is favorable for establishing early thermalization@xcite of qgp . to summarize ,
we have shown how the electric field decays by schwinger mechanism in the presence of the energy dissipation .
namely , the electric current carried by electrons and positrons dissipate its energy owing to the ohm law , which results in the increase of the temperature with time .
our result holds only in the limit of low temperature , in which the relaxation time has been shown to be much short ; the thermalization of produced particles can be realized immediately after their production .
however , we have also discussed that our result is approximately correct even when the temperature or the average energy of the particles is of the order of @xmath2 .
we show that the electric conductivity behaves as @xmath113 in the limit of the low temperature @xmath114 .
we calculate @xmath10 in the relaxation time approximation of boltzmann equation , with @xmath116 , where we have used classical equation of motion , @xmath117 .
@xmath118 denotes relaxation time and @xmath119 does fermi momentum distribution with the vanishing chemical potential ; @xmath120 .
@xmath121 represents a deformed momentum distribution caused by the effect of the electric field . since the electric current @xmath8 is given by where we denote longitudinal momentum of each particle ( parallel to @xmath18 ) as @xmath15 , @xmath126 , @xmath127,and @xmath128 .
we use the notations like @xmath129 , etc . to distinguish the contributions of different feymann diagrams , which was used in the paper @xcite .
we also use the notations @xmath130 and @xmath131 to distinguish the contributions of the processes @xmath132 and @xmath133 . where we use the gauge potential @xmath138 of the magnetic field @xmath139 .
@xmath140 and @xmath141 denote spatial lengths in the direction of @xmath142 and @xmath143 axis , respectively .
the states are characterized by two momenta @xmath15 and @xmath144 . using the formulae ,
the scattering amplitudes can be calculated in the following way .
for example , the scattering amplitude @xmath145 of @xmath146 associated with @xmath147 is obtained by estimating the formula , now we explain that the electric conductivity behaves as @xmath113 in the limit of @xmath114 . in the integrals of @xmath165 ,
we rescale all momenta such as e.g. @xmath166 .
then , we find @xmath167 in which dimensionless quantity @xmath168 depends on @xmath68 and @xmath169 through the dimensionless quantity @xmath170 . using the delta functions we can trivially perform the integration of the variables @xmath171 , @xmath172 and @xmath173 . among remaining integrations of @xmath174 , @xmath175 and @xmath176 ,
the integration of @xmath174 is finite at @xmath177 due to the factor @xmath178 for @xmath179 . on the other hand ,
the integrations of @xmath175 and @xmath176 are finite at @xmath180 or @xmath181 owing to the factors @xmath182 or @xmath183 and @xmath184 or @xmath185 .
hence , @xmath165 behaves such that @xmath186 in the limit of @xmath187 .
therefore , @xmath188 . as we have stated before , the relaxation time @xmath189 is quite shorter than the typical time scale @xmath190 in the period of @xmath191 .
thus , we may think that the particles produced by schwinger mechanism are immediately thermalized at least in the early stage of the electric field decay .
99 a. kovner , l. mclerran and h. weigert , phys .
d52 ( 1995 ) 6231 .
e. iancu , a. leonidov and l. mclerran , hep - ph/0202270 .
+ e. iancu and r. venugopalan , hep - ph/0303204 .
a. iwazaki , phys .
c77 ( 2008 ) 034907 ; prog .
( 2009 ) 809 .
h. fujii and k. itakura , nucl .
a809 ( 2008 ) 88 .
h. fujii , k. itakura and a. iwazaki , hep - ph/0903.2930 .
nielsen and p. olesen , nucl .
b144 ( 1978 ) 376 .
p. romatschke and r. venugopalan , phys .
96 ( 2006 ) 062302 ; phys .
d74 ( 2006 ) 045011 .
j. berges , s. scheffler and d. sexty , phys .
d77 ( 2008 ) 034504 .
m. gyulassy and a. iwazaki , phys .
lett . 165b ( 1985 ) 157 .
a. iwazaki , phys .
c80 ( 2009 ) 052202 ; arxiv:0904.1449 .
a. casher , h. neuberger and s. nussinov , phys . rev .
d20 ( 1979 ) 179 .
+ k. kajantie and t. matsui , phys .
lett . 164b ( 1985 ) 373 .
j. schwinger , phys .
82 ( 1951 ) 664 .
n. tanji , annals .
( 2009 ) 1691 ( see the references therein ) ; annals .
( 2010 ) 2018 .
y. kluger , j. eisenberg , b. svetitsky , f. cooper and e. mottola , + phys .
67 ( 1991 ) 2427 ; phys .
d45 ( 1992 ) 4659 .
+ a. baltz and l. mclerran , phys . rev . c58 ( 1998 ) 1679 .
+ f. gelis , k. kajantie and t. lappi , phys .
96 ( 2006 ) 032304 .
+ b. mihaila , f. cooper and j. dawson , phys .
d 78 ( 2008 ) 116017 .
+ n. tanji , phys .
d83 ( 2010 ) 045011 .
y. hidaka , t. intani and h. suganuma , arxv:1103.3097 .
t. lappi , phys .
b643 ( 2006 ) 11 . t. hirano and y. nara , nucl . phys .
a743 ( 2004 ) 305 ; j. phys .
g30 ( 2004 ) s1139 .
s. ghosh , etal .
astro - ph/0106153 . | initial states of glasma in high energy heavy ion collisions are longitudinal classical color electric and magnetic fields . assuming finite color electric conductivity , we show that the color electric field decays by quark pair production with the life time of the order of @xmath0 , i.e. the inverse of the saturation momentum .
quarks and anti - quarks created in the pair production are immediately thermalized as far as their temperature @xmath1 is lower than @xmath2 .
namely , a relaxation time of the quarks to be thermalized is much shorter than @xmath0 when @xmath3 .
we also show that the quarks acquire longitudinal momentum of the order of @xmath2 by the acceleration of the electric field . to discuss the quark pair production , we use chiral anomaly which has been shown to be very powerful tool in the presence of strong magnetic field . |
while the cold dark matter ( cdm ) paradigm for structure formation successfully describes cosmological observations on large ( cmb and cluster ) scales , there is notable disagreement with small - scale observations . among other issues , @xmath4-body simulations ( e.g. , via lactea diemand et al .
2008 ; aquarius springel et al . 2008 ) predict the existence of numerous cdm subhalos , with masses @xmath5@xmath6 , embedded in galaxy - scale dark matter halos . this has proved troubling observationally , because there are many fewer dwarf galaxies in our own milky way than predicted by cdm . since the discrepancy may be due to baryon stripping from subhalos ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , we need ways to probe dark matter substructure directly , regardless of the presence of baryonic material . gravitational lensing provides a unique way to detect cdm substructure in distant galaxies ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
stars and cdm substructure perturb the lens potential on micro- to milli - arcsecond scales , which can have dramatic effects on the properties of lensed images . most notably , lensing from stars and dark matter substructure can alter the flux ratios from those of smooth mass distributions . as shown by @xcite , lens flux ratios depend on the size of the source compared to the size of the perturber .
when the source is very small , it is effectively a point source for the lens substructure , so it feels an additional magnification boost ( @xmath7 ) over and above the macroscopic lens properties .
as the source increases in size , @xmath8 may increase or decrease depending on the source s location relative to the substructure and the parity of the `` macro '' magnification .
as the source grows still larger , it ceases to be affected by the substructure and @xmath9 .
this phenomenon implies that by measuring flux ratios at different wavelengths , corresponding to different source sizes , we may be able to map substructure on a variety of scales ( also see * ? ? ?
heuristically , a quasar emitting region of size @xmath10 is significantly affected by a subhalo with einstein radius @xmath11 only if @xmath12 . for typical lens and source redshifts ( e.g. , @xmath13 and @xmath14 ) , the einstein radius of a subhalo of mass @xmath15 is @xmath16 .
since the optically emitting regions of quasars have @xmath17@xmath18 cm @xcite , optical lens flux ratios are sensitive to both microlensing by stars and millilensing by cdm substructure .
by contrast , the more extended infrared emitting regions with @xmath19 pc @xcite can only be affected by relatively massive subhalos . comparing lens flux ratios at different wavelengths
therefore makes it possible to constrain the amount of micro- and milli - lensing present in the system , as well as the sizes of the perturbers .
previous studies have used mid - ir observations to probe rest - frame ir emission , yielding evidence for subhalos with masses @xmath20 in the lenses b1422 + 231 and mg 0414 + 0534 @xcite , constraints on the mass of a luminous companion galaxy in h1413 + 117 @xcite , and null detections in several other systems @xcite . here
we extend the study of wavelength - dependent flux ratios by using @xmath0 ( @xmath21 m ) and @xmath1 ( @xmath22 m ) images of six lenses obtained with gemini north during the 2008b semester .
for source redshifts @xmath2 , the @xmath1-band images correspond to rest - frame emission at @xmath23 m where @xmath2420100% of the flux is thermal emission from the inner dusty torus @xcite .
by contrast , the @xmath0-band flux comes mostly from the smaller accretion disk .
thus , comparing @xmath0 and @xmath1 flux ratios may provide a sufficient source size baseline to identify substructure . to be sure ,
there are phenomena besides cdm substructure that may cause lens flux ratios to vary with wavelength .
optical observations probe rest - frame uv emission from the accretion disk of the agn , so they are sensitive to microlensing by stars in the lens galaxy ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
optical flux ratios can also be altered by differential extinction from dust in the lens galaxy ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
finally , intrinsic variability in the source coupled with the lens time delay can cause flux ratios to vary with time , and the variability may be chromatic.100 , he 0435@xmath31223 , sbs 0909 + 523 , and he 2149@xmath32745 . ]
all three effects should be attenuated at near - ir wavelengths , because the effective size of the accretion disk is larger and some of the flux originates in the larger dusty torus , but they may not be entirely absent . in particular , the importance of microlensing and intrinsic variability for @xmath1-band observations will depend on the relative strengths of the accretion disk ( 0.01 0.1 pc , @xmath25@xmath26 arcsec ) and dusty torus ( 0.55 pc , @xmath27@xmath28 arcsec ) emission .
any significant wavelength - dependence in lens flux ratios is interesting , whether related to cdm substructure or not , so at minimum our observations can highlight systems that warrant further study .
most lensing constraints on cdm substructure have relied on the identification of flux ratio anomalies , which is best done using four - image lenses .
the reason is that identifying such anomalies requires either well - constrained lens models ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) or universal magnification relations that apply only to certain four - image configurations @xcite . however , the search for wavelength dependence in flux ratios is a purely observational task that may provide model - independent evidence for substructure .
we are therefore able to analyze two - image lenses for the presence of substructure for the first time .
some care is needed when interpreting the results ( see [ sec : irdiscuss ] ) , but the observations are still valuable .
to explore the multi - wavelength behavior of flux ratios , we obtained the first @xmath0 ( @xmath21 m ) and @xmath1 ( @xmath22 m ) images for six gravitational lenses using the near infrared imager ( niri ) located at the gemini north facility .
our lens sample was selected from the set of known quasar lenses that can be found in the castles database .
our targets ( table [ tab : obs ] ) were chosen to have relatively bright ( @xmath29 ) and well separated ( @xmath30 ) images , and to be accessible during the 2008b semester .
the targets were also selected to have source redshifts @xmath31 so that @xmath1-band observations correspond to rest - frame emission at @xmath32 m .
information about the observations is given in table [ tab : obs ] .
ccccccc q0142@xmath3100 & 0.491 & 2.719 & 2.24 & 8.21.2008 & 3 & 32 + sdss 0246@xmath30825 & 0.723 & 1.680 & 1.04 & 8.18.2008 , 8.20.2008 & 4.8 & 76 + he 0435@xmath31223 & 0.455 & 1.689 & 2.42 & 8.31.2008,12.22.2008 & 4.8 & 64 + sdss 0806 + 2006 & 0.573 & 1.540 & 1.40 & 12.22.2008 & 2.4 & 20 + sbs 0909 + 523 & 0.830 & 1.376 & 1.17 & 12.22.2008 & 1.6 & 2 + he 2149@xmath32745 & 0.603 & 2.033 & 1.70 & 12.22.2008 & 3 & 32 [ tab : obs ] all of our targets have previous ground- and space - based imaging .
results from single - epoch _ hubble space telescope _ ( hst ) @xmath33 , @xmath34 , and @xmath35 band photometry have been used in the past to derive lens models ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) . among the various ground - based studies ,
optical monitoring programs are particularly useful to us because they help quantify the intrinsic variability in the source and the amplitude of variability induced by microlensing @xcite . at wavelengths @xmath36 m ,
thermal emission from earth s atmosphere becomes an increasingly significant component of the flux recorded at the telescope . in order to remove the ( often dominant ) emission from the foreground sky
, observations in the infrared are nodded between positions on and off source . since our targets are much smaller than the field of view ( image separation @xmath37 , compared with a @xmath38 field of view in @xmath1 )
, we decided to `` nod on chip '' by using a small @xmath39 , @xmath40 dither pattern .
for each dither position , three other positions are available to construct sky model images .
this strategy effectively doubles our observing efficiency by eliminating the need for off - source positions .
in addition to providing sky subtraction images , dithering reduces the sensitivity of the observations to hot or bad pixels in the niri array . for @xmath0-band observations ,
single exposures of 2040 s were selected to ensure that the bright quasar images ( extrapolated from 1.6 to @xmath21 m assuming @xmath41 ; @xcite ) would not fill more than 50% of the detector well . in the @xmath1 band ,
the sky brightness restricts exposure times to 1 s in order to prevent saturation . to accumulate the necessary integration time , the short @xmath1 exposures were co - added in 30 s blocks at each dither position .
data reduction was conducted with standard iraf routines provided by gemini observatory .
the reduction proceeded as follows .
first bad pixel masks and sigma clipping algorithms were applied to account for defective and hot pixels in the detector .
the images were then flat fielded . for @xmath0-band observations ,
sky brightness is subdominant and separate calibration flats were taken each night .
since the sky dominates @xmath1-band observations , the images themselves are essentially sky flats and are used to construct flat field images . after flat fielding , the data were sky - subtracted using observations from other positions in the same dither pattern .
@xmath1 sky images were limited to dither positions immediately before and after a given observation , since sky brightness can vary on the scale of minutes at @xmath22 m @xcite .
once each dither position was flat fielded , sky subtracted , and sigma clipped , the final image was produced by combining the various dither positions .
figures [ fig : data1 ] and [ fig : data2 ] show the reduced @xmath0 and @xmath1 images for our six targets . @xmath0 band@xmath1 band + + + @xmath0 band@xmath1 band + + +
we use the ` galfit ` image modeling package @xcite to extract the @xmath0 and @xmath1 fluxes of the lensed quasar images and ( when detected ) the lensing galaxy . `
galfit ` is valuable for general photometry , and specifically for separating the flux of the lensed images from that of the nearby lens galaxy , which is detected in our @xmath0-band images for all targets except sbs 0909 + 523 .
we follow a procedure similar to that of .
we select the lensed quasar image farthest from the lens galaxy as our initial model for the point spread function ( psf ) .
we then perform a simultaneous fit to all the lensed quasar images ( modeled as scaled psfs ) and any galaxies present ( modeled as psf - convolved srsic profiles ) . with this fit in hand
, we subtract the galaxy ( or galaxies ) from the original image and then re - exact a new psf model that contains less contamination from the lens galaxy . using this cleaner psf , we perform a new simultaneous fit .
we compute the reduced @xmath42 value for the residuals using regions defined by the psf size for the quasar images , and regions that are 1 , 2 , or 3 times the psf size for the lens galaxy .
if @xmath43 within these regions , we conclude that the procedure has converged .
if not , we perform additional iterations , improving the model at each step , until convergence is achieved . our @xmath0-band images typically require 3 or 4 iterations , while our @xmath1 images require only 1 or 2 since the lens galaxy is rarely detected in @xmath1 . `
galfit ` provides photometric errorbars , although each quasar image that serves as the psf model is fit perfectly . for these images ,
we determine the uncertainty by computing the range in flux where @xmath44 in the psf region .
( when the lensed quasar images are clearly distinct , we verify the derived flux values and uncertainties using aperture photometry . )
figure [ fig : galfit ] shows an example of the ` galfit ` modeling procedure , and table [ tab : photometry ] gives the derived flux ratios .
we calibrate the flux measurements using observations of standard stars taken immediately before or after science observations .
we consider both aperture photometry and ` galfit ` modeling with the star itself providing the psf model . table [ tab : calibphoto ]
gives the calibrated photometry , along with a list of the standard stars we use .
we report magnitudes in the vega system .
cccc q0142@xmath3100 & a & @xmath45 & @xmath45 + & b & @xmath46 & @xmath47 + sdss 0246@xmath30825 & a & @xmath45 & @xmath45 + & b & @xmath48 & @xmath49 + he 0435@xmath31223 & a & @xmath50 & @xmath51 + & b & @xmath52 & @xmath53 + & c & @xmath45 & @xmath45 + & d & @xmath54 & @xmath55 + sdss 0806 + 2006 & a & @xmath45 & @xmath45 + & b & @xmath56 & @xmath57 + sbs 0909 + 523 & a & @xmath45 & @xmath45 + & b & @xmath58 & @xmath59 + he 2149@xmath32745 & a & @xmath45 & @xmath45 + & b & @xmath60 & @xmath61 + [ tab : photometry ] ccccc q0142@xmath3100 & a & @xmath62 & @xmath63 & 1,2 sa 92 - 342 ( @xmath64 ) + & b & @xmath65 & @xmath66 & + sdss 0246@xmath30825 & a & @xmath67 & @xmath68 & 1 gspc s618-d ( @xmath0 ) + & b & @xmath69 & @xmath70 & 2 hd 22686 ( @xmath1 ) + he 0435@xmath31223 & a & @xmath71 & @xmath72 & 1,2 hd 289907 ( @xmath64 ) + & b & @xmath73 & @xmath74 & + & c & @xmath75 & @xmath76 & + & d & @xmath77 & @xmath78 & + sdss 0806 + 2006 & a & @xmath79 & @xmath80 & 1,2 gspc p486-r ( @xmath64 ) + & b & @xmath81 & @xmath82 & + sbs 0909 + 523 & a & @xmath83 & @xmath84 & 3 hst p091-d ( @xmath0 ) + & b & @xmath85 & @xmath86 & 2 hd 84800 ( @xmath1 ) + he 2149@xmath32745 & a & @xmath87 & @xmath88 & 1 eg 141 ( @xmath0 ) + & b & @xmath89 & @xmath90 & 2 gl 811.1 ( @xmath1 ) + [ tab : calibphoto ] cccccc q0142@xmath3100 & hst f555w & & 1 + & hst f675w & & 1 + & johnson @xmath91 & & 2 + & hst f814w & & 3 + & hst f160w & & 1 + sdss 0246@xmath30825 & sloan @xmath92 & & 4 + & sloan @xmath93 & & 4 + & hst f555w & & 4 + & sloan @xmath94 & & 4 + & sloan @xmath95 & & 4 + & hst f814w & & 4 + & hst f160w & & 4 + & johnson @xmath35 & & 4 + & johnson @xmath96 & & 4 + sdss 0806 + 2006 & johnson @xmath33 & & 5 + & johnson @xmath91 & & 5 + & johnson @xmath34 & & 5 + & 0.391.10 @xmath97 m & & 5 + & 0.450.87 @xmath97 m & & 6 + & & bel & & 6 + & johnson @xmath35 & & 5 + & johnson @xmath35 & & 6 + & johnson @xmath96 & & 5 + sbs 0909 + 523 & 0.38 kev & & 7 + & hst f555w & & 1 + & sloan @xmath94 & & 8 + & hst f814w & & 1 + & hst f160w & & 1 + he 2149@xmath32745 & johnson @xmath98 & & 9 + & hst f555w & & 1 + & johnson @xmath33 & & 9 + & johnson @xmath91 & & 9 + & hst f814w & & 1 + & hst f160w & & 1 + target & filter & @xmath99 & @xmath100 & @xmath101 & ref . +
he 0435@xmath31223 & hst f555w & @xmath102 & @xmath103 & @xmath104 & 10 + & kpno @xmath91 & @xmath105 & @xmath106 & @xmath107 & 10 + & johnson @xmath91 & @xmath108 & @xmath109 & @xmath110 & 11 + & hst f814w & @xmath111 & @xmath112 & @xmath110 & 10 + & hst f160w & @xmath113 & @xmath114 & @xmath115 & 10 + [ tab : existing ]
in this section we use our new measurements to look for differences between the @xmath0 and @xmath1 flux ratios . in the next section
we compare the @xmath0 and @xmath1 results with previous measurements at other wavelengths to discuss wavelength dependence more generally . * _ q0142@xmath3100 . _ the @xmath0 and @xmath1 flux ratios are @xmath116 and @xmath47 , respectively , which are consistent within @xmath117 . *
_ sdss 0246@xmath30825 . _
the flux ratios are @xmath118 and @xmath49 in the @xmath0 and @xmath1 bands , respectively .
the difference is inconsistent with measurement noise at @xmath119 confidence . *
_ he 0435@xmath31223 .
_ we consider flux ratios with respect to image c. for the a / c and d / c flux ratios , the @xmath0 and @xmath1 values are consistent within the errorbars . for the b / c flux ratio ,
however , there is a significant difference with @xmath120 in @xmath0 and @xmath53 in @xmath1 .
this discrepancy is significant at @xmath121 confidence . *
_ sdss 0806 + 2006 .
_ in the @xmath0 band the flux ratio is @xmath122 . in the @xmath1 band , however , we do not significantly detect image b , with an upper limit of @xmath123 ( @xmath124 ) .
this is the most striking wavelength dependence in our sample . *
_ sbs 0909 + 523 .
_ we measure identical flux ratios of @xmath125 in @xmath0 and @xmath1 .
this null detection is interesting in comparison with known wavelength dependence in other bands ( see [ sec : irdiscuss ] ) . * _ he 2149@xmath32745 . _
the flux ratios are @xmath126 and @xmath127 in @xmath0 and @xmath1 , respectively , which differ at @xmath128 confidence .
as discussed in [ sec : irintro ] , wavelength dependence in lens flux ratios ( especially between @xmath1 and shorter wavelengths ) may signal effects of dark matter substructure , but it may also be associated with quasar variability , microlensing , or dust extinction .
here we compare our nir flux ratio measurements ( table [ tab : photometry ] ) with previous measurements at other wavelengths ( table [ tab : existing ] ) in an attempt to disentangle the various effects that can alter flux ratios across wavelengths .
even if we can not uniquely identify the cause of wavelength dependence , our analysis highlights systems that have interesting features and warrant further study . to ease comparison , we plot in figure [ fig : summary ] the flux ratios from tables [ tab : photometry ] and [ tab : existing ] between @xmath129 @xmath97 m . _
_ our @xmath0 and @xmath1 flux ratios are compatible with each other and with single - epoch hst measurements in f555w , f675w , and f160w @xcite .
this is not surprising , because for a source redshift of @xmath130 all bands up to @xmath1 probe rest - frame wavelengths @xmath131 m where the accretion disk is the main emission source .
what is striking is that @xmath91-band monitoring by @xcite yielded a mean flux ratio of @xmath132 and a scatter of 0.009 over 3-month observing windows in 20032005 .
that value , which agrees with the single - epoch f814w measurement from castles , suggests that there is more intrinsic / microlensing variability on several - year timescales than was apparent during the monitoring campaign .
_ sdss 0246@xmath30825 .
_ previous observations in various filters and epochs point to significant variations with both time and wavelength .
for instance , sdss @xmath95 and hst f814w measurements taken 20 months apart yielded @xmath133 and @xmath134 , respectively ( @xcite ; castles ) . at the same two epochs , sdss @xmath93 and hst f555w measurements gave @xmath135 and @xmath136 .
in the nir , we find @xmath118 and @xmath49 in @xmath0 and @xmath1 .
it is unclear whether the nir discrepancy is produced by the same variations that affect the shorter wavelengths , or whether millilensing by dark matter substructure might be at play . to distinguish the possibilities , it would be interesting to use future multi - wavelength imaging to see whether optical and nir flux ratios vary in similar ways . _ he 0435@xmath31223 . _
the measured a / c and d / c flux ratios are consistent with being independent of wavelength over 0.53.8 @xmath97 m .
our measurement of the b / c flux ratio in @xmath1 is consistent with measurements at other wavelengths ( including the @xmath91-band monitoring by @xcite ) .
however , the @xmath0-band b / c flux ratio differs from the rest .
this is curious because @xmath0-band corresponds to rest - frame optical emission ( 0.82 @xmath97 m at @xmath137 ) , which should originate from the accretion disk . using the standard thin - disk model of
, we estimate the @xmath0 source size to be only 4.7 larger than the @xmath91 source size ; for most plausible substructure models , such a difference is too small to account for the @xmath0-band anomaly ( see * ? ? ?
combining that with the agreement between the @xmath91 and @xmath1 flux ratios , we conjecture that the @xmath0-band observations in 2008 may have been affected by microlensing . under this hypothesis
, the @xmath1-band observations were less sensitive to microlensing because the source was larger , while the earlier @xmath91-band monitoring happened to catch a period of smaller microlensing variations .
we study this interesting system in more detail in a separate paper ( fadely & keeton , in prep . ) . _
sdss 0806 + 2006 .
_ it is striking that we do not see image b in the @xmath1-band observations ( @xmath123 at @xmath124 ) , especially considering that @xmath138 at shorter wavelengths .
changes in the flux ratio with both wavelength and time ( see table [ tab : existing ] ) suggest that quasar variability and/or microlensing are at work in this lens ( but not dust extinction ; ) .
it is not clear , though , whether either effect could explain the non - detection in @xmath1 .
for @xmath139 the @xmath1 emission corresponds to rest - frame @xmath140 m , so it presumably contains some contribution from the dusty torus , and thus ought to be less susceptible to intrinsic variations or microlensing than the shorter - wavelength bands . in any case
, the wavelength dependence of the flux ratios is very interesting and should be investigated further with both modeling and follow - up observations .
_ sbs 0909 + 523 .
_ there is significant differential extinction in this lens @xcite ; our observations should further constrain dust models since they represent the longest wavelengths yet measured in this system .
in fact , extrapolating the extinction models of @xcite ( which were derived from shorter - wavelength measurements ) yields predicted flux ratios of @xmath141 in @xmath0 and 0.934 in @xmath1 , whereas we measure @xmath142 in both bands . in terms of dark matter substructure ,
the agreement between our @xmath0 and @xmath1 flux ratios is interesting as a null detection .
if the @xmath0 ( source rest - frame @xmath143 m ) and @xmath1 ( source rest - frame @xmath144 m ) sources have different effective sizes , there must be no substructure near the images with the right einstein radius to produce a chromatic effect .
note that this does not rule out substructure in the lens only substructure with the right mass at the right position . _ he 2149@xmath32745 . _
the measured flux ratios are consistent with being independent of wavelength across 0.43.8 @xmath97 m ( @xmath145 ) , except that our @xmath0-band measurement ( @xmath126 ) formally disagrees with the others .
however , the flux ratio is known to vary with recorded fluctuations at the level of 0.03 . since @xmath0 band corresponds to rest - frame @xmath146 m
, we conclude that the high @xmath0-band flux ratio is likely due to intrinsic and/or microlensing variability .
we have used a multi - wavelength analysis of lens flux ratios to search for effects of dark matter substructure , along with quasar variability , microlensing , and dust extinction .
we have presented new @xmath0 and @xmath1 images of six lensed quasars , which were selected to have source redshifts @xmath31 so that @xmath1 observations probe rest - frame wavelengths @xmath32 m . some of the @xmath1 flux should therefore originate from the extended torus of gas surrounding the central accretion disk , possibly providing the conditions for chromatic millilensing ( see * ? ? ? * ) .
we find strong differences between the @xmath0 and @xmath1 flux ratios for two lenses . in he 0435@xmath31223 the @xmath1 measurement of the b / c
flux ratio is consistent with results at shorter wavelengths , but the @xmath0-band value is enhanced by @xmath2430% .
we argue in a separate analysis ( fadely & keeton , in prep . )
that the enhancement may be attributable to microlensing . to test that hypothesis ,
future observations are needed to look for variability in the @xmath0-band and compare it with variability at shorter wavelengths . in sdss 0806
+ 2006 we do not detect image b in @xmath1 observations , with an upper limit of @xmath123 ( @xmath124 ) , even though the flux ratio is @xmath138 at shorter wavelengths
. it would be very interesting to use deeper observations at @xmath1 to find image b , to measure the flux ratio at other long wavelengths , and to combine all the observations with lens modeling to ascertain whether the @xmath1 anomaly may be caused by dark matter substructure or some other interesting effect .
we find a @xmath2430% difference between the @xmath0 and @xmath1 flux ratios for sdss 0246@xmath30825 , and a smaller but statistically significant difference for he 2149@xmath32745 .
multi - epoch observations of both systems have shown variations in the flux ratios at shorter wavelengths , which are presumably associated with quasar variability and/or microlensing .
it is possible that the same phenomena affect the @xmath0-band flux ratios and explain the nir discrepancies . in that case
, the flux ratios in @xmath1 or other longer - wavelength bands would be useful for limiting effects of quasar variability and microlensing in order to probe dark matter substructure .
alternatively , it remains possible that chromatic millilensing causes the nir discrepancies . to test both hypotheses ,
future observations are needed to quantify variability in multiple optical and nir bands . finally , we detect no difference between the @xmath0 and @xmath1 flux ratios for q0142@xmath3100 and sbs 0909 + 523 .
these results are interesting null detections , indicating that there is no substructure close to the images with masses in the right range to produce chromatic effects .
such results offer constraints on dark matter substructure that may be mild but nevertheless interesting for future statistical studies of substructure populations . , f. , chantry , v. , revaz , y. , sluse , d. , faure , c. , tewes , m. , eulaers , e. , koleva , m. , asfandiyarov , i. , dye , s. , magain , p. , van winckel , h. , coles , j. , saha , p. , ibrahimov , m. , & meylan , g. 2010 , arxiv:1009.1473 , n. , burles , s. , gregg , m. d. , becker , r. h. , schechter , p. l. , eisenstein , d. j. , oguri , m. , castander , f. j. , hall , p. b. , johnston , d. e. , pindor , b. , richards , g. t. , schneider , d. p. , white , r. l. , brinkmann , j. , szalay , a. s. , & york , d. g. 2005 , , 130 , 1967 , n. , oguri , m. , becker , r. h. , white , r. l. , gregg , m. d. , schechter , p. l. , kawano , y. , kochanek , c. s. , richards , g. t. , schneider , d. p. , barentine , j. c. , brewington , h. j. , brinkmann , j. , harvanek , m. , kleinman , s. j. , krzesinski , j. , long , d. , neilsen , jr . , e. h. , nitta , a. , snedden , s. a. , & york , d. g. 2006 , , 131 , 1934 , d. , eisenhardt , p. , gorjian , v. , kochanek , c. s. , caldwell , n. , eisenstein , d. , brodwin , m. , brown , m. j. i. , cool , r. , dey , a. , green , p. , jannuzi , b. t. , murray , s. s. , pahre , m. a. , & willner , s. p. 2005
, , 631 , 163 | we examine the wavelength dependence of flux ratios for six gravitationally lensed quasars using @xmath0 and @xmath1 images obtained at the gemini north 8 m telescope .
we select lenses with source redshifts @xmath2 so that @xmath0-band images probe rest - frame optical emission from accretion disks , while @xmath1-band images probe rest - frame near - infrared flux emitted ( in part ) from the more extended surrounding torus . since the observations correspond to different source sizes , the @xmath0 and @xmath1 flux ratios are sensitive to structure on different scales and may be useful for studying small - structure in the lens galaxies .
four of the six lenses show differences between @xmath0 and @xmath1 flux ratios . in he 0435@xmath31223 , sdss 0246@xmath30825 , and he 2149@xmath32745 the differences may be attributable to known microlensing and/or intrinsic variability . in sdss 0806 + 2006 the wavelength dependence is not easily attributed to known variations , and may indicate the presence of substructure .
by contrast , in q0142@xmath3100 and sbs 0909 + 523 the @xmath0 and @xmath1 flux ratios are consistent within the uncertainties .
we discuss the utility of the current data for studying chromatic effects related to microlensing , dust extinction , and dark matter substructure . |
1.2 cm in recent years , a number of experimental and theoretical studies have been made to understand the decay of light di - nuclear systems ( a @xmath5 60 ) formed through low - energy ( e@xmath6 @xmath5 10 mev / nucleon ) , heavy - ion reactions . in most of the reactions
studied , the properties of the observed , fully energy damped yields have been successfully explained in terms of either a fusion - fission ( ff ) mechanism or a heavy - ion resonance behavior @xcite .
the strong resonance - like structures observed in elastic and inelastic excitation functions of @xmath7mg+@xmath7 mg @xcite and @xmath0si+@xmath0si @xcite have indicated the presence of shell stabilized , highly deformed configurations in the @xmath8cr and @xmath9ni compound systems , respectively . in a recent experiment using eurogam ,
the present collaboration studied the possibility of preferential population of highly deformed bands in the symmetric fission channel of the @xmath9ni compound nucleus as produced through the @xmath0si+@xmath0si @xcite reaction at e@xmath10 mev .
the present work aims to investigate the possible occurence of highly deformed configurations of the @xmath9ni and @xmath11ca di - nuclei produced in the @xmath0si+@xmath0si and @xmath0si+@xmath2c reactions through the study of light charged particle ( lcp ) emission . in - plane coincidences of the lcp s with both evaporation residues ( er ) and ff fragments have been measured .
the lcp s emitted from ff fragments may provide informations on the deformation properties of these fragments .
moreover , the in - plane angular correlations data will be used to extract the temperatures of the emitters . in this paper
we will concentrate on the er results .
1.2 cm the experiments were performed at the ires strasbourg vivitron tandem facility using 112.6 mev @xmath0si beams on @xmath0si ( 180 @xmath12g/@xmath13 ) and @xmath2c ( 160 @xmath12g/@xmath13 ) targets .
both the heavy ions and their associated lcp s were detected using the * icare * charged particle multidetector array @xcite .
the heavy fragments ( er , quasi - elastic , deep - inelastic and ff fragments ) were detected in eight telescopes , each consisting of an ionization chamber ( ic ) followed by a 500 @xmath14 m si detector .
the in - plane detection of coincident lcp s was done using four triple telescopes ( si 40 @xmath14 m , si 300 @xmath14 m , 2 cm csi(tl ) ) placed at forward angles , 16 two - element telescopes ( si 40 @xmath14 m , 2 cm csi(tl ) ) placed at forward and backward angles and two telescopes consisting of ic s followed by 500 @xmath14 m si detectors placed at the most backward angles .
the ic s were filled with isobutane and the pressures were kept at 30 torr and at 60 torr for detecting heavy fragments and light fragments , respectively .
typical inclusive and exclusive ( coincidence with all er s detected at 15@xmath15 ) energy spectra of @xmath4 particles at 40@xmath3 for the @xmath0si+@xmath0si reaction are shown by solid histograms in fig . 1(a ) and 1(b ) , respectively .
exclusive @xmath0si+@xmath2c @xmath4 spectra measured at 40@xmath3 in coincidence with s and p er s at 15@xmath16 are also displayed in fig .
1.2 cm the data analysis was performed using cacarizo , the monte carlo version of the statistical - model code cascade @xcite .
the angular momenta distributions , needed as the principal input to constrain the calculations were taken from compiled @xmath0si+@xmath0si @xcite and @xmath0si+@xmath2c @xcite complete fusion data .
the other ingredients for the realistic statistical - model calculations such as the nuclear level densities and the barrier transmission coefficients , are usually deduced from the study of the evaporated light particle spectra . in recent years , it has been observed in many cases that the standard statistical model can not predict the shape of the evaporated @xmath4-particle energy spectra satisfactorily @xcite , with the measured average energies of the @xmath4 particles generally much lower than the corresponding theoretical predictions .
several attempts have been made to explain this anomaly either by changing the emission barrier or by using a spin - dependent level density .
the change in the emission barriers and consequently the transmission probabilities affects the lower energy part of the calculated evaporation spectra . on the other hand ,
the high - energy part of the spectra depends critically on the available phase space obtained from the level densities at high spin as well as the corresponding transmission coefficients . in hot rotating nuclei formed in heavy - ion reactions
, the level density at higher angular momentum should be spin dependent . the level density , @xmath17 , for a given angular momentum @xmath18 and energy @xmath19
is given by the well known fermi gas expression : @xmath20^{1/2 } ) , \label{lev}\ ] ] where @xmath21 is the level density parameter , @xmath22 is the pairing correction and e@xmath23 = @xmath24j(j+1 ) is the rotational energy , @xmath25 is the effective moment of inertia , @xmath26 is the rigid body moment of inertia and @xmath27 , @xmath28 are the deformation parameters @xcite . by changing the deformation parameters one can simulate the deformation effects on the level densities .
the cacarizo calculations have been performed using two sets of input parameters : one with a standard set and another with non - zero values for the deformation parameters .
the solid lines in fig .
1 show the predictions of cacarizo using the standard parameter set with the usual liquid drop model deformation .
it is clear that the average energies of the measured @xmath4 spectra are lower than those predicted by the standard statistical - model calculations .
the dashed lines show the predictions of cacarizo using @xmath27 = 3.2 x 10@xmath29 and @xmath28 = 2.2 x 10@xmath30 .
the shapes of the inclusive as well as the exclusive @xmath4 energy spectra are well reproduced after including the deformation effects . in the case of @xmath0si+@xmath2c
an interesting result is observed . in order to explain the inclusive energy spectra of @xmath4-particles it has been necessary to use the similar deformation parameters as for @xmath0si+@xmath0si system .
however , it was not possible to explain the exclusive energy spectra of @xmath4 particles obtained in coincidence with all of the er s using this set .
therefore , @xmath4 energy spectra have been generated in coincidence with individual s and p er s as shown in fig .
the shape of the @xmath4 spectrum ( solid histograms ) obtained in coincidence with s is completely different from the spectrum obtained in coincidence with p. the dashed lines in fig .
2 are the predictions of cacarizo using non - zero values of @xmath27 and @xmath28 .
the shape of the @xmath4 spectrum measured in coincidence with p is reasonably well reproduced by the theoretical curve .
however , the model could not predict the shape of the @xmath4 spectrum obtained in coincidence with s. this is due to the fact that in this case , there may be additional contributions to the @xmath4-particle spectra from the decay of unbound @xmath31be , produced through a binary decay such as asymmetric ff and/or an orbiting mechanism with @xmath11ca @xmath32 @xmath33s+@xmath31be .
this confirms the double - humped structure found in the inclusive @xmath33s velocity spectra measured by harmon et al . @xcite .
the question of the real nature ( ff or orbiting ) of this decay process remains open .
1.7 cm inclusive as well as exclusive energy spectra of @xmath4-particles have been measured for the reaction @xmath0si+@xmath0si and @xmath0si+@xmath2c , respectively .
the observed energy spectra of @xmath4 particles are not well reproduced by the standard statistical - model calculations with the usual liquid drop model deformation . however
, a satisfactory description of the measured energy spectra has been achieved by invoking the changes in the level density and barrier due to the onset of large deformation effects at high spins .
the @xmath4 spectra obtained in coincidence with s for the reaction @xmath0si + @xmath2c have an additional component which may come from the decay of @xmath31be , which is unbound and produced through the binary decay of @xmath11ca @xmath32 @xmath33s+@xmath31be .
work is in progress to analyse the proton energy spectra as well as the angular correlations of both the proton and @xmath4 in - plane angular correlations .
1.7 cm 99 k. farrar et al . , phys . rev .
* c 54 * , 1249 ( 1996 ) and references therein . r.w .
zurmhle et al . , phys . lett . *
129b * , 384 ( 1983 ) .
betts et al . , phys .
lett . * 47 * , 23 ( 1981 ) .
r. nouicer , ph.d .
thesis , strasbourg university , report * ires 97 - 35*. t. bellot , ph .
d. thesis , strasbourg university , report * ires 97 - 34*. g. viesti et al .
, phys . rev . * c 38 * , 2640 ( 1988 ) and references therein .
vineyard et al . , phys . rev .
* c 41 * , 1005 ( 1990 ) .
harmon et al . , phys . rev . * c 34 * , 552 ( 1986 ) .
vineyard et al . , phys . rev . * c 47 * , 2374 ( 1993 ) .
g. la rana et al . , phys . rev . * c 37 * , 1920 ( 1988 ) ; _ ibidem _ * c 40 * , 2425 ( 1989 ) .
govil et al . , phys . rev .
* c 57 * , 1269 ( 1998 ) ; _ ibidem _ phys
b307 * , 283 ( 1993 ) . | _ inclusive as well as exclusive energy spectra of the light charged particles emitted in the @xmath0si(e@xmath1 mev ) + @xmath0si,@xmath2c reactions have been measured at the strasbourg vivitron facility in a wide angular range 15@xmath3 - 150@xmath3 , using the icare multidetector array .
the observed @xmath4-particle energy spectra are generally well reproduced by the statistical model using a spin - dependent level density parameterisation .
the results suggest significant deformation effects at high spin . _
23 true cm 16 true cm 0 true cm 0 true cm -1 true cm 5.0 cm * abstract * 2.0 cm |
many suggestions for an experimental realization of quantum computers are related to two - level systems ( _ qubits _ ) .
one of the serious problems in this field is a destructive influence of different kinds of errors that may be dangerous for the stability of quantum computation protocols . in the first line
, one should refer to finite temperature effects and interaction of qubits with an environment @xcite .
however , even in the case when these features can be neglected , errors can be generated by the dynamics itself .
this `` dynamical noise '' can not be avoided since the interaction between qubits and with external fields are both necessary for the implementation of any quantum protocol . on the other hand , the inter
qubit interaction may cause the errors .
therefore , it is important to know to what extent the interaction effects may be dangerous for quantum computation .
as is known from the theory of interacting particles , a two - body interaction between particles may result in the onset of chaos and thermalisation , even if the system under consideration consists of a relatively small number of particles ( see , for example , the reviews @xcite and references therein ) . in application to quantum computers ,
quantum chaos may play a destructive role since it increases the system sensitivity to external perturbations .
simple estimates obtained for systems of @xmath0 interacting spins show that with an increase of @xmath0 the chaos border decreases , and even a small interaction between spins may result in chaotic properties of eigenstates and spectrum statistics . on this ground , it was claimed @xcite that quantum chaos for a large number of qubits can not be avoided , and the idea of a quantum computation meets serious problems .
on the other hand , recent studies @xcite of a realistic 1/2-spin model of a quantum computer show that , in the presence of a magnetic field gradient , the chaos border is independent on @xmath0 , and that quantum chaos arises in extreme situations only , which are not interesting from the practical viewpoint .
one should stress that a non - zero gradient magnetic field is necessary in the model @xcite for a selective excitation of different qubits under time - dependent electromagnetic pulses providing a specific quantum protocol .
another point that should be mentioned in the context of quantum chaos is that typical statements about chaos refer to stationary eigenstates and spectrum statistics .
however , quantum computation is essentially a time - dependent problem .
moreover , the time of computation is restricted by the length of a quantum protocol . therefore , even if stationary hamiltonians for single pulses reveal chaotic properties , it is still not clear to what extent stationary chaos influences the evolution of a system subjected to a finite number of pulses .
in contrast with our previous studies @xcite , in this paper we investigate a time evolution of a 1/2-spin quantum computer system subjected to a series of pulses . specifically , we consider a quantum protocol that allows to create an entangled state for remote qubits . for this
, we explore the model in the so - called _ selective _ regime , using both analytical and numerical approaches .
our analytical treatment shows that in this regime there is no any fingerprint of quantum chaos .
moreover , we show that a kind of perturbation approach provides a complete description of the evolution of our system .
we concentrate our efforts on the introduced quantity ( _ dynamical fidelity _ ) .
this quantity characterizes the performance of quantum computation associated with the _ dynamical _ errors .
dynamical fidelity differs from the fidelity which is associated with the external errors , and which is widely used nowadays in different applications to quantum computation and quantum chaos , see for instance @xcite .
our study demonstrates an excellent agreement of analytical predictions with numerical data .
the structure of the paper is as follows . in section
ii we discuss our model and specify the region of parameters for which our study is performed . in section iii we explore a possibility of quantum chaos in the selective regime , and analytically show that chaos can not occur in this case .
we provide all details concerning the quantum protocol in section iv , and demonstrate how perturbation theory can be applied to obtain an adequate description of the fidelity in dependence on the system parameters . here
, we also present numerical data and compare them with the predictions based on the perturbative approach . the last section v summarizes our results .
our model is represented by a one - dimensional chain of @xmath0 identical @xmath1-spins placed in an external magnetic field .
it was first proposed in @xcite ( see also @xcite ) as a simple model for solid - state quantum computation .
some physical constraints are necessary in order to let it operate in a quantum computer regime . to provide a selective resonant excitation of spins , we assume that the time independent part @xmath2 of a magnetic field is non - uniform along the spin chain .
the non - zero gradient of the magnetic field provides different larmor frequencies for different spins .
the angle @xmath3 between the direction of the chain and the @xmath4-axis satisfies the condition , @xmath5 . in this case the dipole - dipole interaction is suppressed , and the main interaction between nuclear spins is due to the ising - like interaction mediated by the chemical bonds , as in a liquid state nmr quantum computation @xcite . in order to realize quantum gates and implement operations , it is necessary to apply selective pulses to single spins .
the latter can be distinguished , for instance , by imposing constant gradient magnetic field that results in the larmor frequencies @xmath6 , where @xmath7 is the spin gyromagnetic ratio and @xmath8 and @xmath9 is the position of the @xmath10-th spin . if the distance between the neighboring nuclear spins is @xmath11 nm , and the frequency difference between them is @xmath12 khz , then the corresponding gradient of the magnetic field can be estimated as follows , @xmath13 t / m .
here we used the gyromagnetic ratio for a proton , @xmath14 hz / t .
such a magnetic field gradient is experimentally achievable , see , for example , @xcite . in our model
the spin chain is also subjected to a transversal circular polarized magnetic field .
thus , the expression for the total magnetic field has the form @xcite , @xmath15.\ ] ] as is mentioned above , here @xmath16 is the constant magnetic field oriented in the positive @xmath17-direction , with a positive @xmath17-gradient ( therefore , @xmath18 in the expression for the larmor frequencies ) . in the above expression ,
@xmath19 , @xmath20 , and @xmath21 are the amplitudes , frequencies and phases of a circular polarized magnetic field , respectively .
the latter is given by the sum of @xmath22 rectangular time - dependent pulses of length @xmath23 , rotating in the @xmath24 plane and providing a quantum computer protocol .
for a specific @xmath28-th pulse , it is convenient to represent the hamiltonian ( [ ham00 ] ) in the coordinate system that rotates with the frequency @xmath20 .
therefore , for the time @xmath37 of the @xmath28-th pulse our model can be reduced to the _ stationary _ hamiltonian , @xmath38 where @xmath39 , @xmath40 , and @xmath41 .
we start our considerations with the simplified case of the hamiltonian ( 3 ) for a single pulse , by choosing @xmath42 .
we also assume a constant interaction between nearest qubits only ( @xmath43 ) , and we put @xmath44
. then the hamiltonian ( 3 ) takes the form , @xmath45 - \omega \sum_{k=0}^{l-1 } i^x_k \equiv h_{0}+v . \label{ham0}\ ] ] in the @xmath4-representation the hamiltonian matrix of size @xmath46 is diagonal for @xmath47 . for @xmath48 ,
non - zero off - diagonal matrix elements are simply @xmath49 with @xmath50 .
the matrix is very sparse , and it has a specific structure in the basis reordered according to an increase of the number @xmath51 .
the latter is written in the binary representation , @xmath52 ( with @xmath53 or @xmath27 , depending on whether the single - particle state of the @xmath54th qubit is the ground state or the excited one ) .
the parameter @xmath55 thus is responsible for a non - diagonal coupling , and we hereafter define it as a `` perturbation '' . in our previous studies
@xcite we have analyzed the so - called _ non - selective _ regime which is defined by the conditions , @xmath56 .
this inequality provides the simplest way to prepare a homogeneous superposition of @xmath46 states needed for the implementation of both shor and grover algorithms .
our analytical and numerical treatment of the model ( 2 ) in this regime has shown that a constant gradient magnetic field ( with non - zero value of @xmath57 ) strongly reduces the effects of quantum chaos .
namely , the chaos border turns out to be independent on the number @xmath0 of qubits . as a result , for non - selective excitation quantum chaos can be practically neglected ( see details in @xcite ) .
below we consider another important regime called _ selective excitation_. in this regime each pulse acts selectively on a chosen qubit , resulting in a resonant transition . during the quantum protocol ,
many such resonant transitions take place for different @xmath28 pulses , with different values of @xmath58 .
the region of parameters for the selective excitation is specified by the following conditions @xcite , @xmath59 the meaning of these conditions will be discussed in next sections .
here , we consider the properties of the stationary hamiltonian ( [ ham0 ] ) in the regime of selective excitation . in order to estimate the critical value of the interaction @xmath60 , above which one can expect chaotic properties of eigenstates , one needs to compare the typical value of the off - diagonal matrix elements ( which is @xmath61 ) with the mean energy spacing @xmath62 for unperturbed many - body states that are directly coupled by these matrix elements .
therefore , the condition for the onset of chaos has the form , @xmath63 here @xmath64 is the maximal difference between the energies @xmath65 and @xmath66 corresponding to a specific many - body state @xmath67 , and all other states @xmath68 of @xmath69 , that have non - zero couplings @xmath70 .
correspondingly , @xmath71 is the number of many - body states @xmath68 coupled by @xmath72 to the state @xmath67 .
a further average over all states @xmath67 should be then performed .
in fact , such a comparison ( [ esti ] ) is just the perturbation theory in the case of two - body interaction . strictly speaking
, the above condition in a strong sense ( @xmath73 ) means that exact eigenstates consist of many unperturbed ( @xmath74 ) states .
typically , the components of such compound states can be treated as uncorrelated entries , thus resulting in a chaotic structure of excited many - body states .
however , one should note that in specific cases when the total hamiltonian is integrable ( or quasi - integrable ) , the components of excited states have strong correlations and can not be considered as chaotic , although the number of components with large amplitudes can be extremely large ( see details in @xcite ) .
it is relatively easy to estimate @xmath71 in the regime of selective excitation .
let us consider an eigenstate of @xmath69 , @xmath75 , as a collection of @xmath76 s and @xmath27 s that correspond to @xmath77 and @xmath1-spin values .
since the perturbation @xmath72 is a sum of @xmath0 terms , each of them flipping one single spin , one gets @xmath78 . in order to estimate @xmath64 ,
let us first consider the action of @xmath72 on the @xmath10-th spin , and for each spin compute the relative energy difference between the final and the initial energy .
one can find that if the @xmath10-th spin has the value @xmath1 , there are four possible configurations of neighbor spins coupled by the perturbation , @xmath79 if the @xmath10-th spin has the value @xmath77 , there are also four possible different arrangements , @xmath80 which are the inverse transitions of ( [ tru ] ) . correspondingly , the energy changes are determined by the relation , @xmath81 the analysis for the border spins can be performed in a similar way , and one gets four possible configurations , with the following energy changes , @xmath82 summarizing the above findings , and setting for instance @xmath83 , one can conclude that @xmath84 can be estimated as follows , @xmath85 as a result , the condition for the onset of quantum chaos can be written in the form , @xmath86 or @xmath87 however , this critical value is outside the range of parameters required to be in the selective excitation regime @xmath88 ( see inequality ( 6 ) ) .
thus , we can conclude that quantum chaos for stationary states can not appear in the selective excitation regime .
note that the analysis is done for a single pulse of a time - dependent perturbation .
analytical results obtained above , show that during a single electromagnetic pulse the system can be described by perturbation theory .
indeed , if matrix elements of perturbation are smaller than the energy spacing between directly coupled many - body states , exact eigenstates can be obtained by perturbation theory .
thus , one can expect that for a series of time - depended pulses the evolution of the systems can be also treated making use of a kind of perturbative approach . in what follows , we study the dynamics of the system by applying a specific set of pulses ( quantum protocol ) in order to create an entangled state for remote qubits ( with @xmath89 and @xmath90 ) starting from the ground state , @xmath91 ( we omit the subscripts below ) .
our main interest is in estimating the errors that appear due to unwanted excitations of qubits .
we show that these errors can be well understood and estimated on the basis of the perturbation theory developed for our time - dependent hamiltonian ( [ ham00 ] ) , in the parameter range where the protocol holds .
any protocol is a sequence of unitary transformations applied to some initial state in order to obtain a final state , @xmath92 . in this model of quantum computer
the protocol is realized by applying a number of specific rf - pulses , so that we get a state @xmath93 which is , in principle , different from the ideal state @xmath92 .
the difference between the final state @xmath93 and the ideal state @xmath92 can be characterized by a _ dynamical fidelity _ , @xmath94 note that , in our case the dynamical fidelity @xmath95 does not explicitly depend on a perturbation parameter added in the hamiltonian ( 2 ) in order to get a distorted evolution , as is typically assumed in the study of quantum chaos . indeed , the final state is determined by the total hamiltonian ( 2 ) , @xmath96 where @xmath97 is the total time to entangle spins , @xmath98 is the unitary operator given by the sequence of pulses in the protocol , and @xmath99 is the usual time - ordered product .
therefore , it is not possible to identify a single perturbation parameter which is responsible for a `` wrong '' evolution of the system .
the selective excitation regime is characterized by the action of pulses that are resonant with a transition between two energy states which differ for the state ( up or down ) of one spin only .
a close inspection of the time independent hamiltonian ( [ ham0 ] ) , defines the region of parameters where the selective excitation of single spins can be performed .
diagonal elements of hamiltonian ( [ ham0 ] ) are given by the eigenvalues @xmath100 of @xmath69 , while non - zero off - diagonal elements are constant and equal to @xmath101 . in order to have a resonant transition between two energy states , their energy difference @xmath102 has to be zero .
on the other side , for each state no more than one resonant transition should be allowed .
so , we require that the energy differences given by eqs .
( [ cond1],[cond2 ] ) are different from zero ( apart from the wanted transition ) .
this leads to the following set of equalities ( `` fake transitions '' ) , @xmath103 from eqs.([gein ] ) it is easy to see that first `` fake '' transition appears for @xmath104 , the second for @xmath105 and so on up to the last one for @xmath106 .
all these resonances can be avoided if we choose @xmath107 .
indeed , it is not enough to chose simply @xmath108 since resonances have finite widths .
transitions can be defined according to their energy difference @xmath109 , * _ resonant transitions _ , @xmath110 ; * _ near resonant transitions _ , @xmath111 ;
* _ non resonant transitions _ , @xmath112 . for @xmath107
, each state can undergo one resonant or near - resonant transition only , and many non - resonant ones .
the latter can be neglected if we choose @xmath113 . under these conditions
we can form couples of states , connected by resonant or near - resonant transitions , and we can rearrange the hamiltonian matrix ( [ ham0 ] ) by @xmath114 block matrices representing all resonant and near - resonant transitions .
this allow us to describe the dynamical evolution of the system as a two - state problem . using this procedure
, the entire sequence of pulses can be evaluated .
note that special attention has to be paid to an additional phase shift that arises between any two pulses , due to the change of frame .
we remind that the transformation between the rotating and the laboratory frame is given by the expression , @xmath115 at time @xmath116 , and find the probability for a resonant ( @xmath110 ) or near - resonant ( @xmath111 ) transition to the state @xmath117 with the energy difference @xmath118 . here
@xmath119 and @xmath120 are the eigenenergies of the time - independent part of the hamiltonian ( [ ham00 ] ) , written in the laboratory frame .
setting , @xmath121 and @xmath122 , the application of a pulse for a time @xmath123 gets : @xmath124 e^{-i\frac{\delta\tau}{2}-ie_m\tau},\\ c_p(\tau ) & = c_m(0)[i \ \frac{\omega}{\lambda } \
\sin(\frac{\lambda \tau}{2 } ) ] e^{i\frac{\delta\tau}{2}-ie_p\tau},\\ \label{raf } \end{array}\ ] ] where @xmath125 .
note that eqs.([raf ] ) refer to the laboratory frame .
as we can see , the parameter @xmath126 determined as @xmath127 characterizes the probability of resonant and near - resonant transitions . in particular
, the probability of unwanted near - resonant transitions goes like @xmath128 , and it can be reduced by assuming @xmath129 . combining all the above expression , we get the condition ( [ con2 ] ) .
correspondingly , the probability for a non - resonant transition ( neglecting terms of the order @xmath130 , and assuming @xmath131 ) is given by the parameter @xmath132 @xcite , @xmath133 we would like to stress that even if the ideal state has been constructed taking into account resonant transitions only , our dynamical fidelity is a measure of dynamical errors that are due to near and non - resonant transitions .
let us now briefly discuss the perturbative approach that is based on recent studies published in ref.@xcite .
the main idea is that for each @xmath28-th pulse the unperturbed basis can be rearranged in such a way that the hamiltonian matrix is represented by @xmath134 block matrices , as described above .
this is what we call _ unperturbed _
hamiltonian for a specific @xmath28-th pulse .
one should note that this _ unperturbed _ hamiltonian is @xmath55-dependent .
let us now define by @xmath135 the @xmath55-dependent part which is responsible for non - resonant transition and not described by the @xmath134 block matrices .
then it is easy to obtain the unperturbed eigenstates , @xmath136 , and the unperturbed eigenvalues , @xmath137 , by diagonalizing each of the @xmath134 blocks independently . after this step
, one can compute the _ perturbed
_ eigenstates by taking into account first order terms only , @xmath138 note that this perturbative approach is supposed to be valid when eqs.([gein ] ) are not satisfied , and when the errors due to near - resonant transitions are much larger than the errors due to non - resonant ones , @xmath139 .
let us briefly sketch the algorithm and the particular protocol which was developed in ref .
starting from the ground state @xmath140 and applying a number of specific pulses , we would like to generate the following entangled state , @xmath141 this algorithm could serve , for instance , as the first step for a more general teleportation protocol , and for an implementation of conditional quantum logic operations .
the algorithm can be realized in the following way ( for details see ref .
@xcite ) , @xmath142 physically , the above algorithm can be done by applying suitable _
rf_-pulses that are resonant to the desired transitions .
the latter are originated from induced rabi oscillations between the resonant states . to flip the @xmath10-th spin we have to choose the frequency @xmath143 of the _
rf_-pulse according to the relation @xmath144 , where @xmath67 and @xmath68 are the states involved in the transition and @xmath145 and @xmath146 are the eigenenergies of the time - independent part of hamiltonian ( [ ham00 ] ) .
for instance , for the first pulse we have to set , @xmath147 , and we have to apply it for a time @xmath148 to get equal superposition of the states involved in the transition .
for other pulses we require that the first state ( @xmath149 ) remains the same ( apart from an additional phase ) , while the second state flips the @xmath150th spin .
this amounts to say that the probability of unwanted states is due to non - resonant transitions of both states , and to near - resonant ones only of the first state in the r.h.s . of eq.([prot ] ) .
specifically , the state @xmath149 undergoes near - resonant transitions with @xmath151 for each pulse , except the first one which is resonant , and the forth for which @xmath152 .
one should also take into account that at each pulse the state @xmath149 get an additional phase , see eqs .
( [ raf ] ) .
we took them into account in the definition of the ideal state .
since in the selective excitation regime we have @xmath153 , contributions from near - resonant transitions are much larger than the one due to non - resonant transitions .
our algorithm consists of @xmath154 separate pulses , therefore , some modifications are necessary in order to be able to control small unwanted probability . for the product of probabilities this requires to impose , @xmath155 and @xmath156 , that can be written in the form , @xmath157 where @xmath158 . before discussing our numerical results we would like to stress that in contrast to what is mainly considered in the literature , the time for our dynamical fidelity is not an independent variable .
indeed , the length of the protocol is determined by the total number of qubits , @xmath0 .
specifically , @xmath154 pulses are necessary in order to create the entangled state , so that the protocol time @xmath159 is proportional to the number of qubits
. quite unexpectedly , the dynamical fidelity ( 14 ) increases with an increase of the ising coupling @xmath60 , as soon as @xmath160 .
this is due to the fact that the probability of unwanted near - resonant transitions is proportional to @xmath161 ( see eq.([eps ] ) where @xmath162 for near - resonant transitions ) .
the larger is @xmath60 , the smaller is the probability of non - resonant transitions , therefore , the dynamical fidelity @xmath95 increases with an increase of @xmath60 . in fig.[fidj ]
we show how the dynamical fidelity ( [ fidel ] ) depends on the inter - qubit interaction @xmath60 . for convenience ,
the function @xmath163 is shown here and below , instead of @xmath95 .
numerical data have been obtained in two different ways .
full curve corresponds to exact computation of the time - dependent hamiltonian ( [ ham00 ] ) .
data in fig.[fidj]a are compared with those obtained from the perturbative approach explained above .
is shown as a function of the ising coupling @xmath60 for @xmath164 spins , @xmath165 and @xmath166 .
full line represents the numerical data for the dynamical fidelity @xmath95 defined by eq.([fidel ] ) , and obtained from direct numerical computation of the system evolution .
( a ) full circles stand for perturbative calculations , and full curve corresponds to numerical results .
( b ) the same numerical results as in ( a ) , but for a larger range of @xmath60 .
the theoretical expression as given by eq.([fidim1 ] ) is also shown in ( a ) . ] apart from very strong peaks ( see fig.[fidj]b ) for which the dynamical fidelity vanishes , one can say that the global tendency is an improvement of the dynamical fidelity for larger values of @xmath60 . however , strong oscillations occur reflecting a resonant nature of the dynamics of our system .
perfect agreement between perturbative results and numerical data is found for very large variations of the interaction strength @xmath60 .
high peaks for @xmath163 , clearly seen in fig.[fidj]b , are due to eqs.([gein ] ) , in these points the quantum algorithm fails .
thus , one should avoid these situations in a quantum computation .
as for the minima in fig.[fidj]a for which the dynamical fidelity is close to one , they occur when @xmath167 , or , when @xmath168 where @xmath10 is an integer number .
this relation corresponds to the @xmath169-condition @xcite .
let us now explore the dependence of the dynamical fidelity on the parameter @xmath57 which is proportional to the gradient of the external magnetic field , @xmath170 , where @xmath171 is the distance between neighboring qubits .
( below , we shall refer to the parameter @xmath57 as to the magnetic field gradient . )
numerical data for the dependence of @xmath163 on @xmath57 are presented in fig.[fida ] .
one can see that the dynamical fidelity is getting better for large enough values of @xmath57 .
we already mentioned that for @xmath172 a problem may arise in the protocol due to `` fake '' transitions . on the other side ,
in the regime @xmath173 the dynamical fidelity reaches an asymptotic value which depends on @xmath60 and @xmath55 only , see fig.[fida ] . as a function of the gradient of a magnetic field
is shown for @xmath164 spins , @xmath165 and @xmath174 .
as one can see , for @xmath175 the correspondence is not so good as for @xmath176 . ]
it is also important to understand the dependence of the dynamical fidelity on the rabi frequency @xmath55 .
the data manifest two specific properties demonstrated in fig.[fidom ] .
the first one is a global decrease of the dynamical fidelity with an increase of @xmath55 .
the second peculiarity is due to strong oscillations that occur for @xmath177 , namely for those @xmath55 values that correspond to the @xmath169-conditions , @xmath178 for these values of @xmath55 near - resonant transitions vanish , and non - resonant transitions remain only .
thus , the dynamical fidelity has maxima which provides , in principle , the best condition for a quantum computation . as a function of the rabi frequency @xmath55 for @xmath164 spins , @xmath174 and @xmath166 .
full curve is the result of direct numerical simulation , circles are obtained from the perturbative approach described in the text .
arrows show few resonant values of @xmath55 given by eq.([tupi ] ) . ]
nevertheless , let us consider the values of @xmath55 that correspond to maxima in fig.([fidom ] ) .
this we do in order to make an estimate in the worst possible condition .
a brief analysis of the fidelity for specific values @xmath179 will be sketched in the last subsection .
as one can see , for values of @xmath55 different from @xmath180 , the `` average '' dynamical fidelity increases when the rabi frequency decreases .
this is due to the fact that the probability to generate unwanted states ( due to both non - resonant and near - resonant transitions ) , is proportional to @xmath181 .
therefore , the smaller is @xmath55 the more reliable the algorithm is .
note that the agreement with the perturbative approach is excellent .
on the other hand , we can not choose an extremely small value of @xmath55 since it implies a large time duration of the pulse ( @xmath182 ) .
note , that the total time for a quantum protocol should be kept well below the decoherence time ( the latter can be quite large for nuclear spins @xcite ) . taking this point into account ,
an optimal choice is to take the largest possible value , @xmath183 , and large enough value of @xmath57 ( in order to significantly suppress the non - resonant transitions ) . finally , we studied the dependence of the dynamical fidelity on the number @xmath0 of spins in the chain . as was noted before , for a chosen protocol
its length is proportional to @xmath0 .
numerical data clearly manifest a linear decrease of the dynamical fidelity with the number of qubits , see fig .
[ fidn ] .
this dependence can be also understood on the basis of perturbation theory , by neglecting the change of phases between the ideal and the real state .
this can be done since we already considered the main change of phases in the definition of the ideal state .
let us write , @xmath184 and assume that after @xmath185 pulses the components @xmath186 and @xmath187 are , @xmath188 here @xmath186 and @xmath187 are the complex amplitudes of two states in eq.([eq1 ] ) , but obtained as the result of the quantum protocol .
this means that the probability of near - resonant states after @xmath185 pulses is small , @xmath189
. then we get , @xmath190 where @xmath191 and @xmath192 for our specific algorithm . combining all the above expressions ,
one gets , @xmath193 which implies a linear decrease of the dynamical fidelity with an increase of the number of qubits , @xmath0 .
the slope is given by the parameter @xmath194 .
of course , this consideration is valid far from the resonant conditions ( [ gein ] ) . of spins , for different @xmath60 values and @xmath165 , @xmath166 .
numerical data ( triangles for @xmath195 , circles for @xmath196 and squares for @xmath197 ) are compared with the results from the perturbation theory ( crosses ) .
also shown are the best linear fits ( dot - dashed lines ) . ] to compare numerical data with the above analytical estimate for @xmath198 , we obtained the slopes in fig .
[ fidn ] by the best fit to a linear dependence .
these slopes versus @xmath60 are shown in fig .
[ sloppy ] , together with the theoretical result for @xmath198 . .
] as one can see , the agreement is very good except for small values of the ising interaction , @xmath199 , where the probability of near - resonant transitions becomes large .
choosing @xmath55 values as given by eq.([tupi ] ) , one gets that the probability for near - resonant transition is zero , @xmath167 .
so , only non - resonant transitions lead to unwanted states . in fig.([res ] ) we show the fidelity as a function of the number of spins @xmath0 for @xmath200 .
these data should be compared with the analogous ones indicated by triangles in fig.([fidn ] ) . of spins , for @xmath195 and @xmath201 , @xmath166 .
also shown is the best linear fit with the slope @xmath202 . ] as one can see , despite the closeness of these two @xmath55 values ( less than 3% of difference ) , the fidelity is better by two order of magnitude ( see different scales on the @xmath203-axis ) .
it is clear that such preferred @xmath55 values should be chosen in any practical implementation of the algorithm .
however , due to a high instability of such resonant values , see fig.([fidom ] ) , the detailed analysis can only be done within a more general study under the presence of small variations in parameters such as @xmath204 .
this study is currently in progress .
we have studied the model of a quantum computer that consists of a one - dimensional chain of 1/2-spins ( qubits ) , placed in a time - dependent electromagnetic field .
the latter is given by a sequence of _
rf_-pulses , corresponding to a chosen quantum protocol that allows to generate an entangled state for remote qubits from the initial ground state .
main attention is paid to the analysis of the dynamical fidelity , defined as an overlap of the actual finite state , with the ideal one determined by the quantum protocol .
we considered the region of the selective excitation where the resonant excitations of specific qubits can be implemented by time - dependent pulses .
analytical treatment of the stationary hamiltonian which describes the evolution of the system during a single pulse , has revealed that in the selective regime the quantum chaos can not appear . moreover , in this regime a perturbation theory can be applied to all quantities of interest .
our detailed study of the dynamical fidelity manifests excellent agreement between numerical data and the predictions obtained in the perturbative approach .
in particular , we have found how to choose parameters of the model in order to get the best dynamical fidelity for the creation of the remote entangled state .
specific attention has been paid to the dependence of the dynamical fidelity on the number @xmath0 of qubits .
we show , both analytically and numerically , that the dynamical fidelity decreases linearly with an increase of @xmath0 , and we give an analytical estimate for the slope of this dependence .
the work of gpb was supported by the department of energy ( doe ) under the contract w-7405-eng-36 , by the national security agency ( nsa ) and advanced research and development activity ( arda ) .
fmi acknowledges the support by conacyt ( mexico ) grant no .
we acknowledge r.bonifacio for useful discussions .
authors also thanks the international center at cuernavaca for financial support during the workshop `` chaos in few and many - body problems '' where this work was started .
a.peres , phys .
a * 30 * , 1610 ( 1984 ) ; r.a .
jalabert and h.m .
pastawski , phys .
* 86 * , 2490 ( 2001 ) ; ph .
jacquod , p.g .
silvestrov and c. w. j. beenakker , phys .
e * 64 * , 055203 ( 2001 ) ; n.r .
cerruti and s.tomsovic , phys .
lett . * 88 * , 054103 ( 2002 ) ; t.prosen , phys .
e * 65 * , 036208 ( 2002 ) ; f.m .
cucchietti , c.h.lewenkopf , e.r.mucciolo , h.m . pastawsky and r.o .
vallejos , phys .
e * 65 * , 046209 ( 2002 ) ; g.benenti and g.casati , quant - ph/0112132 ; t.prosen , t.h.seligman , m.znidaric , quant - ph/0204043 .
berman , g.d .
doolen , g.d .
holm , v.i .
tsifrinovich , phys .
a , * 193 * , ( 1994 ) 444 .
berman , g.d .
doolen , r. mainieri , and v.i .
tsifrinovich , _ introduction to quantum computers _ , world scientific publishing company , 1998 .
berman , g.d .
doolen , g.v .
lpez , and v.i .
tsifrinovich , phys .
a , * 6106 * , 2305 ( 2000 ) .
berman , g.d .
doolen , d.i .
kamenev , and v.i .
tsifrinovich , phys .
a , * 6501 * , 2321 ( 2002 ) .
bruland , w.m .
dougherty , j.l .
garbini , j.a .
sidles , s.h .
chao , appl .
, * 73 * , 3159 ( 1998 ) .
d. suter and k. lim , phys .
a , * 65 * , 052309 ( 2002 ) .
berman , d.k .
campbell , v.i .
tsifrinovich , phys . rev .
b , * 55 * , 5929 ( 1997 )
kane , nature , * 393 * , 133 ( 1998 ) . | in this paper we analyze the dynamics in a spin - model of quantum computer .
main attention is paid to the dynamical fidelity ( associated with dynamical errors ) of an algorithm that allows to create an entangled state for remote qubits .
we show that in the regime of selective resonant excitations of qubits there is no any danger of quantum chaos .
moreover , in this regime a modified perturbation theory gives an adequate description of the dynamics of the system .
our approach allows to explicitly describe all peculiarities of the evolution of the system under time - dependent pulses corresponding to a quantum protocol .
specifically , we analyze , both analytically and numerically , how the fidelity decreases in dependence on the model parameters . |
there are two types of supernova remnants ( snrs ) in the x - ray region from a morphological point of view : a shell structure and a filled - center structure .
some snrs in each type contain a point source at its center .
therefore , the point source at its center does not always affect the morphology of the snr .
the shell structure is generated as the result of a blast wave propagating inside the interstellar matter ( ism ) , while the origin of the filled - center structure has not yet been established .
a cloud evaporation model can explain the filled - center structure ( white , long 1991 ) . the clouds in the interstellar space will gradually evaporate after passage of the blast wave , which enhances the brightness of the central part of the snr , resulting in the filled - center structure .
many of them show evidence of the interactions with molecular clouds , and have been studied from a theoretical point of view ( chevalier 1999 ) .
another explanation is a radiative phase model ( cox 1972 ) .
when the density at the shell region increases , the radiative instability proceeds and reduces the temperature of the shell region so that it becomes x - ray dim in the shell region .
rho and petre ( 1998 ) proposed a new group of snr , `` mixed - morphology ( mm ) snr '' , among the filled - center snrs based on a rosat observation .
they are characterized as having 1 ) a shell structure in the radio region , 2 ) a filled - center structure in the x - ray region , 3)an absence of a compact source in its center , and 4 ) thin thermal emission in the x - ray region showing a solar or sub - solar abundance .
the forth criterion is considered to mean that the x - ray emitting plasma is not contaminated by the ejecta .
they selected 7snrs belonging to this group as proto - typical mm snrs : w28 , w44 , 3c400.2 , kes27 , msh11 - 61a , 3c391 and ctb1 .
they also claimed 7 other snrs as probably belonging to this group . in young snrs , like cassiopeia -
a , there is a large inhomogeneity in metal abundance ( hwang et al .
2000 ) . even in a middle - aged snr , like the cygnus loop , the abundance in the shell region is quite different from that in its center ( miyata et al .
1998 , 1999 ) , whereas the absolute intensity in the center is quite weak .
although these two snrs belong to the shell structure , it will take long time before the convection of the ejecta with the ism is completed .
therefore , the uniform abundance in the snr may become an important clue to form a new class of snrs . among the mm snrs ,
yoshita et al .
( 2001 ) reported on the x - ray structure of 3c400.2 using the asca satellite , which has better energy resolution than that of rosat .
they found no spectral variation across the snr , with a possible exception of the abundance of fe . due to an elongation in the radio image
, they studied a possible interaction of two snrs .
they concluded that it was generated from a single snr , rather than two .
the snr , kes27 ( g327.4 + 0.4 ) , is classified as a proto - typical mm type snr . in the radio wavelength , it shows a shell structure with a diameter of @xmath7 with a slight complexity , a typical shell with an arm in the northwest .
it has a spectral index of @xmath8 where @xmath9 ( milne et al.1989 ) , which is a typical value of shell - type snrs in the radio region .
no optical emission has been detected from kes 27 ( van den bergh 1978 ; kirshner , winkler 1979 ) .
the x - ray observation of kes27 was initially motivated by the fact that the remnant was located within the error circle of the cosb unidentified @xmath10-ray source , cg3270 ( hermsen et al .
lamb and markert ( 1981 ) observed kes27 with the einstein ipc , and found that the x - ray emission was centrally peaked .
an ipc image was also given by seward ( 1990 ) , which clearly showed clumpy x - ray emission .
seward et al . ( 1996 ) reported using rosat data that there were several unresolved point - like sources as well as diffuse emission .
it showed not only emission from inside , but also that from the bright eastern shell , which coincides with the bright radio emission .
spectral studies of the diffuse emission showed little difference between the central region and the eastern rim .
we report here on an observation of kes27 using the asca satellite to study its x - ray structure , particularly its spectral variation .
the asca observation of kes27 was performed on 1994 august 21@xmath1122 .
we retrieved these data from darts astrophysical database at the isas plain center .
the siss ( yamashita et al . 1997 ) were operated in a combination of the 2-ccd bright mode and of the 4-ccd faint mode .
some data were obtained in the 2-ccd mode , while others were obtained in the 4-ccd mode .
since the radio shell of kes27 has the diameter of @xmath12 , most of the remnant can be covered by the field of view ( fov ) of the sis in the 4-ccd mode , which is a square of @xmath13 . since the major part of the observation was done in the 4-ccd mode , we only selected the 4-ccd faint mode data .
we excluded all of the data taken at an elevation angle from the earth rim below @xmath14 from the night earth rim and @xmath15 ( sis 0 ) or @xmath16 ( sis 1 ) from the day earth rim , a geomagnetic cutoff rigidity lower than 6gv , and the region of the south atlantic anomaly .
after screening the above criteria , we further removed the time region of a sudden change of the corner pixels of x - ray events .
we then removed the hot and flickering pixels and corrected cti , dfe and echo effects ( dotani et al .
1995 ) from our data set .
the exposure times after the screening were 9ks for sis 0 , and 11ks for sis 1 .
the giss were operated in the ph mode with the standard bit assignments ( makishima et al .
the gis data were also screened in a different way .
we excluded all of the data taken at an elevation angle from the earth rim below @xmath14 , a geomagnetic cutoff rigidity lower than 6gv , and the region of the south atlantic anomaly .
the exposure times after the screening were 13ks for gis 2 and gis 3 , respectively .
we subtracted the non - x - ray background and the cosmic x - ray background from the data .
we then made a correction for vignetting .
figure [ fig : kes27_gismost ] shows the gis image of kes27 in the 0.710kev energy band .
the overlaid contours are the radio map reproduced from the molonglo observatory synthesis telescope ( most ) observation ( milne et al .
1985 , 1989 ) .
it clearly shows the centrally peaked x - ray emission confined by the radio shell . in the radio map , there are two bright regions drawn in red contour : one is the east rim and the other is the center .
therefore , the radio - bright rim in the east is relatively dim in x - rays , while the radio - bright center is bright in x - rays .
figure [ fig : kes27_gisimage ] shows gis images for two energy bands : the low - energy ( 0.72kev ) band and the high - energy ( 210kev ) band . comparing the low - energy band image with that obtained by the pspc ( seward et al .
1996 ) , we noticed that the asca image shows no rim brightening in the eastern rim .
the eastern rim was detected with the einstein ipc with relatively weak intensity ( seward 1990 ) .
considering the difference in the energy bands of these detectors , the emission from the eastern rim must be soft in the spectrum .
seward et al . ( 1996 ) reported several point - like x - ray sources detected by the pspc inside the remnant . comparing the image obtained by the hri
, they found that these sources show soft emission . due to the spatial resolution of asca
, we found no point - like feature corresponding to them .
the asca image shows a centrally peaked structure that does not coincide with the point source reported .
we generated the gis band ratio map by dividing the 210kev image by the 0.72kev image , as shown in figure [ fig : kes27_gishard ] .
it shows that the central part shows a harder spectrum than that of the outer region .
the hardest region statistically coincides with the x - ray brightest region , which might suggest the existence of a point source in the center .
we extracted the gis and sis spectra from the circular region with a diameter of 18@xmath17 , which is shown by the outermost circle in the thick solid line in figure [ fig : kes27_gis0710 ] , which surely covers the entire x - ray emission observed .
since kes27 is located near the galactic plane , ( @xmath18 , @xmath19 ) = ( , ) , the galactic ridge emission should be taken into account .
therefore , we extracted the annular region around the source as the background spectra .
we selected the annular region of inner and outer diameters of 24@xmath17 and 30@xmath17 as the background for the gis data .
similarly , we selected the region of the sis fov outside a circle of 22@xmath17 diameter as background for the sis data . in the subtraction process
, we took into account the vignetting effect of the x - ray optics .
after background subtraction , we found that there is no emission above 4kev .
we , therefore , employed the spectra up to 4kev for a spectral analysis .
we performed a simultaneous fit of the model using the gis and sis data . from the spectra in figure [ fig : kes27_spec_entire ] ,
the emission lines of si and s are clearly seen , which indicates that the x - ray emission comes from a thin thermal plasma in origin .
we employed the vmekal model in ftool 5.1 where the free parameters were the interstellar absorption feature , @xmath20 , electron temperature , @xmath21 , abundances of mg , si , s , ar , and fe .
the other metal abundances were fixed to the solar values .
we obtained a statistically good fit , the results of which are listed in table [ tbl : kes27_fitpar ] , of the entire region .
the best - fit curves are also shown in figure [ fig : kes27_spec_entire ] .
we should note that the obtained abundances are statistically consistent with those of the solar values . in the spectral fitting , we need not require to employ a model with the non - equilibrium ionization ( nei ) condition .
the ionization parameter , @xmath22 , the product of the electron density and the elapsed time after the shock heating , is longer than 10@xmath23@xmath2s , which indicates that the plasma almost reaches the collisional ionization equilibrium ( cie ) condition . using the plasma density
, the value of @xmath22 gives us an age estimate of longer than @xmath4 yr , suggesting that the snr is in the radiative stage .
we then tried to search for a spectral variation across the remnant .
since the x - ray band ratio map shows a point symmetric structure , we divided the image into two regions : an inner region and an outer region .
the inner region has a diameter of 6@xmath17 centered on the intensity peak in figure [ fig : kes27_gis0710 ] .
the outer region has an 18@xmath17 diameter .
figure [ fig : kes27_speceach ] shows the spectra obtained from the two regions .
we also performed a model fitting by employing the same model to that employed for the entire region .
the best - fit parameters are given in table [ tbl : kes27_fitpar ] as well as the best - fit curves in figure [ fig : kes27_speceach ] .
we can notice that most of them show statistically the same value , with the exception of @xmath21 .
we can say that there is a temperature decrease from the inner region towards the outer region that causes the harder spectra in the center . as we mentioned before ,
the x - ray brightest region does not coincide with the point source detected by rosat .
if there is a point source inside the snr , it usually shows a hard spectrum and a possible pulsation .
seward et al . ( 1996 ) noticed the possibility that enhanced central emission could be due to a synchrotron nebula .
our results do not require a power - law type component , like that expected for a possible point source inside the snr .
we picked up photons in the 210kev range of the gis from the inner region .
the total number of photons was 381 with a time resolution of 62.5ms .
a fourier analysis showed no prominent pulsation component between 0.1252000s . due to the poor statistics ,
we could not obtain a meaningful upper limit for the pulsation .
the origin of the central emission is still unknown .
so far , there is no reliable distance estimate to kes27 .
seward et al . ( 1996 ) assigned a distance of 6.5kpc by comparing the column density with that of the neighboring snr , rcw103 ( 5@xmath24 away from kes27 ) , whose distance was determined by a h measurement .
case and bhattacharya ( 1998 ) used a refined @xmath25_d _ relation to derive a distance of 4.0kpc . here
, we adopt a distance of 5kpc , an intermediate value of two estimates . in order to determine the extent of the x - ray emitting plasma
, we measured the solid angle subtended by a half - maximum intensity contour . in figure
[ fig : kes27_gis0710 ] , the half - maximum intensity contour is drawn by the curved red line . the solid angle subtended by
this contour corresponds to a circle with a diameter of . since kes27 shows a filled - center structure with a point - symmetric shape , we assume that the x - ray emitting plasma occupies a sphere with diameter @xmath26 and a uniform density .
if this is the case , the half - maximum intensity contour becomes a circle with a diameter of @xmath27 .
therefore , we calculated various parameters while assuming the diameter of the plasma to be 13@xmath17 with a uniform density .
we also assumed the electron density , @xmath28 , to be equal to the proton density , @xmath29 , for simplicity .
these are summarized in table [ tbl : kes27_prop ] .
vwe performed a similar image analysis using the rosat pspc .
we found that the solid angle subtended by the half - maximum intensity contour is equal to a circle with a diameter of 12@xmath17 , which is almost equal to that by using the asca gis .
this can be understood because kes27 has such a high @xmath20 that the emission is confined to only the asca energy range .
the apparent size in the radio region is @xmath30 ( whiteoak , green 1996 ) , which is bigger by 50% in size than that we measured in the x - ray region .
the density given in table [ tbl : kes27_prop ] is that of the x - ray emitting plasma .
the total mass in the x - ray emitting region is a part of the mass affected by the sn explosion .
the radio - bright region outside the x - ray emitting region must have a higher density than that inside , since it cools down and becomes x - ray dim .
judging from the apparent sizes in the radio and x - ray regions , the total mass occupied outside the x - ray bright region must be by at least one order magnitude bigger than that in the x - ray bright region .
therefore , if the ejecta contain plenty of metal , it must be dissolved into the ism , resulting in the solar abundance .
this shows that kes27 is a typical mm snr . in the radio band
, kes27 shows a bright structure along the eastern rim .
the bright radio feature on one side of the remnant resembles the radio morphology of snrs that are known to show an interaction with the molecular cloud , such as 3c391 and w44 . in general , a detection of shock - excited oh maser emission is a strong evidence for an interaction with the molecular cloud .
the detection of oh maser emission was reported for 3c391 ( frail et al .
1996 ) and w44 ( claussen et al .
1997 and references therein ) , while no oh emission has been detected toward kes27 ( frail et al .
therefore , rho and petre ( 1998 ) noted that there is no evidence of an actual interaction with the molecular cloud in kes27 .
the asca observation verified the centrally peaked and thin thermal x - ray nature for kes27 .
in addition , we first found a spectral variation from the inner region towards the outer region .
it should be noted that the harder spectrum in the inner region comes not from the heavier interstellar absorption but from the higher temperature .
the value of @xmath21 in the inner region is higher by 40% than that in the outer region , while there is no variation of the abundances of heavy elements from a statistical point of view .
the temperature gradient suggests that thermal conduction does not play an important role .
however , our analysis may be an oversimplification due to showing an one - temperature model .
other snrs having both a radio shell and centrally peaked x - ray emission with a thermal nature , like kes27 , have a uniform temperature distribution .
for example , no significant @xmath21 variation has been found in 3c400.2 ( yoshita et al .
2001 ) , g69.4 + 1.2 ( yoshita et al .
2000 ) . as mentioned in subsection 3.1 , there are two radio - bright regions in kes27 : one is in the east rim and the other is in the center .
the bright - radio features are generally seen in the rim of the snr where the matter is compressed by a blast wave .
when the matter is compressed , the polarization becomes prominent . the polarization map given by milne et al .
( 1989 ) shows strong polarization in the east rim as well as in the center where both regions are radio - bright .
however , the east rim is x - ray dim and the center is x - ray bright .
therefore , it must be a projection effect that the bright radio feature in the center coincides with the x - ray bright region .
future x - ray observations with a higher spatial resolution , such as by using chandra or xmm - newton , will reveal the relation between the x - ray intensity peak and the radio emission .
we observed kes27 , a proto - typical mm snr , using asca gis and sis data .
we confirmed a filled - center structure in the x - ray region with an angular diameter of 13@xmath17 , which is about 50% smaller than that of the radio bright region .
the x - ray spectrum can be well fitted by a cie ( vmekal ) model with solar abundances . comparing the spectrum from the inner region with that from the outer region ,
all of the spectral parameters are consistent with each other , with an exception of @xmath21 .
the inner region clearly shows a higher value of @xmath21 by 40% than that in the outer region .
this suggests that the thermal conduction does not play an important role .
our analysis using asca supports that kes27 is a proto - typical mm snr .
there are two radio - bright regions in kes27 : one is in the east rim and the other is in the center . the east rim is x - ray dim while the center is x - ray bright . by taking into account the radio polarization ,
the coincidence between the x - ray and the radio in the center is found to be a projection effect .
a finer observation in the future will reveal the detailed structure in the x - ray region as well as any coincidence between the x - ray and radio regions .
the authors would like to express their special thanks to the asca team .
this research was partially supported by the grant - in - aid for scientific research by the ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology of japan ( 13440062 , 13874032 ) .
case , g. l. , & bhattacharya , d. 1998 , apj , 504 , 761 chevalier , r. a. 1999 , apj , 511 , 798 claussen , m. j. , frail , d. a. , goss , w. m. , & gaume , r. a. 1997 , apj , 489 , 143 cox , d. p. 1972 ,
apj , 178 , 159 dotani , t. , yamashita , a. , rasmussen , a. , & the sis team 1995 , asca news , 3 , 25 frail , d. a. , goss , w. m. , reynoso , e. m. , giacani , e. b. , green , a. j. , & otrupcek , r. 1996 , aj , 111 , 1651 hermsen , w. swanenburg , b. n. , bignami , g. f. , boella , g. , buccheri , r. , scarsi , l. , kanbach , g. , mayer - hasselwander , h. a. , masnou , j. l. , & paul , j. a. 1977 , nature , 269 , 494 hwang , u. , holt , s. s. , & petre , r. 2000 , apj , 537 , l119 kirshner , r. p. , & winkler , p. f.,jr .
1979 , apj , 227 , 853 lamb , r. c. , & market , t. h. 1981 , apj , 244 , 94 makishima , k. , tashiro , m. , ebisawa , k. , ezawa , h. , fukazawa , y. , gunji , s. , hirayama , m. , idesawa , e. , 1996 , pasj , 48 , 171 milne , d. k. , caswell , j. l. , haynes , r. f. , kesteven , m. j. , wellington , k. j. , roger , r. s. , & bunton , j. d. 1985 , proc .
astron . soc .
australia , 6 , 78 milne , d. k. , caswell , j. l. , kesteven , m. j. , haynes , r. f. , & roger , r. s. 1989 , proc .
australia , 8 , 187 miyata , e. , & tsunemi , h. 1999 apj , 525 , 305 miyata , e. , tsunemi , h. , kohmura , t. , suzuki , s. , & kumagai , s. 1998 , pasj , 50 , 257 rho , j. , & petre , r. 1998 , apj , 503 , l167 seward , f. d. 1990 , apjs , 73 , 781 seward , f. d. , kearns , k. e. , & rhode , k. l. 1996 , apj , 471 , 887 van den bergh , s. 1978 , apjs , 38 , 119 white , r. l. , & long , k. s. 1991 , apj , 373 , 543 whiteoak , j. b. z , & green , a. j. 1996 , a&as , 118 , 329 yamashita , a. , dotani , t. , bautz , m. , crew , g. , ezuka , h. , gendreau , k. , kotani , t. , mitsuda , k. , 1997 , ieee trans . nucl .
sci . , 44 , 847 yoshita , k. , miyata , e. , & tsunemi , h. 2000 , pasj , 52 , 867 yoshita , k. , tsunemi , h. , miyata , e. , & mori , k. 2001 , pasj , 53 , 93 lccc parameter & entire & inner & outer + @xmath31 & 2.4@xmath32 & [email protected] & 2.6@xmath33 + @xmath21[kev ] & 0.71@xmath6 & [email protected] & 0.59@xmath6 + mg & 1.1@xmath34 & @xmath35 & 1.1@xmath36 + si & [email protected] & 0.9@xmath34 & [email protected] + s & [email protected] & 1.2@xmath37 & [email protected] + ar & @xmath38 & @xmath39 & @xmath40 + fe & 1.2@xmath41 & 1.5@xmath42 & 0.9@xmath43 + @xmath44/d.o.f .
& 333/342 & 102/90 & 339/280 + + & & & + + lc parameter & value + diameter [ pc ] & 18.9@xmath45 + temperature [ kev ] & 0.71@xmath6 + density [ @xmath2 ] & 0.39@xmath47 @xmath48 + thermal energy [ erg ] & @xmath49 @xmath50 + total mass [ @xmath51 & 34@xmath52 @xmath50 + + + + | we report here on the observation of kes27 , a proto - typical mixed - morphology snr , using asca .
it clearly shows a filled - center structure in the x - ray region while a shell structure in the radio region .
there are two radio bright regions : one is in the center , while the other is in the east rim .
the x - ray intensity peak coincides well with the radio bright region at the center .
the x - ray spectrum was well - fitted by a collisional ionization equilibrium model with solar abundances .
taking into account the ionization parameter ( @xmath010@xmath1@xmath2s ) and the plasma density ( 0.39@xmath3@xmath2 ) , we found that the age of the snr is longer than @xmath4 yr .
the hardness ratio map indicates that the inner region shows a harder spectrum than that in the outer region , which does not come from the heavier interstellar absorption feature , but from the higher temperature .
there is a temperature gradient from the innner region ( [email protected] kev ) toward outer region ( 0.59@xmath6 kev ) , indicating that the thermal conduction does not play an important role . |
ultracold atoms in optical lattices provide a versatile laboratory for interacting quantum many body systems @xcite .
one of the major challenges in this field is the experimental investigation of quantum magnetism in atomic mixtures .
impressive experimental progress in this direction has already been made .
the first important step in experiments with fermionic atoms in optical lattices was the experimental observation of the fermi surface @xcite .
recent experiments with bosonic atoms directly observed correlated particle tunneling @xcite and superexchange @xcite , which are the basic mechanisms underlying quantum antiferromagnetism .
moreover , strong experimental evidence for the fermionic mott insulator state was obtained , both by the local probe of observing reduced double occupancy @xcite and the global probe of observing a plateau in the cloud size when the system is compressed @xcite .
a recent experiment in a system of spin-1/2 fermions without optical lattice indicates a stoner instability toward a ferromagnetic state for strong repulsion @xcite .
these are important steps on the way toward realization of strongly correlated many - fermion states @xcite .
currently the experimental temperatures are still higher than the critical ( nel ) temperature , below which antiferromagnetic order is predicted to develop @xcite .
most accurate theoretical estimates for the entropy per particle below which long - range antiferromagnetic order is expected yield a value of @xmath0 @xcite , whereas current experiments reach an average entropy which is still a factor @xmath1 higher @xcite .
ultracold atomic system offer the unique possibility to control the relative densities of the two spin components , as alreday has been demonstrated in experiments without the presence of an optical lattice @xcite .
experimentally , the density imbalance is precisely tunable by means of radiofrequency sweeps @xcite and stable due to the suppression of spin - flip scattering processes in cold atomic gases .
this realizes an imbalanced spin mixture , in which the @xmath2-symmetry is broken by an artificial magnetic field .
when the density of atoms corresponds to one particle per lattice site , the ground state of this system is expected to be a canted antiferromagnet , with antiferromagnetic order characterized by a nel vector directed perpendicular to the applied field .
however , experimentally ultracold atom systems are always confined by an external harmonic trapping potential , which leads to an inhomogeneous system .
if the total particle number is sufficiently high , in the center of the trap a region with particle density per site close to one will develop , where antiferromagnetic order is stable at sufficiently low temperatures @xcite .
the edges of the system have lower filling ; they are fermi liquid regions without spin order .
if the total particle number is even higher , also in the trap center a fermi liquid with particle density higher than one or a band insulating state can exist . in that case antiferromagnetic order can be stable in a shell around this fermi liquid @xcite .
this poses interesting questions regarding the nature and the stability of spin order , which we will address in this paper by means of ( real - space ) dynamical mean - field theory .
these issues have recently also been investigated by other methods . for homogeneous systems described by the hole - doped hubbard model , both commensurate and incommensurate spin - density - waves
have been predicted @xcite . by mapping to an effective spin model ,
the critical temperature for canted antiferromagnetic order was calculated and topological excitations of imbalanced mixtures were studied @xcite .
a hartree - fock static mean - field theory for balanced mixtures in a trap predicts that antiferromagnetism can coexist with paramagnetic states in various spatial patterns , for example antiferromagnetism in the center of the trap surrounded by a hole - doped atomic liquid or antiferromagnetism in a ring with a fermi liquid in the center and at the edge @xcite . for imbalanced mixtures ,
this approach predicts canted order perpendicular to the ( artificial ) magnetic field up to moderate values of the repulsion @xcite .
very recently the hartree - fock approach has also been applied to larger repulsion : in addition to canted antiferromagnetism , a critical interaction was found , beyond which the stoner instability drives a ferromagnetic transition at the edge of the system , where the particle density is lower than half - filling @xcite .
a real - space dynamical mean - field ( r - dmft ) study of antiferromagnetism in a harmonic trap has also been performed , but so far without allowing for the possibility of canted antiferromagnetic order @xcite . for the case of an imbalanced mixture ,
this constraint lead to the prediction of phase separation between the majority component in the center and the minority component at the edge for sufficiently strong repulsive interactions and large values of the imbalance @xcite .
here we perform a full r - dmft study , which includes the possibility of canted order . unlike static hartree - fock mean - field theory , dmft is a non - perturbative method which is reliable both for strong and weak interactions in sufficiently high dimensions .
local correlations are included exactly @xcite .
r - dmft thereby takes the inhomogeneity induced by the presence of a harmonic trap into account in a fully consistent way . for imbalanced systems
we indeed observe canted antiferromagnetic order .
we consider weak to moderately strong interactions , for which no stoner instability toward spontaneous ferromagnetism is found : in the case of a balanced mixture the wings of the systems are always paramagnetic . only upon applying a finite amount of imbalance ,
the system gets polarized and ferromagnetic order starts to develop .
we generally also do not observe the phase - separation scenario for large imbalance .
instead , the canted antiferromagnetic order allows for a continuous transition between balanced antiferromagnetism order and fully imbalanced ferromagnetic order . only for large values of the interaction and strong imbalance phase separation occurs .
we compare our full r - dmft results with calculations based on a local density approximation in combination with dmft , in which the harmonic trap is incorporated by a spatially varying chemical potential . as for the balanced case @xcite
we find that the total density is well approximated by the local density approximation , but a strong proximity effect is observed for the antiferromagnetic order : the staggered antiferromagnetism as obtained by the full r - dmft calculation extends to regions where the local density approach predicts a paramagnetic solution .
repulsively interacting fermions in a sufficiently deep optical lattice are well described by the single - band hubbard hamiltonian in the tight - binding approximation @xmath3 where @xmath4 , and @xmath5 ( @xmath6 ) are fermionic annihilation ( creation ) operators for an atom with spin @xmath7 at site @xmath8 , @xmath9 is the hopping amplitude between nearest neighbor sites @xmath10 , @xmath11 is the on - site interaction , @xmath12 is the ( spin - dependent ) chemical potential and @xmath13 is the harmonic confinement potential .
we also define @xmath14 and @xmath15 as the average chemical potential and difference in chemical potential , respectively . although @xmath16 acts as a magnetic field , experimentally the imbalance is not induced by a physical magnetic field , but by directly controlling the difference in particle number .
the parameters of this model can be tuned in experiments by changing the intensity of the optical lattice and via feshbach resonances @xcite . in the following ,
we take the lattice constant to be @xmath17 .
to obtain the ground state properties of this system , we apply r - dmft @xcite . within r - dmft the self - energy is taken to be local ( which is exact in the infinite - dimensional limit @xcite ) but allowed to depend on the lattice site , i.e. @xmath18 , where @xmath19 is a kronecker delta .
the lattice sites are described by local effective actions , each representing an effective anderson impurity model , which are coupled via the real - space dyson equation for the green s function .
details of the method have been published previously @xcite . in the present paper
we use exact diagonalization ( ed ) @xcite of the anderson hamiltonian to solve the local impurity actions . within ed the spectral function is represented by a finite number of delta peaks .
whereas this is sufficient for a faithful representation of the zero - temperature spectral function , we found it to lead to unphysical behavior at finite temperature , especially away from half - filling .
therefore we restrict ourselves in this article to the low - temperature limit and only investigate ground state properties .
the multigrid hirsch - fye quantum monte carlo method has proven to be a very efficient solver at finite temperatures for a balanced mixture @xcite , but canted antiferromagnetic order is probably harder to obtain within this method . also when using the numerical renormalization group ( nrg ) method@xcite to solve the anderson hamiltonian , it is problematic to describe the canted off - diagonal spin order .
in contrast , the ed - method we use here is very flexible , which also allows to incorporate off - diagonal canted spin order in a straightforward manner .
however , since @xmath20 in this case is not a good quantum number for the individual spin components , the size of the hilbert spaces to be diagonalized is significantly enlarged , which leads to far more time - consuming numerics compared to the balanced case . for very large repulsion
, ed can run into unphysical instabilities .
therefore we consider only moderately large ratios of @xmath21 here . in the practical implementation of ed a small but finite temperature
is used to generate the @xmath22 data , in order to obtain discrete matsubara frequencies .
we chose this temperature equal to @xmath23 for the two - dimensional data and @xmath24 for three dimensions .
we now apply the r - dmft method to spin-@xmath25 fermions in a two - dimensional square lattice and a three - dimensional cubic lattice with harmonic confinement .
we focus on the density distributions of the two species @xmath26 ( @xmath27 ) , the total density @xmath28 , and the local spin expectation values @xmath29 , in which @xmath30 ( @xmath31 ) are the pauli matrices . here
we have set @xmath32 . in the case of a balanced mixture
the hamiltonian is @xmath2-symmetric .
this means that the staggered magnetization can point in any direction .
we have chosen it to point in @xmath33-direction . in the case of an imbalanced mixture , the @xmath2-symmetry is spontaneously broken by the chemical potential difference , which acts as an artificial magnetic field in the @xmath34-direction . in reaction , the staggered magnetization orders perpendicular to this , i.e. in the @xmath35-plane .
the remaining @xmath36 symmetry is also in this case in our calculations broken by a small initial numerical perturbation , resulting in alignment of the spins along the @xmath33-direction , such that @xmath37 in all results presented here . in all the calculations reported here we have chosen @xmath38 , such that the system is at half - filling at the center . in fig .
[ rs2d ] a typical real - space spin configuration is shown for an imbalanced two - dimensional system .
here we have chosen to label the spatial coordinates by @xmath33 and @xmath34 , such that the spin direction and spatial direction can be identified .
results of our r - dmft calculation on the two - dimensional square lattice for the radial density and spin profiles are shown in fig .
[ 2d ] , both for the balanced system and for the situation that imbalance is induced by a nonzero chemical potential difference @xmath16 .
we first turn our attention to the antiferromagnetic region in the center , where the particle density is at half - filling .
our results show that imbalance reduces antiferromagnetic order in the center , and tilts it out of the @xmath35-plane by inducing a nonzero ferromagnetic @xmath34-component of the spin .
the effect of imbalance becomes larger with increasing interactions .
this can be understood from the fact that for large @xmath21 the local spins in the insulating region interact via a heisenberg hamiltonian @xmath39 here @xmath40 , such that with increasing @xmath41 the exchange coupling between the spins decreases and becomes weaker relative to the applied chemical potential difference .
we do not observe any sign of a stoner instability in the paramagnetic wings for the values of @xmath21 considered here , which would mean a spontaneous ferromagnetic polarization for equal chemical potentials of the spin components .
in contrast , we observe that only upon the application of a finite chemical potential difference ferromagnetic order is induced in the wings .
although we can not establish the critical interaction above which the stoner instability occurs , we thus find that this value is considerably shifted upwards compared with the value obtained within the hartree fock analysis , where spontaneous ferromagnetism was observed for even smaller values of @xmath21 than considered here @xcite .
it is indeed well - known that the hartree - fock approximation underestimates the critical interaction for spontaneous ferromagnetism by more than an order of magnitude @xcite . within dmft
the dynamical screening of the local repulsion is fully accounted for and only for extremely large on - site repulsion a ferromagnetic ground state was found on the homogeneous cubic lattice @xcite . however , this limit is experimentally hard to reach , because the associated critical temperature for spin order is very low .
we now turn our attention to the boundary structure between the antiferromagnetic core and the paramagnetic wings . the results in fig .
[ 2d ] show a local maximum of the ferromagnetic polarization in the @xmath34-direction
. this maximum appears at the location where the antiferromagnetic order in the center disappears .
the minority density shows a local minimum at this point ( cf .
[ 2dring]a , b ) , whereas the majority density has a local maximum .
this feature was also observed in the hartree fock analysis @xcite .
the maximum appears because the antiferromagnetic order reduces the density difference of the two components compared to the paramagnetic situation : a smaller density difference leads to a larger sublattice magnetization and hence a lower energy .
this mechanism suppresses the occurrence of phase separation in the trap center , which was found previously in the case where canted order was excluded @xcite .
in contrast , the possibility of canted order allows a continuous transition between the limiting cases of an antiferromagnetic phase with equal populations of the two species and a fully polarized ferromagnetic phase in which only one of the two species is still present .
an interesting structure emerges in the paramagnetic outer region for large imbalance : the density of minority atoms shows a second maximum ( cf .
[ 2dring ] ) originating from the strong repulsion which pushes them to the outside .
this ring - like structure is the remnant of phase separation found before @xcite .
however , in this case it is no true phase separation , since also minority atoms are present in the central antiferromagnetic region . only for large values of @xmath21 in the limit of very strong imbalance , this outer ring of minority atoms
survives when the antiferromagnetic order in the center disappears , implying true phase separation .
in particular for @xmath42 we do not observe this scenario , in contrast to the case where canted antiferromagnetic order was not included @xcite .
when canted order is accounted for , the outer ring of minority atoms disappears before the antiferromagnetic order in the center vanishes , as visible in the data in fig .
[ 2dring]a ) and c ) .
for @xmath43 still phase separation occurs , as shown fig .
[ 2dring]b ) and d ) : for large imbalance the antiferromagnetic order in the center breaks down , but the ring of minority atoms surrounding the phase separated central region with only majority atoms is still present .
note that this phase separation can not be identified with the stoner instability , because it only happens for large chemical potential difference .
moverover , it means that the complete central region , including the part where the density is at half - filling , is fully polarized , whereas the minority atoms are located in a shell around this at low majority density .
in contrast , the stoner instability favors a scenario , where the region at half - filling still supports antiferromagnetic order , whereas the edges are completely polarized @xcite .
results for the ground state ( @xmath44 ) in three dimensions are presented in fig .
we compare the full r - dmft results with a local density approximation ( lda ) ( previously also denoted as a thomas - fermi approximation ( tfa)@xcite ) , where the trap is modeled within dmft by a locally varying chemical potential combined with the homogeneous density of states of the cubic lattice . in order to facilitate the comparison ,
the absolute value of the staggered spin expectation value in @xmath33-direction is plotted in fig .
[ 3d ] . this makes it impossible to distinguish ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic order in the figure ; however , as in fig .
[ 2d ] the in - plane @xmath35-spin order described by @xmath45 is always staggered . for the total density
we observe good agreement between the lda+dmft and the full r - dmft results ; the only difference being that the lda results show a small discontinuity , which is smoothened in the r - dmft calculation .
in contrast , the agreement between the lda and r - dmft results for the spin order parameters is far less good , as also observed for the case of balanced mixtures @xcite . in particular ,
antiferromagnetic spin order extends much further into the region with total density lower than half - filling ( i.e. @xmath46 ) than lda analysis predicts .
this is a consequence of a proximity effect of the antiferromagnetic insulator close to the paramagnetic boundary layer . examining the numerical results in more detail we observe similar features as for the two - dimensional case in fig .
a maximum of the ferromagnetic polarization in the @xmath34-direction is also visible in the data in fig .
[ 3d ] , although it is more pronounced in the lda curve than in the r - dmft data , and in general less pronounced than in two dimensions .
this is because the ratio of the interaction to the band - width @xmath47 ( @xmath34 being the number of neighbors ) is chosen smaller here .
this is also the reason that phase separation is not observed for the case of strong imbalance , even though large values of @xmath16 are considered .
the minority atoms still form a shell for large imbalance , but this shell disappears before the antiferromagnetic order in the center is destroyed . in order to observe phase separation , a stronger repulsion would be needed .
also , a stoner instability is not observed in the three dimensional case for the value of the repulsion chosen in this case .
our data in three dimensions are summarized in fig .
[ 3ddata ] . here
we plot global observables as a function of the chemical potential difference : the total magnetization in @xmath33 and @xmath34 direction @xmath48 and the staggered magnetization in @xmath33 and @xmath34 direction @xmath49 , normalized to the total particle number @xmath50 .
fig [ 3ddata ] shows that the total magnetization always points in the @xmath34-direction ; which is also the direction in which it is induced experimentally via the spin imbalance .
this means that the system is not frustrated and , for the parameters considered here , the interesting scenarios like the one pursued in ref .
@xcite are not realized .
we have solved the fermionic hubbard model with repulsive interactions in a harmonic trap by means of real - space dynamical mean - field theory , with a focus on the ground state properties of imbalanced spin populations .
we considered systems with a density of one particle per lattice site in the center , for which a shell structure appears : an insulating regime in the center , in which antiferromagnetic order can arise , is surrounded by a fermi liquid regime without magnetic order .
imbalance leads to canted antiferromagnetic order in the center , with an interesting boundary structure to the paramagnetic edge , which we investigated in detail . due to the possibility of canting ,
the antiferromagnetism turns out to be very stable against imbalance : only for sufficiently large values of the repulsion and at large imbalance phase separation occurs . in this regime
the central region becomes completely polarized : only the majority component is present and forms a band insulator in the center .
the minority atoms organize themselves in a shell around this central plateau .
we do not observe a stoner instability toward spontaneous ferromagnetic order for the moderately large values of the repulsion considered here .
the critical interaction to observe this phenomenon is thus necessarily relatively large , leading to a small critical temperature for ferromagnetic order .
canted antiferromagnetic order is more challenging to detect experimentally than antiferromagnetic order in the @xmath34-direction , because many proposed detection schemes are only sensitive to staggered order which is diagonal in the basis of the physical particles constituting the system .
this limitation does , however , not apply to bragg scattering@xcite , which is therefore the experimental method of choice to detect canted antiferromagnetic order .
we thank i. bloch , e. demler , w. ketterle , a. koetsier and h.t.c .
stoof for useful discussions .
this work was supported by the nederlandse organisatie voor wetenschappelijk onderzoek ( nwo ) and the german science foundation dfg via forschergruppe for 801 , sonderforschungsbereich sfb - trr 49 and the dip project bl 574/10 - 1 .
d. vollhardt , n. blmer , k. held , and m. kollar , in _ proceedings of the workshop on ground - state and finite - temperature band ferromagnetism , berlin / wandlitz , 4 - 6 october 2000 _ , lecture notes in physics , vol . 580 , ( springer , berlin , 2001 ) , pp . 191 - 207 . | we investigate antiferromagnetic order of repulsively interacting fermionic atoms in an optical lattice by means of dynamical mean - field theory ( dmft ) .
special attention is paid to the case of an imbalanced mixture .
we take into account the presence of an underlying harmonic trap , both in a local density approximation and by performing full real - space dmft calculations .
we consider the case that the particle density in the trap center is at half filling , leading to an antiferromagnetic region in the center , surrounded by a fermi liquid region at the edge . in the case of an imbalanced mixture
, the antiferromagnetism is directed perpendicular to the ferromagnetic polarization and canted .
we pay special attention to the boundary structure between the antiferromagnetic and the fermi liquid phase . for the moderately strong interactions considered here , no stoner instability toward a ferromagnetic phase
is found .
phase separation is only observed for strong imbalance and sufficiently large repulsion . |
with all three electrons residing in n@xmath122 shells leaving the k shell empty , the three - electron atomic system constitutes an interesting multi - excited atomic problem .
these are ideal for examining the delicate interelectronic correlation of three electrons under the influence of a nucleus , the well - known four - body coulombic problem .
a large majority of these triply excited hollow states are autoionizing and have found important practical applications in the field of high - temperature plasma diagnostics . ever since their first observation in an electron - helium scattering experiment by kuyatt _
[ 1 ] and the same for li in a beam - foil experiment by bruch _ et al . _
[ 2,3 ] , many subsequent attempts were made to study the spectra of these challenging systems over the past three decades .
however the lowest 2s@xmath62p @xmath6p@xmath8 resonance of li in a photoabsorption experiment was reported by kiernan _
[ 4 ] only in 1994 with the aid of a dual - laser plasma technique . in recent years , continuing impressive developments in the synchrotron radiation technology has spawned a great upsurge of interest to measure the position , width and lifetime of these hollow atomic and ionic resonances with greater accuracy and precision .
some of these include for example , but not limited to , the measurement of ( a ) the various even- and odd - parity hollow resonances using photolectron , photoion spectroscopy [ 5 - 9 ] , ( b ) the photoionization cross section [ 10 ] , ( c ) the rydberg series [ 11 ] as well as ( d ) both k and l shell vacancy states , the so - called doubly hollow states [ 6,12 ] , etc
. from a theoretical perspective , due to the presence of strong and subtle electron correlation effects as well as an infinite number of open channels associated with these resonances , accurate and dependable calculation of their energies and widths have posed formidable difficulties to the theoreticians .
this in addition with the availability of numerous powerful and sophisticated quantum mechanical formalisms have stimulated an extensive amount of theoretical works in the recent years . in one of the earliest attempts , ahmed and lipsky [ 13 ] calculated the lowest triply excited resonances of li - like atoms by a configuration - interaction ( ci ) type formalism . in a later work , safronova and senashenko [ 14 ] performed a detailed and systematic study on the n=2 intrashell states of li isoelectronic series employing a 1/z expansion approach for a wide range of z. thereafter , a multitude of theoretical methodologies have been proposed which provide results in fairly good agreement with the experimental works , _ viz .
_ , the joint saddle point ( sp ) and complex coordinate rotation ( ccr ) method [ 15 - 18 ] , the state - specific theory [ 19,20 ] , the space partition and stabilization approach [ 21 ] , the r - matrix theory along with many of its variants [ 22,23 ] , the truncated diagonalization method ( tdm ) [ 24 - 26 ] , the hyperspherical coordinate formalism [ 27,28 ] , etc . while a number of formally attractive and elegant methodologies are now available within the traditional wave function based framework , attempts within a density functional viewpoint have been surprisingly very rare .
the latter can be advantageous and desirable in the sense that the former often requires large basis sets and also possibly the mixing of continuum states . also whereas a substantial amount of experimental and theoretical results exist for li , only a few theoretical studies [ 17 - 19,21,25,26,29 - 33 ] and no experimental results exist as yet for the higher members of the isoelectronic series .
moreover , almost all the publications on these ions have dealt exclusively only with the @xmath13 intrashell states ; the only reported results on the @xmath14 resonance series such as those considered in this work , are due to the recent tdm tabulations of conneely _ et al . _
[ 25,26 ] .
furthermore to the best of my knowledge , we are not aware of any density - based results so far for the hollow resonances of these three - electron ions .
the objective of this article is therefore to provide results for such spectra in the lesser explored li - isoelectronic series using a density functional theory ( dft)-based approach with an aim to judge the performance of this formalism in comparison to the commonly used wave function based methodologies in the literature .
earlier an attempt was made to calculate all the 8 n=2 intrashell triply excited states of the li - isoelectronic series ( z=24,6,8,10 ) [ 34 ] with reasonably good accuracy within the realm of nonrelativistic hohenberg - kohn - sham ( hks ) dft . in this scheme ,
a local nonvariational work - function - based exchange potential [ 35 ] and the nonlinear correlation energy functional of lee - yang - parr ( lyp ) [ 36 ] containing the gradient and laplacian of the density was utilized .
the resulting ks type differential equation was numerically solved in the usual self - consistent manner exploiting the numerov s type finite difference ( fd ) scheme . within a single - determinantal approach ,
this has shown to deliver fairly accurate results for various multiply excited states of closed- and open - shell many - electron atoms and ions , e.g. , the low and high as well as the valence and core excitations , bound and autoionizing states , the satellite states , etc . , ( [ 37 - 42 ] , and the references therein ) . however because of the coulomb singularity at r=0 and the long - range @xmath15 behavior , the fd schemes for the radial discretization often requires significantly larger number of grid points to achieve reasonable accuracy even for the ground states and are not feasible for the high - lying rydberg states . to circumvent this problem , subsequently a generalized pseudospectral ( gps ) technique
was suggested for the numerical solution of the ks equation for purposes of greater accuracy and efficiency [ 43 ] .
recently the gps method has been applied quite successfully in the context of electronic structure and dynamics calculation of the coulombic singularities including atoms , molecules as well as other systems like the spiked harmonic oscillators with stronger singularities , the logarithmic potentials , etc [ 43 - 48 ] . using this gps implementation ,
the singly excited state energies for he , and li and be were calculated within 0.01% and 0.02% compared to the best available literature data ; while the doubly excited states of he deviated by a maximum of 3.60% . furthermore the calculated single and double excitation energies were within the ranges of 0.0090.632% and 0.0851.600% respectively .
this provided the motivation to apply this procedure to the more complicated and arguably more interesting triply excited hollow resonance series of the three - electron atoms and ions .
the validity and usefulness of this formalism has been amply demonstrated in a recent study [ 49 ] on the 12 @xmath3n@xmath4 ( n@xmath122 ) hollow resonance series of li covering a total of about 270 low- and high - lying states ( with a maximum of n=25 ) .
the excited state energies were found to remain well within 0.98% ( with one exception ) whereas the excitation energies showed discrepancies in the range of 0.021%0.058% .
additionally 37 @xmath16n@xmath4 ( n@xmath123 ) doubly hollow states were reported , most of them for the first time ever .
here we first compare the dft excitation energies for all the 8 @xmath13 triply excited states , _ viz . , _
2s@xmath62p @xmath6p@xmath8 ; 2s2p@xmath6 @xmath6d@xmath7 , @xmath9p@xmath7 , @xmath6p@xmath7 , @xmath6s@xmath7 ; and 2p@xmath17 @xmath6d@xmath8 , @xmath6p@xmath8 , @xmath9s@xmath8 of selected members of the li - isoelectronic series , _ viz . , _
b@xmath0 , n@xmath1 and f@xmath2 .
then we focus on the 8 even- and odd - parity doublet and quartet @xmath3n@xmath4 ( 3@xmath5n@xmath56 ) hollow resonance series of all the members in the series ; _ viz . ,
_ 2s@xmath6ns @xmath6s@xmath7 , 2s@xmath6np @xmath6p@xmath8 , 2s@xmath6nd @xmath6d@xmath7 , 2s2pns @xmath9p@xmath8 , 2s2pnp @xmath9d@xmath7 , 2p@xmath6ns @xmath9p@xmath7 , 2p@xmath6np @xmath9d@xmath8 and 2p@xmath6ns @xmath6d@xmath7 . in all the cases ,
comparisons with the available experimental and other theoretical results have been made , wherever possible .
the article is organized as follows : section ii summarizes the basic formalism as well as the computational strategy .
section iii gives a discussion of the computed results while a few concluding remarks are presented in section iv .
the calculation of atomic excited states within the work - function formalism [ 37 - 42,34 ] and its gps implementation [ 43,49 ] has been presented in detail previously and will not be repeated here . in the following
therefore we present only a brief overview of it while addressing the essential problems associated with the excited state dft and some recent developments in this direction .
atomic units are used throughout the article unless otherwise mentioned .
ever since the formal inception in the works of hohenberg - kohn - sham [ 50,51 ] nearly four decades ago , dft has emerged as a powerful practical tool for studying the ground - state properties of many - electron systems such as atoms , molecules , solids etc .
this is chiefly due to its ability to incorporate the electron correlation effects in a clever and computationally inexpensive way .
however inherent difficulties were recognized almost immediately for excited state calculations for the following reasons .
no hohenberg - kohn like theorem exists for a general excited state as the wave function can not be bypassed through the pure - state density in this case .
this is easily realizable from the hydrodynamic formulation [ 52 ] of the wave function ; the phase part of the hydrodynamic function is not constant for a general excited state , although it is constant for the ground and some static stationary excited states . in other words ,
the complex - valued wave function can not be replaced by the real pure - state density function alone and consequently both the charge and current densities have to be taken into consideration .
also an accurate ( not to speak of the exact ) functional form of the exchange - correlation energy in terms of the density ( incorporating the symmetry dependence ) is as yet unknown and may not necessarily have the same dependence on density as for the ground states .
thus although it is advantageous to work in terms of density for the ground states , it is not possible to characterize an individual excited state solely in terms of density ( angular momentum quantum numbers are required to classify them ) .
despite all these problems , a variety of promising and appealing formalisms have been suggested in the past years and this continues to remain a very fertile and demanding area of research .
here we mention a few of the notable ones ; others can be found in the review [ 42 ] . in the subspace formulation of dft [ 53 ] for example , the intuitive idea of slater s transition state theory was put into a rigorous foundation by invoking the concept of ensemble density instead of the pure - state density .
later , a formulation of the ks theory based on the constrained search method was developed [ 54 ] bypassing the hohenberg - kohn theorem and defining the functionals in terms of the slater determinants .
several applications of the ensemble density approach have been made in recent years [ 55,56 ] using a variety of approximate functionals .
further a rayleigh - ritz type variational principle of unequally weighted ensemble has been developed [ 57 ] as a generalization of the ensemble approach , where the lowest m eigenstates are weighted unequally . a time - dependent ( td ) formulation of dft for excited states
[ 58 - 60 ] , based on the td density functional response theory , has shown considerable promise for excited states lately .
the linear response of the fermionic system to a td perturbation leads to the frequency dependent dynamic dipole polarizability whose poles give the excitation energies .
a perturbative treatment has been proposed as well [ 61,62 ] , where the non - interacting ks hamiltonian corresponds to the zeroth - order hamiltonian and the differences in the ks eigenvalues simply give the zeroth - order excitation energies .
recently multiplet energies for transition metal atoms , ions with @xmath18 configurations have been reported [ 63 ] using the scf ks orbitals to construct the atomic multiplet determinantal combinations . despite all these attempts , a general prescription that can yield the bound and resonance states of a many - electron system reliably and accurately in a simple and uniform way for both low and high excitations , would be highly desirable .
this is partly because , although some of the above methods produce good - quality results for certain states , cause significantly large errors for other states making them unsuitable , presumably due to the fact that the potentials used are the ones obtained for the ground states and also importantly lacking the correct asymptotic behavior .
some others are difficult to implement computationally .
furthermore applications have been mostly restricted to the single excitations and low - lying states ; results for double , triple or other multiple excitations as well as for higher lying states like the rydberg series studied here , have been very scanty [ 43,49 ] . the work - function formulation of excited states as used in this work , either bypasses or partly overcomes the above mentioned problems of dft in dealing with the excited states via an amalgamation of the conventional wave function based quantum mechanics within dft such that the atomic orbital and the electronic configuration features are retained and we summarize its essential features below .
the point of central interest is the following ks type differential equation of the form , @xmath19 \phi_i({\mathrm{\mathbf{r } } } ) = \varepsilon_{\mathit{i } } \phi_{\mathit{i}}({\mathrm{\mathbf{r}}}),\ ] ] in this equation , @xmath20 signifies the usual hartree electrostatic potential including the electron - nuclear attraction and the interelectronic coulomb repulsion , @xmath21 while @xmath22 , the total exchange - correlation ( xc ) potential is partitioned as , @xmath23 now making the assumption that a unique exchange potential exists for a given excited state , one can physically interpret it as the the work done to move an electron against the electric field @xmath24 arising out of the fermi - hole charge distribution , @xmath25 , which can be expressed by the following line integral , @xmath26 where the field @xmath24 has the following form , @xmath27 in order that the potential is well defined , the work done must be path - independent , ( irrotational ) and this is rigorously the case for spherically symmetric systems .
this work against @xmath24 can be determined exactly as the fermi hole is known explicitly in terms of the single - particle orbitals .
@xmath28 where @xmath29 denotes the single - particle density matrix spherically averaged over coordinates of the electrons of a given orbital angular momentum quantum number .
now within the central - field approximation , the orbitals expressed as @xmath30 , give the total electron density as the sum of the occupied orbitals , @xmath31 at this point we note that the usual dft route of obtaining the potential as a functional derivative is avoided by introducing the physical interpretation that the dynamic fermi - coulomb hole charge determines the potential .
the exchange potential does not have an explicit density functional form ( unlike the usual practice in dft ) and it is universal ; the electronic configuration of a particular state defines it so that the same ks equation now equally valid for both ground and excited states .
although this formalism is in the spirit of slater s interpretation of exchange energy based on the notion of fermi hole , this is expected to offer better results compared to the hfs scheme as it incorporates the dynamic nature of the charge distribution .
the asymptotic behavior of the fully correlated potential ( both @xmath32 and @xmath33 ) is that of @xmath32 only and falls off as @xmath15 for atomic systems .
however although this path allows an accurate determination of @xmath34 as elaborated , an analogous procedure leading to the accurate form of @xmath35 valid for a general excited state is as yet unknown , because the coulomb hole is not known explicitly in terms of orbitals and therefore requires to be approximated .
several approximate forms have been proposed in the literature ever since dft s inception ; this work uses the well - known lyp [ 36 ] functional which has been found to be quite a good choice for the problem at hand . with this choice of @xmath32 and @xmath33 ,
the ks equation is solved numerically to obtain the self - consistent set of orbitals and the densities therefrom . because @xmath32 is local ,
the solution of the resultant ks equation is computationally much easier than the hf case .
from this set of orbitals , various slater determinants are constructed and different multiplet energies corresponding to a particular electronic configuration are calculated by following slater s diagonal sum rule [ 64 ] .
various other aspects of this formalism can be found in the references [ 37 - 43,34,49 ] .
now a few words about the gps discretization technique is in order .
the commonly used equal - spacing fd schemes often require a significantly large number of spatial grid points because of the coulomb singularity as well as the long - range nature of these physical systems ; even for the accurate calculation of their ground states .
the present legendre pseudospectral discretization approach alleviates this uncomfortable feature in our calculation in three steps : ( a ) the semi - infinite domain @xmath36 $ ] is mapped onto the finite domain @xmath37 $ ] by the transformation @xmath38 , ( b ) then an algebraic nonlinear mapping [ 65,66 ] is used , followed by a ( c ) symmetrization procedure leading to a set of coupled equations .
the overall process gives rise to a symmetric matrix eigenvalue problem which can be accurately and easily solved to yield the eigenvalues and eigenfunctions by using the standard routines .
this allows therefore nonuniform and optimal discretization , maintaining similar accuracies at both small ( denser mesh ) and large ( coarser mesh ) @xmath39 regions with a significantly smaller number of grid points with the promise of a fast convergence .
we used a consistent convergence criteria of @xmath40 and @xmath41 a.u .
, for the potential and eigenvalues respectively ; while a maximum of 500 radial grid points proved to be sufficient to achieve convergence for all the states reported in this work .
at first we present the computed density functional results for the nonrelativistic ground state energies ( in a.u . ) of the li - isoelectronic series , _ viz . , _
be@xmath42 , b@xmath0 , c@xmath43 , n@xmath1 , o@xmath44 , f@xmath2 and ne@xmath45 ions in table i. these are compared with the three best theoretical results in the literature , _ viz . , _ the fully correlated hylleraas type variational method [ 67 ] , the full core plus correlation using multiconfiguration interaction wave functions [ 68 ] , and large expansion of the hylleraas - type functions [ 69,70 ] .
our results show fairly good agreement with all of these .
slight overestimation is observed in the range of 0.0016% for be@xmath42 to 0.0002% for ne@xmath45 .
here we note that within the variationally founded hks dft , all many - body interactions are incorporated into the local multiplicative potential @xmath46/\delta \rho$ ] , whose exact form remains unknown as yet .
as stated earlier , the current formalism is not derived from the variational principle for energy . as a result , even though a ks type equation is solved to obtain the energies and densities , the total procedure is not subject to a variational bound .
.[tab : table1]comparison of the calculated nonrelativistic ground - state energies ( in a.u . ) of li - isoelectronic series , z=410 with the literature data .
pw signifies present work .
[ cols="^,^,^ " , ] for ( a ) 2s@xmath63p @xmath6p@xmath8 , 2p@xmath63s @xmath6d@xmath7 , 2s2p3s @xmath9p@xmath8 and ( b ) 2s@xmath63s @xmath6s@xmath7 , 2s@xmath64s @xmath6s@xmath7 . ] for ( a ) 2s@xmath63p @xmath6p@xmath8 , 2p@xmath63s @xmath6d@xmath7 , 2s2p3s @xmath9p@xmath8 and ( b ) 2s@xmath63s @xmath6s@xmath7 , 2s@xmath64s @xmath6s@xmath7 . ] 3s @xmath6s@xmath7 states for ( a ) b@xmath0 , c@xmath43 , n@xmath1 and ( b ) o@xmath44 , f@xmath2 , ne@xmath45 respectively . ] 3s @xmath6s@xmath7 states for ( a ) b@xmath0 , c@xmath43 , n@xmath1 and ( b ) o@xmath44 , f@xmath2 , ne@xmath45 respectively . ]
in this follow - up of our proposed density functional approach to the triply excited states [ 34 ] and recent gps extension to hollow resonance series in li [ 49 ] , a detailed and elaborate study has been made for the 7 positive ions in the li - isoelectronic sequence ( z=410 ) .
the nonrelativistic excitation energies and radial densities were presented for both low and higher members in these odd- and even - parity rydberg series with excellent accuracy .
first all the 8 n=2 intrashell triply excited states , _ viz . , _ 2s@xmath62p @xmath6p@xmath8 ; 2s2p@xmath6 @xmath6d@xmath7 , @xmath9p@xmath7 , @xmath6p@xmath7 , @xmath6s@xmath7 ; and 2p@xmath17 @xmath6d@xmath8 , @xmath6p@xmath8 , @xmath9s@xmath8 ; of b@xmath0 , n@xmath1 and f@xmath2 were compared with the available literature data .
then we compared the calculated excitation energies of 8 @xmath3n@xmath4 ( 3@xmath5n@xmath56 ) resonance series of all the ions with the only reference tdm result available so far in the literature .
finally we singled out the 2s@xmath6ns @xmath6s@xmath7 series to demonstrate the feasibility and viability of this formalism for the high - lying rydberg series by calculating the latter for all members with n up to a maximum of 25 .
literature results for these systems have been recently reported for a maximum n of 17 for f@xmath2 ( @xmath47 for other ions ) and thus all the resonances lying above are presented here for the first time . out of about 380 states considered in this work , the excitation energies show a maximum absolute deviation of 0.57% ( for 2s@xmath63p @xmath6p@xmath8 state of be@xmath42 ; excepting this lone case the latter remains below 0.50% ) , which further consolidates the validity of the present density functional formalism in the domain of atomic excited states .
although a substantial amount of results are currently available for the higher resonances in li , the same for the higher members of the isoelectronic sequence are very rare , and we hope that these results will provide helpful references in future theoretical and experimental works .
naturally more accurate theoretical calculations and experimental measurements would be required which could shed more light on our understanding of these triply excited resonances .
the use of local nonvariational work - function based exchange potential and the nonlocal lyp correlation energy functional helps retaining the features of traditional wave function based quantum mechanics within dft , that lies at the success of this approach .
the nonuniform spatial gps discretization of the pertinent ks - type equation in conjunction with the nonlinear mapping and the symmetrization procedure within an essentially single determinantal framework , offers results that are quite comparable in accuracy to other sophisticated and elaborate theoretical methodologies existing in the literature .
given the fact that these are strongly correlated systems , and the work - function exchange potential offers almost hf - quality results for ground and excited states of a variety of physical systems [ 42,72,73 ] including atoms , ions , metals etc .
, a major and obvious source of error in our work is the correlation energy functional , which is designed mainly for the ground states .
while we are forced by the current inadequate status of dft to use this potential , development of a universal prescription for the correlation potential , if possible , in the same spirit as the work - function exchange , would be highly desirable and challenging .
put differently , the correlation functional may be either improved or replaced to describe the intricate correlation effects in a transparent way leading to better accuracy . a secondary and lesser contributing source of inaccuracy may be due to the tacit assumption of spherical symmetry in the work - function exchange .
the extension of this method to other hollow resonances , as well to higher photon - energy hollow series where all the three electrons reside in the shells with @xmath48 are equally straightforward and simple . in conclusion
, this work emphasizes the applicability and feasibility of a simple general and efficient dft - based formalism for the accurate and reliable calculation of the hollow resonances in multiply excited atomic systems .
99 c. e. kuyatt , j. a. simpson and s. r. mielczarek , phys
. rev .
a * 138 * , a385 ( 1965 ) .
r. bruch , g. paul , j. andr and l. lipsky , phys .
a * 12 * , 1808 ( 1975 ) .
m. rodbro , r. bruch and p. bisgaard , j. phys .
b * 12 * , 2413 ( 1979 ) .
l. m. kiernan , e. t. kennedy , j .-
mosnier , j. t. costello and b. f. sonntag , phys .
lett . * 72 * , 2359 ( 1994 ) .
l. m. kiernan , m .- k .
lee , b. f. sonntag , p. sladeczek , p. zimmermann , e. t. kennedy , j .- p .
mosnier and j. t. costello , j. phys .
b * 28 * , l161 ( 1995 ) .
y. azuma , f. koike , j. w. cooper , t. nagata , g. kutluk , e. shigemasa , r. wehlitz and i. a. sellin , phys .
lett . * 79 * , 2419 ( 1997 ) .
d. cubaynes , s. diehl , l. journel , b. rouvellou , j .-
bizau , s. al moussalami , f. j. wuilleumier , n. berrah , l. vo ky , p. faucher , a. hibbert , c. blancard , e. t. kennedy , t. j. morgan , j. bozek and a. s. schlachter , phys . rev . lett . * 77 * , 2194 ( 1996 ) .
s. diehl , d. cubaynes , f. j. wuilleumier , j .- m .
bizau , l. journel , e. t. kennedy , c. blancard , l. vo ky , p. faucher , a. hibbert , n. berrah , t. j. morgan , j. bozek and a. s. schlachter , phys .
lett . *
79 * , 1241 ( 1997 ) .
s. diehl , d. cubaynes , h. l. zhou , l. vo ky , f. j. wuilleumier , e. t. kennedy , j .-
bizau , s. t. manson , t. j. morgan , c. blancard , n.berrah and j. bozek , phys . rev .
lett . * 84 * , 1677 ( 2000 ) . l. journel , d. cubaynes , j .-
bizau , s. al moussalami , b. rouvellou , f. j. wuilleumier , l. vo ky , p. faucher and a. hibbert , phys .
* 76 * , 30 ( 1996 ) .
s. diehl , d. cubaynes , e. t. kennedy , f. j. wuilleumier , j .-
bizau , l. journel , l. vo ky , p. faucher , a. hibbert , c. blancard , n. berrah , t. j. morgan , j. bozek and a. s. schlachter , j. phys .
b * 30 * , l595 ( 1997 ) .
s. diehl , d. cubaynes , k. t. chung , f. j. wuilleumier , e. t. kennedy , j .- m .
bizau , l. journel , c. blancard , l. vo ky , p. faucher , a. hibbert , n. berrah , t. j. morgan , j. bozek and a. s. schlachter , phys.rev .
a * 56 * , r1071 ( 1997 ) .
m. ahmed and l. lipsky , phys .
a * 12 * , 1176 ( 1975 ) .
u. i. safronova and v. s. senashenko , j. phys .
b * 11 * , 2623 ( 1978 ) .
k. t. chung and b. c. gou , phys .
a * 52 * , 3669 ( 1995 ) .
k. t. chung and b. c. gou , phys .
a * 53 * , 2189 ( 1996 ) .
b. c. gou and k. t. chung , j. phys .
b * 29 * , 6103 ( 1996 ) .
b. c. gou , eur .
j. d * 5 * , 39 ( 1999 ) .
n. a. piangos and c. a. nicolaides , phys .
a * 48 * , 4142 ( 1993 ) . c. a. nicolaides and n. a. piangos , j. phys .
b * 34 * , 99 ( 2001 ) .
h. bachau , j. phys .
b * 29 * , 4365 ( 1996 ) .
k. berrington and s. nakazaki , j. phys .
b * 31 * , 313 ( 1998 ) .
h. l. zhou , s. t. manson , p. faucher and l. vo ky , phys .
a * 62 * , 012707 ( 2000 ) .
m. j. conneely and l. lipsky , phys .
a * 61 * , 032506 ( 2000 ) .
m. j. conneely and l. lipsky , at .
data nucl .
data tables * 82 * , 115 ( 2002 ) . m. j. conneely and l. lipsky , at .
data nucl .
data tables * 86 * , 35 ( 2004 ) .
t. morishita and c. d. lin , phys .
a * 59 * , 1835 ( 1999 ) .
t. morishita and c. d. lin , phys .
a * 67 * , 022511 ( 2003 ) .
u. i. safronova and r. bruch , phys .
57 * , 519 ( 1998 ) .
n. vacek and j. e. hansen , j. phys .
b * 25 * , 883 ( 1992 ) .
l. b. madsen and k. mlmer , phys .
a * 65 * , 022506 ( 2002 ) .
l. b. madsen and k. mlmer , j. phys .
b * 36 * , 769 ( 2003 ) .
n. a. piangos and c. a. nicolaides , phys .
a * 67 * , 052501 ( 2003 ) .
a. k. roy , r. singh and b. m. deb , int .
j. quant .
chem . * 65 * , 317 ( 1997 ) .
m. k. harbola and v. sahni , phys .
* 62 * , 489 ( 1989 ) . c. lee , w. yang and r. g. parr , phys .
b * 37 * , 785 ( 1988 ) .
r. singh and b. m. deb , j. chem .
phys . * 104 * , 5892 ( 1996 ) .
a. k. roy , r. singh and b. m. deb , j. phys .
b * 30 * , 4763 ( 1997 ) .
a. k. roy and b. m. deb , phys .
a * 234 * , 465 ( 1998 ) .
a. k. roy and b. m. deb , chem .
lett . * 292 * , 461 ( 1998 ) .
r. singh , a. k. roy and b. m. deb , chem .
lett . * 296 * , 530 ( 1998 ) .
r. singh and b. m. deb , phys . rep .
* 311 * , 47 ( 1999 ) .
a. k. roy and s. i. chu , phys .
a * 65 * , 052508 ( 2002 ) .
x. m. tong and s. i. chu , phys .
a * 64 * , 013417 ( 2001 ) .
d. telnov and s. i. chu , phys . rev .
a * 66 * , 043417 ( 2002 ) .
a. k. roy and s. i. chu , phys .
a * 66 * , 043402 ( 2002 ) .
a. k. roy , phys .
a * 321 * , 231 ( 2004 ) .
a. k. roy , j. phys .
g * 30 * , 269 ( 2004 ) .
a. k. roy , j. phys .
b * 37 * , 4369 ( 2004 ) .
p. hohenberg and w. kohn , phys .
rev . * 136 * , b864 ( 1964 ) .
w. kohn and l. j. sham , phys .
140 * , a1133 ( 1965 ) . b. m. deb and s. k. ghosh , in _ the single - particle density in physics and chemistry _ , n. h. march and b. m. deb ( eds . ) ( academic press , london , 1987 ) .
a. k. theophilou , j. phys .
c * 12 * , 5419 ( 1979 ) .
n. hadjisavvas and a. k. theophilou , phys .
a * 30 * , 2183 ( 1984 ) ; _ ibid .
_ * 32 * , 720 ( 1985 ) .
nagy , int .
j. quant .
chem . * 69 * , 247 ( 1998 ) .
f. tasndi and .
nagy , int .
j. quant .
92 * , 234 ( 2003 ) .
e. k. u. gross , l. n. oliveira and w. kohn , phys .
a * 37 * , 2805 ( 1988 ) ; _ ibid . _
* 37 * , 2809 ( 1988 ) .
m. petersilka , u. j. gossmann and e. k. u. gross , phys .
* 76 * , 1212 ( 1996 ) . c. jamorski , m. e. casida and d. r. salahub , j. chem .
phys . * 104 * , 5134 ( 1996 ) .
e. san fabin and l. pastor - abia , int .
j. quant .
chem . * 91 * , 451 ( 2003 ) .
a. grling , phys .
a * 54 * , 3912 ( 1996 ) . c. filippi , c. umrigar and x. gonze , j. chem .
phys . * 107 * , 9994 ( 1997 ) .
t. mineva , a. goursot and c. daul , chem . phys
. lett . * 350 * , 147 ( 2001 ) .
j. c. slater , _ quantum theory of atomic structure _
( mcgraw hill , new york , 1960 ) , vol .
ii . g. yao and s. i. chu , chem .
lett . * 204 * , 381 ( 1993 ) .
j. wang , s. i. chu and c. laughlin , phys .
a * 50 * , 3208 ( 1994 ) . z.c .
yan , m. tambasco and g. w. f. drake , phys .
a , * 57 * , 1652 ( 1998 ) . k. t. chung , phys .
a * 44 * , 5421 ( 1991 ) .
f. w. king , phys .
a * 38 * , 6017 ( 1988 ) .
f. w. king , phys .
rev . a * 40 * , 1735 ( 1989 ) .
b. f. davis and k. t. chung , phys .
a * 42 * , 5121 ( 1990 ) .
v. sahni , in _ structure and dynamics of atoms and molecules : conceptual trends _ , j. l. calais and e. s. kryachko , ( eds . ) ( kluwer academic , dordrecht , 1995 ) .
v. sahni and a. solomatin , adv .
chem . * 33 * , 241 ( 1999 ) . | in this sequel to our work on triply excited hollow resonances in three - electron atomic systems , a density functional theory ( dft)-based formalism is employed to investigate similar resonances in li - isoelectronic series ( z=410 ) .
a combination of the work - function - based local nonvariational exchange potential and the popular gradient plus laplacian included lee - yang - parr correlation energy functional is used .
the generalized pseudospectral method provides nonuniform and optimal spatial discretization of the radial kohn - sham equation to obtain self - consistent set of orbitals and densities in an efficient and accurate manner .
first , all the 8 n=2 intrashell states of b@xmath0 , n@xmath1 and f@xmath2 are presented , which are relatively less studied in the literature compared to the remaining 4 members .
then calculations are performed for the 8 @xmath3n@xmath4 ( 3@xmath5n@xmath56 ) hollow resonance series ; _ viz . , _
2s@xmath6ns @xmath6s@xmath7 , 2s@xmath6np @xmath6p@xmath8 , 2s@xmath6nd @xmath6d@xmath7 , 2s2pns @xmath9p@xmath8 , 2s2pnp @xmath9d@xmath7 , 2p@xmath6ns @xmath9p@xmath7 , 2p@xmath6np @xmath9d@xmath8 and 2p@xmath6ns @xmath6d@xmath7 , of all the 7 positive ions .
next , as an illustration , higher resonance positions of the 2s@xmath6ns @xmath6s@xmath7 series are calculated for all the ions with a maximum of n=25 .
the excitation energies calculated from this single - determinantal approach are in excellent agreement with the available literature data ( for the n=2 intrashell states the deviation is within 0.125% and excepting only one case , the same for the resonance series is well below 0.50% ) . with an increase in z ,
the deviations tend to decrease .
radial densities are also presented for some of the selected states . the only result available in the literature for the lower resonances ( corresponding to a maximum of n=17 )
have been reported very recently .
the n@xmath1016 ( @xmath11 for f@xmath2 ) resonances are examined here for the first time .
this gives a promising viable and general dft scheme for the accurate calculation of these and other hollow resonances in many - electron atoms . |
the response of superconducting films to homogeneous applied magnetic fields is well understood , and analytic expressions for the distributions of the magnetic field and current density have been derived @xcite based on bean s critical state model .
@xcite when small current - carrying coils are placed near the surface to probe the local properties of superconducting films , the magnetic fields generated by the coils are inhomogeneous .
analytic expressions describing the response of superconducting films to small coils have been derived for the linear response regime , @xcite but in order to measure the local distribution of the critical current density @xmath2 in superconducting films , it is necessary to investigate the nonlinear response .
@xcite numerical computations of the nonlinear response of superconducting films to the inhomogeneous magnetic fields arising from small coils have been carried out in refs . , but here we present analytic results for the nonlinear response to line currents above superconducting films . the procedure proposed by claassen _
et al . _
@xcite for inductive measurements of the local @xmath2 distribution in films of thickness much greater than the london penetration depth @xmath7 can be described briefly as follows .
a small coil carrying a sinusoidal drive current @xmath8 is placed just above a superconducting film , and the induced voltage @xmath9 in the coil is detected .
the amplitude of the third - harmonic voltage @xmath10 is measured as a function of the drive current amplitude @xmath4 , and the threshold current @xmath11 is defined such that @xmath12 for @xmath13 and @xmath14 for @xmath15 . because @xmath6 , where @xmath3 the film thickness , @xmath2 can be evaluated from @xmath11 .
@xcite since an electric - field criterion must be applied for a precise determination of @xmath2 , it is important to evaluate the electric field @xmath16 generated in the superconducting film . @xcite in the present paper we consider linear wires as simple models of coil wires , and we analytically investigate the response of a superconducting film to linear wires carrying transport currents . in sec .
[ sec_single - wire ]
we investigate the dc ( ac ) response of a superconducting film to a linear wire carrying a dc ( ac ) transport current : we determine the threshold current @xmath11 , and we present the voltage @xmath17 and the harmonic voltages induced in the linear wire , as well as the electric field @xmath16 induced in the superconducting film . in sec .
[ sec_two - wires ] we consider a superconducting film and two linear wires carrying transport currents of opposite directions .
we briefly summarize our results in sec .
[ sec_conclusion ] .
in this section we consider a superconducting film and a linear wire carrying a transport current , as shown in fig .
[ fig_sc - wire ] . and a linear wire at @xmath18 .
the film is infinitely extended in the @xmath19 plane , and the infinite wire is parallel to the @xmath20 axis . ] an infinitely long wire , parallel to the @xmath20 axis , is situated at @xmath18 where @xmath21 .
the radius of the wire @xmath22 is assumed to be much smaller than @xmath23 .
a superconducting film , infinitely extended in the @xmath19 plane , is situated at @xmath24 , where the film thickness @xmath3 is much smaller than @xmath23 but is larger than the london penetration depth @xmath7 .
flux pinning in the film is characterized by the critical current density @xmath2 , which is assumed to be constant ( independent of magnetic field ) as in bean s critical state model @xcite and to be spatially homogeneous in the film .
we consider the limit @xmath25 , as this simplification allows us to obtain simple analytic expressions for the magnetic - field and current distributions . in the thin - film limit of @xmath25 , the sheet current
@xmath26 plays crucial roles , and the upper limit of @xmath5 is the critical sheet - current density @xmath1 .
the lower critical field @xmath27 is assumed to be much smaller than @xmath1 ( i.e. , @xmath28 ) , such that the flux penetration into superconducting films is not affected by @xmath27 , but is determined by @xmath1 .
@xcite we introduce the complex field @xmath29 , @xcite which is an analytic function of @xmath30 for @xmath31 and @xmath32 .
the biot - savart law for the complex field is given by @xmath33 where @xmath34 is the complex field arising from the line current alone .
the @xmath34 is given by @xmath35 where @xmath36 is the transport current flowing in the linear wire .
at the upper ( @xmath37 ) and lower ( @xmath38 ) surfaces of the superconducting film , where @xmath39 is a positive infinitesimal , the perpendicular and parallel magnetic fields @xmath40 and @xmath41 are obtained from eq . as @xmath42 where p denotes the cauchy principal value integral .
the complex potential is defined by @xmath43 , and the contour lines of the real part of @xmath44 correspond to magnetic - field lines .
the magnetic flux per unit length @xmath45 around the linear wire is @xmath46 .
\label{phi - wire_def}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we have introduced a cutoff length @xmath47 , where @xmath48 is of the order of the radius of the wire , to remove the logarithmic divergence as @xmath49 . the magnetic flux per unit length @xmath50 up through the film ( @xmath51 ) in the region @xmath52 is @xmath53 .
\label{phi - film_def}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in this subsection we consider the magnetic - field distribution when the linear wire carries a dc current @xmath54 that is held constant after monotonically increasing from @xmath55 . for @xmath56 , the magnetic field
is completely shielded below the film , @xmath57 .
the field distribution can be obtained by the mirror - image technique , and the resulting complex field is @xmath58 the complex potential @xmath43 for @xmath59 is given by @xmath60 the perpendicular magnetic field and sheet - current density are thus given by @xmath61 and @xmath62 respectively .
the net current induced in the superconducting film is @xmath63 , as expected .
note that the sheet - current density can not exceed @xmath1 ; that is , @xmath64 . because the maximum of @xmath5 given by eq .
is @xmath65 , eq .
is valid for @xmath66 , where the threshold current is given by @xmath67 figure [ fig_field - lines](a ) shows the magnetic - field lines [ i.e. , the contour lines of @xmath68 calculated from eq . , and the dashed line in fig .
[ fig_field - lines](d ) shows @xmath69 given by eq .. the magnetic flux per unit length around the linear wire , calculated by substituting eq . into eq . , is @xmath70 where the inductance per unit length @xmath71 corresponds to the difference between the self inductance of the linear wire and the mutual inductance of the wire and its image . because the perpendicular magnetic field in the film is zero , the magnetic flux up through the film defined by eq .
is also zero : @xcite @xmath72 equations , , , , and are valid for @xmath56 . for @xmath15 , on the other hand , the maximum @xmath5 reaches @xmath1 and the magnetic field penetrates below the superconducting film .
the field distributions for @xmath15 , therefore , must satisfy @xmath73 where the flux fronts [ i.e. , the boundaries between the region of @xmath74 and that of @xmath61 ] are at @xmath76 . the complex field and the parameter @xmath77 are determined such that they are consistent with eqs . and , as derived in appendix [ app_deriv - ch ] .
the parameter @xmath77 is a function of @xmath4 , @xmath78 and the complex field is @xmath79 where the upper sign holds for im@xmath80 and the lower sign for im@xmath81 .
the corresponding complex potential is @xmath82\right\ } .
\nonumber\\ \label{cg_nonlinear}\end{aligned}\ ] ] figures [ fig_field - lines](b ) and ( c ) show the magnetic - field lines , i.e. , the contour lines of @xmath83 calculated from eq . . the perpendicular magnetic field @xmath40 in the superconducting film , obtained from eq
, is @xmath84 0 & \mbox{for } |x|>a , \end{cases } \label{hy_nonlinear}\ ] ] and the sheet - current density @xmath85 $ ] is @xmath86 \displaystyle -j_cd \left(1 -\frac{|x|\sqrt{x^2-a^2}}{x^2+y_0 ^ 2 } \right ) & \mbox{for } |x|>a .
\end{cases } \nonumber\\ \label{kz_nonlinear}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the net current induced in the superconducting film is again @xmath63 , as expected
. figures [ fig_field - lines](e ) and ( f ) show @xmath87 and @xmath69 given by eqs . and , respectively . the magnetic flux per unit length around the linear wire , calculated by substituting eq .
into eq . , is @xmath88 .
\label{phi - wire_nonlinear}\ ] ] combining eqs . , , and yields @xmath89 , where @xmath90 \displaystyle l_0i_0 + \frac{\mu_0}{2\pi } \left [ i_{c0}-i_0+i_0 \ln\left(\frac{i_0}{i_{c0}}\right)\right ] & \mbox{for } i_0>i_{c0 } .
\end{cases } \label{phi_dc - def}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the magnetic flux up through the film , calculated by substituting eq . into eq .
, is @xmath91 \label{phi - film_nonlinear}\ ] ] for @xmath92 , and @xmath93 for @xmath94 . combining eqs . , , and yields @xmath95 , where @xmath96 \displaystyle \frac{\mu_0}{2\pi } \left [ \sqrt{i_0 ^ 2 -i_{c0}^2\left(1+\frac{x^2}{y_0 ^ 2}\right ) } + i_0\mbox{arccosh } \left(\frac{i_0}{i_{c0 } } \frac{y_0}{\sqrt{x^2+y_0 ^ 2}}\right ) \right ] & \mbox{for } i_0>i_{c0 } \mbox { and } |x|<a .
\end{cases } \label{phi - film_dc - def}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in this subsection we consider the time - dependent field distributions when the linear wire carries a sinusoidal ac drive current @xmath97 . in inductive measurements of the local @xmath2 in superconducting films ,
harmonic voltages induced in coils are detected .
@xcite for precise @xmath2 measurements , it also is important to determine the electric field induced in the film .
@xcite we wish to calculate the magnetic field around the linear wire @xmath98 , defined by eq . , and the voltage per unit length induced in the wire , @xmath99 where @xmath100 is the resistance per unit length of the wire .
we also wish to determine the magnetic flux per unit length up through the film @xmath101 , defined by eq . , and the electric field in the film,@xcite @xmath102 for @xmath56 the magnetic field is completely shielded below the superconducting film , @xmath57 , as in sec .
[ sec_dc - linear ] .
the complex field , the sheet - current density in the film , and the magnetic flux around the linear wire are given by eqs . , , and , respectively , except that now @xmath4 in those equations is replaced by @xmath8 .
the magnetic flux per unit length around the linear wire is given by @xmath103 .
the voltage induced in the wire defined by eq .
is thus given by @xmath104 .
for @xmath105 , the harmonic voltages , the magnetic flux per unit length penetrating the film @xmath106 , and the electric field in the film @xmath16 are all zero .
@xcite for @xmath15 , on the other hand , the magnetic field penetrates through the superconducting film , as discussed in sec .
[ sec_dc - nonlinear ] . for ac drive current @xmath8 , the magnetic flux per unit length around the linear wire @xmath98 is @xcite @xmath107 for @xmath108 , and @xmath109 for @xmath110 , where @xmath111 is defined by eq . . the voltage per unit length of the wire , calculated from eqs . and , is @xmath112 where @xmath113 is the differential inductance given by @xmath114 \displaystyle l_0 + \frac{\mu_0}{2\pi } \ln\left(\frac{i_0}{i_{c0}}\right ) & \mbox{for } i_0>i_{c0 } .
\end{cases } \label{l_dc - def}\ ] ] in response to the ac drive current , the magnetic flux per unit length up through the film @xmath101 is @xcite @xmath115 for @xmath108 , and @xmath116 for @xmath110 , where @xmath117 is defined by eq . .
the electric field induced in the film , calculated from eqs . and
, is @xmath118
where the function @xmath119 is given by @xmath120 \displaystyle \frac{\mu_0}{2\pi } \mbox{arccosh } \left(\frac{i_0}{i_{c0 } } \frac{y_0}{\sqrt{x^2+y_0 ^ 2}}\right ) \\[2ex ] \hfill\mbox{for } i_0>i_{c0 } \mbox { and } |x|<a .
\end{cases } \label{l - film_dc - def}\ ] ] in order to measure @xmath2 in superconducting films by the inductive method detecting the harmonic voltages , @xcite it is important to estimate the induced electric field in superconducting films .
@xcite the maximum electric field is induced just below the linear wire at @xmath121 , and is given approximately by @xmath122 for @xmath123 .
the voltage per unit length induced in the linear wire can be expressed as the fourier series @xmath124 where the amplitude @xmath125 and phase difference @xmath126 of the @xmath127th harmonics are calculated by @xmath128 because of the periodicity of @xmath129 , the even harmonics are zero ; i.e. , @xmath130 for @xmath131 .
the fundamental voltage @xmath132 is simply determined by the resistance per unit length of the linear wire , the self - inductance per unit length of the wire , and the mutual inductance per unit length between the wire and its image .
we are interested in the odd harmonics of @xmath133 for @xmath134 ; they are obtained by substituting eqs . and into eq . , which yields @xmath135 where @xmath136 .
for@xmath137 we have @xmath138 figure [ fig_v3-q3-i0 ] shows the @xmath4 dependence of the third - harmonic voltage @xmath139 calculated from eq . with @xmath140 .
although the present model of a linear wire is oversimplified , the behavior of the third harmonic voltage shown in this figure qualitatively agrees with the experimental data measured by a coil with a @xmath141 film .
@xcite and the phase @xmath142 of the third - harmonic voltage as functions of the drive current amplitude @xmath4 . ]
two linear wires are better than a single wire to model current - carrying coils . in this section
we consider a superconducting film and two linear wires carrying transport currents of opposite directions , as shown in fig .
[ fig_sc-2wires ] . and two linear wires at @xmath143 carrying transport currents @xmath144 . ]
infinitely long wires , parallel to the @xmath20 axis , are situated at @xmath143 where @xmath145 and @xmath21 .
a superconducting film , infinitely extended in the @xmath19 plane , is situated at @xmath24 , where @xmath146 .
one wire carrying a dc current @xmath147 is situated at @xmath148 and another wire carrying a current of opposite direction @xmath149 is at @xmath150 , where @xmath145 and @xmath21 .
the complex field due to the two wires is given by @xmath151 where @xmath152 and @xmath153 .
in this subsection we consider the magnetic - field distribution when the linear wire carries a dc current @xmath54 that is held constant after monotonically increasing from @xmath55 . for @xmath56 , the magnetic field
is completely shielded below the film , @xmath57 .
the field distribution can be obtained by the mirror - image technique , and the resulting complex field is @xmath154 where @xmath155 the complex potential for @xmath156 is given by @xmath157 the perpendicular magnetic field is @xmath61 , and the sheet - current density is thus given by @xmath158 where the function @xmath159 is determined by the configuration of the wires , @xmath160 . \label{kz
/ i0_2wires}\ ] ] the sheet - current density @xmath161 is maximum at @xmath162 , where @xmath163 the sheet - current density can not exceed @xmath1 ; that is , @xmath164 , and eq .
is valid for @xmath66 , where the threshold current is given by @xmath165 figure [ fig_field - lines-2wires](a ) shows the magnetic - field lines [ i.e. , the contour lines of @xmath68 calculated from eq . , and the dashed line in fig
. [ fig_field - lines-2wires](d ) shows @xmath69 given by eq . . for @xmath15 , on the other hand
, the maximum @xmath5 reaches @xmath1 and the magnetic field penetrates below the superconducting film .
the field distributions for @xmath15 , therefore , must satisfy @xmath166 where the flux fronts are at @xmath76 and @xmath167 . the complex field and the parameters @xmath77 and @xmath168 ( where @xmath169 ) are determined such that they are consistent with eqs . and ,
as derived in appendix [ app_two - wires - xz ] .
the parameters for flux fronts , @xmath77 and @xmath168 , are determined as functions of @xmath4 for @xmath15 , by solving the following two equations , @xmath170 , \label{ab - i0_2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath171 and @xmath172 are the complete elliptic integrals of the first and second kinds , and @xmath173 .
these parameters obey @xmath174 when @xmath175 , and @xmath176 when @xmath15 , where @xmath177 is given by eq . .
as shown in fig .
[ fig_2wires - ab - i0 ] , @xmath77 increases and @xmath168 decreases with increasing @xmath4 .
( upper lines ) and @xmath168 ( lower lines ) , as functions of @xmath4 , determined by eqs . and .
the solid lines show @xmath77 and @xmath168 for @xmath178 ( @xmath179 ) , the dashed lines for @xmath180 ( @xmath181 ) , and the chained lines for @xmath182 ( @xmath183 ) . ]
the complex field is derived in appendix [ app_two - wires - xz ] , and is given by @xmath184 where @xmath185 , \nonumber\\ \label{hperp(z)}\\ { \cal h}_c(\zeta ) & = & \frac{j_cd}{\pi } \zeta\phi(\zeta ) \int_b^a \frac{du}{(u^2-\zeta^2)\phi(u ) } , \label{hc(z)}\\ \phi(\zeta ) & = & \sqrt{(a^2-\zeta^2)(\zeta^2-b^2 ) } . \label{phi(z)}\end{aligned}\ ] ] integrating eq . [ or ] , we obtain the complex potential @xmath43 , as @xmath186 \nonumber\\ & & { } + \frac{j_cd}{\pi}\int_b^a du g_0(\zeta , u ) , \label{g(z)}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath187 figure [ fig_field - lines-2wires](b ) and ( c ) show the magnetic - field lines , i.e. , the contour lines of @xmath83 calculated from eq . .
figure [ fig_field - lines-2wires](e ) and ( f ) show @xmath40 and @xmath188 $ ] calculated from eq .
[ or from eqs . , , , and ] .
the response of a superconducting film to ac drive currents @xmath189 flowing in the two linear wires at @xmath143 is calculated in a manner similar to that described in sec .
[ sec_ac ] .
the magnetic flux per unit length @xmath45 linked in the two wires is calculated from @xmath190 , \label{phi - wire_def-2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the magnetic flux per unit length @xmath50 up through the film ( @xmath51 ) in the region @xmath52 is calculated from eq . , where @xmath44 is given by eqs . and .
the time - dependent magnetic flux is given by eqs . and .
the voltage @xmath17 induced in the wires per unit length and the electric field induced in the film are given by eqs . and , respectively .
here we discuss the more realistic situation of experiments detecting the response of a superconducting film to a circular current - carrying coil .
@xcite we consider a single - turn coil parallel to a superconducting film .
when the radius of the coil is @xmath191 and the distance between the coil and the film is @xmath23 , the configuration of the coil and the film in the @xmath192 plane is similar to that in fig .
[ fig_sc-2wires ] .
we expect that the magnetic - field lines , the magnetic - field component perpendicular to the film , and the circular sheet - current distribution in the film then will be similar to the corresponding quantities shown in fig . [ fig_field - lines-2wires ] . in actual superconducting films the critical current density @xmath2 and the film thickness @xmath3 can be inhomogeneous , although in the present paper we assumed that @xmath193 is spatially homogeneous .
the magnetic field produced by the coil of radius @xmath191 is largest directly below the coil ( i.e. , the circular region of radius @xmath194 in the film ) when @xmath195 .
if @xmath193 in the circular region below the coil is nearly homogeneous , the response of the film will be similar to that presented in sec .
[ sec_two - wires ] , and the signal in the coil will yield the local value of @xmath193 . in this sense
the resolution of the measurements using the coil is on the order of @xmath191 .
however , if @xmath193 is very inhomogeneous within the circular region below the coil , the response of the film will be quite different from that given in sec .
[ sec_two - wires ] .
we investigated the response of an infinite superconducting film at @xmath51 to linear wires above the film carrying transport currents @xmath36 .
we derived analytic expressions for the complex field , and these are given in eqs .
, , , and .
the behavior of the film can be summarized as follows .
\(i ) response to a dc current , @xmath196 : for a small dc current in the range @xmath197 , the sheet - current density @xmath0 in the film is less than the critical value @xmath1 , and no magnetic field penetrates into the region @xmath198 below the film .
however , for a large dc current @xmath15 , the sheet - current density reaches @xmath199 and the magnetic field penetrates into the region below the film .
\(ii ) response to an ac current , @xmath200 : for @xmath13 the voltage @xmath17 induced in the linear wire has only the first harmonic at the fundamental frequency @xmath201 .
however , for @xmath15 , odd - harmonic voltages with frequency @xmath202 , @xmath127 = 3 , 5 , 7 , ... , are also induced in the linear wire .
the complex field for the case of a single current - carrying linear wire above the film is derived in appendix a. the complex field for the case of a pair of current - carrying wires in a plane perpendicular ( parallel ) to the film is given in appendix b ( appendix c ) .
we thank h. yamasaki for stimulating discussions . this manuscript has been authored in part by iowa state university of science and technology under contract no .
w-7405-eng-82 with the u.s .
department of energy .
in the @xmath203 plane for the integrals in eqs . and consists of a line just above the real axis , @xmath204 from @xmath205 to @xmath206 where @xmath207 , an infinite circle , @xmath208 from @xmath209 to @xmath210 , a line just below the real axis , @xmath211 from @xmath206 to @xmath205 , and an infinitesimal line parallel to the imaginary axis , @xmath212 from @xmath213 to @xmath214 , taking the limit of @xmath215 , @xmath216 , and @xmath217 . ] in this appendix we derive eqs . and . consider the function @xmath218 defined by @xmath219 \sqrt{a^2-\zeta^2 } , \label{f(z)}\ ] ] where @xmath220 is @xmath221 we calculate the integral @xmath222 along the closed contour @xmath223 shown in fig .
[ fig_contour ] , as @xmath224 where the contour integral along the infinite circle vanishes because @xmath225 for @xmath226 . because the integrand in the left - hand side of eq .
has poles at @xmath227 and @xmath228 , the contour integral of eq .
is also calculated by using the residue theorem , as @xmath229 , and thus yielding @xmath230 where @xmath231 is given by @xmath232 for @xmath233 , the @xmath234 and @xmath220 are given by @xmath235 , \hspace{3ex } \label{h(x+i0)}\\ \eta_{\parallel}(x ) & = & i\,\mbox{im}\,{\cal h}_0(x ) , \label{hpara(x)}\end{aligned}\ ] ] respectively , and thus yielding @xmath236 by using eqs . , , and @xmath237 \sqrt{a^2-x^2 } & \mbox{for } |x|<a , \end{cases}\ ] ] we have @xmath238 -i \sqrt{a^2-x^2 } k_z(x ) & \mbox{for } |x|<a , \end{cases }
\nonumber\\ & = & \begin{cases } 0 & \mbox{for } |x|>a , \\[1ex ] i \sqrt{a^2-x^2 } j_cd & \mbox{for } |x|<a , \end{cases } \nonumber\\ \label{f(x+i0)-f(x - i0)}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we used eqs . and
. substitution of eq . into eq
. yields @xmath239 where the upper ( lower ) signs hold for @xmath59 ( @xmath240 ) . from eqs . , , and we obtain @xmath241 note that the first term of the right - hand side of eq . , which is proportional to @xmath4 , corresponds to the complex field in the ideal meissner state for two semi - infinite strips situated at @xmath242 with a line current at @xmath243 . by using @xmath244
, we confirm that eq . for @xmath245 is identical to eq . .
equation can be rewritten as @xmath246 however , the last term of the right - hand side of eq . must vanish , because @xmath234 is finite at @xmath247 .
we thus obtain @xmath248 , such that the parameter @xmath77 describing the position of the flux front is given by eq . .
the resulting expression for the complex field is given by eq . .
see also appendix [ app_two - wires ] for the complex field for a superconducting film with two wires in the @xmath249 plane .
we present here the complex field for a superconducting film with two parallel linear wires above it .
an infinite superconducting film is in the plane @xmath51 , as shown in fig .
[ fig_sc - wire ] .
one wire carrying a dc current @xmath250 is situated at @xmath251 and another wire carrying current @xmath252 is at @xmath253 , where @xmath254 .
the derivation of the complex field for the two wires is similar to that given in appendix [ app_deriv - ch ] for a single wire , and we exhibit here only the resulting expressions . for @xmath13 ,
the sheet - current density and the perpendicular magnetic field satisfy @xmath255 and @xmath61 , respectively .
the threshold current is given by @xmath256 and the complex field for @xmath13 is @xmath257 for @xmath15 , @xmath69 and @xmath87 fulfill eqs . and , and the relationship between @xmath77 and @xmath4 is given by @xmath258 the complex field and complex potential for @xmath15 are respectively given by @xmath259 , \label{ch_two - wires}\\ { \cal g}(\zeta ) & = & \frac{j_cd}{2 } \left(\pm i\zeta + \sqrt{a^2-\zeta^2 } \right ) \nonumber\\ & & { } + \frac{i_0}{2\pi } \left [ i\arctan\left(\frac{\zeta}{y_1}\right ) -\mbox{arctanh}\left(\sqrt{% \frac{a^2-\zeta^2}{a^2+y_1 ^ 2}}\right ) \right .
\nonumber\\ & & \left .
{ } -i\arctan\left(\frac{\zeta}{y_2}\right ) + \mbox{arctanh}\left(\sqrt{% \frac{a^2-\zeta^2}{a^2+y_2 ^ 2}}\right ) \right ] .
\nonumber\\ \label{cg_two - wires}\end{aligned}\ ] ]
in this appendix we derive eqs . . consider the function @xmath260 defined by @xmath261 \phi(\zeta ) , \label{f(z)}\ ] ] where @xmath262 and @xmath263 are defined by eqs . and , respectively .
we calculate the integral @xmath264 along the closed contour @xmath223 shown in fig .
[ fig_contour ] , as in eq . , @xmath265 where the contour integral along the infinite circle vanishes because @xmath266 for @xmath226 .
because the integrand on the left - hand side of eq . has poles at @xmath227 , @xmath267 , and @xmath268 , the contour integral of eq . can be calculated by using the residue theorem , as @xmath269 , and thus yielding @xmath270 the @xmath271 is defined by @xmath272 \nonumber\\ & = & \frac{i_0}{2\pi } \left [ \frac{\zeta\phi(\zeta_1)}{\zeta^2-\zeta_1 ^ 2 } -\frac{\zeta\phi(\zeta_2)}{\zeta^2-\zeta_2 ^ 2 } \right ] , \label{f0(z)}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we used @xmath273 and @xmath274 . for @xmath233 , eq .
is reduced to @xmath275 \mbox{sgn}(x ) \widetilde{\phi}(x ) & \mbox{for $ b<|x|<a$ } , \end{cases } \label{phi(x+i0)}\ ] ] where @xmath276 \sqrt{(a^2-x^2)(x^2-b^2 ) } & \mbox{for $ b<|x|<a$ } , \\[1ex ] -\sqrt{(x^2-a^2)(x^2-b^2 ) } & \mbox{for $ |x|>a$ } .
\end{cases } \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] substituting eqs . and into eq . with @xmath233
, we have @xmath277 -i\,\mbox{sgn}(x ) \widetilde{\phi}(x ) k_z(x ) & \mbox{for $ b<|x|<a$ } , \end{cases } \nonumber\\ & = & \begin{cases } 0 & \mbox{for $ |x| < b$ or $ |x|>a$ } , \\[1ex ] i\,j_cd\ , \widetilde{\phi}(x ) & \mbox{for $ b<|x|<a$ } , \end{cases } \label{f(x+i0)-f(x - i0 ) } \nonumber\\\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we used eqs . and .
substitution of eq . into eq .
yields @xmath278 such that @xmath279 by using @xmath280 we rewrite eq . as @xmath281 \right . \nonumber\\ & & \left.\quad{}+\frac{j_cd}{\pi } \int_b^a \frac{du}{(u^2-\zeta^2)\phi(u ) } \right\ } \nonumber\\ & & { } + \frac{\zeta}{\phi(\zeta)}{\cal r}(\zeta ) , \label{h(z)-calc}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath282 \nonumber\\ & & { } -\frac{j_cd}{\pi}\int_b^a du \frac{\zeta^2+u^2-a^2-b^2}{\widetilde\phi(u ) } \nonumber\\ & = & \frac{(\zeta^2-b^2){\cal r}(\pm a ) + ( a^2-\zeta^2){\cal r}(\pm b)}{a^2-b^2 } .
\label{r(z)}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath247 and @xmath283 , we have @xmath284 in order to remove the divergences in eq . at @xmath247 and @xmath283 , we require @xmath285 , thus yielding @xmath286 equations and reduce to eqs . and , respectively .
we thus obtain @xmath287 for any @xmath288 , and eq .
is reduced to eqs . , , and .
the sheet current @xmath289 $ ] and the perpendicular magnetic field @xmath40 are obtained by substituting @xmath233 in eq . with eq .
, @xmath290\right . \nonumber\\ & & \left.{}-\frac{j_cd}{\pi}\int_b^a \frac{du}{[(x\pm i\epsilon)^2-u^2]\phi(u ) } \right\ } \nonumber\\ & = & \phi(x\pm i\epsilon ) \left\ { \frac{i_0}{\pi } \mbox{re}\,\left [ \frac{x}{(x^2-\zeta_1 ^ 2)\phi(\zeta_1 ) } \right]\right .
\nonumber\\ & & { } -\frac{j_cd}{\pi}\int_b^a \frac{du}{\phi(u ) } \left[\frac{x}{x^2-u^2 } \right . \nonumber\\ & & \left.\left.\quad{}\mp\frac{i\pi}{2 } \bigl(\delta(x - u)+\delta(x+u)\bigr)\right ] \right\ } .
\label{hykz - cal}\end{aligned}\ ] ] substitution of eq . into eq .
yields the sheet current @xmath69 and the perpendicular magnetic field @xmath87 .
the @xmath69 for @xmath291 is given by eq .
, and that for @xmath292 or @xmath293 is given by @xmath294 \right . \nonumber\\ & & \left .
{ } -j_cd \int_{b}^{a } \frac{du}{(x^2-u^2)\phi(u ) } \right\ } . \label{kz_nonlinear_shld_2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the @xmath87 for @xmath292 or @xmath293 is given by eq .
, and that for @xmath291 is given by @xmath295 \right .
\nonumber\\ & & \left .
{ } -j_cd\ , \mbox{p } \int_{b}^{a } \frac{du}{(x^2-u^2)\phi(u ) } \right\ } , \label{hy_nonlinear_pntr_2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where p denotes the cauchy principal value integral .
99 g. w. swan , j. math .
* 9 * , 1308 ( 1968 ) .
m. r. halse , j. phys .
d * 3 * , 717 ( 1970 ) .
p. n. mikheenko and yu .
e. kuzovlev , physica c * 204 * , 229 ( 1993 ) .
j. zhu , j. mester , j. lockhart and j. turneaure , physica c * 212 * , 216 ( 1993 ) .
e. h. brandt , m. v. indenbom and a. forkl , europhys lett .
* 22 * , 735 ( 1993 ) ; e. h. brandt and m. indenbom , , 12893 ( 1993 ) .
e. zeldov , j. r. clem , m. mcelfresh and m. darwin , , 9802 ( 1994 ) .
c. p. bean , , 250 ( 1962 ) ; , 31 ( 1964 ) .
a. t. fiory , a. f. hebard , p. m. mankiewich , and r. e. howard , , 2165 ( 1988 ) .
j. r. clem and m. w. coffey , , 14662 ( 1992 ) .
klupsch and m. zeisberger , physica c * 244 * , 153 ( 1995 ) .
j. gilchrist and e. h. brandt , , 3530 ( 1996 ) . s. j. turneaure , a. a. pesetski , and t. r. lemberger , j. appl .
phys . * 83 * , 4334 , ( 1998 ) .
m. w. coffey , j. appl .
phys . * 89 * , 5570 ( 2001 ) .
k. bernhardt , r. gross , m. hartmann , r. p. huebener , f. kober , d. koelle , and t. sermet , physica c * 161 * , 468 ( 1989 ) .
j. h. claassen , m. e. reeves , and r. j. soulen , jr . , rev .
* 62 * , 996 ( 1991 ) . g. d. poulin , j. s. preston , and t. strach , , 1077 ( 1993 ) .
h. hochmuth and m. lorenz , physica c * 220 * , 209 ( 1994 ) ; ibid . * 265 * , 335 ( 1996 ) .
y. mawatari , h. yamasaki , and y. nakagawa , , 2424 ( 2002 ) .
l. s. koo and k. l. telschow , , 8743 ( 1996 ) .
h. wada , m. migita , e. s. otabe , m. kiuchi , t. matsushita , y. mawatari , h. yamasaki , and y. nakagawa , physica c * 392 - 396 * , 1310 ( 2003 ) ; t. nadami , e. s. otabe , m. kiuchi , and t. matsushita , ibid . * 412 - 414 * , 1011 ( 2004 ) ; t. nadami , e. s. otabe , m. kiuchi , t. matsushita , y. mawatari , h. yamasaki , and y. nakagawa , ibid . * 426 - 431 * , 688 ( 2005 )
. h. yamada , a. bitoh , y. mitsuno , i. imai , k. nomura , k. kanayama , s. nakagawa , y. mawatari , and h. yamasaki , physica c * 433 * , 59 ( 2005 ) .
m. aurino , e. di gennaro , f. di iorio , a. gauzzi , g. lamura , and a. andreone , j. appl . phys . * 98 * , 123901 ( 2005 ) .
the flux - penetration process for finite @xmath296 is more complicated than that shown in the present paper for @xmath28 .
the case for @xmath296 will be published elsewhere , j. r. clem and y. mawatari , unpublished .
j. r. clem , r. p. huebener , and d. e. gallus , j. low temp .
* 12 * , 449 ( 1973 ) .
e. zeldov , a. i. larkin , v. b. geshkenbein , m. konczykowski , d. majer , b. khaykovich , v. m. vinokur , and h. shtrikman , , 1428 ( 1994 ) . y. mawatari and j. r. clem , phys .
* 86 * , 2870 ( 2001 ) ; a. a. babaei brojeny , y. mawatari , m. benkraouda , and j. r. clem , supercond .
* 15 * , 1454 ( 2002 ) ; y. mawatari and j. r. clem , , 024505 ( 2003 ) .
note that the simple result of @xmath297 for @xmath13 is ideally accurate only for the thin - film limit , @xmath25 .
small but finite magnitudes of @xmath298 and @xmath299 arise even for @xmath13 in a superconducting film of finite thickness , because the magnetic flux penetrates in the vicinity of the upper surface of the film .
we confine our attention here to low frequencies , well below those normally used to investigate the surface resistance of superconducting films , where energy dissipation arises due to excitation of quasiparticles or to small - amplitude vortex motion , as discussed , for example , in m. w. coffey and j. r. clem , , 386 ( 1991 ) . | we theoretically investigate the response of a superconducting film to line currents flowing in linear wires placed above the film , and we present analytic expressions for the magnetic - field and current distributions based on the critical state model .
the behavior of the superconducting film is characterized by the sheet - current density @xmath0 , whose magnitude can not exceed the critical value @xmath1 , where @xmath2 is the critical current density and @xmath3 is the thickness of the film .
when the transport current @xmath4 flowing in the wire is small enough , @xmath5 is smaller than @xmath1 and the magnetic field is shielded below the film .
when @xmath4 exceeds a threshold value @xmath6 , on the other hand , @xmath5 reaches @xmath1 and the magnetic field penetrates below the film .
we also calculate the ac response of the film when an ac transport current flows in the linear wires . |
the current generation of ground - based interferometers , such as the palomar testbed interferometer ( pti ) @xcite , the naval prototype optical interferometer ( npoi)@xcite , the infrared optical telescope array ( iota3)@xcite , and the center for high angular resolution in astronomy ( chara ) array @xcite , is advancing stellar astronomy in a number of ways .
@xcite , for example , reviewed the state of optical and infrared interferometry .
one direction of progress is the increasing number of spectroscopic binaries that are being resolved as visual binaries .
this allows the determination of their three - dimensional orbits and the derivation of accurate masses for the component stars and distances to the systems , distances that in many cases are more accurate than those from the _ hipparcos _ satellite . in recognition of this development
we have started a program to determine substantially improved spectroscopic orbits for bright , field spectroscopic binaries .
the program has two benefits : the provision of new radial velocities and spectroscopic orbits of a quality that matches or exceeds the prospective interferometric observations and , for some binaries , the detection of the secondary spectrum and measurement of secondary radial velocities for the first time .
we now briefly consider these two points in turn . while some interferometric studies , such as that of 12 boo @xcite ,
include complementary new radial velocities , the usual practise is to take the radial velocities for the binary concerned from the literature .
the precision of such velocities often falls short of that needed to match the interferometric observations .
for example , in their recent determination of the three - dimensional orbit of the bright spectroscopic binary @xmath17 psc , @xcite had to complement their interferometric measurements with radial velocities observed in 1944 and 1945 @xcite .
their resulting best - fit solution for the three - dimensional orbit has rms velocity residuals of 4.8 and 3.6 km s@xmath13 for the primary and secondary , respectively .
orbits with large velocity residuals are not exceptional because of the generally lower resolution and low signal - to - noise ratio of spectra obtained in the first roughly three - quarters of the twentieth century , for example , of the first 100 systems in the _ eighth catalogue of the orbital elements of spectroscopic binaries _
@xcite , 63 have orbits that were published in 1980 or earlier and 24 have orbits that were published in 1950 or earlier , long before the advent of radial velocity spectrometers and charge - coupled device detectors , which can produce spectra with very high signal - to - noise ratios .
similar proportions must apply for all 1469 systems in the catalogue . while these proportions will have improved as a result of the substantial number of new spectroscopic binary orbits that have been published since 1989 @xcite , most such orbits are for newly discovered binaries .
with respect to the detection of the secondary spectrum , we note that without secondary radial velocities and a determination of the secondary s spectroscopic orbit , the linear separation between the binary components is unknown and the determination of the three - dimensional orbit is incomplete . increasing the pool of double - lined spectroscopic binaries ( sb2s )
thus increases the number of spectroscopic binaries available for fruitful interferometric observation .
in addition , binary systems with components of significantly different masses provide the greatest constraints on evolutionary models . considering that the majority of spectroscopic binaries are single - lined spectroscopic binaries ( sb1s )
, there is ample opportunity here .
@xcite , for example , found that two - thirds of the spectroscopic binaries in their _ ninth catalogue _
( there is no reason to think the catalogue s incompleteness affects this statistic much . )
our program uses new , high - resolution , red - wavelength spectra obtained with the 2.1 m telescope at mcdonald observatory of the university of texas and the coud feed telescope at kitt peak national observatory ( kpno ) .
@xcite provided a preliminary description of our program and an initial list of observed stars , which has now been expanded to over 40 systems .
these come primarily from a sample of 130 candidate systems obtained by searching the _ eighth catalogue _ for sb2 systems that could profit from renewed spectroscopic observation and sb1 systems with large enough mass functions to suggest that high signal - to - noise ratio spectra might transform them into sb2 systems ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
the stars are north of @xmath1840 in declination and generally brighter than @xmath19 mag .
others have also seen the need for improved radial velocities for spectroscopic binaries .
for example , @xcite has successfully applied the iodine absorption - cell method for determining very precise radial velocities to the measurement of radial velocities of _ both _ components in sb2s .
hitherto , this technique , which uses an iodine absorption cell to impose a reference spectrum on the stellar spectrum and is notable for its use in the discovery of extrasolar planets , has been restricted to the radial velocities of single stars or stars with companions of insignificant relative brightness .
his pioneering investigation , which was carried out on the keck i telescope with the hires spectrograph , was limited to five objects including a radial - velocity standard and two sb2s . among
the latter was 64 psc ( hd 4676 ) , a well - known , bright spectroscopic binary ( f8v , @xmath20 days ) with a three - dimensional orbit determined by @xcite , using their own interferometric observations made with pti and radial velocities from @xcite .
konacki s combined fit of his new radial velocities and the @xcite interferometric data leads to better - determined orbital and physical parameters for 64 psc .
in particular , the rms velocity residual of 24 m s@xmath13 , determined from his new fit , is a striking improvement compared to the rms residual of 810 m s@xmath13 ( average @xmath21 m s@xmath13 ) given by @xcite for their radial - velocity solution .
our new velocities are not as precise as the iodine - cell velocities from the keck i telescope we will see that for 12 boo , which has a similar spectral type to 64 psc , the rms residual for our velocities is 110 m s@xmath13 but their quality is still a good match with that of current interferometric observations . there is thus ample opportunity for radial velocities from small and medium - sized telescopes , measured by traditional methods , to make a worthwhile contribution . here
we report new orbit determinations for three bright spectroscopic binaries , rr lyn , 12 boo , and hr 6169 . analysis of our new velocities provides significant improvements in the orbital elements of the systems .
indeed , in the case of hr 6169 some of the revisions are substantial .
table 1 gives basic data for the systems ; all three are known sb2s , have orbital periods near 10 days , and eccentric orbits .
we now briefly look at each system individually .
rr lyn has long been known as both an eclipsing and spectroscopic binary .
its orbit has a period of 9.95 days and a modest eccentricity , @xmath22 .
the star s peculiar abundances are indicated in its metallic - lined spectral classification , which reflects primarily the spectral type of the primary .
@xcite classified it as a3/a8/a6 , based on its ca ii k line , its hydrogen balmer lines , and its metallic lines , respectively , while @xcite called the hydrogen lines a7 and the metallic lines f0 .
@xcite compared the two components with evolutionary tracks and also used their photoelectric photometry on the @xmath23 system @xcite to place the components of rr lyn in a @xmath24 diagram . from those results they estimated individual spectral types of a6 iv for the primary and f0 v for the secondary .
thus , the primary has already begun to leave the main sequence , while the secondary is still ensconced within it .
the metallic - line status of the primary is not in doubt @xcite , while that of the secondary remains uncertain , although the abundances of @xcite indicate possible metallicism .
@xcite published the first spectroscopic orbit .
more recent , but now quite old orbits were published by @xcite and @xcite .
kondo s orbit has the advantages that it sampled the primary and secondary radial velocity curves more fully than popper s and that it has a single systemic velocity , while popper determined different systemic velocities for the primary and secondary .
photoelectric light curves of rr lyn have been reported by @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite .
the last of these studies used precise photometry in the @xmath25 and @xmath26 bandpasses @xcite , which are based on but somewhat different from the johnson @xmath27 and @xmath26 photometric bandpasses .
@xcite showed that the primary and secondary eclipse depths in @xmath4 are @xmath28 and @xmath29 , respectively , the fractional luminosities , also in @xmath4 , are @xmath30 , @xmath31 , and the orbital inclination is @xmath32 . both @xcite and
@xcite needed the addition of third light to solve the light curves , while @xcite , who also did a photometric analysis , found no requirement for third light .
this last result is supported by @xcite , who demonstrated that their observations in all filters are fitted by the same geometry and that their model matches the observations without any need to invoke third light . in a later paper , however , @xcite presented new evidence for a third body , based _ not _ on an analysis of the light curve , but on the times of the eclipse minima .
the presence of the third star , which @xcite suggested is a very low - mass , low - luminosity object that contributes an insignificant amount of light to the system , is inferred from quasi - periodic oscillations in the times of primary and secondary minima .
they proposed an extemely eccentric orbit ( @xmath33 ) with a rather long orbital period of @xmath34 years for it .
the 64-year timespan of the published photoelectric minima amounts to only one - and - a - half orbital periods , however , so the case for the third body can not yet be regarded as conclusive .
the sb2 system 12 boo is the only one in our trio that already has a determination of its three - dimensional orbit @xcite .
the two components have an orbital period of 9.60 days and are of very similar mass , having a secondary to primary mass ratio of 0.97 .
the system s combined spectral type is f8 iv @xcite or f8 v @xcite .
@xcite found that the primary is leaving the main sequence , and with @xmath35 k it is now marginally _ cooler _ than the secondary ( @xmath36 k ) .
@xcite was the first to determine its spectroscopic orbit .
newer orbital elements have been published by @xcite and @xcite .
@xcite presented the newest set of radial velocities as well as interferometric observations .
details for these more recent spectroscopic orbits , including the present investigation , are summarised in table 2 .
prior to its publication , we were unaware of the new investigation of 12 boo by @xcite .
thus , in spite of the element of ( unintentional ) redundancy here , our own study of 12 boo , based on radial velocities acquired from 2002 to 2005 , is still of interest because our velocities turn out to be significantly more precise , allowing us to determine improved spectroscopic orbital elements .
compared to rr lyn and 12 boo , the previous work on hr 6169 has been quite modest .
this binary has a combined spectral type of a2 v @xcite or a1 iv @xcite .
the first and , to date , only spectroscopic orbit is that of @xcite , which was based on radial velocities from blue photographic spectrograms obtained at the cassegrain focus of the 1.8 m telescope at the dominion astrophysical observatory ( dao ) .
this sb2 system has an orbit with a period of 10.56 days and a moderate eccentricity , @xmath37 .
our observations were collected from 2002 april through 2005 october at the mcdonald observatory and kpno , with the majority of spectra of all three program stars obtained at mcdonald .
the mcdonald observations were acquired with the 2.1 m telescope , the sandiford cassegrain echelle spectrograph @xcite , and a reticon ccd with 27@xmath38m@xmath39 pixels arranged in a 1200@xmath40400 pixel format .
the spectrograms cover the wavelength range 5700 to 7000 and have a resolving power of 60,000 .
the collapsed one - dimensional stellar spectra have a representative signal - to - noise ratio of @xmath41300 .
each stellar observation was followed by an observation of a thorium argon comparison spectrum .
the observations at kpno were obtained with the coud feed telescope , coud spectrograph , and a ti ccd detector .
all the spectrograms were centered at 6430 , cover a wavelength range of about 80 , and have a resolution of 0.21 or a resolving power of just over 30,000 .
the spectrograms typicaly have signal - to - noise ratios of 200 - 250 .
the data were processed and wavelength - calibrated in a conventional manner with the iraf package of programs .
the spectra of the three systems are double - lined and , at most orbital phases , the secondary lines are well separated from their primary counterparts . in rr
lyn there are numerous lines of both the primary and secondary with the secondary lines being distinctly weaker , while in 12 boo the primary and secondary lines are also numerous and are of roughly similar strength . in hr 6169
the primary is represented by only a few lines from ionised species , while the secondary has numerous lines , mostly from neutral species , which are also sharper than those of the primary . in this system , therefore , at the yellow and red wavelengths covered by our observations the secondary lines are much _ better _ for velocity measurement than those of the primary .
we now outline the procedures used to measure the mcdonald and kpno radial velocities .
for the mcdonald velocities we proceeded as follows : the wavelengths of well - defined primary and secondary lines were measured by fitting gaussian profiles with the splot routine of iraf , the wavelength differences between the measured wavelengths and rest wavelengths @xcite of the lines provided the topocentric radial velocities , telluric o@xmath42 lines near 6300 ( @xmath43 band ) and 6900 ( b band ) were measured in the same way so as to determine the offset between the stellar spectrum and its associated thorium
argon comparison spectrum , the stellar topocentric velocities were then corrected by subtracting from them the telluric line offset in velocity form , and , finally , the heliocentric correction led to the heliocentric radial velocities .
the mcdonald velocities are , thus , absolute velocities .
the kpno radial velocities were determined with the iraf cross - correlation program fxcor @xcite .
the iau radial velocity standard stars @xmath44 vir , hr 5694 , and hr 7560 , which have late - f spectral classes , were used as cross - correlation reference stars .
their velocities of 4.4 , 54.4 , and 0.0 km s@xmath13 , respectively , were adopted from @xcite . in the kpno spectra , lines in the wavelength region redward of 6445 are not particularly suitable for measurement because most features are blends , and there are a number of modest strength water vapor lines .
thus , the radial velocities were determined from lines in the region 6385 to 6445 .
unfortunately , this 60 portion of the spectrum is so small that a mismatch , caused by the varying strength of line blends , between the spectral type of the program star and that of the cross - correlation standard can significantly affect the measured velocity .
thus , instead of cross - correlating this entire 60 wavelength region , only the wavelength regions around the strongest and least - blended lines were cross - correlated . for our stars with components of late - a or f spectral type
the list includes five lines , the fe i lines at 6394 , 6412 , 6421 , and 6431 plus the ca i line at 6439 .
the weakness of those neutral lines in the spectra of early - a stars means that the only measurable lines in their kpno spectrograms are the two fe ii lines at 6417 and 6433 , which can provide good velocities if the lines are narrow enough .
each cross - corrrelation profile was fitted with a gaussian function . because different techniques were used to measure the mcdonald and kpno radial velocities
, the two velocity systems may have slightly different zero points .
we will examine this possibility in 6 .
table 3 gives the calendar dates , heliocentric julian dates and heliocentric radial velocities for the mcdonald and kpno observations .
@xcite identified several luminosity - sensitive and temperature - sensitive line ratios in the 6430 - 6465 region .
they employed those critical line ratios and the general appearance of the spectrum as spectral - type criteria .
however , for stars that are hotter than early - g spectral class , the line ratios in that wavelength region have little sensitivity to luminosity .
thus , for the a and f stars of our three systems , we have used the entire 80 spectral region of our kpno observations to estimate just the spectral classes of the individual components . in the 6430 region
most of the strongest features are fe i lines with the addition of three fe ii and three ca i lines .
the luminosity class may be determined by computing the absolute visual magnitude with the _ hipparcos _ parallax and comparing that magnitude to evolutionary tracks or a table of canonical values for giants and dwarfs .
spectra of our three binaries were compared with the spectra of a number of a and f type stars primarily from the lists of @xcite and @xcite .
the reference - star spectra were obtained at kpno with the same telescope , spectrograph , and dectector as our binary - star spectra . to facilitate a comparison ,
the spectra of the reference stars were rotationally broadened and shifted in radial velocity with a computer program developed by @xcite and @xcite .
this spectrum addition enables us to determine a continuum intensity ratio of the binary components at 6430 , a wavelength that is about 0.6 of the way between the central wavelengths of the johnson @xmath4 and @xmath26 bandpasses .
if the two stars have very similar spectral types , this intensity ratio is also the luminosity ratio and , thus , can be converted directly into a magnitude difference . however , if the lines of the secondary are intrinsically stronger than those of the primary , as would be the case , for example , if the components were main sequence stars of rather different spectral types , then the continuum intensity ratio results in a minimum magnitude difference .
we have determined projected rotational velocities from our red - wavelength kpno spectra with the procedure of @xcite . for each star
the full width at half - maximum of several metal lines in the 6430 region was measured and the results averaged .
an instrumental broadening of 0.21 was removed from the measured broadening by taking the square root of the difference between the squares of measurements of the stellar and comparison lines , resulting in the intrinsic broadening .
the calibration polynomial of @xcite was used to convert this broadening in angstroms into a total line broadening in kilometers per second . for a - type stars this line broadening corresponds to the _ v _ sin _ i _ value . for f - type stars ,
macroturbulent broadening has been taken into account .
following @xcite , for early - f stars a macroturbulence of 5 km s@xmath13 was adopted and removed , while for mid - f and late - f stars values of 4 and 3 km s@xmath13 , respectively , were used .
all three systems have eccentric orbits , so we obtained simultaneous solutions of the primary and secondary radial velocities by the lehmann filhes method to determine the orbits .
a preliminary to the orbit calculation was the assignment of suitable weights for the various velocities .
typically the primary and secondary spectra are of different quality because the components can differ , sometimes markedly , as to strength of lines , line width , and number of available lines , resulting in primary and secondary velocities that are of different weight .
also , the mcdonald velocities , because of the higher resolution by a factor of two and the substantially greater wavelength coverage of the mcdonald spectra , resulting in a larger number of available lines , are somewhat more precise than the kpno velocities and therefore have higher weight . for each system
there are , thus , four different sets of velocity , each with its own weight . these weights , which are given in table 3 , were chosen so as to approximately equalize the products of the weights and the mean square velocity residuals for the different sets of velocity .
once the weights were assigned , the velocities were then solved to determine the spectroscopic orbits .
the velocity residuals ( table 3 ) for the orbital solutions , given to two decimal places to facilitate our examination , allow a straightforward check on the consistency of the radial velocities from the two observatories .
any systematic difference between the mcdonald and kpno velocities will manifest itself as a corresponding difference between the average residuals , calculated with regard to sign , for the two types of velocity , while if they are consistent then their average residuals , apart from statistical fluctuations , will be identical and equal to zero .
a comparison of the residuals for the mcdonald and kpno radial velocities is given in table 4 .
although the differences are all smaller than or similar to their estimated errors , they all have the same sign , thus suggesting an offset of order 0.1 0.2 km s@xmath13 between the mcdonald and kpno velocities .
we attach the most importance , however , to the primaries of rr lyn and 12 boo because of the six stars in our three systems these two have the most well - determined radial velocities , and in both cases there is no evidence of an offset .
this simple check , therefore , indicates the possible presence of an offset of 0.1 0.2 km s@xmath13 between the mcdonald and kpno velocities , but the results are inconclusive . in the absence of clear evidence of an offset
, we decided not to adjust either set of velocities .
we now look at the results for the individual systems .
table 5 gives the spectroscopic orbital elements of rr lyn obtained from the solution of our radial velocities .
for comparison , the elements of @xcite and the photometrically - based elements of @xcite are also listed .
figure [ fig1 ] shows our radial velocities along with the calculated radial - velocity curves for our orbital elements .
although the photometrically determined orbital period is more precise than our spectroscopically measured value , the difference between the two 10-day periods corresponds to less than 1 second .
we have retained the spectroscopic period for the determination of our spectroscopic orbit , since adopting the photometric period does not change the orbital elements . examining the solutions in table 5 , one sees that to within the uncertainties all three investigations give the same eccentricity of 0.08 .
this agreement is especially pleasing in the case of @xcite because their photometric determination of the eccentricity is completely independent of our spectroscopic one .
we note that our determination of @xmath45 ( 1794 @xmath15 06 ) is the first accurate measurement of this element and that to within its uncertainty , it is @xmath46 , which means the major axis of the true orbit and the line of nodes coincide . also of interest , we find that our and kondo s determinations of @xmath47 and @xmath48 are the same to within the uncertainties .
we will compare the two @xmath49-velocity determinations shortly .
the minimum masses are also in agreement , with our uncertainties being about 10 times smaller than kondo s .
as we have seen , rr lyn is also a detached eclipsing binary so the photometric and spectroscopic orbital elements can be combined to provide the sizes and masses of the components as well as the linear separation between the primary and secondary .
this is done in table 6 .
the new mass determinations of @xmath50 m@xmath7 and @xmath51 m@xmath7 are extremely precise , having uncertainties of only 0.4% and 0.3% , respectively .
although our new determinations of the masses and radii of the primary and secondary are more precise than those of @xcite , our values differ only slightly from theirs .
the new primary and secondary masses are just 0.037m@xmath7 and 0.017m@xmath7 larger , respectively , than theirs , while the new primary and secondary radii differ from theirs by 0.00 r@xmath7 and 0.01 r@xmath7 , respectively .
we will not rediscuss , therefore , the evolutionary state of rr lyn because our new results would have little impact on the conclusions of @xcite in this regard .
instead , we note that insofar as our new masses and radii confirm theirs , so we support their determinations of other derived quantities . in particular we confirm their photometric estimate of the system s distance
, 73.5 @xmath15 2.8 pc , and its age , @xmath52 billion years .
we now look at the question of the third body in the system .
as already mentioned , @xcite proposed the presence of a third star in an extremely eccentric orbit ( @xmath53 ) with a period of 39.7 years as an explanation of variations in the times of minima of the primary and secondary eclipses .
the proposed star is of low mass , estimated to be 0.10m@xmath7 if its orbit is coplanar with that of the eclipsing pair .
thus , it would make a negligible contribution to the spectrum , but its presence would cause a regular variation of the systemic velocity of the eclipsing pair as the center - of - mass of the eclipsing pair orbits the center - of - mass of the entire system . in view of the long interval between the observations of @xcite and ours ,
it is natural to compare kondo s systemic velocity with ours to see if there is a variation .
the difference between our and kondo s @xmath49-velocities is insignificant . from table 5
we see that it is @xmath54 with the estimated uncertainty being set by the uncertainty in kondo s result .
the observations thus set an upper limit of @xmath55 km s@xmath13 on any difference between the two @xmath49-velocities .
what is the predicted difference that would be caused by the proposed third star ? to answer this question we note that we do _ not _ need to know the ( unknown ) systemic velocity of the entire system ; calculation of the _ orbital motion _
alone , of the center of mass of the eclipsing pair , is sufficient to provide the predicted @xmath49-velocity _ difference _ that we want .
@xcite have provided estimates of all the orbital elements needed to calculate the predicted variation of the @xmath49-velocity of the eclipsing pair , with the exception of @xmath56 , and , from the information they give , one can infer @xmath57 km s@xmath13 .
we can thus calculate the predicted variation of the @xmath49-velocity of the eclipsing pair due to its motion in the proposed 39.7-year orbit , and this is shown in figure [ fig2 ] .
it is apparent from that figure that the predicted difference of @xmath49-velocities is tiny , only @xmath58 km s@xmath13 .
the smallness of the difference results from the extreme eccentricity of the proposed orbit , so the velocity variation outside of periastron passage is slight , and because , by chance , kondo s observations and ours are separated by almost exactly one orbit and thus are at the same phase . our null result ,
therefore , is consistent with the predicted minute change in the @xmath49-velocity of the eclipsing pair of stars caused by the presence of the proposed low - mass third star .
of course , the result is also consistent with the absence of such a body , and so we are unable to either confirm or deny its existence . as can be seen in figure [ fig2 ] , the extreme eccentricity of the 39.7-year orbit means that usually the @xmath49-velocity of the eclipsing pair changes very gradually .
so , during most of the orbit , radial velocities are almost impervious to the presence or absence of the third body .
near periastron it is a different story , however , as the third star swoops toward the eclipsing pair , and their @xmath49-velocity suffers an abrupt change with a total amplitude of 2.5 km s@xmath13 .
at the next periastron passage in 2028 one or two precise radial velocities will readily confirm or refute the existence of the third star . in their recent investigation of the 12 boo system
@xcite combined their interferometric observations of the visual orbit and complementary , new radial velocities to make an accurate determination of the system s three - dimensional orbit and the masses and radii of its components .
they then use these basic parameters to discuss the system s evolutionary status .
although our own work duplicates theirs to some extent , our radial velocities are more precise , so our results provide a useful check on the spectroscopic component of their investigation . table 7 lists the spectroscopic orbital elements from the combined interferometric and radial velocity solution of @xcite with our new radial - velocity solution .
the two sets of orbital elements are in excellent agreement , and the uncertainties of our elements are usually smaller than those of @xcite . with the exception of the period , for which our observational timespan is quite short , all our elements are improved determinations and for four of them ( @xmath59 , @xmath47 , @xmath48 , and @xmath49 ) the improvement is a factor of two .
there is also good agreement between the two @xmath49 velocities , where we find @xmath60 km s@xmath13 , while they find @xmath61 km s@xmath13 , which argues that our and their radial velocities have the same zero point .
to make the most of the radial velocities , we also obtained a combined solution of our radial velocities and theirs , making no adjustment to either set of velocities .
( the weights for our velocities in this solution are given in table 3 , while the weights for theirs were 0.1 and 0.05 for the primary and secondary , respectively . ) the elements from this combined spectroscopic solution are also listed in table 7 .
they represent an all - round improvement , with the period determination , in particular , being sharpened thanks to the longer timespan , 1987 to 2005 , of the combined observations .
figure [ fig3 ] shows our radial velocities and those of @xcite along with the calculated radial velocity curves for the combined solution of the two sets . with the help of the inclination , @xmath62 , from the orbit of @xcite
we determine new values of the stellar masses and the semi - major axis of the relative orbit .
we find @xmath63m@xmath7 , @xmath64m@xmath7 , and @xmath65 gm . these results certainly confirm those of @xcite , which are @xmath66m@xmath7 , @xmath67m@xmath7 , but are more precise .
finally we look at the orbital parallax , @xmath68 , and distance of the system .
the orbital parallax is simply @xmath69 ( arcsec)/@xmath69 ( au ) where @xmath69 denotes both the angular and linear sizes , respectively , of the true orbit .
the angular size of the orbit , @xmath70 mas , of course , comes from the visual - orbit determination @xcite .
we note , however , that the uncertainty in the angular size of the orbit , which is 0.5% and is much bigger than the uncertainties in the determinations of the linear size of the orbit ( 0.1% for theirs and 0.06% for ours ) , dominates the uncertainty in the orbital parallax .
thus , although we have improved the determination of the linear size of the orbit , there are no corresponding improvements in the orbital parallax or distance of 12 boo , so we content ourselves with restating the results of @xcite @xmath71mas and a distance to the system of @xmath72pc .
table 8 lists the orbital elements of hr 6169 , derived from the solution of our radial velocities , as well as the elements obtained by @xcite . in figure [ fig4 ] our radial velocities and those of @xcite are compared with the radial velocity curves calculated from our elements alone . for hr 6169 , in the yellow and red region of the spectrum where we measured our radial velocities , the only useful lines representing the primary are the two siii lines at 6347 and 6371 and a smattering of very weak feii lines , while the secondary is represented by lines of neutral and ionised species that are both more numerous and sharper .
for this reason the _ secondary _ velocities are more precise than those of the primary .
it follows that the secondary velocities have much higher weight than those of the primary ( see table 3 ) , the secondary radial - velocity curve is better defined than that of the primary , and @xmath48 is better determined than @xmath47 .
comparison of our results with young s reveals some very significant discrepancies , especially for the @xmath49 velocity . at first sight
the large difference of @xmath73 km s@xmath13 between our @xmath49 velocity ( @xmath74 km s@xmath13 ) and young s ( @xmath75 km s@xmath13 ) suggests the presence of an unseen third star , which must have changed the @xmath49 velocity of the spectroscopic - binary pair in the 84 years between the two measurements .
a glance at figure [ fig4 ] , however , shows there is no need to invoke a third star .
instead , a simpler explanation of the difference can be found because of a systematic error in young s @xmath49 velocity , caused by blending of the primary and secondary lines in his spectra .
@xcite remarked that in his spectra with smaller primary - secondary velocity separations the primary lines and their secondary counterparts were blended , so that he was only able to measure a single blend velocity , which he adopted as the primary velocity .
inspection of figure [ fig4 ] shows that these blended primary velocities cluster around the smaller velocity extremum associated with the nodal passage near apastron .
they mostly fall below the @xmath49 velocity and , being dragged upwards and towards it , are too positive and , not being balanced by the few velocities that are dragged downwards , their presence in young s orbit solution made his @xmath49 velocity too positive .
similar considerations account for his semi - amplitude of the primary being too small , @xmath76 km s@xmath13 compared with our value of @xmath77 km s@xmath13 .
unlike our other two systems , rr lyn , which is an eclipsing system , and 12 boo , for which interferometric observations have been used to determine a visual orbit , hr 6169 has no direct determination of its orbital inclination .
thus , at present we can only compute the minimum masses of its two components , which are 2.20 @xmath15 0.01 and 1.64 @xmath15 0.02 m@xmath16 for the primary and secondary , respectively .
@xcite classified the combined spectrum of rr lyn as a3/a8/a6 , based on its ca ii k , hydrogen balmer , and metal lines , respectively , providing a general starting point for our determination .
the rapid rotation of most a - type stars plus a variety of abundance peculiarities make it difficult to identify a significant number of slowly rotating reference stars for that spectral class . despite the limited choices , identified primarily from the work of @xcite
, we obtained a reasonable fit to the spectrum of rr lyn with hr 3354 ( spectral classes of a3/a5/a7 = calcium / hydrogen / metals @xcite ) for the primary plus hr 1613 ( spectral type of a9 v @xcite and [ fe / h ] @xmath78 0.0 @xcite ) for the secondary .
while the iron lines of the primary are fitted relatively well by hr 3354 , the calcium lines of this reference star are too weak .
our results for the stellar components , however , are similar to those of @xcite , who determined spectral types of a6 iv plus f0 v from their @xmath23 photometry and a comparison with evolutionary tracks .
the continuum intensity ratio of our fit is 0.236 , which corresponds to a magnitude difference of 1.6 .
this is in rough agreement with the results of @xcite , who used the @xmath79 photometric system @xcite and found a @xmath4-band luminosity ratio of 0.276 , which corresponds to a magnitude difference of 1.40 .
our magnitude difference is consistent with the luminosity classes assigned by @xcite .
thus , we adopt their estimated spectral types . guided by previous spectral classifications , we used hr 7560 ( f8 v @xcite and mean [ fe / h ] = 0.06 @xcite ) as a proxy for both components , but found the lines of the resulting composite spectrum fit to be too strong .
however , with hr 5694 ( f8 iv - v @xcite and mean [ fe / h ] = @xmath180.10 @xcite ) used for both components we found an excellent fit to the spectrum of 12 boo .
the continuum intensity ratio of this fit is 0.637 . because the spectral classes of the two stars are essentially identical , this value is also the luminosity ratio at 6430 , a wavelength that is about 0.6 of the way between the center of the johnson @xmath4 and @xmath26 bandpasses .
the intensity ratio produces a magnitude difference of 0.5 with an estimated uncertainty of 0.1 .
such a difference is in accord with the more precise @xmath80@xmath4 magnitude of 0.48 determined by @xcite .
the slightly subsolar iron abundance is also in agreement with the results of @xcite and @xcite , who found [ fe / h ] = @xmath180.03 @xmath15 0.09 and @xmath180.1 @xmath15 0.1 , respectively . from dao photographic plates ,
@xcite determined magnitude differences for 82 spectroscopic binaries , including hr 6169 .
he described the spectrum of this system as consisting of two narrow - lined early - a stars and concluded that both components were dwarfs .
his low - weight magnitude difference in the blue region of the spectrum is 0.7 @xmath15 0.4 . unlike our results for 12
boo and rr lyn we have had difficulty finding a good combination of reference stars to represent the spectrum hr 6169 . given the a spectral class of the components , the lines of both stars are quite weak in the 6430 region with all but one of the lines being less than 5% deep in the combined spectrum .
the primary component has the stronger fe ii lines and weaker fe i lines and so is earlier in spectral class . from the metal lines our best estimates of those spectral classes
are a1 for the primary and a7 for the secondary with a continuum intensity ratio in the 6430 region that corresponds to a minimum magnitude difference of @xmath411 .
alternatively , the spectral types may be estimated from the colors of the components .
guided by the above results , we found that the @xmath81 colors for stars of spectral types a1 v and a5 v , taken from table ii of @xcite , plus an adopted @xmath4 magnitude difference of 0.9 result in the observed @xmath81 = 0.06 from the _ hipparcos _ satellite @xcite .
we have adopted those spectral types and colors in our additional analyses .
the two main theories of orbital circularization and rotational synchronization ( e.g. ; @xcite ) disagree significantly on absolute time scales but do agree that synchronization should occur first . from surveys of b and
a stars @xcite concluded that synchronization occurs faster than circularization , confirming for early - type stars the theoretical results .
the three systems discussed here have orbital periods between 9.6 and 10.6 days and eccentric rather than circular orbits .
since two of the three systems contain a - type stars , the observed eccentricities of their orbits are not surprising .
@xcite examined 62 spectroscopic binaries with a - type primaries and periods less than 100 days .
they concluded that all systems with orbital periods @xmath82 3 days have circular or nearly circular orbits .
they also found that many binaries with periods in the range of 3 to 10 days have circular orbits , while all those with periods greater than 10 days have eccentric orbits .
thus , the eccentric orbits of rr lyn and hr 6169 appear to be typical of a - type systems with periods near 10 days .
@xcite has shown that in an eccentric orbit a star s rotational angular velocity will tend to sychronize with that of the orbital motion at periastron , a condition called pseudosynchronous rotation . with equation ( 42 ) of @xcite
we calculated pseudosynchronous periods for the three systems .
for rr lyn our _ v _ sin _ i _ values are 14.6 @xmath15 1 and 11.3 @xmath15 2 km s@xmath13 for its primary and secondary , respectively .
the uncertainties are estimated , with that for the secondary being larger because of the weakness of its lines .
we assume that the orbital and rotational axes are parallel , so the rotational inclination is 874 .
since it is so close to 90 , we adopt our _ v _ sin _ i _ values as the equatorial rotational velocities of the components . from table 6
the radii are 2.57 and 1.59 r@xmath16 for the primary and secondary , respectively .
those values , combined with the pseudosynchronous period of 9.59 days , lead to rotational velocities of 13.6 and 8.4 km s@xmath13 .
thus , the rotation of the primary is consistent with its pseudosynchronous value , while the secondary appears to be rotating slightly faster than pseudosynchronous .
our projected rotational velocities for 12 boo , 13.0 @xmath15 1 and 10.3 @xmath15 1 km s@xmath13 for its primary and secondary , respectively , are in good agreement with those determined by @xcite and @xcite .
again we assume that the orbital and rotational axes are parallel , so the rotational inclination is 108 .
thus , the observed equatorial rotational velocities become 13.7 and 10.8 km s@xmath13 .
the radii of the two components @xcite and the pseudosynchronous period of 7.84 days , lead to predicted rotational velocities of 15.9 and 12.0 km s@xmath13 .
thus , the primary is rotating slightly slower than its predicted velocity , while the secondary may well be rotating pseudosynchronously . to determine if the components of hr 6169 are pseudosynchronously rotating we must first estimate their radii . from the _ hipparcos _ catalog @xcite the @xmath4 magnitude and @xmath81 color of the hr 6169 system are 6.42 and 0.062 , respectively .
the _ hipparcos _
parallax of 6.17 @xmath15 0.087 ( mas ) @xcite corresponds to a distance of 162 @xmath15 24 pc .
although at such a distance there may be a modest amount of interstellar reddening , the color of the system is consistent with the spectral type of the primary , and so we have assumed no interstellar reddening . as a result , the parallax , the @xmath4 magnitude , and the adopted @xmath4 magnitude difference of 0.9 ( 7.3 ) were combined to obtain absolute magnitudes @xmath83 = 0.8 @xmath15 0.3 mag and @xmath83 = 1.7 @xmath15 0.3 mag for primary and secondary , respectively .
a @xmath81 color of 0.03 for the primary and a @xmath81 of 0.14 for the secondary @xcite were adopted and then used in conjunction with table 3 of @xcite , to obtain the bolometric corrections and effective temperatures of the two components .
the resulting luminosities of the primary and secondary are @xmath84 = 43 @xmath15 12 @xmath85 and @xmath86 = 17 @xmath15 5 @xmath85 , respectively , while the radii are @xmath87 = 2.6 @xmath15 0.4 @xmath88 and @xmath89 = 2.1 @xmath15 0.3 @xmath88 , respectively .
the uncertainties in the computed quantities are dominated by the parallax and magnitude difference uncertainties plus , to a lesser extent , the effective temperature uncertainty , which is estimated to be @xmath15200 k. because the orbit of hr 6169 has a moderately large eccentricity of 0.414 , the pseudosynchronous period of 4.95 days is less than half of the orbital period . with that period and the above radii
, we obtain pseudosynchronous rotational velocities of 26.6 and 21.5 km s@xmath13 for the primary and secondary , respectively .
we have determined _ v _ sin _ i _ values of 32 @xmath15 5 and 18 @xmath15 2 km s@xmath13 for the primary and secondary , where the uncertainties are estimated .
the minimum masses of the components are rather large , suggesting a relatively high orbital inclination . a comparison with canonical values of absolute magnitudes and masses for dwarfs of the appropriate spectral types @xcite suggests an inclination of about 70 .
adopting this value , assuming , as has been done for the other two systems , that the rotational inclination has the same value , produces equatorial velocities of 34 and 19 km s@xmath13 .
thus , the primary appears to be rotating slightly faster than its pseudosynchronous velocity , while the secondary may be rotating pseudosynchronously .
we have determined new spectroscopic orbits for the bright sb2 systems rr lyn , 12 boo , and hr 6169 .
the accuracies of the minimum masses ( @xmath2 and @xmath3 ) range from 0.13% for the secondary of 12 boo to 0.9% for the secondary of hr 6169 , while the accuracies of the linear sizes of the relative orbit ( @xmath90 ) range from 0.05% for 12 boo to 0.25% for hr 6169 .
these results show our radial velocities provide well - determined spectroscopic orbits . which do justice to interferometric measurements of 12 boo @xcite and
, we expect , will also do justice to prospective interferometric measurements of rr lyn , hr 6169 , and other systems in our program . for rr lyn , an eclipsing binary with a well - determined orbital inclination ,
we have determined accurate new masses and radii for its components .
the semi - major axis of the relative orbit , @xmath91r@xmath92 , plus the distance to the system , @xmath93 pc @xcite , lead to a predicted angular size @xmath94 mas for the true orbit and , because @xmath45 ( @xmath95 ) is @xmath96 to within its measurement error so the semi - major axis lies across the line - of - sight , this will also be the @xmath69 of the apparent orbit .
we find that the expected effect of the unseen third star proposed by @xcite on our and kondo s ( 1976 ) radial velocities is so slight as to be well below the threshold of our measurement errors . we have determined a new spectroscopic orbit for 12 boo , which confirms , and
is more precise than , that determined by @xcite as part of their measurement of the three - dimensional orbit of this system .
our investigation of hr 6169 corrects systematic errors in young s ( 1920 ) orbit and leads to significant revisions of the minimum masses and @xmath97 . at the distance of hr 6169 , @xmath98pc ( perryman et al .
1997 ) , the @xmath90 of 22.05 @xmath15 0.05 gm corresponds to an angular separation of 0.91mas . in conclusion
we find that radial velocities observed with small and medium - sized telescopes and measured by traditional methods provide a suitable spectroscopic contribution to the combination of measurements required for determination of three - dimensional orbits .
we thank eshwar reddy and chris sneden for some helpful tips and david doss for his patient guidance , which was essential for the successful operation of the 2.1-m telescope at mcdonald and its instrumentation .
we also thank richard green , former director of kpno , for continuing to make the coud feed telescope available .
we appreciate daryl willmarth s invaluable assistance with the kpno coud feed telescope and our observations .
this research at tennessee state university was supported in part by nasa grant ncc5 - 511 and nsf grant hrd-9706268 .
matthews , l. d. , & mathieu , r. d. 1992 , in asp conf .
32 , complimentary approaches to double and multiple star research , iau colloquium 135 , ed .
h. a. mcalister & w. i. hartkopf ( san francisco : asp ) , 244 lcrccccrc rr lyn & 2291 & 44691 & a3/a8/a6 & 5.53 & 0.238 & 12.01 & 9.95 & 0.08 + 12 boo & 5304 & 123999 & f8iv & 4.82 & 0.541 & 27.27 & 9.60 & 0.19 + ... & 6169 & 149632 & a2v & 6.42 & 0.062 & 06.17 & 10.56 & 0.41 + lccc abt & levy 1976 & 1966 1971 & 20 & 1.3 + de medeiros & udry 1999 & 1987 1992 & 12 & 0.90 + boden et al .
2005 & 1987 2001 & 49 & 0.39 + this paper ( mcdonald and kpno ) & 2002 2005 & 24 & 0.14 + lrrrrrrrrr + 2003 apr 22 & mcd & 52,751.635 & 0.3781 & 33.9 & @xmath99 & 1.000 & 0.100 & @xmath100 & 0.16 + 2004 feb 07 & mcd & 53,042.843 & 0.6598 & 25.3 & @xmath101 & 1.000 & 0.100 & 0.03 & @xmath102 + 2004 feb 08 & mcd & 53,043.803 & 0.7563 & @xmath103 & & 0.000 & & @xmath104 & + 2004 feb 09 & mcd & 53,044.812 & 0.8577 & @xmath105 & 36.5 & 1.000 & 0.100 & 0.11 & @xmath106 + 2004 mar 10 & mcd & 53,074.760 & 0.8691 & @xmath107 & 43.0 & 1.000 & 0.100 & 0.03 & 0.06 + 2004 mar 11 & mcd & 53,075.734 & 0.9670 & @xmath108 & 75.4 & 1.000 & 0.100 & @xmath109 & @xmath110 + 2004 apr 13 & mcd & 53,108.648 & 0.2766 & 2.9 & @xmath111 & 1.000 & 0.100 & 0.12 & @xmath112 + 2004 apr 15 & mcd & 53,110.647 & 0.4776 & 47.8 & @xmath113 & 1.000 & 0.100 & @xmath114 & @xmath106 + 2004 apr 24 & kp & 53,119.647 & 0.3826 & 35.5 & @xmath115 & 0.500 & 0.050 & 0.44 & @xmath116 + 2004 sep 25 & kp & 53,274.019 & 0.9050 & @xmath117 & 58.8 & 0.500 & 0.050 & @xmath118 & 0.21 + 2004 sep 28 & kp & 53,276.991 & 0.2039 & @xmath119 & 6.3 & 0.500 & 0.050 & @xmath120 & @xmath121 + 2004 nov 25 & mcd & 53,334.893 & 0.0260 & @xmath122 & 76.6 & 1.000 & 0.100 & 0.10 & @xmath123 + 2004 dec 03 & mcd & 53,342.913 & 0.8325 & @xmath124 & 24.6 & 1.000 & 0.100 & @xmath125 & 0.15 + 2005 jan 29 & mcd & 53,399.846 & 0.5572 & 45.6 & @xmath126 & 1.000 & 0.100 & 0.07 & 0.40 + 2005 apr 28 & mcd & 53,488.717 & 0.4934 & 48.3 & @xmath127 & 1.000 & 0.100 & @xmath128 & 0.01 + 2005 apr 29 & mcd & 53,489.670 & 0.5892 & 41.1 & @xmath129 & 1.000 & 0.100 & @xmath118 & 0.31 + 2005 apr 30 & kp & 53,490.636 & 0.6863 & 17.7 & @xmath130 & 0.500 & 0.050 & 0.58 & 0.59 + 2005 sep 21 & kp & 53,634.874 & 0.1898 & @xmath131 & 13.6 & 0.500 & 0.050 & @xmath132 & @xmath133 + 2005 oct 18 & mcd & 53,662.011 & 0.9185 & @xmath134 & 64.1 & 1.000 & 0.100 & 0.13 & 0.58 + 2005 oct 20 & mcd & 53,663.896 & 0.1080 & @xmath135 & 54.9 & 1.000 & 0.100 & 0.10 & 0.38 + 2005 oct 20 & mcd & 53,663.990 & 0.1175 & @xmath136 & 51.1 & 1.000 & 0.100 & 0.04 & 0.61 + + 2002 apr 28 & mcd & 52,392.711 & 0.1964 & 76.7 & @xmath137 & 1.000 & 0.500 & @xmath138 & @xmath118 + 2002 apr 29 & mcd & 52,393.750 & 0.3046 & 51.3 & @xmath139 & 1.000 & 0.500 & @xmath125 & @xmath140 + 2003 mar 21 & mcd & 52,719.792 & 0.2512 & 65.6 & @xmath141 & 1.000 & 0.500 & @xmath142 & @xmath143 + 2003 apr 20 & mcd & 52,749.700 & 0.3651 & 33.7 & @xmath144 & 1.000 & 0.500 & 0.06 & 0.10 + 2003 apr 20 & mcd & 52,749.892 & 0.3851 & 27.6 & @xmath145 & 1.000 & 0.500 & 0.00 & 0.18 + 2003 apr 21 & mcd & 52,750.903 & 0.4904 & @xmath146 & 23.3 & 1.000 & 0.500 & @xmath147 & 0.27 + 2003 sep 06 & mcd & 52,888.618 & 0.8289 & @xmath148 & 69.2 & 1.000 & 0.500 & @xmath147 & 0.12 + 2003 sep 07 & mcd & 52,889.586 & 0.9297 & @xmath149 & 29.8 & 1.000 & 0.500 & 0.10 & @xmath150 + 2003 sep 08 & mcd & 52,890.584 & 0.0336 & 52.0 & @xmath151 & 1.000 & 0.500 & 0.09 & @xmath100 + 2004 feb 08 & mcd & 53,043.967 & 0.0034 & 35.0 & @xmath152 & 1.000 & 0.500 & 0.07 & 0.14 + 2004 feb 09 & mcd & 53,044.932 & 0.1039 & 76.7 & @xmath153 & 1.000 & 0.500 & @xmath154 & 0.16 + 2004 apr 13 & mcd & 53,108.880 & 0.7620 & @xmath155 & 75.0 & 1.000 & 0.500 & @xmath142 & 0.00 + 2004 apr 14 & mcd & 53,109.858 & 0.8638 & @xmath156 & 59.9 & 1.000 & 0.500 & 0.15 & @xmath116 + 2004 apr 26 & kp & 53,121.792 & 0.1063 & 77.4 & @xmath101 & 0.500 & 0.250 & 0.16 & 0.21 + 2004 jun 12 & kp & 53,168.659 & 0.9860 & 24.0 & @xmath157 & 0.500 & 0.250 & @xmath120 & 0.69 + 2004 jun 13 & kp & 53,169.752 & 0.0998 & 76.0 & @xmath158 & 0.500 & 0.250 & @xmath138 & 0.34 + 2004 sep 12 & mcd & 53,260.584 & 0.5570 & @xmath159 & 41.6 & 1.000 & 0.500 & 0.01 & 0.11 + 2004 sep 13 & mcd & 53,261.583 & 0.6610 & @xmath160 & 64.7 & 1.000 & 0.500 & 0.11 & @xmath116 + 2005
apr 27 & mcd & 53,487.876 & 0.2220 & 72.3 & @xmath161 & 1.000 & 0.500 & 0.07 & 0.16 + 2005 apr 28 & mcd & 53,488.844 & 0.3228 & 46.3 & @xmath162 & 1.000 & 0.500 & 0.03 & 0.11 + 2005 apr 29 & mcd & 53,489.708 & 0.4128 & 20.0 & 0.3 & 0.000 & 0.000 & 0.74 & 0.69 + 2005 may 01 & kp & 53,491.692 & 0.6193 & @xmath163 & 56.3 & 0.500 & 0.250 & 0.09 & @xmath143 + 2005 may 02 & kp & 53,492.672 & 0.7214 & @xmath164 & 72.9 & 0.500 & 0.250 & @xmath120 & @xmath154 + 2005 jun 11 & kp & 53,532.796 & 0.8990 & @xmath165 & 46.3 & 0.500 & 0.250 & 0.13 & 0.36 + + 2002 apr 28 & mcd & 52,392.790 & 0.2518 & @xmath166 & 20.1 & 0.100 & 1.000 & 0.67 & @xmath167 + 2002 apr 29 & mcd & 52,393.881 & 0.3551 & @xmath168 & 35.1 & 0.100 & 1.000 & @xmath169 & @xmath170 + 2003 mar 21 & mcd & 52,719.891 & 0.2289 & @xmath171 & 14.3 & 0.100 & 1.000 & @xmath172 & 0.13 + 2003 apr 20 & mcd & 52,749.868 & 0.0678 & 35.7 & @xmath173 & 0.100 & 1.000 & @xmath174 & 0.10 + 2003 apr 21 & mcd & 52,750.881 & 0.1637 & & @xmath175 & & 0.000 & & @xmath176 + 2003 sep 06 & mcd & 52,888.661 & 0.2118 & & 8.8 & & 1.000 & & 0.11 + 2003 sep 07 & mcd & 52,889.664 & 0.3068 & & 30.1 & & 1.000 & & @xmath140 + 2004 feb 09 & mcd & 53,044.975 & 0.0150 & 75.0 & @xmath177 & 0.100 & 1.000 & @xmath178 & @xmath179 + 2004 mar 10 & mcd & 53,074.983 & 0.8569 & 14.3 & @xmath101 & 0.100 & 1.000 & 1.96 & @xmath180 + 2004 apr 10 & mcd & 53,105.944 & 0.7889 & & @xmath181 & & 0.000 & & 0.76 + 2004 apr 24 & kp & 53,119.942 & 0.1146 & 0.6 & @xmath182 & 0.025 & 0.500 & @xmath183 & @xmath174 + 2004 apr 26 & kp & 53,121.925 & 0.3024 & @xmath184 & 29.6 & 0.025 & 0.500 & 0.47 & @xmath167 + 2004 jun 14 & kp & 53,170.838 & 0.9345 & 62.4 & @xmath185 & 0.025 & 0.500 & 2.09 & 0.66 + 2004 jun 15 & kp & 53,171.771 & 0.0229 & 74.0 & @xmath186 & 0.025 & 0.500 & 2.95 & @xmath187 + 2004 sep 11 & mcd & 53,259.654 & 0.3456 & @xmath188 & 34.2 & 0.100 & 1.000 & @xmath114 & @xmath110 + 2004 sep 12 & mcd & 53,260.625 & 0.4375 & @xmath168 & 38.2 & 0.100 & 1.000 & 1.26 & @xmath189 + 2004 sep 13 & mcd & 53,261.620 & 0.5318 & @xmath190 & 34.8 & 0.100 & 1.000 & 1.23 & 0.16 + 2004 sep 13 & mcd & 53,261.685 & 0.5379 & @xmath191 & 34.3 & 0.100 & 1.000 & 2.07 & 0.14 + 2005 jan 29 & mcd & 53,400.003 & 0.6369 & @xmath141 & 21.6 & 0.100 & 1.000 & @xmath192 & @xmath178 + 2005 apr 27 & mcd & 53,487.910 & 0.9619 & 75.7 & @xmath193 & 0.100 & 1.000 & 0.00 & @xmath114 + 2005 apr 28 & mcd & 53,488.899 & 0.0556 & 48.0 & @xmath194 & 0.100 & 1.000 & 1.56 & 0.20 + 2005 jun 10 & kp & 53,531.732 & 0.1119 & 6.2 & @xmath195 & 0.025 & 0.500 & 2.55 & 0.25 + 2005 jun 13 & kp & 53,534.900 & 0.4119 & @xmath190 & 38.4 & 0.025 & 0.500 & 3.79 & 0.34 + 2005 jun 14 & kp & 53,535.789 & 0.4961 & @xmath188 & 37.6 & 0.025 & 0.500 & 1.56 & 0.77 + 2005 jun 15 & kp & 53,536.754 & 0.5875 & @xmath184 & 29.6 & 0.025 & 0.500 & 0.04 & 0.43
+ rlrrc rr lyn & primary & @xmath196 ( 15 ) & @xmath197 ( 5 ) & @xmath198 + & secondary & @xmath199 ( 15 ) & @xmath200 ( 5 ) & @xmath201 + 12 boo & primary & @xmath202 ( 17 ) & @xmath203 ( 6 ) & @xmath204 + & secondary & @xmath205 ( 17 ) & @xmath206 ( 6 ) & @xmath207 + hr 6169 & primary & @xmath208 ( 13 ) & @xmath209 ( 8) & @xmath210 + & secondary & @xmath211 ( 15 ) & @xmath212 ( 8) & @xmath213 + lrrr @xmath214 ( days ) & 9.945080 & 9.9450740 & 9.945080 + & fixed & @xmath215 & @xmath216 + @xmath217 ( hjd ) & 2,438,048.97 & 2,444,988.49594 & 2,453,334.634 + & @xmath218 & @xmath219 & @xmath220 + @xmath59 & 0.081 & 0.0782 & 0.0793 + & @xmath221 & @xmath222 & @xmath222 + @xmath45 ( deg ) & 176.1 & 185 & 179.4 + & @xmath223 & @xmath224 & @xmath225 + @xmath47 ( km s@xmath13 ) & 65.87 & & 65.65 + & @xmath226 & & @xmath227 + @xmath48 ( km s@xmath13 ) & 83.1 & & 83.92 + & @xmath228 & & @xmath229 + @xmath49 ( km s@xmath13 ) & @xmath230 & & @xmath231 + & @xmath232 & & @xmath233 + @xmath2 ( m@xmath7 ) & 1.88 & & 1.921 + & @xmath234 & & @xmath235 + @xmath3 ( m@xmath7 ) & 1.49 & & 1.503 + & @xmath236 & & @xmath237 + @xmath0 ( @xmath238 km ) & & & 8.950 + & & & @xmath235 + @xmath1 ( @xmath238 km ) & & & 11.441 + & & & @xmath239 + rms residual ( km s@xmath13 ) & & & 0.11 + ( unit weight ) + lr @xmath240 ( deg ) & @xmath241 + @xmath242 & @xmath243 + @xmath244 & @xmath245 + @xmath69 ( @xmath246 ) ( r@xmath7 ) & @xmath247 + @xmath248 ( m@xmath7 ) & @xmath10 + @xmath249 ( m@xmath7 ) & @xmath11 + @xmath250 ( r@xmath7 ) & @xmath8 + @xmath251 ( r@xmath7 ) & @xmath9 + lrrr @xmath214 ( days ) & 9.6045492 & 9.604596 & 9.6045529 + & @xmath252 & @xmath253 & @xmath254 + @xmath217 ( hjd ) & 2,451,238.2729 & 2,452,400.4266 & 2,452,400.4292 + & @xmath255 & @xmath256 & @xmath257 + @xmath59 & 0.19233 & 0.19243 & 0.19268 + & @xmath258 & @xmath259 & @xmath260 + @xmath45 ( @xmath261 ) & 286.67 & 286.88 & 286.87 + & @xmath262 & @xmath263 & @xmath264 + @xmath47 ( km s@xmath13 ) & 67.302 & 67.283 & 67.286 + & @xmath265 & @xmath266 & @xmath267 + @xmath48 ( km s@xmath13 ) & 69.36 & 69.29 & 69.30 + & @xmath268 & @xmath227 & @xmath236 + @xmath49 ( km s@xmath13 ) & 9.551 & 9.588 & 9.578 + & @xmath269 & @xmath239 & @xmath270 + @xmath2 ( m@xmath7 ) & & 1.218 & 1.218 + & & @xmath271 & @xmath271 + @xmath3 ( m@xmath7 ) & & 1.183 & 1.183 + & & @xmath271 & @xmath272 + @xmath0 ( @xmath238 km ) & & 8.720 & 8.720 + & & @xmath221 & @xmath273 + @xmath1 ( @xmath238 km ) & & 8.981 & 8.981 + & & @xmath235 & @xmath274 + rms residual ( km s@xmath13 ) & 0.49 & 0.18 & 0.18 + rms residual ( km s@xmath13 ) & & 0.10 & 0.11 + lrr @xmath214 ( days ) & 10.56 & 10.559435 + & @xmath273 & @xmath275 + @xmath217 ( hjd ) & 2,422,422.236 & 2,453,171.529 + & @xmath276 & @xmath237 + @xmath59 & 0.430 & 0.4140 + & @xmath277 & @xmath278 + @xmath45 ( deg ) & 4.12 & 10.69 + & @xmath279 & @xmath280 + @xmath47 ( km s@xmath13 ) & 62.41 & 71.35 + & @xmath281 & @xmath282 + @xmath48 ( km s@xmath13 ) & 101.36 & 95.46 + & @xmath283 & @xmath284 + @xmath49 ( km s@xmath13 ) & @xmath285 & @xmath286 + & @xmath287 & @xmath288 + @xmath2 ( m@xmath7 ) & 2.19 & 2.197 + & & @xmath277 + @xmath3 ( m@xmath7 ) & 1.35 & 1.642 + & & @xmath289 + @xmath0 ( @xmath238 km ) & 8.18 & 9.431 + & & @xmath269 + @xmath1 ( @xmath238 km ) & 13.28 & 12.618 + & & @xmath290 + rms residual ( km s@xmath13 ) & 4.3 & 0.26 + ( unit weight ) + | radial velocities from the 2.1 m telescope at mcdonald observatory supplemented with radial velocities from the coud feed telescope at kpno provide new precise orbits for the double - lined spectroscopic binaries rr lyn ( a3/a8/a6 ) , 12 boo ( f8iv ) , and hr 6169 ( a2v ) .
we derive orbital dimensions ( @xmath0 and @xmath1 ) and minimum masses ( @xmath2 and @xmath3 ) with accuracies of 0.06 to 0.9% .
the three systems , which have @xmath4 magnitudes of 5.54 , 4.83 , and 6.42 , respectively , are all sufficiently bright that they are easily within the grasp of modern optical interferometers and so afford the prospect , when our spectroscopic observations are complemented by interferometric observations , of fully - determined orbits , precise masses , and distances . in the case of rr lyn , which is also a detached eclipsing binary with a well - determined orbital inclination ( @xmath5 ; khaliullin et al .
2001 ) , we are able to determine the semimajor axis of the relative orbit , @xmath6r@xmath7 , primary and secondary radii of @xmath8r@xmath7 and @xmath9r@xmath7 , respectively ; and primary and secondary masses of @xmath10m@xmath7 and @xmath11m@xmath7 , respectively .
comparison of our new systemic velocity determination , @xmath12 km s@xmath13 , with the earlier one of @xcite , @xmath14 km s@xmath13 , shows no evidence of any change in the systemic velocity in the 40 years separating the two measurements , a null result that neither confirms nor contradicts the presence of the low - mass third component proposed by @xcite .
our spectroscopic orbit of 12 boo is more precise that that of @xcite but confirms their results about this system .
our analysis of hr 6169 has produced a major improvement in its orbital elements .
the minimum masses of the primary and secondary are 2.20 @xmath15 0.01 and 1.64 @xmath15 0.02 m@xmath16 , respectively .
although all three systems have eccentric orbits , the six components of the systems are either pseudosynchronously rotating or very nearly so . |
the ringing observed in fig .
2 is a manifestation of a non - adiabatic transition through the eit resonance .
landau - zener theory deals with this kind of transitions and gives analytic prediction to the population transfer between the levels . in the case of an eit in buffer gas
the best way to describe the system is using the dressed state picture . taking the hamiltonian of the bare three levels under the rotating wave approximation where @xmath83 are the rabi frequencies of the coupling and the probe fields respectively ,
@xmath25 is a constant two photon detuning and @xmath24 is one photon detuning where in the case relevant to us is @xmath84 . in order to see the resemblance to the landau - zener case
it is instructive to change to a new basis where @xmath85 the new hamiltonian will become @xmath86 the @xmath87 matrix of levels @xmath88 and @xmath89 is a landau - zener hamiltonian . under eit conditions @xmath90 hence it is possible to diagonalize this @xmath87 matrix with two new dressed levels with eigenvalues @xmath91 . in the simple case where @xmath47 these states are
just @xmath92 and @xmath93 with @xmath94 @xcite .
this landau - zener dynamics is interrogated by the probe field , meaning that the transition element @xmath95 we are measuring in the experiment , carries the dynamics described above as depicted in fig .
[ fig : dressed](a ) . in our experiment
a phase modulation sweep in time causes a periodic crossing between the two dressed levels .
when a magnetic field is applied the system is split into three sub - systems with three levels in each on of them as discussed in the main page and in @xcite .
each one of these sub - systems behaves exactly as a single eit system with the exception of a magnetic zeeman shift @xmath32 . as a consequence the energy levels of the sub - systems @xmath97 and @xmath98
are reversed with respect to the magnetic field ( with @xmath96 while the energy levels of the sub - systems @xmath60 is degenerate up to the interaction avoided level crossing as depicted in fig .
[ fig : dressed](b ) . one interesting characterization of the landau - zener transition is the transition time .
this time can be measured by the decay time of the oscillations after the transition @xcite .
the two parameters that determines the transition properties is the coupling rabi frequency and the chirp rate defined as @xmath99 . in the case of sinusoidal phase modulation , where @xmath100 , the chirp rate at @xmath47 is @xmath101 .
it is useful to define the transition using a dimensionless parameter @xmath102 .
figure [ fig : decay ] shows the decay time , @xmath103 , as a function of @xmath104 for our experimental results ( red squares ) as well as for our simulation results ( black circles ) . the decay time is found from an exponential fit to the ringing peaks as depicted in the inset in fig .
[ fig : decay ] .
it is possible to see that in the diabatic limit ( low @xmath104 ) the decay time is nearly constant and converging towards @xmath105 , while at the adiabatic limit ( high @xmath104 ) the decay is linear with @xmath104 .
similar theoretical results for the landau - zener theory have been reported before @xcite .
decay time of the ringing at as a function of @xmath106 .
black circles - simulation , red squares - experiment .
the decay time is calculated using an exponential fit to the peaks of the ringing as shown in the inset .
green dashed line - the eit decay according to @xmath105 .
blue dash dotted line - linear fit for the adiabatic case .
simulation parameters are similar to the one in fig .
3 with variable modulation index and modulation frequency . , width=325 ] figure [ fig : broad magnetic ] shows a broad scan of magnetic field vs. time .
this scan is done in the case of two photon resonance in the absence of magnetic field .
we can distinct clearly the functional behavior of the three eit lines for @xmath68 .
the @xmath60 line is not dependent upon magnetic field thus its phase is constant with a pulse every half a cycle .
both @xmath61 lines are sinusoidally modulated with a cycle equal to @xmath107 and a phase of @xmath108 between them .
each of these two lines behave exactly like the detuning sweep of one eit line ( with no magnetic field ) under phase modulation ( see for example fig .
this feature is understandable , as applying magnetic field can be translated to detuning via the larmor frequency zeeman shift .
adding a constant detuning or constant magnetic field creates a symmetric shift of the two sinusoids until reaching a field larger than @xmath109 . in this case
the two sinusoids get separated and the constant pulse of @xmath60 disappears .
since the two sinusoids do not intersect the interference pattern disappears .
the major consequence is that measuring a constant magnetic field accurately using this method is possible only for magnetic fields with larmor frequency smaller than @xmath109 .
as mentioned in the main text , the spectrum of eit under axial magnetic field creates a splitting to three sub - levels .
this is certainly verified by the three pulses seen in fig .
4(a ) . as a complementary measurement
we also measure the steady state spectrum of the eit under variable magnetic field as can be seen in fig .
[ fig : magnetic - splitting ] .
4ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo
secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty http://steck.us/teaching[__ ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.67.033810 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.59.988 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.62.2543 [ * * , ( ) ] | a strong phase modulated coupling field leads to an amplitude modulation of a probe field in an electromagnetically induced transparency process .
time vs. detuning plots for different modulation frequencies reveals a transition between an adiabatic regime where a series of smooth pulses are created with a global phase dependent upon the detuning , and a non - adiabatic regime where a strong transient oscillating response is added to these pulses . in the extreme non - adiabatic regime , where the modulation frequency is higher than the transient decay time , a coherent interference pattern is revealed .
adding a magnetic field lifts the hyperfine level degeneracy , resulting in a separation of the original pulse to three pulses .
every pulse has now a different phase dependent upon the magnetic field causing an interference effect between the different magnetic level transients .
we explore the dynamics of the magnetic and non magnetic cases and show its resemblance to the landau - zener theory .
we also show that combining the global phase of the pulses with the transient interference allows for a wide magnetic sensing range without loosing the sensitivity of a single eit line .
electromagnetically induced transparency ( eit ) is a coherent process , where a strong coupling field creates a narrow transmission band in the probe spectrum in an otherwise fully absorptive medium @xcite .
the narrow linewidth of eit makes it suitable for applications in many fields such as extreme slow light , quantum storage devices , non linear optics and high sensitivity magnetic sensors . on the other hand
, this narrow linewidth directly limits the bandwidth of data that can be processed . a signal which has a broader bandwidth than the eit linewidth
will be absorbed spectrally , or will not be delayed in the time domain @xcite . in terms of magnetic sensing this means that although a very high sensitivity is possible using eit , it is a problem to probe with this sensitivity a broadband field .
a possible solution to this problem may arise from two directions .
one idea is to use a multimode eit system where each eit line has still a narrow bandwidth but spreading the signal across many systems allows for a broader signal .
such systems were devised spatially @xcite and spectrally @xcite for larger data capacity as well as for broadband magnetic sensing @xcite .
a different approach is to use dynamic eit where the transient response may have a much broader bandwidth than steady state eit .
the transient response of an eit media to a sudden switching @xcite as well as for ac magnetic field @xcite was explored theoretically and experimentally for various regimes . for a constant detuning
the decay of the transients is dictated by the eit linewidth , while the frequency of the transient oscillations equals the two photon detuning @xcite .
the detuning can be larger than the linewidth leading to an under - damped oscillator response . in the case of a linear sweep through the resonance the the frequency of the transient
is chirped @xcite and behaves similarly to a landau - zener transition @xcite .
transients were used also as a magnetic sensing technique to measure the earth s magnetic field with @xmath0 sensitivity @xcite . in this letter
we take both concepts of multimode eit and transient eit and combine them together . using a full mapping of the transient response as a function of the detuning we are able to show the transition from an adiabatic regime to a non - adiabatic regime .
we also show the complex interference pattern that arises when a magnetic field is applied . in this case
an interference between transients from three zeeman sub - levels is visible .
the problem of three level crossing in the context of landau - zener transitions was addressed both theoretically and experimentally @xcite .
experimentally it was shown using 2 two level system ( tls ) defects that have a similar energy gap inside a josephson junction , that interference occurs at certain phases when the junction frequency is swept @xcite . here ,
on the contrary , we have the ability to change the levels energy gap experimentally implementing the three levels landau - zener transition for variable level detuning .
moreover , we show that this interference can be useful as a high sensitivity magnetometer combined with broadband phase modulation sweep in order to achieve a wideband high sensitivity magnetometer .
we now describe the effect a phase modulated strong coupling field has upon the temporal shape of a probe pulse going through an eit media .
the coupling field can be written as follows : @xmath1 where @xmath2 is the amplitude of the coupling field , @xmath3 is the optical frequency and @xmath4 is the time dependent phase modulation . in order to describe the change in the probe field due to this modulated coupling field the full spatio - temporal maxwell - bloch equations for an eit system needs to be solved @xcite . in the case of long enough interaction media and perturbative probe intensity
the system can reach a steady state solution .
the eit susceptibility in this case has only temporal and no spatial dependence . for a susceptibility with no temporal dependence the probe transmission amplitude ,
@xmath5 is given by the convolution of the entering signal , @xmath6 , and the susceptibility , @xmath7 , hence @xmath8.$ ] in the case of a modulated field the susceptibility is time dependent , and this convolution is not valid .
a possible way of solving this problem is by taking the spectral decomposition of the susceptibility @xmath9 .
now the transmission is just @xmath10 $ ] @xcite .
we use a sinusoidal modulation , hence @xmath11 where @xmath12 is the modulation depth and @xmath13 is the modulation frequency .
the spectrum of such a modulated field can be described as a sum of bessel functions @xmath14 the spectrum of this modulation has narrow peaks separated by a frequency @xmath15 with a full modulation span of @xmath16 .
the transfer function in this case is just an infinite comb of single eit lines @xcite weighted by bessel functions : @xmath17 here @xmath18 is the two - level absorption coefficient , with @xmath19 the density of the atoms and @xmath20 is the transition dipole moment , @xmath21 is the homogeneous decay rate , @xmath22 is the decoherence rate of the two ground states , @xmath23 is the rabi frequency of the coupling field which is phase modulated , @xmath24 is the one photon detuning of the probe field and @xmath25 is the two photon detuning . in the case of the d1 line of warm @xmath26 vapor with buffer gas
the fwhm eit linewidth is @xcite @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the doppler broadening .
this linewidth is usually a few khz which is much narrower than the pressure broadened homogeneous linewidth ( @xmath29 ) and the doppler broadening ( @xmath30 ) , thus the probe two level susceptibility is effectively constant for the full modulation bandwidth as long as @xmath31 .
applying a magnetic field removes the zeeman degeneracy and the energy levels of the hyperfine levels will create a ladder according to the zeeman splitting of the two lower levels with a larmor frequency @xmath32 .
@xmath33 here is the magnetic field , @xmath34 is the bohr magneton and @xmath35 is the lande coefficient of the hyperfine level .
the eit susceptibility will be determined by the zeeman splitting with several eit peaks having a certain phase between them .
we can write the transfer function as follows : @xmath36 the experimental setup
is shown in fig .
[ fig : setup ] . for an eit @xmath37 scheme we use the hyperfine transitions of the d1 line of @xmath26 . a dfb laser locked to the @xmath38 transition
is split into probe and coupling beams using a polarizing beam splitter .
the phase modulation over the coupling field as well as the pulse creation of the probe is done using acousto - optic modulators .
in order to bring the probe to resonance with the @xmath39 transition an electro - optic modulator is used . the beams ( orthogonal polarization ) are combined together using a glan - taylor polarizer and pass through a 7.5 cm cell containing an isotopically pure @xmath26 with 10 torr ne as buffer gas heated to @xmath40 .
the cell is shielded from an outside magnetic field using a 3-layers of @xmath20-metal .
an axial magnetic field is created using a uniform solenoid .
after the cell another polarizer is used in order to filter the coupling field while the probe is detected using an amplified photodiode . the experimental setup .
dfb - distributed feedback laser , pbs - polarizing beam splitter , ap - aperture , aom - acousto - optic modulator , eom - electro - optic modulator , gt - glan - taylor polarizer , @xmath20ms - @xmath20- metal shield , bd - beam dump , pd - photodiode , sl - solenoid . ]
figure [ fig : ringing ] demonstrates the transmission temporal response of a square probe pulse with intensity of @xmath41 due to a phase modulated coupling field with intensity of @xmath42 in an eit media .
two major features are observed , one is a train of pulses that is created with a period and phase that is dependent upon the coupling field modulation frequency and the detuning @xcite .
the second feature is a transient ringing that is associated with the response of the media to a sudden change in the susceptibility .
this ringing has a chirped frequency as expected @xcite .
it decays with a characteristic time that depends upon @xmath43 and the chirp rate through the transition @xcite .
the instantaneous frequency of the coupling field due to the modulation is @xmath44 while the response has the spectral width of the eit linewidth , thus the relation between the modulation frequency and the eit width , sets the adiabaticity of the response .
transient oscillations of the probe amplitude due to coupling modulation with @xmath45 and @xmath46 .
red - @xmath47 , green - @xmath48 . , width=264 ] figure [ fig : spectrum ] shows experimentally and theoretically the transition between the adiabatic regime where the modulation frequency is lower than the eit linewidth ( @xmath49 ) and the non - adiabatic regime where @xmath50 .
for both regimes the phase of the pulses is determined by the instantaneous frequency hence we see a sine like plot as a function of the detuning with a period @xmath51 and an amplitude @xmath52 . in the adiabatic regime
the transients decay fast enough so they are hardly noticeable , but as the modulation frequency become comparable to the eit linewidth [ fig .
[ fig : spectrum](b ) ] the transient ringing is clearly observed . in the non - adiabatic regime
the modulation frequency is faster than the decay of the transient ringing creating an interference between consecutive pulses as can be observed in fig .
[ fig : spectrum](c ) .
simulation of these 2d patterns using eq .
[ eq : susc_no_mag ] are depicted in fig .
[ fig : spectrum](c - e ) showing a striking similarity to the results .
one aspect this linear response theoretical simulation fails to take into account is the smearing of the interference pattern when the probe pulse is turned on as can be visualized particularly in fig .
[ fig : spectrum](c ) .
the cause of this effect is the gradual build up of the dark state polariton and consequently the creation of the eit line that has a characteristic time of @xmath53 @xcite . integrating
the time domain reveals the steady state spectrum of the probe light .
figure [ fig : spectrum](f - h ) shows the integrated spectra of the experimental data ( green line ) as well as the simulation ( red line ) in the adiabatic and non - adiabatic regimes .
these spectra fit to the phase modulation spectrum according to the fourier of eq .
[ eq : bessel ] , meaning a delta functions separated by the modulation frequency , broadended due to the finite eit linewidth . another way of thinking about the interference shown in fig .
[ fig : spectrum](c ) is as a landau - zener - stuckelberg interference pattern where a transition is crossed repetitively faster than the transient decay time @xcite .
adiabatic to non - adiabatic transition .
2d mapping of the spectro - temporal response of the probe pulse is demonstrated in the case of ( a ) adiabatic regime , ( b ) intermediate regime and ( c ) non - adiabatic regime .
the parameters of the modulation are ( a ) @xmath54 and @xmath55 , ( b ) @xmath45 and @xmath46 , ( c ) @xmath56 and @xmath57 .
all the experiments are done with @xmath58 .
plots ( d - f ) show a simulation of the three regimes that takes into account eq .
[ eq : susc_no_mag ] with the parameters written above . plots ( g - i ) show the spectrum of the transmission taken as the time integral for each frequency . green - experimental spectrum , red - simulation spectrum . ,
width=325 ] figure [ fig : magnetic - results ] shows a 2d mapping of the temporal response of the probe for different magnetic fields ( the two photon detuning is on resonance with the magnetic insensitive transition ) . in the adiabatic regime ( fig .
[ fig : magnetic - results](a ) ) it is possible to see a splitting of the sole pulse in b=0 into three pulses .
these pulses correspond to three eit lines that are present in the spectrum . for the d1 line of rubidium ,
using an arbitrary magnetic field , up to 7 eit lines may appear @xcite .
due to the vectorial nature of the magnetic interaction , the relative strength of these lines depends on the angle between the beam direction and the magnetic field as well as the polarization of the pump and probe beams @xcite .
the specific configuration we use in our setup is @xmath59 with linear polarization . in this case
only three lines appear in the spectrum @xcite as can be seen experimentally @xcite .
the central pulse matches the @xmath60 and thus its phase is constant , while the other two pulses correlate with the @xmath61 , hence having a sinusoidal phase shift .
figures [ fig : magnetic - results](b - c ) show the non - adiabatic regime where every pulse has an oscillating tail with a certain phase causing an interference pattern . a simulation based on eq .
[ eq : mag ] is shown in fig .
[ fig : magnetic - results](d - f ) having the same basic features of the experimental results . temporal response of a probe pulse due to magnetic field for ( a ) adiabatic regime ,
( b ) intermediate regime and ( c ) non - adiabatic regime .
the parameters of the modulation are ( a ) @xmath62 and @xmath63 , ( b ) @xmath45 and @xmath64 , ( c ) @xmath65 and @xmath66 . plots ( d - f ) show a simulation of the three regimes that takes into account eq .
[ eq : mag ] with the parameters written above.,width=325 ] the observed interference may be understood in the following way . in the case of hyperfine eit in a buffer gas and under the condition of @xmath67 it is possible to treat the two ground states as a degenerate set of effective two level systems @xcite . adding a magnetic field removes the degeneracy and
splits each two level system according to the zeeman frequency @xcite . in our case due to the selection rules stated above the splitting
is to three groups with @xmath68 . as a consequence of this picture it is possible to think of the magnetic sweep in time as a chirp of the three tls s ( as depicted by the black dashed lines in fig .
[ fig : magnetic - results](a ) ) .
thus , the interference we measure is a direct consequence of a three landau - zener transitions degeneracy @xcite .
the dynamic pattern created by the phase modulation can be used for broadband magnetic sensing .
each magnetic field has a certain characteristic pulse timing associated with it .
the phase of the first pulse is a prominent feature for broad magnetic sensing as the total amplitude of the modulation is @xmath69 .
this corresponds to @xmath70 and @xmath71 for [ fig : magnetic - results](b ) and [ fig : magnetic - results](c ) respectively .
moreover , the interference pattern offers a way of measuring accurately the magnetic field in the area of the interference .
the sensitivity to magnetic field is dependent upon the signal ( @xmath72 ) to noise ( @xmath73 ) ratio and given by @xcite @xmath74 where @xmath75 is the measurement time and @xmath76 is the gradient of the integrated measured amplitude and the magnetic field . in our case , since the transient ringing is a complex multi frequency feature the best way to characterize the transients for different magnetic field is by using the correlation between them . using this method we measured the noise and the gradient of the correlation function and
estimate our sensitivity to be @xmath77 for the 5 khz modulation and @xmath78 in the case of 15 khz .
the ultimate sensitivity for a given system is @xcite @xmath79 where @xmath80 is the volume of the magnetometer . in our case
this sensitivity is @xmath81 well below the measured sensitivity .
the main reason for that is the electrical noise in the detector and amplifier which is used in order to observe the data in the oscilloscope .
better electronics may allow at least one order of magnitude improvement . in conclusion
, we show experimentally the transient response of an eit media to a phase modulated pump .
this response reveals explicitly the coherent nature of eit . in the non - adiabatic regime
where eit peaks are spectrally resolved it is possible to see interference between the different modes . albeit the interference between these modes does not contribute to eit spectral narrowing and as a consequence to a slower light propagation @xcite , it does create a transient behavior useful for broadband data transfer .
applying a magnetic field splits the eit line into three , allowing us to see an interference pattern caused by the landau - zener crossing of the three eit lines . along with the wideband sweep due to the high modulation index
it is shown to be a useful tool for sensitive wideband magnetometry .
we acknowledge helpful discussions with n. davidson , m. kiffner and t. dey and support of the bikura ( isf ) grant no .
1567/12 .
35ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.77.633 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1002/lpor.201100021 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.75.053803 [ * * , ( ) ] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19516657 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.75.031801 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/1367 - 2630/11/10/103021 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/josab.24.001482 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/s00340 - 009 - 3463 - 6
[ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.65.053802 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.85.013820 [ * * , ( ) ] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19862058 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.69.023806 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.85.063809 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.55.2165 [ * * , ( ) ] http://arxiv.org/abs/1307.3878 [ ] link:\doibase 10.1088/0953 - 4075/45/21/215401 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/0305 - 4470/19/7/017 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.55.4418 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/nphys2149 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.77.023406 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/ncomms1050 [ * * , ( ) ] http://stacks.iop.org/1751-8121/47/i=1/a=015301 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.79.023829 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/ol.31.002625 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physrep.2010.03.002 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.83.015801 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.82.033807 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.81.013833 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.55.648 [ * * , ( ) ] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/9913629 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.67.033810 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/nphys566 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.70.552 [ * * , ( ) ] |
for a long time it has been known that the solar - system abundances of elements heavier than iron have been produced by neutron - capture reactions @xcite . however , neutron capture is also of relevance for abundances of isotopes lighter than iron especially for neutron - rich isotopes , even though the bulk of these elements has been synthesized by charged - particle induced reactions .
the attempts to understand neutron - induced nucleosynthesis require as important ingredients the knowledge of neutron - capture rates .
the influence of shell effects on neutron capture is one of the most interesting aspects of neutron capture , especially since neutron capture in the vicinity of magic numbers is often a bottleneck in neutron - induced nucleosynthesis .
this is the case also in neutron capture on neutron - rich isotopes close to the magic proton and neutron numbers @xmath6 and @xmath7 , i.e. , in the vicinity of the double - magic nucleus @xmath8ca . in particular , the reaction rate of neutron capture for ti - isotopes is of relevance for isotopic abundance anomalies in silicon carbide ( sic ) grains occurring in carbonecous meteorites @xcite .
contrary to most other solar system solids this type of grains has not been reprocessed an / or homogenized .
therefore , they can be can be potentially associated with their stellar origin .
the main part of presolar sic grains have isotopic compositions implying that they most likely condensed in the winds of a variety of asymptotic giant branch ( agb ) stars @xcite .
the sic grains show a large spread of @xmath9ti , the permille deviation from the solar ratio with @xmath8ti as reference isotope , which is evidence for s - processing @xcite .
the very small neutron capture cross section of the neutron magic nucleus @xmath0ti makes it behave as a bottleneck in the s - process path , building up a considerable abundance .
the predictions of agb models discussed in refs .
@xcite show for the neutron - rich isotopes @xmath10ti that the deviations from their solar ratio are essentially in agreement with their measured values in sic grains @xcite .
however , for @xmath0ti the calculated permille deviations from the solar ratio seem a little too high @xcite .
this was one of the motivations to remeasure and reinvestigate the neutron capture cross section on @xmath0ti in the thermonuclear energy range . in sect .
ii the measurements using the fast cyclic activation technique , the neutron production and the time - of - flight measurements are described .
the analysis of the thermonuclear capture cross - sections and their interpretation in form of the non - resonant and resonant capture follows in sect .
furthermore , the maxwellian averaged capture cross section is derived .
finally , in the last section the experimental results and their theoretical interpretation are discussed and compared with previous data .
possible astrophysical consequences of the new neutron capture rate of @xmath0ti with respect to the abundance of this isotope are discussed .
the thermonuclear measurements have been carried out at the karlsruhe and tbingen 3.75mv van de graaff accelerators . in the investigated reaction @xmath0ti(n,@xmath1)@xmath2ti(5.8min )
the characteristic @xmath1-ray lines of the @xmath2ti product nucleus with e@xmath11=320 and 928kev served as an excellent signature for the capture events because of the high accuracy of 0.4% with which the intensity per decay of the 320kev line is known ( table [ tt1 ] ) .
the capture cross sections were determined relative to the @xmath12au(n,@xmath1)@xmath13au(2.69517d ) standard reaction @xcite , where the 411.8044kev @xmath1-ray line of the @xmath13au decay is known with high precision ( table [ tt1 ] ) . the activation technique @xcite , especially the fast cyclic activation has been described in previous publications @xcite .
an activation cycle is characterized by an irradiation and activation counting period . for
the short lived @xmath2ti product nucleus it is essential to repeat these cycles frequently to gain statistics .
the time constants for each cycle are the irradiation time @xmath14 , the counting time @xmath15 , the waiting time @xmath16 ( the time to switch from the irradiation to the counting phase ) and the total time t=@xmath14+@xmath16+@xmath17+@xmath18 ( @xmath18 the time to switch from the counting to the irradiation phase ) . in the actual @xmath0ti measurements
the runs were carried out with @xmath14=119.6s , @xmath15=119.6s , the waiting time @xmath16=0.40s and the total time t=240s . the decay of the @xmath2ti product nuclei during irradiation and the fluctuations of the neutron beam intensity are taken into account by the factor @xmath19 . the accumulated number of counts from a total of @xmath20 cycles , @xmath21 , where @xmath22 , the counts after the i - th cycle , are calculated for a chosen irradiation time , @xmath14 is @xcite @xmath23 \exp(-\lambda t_{\rm w } ) \frac{1-\exp(-\lambda t_{\rm b})}{1-\exp(-\lambda t ) } n \sigma_\gamma { [ 1-f_{\rm b } \exp(-\lambda t ) ] } \sum_{i=1}^n \phi_i\ ] ] with @xmath24 } { \sum_{i=1}^n \phi_i } \quad .\ ] ] the following additional quantities have been defined ; @xmath25 : ge - efficiency , @xmath26 : @xmath1-ray absorption , @xmath27 : @xmath1-ray intensity per decay , @xmath20 : the thickness ( atoms per barn ) of target nuclei , @xmath28 : the capture cross section , @xmath29 : the neutron flux in the i - th cycle .
the quantity @xmath19 is calculated from the registered flux history of a @xmath30li glass monitor . the activity of @xmath13au is additionally counted after the end of the cyclic activation consisting of @xmath31 cycles using @xmath32 \exp(-\lambda t_{\rm w } ) [ 1-\exp(-\lambda t_{\rm b } ) ] n \sigma_\gamma f_{\rm b } \sum_{i=1}^n \phi_i \quad.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath33 is the measuring time of the ge - detector and @xmath34 the time elapsed between the end of cyclic activation and begin of the new data acquisition .
neutrons were generated by the @xmath35li(p , n ) and t(p , n ) reactions .
measurements with neutron spectra of mean neutron energies of 25 , 30 , 52 , and 145kev were carried out by adjusting with the accelerator the appropriate proton energy .
the energy spread of the neutron spectra produced is dependent on the energy loss of the protons in the target layer . for proton energies close to reaction threshold
the target layers were chosen thick enough that the energy loss of the protons reached the reaction threshold within the layer .
this makes the neutron spectrum independent of the target thickness . using the @xmath35li(p , n ) and t(p , n ) reactions in this way we generated quasi - maxwellian spectra with thermal energies kt=25 and 52kev , respectively @xcite .
the spectrum with a mean neutron energy of 30 kev was obtained via the @xmath35li(p , n ) reaction with a proton energy of 1882kev very close to the reaction threshold energy e@xmath36=1881kev . with this spectrum
it was possible to perform a measurement in between the resonances , where the 16.99kev p - wave resonance @xcite is most critical . a typical tof spectrum at @xmath37 and the respective neutron distribution
are shown in fig .
[ f2 ] . with a proton energy
much higher than the reaction threshold energy of the @xmath35li(p , n ) reaction and a thin li - target the neutron energy distribution is dependent on the thickness of the li layer .
the spectrum at 145kev ( fig .
[ f22 ] ) was generated using li - targets of 2.5@xmath38 m .
the li - targets were carefully prepared .
metallic li was evaporated onto 1.5 mm thick copper backing .
the thickness of the li layer is determined during evaporation .
for each new target also a new copper backing is used because of li diffusion into the copper .
targets of good quality were always freshly made before use because long term storage under liquid nitrogen already leads to slight damage of the metallic li through the onset of oxidation .
the proton energy and the thickness of the li target were checked by a a time - of - flight measurement before an activation run was started . in the flight time measurements typically a pulse width of 10 ns and a repetition rate of 1 mhz was used .
the neutrons were counted by a @xmath30li glass detector ( 2.54 cm dia @xmath39 1 mm ) at a flight path of 91 cm . to determine the neutron distribution at the sample position time - of - flight spectra normalized to the proton beam current
were recorded at zero degree and at different angles in steps of 5 degrees .
these spectra are needed for calculating the angle integrated spectrum at the sample position by montecarlo methods , where the extended li - target of 6 mm diameter and the mean free path of the neutrons through the sample are taken into account .
the neutron spectra shown in the figures have been determined in this way . during
the activation runs beam currents up to 100 @xmath40a could be applied without damage of the li - layer because of an effective water cooling system . for the kt=52kev measurement with the tritium target
a beam current of 12@xmath40a was used , and no significant deterioration of the tritium target was observed during the experiment . in the
activations four spectra were continuously recorded , an 8k spectrum of the relative neutron flux @xmath41 time from the neutron monitor , an 8k spectrum of the proton beam current @xmath41 time , an 8k @xmath1-ray spectrum from the ge - detector and an 1k pulse height spectrum of the @xmath30li glass monitor . for safety
every two hours a backup was stored from these spectra automatically . from the ratio neutron flux and proton
beam the actual quality of the target was controlled and from the @xmath30li glass pulse height spectrum the threshold for @xmath1-ray background suppression was checked .
( [ eq1 ] ) and ( [ eq2 ] ) , respectively , contain the quantities @xmath28 and the total neutron flux @xmath42 .
the unknown capture cross - section of @xmath0ti is measured relative to the well - known standard cross section of @xmath12au @xcite .
as the metallic natural ti and @xmath0tio@xmath3 samples , respectively , to be investigated are characterized by a finite thickness it is necessary to sandwich the sample by two comparatively thin gold foils for the determination of the effective neutron flux at sample position .
the activities of these gold foils were counted also individually after termination of the cyclic activation .
the effective count rate of gold was obtained from these individual rates as well as from the accumulated gold count rate during the cyclic activation run .
therefore , the effective neutron flux at sample position was determined in two ways by the gold activation according to the eqs .
( [ eq1 ] ) and ( [ eq2 ] ) .
using eq .
( [ eq1 ] ) has the advantage that saturation effects in the gold activity for irradiations over several days are avoided @xcite . the efficiency determination of the 60% hpge - detector has been performed with calibrated radioactive sources and the detector simulation program geant @xcite as already reported elsewhere @xcite .
the @xmath1-ray absorption in the samples was calculated using tables published by storm and israel @xcite and veigele @xcite . the half - lives and the @xmath1-ray intensities per decay of @xmath2ti and @xmath13au given in table [ tt1 ]
were taken from @xcite .
table [ tt2 ] gives a survey of the sample weights and the measured @xmath0ti capture cross - sections .
the metallic ti and the @xmath0tio@xmath3 samples of 6 mm diameter were sandwiched by thin gold foils of the same dimensions . at 25kev neutron energy measurements
were carried out with titanium oxid sample masses between 40 and 100 mg .
the samples of the @xmath0tio@xmath3 powder were heated to 1000@xmath43c for 3 hours to get stable self - supporting tablets .
no measurable weight loss was observed .
only thin samples were used to minimize corrections for neutron scattering or self - absorption effects , e.g. from oxygen , the ti isotopes and from the gold foils back into the sample .
estimations show that these effects are below 2% @xcite .
three runs were carried out with metallic ti foils of natural isotopic compositon ( table [ tt2 ] ) .
the largest multiple scattering effects would have been expected from oygen .
however the runs with the metallic ti samples and the runs with the @xmath0tio@xmath3 samples show no measurable differences . in fig .
[ f3 ] the accumulated @xmath1-ray intensity from one of the @xmath0ti activations is shown .
the relevant @xmath1-lines are well isolated on a low level of background counts .
the following systematic uncertainties were combined by quadratic error propagation ; au standard cross section : 1.5 - 3% , ge - detector efficiency : 2% , @xmath1-ray intensity per decay : 0.5% for the @xmath2ti and 0.1% for the @xmath13au decay , divergence of neutron beam : 2 - 7% , factor @xmath19 : 1.5% , sample weight : @xmath440.5% .
our measurement in between the region of resonances , at 20 to 40kev is interpreted as direct capture ( dc ) .
the size of this cross section shows that it is not a negligible effect .
because of the selectivity of our activation method only capture in @xmath0ti can contribute to this value .
the contributions from the tails of @xmath0ti resonances are estimated to be not more than 0.005 mbarn and are neglected .
this estimate is in agreement with the value which can be derived from the respective value for thermal capture given in ref .
theoretical estimations suggest that we have to treat our measured direct capture value as pure s - wave capture with a 1/v energy dependence .
a p - wave contribution would be , as a rough calculation shows , at 30kev @xmath45 17.5@xmath40barn .
if we assume that the thermal capture is also essentially direct capture we can make a comparison .
the 1/v extrapolation of our measured direct capture cross section to thermal energy gives [email protected] barn which is , however , significantly larger than the measured value of [email protected] barn @xcite .
but if the bound s - wave resonance at -16.8kev specified in the compilation of mughabghab et al . @xcite exists destructive interference of resonance capture could occur . as the first positive resonance lies at 56.5kev and
the s - wave level spacing is estimated to be d@xmath46=125@xmath470kev @xcite , this bound state resonance seems to be not unlikely .
a capture cross section of this resonance at 25.3mev of 0.051barn which corresponds to a radiative width of this resonance of 0.34ev can reduce the direct capture to the observed thermal value .
a theoretical dc calculation was performed using a realistic neutron - nucleus folding potential @xcite and spectroscopic factors of @xmath2ti from the ( d , p ) experiment of ref .
the result of the dc calculation overestimates our experimental value at 30kev by a factor of 2 ; the calculated cross section depends on the choice of the potential parameters and the uncertainties of the spectroscopic factors .
the resulting uncertainty of the calculated value is also roughly a factor of 2 .
a further indication of the strong influence of the subthreshold state on the thermal capture cross section comes from the comparison of the experimental @xcite and theoretical branching ratio . in the dc calculations the strongest transition is the ground state ( @xmath47 ) transition with a branching of about 60% ( independent on the choice of the potential parameters ) .
however , experimentally the transition to the first excited @xmath48 state at 1167kev is dominating with 35% , and the ground state branching is almost negligible ( 4.2% ) .
it should be noted that this experimental branching ratio is very surprising because in the neighboring nucleus @xmath8ca the experimental and the theoretical branching ratios agree well and show a dominating transition to the first @xmath47 state .
the disappearance of the ground state transition in @xmath0ti can be explained by destructive interference with the proposed @xmath49 subthreshold state at -16.8kev .
furthermore , a strong branching ratio of this subthreshold state can be predicted from the interference effect which mainly influences the ground state transition at thermal energies .
the @xmath0ti capture cross section has been previously measured by allen et al .
@xcite using the time - of - flight technique .
these data have been essentially adopted in the compilation of mughabghab et al .
@xcite except for the g@xmath50 value of the 97.6kev p - wave resonance which was changed from 0.77 to 0.16ev . in an additional publication allen et al .
@xcite corrected the @xmath51 value of the 56.5kev s - wave resonance from [email protected] to [email protected] and estimated also the @xmath51 widths for the s - wave resonances at 146.8 and 184.9kev to be @xmath44 0.1 and [email protected] , respectively .
these revisions were necessary as the oak ridge capture detection setup had turned out to be very sensitive to scattered neutrons resulting in a high prompt ( time dependent ) capture @xmath1-ray background which requires large corrections to the capture areas of the s - wave resonances with a large ratio of neutron scattering and capture width @xcite .
the areas of the s - wave resonances at 56.5 and 184.9kev had to be corrected for prompt background contributions of 87 and 73% @xcite , respectively .
for the energy interval 100 to 150kev allen et al .
@xcite report an average capture cross section of [email protected] which could contain contributions of the 146.8kev s - wave resonance .
however , allen s average cross section is , it seems to be , only derived from the two identified resonances in this energy region .
the resonance strenghts of the 101.4 and 120.6kev resonances exactly add up to the given average cross section . in an effort to obtain an estimate for the strength of the 146.8 kev resonance we have carried out a measurement with a neutron spectrum of 145@xmath420kev .
our measured average cross section at 145 kev of [email protected] consists of a direct contribution of [email protected] extrapolated from the measured value at 30kev , and the resonance contributions from the known 101.4 , 120.6 , and 185.6kev resonances and the 146.8kev s - wave resonance to be investigated .
the average capture cross section of a narrow resonance compared to the neutron spectrum used can be described in the following way @xmath52 where @xmath53 is the breit - wigner formula for the resonace capture , @xmath54 the experimental neutron spectrum and a@xmath11= ( 2@xmath55/k@xmath56 ) g@xmath57 the resonance area with k the wave number , g=(2j+1)/[2(2i+1 ) ] the statistical spin factor with j the compound and i the nuclear spin , and @xmath58 , @xmath59 and @xmath60 the radiation , neutron and total widths , respectively . after subtraction of the direct capture and the resonance capture from the 101.4 , 120.6 , and 185.6kev resonances , where the resonance capture contribution of the 120.6kev resonance of [email protected] mb is comparable in magnitude with the direct capture part , we obtain for the average resonance capture of the 146.8kev s - wave resonance [email protected] mb which corresponds with a radiation width g@[email protected] .
the dominant uncertainties in this analysis come from the neutron spectrum determinations @xmath61kev)= ( 7@xmath43)@xmath3910@xmath62kev@xmath63 , @xmath64kev)= ( 21@xmath45)@xmath3910@xmath62kev@xmath63 , and @xmath65kev)= ( 4@xmath45)@xmath3910@xmath62kev@xmath63 . the uncertainties of the capture areas for the 101.4 , 120.6 kev and 185.6kev resonances have been taken from allen et al .
@xcite .
the maxwellian averaged capture cross section ( [email protected] at kt=30kev ) recommended until now in literature @xcite has been calculated using the resonance parameters given in the tables of mughabghab et al .
@xcite which are based on the reported resonance strengths in ref .
direct capture was neglected and the revised radiation widths of the s - wave resonances @xcite were not considered . in order to compare our measured maxwellian averaged capture ( mac ) cross sections at kt=25kev and 52kev , respectively with the corresponding values calculated from the resonance parameters we have to take into account the above mentioned changes . in table
[ tt3 ] we calculated first the mac cross sections at kt=25kev and 52kev using the resonance parameters from ref .
@xcite ( calc1 ) , then we took into account the revised s - wave resonance widths reported in ref .
@xcite(calc2 ) , we included in calc3 the direct capture contribution and in calc4 our determined radiation width of the 146.8kev resonance .
the direct capture contribution ( calc3 ) was calculated using our measured cross section value at 30kev and the known 1/v energy dependence , where the mac cross section @xmath66 v@xmath67/v@xmath68(kt = e@xmath69)=@xmath70(e@xmath69 ) .
the biggest changes are caused by considerably smaller radiation widths for the s - wave resonances , especially for the 56.5kev resonance ( calc2 ) and the inclusion of the direct s - wave capture contribution ( calc3 ) . finally , calc4 is distincly in better agreement with our experimental mac cross sections than calc1 . in fig .
[ f4 ] the results of calc1 and calc4 @xmath41 kt are plotted together with our measurements at kt=25 and 52kev and the 30kev mac cross section reported in refs .
@xcite . below 17kev where there are
no @xmath0ti resonances the direct capture starts to provide the dominant contribution .
this part of the capture cross section is well determined by our direct capture measurement at 30kev and the known temeprature dependence .
theoretical determinations are also shown .
the curves whfz and smoker refer to these hauser - feshbach calculations given in @xcite . in the smoker calculation @xcite
a pure 1/v temperature dependence was assumed , and the temperature dependence of the whfz calculation @xcite is practically also 1/v . as there are no @xmath0ti resonances below neutron energies of 17kev these calculations overestimate the mac cross section in the temperature range below kt=20kev .
the final mac cross sections and reaction rate factors ( calc4 ) are listed vs temperature kt in table [ tt4 ] . in our experiment
we found the direct s - wave capture component characterising this magic shell isotope .
our measured direct capture cross section at 30kev is one of the few examples , where the measurement of the direct part in the presence of strong resonance capture was successful .
the measured thermal cross section is most likely the product of destructive interference with a bound s - wave resonance the existence of which was already suggested @xcite .
the present investigations yields confirmative arguments .
the estimated resonance strength of 0.34ev is in accord with the radiation widths of the positive s - wave resonances determined by allen et al .
@xcite and in this work .
the inclusion of a direct capture component into the calculation of the stellar reaction rate of @xmath0ti is of importance .
it compensates the decrease of the mac cross section at kt=25kev due to the necessary reduction of the s - wave radiation width especially of the 56.5kev resonance so that the calculation from the resonance parameters remains in agreement with our direct mac cross section measurement .
this may be considered also as an evidence for the consistence of the present data .
it is also important to note that the stellar @xmath0ti reaction rate is not constant because the capture cross section has a non 1/v dependence in the thermonuclear temperature range important for the investigation of the isotopic titanium anomalies which are supposed to be of s - process origin . for a further improvement of the @xmath0ti mac cross section a new time - of - flight measurement
is recommended in order to determine more accurately especially the s - wave radiation widths .
the direct capture contribution becomes a significant part of the mac cross section at low thermonuclear energies , i.e. at kt= 8kev , where the @xmath71c(@xmath72,n ) neutron source is ignited and s - processing takes place in low - mass agb stars @xcite . compared to the old data ( calc1 ) the direct capture increases the mac cross section at kt= 8kev by about 50% ( see fig .
this also reduces the calculated abundance of @xmath0ti in agb models @xcite . as was stated in ref .
@xcite such a reduction could give better agreement with the measured values of the solar ratio with @xmath0ti as reference isotope in sic grains @xcite .
the interest and support of prof .
g. j. wagner of the universitt tbingen is gratefully acknowledged .
we would like to thank the technicians of the van de graaff accelerators m. brandt and g. rupp , respectively , and the karlsruhe van de graaff staff members e.p .
knaetsch , d. roller , and w. seith for their help and support of the experiment especially in the preparation of the metallic li - targets .
we thank the fonds zur frderung der wissenschaftlichen forschung in sterreich ( project s7307-ast ) , the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft ( dfg ) ( project mo739/1 - 1 ) , and volkswagen - stiftung ( az : i/72286 ) for their support .
e. m. burbidge , g. r. burbidge , w. a. fowler , and f. hoyle , rev .
* 29 * , 547 ( 1957 ) .
p. hoppe , s. amari , e. zinner , t. ireland , and r. s. lewis , ap .
j. * 430 * , 870 ( 1994 ) .
r. gallino , c. m. raiteri , m. busso , and f. matteucci , ap .
j. * 430 * , 858 ( 1994 ) .
m. lugaro , r. gallino , m. busso , s. amari , and e. zinner , proceedings of the fifth international symposium on nuclei in the cosmos , volos , greece , 5 - 12 july 1998 , ed .
n. prantzos , editions frontieres , gif sur yvette , in press .
r. gallino , c. arlandini , m. busso , m. lugaro , c. travaglio , o. straniero , a. chieffi , and m. limongni , ap . j. * 497 * , 388 ( 1998 ) .
o. straniero , a. chieffi , m. limongi , m. busso , r. gallino , and c. arlandini , ap .
j. * 478 * , 332 ( 1997 ) .
r. l. macklin , 1982 , private communication .
w. ratynski and f. kppeler , phys .
c * 37 * , 595 ( 1988 ) . h. beer and f. kppeler , phys .
c * 21 * , 534 ( 1980 ) .
f. kppeler , a. a. naqvi , and m. al - ohali , phys .
c * 35 * , 936 ( 1987 ) . h. beer , g. rupp , f. vo , and f. kppeler , nucl .
methods a * 337 * , 492 ( 1994 ) .
h. beer , p. v. sedyshev , yu .
p. popov , w. balogh , h. herndl , and h. oberhummer , phys .
c * 52 * , 3442 ( 1995 ) .
s. f. mughabghab , m. divadeenam , and n. e. holden , neutron cross - sections , vol .
i ( academic press , 1981 ) .
r. brun and f. carminati , geant detector description and simulation tool , cern program library long writeup w5013 edition , cern , geneva ( 1993 ) .
p. mohr , h. beer , h. oberhummer , and g. staudt , phys .
c * 58 * , 932 ( 1998 ) .
e. storm and h. israel , nucl .
data tables a * 7 * , 565 ( 1970 ) .
j. veigele , atomic data nucl .
data tables * 5 * , 51 ( 1973 ) .
r. b. firestone , v. s. shirley , table of isotopes , 8th edition , volume i , ( john wiley & sons , new york 1996 ) p. 175 .
h. beer , c. coceva , p. v. sedyshev , yu .
p. popov , h. herndl , r. hofinger , p. mohr , and h. oberhummer , , 2014 ( 1996 ) .
r. ejnisman , d. goldman , k. s. krane , p. mohr , y. nakazawa , e. b. norman , t. rauscher , and j. reel , , 2531 ( 1998 ) .
d. c. kocher and w. haeberli , nucl .
* a196 * , 225 ( 1972 ) . z. chunmei , nucl .
data sheets * 81 * , 183 ( 1997 ) .
b. j. allen , j. w. boldeman , a. r. de l. musgrove , and r. l. macklin , australian atomic energy commission , report aaec / e402 , june 1977 .
b. j. allen and a. r. de l. musgrove , in proc of a specialists meeting on neutron data of structural materials for fast reactors , geel , belgium 5 - 8 december 1977 , ed .
k. h. bckhoff , pergamon press oxford 1979 , p. 447
. b. j. allen and a. r. de l. musgrove , r. l. macklin , r. r. winters , in proc of a specialists meeting on neutron data of structural materials for fast reactors , geel , belgium 5 - 8 december 1977 , ed .
k. h. bckhoff , pergamon press oxford 1979 , p. 506 . z. y. bao and f. kppeler , atomic data nucl .
data tables * 36 * , 411 ( 1987 ) .
h. beer , f. voss , and r. r. winters , ap .
* 80 * , 403 ( 1992 ) .
s. e. woosley , w. a. fowler , j. a. holmes , and b. a. zimmermann , atomic data and nucl .
data tables * 22 * , 371 ( 1978 ) .
j. j. cowan , f .- k .
thielemann , and j. w. truran , physics reports * 208 * , 267 ( 1991 ) . | at the karlsruhe and tbingen 3.75mv van de graaff accelerators the thermonuclear @xmath0ti(n,@xmath1)@xmath2ti(5.8min ) cross section was measured by the fast cyclic activation technique via the 320.852 and 928.65kev @xmath1-ray lines of the @xmath2ti - decay .
metallic ti samples of natural isotopic composition and samples of tio@xmath3 enriched in @xmath0ti by 67.53% were irradiated between two gold foils which served as capture standards .
the capture cross - section was measured at the neutron energies 25 , 30 , 52 , and 145kev , respectively .
the direct capture cross section was determined to be [email protected] mbarn at 30kev .
we found evidence for a bound state s - wave resonance with an estimated radiative width of 0.34ev which destructively interfers with direct capture .
the strength of a suggested s - wave resonance at 146.8kev was determined .
the present data served to calculate , in addition to the directly measured maxwellian averaged capture cross sections at 25 and 52kev , an improved stellar @xmath0ti(n,@xmath1)@xmath2ti rate in the thermonuclear energy region from 1 to 250kev .
the new stellar rate leads at low temperatures to much higher values than the previously recommended rate , e.g. , at @xmath5kev the increase amounts to about 50% .
the new reaction rate therefore reduces the abundance of @xmath0ti due to s - processing in agb stars . |
fullerene molecules @xcite are carbon cages which appear in the vaporization of graphite .
one of their most beautiful features from a formal point of view is their geometric character and the exciting possibility of producing them in all sorts of geometric shapes having as building blocks sections of the honeycomb graphite lattice .
the most abundant of them is the most spherical @xmath5 molecule .
the shape of the @xmath5 molecule is that of a soccer ball , consisting of 12 pentagons and 20 hexagons .
however , some fullerenes as @xmath6 are slightly elliptically deformed with the shape being more similar to an american football .
fullerenes belong to a sort of carbon nanoparticles .
carbon nanoparticles , which are expected to have important implications for the development of electronic devices , flat panel displays , nano - switches , etc .
, have recently received great attention of both experimentalists and theorists ( see @xcite ) .
high flexibility of carbon allows one to produce variously shaped carbon nanoparticles : nanotubes , fullerenes , cones , toroids , graphitic onions and nanohorns .
particular attention was given to peculiar electronic states due to topological defects which were observed in different kinds of carbon nanoparticles by scanning tunneling microscopy ( stm ) .
for example , stm images with five - fold symmetry ( due to pentagons in the hexagonal graphitic network ) were obtained in the c@xmath2 fullerene molecule @xcite .
the peculiar electronic properties at the ends of carbon nanotubes ( which include several pentagons ) were probed experimentally in @xcite . by its nature , the pentagon in a graphite sheet is a topological defect .
actually , as was mentioned in ref .
@xcite , fivefold coordinated particles are orientational disclination defects in the otherwise sixfold coordinated triangular lattice .
the local density of states was found in the vicinity of a pentagonal defect for spherical fullerenes @xcite .
moreover , disclinations are _ generic _ defects in closed carbon structures , fullerenes and nanotubes , because , in accordance with euler s theorem , these microcrystals can only be formed by having a total disclination of @xmath7 . according to the geometry of the hexagonal network , this implies the presence of twelve pentagons ( @xmath8 disclinations ) on the closed hexatic surface .
investigation of the electronic structure requires formulating a theoretical model describing electrons on arbitrary curved surfaces with disclinations taken into account .
an important ingredient of this model can be provided by the self - consistent effective - mass theory describing the electron dynamics in the vicinity of an impurity in graphite intercalation compounds @xcite .
the most important fact found in @xcite is that the electronic spectrum of a single graphite plane linearized around the corners of the hexagonal brillouin zone coincides with that of the dirac equation in ( 2 + 1 ) dimensions .
this finding stimulated a formulation of some field - theory models for dirac fermions on hexatic surfaces to describe electronic structure of variously shaped carbon materials : fullerenes @xcite and nanotubes @xcite .
the dirac equation for massless fermions in three - dimensional space - time in the presence of the magnetic field was found to yield @xmath9 zero modes in the n - vortex background field @xcite . as was shown in ref .
@xcite , the problem of the local electronic structure of fullerene is closely related to jackiw s analysis @xcite .
notice that the field - theory models for dirac fermions on a plane and on a sphere @xcite were invoked to describe variously shaped carbon materials .
recently , the importance of the fermion zero modes was discussed in the context of high - temperature chiral superconductors and fullerene molecules .
the most spherical fullerene is the c@xmath2 molecule nicknamed a bucky ball. others are either slightly ( as c@xmath1 whose shape is more like an elliptic deformation ) or remarkably deformed .
we are interested here in the c@xmath2 molecule as well as in its spherical generalizations like big c@xmath3 and c@xmath4 molecules with the symmetry group of the icosahedron , and also in the elliptically deformed fullerene c@xmath1 and its relatives .
big fullerenes are used to store radioactive material and inhibit enzymes related to different viruses @xcite .
almost all fullerenes are only slightly elliptically deformed spherical molecules , e.g. , c@xmath1 and its relatives .
we start with introducing spheroidal coordinates and writing down the dirac operator for free massless fermions on the riemann spheroid @xmath10 .
pi - molecular orbitals in fullerenes as a free electron model ( electron gas ) bound on the surface of a sphere were used in @xcite .
we generalize that work to obtain an electronic spectrum for spherical and spheroidal geometries with and without the monopole field .
the peculiarities of the electronic spectra for these two slightly different types of geometries are shown . to incorporate fermions on the curved background
, we need a set of orthonormal frames @xmath11 , which yield the same metric , @xmath12 , related to each other by the local @xmath13 rotation , @xmath14 it then follows that @xmath15 where @xmath16 is the zweibein , with the orthonormal frame indices being @xmath17 , and the coordinate indices @xmath18 . as usual , to ensure that physical observables are independent of a particular choice of the zweibein fields , a local @xmath19 valued gauge field @xmath20 is to be introduced .
the gauge field of the local lorentz group is known as a spin connection . for a theory to be self - consistent ,
the zweibein fields must be chosen to be covariantly constant @xcite @xmath21 which determines the spin connection coefficients explicitly @xmath22 finally , the dirac equation on a surface @xmath23 in the presence of the magnetic monopole field @xmath24 is written as @xcite @xmath25\psi = e\psi , \label{eq:2}\ ] ] where @xmath26 with @xmath27 \label{eq:3},\ ] ] being the spin connection term in the spinor representation .
the elliptically deformed sphere or a spheroid @xmath28 may be parameterized by two spherical angles @xmath29 , @xmath30 that are related to the cartesian coordinates @xmath31 , @xmath32 , @xmath33 as follows @xmath34 we have assumed that the eccentricity of the spheroid is @xmath0 which in the case @xmath35 gives expressions @xmath36 .
the metric tensor and the natural diagonal zweibein different from zero on the spheroid are @xmath37 where @xmath38 and @xmath39 which , in view of eq .
( [ eq:1 ] ) gives the spin connection coefficients @xmath40 in @xmath41 the dirac matrices can be chosen to be the pauli matrices , @xmath42 ; eq .
( [ eq:3 ] ) then reduces to @xmath43 we have assumed that @xmath44 and only the monopole field @xmath45 is different from zero .
the eigenfunctions of the dirac operator are two - component spinors that satisfy the eigenvalue equation @xmath46 this system of first order partial differential equations in @xmath47 and @xmath48 allows separation of variables therefore we can isolate the @xmath49-dependence by expanding the spinors into the fourier series @xmath50 where @xmath51 are half - integers since we work with the spin @xmath52 field .
then the general form of the dirac equation , eq .
( [ eq:2 ] ) , on the spheroid becomes @xmath53\beta_{\lambda m } ( \theta)= \nonumber\ ] ] @xmath54 @xmath55\alpha_{\lambda m } ( \theta)= \nonumber\ ] ] @xmath56 the number @xmath51 may be called the projection of angular momentum onto the polar axis . if @xmath57 , where @xmath58 is the radius of a sphere , eq .
( [ eq:12 ] ) becomes the dirac equation for sphere geometry .
now we want to find an electronic spectrum for the sphere and spheroid analytically and numerically , respectively ; therefore , we firstly assume that pentagon defects represented in this model by the monopole field @xmath59 .
next , we want to separate the equations for the spinor components @xmath47 and @xmath48 .
this can be done by taking the square @xmath60 ( laplace operator ) of the dirac operator @xmath61 for spheroidal geometry . finally , we find the equations @xmath62\left(\alpha_{\lambda m } ( \theta)\atop{\beta_{\lambda m } ( \theta)}\right)=\ ] ] @xmath63\left(\alpha_{\lambda m } ( \theta)\atop{\beta_{\lambda m } ( \theta)}\right ) \label{eq:13}.\ ] ] further simplifications come from the change of variables @xmath64 , @xmath65 $ ] , which converts eq .
( [ eq:13 ] ) into the generalized hypergeometric equations @xmath66\left(\alpha_{\lambda m } ( x)\atop{\beta_{\lambda m}(x)}\right)=\ ] ] @xmath67\left(\alpha_{\lambda m } ( x)\atop{\beta_{\lambda m } ( x)}\right ) \label{eq:14}.\ ] ] the replacement @xmath68 ( or @xmath69 ) is equivalent to changing @xmath47 for @xmath48 .
thus , the upper and lower spinor components are conjugate with respect to mirror reflection .
equation ( [ eq:14 ] ) is singular at the poles of the spheroid @xmath70 .
we redefine the unknowns @xmath71 and use that in our model of a slightly deformed sphere @xmath72 ; hence @xmath73 , where @xmath74 is small deformation of the sphere . neglecting the second and higher order powers of @xmath75 we solve eq . ( [ eq:14 ] ) to the first order in @xmath75 and by using redefinition ( [ eq:15 ] )
we arrive at the separate equations of hypergeometric type in @xmath76 and @xmath77 @xmath78 where @xmath79 for the above calculations we have assumed that @xmath80 .
a similar solution can be also found for the case @xmath81 . following the calculations above
we can get also the equation for function @xmath82 .
the function @xmath83 is the deviation of the solution for a spheroid from that for a sphere , see @xcite , and can be perceived as next energy part , i.e. the energy shift for a spheroid compared to a sphere geometry .
thus the expression @xmath83 can also be called as a perturbation part of equations ( [ eq:16 ] ) . to find the spectrum for spherical geometry @xmath57
, we have to put the expression @xmath84 , so the case if @xmath85 . the spectrum can be found in the form @xmath86 with non - negative integer @xmath87 , with @xmath88 being the order of jacobi polynomials , see @xcite .
the eigenvalues @xmath89 for the sphere of the unit radius @xmath10 are nonzero integers @xmath90 and indeed the dirac operator has no zero - modes .
the spectra of the spherical geometry as the numerical calculations of eq .
( [ eq:12 ] ) with @xmath59 and for @xmath91 are illustrated in fig . 1 and fit the analytical results in ( 18 ) . , where @xmath91.,scaledwidth=37.0% ] to find the electronic spectrum also in the case of spheroidal geometry when @xmath92 , we solve eq .
( [ eq:12 ] ) for two cases , when @xmath93 and @xmath94 , i.e. for two different types of an elliptically deformed sphere .
the numerical results are shown in fig . 2 .
where , @xmath93 and @xmath94 ( going from left to right).,scaledwidth=90.0% ] as can be seen from fig . 2 , the spectra display the energetic shifts compared to the spectra of the sphere in fig . 1
the shift increases or reduces the initial electronic spectrum of sphere depending on the type of elliptic deformation .
the shift is bigger with increasing value of the modes of the electronic spectra , which can be also seen from the structure of @xmath83 in eq .
( [ eq:16 ] ) .
the perturbation parameter @xmath95 was used to obtain the electronic spectra of the dirac equation for the spheroidal geometry .
the angular momentum @xmath96 was used in the calculations .
all the spectra are mirror symmetric with respect to the @xmath32-axis .
we assume that the parameter of perturbation and the eccentricity of the spheroid @xmath97 , so we can use the magnetic monopole field inside the surface to obtain @xmath6 fullerene or bigger fullerene molecules like c@xmath3 and c@xmath4 also with a small elliptical deformation .
the area of surface for a small elliptically deformed sphere , spheroid , e.g. for oblate spheroid ( @xmath98 ) can be formulated as , see @xcite @xmath99 in the case of small eccentricity the surface area of a spheroid becomes the surface area of a sphere @xmath100 .
it means that we can include the existence of a fictitious magnetic monopole charge @xmath101 inside the surface of the spheroid with the structure as in ref .
the values of @xmath101 , e.g. for tetrahedron and icosahedron structures required @xmath102 and @xmath103 , respectively . with the monopole field taken as @xmath44 and @xmath104 , where @xmath105 ( for structures above @xmath106 ) , the resulting dirac equation ( [ eq:12 ] ) for the spheroid with the monopole field reads @xmath107\beta_{\lambda m } ( \theta)= \nonumber\ ] ] @xmath108 @xmath109\alpha_{\lambda m } ( \theta)= \nonumber\ ] ] @xmath110 unfortunately , general solutions to eq .
( [ eq:19 ] ) are not available yet for spherical and spheroidal fullerenes , so we do not have initial conditions for numerical calculations which are very sensitive to them .
however , we will present some analytical predictions of the electronic spectra for spherical and spheroidal fullerenes from the square of dirac operator in eq .
( [ eq:19 ] ) . to find an analytical expression for the shift of the spheroidal fullerenes , we put for simplicity in eq .
( [ eq:19 ] ) the value of the angular momentum @xmath111 . for elliptically deformed fullerenes in the special case where @xmath111 with using the model of a slightly deformed sphere where @xmath73 , the square of dirac operator ( 19 ) was found in the form @xmath112\left(\alpha_{\lambda m } ( \theta)\atop{\beta_{\lambda m } ( \theta)}\right)\ ] ] @xmath113\left(\alpha_{\lambda m } ( \theta)\atop{\beta_{\lambda m } ( \theta)}\right ) \label{eq:20},\ ] ] where @xmath74 is small deformation of the sphere .
we neglect the second and higher order powers of @xmath75 in the calculations . if the perturbation parameter @xmath85 , we get the square of dirac operator for spherical fullerenes with the electronic spectrum as in ref .
to get connection with section ii , the spectrum with the monopole field for the spherical fullerenes can be rewrite from the right hand side of eq .
( [ eq:20 ] ) to the form @xmath114 with @xmath115 , see @xcite . the value of the electronic spectrum @xmath116 is shifted ( decreases ) by the value of the charge @xmath101 of the monopole field .
moreover , the presence of the monopole restricts possible values of the angular momentum @xcite , so that @xmath117 and , therefore , the values of @xmath51 change contrary to structures without a monopole field inside , as in section ii .
it means that for fullerenes the angular momentum @xmath51 can get the values @xmath118 .
the spectra of fullerenes are appended by the monopole charge compared to eq .
( [ eq:13 ] ) for spherical geometry .
so the spectra of fullerenes are greatly dependent on the value of the monopole field . in the case of tetrahedron and icosahedron structures expression
( 21 ) can predict the existence of zero modes where @xmath119 . if @xmath120 , the shift of the spheroidal fullerenes from the spherical ones in eq .
( [ eq:20 ] ) were found .
moreover , when we use the substitution @xmath64 as in section ii , we can rewrite the shift on the right hand side of eq .
( [ eq:20 ] ) in the following form @xmath121[eq:22 ] the electronic spectrum will be shifted by the value @xmath122 .
the function @xmath83 is the deviation of spheroidal from spherical fullerenes , similarly to the previous section , and can also be perceived as the energy shift to spheroidal fullerenes compared to spherical ones .
moreover , the perturbation function @xmath83 is in the case when @xmath111 and @xmath123 the same as the shift in eq .
( [ eq:16 ] ) for spheroidal geometry .
so we can expect a similar behavior ( shifts ) of the spectra of spheroidal fullerenes ( decreases by the value of the monopole charge @xmath101 ) as in the case of spheroidal geometry without a monopole field , see fig . 2 .
to find the electronic spectra of the @xmath6 fullerene and its relatives , we have used the model of a slightly elliptically deformed sphere , the spheroidal geometry ( @xmath120 ) , as distinct from the @xmath5 fullerene where the spherical geometry ( @xmath85 ) was used .
the dirac equation in ( 2 + 1 ) dimensions for slightly elliptically deformed fullerenes with monopole field inside the surface was evaluated .
the discrete spectrum of energy for both types of geometries was found . the electronic spectrum and the shift of the spheroidal geometry in eq .
( [ eq:16 ] ) contrary to the sphere was calculated both analytically and numerically .
figure 2 shows the shift of the spectra for spheroidal geometry . in the case of
spherical and spheroidal fullerenes the electronic spectrum and shift were derived analytically .
the spectra of spherical and spheroidal fullerenes decreasing by the value of monopole charge @xmath101 were found .
the expression @xmath83 for deviation of the solution for a spheroid from that for a sphere in eq .
( [ eq:16 ] ) was found the same as for the deviation between spheroidal and spherical fullerenes in expression ( 22 ) .
so we can expect a similar shift of the spectra for real elliptically deformed fullerenes when the magnetic monopole field has to be included inside the surface to simulate pentagon defects and create fullerenes .
zero energy modes dictated by the charge @xmath101 were found for fullerenes contrary to spherical geometry without the monopole field inside .
the shift of the electronic spectra of spheroidal , in contrast to spherical fullerenes , gives rise to reduction or increase in the conduction bandwidth depending on the type of elliptical deformation ( @xmath93 , @xmath94 ) . due to this , the crystals made of these deformed fullerene molecules , when doped should be poorer or better conductors than the spherical ones .
moreover , the spherical fullerenes as @xmath5 are stable towards fragmentation than the other bigger fullerenes @xcite , following our analysis , also with small elliptical deformations and with a shift of the electronic spectra .
the presence of the magnetic monopole field with the charge leads to a decrease in the electronic spectra and shifts for spherical and spheroidal molecules , respectively .
the decrease is smaller with increasing value of the modes of the electronic spectra and , therefore , for low - lying electronic levels the spectra of the spheroidal fullerenes @xmath6 or c@xmath3 and c@xmath4 could be shifted to a lower magnitude .
the very big structures like c@xmath124 and c@xmath125 become more deformed , faceted and can no longer form a free - electron model like the electronic shell @xcite , which was the assumption for this model . for these structures the deviation from the sphericity is larger when the pentagon defects are localized at the opposite poles . in the case
when the poles are far away from each other we obtain the structure of nanotubes , and for the exact description some new model related to that proposed here should be used .
we hope that the knowledge of the shifts of the electronic spectra of spheroids could be useful for experimentalists for choosing the optimal energetic scale for different types of fullerenes .
finally , we think that the spheroidal geometry approach could also be related to other physical problems with slightly deformed spherical structures that are common in the nature .
0.2 cm 0.2 cm the author thanks v.a .
osipov for helpful discussions and advice .
0.2 cm 0.2 cm this work was supported by the slovak scientific grant agency , grant no .
3197 , the science and technology assistance agency under contract no .
apvt-51 - 027904 , and grant of plenipotentiary of slovakia at jinr .
kroto , j.r . heath , s.c.obrien ,
r.f . curl and r.e .
smalley , nature * 318 * ( 1985 ) 162 .
lozovik and a.m. popov , usp .
* 167 * ( 1997 ) 751 .
et al . _ ,
phys . rev .
* 83 * ( 1999 ) 3001 .
et al . _ ,
78 * ( 1997 ) 2811 .
p. kim _ et al .
* 82 * ( 1999 ) 1225 .
nelson and l. peliti , j.phys .
( paris ) * 48 * ( 1987 ) 1085 .
osipov , e.a .
kochetov and m. pudlak , jetp * 96 * ( 2003 ) 140 .
r. pincak and v.a .
osipov , phys .
a * 314 * ( 2003 ) 315 .
divincenzo and e.j .
mele , phys .
b * 29 * ( 1984 ) 1685 .
osipov and e.a .
kochetov , jetp lett .
* 72 * ( 2000 ) 199 .
j. gonzlez , f. guinea and m.a.h .
vozmediano , nucl.phys .
b * 406 * ( 1993 ) 771 . c.l . kane and e.j .
mele , phys .
* 78 * ( 1997 ) 1932 .
r. jackiw , phys .
d * 29 * ( 1984 ) 2375 .
osipov and e.a .
kochetov , jetp lett .
* 72 * ( 2000 ) 199 .
j. gonzlez , f. guinea and m.a.h .
vozmediano , phys .
* 69 * ( 1992 ) 172 .
k. kobayashy , _ et al .
_ , j. am .
* 116 * ( 1994 ) 9775 .
s. h. decamp , _ et al .
_ , j. am .
* 115 * ( 1993 ) 6506 .
n. mizorogi _
et al . _ ,
* 378 * ( 2003 ) 598 .
mikio nakahara , _ geometry , topology and physics _ , ( institute of physics publishing bristol 1998 ) .
n.d . birrell and p. c. w. davies , _ quantum fields in curved space _ , ( cambridge 1982 ) .
a.a . abrikosov jr . , int .
journ . of mod .
a * 17 * ( 2002 ) 885 . | graphite is an example of a layered material that can be bent to form fullerenes which promise important applications in electronic nanodevices .
the spheroidal geometry of a slightly elliptically deformed sphere was used as a possible approach to fullerenes .
we assumed that for a small deformation the eccentricity of the spheroid @xmath0 .
we are interested in the elliptically deformed fullerenes c@xmath1 as well as in c@xmath2 and its spherical generalizations like big c@xmath3 and c@xmath4 molecules .
the low - lying electronic levels are described by the dirac equation in ( 2 + 1 ) dimensions .
we show how a small deformation of spherical geometry evokes a shift of the electronic spectra compared to the sphere .
the flux of a monopole field was included inside the surface to describe the fullerenes .
both the electronic spectrum of spherical and the shift of spheroidal fullerenes were derived . |
exactly soluble quantum spin models belong to the most fascinating topics to deal with in the area of modern equilibrium statistical mechanics @xcite .
it should be pointed out , however , that quantum effects usually compete with a cooperative nature of spontaneous long - range ordering and thus , it is quite intricate to find an exactly solvable model that simultaneously exhibits both spontaneous long - range order as well as obvious macroscopic features of quantum origin . on the other hand , it is a competition between quantum and cooperative phenomena that is an essential ingredient for observing a quite remarkable and unexpected behavior of low - dimensional quantum spin models .
the hybrid ising - heisenberg models on decorated planar lattices , whose nodal sites are occupied by the classical ising spins and decorating sites by the quantum heisenberg ones , belong to the simplest rigorously solved quantum spin models that exhibit a spontaneous long - range ordering with apparent quantum manifestations .
it is worthwhile to remark , moreover , that the ising - heisenberg planar models @xcite where a finite cluster of the heisenberg spins interacts with either two or three nodal ising spins are in principle tractable by the use of generalized decoration - iteration or star - triangle transformations @xcite , which establish a precise mapping equivalence between them and the spin-1/2 ising model on the corresponding undecorated planar lattice @xcite . among other matters , the exact solutions for this special class of the ising - heisenberg planar models might serve in evidence that these rigorously solvable models exhibit a strong - universal critical behavior , which can be characterized by critical exponents from the standard ising universality class .
contrary to this , the more interesting weak - universal behavior @xcite of the critical exponents has been recently announced for two ising - heisenberg planar models @xcite , where a finite cluster of the heisenberg spins interacts with four nodal ising spins . the spin-1/2 ising - heisenberg model with the pair @xmath0 heisenberg interaction and two quartic ising interactions
@xcite has surprisingly turned out to be the fully exactly solvable model due to a validity of the precise mapping equivalence with baxter s zero - field ( symmetric ) eight - vertex model @xcite .
the main purpose of this work is to examine in detail how the weak - universal critical behavior of this exactly soluble model depends on a spatial anisotropy in two quartic ising interactions and on the exchange anisotropy of the @xmath0 heisenberg pair interaction , whose effect have not been dealt with in our preceding work @xcite for the most general case .
this paper is so organized . in the following section
, we will describe the hybrid ising - heisenberg model and recall basic steps of the exact mapping procedure to the zero - field eight - vertex model .
the most interesting results for the ground - state and finite - temperature phase diagrams , which are supported by a detailed analysis of critical exponents , are subsequently presented in the next section .
finally , some concluding remarks are mentioned along with a brief summary of the most important scientific achievements in the last section .
let us consider a two - dimensional lattice of edge - sharing octahedrons .
figure [ fig1 ] schematically displays the elementary unit cell of the two - dimensional lattice , i.e. an octahedron , which contains four ising spins @xmath1 in its basal plane and two heisenberg spins @xmath2 in its apical positions .
let each edge of the octahedron , which connects two ising spins , be a common edge of two adjacent octahedrons so that an ensemble of all ising spins will form a square lattice and the heisenberg spins will be located above and below a center of each elementary square face .
suppose furthermore that both apical heisenberg spins interact together via the pair @xmath0 heisenberg interaction , heisenberg interaction between the apical heisenberg spins and both types of broken lines connect spins involved in the quartic ising interactions .
thin solid lines connecting four ising spins are guide for eyes only.,scaledwidth=35.0% ] while they also take part in two different quartic ising - type interactions with two ising spins from opposite corners of a square face ( see figure [ fig1 ] ) . for further convenience
, the total hamiltonian can be written as a sum over all elementary unit cells ( octahedrons ) @xmath3 , where each cluster hamiltonian @xmath4 contains one pair interaction between the apical heisenberg spins and two quartic ising - type interactions between the heisenberg spins and their four ising neighbors @xmath5 above , the interaction parameters @xmath6 label spatial components of the anisotropic @xmath0 interaction between the heisenberg spins , while the interaction parameters @xmath7 and @xmath8 label two quartic ising - type interactions between both apical heisenberg spins and two ising spins from opposite corners of a square face along two different diagonal directions ( see figure [ fig1 ] ) .
the crucial step of our calculation lies in an evaluation of the partition function .
a validity of the commutation relation @xmath9 = 0 $ ] between different octahedron - cluster hamiltonians allows a partial factorization of the partition function into the following product @xmath10 where @xmath11 , @xmath12 is boltzmann s constant and @xmath13 is the absolute temperature .
the summation @xmath14 to emerge in eq .
( [ pf1 ] ) is carried out over all possible configurations of the ising spins , the product runs over all octahedron unit cells and the symbol @xmath15 stands for a trace over spin degrees of freedom of the heisenberg spin pair from the @xmath16th octahedron . in the latter step of our calculation we have used a straightforward diagonalization of the hamiltonian ( [ ham ] ) of the @xmath16th octahedron in order to obtain the relevant trace over spin degrees of freedom of the heisenberg spin pair .
this procedure yields some effective boltzmann s weight @xmath17 , which explicitly depends merely on four ising spins @xmath18 , @xmath19 , @xmath20 and @xmath21 from the basal plane of the @xmath16th octahedron . in addition , the explicit form of the effective boltzmann s factor @xmath17 immediately implies a possibility of performing the generalized star - square transformation @xmath22
\cosh \left [ \frac{\beta}{4 } \left(j_x - j_y \right ) \right ] \nonumber \\ \ ! \ ! \ ! & + & \ ! \ ! \ ! 2 \exp \left[- \frac{\beta}{4 } \left ( j_z + j_1
\sigma_{p1}^z \sigma_{p3}^z + j_2 \sigma_{p2}^z \sigma_{p4}^z \right ) \right ] \cosh \left [ \frac{\beta}{4 } \left(j_x + j_y \right ) \right ] \nonumber \\ \ ! \ ! \ ! & = & \ ! \ ! \ !
r_0 \exp(\beta r_1 \sigma^z_{p1 } \sigma^z_{p3 } + \beta r_2 \sigma^z_{p2 } \sigma^z_{p4 } + \beta r_4 \sigma^z_{p1 } \sigma^z_{p2 } \sigma^z_{p3 } \sigma^z_{p4 } ) , \label{sst } \end{aligned}\ ] ] which substitutes the effective boltzmann s weight @xmath17 by the equivalent expression containing two pair ( @xmath23 and @xmath24 ) and one quartic ( @xmath25 ) interaction between four nodal ising spins from an elementary square face of the square lattice .
of course , the algebraic transformation ( [ sst ] ) must satisfy the self - consistency condition , which means that it must hold independently of spin states of four ising spins involved therein .
it can be easily verified that a substitution of all sixteen possible spin configurations of the nodal ising spins gives just four independent equations , which unambiguously determine so far not specified mapping parameters @xmath26 , @xmath23 , @xmath24 , and @xmath25 @xmath27 that can be expressed in terms of four different boltzmann s weights @xmath28 ( @xmath29 ) @xmath30 \ ! \cosh \ !
\left [ \frac{\beta}{4 } \left(j_x - j_y \right ) \right ] + 2 \exp \ !
\left[- \frac{\beta}{4 } \left ( j_z + \frac{j_1 + j_2}{4 } \right ) \right ] \
! \cosh \ !
\left [ \frac{\beta}{4 } \left(j_x + j_y
\right ) \right]\ ! \ ! , \label{bw1 } \\ \omega_3 ( + , \mp , - , \pm ) \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! & = & \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! 2 \exp \
! \left [ \frac{\beta}{4 } \left ( j_z - \frac{j_1 + j_2}{4 } \right ) \right ] \ ! \cosh \ !
\left [ \frac{\beta}{4 } \left(j_x - j_y \right ) \right ] + 2 \exp \ !
\left[- \frac{\beta}{4 } \left ( j_z - \frac{j_1 + j_2}{4 } \right ) \right ] \
! \cosh \
! \left [ \frac{\beta}{4 } \left(j_x + j_y
\right ) \right]\ ! \ ! , \label{bw3 } \\ \omega_5 ( \pm , + , \mp , + ) \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! & = & \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! 2 \exp \
\left [ \frac{\beta}{4 } \left ( j_z - \frac{j_1 - j_2}{4 } \right ) \right ] \
! \cosh \
! \left [ \frac{\beta}{4 } \left(j_x - j_y \right ) \right ] + 2 \exp \ !
\left[- \frac{\beta}{4 } \left ( j_z - \frac{j_1 - j_2}{4 } \right ) \right ] \ !
! \left [ \frac{\beta}{4 } \left(j_x + j_y
\right ) \right]\ ! \ ! , \label{bw5 } \\ \omega_7 ( + , \mp , + ,
\pm ) \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! & = & \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! \ ! 2 \exp \
\left [ \frac{\beta}{4 } \left ( j_z + \frac{j_1 - j_2}{4 } \right ) \right ] \
! \cosh \
! \left [ \frac{\beta}{4 } \left(j_x - j_y \right ) \right ] + 2 \exp \!\left[- \frac{\beta}{4 } \left ( j_z + \frac{j_1 - j_2}{4 } \right ) \right ] \
! \cosh \
! \left [ \frac{\beta}{4 } \left(j_x + j_y
\right ) \right]\ ! \!.
\label{bw7}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the effective boltzmann s weights ( [ bw1])-([bw7 ] ) are assigned to eight spin configurations of four nodal ising spins explicitly specified in round brackets ( the symbol @xmath31 denotes the spin state @xmath32 , @xmath33 ) , as well as , another eight spin configurations , which can be obtained from them under the reversal of all four nodal ising spins . a substitution of the generalized star - square transformation ( [ sst ] ) with appropriately chosen mapping parameters ( [ ev ] ) into eq .
( [ pf1 ] ) then straightforwardly leads to a precise mapping equivalence between the spin-1/2 ising - heisenberg model and the zero - field eight - vertex model . as a result of this procedure , one actually obtains a simple mapping relationship @xmath34 which connects the partition function of the investigated ising - heisenberg model with the partition function of the spin-1/2 ising model on two interpenetrating square lattices that are coupled together by means of the quartic interaction ( @xmath35 is the total number of the ising spins ) .
it should be mentioned that the latter model is nothing but one of many alternative definitions of _ the zero - field eight - vertex model _
@xcite , which is reformulated in the ising spin representation following the ideas of wu @xcite , kadanoff and wegner @xcite .
besides , the physical meaning of the mapping parameters @xmath23 , @xmath24 and @xmath25 becomes quite evident from the mapping transformation ( [ sst ] ) .
the parameters @xmath23 and @xmath24 denote the effective pair interactions in two different interpenetrating ising square lattices and the mapping parameter @xmath25 determines the effective quartic interaction that couples together both ising square lattices .
last but not least , the mapping parameter @xmath26 ( multiplicative factor in eq .
( [ pf2 ] ) ) in fact represents the partition function of the heisenberg spin pair in the effective field produced by the four enclosing nodal ising spins .
it becomes quite clear from the mapping relationship ( [ pf2 ] ) that the ising - heisenberg model becomes critical just if the corresponding zero - field eight - vertex model becomes critical as well . as a matter of fact , the partition function @xmath36 will exhibit a non - analyticity if and only if the corresponding partition function @xmath37 will exhibit the same kind of the non - analytic behavior , because the parameter @xmath26 is analytic in the whole region of interaction parameters . in this regard , the respective critical points of the ising - heisenberg model can be found from the relevant critical condition of the zero - field eight - vertex model @xcite @xmath38 which determines phase transitions of the ising - heisenberg model on assumption that the effective boltzmann s weights ( [ bw1])-([bw7 ] ) are substituted into this critical condition .
it should be also mentioned that the critical exponents of the zero - field eight - vertex model @xcite continuously change with the parameter @xmath39 by following the formulas @xmath40 consequently , the relations ( [ ce ] ) will also govern changes of the critical exponents of the ising - heisenberg model when the effective boltzmann s weights ( [ bw1])-([bw7 ] ) are used for a calculation of the parameter @xmath41 .
in this part , let us proceed to a discussion of the most interesting results obtained for critical properties of the spin-1/2 ising - heisenberg model with the pair and quartic interactions .
before doing so , however , it is worthy of notice that some special cases of this model system have already been investigated by the present authors in our earlier paper @xcite , where the critical behavior of the particular case with two identical quartic interactions @xmath42 and the more symmetric @xmath43 heisenberg interaction ( @xmath44 ) was explored in detail by assuming both ferromagnetic as well as antiferromagnetic pair interaction .
exact results for this more symmetric version of the ising - heisenberg model indicate that the model with the antiferromagnetic pair interaction exhibits less significant changes of both critical temperatures as well as critical exponents than the model with the ferromagnetic pair interaction . as a matter of fact
, it has been demonstrated that only the ising - heisenberg model with the ferromagnetic pair interaction shows a unusual quantum critical point of the infinite order , which characterizes a remarkable singular behavior of the critical exponents near the isotropic limit of the heisenberg pair interaction ( @xmath45 ) . with this background ,
the main purpose of the present work is to shed light on how this strange weak - universal critical behavior will change by introducing a spatial anisotropy in two quartic ising - type interactions ( @xmath46 ) or by assuming the most general form of the @xmath0 exchange anisotropy in the heisenberg pair interaction .
it is worthwhile to remark that the investigated ising - heisenberg model possesses a rather high symmetry , because all four different boltzmann s weights ( [ bw1])-([bw7 ] ) are mutually interchangeable under the transformations @xmath47 and/or @xmath48 .
this means , among other matters , that one may further restrict both quartic interaction parameters to positive values , since the transformations @xmath47 and @xmath48 merely cause rather trivial changes of the nodal ising spins @xmath49 and @xmath50 , respectively . owing to this fact , let us further assume that all the interaction terms @xmath51 , @xmath52 , @xmath53 , @xmath7 , and @xmath8 entering the hamiltonian ( [ ham ] ) are positive and moreover , the symmetry of the hamiltonian allows us to consider @xmath54 and @xmath55 without loss of the generality . for easy reference ,
the number of free parameters is lowered by introducing the following set of dimensionless parameters : @xmath56 marks the dimensionless temperature , @xmath57 and @xmath58 are proportional to a relative strength of the quartic ising - type interactions , and finally , the parameters @xmath59 and @xmath60 measure a relative strength of the exchange anisotropy in the @xmath0 heisenberg pair interaction . the former anisotropy parameter @xmath59 determines a difference in the exchange interactions along a quantization @xmath61-axis and its perpendicular @xmath62-axis , whereas the latter anisotropy parameter determines a difference between the stronger and weaker exchange interaction in the @xmath63-plane .
first , let us take a closer look at the ground - state behavior .
it can be readily understood that the ground - state spin arrangement will always correspond to the lowest - energy eigenstate that enters into the greatest boltzmann s weight among the four boltzmann s weights given by eqs .
( [ bw1])-([bw7 ] ) . in the zero temperature limit ,
the greatest boltzmann s weight is @xmath64 if @xmath65 or @xmath66 if @xmath67 .
this observation would suggest that the ground - state spin arrangement will basically change whenever the weaker exchange interaction @xmath52 in the @xmath63-plane exceeds the exchange interaction @xmath53 along the quantization axis .
one actually finds that the lowest - energy eigenstate is either @xmath68 if @xmath65 , or , @xmath69 if the reverse inequality holds . in eqs .
( [ gsa])([gsb ] ) , the former ket vector unambiguously determines the states of four nodal ising spins from an elementary square face of the @xmath16th octahedron and the latter ket vector unambiguously specifies the relevant state of the heisenberg spin pair .
it should be also noticed that another equivalent representations of these eigenstates can be obtained from the eigenvectors ( [ gsa])([gsb ] ) under the reversal of all four nodal ising spins and consequently , the phases @xmath70 and @xmath71 are both four - fold degenerate .
let us now make a few comments on spin arrangements appearing in both ground - state phases .
in the phase @xmath70 , the ising spins placed on a square lattice either exhibit a perfect ferromagnetic or antiferromagnetic long - range order , which is accompanied with the entangled spin state @xmath72 consisting of both ferromagnetic states of the heisenberg spin pairs . on the other hand ,
the heisenberg spin pairs reside in the phase @xmath71 the entangled spin state @xmath73 consisting of both antiferromagnetic states and the ising spins prefer a superantiferromagnetic long - range order with the ferromagnetic alignment in a horizontal direction and the antiferromagnetic alignment in a vertical direction , or vice versa . to compare with , is might quite useful to mention that the phase @xmath71 preserves its character even if the less general case of the @xmath43 exchange anisotropy is assumed , whereas the spin arrangement of the phase @xmath70 drastically changes disentanglement of both ferromagnetic states of the heisenberg spin pairs @xmath74 in the particular limit @xmath75 , the phase @xmath76 actually becomes macroscopically degenerate as the heisenberg spin pairs may choose independently of each other one of two ferromagnetic states @xmath77 .
hence , it follows that the phase @xmath76 will exhibit a rather high macroscopical degeneracy of the order @xmath78 , which is proportional to the total number of the heisenberg spin pairs ( remember that @xmath35 simultaneously marks the total number of the ising spins , the total number of the heisenberg spin pairs , as well as , the total number of elementary unit cells ) .
now , we will turn our attention to a detailed study of finite - temperature phase diagrams .
one should recall that phase transition lines of the spin-1/2 ising - heisenberg model with the pair and quartic interactions can be straightforwardly calculated from the critical condition of the corresponding zero - field eight - vertex model by substituting the effective boltzmann s weights ( [ bw1])([bw7 ] ) into eq .
( [ cc ] ) .
it is worthwhile to remember , moreover , that the greatest boltzmann s weight is either @xmath64 or @xmath66 . for both particular cases ,
the critical condition can uniquely be expressed as @xmath79 } { \cosh \left [ \frac{\beta_{\rm c } } { 16 } \left(j_1 - j_2 \right ) \right ] } = \pm \frac{\cosh \left [ \frac{\beta_{\rm c } } { 4 } \left(j_x - j_y \right ) \right ] + \exp \left(- \frac{\beta_{\rm c } j_z}{2 } \right ) \cosh \left [ \frac{\beta_{\rm c}}{4 } \left(j_x + j_y \right ) \right]}{\cosh \left [ \frac{\beta_{\rm c } } { 4 } \left(j_x - j_y \right ) \right ] - \exp \left(- \frac{\beta_{\rm c } j_z}{2 } \right ) \cosh \left [ \frac{\beta_{\rm c}}{4 } \left(j_x + j_y \right ) \right ] } , \label{ccef}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath80 , @xmath81 is the critical temperature and the plus ( minus ) sign applies for a situation when @xmath82 ( @xmath83 ) . by exploiting the critical condition ( [ ccef ] ) ,
let us examine first how a spatial anisotropy in two quartic ising - type interactions influences the critical behavior of the model under investigation . to see this effect ,
the critical temperature is plotted in figure [ fig2 ] against the anisotropy parameter @xmath59 for the particular case of the @xmath43 exchange anisotropy ( i.e. @xmath84 ) when a strength of the stronger quartic interaction is fixed ( @xmath85 ) and a strength of the weaker quartic interaction varies .
as one can see , the phase diagram consists of two marked wings of critical lines that separate both spontaneously long - range ordered phases @xmath70 and @xmath71 , since both critical lines merge together at the ground - state boundary @xmath45 between these two phases .
it is noteworthy that the left ( right ) wing represents a line of critical points of the phase @xmath70 ( the phase @xmath71 ) , which can be obtained as a numerical solution of the critical condition ( [ ccef ] ) by assuming the plus ( minus ) sign therein .
it becomes quite evident from figure [ fig2 ] that one may also found reentrant phase transitions slightly above the ground - state boundary between the phases @xmath70 and @xmath71 , i.e. under the constraint @xmath86 . in this parameter region ,
the reentrant phase transitions from the spontaneously ordered phase @xmath71 to the disordered phase and from the disordered phase to the spontaneously ordered phase @xmath70 take place because the free energy of the phase @xmath70 decreases much more rapidly with the increase of temperature than the free energy of the phase @xmath71 due to the much higher entropy gain of the phase @xmath70 . another
interesting fact to observe here is that a spatial anisotropy in the quartic ising - type interactions does not qualitatively affect the critical behavior of the investigated model system . as it can be easily understood from eqs .
( [ ev ] ) and ( [ bw5])([bw7 ] ) , the spatial anisotropy in the quartic ising - type interactions @xmath46 merely causes an anisotropy in the effective pair interactions @xmath87 of two ising square lattice coupled together through the effective quartic interaction @xmath25 when speaking in the language of the ising spin representation of the corresponding zero - field eight - vertex model .
of course , it is well known that the anisotropy in those pair interactions does not fundamentally affect the overall critical behavior of the zero - field eight - vertex model . for the ising - heisenberg model with the @xmath43 exchange anisotropy ( @xmath75 ) when a strength of the one quartic ising - type interaction is fixed ( @xmath85 ) and that of another one quartic ising - type interaction @xmath58 varies.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] for the sake of comparison , we have displayed in figure [ fig3 ] the critical temperature as a function of the exchange anisotropy @xmath59 for one illustrative example of the less symmetric @xmath0 exchange anisotropy ( @xmath88 ) when a strength of the stronger quartic interaction is fixed ( @xmath85 ) and a strength of the weaker quartic interaction varies . it can be clearly seen from this figure that the finite - temperature phase diagram of this more general case quite closely resembles the one formerly discussed by the analysis of the particular case with the @xmath43 exchange anisotropy .
actually , one still finds two wings of the critical lines that separate both spontaneously long - range ordered phases @xmath70 and @xmath71 , whereas the zero - temperature transition between these phases moves towards the higher values of the exchange anisotropy @xmath59 as it occurs just if the weaker exchange interaction in the @xmath63-plane @xmath52 overwhelms the one @xmath53 along the quantization axis . however , the most obvious difference between the phase diagrams shown in figures [ fig2 ] and [ fig3 ] is that the latter phase diagram does not imply an existence of the reentrant phase transitions near the ground - state boundary between the phases @xmath70 and @xmath71 .
this specific feature can be attributed to the fact that the macroscopical degeneracy of the phase @xmath70 is entirely lifted whenever the most general case of the @xmath0 exchange anisotropy is assumed .
hence , it follows that both wings of critical lines tend to zero temperature with an infinite gradient and thus , there does not emerge reentrant phase transitions near the ground - state boundary between the phases @xmath70 and @xmath71 . to provide an independent check of the aforementioned scenario , the critical temperature is plotted in figure [ fig4 ] against the exchange anisotropy @xmath59 for one selected value of the quartic ising - type interactions ( @xmath89 ) at four different strengths of the exchange anisotropy @xmath60 .
figure [ fig4 ] apparently supports all previous statements , since the critical lines obviously have vertical tangents at the zero - temperature transition between the phases @xmath70 and @xmath71 , which is generally shifted towards the higher values of the anisotropy parameter @xmath59 upon strengthening the exchange anisotropy in the @xmath63-plane ( i.e. when the ratio @xmath60 is lowered ) .
altogether , it could be concluded that the spatial anisotropy in the quartic ising - type interactions has a less significant impact on the overall critical behavior compared to the exchange anisotropy of the heisenberg pair interaction .
therefore , our subsequent analysis will be mainly concentrated on how the exchange anisotropy in the heisenberg pair interaction influences the most essential features of the critical behavior . for the ising - heisenberg model with the @xmath0 exchange anisotropy ( @xmath90 ) when a strength of the one quartic ising - type interaction is fixed ( @xmath85 ) and that of another one quartic ising - type interaction @xmath58 varies.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] for the spin-1/2 ising - heisenberg model with a fixed strength of the quartic ising - type interactions ( @xmath89 ) at four different values of the exchange anisotropy @xmath60.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] at this place , let us make a few remarks on possible changes of the critical behavior and critical exponents , which can be induced upon varying the anisotropy parameters @xmath59 and @xmath60 . for this purpose , the figures [ fig5][fig7 ] display typical changes of the critical temperature and the critical exponent @xmath91 with the anisotropy parameter @xmath59 for the ising - heisenberg model with a fixed strength of the quartic ising - type interactions ( @xmath89 ) at three different values of the exchange anisotropy @xmath92 , @xmath93 and @xmath94 , respectively . in these figures ,
solid lines scaled with respect to left axes depict a variation of the critical temperature with the exchange anisotropy @xmath59 , while broken lines scaled with respect to right axes show in a semilogarithmic scale the relevant changes of the critical exponent @xmath91 .
the figures on the left show the overall finite - temperature phase diagrams , whereas the figures on the right show in an enlargened scale the most striking part of these phase diagrams in a close vicinity of the ground - state boundary between the phases @xmath70 and @xmath71 . along the critical line of the spin-1/2 ising - heisenberg model with a fixed relative strength of the quartic ising - type interactions @xmath89 and the exchange anisotropy @xmath92 .
the solid line , which is scaled with respect to the left axis , shows the critical temperature as a function of the exchange anisotropy @xmath59 . the broken line , which is scaled with respect to the right axis , displays in a semilogarithmic scale the relevant changes of the critical exponent @xmath91 along this critical line .
figure 5b ) shows a detail of the phase diagram near the zero - temperature transition.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] , but for the exchange anisotropy @xmath95.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] , but for the exchange anisotropy @xmath96.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] it is quite obvious from figures [ fig5][fig7 ] that the critical exponent @xmath91 varies continuously along the line of critical points , because its value changes with the interaction parameters involved in the hamiltonian ( [ ham ] ) according to the relation ( [ ce ] ) through the respective changes of the parameter @xmath41 .
it should be pointed out , moreover , that the relevant changes of the critical exponent bring also insight into a nature of phase transitions as the order of phase transitions is proportional to @xmath97 ( see for instance pp .
1617 in reference @xcite ) .
from this point of view , the displayed critical lines turn out to be lines of rather smooth continuous phase transitions , since the respective variations of the critical exponent @xmath91 are restricted to the range @xmath98 and consequently , the order of phase transitions is @xmath99 .
however , the most striking finding to emerge from figures [ fig5][fig7 ] is that the critical exponent @xmath91 exhibits a very special singular behavior in a neighborhood of the ground - state boundary between the phases @xmath70 and @xmath71 where @xmath100 . in this respect
, the zero - temperature phase transition between the phases @xmath70 and @xmath71 might be regarded as a phase transition of the infinite order and hence , this special critical point in fact represents a quite remarkable quantum critical point .
another interesting finding stems from a direct comparison of the figures [ fig5]b)[fig7]b ) . in agreement with the aforedescribed analysis
, the reentrant phase transitions occur in a vicinity of the zero - temperature transition between the phases @xmath70 and @xmath71 by considering the @xmath43 exchange anisotropy ( figure [ fig5]b ) , while the reentrant phenomenon obviously vanishes when considering the sufficiently strong @xmath0 exchange anisotropy ( figure [ fig7]b ) .
a disappearance of the reentrant transitions occurs on behalf of the @xmath0 exchange anisotropy , which generally lifts a macroscopical degeneracy of the phase @xmath70 , as it has been reasoned by the ground - state analysis . owing to this fact , the critical lines of both four - fold degenerate phases @xmath70 and @xmath71 should always tend to zero temperature with the infinite gradient at the ground - state boundary between them whenever the @xmath0 exchange anisotropy is considered .
the quite interesting situation thus appears if there is a small but non - zero exchange anisotropy between both interactions in the @xmath63-plane ( see figure [ fig6]b ) . in this particular case ,
both critical lines meet at the ground - state boundary between the phases @xmath70 and @xmath71 with an infinite gradient but they curve in the same direction at small enough temperatures , which gives rise to another type of the reentrant phenomenon @xcite . naturally , the greater a difference between the exchange interactions @xmath51 and @xmath52 is , the smaller is a temperature range where the reentrant phenomenon may be observed .
in this work , the critical properties of the spin-1/2 ising - heisenberg model with the pair @xmath0 heisenberg interaction and two quartic ising - type interactions have been studied in particular within the exact mapping technique based on the generalized star - square transformation .
this algebraic transformation establishes an exact mapping equivalence between the proposed ising - heisenberg model and the baxter s zero - field ( symmetric ) eight - vertex model , which has been subsequently used for obtaining several interesting exact results for the ground - state and finite - temperature phase diagrams , phase transitions and critical phenomena .
the most interesting finding to emerge from the present study is an exact evidence of the quantum critical point , which appears whenever the weaker exchange interaction in the @xmath63-plane equals the exchange interaction @xmath53 along the quantization axis , i.e. whenever @xmath101 .
it turns out that the critical exponents exhibit a peculiar singular behavior in a close vicinity of this quantum critical point , which consequently represents a phase transition of the infinite order .
the main emphasis of the present paper was to provide a deeper insight into how a spatial anisotropy in two quartic ising - type interactions and the exchange anisotropy in the @xmath0 heisenberg pair interaction influence the striking weak - universal critical behavior .
it has been shown that a spatial anisotropy in two quartic ising - type interactions has less pronounced effect on the critical behavior , which changes quantitatively rather than qualitatively upon varying the anisotropy in two quartic ising - type interactions .
on the other hand , the exchange anisotropy in the @xmath0 heisenberg pair interaction significantly changes the overall critical behavior , namely , it enables to change a location of the quantum critical point as well as an appearance ( or disappearance ) of the reentrant phase transitions .
this work was supported by the slovak research and development agency under the contract lpp-0107 - 06 . the financial support provided by ministry of education of slovak republic under the grant no .
vega 1/0128/08 is also gratefully acknowledged . | spin-1/2 ising - heisenberg model with @xmath0 heisenberg pair interaction and two different ising quartic interactions is exactly solved with the help of the generalized star - square transformation , which establishes a precise mapping equivalence with the corresponding eight - vertex model on a square lattice generally satisfying baxter s zero - field ( symmetric ) condition .
the investigated model exhibits a remarkable weak - universal critical behavior with two marked wings of critical lines along which critical exponents vary continuously with the interaction parameters . both wings of critical lines merge together at a very special quantum critical point of the infinite order , which can be characterized through diverging critical exponents . the possibility of observing reentrant phase transitions in a close vicinity of the quantum critical point is related to a relative strength of the exchange anisotropy in the @xmath0 heisenberg pair interaction .
address = department of theoretical physics and astrophysics , faculty of science , + p. j. afrik university , park angelinum 9 , 040 01 koice , slovak republic address = department of applied mathematics , faculty of mechanical engineering , + technical university , letn 9 , 042 00 koice , slovak republic address = graduate school of mathematics , nagoya university , nagoya 464 - 8602 , japan |
it is well - known that the magnetic susceptibility of a spin model near its critical temperature can be parametrized as @xmath0 in this expression , the exponents @xmath1 and @xmath2 are universal and can be obtained from the calculation of the eigenvalues of the linearized renormalization group ( rg ) transformation . on the other hand , the critical amplitudes @xmath3 are functions of the microscopic details of the theory .
one can find universal relations @xcite among these amplitudes and the ones associated with other thermodynamic quantities , however these relations do not fix completely the amplitudes . in the end , if we want a quantitative estimate of a particular amplitude , we need to perform a calculation which requires a knowledge of many details of the rg flows .
such a calculation is in general a difficult , nonlinear , multivariable problem . in this article
we propose a general strategy based on the construction of nonlinear scaling fields associated with _
several _ fixed points , to calculate the critical amplitudes , and we demonstrate its feasibility in the case of dyson s hierarchical model . a common strategy in problems involving nonlinear flows near a singular point , is to construct a new system of coordinates for which the governing equations become linear .
it seems intuitively clear that if the original problem is sufficiently nontrivial , normal form methods can only work in some limited way , locally , because the flows of the nonlinear problem have global properties which do not match those of the linear flows . a well - known argument for the inadequacy of such procedure ( which extends beyond the special case of an expansion near a singular point )
was provided by poincar @xcite in the context of perturbed integrable hamiltonians .
he discovered that even though it is possible to write a formal perturbative series for the action - angle variables , some coefficients have `` small denominators '' , and generically , the series are ill - defined . however , under some restrictions ( formulated according to some appropriate version of the k. a. m. theorem @xcite ) , perturbation theory can still provide interesting information .
almost thirty years ago , wegner@xcite , introduced quantities that transformed multiplicatively under a rg transformation .
he called them `` scaling fields '' and we will use his terminology in the following . sometimes , one also uses the terminology `` nonlinear scaling field '' to distinguish them from the linear ones ( see section [ sec:3steps ] for details ) . in the following , `` scaling fields '' mean the nonlinear ones and we will use the terminology `` linear scaling fields '' when necessary .
these fields play a central role in the presentation of the basic ideas of the rg .
they appear in almost any review on the subject ( see for instance ref .
@xcite ) . as in the case of hamiltonian dynamics
, there exists a formal series expansion for the scaling variables ( see eq .
( 4.9 ) in ref .
it is commonly assumed that the functions defined with this procedure are analytic , at least within a certain neighborhood of the fixed point .
however , for most non - trivial models , it is very difficult to prove this assumption .
in particular , it is difficult to address the question of small denominators because it requires an accurate calculation of the eigenvalues of the linearized rg transformation .
if the small denominator problem can be controlled and if some _ local _ expansion is well - defined , there remain several important _ global _ issues .
what is the domain of convergence of this expansion ?
how does the accuracy of an expansion with a finite number of terms evolve when we move away from the fixed point ?
can different expansions have overlapping domain of convergence ? these important _ global _ issues are rarely discussed because of practical limitations : in crossover regions , we need large order expansions in many variables . unfortunately , this problem has to be faced if we want to calculate all the critical amplitudes . in this article
, we propose a general strategy to calculate directly the critical amplitudes .
this strategy has been developed using dyson s hierarchical model , where large order expansions in many variables are practically feasible .
all the numerical calculations presented hereafter were done with this model ( or a simplified version of it ) .
the general point of view that we want to advocate here is that one should combine different sets of scaling fields .
even though the scaling fields are almost always constructed in the vicinity of wilson s fixed point , they can in principle be constructed near any other fixed point . if one can find some overlap among the domains of convergence of these expansions it is possible to reconstruct the flows , given their initial values .
in other words , we would like to develop a new analytical approach to complement the existing methods used to deal with the crossover between fixed points , namely , the monte carlo method @xcite , a combination of field - theoretical methods and mean field calculations @xcite or the study of the entropy associated with the rg flows @xcite . in the following , we concentrate on the study of the rg flows in the symmetric phase of spin models having a nontrivial unstable fixed point .
our goal is to calculate the critical amplitudes by constructing the scaling fields near the three relevant fixed points : the gaussian fixed point ( if relevant ) , the unstable fixed point ( sometimes called the ir fixed point or wilson s fixed point ) , and the high - temperature ( ht ) fixed point .
the idea is represented schematically in fig .
[ fig : pic ] . we propose to follow three specific steps to achieve this goal .
these steps correspond to a construction in backward order , starting with the flows near the ht fixed point and ending with the initial conditions .
first , we express the thermodynamic quantities in terms of the scaling fields of the ht fixed point .
second , we use the scaling fields of the unstable ir fixed point , to write the thermodynamic quantities as a main singularity times a rg invariant quantity constructed out the two scaling fields .
third , we calculate the initial values of the scaling fields associated with the unstable fixed point in terms of the basic parameters appearing the microscopic hamiltonian .
these three steps are explained in more detail in section [ sec:3steps ] .
this section is essential to understand the general ideas and the notations used later .
it should be noted that the first two steps are independent of the initial conditions and are in some sense universal . on the other hand ,
the third step provides the initial data as a function of the basic parameters such as the temperature or the `` bare parameters '' of landau - ginzburg models .
consequently , the method used to implement the third step depends on the initial measure considered .
for instance , if we start with an initial measure near the gaussian fixed point , perturbative field theoretical methods ( feynman diagrams ) will be used .
each of these three steps can in principle be implemented for spin models with nearest neighbor interactions in three dimensions , by using available expansions to describe the flows in each region . however , in order to discuss the behavior of the expansions in the crossover region , we need large order expansions . despite the existence of increasingly sophisticated methods used for various expansions in nearest neighbor models ( see e.g. , ref .
@xcite ) , it is still a major time investment to perform these expansions . in order to test the feasibility of the procedure , we have considered approximations for which large order expansions ( see e.g. , refs .
@xcite ) can be reached more easily .
namely , we have used hierarchical approximations where only the local part of the measure is renormalized under a rg transformation .
well - known examples are the `` approximate recursion formula '' @xcite or dyson s hierarchical model ( hm)@xcite . despite this approximation , the nonlinear aspects of the problem are still nontrivial . to fix the ideas , the calculations that we have performed
required the determination of several thousands of coefficients in various expansions .
the relevant facts about the hm and its rg transformation are reviewed in section [ sec : hm ] . before embarking in a multivariable calculation ,
we have first considered a simplified version involving only one variable@xcite where the small denominator problem is obviously absent . this model discussed in section [ sec : tm ] , is simply a quadratic map with two fixed points , one stable and one unstable .
series expansions for the scaling fields of this simplified model , and their inverse , can easily be constructed . treating these numerical series with well - known estimators @xcite
, we obtain radii of convergence and exponents in very good agreement with what we can infer by using general arguments .
these numerical results will be used as references when a similar analysis is conducted later for the hm . the most important result of section [ sec : tm ] is illustrated fig .
[ fig : tmoverlap ] which shows that the expansions of the scaling fields scale accurately in overlapping regions .
the rest of the article is devoted to the hm with one spin component per site ( as in the ising model ) .
for this model , the existence of a non - trivial unstable fixed point has been proven rigorously @xcite .
significant results have been obtained regarding the _ local _ existence of scaling fields for the rg map near the unstable fixed point by collet and eckmann @xcite and koch and wittwer @xcite .
in addition , ref .
@xcite contains a mathematical justification of the polynomial approximations that we have used to perform large order ht expansions @xcite or direct numerical calculations @xcite . in the following
, the parameter playing the role of the dimensionality ( see section [ sec : hm ] ) will be tuned in such way that a gaussian massless field scales exactly as in three dimensions . in other words
, we will work at an intermediate value between the upper and lower critical dimensions and the @xmath4-expansion is not obviously useful .
for this particular choice of the dimensionality parameter , the numerical value of the unstable fixed point is known with great precision in a specific system of coordinates @xcite and the question of small denominators studied in ref .
@xcite . using these results
we first provide an explicit construction of the two sets of scaling fields and show that the first two steps can be implemented .
we found simple linear relations between the derivatives of the free energy and the ht scaling fields .
the rg invariants discussed above can be calculated accurately ( see fig . [
fig : rginv ] ) because the scaling fields associated with the two fixed points scale accurately in overlapping regions as shown in fig .
[ fig : hmoverlap ] .
the third step was performed in the case of an initial ising measure where the temperature is the only free parameter .
putting everything together , we can calculate the leading and subleading amplitude of the susceptibility and have very good agreement with previous numerical calculations @xcite .
this demonstrates the feasibility of the proposed startegy . in the conclusions ,
we discuss our plans to extend this method for perturbative initial conditions and for nearest neighbor models .
a few words of caution .
we want to make clear that the main result presented in this article is a calculation of the leading and subleading critical amplitudes of the magnetic susceptibility of the hierarchical model .
this calculation shows that the strategy discussed in the coming section ii can be implemented successfully for this particular model .
the fact that part of the introduction and section ii are written for a general spin model should not be interpreted as the statement that it is straightforward to implement the strategy for other models than the hierarchical model .
the reader whose main interest is the hierarchical model may read section ii as a general description of what is done in the rest of the paper . on the other hand ,
the reader interested in using the general strategy for other models , should be aware that we do not provide a general procedure for constructing the unstable fixed point and its scaling fields .
in addition , the fact that we found overlapping domain of convergence in the particular computation presented here is an encouraging result but it does not guarantee that a similar overlap will be found for other models .
in this section , we consider a scalar model on a @xmath5-dimensional lattice with a lattice spacing @xmath6 .
we assume that @xmath7 and that the free energy density @xmath8 is finite in the thermodynamic limit .
we discuss the estimation of the critical amplitudes in the ht phase for @xmath9 , the @xmath10-th derivative of @xmath11 with respect to an external magnetic field . for definiteness , we generalize the parametrization of eq .
( [ eq : param ] ) to @xmath12 we assume the existence of a discrete rg transformation @xmath13 , which can be performed in the following way .
we first integrate the fields in blocks of side @xmath14 while keeping the sum of the fields in the block constant .
we then rescale the sums of the fields by a factor @xmath15 . for the hm , @xmath16 and @xmath17 .
we assume that this rg transformation has one non - trivial unstable fixed point and an attractive ht fixed point .
we first introduce general notations for the scaling fields and then discuss the three steps .
a preliminary requisite is the construction of the two sets of scaling fields .
we construct the scaling fields near the unstable fixed point , denoted @xmath18 , in terms of the coordinates @xmath19 in the directions of the eigenvectors of the linearized rg map at that fixed point .
the boldface notations mean that the quantity is a vector . in the following
we will consider finite dimensional approximations for such vectors .
for small values of @xmath20 , we have @xmath21 .
one could call the @xmath19 , the `` linear scaling fields '' or the `` real fields '' @xcite if they have a simple physical interpretation .
if we denote the rg transformation in the @xmath19 coordinates as @xmath22 , and @xmath23 as the eigenvalue in the @xmath24-th direction , we have by definition of the scaling fields @xmath25 in the following , we assume that the spectrum is real , positive , non - degenerate and that only @xmath26 . similarly , the ht scaling fields denoted @xmath27 , can be constructed as expansions in the coordinates @xmath28 in the directions of the eigenvectors of the linearized rg map at the ht fixed point . with notation analog to eq .
( [ eq : scaw ] ) , we have @xmath29 the @xmath19 s can be expressed in terms of the @xmath28 s by a shift followed by a linear transformation . in the following @xmath30 or @xmath31
will denote the value of the @xmath10-th scaling field after @xmath32 iterations , and similar notations will be used for the ht variables .
the first step consists in expressing the @xmath9 in terms of the scaling fields of the ht fixed point @xmath33 . in the vicinity of the ht fixed point ,
the effective lattice spacing becomes larger than the physical correlation lengths .
this fixed point is attractive and as the number of iterations @xmath32 becomes large , one can treat the blocks as almost isolated systems with a large volume @xmath34 . in the following we call @xmath35 the average value of the @xmath10-th power of the total spin in this volume minus its disconnected parts , divided by the volume . assuming that @xmath36 is finite for @xmath37 , we conclude that the subtracted average value of the @xmath10-th power of the _ rescaled _ sum of all the spins scales like @xmath38 for @xmath32 large and should be expressible as products of the @xmath33 with product of eigenvalues @xmath39 .
indeed , in explicit calculations for the hm model , we found that simple linear relations hold , namely , when @xmath32 becomes large @xmath40 and consequently , @xmath41 with @xmath42 denoting the initial values and @xmath43 a constant depending on the choice the scales of the coordinates @xmath28 and easily calculable .
this is discussed explicitly in subsection [ subsec : hmstep1 ] for the hm . for the simplicity of the exposition
, we will assume that this is also true for other models .
nevertheless it is straightforward to generalize the construction for the case of products of ht scaling fields .
the expansion of @xmath44 is expected to converge for @xmath42 small enough , however it might not be very useful or even meaningful near the unstable fixed point or the gaussian fixed point .
if @xmath45denotes the leading critical exponent for @xmath46 , it follows from arguments based on the linear rg transformation that @xmath47 = - ln@xmath48/ln@xmath49 .
consequently , @xmath50 is rg - invariant .
we can then factor out the susceptibility into a singular part and a rg invariant part : @xmath51 \ .
\label{eq : gensus}\ ] ] the factor in large brackets is rg - invariant and does not need necessarily to be evaluated for initial values of @xmath28 . we can use the @xmath32-th iterate of these values @xmath52 for any @xmath32 and get the same answer . in particular , we can choose @xmath32 is such a way that the flow is `` in between '' the two fixed points considered here , in a crossover region where the two expansions have a chance to be valid .
one of the main results presented in this article are numerical evidences that this procedure actually works .
in other words , that there exists an overlap between the domains where approximate expansions of the scaling fields scale as they should .
the scaling properties of expansions are related to convergence issues which need to be discussed in the complexification of the construction . if an eigenvalue appearing in the defining equation for the scaling fields eqs .
( [ eq : scaw ] ) and ( [ eq : scat ] ) , is such that @xmath53 , it is clear that the only values that can be taken by @xmath54 at a fixed point are 0 and @xmath55 .
consequently , a detailed analysis of the fixed points for the complexification of the rg transformation can put restrictions on the domain of convergence of the scaling fields .
later , the inverse functions @xmath56 or @xmath57 will also be used .
their radius of convergence can be restricted by the study of the extrema of the original function . in the case of the one dimensional model of section
[ sec : tm ] , such a study can be conducted easily and confirms the results of the numerical analysis . near criticality , for the values of @xmath32 in the crossover discussed above , the values of the scaling fields associated with the irrelevant directions are usually very small ( unless very large initial values have been chosen ) and can be treated perturbatively . in first approximation
, we can consistently set the initial values of the irrelevant scaling fields to zero since they are multiplicatively renormalized . in this approximation
, we describe the flow along the unstable manifold . a local calculation involving a scaling field corresponding to the the relevant direction
is provided in ref .
@xcite following a procedure developed in ref .
@xcite to prove feigenbaum conjectures .
it should also be noted that since the rg considered here is discrete ( it is constructed by iterating @xmath13 an integer number of times ) , rg - invariant does not mean independent of @xmath42 .
there is room for log - periodic corrections , which have been first noticed by wilson @xcite , discussed in general in ref .
@xcite and observed in the ht expansion of the hm in refs .
these corrections are studied for the simplified model in section [ sec : tm ] . in our numerical study of the hm of section [ sec : hm ] , these corrections are too small to be resolved and will be ignored . in the previous step , we traded a difficult problem ( the estimation of the initial values of @xmath58 ) for two simpler problems : the estimation of the rg invariant and the estimation of the initial values of @xmath59 . up to now , we have treated these initial values as free variables and constructed functions of these variables which depended only on the rg transformation .
we now need to incorporate the information related to the actual initial values .
this calculation depends on the type of models considered .
for instance , for a ising model , one expects @xmath60 and @xmath61 for @xmath62 .
the @xmath63 are constants that we will evaluate numerically for the hm .
the non - leading terms are responsible for the analytical corrections and are usually difficult to resolve numerically .
a more complete construction of the initial values in terms of the `` bare parameters '' used in field theoretical perturbative calculations ( with flows starting near the gaussian fixed point ) is in progress @xcite but will not be discussed here .
in this section , we review the basic facts about the rg transformation of the hm to be used in the rest of the paper and discuss various way to obtain finite dimensional truncations . for more detail , the reader may consult ref .
@xcite and other papers quoted in the introduction .
the energy density of the hm has two parts .
one part is non - local ( the `` kinetic term '' ) and invariant under a rg transformation .
its explicit form can be found , for instance , in ref .
@xcite or in section ii of ref .
the other part is a sum of local potentials given in terms of a unique function @xmath64 .
the exponential @xmath65 will be called the local measure and denoted @xmath66 .
for instance , for landau - ginsburg models , the measures are of the form @xmath67 , but we can also consider limiting cases such as a ising measure @xmath68 . under a block spin transformation which integrates the spin variables in `` boxes '' with two sites , keeping their sum constant , the local measure transforms according to the integral formula @xmath69 where @xmath70 is the inverse temperature ( or the coefficient in front of the kinetic term ) and @xmath71 is a normalization factor to be fixed at our convenience .
we use the fourier transform @xmath72 and introduce a rescaling of @xmath73 by a factor @xmath74 , where @xmath75 and @xmath76 are constants to be fixed at our convenience , by defining @xmath77 in the following , we will use @xmath78 with @xmath79 .
this corresponds to the scaling of a massless gaussian field in @xmath5 dimensions .
contrarily to what we have done in the past , we will here absorb the temperature in the measure by setting @xmath80 . with these choices ,
the rg transformation reads @xmath81\left[r_{n } \left({\sqrt{c}k\over 2 }
\right ) \right]^2 \ .
\label{eq : rec}\ ] ] we fix the normalization constant @xmath82 so that @xmath83 . for an ising measure , @xmath84 , while in general , we have to numerically integrate to determine the coefficients of @xmath85 expanded in terms of @xmath73 . if we taylor expand about the origin , @xmath86 the finite - volume susceptibility reads @xmath87 the susceptibility @xmath88 is defined as @xmath89 . for @xmath70 larger than @xmath90 ,
the definition of @xmath88 requires a subtraction ( see e. g. , ref .
@xcite for a practical implementation ) . in the following
, we will only consider the ht phase ( @xmath91 ) .
the explicit form for @xmath92 in terms of @xmath93 reads @xmath94 where @xmath95 to study the susceptibility not too far from the ht fixed point , we can expand @xmath88 in terms of @xmath70 .
since we choose the scaling factor @xmath75 so that @xmath70 is eliminated from the recursion , we find that @xmath96 . from the form of the recursion , eq .
( [ eq : recursion ] ) , we can see that @xmath93 will always have @xmath97 as the leading power in its ht expansion ( since @xmath98 ) .
we define the coefficients of the expansion of the infinite - volume susceptibility by @xmath99 we define @xmath100 , the ratio of two successive coefficients , and introduce quantities @xcite , called the extrapolated ratio ( @xmath101 ) and the extrapolated slope ( @xmath102 ) which will be used later in a more general context and are defined by @xmath103 and @xmath104 where @xmath105 is called the normalized slope . if we calculate @xmath102 for the hm , we find oscillations illustrated in refs .
. the ht expansion can be calculated to very high order , however , due to the amplification of some subleading corrections by the estimators , this is an inefficient way to obtain information about the critical behavior of the hm . in ref .
@xcite , it was found that one can obtain much better results by neglecting the contribution of the @xmath93 when @xmath106 , with @xmath107 much smaller than the order of the ht expansion . as an example
, one can calculate the 1000-th ht coefficient of @xmath88 with 16 digits of accuracy using only 35 terms in the sum .
this is equivalent to consider the polynomial approximation @xmath108 for some integer @xmath107 .
there remains to decide if one should or not truncate to order @xmath109 after squaring @xmath110 .
this makes a difference since the exponential of the second derivative has terms with arbitrarily high order derivatives .
numerically , one gets better results at intermediate values of @xmath107 by keeping all the terms in @xmath111 . in addition , for the calculations performed later , the intermediate truncation pads the `` structure constants '' of the maps ( see sec .
[ sec : multi ] ) with about fifty percent of zeroes . a closer look at section [ sec : multi ] , may convince the reader that not truncating after squaring is more natural because we obtain correct ( in the sense that they keep their value when @xmath107 is increased ) structure constants in place of these zeroes .
we have thus followed the second possibility where we truncate only once at the end of the calculation . with this choice
@xmath112 compared to the ht expansion , the initial truncation to order @xmath107 is accurate up to order @xmath113 .
after one iteration , we will miss terms of order @xmath114 but we will also generate some of the contributions of order @xmath115 ( but not all of them ) .
after @xmath32 iterations we generate some of the terms of order @xmath116 as in superconvergent expansions . rigorous justifications of the polynomial truncation can be found in ref . @xcite .
before attacking the multivariable expansions of the scaling fields , we would like to illustrate the main ideas and study the convergence of series with a simple one variable example which retains the important features : a critical temperature , rg flows going from an unstable fixed point to a stable one , and log - periodic oscillations in the susceptibility .
in order to obtain a simple one - variable model , we first consider the @xmath117 truncation of eq . ( [ eq : truncation2 ] ) : @xmath118 expanding the denominator up to order @xmath119 in @xmath120 and using eq .
( [ eq : sus ] ) , we obtain @xmath121 this approximate equation was successfully used in ref .
@xcite to model the finite - size effects and was used as the starting point for a study of the scaling field in ref .
@xcite . if we expand @xmath88 ( the limit of @xmath122 when @xmath32 becomes infinite ) in @xmath70 , and define the extrapolated slope , @xmath123 , as in eq . ( [ eq : shat ] ) , we see oscillations in fig . [
fig : tmexslope ] quite similar to those in the hm @xcite . using a rescaling discussed in ref . @xcite and the notation @xmath124
, the map can be put in the canonical form @xmath125 we call this map the `` @xmath126-map ''
. it has a stable fixed point at 0 and an unstable fixed point at 1 .
we recover the susceptibility as : @xmath127 we can expand the map about the unstable fixed point , @xmath128 . using the new coordinate @xmath129 and the notation @xmath130 , we obtain the `` dual '' map @xmath131 with the starting value @xmath132 .
we call this map the `` @xmath133-map '' and we can think of @xmath133 as being the distance to the critical point
. we can construct a function @xmath133 such that @xmath134 by plugging an expansion in @xmath135 into the equation @xmath136 similarly , we can construct the inverse series and obtain @xmath137 .
this allows us construct @xmath138 in terms of @xmath139 : @xmath140 because of the duality between our two maps , we can easily reproduce all of the above results of the @xmath133-map for the @xmath126-map and express @xmath141 in terms of a ht scaling field @xmath142 .
we now turn to the three steps .
note that step 3 is not necessary : the knowledge of @xmath143 provides the initial value of @xmath144 as a function of @xmath70 .
step 1 is straightforward . as shown in ref .
@xcite , in the infinite @xmath32 limit , @xmath145 the only difficult part is step 2 .
the susceptibility can be written as @xmath146 with the rg invariant @xmath147 .
due to the discrete nature of our rg transformation , @xmath148 is not exactly a constant . if expressed in terms of ln(@xmath149 ) , @xmath148 is a periodic function of period ln@xmath150 .
however , for @xmath150 not too close to 2 , the non - zero fourier modes are very small .
note also that the apparent singularity when @xmath151 is exactly canceled by @xmath152 by virtue of eq .
( [ eq : yya ] ) discussed below .
we now give empirical results concerning the large order behavior of of the expansions of @xmath153 , @xmath154 and their inverses .
we first consider @xmath155 .
for all tested values of @xmath156 , we obtained very good linear fits of @xmath157 versus @xmath158 , for @xmath10 large enough .
thus for large @xmath10 , the coefficients obey the approximate rule @xmath159 where we find that @xmath160 is always of order @xmath161 ( in fact , @xmath162 ) and @xmath163 .
using iteratively this formula , we find that the coefficients decrease like @xmath164 and consequently the @xmath165 should be an entire function .
the numerical values of @xmath73 are given in fig .
[ fig : slope ] .
we then consider @xmath166 and again examine the ratios of successive coefficients , @xmath167 .
we find the ratios flatten to constant values , for large enough @xmath10 , indicating a finite radius of convergence .
the radius get smaller and vanish as @xmath168 approaches zero as shown in fig .
[ fig : radius ] .
note that for any value of @xmath168 tried , we found good evidence that @xmath169 , indicating a @xmath170 behavior .
this is consistent with the existence of a quadratic minimum for the inverse function discussed below .
we now turn to the inverse functions starting with @xmath153 . as @xmath171 , we reach the ht fixed point and we expect the convergence of the series to break down in this limit .
we find empirically from the analysis of ratios that for all @xmath156 , @xmath153 converges in the region @xmath172 .
the analysis of the extrapolated slope for various @xmath150 gives convincing evidence that the main singularity has the form @xmath173 this can be seen with short series when @xmath150 is close to one and requires larger and larger series as @xmath150 gets close to 2 .
illustration of these properties for a particular value of @xmath150 are shown in figs .
[ fig : rhdone ] and [ fig : shdone ] where the estimators are compared with those of the hm .
finally , we discuss @xmath154 which can be seen as a high - temperature expansion .
we found clear evidence that the ratio of coefficients @xmath174 approaches @xmath161 for large @xmath10 . for smaller values of @xmath168
, it takes larger order to reach this limit .
a detailed study shows that if we continue @xmath154 for negative values of @xmath126 using the series expansion , the function develops a quadratic minimum at some negative value of @xmath126 .
the absolute value of @xmath175 at that value of @xmath126 , in all examples studied , reproduces accurately the radius of convergence of the inverse function . as one may suspect by looking at fig .
[ fig : tmexslope ] , the analysis of the extrapolated slope is intricated . however , if we calculate enough terms and if @xmath150 is not too close to 2 , we get approximate results which are consistent with a main singularity of the form @xmath176 for instance , just by looking at the asymptotic behavior of fig . [
fig : tmexslope ] , one can see that @xmath177 , as expected , with errors of the order @xmath178 .
it is interesting to note the duality @xcite between eqs .
( [ eq : yya ] ) and ( [ eq : yta ] ) .
all the results concerning the convergence and the singularities have a simple interpretation .
the finite radius of convergence of @xmath144 and @xmath175 is due to the other fixed point which can not be located inside the domain of convergence . in this simple example
there are exactly two fixed points in the complexification of the map and this concludes the discussion . on the other hand ,
the finite radius of @xmath126 is due to a minimum of @xmath175 at negative values of @xmath126 while such a minimum does not appear for @xmath133 . as we have seen above
, @xmath179 is independent of @xmath32 .
we can thus pick @xmath32 such that we are just in the crossover region and @xmath180 expansions have a reasonable chance to be accurate . in order to test the accuracy of the approximations @xmath181 ( series expansion up to a certain order ) for various @xmath32
, we have prepared an empirical sequences of @xmath182 starting with @xmath183 .
we have then tested the scaling properties by calculating @xmath184 - 1|\ , \label{eq : bdn}\ ] ] where @xmath149 was calculated with 16 digits of accuracy by using enough terms in the expansion of @xmath143 . for double precision calculations ,
optimal approximations are those for which @xmath185 . for such approximation , the scaling is as good as it can possibly be given the accuracy of @xmath149 .
indeed , due to the peculiar way numerical errors propagate @xcite , one does not reach exactly the expected level @xmath186 .
we can define a similar dual quantity by replacing @xmath133 by @xmath126 and @xmath144 by @xmath175 . in this case , @xmath187 is estimated with the same accuracy as @xmath149 by stabilizing @xmath188 , for large enough @xmath32 .
we have performed this calculation for @xmath189 1.1 , 1.5 and 1.9 .
the conclusions in the three cases are identical .
for @xmath32 large enough , the @xmath190 of @xmath144 starts increasing from @xmath186 until it saturates around 1 . by increasing the number of terms in the expansion , we can increase the value of @xmath32 for which we start losing accuracy .
similarly , for @xmath32 low enough , the @xmath190 of @xmath175 starts increasing etc ... we want to know if it is possible to calculate enough terms in each expansion to get scaling with some desired accuracy for both functions .
the answer to this question is affirmative according to fig .
[ fig : tmoverlap ] for @xmath191 .
one sees , for instance , that with 10 terms in each series , we have scaling with about 1 part in 1000 near @xmath192 for both expansions .
the situation can be improved . for 70 - 70 expansions
, an optimal accuracy is reached from @xmath193 to 46 . for the other values of @xmath194 quoted above ,
similar conclusions are reached , the only difference being the optimal values of @xmath32 .
another evidence for overlapping convergence is that we can stabilize the rg invariant @xmath148 for a certain range of @xmath135 . to evaluate @xmath148
, we use the series expansions for @xmath175 and @xmath133 , cutting each off at some order : @xmath195 where @xmath196 and @xmath197 are the @xmath10th coefficients in the @xmath133 and @xmath175 series , respectively .
we have found that , given a fixed value of @xmath198 , the most accurate values for @xmath148 are obtained when @xmath199 . in fig .
[ fig : all ] , we show @xmath148 calculated by keeping @xmath200 terms each in the expansions for @xmath144 and @xmath175 . the result is plotted against @xmath201 . we used @xmath202 , which makes the oscillations much larger than , for example , near to @xmath203 . near the fixed points , we need more terms in the appropriate series to get accurate results .
we can study the oscillation we see in @xmath148 by looking at its fourier expansion .
since @xmath148 is periodic in @xmath204 , we can express @xmath205 where @xmath206 .
the coefficients are given as @xmath207 as an example , we calculated @xmath208 for @xmath202 where the oscillations are not too small .
the choice of the interval of integration can be inferred from fig .
[ fig : all ] .
if we had infinite series , the function would be exactly periodic .
for finite series , we see that @xmath209 can not be too large or too small . for intermediate values , we obtain @xmath210 . proceeding similarly
, we were able to resolve the next two fourier modes . for reference , the magnitude of @xmath211 is about @xmath212 . using @xmath213 together with eq .
( [ eq : chitm ] ) , we obtain the leading amplitude together with the analytical corrections coming from the nonlinear tems in @xmath153 .
for notational convenience , we first rewrite the unnormalized recursion given in eq .
( [ eq : truncation2 ] ) , using the `` structure constants '' : @xmath214 with @xmath215 these zeroes can be understood as a `` selection rule '' associated with the fact that @xmath93 is of order @xmath97 as explained in section [ sec : hm ] .
if we follow the truncation procedure explained in section [ sec : hm ] , the indices simply run over a finite number of values .
we use `` relativistic '' notations .
repeated indices mean summation .
the greek indices indices @xmath216 and @xmath217 go from @xmath218 to @xmath107 , while latin indices @xmath219 , @xmath24 go from 1 to @xmath107 .
obviously , @xmath220 is symmetric in @xmath216 and @xmath217 . by construction , @xmath221 and we can write the normalized recursion in the form : @xmath222 with @xmath223 .
we then expand the basic map of eq .
( [ eq : general ] ) about the two fixed points of interest , choosing coordinates such that the matrix associated with the linearized rg transformation becomes diagonal .
this matrix is not symmetric and the relations of orthogonality and completeness are left invariant under rescaling of any right eigenvector by a nonzero constant together with a rescaling of the corresponding left eigenvector by the inverse . in the following , we will fix this ambiguity by requiring , in analogy with section [ sec : tm ] that the `` other '' fixed point ( i.e. the one not located at the origin by construction ) be at @xmath224 in the new coordinates .
the ht fixed point is at the origin of the coordinates in eq .
( [ eq : general ] ) and all we need to do is diagonalizing the linear form @xmath225 .
this is quite simple because it is of the upper triangular form .
the eigenvalues are just the diagonal terms . from eq .
( [ eq : struct ] ) , one sees that @xmath10th diagonal term is given as @xmath226 this spectrum was obtained in lemma 3.3 of ref .
@xcite with a different method .
this spectrum has a simple interpretation which will be discussed below .
the upper diagonal form implies that the @xmath227 right eigenvector has only its @xmath10 first entries non - zero .
this means that if we truncate to @xmath228 , we are simply truncating to a subspace spanned by the first @xmath107 eigenvectors .
this is an interesting reinterpretation of the original polynomial truncation which can be applied for other models . introducing new coordinates @xmath229 , so that @xmath230 with @xmath231 the matrix of right eigenvectors , the rg transformation has the form @xmath232 note that the form of the eigenvectors guarantees that @xmath233 is of order @xmath97
this can be seen by inverting the linear change of variable using the matrix of left eigenvectors . due to the upper - diagonal form of the linear transformation
, the second left eigenvector has its first entry equal to zero , the third its first two entries etc ... . near the nontrivial fixed point
, we first use accurate values of the fixed point @xcite to bring the fixed point at the origin .
the eigenvectors are then calculated numerically using truncated forms of the linearized rg transformation .
there is no exact closure as in the ht case , however the first eigenvalues stabilize rapidly when @xmath107 increases .
there is only one eigenvalue larger than @xmath161 .
for instance the numerical values for @xmath234 are @xmath235 , @xmath236 .
a more complete list is given in ref .
@xcite . in summary , we can choose a system of coordinate @xmath237 where the unstable fixed point will be at the origin of the coordinate and the ht fixed point at @xmath238 , and such
that the rg transformation has the form @xmath239 we can express canonical coordinates ( linear scaling fields ) in terms of the nonlinear scaling fields : @xmath240 where the sums over the @xmath219 s run from @xmath218 to infinity in each variable and @xmath241 . using the notation @xmath242 ) and the product symbol , we may rewrite the expansion as @xmath243 using the transformation law for the scaling fields , we have @xmath244 each constant term , @xmath245 , is zero , as the scaling fields vanish at the fixed point . from eq .
( [ eq : hmdrules ] ) , we see that all but one of the linear terms are zero for each value of @xmath246 .
the remaining term is the one proportional to the @xmath246th scaling variable .
we take these coefficients to be @xmath161 , so that the @xmath247 for small @xmath248 . for the higher - order terms
, we obtain the recursion @xmath249 the calculation can be organized in such way that the r. h. s. of the equations are already known
. this will be the case for instance if we proceed order by order in @xmath250 , the degree of non - linearity .
this expansion may have small denominator problems .
however , as discussed in the introduction , using numerical values of the eigenvalues as calculated in @xcite , we did not find spectacular cancellations between the two terms entering the denominator .
we can likewise expand each @xmath251 in terms of scaling fields @xmath252 .
the derived recursions are identical in form to those derived above . from eq .
( [ eq : hteigenv ] ) , one sees that the denominator will vanish for some equations .
this question is discussed in @xcite where it is shown that to all order relevant for the following calculation , a zero denominator always comes with a zero numerator .
one can likewise find expansions of the scaling fields in terms of the canonical coordinates , by setting @xmath253 and requiring that when @xmath254 is replaced by @xmath255 , the function is multiplied by @xmath256 .
since @xmath255 has a denominator , it needs to be expanded for instance in increasing order of non - linearity .
a simple reasoning shows that exactly the same small denominators as in eq .
( [ eq : sca ] ) will be present in these calculations .
the same considerations applies for @xmath175 .
we have calculated an empirical series of @xmath93 with @xmath234 , an initial ising measure and @xmath257 .
detail relevant for this calculations can be found in refs .
the calculations have been performed with @xmath258 , a value for which at the @xmath70 considered , the errors due to the truncation are of the same order as those due to the numerical errors .
these errors are small enough to allow a determination of the susceptibility with seven significant digits if we use double precision .
we now discuss the flow chronologically .
our choice of @xmath70 ( close to @xmath259 ) means that we start near the stable manifold .
after about 25 iterations , we start approaching the unstable fixed point and the linear behavior @xmath260 becomes a good approximation . during the next 20 iterations ,
the irrelevant variables die off at the linear rate and at the same time the flow moves away from the fixed point along the unstable direction , also at the linear rate . at @xmath261
we are in good approximation on the unstable manifold and @xmath262 becomes proportional to @xmath263 .
in other words , the non - linear terms are taking over .
at this point , we can approximate the @xmath264 as functions of @xmath265 _ only _ : @xmath266 .
this approximation is consistent in the sense that if @xmath267 at @xmath268 then it is also the case for all positive @xmath32 .
we have calculated @xmath269 up to order 80 in @xmath265 using eq .
( [ eq : sca ] ) .
there can not be any small denominators in this restricted case .
we have then inverted @xmath270 , now a function of @xmath265 only , to obtain @xmath271 .
given the empirical @xmath272 we then calculated the approximate @xmath273 and then used the other functions @xmath274 ( with @xmath275 ) calculated before to `` predict '' @xmath264 .
comparison with the actual numbers were good in a restricted range .
for @xmath276 , the relative errors were less than a percent .
they kept decreasing to less than one part in 10,000 for @xmath277 and then increased again .
it will be shown later that this corresponds to the fact that when @xmath265 becomes too large ( a value of approximately 3.7 first exceeded at @xmath278 ) , the series expansion of @xmath270 seem to diverge , unlike the one - variable model for which @xmath165 is an entire function .
the quality of the approximation between @xmath192 and @xmath279 can be improved by treating @xmath280 perturbatively .
we have expanded @xmath281 with @xmath282 up to order 30 in @xmath265 .
this allows us to obtain the first order expression : @xmath283 note that expansions at _ both _ fixed points are involved ( one for @xmath284 and one for @xmath19 ) in this equation .
when finite series are used , the approximation will only be valid in the crossover region .
near @xmath279 , the presence of the ht fixed point starts dominating the flow but we are still far away from the linear regime .
we have taken these non - linear effects in @xmath285 into account by calculating it up to order 11 in @xmath70 .
this is a multi - variable expansion .
recalling the discussion about the ht expansion in section [ sec : hm ] and the properties of the eigenvectors of the linearized rg transformation about the ht fixed point , we can count the number of terms at each order in @xmath70 . at order two
, we have @xmath286 and @xmath287 , but since the linear transformation is diagonalized , @xmath287 will only appear in @xmath288 with coefficient 1 .
it is easy to see that at order @xmath10 , one needs to determine @xmath289 coeffificients , where @xmath290 is the number of partitions of @xmath10 .
it has been known from the work of hardy and ramanujan that @xmath291 it seems thus difficult to get very high order in this expansion . in order to fix the ideas ,
there are 41 terms at order 11 , 489 at order 20 and 13,848,649 at order 80 .
as we will explain below , the expansion up to order 11 has a sufficient accuracy to be used starting at @xmath279 .
it also provides optimal ( given our use of double precision ) results for @xmath292 .
as @xmath32 increases beyond 60 , one can see the effect of each order disappear one after the other as discussed in [ subsec : hmsec2 ] .
finally , the linear behavior becomes optimal near @xmath293 .
this concludes our chronological discussion . from eqs .
( [ eq : sus ] ) and remembering that we have absorbed @xmath70 in the @xmath294 , we obtain @xmath295 where @xmath231 is the matrix of right eigenvectors . for @xmath32 large enough
, the linear behavior applies and the @xmath251 get multiplied by @xmath296 at each iteration . in the large @xmath32 limit , only the @xmath297 term survives and consequently , @xmath298 using the same method as in the one - variable model , we can in the limit replace @xmath299 by @xmath300 and obtain @xmath301 for reference , in the case @xmath234 and with the normalization of the eigenvectors discussed above , @xmath302 . also note
that since for all @xmath10 , @xmath303 , all other monomials in the @xmath304 go to zero faster than @xmath284 .
one can calculate the subtracted 2@xmath305-point function following the same procedure . as shown in @xcite ,
they can be expressed in terms of @xmath306 and higher powers of the @xmath93 with @xmath307 .
following the procedure described above , these quantities can then reexpressed in terms of @xmath308 .
we need to identify the leading term in this expansion . by rescaling @xmath309 by @xmath310
we obtain the average value of the @xmath311-th power of the main spin ( sum of the @xmath312 spin variables @xmath313 ) . in the symmetric phase
, this quantity scales like @xmath314 when @xmath32 increases .
however , the subtracted version of this quantity ( which is generated by the free energy ) is expected to scale like @xmath312 . in other words
, if we assume that the free energy density is finite @xmath315 one clearly recognizes the spectrum of eq .
( [ eq : hteigenv ] ) and expects that the leading term is @xmath316 in order to prove this conjecture by direct algebraic methods , one needs to show that the the non - linear terms which scale faster than @xmath317 are canceled by the subtraction .
for instance for the subtracted four - point function and @xmath234 , @xmath318 and @xmath319 .
we have checked that the corresponding terms @xmath320 and @xmath321 disappear with the subtraction . we have conducted similar checks for the 6 and 8 point functions@xcite and found similar cancellations .
it should be noted that a rigorous proof that the mechanism works in general , would imply the finiteness of the free energy density and hyperscaling ( as defined in @xcite ) .
the practical calculation of the subtracted quantities is made difficult by the fact that as @xmath32 increases , the `` signal '' becomes much smaller than the `` background '' ( the unsubtracted part ) .
this requires the use of adjustable precision arithmetic . in the following
, we will only discuss the 2 point function ( susceptibility ) .
we rewrite the susceptibility as @xmath322 with the rg invariant @xmath323 .
we first constructed @xmath271 by neglecting the effects of the irrelevant directions , as explained in subsection [ subsec : prac ] . in order to provide a comparison ,
we have calculated the same @xmath153 for the one - variable model with @xmath324 . in the following , we call this model the `` simplified model '' ( sm ) .
for this special value of @xmath150 , the critical exponents @xmath1 of the two models coincide with five significant digits .
we have good evidence that both series have a radius of convergence 1 as indicated by the extrapolated ratio defined in eq .
( [ eq : rhat ] ) reaching 1 at an expected rate ( fig . [
fig : rhdone ] ) .
similarly , their extrapolated slopes seem to converge to the same value @xmath325 as shown in fig .
[ fig : shdone ] . in conclusion ,
the function @xmath153 for the sm is a reasonably good model to guess the asymptotic behavior of @xmath271 .
remembering the explanations of section [ sec : tm ] , this indicates the absence of other fixed points in the vicinity of the unstable fixed point .
for the inverse function @xmath326 , the situations more complicated as shown in fig .
[ fig : logco ] . the quantity plotted in this figure will be used to discriminate between a finite and an infinite radius of convergence . if @xmath327 as for a radius of convergence @xmath328 , then we have @xmath329 for some constant @xmath330 . on the other hand ,
if @xmath331 as for an infinite radius of convergence , then we have @xmath332 . in the following , we will compare fits of the form @xmath333 and @xmath334 .
we first consider the case of sm , where according to the our study in section [ sec : tm ] , expect an infinite radius of convergence .
this possibility is highly favored as shown in fig .
[ fig : toyfit ] .
one sees clearly that the solid line is a much better fit .
the chi - square for the solid line fit is 200 times smaller .
in addition @xmath335 as expected .
the analysis for the hm is more delicate .
one observes periodic `` dips '' in fig .
[ fig : logco ] which make the ratio analysis almost impossible .
we have thus only considered , the `` upper envelope '' by removing the dips from fig .
[ fig : logco ] .
the fit represents an upper bound rather than the actual coefficients .
the fits of the upper envelope are shown in fig . [
fig : hmfit ] .
the possibility of a finite radius of convergence is slightly favored , the chi - square being 0.4 of the one for the other possibility .
also , the second fit does not have the @xmath335 property . from @xmath336
, we estimate that the radius of convergence is about 3.7 .
this means that if we want to write some analytical formula for the flows by first calculating the initial values of the scaling fields and then calculating @xmath19 at successive iterations by using their expression in terms of the scaling fields , we will have to switch variables in the crossover region . as explained above
, the approach of the ht fixed point is intrinsically a multivariable problem .
for this reason , the calculation of @xmath190 , defined in eq .
( [ eq : bdn ] ) , that tests the quality of scaling , will be our main tool of analysis . in the following ,
we limit the discussion to @xmath285 which enters in the susceptibility .
we have calculated @xmath285 in terms of 11 variables , up to order 11 in @xmath70 . as in section
[ sec : tm ] , we will use an empirical series @xmath93 , calculate the corresponding @xmath233 an plug them in the scaling fields and check the scaling properties .
this empirical series was calculated with an initial ising measure and @xmath337 ( see ref .
again we define a quantity @xmath190 as in eq .
( [ eq : bdn ] ) which is very small when we have good scaling and increases when the approximation breaks down .
the results are shown in fig .
[ fig : app ] for successive orders in @xmath70 .
the solid line on the right is the linear approximation .
it becomes optimal near @xmath293 .
the next line ( dashes ) is the second order in @xmath70 expansion .
it becomes optimal near @xmath338 .
each next order gets closer and closer to be optimal near @xmath339 .
the last curve on the left is the order 9 approximation .
it is hard to resolve the next two approximations on this graph .
the asymptotic value is stabilized with 16 digits and one may wonder why we get only scaling with 14 or 15 digits in fig .
[ fig : app ] .
the reason is that we use empirical data and that numerical errors can add coherently as explained in ref .
this can be seen directly by considering the difference between two successive values of @xmath190 .
a detailed analysis shows that the numerical errors at each step tend to be negative more often than positive , and consequently there is a small `` drift '' which affects the last digits .
we can now look at the @xmath190 defined as in eq .
( [ eq : bdn ] ) for @xmath265 and @xmath284 together in fig .
[ fig : hmoverlap ] .
if we use an expansion of order 5 in @xmath70 for @xmath175 and of order 10 in @xmath270 for @xmath265 , we can get scaling within a few percent for both variables at @xmath277 .
we can go below 1 part in 1000 , with an expansion of order 11 in @xmath70 and order 80 in @xmath270 . at this point ,
the main problem is that the effects of the subleading correction makes the scaling properties _ worse _ when @xmath340 and @xmath32 decreases .
one can improve the scaling properties by taking the effects of @xmath280 into account .
a detailed study shows that one can estimate the subleading effects between @xmath341 and @xmath192 as @xmath342 it is thus possible to get a function scaling better by subtracting these correction .
this improve the scaling properties by almost one order of magnitude near @xmath277 and by almost two order of magnitude near @xmath192 . from fig .
[ fig : hmoverlap ] , we see that the combined scaling is optimal near @xmath277 which corresponds to an approximate value of 2 for @xmath265 . using eq .
( [ eq : pertexp ] ) , we can take into account the first order correction in @xmath280 .
after simple manipulations , we can rewrite the rg invariant as @xmath343 with @xmath344 and @xmath345 .
the functions @xmath346 and @xmath347 are defined by eq .
( [ eq : paramy ] ) .
they rely on _ both _
expansions used and consequently they are only valid in a crossover region . using explicit forms of @xmath348 and @xmath349 as a function of @xmath265 , we observe a plateau for each function which are shown in fig . [
fig : rginv ] . using the flattest part of the plateau to estimate the constant we obtain @xmath350 and @xmath351 .
note that these two numbers are dependent of the choice of the scales for the scaling fields , but independent of the initial conditions .
consequently , if everybody agreed on the scales , these quantities could be called universal .
there remains to estimate the initial values of the @xmath265 and @xmath280 .
this step will done numerically from empirical values of @xmath254 .
first , we obtain a rough estimate of @xmath352 from @xmath353 at values of @xmath32 where the linear approximation is good .
plugging this value in eq .
( [ eq : pertexp ] ) for @xmath354 , and inverting to get @xmath273 as a function of @xmath272 . dividing by @xmath355
we get an estimated value of @xmath356 with a plateau of about 10 iterations where the value is stabilized with 6 digits . repeating for various temperatures we were able to determine the leading coefficient in eq .
( [ eq : init1 ] ) : @xmath357 . using eq .
( [ eq : pertexp ] ) but for @xmath358 , together with our previous estimates of @xmath359 , we obtain @xmath360 .
subleading coefficients are difficult to resolve because @xmath361 and the nonlinear contributions in @xmath362 are of the same order as the analytical corrections .
this conclude our approximate treatment of step 3 . using eqs .
( [ eq : suspar ] ) and ( [ eq : rginv ] ) we obtain the usual parametrization of the susceptibility of eq .
( [ eq : param ] ) with @xmath363 and @xmath364 in very good agreement with a fully numerical determination of these amplitudes @xcite .
in summary , we have shown with two examples that the 3 steps advocated in section [ sec:3steps ] lead to an accurate determination of the leading and subleading critical amplitudes .
we provided numerical evidence that the formal expansions of the scaling fields associated with the ht and unstable fixed point have reasonable convergence properties and scale properly in overlapping domains .
the determination of the initial values of the scaling fields associated with the unstable fixed point ( third step ) have been obtained numerically in the case of an initial ising measure . putting everything together
, we were able to confirm numerical results obtained earlier .
analytical methods are now being used @xcite to consider initial measures of the landau - ginzburg type in the vicinity of the gaussian fixed point . for such initial measures
, we can use perturbation theory in the quartic ( or higher orders ) coupling constant to construct the scaling fields associated with the gaussian fixed point .
interestingly , one could use some of the methods developed here to interpolate between the gaussian fixed point and the unstable fixed point .
the completion of this task will allow us to give analytical expressions for the renormalized quantities in terms of the bare ones , which is the notoriously difficult problem that has to be faced by a field theorist .
we are planning to extend the calculations performed here , to higher order derivatives of the free energy with a non - zero magnetic field and check explicitly amplitudes relations appearing in the literature @xcite .
another interesting question that could be addressed within this context is the crossover from classical to critical behavior @xcite .
the completion of these projects will provide a detailed comparison between general rg expectations and their practical realization for the hm .
the hierarchical approximation used in this article has allowed us to calculate large order expansions for the scaling fields .
the fact that the general ideas advocated have worked properly means that one should now attempt to apply them to nearest neighbor models where similar calculations would be more time consuming .
the examples we have in mind are spin models in three dimensions and asymptotically free theory such as the @xmath365 spin models in two dimensions or lattice gauge theory in four dimensions . in all cases
, there exists some advanced technology for the weak and strong coupling expansions but the question of the interpolation has only been studied with the monte carlo method @xcite .
we expect that some of the simple features found in the study of the ht fixed point of the hm will generalize to nearest neighbor models .
first , the fact that the ht scaling fields are linearly related to the successive derivatives of the free energy .
second , the fact that the restriction to a finite number of eigenvectors of the linearized rg transformation near the ht fixed point can be used to obtain improved ht expansions such as the polynomial truncation used above .
however , the most difficult task remains a construction of the unstable fixed point and the rg flows in its vicinity , with a control comparable to the case the hierarchical model .
this is a challenging problem for the future .
this research was supported in part by the department of energy under contract no .
fg02 - 91er40664 .
y. m. thanks the aspen center for physics , where discussions have motivated part of this work and where part of this manuscript was written .
v. privman , p. hohenberg and a. aharony , in _ phase transitions and critical phenomena _ , v. 14 , c. domb and j. lebowitz editors ( academic press , new york , 1991 ) , and references therein .
h. poincar , _ les methodes nouvelles de la mecanique celeste _ ( gauthier - villars , paris , 1892 ) .
v. arnold , _ geometrical methods in the theory of ordinary differential equations _ ( springer - verlag , new york , 1988 ) .
h. koch and p. wittwer , in _ nonlinear evolution and chaotic phenomena _ , nato asi series , series b : physics , vol .
176 , g. gallavotti and p. zweifel editors , plenum ; and in _ mathematical quantum field theory and related topics _
, canadian mathematical society , conference proceedings v. 9 ( 1988 ) . | we propose to combine the nonlinear scaling fields associated with the high - temperature ( ht ) fixed point , with those associated with the unstable fixed point , in order to calculate the susceptibility and other thermodynamic quantities .
the general strategy relies on simple linear relations between the ht scaling fields and the thermodynamic quantities , and the estimation of rg invariants formed out of the two sets of scaling fields .
this estimation requires convergent expansions in overlapping domains .
if , in addition , the initial values of the scaling fields associated with the unstable fixed point can be calculated from the temperature and the parameters appearing in the microscopic hamiltonian , one can estimate the critical amplitudes .
this strategy has been developed using dyson s hierarchical model where all the steps can be approximately implemented with good accuracy .
we show numerically that for this model ( and a simplified version of it ) , the required overlap apparently occurs , allowing an accurate determination of the critical amplitudes .
keywords : renormalization group , scaling fields , high - temperature expansion , hierarchical model , normal forms , critical amplitudes , crossover . |
there is a small but growing family of blazars detected at tev energies .
these belong exclusively to the class of high peak frequency bls , i.e. blazars whose synchrotron component peaks at x - ray energies .
tev emitting bls are of particular interest because of the possibility of absorption of their tev emission by the dirb @xcite .
study of their spectra in the tev range can be used to probe the properties of dirb as a function of redshift @xmath4 @xcite , given that the magnitude of absorption depends on the redshift of the source and the , still elusive , dirb spectrum @xcite .
the absorption of the tev photons of this blazar class suggests that both the intrinsic peak photon energy @xmath5 and peak luminosity @xmath6 of the high energy ( tev ) component are higher than those observed .
even for the nearby ( @xmath7 ) mkn 421 , @xmath5 can increase by a factor of @xmath8 after de - absorption to @xmath9 tev @xcite .
the de - absorbed spectrum of h1426 + 428 at z=0.129 is even more extreme , characterized by @xmath10 tev @xcite .
modeling of these sources has been done in the framework of the homogeneous ssc model [ e.g. @xcite ] , according to which a blob of energetic plasma is moving with a constant lorentz factor @xmath11 forming a small angle @xmath12 to the line of sight .
such models require high doppler factors ( @xmath13 , where @xmath14 is the dimensionless speed of the flow and @xmath12 its angle to the observer s line of sight ) to reproduce the de - absorbed @xmath5 [ e.g. @xcite ; see also next section ] . however , even smaller values of @xmath15 are in conflict @xcite with the unification scheme according to which bls represent fr i radio galaxies viewed at small @xmath16 ) @xcite . also , these high values of @xmath17 are in disagreement with the small values of the apparent velocities observed in the sub - pc regions of the tev bl mkn 421 and mkn 501 ( e.g. @xcite ) . in this note
we propose that the above issues can be resolved by postulating that the tev blazar emission originates in a relativistic but _ decelerating _ flow . in
2 we present a quantitative analysis and formulation of the above arguments , while in 3 we outline the basic notions behind our proposal and explain why and how they resolve the outstanding issues discussed in 2 .
finally , in 4 we discuss some further issues .
* the blazar spectra : * one of the characteristics of the synchrotron components of the tev blazar spectra is a break at an energy @xmath18 ( unprimed energies are in the observer frame while primed ones in the flow rest frame , all normalized to the rest mass of the electron @xmath19 ) , with most of the ( comoving ) synchrotron energy density above @xmath20 , a feature that significantly affects their tev emission : because of the reduction in the inverse compton ( ic ) scattering cross section in the k - n regime and the break in the photon energy density at @xmath21 , electrons with energies @xmath22 will channel a decreasing fraction of their energy to ic scattering , leading to a peak in the ic luminosity at @xmath23 even if the maximum electron energy is @xmath24 . for a source moving with a doppler factor @xmath17 relative to the observer @xmath25 and @xmath26 will be @xmath27 and @xmath28 yielding @xmath29 where @xmath30 is the _ observed _ synchrotron break frequency in units of @xmath31 hz and @xmath32 is the energy of the _ de - absorbed _ ic peak in units of 10 tev . de - absorbed @xmath5 values in excess of 10 tev then imply relativistic flows in blazars with @xmath33 . the crucial point in the above argument , namely that the ic luminosity peaks at @xmath34 , can be demonstrated explicitly within the homogeneous ssc models : assume , as customary , continuous injection of a power law electron distribution within a uniform source at a rate @xmath35 , @xmath36 .
the steady state electron distribution is then @xmath37 with @xmath38 the electron energy below which electrons escape from the source faster than they radiatively cool .
the corresponding comoving synchrotron energy density distribution is @xmath39 where @xmath40 , @xmath41 , and @xmath42 is the comoving magnetic field in units of its critical value @xmath43 g. fits to the synchrotron spectra of tev blazars require @xmath44 , with comoving peak synchrotron luminosity at @xmath45 .
we now examine the energy @xmath26 at which the ic luminosity peaks as a function of the maximum electron energy @xmath46 .
the k - n influence on the cross section begins at @xmath47 . above that energy
the electrons interact only with the fraction of the synchrotron spectrum at energies less than @xmath48 , while the maximum photon energy resulting from the ic is @xmath49 .
if @xmath50 is the photon scattering rate to energy @xmath51 , the ic luminosity at this energy is @xmath52 setting @xmath53 as the appropriate seed photons ( photons of larger energy are in the k - n regime , and photons of lower energy give lower @xmath54 ) , and using eq .
( [ n(g ) ] ) , ( [ u(e ) ] ) we obtain @xmath55 where we have also used @xmath56 . therefore , for @xmath57 the luminosity at maximum photon energy @xmath58 increases with @xmath46 for @xmath59 and decreases for @xmath60 , achieving its peak luminosity at energy @xmath61 .
* blazar unification : * according to the unification scheme of radio loud active galaxies ( e.g. urry & padovani 1995 ) bls are fr i radio galaxies with their jets oriented close to the line of sight .
the average lorentz factor @xmath11 of the jet flows , derived by matching the luminosity functions of bl and fr i samples , were estimated to be @xmath62 @xcite , in clear disagreement with the values of the doppler factors required by the homogeneous ssc models for the tev blazars .
the high doppler factors estimated on the basis of homogeneous ssc models imply that for @xmath63 , @xmath64 requiring sources very well aligned to the line of sight , thus grossly overpredicting the number of fr i galaxies above a given limiting flux ( this actually would be the case even with the much smaller value of @xmath65 ; @xcite ) . in a different aspect of the same problem , chiaberge et al .
( 2000 ) showed that the fr i nuclei are overluminous by a factor of @xmath66 compared to their luminosity should they have been misaligned bls harboring flows with lorentz factors @xmath3 .
applying to sub - pc scales the arguments of laing et al .
( 1999 ) concerning the structure of fr i kpc scale jets , they opted for jets with a high @xmath11 ` spine ' surrounded by lower @xmath11 sheath . for a source at a small angle to the line of sight
the emission is dominated by the fast spine , while , at large angles this radiation is beamed out of the observer s direction and the observed spectrum is dominated by the mildly beamed emission by the slower sheath .
however , recent vlba @xcite , vlbi @xcite , and combined vsop and vlbi @xcite studies do not detect any high velocity components in the jets of the two tev sources mkn 421 and mkn 501 .
these observations are compatible with subluminal ( @xmath67 , piner et al .
1999 , edwards et al . 2002 ) or mildly relativistic ( @xmath68 , marscher 1999 ) sub - pc velocities .
a value of @xmath69 , as needed in modeling the tev emission of these sources , could produce the observed velocities only for @xmath70 .
rather than assuming such an extraordinary jet alignment for both sources , marscher ( 1999 ) suggested that the flow in the sub - pc environment of these sources has already decelerated substantially
. additional support for slow flows in sub - pc scales comes from @xcite that showed that in several cases vlbi components in bls move with @xmath71 .
that low jet velocities at pc scales are real and not the result of projection effects is supported by the observation of subluminal velocities at the jet of the fr i galaxy 3c 270 jets , which are thought to be at large angle to the observer s line of sight ( piner et al .
motivated by the above issues , we propose that in the high energy emitting region of the tev bls the plasma flow is relativistic and _ decelerating _ ( a similar proposal was advanced to unify the broadband properties of the hot spots of fr ii radio galaxies and quasars @xcite ) .
our proposed scheme for the bl flows involves the injection of a power law electron distribution at the base of a relativistic flow which decelerates while at the same time the electron distribution cools radiatively .
the highest synchrotron frequencies originate at fast base of the flow where the electrons are more energetic . as
both the flow velocity and electron energy drop with radius , the locally emitted synchrotron spectrum shifts to lower energies while its beaming pattern becomes wider . at small angles
the observed spectrum is dominated by emission from the higher @xmath11 base of flow , where the most energetic electrons reside . at larger angles
this emission from the inner , fast flow section is beamed away from the observer and the major contribution to the spectrum comes from its slower parts which contain less energetic electrons , leading to softer spectra .
the inverse compton emission of such a flow behaves in a more involved way : electrons will upscatter the locally produced synchrotron seed photons , giving rise to a local ssc emission with @xmath72dependence similar to that of synchrotron
. however , the electrons of a given radius scatter will also those synchrotron photons produced downstream in the flow .
the energy density of the latter , will appear doppler boosted in the fast ( upstream ) part of the flow by @xmath73 @xcite , where @xmath74 is the relative lorentz factor between the fast and slow part of the flow . with their maximum energy being lower ( because of cooling ) and their energy density amplified they contribute to the ic emission at energies higher than expected on the basis of uniform velocity models without the need of invoking as large doppler factors .
the beaming pattern of this uc radiation is also intermediate between the synchrotron / ssc pattern of @xmath75 and the external compton pattern ( ec ) of @xmath76 @xcite , where @xmath77 is the spectral index of the radiation . to demonstrate this consider a two - zone flow , a fast part with lorentz factor @xmath78 followed by a slower part with lorentz factor @xmath79 .
consider also an observer located at an angle @xmath12 such that the doppler factors of the two zones are @xmath80 , @xmath81 .
the beaming pattern of the uc radiation in the frame of the slow part of the flow will be @xmath82 , where @xmath83 is the doppler factor of the fast flow in the frame of the slow flow . to convert this beaming pattern to the observer s frame we need to boost it by @xmath84 .
the beaming pattern is then written as @xmath85 . to write @xmath83 as a function of @xmath86 , @xmath87
, we note that a photon emitted in the fast part of the flow is seen by the observed boosted in energy by a factor @xmath88 .
the same boosting can take place is two stages : first going to the frame of the slow flow by being boosted by @xmath83 and then going to the observer s frame by being boosted by @xmath89 . because the final photon energy in the observer s frame does not depend on the intermediate transformations , @xmath90 .
the beaming pattern of uc scattering is therefore @xmath91 .
note that , as expected , for @xmath92 , we recover the beaming pattern of ssc , while for @xmath93 , that of ec radiation . to demonstrate the relevance of decelerating flows in tev blazars
, we developed a simple model , based on an one dimensional kinematic flow description .
an electron distribution @xmath94 is injected at the base of a decelerating relativistic flow with velocity profile @xmath95 .
electrons cool radiatively as they propagate downstream .
we calculate their radiative losses along the flow and also their energy distribution as a function of @xmath4 .
we then calculate the synchrotron emissivity along @xmath4 and , performing the necessary beaming transformations and @xmath96integration , the volume integrated synchrotron emission as a function of observing angle @xmath12 . using the synchrotron emissivity as a function of @xmath4
we calculate the ssc and uc emissivities as a function of @xmath97 .
a final integral over @xmath4 then provides the volume integrated compton emissivity as a function of @xmath12 . in fig .
[ fig1 ] we plot the sed for a deceleratring flow for two different observing angles . note that at @xmath98 this model achieves a peak energy for the high energy component at @xmath8 tev , using a modest lorentz factor of @xmath99 .
note also the stronger angle dependence of emission from the inner fast part of the flow which produces the highest frequencies in each spectral component .
finally , note that , in contrast to single velocity homogeneous ssc models , the compton component is more sensitive to orientation than synchrotron , as expected if uc scattering dominates the @xmath2 tev observed luminosity .
we now turn to the problem of the unification of bls with fr i sources . @xcite and
@xcite compared a sample of fr i nuclei to bls of similar extended radio power , which is believed to be non - beamed , and therefore orientation independent .
they found that de - beaming the bl emission under the uniform velocity assumption by changing the observer s angle from @xmath100 to @xmath101 leads to fluxes far smaller than those of fr is .
in particular the average bl to fr i nucleus luminosity ratio at radio , optical and x - ray bands was found to be : @xmath102 , @xmath103 , @xmath104 . in fig .
[ fig2 ] we plot as vertical bars the luminosity separation of bls and fr is according to @xcite and @xcite .
we also plot the sed of a decelerating flow with physical parameters similar to that in fig . 1 , but with smaller value for @xmath46 to produce sed synchrotron peaks similar to those of the intermediate bls that correspond in extended radio power to the fr is @xcite .
as can be seen , the luminosity change of the model sed at @xmath105 ( fr i ) and @xmath106 ( bl ) reproduce relatively well the observed luminosity range .
the need for additional seed photons in modeling the @xmath1 few tev peak emission of the tev blazars drives homogeneous ssc models to @xmath107 , values in conflict with the presumed unification between fr i s and bls . the problem of the missing seed photons can be resolved if one considers a relativistic flow decelerating from @xmath108 down to @xmath109 a few : in this case uc emission produces spectra that can easily provide the observed de - absorbed @xmath5 without the need to invoke values of @xmath17 greater than @xmath110
. such decelerating flows are consistent with the low , possibly subluminal , speeds observed in the sub - pc scale jets of mkn 421 and mkn 501 without unreasonable alingment requirements ( for @xmath111 and @xmath112 the corresponding value of the observing angle is @xmath113 ) .
it also resolves the problem of fr i bl unification , which fails for flows with constant lorentz factors even as low as @xmath114 . the spatial separation of different frequencies seen in fig .
1 has interesting consequences for the expected variability . in homogeneous ssc models a variation of the number of the injected electrons produces a linear response in the synchrotron flux and a quadratic one in the ssc flux .
this is because both the number of the electrons and the synchrotron energy density increase linerarly and the ssc flux increases quadratically because is proportional to their product . for decelerating flows , fast variations ( faster than the light crossing time of the separation between the x - ray emitting region and the downstream region responsible for most of the synchrotron seed photons used to produce the tev emission ) should result to approximately linear variations of the tev relative to the x - ray flux
this is because the freshly injected high energy electrons uc scatter mostly synchrotron photons produced downstream before the injection , and therefore contribute an undisturbed photon energy density .
a physically plausible scenario for the flows we consider may be that suggested by marscher ( 1999 ) , according to which the energy dissipated at the shock is converted into a non - thermal electron component , whose radiative losses lead to the deceleration of the relativistic flow . in this case
the deceleration length scale would be approximately equal to that of radiative losses , an assumption we have employed in our calculations .
a similar scenario has been proposed for the hot spots of large scale jets , and it seems possible that relativistic and decelerating flows exist in different astrophysical environments which exhibit similar characteristics , and in particular a stronger that anticipated high energy emission due to uc scattering . | tev emission from bl lacertae ( bl ) objects is commonly modeled as synchrotron - self compton ( ssc ) radiation from relativistically moving homogeneous plasma blobs . in the context of these models , the blob lorentz factors needed to reproduce the corrected for absorption by the diffuse ir background ( dirb ) tev emission are large ( @xmath0 ) .
the main reason for this is that stronger beaming eases the problem of the lack of @xmath1 ir - uv synchrotron seed photons needed to produce the de - absorbed @xmath2 few tev peak of the spectral energy distribution ( sed ) .
however , such high doppler factors are in strong disagreement with the unified scheme , according to which bls are fr i radio galaxies with their jets closely aligned to the line of sight . here , motivated by the detection of sub - luminal velocities in the sub - pc scale jets of the best studied tev blazars , mkn 421 and mkn 501 , we examine the possibility that the relativistic flows in the tev bls decelerate . in this case , the problem of the missing seed photons is solved because of upstream compton ( uc ) scattering , a process in which the upstream energetic electrons from the fast base of the flow ` see ' the synchrotron seed photons produced in the slow part of the flow relativistically beamed . modest lorentz factors ( @xmath3 ) , decelerating down to values compatible with the recent radio interferometric observations , reproduce the @xmath2 few tev peak energy of these sources .
furthermore , such decelerating flows are shown to be in agreement with the bl - fr i unification , naturally reproducing the observed bl / fr i broad band luminosity ratios . |
many astrophysical observations have confirmed the existence of dark matter ( dm ) , which contributes to roughly @xmath4 of the energy density of the universe . among many proposed dm candidates , weakly interacting massive particles ( wimps ) @xcite are popular proposals since they are theoretically well motivated and also capable of producing the correct relic density .
wimps could annihilate or decay into particles such as electrons , positrons , protons , antiprotons , photons , and neutrinos .
it is possible to establish the wimp signature through detecting these particles @xcite .
research activities on wimps have been boosted recently in efforts of explaining the observed anomalous positron excess in the data of pamela @xcite and positron plus electron excess in the data of fermi @xcite . to account for spectral shapes observed by these experiments
, wimps must annihilate or decay mostly into leptons in order to avoid the overproduction of antiprotons .
this could indicate that dm particles are leptophilic in their annihilations or decays @xcite .
it has been pointed out that the observation of neutrinos can give stringent constraints on the above scenario .
measurements of upward going muons by super - kamiokande observatory place a limit on the galactic muon neutrino flux , which in turn rules out the possibility of wimp annihilations to @xmath5 as a source of @xmath6 anomalies @xcite .
furthermore , one expects that the possibilities of wimp annihilations into @xmath7 , and wimp decays into @xmath7 and @xmath8 will all be stringently constrained @xcite(see also discussions in ref .
@xcite ) by the data from icecube detector augmented with deepcore array .
the deepcore array @xcite is located in the deep center region of icecube detector .
this array consists of @xmath9 densely instrumented strings plus 7 nearest standard icecube strings .
the installation of deepcore array significantly improves the rejection of downward going atmospheric muons in icecube and lowers the threshold energy for detecting muon track or cascade events to about @xmath10 gev . as summarized in ref .
@xcite , the low detection threshold of deepcore array is achieved by three improvements over the icecube detector .
first , the photo - sensors in deepcore are more densely instrumented than those of icecube , as just mentioned .
second , the ice surrounding the deepcore array is on average twice as clear as the average ice above 2000 m @xcite .
such a property is useful for reconstructing lower- energy neutrino events .
finally the deepcore array uses new type of phototube which has a higher quantum efficiency .
it is clear that deepcore array improves the sensitivity as well as enlarges the energy window for observing neutrinos from dm annihilations or decays in the galactic halo .
previous analyses on the detection of these neutrinos in deepcore @xcite have set the threshold energy at @xmath11 gev for both track and cascade events . for neutrino events with energies higher than @xmath1 gev ,
the estimation of atmospheric background event rate is straightforward since oscillation effects can be neglected .
however , to take the full advantage of deepcore array , it is desirable to estimate the track and shower event rates due to atmospheric neutrinos in the energy range @xmath12 . in this energy range ,
the oscillations of atmospheric neutrinos can not be neglected . in this article , we take into account this oscillation effect and calculate the track event rate with a threshold energy @xmath13 gev due to atmospheric muon neutrinos from all zenith angles . given such a background event rate , we then evaluate the sensitivities of deepcore array to the neutrino flux arising from dm annihilations and decays in the galactic halo .
in the subsequent paper , we shall analyze the corresponding sensitivities associated with cascade events .
this paper will focus on neutrino signature induced by low - mass dm .
hence our interested dm mass range is far below tev level implied by pamela and fermi data .
therefore we shall consider neutrino flux induced by dm annihilations / decays into both leptons and hadrons .
specifically , we consider the channels @xmath14 , and @xmath15 for annihilations and the channels @xmath16 and @xmath15 for decays .
since we are only interested in low - mass dark matter , we have neglected neutrino fluxes generated through dm annihilations or decays into @xmath17 , @xmath18 and @xmath19 final states .
we also neglect neutrino fluxes arising from light meson decays , as the annihilation cross section for @xmath20 is likely to be suppressed by @xmath21 @xcite .
we shall compare the constraints on dm annihilation cross section and dm decay time for different values of threshold energy @xmath22 .
for such a comparison , we employ the modes @xmath23 and @xmath24 for illustrations .
this paper is organized as follows . in sec .
ii , we outline the calculation of muon neutrino flux from wimp annihilations and decays in the galactic halo . in sec .
iii , we calculate the atmospheric muon neutrino flux from all zenith angles with @xmath25 gev .
the oscillations between @xmath26 and @xmath27 are taken into account . in sec .
iv , we evaluate the sensitivity of deepcore array to neutrino flux arising from wimp annihilations or decays in the galactic halo .
we compare our results with those obtained by setting @xmath28 gev .
we summarize in sec . v.
the differential neutrino flux from the galactic dark matter halo for neutrino flavor @xmath29 can be written as @xcite @xmath30 for the case of annihilating dm , and @xmath31 for the case of decaying dm , where @xmath32 is the distance from the galactic center ( gc ) to the solar system , @xmath33 is the dm density in the solar neighborhood , @xmath34 is the dm mass , @xmath35 is the dm decay time and @xmath36 is the neutrino spectrum per annihilation or decay for a given annihilation or decay channel @xmath37 with a corresponding branching fraction @xmath38 .
the neutrino spectra @xmath36 for different channels are summarized in ref @xcite .
the quantity @xmath39 is the thermally averaged annihilation cross section , which can be written as @xmath40 with a boost factor @xmath41 @xcite .
we set @xmath42 , which is the typical annihilation cross section for the present dark matter abundance under the standard thermal relic scenario @xcite .
we treat the boost factor @xmath41 as a phenomenological parameter .
the dimensionless quantity @xmath43 is the dm distribution integrated over the line - of - sight ( l.o.s ) and averaged over a solid angle @xmath44 , i.e. , @xmath45 + where @xmath46 is the dm density at a specific location described by the coordinate @xmath47 with @xmath48 the distance from the earth to dm and @xmath49 the direction of dm viewed from the earth with @xmath50 corresponding to the direction of gc .
the distance @xmath51 is the distance from gc to dm .
the upper limit of the integration , @xmath52 , depends on @xmath53 , the adopted size of the galactic halo . in this analysis , we take @xmath54 and use the navarro - frenk - white ( nfw ) dm density profile @xcite @xmath55 + with @xmath56 such that @xmath57 .
neutrinos are significantly mixed through oscillations when they travel a vast distance across the galaxy .
we determine neutrino flavor oscillation probabilities in the tribimaximal limit @xcite of neutrino mixing angles , i.e. , @xmath58 , @xmath59 and @xmath60 .
the neutrino fluxes on earth are related to those at the source through @xcite @xmath61 and @xmath62 where @xmath63 is the neutrino flux of flavor @xmath29 at the astrophysical source .
it is understood that the recent t2k @xcite and double chooz @xcite experiments have indicated a non - zero value for @xmath64 . taking the t2k best - fit value @xmath65 at the cp phase @xmath66 for the normal mass hierarchy , we have @xmath67 to proceed our discussions , let us first take the neutrinos at the source to be those generated by @xmath41 meson decays following the @xmath68 annihilation . in this special case ,
@xmath69 at the source , and consequently the relation @xmath70 always holds due to the probability conservation , irrespective of the form of oscillation probability matrix .
let us now consider neutrinos produced at the source by muon decays following the @xmath23 annihilation .
in this case , one has @xmath71 and @xmath72 .
taking @xmath73 , one obtains @xmath74 and @xmath75 for tribimaximal values of neutrino mixing parameters . on the other hand , with the t2k best - fit @xmath64 value ,
one arrives at @xmath76 , @xmath77 and @xmath78 for the normal mass hierarchy .
clearly @xmath79 is almost unaffected while @xmath80 . for the inverted mass hierarchy ,
one obtains the same @xmath81 flux while @xmath82 .
hence t2k result implies an @xmath83 difference between the arrival @xmath26 and @xmath27 fluxes for neutrinos produced by @xmath84 annihilations .
knowing atmospheric neutrino background is important for evaluating the sensitivity of deepcore array to neutrino flux from dm annihilations or decays .
we begin by computing the flux of intrinsic atmospheric muon neutrinos arising from pion and kaon decays , following the approaches in refs .
the @xmath26 flux arising from @xmath85 decays can be written as @xmath86 where @xmath87 is the neutrino energy , @xmath88 is the slant depth in units of g/@xmath89 , @xmath90 is the zenith angle in the direction of incident cosmic - ray nucleons , @xmath91 , @xmath92 is the pion decay length in units of g/@xmath89 , @xmath93 is the nucleon interaction length and @xmath94 is the corresponding nucleon attenuation length .
the function @xmath95 is the probability that a charged pion produced at the slant depth @xmath96 survives to the depth @xmath88 ( @xmath97 ) , which is given by @xcite @xmath98 where @xmath99 g/@xmath89 is the pion attenuation length , @xmath100 is the pion lifetime at its rest frame , while @xmath101 is the atmosphere mass density at the slant depth @xmath102 .
finally , @xmath103 is the normalized inclusive cross section for @xmath104 , which is given by @xcite @xmath105 with @xmath106 , @xmath107 , @xmath108 , @xmath109 , and @xmath110 . the primary cosmic - ray spectrum @xmath111 in eq .
( [ atm - nu ] ) includes contributions from cosmic ray protons and those from heavier nuclei .
we have @xmath112 with @xmath113 the atomic number of each nucleus .
the spectrum of each cosmic - ray component is parametrized by @xcite @xmath114)^{- \alpha},\end{aligned}\ ] ] in units of m@xmath115s@xmath116sr@xmath116gev@xmath116 .
the fitting parameters @xmath117 depend on the type of nucleus .
they are tabulated in table i @xcite . the kaon contribution to the atmospheric @xmath26 flux
has the same form as eq .
( [ atm - nu ] ) with an inclusion of the branching ratio @xmath118 and appropriate replacements in kinematic factors and the normalized inclusive cross section .
in particular , @xmath119 can be parametrized as eq .
( [ npi ] ) with @xmath120 , @xmath121 , @xmath122 , and @xmath123 .
ccccc parameter / component & @xmath124 & @xmath125 & @xmath126 & @xmath127 + + hydrogen ( a=1 ) @xmath128 & 2.74 & 14900 & 2.15 & 0.21 + hydrogen ( a=1 ) @xmath129 & 2.71 & 14900 & 2.15 & 0.21 + he ( a=4 ) & 2.64 & 600 & 1.25 & 0.14 + cno ( a=14 ) & 2.60 & 33.2 & 0.97 & 0.01 + mg - si ( a=25 ) & 2.79 & 34.2 & 2.14 & 0.01 + iron ( a=56 ) & 2.68 & 4.45 & 3.07 & 0.41 + since our interested energy range is as low as @xmath0 gev , the three - body muon decay contribution to the atmospheric @xmath26 flux is not negligible , particularly in the near horizontal direction . to obtain this part of contribution
, we first compute the atmospheric muon flux from pion and kaon decays . the muon flux induced by pion
decays is given by @xcite @xmath130 where @xmath131 and @xmath87 are muon energies at slant depths @xmath132 and @xmath88 respectively , while @xmath133 is the muon survival probability .
the muon flux induced by kaon decays can be calculated in a similar way . since @xmath134 produced by @xmath135 decays
are polarized , we classify muon flux into four different components such as @xmath136 , @xmath137 , @xmath138 , and @xmath139 .
we also calculate additional four components of the muon flux arising from the kaon decays . hence the @xmath26 flux arising from muon decays
can be written as @xcite @xmath140 where @xmath141 is the muon decay length in units of g/@xmath89 at the slant depth @xmath88 and @xmath142 is the normalized decay spectrum of @xmath143 .
summing the two - body and three - body decay contributions , we obtain the total intrinsic atmospheric muon neutrino flux . in fig . 1
, we show the comparison of angle - averaged atmospheric muon neutrino flux obtained by our calculation and that obtained by honda et al . @xcite . at @xmath144 10 gev ,
two calculations only differ by @xmath145 . at @xmath144 100
gev , the difference is @xmath146 .
we also show in the same figure the atmospheric muon neutrino flux measured by amanda - ii detector @xcite .
it is seen that both calculations agree well with amanda results . to completely determine the atmospheric muon neutrino flux
, one also needs to calculate the intrinsic atmospheric tau neutrino flux , although this part of contribution is rather small .
the intrinsic atmospheric @xmath27 flux arises from @xmath147 decays .
this flux can be obtained by solving cascade equations @xcite .
we obtain @xmath148 where @xmath149 and @xmath150 is a special case of the generic expression @xmath151 with @xmath152 and @xmath153 the interaction length of particle @xmath29 in units of g/@xmath89 .
the decay moment @xmath154 is given by @xmath155 where @xmath156 is the decay length of @xmath147 and @xmath157 is the normalized decay distribution . in this work ,
we employ the next - to - leading order ( nlo ) perturbative qcd @xcite with cteq6 parton distribution functions to calculate the differential cross section of @xmath158 and determine @xmath150 . )
flux obtained by our calculation and that obtained by honda _
et al . _
angle - averaged @xmath159 flux from amanda - ii measurements @xcite is also shown .
, title="fig:",scaledwidth=85.0% ] 0.5 cm finally , the atmospheric @xmath26 flux taking into account the neutrino oscillation effect is given by @xmath160,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath161 is the @xmath162 oscillation probability and @xmath163 is the linear distance from the neutrino production point to the position of icecube deepcore array .
the unit of @xmath164 is ev@xmath165 while @xmath166 and @xmath87 are in units of km and gev respectively .
the best - fit values for oscillation parameters obtained from a recent analysis @xcite are @xmath167 and @xmath168 respectively .
in icecube deepcore , the event rate for contained muons is given by @xmath169 where @xmath170 is the density of ice , @xmath171 is avogadro s number , @xmath172 is the effective volume of icecube deepcore array for muon track events
@xcite , @xmath173 is the muon neutrino flux arrived at icecube , @xmath174 is taken as @xmath34 for annihilation and @xmath175 for decay , and @xmath176 is the threshold energy for muon track events . in this work ,
we use differential cross sections @xmath177 given by ref .
@xcite with cteq6 parton distribution functions .
we also set @xmath178 gev . , @xmath179 , and @xmath180 channels , respectively .
the thick solid line is the h.e.s.s constraint on the annihilation cross section of dm into the light quark pair @xmath20 @xcite .
the dot - dot - dashed line is the constraint on @xmath181 annihilation cross section from the analysis of cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) data @xcite .
the dotted line is the @xmath182 constraint on the annihilation cross section of @xmath183 from super - kamiokande data @xcite .
, title="fig:",scaledwidth=85.0% ] 0.5 cm as a function of @xmath34 such that the neutrino signature from dm annihilations can be detected at the @xmath184 significance in five years .
results corresponding to different @xmath185 are presented . for comparison
, we also show the result with @xmath28 gev and @xmath186 @xcite .
, title="fig:",scaledwidth=85.0% ] 0.5 cm as stated before , we consider neutrino fluxes generated by the annihilation channels @xmath187 , and @xmath15 , and the decay channels @xmath188 and @xmath15 . given the atmospheric neutrino background , we present in fig .
2 the required dm annihilation cross section as a function of @xmath34 for threshold energy @xmath189 and a cone half - angle @xmath190 such that the neutrino signature from dm annihilations can be detected at the @xmath184 significance in five years .
non - detection of such a signature would then exclude the parameter region above the curve at the @xmath184 level .
we have presented results corresponding to different annihilation channels .
one can see that the required annihilation cross section for @xmath184 detection significance is smallest for @xmath179 channel and largest for the channel @xmath191 .
we also present the @xmath182 constraint on @xmath192 annihilation cross section obtained from super - kamiokande data of upward going muons @xcite , which has been used to rule out wimp annihilations into @xmath5 as a possible source of previously mentioned @xmath6 anomalies @xcite .
such a constraint can be compared with the expected @xmath184 constraint on the same annihilation channel from deepcore detector .
constraints on dm annihilation cross section were also obtained from gamma ray observations and cosmology .
telescope performed a search for the very - high - energy ( @xmath193 gev ) @xmath194-ray signal from dm annihilations over a circular region of radius @xmath195 centered at the gc @xcite . with dm particles assumed to annihilate into @xmath196 pairs , the limit on dm annihilation cross section as a function of @xmath34 for nfw dm density profile
is derived in ref .
we present this constraint in fig . 2 as well .
for @xmath197 gev , the parameter space with @xmath198 ( i.e. , @xmath199m@xmath200s@xmath116 ) in fig . 2 could be excluded by the h.e.s.s .
however , the h.e.s.s . constraint on @xmath20 becomes much weaker for @xmath3 gev .
we point out that this constraint is obtained with nfw profile normalized at @xmath201 .
the h.e.s.s .
constraint would be slightly less stringent if our adopted normalization @xmath57 is used .
cosmological constraints on dm annihilation cross section can be obtained from the data of big - bang nucleosynthesis ( bbn ) and cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) .
in such an analysis , the dm annihilation cross section is assumed to be velocity dependent such that @xcite @xmath202 where @xmath203 is the dm velocity at the freeze - out temperature , while the values for @xmath204 and @xmath205 depend on specific models . for sommerfeld enhancement @xcite of the dm annihilation cross section induced by light - scalar exchange , one has @xmath206 and @xmath207 with @xmath208 the light - scalar mass .
the cmb anisotropy can be affected by the energy injection in the recombination epoch due to dm annihilation process such as @xmath181 and @xmath209 . in fig . 2
, we show the upper bound on @xmath210 for @xmath181 channel for @xmath206 and @xmath211 with @xmath212 the kinetic decoupling temperature .
this upper bound is inferred from the upper bound on @xmath213 such that the resulting cmb power spectrum remains consistent with observations @xcite .
the above upper bound on @xmath213 is shown to be sensitive to the parameter @xmath204 while the corresponding bound on @xmath210 is insensitive to it .
it will be interesting to convert the above bound on @xmath214 into the one on @xmath215 .
however such a conversion is highly model dependent which is beyond the scope of the current work .
having compared the expected sensitivities of deepcore detector with other experimental constraints on various dm annihilation channels , we discuss how the deepcore constraint on dm annihilation cross section varies with the chosen cone half - angle and threshold energy .
we use the channel @xmath23 to illustrate these effects . fig .
3 shows the required dm annihilation cross section @xmath216 for a @xmath184 detection in five years for different cone half - angle @xmath217 .
one can see that the constraint on the dm annihilation cross section gets stronger as @xmath217 increases from @xmath195 to @xmath218 . however , the constraint turns weaker as @xmath217 increases further .
this is due to the factor @xmath219 which depends on the square of dm density ( see eq .
( [ eq4 ] ) ) .
the constraint curve rises with an increasing @xmath217 for @xmath220 , since the signal increases slower than the background does for such a @xmath217 range . in this figure
, we also show the result for a higher threshold energy @xmath221 with a cone half - angle @xmath186 for comparison .
this result is taken from ref .
@xcite where @xmath186 is identified as the most optimal cone half - angle for constraining dm annihilation cross section at that threshold energy .
we note that , for large @xmath34 , lowering @xmath222 from @xmath1 gev to @xmath0 gev results in more enhancement on the event rate of atmospheric background than that of dm annihilation .
hence , the constraint on dm annihilation cross section is weaker by choosing @xmath189 . on the other hand , for small @xmath34 , lowering @xmath222 enhances more on the event rate of dm annihilations than that of atmospheric background . for @xmath223 gev
, one can see that the constraint on dm annihilation cross section with @xmath189 is always stronger than that with @xmath224 .
we note that deepcore constraints on other annihilation channels have similar cone half - angle and threshold energy dependencies . besides studying deepcore constraints on dm annihilation channels , we also present constraints on dm decay time for @xmath16 and @xmath15 channels . fig .
4 shows the required dm decay time for a @xmath184 detection of neutrino signature in five years for each channel .
we have taken @xmath225 and @xmath226 .
non - detection of such a signature would then exclude the parameter region below the curve at the @xmath184 level . for comparison , we also show @xmath182 limit on @xmath227 from super - kamiokande data of upward going muons @xcite .
one can see that the channel @xmath24 requires the smallest decay width to reach the @xmath184 detection significance in five years of deepcore data taking .
detection of neutrino signature in five years for @xmath228 and @xmath5 channels , respectively .
the dashed line is the super - kamiokande constraint on @xmath227 @xcite.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=85.0% ] 0.5 cm as a function of @xmath34 such that the neutrino signature from dm decays can be detected at the @xmath184 significance in five years .
results corresponding to different @xmath185 are presented . for comparison
, we also show the result with @xmath28 gev and @xmath229 @xcite.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=85.0% ] 0.5 cm finally we present how the deepcore constraint on dm decay time varies with the chosen cone half - angle and threshold energy .
we use the channel @xmath24 to illustrate these effects .
5 shows the required dm decay time @xmath230 as a function of @xmath34 for different cone half - angle @xmath217 such that the neutrino signature from dm decays can be detected at the @xmath184 significance in five years . for dm decays ,
the curve rises with increasing @xmath217 since the event rate of dm signal increases faster than that of atmospheric background as @xmath217 increases .
for comparison , we show the required dm decay time for a @xmath184 detection in five years with @xmath221 and @xmath231 . it has been pointed out in ref .
@xcite that @xmath232 gives the most stringent constraint on dm decay time for @xmath224 .
one can see that the constraint on dm decay time is strengthen by lowering @xmath176 from @xmath1 gev to @xmath0 gev for @xmath233 gev .
we have calculated the track event rate in icecube deepcore array resulting from muon neutrino flux produced by annihilations and decays of dark matter in the galactic halo . in this calculation , we have employed nfw profile for dark matter mass distribution and consider the channels @xmath14 , and @xmath15 for annihilations and the channels @xmath16 and @xmath15 for decays .
we also calculated the track event rate due to atmospheric background .
we compare the signal event rate with that of the background for @xmath234 gev .
we have presented sensitivities of icecube deepcore array to neutrino flux arising from dark matter annihilations and decays . for a given dark matter
mass , we evaluated the dark matter annihilation cross section and dark matter decay time such that a @xmath184 detection significance for the above signatures can be achieved by deepcore array for a five - year data taking .
the deepcore sensitivities on dark matter annihilation cross section were compared with the constraint obtained from h.e.s.s .
gamma ray observations and the constraint derived from the data of cmb power spectrum . using @xmath23 and @xmath24 as examples
, we also presented how deepcore constraints on dark matter annihilation cross section and dark matter decay time vary with the chosen cone half - angle and threshold energy .
we like to point out that our calculated sensitivities based upon @xmath189 are significantly more stringent than those obtained by taking @xmath221 for @xmath2 gev in the annihilation channel and @xmath3 gev in the decay channel .
this work is supported by the national science council of taiwan under grants no .
099 - 2811-m-009 - 055 and 99 - 2112-m-009 - 005-my3 , and focus group on cosmology and particle astrophysics , national center for theoretical sciences , taiwan .
99 g. jungman , m. kamionkowski , and k. griest , phys . rep . *
267 * , 195 ( 1996 ) ; l. bergstrom , rep .
. phys . * 63 * , 793 ( 2000 ) .
g. bertone , d. hooper , and j. silk , phys . rep . * 405 * , 279 ( 2005 ) .
atwood _ et al . _ [ fermi / lat collaboration ] , astrophys .
j. * 697 * , 1071 ( 2009 ) ; e.o .
wilhelmi [ hess collaboration ] , aip conf . proc . * 1112 * , 16 ( 2009 ) ; m. beilicke [ veritas collaboration ] , aip conf . proc . * 1112 * , 33 ( 2009 ) ; t. mizukami [ cangaroo - iii collaboration ] , aip conf . proc . * 1085 * , 364 ( 2008 ) ; y. yukawa [ cangaroo collaboration ] , j phys . conf .
ser . * 120 * , 062018 ( 2008 ) ; j. rico _ et al . _
[ magic collaboration ] , aip conf .
proc . * 1112 * , 23 ( 2009 ) .
p. jean _ et al .
_ , astron .
astrophys . * 407 * , l55 ( 2003 ) ; c. boehm , d. hooper , j. silk , m. casse and j. paul , phys . rev.lett . * 92 * , 101301 ( 2004 ) . d.p .
finkbeiner , astrophys .
j. * 614 * , 186 ( 2004 ) ; g. dobler and d.p .
finkbeiner , astrophys .
j. * 680 * , 1222 ( 2008 ) ; m. bottino , a.j .
banday and d. maino , arxiv:0807.1865 ; d. hooper , d.p .
finkbeiner and g. dobler , phys .
d * 76 * , 083012 ( 2007 ) .
m. aguilar _ et al .
_ [ ams-01 collaboration ] , phys .
b * 646 * , 145 ( 2007 ) ; c. goy [ ams collaboration ] , j. phys . conf .
* 39 * , 185 ( 2006 ) ; d. casadei , arxiv:0609072 .
barwick _ et al .
_ [ heat collaboration ] , astrophys .
j. * 482 * , l191 ( 1997 ) .
o. adriani _ et al .
_ [ pamela collaboration ] , nature * 458 * , 607 ( 2009 ) ; e. mocchiutti _ et al .
_ , arxiv:0905.2551
. j. chang _ et al .
_ , nature * 456 * , 362 ( 2008 ) . s. torii _ et al . _
[ ppb - bets collaboration ] , arxiv:0809.0760 ; k. yoshida _ et al .
_ , adv . space res . *
42 * , 1670 ( 2008 ) .
aharonian , astron .
astrophys . * 508 * , 561 ( 2009 ) .
a. a. abdo _ et al .
_ ( fermi lat collaboration ) , phys . rev
. lett . * 102 * , 181101 ( 2009 ) .
j. braun and d. hubert [ icecube collaboration ] , arxiv:0906.1615 ; d. hubert [ icecube collaboration ] , nucl . phys .
. suppl .
* 173 * , 87 ( 2007 ) .
r. abbasi _ et al . _
[ icecube collaboration ] , nucl .
instrum . meth .
a * 601 * , 294 ( 2009 ) ; c. rott [ icecube collaboration ] , arxiv:0810.3698 .
katz [ km3net collaboration ] , nucl . instrum .
methods phys .
res . , sect . a * 602 * , 40 ( 2009 ) .
see , e.g. , p. j. fox and e. poppitz , phys .
d * 79 * , 083528 ( 2009 ) ; r. harnik and g. d. kribs , phys .
d * 79 * , 095007 ( 2009 ) ; q. h. cao , e. ma , and g. shaughnessy , phys .
b * 673 * , 152 ( 2009 ) ; b. kyae , jcap * 07 * , 028 ( 2009 ) ; x. j. bi , x. g. he , and q. yuan , phys .
b * 678 * , 168 ( 2009 ) ; s. baek and p. ko , jcap * 10 * , 011 ( 2009 ) ; d. j. phalen , a. pierce , and n. weiner , phys . rev .
d * 80 * , 063513 ( 2009 ) ; h. s. goh , l. j. hall , and p. kumar , jhep * 05 * , 097 ( 2009 ) ; a. ibarra , a. ringwald , d. tran , and c. weniger , jcap * 08 * , 017 ( 2009 ) ; y. farzan , s. pascoli , and m. a. schmidt , arxiv:1005.5323 . v. barger , y. gao , w. y. keung , d. marfatia , and g. shaughnessy , phys . lett .
b * 678 * , 283 ( 2009 ) .
p. meade , m. papucci , a. strumia and t. volansky , nucl .
b * 831 * , 178 ( 2010 ) .
s. palomares - ruiz , phys .
b * 665 * , 50 ( 2008 ) .
j. hisano , m. kawasaki , k. kohri , and k. nakayama , phys .
d * 79 * , 043516 ( 2009 ) .
d. spolyar , m. r. buckley , k. freese , d. hooper and h. murayama , arxiv:0905.4764 [ astro-ph.co ] . m. r. buckley , k. freese , d. hooper , d. spolyar and h. murayama , phys . rev .
d * 81 * , 016006 ( 2010 ) .
s. k. mandal , m. r. buckley , k. freese , d. spolyar and h. murayama , phys .
d * 81 * , 043508 ( 2010 ) .
l. covi , m. grefe , a. ibarra and d. tran , jcap * 1004 * , 017 ( 2010 ) .
e. resconi ( icecube collaboration ) , nucl .
methods phys .
res . , sect .
a * 602 * , 7 ( 2009 ) .
c. wiebusch , for the icecube collaboration , [ arxiv:0907.2263 [ astro-ph.im ] ] . m. ackermann _ et al . _
( icecube collaboration ) , j. of geophys
111 * , d13203 ( 2006 ) .
a. e. erkoca , m. h. reno , and i. sarcevic , phys .
d * 82 * , 113006 ( 2010 ) .
a. e. erkoca , g. gelmini , m. h. reno , and i. sarcevic , phys .
d * 81 * , 096007 ( 2010 ) .
a. sommerfeld , ann .
( leipzig ) * 403 * , 257 ( 1931 ) ; j.m .
russell , s.m .
west , d. cumberbatch and d. hooper , jhep * 0807 * , 058 ( 2008 ) ; n. arkani - hamed , d.p .
finkbeiner , t.r .
slatyer and n. weiner , phys .
d * 79 * , 015014 ( 2009 ) ; i. cholis , g. dobler , d.p .
finkbeiner , l. goodenough and n. weiner , phys .
d * 80 * , 123518 ( 2009 ) ; m. lattanzi and j. silk , phys .
d * 79 * , 083523 ( 2009 ) ; b. robertson and a. zentner , phys .
d * 79 * , 083525 ( 2009 ) ; m. kamionkowski , s.m .
koushiappas and m. kuhlen , phys .
d * 81 * , 043532 ( 2010 ) ; s. hannestad and t. tram , jcap * 1101 * , 016 ( 2011 ) ; j.l .
feng , m. kaplinghat and h .- b .
yu , phys .
d * 82 * , 083525 ( 2010 ) ; c. arina , f .- x .
josse - michaux and n. sahu , phys .
b * 691 * , 219 ( 2010 ) .
j. hisano , s. matsumoto and m.m .
nojiri , phys .
* 92 * , 031303 ( 2004 ) ; j.m .
russell and s.m .
west , phys .
b * 676 * , 133 ( 2009 ) ; s.m .
koushiappas and m. kamionkowski , phys .
lett . * 103 * , 121301 ( 2009 ) ; m. lindner , a. merle and v. niro , phys .
d * 82 * , 123529 ( 2010 ) ; d. suematsu , t. toma and t. yoshida , phys .
d * 82 * , 013012 ( 2010 ) .
j. f. navarro , c. s. frenk and s. d. m. white , astrophys .
j. * 462 * , 563 ( 1996 ) .
p. f. harrison , d. h. perkins and w. g. scott , phys .
b * 530 * , 167 ( 2002 ) ; phys .
b * 535 * , 163 ( 2002 ) ; z. z. xing , phys .
b * 533 * , 85 ( 2002 ) ; x. g. he and a. zee , phys.lett .
b * 560 * , 87 ( 2003 ) ; see also l. wolfenstein , phys .
d * 18 * , 958 ( 1978 ) ; y. yamanaka , h. sugawara and s. pakvasa , phys .
d * 25 * , 1895 ( 1982 ) [ erratum - ibid .
d * 29 * , 2135 ( 1984 ) ] .
j. g. learned and s. pakvasa , astropart .
phys . * 3 * , 267 ( 1995 ) .
h. athar , m. jezabek and o. yasuda , phys .
d * 62 * , 103007 ( 2000 ) ; l. bento , p. keranen and j. maalampi , phys .
b * 476 * , 205 ( 2000 ) .
see also k. c. lai , g. l. lin and t. c. liu , phys .
d * 82 * , 103003 ( 2010 ) .
k. abe _ et al . _
[ t2k collaboration ] , phys .
rev . lett . * 107 * , 041801 ( 2011 ) .
double chooz , h. d. kerret , ( 2011 ) , lownu11 , 9 - 12 , november , 2011 , seoul national university , seoul , korea . t. k. gaisser , astropart .
* 16 * , 285 ( 2002 ) .
f. f. lee and g. l. lin , astropart .
* 25 * , 64 ( 2006 ) .
t. k. gaisser and m. honda , ann .
sci . * 52 * , 153 ( 2002 ) .
m. honda , t. kajita , k. kasahara , and s. midorikawa , phys .
d * 70 * , 043008 ( 2004 ) .
p. lipari , astropart .
* 1 * , 195 ( 1993 )
. m. honda , t. kajita , k. kasahara , s. midorikawa , and t. sanuki , phys .
d * 75 * , 043006 ( 2007 ) .
r. abbasi _ et al .
_ , astropart .
phys . * 34 * , 48 ( 2010 ) .
t. k. gaisser , _ cosmic rays and particle physics _
( cambridge university press , cambridge , uk , 1992 ) .
p. nason , s. dawson and r. k. ellis , nucl .
b * 327 * , 49 ( 1989 ) [ erratum-_ibid_. b * 335 * , 260 ( 1990 ) ] ; m. l. mangano , p. nason and g. ridolfi , nucl .
b * 373 * , 295 ( 1992 ) .
m. c. gonzalez - garcia , m. maltoni and j. salvado , jhep * 1004 * , 056 ( 2010 ) .
r. gandhi , c. quigg , m. h. reno , and i. sarcevic , astropart .
phys . * 5 * , 81 ( 1996 ) ; phys .
d * 58 * , 093009 ( 1998 ) .
a. abramowski _ et al . _
( h.e.s.s .
collaboration ) , phys .
lett . * 106 * , 161301 ( 2011 ) .
j. hisano _ et al .
d * 83 * , 123511 ( 2011 ) . | the deployment of deepcore array significantly lowers icecube s energy threshold to about @xmath0 gev and enhances the sensitivity of detecting neutrinos from annihilations and decays of light dark matter . to match this experimental development , we calculate the track event rate in deepcore array due to neutrino flux produced by annihilations and decays of galactic dark matter .
we also calculate the background event rate due to atmospheric neutrino flux for evaluating the sensitivity of deepcore array to galactic dark matter signatures . unlike previous approaches , which set the energy threshold for track events at around @xmath1 gev ( this choice avoids the necessity of including oscillation effect in the estimation of atmospheric background event rate ) , we have set the energy threshold at @xmath0 gev to take the full advantage of deepcore array .
we compare our calculated sensitivity with those obtained by setting the threshold energy at @xmath1 gev .
we conclude that our proposed threshold energy significantly improves the sensitivity of deepcore array to the dark matter signature for @xmath2 gev in the annihilation scenario and @xmath3 gev in the decay scenario .
= = = = = = = = = ==================== = ======= |
computing the covariance matrix @xmath48 requires two - point functions . the latter should be computed by inverting the operator ( cf .
( 3 ) of the main text ) @xmath116 defined on the support of the media @xmath117 . to invert this operator
, we will treat the second term perturbatively justified in the weak - coupling limit where @xmath118 with @xmath39 the linear size of the media .
therefore , to the first order , we find @xmath119 the two - point functions @xmath120 and @xmath121 defined in the manuscript can be computed accordingly .
the field correlation function reads @xmath122 where the factor of 2 in the first equality comes from the restriction to @xmath123 .
similarly , the correlator of the conjugate momentum is given by @xmath124 with the minus sign in the first equality due to @xmath125 .
superficially , the integral over the first term in eq .
psi - psi correlation ] ) is divergent ; however , a proper regularization is to compute @xmath126 ( @xmath127 representing the conjugate momentum ) which yields the first term in the last equality above @xcite .
the last term in this equality can be simplified by dropping @xmath12 in the denominator as @xmath128 .
it is useful to note that @xmath129 where the superscript denotes the dimension , @xmath130 represents coordinates in one higher dimension , and @xmath131 is the green s function corresponding to the laplacian . defining @xmath132 and @xmath133 as in the manuscript , the above equations yield @xmath134 with @xmath135 , while @xmath132 can be neglected compared to @xmath133 . with @xmath136 ( cf . the manuscript ) , we recover the expression for @xmath50 in eq .
( 5 ) of the manuscript .
in this section , we consider a modified electrostatic problem in 3 dimensions .
the ` potential ' @xmath138 satisfies the laplace equation , @xmath84 , except on the surface of a disc of radius @xmath139 sitting at the @xmath140 plane .
the disk imposes the @xmath63-dependent boundary condition ( 9 ) on @xmath58 ( whose dependence on @xmath63 is implicit ) .
it is convenient to consider the oblate spheroidal coordinates @xcite , @xmath141 where @xmath142 , @xmath143 , and @xmath144 . with the reflection symmetry
@xmath145 , we separately consider even and odd solutions with respect to the @xmath146 coordinate .
odd solutions become trivial as @xmath147 whereby the boundary condition simply requires the continuity of the first derivative . for even solutions ,
the boundary condition becomes @xmath148 where @xmath149 is the normal derivative on the surface . in oblate
spherical coordinates , the latter condition takes the form @xmath150_{\xi=0}=0.\ ] ] the regular solutions ( decaying at infinity as @xmath151 ) of the laplace equation are given by @xmath152 where @xmath153 with @xmath154 ( @xmath155 ) the legendre polynomial of the first ( second ) kind . to find the capacitance
, we consider a constant potential of magnitude 1 at @xmath156 , to which the object responds in a multi - pole series expansion as @xmath157 we have exploited the symmetries of a disc to restrict the sum to even @xmath158 , and choose @xmath159 .
the boundary condition then takes the form @xmath160 where we have defined @xmath161 and @xmath162 integrating over @xmath163 , eq .
( [ eq : bc expansion ] ) yields @xmath164 comparing with numerical evaluation , one can see that ignoring higher multipoles , i.e. dropping the sum over @xmath165 , is an excellent approximation ( and , at least , exact in the two limits where @xmath166 and @xmath167 ) ; we can then solve for the lowest multipole coefficient ( using @xmath168 and @xmath169 ) , @xmath170 inserting @xmath171 in eq .
( [ eq : chi ] ) , we find that , at large radius @xmath172 , the potential behaves as @xmath173 ( using @xmath174 and @xmath175 for large @xmath176 ) .
the capacitance is then given by @xmath177 this formula correctly reproduces the dirichlet case for @xmath85 @xcite .
in this section , we outline an alternative approach to computing the free energy of a thermally fluctuating field based on the worldline formalism @xcite ; this technique was first applied to computing the casimir interaction energy between two objects .
we shall consider the objects as infinitely thin surfaces represented by a @xmath178-function potential [ @xmath179 denotes the coordinates in @xmath1 dimensions ] @xmath180 defined on a @xmath0 dimensional hyper - surface @xmath69 in @xmath1 dimensions .
note that the limit @xmath181 corresponds to dirichlet boundary conditions .
now consider a worldline @xmath182 parameterized by the variable @xmath183 which is normalized as the euclidean length of the worldline trajectory , and define @xmath184=\int d\tau \
, v_a(\tilde { { \mathbf x}}(\tau)).\ ] ] we are interested in finding the thermodynamic entropy in the presence of two hyper - surfaces @xmath69 and @xmath70 . the change of the thermodynamic entropy @xmath185 ( cf .
the manuscript for the definition ) can be expressed as a sum over worldline loops , or closed phantom polymers , as @xmath186 where @xmath187 and @xmath188 are the length and the center of mass of a worldline trajectory , respectively , and the average @xmath189 is taken over all loops with a fixed @xmath187 and @xmath188 ; see ref .
@xcite for more details .
we also made explicit the dependence of thermodynamic entropy on the hyper - surfaces @xmath69 and @xmath70 .
finally , the proportionality coefficient is a @xmath0-dependent constant , which will not be important for our purposes .
the above equation has a simple interpretation : only worldlines that `` see '' both surfaces contribute to @xmath185 .
for the special case of dirichlet boundary conditions , @xmath85 , the integrand is 1 when the worldline intersects both @xmath69 and @xmath70 , and 0 otherwise , since @xmath190
in the main text , we derived an expression for the mutual information between two material bodies in terms of the thermodynamic free energy , and consequently the thermodynamic entropy , in one higher dimension . here
, we generalize this result to three bodies .
further generalization to more than three regions is straightforward .
first we define the quantum tripartite information @xmath191 for three systems @xmath69 , @xmath70 and @xmath192 as @xcite @xmath193 where @xmath194 represents the von - neumann entropy .
again this definition is free of uv divergences .
therefore , the tripartite quantum information maps to the thermodynamic entropy as ( also making the dependence on the dimension @xmath0 explicit ) @xmath195 where we have defined ( making the dependence on @xmath63 implicit ) @xmath196 . a trace expression in terms of capacitance matrices similar to eq .
( 8) of the main text , but for three objects , can be found in ref .
for any tripartite quantum system comprising disjoint subsystems @xmath197 and @xmath192 , the strong subadditivity theorem states that @xcite @xmath198 this inequality can be recast in terms of the mutual and tripartite information ( cf . the manuscript and the previous section for the definitions ) as @xmath199
the proof of the above theorem is highly nontrivial . nevertheless , using the thermodynamic analogy , eq .
thermo analogy three objects ] ) , the subadditivity property can be easily verified in our model .
more precisely , we show that @xmath200 for each value of @xmath63 .
the quantum strong subadditivity property follows immediately . to this end
, we cast the change of the thermodynamic entropy for three objects in terms of polymer chains : @xmath201 similar to the mutual information , only worldlines that see all three surfaces contribute to @xmath202 .
equation ( [ eq .
strong subadditivty for s - th ] ) then finds a pictorial meaning : the contribution of polymer configurations that intersect all three regions @xmath69 , @xmath70 and @xmath192 is less than or equal to those that intersect @xmath69 and @xmath192 , but not necessarily @xmath70 .
in fact , for the special case of @xmath85 , the inequality in eq .
strong subadditivty for s - th ] ) becomes rather trivial as it simply means [ cf .
( [ eq . lambda=0 ] ) ] that the number of polymers that intersect all three regions is less than or equal to the number of those which intersect any two regions , but not necessarily the third one . to prove the inequality in general
, we define @xmath203 hence , @xmath204 and @xmath205 etc . to derive eq .
strong subadditivty for s - th ] ) , it is sufficient to show that @xmath206 but this is simply equivalent to @xmath207 which is trivially satisfied ( note that @xmath208 ) .
as noted in the main text , an advantage of our method is that it expresses quantum mutual information in terms of classical scattering data , thus opening the door to myriad existing methods for practical computations . indeed , in principle
any method of computational electrostatics could be used to calculate the quantities @xmath209 and @xmath210 that enter eq .
( 8) of the main text ; this includes both analytical techniques such as multipole expansions and numerical methods such as finite - difference or boundary - element approaches .
the choice of a computational method may be viewed as the choice of a discrete _ basis _ in which to evaluate matrix elements of the @xmath209 and @xmath210 operators in eq .
( 8) of the main text .
many different choices of basis are possible ; we here consider two in particular : 1 . for highly symmetric shapes at medium or long distances ,
it is convenient to introduce a multipole basis that takes advantage of symmetries to encode scattering data in compact form . in some cases the representation is so concise that eq .
( 8) of the main text may be evaluated analytically , as in the case of the discs at large separation discussed in the main text .
2 . for more general shapes , or in the short - distance limit
, it is convenient to introduce a basis of localized functions supported only on the material bodies .
this allows treatment of essentially arbitrary shapes such as the squares of figure 2 , for which a multipole expansion would be cumbersome and calculations at essentially arbitrarily short distances . before describing each of these possibilities in turn ,
we pause to note that this dichotomy mirrors the recent evolution of theoretical approaches to electromagnetic fluctuation phenomena ( casimir forces and near - field radiative heat transfer ) , in which geometry - specific multipole bases have been employed to yield rapidly convergent or even analytically tractable series expansions of casimir quantities and heat - transfer rates in high - symmetry geometries @xcite , while localized basis functions have been used for numerical casimir or heat - transfer calculations in arbitrary geometries @xcite . for objects of high symmetry such as the disc - shaped material bodies considered in the main text
it is convenient to work in a multipole basis .
for example , in a basis of spherical multipoles one expands scalar fields in solutions of the laplace equation indexed by the usual spherical indices @xmath211 : @xmath212 where @xmath213 are the usual spherical harmonics . in this case , * the @xmath210 matrices in eq .
( 8) of the main text become translation matrices , which relate spherical multipoles centered at the origin of one body to multipoles centered at the origin of another body , while * the elements of the @xmath209 matrices in eq .
( 8) of the main text describe the multipole sources induced on ( or , equivalently , the outgoing multipole fields emitted by ) material bodies by an incident multipole field .
more specifically , the definition of the spherical - wave @xmath214 matrix elements for a body is as follows : if the body is exposed to an `` incident '' field consisting of a single incoming multipole field , i.e. @xmath215 , then the `` scattered '' field produced by the body is @xmath216 thus , to compute one full column of the @xmath214-matrix we solve a modified electrostatics problem in which the body [ on whose surface we have the @xmath63-dependent boundary condition ( 7 ) ] is exposed to an external @xmath217 field ; after solving the scattering problem we extract @xmath218 as the @xmath219 source multipole induced by this field on the body .
as noted in the main text , the multipole basis becomes unwieldy in the short - distance limit due to the need to retain large numbers of multipoles to obtain sufficient accuracy .
moreover , even at long distances the _ analytical _ usefulness of the multipole basis is restricted to highly symmetric objects for which the @xmath214-matrix elements may be computed in closed form . for shorter distances or less symmetric objects ( such as the squares of figure 2 ) , it is convenient to work with position - space representations of the @xmath214 and @xmath210 operators in eq .
( 8) of the main text . a direct position - space interpretation of the operator trace in eq .
( 8) of the main text is ill - defined for at least two reasons .
one difficulty is that the operator @xmath210 , whose position - space representation is @xmath220 is singular `` on the diagonal , '' i.e. for @xmath221 this singularity needs somehow to be regularized before the operator products and trace in eq .
( 8) of the main text may be performed .
a second difficulty is that the @xmath209 operators are unwieldy in position space .
indeed , for e.g. body a the position - space matrix elements @xmath222 satisfy the following mixed definition : 1 .
if either of the points @xmath223 lies outside of object @xmath69 , then we have an explicit representation for @xmath222 , namely @xmath224 2 . on the other hand ,
if both points @xmath223 lie inside body @xmath69 then we have only an explicit representation for the _ inverse _ of the @xmath214 operator , @xmath225 both of these difficulties are alleviated by introducing a finite basis of @xmath226 localized functions @xmath227 whose supports are restricted to a finite subregion of body @xmath228 for example , we might discretize the body into @xmath226 small triangles ( as depicted in the inset of figure 2 ) ; to the @xmath158th triangle @xmath229 we associate a basis function @xmath230 defined to be unity for @xmath231 and vanishing elsewhere . [ similarly , for body @xmath70 we introduce @xmath232 basis functions @xmath233 supported on subregions of body @xmath70 . ] with this choice of basis functions , the elements of the @xmath234 operator take the form of four - dimensional integrals over triangle - product domains : @xmath235 ( note that the @xmath234 matrix in the localized basis is nonsingular even on the diagonal , i.e. @xmath236 the finite extent of the basis functions regularizes the position - space divergence of equation ( [ g0positionspace ] ) . )
the @xmath234 operators in eq .
( 8) of the main text become @xmath237 or @xmath238 matrices describing the interactions of triangles on body @xmath69 with triangles on body @xmath70 .
the @xmath239 and @xmath240 operators in eq .
( 8) of the main text become @xmath241 and @xmath242 matrices . to compute these
it is easiest to use equation ( [ cinvpositionspace ] ) to compute first the inverse matrices @xmath243 .
the elements of e.g. @xmath244 read @xmath245 where @xmath246 is the norm of basis function @xmath247 and the @xmath210 matrix element is computed as in ( [ g0mn ] ) .
having computed the full numerical matrix @xmath248 , we then simply invert this matrix numerically to obtain the @xmath214 matrices that enter eq .
( 8) of the main text .
matrix products are computed using standard numerical linear algebra software , and the logarithm is computed using the identity @xmath249 where @xmath250 are the eigenvalues of @xmath251 .
finally , the @xmath63 integral in eq .
( 8) of the main text is evaluated using an adaptive numerical quadrature method . | a dispersive medium becomes entangled with zero - point fluctuations in the vacuum .
we consider an arbitrary array of material bodies weakly interacting with a quantum field and compute the quantum mutual information between them .
it is shown that the mutual information in @xmath0 dimensions can be mapped to classical thermodynamic entropy in @xmath1 dimensions . as a specific example
, we compute the mutual information both analytically and numerically for a range of separation distances between two bodies in @xmath2 dimensions and find a logarithmic correction to the area law at short separations .
a key advantage of our method is that it allows the strong subadditivity property to be easily verified .
entanglement as a purely quantum phenomenon has become a central subject in many fields , ranging from high - energy physics to many - body systems and quantum information . in particular , the characteristic entropy associated with entanglement
has proved a powerful tool for describing the quantum nature of a system @xcite as well as for quantifying resources available for quantum computation @xcite .
inspired by formal similarities with thermodynamics , parallels between quantum and classical notions of entropy have been suggested in the literature @xcite .
while many studies of entanglement entropy have considered geometrical regions in vacuum @xcite or domains in many - body systems @xcite , rapid advances in quantum computation and atomic and optical physics have prompted studies of entanglement between atoms and light @xcite .
although most studies have addressed the case of one or a few bodies , recent attention has turned to the problem of quantifying the entanglement of a medium interacting with a quantum field , both described by ( infinitely ) many modes . in particular , ref .
@xcite took key first steps in this direction , but simple conceptual pictures and efficient computational tools have remained elusive . in this letter , we consider two or more dispersive media in the presence of a fluctuating field and compute their quantum mutual information , a characteristic measure of quantum correlations between parts of a system , and closely related to the entanglement entropy .
our model is a simplified electromagnetism in which a free scalar field couples weakly to `` dielectric '' bodies .
we relate the mutual information in @xmath0 dimensions to classical thermodynamic entropy in @xmath1 dimensions , where the dispersive media become planar disk - like regions ( fig .
[ fig .
dtod+1 ] ) .
inspired by an electrostatic analogy , our formalism relates quantum information to classical scattering theory , thus allowing practical computations by any number of techniques including multipole expansion or numerical methods . as an example
, we compute the mutual information between two bodies at all separations in @xmath2 dimensions and observe area - law - violating logarithmic behavior at short separations .
dimensions coupled to a quantum field in vacuum .
the mutual information between the two is related to the thermodynamic entropy of fluctuating fields in @xmath1 dimensions .
the material bodies @xmath3 are reinterpreted as subregions in the plane @xmath4 in @xmath5-dimensional space , and impose a boundary condition on the fluctuating fields .
this analogy finds a geometrical picture in terms of phantom chain polymers intersecting both regions.,width=359 ] _ model . _
our starting point is the action describing a free scalar field in @xmath0 spatial dimensions in the presence of dispersive material bodies , @xmath6=\int_{0}^{\infty}\!\!\frac{d\omega}{2\pi } \!\int \!\!d{{\mathbf x}}\ , \phi^*_\omega({{\mathbf x}})\left[\epsilon(\omega , { { \mathbf x}})\,\omega^2+\nabla^2\right ] \phi_\omega({{\mathbf x}}),\ ] ] where @xmath7 is a frequency- and position - dependent dielectric function .
this model offers a simplified theoretical framework for exploring quantum electrodynamics and has proven useful in studies of casimir @xcite and entanglement @xcite phenomena .
specifically , the limit @xmath8 is the basis of a vast literature on entanglement entropy .
we take the susceptibility @xmath9 to be nonvanishing in a region @xmath10 ( the material bodies ) , within which it assumes the spatially constant form @xmath11 with @xmath12 and @xmath13 the resonant and plasma frequencies of the dispersive material , respectively .
equation ( [ eq . action of phi ] ) may be viewed as an _ effective _ action arising upon integrating out the matter degrees of freedom from a parent action describing both vacuum and matter fields @xcite , which ( upon wick rotation , @xmath14 ) reads @xmath15=\int_0^\infty \frac{d\xi}{2\pi } \big\{\int d{{\mathbf x}}\ , \phi_\xi({{\mathbf x}})\left(\xi^2-\nabla^2 \right ) \phi_\xi({{\mathbf x}})\ , \nonumber \\ & + \int_{\omega } \!\!d{{\mathbf x}}\big[\frac{\xi^2+\omega_0 ^ 2}{4\pi } \ , \psi^2_\xi({{\mathbf x}})+ 2\omega_p \xi\,\phi_\xi({{\mathbf x } } ) \psi_\xi({{\mathbf x } } ) \big]\big\},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath16 represents the degrees of freedom within the material bodies .
note that the action in the first line is that of a free scalar field , while the first term in the second line describes harmonic oscillator modes localized in @xmath10 , and the last term is assumed to be of the form @xmath17 . ) . ] integrating out the field @xmath16 from eq .
( [ eq . action of phi and psi ] ) recovers the action ( [ eq . action of phi ] ) . on the other hand
, we are interested in finding an effective action for the matter field @xmath16 . integrating out the scalar field @xmath18 yields @xmath19 = \int_0^\infty \frac{d\xi}{2\pi } \big\{\int_{\omega } d{{\mathbf x}}\frac{\xi^2+\omega_0 ^ 2}{4\pi } \ , \psi^2_\xi({{\mathbf x } } ) \nonumber \\ & + \omega_p^2\xi^2\int\!\!\!\int_{\omega } \!\!d{{\mathbf x}}\ , d{{\mathbf x } } ' \ , \psi_\xi({{\mathbf x } } ) g_\xi({{\mathbf x}},{{\mathbf x } } ' ) \psi_\xi({{\mathbf x}}')\big\ } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath20 is the green s function of the euclidean helmholtz operator .
the above effective action will allow us to study the entanglement between different parts of medium ( or between two media ) .
to this end , we briefly introduce the main tools to compute the entanglement entropy .
_ entanglement from covariance matrices .
_ for a mixed state @xmath21 , the von neumann entropy , a widely used measure of entanglement , is defined as @xmath22 $ ] .
let us consider the local field @xmath23 and its conjugate momentum @xmath24 describing the local degrees of freedom in the region @xmath10 . for a quadratic action ,
the ground state is a gaussian functional of @xmath25 ( or @xmath26 ) .
therefore , the quantum state can be fully represented by equal - time two - point functions @xmath27 and @xmath28 .
the von neumann entropy is directly related to the two - point functions via @xmath29 $ ] where @xmath30 is the identity matrix , and @xmath31 is the covariance matrix @xcite with the subscript @xmath10 emphasizing its zero support outside @xmath10 .
we find it more convenient to recast the von neumann entropy as @xmath32,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath33 $ ] is an auxiliary parameter .
the last expression is reminiscent of a one - loop effective action .
in fact , we shall see that , by using the above identity , the entanglement entropy finds a convenient path - integral form .
next we compute the covariance matrix @xmath34 .
the correlation functions in imaginary frequency are given by @xmath35 and @xmath36 ; the two - point function in the integrands can be derived from eq .
( [ eq . action of psi ] ) . in general
, this is a difficult task which requires knowledge of the full ( off - shell ) @xmath37-matrix an object that appears in the lippmann - schwinger equation of the material bodies in position space @xcite .
nevertheless , we consider a weak - coupling limit in which @xmath38 with @xmath39 the linear size of the media . in other words ,
the bodies are sufficiently small that their coupling to the background scalar field [ the second line in eq .
( [ eq . action of psi ] ) ] can be treated perturbatively , a condition well satisfied for sub - micron - scale bodies with typical plasma and resonant frequencies .
one can then expand the correlation functions perturbatively : @xmath40 and @xmath41 . in the absence of interaction with the scalar field ,
one recovers the standard variances of the field and its conjugate momentum as those of a harmonic oscillator , whereupon @xmath42 and the entanglement vanishes . to leading order
, we have @xmath43 . within this approximation
, we find that @xmath44 , with @xmath45 the projection operator onto the spatial domain of @xmath10 , and @xmath46 where we have put @xmath47 .
this equation relates the covariance matrix @xmath48 to the green s function for the laplacian in @xmath1-dimensions , @xmath49 ; see the supplemental material @xcite .
it is perhaps surprising that @xmath50 depends only on @xmath51 and @xmath52 , and not the specific geometry of @xmath10 ; however , this is an approximation , and the geometric dependence appears in higher orders in @xmath53 .
now we are in a position to write eq .
( [ eq .
i d ] ) in a familiar form .
first note that , with @xmath44 , the second line of eq .
( [ eq .
i d ] ) can be written as @xmath54 $ ] .
the inverse of @xmath48 finds an awkward nonlocal form in @xmath0 dimensions , while it is simply proportional to the laplacian ( hence , local ) operator in @xmath1 dimensions .
therefore , we can cast the above expression as a functional integral over a real - valued field @xmath55 living in @xmath1 dimensions [ @xmath56 , @xmath57}{\int d\theta \ , \exp\left[-\omega_c^{-1}{\int_{d+1}\left(\nabla\theta\right)^2}\right]},\ ] ] which is easily seen to reproduce eq .
( [ eq .
i d ] ) upon functional integration .
we emphasize that @xmath58 is an auxiliary field , and is not related to the original fields in the model .
the exponent in the numerator inside the logarithm can be interpreted as a hamiltonian which is a sum of the free and potential terms : the first term is the usual gradient term in @xmath1 dimensions , while the latter is the local potential felt only in the @xmath0-dimensional region @xmath10 where @xmath4 ( see fig .
[ fig .
dtod+1 ] with @xmath59 ) .
thus the terms inside the logarithm take the form of a partition function of the classical field @xmath58 at a finite temperature ; we choose @xmath60 for convenience .
the above expression then characterizes the change of the _ classical free energy _ in the presence of the potential term , that is @xmath61 \right\rangle_0 $ ] where @xmath62 denotes the average with respect to the gaussian fluctuations of the gradient term .
we will argue later that the change of the free energy is purely entropic , and make the connection to the thermodynamic entropy .
for now , we point out another simplification : @xmath63 can be scaled by @xmath64 to eliminate the latter in the gradient term .
this gives rise to an overall factor of @xmath65 to the integral in eq .
( [ eq .
i d ] ) and changes its upper bound to @xmath66 which we extend to infinity as @xmath67 .
the von neumann entropy is then obtained from the free energy of the thermodynamic model described above as @xmath68 the degrees of freedom in @xmath10 are uncountably infinite and thus the entropy depends on a uv cutoff @xcite ; such dependence may exhibit some form of universality in one dimension @xcite . we , on the other hand , consider the quantum mutual information ( qmi ) between two subsystems @xmath69 and @xmath70 defined as @xmath71 , which is inherently cutoff - independent , and measures quantum correlations between @xmath69 and @xmath70 .
equation ( [ eq . s from f ] ) then relates the qmi to the change of the free energy with the local potential turned on in one or both regions , @xmath72 , @xmath73 the latter , however , is a familiar quantity in the context of thermal casimir effect that gives rise to an interaction between two objects due to thermal , rather than quantum , fluctuations in the space between them @xcite .
the relation in eq .
( [ eq .
i from f ] ) enables us to use the powerful tools available to study the ( thermal or quantum ) casimir effect .
it is well - known that one can compute the casimir energy between two objects from the knowledge of their classical scattering matrices , i.e. their response to incoming classical waves @xcite . in the case of the thermal casimir effect , one should compute generalized _ capacitance _ matrices , or the multipole ( monopole , dipole , etc . )
response of the objects to an external electrostatic potential .
the interested reader can find more details in refs .
@xcite ; we quote the final expression for @xmath74 , @xmath75,\ ] ] where @xmath76 and @xmath77 denote the @xmath1-dimensional green s function and capacitance matrix elements , respectively .
to understand the @xmath63-dependent @xmath78 , we note that , in the absence of fluctuations , the field @xmath58 satisfies @xmath79\,\theta=0 $ ] ; the derivatives in this equation act in @xmath1 dimensions , and the potential is defined as @xmath80 when @xmath81 , and 0 otherwise . as the potential
is confined to the plane @xmath4 , its effect is simply to impose the boundary condition [ @xmath82 @xmath83 on the otherwise free electrostatic field satisfying @xmath84 .
for example , @xmath85 corresponds to a perfect conductor , while in the limit @xmath86 the object is completely transparent .
the generalized capacitance matrix elements in @xmath87 then characterize the electrostatic response of the object due to the @xmath63-dependent boundary condition in eq .
( [ eq . b.c . ] ) .
for the sake of completeness , we mention that the capacitance can be expressed as @xmath88 , where @xmath89 is the operator - valued potential corresponding to @xmath90 .
this equation is reminiscent of the lippmann - schwinger equation , which is yet another route to scattering theory . in short , eqs .
( [ eq .
i from f],[eq .
cgcg formula ] ) are the central results of this paper , and relate quantum mutual information in @xmath0 dimensions to classical ( generalized ) capacitance elements in @xmath1 dimensions , which allows exploitation of myriad analytical and numerical methods for computing @xmath91-matrix elements .
next we consider specific examples to showcase the efficiency of our method .
we start with two material bodies ( fig .
[ fig .
dtod+1 ] ) separated by a large distance @xmath92 compared to their sizes ( yet small compared to @xmath64 ) .
the @xmath91-matrix elements may be computed analytically for simple shapes via techniques reminiscent of electrostatics . for large @xmath92
, we can keep only the monopole coefficient in eq .
( [ eq . cgcg formula ] ) , combined with eq .
( [ eq .
i from f ] ) , to find @xmath93 where @xmath94 ^ 2 $ ] with @xmath95 the area of the unit @xmath0-sphere , and @xmath96 is the monopole element of the generalized capacitance matrix .
cardy @xcite also finds the same power - law and a similar expression for the qmi in terms of the capacitance for a scalar field theory , albeit in the absence of matter ; see also @xcite .
this suggests that we can view material bodies coupled to a free field as a _ probe _ of quantum information shared between different regions in space . as a specific example , we consider two disc - shaped bodies in @xmath2 dimensions of radii @xmath97 .
for a single disc of radius @xmath98 , one computes @xmath99 ; see the supplemental material .
the qmi is then given by @xmath100 note that , even at large separations , the mutual information depends nontrivially on the radii , reflecting the difficulty of computations in general . at short separations @xmath101 , on the other hand , the multipole expansion becomes inconvenient due to the need to retain large numbers of multipoles . in this case
it is useful to note that , while the @xmath91 operator itself is unwieldy to describe in real space , the _ inverse _ of this operator has a simple real - space representation @xcite , namely @xmath102 it is then tempting to discretize regions @xmath69 and @xmath70 into small finite elements ( fig . 2 ) and introduce a basis of @xmath103 expansion functions @xmath104 localized on these elements ; in this basis , we easily compute matrix elements of @xmath105 directly according to @xmath106 , then simply invert the matrix @xmath105 numerically to yield the @xmath91 matrix for arbitrary @xmath63 ( with @xmath107 computed similarly ) . the operator products and the trace in eq .
( [ eq . cgcg formula ] ) become @xmath108-dimensional matrix operations and the @xmath63 integral is evaluated by numerical quadrature . as two examples , fig .
2 plots the predictions of eq .
( [ eq . cgcg formula ] ) for disc - shaped and square - shaped bodies evaluated numerically for a range of separations @xmath92 . in the long - distance regime ,
the qmi follows the power - law in eq .
( [ eq . two disks at large sep ] ) and increases monotonically as the separation becomes shorter . for small separations
@xmath109 , the numerical data suggests a logarithmic dependence on @xmath92 , @xmath110 note that the mutual information is proportional to the `` area '' of the common boundary of the two media up to a logarithm , in this case the area being the common edge of the two - dimensional regions .
the area law can be proved under certain conditions @xcite ; for a review , see ref .
@xcite .
logarithmic violations of the area law also appear in several contexts @xcite .
_ mutual information from thermodynamic entropy_finally , we provide a geometrical interpretation of the thermodynamic model described above in terms of the random - chain polymer ensemble @xcite ; this approach was inspired by the worldline formalism @xcite .
we first note that the functional integral of the gradient term @xmath111 $ ] has an entropic origin as it sums over configurations of phantom chain polymers in free space . in the presence of boundaries [ eq .
( [ eq . b.c . ] ) ] , this sum is further weighted when a polymer intersects a boundary .
in fact , to compute @xmath74 , one must sum over chain polymers that intersect both @xmath69 and @xmath70 regions , weighted by their size and intersections , the latter through @xmath63 ( see fig .
1 ) . in this sense , the change in free energy is nothing but the change of the entropy ( @xmath60 ) , that is @xmath112 where @xmath113 denotes the purely thermodynamic entropy of a fluctuating polymer .
we thus arrive at the fundamental conclusion of this letter : the qmi in @xmath0 dimensions is obtained from the _ thermodynamic entropy _ in @xmath1 dimensions as @xmath114 where we dropped the dependence on @xmath3 , but made the dependence on the dimension explicit .
we stress that eq .
( [ eq . thermodynamic dictionary ] ) and the above geometrical picture is easily generalized to three or more regions .
for example , the quantum tripartite information is due to polymer chains that intersect all three regions .
in fact , the strong subadditivity property for quantum systems @xcite expressed in terms of mutual and tripartite information becomes rather trivial once formulated in the geometrical picture above ; see the supplemental material for details .
the thermodynamic analogy ( sum over classical configurations ) is crucial here .
_ discussion and outlook_we have studied the entanglement of dispersive media , and shown that their mutual ( and tripartite , etc . )
information maps to the thermodynamic entropy in a higher dimension .
both analytical and numerical computations are illustrated based on an electrostatic analogy .
extending the results of this paper to realistic models such as electromagnetism is worthwhile .
the response function can also be generalized to a sum of lorentzians , and thus a general @xmath115 , at the expense of introducing several copies of the matter field for each term in the sum .
including finite temperature should be of interest from both fundamental and practical perspectives . finally , lifting the assumption of weak coupling as well as generalizing to non - linear and conformal field theories are worthwhile but more challenging . + *
acknowledgements : * we thank frank wilczek for many stimulating discussions specially regarding the strong subadditivity property .
we acknowledge useful discussions with r.l .
jaffe , m. kardar , a. gorshkov , m. hertzberg , b. swingle , e. tonni , and j. sonner .
this work was supported by nsf pfc at jqi , nsf pif , aro , arl , afosr , and afosr muri .
30 natexlab#1#1bibnamefont # 1#1bibfnamefont # 1#1citenamefont # 1#1url # 1`#1`urlprefix[2]#2 [ 2][]#2 , , , , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , , , , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , , , , * * , ( ) .
, , , * * , ( ) . , *
* , ( ) . ,
* * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , , , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , , , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , , ,
, * * , ( ) . ,
* * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , , , , , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) , . , , , , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , , , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , _ _ , vol .
( , ) . , _
_ , vol .
( , ) . ,
_ _ ( , ) . , , , ,
* * , ( ) . , , , * * , ( ) .
, , , * * , ( ) . |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.